We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 6—General (Resumed).

Contributions 150–320 of 488. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Of course you cannot. Your ear is nailed to the pump in this matter.

Comment on this

The Minister is under the impression that this debate is going to stop here. It is not. I will have ample opportunity to deal with this matter on the Finance Bill and I hope it will be possible to have the official documents by that time.

Comment on this

We will give you a copy of this. There are bound to be copies and I am sure the Deputy can have one. Item 10 on the agenda dealt with the granting of hauliers' licences to persons engaged in the transport of turf during the emergency and the point put up by the Department was the curtailment in turf production and haulage expected with the resumption of coal imports. What did that mean? It was quite clear that turf production was not only going to be lessened, but that turf haulage was going to be lessened because of the coal imports. This document says:

"With the curtailment in turf production and haulage expected with the resumption of coal imports, it was expected that persons engaged in the transport of turf would be approaching the Department for hauliers' licences. The matter would, it was expected, be required to be fully examined in the light of policy regarding the grant of hauliers' licences. It was suggested that petrol allocations should not be made to newcomers for the present.

Decision: "A comprehensive review of the situation should be undertaken with a view to formulating policy regarding the attitude to be adopted towards applications for hauliers' licences by persons engaged in the transport of turf and timber during the emergency."

If that was not putting a decision on the long finger for a week, then I do not know what it means. I ask Deputies to consider the meaning of that in the light of the existing circumstances. To me it was simply saying: "Do not bother me about these hauliers until we get the 18th February over us". Is not that what it means?

Comment on this

Certainly, but I am not to be represented as taking contrary decisions. That is what the Minister for Industry and Commerce did.

Comment on this

You are being found out at last on this matter.

Comment on this

The Minister is being exposed—he made a false statement.

Comment on this

I have been accused of making a false statement——

Comment on this

A false statement as Minister—over the radio.

Comment on this

Can you produce it?

Comment on this

I will produce it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We will hear the Minister for Finance now.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass, when he was Minister, clearly indicated that turf could always be cut. We expected that to be so. There can be no question about all these years preemergency when turf was cut. It will continue to be cut and I do not know what would happen to disturb that. But, with regard to turf being cut by county councils on bogs that were taken over by them under Emergency Powers Order, Deputy Lemass clearly saw that coming to an end. It was to be in part replaced by machine-won turf cut under the supervision of Bord na Móna. But that was to depend on the importation of coal.

Comment on this

There was a White Paper issued in 1946. If you adopt the policy outlined in that Paper you will settle the position.

Comment on this

On the 12th February we had reached the position in which we were getting in 31,000 tons of coal. That must have had an effect on the winning of turf by the hand process, or it clearly was going to have. The situation which the Deputy indicated on the 18th February as a result of these operations was somewhat interesting. I am quoting from the debate on the 18th February, column 59:

"There are a number of other problems which I am leaving to him——"

that is, to his successor.

"Most of them are problems resulting from the fact that efforts to accumulate stocks have been rather more successful than otherwise. In particular I want to refer to fuel. We have on hands a very large stock of American coal. At the present rate of disbursement there will still be large stocks on hands next winter. There is about a ten years' supply of firewood at the present rate of usage."

Comment on this

At the present rate of usage.

Comment on this

The rate of usage could not be increased and I do not know what the Deputy means by that interruption.

Comment on this

The quantity of coal used is half the normal supply.

Comment on this

It is three-fifths.

Comment on this

Am I right in saying that it represents half the normal requirements?

Comment on this

Three-fifths of the imports.

Comment on this

Three-fifths of our normal requirements?

Comment on this

Three-fifths of our imports and, in addition, we have on hands a large stock of American coal.

Comment on this

250,000 tons.

Comment on this

Let me continue what the Deputy said:

"There is about a ten years' supply of firewood at the present rate of usage. In that regard a particularly acute problem is now coming to a head. There are a large number of people engaged in this business of felling and hauling firewood. Many are Army officers and soldiers who spent their gratuities on the purchase of lorries."

Listen to this:

"That business must stop if for no other reason than the physical difficulty of finding further storage space for timber."

Physical difficulty? It is not merely the Park in which the timber is stored; there are about 17 other dumps in the country, full.

Comment on this

And you never mentioned the South African coal?

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe is not in the House.

Comment on this

But the coal is in the Park.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass continued:

"All the storage space rented by Fuel Importers, Limited, is full. If this hauling of firewood must cease then these men have no other haulage business in which they can legitimately engage. It may be that a suggestion will be put forward to amend the Transport Act so as to give them the right to engage in public haulage of other kinds."

He talks about that and then goes on to say:—

"There is, therefore, no easy solution of the problem to which I have referred."

Comment on this

You did not abolish turf rationing until six weeks afterwards and you did not cut the price of timber. No one will buy timber at £4 when he can buy turf at £2 14s. 0d.

Comment on this

Those prices were in operation in your time.

