Committee on Finance. - Vote 29—Agriculture (Resumed)
Contributions 412–627 of 627. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I cannot see any reason for this activity of the Minister against the horse except that perhaps some time or another he might have got a bad kick from one. Mind you, some of those horses are fairly intelligent. I am sure Deputy O'Leary, Deputy Dunne and the rest of the Labour Party will agree with me that all those tractors are not going to increase the number of agricultural workers. They are certainly going to help to decrease the workers and the population of rural Ireland. I imagine that the Minister for Justice is thinking the same as myself although he will not say it, as one old blacksmith to another.
Comment on this
I was very much surprised last night to find there were Deputies belonging to Clann na Poblachta who seemed to be in favour of this policy of taking the people out of rural Ireland and putting them into the big towns.
I was very much surprised to find a man like Deputy Timoney standing up and objecting to the chocolate crumb factory that was put up at Rathmore by the Fianna Fáil Government. As he said, it should have been put in Tipperary town. Now I, possibly, believe that the best place for that factory would be in Cork. I suppose there are a lot of other people who believe that the place for it would be Dublin. I would like to know why the people of Rathmore are not entitled to get employment in their own area. Why should they be forced out of their own area, and why should they be forced into places like Dublin to make Dublin bigger than it is? I would like to see factories like it started in every rural area. If that were done it would be better for this country. There would be a better balance and a lot could be saved on the transport of food to feed the people of Dublin.
I have a note here with reference to the promises of the Minister as regards potatoes and oats, and the statement that he made that he would not put a floor to the price for oats. Apparently, the Government had to wait until he was in America. When they saw the Donegal by-election coming along they said: "Well, we will have to do something about this; anyway, the Minister is away and we will fix the price of oats." The Minister had stated that on no account would he do it.
Last Friday I listened to Deputy Corry speak on this Estimate. I think there is a lot of truth in what he said. The Minister's two strong points, as regards agriculture, seem to be pigs and eggs, and, as Deputy Corry wisely remarked, you could carry on these businesses in any kind of a decentsized back-yard. You could feed pigs and hens and you would not want any land at all. If agriculture is going to be developed on that line, perhaps the city Deputies will be taking more of an interest in agriculture than ever before, and the country Deputies will be finding that there are more valuable dogs than greyhounds, and that the cattle dogs, to mind the cattle, will be making a higher price, because, apparently, that is all that will be wanted in this country. You will not want horses, men or anything else—only a sheep-dog and a boy.
Comment on this
One after the other, the Coalition Deputies have congratulated the Minister on being the best Minister for Agriculture this republic ever saw. Some of them joined with the Taoiseach in going so far as to say that not only was he the best Minister this republic ever saw but that he was the best Minister for Agriculture the world ever saw. There is one Minister in the Government to be congratulated on having the best Minister for Agriculture in the world, the most subservient Minister for Agriculture in the world, and that is the Minister for Finance. When the Minister for Finance, last year, wanted to make some savings the Minister for Agriculture stepped into the breach, held up the farm improvements scheme and stopped the farm building scheme.
This year, when the Minister for Finance wanted some more money he gave over some of the food subsidies to the Minister for Agriculture and immediately he started to save by doubling the price of white flour, and, recently by making the use of white flour compulsory for the making of cakes for sale. Had the Minister for Agriculture been in opposition when some Minister in the Government doubled the price of white flour and made white flour compulsory in the making of cakes for sale thus increasing their price, we would have heard him denounce that roundly with some of the old phrases that he used about former Government policy. He would call it "a dirty trick,""a dirty deceitful game,""a shuffling cloutish way of dealing with the problem" and getting some money for the Minister for Finance, "a vicious, contemptible, mean jab at the poor."
The Minister for Agriculture of course and people of his standard of income can afford to eat cakes, no matter what price they go to and the Minister for Agriculture, in order to get some money for the Minister for Finance, will force them to pay it or go without. But when the Minister for Agriculture fixes the price of some agricultural produce here he claims it as his duty to fix it at a price that everybody can afford. When Deputy Dunne wanted him to stop the flood of foreign tomatoes last year, the Minister for Agriculture said:
"I decided to permit the importation of tomatoes to such an extent that supplies will be available for all sections of the community at prices which all, including the poor in our towns and cities, can afford to pay."
Comment on this
That is a trick of the Minister's that I am going to expose before I sit down—that when anyone quotes something effective against the Minister he says: "Quote it all". He wants me to quote the whole Dáil Debates, to give other parts of the Minister's statement in reply to supplementaries by Deputy Dunne who was not satisfied with the reply he received. The Minister was not going to eat tomatoes unless the people in Dominick Street and Meath Street were able to eat them. That is the Minister's attitude when he is fixing prices for farm commodities but not when he wants to collect sums of money for the Minister for Finance. He is then quite prepared to make certain that some of the lowest paid people in this country cannot eat cake, although he will not eat tomatoes unless they can because it would mean giving a reasonable price to the farmers. He will collect money for the Minister for Finance, even though certain sections of this community who heretofore, could afford it will have to go without cake.
The people of the country and the farmers of the country do not know from day to day what is the policy of the Minister for Agriculture. They cannot judge from his actions what way he is likely to go in the future. He jumps from one thing into another. I will now give another quotation from the Minister—a question which he asked a member of his own Party.
Comment on this
I will give it all. Deputy P.D. Lehane—Deputy Con Lehane would not dare embarrass the Minister by giving a quotation of this kind or saying anything about it— said on the 12th May, 1948 at column 1169:—
"The Minister said everybody who has a Jersey, a Friesian or an Ayrshire is a crank or an old maid.
Mr. Dillon: I should like the Deputy to refer me to that statement."
Well, I will refer him to it. The Minister for Agriculture, if he looks up column 2603 of Volume III will find that he said:—
"I know there are a lot of old maids and cranks in this country who keep Jerseys and Guernseys and Friesians and the rest of them."
Old maids and cranks! He tried to put Deputy Lehane off by saying: "I should like the Deputy to refer me to that statement"—that statement in which he said that everybody who has a Jersey a Friesian or an Ayrshire is a crank or an old maid.
Comment on this
Deputy Lehane was inaccurate to the extent that the Minister did not say "Ayrshire". But he did say Friesian or Jersey. He said:—
"I know there are a lot of old maids and cranks in this country who keep Jerseys and Guernseys and Friesians and the rest of them."
