Supplementary Estimate, 1948-49. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach.
Contributions 457–700 of 700. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I am satisfied that I am now in order. The only way in which I can find out what the true position is is by putting down a question next Tuesday for the information. That is putting me and the Minister for Industry and Commerce to more trouble.
Comment on this
I am reliably informed that that is the position and I regret very much that the Government when it came into office introduced the axe, cutting out certain schemes—many of which have been referred to in this debate—and cutting away with that axe the livelihood of a great many of our people, and a form of livelihood which was very much needed in this country. To have in this country men highly developed in technical matters, particularly in the condition of the world as it is to-day, was something that was of great importance. In order to get more money, because the economies cannot go far enough, what do we find? We find an indirect form of taxation. £200,000 is put on the backs of people who post letters. Yesterday we were informed by the Minister for External Affairs that in order to get in a few more coppers into the Exchequer in the form of indirect taxation, passports from now on would cost £1 or £1s. 0d. instead of 12/6.
Comment on this
But a great many unfortunate Irishmen and women will have to buy passports from now on to go to America.
Comment on this
I suggest that Deputy Briscoe could conduct his speech within the rules of order if he were protected from interruptions.
Comment on this
I say that this Government, in what it calls the wisdom of its own decisions, decided to introduce a great many economies, economies which have fallen very heavily on the shoulders of almost every section of our community. Instead of admitting that extra money is necessary and getting it in the form of direct taxation, we have these forms of indirect taxation which are again a burden on the people, but which are not referred to as Government expenditure. We have no economy in departmental expenses.
The Deputy who spoke immediately prior to my speaking favoured us with a long technical lecture on the history of Party Governments, going right back to the Williamite wars and bringing in the Whigs and the Tories. Not one word of that part of his speech had any relevancy whatever to the Estimate for the Taoiseach's Department. Nevertheless, he was listened to without interruption by every member of this House. As far as his references to the Constitution were concerned, I shall leave it to other speakers to deal with them.
There is one item to which I wish to refer. I wish to refer to his concluding remarks where he stated that he felt inter-Party Government was something which was of vital importance in a democracy, where one could have Government by every member of the House joined together with the complete elimination of an opposition; that oppositions were there only for the purpose of creating problems, creating troubles and looking for them. All I can say to Deputy Sir John Esmonde is that if he—and I believe him to be quite sincere, but I believe him to be also a very simple gentleman—believes that a time can be reached when a conglomeration of mixed Parties forming a Government can meet together in one Party room to try to define policy without there being any opposition amongst themselves, or without there being certain Deputies following the example of Deputy Cowan, then he is an even simpler gentleman than I thought.
Comment on this
I have heard of party government in America, in England, and in other countries, and I have heard of coalition governments, particularly in France. I hope this country will be saved the experiences of coalition governments such as France has experienced.
Comment on this
I had not intended intervening in this debate, and I am not going to deal with any of the irrelevancies that were indulged in by the last speaker, because the Deputy was irrelevant from the time he got on his feet until he sat down.
Comment on this
It may appear so to Deputy Lemass, but it is not nearly as grave a reflection on the Chair as the reflection the Deputy cast about five or six minutes ago. What is all this heat and bitterness about?
Comment on this
If there was not heat and bitterness over there, I do not know what to call it. Deputies were losing all restraint and speaking in hot blood and for no apparent reason whatsoever. I suggest it was simply and solely because Deputies on the opposite side realise that the inter-Party Government is a complete 100 per cent. success. That is the cause of their bitterness and, so far as some of them are concerned, their viciousness. The reason for some of the methods adopted by them and by some of their organisations throughout the country to attempt to sabotage certain national activities is because it is being borne in on them that the people of this country are overwhelmingly behind the inter-Party Government and that the goodwill and support for this Government is growing every day.
Deputies on the opposite side ought to realise, after a period of five months, that the line which they have been pursuing both in their speeches in this House, in their speeches outside this House and in their Party organ, is doing no harm to the Government, is doing a certain amount of harm to aspects of our national life, and is doing very great harm to themselves.
Comment on this
Funnily enough, I do because I am one of the people left in this country who believe that a well-conducted, responsible opposition can be a useful addition to any Parliament. I despair of a balanced debate in this House when I look across at the Opposition and when I judge their conduct for the past five months. There is no hope, boys, that you will ever be able to stick out for 16 long years. You simply will not be there. The sooner you realise it the better. The trouble about Deputies opposite is that they are going around in a sort of daze and they are wondering why it is that the doom prophesied for this country has not fallen down on top of us. We were told at one time: "If you do not return Fianna Fáil with an overwhelming majority, the only Party that is fit to lead and to run this country, then Ireland is doomed."
