We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949—Committee.

Contributions 1–199 of 405. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 8 of 1949 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

To insert after line 13 the following definition:—

"the word ‘land' includes all privileges, easements, profits, rights and advantages whatsoever appertaining to, enjoyed with or appurtenant to land."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy consider whether that is met, and to what extent, by amendment No. 21 which he might have looked for?

Comment on this

I have seen that. I think that the Minister will agree with me that to put a long definition within the section itself is rather a clumsy way to overcome the amendment I have put in my name and in Deputy MacEntee's. I think the Minister must well appreciate that the usual method of defining a word and what a word is intended to connote is in the definition section and it would be more properly done in the amendment I have submitted. I also wish to point out to the Minister that his amendment, No. 21, is not as wide as the amendment I have submitted.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is a matter for the Deputy.

Comment on this

He uses the words "or other rights," and if I took it that that would apply to such rights as conacre lettings I would be satisfied, but I put it to the Minister that the method in which I have submitted the amendment is the more usual way and that his amendment is a more clumsy way of meeting a situation like this.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government (Mr. Corish) Labour Party

Apart from the fact that land is not defined in similar Acts, I think the Deputy need not have any anxiety as far as the definition which is intended in this Bill. Land is defined in the Interpretation Act, 1937, and I think that as far as compensation is concerned the Deputy need not have any worries in view of amendment No. 21 which will be introduced. Land was not defined as widely as the Deputy would have it defined in the Arterial Drainage Act, 1945, nor in the Relief Works Act, 1940. He raised the question of conacre rights and that would be included under amendment No. 21, but as far as compensation is concerned—and I think that is the Deputy's main anxiety—he need not have any fear in view of amendment No. 21.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 21, however, seeks to declare that the compensation is to be paid by the local authority concerned and that is mixed up with a definition of land. An Leas-Cheann Comhairle wants to know if Deputy Lynch wants to move his amendment in view of amendment No. 21. Amendment No. 21 includes as well as the definition of land the authority by which compensation is to be paid, two different things.

Comment on this

We are in the very fortunate position of having in the Government a number of Ministers who have a very extensive knowledge of law and this amendment of Deputy Lynch's is an important legal amendment. This is an important Bill which will affect rights and which is required for the purpose of easing a difficult situation all over the country and I think it would only be right if, in addition to the Parliamentary Secretary who is handling this measure, some of the other Ministers, particularly those who have a good knowledge of law, were present in the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes, but that does not arise peculiarly on this amendment.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the Government and does not arise peculiarly on this amendment, but I do not see why this discussion should be left to a handful of Deputies. If there is a vote on it we will have voted without having had the benefit of the best advice which is available to the Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not short of advice.

Comment on this

Since amendment No. 21 is bound up with another matter in respect of which there is at least one and possibly more amendments, I seriously suggest that the Minister accept this amendment. It is simply a definition and since there are other definitions in Section 1 of this Act he should accept it. It does not widen the scope of the Bill and in case amendment No. 21 is not accepted I think he ought to accept this definition of the word land.

Comment on this

I think it is adequately covered in amendment No. 21. In any case, there is no proposal to acquire land and the only question with regard to land is the question of compensation. That is covered by amendment No. 21.

Comment on this

The mover of this amendment might consider whether by actually defining land he does not thereby defeat his own purpose. The purpose of a definition is to restrict the application of a word and, if he seeks to broaden the scope of the compensation that may legitimately be claimed by those who suffer damage under the operation of any section of this Bill, surely his purpose would be to have the idea of land as broadly based as possible and to have it open to the widest possible interpretation. As it stands it is restricted to "all privileges, casements, profits, rights and advantages whatsoever appertaining to, enjoyed with or appurtenant to land". That seems to be very extensive to the lay mind, but perhaps when the legal gentlemen get it, it may be found that some set of circumstances may arise under which certain damage will not come under this very wide definition; whereas if the word "land" itself is understood in its normal meaning the lawyers can extend its definition to include probably any given case that arises requiring the operation of any clause dealing with compensation. It appeared to me, from that reasoning, to be unnecessary. I suggest that the Deputy would achieve his purpose by considering that aspect of it and, if he is so convinced, it might serve his purpose better to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

That advice would be all very well were it not for amendment No. 21. The mere fact that the Minister has seen fit to insert amendment No. 21 indicates clearly that there is something in this amendment No. 1. This amendment may or may not be defeated. In any case, it is bound up with the question of liability for payment of compensation and, therefore, I ask the Minister to accept it.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Would the Deputy not agree that the definition in amendment No. 21 goes farther than his own?

