Committee on Finance. - Vote 55—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).
Contributions 163–337 of 337. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am not saying he did or did not. I am stating that since the Minister came into office the price of sweets to the public has been permitted to go up.
Comment on this
I supposed we were eating Irish sweets before. I thought our manufacturers manufactured sweets during the war. It now appears that they did not from what the Minister says.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting anything of the kind. The profiteering suggestions came from that side. I am saying the cost of living has gone up.
Comment on this
Since Deputy Cowan is so concerned about the poor of Dublin, does he realise that since last week the ordinary bun has gone up because of a decision of the Government that white flour must now be used in any form of confectionery, including buns? Is that not correct?
Comment on this
It is reminiscent of promises that were made and never intended to be kept. That constitutes an increase in the cost of living. Deputy Crotty had some cross talk with the Minister which I was not able to follow fully. However, he mentioned that in his constituency if a person bought an additional amount of tea over and above the ration he was entitled to get it at the rationed price. Deputy Crotty, of course, said people were paying 5/- but I understand, and I would like it made clear, that the position now is that you get a certain amount of tea on the ration at a certain price which contains the Government subsidy. If you want additional tea you pay a non-subsidised price for it.
Comment on this
I am not dealing in the black market and I have never dealt in the black market. I know nothing about the black market, but I do know that it is believed that, in the same way that sugar can be bought now at 7½d. above the three-quarters of a pound ration at the subsidised price, there is no objection to it. Am I correct in that?
Comment on this
No, tea is issued to anybody for sale except the tea which bears the subsidy and which is supposed to be retailed at 2/8.
Comment on this
The Deputy is talking about the position as it is now. If the Deputy is trying to get a little advance information as to what is going to happen, that is another day's work.
Comment on this
That is typical of the Minister. That has been his attitude all through. I am not interested in tea, no more than I am in the housing business. I read into the Minister's statement, and there was a pronouncement made by the Parliamentary Secretary in answer to a question some months ago, that there was going to be additional tea available at a non-subsidised price and that the subsidy charged to the State was going to be less. The Minister has something of that nature in his own introductory remarks. I am asking, is that so? Is it going to mean that if you want extra tea, after a certain period you can get off the ration tea at a higher price?
Comment on this
The Deputy is now amending his remarks. What the Deputy alleged was that that was the practice already.
Comment on this
I said it was generally believed. I never bought any because I do not need it. I get enough on the ration to keep me going at the present. It is generally believed as the result of an answer to a question by the Parliamentary Secretary that this was going to be done.
Comment on this
The Minister said in his introductory remarks that there will be a saving in the tea subsidy because a certain amount of tea will be sold. I am not confusing it with the tea sold to restaurants and hotels. That is another matter altogether. I should like the Minister to make that quite clear. In any event, Deputy Crotty talked about the price of bread being cheaper now than it ever was during the war. As a matter of fact, an increase has been put on to the price of bread since the advent of the Government because of a threatened strike—in fact there was a strike—so that bread is, in fact, dearer.
With regard to this new industrial advisory body that has been talked about, I do not exactly know what it is going to be. The Minister stated in his introductory speech that, because of the delay which was bound to happen since it was discovered that legislation was necessary to regulate the powers of this body, in view of the urgency they are going to be permitted to start before the legislation goes through. I am not yet clear, nor do I think anybody is clear, as to what the function of this body is going to be.
Some Deputies seem to think that the function of this body will be to advise and recommend to the Government purely on matters of applications of tariffs, whether it be an increase to an existing tariff, or a decrease to an existing tariff, or an application for a new tariff for a new industry. Other Deputies seem to think that this advisory body will be the body to whom potential promoters of new industries will go with a view to finding out whether this is an industry which will be considered necessary, whether there is any intention of the Government to suggest the site that they should bring their industry to, and so forth. I do not know whether the Minister ought not to be a little more specific in telling the House exactly what this body is supposed to do.
There is a rumour that this body is going to have a very large staff up to some hundreds of officials previously, or to a great extent, in the Department of Industry and Commerce. If that is the case it means they are going to do a terrific amount of research work, a terrific amount of examination and they are going to be a body that one would expect quick results from. I should like the Minister to be somewhat specific in order to let the people know. There are people who say: "If we are considering either an extension to an existing industry or a new industry to whom do we go? Do we still go to the Department of Industry and Commerce or do we have to wait for this new body?" My view is that up to this moment, anyway, and for some time to come the proper place to go for a new industry is to the Department of Industry and Commerce and let the Department decide whether they will give a decision on this matter or advise the people to wait for this new body. However, we will not know yet when it is going to be set up except that I imagine from what I read in this morning's paper this body will function almost immediately.
The final thing I want to refer to is the tourist trade. It is true that a great deal of agitation has developed in the minds of the people in recent times about whether tourist trade was of value or not to this country. A lot of people thought that tourists coming here were actually taking the bread and butter out of the mouths of the citizens of this State. Others suggested, as did Deputy Lehane, that this was a worthless trade because the money which they brought here was only bits of paper of no value and that we were giving goods away for that money.
I believe that the tourist trade is an important one for the country. The people in the hotel and restaurant business supply food to the visitors who come here. The income derived from those tourists is in exchange for the services rendered to them. The people employed in hotels and restaurants are not necessarily producing industrial articles, but they are rendering services for which the country, in return, gets a big income. If the people from other countries who come here in a friendly way to see our country and spend their money here while on holiday should feel that they were not wanted—if there is the suggestion that they should not come here —then, I am afraid, it will not take very long before you will damage the tourist industry to such an extent that it will be almost impossible to recover that trade again. The Minister stated that in 1948 which was the peak year so far as tourist traffic is concerned, the income which this country derived from it was in the region of £30,000,000 represented food, shelter, services and other odds and ends.
The people who come here contribute very extensively indeed to our revenue. They smoke cigarettes on which there is a heavy tax, and they drink whiskey, and plenty of it. All that is of great benefit to the State, and hence I suggest there ought to be unanimity on this, that we all do our best to see that this particular industry is encouraged and that it will not be spoken of in a disparaging manner. Nothing of a disparaging nature should be said about those customers of our nation who come here as tourists. We should do our utmost to see that the country would benefit from the tourist industry.
The most important item that I had in my mind, when I rose to make my contribution to this debate was to get a specific answer from the Minister to the questions put to him by Deputy Larkin as to where he stands on two or three matters. These matters are of vital interest to the Labour Party and if you like, to other elements in this House.
Comment on this
I suppose Deputy Cowan may be described as one splinter of another element in this House, but there are other elements besides Deputy Cowan and the Labour Party which make up the Coalition Government. We, for example, are on this side of the House, and we are anxious to find out——
Comment on this
I daresay that, before the debate concludes, Deputy Cowan will give us the benefit of his advice. I suggest to him that he should allow Deputy Briscoe to finish his speech.
Comment on this
I am about to finish, and I do not want to be set off on new trains of thought by the Deputy's interjections. I am anxious about this particular matter—that Deputy Larkin put certain specific questions to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Connolly repeated them and I think they are of vital interest. I do not want to say that I am in agreement with them. I am not in agreement with these particular points, but as I have said——
Comment on this
——I would like to have that issue more or less clarified, so that the Minister can get to the point and say: "There is the policy of this Government for as long as we are going to be here." If he thinks that he is going to be there for the next 15 or 14½ years, then I do not want to see the country suffer by any uncertainty on the part of the Government in making up their minds as to policy. The country will make up its mind about this Government when it gets the opportunity. It may put them back with a much larger majority than they have at present as a Coalition and it may not, but the duty of this House is to do the business of the nation, and one of the most important items in doing the business of the nation is to find the ways and means of giving employment to those of our people who are unemployed and to see that those ways and means shall provide good conditions of employment. I do not think the Labour Party ever grumbled with Fianna Fáil with regard to the conditions of employment that it provided, or with the setting up of the Labour Court.
Comment on this
The last Government guaranteed and continued the payment of subsidies on essential foodstuffs. These have now been removed. Deputy Davin, of course, is not so innocent as he pretends when he speaks of the standstill Orders. If we had not the standstill Orders, and if we had not provided the millions which were paid in subsidies there would have been a different story. There is no standstill Order now, and there is no great emergency. We are getting out of it because the supplies which are coming from all over the world have changed all that. There has been an increase in the cost of production, due to increases in wages. The point is that we on this side of the House subscribe definitely to the right of Irish citizens to find the best employment they can. We believe that it is the duty of the Government, whatever Government it is, to encourage, as far as possible, every single thing that will help to absorb our unemployed. We subscribe to certain minimum conditions of employment and certain maximum hours of working.
Comment on this
Are you suggesting that the wages and conditions offered either by Bord na Móna or the Electricity Supply Board are unfair conditions?
Comment on this
I think you are somewhat impatient with me and that you are taking me up in the wrong in advance of what I have to say.
Comment on this
I know the Minister. We know each other privately outside. The Minister is somewhat impatient with me, taking me up somewhat in advance of the jumps before I am over them. I am just expressing what I think should be the policy the Government should adopt. There is a very serious unemployment problem and there is emigration as a result of it. In view of that, I think there should be certain large-scale State schemes to absorb as many of those unemployed as possible. Encouragement should also be given, as far as possible, to State-aided undertakings to take up another lot of the unemployed, and then for the balance there should be some definite policy stated to encourage private enterprise with the profit that goes to the people who start it.
I do not see that there is anything wrong in an industrialist getting a certain yearly income out of his business. There is nothing more wrong in that than that Deputy Cowan, as a solicitor, should get an income for the very good advice that he gives to his clients.
Comment on this
It all depends. I know very few solicitors, or very few professional people, who will give their services free, gratis and for nothing, no matter in how aggravated a form the blood may be flowing out of their particular clients. Recently, we in the Dublin Corporation had to set up a scheme for the giving of free legal advice to people who could not afford to pay for it and who, consequently, would otherwise have to go without it. So long as we subscribe to the system under which we are living at the moment, so long as we subscribe to the present Constitution, I have yet to be told that the making of a profit by a business man is something that is illegal. Unless the Dáil makes it illegal for people to work for the profit motive, then I say it is quite legal for those engaged in private enterprise to look for a profit out of their business. I say that private enterprise can absorb, under very good conditions of employment, a considerable number of our unemployed. It can also continue to keep in employment a considerable number of those who are presently in employment.
