We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 55—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).

Contributions 1–162 of 337. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Major de Valera

I indicated last week that I should like to discuss with the Minister two problems specifically related to his Department and I think I was at some pains to point out that I should like to approach these matters objectively, realising that problems exist, and I hope that my remarks will be taken in that spirit. The first matter is the vexed matter of the cost of living. As a Deputy representing a city constituency, I am naturally interested in that problem, and in the particular aspect of it from the point of view of the city dweller. It is a problem which is felt acutely by the city dweller because we have always to remember that the average inhabitant of the city is forced strictly to live on the money available to him at any particular time. If he cannot meet his living costs out of that money, he must go without essentials.

It is, I think, slightly different in the rural areas where there is rather more elasticity. The fact that food is produced in rural areas means that no matter how hard pressed the rural dweller is, he will manage to find food, but, in many strata of the city population, if they have not got the money there and then when required to buy the food, they must go without it. The only way in which they can get essentials is by paying money for them, and if the money they have at any particular time is inadequate for their needs, they must, as I say, go without essentials.

It is from that point of view that one sees how severly a rising cost of living strikes the city dweller, and particularly if the cost of such essentials as clothing, food, accommodation and transport rises, so that the total amount of money to be found for these necessaries exceeds the amount available through wages or other remuneration, then the city dweller must go without some of these essentials. Unfortunately, from the point of view of a unified debate on this matter, some of these matters do not directly concern the Minister who is in charge of this Vote—notably the question of accommodation, but I am afraid that we cannot completely divorce that aspect from any other aspect, and I must refer to it in passing, at any rate, in order to give a balanced picture.

What is the actual situation? The actual situation is that, after the rapid rises of 1947, the rises which mainly affected the city dweller in the increase in the cost of living and notably in the cost of foodstuffs, the wages and remuneration of the city dweller did not go up in proportion. Two Governments have been successful in holding the total cost of living round about the figure it reached in August, 1947, but they have been unable to do better. The cost of accommodation has gone up, and has gone up in an oblique kind of way. It has gone up largely owing to the fact that rates have gone up, apart from certain increases in rents, which have been unavoidable. The real addition to the cost of accommodation has been the rise in rates, which affects everybody in the city, practically without exception, as I have mentioned on previous occasions. It is a matter which does not concern the Minister, but I must bring it in here because the cost of accommodation having risen, it means that there is less money left, after accommodation has been paid for, to meet the cost of essentials in other regards, so that we must take it into account.

Therefore, when the cost of living is represented by the index for all items —about the only consistent set of figures I can find or on which we can argue on common ground—the first fact that strikes me in regard to the city dweller is that the cost of living, all items, stands still, but he has actually less money to meet it in so far as the increased cost of accommodation is taking out of his resources a greater amount than was taken at that date. On the other hand, in many cases there will be wage increases to offset that. It is a matter of calculation in individual classes, may be in individual cases, to see what the relative position is.

A similar case holds in regard to transport. The cost of transport has now risen in Dublin and that is a serious matter, particularly for dwellers on the outskirts. In Crumlin, and in fact all the suburban areas, the cost of transport has gone up and, therefore, again there is something more coming out of the available resources to meet the cost of living as represented by the general index. I am precluded generally from drawing a definite conclusion in the matter by virtue of the fact that, as against that adverse situation from the citizen's point of view, we must in fairness equate increases in wages which have undoubtedly taken place in the same period. Probably what one will find is that, on that approach, some people will be worse off and some, perhaps, a little better off but very few very much better off.

I could develop that line, but the net lesson to be learned or the net problem arising out of it is that the cost of living in this city is still at an emergency value, so to speak. It is at a value which it attained in the post-war inflationary phase and is to that extent abnormal. As against that, there is no great, if any, increase in the resources of the citizen to meet that cost. Such increases as they have received in actual wages and remuneration have been largely offset by increases in the cost of accommodation, transport and similar things. Therefore, logically, we are led to the conclusion that the cost of living in this city is still at an emergency level and that, in spite of favourable trends representing a return to more peaceful economic conditions, the cost of living has remained obstinately at this high level. I think I have stated the matter as fairly and as objectively as I can, and that the Minister must agree with me that that is the position.

If we are agreed on that, the next thing is, how can the problem be tackled? In some regards we know that certain remedies are available. One of these, in the short term view at any rate, is the remedy of subsidy. That remedy was eminently successful in 1947. It held the inflationary rise in prices and, in fact, stabilised the cost of living at a value under very adverse conditions indeed. Now that we are facing conditions that are easier in other regards and that the State is relieved of the necessity for finding excess subsidies in the matter of flour and fuel, it seems to me that the moneys which automatically become available because of those favourable factors could be diverted to control some other costs.

Another remedy is, of course, increased production, but before I deal with that I should like to deal with the question of these costs. Let us take food alone. With regard to the essential staple food, bread and flour, our position is that the price of the ordinary bread, not the white flour, remains the same to the consumer, that is, to the bulk of the population. As far as the consumer is concerned, I understand there is no change. On the other hand. On the Exchequer side, because of a favourable change in the purchasing position, the State is able to save something over, I think, £3,500,000 in regard to food subsidies as a whole and a substantial amount in regard to flour. But, the point is that the citizen is getting no benefit. In fact, it works out the other way. The Government has resorted to a device whereby flour of a certain extraction can be sold unsubsidised and, of course, at a higher price. As pointed out previously, there are certain objections to that course. There are objections about which I think the Labour Party, if it were not tied to the Coalition, would be very vocal indeed. But, quite apart from that, this must represent an increase in the cost of living to the average citizen, in some small degree at any rate.

Take the case of confectionery. Many a poor person, many a person who would not be considered poor, but who, in fact, is taking the brunt of the present economic situation, namely, the so-called black-coated, white-collar worker, needs some confectionery and is entitled to a certain amount of it and, in fact, purchases a certain amount. If the provision necessitating the use of white unsubsidised flour in confectionery is going to have the effect of putting up the price of that commodity, then there is a further increase in his actual living costs, a further real increase, notwithstanding the fact that, apparently, it will not show in these index figures. I mentioned in a previous debate that on one occasion I asked for some buns in a restaurant. I broke them and found they were white. I asked the price and found they were ½d. dearer than I was accustomed to pay for the same article up to the time the white flour was introduced. Just to test things, I asked the waitress to bring me some buns made with the standard flour which is subsidised. The waitress told me that they had not got them. In other words, I was forced either to take that bun and pay the higher price or go without. In other words, it was perfectly obvious that even at that stage the whole theory of the unsubsidised white flour scheme was falling to the ground; that, in fact, it was being forced to some extent on certain citizens who were not in what one might call the luxury class and that— notwithstanding what one might argue the legal position to be—the factual position was that they were forced to take it at somewhat increased prices. Now, it appears to me that a provision making it mandatory to use subsidised flour and confectionery is going to bring the legal position, so to speak, into line with the factual one. The net result is that, even though in a small degree, it must represent a rise in the cost of living. What can the Minister do about it? For my part, I should like to ask him why it is necessary, at this stage, when the market from which we are buying the flour is becoming more favourable to us— when, apparently, through a favourable trend in the price at which wheat can be bought which enables us to make a saving and to have money available in other directions, money which otherwise would, of necessity, go on the subsidy as heretofore—to aggravate the existing position by such a device which, apparently so far, is not being of very great benefit to the Exchequer, and which, in fact, as I have indicated, represents an increase actually in the cost of wheaten products to the consumer by and large?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy, I suppose, is aware that flour and wheaten meal subsidies have been transferred to the Department of Agriculture?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Yes, but the point is that the cost of living is here and I want to move on, if the Chair will permit me, to deal with another matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair will certainly permit the Deputy to move on.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

My only reason for labouring the point is so that we might have the whole picture.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not mind the Deputy introducing the point, but he seems to be going into it deeply.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is a question that I should like to have answered from the general point of view, not merely from the local Ministerial point of view. On moving on from that, it is obvious that, combining the two things, there is a considerable sum of money available to the Exchequer on the saving on these food and fuel subsidies. Can we find any indication that it has been turned to account in reducing the cost of living in other regards?

Moving from those which are essential in considering the city dweller's problem, we come to what is perhaps the most aggravated question of all— meat. I have dealt with the preliminaries in some detail in order to show that the savings on these fuel and food subsidies have apparently not been transferred or absorbed by any provision going to reduce the cost of living either in regard to accommodation, wheaten foodstuffs—which, I suppose, would be our main staple foodstuffs— transport or anything like that. Where are we in connection with the meat situation? I think the Minister practically challenged some of us to raise that matter again and, in the conventional phrase of public speakers, I have pleasure in accepting the challenge. What was the position and what is the position? Again, before discussing this problem let us get our facts right. Coming back to the official figures I find that, on the whole, taking the prices published in the Trade Journal for December, 1947, the percentage decreases at mid-November, 1947, with mid-August, 1947, in regard to beef and mutton generally were substantial. In other words, at the time when the Fianna Fáil Government introduced its unpopular Budget and made an attack on this cost-of-living index with a view to holding it at any rate, they were not only successful in holding it in matters which they directly subsidised but, apparently, from whatever the cause, there is at that same period a very substantial reduction in the price of meat shown in November of 1947 as compared with August, 1947. The reference is page 147 of the Trade Journal. It is hardly necessary to read it.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Morrissey) Fine Gael

The Deputy, I take it, is referring to fresh meat?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Beef and mutton. There is a big decrease there.

Comment on this

That is because the prices of fresh meat were brought under control in November, 1947.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I accept that, but it is more favourable to my argument——

Comment on this

That is the explanation.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Yes, and it is more favourable to my argument if I were arguing from the point of view that we were better than you.

Comment on this

I might argue that it was a pity it was not done a few years earlier.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister might, but the fact is that it was done. However, I have been trying to look at the Minister's problem as fairly as I can—so I do not want to go on that line.

Comment on this

I appreciate that.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Here you had a substantial decrease and, as we are on the argumentative trend——

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Are you not? All right. It was just a little remark the Minister made in the course of the debate the last evening, more or less insinuating a certain blame on Deputy Lemass. I think that there is the answer from Deputy Lemass. However, that is beside the point at the moment. In November, 1947, the price of meat was controlled. If one looks —I have them all here—through the succeeding issues of the bulletin, to date, one finds a creeping rise, let me put it that way, as from that time, but I think I am warranted in saying that at the present moment, for that beef and mutton again, the prices are comparable with the pre-controlled prices.

But, in any event, the fact is that, whether large or small, in practically every item there has been an increase in the cost of meat to the city dweller since that date. That, in itself, is to some extent serious because the city dweller should get a certain ration of meat. If the price of meat rises, where there are no corresponding decreases in the cost of living otherwise, the only way that the particular city dweller whom I have in mind can make do is by cutting down his consumption. That, in fact, is, I think, what is happening. I think it is a sad reflection on our economy that here we are in this country—in a country as a whole producing the finest meat and exporting the finest cattle and meat that one could wish for—and, notwithstanding the fact that here at home we are producing such a prime commodity, the figure in regard to costs is such as to tend to a reduction in the consumption of that commodity by our people in the cities. I know that we criticised a foreign Government at the time of the famine for sending wheat out of the country when our people were starving. We were very indignant. There is no comparison in degree, I admit, but essentially there is a certain comparison between that and the situation where we produce the best meat in this country and our city population are constrained because of the price of the commodity to consume less. Is it not possible by some method to give our own people a reasonable benefit from the production of such a high-class commodity?

But, the matter is a little bit more complex than that because of the butchers' problem. This has been going on for a long time and, so far as I understand it, it is this: that once the price of cattle in the market rises above a certain value then it becomes uneconomic for the butchers to sell at the controlled prices. Roughly speaking, I understand that is the problem. I have heard figures given for what is, so to speak, the critical value for the price of cattle, but the actual value is not material for the argument. The point is that here you have a certain natural conflict between the interest of your own consumers and the interests of your own producers. As the Minister very rightly said: "If I do not give the farmers the price, what are you going to do about it, or, if the farmers get the price outside, are you going to make them sell at less at home?"

Admittedly, that problem is there, but the fact that it is there does not mean that we should not face it, particularly having regard to this other fact—that the effect of simply saying "no" to the butchers is that the butchers are tempted to purchase inferior meat and the result to the city consumer for whom I am pleading is that not only is the quantity restricted because of the price, but the quality is restricted and is, apparently, deteriorating because of the butchers' problem.

When I am arguing this with the Minister, I should like him to understand that it is not to argue the butchers' case I am approaching it, but to argue the case of the non-vocal citizen who is suffering from the conflicting interests of our producers and our butchers at the moment. In fact, the consumer, I am told, is very often getting inferior meat, sometimes even at higher than the controlled prices, and there are allegations—it is as impossible for me to check them as it is practically impossible for the Minister —that there are cases where, because of the convention of including non-consumable portions of the animal and that kind of thing, the consumers are not actually getting value to the nominal value they are obtaining, and are, in addition, getting a very inferior quality. It is that aspect of it which makes it so serious.

Is it sufficient, therefore, to say "no" to the butchers? Obviously it is not. You may succeed in holding down the nominal value of the meat, but the indirect effects on the average citizen are too serious just to leave the matter at that. If, on the other hand, you are going to ensure quality, at any rate it must be such an economic proposition to the butcher that there will be some competition and that competition will put up the quality. Again, I am looking at this from the consumers' point of view. I am purposefully taking a hostile attitude to the butchers in this matter, but I am not to be considered as being essentially hostile to them. In order that we can go as far as we can to see what the nature of the matter is in that direction, I am purposefully taking what I might call a hostile attitude to the butchers. But, if the quality is going to improve, some competition is necessary, and competition can only occur where there is some profit being made. It is not enough simply to assume that the butcher is making a profit.

