We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplementary Estimate, 1948-49. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach.

Contributions 221–456 of 700. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I am coming down very quickly to the point. I do not know how they will like the point when they hear it. This is the letter: "Mitchelstown Creamery, Mitchelstown, 16th July, 1948."

Comment on this

I take it this has reference to cheese.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It sounds like a particular point in regard to agriculture and not a point in regard to general Government policy.

Comment on this

This is general Government policy as enunciated by the Minister for Agriculture, and I want to know whether or not the Taoiseach stands over it.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I cannot allow the Deputy to read that letter because it has reference to a particular point of agricultural policy the responsibility for which lies with the Minister for Agriculture and not with the Taoiseach. It is not a matter of general Government policy.

Comment on this

I understand that there is collective responsibility in the Government.

Comment on this

But not for cheese, Deputy.

Comment on this

I would expect that there would be general or collective responsibility for the dismissal of 113 men in the town of Mitchelstown.

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong in that.

Comment on this

Apparently that does not concern the Taoiseach or those other people over there, nor does the policy which is going to take 3d. per gallon off the price of the farmers' milk.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

If we take that line we could go over every single Estimate again.

Comment on this

I want to know whether this is general agricultural policy or not.

Comment on this

What!

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is afraid to let me read the letter because he knew what it was about.

Comment on this

I did of course. May I say that the Deputy announced outside that he was going to raise this question with regard to cheese if he could get away with it. I am not going to allow him to get away with it.

Comment on this

I promise those people over there that if they cause damage to my constituency they will pay for it. There seems to be general dodging on the part of the lawyers or the liars. That seems to be getting under the hide of the lawyers' skin and a lawyer's skin is supposed to be thicker than that of an ox.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy know? I have not yet discovered that he knows anything.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You are not likely to.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach ought to learn not to interrupt.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It would be better if the Deputy would continue his speech in an orderly manner.

Comment on this

What speech?

Comment on this

I will, if the Acting-Chairman will keep the children quiet——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It sounds more like a screech.

Comment on this

—— and make them learn their lesson, if they can do so. I want to know what this general agricultural policy of which we hear so much about is?

Comment on this

Cheese.

Comment on this

We hear day and night a lot of talk about the saving of money. We have a branch of our agricultural policy that does not require subsidisation and in which we can get a better price for our commodity than we can for manufacturing our milk into butter.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy has already been told that he cannot continue on that line. He will have to desist and go on to general Government policy.

Comment on this

I want to know what is general Government policy in connection with this matter——

Comment on this

Cheese.

Comment on this

—— and I cannot find it out. However, if that is the attitude I will have a good half-hour here and I will have the daft Minister for Agriculture maybe next Tuesday night——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy will then be in order.

Comment on this

I hope so, and I hope there will be somebody in the Chair who will be in order.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy must withdraw that remark. It is not the occupant of the Chair but the Chair itself that deserves respect.

Comment on this

I would suggest also that the Deputy should withdraw the epithet "daft".

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It is a favourite word of the Minister himself.

Comment on this

Does Deputy de Valera stand over the epithet?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It should never have been allowed.

Comment on this

Does Deputy de Valera support me now?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I do.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

As a matter of fact the Chair did not hear the remark but if the Deputy did make it I think it should not have been made.

Comment on this

I regret that, but the remark has come so often from the present Minister for Agriculture in this House and has been applied by him to previous Ministers in this House, it has become quite orderly and respectable. On at least 20 occasions I have heard that remark hurled across the floor of this House by him.

Comment on this

Surely this is not general Government policy?

Comment on this

I will be very silent, too, but I wish that the Taoiseach would keep that Minister in order——

Comment on this

He is in great order.

Comment on this

——and not have him running away making one declaration to-day and another declaration to-morrow. The agricultural community of this country are entitled to know where they stand. They are entitled to know from morning till night and from to-day till to-morrow what the policy of the Government is. They should not be badgered in the way they are being badgered at present—waiting from morning till night to know what the new policy is in regard to these matters. That is what I was anxious to allude to.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

On a point of order. Is the Taoiseach expected to be able to deal with the ordinary day-to-day policy of Ministers?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I have already ruled that out of order. Day-to-day policies do not come under this Estimate.

Comment on this

I do not want day-to-day policy. I want the Government to have a policy and to stand over it. I do not want them to be writing to the people to-day telling them to do this and racing away from it to-morrow morning.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins has a policy every day.

Comment on this

He has, by Jove.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It got ye over there.

Comment on this

The Deputy seems to be very proud of the fact that we are over here. Let me assure the Deputy that I am getting the utmost amusement out of being over here and that it is simply——

Comment on this

So are we.

Comment on this

——and solely because of the worry about the danger to our people and the damage that is going to be done to our people and that is being done to them that I am raising this point. These people do not know where they stand. The agricultural community of this country do not know from morning till night where they stand.

Comment on this

They are very happy.

Comment on this

They are told to-day that it is a matter of producing milk; they are told to-morrow, according to the Minister for Agriculture, that it is dangerous and foolish—he said that he wanted to declare in this House that it was definite lunacy to produce butter. Then he comes along when we make cheese——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy will have to desist from that line of argument or sit down. I have told him that twice before.

Comment on this

The Deputy can talk about cheese on next Tuesday night.

Comment on this

There is a maggot in the cheese.

Comment on this

Let us turn to other aspects of this matter and see where exactly the garden path up which we are being led leads, and see exactly what is the policy in this matter in regard to the agricultural community. We had a lot of talk about trade and a lot of talk about transatlantic airliners, and so forth. We were told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that a whole lot of cement was going to go towards the making of new runways. We were told here, too, that the agricultural community must wait and do without the £150,000 that was guaranteed by the previous Government for their farm buildings—because, apparently, the material is required for cement for runways for those luxury travellers Deputy Davin was talking about a short while ago.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy is again covering the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. He must desist.

Comment on this

Apparently the principal industry in this country is not to be touched upon——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Not in detailed items.

Comment on this

——by this Government. Surely when the Government make a case the details of the case must be given.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy was already given the details in the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

I have a whole lot more to say. I will surprise you. That is item No. 2 and item No. 3, which is of grave importance also, is the definite attack that was made here on the previous Government in connection with barley.

Comment on this

The Deputy is off again.

Comment on this

We want to know now what the position is because next week the Dáil will be adjourning and when we come back after the general election the harvest will be sold.

Comment on this

It will keep you there.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You will lose a few bob on that.

Comment on this

I want to know whether we are entitled to go across to Messrs. Arthur Guinness and Son, Limited, and fix our price for barley this year.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

That is a question the Deputy must address to the Minister for Agriculture in the ordinary fashion. He cannot discuss it on a debate on general Government policy.

Comment on this

Is it a matter of indifference whether the agricultural community will get £50,000 or £60,000 extra for their barley or not?

Comment on this

Did the Minister not say that he would make a statement on that matter next week? On a point of order. The Deputy had a question down to-day to the Minister for Agriculture on that matter and he was asked to repeat it this day week.

Comment on this

That does not clarify the matter. I think the farmers of this country are entitled to know——

Comment on this

You are not entitled to get to know it on this Estimate.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

That is not in order on this Estimate. I have spoken to the Deputy several times. For obvious reasons I do not want to adopt another course.

Comment on this

Since the Deputy cannot and, apparently, dare not speak on agriculture in this House on the general policy of the Government, I will leave it at that.