When I speak of private enterprise, I mean public companies as distinct from State enterprises. The State will be nationalising the railways very soon. When that happens, the railways will become State enterprises and State employment. The Electricity Supply Board is already State employment. The same applies to Bord na Móna. The Sugar Company is a semi-State enterprise because there is a considerable amount of private capital in it. I want to wind up by saying that these are some of the things in respect of which we find there are differences of opinion, and in respect of which there can be, as has been suggested, unstable conditions unless there is agreement. The Minister, therefore, will have to make up his mind. He will have to make his pronouncement and, when he does, it may be that some of his own supporters will disagree with him, while, on the other hand, he may find some of us agreeing with him on it. That is the problem that faces the Coalition Government. The Government have to make decisions and stand over them. Sometimes these decisions are not very popular, and when the Government go to the people they will get it in the neck if the people think they have done something wrong.
Comment on this
I do not usually criticise other Deputies' speeches, but I do not think I ever heard a more blandly inaccurate speech than Deputy Briscoe's. I think it almost amounted to defamation of character by innuendo of the Minister. He spoke about the building industry and inferred that the Minister was not doing what he ought to do in connection with furthering building.
Comment on this
I did not, but if the Minister and his Party are that thin-skinned, I will present them with it.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister is thin-skinned and I am not thin-skinned, and I hope I am not half-witted, but if the Deputy's speech meant anything—the beginning portion of it—it meant that the Minister was not doing what he ought to do in connection with furthering the building industry. If it did not mean that, it meant nothing at all.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will read it, if he gets an opportunity, and no matter where he reads it.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not mention that local authority building is not really concerned with the Minister for Industry and Commerce and that the Minister quite recently has taken the licences off subsidy houses. That was a very big step and it has helped the building industry to go ahead more smoothly. Of course, that was not mentioned.
We heard a lot about the increased price of sweets. I may be wrong, but I am not aware that sweets are included in the cost-of-living index figure. But, again by inference, we were to accept it that that was so.
I would like now to turn to the real subject—industry. The Taoiseach stated the other day that this country suffered from chronic under-investment. That is perfectly true. It suffers also from chronic under-employment and has for many years suffered in that way. Those twin evils have walked hand in hand down the pages of history in this country and every Government have tried to do what they could to further investment and to increase employment. The first Irish Government, the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, started the system of tariffs in order to help Irish industries. They adopted a system of selective tariffs. Then we had the Fianna Fáil Government and they in their earlier period accelerated the tariffs given to Irish industries until at one period we had tariffs going on all the time. As the years went on, they became more selective and now we have the inter-Party Government using the tariff system as a means to further the promotion of Irish industry, but at the same time trying to watch the interests of the consuming public in a way that was not done in the past.
Tariffs are absolutely necessary— there is no getting away from that. They are necessary for the promotion of industry in this country. We are next door to one of the greatest industrial countries in the world, a country with a trained population, with people who have an inherited business acumen. Their work people in many cases, especially in the textiles industries, have an inherited sense which enables them to become, in a very short time, first-class workmen. We cannot in this country train in an agricultural population as quickly as it can be done in industrial countries where they have been at it for a long time.
That system of tariffs carried with it in the past certain dangers and difficulties. It is absolutely necessary to have tariffs in order that this country may build up its industrial arm, but, nevertheless, certain people were apt to forget that old phrase that property has its duties as well as its rights. They were apt to forget that that phrase is applicable to industry and that industries in the process of being built up behind the tariff wall ultimately must give value to the consumer or no tariff will protect them. I remember Deputy Lemass talking somewhat along those lines in the last year or two of his Government. I think our manufacturers are realising that and in the main are doing a very good piece of work.
We have had difficulties and we have had complaints of the quality of Irish goods in the past. I think those complaints are becoming fewer and that shows that this country can and will succeed in building up an industrial arm. An industrial arm is necessary here and, indeed, it is necessary in every country. We are mainly an agricultural country and to balance our agricultural population we must have factories and industries to take the products of agriculture and to absorb some of our surplus population.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce is doing a very good piece of work in his Department. He is watching the interests of the manufacturers and seeing that every effort is made to promote Irish industry, but at the same time he is keeping an eye on the interests of the consumer. The necessity for watching both sides of the question is something that has only become apparent as the years go on. I am glad to see that the Minister is divesting himself of as many controls as can be safely laid down because industry is not really helped by controls. In many cases the fair and equitable distribution of goods may be helped but the actual work of industry is not furthered by control. In fact, industry is slowed up. Every business man will welcome the gradual divesting of these controls by the Minister.
In that connection I would like to mention the subject of customs clearance. I would impress upon the Minister the importance of speeding up that process. Goods accumulate in Dublin and other ports of entry and the warehouses become cluttered up. Business men generally find that they cannot get goods through sufficiently quickly. I would impress upon the Minister the importance of speeding up this customs clearance by every means in his power. The port authorities would appreciate that very much indeed.
I would like to say a few words in connection with Córas Iompair Éireann. Deputy Lemass in his speech here mentioned the site of the Córas Iompair Éireann bus station in Dublin and he said that the Dublin Corporation approved of that. The pistol was held to Dublin Corporation's head. The Dublin Corporation never approved of that site as a bus station. The town planning committee was against it. The consultant town planner in his report mentioned an entirely different site as being a suitable one for the City of Dublin and the corporation experts were not in favour of the present site. Lastly, common-sense was all against the selection of the present site. This site means that country buses will now be dragged across the north and south traffic lines of Dublin City in order to reach the terminus. Surely, on the face of things, that is not wise. Surely that is not a very sensible place to put the main Dublin bus station.
The Minister has had a very difficult task in clearing up the sorry mess in Córas Iompair Éireann. I think most members of the House and the public are conversant with the details of the various schemes which had to be either abandoned or cut down in the public interest and in the interests of economy. I need not go into them now. But I would like to mention a report which appeared in the press recently in connection with Córas Iompair Éireann. According to that report sight-seeing tours by bus are going to be organised in Dublin. I do not think that should be done until the bus queues are taken off the streets and I would suggest that a much better purpose would be served by those sight-seeing buses if they were put on as auxiliary buses during the rush hours. That is done in other cities. I myself have stood in a bus queue and felt very pleased, indeed, to see a bus come round the corner marked "Auxiliary relief bus"; and half the queue got into that bus. I suggest that use could be made of these proposed sight-seeing buses. It could be arranged quite easily. It is arranged in other cities and I see no reason why Córas Iompair Éireann could not do it here.
We have had some discussion here on the question of tourism. I wonder do we do for this country all the specialised advertising that we ought to do. I wonder is Dublin ever advertised as being the very beautiful Georgian city it is. There are not so many large Georgian cities in the world and we certainly are the only capital city which can claim to be a Georgian city. We have some of the most beautiful Georgian buildings in existence. That is a type of selective advertising that I would suggest to the Tourist Board. "Come to Dublin and see the finest Georgian city in the world." There is no other Georgian city which can touch Dublin and there are a great number of people who are interested in Georgian architecture. There are other forms of specialised advertising which we might do. Many Americans would be interested in certain aspects of Irish life or Irish architecture. That type of advertising should be taken up and these things should be circularised through the agencies.
Another matter in connection with Americans touring continental countries and perhaps coming here via England is, is there any way in which they can be assured of getting sailing tickets during the busy months of July and August or do they have to stand in a queue with other people? There may be some answer to that. I know a number of people have raised that question and I would like to have an answer to it.
Industry and Commerce is a very big Department and a very important Department and I think the Minister has done a very fine job in the last 12 months. I congratulate him warmly on his work and I am glad to see that he is furthering in such an intelligent —for that is the manner in which I think it is being done—way the industrial side of this country. We must have an industrial arm. It keeps our population at home and provides a market for our agriculture. It gives employment. It is vitally necessary to the country in time of war. I congratulate the Minister on what he has done in that respect and for the way in which he has watched over the consumers' interests at the same time.
Comment on this
One of the principal planks of the Republican programme in the old Sinn Fein days was that when we attained national freedom, or even portion of it, whereby we could develop our own industries, that measure of freedom should be utilised in every possible way to develop our national resources. In 1922, I must admit, we did get a certain amount of control so far as certain rights were concerned inasmuch as we could control Departments of State. That gave us liberty also to put into effect the programme of industralising the country but up to 1932, the efforts made in that direction by the Government in power at the time fell very far short of the expectations of those who believed, even before we got that modicum of freedom, that industrial expansion would follow. Nobody believed that in ten years so little would be done. I admit that some new industries were established during that period but, on the other hand some of the old industries that were in existence when the British ruled this country were closed down. I refer to the small flour mills distributed over the country.
In 1932 when Fianna Fáil took over control of the country, they immediately started on a programme of industrialisation. I think it must be admitted—and I am sure every honest Deputy on the other side of the House will admit—that a number of industries were established in a remarkably short space of time. Many of these industries were of vital importance during the emergency in serving the needs of the community when most foreign sources of supply became exhausted. The mills, which, as I have already mentioned were closed during the regime of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government were reopened. We had other industries, such as the manufacture of boots and shoes, established. No doubt some of these were in existence prior to the coming into office of the Fianna Fáil Government but they would have been entirely inadequate to meet the demands made on that industry during the emergency period, had no additional factories been established. Due to the fact that a number of boot and shoe factories were established by the Fianna Fáil Government, we found during the emergency period that every man, woman and child in the country had at least sufficient boots and shoes to wear. That is something we can look back upon with pride. We hope now to look ahead and I hope that the present Minister will put on an extra spurt. In spite of the fact that from time to time he uses threats, as we read in the newspapers, against those engaged in industry, giving the impression by times that he is opposed to the establishment of industries in this country, he at other times, clearly and distinctively admits that he is all out to promote the establishment of further industries in the country.
