We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1949-50 (Resumed).

Contributions 1–173 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

During the course of this debate a number of Ministers have participated and have made statements bearing upon matters of public concern. I should like to open my remarks by expressing the opinion that unless Ministers are frank with the Dáil, unless they put before the Dáil all facts bearing upon problems which the Dáil has to consider, unless information which they give or which is extracted from them by Dáil questions is reliable, then the Dáil cannot do effective work and, inevitably, national interests will suffer. The complaint I have to make, having heard some of these speeches and read others, a complaint which arises not merely out of these Ministerial declarations but out of previous ones, is that Ministers are habitually less than frank with the Dáil and that very frequently the facts given here are distorted by them in order to support the particular argument which they are pursuing. I go further and I will say that there is evidence to suggest that even statistical information which is prepared by the Statistics Branch reaches the Dáil through some propagandist bureau by which it is not infrequently distorted in order to support some political point in which the Government are interested.

Comment on this
Seán MacBride Minister for External Affairs (Mr. MacBride) Clann na Poblachta

Will the Deputy give instances? It is a very serious matter.

Comment on this

That is what I propose to do.

Comment on this
William Norton Minister for Social Welfare (Mr. Norton) Labour Party

The Deputy, I take it, will be required to justify the charge he has made, that statistical matter which comes from the Statistics Branch passes through a propaganda organisation, where the statistics are distorted. If that is not proved, I take it, Sir, that you will ensure the withdrawal of it.

Comment on this

I will attempt to demonstrate that information given here of a statistical character was, on the face of it, false and inaccurate, and that it was published in that manner in order to justify some particular contention in which the Minister concerned was interested.

Comment on this

And that it goes through a propaganda bureau. That is the charge.

Comment on this

I do not profess to have any personal knowledge as to the process.

Comment on this

That is what you said.

Comment on this

I said that it appears to pass through some propagandist bureau on the way from the Statistics Branch to the Dáil.

Comment on this

That is grossly untrue.

Comment on this

We shall find out whether it is or not. We shall let the ordinary members of the Dáil judge that. The Minister for External Affairs has also intervened and asked me to substantiate it. I notice that he has been lecturing his Ministerial colleagues on their behaviour here. I think he would be far wiser to advise them as to the political advantage of honesty in debate and that, if he did that, it would be contributing far more to the effectiveness of the Dáil as a legislative chamber than deploring various regrettable losses of temper, which, from time to time, develop. May I say also to the Minister for External Affairs that if, instead of lecturing his colleagues, he gave them the advantage of his example, it would help them a lot more?

Comment on this

I take it the Deputy is implying that they give false or wrong information to the House. I take it the Deputy will justify that or withdraw it.

Comment on this

I am quite certain that whenever it suits the Minister to colour information that is given to the House in order to support his case he does so with an easy conscience.

Comment on this

The Deputy has suggested that I gave false or misleading information to the House. Is the Deputy going to justify that allegation?

Comment on this

Wait and see.

Comment on this

Then I take it it is a completely irresponsible and unfounded charge.

Comment on this

On the contrary, any charge that I make I will prove.

Comment on this

Can you give the facts?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy is allowed to proceed with his speech, objections might then possibly be raised.

Comment on this

The first example I shall give——

Comment on this

On a point of order. I take it that the Chair will not allow false charges to be made against a member of the Government without an opportunity being given to reply to them.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have not heard any personal charge. I have heard suggestions. Deputies are getting very thin-skinned. Political charges are made frequently in the House.

Comment on this

Will the Chair get the note of what the Deputy has said and read it?

Comment on this

Let me take the very brief formal statement made by the Minister for Finance in moving this Vote.

Comment on this

You were talking about me.

Comment on this

The Minister is not yet the most important member of the Government. It is, of course, a central point of Coalition propaganda to establish that the Government are genuinely seeking economies. They are trying to convince the people that they are reducing the cost of administering the Government Departments. The Minister for Finance, in support of that general propaganda line which he and his colleagues are following, pointed out that 31 of the different Estimates in this Book of Estimates show a reduction as compared with last year. They do not. It was a misleading statement and intended to be misleading, because, in so far as many of these Estimates are shown in this Book to be lower than the corresponding Estimates last year, it is because the Estimates for last year have been written up in an unprecedented way by the addition to them of higher administrative costs sanctioned by the Minister for Finance after these Estimates were passed by the Dáil.

I ask Deputies to turn to the Book of Estimates where these reductions are shown. The first is the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor-General. This Estimate purports to show a decrease compared with last year of £360, but the amount of last year's Estimate was written up by £1,640 in respect of increased remuneration to the officers of the Department sanctioned during the year. There have been other years during which the Civil Service has got increased remuneration, but always the Minister for Finance set out on the face of the Estimate in a footnote the amount of the last year's Estimate and the amount of the addition to it sanctioned by Supplementary Estimate during the year.

Never before was the present device adopted and I suggest that that device was designed to trick the Dáil and the public into the belief that this campaign of economy has been successful. In fact, we know it has not. We can point to almost every Department of State and show that the costs of administration have gone up since Deputy McGilligan became Minister. Taking the Estimates as a whole we find that all the Government Departments and services are estimated this year to cost approximately £65,500,000. That is £6,500,000 more than the net audited cost of these services in the year 1947-48. It is £1,000,000 more than the services cost last year, if the estimate of their cost upon which the Minister prepared his Budget was realised. We do not, yet, know what they cost. We know, however, that when the Minister for Finance was preparing his Budget he estimated that all the Departments and services of the Government would cost £1,000,000 less than he estimates they will cost this year. This campaign of fooling the people into believing that economies are being secured has been pursued by many devices but the most flagrant trick ever attempted was that to which I have referred and which is evident upon the face of a number of the Estimates set out in this Book. There has been a reduction between the total cost of the public services as set out on the face of this Book and the total cost of public services set out on the face of last year's Book. The main contributory cause of that reduction has been the change in the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce. I am referring now to the Estimate of the Department of Industry and Commerce as introduced. Certain changes in Government practice have been announced in the meantime. Many of the charges which formerly appeared against the Minister for Industry and Commerce's Vote will appear in future against the Vote for the Minister for Agriculture.

The amount required for the service of the Department of Industry and Commerce is reduced by £6,500,000. £2,500,000 of that £6,000,000 is attributable to the termination of the emergency turf scheme and the dropping of fuel subsidies. Over £3,000,000 of the balance is attributable to the lower cost this year of food subsidies. In fact, the whole of that reduction was automatic and would have come about if the Minister for Finance had sat in his office for the whole year playing tiddly-winks. In so far as economy means the reduction of unnecessary expenditure in Government Departments and the elimination of waste in the financing of public services there is no evidence of it. On the contrary, all over the field costs are rising, and so far as one can judge from Ministerial declarations bearing upon the question they are likely to continue to rise. If, however, the main change in the Estimates this year, as compared with last year, is the reduction in the cost of food subsidies, then I think it is high time we got some authoritative declaration from the Minister for Finance as to Government policy in regard to food subsidies. Even this year, with the lower cost, the amount required to finance food subsidies comes to no less than 14 per cent. of the total bill for all Government Departments and services. It is, therefore, a matter of some importance that the Dáil and the public should be informed as to what the Government intends to do in regard to the maintenance of these subsidies or the policy of rationing which appears to be associated with them. At the present time, the whole of the Government's policy in regard to rationing and food price subsidisation is clouded in mystery. Here, again, I want to accuse the Government of being less than frank in the Dáil, of playing tricks upon the Dáil, of deliberately misleading the Dáil concerning the facts of this matter. Whenever some Deputy asks a Dáil question as to why bread, flour, tea or sugar are still rationed, or as to the prospects of having these commodities unrationed, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce is put up to give the misleading reply that the supply position does not at present permit of the ending of rationing in respect of these goods. I say that is not true.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Cosgrave) Fine Gael

What goods?