Comment on this

Now that the storm has subsided I want to say that I think this House appreciates the fact that we have in charge of the Government a man of sincerity and a man who will bring to his task the enthusiasm, the energy and the honesty that that task demands. Deputy Corry has been inclined to talk a good deal about agriculture. I would be rather inclined, when speaking on the Taoiseach's Estimate, to ask him to regard himself in his function as head of the Government as a farmer with 26 fertile fields under his control, but as a farmer who is always anxious and determined to add to those 26 fertile fields six other fields which have been amputated from us. I ask the Taoiseach to bend his will during the four years, at least, when he will hold office as Taoiseach to developing these 26 fields as a farmer would develop his farm—that is, to get the last ounce of productivity out of them and to ensure that they provide for the people in this area the maximum of comfort and the best possible standard of living. That is the function which the Taoiseach is called upon to perform.

Deputy Corry appears to be in fear and trembling that before the Dáil meets again there will be a general election. He knows well that were it not for something that happened on the 18th February last he would have put his general election over him during the past few months and the 13th Dáil would be as dead as Queen Victoria. We have now a Taoiseach with a sense of responsibility and a Taoiseach who does not go galloping off to the Park on the slightest provocation to dissolve Parliament simply because he is not getting his own way in everything or because he thinks it will help to benefit his Party.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Have the people no right to be consulted?

Comment on this

The people have a perfect right to be consulted and the people gave their decision very plainly and in a very definite manner to the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

And we accepted it unquestionably.

Comment on this

The people were consulted too often probably.

Comment on this

I think it is one of the things that Deputy de Valera probably regrets.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

No.

Comment on this

He regrets that he went to the people too often. There is such a thing as intimidating people by over-frequent elections and the Leader of the Opposition seemed to believe he had established a technique by which he could successfully intimidate the people. But the people have shown that they are not prone to intimidation. If Deputy de Valera's successor should ever think that the people can be intimidated——

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

By being consulted?

Comment on this

I would give him these words of advice: "Remember de Valera." When this Parliament met on the 18th February I was one of the Deputies who suggested that it was desirable that all Parties should join together in the formation of a national Government. I did that not because I believed that there was any outstanding merit in the representatives that Fianna Fáil might send in to the Government but because I believed that, as representatives of the people, they were entitled to representation in the Government. I think the leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party now regret that they did not accept that invitation.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Not a bit.

Comment on this

Neither do we.

Comment on this

They see their Party dwindling. Deputy Corry says he is happy on the opposition side of the House. I suppose he is. He never appeared to be very happy on the Government side of it but I do not think Deputy Corry's leaders are particularly happy on the opposition side of the House.

Comment on this

You did not seem to be very happy in all the Parties to which you belonged.

Comment on this

I did not like the note upon which Deputy Lemass closed his speech to-day. It sounded like a note of distrust. I am one of those who always had a very considerable respect for Deputy Lemass. I have always thought that he was a very able man and a very able Minister. I regret that he should be so bitterly and venomously angry because time has proved that it is possible for this country to carry on under a Government which Fianna Fáil does not control.

There are many urgent tasks immediately ahead. It should be the Taoiseach's function to hold the balance fairly between all sections of the community. I have always held since I came into this House ten years ago that that balance has never been fairly held. Agriculture has never been fairly treated. Half the people of this country are gainfully employed in agriculture. Yet, up to the period of the war they were never able to win for themselves more than one-fourth of the national income. That was always a crying injustice. That is an injustice that must cease if we are to prevent the steady divergence of our people from the rural areas to the towns and the export of them abroad.

I have always been somewhat amazed at hearing Deputies speak about a machine majority in this House. I wonder do those Deputies know what they are talking about? As an Independent farmer Deputy I have never known of any machine that could either induce or compel me to cast my vote in a particular way in this House, direct me as to how I should speak in this House, or as to how I should act. I have always acted on my own independent judgment. I have never recognised any Party Whip. I think that is true of all Independent Deputies. We judge the issues on their merits. We stand over decisions we have taken. I think it is desirable that there should be a certain number of Independent Deputies in this House. We can view matters impartially. We can at times, perhaps, influence Parties when they seek to submerge vital national interests for purely Party gain, or Party advantage, or to score Party points. There never was in the history of our country a time when there were so many urgent national questions requiring attention. The Taoiseach is the head of a Government who have declared that their first object as a Government is to promote the expansion of agricultural and industrial development. There has been an equality of interests upon those two branches of development. Agricultural development and expansion are essential and desirable; so, too, are the development and expansion of our industrial potentialities and our mineral potentialities. All these things require to be developed in order to keep our people in productive and remunerative employment within this country and to undo the evils under which this country has laboured.

I wish the Taoiseach success in the onerous tasks he has undertaken. I want to make a special appeal to him. Since his Government have made the development and expansion of agriculture and industry their main concern, I think it is their duty to see that the necessary credit facilities for the expansion of those two important branches of our economic life should be made available. I am told by people in business that there is a tendency in the banks to restrict credit. If that policy is directed against the interests of the nation—if the Government are satisfied that it is directed against the best interests of the nation —then it is the duty of the Government to correct and offset that policy. It is also the duty of the Government to build up the country's resources and the reserves of the country as quickly as possible to meet the needs of any world emergency. That task is one that cannot be delayed. Food supplies and supplies of raw materials for our industries, together with essential fuel must be accumulated. These are urgent problems and I am sure they will have the wholehearted consideration of the Government.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I think it would be no harm if I broke away from the tenor of some of the speeches and if I try to apply myself to some specific matters of Government policy of immediate interest to the community The first one which I would like to discuss with the Taoiseach is the co-ordination and direction of the activities of various Departments with a view to securing a proper line of action, having regard to the country as whole.

What I have in mind is this, that in every Government each Minister is charged with his own particular responsibility. He has his primary interests and each individual Minister is naturally and humanly tempted and, in fact, is charged with the duty of pursuing the end for which he is there and trying to secure the maximum good for the particular element in the community's life which he represents. That is as it should be, but it is elementary that if there was no co-ordinating agency, all horses would be pulling against each other and anything might happen, so that in order to make our system work there is a Government and a head of that Government, the function of the Government being the Executive Committee of this House, composed of those Ministers, a body where those Ministers can be co-ordinated and can exchange their views and their problems and arrive at a common solution under the general direction of the head of the Government. Perhaps more than anything else, the duties of the head of the Government are to co-ordinate the activities of these Departments.

One realises that the present Government is not very long in office and I wish fairly to make all allowance for that fact, but I am afraid that there are already evidences of a lack of co-ordination, evidences that the Departments in certain instances are pulling away on their own without having due regard to problems that any Minister will have, and the community is suffering from the results of that lack of co-ordination. There is, up to the moment anyway, some evidence of lack of Governmental decisions, a lack of the taking on of responsibility of the Government so as to have a homogeneous, defined and clear line of policy with which the elements which are the Ministers can be co-ordinated.

These are general words, but I think that they express my ideas accurately enough. While trying, especially as time is short, to avoid going into detail with regard to every department, I want to refer to a few specific instances of what I mean, primarily with regard to this question of co-ordination. I want to try to focus attention on the over-all picture, because that is the picture which represents the repercussions on the man in the street and that is what we are here to look after.

