Committee on Finance. - Vote 31—Fisheries.
Contributions 95–211 of 211. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am sorry the Minister is getting so ruffled, though he would not mind ruffling others himself. I wonder if he ever saw a fishing boat at all.
Comment on this
Deputy Collins was not interrupted once and he should give as good a hearing as he got.
Comment on this
Does the Minister realise what these men have to put up with when they go to sea? Does he realise the conditions in the old tubs in which they go out, without any modern conveniences to enable them to send messages, if they are in difficulties? He knows well enough what I have been trying to talk about. He is the Minister who, on other occasions, tried to misrepresent me and we know how flamboyant he can become on these matters. He is the Minister who, on last Friday, spoke of a decent group of people, the Beet Growers' Association——
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will now be manly enough to withdraw his scurrilous remarks of last Friday about these people.
Comment on this
There is another problem in marketing fish from the fishing ports of North County Dublin. The fishermen in Loughshinny purchased a lorry to carry fish to the market. The lorry was driven by a man who was a mechanic and who looked after their boats. It was a co-operative venture. It happened on a few occasions that the Loughshinny fishing boats had to go to Skerries and, as a result, the lorry driver contravened a section of the Transport Act. He was summoned. I know that the Minister has not very much control over this matter. Neither has the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Act is there. The fact remains that there is grave hardship involved for these people, having purchased the lorry and having employed this man. They were anxious to keep him but they are finding great difficulty in keeping him in constant employment. He does not care to go to sea.
Deputy Bartley made a point about the employees in the Sea Fisheries Association. I have great satisfaction in supporting Deputy Bartley in his plea that these employees should be considered for a pension scheme. If the State or semi-State organisations cannot give good example——
Comment on this
As far as I am aware, I have no power to initiate a pension scheme for the Sea Fisheries Association employees.
Comment on this
Is it not in order to refer to the employees of a concern, and to their conditions of employment?
Comment on this
There is no use asking the Minister to initiate a pension scheme if he has nothing to do with it.
Comment on this
When the Minister gets an opportunity of dealing with the employees of that association, he should make the necessary recommendations that they should be looked after. It is very little use for the Government of a country to ask employers——
Comment on this
I take it that the question as to whether it is in order or not is one you are prepared to overlook for the moment?
Comment on this
Employees of an organisation that this Estimate is voting money to. I submit that is in order.
Comment on this
I am not giving way at all, Minister. Sit down. You can answer later. I was called by the Ceann Comhairle. The Minister did not raise a point of order.
Comment on this
On a point of order. So far as I am aware, Sir, I have no responsibility or power to initiate any proposal in regard to a pension scheme for the employees of the Sea Fisheries Association. Having put that on record, I make no objection to Deputy Burke talking about them for an hour but, so far as I know, I have no power to initiate such a proposal.
Comment on this
In reply to that, I would submit that when the Dáil is being asked to vote money for the purpose of any association, it is open to a Deputy to argue that the Vote should be made subject to conditions affecting the terms of employment of those in its service.
Comment on this
Provided it does not involve legislation, which may not be advocated on the occasion of discussing a Minister's Estimate.
Comment on this
The Chair thinks that a pension scheme contributed to by the State would require legislation.
Comment on this
I do not see why I cannot make a suggestion regarding employees. We have spoken from the national point of view as far as the fishing industry is concerned.
Comment on this
I have spoken about the fishermen and the conditions under which they have to work. I have indicated the hardships they labour under. I have made suggestions for the alleviation of those hardships: the provision of better harbours, better gear and better markets. I am also concerned with the employees who are administering the affairs of the Sea Fisheries Association and, if that is out of order, I must have been out of order since I got to my feet. The Minister has tried to put me off some points by interrupting me repeatedly but, of course, that is nothing new in this House. The Minister in charge of this Vote is very good at doing these things. I cannot see why the Minister would not recommend to the responsible authorities that these employees should be made permanent, if he is not in a position to make them permanent himself. I know that he has lost some very good employees in the Department of Fisheries because of the temporary nature of their work. There was no permanency about it.
I wonder could something be done for dependents of fishermen who lose their lives? Could the Minister, the Department of Fisheries and the Sea Fisheries Association consider introducing some scheme of insurance that would be initiated by the Government for the dependents of fishermen who lose their lives? There have been many tragedies around our coast from time to time. There have been periodic appeals for assistance for the wives and families of drowned fishermen and, possibly, for funds to bury the fisherman and perhaps two or three sons who were drowned with him. The State should see to matters of that kind and ensure that the dependents of these hard-working fishermen will not be left in want for the remainder of their days. These are matters of public and social importance and should be favourably considered by the Department concerned.
I want now to refer to the inadequate lighting of harbours. The county council are concerned. The Electricity Supply Board will do a certain amount. The Minister should look after all these things. I do not see why any public representative should have to come in here and make these appeals. If the industry is to be put on its feet, the needs of these people must be looked after. Some fishermen have to travel a long distance to their boats and may have to be at the harbour on a winter's morning at 2 or 3 o'clock, waiting for the tide. A house or clubroom or some such shelter should be built for them near the pier. These men should be catered for as employees in other branches of industry are catered for. In other industries, clubrooms and canteens are provided but the unfortunate fisherman is treated as nobody's child. These are modern demands that one would expect any responsible Department would definitely look after. In some of the fishing ports I have been in you have to go out with a storm lamp. If you slip you have to crawl on your hands and knees until you reach the boat. If I were speaking to a considerate Minister and to a Minister who had the welfare of the plain people of Ireland at heart, I would have more pleasure in trying to put over this point. However, I am dealing with such a flamboyant Minister who does not mind whether I sit down or talk, and takes no notice whatsoever. I might as well not be talking to anybody.
The Minister did not think the various points I raised on other Votes worth referring to. I know the way he has answered me in the past. I know the way he will answer me tonight or to-morrow. He will go back to his old game—personal slander. That is his answer. I have raised these points conscientiously in the interests of the people whom I have the honour to represent and the people of the fishing industry as a whole. I do not want my remarks to be treated in any flamboyant way by any Minister of State. This is a serious matter to me and to the country as a whole. We are sent here by the people of the country to do our best to improve their lot. For my part, no flamboyant Minister or anybody else will ever deter me from putting before this House the views which I conscientiously hold.
