Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 6—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–149 of 488. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
When we adjourned on Thursday night I was dealing with the question of catering establishments and hotels. These concerns will in future pay the full retail price for rationed goods. It is claimed that this measure will not result in any increase in price to the consumer. That may be so in regard to the larger hotels. However, as regards the ordinary restaurants which the ordinary worker in Dublin patronises for his lunch, where the prices are already pinned down to the lowest level possible, it is extremely likely—in fact it is certain— that the increase will be passed on to the consumer. In the very poor type of workers' restaurants around such places as Parnell Street, Summerhill and Marlborough Street, there will definitely have to be an increase and, as a result, this item in the Budget will work out as an increase in the fundamental items of food for the very poorest section of the community.
The Minister, in introducing his Budget and referring to the increase in petrol, prefaced his remarks by referring to the number of new cars that had been taxed during the past 12 months. We all know that the increase in the number of cars was due to the fact that cars could not be replaced during the emergency. I think the Minister will find that a very large percentage of those new registrations are for commercial vehicles. This tax on petrol means, therefore, a tax on trade.
Comment on this
The number of miles travelled for pleasure purposes nowadays is infinitesimal. Already one firm in Dublin is threatening to make a charge for delivery. Undoubtedly we shall have an increase in transport charges. The Minister will be driven into the position of allowing it, after a short period of time. That, too, works out as an increase in the cost of living for the ordinary worker in Dublin. This increase in the price of petrol will also probably affect the price of milk in Dublin. The greater part of the milk supplied to Dublin is delivered by motor lorry, and when the price comes to be settled again, the increase in the price of petrol will have its affect by raising the price of milk. The most necessary food in the life of a child will under this paternal Budget be taxed.
So far, as a result of the Government's policy, large-scale unemployment has occurred. Week by week the figures show an increase in unemployment of somewhere around 7,000 on the figures for the corresponding period last year, that is, an increase of roughly 10 per cent. This is the work of a Coalition Government which set out to stop emigration. As far as I can see, they are making the road easy for emigration instead of doing otherwise. Some years ago there were great lamentations from the Labour benches about the emigration from the country, which at that time was due absolutely to lack of materials during the emergency. To judge by these lamentations one would really have believed that the Labour Party had a cure for emigration. To-day, however, materials are not nearly in such short supply, but, due to other actions, unemployment is increasing and emigration is very likely increasing too.
During the election the Minister for Social Welfare gave us to understand that he had a cure for it. But, when he gets the responsibility, it turns out that he has no cure, except to pass it on to a commission to find out the causes. During the election he had no doubt that it was all due to the misgovernment of Fianna Fáil, but some weeks later he had grave doubts and he had to set up a commission to find out the causes.
Comment on this
Did you people try to set up a commission? Do you not know that you did and then ran away from it?
Comment on this
Owing to this policy of the Government one very grievous thing is happening. For years we have been spending money on scholarships to send young brainy lads to the university. For a number of years most of those who have taken engineering and science degrees have been finding employment at home. Now, owing to this policy of cutting out the air services and other services which were started under the Fianna Fáil Government, a number of those young men are finding it necessary to emigrate. There is no work at home for them, so that all the public money that has been spent on their education is lost to this country, to say nothing of the other results of emigration. The Government seem to be going out of their way to bring about such results as that.
When one recalls the various motions put forward by members of the Government and their followers when they sat on the Opposition Benches for remedying a number of existing grievances, one is terribly surprised that the Budget does not attempt to deal with one of them. We know how the Minister for Finance raved about the injustice under which the teachers were suffering. We know that the threeyear period attached to the teachers' agreement by the Fianna Fáil Government was regarded as outrageous. The Minister has now power to remedy that, but he has not taken one step to bring that remedy about one hour earlier than it would have been brought about by the Fianna Fáil Government. Then we had motions for increased personal allowances and children's allowances under the income-tax code. There is no sign of any such reliefs in the Budget. Various other matters were enumerated here by Deputy Brady the other night. No relief in respect of any one of them has been given under this Budget.
The comparatively small sum of £85,000 for mineral exploration has also been cut out. If there was one thing on which there seemed to be general agreement hitherto it was that we should spend some money on mineral exploration to see if the mineral deposits in this country were worth developing. When the Bill dealing with that matter was before the House last year I do not think there was any voice raised against it. But not one penny has been provided for the work. Judging by the way the other schemes which were attempted to be developed by the Fianna Fáil Government have been cut out or cut down, there is, perhaps, a bit of consistency about cutting out mineral exploration, in spite of the fact that Labour and Clann na Poblachta Deputies have objected to that. If this mineral exploration did reveal a valuable deposit, it is very possible that the Minister would say: "You could not go ahead with that because there is no guarantee that it will pay a dividend the first year," just as he said about the air service, so that perhaps he is consistent in that. I think Labour and Clann na Poblachta Deputies ought to waken up to the fact that there is going to be no progress whatever, that they are going to have no chance whatever of carrying out the policies which they set before the people.
Under this Budget, the cost of living will be increased. The price of certain foods will certainly be increased. The imposition of certain taxes will lead to an increase in the price of certain foods. But the drink trade, the one trade that statistics show was increasing every day and was able to bear further taxation, is the one that was picked out for special treatment and the duties that were put on under the Supplementary Budget were taken off. It is extraordinary that that one trade should get such exceptional treatment. The Minister quoted certain figures for the last few months to show why he was taking off these duties. Everyone was aware, however, that there was a complete hold-up in that trade during those few months because of the definite promise that these duties would be remitted. These are not the months that should be taken. If one takes the figures from 1942 on, or even from 1939, one can see the continuous increase in sales. The increased prices given for public-houses during that period show that the trade was booming. But that trade was deliberately given special treatment although, no matter how one looks at it, it seemed to be able to bear increased taxation more than any other trade. As far as I can calculate it, the old age pensioners are to get about £3 per head extra this year. That will work out at something over 1/- a week. It is based on the fact that we have about 150,000 pensioners, that a sum of £600,000 is being provided this year, a provision which makes allowance for some increase also in the case of widows' and orphans' pensions. The Labour Deputies and the Clann na Poblachta people have been telling us all through the years how we had been neglecting the old age pensioners. They told us last year that we were not giving them near sufficient, even though we provided £2,000,000 for social services and £1,000,000 for old age pensioners. We did that without asking for any increased contributions from those who subscribe to the various funds which make provision for social services. Yet these same Deputies seem very pleased to-day that the old age pensioners are now to get something over 1/- a week more than they had been getting.
Comment on this
But that will be paid by subscribers to the social service funds. Out of those funds the Minister is going to provide £350,000 for the Exchequer instead of something for the old age pensioners.
The whole policy behind the Budget seems to be to stop any progress whatever—that we are too poor to attempt to do anything. That is much the same type of mind we on this side met with years ago when we attempted to do something in the way of bringing freedom to this country—that we were too weak to do anything. We met with that type of mind over and over again. Now, we are too weak to defend the country or to develop it. We will never be anything else unless some type of mind comes along and takes some chances. Personally, I cannot see the reason for that at all. Judging by what I know of other countries, we here are in as good a position to advance as any other country in the world. I am not satisfied at all that there are any good grounds financially for stopping development, but that seems to be the whole policy behind the Budget.
The figure of £1,250,000 has been mentioned in connection with further economies about which we have got no information. A policy of that kind may mean further unemployment when it is put into operation, and it is very likely that it will. The Minister is one who has never worried about unemployment, and his whole career shows that. It never worried him that anybody was thrown out of work. I hope I am wrong in that, because none of us want to see that. I hope, if it does happen, that the Labour people will show some more strength than they have shown up to the present about that sort of thing. That policy, if it is developed, will leave this country absolutely impoverished. We cannot stand still. We must go forward or else we will go backward, and we are definitely going back, I think. As I say, it will leave the country very impoverished, but I hope that such a policy will not have gone too far by the time some other Government will have a chance of rectifying it.
We have been told from the Government Benches that the people are well satisfied with this Budget. Deputy Cowan was one of those who told us that. Just a few hours before he mentioned it, I had been speaking to a constituent of his and of mine, to a man who has never been a supporter of Fianna Fáil. He described the mentality behind the Budget in this way. He said:—
"The mind behind it is the mind of a man who looks at the flag floating over Government Buildings and says what use is that; it cost 2/6 a yard; it is sheer waste, take it down."
I leave it to the House at that.
Deputy Connolly rose.
Comment on this
I do not want to keep the House too long on the Budget at this stage, but I would like to suggest to the House that when we are considering this first inter-Party Budget we have at the same time to think of the future working of democracy in this country. The problem for the present Government is to make one policy out of 12 effective. I should like to emphasise that point. There are some half-dozen Parties forming the Government. Each one of them at the general election proposed its own special policy, it made recommendations as to what it proposed to do in the industrial, agricultural, social and educational fields and, at the same time, it left in considerable doubt, as far as the electors were concerned, what compromise it was prepared to make if it took part in a Coalition. It is no easy task for any Government in any country in the world, no matter how many years that country has had its independence, to turn 12 policies into one, and to produce a policy which the people know is going to be adopted and promulgated for the length of that Government's term of office. It has been tried at various times throughout the whole of Europe. I should like to hear any Deputy on the Government side of the House make a defence, as a whole, of Coalition Government in times of peace. I should like to hear any Deputy on the Government side of the House recite for me the names of democratic countries either with a longer or a shorter term of independence than ours which, in times of peace, have made a success of making one policy out of 12. I say 12 and not six because each Party—at least in the next general election that follows— must have two policies. It must have its own private policy and a policy in the event of a Coalition. At the same time I do not wish to be unfair to the Government. They have been only a short time in office. They can produce one policy out of 12. If it is a good policy, if it works, if it increases agricultural and industrial production, if it gives confidence to the people of this country, they will be congratulated. They will have achieved success where others have failed.