I will take a problem which is acutely noticeable in the City of Dublin, but which has ramifications in our industrial and agricultural life. We have heard and read a great deal about the meat difficulty in Dublin—the shortage of meat. That is only an aspect of a general problem and the general problem is this, that the agricultural community at the moment is in a position to obtain relatively high prices and it is relatively prosperous. We have been able in the past year or so to secure adequate markets for certain of our live stock. That is an excellent situation from the point of view of the farmer, who has got the price, and from the point of view of the Department of Agriculture, if it continues and if that trend can be maintained. But that situation, favourable and all as it is for one section of the community, is operating unfavourably on another section.

The fact is that in Dublin and other centres the prices of vegetables and meat have so risen as to place a serious burden on the ordinary man in the street. I have on more than one occasion pleaded for the white-collar worker. There are in certain categories people who are comfortable and well off, but there are other categories where the women of the house find it difficult to victual their families. In that case the woman finds her menu must include more meatless days than before. There you have something paradoxical, a prosperous situation for the farmer and a difficult one for the housekeeper. If our farmers get a high price for their cattle across the water, naturally the cattle tend to go that way, and some positive action is necessary if you are to have cattle of comparable quality for victualling the towns at home.

If there is no co-ordination between the producer and the consumer you have the position that times of prosperity for the farmer will mean times of severity for the townsman and, on the other hand, times of cheap food for the townsman will usually mean a time of depression for the farmer. That is the situation and it is there the co-ordinating policy or function of the Government and the Taoiseach should come in.

Here you have a problem, again getting back to the question of the meat situation in Dublin. It has gone beyond the limit of automatic adjustment. So long as you had the butchers getting a substantial profit, when they could bear the burdens of the trade without passing them on to the consumer, you had a situation which made Governmental interference unnecessary. I do not want to go into the figures mentioned last night, but it is obvious, and it has not been controverted, that the limit of endurance has come for the butchering trade. The butchers have given their figures for profits, which at no time since 1940, except on one occasion, exceeded 5 per cent. In 1944 their profits went to 6.5 per cent., but there is the significant fact that in 1947 they had a loss— a minus profit of 1.5—while in 1948 the minus profit was 2.8. Without going into the merits of their case, these figures are there and the Minister for Industry and Commerce should be able to prove if these figures are right and if they express a fact. If they are wrong, let us be told that they are.

Comment on this
A Deputy

The Minister has already told us they are.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am just taking the figures and if they are controverted I am open to correction, but that does not affect my argument. The butchers will tell you that they would far prefer to sell meat more cheaply because they find that the decrease in sales has so much offset the increase in prices that they are losing more than if they were selling larger quantities at a cheaper price and they are very anxious that the price of meat should be kept at a reasonable level. I have tried to study the problem impartially and I would invite Deputies to look at this question in the same spirit and to see what can be done.

The problem, then, is a question of co-ordination. The Government in many questions of that nature will be faced with the problem of striking a mean in the best interests of the community. Only a Government with accurate sources of information and complete and adequate returns, can attempt to give an accurate answer to this problem. I would not be so presumptuous as to give an answer without accurate information, but I am making the point that the co-ordinating function of the Government is to deal with such a problem and not leave the people of Dublin to suffer from a meat shortage and a vegetable shortage.

Comment on this

That could not be traced back to the slaughter of calves by any chance?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It could not.

Comment on this

Of course it could.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If the Minister would allow me to develop my argument objectively, we would get much further in this House. I am attempting to deal with the Taoiseach's problem fairly and squarely with due regard to the fact that he has a problem. If the Minister for Lands would cease playing politics and try to get down to the problems of the country, he would be rendering a more useful service to the people. We all realise the problem which the Taoiseach has and we can sympathise with him in the many problems which anybody in his position will have to tackle where the solution can only be provided by finding a mean, where the solution will have to be one of balance, a solution that may not please completely either his Minister for Agriculture, his Minister for Lands or his Minister for Industry and Commerce when they look at it from their own narrow compartments, but when together they have to strike, in common agreement, a certain line of action, which is going to be the best mean solution for the whole of them. We can all, particularly a Party which has been in office, sympathise with him in that problem.

I have taken a specific instance in which there is an obvious need for co-ordinated action. There is a possible solution that jumps to my mind. You may, for instance, subsidise meat in the towns. I know the difficulties of that. I am not getting up like other people and saying "Subsidise and all will be well", but I am suggesting that that is one avenue that might be explored. There are, I know, the difficulties, not only of finding the money for the subsidy, but the question of the administration of the subsidy, which is an extremely difficult matter. So far as the question of vegetables is concerned, the Government has my sincere sympathy in facing a problem of that nature. Nevertheless, the fact that the problem is difficult of solution is no reason why a determined effort should not be made to solve it.

To come back to the question of subsidies again, the question of finding the money would be the first objection. There I would join issue on the attitude already adopted in regard to certain matters. I am not going to cast aspersions as to motives but, to my mind, it was an improper thing to do, namely to reduce taxation on non-essentials and recreation items such as beer—not so much perhaps in the case of beer because so far as the workman's pint is concerned I make an exception —but on items such as cinemas and so forth, giving them reliefs in taxation while permitting an increase in income-tax and other items referred to in the Budget. If it were necessary to find the money for the subsidisation of meat in the City of Dublin, to enable citizens who now find themselves obliged to face more meatless days than they should, who find themselves going without meat while the finest beef in the country is being exported to feed the foreigner— a trade from which we are getting a very necessary return in cash—why should we not try to provide that money rather than give remissions of taxation on non-essentials? If money were the objection to subsidisation, I would have no hesitation in recommending to the Government to consider whether it would not be better to appropriate moneys to make a prime food available to our own people in the towns and to find that money by a form of essential taxation rather than to give reliefs in taxation on non-essentials. That is one suggestion that might be examined.

Another is how far, in so far as the prosperity which will come to the country through the cattle trade is concerned, a fair percentage of it could not be deflected in order to make a reasonable proportion available to our people in the cities. I am all the time admitting that there is a difficulty, but the fact that such a difficulty exists is no excuse for not tackling it. I move from that. It would be well, while this situation persists as it is, that it should be tackled. I have said that the question of nutrition of the people in certain quarters of the city will need attention. That is a matter of Government policy as a whole rather than a matter for the Minister for Health, because he cannot attend to it unless there is a co-ordination of the functions of other Departments. There is no use waiting. I presume the Government is not stalling on the meat problem in the hope that the price of cattle will fall. That is a negation in itself and I presume, having heard the Minister for Agriculture on cattle prices and on the prosperity attending the cattle trade, there is very little possibility of such a situation adjusting itself naturally. That is if the information given by the Minister for Agriculture is right. If it will not adjust itself naturally, it cannot be left just to force an unnatural situation on the people of the city. I have laboured that from the point of view of an example.

I want to get back to stress again the need for Governmental action as a whole, the need for a definite policy, the need for decision and action on policy, apart from administrative single action on the part of individual Departments of State. Now, similar problems arise in connection with such things as the economy drive in regard to fuel. Suppose we admit without prejudice, as the lawyers say, for the purpose of argument, all the arguments of the Minister for Finance in regard to that—I will join issue in a moment as to how he affects Government policy—and suppose we take it that he got his way, what about the counter co-ordinating problems that arise as a result of that in the Department of Industry and Commerce? Two problems arise immediately. There is the problem of the personnel concerned and the finding of employment for them, and the sudden withdrawal of the lorries engaged and so forth. From the point of view of a long-term policy by the Government, and considering the present unsettled world situation, where is the evidence of co-ordination in regard to that problem? The only evidence we can find is that the Minister comes in here with an axe and looks at it from a certain doctrinaire financial point of view. The man in control of the purse strings pulls the strings, but what about the other Departments?