I am glad to see by to-day's Press that the new Advisory Authority are going into occupation of their premises. I am glad that the Minister accepted the advice tendered to him by Deputy Lemass in his speech on this Estimate. As well as I remember Deputy Larkin tendered the same advice, that he should get this Industrial Advisory Authority going as quickly as possible in order to allay the suspense that apparently exists in the minds of those who are prepared to engage in Irish industry, so that they can see where they are going and what is expected of them. I hope that that authority will not confine their activities to sitting in their offices in Stephen's Green, waiting for the appearance before them of some particular individual seeking for information as to what type of industry can be established in his area, speaking probably on behalf of a number of residents in that area. I hope that this authority will go into their work carefully, deeply and enthusiastically, and from time to time will let the general public know the type of industry that is suitable in this country, with reference probably, if not to counties, at least to provinces, so that people who have money and who are prepared to invest money in Irish industry may have an opportunity of studying the matter and, perhaps, eventually of taking the all-important step whereby an industry could be established in their area.
There was one type of industry that was in a very affluent position before the war and which during the war went to a large extent out of production, an industry, the products of which are of such vital importance to-day when there is a great housing drive on throughout the country. I refer to the natural stone slate industry. Before the emergency, quite a number of slate quarries were distributed all over the country. There was one quite close to my own place but unfortunately that particular quarry happened to be a private concern. In other parts of the country slate quarries were in production and, being interested in building, I often have wondered what happened to some of those quarries during the emergency. I think that the natural covering for any building in this country is slate. I quite agree that in the production of concrete tiles and asbestos slates a certain amount of work is provided, but I think to produce the quantity of slates that would cover a normal building, far more money would be involved by way of labour content than would be involved to cover five buildings of similar size with either asbestos slates or concrete tiles. I would ask the Minister to take a note of my remarks about natural stone slate quarries with a view to putting the matter before the Industrial Advisory Authority in the hope that they could see what could be done with the quarries that have closed down during the emergency to put them back into production. There is one slate quarry in the Minister's own county, Carrick-on-Suir. I discussed the question of the type of slates and the easiest method whereby they could be produced with the manager of that slate quarry, a man who knew the ins and outs of the production of slates, a man who had practical knowledge of a Welsh slate quarry —he is now dead, the Lord have mercy on him—and he informed me that on one occasion he was asked to make a report on that particular quarry. To my surprise, he told me that he could not understand why Carrick-on-Suir slate quarry was not in full production. He gave me to understand that it was probably the easiest quarry in the country out of which to get slate with the least amount of waste.
I do not know what powers the Industrial Advisory Authority may have or whether the Minister is giving them discretionary powers to work on their own, but if he is, I would ask him to bring this question of Irish national slate before them with a view to seeing what could be done to have these quarries reopened. Now that there is a big housing drive on and a number of houses still to be built all over the country by local bodies, private individuals and otherwise, I hope that the country will not be dotted with concrete covering, or with asbestos covering that loses its colour in a few months but that we may be in a position to procure natural Irish slate that can be used here and there and from the scenic point of view have a mixture of all.
Reference has been made by some speakers to the building industry. I took particular interest last Wednesday, I think it was, in the speech of the Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Larkin, particularly in the portion where he referred to the fact that not alone the Minister himself but industrialists and those representing industrialists are continually calling out for greater output in production. Having listened to Deputy Larkin—and I am sorry that he did not develop his point further—I got the impression that there was no use in the Minister or any employer asking for greater output from the worker until such time as the worker had a say in the management and general policy of the industry itself. I would have preferred if Deputy Larkin had developed his points further, as I was thinking in terms of the building industry. That is an industry which has fluctuated from time to time. There is a big drive on at present and everyone engaged in the industry is in full employment; but it will not continue, as we will eventually reach a stage when it must end.
I cannot understand how you could bring in the workers to take part in the management, to define or take part in the general policy and share in the profits. When a building contractor takes on a job, he employs a certain number of men. The Trade Union Congress or other congress, or the representatives of the trade union concerned—the brick and stone layers or the carpenters and joiners, or whatever it may be—have a representative on the management of the business. The ordinary worker, artisan or labourer working there is supposed to get a share in the profits. But before that contractor can ascertain the profits on that particular job, the workman, and probably the individual representative in the management, will be gone to some other place. Therefore, I fail to see how the scheme could operate eventually in the building industry.
If those representing labour want the worker, be he skilled or unskilled, to have his share in the profits of building, what I suggest is an alternative principle. I know it is against the principles of labour, but I have given great thought to this matter and have definitely come to the conclusion that the only way that you can share whatever profits can accrue from a particular building operation is by paying the individual artisan for his output. Deputy Larkin said that if they are not prepared to give the workers a say in the management, in the general policy and a share in the profits, this appeal for greater production can only mean further sweated labour in order to put profits into the hands of the contractor or builder. I say to Deputy Larkin or anyone else who argues like that, that there can be a greater output without any sweat now. Only some 12 months ago there was a building dispute before the Labour Court. One or two contractors or builders concerned gave evidence—which could not be contradicted—that from 1939 to that date the man output per hour in a certain trade in the building line was reduced 40 per cent.
I am speaking as one who has done my day's work, one who knows from practical experience what the average output would be for an individual. In my own particular line in the building business, the output as compared with 1914 is down by well over 50 per cent., in spite of the fact that in 1914 the workers in the provincial towns were doing 60 and 62 hours a week, while now they are down to approximately 48. When I say that the output has been reduced 50 per cent., I am taking into consideration the fact that the hours have been reduced also. It is the output per man-hour that is down. When a man works fewer hours in the day, one would naturally expect that he would be in better form when finishing up, that is, a better man at the end of the eight hours than if he had to do nine or ten as in 1914. Therefore, instead of having a reduction in the output, there should be an increase. However, that is the position and until the workers realise that it is in their own interest to put a little more elbow grease into it, we will not succeed. It is not going to sweat anybody, or anything approaching it.
Comment on this
Did not someone say that it is 50-50 as between the cost of the building materials and the labour content?
Comment on this
It was about 60-40 for a time, but it is about 50-50 now. Until they realise that and put a little more elbow grease into it, the cost of building will remain as it is now or increase further. It could be reduced if the workers would take into consideration the fact that they are working only 44 hours a week, that they have plenty of work before them and that, by putting a little more elbow grease into it, they will help to reduce the cost of housing and thereby reduce the rents to their own class and perhaps even to themselves.
Side by side with that drive for industrial development goes, as we learned in the old days, the development of our mineral resources. I am glad to see that the Minister has agreed to provide a certain sum for exploration to be carried out in the Avoca mines. It is a matter of £120,000, he stated himself. In the past year very little work has been done in that direction. In the early portion of the year, it was apparently the policy of the Government to cut out completely all moneys for exploration work. Evidently they changed their viewpoint and decided to go ahead with a certain amount, but very little has been done. My information is that a start has been made in sinking the shafts at Ballygahan, as suggested, I think, by Professor Jones. However, the pump which had to be used became damaged and I understand it was difficult to procure the necessary parts and the work was held up for some time. I am informed that the work was held up also because certain essential pipes could not be procured. The rumour in the Avoca area is that the money was not available to provide those parts. Some 30 men were employed in sinking this shaft at Ballygahan. There are 40 other men employed in the work also. It was suggested to me that these 40 are not usefully employed on that job in the particular work that they are doing. I take it that, probably due to the pump not being in working order and the parts not been available, or because the pipes could not be secured, there is the possibility that those men were kept going anyhow sooner than let them go off, hoping that the pump and the pipes would be available within a short period. I take it that that is probably the reason why those men are not usefully employed at the moment. I am sorry to have to say it, but that is my information.
With regard to the sinking of this shaft, I understand that Professor Jones, mineralogist, reported on this particular shaft, or generally on the mine area, that if this shaft were sunk 1,000 feet there was every likelihood of a fair amount of ore being found, or a good return. Now, £120,000 is quite a large sum of money, but if the Minister intends to carry out Professor Jones' suggestion to its logical conclusion, he will have to be a little more flaithiúlach and get the Minister for Finance to give a further sum to carry out such important work as this.
I am also informed that, in conjunction with exploration work, a certain amount of development work could be carried on in those mines. I understand that the expenditure of about £4,000 or £6,000 and the provision of a number of cells to the existing floating plant would result in quite an amount of copper, zinc and lead being obtained from the mines at the moment.
At one period it was thought that a proper flotation plant would be secured. I understand that, even during the emergency, when it was hard to get machinery of this type, a gentleman named Keyes, from England, was prepared to sell and transport a plant suitable for the extraction of the lead ores to which I have referred, but those in charge at the time, instead of accepting this offer, had, previously or thereabouts, installed a pilot flotation plant—a plant that is really only for testing purposes and from which nothing could be secured but sulphur. It seems that a certain amount of copper, known as precipitated copper, is going to waste down the river from the mines. I have been told that if this proper flotation plant had been installed and put into operation, with the expenditure referred to and the provision of extra cells, all this waste would be overcome and the mines of the company would benefit, as a result of the segregation of the copper, lead and zinc. We know that sulphur will not bring in a great financial return, but copper, lead and zinc should bring in very great financial return to the mines concerned where the necessary machinery is installed for the extraction of these ores. I am informed that a certain amount of precipitate copper flows away in the streams under some of the existing shafts, and individual miners, if they were in a position to do so, could make a living out of it by throwing ordinary iron into the water, which would collect the copper. I have here a sample piece of iron which was thrown into one of these small streams flowing under the shafts and the copper can be seen collected on it.
I would ask the Minister to investigate the few points I have made in connection with the Avoca mines. I can assure the Minister that the workers are not satisfied that everything that should be done is being done down there. I do not wish the Minister to assume for a moment that that refers either to him or his Department, but they believe that things are not right in Avoca, that the administration is not right. They believe that there is some sinister outside influence working against the best interests of the Avoca mines, and they cited for me as an instance of that when, in sinking shafts, they come to a good vein of ore, that vein is built up and closed up and nothing more is done about it. I have not seen it. I am just giving the Minister the views of the men engaged in the mine. I have spoken to and met deputations of the miners. They are definitely of the opinion, particularly so far as the extraction of ores is concerned, that there is some influence outside this country working against the best interests of the Avoca mines. They suggest that the Minister should send down an engineer and representatives of his Department or members of the Government to the Avoca mines to meet the men there and to discuss all their grievances with them. I can assure the Minister that I am putting the position to him exactly as I have it from the men and I believe that the men are genuinely interested, and should be genuinely interested, in the development of the mines. Perhaps the Minister would see his way, as a result of the statement I have made, to comply with their wish and send down an engineer and representatives of the Government to go into the question of the administration, etc., of the Avoca mines.