Comment on this
One of the best speeches made in this debate was made by Deputy S. Collins. I am in full agreement with his statement that a deep-sea fishing fleet should be established and so arranged as to be an asset to this country and, indirectly, to assist the inshore fishing industry. In fact, I would go further and say that the Sea Fisheries Association as we know it ought to be remodelled and that we should have a separate Ministry of Fisheries. The matter, in my opinion, is so important that the Department of Fisheries should be a separate Department with a separate Minister and, instead of having an allocation of, say, £100,000 or £500,000, it should be capable of being developed and of calling for an Estimate of £1,000,000 for a year. The only fault I have to find with the Minister's statement is that he said that a deep-sea fishing fleet was not and could not be practical. Not alone did he say that it was not practical at the moment but he said that he did not believe it would be practical in the future. I entirely disagree with the Minister on that point. Whilst I appreciate his efforts in other directions I certainly am not in agreement with him in that connection. We have, on several occasions, put forward to his Department and to the Sea Fisheries Association certain schemes for developments in our district in South Kerry. I am glad to hear the Minister say that he will give us certain consideration in regard to building yards, facilities for acquiring gear, nets and so forth.
However, I should like to make the point that we have men down there who are perfectly capable of boat-building and other practical work of that kind. They resent the idea of being sent to Killybegs or to any other district for their requirements or of bringing men in from other districts when we have our own men on the spot who are capable of doing that work. I was down there and they informed me, when it was a question of installing engines, that our men should take their boats across to Dingle or have them supervised by some engineer from Killybegs. We have men down there who are well qualified and I will give their names to the Minister and to his Department. These men are trained and they are very capable. In addition, they have had very long experience in the boat-building business, in the installation of engines and so forth. I want to stress that point.
On another occasion I have referred to a quick-freezing plant. There is no such thing as a marketing system and there never was in the strict sense of the word. If we had this type of plant it would enable our people to obtain the maximum price on the spot. The catch could then be preserved, held over for an evening and then transported to the different towns throughout the country. In that way a profitable organisation could be built up and we could have a proper system. I know that the Sea Fisheries Association are doing their utmost in present circumstances but there is not sufficient interest. For instance, the Sea Fisheries Association last year were allocated by the Government only about one-fifth of the amount required for the purchase of gear, boats and work in connection with the organisation. Nobody can blame an organisation when its recommendations are not carried out and when the money is not provided to enable the suggestions put forward by them to be put into force. I am aware of all that. I am not against the Department but I am against the whole system. For years this has not been dealt with as an important Department of State and as an important industry.
I was listening to Deputy Dr. Ryan. He referred to the 1939 Act. To my amazement, he asked why it was not implemented. What was he doing when he was here for nine or ten years? This is 1949 and that Act went through in 1939. Provision was made at that time for the acquisition by the State of several fisheries, to be run in the general interest, but no action whatever was taken. I admit, of course, that the war period intervened. Nevertheless, something should have been done and could have been done, and now Deputy Dr. Ryan comes along and asks, as if he were a disinterested party for the last ten years, why something was not done.
We have one of the most valuable fisheries in the State in County Kerry which is run by a company who are making a huge profit. We have dozens of fishermen employed there and we have dozens of fishermen unemployed in the district. If the State acquired this fishery, instead of having one or two people running the whole concern and making £50,000 or £100,000 a year profit, it could be so arranged that the fishery would maintain 100 families instead of the ten, 20 or 30 employed at the moment. That is the type of work I want to see carried out under the Bill referred to by Deputy Dr. Ryan. That Bill was not implemented and the time is ripe when it should be. I have listened to Deputy McQuillan and others who made the same request as I am making. I realise that these men will have to be compensated. Nevertheless, it will be a good day's work for the country and for the fishing industry. Why should not the State take this fishery over in the same way as the Department of Agriculture acquires proprietary creameries and runs them in the general interest and for the benefit of the farmers? There was no sense at all in putting a measure through here in 1939 and leaving it over since then and doing nothing about it. I entirely agree with Deputy Commons that the fishing industry could be made a good second to the agricultural industry if sufficient money was made available for the carrying through of different schemes of development.
Deputy Dr. Ryan also referred to the Cromane mussel plant. The Sea Fisheries Association allocate very little money for operations down there. They are restricted and have not sufficient money to enable them to carry on important operations there. I have made representations to the Minister in the matter. I am not like other people—I like to give full credit where it is due. In my opinion, the Minister is making a good job of his Department and has gone out of his way to make a study of all these problems and to alleviate the hardships of the people I represent. This Cromane mussel plant was an experiment. I give full credit to the former Minister for Agriculture who assisted us in establishing that plant which has justified itself. We have proved that, in certain conditions, not alone can we have an export trade but we can compete favourably with Holland and other countries on the British market. We are hoping that this plant will be extended. It is not sufficiently large at present to deal with all the people who want to get their mussels put through that purification tank. I am making the case that further development work should be carried out there.
As to boats and gear, Deputy Bartley complained that Galway did not get what it was entitled to in accordance with the number of fishermen registered with the association in regard to the allocation of boats and gear. I claim that Kerry is as important and perhaps more important than some of the counties mentioned. It certainly is as extensive and important as Galway and we have not obtained the quota to which we are entitled. Were it not for the Minister's action in assisting me to get Kelvin engines for a few people down there, we would have been left out completely. So far as boats are concerned, our fishermen have been applying for them since 1939, but, with the exception of one or two, they have been left out completely. Deputy Bartley may have good grounds for his complaint, but he is not alone in this matter. I claim that we are entitled to our fair share in proportion to the number of our fishermen and the number registered with the association.
I hope the suggestions I have made will be borne in mind. I am making them in a helpful way. I am not offering destructive criticism, but helpful criticism. I am anxious that the conditions of our people on the southwestern seaboard should be realised. If the Minister for Agriculture was in Valentia Island as I was some time ago on a Sunday evening, he would have seen three Spanish trawlers hauled in there. It would make your blood boil to see them. You would certainly think that we were 100 years behind the times and ask yourself: "Where are our own fishermen who could handle that industry if they had these trawlers and fishing fleets?" These invaders, as I would be inclined to call them, were right in at the pier. That is the thing which should be uppermost in your mind. That is why I resent the Minister's statement when he said that he did not see now or in the future the possibility of having a deep-sea fishing fleet. In my opinion you either have machine-guns and clear these people out of the three-mile limit or go out and put your own fleet side by side with them. That is the only way out of it. In conclusion I appreciate everything the Minister and his Department have done and I hope that any suggestions I have made have been helpful.
