Committee on Finance. - Vote 31—Fisheries.
Contributions 1–94 of 211. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That a sum not exceeding £151,900 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending the 31st day of March, 1950, for Salaries and Expenses in connection with Sea and Inland Fisheries, including a Grant-in-Aid.
The House will note that this Estimate represents an increase of £87,355 on the sum asked for last year. I have no doubt the House will also note with satisfaction that part of this increase is accounted for under sub-heads G (2) and G (3), which represent the repayable advances to the Sea Fisheries Association. G (2) speaks of repayable advances for boats and gear and G (3) speaks of repayable advances for general development. Deputies will recall that for the last few years, despite everybody's best effort, we have been unable to secure for the fishermen that supply of boats and gear which we would have wished to make available. The problem very largely arose out of the difficulty of getting engines. That problem is by no means wholly resolved as yet, but the supply position continues to improve and we feel we may legitimately hope to appropriate this substantial sum this year, in the confident expectation of spending it all in loans to fishermen for the supply of boats and gear.
The sub-head relating to development envisages the work we intend to pursue, increasing our capacity to produce boats and other services for the fishermen for whom the Sea Fisheries Association caters. In that connection, I desire to direct the attention of the House particularly to a project which is peculiarly dear to my heart, that is, the decision to restore the boatyard at Meevagh, locally known as Fanny's Bay. This was a small boatyard on the north shore of County Donegal which had been there for very many years. Through it many boys from Downings and that area have passed in the course of time as apprentices. Having learned their trade, some of them have subsequently served in other boatyards here in Ireland, while others have earned distinction abroad, by use of the skill that they acquired in Meevagh boatyard. When the Killybegs boatyard was developed in Donegal, it was at first thought that its resources would be ample to cater for the requirements of the Donegal area. Experience, however, has suggested that the small boatyard of Meevagh, capable not only of carrying out repairs of the boats domiciled from Moville round to Middletown but also equipped to produce at least two boats of its own every year, would be a welcome addition to the facilities available in Donegal. In contemplation of its abandonment, the yard was allowed to fall into a state of considerable disrepair, which was prudent and sensible, inasmuch as the intention then was to abandon it altogether. I am glad to inform the House that the Sea Fisheries Association, in deciding to re-establish Meevagh, have resolved to make of it, albeit a small yard, a yard which will be perfect in every particular. I cannot too highly commend that decision on the part of the Sea Fisheries Association, for I feel it to be a matter of very real importance that, whether an enterprise sponsored by a body of the standing of the Sea Fisheries Association be large or small, of its size and capacity, it ought to come as near perfection as it is humanly possible to bring it, and that is what I look forward to having at Meevagh.
Nor has the association forgotten its duty to provide analogous facilities for the Kerry area, and we hope to develop at Dingle a growing capacity for the building of boats suited to the requirements of the fishermen in that area. We have a long waiting list of fishermen who want boats and gear. I must not over-indulge my constitutional inclination to optimism, but I shall be much disappointed if a great part of that waiting list is not eliminated by the end of this financial year. That certainly is the intention of the association.
We are also planning this year to embark upon something which I trust will prove to be merely the forerunner of a very much larger development. A pilot plant for the quick-freeze process is to be established and it will be used with a view to determining on what lines of production we can most profitably and advantageously develop the quick-freeze and attendant services. I do not pretend, and I do not think anyone can pretend, to know with certainty in advance what branches of production can most profitably be associated with the quick-freeze process in our special circumstances. We propose to learn by experience, and I want to warn the House that we shall not be afraid to run the risk of loss, in order to establish to the point of certainty whether a fair capital investment in some particular line of business would yield permanent returns where an imprudent parsimony might make the venture a failure.
Before departing from sea fisheries— and of course I anticipate that many specific questions will be raised in the course of the discussion which Deputies will want me to answer categorically—I want to deal with one point. It has long been a matter of argument and contention why in this country we do not have a deep-sea trawling fleet. We do not have it and we will not have it, for one reason only, that the best information I can get is that you must choose between the inshore fishermen and the deep-sea trawler. If we are to have deep-sea trawling, then we must do it right. We must do it on the most efficient basis, by the most economic methods and with the best equipment that money can buy. So to operate, a deep-sea trawling fleet must provide a supply of fish more than adequate for the home market in Ireland and a surplus for sale abroad.
For the moment, I ask Deputies to forget the surplus problem. If the employment of trawlers regularly delivers at our ports a supply of fish amply adequate to cater for all the domestic demands, every inshore fisherman in Ireland is thereupon disemployed, because let none of us forget that it is no solution to say that you will transfer the inshore fisherman from his present occupation to the trawlers. They will not go, and they ought not to go. That is not their line. Their life, their culture, the social pattern they have woven for themselves is one of part-time farmer and part-time fisherman. It is not a system founded on the rock of perfect efficiency and absolute economic law, but, in my judgment, it is founded on something infinitely more precious—an Irish way of life which is the way of life obtaining along our west coast from Donegal to Cork.
I fully understand that the opposite view can legitimately be held, that, in this modern world in which we live, all that sentimentality and nostalgic looking back on the past must go, that the right course is to sweep all that away and to base upon this country a deep-sea trawling fleet which will enter into competition with Grimsby and Glasgow and all the great trawling ports of the world. That is a legitimate view. I reject it but, "you pays your money and you takes your choice". I can quite understand somebody who feels himself at home in the modern tempo who has no patience with the kind of people I represented in this House when I stood for Donegal or the kind of people of West Mayo with whom I have been brought in fairly intimate contact all my life. It is not that I know them better than other Deputies do that convinces me that theirs is a way of life we should preserve but it is because of my profound certainty that that way of life is part of our social pattern, a way of fishing that belongs to our people and in which it is now natural for our people to engage and the sordid industrial horror of the modern trawler trade is a servitude to which some people who value money more than life are entitled to subject themselves but which I would be long sorry to inflict on our people to the exclusion of a very much more gracious way of living which can be made to serve the requirements of our domestic market just as well.
So that the policy I commend to this House is founded on the inshore fisherman and on him alone and my aim is to make of the Sea Fisheries Association a co-operative body representative of the inshore fishermen and of them alone and to give to them through their co-operative the exclusive right of furnishing the domestic market with fish. There will be lacunæ when the weather is peculiarly turbulent or some other unforeseen circumstances arise when, for a week or ten days, perhaps, our inshore fishermen will not be able to meet the domestic demand. In that event, their co-operative, acting on their behalf, will bring in fish from abroad to fill the need of one or two or three days until the normal landings of our own men pick up the task of furnishing this market.
That deals with demersal fish. There remains, of course, the constant problem of providing for landings of pelagic fish. Sometimes one is inclined almost to the view that we are presented with insoluble problems. I am glad to tell the House that these problems are beginning to look less insoluble than they used to do and I am not without hope that, by carefully organising supplies of herring, we may establish a canning industry here which will provide a profitable commercial outlet for a very considerable volume of fish. As Deputies know, mackerel is very much a seasonal market and herring often presents a serious problem. Recently, I think, our experience with mackerel has not been as difficult as it often was before. I do not see my way through the problem of a regular and adequate market for mackerel as clearly as I think I see it for herring, but all that I know of as possible is being done and will continue to be done to seek a market and I would hope that, in time, the guarantee which is at present available to fishermen for their landings of demersal fish will be practicable for pelagic fish as well.
May I refer to one small detail? Our practice has been to provide a guaranteed price for landings of demersal fish, the marketing problem being one for the association itself. There are certain seasons in the year when the abundance of Providence speeds whiting towards our shore and fishermen in certain parts of the country can either go out and sit in the middle of the whiting and bring in boats loaded to the gunwale or go a little further and bring in choicer varieties of fish. This is true for two or three months of the summer season and, accordingly, I have advised the Sea Fisheries Association that, during these months, when these alternatives are available to fishermen they must, for their own protection, be advised that if they elect to confine their attention to whiting they must be prepared to have them sold on consigment on the market when they sometimes fetch a very dismal price, because they always have the option of going out beyond the whiting and bringing in these varieties of demersal fish for which there is a guaranteed price, the size of which they know before they put to sea. If they want to spare themselves the extra effort and confine their attention to whiting, they must face the peril of a market which they themselves elect to overload.
The Department of Fisheries is, of course, also concerned with inland fisheries. Perhaps I should tell the House that the age old battle goes on to define precisely the territorial limits, the three-mile limit or the nine-mile limit; how these limits should be drawn and whether international law prescribes that the three-mile limit in a bay that is six miles wide leaves a neutral hole in the middle of the bay. That still jogs cheerfully on and international lawyers exchange long queries and rejoinders. It is not the intention of your Government, now or in any foreseeable time, to send the fleet to sea for the purpose of challenging rival navies on the interpretation of obscure points of international law. The three-mile limit is universally acknowledged. In so far as we can hunt the offending trawlers out of those areas we intend to continue doing so. I have been listening to strong reprobation delivered against the Government of this country for 20 years for its failure to dismiss the foreign trawlers. Many is the powerful speech I have made in Deputy Brian Brady's constituency upon that very subject. It seems always a simple thing to do and, during the last 12 months, it is a matter to which I have turned my attention not infrequently. It seems to me that, to protect a coast line even of such modest length as our own, one would want to dispose practically the whole British Navy in order to have posted at the point of vantage an appropriate vessel to deal with every errant poacher. It occurred to me at one time that our air force might contribute by doing an occasional patrol. I do not dismiss that entirely from the sphere of possibilities and it is a matter which I intend to take up with the Minister for Defence in the hope that even though it might not produce the prompt arrest by service vessels on wireless notification from aircraft at least it would be in terrorem and might discourage skippers——
Comment on this
I think that even though they steal our fish we would be a little uncomfortable if we started dispatching all those respectable trawler captains to Davy Jones' locker. Arrest them, deprive them of their trawls, harry and insult them—but we must draw the line somewhere.
Comment on this
We will go to very great lengths indeed, but I am afraid there is no use pretending that I would even pretend to pretend that I would ask anyone to blast them out of the sea. Short of that, I am prepared to do almost anything that would inconvenience and annoy them if they trespass within the three-mile limit, which they undoubtedly know they ought not to do. I think Deputies ought to bear in mind that, while every area sends its Deputy to this House to protest most furiously against the poaching of these trawlers, it has been known that these trawlers have established friendly and profitable relations with some of our citizens who have been most vocal in denouncing their scandalous incursions upon our territorial waters.
Comment on this
Now to turn to inland fisheries, I am a great believer in the brown trout. I believe the brown trout fisheries of this country are of great value. Every device the mind of man has thought of for increasing the population of our brown trout rivers has been canvassed to and fro but it seems to me that there are two diametrically opposite expert opinions upon any proposition anybody ever makes. Accordingly, I have listened to all the experts, and I am going to try a few experiments. I am told that you ought to stock the river with imported fry but there is equally good authority for the proposition that one sprightly pike will do more damage than all the hatcheries in Ireland can repair and that if you pour fry into the river when the pike is on the rampage, you are simply fattening him up, pandering to him, where he otherwise would have to swim further afield. Nevertheless, the hatcheries continue to function. Certain local fishing associations operate hatcheries of their own. These we are glad to help by providing ova which we import whenever we can find supplies, and by giving them small grants and technical assistance whenever they apply to us.
Over and above these, we are now proceeding with a new experiment. If it is true that coarse fish are inimical to the trout population of a good lake or stream, it is equally true, I think, that the complete elimination of coarse fish and eels may, result in either of two disasters—that the bottom vegetation becomes so abundant that the trout become bottom feeders and will not rise, or that the trout so multiply that the available feed in the lake gets out of proportion to the trout population and the average-sized shrinks to a minimum of about three ounces, where it appears to establish balance, and you get, as in Loch Talt in County Sligo, a very large population of undersized fish and no fish over four ounces at all.
