We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 29—Agriculture (Resumed)

Contributions 1–203 of 627. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

When progress was reported last night, I was proceeding to refer to some matters, arising on the Minister's Estimate, that have reference to the farm improvement scheme. I was trying to get some information from the Minister with reference to that scheme in the coming year. The Minister informed us that instead of what I suppose he would call the little farm improvement schemes that we had in operation for a number of years, he was going to put into operation this year a scheme costing £40,000,000. Will the Minister tell me when the full details of that scheme will be published.

Comment on this
James Matthew Dillon Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Dillon) Independent

I understood there was agreement that, inasmuch as that scheme might be the subject of legislation, we were not going to discuss it on this Estimate. I am in the hands of the Chair.

Comment on this

There is no agreement whatever.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is a difference, of course, between discussing the subject matter of a scheme and advocating legislation.

Comment on this

I do not propose to discuss legislation. Nobody could do that since we have not yet seen it. I simply propose to ask the Minister certain questions. He told the House, when introducing his Estimate, that he proposed to abolish the farm improvement scheme as it was known and to substitute something else for it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy understands that he cannot ex-pressely advocate legislation on an Estimate.

Comment on this

There is no question of legislation at all in this matter. I question whether any legislation is needed at all to continue the farm improvement scheme, and I question my right to raise this matter.

Comment on this

So do we.

Comment on this

On numerous occasions during the past year the Minister who is responsible for this Vote thought fit to speak on this proposed scheme. I take it that he was speaking as Minister for Agriculture when he announced more particulars about this proposed scheme. He told the farmers of the country about the good days that were in store for them under this proposed scheme, and he told the workers of the country all the extra labour that would be provided under it. I think that Deputies are within their rights on this Estimate in making reference to that scheme.

I should be glad if the Minister would give the House and the country some information as soon as possible on this proposed scheme. When will details of the scheme be published, and what proportion of money will be given by way of subsidy on lime, either ground or burnt lime? What amount of money will be spent in the present year on it? What amount by way of subsidy on artificial manures will be spent on it in the present year, and, generally, how much does the Minister estimate will be spent on the scheme this year? These are all very pertinent questions about which the public at large will need information.

How much does the Minister estimate will be spent in wages, and how much on workers who have become unemployed as a result of the Minister's policy and of the policy of his Government? These are all important matters on which I think the public should have some information, particularly if the Minister proposes to do away with the farm improvement scheme which, generally speaking, was a popular scheme amongst the farming community. Under it a lot of good and useful work was done on the land and farms of the country over a number of years. This House, before it agrees to vote money to the Minister for the coming year, would like to have some information as to what his proposals are for replacing the farm improvement scheme. Whether the House approves of his proposals or otherwise, it surely is entitled to have some outline of the details of this proposed scheme.

I should also like to refer to the question of oats, and as to how the muddle in regard to it has been dealt with. There are some burning questions arising out of the oats muddle. Will the Minister tell the House what he has done with the oats that he has purchased? I understand it is all lying on the merchants' hands still. Did the Minister provide any moneys to help the merchants to purchase that oats? Is the Minister aware that the money used to purchase that oats was largely borrowed money, and that the merchants are awaiting, the liquidation of the Minister's promise to take the oats off their hands? Many of them are anxiously wondering how long more they will have to wait, and how long that corn will be left on their hands, as well as when the Minister will make an advance to them, if he has not already done so, to cover their capital costs. This is a very important matter for a number of responsible citizens in this country.

I should also like to know if the Minister is aware that, in the spring of 1948, many corn merchants gave seed oats to farmers on credit out of moneys which they had received, by way of overdraft, from their bankers? Is the Minister further aware that, in the harvest of 1948, many of those merchants who had given seed oats on credit to farmers did not come under the Minister's scheme, and did not get licences to buy oats? Is he aware that those merchants are still waiting to be paid for the seed oats they advanced in 1948? These are all questions that I want the Minister to answer.

I suppose the Minister is aware that oats is being exported to the Continent and, while we are exporting oats, we are continuing to buy maize with borrowed money. Is that a good agricultural or national policy? Does the Minister ever stop for a moment to consider that aspect of the matter? We are selling oats to continental countries— I do not know whether it means a profit to this country or not—and at the same time we are borrowing dollars to buy maize meal, which is being retailed at 25/- to 27/- a cwt. —not around the £ at all. Is it good policy to continue to borrow money in order to bring maize from the ends of the earth to this country——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Towards the end of the first hour of Deputy Allen's speech he dealt with this at length—the relative value of maize. He is now starting the third hour of his speech with a recapitulation of those views. Is that repetition in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Repetition is not in order, but the Chair is not convinced that Deputy Allen is repeating himself.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen did not make previously the points he is now making.

Comment on this

Now that the Minister has raised this matter, I would like to bring to the notice of the Chair that in probably less than one and a half hours yesterday evening the Minister, while I was speaking, interrupted 113 times—over a century of interruptions in a little over an hour, or more than one for each minute.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Interruptions are not peculiar to either side of the House.

Comment on this

But the majority of them come when any Deputy on this side is speaking. There is one other matter to which I would like the Minister to give a little attention. Representations have been made to me and to other Deputies within the past few days by people who have farmers' butter on hands to the effect that a cheap cocoanut oil as a substitute for fats is being extensively imported and is being used for the same purpose for which farmers' butter is used—that is, for making confectionery. This practice is preventing farmers' butter being sold to the confectioners who formerly used it. It is drying up the market, cutting out the farmers' butter from the home market. This foreign product bought with dollars is cutting out the farmers' product from the home market. It is a serious matter. The farmers have the butter in their dairies and they are not finding buyers. The cocoanut oil substitute is one of the factors that has brought that about and I hope the Minister will take some action.

We hope in the coming year that the Minister's policy will bring happier results to those engaged in agriculture. Schemes were already prepared when the Minister took over control. There was little or no alteration needed in any direction and those schemes were definitely meant for the benefit of agriculture. Everything would have been all right but for the muddling of the Minister or his Department, and the advice which he gave to the farmers. The Fianna Fáil agricultural policy was a sound one. It has been proved sound in so far as the Minister has adopted it. Where it was allowed to operate freely it has served this country well; but to the extent that the Minister has interfered with it, either in relation to tillage or otherwise, he has damaged the interests of agriculture. He has put numerous people out of employment and injured the income of the farmer in the past year. The country hopes that in the coming year he will direct his energies to see that the sound national policy that was in operation under the previous administration will be carried out to the full and it is to be hoped also that he will not interfere so as to damage it further.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Deputy Con Lehane hesitated to follow Deputy Burke into the labyrinths of his mind. I would hesitate to follow Deputy Allen in his many divergencies and amazing tangents. He spoke of muddle in the Department of Agriculture. He had not to suffer listening to himself while he muddled and floundered in the most extraordinary flights of stupidity, criticising our agricultural policy. Tempted as I might be, having listened to two former Ministers for Agriculture, to be facetious, I hope in the course of my contribution to this debate to discuss in a calm way with the Minister aspects of his policy on which we might possibly be at variance. I, like any other member of the House, occasionally feel I have a better slant on a certain section of agricultural policy than the Minister, and for what it is worth I will discuss in that spirit certain aspects of the Minister's policy.

I will start with milk. There was a time when I was absolutely convinced that an increase in the price of milk was an imperative necessity. I feel the Minister has been able to offset the necessity for that by the increase in the various prices of other agricultural commodities during the year. There is a lot of sound reasoning in the statement that the price of calves has so appreciated that it offsets any hardship that might have been caused by the stable price of milk. However, I would ask the Minister, particularly now that we have arrived at the happy stage where there will be a surplus of butter, to consider milk from another angle, to consider, if it were possible, limiting the use of milk by the creameries to supply home market needs only and converting the surplus milk into more remunerative types of export than butter would be. The Minister is aware that there are forms in which milk can be exported other than as butter, and from the point of view of the milk producer they would be more remunerative.

I have not been able to work out a scheme, but if the Minister is faced with having to export surplus butter at a subsidised price to England it might be better if he were to divert the surplus milk into other channels so that it could be exported as chocolate crumb or possibly as liquid milk. That might be more remunerative for the producer. I think the House must feel satisfied that the Minister has succeeded in giving an impetus to agriculture that will benefit the country as a whole. It may be honest to say that there were many factors which contributed to this impetus. I do not think, however, that it is anything other than petty hate and intense personal jealousy, as is evidenced in the case of at least one of the Minister's predecessors in office, or sheer political expediency which completely overlooks the fact that, no matter what circumstances may have been in the last year, the prime and most important factor was that the Minister for Agriculture was Deputy Dillon.

The cattle population of this country is showing a gratifying upward trend. I know discussion on the cattle population is rather a sore point with the Opposition because it took many years of bitter experience to make the Fianna Fáil Party revert to the common-sense practical view of developing the maximum possible trade at the maximum possible remunerative benefit to our own people with the English market. The Fianna Fáil Party meandered around the Continent of Europe looking for other markets. They did not get them. Now, because in an extraordinary situation it might be possible, if one were sufficiently shortsighted, to exploit a temporary shortage on the Continent that Party is crying out because it is not done. Mark this. If we were to play with that folly in this Government there is nothing surer than that when the continental situation had cleared itself the continental buyers would laugh at us and we would find ourselves forced into the unwelcome position of having to go—as the present opposition Party often did go—hat in hand to beg for something.

Let us be rational and reasonable in our approach to agriculture. Your nearest and most readily available market is England. There you have a consumer who can consume without any trouble more than we shall ever be able to produce. Why not adhere then to what I believe should be the political watchword of the country; repair the ravages of the past by selling England as much as we can as often as we can and as dear as we can? That is my simple approach to the English market. Let nobody think for a moment that my heart is aflame with any love for England. But I believe that the more money we can make out of England the better it shall be for our agricultural community.

