We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 29—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 1–141 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Browne

When the debate was adjourned, I was dealing with the poultry population and egg production. I am satisfied that, with the method adopted by the Minister, he will have got over his difficulties in a very short time, and definitely by the end of this year. With regard to the pig industry, it will take the Minister some time to bring the industry back to anything like the condition in which it was some time prior to the emergency, and I believe that some sort of encouragement by way of a loan—I was going to say a free grant, but I confine it to a loan —should be given to farmers, because it will encourage farmers, and especially small farmers, to get back to the foundation of the industry, the keeping of a breeding sow. It may involve anything from £8 to £10, but I suggest that there should be some scheme under which a farmer could borrow that sum and under which the Minister could see to it that the money was used for the purpose for which it was borrowed, for the purpose of keeping a breeding sow.

Comment on this

Or if a sow were provided on credit for the farmer?

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

That certainty would be one of the ways, but I do not like it. There was a breeding sow subsidy scheme some years ago and it did not work successfully at all, because the terms were not at all suited to farmers. There were all kinds of regulations and orders, and the farmer did not know when he was going to get the sow; when he got her, he did not know how long he was to keep her; and when he had her for two or three years, he had to dispose of her, so that he did not know exactly where he was. I should like to see some scheme whereby the farmer who is not in a position to put in a breeding sow, would be able to get a loan repayable in three or four years—perhaps four years would be better.

Comment on this

Six litters of bonhams to pay a £10 loan.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

It would be at least a year or a year and a half before he got any return. By means of a loan the farmer who could not afford to put in a breeding sow would be encouraged to do so. The loan would be repayable in four yearly premiums, starting from the year following the year in which he borrowed the money. In that way, I believe it would be possible to bring back an industry which existed for years, without assistance from anybody and which was capably worked by the small farmers. The Minister is giving freedom to the farmers in the matter of different methods of working and I should like him at the first opportunity to restore the connection which originally existed between the farmers and the pig factories.

If the farmers and the factories get working together as in pre-emergency days, I believe that the pigs will come back, and in a very short time, to the level at which they were five or ten years prior to that emergency. The factories, the machinery and the workers are there. The farmers are the suppliers, and there would be no necessity for the factory, if the farmer were not in pig production. If we could achieve a position in which all the activities connected with pig production were left as between the factory and the farmer, I believe we could achieve success.

I am very glad that the Minister has taken under his Department this matter of field drainage. Field drainage is very important and in practically every part of Ireland, even on the best land, field drainage schemes could be undertaken with advantage. I believe the Minister will make a great success of it, and, from what I can hear, he will have a job in coping with the numbers of applications he will get. He will possibly find that in a very short time these applications will come in as the applications under the farm buildings scheme came in.

Comment on this

They cannot come in too fast or too many.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

The Minister will get plenty of them, and I feel sure that they will be a great success, because wherever they are started, they are the talk of the area.

Comment on this

Only ten of them have started in the whole of County Mayo.

Comment on this

There is a little trouble in finding men who will work on them.

Comment on this

Schemes to the number of 49 had to be abandoned because there were no men to be found to do them.

Comment on this

The fact is that ten only have been started.

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Browne was referring to farm improvements.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

No, field drainage schemes.

Comment on this

Anyway, you cannot get the men to work on them.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

With regard to the farm improvements scheme and the farm buildings scheme, I take it that the farm improvements scheme is being continued and that there is no restriction?

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

It has been suggested by Deputies on the other side that these schemes are not in operation. I take it that they are in operation and any farmer who has a scheme in hands for the past 12 months can continue it.

Comment on this

Certainly. Give them plenty of rope; the more they take, the higher they will hang.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

The second point I wish to raise in connection with farm building schemes is the erection of poultry houses. I would like the Minister, when concluding, to give us some idea of the position, because in my part of the country and in County Mayo, the people are keenly interested in the erection of poultry houses and they want to get on with the job straight off the reel.

Comment on this

The county committee of agriculture have all the funds at their disposal that they can possibly spend.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

For the erection of poultry houses?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

It is between us it is.

Comment on this

Tell us about the circular that was sent out in March.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

The farmers of this country know when their bread is buttered and they know when their bread is not buttered. Every farmer knows where he stands as regards the future plan and the future price for his cattle, sheep, poultry, eggs, potatoes and everything he can grow on the land. There is a guaranteed price for potatoes of £10 13s. 6d. a ton from October to February, and £11 8s. 6d. a ton after February. That is a better price than the farmer got for potatoes for the last five or six years. The guaranteed market for potatoes will help the farmer to produce and raise pigs. If the farmer saw a danger of not having a market for potatoes, he might go out of potato growing. He now has a market for potatoes in bulk and if he does not wish to take advantage of that, he can go into pig production. Therefore, the guaranteed market for the potato crop is one of the greatest things the Minister has done.

I want to join with other Deputies from this side of the House in congratulating the Minister on the terms of his agreement and on the plan. He has given new hope to the farmer and, as far as I can see, every farmer will make up his mind as to what he will do and the Minister can rest assured that they are going to take full advantage of the schemes he has put before them.

Comment on this

The Minister has changed his mind so often in connection with matters affecting agricultural policy that it is difficult to know to what he is going to stick. The last speaker suggested that the arrival of the Minister in his present Department meant new life and hope for the farmers. It certainly means new life and hope for the ranchers because, if there is one thing that is consistent in an otherwise inconsistent Minister it is his policy to make this country a heaven for ranchers and to reverse the whole economy of this State so that we will be changed from our former position into a cattle ranch for the production of cattle for the British market at the British price. That is not only my view of the Minister's policy. It appears to me that all his life, or at least as long as he has been in this House, the Minister has persistently and continually thrown slurs at and discouraged tillage in this country.

He suggested to Deputy Allen to-day that he did not make the remarks he was alleged to have made about people who use horses on their land for the purpose of tillage, but it is on the record of this House, on the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture in 1944, that he poured scorn on the holding of ploughing matches throughout the country and he entertained us by painting a picture of, as he said, country yokels plodding after horses at ploughing matches to the applause of the former Minister for Agriculture, and he suggested—it is on the record of this House—that you might just as well have a competition between nail makers in this country in producing hand-made nails as to have ploughing competitions. I do not know how that could be interpreted other than as a suggestion that it was absurd for the farmers of our country to till or to have horses, that it was absurd to endeavour to encourage the healthy competition that we had throughout the ploughing matches that were held over the last number of years.

Comment on this

With horses.

Comment on this

With horses. The Minister evidently sneers at horses, which is a very strange view in a man who should be familiar with the West of Ireland. Does he imagine that we can have ten-ton tractors driving across the bogs of Mayo or Roscommon or Galway or any of the western counties?

Comment on this

Oh, no. Suitable tractors.

Comment on this

That is the Minister's view. I do not mind the Minister's flights of imagination about ploughing matches, but what I do mind is the fact that he has always consistently opposed any tillage policy in this country and every public utterance of his, even since he became Minister, has gone further in that direction. He has resurrected his old slogans about its being a "cod" to grow wheat and a "cod" to set beet and he has set out on this campaign of turning this country into a ranch to supply cattle to Britain, culminating in the recent trade agreement that has got a certain amount of publicity recently. Evidently outside this country the present Minister for Agriculture is also regarded as a rancher's advocate and presumably it is the policy both of the Minister and of the Government of which he is a member.

A publication that is generally rather impartial for a British newspaper gives an account of the Minister's visit to the other side in connection with the recent trade agreement. In the issue of News Review for June 24th they say:—

"Irishmen are basically either farmers or ranchers, tillers or cattleraisers, and as such are interested in raising wheat and farm produce for home consumption or beef and dairy produce for export. The farmers are smallholders, not particular about a connection with Britain, but the ranchers have great tracts of grazing land and look on Britain as a customer with whom they should have the closest ties.

Under 15 years of Eamon de Valera's rule, the farmers were on top. Wheat, beet and potatoes were the basis of Éire's agricultural economy, and the cattle-ranchers had lean years. But with John Costello as Prime Minister, and James Matthew Dillon as Minister for Agriculture, the ranchers are coming back into their own."

They proceeded to say that last week an Irish delegation arrived in London on behalf of the ranchers of this country.