Comment on this

Bread, tea, flour, sugar. I say it is not true. I say that the Parliamentary Secretary, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce know that it is untrue and that they have another reason for maintaining rationing in relation to these goods but that they are not frank enough to state the reason. There is no scarcity of tea. The Government can buy all the tea necessary to meet the full requirements of the people of this country. There are no restrictions whatever upon the purchase of tea.

Comment on this

You know we have tried to do it.

Comment on this

I know that you purchased last year less than we did in 1947 and the only reason I suggest is that you decided to do that. There is no scarcity of sugar. There is enough sugar in the country at this time to abolish rationing. More sugar can be purchased if home production is insufficient. Why, then, are we still subjected to tea and sugar rationing? Not merely are we subjected to this unnecessary rationing of these foodstuffs, but the Minister for Finance has imposed upon sugar used for manufacturing purposes an illegal tax. I said here in the course of an earlier debate that the policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in relation to industry, the policy which he has proclaimed at various banquets and occasionally in this House, is being sabotaged and negatived by the policy of the Minister for Finance and I was asked for an illustration. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is, on every occasion when he speaks about industrial matters, urging the importance of expanding our industrial exports. There is one class of industrial products for which an export possibility exists now and that is sugar confectionery, particularly jam, marmalade and so forth. Those who are engaged in the manufacture of these commodities could, at this moment, be building up an important export trade which might prove to be permanent. I will not put it stronger than that. They are prevented from doing so by reason of the fact that the Minister for Finance is taxing their raw materials to the extent of £20 per ton. I say further that that tax is illegal. The Constitution of this State requires that no citizen can be taxed without the consent of the Dáil and the imposition of that levy for the benefit of the Exchequer upon sugar sold to manufacturing consumers has never been sanctioned by the Dáil.

It is not true that we could not obtain sufficient wheat to abolish the flour and bread rationing. The recent wheat conference, at which an agreement was signed last week, was apparently embarrassed by the surplus of wheat which the exporting countries had to offer. In fact, instead of the importing countries, as in previous years, being concerned to write up the amount that they were prepared to contract to buy, they were, this year, trying to write down the amount which they would be under contract to buy for the period of the agreement. The price of wheat has fallen, and the Government was able to authorise its representative to sign that agreement upon the basis that for its duration the maximum price which they would have to pay for wheat purchased under it would be $1.80 a bushel—roughly about £18 per ton. Why have we got these unnecessary rationing schemes? If the real explanation is that the Government is economising in foreign exchange, then why do they not tell us that? I do not believe that is the explanation. On the contrary, I know that it is not. I suggest that the reason why rationing is still maintained is because the policy of price subsidisation is still in operation as regards these goods. I suggest that when the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce gets up to tell the Dáil that the rationing of tea, sugar, bread and flour has to be maintained because the supply position does not permit of anything else, he knows that is a misleading explanation. He knows that the true reason why the people of this country are being subjected to the unnecessary rationing is because the Government cannot make up its mind between two courses, each of which they think might be politically unpopular—either to allow the prevailing prices of these commodities to rise, or else to vote more money out of revenue for their subsidisation. Let it be clear, however, that when the Minister for Finance boasts about having reduced the cost of Government services, even though the amount which the people pay in taxes is increasing, the price which the country is paying for that notional reduction is the perpetuation of the rationing of essential food for long after the supply position had so improved as to make it unnecessary.

Can we get some statement of policy from any Minister on this matter? How long is this going to last? Have we to face the prospect that so long as the maintenance of the present price of these commodities involves the payment of some subsidies, then we will continue to be rationed? Is that the position? Is there any reason why the people of this country should not get the benefit, in flour and bread prices, of the fall in wheat prices recently recorded? Is it the policy of the Government to maintain these prices at their present level so long as any subsidy is payable? Can we get some information, other than the false and misleading information which is occasionally given to the Dáil by the Parliamentary Secretary? How long are we going to suffer this unnecessary rationing of essential food stuffs, and why?

The Government, of course, can provide the necessary dollars to supplement our tobacco purchases and to increase the delivery of tobacco from bond by 12½ per cent. because, of course, that is going to bring in more revenue. We can get an announcement as to the doubling of the basic petrol ration and, again, we have to bear in mind that an increase in the petrol ration means increased dollar expenditure, but that also brings in increased revenue. Why is petrol rationed? Will someone give me a sensible reason as to why the petrol ration was not abolished altogether? We imported into this country last year 58,000,000 gallons of petrol. Our normal pre-war imports of petrol, averaged for the three years 1936, 1937 and 1938, 38,500,000 gallons. We have a 50 per cent. increase already over the pre-war total petrol supply, and petrol rationing is still being maintained. There is not a Deputy in the House who does not think, as I think, that the Government could, in the present supply position abolish petrol rationing entirely. Why is it being maintained? What secret motive is there in the minds of the Government to justify the retention of petrol rationing when the supply position does not require it?

The reduction in the price of wheat, and the conclusion of an agreement to buy annually 270,000 metric tons of wheat at 1 dollar 80 a bushel is practically responsible for the whole of the drop in the food subsidies. It is possible that there will be a further drop. Under the agreement which will shortly be submitted to the Dáil for ratification, there is provision for the possibility of a further drop. At what stage will the Government give the people the benefit of these reductions in price? At what stage can the consumers of flour and bread hope to get their supplies cheaper because of the drop in the price of wheat? Will the Minister for Finance even say that it is the policy of the Government to maintain present prices so long as the subsidy is payable? I do not know what the view of the Government is upon the whole question of food price subsidisation. I do know that some members of the British Government have on occasion spoken as if they regarded it as a permanent addition to their social services, something to be maintained even when abnormal trading conditions or war-time scarcities had ended. Is that the view of the Government here or are they aiming to get rid of these subsidies by the various devices to which they resorted during the year? The white flour scheme has been a flop; the allocation of additional tea at 5/- for harvesting or the release of additional sugar at the uneconomic price of 7½d. per lb. in order to help the Exchequer to meet the cost of the sugar subsidy.