Take, again, the Government's decision to increase income-tax and to decrease the taxation on beer. That may have been a good thing, even from the administrative point of view of the Department of Finance. That Department may have found that in some quarters the high tax was not bringing in the same revenue, but, as against that, were two things considered from another angle?

I had the honour of being elected to this House from an area in the City of Dublin, and in this city I have heard this kind of misguided talk. I have heard workmen in the building line say what was so commonly said in England, that it was not worth their while working beyond a certain limit because if they did their earnings over and above would be taken in income-tax. That has recently been said in Dublin City. It was commonly said across the water. It has been said by workmen, "We would not work for the boss for less than the trade union rate and if he tried to make us work, we would strike, but here they are working for less for the Government." Now, there is a factor in Government policy which, looked at from the point of view of the Department of Finance, is one thing, but looked at from the point of view of the Minister for Local Government, who has the problem of getting houses built quickly, is another. These are pretty good examples of what I mean. The appointment of committees to survey employment may be very necessary, but if things are not to be allowed to drift, definite Government policy as a whole and definite co-ordination in these matters is essential if we are to avoid the cross-cuts of various Departments made perhaps with the best intentions in the world. I have analysed all this as nakedly as I could with a full appreciation of the Taoiseach's problems. The Taoiseach of the present Government has probably more problems than the Taoiseach in any other Government, and a Coalition Government is notorious for difficulties of that nature.

Comment on this

There are no such difficulties in this Government.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am very glad to hear the Taoiseach say that. I look forward then to results of unified action and unified co-ordination. By their fruits you shall know them.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Time is getting on, and I do not want to delay by passing words across the House. I want to get on now to another matter. The respect in which a Government is held by the people of a country is an important thing. It has been customary for us, and for other countries, to treat Ministers and the representatives of other countries with respect. From that point of view, I want to draw the Taoiseach's attention to a scurrilous, degrading, insulting and altogether unworthy article or report that appeared in the Daily Express on June 17th. I think it is a thing that should not be let pass in the interests of the good name and in the interests of the dignity of the Government of this country. The heading to the article is “Costello, Dillon to the Boys Over There. Is it our Beef you are Wanting?” It reads: “Mr. John Costello, Prime Minister of Éire.”

Comment on this

I am responsible for a lot but I do not think I am responsible for the Daily Express.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I want to draw this matter to the Taoiseach's attention because I think it is one that calls for some formal action on the part of the Government of this country when the Government of this country is so sneered at and belittled as it is in this article.

Comment on this

Assuming that everything that the Deputy says is correct, I do not see that there is any possible action that this Government can take in the matter. I have not seen the article.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

This is a matter which affects the good name of the Government as a whole. It is a matter in which the Taoiseach primarily is named. It is a scurrilous and unworthy report which is an injury to the Taoiseach and to the Government of this country. I think that some positive action should be taken by the Government, and to that extent I think I am entitled to raise it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach says he has no power to interfere, and if he has not it cannot be raised.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Why cannot the Taoiseach take some action about it?

Comment on this

On a point of order, cannot the Taoiseach stop the circulation of this paper in the country?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not know that he can without legislation.

Comment on this

Is there not a censorship?

Comment on this

That is a new one.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The mechanism by which this problem should be tackled is one thing, but the fact as to whether it should be tackled or not is another. As I have already said in another way, these problems, when they arise, have to be tackled whether they are difficult or not. Here on an occasion when the Ministers of this country were over trying——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach says that he has no power to interfere. Therefore, it is not his function and it cannot be discussed.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I submit that the Minister has power and if he has not——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have to be guided by what the Taoiseach says, that he has no power in the matter.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Taoiseach says he has no power to interfere. I think that is open to question, but is the Deputy not entitled——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair must be guided by the Taoiseach in the matter.

Comment on this

But, apart altogether from that, is the Deputy not entitled to quote from the columns of a news-ship paper which is in circulation in this country?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

You know, a Chinn Comhairle——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not know yet. The Deputy has asked a question, whether Deputy de Valera, junior, is not entitled to quote something that affects the country. If it does not relate to the province of the Taoiseach's Vote, which is before the House—and it does not, on the word of the Taoiseach—it is not in his power. That finishes it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If I wanted to put a dirty twist on it or misrepresent it, I could very easily do it by putting this report in another way to the Taoiseach, by asking what did he mean by saying this and by accepting this as a correct report. I have tried to be fair in dealing with it, as I should and as everybody in the House should, from the point of view of the dignity and the good name of our Government abroad, whereas the Taoiseach is trying to stifle me with regard to this article and force me into a position which members of his own Party would not scruple to avail of, to quote it and put the onus on him to deny its truth. The Taoiseach has put that onus on me, but I am loath to stoop to putting such words in the Taoiseach's mouth, words that I would hardly think worthy of him. The Daily Express, however, puts these words in quotation into the Taoiseach's mouth.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I will not hear the Deputy further on it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If the Chair pleases, I can ask the Taoiseach through you did he say certain things as Taoiseach of this country on a certain occasion, a certain night in England, or not. If he did not, I am entitled to ask him for the sake of the good name of the Government, for the good name of the country at home and abroad, to take action against this scurrilous rag that reported him as saying that. If he said it—but I do not believe that he said it as it is so much beneath any man of standing, and what is attributed to the Minister for Agriculture, too, would be beneath any man of standing. The only conclusion I can draw then, is that it is gross misrepresentation of this country, and for the good name of the country for goodness' sake do something about it. I will leave it at that. I am very sorry that I could not have dealt with that objectively as I have dealt with other matters.

Either bouquet throwing or criticism will do us very little good. Let us face our problems, see what they are and then discuss them. Then we will get somewhere. That has often been suggested in this House. There is a problem with regard to general Government co-ordination that I would like to deal with. We have undoubtedly at the present moment a time of stress and uncertainty, and I think that it is not unsober on my part to say that if the situation had been so in the years before 1939, war would have been precipitated immediately. Perhaps it is only our proximity to the last calamity and the fact that some of the participants or ex-participants are relatively exhausted preserves us from the outbreak of armed conflict. At some time in the future, whether it be near or far, there is a virtual certainty, I am afraid, of another world calamity. Under these circumstances, it is obvious that again the co-ordinating functions of the Government must come into play. The foresight of the Taoiseach must come into play in looking ahead, while the Ministers in their day to day activities are doing their best for the day.

We can learn the lessons from the past showing that there are certain questions of co-ordination which must come in. The Minister for Finance wants to economise, but would it not be more prudent if the Minister for Industry and Commerce looked ahead, and had we not better have adequate stocks? That is an immediate conflict between two Departments at the present moment in embryo.