They will find, however, going through the history of democracies in Europe that, for example, Sweden, Norway and Denmark, to take Scandinavia, tried coalitions, but on the whole did not continue them for very long. They even preferred minority Governments, Government where Parties in a minority took all the Ministries and remained in office for a considerable period, with a majority actually in the House against the Parties in power. They will find countries which adopted a coalition policy during the war reverting after the war to a one-Party Government, even although that Party was in a minority. They will find a number of exceptions where Coalition Governments for a short period succeeded admirably, but they will not find that it is easy to produce one policy out of 12.
In this country, on account of our short period of independence, Government has a profound influence on business and production. At the moment about 20 per cent. of the national income is taken in taxation. Government Orders and Government policy, therefore, have a considerable effect as far as the whole life of the community is concerned. People like to know what policy is going to be in respect of every aspect of Government. They like to know what the policy is going to be about tariffs, about the tillage area, about the improvement of farms, about the amount of money to be made available for certain services. The last Government made its mistakes like other Governments, but we were known to have a certain bias and a certain attitude towards the development of the country. As years went by and even in respect to the economic war and the Great War, the average business man, the average farmer and the average worker knew what our attitude was going to be. He knew we had certain well-conceived prejudices and certain well-conceived ideas. He knew that if we weighed certain things in the balance, we were always likely to put a little bit into the scales on one side or the other. The people of this country knew as far as tariffs and industry were concerned, that we were willing to take risks in assisting suggested new industries and that in reading all the memoranda put forward by the promoters of an industry there was always a little extra to be added to the balance. You could never judge these things purely on business principles, on purely financial principles. After we heard what the promoters had to say about the possibility of a market here, about the likely price of the goods manufactured here, about the employment to be given here, about the technical skill available and all the other factors, the people of this country knew that there was always some little weight to be put on one side or the other.
Comment on this
We in Fianna Fáil put the weight on the side of industry, a little extra risk going beyond the sheer ponderables in the situation. The same thing occurred in regard to social services. We on the Fianna Fáil side stood just half-way between the conservative world and the socialist or labour world. The people knew, as the years went by, that we would always take a risk, that we would take a little bit more out of the national pool of production and income if necessary to advance social services. We did advance these services. We advanced expenditure from £4,000,000 to £13,000,000. Labour made the complaint that we did not spend enough. People on the Fine Gael side complained sometimes that we spent too much and sometimes too little. They were divided in their views, but whatever the Labour people had against Fianna Fáil, they knew that the bias on the whole was always in the direction of providing more generous allowances and that our attitude was that there is no harm in taking a little more out of the national pool for social services. This brings stability in time of depression and is justified, because I suppose the majority even of those who might be described as capitalists now agree that the rate of private saving is not nearly sufficient in any industrial community in order to provide for the accidents of life, to provide for sickness and ill-health and all the other eventualities that face a man of small income. Therefore no matter what private enterprise may say, no matter what the taxpayer may say, you have constantly to go in the direction of making adequate provision for social services.
As I have said we, in Fianna Fáil, had that certain bias. The same thing applied to new and entirely speculative enterprises, such as the wireless station, such as air development, such as Irish Shipping Limited. I am very glad that, owing to the war, Irish Shipping Limited managed to develop shipping services for this country and that because of the peculiar circumstances which attended the operation of our new merchant service, they managed as far as I can gather to offset most of their initial loss. If not, their position would very likely be that of the air company here. If we had not had the war, if we had not the peculiar, the automatic, protection afforded to our merchant service, the little group of ships that now exists might be exactly in the same peril from the action of the Government as the air service— evidence of an annual loss for years to come if the service were continued. Mercifully, as far as I can gather, the shipping service was a success. I have not heard if the Government have in any way inhibited its future activity. I should like to ask the Minister for Finance if there has been any change of policy in regard to Irish Shipping Limited since the election.
Comment on this
My answer would be directly contrary to that of Deputy Lemass. In any event Deputy Lemass is wrong.
Comment on this
I have indicated the general tendency of Fianna Fáil in regard to Government policy. When we start to examine this Budget in the light of the various policies of the Parties forming the inter-Party Government, we find an element of uncertainty. It would be good for the country if that uncertainty could be removed as soon as possible because, as I have said, Government influences business, influences production, influences industry and influences agriculture. To examine for a moment tendencies in policy, we will take the attitude of Fine Gael towards the future industry of this country. I do not think I am wrong in saying that that Party has been divided considerably in the past ten years in regard to industry. I have heard Fine Gael Deputies speak of industry with very different voices. I have heard some who took a very definitely modern attitude towards Irish industry, who were prepared to accept tariffs provided industry became efficient later on —the general attitude of Fianna Fáil. I have heard other Deputies in Fine Gael, right up to the last few weeks, speak of industry in the very old conservative free-trade terms of long ago.
I have heard Deputies speak in the last six months in this way, that there should be no tariff on any new industry unless the raw material is entirely produced in this country. That is a matter which is of profound significance in this country. You cannot have stable business, you cannot have industrial development, if there is to be even that amount of difference in regard to industrial production as between different members of Fine Gael. In the case of England and Denmark—let us leave England out of the argument, because, if one brings in England, people are inclined to say: " You are copying the English"—a higher proportion of Danish national production is involved in industry than is the case in this country. In spite of their success as an agricultural country, a higher proportion of their national income is concerned with industry and these raw industries almost exclusively are industries of which the raw material is imported. I mention that merely to show that the sine qua non of success in industrial production is not necessarily the fact that you have materials at hand in your own soil. You can import them; you can process them; and you can do it successfully and efficiently, and can produce a good article for home or foreign use. I am quite willing to admit that, if you have the homeproduced raw material, you may give a higher level of employment, and you are more likely to be efficient; but I have heard Deputies of Fine Gael disagree on that one subject alone, without taking into account the other five Parties. There is every element there —from people who are almost free trade to those willing to give a very good chance to would-be industrial promoters in this country guided, as always, by the idea that eventually they are able to show a success by charging a price for their goods which compares with the English price or prices of similar goods in the same currency area or, alternatively, are able to export a good proportion of their produce—either or both.
Take social services. We would like to hear a more consistent approach to social services. We hear members of Fine Gael deploring social services. They would like to see no social services in this country.
Comment on this
They believe that, if you can have all the wage levels and profit levels organised in some way, there will be no necessity for social services, that all the private individuals in the community, from the poorest to the richest, would save sufficient to provide themselves with retirement benefit, with widows' and orphans' pensions, with the means of paying sickness benefit, even if it be serious and unexpected, and the payment of the costs in respect of maternity. You have these gentlemen in Fine Gael, and you have others who take a different point of view, who believe that social services should be less or more, according to the state of the community.
You have the same thing in regard to their attitude towards our relations with the Commonwealth. A certain Deputy in Fine Gael before the election said it would be well to repeal the External Relations Act. You have others in Fine Gael who suggest that they would like to be closer to the Commonwealth, but who are not prepared to amend the Constitution or the External Relations Act. Equally, there are varying views, even in Fine Gael alone, with regard to agricultural policy. You have certain Deputies who, from platforms during the election, tempted the votes of the larger farmers by suggesting that it was time that compulsory tillage went, implied that tillage was not particularly good in itself, and you have others who advocate no compulsory tillage but who admit that for the great majority of the land of this country, tillage is best for both grass and crops.
I leave Fine Gael then and come to the Labour Party. We have the Labour Party's programme in regard to social services. I do not want to exaggerate, but in my constituency the Labour Party programme for social services, while a little vague, certainly did not work out at less than £50,000,000 per year more on the Budget. The Labour Party equally in my constituency advocated the complete severance of all relations between road workers' wages and agricultural workers' wages. They went far out of their way to deride the work and verdict of the Agricultural Wages Board. They implied from platform after platform that, if agricultural wages were dictated by the Agricultural Wages Board, it was the result of the influence of a conservative and reactionary Minister for Agriculture. They asked, even if the agricultural labourers had to suffer under the Agricultural Wages Board, because the farmers could not afford to pay them more, why in Heaven's name should road workers, even with a 48-hour week as against a 54-hour week, not receive automatically all the wages a county council was prepared to offer them, and they stated freely that that wage, having regard to the fact that they were semi-Government servants, working under a local authority, should be in the region of £4 10s. 0d. to £5 per week.
What do we find? We find a certain Deputy of the Labour Party getting up in this House and speaking of the 55/- a week award of the Agricultural Wages Board, closely followed by the new wage of the road workers, as an act of the new inter-Party Government, when, in fact, that increase was the result of the Agricultural Wages Board's work and was consonant with the increases granted in former years in respect of the increase in the cost of living. Labour Party Deputies will recall the years before the war when the agricultural worker's wage was between 27/- and 30/- per week. That wage has gone up steadily ever since. If I remember rightly, it went up from 44/- to 48/- between 1946 and 1947 and has gone up now from 48/- to 55/-. There is no credit due to the inter-Party Government as a result of the work of the Agricultural Wages Board and it would appear that the present Minister for Local Government has not given any ukase to the local authorities to grant wages entirely detached from the agricultural worker's wages. We see no indication of that. Maybe that will come, but at least we have not heard of it up to now.
When I come to the new Party, I find it hard to restrain my language, but I have always done so in this House and will continue to do so. Excuses were made from a platform in Westmeath last Sunday in regard to the wild promises which were made by the new Party in the election and which bear some relation to the Budget. Excuses were made that they were a new Party like ours when we came into office in 1932. Even if that be granted for the sake of argument, 15 years have elapsed, during which all the people of this country are supposed to have received some democratic and Parliamentary education, and if one takes a figure of 100 as the degree of exaggeration excusable in a new Party coming into office for the first time, one would at least take half off for a new Party coming into office in 1947, or are we to have a sort of flippant attitude towards democracy in general, that the more extravagant you make the promises, the better; that it does not matter how many years of experience of selfgovernment we have had, people coming into office for the first time can offer all the bribes they like to the electorate? The fact that 15 years have elapsed between one Party coming into office and the other is supposed to make no difference.
