We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1949-50 (Resumed).

Contributions 174–335 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

You know the game.

Comment on this

I did not intend to speak about the Department of Health but I want to make a few comments because of the remarks made by the Minister for External Affairs. In the first six months of this Government we had nothing but plans and schemes with big headlines in the papers telling us what was going to be done by the Department of Health. I believe the Minister had the best intentions in the world when he started out. He visited Cork and we gave him a hospital in Mallow capable of accommodating 100 patients. But since that time nothing further has been done. Plans have been drawn up——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must get it out of his head that everything connected with Cork comes under the heading of policy.

Comment on this

I am here representing Cork.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have his opportunity on the Estimates.

Comment on this

I have not done too badly. But we are being allowed to drift. Letters have been written to which we have got no replies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will pass from that. I will not have any more about it. The Deputy is not going to get past the Chair in that fashion.

Comment on this

I must say you have been lenient enough.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think so.

Comment on this

I merely want to recall now the great promises that were made about the reduction in the cost of living, full employment and the building of hospitals. Deputy Lehane said on one occasion that the work would be done in two months. I think the people have had their eyes opened at last and I hope they will be given an opportunity, though not at our expense, of following the example set in Donegal.

Comment on this

I am in sympathy with the statement made by Deputy McGrath in relation to the unemployment problem in Cork. It is not to-day or yesterday, however, that this problem confronted this Government or any previous Government. If we all joined together for the working out of a better and happier economy we might go a long way towards solving this problem. I suggest to the Minister that the best help he could give in that direction would be to lower taxation. Taxation is a terrible drain on the industrialist as well as on the rank and file. If taxation is lowered more money will be available for capital expenditure and for industrial expansion. Those who pay income-tax will have more to spend on purchasing and will thereby bring about a better standard of living.

A good deal has been said about emigration. The people have always emigrated from this country to England, America, South Africa and all over the world. We are all proud of our emigrants. Even though they may be divided from us their heart is always in this country. Ours is a small island country. In rural Ireland, the children of farmers on small holdings who have families of six or eight must have an outlet somewhere. This country is too small to provide for all these people. They have been emigrating down the ages and they have made good in other countries. What can a farmer who owns 30 or 40 acres do for a family of nine or ten when they grow up? Some of them may come to Dublin, to enter the Civil Service, perhaps, but the majority of them have to go abroad, as there is room for only one on the farm. The same applies to families of labourers. I have listened to Deputies here advocating the division of large farms into smaller holdings of 20 or 30 acres. I think that is a policy that is altogether wrong, because a man can only get a bare existence on a farm of that size. The extension of agricultural production is, of course, a thing which appeals to many people. We were discussing it to-day coming up in the train and it was pointed out that if the Minister makes another 1,000,000 acres available, we shall have over-production. What then are we going to do with our surplus products? So far as the housing problem is concerned, I think the Minister for Local Government has done his share in trying to find a solution for that problem during the past 12 months. He has appealed to local authorities to do their utmost also and they are doing their best, but you cannot build houses overnight.

We have heard a lot of discussion about turf production, but I should like to point out that in Cork we have 50,000 tons of turf which have been lying there for the last two years and which are rapidly deteriorating. I suggest that it is madness for Deputies to say that we should have produced turf last year at the same rate as during the emergency. I am sure the Government has no objection to the people of rural districts producing as much turf as they want but, so far as I can see, the tendency in this, as in many other matters, is to look to the Government for everything. I think that the production of turf is largely a matter for private enterprise.

In conclusion, may I suggest that it would be much better for the country if, instead of bickering here across the floor, we pooled all our efforts to try to solve unemployment and to do some good for the country? I think it would be much better, too, if the membership of this House were reduced to 50 or 60 members. At present there are almost 150 members, each drawing a salary of over £600 with expenses. I think this House could do much more useful work if we had, say, two representatives for each county. That would mean a substantial reduction in the cost of Government and I think the country would be run much more efficiently.

Comment on this

The claim is made for the present Government that it has reduced the amount of the Estimates by £5,000,000 or £6,000,000. That represents, in comparison with last year's figures, a reduction of 1 in 14. The comment I have to make is that the services which were designed principally for the benefit of the poorest areas and the most depressed areas in the country, including my own constituency, had the figures reduced by 1 in 4. I think that is hardly fair. The Minister for Finance should have left the Estimates for services which benefited the people in those districts untouched and should have looked around in other directions for the economies which he thought it necessary to effect. The unexpected cessation of the production of turf hit those areas very seriously. I am not going to comment on that now further than to say that it was a very sudden blow and a very big blow and that it increased emigration almost immediately from these areas. I asked the Minister for Social Welfare for the figures in regard to the recipients of unemployment assistance in my own constituency last November and I was given the rather startling information— startling to me, in any event—that there were fewer people drawing unemployment assistance in my constituency last November than in November, 1947, and that a larger amount of unemployment assistance was being paid. To me, of course, the explanation was obvious because I knew that all the people who had no domestic ties, all the younger men, had left the area immediately employment on the turf scheme ceased, and that a larger number of small landholders came on the register. These people, having dependents, qualified for a larger amount of unemployment assistance. The amount paid was increased while the actual number receiving it had been reduced because there had been a big increase in emigration.

I should like to draw the Minister's attention to the contraction of the amount for the glass-house scheme, which, on the figures given recently by the Minister for Agriculture, was a very good scheme. If the public purse has to undertake certain expenses in connection with that scheme, I would put it to the Minister that it is much better to expend the money in that way than that we should pay it in unemployment assistance. It is a scheme which promises to become a paying one in a short time, even from the point of view of the national Exchequer.

Recently we had an announcement that another enterprise started by Fianna Fáil is to be terminated. I know the Minister will not agree when I say that it is going to be terminated. I refer to the sale of the Ballynahinch Hotel, which gives employment to about 50 people in that county. The people have benefited very considerably by the existence of that hotel. There is, I believe, nobody in the West who believes that a buyer who will run Ballynahinch Castle as a hotel will be found. I hope it will be possible to continue it as a hotel, but the prospects of people getting into the hotel business in the tourist areas, now that we are getting further away from the war, I am reliably informed, are very thin, indeed. I know of one tourist hotel in the West which is privately owned and which is already advertised for sale. There are rumours that another large hotel is also for sale. With that information in mind, it seems to me unlikely that the Government will be able to find a purchaser who will keep that hotel going and thereby guarantee employment to the people now employed. It is going to be a very serious loss to the district in which it is located. The majority of those employed are local people. They are married men and their condition is going to be so worsened that I cannot conceive of any public scheme which the Government can introduce which will put them in as good a position as they are in now.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that the hotel lost money when the tourist trade was very big and the Deputy agrees that the tourist trade is going to go down. Is the suggestion that the hotel should be kept on, losses or not?

Comment on this

Here is the suggestion I want to make to the Minister. These hotels were designed for the purpose of getting foreign visitors and gaining foreign currency for the country. I understand that that means of getting foreign currency is adopted in other countries, notably Switzerland, and that, even if there is a loss, the national Exchequer believes it is well paid if the earnings of the hotels are in foreign currency.

Comment on this

Do you mean sterling.

Comment on this

Even in sterling.

Comment on this

We have far too much sterling.

Comment on this

Last year the Minister regretted that we had spent too heavily of our sterling assets in 1947. I think he complained in his Budget statement that we had overspent.

Comment on this

I do not like to get further assets at a very serious loss. I would not call that good business.

Comment on this

If the results of the last war are to be removed and the world is to get back to peace, surely it is reasonable to expect that whatever sterling assets we have will be convertible into the other currencies which we require.

Comment on this

But we lost money on that hotel—at least the board did and they did not get much in the way of dollars.

Comment on this

Did they get sterling?

Comment on this

Yes, but they spent more than they got.

Comment on this

What did they do before this hotel was established?

Comment on this

Why should we keep on a hotel which had losses at a time when every boarding-house in the country was making money?

Comment on this

Why should not the Deputy be allowed to speak without interruption?

Comment on this

A Deputy asked what did they do before this hotel was established. That is the cause of the complaint we are making.

The previous Government improved the lot of the people and now they are to revert to the bad condition in which they were before. The position was had before and it should now be made as bad as it was. That is the genesis of the complaint which we have on this side of the House in regard to this matter. Apparently that is the outlook so far as the West is concerned.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy approve of building another half a dozen hotels to be run at a loss?

Comment on this

The principle stated by the Minister for Industry and Commerce was that it is not the business of the Government to provide money for the tourist hotels.

Comment on this

That is sound.

Comment on this

That was going on for years without anybody taking any notice. These hotels were operated by a State-subsidised organisation.

Comment on this

And all of them lost money.

Comment on this

When money was lost on the operation by a transport concern nobody said anything about it, but because the Tourist Board operated hotels, objection is taken immediately to it. Deputy Sheehan made a great many statements to which I believe a great many people on that side of the House would take exception. It seems to me that if we had not the organisation of Parties in the country which we have had we would have a much different alignment of representation in this House from what we had even in the Fianna Fáil time. Anyone who read Deputy Commons' speech last week will find that, making due allowance for his artificial opposition to Fianna Fáil, the sentiments he expressed are the same as are expressed by other Western Deputies in this House. I want to congratulate Deputy Commons on his honesty in saying that he is not satisfied that his own side of the House has shown any earnest that they are going to make any more progress in solving the problems of the West than has been the case in the past. We want to find out, for instance, what the Government are going to do in the matter of providing money for land settlement. I know that complaint has been made that too much land is being divided, that it is a pity to divide any more, and that, in any event, if you give people 20 or 25 acres you are not going to give them an economic living. What Deputy Commons and myself and a lot of other people from the West put forward against that point of view is that, in any event, you give them the means of keeping body and soul together, of getting a sustenance from the land which they cannot get from the bogs and the rocks where they are huddled together at present. The people who have been migrated from the West and given small farms have, on the figures given by the Land Commission, increased enormously the production of the food that human beings require. Even if their families have to emigrate, they have had the advantage of having been well fed, well housed, and well clothed during their early years. If that consideration does not appeal to the average Deputy, I want to tell him that the Deputies from the West place a great deal of store by it.