Talking about wheat brings me to this question of the Argentine wheat. The Minister for Agriculture has been dealing with this matter again and dealing with it just as dishonestly as ever he did before. I have no hope that anything that I may say here will prevent him or any of his colleagues from misrepresenting the facts of that deal to the people of the country. I have no hope beyond putting the facts on record that I can prevent the possibility of confusion in the public mind but I am going to put the facts on record. I know that every official in the Department of Industry and Commerce and in the Department of Agriculture and every officer of Grain Importers, Limited, as well as every British or American official who was dealing with this matter at the time will know who is telling the truth— the Minister for Agriculture or myself. They will also be able to form their personal judgment between us upon the basis of that knowledge.

Let us get the facts right first. I apologise for using the word facts. Let me give the Dáil the information that was given to me by the Minister for Agriculture in reply to a Parliamentary Question. I apologise again for describing them as "facts". I asked the Minister for Agriculture what was the total consumption of wheat in this country between the 1st of March, 1948, and the 1st September, 1948, that is to say the wheat equivalent of the flour and bread consumed and I was told it was 220,000 tons. Now there was available, to meet that alleged consumption of 220,000 tons, the following quantities of wheat: from stocks 24,217 tons. The stocks on the 1st March were 64,984 tons and on the 1st September 40,281 tons. There was, therefore, brought into consumption from the available stocks 24,217 tons. The stocks left on the 1st September were much lower than would normally be regarded as the requirement of safety. The international wheat organisations used to assume that in order to maintain an uninterrupted supply of flour and bread a minimum of nine weeks' stock was required. In practice we found we could work upon a five or six weeks' supply. On the 1st September, 1948, there was just roughly a five weeks' supply so that we had reached the stage of minimum stocks. There was imported during the period, according to the Minister for Agriculture, from Australia, 83,000 tons; the Argentine, 73,658 tons, and the United States, 2,116 tons. If some Deputy takes the trouble of adding these imports to the 24,217 tons that we drew from stock I think he will find that he will get a total of 183,019 tons. With that total available by some miracle according to the Minister for Agriculture we consumed 220,000 tons. The propaganda department slipped up there. The Statistics Branch produced those figures and if the officers in the propaganda department had not slipped in adding up we would not have had this ridiculous reply given to a Parliamentary Question.

That reply shows that in six months of last year the people of this country consumed 37,000 tons of wheat which was not here at all. The Minister for Agriculture, when speaking in this debate last week, referred to the Argentine wheat as involving 50,000 tons. Whatever the present Minister for Agriculture may be, he is not such a fool as he sometimes tries to appear, and he knew that when he said that 50,000 tons of wheat were involved. I suggest that the reply that he gave me on the 16th February was distorted for the purpose of making the quantity of Argentine wheat purchased less significant than it really was in relation to our total requirements. When the Minister last week spoke about imports of Argentine wheat of 50,000 tons he was again taking the same line, also hoping to give some significance to a document which he quoted in the form of a memorandum from Grain Importers, Ltd., which suggested that it might have been possible in May or June of last year to purchase 50,000 tons in the United States of America.

The Minister for Agriculture did not make a mistake when he spoke about 50,000 tons of Argentine wheat instead of 75,000 tons. He had to get a figure which related to the figure which appeared in Grain Importers' memorandum, because if he admitted that even the quantity of wheat which Grain Importers thought they could be able to import from the United States would, nevertheless, leave our requirements unfilled, then he would have to admit some purchase of Argentine wheat was necessary in any case.

The Minister for Agriculture stated that the Fianna Fáil Government, in December, 1947, decided to leave this question of purchasing Argentine wheat to myself. He also stated that we got advice not to purchase it from the British Government, and he read a memo sent to the Department of Industry and Commerce from Grain Importers. Not one of these statements conveys the whole truth. Every one of them has been twisted or doctored or clipped in order to convey a false picture. The question which went to the Government was whether we should reduce the bread ration or buy Argentine wheat. The decision of the Government was that the bread ration should not be reduced. When that decision was taken, it was irrevocable.

Ministers opposite may play with the suggestion that this decision to purchase Argentine wheat was made a day or two before the change of Government. It became inevitable when the Government decided not to reduce the bread ration because, if we were to leave a reasonable ration available to the following September, a reduced bread ration would have to be brought into operation immediately. Every month's delay in making the reduction in the ration meant a severer cut. What the Government decided in December, 1947, was that the bread ration would not be reduced and they left to me the question of the manner in, and the time at which the purchase of Argentine wheat would be effected in order to supply the necessary quantities of wheat to maintain the ration.

The Minister for Agriculture stated that the British Minister of Food advised us not to buy Argentine wheat. Is he or any other Deputy opposite under the illusion that Britain gave us that advice in our interests? The British Minister of Food were thinking of the interests of the British Government. They were anxious that other countries would stay off from buying Argentine wheat and perhaps force a reduction in price so that they could buy cheaper. They did not care if our bread ration was reduced. At that time it was higher than theirs.

As regards this memo from Grain Importers I am not willing to discuss the motives that inspired it—its author is dead—but I will go on the fact that when they expressed the view that it might be possible in May or June to purchase some 50,000 tons of wheat in the United States of America, they were giving us information of no value. There is no responsible Government that would have taken the risk in January or February of 1947 that, if the hope expressed by Grain Importers was not realised and if by May or June wheat could not be purchased, there would then be no bread in the country. Can you imagine any sensible group of men deciding to gamble on the possibility that in some future month wheat might possibly be procured when, in fact, it could not be, and knowing that if the hope did not come off there would be a period of two months in which no bread would be available to the Irish people? In fact, the quantity of wheat imported from America during the six months' period was 2,200 tons—two weeks' supply. If the Government had taken the advice which Grain Importers gave them, do you think we would have been exempted from blame by our successors if they found themselves in May or June in the position that there was no wheat available in the country and no possibility of buying it anywhere?

This thing has been brought up here again in the hope that some political advantage will go to the Coalition Parties. I am prepared to face the Irish people on this issue, that the Government now in office, the Coalition Government, thought it would have been better policy to have reduced the bread ration last year than to have purchased this Argentine wheat, and I am prepared to defend my action, that by purchasing that Argentine wheat before the change of Government I put them in the position that they could not reduce the bread ration. If there is any question about the price of Argentine wheat I will tell them that at the time they were eating it the price of bread was lower in Dublin than it is now.

Comment on this

Could you not have waited 48 hours and given the new Government an opportunity of deciding for themselves?

Comment on this

No, sir.

Comment on this

Even if the technical people advised you against purchasing?

Comment on this

That statement is untrue. The officers in the Department who advised me as to the position are still there.

Comment on this

And the letter is there, too.

Comment on this

I will challenge any official to put his name to that declaration.

Comment on this

Is it in order for any Deputy to suggest that civil servants should enter upon a political matter?

Comment on this

The information given by these civil servants to the present Ministers is being distorted by these Ministers before it reaches the Dáil.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste has twisted certain statements.

Comment on this

The characteristic dishonesty of the Government's propaganda in this matter is to be found in almost every Department. We are used to that type of propaganda at home. What I want to inform the Minister for External Affairs is that I object strongly, and will always object, to the introduction of the same type of tendentious propaganda into documents intended for international circulation.