Comment on this
I propose to answer it. I had occasion during the election to read the publicity issued by the Fianna Fáil Party in 1932 and 1933. I am not in the least ashamed of it. We made certain promises which we did not keep——
Comment on this
——and we made a great many promises which we did keep. I am not in the least ashamed of the record, but I will accept the judgment of any international arbitrator on a comparison between the promises made by Fianna Fáil in 1932 and the promises made by the new Party in 1948. They have sacrificed everything. They have nothing left of their programme except an emigration commission. They have given up the change in the currency and they have failed to survive the test put to them by Deputy Vivion de Valera when he asked whether, if the £ was to be changed, it was to be greater or less than the Irish £. Their social service programme was worth anything up to £200,000,000 a year. I will say this for the Labour Party: their social service programme was, shall we say, flying the kite a little too high, rather in the manner of Fianna Fáil in 1932. It was a dream but it was just within the bounds of possibility that if one altered the whole social system in the country and brought about a great change in our whole manner of living one might, in bare imagination, just arrive at the official Labour Party's social service programme. But one could not within 1,000 years arrive at the new Party programme. With them the sky is the limit.
Comment on this
You are convinced, then, that there was need for a change?
Comment on this
Take, then, the question of employment. We were told off the platforms that if the new Party came into office everybody would be employed all the year round. We were told that there would be no unemployment.
Comment on this
I was speaking of the new Party. I was telling the House how on every platform in Westmeath and Longford they were talking of a new programme. They were talking of sweeping aside everything that had gone before. They were going to sweep aside the worn-out old men in Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael and all the other Parties. They believed in a new destiny. They believed in finding happiness and prosperity for everyone. O! what a fall is there? We were made to look like vampires sucking the life blood of the body politic and making vast sums out of Party office. We find now that all that is left of the new Party programme is an emigration commission—a body of gentlemen who are going to decide for us the cause of emigration and make remedy therefor.
I do not know that I need say very much more about the other Parties. I could speak of Clann na Talmhan. I could refer to the fantastic claims which some of them made in Longford in regard to drainage. I could speak to them about the difficulties of relating the promises made in regard to arterial drainage to the practical difficulty of finding even one-tenth of the number of surveyors skilled in drainage levels who could bring about a change so that you could drain three or four main rivers in each county in Ireland at once. I could mention the difficulty of finding even one-tenth of the number of dredgers and of the special mechanical equipment required to create under-water explosions in order to break rock in areas where channels have to be deepened while water passes over them, in order to carry out main drainage at the rate, shall we say, of two or three main rivers in a county at once. That was the talk. That was what we heard. That was the promise made by certain speakers in the Clann na Talmhan Party. However, we shall pass that by.
Comment on this
I do not wish to do anything except ask the Government to produce for us one policy out of the 12 as soon as possible for the benefit of the country. If they do that, they will not find that I shall cavil at what they do. They will not find that I shall be unfair, that I shall hit below the belt or that I shall criticise. I have never done that so long as I have been a member of this House. I am merely asking, for the benefit of the country, that the directives of this Government will result in a single policy as soon as possible for the sake of the country, for the sake of business men, for the sake of industrialists, for the sake of agriculturists and for the sake of those sections of our community who are profoundly interested in policy. I will be fair and say that this cannot be done all at once. I merely ask for a reply some time within the next three or four months.
Comment on this
I would like to say something more on this question of industrialisation. I would like to emphasise that industrialisation is a most difficult matter for an inter-Party Government. There are always the imponderables. I think some of the Fine Gael speakers referred to this question. A group of promoters puts up a proposition for a particular industry. The industry, perhaps, uses half imported materials and half native materials. The promoters will say we can produce this article about 10 per cent. above the cost of the British article or 10 per cent. below it. You then put the question to them as to whether they have sufficient skilled labour here. The answer is "No, we will have to get key-men from X country to teach the workers here." The next question is: "How long will you need a high tariff?" The answer is: "We probably shall need 100 per cent. to begin with because of competition which may take place and because of the effort that may be made by importers in their own right to keep us out of the market?""Can you give any guarantee as to how long you will want the 100 per cent. tariff?" These people, being ordinary human beings, will probably indulge in a bit of bluff. No one can blame them for that. No group of promoters is likely to be conservative in its estimate. They will say what seems to them to be the right thing. That is inherent in all ordinary business transactions. The point is that risks have to be taken. It would be much better for this Government to inform us fully within the next three or four months as to what their particular bias is. If their bias is restrictive in relation to new industries this will help prospective importers and materials will flow in freely. If the Government has a bias towards home production and they so inform us, those who are prepared to take risks will be encouraged.
There is one factor in all estimates of new industrial production. It is an imponderable factor and it cannot be measured on paper. If you attempt to calculate this imponderable factor, you will have commissions lasting ten years —as they frequently lasted under the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government—in which all the evidence says, "Take care; go slow; do not put on a tariff." Everybody in this House knows what I mean. I am not accusing this Government of not being prepared. I am giving them an example of the necessity for giving a very clear directive to the people of this country for the next few years. In that connection some of the acts of the new Government have given rise to disquiet. I do not want to labour this point because it has already been debated at length by Deputies on our side of the House. When I had a professional position in the industrial world of this country I had occasion to read various reports on mineral development and I quite accept what the former Taoiseach said, with much regret, that he had found that on the whole the geological surveys by the British Government had proved more accurate than he thought and that the optimistic expectation of the Fianna Fáil Government as to mineral development had not been realised. At the same time, I am well aware that a number of new processes in regard to mineralogical development have taken place since the war. There are new and simplified processes of extracting minerals by means of electricity and centrifrugal separation, and so on. Before we take an extremely pessimistic view that, although we have practically every mineral in this country in small lots in the soil, we must abandon all major mineralogical development, we should make at least one final examination using the new processes evolved during the war for extracting metal from low-grade ores.
The psychological effect of the inter-Party Government's action must be considered. The cutting off of £85,000 does not seem to me to be a courageous attitude towards mineralogical development. If it were £150,000 or £250,000 we could have a good argument about it. If they had reduced the sum from £85,000 to £50,000 we might have felt —well, perhaps, that is right. But the complete elimination of £85,000, in view of the fact that there are new processes for extracting minerals, does not encourage industrial promoters, does not encourage people to risk money in development generally. It is a psychological factor rather than a financial factor. It just does not look very well—that is my objection.
The same thing is true of air development—I will not go into that—and of wireless development. I made certain investigations since this Budget was introduced. I understand that most of the smaller countries in the northern part of Europe have short-wave stations, and Ireland seems to be the only one that has not a short-wave station. I know that the programmes of a great many short-wave stations are interrupted. I went to the house of a friend of mine who has a very powerful wireless set and, even with such a set, there is interruption and overlapping. Even in the case of countries that have an official short-wave length, regarded as useful to them and incapable of being interrupted by other countries, there is a certain amount of interference. If one listens on a modern wireless set, even to countries having an official short-wave, there will be interruptions. Notwithstanding all that, I wonder why we did not take the risk.
There are interruptions in the case of the B.B.C. Third Programme. Everyone knows that the B.B.C. Third Programme is constantly being interrupted by a Russian controlled station at Riga. If one travels through the country from Dublin one finds people with sets going back to 1937 and on some of these sets the B.B.C. Third Programme can be heard, whereas some people with absolutely new wireless sets cannot hear that programme at all.
I do not accept, without further technical explanation, the statement that we would not be able to hear on whatever wave-length were adopted. I can say this much, that, having travelled abroad for a few weeks since the end of the war, I found two things. The previous Government did a great deal to establish our position, to put this country on the map, to make us known as a separate nation. In spite of all the work the last Government did, there are a great many people who have not heard of our Irish music or plays or about Partition; they do not appear to know much about Irish life, about anything Irish at all; they appear to consider us a sort of English colony.
In spite of all the work that has been done in making Ireland known to the world at large, there is still a great deal more to be done. Many people have an entirely false conception of our country, of how we live, and of our cultural standards. They think that our economic life is very much lower than it really is. I am prepared to gamble on the wave-length. I think it was a mistake not to proceed with the short-wave station; I do not think psychologically it is a good thing at all.
Coming to some other aspects of policy, I should like to ask the Minister some questions with regard to the road restoration programme. The former Minister for Local Government asked a question the nature of which was, "will the restoration programme arranged by the previous Government continue, whereby in addition to the receipts from the Road Fund, there will be added to that £1,000,000 in order to continue the high level of expenditure by county authorities for the restoration of our roads?" The question was asked, from what source would the extra £1,000,000 eventuate? The previous Government had agreed that the extra £1,000,000 would not be borrowed from the Road Fund, but would be a charge on the Transition Development Fund; in other words, that the future work of improving the roads would not be impeded and the expenditure would not be reduced through borrowing the extra £1,000,000 to continue the road restoration programme. The reply of the Minister was ambiguous.
I should like to ask him where the extra £1,000,000 is to come from. We decided to give extra grants for road restoration on main and county roads. We gave restoration grants for county roads that had never been given before. We gave these grants because we found that the roads had deteriorated during the war, owing to labour and supply difficulties. Owing to the appalling season in 1947, owing to turf work, owing to the continued scarcity of tar and modern road machinery, in spite of those enormous grants and the excellent work done in most cases by road authorities, the average percentage of restoration effected on the existing skin of the main and county roads was only 30 per cent., as reported to us by the county surveyors in January of this year. In other words, another 70 per cent. needs to be completed before the Government can go on with the programme of modern road improvement, the distinction being between covering the skin on existing roads and widening and improving the roads generally.