Comment on this

You know who publishes News Review?

Comment on this

From the terms of the trade agreement, perhaps it is unnecessary——

Comment on this

You know who publishes News Review?

Comment on this

——to stress that it was on behalf of the ranchers of this country that the Minister went over.

Comment on this

You know who publishes News Review?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The Communist Party in Great Britain.

Comment on this

The Minister should wave his hat in applause of News Review because News Review gives a little bit further down in connection with the Minister himself.

Comment on this

I want no praise from them.

Comment on this

The article says of the Minister:—

"At war's outbreak he was the only member of the Dáil to oppose openly Mr. de Valera's neutrality policy, and come out wholeheartedly on the side of Britain."

They also proceed to state in the same article:—

"If Mr. Dillon can come to terms with Britain, increased imports of eggs, bacon and beef should lead to the progressive raising of the ration-level, the doubling of the meat ration within two years, and its abolition by 1953."

I think the Minister went so far as to announce that when he was over there to the Pressmen there——

Comment on this

You think quite wrong.

Comment on this

"Unless, of course, the tables are turned in a future Irish election and the farmers get the ranchers on the run again."

The ranchers are evidently firmly entrenched behind the present Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

That language comes trippingly to the Deputy's tongue.

Comment on this

And outside people take the view that we are now compelled to take, that the Minister's sole concern is with the ranchers of this country. Wheat growing and beet growing, according to the Minister, as a policy are a "cod" and we must get back by relying solely on the amount of cattle we will export to Britain, and we are tied now under this trade agreement hand and foot to give our produce to that one market. I wonder does the Minister realise the position that he has walked the country into on this agreement. I do not want to go into it in detail at this stage, but there was never a time when a Minister for Agriculture went to make a bargain on the other side and had a greater opportunity of ensuring the agricultural future of this country, by insisting that the type of economy that suits us be carried out by them.

The Minister talks about an unlimited market. Of course, there is, through the British people being half starved and having been so for some time. They are prepared to take our eggs, beef, butter and bacon, and anything else we can give them to raise their ration. It is equally true that the same is the position all across Europe. The Minister is well aware that Europe was denuded of cattle during the war years. This is the time when the Minister— if he had this idea in mind that we should kill as many of our own cattle as we possibly could—should have insisted on getting a greater quota of canned meat into the British market.

Comment on this

I did; I doubled the quota.

Comment on this

The Minister got 10,000 tons. That was only going back to the status quo the year before last, when the quota was 10,000 tons.

Comment on this

The Party opposite lost it and I got it back.

Comment on this

The amount of the quota was reduced—due, in the main, through the scarcity of tin for canning as the Minister knows. The position is now that the Minister has got 10,000 tons. He had an opportunity, now that they want our stuff, and are crying out for it, of endeavouring to break that Birkenhead ring that, irrespective of what Government is in office, will try to insist on our live stock going out on the hoof. He had an opportunity of getting them to this position of increasing our volume of exports of meat in tins and thereby creating employment here and securing the various offals that would be useful for other industries as well as the hides that would give further employment.

Comment on this

There is an unlimited market for tinned meat.

Comment on this

If the Minister would keep his mouth shut we would get on a little quicker. Some people fill up so much with their own importance that they swell and swell and ultimately, like the frog in the fable, they burst; and I am expecting the explosion from the Minister at any moment.

Comment on this

You can ship all the canned meat you wish.

Comment on this

The Minister may keep quiet until I say what I have to say. There never was a position when we here, or our representatives for this State, could more favourably insist on getting an agreement between this country and Britain which would be more suitable to our economy than there is at present. They were never in so much need of our produce as they are at present. If the Minister had an eye on the future he had an opportunity—himself and his colleagues—on this occasion to increase the quota of canned meat we could send out.

Comment on this

There is no quota.

Comment on this

The Minister was busier endeavouring to ensure that they would get people cheaper food from this country than he was on the question of our economy.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I direct the Deputy's attention to the fact that there is no quota or restriction of any sort, kind or description on the export of canned meat? He may send 10,000,000 tons, if he wishes to.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

The Deputy is going on saying there is, when there is not.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not a point of order, obviously.

Comment on this

The Minister is well aware that his own agreement sets out the figure of 10,000 tons that we are to sell them. That is the amount we are entitled to give them. The Minister knows that the amount of tin we will get to produce the tins to send out that 10,000 tons comes from there. The Minister knows we are rationed in that way, that unless we get the tins we cannot send out the canned meat. The Minister need not try to hoodwink the House by suggesting that we have an unlimited market for canned meat. It is in the Minister's agreement, as far as the announcements in the Press go, that 10,000 tons is the quota we have there. The Minister, when replying, will presumably get an opportunity to explain that away, if he can.

Comment on this

I should not, because it is not in order, but I will.

Comment on this

Our whole economy has been put back to the position it was in away back in 1929, 1930 and 1931. The Continental buyers are cut out of our market and we are forced, whether we like it or not, to send our stuff to the British market. That is all right at the moment. In addition, the Minister has created this new business of a third grade that was unknown before his signing the agreement.

Comment on this

Are we discussing the trade agreement or not?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The trade agreement is not to be discussed, except in so far as it affects agricultural produce.

Comment on this

On a point of order, in the Minister's opening statement here, he referred to the trade agreement and what it was going to do for this country. There were certain heads of that agreement published. The question of meat prices was published in detail in last Saturday's daily papers.

Comment on this

That is right, Sir.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy not be in order in referring to a matter that is public property, the matter of meat prices?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not right for me to say how far a Deputy can go, as it was decided that the agreement as such was not open for discussion. The Deputy went a considerable distance.

Comment on this

I think you said a moment ago that it was not open for discussion except in so far as it affected agricultural policy.

Comment on this

That is as far as I want to go in discussing it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister did not go very far in discussing it at the outset.

Comment on this

Surely, I am entitled to assert that it has always been the position, as far as the relationships between this country or any other country and Britain are concerned, that the British always bought in the cheapest market available to them. They are buying from us now, not because they are "an old and valued customer", as the Minister would like to describe them, but because they can get the stuff here. That is the only reason. It is not for any love of us that the British are taking our stuff, whatever love may be manifested on the Minister's behalf in presenting our stuff to Britain cheaper than he is prepared to give it anywhere else. I never heard of a countryman going to a fair and proclaiming to the world that he was prepared to sell his cow to the lowest bidder and not to the highest bidder. The Minister, before going across, thought fit to do that. He has such a great regard for the people across the water that he would prefer to sell the stuff more cheaply to them than he would to any other country.

The day will come when the country will seriously regret the Minister's view. It is true that, for the next four years, we can anticipate world shortages for the articles we are able to produce and export as agricultural produce, but immediately that the British can get stuff cheaper elsewhere they will do with us the same as they always did. We will have either to sell our surplus produce to them at depressed prices or they will not take anything from us. According to the Minister and the policy he is adopting and pursuing, we will now be committed to changing our whole economy back again into that one single channel. That would leave us solely dependent on the whim of any British Minister for Agriculture. It would put us back in the position that, immediately, for instance, the Dutch were able to produce cheaper eggs our prices would be depressed as they always have been. I do not intend to go into egg prices—that question was discussed by a number of other Deputies— except to say this, that nobody should imagine that on this question of poultry we are the only people going in for intensive egg production. The scheme that is being fostered by the Minister in connection with poultry and egg production in the country comes direct from the Dutch, and it is correct, I think, to say that the British are financing the Dutch to a larger extent than they are financing this country.

Comment on this

Do not blame me for that. Deputy Smith made that agreement.

Comment on this

I do not mind who made it. I would ask the Minister to try and contain himself until I have finished. What I was saying was that the same poultry and egg scheme is being fostered by the British in those other countries, and that immediately they can get cheaper eggs and a sufficient quantity of them from those other countries they will take them. Immediately that position arises, irrespective of our production here, the British will stop buying our eggs if they find they are dearer than the eggs they can get from other countries. I want to point out to the House the great danger there is of committing the country to a long-term policy of that kind. It would put us back into the position in which we would have to rely solely on one buyer and that buyer could inflate or deflate prices at his whim as it suited his book to do so.