I should like to find out from some Minister what the policy of the Government is going to be in relation to that matter. I am not asking this Government, any more than I asked the last Government, to take all the congests in the West and bring them up to the good lands. I do say, however, that the problem ought to be tackled and that relief ought to be given. I do ask that the worst places in the West should get more assistance. A whole lot of other schemes in relation to the congested areas—housing schemes, land reclamation, and various things of that sort—are of no use to people whose lands are to be rearranged. If there is a townland where the Land Commission has yet to carry out rearrangement work, the people living there cannot get a grant for a new house. These people are condemned to live on in hovels simply because the public authority, the Land Commission, will not do its work or will not say that it is not going to do this job at all. We asked the last Government and we want this Government to declare the extent to which this problem is going to be tackled, the number of people that the Land Commission intends to migrate and the places from which it is going to be done. I do not think it is beyond the powers of the Land Commission to give that information.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be a matter for the Estimate on Lands.

Comment on this

All I want to put to the Minister is that he ought to consider, if it is necessary to finance a large scheme of land settlement by floating a loan, raising the necessary finance for this matter in that way.

I do not like to refer on this Vote to anything that seems to be purely politics, but I cannot pass by a speech that I heard last week from a Deputy on that side. I think it was Deputy Cowan. He said that for the first time we now had peace and order in the country and that he, for one, although he had broken away from his own Party would not give his vote to put this Government out and the last Government in. He went on to say that if Fianna Fáil were returned to power there would again be in the country disorder and disturbance. That seems to me a very strange statement to make and, in view of the statement of the Taoiseach with regard to the difference between the position under Fianna Fáil before the External Relations Act came into operation and the position since the Republic of Ireland Act, it seems a very strange thing that any Deputy should prophesy that any Party would be justified in creating conditions of disorder and disturbance if Fianna Fáil were returned to power. Is it not being made the case that whatever disorder did exist in the past, whatever lack of peace there was, was due to the fact that the people kept Fianna Fáil there by their votes and that there would not be any peace or any order in the country until the people changed their minds and put them out?

If the people again in the next election decide that they are going to put back Fianna Fáil will these people feel justified again in creating these conditions of disorder and disruption for the purpose of bringing duress on the people to change the Government? Does the argument not boil down to the fact that the peace was established simply because the people put out Fianna Fáil? The Deputy who made that speech also seemed to take great exception to any criticisms being offered to the present Government. He particularly attacked the one organ of expression in the country—the Irish Press—which does criticise the Government. It seems to me that any man who objects to one newspaper out of the great number we have in the country, both daily and weekly, criticising the Government has a totalitarian attitude in that he wants a single Party in the country. I hope that we have departed from that outlook for a very long time. That type of attitude has brought enough destruction to the world and I hope that the satisfactory position in that regard which exists between the Opposition and the Government will be continued and that whatever criticism is offered by the Opposition and by Opposition organs will be lumped if it is not liked. I think it is best for the peace and order of the country that it should be so and that no Deputy of this House will succeed in introducing any type of totalitarianism here.

Tá an scéal níos measa i gConamara ná mar a bhí sé le fada an lá. Tá gné nua den imirce le tabhairt faoi deara, sé sin, go bhfuil muiríní ag díol a gcuid talún agus ag bailiú leo as an tír. At ndóigh ní tharlaíonn sé sin go dtí go mbí an dochas féin leáite.

Comment on this

I should like to say at the outset that I welcome very much the fact that the Minister, notwithstanding all the difficulties with which he has had to contend during the past year, has been in a position to reduce taxation so far as the coming year is concerned. That is a fact that should be welcomed by all Deputies of this House because I think it is fairly well agreed that high taxation is not good for industry or for increased production, especially as this is a very small country with limited resources. It cannot be compared with any of the other countries in the world. It is good to see that the Minister has thought fit to cut the cloth according to the measurement. On an occasion like this it would be well to take stock of the present position in the country, especially so far as the future is concerned. I think we should realise at once that Acts of Parliament or the making of speeches or criticising one another are not going to increase production in this country. That can only be done by hard work and efficiency and the sooner we recognise that fact the better. I can speak with a certain amount of contentment on this Vote for the simple reason that I think I cannot be charged with criticising the previous Government or accused of making rash promises during the previous election. I think we should forget all about that. Everybody makes certain promises during an election and hopes to fulfil them. He will do his best to fulfil them but if he cannot, that is that. It is about time that the present Government got a little consideration from the Deputies opposite. They have only been in office for 12 months and surely things cannot be that bad after 16 years of as successful a Government as Fianna Fáil was, according to themselves. They are unconsciously blowing sky high their own case by stating that the country is bankrupt. Deputy O'Reilly stated in the Dáil last week that in County Meath 40 per cent. of the farmers were leaving the land and on the verge of starvation.

Comment on this

I said that 40 per cent. of the grassland is not now set. That is a fact. I further said that there were people on the verge of starvation.

Comment on this

That, I said to myself, is nonsense. Deputy O'Reilly is hardly fair to his own Government after 16 years to say that the people of Meath after one short 12 months should be on the verge of starvation. Let us be a bit realistic on an occasion like this and not try to score one over the other. We are all pledged to do the best we can for the country. The outlook for this and other countries at the moment is not just as promising as it was ten or 11 years ago and the sooner we recognise that fact the better. During the last eight or ten years we have been, like a fly in the summer time, basking in the sunshine of prosperity, but an economic blizzard has come now, and that would be there, no matter what Government was in power. There is no use in the Deputies opposite trying to create consternation in the country by the mere fact that half a dozen men were dismissed from their employment. That will always happen. We have always had unemployment here, and I have said so many a time during the last 20 years in this House. No matter what Government is in power, you will always have a certain amount of unemployment.

As regards the various Ministers and their efforts during the past year, I do not intend to say much. The Minister for Industry and Commerce will, I am certain, do his best, just as his predecessor did, to foster existing industries and help in the creation of new ones. That is his job. He is the Minister not only of the Parties represented in this Government, but of the Irish people as a whole, including the Deputies on the far side. We have then that much abused Minister, the Minister for Agriculture. He, too, I think, is doing his best in the interests of the farmers, but his work, too, will take time.

The Fianna Fáil Deputies seem to think that the Minister for Agriculture is going out of his way to do things that militate against the best interests of the farmers. Now, I come from a county in which mixed farming is carried on very extensively. Like other members of the House, I meet many farmers from time to time, and I must say that in the County Louth I have heard no undue criticism either of the work of the Department of Agriculture or of the Government as a whole. I cannot understand where some Deputies get their information. They seem to meet people who are always complaining. It may be that those people are different from the people of the County Louth. I know that, as far as the farmers in Louth are concerned, and indeed farmers all over the country, the position is this, that while there may be certain things about which they are a bit annoyed at the moment, their income does not seem to have decreased to any appreciable extent last year as compared with previous years. I want to substantiate that statement by referring to the statements made by the various chairmen at the annual meetings of the joint stock banks. I am sure nobody will suggest that they are telling lies or making false reports. It will be seen from these annual reports that the deposits in the banks were greater last year than during any previous year. In view of the fact that agriculture is our chief industry, one must assume that a great part of those moneys put on deposit came from the farmers. We should be all proud of that fact and should not try to minimise it. Neither should we criticise the Minister because of the fact that a particular person happens to be in that position at the moment.

So far as I can see production seems to have increased considerably in many spheres of agriculture. Poultry is a case in point. That is an industry that has always yielded a considerable income the whole year round. The production of poultry has increased to such a large extent that I understand the L.M.S. have had to put on extra cargo boats to meet the demands of the export trade. That is so far as poultry is concerned.

Comment on this

And eggs.

Comment on this

The same is true of eggs. I am sure that a great many people who supported Fianna Fáil at the last election, and were entitled to do so, have benefited from this increased production of eggs and poultry because they knew it was good business. The Minister for Agriculture, realising his responsibilities, is, I think, doing his best. Deputies must agree that so far as he, personally, is concerned he is a hard worker. I do not think his labours are confined to eight hours a day, judging by the close attention he gives to the work of his Department. I think that if he and the other Ministers receive the co-operation which they are entitled to, especially in the case of many schemes which are contemplated and are calculated to increase the productivity of the country, much good can be done for the country. I hope that those schemes will, at least, get the tentative co-operation of the Party opposite and of their supporters in the country. If that is done, much more employment will be provided for the people. I think the Ministers are entitled to that co-operation.

Deputies should remember that we have millions of acres of land going to waste. If they help schemes for the reclamation of that land, so that it may be brought into production, then they will be doing the work they were sent here by the people to do. I think it is bad policy to be magnifying any little shortcomings that there may be in this or in any other Government.