If borrowing takes place from the Road Fund for the purpose of expending this extra £1,000,000 the rate of road improvement will be less when the work of restoration is completed. The difficulty the Government faces—it is the difficulty we would have to face if we had been in office—is that the cost of road work has gone up by 50 or 60 per cent., while the taxation of motor vehicles has increased by a very much smaller percentage. I suggest that it will not help if the Road Fund is used as security for the extra £1,000,000. What is the Minister's attitude towards that problem?
I should like to know from the Minister whether he can throw further light on the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the Government might have to restrict the importation of luxuries, even those paid for in sterling. The Minister for Industry and Commerce repeated to some degree statements by the ex-Tánaiste relating to our adverse balance of trade and the fact that part of the payment was secured from tourists and there were large importations of capital equipment valuable to the country, but there were large quantities of goods bought for sterling which were not necessary. That causes disquiet in the minds of business people. What is the Minister's attitude now towards sterling importations, and I should like to know whether he can give any idea of the trend in the future.
With regard to the production of turf, I realise that the Government is faced with great difficulty; I realise that the cessation of supplies of hand-won turf to Dublin is bound to create temporary unemployment and I do not think that it is unfair to the Government to suggest that they could offset the difficulty created thereby. I represent a turf area and I am well aware that the private production of turf, added to the production by the county councils, meant a very large matter to the people concerned, and I know that with the non-importation of hand-won turf into Dublin you have got a firstclass problem. An arrangement had been made by the last Government with regard to the programme of machine-won turf on the larger bogs— not the small machines on the smaller bogs—to double the existing programme of Bord na Móna for machine production as it existed in, I think, December, 1947, and to go ahead with more development and to break new bogs for production with big machines for electrical and industrial uses, and I should like to ask the Minister for Finance whether it is a fact that that doubling of the programme has been abandoned by this Government. That bears no relationship to the difficulty of marketing hand-won turf in Dublin, but is a matter of the Government's long-term turf policy. I understand that the doubling of the programme has been cancelled. If so, that will present great disadvantages to small farmers and agricultural labourers.
I should like to ask the Minister for Finance whether he has considered, at least as a temporary measure—and a very unpopular measure it would be— to exclude the use of coal for domestic purposes in the turf areas. I should like to ask him whether the Government has ever considered that as a temporary policy—either complete exclusion of coal or partial exclusion. I am aware that a great many people in the turf areas prefer coal because of its obvious advantages from the point of view of purely domestic convenience. They may argue that one can use the waste, one can store it in small quantities, one does not have to have storage for it, one can leave it in the wet and one can leave it in an open place with no covering on it. All these matters are of interest to the housewife; they are all important and they all count, but I should like to know whether this measure has been considered as a temporary policy, if unemployment continues.
I cannot see that the grants for drainage will effect a sufficient increase of employment to offset the decrease resulting from the cessation of the hand-won turf programme. I realise that this is a difficult matter for the Government but I would simply like to hear the Minister's views upon it. When the Fianna Fáil Government was in office we were belaboured from pillar to post with regard to a national drainage plan and I should like to hear from the Minister for Finance whether he has been able to decide some of the problems which affected us when we were in office with regard to the temporary cleaning of rivers which are not under the control of county councils. This may seem to be hitting below the belt but in view of the way that we were criticised when we were in charge of drainage I think that it is only fair.
There is a certain river in South Roscommon, in the district which I used to represent before the change in the constituencies, called the Cross River. It winds an indeterminate way through South Roscommon and it is not likely to come under any drainage scheme for many years. An argument has been put up by the riparian owners that if there could even be a temporary cleaning done on the river, if you could just blow up the trees, dig up the sand banks without the use of dredgers or without going below the normal level of the river, and if you could cut the reeds, it could then flow into the Shannon. Even if the tenants were willing to undertake the work with the aid of a contribution—which they were—the Board of Works considered that it would be impossible to effect the temporary cleaning of rivers not under the control of county councils and that a drainage scheme even under the guidance of angels would take four years. I should like to hear whether this Government, which was elected by what you might call drainage maniacs, would consider that the engineers of the Board of Works might revise their decision and take the risk of trying an experiment on a river, without surveyors, by just digging out the banks, cutting the reeds, and blowing up the trees by means of a contribution either from the county council or from the road improvements scheme. I see Deputy Donnellan smiling over there. I know that he is finding the expert advice from men who are not merely theorists difficult to assess, advice from men who have not just read books and studied papers, but who are practical engineers.
I do not want to keep the House any longer except to close by referring to one particular aspect of Government policy with regard to the social services programme. I have already indicated that we in the Fianna Fáil Government increased the social services from £4,000,000 to £13,000,000. I have noted that the present Government's policy included an increase of old age pensions from 15/- to 17/- per week in the case of persons who are in receipt of the full pension having been regarded by the local authority as being in necessitous circumstances. It is a desirable thing and it is welcome, although it is not as large as was indicated. People who are not extremely necessitous cases, who used to receive 12/6, have also had their pensions increased to 15/-. All that is very desirable, but I have noted also that workers have got to pay some few pence per week for the medical benefits available to them under the national health insurance scheme. There is no longer a contribution of £450,000 to the widows' and orphans' fund. According to an actuarial examination made of the widows' and orphans' fund, the sum was considered necessary in order to keep the fund in pensions.
Comment on this
A contribution of £400,000 for ten years will be sufficient. Because you were good enough to pay £450,000 for two years, that covered four years' payment.
Comment on this
The Minister does not know what I am going to say. The contribution is no longer being paid; an extra sum is being paid by workers in regard to the national health insurance scheme and there has been an increase in the old age pensions. On the face of it that does not look very good for the people in the inter-Party Government who had faith in a colossal social security scheme. It does not look a very good augury for the people in the National Labour Party who had such faith in Dr. Dignan's proposals; it does not look well for the Labour Party who had faith in Dr. Dignan's proposals and in their own, nor does it look well for the new Party. If you could have a social security scheme of that kind it would cost £28,000,000, including the present value of the social services; an inevitable increase in the workers' contributions; an increase in the State contributions and an increase in the employers' contributions. It does not look to me to be a very good augury in issuing the expenditure of the Budget to increase old age pensions which are at the moment a matter of national assistance, and to take away from the widows' and orphans' fund £450,000 a year although the fund will need all the money it can get from the State, if you are ever going to have social security schemes put into operation. You tax employees for the benefits they will receive under the national health insurance system, when you can say that whatever employees may have to pay under a new national health insurance system, the State will at least have to begin by paying the existing medical service contributions. In other words, if you have a new social security plan that is going to cost so many millions and the State, in any event, from the taxpayers' pocket has to find £3,000,000 extra, they might as well begin by leaving the national health insurance fund where it is and pay for these extra benefits; they might as well leave the £450,000 to the widows' and orphans' pension fund, where it is, because it will need that money.
Comment on this
In the light of the social services plan of the new Party, I cannot see any good augury when I look at the plan for social services in this Budget, but it may be that it is only a matter of immediate juggling with figures in order to overcome what they regard as a difficult situation and that later on we may see some ideal social services plan. We know it will never reach the levels proposed by the new Party or by the Labour Party. It may, perhaps, be a modification of the plan which was being prepared by Fianna Fáil but which was not yet completed at the time of the general election.
In conclusion, I would simply like to say that the country is waiting anxiously for a final and definite policy, a policy that is definite in regard to matters of vital importance such as tariffs, agricultural production, social services, a policy which is not going to be pulled from the right to the left as years go by, so that people will not feel that if the policy is based on one definite system it is likely to be accentuated in another direction through the influence of another Party. If this new Government can achieve that position, they will earn the commendation of every person in the State, if they get over the difficulty, as I have said, of producing one policy out of 12.
Comment on this
I do not intend to go into the technical points, pro or con, of this Budget. Fundamentally, it is a bad Budget, because it gives no incentive whatsoever to the agricultural community or to the industrial community. The people who now compose the Government remind me of the story of the lady and gentleman who got married. For the purpose of the story we will call the lady "Maggie" and the gentleman "Pat". When they had left the church, Pat tapped Maggie gently on the shoulder and said: "At last, Maggie, we are one". Maggie turned to him and said: "Yes, Pat, and I am the one". It is easy to see that a marriage has taken place between Fine Gael and the other small Parties, and it is easy to see, also, that Fine Gael is the one, that Fine Gael is directing operations. It used to be said in this House, particularly during a Budget debate, that it was very easy to see the dead hand of the Department of Finance. To-day it is very easy to see the dead hand of Fine Gael come back to life. Whether or not that is a good thing for this country remains to be seen. In my opinion, it is a very bad thing.
The people expected to get in this Budget some incentive with regard to expenditure that would allow of the development of agriculture and industry. Such an incentive is absent from this Budget. Any Government that goes out to save in these times, when development is necessary, when everybody and everything is crying out for greater development, will not remain very long the Government.
Comment on this
Unlike the former speaker, I think this is an admirable Budget. As one of the members of the Party that helped in the formation of this inter-Party Government, while retaining their individuality and independence, I am proud of the Budget and will not offer any apology to any man, inside or outside the House, with regard to it. As a matter of fact, I have never been asked to offer an apology for it and, going through the country, north, south, east and west, I find that the Budget on the whole is a popular Budget.
Great things may be expected from the present Government, but we must all remember that they have been only a few weeks in office. When we have spent 16 years on this side of the House I do not think we will have to offer any apology to any section of our people. Our intentions are good; our intentions are sincere; our intentions are honest. I have been absolutely disgusted, and I presume many Deputies have been disgusted, at the length of this debate. Instead of the harangue that has continued here for the last ten or 12 days, we would prefer to have had helpful co-operation from the other side. If we got that co-operation the country as a whole would benefit.