The question of dairy cows has been dealt with at some length by other speakers. I want to say that dairy herds, particularly in the vicinity of country towns, are disappearing. The question of milk supplies to country towns is becoming a headache for the people who live in them. I think one of the great difficulties is that of getting agricultural labour. I am not dealing now so much with the creamery areas because milk production in those areas is made easy for the producers. They leave their milk in a churn at the gate and it is collected from them by the creamery. That type of man can produce when it suits him. The cows give a good supply of milk during the summer season when they are being grass fed. At the approach of winter he can sell off his surplus cows and even if he does it will not interfere very much with the kind of economy he practises.

The ordinary dairy farmer who is supplying milk to the country towns cannot do that. He has to maintain his customers the whole year round. No matter what it may cost him, he has to keep up his supply during the winter months. That may involve him in great loss, because the price that he is getting for his milk during the winter period may not be sufficient to cover his outgoings. It is also true to say that that type of man has to employ agricultural workers to milk his cows and to keep them the whole year round. He has to pay them well because the conditions under which they work are altogether different from those that prevail in the creamery areas. The men have to be out at 6 o'clock in the morning to milk the cows so that they may be able to leave on their delivery rounds at 8 o'clock.

There is another big difficulty which this type of milk producer is faced with. If his cows go dry during the winter months, when prices are at their maximum, he has to replace them by fresh milkers, irrespective of price, because if he fails to do so he is going to lose his customers. Therefore, during the months of November, December and January, when milch cows fetch the highest price, this man has to buy them irrespective of what the price may be. All these things contribute to increase his costings. The result of all that has been that it is steadily but surely driving those people out of milk production. That position is quite apparent in various country towns, and from what I have heard, the situation is becoming more or less universal.

I think that situation is dangerous and that it is a bad sign for agriculture as a whole, because it is unnecessary for me to stress how much the dairy farmer is the keystone in the agricultural fabric of the State. A case has been made for increasing the price to the dairy farmers who sell their milk to the creameries. I think that is a case that should be listened to. As I have said, I do not propose to deal with the creamery side of this question, but I do say that a very good case can be made for the man who is supplying milk to country towns because his costings are certainly far more, and his difficulties far greater, than those of the ordinary dairy farmer.

It is true to say that farming as a whole is an expert job. I am one of those who believe that, if possible, we should have more agricultural colleges than we have. We should have some method whereby the farmer's son who intends to remain on the land should be technically trained and fitted for that calling. I think it is agreed by most observers that what is mainly responsible for the success of our competitors from Holland and Denmark is that 90 per cent. of their young people who attend agricultural schools or colleges go back to the land. I do not know how far it would be possible, in the case of our rural schools, to give the curriculum not only an agricultural bias, but to arrange for the holding of regular courses in each parish each year so as to keep the young men, who intend to make a living from agriculture on their fathers' holdings, abreast of the different developments in agriculture.

I am not so much concerned with the larger agricultural colleges, because, invariably the people who attend them and who, ultimately, take a degree in agriculture, do not intend to go back to the land. They intend to make their livelihood either as teachers or in some other job away from the land. I think the Minister should direct his attention to the provision of educational facilities in agriculture for our young people who intend to live on the land and to make farming their vocation in life. These are the people that I am principally interested in. I do not know how far it may be possible for the Minister to provide for them the facilities which I suggest.

I notice that recently the Minister's Department sent out a circular in connection with the propagation of grass seeds. I think that is an idea that could only have originated in the mind of the present Minister for Agriculture. We are solemnly asked in the County Mayo to produce these experimental grass seeds on the mental hospital farm tended by the lunatics resident in the mental hospital, and I presume that the other counties throughout the country got the same request. The Minister should be aware that the lands attached to mental institutions throughout the country are made use of by the authorities from the point of view of occupational therapy for the patients and the crops produced on these lands are produced by patients who may one day work on them and pull them up the next unless they are carefully watched.

Of all the people to ask to propagate grass seeds, to ask unfortunate mental patients is the most extraordinary thing that I or anybody else has ever heard. We had this request from the Minister. Whether he has himself gone off the rails on this question of grass or not I do not know, but it is an extraordinary thing to ask us to carry out grass experiments in a mental hospital.

Comment on this

If the Deputy has finished jeering at people of unsound mind we might pass to another topic. This is not a very edifying spectacle.

Comment on this

The Minister is not the best judge of what is or is not an edifying spectacle. I have listened to him for a long period and if he would forget for a moment that he is James Dillon and act as Minister for Agriculture we could get on more peacefully in this House.

One matter I would like to dwell on briefly is the provision of veterinary services, particularly in congested areas. I would like to point out to this House that the practice and economy of our country has mostly developed on the provision of stores for farmers up the country by the smallholders of the congested districts. It is true that these people may not be able economically to avail of veterinary assistance when they require it, but it is equally true that not alone thousands but millions of pounds are lost through disease in our live-stock industry.

I suggest that the Minister should make a start by providing a veterinary service free in the congested areas to ensure that the people would produce good stores, because stores are what they specialise in as far as cattle are concerned and it would combat some of the diseases that we get in these areas. Such a scheme would, I think, pay for itself in a short time and it would be money well spent. I have stated in this House on another Estimate that something could perhaps be done by this Minister for the free tuberculin testing of dairy cattle. Until the Minister does that and gives an enhanced price for cows reported to be suffering from tuberculosis in order to get them destroyed, he will not achieve what we all want to achieve, the stoppage of the spread of bovine tuberculosis in our dairy herds.

I want to nail one of the falsehoods which was spread widely by the Minister when he was an opposition Deputy in connection with the bacon industry. I listened very long and very patiently to the Minister over a number of years stating from these benches that the Fianna Fáil Government had killed the bacon industry. A very short time before the Minister came into office we heard him holding forth in this House and outside it, telling all and sundry how the then Government had destroyed the pig and bacon industry. The Minister, of course, knew at that time that it was untrue, and the Minister was not a fortnight in office when I listened to him state at a consultative meeting of the Agricultural Advisory Body that it was solely a question of feeding stuffs. The Minister was well aware of that——

Comment on this

The Deputy has recently become a director of a bacon company. Is not that so?

Comment on this

——but he wanted to put over for his own political purposes that the cause was something that should be attributed to the Government of the day. Now, at all events, the Minister admits that it is a question of feeding stuffs and of cheap feeding stuffs. We all know that you can get the pig population back and increase production if you can get feeding stuffs and more and cheaper maize than we got pre-war. The number of pigs will increase in proportion to the price and availability of the maize that the Minister will be able to get. I do not know if he has stated so far the amount of maize he will be able to get and the prices at which it will be available, but it is by all these factors that an increased pig population can be achieved.

The Minister, with a great blare of publicity, proceeded to suggest to all and sundry that he would put rashers in the shops and make them available for every housewife in the country.

Comment on this

That is wholly untrue.

Comment on this

The figures are very disappointing from the Minister's point of view. The number of pigs that came into the factories in the week ending 5th July, 1947, was 4,089 and in the week ending the 3rd of July of this year the number of 3,574, practically 500 down on last year. If we take the 27 weeks ended 3rd July, 1948, the number of pigs delivered to the factories in that period, roughly six months, was 102,185 and the number in the period ending 5th July, 1947, 122,008. Comparing the two sixmonth periods, we find that the number of pigs delivered to the factories is 20,000 down on last year's number.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say what is the average age of a pig delivered at the factory?

Comment on this

The Deputy would not know a pig if he saw one, but in the West of Ireland the pigs go into the factories at five or six months.

Comment on this

Exactly. The Minister has not been in office six months yet.

Comment on this

The Minister has been in office since February, and I am comparing the figures, if the Deputy can understand them, of the number of pigs delivered to the factories last year and this year. The pigs delivered to the factories these last six months would be the result of the sow services of the last six months of 1947. We understood from the Minister with all his thunder and fury that he would produce the bacon.

Comment on this

If we are to go into that indelicate statistic, I think I could impress the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Minister certainly has not produced the bacon so far. The Minister, of course, knew that he will not get bacon in this country until feeding stuffs are available and at a cheap rate. With all the waving of his flags about this matter has he set about endeavouring to procure feeding stuffs? I think that would probably go a long way to make a better attempt at solving the difficulties of the bacon shortage. The Minister further stated that the curers had thousands of tons of bacon in cold store.