Comment on this
There are only a few observations that I should like to make in connection with this Estimate. In doing so I should like to depart from the matters which have been discussed rather extensively, the relative merits of different policies in relation to the sea-fishing industry. I should like to say a word or two in connection with the inland fisheries of this country. Again, much that has been said regarding the potential value of our sea-fishing industry applies, of course, with equal force to the inland fisheries of Ireland. Apart from other matters they are an important source of wealth to the people connected with the tourist industry and to the country generally. That being so there is no necessity to expand that at all. That is a fact which is universally recognised. Realising that fact, I think anyone who regards the inland fisheries of this country to-day must have considerable misgivings about the care and attention which is being paid to them and about their future. Many people who have studied, even casually, our inland fisheries are of the opinion now that unless some immediate attention is given to their care and protection, in a very short space of years we will have no inland fisheries at all. Inland fisheries in this country ordinarily cover the important salmon fisheries of the country, but they also cover the more mundane trout fishing which used to represent a very important attraction in this country, not only to holiday-makers from other countries but also to Irishmen to spend their holidays in this country.
There are at present certain clearly distinguished deficiencies in the manner in which our brown trout and, indeed, the salmon in our fisheries are controlled. To my mind there are two causes of the present condition of our inland fisheries. These two causes could be grouped into (1) social or artificial causes and (2) natural causes. As far as social or artificial causes are concerned, there is the great problem of poaching. It is not necessary for any Deputy to discuss the harm which poaching does to fisheries generally. Suffice to say that poaching carried on as it is, pretty widespread in certain areas, destroys not merely the existing wealth of fish but also the potentiality for future increases in inland fisheries. I suggest to the Minister that some proper scheme of education should be carried out by his Department in relation to poaching. I know myself and I think many Deputies, particularly country Deputies, will recognise the truth of what I say. Most of us do not regard poaching as very serious. Most of us, indeed, find it hard in any way to regard the poacher as an offender or in any way as a person to be blamed, the reason being that up to 27 years ago fishing in the inland fisheries of this country was the strictly guarded preserve of the old ascendency class. The ordinary Irishman, the ordinary person in this country, when he heard of the poacher always said: "Good luck to him and may he get his catch."
When I discuss poaching I do not mean the fellow who goes into some strictly preserved fishery in the proper season by fair means and takes a catch of fish. If he gets away with it, good luck to him. But I do condemn the young fellow in the villages and towns who, in the spawning season, goes out to the little stream that flows under or near a road and nets the unfortunate trout or salmon when they are spawning. That man is doing considerable damage to an important national asset. I say to the Minister that poaching cannot be prevented by the Gardaí in the country or by water bailiffs where such exist. It can only be prevented by a proper public opinion which will condemn it. In each village and town, particularly in the tourist areas of the country, the local publican, the local hotelkeeper, the baker or butcher, a local person of some note in that particular village or town, should be entrusted by the Department, or whatever other authority may interest itself in this particular matter, with the duty of keeping an eye on poaching, particularly at times when damage can be done. That is one matter which I think is a cause of the present sadly depleted fish of our inland fisheries.
Another cause is the question of pollution. I only say that the provisions of the Fishery Act, 1939, in relation to causes of pollution in our rivers should be more strictly enforced by the Gardaí or by responsible authorities in each fishing area. Pollution will completely destroy a river, not merely temporarily but for many years. Pollution, particularly pollution from creameries, is even still doing considerable damage in the inland fisheries. One other matter which also causes considerable damage to fisheries —and I am glad to see the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance in the House—is arterial drainage. I do not want to discuss that in any detail. I know that the authorities responsible for arterial drainage are aware of the possible damage which arterial drainage does. However, it is a matter with which the Minister must concern himself. It stands to reason that if you deepen a river by means of arterial drainage the excessive flow of water at certain periods of the year and the reduced flow of water at other periods of the year bring about that unstable condition which frightens any existing stock away from the river. There is one thing that could be done in connection with arterial drainage, and that is that, instead of cutting the rivers in a straight course which appears to be the practice at present, as far as possible a certain amount of zigzagging should be done. That is one way in which the harm that arterial drainage does to fisheries could be reduced. Another thing is, of course, that weed cutting could be modified greatly.
Apart from these matters which I have mentioned, which continue to cause damage to fisheries, there are other causes which I may describe as natural causes which must get the attention of the Department and should have the attention of it from year to year. Some 18 months or two years ago in an inland fishery near this city a disease known as tapeworm broke out amongst a stock of trout. It spread throughout the entire stock of trout in an artificial lake not far from the city. It spread from fish to fish, and eventually destroyed the entire stock. That disease was caused by the presence of cormorants in the lake. Since the outbreak of that disease two years ago, the particular signs of it have been found in other places, particularly in the West. I should like to impress on the Minister that, if the inland fisheries are to be safeguarded, some section or officials in the Department should be very much on their toes to safeguard against a further outbreak of this disease. If through inattention or through complacency it is allowed to spread from lake to lake it will be found very quickly that there is no way of getting rid of it until the entire stock of fish in a particular lake or river is completely destroyed.
I want to impress on the House and on the Minister that the one matter which does require immediate attention is this question of disease in trout and salmon. I might mention in that connection that at present a number of our lakes in Connemara and the West are affected by a particular parasite known, I think, as carp louse or argulus to give it its technical name. This particular parasite is in some of the principal western lakes at present and is likely to spread to other lakes throughout the country. Its presence in a lake means that the entire stock of fish is being slowly destroyed and that once it gets into a lake the stock cannot be saved. The existence of such diseases, or their possibility, are matters which should have the immediate concern of the Minister and the Department. Might I also mention, that another cause of the present condition of the inland fisheries is the lack of attention to predatory birds. I mentioned cormorants. They are one of the most serious enemies to our inland fisheries. Not very long ago 72 of them were counted on the river Liffey. It is estimated that a cormorant eats from ten to 15 lbs. of fish in the day. It is not difficult to calculate that those 72 cormorants on the river Liffey ate some 5,000 or 6,000 lbs. of fish in a week. These figures enable one to appreciate the considerable damage and the depredations that are done by those birds to our inland fisheries. I suggest to the Minister that the rewards for the shooting of cormorants should be increased and that every effort should be made to destroy them.
