We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 6—General (Resumed).

Contributions 316–487 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Major de Valera

You have adopted the proposal to increase income-tax.

Comment on this

I have adopted a proposal?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Am I unfair in putting it that way?

Comment on this

No, not at all.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I said that the Minister had adopted a proposal to increase income-tax and we can find no suggestion of any reduction of tax of this character.

Comment on this

You are not forgetting the £6,000,000?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am dealing with the actual tax which the taxpayer has to bear at the moment and the position with regard to that burden. I grant freely to the Minister that he has taken a certain sum off the original Estimate, but that is not the point. The point we are facing is, has there been a reduction in existing taxation? I started with the question of income-tax, and, far from having any reduction in taxation in respect of income-tax, I repeat that the Minister for Finance himself has been forced to adopt a proposal which was forecast by his predecessor involving an increase in income-tax. Now this is a matter of some importance because income-tax is one of those taxes that is nowadays levelled very generally over the whole community.

Having regard to the value of money and the general level of incomes, one finds, nowadays, the classes which bear the burden of income-tax are widely distributed throughout the whole community so as to embrace not only business people or professional people, but workers, even, in some cases, unskilled workers in certain trades and under certain circumstances. Of course everybody over a certain income must pay tax and there is no need to labour that point. I think that we must see that there has been no decrease in the tax in that important item which covers perhaps a greater number of people than any other direct form of taxation and which covers a wider number of classes than any other direct form of taxation. In that way we find that there is no reduction in a tax which is, perhaps, one of the greatest burdens on the lower-paid members of the community, those members who are, perhaps, in greatest need of relief. I am not denying that it is necessary to impose such a tax, but I am merely approaching it from the point of view of examining this Budget from the standpoint of how far it effects its avowed object of reducing taxation and reducing the cost of living.

Moving from income-tax we come to the question of other direct taxes. Since the Minister has assumed office he has been able to reduce the taxation on beer, entertainments and tobacco to a very considerable extent and nobody will deny him that. But as against the increase in income-tax, one asks the question whether, if it was possible to effect a saving as is reported, of the sum involved by saving on things that are really not necessary—I will not go so far as to call them luxuries—would it not be sound policy to give some relief on income-tax? Is it sound policy to reduce the taxation on beer, cigarettes and entertainments and at the same time to increase the taxation on the incomes of families who under present economic circumstances find it hard enough to live, in other words incomes, the bulk of which is applied to the maintenance of families and for the procurement of the necessities of life for the individuals of the community? Under this Budget that income is to suffer a further burden although we are in a position to relieve on the luxury side or the semi-luxury side, or rather on non-essentials, such as beer, entertainments and cigarettes. I simply pose that question to the Minister. I wonder are we wise in that.

Even if the Minister thought, because of various factors, that it would be necessary to reduce the taxes on commodities such as beer, entertainments and cigarettes, would it not have been preferable only to take a fraction and to try to alleviate the income-tax position rather than to adopt the attitude which the Minister and his Government have adopted? These are, I think, very fair questions to ask, and it is no answer to me to say that the previous Government would have had to increase the income-tax while leaving these taxes on beer, entertainments and cigarettes, because the previous Government had in view certain other things that are being wiped out by this present Government. That side of the account would have to be taken and looked at. I am granting the Minister full credit, if it is to be credit and if it is a saving. That is purely provisional because I have a few remarks to pass later and I am saving myself for that and do not want to be taken up shortly—but granting him full credit for capturing that sum which reduced the Estimate to the sum which he is budgeting for now, it leaves him with a certain sum of money to be found and he is finding the money in putting sixpence extra on income-tax. He has been able to save by means of the complete abolition of the last Supplementary Budget which imposed a tax on beer, entertainments, cigarettes and tobacco. Taking credit for what he has done in the present Budget, the Minister has still the alternative of keeping some tax on tobacco, beer and cigarettes which are non-essentials as against the imposition of income-tax. Why not have held some part of the tax on non-essentials and not put it on income-tax? The Minister approached this question, I think, with a view to undoing what he and his colleagues considered to be the evils of the Supplementary Budget. Let me, provisionally and for the moment, approach it in that spirit too.

The Minister was so concerned with getting rid of the evils flowing from the Supplementary Budget, why did he not take the course of leaving income tax as it was and leaving some tax on the other commodities or balance it in any way he liked and give some relief even if it were only to the people with very small incomes? I would be quite satisfied if the Minister had not put any increase on the very small incomes. If it was a question of reviewing the Supplementary Budget I think it would have been better to consider all the items rather than to go straight away and strike out the tax on non-essentials, leaving so many things which affect the essentials.