The Government has a very serious decision to take as to how far we should provide for the future. The question of fuel is a very good example. The disastrous winter of 1946 caught us with an acute problem, largely a transport one. We learned one lesson, but the danger has not materialised and because of the attempt to keep some reserves there may be a certain loss with regard to fuel. These are only incidentals of the problem of the Government and they can only do their best with reasonable foresight. With regard to the present situation, what co-ordinating action can they take? You have financial restrictions on one hand and day-to-day problems on the other, but is it not desirable in such a situation to ensure that we will have adequate supplies for transport? I referred to the turf situation. It is all right to say that we should not cut turf, but what is to happen to our supplies and to the transport question associated with them and what can be done to keep up our vehicle transport? We were getting—to use the common phrase—very shook with regard to transport towards the end of the last emergency. What are you going to do with regard to certain stocks, particularly nonperishable stocks that experience has taught us we can run short of? What about the wheat situation? Is it prudent to continue our present policy? In spite of the predilections of the Minister for Agriculture, we should provide reserves of food at home. as an insurance policy, as it were, if only as that. What can we afford to get in by way of reserves? There are specific lessons that we might never have been taught only for the emergency. Before the recent war, if any Deputy stood up in this House and told us: "You had better look to your supply of matches; you will have an acute problem if war breaks out", what would we have thought?

Comment on this

If he had lived through the 1914-1918 war he would have known it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I know that with regard to the recent emergency, matches were quite a problem—it is a relatively unimportant item, I know, but when it comes to an emergency the supply of matches becomes an acute problem for the country. In fact, at one stage, if the Army had not been able, by means of a certain plant they had which was originally designed to supply phosphorus chemicals, to supply us with some, I doubt very much if we would have been able to continue through 1944 and 1945. The fact that we would be able to produce chemicals here at all would have a twofold effect. If you are able to produce chemicals here, the man who is exporting the stuff must give it to you, whereas if you are completely dependent on him he would not. That is a factor which must also be taken into consideration. If, at that time, we could not have looked after ourselves, the English suppliers, from information which is available, would not have sent us the materials we required, but as we were, we were treated with an eye to a later market. That, too, is a very big factor in bringing in essential supplies. That is merely a small instance, but it is the type of thing that will occur again all round. I would therefore strongly urge on the Government that such a possibility should be considered and the Government need fear no unfair criticism from me on the matter of prudence.

On the Minister for Agriculture's Estimate, I have already talked of the question of trying to have our own source of fertiliser. That, again, is a co-ordination problem because it ties up with three things. The actual plant or mechanism ties up with industry and commerce, while some of its uses tie up with defence, and the rest of its uses tie up with agriculture. No one Minister can deal with such a problem himself. For instance, the Minister for Agriculture might very well decide—he was very sympathetic during the debate on agriculture—that it would be a good idea if we were prepared to exploit our phosphorus and if we had some nitrogen plants here, whether a saving plant or a generating plant, but it is no part of the functions of the Minister for Agriculture to manufacture anything, in the industrial sense, so that it ties up with industry and commerce. There is a problem for the Government as a whole and a problem for which the country must hold them responsible, and, in particular, if the situation worsens or if a calamity should break, it is then, above all times, that the Government would be held responsible.

Having regard to the limited time for this debate, I hesitate to proceed further, but since probably nobody will mention another matter of co-ordination, I think I should. Again it takes me into a little detail on the Department of Defence. In the surveys before the last war, it is patently evident that, except for certain co-ordinating action brought in by the Department of Finance and the Department of Industry and Commerce, in many regards the Department of Defence was left, so to speak, to plough its own furrow and get ready for the task when it came upon it. It would have been very helpful if they had had more day to day information —the big information, of course, was swapped, but I am speaking of co-ordination at the lower levels, which can only flow from co-ordination at the top—and the Army authorities should have been kept completely briefed with police intelligence. There should have been a liaison between the police and the Army on the matter of intelligence. There should have been a liaison between External Affairs and the Army on the matter of general European intelligence, and our people in our foreign legations should have been instructed to take an interest in these things. We are too small a country to think of sending military attaches and I do not advocate that at all.

On the question of swapping information, before the last Government went out as part of the post-war idea, the idea was being encouraged—and I hope and presume the same thing will be encouraged under the present Government—and now more than ever I should like to commend it to the Taoiseach's attention in order that he may check on it. These swappings of information were very important because, first, if the Army authorities had had more day-to-day information, they might have been able to make a better estimate than they did make as to what was likely to happen, and, secondly, if they had had a proper police estimate, the Magazine Fort raid would never have happened. The Magazine Fort raid was to a certain extent due to that. I do not want to stir up anybody about the Magazine Fort—I merely refer to it. If anybody wants to know what happened in the Magazine Fort raid, it is this, that, at a very critical time for the nation——

Comment on this

It might be very interesting, but it does not arise on my Estimate.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I agree, but I appear to be worrying somebody on that side about it.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy not worry me about it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If that Magazine Fort raid had happened three months later, this country would have been tied up in the war, practically of a certainty, and the will of the people to remain neutral would have been completely defeated by a minority, so that I am mentioning the matter as indicating the need for co-ordination in the general direction, both in respect of problems at the moment, such as the meat problem and the general situation ahead, the problems which arise in relation to the general world picture.

In that regard, I should like to commend certain things to the attention of the Taoiseach in exactly the same spirit in which I commended them to the Minister for External Affairs, and with the full qualification in regard to the necessary tact and reticence which sometimes has to be associated with foreign relations, and, of course, in asking these questions, I am, on this occasion anyway, completely content, so far as an answer is concerned, to leave it to the discretion of the Taoiseach, but it does suggest a problem of co-ordination. The Minister for External Affairs, in his speech, referred to isolationism. He remarked that isolationism would be impossible in any future conflict and I couple that with remarks about a United States of Europe and the surrender of sovereignty. I think these were the words he used. Unfortunately, the printed report has not come to hand, and I speak subject to correction. There, obviously, the Minister is thinking of matters of the greatest and deepest import for the future of this country albeit they are problems which, once resolved in any particular way, may remain so resolved for ever, or, if not, for a very long time. Therefore, these problems in regard to external affairs in that connection obviously bring up problems which intimately touch the Government and the Taoiseach in his proper capacity as such. I would commend them, too, for scrutiny and careful co-ordination.

This is no place to go into the policy of the Minister for Finance, but the Minister for Finance is something more in a way. Financial policy is something of the Government as a whole and the general overall policy of the Government here has been a seeking for economy by a method of restrictions, a method by which heretofore, I am sorry to say, the Government have not brought very many benefits to the community beyond giving cheaper entertainment and cheaper drink. In this, I wonder is Government policy sound. Here is what you are doing. You are attempting the classical remedy for inflation in a localised area here which is only a small part of a large sterling area. So long as you remain at the par level with sterling, you are only a relatively microscopic portion of the sterling domain, and any perturbation you introduce here is unlikely to affect the trend of your currency as a whole, because your currency, because of the link, is the currency of that whole living space. Any perturbation you introduce here has its concomitant disadvantage. It is an almost invariable law of nature, or of politics, anyway, that any austerity remedy or adjustment of social matters nearly always brings some disadvantage, so that, in the long run, you are trying to choose the best means.

In the case of finance, here we are trying the classical remedy, the so-called austerity or restriction remedy, for which there may be a certain amount to be said in theory, without being able, by that remedy, to affect our currency because of this, so to speak, absence of a lockgate to wall in our own territory. Therefore, is it really wise for us to suffer all the disadvantages, when, in such a situation, the austerity programme is not going to give you the currency adjustment necessary to give you the relief you seek? It would be all very well if you are adopting this or any remedy which is pushed through logically and has some rational basis in company with everybody else over the whole area. Then the different units co-operating together might get some result, but is it wise to adopt the austerity remedy here when we were so much better off relatively in fundamentals than the big area next door to us, England, when, in regard to fundamentals of food and way of living generally, we were actually better off, though we were feeling the pinch, too? Does not the adoption of such a remedy mean voluntarily throwing ourselves from a relatively advantageous position into a general level of difficulty? Is that good policy? Is that good co-ordination policy? Further, read the papers to-day and you see that, whatever remedies are being adopted by the people on the other side, the cost of living is going up there. We are throwing ourselves into the melting-pot, so to speak, with them. We are only a small part. Quo vadis?