I wish now to refer to the question of harbours. I am particularly interested in Arklow harbour. As the Minister has said, it is one of the harbours on which a big repair job is about to be started. We understand that work should be in full swing in a very short period. The port of Arklow will develop and benefit from the work of the Department and those carrying out the necessary repairs. In addition to repairs being carried out, the dock walls will be extended and, for its size, it will be a very fine harbour when the work is completed. There is one unfortunate snag, to which I referred on the Vote for Fisheries, that is, the silting of the bar. The harbour commissioners find themselves mulcted financially every year to a very large extent in having to contribute their share of the moneys expended in keeping the bar of Arklow dredged. They felt the strain so much that eventually they decided to ask for expert opinion with a view to having a report submitted as to the reasonable chances of carrying out certain works by way of extension to the piers or otherwise in order to avoid the silting of the harbour which occurs perhaps two, three and four times a year. A preliminary examination has already taken place with that expert. My reason for mentioning it is that we have good hopes that something definite may evolve as a result of a further survey and that a scheme may be put up whereby the dredging will be eliminated to the extent that perhaps it will only need to be done once in every four years. If that can be done it will be a great relief, from the point of view of finance, to the harbour commissioners and it will be a great relief to the Department of Industry and Commerce and to the Board of Works which particular Departments put up their share every year. What I want to ask is that if that scheme develops, the Minister will, when it comes before him, take a broad view of it and, in coming to a decision, take into consideration the fact that for years and years the harbour commissioners have hardly been able to meet their financial responsibilities. In giving his blessing to the scheme, the Minister will be doing a good day's work for the people of Arklow, for the fishermen of Arklow and for those foreign people who occasionally have to bring their boats into the harbour of Arklow. He will be doing for all those people a good day's work and he will be relieving the commissioners of quite an exceptionally bad headache.
Comment on this
While it is generally appreciated that agriculture is the major industry of this country it is also accepted that it is necessary to have industry as an adjunct to it. It is, therefore, essential that the Minister in charge of that important branch of our industry should be fully aware of his responsibility and it is also well to note, from the interest taken in this debate in the last few days, that it is obvious that the Deputies are very conscious of the necessity for the Department of Industry and Commerce and for the discharge by that Department of its essential duties in this regard. Many suggestions have been made as to how the Minister's industrial programme can best be directed. Large industries are mentioned; State control, where necessary, is advised, as also the speedy erection of houses for the workers and for the growing population of the City of Dublin. As to these proposals in general, I must assert that I hold quite contrary views.
The men who advocate industrial development should turn their eyes from the big centres of population. If the Minister responsible believes that special facilities should be given for the erection of houses in the city of Dublin or other large centres of population, he is wrong and he is taking a wrong course. There are already far too many people living in our chief cities and no facilities whatever should be offered to encourage more people to come to these cities. So long as our line of policy is to continue the centralisation of our industries so long will we centralise and concentrate on more and more people coming to our cities. My plan is definitely one in the opposite direction. I ask the Minister and his Department to experiment in regard to the possibility of rural industries. Great play is made in the newspapers about the public concern in regard to the exodus of our people to foreign countries. From where are these people emigrating? Not from the large centres of population but from the rural areas. I forecast, and I am reasonably sure that the forecast will prove to be correct, that when the next census is taken the Government of this country, whatever Government may be in office then—and the people responsible—will be astounded at the diminution of the rural population. It may be that this problem of keeping the people in the country will present many difficulties. If the problem were not difficult it would not exist. If our industries are to make themselves worth-while to the nation they will have to develop to the point of finding an export market for their products. Otherwise, in some respects, we have reached the point of saturation. Is it possible and is it within the reasonable reach of things as we know them that our industries will be able to find an export market in competition with outside countries? Personally I do not think so. I have yet to meet the men in industry in this country who say that they are expecting to reach that stage. They give good solid reasons for not being able to do so. The volume of their business is limited. In most cases they have to import the raw materials. Their workers are practically inexperienced as compared with outsiders, and the machines they operate are comparatively small. All these are factors which operate against them. Where, then, is the reasonable prospect of finding an export market for our industries to-day? We import a lot of products manufactured in outside countries. If it were not for the fact that these products are limited by quota or are subject to tariff I am afraid that our local industries would have a difficulty in competing against them, even in the home market, and of maintaining their status. With all that disadvantage, then, as we see it, where is the prospect of our factories finding an outside market?
Comment on this
Would that increase have been in any way the result of the extraordinary circumstances which prevailed in the world in the last few years? The Minister thinks not. I am glad to know that.
Comment on this
Did the Minister say that whiskey and stout were involved in the industrial exports?
Comment on this
Not to a very great extent in the increase. They are always a very valuable part of our exports, but we certainly did not increase whiskey and stout exports by £2,000,000 over 1947. The increase was very largely due to the trade agreement negotiated in 1948.
Comment on this
I am delighted to know that the prospect of selling our goods in outside markets is very good. It is really a credit to the industries concerned. There is, however, the fact that all these industries have in no way stemmed the emigration from the countryside. I must draw the attention of the Minister to his responsibility to the countryside to see that it is not stripped of the most valuable asset that God has given us, namely, human beings. Look at the west of Ireland. What have Governments done for us? What employment have they given us? What has become of our people for the last 25 years since native government was established here? There has been a continued flow of people from the countryside and that flow is not to the city of Dublin or any of the industrial towns to any extent. There is definitely emigration from the western seaboard. There is a responsibility there which cannot be met by saying that we are doing fairly well. We are not doing well. We are going fast to ruin.
What is the prospect for the average family on a small farm in Leitrim. Sligo, Donegal, part of Cavan or Galway? None whatever. There may be five in family on a farm of £10 valuation. There is not any human feeling in the minds of people who say that these people should stay at home. They cannot stay at home. They could not marry and bring up a family. They must find an outlet. When they have no means of occupation in their own locality, do they come to Dublin or Dundalk or any of the other industrial towns? Not at all. The trade unions would not allow them to get a job if they came up here. They are debarred; they are like lepers in their own country. They cannot get a living at home and they must leave the country. That is the policy which is in operation. The Government must see that some steps are taken to deal with it before it is too late.
The position is so serious that the Government should declare a state of national emergency and deal with this question of emigration rather than going around glibly discussing the prospects of an industry here and an industry there. Industry should be placed in the thickly populated centres of rural Ireland where a person working in an industry however small can leave his home in the morning, come back at the end of the day's work and come home on Friday with his wages in his pocket. That is the kind of industry that is needed. Let us stop this notion about our trade unions and trade union regulation of wages. Leave these people in the countryside in their own atmosphere and let them follow out their own plan of energetic work and they will produce specialised goods. I do not suppose they can operate machines in a large way which can compete with factory work. Surely it is not beyond the bounds of ingenuity for the Department and its experts to develop some scheme of specialised products that our country boys and girls, who are very apt with their hands and are very clever, can produce and for which a market can be found in countries outside. I emphasise the necessity for turning our minds from centralisation and big industries and saving our people in the rural areas. With all our industries and our protection we have done nothing more than to make life more difficult for people in the west because of the increase in the cost of living without any corresponding increase in the income of these people. Consequently emigration is the only outlet.
I am very glad that the Minister has set up this industrial authority to investigate industrial concerns. There are many things which they could usefully investigate. In the near future I anticipate that the Government will be bringing in a Bill dealing with transport. I suggest that the first consideration in that regard is that the Minister should see that the transport facilities for the conveyance of industrial and agricultural commodities to and from the remotest parts of the country should be as cheap to those who live 50 or 100 miles from the centres of population as those within 15 or 20 miles of them. That may seem difficult to do. It may require State aid. But, if we are going to develop industry, we must provide cheap transport facilities. There is no use in saying that that would cost the State too much. For the last 40 years transport has cost this State in the form of shareholders losses of money and subsidisation by subsequent Government interference, sums running into millions of pounds. If transport is to be nationalised let it be national transport that will bring facilities to the remotest parts of the country and give equal facilities to those living at the extreme ends of the country as well as those within 15 or 20 miles of the cities and towns. Cheap transport is the essential thing.
I trust this new industrial authority will pay attention to another potential source of national wealth which has only been explored in a very limited way so far, that is our mineral wealth. I know that one can talk very widely about the possibility of mineral wealth. I know we shall hear the old story that after all possible exploration has been carried out the result is negative. People will say, "We know the reason why it is negative—because the people who did the exploration did not want to let it be known that there were immense resources down there." I know that many areas which it was thought contained mineral wealth proved on examination to be devoid of minerals. Yet there are many deposits, perhaps not so extensive as we would like them to be, not so rich and valuable as we would wish, still existing.
In my part of the country there are clays of different kinds and of very good quality which could very well be turned commercially into valuable glazed brick and glazed earthenware, for which a market could be found, I am sure. They have the advantage of being adjacent to an area where coal is produced, which is so essential in the turning of these clays. That is one industry that I know does exist and I direct the attention of the Minister and his new committee of investigation to the examination of that at the earliest moment with a view to seeing what can be done. There is also in that part of the country stone used for sharpening purposes. That is another deposit, the facts of which are very well known to the Department. I recommend that the board to be set up by the Minister should look into the matter and do what is necessary, if further exploration is required, so that these jobs could be undertaken at the earliest moment. I mention these because of the great importance of industry if the life of the people in the West of Ireland is to be maintained.
I do not know that I could find words hard enough to express what I consider to be the complete neglect by successive Governments of that area in the north-west. Not the smallest regard has been had to the welfare of those people in so far as providing them with an alternative occupation to that which they have and their predecessors always had recourse to—the ship that took them to the United States of America or the boat that took them to England or Scotland. It is a downright shame that those responsible for it, those who held the reins of office and who had the power to do something, neglected to do their duty. Let the responsibility rest upon them. I trust the Minister will do something to bring about better hope and prospects to those distressed people who showed courage and made an existence out of what nature was willing to yield.
