Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 6—General (Resumed).
Contributions 321–488 of 488. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
You can take it that 430,000 tons are going to be sufficient to get us through this year.
Comment on this
Is it your contention that, without the 75,000 tons from the Argentine, we would have been left short?
Comment on this
Deputies, I am sure, will realise how moderate I am in dividing out the cost of the wheat over four or five years. There is a scheme to provide wheat at two dollars dropping by 20 cents each year. The Deputy's first view of that scheme was that it was going to be all right. Any information I have is that it is going to be all right. As regards the wheat purchased from abroad, if we take the four years, the price will not be the 2-dollar figure I have taken but $1.60. We estimate that we are going to get 100,000 tons of native wheat. If I only get what the Deputy mentioned, I will be relieved in the payment of a bit of money on, say, 30,000 tons of wheat.
Comment on this
We are getting 360,000 tons from abroad. That is 30,000 tons more than the Deputy left us this year. A great many of these calculations may slide in my favour and I need not take the 2-dollar wheat all through.
Comment on this
Taking it that the agreement will be fulfilled it would be good finance and good economics to take the middle point of $1.60 wheat. If I do not look for 100,000 tons of native wheat but for 60,000 or 70,000 tons then I will save the subsidy on 30,000 tons. As regards freights, there is a certain view that they may not be as high for five years as they are to-day. Am I doing anything really to undermine the stability of the State in taking these factors into consideration? They are factors that can operate very easily in favour of the country. Am I not to take any cognisance of them but simply to budget for $2 wheat right through the five-year period, find out what I have to pay and divide by five?
Comment on this
I have not described it as an economy. The Deputy can describe it any way he likes. I say it is good both as a finance matter and as a matter of economics. It is certainly a good deal better than the Deputy would have done. He left us with 75,000 tons of Argentine wheat bought at £50 a ton, so that the Lord only knows what we would have had to pay in wheat and flour subsidies this year.
There was one small matter raised by Deputy McCann. He referred to the building programme for vocational education schools. Deputy McCann must know that there was a meeting on the 30th January of this year to discuss that particular matter. On the 30th January, the people who form the present Government were not in office and that matter has nothing to do with any economy measure I have adopted. It was developed before we became the Government. I have a feeling that Deputy McCann was at that meeting with the Departmental officers who discussed this question and that it was agreed to have schools of the size the Deputy now complains of instead of having them built on bigger lines. I ask the Deputy to take it from me that the records show that the Department's inspector, at the request of the Chief Executive Officer of the Vocational Education Committee, attended a meeting on the 30th January to discuss plans for these schools. Let the Deputy knock it out of his head that it has anything to do with any measure of economy which I have initiated.
Comment on this
Our plans were submitted for schools to accommodate 360 pupils. We were later asked to revise these plans so that schools would be provided to accommodate only 120 pupils.
Comment on this
At no time was there a submission in regard to schools for 120 pupils. At all times we stuck to our submission that schools to accommodate 360 pupils should be provided.
Comment on this
I have pointed out that the Departmental records show that an inspector of the Department attended a meeting at which it was pointed out that while it was possible that schools might be required to accommodate 240 pupils, he estimated that the existing demands would be met if schools were built to accommodate about half that number. He suggested that schools designed to accommodate about 120 could be erected at once and that the number could be added to if and when required.
Comment on this
The Deputy alleged that this was being done as a measure of economy by the present Government. It was promulgated on the 30th January by people who certainly were not inclined towards economy.
Comment on this
I have not said it was accepted. It was proposed by the Departmental inspector who was acting on the instructions of the last Government on the 30th January.
The matter of the reduction in the duty on wine has been referred to. I want to make one simple comment about it. There is, of course, a certain form of propaganda which it is open to Deputies to make in that regard but let them remember that they carried the existing taxation on wine, as they found it in 1930, up to the year 1946 when they made a change. The duty on wine, as I leave it, is higher than what the last Government put it up to in 1946. They went on again to raise it in 1947 by what a Deputy here behind me called a blunder. We tried to retrieve that blunder which stopped the consumption of wine. It drove people from drinking wine and sherry to drinking spirits. There have been many complaints made about the bad social tendency developed in consequence. I have kept that in my consideration but I have also the consideration that the Government will get more money by reducing the duties. I estimate that I can get £250,000 more from the people who drink wine. The last Government failed to get that duty by putting the tax too high. If there is any attempt to represent this Budget as being a Budget for wine drinkers—and Deputy Allen is already preparing his propaganda—let him remember that the tax on champagne at the moment is higher far than it was between the years 1930 and 1946.
Under Deputy Allen's Budgets from 1932 to 1946 the duty on a bottle was 2/7; it is now 6/5. In 1946—I do not know why that was the year in which it was possible to get after the wine drinkers—the tax rose to 5/2; it is now 6/5. The only difference is that in 1947 the last Government put it up to 10/4 at which point it ceased to have any revenue value. We are now bringing it back, not to the point which would make it as cheap as the champagne which Deputy Allen could have in his palmiest days but to some reasonable figure at which we expect we shall get £250,000 extra by way of revenue. I suggest that that is not a matter which people should lament. There is no bad social tendency involved in it. It is a good social tendency inasmuch as I think it will keep young people from drinking spirits. When the last Government increased the tax they were not thinking of social tendencies but of some way in which they might get more money. They failed to get that money and I hope to get the money by a more reasoned view on this whole matter.