We have had some discussion here already concerning remarks made by me relative to this memorandum dealing with the European Recovery Programme and presented to both Houses of the Oireachtas by the Minister for External Affairs. I think I am as well fitted as any other Deputy to assess national interests. I think that anything I may have said in this regard was more likely to help national interests and national prestige abroad than the contrary. We have had the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Agriculture and other Coalition Deputies repeatedly boasting that during the year 1948 there was a recovery in agricultural production as compared with 1947 and, in particular, that the yield of wheat per acre was substantially higher in 1948 than in 1947, and they have endeavoured to suggest that that was due to some benign influence which they spread over the country. By their speeches they have tried to ensure that the maximum political advantage would redound to them by reason of that fact. They know that that is a false picture. That will not prevent them, nevertheless, continuing to present it here at home. They know that the year 1947 was a completely abnormal one because of weather conditions. That will not prevent them, I am sure, continuing to endeavour to take some undeserved credit from the fact that there was a recovery in agricultural output in the following year. When they do that at home I am prepared to meet them and answer them. I am prepared to show the Irish people the falsity of their propaganda and the baselessness of their claims to credit because of the 1948 figures. I am not going to be blackmailed into remaining silent in the face of such dishonest propaganda because the Minister for External Affairs chose to write the same propaganda into a document for international circulation. Every Deputy knows that the year 1947 was an abnormal year. Yet, the week before last the Minister for Agriculture was expanding his chest here when announcing that the quantity of wheat delivered to Irish mills from the Irish harvest last year was nearly double the quantity delivered in the previous year. The acreage had declined by 60,000 acres, but the wheat yield, because it was a good season, had enormously increased.

Comment on this

Almighty God was on our side.

Comment on this

That is exactly what the Minister for Agriculture said—a slightly blasphemous observation, I think. The Minister admitted, however, that the yield per acre in 1947 was 10.8 cwts. as compared with 14.4 cwts. in 1946. If there is to be any suggestion that the improvement in 1948 was due to the availability of fertilisers or other materials which were not procurable during the war years, I prefer to make a comparison between 1947 and 1946. 1946 was not a good year either. It was the year in which we mobilised the shop hands and factory workers and the people in the towns and villages to go out to help the farmers save the harvest. It was not a good year. It was not a year for which one would normally quote the statistics as indicative of the productive potentialities of Irish agriculture. But 1947 was worse. When we find, however, the Minister for External Affairs explaining or purporting to explain to O.E.E.C., or to their American advisers, that that decline in yield in 1947 was not due to any abnormal circumstances prevailing here in that year but to the effect of the war upon Irish agriculture, then we know that he is putting himself in a position in which he can be proved wrong. It is to that I object. I expect members of the Coalition Government at home to use that type of false propaganda, but when they are using it abroad they are using it in relation to people who know the facts. The Americans will not be deceived. O.E.E.C. and its advisers will not be deceived. They know. Every one of the Governments concerned has a legation here which supplies them with that type of information. They know that 1947 was an abnormal year. They know that in that year not merely did the wheat yield decline to the extent I have indicated, but they know also that the yield per acre of oats declined and the yield of barley per acre declined. In the case of oats, it declined from one metric ton per acre to .8 of a ton. In the case of barley, it declined from .95 of a metric ton to .61. The yield of turnips, mangolds and potatoes also declined. The yield of sheep and lambs was down by 36 per cent. as compared with pre-war. Egg production was down by 27 per cent. Milk production was down by 11 per cent. The number of cattle under one year was 17 per cent. less. There is no point in the Minister for External Affairs trying to suggest to the European Economic Co-operation Organisation, or the American authorities administering E.R.P., that the decline in yield in 1947 was attributable, as he said, to the effect of the fertiliser shortage. I am not going to deny that we cannot make a very strong case for an increased supply of fertilisers under the E.R.P. scheme. But let us make an honest case.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt but I have replied to questions and to statements made by the Deputy pointing out that it was decided by O.E.E.C., in conjunction with E.C.A., that the year for comparison was to be the year 1947. Now, can we ignore that direction?

Comment on this

No, Sir, but you could have put in this memorandum a statement to the effect that, while the comparison was based upon the figures for the year 1947, it was necessary at the same time to point out that the year 1947 was a completely abnormal year here and that, because it was a completely abnormal year, comparison was invalidated.

Comment on this

Everyone knew that.

Comment on this

Tell the Minister for Agriculture that and tell the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that also. They have been making speeches throughout the country which were intended to convey that the increase in 1948 was due to their efforts and not to better weather conditions. Everybody knows that that document was prepared mainly for home propaganda purposes. It was so used by the Coalition newspapers and so presented over the Government-controlled radio. In case any Deputy on the Government Benches believes that any of us on this side of the House can be intimidated in this, or any other matter, from telling the people the truth by the suggestion that we are thereby in some way impairing the national interest, I assert that I shall do it on every occasion because I believe that our national interest and our national prestige depend upon scrupulous honesty in all dealings outside the country.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Set out in this memorandum, also, there is a list of national development projects. I hope the Deputies have read them. It is not a bad list. Every single project on it was a Fianna Fáil idea.

Comment on this

Including forestry?

Comment on this

Including forestry.

Comment on this

25,000 acres a year.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will explain to me the further miracle of how 25,000 acres are going to be planted on the 3,000 acres purchased for that purpose last year. That would be a typical Coalition miracle. The point I want to make is, however, that every single one of these projects was devised by us——

Comment on this

Including forestry?

Comment on this

——because it was desirable in the national interest and a necessary development that we wanted to undertake and which we would have undertaken had there been no Marshall Plan. There is a list of projects presented as devised to meet the requirements of the Marshall Plan. It is a list of the projects taken over from Fianna Fáil which they intended to go on with in any event.

Comment on this

But you woke up too late.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to agree, if the Minister for Justice wants to make the point, that in none of the development schemes we contemplated did we go as fast as we would like to have gone. Many of the impediments were unnecessary. Some of them were inevitable. Amongst the unnecessary was the opposition offered by the present Minister for Justice and his colleagues.

Comment on this

You are now copying us. Is that it? You are now taking the same line.

Comment on this

I do not know to what extent the Minister for Finance is prepared to tell the Dáil his scheme for financing these or any similar projects upon which they may decide in the future. There is a suggestion that the money put into the loan account — if that is the right name for it—under the Marshall Plan will be invested in Government stock and used for development purposes. If that is so, it is clear that some further information is required by the Dáil. We were certainly given to understand that the payment of sterling funds into that account corresponding to the dollar value of purchases made under the European Recovery Programme, was a device by which sterling would be accumulated to wipe out the dollar debt when sterling became convertible into dollars. If it is now going to be used as a capital fund for Government purposes here, at what stage and in what manner will it be replaced when the repayment of the debt becomes due? Will any of the funds be used to finance Electricity Supply Board development or Turf Board development? That presupposes investment on a long-term basis and, if so, can these organisations, or similar organisations, be required to repay at any time when the liquidation of liability under the Marshall Plan is being effected? There is no reason that I know of why the Minister for Finance cannot give, and should not give, the fullest possible information to the House on these matters.