A suggestion was made here by one of the speakers, Deputy Connolly, about labour having a share in the control of industry. I think it would be ideal. I see nothing wrong at all in it. I see no revolutionary project in that. I can see labour in harness with industry in this country with great advantage to industry generally. One of the most damning things in the whole scheme of industry is people going into industry with the one purpose of capitalising and making plenty of money out of it. The valuable thing about industry is that it should be gauged from a national and Christian point of view. Let industry be the means of producing national wealth. Let us produce more that way and let the wealth belong to the nation. It is bound to belong to the nation. If we ever want to reach the stage where we can compete successfully with outside countries such as England we will have to produce more.
If the means suggested of having labour representatives on our boards is the way of doing it—and I believe it could help—then I am all for it. If labour participates in the management, labour will have to participate in the profits. They will also have to participate in the losses, naturally, and if a lean period comes they will have to be prepared to accept a lower wage or to allow contributions from their wages, or by extra hours of work, to go into the capital and to subsidise the industry. Let them take and give and give in full and take in full and within these limits. If some proposal could be hammered out by which labour would have a say in industrial management it would be all for the good of industry. I would be very glad to see such proposals put forward and actively operated.
I should like to make a small proposal as regards the western area. I mentioned the development of clay and of sharpening stone. Bogs in the West of Ireland have never had a chance since the hand-won turf scheme ceased. Why not concentrate on those bogs in the West of Ireland where the best workmen in the world are, the most willing workers? Why not concentrate with those small machines that are in operation in the midlands where bog areas are so big? The Minister complained about the difficulty of finding workers for his major bog production plants. It is true. The moment you centralise any industry and try to take men from their homes from a wide area and put them in one centre you are bound to have difficulty. Let the men be employed so far as possible, leaving their home in the morning and returning in the evening and bringing back their pay cheque on Friday to their homes. Develop the bog areas with the machines as unlimited markets because you can always limit the outside supply of coal from England and elsewhere. Why will you allow unemployment and emigration from the West of Ireland while those bogs are lying there and you have machines on which you can put these men to work? There is a complete neglect on the part of the Minister in that regard.
We all make strong appeals to the various Ministers when their Estimates come before us. If we want to morally justify ourselves with the public we will have to tell them more straightforwardly what the conditions and circumstances are. Every time we appeal to the Minister and to the Government for more money for this and for that and say: "If I were in your place I would do so much better," we are failing in our duty here. That is only sheer dishonesty. There is no means by which a Minister or Government can subsidise any industry or scheme other than by taxation. However, by the implications that go on between Parties we are leading the public to believe that the Minister and the Government have the power of making money without interfering with anybody's pocket or source of income whatever. It is all immoral and wrong. We should tell the people straightforwardly that it is not politics that does things in the way of finding money or resources of that sort. If we demand money we must be prepared to take it in increased contributions from the taxpayer.
There is no use whatever in any Party in this House or any individual saying that they have a monopoly of good intentions and capacity to do things better than another. There is not a man in this House, I would say, but means well. There is not a man or a Party who would not like to see the country progress. Why, then, all this crying from bench to bench in implications that you are not doing as well as you should or as well as I would. That is not right. Different Parties may have different plans but any Party in office, even if it were only from a selfish point of view, would naturally like to do the best it could to satisfy the country and thereby get into favour. The pulling together of all Parties and the laying aside of Party criticism on this economic question would, to my mind, do more to further the projects that we have in view than any amount of criticism between Parties inside this House and outside.
I say to the Minister that I appreciate his effort in so far as this new board is concerned. I and others may expect too much from them but in any case if he makes them do their job, if they direct industry in a better manner than it has been directed hitherto, and if it means that they will specialise in providing employment in the West of Ireland then I would say he has done a good job and God bless the men who have made efforts in that direction—they have done a faithful and very useful piece of work.
Comment on this
I am disappointed with this Vote because I was expecting very big things from the brains of the inter-Party Government in view of all the promises they made to us some time ago. I find that there is nothing very strange in it. The only change that I see in it is that the inter-Party Government are adopting some of the schemes that were initiated by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
They are adopting schemes that had already been initiated by that much-despised Party known as Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
We were to have a number of grandiose schemes. In fact, I was contemplating that, when the Minister introduced his Estimate, we were going to hear something that would put everyone in the country working, and that, from the joint brains of Clann na Poblachta, Labour the Farmers and Fine Gael, we were going to get some original plan that would make this one of the grandest countries in the world in which to live.
Comment on this
On a point of order. This is a deliberative Assembly, and can it be reduced to the state of a cross-roads meeting?
Comment on this
I am more or less concerned with the policy of this Department and I am just expressing my disappointment that more original and more concise plans for the workers as a whole have not been mentioned during this debate. I am very sorry that Deputy Cowan could not listen to hear the truth and that he has to go.
Comment on this
This Vote is very disappointing to the unemployed. There is nothing very encouraging in it for a man who is out of employment. As far as it is concerned, the only thing for him is the emigrant ship again. I realise that a certain amount of protection is being given to certain of our industries. The Minister has stated that our export trade has increased. I should like to hear from him on what developed product we have increased our export trade. I know we have reached the position that certain of our manufactured articles are being exported. We should like to see more of them exported.
I have heard a lot of talk here in the last few days about the unemployed. Some people have stated that they should be asked to work and forced to work. Other Deputies have given an explanation as to why they could not work or do certain jobs in certain industries, State-subsidised and otherwise. A few explanations have been given on these lines. The last speaker said that a man who is unemployed and is living with his wife and family in a certain area does not like to be asked to go to a place that is a long way from home. It is possible that one is bound to come up against that sort of thing. I do not see why certain unemployed men should be asked to take on work that they have not been used to. We hear a good deal about vocationalism. As far as we were concerned, we tried to fit into our everyday lives, our vocational system, those workers who were best fitted for certain employment. We thought that they should get the opportunity of going into it. It is a big State matter. The Minister, when introducing the Estimate, did not say anything regarding this very much-discussed subject at the moment. If we are going to threaten our unemployed, then we are not carrying on according to ordinary democratic principles to which we hear so much lip-service given from time to time here. I have heard of a number of our workers being threatened that they will have to produce more. The only way in which I can see that they will be encouraged to do so is when some of our manufacturers, who are in a position to do so, will carry on industry in the same way as successful manufacturers are doing in other countries. I read recently a fine paper by a very eminent Irish clergyman, in which he said that the surest way to have stabilised conditions in industry was by making the workers profitshares in it. If that were done, he said, they would take a special interest in the industry in which they were employed. I subscribe to that view. If things are going well, I believe that the workers should get a share of the profits. If we are to carry on in this State, according to ordinary Christian principles, which we all idealise so much, then our workers should have the opportunity of taking part in the management of industry. When things are going well they should get their share of the profits, and if things are not going well, then, as Deputy Maguire said, they should take the rap. The position should be the same for them as for the directors of the firm.
Comment on this
I believe that, if we had the co-operative spirit in industry, we would get somewhere. Some of our industries have tried that system successfully. It is a great encouragement to any worker when he realises that the more work he turns out the more he is going to get.
Comment on this
I am expressing my own views. The Deputy will have an opportunity of making his contribution to the debate. I believe that a lot of the misunderstandings, the strikes and other things that go on in industrial concerns are due to the feeling that the people at the top are making all the profits, while the people who produce the goods are not getting a fair share of the profits. I believe that if our industrialists could see the other point of view, it would be good for themselves and the country, and would help to counteract the effect of the "isms" that are being preached by people in the East. We would be building up the foundations of an ordinary, decent, Christian State where the people will work in one great co-operative movement.
There are certain industries that have adopted pension schemes. We have reached the point where, in the State service, the service of the local authority, the service of the railway and so on, small pensions or large pensions, according to years of service, are awarded to workers. I do not see why all industries should not make an effort to provide for their workers when those workers gave years of faithful service. It is up to employers to take a special interest in the welfare of the worker. I must pay a high compliment to certain industries in my own constituency where there is a Christian atmosphere adopted regarding pension schemes, canteens and medical service. I should like to see those things developed more and more, and instead of threatening the workers to produce more and driving them along, much better results can be achieved by encouraging them.
Comment on this
This comes under that very much discussed topic—more production. I am only giving my views on how production can be increased.
Comment on this
I do not see any relation between canteens and pension schemes and more production. I do not see what the Minister can do. I do not see that there is any money provided in the Estimate or what control the Minister has in this connection.
Comment on this
I agree he has no direct control and is not a partner in any of these firms, but as Minister for Industry and Commerce he has a right to see that a firm will run its business along certain lines.
Comment on this
There are lots of things the Minister could do or would like to do, but has he power to do them?
Comment on this
I will go away from that point if you do not permit me to develop it. My submission is that the Minister has power to send an inspector to see that a factory is conducted according to law.
Comment on this
I am dealing with industry and production and I will not go away from these subjects. We have asked our workers to increase production. We have different factories and workshops where the workers are asked to increase production. Certain encouragement is being given both to industrialists and workers to do certain things. We have reached the stage when the Minister and other responsible people are complaining about low production in industry. I have mentioned the statement made by an eminent clergyman some time ago, that he believed in industrialists sharing profits with their workers. In my opinion that is the solution of the whole problem. If that were done it would improve conditions in this country; it would be responsible for helping our country; it would put down bitterness and cut out misunderstandings and it would help both employer and employee to work for their own individual benefit and for the benefit of the country as a whole. Where this has been practised in other countries it has been successful. It is a principle that should be adopted by all industrialists who are in a position to do it. Under that policy they could increase production for their own benefit and for the welfare of the nation.