Comment on this
If the Minister goes further down the column he will see where he said:—
"If the Shorthorn cows of this country got one-third of the feeding and the fancy treatment that the Friesians and the Guernseys and the Jerseys and the rest of the Pekinese get...."
and he went on further to refer to the "fancy breeds".
Comment on this
The Minister sometimes can get away with a lot of tripe and he can say to a lot of his own members; "Quote me." I will quote him.
Comment on this
Yes, I am quoting him, and I will quote him further. I will quote something else that the Minister is trying to deceive our farmers about.
Comment on this
The man who exposes the Minister for Agriculture most effectively is the Minister himself, every time he opens his mouth, and the people know it. They have certain names for the Minister that it would be unparliamentary to describe him by here. The Minister may be getting into a frenzy. I know it was not possible for him to be satisfied with the mere celebration of the republic here. He had to go to Paris to do it. I understand he got into such a republican frenzy there that he spat on the grave of Marie Antoinette. He is not only a republican but a regicide—that is what he is now.
The Minister exposed himself, not only on that occasion by going to Paris, but he also exposed himself in reply to a question put to him by Deputy Smith about eggs. The Minister has been trying, ever since he made the agreement about eggs last year, to misrepresent the situation to the farmers. He sent this circular of the 14th April to the committees of agriculture, a circular which, in fact, was untrue and intended to deceive the farmers with regard to the egg agreement. We discovered to-day from the question put by Deputy Smith that the basic price that the Minister will get for the next two years is 30/8 a great hundred. That is 2/- above the basic price which was in the agreement of 1947 to apply to 1948 and 1949. The Minister succeeded in getting 2/- more, but he did not tell the country that of the £1,330,000 odd that Deputy Smith, when he was Minister for Agriculture, got from the British in order to give the additional amount to bring the price to the farmer up to 3/-, £500,000 or more was left unspent and still in the hands of the British. He did not tell them he left that in British hands in order that they might bring the basic price from 28/8 to 30/8.
The Minister in this circular also made a calculation as to how much extra his agreement would mean for 1950. In the third year of the Fianna Fáil agreement the basic price was only 20/-. That was the minimum price to be guaranteed and it was left open to negotiation to see how much higher it would go. We were satisfied with the two-year agreement and with having some minimum mentioned for the third year, but the Minister made the calculation that the minimum the British agreed to give us for the third year would be the maximum and he made a calculation as to how much more his agreement would make for the year.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Where a Deputy produces a document and purports to read from it, I submit it is deliberately disorderly to read from the document that which is not in it. I charge the Deputy with doing that now.
Comment on this
The Chair cannot have at his disposal every time a document is read from, the particular document, to see whether it is read in full or not. What I wish to draw the Minister's attention to is that he said the Deputy's statement is untrue and the Deputy knows it. That is a connotation which cannot be allowed to pass in the House and I ask the Minister to withdraw it.
Comment on this
I wish to draw the attention of the Chair to the fact that Deputy Aiken prefaced his introduction of the circular by saying that it was untrue and intended to deceive.
Comment on this
I trust the Minister will place on the Table a copy of this document that was sent to committees of agriculture on the 14th April and it will settle the matter. There is no use in arguing about these things. If the document is there it can be seen that for 1950 the Minister calculates that there will be 4,250,000 great hundreds of eggs exported at 1/5 a dozen or 20/- per great hundred, meaning 1/5 to the farmers when expenses are paid. He calculates that in 1950 we would get only 1/5 a dozen and he shows that his agreement means that the farmers will get more in 1950 because they are guaranteed 30/8. The 20/- referred to in the third year of the agreement was a minimum.
As the Minister has no minimum for the third year, I could as truthfully say that the Minister proposes to export 4,500,000 great hundreds of eggs for nothing because there is nothing in the Minister's agreement about the third year. At least we had in the third year a basic minimum of 20/-. The Minister has none. If he calculates and sends out information to the committees of agriculture that they will only get 20/- per great hundred, it would be true for me to say that in the third year they are going to get nothing and they will export their eggs for nothing.
Comment on this
It is absolutely correct and the Minister knows it is correct. What is more, I direct the attention of the committees of agriculture to the reply that the Minister gave to Deputy Smith to-day and to the circular that was sent out to them by the Department of Agriculture on the 14th April last. There is another point about this. The Minister laid down as a principle—a principle which dominated the policy-making aspect of his Department —that when a chicken would put its beak through the shell the farmer would be able to say: "If you are a pullet I know what every egg you lay will fetch during your economic lifetime." That was the principle he laid down. Now when Deputy Smith made the agreement the farmers put eggs to hatch in the month of December, 1947, and in the early months of January and February of 1948. Those farmers were expecting 3/- for 1948 and 1949. Suddenly in the middle of 1949 the Minister comes along and brings the price down to 2/6 because he wants to leave £500,000 in the hands of the British in order to subsidise prices during the operation of this agreement. Why should the Minister give the British "home assistance"? That is what the Minister for Education would call it; he referred to the £1,300,000 that we got from the British in order to give an increased price for eggs as "home assistance". The Minister for Agriculture himself denounced that agreement and said that we were asking the British to come over here and teach us our business.
He himself has asked a lot of other people to come over here and teach us our business, but that is by the way. Why did he leave £500,000 in the hands of the British when he made this agreement? Why did he break the principle he laid down that the farmer must know before the chicken comes out of the egg what the price per dozen will be for the eggs that chicken will lay if it happens to be a pullet? It is no wonder the farmers do not know where they are when the Minister enunciates different principles to suit himself in every particular difficulty.
Another principle that the Minister laid down was that it would be accepting the status of "poor peasant" for our farmers if we were to sell our flax for less than the northern farmers could get from the flax millers, plus what they could get by way of subsidy from the Northern Government. If it is demeaning our farmers to ask them to take less for flax here than the northern farmers can get from the northern millers, plus the subsidy from the Northern Government, how does he stand over asking our farmers to take 6d. less per dozen for eggs than they were getting under Fianna Fáil and about half what the British egg producer is getting? If it is demeaning to our farmers to ask them to take a few pence less per stone for flax, surely it is demeaning to ask them to take half the price for eggs? Let the Minister square that one out.
Comment on this
To come back to this agreement and to the old maid and crank who persists in breeding Friesians, the Minister himself was quite an advocate for a breed called "Friesian" a few years ago. I have another quotation for him, in which he said——
Comment on this
The Minister need not console himself by thinking he can put me off in that fashion.