While, by pragmatic procedure, I have now decided on four lakes, out of which we propose to dredge the coarse fish, returning to the water of the lake 25 per cent. of the whole. If that does not seem to establish a satisfactory balance between the thriving trout population and the controlling fish population, we shall look to see if it has given any encouragement in one direction or another. If it appears to have helped in some degree, why then, we must try different percentages of fish to see if an artificial balance which is of maximum advantage to the trout population can be established. Another theory presented is that the ph content of the water is a matter of consequence to the fish population. Therefore, in suitable streams and lakes, experiments will be carried out this year and for some time to come in an effort, with reasonable economy, to control the ph content of the water. Deputies will fully understand that it is no easy task to maintain an artificial ph content of water: (1) to ensure that it is not raised too high and (2) to prevent it going too low. In so far as it is practicable, within reasonable limits of expense, the experiment will be made and on the results the policy must be formed. If any Deputy here has any other proposal which partakes of commonsense I beg of him not to be backward in presenting it. I can assure him that he need never blush in the presence of experts because, no matter how distinguished or exalted they may be, I will find an expert of equal distinction and equal exaltation who will categorically contradict the first. I do not want to suggest for a moment that I have not the greatest veneration and admiration for experts. There is no doubt whatever that some men have given a life of study to this whole problem. But it is a science that is at so early a stage at the present time that it is quite possible for men of equal distinction to reach diametrically opposite conclusions, both believing that their process of reasoning is impeccable. I should mention in that connection that we are collaborating with Great Britain, Norway and, I think, some other Atlantic countries in the campaign to tag salmon for the purpose of establishing with greater certainty their migratory habits. At first I understood these experiments to have indicated that the whole theory of salmon returning to the river where they were spawned was false. Now it appears that that is not true at all. The results clearly indicate that the venerable theory that salmon return to the river of their spawning is true. I would not be in the least surprised if the results of next year's tagging produces a pretty general report that neither of these propositions is universally valid. But with time I do not doubt that scientific certainty will emerge and in the carrying out of experiments of this kind patience and persistence are of their very essence; and we must firmly resolve not to be discouraged with the perplexities of conflicting results in the early stages.
My predecessor, Deputy Dr. Ryan, was responsible for the legislation which brought fresh-water netting to an end in the beginning of last year. I am at present engaged in assessing the compensation due. We have received claims which amount to something like £150,000 for rights and these are under examination and discussion. Claims in respect of displacement of employees represent a much smaller sum and we have already agreed to and discharged claims amounting to £1,456. There remain outstanding further sums which we do not doubt will be agreed between us and the claimants and in so far as the limits of reason will permit, we shall try to spare the claimants the expense or annoyance of seeking arbitration. So far as any degree of generosity will permit of the equitable settlement of claims without that expense being imposed upon claimants, we have interpreted the instructions of the Oireachtas to mean that we should err rather on the side of liberality.
There is much more that could with relevance be said in introducing this Estimate, but I do not know that it is necessary to go further than I have gone, provided always that Deputies will kindly remember that any topic which is of interest to them is of interest to me and, if they will mention it, I will be glad to furnish the necessary information if I am in a position to do so, but, if not, I shall find out what they want to know and communicate with them directly as soon as may be.
Comment on this
I move that the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration. The general tone of the Minister's speech was very optimistic for the future of fisheries in this country. In general, he gave his reasons for being optimistic, but I should like very much if he could give a little more detail on a number of matters mentioned. He pointed out that there is a larger amount of money passed on to the Sea Fisheries Association this year for the building of boats, equipment and development. We all hear, I suppose, from time to time of applicants who are very anxious to get a boat but who have not got very much encouragement about even the approximate month or year they are likely to get it. I think I heard the Minister say that he thought all applicants would be satisfied before the end of the year.
Comment on this
I take them to be genuine applicants. If we could believe that, we would be very satisfied. I should like if the Minister could give us some figures on which he bases that hope. For instance, if he could tell us how many boats are being turned out per month or quarter in the boatyards now established, we might have some data for assessing whether the applicants are likely to be satisfied within the next 12 months or so. I believe that the position with regard to gear is very much easier. There, again, the Minister says that, although the position has improved considerably with regard to engines, which are the big trouble, the full solution of that problem has by no means been reached. I wonder could we have even an approximate estimate of the number of engines that will be available during the year and, therefore, the number of boats which can be fully equipped.
The marketing of fish is a very important matter because, in regard to sea fisheries at least, one of the objects of the Minister and of the association is to give the inshore fishermen a living, and marketing is a very important matter. There has been for many years a surplus of certain types of fish which is not absorbed in the home market, principally salmon, shellfish, herrings and mackerel. I think the other varieties of fish are usually absorbed at home and, in fact, are hardly ever available in sufficient quantities for the home market. So far as I know, the agreement with regard to salmon for export this year has been on the same lines as for the last couple of years and, on the whole, has been satisfactory.
Comment on this
That is good. With regard to shellfish, it is necessary to improve the yield, as it were. In the case of oysters, for instance, beds must be laid from time to time. I should like the Minister to give us some information as to what progress has been made and what is the report with regard to the oyster beds laid during the last ten years. Oyster beds take a long time to develop, and it is not easy to get a final report within a few years. There were oyster beds laid ten or 12 years ago. I should like to know what the report with regard to them is and whether the laying of beds is being continued.
The mussel industry is a very important one in a few centres and mussels surplus to home consumption must find a market by export. In Great Britain the medical officers of health in the various counties were refusing to accept these mussels unless they went through a purification tank. Some time before the war there was a tank erected at Cromane, County Kerry, which was doing very good work. At that time we were being pressed to erect tanks in other centres, in particular on the banks of the Boyne. At the time we said that we should like to have a few years' experience of the working of the tank in Cromane to find out how efficient it was and that, having gained that experience, we would probably proceed to erect a tank at Mornington, perhaps with improvements, in view of the experience gained. I should like the Minister to give us some information with regard to the intentions of the Sea Fisheries Association as to the erection of further purification tanks.
I heard complaints quite recently with regard to the marketing of mackerel. It appears that the price for some time back has been very poor. In fact, the price got for the fish in England would go very little further than paying the expense of packing and export. It looks as if the buyers will have to refuse actually to take the mackerel from the fishermen unless things can be improved somewhat. The Minister did not give us any specific information with regard to any negotiations he may have had with the British for the selling of herrings or mackerel in Great Britain or whether there was any hope of getting back some of the old markets we had many years ago on the Continent and in America for some of those fish. The home market, of course, is very important. In the years when I was Minister for Fisheries complaints were always made, and justifiably made, that in the Midlands it was almost impossible to get fish at all. The complaint was often made that even in centres where fish was caught it was impossible to get fish, on the day they wanted it, at any rate. Towards the end of the war there appeared to be a great hope that, with the big advance made in the various grades of quick freezing and quick cooling that had been discovered, there was a good future for a process of that kind in getting fish consigned to inland markets and, in fact, also in getting fish held over in the case of a big glut to supply the market when fish was not so plentiful. I would like the Minister, although he touched on the subject, to give us very much more detail if he possibly could on these various processes and what use has been made of them or how far experimentation has gone in using these various grades of freezing and cooling in the holding of fish either for transit for immediate sale or for holding over for another time when fish would be less plentiful.
The Minister expressed an opinion which, I must say, I am very interested in. He did not think that there was room in this country for both inshore fishermen and for deep-sea trawlers. The Minister said that was a point of view. He is quite right. That controversy, as it were, has gone on in this country for as long as I have been interested in the fishery business, anyway. I think that probably the great majority agree with the Minister that the development of a trawler fleet here would interfere adversely with inshore fishermen. I do not hold that view, I must say. I think they could be made complementary to each other. The Minister did say, for instance, that the inshore fishermen cannot go out sometimes at all and at other times can only get, perhaps, one variety of fish. They cannot get the variety at certain times of the year even if the weather is quite good and when the weather is bad they cannot go out. Trawlers, of course, can go out at all times. Not only that, but they can go to different places and are, therefore, able to get the varieties that the inshore fishermen cannot get and would, as it were, act in a complementary way to the activities of the inshore fishermen. I think we should look on it in that way.
I quite agree that we should not even try—we cannot, I am quite sure— to divert inshore fishermen to the trawler business. In any case, they are usually different men altogether. As the Minister pointed out, it is the small farmer who usually does the inshore fishing. He is usually not a full-time fisherman and not a full-time farmer. Those that engage in trawler fishing are really full-time sailors as far as the occupation goes. We are not going to draw one from the other. I would press on the Minister to keep an open mind on this for another while to see if it would not be possible to have the two systems going together, one being complementary to the other. If we do not have our deep-sea trawling fleet we will have to import fish at certain times. It is not so easy to import quantities of fish at times when our inshore fishermen cannot go out, because at these particular times it is only natural to expect that fish will be scarcer than usual in Great Britain also, the weather being bad, and we may not get a great variety from there when we want it. On the whole, it would be better to have the fish caught by our own deep-sea trawlers.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy, does he not feel that efficient deep-sea trawling would flood the market?
Comment on this
No, I do not think so. Of course, I admit that is one of our difficulties in this country, that our market is so small that even when the inshore fishermen, as the Minister knows, get a big catch of, say, herrings or mackerel, the country is flooded immediately. My idea would be that these trawlers would have to go a big distance to get the fish, perhaps a three weeks' journey from the time they leave here until they get back. If one trawler or two trawlers come back in the week, say a fleet of six, I do not think there would be any danger of flooding the market. That has to be calculated out to a nicety to find out what is the capacity of the market in this country and to find out what quantity each trawler would bring back and so to try to calculate how many trawlers we really should have. However, I think it could be done. I just want to say that I agree with the Minister that there are two points of view and it is very difficult for anybody to be dogmatic about one point of view being right and the other being wrong. I am, on the whole, inclined to think that our fisheries would be developed better and we would be able to help our inshore fishermen better by having a trawler fleet because we would be able to direct our trawler fleet to go to a certain place for a certain type of fish and at a certain time. It would help to make fish consumption more popular. People would be able to get what they wanted and would consume more fish than they would if there were only one variety.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy agree that if we had to choose between deep-sea trawlers and inshore fishermen, we ought to preserve the inshore fishermen?
Comment on this
If I thought there was any danger of injuring the inshore fishermen I would say to cut them out. I think it would not only not injure them, but that it would help us to get the varieties which the inshore fisherment cannot catch. That would keep the consumer satisfied. Otherwise, I think there is the danger that if the consumer cannot get the fish he wants he will begin to ask to have the ports opened to the imported fish. That is the danger.
I am glad to know that the Minister has some hope of establishing a canning industry. I should like to have some more details from him on that. Of course, if the idea is still only in the air, I do not wish to push the Minister further on that point, but if he has more information to give the House on it I should be glad to have it from him when he is concluding.
The problem of protection has, of course, always been a big one on this Estimate. I think there are more complaints made against the Minister for Fisheries and the Fisheries Department on the question of protection than on any other subject. Most people around the coast seem to feel that the fishery laws are not being maintained by the fishery authorities here, and that they are not being observed by the foreign trawlers. I am quite sure that these trawlers do take a run inside the limit occasionally. I do not know if the law is transgressed as often as some people seem to think.
The Minister mentioned the question of exclusive fishery limits. That has being going on for many years between the Government here and the Government in Great Britain. It is universally recognised, as the Minister has said, that no foreign trawler, or British trawler, is permitted to come within three miles of the coast. Naturally, we want to get more than three miles. Many countries have adopted a limit of seven or nine miles and have got it recognised. They are able to enforce it, too. Our object in negotiating with the British Government has always been to get the British Government to recognise a better limit than three miles. We always had hoped that, if the British Government agreed to it, other Governments would follow suit. I should like the Minister, when replying, to give some indication as to whether any progress has been made in these negotiations. The question was being examined, before the present Government took office, by officials on both sides. I would like to know if the examination has concluded, and, if so, whether any recommendations have been made to the two Governments, what these recommendations may be and whether there is any hope that some agreement may be signed between the two Governments in the very near future. I take it there are still complaints about foreign trawlers poaching inside territorial waters. I should like to know whether, in the new situation in which the Department of Defence has taken over the protection of our fisheries, there are less complaints now than when the Department of Fisheries itself was doing the protection work.