Now we come to the question of indirect taxation. Indirect taxation can arise in a number of forms under modern conditions. It can arise under the form of a tax paid on a commodity directly but I do not think that we are particularly interested in that in this Budget except in regard to certain categories. It can arise in increasing the burden through the operations of the executive in control of financial affairs. If, for example, subsidies were withdrawn it would have the effect of increasing the price of commodities. That form of indirect taxation might, however, be more properly dealt with under the heading of the cost of living. But indirect tax can arise more specifically and it can be described as nothing else than an indirect tax where money is collected, say, as a contribution or where money is collected in some way other than directly as tax to the central Executive, such as rates.

In this Budget there is an indication that we are being tempted to impose what really amounts to taxation in such indirect ways and to think that in escaping liability for the Central Fund by charging it in some other way or collecting it in some other way that we are reducing taxation. It does not matter to the person who has to pay what way it is collected from him. In that regard I would mention the supplementary allowances where, apparently, the proposal now is to increase contributions. If contributions are increased that is nothing more than a tax under another name. So, in so far as this Budget contains a proposal to increase contributions, we have a further indication of increased taxation. I think there is another proposal in regard to cash benefits recoupments which may have the effect of putting up rates. If it has the effect of putting up rates it is, in effect, an increase in taxation. As any ratepayer will tell you, it is very little consolation to him to find that the money which he has to pay out is divided into two categories, that he pays one cheque to the Revenue Commissioners' representatives directly and that the other goes to the rate collectors. It is very little solace to him to find that he simply has to treat it in two different accounts. The total sum of money that comes out of his pocket is the same.

So, as far as I have gone, what have we got? We have got in this Budget, not touching even necessaries, income-tax, increased contributions and, to be strictly fair, I will put it in this way, the probability or possibility at least of an increase of rates in certain quarters. Against that we have the very substantial reductions which the Minister has made in beer, tobacco, cigarettes, and so forth. That is the position. I wonder is such a distribution a wise or a desirable distribution?

Personally, I would be inclined to favour reliefs which would benefit the family, which would touch the necessaries of life, which would touch directly the problem of rearing families and of living up to a decent standard, especially for lower salaried workers and people like that as against the question of affording reliefs in what are not necessaries, to put it mildly.

On that showing then, I think that this Budget fails completely to show any real decrease in taxation under those heads which would be of benefit to the community at large. On the other hand, the decrease in taxation on the items which have been favoured seems to me to be encouraging that aspect of our life which under modern conditions needs least encouragement. If we have to face up to the difficulties of the present moment I think we should be prepared to cut down on our luxuries or near-luxuries and so provide the moneys which are necessary for the other things for which we must provide.

The picture is even less reassuring when one comes to consider the question of these food subsidies. In regard to the wheat subsidy, in effect, the bread and flour subsidy will remain. What we are doing is averaging the cost over a number of years. I may be wrong in this but that appears to me to mean nothing more than borrowing, so to speak, for the next five years ahead. We are taking credits from the years ahead and in effect we are borrowing this year up to a certain amount. If I read the Minister's figures correctly, it comes to about £7,000,000 over each of these five years. We are borrowing ahead over the next five years in order to relieve our Budgetary position this year. Of course, the burden which we are committing ourselves to this year must be paid for in the years ahead. Supposing we are to do the same thing next year and the year after it will not be a very happy situation. In any event, by taking this step now, we are precluding ourselves from certain benefits that good fortune might bring to us in the next years. We shall have to find the money for this year, that is, if I read the figures correctly. Again, I doubt the wisdom of such a policy. It has always been accepted that borrowing for current expenses of this nature is unwise and this device appears to me to be nothing more than borrowing.

Then we have the removal of the subsidies on oatmeal and margarine. These are commodities that are used in certain poor households fairly freely. If, as a result of the removal of the subsidies, the price of these commodities goes up, we are contributing directly to an increase in the cost of living for the consumers of these commodities.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know how much it is?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I said we are contributing. It may not be much.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy any idea of how much it is?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I have not at the moment but it would be something.

Comment on this

.0043.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

What is it per lb?

Comment on this

.0043 of a point in the cost of living.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is a different way of putting it. I should like the Minister to look at it from this point of view, that there are certain poor families whose cost of living is not represented by the index struck on the basis of the consumption of a large number of articles that that family does not consume. I shall see if I have a note of the actual articles comprised in the computation of that index.

Comment on this

Which index is the Deputy looking at?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The cost of living index.

Comment on this

There are two of them.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I know that. I am taking the general one.

Comment on this

You are taking the last one?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Logically, I should ask the Minister that question because, since he gave a figure, I should like to know on what it is based.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was going to refer to commodities that were taken off.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Whichever index it is, there were a number of commodities taken in that index that are not representative of the particular poor class that I am thinking of in connection with the consumption of oatmeal and margarine. Suppose it only amounts to a few pence per lb. on the commodity, it is a few pence on the lb. of margarine or oatmeal, if it is as much as that, and that is significant to them.