Comment on this
The Deputy apparently has not yet realised the feeling there is in this country after 16 years of Fianna Fáil—the feeling amongst the ordinary people that there is an air of freedom about and that people are really free——
Comment on this
The less the Deputy says about emigration the better. I know a fair bit about it and I know what happened under Fianna Fáil for 16 years. I say that there is an air of freedom in this country to-day and people can speak their mind.
Comment on this
The Deputy can. People can speak their mind and they know they are not going to be victimised either in their jobs, in their business or in any other way. I know that Deputy Briscoe would like to interrupt me while I am on this line. I know quite well that while a vast majority of the people have benefited as a result of the change of Government, there are quite a considerable number who have lost, and lost heavily.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that that is not a true figure. The Deputy knows there are not as many people flying out of the country as in the days of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
If there are 6,000 additional on the exchanges to-day, that is largely due to this, that every Fianna Fáil club has been canvassing and inducing people to sign up at the labour exchanges. They have been canvassed in every corner of the country to sign at the labour exchanges and to swell the unemployment lists. That is good propaganda for Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I know it is true. I might even believe that Deputy Lemass does not know it, but I find it very hard to believe that.
Comment on this
I do not know it; not merely that, but I know that it is not true and the appalling thing is that the Minister really thinks that this is an explanation of the increasing unemployment.
Comment on this
I am giving Deputies opposite a few home truths. Those Deputies know this, that in their line of conduct both in this House and outside it, in their efforts to damage this Government, they have not stopped short of actions and utterances that do damage to the country. Deputies on the opposite side, and the organisation to which they belong, have done their damnedest to create unrest amongst our people, to create uneasiness amongst our people, to get some people to think that their livelihoods, their jobs, are in jeopardy, to suggest that people are losing employment because of this Government's action, and they try to twist completely what Deputy Briscoe tried to hang his speech on, what is called economy and retrenchment. We made it perfectly clear that what we meant by economy and retrenchment was cutting out wasteful and extravagant expenditure. We made it quite clear we were not concerned about any money that might be required when it came to worth-while schemes, schemes that would benefit the country. But we did make it very clear that a small, a comparatively poor country, could not afford to ape the ways of the greatest and the richest countries of the world.
Deputy Briscoe bewails the loss of the transatlantic service. Millions of pounds for that and the same Party who started that could not find a few shillings extra for a blind pensioner or an old age pensioner. The Deputy tells us that we had no direct line of communication between our kith and kin in America and ourselves until they put forward this scheme. I listened to Deputy MacEntee on the same lines, speaking passionately and eloquently about the millions of Irish in America and the transatlantic air line. The very same case could be made for a fleet of Queen Mary or Queen Elizabeth liners and, mind you, it would not surprise me if Fianna Fáil made that case. Millions for everything, so why not——
Comment on this
This Government has been only five months in office. Fianna Fail, with an overwhelming majority, were in office for 16 years. Why did they not give £25,000 for athletics?
Comment on this
It was not. They never gave it. Let us get down to brass tacks in this House. Deputies opposite, although they are in opposition, have a responsibility, whether they choose to shoulder it or not, to this country, and, mind you, they got a fairly good example from the Opposition that sat on the benches over there during the 16 years they were in office —a very good example that they might follow with profit not only to themselves but to the country. Deputies opposite spend their time in trying to drive wedges between the Parties that make up this inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
The fact that we have them is what is breaking your heart. Deputy Briscoe tries to establish that there is something fundamentally different between what Deputy Dillon says, what I say, and what Deputy Larkin says. That is undoubtedly strange to Deputy Briscoe because the Deputy has the good or bad fortune to belong to a Party where there is one view and one voice, where nothing else is allowed or will be allowed. That is another of the very great differences between the Party on the opposite side and the Parties that make up the Government here. For us, whether we sit at that side of the House or whether we sit at this side of the House——
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan is there and he has a right to be there. Do not ask me to refer to certain Deputies that had to leave the Fianna Fáil Party. I should not like to be drawn into that.
Comment on this
I should, indeed, and if it were relevant at the moment, I would tell the Deputy all about it. That is a pleasure I hope to have on some other occasion; the pleasure would be all on my side and there would not be much of it on Deputy Moran's side. Deputy Moran is a young boy in this House. Like a lot of young boys, he does not know quite as much as he thinks he does.
Comment on this
I am doing my best, but it takes two to succeed at a job like that. That is the position. We have all this set-up here because Deputies on the opposite side on the 18th February got the biggest shock they ever got in their lives. There is no doubt about that. It was quite obvious to anybody here in this House on that date and for a week afterwards that the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party did not know whether they were standing on their heads or their heels, whether they were in Leinster House or outside it.
Comment on this
Mind you, it is very relevant. Remember we are discussing the inter-Party Government. We are discussing why they are here. There is no necessity for us to discuss why they should remain here.
