Committee on Finance. - Vote 29—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 142–264 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
That statement is not true. Any report which reached my Department from the Deputy, or from any other citizen of this State, was fully investigated, and the law vindicated.
Comment on this
The Minister may be mixing up things. I made a report. There is no doubt in the world about that. Perhaps the Minister's inspectors visited those men, but I definitely say that no wheat has been grown. I can give him not one but a dozen names.
Comment on this
I would be very much obliged if the Deputy would send me any particulars that he has. If he does that, I will see that the law is enforced.
Comment on this
If the Deputy gives me the particulars, I will have the matter investigated at once.
Comment on this
I can give them although it may be a hardship on those people because it is the Minister's own statement that, I think, is responsible for people not doing that work. I heard the Minister during this debate, when different Deputies were talking about the unemployment that exists here and there, ask: "Where is the unemployment?"
Comment on this
The Minister has in operation in the Counties of Galway and Mayo a field drainage scheme. On that scheme only a certain type of worker can get employment. He must be a man who was employed in turf production in 1947. The Minister has been so badly advised by his colleague, who has responsibility for the Office of Public Works that he does not seem to realise that it is not the same individuals who produce turf in this country in any one year.
Comment on this
If the Minister wishes, I can go down the alphabet, O.P.Q., but what I have said is so. In 1945, there were men producing turf who perhaps went to England, or somewhere else, in 1946. Does the Minister think that the men who produced turf in 1946 were the same men as those who produced it in 1945? Is he going to try to convince me that he is so innocent as to believe that the men who produced turf in 1946 were the men who produced it in 1945, and that the men who produced it in 1947 were the men who had produced it in 1946?
Comment on this
According to the Minister's statement this Government, since it came into office, cannot find any unemployed men.
Comment on this
Since we have come in here as an Opposition, day after day we have listened to statements from different Ministers and from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance that when they tried to put schemes into operation they could not do it because there was no unemployment. Those are not the statements we listened to during the elections although the peat scheme was in operation then, and surely, since the peat scheme was dropped there must be more people unemployed. I want to tell the Minister that there are unemployed, but his scheme was deliberately drafted so as to convince the unemployed that they are working. A man who was 17½ years of age in 1947 would be 18½ years of age in 1948; he was not entitled to employment in 1947, so surely he would be entitled to it in 1948. Is there common sense in that statement? Are there not hundreds and thousands of such men in the country who cannot find employment? But the Minister comes along and says we have no unemployed. They are there, but you will not let them work. They are there, but you will not make any effort to find employment for them. I hope that what he has said with regard to the employment and the drainage scheme will be amended so as to give employment to those men who are looking for work and who are anxious to secure it. We have, as the Minister, I am sure, is aware, during the last three or four months more young men going to England and more young men and young women, too, going to America than in any similar months or in any three months for a number of years back. If you go to the different labour exchanges to find out whether what I am saying is correct or not, you will be convinced that that is so. I come from a constituency where I am alive to the conditions of employment and where I am alive to the conditions that exist regarding the people who are making a effort to get to England because they cannot get employment. The Minister's statement that there are no unemployed will, I am afraid, be true in the very near future, because there will be nobody there to be unemployed; they will all be gone
One other matter I would like to refer to is that the technical schools which we have all over the country are not, to my mind, being used for the purposes for which they were really intended. I always had the idea that these technical schools should be mainly for the purpose of giving education by way of domestic economy and I think domestic economy is one of the most important things.
Comment on this
I am sorry that the Minister was not here for the principal thing I wanted to refer to, the fact that he has curtailed the farm improvement scheme.
Comment on this
I beg your pardon. You might manage to fool the people behind you there, but any active Deputy in this House can contradict you by means of this pamphlet sent out by yourself or by your Department.
Comment on this
This is the application form that has to be filled in before you can get a farm improvement grant. This particular year you will not get a grant for the construction of water tanks, of liquid manure tanks, of silos, of concrete stands for corn stacks or cattle enclosures.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith had nothing to do with the farm buildings scheme. Now the poor Minister is feeling very worried. Mr. Smith or Mr. Fianna Fáil can be blamed for everything, but Mr. Smith cannot be blamed for cutting out the farm buildings scheme. The man who cut out the farm buildings scheme should have said at least: "I will allow the people to carry on with the works that Fianna Fáil had on their programme and allow the people who had started a farm improvement scheme to carry on to the same extent as heretofore." But you have not done that. It is the Minister alone who has drawn a pencil through this scheme. It is not Deputy Smith or any other Deputy in this House. It is the present Minister for Agriculture who has cut out the farm buildings scheme which Fianna Fáil had on their programme for the improvement of these things. When you decided to leave it in abeyance for a year you could at least have allowed the people to carry on with schemes they had undertaken. That would not have been too much for the Minister for Agriculture, and I hope he changes his mind about it. Seeing that we are not to have the farm buildings scheme for another year or so, I hope that this thing will be rectified and remedied so that people will be able to avail of the opportunity——
Comment on this
I want to make quite clear that Deputy Smith brought in the scheme for the improvement of farm buildings.
Comment on this
But let it be clearly understood that it was not Deputy Smith who drew the blue pencil across that scheme in order to save £350,000. It is the present Minister for Agriculture, Mr. Dillon.
Comment on this
You can read all the files you like, but I have things that I can interpret too; the people will not get the improvements which they were getting under Fianna Fáil, and you are responsible for it.
Comment on this
I propose to be very brief on this Estimate, but I will commence with the concluding remarks of Deputy Killilea, who complains that the Minister for Agriculture put in abeyance the farm buildings scheme and the farm improvements scheme. The Deputy realises as well as anybody in this House that there is a cement shortage and a keen demand for houses at the present time and that the Government has to choose between the provision of cement for pig sties and the provision of cement for houses for the Irish people.
Comment on this
We build, down the country, with stones and we still have got stone masons, so that red herring is no good.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil had to do something to justify their existence during their period of office. Their outstanding achievement was the slaughter of our calves.
Comment on this
There is a difference between the slaughter of calves now which has not the Minister's blessing, and the slaughter of calves under the Fianna Fáil policy when every farmer who could prove that he had murdered a calf received 10/- on producing the skin.
He referred to the wheat scheme under the Fianna Fáil Government. It would have been better if Fianna Fáil had left the compulsory wheat scheme until the war came about when we would have had more fertile soil for better crops. When the war came we had what you might call a dust bowl in which to attempt to grow the necessary wheat in this country.
This Estimate appears to be something in the nature of a post-mortem on the agricultural industry. The Minister's statement on the Estimate is encouraging because he has indicated his plans for the future. He has encouraged the farmers to take the long view and plan for the future and not be planning from one day to another. We find the Minister standing alone amongst the shattered ruins of the agricultural industry and wondering which way to look so that he can bring some form of prosperity to that industry, which ought to be the main industry of the country. I know that he has a colossal task before him. I also know that the policy of Fianna Fáil has not been in favour of agriculture. It must be admitted by the Party themselves that the Fianna Fáil policy had a completely industrial bias, that if industry was to be put on its feet, agriculture had to suffer, and it did suffer.
The former Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Smith, spoke for something like four and a half hours on this Estimate. He abused the Minister and accused him of being unbalanced and irresponsible. He based those observations on some after-dinner speeches made by the Minister. No doubt, these speeches were made off the record: they were not official statements, and speaking after dinner the Minister was expected to give some form of topical expression to whatever matter was under discussion. I do not think Deputy Smith was justified in adopting the rôle of alienist in this matter. I think that people are able to form their own opinions, especially the farmers.
Comment on this
He is getting away with nothing so far as we are concerned. The farmers do not forget the bullying methods adopted by the previous Minister for Agriculture. They remember well his statement at Navan. That goes further into the minds of the farmers than the present Minister's expressions on some occasions after dinner. The Deputy complained that the farmers were conservative, which goes to show that they did not indicate any kind of reliance on the Fiana Fáil policy. Farmers are conservative and they certainly will not run into any stunts which might seem crazy to them. The calf population at present is the lowest yet recorded. That is a desperate position when we consider that in Great Britain and Europe there is an almost unlimited demand for fresh meat at the present time. I realise that the Minister has a difficult task before him to devise methods which will increase the calf population to a reasonable level within a short time.
Deputy Smith also in the course of his prolonged attack on the present Minister scorned modern farm methods. He implied that a stick tied to a donkey's tail is good enough for the Irish farmer, decrying the Minister's statement that he would prefer to see modern methods employed rather than the broken-winded horses which are used on various farms. He also said that some farms range from one to 20 acres. I do not see how Deputy Smith could see his way to feed two broken-winded horses on a five-acre farm. It is not economic. He could have something in the nature of a light tractor or machinery to till that land. In Rush there are farms of not more than five acres and the farmers there have tractors for tilling the land.
Comment on this
They are very busy farmers. They are market gardeners and I can assure the Deputy that they are able to get three crops out of their land in the 12 months. They are able to use tractors efficiently on less than one acre of land. Besides the four-wheel tractors, Deputies opposite should know that there are also the smaller machines which could be purchased by small landowners instead of attempting to feed horses on a small area of land. Deputies who are familiar with farming methods will agree with me that the cost of feeding a horse is something like £2 a week. The feeding of a useless broken-winded horse is not good economics, even though it may be argued that the manure could be put into the land, whereas with a tractor it is just a question of using the fuel. We would have been lucky in this country if we had succeeded in importing a sufficient number of tractors in 1938 or 1939 when they could have been got at a reasonable price.
Comment on this
The Deputy will remember that during the war tractors dating back to the years between 1915 and 1920 were sold at something in the region of £400 each. That shows the grave need there was during the emergency years for machinery instead of horses. Deputies who are aware of the conditions on the larger farms, on looking back, will see that the farmers with the larger farms were compelled to replace teams of horses by tractors because the tractors were able to do a greater amount of work, as efficiently as horses, in a shorter period of time. The British and the Northern Ireland farmers during the war years received subsidies. I will mention specially the potato subsidy. Agriculture in this country has not been subsidised to any such extent. In fact, we pay rates on agricultural land and that is not the case in Northern Ireland or Britain. Therefore the overhead charges in this country are far higher than they are in Britain. Light tractors can work quicker and better on these small farms that I have mentioned. I hope the Minister will devise a scheme whereby he can make such machinery available to farmers in a locality who cannot afford to buy it themselves.
Comment on this
There was some indication by the Minister that it was possible that in the future, tillage might be dispensed with. I would rather see a reduction in the tillage quota, even if it were a very drastic reduction, than a complete abandonment of the scheme of quotas. There is the possibility that some farmers who are not inclined to give employment will take advantage of it, whereas the ordinary farmer will carry on in a reasonable way. There are tillage contractors who have purchased anything from £1,000 to £5,000 worth of machinery. I have in mind a farmer who has three threshing-mills, six tractors and four lorries in operation. If compulsory tillage is abandoned he will lose. His machinery will become useless, because he carries out the tillage on other people's farms. He carries the tillage out on the farms of persons who cannot afford to till them themselves and who are not suitably fitted, as he is, to till. If compulsory tillage is completely abandoned these landholders will not let the land in conacre to this man who is carrying on as a tillage contractor. I have been informed that some farmers in Meath, rather than equip themselves to carry out compulsory tillage quotas, pay a contractor £1, £2 or £3 an acre to take the land from them and comply with the tillage regulations by tilling the necessary quota. That matter was mentioned in this House by a Deputy. This is an example where unemployment would be caused. The farmer whom I have just mentioned employs about 60 men for a period of four months. If the land is to be put into grass again, the question as to whether farmers have sufficient capital to fully stock their land arises. If they have not sufficient capital, especially in view of the shortage of live stock and the present high prices prevailing, it would seem that the land would not be producing and would not be giving employment either.
I should like the Minister to consider the abolition of compulsory tillage so far as dairy farmers are concerned— especially farmers who have a holding of normal size, having regard to the acreage of the farm and the number of cows on it. When it was indicated that, to some extent, compulsory tillage might be abolished in the future some farmers decided that they would not give any further employment. Luckily, that is not typical of the general farmer. He carries on mixed farming rather than give no employment at all. It is necessary that the Minister should devise a scheme whereby the quality of grass will be improved. Any Deputy who goes along a road and looks across the broad acres of land can see at a glance that the grass is not of good quality. The land needs to be treated in some way or other—probably by lime or phosphates —to produce a good class of grass. It is the same as anything else—an acre of land will produce more grass if it is a good type of grass. I understand that there is a farm in County Dublin which makes grass meal. The particular machine concerned mows the grass, processes it and sends it out in the form of meal all in the one operation. It is not disputed that grass meal, especially if it is of good class, has a high feeding content. For that reason I am anxious that the Minister will take active steps to improve the class of grass growing in our grasslands.