Comment on this
As regards mineral exploration, there is very little in this Estimate to encourage us in the belief that anything worth while will be carried out during the coming year, notwithstanding that the emergency is over and the Minister has had a very prosperous year in other directions. I was expecting the Minister would do more along this particular line. It is most disappointing to me that he is not doing more to develop our mineral resources. Many people were anticipating that he would do something worth while. I thought his friends who make up the inter-Party Government would contribute something to encourage the Minister to proceed with that very necessary work in order to see what minerals we have, where they are and what they are worth. He has a good opportunity now because times have improved and there is nothing to stop him. Is he prepared to do anything in the coming year?
Comment on this
Would I bring any joy to the Deputy's heart if I tell him that there will be more mineral development in the coming year than at any time since the State was founded?
Comment on this
The Minister and his colleagues in the Government were handed over this country in a most stable condition.
Comment on this
When this Government took up office the credit of the country was very high and everything was left ready for the Minister to do something worth while. If the Minister has the mind to go ahead with mineral exploration he has a grand opportunity now. I hope he will think of the people in rural Ireland. With all respect to his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, he has forgotten those people and they are running to the factories that this Minister is trying to keep open around the towns. I am concerned about the unemployment that exists in rural Ireland. Every day I am meeting unemployed persons and I ask the Minister favourably to consider doing something for those people. As it is, the Minister for Agriculture is gradually running them out of the country. If the Minister is not prepared to consider this matter seriously as Minister for Industry and Commerce it is going to be a very poor lookout for the country. The only outlook we shall have is watching our people emigrate day after day. I am deeply concerned about another industry. I mentioned it on another Vote; It is connected with the possibility of keeping more of our people on the land. The Minister for Industry and Commerce deals with the export side of this industry. It is subsidiary to our dairying industry. The Minister deals with cheese, cream, dried milk and butter. I know that he only deals with the export trade in these commodities.
Comment on this
Any questions I have put down with regard to these matters have always been referred to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He is responsible for the export of them, if they are exported.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister for Industry and Commerce has any responsibility for the export of agricultural produce.
Comment on this
If he has not, then the whole position is hopeless because I tried to reason with the Minister for Agriculture and he never replied to me but merely abused me personally.
Comment on this
This is too serious a matter to be put on one side. I have made a study of what that industry has done for the people in other countries. I am here pleading on behalf of the unemployed in rural Ireland. I welcome any scheme responsible for keeping our people at home. I have pleaded with another Minister in relation to this industry. I bow to your ruling since I cannot go ahead with it now. Anything that will be done to improve the lot of the people in the rural areas will be welcomed by me.
During the year I had a number of questions here to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and a correspondence with him too with reference to the paper industry in Clondalkin. That matter has now been settled to the satisfaction of all parties. I am sure the Minister will hold a watching brief for that industry in the future, and I am sure he will do anything he can to keep the people employed therein the Clondalkin and Killeen paper mills in continuous employement.
There is another matter with which I wish to deal. I have here a letter from a representative of the workers in the Balbriggan hosiery factory. He says that he is writing on behalf of the workers of Smith & Company. He says:—
"The position here is very bad with reference to unemployment and short time and, worse still, there seems to be no bright hope for the future. The actual position is very serious as many other workers will be laid off and as stock cannot or will not be added to."
That unfortunate, misguided man was a member of the Clann na Poblachta Party during the last election.
Comment on this
"How can there be any prospect for a brighter future when things are so bad here? On January 22, 1948, a tariff of 25 per cent. was imposed on clothing and hosiery and on May 11, 1949, the tariff was increased for men's and boys' clothing." I was dealing with that factory during the year and with some other factories too. I see the Minister has dealt with it. "But there was no further increase in tariff for hosiery." The complaint is that a number of the workers are on short time in Balbriggan. I will give the Minister the letter and he can question the author of it if he likes. I received the letter this morning. I do not know the man at all, as a matter of fact.
Comment on this
Because I was told by a friend of mine that he was a member of the Clann na Poblachta Party and an ardent supporter of it.
Comment on this
I was looking after that factory before you came into public life and I am looking after it still; and I will look after the tomato-growers in County Dublin too.
Comment on this
Is it true that several tanneries are not doing so well at the moment and that we may be faced with the prospect of a shortage of leather? Can the Minister give me any information on that? Is it true that we are exporting some of our hides? I have been given to understand that such is the case. I am looking for information on this point since I do not know of my own knowledge whether that is so or not. If we are exporting hides then the position is serious.
The Minister went to America some time ago looking for tourists. What encouragement will this new Tourist Board give to tourists? Are all the Parties on the Government Benches now converted to the idea that the tourist industry was not such a bad industry after all? It was cried down at one time and then suddenly one of those who had condemned it most vehemently on the hustings and at the chapel gates goes down to open one of the tourist industries and states that it is worth £35,000,000 to this country. It is surprising how he was able to contradict himself after gaining a little knowledge. But when a man succeeds in contradicting himself, he is not too bad after all. I hope that he is now sincerely convinced that the tourist industry is well worth while, and I want to know from the Minister what he is doing to encourage it.
Comment on this
Surely it is not Deputy Rooney who is interrupting me again. I want to know what part our representatives abroad are playing in encouraging the tourist industry? What are we doing to improve our hotels? This is a very important industry because it brings us in much-needed dollars. We lost an excellent opportunity when we scrapped our Constellation planes. Posterity will judge this Government for that. Those planes were bought after judicious consideration by a competent Government. That step was taken in the interests of the nation, and not in the interests of any particular Party, in order to put us in the position of balancing our dollar exchange. We would have been responsible then for bringing our exiles back to visit their homeland with much needed dollars.
Comment on this
I want to know whether the vilification carried on by the gentlemen opposite against the tourist industry has ended. I want to know what you have done to counter that campaign——
Comment on this
Other countries have been very anxious to encourage this industry. They have realised that tourists are an asset to any country they visit inasmuch as they consume any surplus produce and thus obviate the necessity for exporting it. Even the Tánaiste said when he opened Butlin's Camp that the tourist industry was worth £35,000,000 in this country. We have now reached the time when I should like to see a good deal more energetic work put into the creation of a special Department to deal with our export trade. I know that trade agreements have been entered into with certain countries. That is one aspect of our economic life that should not be lost sight of by our representatives abroad and by the Minister himself as he is chiefly concerned with matters connected with industry generally. I want to know what encouragement he is going to give to the expansion of our export trade.
I have heard a good deal about our mercantile marine service. Is it the Minister's intention to carry on the good work already initiated with reference to our mercantile marine service? Is the present Government going to continue the good work initiated by Fianna Fáil and are we going to have this country in the same position as other maritime countries of its size, with its own boats plying between this country and other countries throughout the world? I hope that every encouragement will be given to Irish Shipping Limited to have ships built here at home so that we shall not find ourselves again in the position in which we were when the war broke out, dependent on other countries.
Comment on this
It is very easy for Deputies on the other side to say "hear, hear." There is a very feasible explanation for that.
Comment on this
During the years that Fianna Fáil were in office they tried to do what they could for the people of this country and they succeeded.
Comment on this
I shall pass away from the ships at the moment and come to the harbours. One very vexed question in this country is the question of coast erosion. I am told it is the bailiwick of no Government Department.
Comment on this
If I went down to where I live and brought a shovel and bucket with me and started to take gravel from the strand, the Minister for Industry and Commerce would be down on top of me.
Comment on this
The Chair is prepared to rule that it is caused by some power outside the control of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and there is no money in this Estimate to deal with it.
Comment on this
On the contrary, I submit that the Minister is responsible for the administration of the Foreshore Act and the removal of gravel from the foreshore is under his supervision.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce is concerned with the foreshore and I want to know if the Minister has power, as I contend he has, under the Foreshore Act, to stop people from removing gravel from the beach.
Comment on this
He should also be concerned in trying to protect the land because, as far as I understand, he is the only Minister who is deeply concerned with the foreshore.
Comment on this
I think if the Deputy wanted to discuss coast erosion and the Foreshore Act, he should give us the Short Title of the Act.
Comment on this
I have just about two more years to do and I shall be able to talk to you after that. This is a very serious matter. It is so serious that unless the Minister for Industry and Commerce gives it his immediate attention and sees what can be done about it, we shall reach a time when coast erosion will develop to very serious proportions. We have coast erosion in various parts of the country but I am concerned primarily with the constituency of County Dublin.
Comment on this
If the Deputy repeats himself much further along these lines, I shall be tempted to offer him a bucket and spade.
Comment on this
That is what I am endeavouring to establish, that if I did take a bucket and spade the Minister would be inclined to prosecute.
Comment on this
In dealing with this point I hope that the Minister will consider going a little further than the shore in future and think of the land that has been washed down into the sea. At points by Skerries, Balbriggan, Rush, Donabate and Malahide there has been very serious coast erosion and various representations have been made from time to time about it.
I am concerned also with the decision of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to increase the fares on the buses. I agree, of course, and concede to him that he was in a position where he had to do something, but the fact remains that he has made it very hard for a number of our people. I am dealing specifically with school children because they have been hit very hard. If we are to have regard for the education of the children of Ireland that is a matter that this Government or some future Government will have to consider. On numerous occasions fathers and mothers have come to me and pointed out what the increased fare has meant to them per week and it is a very serious thing. On a few occasions they have told me that they will have to keep their children from school altogether and I can easily realise that. When a good father and mother are doing the best they can for their children and spending as much as their small income allows, when the last penny is counted, what is their position when they have to pay 1/-, 2/- or 3/- more per week? I think the Minister and the Government made up of allegedly sympathetic Labour, Clann and so on should seriously consider doing something for the parents and children to whom I have referred.
Certain harbours come into the bailiwick of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and, as well as looking after shipping interests, he should also look after the harbours and see what can be done with them.