Comment on this

We were building up stocks.

Comment on this

In column 60 of the debates the Deputy is reported:—

"A similar situation exists in relation to turf."

The situation with regard to turf and timber was that we had far more than we wanted. I do not know whether that is caught in the phrase: "A similar situation exists in relation to turf."

Comment on this

Far more people were prepared to buy because of the price.

Comment on this

The Deputy continued:—

"It is true that turf is still rationed, but it is rationed solely because of the subsidy arrangement. The price of turf in the eastern parts of the country is subsidised. The justification for the maintenance of the subsidy was that turf was rationed in that area. In the rest of the country turf was unsubsidised and unrationed. Now there are ample supplies of turf and rationing could be abolished, subject to the adjustment of the price or the subsidy arrangement relating to price."

Later he said:—

"There is, however, in the dumps of Fuel Importers, Limited, enough turf at the present rate of distribution to last until the winter of 1949."

There is the Deputy's statement. We have a ten years' supply of firewood, large stocks of American coal, and enough turf in the dumps to do us until the winter of 1949.

Comment on this

If you kept up the ration.

Comment on this

Not merely was the Minister talking like that, but he was keeping up the supply of timber into this city.

Comment on this

It had stopped before you came into office.

Comment on this

It had not stopped. We gave the order to stop it.

Comment on this

The price was reduced a month before, and the measures which diverted it from Dublin were taken a month before.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not live on the Naas road as I do.

Comment on this

Ten thousand tons were coming into the city. On the 18th February the Deputy continued: "I think that my successor will be very relieved that there are no immediate fuel difficulties to face in the country but he will have problems to meet in relation to the stocks accumulated.... These stocks will not keep indefinitely as turf deteriorates and timber deteriorates even more rapidly, and clearly the stocks must be disposed of before they become useless." That is the situation and does anybody expect that we were going to take a contrary decision, that we were going to have the winning of turf by county councils and on the bogs in the counties continue and have it sent into the city, when the dumps here are full between timber and turf and when we got a warning from the man who knows most about it that the stuff deteriorates rapidly and must be got rid of? I want to ask the House who is responsible for the closing down of turf cutting in this country. Was it not the Government that made that situation inevitable, that turf production would have to cease for a while?

Comment on this

Now the policy of the White Paper will start again.

Comment on this

I do not know what that means, but we have ten years' supply of wood in the Park. That is the situation and then we have Deputies running round the country talking about stoppages of turf cutting and unemployment. Let them tell their constituents the facts. They will get them out of Dáil Debates—the reports which I have read—and official documents, and let them place the blame where it belongs. This would have to come sooner or later; Deputy Lemass knows that and he had no scruples in saying that to this House in February, 1946. Now that he is in opposition, however, he, of course, finds it useful to say that this is a national development scheme and that it has been dropped. How can he expect us to use the stuff when the Deputy himself said that it was physically impossible to locate it in the place set apart for it?

With regard to unemployment, some of the Donegal Deputies were very vocal about unemployment in Donegal. I have heard figures quoted with regard to unemployment in Donegal which were vastly in excess of the number employed on the production of turf. I wonder what is the cause of the unemployment? I wonder is it because coal has been imported into Donegal? The present Government made no arrangements for bigger importations of coal into Donegal.

Comment on this

You can stop it if you want to. Do not ride that horse now.

Comment on this

We are in the same position as the last Government when the Deputy did not stop it. Those Deputies who have been talking should get the ex-Minister and ask him if those facts are not correct, and I think that they can form their own conclusions. The production of turf could not go on for ever; it had to be brought to a conclusion and the conclusion was forced upon us because of what the previous Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, had done, particularly in the autumn of 1947, and continuing into the early stages of 1948 and up to the week of his leaving office.

Further, in regard to unemployment, Deputies have spoken in this House of the difficulties that they have found in getting people to sign on for the alternative schemes which have been put into operation in the turf areas where unemployment was caused. I have heard people saying that it was impossible to get workers for farm operations, even in areas adjacent to bogs which were worked under county council auspices. I am sorry that Deputy Childers and Deputy MacEntee are not in the House at the moment because they know full well what happened at a gathering in April, 1947, of the people most concerned all over the counties in getting up a special drive in connection with turf. They heard from those people that there was a scarcity of labour for turf cutting and where there was not a scarcity of labour there was a condition of demoralisation because people found it easier to get money from the so-called social service known as the "dole" than to work on the bogs. Deputy MacEntee asked at the conference table if he could take it that that was the experience of everybody and the answer was "Yes, all of us have had that experience."

It is no wonder then if you go out with alternative schemes that you cannot get labour to work those schemes. Let those workers who have been unemployed hurry to their local branch manager to register and we shall see what unemployment we can mop up through alternative schemes. At the moment it is not easy to get the money which is being spent, so if Deputies, instead of doing their propaganda work here, would get those people to register for work of another type it would be better.