I was interested to hear what the Minister said about coarse fish and the tests that the Department proposes to carry out on four experimental lakes. I sympathise with the Minister in the difficulty that he finds himself in between two sets of advisers, each suggesting quite contrary theories as facts to him. I do not know sufficient about the subject to say whether it is necessary that all coarse fish should be destroyed, but it is interesting to consider this, that one of the main predatory fish that we have—the pike—is an imported fish and has been quite a recent arrival in this country. I do not think there can be any doubt that pike do a considerable amount of harm. I commend the Minister for his foresight in carrying out these experiments and I trust that the results will enable him to arrive at a very clear protective policy.
Now, having said so much about our inland fisheries, may I say one other thing without in any way advocating legislation in this matter? I do suggest to the Minister that this whole question of the preservation of our inland fisheries, the proper policy to adopt and the proper steps to take, is a matter which has been argued about and talked about for a great number of years, and that we are still at the arguing stage and still at the urging stage. I suggest to the Minister that he should apply his mind to the desirability of establishing some central body, statutory or otherwise, which will be charged with the duty of safeguarding the country's inland fisheries. This is not a matter that often gets publicity, and it is not a matter that ordinarily arouses either interest or much discussion publicly. I do impress on the Minister that, unless immediate steps are taken for the preservation of our inland fisheries we shall have nothing to preserve in a short number of years. In saying that, I do not mean this year or next year, but I do say that the inland fisheries—quality and potential—are unfortunately on a very steep decline at present. Their condition is such that they require the immediate attention of the Department. I suggest that not only by the ways I have mentioned, but also by the establishment of some central body charged with the care and protection of inland fisheries, a beginning can be made.
I would also like to suggest to the Minister that some consideration should be given to the question of angling facilities for the ordinary people and for tourists who come here. Deputy Bartley, Deputy McQuillan or some other Deputy mentioned already that a considerable number of very attractive fisheries are at the moment strictly preserved. Of course, that is a fact. If you cross the Shannon there is scarcely a place where you can throw a line without having to pay a fee to the owner or to some person who claims to have a right to that particular fishery. Apart from that, there are lakes and rivers in respect of which the fishing rights are vested either in the Electricity Supply Board or the Land Commission, or other bodies of that type.
There are, on the other hand, rivers and lakes which are completely unrated. If it does occur to the Minister that such a body as I have suggested should be established to safeguard the inland fisheries, that body should, as a first step, be given the charge and care of waters in respect of which the Land Commission have the fishing rights or in respect of which the Electricity Supply Board have similar rights, and also all unrated waters. As regards these particular rights, a policy such as I have suggested, or some policy with a similar aim and purpose, should be carried out. In that way we will be making a good beginning towards preserving a very important national asset.
Comment on this
In the course of my remarks I shall deal almost entirely with the claims for fishing rights of a number of my constituents who live on the banks of the Blackwater. There is a peculiar situation prevailing there, in that you have a number of tenants on the right bank of the Blackwater who purchased under the Ashbourne Act and who enjoy the fishing and game rights, and then there are a number on the left bank who purchased under the Land Acts of 1923 and 1927 and who did not secure the fishing rights. In effect, the position is——
Comment on this
On a point of order. The matters now being raised relate more to the Department of Lands and the acquisition and disposition of fishing rights, and that is a matter for which I have no authority.
Comment on this
I do not intend to suggest legislation. I am merely dealing with the fishing rights of the people living on the banks of the Blackwater.
Comment on this
I do not want to put the Deputy off, but I assure him that the problem is really one which concerns the Minister for Lands and I have no function at all in that connection. It is a matter of reserving fishing rights or transferring them on the occasion of the acquisition of an estate.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would be kind enough to make a recommendation to the Minister for Lands?
Comment on this
The Minister has no authority in relation to the matters with which the Deputy is dealing.
Comment on this
I suggest that the vesting of fishing rights in the tenants on both banks of our rivers would afford the best possible protection for our inland fisheries, as the local interest in fishing would be developed and, further, there would be a desire on the part of the tenant owners to protect their rights and in that way we would succeed in reducing poaching to a minimum. For that reason the Minister might recommend to the Minister for Lands the securing of these rights and the vesting of them in the tenants. I believe the tenants would be quite prepared to pay the fishing rent and compensate the owners, if it is necessary to do so. I feel sure they would be quite agreeable even to devote some portion of their annuities to that purpose.
Comment on this
There is another matter which I would like to mention. It is the question of the operation of the weir on the River Blackwater at Lismore. I believe the operation of that weir is so conducted as seriously to affect the run of salmon to the upper reaches, thereby affording very poor fishing for the ordinary fisherman above the weir, while the Lismore estate—in other words, the Duke of Devonshire—reaps the benefit in securing tons of fish below the weir year after year. This weir is a barrier across the river. There is a narrow gap through which the water rushes and the fish have no way of going upstream except through this narrow gap. There is a period of 24 hours in every week when the gates in the weir are opened to permit the passage of fish upstream. In the interest of the anglers above the weir who pay thousands every year, I suggest that the Minister should have this matter investigated so as to ensure that the weir will not be operated in a way that will seriously impede the passage of the fish upstream.
I understand that the Minister received a deputation from the Waterford County Council some time ago. They made representations for the provision of a 100 per cent. State grant to improve the landing facilities for the fishermen at Ballymacaw. I understand that the cost would be about £1,100. The lack of proper landing facilities for the fishermen has definitely prevented the development of the fishing industry in that area. There could be considerable development of that industry if they were provided with proper facilities and amenities. The granting of the council's request would be a great benefit to the fishermen and would definitely help to encourage and develop the fishing industry there. If the Minister has not already arrived at a decision in that regard, I would appeal to him now to give the matter his very favourable consideration. The fishermen there have suffered great hardships in the past. Their difficulties are very considerable, because the landing facilities at the moment are such that they cannot bring their boats up on the shore. Their boats are very small indeed. They suffer as a result of these boats being broken up because they are unable to take them on the shore through lack of landing facilities. If the Minister has not already come to a decision in this regard perhaps he would give the matter favourable consideration.
Comment on this
Deputy Burke earlier this evening made reference to his multifarious activities on behalf of the County Dublin inshore fishermen. With all due modesty he claimed that his representations to the Minister had resulted in the improvement of Loughshinny harbour. It surprised me to hear Deputy Burke, who last week described the Minister as a hypocrite, compliment him this evening upon his attitude and his policy towards the inshore fishermen. I suppose one must get used to changes of face in this House and surprises of one kind or another.