I have a report here of a prosecution for a sale beyond the controlled price. As usual, the butcher pleaded that butchers had to buy at prices which were not controlled and sometimes had to sell at a loss. I think that is undeniable. The reason I am adverting to this report is that the person in charge of the prosecution, who apparently represented the State and the Minister, dismissed the matter by saying that that was no defence, that no man stayed in business for the love of it, that the butcher would not stay in business if he were not making a profit and that was the end of it. That approach to the issue is altogether too offhand. If that representation made on behalf of the Minister means anything, it seems to me that it is far too summary a dismissal of this problem. It may be quite true, as that solicitor said, that a butcher will not stay in business if he is not making a profit. But, if the butcher has been in business, is he not entitled to continue in business, or are you going to contemplate wiping him out? The trouble is that if you put him in such straits, the profit will be made at the expense of the consumers in just the way I have outlined, so that a summary dismissal of the problem solves nothing.

That is the problem. Fundamentally it arises from the fact that the favourable price position to the farmer and the meat producer is in fact an unfavourable situation to the consumer. What is the Minister to do about it? One suggestion I have mentioned is the money which has been saved already. The Exchequer should be in a position to deal with these matters. They were forced to find certain moneys for subsidies a year ago which need not now be found and, therefore, should be considered available. Can nothing be done in that regard to provide a reasonable subsidy for cattle to the home producer? That is one possible matter for examination. There are possibly other matters which will arise on it. But the point I want to stress is that this meat situation represents a serious factor in the cost-of-living problem for the average city dweller. This is not merely to be regarded, so to speak, as a price dispute with the butcher. It is a problem that should be tackled. Something more should be done about it than merely saying "no" to the butcher. It may be that the ultimate answer may still involve keeping the price at the same controlled level to the consumer. Whatever the case may be it is a problem that needs examination and co-ordination in all its aspects. If it cannot be directly tackled in the way I suggest or in any other way, then surely some indirect method of approach should not be beyond the ingenuity of the Government.

Looking at the cost-of-living index as a whole we find this position. From November, 1947, when things were stabilised until the present day the cost of living for all items has shown a slight increase. It has risen steadily from 97 in November, 1947, to, we will say, 99. It is a small increase. It rose in regard to food but the general food index now indicates that it is approximately where it was in November, 1947. In regard to light and fuel, it is the one place where the index is slightly lower than in November, 1947, but it rose sharply during 1948 to 103 and then declined gradually to the present moment. However, that favourable trend is completely offset by the fact that the index for clothing has increased progressively from 100 to 103 Deputy Michael O'Higgins quoted figures published by the Minister of the reduction of costs and it did seem on a cursory examination of these figures that certain reductions in prices of clothing had taken place since this Government came into office. On the other hand, the official statistics show clearly that in the case of clothing, more so than in the case of food or fuel and light, there has been a progressive rise since the Government came into office. Frankly, I have not studied how that came about but I take it that we must accept the figures in the official journal. I think I have said enough to show that the cost of living remains a problem. It has, in fact, been a problem since the end of the war. It has not been greatly alleviated by the increase in wages as most people who studied the problem foresaw. As is usual when it is a race between prices and wages, the prices always seem to win.

Comment on this

Not in the last 12 months.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

They usually seem to win in the long run.

Comment on this

Not in the last 12 months.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister will appreciate that I am not taking the attitude that you promised to reduce the cost of living and did not do it. I see the difficulties that are there. I think we saw them for quite a long time. I am specifically pleading now for the city population. The final remark I wish to make on the subject is that the problem is still showing a hard core. Having regard to the fact that the cost of certain imported items is decreasing, is there no device by which we can actually reduce the cost to the consumer in the city? I should like to hear what the Minister has to say on that matter.

Another question affecting the city population is that of employment. That, of course, is tied up with the cost of living and also in regard to the amount of money the State has to pay. The position in the city in regard to certain types of workers is not altogether satisfactory. Notwithstanding the fact that more employment is becoming available, that more numbers are being employed—I think the figures show that progressively over a number of years now there are more employed than there were, in certain regards—the unemployment figure has also gone up during 1948. I cannot speak for the last period as the figures are not available. That is the cause of restriction in purchasing power in the city. There are also restrictions on the circulation of money.

I want to refer to the question of transport which is a very vexed one from the Dublin point of view. Many people have the feeling that Dublin is being asked to pay an undue portion as its share of the transport costs of the country as a whole. We have more to learn from the Government on the question of transport but in the meantime I should like to mention this fact. When the Dublin transport undertaking was independent it apparently could be an economic proposition. Recently there has been an increase in Dublin fare charges which represents a serious increase in the cost of living and it seems that there is no great reciprocal benefit to the city, if any.

Generally, one has the feeling in the Minister's approach to this matter that he is now attempting to take a reasonable attitude to the development of industry and commerce but that he was for a period handicapped by the statements and threats of spokesmen of his own Party which brought about a lack of confidence in manufacturers and a certain lack of confidence even amongst labour. I think we can say now that that phase should be over.

Comment on this

Might I ask if it would be in order to move the Adjournment of the Dáil if the members do not come in and take part?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The motion is not accepted. There is not a quorum.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Having dealt with the two particular items that were of particular concern to the city, I would like now to refer to a general one. It deals more with the future than with the present. I should like to hear from the Minister, in his reply, what his Department is doing, or can do, in regard to our general defence problem. Before the last war, even from 1936 onwards, when there was an immediate effort being made in the realms of the Department of Defence, at any rate, to prepare for the war, we had singularly little appreciation of our defence needs, of co-ordinating and preparing our resources of raw materials and commodities, of emergency plans for transport, power and so forth. These were the things which were overlooked and, in fact, for which we made very inadequate preparation. We were fortunate, as has often been pointed out, in this, that at that time we got time to face our problems. We were fortunate in that. The war situation developed gradually as far as we were concerned, and the deterioration from the economic position was sufficiently gradual to enable us to face it. The fact is, however, that it would be very unwise to bank on the happening of such favourable events in a future emergency. therefore, the lesson in the economic sphere, particularly for the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is very similar to that to be learned by the Government in regard to defence matters as a whole: that we cannot wait until the emergency situation is upon us to prepare for it. If we do, we run the very serious risk that our economy cannot stand it if the strain becomes suddenly acute without the favourable circumstances that we had on the last occasion.

In that regard, I should like to refer briefly to some of these matters. There is the question of power. Power production, of course, is fundamental for industry and, to a large extent, your success in industry will depend on your capacity to produce power, and to provide it economically. Schemes are under way for the development of our resources in that regard. I think they should be hurried forward with all speed because they are a priority both in peace time and from the emergency point of view. In that regard, too, there is a certain dispersal. One of the great dangers on the last occasion was the fact that you had only Ardnacrusha and the Pigeon House. That was all we had with regard to power in the country at that time. The situation will not be so serious in the future. I commend to the Minister's attention that, in planning such undertakings, the defence needs should be taken into account, particularly with regard to proper regional dispersal in the planning of distribution lines, and that the possible requirements of defence are one that should be considered. I think it is necessary that I should say that here because the experience in the past was that that phase of the picture was completely ignored. There was an excuse until we had actual experience, and in that connection I am not seeking to blame the two Governments that went before for that; but the fact is that, having had that experience and having had the providential escape that we had in the past, I think we should now learn the lesson so that there will be no excuse for falling down on that in the future.

Following from that, there is the question of certain basic industries, notably of an engineering nature. Again, our experience during the emergency was that we were completely deficient in anything that required elaborate or even ordinary mechanical engineering technique in the working of steel and metal, even though efforts were made at that time to get the steel mills going at Haul-bowline. We were completely dependent on outside resources, and we just could not do anything. I know from my own personal knowledge that, on occasions when we needed steel, we had to make-do with very inferior articles at a very enhanced cost. Now, I understand that industry is there and is to be developed. I think it should be, even though it may involve some cost to us. A case is to be made for it from the defence point of view alone.

I would ask the Minister in this regard that, in planning such industries, due regard should be had to their possible rôle in the case of an emergency. It is a pity, from that point of view, that certain heavy shops have been lost to us, particularly in regard to aircraft—the Lockheed factory and the Leland factory. It is not so much from the point of view of what they were actually designed themselves primarily to deal with, but the fact is that if you have well-equipped workshops in operation, with technicians who have experience in the handling of tools, then the number of things to which they can be turned are very much larger than the specific objects for which they were maintained in peacetime. Were it not for the Great Southern Railways workshops at Inchicore, and for other firms that were fairly well equipped, firms dealing principally with transport, the Defence Forces would not have been able to get certain essential material which they required in 1941 and 1942. These industries were available for turning to face emergency problems, so that from the defence point of view it is a mistake to regard a workshop or an engineering industry of that nature purely from the point of view for which it is specifically there in peacetime. It has emergency potentialities, which are very much greater and which should logically be taken into account.

Passing from these industries, we have our ordinary industries. They, too, have a certain emergency use. They will be useful in emergency and, particularly, they will be able to cope with the initial crisis of an emergency only in proportion to the degree to which a plan has been prepared and to the degree to which it has been foreseen that they will play a part. The trouble is that in industry as in anything else, if you do not foresee what may come and make certain provisions, chaos may very easily result. It is for that reason also that I would like the Minister to take cognisance of our defence problem in relation to industry.

It goes without saying that the whole supply position is one of permanent importance and cannot be overlooked in regard to an emergency, both in relation to raw materials and the commodities available. We as much as any other country—and perhaps more so— are dependent on outside supplies. Therefore, as long as there is a critical situation—and the present situation is critical enough—we should always carry certain reserve supplies, even though that involves a certain cost. That cost may be written off as an insurance, just as we maintain our Defence Forces as an insurance. The point is that without adequate provision in this regard within the sphere of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, it is idle and foolish to spend money on defence in other regards. The two must go together.

Before the last war the co-ordination between his Department and other Departments on defence problems was insufficient. There was insufficient preparation all round for that emergency. I think we should always keep the possibility of an emergency at the back of our minds, particularly in the present set-up all over the world. That being so, I would like to direct attention to the need of the Minister considering his defence problem actively and to have due regard to other aspects.

I could, perhaps, elaborate more on that, but the difficulty is that what may be the Minister's sphere in time of war is not his sphere in time of peace; but he should have no hesitation in justifying these workshops, engineering undertakings and other methods of power production from the defence point of view as well as from the general economic point of view, and I think many of us would support him in that attitude.

Transport is another matter which I omitted to mention and it is fundamental in any defence picture. It is fundamental from the point of view of Defence Forces, civil evacuation and supplies. Next to power production properly dispersed, the proper organisation of transport services is paramount. Therefore, when dealing with the transport problem the possibility of an emergency situation should not be overlooked. I have dealt with that at some length because I feel we cannot afford to ignore defence problems. For the moment the temper of the newspapers—it boils down to nothing more than that—seems to show an easing of the situation in the West. But balance that against the situation in the East and look at the picture all over and you will find very little consolation, very little hope that the international situation is going to be any better than the indications heretofore have shown.

In other words, there is still acute danger, and while such danger lasts it is obviously our duty, in the light of the lessons to be learned from the last emergency, to take suitable precautionary measures of preparation, even though many of them may be nothing more than the working out of a plan to take effect immediately the necessity arises. But, in order to have any effective plan, we must be in a better position than we were before the last emergency. Hence, the organisation of power, of certain industries and the organisation of workshops where certain engineering operations will be carried out and the organisation of transport and other matters must be looked after.

I should like to make a brief reference to the chemical industry. I am quite conscious that in this matter even the Minister's predecessors were not successful, and I am quite conscious that there are economic difficulties. On the other hand, we in this country consume of necessity a high proportion of chemicals. As regards nitrate alone, our agricultural industry needs a certain supply. A certain amount of phosphates and other chemicals are used more and more in modern life. Practically all the chemicals which we use have to be brought in from outside, ultimately at any rate.

I think there is a case for considering, both from the defence angle and our internal angle, the establishment of a chemical factory, if only in a limited degree. If it could be done, we should establish a nitrate industry and hinge the whole thing around the production of fertilisers with a view to maintaining the fertility of our land, putting back into it what we take out of it. That, probably, would be the most rational approach, and if you found your industry around that you will probably get the best results. But there are other possibilities, and a start can be made from any angle. Though much talk has been going on about this matter there seem to be very few concrete steps taken. Firms have come in to carry out certain chemical operations during past years, but if one examines them closely one will find they were usually subsidiary operations. They depend on certain imported chemicals already made and they are really secondary processes. One effort was made with success during the war to supply one industry here. It is about the only large-scale experiment that was carried out here so far as I know. In dealing with that the Minister will have certain interests to cope with, but we have talked about the matter for so long I think it is now time we did something about it.

Aside from all these matters which I have mentioned, there is one little query for the Minister with regard to this Industrial Authority. The Minister has set up a body but we have not yet seen any legislation dealing with that body or any proposals about it. I do not quite understand the delay. Why could the proposals not have been put before us in concrete form before now? Surely we ought to have them within a very short space of time. We were, after all, able to rush through the Courts of Justice Bill in a matter of two days. If the Minister has his mind made up and if the Government know where they are going and the matter is sufficiently definite to warrant the appointment of personnel there should be no insuperable difficulty in presenting proposals to the House.

There is another matter of which the Minister may need to take cognisance. I am referring to the Control of Manufactures Act. Here, again, we have a subtle change in historical circumstances. From 1932 onwards when we were attempting to establish industries in this country the position was that industrialists in England and elsewhere were definitely not interested. In fact the majority of them had hostile interests in the main. The difficulty with which the Government was faced at that time was to imbue our own people with a sufficient degree of confidence to inspire them to engage in industry and at the same time encourage people from outside to bring in capital. The Control of Manufactures Act was passed in order to preserve ownership and control of those industries in the hands of Irish nationals.