Comment on this
The Deputy has taken to himself an importance I am not prepared to accord him. I do not want to waste the time of the House, but I thought it might be no harm to remind Deputies opposite of a few little points they might be inclined to forget. Do not make the mistake of thinking that you are only going to be over there for a month or two. May I assure—I forget the title for the moment, but I think it is the Dáil correspondent—may I assure the Dáil correspondent of the Irish Press——
Comment on this
—the Dáil reporter of the Irish Press, that he may go on his holidays when the Dáil rises in peace and quietness? There will not be a general election in the autumn so that he can go away in peace and quietness.
Comment on this
Mind you it is good news for Fianna Fáil, because the Dáil reporter has such a view as to the strength of the inter-Party Government that he assumes that it is preparing to go to the country——
Comment on this
——and to come back stronger than ever, or was he thinking that we might make the mistake which he and his colleagues made last February?
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy and his colleagues are rather sorry they did not wait for the full period. They need not worry whether this Government goes to the country in a month's time or in five years' time; it will come back bigger and stronger and more united than even it is to-day.
Comment on this
If we had a good Party organ at our back and unlimited cash in the political coffers of our various Parties, I would not have the slightest hesitation in taking the Deputy on, but we could not afford, either at the last election or the next election or if there is to be one this year or next year, to spend a shilling for every pound which the gentlemen opposite can afford to spend, but, thank God, we will not need it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I understood that we were discussing the Taoiseach's Estimate. It seems that we are discussing everything but the business that is before the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Sir John Esmonde said he was proud to stand behind the inter-Party Government. He said that Government was something for which the people had been unconsciously searching since we got a Parliament of our own. The Deputy finished by saying that the inter-Party Government was the country's solution, and in saying that I give him credit for thinking that he was saying what was true—but it is obvious that the inter-Party Government was not the country's solution. The Minister for Industry and Commerce held the same idea, but I think he knows probably pretty well that the inter-Party Government was no solution furnished by the people of the country, but was a solution by a combination of groups whom nobody could reasonably think could come together to form a Government. I agree with the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he says that we were stunned on the day on which the present Taoiseach and the present Government were put into office. We were. He said that we went to sleep for a week. I can assure him that the whole country was in that state for longer than a week, and is in that state to-day.
Comment on this
Could it be reasonably contended that the people of this country expected that the Parties that form this Government could come together, Parties with such diametrically opposite policies, Parties that had to put to the country these diametrically different policies? How can anyone honestly say that the present Government was a solution furnished by the people of this country? It was no such thing. It was a solution furnished by the groups that go to make up that Government to the wild astonishment of the people who elected them.
Comment on this
Almost a miracle. Now, this discussion brings up probably the most serious question that we can put to ourselves as a Parliament. What is the present Government's policy with regard to democratic representation? I want to put that question. In so far as a Parliament freely elected in a democratic way has any authority, that authority comes from the will and wish of the people who have elected it. Now, two of the Parties that go to make up the present Government put forward sufficient candidates to form a Government in this country, and a majority Government in this country. Fine Gael did that, and Clann na Poblachta did it, and what was the answer of the Irish people? In the case of Fine Gael they made a fairly respectable showing, but in the case of Clann na Poblachta you had a 90 per cent. turndown of the Party and of their policy by the people of the country. What moral authority resides in a Government of that sort? You have the Minister for External Affairs, one of the most important Ministries in a Government——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I think there are many things open to us to discuss in this House, many arguments, but certainly the argument as to whether a government is moral or not is not open for discussion. I submit that there is no one in this House to decide that issue—whether it is a moral government or not.
Comment on this
I take it that we shall get from the decenter members on the other side of the House as good an opportunity to express our views as that which is given to the people on the other side. I am really replying to the speech of Deputy Sir John Esmonde.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I cannot permit any Deputy in this House to talk about the moral law in so far as the formation of this Government is concerned.
Comment on this
I will leave out the word "moral" and just say "authority." Is it not an extraordinary thing to see as Minister the head of a Party that was turned down to the extent of 90 per cent. by the people of Ireland? Is not that a very extraordinary thing?
Comment on this
That is the point. It is not the will of the people but the will of those groups that did it.
Comment on this
I want to discuss the question on its merits, and I do not want to be abusive or offensive, but, mind you, you can have a little of that if you insist on having it. It was not sufficiently extraordinary for the Taoiseach to put the Minister into that position, but he picked a second Minister from the same party that had been turned down to the extent of 90 per cent. by the people, and made him Minister in one of the most important Departments in the Government.