I find myself in agreement with the Minister in his attitude to the inshore-fishing industry as opposed to the proposal that we should have a deep-sea trawling industry. To me it is beyond question that there has to be a choice for one kind or the other. We have no choice. We must protect the industry which is in existence and which has been in existence for a long number of years. While much lip service has been paid to the fishermen and much has been said in their praise, so far I do not think it can be said that any Government has taken all the steps necessary to put this industry into its proper relationship to our national economy. The Minister indicated his view that the fishermen as such were not alone fishermen but were something in the nature of farmers as well. He said that most of them, as well as fishing, derived their livelihood mainly from the cultivation of the soil. That may be true along the western seaboard. I doubt if it is true on the east coast. So far as my experience goes, I would say that on the east coast the reverse is the case. From Dunmore East to Clogherhead the men who engage in fishing have no other means of livelihood. They are fishermen pure and simple. They have been fishermen for very many years.
Inshore fishing, circumscribed as it may be, is a very hazardous occupation and one which has never yet received its proper due from any Government. The basic problem in regard to this particular industry is the fact that we shall never in my view make it a really prosperous, thriving industry unless it is fully financed. Some Deputy indicated this evening that when we are thinking of bringing prosperity to our fishermen we should not think in terms of thousands or hundreds of thousands but in terms of millions. Deputies who represent constituencies that do not touch upon the sea may think that that is too large a demand to make upon the Exchequer. Those of us who have intimate knowledge and experience feel that the whole approach so far as finance is concerned has been niggardly. That is a bad thing. It has been said that there are only roughly 2,000 fishermen engaged in the industry. While the number actually engaged in fishing may be only 2,000, nevertheless that figure can be multiplied by at least five to discover all those who make their living from it. The potential number of people who could get a living from sea fishing is very great.
Prior to the time when this country secured a measure of independence every leader of this nation maintained that when we finally achieved independence our fishing industry would receive the beneficent attention of an Irish Government. I think that was one of the prominent points of policy in the programme of Sinn Féin. Despite the advent of three native Governments we have not yet reached the stage when the importance of this industry is fully realised. I think there is hope, however, that the present Minister realises that concrete steps must be taken to put this industry in a prosperous state. The first essential step is the allocation of sufficient money from the Exchequer in order to do that.
When one considers the need of the inshore fishing industry the first thing that springs to mind is the lack of proper harbour facilities. In Fingal we have four harbours well known to fishermen around our coast. They are Howth, Rush, Loughshinny and Skerries. Farther back than my experience goes there have been continual complaints from the fishermen using these harbours because of their inaccessibility and their utter inadequacy. In Howth and Loughshinny there has been a great deal of silting up with the result that on numerous occasions fishermen returning with their catch have been unable to make port. There have been considerable delays in securing the services of a dredger from the Board of Works. This problem of silting is one that affects every maritime county and we need far more dredger equipment than is available at the present time. I think that at the moment we have only two or three. These harbours silt up with fair regularity and I believe that we shall have to have much more than two or three dredgers in order to keep them clear. Last year we had a dredger in Balbriggan. For some reason—possibly one of urgency—it was taken away.
Comment on this
I do not see any provision in the Estimate for it. I do not think the Minister has any responsibility for the provision of dredgers.
Comment on this
Howth Harbour is a State harbour for which the Board of Works is responsible. The Department of Fisheries has no function in regard to Howth Harbour. We have responsibility in regard to harbours which are primarily the responsibility of the local authority, but not in regard to State harbours.
Comment on this
I may be in error in raising the matter on this particular Estimate but it is relevant to the discussion of the inshore fishing industry and it is something about which the fishermen continually complain. I think I may be forgiven for mentioning it. However, I shall pass from it now.
One of the great disabilities of fishermen is the fact that the type of boat at present supplied to them is not a fit boat for heavy weather, which means that when the weather is bad the fishermen must remain in harbour. Added to that, the harbours, in my constituency at any rate, are so constructed as to make shelter for any large type of boat a difficult proposition so that in order to secure improvement it is necessary that such harbours as come under the purview of the Minister should receive attention and should be improved. I refer to the fact that Deputy Burke in his extreme modesty claimed credit for securing improvement in Loughshinny. I do not wish to detract at all from the Herculean efforts of the Deputy in relation to his constituents but I think it is not unfair to say that he was not alone in his representations.
Comment on this
In any event, I do not wish to labour this question but briefly the criticisms which have to be made as to the present state of the industry come under three heads. First of all, there are the harbours which I have mentioned. Secondly, there is the question of the catching capacity of the type of boats at present supplied. I had the pleasure and the honour to be present at the last meeting of the Sea Fisheries Association in Westport when fishermen from all over the country were discussing their needs and their grievances. The keynote of that particular discussion, as far as the fishermen were concerned, seemed to be their entire dissatisfaction with the present size of the sea fishery boats. It is felt that the larger boat, the 50-foot boat, would be of much greater service and value to them. That, of course, presupposes, as I have indicated earlier, that the harbours must be of such size and in such condition as will afford adequate protection for the larger type of boat.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be glad to hear that that is the type of boat on which we are concentrating now.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear that. We welcome also the intimation of the Minister that an effort is now being made to remedy the extreme shortage of boats which has been prevalent for the past few years. The Minister stated that he may be optimistic in anticipating that the greater part of the waiting list will be eliminated by the end of the financial year. If that can be done, it will certainly be a great achievement. There are many hundreds of fishermen who have been waiting patiently for some years for new boats and additional boats and if in the coming year the Minister succeeds in having their needs satisfied, he will be deserving of every compliment that can be paid him.
I think I referred last year to the question of fish distribution and it has been discussed at considerable length again this evening. It is an ironic commentary on this particular matter to find that when the Sea Fisheries Association met a couple of months ago in Westport, the fishermen assembled there on Friday could not get a bit of fish in that seaport town. That indicates the absolutely chaotic condition which exists so far as distribution is concerned. There does not seem to be any attempt made to cater for the adequate distribution of fish throughout the country. We have even cases, such as were indicated at Westport, where fish are landed in a seaport town, conveyed to Dublin and in some cases returned from Dublin to that town for sale. I have had the belief, strengthened by my conversations and discussions with fishermen for a long time, that, so far as distribution is concerned, there would appear very definitely to be a group of commercial gentlemen in this city who have a stranglehold on the distribution of fish. The return which the fisherman gets for the fish and the price the consumer has to pay in the shop are so vastly different as to be a matter of complete mystification to the ordinary layman. There does not seem to be any adequate explanation of it other than the fact that the distribution is controlled, as I have said, for purely commercial reasons and the public is at times held up to ransom for fish when it is in somewhat short supply and even at times when it is in large supply, by the distributors while at the same time we have the injustice perpetrated on the fisherman of the low inadequate return paid to him.