Another point that fishermen have put to me is that at the end of the war there was a good lot of fish to be got. With all the danger that was involved in going far afield to fish and with the scarcity of men and boats in other countries—more perhaps than here— there was not so much fishing done during the war. The result was that the number of fish in the sea increased. When the war was over there was a great supply of fish. Our inshore fishermen found it comparatively easy to get a catch. They complained to me recently that they now have to go farther out to get fish and are continually meeting with accidents— whether that is deliberate or not is a matter to be decided—to their nets. The foreign trawlers evidently cut the nets on them. That may be due to accident or it may be by design. I do not know, but it is a matter that should be looked into as to whether those foreign trawlers, as our fishermen allege, are purposely cutting their nets. There should be some way of coming to an arrangement about that.
Now, our inland fisheries are very important, first of all, from the point of view of recreation for our own people, and, secondly, from the point of view of our tourist industry. The Minister said a very true thing when talking about the effect of hatcheries. It is quite true that when some society proceeds to develop a lake or a river by putting some thousands of fry into it, they are not giving very much more than three or four energetic pike will eat up in a year. Experience teaches that, where these hatcheries are, and where you have a society looking after a river or a lake by putting fry into it, the fishing in it improves. If you have a society that is enthusiastic enough to purchase fry and put them into a river or lake it is safe to assume, I think, that the members of it will be enthusiastic enough to protect the river or lake in other ways. I think it would be a great pity to discourage people of that type because I think they are doing good work. If it is a matter of providing the fry for them, I think we should try to do it so that they will continue their good work and help to increase the number of fish in these rivers and lakes.
Protection is most important against the human enemy as well as other enemies. The conservators have the task of protecting the fisheries from poachers or, if you like, from the human marauders. They also have the task of trying to destroy predatory birds and so on. The Minister spoke about carrying out an experiment to try and relate the number of pike, say, to the number of brown trout. I do not know how he is going to do that. It is an experiment that might be useful, but it appears to me to be one that is going to create an infinite amount of trouble, and it may not give any positive results. I think it has been proved beyond yea or nay that the private owner always kept his fishery up-to-date and well stocked by destroying predatory birds and predatory fish. I do not think we are going on the wrong line if we try to keep down the number of pike or the number of cormorants, as the case may be, in our lakes. The Minister's experiment may be useful, but I certainly think we should follow the old practice of destroying these predatory birds and predatory fish. The Minister was afraid that if we killed all the pike, say, in a lake, vegetation would become so good at the bottom that the fish would not come to the top. On the other hand, he thought there would be so many fish that they might get very small. Is it not obvious that a balance would be created some way or other? After all, if there is so much vegetation at the bottom, the fish will get so plentiful that some of them must come up, and then the fisherman can make his catch and things will balance out.
The Minister mentioned that under the Fishery Act, 1939, the State was enabled to take over private ownership in fisheries on the estuaries and the weirs. When does the Minister intend to implement that Act, where is it intended to commence, and in what way does he intend to operate these fisheries when they are taken over? I take it for granted the Minister is in agreement with the legislation passed at that time, when it was provided that the State should take over these private fisheries and operate them. When that legislation was being passed there were suggestions from various Deputies. Some were to the effect that the Department of Fisheries should operate the fisheries; others suggested that having taken them over, the Department should let them, and there were other suggestions that they should make them public fisheries. I should like to hear the Minister's views with regard to the implementation of that Act and how he intends to operate the fisheries when he takes them over.
He referred to netting in fresh water. In the Act it is provided that netting in fresh water would become illegal after a short period. It has now ceased and those who made a livelihood by it are due to receive compensation. I was glad to hear the Minister say that numbers of them already had been compensated. I would urge him to complete the settlement of these men's claims at the earliest possible moment. Everybody will agree that if a man is making a living out of a certain occupation, he cannot afford to wait two, three or four years to get compensation to enable him to enter some other occupation. He must get his money as quickly as possible. I am sure we will all agree with the Minister's sentiment that we should not be too particular about beating these men down to the last farthing. The best thing would be to settle with them and let them go ahead in some other form of livelihood.
When he was referring to the balance between brown trout and their enemies, the Minister spoke of various theories relating to the supply of brown trout in lakes. One was that the number of brown trout was regulated largely by their enemies, and that appears to be a fairly sensible explanation. Another theory had relation to the ph content in the water. I remember when I was in the Department of Fisheries, reading some articles on that subject. As usual, when you have an enthusiast writing on such subjects, he puts such a picture before you that you are inclined to come to the conclusion that if enough phosphates were put into the lakes the waters would be teeming with fish. You always have to discount a certain amount of what the enthusiasts say, but by this time there should be sufficient information collected, and I am sure the Department of Fisheries has done sufficient by way of experiment to give us some idea of the results that would be achieved by putting a certain amount of phosphates or other fertilisers into the water. The main idea was that fertilisers would increase the feeding for the fish and, in that way, the fish supply would be improved.
When I was in the Department of Fisheries I was interested in consolidating the laws, and the Government at that time authorised the consolidation of the whole fishery code. I had many conversations with the draftsman and he told me on the last occasion I conversed with him that he would have a draft prepared early in 1948. I should like to know from the Minister if this draft consolidation of the fishery laws reached him in 1948 and, if so, what does he intend to do. This is a matter which created some speculation at the time. Does he intend to amend the law—because there are amendments necessary—first of all, and then consolidate, or vice versa? Will he bring the Consolidation Bill before the Oireachtas and then, having gone out of here with a clean Act, the only Act on fishery law, will he start to amend it? There are arguments both ways, and I should like to know if the Minister will tell us what are his intentions before he proceeds to put these intentions into operation. There are very cogent arguments on both sides and it is well worth while debating which is the best course to take.
Comment on this
Frankly, I am disappointed at the decision which the Minister has taken to confine the fishing industry to inshore fishing. I am afraid the speech which I am about to make will be more or less on the same lines as the speeches I have made on several previous occasions in the House. I agree with the Minister and the last speaker and, if the extension of our fishing industry beyond inshore fishing were to do away with inshore fishing, then, of course, I would be against any such extension, but I am not satisfied that the creation of a suitable fishing industry, comparable with the industry that exists in other countries of our size and population, would interfere in any way with the inshore fishing. I agree with Deputy Ryan that it would help. We seem to forget in this country that we have at our shores an enormous potential wealth which foreign visitors and observers from time to time refer to. There was a letter in the latest issue of the Sunday Independent from a Danish visitor. He drew attention to the fact that we have not properly developed that aspect of our fisheries.
I have taken out certain figures to indicate to the Minister and to the House what the situation is in other countries. The suggestion is made in connection with the fishing industry that you can have either an industry based upon part-time fishermen or an industry based upon whole-time fishermen, and it is said that an industry based on whole-time fishermen must inevitably do away with part-time fishermen. Norway has a population of 3,600,000 people. From that point of view it is not very much different from our own country. In Norway there are no less than 112,000 people engaged in fishing. That is the figure given for the year 1945. That is the latest figure that I could get. Of that 112,000 people 38,000 odd have another chief occupation. The inshore fishermen here, who, as we know, are sometimes small farmers or have some other occupation to follow, correspond to the 38,000 odd in Norway. These figures illustrate not only the fact that you can have two types of fishermen working in the industry without doing each other any harm but you also have the stupendous fact that a country with a population only a little larger than our own can employ permanently in the fishing industry over 70,000 people.
The same waters that wash the coast of Norway flow around our shores. It is as easy for our fishermen to reach the fishing beds as it is for the Norwegian fishermen. Denmark has a population of 4,000,000. Three or four years ago—these are the latest figures I can get—the fish landed in that country were valued at £5,000,000. Iceland has a population less than the average Irish county, 121,000 people. In 1945, Iceland landed fish to the value of £5,300,000, of which £380,000 was in reference to herrings. It may be said that there are some differences in climate and so on between our country and Iceland and Norway. Let me take Great Britain. What do we find there? In the year 1947—the latest year for which I can get figures —£41,000,000 worth of fish was landed, representing 993,000 tons. If one wishes to carve that figure up still further and take an area and a population more approximate to our own, then one can take Scotland. Scotland in the year 1947 landed 229,000 tons of fish valued at £10,507,000.
Taking our own country in the years 1942 and 1947, inclusive, the best figures that I can get are 316,000 cwts. of fish, or 15,800 tons, with a value in money of £547,000. From these figures I think it is evident that we are neglecting a very, very valuable industry. I know there are differences of opinion on this matter, but I think those differences must be resolved in favour of making our fishing industry one of the foremost industries in the country when one considers that there is no other single country whose shores are washed with the same waters that does not indulge in this industry to its fullest extent.
I have not quoted the figures for France. I do not think it is necessary to do so. We have all seen the pictures of the blessing of the fleet in Brittany. We know that the French fishing fleet is enormous. We know that it comes as far as our own coast and that it is sometimes the subject matter of dispute when our territorial waters are entered.
It may be said that there is a difficulty with regard to boats. But what did Belgium do? Belgium has a coastline of about 75 miles, together with the inlet of the river Scheldt down to Antwerp. In 1945 Belgium had a fleet of 11,260 tons. Belgium had been occupied and had gone through the war. She was faced with many problems in 1945. She had to build her roads, her bridges and her houses. Yet in 1946 she had built up in one year her fishing fleet to 23,179 tons. If Belgium finds it worth while to keep and maintain a fleet of that size in the restricted area she has, surely it would be worth our while to consider the question of developing this industry. I understand that one of the objections to its development is that there will be too much fish for consumption. Fish has other uses besides being consumed at the family table. It can be canned. It has even further uses, the importance of which these countries fully recognise. If we were to wake up to-morrow and discover that underneath one of our mountains or one of our bogs there were vast deposits of mineral wealth this House would be unanimous in voting large sums of money for the exploitation of that untapped wealth. The position with regard to the fish around our shores, within distance of our fleets, if we had them, is comparable, in my submission, to such untold mineral wealth suddenly discovered.
We have this important item of potential wealth at our doors. We have an item that would be a dollar earner, a hard currency earner, and yet we are prepared to neglect it. In fact, we are prepared to disregard it, on the basis, as the Minister says, that it would interfere with our way of life. We are going to have a plan for the reclamation of waste land, a plan which I welcome and which is a good one, but what about a plan for the creation of a proper fishing industry? I put that proposition to the Minister. Let him and his advisers take the advice of persons engaged in this industry in the countries to which I have referred. I think a scheme under which a substantial sum of money would be devoted to the creation of an industry comparable to that in existence in Norway, Iceland and to a lesser extent in Denmark, Belgium, England and Scotland would be very well worth while. The position is very unsatisfactory here. That is not the fault of any particular Government but I think since the inception of this State and since we gained control of the economic life of this country, this question of developing the fishing industry on a proper basis has been more or less by-passed by each successive Government. I do not think there is a proper appreciation of the wealth or the benefits that would accrue from developing the industry in this country.
I know the officials in the Department of Fisheries are very excellent people doing their best, but it is only a small Department. It is only a branch, in fact it is only a section, although nominally a Department in itself, of the Department of Agriculture, and even in its own sphere it is hampered and restricted. I understand that there are at least 100 persons on the waiting list—and if those who apply to the Sea Fisheries Association are included there are more— who could be considered as real live applicants for boats and gear. The rate at which boats are being built is, I understand, very slow—probably four or five boats a year—and the requirements of these 100 people, together with those of others who will come on the list from time to time, will never be met. It is a dreadful situation. It is not the Minister's fault, the Government's fault nor the fault of the last Government. It is entirely due to the fact that we are not sufficiently fishminded in this country. We are not sufficiently conscious of the terrific wealth that lies at our doors if the industry were properly organised. Even in the restricted sense in which the industry operates at the moment, confined as it is to inshore fishermen and to the sons of fishermen who wish to start in the business, many of these people will have to wait six months, 12 months, two years or more, before they can be furnished with the necessary boats and tackle. Does it not amount to this: That we have entirely overlooked this industry and that until we become conscious of its importance and its necessity to our economic life, we shall get nowhere?