The sheep population at the present time is very low. There is a strong demand for mutton outside this country as well as inside it. It seems to me that the most desirable action that the Minister could take in this matter is to prevent the slaughter of ewe lambs because in the near future it might be one method of increasing the sheep population. That brings me to the question of wool prices. Farmer Deputies of this House will agree with me when I say that the price per pound for wool given to farmers bears little or no relation to the price of wool when it issues as a finished product. I should like to see the Minister devising a scheme whereby the price received for the raw material would bear some relation to the cost of the finished article.
The pig position is pretty bad at the moment. We must remember that, besides the farmers, the farm workers participated in the past in the production of pigs and the ultimate production of bacon. I should like to see the Minister bringing forward some kind of scheme that would encourage agricultural workers to feed pigs and have them for sale periodically as they did in the past. Bacon quotas in the shops apparently do not satisfy the demand that there is for bacon at the present time. On inquiry I have ascertained that the shopkeepers are receiving their full quotas. Illegal curing destroys any effort the Minister or anybody else may aim at in the matter of increasing pig production. I would urge the Minister to put down all classes of illegal curing because it is the most destructive method that can be adopted so far as the destruction of the pig population is concerned.
The wheat price of 62/6 per barrel over a period of five years offers a good business to the farmers. Taking the long view, the farmer will be in a position to calculate what return he will receive from any particular acreage. He will be able to choose the number of acres suitable to himself — the acres that he can have properly fertilised and treated for the production of a good paying crop. Besides farmyard manure, fertilisers have proved to be very valuable so far as wheat is concerned. In fact, it is true that the application of fertiliser increases a wheat crop to the extent of 50 per cent. on reasonable land. That is a very considerable measure of improvement when it comes to reaping the crop and balancing the farm budget.
There is an unlimited scope for agricultural production at the present time. In the development and in the stepping-up of agricultural production, I believe that the machine will have to take a very prominent part. For that reason I hope that the Minister will take some steps to equip farmers with all classes of useful instruments. I am sure that that work can be done through the various county committees of agriculture. If the Minister succeeds in creating prosperity amongst the farming community the farmer will be in a position to pay better wages to his farm workers. Nobody disputes the fact that the standard of pay of farm workers, having regard to the skilled nature of their work, bears very little relation to the wages received by employees in other occupations. The farm worker is a very skilled individual. He has to be a veterinary surgeon, a mechanic and a scientist all at the one time. That is why I say that he should be regarded as a highly skilled individual and paid accordingly.
It is reassuring to know from the Minister that he proposes raising the barley price from 45/- to 55/-. It is a step in the right direction. It is a step nearer to the world market price. It is desirable that as far as prices for agricultural goods in this country are concerned, and especially having regard to the demand for produce outside this country, we should get as near to the world market price as possible.
This brings me to the question of costings. The Minister will, I am sure, agree that if some form of costings were in operation it would help the farmers as a guide in their own budgets. Even if such costings were only crudely done and even if they did not fully represent normal conditions they would be of considerable assistance. These costings could be done on the model farms. It might be argued by the ordinary farmers that conditions on the model farms are very different from the conditions on the ordinary farms. At the same time such costings would fill a gap in farming economy generally.
The sugar beet position is not as encouraging as it might be. There are some drawbacks in the growing of beet. I would suggest to the Minister that he should confer with the Minister for Finance as to the possibility of increasing the price of sugar by 1d. per lb. That extra 1d. would give a good return to the growers and it might in time have the effect of bringing about the abolition of the rationing system.
A good deal of criticism has been levelled against meat prices at the present time. I believe the present high level of prices is bound to continue so long as the demand is greater than the supply. When conditions return to normal prices will fall because the world market will then bring to bear once more its influence in the sphere of competition. So long as there is a scarcity there will be difficulty in regard to retail prices. In the coming year we shall find it difficult to meet the full demand of the British market for meat. So long as that position obtains the retail price of meat in this country will create difficulties and problems for the Ministers concerned.
So far as the dairying industry is concerned, I am convinced that in our particular farming economy the dual-purpose cow is the most valuable animal we can have. I believe that the dual-purpose cow is a definite asset when we come to consider which particular class of live stock we should cultivate in this country. We must take the long view. For that reason I am in favour of the double dairy cow. If it comes to the point where the Minister has to decide in favour of one class of live stock as against another, then I say that he should definitely take the dual-purpose animal.
I would appeal to the Minister to take immediate steps to prevent the slaughter of calves. In various hotels and restaurants at the moment veal is available on the menu. It is our endeavour to increase the live-stock population. If we permit the killing of prime veal calves we cannot expect to bring about the desired effect.
Deputy Major de Valera said that the price of vegetables was too high. So far as the farmers of County Dublin are concerned, the retail price of vegetables bears very little relation to the price the farmers get for their produce in the markets. So far as vegetables are concerned it is, therefore, a question of marketing.
I feel that some steps should be taken to make provision for the inclusion of instruction in agriculture in the curriculum of the rural schools. It must be appreciated that the majority of the children attending these schools will eventually be either farmers themselves or agricultural labourers. Systematic education in agriculture is important from the point of view of future generations.
I know it is the Minister's intention to give a square deal to the farmers. I know it is his desire to put our main industry on its feet. If he succeeds in restoring our live-stock population and the fertility of our soil, thereby increasing the volume of agricultural production, he will create a measure of prosperity in the country such as it has not heretofore known and that prosperity, in turn, will percolate to industry, commerce and the professions. We all know that, fundamentally, prosperity comes from the soil. We have a fertile soil capable of development. We have a soil that will react favourably to proper treatment. I am convinced that the Minister will succeed in his determination to restore the fertility to our soil, thereby assuring us of prosperity in the future.
Comment on this
Mhair an díospóireacht seo tamall maith agus ní maith liom cur léi go mór. Ní cainteoir leadránach mé agus déanfad mo dhicheall gan a bheith leadránach an iarraidh seo; ach ní féidir liom an ócáid seo a ligint tharm gan tagairt a dhéanamh do chúis gearáin amháin. Chualamuid trácht ó gach taobh den Teach ar mheasaisíní, tractors, cruithneacht, earnan, eallach reamhar, ba bainne, im agus eile, ach, fairíor, ní bhaineann ceachtar de na rudaí sin ro-dluth leis na ceantracha cúnga, bochta, iargulta. Níor chualamuid glór na Gaeltachta fós sa díospóireacht. Is minic a deirtear go mbíonn an iomarca cur i gcéill i dtaobh na Gealtachta.
Ach ní raibh aon chur i gcéill ag an bhfear a bhí in áit an Aire atá anois ann—An Teachta MacGabhann —nuair a bhunaigh sé na tithe gloine; agus ní raibh aon chur i gcéill ag an Aire nuair a dúirt sé gan frapa gan taca ar a chéad mheastacháin go raibh sé lena stopadh. Bhí an Teachta MacGabhann i ndearmad, áfach, nuair a dúirt sé gur athraigh an tAire a intinn i dtaobh na ceiste ar iarratas toscaireachta a tháinig aniar chuige. Tamall i ndiaidh an toscaireacht i gcomhairle leis, chuireas-sa ceist Dála air ag iarraidh air cúigear iarrthóirí a thoghadh in ionad cúigear eile a tharraing siar as an Scéim. D'fhreagair sé is dúirt nach dtoghfadh, mar gur dóigh leis nach raibh sa scéim ach caimiléaracht déisteanach. D'fhiafraíos annsin de cad chuige, más amhlaidh a bhí, nár chuir sé deireadh ar fad leis an scéim, agus dúirt sé go gcuirfeadh marach go raibh gafa ro-fhada léi ag an Aire a bhí ann roimhe, agus go raibh a lámha ceangailte mar gheall air. Ní raibh aon mhuga-magadh aige faoi. Is mór an truaigh nach mbreithneodh an tAirn scéim ar a fiúntas fhéin. Má fhaghane sé blas nó boladh Fhianne Fáil ar rud ar bith bíonn déistean air dó. Tá an oiread sin gráin aige don scéim seo gur dóigh le gach duine a bhfuil baint ar bith aige léi nach féidir rath a bheith uirthi. Chualas scéal greannmhar le goirid faoi seo. Bhí oifigigh de chuid na Roinne ag cur spréála nó rud éigin as buidéil ar na planndaí. Bhí amhras ar chuid de na daoine gur rud nimheanta a bhí ann a dhéanfadh dochar do na trátaí agus bhíodar idir dhá chomhairle ar chóir dóibh bac a chur leis na h-oifigigh. 'Séard a deirtear freisin. go bhfóiridh Dia ar na h-oifigigh, mara bhféachfaidh siad chuige go loicfidh an toradh. Ar ndóigh is caint ráiméiseach í, ach sé mochtadh intinne an Aire cionntsiocair leí. Cé go bhfuil an tAire in aghaidh na scéime ba chóir dó, ós rud é go gcaithfear dul ar aghaidh leí, a theaspáint do na daoine, agus go mór-mhór do na h-oifigigh, go mba mhaith leis go n-éireoch léi thar cionn. Tá ré na míorbhuilt thart, ach síltear go mba mhíorbhuilt é dá n-éiriódh leis an rud seo agus an tAire ina haghaidh. Bhí sé, scathamh, ina Theachta do Thír Chonaill agus tuigeann sé comh cruaidh is tá saol na Gaeltachta, agus ní h-é an doicheall a beifí ag súil leis uaidh roimh rud ar bith a dhéanfadh a leas nó a d'fhreagródh dóibh. Níor dochar ar bith dó dá ngabhfadh sé siar agus dá míníodh sé do na daoine an t-údar a bhí aige leis an gcaint a rinne sé sa gcúis seo, agus dá míníodh sé céard tá faoi a dhéanamh dóibh ina háit. Idir gheáitsí an Aire faoi na tithe gloine agus stopadh obair na móna, ní fhéadfadh muintir na gceanntracha bochta gan a bheith den tuairim nach í an Ghaeltacht atá ag déanamh imní don Rialtas seo, ach a mhalairt.
Tá scéim eile a rinne an-leas do na ceantracha cúnga agus sí sin Feabhsú na bhFeilm. Tá aicme daoine, áfach, nach bhfuil buntáiste na scéime seo ag dul dóibh agus sin iad na lanúna óga a dhéanas botháin amuigh ar an gcimín. Ní bhíonn teideal faoin dlí acu chuig an talamh. Is amhlaidh a phósas mac le tionónta amháin, iníon le tionónta eile, agus ní chuireann aon tionónta in aghaidh an lanúna óig nuair a shaothraíos cuid den chimín agus a chuireas siad fúthu air. Sé mo thuairim gur fearr iad a fheiceál ag fanacht ar an tuaith ná dul isteach i seomraí i nGaillim nó i mbaile mór eile agus a bheith ag braith ar chúnamh poiblí. Tá na daoine óga seo ag déanamh obair mhaith agus ag saothrú droch-thalamh nach saothrófaí ar aon bhealach eile. 'Sé m'iarratas ar an Aire go ndéanfadh sé pé athrú is gá chun go mbeadh buntáiste na scéime ar fáil ag an dream seo atá ag saothrú na talún chomh maith, agus béidir níos cruaidhe, ná talmhaithe ar bith eile.
Comment on this
Much has been said during this debate regarding the production and price of milk. I have a few remarks to make in that connection which I hope will not unduly delay the House. The greater part of the constituency which I have the honour to represent is catered for by two large co-operative societies and the Dairy Disposals Company. These three organisations constitute the only market for milk in that huge area and the plea I wish to make here is on behalf of farmers who cannot avail of any of these organisations to market their milk.
I wish, first of all, to pay a very well-deserved tribute to the Dairy Disposals Company for the enormous amount of work and organisation that they put into the provision of a market for milk in the Beara peninsula. There is no doubt that they did a very decent job there. In a short time, they built up an organisation that catered for every gallon of milk in that remote and difficult area. Their efforts have been crowned with success, one of the most successful undertakings we have seen operated by that or any other organisation in that part of the country.
For many years I have been exhorting the officials of the company to extend their efforts to the Glengarriff area. It would be a very easy matter for them when they have a travelling creamery on the road from Castletownbere to Droumgollane to continue a few miles further on to Glengarriff, take up the milk there and separate it. They have failed so far to connect with that district. They had one excuse or another—the scarcity of lorries and machinery—during the war, but I think this should not hold any longer. There is no reason now, with machinery and lorries available, why that area could not be catered for, either from Castletownbere or from Kenmare from which a travelling creamery comes to Bonane to within a few miles on the north side. I know the quantity of milk available there is small but I am satisfied, from my experience, that a travelling creamery, even with small supplies, would provide a market where none exists at the moment. During the time that the Dairy Disposals Company have been operating travelling creameries in the Beara peninsula they have given satisfaction to the farmers.