If there is one section of the community that deserve to get the consideration of the Minister in so far as he can give it to them, if there is one section that deserve to have every possible step taken by the State to help them, that section is the inshore fishermen. As I have said, the way in which they get their livelihood is the most hazardous in the State. I would ask the Minister to investigate thoroughly, if he has not already done so—it may well be that he has—all the circumstances surrounding the price which is paid to the fisherman for his fish and the price which is paid by the consumer in the City of Dublin and other cities and large towns in the country. This has been a matter of very much contention and complaint by fishermen for many years and it is high time something was done about it. It is beyond doubt that there is some degree of a racket in the sale of fish and that is something which we should not tolerate for one moment.
The three-mile limit has been mentioned. East coast fishermen and men from the harbours I have mentioned in my constituency—Howth, Rush, Lough-shinny, Skerries and Balbriggan—are suffering as the result of the Scottish ring-boats, which are well-equipped, large boats, coming inside the three-mile limit and in very many cases robbing the fishing grounds. These boats are vastly superior to anything which we have. Their condition is due, it can be said, to the fact that they were part and parcel of the British war effort. They are equipped with all sorts of fish-finding apparatus, radio-telephonic communication, and our fishermen have no chance whatever of competing with them. There are undoubted difficulties in so far as trawlers are concerned but these difficulties would be lessened if the three-mile limit were extended to something in the region of six to ten miles. I do not suggest that that is a matter than can be easily accomplished but an important consideration is that the three-mile limit was the result of an international convention which took place about 45 years ago. When that is borne in mind I think it will be recognised that it is high time a change was made.
Comment on this
I imagine, in fact I am sure, that we will get more fish, and I am certain also that the livelihood of our own native fishermen will be protected. It would be far better to have that protection than to have the Scottish boats, the Grimsby boats, coming to our shores and taking what fish there is while our men come back with their boats empty. I think that is something to which the Minister should bend his mind and energies. Deputy Lemass indicated, by way of interruption, that the previous Government had set in train some steps in that direction and I would like to hear, if the Minister has any information on that particular matter, if any steps have ever been taken to remedy the question of the three-mile limit and, if so, how far this project can be furthered. I am convinced, and the fishermen are definitely of the opinion, that before they can have a fair and reasonable chance of winning a livelihood from the sea they should at least get the protection of an extension of the three-mile limit so as to make it more difficult for foreign trawlers to come in and rob them of what is rightfully the property of this nation, the fish around our shores.
While the Minister is replying I would be glad if he would indicate if he has given consideration to the possibility of the development of our ports by means of the use of some Marshall Aid. Any moneys we garner under that scheme would be very well applied if they were applied to the improvement and enlargement of our fishing ports. I ask the Minister finally to approach this whole problem of fishing with a determination to make it what many people state and claim it is and what, in fact, it is not yet, a major industry. It cannot be said to be a major industry at the present moment as it is a very much neglected industry. I compliment the Minister upon his determination that we shall not have a deep-sea trawling industry because of the possible danger that would ensue for the inshore men, but I would ask him to bring a new attitude to it and to try to get his Department to take an entirely new view of this industry with a view to making it something it should be—the most important industry in this country after agriculture.
Comment on this
I speak as one who has looked for a great many years on the fishing industry as being basically second only to our main industry, agriculture. I always took a certain amount of interest in that industry and while I cannot claim to speak as thoroughly in connection with that all important industry as those who reside on the coast itself, as representing a constituency in which there is a fishing port, probably as large a fishing port as there is on any part of the coast of Ireland, I should like to draw the Minister's attention to the number of difficulties with which the fishermen of that port of Arklow have to contend from time to time while they are engaged in what I might call that hazardous trade of fishing. Their work is hazardous and having carried out that work inasmuch as they have gone to sea, sometimes in very bad weather, they find that due to the fact that the bar of the port of Arklow, which becomes silted with sands periodically, is in such a state that they are unable to bring their fish into port, they have to run into some other port in order to dispose of the fish they have caught practically in their own waters. Some Deputies this evening have supported the idea not alone of helping the inshore fishing industry but also of developing the deep-sea fishing industry. That may be all right but I would suggest—and I should like to see it carried out—that every effort on the part of the Minister and the Department responsible be put into effect to ensure that the difficulties with which those inshore fishermen have to contend will be wiped out and, having been wiped out, that their catch can be disposed of when it is brought into port. If that is done, when fish is available they can go out every night and bring in the fish, sure of the fact that they can dispose of it. I have known occasions in Arklow when there was, if you like, a glut of fish and the fishermen were informed, after two or three nights fishing the result of which was a great catch, by those who were responsible for disposing of their fish not to go out that night, that there was no use in going out because there was no market for fish.
Comment on this
Herrings, in particular. I am glad to see that the Minister has provided a large amount of money this year for boats and gear. Now that the emergency is over and engines and timber are available, I hope the full amount will be expended during the year. I hope that, when allocating the boats, the Minister will keep Arklow in mind, where quite a number of people are anxious to secure boats.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy would approve of the Minister keeping a million miles away from the allocation. I certainly ought to. It is a matter for the board, not for me.
Comment on this
The Minister is responsible, is he not? If I refer to the board, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle might say I should refer to the Minister. I hope the board or the Minister, or whoever is responsible for allocating the boats, will keep in mind the town of Arklow and give fair and due consideration to any applications received from the people there.
On the question of silting, I hope it is not irrelevant to mention that those responsible for Arklow Harbour naturally take a great interest in the sea fishing industry. They have been very worried over the silting up of the bar, because of its effect on the fishing. I think the Department of Fisheries have been worried over it also, as when approached they took steps to ensure that the wherewithal would be provided to relieve the position that arises there. The real point is that the sum of money involved annually, in order to keep the bar clear for the fishermen and other boats coming in, is becoming such a strain on the harbour commissioners that they are suggesting, or have suggested, that certain steps be taken to avoid that annual outlay. They asked for expert opinion to find other ways and means to prevent the silting. I would ask the Minister and the Department to give due consideration to any application in connection with this matter, so that the Arklow Harbour Board may be relieved once and for all of the financial strain which comes, not only annually but at different periods of the year.