Comment on this
I have not heard any criticism from the opposite side that convinced me that there is anything radically wrong with the Budget. Great stress has been laid on turf production. My colleague, Deputy O'Rourke, referred to turf production in County Roscommon and gave some illuminating figures, which I wish to correct. I do not mean to say that Deputy O'Rourke deliberately gave an incorrect or wrong figure but, through an oversight or through some miscalculation of the amount spent in Roscommon, Deputy O'Rourke made a mistake. He said here on last Friday, I think it was, that last year the amount paid in wages by the county council for hand-won turf in County Roscommon was £74,000. I wish to correct that statement. The gross amount paid in connection with hand-won turf in County Roscommon was £74,000. He is absolutely correct. When he says "in wages", he is absolutely incorrect. The amount spent, as he said, was £74,000, but I want to correct him on the point of wages. The amount of wages paid in connection with the hand-won turf scheme in County Roscommon was £48,000. The balance, which amounted to £26,000, was diverted to haulage and other transport costs.
Comment on this
No. I do not agree at all. I do not agree that a man with a lorry hauling turf from the bog can be considered to be a labouring man. I do not agree that the transport of turf has a very high labour content and the Deputies should agree with me in that. The amount actually spent in wages was £48,000, and that is correct. Now, to compensate for that, we in County Roscommon this year have made provision for an additional £48,000 to be spent on roads, which counter-balances the loss on turf. We are told here that there is unemployment all over the country—I am interested only in one county, Roscommon—and that owing to the discontinuance of the hand-won turf scheme unemployment is bad in Roscommon. I want to contradict that flatly.
At the peak period last year for hand-won turf production, we had engaged in Roscommon 827 men and four women on turf and on the roads we had 293 men, making a total of 1,120 men and four women. To-day, in 1948, we have made provision for and have actually employed at the present time 1,000 men on roads, we have 90 on drainage and 200 on Bord na Móna, making a total of 1,290 or 170 more than last year.
Comment on this
We have made arrangements in Roscommon that our county institutions, the county home and the county hospital in Boyle, will use a certain amount of hand-won turf amounting to several thousand cwts. I hope the people in Dublin are catering for hand-won turf schemes in Dublin as well as we are in Roscommon.
The election promises have been brought very much into the limelight during this debate. I was rather interested in what Deputy Allen said here the other night. He accused our present Minister for Defence, Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, of speaking to some members of the licensed trade here in connection with the duties imposed by the recent Supplementary Budget and he preferred a very serious charge against him—almost a charge of bribery. He said it was a thing that should not have been done, that it was indiscreet, in bad taste, corrupt and all the rest. I do not see anything wrong in what he did. I criticised the Supplementary Budget during the recent election campaign, and rightly so, and I have no apologies to offer for doing so. I consider that the duties imposed on beer, tobacco, cigarettes and entertainment tax were unjust and unfair; and from the public platform and in speaking privately to members of my constituency, I told them that—not as a means of catching votes but, as I honestly believed, the taxes were unjust.
Like Deputy Dr. O'Higgins I told them that if returned I would do my utmost to have those taxes removed. I see nothing wrong in that. It was a serious charge to make that it was improper for Deputy Dr. O'Higgins to meet certain members of the licensed trade in Dublin and tell them that if returned to power or if a member of the Government he would do his utmost to have these taxes removed. He told them that and carried out his promise to the last letter of the law. The taxes in the Supplementary Budget were unjust and wrong and hit certain sections of the community which we call the poor people. The man who drinks a pint of beer or a half of whiskey, or smokes a cigarette, cannot be accused of enjoying luxuries in this world, as these nowadays are necessaries. Particularly in Dublin, the man who works at the docks may have a sandwich for his lunch in the middle of the day, and a pint of porter is something to which he is entitled. It is most unfair that this section of the community should have been made pay in the Supplementary Budget and I am glad the day has come when those taxes have been removed from the poor people.
Who can grouse over the increase in old-age pensions? Can anyone in the Party opposite grouse? Is it not a step in the right direction? Has not the Government done the right thing in giving an increase in the starvation rate of pensions? Some of those who have tears in their eyes over there and have criticised us went into the Division Lobbies here last October and voted against a Labour motion to increase old-age pensions. Are they sincere or honest when they say they are in sympathy with the old-age pensioners and the widows and orphans? I do not think they are a bit sincere. We went out on platforms and told the people we would see that these pensions were increased. Have we not kept our promises? We have, and we intend to keep our other promises.
I was disappointed that the Deputies on the far side were angry and vicious in their vituperations in the last nine or ten days. I would ask them to throw in their lot with us, as good Irishmen, to come and assist us. We are going to shoulder the burden of running this country through a crisis and we hope to succeed. We ask the co-operation of those on the other side. With that co-operation, we can make this country a better country than it is. While there is obstruction, such as we have had this week, harsh criticism, giving no credit for things that deserve credit, trying to pick holes in the things we have done, making mountains out of molehills, we cannot succeed. I would appeal to all the Deputies to co-operate with us in the future and not delay progress by a policy of obstruction which, I regret to say, has been carried on for many years past; and I hope that the future will bring us a change for the better.
Comment on this
After all that has been said in this lengthy debate, it is not possible for me to reply in detail to everything. I would like to deal with some of the points made by way of criticism of the financial proposals and then go on to more general matters of social policy which are to some extent affected by this Budget. To start with, we have had some comments, made rather lightheartedly if not completely hypocritically, by Deputy Childers. Deputy Childers, at this stage of our history, has the brazenness to talk about promises, to say that the promises made by the inter-Party Government, or members of it, are not capable of fulfilment. He criticised the people whom he alleges to have spoken in that way for being either rash in judgment or being deliberately misleading in their appeal to the public. I do not want to go back too far, but still fresh in the memories of the people since 1932 is the fact that we were not merely promised full employment in this country but such full employment that the emigrants were to be called back. I do not need to rub that in, other than to mention it. All that happened in the end was that the Government saw emigration increasing. It had been stopped by 1931—more people came back in 1931 than those who left. That was the beginning. That was the conclusion of a very successful effort under a native Government to stop the evil tradition that had been started with the Famine, but the evil tradition of the Famine was restarted by Fianna Fáil. The two evil things that hit this country that gave rise to emigration were, first of all, the Famine in 1847 and, secondly, the advent of Fianna Fáil to power in 1932.
Comment on this
I said that more people came back in 1931 than went out —there was a surplus immigration.
Comment on this
It was very nearly a miracle but the Deputy's Party saw to it that the miracle did not last long. Emigration started again immediately in Fianna Fáil's time and went on developing and growing apace. Deputy Childers, amongst others from the Fianna Fáil Benches, says that the end of all the promises made about emigration by this Government is reduced to a commission on emigration. Next week I suppose we will read in the Irish Press that this is another of the Fianna Fáil plans that we are carrying out. I am sure the back-benchers do not know it, but the ex-Ministers do—that about Christmas time, in the month of December, 1947, the best proposal that the Minister for Social Services had for his Government was the institution of a commission on emigration. It was entered on the agenda for the Government on the 15th December last year and was removed from the agenda the next day. One of the paragraphs in the memorandum which the Minister supplied to the Government was to the effect that the end of the war had come and that the British control of emigration from here into England was likely to lapse. His proposal, facing that particular dangerous set of circumstances, was that this Government should abandon all restrictions on emigration. Therefore, the proposal in December, 1947, of the previous Government was: abandon whatever restrictions in the way of permits or visas there may be on the people who flock to England; throw the doors wide open—and have a commission after the event to inquire into what has been done. That is a very different proposal to calling the emigrants home in order to fill all the vacant posts. That is the result of Fianna Fáil policy between 1932 and 1947.
Deputy Childers is very anxious to know whether we can make one policy out of 12. I do not know whether we can be successful in doing that—I do not know whether there are 12 policies to be moulded into one. I did find two cuttings amongst the library of cuttings which I have with regard to Fianna Fáil. I considered them of interest as an indication of the identity of policy that everybody who ever went into the Fianna Fáil ranks is supposed to have had from the day he entered that Party. Deputy Boland, then Minister for Justice, speaking on the 10th November, 1947, made a speech to such an effect that the heading it got in the Irish Independent was “Only Austerity Ahead, Mr. Boland says.” Three months later Deputy Lemass, dealing with the message of Fianna Fáil, spoke in such terms that the Irish Press gave him the heading “No Need for Austerity.” It is pretty difficult to reconcile the headings “Only Austerity Ahead” and “No Need for Austerity” that two members of a completely unified Party had. I wonder if it is possible at this stage to get rid of that particular type of nonsense which has been so much promulgated throughout the country. We are asked to believe that everybody who joined the Fianna Fáil Party—without any coercion, without any request made to him that he should sign on the dotted line— just immediately and naturally adopted the view on everything that every one of his colleagues in the Party held; that that is what they call a unified Party and that there is, therefore, no necessity at any time to worry or argue about a policy because the members of the Party always hold the same view on everything. If that is not so then I assume Fianna Fáil will be able to work out, as we have, a series of compromises. I always understood that Party politics did work on compromises, and that men having different views came together and hammered out a policy. We will probably have to do so openly here in the Dáil. I do not think that is an unwise procedure. When there are so many different views on different matters, I do not think there is anything undesirable about it. I think it is preferable to getting behind closed doors and getting a Party to adopt a special line and later, when that line is brought into public debate, presenting it as representing the complete view on any particular subject of all the members of the Party. I agree that the members who support the present Government and even some of the members who form it have put emphasis on different points of policy. I have found nothing irreconcilable in their views and I do not think that we will find anything irreconcilable in them until we decide that the time has come to have a general election, say, when the full term has been run.