All around my constituency there are little harbours and piers built from time to time. One by one they are falling into disrepair. When the question arises of having them repaired, you are faced with two propositions. The first proposition is that if a certain amount of money is spent on a particular harbour, either for dredging, building a wall or some work of that kind, you are not going to get any return because there are not enough people in that district engaged in the industry. But if the harbour were right and the boats were right, the fish are there and there would be enough people in the industry. The point then arises that, supposing it is considered an economic proposition to expend some money in this way, you find yourself up against the difficulty that there are about three different Departments concerned. The Minister for Agriculture, as the person in charge of the Department of Fisheries, has to consult with the Board of Works and the county council and perhaps with other bodies.
The mere fact that there is such difficulty in keeping all the tools and the raw material, if I may use that expression in connection with harbours and boats, in full working order, the fact that there is such difficulty in connection with inshore fishermen alone, illustrates beyond all doubt that it is necessary to put the fishing industry on a broader and wider basis. I should like to see a separate Minister in charge of that particular Department. After all, if we could even reach 50 per cent. of Norway's output, we would have over 50,000 men in gainful employment in this country in an industry that will not occupy a square inch of our soil, other than the ground needed for the necessary harbour facilities and the necessary factory facilities for dealing with the fish landed. I make this plea to the Minister in all good faith. I have made it practically every year since I came to the Dáil and I make it again to the present Minister, as I say, in all good faith. I say that he has as valuable an asset for development in the fishing industry as he has in the very excellent plan which he proposes to put into operation for the reclamation of the waste lands of this country.
Comment on this
I cannot speak with the experience of Deputy Sir John Esmonde, but I think he made an excellent speech for the development of the fisheries of this country. I represent a few fresh water fishermen, probably in or around 50, on the reaches of the Shannon north of Athlone and if what I hear to-day is true or if any person is serious about putting these suggestions into effect, these people will be deprived of their livelihood. There was an inquiry a fortnight, three weeks or a month ago —I do not know the dates—and I thought that the findings of that inquiry would be in the hands of the local Deputies, but I have not got them. These people are being deprived of fishery rights at the moment. Mind you, I think there was a time when they should have applied for compensation, but I suppose they were strong-headed enough to think that they could carry on and, by carrying on, support their wives and families. Their wives and families will be in a bad way in the future. I am disappointed that the findings of that inquiry are not in the hands of the local Deputies. I expected that this would be on to-day and I suppose I should have gone to the Department of Fisheries and found out all about it.
These people are real fishermen. They cannot take an eel less than ½ lb. and they cannot take an eel of ½ lb. either. It is the contention of the experts in the Department of Fisheries that if an eel they catch is let go, he will live again, but the fishermen say "no". I do not know who is right. I am told by a very reliable authority, a man who has fished in the fishing waters in Norway that Sir John Esmonde spoke about, that any fish with a hook in him will die. I believe that myself and I think everyone else would agree with me, but the contention is that that is not true. I advised these people, if they get compensation —they cannot be deprived of their right to a living—to take it. I do not know whether they will accept my advice or not; they did not vote for me the last time. The reason they did not vote for me was that fishery inspectors came down and had a fight with them. Deputy Dr. Ryan was in charge at that time and it was like the invasion of Normandy. Man dear, the fight went on for the whole day and only that there was a decent sergeant, somebody would have been killed. My colleague, the Minister for Justice, has, I think, also advised them to take it. If they do not, I would say that they are foolish.
I am living on the banks of a river and I believe it was one of the best rivers for salmon. The old people told me. It is the River Inny, where Leo Casey wrote that valiant song, The Rising of the Moon. The salmon were thick coming up but now there are none at all. The river wants to be silted, as it is all dirt and filth and no clean fish will live in it. It would be easy to clean that river, and it would be a great addition to the State to breed good fish. There are big perch in it and they are as bad as big pike. There is a man there who does not allow anyone to fish even for rough fish—I suppose he thinks every man would poach. He has the rights from Ballynacarrigy to Lough Ree. There is no use in talking to him; he will not allow anyone to fish unless he was a soldier of the British Army, and surely I am taboo there. I do not want to dwell very long on that, but I would like it very much if the Minister could give some idea of what he is going to do with these people. Every night at the week-end when I go home I have them whether they voted for me or not. I think it would be very well if they got compensation and I hope they would be wise enough to accept it. I also hope that the Department of Fisheries will see to that river and clear it of rough fish because there was grand trout and salmon in that river. I hope the Department will also take into consideration the very sound advice that Deputy Sir John Esmonde has given. He is a man of experience who has travelled very far and gained much knowledge. I would like to see fishing thriving and I hope it will.
Comment on this
I find myself in complete and absolute disagreement with the Minister on one aspect of this fishing problem. I do not know where the fallacy was conceived, but I am completely convinced that it is a fallacy and a dangerous fallacy for the Minister to believe that it is impossible for deep-sea trawl fishing to exist side by side with inshore fishing. I am absolutely convinced that there is ample room for both of them and that there is an industrial and employment potential in deep-sea fishing to which the Minister will ultimately have to direct his mind if he is going to preserve the way of life of any section of the population, particularly in areas of my constituency such as Castletown-bere. The Minister has made a suggestion that deep-sea trawling was the weird and ghoulish entity that would consume the inshore fishermen in its onward sweep. I do not believe that and, what is more, I am going to say what I honestly believe. I do not believe that the inshore fisherman is pulling his weight half as much as he should in this industry. I have had some fairly considerable connection with fishing and some very considerable experience to the extent of trying the experiment of going out with these fishermen myself and doing a bit of work. I find that the mentality of the inshore fisherman militates against having a full supply of fish for the home market because he is inclined to work only to the extent that will make his position for the winter secure and is not inclined to go beyond that. He does enough work to satisfy his needs and is inclined to stop at that. I do not for one moment believe, and I do not think any Deputy in this House can believe, that the full market for fish has ever been tapped. I know for a positive fact that there are homes in this country where there never was fish other than salt fish and that is an absolutely deporable condition when one considers, with the development of transport facilities, how easy it is to transport fish, even in a rough iced condition, to any part of this country. I hear people talking about the domestic market. I do not believe that the home market has ever in the history of government in this country been adequately supplied. I do not believe that the Department of Fisheries knows what the home market is and I certainly do not believe that they ever made any real conscientious effort to develop it to the fullest extent.
We have heard in this House a series of complaints of the incidence of cost, particularly in the butchering trade. We have a ready and effective substitute to offer at a more reasonable price, if we go the right way about it— because fish, according to medical experts, is just as nutritious and just as valuable as any meat. There is no difficulty, to my mind, in making this country itself fish-minded, making it have an appreciation of the variety, the quality and the edibility of fish. There is no difficulty about getting down to the fact that we can base in this country a trawling industry that will be able to use and absorb glut catches in more ways than one. People talk of gluts as if it necessitated leaving fish either to rot or to be dumped back into the sea. People seem to forget all the various processes and various subsidiary industries that exist in other countries in relation to fish. You can smoke it; you can can it; you can, by the development of any type of reasonable cold storage facilities, carry it over a glut period into some of the lacuna periods that the Minister is talking about. You can divert certain types of fish, that might be uneconomic in other ways, to certain meal processes that would be useful and would find a ready market.
The one thing that this industry in this country has suffered from—and I am directing the Minister's attention to it deliberately—is that ideas a little too conservative and a little bit too archaic are allowed to permeate the official mind with regard to this problem. The Minister has told us here to-day—and I believe that he himself believes what he says is feasible—that he is going to form this inshore fishery body into a complete co-operative unit, that he is going to have the Sea Fisheries Association guarantee certain prices for certain types of fish and that, with the exception of a certain period when whiting might be running very plentiful, the inshore fisherman will have a guaranteed price and, when fish is not plentiful and he cannot go out for fish, he, in these lacuna periods, is going to buy fish. I would like to ask the Minister where he is going to buy it.
The Minister does not seem to realise that, dealing with the problem of fish at the moment and with all its trawling experience and with all its trawlers in the sea, the British fleets are not able to supply their own market. Even the foreign fish sold in England does not supply the full requirements of that market. How does this Minister anticipate in these lacuna periods being able to buy fish in any great quantity to fill the gap? I think it is a pitiful admission of failure, if you have to admit that you must build your industry in such a way as to give you lacuna periods.
The Minister should keep his mind open on the question of the interlocking of the two types of fishing. I would be very sorry to see the income derived by many of the small farmers who are also inshore fishermen in any way jeopardised, but I do not think that the development of deep-sea trawling would jeopardise it, if the development of deep-sea trawling is done on the following basis. Let the inshore fisherman have the run at your market, let him supply it to the extent that he is able; let your deep-sea trawler fill the gap to give the market its full supply, let the deep-sea trawler ensure that you will not have lacuna periods and that you will have the material for the canning industry apparently envisaged by the Minister. They will be able to build up a supply of fish also for introduction into the various fish meals that can be made a lucrative adjunct to any fishing industry.
The Minister must realise now that there is here a very ready and continuous solution to the unemployment question. There is a huge employment potential in the fishing industry. It mainly consists of the fact that, apart from people who may be engaged in the actual manning of the trawlers and the working of the trawlers themselves, all the various subsidiary industries will require personnel. They will be managed by a few experts and, in general, the workers can be recruited in the normal way in any country district. The Minister will have to realise this and have to keep his mind open on the problem. I can inform him now, even though he himself may be convinced that the inshore fisherman does not usually turn to trawling, that the position exists at the moment that one of the biggest trawling companies of the world, Yeolands of Grimsby, have more Castletownbere and West Cork men managing their trawlers, who were formerly inshore fishermen, than they have of any other nationality. The mind of the younger man in that area is turning to fishing as a full-time occupation, because the conditions in the trawlers are good, the wages are high, the catch bonus is high, the employment is constant and there are regular holiday periods. The younger man growing up who has gone into the trawling service finds it is a steadier and less arduous type of life than his father had before him in trying to augment the earnings of the small farm by earnings in fishing.
The Minister need not have any fears on the ground that you have not the material in this country that will man your trawling fleets, just the same as you might have the material that will man your inshore boats. I want the Minister to keep his mind open on this problem, because fishing will never be developed on a proper basis here until somebody realises that these two types of fishing can exist together, can be worked effectively together and, above all, can become a real national wealth, both from the point of view of the earning capacity of the industry itself and from the point of view that we can keep in gainful employment and based at home in this country many of our boys who are now serving in the trawling fleets of Grimsby and of the other English companies around the English coast.
The problem is a simple one. I think we have become a little bit too Sea Fisheries Association minded in this country. The Sea Fisheries Association itself, with all the goodwill in the world has not got the broadness of vision that it will require. I think that the association, if it had a certain breadth of vision, could see that, even within itself, it could extend to build a co-operativism between the deep-sea fishing and the inshore fishing that would lead to harmony as well as to profit, that it itself could become the nucleus and the driving power to guide the complete coalescing of the two types of fishing into harmonious profit to the nation.
What is really wrong in this country is that, by being over-anxious to preserve the inshore fishermen to the exclusion of trawling, we are ultimately sealing the doom of the fishing industry here altogether. It is bigger than a home market; it can be made infinitely bigger than the home market. The position at the moment is that the home market itself is under-developed and certainly never filled. Drive from Dublin to my constituency any Friday and it will be a miracle if, in the towns of Maryborough, Cashel or Cahir, you can get a bit of fish—at first-class hotels. They can give you a poached egg or a bit of meat. And then people talk seriously to me about the inshore fishermen supplying the home market! It is quite possible that they could supply the home market, but somebody requires to revise completely the idea of what the home market is and to bring up to date in the Fisheries Department the system of marketing. In view of the distance of any place in this country from the sea and from a fishing port, it should be possible for fresh fish to be put into practically every provincial town at least three times a week. That is not done, as we all know, and none of us will blind himself to the fact.