I am glad that the Minister is taking a realistic view of the urgent necessity for veterinary research in connection with the various diseases that arise in this country. Some people condemn expenditure of that nature. I think it is only right that all the aids of modern science should be brought to the assistance of the agricultural community. It is nearly always that section of the agricultural community that can least bear the loss of a cow, a bullock, a heifer, a sheep or a pig that suffers most intensely when disease breaks out among animals. To these people veterinary research that will lead to the extermination or prevention of disease is a tremendous boon. I hope that the Minister will go even further than he has done. I think the agricultural community should have veterinary services available to them in the same way as the ordinary people have medical services available to them. I hope that the Minister's scheme, when it ultimately comes to fruition, will make veterinary services available to those who can afford them at a moderate fee and to those who cannot afford them without any fee at all. If the burden of this country is to be carried successfully in its economic revival, it must be carried by our primary producers. We all know that our primary producers are the agricultural community. Veterinary services given in the way I have indicated will repay themselves one hundredfold in the gradual decline of mortality and the ultimate improvement of our stock. In that particular line of work I say to the Minister: "God-speed to his work." I urge upon the Minister the utmost expedition in bringing this scheme to completion throughout the country.

Again, let us be reasonable and rational in our approach to the problem of tillage. Cries of lamentation and weird rumblings of dire distress were heard and crocodile tears, such as only Deputy Burke can shed, were shed on the abolition of compulsory tillage. Yet, the amazing fact remains that this year the amount of tillage is very little less than it was when compulsion was in force. I hazard the guess that the ultimate yield this year, if we have any kind of reasonable weather between this and harvest time, will be better than it was during compulsion. I firmly believe there is no tougher or cannier businessman in this country than the farmer. If he finds there is profit for him in tillage he will do it far more readily than he will under all the compulsion in the world. Going through the country on my way to my own constituency, I pass through the major portion of the country. I am gratified on my journeys to see all the evidence that the plough is as busy this year as it ever was. All these vapourings about the unemployment arising from the abolition of compulsory tillage and the emigrant ships should be given the lie to now once and for all. Much of the unemployment that has arisen is paper unemployment. Where genuine unemployment has arisen the steps proposed by the Minister in his land reclamation scheme hold out a prospect of more employment in rural Ireland in the future than has ever been held out in the past. I would urge upon the Minister that he should find some way of encouraging, if necessary by an increase in price, the milk producer. He is the basis on which our cattle trade is built. He has been clamouring for an increased price in milk. If an increase is not feasible I urge upon the Minister that, instead of using milk for the production of an exportable surplus of butter, he should divert its use into other channels which might make for an increase in the general price of milk on an over-all basis without in any way affecting the price that the consumer in either the city or the urban area has to pay for it.

I was rather amused at the confusion the Minister's answer to Deputy Smith on the poultry question caused the Deputy to-day. I was not really surprised because the very nature of the question led me to the inevitable conclusion that Deputy Smith did not know what he was asking about or did not understand where the question led. He wants us, as reasonable people, to draw a very sinister inference from the fact that the Minister, instead of continuing for a very limited period a price of 3/- a dozen for eggs and then allowing the whole egg situation to go "phut" until the price fell to about 1/6 a dozen, negotiated an arrangement by which, for a period of over two years, there will be a stabilised price of 2/6. Because the Minister took the situation firmly in hands in that way, the Deputy wants us to draw some sinister influence from it. The only inference I can take from it is that his successor in office was able to bring about a greater increase in poultry and in the production of eggs in this country than the Deputy, in his wildest dreams, could have imagined. That is the simple answer to your egg worry. I am happy, representing a constituency that has a very large poultry population, to endorse thoroughly and without any qualification, the courageous action of the Minister in taking that step because I know the lamentations that would have arisen if, at the end of about next August, the bounty or the subsidy of the British having been exhausted, the price of eggs fell to 1/3 or 1/4 for the farmer's wife.

I think the time has come when we in this country, planning the agriculture of the community, must do it, not on the basis of profits in a scarcity market or profits in a difficulty but on the basis of a long-term sensible approach, to give the farmer a reasonable choice of crops to choose from and a reasonable choice of the type of live stock to feed, so that he himself in his judgment can go in year after year or by biennial periods, for what form of agriculture he feels would be most remunerative. I do not think we are doing the farming community any good unless we, in a constructive way, try to suggest how the farmer can better his margin of profit. I think the only service we can do in this Dáil is, in a unified way, to encourage him rather than just indulge, as we have been doing in this Estimate, in tirades of vulgar abuse either of the Minister personally or of some alleged mistake that is not a mistake at all, but a misunderstanding of the situation by a befuddled Opposition.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy will give a good example of that in future.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Deputy Burke asked who started the economic war. He should go and ask his colleague, Deputy Erskine Childers, who said he started the economic war and carried it on. We might then have fewer stupid interruptions from him.

Comment on this

I am referring to your vulgarity in the House yesterday.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

When I called you a sanctimonious old cod? What else are you? —a sanctimonious old hypocrite.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies must refrain from these recriminations across the floor and address the Chair only.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I am very glad to see the return of bacon to shops in this country. I am even more glad to see poor old Deputy Burke picking up a little bit of courage at last and that he is raising his voice now and again. Let me say to the Minister that I think he has reason now to gloat over the jibes and sneers of people when he said he was going to tackle the black market in bacon. He tackled it with more courage than the Opposition can appreciate and the patent fact now remains that there is more bacon in this country. I was delighted to hear the Minister say that we may be able to export bacon before the end of the year. That is something about which some Fianna Fáil Deputies might sit down, scratch their heads and do a little bit of thinking. Some of the rackets that have been growing up in this country——

Comment on this

What are the rackets?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

One was the millers and the other was in reference to bacon. There is another and more welcome side to that. It leads to a more pleasant and more cheerful week's purchase from the housekeeper's point of view. I must say to the Minister on behalf of the harassed housewives of this country: "Well done; we have a rasher at last."

Comment on this

And flour at 7/-a stone. The housekeepers are delighted with that too.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

When the old cuckoo over there has stopped, I shall continue.

Comment on this

Or the barrel organ over there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Calling names across the floor of the House is not calculated to lend dignity to this Chamber and it should be discontinued.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I did not wish any discredit or discourtesy to the cuckoo when I referred to the Deputy as one.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not going to repeat these observations by entering on explanations. The Deputy must cease calling names across the floor of the House. There is a particular form laid down for debate in this Chamber and it must be observed.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I just want to make this further point. It is gratifying to people who have an intelligent approach to agriculture to see that at last we are tackling the problem at its very roots. I congratulate the Minister on the foresight he has displayed and I wish to see a very rapid implementation of the recommendations contained in the Holmes Report. I think that the Minister is absolutely right in getting down to the problem of putting the land itself right, because if he does that production will right itself without any trouble. I welcome the drive to improve the soil of this country. I think the Minister should in all ways be encouraged to keep at experimentation and tests until he gets back into the soil the maximum heart and the maximum fertility. I hope his new land reclamation scheme will permit not only the draining and reclaiming of bad land, the removal of scrub and unnecessary fences and things of that nature, but that it will extend to putting back into heart the better land of this country that compulsion and stupid carelessness allowed to go out of heart very much. I do not blame any Administration completely for the fact that there has been a deterioration in the actual soil value of much of the land of this country. I think emergency conditions forced an overuse of land and that was contributed to in no small way by the fact that there was a lot of absentee landlordism in this country for a long time so that the land was used to the full and as little as possible was put back. I think we can all be adamant on one thing, that it is necessary, urgently necessary, for the Minister to tackle the problem of increasing the value of the land to the maximum. When that is done I have no hesitation in believing that production will follow the trend of the land itself. The better the land, the better the grass; the better the actual land used for tillage after being put into heart by fertilisers, either artificial or natural, the better the yield is going to be, the better the profits will ultimately be and, in the final analysis, the greater the wealth for the country generally. I welcome honestly and wholeheartedly this drive towards putting the land itself back into heart.

I would say to the Minister: Go further. I do not think this House would quibble in any way about giving him further moneys if he finds it necessary for additional proper soil-testing stations and for proper large-scale experiments with grass. I think the Minister has the nucleus of a rational, sensible, sound, national policy in the pretty little saying of the late Paddy Hogan: "One more cow, one more sow, one more acre under the plough." I think his drive for the actual strengthening of the land itself will give him more and more readily the realisation of that hope.

I want to say that the Minister has one failing in common with myself. He likes to say things in a very effective, and sometimes in a very dramatic, manner. I hope his launching of the land reclamation scheme is going to be effective and dramatic and is going to embrace all types of land in this country. Instead of in any way injuring Deputy Smith's conception of the farm improvement scheme and that type of scheme, I hope that it will only serve by its magnitude to enhance the value of that germ that came from Deputy Smith's brain during his period of office and that the land reclamation scheme will serve in its final realisation to leave on the escutcheon of the Ministers for Agriculture of this country the name of Deputy Smith—if that would gratify his hurt spirit.

I want to say to the Minister that no matter what we may say about any individual branch of agriculture, I am glad to report that in my constituency the general farm income is better. It may be that the farmers are not getting as much for their milk as they think they should get, but there is some general compensation in an increase in other prices and the over-all income of the farmer is better than it has been before. No matter what particular small issue may be raised, I can tell the Minister quite honestly on behalf of my constituents, that they feel that the impetus is upwards and that they know that they have more money. It is gratifying to go back into some of the parishes in my constituency and see that the farmers— not big farmers because we have not very big farmers in West Cork—are now able to afford a little van to take their produce to the local market, or the milk to the creameries, and on a wet morning they are able to run the children to school in the van, too.

Comment on this

I wonder does the Deputy realise what a cod he is.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I wonder does Deputy Burke realise that his interruption is disorderly.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I think this is a very good and welcome trend and I give it to you, Mr. Minister, as an encouragement to have the courage—as we have reason to know you have—to keep on in spite of fogs of vituperation and stupid laceration by a disgruntled and a distorted opposition. Keep on, because if you ever conceive the idea that you will please all the farmers of the country you will be fit for an establishment other than the Dáil. As long as you keep pleasing them where it counts most by adding to the profit of their farms, that long and only that long will you redound to the credit of this country as somebody who faced the problem of putting the primary producer in the best possible position and of making the people of this country realise quickly that the boy from the country is not either a yob or a gom but that he and his farm labourer are, as they should be and as please God they always will be, the real aristocrats of this country.

Comment on this

All the farmers of West Cork have vans now.