Take housing. I think there has been undue criticism of the policy pursued by the present Minister. In my opinion he is doing his best. I ask Deputies to remember that, even if the country were full of money, we could not build one extra house. We have first to wait for the skilled labour required to do so. That is true, no matter what Minister or what Government is in power. I think Deputy T. Brennan would bear me out on that. It is not a question of money but of getting men to erect the houses. There is only one factor that will solve the housing problem, and that factor is time. It is important to remember that Fianna Fáil, during the greater part of its régime, was engaged in building houses for people who had houses that were not fit to live in. In other words, for every house they built they knocked down one. That is the explanation of the fact that despite all the houses that have been built there still is a scarcity.

The housing problem, as I say, will be solved in time no matter what Government is in power—in one, two, or three years. I do not think it is good policy, because you have a boom in a particular industry for one or two years, that you should take thousands and thousands of people into it, and then at the end have a slump. We had an example of that in the case of the turf industry. As regards housing, we all know that we are not complete masters of the situation here. There are many things required for houses that we have to import. We had shortages during late years.

As regards the position we occupy internationally, I think that our Minister for External Affairs did excellent work during the past year, as did his predecessor. I think we can congratulate ourselves on the position in which the country finds itself at the moment. I do not intend to say much about unemployment. I have expressed my views on it on many occasions in this House. I think that problem will be solved to a certain extent when all, including the workers, recognise that this is a small, poor country, and that it can give a certain standard of living to the majority of its people. We may then be on the road to the solution of the unemployment problem. It will be very difficult, almost impossible, without general co-operation.

The Leader of Fianna Fáil said in this House that he saw no reason why this country would not support 9,000,000 people. I shook my head, because I knew that after a bit he would more or less have to amend that statement. He did so, and all credit to him. It will require the co-operation of everyone in this country to solve unemployment. There is no use in magnifying small aspects, such as a few men being dismissed here and a few being dismissed there. In the building trade we did not wait to be sacked and we did not go to a Minister or a Deputy to complain. We set our chins and took the road to look for another job.

I deplore the tendency in this country lately of people sending word to the Minister to know what he will do because so many men have been dismissed in a particular job. The less a Government interferes with the ordinary affairs of our people the better. Let the people use their own initiative and enterprise and you will find this country will be much better off in the course of a few years. We have to sink or swim together, and make no mistake about that. It does not matter what Government is in power; we have to help one another. This Government in the main will make progress in accordance with the assistance it gets, not alone from those who support it but from Deputies on the opposite benches and above all from the people generally throughout the country.

Comment on this

I listened carefully to Deputy Coburn. He suggested that Deputies on this side of the House should not talk about unemployment and emigration, should not magnify the evils that exist in the country to-day. It is a great pity that Government Deputies did not take up that attitude during the last general election when they attacked Fianna Fáil and tried to persuade the people that the Fianna Fáil Government was responsible for unemployment and emigration and other attendant evils. It now appears, since there has been a change of Government, that we cannot talk about these things at all. The fact of the matter is that there never was such unemployment and never such emigration.

Comment on this

The Deputy should study the 1938 figures. They would be more apt.

Comment on this

The Deputy should permit me to speak; he is very good at interruptions. There was talk about the twin evils of unemployment and emigration. I think it is right to bring to the notice of the Government that these twin evils are greater to-day than they were at any time and the Government apparently has no solution for them.

I have risen particularly to point out to the House that there is a reduction of £20,000 in the Gaeltacht Estimate for Seirbhísí na Gaeltachta. I cannot understand why that is the case, why there is such a reduction in the Gaeltacht Estimate and an increase of £20,000 in the Estimate for the External Affairs Department. I know that it is necessary for this country to follow the trend of external affairs and to play its part in any deliberations and activities that take place between the nations, but I believe that it is much more important for us to look after the interests of the weakest section of our community before we expand our provision for the Estimate for External Affairs.

The people living in the Gaeltacht are the weakest section of the community and any Government in power here should see to it that there is provision made to assist those people. There was a time when there was a Parliamentary Secretary in charge of Seirbhísí na Gaeltachta. I still believe that there should be a Parliamentary Secretary, if not a Minister, in charge of that service.

Comment on this

When was it changed?

Comment on this

That is another matter. Whether there is a Minister or a Parliamentary Secretary in charge of Seirbhísí na Gaeltachta I do not see any justification for a reduction of £20,000. But that is not the whole story. There are other reductions in the Book of Estimates which I hold are completely unjustifiable. They affect the people of the Gaeltacht and the welfare of the Irish language. We have, for instance, a reduction of no less than £64,000 for the glass-house scheme.

Comment on this

We know all about that.

Comment on this

We do not know all about it, because the Minister for Agriculture has given us no information, and neither has the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Your own Minister said it was only nonsense.

Comment on this

When a question was put to the Minister for Agriculture as to whether the glass-house scheme, as it is called, was a success, he said the time had not yet arrived to make a comment. "It is too soon," he said, "to make any comment on the glass-house scheme in the Gaeltacht." It is a pity the Minister did not take up that attitude earlier; at the time when he said that the scheme was a flop and when he called it an exotic scheme. We are still without information as to whether the Government propose to continue the scheme. I am afraid we are inclined to be sceptical when we see that the Estimate has been reduced by no less than £64,000.

There is also in that Book of Estimates a reduction of £3,000 in the scheme which provides grants for Irish-speaking families in the Gaeltacht. There is a reduction of £4,000 in the amount to be made available for Comhdháil Náisiúnta na Gaeilge. If we add these reductions together—the reduction of £20,000 in the Estimate itself, the reduction of £64,000 for the erection of glass-houses in the Gaeltacht, the reduction of £3,000 for Irishspeaking families and £1,000 for Comhdháil Náisiúnta na Gaeilge—we get a grand total of £91,000. It seems to me that the policy of the present Government is to forget about the Gaeltacht and to reduce the Estimates relating both to the Gaeltacht and the Irish language. The moneys so saved may be used for other purposes, but if so, I think that is a bad policy. We all acknowledge that the problem of the Gaeltacht is one that should be tackled. We all believe, or profess to believe, that the people of the Gaeltacht have first claim on our consideration. But we are now reducing the Estimate for that particular service which deals with the Gaeltacht. I think that is an indefensible step.

I cannot understand why the Estimate for the Department of External Affairs should be increased by £20,000. When the Minister is replying, I would like him to give some justification for that increase. I think it would be better for us to keep our eyes on the problems affecting us here at home before we concern ourselves too much with problems abroad.

There are a few other matters to which I would like to advert in connection with this Vote on Account. Reference has been made to unemployment in rural Ireland. The problem of emigration has been mentioned. Lest anybody might think that we refer to these things for political motives, I would like to quote from an independent paper to show the magnitude of the problem and give the House some idea of what the position is in certain parts of rural Ireland. So great has been the increase in unemployment along the western seaboard and especially in the county that I have the honour to represent that The Kerryman thought it advisable to send one of their staff reporters to find out for himself what conditions are. I have here a report published on the 11th December, only a couple of months ago. As far as my knowledge goes, the position is even worse to-day. Yet, the present Government seems to ignore the position. Here is an extract from the report.

Comment on this

What area does it deal with?

Comment on this

Kerry, and Killorglin especially. Here is what the staff reporter found. He found that practically every family in a district adjacent to Killorglin town and extending roughly over five square miles is dependent for existence on remittances sent by relatives in England.

Comment on this

How long are they in England?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will ignore interruptions.

Comment on this

I did not hear the interruption, and I do not know what it was.

Comment on this

Cad is ainm do'n phaipéar?

Comment on this

"An Chiarraíoch." It can hardly be said that The Kerryman is prejudiced against the present Government. Yet this is what the staff reporter found: “In a district adjacent to Killorglin town and extending roughly to five square miles a Kerryman staff reporter this week investigated the conditions under which approximately 10,000 people live and was appalled by the conditions he found existing. He found that practically every family in the area is dependent for existence on remittances sent by relatives from England; that the people were fatalistically accepting the fact that when the youngsters at present at school grow up they too will emigrate and that meanwhile many mouths have to be filled and are being filled with limited rations of bread, tea and potatoes. Meat is a luxury here among these people who during the war years worked on turf schemes estimated to be worth £120,000. We went into cottages at random. The cottages in every case are clean and neatly kept. The children, and they are many, bright and intelligent. There was no complaining here—just a longing that something might be done to provide them with employment at home. A 20-year-old boy who, like every other boy and girl I spoke to, said he was going to England, told me ‘If I could get a job at home I would stay.‘” That is the condition of affairs.

What is true of County Kerry, which I represent, is equally true of many other counties along the western seaboard. There is no work for the people there and they have to emigrate. Emigration is more rife in these counties now than it has ever been. When is the present Government going to bring its plan for stopping emigration into operation? That is the plan we were told about in the last general election. It is about time we heard something more about it. This is not my own statement; therefore, it cannot be said that I am doing this for political purposes. I am giving the House what an independent reporter found for himself. I am giving the House a description of the conditions as he found them. The sooner the Government turns its attention to the people living in these areas the better. I do not know whether any reference has been made so far—if there has I did not hear it— to the question of the price of milk delivered to creameries. I am sure Deputy Madden takes a very keen interest in this question.

Comment on this

Deputy McGrath is glad to hear about this too.

Comment on this

I remember when the last Budget was introduced by the present Minister, Deputy Madden advocated an increase in the price of milk but, so far as I know, the Minister for Finance turned a deaf ear to it. Deputies have been approaching the Minister for Agriculture since and, so far as I can recollect, one deputation made such an impression on the Minister that the Minister was forced to admit that they had a very good case but still there appears to be——

Comment on this

May I point out that that is not quite accurate? The Minister did not express any opinion whatever on the case but he said that he would represent the case as it was put to him to the Executive Council. He expressed no opinion himself. Another Deputy spoke here this afternoon in regard to this matter but I was not in the House to contradict him. The Minister gave no specific promise but said that he would put the case as represented to him to the Executive Council for consideration.