Up to the outbreak of war there was no real danger of our industries falling into foreign hands except for the sake of closing them up. They proved lucrative to those who had sponsored them and, because of that fact, the chance of closing them up was nil. Up to that time, therefore, the present Act was quite adequate and there was no problem. But the situation has now suddenly changed. We have, first of all, the general strategic situation that people now like a greater degree of dispersal. Economically, we came out of the war situation rather favourably placed. There are other reasons which suggest to the outsider that it might not be a bad idea to come in here. As evidence of that, I can cite the purchase, or attempt to purchase, much of our property by people outside this country. To some extent that effort was blocked by the imposition of the stamp duty. My fear at the moment is that outsiders may try to get control of some of our industries. In fact, some of them have attempted to do so. I myself have one specific case in mind. Possibly the Minister is aware of it also. In the case I have in mind it seems to me that there was a complete evasion of the Control of Manufactures Act. An industry which had been set up and developed under completely Irish control found itself in difficulty with a corresponding industry of the same nature on the other side of the Channel. The corresponding industry enjoyed reciprocal trading relations and thereby got the benefit of certain foreign markets. There were not available to the Irish industry. The factory here manufactured stuff for the factory across the water and that was exported to, say, Northern Europe with the name of the factory across the water advertised on the goods manufactured here. I will give the Minister full particulars in private if he wishes to have them. Naturally, I do not want to mention names here. That certainly was not a very favourable circumstance, but following on that position it appears that somebody was used here in the capacity of a "stooge"—a gentleman whose name featured on another occasion. A legal device was adopted by which control of this particular industry now lies in the hands of a foreign concern. Now the home industry is doing its share and obtaining a certain return, but that return is got in such a way that no goodwill can be established.

It seems to me, having regard to these facts, that the Minister may have to consider some amendment to the Act. If necessary, he can take power into his own hands to deal with such a situation. So long as our nationals are getting some benefit and the results of the industry are accruing to the nation, apparently the situation is all right. But the position is fraught with danger. I do not think the danger of closing down is too serious since the Minister can always take the matter into his own hands. From the point of view of the development of that industry and from the point of view of general policy the situation is an undesirable one. It is particularly important that our manufacturers should remain completely independent. I know they have been criticised by certain people in this House. I know that a lot has been said about the excess profits they are alleged to have made. I think a good deal of that criticism was unfounded. These people took a risk in establishing these industries. They put their money into them. They put their energies and their abilities into them and in very many cases they did a service to the country. They did a service to the people for whom they provided employment. These industrialists and their employees are creditors of the community. The establishment of these industries and their building up was done by our own nationals largely under their own steam. The preservation of their independence is to my mind a matter of some importance. If they lose their independence there will be danger of the subordination of the interests of this country to the interests of some outside concern. The Minister may not know the specific case I have in mind. I shall be only too pleased to give him full particulars if he is not already aware of it. The question, therefore, in the net, is whether it is necessary to adjust the Control of Manufactures Act or whether, in fact, the Minister thinks he has through his own officers or in his own Department sufficient control of such a situation. For my part, I think that if I were to hear of a similar occurrence in, say, another industry I would feel bound, as a matter of public duty, to raise the matter specifically here in this House.

These are, I think, the main questions arising on this Vote. As I started, I should like to end by appealing to the Minister on behalf of those city dwellers who are in the position I mentioned earlier, to ask him if some relief cannot be given to them in regard to this obstinate problem of the cost of living, particularly where from their point of view this meat problem cannot be solved, so that the families and the classes which I have mentioned can get back to the day when they can have good Irish beef and mutton on as many days of the week as they like without regarding it as a luxury.

Comment on this

I should first of all like to congratulate the Minister on what I consider to be the very successful conduct of his Department during the last 12 months. That success I think is most eloquently reflected in the figures which he has given with regard to the percentage of the rise in production in the country compared with a number of different years. In the course of my remarks, I wish to draw the Minister's attention to certain matters which I consider relevant in connection with industrial activities in this country and if I express myself in what might be considered terms of criticism, I should like to point out that it is merely friendly criticism from an angle outside that of a Ministerial Department.

I believe that we have in this country a very good future for industry. There are a number of factors which help towards that future and one is something that has impressed me very much in regard to matters which I have had to bring to the notice of the Department and of the Minister during the past few months. I refer to the attitude of the workers, in my constituency at all events—and I think it is general throughout the country—towards industry generally. Whenever an industry was in danger of stopping or slowing down, there was intense anxiety on the part of the workers concerned, as on the part of the employer, to keep that industry going and going on a firm basis. I have found also that there has been a very good spirit of co-operation between employers and workers in this regard.

In our approach to industry in this country I think we need a certain—I shall not say a rigid—plan and a certain amount of planning. I believe that is essential because of the peculiar background and origin of Irish industry generally. In most big industrial countries the manufactures for which they are famous came into existence for historical, geographical, geological and other reasons, but we in this country went through a period when we were ruled by an alien Government and when any attempt to take part in the industrial development of either the 18th or the 19th century was severely frowned on if such an attempt interfered with industry in England or Scotland. Therefore, when we came to get control of our own affairs, we were entirely dependent, with the exception of certain industries such as brewing, bacon curing, etc.—it is unnecessary to go through the whole list—for most of the goods consumed here on countries abroad. Leaving that aside altogether, since the last war, the world has entered on a new phase and when we consider that as recently as last week one heavy importing country of the world, namely, South Africa, closed down altogether on imports, we can readily appreciate that one must make one's plans entirely in terms of the conditions of the middle of this century with regard to the development and growth of industry generally. We have in this country a future which depends, I think, upon certain well-laid plans, and for the benefit of the Minister and the House I should like to give my views, for what they are worth, upon the general situation as regards industrial planning.

I think we should base our plans first of all upon industries in which we can use the raw materials available at home. We have of course a large number of industries based upon that principle but we have not gone by any means the whole way. I had occasion on the Estimate for Fisheries to refer to the canning of fish but that is only one item. In addition we ought to concentrate upon industries for which portion of the raw materials is produced here. In any case, in any industry that is fostered here, we should have regard to the fact that a large part of the products in the way of food, clothing, etc., are suitable for home consumption. Many other articles will find an outlet in the very big market we have at the present time in connection with the housing drive. In addition, we must not lose sight of the fact that under any general long term plan, we must run our industries in such a way that portion of the manufactured products is available for export to a suitable market. The reason for that is two-fold. Firstly, we must have goods to earn dollars and hard currency. That is the way the world is set up at the present time. Secondly, and I think this is rather important, we must have goods to fill the empty bottoms of our mercantile marine. That should be a very important link in our commercial and industrial activity. We must bring about a state of affairs so that when our ships go to fetch goods they take goods with them.

We must bear that very strongly in mind. I think those are the main considerations with which we should plan our industry in this country, but there are certain weaknesses which we must not disregard. There are two sources of weakness—really both arise out of the same thing—and I think the Taoiseach, in his speech in the chamber of commerce in Waterford the other day, referred to it, that is, the investment of Irish money in Irish industry. The sources of weakness which I see are, first of all, by no means enough credit is available in the country at the present moment for use in industry. The reason for that is that credit here is not controlled by the Government. Credit is controlled by joint stock banks acting through their joint committees, and if the joint stock banks say tomorrow: "We will raise credit by 5 per cent. or lower credit by 5 per cent. in comparison with what it is at the present time," it will have an immediate repercussion on Irish industry. But there is worse than that. The difficulties Irish industry and life in this country generally have to contend with are not confined to absence of credit only, but to the fact that credit is controlled from outside our shores. When the Taoiseach said the other day in the chamber of commerce in Waterford that sufficient money was not invested in Irish industry, it is due to the fact that a number of our banks are operated from London. They hold their meetings in London and they are manned by a certain number of directors, some of whom have no residence in this country and others of whom visit this country once in two years. The investments and savings of Irish farmers at the present time are being used to finance industries that could be in competition with our own.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What has that got to do with the Estimate?

Comment on this

I will pass from that. I was pointing out a source of weakness to industry in this country.

I believe that the Minister has a proper approach to industrial production in this country. I have followed very carefully the speeches he has made, both up and down the country and in this House, and I feel perfectly satisfied that he is fully alive to the importance of the various matters that go to build up Irish industry and also to the dangers which exist and which stand in its path.

I would like to mention mineral development. Mineral development has now entered a different phase in the world. I understand that there were certain mining activities in this country in the past when lead, for example, was at a very much lower price than it is at present. I understand that the price of lead is now something like ten or 20 times what it was before the war. I would like to see not so much exploration as development taking place in the old workings which were abandoned 50 or 60 years ago due entirely to the cost of the mined ore at that particular time.

In regard to industrial research, I feel that a great deal has not come out of it yet. With the enormous increase in the number of articles which come under the heading of plastics, one would imagine that it could have been ascertained whether plastics could be developed in this country out of different raw materials. This question was brought home to me here in this House when, in answer to some Deputy, a Minister—I think it was the Minister for Agriculture—stated that foreign timber had to be used in the manufacture of egg boxes. It strikes me that the Industrial Research Department could surely take up the question of whether there would not be some very easy simple method of treating Irish timber so that it could be used for the simple business of making egg boxes. It seems to me that that is something they could undertake and I was very surprised, indeed, to hear that Irish timber was not suitable for the manufacture of egg boxes. After all, they are not a very difficult article to manufacture.

Transport: the Minister knows that I probably differ slightly with him on the question of the use of the lorry. I know that there are arguments for and against the use of the private lorry which has come to be known as "the plate". I have very strong views indeed on the proposition that the collection of and distribution of goods in rural districts should to a large extent be left in the hands of private enterprise. It is, I think, for the benefit of trade, industry and production that every small producer, whether a farmer's wife with a dozen eggs or a man with a load of pigs for the factory, should be in a position of pressing a button, if it is in the city, and, in the country, of sending word to a neighbour: "Will you have your lorry in my yard at 4 or 5 or 6 o'clock tomorrow morning to take goods to the nearest railhead or wharf?" You cannot do that with Córas Iompair Éireann and you will never be able to do it with Córas Iompair Éireann. If you change the name of Córas Iompair Éireann a dozen times over and reorganise it into something else, you will never get that. If the people living in rural districts know that a suitable conveyance will be available at their door at the time arranged by themselves to suit themselves to take goods to railhead or wharf they will produce more. There has been a great deal of talk here in this House about co-operation between farmers in rural communities. What better co-operation can you have than the knowledge that there are one or two lorries with a plate in your parish and that they are going to co-operate to take your goods out of the district to where they will earn money and bring other goods back into the district? I do not believe that that type of service by private enterprise will do the central transport authority a bit of harm. On the contrary, it will do it a great deal of good and bring to certain districts an increased amount of goods traffic.

There is another question in regard to transport and I think this affects all services of a semi-government character in this country such as the Electricity Supply Board. There is a kind of idea that the people down the country do not count as much as people living in the city. I want to give an example here in this House of the mentality which exists in Córas Iompair Éireann with regard to the country. Córas Iompair Éireann has a monopoly for carrying passengers with, I think, one or two exceptions here and there. At all events, it has a monopoly in Wexford. There is a district roughly south of New Ross which is bounded on one side by the sea and on the other by a river. It is a well populated and industrious district and those people are as much entitled to transport as the person living in Rathmines, Terenure or Crumlin. In the ordinary course of events an agitation grew up that a bus should be supplied to bring people into New Ross for marketing and so on and out again. I had certain distinct evidence that there would be plenty of passengers for that particular bus. Why did we not get it? Not on the grounds that there were not sufficient passengers, not on the grounds that it would not pay, but we were told to reconstruct our roads and when we had done that we would get a bus. I want to say here, as representing a rural constituency, that it is a great piece of, I will not say impertinence, but wrong appreciation of their function for a company which has a monopoly of the transport of passengers in this country to say: "You make your roads right and we will get you a bus." I say in answer: "There are our roads and we could run a bus as we are entitled to and it is up to you to make a bus to fit our roads." That very same week, the tramlines were being torn up in Dublin on the Dartry and Terenure routes, in order that the people in Dartry and Terenure would have an efficient bus service; and there is always an outery if there is a bus short or if there are not enough buses on all routes. There you have a district in County Wexford, inhabited by brother Irishmen, and until they have reorganised their roads this great company will not give them a bus to travel in.

Regarding marine services, I often wondered when we started our merchant fleet—I think we started it very much too late, and that we should not have waited for the world war to commence—why we did not get a few tankers. We consume a big quantity of oil of various kinds and other countries have tankers. A tanker, if it has supplied the needs of its own country, will always get a job of work to do carrying oil to some other country. It came to my notice recently that one of our ships, I think it was the Irish Rose, which is on the Scandinavian route, goes over to Ardrossan to fuel and loses both fuel value and hours of time for which money is being paid out. It seems to me that, with the rise of the mercantile fleet and the fact that oil seems to be the coming fuel for motor boats, it is strange that we have not got a suitable oil depot in this country. I was very surprised to hear we had not. I acquired the information quite accidentally in the course of conversation with a friend who had been on a trip recently to Sweden. I discovered that the boat had to go out to Sweden to get goods to bring back here —principally timber and wood pulp— and that there were very little goods going out with the exception of some canned meat and so on. We have something for which the Swedes are crying out and are importing from Scotland at present. Possibly we could not supply it yet, but it is an item of industry which could be looked into. Apparently, one learns as one goes along. The Swedes require vast quantities of powdered lime for various manufactures and they have none in their own country. This boat could take such a cargo, as the Swedes are getting the lime from Scotland at present.

Turning to our tourist trade, I hope I will not be charged with a moral criminal offence on the spot when I suggest that, for the purpose of attracting tourists, our tourist resorts should take some example from the continental resorts. This country is full of people who are fond of a bet on a horse. I cannot see any difference between the roulette table and a bet on a horse and if, in our various resorts, we had municipal casinos with roulette tables, I believe that the tired businessman with a good wad of notes in his pocket would be attracted here just as soon as to the Belgian or French coast, to Monte Carlo and such places. I understand that, for some reason or another, the game of chance with the little ball and coloured numbers is frowned on, but I cannot see any difference between it and the Irish Sweep, or a little bet on a racehorse.