Much has been said about costs of production and the price of milk generally over the country, but I think the first thing our farmers want is to have a market for the milk. Milk is being produced at the moment in a few areas in which there is no market for it, more especially since the subsidy was removed on home-produced butter. These people were able to get a fair price for home-produced butter up to recently but now they require this market more than ever. They also require some organisation to assist them in the poultry scheme there. It is true that about 12 months ago the Dairy Disposals Company started this industry in the area. They set up a hatchery and purchased a farm to raise stock. I think they should go a bit further and they should be empowered to give credit to their suppliers where it is required for the purchase of stock such as poultry and cattle. That is one great fault that I have to find with them in that area, that they do not give credit to their customers to purchase commodities which they do not sell themselves.
In passing, I should like to place on record my horror at the company's entering into competition with local merchants in the sale of any kind of retail goods that they have not hitherto sold. In other words, I do not think that the company should be allowed to go into the retail trade of goods which they have not been retailing in the past. If they are allowed to do that, it would certainly be to the detriment of local merchants and the local towns eventually.
There is some kind of unwritten law by which co-operative societies had, more or less, a monopoly or a right to trade in a particular area for themselves. I am sure that is done after consultation with the officials of the Department. At any rate, there are boundaries beyond which one co-operative society may not enter into competition with another co-operative society. The same applies with regard to the co-operative societies and the Dairy Disposals Company. I have in mind an extensive area where there are 300 or 400 farmers, good, hardworking, industrious farmers who can get more out of an acre than farmers in any other part of the country. These people have no market for their milk. There is a stretch of country extending from Glengarriff to Kealkil where there is a branch of the Drinagh Co-operative Society's creamery, and there is also a branch in Bantry, but the whole area from Snave, Coomhola, through the Borlin Valley to the Kerry border is absolutely unprovided for.
Officials of the Dairy Disposals Company have time and again given the excuse of shortage of lorries and machinery. Like the Glengarriff area, I hold that these excuses can apply no longer, and that the Drinagh Co-operative Society should get instructions to provide creamery facilities for that area or the Dairy Disposals Company should provide them. It would be very easy for one or the other to put a travelling creamery on the road from Bantry or Kealkil. The Drinagh Co-operative Society could put a travelling creamery on the road to take in all that country and return to Kealkil with the cream. If they refuse to do that and say that this valley does not belong to their area, I think the Dairy Disposals Company should be asked by the Minister to proceed with the work there. They could very easily work it in from Kilgarvan, over the hill to the Borlin Valley and on to Glengarriff and back to Kenmare or Castletownbere. I trust that steps will be taken immediately to provide creamery facilities for that area which appears to be no man's land, in so far as the co-operative societies are concerned.
There is another similar area which is right in the heart of the Drinagh Co-operative Society's territory, if I may call it so, the Mealagh Valley. The end of this valley is only about eight miles from the creamery itself and the people on both sides of the Mealagh River have not been given proper creamery facilities. They are hard-working and industrious farmers who have been producing milk and are anxious to produce, but cannot get a satisfactory market for it, being too far away from the creamery. It is clearly the duty of the Drinagh Co-operative Society to put a travelling creamery in that valley and so give the people there an opportunity to market their milk.
This co-operative society has another area in its territory which is worthy of more consideration—Whiddy Island, in Bantry Bay. This island has a very industrious, intelligent and hardworking population of farmers. They have excellent land and very good cattle. Time and again, we have made representations to the Drinagh Co-operative Society to provide some creamery facilities on the island. What they want is a separating station, so that the cream can be brought across to Bantry by the boat which plies with the post every day. The Drinagh Co-operative Society's officials have examined this matter and they have given various excuses, but during all the years no creamery facilities have been provided for Whiddy Island. It is within two miles of Bantry town and has good farmers, good land, good cattle and a good supply of milk. I trust that the Minister will be able to renew representations to the Drinagh Co-operative Society and, if they still refuse to provide the facilities, that some arrangement will be made by which the Dairy Disposals Company will collect the cream there.
On the southern side of that constituency, the Dairy Disposals Company have been operating for the past couple of years and have succeeded in providing a much-wanted market for milk in the Goleen area. This was also a very remote area for which co-operative societies refused to cater, and the people of the area have expressed their satisfaction with the provision made by the Dairy Disposals Company; but I am not satisfied that the company has done as much organisation in that peninsula between Skibbereen and Mizen Head as they could have done in the past 12 months or two years. It is quite true that they have provided this very much-wanted market for milk in the Goleen area, but they have built a centre at Aughadown and have not yet succeeded in organising the areas in between.
I am not satisfied, either, with the way the company has handled the area around Ballydehob. As the House is aware, the Dairy Disposals Company took over the interests of creamery proprietors in that area and they have been dilly-dallying too long with the Ballydehob area. In my opinion, they have not played fair with the local creamery proprietors while they have entered into competition with them in taking milk from that area.
The farmers of that area have long been requesting that a stop for a creamery will be provided there and they are still awaiting the provision of a stop for a travelling creamery which would be central in that area. With all the speed made in earlier years by this company, I cannot understand why they have not succeeded in organising that area to a greater extent and with more efficiency.
The position regarding all these areas that I have mentioned is really urgent and could be remedied with very little loss of time if the company got down to it. The position of the farmers who were depending on marketing their butter in the past is now definitely very critical, and the only way they can be helped is to provide a market for their milk. I trust the Minister will consider the position regarding the areas I have mentioned and remedy matters in the way I have suggested or, possibly, in some better way, with the least possible delay.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom cúpla focal goirid a rá faoin scéin tábhachtach sin a chuir Rialtas Fianna Fáil ar bun i nGaeltacht Thír Chonail anuiridh nó i dtús na bliana sco. Táim ag trácht ar an scéim chéanna a ndearna an Teachta Mac Pharthaláin tagaint di, scéim na dtithe gloine. Ba mhaith liom a rá go raibh brón agus íontas orainn go léir nach raibh an tAire sásta dul ar aghaidh leis an scéim sin nó leis an scéim a mhéadú nó a leathnú ar na Gaeltachta go léir. Sin í an intins a bhí ag Rialtas Fianna Fáil, go raibh siad leis an scéim a leathnú ar fud na Gaeltachta chun cuidiú le saol na ndaoine sna límistéir sin. Ba mhaith liom insint don Aire go bhfuil an scéim sin ag dul ar aghaidh go h-an-mhaith i dTír Chonaill. Gach aon duine atá baint aige leis an scéim, tá sé íontach sásta leis an dóigh a bhfuil sé ag aghaidh agus táid den bharúil gur cheart an scéim a leathnú agus na tithe gloine a chur ar bun ins na háiteacha nach bhfuil an scéim sin ag obair go fóill.
Tá brón orm, dá réir, go bhfuil saol níos measa ag muintir Thír Chonaill i mbliana nar mar a bhí de blianta. Tá níos mó imithe ón Ghaeltacht ná d'imigh le 20 bliain. Tá scéim na móna críochnaithe agus, mar is eol don Aire, níl an talamh ansin maith go leor le daoine a choinneáil sa bhaile agus caithfidh an Rialtas scéimeanna den tsort seo, scéimeanna cosúil le tithe gloine, a chur ar bun le cuidiú leis na daoine ansin gléas beatha a bhaint amach ins an phairt sin den tír.
Má tá an scéim ag dul ar aghaidh go maith i dTír Chonaill, tá mise den bharúil gur cheart don Aire a rá linn go bhfuil sé fá choinne cuidiú leis an nGaeltacht agus na tigthe seo a chur sna háiteacha nach bhfuil siad ann go fóill. Tá mise den bharúil go bhfuil sé ag dul ar aghaidh mar sin agus gur cheart don Aire smaointiú ar aon Ghaeltacht nach bhfuair na tithe sin go fóill agus cuidiú leis na daoine annsin sa dóigh céanna a chuidigh Rialtas Fianna Fáil le paráiste chloich Chinn Fhaolaigh, i dTír Chonaill agus paráiste eile i gCo. na Gaillimhe. Tá sé íontach deacair a thuiscint go bhfuil an Rialtas —mar tá an Rialtas—ag dul ag sábháil airgid ar scéimeanna den tsort sin san am céanna iad ag iarraidh daoine a choinneáil beo ins an nGaeltacht.
Cloisimid cuid mhaith de na Teachtaí ag cainnt faoin nGaeltacht agus chomh tábhachtach is atá sé scéimeanna a bheapadh leis an aos óg a choinneáil sa chaile agus saol na ndaoine d'fheabhsú. Ba cheart don Aire dul ar aghaidh leis an scéim a chuir an Rialtas deiridh ar bun. Níor thug sé seans éigin don scéim sin agus ba cheart dó amharc isteach sa cheist agus, má tá sé ag dul ar aghaidh go maith, insint don Dáil agus do lucht na Gaeltachta go bhfuil sé fá choinne an scéim a mhéadú agus a leathnú ar fúd na Gaeltachta go léir.
Comment on this
Is slán do gach saoránach a ionad cónaithe agus ní cead dul isteach ann go foiréigneach ach do réir dlí. Tá a fhios agaibh cá háit a bhfuil na focla sin inniu. Bhí siad ar bhratha an Land League 70 bliain ó shoin agus tá siad chomh fíor inniu agus a bhí siad 70 bliain ó shoin. Ach, deirimse anseo, is slán do gach saoránach a ionad conaithe agus ní cead do chigire dul isteach ann ach do réir dlí.
It appears, according to the Deputies who belong to the Fianna Fáil Party that the law that I have just read out of the Constitution—"The dwelling of every citizen is inviolable and shall not be forcibly entered save in accordance with the law"—is to be the fundamental right of only such citizens of this State as are not farmers. I have just said that these words are taken from the Constitution but they first appeared upon the standards of the Land League. We invoked them and those who went before us invoked them to establish the principle that the people of this country who live and get their living on the land would have the right to stand upon their threshold and forbid any man to cross it until they invited him. There was a good deal of blood spilt in this country and a good deal of suffering undergone to establish that no landlord and no land-lord's bailiff would force his way into any kitchen in this country until the farmer, large or small, ten acres or 1,000 acres, invited him in.
Very well; I believe that that is just as true to-day and just as well worth fighting for in 1948 as it was in 1878, and I want to re-establish the doctrine in this country that, on the holdings of our people, no officer of my Department, from the Minister down to the most junior officer, shall have the right to enter uninvited. If the people of this country want a different rule of law, then they must have a different Minister because, so long as I am Minister for Agriculture, no officer of my Department will use my name to force his way unwanted, in the ordinary discharge of his duty, on to the holding of any free citizen of this country. I do not subscribe to the view that the farmers of this country have to be flogged into doing their day's work.
Comment on this
I do not subscribe to the view that, when we do not claim the right to tell the storekeeper what to do, or tell the doctor what to do, or tell the contractor or anybody else what to do, we have any right to go in and tell the farmer when he must get up and go to bed, how he is to work his land, what he is to plant, when he is to sow and reap.
Comment on this
If the farmers are incapable of using the land of Ireland without supervision and coercion every hour of their lives, we can throw our hats at it. I am staking my political existence on the proposition that there are no people in the world better able to use the land of Ireland to the greatest advantage than the farmers who live and get their living on it; and, given access to the implements and the requisites with which to cultivate that land, it will be the most fruitful land upon the surface of the earth.
Comment on this
In five years' time, I will not be one bit afraid to go to the country, in any constituency in Ireland, whether it is a city constituency or a country constituency; and I venture to prophesy that, whether they are city dwellers or country dwellers, they will demonstrate by their votes that we are right and Fianna Fáil was wrong. We believe in free men on the land of our country and we are sick of fighting for the right to be free in our own country.
There is no Government, foreign or domestic, that will keep our people on the land in the position of hewers of wood and drawers of water. There has been for long enough in this country a proposition that, if you are an industrialist or a tariff racketeer or an exploiter, you are entitled to wear a silk hat and drive in a Chrysler car and keep a house standing in its own grounds in the suburbs of Dublin, and draw your living out of the little men, the insignificant men, the hardworking men who live upon the land. That day is over. The farmers of this country are now the big men, the farmers of this country are now the people that matter and it is the interest of the farmers of this country which will be the first charge upon the Government that we now have. Is that clear to everybody? When I say "the farmers of this country", I mean the men and women who live upon the land and get their living on the land, whether they be tenant purchasers of their land or the agricultural workers, moving with dignity about their work, hoping that they some day will also enter the privileged ranks of those who are to be farmer-proprietors in due time. There is no step forward that the farmers of this country can make in prestige or comfort that may be made with justice unless those who own the land and enjoy its fruits remember that, as their prosperity progresses, they have an obligation in justice to share it with the workers who work for them.
Comment on this
Now, Sir, I cannot find it in me to resent Deputy Burke's intervention, because I am conscious of not having been guiltless myself, in extenuation of which I direct to your attention that on the first day I sat in this debate for four hours, on yesterday I sat for 14 hours, and to-day I have sat for nine hours. Fifty-four speeches have been made upon this Estimate, and I confess that I was not born a patient man—and we cannot be other than what God made us. I glory in the fact that there were 54 speeches made. This is one of the last free Parliaments in the world. God keep it so. I do not think Deputy Smith did himself much credit in speaking for four hours, but he had the right to do that if he wanted to, and there is something glorious in the knowledge that there is a Ceann Comhairle presiding over our proceedings who will defend that right and maintain it, whether the Deputy who does speak for four hours sits on the Front Bench or in the least significant seat this House provides.
