Committee on Finance. - Vote 29—Agriculture (Resumed)
Contributions 204–411 of 627. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
In any case, there are a number of these hatchery supply farms in the part of Limerick I live in and I have here an interesting document, a communication received by the owner of a hatchery supply farm some time ago from one of these hatcheries. The hatchery supply farms supply eggs to the hatcheries at, I think, 7/6 per dozen for the hatching season and there was an understanding—I believe it was really an agreement — between the hatchery and the supply farm owner to supply all the eggs produced on that farm to the hatchery for the purposes of the hatchery. But, after the announcement of the reduction in the price of eggs from 3/- to 2/6, the owner of the farm received this communication.
Comment on this
The letter reads:—
"Further to our circular of the 11th inst., we find that, with present bookings, we have more chickens than we require for the rest of the season. We regret therefore that we cannot take further supplies of hatching eggs for the remainder of the season."
Comment on this
I cannot, unfortunately, produce the previous circular, the circular of the 11th April——
Comment on this
——but that circular definitely stated that, owing to the number of cancellations of orders for chickens, they could do nothing but reduce the supply which they were taking each week.
Comment on this
To a hatchery supply farm in County Limerick.
Comment on this
Bheadh eagla orm díobháil a dhéanamh don chomhlucht a chuir an litir amach go dti na feirmeacha sin go léir ach tháinic an litir sin chuca.
Comment on this
Níor tháinic— go dti na feirmeacha.
Comment on this
Níl a fhios agam. I will not give the Minister an opportunity of doing any damage to the hatchery that sent out that letter to its suppliers.
Comment on this
I am telling you that this is a letter sent to all the hatchery supply farms supplying eggs for hatching purposes in that area. It is only one of a number and this is a stencilled copy.
Comment on this
Deputy P.J. Burke can speak for himself, but the Minister can take my word for it. I did not stand up here to mislead him or to mislead the Dáil in regard to this matter.
Comment on this
I said last year that the extension of the poultry industry was, to a certain extent, justified and desirable, but that we should not go over the precipice, or we would be left in the same position as that in which we found ourselves before with the old and valued customer, that, when supplies began to come from the Continent and from other sources, our eggs would not be as valuable as they are to-day, even with the reduction.
I want the Minister to tell us what is the position with regard to the farm improvements scheme and the farm buildings scheme. Money is provided in this year's Estimates for both and I should like the Minister briefly to say what is the position with regard to people who wish to apply under this year's scheme. It has not been announced yet. Will it be announced soon and what will be the position with regard to applications, particularly under the farm buildings scheme which he dropped last year, at the behest, I suppose, of the Minister for Finance?
The Minister paid a visit recently to Limerick in connection with the subject with which I have been dealing. He went to a meeting of the Limerick County Committee of Agriculture on the invitation of the committee who were hoping, as Deputy Madden had let it be known, that he was going to announce an increase in the price of milk. He went down there, but he did not deal with the price of milk at all until he was questioned about it. He dealt principally with this £40,000,000 scheme he talks about, which, I understand, will not apply to Limerick this year and in respect of which one might say that it may be for years and it may be for ever. In any case, Limerick is not one of the first counties to which the scheme will apply. When the Minister was asked to go down there, he was asked to do so for one specific purpose, to deal with the price of milk. He was not wanted for anything else. They were not interested at all in that scheme, particularly when it will not apply to Limerick for some time to come. They were interested in only one subject, the price of milk.
It was a rather noisy meeting, I believe, and the Minister, I understand, has been led to believe that all the noise was created by the Fianna Fáil organisation. If the Fianna Fáil organisation was responsible for that, we would not deny it but there is no truth whatever in that statement. We had nothing whatever to do with what took place at that meeting. The Minister's information is just as sound and as reliable as the information that was given at that committee to the country and to the whole world a few years ago, when a certain member of that committee said that the cows in County Limerick were rotten with tuberculosis.
Let me repeat that when the Minister went down to Limerick he was asked for one specific purpose, to deal with the price of milk, and the dissatisfaction that was expressed there came principally from the supporters of the Party sitting behind him—he has no Party, of course—and that dissatisfaction was occasioned by the unfavourable news that the Minister gave with regard to the price of milk for the coming year.
Comment on this
All the interruptions prevented me from dealing with it when I was dealing with the price of milk.
Comment on this
What is Deputy Collins growling about now? Will he shut up or else take himself out of the place. He is a proper pest in this establishment. He ought to be ashamed of himself growling like that always. There are two other points on which I want information from the Minister. The first is, what is the position now about the wheat credit voucher fertiliser scheme? Payments are in arrears, as I have been informed by farmers who have some vouchers to their credit.
Comment on this
Let me say what I have to say without this continuous barrage of interruptions. If you stopped the interruptions, you would not be here so long. Will the Minister say what is the exact position and can he give an assurance that all farmers who hold such vouchers will be paid without further vexatious delay?
The second point is in connection with the proposal that was mooted before the Minister became Minister for the establishment of a factory in the town of Kilmallock, County Limerick, for the manufacture of a milk product—I think Horlick's Malted Milk.
Comment on this
I do not know I know nothing whatever about it.
Comment on this
I want the Minister to give information. The factory was to be set up in the town of Kilmallock. A site of ten acres was purchased and the site is now let in grazing. A deputation waited on the Minister in regard to the matter on that famous occasion that he visited Rathluirc. That deputation was representative of all sections of the community in Kilmallock, all organisations, political and otherwise, with the exception of the Fianna Fáil Party. They were not invited to go on the deputation. Would the Minister tell me, when he is concluding, what exactly is the position with regard to that factory and is he going to give a licence for the establishment of that factory or for the milk to be supplied to it?
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to give the information I have asked for with regard to the wheat credit voucher scheme, the factory in Kilmallock, the farm improvement scheme and, particularly, the farm building scheme.
Comment on this
Last year, when I was contributing to the debate on this Estimate I mentioned that I thought the solution of all the grievances of farmers would be production. There is no doubt that production has stepped up to an amazing extent within 12 months. We hear a lot of talk about oats. The people on the other side of the House were very doubtful as to what was going to happen to the oats crop in October of last year but, surprisingly, everyone who grew oats got a remunerative price for it, with the exception of people who were exploited by speeches made by Deputy Davern and Deputy Corry who, at one time, got 30/- a barrel which, in my opinion, is a fine remunerative price for oats. I can assure the Minister that if he can guarantee that price for oats every year a lot of oats will be grown. Surprisingly, the bottom fell out of the case about oats. There is not a word about oats now and we are moving very cautiously on to potatoes. Deputy Blaney was speaking about Donegal and the terrible hardship imposed on the Donegal people by the slump in potatoes. I do not know in exactly what paper I read it but I did read in some paper that they were working by moonlight in Donegal recently sending potatoes to England. I do not know whether that is a fact or not but it appeared in some paper and I think it was an English paper. I have not seen it contradicted by the Dáil Correspondent of the Fianna Fáil Party yet. Therefore, I must assume that it is right.
Reference was made to the price of cattle. This day three weeks the prices of yearlings in Mitchelstown fair were from £22 to £27. If anybody will say that is not an unprecedented price for yearlings, he must have been born long before anyone else in this House. I am sorry that Deputy O'Reilly of Meath is not present to hear that because I am sure that if the people of Meath heard it there would be a rush from Meath down to Cork at the earliest opportunity to pick up all these cattle at that price.
We have heard about eggs. Deputy Ó Briain was speaking of eggs at 3/-and 2/6 a dozen. I wonder what is the increase in production from the time they were 3/- a dozen to the present time when they are 2/6. I would say that the gross amount at 2/6 would compare very favourably with the gross amount at 3/-.
Solicitude was expressed by Deputy Ó Briain for the Limerick farmers. Some four years ago a group of Limerick farmers decided by a big majority on coming in under the Mitchelstown Co-operative Creameries. At that time Dr. James Ryan was Minister for Agriculture. He could not, constitutionally, put a stop to it but, very adroitly, he stopped subsidies to the Mitchelstown Creameries to the extent of £18,000. I do not know for what length of time he held those subsidies. In any case, the committee of management took legal advice from, I think, the present Taoiseach, Mr. Costello, who advised them that he thought the Minister could not do it legally. When they told that to Dr. Ryan he said: "All right. I may not be able to do it but I will get a Bill through Dáil Éireann with a retrospective and retroactive clause which will leave you people minus your £18,000." Therefore, the County Limerick farmers who had been getting 2d. or 3d. a gallon more for their milk had to revert immediately to their former system and suffer that loss. I do not think that at any time we heard any complaints from the Limerick Fianna Fáil Deputies about that.