Amongst the projects upon which the Government is going to embark is industrial development, and, for the purpose of promoting this industrial development, we are going to have an industrial advisory authority. I hope that before the debate ends, we shall get some information concerning this industrial advisory authority. Up to the present we know nothing about it except the names of the members and the fact that they are going to get £2,000 a year each.

Comment on this
A Deputy

And something more.

Comment on this

There may be something additional to meet travelling expenses.

Comment on this

Do you think it is too much?

Comment on this

I have not expressed any opinion on the matter. I am merely complaining of the paucity of information.

Comment on this

Would you like to express the view that it is too much?

Comment on this

I did not say that. So much will depend on the work they will have to do.

Comment on this

Would you like to relate the salary to that paid to the chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann?

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that the chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann is paid too much?

Comment on this

I am suggesting that he got three times as much as these men are getting.

Comment on this

The lawyers like crossexamining.

Comment on this

So far as I am concerned that is not so.

Comment on this

You know well he got over £6,000.

Comment on this

Perhaps these men are worth £10,000. All I am asking is what they are going to do, when they will start their operation and other information of that kind, and whether any declaration made by an appointee since the date this authority was constituted is to be taken as an authoritative pronouncement of the policy that is to be followed. We have had a declaration from one member of this authority since he was appointed, from Senator Luke Duffy. He is still a Senator I take it. In case there is any intention of leaving him in the Seanad let me say that I shall oppose every single project or proposal that comes to this House concerning this authority if a member of it is also a member of the Oireachtas, particularly a member who is secretary of a political party.

Comment on this

What was the date of his appointment?

Comment on this

I do not know. I am asking for information not giving it. The official announcement states that five people were appointed.

Comment on this

How do you know that was an official announcement?

Comment on this

I do not know when it was made but it was an announcement from the Government Information Bureau. Whether that organ is still fulfilling the purpose for which it was first created or is merely a propaganda agent for the Coalition Parties I do not know. The first pronouncement made by this man since his appointment was an attack of a political kind. He said that the Fianna Fáil Party, the Deputies on this side of the House, were

"bracketing themselves with the various Communist Parties in Europe who were trying to promote disaffection in the hope of bringing down existing Governments."

The existing Government about which he was worried is the Government over there. The man is an ass to start with. Is there any Deputy opposite who did not read that without a blush? That is one of the people you have chosen to be the architects of Irish industry. He then expressed his views as to how Irish industry should be planned. First of all we get a formal pronouncement from this member of the Irish Industrial Authority that flour milling is to be nationalised. Is it? Can we get some authoritative statement from some member of the Government that a policy of that kind is to be operated. There might be a case to be made for that——

Comment on this

You supported it at one time.

Comment on this

Next we were told that if the Government gives protection to any industry then there is to be a new job created. Sitting on the board of management of that industry there will be a Government representative. Is that part of Government policy? Let me quite seriously advise them on this matter. If the Government participates in the management of industry it must do so in a controlling capacity or not at all. It is an impossible situation for the Government to be represented by a minority of directors on the board of some industrial concern. The only consequences is that the Minister who appoints the representatives on the board can be questioned here in the Dáil concerning its administration while his representatives will have no effective power to direct its administration. If the Government is going into industry it will have to go completely into it. Any combination of Government and private interests in industrial management would be completely unworkable unless the Government is in the saddle.

I hope that Deputies opposite will discourage any intention on the part of the Government to adopt that particular suggestion by the brains of the national advisory authority. He also stated that there should be a representative of the workers on the board. That is a suggestion that has been made on other occasions, and maybe there is something in it. We can judge of that after we know what is meant by the term "representative of the workers." If it is intended that there should be upon these boards, whether State appointed or otherwise selected, men of experience of the trade union movement who have withdrawn from active participation in it for the purpose of doing work of this kind, then I have no objection whatever. But if the idea is that workers in a trade or industry should have on the board of management of that industry their representative acting as such, I think it is a completely wrong idea and that not merely will it put an end to trade unionism as we have known it, and to collective bargaining as heretofore practised, but it will mean that the board of the concern will be ineffective to do its main job, which is to direct and develop the industry. I do not know whether Senator Duffy knew what he was saying in using those words, but if there is any intention of moving along these lines there should be some elaboration of this policy, because I am quite convinced, if the idea is to put on the boards of management of State, semiState or privately-owned concerns, persons who are representatives of the workers employed by these concerns, not only will the interests of the workers themselves suffer, but the interests of the concerns will most certainly also suffer.

In any event there is going to be no new industry started because the policy of this new authority as announced by Senator Duffy is that those investing money in it are to have their margin of profit limited to the interest earned by an investment in gilt-edge securities.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

I am quoting from a memorandum prepared by Senator Luke Duffy and submitted to a Labour Party conference.

Comment on this

But what is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

From the Irish Press of March 26th.

Comment on this

I thought so.

Comment on this

Is it denied that he prepared this memorandum?

Comment on this

It must be the whole truth if it is in the Irish Press.

Comment on this

Is there any serious intention on the part of this authority or of the Government of imposing on those who may engage in industry the limitation that they will not be allowed to draw more in dividends on their investments than they would get as interest on a gilt-edge security? Anybody can imagine himself winning a sweepstake and seeking a suitable means of investing that money. He could, according to Senator Duffy, invest in Irish industry, but, having risked his money in a speculative enterprise of that kind and taken all precautions to ensure that his investment will not depreciate, he can hope for no greater return, according to Senator Duffy, than if he had invested the money in Government bonds and sat back to enjoy the interest. If that is the idea that is to be operated by this authority it will mean the end of development of Irish industry by private enterprise.

I have no confidence in the intention of this Government to promote industry by State enterprise. I believe that if we are going to get industrial expansion it will come more quickly and more effectively and over a wider field if it is promoted by private enterprise and individual initiative. I have no objection, and Deputies who were in this House before know that I have never raised an objection, to State intervention where it was quite clear that private enterprise was ineffective, but I believe if the policy enunciated by this member reflects the policy of that board or the intention of the Government then we can give up any idea of industrial development by private enterprise so long as the board exists or the Government is in office.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy say if there was any official statement of that kind issued by that board?

Comment on this

My point is that the only information we have got from any source as to the policy of this authority and as to the powers it is going to use is that declaration of Senator Duffy. Let us have a more authoritative declaration if it can be made.

Let Deputies have no misunderstanding about it that, in the absence of any more authoritative pronouncement, business people are assuming that Senator Duffy is speaking the mind of the Government and that it is because he knows the mind of the Government that he was chosen for this position. I have based my speech on the contention that the Government in matters of public interest are often less than frank with the Dáil and, on occasion, fail to give the Dáil either adequate or reliable information upon which to form conclusions.

Comment on this

Does that apply to Córas Iompair Éireann?