If I have been, on occasion, less placid than the Chair would have wished, I must plead in extenuation nearly 30 hours' listening, with an introduction of four hours by Deputy Smith, whose peroration on the first day was: "I am a wonderful man, there is no doubt about it, and there is not a member of this Party of mine who does not believe it. That is the main thing about it." When he got up again for another two hours the next day, he said it was a source of amazement to him that the radio did not report anything he said and the evening paper did not print anything he said—and when you read the Official Report since, is it any wonder, when they tried to make out of that something to put on the radio or in the evening paper, do the best they could, they could make neither head nor tail of it?
Some charitable soul, sitting up overnight with a wet towel around his head, endeavoured to make something of it for the morning paper and, to the eternal credit of the Press, I must say that, apart from some of his wilder extravagances, it did appear at least coherent, which it most unquestionably was not for those who heard him. I plead again, in extenuation, that I was constrained to listen to lamentations for the decline in the number of calves, from the greatest calf butcher in history, Deputy Dr. Ryan. There is no man whose arms are more deeply steeped in the blood of calves than Deputy Dr. Ryan. I then was obliged to listen to a Fianna Fáil T.D. up there who worked himself into a passion because the neighbouring woman could get only 1/9 or 2/- for her farmers' butter. In the next breath he accused me of having started a black market in butter at 3/6 per lb., and thought it was nothing wonderful to say these two things in two consecutive breaths. Then I had to listen to Deputy Walsh spluttering about the value of the fat cattle that went to the Continent last year and that compared with the fats that were sent to England, the reason being that his own colleague, Deputy Smith, went over to London last November and after great craving and begging there got the British Minister for Agriculture to increase the price of fat cattle by 5d. a lb., on the strict understanding that it would be cut to 4d. on the 1st of March. When the increase was given the fats went to England. They had been sitting on the land because they could not get out, and it was because they could not get out that Deputy Smith went to London last autumn.
Now, I want to deal categorically and exhaustively with the measure of my offending according to Fianna Fáil. I understand it comes down to the glass-houses, the inspectors and the farm buildings scheme. These are my principal crimes, I understand. I sometimes think they are mad because they must know I have the files and the documents to answer them. Do they think I am a fool or that I am going to allow them to blackguard or misrepresent me when I have the particulars here in front of me? A time must come, sooner or later, when they will so exhaust my patience that I will read out the whole file. That is what I am going to do now in regard to the glass-house scheme. Connemara is dying about the glass-house scheme. Poor Deputy Smith and Deputy Ryan and their lovely glass-house scheme! What is the history of the glass-house scheme? I will tell the House. It begins with a letter, "A Chara", and then, of course, it is all in English. Next, Proinnsias Mac Aogáin drops a hint to the then Minister for Agriculture that he would appear to be overlooking his duties and making "a slight suggestion that he should invest a considerable sum of money in building glass-houses in Connemara". After a great deal of excogitation in the Department, An tAire Talmhaiochta replies on the 25th June, 1946, as follows:—
"Dear Frank,
You wrote me last September about a scheme for glass-house culture in Gaeltacht districts with particular reference to the growing of tomatoes and I replied to you giving you my opinion on the scheme a few days afterwards and promised to get the observations of the Department.
I expressed the opinion in my letter to you last September that outside tomatoes the prospects were much less hopeful. I still think there is a small market for cucumbers. We tried some years ago to encourage the production of grapes by putting on a tariff against the imported crop. We got no response and the tariff was dropped. The Dublin market is very sensitive as regards peaches. The opportunity for expansion of peach-growing can be dismissed as negligible.
The full merits of the scheme could, therefore, be assessed at a capital expenditure of £400,000 to £500,000 benefiting 1,000 growers with the possibility that these 1,000 producers would after a few years need a permanent subsidy to keep them in production and the strong probability that the full capital expenditure would never be repaid. If your committee think that we should, notwithstanding, proceed I am prepared to ask the Department to go ahead.
Yours sincerely."
There is no "mise le meas" in that letter.
Here is the technical opinion given to the Department on the 10th September, 1946:—
"The arguments which can be advanced in support of the scheme are, we find, few and unconvincing whilst the objections are many and seemingly overwhelming. A most important point for consideration is whether in view of the relatively small number of farmers to benefit an ambitious scheme involving such a considerable expenditure of public funds would be justified in view of the attendant risks of failure and loss to the State."
That was in 1946. Then the business went to sleep for a year, but it was dug up again. I next find that:—
"The Minister had before him an officer's record of the conference held on the 12th instant in which the scheme was discussed in detail. He said that he had little hope that this scheme would be a success if the Department had to impose conditions in regard to the repayment of cost of the houses as contemplated at conference referred to. He went on to say that in his opinion it was far more preferable to be prepared to lose entirely the cost of the erection of these houses rather than to impose conditions which would result in making it almost impossible to get people to take them up or if they are taken up to have the conditions such as would impair the success of the scheme. He directed, therefore, that the Department should envisage the erection of these houses almost as a free gift and that for a number of years at least the owners should receive the total proceeds of the tomato crop less such expenditure as would be incurred in supervising the scheme and marketing the produce."
That was a very encouraging forecast.
Twelve months later up she bobs again on the 20th June, 1947, but this time there is an interesting addendum: "The Minister for Finance is to be kept fully informed through the private secretary to the Minister for Agriculture of progress and development." It becomes increasingly clear that every time this comes up to the Department of Agriculture it is put to bed, and every time they put it to bed the Minister for Finance digs it out again.
Then we proceed to the stage in which we are to acquire the land for the central station. In Knock-Carraroe area it was found on investigation, however, that there was only one site of approximately half an acre that was really suitable. Following negotiation, we secured this site at the rate of £400 per acre. It is nice to keep the wheel turning in Carraroe. But not to be outdone, we went to Gortahork and we located a suitable three-quarters of an acre there, and we took it for a 25-year lease at an annual rate of £20 a year. As long as people can get £20 a year for three-quarters of an acre of land in Gortahork there is no need for tomato houses.
That is the position with which I was confronted when I came into office. As far as I could find out, the general impression in my Department, as far as expert opinion was concerned, was that there was no prospect whatever of these people being able to earn on these tomatoes sufficient money to pay back the capital commitments for which they made themselves liable under the agreement. The amount, I think, was £150 in respect of each house constructed. I foresaw a situation in which, when the time came for the people to pay it back, they would not be able to do so, and instead of conferring a benefit on each of them they were being saddled with a burden under which they had been urged to go. I did not think it was just to allow a situation to develop in which, to my mind, they would seriously embarrass themselves, and I recommended that the scheme be stopped. Father Moran came up here and shouted at me very loudly and I shouted at him. Next, Father Eaton came along. Father Eaton is a young curate there. He said to me: "Minister, these people, rightly or wrongly, believe that they have a claim in natural justice to the performance of what they understood to be a promise of a Minister of State to carry out the undertakings they had been given." Rightly or wrongly, I replied: "Father Eaton, if these people believe that they have a claim in natural justice to the performance of what they understood to be the promise of a Minister for State, that is an argument I cannot resist. Communicate with those persons who did not get a glass-house built for them as a result of the direction I have given and tell them that if they write in and say that they believe that in natural justice that they have a claim to the performance of the promise of a Minister of State, I will direct a glass-house to be built for them." Most of them wrote in, with the exception, I think, of three, and the houses were built.
The Deputy from Connemara and Deputy Breslin seemed to suggest that consequent on that I did my best to frustrate the scheme. That is an unworthy kind of misrepresentation. Far from that being so, I directed the officer appointed by my predecessor to supervise the scheme to be whole time with explicit instructions that nothing in his power to do should be left undone in order to make this a success if it could be made a success, and if any additional help or alteration should be brought into operation in order to make it a success, not to hesitate to let us know, and if it was humanly possible to do it, it would be done. The same applied to Gortahork. The matter that must be rectified now is the sale of the tomatoes. I got offers for them and I do not think those offers were fair. I would be obliged to the Deputies from these constituencies if they could do anything to get better and fairer prices. If I cannot sell them locally I will bring them to the Dublin market if need be. One thing is certain, however, I am not going to let anyone get away with the idea that because the fruit happens to be in Connemara or Gortahork, it can be bought at rubbish prices, because it can not. If necessary I will bring it to Dublin and sell it in the usual way on commission in the market as any other dealer would sell it. But it should be possible to sell it in Galway or Sligo or in towns in Donegal and get a reasonable price. It would be better to sell it locally as it would save on transport, but it will not be sold at rubbish prices. If any distributor thinks he has got a soft bargain there let him think again.
Comment on this
If the Minister will permit me I would like to ask one question. From listening to what he has said, it might be thought that the Minister would have some trouble with people who have glass-houses. I understand, however, that there is a clause in the agreement between the Department of Agriculture and the grower, the man upon whose land the glass-house is, that in the event of his not paying, the Department has the right to remove the structure, and in the event of the grower saying that he does not want to go ahead, he can ask the Department to remove it.
Comment on this
I think I can say to the Deputy, and that I may say it with the full approval of the Government, that the people engaged in this scheme are not going to be salted. We will do our level best to make a success of it. My advice to them is to do their best to make a success of it, but that they are not going to be left in a state of serious loss as a result of its success or failure. That is what both the Minister of the Deputy's Party and my Party intend whether it is in the agreement or not.
That is the story of the tomatoes. There is nothing I have done which, if I had to do it all again, I would not do exactly as before. I think the scheme is a thoroughly rotten one and I wanted to protect as many as I could from becoming involved in it, but when it was represented to me that they believed they had a claim in natural justice to the performance of the promise of a Minister of State I could not resist that representation and accordingly I changed my mind. If it is a crime to yield to that kind of argument, I committed that crime of changing my mind under the coercion of an argument which I felt I could not deny. If I had to do the same thing at the present moment I would do it without the slightest hesitation.
The next iniquity I am accused of is the question of inspectors. I have said 100 times that I strenuously object to the system of sending out inspectors to snoop around our people's homes telling them to do this or that. A vicious piece of misrepresentation was started by which the Fianna Fáil Party sought to create the impression that the strictures that I passed on that system were aimed, not at the inspectors who considered themselves or who wished to think of themselves as the masters of our people, but at the instructors of the Department of Agriculture, the overseers and assistant overseers who have moved among the people and always helped them in their work. It is true technically that they are all known in my Department as inspectors, but the best way, perhaps, to express the difference between them is that it is the same as the difference between "múinteoir" and "cigire", and it is the "cigire" I am talking about. But I want to say that when we spoke, when I spoke, in terms of stringent condemnation of the system of sending inspectors here and sending them there, as I have said on many occasions, those strictures should not fall on the inspectors themselves, but upon the system that has called them. For that we in this House are responsible. We made the law, we sent them out. I do not believe that they enjoy, any more than any of us would, breaking in on their neighbours' land and interfering with their neighbours' day-to-day work, but we told them to do it.
It was the system we created and by which we sent them out that I have always been concerned to denounce and destroy. I am glad to think that the day has come when I have the power to destroy it and, please God, it will never raise its head again. But let me add this. Tillage inspectors have been appointed every year since compulsory tillage came into force. For the last five years when June and July came all the tillage inspectors were dismissed. I would not permit the dismissal of a single one of them until I first found out who were the married men amongst them and recommended that every married man should be kept on as long as it was possible to keep him. The second category was those men who had qualifications, who had shown a desire to get on and improve themselves. For the remainder of single men without family responsibilities the rule was to apply rigidly— last man in, first man out. No one was to be dismissed until we published an advertisement in the papers asking anyone who wanted a land steward or a farm manager to send in an application so that we might recommend some of these young men for interview with a view to getting them employment rather than kicking them out the door. These are the facts. Yet I am represented as not looking after their welfare having a personal animus against them and desiring in any way I could to humiliate them before the public. In fact I am the only Minister for Agriculture who has ever concerned himself about their welfare or sought to secure employment for them. I am continuing at the present moment to do all I can in that direction and shall continue to do so.
I want to say something about farm buildings. I am told that I came in here to mislead the House and that my concern was falsely to suggest that the reason why the farm buildings scheme was being held over for the constructional work until next year was because there was a shortage of supplies. The most strident accuser was Deputy Smith. The only difference between Deputy Smith and me in regard to this matter is that I came in and told the House the truth and that Deputy Smith came in with exactly the same information and told them what was not true. Deputy Lemass is now as quiet as a mouse. Why is he as quiet as a mouse? Because I have a letter from him forbidding Deputy Smith to put a stone upon a stone in 1948, and I am going to read it:
"9th December, 1947.