How is it to be done? I heard the Minister talking for a long time about travelling creameries and co-operative creamery systems. Is there any reason why the developing of the marketing of fish should not be done through branches of co-operative societies or by means of various types of transport which have to go in a broad general way amongst the rural community. I am convinced that if fresh fish was available at many of the branch creameries or at the creamery centres to the ordinary rural dweller, it would be bought very readily and I think the time has come, not for experimentation with the balance between brown trout and coarse fish in the rivers, but for experimenting to find a way to get fresh fish into the home of any person who wants it. There are many people who, no matter how they look for fresh fish, are very fortunate if they can get it more than four or five times a year.
I have listened to arguments put up by fishing organisations against deep-sea trawling and have got pamphlets and documents from them. I do not think that any of them have got down to a real analysis of what is the potential of fishing in this country. The richest harvest around our shores is the silver fish in the sea. Anybody who wishes can travel with me the road from Glengarriff to Castletown-bere and he will see there evidence, absolutely incontrovertible, of how good are the fishing grounds around that coast. Spaniards, Danes and Frenchmen—the flags of every nationality under the sun are to be seen on trawlers there, and they are not there for the good of their health. If a Frenchman or Spaniard can incur all the overheads of a journey from his base to the Fastnet to get a catch of fish, how much more profitable should it be for the Irishman within six or seven miles of the fishing ground?
Look at the reality of the situation, I say, and say very earnestly to the Minister. These people can travel long distances and can afford to stay out from their home ports for long periods and, with only a medium catch, as some of the skippers have told me, can show a very considerable profit. An Irish trawling fleet would not have these long distances to travel and would not have to stay out for long periods. They would not have the same overheads but they would be in a position to compete very effectively with any country in the world if we got down to a realisation that fishing could be built into as big an industry as agriculture. It could, within the limits of reason, be developed to the point at which it could be as profitable to the country, from an export point of view as well as from the home market point of view, as agriculture. It could be made an industry with a turnover of £6,000,000 or £7,000,000 a year.
People may think I am mad and I suppose anybody who has the courage to be progressive is usually dubbed mad, but if smaller countries than this, countries with fewer facilities and not so well placed geographically, without the advantage of proximity to certain runs of fish that come at periods of the year, can make this industry a tremendously lucrative industry, why cannot we who are searching for a way to stem emigration and to kill unemployment, get to grips with the whole problem of a fishing industry and explore its potentials? With certain constituents of mine, I went to see the Minister and I was given a long lecture on the inshore fisherman, on his many qualities, his way of life, and so on. I was thoroughly appreciative of all that, but I was not convinced then, and I am still seeking somebody who can convince me, that it is not possible for these two types of fishermen to work together, as they could work together. So much for that aspect of fishing.
I come down now to the mundane realities of the situation as it is. The Minister expressed fond hopes that, at the end of this financial year, many of the applicants on the waiting list for boats, gear and tackle would be dealt with. I want to ask a very direct question: how many boats can we expect in West Cork in the coming year and when can we expect the first boat? The Minister may recollect that he made a certain promise to me, following a deputation, and I should like to know now when we may expect the first welcome incursion of new boats into our fishing fleet in West Cork. I should like to know also if he proposes to develop the boat yards at Baltimore to a higher capacity and if his representations to the Minister for Industry and Commerce with regard to electric power in these boatyards have been successful. I should like to know further how soon he hopes to have this co-operativism which he has envisaged for the Sea Fisheries Association completed and where he proposes to buy the fish to fill the lacuna periods.
I may have sounded critical of the Minister, but my criticism is not a criticism of any specific Minister. My criticism is that we have not yet got down to tackling fishing in its proper concept. I think we are inclined to hit and run in the matter of fishing, which I feel should be and could be as important as agriculture, and which should have in the Department as much significance as wheat growing, cattle feeding or any other branch of agriculture. It can be made a ready and positive source of wealth and I would not be doing my duty if I did not urge that it is a problem which still needs much exploration and that it is too soon yet to shut the door against a double-edged or double feature fishing industry.
In so far as the Estimate shows substantial increases in the money made available for the provision of boats, tackle and engines for inshore fishermen, I welcome it. I want to see the Minister as rapidly as possible putting the inshore fishermen in the best possible position to do the job they are meant to do. I want to see them getting every facility the country can provide for them, and if an increase in these facilities will make life better for the hard worker who has to farm his few acres and try to farm the many acres of the sea, this House should commend and wish God speed to them. I earnestly urge the Minister to get down to the job now, so that, in the coming year, he can come before the Oireachtas with a well-balanced plan for taking the fishing industry out of the category of a £500,000 a year industry and putting it quickly in the category of a £6,000,000 a year national asset.
Comment on this
In my opinion, there are far more people in the country interested in the nationalisation of inland fisheries than there are persons interested in any other form of nationalisation that has taken place or that is about to take place. Nearly always, the popular comment about people who own private fisheries is adverse. There is never the same adverse comment about private monopoly of transport, electricity, or anything else. For that reason, the contrast which the Estimates show between the treatment of people who, quite voluntarily, for reasons of sport, or some other reason, foster fisheries who make no profit out of them and who can get only very meagre grants for the provision of hatcheries and suchlike work, and the treatment of the boards of conservators, most of whom have a financial interest in the fisheries, is very unwelcome. There is an increase in the grant to boards of conservators of £500 as compared with last year whereas a very fine undertaking, the Corrib hatchery at Oughterard, which was established by Galway and Lough Corrib, Anglers' Association, get the miserly grant of £10. They have done trojan work to restock Lough Corrib, which is the largest sheet of water in the country which provides free fishing. That contrast is not at all complimentary to us as a Parliament. I do not want to lay the blame entirely on the Government. We all should unite our voices in asking that the people who are showing a praiseworthy interest in the development of inland fisheries should be encouraged by better financial assistance than they have been receiving.
I want now to discuss the estuarine fisheries. They give good employment to a large number of men in my constituency. I never could understand why the Sea Fisheries Association, which goes to so much trouble to organise the ordinary sea fishermen, has always excluded these men. They are left to the mercy of the dealers in salmon. I am not saying that they have been crushed entirely by these dealers but the point I want to make is that if the Sea Fisheries Association provided for these men the facilities that are provided for other fishermen, the lot of these men would be improved enormously.
For instance, in each estuary or convenient area along the coast, they could organise the local fishermen and give them the facilities they require to carry on their trade. The first essential would be the provision of nets. At present, nets are provided for them by the people who buy the fish and so much per pound of salmon is deducted, and out of the fund thus created the men are provided with nets which, of course, as far as I understand, remain the property of the person who finances it.
There is a fairly big difference between the price the men get for their salmon and the price salmon fetches on the Dublin or English markets. I make the plea that the Sea Fisheries Association should see to it, that these fishermen are organised so that they can get, to the fullest possible extent, the benefit of the price which the fish makes when it is sold in Dublin or England. That would represent a very considerable improvement in income for these men. Having said so much about it, I leave it to the consideration of the Minister and the Department.
The Minister referred to the inshore fishermen who complain of failure to sell their catch at certain times of the year and he said that they had no cause for complaint if they supplied— the words he used were "the market that they themselves elect to overload". After all, these inshore fishermen have no choice. The problem is part and parcel of the old question that was discussed here last year and that has been referred to by a far larger number of speakers this year than I have heard in my experience in this House. It is the question of the inshore fishermen versus the deep-sea trawler. Everybody knows that the equipment which our inshore fishermen have does not enable them to fish in all weathers and in all places. They have to go by the weather and fish within a fairly confined area. Are these men to be blamed if, being restricted in that way, they fish when they can and where they can? The solution, as other speakers have suggested here to-night, is to have a complementary fishing arm. I spoke about it last year and the Minister pooh-poohed it. I was very pleased to hear so many Deputies supporting that suggestion as enthusiastically as they have done this evening.
I, too, am all for the inshore man. We have been treating inshore fishing for a long time more or less as a social service. Years ago, loans were issued and, after a lapse of time, when the loans could not be repaid, an Act was passed to revise the loans. A great many of them were wiped out. Therefore, I think I am justified in saying that we have been regarding inshore fishing more or less as a social service. If our main consideration is simply to keep these fishermen going as they have been going almost from time immemorial, without any ideas of expanding the numbers engaged and without reference to the supplying of our own home market with fish, I take it that that is a confession that we have no policy in the matter and that we have no aim other than that of continuing this method of maintaining a small fishing community. I want to support those speakers who have spoken to-night and who have advocated a change of mind on the part of the Minister and who have indicated that this country should emulate other small countries who have made their fishing industry a very profitable one. Last year I was bold enough to make a suggestion as to how that might be done. I have not heard it referred to by anybody this evening nor, I think, did anybody refer to it last year other than myself. It is that the development of that type of fishing might be turned over to our naval service. There is no reason why we should not acquire a number of boats of a large size. They would serve, incidentally, as training ships for the men who join the naval service. There would, too, be a more complete control over them than there would be in the case of a privately-owned trawling company. I do not think we are ever likely to see a privately-owned trawling company coming into existence unless it is substantially financed in its initial stages by the State and unless the people who operate it are guaranteed against loss by the State. I do not think that that is an arrangement any Government in this country should enter into. If it cannot be established in any way other than by the assistance of the State it should be done entirely by the State and, most appropriately in my opinion, be handed over to the naval service. Then, if you have your inshore fleet supplying your home market reasonably well it is quite easy to keep your larger ships in port. Then when—because of weather conditions or for any other reason—there is a fall in the catches of the inshore fishermen, these others are always there to supply not alone the country's needs but, if there is a good market outside, to expand our exports.
That may be a very half-baked idea but I think there are people in the country who would support it. Whether it is a good idea or otherwise, we ought—seeing that we are now trying to induce our young men to become sea-minded—to have a second arm to our naval service and I believe it would attract a larger number than are now going into the naval service. After a period of training we could release them. They could go back to their own areas and they would be better marks for the attentions of the Sea Fisheries Association in the allocation of their boats later on. Along the coast, where the inshore tradition has been kept alive, we require to train a large number of the young men who are growing up and some means will have to be found of getting them to take an interest in the sea.
On the question of the increased provision of money for advances for boats and gear and general development, I should like to ask the Minister two questions. What type of boat is it intended to provide? Are we going to get a larger boat than has heretofore been provided and can the Minister give us an approximate idea as to the distribution of these boats? When I ask him about the distribution of these boats I ask him to tell us where the applicants on the waiting list are located. Will he allocate the available boats this year fairly reasonably around the coast? I want to make one very serious complaint in this regard. As far as I recollect, County Galway has practically the largest membership in the Sea Fisheries Association. It has also the unenviable record of having received the lowest number of boats— in any event, of all the counties with a large membership of the Sea Fisheries Association. That situation should be remedied. There is a fairly substantial increase this year but I do not suppose it will go as far as it would have gone, say, pre-war when costs were lower. I know that the cost of boats and equipment has gone up but, whatever number may be provided this year, I think I am entitled—in view of the present position in regard to the distribution of boats and the membership of the association—to make a very strong plea that County Galway will not be ignored as it has been in the past. I should also like to repeat an opinion that I have often expressed. It is not altogether my opinion; it is based on the opinions of the men who have to go to sea. It is that the standard type of boat— I know it is not now rigidly adhered to by the association—is not at all suitable for the west coast and a larger boat should be provided.
The sum of £13,000 for general development is not very large. I am surprised to hear the Minister say that it is now intended to re-establish the boat yard at Meevagh which was discarded. There is a boat yard in Killybegs and that particular boat yard replaced Meevagh. Now the Minister says that it is intended to reopen the boat yard at Meevagh. I do not object to giving the Donegal fishermen all the facilities it is possible to give them, but what I do say is—and my remarks in this connection are on a par with what I said about the distribution of boats—that the distribution of the facilities should be equitable. Why have two boat yards in one county while you have the whole west coast from Donegal to Kerry without any boat yard? If you are going to establish a second one, why not establish it either in Mayo or Galway? I think that is a very reasonable request to make. I have no doubt that a second boat yard would be very welcome and required in Donegal, but it might be left over until the next time this type of development takes place.