The £85,000 for mineral exploration is one of the great grievances I have to meet in connection with this Budget. Again I would like to remind the House what Deputy Lemass, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, said about the matter in October, 1947. In October, 1947, the then Minister with regard to the Slieveardagh Mines had abandoned——

Comment on this

The deposits would have been worked by private enterprise which was given £50,000 for the development of the mine.

Comment on this

Two approaches of the Slieveardagh Mines were closed down by Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this

They were not.

Comment on this

Ballylunty and Lickfinn were closed.

Comment on this

£50,000 capital was provided to open new shafts.

Comment on this

They were closed by Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this

£50,000 was provided.

Comment on this

Has £50,000 been made available or has it been cut down? That is the point people in Slieveardagh are interested in.

Comment on this

In column 112 of the Official Debates of October 8th Mr. Lemass said:—

"I would not say Slieveardagh is completely mechanised, or that production difficulties have been overcome. In fact, I am satisfied that that has not happened. The other mining operations of the company have been closed down."

That is the limit of his advances for working the deposits. And later in column 113 Deputy Lemass said:—

"If, in fact, as we must always assume in mining operations the plans do not work out as they hope and a stage is reached where they cannot continue without further capital expenditure the decision of the Government will probably be to close down the work."

Comment on this

But was the £50,000 made available?

Comment on this

The £50,000 is on the Estimate at the moment.

Comment on this

Will it be made available?

Comment on this

The sum I am cutting is the £85,000, which is entirely distinct from that.

Comment on this

Then why bring in Slieveardagh? The £85,000 has nothing to do with Slieveardagh.

Comment on this

The poor Deputy from Tipperary who thought it was in the £85,000 brought it in.

Comment on this

Has the £50,000 capital been made available or will it be made available?

Comment on this

Do not lose your temper.

Comment on this

Answer the question.

Comment on this

Do not get angry.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass made the case about Slieveardagh that he was sick and tired of it. I do not think I am parodying him in saying that.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

That it had been offered to a private company and they would not have it, and he was washing his hands of it. It was advertised for sale.

Comment on this

Publicly.

Comment on this

It was advertised for sale, not offered to a private company. It was advertised in the newspapers, for sale. When it was not sold, £50,000 was made available for its development. What has happened it?

Comment on this

It is still there.

Comment on this

Is it going to be used for that purpose?

Comment on this

You will hear all about it.

Comment on this

What is the use of arguing about the £85,000, which I am taking, which has nothing to do with Slieveardagh but has to do with Mianraí Teoranta, with regard to which Deputy Childers quoted, when Deputy Lemass was out, what he called the rather mournful statement of the ex-Taoiseach which was to the effect that all the geological surveys and everything we had seemed to indicate that we had no worth-while mineral deposits in the country and I accept the tenor of Deputy Childers' remarks as being what I would myself say was the real complexion to be put on what the ex-Taoiseach said, that this money ought to be spent to get settled once and for all whether we had minerals or not. In fact, the emphasis was to get it settled that we have none. Certainly, there was no optimism about the thing.

Comment on this

Least of all by Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this

There are experts' reports there. I am not an expert. Go on the experts' reports.

Comment on this

At column 147 of this debate Deputy Lemass told us what he expected. He said that these people were going to explore and develop; that that would be done in accordance with a systematic plan that was going to last for seven years. At the end of the seven years what was to happen? This:—

"At the end of that seven years' period, we should have a complete picture of the mineral resources of the country which will enable us to decide to what extent we should develop them commercially now and hold them as a sort of strategic reserve against another war or to what extent they are of no value either for commercial exploitation or reserve purposes."

Nobody would get a lift in his heart from that statement about the future of minerals in the country. The Deputy went on to comment upon a phrase that was used in the debate by the late Deputy Hughes. He said, at column 148:—

"Deputy Hughes appeared to suggest that if the company finds workable deposits and wants to work them, it should go ahead and do so, and that the Bill should provide for that possibility. I do not think it should. If workable deposits are located and developed to the point at which they can be worked, and if it is decided that this company or any other State organisation should work them rather than that they should be leased to private enterprise, the Dáil should have an opportunity of expressing its view on the matter. As this Bill stands, Mianraí Teoranta could not do so. There would have to be other legislation which would enable the Dáil to decide whether it wanted the deposits worked in that way or in some other way. I think that is as it should be. I want no ambiguity in anybody's mind as to the view of the Government. It is that if workable deposits are located and developed to a point at which they can be exploited, they should be leased on some satisfactory basis to private concerns rather than that they should be exploited by Mianraí Teoranta."

There is the £85,000. People are talking in this House as if there was actual mining going on, that workable deposits had been found, that they were being got out, that there was commercial use found for them and that we had a purchaser for whatever was there. That is all-nonsense. These are all figments of the vivid imaginations of the Deputies. The money was provided there to allow certain development and exploratory work to be done and, beyond Slieveardagh, it had been definitely thrown aside by the Minister. The only other thing that was ahead was Avoca and with regard to Avoca I do not want to speak too much at this moment because there is a possibility of a scheme with regard to Avoca being worked out.