Comment on this

Listening to the speeches made by the vast majority of those on the Government Benches, where exactly is the Minister going to find himself? If they come from a dairying district, I notice that they start off by telling the Minister that the dairy farmers are most unsatisfied with their present position with regard to the price of milk. Then, like Deputy Collins, they switch from that to saying that the Minister has offset this by the general increase in prices to the agricultural producer. Of course, most of the Deputies I have heard speaking from the opposite benches are not farmers at all. I do not think I could call Deputy Collins a farmer or Deputy Rooney or Deputy O'Higgins. Most of those whom I have heard cannot be termed farmers and I do not think they know anything at all about farming.

To my mind, when this Estimate is under discussion it should be discussed under two headings. We should be in a position to separate the question of grasslands and live stock from what, in my own part of the country at any rate, is clearly understood by the word "agriculture." An agricultural farmer in my part of the country is a man who works his land with a plough and horses or with a tractor, and produces food from the land. A man who goes in for live stock is in most cases called a grazier or a rancher. That is why, in order to know exactly what type of farmer those people are speaking for, I suggest that the Estimate should be divided into two different headings. We might then be in a position to know along what lines most Deputies are trying to concentrate their energies or their efforts.

Deputy Collins has told us about the increase in the price of other agricultural produce. I happen to come from a part of the country where a very small farmer produces seven, eight or nine acres of potatoes — potatoes known as certified seed. After the certified seed is selected, he is faced with the problem of getting away his ware potatoes. I would like if Deputy Collins could tell me what increase that farmer has got this year in the price of the ware potatoes that he has for sale. I would even like him to tell me at this particular moment where he might get a market for them. The Minister made great claims here about a year ago and told us that we had now a guaranteed market for all these commodities, that he had made arrangements for the disposal of 50,000 tons of potatoes to the British at £10 13s. 6d. a ton. I would like to know if anybody who has been praising the Minister can point out one farmer who has got anything in the neighbourhood of £10 13s. 6d. a ton. The Minister went further and said it was for the period November to February and that from February to May the price would be £11 8s. 6d.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

From the Minister's speech, as reported in col. 2596 of the Official Debates, Volume 111.

Comment on this

It is a good job you had that, or the Minister would have denied he said it.

Comment on this

He has heard it often enough in the House to know what I was quoting from. No matter how often a thing is quoted to the Minister he tries to quibble and find some easy way out in order to hide his mistakes.

Comment on this

But the Deputy has misquoted. Come, come! The Deputy must learn to read. Come, now. Let the Deputy read on.

Comment on this

£10 13s. 6d. per ton.

Comment on this

Did the Minister not promise that? Did he not tell the House——

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Deputy purports to read the Official Report and he is, apparently, deliberately seeking to misrepresent its contents. The paragraph he purports to quote reads:—

"There is a guaranteed market for 50,000 tons of ware potatoes in Great Britain at £10 13s. 6d. per ton delivered f.o.b. at a port in Ireland."

There was no suggestion that there was a market for them at the farmer's farm at that price.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy purports to quote he must quote exactly what is in the document.

Comment on this

Is it not lucky that I had the Official Report?

Comment on this

I have quoted, anyhow, £10 13s. 6d. per ton.

Comment on this

Very well, f.o.b. I remember distinctly putting a question to the Minister at that particular time, and he will find it in the Official Reports of this House, asking him to tell us then and there what price the farmer would get, but he shelved that question, as he has shelved many other questions since that it is important for the farmers to know. He did not tell us at any time what price the farmer would get, but this looked very nice and was something in the way of a nice bait for the farmer to swallow. It gave him the idea, as it gave to Deputies, that there was a market at £10 13s. 6d. per ton. I knew we could not get it. I am glad the Minister has come out, even at this particular stage, to admit that he knew very well he was only fooling the farmers when he told them that. He knows very well that the price was around £8 a ton, and he knows they cannot get £5 a ton now, that they cannot get a market at all for potatoes at this particular moment. It was the same way as regards oats. The Deputy Collinses and Deputy O'Higginses and the rest of them who sit behind him there do not know a skillet from a skib. They try to tell us he is a powerful man and that he has done marvellous things.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

He has done a damn sight more than the Deputy.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would take that thundering big voice of his outside and let the debate be carried on, we might proceed more intelligently.

Comment on this

Stop the growling now.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Do you hear my bold cousin over there?

Comment on this

"Grow oats," said the Minister, "grow all the oats that your land can produce and you will sell it profitably, either in the bags or on the hoof." Deputy Collins, of course, did not try to tell us, when he said we had got the increase in other ways, what the profitable price for the oats is that the Minister told the farmers to grow. He did not tell us where the market is for it. He listened, as I did, to the Minister answering the farmers who came up here on a deputation to him from farmers' organisations—I think it was Clann na Talmhan who were at the head of the deputation—asking what they would do with the oats. He said:—

"Go home and thatch the stacks and you will get the price later on."

What advice is he going to give at a later stage, when the oats is still unsold? Of course, he imported maize meal. Deputy Allen dealt with that in detail last night. I listened here attentively to a speech by Deputy Rooney the other evening. Deputy Rooney is another of the Deputy Collins type of farmer—I understand he is an insurance broker.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

What kind of farmer are you?

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for a Deputy to speak here about the professions of Deputies? Every Deputy is sent here by his constituents to do the business of the House, and I think that his profession should not be mentioned in the debate.

Comment on this

That is a lecture to the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair does not take it as a lecture. The Chair would say that a great many of the things stated, while not absolutely disorderly, should not be stated. Most of the interruptions should be avoided definitely by every side of the House. To refer to a Deputy's professional occupation is not in itself disorderly, but it is undesirable.

Comment on this

When an ignorant remark is thrown across the floor by a Deputy like Deputy Collins——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us pass on to the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

I would like Deputy Cowan at least to be honest to all sides, and——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us have a discussion of the Department of Agriculture and not a discussion of the disorder.

Comment on this

I think I am entitled to make my point. I made a reference to individuals——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That point has been decided. The Deputy will return to the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

I listened to Deputy Rooney and it struck me that what Deputy Rooney should do is to have a record made of the speech he delivered here, the same speech as we have heard time and time again—I have heard it six or eight times—and then all he need do is play it over here. When the Deputy has heard it a certain number of times, he will realise that there are a number of errors here and there in it and that, if these errors were corrected, his speech would sound a little better at some later date. He told us that when we started to produce food for the country at the beginning of the emergency we had nothing but a few worn-out horses and went on to talk of the great steps this Minister has taken to provide the farmers with machinery. I should like to know what steps the Minister has taken to provide us with machinery. I have heard Deputies who claim to represent the farming community asking day after day when the Minister would make even loans available and the Minister has completely refused to do so. What are the steps which we are told by Deputy Rooney and others the Minister has taken to make machinery available to the farmers?

Deputy Rooney told us about tomatoes and he spoke of the price of tomatoes in 1937 and in this year. Is he aware that, in 1937, there were very few tomato houses erected in the country, and, when he gives us huge figures of imports in that year as against this year, does he not know that the number of tomato houses in existence was so few that our requirements here could not possibly be met? Is he not aware that every time tomato production went up, the necessary protection was given to the grower by the Fianna Fáil Government, and is he not also aware that the only Minister who refused point-blank to give protection to the tomato growers is the Minister who now holds the office of Minister for Agriculture?

That Minister when sitting on this side of the House tried to convey the impression to people inside and outside the House that he was a mighty strong man who would smash to smithereens any obstacles that came in his path, but quite recently we saw a very delicate looking, feeble type of individual frighten the heart out of him. We saw the Minister for Finance coming with his economic axe in his fist, and, holding it up to the Minister's nose, saying: "Mr. Dillon, if you do not severely and drastically cut down the subsidies given to the farmers in respect of artificial manures and other things, I will deal with you." The Minister fell before the Minister for Finance and said: "Very well; I will give way", and thousands and thousands of pounds were taken from the farmers and handed over to the Minister for Finance to be used for purposes which are not by any means beneficial or helpful to the farming community.

One of the things in respect of which the Minister gave way was the subsidy which was made available by Fianna Fáil for artificial manures. The Minister went to the trouble of bringing in foreign experts to examine the land and to tell us what condition it was in and they reported that it was starved of phosphates and other artificial manures. One would imagine that the first step that would have been taken by the Minister would have been to encourage the farmers by all means at his disposal to put more phosphates into their land, to purchase all the superphosphate they could lay their hands on and to put it on the land to bring back its fertility.

Comment on this

That is precisely what they did.

Comment on this

Precisely what they did, but what was the Minister's contribution towards helping them to do that? He removed the subsidy made available by Fianna Fáil to help them to purchase cheaper artificial manures in order to do the work which the experts who were brought in said should be done. Is that not the help the farmers got from the Minister?

Comment on this

No shame at all.

Comment on this

The Minister said last night that Fianna Fáil did not spend any of this money, but, as Fianna Fáil were out of office, there was no Fianna Fáil Minister to spend it. The Fianna Fáil Minister had been replaced by the Minister who now occupies the post. The money was made available and provided for in our Estimates, but not one farthing was spent by the Minister in doing what the experts said should be done to bring the land back into fertility. Some Deputy last night said that the price of pigs had dropped and the Minister said it had not. I can tell the Minister that I was at a fair in Tuam a few weeks ago, and, in the course of two hours, I saw pigs drop from 19/6 to 18/- per stone. At this fair, where there was a fairly reasonable supply of pigs, there were only four people in the market to buy them.

Comment on this

They had all gone away.

Comment on this

I do not think we will ask Deputy O'Leary to step into this matter at all. If he wants to make a speech, he can do so. The Minister advocated the use of lime by farmers and I have been listening to the Minister for a long time telling us about all the new industries he intends to start in making more lime available. I suggest that the means of producing all the burnt lime we require are already in existence—the machinery is there.

We have the greatest lime kilns in the world lying idle for about nine months of the year. I ask the Minister has he got around to seeing where they are. I do not think he knows they exist. I will tell the Minister where he will find them. In each of the beet factories there is one of the most up-todate lime kilns, capable of turning out thousands of tons of lime per week and these are used for only a couple of months of the year. Did the Minister ever consider asking the sugar company if they would work those kilns in the off season. That would be a very brilliant idea. I think the sugar company have offered their services to farmers to facilitate them in every way. If the Minister were to approach them now, they would probably use these kilns all the year.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us why they did not use them for the last ten years?