The question of boat yards has a very close relationship with the question of harbour works generally. Deputy Esmonde made a plea on which he was on a very solid ground, and I want to support him. I think we should raise a large sum of money— and there is no reason why we should not ask the people to lend that money as we have for other purposes—(1) to repair the damage done to existing harbour works and (2) to provide new ones where they are required. A great deal of damage was done in the winter of 1942 by a very high tide that struck Western Europe. Some very important piers and harbours in this country were practically destroyed by that high tide and they are still lying derelict because the county councils are unable or unwilling to provide money to repair them. In view of the high rates which now prevail, the county councils have a very good case to make. Having carried out a survey of the work to be done, the State ought to make it a special job to provide the money necessary to repair these works and provide new ones all round the coast.
While the exports of demersal and other fish have increased satisfactorily in 1948 over 1947, I was very much disappointed to see that there was a very heavy falling off in the value of the takings of crayfish, escallops and lobsters. I have had complaints that we have not been given in Galway the number of boats to which the organised membership entitles us. From this type of fish, however, we have always been able to make a nice income in the summer season. The cray-fishing industry was established by Frenchmen here. It was down on its luck during the war, but one would expect it to be showing signs of improvement now. There was a drop in the value of the takings of crayfish from £7,315 in 1947 to £2,886 in 1948. In escallops, there was a drop from £7,636 in 1947 to £4,198 in 1948. The drop in the value of lobsters taken was from £34,406 in 1947 to £27,327 in 1948. I am not putting that down to neglect on the part of the Department of Fisheries, but I should like to be given some information as to why that is so. What is responsible for this very heavy drop in this type of fishing which is particularly advantageous to the people on the west coast?
We have not the same advantages in regard to other forms of fishing. We have not got boats such as they have on the east and south coast, or a chance of making a decent income by taking demersal fish. But this was a sort of speciality in the west and it is a pity to see it falling off. I know that one very good bay in Galway for fishing for escallops was over-fished some years ago, but it was given a rest for the last couple of years and I am wondering if fishing in that bay cannot be resumed again. As to cray fishing, I do not know why it should have fallen off. One Frenchman who was interned or unable to come back during the war is back for the last couple of years, and there is another Frenchman, I understand, in the south of Ireland who has been following up cray fishing since the end of the war. We were expecting that this fishing would increase rather than decrease.
I want to make a plea for the officials of the Sea Fisheries Association. I do not know why they have been left without a pension scheme up to this. I think that they are the only officials employed by a State-subsidised organisation who have not got a pension scheme. The Minister, the Department and the directors of the association ought to give that matter some attention.
On the question of quick freezing, I should like to put to the Minister the very exceptional position that exists in the Aran Islands. It is not easy to transport fish at suitable times from the islands. The Dun Aengus only makes the trip to the islands once a week and that day may not always be suitable for despatching fish. If the question of the marketing of the fish from the Aran Islands can be solved by the establishment of this quick-freeze process there, I would ask that the matter be considered. The Aran islanders and people situated like them around the coast are very often able to take very considerable catches of fish, but, when they get them on to the islands, they are faced with this difficulty which during the war was insuperable. If this quick-freeze process would solve it, I make a plea that it be considered in connection with the location of these plants around the coast. Finally, I want to ask when the report of the committee of inquiry which the Minister set up last year will be available and, if it is available to him at present, when is it intended to publish it.
Comment on this
As a result of the speeches made on this Estimate, I feel that it is the intention of members on all sides of the House that there will be no necessity in future for the insertion in the local papers of that slogan we have been reading for many years: "Eat more fish." It is refreshing to find the unanimity that exists amongst Deputies that something should be done for the fishing industry. It was heartening to me to hear the Minister inform the House that it is his intention during the current year to spend a sum of £86,000 more than last year. The sum is a reasonably large one, but I do not think it is large enough, considering the lucrative harvest that can be got from the sea by spending a larger amount of money.
I will not say the fisheries in this country have been sadly neglected since the inception of this State, but certainly they have never been pushed forward as they might have been. I would like to see the Minister do a little more for the fishermen than has been done up to the present time. I realise, of course, that during the war it was very hard to get boats of the standard and style made to stand up to the south-westerly gales that rage around the west and southern coasts of Ireland. However, now that things are coming back to normal, I hope that as year succeeds year the Minister will expedite the getting of boats for fishermen.
The particular locality from which I come, the South of Ireland, is fringed by one of the finest sea fishing grounds in Europe; that is the sea-line from Roche's Point to Ardmore Head. Ballycotton, which is included in that area, is renowned amongst fishermen all over the world. I think I am in disagreement with the Minister somewhat. If the fishermen of Ballycotton could get a larger type of boat than they have been used to fishing from for many years they would bring far more fish into their port for distribution throughout the country. In my own town of Youghal we have a considerable fishing community, those hardy toilers of the deep, men who make a very hazardous and dangerous living for many months of the year at the mouth of the Blackwater and extending out into Youghal Bay. When the salmon season finishes in the month of July the outlook for many of these men is somewhat gloomy until February comes around again. The vast majority of them are really fishermen by profession and there is nothing open to them during the ensuing months but to go to the unemployment exchange and draw the dole. They do not want to do that. I know, and I hope to impress on the Minister—big-minded man that he is, I am sure he will be generous where men like these are concerned—that if he, through the Sea Fisheries Association, could give two or three boats to these men which would employ 12, 15 or 20 men during the intervening months of the salmon season it would be a veritable godsend for all those people. As I say, we have some of the finest fishermen in Ireland along that coast—Ballycotton, Youghal, Roche's Point and Gyleen— men who have been brought up in an atmosphere of fishing. Unfortunately, however, the vast majority of them have not got the finance to put into boats.
I would respectfully suggest to the Minister that he should recommend his Department to make a survey of those localities and see if he could help men who are willing to work and work at a very dangerous livelihood. I heard the Minister state in his opening speech that there is a long waiting list for boats. Materials are now getting somewhat more plentiful than for many years and I hope that when next year comes along we will not have a long waiting list of boats and that anybody who wants a boat will get it.
There seems to be some danger of gluts of fish. I suggest that a glut of fish is a good thing but we do not want gluts of fish if we have nowhere to preserve them. May I suggest that at various parts of our coasts the Minister should instal canning factories. Naturally, I should like to see one installed in my own town where there was a very thriving canning factory in days gone by. Times have changed but I do feel that the people of this country are becoming more fish-minded again than they have been for many years past. Deputy Collins, I think, referred to the paucity of fish in many of the inland towns in Ireland. I agree with him there. I do not see any reason at all why any of the larger towns throughout the Midlands, where people through religious persuasion eat fish on Friday, should not be able to get fresh fish. Many have to import from places like Tramore and Ballycotton and there should be no necessity for that. I think that in modern times when vans can travel 150 miles over the country no town in Ireland should be left without fish on such a day.
Take the sprat industry. There is a colossal amount of money in sprats. In my own town of Youghal, last year, during August and September it gladdened the heart of every townsman there to see up to 80 or 100 men employed day after day boxing sprats— to see those boxes loaded, as they say, up to the gunwale with sprats coming in from Youghal Bay—packing them and sending them off to the various preservative houses in this country and putting them into cold storage. The time came when there was no room for the sprats in the storage premises and the men could not go on bringing in any more. Increasing the volume of the storage required for the preservation of fish in this country is a thing the Minister might look into.
Deputy Sir John Esmonde gave a very lucid and comprehensive survey of what the fish industry means to the various countries throughout the world. He mentioned Norway, Iceland, Belgium and France. I do not see, at all, why we should not have a fishing fleet of our own in this country. The Minister at the moment does not seem amenable to that suggestion judging by his opening utterances, but I hope that as a result of what the speakers have said in the House this afternoon he will bear it in mind and when he introduces his Estimate next year that he will announce to the House that he is forming a fishing fleet. Naturally it is a great change for us. I believe that the people of this country are acquiring a greater taste for fish than they had in days gone by. Perhaps in our young days when we visited our relations in the country we were delighted to be served with dried cod. There was nothing nicer and nothing would give a greater crispness to our appetites than to get some of that served up to us in the days when we were younger.
The Minister mentioned the question of the protection of our fishery beds. I do not think sufficient attention is paid to the preservation of the fishery beds along our coasts. I am referring to the whole coast of Ireland. I saw with my own two eyes during last summer around the months of June, July, August, September and October hordes of French fishing trawlers. They came along from Roche's Point to Ballycotton, where I told you a few minutes ago the finest sea fishing ground in Europe is, right on into Youghal Bay and right on to Ardmore and Dungarvan. They absolutely ruined the grounds. They came in there under cover of the darkness showing no lights, dropped their nets and literally tore from the fishing ground every type of fish. Now, knowing the Minister, I feel certain that he will pass on what I have said to his Department. It is not my desire to throw any further work on the Department because I realise that every Government Department has quite enough to do. This is a case, however, where night after night the finest fishing ground in the world is being torn to pieces. I have no doubt that the Minister will attend to this.
There is another thing which is causing a vast amount of damage to our fishing grounds throughout the country. I refer to the destruction of fish by cormorants or, as they are known to myself and people who live by the seaside, the "big black divers". According to the local fishermen, each cormorant can devour up to two stone of fish in a day. I have seen them myself devouring a plaice weighing up to three or four pounds. I do not know how they got it down. I suggest that these cormorants are causing terrific havoc not only along the coast of the South of Ireland, but all over the coast of the country. They just come into our harbours and bays. I think that, if the Minister could devise some means of destroying these birds, he would be conferring a great favour on our fishermen. The only place to get at them is in their breeding places. They breed in the rocky places at Cable Island and elsewhere. Thousands and thousands of them are bred there. Something should be done to destroy them. They go up along the Blackwater and they do a tremendous amount of damage. This is a matter that the Minister might give his attention to.
I am firmly convinced that there is a potential of enormous value in our fishing industry. If all the money that is in it could be got out of it, it would certainly bring great happiness and contentment into the homes of our people who make their living from it. We are all glad, when the harvest time comes in August, to see the corn ripening into a lovely golden sheen. That gives happiness to all of us because we know that we are going to have a bountiful harvest which will make our livelihood secure for another year. We should be able to reap a silver harvest from the sea. If the industry were properly attended to and properly managed, the glistening, glittering fish in the sea would bring the same gladness and happiness into the homes of our fishermen which the golden harvest brings to our farmers and others engaged in the agricultural industry. There seems to be complete unanimity amongst Deputies that the fishing industry could be made a vast and a colossal one if properly worked, one that would bring considerable happiness into the homes of our fishermen.
Comment on this
I have spoken on this Estimate on each occasion that it came before the House in the last four or five years. I must say that it is in a very deplorable condition. The principal reason for that is the want of proper boats and of proper landing places.
Comment on this
In my part of the country. The piers and the slips are in a very bad state. They are in such a bad condition that the fishermen are afraid that if they go out they may not be able to get back. I have three or four landing places in mind that I want to call attention to. There is the one at Portheen at Achill. It is in a very bad condition. That has been so during the past 12 months or two years. The officials of the Board of Works went down there and examined it. I understand they made an estimate for its repair but nothing has been since done. The same can be said of the pier at Darby's Point. They also made an estimate for it. There was the question of a grant from the Government, but nothing has been done because the 25 per cent. that the Mayo County Council was to contribute was not forthcoming. There is a good deal of fish landed at both these places, but the local fishermen are suffering great hardship because nothing has been done to improve the condition of the piers.