When this Government took over there were approximately 500 tons of cheese in the creameries at Mitchelstown for which no market could be found. Representations were made to the previous Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Smith, on two or three occasions, for an export licence but he would not grant it. When this Government came into office representations were again made and the present Minister for Agriculture, realising the losses that would otherwise occur, immediately gave an export licence, thus saving the creameries anything up to £100,000. I feel sure that that is one thing the Minister did which the farmers in my area appreciated.
Reference was made during the course of this debate by Deputy Allen to "Bloody Balfour". I felt that I should interrupt Deputy Allen and say that that name should not have been introduced against the present Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
I was never on any platform with the present Minister's father, the late Mr. John Dillon.
Comment on this
I know that I am speaking with the support of 90 per cent. of the farming community in my area when I say that 1887 will not be forgotten for the Dillon family——
Comment on this
I must say that I am inclined to wonder at all this talk to the effect that the farmers are not getting a remunerative price for milk. I wonder if the Minister would contradict me if I said that recently a costing experiment was carried out by a pretty good farming organisation and that it was supervised by a very prominent professor of agricultural science. If I said that the costing— outside its management, principal and interest—did not come to a shilling per gallon I wonder if the Minister would contradict me or if any Deputy on the other side of the House would contradict me?
Comment on this
That experiment was carried out and supervised by the farmers under the direction of Professor Murphy, of University College, Cork. I may not know the exact figures but I say that outside of its management, capital and interest, the costing per gallon did not come to one shilling. Therefore I cannot see why the farmers should be grumbling at the present price of milk. What I am afraid of is what Deputy Donnchadh Ó Briain has mentioned—the danger of a slump in the dairying industry. As far as I can see, in the constituency I represent, the farmers are getting more and more into the dairying industry, and I am sure that they would be very satisfied if the present price of milk could be stabilised.
In 1944, while the war was on, the price of oats in this country was from 24/- to 26/- a barrel. No maize was coming into the country at that time and we were relying absolutely on oats for feeding. We heard no outcry then —good, bad or indifferent—from the Fianna Fáil Deputies about the price of oats and the Minister was not asked to increase it. The very same thing obtained in regard to the price of barley. Early last June I asked the present Minister for Agriculture a question about the guaranteed price of barley. I followed up that question with a supplementary question. I asked him if any attempt was going to be made to recoup the barley growers of this country who had had to sell their barley at £1 a barrel less than Messrs. Guinness were prepared to pay and who had indirectly contributed £2,000,000 to the war fund of John Bull. Immediately after that, an all-out drive began—and the leader of the drive was Deputy Corry. He contacted Messrs. Guinness and got amazing and glorious promises and guarantees from them. He went down the country and, as is typical of Deputy Corry—he tries to get credit for everything, no matter who does it—he tried to take credit for the whole lot of the increase that Messrs. Guinness was going to give to the malt barley growers of Eire. He also tried to get the farmers to swallow the whole thing and if they had, we would have had a slump in barley in the coming year. A dastardly attempt was made by Deputy Corry and some of his colleagues in the county committee of agriculture of which I am a member to get the Cork farmers to grow barley ad lib notwithstanding the fact that only barley on contract would fetch 52/6d. a barrel. Fortunately some people circumvented the efforts of these gentlemen and, by question, succeeded in getting the Press to publish that it was only those people who had contracted with Messrs. Guinness and the breweries who would get the price Deputy Corry was speaking about. If some people think that this exploitation of the farmer is going to get Fianna Fáil back into power let me say that it will be a very long time before they will sit on this side of the House again. The farmers were exploited a couple of times and if the people who are living in a fool's paradise—and who are having very unhappy dreams now and again—think they are going to exploit the farmers this time they are mistaken.
References were made to the credit system as it exists at present in this country. I have no hesitation in saying that unless, shall I say, direct action is taken in regard to the banks of this country so as to make them realise their responsibility to the farmers and to the security of this country by offering them what they have at the moment at their disposal at reasonable terms, I certainly would recommend very strongly —— and I am not a bit afraid to say it—the nationalisation of that particular system.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I have digressed too far but I heard a reference to the agricultural credit system. I cannot agree that the Agricultural Credit Corporation gives loans as freely as I would like them to do so or, I am sure, as freely as a lot of other people in this House would like, irrespective of what side of the House they may sit on. The bank managers throughout the country are absolute Mandarins as far as the farmers are concerned——
Comment on this
Surely the Minister has no control over bank managers. The Deputy has already been told that in very clear terms.
Comment on this
I should like to refer to the freedom which the present Minister for Agriculture has given to farmers so that they may work their lands to their best ability and to their own advantage. Undoubtedly, his latest scheme of allocating an agricultural instructor to every three parishes is one of the greatest steps ever taken to improve the production of the farming community. We all know that even in one field there are different soils. With these men of technical and practical experience helping the farmers, I am sure that after 12 months we will be in a position to state that production has been stepped up to a remarkable extent.
I am sure the Minister will take into consideration the points put before him by Deputy Ó Briain. I am sure he will also take into consideration that there are people who have to live in cities and towns and if people who can least afford it have to pay, whether by subsidy or direct taxation, £700,000 extra to give an increase of 1d. per gallon of milk—I think Deputy Ó Briain wanted an increase of 2d. which would come to £1,400,000—there will be a famine I am afraid. We have to take into consideration the people in the towns and the cities as well as the agricultural community. I would ask the Minister before he allows any increase in the price of milk to explore every avenue to see whether more help could not be given to the farmers by improving the price of cattle, pigs, poultry or something which will be exportable, instead of giving it to the dairying industry. I am a farmer myself and, personally, I should like to see the Minister giving 1/- per gallon more for milk. However, I am alive to my responsibility to my constituents. I have put a firm case before the Minister and I would ask him to contradict it if he can—that the cost of producing a gallon of milk is less than 1/-. If we continue with our policy of improving the conditions of the agricultural community, we shall be a very happy country in 12 months time.
Comment on this
Were it not for a remark of the Minister's which I read in the report of his introductory speech, I would not have spoken on this Estimate. The Minister said that certain committees of agriculture on which there was a Fianna Fáil majority deliberately turned down some proposal of his for political reasons. Personally, I resent that very much. I am chairman of a county committee of agriculture which has a Fianna Fáil majority. I was also a member of that committee before we had a majority there, and I can say very definitely that any matters put up by the Ministry, no matter who the Minister may have been, were considered on their merits. Whatever impression the Minister may have got, I think he is very wrong to make a sweeping charge like that.
I got a letter from the Minister to which I did not reply because, in fairness to the county committee, I could not have done so without consulting them. However, I have handed that letter over to the secretary and asked him to put it on the agenda for the next meeting. I can assure the Minister that it will get full and fair consideration on its merits. These exaggerated notions of the Minister's, I am afraid, are not doing him any good and they have prolonged this debate very much.
As to the general policy which the Minister has expressed on various occasions, I must confess I am very puzzled. Not very long ago he stated that, while farmers might grow any crop they desired, the best crop to grow was grass. Within the last few weeks he stated that we must have tillage. It is very hard for a county committee of agriculture to decide what the Minister really means. I think he should settle down and decide definitely what his policy is going to be. Hitherto, it has been very mixed, which is a very bad thing. I am not doubting the enthusiasm of the Minister in many ways or that he means to do the best he can. But, when there are so many statements which appear to be contradictory I do not think it is good for the Department or for the country.
Comment on this
If the policy is to be a grass policy, I do not think it can be reconciled with tillage.
Comment on this
We know the difference between the two. We have had experience of both; we have had a long experience of the grass policy anyhow While giving the Minister credit for all the good intentions in the world, I do not think he has been fair to the working farmer. There is no use in repeating what has been said already, but during the year in which he has been Minister I do not think that the working farmer got a fair chance. The question of a market for oats and other produce has been referred to repeatedly. This year, however, according to the Minister's own statement, the subsidy on artificial manures has been withdrawn. In fact, I do not see any advantage that he is giving the working farmer, especially the small farmer. When I speak of farmers, I generally mean those who have small holdings and the Minister is very well acquainted with them. I do not see what advantage they are getting or what help they are getting.