After he came back from the United States, the Minister referred to the point I am making now. In connection with planning in all countries at the present day, the English are very keen on their export trade and the Americans are very keen on building up in Europe an economy that will give them some place in which to sell their goods. We could take advantage of that position and there could be fitted into the picture a suggestion that came from the Minister. The Americans might be interested in furthering some industries in this country suitable to their own particular economy in Europe. I do not mean that the control of such an industry should pass into American hands, but I think the Americans could make use of their money in this country in connection with their programme of economic development.

In conclusion, my experience throughout the length and breadth of this country, wherever I go, has been that the people realise that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has taken over, particularly in view of the recent war, a very difficult and comprehensive Department. I am told everywhere that the method and manner in which he is running that Department has met with the complete approval of the majority of the citizens of this country.

Comment on this

I have no objection to offer to the last remark of Deputy Esmonde about the Minister's administration, but I think we are entitled to criticise generally the policy of the Government, which, in my opinion, has had disastrous effects on some parts of the country. The Minister did not say a whole lot about employment, but he did make one statement to indicate that the numbers in employment in the production of transportable goods were the highest on record. That statement, as it stands, is quite true, but, if we look back over a number of years and compare the progressive increase since the end of the war with the increase following the coming into office of this Government, the fact that the figure for 1948 is the highest is not in itself any cause for complacency.

Taking the figures in the Irish Trade Journal for March, 1949, in the group of industries which represent 80 per cent. of the employment in the production of transportable goods, we find that, for the six months' period from September, 1945, to March, 1946, there was an increase of 6½ per cent. in the numbers of persons employed; in the next six months' period, from March, 1946, to September, 1946, there was an increase of 4½ per cent.; from September, 1946, to March, 1947, there was an increase of 3 per cent.; from March, 1947, to September, 1947, a further increase of 3 per cent.; and in the period ending March, 1948, which more or less coincides with the time Fianna Fáil went out of office, there was a still further increase of 3¼ per cent. For the first six months of the change, the increase was only ½ per cent. In other words, there was an average increase over the five half years I have mentioned of 4 per cent., but, when the change of Government took place, the increase was only ½ per cent.

That is a fact of which the Minister and the Government particularly must take notice, because it shows a trend. The figure for September, 1948, was 92,000 odd, and, while it is the largest, in actual fact, it would be still larger if the trend which had set in 1945, when capital goods became more or less available, had been continued. It is that trend, shown by the figures published by his own Department, that I want to bring to the notice of the Minister. These figures, according to the Trade Journal, are the employment figures for the group of industries which represent 80 per cent. of employment in the production of transportable goods.

The constituency I represent is very interested in this question of employment. It has lost, in great part, the emergency employments which it had during the war. Turf was the principal employment and we have had sufficient discussion of the turf industry, so that I do not propose to say very much about it now. The industry generally must be of primary interest to those poorer agricultural areas which have to rely on means of making a livelihood other than agricultural pursuits. The change of policy in relation to matters which gave employment in the poorer areas during the emergency produced a peculiar result in my constituency. I asked the Minister for Social Welfare to give me the comparative figures of unemployment, that is, of those on the register, in November, 1947, and November, 1948, and I find that for my constituency, which would be represented by the figures supplied by the three offices, Galway, Oughterard and Clifden, the figures in 1948 were less than those in 1947. I find also, however, that the amount paid out in 1948 was larger than the amount paid out in 1947 in unemployment assistance.

These figures would appear to be contradictory, but I see the meaning of them straightway. What happened was that, as soon as the turf industry ceased, the young unmarried men, all those who had no domestic ties or responsibilities, cleared out almost en masse and these are the people who received the small amounts of unemployment assistance. The numbers must have fallen considerably, there fore, as is verified by this official reply from the Minister; but the increase in the amount paid out is accounted for by the fact that more people with dependents, more married men, who cannot so easily leave their small patches of land and go to England, came on the register and these are the class who received the largest amounts. That is a state of affairs about which we cannot be too complacent.

With regard to the operation of the employment periods, I do not know whether or not I have correctly interpreted the figures which the Minister's Department supplied, but it seems to me that there is a bigger drop in the number of unemployment assistance recipients at the commencement of the first employment period, which applies to people who have means, than there is when the second employment period comes into operation, the time when the men without means or dependents go off the register, or are no longer entitled to unemployment assistance. The reason I mention that is that the Minister recently made a speech in Westport in which he referred to the large numbers of people on the register who would not take employment. I put a question down to-day asking the Tánaiste for information on that matter, and, strange, to say, the Tánaiste, who is the Minister in charge of Social Welfare, was unable to give me the information. I wanted to find out the numbers of those without means or dependents who were offered employment since the end of the employment periods last year and the number who had refused, and it seems very strange to me that the Department was unable to supply the figures.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister for Industry and Commerce is not responsible for that.

Comment on this

I know he is not, but it is a matter to which you, Sir, and the Minister might allow me to make a passing reference.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have allowed the Deputy to make a passing reference, but clearly it is a matter for the Minister for Social Welfare, whose Estimate will come before the House.

Comment on this

I agree it is, but, in any event, I would ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce to examine his own statement again or, if he has figures of those who were offered employment in public schemes and have refused it, I would like the Minister for Industry and Commerce to examine the question in relation to the two classes of people to whom I have referred, those who have some means and those who have neither means nor dependents.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no good in speaking to the Minister for Industry and Commerce on that matter. He has nothing whatever to do with it.

Comment on this

All right. I will leave it. I welcome the Minister's reference, although it was rather short, to the tourist industry. The figures which he gave of the value of the industry to this country for 1948 must have surprised a great many people. I think he put it at £30,000,000. He warned us that he regards that as a peak figure and that it is not likely to be repeated. I want to say to the Minister in that connection that, in my opinion, the Government's general attitude towards this question of the tourist industry, and particularly to the activities of the Tourist Board, will ensure that it will not be repeated. I understand that one of the first economies made when the Government came in was the closing down of the Tourist Association office in New York.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

Was it not closed down?

Comment on this

No; it is still in operation.

Comment on this

Were the grants for it reduced?

Comment on this

The office is still open and operating as it was before the change of Government.

Comment on this

While I was waiting my turn to speak I read some references made by Deputy Lehane to this question of tourists and he trotted out an argument that was very common during the emergency up to the time that Fianna Fáil went out, that people who made easy money in England and elsewhere could come in and eat up our supplies of rationed goods and that, in return, we got a whole lot of printed paper money that was of no value to us. As soon as the war ended and goods became available, all that accumulated paper money which we were led to believe was of no value was converted into a pretty large supply of capital equipment and goods for this country and we see the result of that action on the part of the Minister's predecessor and the effect it has had on employment in these figures in the Trade Journal. Then we were criticised for having spent these external assets too rapidly. Because the trade balance was unfavourable to the extent of £90,000,000 in one year, we were criticised as dissipating the foreign assets which we had accumulated through tourists eating our rationed goods here and through exports to the British market. We cannot have it both ways. Either foreign credits are of some value or they should not be accumulated and, if the Minister holds the view that they ought not to be accumulated, then he ought to put into effect the indication of policy with regard to the tourist industry which he gave when he first came in.

On this side of the House we believe that anything he can do to encourage the tourist industry should be done and, for that reason, I must criticise the decision of the Government with regard to the hotels. I do not ask that these hotels or any other undertaking that is costing money should be carried on for a long period at a loss but I do maintain that the hotels set up by the Tourist Board have not got a fair trial. I really have only one of them in mind, the hotel in my constituency. From the very day it was set up, there was a continuous campaign of denunciation of these hotels. One argument was that they would compete with private hotels and another was that they would induce people from other countries who had a lot of money, which possibly was got in a doubtful manner, to come here and enjoy themselves at the expense of the Irish poor. That campaign, in any event, has depressed the hotel industry in my constituency and at least one other important hotel has been put on the market as a direct consequence, in my opinion, of this campaign.

In Connemara, where the Minister, the Government and previous Governments found it very difficult to find employment and means of distributing money amongst the people, tourism meant a certain increase in the standard of living and if two of the important hotels in the place close down it will definitely put a damper on the tourist industry in the area. If a district has the reputation of having good hotels in it people will be attracted to that place because they will be sure of decent accommodation. Tourists like to have a number of first-class hotels in a district and they like a change. All down the years we have seen tourists going from one district to another. That applies particularly to anglers. They like to spend a while in each place.

Comment on this

There would be very few Irish anglers at Ballinahinch. None of us could spend £40 a week.

Comment on this

The only comment I have to make on that is that this is the first time in my memory that an Irish angler was able to fish at Ballinahinch. It was the only time he was able to buy permission.

Comment on this

He would want to be a very wealthy man.

Comment on this

I think my answer to the Deputy's remark is good enough.

Comment on this

It is not. £4 a day would be too much for the Irish angler.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Bartley.

Comment on this

No matter what the length of your purse was, you could not fish in Ballinahinch until the Irish Tourist Board took it over, unless you were persona grata with the people who occupied these places and they did not usually have very many Irish people in their coterie of friends. As a matter of fact, one of the main objections of that class to the Irish Tourist Board having these places is that they have not got the same perquisites in the way of free fishing that they used to have as a result of their acquaintance with the occupiers of these places. They used to get fishing practically free. They can fish now at Ballinahinch but they have to pay the price and they have to employ a gillie. Employment of a gillie has been insisted on by the management of that hotel. In that way the Tourist Board showed that they would not allow people who could pay to get out of their obligation to the people of the locality who were, I think I can safely say, the prime consideration of the Tourist Board. The first consideration of the Tourist Board was that employment would be given in those places, and in Ballinahinch they gave a pretty decent livelihood to about 50 people. In my own knowledge, one employee, who was a porter or in some occupation of that kind, after one season banked a very considerable sum of money, much more than he would have been able to send home if he had spent two years in England.

It is because of things of that sort that have come to my knowledge that I feel so strongly about the attitude of the Government in regard to Ballinahinch. Surely to goodness, if the Government had to reduce the standard of living in a place like Connemara as much as they did by closing down the turf industry and by reducing the employment schemes the following winter, they should not have followed up that policy so inexorably by hitting on the head everything that had been established there in recent years to bring some little comfort into the lives of the people. It is the same with regard to everything that was established in those areas. If every congested area has been treated in the same way an West Galway nobody can escape the conclusion that this Government has a bias against those areas. Take the attitude of the Minister for Agriculture on the question of the tomato houses as just one other instance. I would appeal to the Minister to keep Ballinahinch going for another year, in any event, and let us see if it will not offer some hope of coming reasonably near paying its way by the end of that time. I would also make another request to the Minister in connection with Ballinahinch. There are large properties outside the hotel itself. I should like him to find out for me and, indeed, for his own information, to what extent the loss that has been sustained in the operation of that hotel has been sustained in the management of the property other than the hotel. I should also like him to inquire into the expenditure—he gave me a figure recently—for the equipping and the furnishing of the place. While I am defending the Tourist Board's decision to set up that hotel, I think there was not sufficiently close supervision in the early stages of its development. Having said that, I shall say no more about it.

I desire to draw the particular attention of the Minister to Galway Harbour. The Minister knows that there is an application in his Department from the Galway Harbour Commissioners for the past year and a half— I think since about October or November, 1947. Galway Harbour is in the position that it cannot hope to make much revenue from post-war traffic unless it can improve the capacity of the harbour to accommodate larger ships. One stage of the works has been carried out, as the Minister knows, at a fairly high cost. But, whatever its magnitude, it would have been three times as great if it had been done since the war. They were fortunate in having it carried out before the war. The cost of it was financed entirely out of local resources—the revenue of the harbour itself and a guarantee by the Galway County Council and the Galway Corporation. Galway County Council contributes a sum equivalent to a rate of 4d. in the £ and the corporation contribute a sum produced by a rate of 1/- in the £. Under the Galway Harbour Act the works must be completed within the time laid down. Then years was the time laid down, with a possible extension of a further ten years. The previous Minister agreed to extend the time for a further ten years. The further ten years will have been completed by the year 1955. The position is that, if the second stage of the works has not been completed by that time, the Galway Harbour Board is precluded by the Act from undertaking that second stage of the works unless the surplus of revenue of the dock, without the aid of the rates, will be sufficient to finance such works—having cleared up the loan charges which they are liable to pay at the present time and a deficit of £12,000 in their revenue account which they have accumulated. Unless this State steps in, Galway Harbour will be in the position in which it has accumulated a huge debt which it cannot clear and the docks will not have been adapted to use for post-war traffic. Between the two stages it is in a half-finished State and a sum of £370,000 has been estimated as being necessary to complete the work. I know that the last Government intended and I understand from the Minister that the present Government intends to formulate some kind of a national harbour policy. The quicker that policy is formulated and put into effect the better.

I would ask that the very special position of Galway Harbour be taken into account. I know that the provisions of the 1939 Act can always be amended and improved by a further Act, but the Galway Harbour Commissioners have to deal with the position as they find it. They are being tied up if they cannot get this second stage of the work, which is absolutely necessary, completed by 1955. The principal dock is not at all suitable for the type of boat which is now employed in the cargo-carrying service. We have a deep dock, the Dun Aengus dock, which is a small dock and which is quite deep enough for the average-sized boat. That dock has to be connected with the commercial dock. Plans have been submitted to the Department and unless that connection between these two docks is made neither the commercial dock nor the Dun Aengus dock will be of any advantage to the Galway Harbour Commissioners— rather will they be a liability. Further, the old dock main gates into the commercial dock will have to be removed at a cost of from £20,000 to £25,000. If something is not done soon these old dock gates will collapse, and in that event the commercial dock cannot be used by any type of boat. That is a matter of great urgency and of great importance to Galway. I hope that the Minister will see that the application of the Galway Harbour Commissioners, which is there for the last one and a half years, will be attended to and that some communication will be sent to the harbour commissioners indicating what the Government proposes to do.