Comment on this

And I dug it out.

Comment on this

That is the most extraordinary statement we ever heard from any Minister, because the Minister knew from his own officials the amount of bacon in cold store. There could not be one ounce of bacon in cold store without the Pigs and Bacon Commission knowing about it. The commission undoubtedly had to inform the Minister and he had these figures available to him. But, knowing that any bacon in cold store was known to be there officially—I should say that the small quantity of bacon in cold store was only there for the gammon and shoulder trade and the Minister was well aware of that— he tried deliberately to create the impression that the bacon curers had an enormous quantity of bacon hidden away in cold store in anticipation of some removal of controls. Everybody knows that the price that had to be paid for pigs was exorbitant and that the curers were running their business uneconomically. Everybody knows that the pigs were so scarce we had this competition for them between the different curers.

Notwithstanding that the bacon curers had to pay such high prices and were turning these pigs into bacon and getting shut of them as fast as they could, they could not meet the huge demand for bacon throughout the country. If, for some extraordinary reason known only to the Minister, bacon curers had hidden away thousands of tons of bacon, where is that bacon now? Why did not the Minister get these thousands of tons of bacon, if they were there, on the shop counters?

Comment on this

How is it that since the Minister started his ramp bacon is scarcer than ever before in the shops? The Minister deliberately tried to create the impression that by some underhand method bacon was hidden away in some illegal manner.

Comment on this

It was.

Comment on this

The Minister should know that there was no bacon hidden away illegally, because the Pigs and Bacon Commission were aware of what was in cold store. Of course it was good publicity for the Minister while it lasted. The Minister purports to be a lover of Great Britain, and, more particularly, to have a soft spot for the axe. He should ponder on the maxim that deeds speak louder than words. When he gets the bacon into the shops it will be time enough for him to start waving the applause flags and get encomiums from the newspapers which are supporting him. I do not know how far the Minister is responsible for the prices fixed for the butchers. Possibly the Minister for Industry and Commerce has an equal responsibility, if not the greater responsibility, for that. I do not want to dwell upon it except to say——

Comment on this

That racket is over. Do not worry any more about it.

Comment on this

The Minister is so fond of calling people racketeers that the mere fact of the Minister saying that they are racketeers does not cut a lot of ice with me. Those who drafted the Emergency Powers Order which controls the prices charged by the butchers seem to have lost sight of a couple of things. There was an Order made last November that lamb should be sold at the same price as mutton.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture has this to do with it, that there was no variation made in that Order since last November, the result being that spring lamb had to be sold this year at the same price as mutton. That is an oversight on somebody's part. That is one of the grievances of the butchers whom the Minister referred to in this House as racketeers. Like every other section of the community, the butchers are entitled to have their side of the case heard.

Comment on this

The Estimate of the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be discussed very shortly.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce is so busy with inter-Party affairs that he cannot receive these people.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not discuss the Minister for Industry and Commerce on this Vote. This is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That has been ruled.

Comment on this

Very well. We shall have an opportunity of dealing with this matter at greater length when the Estimate for the Minister for Industry and Commerce comes before the House.

Comment on this

I will lay you 6 to 4 that you will not take it.

Comment on this

The Minister is very good at making bets. I ask him to wait and see. He will find that when the Minister for Industry and Commerce comes along with his Estimate I shall deal with the question of the butchers. I want to make a suggestion in connection with a sum of money held up by the Pigs and Bacon Commission for some time. I refer to the Stabilisation Fund, which was paid in by the curers to the Pigs and Bacon Commission. It is still held by that commission and I understand nobody can get it. So far as I remember, it was in the region of £20,000 and, with the accumulation of interest, it should now be in the region of £34,000 or £35,000. If the Minister is going to accept the suggestion of some Deputies as to the provision of a sow scheme to be administered by the committees of agriculture, there is a sum of money which could well be devoted to that purpose. It was paid in for the purpose of price stabilisation, but I am sure the curers would be agreeable to having it ploughed back into the industry. As it could not be used now for the purpose for which it was originally subscribed, if we go according to the doctrine cy pres, it could be used for a similar purpose, and the best purpose I can suggest for its use would be some scheme administered by the county committees of agriculture to be financed out of this particular fund.

If we suggest any scheme like that to the Minister, or to any Minister of the present Government, we come up against the economy axe. The Minister is not prepared to find money to finance them. I listened to a number of Deputies complaining about the holding up of different schemes for which the Minister is responsible. They need not have wasted their time referring to these schemes because the reason for the hold up is quite apparent. They have only to turn to a statement made by the Minister for Finance in his Budget speech when he stated, as reported in column 1040 of the Official Report of 4th May:—

"I am also taking account of further reductions in expenditure totalling £1,122,000, which I am closely pursuing and confidently expect to capture, but of which it would be premature to give particulars until they are safely in the net."

That £1,122,000 has been kept in the background. But, if any Deputies want to know the reason why the schemes that were in operation under the former Minister for Agriculture are being held up, such as the poultry houses scheme, the farm improvements scheme, etc., I suggest to them to consider these sinister words of the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Agriculture is carrying out his part of the Coalition bargain. He is going to do his own share in finding this £1,122,000 for the Minister for Finance. That is the explanation in connection with this Estimate and every other Estimate for the dilly-dallying, for the putting off, for the sabotaging of these schemes for which our farmers are crying out.

Let those people sitting on the benches opposite who talk about continuing self-sufficiency examine their consciences when they come to vote with the present Minister for Agriculture on this Vote when it is referred back. Let them examine the condition which existed in this country when Fianna Fáil were in office and consider the outlook of the Fine Gael Party which is expressed by their old henchman, Deputy James Dillon, who now occupies the position of Minister for Agriculture. They have an opportunity now of undoing the harm that has been done. They have their opportunity on the Vote for this Estimate to show that they do not want to turn this country into a cattle ranch for Britain. If they do not accept it the responsibility will be on their shoulders and they will not get out of it by shedding crocodile tears down the country when they find we are back again, lock, stock and barrel, inside the four walls of British economy to produce all our exports for the one market at whatever price the British choose to pay us.

Comment on this

During the four days this Estimate has been under discussion criticisms, proposals and suggestions have been directed from every angle of the House for the purpose of improving agriculture in this country. Fortified by all that information the Minister will, no doubt, have a very busy time during the coming year coordinating them. I should like to reiterate some of the points which have already been made by other Deputies.

Deputy B. Maguire mentioned that the Department of Agriculture has not been helpful to the poorer areas in the country. It can be said with equal truth that it has not been helpful in areas where the land is richer. For that reason I welcome the optimism of the Minister in that he feels competent to depart from compulsory co-operation on the part of the farmers. I think that, with certain protective methods, that voluntary effort will be justified. To make agriculture really successful it must be made popular and there is no doubt that it is not as popular as it ought to be. Deputy Kyne, in his valuable contribution to the debate this morning, referred to the popularising of agriculture. The workers in the agricultural industry must be made more prosperous and more contented. They should be enabled to secure a decent livelihood in the country rather than have their eyes on the cities and towns. That can be achieved by giving them better conditions of employment and reasonable remuneration. The farmer must be prosperous and the agricultural labourer must be prosperous. If that is done, agriculture will be prosperous and popular.

After so many years of necessary compulsion as a result of the emergency farmers are now being allowed to utilise their land in whatever way they think it is most suitable to utilise it. Compulsion was understandable during the emergency period, but in normal times it would be an uneconomic and an unsound policy. The farmers will now have an opportunity of going back to the proper utilisation of their land. Surely a man who was born on a holding, which was worked by his father before him, knows the best use to which it can be put. The patriotism of the farmers is beyond all doubt. Canon Sheehan said that the farmers' patriotism did not extend beyond the boundary wall, but conditions were different then, and during the emergency tributes were paid from all sides to the spirit of co-operation of the farmers. Patriotism and not compulsion was the mainspring of their magnificent co-operation.