We are told about a number of schemes that are to be put into operation, such as the reclamation scheme and the field drainage scheme, but in fact nothing is being done. The Minister should fix his mind on doing something practical and giving some help to those people who require it very much. We had, of course, complaints that the fertility of the soil has been very badly impaired during the years past. I am sure it has. But, now that artificial manures are available at a price, we find that the small poor farmer is not able to buy them in sufficient quantities. Even during the last few weeks the prices of artificial manures were increased.
When the various other increases are added, it is very hard for the small farmer to make ends meet. I am sure that those people who have a big number of cattle to sell are doing well. But the type of farmer to whom I refer has not a big number of cattle to sell and never can have, as he has very little land. The Minister comes from the same area as I do and he should understand the necessity for helping the small working farmer.
The Minister thinks that it is a good thing to import feeding stuffs from abroad. I entirely disagree with him in regard to that. It is a very bad policy. The land of this country should be utilised to grow feeding stuffs both for human beings and animals. Even if it costs the State a good deal in subsidies, I think that should be done. If, as the Minister states, barley is at least as good as maize I do not see why the growing of barley should not be encouraged. After all, it keeps our farmers employed and it keeps the money at home. That was never more necessary than at the present time when it is stated, and truly stated, that it is very hard to find dollars to buy stuff in the dollar area. I say that I think it is a national folly to be importing stuff the equal of which can be produced at home. The Minister may not agree with me in that but I think I am right. However the fact is that a great many people in the poorer areas have left the land. I suppose there is no use now in introducing the question of those poor people of three, four or five pound valuation who have been knocked out of employment by the discontinuance of turf production. They are a very important section of the people, too.
Comment on this
They are gone. Four hundred left the parish of Kiltullagh. It was not for a joke they went. They went because the few acres of land they had were not sufficient to give them a living.
Comment on this
The Minister knows as well as I do that these people were never able to live on the patch of land they had and I think their lot is worse now than it was. I hope that that will be remedied. It certainly needs a remedy. There are less people employed on the land at the moment, as you know, than there were some time ago. I am not going to refer to the agricultural conditions in general; they have been dealt with. Those who spoke from the Government Benches are convinced that everything is all right. On the other hand, the people in these benches do not think so. There may be a bit of right on both sides. I am certain that the working farmer has not received any advantages recently.
I should like to refer to the proposed reclamation scheme. When I say this I am not speaking critically of the Minister at all. Anything I say is by way of advice. Whether the amount to be spent be £40,000,000 or £50,000,000 it can, to a large extent, be misspent. If you reclaim land which in a few years will be back again to its wild state you will find that a lot of that money will be swallowed. In my native district many years ago I saw patches of land reclaimed. I have been there within the last few months and it is as wild as it was a 100 years ago, almost. What I would put before the Minister is this. I understand that the Marshall Aid Plan is for increasing food production. I would suggest to the Minister that he should devote a reasonable fraction of that money to help the people on land that is already reclaimed and to give them a chance. After all, I presume the money so borrowed will have to be repaid and with interest. The best way of using it would be to spend a considerable share of it in helping farmers to till the land which is already in reasonable condition. I am sure the Minister will agree that there is a danger that while you may temporarily improve reclaimed land it will go back again in a short time. I know that matter will need very close examination. However, I think it is well worth an attempt.
There are some points in the Minister's statement that I am happy to compliment him on. One of them was his desire for scientific research, applying the results of experiments to the curing of cattle diseases and so on. That is a very desirable thing, but it is nothing new. It was started before he came in and the instructors of county committees were also working on these lines. The fact that the Minister is trying to improve the position and is determined to do so is commendable. I am happy to congratulate him on that line of action. I should like to say a word about those instructors that the Minister proposes to put in at the rate of one per three parishes. It will all depend, of course, on what the Minister proposes to do and how he proposes to use these instructors as to whether it will be a desirable scheme or not. If the Minister is definitely carrying out a tillage policy as opposed to the ranching system, I certainly will be in favour of it. I have always held that we need more instructors. I am not stating this for the first time. Years ago I urged the county committee to appoint additional instructors. I remember a time when we had only one poultry instructor in County Roscommon and now we have four.
Comment on this
I did not. If the Minister is determined on giving instruction in the proper tillage of the soil, the proper use of tillage and, above all, if he is determined on producing our own feeding stuffs at home I will certainly back it. If, on the other hand, he is not determined to do that I should be very doubtful about the advantage of having extra instructors.
I heard a number of Deputies on the other side of the House talking about Fianna Fáil compelling the people to till. I think that is hardly fair in view of the fact that until some years after the war started Fianna Fáil had no compulsory tillage. It had never been a doctrine that we should have compulsory tillage. It is not my doctrine. I have some land and I am tilling more this year than last year. I may be a doctrinaire tiller but I certainly have no doctrine about compulsion. The fact of the matter is there was no compulsion until it had to be. If you ask why it had to be it was because those people with large areas of land would not till and when they did till they certainly did not till the part of the land that was likely to give a good crop. The number was very limited, of course, but at the same time they occupied a great deal of the land and surely compulsion was necessary in that case. I do not know what would have happened if Fianna Fáil had continued in office.
Comment on this
I believe a certain percentage might be required but nothing like the same percentage as was required the year before. I should like to direct the Minister's attention to this. The Minister apparently is in favour of having grass. To the extent to which I grow grass I certainly would agree with him but is it desirable that land which was in tillage for the last few years is now let out to grow weeds?
Comment on this
I know. I am drawing the Minister's attention to the fact that thousands of acres are being let out in weeds and I should like to know what the Minister is doing about it. It is a very serious matter.
The Minister may not want to have compulsion, but I think he should have it. I do not know what powers he has at the moment, but, if he has the power, I think he should see that it is not right that land which had been tilled every year up to now has not so far been ploughed, scraped or seeded this year. If the Minister makes inquiries he will find that I am telling the truth so far as County Roscommon is concerned, and I do not mean that the people there are the worst offenders. I recommend to him that he should make inquiries into this and see what can be done. It may be rather too late to do anything about it now, and for that reason I am sorry that this Estimate did not come up earlier for consideration so that the matter might be raised.
As I have said, I had no intention of speaking on the Estimate were it not for the fact that I am anxious to remove the false impression which the Minister seems to have got—that because our county committee has a Fianna Fáil majority it is necessarily opposed to any proposal which he puts up. I think if that were to happen it would be very wrong, and that if the Minister's mind were prejudiced in any way it would be a bad thing. I have attended every meeting of the county committee for several years and I can assure the Minister that not one single decision of that committee has ever been arrived at on political lines. That applies particularly to the county committee of agriculture. I hope the Minister will believe me in what I am saying, and will act accordingly. In so far as the Minister is anxious to improve conditions in this country, he will have my wholehearted co-operation, as would any other Minister. This is a very serious matter because the Department of Agriculture is, from the point of view of the majority of the people, the most important Department in this State. I hope that the Minister will take what I have said in that light.
Comment on this
Kiltullagh. That was after the cessation of the turf production scheme. That is all I have to say, and I hope the Minister will give attention to the matters that I have mentioned.
Comment on this
I propose to be very brief, but I really could not face the majority of my constituents if I allowed this opportunity to pass without saying a few words to congratulate the Minister on his success, and also his Department, during the past year. Despite what the Fianna Fáil Deputies may say and the propaganda they use through the country, the Minister is very popular because he has had the courage to tackle our agricultural problems in the proper way. I am in thorough agreement with his proposal to increase the number of agricultural instructors. We have at the moment a system of instruction that is archaic and obsolete. Some of the agricultural instructors to whom I have been speaking feel that the system under which they are working results in a waste of money, and that they cannot give a sufficient return for the salaries they are receiving. One reason for that is that their areas are so extensive that most of their time is spent in travelling. If an instructor delivers a lecture in a parish in some particular year it will probably be ten years before he returns to give another lecture.
A lot has been said about the inspectors who were appointed during the Fianna Fáil régime. In my opinion, the money that was spent on them was wasted. If, during the emergency, the Fianna Fáil Government had given guaranteed prices to the farmers for what they produced there would have been no necessity to have inspectors. There is no doubt that, if the farmers of this country get an economic price for what they produce, they will avail of their opportunities, and there will be no need for inspectors.