Comment on this
Send out one of your Sancho-Panzas. Deputy Allen is very fleet of foot on messages like that. Deputy Ó Briain is very good, too.
Comment on this
Last year the Minister said that everybody who bred a Friesian or kept a Friesian or a Jersey was a crank and an old maid.
Comment on this
A couple of years before that at column 1528 of Dáil Debates, 6th June, 1946, the Minister said:
"If we want to go into the kind of dairying industry in which Denmark and New Zealand engage then we ought to go in for the Friesian cow. As a milk machine there is nothing to compare with her."
Comment on this
And he wound up by saying that—
"...as a means of producing milk it is fantastic to compare any existing breed with the Friesian cow."
Comment on this
And then, two years afterwards, he calls anyone who keeps one of these beasts a crank and an old maid and he calls the beasts themselves "Pekinese breeds." I would like the Minister to square that up when he is replying.
Comment on this
I want the Minister to square this up for the farmers. He said the Friesians were the best milking machine we could have and it was fantastic to keep any other breed for milk and then the next year——
Comment on this
On a point of order. This is the third time the Deputy has made that identical observation. Is he entitled to keep repeating himself?
Comment on this
I am perfectly certain the Deputies on the Government Benches do not like to hear it. I want to get this straightened out for the farmers. Otherwise where are they? Yesterday, or the day before, in challenging Deputy Lehane it seemed to me that the Minister was going back to what he said in 1946 and not to what he said in 1948. Before the end of this debate will the Minister let us know where he stands in this matter?
Comment on this
The Deputies can read the quotation. The people can read the quotation and they can reason quite well. The Minister need not think that because——
Comment on this
The Minister can gallop off to Paris because he cannot live a lie here. He thought he could shove a lie down everybody's throat.
Comment on this
I want to find out where the country stands in relation to cattle prices. The Minister made an agreement last year—an agreement which we always refused to make—to limit our exports to countries other than Britain to a certain percentage of what we sent to Britain. The Minister for External Affairs explained the reason for that limitation.
Comment on this
No, no. You did not get the wheel of your intelligence round the axle of his observation.
Comment on this
The Minister for External Affairs in an interview with the Manchester Guardian in September of last year said:—
"We on our part in the recent trade agreement have agreed to supply meat almost exclusively to Britain at prices far below those we could have obtained by selling elsewhere. I think that the British public appreciate this great gesture of our goodwill and faith in their recovery. These are the real constructive links in the chain upon which Anglo-Irish relationship should be based."
Comment on this
From the Manchester Guardian, and it is quoted in the Irish Press of September 27th and not contradicted since, although quoted and published almost eight months ago.
Comment on this
It was not contradicted although published in a paper in this country. One of the activities, the greatest activity possibly, of this Coalition Government is contradicting things that appear in the Irish Press. That was not contradicted because it is true.
Comment on this
The Minister need not think that he is going to put me out by talking that sort of nonsense. I challenge anybody in this House to read what I said and to read the quotations and see if there is any contradiction. It does not matter that the Minister says there is a contradiction. The people of this country are cleverer than the Minister thinks. The Minister is foolish in thinking that the people of this country are big fools. Give them an opportunity and we shall see where they stand.
Comment on this
I shall expose you. You must not try to change the typescript because you will not be let.
Comment on this
That is an activity in which the Minister for Agriculture indulges with great freedom on occasions, as all Deputies who read the volumes and have heard the Minister, know. The Minister did not deny a statement which appeared in the Irish Press on May 5th, when he said to the Irish Shorthorn Breeders' Association that his aim was to export 1,500,000 cattle to Great Britain within the next ten years. Further down he said:
"I am not one bit ashamed of saying that it is a proud assignment if we accept it, to help in time of need to restore as brave and gallant a people as ever defended the world against barbarism single-handed——"
Comment on this
It is from the Irish Press of May 5th. The Minister went out of his way to throw this fulsome praise at the British, who are still occupying six of our counties, three days after they announced a change in their law to perpetuate Partition.
Comment on this
That is the sort of tripe the Minister used. I should like the Minister to cut out that fulsome praise because the only barbarism we ever knew in this country was British barbarism.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy that this has nothing to do with the administration of the Department of Agriculture but he still continues to refer to a matter which has no reference whatever to the administration of the Department.
Comment on this
The Minister has not denied that, last week, speaking to the Irish Shorthorn Breeders' Association, for which we have some provision in this Estimate, he said it was his object, in spite of the fact that they were just after introducing a Bill, which this Parliament repudiated——
Comment on this
The fact that the Minister said it at the Shorthorn Breeders' Association does not make it relevant to this Estimate. The matter itself must be relevant before the Deputy would be in order in introducing it to this discussion.
Comment on this
I hope that on the conclusion of the debate on his Estimate he will let us know where he stands. Is this country going to be tied, as far as these people can tie it, so as to exclude us from the continental market by compelling us to export to the Continent no more than 10 per cent. of the cattle we send to Great Britain? It is a well-known fact that had it not been for the buyers from continental Governments for a number of years past, the price the Irish people got for their cattle would have been very much lower. Since this agreement was made by the present Minister for Agriculture, limiting our total exports to the Continent to 10 per cent. of the amount of our exports to the British——
Comment on this
Upon my soul, the Minister is the most astounding creature the world has ever seen. We spent days here discussing the agreement with that 10 per cent. provision in it. The Minister for External Affairs goes over to Britain and assures them it is in the agreement, and he is delighted it is in it, in order that we can show our love——
Comment on this
There is no such statement in the agreement negotiated by the Minister for External Affairs about 10 per cent. to Britain.
Comment on this
There was a reference to the fact that we could get more for the cattle on the Continent, only that we decided, for the love of the British, to send our cattle there.
Comment on this
Sit down then. Article 5 states:
"The Government of Ireland undertake that they will limit their exports of live cattle to countries other than the United Kingdom to 50,000 head in the 1948 season and to a number in subsequent seasons which shall not exceed 10 per cent. of their total exports of live cattle to all countries."
That is from the trade agreement presented to Dáil Éireann by the Minister for External Affairs on July 31st, 1948.
Comment on this
I thought the Minister might delay his entry into a mental hospital for some years, but after hearing that I think he should go there now.
Comment on this
We have limited our exports to the Continent to 10 per cent. of our total live exports to England.