Comment on this

I am making the suggestion to the Minister now. He says that he is going to establish lime kilns. I put the suggestion to him now, whatever about the last ten years. As the Minister knows, coke was not available.

Comment on this

We had turf.

Comment on this

Coke was not available and the Minister knows that as well as I do. Let him not be quibbling all the time. Let him be a small bit honest at some time. The Minister's encouragement to people to collect lime was indicated very clearly in this House on the 14th December, 1948. At that particular time the Minister abused an organisation who had done their utmost to encourage farmers, in the West of Ireland at any rate, to lime their land. The people I refer to are the Beet Growers' Association. Ten or 12 years ago, the vast majority of farmers did not think that lime served any useful purpose in increasing output. The Chairman of the Tuam Beet Growers' Association was the first to carry out experiments. He even got the sugar company to send out their agricultural advisers to examine and report on the experiments he had carried out. The Minister should know as well as I do that from that day on every effort was made by the Beet Growers' Association to encourage the use of lime all over the country and the first efforts were made to get the factory waste lime distributed. The Minister thought fit to abuse this particular association in this House, knowing that they were not here and that they had no means of defending themselves.

Comment on this

Was not Deputy Corry here?

Comment on this

I am leaving Deputy Corry out of this altogether.

Comment on this

He is a big man in the beet growers.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry was in the House and was able to defend himself. The people I am referring to were not. I am proposing to give the Minister some idea of what their attitude was and how he has actually slandered them. The Minister's statements are on the records of this House. At the time he told us that they had made every effort to try to—he almost said "prohibit"—the farmers in the West of Ireland using waste lime.

Comment on this

"Almost" is good.

Comment on this

The Minister did not use the word "prohibit". That is the only difference. He went further. He went on to say that the Galway County Committee of Agriculture had tried to subsidise lime which was being given for nothing to the farmers—the usual quibble, of course, of this particular Minister. No greater falsehood ever issued from the lips of any individual. That was never done by the county committee of agriculture and the Beet Growers' Association never advised people in the West of Ireland not to take waste lime. What the County Committee of Agriculture in Galway did was quite a different thing.

The waste lime in the factory of Tuam is in two different forms, as the Minister knows, and up to a distance of 20 miles it can be delivered by the factory in their own lorries. For distances over 20 miles the carriage is exceptionally heavy and what the Galway County Committee of Agriculture tried to do was entirely different from what the Minister said. They tried to see if there were ways or means by which they could help to subsidise the carriage of the lime for distances of 20, 30 or 40 miles and they asked for information from the Department in that connection. That is what they did. Was there anything wrong in that?

There was a pile of lime lying in a silo. Our efforts were directed to getting it from there on to the land all over the country, not merely around the beet factory. These efforts were made by the association with the object of getting the farmers to avail of the waste lime. There was hardly a year that there were not three or four efforts made by the Tuam Board of the Beet Growers' Association to advertise in every possible way the use of factory waste lime and to educate the farmers in the importance of putting it on to their lands and to show them the results that had been obtained by experiment.

I do not want to go any further into this matter. I just want to make it clear that the Minister did definitely blackguard an association that had been making an honest effort to do for the people they represent what they thought was a good day's work. When the Minister tried, for political purposes, to convey the impression that that association had been working, perhaps, as he said, in the interests of some individual rather than in the interests of the community as a whole, he was stating what he knew to be false and a complete misrepresentation of the whole position.

Deputy M. O'Reilly took the Chair.

Comment on this

Did they succeed in getting them to take the lime?

Comment on this

No. The lime is there yet. There are thousands of tons of waste lime in the factory in Tuam.

Comment on this

For nothing?

Comment on this

Yes, except to pay the carriage. I do not know whether the Deputy understands the kind of lime it is. It is sludge lime—about 60 per cent. of it is moisture in wet weather.

Comment on this

It is beneficial, but they will not take it?

Comment on this

Farmers within a certain distance of the factory will take it but it is uneconomic for people who live outside a certain radius of the factory to take it.

Comment on this

They tried to get the farmers to take it and they did not succeed?

Comment on this

They are taking it now to a greater extent than in days gone by but that state of affairs has not come about without effort. The Deputy who is sitting beside the Minister at the moment, Deputy Donnellan, is well aware of the efforts which were made by the Beet Growers' Association to have the lime taken. He should have advised the Minister not to make such silly statements.

Comment on this

Deputy Killilea, you are an honest man. You believe anything you hear.

Comment on this

There is not a statement I have made which I cannot stand over. If the Minister thinks that there is, he is entitled to say so. I notice he is behaving in a rather silly way about it. He can whisper back to the Deputies behind him.

Comment on this

Ninety per cent. of what the Deputy has said in the last ten minutes is wholly untrue. I did not bother to contradict him because everybody knows it.

Comment on this

I challenge the Minister to come anywhere he likes—to any public meeting in Tuam or elsewhere— and have the facts thrashed out between himself and anybody he chooses. I should like the Beet Growers' Association to be represented there. We shall then see who is telling the truth and who is telling a lie.

Comment on this

That is a fair offer.

Comment on this

The Minister has in his records at this particular moment details of the efforts made by the county committee of agriculture not to subsidise lime, which he has said in this House they were getting for nothing, but to subsidise the carriage of lime over 20 miles. Does the Minister deny that that is true? Those are the statements I have made. The Minister might at some particular stage be prepared to listen to reason. If there was anything like ordinary decency about him he would at this stage apologise for the statements he made and which he knows were absolutely untrue.

Several other matters were dealt with by the Deputies on the back benches on the other side of the House. They referred to the economic war——

Comment on this

What did Deputy Childers say about it?

Comment on this

I was interested in what Deputy Rooney said. I have made a study of the people who gave assistance to and helped to bring about a successful end to that particular fight when it was on and of many of the things that have led to the particular state we find ourselves in to-day. I do not think the economic war was fought solely for the retention of the land annuities. I consider that the whole political situation at that time hinged on it.

Comment on this
Matthew O'Reilly Acting-Chairman (Mr. M. O'Reilly) Fianna Fáil

We cannot discuss the economic war now.

Comment on this

I know that, but Deputy Rooney seemed to get away too much with it last night.

Comment on this

It cost the farmers of this country £4,000,000.

Comment on this

It cost farmer Rooney nothing because he is not a farmer.

Comment on this

Who told you so?

Comment on this

I know it well. I have the whole of his history at the tip of my fingers.

Comment on this

It seems to have annoyed Deputy Killilea.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Deputy Killilea is in possession.

Comment on this

I have gone through this economic war and I say that the people are better off to-day than they were before it. It is very doubtful if Deputy Rooney and those who belong to him who reside on farms—although they probably did help to start this "no rent campaign"—were better off before the economic war started than they are to-day.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

We cannot go through the history of the economic war now.

Comment on this

Ask Deputy P.J. Burke about it.

Comment on this

If the Deputies sitting behind the Minister would only make up their minds to advise him along the right lines instead of trying to praise him it would be better for himself and for the country. I think everybody knows that the Minister has a swelled head. To reduce that swelling would not do any harm and it might help to put a little more commonsense and a clearer understanding of the real agricultural position as it is to-day in it. As far as I can judge, the Minister has made every effort to bring about in this country the grass ranchers' position that we had in days gone by. That is clearly indicated.

Comment on this

Is that why we have more eggs and poultry now?

Comment on this

The production of eggs and poultry in this country was handled very well indeed before the present Minister for Agriculture came into office, and the Deputy knows that too. The only thing that this particular Minister has done in regard to egg production in this country is to reduce the price by 1/2d. per egg. Is that not right? Those professional interrupters across the House had their chance last night to make their speeches. One would imagine that they would have said then all they had to say and not interrupt as they interrupted Deputy Allen last night and as they are interrupting to-day also. They are trying not to devote too much time to this Estimate and to that Estimate but, by their constant ignorant interruptions and interference, they seem to be prolonging the agony hour after hour and day after day.

The greatest disaster this particular Minister has been responsible for is the fact that, immediately on taking office, he made a certain number of statements that were not then, and are not now, helpful or beneficial to the farming community. His statements regarding the inspectors who should be shot like scarecrows if they were seen on a farm undoubtedly helped one particular section. As I have pointed out in this House before, there were in this country all during the emergency farmers who were not anxious to have their grass lands broken up and who were not anxious to see that the people of this country should be supplied with food from the home market—considering that they must have known that it was impossible for us to import foodstuffs at that particular time from any other country. We had in this country an enormous number of people who availed of the opportunity that was given to them by the Fianna Fáil policy of compulsory tillage, of taking land in conacre. Undoubtedly they paid huge prices for it but, through their extra efforts, they made it pay and they were able to make a few shillings for themselves while, at the same time, they were doing a good day's work for the country in producing the extra food that was required. Having done that for a number of years and having laboured so hard for a number of years they were not entitled to receive from any Minister for Agriculture the blow they received from the Minister who occupies that bench over there at this particular time—I refer to the complete abandonment of the policy of compulsory tillage.

I believe that compulsory tillage should have been continued, of course on a much lesser scale, for a number of years. I believe it was a tremendously foolish policy to have cut it out overnight, because those unfortunate people who this year, and some of them last year, were looking for conacre to try and clear up things and get out as easily as they possibly could, when they looked for conacre were told by the larger landowner that he was applying hay seed to all his land in accordance with the policy of the present Minister for Agriculture. They were given the high road. They found themselves in a very bad position last year and they find themselves in a very much worse one this year.

I think the Minister was badly advised by Deputies who sit behind him and who to-day are singing his praises. I think those Deputies have done a terrible injustice to the smaller farmers, who always did their day's work honestly and well. Deputy Collins said that the Minister had now brought about a condition of soil fertility on land that was destroyed by the blundering policy of compulsory tillage that was adopted by Fianna Fáil. I wonder if the Fine Gael Party had been the Government during the economic war and were allowed to continue the policy they adopted in days gone by of the land for the bullock and the road for the people what would have happened to the people of the towns and cities in regard to their requirements of essential food during the emergency. I wonder would they have had it.

I am, as I said, surprised that Deputies of other Parties who, apparently, some time ago had a different outlook on agriculture, have fallen into line now with the old worn-out policy of the Fine Gael Party. I suppose when you start associating with certain company you begin to develop their habits and, eventually, you become part and parcel of the particular elements with which you are associating day after day. That is why the different Parties supporting the Government at this time have now developed that Fine Gael outlook and we are once more back in the position in which we found ourselves when Fianna Fáil took over office in 1932.