Comment on this

Particularly to Córas Iompair Éireann. Was there one member of the Government with the moral courage to stand up and tell the public why Córas Iompair Éireann is losing money? The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce—and all credit to him —did make some attempt to explain the position. The fact of the matter is that Córas Iompair Éireann, in 1948, was paying out £2,500,000 more in wages than in 1946. Every attempt has been made to suggest that the losses incurred by Córas Iompair Éireann were due to faulty management or direction and that the losses will disappear when the board of directors is changed. Do not Minister know that that is not true? Is it wise to tell the people that the employees of that concern can get wage increases amounting to £2,500,000 per year and that increases in charges for transport could, nevertheless, have been avoided? Is it not much wiser to be frank with the people and tell them that the increase of wages, the justifiable increases, that were sanctioned by the Labour Court or settled by negotiation have to be paid for by somebody and that there is no source from which the company can draw revenue to pay them except transport charges?

Comment on this

And a proposal to dismiss 2,000 men.

Comment on this

That again is a falsehood. I say that the clear meaning of the letter sent by the chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann to the Government was that, because of the increase in rates of wages, it was necessary to increase the charges and that the alternative to increasing the charges was to cut their costs, even if it meant disemploying men.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

They made it quite clear in the letter that they did not approve of the policy of reducing maintenance.

Comment on this

I heard them; I was listening to them.

Comment on this

I read the letter which they sent and other Deputies could have read it.

Comment on this

I asked if these proposals were an alternative and I was told they were not.

Comment on this

I am prepared to take the clear meaning of the words contained in the letter which was sent by the company to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and which was published in the newspapers. Let us have no illusions with regard to this matter. Irish transport is in difficulties. Let us have no illusions that meeting these difficulties is not going to be easy. You will not solve them by dismissing the present board of directors and putting in a bunch of Government nominees. That is not going to solve them; that is only pretending to solve them. It is leaving the essential cause of the trouble untouched. This is not a matter which we can discuss now. My views will be given when it comes before the Dáil officially. I say that the Government were dishonest in every public declaration they made in the matter; that they are less than frank, and because they are less than frank, they are unwise, and particularly in concealing from the people the real cause of the increase in the operating charges of Córas Iompair Éireann which led to the losses of last year and at the present.

The same thing applies to a reply given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce last week concerning the generation programme of the Electricity Supply Board. There is to be a new steam station at Ringsend. In order to divert criticism, he endeavoured to convey that this was really a steam station of which I approved, with this difference: that I had approved of its establishment in Cork and it was merely being transferred to Dublin. I approved of the inclusion in the generation programme of the Electricity Supply Board of a small station at Cork which was intended, as I understood it, to be used to boost the supply into that part of the network and which would not have been required except for that purpose. To misrepresent the decision to establish that small station as being equivalent to setting up at Ringsend a steam station which I understood him to imply would be as large as the Pigeon House is thoroughly dishonest.

Comment on this
A Deputy

To replace the Pigeon House.

Comment on this

Would someone explain this business of replacing the Pigeon House which has been there for some years and which, I think, contains six generating units? From time to time as units wear out they are replaced. Some were replaced in the last ten years. There is no question of replacing the Pigeon House in the sense in which I understood the Minister to use that term. Each generating unit is replaced as required. This problem of planning the development of electricity generation can be considered under three headings. It can be considered solely in relation to the economic cost, and that is what the Electricity Supply Board is inclined to do. It can be considered in relation to the development of national resources, whether of water power or of peat. It can be considered in relation to national security in times of emergency. On any ground, the decision to establish a new steam station of the dimensions which the Minister suggested at Ringsend is wrong.

Let me admit that, earlier in the planning of the Electricity Supply Board development, I had tentatively agreed to the erection in Dublin—not at Ringsend, but at another site in Dublin—of a new large steam station using foreign fuel, because at that time it seemed to me there were practical difficulties of a real kind in developing turf-fired stations for standby purposes. It seemed to me, and I stated it in the Dáil when I brought the Bill here in 1944, that every turf-fired station would have to be a base-load station, because it was a station with a bog attached. You could not lay off men or take back men according as the station was brought into or put out of commission.

It is recognised that there must be in relation to a system which is based largely upon water power a great deal of standby plant. It is obviously much more convenient that a standby plant should use a fuel which can be imported or not imported, as suits ourselves. However, in the course of 1947 repeated conferences between the engineers of the Electricity Supply Board and Bord na Móna secured, as I understood, an agreement that the standby plant requirements of the Electricity Supply Board could be met by steam stations using turf and that that was made practicable by the decision to expand the programme of Bord na Móna. It is quite obvious that the absorption into the ordinary commercial market of the quantity of turf that might have been used in a steam station if the steam station was not brought into commission was less difficult when that market was enlarged than it was as originally planned. Again, I am merely bringing this matter in to illustrate the disreputable methods by which the Government are endeavouring to defend their decisions and to score points over their opponents. It is not honest to represent the establishment of a new steam station at Ringsend as the implementation of a decision taken by me. I did not decide on the inclusion in the programme of any steam station using imported fuel except, as I understood it, a small station in Cork intended merely to boost the supply. That station was of no significance in relation to the generation programme as required. A large station at Ringsend does inevitably mean the putting back to a further date the development of our peat resources. Furthermore, I should like to know if the military authorities were consulted before that decision was taken. It seems to me the height of folly in a world which might in three, five or more years be at war to concentrate in one area—an undefendable area of Dublin—such a significant proportion of our total generating capacity. It would be far wiser to space our generating stations in smaller units throughout the country than to concentrate them into one unit located at Ringsend merely because it is cheaper to import English coal into Ringsend than into any other part of the country.

I have, perhaps, spoken unduly long on this matter, but I do ask any Minister who proposes to participate in the debate to realise that the value of the work done in the Dáil—our debates are often acrimonious, but even acrimonious debates can be useful— depends upon the reliability of the information which the ordinary Deputy gets.

Comment on this

What about Aer Lingus?

Comment on this

Perhaps I had better leave that until the Estimate comes along. I have so much to say about it. The work we do here is of value only if we have the proper tools with which to do it. The tools we use are reliable information. Whether the statistics which are given in reply to questions are accurate or not, sufficient doubt has been created by the misuse of statistics in the past to make us accept them with doubt, and Ministers have got to break down that bad tradition by being frank and honest with the Dáil in future. If they are, they will get from these benches criticisms when they deserve them, but constructive proposals when they are in order.

Comment on this
Seán MacBride Minister for External Affairs (Mr. MacBride) Clann na Poblachta

I think there is a general opinion that Deputy Lemass, who has, I think, considerably more ability than most of his colleagues, seems to be intent on proving that he has a number of blind spots. He has allowed his intelligence and his ability to be minimised by bitterness and by dishonest suggestions. Probably the most damaging form of dishonesty or slander is that which is carried out by way of innuendo. I do not think that it is easy to deceive anybody, and I think it is a pity that Deputy Lemass, in particular, should indulge in it, because he has more ability than most of his colleagues and he would contribute more to the discussion if he did not resort to palpably dishonest statements.