I cannot say what I would like to say in answer to Deputy MacEntee but I would say this: that I do not think anybody who comes here to work Avoca or any other mines will ever have imposed upon him the sort of confidence trick that would certainly be put upon him if he were to go by the phrase used by Deputy MacEntee in the Dáil. Deputy MacEntee gave a highly-coloured version of a report about deposits in Avoca. He never told this House that there were three reports, two of them very unsatisfying. The first approached was an Englishman. Nobody could say any penny would be spent on what he reported. The second was a Swede. His report could be described as equally unhelpful. The third was the professor to whom Deputy MacEntee referred. Really, it is something approaching dishonesty to promulgate to this House one of three reports, two of them bad and one middling good, and then to pretend that there is a whole field, not merely for exploration but for development, and that we are definitely and clearly putting that aside. We have other plans with regard to Avoca. I do not believe it is worth while spending this £85,000 a year in the way in which Deputy Lemass outlined in October, 1947—so that in the end we could get a picture of the mineral resources and see whether there was something we could exploit, and then exploit and hold them as a strategic reserve and later make up our minds as to whether the thing was commercially workable or not.

There is any amount of information about minerals in this country—any amount of it. If there is anything in which the whole Geological Surveys report any possibility of good, I would rather tackle these and spend money on them, not on any further exploration, attempting to discover whether there are minerals there or not, but trying to get down to something and getting some good out of the country.

Comment on this

Does not it show that in Avoca?

Comment on this

The Geological Surveys did not.

Comment on this

Surely the Geological Survey was always very strongly of opinion that Avoca should be explored?

Comment on this

If they did, why call in three experts, two of them not being satisfactory in the end? Does the Deputy deny what I have said? I do not want to go into this in detail and I hope the Deputy will not press me to because at the present moment there are people interested. There were three reports. The Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

I am querying the suggestion that the Geological Survey suggests that Avoca has no minerals or is not capable of being worked. The Geological Survey has always been strongly of opinion that Avoca should be explored. The past director of the Geological Survey was a director of Mianraí Teoranta. The present director of the Geological Survey also is a director of Mianraí Teoranta.

Comment on this

I want the phrase noted—"If there was enough there to have them explored."

Comment on this

You cannot be certain until you go down to look. It is also a fact that that Bill was supported by every Party in the House, including the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

I do not know whether that is so or not. I have not been able to look through the debate. I should imagine it probably was supported. It is only when one gets behind the curtains and realises what the reality of the situation is that one can appreciate the phrase used in Dáil Éireann. The phrase used in Dáil Éireann certainly would not have enthused anybody about the exploration. Probably people said it was better than nothing but, when you get the reality and realise that what was said to the Dáil was putting the best face on a rather bad situation, then you begin to wonder whether or not the expenditure of the money was worth while. I do not think, in present circumstances, that it is. If money is to be spent, in exploration and development, I think there are better ways of spending it than that scheme of going on year by year paying £85,000 to discover whether or not we have any minerals, with a rather definite accent on the phrase that it is really to prove to people that we have none. That is the mood in which the money was voted.

I have been questioned with regard to what I am doing in connection with the cinemas and a great case has been made here about the hardship caused to certain cinemas. Let the situation be understood. There are 360 picturehouses, or thereabouts, in the country. Prior to the imposition of the Supplementary Budget only 11 of these gave variety performances. I suggest that only 11 have to be considered as in any way affected by the present financial proposals. It is true that, after the Supplementary Budget proposal being brought in, a great number of these houses went over to what are called live shows. The calculations that I have show that 248 of the cinemas had these live shows. A live show meant that they got in someone to play a tin whistle or strum the piano or play about with a melodeon or something like that for, say, two hours and five minutes. Then a two-hour picture show was run and, of course, the greater part of the performance, more than 50-50, was a live show and therefore the tax was remitted. I do not propose to allow those people to evade the tax in that way. It was never the policy that the tax should be remitted in those circumstances.

With regard to the 11 houses, here is the only information I have been able to get in regard to those places. Half a dozen places were mentioned here in the House during the debate and with regard to the six mentioned, only one of them ran cinema variety to any extent prior to the Supplementary Budget. The rest had taken it on as a method of evading the tax. If they had not the habit of feeing variety artistes, I do not propose to allow them the remission. In regard to the 11 that had, one can weigh in the balance the statement made about 400 or 500 variety artistes being thrown out of employment by the new budgetary proposal, when I tell you that the places where these 11 cinemas operated were Lucan, Navan, Oldcastle, Kilcullen, Kildare, Naas, Baltinglass, Portlaoighise and Moville. It is quite clear that there could not be any great employment given to variety artistes in that number of the 11 that I have mentioned. I suggest that this is all humbug.