Comment on this
I do not think anyone can seriously say that that was a right or a judicious thing to do. I have no quarrel with the Ministers that I have referred to, and I do not want to be offensive to them in any way. I just want to show how illogical and how wrong such a Government as the present inter-Party Government is. I can well understand this: we met here after the people had spoken, after the people had returned one Party bigger than all other Parties put together, because I do not concede that the Independents are a Party. An Independent is elected——
Comment on this
——by his own people, for his own qualities, and not on the policy of other Independents. They have no common policy and, therefore, they have no common Party, and it is perfectly right to say that our Party, the Fianna Fáil Party, were returned in larger numbers than all the other organised Parties put together. Of course that is perfectly true.
Comment on this
When we saw that it was necessary to have a unified single Party in charge of the affairs of this country and when we refused to coalesce with the other groups——
Comment on this
——and let them direct the affairs of the country, I could well have understood the Taoiseach accepting nomination, accepting office and then appointing all his Ministers from his own Party as the biggest Party in the House that consented to take office. That would have been perfectly right. The genuine truth and honesty of the other members would have been shown up if they had voted unanimously for the Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, and for the other Fine Gael Ministers, and if they had stood by them without fees or reward or office. That would have been understandable and nobody could have criticised them.
Comment on this
I think, however, and I repeat it, that it is a very wrong thing for Ministers to be selected from the Party that was almost unanimously turned down—turned down at any rate to the extent of 90 per cent. by the Irish people. There are smaller Parties in the House than Clann na Poblachta, but remember, even if they are smaller, they did not have such a percentage turn-down by the people and they could reasonably put forward the argument that if they had put up sufficient numbers and got correspondingly large support from the people, they would have been in the position of Fine Gael, at least in point of membership. I have no real quarrel, therefore, with any of the Parties that put up a small number and got a fairly good percentage of those people elected. They would have a far better right than the Party who put up far more candidates than was necessary to supply an overall majority, the Party who went to the people, who put their policy before the people and were turned down to a 90 per cent. extent by the people.
Comment on this
As I said, I am talking on a broad principle, without any malice or bad feeling towards any of the Ministers to whom I refer.
Comment on this
The smallest schoolboy would be rated more highly efficient than Deputy Sweetman, much less their teachers.
Comment on this
Minister have spoken on their Estimates and spoken well. The Minister for External Affairs was lauded up to the skies by the Irish Times yesterday.
Comment on this
When Deputy de Valera heard his statement and found that less than any other Minister in the House he was deviating from Deputy de Valera's own policy——
Comment on this
——he got approval from Deputy de Valera that clothes him with a good deal of moral authority that he did not previously enjoy.
Comment on this
On a point of order, while the Ceann Comhairle was here, I already directed the Chair's attention to the humbug that this particular Deputy——
Comment on this
I want to put the point of order to the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that if the Deputy takes to himself the right to say what is moral law in this Assembly, in this country——
Comment on this
The Chair has no right, no means to appraise the qualities of any of the speeches in this House.
Comment on this
As I said, the Irish Times paid a very high tribute to the Minister for External Affairs, and to-day the Irish Times again repeats that praise, and links it up with praise of Lord Glenavy. Those of us who know the Irish Times, who know its national record, or rather its antinational record, do not feel in the least reassured by the praise that has been poured out on that Minister by the Irish Times.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I would like to know if it is in order for a Deputy to refer to comment in a newspaper on a Minister.
Comment on this
The Deputy is merely making a passing reference to the Irish Times, and he is quite entitled to do it.
Comment on this
What I want to bring home to the people on the other side of the House is that they know perfectly well——
Comment on this
——that the inter-Party Government was not the solution furnished by the Irish people.
Comment on this
It was the will of the Irish people.
Comment on this
It was not the will of the Irish people. It was an action of the small groups that go to make it up. If I may give a little proof of what I say, it is that I myself got more of the preferences, from the Minister to whom I referred, at the election than other candidates of his own Party got.
Comment on this
The people who originally voted for them expected that these men would comport themselves befittingly when they came into this House. Do you think that when their second preferences went to Fianna Fáil, they expected that Labour or Clann na Poblachta would vote for Fine Gael? You know perfectly well that they did not and you know perfectly well that you let down those who elected you.
I come back to the original query: what is the policy of the new Government——
Comment on this
——with regard to democratic representation here? I hold that Deputy Esmonde was very wrong when he said that we should not follow the British custom in the matter of selecting a Government. We have possibly no great attachment for them, but we must remember that they have a long tradition on the other side and that, in Parliamentary matters, they can furnish a very good example. You get a better and more cohesive Government by selecting your Government from one Party. When the people get tired of that Party, let them turn them out.
Comment on this
If they turned Fianna Fáil down, what in the name of goodness did they do to you fellows?
Comment on this
It is not Deputy Butler whom Deputies are shouting down. It is the prestige of the Dáil which they are injuring, and injuring very considerably.