With regard to applications for factories, has the Minister considered sending some of them to the rural parts of the country or are all the factories to be centralised round the cities and large towns? Other Deputies have referred to the decentralisation of factories and industry as a whole and I do not see why the Minister with the opportunities given to him should not encourage decentralisation. I forgot one point when speaking about factories before. When a Minister of State refers to certain manufacturers, I do not think he should take it upon himself to defame and, if I might say so, to blackguard a number of them. If any man in this country—as I have told the Minister for Agriculture before—let him be a manufacturer or anything else, has done anything wrong the judicial system of this State is there and the courts are there. I think it comes badly from a Minister of State to take advantage of this House——
Comment on this
I am dealing with a Minister who did make irresponsible statements about people who are respected in the State and who have made a contribution during the emergency to it. I feel that it is not fair that they should be defamed. If one or two erred, then that one or two should be brought to justice, but all the people concerned should not be defamed by any Minister. Since I have been here I have defended that theory from this side of the House and from the other side of the House. If a man is guilty, the courts are there, but when a Minister of State says that certain manufacturers have done something and should be put inside closed thick walls, I say that that Minister of State is taking advantage of his position, not to the credit of the State or of the country as a whole and not as an encouragement to people who would invest money in industry—what we want—and help the country in every way possible. Having made these remarks I will say no more.
Comment on this
The principle of protection for Irish industry does not now need any advocate, but the application of the principle calls for comment and I appreciate that the Minister has a serious responsibility in the matter of affording protection to Irish industrialists. I do not want to be misunderstood. I am all for fostering Irish industry, but I do not want to take up the attitude that is taken up in the monthly magazine, Irish Industry, that every Irish industrialist is a saint, that he has never erred and that the present Minister for Industry and Commerce can never make a sensible statement about Irish industry and Irish industrialists. If people get assistance from the State, the State obviously has a perfect right to exercise a great measure of control over the people so assisted. I think there is nobody in this House who will deny that some people and some industrialists accumulated to themselves excessive profits during the war years. Reading Irish Industry, one would get the impression that it is a very wrong thing to say that. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has said it and I commend him for saying it. Gross profits have been made. I have this complaint to make about certain Irish industrialists, apart now from those who, by manipulating balance sheets, by the issue of bonus shares and by other tricks, were able to conceal profits. There are some Irish industrialists, and people connected with them and they are not very concerned about supporting other Irish industries. In one particular case I know of a man who is interested in a number of Irish concerns getting protection from the Irish State and who had occasion to write to me recently on a number of matters. Each time I got a letter from him the paper bore a British watermark.
Comment on this
Crown bond or some-think like that—certainly not Swift-brook bond. I was speaking not long ago to an industrialist who has recently got an increase in the tariff on his goods and I happened to see on his office table a high quality British made paper, used as his letter heading. This paper question has caused me a good deal of concern, as we are not Irish industry-minded regarding the use of paper. I do not know if even the notepaper supplied to Deputies and Senators is made in Ireland. I hope it is, but as a matter of interest I held it up to the light recently to see if it had an Irish watermark and I could not discern any watermark. I would like to get the Minister's assurance that it is made in Ireland.
That leads me to the question of our publications and the absolute prohibition there is on our sending them into England. It is time to take very definite action to prevent the flooding of this country with British publications. I am not given to reading English dailies or English Sunday papers, but a few weeks ago I could not get a Sunday Independent and I bought an English paper instead.
Comment on this
I did. I was very sorry I spent 2d. on it. If Deputy Lemass does not see any difference between some of the English Sunday papers and the Sunday Independent, I am sorry for him.
Comment on this
The English Sunday papers are a little more friendly to Deputy Lemass's point of view.
Comment on this
The Minister would be doing tremendous benefit to the country if he would exercise the power he has to the extent of absolute prohibition of many of those publications.
On the question of the organisation of industry and the place of the workers in industrial concerns, I was very interested in Deputy Ben Maguire's contribution and in that of Deputy P.J. Burke. I agree altogether with what those two Deputies said regarding giving to the workers in industrial undertakings a share in the profits. That idea is in accordance with the pronouncements in the Papal Encyclicals Rerum Novarum and Quadragesimo Anno. It is laid down there that workers are entitled to a just share in the profits and even to a say in the management of the business. I happen to have Quadragesimo Anno here. Paragraph 61 says:—
"Every effort therefore must be made that at least in future a just share only of the fruits of production be permitted to accumulate in the hands of the wealthy, and that an ample sufficiency be supplied to the workers."
Paragraph 73 says:—
"Let employers, therefore, and employed join in plans and efforts to overcome all difficulties and obstacles, and let them be aided in this wholesome endeavour by the wise measures of the public authority. In the last extreme, counsel must be taken whether the business can continue, or whether some other provision should be made for the workers. The guiding spirit in this crucial decision should be one of mutual understanding and Christian harmony between employers and workers."
I mention that because Deputy Burke said that when profits are good the workers should have their share and when they are bad the workers should take the rap. That does not seem to me to be the spirit of the Papal Encyclical. It says that by all means the workers should get their just share when profits are good and when times are bad the State should help them.
What I am leading up to is that the Minister can exercise his right to control every industrial concern that he backs. He can very easily extend that control to a provision in the memorandum or articles of association to the effect that, after provision from the profits for a certain percentage to the shareholders, there will be, step by step as the share profits grow, a bonus to the workers as well. If that were done, it would be a very effective means of helping the Minister to put into effect his abjuration to the workers to put more effort into more production. It is unreasonable and unnatural to ask a man to work harder and produce more without giving some hope to that man of being able to get something more for the increased effort. We must hold out some practical incentive to the worker. It seems to me that that would be a practical and fair means and, for what it is worth, I give it to the Minister. Certainly, I would be very pleased to see him putting it into effect so far as coming industries are concerned.
The objection might be made that people would not invest in these industries at all or be anxious to put their money into them. I am confident, however, that there are sufficient people in this country who have the money and who have confidence in this State and to whom State guarantees would be a sufficient inducement to invest their moneys in Irish industry for a fair return. I know we have people who want to get rich quick, but the vast majority of our people are nationally-minded and will co-operate with the Minister in an industrial policy of that kind. Money can be found if the guarantees are given.
I do not know what function the Industrial Development Authority would have in that particular connection, but I welcome it, and particularly for the reason that it shows that the Minister is a modest man. As Deputy Lemass said in his opening speech for the Opposition, the Minister does not hold himself out as somebody who knows everything about everything. I do not know if those were his exact words, but that was the gist of them. His move in setting up this authority shows that he appreciates that he does not know everything and that is a very healthy sign in a man. I did not have the opportunity of listening to the Minister's opening speech, nor to the speech made by Deputy Lemass, but I had the advantage of reading them over the week-end and I feel it only right to say that I was heartened by the note of optimism in the Minister's speech, and, while I am throwing bouquets at all, I might say that I thought that, from the point of view of the Opposition, the contribution made by Deputy Lemass was very commendable indeed.
Comment on this
This Estimate, to my mind, is very important because the Department of Industry and Commerce is concerned, either directly or indirectly, with every other Department of State and every phase of our economic life. The Minister in his opening statement mentioned the gross decrease in his Estimate and explained that a certain amount of it had been transferred to other Departments. He said that there was a net decrease of £3,735,965, but that decrease was mainly on food and fuel subsidies. A decrease in an Estimate looks nice. It shows that the cost of administration is being brought down, but that is not so in relation to this Estimate because the decrease is mainly on subsidies. A decrease also looks well because it shows a lowering of taxation, but I am one of those who do not believe in the lowering of taxation, because, as was mentioned by Deputy Maguire, if a Government contemplates carrying out schemes and has been asked to carry out schemes, the money has to be provided, and, when the Minister was able to show a decrease of almost £3,800,000, I should have imagined that he would devote it to industrial expansion and to employment expansion.
He may try to make it appear that he has done and is doing a lot in that way, but unfortunately I cannot agree with him. The figures on the unemployment register have been fairly static and the number of unemployed is given as 70,000. That total of 70,000 is made up of a number of classes, males and females, and of workers who could be termed skilled workers, but the main problem confronting the Minister at the moment is the problem of the unskilled workers who constitute the vast majority of the unemployed. Statements have been made to the effect that this system was brought in by Fianna Fáil for political Party purposes, but I cannot understand the logic behind that, because, if Fianna Fáil were out to serve their own political Party purposes, they would not introduce this system, because the concealing of the unemployment figures is more to the advantage of a Party than the revealing of them. This register system was brought in not merely to give a picture of those wholly unemployed but to give an index of the people partically unemployed, people unemployed at particular times of the year. The type of person I am referring to is the uneconomic holder in the West and throughout the country. It is true that during the latter part of spring, summer and early autumn, they can find a fair amount of employment working with neighbours and so on, but when it comes to the winter period, there is nothing for them and certain schemes were set on foot in order to relieve that unemployment.
The register also proved a very useful guide to the type of employment needed for the various classes and I should be very sorry to see any departure from it, although we have been told that a number of those on the register are not prepared to take work when it is offered to them. Deputy Maguire dealt, and, I think, dealt very well, with that aspect of it. He stated, and I want to emphasise what he said, that those who were in the habit of getting employment on relief schemes and on the turf schemes are not very anxious to go any distance, even within their own county, to work when they know that quite convenient to them there is an industry on which they could be employed. So far as my county is concerned, during the emergency period, an average of £116,000 a year was spent, but that was all put away almost overnight.
I do not intend to go into details on that matter, but I hold that that industry should be maintained and that certain work could have been carried out in preparation for what, to my mind, is a very useful scheme, a scheme that holds out great hope as far as the future is concerned, that is, semi-automatic machine-won turf. Last year in County Galway, the first year that the present Minister was in charge, semi-automatic machines were being operated on 18 bogs, according to the Minister's reply to me. Fourteen machines were operated, giving employment to 261 people. This year, that has been reduced to ten bogs, 27 machines and an estimate of 250 workers. If the Minister had taken his courage in his hands last year, he could have found a number of other bogs in County Galway on which to operate these machines. If the eight bogs that have been dropped were unsuitable for semi-automatic machineproduction of turf, I am quite sure that there is a number of other bogs on which machines could be operated this year if the necessary preparatory work had been carried out last year.
South of Loughrea, in my constituency, there is a big tract of bog. It is a mountain area. During the emergency, several hundred men were employed producing turf which was taken to Dublin and other centres. It is a very good quality turf. As a result of what happened, those people were unemployed. It has been stated by some people, including prominent members of the Government, that people registered because they were told to do so. When you find people of valuations of £5 or £6 and less whose livelihood has been suddenly cut away, is it any crime to advise them to register? I advised them to register and I make no apology to anybody for doing so because I believed that it would be an indication to the Government of the position and that, if they were not prepared to go on with the turf scheme, they would try to find alternative schemes in order to provide employment.