As regards the additional instructors who are to be appointed, the success of the scheme envisaged by the Minister will depend on a continuation of the policy of guaranteed prices over a period of years. I am sure the Minister himself is well aware of that fact. If the farmers are given a guaranteed market and guaranteed prices they will welcome the instructors and will be only too glad to avail of their instruction.
The people in my constituency are greatly interested in the question of drainage. A lot has been said down the country to the effect that the Minister is slow about putting the drainage scheme into operation. People complain that they really do not know what is in the Minister's mind as regards the scheme. In my constituency of Sligo-Leitrim, the valuations in Leitrim especially, are very low—£3, £4 and £6. I would ask the Minister to expedite the putting into operation of that scheme in my constituency because the majority of the farmers there see no prospect of ever being able to increase the size of their holdings. There is not sufficient land there to be acquired and divided by the Land Commission. The next best thing, so far as they are concerned, is the carrying out of a drainage scheme and the provision of fertilisers to increase the carrying capacity of their small farms.
I listened to my colleague Deputy Gilbride speak here this evening. His speech rather disappointed me because I know him to be a sound, solid, common-sense man. He comes from farming stock as I do myself. I would invite him to make his own speeches in future and not to speak as a Party man. He referred to the question of oats and said that the small farmers of Sligo needed an increased price for what they produce. Last year the price of oats was raised by the Fianna Fáil Deputies at the Donegal by-election. Oats were then fetching 22/- and 23/-per cwt. on the Sligo market, but as a result of the campaign that was started at that time the price was fixed at 2/- per stone so that the farmers had to take 16/- for their oats. That is what Deputy Gilbride stood for, so far as the farmers of Sligo-Leitrim are concerned.
The question of the advisability of confining ourselves to one export market for our cattle was also raised. Well, our memories are not so short that we cannot recall what happened in 1932 during the economic war. Deputy Childers said it was deliberately and intentionally conducted. We were made well aware of that down the country. The Government of that time tried to get a continental market for our produce and they failed. Perhaps the Fianna Fáil Deputies imagine that if we had a second market the price of our cattle would fall. I think that was the gist of Deputy Gilbride's remarks. I do not see why he should begrudge the small farmers, whom he claims to represent, the £25 or the £27 per head that they are getting at the moment for yearlings.
I am in thorough agreement with the Minister as regards the selection of dairy herds. I think that the shorthorn cow is the most suitable one for this country, particularly for the small farmer, because she is the type of cow that will stand up to all sorts of weather. Fianna Fáil did attempt to introduce the Friesian breed. I know something about the different breeds of cattle. My opinion is that if the small farmer was confined to the one breed —the Friesian—he would find his position rather difficult. The Friesians are a delicate class of cattle. In the winter and spring—if you had bitter showers of hail—the farmer would need to stand over them in a field with an umbrella. I think that if the farmer were confined to that breed of cattle a considerable reduction in milk supplies would soon be noticed.
I was glad to hear the Minister say that he intends to encourage the growing of barley. It is a crop that can be easily grown, and has not to be sown until late in the season. I believe the middle of May is the proper time to sow barley. That is the experience of the farmers in Sligo and Leitrim. The fattening qualities of barley are equal to those of maize meal, Indian meal.
Deputy Sweetman took the Chair.
Comment on this
If I were to say any more, I think I would be merely repeating what has already been said, so I will conclude by congratulating the Minister on the very fine job he has done during the past year. The production of bacon and butter has jumped up, I might say, at an alarming rate. Some of us wonder what happened the butter and the bacon during the Fianna Fáil régime. It certainly did not find its way to the counters in the shops in the cities and towns and it did not find its way into the homes of the poor people.
Deputy Blaney rose.
Comment on this
I heard the Minister just now mentioning that this is the 29th hour of the debate. I wonder why he should pass a remark such as that? Is it that what has been said on the Opposition side of the House is not very good medicine for him? Is it that he feels sore because the allegations that are being made against his policy, or lack of policy, are well-founded?
I am very sorry that the Minister has seen fit to leave the House just now, because I would like to disabuse his mind and the minds of many Deputies in the benches behind him with reference to a few matters which, I thought, were very well known to anybody, both inside and outside the House, and on which I am somewhat loath to speak because so much has already been said.
I heard so many strange views aired over there for the past few days that I feel I must again refer to the problem that the farmers in my constituency and in many other constituencies found facing them this year in relation to potatoes, oats and flax. I do not want to labour this point, but I should like to say, in reply, particularly to Deputy Keane, who made the statement that everybody got a remunerative price for oats this year, that that seems to be something which the Government members wish to put around and wish the people to believe. I dare say if they repeat it often enough they will get some people to believe it, but you will not have among them those who still have got oats and cannot find a market for it. The fact is that there is not a market big enough to absorb all the oats on the hands of the farmers. There are still oats in Donegal for which there is no market. We hear some Deputies shouting across the House and talking about the market that is available, but I would be very glad if they would let the people in Donegal, who have oats on their hands, know where that market is and what is the price.
Deputy Keane said that he saw recently in some papers where labourers and farmers in Donegal were working by moonlight packing potatoes for sale. As a matter of fact, that is true, but I do not want anyone to get away with the idea that because those people were packing potatoes in the moonlight or late at night that everything is as it should be. The fact is that for some weeks past these people were working very hard during the day trying to get their crops in and they found they had to work overtime if they were to pack their potatoes. These are potatoes which, I may add, should not be there at this time of the year to be packed. These potatoes should have been taken away months ago when it would have suited the farmers better to get them away and when they had more time to get them ready. But there was then no outlet for them. After the glut and when no market was available for months some opening eventually comes along, almost at the last moment, and these farmers have to do all sorts of things to get rid of some of their potatoes, even if they have to go so far as to pack some of them in the moonlight.
That is not the point I want to make here. I want to ask the Minister a question this evening and I was anxious, if it is possible, to have an immediate answer. This matter also has to do with potatoes—seed potatoes. During the past few months certified seed potatoes of the 1948 crop were for the first time in my county sold at ware potato prices, despite the fact that they had to be graded just the same as if they were going to be used for seed. Arising out of that naturally enough there is some confusion in the minds of the farmers who have been growing certified seed potatoes for years. There is confusion as to what is to happen the 1949 crop.
During the past three or four months I have endeavoured on several occasions, by way of Parliamentary question, to get some statement from the Minister as to what prospect the farmers have with regard to a market for the produce of the seed potatoes now in the ground. Each time the question was asked the same reply was given and that was to the effect that the matter was under consideration and a statement would be issued in due course. Later I pointed out the urgency of this matter from the farmer's point of view—that he really had to know what the price would be before he would put any potatoes in the ground. On that particular occasion the Minister replied that the matter was still under discussion and that a statement would be issued in the very near future. That was eight or ten weeks ago so far as my recollection goes. The same question was asked to-day and the reply has gone back again to its first state; it is not even in the "near future" now. The Minister merely says that it is still under discussion.
Is it any wonder that the farmers who engage to any appreciable extent in tillage, as the farmers in my area do, are confused and do not know what crop they should grow or what crop they should not grow? Many of them have sown seed potatoes again this year. Because of the Minister's early reply to my question they understood that they would know what the price would be before they sowed them. But the time came for sowing and they did not know the price. Rather than let the land go to waste they set their potatoes. They do not know what market they will have for them. They do not know what price they will get for them. What is still worse, apparently the Minister, who should know, does not know either.
With regard to flax the Minister has heard Deputies on the Government Benches say that the attitude which he adopted in relation to the flax market was right. But that attitude has definitely proved to be wrong because the growers and their representatives and the millers have accepted a lower price than the Minister was offered. If that is not proof that the Minister was wrong there is no point in saying anything more upon the subject.
Potatoes, flax and oats are the main crops from which the farmers in my constituency derive their livelihood. Because of the contradictory statements made by the Minister—particularly the statement made by him approximately this time last year—the farmers are really very worried. The Minister last year urged the farmers to grow more oats and potatoes and he assured them that there would be a good market available for the crops. In relation to oats he went even further than that at one stage; he said that if any farmer had any difficulty in getting rid of his oats he should drop a postcard to the Department and the Minister would fix him up with a good market. That statement was made about 14 months ago. It is obvious from that statement that the Minister did intend that some of the farmers should sell oats for cash. Yet, his opening remarks in introducing his Estimate this year were to the effect that the man who grew oats for cash should get out of farming altogether and in doing so he would be doing good for himself and for the country. Whether he would apprentice himself to a tailor or a cobbler really does not matter. Apparently in the last 14 months the Minister has changed his mind and that latest statement of his, following on the muddle that was made of the oats last year, is surely adding insult to injury. Farmers do not know where they are going. They do not know which way to turn. They do not know what they should do. One can scarcely wonder at that since they have been hit so very hard during the past year. Many of them have lost heavily. Some of them have lost to the extent that they will be compelled to get out of land altogether. I know that is true in one particular case at any rate. Some of the farmers are practically on the verge of bankruptcy to-day and the only encouragement the Minister can offer them is that they should apprentice themselves to tailors or cobblers or some other trade.