Comment on this

It is not significant.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

To a poor person.

Comment on this

It is not significant to any person.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If that is the Minister's view, it is very well to have it— that the increase in the price of oatmeal or margarine would then be insignificant.

Comment on this

It is insignificant.

Comment on this

To the Minister. The Minister does not eat them.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Let us take the adjustments on tea, sugar and butter. I can understand what the Minister is doing in withdrawing the subsidies from certain catering establishments, and if that were to affect only our big hotels here in the city I would be inclined to congratulate the Minister on his ingenuity in finding this particular manner of economising on a subsidy. The difficulty is in regard to the big hotels—the Minister knows the type I mean and I do not wish to name any one in particular in this Assembly. In that case, their other income and the money they get from their clients in other ways is so large compared to the items of tea, sugar and butter that it is very probable that in those institutions the withdrawal of the subsidy will not increase the price at all.

In those high-class hotels, the change in the subsidy probably will have no adverse reaction on the price of the meal charged to the customer. The trouble is that that is not likely to be the situation in the case of catering establishments which provide for the lower paid and salaried worker in the city. There is a large number of people who travel in from the outskirts every day and who have a meal in town during the day. Some of them have lunch, but very many of them, as a matter of economy, have tea and a bun, or something like that.

In many of the establishments which cater for these people, they have not got the resources and other sources of income of these big hotels and they will be compelled to pass on the increased price of tea, sugar and butter to their clients. The danger that I anticipate could materialise from this proposal, in short, is that it will have no adverse effect on the clientéle of the large hotels, but in the case of canteens and smaller institutions providing for city workers—and by worker I include not only the manual worker but the clerks and others who eat in the city every day—these workers will have forced upon them certain increased charges for their lunch. This removal of the subsidy in the case of these commodities will have the effect, if my reasoning is right, of increasing the cost of living on these people.

Looking at it vis-a-vis this Budget, many of these people will find that they have to pay more in income-tax and their daily lunch will cost them a little more, so the net effect will be that they are suffering an increase in taxation and a rise in the cost of living. How far such prognostications on my part will appear in practice I cannot say in actual figures, but they are fears that I entertain at this moment and I think it is valid for me to put that point of view to the Minister. I ask him whether that aspect has been considered and, if not, whether it will be considered and whether the necessary adjustments will be made; and if it has been considered, what precautions are being taken to see that that class of person does not suffer from the withdrawal of the subsidy, with a net increase in the cost of living for him.

On that showing, this Budget is not revolutionary. It cannot show a provision for reducing the general level of taxation—and I have given the Minister full credit, and do it again, for the reduction in the tax on beer, cigarettes and so forth. But does that compensate for the increase in direct and indirect ways in other cases? In his own statement, the Minister uses the fact that he gave these reductions as a justification for the imposition of, say, an increased amount of contribution in respect of certain allowances. This Budget does not reduce taxation in its general level, nor does it reduce the cost of living. Its tendency in regard to subsidies is to put up the cost of living. Bad and all, from certain aspects, as the Supplementary Budget so much complained of was, it did halt a certain trend and did bring down the cost of living to a certain small degree. It was unpalatable. I myself from the far side of the House asked the then Minister to consider the question of the pint and many of us would have liked to alter some of these things. Yet there is this much to be said—it halted a certain trend which had got altogether out of hand in 1947. On the Vote on Account, I traced the factors which went to increase the cost of living in 1947. That Budget did halt it. Will this Budget maintain things steady, let alone improve the position? There is nothing in it which shows a marked improvement and, on the general level, any improvement, on the position as it was last autumn. It is, therefore, a question as to whether the general policy adopted by the Minister in this regard is wise.

There are some disquieting features in this Budget. We are all talking about the cost of living, taxation and an increase in production—but what are we doing to tackle the problem involved? On the Vote on Account, I traced in some detail the factors which increased the cost of living in 1947. I think the arguments which I advance were valid. Briefly, they were three, and I wish merely to state them and do not intend to repeat my argument. The increase was due to the increased inflationary pressures in the world at large, to the rise in world prices; they were due to a certain sympathetic rise in prices here; and they were due to the removal of the Standstill Order. Over the external pressure, the then Minister, like the present Minister, could have no control and in any event I can find no proposal in this Budget which would be calculated to deal with the external inflationary pressures, with the outside forces affecting the value of sterling. In regard to the rise in our own local prices the present Minister is faced with the very same problem which faced his predecessor. He cannot simply say to our own producers: "You will hold your price at that level and sell at such a level to the consumer," because he knows that to do so would drive the producer below the economic level and would put him out of production. He cannot do that and neither could his predecessor.

The only thing that could be done in the matter of wages would be an attempt to control wages voluntarily at first. The Minister's predecessor advocated that.