It is very easy for me to throw up the problem. I have tried to put it fairly, realising that the Taoiseach and the Government have the difficulty of solving it but, as against that, they are the Government; they are charged by the House and the people with that responsibility; and I think it is a legitimate function of a member of the Opposition to demand that that responsibility be discharged. I think I had better leave it there.

I could expand further on the economy argument, on the particular financial policy here. It seems to me, looking at it from one point of view, that the logical thing for the Minister for Finance to do, if he wanted to carry on on the line he was carrying on, would be to go the whole way with Clann na Poblachta and put in the lockgate. That would give him some possibility of getting some result. That would be added to the general level of the whole sterling area. Whether he would get a better or a just result, I am not prepared to say at the moment, but I realise that the problem of breaking with sterling at the moment is a very difficult one and would be a peculiarly difficult one, perhaps, at the moment. I do not want to go into it. You have three possibilities. If it is not at par, then it overvalues or devalues. In either case you have certain real difficulties that would have to be got over. Again, I am not the Government. I have not their information. I have not the facilities of staff for examining the problems and I am not going to imitate certain irresponsible people by pretending that I have the omnibus remedy to give. I have not. The problem is there and the Government has the information and it is the Government's duty to deal with it.

Incidentally, on the sterling question, I was applauded by the far side. I once propounded in public, and it was duly printed, the difficulties of that problem. I never got an answer. However, I leave it so. There is no use in this "hear, hear" business. The unfortunate Government of any country at this day has its problems. We will not help with doctrinaire approaches. We will not help with criticism that is aimed at merely criticism. We can help by examining the problems and realising them. It is in that spirit that I recommend what I have said to the Taoiseach, but, again, I repeat, the reins are in his hands and the hands of the Government and action is needed.

Comment on this

In accordance with the provisions as laid down in the Constitution, on the 18th February last, the Taoiseach, having been appointed according to that Constitution, duly presented his Government for ratification to the members of this House, and the Government which he presented was a new departure in Irish politics. I venture to think that it was a solution which this country unconsciously was seeking for and moving towards since the inception of this State. I am glad and happy to be sitting on the benches behind an inter-Party Government because I personally have always held the view, and have on every possible occasion enunciated that view, that the only suitable form of government to meet the special needs and the special requirements of this State is that type of government. I do not believe that the other system of Government which this State suffered under—and I use the expression "suffered under" deliberately—ever since its inception, was one that operated for the benefit of the citizens generally.

I do not want, in putting forward the following argument in support of what I am saying, to be immediately met by the suggestion that on the four different occasions that I refer to the country wanted a one-Party Government. We have had 13 general elections. This is the 13th Dáil. What the country has been striving for unconsciously all the time was to find the type of Government that really suited it and, in 1927, in 1932, in 1937 and in 1943, on the four occasions when, under the system of proportional representation, a Government was formed here of a Party nature, which did not command the majority of the support of this House, on each of these occasions the Government found it necessary to go to the country and to say to the country: "We cannot carry on because we were defeated in the Dáil and it is your duty now, in the interests of the country, to put us back as a Party Government." It was as true in 1927, under Cumann na nGaedheal as on the three occasions under Fianna Fáil. That was always done within a year of the previous election on those different occasions.

The general election of this year was on a different basis. The issue was put fully and fairly. The pleading was easy to understand. The issue was, shall this country be ruled by Party or shall it not? That was the issue that was made by the Government who went to the country before their term of office had expired, and the country gave its answer. It was not going to the country after one year of office saying: "We cannot carry on." It was putting the issue fairly and squarely before the people and, after 26 years of experience, the people gave an emphatic answer but, in doing so, they unconsciously followed the principles that are laid down and enshrined in the Constitution which I hold here in my hand.

That Constitution precludes the people of this country from electing their representatives in any manner except by the system of proportional representation and the whole spirit of that Constitution is driven in one direction only—that the Parliament, and through Parliament, the Government, shall be truly representative of all sections. If you want to say that there is something sacred in the words "Party Government," so sacred that it is wrong for us to depart from it, well, you do not find it in the Constitution. You have to go to the source from which it comes.

If the House will bear with me for a few short minutes, I propose to demonstrate the fact that, in urging upon us here a system of Party Government as necessary for the welfare of this State, we are trying to impose on our native institutions a system from outside that is not only foreign to our nature, foreign to our set up, but foreign to our Constitution. The Party system, as known to many Parliaments of the world to-day, originated in an historical event which took place in the country which is the birthplace and the home of modern Parliaments—our neighbour Britain. It arose as a direct result of the Williamite wars, as a direct result of the banishing of the Stewarts and the putting on the throne of England of a parliamentary-appointed King.

There grew up there—under a Constitution that was not in writing but depends for every great anchor sheet that it has, upon its unwritten nature —the convention that was known as his Majesty's Government and his Majesty's Opposition—Whigs one day and Tories the next. But by whom was that Government elected or selected? The largest Party went into the British House of Commons and, once again, the unwritten Constitution having become the force of law, by certain conventions, the Head of the State, the King of England, sent for the Leader of the largest Party and asked him to form a Government. When he went back to the Commons he formed his Government and that Government sat on one side—that was his Majesty's Government. The other Party—the Whigs or Tories as the case might be—sat on the other side. This was his Majesty's Opposition. Then the other countries in Europe, imitating the English set-up, through their Heads of State, summoned their Parliaments and through the same Heads appointed their Governments, and in the same way they had their local his Majesty's Government and their local his Majesty's Opposition.

With that full knowledge here, in the deliberate framing of the Constitution that we had in 1937, in that Constitution there is created a Head of the State, a President who is intended to correspond to the crowned Head of England or the President of France, the President of Italy or the king of any monarchy on the Continent.

Comment on this

In internal affairs only.

Comment on this

In the setting up of a head of the State here, there was deliberately left out from the functions of that head of the State the obligation, the right or the duty to send for the leader of the largest Party. That was deliberately left out of the Constitution here and this Dáil, and this Dáil alone, by various constitutional methods, is the organ that appoints the Taoiseach and appoints its own Government. Therefore, I say, not only the will of the people but the Constitution under which we live bearing out the will of the people, has at last brought such will to fruition in this inter-Party Government. So much for arguments against Party Government. What about the arguments in favour of inter-Party Government? We in Ireland, in this Christian, democratic State, should not be looking for the things that are to divide us but for those upon which we can agree. There could have been in this House to-day a Government representative of every Party and every section of the community.

What are the fruits that flow from inter-Party Government? What is the benefit that accrues from it? It means that those who will have nothing to do with it and who still insist upon maintaining the Party system must for their own preservation and in their own interests—I will not say deliberately, but will use the word "subconsciously" invent problems upon which to differ, and if there are not any, then they must invent them. Where does that lead you and what benefit does it bring to the country? I am proud to sit here to-day on these benches with people with whom, in the normal course of events, in years gone by, one might disagree on many points. I am proud to know that we have been able to resolve these points under ten major headings, and I am prouder still to know that this country, in the solution of these problems and in the leadership of that army in their solution, has been able to find a man like my colleague, Deputy Costello, the present Taoiseach.