Owing to their policy agriculture had been brought to its lowest ebb and there did not seem much hope of recovery for it. Were it not for the wisdom of the people at the time in putting the Fianna Fáil Party into power at the right moment and the wisdom of the Fianna Fáil Government in adopting their agricultural policy and putting it into operation as swiftly as they possibly could, I am afraid that during the emergency starvation would have wiped out the vast majority of our towns and cities and probably a lot of the agricultural community would have gone with them.

Comment on this

Listening to the debate on this Estimate for the last few days, I am at a loss to understand who is right and who is wrong. On the one hand, if one believes what has been said by the Deputies opposite in regard to the position of the agricultural industry at the moment, one must come to the conclusion that the position is indeed very bad. On the other hand, if one examines the figures issued by the Department of Agriculture, which I presume are accurate and vouched for, one must come to the conclusion that the agricultural industry to-day is in a very healthy and prosperous condition. If the opinions expressed by the Opposition are right, that would prove that these figures and statistics are wrong, and I think that all the officials of the Department of Agriculture would deserve instant dismissal. If, on the other hand, these figures are correct, I think it is only right and proper that someone on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party—I should say the Leader—should disown and disclaim absolutely what has been stated here by the members of that Party, which, in effect, is a very serious reflection upon the honesty and integrity of the officials of the Department of Agriculture.

Making a rough-and-ready calculation from these figures, I find that the net revenue from cattle, horses, poultry, eggs in shell, condensed milk, raw wool etc., for the year ending 31st March, 1948, was somewhere in the region of £28,000,000 and that the revenue for the year ending 31st March, 1949, was somewhere in the region of £32,000,000. Therefore, if figures prove anything, the revenue derived by the agricultural community for the year ending March 31st, 1949, was much greater than that derived by them in the previous year.

I do not think Deputies opposite are doing a good day's work for the country when they set out deliberately, I am sorry to say, to misrepresent in every detail and to minimise the efforts that are being made by the Minister, in close association with the responsible officers of his Department, to put the agricultural industry on a proper footing. All Deputies must realise the fact that the position to-day, not alone in regard to agriculture, but to all industries, is much more difficult than it was even during the war. A great many people have the mistaken view that it was more difficult to carry on the government of this country during the six years of war. I admit it was fairly difficult, but not so difficult as it is to-day because, being neutral and not in the war, we were then in a position of great prosperity. Those years are now past. It inevitably happens after every war that slowly but surely there comes a reversion of the state of affairs from what appertained during the war. It is generally followed by something approaching what is known as an economic blizzard. Get it into your heads, my friends of the Opposition, that you will not beat that economic blizzard by talking nonsense and by pretending that the farmers of this country have no initiative and that they want to get subsidies at every turn. I would say you would be doing a better day's work if you would tell the farming community that it would pay them to fall in line with the suggestions contained in the Minister's very instructive and educative statement and to co-operate by doing their own business in a proper way. That is what the Minister is out to do.

No matter what opinion we may have as individuals we must remember that he is the Minister that represents the farming industry of this country. He is out to promote the interests of the farming industry—not the Fianna Fáil farmers of this country but all the farmers. That being so, I think the least he may expect and should get is the attentive co-operation of the people opposite. I believe that deep down in their hearts they take as much interest in the future of the farming industry of this country as we on this side of the House do.

Having said so much, I think that the attitude adopted by the Opposition, with a few exceptions, was a wrong and unpatriotic one in the face of the figures that I have quoted. I do not intend to go through the whole litany of everything incidental and ancillary to the agricultural industry but there are two things which seem to have been brought specially to the attention of the Deputies opposite—the question of eggs and potatoes. In the facts and figures produced here it is definitely stated that production, so far as eggs are concerned, has gone up by leaps and bounds, so much so that the subsidy guaranteed by the British Government was eaten up almost a year and a half before the year it was supposed to last out, 1952. Yet, on the face of that we have Deputies making statements that the Minister for Agriculture has destroyed the poultry and egg industry simply because a reduction has occurred in the price of eggs of 6d. per dozen. Do the Deputies not realise that had the Minister not made that agreement extended over two years, had he allowed the production of eggs to grow, as undoubtedly it had been growing, he would have arrived at a point where it would be almost impossible to get rid of the surplus of eggs and he would be compelled to sell them at anything from 1/- to 1/6? Was it not better to make this bargain for two years? That, in effect, is briefly the history of eggs in so far as the reduction of 6d. a dozen is concerned.

We have, then, the question of potatoes. I heard a lot of questions asked as to what the Minister proposed to do with the surplus of potatoes and oats. Let me say what I would say even if I were addressing a meeting of farmers. Get it into your heads here and all over the country that no Minister of Agriculture, no matter what Government is in power, can be held responsible for enabling the farmers of this or any other country to get rid of any extra tons of potatoes or oats. There must always be those ups and downs in all walks of life and in all industries and more especially in the agricultural industry. If Nature, in her bounty and goodness, increases crops by 400 per cent. in one particular year surely it cannot be argued by anyone who has any commonsense that the particular Minister who happens to be in power at that time should be held responsible for the disposal of all those extra crops. Let us deal with potatoes. Great stress has been laid upon what the farmers are going to do with their potatoes. What will be the total quantity of potatoes left in the hands of the farmers? I should like some of the Deputies opposite to answer that question in so far as their respective areas are concerned. The same was said about oats and there was a time when I, myself, was a bit anxious. However, this must be said. Were it not again for the foresight of the Minister in making the agreement with the British Government whereby the Minister of Food in England guaranteed to take 50,000 tons of our potatoes, the position of the potatoes in this country would indeed have been a very hopeless one and one which would have meant great financial loss to the farmers of this country. Instead of putting such questions to the Minister and asking him what is he going to do with regard to the disposal of any little surplus of potatoes, they should congratulate him for the very good bargain he made with the Minister of Food on that occasion.

As I say, a fair price was being paid. I am sorry that Deputy Killilea, possibly unconsciously, tried to create the impression here that he, at least, was convinced that the Minister definitely promised that the farmers would receive an average of £10 per ton net. I listened to the Minister making that statement but I have not had time to refer to the records. However, as far as I know it was £10 f.o.b. delivered at the nearest harbour. Deputy Killilea must know that potatoes do not just leave the field and get to the harbour free of charge.

Comment on this

I should like to inform Deputy Coburn that the farmers I am referring to delivered them at the port in Galway harbour and did not receive £10 for them.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that is not true. It is against the law. If they attempted to do it they would be arrested at the dock.

Comment on this

I am only explaining to Deputy Killilea how that business operated in the county which I represent. As far as I understand it, the buyers who were appointed were usually men in the business because they had the necessary accommodation as far as a suitable building and weights and scales were concerned. They were the men to whom was entrusted the work of getting the potatoes. Everybody knows that the Minister cannot depend on each individual farmer all over the country by saying: "You will be able to give me a ton." He had to get some central authority appointed on whom the responsibility could be placed. I readily admit that very few farmers received £10 or anything approaching it. What they did receive was something in the region of £8 to £10.

Remember, the picking of the potatoes and the selection of them was on a very strict basis and the men who did this had to be paid. It was not a question of just taking them out of the fields. They had to be selected very well for export otherwise the British people would reject them. Taking it on the whole, I think that matter of the potatoes was very well handled, not alone by the Department officials—leave out the Minister altogether to whom I want to pay a special tribute—but also by those men who bought the potatoes. The principal buyer in my own county was the right-hand man of Deputy Aiken and the man who nominated him. I want to make that clear and to show that he was the man appointed who got most of those potatoes and carried out his work well.

I want to pay that tribute to all concerned. I do think that the Minister does deserve a little credit, if for nothing else, for the way in which the potato question was handled. The Cooley area, as Deputy Killilea must know, suffered very extensively. The farmers of that area, not for the last few years but for the last 25 years, could not get their potatoes out to the Dublin men. There were years when they had to sell them for £2, £2 10s. 0d. and £3 when the average price in other regions was £7 per ton. I am glad to say that this year due, again, to the foresight of the Minister and his officials there is very little, if any, of the potato crop in Cooley left on the hands of the farmers. It has been all bought up and cleared at a price which, taking all the circumstances into consideration, was a very favourable one for the farmers in that area.

The Minister, in the course of his statement, indicated the steps that he proposes to take to enable the farmers to avail of the services of our veterinary surgeons for the eradication of fluke, mastitis, contagious abortion and other cattle diseases. That is an aspect of his policy which should command the respect, support and, above all, the co-operation of the Deputies opposite. In pursuing that policy, the Minister is working in the interests of all the farmers.

Another aspect of his agricultural policy, which should command the support and co-operation of the Deputies opposite, is the use which the Minister proposes to make of part of the loan given to this country by the American Government. That loan has been readily accepted, and our people are deeply grateful to the American Government for it. Part of it will be used, I understand, in connection with the Minister's reclamation scheme, the success of which will depend, not in the main on the Minister or his officials but on the co-operation of the representatives of the people in this House, irrespective of what side they sit on, and on the lead they will give to the people. I hope that, when the scheme is being put into operation, every Deputy will make it his business to make a tour of every area in his constituency and advise the farmers to do all they can to make the scheme the success it deserves to be.

It has been stated here that the Minister is against compulsory tillage, that he wants to end tillage. I think it is about time that the Deputies opposite should use a little discretion in regard to that matter. The Minister is not against tillage, and the facts and figures which I have quoted prove that. There was a bigger revenue derived from the growing of cereals last year than in the previous year when Fianna Fáil were in power. I am not making that comparison just because the present Minister and not Deputy Smith is in office. It is all the same to me what Minister is in power. I spoke on much the same lines on this Estimate when the last Government was in power, and gave credit to the last Government, but let me say again that the present Minister is not against compulsory tillage. The farmers, as far as he is concerned, can put every acre of their land under tillage this year and the Minister will not raise the slightest objection. He has indicated that he is in favour of mixed farming, including, of course, tillage and, above all, of increasing our cattle and pig population. There, again, we must admit that the Minister, like the previous Minister, has had to pass through a difficult time, but in spite of the difficulties that beset him at the moment lie has succeeded in increasing the pig population to such an extent that not only will there be sufficient bacon for home consumption this year, but he is hopeful, before the year is out, of having a little bacon to export to our people in Great Britain. Is there anything wrong with that? I do not think so.