Quite a number of small points were referred to and certain features were paraded as putting impositions on the people. In particular, references were made to the extra contribution called for from those who are contributors to unemployment insurance and national health insurance. These calculations will be worked out in much more detail when the appropriate legislation comes before the House but I have made a calculation based on certain papers sent to me by the Department of Social Welfare. I have calculated that the cost to each contributor of this overloading will not be as much as 4d. per week. Do not forget that the tax remissions by the present Government on beer, stout and tobacco will involve a loss of £6,000,000 in revenue. The increase in the cost of a single packet of Players was 4d. I am imposing on the weekly contribution under this scheme the equivalent to the tax which the last Government put on one packet of Players. If anybody wants to complain, I suggest that people throughout the country will be better pleased to pay these increased contributions than to have to pay the heavy extra tax on tobacco. Deputy Allen said that it was a tax.
Comment on this
I think not. I think the employee would prefer to pay 4d. per week increased contribution than to have to pay 4d. extra for each packet of cigarettes which he purchases.
Comment on this
Similarly in regard to margarine and oatmeal. I am told that these proposals would put up the cost of living. I notice that when Deputies started off on a flight of the imagination about these things they had little regard for the fact. I want to let the House know what the situation is. The withdrawal of the subsidy on margarine and oatmeal will mean an addition to the cost-of-living index figure—that is the index figure our predecessors left us—of .0445 of a point. That is the increase in the cost of living. If you take the old cost-of-living figure—and I would rather take that—it means less than half of a point in the increase. Balance against that the very definite reduction in the cost of living occasioned by the reduction in the tax on tobacco and liquor of various types. People would weigh in the balance seriously some sum of less than £200,000 against a remission of £6,000,000 and tell me that on balance the country has lost and that the cost of living has been increased. I suggest that that phrase cannot be used in the light of the figures I have quoted.
Comment on this
I am not going to answer that question, for this reason, that I am not concerned immediately with the increase in the cost-of-living figure. I am concerned when it comes to certain calculations based on that figure. I am talking here about the cost of living. Does Deputy Allen seriously suggest that if, on the one hand, the Minister remits taxation costing £6,000,000 to the people and imposes, in return, taxes that put on £200,000——
Comment on this
The Deputy is back again on this bags of gold business. He ought to ask his own leader what gold there was from those industrialists whose circular I quoted. Before Deputy Allen goes off on any panegyric about the publicans and their power, let him not forget that in this House Deputy Lemass said that he would probably have remitted these taxes himself—these taxes on the few "boozers".
Comment on this
We did it as a Government. If Deputy Allen wants the quotation, he will get it at column 233 of the Official Debates of 9th March. I asked if Deputy Lemass was angry at our having remitted them and he said: "Not at all; we probably would have done it ourselves."
Comment on this
I wonder will Deputies opposite realise that it is rather a significant thing that a Government built up from five groups— Deputy Childers wanted to fix the number at about 12—were found to be unanimous on one thing, that these taxes should be remitted. Deputy Allen says that the deputy leader of my Party sold my Party to the publicans.
Comment on this
Did they sell out to the publicans? It is a significant thing that five groups coalescing in government found themselves unanimous on at least that one point. Will Deputy Allen pause and think why that unanimity was brought about? It was brought about because the people who form the Parties supporting this Government are responsive to public opinion. As we went through the country, we found that public opinion was very alert, very vocal and very argumentative about the hardship they found as a result of these taxes, and, in the different Parties, we felt the effect of these appeals and five different Parties made promises.
Comment on this
A highly-organised body which used plenty of money—that is what affected all of you.
Comment on this
There are people through the country who were shouting about this. The publicans have not got the power in their votes, if they have it in their money, but it was votes that shifted the Deputy from this side of the House to the other, and a lot of the votes were swayed by the feeling created throughout the country by the imposition of these taxes.
Comment on this
We are responsive to public opinion. We found ourselves coerced into accepting the appeals, and we carried out that promise. If the Deputy wants to measure bags of gold against bags of gold, let us get into a huddle with Deputy Lemass, or with whomever is treasurer of Fianna Fáil, and find out what accrued from the industrialists' circular, how many people subscribed and whether there was any consideration for it. Then we will know where we are with regard to selling out.