The effect of these contradictory statements made by the Minister is that tillage has declined all over the country. The area under tillage has diminished. I am not talking now about something I have been told. I have been down and across the country and it is evident that tillage is diminishing. That brings me to another inconsistency on the part of the Minister. Considering that the Minister's own maladministration over the past year has caused tillage to decline, it is rather strange to find the Minister at this late stage declaring that tillage is very essential. To quote his exact words:—
"Every farmer knows that if the maximum fertility and yield of his land is to be maintained, except in very exceptional circumstances tillage must constitute an essential part of his annual farming operations."
If that is so, how can the Minister justify his action and his statements over the past 12 months? Most people believed that the Minister's long-term policy was to get back to grass. That is the prevailing belief. No one can blame the people in general coming to that conclusion because of the Minister's own statements. Yet, far from getting back to grass, we now find the Minister declaring unequivocally that tillage is really essential. Possibly the Minister has such a large mind that these contradictions are simple to him. Possibly he can resolve them into something definite. Possibly he sees some goal for which he is heading in the future. Certainly the farmers do not see it. I would like the Minister to state clearly what he does mean in ordinary language so that the farmers will understand.
Not so very long ago the Minister talked here about importing maize. He mentioned a price of £1 per cwt. or £20 per ton. The fact, of course, is that you cannot buy maize at £1 per cwt., or even at 22/- or 23/- per cwt. The price is as high as 24/- to 26/- in my county. While the price of imported feeding stuffs, maize included, is at this high figure, I can assure you that there will be very good reason for tillage, but I want to know from the Minister, when these imported feeding stuffs become cheap, when they cost as little or less than we can produce the equivalent at home, what does he expect the farmers to do? He talks about feeding our produce to live stock, but if we can get feeding stuffs from abroad cheaper than feeding stuffs can be produced on the farm, you can hardly expect the farmer to lose money by growing the feeding stuffs himself.
I would urge the Minister to make a statement as to what is his long-term policy, whether we are going back to grass, whether we are going to have mixed farming or whether we are going to have tillage. I do not want him to hedge on this matter, to say that when feeding stuffs from abroad become cheaper than we can produce feeding stuffs at home, he will make a statement then and that that will be time enough. It will not be time enough. The farmers cannot change overnight from a grass policy to a tillage policy. You cannot pull down a switch and wake up in the morning to find that they have changed overnight from tillage to grass or vice versa. They have got to know in advance and only by knowing in advance can they possibly make the best of their land and make the land pay for their work on it.
I also heard a Deputy on the other side of the House—I cannot recall his name at the moment—challenge anybody on this side or elsewhere to point to one thing which the Minister had done wrong during his term of office. He seemed very serious about it, so serious that I really think he believed himself that there was nothing, absolutely nothing, that was not done perfectly. Despite the fact that the Minister is responsible for the wellbeing of the agricultural community, for the regulation of prices to enable that community to live, I shall mention a few things which the Minister has done wrong during the year. At least I take them to be wrong; possibly there are other people who take a different view. The reduction in the price of tillage produce to my mind, in the present circumstances, is wrong, As I say there may be other people in the House who believe it is right. I do not. I do not believe that to reduce the price of eggs is right. I do not believe the reduction in the price of poultry is right; neither do I believe the reduction in the price of oats and in the price of potatoes is right. Yet, I have heard it stated from the other side of the House—and I am almost convinced that everyone who said it really believed it—that the present Minister had done nothing wrong during his term of office.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not know that the general price of agricultural produce is higher this year than last year?
Comment on this
If the Minister had taken me up properly, he would have noticed that I enumerated the items.
Comment on this
That is enough. On the question of the price of eggs, I should like to ask the Minister is it a fact—I have heard it but I do not know how true it is—that the price of 5/- per case paid to collectors was cut to 1/- not so very long ago. The Minister is not here and I cannot find out one way or the other. If it be true—and I have been assured it is—it seems a ridiculous figure for handling eggs.
Comment on this
I heard that the collection rate for eggs has been cut from 5/- to 1/-.
Comment on this
The Minister has absolutely no control over that. Has not the quantity of eggs gone up?
Comment on this
That reminds me of a point that has been troubling me for a long time. I remember hearing a lot about eggs some time ago—a lot of "ballyhoo" as it since turned out to be. I believed at one time, and I think a great many farmers and their wives believed it too, that the more eggs we produced the higher the price would be. The price was 3/- per dozen at that time. Many more eggs have been produced since but, strangely enough, the price has not gone up. It has, as we all know, gone down. I should like to ask anybody to give an explanation as to how that came about since we were told that the more eggs we produced, the higher the price would be.
Comment on this
These are the points which I want to bring to the Minister's notice. The fact that he is not here means that they have not been, and very likely will not be, brought to his notice and, even if they were brought to his notice, I doubt very much if I would get very much information from him judging from the results I have had in putting Parliamentary questions during the past few months.
I should like to conclude by asking Deputies who support the Government, who are committed to support it— whatever way they are lined up I do not know—to examine their consciences when they get up to speak here and if they have any criticism to utter, as I am sure most of them have of the present Minister, then let us hear it instead of their getting up one after another, parrot-like, to tell us that we have the greatest Minister in Europe.
Comment on this
I do not at all agree. Nobody in his rational senses, who knows anything about agriculture, could agree that he is the best Minister in Europe. Not alone do I think he is not the best in Europe but I think he would have a very tight race to escape the last place. With that I will leave the floor to some other person.
Comment on this
I rise for a few minutes only. I have listened to the people on the opposite benches for the last three days and I do not blame them for painting the picture they painted because naturally they have to say that the country is doomed. During the general election the leader of their Party told the people that if they did not vote Fianna Fáil the country was doomed, so naturally the T.D.s of the Opposition must try to tell us here that the country and the farmers are ruined. The great issue here has been oats. I am surprised at Deputy Allen who lives near the people who advertised for oats in the local paper, the Enniscorthy Echo, of March 26th, 1949:
"We are open to buy large quantities of good, sound white oats. Highest market prices paid. M. Breen and Sons, Raheenduff, Oulart."
Comment on this
Last Monday week I was in Wexford and there was a boat there being loaded with oats. I went to see it and people told me that it was the first cargo of oats to leave Wexford in ten years. I see potatoes coming in on lorries from almost as far as Wicklow. Some are brought by tractor. There must be a market for them and I was surprised at Deputy Gilbride— I think it was—saying that in Sligo the potatoes were rotting in the fields and in the ditches. That is a shame when there are plenty of people in the City of Dublin and in provincial towns who cannot get them cheaply. Cabbage costs 1/2 a head here in Dublin. Potatoes are not as plentiful as you say at all and I come from the best agricultural county in Ireland where there are no lazy farmers.
Comment on this
I suppose you are insinuating that there are in my county.
Comment on this
We heard a lot about the price of milk and the scarcity of milk. Deputy Allen had milk brought from his own constituency to Dublin —not to give it to the youngsters, but for the ice-cream vendors, the Italians who are using gallons of milk that should go to the people. I hear a lot about scarcity but I saw in the papers that during the Dublin Show farmers of the 32 Counties were looking for machinery at Ballsbridge, the latest most modern type of machinery. What was it for? Because the Minister for Agriculture said that higher wages had to be paid to workers and they are trying to counteract that by using machinery. There is a campaign for farmers to put men on short time, to shorten their hours, because they do not want to pay them £3 a week. They can pay £700 or £1,000 for a tractor but they cannot pay their labourers £3 a week. They will put a man out on the street and then you are talking about unemployment. Fianna Fáil farmers that never needed to sack a man say there is unemployment.
Comment on this
There is plenty of unemployment without Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
There is a campaign going on to do it. What is Deputy Allen going to do to give employment?