Comment on this

Advocated?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The control of wages under three headings. I take it that that is what the Minister wants, since he has threatened compulsion at a later stage if he cannot get it in that way.

Comment on this

Compulsion in what?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I will read what the Minister said:

"I would make a most earnest appeal to all employees not to seek further increases in monetary remuneration or improvements in working conditions, unless warranted by exceptional circumstances. Recent experience confirms that the benefit of an increase in money incomes is rapidly swallowed up by rising prices."

Comment on this

What about the former Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am answerable for myself. When speaking on the Vote on Account I pointed out the danger of a race between prices and wages—Official Report, Vol. 110, No. 4, Col. 377. The Minister is probably right in stating:

"Recent experience confirms that the benefit of an increase in money incomes is rapidly swallowed up by rising prices. Another important factor in the present inflated structure of wholesale and retail prices is the high level of profits in trade and industry. When the excess corporation profits tax and excess surtax were abolished two years ago by my predecessor, with effect as from the end of 1946, it was expected that this would be followed by a general fall in prices, with consequential effects in the shape of a reduced cost of living and an increase in the purchasing power of incomes. This expectation has unfortunately not been realised, and from the figures which I have examined it is clear that excessive profits are still being taken in a number of instances, despite all efforts at price control. I have already appealed for the cooperation of the business community in the task of bringing down prices, but so far without result. If inflationary forces are to be prevented from getting completely out of hand, there may be no alternative but to restore the machinery of control embodied in the various Standstill Orders. This is not in contemplation but if it should be forced upon us it would be accompanied this time by the appropriation of the whole, not merely a part, of any excess profits."

Comment on this

Surely that refers to profits now.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Does it not?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Of course it does, but it refers also to the machinery of control embodied in the various Standstill Orders.

Comment on this

If you like to take it that way you can do so.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If that is not wide enough to include the Standstill Orders——

Comment on this

Ask anyone to read it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I ask the Minister, who is a lawyer too, to read it.

Comment on this

I have real it. I composed it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister rightly appealed to workers and to people who got an increase in remuneration which amounted, he says, to from 100 to 160 per cent. not to seek further remuneration. He dealt with the question of profits. In other words, he is requesting voluntary control. His predecessor did the same and he is compelled, as was his predecessor, to say that if he cannot get the necessary results voluntarily he will be forced to seek them compulsorily. If that is not what the Minister says I am afraid I do not understand English.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy does not.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I will have to learn the Minister's English.

Comment on this

That is good King's English but the Deputy may not understand that.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister's English is good King's English. We always knew that.

Comment on this

You have come a good bit towards it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

In regard to these three facts that are putting up the cost of living there were only three possible remedies, and, as far as I can see, the Minister has not been able to improve on them. He has, however, by making these adjustments here, in my opinion, taken some very undesirable steps. I have already traced the trend in regard to taxation. Not only does the Minister find himself—I am giving him credit for the best of intentions—completely unable to redeem his promises to reduce the cost of living and to reduce the taxation in any real sense affecting the community as a whole but he finds himself forced in this year anyway, no matter what the reasons are, to resort to certain borrowing expedients. He has already raised a loan. I am not sure what the exact appropriations of that loan are—perhaps the Minister will tell us. I would ask him in detail the specific appropriations of the sums of money collected by him under that loan. I am not criticising that loan but the fact is that it has been raised and that it will have to be paid back with interest. That is number one contribution by the present Government to the financial affairs of the State. I hope that it will be applied in a way that will be beneficial to the community. In raising it he would have our help and support for such purposes but he cannot get away from the fact that, as a whole, it represents a debt that has to be paid back.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy asking for the details of the appropriations of the loan? I will give him the details, with pleasure, in a moment. They are your debts.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am asking the Minister to specify in detail the appropriations. It is very easy to say that they are somebody else's debts.

Comment on this

It is very hard to meet somebody else's debts.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The device for deferring the raising of the wheat subsidy for this year's commitment is, in effect, a loan. Then we have a further device for the raising of a loan in the device of the beer duties. I congratulate the Minister on his ingenuity in this matter. However, when he tries to collect, in the current year, 13 months' instalments from the brewers —if I read this aright—it will leave only 11 months' instalments next year.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Major de Valera

What is that but a loan from next year to this year? I question, in regard to the wheat subsidy, and also in regard to the beer duty, whether these devices which, in effect, amount to a loan, are in the public interest. They will have to be paid back. The money will have to be found. They do not, therefore, represent anything in the nature of a saving. If it is not paid this year, posterity in subsequent years will have to pay. On top of that, there is the complete failure to alleviate either taxation or the cost of living.