I belong to his profession; I have worked with him at his profession for a quarter of a century. There was no client in this country, no matter what his political views were, no matter what his occupation in life, who was not glad to retain his services at the Bar. I say it is a proud moment when the wisdom of this House and the good luck of this House chose that man to lead this new movement in our country. That man sacrificed a big career and a big income to carry the biggest brief he ever carried; but he is carrying it in a great cause, and he has set a glorious precedent. The cause, I hope, will endure; the precedent, I hope, will be followed—that never again will this Parliament here ever meet except to elect a Government representative of each and every section of the community.

Comment on this

I want to turn my mind at least to the evening when the present Taoiseach assumed office and he addressed the nation over the radio. I listened attentively to that broadcast and certain passages remain in my mind to this moment. The most important of these was the reference the Taoiseach made to the position of Ireland in this world to-day. He indicated that Ireland had a mission, to interpret Europe to America and America to Europe. Now, we had almost complete machinery to put into effect this particular duty or mission, but immediately after the assumption of the present Government to office, the machinery was scrapped. How can we interpret Europe to America or America to Europe, if we have not got direct contact with both those Continents? We scrapped Aerlínte, the only means we had of direct transport between this country and the American Continent. We reduced the services of Aer Lingus, restricting the contact of this country in a direct manner with parts of Europe.

Comment on this

The Government did not restrict the air services to Europe.

Comment on this

The Government restricted the air services to certain parts of Europe.

Comment on this

They did not.

Comment on this

The Government certainly abandoned Aerlínte which restricted direct contact on the part of this country with the Continent of America. I make a present to the Taoiseach of the fact that it was Aer Lingus itself which, in the interests of economy, reduced certain of its services.

Comment on this

Not in the interests of Government economy.

Comment on this

In the interests of the subsidy which the Government would have to pay to Aer Lingus.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Morrissey) Fine Gael

That is not true and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

I disagree as to that.

Comment on this

The Deputy has inside information.

Comment on this

I have no inside information.

Comment on this

The Deputy has direct inside information.

Comment on this

If the Minister wants to be personal and to indicate that it is because I happen to have a son who is a pilot in Aer Lingus that I have inside information, I may say that that does not mean that he has access to the secret files of Aer Lingus or knows anything about its policy.

Comment on this

I was not thinking of the Deputy's son.

Comment on this

What does the Minister mean about having contact with Aer Lingus other than that?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will allow me to say that I had not the Deputy's son in mind. I did not even know he had a son in Aer Lingus.

Comment on this

Will the Minister indicate what he means by any contact other than that which I might have with Aer Lingus?

Comment on this

I will tell the Deputy later.

Comment on this

Tell me now. I have no other association with the company and only know what is known in a general way. It is unfair for the Minister to suggest something which he is not prepared to indicate to the House. I say that I have not any other information. I repeat that I believe that the Aer Lingus economies were introduced with a view to reducing the subsidy by the State which might be incurred as a result of losses in the running of Irish air services to the whole of Europe.

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy know that that happened under the previous Government, that it happened last November?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

That is a fact and Deputy Lemass can tell the Deputy that.

Comment on this

I did not know that certain services between this country and certain parts of Europe were discontinued before this Government came into office. I should like the Minister to tell me——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might have raised that on the Minister's Vote.

Comment on this

I am making what I believe to be fair comment. I listened to the Taoiseach's broadcast to this nation immediately after his acceptance of office as head of the Government and I am relating that to what happened afterwards. I say, further, that the abandonment for the time being at any rate, as we understand it now, of the short-wave station means the removal of the balance of the machinery which would make it possible for this nation to have direct contact with any part of the world. I refer to that for this reason. I think it is the general opinion that this country's struggle for freedom has been not only an example to all subject nations in all parts of the world but was actually copied by these nations, and that the leaders of the movement for Irish freedom are known throughout the length and breadth of the world. The abandonment of the short-wave station, therefore, is regretted not only by people here but by many people far away from here in addition to those of Irish blood and origin.

A number of policies have been propounded by various spokesmen of the different Parties who make up the present inter-Party Government all of which are in conflict with each other. The people, therefore, want to know where we stand. The Minister for Agriculture has stated, and he has not been repudiated, that the time has now come when the farmers are to be the rich people in this country; that the time has gone when the industrialists and the businessmen will be those who are making the money. The Minister for Industry and Commerce agrees that Irish industry should be kept going, that every assistance should be given to it to give employment and to manufacture commodities of good quality at a reasonable price. In fact the most recent statement of the Minister was that, if it was necessary to get additional industrial development here and Irish citizens could not be found to comply with the Control of Manufactures Act, he was prepared to give licences to non-nationals to start certain essential industries here. That would imply that the industrialist is to be attracted here on the only inducement which will attract industrialists, particularly non-nationals, namely the profit motive.

When you relate these two points of view to the point of view expressed in this House by Deputy Larkin, who is leader of the Labour group in the inter-Party Government, that the time has now come when not only will Labour take part in the political management of the country but will move forward to the management and control of the businesses of the country, I think these three different points of view of policies require, as Deputy de Valera said, co-ordination with a view to having some common policy which can be understood by the different sections of the community who are affected. I ask the Taoiseach to say what these different points of view really mean, according to his understanding of them.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Is there anything incompatible between the three of them?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy asking that question for the purpose of getting information or just by way of interruption?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

If he can, the Deputy might point it out.

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera referred to the position of this country as a result of our continued link with sterling. I have a personal view on that matter. It may be entirely wrong. The present Minister for Agriculture in 1947 said that by June sterling would be internationally convertible. Again it was believed, as expressed by the Minister for Finance, that as a result of Marshall Aid and the latest international arrangements in regard to the European recovery programme sterling would shortly become internationally convertible. I do not believe that. I rather hold the view that in time, not too far distant, sterling will, in fact, have to be devalued.

I am wondering whether the Taoiseach has any policy with regard to our sterling position. I know that to-day, although there is a legal rate of exchange between this country and the dollar countries whereby we get four dollars to the £, and although there is an official legal rate of exchange in Paris of 860 francs to the £, nevertheless, because dollar currency is free in France you can, if you are an American and have dollars, buy francs at the rate of 380 to the dollar, and then buy pounds with those francs at the rate of 860 to the £. That means that the £ is costing the dollar-holder only 2 dollars 30 cents. To me that is an indication of the direction in which sterling is heading. It is well known here that on the free exchange in America sterling is bought at rates much lower than the official rates. We may find ourselves trying to get all our eggs again into the one basket—the British market with British currency— and we may find ourselves ultimately in a situation for which we had no responsibility, but which may have very serious adverse results for us.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy anything to suggest arising out of these observations?

Comment on this

I am not suggesting anything, because I do not suggest that my view is of any consequence.

Comment on this

In so far as it is in your mind, what is it?

Comment on this

It is the view I expressed twelve months ago to the effect that I thought the time had now been reached when we should consider the advisability of separating from sterling.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee thought that in 1931.

Comment on this

I do not know what Deputy Cosgrave knew about Deputy MacEntee in 1931.

Comment on this

He said it.

Comment on this

I do not know whether he said it or not in 1931 but I am stating now what I believe to be the position.

Comment on this

A lot of people on your side of the House said that last year before the election.