Some Deputies seem to have nothing much else to talk about in connection with the Budget except a case to be made with regard to some variety artistes, but the number has been magnified to some 500 or 600 in constant employment who are going to be thrown out of their occupations. These houses could not employ 400 or 500 even in five years. I suggest there is no real case for alleviating the effect on these people of the proposals that I have made. If it could be said with regard to any one of them that they were seriously in the cine-variety line and that they intended to continue that way, that they had built premises specially for that and that they were going to be handicapped in recovering their capital expenditure, I would suggest, in regard to such a particular picture house, that a case has been made. I have no information about any such place yet and I think my proposal should be accepted until such a case is made.

Deputy McCann told us of a picture house in Ringsend and either he or Deputy MacEntee says that the proprietor of the establishment told whichever of the Deputies was speaking that they had engaged in cine-variety. The investigation showed they never once had an artiste on their boards, and could not, because the Dublin Corporation had certain regulations with regard to fire precautions which would preclude any such picture house having variety artistes. While I was told the proprietor of the picture house had so told one or other of the Deputies, the investigation reveals that it is a complete fabrication.

I suppose the greatest fuss caused in connection with these proposals is over the short-wave station. I think Deputy Derrig was the last man to speak about the short-wave station in operation, so that news and information could be transmitted to America, Australia and elsewhere, and millions of people of Irish descent could, by the turning of a knob, switch in and hear Irish programmes and news from Ireland. He talks about our great boast being that we have not material goods to give to people, but that we have a spiritual and national heritage and we could transmit that by allowing those people to switch in on their radio sets in America, to get whatever is to come from our short-wave station. That is a great picture. Deputy Little had very much the same thing to say. He talked of the thousands who were going to be disappointed by the disappearance of these proposals. Deputy Lemass used the phrase that many thousands of Irish citizens had been looking forward to the station as being the only means by which the Irish people could correct any misrepresentation abroad.

I cannot find out what the policy was in regard to this station. As Deputies here have expressed it, some say it was to enable those of our kith and kin abroad to listen-in to the Radio Éireann programme, while others talk as if it was going to be an opportunity to give them a new programme here at home, that they could switch on the new station on their sets at home and get a sort of second show as well as that which they get from Radio Éireann at the moment. However, the great complaint was with regard to propaganda through this use of the air, that it was the way in which we could tear down the paper wall around us and, when the occasion arose, could correct any misrepresentation; and if, in a moment of agony, we were going to be invaded, we could have a last despairing cry sent to the world, so that the people abroad would know from those at home what the real situation was. That is a great picture. I do not care which of the two arguments is used— there is some policy in either, if you neglect the facts. What are the facts? Deputy Little almost cried aloud the other day over this. Deputy Little, while he remained Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, as far as departmental memoranda is concerned, stoutly opposed this scheme from beginning to end.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

He opposed it. The first memorandum that proceeded from the Deputy's Department was:—

"It cannot be too strongly emphasised that the view of this Department is quite definitely that it will be extremely difficult to get any wave-length free from all interference suitable for working from here to the United States."

On that basis, he was all against it, I suggest. There is the situation and there is no doubt about it. We have not got a wave-length for broadcasting from the short-wave station, if it were erected.

Comment on this

We are just as entitled as any other country to get one.

Comment on this

Just, but we have not got one.

Comment on this

Everyone has a right.

Comment on this

We went to the conference in Atlantic City when the matter was thrashed out and we did not succeed in getting one.

Comment on this

We did not fail, either.

Comment on this

The matter was left over to Mexico City in the autumn, when it was to be thrashed out again.

Comment on this

October.

Comment on this

Certain arrangements had been sought, attempting to discover whether we could have share arrangements on a short-wave with some other country, which would enable us to do a couple of hours' broadcast on a couple of nights in the week. We never got such a share arrangement, so we had no wave-length and we had not even a share arrangement.

Comment on this

The negotiations were not finished.

Comment on this

This whole project started in 1945, when the negotiations for a wave-length had not even started and when the Post Office view, which I presume was that of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, was that there would be extreme difficulty in getting any suitable wave-length free from interference.

Comment on this

It was not my view.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding that—I need not go through all the memoranda; the Deputy must know— eventually this was pushed across on him as being a matter of national importance. In other words, the answer was: "We do not care anything about your technical difficulties. Whether or not we are getting a wave-length, we want a short-wave station." That is what it came to.

Comment on this

It is not true.

Comment on this

That is on the memorandum issued. I am right and the Deputy must admit that no wave-length was secured.

Comment on this

The Department put up the difficulties.

Comment on this

The Deputy says we can broadcast on any wave-length we like. And if we do, have we got a wave-length for the medium band— we have—and does that depend on our being, so to speak, reasonable people in connection with wave-lengths? If we came home and decided, as the Deputy suggests, that we would just go on the air any time and jam other people abroad on the short-wave, would not we be deprived almost certainly of our medium wave-length? I suggest we would. So, for the purposes of showing ourselves off on the air, on some wave-length which we would not have for use as a rule and which we would use with other people and jam their programmes, resulting in the eventual disappearance of our right to the medium band, we decided to go on with the erection of the station. We further had tried to get a share arrangement and failed to get it.