Comment on this
Deputy Esmonde painted a picture of the virtues of an inter-Party Government. Let me point to one or two of the weaknesses of such a Government. There was elected here a Minister for Health and I want to say straightaway that I think he is an earnest, well-meaning and hard-working Minister. I believe that, but can he implement his policy? He is very interested in tuberculosis; the treatment, prevention and cure of tuberculosis are the things nearest to his heart. I wonder did he protest against the action of the Minister for Finance in taking away the additional £25,000 set aside by the Fianna Fáil Government for the heating and cleaning of schools in this year?
Comment on this
I am trying to point out that there must be co-ordination between different Departments and I am pointing to the difficulty of an inter-Party Government carrying out that necessary co-ordination.
Comment on this
The Minister is not responsible for the matter to which the Deputy is referring. It is a matter which should be raised on the Minister's Estimate; it does not arise on this Estimate.
Comment on this
If the Chair rules in that way, I accept the ruling and I cannot refer to all the other things that the smaller splinter Parties have fallen down on, such as drainage, forestry, housing——
Comment on this
I seem to have given the Parliamentary Secretary a shock by mentioning drainage. We were assured earlier in the debate by the Taoiseach himself that there was agreement and concord between the members of his Government, but I came into the House the other night and heard one Deputy from amongst the present Government Party painting the most shocking picture of the condition, a condition worse than that of galley slaves, of the fellows working on the drainage schemes in his own constituency, and at one-third of what they earned under the Fianna Fáil régime.
Comment on this
I wonder what was Deputy Flanagan talking about. He was comparing what they earned on field drainage schemes with what had been earned under the turf schemes.
Comment on this
Having pointed out some of the defects, and not being allowed to point them all out, of an inter-Party Government, I will not hold the House longer.
Comment on this
It requires a certain amount of courage to speak in this debate, in view of the number of interruptions coming from the far side of the House, but I am entitled to speak here as long as the Chair allows me to do so. If I do not keep in order, the Chair will pull me up, and it is not necessary for the interrupters, official or otherwise, to endeavour to keep me on the right lines.
Comment on this
On a point of order, are Deputies on this side to be allowed to speak or not? Is the babbling brook on the far side to be allowed to take possession of the House?
Comment on this
All Deputies will get the protection of the Chair, so far as the Chair is able to give it.
Comment on this
In spite of all the protestations here to-night and previously about the prospective longevity of this Government, the attitude, not so much of the Government as of the back benchers, would suggest the attitude of the boy passing the graveyard. They were whistling and chirping here to-night in order to keep their courage up, because they know just as well as we know what the feeling about them in the country is.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan is in a sort of Limbo between this earth and a graveyard. The people on the opposite benches have probably as good an idea as we have of what the public opinion about them is and they know the truth of the assertion which Deputy Butler was endeavouring to convey to the House, despite the many interruptions from the far side, that this Taoiseach is elected not by the majority vote of the Irish people but by the majority vote of the members of this House.
I want to substantiate my view in that respect. I claim that, reading over the speeches made during the general election, the people who voted for the National Labour Party and for the Labour Party were voting for two diametrically-opposed policies. The people who voted for the National Labour Party certainly never believed having listened to the speeches made by the candidates and representatives of that Party in the different constituencies, that, in voting for Deputy Everett, the present Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and other members of his Party, they were voting to make Deputy Norton, Tánaiste, and Deputy Murphy, Minister for Local Government.
Just as that happened in the case of the National Labour Party, the same is true of the people who voted for another Party. Deputies, if they do not take my word for it, need only go into the Library and go over the files of the Irish Independent for the month of January and the first few days of February, and read the speeches that were made by National Labour Party speakers and by Irish Labour Party speakers, and they will find there the truth of the assertion that I am making. Deputy Davin, speaking in his constituency, asked the people who were listening to him to create unity in the Irish Labour ranks by putting the National Labour candidate at the bottom of the poll, and Mr. S. O'Farrell, now Senator O'Farrell, secretary of the National Labour Party, speaking at a meeting in the Hotel Workers' Hall, Eden Quay, reported in the Irish Independent of 21st January last, stated that National Labour was an independent Party.
They had been approached in the past to agree to an arrangement by which the different groups in opposition to Fianna Fáil would not oppose each other's candidates in the event of an election. "That proposal was made to me," he said, "by a leader of one of the opposition Parties. The answer I gave was: ‘If we cannot accept each other's policy before an election, how can we enter into a blind bargain to act together afterwards. If you are prepared to accept another Party's candidates, what is to prevent you accepting that Party's policy.'" Do the members of the Government or any of the Deputies opposite mean to say that the people who gave attention to Senator O'Farrell on that occasion were voting to put representatives of other Parties into Government Benches?