Comment on this
I have been asked about the Ferguson tractor. That is a question which is causing a great deal of anxiety. I know that farming interests feel that they have been prejudiced by the fact that the petrol tax has been raised and that those with Ferguson tractors which run on petrol have an extra amount to bear. It is not easy to find a way out. It is being examined. It seems to be clear that certain arrangements can be made with regard to unregistered tractors and agricultural tractors, really so-called. The difficulty is met when we come to the tractors used for work other than completely agricultural work, and, if anything is to be done with regard to the petrol supply to these, it opens up wide avenues for evasion and the full effect of the tax may be lost. However, Deputies can realise that, even though there are grave administrative difficulties, the matter is being very sympathetically considered. It may be that the administrative difficulty will prevent a successful issue to the considerations now going on, but the matter is being considered with a view to having it readjusted as quickly as possible.
Deputy Kissane was the only Deputy who was really angry about the increased petrol tax. He was particularly aggrieved because it would, as he said, and other Deputies joined him in this, put up the cost of living, because bus fares would rise. I see no reason for bus fares being increased because of the increased charge on petrol. I have in recent months given a concession to both the Great Northern Railway and Córas Iompair Éireann in respect of the importation of certain vehicles which, so far as my calculations go, save them either the whole, or nearly the whole, of the extra money they will have to spend on petrol, so that they are no worse off at the end of the two operations than they were at the start. Apart from all that, there is no case made yet that I have seen for raising fares to the travelling public, because of this extra tax being levied on petrol. As a matter of fact, I feel that the situation has been altered in favour of the main transport companies because this tax is a rather heavy impost upon the people who use cars for private use and these are the people of whom the transport companies complain. They say that it is these cars mainly which are taking traffic away from them. We have hit these people rather hard with this petrol tax and, to that extent, we have done Córas Iompair Éireann and the Great Northern Railway a considerable service, in addition to the fact that we have given them in another concession the whole, or very nearly the whole, of what this tax will mean in any year to these two companies.
Comment on this
What will it mean with regard to lorry transport?—for instance, the transport of farmers' produce?
Comment on this
By private haulier or Córas Iompair Éireann lorries? If it is Córas Iompair Éireann lorries, I have answered the point.
Comment on this
I come, eventually and finally, to one last word about old age pensions. I have outlined, very definitely only in skeleton form, what my colleague, the Minister for Social Services, proposes with regard to old age pensions. Before pretending to have any grievance about this matter, Deputies ought to wait and see what these plans are. They are going to involve the State in very considerable expenditure. It will not be less than £2,000,000 and can easily go to £2,500,000. Deputies facing me and pretending to lament that the date for the introduction of these reforms is postponed must remember that, as late as October last, they voted against any modification of the means test, and any lamentation from them is complete hypocrisy and would be understood to be such by the people who are likely to benefit under the plans which this Government are bringing forward. I had actually budgeted for more than £600,000 and I was told that I need not make any more provision because the difficulties of getting these books examined would delay the introduction of the easement of the conditions of these people.
Comment on this
Why does the increase in the rate of pension have to await the decision concerning the means test?
Comment on this
Because we want to have it brought in at once. Is the Deputy aggrieved because of that?
Comment on this
It was done last year. But on the 22nd October the Deputy, with others, voted against giving £500,000 to these people.
Comment on this
You were asked on the 22nd October to give an extra £500,000 and you threw it out. That was an extra £500,000 in a year. I am giving an extra £600,000 in part of a year. Do not let Deputy Allen try us too much now. Let him hold his tears until the £2,000,000 scheme comes forward. He will have his opportunity then.
Comment on this
I cannot estimate the figure at the moment, but it will not be less than £2,000,000. The full details have not been worked out yet.
Comment on this
Relating the £600,000 now to the present cost of £4,600,000, I do not know what the full increase to the old age pensioners will be.
Comment on this
The scheme which will be introduced here in the autumn will involve this Government in an expenditure of £2,000,000 in a full year and it is more than likely that it will eventually go to £2,500,000.
Comment on this
In addition to anything that was done by the last Government—over and above all that.
Comment on this
Certain grievances have been voiced here with regard to the teachers. We were told that no mention had been made of the teachers. Deputy O'Rourke mentioned that. I do not like to answer him because I gather that he is so to speak off-side at the moment as far as the teachers are concerned. I am not sure that Deputy Butler was not expelled from the organisation when the teachers' strike was under discussion here.
Comment on this
He must have been very close to it. So long as I do not break any trade union regulations by discussing these matters with the Deputies, I would ask them to wait awhile in that matter too. The Minister for Education has already made arrangements with the teachers covering quite a variety of their problems. Any number of details have been discussed by him with them and he has other proposals under consideration. He has agreed to have arbitration with the teachers on any matters that are outstanding. Naturally we have to await the result of that. I have no doubt that Deputy Butler, who is now so anxious to have something done immediately for the teachers, will hardly be able to possess his soul in patience until the autumn or until next year perhaps.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had been attentive to the conference that was held at Easter he would have observed that the Minister for Education was present at that conference, met the teachers there and had quite a satisfactory session with them and that he agreed immediately to the satisfaction of certain grievances—all costing the State money—and also agreed to establish certain other machinery to put an end to certain other difficulties.