I wonder if the Minister will be able to give us any information as to what progress the Industrial Research Council has made or if it is investigating the use of seaweed for the production of yarn. I understand this was undertaken in England during the war and that our Industrial Research Council was associated with the work. I believe the yarn has been produced, but whether or not it can be produced on a commercial scale is another matter. I was told that it was tried out and found to dissolve in water and that somebody hit on the idea of weaving it into some other fabric and that, on the fabric being washed out, the seaweed dissolved in the water, the result being a much finer woollen fabric than it was possible to get by any other means. If such a yarn were produced I imagine we would be able to compete successfully with the very fine yarns imported from Italy and France. It is a development which would be of first-class importance to our poor areas if it takes definite shape. I should like the Minister to give us any information he can on the matter when concluding the debate.

I should also like to find out—possibly it would be more appropriate on the Vote for External Affairs—what is the result of the trade agreement made with France, particularly in regard to the export of woollen textiles. The trade agreement with Great Britain hit the parcel post end of the Irish woollen trade very severely and we were hoping that the trade agreement with France might make up to some extent for the losses on the British market. It is a matter of interest to the poor areas and I should like the Minister to say what the position is and what the prospects are for development.

There is one local matter to which I wish to refer, arising out of the transport question. I do not want to say very much about transport, but the Minister, in his opening statement, pointed out that £360,000 had to be advanced from the Central Fund to Córas Iompair Éireann in July, 1948, and in January, 1949, to meet interest on State-guaranteed debentures. The fares have now been increased and the need to repeat expenditure of this sort has been obviated. The only comment I have to make is that it is a pity the Minister did not make his decision sooner. He has to bear whatever opprobrium attaches to the increase of fares and, if he had faced up to it sooner, he would have lived down the opprobrium by now and saved the Exchequer this sum.

We have no great grouse in the West with regard to the services generally. A great deal of political capital was made out of the fact that the railway line in West Galway was closed in the year 1935. If a plebiscite were taken west of Galway on the question of road or rail services, I have no doubt what the result would be. The road services have been brought into every village in the area. The bus and the lorry serve the remotest of these villages now. When the railway was operated people had to hire sidecars and drive up to 15 miles to get the train. They had also to maintain a large number of horses to bring goods from the railway station, and these horses had to be fed on corn brought from areas outside Connemara. All that has been done away with and the people have transport at their doors.

From that point of view we are satisfied enough, but I want to renew my representations to the Minister with regard to the interruption of the service from Galway to Lettermullen because the county council is dilatory in repairing bridges. The county council offers the excuse that the Government have cut down the road grants so enormously that they cannot go on with the work. As transport is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce, I should like to point out to him that many thousands of poor people have to travel long distances to get this bus. The point of my question to him recently was that he should get Córas Iompair Éireann to continue this service on the understanding that when the bus came to one of these defective bridges the passengers should alight and walk across the bridge and then get into the bus on the other side. The reason I made the request was that the local people are asking why an empty bus cannot be allowed to cross over these bridges when a heavily laden lorry with its load and driver and helper, which is much heavier than an empty bus, is allowed to go over the bridges. If the bridges are able to stand up to that, why will they not allow an empty bus to cross the bridges? I think that is a reasonable suggestion to make. It will mean that these people will have the service which they had formerly. If there was a little slowness in repairing the bridges people would not notice it so much, but when they have to walk long distances they will not give their blessing to those who are responsible and the Government gets its share of the blame.

Comment on this

The previous Deputy experienced some difficulty in relation to the figures for unemployment and unemployment assistance. It is a difficulty which many of us sympathise with because we have experienced it ourselves. It is one of the defects of this organisation of the Department of Industry and Commerce that, whereas the Minister is responsible for unemployment and, naturally, to some extent, can be held responsible for unemployment when policy is discussed, yet the compilation of the statistics governing the extent of unemployment and the nature, variety and depth of it relates to another Department, the Department of Social Welfare. However, I suppose we can hardly go back to the time when the Department of Industry and Commerce was responsible for the compilation of these industrial statistics, particularly as it has been indicated by the Minister that, in the process of shedding some of the functions of this overgrown monstrosity of a Department, he has relegated the statistics branch to the Department of the Taoiseach.

There are many points and aspects of this Estimate which are of great interest to this House and might evoke a fair amount of consideration from the House, but the one of paramount importance to the Department, the Minister and the House as a whole as the guardian of the welfare of the people of the country is the question of employment. I propose to address myself to some extent to this question. That it is of the utmost importance, that its gravity cannot be disputed, is instanced, I think, by the very grave warning issued by the leader of the Labour Party in this House with which, with great haste, I wish to associate myself. I regret that I am not speaking to the Minister himself, but I am sure that the sentiments I express will be conveyed to and understood by him. I wholeheartedly endorse what Deputy Larkin said when he stated that he was

"not going to be associated with any Government or Party or individual who feels that the unemployed are to be the subject of open rebuke, strong criticism and scornful references because they are in the unfortunate position of being denied reasonable opportunities of earning a living under decent conditions."

I have noted with regret and with dislike that there has been a growing volume of adverse references to the unemployed. I thought that mentality was dead, I thought it had been killed by the war and by the activities of those workless people in this country who have gone to the dangers and hazards of employment in England. I thought that mentality which looked upon the unemployed as shirkers, which scathingly referred to the fact of the disinclination, as they thought, of the unemployed to work, had been killed by the war. But for some unknown reason, whether it is to escape the responsibility or whether it is because the solution to the problem escapes those who indulge in this type of remark, there has been a very dangerous tendency to get back to those pre-1932 days when the unemployed were referred to in such terms and, in fact, constituted such a very important aspect not only of our industrial but of our political life in those days as to contribute very considerably, I think, to the return of the Fianna Fáil Government. That mentality should die and should be buried, and buried deeply.

The dimensions of that problem have been referred to by Deputy Larkin. It is of very little interest to those who are unemployed to get the figures given to us by the Minister in relation to industrial production in this country. It is quite true that, according to his figures, industrial production in transportable goods has increased over the period to which his Estimate refers by about 15 per cent. and that as far as industry as a whole can be estimated there is an improvement to the extent of 16 per cent. That is of very little interest to those who are as yet or continue to be unemployed and it is of very little interest to the sections of industry where they have not the benefit of or do not participate in that general improvement, such as the sections mentioned by the Minister, the leather and footwear industries in particular, where there is unemployment and short time and where the symptoms of a crisis appear to be developing, symptoms to which I suggest the Minister should direct his attention.

Though one may take comfort, as the Minister definitely does, from this improvement in our industrial output, one should not, I think, be too over-confident about the matter. We may have reached a period which can shed a certain amount of satisfaction upon us and give some of us a certain amount of smug satisfaction but there are portents to the contrary in other parts of the world which undoubtedly have their reaction on our economy. We cannot in the present world consider ourselves as being in water-tight or economic-tight compartments. Any major development in one section of the capitalist world has its effect all over the area in which capitalism operates. In the United States at the present time economists and thinkers, those who are concerned about these matters, are becoming worried as to whether we are going to witness again a slump of such dimensions in the United States as may have very adverse reactions on all the other sections of capitalist economy throughout the world.

I merely instance this as a method of suggesting that we should be on our guard and take steps in time so to organise or protect ourselves that while we cannot hope to escape the full effects of any adverse decline in American economy, yet we might by judicious reorganisation, by protection and by various other economic agencies and tricks be able to mitigate the effects of what may be a coming slump. If that slump does affect our economy, I suggest that it can affect it in a way that can be of very grave significance to the country as a whole and that it will inevitably result in a swelling of the unemployed. The figure that we reached during the period under review of 84,000 unemployed distributed over the whole area, all types of industry, rural and urban, is indeed a warning of the gravity of the situation. We have yet time perhaps to take some steps in relation to it.

If, in the coming winter, this figure should mount we might witness again those stirring days when, in order to obtain justice, in order to obtain their demands for work, their demands to be given the opportunity of providing bread for their families, the unemployed started their marches on Dublin, their marches on the Dáil and all that type of activity, which I am sure the present Minister and the present Government would be the least likely to enjoy or in any way to take comfort from. They would, I believe—I am sure as far as one section of the Government is concerned anyway—be over-anxious to mitigate that increasing unemployment and the effects of it, not only by the provision or by an increase of social benefits and of relief for the unemployed, but by taking such steps as may enable industry to absorb the unemployed to a greater extent than it appears to do at present. The different factors in relation to that question of the absorption of the unemployed and the development of industry are too many to address oneself to at the present time, but there are a few aspects of it which could be fairly quickly remedied if the Minister were inclined to deal with them, if he were inclined to examine the question or to re-examine it and to take it under further consideration, and probably revise his views, or change his attitude in regard to certain fundamental aspects of this question of industry.

With regard to some of the aspects of this reorganisation of industry, which it seems to be agreed is necessary, I should like to contrast one attitude, which appears to be rather general on the part of the Minister, with the attitude of the Taoiseach in regard to the same matter. The attitude of the Minister appears to me to be reflecting the attitude of those industrialists who think that they and they only have the knowledge, capacity and confidence to run their own industry. I can say that many of them, from my own personal experience, appear to think that. I am referring now in particular to the footwear industry—the boot and shoe industry. Many of them seem to suffer from a very exaggerated conceit of their own competence to organise their factories with, I think, lamentable results. Whether, consciously or unconsciously, the Minister has given that sufficient thought or not, I am not aware, but we have in the Minister's introductory speech his examination of the boot and shoe industry. It can be taken as an example of this question of the examination of the whole industrial position, particularly in regard to those sections of the community which have got into difficulties or are not developing to the extent they could, and are not absorbing labour to the extent that they should, and to that degree are contributing to unemployment. He talks about the difficulties of the industry. It is quite true, as he has stated, that he has not neglected the interests of that important industry; he has consulted with the different elements which participate in that industry, not only with the industrialists but with the trade unions and with the trade union officials who are interested in it. But his main reliance, for the making of an improvement in that industry, is on a committee which, at his suggestion, was set up by the manufacturers to make a comprehensive examination of the industry and to submit proposals for action.

Now, here we have a case where the whole burden of the examination, the creation or the thinking out and the making of proposals for the reorganisation of that important industry rests upon a group of manufacturers, and unless I am mistaken—if I am I should like to be corrected—there is no evidence whatever of the workers being concerned in this re-examination and there is no indication that the appropriate trade unions have been asked for their advice, even though they do some pretty constructive thinking about this matter. As the Minister knows, they are concerned not merely with trying to improve the conditions of the workers whom they represent, with trying to get increased rates or improved conditions for them, but they necessarily have to give their attention to the organisation of the industry as a whole, and they have, I think, equal, if not superior, knowledge to that possessed by the employers as to the detailed organisation of the various factories. As I have said, in contrast to the Minister's attitude, there is the much more pleasing attitude of the Taoiseach, as indicated by his Waterford speech, in the course of which he said :—

"An aspect of the human factor in industry which had not been sufficiently appreciated was the failure to secure the participation of the worker in industry. The workman could not be expected to contribute of his best to productivity and high output unless he had a clear understanding of the problems of industry and unless he could be satisfied that some of the benefits of high productivity and output would accrue to himself. It would be of advantage to the community generally, and to industrialists, if, on a voluntary basis, workers could be induced to take a personal interest in the management of the industry in which they were occupied."

We would all welcome that, but instead of that, unless the Minister takes the initiative, it will be considered that he supports that false idea of the manufacturers that they, and they alone, know how to run or organise a factory: that the workers have no say in that matter, and that the workers are not competent to participate at the present time in this question of increasing productivity and of organising it on a basis which would be more profitable to the manufacturers and more profitable to the workers as well.

That is an important point in relation to employment, though the Minister, indirectly, has paid a very fine tribute to the workers in so far as they must be credited with the increased productivity shown by the over-all figure which he has quoted. If they are responsible, and I believe them to be very largely responsible for achieving the highest standard of output that has been achieved in industry in this country since records were kept, then surely the time has come for the Minister to insist that those who have achieved results of such outstanding importance should participate in the management of the industries in which they are occupied.

On the other side of the picture, there is the fact in relation to that industry that there has grown up, during the war period particularly, a tendency on the part of manufacturers to act in a very anarchistic manner, to misunderstand, or not to understand at all, the dimensions of the market in which they are engaged and, without reference to the general well-being, to improve and increase their productive organisations to an extent which is not warranted by the market at their command. This is abundantly shown by the figures given by the Minister in relation to the footwear industry. The fact that we have been producing of late years a quantity of goods far beyond the capacity of our home market to absorb can lead to but one thing. It can lead only to the bankruptcy of some of these concerns, with consequent disemployment, constant short time on the part of some of these factories.

This is a matter on which we should have some indication of policy from the Department. the matter may yet be too new to the Department or to the Minister to have worked out a policy. It may be a very difficult matter to work out a reasonable policy and it may be one that is fraught with political difficulties, but be that as it may, I think we cannot with any equanimity look upon development where the factories are now so equipped that they could produce the entire complement of footwear required by the citizens of the Republic in much less than the time in which the citizens would consume those products. In other words, it might be estimated that a number of these factories have become unnecessary. With the development of equipment in better financed, better organised or more firmly established factories having a higher industrial potential, they have so taken over a section of the market that they are leaving some of the weaker factories in a position where they will face increasing unemployment on the part of the workers.

This is a matter that probably would require Governmental intervention. If this committee to which the Minister has referred cannot produce a very good form of voluntary co-operation and reorganisation on behalf of the industry itself, it would appear to me that the Government must take some hand in regulating the industry in such a manner as to produce the least hardship on the workers. If that is not done there will be increasing dissatisfaction, there will be the usual wave of unofficial strikes, and there will be a situation in which large numbers of these operatives who have become skilled in their particular sections of the trade will emigrate and they may find that though this will lessen the impact of the crisis on the industry as a whole, when it starts going again after a period of decline they will have the same difficulties as they had at the start in training good operatives who will be willing and capable to run the industry.