Comment on this

I am thankful to the Deputy for the correction. If I do not mistake, the Deputy was a member of the deputation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would suggest that both Deputy madden and Deputy Kissane will have their opportunity to debate this matter on the Estimate for Agriculture, much more relevantly than now.

Comment on this

I agree and I am not going to pursue the matter except to say that the time has come when the milk position should be reviewed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I thought the Deputy had no more to say on that matter.

Comment on this

I am not going to labour the point. I have said, and I say again, that it appears to me that the present Government are not taking an interest in Gaeltacht problems. Instead of finding a reduction of £20,000 in the Estimate for the Gaeltacht and a reduction of £64,000 for other schemes in connection with the Gaeltacht, we should find an increase if we want to help the people there to exist. I hope that other Deputies who have been listening to my remarks on this question will voice their opinions, because I believe they will say with me, that it is not right to make the weakest section of the community suffer because of this drive for economy.

Comment on this

There is no decrease in employment arising out of the Estimate.

Comment on this

There is a decrease in the Estimate for the Gaeltacht.

Comment on this

Because the stuff that is being bought is cheaper.

Comment on this

If the Department was lucky enough to buy stuff cheaper, it should not, because of that, reduce the Estimate.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy suggest I should do?

Comment on this

I am saying that anyone going into the figures for the Gaeltacht must come to the conclusion that the Estimate is being reduced.

Comment on this

If you buy the same quantity of material at a lower price, you are not reducing the Estimate by cutting down the price.

Comment on this

Does that apply to everything in the Gaeltacht—to the glass-houses, for instance?

Comment on this

The glass-houses are only a cod.

Comment on this

Does the Minister tell us that?

Comment on this

Your own Minister said it.

Comment on this

He never said any such thing.

Comment on this

He did. He said that it was all nonsense.

Comment on this

I repeat that he never said any such thing. That is all I have to say in the matter.

Comment on this

As Deputy Kissane began by referring to the Gaeltacht, I think that perhaps I had better deal with the same question because I represent a Gaeltacht area too. I wonder what his Party did for the Gaeltacht during their period of office. The principal industry in the Gaeltacht would be fishing, and it is the one industry that should have been developed in order to give the people full employment. Yet during all that time, it cannot be contradicted that the fishing industry was entirely neglected. In fact, when this Government took over, it found that the fishermen had no proper gear, scarcely any boats of value and everything was in a deplorable state. Had it not been for the war years, when whatever fish they were able to catch carried a good price, the fishermen in that area would have been drawing unemployment benefit. As a matter of fact, owing to some regulation of the Fianna Fáil Government, they could not even do that. However, that matter has been rectified.

Since the present Minister for Agriculture has taken over control of fisheries, he has made wonderful improvements and has enabled fishermen to get boats and gear on a 20 per cent. deposit whereas under the Fianna Fáil Government, they had to make a 50 per cent. deposit. In fact, the Minister has been so good to the fishermen in the various areas that any fisherman who had proved himself industrious and paid up all his loans in previous years, will not be left without a boat or gear even though at present he may not be able to make any deposit. I think that is a wonderful advantage.

It can be shown by statistics supplied by the Sea Fisheries Asociation that during the past year fishermen have made more money out of their catches and have been more successful than they have been for many years past.

As regards unemployment in the Gaeltacht, there is always a certain amount of unemployment everywhere, and it is no new thing to hear of unemployment in these congested areas. The problem goes back, I suppose, to the time of Cromwell when he pushed the people from the rich lands back amoung the mountains of Kerry and Connaught. The only way they can ever be made prosperous is by removing as many as possible and giving them land where land is available. Emigration has been going on in these areas since the famine years. That is supposed to be the first cause of emigration and we find that down through the years it continued. But, statistics will show that in the year in which the Fianna Fáil Government took office 11,000 more people came into this country than left it. It was only when the so-called economic war started and people could not get a living at home, especially on the land, that emigration started again. Once anything like that starts, when people go away they entice other people at home to follow them. I suppose they paint bright pictures of entertainments and so on in foreign countries. They have a certain amount of money and, for the time being, until perhaps they settle down in life, everything looks bright and prosperous and so others follow them. I know some people in my area, even in Gaeltacht sections of it, who had a good living wage at home and decent employment and yet they gave it up and actually used every means to get released by the labour exchange so that they could go to England or to the United States. Emigration is a rather difficult problem and it will be very difficult to solve and to entice people to turn their minds from foreign countries and settle down at home.

Deputy Kissane read an extract from The Kerryman of 11th December. A staff reporter was reported to have visited that area. As a matter of fact, he was not a staff reporter attached to The Kerryman. He was taken there deliberately by a Fianna Fáil county councillor to write that article. If Deputy Kissane had referred to an article in The Kerryman of the 19th March by a real staff reporter, he would find a very different account of the conditions in that particular area and the whole of South Kerry. I shall not delay the House by giving quotations from it. It is remarkable that Deputy Kissane should pick on that article and not refer to the other.

When the previous Government increased the ordinary housing grants, they forgot to increase the grants for the building of houses in the Gaeltacht. The Minister for Lands recently introduced a Bill which increases these grants for housing in the Gaeltacht not only up to the maximum for ordinary housing, but £25 beyond it. Therefore, I think that, on the whole, ample provision is being made for the people of the Gaeltacht. I understand, of course, that they cannot be made as prosperous as those living on the rich land throughout the country, but, as time goes on and the fishing industry is further developed, I am confident that the people in the Gaeltacht will have cause to be grateful to the present Government.

Anybody listening to the doleful tales of Deputies opposite would think that because they are not in office this country is heading for doom. Deputy Lemass spoke of the distortion by Ministers of information issued by officials of their Departments. In a speech recently in Fermoy he deliberately charged the Minister for External Affairs with submitting wrong information to the United States Government which may be the means of getting for this country greater help under the European Recovery Programme than that to which it would otherwise be entitled. An ex-Minister making a statement like that is really guilty of blackmailing the Government and, to a certain extent, the people of the country.

Deputy Aiken's mind appears to be centred on oats, flax and potatoes. If he had ordinary intelligence it would help him to understand matters of a political and economic nature. The estimate given to him by Ministers regarding agricultural products should satisfy him, as it has satisfied the people of the country. The Deputy manages to forget those agricultural products and the manner of their disposal. He is filled with the fantastic idea that we have illegal organisations in this country. He forgets the time when he himself was connected with these and perhaps he should be the very last man in this House to refer to them.

No matter what Deputies on the opposite side say, the people are perfectly satisfied with practically everything that has been done by the present Government since they came into office. It is a matter of comfort to the taxpayers to find that, for the first time since the establishment of the State, there has been a reduction of taxation. Ever since 1922 it has been mounting up gradually year after year and especially during the period of office of Fianna Fáil. Last year the Minister for Finance managed to reduce it by something between £6,000,000 and £7,000,000. This year, in spite of the increased social services and various other commitments which were handed down to him by the previous Government, it must be a massive satisfaction to the Government's supporters and the people of the country that he was able to bring about that reduction in taxation. I would suggest that if the Fianna Fáil Party had been in power this year the carrying-out of these schemes—land settlement, shortwave stations, turf schemes, the producing of turf for which there was no market—would have increased the taxation of the unfortunate people of this country to about £100,000,000. Notwithstanding all that the opposite Deputies say, the people of this country have an entirely new outlook since the change of Government. I think it is, perhaps, because of that and because of the improvement in the people's condition that the Fianna Fáil Party knows it is losing power in the country, that they have become so soured and are making statements which are anything but the truth. They have a habit recently of starting whispering campaigns, knowing that the people in their innocence may believe them. You can understand the people of this country do not always read the daily papers and the weekly papers and, therefore, it is very easy to make them believe things that are not true. However, they know that they need no longer have any fear of expressing their views, no matter what they are, and that there will be no victimisation of any kind. That was not the case formerly, I am sorry to say. I have had good experience of it. If a man in employment—a postman, ganger or road worker—at any time said anything in opposition to the Government he was a marked man and very soon his position was filled by somebody more sympathetic to the views of Fianna Fáil.

If I may refer to some statements made about Government policy I should like to mention the policy of members of the Opposition and in particular Opposition leaders, in making statements either in this country or in foreign countries during their visits which may be in conflict with Government policy. For instance, Deputy de Valera, as was reported in an American paper, stated in Los Angeles, when he was asked if Partition were abolished would he be willing that the Government in Belfast be allowed to function, that he would, provided that the powers of the English Government were transferred to the Irish Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think that Partition arises on this.

Comment on this

I should like to say that, on the whole, people are quite pleased with the present Government and I think their hope is that it will be many years to come before Fianna Fáil will come back into office. After all, they can now look out into a free clear atmosphere where they can feel sure of having perfect freedom of speech, freedom from want and freedom from fear.

Comment on this

I congratulate the Minister for Agriculture in making his one conversion in this House in the person of the Lord Mayor of Cork. I think he is about the only Deputy in this House who subscribes to the rancher outlook of the present Minister for Agriculture. The Lord Mayor of Cork stated there were too many people on the land. A typical city outlook. I hope that the day will not come when we have a Dáil in this country, as outlined by the Lord Mayor of Cork here to-night, of 65 Deputies with the same views and outlook as the present Minister for Agriculture and himself. In any event, I think it would be an impossibility. I do not believe that if you searched all the zoos in the world you would get 65 of the species.