Deputy Childers feels that the last Government put Ireland on the map. He immediately countered that by saying that he met quite a number of people during his tour on the Continent who had never heard of Partition. It was an amazing preamble to an argument about the necessity for a short-wave station that the last Government had put Ireland on the map. If they have done so, they have done so without the short-wave station. I do not know what conclusion Deputy Childers was hoping to drive us to except that, as something had been thought of by the Fianna Fáil Government—whether practical or not—then anybody who succeeded Fianna Fáil as a Government must immediately adopt all the schemes Fianna Fáil had thought of. I was asked particularly about the turf situation and whether this Government had thought of excluding coal from domestic use in certain areas in this country. I had hoped Deputy Childers would go on to tell us that the last Government had considered that and would tell us what their answer to it was. I was wondering how exactly he would answer that because my complaint is that, in regard to the whole turf situation, they made a bad situation worse by sending emissaries all round the globe to see if they could not get more coal and they succeeded in chartering over 40 liberty ships from America to bring American coal in. Having done all that, Deputy Childers, one who was responsible for that plan, asks—while we have all that coal—for the exclusion of coal from domestic use in certain areas in the country.
Comment on this
In respect of coal? Certainly not. Deputy Lemass on the 18th February could tell us that there was a ten years' supply of firewood in the Park. We have on hands a very large stock of American coal. At the present rate of disbursement there will be large stocks on hand next winter. That was the situation which Deputy Lemass, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, brought about. In those circumstances one thing was inevitable, namely, that turf production had to fall.
Comment on this
You are dealing with what was done as an absolute necessity. It was the most commendable measure during the emergency.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the result of what was done. I am not querying the motive. I am merely dealing with the result of it.
Comment on this
They have brought in so much American coal that there would be large stocks on hands by winter, ten years' supply of firewood, and enough turf to last to the winter of 1949. The men who brought that situation about now want to know if we will refuse coal for domestic use to certain areas in the country in order to ensure that more turf than is required will be cut.
Comment on this
If the Minister is quite sure that we are facing peace then there may be something in his argument but we were not sure of that until lately, if we are sure of it now.
Comment on this
I will come back to this when dealing with turf. I am asked about the situation which has been caused in regard to employment through the discontinuance of turf production on a major scale. The discontinuance of the production of turf on a major scale was accepted by the previous Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
He set all the plans going which would stop turf production and leave no real necessity for it. Now he complains that more turf is not being cut.
Deputy S. Brady decided that he would run the argument that a lot of other Deputies have adopted in the House, namely, that various members of the groups that form the Government have made various promises in regard to various things. I do not remember any time limit being specified. I do not remember that all these things were to be done by the month of May of this year. If anybody had any idea that that was what was promised I want to disabuse them of that view. Plans that we have to carry out will require many years, and if anybody thinks of using as an argument the fact that some promise has not, so far, been carried out, I say to him that that argument would gain in strength as the months go by. It is not an argument now, in the month of May, considering that this Government came into power only in the middle of February.
I was associated with an earlier Government in the development of a certain river and I learned from certain education I got about the harnessing of a couple of great rivers to clean the Augean stables; and I would require several rivers and all the energy that would be developed from the harnessing of several rivers to get rid of any part of the mess that has been left to us to clear up. It will take some time to do it. I do not pretend that it will be within the range of the present Government to do it easily or to do it speedily. It can be done with speed if we are inhuman about the results for individuals. It can be done very slowly and very easily by paying attention to the human personnel in the background. But as to the attempt here to make debating points with regard to certain things that were said and pretending to believe that these were promised for immediate performance—they were not. We have, however, given already a very good earnest of what we are at and we ask the people to take these things as an earnest of particular plans to which we have put our hands and from which we will not withdraw.
Comment on this
There was a promise of an immediate drop in the cost of living —a 35 per cent. drop.
Comment on this
Possibly she does not. Is it possible that in this House a man should be found so unreasoning as not to believe that a reduction of taxation to the extent of £6,000,000 does not affect the cost of living, even on smokes and liquor? Is it believed that that does not affect the cost of living?
Comment on this
If the Deputy is talking about a cost-of-living figure, that is one thing. I am talking about the cost of living. I suggest that the cost of living has been very definitely reduced from what we found it and very definitely reduced from the high point to which it must necessarily have been driven if our opponents across the House had been left as a Government to handle this Budget.
Deputy Killilea complained amongst other things of the means test and our attitude with regard to old age pensions. There is a great deal of complaint of all sorts that we only provided £600,000. It is only £600,000. It is for a bit of the year. Deputies who feel that they have any bit of propaganda value in stressing that there is only £600,000 provided, should make the most of it while the going is good, because it will not be long before they realise that the bill for the improvement of old age pensions which we stand behind will certainly not be less than £2,000,000 and may easily go to £2,500,000. Deputies who are complaining now about £600,000 only being provided this year must remember their own activities in a debate and a vote on a motion on the 22nd October last year. It was not an outrageous motion. It asked that the basis upon which income should be assessed for the purpose of the means test in the case of persons entitled to pensions should be revised. In reply, as reported in column 882 of the Official Report for the 22nd October, Deputy Dr. Ryan, who was then in charge of the Ministry which had to deal with this matter, said:—
"To carry out the terms of this motion, a very moderate motion, would, so far as I can calculate—it is difficult to calculate—involve a sum of between £500,000 and £750,000."
The whole scheme which was proposed was going to cost £500,000 or £750,000 in the year. All those Deputies opposite who were members of the last Dáil went definitely into the Lobby to vote against that proposal—every man jack of them. Even for £500,000 for the whole of the year the Deputies were coerced into the Division Lobby against it. Now they complain because in these proposals of mine, which are only for a very limited part of the year, £600,000 will be given between modifications of the means test and certain additions to old age and widows' and orphans' pensions. They complain because it is only £600,000 for a part of the year. I do not suppose Deputies have really any complaint to make against that. I suppose they are really sitting back and wondering how it will be done. If the truth were known, I suppose they are gathering in their little clubs to prepare arguments about the fierce impact this will have on the cost of living, because Deputies will be saying that it will probably mean increased taxation and something that the country cannot afford. Deputy de Valera, when Taoiseach, put himself on record as saying that no improvement in social services was possible in this country until production increased. We have had complaint after complaint. Deputy Butler is burning with a complaint at this moment about the meanness of the £600,000.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Minister. I would just remind him that we are talking about promises. It is for the reasons that he gave just now that we did not make promises during the election. Your colleagues here promised as high as £2 per week to old age pensioners.
Comment on this
I thought I could get Deputy Butler to speak, because he said "no" on the 22nd October, 1947, to the plan to give £500,000 in the whole year. That was too high for Deputy Butler to tolerate.
Comment on this
£600,000 in part of the financial year. If the Deputy waits until the end of the year or the beginning of next year, he will see the full plan and, as I say, it will not be less than £2,000,000, and it will be most likely in the neighbourhood of £2,500,000. If the Deputy thinks that we are not carrying out our promises, I think we are at least making improvements on what the Deputy wanted on the 22nd October last year.
Comment on this
No one will congratulate you more heartily than I will if you do that and reduce taxation at the same time.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen was very angry about our having reduced the taxes on beer, stout and tobacco. In that context, he had decided to use the phrase that we had sold out to the publicans. He spoke of the bags of gold which were jingling around us as we went around our constituencies, all derived from the publicans.
If Deputy Allen wants to discuss that, he ought to remember the general election financial committee circular which Fianna Fáil published, this circular sent round by 16 industrialists, dealing with the generosity and goodness of those industrialists who helped them to obtain the substantial funds necessary for a vigorous and successful election campaign. There was a note at the end: "The subscription will be treated in confidence if you so desire." I wonder were the bags of gold which came from that group heavier than those which the publicans are supposed to have given to the groups who comprise this inter-Party Government. One of the very definite things that weighed against Fianna Fáil in the last election was that very obvious revelation to the country of the money subscribed by these moneyed people and their support. I suppose nothing impressed the ordinary people down the country more than that, the people, say, who knew what Deputy Butler had done on the 22nd October last in connection with old age pensions. When they saw that this group of people were asking for support for a vigorous election campaign they made the ordinary calculation and that was, that the people who had made well out of this Government during the last 15 or 16 years were out in the open.
These circulars, of course, were sent out for every election prior to 1948, but I think this was the first time a circular was published openly. Whether or not they thought that it would be announced and that it was better to publish it openly, I know that it had a terrific effect on the countryside. That indicated where the money bags were. It meant that people made their own calculations and said that the people who wrote that circular had got good consideration for writing it. That affected a considerable number of people and helped us to get back again into the good graces of the people who did not feel that they had got fair treatment from the people whom these folk represented during 15 or 16 years.
There has been a great deal of lamentation in the house over what are called allegations of corruption. I have spoken in the House before on what I called the corruption of Fianna Fáil administration. I want to put myself on record as still saying that, but I must explain what I mean. I said that, as far as I knew, no person belonging to the Party with which I am associated said that there was any personal corruption alleged against any member of that Government with the exception of the matter that was tried before a tribunal which led to the disappearance of a Parliamentary Secretary from that office. Outside that, any allegations that I have heard made were to the effect that Fianna Fáil had built up over years a very definite machine by corrupt administration. I asserted that they had done that, and they know they did it.
Comment on this
I understand, since I became a member of the Government again, that the situation that developed in Government buildings was that a particular member of the Government was always given charge of appointments. I think he had got to be known as the patronage secretary attached to the Government. The first person who was attached to the post ordinarily was the Parliamentary Secretary to the Department of Industry and Commerce, and the reason why he was so attached to that post rather than anybody else was that he was a person who was in close touch with, say, people like the branch managers of employment exchanges and with all the small people who can give out work to gangers on roads.
Comment on this
That is a terrible charge to make against the branch managers of the exchanges. The Minister did make the claim of privilege when collared.