With regard to the civil servants, things are not so far advanced. If Deputies feel aggrieved because there is no precise mention of either teachers or civil servants in this Budget they must possess their souls in patience. Certain promises have been made with regard to teachers and other people. We shall try to fulfil these promises as quickly as possible. I do not promise that they will all be attended to in the same year.
Comment on this
I was criticised on both sides of the House with regard to excess corporation profits tax. I have been reminded—though, indeed, nobody could remind me because my own phrases are still definitely ringing in my ears—of the comments I made about those people who had taken these excess profits and who had been allowed to take them. Deputy Dunne regretted the fact that we had not seen fit to reimpose it. Deputy O'Higgins indicated that I had asked traders to reduce prices and said that my appeal had not been met. That is a matter to which I want to return later. Deputy Keane, Deputy Hickey, Deputy Larkin and Deputy Con Lehane all asked me to reimpose the excess corporation profits tax. These appeals came in the main from this side of the House. Certain people on the Opposition Benches spoke about it. Those speakers on the Opposition Benches nearly talked me into reimposing it. I had decided not to reimpose it. I had decided that on a plan. If that plan does not work out then people ought to know where they are. The excess corporation profits tax was put on here at a time when there was a standstill Order put on wages. There was supposed to be a balance between the two. People were not to be permitted to have increases in their emoluments. At the same time prices were to be controlled and, in particular, profits were to be controlled.
The Minister for Finance, Mr. Seán T. O'Kelly, early in the war said that he would not allow anybody in this country to make money out of the exigencies of the war situation. Inside a year in this House he said that the Revenue Commissioners showed that people were making money and that he proposed to take it off them. He did not go very far with his proposal. Later on he put on his excess corporation profits tax but he did not make any effort to ensure that people would not make money out of the exigencies of the war. He allowed profits to be made. He fixed certain artificial standards and allowed traders to make more money than they had made in the standard year by 50 per cent. Why he did that I do not know. That situation continued until 1946 and then the excess corporation profits tax was entirely thrown off. It was thrown off on a definite statement made here by the then Minister for Finance that he expected prices to go down and he wanted those people who had been allowed these profits to realise that they had them as a fund and that out of that fund they must reduce prices. I want to say that those people still hold that money as a fund. It is, in fact, our money and we can get it if we want it. The money is still there. It is known how much is there. The returns upon which these people will have to pay can be produced. I made an appeal on the Vote on Account both in this House and in the Seanad that the people who had been let pile up these moneys should immediately reduce prices and give the consumers the benefit of those reduced prices. The moneys are considerable. I warned them in both Houses that if they did not agree to some such movement as that sterner methods would have to be taken with them. I indicated that while I was in opposition I might have been talking from certain newspaper returns, but I have definite information at my disposal now and I am speaking from records. They did not even pay me the compliment of even calling a meeting perfunctorily to discuss my proposal that they would be allowed to retain these profits if they reduced prices.
I want to address another exhortation to them now and I would like them to pay more attention to it. I still regard those moneys, because of the statement made by my predecessor in office, as due and owing to the community. If there is any excuse that can be made for the plan that was adopted of allowing industrialists to make 25, 30 or 50 per cent. more than they made in certain years it is so that they might have a fund to enable them to meet the difficulty that might arise if the market broke and they might have to sell in a cheapened market, having bought dear. They were allowed to have certain reserves for that. They have those reserves. I know the situation now. I am not talking from newspaper reports now. If necessary, machinery can be put in operation to get that excess corporation profits tax from those people back to the 31st January, 1947. I thought it was a better plan to ask those people to be good citizens, to take their prices and give the consumers of this country an opportunity of having a decent living by bringing the purchasing power of the £ back somewhere towards where it was in 1939 by reducing prices. I make that appeal again to all the traders of this country while there is still freedom to act and I warn them that if they do not act their inability to do so will draw corresponding good action from us. We can get the money. We know the money is there. I believe the money can be regarded as a debt owing to the community, because those people were told at the start of the war that they would not be allowed to make money out of the exigencies of the war situation, and yet they have done so.
I would prefer to break prices rather than to go out to get that money. If I want to get the money I would have to go back retrospectively to 1st January, 1947. I do not like doing that. Those people ought to know the precarious position they are in and that that money can be taken from them. If I sense the feeling of the Dáil from every side of the House correctly, I believe there is a considerable view that that money should be taken from them. I have not proposed in this Budget to take it from them. I would like to see them giving it back to the community in reduced prices. I would like to see a movement of breaking prices started. These people can help it by using the reserves they have in considerable amount. They can use these reserves to ease the price situation for the whole community. I hope they will do that. I hope they will have meetings to see how it can be done, and if I can assist them by attending any meeting I shall be glad to do so. If they want to know what information I have and how far my records go, I will tell them. I would like them to see what is known about the whole situation.
I decided for this Budget that it was better not to adopt the bad system of retrospective legislation, particularly when it amounted to taxes, for taking money from people. Undoubtedly, it would work hardship on certain people. It may be that the money has been divided or set out in dividends; it may be the people concerned would not have enough resources to meet the full impact of the excess profits tax reimposed as from 1st January, 1947. But that may be what is in store if I do not get prices reduced.