In the same way, the position as regards cattle has improved. We are now not only able to supply our own needs, but our farmers are presented with the opportunity of being able to export almost 1,000,000 extra cattle whenever they become available. That is as a result of the policy which the Minister has pursued during the last 12 months. I do not want to go back on the question of the slaughter of the calves, but we all know that when you kill calves you cannot have cattle. If you do not kill them you will have cattle. In 1945, the number of calves slaughtered was 56,961. In 1946, it was nearly 47,000, and in 1947 it was 68,713. It is well to point out that the number slaughtered in 1948 was 14,500, a decrease of 40,000 on the number slaughtered in some of the previous years. If those figures mean anything, they mean that, on the average, we are going to have 35,000 more cattle for export. I do not think there is anything wrong with the Minister's policy if it results in such a significant increase in our cattle population. As a prerequisite to that we must, of course, increase our tillage in order to be able to feed the extra number of cattle that we rear. That means we must grow more cereals.

There, again, the question of oats comes in. There has been talk about cash crops. The Minister never meant to tell the farmers that they were going to get a remunerative price if they sowed oats only as a cash crop. I know large numbers of farmers who have never sold a stone of oats. The economy they pursue is to walk it off their farms. The farmers who grow oats only as a cash crop should not put the responsibility on the Minister if they cannot dispose of it. If all the farmers of the country were to decide to grow oats only, what can the Minister do if they cannot dispose of it? In my opinion, the policy that is being pursued by the Minister and his officials is one that will pay the farmers. It is one that would pay them better if we were all to co-operate a little more with the Minister than we have been doing during the past 12 months.

I do not want to throw any bouquets at the Minister, but, so far as I can see, the farmers all over the country do not disagree so emphatically or so violently with the policy of the Minister as one might be led to believe from the speeches made by the Deputies opposite. He is not the big, bold, bad wolf that he is represented to be by the people opposite. If he were, the farmers would soon make themselves heard. They are not cowards, and if anybody were to threaten their industry in any way, they would soon make their voices heard. I do not see much sign of that at the moment. There is, of course, nothing perfect in this imperfect world, but, taking it in general, the policy pursued by the Minister certainly has the tentative, if not the active, support of our farmers.

Comment on this

I have listened to a great many of the speeches—and read others—made by Deputies who support the Government on this Estimate. In my view, the proper approach is not being made to this Estimate. From the Deputies opposite, we have heard nothing but long speeches in praise of the Minister. "We have got a great Minister and, thank God, we have got rid of Deputy Paddy Smith"—that has been the sum total of the speeches from the opposite benches. Hardly one of them got up to point out what item of agricultural produce had improved in price since the present Minister took office. No amount of statistics will convince me that 2/6 is more than 3/-. No amount of talk will convince the farmers that 2/6 is more than 3/-, or that 2/- a stone for oats is better than 3/-. No amount of talk will convince me or convince the farmers that the policy pursued by the Minister is not accountable for the emigration and unemployment that we can observe all over Ireland.

The first thing that strikes me about this Estimate is that the cost of administration has gone up while the Estimate itself has decreased; in other words, the cost of administration has gone up while the money that should go directly to the farmers has been decreased. That is what we have from a Minister who promised to give cheaper administration and better service. That will take a lot of explaining. I believe the whole outlook of the Minister and his Department is to make this country a cattle ranch for England. Let me deal with cattle. I admit the price of cattle has increased, but does that policy bring us more employment?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like to have them reduced?

Comment on this

I did not say I would. When I was a young man I remember reading about meetings held in various parts of this country when the people were fighting the ranchers and the landlords, and one of the slogans was: "The land for the people and the road for the bullocks." Now that slogan seems to be reversed and the Minister's policy seems to be: "The land for the bullock and the emigrant ship for the people." These slogans were invented after the policy of ranching had been tried out for years and after it had reduced the population almost to half.

Comment on this

It is lower than ever.

Comment on this

It is, because more people than ever before emigrated last year. I come now to the question of oats. In his opening speech—Thursday, 12th May, Volume 115, col. 1081—the Minister, dealing with oats, said:

"The farmer who grows them exclusively as a cash crop"——

Comment on this

I wonder can this man read better than the last?

Comment on this

Of course, he was not in an English public school— he is only an ordinary farmer's son.

Comment on this

My head may not be as big as the Minister's and there may not have been as much money lost on my education as on the Minister's and some of the Deputies behind him, but I am endowed with a certain amount of commonsense and I know what the small farmers want just as well as he does. Speaking about oats the Minister said:

"The farmer who grows them exclusively as a cash crop will confer a blessing on the community at large if he puts himself as an apprentice to a tailor or a cobbler and gives up farming altogether."

The people of Donegal and Sligo and elsewhere who grow oats as a cash crop may remember that. What arrangement has the Minister made to apprentice all these men to tailors and cobblers? Has he made any? Further on, in relation to potatoes, he says:—

"The value of the potato crop cannot be exaggerated, subject precisely to the same reservation, that those who grow potatoes will grow them in the knowledge that if they are to be a standby to Irish agriculture everywhere, they must be grown by a farmer who is prepared to sell them as a cash crop when the market justifies that course, and who is also prepared, if necessary, to convert the surplus into feeding stuffs for live stock, whether it be pigs, cattle or fowl."

How does the Minister expect any farmer to grow oats as a cash crop if he thinks fit suddenly to change his mind? Does he expect the farmer to follow his advice and grow more oats as a cash crop if later on he thinks fit to say: "There is no cash for it"? Where is the farmer to get the cash? By what feat of acrobatics can the farmer keep turning from one crop to another? The farmer wants continuity of policy. He does not want to be told one day to grow oats, the next day to grow wheat and the next day to rear cattle. I would like the Minister to explain how these things can be done. I know it is only in keeping with the Minister's other changes.

As regards the cattle trade, what steps are being taken, by reason of promised developments and the statement of the Taoiseach, to make a further trade agreement with the Continent? Will we be as we were before, put into the position of having only the one market? I say without fear of contradiction that if this country is forced into the position of having only one market, as we were before, we will be getting any price these grand English gentlemen like, whatever the Minister may think about it.

Comment on this

Could you find another market?

Comment on this

What would the Minister say to any housekeeper who would go to a bank to borrow money to buy food while his own stuff was going to loss? That is just what we are doing. National housekeeping is the same as private housekeeping. We are borrowing dollars to buy maize and wheat from the ends of the earth while our oats and potatoes are rotting along the ditches of Donegal and Sligo. I defy any man to contradict that.

Comment on this

I contradict it.

Comment on this

You may, but if you come with me I will show them to you. The crops are lying there and you are importing Indian meal and wheat from the ends of the earth while our young people, who should be producing more food, are going in the emigrant ship to England and America. I want to be fair to the Minister. I do not blame him because that has been his outlook. He never made any secret of his policy in regard to agriculture. He said he would not be seen dead in a field of wheat and he hoped the day would come when wheat and beet and all those things would go up the spout. Still, County Monaghan thought fit to re-elect him.

I defy Deputies over there to say that they got a mandate to put that policy into operation, to change our agricultural policy. It is all very fine for Deputy Kinane and others to say that there is too much talk about the almighty bullock. If he can salve his conscience with that, well and good, but those Deputies got no such mandate and they will be held accountable later on for the Minister's policy.

Deputy Coburn quoted a lot of figures about agricultural produce. In a reply given to a question asking the Minister for Industry and Commerce to state in respect of each of the years 1947 and 1948 the net value of agricultural output the Minister said: "The net value of agricultural output for 1947 was £102,144,000 and in 1948, £106,746,000." That was a little over £3,500,000 as compared with 1947 which was one of the worst years since the famine and one must remember, too, that in 1948 the costs of production and wages had gone up by millions.

Comment on this

That is the net production off which both wages and every other charge have been taken.

Comment on this

Why did you not give the gross figures then?

Comment on this

You did not ask for them but, if you do, I will and welcome.

Comment on this

I come now to the parish committees. The Minister made some jibing remarks about the county committees in his opening speech because those committees did not see eye to eye with him with regard to the proposed parish instructors.

Comment on this

The county committees of agriculture?

Comment on this

The county committees of agriculture. In Sligo most of the members of the county committee of agriculture are supporters of either the Minister or some of the Parties who constitute the inter-Party Government. That committee voted practically unanimously against this scheme. Now, what the people in Sligo want is what the people all over the country want. They do not want experts. They want a decent guaranteed price for their produce. No amount of instructors will make the farmer till or do anything else. Give the farmer a decent guaranteed price for his potatoes, oats, milk and so on and he will produce the stuff. The people have a horror of inspectors.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Or experts. The Minister asked the county committees to give up control to these instructors.

Comment on this

Experts.

Comment on this

It is very hard to understand an invitation like that from a Minister who showed such opposition to the Managerial Act because he held that the rights of committees and public bodies were being infringed.

An Leas-Cheann Comhairle resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

This is the fifth day of this debate. We are engaged in discussing a very important Estimate admittedly but, with the exception of Deputy Beegan, who made a constructive and critical contribution, most of the time has been taken up with misrepresentations and personal attacks on the Minister for Agriculture. I think the time has come when we should search out out hearts and answer the question: "Are we fair to the people whom we represent when we adopt an attitude like that?" There are many points at which I differ from the Minister for Agriculture, but, at the same time, I feel that he has a certain vision and a certain outlook upon agriculture on which I cannot find much with which to disagree. I do not for one moment agree that our tillage should be reduced by 33,000 odd acres in 1948 as against 1947. Yesterday in reply to a Deputy he said that there was a surplus of milk. I take it he was referring there to the City of Dublin. If there was a surplus of milk surely we could have more than eight ounces of butter per head per week. I do not think there is any ground for complacency on the part of anybody until every man, woman and child has a pound of butter per week at his or her disposal.

Comment on this

He would not eat it, Deputy.

Comment on this

I consider that remark to be in bad taste and so do many other people. There is a scarcity of milk in the country at the present time. We cannot be satisfied about our position until we have one pound of butter per week per head of the population. There was a time before the war when that situation prevailed.