What do we find, looking at it from a long-term point of view? Whatever may be the faults or mistakes of the previous Administration, there was a drive forward towards development. You had to pay for it. I am open to argument as to how much it was worth it or how much it was not. The present Minister approaches this Budget primarily from the point of view of retrenchment. When all is said and done, some of the biggest items he has been able to find, the savings in this Budget, come from retrenchment, and from what retrenchment? From the following items. We have already dealt with defence and I do not intend to go into it again. More will be said about that in the future. We now have a proposal to abandon the scheme for mineral exploration.

Surely if we are looking forward to increased production, development of our mineral resources, such as they are, and the surveying of them should be of importance to us here, particularly after the lessons of the emergency. Even if we are only to have readily exploitable resources, we should go on with that development. The Labour Party has always advocated such things. Provision was made for such development and, if I remember rightly, that provision was the subject of a certain amount of acclamation on the part of Deputies now supporting the Government. Nevertheless, as part of the present Government's retrenchment programme, the Minister wipes out that provision and with it the prospect of such development.

The Minister will probably say that it is not economic and that he will have to have due regard to economics and all that. I say to the Minister that it was precisely that outlook which brought the Governments of the day after the war before the last into the predicament in which they found themselves. In their efforts to retrench they forgot the need for developing and for balancing. That brought the Minister himself logically to make many speeches that perhaps he would not like to have quoted to him now. The question of finance, the question of finding money, was the paramount and dominant matter for consideration. The Minister himself on one occasion—he has had it thrown in his teeth often since—faced ruthlessly up to its implications. I wonder is the Minister coming back to that again. Taking this matter of not developing mineral resources, together with the cutting back of turf development, etc., I wonder whether that is a wise policy. I sympathise with the Minister in his problem of finding the money. I do think, however, that he is unwise in taking that attitude. When all is said and done, it is better to have real activity and to try to develop wealth than to cut down on such development in order to show a proper balance sheet. The Tourist Board is now to go I believe. I understand the building of national schools may be suspended. Am I right in that?

Comment on this

Quite wrong.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am glad to hear that.

Comment on this

The building of some of them will be suspended.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The building of some national schools will be suspended.

Comment on this

How many did you build last year?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Do not mind that. You are in charge now. Provision was made for the building of a certain number of national schools and everything was set for that. You have the responsibility for any changes in that programme now. You cannot evade that by asking how much we did or did not do. You have it in your hands now. The plans are there. Why are the schools not to be built?

Comment on this

I am trying to point out that you could not spend the money last year.

Comment on this

Materials are plentiful now.

Comment on this

I wish they were.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The short-wave station is to go.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I have one observation to make on that. One of the reasons why we were interested in a short-wave station was that during the war we found ourselves in a rather isolated position and, if my memory serves me right, at that time we were anxious to have a short-wave station as a means of communicating with the outside world in certain eventualities.

Comment on this

You are doing it now without a station.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am talking in terms of possible defence. I am raising the question whether it would not be wise for us, since we realised in the past the effects of its absence, to get a short-wave station to give us an independent means of communicating with the world at large in certain eventualities. That apparently is to go. I doubt if it is wise, from a defence point of view.

Comment on this

Is a short wave station any good without a short wave-length?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is not the point. Under the circumstances I am visualising, you are now going to find yourself without any wave-length. You can get out a wave-length that will penetrate——

Comment on this

Are you sure you can?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

You can in these circumstances. During the war we felt it a number of times. Actually the Emergency Scientific Bureau had as one of their tasks the question of trying to improvise such a station because, in certain circumstances, we would have been unable to communicate with the outside world, as the range of our long-wave station is very limited. In these circumstances, during the war its loss was felt. There may be difficulty in getting a wave-length assigned in peace time. But, if you have the station, I think you will probably get a wave-length. That is my own personal opinion. In any event, if you have a station, you will be able to communicate with the outside world during an emergency when you would not be so terribly worried about legal distinctions and trespassing on somebody else's.

Comment on this

That is not the only difficulty.

Comment on this

It does not matter. Let us have the station and we will overcome the difficulties.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is a difference between two approaches, and the Minister's approach is that it is too expensive to do anything.

Comment on this

Not at all. It is futile.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Our approach was to get things done. However, I am trying to take this in a reasonable way and I shall try to resist the temptation that the Minister is putting in my way to be a little more forcible. I shall have to conclude in a moment.

Comment on this

There is no question on the adjournment.