I think the community is entitled to a reduction in prices. So far as I can see from the materials coming in, prices have broken on the other side and people here in trade are getting semimanufactured or raw material at considerably less prices than those at which they used to get them. I see no reduction yet in the articles paraded in the shops and there should be a reduction
I want that aspect of the situation as I see it—being, as I phrased it myself, behind the curtain—seriously considered by the people whom I am addressing through this House. I would like to say another thing to all traders in this country. There is an attempt being made by propaganda efforts on the other side of the House to produce a sort of feeling of desperation. Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Lemass used the phrase that there is stagnation. I do not know why there should be. Deputy Childers asks—as if he did not know the answer—what is the Government's attitude towards tariffs and industrial activity. I thought I made that quite clear in the Seanad; I thought I had spoken enough there and that it did not require any further explaining. This Government wants industrial production. This Government will stand for every legitimate method of increasing and fostering industry.
I look back to the time when I started industrial development. I was criticised for not having big enough powers and not going fast enough. In any event, at that time we kept the cost of living down and we gave employment. I am not so sure that the headlong pace my successor set has been of any great benefit to the country. There have been three Governments. The policy of one was derided as being too slow and because there was not sufficient in the way of tariffs. The other policy we know. We came in here with no principle of changing the tariff policy. We may rationalise it. If we do, it will be done very carefully—the rationalisation.
The community has paid too dearly for the industries that have been started, or for industries to start which an attempt has been made, easily to see them fade away. A lot of the people's money has gone to build up industries and gone, unfortunately, to give enhanced profits to the people who did not act in a spirit of patriotism when they were grabbing business. I say that as regards some of them, not them all. Nobody in industry should have the slightest fear about a change of policy. The Government to which I formerly belonged started industrial activity and we have not shown any signs of changing it; we have not given any proof that we desire to change it. People in industry ought to know that they are well settled in that industry. There has not been a Government that had a free trade policy or anything approaching it. If any people ought to feel well secure about a particular programme, the industrialists should.
Are we not entitled to ask a return from them? If industry is regarded as something to be protected—and nearly everybody in the community accepts that as an axiom—is it right that the people in entirely tariffed industries should demand from the community the profits usually associated with highly speculative industry? I do not think it is right. I always understood that the returns people expected from business depended on the risk there was in the business into which they put their money. A man in a speculative business looks for a high return in order that he may quickly recoup his capital. Persons in what might be described as the gilt-edged type of business look for a low rate of profit and do not look to get back their capital so soon. Surely Irish industry is in the second category and we should ask the people in that industry to remit some part of the interest rates they are looking for and they should not be all out to get their capital reimbursed to them at once.
They know there will be no change in the situation with regard to industry. I think we are entitled to ask of them that they should not look for any return on their capital that they might like to find if there was any fear about the tariff movement breaking down. They have every security and they have the knowledge that it will not break down. I add that to the other exhortation I have addressed to traders. During the war they were enabled to pile up funds. I ask them to take all I have said to heart. If I am wrong in what I say I should like to have someone to argue against me. I would like to meet such people either in public or in private so that we could have this matter hammered out.
I put forward as a reasonable point of view what I have said here, that it would be a better thing that they should go back to lower prices than that we should get the money by way of taxation. We should leave it to them freely and decently to pass on this concession to the community through a reduction in prices. They should now break down the prices freely or a changed Government will meet the changed circumstances with regard to industrial tariffs. They are no longer entitled to say that they must make money as fast as ever they can because a change of Government might mean a reduction in their profits. We demand from them then a good, speedy and a considerable reduction in the prices of articles and if they do not give us that they will bring the other thing upon themselves. I do not like going back to the excess profits tax. I would much rather deal with the situation in the way I have described, but let these people labour under no mistake, because I am the only barrier between this House and the reimposition of the tax. From every quarter of this House I have had appeals made to me to reimpose it but I would appeal to the House to let my plan work for the present. But if prices are not broken down, then all the arguments which have been used round the House must have their effect and the trading community must expect that there will be a move in this House to reimpose either the excess profits tax or some better form of it and the excess moneys which they are making will be taken from them. I say a better form of the tax because the standard set by the excess profits tax was a fictitious standard. This standard was built up beyond which people were not allowed to go, but in effect people who were building up their business and who had not reached full capacity were taxed while it let people who had been profiteering before the war years get away with more money than they were in conscience entitled to. There will not be an excess profits tax but a tax that will cut deeper into the excessive profits which were made by those people during the war years and we will not be baulked by any artificial standard that was taken for the purpose of that tax.
I hope that the business community will realise that these arguments are not coming from me, speaking as a Minister in this House, but are coming from the people generally as they were expressed in the House. The business people in the main made quite well out of the war and now it is time for us to see the more benevolent side of their activities. We want them to get prices to drop and we shall see that they drop and, if not, we shall have more to say to it in the future.