Comment on this
Did the Deputy not cut down the Estimates himself? I have the minutes in my pocket and I can produce them if you want them. All are worried about the workers to-day. When I came in here in 1943, 1944, 1945, 1946 and 1947 asking the then Ministers, Deputy Ryan and Deputy Smith, to increase agricultural wages, how did they escape an answer? They said: "It is not my function but a matter for a wage board." That was their cry, but the present Minister said he would see that they would get an increase and they got it while for years before that the previous Ministers were putting it on to a wage board. You want better prices and you want the cost of milk brought down. You want the cost of producing milk brought down and the price for the people who have to exist on it to go up. Who has to pay for that increase but the working class people in the towns and cities? I would like to see eggs at one penny each because every poor person could get one then. Who will be affected by a rise in price?
Comment on this
The working classes. Why are people travelling to the Department for Agriculture for grants for hens if they are not paying?
Comment on this
Deputy Allen objected to interruptions when he was speaking and should not interrupt now.
Comment on this
Every other day the Department gets applications for fowl-houses, yet you say that hens are not paying. All that leads us nowhere. We are only 15 months on this side of the House and if the great fortunes that were made during the previous 16 years under Fianna Fáil have broken inside 15 months those people have a great deal of credit. We all got the figures given by the Minister which showed an increase. I would certainly say that the bacon came out anyway. Wherever it came from, everyone can get a rasher now. Where was it during the Fianna Fáil time? They are trying to make capital out of the white flour and, at the same time, they are saying that we wanted more pollard and bran. How will you get pollard and bran if you have not an extraction? You got flour from America and you did not let one spoonful of it go to the people who wanted it.
Comment on this
If you want to buy beer you will get it cheap but if you want to drink whiskey you will pay for it and the same applies to that. We are not asking you to buy it but there are people who can afford to pay it.
Comment on this
You need not talk; we know your tactics. Slogans will get you nowhere. There was one thing that did the farmers more good than all the talk here and that was the few showers of rain we had during the week. They were a godsend to the farmers of the country and to the nation. There is nothing here but unfair attacks. Deputy Allen spoke about the export of horses. I see horses going out of my own town every fair day and farmers getting £10 or £20 for them though they are broken down and good for nothing; whereas if that were not the case the farmers would be giving them away for greyhounds for a few tips. If they had not got this, they would have to sell them as food for the dogs. I think it is a great market to get rid of all the old horses in the country.
Comment on this
I do not know what Chappies factory is. One of the Fianna Fáil people was the agent to buy up these horses in my constituency.
Comment on this
Why not label it "Dog Food" and they could have it? Was that not the idea—to have it labelled "Dog Food", but the people interested would not do that? I suppose they would get nothing out of it. We heard a lot about guaranteed prices. Deputy Allen and Fianna Fáil farmers know that, during the emergency, very few farmers got the guaranteed price for wheat from the flour millers. I know something about that, as I had questions down about it here.
Comment on this
I never got anything from anyone except what I earned hard. When I put a question down to the then Minister, Dr. Ryan, to see that the farmers got the guaranteed price, what was his answer? It is there on the records—"anyone that saved it well, in a reasonable condition". The farmers at that time in my constituency got only 45/- a barrel, when the guaranteed price was 55/- There was no guaranteed price there, after all the protection we heard about from Fianna Fáil. We would like to see the farmers doing well. The majority of them are not the worst-off section of the community. There may be small farmers who have no capital in the bank, but the majority of them are fairly well off to-day, after five years of a war with top prices. They are all sitting back snug, any Deputies who had any stock during the past war, and they have no need to worry.
Deputy Ó Briain comes from Limerick. There was a cry about the slaughter of calves. Why was that allowed to go on for years, until the change of Government? If the people were getting the calves slaughtered to get the skins, we all knew what was going on and there was no outcry at all about it. Thousands of young cattle were slaughtered, but if they had been on the market to-day the plain people in Britain would not be looking for 1/2 worth of meat a week—we would have cattle in the Dublin cattle market to give them. That is why there is a scarcity.
The Minister says he will have plenty of butter. He ought to bring some of it into the resturant here and give it to us. Whether it is the Minister's fault or the fault of the people running the restaurant, the committee looking after it ought to see that we get more butter. I know the poor people find butter a novelty. The majority of poor people get nothing but margarine, as they are not able to buy butter at 3/6 a pound. There are men living in the country on small wages, as road workers or agricultural workers, on 60/- a week, and they have to keep families on that. If anyone thinks that a good wage to be giving to the people producing on the land the food of the nation, then they are not doing justice to the people who are toiling up and down the fields after a pair of horses or a tractor.
The only thing is to pay skilled workers in any industry according to their skill—as skilled, semi-skilled and unskilled. If that was applied to the agricultural worker, the skilled all-round man would get more money and you would have young men to-day studying agriculture and the workings of machinery and the management of horses; but when you have the man who can only draw out the manure and the skilled man getting the same rate of wages, there is no proper encouragement. I am stating this from my experience as a worker myself. In the bacon factory, in the flour mills and in other skilled industries, there are three grades and naturally you will work to get the high grade with high wages. That is the reason why people are not staying on the land—the skilled man gets no encouragement.
We have had 15 months here with the present Minister for Agriculture who has met with great opposition, not alone in this House but from the county committees of agriculture, where the Fianna Fáil henchmen are doing everything to put a spoke in the wheel and agitating the farming community. That is very wrong, as we all depend on agriculture, no matter what sphere of life we are in. The towns and cities depend on it and that sort of thing is of no help to farming.
Regarding the talk about alternative markets, there was a time here when some responsible people said: "Thank God, the British market is gone, and gone for ever." They put cattle on the boat and it went around the seas, but they could not find a market for it and they had to bring it to Germany and give it away for nothing. That happened, but the people in opposition now would not believe that. Is not that true? The Deputies opposite were looking for alternative markets and could not get them.
Comment on this
You have an agreement now for three years ahead on prices. That was never got before.
Comment on this
A friendly nation, confining us to Britain practically.
Comment on this
In all the agreements, farmers never got three years to look forward to. They are to get 2/6 for the eggs for the next three years. They never got the 5/- which the British farmer had in the market, until the Minister for Agriculture got it in that agreement. These are the things that must be faced. The British farmer had 5/- more on the market for his cattle in preference to the Irish farmer.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen would believe nothing. He is an auctioneer and the more farmers who are down and out the more auctions he will get.
Comment on this
I urge that the agricultural labourer should get some benefit from the profits accruing to the farmer by reason of these agreements, because, if the working class people who are helping to produce are not enabled to get some of the benefits, no agreement is any good. It is all very fine for people to say that the agricultural labourer is well off, but agricultural labourers are the most depressed class of worker in the State, and, signs on it, the agricultural worker is going over to Britain where he can get £4 10s. 0d. a week. He cannot be expected to stay on the land here for £3, and some of them are not getting that, because they are an unorganised body, unlike industrial workers, and have not got a union strong enough to enforce their demands. I know farmers who have bought tractors which their sons are driving and they are going into their neighbours' fields and doing their tilling for them. That is why we have unemployment in rural Ireland.
People make complaints with regard to milk. In my town, a milk cart was put on a month ago which is selling milk at a price lower than that at which the milk hitherto has been supplied. I blame Fianna Fáil for the milk situation, because, when they brought in the Milk and Dairies Act, they forced people who had a few cows out of existence with their regulations. They gave a monopoly to the few and the small farmer had to give up selling milk. In our own area, when the free milk scheme came into operation, we found that we could not get a person to supply a pint of milk to a poor person. They were afraid to do so as they were not registered dairymen. The supply of milk was left to three or four vendors and other people who had not got an up-to-date dairy, although they had supplied milk for years, were put out of production. Milkmen had to have white coats and special buckets had to be bought, but, when a few people got a monopoly, the white coats and the Irish on the back of the carts were forgotten. Milk in the rural towns is dear enough and the reason for the prevalence of tuberculosis is that the youngsters are not getting fresh milk because their parents cannot afford to buy it.
Comment on this
We will. We have already changed the bacon position. The whole mistake Deputies opposite made was in thinking that we would not be here six weeks, but the figures which were given here will be greatly improved upon next year, and well these Deputies know it.
Comment on this
The only cockshot they have now is the Minister for Agriculture because he made certain statements when on the other side of the House, but we all heard Deputies opposite making statements in 1932.