Comment on this
As I say, Deputies will remember that in 1943 Deputy Tadhg Murphy, now Minister for Local Government, brought forward a motion in this House dealing with the appointment of an employment exchange manager and he revealed what was then accepted to be quite all right. I must say that Deputy Moylan did not pretend to deny that this was the ordinary procedure. It was a good revelation of what was happening. The little episode that Deputy Murphy brought out was that the post of employment branch manager at Mallow was vacant, and that a person called Gilligan was up for it. Miss Gilligan had apparently some political influence, or thought she had political influence, and she got an approach made to the Parliamentary Secretary, now Deputy Moylan. Deputy Murphy read the letter which Deputy Moylan sent to this young lady's father on that occasion. The letter was in these terms:
"Dear Mr. Gilligan,—I have your letter and a number of others in relation to Miss Nan Gilligan's application for the position vacant at Mallow. The appointee shall, in the first instance, be certified as competent and suitable for the position by the interview board. I believe Miss Gilligan will fulfil that condition. From the list certified as competent, I shall appoint the person best suited to the position from a political viewpoint."
That was written, and there was no denial that that was the scheme. The qualifications, of course, were light. Deputy Moylan's letter indicated that pretty nearly anybody would qualify, and then "from the list certified as competent, I shall appoint the person best suited to the position from a political viewpoint."
Comment on this
Column 1736 of the Dáil Debates for the 7th April, 1943. That is what I mean by corruption. May I say that poor Miss Gilligan was done down eventually, because Deputy Moylan had to write a letter saying that he had to have regard to the claims of another applicant as being more urgent than hers, and in that connection one knows what "urgent" means—somebody in the neighbourhood with a better political pull? Deputy Murphy raised all that in the debate and there was no denying that that letter had been written. There was no questioning of the construction that Deputy Murphy had put on that before the House.
Comment on this
He had. Deputy Butler is not long enough in Fianna Fáil to know what happened. The disappointed Mr. Gilligan gave the letter to Deputy Murphy. He was well in, as he thought, but then found that he was not—that there was a more urgent claim, and the correspondence was handed over. The letter was paraded and shown to quite a number of people and was not denied. I think that, in the next year, when this matter came before the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis there was a considerable amount of anxiety over this revelation about the spoils system. There was clear evidence that it was in operation. The then Taoiseach made many attempts to explain that Deputy Moylan did not mean what he said when he wrote the letter. The plain meaning was not the one which the then Taoiseach read into it. The then Taoiseach got Deputy Moylan to agree before the Árd Fheis that the plan of Fianna Fáil was that the fruits of Government policy must go to Government supporters. There was the clear statement again of that. That was the best that Deputy Moylan could be brought to.
With all these things on record, am I doing the Party very much injustice when I say that they built up their whole Party system on administrative corruption? I think they did and I assert here now that they did. There is clear evidence of it. It takes some little time, I may tell you, to get people who were put in under such a system just smoked out, but the process is on, and I hope it will be continued. We will get an administration which will be based on merit. In that way we will get efficiency in the various posts that have to be filled and in the various classes of work that have to be done, and will get rid of that. I am sure people may come at me in a year's time or so and say that there is still someone hiding in a post obtained under a corrupt administration. I may have to confess that it is so because all this cannot be done immediately. We are taking a big step forward on that and on other matters, and we hope to get success there, as in other things, too.
As far as this Budget is concerned, the situation I want to present to the Dáil now is that I made a mistake when I said that I was faced with a deficit in the Budget of £8,731,000. I am really faced with a deficit of £10,500,000. I stated that I was faced with an estimated deficit of £8,731,000. In addition there is £600,000 for old age pensioners in some part of the financial year. Further, there is the extra half-ounce in the tea ration at a cost to us of £487,000; that makes £9,818,000. If I have to bear the odium of putting on the 6d. extra on income-tax, there was a failure in the estimated revenue of £600,000. Adding all that together means that the deficit I faced was £10,488,000. I want that sum thought of and pondered over. It is a big sum. In 1932, we were able to run the country on just about double that sum. At that time the country was run on a sum of between £21,000,000 and £22,000,000. In the end, what this country has to suffer through Budget impositions is that a tax has been put on petrol, 6d. on income-tax and that certain things have been done, that have been talked of ad nauseam, to hotels and caterers; the subsidy on margarine and oatmeal has been removed, farmers' butter is now without a certain addition by way of subsidy while there are various devices I adopt in regard to unemployment insurance and national health insurance. I suggest that it is not a bad performance to have bridged a gap of £10,500,000 by two serious taxes, one worth £900,000 and the other worth £670,000—call it £1,500,000 between them—and then by certain devices in regard to farmers' butter, margarine and oatmeal and the various other things that have been spoken of, made up the remainder.
What would have been the situation if Fianna Fáil were still the Government? They would not have made the economies that I have tried to make. They certainly would not have "looted"—that is the delightful word that has been used—the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Fund. They certainly would not have off-shouldered the oatmeal and margarine subsidy on to consumers, and they would not have made any addition to the contributions called for under employment insurance and other schemes. They would not have stopped—it was still running when we came into office—the extra fuel subsidy even though Deputy Lemass said that we had ten years' supply of timber. Timber was still rolling in at the rate of 10,000 tons a week, for which a subsidy of £40,000 was required. It was still running when we came in but we stopped it. Aer Linte would certainly have been started and we would have been facing, I suggest, a loss of not less than £500,000 a year. Deputy Lemass said that we are in a deflationary period and his exhortation was to spend more. We should probably have to spend more and more if Fianna Fáil were in office. He certainly had the attitude that we should budget for a genuine surplus of several millions. If Deputy Lemass had any say in the framing of the Budget it would not have been a gap of £10,000,000 that we should have to bridge; it would have been something in the neighbourhood of £15,000,000. How would he have done it? He would not have done it by enforcing economies because they are taboo to him. He said there were only three types of taxation open—taxation on spirits or liquor, taxation on tobacco and taxation on incomes. These were the only three types that were left open to anybody. So not merely would you have continued the tax on beer and stout and the tax on tobacco, which we remitted, not merely would they have been left on, but they would have been increased.
Deputy Vivion de Valera said that, and there is no answer to him, these taxes would probably have to be heavily increased. Income-tax would also have been increased. Instead of that situation, I have succeeded by various devices in so narrowing the gap that in the end by one substantial tax —the tax on petrol—and by continuing what had been threatened, this extra 6d. income-tax, we are able to get over the difficulty.
There have been many comments as to the manner in which the gap has been closed, a criticism about nearly every part of it. The first item discussed was the question of the reduction in the Army. I copied down some of the spectacular phrases used about that. Deputy Ormonde thought that it was scandalous that this little defenceless island should be left to fall into the hands of the enemy. In fact, he thought that what was being done by the Minister for Defence would operate as an invitation to the British to seize the country. Deputy Lemass thought that we were destroying the efficiency of the force. Deputy Boland warned us that in this critical situation with war threatening, when the Americans were asking for £3,600,000,000 for an army, it was no time to cut down the Army. Deputy Burke said that we are insulting and belittling the Army by what we are doing.
I want to make one simple answer to all this. The last Government had no urge to economy at all; they did not want to save money; they wanted to spend it, but they had failed to spend on the Army last year as much as I am looking for by an economy this year. To do their worst in the way of spending, they could not ladle money out fast enough to exhaust the Vote last year and the Vote was not as big as this year. Out of last year's Vote, they failed to spend £750,000. That did not destroy the efficiency of the Army last year. Apparently it was no invitation to the British to come along and seize this defenceless island. None of these costly things happened, because the money was not spent.
I do not often find myself in agreement with Fianna Fáil but Deputy Killilea said that it was not too much to talk about, that it was very little in the end, and I agree with him, but Deputy Killilea is well out of step with his Party, when he puts that forward as a comment on the Budget. The Minister for Defence, Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, said he had been able to achieve this economy; that it was a solid economy, and that he had achieved it without having to dismiss out of the regular Army any single person and without, as he said, impairing the efficiency of the Army in the slightest degree, without disrupting any Army plans there were for the establishment of the Army on a decent footing. It is surely not too much in a critical year, when every effort should be made to collapse Government expenditure to the smallest possible point, and when a determined effort has to be made to alter the price structure in the country, that the Government should be allowed to secure economy in this financial year by confining expenditure on the Army to the figure that the last spendthrift Government thought was sufficient to spend. They did not think they were breaking down efficiency. I do not believe that I am breaking down efficiency and I think I am entitled to save if the efficiency of the force is not affected. We shall see how it works out with regard to Army efficiency during the year.
The second matter about which a great deal of comment has been made is this question of taking of money from the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Fund. Deputy MacEntee used phrases such as "malversation of public funds", "looting", "pilfering" and every other odious comparison that came into his head and he based every comment he made on an actuarial report which, I think, he dated in the year 1943. My colleague, the Minister for Social Welfare, has written to the paper which gave Deputy MacEntee a certain amount of publicity in this matter and I think that a mere recital of a paragraph from the actuarial report ought to be sufficient to put an end to these bogies which Deputy MacEntee and others are trying to arouse in connection with this whole matter.
As I understand the objection made to this, it is that I am not paying in the sum of money which ought to be paid in, and which has always been paid in, that I am bringing the fund to some near approach to insolvency and that, according to Deputy MacEntee, investments would have to be sold, thus correspondingly weakening the fund still further and that the whole fund would come into a terrible and complete state of bankruptcy. The actuary who investigated this matter reported on 16th November, 1944, and paragraph 18 of his report is:
"Under the Acts, the amount of the Exchequer grants is prescribed until 31st March, 1945, and thereafter is to be such sums as the Oireachtas may determine. As indicated in paragraph 16, the sum paid during the last eight years, namely, £450,000 per annum, is substantially larger than will be needed in the future, and an equalised annual grant, during the next decennium commencing on 1st April, 1945, of about one-half of this sum, say, £220,000, is estimated to be sufficient, together with the contributions at their present rates and the interest on the accumulated assets, to meet all expenditure out of the fund for contributory and non-contributory pensions and the cost of administration thereof, and to secure that in ten years' time the invested reserves of the scheme will then be substantially equal to the present balance, namely, £3,900,000."