Comment on this

The short-wave station is still open for another half-hour.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I may have a few more facts to broadcast that the Minister may not find to his liking. I am trying to approach this Budget from a reasonable point of view. After all, although it is very entertaining, it is the country at large which has to pay for the expense of Government. Our function is to examine these things critically and carefully. As I said, I feel that in this Budget, although it is not by any means revolutionary, the Minister has failed in any substantial degree to reach the target he set himself of reducing the cost of living and reducing taxation. On the other hand, in finding the money, notwithstanding his economies within the service, he has been forced to take two steps at least which threaten a tendency towards a rise in the cost of living in respect of certain lower paid workers, salaried workers and even manual workers. He has been unable to avoid the forecasted increase in income-tax. Then on top of that, in effecting his retrenchment, he has been forced to take certain steps which have brought even from his own supporters and from some of the Parties like the Labour Party a hornet's nest about his ears. I wonder is he wise in these things.

One last word with regard to inflationary pressures. The Minister himself, when on these benches, was very insistent on the fact that the Administration in his view appeared to take no cognisance of external inflationary pressures. There was the inflow of a large volume of money into this country through the adjustment of the value of sterling, and the Minister's Party went so far as to blame the Administration of the day here for the depreciation in the value of the £, notwithstanding the fact that the £ here was, of course, linked at par value with sterling, and that we had no control over sterling. I do not think the Minister had advocated a break with sterling. I was expecting, in view of the fact that the Minister when he sat on this side made such play with these matters that, at least, he would have adverted to them in the Budget. He has not done so, and therefore I can only conclude that now, with responsibility upon his shoulders, he has to take certain hard facts into consideration just as his predecessors did. I do not want to exploit that situation now against the Minister, but I do want to say that, notwithstanding his Budget and the change that has taken place, our problem remains. It is fundamentally the same problem as the problem which faced his predecessor in the autumn of last year. The Minister, however, has this advantage that he has the proposals for European reconstruction to fall back upon, but except for this, and for the aid which he can get from the Marshall Plan and the aid which he can get through any drift-back to stability in the outside situation, he finds himself in the same position.

As I said at the outset he has had prices going up and the cost of living going up because of three things. There is first the world situation. It may better itself for him. I sincerely hope it does. There are the increased prices for our home produced commodities and the tendency towards inflation through the increase in wages here. I hope that the European aid programme will come to his rescue on the first point. He has talked about getting after excess profits, but so far he has made no proposal. He has threatened the reimposition of the excess profits tax, but he has not yet disclosed to us any examination of that particular problem. I know it was examined in the past, and I wonder whether, at the end of the examination, the Minister will not find himself confronted with the same hard facts as his predecessors were confronted with in the past, namely that there are no big savings to be got from that quarter—I mean big in relation to the amount of money which he has to find for his Budget. On the other hand, he will have a difficult position due to the increased prices which our farmers are getting for home produced commodities. Since he cannot cut these prices he can only subsidise as his predecessor did. He cannot cut prices anywhere, or does he propose to? I do not think he does. What can he do then with regard to these except to subsidise? Does the present Budget forecast a removal of further subsidies in the future and, if so, how can it affect prices?

We have already had our argument about the wages position. In other words, the Minister has the same problem as his predecessor and he has not been able to produce any more revolutionary answer to it. The economies which he has effected have been effected at a cost which, frankly, I think they are not worth. That is so in regard to some of these items anyway. The public had been expecting a Budget which would compulsorily reduce prices and which, at the same time, would reduce taxation.

In all this discussion I have omitted the motor car because I was trying to deal with the general impact of the Budget on the community as a whole rather than on classes. But take the case of the oil tax and even leaving out the private owner of a motor car. Take distributing firms which are dependent on petrol for transport. How are they going to be affected by this tax? Already the representative of one of the leading firms in the city has threatened a delivery charge. If there is a delivery charge on my groceries is not that going to put up the price of my groceries and put up my cost of living? I am trying to be strictly fair to the Minister and not to exaggerate, but surely he must see that this tax may tend towards a movement to increase bus fares, and if they are increased will not that put up the cost of living on the many civil servants and other classes of workers who have to travel to their work in the city every day? They get a certain salary and have to live out of it. To juggle with the cost-of-living figures will not help them very much when they find that they have to pay a higher bus fare to get to their work or, if they have to take a meal in town, to pay more for it. Is the net result of this Budget for many of these people who pay income-tax to be that they will have to pay 6d. more in income-tax, plus a dearer lunch in town and plus higher bus fares?

Comment on this

And dearer margarine.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

And plus dearer margarine, and dearer oatmeal if the Minister wants to have his joke, and I suppose plus cheaper cigarettes and beer and so forth. Do Deputies opposite think that a man's wife and children can exist on beer and cigarettes?

Comment on this

The wife may smoke too.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

But is that good economy? Is it good from the point of view of public policy that we should allow the necessaries of life to increase in their cost while we pander to the not-necessaries?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy advocate the re-imposition of the duty on beer and tobacco?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I shall make one reservation, as I did when speaking on a former occasion on the other side of the House. I asked the Minister at that time not to put a tax on the pint because the pint was not in that category. In regard to other liquors, if it is a choice between increasing income-tax, increasing bus fares and a tax on food or a tax on beer, I say that if I had that choice I would put it on beer.