Regarding inland fisheries, I understood the Minister to express himself last year regarding fishing rights on rivers by stating to the House that he hoped to see the day when every man could walk in on a river bank and have his bit of sport by fishing as he wished.
Comment on this
I would be glad to see that day also. I remember the time when that position practically did obtain on the rivers. It was only when the different Land Acts became operative that this monopoly of the fishing rights on different rivers developed. If the Minister, through nationalisation or otherwise, can do anything to make the rivers of the country available to every individual who is prepared to bind himself to whatever regulations are laid down, so that he would have the right to go in on any river and fish there, everyone will be pleased throughout the country.
Deputy O'Higgins referred to poaching on inland rivers. I have a fair idea of some of those rivers and, although I read reports of the different conservators at their meetings, I believe that poaching is a dying-out practice, though I am sure a certain amount of it still goes on. In order to ensure that the proper civic spirit will be created, as suggested by Deputy O'Higgins, the sooner the Minister or the Department responsible leaves the rivers in that position whereby the man who is fond of sport can go in on any bank and fish to his heart's content, the better it will be. On the day that happens, poaching as an illegal action will cease to be of any great importance.
Comment on this
I do not subscribe to the view that there is of necessity any essential conflict between the interests of the inshore fishermen and the development of a deep-sea fishing industry. In my view, if a fishing industry is to be developed here—and apparently that is the view accepted on all sides of the House—it is essential that we should attempt the creation of a deep-sea fishing fleet. I would view with considerable apprehension allowing that development into the hands of private enterprise. It is something which should be undertaken by the community in the interests of the community. Many continental countries have successfully developed deep-sea fishing industries, working on the principle of the factory or master ship with its attendant trawlers. I gather from what the Minister said in opening the debate that that was a view he could not accept. May I say that the Minister is an eminently reasonable man in many respects and there are many views the Minister did not hold which he now regards with considerable favour? I am not hopeless of the Minister's conversion to my point of view in this respect.
The greater portion of the debate was devoted to our inshore fishing industry. The references made by Deputy Brennan to our inland fisheries and to what the Minister described as the beau ideal are references which would commend themselves to me. I should like to see the day when all our inland fisheries were the property of the people of this nation, and, though the Minister may describe it as a beau ideal and one which I gathered from the tone of his interjection he imagines is not possible of any immediate fulfilment, let me at least express this hope, that we will not, for very much longer, have to put up with the spectacle of some of our richest rivers, rivers teeming with fish, the private preserve of aliens and foreigners, as is the case to-day.
In so far as our inshore fishing industry is concerned, discussion of it must fall under four main heads: gear, in which I include boats, harbours, marketing and protection. In the remarks which Deputy Dunne addressed to the House, and I think that many other speakers supported him, I would concur. I think the Minister should decide that, if we are to develop our inshore fishing industry, we will have to spend much more money on it than we are spending at present. We will have to see that those who put out in boats to win fish will put out in good boats equipped with the best possible gear available and with all necessary devices, such as wireless and any other protective apparatus necessary.
Anybody who knows our western coastline, and even the Leinster coastline, knows the extent to which the activities of our fishermen are circumscribed, due to lack of proper harbour facilities. Some of these harbours are not the responsibility of the Minister, but others of them are, and, in respect of those which are, let the Minister show a lead to his colleague, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance.
One of the difficulties facing the Minister, and anybody interested in the development of our fishing industry, is the mental attitude of many people towards fish as a food. I think it was during the period of office of the previous Administration that an attempt was made for a while to educate the public taste in that matter. That was a creditable attempt and I commend it to the Minister for emulation by him and his Department.
The fourth aspect of this problem which I suggest to the Minister for his consideration is that which I have listed under protection. I await with interest a statement from the Minister on the position with regard to the extension of the three-mile limit. To my mind, that extension is overdue, but whether the limit is extended or not, I am appalled—unless I misinterpret the Minister—to gather from him that he feels that more protection cannot be given, even within the three-mile limit, to those fishing from our shores. Two years ago, in the course of about an hour and a half, I saw in the harbour of Bantry 24 Spanish trawlers. An hour and a half later, in the harbour of Castletownberehaven, I saw 18 Spanish trawlers—these boats coming to our shores and taking from under the very noses of the fishermen fishing along our coast the means of making a proper livelihood.
I do not think that is an insoluble problem and I do not think it is a difficult problem. It is one which could be solved by the Minister, in collaboration with the Minister for Defence. I do not know whether corvettes are the answer to poaching within the three-mile limit. Some few years ago it was suggested here that the proper answer was an organised aerial patrol, and, if I am right in interpreting the Minister's attitude, I am appalled that he should think this a matter in which he can do nothing.
Comment on this
I may have misunderstood the Minister and I should be very glad to hear that I have. I did interpret the Minister as saying— I am attempting to paraphrase the Minister—that the present poaching within the three-mile limit was something for which he had no immediate remedy. I would suggest that the development of an aerial patrol for the proper protection of boats fishing from our shores is something which should engage his immediate attention.
Comment on this
So far as I am concerned, I am perfectly satisfied with everything that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries has done since he came into office. Previously, fishermen had to deposit 50 per cent. of the purchase price of boats and gear. The Minister has reduced that to 20 per cent. and he has stated that where a fisherman can show that he has fulfilled all his previous commitments, he will not be left without gear. The Minister is going to expend £40,000,000 on drainage, reclamation and rehabilitation of land. May I suggest that he should spend £1,000,000, £500,000 or £250,000 on putting the fishing industry on a proper basis? In this country, agriculture comes first and I maintain that the fishing industry comes next. If that were done, fishermen would be enabled to get boats and gear and would then be in a position to do their work properly. I am sure that efforts have been made to procure boats from various countries and there is still a hope that they can be obtained. I would ask the Minister to purchase boats from France, Spain, Denmark, even England, or boats that would be built in Belfast. It might be a nice gesture to give them an opportunity of helping our industry here. Although the facilities in Killybegs, County Donegal, are as good as the facilities afforded in any country in Europe, perhaps something could be done to enlarge the space for boat building.
As a safety measure, there should be look-out posts along the coast. The posts are already in existence and only need to be equipped with suitable apparatus. That would be a safety measure for fishermen when fishing within a certain distance of the land. I would also suggest that, in certain areas, there should be a mechanic to look after the engines of the boats. For instance, in South Kerry—in fact, in the whole of Kerry—there should be a special man to look after the engines and carry out repairs. There is great difficulty when there is a break-down and the fishermen have to wait a long time before help comes from Cork or Baltimore.