"Dear Paddy,
"A reply is being sent by this post to your Department's minute of 4th December regarding your scheme of grants for the improvement of farm buildings. You will see that the reply sounds a note of warning regarding cement supplies. Though the cement factories are in full production the demand is more than the supply and difficulty is being experienced in getting cement for the building and engineering work at present in progress. The shortage will, I fear, be more than a temporary one. We shall try to make supplies available but it would be impossible for us to give you an assurance that you will get your full requirements for your scheme even on the restricted basis which you propose for 1948-49."
I am held up as an iniquitous criminal for coming in and telling the House that the Minister for Local Government had stopped all building except the building of houses for residence and had bespoken all the supplies of cement available; that, in addition to that, we had a strike in the cement factories—I did not know that when I spoke first; that is only a recent development;— that I was warned by the Minister for Local Government, and rightly warned, that he has first claim on all cement; that after that certain essential industrial requirements were necessary and that there were certain categories of work for which cement would not be released. Like a simpleton, I came into the House and told the truth. Wait until you hear what the former Minister for Agriculture told the House. He is not such an innocent as I am. He knows how to put a gloss upon it. Listen to this evidence of frank, open, ingenuous, Parliamentary procedure. Deputy P. J. Burke on the 11th December asked the Minister for Agriculture when he intended to introduce the scheme for grants for the improvement and reconstruction of farm outhouses and in reply the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Smith, said:—
"A scheme for the improvement of farm buildings has been prepared by my Department and I hope to be in a position to announce it soon."
When we get these pink documents the way they are made up is this: There is the question and there is the answer which we read out and here are the secret bits. If they come at you again, here is your ammunition. Down at the foot of this, with a star in front of it, is this:
"The Department of Industry and Commerce has now replied pointing out that progress under the proposed scheme must be restricted to the rate justified by cement supplies, which are expected to be barely sufficient in 1948/49 for the continuance of building and engineering work on the present scale."
The ammunition was kept in the pouch that time. Maybe Deputy Burke had something whispered in his ear behind the Ceann Comhairle's chair, but the voters in the impending general election did not hear it.
Now a great miracle took place about this farm buildings scheme; one of the greatest miracles since Moses struck the rock. This farm buildings scheme, after two years' fermentation, suddenly blossomed forth from the head of the Minister for Agriculture. Do you know when the egg was hatched, when the bird stepped forth? About three weeks after the by-elections. Then the correspondence was resumed. Then the scheme was formulated. Deputies know the procedure of getting a scheme formulated, circulated to the Department, commented upon by the Department and referred to the Government. Even the youngest Minister knows the dreary tedium of that procedure. But, my gracious me, the procedure was streamlined on this occasion. It went through like a knife through a cheese. Do you know the day the advertisement was published? The 31st December. I do not believe that in the history of Great Britain or Ireland for the last 400 years was there ever a Government notice published on the 31st December. But this had to be published as quick as lightning. Why? So that the forms could be stereotyped and sent out to every agricultural overseer and every assistant agricultural overseer throughout the country to tell them that we were going to rebuild every barn and hay shed and everything else on the holding of anybody who did what was necessary on the fatal day. When that advertisement was published there was neither staff, organisation, plan nor idea of how they were going to handle the work that was inevitably going to develop.
Comment on this
If they had got back.
Comment on this
I think it is just as well to let matters of that kind rest. It is disgusting for one Minister to be reciting the peccadilloes of another and God knows that I have not said anything sensational about that scheme since I came into office. I said I could not go on with it this year. Is that not so? But there is a limit. I have been jibed at and I have been held up to ridicule of a fair and reasonable kind from time to time. However, when the whole debate of the Agricultural Estimate, 27 hours, is devoted to proving that I am a fraud and a liar—when in my hands is resting the proof of the fact that my only sin is that I told the Deputies the truth while my predecessor in office came in and told them what he thought it would be prudent to tell them—I think, in justice to myself and my colleagues, I ought to speak out. It is a vicious, mean thing to go round the country misleading decent, simple people. That is what Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party have been doing. They have been out to tell the people that the farm improvements scheme is abandoned. It is not. Every single penny appropriated for that scheme will be spent on it—as much more next year and the year after until every penny that is necessary to reclaim every acre of the land of this country that requires reclamation has been spent.
I am not going to promise and I cannot promise that it will be done like that if we have not the money. We must do it in stages year by year with our resources. I do say, however, that I am quite satisfied that if Marshall Aid came to us by way of grant and we were allowed to use that grant money inside our economy a great part of it could be added to our annual resources to expedite the work. That is why I said that with Marshall Aid it could be done in five years but that if we have to depend on our own resources we may have to spread it out over 25 years. But whether it is 25 years or five years, if we remain in office, we will keep at it until the work is done. In saying that let me record that when we finish that work it will be right and proper to look back and remember that, by whatever inspiration or advice or encouragement he may have got, it was Deputy Dr. Ryan who started it.
Comment on this
If I heard the Minister correctly he stated that all this money will be spent this year and that every acre of land in the country would be drained. But he said we cannot do so if we have not the money. He then went on to allude to the Marshall Plan and to the money that was expected from it. Did I hear the Minister aright?
Comment on this
If I was satisfied that the Deputy was intervening in good faith I should be inclined to give him a more civil reply. The Deputy must excuse me if I sometimes suspect him of intervening not in good faith and if I give him a sharp reply. I will give him the benefit of the doubt that he is now intervening in good faith. We will spend every penny that is appropriated now. We will appropriate next year, I hope, the same amount, if not a larger one, and the next year and the next year and the next year and as many years as we are the Government of the country until the work is done. If into that picture there should be injected the Marshall Aid money then we will be able to undertake a very much larger scheme so that the work to be done will be done more rapidly and that the whole area of the country will be restored to productivity much sooner than it can be if we only have our own resources to depend upon.
Comment on this
Yes. Two ghosts are now laid low. I shall now deal with the specific questions that were put to me. Great play was made here to-day about what I said at the ploughing dinner. This is what I did say—let us get it accurate. I said that but for the fact that I believe in individual liberty I would make it illegal to plough land with a horse in this country. Is that clear? If anybody misunderstands it I shall repeat it. The agricultural worker has a minimum wage throughout the greater part of this country of 55/- a week. Frankly I am ashamed to name it. Fifty-five shillings a week! He is the lowest paid worker in the English-speaking world and that is something of which I am bitterly ashamed. There is no means that I know of to get for that highly-skilled craftsman an adequate wage if we do not put into his hand the modern implement that will enable him to use to the limit of his capacity the gift that God gave him. The industrial worker is working with the machines and implements of 1948. The agricultural worker is using the same horse and the same plough that was being dragged through the soil of this country 80 years ago. Eighty years ago! He is being paid in 1948 on the basis of a performance capacity which his great-grandfather had 70 years ago. That man working a fair day will plough half an Irish acre with a pair of horses and a plough. Put him on a Ferguson or a Fordson tractor and he will plough three acres of the same land. Now, if he does six times as much work simply by changing the implement that is put into his hands surely to God there is nobody in this House or this country who will suggest that he will still get 55/- a week. Am I right or am I wrong?
Now do you see why I said that but for the fact that I believe in individual liberty I would make it illegal to plough land with a hand-plough and a horse? Was I not right?
Comment on this
Why should we insist? Why should we glory in the fact that those who work the land are compelled to use antediluvian methods and are paid antediluvian wages?
Comment on this
Now, Deputy Smith referred to a story that was published in the Irish Times about my intention of taking all the controls off the bacon. I am a great believer, when a fight is over, in letting the dust die down— forget it and get on with the job. But I am not in favour of letting a bone go with any dog; and, if Deputy Smith wants to open that up again, I shall give him his answer. If Deputy Smith wants any information about that I would invite him to go and have a chat with Deputy MacEntee, because he knows a lot about it. I know a lot about it, too, that Deputy MacEntee does not know I know. Deputy Smith, poor fellow, never knew what was going on at all.
When I came into office there was a certain warrior in this country and I knew well that he had been forcing up the price of pigs to create an impossible situation and, at the same time, to draw into his bacon factory the bulk of the pigs to be slaughtered. All his competitors were saying: "What the devil is X on to; he is paying 210/- and 215/- for pork and the fixed price for bacon is 200/-; what in the world is he up to?" X knew well what he was up to. I was not long in office until there was a hullabaloo; the poor bacon curers and the pork butchers were "kilt" and the solution of the whole thing would be to take all the controls off and in about a month everything would settle itself. But in that month one particular warrior would have disposed of 4,000 cwts of bacon at 5/- per lb. It was that same warrior that pedalled that article that appeared in the Irish Times, first to the Irish Press, but “old faithful” would not publish it; he was too cute. Then it was brought around to the Irish Independent and they would not publish it; and out it came in the Irish Times. There was great hope that the golconda was about to open up for the warrior that had the nest egg, but he got a golconda that he was not expecting. I shifted the nest egg and I distributed it over the rest of the curers in the country; and I met him—as the bulk of the curers wanted to do. I found the vast majority of the curers honest, straightforward men, just as anxious as I was to put an end then and there to the rotten transactions that were going on and which were attributable to a very small minority of their number. Every pound of that bacon came out of the nest egg and was freely distributed. I am glad to tell the House that I was able to say to the bulk of the curers: “If I leave the fair operation of this business to yourselves to run it voluntarily will you give me your word of honour that, whatever bacon we can gather in, will be equitably and honestly distributed?” That has been in operation for about six weeks and it has operated fairly and justly and honourably and, I believe, not infrequently at considerable expense to the curers themselves.
I think it is due to them that I should say that and I think they have done that in the belief that I am doing my best to increase the supplies of pigs and feeding-stuffs and that they will benefit from that when their trade returns to normal; and that it is up to them to lend a hand until we can restore the pig industry. I am glad to be able to report to the House that there were more pigs on offer in Clonmel last market day than have been there for the past ten years. There are certain other indelicate statistics I could give but I think propriety requires me to give them individually and privately to Deputy O'Leary. I may say, however, that they are of a rather reassuring character and give promise of an early bacon increase.
The next matter to which I want to turn is the suggestion that I am entirely indifferent to the price of milk. I am not. But here is an issue joined—if there is an issue—between me and some of the representatives of the dairy farmers. I said to them: "Satisfy Oireachtas Éireann that the cows kept by suppliers of milk to dairies or to creameries have a reasonable milk output of from 500 to 600 gallons and I will request the Government, of which I am a member to take whatever steps are necessary to ensure that the people producing milk from these cows will get a fair price for it; but I am not going to ask our people or our Government to give a price for milk in order that you improvident farmers, whose cows yield 300 gallons per lactation, will get a good profit, because it cannot be done." It is a waste of land. It is a waste of a farmer's skill and it is a waste of time to try to operate the dairying industry on 300-gallon cows.
I have asked the co-operative creamery societies throughout the country to set up cow-testing associations and to come to me with a plan. If I can possibly help them, or facilitate them in getting them money, or maintaining them, I will, in order that we can get a pretty general average of between 500 and 600 gallons of milk from every cow whose milk is going to a creamery; and I will guarantee, if we arrive at that point, the Government of which I am a member will see that the farmers who keep those cows get a price for their milk which will entitle them to carry on with a reasonable margin of profit for the work they do.
In that connection I want to say two things. I am ashamed of my life of the conditions under which the supervisors of the cow-testing associations work. They are doing invaluable work for the dairying industry of the country and for the agricultural industry as a whole. They are scandalously paid. When I met them in Mallow three or four months ago I promised them that I would look into their case and try to work out a scheme which would enable us to employ them on reasonable terms. I have to confess that I have not yet been able to get around to that. It was not for want of the will; it was for want of the way. I was not physically able to do it. It is something which we ought to do. It is something I do not see we can do without the help of the co-operative societies. I wish that I could find one co-operative society that would come to me and say: "We will require every supplier sending milk to our creamery to join a cow-testing association." If I can find one society to do that I will ask the Government to authorise me to give them generous financial assistance so as to enable them to employ supervisors on a fair and reasonable basis, to look after those cattle.
Some of these are married men with families. They earn a few pounds a week. They are barely able to live, struggling around on bicycles in all sorts of weather and, as a result, chucking the job. I regard that as a great misfortune. It is a matter in which I would be very glad to have the help of some co-operative society in order to bring it to an end so that by that example others might be induced to do something along the same lines.
Now, a lot of people have said that one of the difficulties about the creamery business is that you cannot get fellows and girls to milk cows. I think that that is true and I do not blame them. Why should they take work sitting under a cow and getting slapped in the face with the cow's tail if they can get a good job in the town? If we want people to do agricultural work we have to make that agricultural work as agreeable as rival forms of occupation. It is perfectly possible —there is nothing marvellous or extravagant about it—to aim at providing any dairy farmer with 15 or more cows with a portable milking machine that can be pulled on to the field where the cows are and have the cows milked by machinery on the field. There is no need to have any elaborate installation or anything else. It is as common as kiss my hand all over England.