Comment on this

You put it on all of them.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I would try to exempt the pint for the reason I gave.

Comment on this

Did you not vote for that tax?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Certainly.

Comment on this

Although you did not believe in it?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I was a member of a Party and I voted with that Party but at the same time I expressed my own view. I have no apologies to make for that at all. To get back to the question I was asked in regard to other things, if it were a question of balance—I do not say that the Minister should not have reduced the tax on some of these items but he ought to have struck a more suitable balance as between them—I say in our approach to these things, necessaries in that sense come first.

Comment on this

When did the bus fares go up?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Anyway, it is very apparent that, by what I have said, I have made certain people on the right-centre from me uncomfortable, but that was not my purpose at all. I want to approach this matter in an objective spirit. I am prepared to wait for the Minister's answers and to argue with him. It is not from the point of view of making political capital out of the question that I am approaching it in this way. I hope I have shown that the balancing of this Budget is unbalanced, if I might put it that way, that the Minister has been too constrained by the promises he made before he assumed office and before he examined the facts, and that he could have given a much better performance if he had not prematurely committed himself in one direction without examining the problem as a whole.

These are the criticisms I wish to make and I have to leave it at that. A year, anyway, will tell us the whole story. It will be interesting to see whether the Minister will be forced to impose these controls to which he referred. It will be interesting to see whether his hopes or my fears will be realised. Personally, for the good of the country, I hope that it will not work out——

Comment on this

That you will be wrong again.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

——in the way I fear. I should be very glad to feel that the Minister can by such a device as he adopted in the case of tea, sugar and butter, save the Exchequer something. That device will, I am afraid, pass nothing on to the people who go into the big hotels but it will pass it on to the people who go into the small canteens. If it does not do that there is something to be said for this approach. I have no figures that would enable me intelligently to deal with the reduction in the traders' margins. I realise that with the new increase in the ration, there is an automatic increase in the turnover but in the absence of specific data I do not feel warranted in criticising that particular item, approving of it or otherwise.

It would not be fair for me to leave the Budget without saying that, though I do not think it can be done without serious repercussions on the rest of our economy, I am glad to observe that the Minister has been able to give these reliefs in regard to pensions. I would have been more glad to see these reliefs given if they had come from the maintenance of some amount of tax on non-essentials rather than on some of the things that are involved in this Budget.

Comment on this

Are you going to vote against it?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Deputy O'Higgins is going back to his old catch-cry: "Are you going to vote against it?" We vote on the Budget as a whole.

Comment on this

Answer the question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy de Valera is making a speech and is not under cross-examination.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I think it a good thing if such reliefs can be given but it would have been better to have done it in another way. There are a number of things in this Budget, as I see it, that are, to say the least of it, dangerous for the future. On turning over the Minister's speech I find the entertainments duty and the question of wines. On the question of wines, the Minister has posed in this Legislative Assembly a very interesting moral question. The wines here consumed are luxury wines; nobody can say that they are in the nature of a necessity. They are luxury wines and they are consumed by the type of person in the luxury class mostly. We have, therefore, here two conflicting interests. The Minister says that we put too much of a tax on wine, that the consumption went down in consequence and that we are not getting sufficient revenue from it. What I shall call the finance administration, qua finance administration, says: “We had better get more wine drunk in the country so that we can get more money.”

Comment on this

That is not right.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It looks very like it. The Minister gave as his reason——

Comment on this

May I correct the Deputy? We say: "Let us get the consumption of wine back to the same point as before the taxes were increased and we shall get more revenue."

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The finance machine, so to speak, feels that it is a very sad thing that the consumption of luxury wine decreased. I do not know how we are tied up with foreign exchange in this matter but the decrease in the consumption of luxury wine cost the revenue apparently a certain amount. On the other hand, I should like to urge on the Minister, from the point of view of the community as a whole, that other people in this community are suffering certain hardships owing to general economic conditions. His colleagues on his left will give him all the details of the picture. In such a situation, is it a good thing that we should encourage the spending of money on such luxury items? We have been talking of luxury expenditure. Here we have a provision directly encouraging expenditure on a luxury of the most extreme type——

Comment on this

Rubbish.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

——simply because a certain proportion of that will flow into the Exchequer. I sympathise with the purely financial temptation in that regard but from the point of view of the general good I question whether it is wise——

Comment on this

To do what?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

To try to encourage the drinking of wine back to the point at which it formerly stood in order that we may get an adequate return.