To deal with the National Labour Party, I think we have only to read the report of the conference that is being held in Tralee these days to know what mandate the National Labour Party had for taking part in the inter-Party Government, and to say that the supporters of National Labour, for instance. gave the National Labour candidates a mandate to change the Government is to say something that is untrue. That has been borne out by the meeting of the organisation which supported the National Labour Party in their campaign.
Comment on this
On a point of order. How does this matter affect the Taoiseach's Vote?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach will not be able to reply to these irrelevant matters.
Comment on this
The Chair thinks there is a very tenuous relevancy in what the Deputy is referring to.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that the Taoiseach, whose Department we are now discussing, would not be Taoiseach except for certain members of this House and I am trying to point out that, while people on the opposite side are claiming that they got a mandate for it, here is one group at least that got no mandate to support the present Taoiseach.
Comment on this
At the same meeting at which Senator O'Farrell spoke there was a candidate, Mr. Seamus O'Moore. Mr. O'Moore told his hearers that he had broken with Mr. Norton's Party——
Comment on this
I will leave that. There are other Deputies here who adopted an attitude on the 18th February and I do not know whether they can claim that they got a mandate for it or not. I am referring to the Clann na Poblachta Party. I have looked up all the papers that I could find dealing with the last election campaign and I have yet to discover any statement by any members of the Clann na Poblachta Party who were elected to this House that they would participate in the type of Government that they are now participating in. I think it is not necessary for me to dwell very long on their attitude because I think the members of that Party know what the view of a large percentage, if not the majority of their supporters, is on that matter.
Comment on this
I will admit to the Deputy that he got a mandate to put Fianna Fáil out but he did not get a mandate to put Fine Gael in. That is what he has done.
Comment on this
Talking about this inter-Party Government, apart from the people in the country, I wonder what respect people outside the country can have for a Government whose Ministers speak with different voices. It is a well-known fact that the majority of the Ministers of the present Government—I am sure they would not deny it—are men who are pledged to membership of the British Commonwealth of Nations. We have, then, a Minister for External Affairs who stated quite definitely here yesterday that we were not members of the British Commonwealth of Nations.
Speaking on this Vote last year, the present Minister for Industry and Commerce said, in reply to an interruption by Deputy Moran, that the only difference between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil was that they were all members of the British Commonwealth, that he was stating it definitely that they were and Fianna Fáil were afraid to state it. Deputy MacBride, Minister for External Affairs has borne out in his statement yesterday the contention that we have put forward that, since our Constitution and since the other legislation that was enacted since Fianna Fáil came into office, we are now no longer members of the British Commonwealth of Nations.
Comment on this
I wonder what the position of the Taoiseach is going to be if he sticks to the policy of Fine Gael and says we are members of the British Commonwealth of Nations at a conference, say, with British representatives, and he has with him a Minister for External Affairs and, I presume a Tánaiste, to get up and say that we are not members of this Commonwealth of Nations.
Comment on this
Talking about mandates, I wonder what is the position of the Tánaiste and the Taoiseach in regard to the Industrial Prices and Efficiency Bill? During the election campaign Deputy Norton, as he was then, thumped the country and accused Deputy Lemass, then Minister for Industry and Commerce, of retreating from his Prices and Efficiency Bill. He gave the electors to understand that if he was returned and had any say in the Government resulting from the election he would see that that Bill would be put into effect, would be passed into legislation. At the very same time, Deputy Costello, the present Taoiseach, wrote to the Federation of Irish Manufacturers and told them that if Fine Gael had any say in the formation of a new Government they would see to it that that Bill was withdrawn.
Comment on this
It is a strange thing that if the federation gave Fianna Fáil £50,000 the federation were out against that Bill. Possibly the fact that Deputy Costello, the Taoiseach now, gave an undertaking that if Fine Gael were elected the Bill would be withdrawn, had some effect in getting Deputy Costello elected.
Comment on this
I got nothing at all. Is this Bill to be put into law in accordance with the promise given by the present Tánaiste, or is it to be withdrawn in accordance with the promise given by the present Taoiseach?
Comment on this
One thing I can assure Deputy Norton is that we got nothing from the federation or from any British trade union.
Comment on this
The present Tánaiste was telling the electors that the new Government's first task would be to enact drastic legislation to control prices and impose punishment on profiteers and reimpose the corporation profits tax so that it could be used to subsidise prices of the necessaries of life. I wonder what success he has obtained from the Taoiseach in that direction and whether the committee now being set up to deal with subsidies on bread has any relation to those promises made by Deputy Norton. Are they going to fulfil the promises in that way? If they do not increase the price of bread, will Deputy Norton persuade them to reimpose the corporation profits tax so as to subsidise bread prices?