Comment on this

We reckon the total requirements of butter on the statistical experience gained in the years before the war when there was no limit to consumption at all. We never reached a point at which we were consuming butter at the rate of one pound per head of the population per week. If that quantity of butter were supplied the people would not take it. When there was no limit our experience was that the people did not take that quantity per week. If you have a household comprised of grown-up people and small children it is more than likely that the younger members will not consume as much butter as do their parents. The common experience is that the highest consumption we ever reached was about 660,000 cwts. per annum.

Comment on this

From 300,000 in 1932.

Comment on this

But it is nevertheless true that though some people might not consume one pound of butter per week there are others who would be very glad to consume more than that quantity. These people cannot get it. As I said last year, we have consistently neglected agriculture down through the years. When this country was free from the turmoil and havoc of war milk production declined. Yet in countries ravaged by war the output of milk has increased. Recently I read a statement published in connection with the consumption of milk in England. That statement says:—

"In the year ended March 31st, 1939, milk produced for sale amounted to 122,000,000 gallons. In the year ended March 31st, 1947, the quantity was almost 129,000,000 gallons."

Will Deputy Brian Ryan suggest that that is not true? Let me say further that that increase is reflected in the health of the people in England. A pamphlet was issued recently by the United Nations dealing with the health of the people of different countries.

"A world-wide drop in infant mortality is shown in a statistical bulletin just published by the United Nations. In 1947 the lowest rate of infant mortality was recorded by New Zealand and Sweden, with 25 deaths per 1,000, followed by Australia with 29 per 1,000. The United States, the Netherlands and Switzerland had rates below 40 per 1,000, and Denmark, Britain and Canada had rates of 45 per 1,000. The most striking improvements in the last ten years were made by Sweden, the United States, Canada and Denmark, where the infant mortality fell by 40 per cent. or more."

What is the position in my own City of Cork? The infant mortality rate in that city was 62 per 1,000 in 1946 and 87 per 1,000 in 1947. I attribute that to lack of nourishment and an insufficiency of milk. From that, of course, we cannot divorce the lack of purchasing power to buy a sufficiency of milk for human consumption. What did they do in England? They gave a priority of 57 per cent. to young children and mothers; third in priority were the adults. Now, that is reflected in the health of the children and the youth of the country at the present time. It is very desirable that the Minister should step up the production of milk in this country. He should consult with the Minister for Health at the same time because agriculture and health are closely allied. Nobody in this House can ever estimate the social cost of poverty in the country.

I have heard a good deal of unfair criticism of the Minister because of his proposal to appoint instructors. I am afraid a good many Deputies are confusing inspectors with instructors. That is one of the faults I have to find with some Deputies' contributions to this debate—the unrealistic attitude they have adopted towards this important Estimate. I want to say to the Minister—probably he will consider it presumptuous on my part because I am so far removed from agriculture—that I think the one thing needed in this country is instructors who will provide farmers with an opportunity to acquire the latest knowledge in regard to seeds and improved types of production of all kinds. I can throw my memory back to my young days when there were demonstration plots on every second farm. I should like to see the same system established again. Groups of farmers came regularly to these demonstration plots to learn the latest developments in agriculture.

Comment on this

They are still there.

Comment on this

I do not think they are as universal as they used to be. I am satisfied that the more instructors and the fewer inspectors we have the greater production we shall get from the farms. I must say that I was rather disappointed last night to hear the unfair criticism coming from responsible Deputies, like Deputy Allen and a few others, in regard to the sugar company and in regard to what was taken from them by the Government.

Comment on this

I never mentioned the sugar company.

Comment on this

You talked about beet.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I am sorry, then, but I know Deputy Corry referred to it. We hear a lot of talk about robbing the sugar company but I did not hear one word from Deputies on that side of the House about the large amount of money the gentlemen who were getting 6 per cent. on their preference shares in that company receive every year. Last year they absorbed £47,000.

Comment on this

A lot of them are farmers.

Comment on this

I did not hear one word of criticism about the large amount of money these men absorbed from the profits of the company last year. If profits are accruing from the operations of the sugar company, the first benefits should go to the producer, those who are producing beet. Many of the men who are drawing that £47,000 a year never stood in a beet field in their lives.

Comment on this

A lot of them are beet growers who have money invested in the sugar company. I know several of them.

Comment on this

I am surprised to hear it.

Comment on this

Many of them are farmers.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Allen also make great play and lay great stress on the last increase given to agricultural labourers. The Deputy suggested that this might lead to less permanent employment for some of these people but I would challenge the Deputy to say if there is anybody in this country creating more wealth for the nation than the people he referred to. It would be interesting to have some comparison between the value of the contribution of the agricultural worker and that of other people to the wealth of the nation because I hold that the worker who is giving service to the community, whether by hand or brain, is of real value in creating wealth for the nation. If anybody can be said to be engaged in essential production, these people surely fall within that category and not those who are well fed and well clothed, many of whom, I doubt, ever produced a pound of goods for the people as a whole. Non-producers are a drag on any community.

I think it is a strange thing that the agricultural worker, the man who is most essential to the nation, should be paid the lowest level of wages in the nation. I do not at all agree that there is any room for criticism of the increase in their wages because their wages are not yet up to standard. In Britain we know that 129,000,000 gallons of milk were produced last year as against 122,000,000 before the war. The wage of the agricultural worker there is now £4 10/- a week for a 48 hour week and there is no complaint that the payment of that wage imposes too heavy a burden on the agricultural community. There is no use in my having £1 in my pocket if I cannot buy a pound of butter because goods and materials are the things that count and not the mere possession of money for which one cannot get goods.

I have heard a good deal of criticism about the price of pigs and the sale of oats but if I could convey my views to the farming community I would say that if they are unable to carry on the industry efficiently and with profit to themselves under the present system, they should develop the co-operative movement and become masters of their own industry. I am rather surprised that the farmers are not taking more advantage of the co-operative movement. I know there are a number of co-operative societies throughout the country and that they are doing marvellous work. They are especially useful for the farmer of 25, 35 or 40 acres. These are the people to whom Deputy Beegan referred in his very constructive speech last night. I feel that the Minister should pay the utmost attention to many things he said about the small farmer.

I think the Minister is somewhat mistaken in his idea that the farmers are going to till their land without some form of compulsion. The fact is that we had some thousands fewer acres under tillage in 1948 than 1947. If that reduction in tillage continues and people are allowed to turn to other forms of activity, does the Minister think that there are many people in this country who will be anxious to engage in tillage if they can get the same return out of anything else? While I believe that the Minister has the ability and the courage necessary to develop the agricultural industry in this country I think that it is a terrible thing that in a country such as ours, with a high reputation for the excellence of its cattle and its pastures the people are compelled to accept a ration of six ounces of butter. If there is anything in which we should expect surplus production from the agricultural industry, I think it is butter.

Comment on this

We have a surplus of butter.

Comment on this

But it is rationed.

Comment on this

To prevent it going across the Border.

Comment on this

I think we should encourage the people of the North by sending them our butter across the Border.

Comment on this

And pay the Ulster people £4 a cwt. in order to induce them to eat it?

Comment on this

Why not? They are Irishmen, too.

Comment on this

I am very fond of them but not to the tune of paying them £4 a cwt. to eat our butter.

Comment on this

Before we can say we have a surplus of butter, I think it should be possible for our own people to purchase a pound of butter every week. That would prevent it from going across the Border. I am not at all so convinced that there is such a surplus of butter when we cannot allow our own people to have a pound of butter per week at the moment. Apart from some speeches in which there was fair criticism, there has been a great deal of misrepresentation in many of the speeches I have heard in this debate. It is rather regrettable that we should have Deputies occupying the time of the House, one for an hour and 50 minutes and another for two hours, delivering speeches in which there was scarcely a single constructive suggestion and which contained many misrepresentations. The sooner we realise that that is not a fair form of debate, the more respect there will be for our Parliamentary institutions amongst the general body of the people.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom cúpla focla a rá ar an Meastachán seo, acht sul a dtosnú mé ní foláir dhom na giotaí sin as cainnt an Aire a thabhairt dhó mar a gheallas dhó.

I had better start with the quotations I promised the Minister last night. On this question of oats and potatoes which must be nauseating to him he challenged us with regard to quotations and I will give them to him. He spoke on the 5th August on the debate on the Trade Agreement with Great Britain and what I am quoting is to be found in Volume 112, No. 12, columns 2247 and 2248. The Minister said:—

"With regard to the last paragraph, the price for potatoes was published recently and I think it was £10 18s. 6d. up to Christmas and £11 8s. 6d. from Christmas onwards. That is something on which I would like an expression of opinion from Deputies. If Deputies will look at that last paragraph of the agreement they will see that further negotiations with regard to potatoes are envisaged. We have undertaken to deliver 50,000 tons at a price which Deputy Smith says is not enough. I am glad to have that outlet for the Cooley potatoes, so as to ensure that they will not have to be sold to the alcohol factory."

That is the first quotation. There is more about potatoes also but I will not weary the House or the Minister by reading it. He spoke on potatoes again during the debate on agriculture on the 9th July, 1948, in Volume 111 column 2596.

"There is a guaranteed market for 50,000 tons of ware potatoes in Great Britain at £10 13s. 6d. per ton delivered f.o.b. at a port in Ireland between November and February and £11 8s. 6d. per ton delivered at the same port between February and May. None of us will grow rich on that, and if the British want any increased supplies of potatoes from this country, they will want to straighten themselves and pay a bit more for them; but there is no obligation. We will send them 50,000 tons, I believe, at this price this year, if the potato crop turns out as it looks like turning out. In any case, it is a useful basement to have under potato prices that, if any temporary surpluses occur, there is a price of £10 13s. 6d. at the port here up to February and £11 8s. 6d. thereafter. I am in a position to say to the House, however, that, in future years, if we wish to produce a greater acreage of potatoes, the British Government are prepared to take from us whatever acreage we are prepared to offer. If they want a larger acreage than we are at present offering them, they will have to do better than £10 13s. 6d. and £11 8s. 6d., and I intend to tell them so. If they are not prepared to go a bit higher— no hard feelings and no potatoes; if they are prepared to go a bit higher —mutual satisfaction and more potatoes."