I look forward to the time when economic prices will be paid for the various types of agricultural produce. I look forward to the time when the man who is now producing wheat will be enabled to return to the production of milk. I believe they will appreciate that. I think, however, that some steps should be taken to prevent a recurrence of what happened before ever the emergency took place. I refer to the large landowners who did not even till sufficient for their own requirements. I had the sad experience of seeing in the City of Limerick owners of the richest land buying agricultural produce in competition with city workers and traders. That is the other extreme. I hope that steps will be taken to ensure that the man who has land will shoulder his responsibilities in that connection. I believe that farmers, after years of compulsory tillage, will shoulder their responsibilities without compulsion and in that way the dreadful fear that was expressed in this House yesterday will not materialise. There will be no necessity, either, for the inspector to pay visits as frequently as heretofore if the farmers get down to their jobs and they will do so if they are guaranteed a remunerative price for their produce.

I was amazed by the statement made by Deputy Moran in regard to the illegal curing of bacon. He asked the Minister if he really believed, as he was asking the public to believe, that illegal practices were taking place in regard to the curing of bacon.

Comment on this

In factories.

Comment on this

It is amazing how innocent we can be when we want to. Deputy Moran's mind must have been in Mars or somewhere else when he asked that question. Everybody in the country knows that not alone has the pig population decreased but that many of the pigs that should be available never reach the bacon factories. I know for a fact that at a particular fair 60 per cent. of the pigs disappeared—the other 40 per cent. reached the curers. Where the 60 per cent. disappeared to remains to be seen. The carcases of the 40 per cent. were inspected by inspectors to ensure that they were free from tuberculosis and any other infection. The 60 per cent. were killed unseen and there is no doubt that they were able to command any price. Deputy Moran says that the Minister is wrong in suggesting that there is any such thing as illegal curing of bacon. The few prosecutions that give the lie to that are infinitesimal in comparison to the extent of the racket which is going on not alone in Dublin but throughout the length and breadth of the country. I want to advert to a particular point of local interest. In a statement made by the Minister recently, he indicated his intention of dispersing in the near future some of the holdings and assets of the Dairy Disposal Company to certain co-operative creamery institutions. I have no quarrel with that. I think the Minister is merely reverting to the original intention for which the board was set up to put certain creameries on an economic basis and hand them back to the farmers to work as a going concern. In the absence of a more detailed statement of his intentions, a certain amount of anxiety and alarm has been created in the minds of the employees of a very considerable industry in Limerick, the condensed milk company and toffee factory. The employees are a bit scared as to whether they are going to be dispersed in common with the other interests of the board.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy not one single one of them need be in the slightest degree apprehensive about his job.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that. This is a very old industry and one of the biggest in the City of Limerick. When it first came into being, it was operated both as a dairying concern and condensed milk. Now it is only dealing with condensed milk and it is dependent for its supply on Tipperary and Knocklong and Drumree. It is a co-ordinated unit and it is essential that the industry should be kept alive for the benefit of Limerick. I am glad to have the Minister's assurances in that respect.

Deputy O'Grady closed his speech to-day by a quotation from, I think, Stewart Mills to the effect that "every country gets the Government it deserves." He piously asked, "What has this country done to deserve its present Government?" I can only suggest that God and the people, having recognised the fact that we had endured 16 years of Fianna Fáil, thought the country richly deserved this, or even a better, Government.

Comment on this

I feel a sense of confidence in rising to speak on this Estimate, because, as most people in the country know, in spite of the statements made by members of the inter-Party Government that the last Government was thrown out by the farmers of the country, a very brief study of the figures at the election will reveal that, however we suffered defeat by a very small margin, it was not in the farming areas. It is quite evident that we have a natural right to ask the Minister to pursue what we believe to be the best aspects of Fianna Fáil policy because, as I have said, the farmers indicated in no slight degree their generous support of that Government.

I believe that the Minister for Agriculture has a better opportunity of enabling production to be increased than any Minister for Agriculture in the history of this country. For the first time he will have more normal conditions in which to improve production than have ever been the case before. We went through the fight for independence followed by the civil war. No Minister for Agriculture, Republican or Free State, could have been expected to launch a large-scale scheme of agricultural development at that time. No sooner were these events terminated, than agricultural prices the world over began to fall and, whatever the shortcomings of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government were, it would have required more than the courage they showed to start a large-scale development of agriculture at a time when prices were falling year by year. In the middle of that depression there began the economic war and the permanent and long-term policy of the Fianna Fáil Government was to a considerable degree twisted by necessity owing to the fact that the economic war had to be fought and the economic war had to be won. Many items of that policy were either not put sufficiently into operation or had to be modified to suit the circumstances of the time. No sooner was the economic war over than the second world war began and brought with it shortages of machinery, materials and fertilisers. Now if the Russians behave themselves, the Minister for Agriculture has no political war to fight, no world war to fight, and he anticipates an increase in supplies of agricultural machinery. He anticipates greater supplies of fertilisers arising from the resumption of more normal trade conditions between this and other countries. There is no major political dispute in this country in which the farmers have to take the front line trenches, as they did for so many years. I think that the Minister will honestly admit that he has a chance given to no other Minister to bring about an increase in agricultural production. He will not mind my suggesting that his modesty in prophesying a great increase in agricultural production in so far as he might be responsible for it is not noteworthy. The Minister is prone to make ebullient statements, and certainly sometimes we find it difficult to understand his policy when outlined at after-dinner speeches and when given to the House in connection with his Estimate. I agree with Deputy Dr. Ryan that, bearing in mind we have inadequate information, the Minister for Agriculture in many ways is following Fianna Fáil policy and expanding Fianna Fáil policy. We doubt his views about tillage and about the future of the dairying industry, because he has not made them sufficiently clear. But it is quite evident that he has adopted the vast majority of the plans we had in operation when the Government fell. We ask the Minister to relate his statement on the close of this Estimate to some of the wilder observations he made in the course of a number of public functions. I failed to understand them. To give an example, the Minister for Agriculture showed a contempt for the horse in one of his after-dinner speeches as a means of transport——

Comment on this

Of traction.

Comment on this

——on the occasion of one association dinner while, at the same time, he indicated that farming to some considerable degree was to be mechanised. I think he made an extreme statement. Granted there must be a great deal of mechanisation of farming, I think at the same time he was going beyond reason in what he said in regard to that matter.

I have noted one thing. Once again we find that all the new Clann na Poblachta policy is to be put in abeyance. I listened with eagerness to hear whether any of the high-sounding and grandiose promises made by that Party were going to be implemented by the Minister. I find that that Party in return for some nebulous concession —I know now what it is—have sacrificed every single one of their special policies with which they so successfully bribed the farming electorate. We did not hear of the £130,000,000 free of interest to the farmers; we did not hear of the vast supply of absolutely free artificial manures. We waited, in vain, to hear the Minister recommend that farms in this country be not greater than 50 acres and that all holdings in excess of 50 acres be divided up among the population. We find that the Minister is not faced with the problem of reducing the cost of living by 30 per cent. by means of subsidies on agricultural produce. We find that he is not faced with the impossible task of raising agricultural prices, according to Clann na Poblachta standards, and, at the same time, seeing the food produced in this country sold at a 30 per cent. discount on the market by means of subsidies which at current prices would cost no less than £50,000,000 per year.

And so we find that, once again, a great deal more of this strange new policy is put in abeyance, and, listening to the Minister, it seems to me as though it is more or less permanently in abeyance. I heard Deputy McQuillan make a foolish apologia for the new Party. He said:—

"We are waiting and watching the new Minister, and if he can succeed in arresting the flight from the land, we will be prepared to abide by his decisions."

If the flight from the land continues, then we may anticipate a resumption of our freedom in order that our special policies can be put into operation. It is true that Party succeeded in gaining very few seats in the country. Maybe it was that the farmers did not believe what they were told and did not believe the promises would be fulfilled.

We have also noted in this debate a refreshing absence of comment on the way of life in New Zealand. Apparently members of the new Party and of the Labour Party have discovered, since the election, that to compare agricultural conditions in an under-populated country, where the grass in winter is almost as green as in summer and where 1,700,000 people occupy a land four times the size of ours, is neither judicious nor sensible.

I should like to ask the Minister what he now believes to be the proper policy in regard to sugar-beet growing. We heard much condemnation from him in the past and I should like to ask him whether he favours beet as the future long-term policy, particularly in regard to the necessity of maintaining security measures. As has been indicated in previous Estimates, the Government have done little to prepare this country for a possible war. The present inter-Party Government are probably the only Government that are not taking measures to protect our interests should the tragedy of a war be our lot. Does the Minister regard the preservation of the beet factories, even if he does not believe in growing beet, as wise from the standpoint of security if not from the standpoint of bringing an income to the farmer?