From all these angles I urge the Minister to give the greatest possible attention—and I know he has been doing so—on the basis of some planned policy and to take into consideration whether he can overcome his natural, or perhaps unnatural, aptitude towards a laissez faire policy in regard to these matters, as was indicated by some of his introductory remarks. He should realise that what may apply to this industry to-day may apply to some other industry to-morrow, next week or next month.

While the main consideration should be the relation of industry to the home market, there is the possibility of an export market, but in view of the competition from the Continent and England and the huge industrial equipment other countries have, it would be a very difficult matter for us to get an export market of any dimensions. If we are to get that export market, it ought to be got on some specialised line to which all our manufacturers will contribute in some way or another so as to enable a product representative of Ireland, of having some definite connection with Ireland to be exported— something that would command attention in America, on the European Continent, or in England. We might establish a good export market with a specialised line, but that appears to be a very slight factor in mitigating unemployment in industry.

Our efforts should be directed towards increasing the number of employees and reducing the 84,000 now unemployed. If those able to work were absorbed in industry they could buy two pairs of shoes or boots instead of one, and that would definitely react on employment in the boot and shoe industry. In relation to other industries, there would be a similar reaction. That is what renders the question of unemployment so very important to all of us.

We have a great interest in this Industrial Development Authority and we are all anxiously waiting for an opportunity to discuss that matter in full. Already we have had a slight reference to it when a motion was before the Dáil dealing with the development of the industrial resources of the country. We are all waiting an opportunity of giving constructive thoughts on that matter. Constructive thoughts in regard to the abatement of unemployment and the proper organisation of industry are more germane to such a subject as the Industrial Development Authority and had better be reserved for that occasion.

In regard to the unemployed themselves, I have mentioned my concord with Deputy Larkin in reference to statements about the unemployed. The attitude that the unemployed take to these various jobs should be understood. I am sure that it is understood by the Minister because of his connection with and knowledge of the Labour movement. Now, Deputy Larkin related his remarks to the Ballyshannon-Erne scheme and the developments there where the question of the employment of hundreds of workers arises. But a similar question arises in small towns where there are four or five hundred people, or even 1,000 people, where the unemployed are offered work within the meaning of the Act and according to the law, but because of the conditions, difficulties and disadvantages attaching to such offer, the workers refuse to accept. We had a case like that in my own constituency. I addressed a question to the appropriate Minister in reference to certain unemployed who were offered and refused work. I do not want to give details now, but the case may be a typical one, particularly in considering the unemployed register. I do not want to suggest for a moment that I have the slightest sympathy with all the nonsense talked about the unemployed register and I hope the Minister is not deceived by any nonsense talked by the Fianna Fáil Party—for purely political purposes— in reference to the constitution of the unemployed register. I think that is sheer baloney and the problem of the unemployed is too serious to permit of any attempts at diverting attention from it in that fashion.

The case that I referred to was one where on one occasion 70 men and on another six men were paraded by the local employment exchange to go out and offer themselves to a farmer four miles distant from their homes. Deputy Larkin said that whenever a job has a bad name that bad name travels quickly. In small towns the local people will know the reputation of the surrounding farmers as employers. When a job has a bad name, nobody could expect town workers who know the conditions on the farms around to offer themselves to some cantankerous employer who is in perpetual trouble with his workers, who has continuous rows with them, who frequently takes a pitchfork to them and they to him, who is constantly using bad language, who indulges in slave-driving tactics and, furthermore, who persistently refuses to pay his workers until the last moment on Saturday night.

Just the other Saturday, I was driving home from a town where I had a meeting with a couple of colleagues. On the way we gave a lift to a young woman with a boy of about three years of age. She was laden down with parcels. She told us she lived four miles out from the town and there was no bus service of which she could avail. I asked her how it happened that she had to do her shopping at that late hour and she told me it was due solely to the fact that the farmer who employed her husband refused to pay his men until the last moment on Saturday night. She had then to lug the young lad into the local town with her and depend upon the kindness of some motorist to give her a lift home. When a bad name attaches to a job, no one could expect workers, who have a certain prestige and character and manliness, to offer themselves for such work. I think the Act is too harsh. I think there should be some clause dealing with such cases as this. If there were such a clause, it is possible that we might have a better understanding and appreciation of the situation. The unemployed would prefer to go without their unemployment benefit or assistance rather than work for an employer who has a bad reputation.

I know of one specific instance of that. Possibly that instance could be multiplied in other parts of the country. Where a number of unemployed refuse to work, there must be some fundamental reason for that refusal. Their refusal may look bad to those who do not understand the circumstances. In the case of Ballyshannon, where some hundreds are involved, it does look as if it reflects very badly on the unemployed. But it must be remembered that, from the point of view of the unemployed, there are extenuating circumstances for their refusal to accept work when it offers. There must be some sound reason which will impel them to forgo their benefits rather than take certain work. It was proved conclusively during the war that when work offered under satisfactory conditions the unemployed were more than anxious to take such work.

The Minister referred to the widespread prejudice against Irish manufactured goods. That is a matter which may call for attention and it is one upon which we could make some constructive suggestions. In Deputy Lemass's mind there appeared to be some doubt as to whether such an attitude does exist over any wide sections of the community. Having been Minister for Industry and Commerce so long, I presume he could hardly believe now that there could be such a prejudice still in existence. He said that there will be criticism of Irish goods if quality is defective, but that there certainly does not exist prejudice in the true meaning of that term which will deter people from buying Irish goods even when quality is satisfactory. I know a number of instances of my own knowledge and I know how this prejudice is created. I have brought my investigations in this respect to the notice of the Department and I have made constructive suggestions whereby I think this prejudice could be overcome. I wish to amplify that now to some extent. I am referring to a product with a very restricted market. The industry is a small one, but it is an important one since it has a direct bearing upon the transport industry. It is essential that it should continue as an ancillary to the transport industry. This industry manufactures sparking plugs. It is on a comparatively small scale, but, nevertheless, it is getting into difficulties. Its market is falling. The workers have been put on short time and the promoters of the industry fear that, if they have to close down, the workers they have trained in the last 15 years will emigrate. If that happens and conditions afterwards become better, through Governmental or other interference or other economic changes——

Comment on this

Or a change in Government.

Comment on this

——or a change in Government—it is immaterial to the matter under discussion—and if an attempt be made to restart this industry, they will have difficulty in trying to get together another band of skilled mechanics—turners, fitters and the different groups necessary for this type of industry. They suffer from this prejudice to which the Minister has referred. The prejudice against Irish manufactured goods is the primary cause, as instanced by them, for the decline in the demand for their products. We should ask ourselves is there any truth in these allegations? Anyone who goes about in a motor-car or has any connection with that industry or that mode of travel knows that there is undoubtedly a prejudice in favour of British sparking plugs and it is a prejudice which has no basis in fact. The previous Minister for Industry and Commerce, who was largely responsible for the development of this industry, laid down certain conditions for the continuance of the protection which is afforded to the industry, in reference to, for instance, the provision of up-to-date premises, the proper equipment of the factory in regard to machinery and processes generally——

Comment on this

And conditions of employment.

Comment on this

And conditions of employment. In regard to the conditions of employment, we are not making any entry on that basis in this discussion. This discussion relates to the question of the widespread prejudice against Irish products, how it affects industry, and how it can be overcome. The machinery installed in this factory is new up-to-date machinery. It is the latest type of machinery available in this form of industry. I inspected it myself. I know of my own knowledge that the firm have invested quite a considerable sum of money and they have got all the machinery available to do the work. The premises may not be too up to date but they are only temporary and they are waiting for another site. They have tests to which they subject their products and these tests are much superior to the tests to which the English products are subjected. They have withstood all tests and examinations and they have come out superior to the lines which are produced by their British competitors.

Despite that fact, there is always in the garages of the country a tendency to discount the Irish product and to advance the English product. For what reason? Not because the English product is at all superior. It is not, but because they can sell the English product at 7/6 to 12/6, whereas the Irish product is controlled—and rightly so—at 6/-. That is the reason. There is, of course, a quota. The Minister has exercised his powers and the industry is protected by a quota. There may be some smuggling from the North of English plugs. Of that I cannot speak. I have not got in touch with the king of smugglers to know how much business they have done it this regard, but I do not think it is very much. I do not think it is of such dimensions as would affect the whole industry, but there is this device on the part of garage owners and garage employees who want to make a little extra money. The very first thing they will suggest to the owner of any car that comes along is that the sparking plugs are the cause of trouble, that they should take them out and put in a set of Champions, K.L.G.'s or some other make. The factors who handle sparking plugs, in order to curry favour with the garages, do whatever they can to get a few dozen of the English plugs, and so they are pushing English plugs rather than Irish plugs.

I could say quite a lot about this matter. I know of it of my own knowledge and from the experiences of dozens of my friends who have been told to take out satisfactory Irish products before they have been fairly tried and to fit their cars with English plugs. Because they are not mechanically minded, they think that the garage hands must know, that the Irish plugs are the cause of the trouble and they accept the advice tendered them. Personally, I have done 24,000 miles on sparking plugs produced by the factory in my own constituency and they have never let me down. That statement can be corroborated by thousands of people and there is no necessity for pushing the English manufactured article at all. Here is the point to which I am coming. The Minister can help towards a solution of this problem even while allowing in these English plugs, so as to have a certain amount of competition, to keep prices right and to make native manufacturers keep up to standard. The industry is perfectly agreeable to allowing a certain quantity of these plugs into the Irish market, but they suggest—and it is a constructive suggestion—that these plugs should be used only by the assemblers in producing new cars for the market so as not to have these English plugs stocked by garages and sold at extravagantly high prices on the specious plea that they are far better than the Irish product. In other words he should exercise control of the quota in such a way that goods imported under it would not be used to the deteriment of the Irish industry.

Another fact which contributes greatly to the growth of prejudice against Irish manufactured goods is that sufficient advertising is not being done by this firm and, indeed, by a number of other Irish firms. Whether or not it is due to something in the Irish character, many Irish firms do not appear to understand the pulling power of advertising. They do not appear to understand the necessity for advertising their products. Whereas the previous Minister laid down certain conditions to which I have adverted, might I suggest to the present Minister that in operating these quotas he might lay down another condition, that a certain proportion of the resources of a company should be devoted to advertisement so that the people of Ireland will know what are the good quality goods and what are the aspects of the goods they are trying to sell which will appeal to them? The Minister himself, in fact, if he has any function in that regard, should develop an intensive advertising campaign—not that I have any interest whatsoever in any advertising agency -for Irish goods of all descriptions. That being done, we might overcome that prejudice which has such a detrimental effect upon the manufacture of Irish goods.

Comment on this

This is an extremely quiet and peaceable debate, a complete contrast with the debate on agriculture, but I suppose that farming has always a degree of noise about it which modern industry has not. At the same time, it has always been my opinion that the Department of Industry and Commerce is almost as important, if not as important, as the Department of Agriculture. If industry is successful it provides an enormous market for agriculture and for the employment of the sons and daughters of agricultural workers. No matter what people may say about industry in this country, it is quite a recent growth. It has been sought after and agitated for for quite a long time, but it is only in recent years that industry has been established here on any sort of basis. The Cumann na nGaedheal Party ventured on industry in rather a timid fashion. They set up a board to examine the possibilities of developing industry here and decide exactly what tariffs should be employed to protect it. They developed a few industries for a few years but just before our advent to power the greater number of them had disappeared.

When quite recently this Government came into power they seemed to adopt more or less the same attitude as the Cumann na nGaedheal Party adopted, and industry began to decline. Industry declined, not alone in the towns, cities and factories, but in the rural areas and the agricultural industry commenced to decline. I want to prove that by the number of people who emigrated and the number of people who are unemployed both in the cities and towns and in the rural areas. These people, having lost confidence, immediately went abroad to seek employment elsewhere, with the result that if the figures of those who emigrated within the last couple of years to the United States, Great Britain and some other countries were properly made up, I am sure the number would be appalling. This has had an extraordinary effect on industry because, due to unemployment and emigration, the sale of products began to decline.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know that that statement is absolutely untrue?

Comment on this

That statement is perfectly true. It cannot be denied. Not alone was there a decline on the industrial side but on the agricultural side. Up to a point—and a point not so very far away—the dairying industry was extremely successful but for the last three or four months it has dried up. Let us examine honestly, candidly and fairly why it has dried up. First, because people have left the cities and towns. Is it not a fact that 80,000 or 90,000 people have left the City of Dublin, emigrated, and how many more are unemployed? These people cannot consume milk and they cannot buy boots or shoes.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say that 80,000 or 90,000 people had left Dublin?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I just wondered if I had heard him aright.

Comment on this

There are more people in the City of Dublin than there ever were.

Comment on this

Let that statement stand on the record.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

But when I hear that there is less milk coming into the city than ever came in——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is perfectly entitled to say so.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that the milk produced in the country has been cut down? If less milk is consumed in the City of Dublin now than was consumed when the people took all the farmer could produce it must be because the people are consuming less now or because they are not there. Therefore the situation is not as rosy as would appear on the surface. Deputy Con Lehane must have heard some footsteps when he made this statement on page 2095:—

"I believe that between some of us who sit on this side of the House and the Minister there is a pretty deep philosophical chasm. The Minister and two or three of his colleagues make a fetish of free enterprise, of doing away with controls and the policy generally that, in the long run, if things are left to work out for themselves, they will work out for the best. That is a policy to which I do not subscribe and a policy to which the members of Clann na Poblachta do not subscribe. We believe in intelligent planning. I think it was Deputy Larkin who regretted the absence, or apparent absence, of any unified industrial and economic plan for the whole country. I may be told, and probably will be told, that it is premature to expect the emergence of such a plan."

This is the most important part of it:—

"At the back of my mind, speaking perfectly frankly, is the fear that the Minister and his Department are afraid of being accused of following too closely in the steps of their predecessors."