Do not forget this, that the best Post Office information appears to be that the radio sets now being made in America do not include short-wave reception. They are off on some system called modulated frequency or frequency modulation.

Comment on this

It is far from being widespread.

Comment on this

While not widespread, it is certainly coming in. In that event, a short-wave broadcasting station is a real white elephant. Think of the frustration that was ahead, people leaping around to get a short-wave station so that our nationals abroad could hear Radio Éireann's music or something during the emergency. We were in an unhappy situation; we had no wave-length and no sharing arrangement. The people whom we wanted to approach were getting out of short-wave reception as fast as they could and a new system was coming in which was making the old system obsolete before we could operate it.

Comment on this

That is a complete distortion of the situation.

Comment on this

New countries have established new stations and have got wave-lengths since.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Have we not tried travelling showmen? So we do not need a short-wave station.

Comment on this

That remark is typical of Deputy Seán Collins. He should not speak about the ex-Taoiseach in that fashion.

Comment on this

So long as it is not broadcast from the short-wave station it is all right. As a matter of fact that would be a good place to broadcast the remarks about the ex-Taoiseach because they would not get out anywhere.

Comment on this

The people abroad know all about our ex-Taoiseach already.

Comment on this
A Deputy

And the people of Ireland too.

Comment on this

And the people of the world.

Comment on this

I confess astonishment at all the fuss that has been created about a station that was going to be dumb. We had a lurid figure in our minstrelsy about "The harp that once through Tara's Halls." We now have added the short-wave station that never—and never could, as far as the arrangements were concerned.

Comment on this

Do you propose to send anyone to the conference to try to complete the negotiations?

Comment on this

I wonder whether that would be good or bad. It is almost a complete stultification to have people looking for wave-bands when the evidence so far is that we would not get one.

Comment on this

You certainly will not get one if you do not try.

Comment on this

I am wondering if it is worth trying. I have to get further information as to whether it is worth trying. I think the Deputy will admit that if the American sets are no longer capable of receiving short-wave programmes it is not worth while getting it.

Comment on this

That is a complete distortion of the situation in America. The modulated system is not widespread, is not liked, and it is expensive.

Comment on this

I do not say that frequency modulation is the reason for this short-wave going out. There are two movements, one may make the other a certainty, but with frequency modulation coming in short-wave reception is going out.

Comment on this

It is always used in time of crisis and war. That was to have been its main function.

Comment on this

We are not back in time of crisis. Some Deputies want this station erected so that in some emergency which is not precisely brought before the Dáil somebody would be able to broadcast something somewhere. What is it that is required? Why should we spend money on this unnamed emergency and for an unmentioned purpose in connection with it? I do not understand the reason and, until the Deputy is more precise about what he requires, I will pass the argument over. There is all the fuss about the closing down of this station. I suggest there never was a case for the building of it. My only regret is that I did not get into the Department of Finance in time to stop the expense earlier. The station is there at the moment. Deputy Lemass apparently thinks that four masts or three and a half are erected. I understand that one and a half is the figure. The Deputy will realise that there is no great contradiction between us because you have to have two to make a unit. There are one and a half erected. That is the situation as we know it.

Comment on this

There are five masts there now. That means only two units.

Comment on this

There are three and a half masts and that means one and a half units.

Comment on this

There are five masts up. I see them every day when I pass by them.

Comment on this

I may be mistaken. That means one and a half units. I do not know whether the unit, as it is erected, is the American or the European. Deputy Little went out of his way about some grand order of priority which was arranged first for North America; then, if you please, Australia and the South Pacific; then the European countries and, finally, South America. Certainly Deputy Little managed to get the European masts in very quickly, but whether they are the ones fully erected or not I do not know. The highest point of the futility about this station would be if the masts erected for broadcasting to America should be those for broadcasting to the Continent. That might easily be the situation which will develop. However, it is only part of the whole background which is really an effort at frustration and futility of the worst type, and no good to the people in the country.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give a licence for its establishment by private enterprise on a commercial basis?

Comment on this

If anybody offers I shall consider the proposal. I will do anything to save money on this project. It is desperate to see it there. It does not show up any Government, or the people who gave the lead to a former Government that they should advance as far as they did on the lines they did on that project with the information they had at their disposal.