Comment on this
Can I explain that again to the Deputy? It is a slow process but we will get it in by reading it again and again:
"The Government of Ireland undertake that they will limit their exports of live cattle to countries other than the United Kingdom to 50,000 head in the 1948 season and to a number in subsequent seasons which shall not exceed 10 per cent. of their total exports"——
Comment on this
I wish the farmers of this country who are dependent for their livelihood upon the policy of the Minister for Agriculture had been in this House to see that exhibition.
Comment on this
I will give the Minister an hour and ten minutes to finish if he wishes but I will conclude by asking him what he thinks the country gained——
Comment on this
Some of your Sancho-Panza brigade are very indignant about that. They think their Don Quixote should not sweep them away.
Comment on this
We might quote a parable from Don Quixote because never did I see anybody behave so much like Don Quixote as the Minister when surrounded by sheep which he thinks are an enemy army.
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell the House what advantage there was, in the effort to get our farmers to use more fertilisers and lime, in getting the Holmes Report. I read the Holmes Report and; like a lot of other reports written by agricultural experts, it was interesting, but there are at least half-a-dozen Irish experts I could name who could, in order to persuade Irish farmers to drain their land or improve it, write a better book than Mr. Holmes's. I think some of the advice he gave was open to grave doubt. I do not think that a lot of the New Zealand seeds which he proposes to broadcast here are anything like as good as native seeds. There is nothing produced in New Zealand or even in Aberstwyth to come up to the multi-leaved cocksfoot bred in Glasnevin ten years ago.
Before Mr. Holmes wrote his book I wish the Minister had explained to him that our low level of production in 1947 was due to weather as much as to deficiencies. Without a great increase in fertilisers we increased some production by 50 per cent. and others by 33?rd per cent. in 1948. With regard to Mr. Holmes's insult to the Irish people—if we are to take it as an insult—when he said that he had seen lands produce as little as lands could possibly do under Irish climatic conditions, there are millions of acres of land in every country in the world as bad, and millions of acres in New Zealand and a greater percentage of it than here. We admit that there is high development in certain sections of New Zealand but in other sections there is low development.
Comment on this
Although the Minister for Agriculture did stuff him with a lot of things that were unreliable, he might easily have dropped that out. I would say to him if I saw him that the book would be more valuable and likely to be read with more sympathy if he had not in his introduction hurled that at us. I would not like to see any good effects that might come of it nullified by a useless and unwarranted ukase of that kind. I want to give the Minister time to reply, and I hope to goodness he will give the farmers of this country who are looking for a line of policy some good definite line on the policy he intends to pursue while he remains in charge of agriculture.
Comment on this
I will not delay the Minister very long, because having read his quotation from the trade agreement, and as he is an ardent republican, I am sure he will be very busy during the next few months seeking alternative markets for our cattle as a result of recent legislation.
Comment on this
The Minister will discover at the next election. Before I say something which intimately concerns the people of my constituency and the Minister's——
Comment on this
I said I did not intend to delay the House, because after your reading the quotation from the trade agreement you would be very busy seeking an alternative market for our cattle.
Comment on this
That is all right. It is a matter for you. I am not Minister. Before I refer to matters intimately concerning the small farmers of my county I would like to refer to what is known as "white" flour. I would like to refer to it purely from a medical point of view. The Minister took the occasion of a visit to Castleblayney to make an announcement that the price of the best-quality bread and flour would remain but that as from the 15th January, white flour would be on the market at this fantastic price you all know. If the best-quality bread and flour already existed, what was the object of introducing an alternative quality, an inferior quality?
Comment on this
In other words, it is one of the many trick-of-the-loop devices invented by this Government to provide revenue and erroneously convey to the public that it was not going to increase the cost of living.
Comment on this
I think it is agreed that you have already asserted yourself that the best quality from the dietitians' point of view, in the opinion of dietitians, was the quality that already existed in the country.
The commodity that intimately concerns the Minister's constituents and mine is first of all potatoes for which he promised over £10 per ton. We are now getting £5 per ton for them and as the Minister knows—or perhaps he does not know—there is a glut of this commodity in County Monaghan.
He promised 45/- per barrel for oats. As a result of his protestations from platform and Press, 47,000 extra acres of oats were grown in this country. With what result? I appealed to you some time ago in connection with this glut of oats and asked you for suggestions and the only answer you gave me was that if I had any isolated case it would be dealt with. Might I refer the Minister to a letter I got following this answer from one of his constituents?
Comment on this
I will hand it over to you but I will read it to the House first. It has not been replied to and it was written on the 28th February.
Comment on this
"Dear Sir,
Seeing the reply given to you by the Minister for Agriculture regarding the sale of oats I wish to supply you with the following facts. Last spring I took 4½ acre of conacre——"
that the Minister is so fond of—
——for oats at £7 10s. 0d. per acre. I paid £10 for getting it ploughed by tractor. The harrowing and sowing I did with my own horses. I put seed oats in it at £3 per barrel. It was a success! The earth yielded forth its fruit in abundance. After plenty of hardship and expense (as it was four miles from home) I succeeded in getting it to the stage of threshing. I got it threshed but not sold. I have 80 barrels bushelling the required standard but no one wants it. I went to Dundalk and to Magee's, Ardee——"
I am sure the Minister knows the place referred to.
——"a registered merchant. He had no storage space. That was in January about the time that Dillon said in the Seanad that the amount of oats offered for sale wouldn't cover the floors of the merchants' stores. This merchant showed me his stores and one floor was propping the other with oats——"
Just get a load of that.
——"He said to call again in February. I did, with the same result. I have tried all the towns around, some would agree to take it at 23/-per barrel. That's no good. I expect there are plenty in the same boat as myself but why did the Minister for Agriculture encourage people to grow oats and then let them down in such a fashion. He needn't be showing his indifference. It is a serious case. I suppose there will be no redress."
I will give the Minister the letter and he may reply to it, as I have not done so yet.
Comment on this
The gentleman in question might have written to the Department or to me last February.
Comment on this
This is not an isolated instance. The Minister's panacea for all this glut of oats and potatoes is to feed it to live stock. I did not know, until he became Minister for Agriculture, that rats were included amongst live stock. He mentions about farmers having taken conacre at £7 10s. an acre. It is his declared intention to do away with the conacre system. Is he aware of the type of constituents he represents? If conacre were done away with in County Monaghan, there would not be a living for half the people there. Fortunately, even in his own constituency, the people have become so accustomed to him that they pay no heed to his eruptions concerning conacre, horses to ploughs, inspectors on land, and so on.