In a great many respects I might share Deputy Lemass's views. A great many other people in the country might also share them in a great many respects. However, he antagonises people from even taking him seriously by reason of that bitterness and of the false innuendoes that he interjects in the course of his statements. I think it is a pity that we have so many acrimonious debates in the House. It reduces the standard of the discussions, and it precludes the House from making the contribution that it could to the various economic and political problems of the Continent. It would be a good thing if we could agree to avoid these acrimonious discussions, if we could agree to prevent over-statements and if we could agree not to slander each other, either directly or by way of innuendo. I do not think that the country wants behaviour of that kind; I think it prefers us to conduct constructive discussion in the House.

The last portion of Deputy Lemass's speech was concerned with trying to justify a completely irresponsible speech which he made in Fermoy and which was reported in his paper on the 7th of March. The speech was irresponsible because it was both untrue in its main facts and also calculated to be damaging to this country abroad, as the House knows. This country joined with a number of other European nations in the O.E.E.C. to formulate economic programmes and plans. It has to submit these to the O.E.E.C. and to the economic authorities now in Washington. They have to be approved and passed by them before this country can get any allocation of dollars. They are carefully screened both by the O.E.E.C. and by the American authorities in Washington. They are doubly screened. The statistics are checked and counterchecked not merely here, in Paris and in Washington but most of the other countries have also an interest in verifying the statistics and in ensuring that there is no over-statement. Finally, when the allocations are made the provision of the money which is required for this operation is discussed by the Congress of the United States. Speeches made, even by irresponsible members of Parliaments in their own countries, are often quoted in the discussions on the appropriations of different countries. Therefore, it is clearly damaging to the interests of the country that a Deputy of this House, and particularly one who is an ex-Minister, should make untrue allegations concerning his country's economic requirements or position. Deputy Lemass, in his Fermoy speech, which he sought to justify this afternoon and which is headed in his paper "Coalition Propaganda ‘Dishonest'," begins, first of all, by accusing the Government of falsifying national conditions and then proceeds to deal with the long-term programme put forward by this country:—

"The Report gave a definitely misleading picture, both of the effect of wartime shortages on Irish productive capacity, and on possible future increases in production."

I notice that to-day Deputy Lemass did not seek in any way to accuse the Government of having given a false estimate of wartime shortages on Irish production. I take it he could not do it, nor did he challenge the long-term report on the ground that future increases were also wrong. It is quite easy for the Deputy to make a speech and have it reported in his paper, but he did not try to justify these assertions to-day. He then went on to say:—

"The section dealing with agriculture set out to show the effect of the war on our agricultural production by comparing pre-war output with output in 1947. It also gave estimates of increased future production... based on 1947 figures. The selection of 1947 could not have been accidental."

I issued a statement immediately I saw that speech to try and minimise the damage that a speech of that kind might have on our programme which is at present going through the E.C.A. machine and the O.E.C. machine.

Comment on this

You mean the damage done to your political interests. That is all.

Comment on this

The damage done by the Deputy whose speech might well mean that this country's allocation of dollars in future might be prejudiced because of your erroneous statement.

Comment on this

Utter nonsense. It was far more likely to be prejudiced by your bogus report.

Comment on this

The Deputy says it is a bogus report. That is a lie, and you know it is a lie.

Comment on this

Is it in order to call a Deputy a liar?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not in order to call a Deputy a liar.

Comment on this

All right. I certainly withdraw that. I take it that the Chair will ask the Deputy to withdraw the allegation that the Minister put forward a bogus report.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a political matter. Deputy Lemass is quite entitled to say that any Deputy in the House put forward a bogus report. The Minister for External Affairs would be quite entitled to say that the Deputy put forward a bogus report. That is purely political. The statement that the Minister for External Affairs was a liar is a purely personal matter, or that Deputy Lemass was a liar is a purely personal matter.

Comment on this

In respect to the Chair I withdraw the expression. Deputy Lemass accused me of having made a bogus statement. I retorted that that was a lie. I am quite prepared to withdraw it if the Chair considers that it is an improper remark.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot make the term "liar" the current language of the Dáil. That is obvious to anybody. To call Deputy Lemass a liar is a purely personal statement.

Comment on this

The Minister will issue another statement to-morrow.

Comment on this

The Deputy in his speech said that the selection of the year 1947 could not have been accidental. It was not accidental. The year 1947 was selected, not by us, but by E.C.A. and by O.E.C. as the year for comparison. The long-term programme was compiled at the end of 1948 and the comparisons were between pre-war figures, in most cases laid down by O.E.C. and E.C.A. as the year that had been directed.

The Deputy said to-day in the House that weather conditions in 1947 were bad. They were, but it was not only here they were bad; they were bad in the rest of Europe as the Deputy knows, and nobody could have been misled by the figures. The details and figures given were prepared by an inter-Departmental committee representing officials from the Departments of Industry and Commerce, Agriculture, Finance and External Affairs. Therefore, most of the burden of Deputy Lemass's speech was, in effect, an attack on the officials who prepared the report. I do not think it is proper to attack these officials because that is, in effect, what the Deputy did.

The Deputy destroyed his own criticism by saying that the Americans knew the facts; that they had their experts here to advise them. Other west European countries had the same experience as this country in 1947 and their production had been cut by nearly half. It is perfectly futile to suggest that the year 1947 was taken arbitrarily by this Government in order to mislead the United States authorities or the authorities of any other country. It was the year determined for comparison purposes.

May I, before I pass from that speech of Deputy Lemass—I dealt with some aspects of it before—refer to one typical sentence in it? He said:—

"Housing and health plans had been reduced in scope or delayed by incompetence."

Can Deputy Lemass seriously suggest that housing and health plans had been either reduced in scope or delayed by inefficiency? Before the change of Government Deputy Lemass and his colleagues, when on these benches, did, in fact, allow people to die year by year for want of treatment in sanatoria.

Comment on this

Not a brick has been put upon a brick.

Comment on this

775 beds were provided by the Minister for Health in the last year.

Comment on this

Not a brick has been put upon a brick.

Comment on this

Those 800 beds are now occupied by people who had been left without treatment and left to die in their own homes.

Comment on this

I know all about that.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows very little about it.

Comment on this

We know it in Cork.

Comment on this

Do you deny that these beds have been provided? Deputy Lemass, very unwisely for himself I think, proceeded to talk about Córas Iompair Éireann and asked why it was losing money. I can tell Deputy Lemass why Córas Iompair Éireann was losing money. The citizens of Dublin have only to look at the skyline over the Custom House at night to see why they have to pay increased fares——

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

—— where £500,000 has been spent on the erection of a building which will be of no use and which will not add one penny to the revenue of the company.

Comment on this

Go down and look at the corrugated iron along the quays— something like a public lavatory— where people now have to wait for buses. Is that good enough for them?

Comment on this

That building was scheduled to cost approximately £500,000 and it is likely to cost £750,000 now. It is a sheer waste of money.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

It is a sheer waste at a time when the company is insolvent.

Comment on this

It is not insolvent yet.

Comment on this

You were paying its chairman £2,500, with £4,000 a year as an allowance—a total of £6,500. These are the reasons why that company is insolvent.