Here is another quotation about the subject of oats and I will finish with quotations then. I will also finish with those two subjects because they are not what I stood up to speak about at all. In Volume 111, the 9th July, 1948, in column 2596, the Minister said:—

"Oats I need not speak of because their value is too well known. ‘Grow,' I say to the farmers, all the oats your land will produce and you will sell them profitably either in bag or on hoof——"

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

"‘——during the winter and the spring of next year.'"

We know what happened the oats in bag. We had a surplus of potatoes last year and a surplus of oats, a large one. That is not the first time that happened and I would not have had blame for the Minister for that situation were it not for the foolish statements he made and what he said in an advertisement about a guaranteed market at remunerative prices for all the oats that could be grown. That is why we quarrel with him; that is why the farmers of this country quarrel with him. He did not live up to his promises.

Comment on this

What about "on hoof"?

Comment on this

I have things to say, so would the Minister stop interrupting me? I cannot hear what he said. I want to talk on the subject of the price of milk supplied to the creameries. I cannot deal with the subject of the liquid milk trade at all, but living as I do in one of the premier dairy counties of the country, I want to ask what happened with regard to milk supplied to the creameries before Christmas 1948, and I want the Minister to tell us. I will refer to a report that appeared on Christmas Eve in the Irish Independent and which was referred to by Deputy Corry. A deputation consisting of southern Deputies and Senators of various alliances approached the Minister about milk supplied to the creameries and the report in the Irish Independent says that he told the deputation that he had been greatly impressed by the case made by the deputation and the representatives of the Munster Dairy Institute and that having regard to the case made by the deputation he would now reopen the whole question and he was sure that any recommendations he made would be favourably considered by the Government. Deputy Madden intervened in this debate on this subject. He was not so vocal on this debate this year as he was in the years gone by in County Limerick. He was not as loud. I rather enjoyed his change of tone and his change of tune from what we used to hear on this very subject from him at the Limerick County Committee of Agriculture or on the hustings all over the constituency. He was a changed man and a mute man yesterday—I am sorry he is not here now but I have to make this statement and I think he cannot contradict me.

Comment on this

He certainly cannot when he is not here.

Comment on this

At Christmas he told the farmers of Limerick that he had secured an increase of 2d. per gallon on milk for the coming year. He definitely said that and I can bring him at least two men to whom he told it, friends of his.

Comment on this

That was Christmas time.

Comment on this

He meant it to be a Christmas-box but it turned out to be a very false Christmas-box.

Comment on this

This is like the Balbriggan widow.

Comment on this

This might be a subject for laughter here, but it is a serious matter for the dairy farmers of County Limerick and in other parts of the country. It was wrong for anyone to mislead people in that way by promising that there would be an increase of 2d. per gallon for milk when the thing did not come off afterwards. What happened in regard to that increase when that deputation were given some indication that something like that was about to happen? I believed it from the sources from which I heard it and I told it to other farmers I met who were asking me about it.

I knew that the Minister had made a very categorical statement a few months before that at Rath Luirc when he went to accept one of those golden keys for opening factories about which he used to sneer for many years when the previous Minister for Industry and Commerce took them. He made a very categorical statement on milk prices. He told the assembled body— I was listening to him—that he had no intention of asking the Government to provide an increase in the price of milk. He said that more than once. The Minister was consistent about that, up to the time he met this deputation and the newspapers reported him as having said he was greatly impressed by the case made.

There was a very sound case for an increased price for milk supplied to creameries. All the other sections of the community got increases in their remuneration, except that section of farmers supplying milk to creameries. They had to provide for certain increases in the cost of production, since the last price increase was granted in May, 1947. I stated last year—and I repeat this year—from the experience I have gained on this subject, that this problem of dairying is a very difficult one for any Minister for Agriculture and any Government. If that increase of 2d. a gallon, which would have been very welcome to the dairy farmers, were granted, it would have meant either of two things—an increased price of butter to the consumers or an increase in the amount of subsidy provided by the State and the taxpayers.

Comment on this

Or both combined.

Comment on this

Or a combination of both, as Deputy Allen says.

Comment on this

From the poor of the City of Dublin.

Comment on this

Will the official interrupter of the Fine Gael Party keep his mouth shut and let me make my speech?

Comment on this

Can the Deputy answer that?

Comment on this

I cannot hear very well, as the acoustic properties of this House are not too good and my hearing is not the best. You can have an increased price for butter or an increase in the subsidy, or a combination of the two, as has been done in previous years. The Government had to face the music when the price of butter had to be increased.

These Parties that form this conglomeration are against any increase in the cost of living. Therefore, they could not deal with it from that angle. Secondly, they went out on a policy of retrenchment and, therefore, they could not provide in the other way by increasing taxation in order to give an increased subsidy on the production of butter. In any case, the dairy farmers have been left in the lurch. I hope that in future we will not hear any of the sound and fury we have been hearing for the last 15 years from the Deputy Maddens, Hallidens, Lehanes of Clann na Talmhan and O'Reillys of Cavan. They had the ball at their feet and they did not kick it. Let us hear no more about it.

Comment on this

Sixteen years.

Comment on this

The Government which was in power for 16 years put the dairying industry on its feet when it was dying. If the position is that the dairy farmers have 1/2 per gallon in the summer and 1/4 in the winter, they may thank the previous Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Smith, who provided those prices for them. The dairy farmers now have to depend on the prices fixed in May, 1947, by the Fianna Fáil Minister for Agriculture— the prices that were termed then rotten, inequitable, iniquitous, mean prices. They have to depend on them just the same and have got nothing from this Government, in spite of all the shouting and the fury on this subject. I will be happy next year if there is not a raid by the Minister for Finance—this economist we have going out for economy and retrenchment—on that fund that has been provided to keep the price of milk supplied to creameries at the figure it is. If there is, then the dairy farmers will have to fight on, their backs to the wall, against a reduction, instead of talking about an increase. It is not coming from those people over there, as far as I can see.

The Minister spoke about butter production. There has been a substantial increase in the production of creamery butter this year, beyond what there was last year. We have had a good winter and a good spring.

Comment on this

And a good Minister.

Comment on this

There has been a favourable season this year. A few years ago we had the worst winter in living memory—none of us in the House remembers anything like it—with a most deleterious effect on the dairy stock of the country and, accordingly, a decrease in production. I would not be too sure, if I were in the Minister's boots, about this surplus in butter that he says is coming. When the Minister sees the production of creamery butter at the 700,000 cwts. figure or thereabouts, he can begin to think about a surplus for export. I hope the day will never come again when we will have any surplus of creamery butter for export, because if it does come, the dairy farmers might get it in the neck again as they got it before, particularly in the years 1929 to 1931. The price of milk supplied to creameries toppled during the years from 1922 to 1932, from 1/0½, on an average, per gallon all over the year to 4d. per gallon in the year 1932, when Fianna Fáil took over. These official figures are in existence and cannot be denied.

If we are going to depend on the "old and valued customer", as the Minister called him last year, or, as he stated recently, on the "base, bloody, brutal, British Saxon", for a remunerative price for our dairy farmers from that market that the Minister thinks so much about, I hope we will not have the same experience as we have had before in regard to dairying, when our economy was tied up in that way and we were exporting creamery butter during the peak period and importing Danish, New Zealand and Australian in the scarce period. I hope we will never see that day again. Dairy farmers will be wise if they take time by the forelock and arrange their output in such a way as never again to have an exportable surplus—because, if there is, we will have to take whatever price the British are prepared to give us.

I would not be too sure with regard to this forthcoming surplus of butter.

The consumption of creamery butter has gone up from about 350,000 cwts. in 1932. I think we had about 656,000 cwts. in 1945. We had more than that in other years. The peak figure for production was 836,000 cwts. in 1936. Until we have between 700,000 and 750,000 cwts., I do not think, from the point of view of sufficiency, that our consumers at home will be safe. When we reach that figure, we can be looking out for squalls, as we will have to be dependent then on the "old and valued customer"—and we know what we got when we were depending on him for a market for our surplus creamery butter before. I agree with the Minister that it is not the best policy to subsidise the export of butter to a foreign market.

Comment on this

So Deputy Ó Briain agrees with me!

Comment on this

If the butter is there, you have to do something with it.

Comment on this

There is the puzzle. What do you suggest?

Comment on this

There is nothing but dumping. Every country in the world has to do the same. When they cannot consume at home an article they produce, they have to dump it at whatever price they can get for it.

Comment on this

That is a counsel of despair. I hope to be able to do better than that for the farmers.

Comment on this

There is nothing the Minister can do.

Comment on this

The Deputy may be surprised.

Comment on this

The Minister might turn it into cart grease or something like that.

Comment on this

No, no. Courage!

Comment on this

There is another thing that might be done if this surplus comes about, although I do not believe it will come about as soon as the Minister seems to think. The Minister might subsidise the consumption of it by certain deserving classes here at home at a cheap rate, by people suffering from diseases of various kinds——

Comment on this

It is being subsidised at present to the extent of 9d. per pound.

Comment on this

——who might need extra food of that nature. I want to refer now to this question of eggs and the recent agreement the Minister has made. If there was any section of the community praying for the Minister, it was that section of the people, the farmers' wives and the women who go in for the production of eggs, when they heard of the recent reduction in the price of eggs. It does not matter what the Minister tries to do with figures or how he tries to juggle figures, he can never convince anybody that 2/6 a dozen is better than 3/- a dozen. He handled that situation very badly, I am afraid. The figures and finances of the whole thing are very mysterious to me and I do not understand them. The Minister should take the Dáil more into his confidence on the subject of the £1,300,000 fund that was available and the money that was available in respect of the turkey levy last year, as well as any other money available. He should tell us all about it and how it was disposed of.

Comment on this

I gave it back to the turkey women.

Comment on this

That is not very clear, either—there is a catch in that answer, too. There is the question of £1,700,000 more. How can that be when the price of eggs is less? There are a number of what are known as hatchery supply farms and various poultry producers were supplying eggs to these hatcheries under conditions and regulations laid down by the Department of Agriculture and in accordance with the instructions of the poultry instructresses — inspectors, I would call them, because their visits are always of an inspectorial nature ——

Comment on this

I would call them inspectresses.

Comment on this

——and God help the poultry producer if things were not in order.

Comment on this

Do they frighten you?

Comment on this