Comment on this

A lot of our people did not also. You people are not saying it now——

Comment on this

We still say it. It is in the ten-point programme.

Comment on this

You are keeping the Government in office and you cannot have it both ways. You cannot say that you stand for a break with sterling and at the same time support a Minister for Finance who is a prominent member of the Fine Gael Party and who stands for the exact opposite.

Comment on this
A Deputy

He said "not yet".

Comment on this

The Clann na Poblachta Party advocated the break with sterling prior to the election and they still maintain that view.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe is quite right. He expressed his view and it is quite sound.

Comment on this

May we all join in this conversation?

Comment on this
Patrick Joseph Halliden Acting-Chairman (Mr. Halliden) Clann na Talmhan

The Deputy should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

What about the next four and a half years?

Comment on this

Clann na Poblachta in any event now indicate that they are in favour of breaking with sterling. That is quite clear from what has been said.

Comment on this

And Deputy Briscoe says that also.

Comment on this

Yes, but I do not say so through any influence of Clann na Poblachta. I say so because it is my own point of view.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Will the Deputy say whether it is the policy of Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

Deputy Byrne should not ask me about the policy of Fianna Fáil. I think that Deputy Byrne is about the greatest expert in this House on the policy of every Party.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

The Deputy is not answering my query as to whether it is the policy of his Party or not.

Comment on this

I do not say that it was not the policy of the Clann na Poblachta Party.

Comment on this

The Deputy was emphasising it.

Comment on this

I am accepting it and I am delighted to hear it.

Comment on this

Why not come over and sit on this side of the House?

Comment on this

I am pointing out their invidious position in that they should be part of a Government——

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking about international gamblers and money-lenders.

Comment on this

What does Deputy Davin mean?

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking about the policy of international gamblers.

Comment on this

I am talking about the facts as they exist. I am talking about what I myself witnessed only ten days ago when I was in Paris. It is not a question of international gamblers——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy should address the Chair.

Comment on this

The position in France is that the dollar is not controlled and that it commands 380 francs——

Comment on this

Is the Taoiseach responsible for that?

Comment on this

——and that at the rate of 860 francs to the £ it can buy the £ for two dollars 30 cents. That is a fact. It is not the result of international gambling. It is a result of a weakening and a lack of faith in the £ sterling at the present time.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Did the Deputy make a few bob on the £?

Comment on this

I did not. Perhaps the Deputy will come with me the next time and help me to do so.

Comment on this

What has all this to do with the Estimate?

Comment on this

I do not know whether there is anything in the news we read which should cause us to fear that a conflict will break out again in the near future. One set of opinions says that war is inevitable and another set of opinions says that war will be averted at least for a number of years. I am wondering whether the Taoiseach has in mind the advisability of loosening up some of the economy springs and of spending a certain amount of money by way of insurance so that this country can meet the situation should war break out. The Fianna Fáil Government, shortly after assuming office, recognising that war could come, insisted—even to the extent of compulsion—that wheat growing should be indulged in in this country. In the event of war we would, in that way, be able to have some bread for our people instead of having to sell our freedom for a loaf of bread. In other words, we would not have to join in a war in which we had no interest, for the sake of feeding our people.

In the same way I should like to know if the Government is aware of the seriousness of the world situation. The uncertainty of the world situation is such that I want to know if the Government is satisfied that its policy of economy will ensure that in the event of the outbreak of war nobody will be able to come in here and say: "Well, we told you." Nobody wants the doubtful satisfaction of coming in here afterwards—if such a situation should arise and if our people should have greater difficulties than they might have had if certain precautions had been taken—and saying: "I told you so." I am raising this matter in the hope that our minds will be eased on this point and that we will be told that we need not worry because it is being kept in mind. There is one other point I want to put to the Taoiseach. Under the Fianna Fáil Administration a very extensive scheme for rural electrificaton was put through this House, partly by subsidy and partly by capital expenditure on the part of the Electricity Supply Board. The scheme was to cost something like £20,000,000, expended over a period of ten years. I want to know if the present Government has changed the policy with regard to rural electrification by reducing in this financial year the amount to be spent on development under the scheme as envisaged.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but it is quite obvious that the Deputy was unable to be in the House this afternoon when the Vote responsible for electrical development in this country was under consideration. This matter of the Electricity Supply Board and the generating stations was taken on Vote 55 to-day. I am suggesting it should not be brought in again now. It is out of order.

Comment on this

I was absent from the House for a considerable part of the day.

Comment on this

Exactly, and the Deputy now wants to heel-tap on this Vote.

Comment on this

It is not relevant on this Vote.

Comment on this

It is a matter of policy which, I am sure, was not touched on to-day.

Comment on this

It certainly was.

Comment on this

Because I asked a colleague if this matter had been dealt with. I want to ask now has the policy been changed.

Comment on this

You may ask it, but you will not get any answer from me on my Vote.

Comment on this

I am asking it from the point of view of economy.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I ask the Deputy not to persist in this because it is out of order.

Comment on this

I accept the ruling of the Chair without hesitation, but I ask the Chair for a ruling on this. I am approaching the Estimate of the Taoiseach from a general point of view. I have touched on a few items already which, strictly speaking, would have been more appropriate under the Estimates on other Departments. It is only in connection with the policy of economy that I ask the question. Will the Chair hear me and then rule? If the Chair rules I am out of order I shall not proceed any further. I am simply asking is it the policy now to change the plan by reducing the amount spent on rural electrification. In other words, the Electricity Supply Board is divided into five zones——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

That is a matter for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Is it the position that any matter dealing with Industry and Commerce cannot now be raised when we are discussing general policy?

Comment on this

Yes, unless it is general governmental policy.

Comment on this

Have I no right, then, to discuss rural electrification in this debate?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

You cannot discuss specific matters.

Comment on this

I respectfully suggest we are entitled to a ruling. The Chair has given a ruling now that the Deputy is not to be permitted to speak on a matter which might have been raised on any one of the Estimates already discussed in the House. It seems to me that is restricting—I again respectfully suggest—very greatly the ambit of the discussion on the Taoiseach's Vote.

Comment on this

Not at all; and that has been the practice in this House for 25 years.

Comment on this

I have asked the Acting-Chairman a question and not the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Do not lose your temper. The day when you could bully anybody in this House has gone.

Comment on this

You will not worry me anyway. You are not going to interrupt me as you interrupted Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this

Sit down.

Comment on this

You think when Deputy Briscoe is speaking that you can sneer at him and taunt him but you will not make me sit down.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Order!

Comment on this

The Chair has been asked for a ruling and the Chair should be allowed to give a ruling.

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation, may I say I did not interrupt Deputy Briscoe? He was sitting down before I got on my feet. There is no use in Deputy Derrig shouting at me. He is not hurting anybody but himself.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

In my opinion the Deputy is dealing with particular rather than general matters, and he is, therefore, out of order. I ask him to pass on to something else.

Comment on this

I am not going to discuss particular Electricity Supply Board operations. I am asking a simple question as to what economy the Government intends to make in the activities of the Electricity Supply Board, with a view to reducing the amount of subsidy that would have to be paid in this year if the Electricity Supply Board continued on the plan previously adopted. I think I am entitled to ask that question.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Taoiseach will reply if he thinks fit.

Comment on this

That is the question I am asking and I am glad the Chair does not rule it out, but leaves it to the Taoiseach, if he so desires, to reply. I am not putting the Minister for Industry and Commerce into the position that I am trying to ask this question——

Comment on this