Comment on this

Is it in order for a Minister to attack a man who is not in a position to defend himself in this House—the ex-chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann?

Comment on this

I have not attacked the ex-chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is not attacking the ex-chairman; he is dealing with money expended in connection with Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this

I take it your ruling is that any reference to the chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann, past or present, is quite in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister has been dealing with moneys expended in connection with Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this

If we can discuss the past chairman of that company, we can discuss the present one, too.

Comment on this

I am not discussing any chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann, past or present. Deputy Lemass asked the question, why was Córas Iompair Éireann in such a bad position.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

I took a note of it— I have it here.

Comment on this

I asked why would not Ministers tell the truth to the public.

Comment on this

I am giving you the answer, and that answer is because Deputy Lemass sanctioned and encouraged the squandering of millions —literally millions—on unproductive schemes for Córas Iompair Éireann, of which that bus depôt near the Custom House is a typical example.

Comment on this

That represents a saving to Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this

A saving? Spending £750,000 on a bus depôt represents a saving?

Comment on this

They will save money on it; ultimately it will mean a saving, because they will not have to continue paying so much in rent.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is true, and the Minister will find that out in due course.

Comment on this

Will we be in order in discussing the management of Córas Iompair Éireann? The Minister is now discussing the management of Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

In so far as it relates to Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

I put it to you that the Minister is discussing this matter, not in relation to Industry and Commerce, but in relation to the management of the concern.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

He is relating it to the extent that the Government were responsible for certain things in connection with the management of Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass contemptuously referred to the Government appointing a group of Government nominees as directors of Córas Iompair Éireann. That remark comes ill from Deputy Lemass. Who were the directors of Córas Iompair Éireann and who was the chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann during Deputy Lemass's time, and who appointed him?

Comment on this

The Government appointed the chairman.

Comment on this

Very well. Then what is the use of referring to a bunch of Government nominees? Who appointed the last directors?

Deputy Lemass sought to take credit for the policy of the Government in reference to afforestation. It might have been well before he did so if he had read the speech made by his colleague, Deputy Moylan, a week or ten days ago in this House, where he admitted frankly that the Fianna Fáil policy had failed in respect of forestry, and where he stated that it was one of the faults of Fianna Fáil that they had done nothing about forestry.

Comment on this

That is an absurd statement.

Comment on this

I would like to bring members of the Dáil back to the time previous to the last election when a lot of people who voted for the present set-up thought they were going to enter the promised land. I think they realise by this that it was a land of promises they entered.

I am glad the Lord Mayor of Cork is listening to me because I want to speak about unemployment as it exists in Cork. In my opinion, the number of unemployed there was never greater than at the present time. Workers have been laid off in several factories within the past six months. Every Cork Deputy must admit that he has been repeatedly asked to try to get employment for young people and old people in the City of Cork. I am sure that Deputy Sheehan has been requested to do that as often as anybody else, and I am sure that he has to tell the people as often as any of us have to tell them that he does not know of any employment offering.

We have been told here about drainage schemes, river clearance schemes, for the country. That is no good to the unemployed in the City of Cork. What are the Government prepared to do for the unemployed in Cork City? The Minister for Defence is a Deputy for the city and I would like to know if he can offer any suggestion as to where we could put those people to work. Will he ask the Government to do anything so that those people can be employed and not have us forcing them out of the country? That is what they are doing every week.

I was in the American Consulate in Dublin last December, and I saw there a woman with six children who wanted to join her husband, who had gone to America 12 months before. She had been told she could not get away until February. There was an air of great activity over there, and when I saw the Consul he told me: "You can tell that lady that she may be able to get away by the middle of January, because we are stepping up production here." That is not a lie—that is the fact.

I put down a question a couple of weeks ago to the Minister for Defence about the repair of furniture in the Southern Command. I asked if it was a fact that it was being sent to Dublin for repair from all the stations in the Southern Command. The answer I got was that small repairs were done by a cabinet-maker in Cork but it was found more practicable to send major repairs to Dublin, where they had workshops equipped to cope with them.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That happened during your régime too.

Comment on this

Will you stop interrupting? You had to leave the House last week.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You do not know anything about the new Army.

Comment on this

The Minister told me that that had been going on for 25 years. We have a representative for Cork now as Minister for Defence. The people of Cork expect a little more from him. Irrespective of the fact that this practice was done over the last 25 years, the time has now come when the practice should be stopped. Surely, it should be possible to get the work done in a properly equipped workshop in Cork, instead of sending the stuff from Cork and Castletownbere all the way to Dublin. That is one of those small items which are helping in the aggregate to destroy the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is irrelevant on this Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I want some information, too, on the recommendation made by Sir James Milne to remove the heavy workshops from Rocksavage. I hope that is not another effort to make a still bigger Dublin and a still smaller Cork and elsewhere. The sooner someone discovers a cure for the present epidemic of "Dublinitis" the better it will be for the country at large. We are completely unbalanced at the moment. It is all Dublin and nowhere else.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I am with you there anyhow.

Comment on this

A couple of weeks ago I was travelling up by train and I saw some members of the Emigration Commission coming up to Dublin on the same train. As far as I am aware it is not from Dublin the people are emigrating. I think it would be more appropriate if the commission sat in Kerry or Galway. I take it that the only reason why they sit in Dublin is in an endeavour to find out why the people are coming to Dublin.

Comment on this

Was there any Corkman coming up?

Comment on this

The unfortunate thing is that when you ship the work up here you must ship the men up likewise in order to do it for you. That is the trouble. I would like to draw attention to the increased cost of living because of the increased bus fares. These increases will cost an adult family of six members an extra £1 1s. per week. On to that must be added the 3/- per week that this family of six will have to pay in increased insurance contributions. The Government should do something in the matter. There has been a lot of criticism about one Minister saying one thing and another Minister saying something else. On the 9th of December I put down a question to the Minister for Defence with regard to a couple of clerks employed in Collins Barracks in Cork, and I pointed out that one of the men had neither Army nor Old I.R.A. service.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I allowed the Deputy to refer to the removal of repair work from Cork to Dublin even though that is a matter of purely Departmental administration and will arise on the Estimate for the Department concerned. What we are discussing now is general policy.

Comment on this

I want to point out, with your permission, that the answer I got was that the man in question had been a member of the L.D.F., and I was asked if I was going to treat the members of the L.D.F. as pariah dogs. I put down a question a couple of weeks ago with regard to a man employed in the Board of Works. He had offered himself for Army service but was rejected because of varicose veins. He spent seven years in the L.D.F. In his case the Minister very coolly told me that he had no Army service. Is it the case that a man need not have Army service if he is a supporter of Fine Gael?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I want to indicate to the Deputy that these are purely administrative matters and not for discussion on the question of policy.

Comment on this

It is a question of policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a question of policy; it is a question of administration.

Comment on this

It is a question of policy in the filling of minor posts.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is a question of administration and the Deputy will pass from it now. I have given him enough latitude.

Comment on this

I have said all I wanted to say.

Comment on this