The piers at Porturlen and Portacloy are also in a very bad condition. The engineers from the Board of Works also went down there and made a report. I would ask the Minister to see that full grants are given for the repair of these piers. They are very important landing places in that part of the country. There would be a good deal of deep-sea fishing there for mackerel and herring if these piers were improved. Their condition at present handicaps the fishermen considerably.
There is another pier at Graughill. It is in such a condition at the present time that nothing can be landed there. It was blown up by a mine during the first world war and has never been repaired. I understand that the Department was prepared to give a grant for its repair, but since the 25 per cent. contribution that is required from the Mayo County Council was not forthcoming, nothing has been done. The members of the county council hold that a full grant should be given by the Government. As the Mayo County Council is constituted, the majority of the members come from inland places, and hence they are not prepared to agree to the 25 per cent. contribution. I would ask the Minister to see that a full grant is given for the repair of these piers. They are in a very dangerous condition. The fishermen are likely to lose their lives if something is not done to put them in a safe condition. The fishermen there are poorly equipped for fishing. They have only small currachs along that coast and are afraid to go out in bad weather.
I would ask that the Department would give loans for boats to some of the fishermen in that area. I think they are entitled to that much. They should be provided with proper facilities to enable them to carry on the fishing industry. Complaints have been made to me by men in my constituency who used to be engaged in net fishing in the fresh water lakes and rivers which have now been taken over by the rod fishermen. I am of opinion that a law was passed some years ago under which the men who were engaged in the net fishing there would be entitled to compensation. So far, they have not been paid any compensation. I think it is time they got it. These are some of the points that I would ask the Minister to look into.
Comment on this
I feel that the fishing industry has been very much neglected. I am afraid that we have wasted a considerable amount of energy in developing industries for which we had not the raw material at hand. In fact, we tried to develop some industries that could be described as exotic industries, while at the same time ignoring the wealth and the harvest that, so to speak, lie at our hands around the coasts of the country. I think it is about time the Department tackled this problem seriously. I believe the home market for fish could be considerably developed if there were proper transport facilities. I suggest that the Minister should take that matter up with the Department of Industry and Commerce and see that proper facilities for transporting fish to inland towns are made available. There is a certain antagonism to the eating of fish among people in inland towns, but I believe that if they got their fish delivered fresh regularly the fish eating habit could be developed. In that way we would provide a considerable market for the catches of our fishermen and at the same time we would leave other commodities available that we might export in exchange for something we require at home.
The Minister referred to trawlers and deep-sea fishing. He said he has decided that we are not to have deep-sea-fishing or trawlers. The fact is that we have trawlers but we do not own them. Other countries have these trawlers coming within our three-mile limit and they are carrying on deep sea fishing which the Minister thinks, in his wisdom—probably he is very well advised—is against the interests of the inshore fishermen, and the interests of fishing generally. He has decided, anyhow, that he cannot permit the Irish people to have trawlers, but the French, the Spaniards, the Norwegians and the English are coming within our three-mile limit and taking these fish. If somebody has to take the fish, I suggest it should be Irishmen in Irish trawlers rather than men in foreign trawlers.
I am glad that the Minister will see the Minister for Defence with the object of getting our aeroplanes to have some practice spotting poachers. He should also ask the Minister for Defence to put the motor torpedo boats and corvettes in certain areas where they would be in reasonable distance of the foreign trawlers when they are notified by the aeroplanes that the Minister hopes to have protecting our coasts. That practice would give valuable experience to the members of the naval service and our air force.
There is one place in my constituency that I hope the Minister will make some effort to help, and that is the town of Kinsale, which has for years been famous for its fishing industry. At the moment the natives of Kinsale cannot get a fish because they are taken by foreign trawlers. Kinsale is like a deserted village, a decadent town. The people are emigrating; they are joining the British Navy or are going to the United States. If there was proper protection for the fishing industry and proper transport for the fish there would be considerable employment for the people there. Kinsale is one of the towns that have had their railways taken away by shortsighted people. In the old days it was a garrison town, but it is not like that at the moment.
When the Minister is considering where he will place the quick-freezing plant to which reference was made in this debate, he should give some consideration to such an important centre as Kinsale. It could also serve other parts of West and East Cork. There is also room for a canning factory in Kinsale and it would be desirable to establish a factory there for producing fish foods for stock feeding and possibly a factory for fertilisers. Kinsale is a town that has great possibilities and if the Minister will give these matters some consideration he will find he will be doing something for the benefit of the fishing industry as a whole.
Our fishing industry has undoubtedly been neglected and it can be developed. I believe the home market for fish can readily be developed if some attention is paid to a proper system of transport.
Comment on this
When I raised certain questions last year in the innocence of my heart I got a certain amount of abuse because I criticised certain matters, and I came to the conclusion that it was the usual legal method—when the lawyer has a bad case he must have recourse to abuse. I am, and always have been, interested in the fishing industry and, perhaps, that is natural enough, seeing that I represent a constituency which has such a large seaboard as County Waterford. Listening to the debate, I was impressed by the general criticism of the policy of the Government with regard to the fishing industry. There seems to be a lack of imagination and enterprise about it.
I have listened to people putting forward ideas as to how the fishing industry should be developed and it often set me wondering how it is we are so lacking in Ireland in the matter of being marine minded. I do not say that it is altogether the fault of this Government or the previous Government or the Department, but we are definitely lacking in what one might call the marine mind. It may be due to British influence. I think it is partly due to that. The British Government have always encouraged fisheries, especially in Scotland and Newfoundland, so that they could draw from those places material for their fleet. But that incentive was not present in the case of Ireland. Again, we were overshadowed by the fishing industry of Britain which has its own difficulties and its own hard fight. Another factor is that we are such a large producer of meat. You may notice that countries that are good for developing fisheries are fairly poor, from the agricultural point of view—countries such as Norway and the Basque country in the south of France and the north of Spain, where the people are tremendously energetic in their fishing enterprise.
Whatever the reasons may be, we are ignoring a great source of wealth in this country. There is a great fishing bank about 200 miles west of Ireland. Continental people have often spoken to me about it. It is the place where fishermen used to go. Stories have been written in French and other languages about how the fishermen visit that part of the ocean and do most of their fishing along that bank. We have never tried to exploit that bank. The problem before the Minister, of course, is one of marketing. I imagine the solution can be found in several directions. First of all, there is room for the development of the home market. Fish sold at the present time in inland country districts is very unappetising. It is generally carried in baskets which are often not clean and are quite definitely unattractive. Again, we do not cook fish in this country as they cook it on the Continent or in Scotland. We do not seem to have mastered the art of dealing with fish. Countrymen are very glad to get good fish. Men from the mountains have often told me that they would give anything to get good fish. I think a great deal of attention must be paid to the humble details of marketing and of teaching our younger people how to cook fish properly.
It has been impressed upon me by enterprising men that there is a tremendous source of untapped revenue in our potential fishing industry. Factories could convert the surplus fish into fish meal for poultry and animal feeding. If we were to use our own materials in that way it might save us many dollars now and in the future. It is an industry which should be closely examined by the Department. Perhaps the Minister will tell us in concluding whether any examination is being made into the possibilities of developing this wealth around our coast.
I am not impressed by the Minister's argument that we may do away with a mode of life. I do not think you would change the farmer-fisherman into a whole-time fisherman. In some areas in my constituency the fishermen are all deep-sea. They know more about the South Seas than they do about the city of Cork. It is these men and their families who will keep up the supply of deep-sea fishermen. In time the sons of the inshore fishermen could be trained also for the deep-sea fleet.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not take it amiss if I put before him now my dilemma. My problem is that if you have an efficient trawling fleet operating it will deliver so much fish to the domestic market that no market will be left to consume the produce of the inshore fisherman's labour and he will be completely squeezed out. That is the problem.
Comment on this
I admit that problem is there, but I assume that supply and demand would have to grow hand-in-hand. The best way out of the difficulty would be to develop the market simultaneously with the gradual development of the supply. I think it would be a mistake to discourage even small attempts at deep-sea fishing in the beginning. I think they should be allowed to grow and at the same time we should develop the market. That would be a useful experiment and it might develop into a very valuable source of wealth. I admit it should not be gone into too hastily. We should not develop a large deep-sea fleet to such an extent as to spoil our market. We should develop the fleet and the market pari passu.
Comment on this
I will do it to-morrow if you can prove to me that it will not destroy the living of 2,000 men.
Comment on this
There is one matter upon which I am almost afraid to touch because of the outrageous way in which the Minister spoke last year when I mentioned it. I refer to the guarding of our fish. Last year the Minister asked why I did not do something when I was in office. When a Minister is in office he does not make public announcements about these things. Representations are made by word of mouth. Every Deputy who represents a coastal area is always nudging his Ministerial colleagues and saying: "My friends are at me again about the foreign fishermen coming in and would you send a boat around our way some time." Complaints come from all parts of the coast. I am glad the Minister hopes to induce the Department of Defence to send out their aeroplanes. I imagine that will have a salutary effect. But how is the Minister going to deal with the foreign fishermen who come into the local pubs and do a deal there? That presents a problem. Perhaps it is a trivial matter.
There is then the vexing problem of control over the small ports and piers. I could enumerate several of them beginning at Sheep Point on to Passage and Dunmore and down as far as Ardmore and into Youghal. These are all under various authorities. Some are under the authority of the county council. Some of these authorities do not appreciate the necessity for attending to the upkeep and repair of the harbours and so on under their care. I think all these should be taken over by a central authority in close relationship with the fishing industry. I get all kinds of complaints. Sometimes it is complaints about dredging; sometimes it is because of the length of the pier and sometimes it is because of lack of repair. Nobody seems to know to what authority to appeal. In most cases one gets no results at all and things remain as they are.
In one area I have seen quite a good fishing industry develop in recent years and the number of families making their living out of fishing has increased considerably there. I believe that if attention were paid to these matters very satisfactory results would accrue. There is no doubt that the fishing community are amongst the finest of our people. They live hard, healthy lives. They make fine Irishmen. In many cases they live in native-speaking areas. Any assistance given to them would help in the development of a native-speaking Irish people.
Comment on this
As Deputy Little has remarked, the House seems to be fairly unanimous that the fishing industry needs much more attention than it has received in the past. All Deputies are agreed that this industry could develop into the second major industry in this country. The Minister, however, does not appear to hold that view. I do not propose to delay the House very long. I spoke on this Estimate last year and I think it is a waste of time repeating myself. The Minister's problem, according to himself, is that he is afraid that the livelihood of the inshore fishermen will be destroyed if he takes steps to develop a deep-sea fishing fleet or to get large trawlers to engage in deep-sea fishing. He has mentioned the fact that he has been asked to put in jeopardy the livelihood of 2,000 inshore fishermen.
Let us examine that argument of the Minister for a moment to see if it can be demolished, as I think it can. He is prepared, as far as I can see, to sacrifice the development of a first-class industry for the sake of protecting the livelihood of 2,000 individuals. He has revealed himself as a man of vision in the sphere of agriculture but he has shown himself to be more than conservative in his outlook on fisheries. The man who is prepared to look ahead and to take a chance in the vast field of agriculture is now hesitating over a small matter—it is a small matter to my mind, at any rate—because the livelihood of 2,000 individuals is going to be affected, in his opinion. I do not want to be misunderstood on this matter. I do not think the livelihood of these 2,000 individuals is going to be affected. I believe if we had a deep-sea fishing fleet the majority of those, who, up to the present, have been participating in inshore fishing could be absorbed in the deep-sea fishing fleet. That such is the case is proven by the fact that of the vast number of fishermen and sailors at present employed in the British mercantile service and the British trawling fleets, the majority are Irishmen.