The present Minister for Agriculture has set out deliberately to turn this country into a cattle ranch for Britain. He has set out deliberately to discourage tillage, to grow more grass, to produce cheaper and more meat for the British market. It was not sufficient to warn the Minister at the time that he negotiated the trade agreement that the British always buy in the cheapest market and that if there is an alternative market cheaper than ours the British will avail of it. That has always been their policy and that is their present-day policy. If the cattle population in other countries which used to compete with us in the British market were up to standard to-day and they could buy there more cheaply, they certainly would not buy from us. The present Minister missed the greatest opportunity of any Minister of any Government in this country of providing employment here and of providing a permanent market for the export of beef from this country. For the first time in the history of this State he had the opportunity of having our live stock slaughtered here, thereby giving the employment that is now given in Birkenhead and elsewhere. He was in the position that he represented a State that had an exportable surplus of meat when the whole of Europe was looking for meat. This matter could not be tackled before because we were dependent more or less on the British market due to our long economic history with Britain, and if they closed down on us as they did during the economic war they could penalise us to a certain degree. However, the present Minister for Agriculture was in the position that he had ample markets for his product. If the British did not want our cattle dead there were various other countries that would take our meat and he let that opportunity slip.

He then came into the House a couple of nights ago and attempted to perpetrate one of the greatest political frauds that were ever attempted in this House. He tried to put over on the Irish housewife that 2/6 a dozen for eggs is better than 3/-. We have been listening to the Minister for Agriculture throughout the last 12 months asking the people to produce more eggs and saying that the more eggs produced the greater the price that would be available. We listened to him when he invited himself to a meeting of the Mayo County Committee of Agriculture recently when he assured the people there, publicly, that the more eggs produced the more money they could get. Can anybody explain why the Minister for Agriculture has accepted this reduction of 6d. a dozen in the price of eggs?

Comment on this

What about next year's price?

Comment on this

Is there any logical reason why the Minister should accept that price? A price of 3/- a dozen was guaranteed under the previous régime. The Minister attempted in the House the other night, in order to cover up his own failure, to put over the idea that a firm bargain was made whereby, at the expiration of a two years' period or on exhaustion of the money supplied for this egg and poultry scheme, we were committed to sell our eggs to Britain at 20/- per great 100. That is an absolute untruth and the Minister knows that quite well. He said here last week:—

"However in 1950 a new price would have to be negotiated and the only assurance we have for that year is that it will not be less than 20/-per long 100 which is about the equivalent of 1/6 a dozen."

What it means to the producer is not material. The fact is that the Minister tried to twist the position under the previous trade agreement in this way that we were committed to sell our eggs after a period of two years at 20/- per long 100. The fact is that we have other markets than Britain. There is Spain for example. When the Minister went over recently he should have known that he was not tied to the British market. Under the agreement negotiated by his predecessor this country was not committed to sell to the British at all after the two year period, or as soon as the amount of money provided by way of subsidisation for this scheme was exhausted. I think I know the real reason why the price of eggs has been reduced by the Minister under the recent trade agreement. The British put up £1,350,000 for this scheme and our Government had to put up a similar amount. Is it because the Minister for Finance has refused to give the Minister for Agriculture the proportionate amount of money to subsidise the scheme on this side that the price has been reduced? I believe that is the true reason why the Minister for Agriculture was forced to go over and accept 2/6 per dozen for Irish eggs after guaranteeing publicly in written articles and notably in the article published in P.E.P. last May, that the more eggs the Irish housewife produced the more money would be available for her. Our egg producers have got a rude awakening in this matter as well as in many others from the present Minister for Agriculture.

A few nights ago, when complaints were made here about the price of milk and the condition of the dairying industry, the Minister for Agriculture tried to flood us with statistics to prove something that everybody knows to be untrue. I am not concerned with the dairying industry because we have no creameries in our part of the country, but there is a problem there that is prevalent in every town in the West of Ireland. The position there is that it is impossible to get milk. Milk is rationed in virtually every town in the County Mayo that I am familiar with. I can tell the Minister that, during the last month, there were several prosecutions for black marketing milk in Westport. Does he think that we live in the moon, or that the consumers of milk in those towns are going to pay more than the fixed price for it if there is milk available for them to buy, or if there is competition between milk producers? The fact is that the Minister's policy is driving dairy farmers out of production in the West of Ireland. These farmers have to meet increased costings and increased wages. All costs in connection with the milk industry have been increased, and yet the Minister has refused to do anything about the matter.

The position is that the unfortunate people in the towns there have to take a pint of milk where they expected to get a quart because the dairy farmers have been driven out of production and are not in a position to meet the demand. I do not know what the Minister proposes to do about that. If he thinks that by coming into the House and by waving his arms, as he did the other night, he can put over the statement that there is no such thing as a scarcity of milk in the country he is just fooling.

He also told us that there was an increase in pig production. In 1947, before ever he became Minister for Agriculture, every curing company in the country knew that, once feeding stuffs became available, the pig population was going to increase and was, in fact, on the increase. Everybody connected with the bacon industry and with the production of pigs knows that the production of pigs in any one year is based on the sow service of the previous year. The margin of error in regard to that is never more than 10 per cent. The Pigs and Bacon Commission could have told the Minister that, and I am sure they did. The sow service of the previous year indicated that we were going to have more pigs, and, goodness knows that was needed, since under the Minister's policy the bottom had fallen out of the market for oats and potatoes. The pigs are there and there will be more of them. The Minister was informed over 12 months ago by the people in the industry that the bacon requirements of the country would be met and that the chances were that we would have an exportable surplus even by the end of this year. He quoted figures the other night to show that once Deputy James Dillon walked into the seat of the Minister for Agriculture pigs would suddenly multiply at the wave of his wand, and that suddenly we would have the pigs producing bonhams and bacon porkers. One, of course, knows that is all codology. All that one has to do is to point out the falsity of those figures, especially to city Deputies who may not understand the position as well as those of us who come from the country.

I would like to point out that the first great fraud perpetrated by the present Government on the people of this country was the promise that was made on the abolition of the turf scheme. In the area that I represent, when that scheme was in operation, the people were getting as much as £200,000 a year for hand-won turf, and we had over 5,000 people employed. When those people were thrown out of employment we were told that work would be provided for them on the roads. The Minister for Local Government said that he would employ all the people who were employed at turf work on work that would be met by special grants. In the County Mayo we were gravely affected by the discontinuance of the turf scheme. It meant as I have said the earning of £200,000 a year on the turf that was produced by the Mayo County Council, irrespective of what was earned by private producers. There were over 5,000 employed. They were thrown on the dole. In substitution of that work on turf production, we were offered the magnificent grant of £17,000 by the Minister for Local Government, provided the ratepayers in the county put up another £6,000 or £8,000. Even if the ratepayers in the county blistered themselves to put up that amount of money, in addition to the sum promised by the Minister for Local Government, the result would be that it would not mean three days' work in the week for the 5,000 people displaced. The Mayo County Council, irrespective of Party or politics, told the Minister in no uncertain terms that he might as well try to empty the ocean as to try and replace the £200,000 that was being earned by the people heretofore on the turf schemes by his grant of over £17,000. At all events, the promise then was— it was the first great fraudulent promise to those unfortunate people—that they would be all absorbed, through these grants, by the work on the roads. No work came their way and the result was that they emigrated in thousands.

We reached the unfortunate position that during the past 12 months, under the present Government's rule, the emigration figure in County Mayo hit the new high level of 4,430, an increase of virtually 1,000 on the figure for the previous year. That does not represent the true figure, because any Deputy familiar with the people going out knows—and the figure that I have given does not cover it—that quite a lot of them go on what are termed holiday passports. They get a travel permit purporting to go out on a holiday in order to get out quicker and not be stultified, when they go over, by being tied to any particular job. The 4,430 emigrants who left Mayo do not represent the total number who emigrated from that county.

Comment on this

It is a pity you did not take the £18,000 you were offered; it would have saved some of them from emigrating.

Comment on this

I could refer the Parliamentary Secretary to his colleague, Deputy Commons, one of his backbenchers, or to his ex-friend, Mr. Dominick Cafferky, a former member of this House, and various other members of the Mayo County Council who were just as adamant as I was in refusing the paltry few pounds the Minister sent as a bluff on the turf workers.

Comment on this

The £18,000 offer was not bad at all and you were foolish not to take it.

Comment on this

You have to take the responsibility of driving out of employment in Mayo the 5,000 who were employed on schemes there. You are endeavouring to insult the intelligence of the representatives of all parties on the Mayo County Council who informed the Government of the position there.

The next great fraud perpetrated on the people by the Government was the cut in the road grants. In my constituency the amount we lose is something over £47,000.

Comment on this

When will the expenditure of that money begin?

Comment on this

I cannot hear the Deputy. The official interrupter of Fine Gael had better get his throat looked after.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

There are none so deaf as those who will not hear.

Comment on this

This year in County Mayo we lost approximately £47,000, due to the cut in the road grant by the Minister for Local Government. I wonder is that a reflection of Government policy? Will the Government continue to take away from the congested areas one of the few sources of employment that the people there have? In Mayo and in the West generally our roads were not restored to the condition they were in before the war. We were not in a position to avail fully of the grants available from the present Ministers' predecessors. The result is that many of our roads are in a bad way. Our unemployment and congestion problem being what it is, one would imagine that the Western representatives in the Government parties would press particularly for the grants to be left as they were.

Comment on this

Surely, if Mayo could not avail of the grants during that period it is the fault of the last Government?