I do not believe there is a single cow in New Zealand milked by hand—not one—and many of them are 12, 14 or 16-cow men. It is a detail to which people do not attach much importance, but there is not a single cow in New Zealand stripped by hand, because it was discovered there, under the pressure of shortage of labour, that if cows are accustomed to be milked by machine from the first lactation, stripping by hand becomes unnecessary. That is a detail, but it is that kind of thing that makes all the difference between agricultural work being slavery for a young person and analogous to regular industrial employment, which permits of people having regular hours and a reasonable respite.
Deputy Dunne was very wicked when he was talking about agricultural labourers. I agree with Deputy Dunne. I think agricultural labourers ought to have a weekly half-holiday and seven days' holiday every year. But the majority of the people do not think that—and this is a democratic country. I am doing what I can to persuade the majority of the people to come to our point of view. I am trying to do what I can to encourage the majority of the people to put in an installation and equipment that will make such a proposal practical politics, because if we do not do it young people will not stay on the land and we may make up our minds to do these things when it is too late and the young people are gone off the land.
But there is no use in Deputy Dunne and I believing that we can take the whole population by the throat and make them do what we want. We shall have to persuade them that we are right and that they would be wise and prudent to accept our view. I am doing my part; let Deputy Dunne do his. But he does not help when, in order to make Deputy MacEntee's flesh creep, he says "I would be in favour of municipalising the milk supply". There are a whole lot of men in this Dáil and, when you say that, their hair stands on end and they say "He is a Bolshie". By municipalising I do not know what he means, and I do not believe that he does either. Does he mean that the municipality is to own 15,000 cows and milk them morning and evening?
Comment on this
Might I be allowed to explain? I meant to convey that I believe the true solution for the present scandalous state of the milk supply in the City of Dublin is the municipalisation of the distribution of milk. There is nobody here appreciates more keenly than I do the difficulty that would be entailed by the municipalisation of production.
Comment on this
Now I know what the Deputy means, but I have not such a love for bureaucracy as to believe that that is going to work. I do not give a fiddle-de-dee who distributes the milk, provided the people get it clean and at a low price. I know of no way in which I can get milk into the poorer sections in Lower Dominick Street or Gardiner Street in a clean and cheap condition except by pasteurising. In theory, if we have tuberculin tested grade A milk herds we ought to get milk without any tuberculosis or contamination; but if, in effect, we succeed in getting that, it would be cheaper to give the people mulled claret because the cost of producing that high standard of perfect cleanliness would be prohibitive. The precautions necessary involve expense which would bring the milk to such a price that the people could not afford it and it would be absolutely out of the question.
By careful supervision we must do the best we can to see that milk is handled in as clean a way as possible. We must pasteurise it to see that no tubercle bacilli shall survive and reach little children. One of the most important things is to make illegal the cardboard cap for the milk bottle. I would require every milk distributor to use a paper cap for the reason that I have often seen fellows in the back streets of Dublin coming up with a tray of empty bottles which they have collected in exchange for full bottles; they fill them out of a can, take a handful of discs out of their pockets, and pop one on each bottle. If they have to put a wire and paper cap on each bottle it will tighten them if they do not carry a machine with which to do it.
The best method of all is one I expect the new milk distributing body to employ, and that is to use nonreturnable, destructible cardboard containers. These cannot be used again and they must be thrown away. That is the best way. I can assure the Deputy that municipalisation will not get rid of much, because the municipaliser is as liable to go up the back street and fill the bottles out of his neighbour's can as is the base, bloody and brutal capitalist.
I do not want to leave the inspectors without putting on record that I regard the agricultural instructors in the service of my Department and in the service of the county committees of agriculture, together with the overseers, the assistant overseers and the other instructors, as some of the most valuable servants this community has and, incidentally, some of the worst paid.
Deputy Cogan complained that people find it hard to get fertilisers in sufficient quantities on credit. I am amazed to hear that. I have been for 25 years a shopkeeper in a small country town, Ballaghaderreen, and I had to put a shingle out calling on the people to buy manures from me on credit. Any fellow I believed had the intention— even the intention—of paying, I took a flying leap at him. Some of the best intentions misfired when it came to paying, but even if I believed they had the intention, I would give them the manure on credit. To their eternal credit be it said that 99 per cent. of them paid. Some were a bit tough and slow, but they paid in the heel of the hunt.
Comment on this
Devil a much I got out of it. I got 3d. a cwt. out of super, cash or credit—3d. on super and 6d. on fertiliser, and it was not philantrophy. If I did not give it my neighbour would and I wanted to prevent him going to the neighbouring shop. The same is true of all parts of rural Ireland. Where there is a commodity that everybody buys, competition is the boy to keep the price down. If they come in for super they will buy tea. In the country we do not go in for these grand shops where you have one place for super, another for tea and another for silk stockings. But we are hopeful that when a man comes in for a bag of "super" he may buy a pair of silk stockings, a lb. of tea or maybe a teaset before he goes out.
Deputy de Valera intervened and cautioned me that, although I was Minister for Agriculture, I owed a duty to the citizens of the State and that I must be very careful not to push up the price of agricultural produce so as to leave the people of the towns and cities hungry and without the things they should have—the white-collar workers. And this was going on within the ten minutes of Deputy Smith having torn passion to tatters and having advanced against me horse, foot and artillery, because I had not raised the price of everything high enough!
Somebody asked me about the user of the Clare deposit of phosphate. I should be glad to use the Clare deposit of phosphate if I knew how. So far as I can find out, scientific research has established that the only means of using it or activating it is by raising it by some chemical process to a temperature of 380 degrees centigrade. If anyone will propound a procedure whereby I can raise it to 380 degrees centigrade, without an expenditure which will make it dearer than gold dust by the time I have made "super" of it, I shall be glad to know of it. I exhort any private enterprise which thinks that Clare phosphates can be activated without undue expense to turn their attention to it and exploit it so that it can be used for the benefit of the country. I understand there is a prospect of developing a considerable lime deposit in the neighbourhood of the Clare phosphates. If there is I shall be delighted to hear of it.
I deal with Deputy Madden's trouble by saying that if he will produce the 500-gallon cow I shall go on campaigning to get a price for milk now and for all time which will yield a reasonable profit to the farmer. A Deputy said that the £2,250,000 subsidy for butter is not a subsidy to the farmers of this country. If the community as a whole will release butter and say to the farmers to go and sell where they like, we shall sell it on the foreign market without a penny subsidy. The subsidy paid on butter is a subsidy to reduce the price of butter to our own people; but if our own people do not want to eat butter, if our own people say to the dairy farmers of the country that they are to sell their butter where they can get the best price, I can sell all the creamery butter elsewhere without a subsidy and not reduce the price of milk by one farthing.
Deputy Sweetman mentioned a case where he said some local officer of a county committee was pursuing an investigation regarding aphosphorosis and that we had stopped him. The Deputy is mistaken in that because we provided a grant of £500 for further investigation in that area. If that grant is not sufficient more money will be provided to carry on the inquiry to a conclusion.
Somebody said that a great solution of the milk production problem was to get proven bulls, that what has happened is that the Livestock Breeding Act has broken down and that beef-type bulls are being used, with the result that the average milk yield of cattle is declining. That is quite a mistaken view but I agree that the only way by which you can be certain that you will raise the milk yield of your cattle is to use only proven bulls. The difficulty of that is that you cannot satisfy yourself that a bull is a proven bull until he is seven years old. You cannot start using him until he is over a year and you cannot know whether he is a beast of a quality to increase the milk yield until his granddaughter calves. By that time the bull may be sold off because of the difficulty that most of our farms are small farms and a seven-year-old bull is a pretty unmanageable beast on a small holding where you have not got a large staff. Many bulls of that age get cross and are hard to manage. All I can do is my best.
I cannot shorten time. I can only tell the House of a plan which I hope will produce results in time and it is this. We have a place called Chantilly where we have a farm and keep imported beasts for a while and rest them before they are sent out to the country. I am trying out a plan by which Chantilly will constitute a considerable dairy farm in which there will be from 40 to 50 tested cows. Each bull we bring in we shall mate with a certain number of these cows and record the results. When these bulls are sent down the country we shall keep track of them. If the granddaughters of a bull prove to be the progeny of a bull possessing the quality of an increased milk yield we shall recall that bull. If artificial insemination proves to be as satisfactory and as successful a procedure as it seems likely to develop, we shall bring that bull to an artificial insemination centre for the three or four years of its useful life that remain and the maximum number of cows will be put into calf by what we know to be a proven bull having the faculty of passing on the milk yield quality. It may take time to start and we may not get any more than three proven bulls in each year, but let us assume that it is possible to get 1,000 services from each bull. In the first year you would have three, in the second year six and the third year nine and you then reach the point where you have 9,000 dairy cattle served by proven bulls. That plan can be extended interminably but it will take time to work out. In the meantime, the farm can be used as a dairy farm to provide Dublin with liquid milk and as a means of measuring whether the prices fixed for milk sold in Dublin are fair and equitable, bearing in mind the costings of a well-run dairy farm supplying milk to the city.
Deputy Giles spoke of the potentialities of Muinntir na Tíre and asked me to assist the formation of co-operative societies and activities of that kind among rural communities. Anything I can do to assist in the formation of co-operative societies of that description I shall gladly do whether it be in equipping them with farm machinery, or helping them to build a hall. Any activity of a social character like that I shall be delighted to help. There is nothing further I can do. I cannot be expected to go down to a parish in the country, take the people, as it were, by the back of the neck and tell them that if they do not form a co-operative society they will not be allowed to live but they have only got to ask for any reasonable assistance which they require to form a co-operative society and I shall ask the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society, as well as Muinntir na Tíre, to help them, but I have not got their help yet. They may come along with a plan soon.
Deputy Giles rightly mentioned the rings which exploited the farmers of this country. I have "bust" a couple of them and any more I can find I will "bust", or "bust" in the attempt. I pledge my word to that—every blooming one of them. Somebody complained about the tanglers meeting the cattle out the road. I never saw a tangler coming out the road that I did not thank God for the sight. Whenever the tanglers are coming out the road, there is a good fair. No one but a fool ever sold his beast outside the fair green if he met a tangler on the road. The road is a lonesome place, if there is a bad fair, but it is like an election meeting with tanglers, if prices are rising.
Deputy Hickey spoke about the Cork milk situation. I am blowed if I know what the Cork milk situation is. Every second person from Cork tells me a very different story about the Cork milk situation. I will make an offer: Let the Deputies for Cork City and any Deputy whose constituency contains part of an area supplying Cork City or part of an area that wants to supply Cork City, come together and then come to me, and, whatever they agree upon, I will do.
Comment on this
Do not draw me, because there are some people who send me resolutions and sign them, and then meet me behind the door and say: "Look, do not mind the resolution." If the Deputies will come and meet me, Deputy McGrath with them——
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to do his job by his constituents, he will meet his colleagues representative of that area and whatever they agree is in the best interests of the people living in the area, I will do, if it is physically possible to do it.
Comment on this
I asked Deputies who are interested in this matter to remember that I have a certain duty to the people who consume milk and that every time I put a farthing on the gallon, somebody has to pay more. I beg of Deputies to remember this, that, when the price of milk goes up, it is highly unlikely that I will cut down the supply coming into my house. It is the resident of Dominick Street and Lower Gloucester Street who must cut his supply.
Comment on this
It is a shocking thing, and it is doubly shocking that the area of supply should be restricted and that anybody in Cork, rich or poor, should be unable to get enough milk for his family. I was not aware of it. I did not know it to be the case. I believed that the reverse was the case. Open confession is good for the soul, and, as soon as ever the Deputies can come to me, they will be welcome.
Comment on this
The Deputy need not worry about that. Just come and tell me the area, and no more than drowning the English people in eggs, I will drown you with milk. I may add, to reassure the Deputy, that both observations are figurative.
With regard to the sewage compost business, that is my old friend, Sir Albert Howard. When ever I meet a member of the Oxford Group, or a believer in Sir Albert Howard's theories, I can always tell them after the third sentence he utters what he belongs to. Both these beliefs seem to have some kind of mystic charm for the people who get bitten by them. To be quite frank, I think there is a lot of nonsense talked about sewage conservation, but, very prudently, my predecessor said: "Let us refer the whole thing to a competent body of experts to examine the whole business up and down. If it is worth doing we will do it and, if it is not, we will not." That committee has been sitting and is at present working. As soon as I get its report I will send a copy to the Lord Mayor of Cork, the Lord Mayor of Dublin and to any other municipality interested, and I shall be glad to discuss with them whether they wish to process the material themselves and sell it, or to invite the Department to collaborate with them in the undertaking.
Deputy Hughes spoke about the provision of ground limestone and phosphate. I have deliberately left the business of producing limestone in the hands of private enterprise, because I believe that is the way I will get it done cheapest, but the costings I have heard so far envisage a price of 16/- at the pit. I think it was Deputy Aiken or Deputy Ryan who envisaged the possibility of a contract service in which the man who ground the lime would undertake to bring it to the land and spread it for an all-in charge per acre. I think that is an extremely good idea, if we can get a sufficient number of people to undertake it.