We now come to the interesting question of flax, which intimately concerns people of the constituency. Deputy Mrs. Rice very innocently asked a question early in February concerning the price of flax for the coming season and, to our utter astonishment—it must be remembered that the Minister, Deputy Rice and myself represent the constituency of County Monaghan, one of the best flax-growing counties in the country—we heard the Minister upbraiding Deputy Rice for embarrassing him in his negotiations with the flax-spinners. He informed us that these negotiations had commenced the previous June. This question was put early in February of this year. There was a complete vacancy from June until December, when the negotiations were resumed. Where was the Minister from June to December, if he was not attending to a matter of such urgent importance to the small farmers—and the women, particularly—of County Monaghan? Of course, he was flying his kite in the United States, escaping the declaration of the republic and speaking to the Americans and the British people and making suggestions to them as to how to ensure for the future the invulnerability of England from the new republic.
Comment on this
Yes, I was, and I am not a damn bit ashamed of it. As I told Deputy Collins in the debate on the Budget, better Irishmen than he or I have served the British Government in one capacity or another—and Deputy Collins, of all Deputies in the House, should be aware of that.
Comment on this
We will see what colours Deputy Collins will fight under, if ever he gets the chance, and he will be a great help to the country when the time comes.
Comment on this
I was making a rough calculation and it is interesting to think that, when some of us were making our contribution towards the effort by this country for independence, Deputy Collins was kicking the bottom out of his cradle.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I would like to know if this is relevant to the debate on agriculture.
Comment on this
I served six years in our Army, when Deputy Maguire was serving in the British Navy.
Comment on this
A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, I appeal to you for permission to speak. The Minister proceeds to upbraid Deputy Rice and myself for embarrasing him in connection with negotiations which were afoot at the time, not in December but in February. In connection with flax, conacre had been taken at the time and the seed was ready to go in. The Minister does not think for a moment, and cannot believe, that we would prefer to embarrass financially the small farmers of County Monaghan than to embarrass the Minister in his negotiations, which should have been completed at the time and for months previously. If it were a thing that he saw, as he should have seen if he had any brains at all, that negotiations in connection with flax prices with the northern spinners were going to be difficult, it was his duty to consult with the people primarily responsible, namely, the flax growers, as to the price they would accept.
Another point is that, before eventually coming to a decision in the matter, he should have called the flax growers together and asked them what was the lowest price they would take, before he would tell the one buyer he had for this valuable commodity to go to blazes, as he boasted in this House. No businessman with any sense, knowing he had only one buyer for his commodity, would tell the buyer to go to blazes and hope eventually, when the flax was grown, that this buyer would come along and give the price required. He was offered 31/3 in June for 4,000 tons of Grade 5 and was offered, I admit, 32/- for 2,000 tons in December. As a result of the Minister's impetuosity and his attitude, unbefitting a Minister, the unfortunate flax growers had eventually to go behind his back and accept 28/3. The Minister ought to be ashamed of himself. That means to the people a loss of £120,000 in flax alone.
I do not blame the Minister—he is entirely unaware, he is not au fait or conversant with the struggle of the small farmers of County Monaghan or the women farmers of County Monaghan. He does not realise, because he is very seldom there, that it is on the flax crop that the small farmers there, and the women particularly, depend to pay their shop debts at the end of the year. I know young fellows who have taken, in their spare time, conacre for flax and have made quite a lot of money out of it. It is a blow to these ordinary labouring chaps. The Minister turns up his nose and gives the impression that he is a great patriot in refusing this, saying that he would not stand this from the northern spinners. If he would not stand us accepting less than the northern flax growers, why did he ask the farmers to accept 3/- a dozen for their eggs when, at the same time, Englishmen were getting 4/- a dozen? There must be some commonsense amongst us. We were not in the least reluctant to accept the price offered by the northern people. We would have accepted it and the Minister knows that, too late, of course. Then he goes down to Scotstown in County Monaghan, even after the price had been settled, and tells the farmers that they should not grow flax. Why? Jealousy, because he was not in at the death. As bad as the price is, I am hoping they will make something out of it.
We have heard about our farmers accepting 3/- a dozen for eggs while the British farmers get 4/-. Under this trade agreement the Minister, with the usual blare of trumpets, announces the glad tidings to the people that in future they will get 3/-a dozen, and the more eggs, the better price they will get. He calls himself a businessman, but anybody with an ounce of sense will know that the more plentiful a commodity the less the price must eventually be. Then, just as the people had responded to the drive and the price of 3/- a dozen, he gets up in County Donegal and announces a drop of 6d. a dozen which, to the vast majority of the farmers of Monaghan—I am referring to the small farmers—means a loss of £2 a week in income. He assured us that we were to get 3/- per dozen. As the people believed, for the rest of their days, the English people were prepared and were glad to pay 3/- per dozen for the privilege of being drowned with this commodity.
He has abandoned compulsory tillage, and nowhere more than in his own constituency is that having such a desperate effect. There is scarcely a day I hold a dispensary that some men do not come into me hoping I will discover something wrong with them in order to put them on national health insurance.
Comment on this
I know families of three and four who have not done a stroke of work since before Christmas for the reason that the neighbouring farmers, and the Minister knows them very well, have abandoned tillage and have left these men high and dry. The Minister may say that there is alternative employment for these men in Ballyshannon and on the bogs. The Minister must try to get down to their level.
Comment on this
These people who came to you fraudulently to certify them for national health insurance.
Comment on this
That is what you said— that they came in to you hoping that you would find something wrong with them.
Comment on this
If they got employment on turf work or at Ballyshannon, you would think it damned well good enough for them. You have no use for this type of people.
Comment on this
Yes. If these people go to Ballyshannon or to work on the bogs, it means they must keep two houses going. They have to pay for their "grub" at their work and send back their money to keep their wives and families at home, so that these State schemes have no attraction for them. I consider that the Minister, since he took office, has, due to his ineptitude, contributed more to the encouragement of emigration from this country by his encouragement of grass and his discouragement of flax, together with his abandonment of compulsory tillage, than any other economic factor operating in this country at present.