Comment on this

No, sir. The money was provided for us in County Mayo the same as for every other county, but during that period there was a shortage of certain types of road material and that was one of the reasons why we could not complete our programme under the previous grants. Again, during part of that time we were engaged in major turf production. At that time a certain amount of labour was not available. There were various reasons why we were not able to spend the full amount available to us under the previous grants and we were not in a position to bring our roads up to the condition that we could have brought them to had we been able to avail of the same grants this year as we had in other years. There was no indication by the previous Government that there would be a reduction in these grants.

The suggestion that this is only a temporary measure will not wash. It was never indicated by the previous Minister that councils would be sent back to 40 per cent; it was never indicated to any county council that we could not look forward this year to the very same grants as we got in other years. So much was opinion to the contrary that in our county we prepared the estimates on the same basis as they were prepared last year. No one had any idea of a change and then we got this extraordinary circular from the Minister for Local Government, presumably dictated by the Minister for Finance, telling us that he was not allowed to spend the same money on roads as was spent by Fianna Fáil. The result is that we will have greater emigration from the west and more unemployment, the twin hall-marks that the Coalition are leaving on the congested areas.

Some of the Government's supporters, particularly Deputies from my own county, decided, when a motion was put down here a couple of weeks ago, that they would have to support the Government on this issue. They went against the express instructions of their own council. They went into the Division Lobby and voted to deprive County Mayo of this £47,000. The excuse they gave when they went back to Mayo County Council was, in the case of Deputy Commons, that he could not catch the Speaker's eye, but he could enter the Division Lobby on the side of the Government. Deputy Browne told the council that he had fallen for the Minister for Agriculture's new scheme, that everybody will be employed under the £40,000,000 drainage scheme.

First we had the promise bluffing the turf workers that there would be work for them on the roads, and, secondly, we had the position that the road work is being wiped out. The people are now being asked to swallow a new pill, that everybody will be employed on this £40,000,000 drainage scheme. It is difficult to know much about this drainage scheme beyond the fact that the Minister says the money will be expended over ten years. I want to put it on record for the benefit of the Deputies on the Government Benches who voted for the cutting of the grant for Mayo County Council that Mayo is not one of the counties in which this scheme is going to be put into operation. According to the Minister's statement, not even the Minister himself appears to know when this scheme will commence in the west of Ireland. I wonder what our unemployed are going to do? I wonder what the people will do who used to work on the roads and on the bogs while the Minister for Agriculture is making up his mind as whether it is in 1952, 1953 or 1958 that this scheme will come into operation in the west of Ireland.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Does the Deputy admit we will be here in 1958?

Comment on this

I have been here longer than Deputy Collins has been. I am very much afraid for the future. I think it was Deputy Collins who described the present Minister for Finance the other night as a wizard.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You must be getting hard of hearing.

Comment on this

I do not know what particular type of wizard he is. The 4,430 people he has driven out of County Mayo and the 18,000 on the bread line would hardly regard the present Minister for Finance as a wizard. They certainly could not regard him as the Wizard of Oz. He will certainly be a wizard if he succeeds in getting the Deputy and some of the other boys behind him into this House again in 12 months' time if the Irish people get a chance of doing anything about it.

Comment on this

And keep you over there.

Comment on this

I want now to refer to that colossal monument of Irish efficiency—the Irish Land Commission— with its present Minister for Lands. Prior to the election Deputy Blowick, as he then was, gave an interview to the Sunday Independent in which he set out his policy. That policy can be summarised under four main points. He wanted new legislation to deal with congestion; he was going to give cheap fertilisers and plenty of them; he was going to derate the first £20 on agricultural land; and he was going to make the town tenants the owners of their own homes. I want to know what has the Minister for Lands done in connection with this new legislation, if new legislation is necessary to deal with the problem of congestion. Prior to the election the Minister for Lands said that the problem of congestion in the West of Ireland could be solved in 12 months, and that what was wrong then was that the Fianna Fáil Ministers were lazy and sufficient money was not provided for the Land Commission. The Minister has been in office now for 12 months and, to use Deputy Commons' own words the other night, he has done nothing and the Land Commission has done nothing. If new legislation was necessary why has the Minister not introduced it in the past 15 months? This Government will certainly not go down in history as one that flooded Dáil Eireann with legislation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot advocate legislation on this Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I am merely saying that the Minister for Lands held that some legislation was necessary and I am pointing out that no legislation has been introduced even though there was ample time in which to do so. He told the electors that he was going to provide cheap fertilisers. Instead of that the subsidy has been reduced by £329,000. That is the way in which the Minister for Lands has implemented his promise to make cheap fertilisers available to the farmers in order to restore fertility to the soil. He was going to derate agricultural land up to the first £20. He has been, to use the Minister for Agriculture's expression, as mute as mice on that question since he took office. I have heard nothing about any legislation where town tenants are concerned.

On the 6th May, 1947, at column 2182 of the Official Report, Deputy Blowick, as he then was, said:

"Are we to leave 23,400 people in Mayo, not to speak of people in other parts of the country, to eke out an existence on holdings with such low valuations? They are to exist there, get married and rear their children for export. Is that the Government policy?"

He then goes on to ask:

"Is the export of human beings to go on because no attempt will be made to solve the land problem?"

Comment on this

To what is he referring?

Comment on this

I am quoting from a speech made here by the present Minister for Lands on 6th May, 1947.

Comment on this

To what is he referring?

Comment on this

He was referring to congestion in the West of Ireland. I am referring to it now.

Comment on this

So those conditions did exist under Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

"Is the export of human beings to go on because no attempt will be made to solve the land problem? Instead of asking for £1,140,000 it would be far better business if the Minister asked for £7,000,000 and kept doing so for the next eight or ten years. Then an end of the problem might be in sight." Further on he said:

"It strikes me very forcibly that the Minister for Lands is not as forceful in making his demands as the Minister for Lands each year at the appropriate time, as the Minister for Defence or the Minister for Industry and Commerce in putting forward demands for their Departments. I wonder is the failure to deal with this question with sufficient speed due to that inactivity of the Minister for Lands? I wonder is he taking his office in a too lackadaisical fashion, in not demanding sufficient money for his Department? At the present rate of progress, the Land Commission would not have the land question settled for the next 120 years. That is a very glaring state of affairs for a responsible Government Department. They seem to be in the position of a person with his hands tied behind his back."

Not alone has the present Minister got his hands tied behind his back but the Minister has been tied hand and foot since he took office. What has he done to relieve congestion? According to the Minister himself during his 15 months in office he has removed only two families out of the congested areas. Those families went to farms which were prepared by the Minister's predecessor. The Minister has moved two families out of approximately 23,500 in County Mayo. If that is the Minister's rate of progress it will take him 2,400 years to do the job which he accused his predecessor of taking 120 years to do. Possibly that may solve the Minister's problem because there will be no people to take out then. The Minister is quite aware of that. We have listened in the past to the Minister ranting from public platforms and in this House about the operations of the Land Commission in bygone years. The Minister may suggest now that there is no land. Let me quote for him from the new republican issue of the Irish Independent of January 15th, 1949. This is not that terrible paper, the Irish Press. In that issue of January 15th there are farms advertised in Leinster over the name of one auctioneer alone comprising 1,487 acres. In the same issue, there are farms advertised by other auctioneers in Leinster to the extent of 1,893 acres while there are lands advertised to be let for grazing to the extent of 664 acres.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What has the Minister to do with that?

Comment on this

I am pointing out to the Minister that there are lands available there and I want to find out what is Government policy on this question of land settlement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Clearly it is not the business of the Minister to prevent people offering their land for sale.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that it is the duty of the Minister to find out if lands are available.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It clearly is not the duty of the Minister to prevent any individual from offering his land for sale. The Deputy will pass from that.

Comment on this

May I make this point on the question of relevancy? Surely, if the Minister says that land is not available, am I not entitled to point out where land is available?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are discussing major policy and not matters of detailed administration.

Comment on this

I suggest that I am entitled on this Vote to deal with the question of congestion in the West and the question of the acquisition of land for the migration of tenants.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise on this Vote. It is not the duty of any Minister to prevent anybody from advertising land for sale. Does the Deputy suggest that he should read the advertisements in all the papers of the country in which land is offered for sale?

Comment on this

No. I am merely pointing out that there was a total of over 4,000 acres available for the Minister and you see——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Having said that the Deputy must now pass from the matter.

Comment on this

Very good. I can point out this, that on one particular date in the Province of Leinster there were 4,044 acres of land offered for sale and they are available to the Minister for Lands if he wants to acquire them for the relief of congestion. I want to point out that that amount of land would be sufficient to give 25 acres to each of the 160 Clann na Talmhan Secretaries in South Mayo, if they were migrated to it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will pass from that aspect of it now.

Comment on this

Very good. In passing from that aspect, I can point this out to the Minister for Lands. If the Minister for Lands is sending his minions round the West of Ireland taking two acres, three acres and four acres, here and there, principally from his political opponents, even if all these two, three and four acres were acquired by the Land Commission, it could not affect the problem of congestion in South Mayo.

Comment on this
Joseph Blowick Minister for Lands (Mr. Blowick) Clann na Talmhan

On a point of order, I put it to you, Sir, that you should not allow the suggestion contained in the Deputy's last remark to pass—that I am sending inspectors deliberately to my political opponents. That is a very serious charge and, whether you view it or not in that way, I take a very serious view of it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it that it is the statutory duty of the Land Commission to distribute land and it is the Land Commission that is responsible for sending around inspectors so that the reference to the Minister is totally outside the scope of the debate.

Comment on this

May I say, that I am not satisfied with that? I ask for an unqualified withdrawal of the statement or else that the Deputy should be asked to prove the charge. I respectfully suggest, Sir, that the Deputy should be asked to make an unqualified withdrawal of the statement.