I thought we had got rid of Aer Linte for ever once the decision was taken to close that service down. Apparently some people are still concerned about the closing of the transatlantic service. I would like to correct a few wrong impressions. I hear comments—I do not know whether they are supposed to be quotations or not but they are made as if they were— that the air services were supposed to pay from the start. I never judged that service on that basis. As far as I could I had inquiries made to find out if it was ever likely to prove a success. I never got anybody to state that it would. I do not know if anybody in this House, who has any knowledge of that service, would dare to suggest that it was likely to be a paying proposition. I saw no memorandum that came within miles of suggesting that. It was starting at a loss and it was going to continue at a loss, and a heavy loss at that. I understand that the estimate given in this House was in the neighbourhood of a loss of £150,000 per year. The real loss was something in the nature of £500,000 without paying the interest on the capital moneys which were sunk. There was a scheme which I thought showed a remote possibility of this loss being brought down to about £150,000 but it involved the Constellations which were going to be leased to Aer Lingus at a fee of £500,000 per year.

If Aer Lingus was going to get £500,000 per year put on to its already overburdened back it only meant that we pretended to make the transatlantic air service a bit less of a deficit by off-loading part of the deficit on Aer Lingus. Any decent finance outlook with regard to the transatlantic air service would be that it started at a loss, continued at a loss, and never looked like being anything but a loss. The most bolstered-up estimates of receipts—even allowing that it was going to cater for all and sundry without any difficulty in connection with foreign exchange and including the possibility that Americans were going to travel in our planes rather than in their own —had to embrace all these certainly rather improbable events before one could bring the loss down to some moderate point. But it was always going to be a loss, and let nobody pretend to have any information to the contrary. We are having air services but, as far as I understand, every item in connection with them is, at the moment, operating at a loss. The two airport accounts are in deficit. Aer Lingus and its various branches are in deficit but nobody proposes to close them down for that reason. It was to be expected that company would have to bear rather heavy expense at the beginning but one would expect that a service running between here and England ought to find enough passengers offering to enable the service to pay. It may be that there were some mistakes made with regard to the set-up of the establishment which they were unable to rectify. There is no suggestion that I have heard of, at any rate no suggestion proceeded from me, about cutting down all the air services which show a deficit.

I am faced with a situation in which every single one of them is in deficit. The only one that has been stopped is the transatlantic service and I think it was a wise thing. I think we are going to give air development in this country a little bit better chance of proving itself to the people, of having itself established here as a good service, if we take away one branch which was going to operate at a heavy loss and as far as I can make out, was going to operate permanently at a loss. Deputy Briscoe said that all the transatlantic air services were paying their way. My information is to the contrary.

Comment on this

Airline shares are booming on the New York Stock Exchange.

Comment on this

Every line is losing money.

Comment on this

There was a statement the other day about airlines carrying mails which, of course, would be another way of giving subsidies under a cloak. The great thing is to give a new Post Office contract and, instead of having the mails carried by ships, we should give enormously increased payments to the air service to carry them. That, of course, would bring down the deficit by what is really a subsidy.

When I heard Deputy Little talking about the authentic voice of Ireland going over the air on the short-wave station and when I got finally into my hands the scheme of advertisements for the transatlantic service, I began to feel that we did a very good day's work for this country in closing down quick and fast the transatlantic air service. The transatlantic air service had decided to advertise their comings and goings. Amongst others, they advertised in a paper called The New Yorker. I wish people could see the advertisements and the sort of typical little figure which, apparently, the advertiser had decided to make for the Irish transatlantic air service. It is very reminiscent of the bad old days of the stage Irishman—the little squat figure with the Irish features as portrayed in the pages of Punch years ago in derision of this country—the long upper lip, the long nose with the caubeen on the head. They had not the pipe, but only a shamrock this time. That was paraded in New York as being an advertisement under the auspices of Aer Línte or some of their advertising agents, in order to get people to travel by that service. On February 14th, 1948, over this amazing parody of a figure supposed to represent an Irishman we had this: “Cushla machree, and would you look at what the Irish are doing.” On February 21st: “ 'Tis a proud day that's coming for the Irish”—with the little figure bobbing around. On February 28th: “It's a Shamrock that's coming ... the likes of which ye've never seen before.” On March 6th—this is preparing for the great flight which was to take place on St. Patrick's Day: “And did you hear the news that's going round—the Irish are flying on St. Patrick's Day.” That is a nostalgic horror as an effort at advertising. It certainly deserves immediate retrenchment. If that is the way the Irish air line was being paraded by advertisement through New York, I feel prouder than ever that I brought that to a finish. If that was the sort of stuff that was being paraded to promote the onset of our nationals on this country by the grand air service we were providing——

Comment on this

Is not all that just a red herring?

Comment on this

It is a very malodorous one. Certainly I do not think Deputy Little would be guilty of broadcasting that type of stuff over the new short-wave station. If he did, I would not call it the authentic voice of Ireland calling. I am criticised for what I am doing with regard to wheat. What I am doing is what has been done in quite a number of countries since 1930. So far as I remember, about 1930 Sweden started a scheme of having the Budget not alone regarded as an annual matter, but of having certain parts of the Budget schemed out for a four or seven years' period. They were advised by good financiers that if they could make ends meet inside four, five or six years that was all that was required. They took into consideration circumstances in which certain expenditures were bearing very heavily on them in a particular year and in which they could see these circumstances ceasing, in the latter years, and they did what I have done.