I have been asked by, I think, Deputy Vivion de Valera about the loan and what use I am making of the last loan. I have said several times in the course of this debate, by way of interjection, and I am trying to make clear to the people of this country, that I have no money to spare. A £12,000,000 loan has been got since this Government took office. All that loan has not been paid in but £10,900,000 has been paid in. I have not a penny of that money left for future development. That £10,900,000 has had to be spent to pay the debts left to me by the last Government.
Comment on this
Can the Minister not give them now? Does not everybody in this House know that you have only borrowed under Government control?
Comment on this
Rural electrification, electricity generation, post office development, all the phones which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is now putting in—these are what you call debts, these are what you call extravagance. They were paid out of moneys under Government control, Departmental funds.
Comment on this
The money went to pay commitments which were already entered into. The suggestion was made at the time when the loan was being floated that I was borrowing against deficits which I was going to make and that I was, therefore, providing a fund. I would like to say that if that were my intention I have been frustrated in it and I have no money left.
Comment on this
So the Minister has made no provision for the borrowings with which he is balancing his Budget?
Comment on this
Very little of the type of enterprise in which the Government money is sunk is really reproductive. I think that it is true to say, with the exception of the Shannon scheme— the Shannon scheme proper—and certain advances made through the Local Loans Fund, nothing else can be really rated as remunerative, financially speaking. The cost of rural electrification is being borne by the Exchequer.
Comment on this
If I had been in office for the last 15 years the ground would have been prepared for rural electrification before now. The Shannon scheme was completed in 1932 and I think it was 1946 before you began to think of rural electrification.
Comment on this
The report was prepared and could have been furnished but it was not acted upon until 1946. It was not called for until late in the Deputy's period as Minister. The officials were prepared to furnish the information about rural electrification but they were not asked for it. You did not try to establish rural electrification as a project until later still.
Comment on this
I do not want to criticise rural electrification but I have no money left out of that loan with which to finance any deficit. It is already absorbed by commitments which my predecessor left to me—I use the word "commitments" as being a lighter word than "debts". The people of this country in fact subscribed to the present Government £12,000,000 but £10,900,000 of that money has been already involved in commitments so if anyone thinks that I am in an easy position and that I have plenty of money then he is mistaken.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell the House if any of the Departmental funds from which these moneys were borrowed and which he has now repaid were invested in securities outside the country?
Comment on this
Could the Minister tell us whether any of the money has gone into sterling securities?
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy is getting at there at all. If the Deputy wants to know how much of the moneys——
Comment on this
I want to know if the Departmental moneys, which were advanced to the Government and which now, according to the Minister, have been repaid, have been reinvested?
Comment on this
I put a very small portion of Departmental funds into the loan, something short of £500,000. However, the Deputy can ask me these more detailed questions later, if he wants to pursue this matter.
Many points have been raised here of a general type that I would like to reply to but I have been too long at this already. Deputy Timoney raised the point that direct taxation is a better tax than indirect taxation. Of course, theoretically, everybody agrees with that. The only difficulty is when you come to definition, trying to find out what is your direct tax, what is the one that cannot be passed on. But we do know that during the period of office of the last Government, indirect taxation was very definitely advanced. The tax that people were made to pay without one being able to parade before the public what they were paying, of course, was very seriously increased. Some of the taxes that were levied at the ports by means of customs duty were very heavy indeed. I think if they had been proposed as definite taxes of the direct type, certainly years ago, they would have raised such protest that they would have had to be abandoned. To those who are investigating that matter with a view to finding out what percentage of the money is levied by direct taxation and what by indirect taxation, I cannot give a direct answer but I can assist Deputy Timoney, if he wants to pursue that matter, with certain figures, but be will have to take them with reservations.
I think it was Deputy McCann who said that the present Government, or I in particular, have no mandate for retrenchment. I suggest I have. I spoke on retrenchment. When so many others are trying to make antagonism between the Parties by saying that one wants to retrench and the other to expand, I want to say that I do not think these statements are incompatible. I want retrenchment on certain things. I am not aiming at retrenchment for retrenchment's sake. I want to retrench on certain unessentials, certain extravagances, certain wasteful ways of spending money, in order to have moneys, which can be levied off the people of the State without doing too much harm, available for constructive work. It was put up to me that one of the groups that help to form the Government at this moment were very loud in their demands for increased expenditure for constructive purposes. I approve of their ideals and aims. I do not know if we have enough money to carry them out but I believe —I stated in this House my belief— that coincident with that, I can run a policy of retrenchment. I think it is surely worth while cutting down on these extravagances like the short-wave station and the transatlantic air service in order to be able to build up something that will give a return. Nobody ever said these things would give a return. I do not know whether they were going to be classified as social services or what category they were going into but they never could give a return. The only return that has ever been suggested is in the nature of prestige.
Comment on this
Defence! I am glad the Deputy almost breathes that and does not say it aloud. He dare not say aloud that that is an item of defence.