Comment on this
I have the same legal and constitutional right to speak and be heard here as the Ministers. The administration of the Minister for Agriculture has been subjected to a very caustic review by Deputies, from my colleague, Deputy Corry, to my opposite number, Deputy Madden, although he applied the soft soap, and I would not have spoken were it not for a remark by my namesake, Deputy Seán Collins, while Deputy Maguire was speaking. I will be very honest and sincere about the points I want to raise. Last year, I spoke about farm improvements and I was very disappointed that the farm improvement scheme for 1948 should have been suspended.
Comment on this
On the Minister's own admission, 23,000 applications were received in his Department and they were deferred for consideration until August of 1948. We have now, as a result of pressure which has been brought to bear on him, an undertaking that, for 1949, the farm improvement scheme will be operated as it was intended by his predecessor. In that connection, I should like to say that farm improvement schemes were matters on which all members were at one.
Comment on this
Do not try to persuade me. The Minister must be honest with the House and with the people. It was suspended for 1948. The Minister said that 23,000 farmers made application in 1948 under the farm improvement scheme, which applications were passed on to the senior supervisors of the Department. I challenge any member of Clann na Poblachta or Fine Gael to contradict what I say in that respect.
Comment on this
The farm improvement scheme was not suspended for an hour, for a minute or for a second, and it is still in operation.
Comment on this
If the Minister is sincere in wishing to implement fully this scheme which was inaugurated in 1947, it is necessary, in view of the increase in wages and the extra costs of materials, that he should increase the grant by at least 25 per cent.
With regard to milk, I represent the dairying County of Limerick, although I cannot claim to be the senior Deputy, and I am convinced that it is useless to make any further pleas to the Minister with regard to our dairy farmers. I believe that the Minister has definitely closed and double-bolted the door. To use an expression that has current application, I believe he has put on the double bolts in a Basil Brooke fashion. I would like to tell the Fine Gael people that they are wronging him to this extent: they come to my county and say: "Unfortunately, we have not the right Minister for Agriculture. If he was one of our men, we might do better for the dairy farmers." In fairness to the Minister, the full responsibility should not be placed on his shoulders for saying "No." The refusal to grant an extra 2d. a gallon to the dairy farmers of Limerick should be the collective responsibility of the Government. I would like that to be recorded. It is not fair. I do not want to mention names, but we have Fine Gael Deputies saying that.
Comment on this
I am not running away. I name Deputy Madden. That is a queer one for you, and I never in my life told a lie and I never will. I will always stand behind the truth. I would not like to wrong the man. It is the collective responsibility of the Fine Gael Party and the people who are in the Government who have refused to give our dairy farmers an extra two pence a gallon.
Comment on this
It is not. I strove to make a case for an increase in the price of milk for the dairy farmers of Limerick. I can make the same case to-day. I put it to any decent Deputy on the Government side that the Limerick farmers cannot produce milk at the present price of 1/2. I would ask the Minister to remember that we have not developed to the extent of having winter dairying in this country. In the district that I come from, the extreme part of West Limerick, from November to May, the farmers do not receive a penny for milk. That is not the fault of our economy. It is due to a certain set of circumstances over which we have no control. I admired Deputy Smith when, in 1947, on succeeding Dr. Ryan as Minister for Agriculture, he gave us 1/2 and 1/4, but 1/4 for winter dairying in my part of the country is no good to us at the moment. I would like to come down like a ton of bricks on the Minister for Agriculture because he has refused to give us an increase, but we should be fair. I do not like the Fine Gael people, just because they want to keep their barometer reading at a steady level, to come to my area and say: "Were it not for the fact that Deputy Dillon is Minister for Agriculture, if we had somebody who belongs to our own Party, we could do better." I want to nail that here and now. It is the collective responsibility of the Fine Gael Party and the Coalition as a whole that our dairy farmers did not get the increase they deserve. There is one other matter that I want to deal with—lime and fertiliser.
Comment on this
No. I always stand on my own feet, thanks be to God, and nobody will ever shake me off them. While I appreciate the lime scheme, I would suggest that the grants that are made available by the Department to the county committees of agriculture for burnt lime should be increased. I have met several farmers in my constituency who are much keener on buying burnt lime than crushed lime. Comparatively speaking, the price is not much higher and they tell me that the results are quicker with burnt lime. The amount of the grant given by the Department to the Limerick County Committee of Agriculture is not sufficient to meet the number of applications received in the last three or four years from farmers in West Limerick. Does the Minister consider that burnt lime is as good and as cheap as the crushed lime which, I understand, is being produced at Fermoy and which is very handy for spreading but which has not reached my area yet? We would ask that the Department would give our county committee of agriculture an increased grant in that respect.
In connection with fertilisers, there is another matter that I want to raise. Some Kerrymen are here and I think they will agree with me. In Limerick, where there is a heavy, loamy soil, there is another fertiliser available that has a manurial value and a great physical value, that is, sea sand. The sea sand that we can get is 65 per cent. lime. Its physical value is of great importance. It is absolutely invaluable both for tillage and grass on that particular land. I would like the Minister to consider any representations that may be made by our county committee of agriculture to his Department and to give us whatever he thinks is fair as a fertiliser subsidy under the heading of sea sand. It has been a great blessing to us in the West. If the Minister thinks it fair or practicable, I would ask him to say, when he is concluding, that he will give consideration to the suggestions or representations that may have been made by our county committee of agriculture.
Next I wish to deal with the poultry industry. The poultry industry, notwithstanding all the criticism that we have heard in this debate, has taken root. Our people and the Department have thrown their weight behind it and we all hope that this scheme will be a success. I say very honestly and sincerely that the one danger I see is in the possibility that we are placing all our eggs in the British basket. There is an awful danger. History has a peculiar knack of repeating itself. There is a danger in pandering to the British. In connection with the poultry and egg industry, I would ask the Minister has he made, or is he making, any effort to try to procure alternative markets for this industry that is going ahead at the moment? It is no harm to recall what the Minister said last year. He said he would drown the British with eggs. I told him last year, when I made my maiden speech, that if he gave a price to the dairy farmers of Limerick, we would choke him with butter. I would suggest to the Minister that he should be mighty careful. I know he has great grádh for the British. I have not and never will. I will never depend on them.
Comment on this
And remember this. There are people sitting over there, who are supporting the Minister for Agriculture at the moment, and if they got their freedom to speak their minds they would speak as I am speaking.