There are many extracts that could be taken from newspapers in the Library, from speeches made by the different groups on the far side. It is a wrong and untrue assertion to make that the Parties at present backing the Taoiseach had a mandate to do so. Some of the Parties, to give them credit, Clann na Talmhan, during the whole election campaign announced to the public that they were prepared to support any Party in opposition to Fianna Fáil and, in accordance with that promise, they backed Fine Gael for Taoiseach.
Comment on this
We would support any Party that would give us a good Government and that is what we did— and we put your Party over there and we will keep you there.
Comment on this
Good luck to you! We had an apology for the Clann na Poblachta attitude from Deputy Dr. Brennan. He spoke from a well prepared statement of the reasons that actuated that Party in supporting the inter-Party Government and he made some very astounding statements. He told us, first of all, that we had here a non-political Taoiseach and gave the impression that the present Taoiseach was a man who had no interest before in politics. Some of us who have been for a good number of years in this House know the present Taoiseach as a very active politician.
Comment on this
I said that the Taoiseach in his capacity as Taoiseach was above politics and had no politics.
Comment on this
It is not to the Taoiseach's discredit that he has been an active politician for a long number of years. No member of the House, even those who disagree with him politically, can have any grievance against him for being an active politician, but I resent anyone trying to convey to us that the present Taoiseach has not been a very active politician. We remember him as Deputy Costello contributing to public affairs in this country at a time when there was a good deal of heat attached to politics. We remember him shortly after Fianna Fáil took office from 1933 on, speaking here and participating actively from the Opposition Benches. We know that he was a violent opponent of Fianna Fáil policy and opposed every action Fianna Fáil took to make progress along the national road. He opposed the removal of the Oath, he opposed the retention of the Land Annuities, he opposed the new Constitution, he opposed every national step that Fianna Fáil endeavoured to take. I am telling the House what I have known of his activities, lest Deputy Flanagan or any of the newer deputies might be carried away by Deputy Dr. Brennan's speech this evening.
Comment on this
We were all listening to him. I will wait until the official report is published and will challenge the Deputy.
Comment on this
If it does not bear you out, I hope you will apologise to him. You spent a quarter of an hour on your statement.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach, then Deputy Costello, speaking on the 28th February, 1934, said, as given in column 2237:—
"The Minister gave extracts from various laws on the Continent, but he carefully refrained from drawing attention to the fact that the Blackshirts were victorious in Italy and that the Hitler Shirts were victorious in Germany, as, assuredly, in spite of this Bill and in spite of the Public Safety Act, the Blueshirts will be victorious in the Irish Free State."
Whatever you might accuse the Taoiseach of when making a statement like that, you certainly would not accuse him of being a non-politician. So far as I could understand Deputy Dr. Brennan, he was putting the mantle of Wolfe Tone around the Taoiseach and declaring that we were going to march forward to an Irish republic under the leadership and guidance of the Taoiseach, or words to that effect. I do not know if the Deputy got any assurance from the Taoiseach that he was going to change his political line of thought and lead the Deputy along the road to an Irish republic. If the Taoiseach does, he will belie his past and do something that those who know him well enough would not suspect him of doing.
Comment on this
I do not forget anything. If Clann na Poblachta and others in the inter-Party Government think it will assuage their consciences or make things easier for them to have a speech like that of Deputy Dr. Brennan's published in the Press, that we are going to march into a republic under the leadership and guidance of the Taoiseach, I do not begrudge it to them. But, knowing what the Fine Gael Party was in the past and the actions both as Ministers and Deputies of members of that Party who are now members of this inter-Party Government, I can assure Deputy Dr. Brennan and other Deputies that they will have to wait a long time before they are marched into an Irish republic through any efforts of the Fine Gael Party. I repeat that the Parties I have named, particularly the National Labour Party, the Irish Labour Party and Clann na Poblachta, got no mandate whatever for the attitude they took up here and that this Government is not a Government elected by the Irish people but a Government elected by the majority of members of this House.
Comment on this
I am very sorry that Deputy Brady has seen fit to leave the House. I see that he is followed by Deputy Corry. It is typical of these Deputies to be on the run and not remain to hear some of the truth. In my opinion, the Vote for the Department of the Taoiseach is one of the most important Votes taken in this House. I see that there are only four Fianna Fáil Deputies left in the House now.
Comment on this
I am talking of Deputy MacEntee, who has stooped so low that he will soon be walking between a duck's legs.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I have here the official report of the Locke Distillery Tribunal. May I read what it says about Deputy Flanagan?
Comment on this
Over 12 months ago, when those of us who are sitting on this side of the House were in the Opposition Benches, appeals were being made to the smaller groups of Parties who were then in opposition to sink their differences, forget the past, unite together for the common good of Ireland and form one sound, solid Government which would work in the best interests of our people and not in the best interests of themselves, as we have seen the previous Government do. That was the responsibility which last February fell on every elected representative to this Parliament, because we knew that there was only one way in which the people could have clean, sound government and that was by the removal of Fianna Fáil from office. Every Deputy of the various Parties who form the Government had a responsibility in that way. We considered the interests of the people. We are considering the interests of the people to-day and it is by consideration of the interests of the people that we will continue to be on this side of the House.