Comment on this
I enumerated items. I said that in respect of not one of those had the Government a mandate for retrenchment. Certainly not with regard to the Garda Síochána in the City of Dublin or mineral exploration.
Comment on this
They have stopped recruitment? That is called retrenchment? I know I am faced with this situation by my opponents, that they had run this State at the ideal expenditure, with the ideal number of men in the Army and in the Garda, with the ideal services in the air and by way of broadcasting and that any attempt to shift a penny piece or a single man out of those services is destruction. Of course, that is a clear view. It is a rather arrogant view. It is almost in line with the arrogance that said that people were heading for doom in this country if they voted the late Government out. It is surely arrogance to say that no change can be made in the Book of Estimates that were built up to £70,500,000, without incurring serious risk to the State.
Comment on this
But they are going to get far more than the Deputy would have given them if his Party were still the Government. Is not that a satisfactory answer to the question? I do want the House to understand that if I pursue, and I hope to pursue, a policy of retrenchment, I do not regard that as destructive and I do not regard it as in any way contradictory of the other policies of reconstruction and development, of which I myself approve and have often spoken about on platforms. I think it is possible to do both but I do not think it would be possible to find the money for some of the things that were desired, some of the things that were classed as socially desirable, unless savings were made on this hugely inflated bill.
I have apologised in the Budget speech, I want to apologise again, that the economies that have been made so far do not amount to very much. Lump them all together, even putting the phrase economies on certain things that are really expenditure, there is only £6,000,000 out of £70,500,000. That is very little. If I cannot do better by this time next year I will let Deputies accuse me of failure. I think it can be done and I think better economies can be made without at all stopping any plans that there are for development, reconstruction and production. In fact, I think you cannot get the second desirable object unless I am aided to a successful conclusion in my efforts with regard to economies. I am going to pursue these and I believe that they are covered by mandates. There are mandates for both things and even both things to be done simultaneously and there is no incompatibility between them.
I have asked at the beginning what would the Fianna Fáil Budget be if they were running the State instead of this Government. I say that I was faced with a gap of £7,000,000 odd which, I have pointed out, when starting this speech to-night, should be really regarded as £10,500,000. That is only on the £70,500,000 in the Estimates and the Central Fund services as they are. Deputy Lemass has said he would want to spend more. He also said he would want to budget for a real surplus. I suppose a couple of millions.
Comment on this
It is on your own thesis you say you would budget for a genuine surplus. Then there would be no economies. The £6,000,000 would not have been saved. There would be none of that. Suppose timber was still rolling into the country and there was a further subsidy required. The bill would have soared. Deputies ought to pride themselves on the mood in which they have been speaking in the House. They ought to be taking pride in my suggestion that the bill that would be put before the taxpayer would be well beyond what I am presenting. How would they have found the money? Beer, stout, entertainment, tobacco and income-tax— these are the things that Deputy Lemass said were the only available sources of taxation. Have Deputies any idea in their heads what the bill would be?
What extra tax would there have to be, what extra tax on beer and stout, on cigarettes, entertainment and income-tax? It would be something phenomenal. That is the contrast I would like to get, as between that and the proposals I have, with my small little efforts at economy and my anxiety to save the people of the country heavier burdens than I think they should be asked to bear. In addition to all that, if taxation had risen— I think it was bound to rise in what my opponents were bound to do—there would have been no chance of getting prices down. If the cost of government goes up, there is certainly an added item in the cost of trade and business, so there was need to get prices down. I have tried to keep the cost of government as low as I can, for a variety of reasons, but possibly the biggest reason is an effort to aid the trading community and the business community generally to lower their prices, as I believe that is what the country wants and, if they can do that, we can get the purchasing power of the £ in some way restored to a decent level.
Finally, I have been jibed that the present Government is helping to keep up a Party, the leading members of which are Communists. There is very little charity in the people who make that sort of remark, without having any proof or attempted proof of what they have said. There is an obligation of charity on all public men and there is a special obligation——
Comment on this
I did not. What I have said about the Locke Tribunal is on record and I stand over it. I say it was good comment and, as far as it was comment, it was backed by evidence. Deputy MacEntee is great at talking about Communism. He must know that to attempt to apply that phrase to people of this country is dastardly.
Comment on this
Such an attempt cannot have any effect other than to degrade people. It is definitely defamatory.
Comment on this
To say a man is a Communist means in this country that he should be ostracised from community life.
Comment on this
It means certainly, as far as people of the Church to which I belong are concerned, that you have no touch with any such persons. Is that what the Deputy means when he says that sort of thing, in attempting to drive a wedge between the ranks here?
Comment on this
Will the Minister ask the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs about it? He is the only man who alleged to me that there were Communists in the Labour Party, before the election.