I think that is the kernel of the whole thing, but I am very glad that recently the Minister has changed his views on that and has ceased to adopt the policy that he adopted when he first came into office. There is hardly any doubt that the policy which he adopted when he came into office—if it was not his intention—had the effect of doing serious damage to industry in this country. Not alone the Minister himself, but his colleagues went very far to make foolish statements. The Minister for Social Welfare is always one of those and the Minister for External Affairs made some statements that were extremely damaging to industry.

Comment on this

Are Deputies entitled on this Vote——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is quite in order.

Comment on this

I am glad to know that.

Comment on this

I am very glad, therefore, that the Minister has changed his attitude on that, and that these wild and foolish statements are no longer being repeated and that he is working in full co-operation with the industrialists of the country. Quite honestly and straightforwardly, I think we owe a deep debt of gratitude to the industrialists. If these industrialists were not producing during the war, nobody will deny that we would have been without shoes and boots and would possibly have had great difficulty in clothing ourselves. They had the greatest difficulty in procuring raw materials, but they succeeded in procuring them, and where they were unable to get them, they got reasonably good substitutes. They kept us, during all that period of some six years, reasonably well clothed and reasonably well fed, and we therefore owe a debt of gratitude to them.

They are people who were working without very much tradition against a country with a very long industrial tradition. There is no country in the world which has such an industrial tradition as Great Britain. Tariffs had to be applied here and they were very severely criticised, sometimes by farmers. The Minister himself often adventured on that line and told us about the farmers having to pay all these tariffs. These tariffs sometimes were not sufficient, and, even at present, industrialists here are paying from 20 to 30 per cent. more for their raw materials than industrialists in Great Britain. I am not sure how that can be got over. Before the war, the Germans did not succeed in getting over it and it was one of Hitler's greatest difficulties. We are in the position here that Great Britain, a great manufacturing country, with very powerful control of raw materials, can exert another form of tariff against us which I believe she is to a large extent exerting even up to the present.

One of the things which would benefit us here is an export market, but we scarcely yet have the machinery for an export market. I am doubtful if we have the capital and considerable capital is necessary in order to develop an export market. I believe that we will have to guarantee manufacturers who are exporting their products against losses for some considerable time. An export market costs something to get and I believe we would need to have some such fund as that, and, not alone that, but we would need, through our universities and other educational centres, to prepare and train travellers for the purpose of selling our goods abroad. It is not so much the quality of the goods that counts. I believe that it is the sales-masters and the confidence the exporters have which count. Sales-masters are sometimes able to sell a great number of things.

For instance, Deputy Connolly spoke about British goods and it used to be part of the Bible that the British produced the best goods in the world. No doubt, in certain lines, they produced excellent articles, but, in other lines, they produced goods which one could not say were of any high quality. Since the war, of course, the quality of their goods has deteriorated very much indeed but still they are able to sell them. They are able to sell them because of the variety they provide. On Saturday last, I saw what was known as a "cheap John" selling goods in a market. I watched the people buying these goods and I saw that what attracted them was the variety which he had displayed on his stand—and I can tell you that he had a big variety. It was the variety which brought the people around, and, once he got them around him, he was able to sell the goods.

One of the difficulties we have in our home market is that our variety of goods is not as large, or anything like as large, as the people require. There was, and is, a slump in footwear, in clothing and in some other industries. I said that it was due, to some extent, at any rate, to emigration and unemployment, with consequent shortage of money, but it is also due to a very considerable slump on the other side. There they have passed through the number one slump, and, whether they came in across the Border or otherwise, enormous quantities of cheap shoddy goods got in here—the worst type of shoes and children's footwear that could be bought; articles which would be dear at any price—and flooded the market. I am not saying for a moment that these goods got in here with the consent of the Government or the officials, but, however they got in, they got in, and did a lot of damage to the market here. Whatever the Government did allow in seems to be still here and there is a big store yet to be disposed of which is going to cause us a good deal of trouble.

The Minister has set up an advisory authority and I hope that that authority will have the courage of its convictions and that the Minister will stand behind it. I am sure that we as an Opposition will stand behind him in his effort to develop every industry we can possibly develop here. It is the only hope we have. Too long have we been without that arm and it is due to that fact that we had so much emigration and that our farmers are comparatively poor. They had no market but the market on the other side, and, for the sake of the farmers and producers, I hope the Minister will not fail to develop to the fullest extent by every means in his power the tourist traffic, so that, instead of having to ship our beef and whatever else we may have across the water, we will be able to feed it to tourists. There is no longer any necessity to say that the people here have not got enough to eat. The people have more than sufficient to eat and the more people we get in here, the more we can produce and the more we can get for our produce here at home.

I hope the Minister will do his utmost to develop the tourist industry and, together with that, there must be developed a reasonable and comfortable transport service. No matter how much we object to it, tourists will be coming in here with money and with luxurious cars—that is all to the good —and they will want good roads. I hope the Minister, in his interest to develop the tourist industry, will have a chat with the Minister for Local Government and try and persuade him to help the industry by keeping the roads in good condition. I may tell him that they are rapidly deteriorating, and, if they are allowed to go much further, you will not have many tourists with good cars coming here to travel over them.

Comment on this

I was very interested in Deputy Connolly's remarks about the boot and shoe industry. He apparently thinks that these people should get together and that the cure for the ills of the industry would be to establish a quota system, each factory to receive a quota. That is what I gathered from his remarks. I feel that that would be very bad for the industry, because I believe that, if you establish a quota system for an industry, it leads to inefficiency, whereas, if you have open competition in such an industry as the boot and shoe industry, it will lead to efficiency, the employers being anxious to sell their goods and the workers anxious to give good returns for the work for which they receive wages. If you have a quota system, it means that everybody becomes inefficient because they know the market is reserved for them and know that they will get so much work and will get no more.

The Minister said that during 1946 over 1,000,000 pairs of boots and shoes were imported and that, in 1947, 2,000,000 pairs were imported. Since he came into office, these imports have been drastically reduced, so much so that during the first three months of this year only 28,000 pairs, or about 2 per cent., were imported. Quite a number of people, especially those engaged in the industry, felt that the unemployment in the industry was caused by imports and I am glad the Minister has cleared up that point and has shown that imports are not the reason for that unemployment. The Minister has announced that he proposes to call the manufacturers together to devise a scheme for improving the quality and to get an export market. I hope he succeeds in that effort and I wish him well.

Another industry in my constituency which has been very much affected of late is the woollen industry, and particularly blanket making. One mill at present is completely shut down and another is working about half time. In 1947, the number of blankets imported was 100,000 pairs and, in 1948, 80,000 pairs, which is quite a considerable import. There is a free market here for blankets from any country in the world. England or any other country can send these blankets in and the local industry has no protection whatever. Up to this, the position was not so bad because there is a big demand for blankets in England, but, when that demand ceases, we will have dumping here and I want the Minister to look into the matter of giving protective tariffs to our blanket industry. This time of the year is the slack period, the period when most of the mills store up blankets for sale in the winter, and the mill which is working about half time at the moment would not be working even half time, were it not for the fact that they are storing the blankets for the winter. If these people could have an assurance that the market would be protected and that no dumping would be allowed, they would not mind building up stocks, but, so long as the market is left a free market, they are very nervous about employing their workers during the slack period.

I understand that this country has an export quota of 12,200 pairs. I was speaking to the manager of one of these mills who went to Belfast and offered his blankets to a Belfast firm. He told me that they had accepted them, the price being satisfactory, but, before he left, the merchant decided it would be better to ring up the Board of Trade to see that everything was all right. The Board of Trade said that everything was all right, but that blankets coming from Southern Ireland would have to bear a purchase tax of 66? per cent. That meant that these blankets were cut out because they were not made to the specification of the English utility blanket which is sold without purchase tax. The Irish blanket comes into the category of the better quality blanket which has to bear purchase tax at the rate of 66? per cent. Our blankets have to bear that tax, whereas English blankets coming in here can be sold in an open market.

Twenty years ago, the blanket trade had protection of 15 per cent., which was subsequently raised to 20 per cent. and, in 1936, to 25 per cent. and the least these manufacturers can expect —they have been giving good employment and not charging a penny more for their products which they are able to sell in competition with the English article—is that, in order to prevent dumping, the Minister will put a tariff of 25 per cent. on blankets coming in

The debate on this Estimate this year is different from the debate last year in that we have heard scarcely a word about the cost of living from the Opposition. A straw shows the way the wind blows and things must be going right, or we would have been hearing from them about it. I need not say any more about it. We have had some talk about sugar being sold at 7½d. a lb. We get a ration of ¾ lb. of sugar, 50 per cent. more than in England, at 4d. a lb., and any extra sugar required can be had at the rate of 7½d. a lb., which means that the racketeer and the profiteer are cut out. Not many years ago, I knew plenty of people who offered bags of sugar at the rate of 1/- a lb. and manufacturers and confectioners were delighted to send vans down in the night time to bring that sugar up to Dublin. I am very glad that the Minister has made it available at 7½d. because it cuts out the black marketeer and the profiteer.

With regard to tea, the Minister has announced that he intends to bring tea under ration, tea up to this having been supplied under quota. All the tea supplied under quota was subsidised, and I wondered, when I heard his announcement, because I understand that, in my city, a person who wanted ¼lb. of tea off the ration and who went into a multiple shop for it was charged 5/- a lb. In the ordinary shops, if a person gets extra tea, he pays 2/8 a lb., but I have been told by people that they had to pay 5/- in one of these multiple shops.

Comment on this

I wish they would come and tell us that and would give us the name.

Comment on this

I have raised it now. I thought these people might have been charged extra for tea off the ration. Other shopkeepers are delighted that tea is to be available on a coupon basis. Some of these people before the war had very small quotas and when during the war people sought to be taken on as customers, they were unable to supply them with a quota of tea, and naturally enough, these people would not then go to these shops for other groceries. They had to go to the multiple shops who were able to supply these commodities and they took on new customers by the hundred, whereas others were unable to take on any new customers. These other people are now very pleased to know that, if a person comes in and hands in the appropriate pages, they will be able to supply him, no matter how big their trade becomes.

With regard to bread—bread is being sold at present at a much lesser price than it was when wages were two-thirds of what they are now. Bread is one of the cheapest articles being sold at present. People suggest that the white bread is dear, but I saw people during the war queueing up to pay 1/- a lb. for white bread. They did not regard it as dear or exorbitant at a time when wages were much less than they are now. I think the whole difficulty now is that the ordinary bread is of too good a quality and, if the Minister wants to sell his white bread, he will need to increase the percentage extraction of ordinary bread, but I do not think he will want to do that and I do not think he should.

We have had a strike lasting for nine or ten weeks in another very big industry in Castlecomer, where we have the largest coal-mine in Ireland, a coal-mine which employs 500 men. The Labour Court held an inquiry down there some time ago and the men were asked to go back, but they said they would wait to see the result of the Labour Court's examination. This is creating a big loss to the men, the owners, the people of Castlecomer and Kilkenny and to the country in general. I do not know whether the Minister has any power in the matter or not but, if he has, I would ask him to ask the court to announce their findings as soon as possible. I do hope that they will be satisfactory, that both sides will be satisfied and that our industry will again be in production. There is a loss of 500 tons a week, which is a big loss to the country. I hope it will be in production in a short time.

Comment on this

Deputy Crotty who has just spoken amazes the House. In trying to suggest a comparison between what happened some years ago and what happens to-day, he makes the most extraordinary statements. I would like him to wait and tell us. He said that during the war there were queues waiting for white bread outside shops. My recollection of it is that during the war white flour was strictly prohibited and many people were put in jail for selling or black marketing white flour.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. I have seen these queues within 100 yards of my own shop and I sell bread and I ought to know.

Comment on this

During the war?

Comment on this

During the war and there was no word said about it.

Comment on this

All I can say is that the "pip squeak" inspectors who were put into other activities when the change of Government came must not have been such "pip squeak" inspectors in Kilkenny.

Comment on this

He was asleep in those days.

Comment on this

Perhaps they were watching a bigger racket even than the white flour.

Comment on this

For instance?

Comment on this

For example?

Comment on this

I will give you plenty of instances.

Comment on this

The Minister is always threatening to get plenty of this and plenty of that. A Deputy gets up and suggests that certain things happened during the war when we know that the Department of Industry and Commerce had a team of inspectors going around. First of all, the millers were not allowed to mill white flour. Anybody caught sifting white flour got very severe penalties.

Comment on this

Did anyone get severe penalties? Were there any put in jail?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to be serious in his interjections, he should realise that one of the first things the Minister for Industry and Commerce did under his Government, when he got back to power, was to restore for supplies very large numbers of shopkeepers who had been cut off for breaches of all these regulations.

Comment on this

Can Deputy Crotty exist on that?

Comment on this

I am not going to answer any more questions because I am quite serious in what I am going to say. Deputy Crotty also said that nobody had raised the question of the cost of living, proof positive that the cost of living had gone down since the change of Government. I propose to deal with it. I have some information about it. We are not finished on this side yet in discussing this particular Estimate. First of all, I want to get down to this point: There appears now to be unanimity in the House that what were previously described as a form of racketeering in the country, protected industries, are necessary. After all the wild charges which were made against industrialists during the last general election, all the threats of exposure, when the books would be examined, of the terrible disasters which overtook the country, everybody now realises that side by side with the agricultural industry there must be a form of balanced economy that can only be brought about by having ordinary industrial activities which will give employment to those who are not employed on the land.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say there was no racketeering?

Comment on this

I am saying that the charge against industry generally was that protection for industries was only a protection for racketeers.

Comment on this

There never was such a charge.

Comment on this

Indeed there was.

Comment on this

There never was.