He gave facts in regard to agricultural production, but in order to gain a political point he did not go far enough in describing agricultural production in this country over the past 25 years. The volume of agricultural production and the population of our live stock have been virtually stagnant since 1912. The percentage of alteration in the density of live stock or in the volume of production has not been notable. Whether prices have collapsed or increased the figures have remained virtually the same. Even during the economic war, when the farmers suffered severely, they suffered from low prices but at the same time it can be noted that the actual volume of their production remained very stable. The character of production changed in regard to certain classes. There was an increase of tillage of about 5 per cent. Although production suffered modification and there were a number of other adverse repercussions, the actual volume of production did not vary very considerably. I do not know whether the Minister mentioned that during the war the total of our live stock actually increased.

Comment on this

The number of cattle increased, but the number of sheep decreased steadily.

Comment on this

For the purpose of correcting Deputy Dr. Ryan, I said they went down.

Comment on this

In connection with our sheep population, has the Minister noted the change in other countries and does he consider that Fianna Fáil is responsible for the decline in the production of sheep? Does he consider that the inevitable compulsory tillage, with the difficulties affecting sheep arising from it, contributed in not a large measure to the reduction of the sheep population?

The Minister has indicated his policy. A very large amount of it is Fianna Fáil. In connection with some other items we still await the Minister's answer and we also await his ultimate beliefs. We presume the Minister will continue to protect the home market from imported food where it can be produced here. That policy brought the Irish farmer a market worth many millions. We presume the Minister will welcome the maintenance of relief of agricultural rates which totals no less than £3,000,000 this year, and is a very considerable contribution in relief to the farmers. In the case of holdings of a certain acreage it means they are paying a smaller rate than a few years ago. We presume the Minister will not recommend to the Minister for Finance that there should be any change in the levy of the annuities.

With regard to the general encouragement of tillage, the Minister was not so precise. He spoke of bringing over an expert on grass-land. I take it he subscribes to the Fianna Fáil belief that in a great part of the country mixed farming encourages the production of good grass, but there are certain lands where it may be argued the pasture should be left permanent. I take it the Minister does not stray far from the Majority Report of the Post-War Commission on Agriculture. In that regard, although he may make many modifying statements, necessary in particular circumstances, I take it that in general he will agree with Fianna Fáil that tillage of any kind—we are not discussing wheat—improves the grass in many areas, gives employment and should be given every reasonable encouragement.

Reading his observations in regard to barley, oats and potatoes, I take that as his policy. I take it he subscribes to that aspect of Fianna Fáil policy and that it is not true, as might be gathered from listening to some of his speeches, that he is in fact a rancher type of farming advocate. Deputy Dr. Ryan assumed that the Minister agreed with the Majority Report in regard to that matter, and I follow Deputy Dr. Ryan.

I would like to hear more about the grass-land expert. Any expert who comes here should have some preconceived notions on how to direct farming policy and grass-land policy in a country with our humidity, rainfall and average temperature. We have heard that this man is to come from New Zealand. Unless he has studied where the climate approaches ours, and adopts a modest attitude, he may take us far off the track. There are 100-acre farms in New Zealand where there are 70 cows but no bullocks and where a man and his wife have no hired labour whatever with which to produce milk or butter for the market, where the grass is perpetual and is treated with artificial manures, where the fields are big and where the temperature in winter is higher than here. I trust the expert will not be prejudiced in his attitude. It will be interesting to hear the opinions of this expert. It is important that we should not have a man who arrives with a big prejudice.

The Minister is continuing the farm improvements scheme, and I would like to ask him to consider a suggestion which I made while the previous Government was in office and which, I think, was being considered by the Minister at the time. The object was to increase the number of farm improvements schemes in the area where paid labour is employed. If the Minister examines the figures of the number of grants issued in the bigger farm areas he will find they are a very small percentage of the total holdings in those areas. He will find a great concentration of the scheme in the congested areas, the areas where the person getting the grant receives cash for labour he has performed. If he examines Carlow, Wexford, Wicklow or Louth, he will find the scheme at a low ebb in these counties. It might take a considerable amount of complicated and perhaps annoying administration. Perhaps the Minister could give a larger grant, up to 70 per cent. or 80 per cent. of the labour value, for farm improvements schemes where the farmers employ labour. I ask him to consider that. I know it was being considered when the last Government fell, and I should like to draw attention to it.

The Minister spoke about an improved quality of seeds for this country. I understand that under the last Government, measures were in progress for securing the best seeds that could be provided for the renewal of our crops. I understand that was going on before the Minister took office. So far as the provision of artificial fertilisers is concerned, I understand the previous Government were ransacking the world for artificial manures and that there was no duty on them. I am glad to hear that the Minister is continuing that policy.

I do not want to repeat ad nauseam what has been said before but in common with other Deputies I should like the Minister to give us some indication of what he believes the price of creamery and other milk should be in comparison with the price of cattle generally. I think it was Deputy Lehane who said that the only good thing Fianna Fáil did during their term of office was to initiate the farm improvements scheme. I believe Deputy Lehane comes from a dairying area and I always understood that Fianna Fáil saved the dairying industry from complete destruction by the introduction of subsidies for butter. Even if there was no economic war, such a measure was highly desirable and should have been introduced at least 12 months before that. I do not know whether Deputy Lehane remembers that but perhaps his memory is too short. I trust the Minister will give careful consideration to the question of ancillary industries such as casein and allied products, tanneries, etc., the raw materials of which are provided by agriculture. I understand that there are a number of industries, for which the raw materials are agricultural products, which are awaiting the decision of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in regard to their protection. The question of protection has not yet been decided upon and I trust that the Minister for Agriculture will encourage the Minister for Industry and Commerce to come to a decision at an early date.

Of course, the former Government assisted farmers to improve or provide roads to their residences by initiating the farm improvements scheme, and I trust the Minister will put that into operation as soon as possible. I should like to hear from the Minister whether he considers that the subsidies which we gave for fertilisers and manures, which were still further increased through the supplementary budget, are sufficient. We are not going as far as Clann na Poblachta, who desired that manures and fertilisers should be given away to farmers, but we recognise the necessity for an extended use of these fertilisers. Is the Minister satisfied that the subsidy is now large enough? Conditions have changed even since the last Government left office. Is the subsidy large enough or does the Minister consider that the Minister for Finance might allow him even a loan under which higher subsidies for artificial manures could be provided for the next five years?

We are not allowed to discuss the agreement made with Britain, but I should like to point out, in passing, a fact that seems to be forgotten by some of the Deputies opposite that we did make a preliminary agreement with the British which was a step forward, and I have no doubt that if the former Government were still in office they would have improved on that agreement.

I should like to ask the Minister to supply us with some further information about the improvement of veterinary services. I understand that matter was under consideration by the former Government and that one of the difficulties lay in the training of the necessary number of vets. Does the Minister favour the veterinary dispensary scheme wherby a vet. would be in a certain place on a certain day where he could be reached by the farmers without difficulty? Is he in favour of a change in the method of administering the veterinary service or is he merely going to increase the number of vets to give them every encouragement or to plan some sort of veterinary insurance or some veterinary assistance scheme?

I should like also to ask the Minister whether he would give us some information as to the publicity he is going to undertake in connection with the soil analysis service. The arrangements for that service were commenced by the former Government. As the Minister may know, some 10,000 samples are sent for analysis every year by the level-headed farmers in Scotland. The figures are very small for this country, as far as I know. It seems to me that we should initiate an advertising campaign in this connection in a way which the farmers would understand. Farmers are loth to engage assistance for a purely technical service of this kind and I should like the Minister to say if he would think it wise to advertise that service.

Speaking about improvements schemes, the Minister will be aware that there are areas in the Gaeltacht in which schemes were operated which were largely devoted to bog roads and accommodation roads. In connection with these schemes it was sometimes found very difficult to find adequate work. There are areas in Galway where by-roads and small roads of that kind have been undertaken and where there is a great deal of unemployment. I would suggest that the farm improvements schemes and the unemployment schemes——

Comment on this

Where is the unemployment?