Comment on this
He is a practical man, a man who has travelled and a business man, with as good a knowledge of agriculture as the two people before him—misfits of doctors.
Comment on this
Deputies opposite have oats on the brain. There were 300 hens in the County Home in Enniscorthy, and we had to send five or six members of the county council to investigate why they had no oats, and, while we are on the subject, I might add that when the committee went to inspect the oats sent into the institution, 32 stone of oats, they found it was all hulls, but the top price was paid to a supporter of the Fianna Fáil Party. I saw on the paper recently that a question was asked in the British House of Commons about the agreement in regard to potatoes, and, bad and all as they are, the British Government said they intended to honour that agreement, although they did not require the potatoes, as they had had a bumper season themselves.
I should like to see the farm workers getting some benefit from any agreement made with England or any other country and surely the farmers ought to pass on some of their profits to the men working on the land. I do not believe that farm labourers with £3 a week are receiving a living wage, in view of the cost of living. We see people who are 100 per cent. better off complaining when they get 11/- and asking for more—men with £6 and £7 a week. I am referring now to the Guards.
Comment on this
I should like to see the agricultural labourer getting that 11/-on top of his £3 a week. I am glad that the bacon factories are now working full time. Our own factory in Enniscorthy is working full time, although, under the Fianna Fáil Government for a time, there were not 20 pigs going into it per week. In addition to providing bacon, employment will be given in the production of pigs. There is a demand for young pigs at every fair. Sheep are £8 a-piece. I do not see what the farmers in the Fianna Fáil Party have to growl about. Of course, I know it is only political propaganda. They are not sincere. They know well enough that the farmers are doing well.
Comment on this
That is quite true. That is an honest admission.
An Leas-Cheann Comhairle resumed the Chair.
Comment on this
I shall not delay the House any longer because there may be other Deputies who want to speak before the Minister concludes, if they are going to let the Minister in at all to give the replies they are asking for. I hope he will be given plenty of time because I am sure he will be able to answer everyone.
Comment on this
He will be able to give them all their answer. There is no doubt about that. There is no argument to put up, only slander. They have not put up a good case yet, either for the farmers or the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
When I heard Deputy O'Leary, I was beginning to think that there was no further need to speak because, as at the Wedding at Cana, the good wine was kept to the last. The position as I know it is that the farmers of this country have lost confidence in the present Minister. Regardless of his many irresponsible, verbose statements, they are nevertheless satisfied beyond all doubt that one of the greatest calamities in the history of Ireland was when the present Minister was appointed to the post which he now occupies. It is unfortunate— perhaps we must blame the Taoiseach for it; perhaps circumstances—that the present Minister for Agriculture above all other members of Dáil Éireann was appointed to guide the destiny of the farmers and to guide the destiny of the all-important industry, agriculture.
Without throwing bouquets to the others of the 12 apostles who constitute the Independents, there were many sound people among them but, unfortunately for the farmers of this country and for the country as a whole, this one man was foisted on the people.
It is the duty of a Minister, by sound, sane utterance and by planning ahead, to give confidence to the people, especially to the farming community, to inspire them with confidence for the future, to give them the necessary assurances that their labours will not go unpaid. That is the duty of a Minister. Despite the many verbose utterances, proceeding from the unbalanced mind of the Minister, the farmers of this country find themselves in the position that they do not know whether they are on their head or their feet.
Deputy O'Leary made many wise remarks, although he had not the same ability as the Minister has to put his ideas into chronological order. There is no doubt that the Minister is a past master in the art of coining phrases and, so long as he utters his kind of phrases in this House, so long is he satisfied that he has done a good day's work, regardless of the consequences to the Irish nation. It appears to me from the many irresponsible statements that I have heard and the many irresponsible statements that I have read that if the Minister is able to reverse the old Sinn Fein policy of 1918, of self-sufficiency and preservation of the home market for the Irish farmer, and if he can insult every member who stood for that policy in the past, the Minister will have satisfied himself that he has done a good day's work for the country.
One of the policies preached in the past, preached by Griffith and other Irish leaders of 1916, 1918, 1920 and 1921, was that the curse of this country was emigration. We find the Minister for Agriculture, occupying as he does that all-important position, saying to the people that he hoped that every 20 of 21 children would emigrate. No Irishman worthy of being called an Irishman would dare to say anything except that emigration was the curse of this country and will remain the curse of this country until some plan is found to keep our manhood and the cream of the Irish nation at home. When we export our manhood, we continue to do the devil's own work for this country.
The Minister ought to know that the dairying industry is the all-important industry in this country. I remember when Australian butter was imported. I remember full well when the Irish farmer, in 1931-32, was getting 3½d. a gallon for his milk. The Irish farmers, unlike their antecedents, did not strike for a better price. Why, I do not know. They would have struck under an alien Government. Why they did not strike under an Irish Government, I do not know. While they were getting 3½d. per gallon they found that in every shop in the country they could purchase Australian butter, to the detriment of the Irish dairying industry.
The old Sinn Fein policy was resumed under Fianna Fáil and we preserved the Irish market for the farmer. The result was that under the Fianna Fáil régime, two years ago, the price of milk was fixed at 1/2 for a certain period, 1/6 for another period. Despite the fact that costings have increased considerably and that the rates on the Irish farmers are almost unbearable at the moment and despite, above and beyond all, the promise of the Minister for Agriculture that he would increase the price of milk, the Irish farmer finds himself getting the same price for milk to-day as he was getting two years ago when the cost of production was very much less.
There are in the mountainous areas of this country people who must depend entirely on the money they receive from the creameries by way of milk production. Every Irish Government—the last and the previous, the present and the future—owes a debt of gratitude that we can never repay to the mountainy farmers. One thing we should do to compensate them for their losses in the past is to give them a decent price for the one product that keeps them between poverty and frugal comfort. The mountainy farmers paid dearly and very dearly for the independence of this country. We made barracks of their homes and we bankrupted many of them. Many of them will never recover from the columns they kept in 1920 and 1921. Perhaps the Minister would not appreciate that. However, it is the duty of an Irish Government to give to those farmers an opportunity to recover and to compensate them in some way for the losses they have sustained and for their service and generosity which has undoubtedly been forgotten amongst those adherents of the inter-Party Government.
Tillage is decaying in this country. It behoves me to tell the Minister, if he does not know it already, that there are thousands of acres of land in this country being laid down without even putting grass seeds into them. I saw a 37-acre field only a couple of weeks ago and no grass seeds were being put into it. The weeds will grow and nobody dare contradict me when I say that it will take at least ten years before that field is back again in normal production, unless a large amount of fertiliser is used on it for that purpose. Tillage was the one thing more than anything else that gave employment in rural Ireland. It gave an assurance to the farm worker that he need not go to Britain or anywhere else for employment. While the farmers of this country were tilling their land—especially the larger farmers who had of necessity, and no apologies about it, to till a percentage of their land—there was no danger of unemployment amongst farm labourers. To-day, we have, unfortunately, in every parish, district and townland in the country unemployment of farm labourers. These men are now doing their best to get work on the roads and so forth. What I say is true. I know of one instance where six out of 11 had to go because the farmer had gone back from tillage to grass. If the Minister doubts my statement I shall give the name to him privately but I am not going to say it in public.
Comment on this
None so deaf as those who will not hear. There is a large and respectable section of the farming community to which the Minister has not referred. I am thinking of those farmers who have very little capital, if any, and who—perhaps in many cases through no fault of their own — lack sufficient capital to restock their land where they had mortality in cattle——
Comment on this
——during the recent years. They might as well speak to the moon as to think they are going to get credit from the Agricultural Credit Corporation. As a matter of fact, it is much easier for them to get credit from the banks than to get credit from the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I know the case of a man who lost six cows last year. He is a hard-working man—a man who can produce over 100 barrels of wheat, barley and oats as well. However, because there was in his home a simple boy who, under his father's will, could not sign his rights away to the Agricultural Credit Corporation that man was refused a loan. The simple boy whom Almighty God had given to that homestead was the impediment. Is there any sound commonsense in such a refusal? It is hard to mention matters of that kind in this House.