Comment on this

Indeed there was. If the Deputy reads the debates in the House prior to the time the Deputy came here, he will see it. There was a great deal of objection to any protection for any industry.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

The Deputy should read the speeches of the Minister for Agriculture when he was Deputy Dillon. I can quote it. Time and time again he was positively against protection of industry. The Minister for Agriculture, when he was on this side of the House, felt that we had no business to try to start these industries. He actually spoke on this side of the House to the effect that the difficulty in getting agricultural workers at rates of wages which would make the sale of our agricultural produce possible was because our people were being employed at twice the rate of wages on stupid ideas, making tin-pot types of furniture and so forth. Let us not say now that that was not the case. The position now is that it is agreed that we should have industries. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has changed considerably in the short period of time that he has been responsible for that Department because he probably now realises that it is not all what it was suggested to be.

Comment on this

It is a pity the Deputy would not change.

Comment on this

About what? Change about what? Does the Minister mean that I should change my political outlook, my religion? What does he mean? Change what? I would like the Minister to be definitely more specific.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Change on to the Estimate.

Comment on this

Very well. There is, however, a very serious difference between the members of the Labour Party and the members of Fine Gael. I do not know to what side the Clann na Poblachta Party hold on this. First of all, we have listened to-day to a repetition by Deputy Connolly of a very severe castigation of the Minister because of the statements which were made recently in connection with the unemployed and the manner in which they were answering the call to a certain specific type of work. I did not hear the Minister answer either Deputy Connolly to-day or Deputy Larkin when he spoke on the same point last week.

Comment on this

That is a pleasure in store for you.

Comment on this

I hope it is a pleasure in store for Deputy Larkin and Deputy Connolly. I say there are certain differences. One of the differences is a very important one to certain people. I can understand it. I spoke on it last year. Deputy Larkin again this year repeated what he more or less requested on the last occasion that this Estimate was discussed. He feels that the time has been reached when the worker in industry has a right to be on the board of management of the industry in which he is employed and also to participate in the profits of the industry.

Comment on this

Anything wrong with that?

Comment on this

I shall refer to it in my own way. He says that just in that manner. As I understand the present position controlling industry and the conditions of employment in industry, the Government will give protection to industries provided the industries fulfil certain requirements, some of which were mentioned by Deputy Connolly. The industry must produce a certain quality of article; it must pay certain specific wages; it must comply with certain other conditions and must not exploit the consumer. I mention this for the simple reason that there is an opinion abroad that a great deal more rapid development could take place in the establishment of additional industries if those who are asked to establish those industries or who are encouraged to do so can be satisfied on certain points.

I cannot see private individuals starting a private enterprise with their own private capital and with their own knowledge, experts and so forth, if they have the threat over them that other people will join, by law, if you like, in the management of their industry, as distinct from the control which the Department of Industry and Commerce rightly exercises over them. It is all very well to talk about the dividing of profits. If we can establish industries that will give reasonably well-paid employment to the workers, without overworking them and, at the same time, give them reasonably good hours, and so forth, it is not fair to say that the owners of the industry, so long as it is private enterprise, should have to provide additional benefits when they may have to save their margins of profit against times when they have losses. To me, this difference between the members of the Labour Party and, I take it, certain elements of the Coalition group, will have to be solved one way or the other. It will have to be made clear what the position is going to be. Then you will have to have a new approach to the method of establishing the industry.

Comment on this

Are you all agreed on the matter over there?

Comment on this

We will be agreed on any of these matters when we are again over there. At the moment it is your business to be agreed, if you can.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Then it will be a long time before you can make up your mind.

Comment on this

The Deputies opposite may be somewhat surprised if Deputy Larkin carries out the threat which he made in his speech and withdraws his support from the Government. If they do not stop abusing the workers in the manner in which they have been abused recently, the people over there may find themselves in a minority and the change may take place without an election.

Comment on this

That is your dream.

Comment on this

It is not a dream at all, but it is something you may find out. There was a Government over there which thought it had a very proud record when it had ten years——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a long time ago.

Comment on this

I agree. This is something that will have to be settled by a pronouncement by the Minister on behalf of the Government. If industry is required, if industrial development is to be encouraged and is felt to be desirable and if, in connection with that industry, the industrialists have to give certain undertakings as to how they will carry on, all that should be stated and there should not be a veiled threat that their conditions will be altered at some other time, or something else. If certain groups feel that workers should be the owners of their industries, what is to stop them from establishing an industry—as I said on the last occasion this Estimate was discussed—on a co-operative basis? What is to stop them from competing with the ordinary businessman? What is to stop them from showing how labour can, by its own ingenuity and knowledge, operate an industry better than the capitalist element from whom they are making these demands by suggestion?

Comment on this

Is that view universally held on your side of the House?

Comment on this

I am not giving the views of this side of the House. I am just indicating, as a result of the discussion on this Estimate, that there is a difference between the members on that side of the House. I say that if industry is to be encouraged and if we want to get these 84,000 unemployed reduced considerably by getting industries established, one of the things which may prevent certain industries starting will have to be clarified—the difference which exists between the Labour element of the Coalition and the Fine Gael element. As I have already said, I do not know where Clann na Poblachta stands in regard to this question.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy knows quite well.

Comment on this

I do not. Perhaps the Deputy will tell me?

Comment on this

Very well. I will give way to the Deputy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Oh no.

Comment on this

I do not know where Clann na Poblachta stand in regard to this matter because I have never heard their view ventilated as clearly and as specifically as it has been ventilated by the Labour Deputies who have spoken.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say where he stands?

Comment on this

He has indicated where he stands.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Please give Deputy Briscoe a chance to make his speech.

Comment on this

One of the most important sections of industry that could give very large-scale employment is building. One of the evils from which our people, and the working classes in particular, suffer greatly at the moment is lack of proper housing facilities and accommodation. The Government have not changed in any way their desire to see the building of houses continued. I do not say that they have in any way diminished the support to encourage housing as it was in the past. Local authorities are anxious about it. This present Government have appointed a housing director with a special staff to see how best these matters can be accelerated. That is one of the industries which can, as I say, give very considerable employment and which can bring great relief to the mass of our people who are in dire need. Yet progress is considerably slow.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Has the Minister anything to do with the housing drive?

Comment on this

Oh, yes. I am coming to it. If we had very large housing schemes being rapidly built, every ancillary industry would profit. Employment would be greater in the furniture industry and it would be greater in every single industry that would be involved in the equipping of these houses for the people. That is how I relate it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That would not make it relevant.

Comment on this

Whatever delay there is in accelerating progress is going to delay employment in certain industries which are working on short time. I shall deal with that point later. However, this is something that perhaps the committee of which Deputy Connolly spoke would take up with the Minister. If the master builders, the trade unions and representatives of the building operatives could get together and find out how local authorities, in particular, could be helped, considerable employment would be given. I believe it was mentioned, and was in order in this debate, that because of the shortage of certain types of skilled labour, unskilled labourers at present signing on at the labour exchange, and who are on the list of unemployed, could be employed and would not, therefore, be on that list. I was glad to hear Deputy Connolly emphatically say that there was no truth whatever in the statement made in this House recently that, because of the advocacy of the Fianna Fáil members, the unemployment register was being stuffed so as to make the figures of unemployed look larger than they actually were. Deputy Connolly repudiated that statement in no uncertain terms and I was glad to hear it. I hope that that hare will not be started again.

Comment on this

That is his opinion.

Comment on this

In connection with the statement made by the Minister as to the difficulty in getting workers to answer the call of Bord na Móna and the Electricity Supply Board in regard to their present large-scale schemes, I quite appreciate the point of view of the Labour Deputies who have spoken on that matter. It is not so easy to get unemployed men in Dublin who have their families here to agree to go to——

Comment on this

The Dublin workers were not asked. I was speaking about rural workers.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, when Deputy Connolly was speaking, he was labouring under the same misapprehension as I was. The Minister did not correct him so, therefore, I was quite entitled to assume that he was speaking correctly on the point. In any event, it is true that city dwellers who have families and commitments cannot be expected to go to another part of the country to work. When this matter was discussed last week the same thing was suggested and interjections were made from that side of the House while Deputy Corry was speaking. He was asked: "Is it not nearer than to go to England?" I want to say this and I hope Deputy Hickey will appreciate it. I subscribe emphatically to the Fianna Fáil view that the ordinary worker has the perfect constitutional right to choose for himself the work he wants to go into. I would resent very much a development whereby our working people would be dragooned and sent along en masse as if they were, if you like, under a State where they would be conscripted to work.

Comment on this

That is a scandalous statement to make.

Comment on this

What is scandalous?

Comment on this

The statement which the Deputy has just made.

Comment on this

What have I suggested?

Comment on this

I will deal with it when replying.

Comment on this

The Minister must not try to misconstrue what I said. I am saying to Deputy Hickey that I subscribed to a certain point of view as distinct from another. I want to develop that further and say, that being the case, that you can bring employment to those who are unemployed. As to the Fianna Fáil policy during the war, we were asked why we did not prohibit our people from going to England for work and the answer we gave was: "Until we can provide full employment for our people we have no right to restrict their freedom or prevent them from going for work wherever they can find it, but it must be the free choice of the worker."

Comment on this

There was no free choice then. It was either go or starve.

Comment on this

I do not know whether I am speaking very stupidly or whether those who misunderstand me are taking my remarks in a stupid fashion. What we did say was that unless and until there was sufficient work for any person who sought work at home, the Government had no right to restrict his freedom to go wherever he wanted to go whenever he could find work. In the same way, if we cannot provide State industries or semi-State industries and cannot provide sufficient work at attractive terms of employment for our people, then we are going to have this number of unemployed with constant emigration because they have to go to find work somewhere else. The only way that can be dealt with is by a plan of development of State undertakings, semi-State undertakings and a certain amount of private enterprise. Between the lot, it should be possible to find sufficient work for all our people in a reasonable space of time. Until that is found, I say we must have some means of sustenance for those of our people who, through no fault of their own, cannot find reasonable employment. I do not know whether Deputy Hickey will regard that as something very extravagant.

Comment on this

Do you believe that private enterprise will enable you to get that?

Comment on this

I said all three things —State undertakings which will give employment, semi-State undertakings which will give employment and, on top of that, you have room for private enterprise.

Comment on this

To make all the profits if possible.

Comment on this

Now we know where Clann na Poblachta stands, if the Deputy is in that Party. I do not want to attribute something to the Party which may not be correct. Deputy Cowan indicates that he is against private enterprise because private enterprise will pay certain profits to industrialists.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy Briscoe would continue without looking for interruptions and answering them we would get on better.

Comment on this

I should like to draw the Minister's attention to another matter. I understand that in Rineanna some hostels were built to house people who have to stay overnight and that these hostels are closed at the moment or not availed of because the air companies considered the price of accommodation to be too high. I think it was 30/- per night. The result is that the air companies bring their personnel and passengers who have to stay overnight into Limerick or some place adjacent to Limerick where they can get accommodation at a much more reasonable price. I should like the Minister to have that looked into. If there is a considerable loss on Rineanna at present, making use of these hostels may reduce that loss.

Deputy Connolly spoke of trying to educate the public to understand that Irish-manufactured goods were not necessarily second-rate. He suggested that there should be an encouragement to Irish manufacturers to advertise. I remember that when the Minister took over office one of the things he felt that was wrong with Irish industry was that part of the high cost of its products to the public was due to the fact that, from the point of view of the turnover, the advertising costs were too high and they should be cut down or cut out altogether. I do not know whether I am quoting the Minister wrongly.

Comment on this

Indeed you are.

Comment on this

There was some reference to it and I read some comments on it in an industrial organ.

Comment on this

Irish Industry.

Comment on this

Quite right. I remember reading the speech of the Minister in which he did make reference to advertising by Irish companies and said that he felt that if less advertising was indulged in there would be lower charges to the public. There you have a difference of opinion. I am not giving my own opinion on that. I am just saying that there is a difference of opinion between two sections of one Government.

The Minister gave certain figures in his introductory speech. He gave one set of figures to show there was an increase in our exports. The increase was in the form of money and it was related to increased industrial output. I say that the increase in our exports was due to the higher prices charged for our commodities, not necessarily industrial commodities. It does not follow that because our adverse balance was reduced or our export figures were up that more goods were in fact disposed of from the industrial point of view.

Comment on this

So far as industrial exports are concerned, last year they were up by 20 per cent. on 1947— £2,000,000.

Comment on this

The figures given by the Minister were comprehensive figures.

Comment on this

I am giving the Deputy the specific increase relating to non-agricultural exports.

Comment on this

That is something I did not see. The Minister also gave figures of people in employment to show that an increased number of people were employed. I want to say to the Minister that that also can be misleading. I happen to know a number of industries where workers are on what is called short time. Deputy Crotty referred to a similar situation in his constituency and also Deputy Connolly, so far as his constituency was concerned. A number of workers in industrial employment to day are on short time. A great number of factories, instead of laying off people, have put them on a rotation system, by which they work for so many weeks and are then laid off for one week. From the statistics point of view these workers are still regarded as being fully employed while they are not fully employed. The Minister ought to have these figures examined with a view to seeing how many weeks in the year each one of these people has been working. He will find that he will get a slightly different picture and it may encourage him to look even more favourably than he has in the last few months, which have been, if you like, favourable towards the situation.

Deputy Crotty talked about the cost of living. The cost of living has, of course, gone up since the change of Government. My children have to pay 5d. for sweets that they previously got for threepence.

Comment on this

Irish sweets?

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass imports?

Comment on this

With the two Deputy O'Higginses yapping at the one time it is difficult to hear what they want.

Comment on this

They were not Deputy Lemass imports?

Comment on this

I am talking about Irish sweets made with Irish sugar. The price of sugar to the sweet manufacturers has gone up and the sweet manufacturers are entitled to charge the public more. I know that sweets have gone up from 3d. to 5d. for certain types. In other cases they have gone up other amounts. That is an increase in the cost of living.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy aware that the price of 7½d. a lb. for manufacturers was not fixed by me but by Deputy Lemass when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

Since the change of Government the price of sweets has been permitted to increase. Whatever the reason is I do not know.

Comment on this

I am making it quite clear that my predecessor fixed the price of sugar at 7½d. to manufacturers.

Comment on this