I want to say a special word about Kenmare Bay. In former years, there were oyster beds in the bay. They have been destroyed. Recently, an attempt was made to plant the seed of oysters but in a different place from where the oyster beds were previously. There is one particular place, Garnish Island, in Kenmare Bay, which is really a Riviera. Tropical plants grow there and I believe that would be a very suitable place for the planting of oyster seed. During the war people were so anxious to make all the money they could out of lobster fishing in Kenmare Bay that they actually fished the hen lobster and at present there is no lobster fishing there. I would ask the Minister to look into the matter of the oyster beds and lobster beds, which is so very important in that particular area.
Perhaps the Minister could use his influence to improve the piers in Reenard, Ballinskelligs and Valentia. It is not in any criticism of the Minister that I have spoken, because I know he has done his best. When he came into office, he found an industry for which there was no gear or protection. During the past 15 or 16 years, nothing at all had been done. It was absolutely destroyed. The fishermen are hopeful, now that we have this Minister, that, just as he has improved agriculture, in the very near future he will place the fishing industry on a proper basis and that our fishermen around the coast and the inshore fishermen will be afforded every facility to enable them to make a good living from the industry in which they are engaged.
Comment on this
There are a few matters on which I want to get some information from the Minister. One of them is the improvement of harbours. The Minister has some responsibility, I take it, for improving small fishing harbours. There are such harbours in Wexford in connection with which there are applications before the Minister at present for improvement grants. The fishermen in the Cahore area are very disappointed that nothing has been done about it. The Wexford County Council, who have no responsibility for providing capital for the improvement of harbours, have offered to put up 40 per cent. of the cost and the Department or the Minister, so far, has not given any decision as to providing the balance. A good number of fishermen in that area are anxiously awaiting the Minister's decision. It would be a small grant, of £2,000 or £3,000. I do not know exactly what it would be. They ask to have a boat safe erected in the village of Cahore.
Comment on this
The local authority, who have no responsibility for providing capital for that, offered to put up a grant of 40 per cent. of the cost almost 12 months ago, and the Minister has not given any decision as to whether he is going to provide a grant or not.
Comment on this
If your Department and yourself were interested and pressed the Board of Works to provide a grant it would have been done. The good weather for doing that type of work is going by very fast. If the work is not undertaken inside the next couple of months it will not be possible to do anything before the herring fishing season opens in October or November of the present year and the people in question are mainly interested in that. I want to press the Minister to have a decision reached immediately in that connection.
Comment on this
The Deputy wants me to do in two or three months what his Party did not do in 14 years.
Comment on this
It is only within the last year that this thing has become a matter of urgency. Whatever works were there, there was sea erosion. The men have to haul the boats through the surf to the sand. They have lost something like four or five motor boats in a number of years. There was no protection for boats there. The little harbour was never fit to moor boats in stormy weather and the fishermen had to haul them on to the strand. These people are expecting and anxiously awaiting some information as to whether they will be allowed to proceed with the proposal to erect a boat safe there. The cost would not be very much. Over a great number of years it has been found very difficult to get any grant towards the improvement of harbours from the Minister or the Department of Fisheries. The local authority have responsibility for the maintenance of a number of small fishing harbours—let us say the county council. These harbours need capital improvement works but the Department of Fisheries have not been a bit helpful. It is not only this year or last year or five years ago that that has been so. I have never found them a bit co-operative in providing help to local authorities to improve those harbours. We would ask the Minister to try and have the policy altered in that respect and to encourage the local authorities who are anxious to improve those small harbours by giving them portion of the capital cost. That should be done. Whether there is anything in this Vote or not, I am sure that if the Minister is inclined to do that he will find some means of getting the money.
I am glad to see that there is a larger allocation in the Estimate for the present year for the provision of boats and gear. We hope that those engines will become available in the boats and that it will be possible for all this money, and somewhat more, to be spent. During all the war years, when it was not possible to have the engines will become available for the in the old boats replaced, the inshore fishermen had great difficulty in carrying on at all. Much can be done in that direction. The general complaint I hear from fishermen, from old salts who have spent their lives at the sea, is that the boats provided by the Sea Fisheries Association are too small.
Comment on this
A larger and heavier type of boat is required because of the difficulties in stormy weather. I think I am correct in saying that the largest proportion of the fish is brought to shore during the winter months. It is absolutely necessary to have a larger and heavier boat than the type formerly provided by the Sea Fisheries Association. All inshore fishermen will tell you that.
There seems to be a difference of opinion on the question of whether all fish should be landed by the inshore fishermen or whether there should be a deep-sea fishing fleet. To come to any decision in that regard would, I think, be a matter of great difficulty. There will always be room for conflicting points of view on that question. From anything I ever heard about it, if we have an exportable surplus of fish the question arises whether our fishermen would be prepared to sell at the price it would fetch in some of the export markets. I understand that our men would not be prepared to do so. I understand that it would not be economic from their point of view to export it at the price Norwegians, Danes and others would be prepared to accept for it. I do not know whether that is true but I believe it is substantially true. Norwegians, Danes and others are prepared to work for a much lower return to themselves than our fishermen might be. I am told that there is a lot in that.
Comment on this
If the Minister has an exportable surplus of fish and tries to sell it across the water he will find that his return will be much less than that for fish sold in this country.
Comment on this
The Minister and I might cross swords. If he gave short answers I could give other short answers.
Comment on this
Inshore fishing is partly dying out—for what reason I do not know. Inshore fishermen are becoming more and more scarce in the little fishing villages all over the country. The men are getting old and they are retiring from fishing. Their sons are not replacing them except in a few instances. That is the truth. The conditions of livelihood these people were prepared to accept 20, 30 or 50 years ago are not acceptable to the young men of to-day. They must have fulltime employment. The young men will leave the fishing villages sooner than accept the part-time livelihood inshore fishing gives them. It is an uncertain life. I am sure the Minister is aware, and his Department can advise him on it, that the number of young men engaging in fishing, and likely to continue at it, is very small at the present time. He may have people who have some other means of livelihood——
Comment on this
If they have some other means of livelihood in the district they will continue to fish but if they have no means of livelihood other than the uncertainty of inshore fishing you cannot be very sure you will get the full supply of fish needed in this country from the inshore fishermen. Many Deputies seem to think there are great possibilities for selling fish in this country in the future. Personally I believe there are not. We will never become a fish-eating people.