In the past we saw the way in which the affairs of this country were administered by the previous Government. We saw the unemployed lined up in long queues outside the labour exchanges throughout the country. We saw the cream of Irish manhood being forced to go across to the land of our traditional enemy, in order to eke out an existence in English coal mines, English maltings, English factories and English farms, because they were denied a living in their own country owing to the policy of Fianna Fáil. When we saw the cream of Irish manhood forced to leave this country, when we saw the deplorable conditions under which the poorer sections of our population were compelled to live, when we looked at our housing position, when we saw large numbers of our people suffering from tuberculosis, when we saw the plight of our farmers, who were suffering severely as a result of the unsound agricultural policy first of Deputy Dr. Ryan and then of Deputy Smith as Minister for Agriculture, we realised that the members of Fine Gael, Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta, the Labour Party and those who were independent Deputies, had an obligation to our country and to our people. We knew that we could not realise the ambitions of our various Parties without removing the first obstacle—the hindrance to progress in this country—the Fianna Fáil Party. We have succeeded in removing the Fianna Fáil Party from office. We have replaced it by a Government which I can say without a boast is the best Government in every way the world has to-day.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I would ask the Chair to insist that Deputy MacEntee withdraws an untrue remark which, I believe, he knows to be untrue. The courts said no such thing.
Comment on this
In deference to the Chair, I will withdraw it, despite what is written in this paper.
Comment on this
We have at last removed the one obstacle, the one hindrance to progress, namely, the Fianna Fáil Party. Now that we have the Fianna Fáil Party removed from office, no greater misfortune could befall this country than to have another Fianna Fáil Government. Since we have given the Irish people a clean, intelligent, sound and efficient Government, it is our duty to see that that Government is held tightly together and that we will all work together in the interests of the country and of our people. I am given to understand that, in the course of his address on this debate this afternoon, Deputy Lemass referred to the fact that this Government is commencing to crumble and that he said that Deputy Flanagan would be one of the Deputies to withdraw his sympathies from it. I am taking this opportunity to inform Deputy Lemass and this House, through the Chair, that everyone of the back benchers on this side of the House realise that we have a responsibility to the Government we helped to elect last February. We realise that it is our responsibility to keep that Government there—and that we will do. This Government will have my full support and my wholehearted co-operation. If Deputy MacEntee or Deputy Lemass is waiting for me to withdraw my support from the present Government they will have a very long wait, despite the fact that they are at the moment touring the country and warning the people that within the next few months we are going to be faced with a general election.
Comment on this
We have Deputy de Valera again drawing his old red herring across the trail—another war.
Comment on this
Does Deputy MacEntee or Deputy de Valera or Deputy Lemass or any other member of the Opposition think for one moment that they can again gull the majority of our people? Our people realise that after 16 long years they can at last draw their breaths. Since the 18th of last February they have discovered that they have in power a Government that is going to see that merit will be recognised and that it will replace the graft and the jobbery that existed in the past. They realise that political jobbery is about to end in this country—and end for all time. They realise that they have an alternative Government to Fianna Fáil despite the fact that we were told that there could be no alternative to Fianna Fáil and despite the fact that we were warned that if Fianna Fáil was not returned as a Government there would be very serious consequences for our people. Fianna Fáil is now six months out of office and yet the earth has not trembled nor has the sky darkened. None of the extraordinary prophesies of Fianna Fáil has come to pass. None of the horrid and terrible misfortunes that Deputy de Valera prophesied if Fianna Fáil were not returned to office has come to pass. But what have we seen? We have seen that the responsible members of the various Parties in this House have placed the country and the people before their Parties. They have realised their responsibilities and they have come together and offered the people the alternative Government which is functioning to-day, sound and steady, in complete unity and harmony. That Government is functioning and will function despite whatever attempts will be made by the front benches of the Opposition to undermine the confidence of the people in it.
Deputy Brian Brady has spoken in this House and referred to the Taoiseach. I would point out that, despite the fact that I am six years a Deputy in this House, I think that this is only the second occassion on which I have heard Deputy Brian Brady speak. In his reference to the Taoiseach he said that during his membership of this Dáil he seldom heard the Taoiseach participate in the debates of this House. We have elected a Taoiseach and I share one-seventy-fifth of that responsibility with other Deputies. We are proud of the fact that we have a Taoiseach in this House to-day who has not on his hands or on his record any of the bitter memories of the civil war. We can boast loudly and proudly of that fact——