As far as machine-won turf is concerned, as I said, I believe there is a great future for it and I would like to see it extended very considerably. I would like, in the first instance, that hand-won turf production would be encouraged. Many of the co-operative societies that were established did very useful work and their members got a fairly decent return for their labour. I would like that such co-operative societies should be encouraged again, that the improvement of bogs would be continued and that grants for that purpose would not be stinted. While the production of hand-won turf would be continued through the medium of co-operative societies, I would very much like to see the production of semi-automatic machine-won turf being encouraged. Every encouragement should be given to co-operative societies or to persons who have a technical knowledge—I am sure many of them would be found—who would be prepared to invest in that type of machine. I would like to see the day when the entire domestic fuel requirements of the people in the rural areas in the West of Ireland would be provided by the semi-automatic machine. I hope the Minister will bear that in mind.
I am glad that the Minister, although he comes from the town of Nenagh, is conversant with rural Ireland and I am sure he understands that one of the heaviest and most costly crops to save as far as the farmers are concerned is the turf crop. For instance, take a farmer who has to produce his own supply of turf fuel with the help of his own family or hired labour. He generally goes to the bog after he has the greater portion of his crops sown. Even if the weather is fine, the operation on the bogs continues for at least a fortnight at cutting, then a number of days spreading and a certain amount of time footing. That is a big handicap on the farmer. He may have to go a distance of two to 15 miles. The meals have to be prepared by the housewife and taken to the bog at the very time that the root crops are commencing to come above the ground and when the weeds are also appearing. In view of the distance involved and particularly if the weather is fine, the farmer will try to finish the turf production and, consequently, neglects his crops at the very time that they require attention. That is why I would like to see co-operative societies or individuals or some organisation under Bord na Móna undertaking, as far as possible, the whole supply of domestic fuel in the rural parts of Ireland where bogs are available. That would be of very great importance to the farmers and many farmers would be prepared to pay reasonably well to have that work carried out. They could afford to pay because, if they had any worthwhile crops at all, it would doubly repay them to give proper attention to them when they need it most. I mentioned one or two bogs south of Loughrea— that great tract of territory there. I sincerely hope that the Minister will convey to Bord na Móna my recommendation that that large bog be inspected and that semi-automatic machines be put to work there. In the first place they will get a certain amount of a market in the town of Loughrea and probably also in the town of Gort. We have a number of public institutions in County Galway that could also be supplied without sending any out of the county at all. There is another bog convenient to Woodlawn station— Moyardwood bog. Machines were on that bog last year but not for very long. I am not in a position to state whether the bog was suitable or not, but I know that as far as the production of hand-won turf was concerned, a very fine amount of it was produced on that particular bog during the emergency. There is the very great advantage, too, that it is along the railway line from Galway to Dublin. There is also another bog at Caltralea between Ballinasloe and Ahascragh where very fine turf was produced during the emergency. A bog was also taken over by the Land Commission on the Trench estate at Poolboy and Kellysgrove, Ballinasloe. That bog was, in the main, given out to people in the town of Ballinasloe. If machines could work on that bog in something like the manner I have indicated I am sure that the people of Ballinasloe town would be quite willing to pay for the turf that would be produced there. It would give just as much employment and perhaps even more than is available at the moment where the individuals are producing it themselves.
The Minister stated at Westport and, of course, he stated it in this House, too, that there was work for 5,000 with the Electricity Supply Board and Bord na Móna, but that the response was very poor. It may be so that the response was very poor. However, I remember that in the past there was very great criticism, even in this House, of the conditions of employment with Board na Móna—very unfair criticism and of a type that would not by any means bear the light of investigation. I am told that conditions have not worsened since. But, nevertheless, when you have criticisms of that kind it is not very helpful. People take it to themselves. I would like that when workers are being advertised for— apart altogether from the conditions and the rate of wages being given at the labour exchange—they would also be given in the public Press. I think it would be a very useful thing to do. I hold that turf production is an industry that can do more to expand employment in rural Ireland, particularly in the western counties, than anything else. Of course, we would have employment on roads—very useful employment, too—but that is a matter for another Department. Nevertheless, the Minister is interested in giving employment and I hope he will pull his weight, as I am sure he will, in the Government, to see that the shortsighted policy which was put into operation this year in regard to road grants will not be continued and that, in regard to the improvement of roads, main and county—as well as the improvement of roads and drainage in connection with bogs—good substantial grants will be made available. After all, the giving of good useful employment to people in their own areas and districts, in my opinion, overshadows all this thing and what I term the "penny wise and pound foolish" policy which is being carried on by the present Government since it took over office.
The question of commercial industries in towns was raised. That is a matter in which I am keenly interested. We have a few towns that could very well do with industries. When the Minister was making his opening statement on this Estimate he said that notice of approval had been given in 90 cases; that the production stage had been reached in 14 cases and that proposals were in an advanced stage in 70 cases. One thing I should like to know and which I should like cleared up is, how many of the 90 cases, in which notice of approval has been given, were on the files of the Minister's Department previous to his taking office, and how many of those 14 cases that have reached the production stage were on the files of his Department before he took office.
Comment on this
I will try to look it up. I believe that at least 90 per cent. of them were on the files of the Department before the change of Government. I am glad that the Minister is going on with them. I am delighted, and I congratulate him on being so broad-minded as to go on with them. I only wish that in every other sphere we had the same spirit of broad-mindedness and appreciation for the efforts of his predecessor in office.
The Industrial Development Authority has now been established. I do not know any of its members except one and I know that he, like the Minister, is very interested in the welfare of the country. I was pleased to note in the evening paper that the Minister referred to a question which I intended to ask on this Estimate, namely, whether that body would advise those anxious to promote and invest in industry as to the most suitable type of industry for the particular district concerned. I remember that on certain occasions since the industrial revival in 1932 people came together in an area and were prepared to put up a certain amount of money to go into an industry. The trouble with them was that they did not exactly know what industry they should invest in or what industry would be most suitable to their area. Of course they had certain ideas about industries that they might start, but when they went a distance, not having any technical knowledge or experience, they were told that an industry of that kind would not be suitable. They were given a list of other industries which they might consider but as a result of their first experience they became confused and consequently no industry was started. I should like to see the Industrial Development Authority go as far as possible to supply advice in a matter of that kind.
In the town of Loughrea there is a number of people prepared to put up anything from £15,000 to £20,000 to start an industry. I should like very much that the Industrial Development Authority or certain of its members would be prepared to go down to meet these people and talk the matter over with them. I think it would be better business than bringing these people to Dublin, because the members would see the position for themselves and get an idea of the district. I know that in Loughrea they were very keen on one type of industry and anybody having raw material so near at hand would imagine it should be a very suitable industry. They were told from time to time, however, that it was an industry which was very doubtful from the profit-making point of view. I refer to a wool scouring and combing industry. After all, Galway produces a very fine type of wool and supplies, I suppose, one-sixth of the wool of the entire State. An industry of that kind should be thoroughly examined. Deputy Bartley mentioned something to-day about seaweed coming into the manufacture of fine textiles. If that is the case we have both the seaweed and the wool in County Galway and, as the emergency in now over, it is quite possible that the machinery necessary for this fine combing process could be made available.
Another matter that was mentioned in relation to Loughrea and Portumna and I might say Gort, but not so much Gort, is that they were unsuitable centres because they had not good railway facilities. I wonder in connection with the Milne report on the transport position if legislation is introduced and carried through on the basis of that report will this railway-minded legislation be of any great advantage or benefit to towns like those I am speaking about. There are, of course, several hundred towns in the country similarly situated. They are either at the end of a line or there is no railway line at all. I believe that with a good lorry service industries could be established in towns such as Loughrea and Portumna and that the cost of distribution would be no greater than where you have railway facilities.
As I said, there are five towns in my constituency, Loughrea, Portumna, Gort, Ballinasloe and Athenry which could do with an industry. In Ballinasloe a boot and shoe industry was established during the Fianna Fáil regime. It had some difficult years to contend with in the early stages, but it is a very fine industry now. I know well, and the people who are drawing their wages know much better, the value of that industry to them. Some £500 or £600 per week is paid out in wages in that town. Even the small sack factory in Athenry, although the number employed is not so great, is a great asset to that town. I should like to see an industry in all the towns and even a second industry. I should like to see an medium-sized or small industries in the smaller towns given every encouragement. Where we have people willing to invest money and take an interest in an industry they should not be discountenanced because the proposed in dustry was not a big one. Every help and assistance should be given then by the Industrial Development Authority.
I am afraid the Government made a bad start as far as industrial development is concerned. A number of references were made to Irish industrialists —they are even being made yet. I think a number of them would have been better left unsaid. It is very difficult to expect people to invest money in Irish industry when they know the background and history of some of the people who are members of the present Government. Here is a quotation from one of them:
"We do not want to see Irish industry for ever carrying on its purse the parasites that have attached themselves to it in the last ten years. I pray for an economic D.D.T. with which we can spray Irish industry and watch the vermin that infests it to-day falling off."
That was the then Deputy Dillon in 1945 as reported in the Official Reports, Volume 97, column 1579. He is now a member of the present Government.
Comment on this
Has the Government proof that there are any such parasites? If they want to prove that there are parasites, all the flock should not be blackened because of the one black sheep. Whatever few parasites are in it, they should not be spared. All the other people, however, who invested their money, perhaps their life savings in industry and did a very good job of work should not be tarred with the same brush. That type of talk is no inducement whatever. It is all very well for people to say—I do not disagree with it—that workers should have a say in the management and a share in the profits of industry. We should remember, however, that the people who invest their money are investing money which they earned, in the main, honestly for services rendered to this country. In my opinion, no matter what anybody else says, they are entitled to have a greater say in regard to how that money is to be utilised than the people who come in just to work for what they can make out of it. I do not think there is anything wrong in what I have said. It was stated here by Deputy Maguire and certain others that if the workers have a say in the management—and I should like to see that—and a share in the profits, they would not do more when the question of losses came up.