Comment on this
A Deputy

It is a slander.

Comment on this

The Deputy can press for an inquiry if he wishes to prove that statement. If that charge be true, I am not fit to retain office for one minute more.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister has no responsibility in this matter.

Comment on this

I respectfully submit that that does not arise. What I am pointing out is that the Deputy made a very serious charge and I am afraid that I shall have to press you to ask him for an unqualified withdrawal or else that the Deputy take steps to prove his charge.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I want to get this point cleared first: Is it the Land Commission which sends round inspectors?

Comment on this

The inspectors are sent out at the discretion of the commissioners. The Minister or no representative man has, or should have, any authority in that matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I wanted that made clear. The Land Commission is responsible in that matter.

Comment on this

It is time some of the Deputies over there realised that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Land Commission is the only authority to send out inspectors——

Comment on this

On certain work.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has stated that the Minister has sent round his inspectors to people who differ from him in politics. The Deputy knows that is not so and I must ask him to withdraw that statement.

Comment on this

If the Chair says so, I must withdraw it but I may point out——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will point out nothing. He will either withdraw the statement or sit down.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is responsible for the acts of his officials?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

For the last time, the Deputy will withdraw the statement.

Comment on this

I have withdrawn it. I do not want to infringe on the ruling of the Chair but is the Minister not responsible to the House for his Department and for his officials?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is responsible to the House for the administration of the Department of Lands.

Comment on this

On the question of Government policy, if it is Government policy, we have officials going round County Mayo inspecting plots of three acres and four acres and small back stripes as they are called. If everyone of these little patches were acquired that is not going to make any impression on the problem of congestion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have allowed the Deputy a good deal of latitude but he has travelled far from the subjects that may be discussed on the Vote of Account. He knows perfectly well that a detailed discussion of that kind properly arises on the Estimate for the Land Commission. He will pass from that now to matters of major policy.

Comment on this

I want to point out, on the question of major policy, and I hope that I am not infringing the ruling of the Chair on this occasion, that I quoted what the Minister stated when he said that there should be at least £7,000,000 paid by the Exchequer for expenditure on this particular Department. Yet the figures this year are exactly the same as last year, with the exception of £100,000 and the major portion of that is not money expended on Land Commission schemes. It is represented by the increase in the cost of labour or the increase in Civil Service salaries. Therefore the Minister who now occupies the position of Minister for Lands, the very man who demanded £7,000,000 for the Irish Land Commission some years ago, is quite content now to sit back when the very same figure, a reduced figure, is provided for the Land Commission. There was reason for a reduced figure as the Minister well knows for the Land Commission during the emergency, because the Land Commission staff was sent off to the Department of Supplies and other Departments and the normal functions of the Land Commission could not be proceeded with. The Minister has not that excuse. The Minister has got back his staff and still we are dealing with this comparatively small amount being expended on the most vital of our Departments, namely, the Land Commission, when, on the Minister's own statement, it requires at least £7,000,000 to make any headway with the problems confronting him. I think it is obvious that, either before he became Minister he was speaking with his tongue in his cheek, or now, as he said about his predecessor, he is not sufficiently energetic in pressing the claims of the Land Commission and the other sections catered for by the Land Commission, particularly in the congested districts.

I know that the Minister is quite well able to get round this matter. Prior to the last election, he told us that not alone should a certain amount of money be spent by the Land Commission, but that the annuities collected for the land should be devoted to the work of the Land Commission. He has travelled a very long way since then. I am also convinced, and I think every Deputy irrespective of Party who comes from the west is convinced, that if you wanted to have a picture painted of Irish inefficiency and you imported one of the French Surrealists and he painted 26 Upper Merrion Street, there is not a backward farmer in Ireland who would not recognise it for what it is—a monument to Irish inefficiency. Unless the Minister bestirs himself, and I press on his colleagues to put some pressure on him, we shall still be talking our heads off about this problem for the next 20 years or, at the Minister's rate of progress of two people a year from the West of Ireland, it will take another 2,400 years.

I did not intend to say anything about the Government's policy in the matter of health and hospitalisation until I listened to the Minister for External Affairs to-day. Here again we come back to the spider-like figure of the present Minister for Finance floating over the national treasury and refusing money for these vital services. Deputies on the opposite side of the House are also aware that the Minister for Health, presumably speaking on behalf of the Government—if any Minister does—declared war on the county homes in this country. He came down to the west of Ireland and attacked the county homes and some hospitals we had there. My council decided to try and do something about our county homes in Mayo and went to the trouble of getting an architect to prepare plans. We came along to the Minister for Health, with all his high-sounding remarks which appear to signify nothing, looking for money, and he told us that if we wanted to do anything the ratepayers should provide the money. He pressed us to turn the county hospital into a training school for nurses. He knows just as well as any of us in Mayo that the hospital is overcrowded and that an extension of the nurses' home is required, which would cost approximately £30,000. When we came as an all-Party deputation to the Minister for Health, he blandly informed us that if we want to do this vital work we have got to find the money.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is not that health administration?

Comment on this

No. With respect, I submit that this is Government policy in refusing to provide the finance for these vital services.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is speaking on the administration of the Department of Health. That would arise ordinarily on the Estimate for the Department of Health.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

After 16 years the Deputy found out.

Comment on this

I do not know if that is the Labour Deputy, or if it is his colleague, who has provided a new excuse for the migration of the people he is supposed to represent—the Irish wild geese. He might direct his attention to bringing some pressure to bear on the people whom he is keeping in office, because only for the Deputy and some other stupid fools of his calibre behind him, sitting there as mute as mice, this Government would not be inflicted on this State.

Comment on this
Joseph Blowick Minister for Lands (Mr. Blowick) Clann na Talmhan

On a point of order. Is the Deputy in order in referring to those who sit behind Ministers on the Government side as fools? The point I am interested in is whether the Chair sees fit to allow that word to become an ordinary word in Parliamentary usage.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is entirely undesirable.

Comment on this

If the level of language used is to descend that low, the House will soon earn for itself the name of a tinker's camp.

Comment on this

I would prefer the Deputy should develop the question of the county homes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not in order.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary was saying something. I am being continually interrupted.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not being continually interrupted. The Deputy ought to proceed with his statement and avoid words which do not bring credit to this Dáil.

Comment on this

Very good. If I did use any words to which exception is taken, I can only plead that it has been due to interruptions from the gentlemen opposite. I warn the Minister for Finance that, if he continues with his present policy, if all State expenditure is to be curtailed irrespective of the effect it is having on the employment of our people, if schemes inaugurated by the previous Government are being done away with simply because they were inaugurated by them and for no other reason, if he continues on that path and if he is left long enough there, he will do the State irreparable damage. When we get an opportunity of dealing with the Estimates we will be in a position then to point out some of the things, particularly with regard to the congested areas, that evidently I am precluded from dealing with on this Vote.

Comment on this

Listening to some of the Deputies on the opposite side, it seems to me perfectly clear that they are more interested in Party politics than the welfare of the people in rural Ireland. The previous speaker drew attention to various points in connection with agriculture. So much has been said on that matter that I do not intend to go into it very deeply. I should like, however, to refer to two points. He spoke about the prices of eggs in his own area. He maintained that there should be a bigger price given. Yet his fellow Deputies representing various towns and cities are complaining about the cost of living. With regard to local government, I notice that the Deputy did not say very much about housing. Deputy Burke spoke about it the other night. Naturally each one of us is interested in his own constituency and in his own county. I want to say that we in South Cork, at any rate, are very pleased at the way housing is going on at the present time.

The previous speaker again laid emphasis on the question of the turf scheme. Must it be for ever in this House a question of Party politics? Twelve months ago this question was dragged out again and at that time we clearly pointed out the fact that it was the previous Government who brought the hand-won turf scheme to an end through the circulars issued from the Department to the various local county councils in this country. If Deputy Moran is unable to recall such a thing —I presume he is on the local council —it is just too bad for him. I can say, at any rate, that the people in County Cork are fully aware of it. In connection with the hand-won turf scheme naturally we are interested to see work going on as far as possible. One thing which strikes me very clearly is that during the emergency the price was enormous and the people found it very difficult to get turf at the price, yet at the present time under the present regime in Cork City turf can be brought in at 32/- per ton delivered.

The Deputy mentioned, also, the question of road grants and so forth. Again I should like to draw attention to the fact that no matter what Government is in power in this country in all local matters including roads, a great responsibility must, of necessity, rest with the local council. No matter what Government is in power, if Parties through the local county councils are trying to obstruct and to offer criticism which is of a destructive nature no one in this country will fail to realise what is behind it. Perhaps it may be indifferent to members of this house, but if the people in the country could but realise the waste of time by Deputies talking about things time by Deputies talking about things outside the country which they must know in their hearts is false from the start, they would have a vastly different opinion from the one they have.

With regard to the question of the road grants, at the present time it is not very clear what is going to be lost. In fact, we do not yet know whether there will be a loss or not. However, I should like to remind the Opposition again when they speak of the grants that we do know that they were not going to continue giving the grants on the same scale themselves. I should like to draw attention to the fact that two years ago, or a little over, we were told in the council by a circular from the Department of Local Government and, furthermore, were threatened afterwards, that if we did not spend £18,000 to £20,000 in mapping the main roads for the improved carriageways for tourists that even the grants we were getting then would be stopped. That has not been the case with the present regime at any rate. Even on this side of the House we realise it is our duty to offer criticism when it is necessary, provided it is of a constructive nature. If, however, any Party or any member believes that the constituencies they represent are going to gain anything by Party quibbling in this House in years to come a poor view will be taken of their attitude at the present time.