Comment on this

Those were depression years. They were fighting deflation, not inflation.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy's view was that this was a deflation period. Has he changed to inflation now?

Comment on this

I said that there are signs that we are passing into one. They started at a period when they were in the depths of one.

Comment on this

They continued it in the other stage. It was meant to even out these curves between deflation and inflation. Apart from any of these examples, I suggest that it would have been quite fair and reasonable, and that it is particularly fair and reasonable when the present year's difficulties have to be considered. This year the subsidy for wheat would have to be £6,850,000. In that £6,850,000 there is one item of 75,000 tons of Argentine wheat at £50 per ton, and the subsidy on that alone is nearly £2,500,000. The subsidy on the native 1947 harvest was £600,000 and for the native 1948 harvest £1,190,000. The subsidy on Australian wheat at a price of £35 per ton was £2,625,000. The real blister this year was the 75,000 tons of Argentine wheat which the then Minister bought the day before he left office.

Comment on this

Would you have preferred to do without it? Could you have got it anywhere else for less?

Comment on this

Could you not have left it to your successor to decide?

Comment on this

The statement that I bought it before I left office is not true. Negotiations had been proceeding for months and were concluded at that time.

Comment on this

On the 14th February the Chargé d'Affaires cabled to say that he expected an interview shortly with the head of the Argentine Grain Exporting Agency. There was a further cable received from the Chargé d'Affaires on the 16th February intimating that as a result of his representations payment would be accepted in sterling. The Minister for Industry and Commerce decided that the purchase should be concluded. Perhaps I was wrong in saying that it was the day before he left office. In any event, it was finished by the evening of the 16th or some time on the 17th; certainly about 48 hours before he left office.

Comment on this

What would be the bread ration now only for it?

Comment on this

Exactly the same.

Comment on this

The then Minister deferred consideration of whether or not he would discharge the turf workers from the bogs on the 12th February to a later date. He is faced here with this purchase on the 16th February, when by the 16th Deputies knew what their fate would be on the 18th. That purchase of 75,000 tons of wheat at £50 per ton cost this country nearly £2,500,000 in the way of subsidy.

Comment on this

If I had not closed the deal and the bread ration had to be halved, what would the Minister be saying?

Comment on this

The only thing that I can say about that decision is why could you not have left it to your successor?

Comment on this

You might not have got the wheat.

Comment on this

You left turf and other things to your successor. There is nothing in the cables that I have seen to say that the bargain was not open on that date.

Comment on this

Find out about that.

Comment on this

I will find out. It is not in this memorandum from the Chargé d'Affaires from which I have already quoted. Why should the Minister for Industry and Commerce have put this blister of £2,480,000 on the country within the last 36 hours of his Party leaving office? I think I am entitled to take that into consideration and to say that no such profligate purchase will be made in any other year, I hope. That was done by a Deputy who is now going around the country saying that I cannot pay for this year's bread for the country. I am not sure that I am bound to enforce on the people of the country that gorgeous mistake of Deputy Lemass's and make them pay for it in one year.

Comment on this

If that was a mistake I take it that the policy of the Government is to reduce the bread ration rather than purchase wheat from abroad.

Comment on this

There is no foundation for that.

Comment on this

Do not be trying to deceive the Dáil. There is no place else where you could have got it.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

We are getting it from Australia.

Comment on this

There is not a grain of Australian wheat coming in before September that was not purchased before your time.

Comment on this

We have got some from America.

Comment on this

75,000 tons.

Comment on this

No. Why should we look for that 75,000 tons?

Comment on this

You prefer to cut the ration.

Comment on this

No. The tonnage of wheat, including this very dear 75,000 tons, is got by providing for this year 430,000 tons and budgeting next year for 460,000 tons. I am not trying to cut any ration, but I am providing that extra 30,000 tons of wheat.

Comment on this

This country has not been allocated 480,000 tons for next year.

Comment on this

No one said we had. There is the native wheat.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking about native wheat when nobody knows what the harvest is going to be.

Comment on this

They do.

Comment on this

We believe we will get 100,000 tons of native wheat and 360,000 tons from abroad, or 460,000 tons in all.

Comment on this

That will not maintain the ration.

Comment on this

I am not cutting the ration but I am cutting the heavy expenditure on the people. What is being done in regard to wheat is that recognising that this was a very bad year, made particularly bad by the bad bargain the Deputy made so late in his time, we feel that we could not ask the people to bear the whole of that in this year.

Comment on this

If that wheat had not been purchased the ration would have had to be reduced on the 1st March.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

The Deputy might say that with a good prospect of getting it over if he was sitting on this side. He was then able to bully and boast and rant but he cannot do it now. We have the documents.

Comment on this

If the Minister looks at the documents he will find that the official view of the Department of Industry and Commerce was that even after that purchase the ration would have to be reduced.

Comment on this