Comment on this
Deputy Collins is wrong. I say that on behalf of all supporters of the Government on this side of the House.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Palmer tell me, for the purpose of having it on the records of this House, that he depends on John Bull?
Comment on this
The man you admire, the Minister for Agriculture, is the man who said 12 months ago that he would drown them with eggs.
Comment on this
Whatever you like. I do not want to dwell on what has happened in regard to this country recently. Every member of the House realises the position. John Bull has played an ugly part, as far as this nation is concerned, within the past fortnight—as he has done for generations past.
Comment on this
If we want to live in this country and preserve a good agricultural economy, either under the heading of beef or poultry, I would say in all sincerity to the Deputies opposite not to place too much reliance on John Bull. I would seriously suggest that if it is within the power of the Government to do so they should seek continental markets for our cattle and eggs. I appeal to the Government to make a sincere and energetic effort to find those markets rather than to pass everything we have over to John Bull. I am telling the Minister for Agriculture, with a full realisation of what I am saying, that the more we pander to John Bull the more he will put his heel down on us.
I want to say a word on behalf of the officials of the Department. We are in the poultry industry at home and we are playing our part as ordinary honest citizens. I would point out that there are in the Department junior poultry instructresses who, I understand, are badly paid. I would ask the Minister to take some cognisance of the great work they are doing from dawn till dusk. If the scheme is going to be a success I believe that those junior poultry instructresses— who are working throughout the country and who are, so to speak, carrying out in toto the instructions of the Department—should be better paid.
In conclusion, I want to pay a tribute to the underdog—the under-worker who is the foundation of any industry we have in this State. I would recommend the Minister to give him a fair break.
Comment on this
In concluding this debate, before I turn to the myriad topics that have been touched upon, I want to reaffirm my faith in parliamentary democracy, even after what we have witnessed here during the past five days. The system of parliamentary democracy we have in this country is the greatest instrument of human freedom that has ever been formed. I do not deny that on a grave occasion, under prudent leadership, an opposition may legitimately, in defence of fundamental rights, threatened by a tyrannical majority, resort to all the devices that the rules of Parliament permit in order to ventilate their grievance. But there is no precedent since this Parliament sat first in this country for the shameless misuse of its power and privileges that we have seen during the last five days. The Leader of the Opposition in this House has, in his own rôle, as significant a parliamentary office as has the Taoiseach himself. I direct his specific attention, as Leader of the Opposition, to the printed record of the proceedings of this House last night. After four days' deliberate malicious obstruction, so hopelessly exposed was the Opposition that I charge that the printed record of this House will show to anyone who reads it that shortly before 10 o'clock last night the Deputy Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Lemass, came in here for the purpose of breaking up the proceedings in a riot.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, you were in the Chair last night when I was in the House. You recollect that I took no part whatever in the proceedings except to protest against the persistent interruption of Deputies by the Minister for Agriculture. Is that not correct?
Comment on this
I leave the written record to speak for itself but I want to remind the House of this—that the circumstances of this nation at this moment demand, above all, that we should provide the traducers of this country with no material for slandering us more foully than they may have already tried.
Comment on this
The persons who risk at this time—simply for the purpose of venting their contemptible vicious spleen on one individual—the whole reputation of our Parliament are in my judgment so maddened by irresponsibility as to be unfit for public life.
Comment on this
I heard the deputy Leader of the Opposition get up here last night and say, with the Leas-Cheann Comhairle then presiding:—
"If this is not ended, we ought to wind up the session on the ground that it is impossible to carry on."
Comment on this
That application was made in the immediate proximity to the user of language by Deputy Corry which constituted a clear breach of order; the user of which was designed to elicit from the Chair an order to withdraw, to be followed by a refusal, a scene, and then a further demand from the deputy Leader of the Opposition to wind up Dáil Éireann—that we had ended the day like cats and dogs, unfit to sit down in our own Parliament and, by free debate, resolve our differences. Fortunately, by the prudence of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and the restraint and generosity of certain Deputies on this side of the House, insults, scurrility and affront were allowed to pass and thus the public degradation of this House by those who sought to achieve it to cover their own ignominy was avoided. Shame on a man who was 15 years a Minister in the Government of Ireland——
Comment on this
——and who is now the deputy Leader of the Opposition in this House to be a party to that transaction. Are not the proceedings that attended the discussion of my Estimate part of my Estimate? Am I to sit five days while all the filth and all the scurrility that degraded Party is capable of pouring forth is poured upon me and not to be permitted to characterise their contemptible conduct for what it is?
What fools they are, hoping and praying to scramble back to office, after the first 12 months, making up their minds that that cock is not going to fight and asking themselves: "How are we going to get them out; how are we going to get back?" and then the device: "We will concentrate all our venom on one member of the Government and, if we can destroy him, we destroy all." Fools that they are, they do not understand that to concentrate their attack upon me renders me more secure with every bit of filth they hurl upon me. I do not work with colleagues of a character that they would understand. I do not work with colleagues who begin to look for an opportunity of running away from the individual in their ranks on whom the enemy fire for the moment may be concentrated. Fire away. The more Deputies of that Party are put up, the more their utter degradation is revealed.
Ineptitude, scurrility and worse, which I am about to prove, untruth, have been the instruments employed in this debate by the Fianna Fáil Party; most of it of that subtle kind so difficult to expose until Deputy Killilea, the agile performer, entered the ring. He had his Balbriggan widow like all the rest of them, the nameless and oppressed creature who came crying to his door that she had mountains of potatoes and had been promised £10 per ton for them and was only given a tithe of that. The Minister promised Deputy Killilea's constituents £10 per ton. Deputy Killilea is reminded that his memory has played him false, that the £10 13s. 6d. applied to potatoes f.o.b. at the port. Is Deputy Killilea consternated? Not at all. He says: "I was at the port and I saw the farmers bring them there." He forgot for the moment that the only person who can bring potatoes to a port is a registered exporter. If Deputy Killilea had gone with his farmer to the port, he would have been summoned for his pains. The fact is that he never went to the port; that there was no Balbriggan widow; that there were no potatoes which the poor, downtrodden farmer could not sell. Deputy Killilea had a widow, Deputy Ó Briain had a widow, Deputy somebody else had a widow; but we could never find out the widow's name. We will never find out the widow who went with Deputy Killilea to load sacks of potatoes on to the boat at Galway Bay. Poor Deputy Killilea, we must not blame him.