Comment on this

——might be operated jointly as a permanent feature. I do not know whether that matter has come to his attention. The Minister speaks of improved production and in the course of his observations he said that money was being provided to improve the quality of grass seed. Does he not believe that it would be advisable to offer a subsidy for grass seeds of an approved quality. There are areas in Longford where only half the farms sow grass seed of any quality upon land as an under-cover crop after a four years' rotation. A very large proportion of the farmers take what they find in the hay barn. Even if the price of good seed were much dearer, it would be still worth while in encouraging farmers to buy good seed. Does the Minister not consider it high time to make available a grant or subsidy for grass seed of approved quality?

The Minister said a great deal about inspectors. I have views which are entirely my own and which do not belong to any particular Party on the question of propaganda in regard to production in this country. The Minister said that he is never going to ask an inspector to enter on a man's land. I think it is time we adopted an entirely different administrative method for conducting propaganda operations in the Department of Agriculture. I do not believe that civil servants, working under Civil Service rules, are going to help the farmer to improve his production. I believe there should be an agricultural production council set up, quite independent of the Department, a council which should be given a policy and given money, and the people who work for it should not be called inspectors—I do not know what they should be called—but they should be people who would go around amongst the farmers and help them to improve their production by every means possible. They should be welcomed by the farmers——

Comment on this

They are.

Comment on this

——and they should be able to go inside a man's gate and help him, without having to adhere to strictly Civil Service rules—something like a glorified young farmers' club in operation throughout the country. I believe that something of that kind should be considered by the Minister. We have already delegated to boards a number of important activities, such as the giving of industrial credit, the giving of agricultural credit and assisting the tourist industry, but the propaganda work of this Department is still in the shadows, in which it must be, of Departmental routine. I should like to suggest to the Minister that, excellent as the Department is, if he were to change that method, he might have far better results.

In connection with agricultural education, during the lifetime of the former Government, it was extremely difficult, at least during the war, to procure mobile film units. I should like to know whether the Minister considers that the winter classes for agricultural instruction would be much better attended if there were always films available.

Comment on this

I am trying to procure six such units.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that the Minister has adverted to that matter, because, if you have the type of film which can be stopped while the lecturer proceeds with his lecture and a hall of sufficient size, the attendance at these winter classes, which are so useful in connection with demonstrations in the summer, would be far greater. The attendance in County Longford in past years has been not more than 10 per cent. of the farming population at any time, and although it is hard to ask young farmers to come out on the long nights, in winter weather, to attend these classes, I have met a great many who did and who say that they gained great value from them.

I do not think the Minister has made it sufficiently clear to the House how he intends to use the increased maize supply. He has spoken of exporting the surplus potatoes to Great Britain, and I should like to ask him how he thinks that will affect pig production, and having regard to the present price of maize, £27 per ton, if there are largely increased supplies of that product, even if it comes down slightly in price, will it affect pig or poultry production more?

Comment on this

The Deputy forgets that that price includes the Fianna Fáil margin of profit.

Comment on this

Whatever margin it includes, will it affect pig or poultry production more? The Minister has taken over the scheme started by Fianna Fáil for increased poultry and eggs and he is very anxious to increase the production of pigs. How does he think the increased imported feeding stuffs will be utilised? Has he had regard to what the average price of compound feeding stuffs for pigs will be when the proportion of maize is very largely increased, due to its total greater importation, and what does he think the result will be in connection with pigs and poultry?

The Minister has, in very large measure, adopted the Fianna Fáil policy and is uncertain about other policy. I trust that he will clarify the issues before the House when he replies and that we may know what we have to face in the future. The Minister for Lands, in the course of his speech on the Estimate for Lands, stated that he foresaw the complete disappearance of all large farms in the Midlands. He was asked afterwards whether that means the farm well worked by a large number of workers would be divided, and he said no. The question was still left undecided as to why he made such a prophecy. I should like to ask the Minister——

Comment on this

Would the Deputy not ask that of the Minister for Lands.

Comment on this

——whether he agrees with the Minister for Lands with regard to the likely disappearance of all large farms in the Midlands.

Comment on this

That is a very flatfooted scamper outside the rules of order.

Comment on this

In intervening in this debate, I am under the double difficulty that I am not a farmer, or in any way an agricultural expert, and that the time factor and the desire of the House to conclude the debate on this Estimate makes my intervention, of necessity, brief. I had not the privilege of hearing all of Deputy Childers' contribution, but what I did hear of it was sufficient to increase for me the puzzle as to what constitutes Fianna Fáil agricultural policy, because his major premise, so far as I could understand, was that the present Minister was merely extending the policy of Fianna Fáil, except in so far as that policy had been somewhat curtailed or amended by incidentals like the economic war and the intervention of the world war; but, on the whole, I took it from him that there had been no radical departure in the agricultural field. This occasioned great surprise for me, in view of the acrimony with which the Minister's Estimate has been assailed by his Party colleagues.

However, so far as we in the Labour Party are concerned, we take cognisance of the fact that this is an inter-Party Government, and that the present Minister in presenting his policy is presenting a policy which is a compound more or less of the policies of the composite parts of the Government. It is not a Labour Party policy and there is therefore no necessity for us to defend the policy as a whole. Fianna Fáil policy was examined and analysed by the Labour Party on various occasions and our policy was very fully announced as far back as 1943, but the Labour Party as a whole has not had an opportunity of examining or analysing the policy of the present Minister. We must therefore speak with a certain amount of restraint and reserve on this matter. So far as the Labour Party policy was announced by Deputies Dunne, Davin and Kyne and, to a certain extent, Deputy Keyes, I am in accord with their presentation of it and with their concern for the agricultural worker more especially, and their request, if it was not more, to the Minister to reexamine this question of compulsory tillage, in so far as it relates to increased agricultural production.

More than that I do not want to say, but I want to draw the Minister's attention to an item of local interest in my constituency. I would not have intervened had Deputy Aiken made reference to the matter but unfortunately he was more concerned with matters which naturally interest the Opposition, such as election posters and promises, rather than with raising this matter, which is of vital importance to a very large agricultural section in my constituency. That relates to the question of Cooley potatoes which are under certain restrictions as black scab potatoes. The matter is long-standing, and with the advent of a new Minister for Agriculture many people concerned with the production of potatoes in the Cooley peninsula hope for a reorientation of policy in that matter. In this area there is a very high productivity of potatoes. The farmers there feel that the prevention of the export of Cooley potatoes to the Dublin market is not motivated on scientific grounds or by a desire to protect the seed potato export market, but is an unfair discrimination against them. I suggest that the matter should be re-examined by the Minister. If the contention of the farmers of Cooley is correct then a great injustice is being done, not only to the farmers but to the consumers in the Dublin market. The farmers maintain that their productivity is so high that they could supply to the Dublin market sufficient potatoes to reduce substantially the price in the Dublin market, and that, by reducing the price there, they would bring the price nearer to the price at which potatoes would be useful for pig feeding, and thus aid the production of bacon.

On these matters I am speaking second-hand. I do not pretend to any agricultural expertness, but there are certain aspects of it to which I would direct the Minister's attention. There is a degree of smuggling from that area to the Dublin market due to the great difference between the price at the alcohol factory, to which they are compelled to send the potatoes as the only outlet for their produce, and the price in the Dublin market. Smuggling has gone on for a considerable time and there is regular imposition of penalties and a certain amount of trouble is caused in the area. That would be obviated if there were some way of increasing the price for Cooley potatoes even in that area or of permitting export to England or of reducing the difference between the price at the alcohol factory and the Dublin price.

If one examines what happens the smuggled potatoes which are seized, the matter acquires a certain amount of mystery. On seizure, the potatoes are brought in to the town of Dundalk and it is found that they are railed somewhere to the south and apparently are used in some institutions under Government control in such a manner that the danger of black scab occurring in the area in which they are used is avoided. The thought naturally arises that if these smuggled potatoes can be used, as there is no doubt they can be used, for human consumption, there should be some means of regular Government control of the potatoes so that they would be washed or chemically treated and allowed on to the Dublin market.