Comment on this
A vast number of them are Irishmen, from Cork, Connemara, Donegal and other maritime counties. The Minister does not seem to agree with that but I challenge him to dispute it. Deputy Sir John Esmonde and other Deputies have spoken of the by-products of the fishing industry. I do not want to delay the House by elaborating that point, but the Minister himself must realise that apart from supplying fresh fish to the market, deep-sea trawlers would provide the raw materials for further ancillary industries such as the canning and processing of fish. I think I mentioned to the Minister last year that he should consider establishing factories along our coast, and he as much as suggested that I asked him to set up tin-pot factories all over Connemara, Waterford and Donegal. I did no such thing. If the deep-sea fishing fleet produce bigger catches than the Minister or I can envisage, could the surplus not be directed into these canning factories? Why put it on the market or why say that the market is going to be flooded by the quantity of fish that would be caught by the deep-sea fishing trawlers?
At the present time we have a big drive on in agriculture and we all welcome the improved situation in regard to the bacon industry. Every Deputy knows that one of the by-products of the fishing industry, fish meal, is an ideal mixture for feeding pigs. How do we get our fish meal at the moment? We allow foreign trawlers to fish off our coast. They send their catches back to their own countries and we, in turn, buy the fish meal from them, the raw material of which is caught off our own shores. I think that is a nonsensical type of arrangement. I was very critical here before of our navy. I am still critical of it, and I do not believe that we should even discuss such a thing as having a navy.
Comment on this
Our chief objective should be to have a fishing fleet. We have people here talking about protecting our fishing grounds by getting aeroplanes and motor torpedo boats to chase around after foreign trawlers but the real protection, in my opinion, is to send out our own deep-sea trawlers to fish in competition with these foreign gentlemen, to fish on grounds which these gentlemen find so very lucrative. That is the way to protect our fishing industry—to provide competition against these foreign trawlers. Other speakers have mentioned the huge labour content of a deep-sea fishing industry. As I have said, we have only one major basic industry, namely, agriculture. We should try to establish a second one and not depend on foreign countries for these raw materials. We have the fish right at our doors and I think the majority of Deputies would be willing to press very strongly on the Minister to reconsider his attitude towards the question of establishing a deep-sea fishing industry. I was not listening to the Minister's opening remarks but I believe that he is going to reorganise inshore fishermen. That, of course, will be doing the thing in a small way and it will wipe out, in my opinion, any hope of having a deep-sea fishing fleet.
The question of the supply of fish for rural areas enters into this matter in no small way. At the present time, there is a fairly good demand for fish in rural areas but the unfortunate feature about it is that while people may get fish on one Friday, they may not be able to get it for another three weeks afterwards. The supply is so uncertain that some people will not bother looking for fish. In addition, some shops do not like stocking fish as they say it contaminates other commodities and has an objectionable smell. But all that can be got over. If the fish are put on the market regularly the market is there, in other words, transport and the marketing of the fish are vital problems. No sooner have the catches been landed on the shore than there must be a fleet of small trucks like whippet cars at hand to transport it to depot centres all over the country. Fish should be there the same as the daily paper in every corner of the country within 12 hours if the transport system were functioning properly. That is something for the Minister to look into.
To go back to another aspect for a moment, the inland fishing which Deputy Bartley or someone mentioned, I should like the Minister to consider the possibility of nationalising our inland fishing. To my mind, it is a deplorable state of affairs that a few gentlemen, "brass hats" from far-off regions, can come into this country and get control of fishing rights in various rivers. I have one gentleman in mind at the moment who has fishing grounds, fishing rights, which are the most lucrative in the country. They are all in the possession of one individual. People may say that that savours of Communism, but I do not see why it should for a moment.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy excuse me? Is that fishing on the banks of a river or in the mouth of a river?
Comment on this
Both in the mouth of the river and on the banks for considerable distances. The fact is that that is a natural source of wealth and should be at the disposal of a majority of the people. It should not be the right of any individual to have a mineral or a source of wealth which God gave for the use of everybody. It is not right that one man can hold the public up to ransom because he is lucky or powerful enough to secure control of certain fishing rights. The Minister should look into that. Let the rights be State-owned and not the property of any individual or individuals.
I can only confess to a very deep disappointment at the present Minister's attitude towards the fishing industry. I would always pay a compliment to a man who works hard as the present Minister is working. He has shown in his other sphere of agriculture that he has vision and is prepared to go full steam ahead in spite of strong and at times unwarranted criticism, but his attitude towards the fishing industry is, to my mind, very conservative. That is a sad commentary to have to make on the Minister but the truth must be faced.
Comment on this
Like other speakers, I agree that we should now try to make fishing one of our chief national industries. This is done in other countries, Norway, Denmark and Sweden, some of which have a population similar to our own and some of which have a population less than our own. Take Denmark: in 1947 the fishing industry was worth £5,000,000. In Norway there is a population of 3,600,000 and it gives employment to over 112,000 people. I feel that we have a wealth in the seas around our shores. It was nice to hear Deputies of all sides of the House agreeing that we have reached the time when we should give more encouragement to our fishing industry. I feel also that by dealing with the fishing industry piecemeal we are never going to get ahead. I thoroughly agree with the Minister in support of the inshore fishermen; their fathers carried on that work before them and they have always lived in a little community and tried to carry on in that way.
The problem with which we must deal first is to try to improve our harbours even if we have to protect the inshore fishermen to some extent. We have reached the point even in County Dublin where the harbours are not adequate for the boats which have to go into them. While I have been critical towards the Minister on other occasions, I must say on this occasion that he is making an attempt to do something about Loughshinny harbour as a result of representations I have made to him. I am not as uncharitable as you might think.
Comment on this
But I would like the Minister to continue to do something in regard to that harbour. The Chairman of Sea Fisheries and an engineer from the Board of Works were down there with me and the one thing they were afraid of is that the Minister will not come forward and give the required grant to make it a decent job.
Comment on this
I am not compromising any civil servants; I am dealing straight with the Minister and his Department. There is no use in dealing with Loughshinny as one harbour and giving a small grant. A number of boats have been smashed there during the last few winters. There would be about ten boats altogether in that small harbour, two of 50 feet and others of 38 feet, 30 feet and 40 feet. The Minister and his Department should show that they are really in earnest and make one decent harbour in that area. The fishermen in north County Dublin feel that the time has arrived when small boats are of very little use because a boat of less than 50 feet cannot go to sea unless the day is reasonably calm. If the public at large want a supply of fish these men must be supplied with boats that can go to sea in reasonably bad weather. Furthermore, an important point is that they want a harbour they can run into when bad weather comes. Sea Fisheries as an institution have been doing their best but they could not get boats or gear during the past few years. There is no use in putting the blame on Sea Fisheries or the officials unless the Minister responsible and his Department will supply the necessary money to carry out this very necessary work. Rush harbour, if I might say so, is also on dry land. The Minister had promised to get that harbour cleaned. That promise is 18 months old now and nothing has been done and I hope it will not continue for another 18 months. The fishing industry is decaying in that district as a result of the very bad harbour and the boats have to go to other harbours. The result is that the small number of families there who are concerned with the fishing industry are losing heart.
Comment on this
By "a dry land harbour" I mean a harbour that has silted up with sand to the extent that you would think it was a dry land harbour. That harbour has silted up nine or ten feet so that the boats can only come in on a high tide and then only to the mouth of the harbour. That is another harbour for which the Minister should come up to his promises.
Comment on this
We have another problem in the Balbriggan harbour. The fishermen over a number of years have constantly agitated about the silting of sand in the harbour and the Parliamentary Secretary, now sitting beside the Minister, dealing with that problem made some promises also to send a dredger to Balbriggan. He did send a dredger, but she did not stay long enough to do a good job.
Comment on this
Why?
Comment on this
She was wanted somewhere else in a hurry and she ran into Balbriggan and out again. These are problems the fishing industry is up against in the local harbours, in Howth, Loughshinny, Balbriggan and Rush. Give the people a decent harbour if you want to put the inshore fishermen in a way in which they can earn a decent livelihood and develop the industry. Save the inshore fisherman and his family. Give them a boat, 50 feet or larger, in that particular area and you will be doing something worth while for the industry in the constituency with which I am deeply concerned.
Until this or any other Government makes an honest effort to do something worth while for the fishing industry, instead of heaping all the abuse and vilification on the Sea Fisheries Association, and until it becomes Government policy to give, not £80,000 more for gear and boats but a few million pounds, we will not be developing properly the industry we have at our doors ready for development. It has been dealt with properly in other countries and I do not see why that cannot be done here.
We have also the problem of the three-mile limit. My colleague, Deputy Dr. Ryan, referred to the time when he was in charge of the Department and made representations to the then British Government to agree to get the three-mile limit extended. The present Minister should continue those representations, to make it at least six miles. Old fishermen along the coast have told me that the fishing industry has been robbed by deep-sea trawlers coming in during the night. That is a national problem. I ask the Minister to try to get the limit extended.
Comment on this
We want to know from the Minister the result of the discussions that were proceeding with the British Government at the time of the change of Government here.
Comment on this
That is not what Deputy Burke asked. Deputy Lemass is trying to dig him out—and making a pretty good hand of it.
Comment on this
I want to know if he will make representations to have the three-mile limit extended.
Comment on this
You would have to call a peace conference analogous to that which settled the Treaty of Versailles.
Comment on this
I am not going into that. We can discuss it on another Vote. I welcome also the quick-freezing plants and would like to find out from the Minister where they will be installed. I have felt for a number of years that the association should get more power, and more money should be put at their disposal to run fish from the harbours to the centre of Ireland. The Minister may tell me he does not want to compete with private enterprise.
Comment on this
I say that possibly the Minister would tell me that. If we are to handle this industry properly, it must be on national lines. What has happened the industry is that the fish usually arrive in inland towns about three days old. The people may buy on one occasion, but on the next five occasions they will say they cannot go near such fish owing to its bad condition. The association and the Department should consider the possibility of making fresh fish available in the large inland towns. That will have to come, of course, after the harbours and ports are developed and gear is provided.
I was not here when the Minister referred to the canning industry. Canning industries have been a great success in other countries and should be a success here. Why should we import fish from other countries, instead of curing our own? The Minister has an opportunity now, if he has any regard for the industry, if he acts properly instead of carrying on, promising to do something and taking such a long time to do it.
Comment on this
Deputy Rooney will get an opportunity to speak in due course. He should be very careful about making interruptions here, because the last interruption here caused a debate down in Rush. There is a surplus of fish at certain periods of the year and we are told the fishermen have a lot left on their hands. I do not see why the association and the Minister should not encourage the canning industry more.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that we are canning fish? May I have the pleasure of sending him a can?
Comment on this
It must be in a very small way and without the national outlook a national industry should have. That is only dealing with it in a piecemeal way. Unless the Minister is going to do it properly, he should leave it alone. He should not be starting on the old game of adding a yard to the pier and a yard to the boat and then saying that the inshore fishermen are doing well.
Comment on this
I will deal with Deputy M. O'Higgins' interruption in a few minutes. Another industry which has been discussed here on several occasions is the fishmeal industry. It is an industry which should be developed. In other countries, there are fishmeal factories where surplus fish are disposed of and, in Norway, even the bones do not go astray. Unless we look on the fishing industry, not from a Party point of view, but from an entirely national point of view, we will not get anywhere with it.
I should like to see more liberal grants available to inshore fishermen for the purchase of boats and gear. While the Sea Fisheries Association has been doing its best for them, the officials are tied up in rules and regulations since the association was established. We are dealing here with a section of our people who are very poor, although there may be a few amongst them who have got on. They are people who undergo great hardships, and, when we speak of them here, we deal with them in a general way. I feel that these fishermen should be better looked after. I have been on some of the boats and have seen the conditions in which these men have to sleep, when staying out possibly for weeks. The only way to deal with this problem is to give them a harbour and then give them a decent boat, and give up all this eyewash about giving them something worth while when you give them a net and a small boat. I should also like to see more up-to-date marine apparatus in their boats.
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister is not so dull of apprehension that he need ask that very nonsensical question.
Comment on this
There have been several speakers on this Vote and no interruptions until now. Some Deputies seem to think this is a place of amusement.
Comment on this
I respectfully asked the Deputy, whom it is my duty to answer, what is marine apparatus, because I want to be able to tell him whether it is in the boats or not.