But, when we come on to an old warrior like Deputy Allen, he carries his Balbriggan widow in his hands. There is an air of verisimilitude about his problem, because his widow takes the form of the Book of Estimates and he is going to read from them for us to reveal the Minister's iniquity. He says that he is pained and shocked when he turns to sub-head G (3) and finds that, ample provision having always been made for fertilisers by the Fianna Fáil Government, the iniquitous Government now in office has not made any provision for them.
Let us see what provision the Fianna Fáil Government made, and then let us see, having made the provision, what they did with it. In 1945-6, this public-spirited Fianna Fáil Administration provided £120,000 in the Estimates for fertilisers. The Minister for Agriculture of that day wept to think that he could do no more but offer this pittance and all his colleagues gathered around and said: "While a provision of £120,000 is all you can make, you can do better next year" and he said "Please God" and we passed the Estimate. Do you know what the decent man spent in subsidising fertilisers that year? It would be well to have a little guessing competition. He spent £1,463 out of the £120,000 and the rest went back into the Government's left breeches' pocket and the boys knew nothing about it. They are so simple, poor creatures, that you can do that kind of thing with them and have them behind you and they never know anything about it. But, vigilance personified, they wanted to know next year what uncle was going to do for the farmer that year after all he did for them the previous year and they were told: "This year all we can do is to provide £77,400," and sympathy was expressed, but they were content.
That year a very strange transaction came to light. They spent £18,395 and then they discovered that the year before the fertiliser manufacturers had plucked the public for £39,512, and they took back from the fertiliser manufacturers what they had charged in excess profits to the farmers in 1944-45. That Liberal Government in 1946-47 bestowed it on farmers amidst loud praise. Deputies understand what this business ultimately became. The distribution of the modest sum for 1947-48, the year before we came into office, came along. There was an appropriation of £198,750—it just missed £200,000. Do you know how they spent it? They gave £19,058 to the manure manufacturers because they said they had not made enough profit. Now, knowing that I have those figures in my hand, did you hear them hold forth the whole day and last week comparing the deplorable record of this Government in subsidising fertilisers with their record of lavish benefaction? The only difference between this Administration and the Administration that went before is that we made the fertiliser manufacturers cough up their unjust profits and sell their manures to the farmers cheaper, without subsidy, than they ever sold when they were getting doles of £19,000, £18,000 and £1,463 in the years that went before. I guarantee to the House that that process will be continued and that no manure ring or any other ring will be allowed to batten on our people or be paid to do so as long as the present Government is in office.
That is the first fruit of honest Deputy Denis Allen's contribution to our proceedings but not the last. He did not really become lachrymose until he reached I (3). The poor—and his voice broke a little—hard working Connemara people. For the scheme to encourage the commercial production of glass-house crops in Gaeltacht areas Fianna Fáil provided £77,438 and this Government only provided £13,456. I told him to turn to page 145 and, if the House remembers, he was like a cat on a hot brick for about ten minutes trying to avoid turning to page 145. If he had turned he would have discovered that last year, of the £77,000 odd that was provided £73,000 odd was expended on the erection of propagating houses, packing sheds and glass-houses themselves. Did he want me to erect another propagating house? Did he want me to erect another packing shed? Did he want me to duplicate all the capital expenditure in connection with the existing scheme or did he want to suggest to this House that, while liberal expenditure was made on this scheme last year, drastic economies were being made this year? The fact is that I warned the House on this repeatedly although I deliberately refrained from giving it publicity lest it should discourage the growers.
In the Gortahork glass-houses bacterial canker has reappeared this year. I have sent down to Gortahork the leading botanic expert in these islands on that matter and he is there now. I am not without hope that we may bring this business under control. If that disease spreads there is an end of this experiment. Every resource of the Department is now expended to circumscribe it and to ensure that it will not spread. As the Deputies from Donegal know, it wrought considerable havoc on the crops last year. Every device that was known to science was employed during the winter to disinfect the houses and the soil and to fumigate every place where the spoor of that bacteria could survive. Despite the employment of every device known to science, that bacteria reappeared and again all the resources of the Department and outside the Department, including, in my opinion, the advice of the best botanists in this matter in these islands, were invoked for the protection of this enterprise. Nothing public expenditure can do to secure a fair chance for this experiment is being, has been, or will be left undone. Why then does Deputy Allen waste his time and the time of this House in manifesting misrepresentations of the figures before him, knowing, as I believe he knew, their true significance but desiring to create in the minds of most Deputies of this House an entirely false impression?
What is the use of people making the case that an industry is in the process of disintegration when the facts are that the total production of milk carried to the creameries up to the 5th May this year is the highest figure since 1939? In 1939 there were 28,134,620 gallons. In this year in the same period 27,753,000 gallons approximately have gone to the retailers. The daily consumption of milk in the City of Dublin between 1939 and 1949 has gone up from 40,000 to 50,000 gallons in round figures.
The daily consumption in Cork is about 9,000 gallons as it was ten years ago. Coming into the City of Dublin now are about 4,000 gallons in excess of the demand for it and we have to divert that milk from the liquid milk market into the chocolate crumb factories in this city. I want to see enough milk for everybody. I hope my friend, Deputy Hickey, will give me credit for this, that in one 12 months, whether it was the providence of God in my despite, or with me as His instrument, I have created a surplus of milk in the City of Dublin for the first time since the Dublin Milk Board was set up. That is not bad going, no matter what way you look at it.
Of course, it was not as a result of anything I did, but it is none the less true that with a higher consumption of butter in this country than ever was known before, unless some unprecedented catastrophe takes place between now and the end of July, we will have an exportable surplus of butter for the first time since 1941. On top of that, far from having any shortage of butter, if Deputy Hickey or any other Deputy of this House will get me a domestic market for all the farmers' butter that we can manufacture this year, they are heartily welcome to use it all, every pound of it without control, without ration, without question and without investigation of any kind.
The direction I got from the Government was to raise production. According to Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party the dairy industry is destroyed, the liquid milk producers are ruined. If they are they seem to enjoy it because they are bringing more ruination on themselves than they have done in the last ten years. The more ruination I bring on them the more milk they produce and the more farmers come into the milk business. More farmers are sending milk into the Dublin milk supply area than ever before and every day there are new farmers beginning to send milk to the various creameries. I have got to organise some kind of subsidiary creamery service to go up into South Galway in the Gort area to draw milk out of that area because if I do not they will smother us in butter.
I move to report progress.