The contention of the Department of Agriculture is that it is not the potatoes that are the source of contamination but the earth adhering to the potatoes which contains spores of a disease which could spread black scab to other parts of the country and, therefore, exportation of potatoes from this black scab area is a very serious matter, particularly in regard to the export seed trade. That export trade is of considerable value to the country and certificates have to be issued in respect of seed for export that the seed was not grown in any place within twenty miles of a black scab area. While there is this very stringent regulation in regard to seed potatoes, there seems to be no regulation whatsoever in respect of the exportation of beet or other crops from that area, which obviously carry the same earth. There is no decontamination squad attending to the potato workers, or those who work in the field and carry this earth on their boots from that area into Dundalk and the surrounding district and as far down as Dublin or anywhere else they may go.

There are many aspects of this matter that seem to indicate that the whole question should be reconsidered. At one period there may have been some necessity for cutting off the whole Cooley area. There may have been a case for it in the past and because that case was made out by the Department at that time—on scientific grounds, I have no doubt—it seems to me that they have gone on from year to year and that the matter has never been re-examined. Although promises were held out by various Deputies in the past that the Fianna Fáil Government would reconsider the matter, that was never done. The Cooley farmers now confidently hope that the new Minister for Agriculture in the inter-Party Government will take steps to have the question re-examined.

Comment on this

We have listened to appeals from most of the speakers on the opposite side of the House for cooperation and assistance for the Minister in carrying out his policy. I listened to Deputy Coburn yesterday making a very impassioned appeal, telling us it was our duty to assist the Minister to get the people to produce wheat, barley, oats, potatoes and all crops at the prices that have been guaranteed by the Minister. It is hardly necessary for any Deputy sitting behind the Government to-day to make appeals to this side of the House, because one outstanding plank on Fianna Fáil's programme is its agricultural policy. Since the first day Fianna Fáil took over the reins of Government, their every-day effort has been to try to make the people purely agricultural minded. It was not merely in the days of emergency that that effort was made.

We have heard many speeches regarding statements made by the present Minister. I cannot describe them as other than mischievous statements made by him during the emergency, at a time when the people had no hope of getting any food anywhere except that which could be produced by the farmers. Then this particular Minister was as obstructive as he could be and did his utmost to smash the food drive.

In his opening speech, he said that Fianna Fáil were responsible for giving Guinness £2,000,000 last year. Let me take one item and see what the Minister thinks about it. We are to get a guaranteed price of 55/- a barrel for barley, that is, £27 10s. 0d. a ton. The experience of everybody, especially of Deputies from the barley-growing districts, is that when Guinness gets a certain amount of barley he puts his foot down and says: "Thus far will I go and no further." That means that, if we have a surplus of barley above his requirments, it will have to be converted into animal food. That will cost £6 per ton, bringing the price of barley meal up to £33 10s. 0d. per ton. I would like the Minister to tell us how it will be economic to produce pigs fed on barley meal at £33 10s. 0d. a ton. I do not think it can be done.

The Minister has been charged from this side of the House with having drawn the pen across the farm buildings scheme. Although he had 25,000 applications, he did not try to realise that that showed the urgency for reconstruction and erection of out-offices all over the country. If he were satisfied with doing away with that particular scheme for the time being and helping to save the £350,000 that the Minister for Finance is seeking, we would not be so worried, but he has not been content with that. He has gone into the farm improvements scheme, to which he paid a very high tribute in his opening speech, when he complimented Deputy Dr. Ryan, who was responsible for introducing it, and told us that it was the greatest monument that could be erected to any mortal man. He was not satisfied with leaving the farm buildings scheme in abeyance, but he draws the Fine Gael economic axe right across the farm improvements scheme.

The Deputies who have been loud in their praise of the Minister's action have not gone to the labour of finding out what exactly he has done. I have here before me the form of application being sent out at present to those who wish to make application under this scheme. Do you know what this Minister is doing? He is cutting out the construction of water tanks, of liquid manure tanks, of silos, concrete stands for corn stacks, piers, cattle enclosures and a whole number of things that were carried on for years and years by the Fianna Fáil Minister for Agriculture, by the man whom this Minister complimented and whose scheme he described as his greatest monument. He has drawn the Fine Gael economic are across it, and now the only schemes for which you can get grants under the farm improvements scheme are drainage and other improvements purely on the land. The people who stand behind the Minister and who are not prepared to have this Estimate referred back, until such time as the Minister gives at least as much effect to the old farm improvements scheme as had been given by Fianna Fáil, are not doing their duty by the farming community or by the people who sent them here to represent the farming community.

We are told that we are not entitled to criticise the Minister. If that is not a reason for criticising him, I do not know where we are going or that we are doing our duty towards those who deserve more from us than anybody else, that is, the agricultural community. I can clearly understand the Minister doing things like that, as he has not been sent here by any section of the farming community. As far as I know, he has no association with any section of the farming community.

Comment on this

He is a farmer himself.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy know about his farm?

Comment on this

What does Deputy Killilea know about it?

Comment on this

His main business to-day is not farming. There are men who have farms in this country and who never saw them—and in other countries, too.

Comment on this
Joseph Blowick Minister for Lands (Mr. Blowick) Clann na Talmhan

The Deputy might pay a visit to the Minister's farm and learn a good deal of useful information from it when he compares it with his own.

Comment on this

If the Deputy should need to learn anything and makes an effort, he will be prepared to carry on where he is. I am quite satisfied that the Minister for Lands up to recently was not prepared to stand by any of the statements made by this Minister. It is only the set of circumstances that have driven him into the benches opposite with him that has made him stand by him now. I do not think the Minister for Lands to-day is prepared to allow himself to be described as his colleague, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance has described, in days gone by and up to recently, this present Minister for Agriculture—and the Minister for Lands knows that just as well as I do.

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

The Deputy should keep to the Estimate.

Comment on this

If you can manage to keep the Minister for Lands in his place, Sir, I will keep to the Estimate. We heard a lot said about the Department's inspectors and the way that they jumped in on top of farmers here and there. I want to say that I happened to be one of the Deputies who, during the emergency—I was not in the same position and my mind was not focussed in the same direction as that of the present Minister for Agriculture —and prior to it was interested in seeing agriculture carried on as I think it should be in this country—that is, that the land should be used mainly for the production of food for the people. Time and again I made reports to the Department of Agriculture—I am sure the Minister will find some of them in the Department— regarding people who were prepared to ride rough-shod over the regulations governing compulsory tillage. There were farmers—and this must be known to Deputies no matter what county they come from—and not small farmers either, who sowed wheat, barley and oats, and because they possess a destructive type of mind, and probably because of advice given to them by the present Minister for Agriculture, they turned their cattle and other stock in on those crops and allowed them to destroy them, rather than put them on the market to feed the people during the emergency. If inspectors went in and tried to make those people do their job, I think they deserve a little more credit than they have received from the Minister.

What is the position this year? Some farmers cannot be blamed for what they are doing, because I do not think anyone could blame the farmers of the country for taking the advice that was given to them by the present Minister for Agriculture. He was only a few weeks in office, as a matter of fact only a few days—indeed I could almost bring it down to a few hours—when one of the first announcements he made was that compulsory tillage was going to disappear. Now, a wise Minister coming in new to an office would take his time and see where exactly he stood in connection with compulsory tillage. He would have had plenty of time during, say, the coming 12 months, or we will even say six months, to make such a statement after he had examined the records of his office and the whole position. When he had done that, it would be time enough for him to make such a statement. Immediately the Minister made this announcement a few days after taking office there was a rush all over the country by farmers, not, I say again by small farmers, but by the bigger type of farmer, to collect any and every sort of hayseed to throw it on the soil. The result has been, as I know myself, that even in this very year I have had to report people for not having complied with compulsory tillage so far as wheat growing is concerned. No action, of course, was taken, and those people have not grown the wheat.

Comment on this

What did the Deputy say?

Comment on this

I said that in this very year I made complaints or at least brought to the attention of the Department by letter the cases of certain individuals who did not comply with the compulsory wheat-growing regulations.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Were they supporters of yours?

Comment on this

I have never made any distinction as to whether they were supporters of mine, or not. My idea in connection with compulsory tillage is, as the saying goes, that it is as good for the goose as for the gander. Everyone has to do it and everyone ought to be made do it, be he large or small farmer. I make no distinction.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say that no action was taken on the report that he made?

Comment on this