Considering that this debate has dragged on for so many days already and at enormous expense any other remarks I wish to make I shall make on the Estimates dealing with the Departments when I shall criticise if I feel I am entitled to. However, I assure the House that such criticism will definitely be of a constructive nature.

Comment on this

The debate on the Vote on Account this year has been carried on in a bad spirit, a spirit for which there was no need at all. I am satisfied that if Fianna Fáil put in as much energy during the last sixteen years in solving the problems of this country as they have during this debate they would have had the same success as the inter-Party Government has. Fianna Fáil should get away from the idea of attacking the inter-Party Government. They should realise that the people rejected them and not the inter-Party Government. I must congratulate the Government for the very peaceful state of the country. For about 25 or 30 years we have generally had some class of political turmoil every other year but all this year we have had perfect peace in all parts of the country, thanks to the spirit and the good-will that the Government has shown to all the different political parties. The inter-Party Government is, as we all know only on a try-out. Fianna Fáil strongly object to it but I suggest that as the first inter-Party Government it should get a fair trial. As far as I have seen during the last twelve months it has worked very well and smoothly and produced good results. I think it is entitled to the respect of the people and of Fianna Fáil. The inter-Party Government is new to Irish politics. It may be of immense benefit to this country and it is only right that it should get its trial. Fianna Fáil are attacking the present Government all over the country for not having solved all the problems in front of them. They are attacking them over emigration, employment, afforestation and all those vast schemes which they themselves spent sixteen years trying to tackle and never solved. It is unfair of the Opposition to do that. They know that no Government, can solve in 12 months the problems that have confronted the country for the past 200 years. Emigration is the major problem. It is the canker that has taken the life out of this country. It will take superhuman efforts on the part of any Government and it will also test the resources of this nation to stop it. I am satisfied that the schemes initiated by the present Government are laying the foundations of the stamping out of emigration. I would ask the Deputies to realise that when a change of Government takes place it also means a change of policy. The policy of Fianna Fáil was very grandiose and high-falutin. They were up in the air, up in the clouds. Big things were all they wanted but they did not realise that the plain man out of the bogs and hills and out of the country towns counted more than the big men at the top. That is how they lost control of Irish affairs. Thanks to their foresight the present Government is starting at the bottom and is trying to give a fair chance to the underdog and that is what should happen. It has brought immense benefits to the aged, sick and blind and resources are being spent to alleviate the sufferings of those people.

Fianna Fáil must realise that they left some bad legacies to the present Government, such as the legacy of the bankrupt Córas Iompair Éireann. In that case the present Government has to find millions of pounds in order to put our transport system in a proper working order and no thanks to the past Government. They should also realise that £8,000 or £10,000 of the people's money has to be spent on the fuel dumps in the park. That is more waste of public money and bad foresight by the past Government. Fianna Fáil should realise that these are the headaches which they left behind them. It will take big money and resources to solve those problems. During the last 12 months there have been greater achievements in this country. We have brought perfect peace to our people; we have brought freedom and there is no quibbling about votes and so forth. We have brought about what I think is of more benefit to the country than anything else and that is the freedom of the farmers from the shackles which Fianna Fáil put on them.

The farmer to-day is a free man and he can now work with a free will. In addition to that the Minister for Agriculture has brought about a four years' stable market so that the farmer can see four years ahead with a reasonable chance of good prices in that four years. He can lay down his policy and know that at the end of four years he will know where he stands. We had not that in the past. In addition, we have a housing programme in progress of which any Government can be proud. In the towns and villages vast schemes of house building are going ahead and are being intensified every day. The more contractors we can get the more houses we can build. The Minister for Finance is prepared to spend money on housing. It is a thing which will bring great benefit to the people.

The Estimates this year are being reduced by over £6,000,000. The Minister for Finance reduced them by a similar sum last year when he was only a month in office. That is what we want instead of the squandermania that went on before. The people are very thankful that there was a change of Government. They do not want the high-falutin nonsense that had been going on, the "Constellation" aeroplanes, the high and mighty spending, the big dinners and great speeches about things all over the world. What the people down the country want to talk about is their way of life. That was all forgotten by Fianna Fáil. In regard to the major problems before the country, there is not so much dividing Fianna Fáil from this side of the House except that they want to pretend that there is. Afforestation, drainage and the stemming of emigration are three major problems. If we are all Irishmen and brothers we should try to tackle these problems. There may be a difference as to the best way of doing so, but surely we can agree to differ.

There is no use in Fianna Fáil bawling and ranting that the country is doomed, and that emigration is on the increase. I am not going to say that this Government has stemmed emigration. We could not do it in one year, but I believe the back will be broken in it within, say, five years. I do not believe you can have any such thing as the complete stemming of emigration. There should not be that either. People in the past emigrated to Australia, Canada, America and Britain. They were quite entitled to do so. Many of my own people, and many of my neighbours in the County Meath did so, and all of them did well in America, Canada and other countries. If freedom is freedom, then people are free to go away if they like. One thing is certain and it is that the vast schemes initiated by the present Government are well calculated to stem emigration. It is proposed to spend over £40,000,000 on vast schemes of land reclamation, field drainage, afforestation, bog developments, etc. These will afford employment for our people, so much that I think many of those who went across to Britain will be required to come back and give a hand. I believe they will be glad to engage on work in their native land.

The problems that are to be undertaken are certainly of vast magnitude. They are being pressed forward by men of vigour and experience. Some of the members of the present Government held office in a previous Government and have learned from their successes and their failures. Some of the chief men in Government to-day were in Government more than 17 or 18 years ago. They have learned from their own mistakes in the past and from the mistakes of Fianna Fáil and are in the position to build on a good foundation. I believe they are doing that. The policy that is being initiated by the Minister for Agriculture is one that holds out great hopes for the farmers and farm labourers. He has stepped up production in the case of pigs, poultry, butter and milk. The farmers are quite content. They are happy under the Government and they are not worried or trembling as Fianna Fáil has suggested. They know what the policy of the Government is for the next four years. They have their coats off and they are working hard laying down their economy in their own way without interference from the Government or from anybody else.

One of the Deputies for whom I have great respect is Deputy M. O'Reilly, who comes from my own county. He is a man that I seldom differ from because I believe he is a decent gentleman. But I certainly found it hard to believe that it was Deputy O'Reilly who was talking when he made the speech that he made on this Vote. He made a nonsensical speech, coming as he did from the County Meath. He said that 40 per cent. of the land there that used to be set on the 11 months' system could not be set this year, and that there was starvation in many homes in that county. I say that is a falsehood. As regards the land that is let there on the 11 months' system, I know that quite a number of people who used to take it held back this year because they thought that the price asked for it, compared with last year, was a bit too high. The Deputy forgot to tell us why the land was not being set. It was because of the good prices for store cattle that people were afraid to pay the high prices asked for letting. For that reason they were hesitant in taking the land. I want to tell him that 99 per cent. of that land is let to-day at reasonably good prices, and that it is well stocked. I do not think the Minister for Lands was in the House when that statement was made. But what would he think if he were? He would think that we were driving the Meath men out of Meath, and that it would be necessary to have another drive of migrants from the west. He might think that Deputy O'Reilly was not a Meath man. I would ask the Deputy to restrain himself a bit in future and not make such an opening for the Minister for Lands. We certainly had enough migration in the last 16 years, but if the Minister were to accept Deputy O'Reilly's statement it might be that the drive would be doubled in the future.

We have been told that under the present Government a certain amount of money has been set aside to build a memorial to the memory of Griffith and Collins. Who could object to that? Why should we not do that—put up a memorial to two of the greatest patriots that this country ever produced? They gave their lives that we might live in freedom. I am not worried about stone memorials. I am more concerned to see Ireland built up on a basis that will give us peace, contentment and prosperity, that will help to increase the population, that will give our people a better living than they had in the past and that will enable large families to be well reared, educated and properly disciplined. That is the kind of memorial we want here. The present Government are laying the foundations of peace and prosperity. If they follow the policy they have pursued during the last 12 months, then at the end of five years we will have a memorial that will be worthy of our patriots.

A Government's duty is to hold the balance evenly between all classes of the people. I am satisfied this Government is doing that. It is helping the farmer; it is cutting down waste; it is cutting down unnecessary Estimates and, on the other hand, increasing the Estimates where that is required. In the past this country was run for politics and for politics solely. Politics has been the curse of this country. It has left us with a dead-weight debt of £120,000,000. Emigration was not being stemmed and, as Deputy O'Reilly has said, there were men hungry in the country. We are now getting away from all that and are facing realities. The more we work the more we will have. This country is initiating schemes of national progress, schemes which will develop our national resources, that will build up our industrial life and strengthen our agricultural arm.

Let us get all the industries we can started on the basis that agriculture is the key, the pivot, of our whole life. The present Government are working on that basis. If we can attain that, I am satisfied that Fianna Fáil, instead of attacking us as they did during the past year, will have to change their tactics. If the present Government keep building in the same way as they are building now, and if Fianna Fáil continue their present tactics, then Fianna Fáil will be a small Party in this country five years from now.

I will say to the former Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, that he speaks in a reasonable way in debate. He may be able to use words with four or five meanings—he is a terrible man at that —but he is very reasoned in debate. I hope he will ask some of his front and back benchers to modify their conduct, to behave themselves and to realise that they are living in a country that needs the help of every man so that we may raise it to a standard it never reached before. The chance has come our way now and if we do not take it we may not, perhaps, ever get such a chance again.

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this