Comment on this
Whoever may have fixed the rate of interest for the Agricultural Credit Corporation, I know perfectly well who fixed the rate of interest in regard to housing. You increased it from 2½ per cent. to 2¾ per cent. That is the answer I am giving the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Minister himself would bring in the Southern States of America if it suited him to do so. The Minister has been very severe in regard to those people who use horses to till and cultivate their land. Deputy O'Leary very kindly reminded me of the fact that he said a few months ago that everybody in the country could get rid of them. In the Deputy's own words—and remember, he is one of the people who keep the Minister there— he said that every old hollow-back in the country could be exported and that the farmers would get plenty of money for them.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary was speaking in complete ignorance of the facts and if he has patience with me for a moment or two he will be enlightened as to what happened. If I were to tell him that 260 people were put out of employment in Clonmel because of the decision of the Minister for Agriculture not to allow the factory there to proceed——
Comment on this
I can assure the Minister than when God made us he matched us and that he will not get away with anything with me.
Comment on this
I am going a bit further for Deputy O'Leary's information because he is one of the gentlemen who spoke very strongly in favour of trade unionism, full employment and good wages. It is quite on the cards that the Minister was prejudiced against some of the directors of that company. That is my honest opinion and that is one of the reasons, if not the chief reason, why he refused a permit to Chappie and Company to export horse flesh to nations that were looking for it. They were looking for it. The people of Sweden were looking for it— and the Minister knows it. Still you refused sanction because you did not like some of the directors, perhaps.
Comment on this
I am sorry. The Minister has been a bit vocal. At times he would lead you to believe that there was nobody in the House except himself. Chappies is closed down and 260 people, with an average of perhaps four or five depending on them as well, have been disemployed. That is what the Minister has done for the capital of Tipperary. The capital of Tipperary deserves better from an Irish Government than that they should deprive 260 people of good employment at top wages.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not heard that it has reopened, not to send out horse flesh as corned beef, but to send out beef.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that it has been bought over and is to go into full production shortly?
Comment on this
I should like Deputy Timoney to be able to assure me that it is going into full production and will remain in it. It will be in production for a few months to the detriment of other canning industries in this country and, thank God, it is not Tipperary directors who are doing that. They would not stand for taking the bit out of the mouth of the Waterford people or the other people who are in the canning business.
Comment on this
I am glad to be able to boast that gallant Tipperary would not dare to do a thing of that kind. There are no "emergency" men in Tipperary.
Comment on this
If I were to discuss John Brown, some of you would blush very much. If it were not for him, the economic independence of this country would not be established and you did your damnedest to smash it. We won the economic war in spite of you. The farmers of this country stood up to it —the majority of them, anyway, because there were some black sheep. You have a similar fight yourselves now and we shall see how you will stand up to it.
In my absence, the Minister on one or two occasions accused me of sabotage. We had many debates here in the months of November and December on oats and potatoes. The Minister at that time was going over to America to settle world affairs, having of course settled the agricultural problem here. As a matter of fact there is a story told that during the voyage there was a Question Time and the compére asked, "Who is the greatest man the world ever produced?" One very good looking gentleman, a very honest man said, "James Dillon." The compére asked: "How do you know James Dillon is the greatest man the world ever produced"? and the answer was, "I am James Dillon."
Comment on this
The Minister will have to take his medicine, just as he gave it. In my absence, the Minister accused me of sabotaging his whole agricultural policy. Could you believe that the policy of the Minister was so fragile that a Deputy in a few minutes speech could smash the whole thing to atoms? That was the Minister's excuse and the only one he has ever offered this House for the mess he has created by promising farmers that if they grew oats he would give them a remunerative price and if they grew potatoes he would give them £10 13s. 6d. a ton. Every farmer was delighted with that, thinking that the Minister was speaking with responsibility and that he was sincere.
Comment on this
We would not like to have Deputy Cowan in doubts about what happened. The Minister for Agriculture made the dreadful statement that I sabotaged his whole agricultural policy. When the Minister makes a statement of that kind I would not dare to say he told a lie, but I am going to say that he handled the truth very carelessly. Speaking at a meeting in Tipperary, composed mostly of practical, hard-working farmers who produce beet and wheat and the other things upon which this nation survived and on which this nation hopes to survive and become an independent selfsufficient nation, I told them that from many statements I heard here I concluded that the Minister for Agriculture had made a complete mess of agriculture so far as oats and potatoes were concerned.
A child of five would realise that the Minister had made a mess of it and that he was not even going to try to help the farmers. "Smart Alec" talk and high-falutin phrases were all the Minister had to offer the farmers after advising them to grow oats at a remunerative price and potatoes for £10 13s. 6d. per ton. The result was that when the farmers grew the oats—and they certainly had a very plentiful harvest—they could not get the merchants to buy the oats. Some of them sold the oats at as low a price as 18/- a barrel. I know others who offered the oats at £1 per barrel, plus the straw which was left after the oats was threshed. That was a very different price from what they got the previous year. Many farmers that year got as high as 39/6 per barrel for oats.
Many people who were the victims of the Minister's promises had taken conacre in order to grow oats. The result was that they had threshed it and having no place to sell it had thrown it out in the garden with no protective covering whatsoever. They were the victims, perhaps. Unlike some of the Minister's friends they did not have the big stores to put it into. They did not have the capital to survive the calamity that had overtaken them. The position was to clear it out at any price or let the elements take the best of it. The Minister has few, if any friends in this country and definitely not in Tipperary except the rates. They are the only people he caters for. The rats have grown fat on the Minister's policy or his lack of policy.
Comment on this
It is a pity that the Minister is leaving the House. However, if he decides on going I am afraid it takes much from the spice of my argument. Deputy O'Higgins complimented me on being stout. I certainly do not owe any of it to Deputy O'Higgins. I advise him to read the history of The Invincibles and he will not get overburdened with fat as a result. The Minister has gone away. Apparently he cannot take it. The Minister is a very proud man. Mind you, most decent, honest people are proud too. The Minister cannot take it because a former statesman said on one occasion, he had the brains of a pig; he is as proud as a peacock who has less brains. I am sorry he has gone.
One word in consolation—he referred in a disparaging manner to certain farmers in this country. He advised them to be apprenticed to tailors or to cobblers. What is wrong with being a tailor or with being a cobbler as long as you are an honest man? How dare any Minister or any Deputy in this House refer to any man with an honest trade in such a way? The great Master Himself had a trade; St. Joseph had a trade. What is wrong with it? Why use these disparaging remarks when referring to tailors and cobblers? Why should that happen in a Christian country? If the Minister had waited I would have asked him to withdraw. The only thing I can say to the Minister is that it is a good job he was not apprenticed to a tailor because, judging by the way in which he has handled agriculture, he could not make a jacket for a gooseberry.
Comment on this
I did not intend to speak on this Estimate for Agriculture but I received a letter to-day from a man in Cork who is a flour, meal and general provision merchant:—
"A Chara,
I wonder if it was to reduce the cost of living and to increase the supply of eggs that the price of maize was advanced £1 per ton in Cork this morning. The millers refused to supply only at advanced price."
That letter was sent to a colleague of mine, Deputy Corry. As he has already spoken on this Estimate he asked me to give it to the House.
While I am on my feet at all I thought I would say a few words as to how this Minister for Agriculture is acting in the view of the city man. It would appear to me that the policy of the present Minister is to drive the people of rural Ireland away from the land and to compel them to go to the cities and towns of this country as well as driving thousands more out of the country completely. Of course, as Deputy Davern stated the Minister said that if a farmer had a family of 21 it would be a good thing if 20 went away and one was left at home to rear another family of 21 on the same farm.
I am very glad that the Minister for Justice is here. I belong to a trade which is closely allied to the agricultural industry. I believe that every blacksmith in this country, including the Minister for Justice, strongly resents the Minister's attitude to the horse in this country. In March, 1948, he stated that only for the sake of freedom he would make it illegal for any man to plough with horses. In other words, he was giving the blacksmith, carpenter and the harness-maker notice to quit rural Ireland. The horse and everything connected with it is produced in this country with, perhaps, the exception of the iron for the shoes and for parts of the cart. While I have no objection to mechanising the agricultural industry in this country I believe that it can be overdone. No tractors are made in this country; they are manufactured in other countries and brought into this country. The oil, petrol, spare parts and everything connected with them have to be brought into this country. It is very doubtful that they are such a good proposition as many of the people on the other side of the House seem to think. I cannot see any blacksmith or any rural tradesman supporting a policy such as this. If they voted for the present set-up, I do not believe they ever thought it would be the policy of that Government to try and drive the horses out of this country. We can all see that the people of this Government thought it better to have motor cyclists than horses even for the President's escort.