Comment on this

Did the amount of wine consumed last August annoy the Deputy's conscience?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am talking about the position at the moment. I am talking of the desirability of this public Assembly sponsoring such an approach and I am perfectly entitled to do that.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not very logical.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I think it is a perfectly fair comment. Is it right to encourage expenditure on the consumption of commodities such as luxury wines in order that a percentage of the money spent will flow back into the Exchequer?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy suggest that the worker's wife is not entitled to have a glass of Hall's wine if she feels she needs it?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Hall's wine is a very different type of wine from that dealt with here. A specific exemption would deal with that case, if necessary.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy ill enough to get a glass?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I should like to congratulate the Minister on the excellent way in which Fine Gael has got everybody else under the Party Whip. Not only is the coalition staying together but Fine Gael policy has been accepted so beautifully. However, so much for the wines. I have said it twice and I do not intend to say it again, but I doubt the wisdom, from the public point of view, of doing it.

Comment on this

You have not answered.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

What is worrying me is that I have approached this matter, so far as I can, in a dispassionate and objective way, but the Deputy is making me feel that I am enjoying myself.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Morrissey) Fine Gael

You are providing a certain amount of enjoyment.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

There are a few more matters in this Budget which might be mentioned, one of which is the entertainments duty. How far will the provision with regard to live performances have an adverse effect on employed talent? I am thinking of the City of Dublin which I represent and towards which I have a particular duty. It may not be an important matter in the country, but it may very well be important in the City of Dublin. How far will this provision have a direct effect on people employed? I sympathise with the Minister——

Comment on this

You need not. It has no effect.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is easy for the Minister to say that. The patent theatres are in a class apart and that is very satisfactory. Will it have any effect on employment in other theatres in Dublin City?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Is the Minister perfectly certain?

Comment on this

Absolutely certain.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister says it will not disemploy one person?

Comment on this

I think not—not in Dublin.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That may be the Minister's information at the moment, but I ask him to look into it carefully again and see if it is so.

Comment on this

If the Deputy gives me any information to the contrary, I will have it examined microscopically.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Very well.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell me now what he is talking about?

Comment on this

Representations will be made to the Minister in due course.

Comment on this

About what?

Comment on this

The disemployment of variety artistes.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. Cosgrave) Fine Gael

It was the previous Minister who employed foreigners.

Comment on this

Disemployment by reason of the change?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I put the question to the Minister and the Minister said he was sure that no one would be disemployed. I say that I hope so, but I ask him to inquire again. I leave it now to people with more specific information. I confess that I am talking in the general sphere.

Comment on this

Without any information.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Not quite.

Comment on this

Tell me what the information is.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Let me put it this way: are there not theatres in Dublin which are getting an exemption because certain artistes perform at certain times?

Comment on this

There were.

Comment on this

Tell me where they were.

Comment on this

The Ritz Cinema, in Ringsend.

Comment on this

Wholly or mainly a live show?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

It only got exemption in those circumstances.

Comment on this

No. They are enjoying the benefit of the concession in respect of entertainments tax.

Comment on this

Do you know it was getting the exemption?

Comment on this

My informant was the proprietor.

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera is only in reserve to-night.

Comment on this

I think his prompter from behind was better than the one in front.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Deputy is open to a very hurtful answer, but I will not make it.

Comment on this

Will Deputy MacEntee give me the case again?

Comment on this

I can give it when I am speaking. I want to allow Deputy de Valera to speak. It is quite clear that the Minister does not want to hear him.

Comment on this

Deputy McCann will give me the information.

Comment on this

I will.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Another matter the Minister mentioned in the Budget was this question of foreign travel. He proposes to make available now certain sums for foreign travel, in conformity, I think, with somewhere abroad. In the main, it is only the better-off classes in this country who will go for holidays abroad.

Comment on this

Is that true?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

In the main, is it not?

Comment on this

Nobody will go abroad but better-class people?

Comment on this

In the main.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

There is only one question I want to ask the Minister in that regard. He included a reference to it in his Budget. Does it involve any commitment for the State? He does not have to find these sums of money internally. They are found by the person who proposes to travel.

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

So do I, especially when they are, in the main, the more leisured classes. Does it involve any alteration of or burden on our balance of payments position? Will it have any repercussions on our external situation? It is bound to have a certain amount of repercussion, and I should like to know to what extent this provision will affect our balance of payments situation. I should also like to know in this connection how far the remuneration we are getting through tourists will be correspondingly cut off by the proposed provision in respect of the tourist trade. I understand that certain reorganisations are envisaged. The effect of these—I am again open to correction by the Minister—may very well be to reduce the monetary income from these tourist sources. That is the effect in one direction. That will have to be looked at in conjunction with the effect of this provision for giving our money abroad, that is, for doing the reverse. What will be the combined effects of these two departures on the part of the new administration on our general position? It does not appear to me to be shown in this Budget.

Comment on this

Do not some of our travellers expect to bring home more with them than they take with them?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I move to report progress.

Comment on this