Comment on this
I believe they could all be included in our short-wave station. I want Deputy MacEntee to realise that nothing he says in the way of jibes about Communism will have any effect upon this association of four or five groups of people. We have different views on certain political and economic matters. Some of us stress some points of policy more than others, but we all have certain things in common. We are against the programme the last Government had, of establishing a bureaucratic control over life. Deputy Dillon has said, with regard to agriculture, that he wants the inspectors to keep outside the farms down the country. We want that policy all over the country as far as we can. We want to get away from the idea of people being harried, persecuted and even investigated, by inspectors and investigators of different types. We feel that freedom of life is something that is desirable. Communists do not believe in that. We want to give that freedom and we believe we can give it. As I have said before—though my words have been parried here, as might have been expected in the House today—we want to get away from the idea that people have to be put on some sort of dole, under what are called social services but which are being magnified to the point that every man, from the cradle to the grave, will be "done well by" and that there will be a good little group of persons in control of a Government, with a hoard of civil servants and inspectors, to see that people behave—and if they do not behave along the proper political lines, they will not get the emoluments that the State provides for them. We do not believe that is freedom to live a proper life.
Comment on this
The Deputy's Party operated as if they did. Deputy Childers, in a speech, claimed that the only Government worth anything in these times was the paternalistic arm of the State, operating through a well-trained group of civil servants. He claimed that as his aim when speaking in Cork about two years ago, and he certainly seemed to be expressing the view of the Government. They had this view I expressed before, that if you can control certain things—ration books, family allowances, old age pensions, and that sort of thing—you may control votes and the greater the control you can impose on these little subventions to life, the more sure you can make your political power.
Comment on this
It is a lecture on what I call a Christian concept of life, but it has its base in charity. It is expected of the human being that he will develop to the full height of his personality and will make his way in the world for himself and will be allowed to do that by being given a good wage and having the wage level attended to and not so much the social services level attended to. Then you get freedom and a better life.
Comment on this
I want to read the Deputy another document. I have a quotation here from a very famous document about working-men's wages:
"If a workman's wages be sufficient to enable him to maintain himself, his wife and his children in reasonable comfort, he will not find it difficult, if he be a sensible man, to study economy, and he will not fail, by cutting down expenses, to put by some little savings and thus secure a small income. Nature and reason alike would urge him to this. We have seen that this great labour question cannot be solved save by assuming as a principle that private ownership must be held sacred and inviolable. The law, therefore, should favour ownership, and its policy should be to induce as many as possible of the humbler class to become owners."
That is taken from the Encyclical on "The Condition of the Working Classes," issued in 1891.
Comment on this
I am addressing it to my left and to the whole House. I am putting it forward as an ideal.
Comment on this
I do not think I will find any lack of recruits to that programme. That was produced in 1891.
Comment on this
There are men sitting on those benches who have declared they want to abolish private property —and they are supporting that Government.
Comment on this
In opposition to this, which I think is sheer dishonesty on the part of Deputy MacEntee in trying to make people believe that the Government is permeated by Communistic tendencies. I want to give him that as a counterpoint. I would like to go further. That document was 40 years later dealt with again and the new document stated:
"Every effort therefore must be made that at least in future a just share only of the fruits of production be permitted to accumulate in the hands of the wealthy, and that an ample sufficiency be supplied to the workingmen. The purpose is not that these become slack at their work, for man is born to labour as the bird to fly, but that by thrift they may increase their possessions and by the prudent management of the same may be enabled to bear the family burden with greater ease and security, being freed from that handto-mouth uncertainty, which is the lot of the proletarian. Thus they will not only be in a position to support life's changing fortunes, but will also have the reassuring confidence that, when their own lives are ended, some little provision will remain for those whom they leave behind them."
In the same document in which those words were written that paragraph finished in this way:
"These ideas were not merely suggested, but stated in frank and open terms by Our Predecessor. We emphasise them with renewed insistence in this present Encyclical; for unless serious attempts be made, with all energy and without delay to put them into practice, let nobody persuade himself that the peace and tranquillity of human society can be effectively defended against the forces of revolution."
That is 1914. I am glad to be able to read it to a Dáil Eireann of 1948. I want to tie up with what I have said the statement that a just share only of the fruits of production be permitted to accumulate in the hands of the wealthy, and I would like to add a passage from a Papal Encyclical to my own words. Traders, businessmen and industrialists in this country will understand what I am driving at. I ask them to reduce prices. This Encyclical adds that unless people attempt, without delay, to put these principles into practice, "let nobody persuade himself that the peace and tranquillity of human society can be effectively defended against the forces of revolution". Deputy MacEntee wants to suggest that there are Communist forces operating towards revolution in this country. I refer him to this Papal Encyclical. Let me say that we are asking those who have accumulated certain profits to pay wages at a point that the workingman will have a little comfort and will provide some little property for him. Those are the most effective arguments against revolution. In that way we will be able to provide the peace and tranquillity of human society in this country.
I believe the Budget I have produced is an effort along these lines. I believe that when I cut out mere extravagance and get this country more precisely able to move along a path of reconstruction and profit we will more rapidly and speedily put into effect the principles of that Encyclical. That is the mood in which I want this Budget to be taken. In so far as it falls short of it it is a bad Budget. In so far as it leads anywhere towards it it is better than any of my predecessors could have done, although that is not saying much.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?