In any case, I am glad to be able to tell the House at last that I have something concrete, instead of these hopes which trouble my friends across the House so terribly. There is one plant up in Kilkenny. It is there to see and to feel. To tell the truth, I sometimes wondered whether I would ever be able to see and feel one but there is one there. It should go into operation next month. I am hoping that a very great many more will be established and the equipment for a very large one is at present on its way from the United States. It is frightfully difficult to get delivery of this kind of machinery in Great Britain, but we have got one large plant coming from the United States for a man who is to do it, and, as soon as it comes, it will be erected, and I am not without hope that it will be grinding and distributing well before Christmas.
I need not dwell on the young farmers' clubs. I substantially agree with Deputy O'Grady's estimate. Given that they maintain their independence and are firmly resolved that neither I nor any other Minister for Agriculture will dominate or control them, they are of incalculable value to this country; but once they become the appendage of any political organisation or any Government Department, instead of being valuable, they are a menace. I do not doubt that they will be all right and I exhort them to keep that way.
I think it was Deputy Hughes who inquired what we were doing about blackleg in beet. The answer is everything that it is humanly possible to do. Glasnevin and the Sugar Company are studying the matter with all their resources, but the plain fact is that nowhere in the world has it yet been determined precisely what is the source of the disease or what is its cure. Every conceivable resource in this country, the United States and elsewhere is being employed to try to track down the source and provide a remedy. Deputy Bartley also spoke of the incidence of disease in some of the tomato plants in the houses in Connemara. There has been disease, but I can reassure the Deputy that the disease which has occurred amongst certain of the plants in the tomato houses in Connemara is a seed-borne disease, and is not one which is calculated to spread from plant to plant. It comes in the seed and the plant which grows from the particular diseased seed will die, but there is no danger that if you have two or three other plants in a hothouse, they will wilt and die subsequently. The presence of the diseased plant will not affect them.
With regard to veterinary services, we have recently had transferred to our Department all the veterinary services of the Department of Local Government and Public Health, and we are now in the process of reorganisation. The first thing I did in that regard was to ask the Government to authorise me to send the Director of Veterinary Services on a two-years' course of postgraduate study and research in the United States, Canada and South Africa, because I found that a great many of the veterinary surgeons in this country, certainly those in the service of the Department, had not had much contact with colleges outside Ireland and I felt it was necessary, if we were going to have a director of veterinary services here, that he should be familiar with all the great centres of veterinary learning in the world so that in the years that lie ahead, as he is developing the service, he can pick out one young man from this branch and another young man from that branch and send one to Canada and another to South Africa to study some particular branch of veterinary science. Thereby, we would build up a very much higher standard of veterinary learning and a very much better standard of veterinary education and administration.
While he is away, the skeleton scheme that he is working out with the deputy director will continue to develop but we may not but assume that the general scheme of veterinary services worked out during the next two or three years will be more or less of an experimental character. When the director returns to assume permanent occupancy of his position, we plan to establish a permanent and growing veterinary service, the nature of which, frankly, I do not at present know, because I have not got the information requisite to form a reliable judgment and I cannot hope to have it until I have an opportunity of contacting people familiar not only with veterinary science, but with the complex problem of veterinary administration in dairy conditions and live-stock conditions, and so forth.
Therefore, one of the centres to which the veterinary director will go will be Wisconsin, which is one of the great dairy States in America, where the veterinary service is operated from the University of Wisconsin. There is also a great veterinary station in Iowa. He will spend some time there. The principal of the McDonald College, in Quebec University, is a friend of mine who will not only place the facilities of the McDonald College of Quebec at his disposal, but will introduce him to the heads of the other Veterinary Colleges in Canada. Odendaalsrust is a place which all Deputies know of. It is one of the greatest agricultural research stations in the world and a period of study there, I cannot but believe, will be of material advantage to the director in determining the proper course to be pursued in this country, both in the sphere of education and the sphere of administration in the years that lie ahead.
Deputy Lehane spoke of the maize millers' profits. They are monstrous and revolting but they will not be that long. I am happy to inform the House that the International Emergency Food Council has, for the first time, made an allocation to us of 75,000 tons of maize for animal feed. That is a very important new development.
My predecessor in office had to labour under the very great difficulty of having no such allocation and having to search the markets of the world to find maize in a condition which put it outside the category of human food. It was only in such cases that he was able to purchase it and use it for animal feed. That he was able to get as much as he did, with the assistance of Deputy Lemass, under these extraordinarily difficult circumstances, is something for which the people ought to be duly grateful to them. This allocation makes my task easier but I am faced with the difficulty of price. Unfortunately, prices have risen in the cereal market very substantially in the last 12 months but I think they are coming down and I am not without hope that we shall be able to purchase maize. I want the House to understand very clearly that it is one thing to have maize allocated and another to get it. The allocation merely amounts to this that the international authority says: "You may buy maize now." Then you have to go and buy it and at that stage you learn what you have to pay for it.
We could buy maize to-morrow but it would cost us so dear a price that we could not afford to use it or to feed it to our live stock but I am not without hope that, with hopping and trotting, I will be able to get it yet at a price at which, having dealt effectively with the profit margin to which Deputy Lehane referred and reminding the retailers of this country of the good old-fashioned practice of selling Indian meal for 3d. a cwt. profit, we will get it to the farmer at a price which will enable him to feed it to his live stock and make a profit on his produce.
I want to tell Deputy Kinnane that it is merely malicious and mischievous to say that I do not believe in tillage. I have always stood for the policy enunciated in this House 25 long years ago—one more cow, one more sow, one more acre under the plough.
Comment on this
I did not say that you did not believe in it. I said that it was generally accepted that you did not believe in it.
Comment on this
I beg the Deputy's pardon and I will ask him to do this much publicity for me, to tell those who allege that that it is all my eye and Betty Martin plus Fianna Fáil—a thoroughly disreputable company. I have always believed in one more cow one more sow, one more acre under the plough, and 700,000 barrels of barley for Arthur Guinness, Son and Company, at a good price. The difference between me and my predecessors is that, with God's help, I will get it and, instead of having to subsidise half the land of Ireland, every acre of our land into which a plough is put will pay its own profit and nobody will have to subsidise it. It will pay the man who ploughs it a profit for his labour and he can stand independent upon it and thank nobody for the livelihood he gets out of it.
He will not have to be going around with his cap in his hand to any Fianna Fáil T.D. or any Fianna Fáil Minister begging him to give him a subsidy on that crop or a subsidy on this crop or, for the love of God, to push the price of this or that up a little higher than it is. He will sell his produce in competition with all comers and it will be better quality and make as good or better a price than what will be produced in any other country in the world.
I am sick of the doctrine that there is nothing we produce that cannot be produced better and cheaper somewhere else. That is all hog-wash. We can meet the Danes and the Dutch and all other comers in the British market and beat the tar out of them in quality and quantity, if we try. There is no bargain to which the Taoiseach's name will be put beside the Sir Stafford Cripps', by which the price provided does not recognise the fact that Irish produce is equal, grade for grade, with the best that Denmark or Holland can ever hope to produce.
I think it was Deputy Davin who said that he would not be in favour of compulsory wheat, but would be in favour of compulsory tillage. Why is it that there is one section of the community that is always presumed to be lazy, a potential criminal and in need of continual supervision to see that he does not do everybody else down? Do you go into a plumber and compel him to use solder? Do you go into a painter and insist that he put on paint? Why is it necessary to go to a farmer in order to see that he farms? If that is to be the rule, why not take over all the land of the country and hire the farmers and tell them what to do—do you plough that acre, do you sow that one, do you dig that one?
What is the use of calling a man's farm his own, if every hour of the day an inspector—representing me—can walk in and push him about and tell him what to do. Why should I go on to Deputy Killilea's holding and tell him what to plant and sow and reap? Is it not his own? What good is it to him if he has not the right to throw me off it? What right have I got to go into the farms of any of the Deputies sitting on that side of the House and dictate to them what they are to do with their land? I will not do it; and so long as I am Minister for Agriculture there will be no compulsion on farmers that does not apply to everybody else.
All agree that, if war comes upon us, all of us have to surrender our liberties. I remember, when the last war began, we passed an Act in this House which left in the hands of the Government virtually the power to do anything they liked in respect of everybody. In that situation, you have to compel farmers, you may have to compel workers, you may have to order everybody to their post, and require, for the public safety, that each person will do his allotted task. But there is no reason why, if that is the proper course to pursue in war-time, you should release the whole rest of the community from that rigid regulation when the war is over and say: "The poor old clodhopper on the land, it would be as well to keep a grip on him because if we do not he will go astray or go wild."
Are we to claim that every Deputy in this House is some lazy old somachán that slept half the day and would not till his land and would not make anything out of it? What put the navy blue suits on the Deputies of this House? Who made doctors and lawyers and clergymen out of the farmers' sons? Was it not the ordinary, plain, simple, ignorant farmers—and they had no cigire or inspector running round saying: "You plough there, you sow there". Are we to assume that their sons have all become degenerates? I do not. I do not think their sons are one bit less than their fathers. I will stake my existence on that conviction and if it is necessary to take every farmer by the back of the neck and teach him his business, then kick me out, for I am not fit to do it, I do not want to do it and I never will.
I dealt with the pundit over there who ate the face off me for reducing the price of farmers' butter to 1/6 and then ate the face off me for putting him in the black market to get 3/6 a lb. for butter. The truth of it is that the woman who makes good farmers' butter now, if she can get a choice customer, will get 3/-; the woman who makes cartgrease will not get anything and I hope she will not. Let her go and grease the axle of the ass cart and not be trying to sell it to her neighbours as butter. The woman who makes middling butter may have some trouble in selling it, but—we got some of it inside recently—it is just the kind of stuff you can sit at the table with and put on a potato and put a bit of cabbage over it. She will easily get about 2/4 and is well paid. Let me say to the Deputy from Galway. Deputy Lahiffe, that if his neighbour has beautiful, first quality butter and no one to buy it, let him put it in the boot of his car and bring it up here next Tuesday and let him go around to two or three hotels and he will sell it as quick as lightning.
There was a lot of bad grass seeds in this country. I am not going into the whole salam about it, but all control of every sort, kind and description is coming off grass seeds soon. They can come in and go out, they can go up or go down. The man who produces good perennial or good Italian will get a good price for it and the man who tries to sell the sweepings of the loft will get nothing whatever except six months in gaol, and I think it is the best thing for him.
Oh, I must pluck a crow with Deputy Commons. He says he views the prospect of the mechanisation of agriculture with alarm, lest the introduction of machinery should displace men on the land. That is the most poisonous heresy that could creep in upon us, because if you accept that doctrine it will mean that the men who work upon the land are for ever to be the lowest grade of manual labourer, never allowed to have access to the instruments or methods which will enable them to take their place where they belong—at the very top of craftsmen in our country. I want to put on every farm in Ireland—whether through co-operative societies or individual ownership—those instruments which will enable the farm labourer of to-day to do the work of six farm labourers and to ensure that, having so equipped him, he will be proportionately paid.
I am much beholden to Deputy Moylan for describing me as an adolescent. As you pass the middle forties, you look affectionately at those who still regard you as an adolescent. Deputy Moylan regarded it as a fallacy to suggest that any old pastures should be preserved. That is a question about which I am not prepared to dogmatise, but I can tell you I was speaking to one of the greatest authorities on grass in Great Britain, a man whose name is nationally known, and I asked him that very question: "Could it be possible that there would be such pastures as we had in Meath, which were alleged to have been undisturbed for centuries and to have this extraordinary quality of finishing cattle?""Yes," he said, "it is undoubtedly true; there are certain areas in which that is true." And I think he mentioned Leicestershire. I said: "With all the progress in soil science, can you suggest to me why it is that you have a field on one side of the road which will finish a beast and a field on the far side which will not?""No," he said, "you cannot, not with precision. It appears to have something to do with the incidence and survival, owing to some soil constituent of the traditional indigenous grasses of the district. As yet it is hard to determine what will preserve that."
So long as that view obtains, God forbid that any fool in this country would go down and tell a Meath farmer to tear up something that may be of incalculable value, something that is utterly irreplaceable, and that is producing more food through the medium of grass owing to this purely chemical coincidence as it apparently does in parts of Leicestershire. Surely out of pure prejudice we are not going to destroy it. If we were it would be much the same as if some ignorant imbecile were to walk into the British Museum and smash the Portland vase because he did not like the look of it. The real explanation of that kind of sward can be satisfied only by breaking it up. So long as we do not know, do not let us smash it up and then deplore our action for the rest of our lives.