The actuary, in fact, reported that the previous Government were paying too much into that fund. A sum of £450,000 was not required and the actuary says that, for ten years to come, £220,000 a year would do, and that, at the end of that time, every call on the fund would have been met and "the invested reserves would then be substantially equal to the present balance, namely, £3,900,000." The reserves are now at £4,500,000 and the previous Government after getting that report—why, I do not know—put in two sums of £450,000 in each of two years. They made in two years what I would call a four years' contribution.
I say that I am entitled to save not merely £450,000 this year but £450,000 next year. I had not thought of it until this report came in detail before me. I think I have a good case for remitting any payment to that fund this year and next year. Certainly, on the basis of that report, nobody can say that the fund has been brought an inch nearer insolvency and yet we have had all the propaganda of the last three weeks from the benches opposite, focussed to a great extent upon this point about the fund being brought to the point of insolvency and that either of two things would happen—the sale of investments would be necessary or the benefits given to the contributors would have to be reduced. They can be continued at the same old rate and the investments still kept at that high point.
The turf matter had to come very heavily into this debate. I wonder could we treat this matter seriously and not have it just as a matter for propaganda lectures to Fianna Fáil clubs in an attempt to do what I can only describe as serious fifth-column work—to disturb people who should not be disturbed, who should be allowed to get quietly back to their own avocations and who should be brought to realise that there is available work, and work in abundance, work which they used to do until, in an emergency, they were asked to remit their old labours and come into a new type of occupation in order to help the country through.
The late Minister for Industry and Commerce spoke here on 21st February, 1946. I propose to give certain extracts from his speech and I do not think I am parodying his speech or putting it unfairly if I say that, in dealing with the prospects as he then outlined them, he divided the matter into four heads. There was what he called the production of turf by people in turf areas, which had always gone on and which he hoped would continue; there was the production of certain hand-won turf for what was called the national turf pool; there was the production of machine-won turf by Bord na Móna; and there was coal. There was also in the background the provision of fuel of the firewood type. I think the Minister in February, 1946, definitely outlined the prospects in this way: turf production always went on for the needs of the people in certain areas and it was not affected to any great extent by the drive for the extra effort put into the winning of turf, and it should go on. I see no reason why it should not go on, except that possibly the late Minister brought in too much coal; but the position being at the point of the importation of coal we had in 1939, there is no reason why anybody who used to produce turf for sale in the turf areas or for his own use should not continue to do so.
The Minister went on to look a little ahead with regard to the turf won by the county councils and he contemplated that as being a declining process, likely to end quite soon and all the more speedily if great quantities of coal could be brought into this country. The gap which had to be filled was that as between the then imports of coal as compared with what they were in 1939 and that gap was to be filled by turf, either hand-won or machine-won. He said that the whole thing depended on coal—whether we could get back to the coal importation of 1939. If we did, turf was going to disappear, except that turf which was always produced in turf areas for people's own use. Speaking on 21st February, 1946, at column 1335 the Minister said:—
"As many Deputies know, hand-won turf provides the basic fuel over large areas of the country and in some districts no other fuel can offer even a partial alternative. Production by persons resident in those areas, for their own use or for local consumption, averaged about 3,500,000 tons per year, and it is to be assumed that those people will continue to provide their own requirements by their own efforts in the future."
Later, in column 1336, the Minister continued:
"On the most optimistic basis, it will be very many years before the production of machine-won turf will make good the deficiency in coal supplies and, as we move from the emergency to normal conditions, this machine-won turf, produced under the auspices of the Turf Development Board, will merely replace the hand-won quantities now being produced by the county councils and by the Turf Development Board, as agents for the Government during the emergency and now being supplied on a ration basis in the non-turf area."
Again, there was a forecast that machine-won turf under Bord na Móna auspices was going to replace all hand-won turf other than what people in certain areas produced for their own requirements or for local consumption. Later in the same debate, at column 1349, the Minister said that he would urge upon each individual turf producer in the country to keep up the supply, and here is the basis for that:
"that we must get this year at least the same production of hand-won turf as we got last year, because there is no likelihood that we will be able to get any more coal or even able to dispense with fuel rationing in the eastern area next year."
It is clear from that speech that the Minister's view was—and he was announcing it quite clearly to the Dáil in February, 1946—that there were certain areas in the country where turf would always continue to be cut and there was no reason to interrupt that. Nothing that has happened since the 18th February has interrupted that.
There was then hand-won turf under the auspices of the county councils. That was going to be changed over to Bord na Móna and that hand-won turf was going to be replaced by Bord na Móna machine-won turf. The amount required from Bord na Móna would depend upon what coal supplies were likely to come into the country. The then Minister for Industry and Commerce got somewhat frightened at this stage about the fuel situation and in February, 1947, an Irish coal mission, with the benediction of the Government, was sent to the United States. That mission arranged for 500,000 tons of American coal to be shipped to Irish ports during the ensuing three months in 60 specially chartered Liberty ships. The Minister was, no doubt, acting in an emergency. He was taking steps to get in a lot of coal and, the more coal there was in the country, the less necessity there was for turf. The old importation of coal used to run about 50,000 tons a week. In 1946 the average was less than half that. Towards the end of the year 1946 the imports fell to 17,000 a week and they continued to fall steadily. In February, 1947, there was less than 13,000 tons of coal coming in. The British were being pressed to increase their supplies and on the 21st March, 1947, the then Minister for Industry and Commerce met the British Minister for Fuel and Power. The best he could get at that stage was 11,000 tons of British coal of the lowest quality and there was no hope of improvement for an indefinite period. But, in November, 1947, the British Government undertook to supply 1,000,000 tons and the Minister grabbed it. The 11,000 tons were of course still to continue and that meant that, if the 1,000,000 tons were going to come in in regular instalments over the year, we had got to a position where we were having 31,000 tons of coal per week coming into the country.
Alternatively, if a considerable amount of the 1,000,000 tons was to be landed in at once it would presumably be put in the dump with the American coal that had come here. There is no doubt about it that by November a situation had been reached in which we had very big supplies of coal promised to us. The consequence of that upon the hand-winning of turf was obvious to anybody who knew and understood the problem.
Prior to that, of course, certain things had happened. In 1947 the then Minister for Local Government objected to the enlargement of the scope of his duties in connection with turf; he objected to county councils being asked to take any more responsibility with regard to the production of turf and he objected to any intention of continuing beyond the emergency that Minister's responsibilities for turf production through the county councils. In accordance with his views on the 18th August, 1947, a circular was addressed to county councils telling them that the Minister for Local Government had decided that county councils should not participate in the production of turf for Fuel Importers, Limited, after the 31st December of that year. The future production on behalf of Fuel Importers, Limited, was to be taken over by Bord na Móna. There then follows in the memorandum that was circulated a list of 17 turf counties. There is another memorandum here about the difficulty of transport and as to what would be done with bogs and so on. County councils were definitely given their instructions on the 18th August. They were not to have any further responsibility for the production of hand-won turf. That was followed by letters from the Minister for Local Government in December, 1947, thanking the various county councils for all they had done and more or less bidding farewell to the whole scheme.
Eventually we come to this conference, which has been mentioned so often, held in the Department of Industry and Commerce on the 12th February of this year. There was a long agenda. A number of items appeared on it and one of those items was "turf development programme for 1948." The decision that was taken was "no provision should be made in the 1948-49 Estimates for Bord na Móna hand-won turf scheme." That was a week before the Minister left office they decided that. Part was not decided. "The question of the discontinuance of hand-won turf production by the county councils should be further examined." Can anybody tell me that that meant it was going to be continued? That is the 12th February.
Comment on this
That is in direct contradiction to the statement made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, which I said was untrue.
Comment on this
That I had decided that the production of turf on the county council bogs was to cease.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce issued a false statement which is contradicted by that record. I never saw that record and never heard of it before, but that record contradicts the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. His statement is untrue.
Comment on this
As I said, I never read that minute. It was not prepared before I left office. Did I understand the Minister to read out the minute?
Comment on this
Yes, and the agenda included a provision to stop the hand-won production of turf: "No provision should be made in the 1948-49 Estimates for Bord na Móna hand-won turf scheme."
Comment on this
I want to be quite clear about this. The winning of turf on what are called the Bord na Móna camps was done away with.
Comment on this
The camps affected were the following: Mucklon, Corduff South, Killinthomas, Derries, Drummod, Lullymore, Newbridge—Newbridge, however, is to be retained as a central store—Edenderry, Robertstown, Corduff Middle, Allenwood and Slane. They were all to be done away with as far as hand-won turf is concerned. The next sentence is: "The question of the discontinuance of hand-won turf production in the county council bogs should be further examined."
Comment on this
Did the Minister for Industry and Commerce issue an official statement to the effect that I had decided that the production of turf on the county council bogs was to stop?
Comment on this
I produced the statement here. The Minister issued that statement and I contradicted it. Now I am proved to be right and the Minister is proved to be wrong.
Comment on this
Here is what the minute says: "The question of the production of hand-won turf on the county council bogs should be further examined." What does that mean? Take it in the context of the date, 12th February. On the 18th February a very critical point is going to be arrived at here. On the 12th February the Minister did not want to take a decision because of that. Is not that what it comes to?
Comment on this
The only matter I am interested in is that the Minister for Industry and Commerce issued a false statement officially.
Comment on this
The next item on the agenda for this conference on 12th February is the granting of hauliers' licences to persons engaged in the transport of turf during the emergency.
Comment on this
May I intervene to ask that this official document will be circulated or made available in the Library to all Deputies?
Comment on this
It was the custom in the Department of Industry and Commerce to circulate minutes of conferences a week or more after the conference. The particular conference on the 12th February was held a few days before I left office. I never saw the minutes. If they are to be quoted here and used in argument, the customary procedure of tabling them will, I presume, be followed.