I would say to Deputy Lemass that 90 per cent. of the land of this country given to grass means rotational tillage. There is very little left in Ireland or anywhere else which, if left in permanent grass for a protracted period will not show a tendency to deteriorate and to carry stock. We know the reason why so little land was broken in many cases. It was because farmers would not walk behind two horses with a plough, and because west of the Shannon men would not go out and turn the fields with a loy. Thanks be to God the day is going when they will have to do that any longer. There are some Deputies who know what it means to face into two Irish roods of land with a loy, turn every inch of it and break it up. Work with a loy is work fit for a horse and not fit for a man. There has been a transition between these utterly primitive methods and the methods that we can give to them. We will have tillage to keep the people on the land and the means to do it in dignity and decency. So far as I am concerned, we will do all we can to give them the means. I am not going to ask them to get down in the gutter in order to gratify those who are standing on the ditch.
I thought it was extremely bad taste on the part of Deputy Moran to sneer and jeer at the occupants of our mental hospitals. Is there anything wrong in asking the resident medical surgeon of the mental hospital whether occupational therapy for patients might not in turn become an invaluable public user in propagating certain varieties of grass seeds which it is extremely difficult to get propagated commercially? The whole object of grass strains is to get a strain of grass that will be very leafy. The trouble about that leafy strain of grass is that when you try to propagate commercial seed the yield is so low that the cost of the seed is fantastic. It is such that the average farmer cannot afford to buy it. We have all over the country a number of mental hospitals with considerable tracts of land surrounding them. It is generally assumed that in occupational therapy the afflicted people will become interested in this as a regular routine. It is a thing to which they can readily adapt themselves as a desirable occupation. It seemed to me that if we could associate their therapeutic occupation with the feeling that they were making a very material contribution useful to their neighbours, on whom through no fault of their own they had become a charge, it would be a desirable thing. I do not think that is a silly thing nor an undignified thing to do. In that way we can steadily provide an annual supply of this seed which is so difficult to propagate. It will be a material contribution to the agriculture of the country which we cannot get in any other way. It will mean that those poor afflicted people will be doing something which is most valuable. If anybody thinks that is a foolish, undignified or improper suggestion, I do not agree with him.
Deputy Flynn spoke about the reconditioning of the Kerry mountain pastures. The question is who owns them. There are a lot of people who have grazing rights on these mountain pastures, but when you go to find a person who actually owns the mountain so that you can do reclamation work you find that the owner is somebody entirely different from the occupier. The same difficulty arises in Wicklow. If the users of the Kerry mountain pastures combine and approach my Department I will be delighted to use the resources of the farm improvements scheme. We shall try to work out a general plan for the reclamation and improvement of these mountain pastures so as to double, treble and quadruple their capacity for carrying sheep or cattle as the case may be.
I did say in this House that I could see a case for zoning the country, one part for Friesians and some other part for beef. When I came to put my mind down to it, I saw that it was daft. I said in this House, and I repeat it, that if you had an exclusively dairying country, or an exclusively liquid milk country, you ought to carry Friesians or Jerseys, but Ireland is not an exclusively dairying country. It is a very small country, and there is not room in it for setting neighbour against neighbour. If we do not all work together we will all perish together. Surely, we do not want a position where an individual in a parish can say: "So long as I can get my grab what matter about the rest of you." The result of that would be that the neighbourhood would go smash. I am convinced that this country must be regarded, agriculturally, as a unit, all working together. Otherwise we will all go burst together.
I can quite understand the viewpoint, particularly of a dairyman living in a dairying area, feeling: "If I could get the class of cattle where I knew that nine out of every ten cows would have a heavy milk yield," and saying: "I would be desperately tempted to choose that particular breed." What a lot of people forget is that 95 per cent. of the cattle in this country are Shorthorn cattle, and that about 5 or 10 per cent. belong to the fancy breeds. When you are dealing with fancy breeds, which are in a very small minority, the likelihood of your getting a good milker is much higher than if you take the whole cattle population and make a pick there. It is true to say that the Friesians, the Ayrshires, the Jerseys and the fancy breeds are better fed and better looked after by their owners than the average Shorthorn, but go up to Glasnevin and there is a herd of Shorthorn cattle there. They are not pedigree cattle. There is not a beast among them that was not bought on the Dublin market from common Shorthorn cows walked in there that anyone could buy, and the average yield of the herd is over 800 gallons a cow and most of them give 1,000 gallons. They are yours. They belong to the Irish people. If any Deputy in this House would like to go up there and have a look at them Professor Drew would be very glad to show them to you and to tell you the history of each cow. They were bought on the Dublin market in competition with all the dairy people and every one of them gives a yield of over 800 gallons, while many of them give a yield of 1,200 gallons. There is no special fancy feeding, and only when they go to about 1,500 gallons are they milked more than twice a day. Go up there and look at them.
I want to repeat my challenge. I will match, against six cows of any breed you care to name from any herd you care to pick, six of those ordinary Shorthorn cows bought on the Dublin market. Bring out six cows from any herd you choose to take and let them spend a full lactation in competition and I will pick six Shorthorn cows from the Glasnevin herd against any six cows in Ireland. Now can I say fairer than that?
Comment on this
The only thing is that they are 40 Shorthorns out of 1,000,000 cows, and they were well picked.
Comment on this
The interesting thing is that they were not selected, and some of them look very qucer.
Comment on this
Upon my word, he would want to be a mighty good judge to pick some of them. Some of them are the "quarest" looking things.... But there you are. If you know how you can do it. There is a difficulty that they are 20 cows out of 1,000,000, whereas if you picked 20 Friesians they would be 20 out of a 1,000, all of which were carefully picked in the first instance and your chance of getting 20 good cows is much higher than your chance of getting good Shorthorns. But damn it, we cannot run the country on the assumption that every one who keeps a cow or who buys a cow is not competent to do so.
Deputy Ben Maguire produced the astonishing theory that the flight from the land was due to the live-stock policy. God forbid that I would call the members of the Party beyond live stock, but it seems to me that the flight from the land took place from the time the Fianna Fáil policy was in operation. We were told that its result would be the return of the emigrant, but in fact the result is the disappearance of —is it?—20,000 per annum. Heaven forbid that at this hour of the night I should get contentious.
I am afraid of my life of mentioning anything that Deputy O'Reilly said, because if I compliment him he will think I am making fun of him, and if I criticise he will think I am insulting him, while all I want to do is to deal with him as I would deal with any Deputy. Deputy O'Reilly contended that the yield of our cattle had gone down through the Livestock Breeding Act, but he followed that by the record of the Milltown Cow Testing Association, which showed that the yield of our cattle was going up. That done, he passed on to the next topic. Is not that so, Deputy?
The Deputy's case was that the Live-stock Breeding Act had let the country down and that the yield of Shorthorn cows was going down in the country. Here is the cow testing association's record:—1940, 466 gallons; 1941, 474 gallons; 1942, 466 gallons; 1943, 455 gallons; 1944, 428 gallons; 1945, 466 gallons, and 1946, 491 gallons. That was at a time when we had no artificial manures, when the fertility of our land had notoriously gone down, when the difficulties of feeding cattle adequately must have been immensely increased to the people in the milch cow areas. Is not that a most striking advertisement of the Act? I am going to get that record framed and hung up in my office in the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
I hope it will be of great help to the Department. Perhaps I have not that oratorical ability of the Minister—I could not claim to have it— to put over the point I intended to put over. In putting that comparison of the cow testing association's figures I also gave the figures of the supply of milk to the Milltown Co-operative Creamery. I drew the attention of the Minister and of the House to the fact that the members of the Milltown Cow Testing Association are as nearly related as is humanly possible to the creamery area. I have not my notes as I did not expect this. I gave the figures of the supply of milk from 1940 to 1946. I pointed to the fact that the milk yield had gone up—will you oblige with the number of gallons?
Comment on this
And 4 lbs. per cow increase of butter fat. I pointed to that fact, but at the same time I pointed to the fact that the supply of milk to the creamery in that area— Milltown—had gone down by 60,286 gallons per year as from 1940 to 1946, with the intention of showing that even the cow testing association's figures are not an accurate reflex of the condition of milk supply. A point I want to elaborate is this——
Comment on this
I will ask the Deputy not to elaborate further now; we can discuss the matter at another time.
Comment on this
They are most valuable and to my mind constitute a very striking vindication of the Livestock Breeding Act where people can cooperate by running well-run cow testing associations.
Deputy James Collins spoke of carting stones seven or eight miles for field drainage. Surely to God if you are thinking of carting stones seven or eight miles, it would be worth your while to think of using cement tiles or three-inch pipes. If you have to cart stones seven or eight miles you would make drainage too expensive to be economical and I imagine that it would pay very well either to make or to purchase cement tiles for that purpose. He suggests that if we are going to end compulsion in wheat we should have compulsory nothing. He advocates shelter belts. I thoroughly agree, but I do not think we ought to pay our neighbours to put shelter belts on their own land. Why should they not put them down when they get the trees for nothing from the county councils? If a man is too lazy to dig a trench and put into it free trees, if the wind blows the thatch off his house the "divil" mend him.
Comment on this
If he loses his thatch that is the best incentive he can have.
Deputy O'Rourke, in a most mild and seductive way, asked was not this the policy of Fianna Fáil that Deputy James Dillon, Minister for Agriculture, was preaching. He had not a word to say against it. After 27 hours of hullabalco during which I was everything short of a branded criminal, I invite my friends to make up their minds. Am I a villain tearing down the foundations of agriculture in Ireland? By the time we come to discuss the trade agreement will they oblige me by making up their minds. Are we carrying on the agreement they made in 1938 and no more, or have we sold the Irish people lock, stock and barrel into the hands of the base and brutal Saxon? They must make up their minds. It will have to be one or the other. It cannot be both.
Now I am coming to flax. I would be a foolish man coming from County Monaghan if I did not. I have abolished all control on scutching charges, because there is now scutching capacity in the country considerably in excess of the total acreage of flax. I want to make this announcement. If the scutch millers try to overcharge those farmers who grow flax I look to co-operative societies to operate flax scutching mills in order to see that the scutch millers do not get away with it. If they do exploit their customers this year, they can shut their mills up because people will get out of flax and I would advise them to get out of it. The Board of Trade in Great Britain heretofore has supplied the seed and bought the crop. They have announced this year that they have disinterested themselves in it, but that they invite the linen spinners in Northern Ireland to make a similar contract with our people. That contract could be settled in a word. If the linen spinners in Northern Ireland pay the same price, grade for grade, for our flax that they pay to people in Northern Ireland, we will grow flax and, if they do not, we will not.
Comment on this
The Minister has brought up the question as to the controlled price of flax scutching. As I happen to come from one of the premier flax-growing counties——
Comment on this
I will not give way to the Deputy. Deputy Beegan upbraids me about the price of wool. Deputy Beegan, who voted for a prohibition on the export of wool and who voted for the Fellmongers Act in this House upbraids me with regard to the price of wool. Those two things, the resolution prohibiting the export of wool and the Fellmongers Act put the farmers of this country, bound hand and foot, into the power of as unscrupulous a ring of racketeers as ever held sway in this country.
Comment on this
The position was that the price in Ireland was higher than the price outside and therefore they prohibited the export for fear people would buy it dearer and sell it cheaper. Do you think we are all fools?
Comment on this
You are asking that in a doubtful kind of way. You are afraid you may get an answer.
Comment on this
I think I have come near to the end of the questions I have been asked. I wish Deputy Allen and Deputy Ó Briain would make up their minds. Deputy Allen says that the egg scheme is a delightful scheme and that they will do all they can to help. Deputy Ó Briain said: "Be careful. You may destroy us with that egg scheme. Look at it with great suspicion." I wish they would meet somewhere and make up their minds and then talk with the same voice. There is no use in one fellow getting up to praise it and the other fellow getting up to give it a stab in the back, because it is easy to kill it. If Fianna Fáil Deputies go round the country saying: "If you go in for eggs or hens you will be in a sorry plight this time two years," they can do a lot to damage it. But I do not give two fiddle-de-dees what they do because, with their help or without their help, we shall make a success of Deputy Smith's egg scheme and, if we make a success of it, let us give the devil his due. It was Deputy Smith made the agreement and, any loopholes he left in it, I filled them.
I think I have answered all the questions I was asked. I am not a bit afraid of the verdict of the country. Every blunderbuss you could find by way of argument, insult, violence and threat Fianna Fáil has launched against me in the last 27 hours and you did not knock a feather out of me. I am not one bit distressed. My confidence in the rectitude of the agricultural policy of this Government is not in the least shaken. My profound conviction that the events will justify the decisions we have taken and are now taking is unshaken.
My profound conviction that the farmers of the country will do more and do it better as free men than they would ever do it as inspector-ridden slaves is stronger now than ever it was, and I am quite content to let my reputation and the fate of the Government to which I belong stand or fall by the result of this test: is Fianna Fáil's policy of slavery or this Government's policy of freedom for the farmers the best for the Irish people in the long run?
Comment on this
Motion—"That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration"—put.
Do you agree with this result?