Comment on this

Would it not be possible to leave it over until we come to amendment No. 21, which seems to be the major issue?

Comment on this

In the case of the Arterial Drainage Act and the Relief Works Act, it was intended, under the provisions of the Arterial Drainage Act, to assume that damage would be done to land, and land was not defined in that Act. I do not think it is necessary to give any wider definition to "land," as it is clearly covered, as far as compensation is concerned, here. There is no definition of "land" here at all. I presume the definition is as it was given in the Interpretation Act of 1937.

Comment on this

One can appreciate the position in regard to this amendment. I think Deputy Lynch himself, from his own knowledge, should be able to tell the House what "land" means. I do not presume to have the knowledge that he has, but "land" is a very wide interpretation. Deputy Lynch should be able to tell us where in any Act, for the purpose of Acts of Parliament, the word "land" includes these things that he wants to bring in. That is why I made the suggestion when speaking a few moments ago. I intend to follow the advice of Deputy Sir John Esmonde on the previous stage of this Bill in regard to it. I would suggest to Deputy Lynch that he might say, for the information of the House, what the word "land" connotes in Acts of Parliament.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has given us, as an excuse for not accepting this amendment, that the word "land" is defined in the Act of 1937. I would like him to give us the quotation, if he has it.

Comment on this

It is as follows:—

"The word ‘land' includes messuages, tenements and hereditaments, houses and buildings, of any tenure."

Comment on this

This covers more than that.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

So does amendment No. 21.

Comment on this

Irrespective of the Arterial Drainage Act, this Bill may interfere with certain rights by the very nature of the Bill itself and, in particular, may interfere with rights that are very valuable to the small farmer. I have in mind, in particular, easements of different kinds affecting their rights to water and so forth. Any definition of "land" in any previous legislation. I respectfully suggest, does not cover casements and prendres of different kinds. There is no definition of “land” in this Bill except the one which the Minister is suggesting in amendment No. 21. As this is a Bill in which these small matters will arise, what is the objection to making the definition as extensive as possible to cover any matters that may arise?

Comment on this

The Deputy mentioned two matters—easements and profit-a-prendre. These two words are included in amendment No. 21. It is even wider than that.

Comment on this

This is bound up with the question of compensation. There is a further amendment down at a later stage to give a wider definition.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 41.

Comment on this

Compensation is the only thing concerned. There is no proposal in the Bill to acquire a square inch of land.

Comment on this

I know that, but there are proposals to interfere possibly with many of the rights that are pertinent to land. Therefore, whatever definition we put in this Bill must envisage covering all the different rights that may be interfered with. I must ask the Minister to accept this amendment or give an undertaking to the House that he will further amplify the amendment he himself has introduced.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Surely the Deputy does not suggest that because it might be tied up with compensation it is limiting the scope of the definition within the walls of the Act itself?

Comment on this

Of course I do. There was no definition in this Bill originally. This definition is brought in by way of amendment. Whatever artificial definition we give to the word "land" in this Bill is going to be the definition that will count. Any previous definitions of "land" will not cover some of the matters that may arise in the way of damage to easements, rights of water, rights of way, and so forth. Therefore, you have to give a very special definition to the word "land" in this Bill, so as to cover the different matters that might arise in connection with claims to compensation.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I do not know if Deputy Moran is being mischievous or just a little bit stubborn on this issue. Surely, if amendment No. 21 is to go through the House and become embodied in the Act, the definition of "land" there is as wide and as broad as any definition you can get? Surely any matter that is tied up with land as a whole will come within the definition?

Comment on this

There are a lot of people in the House who would be prepared to accept the definition of "land" in amendment No. 21 who would not be prepared to accept that the compensation is to be paid by the local authority. They might want the compensation to be paid by somebody else.

Comment on this

I suggest that Deputy Lynch should withdraw this amendment and allow it to hang on amendment No. 21, because, if you put a definition of land in the definition section, it gives rise to all sorts of complications. Obviously, the Deputy's intention is in regard to compensation, which is covered in Section 5 and amendment No. 21. If his amendment were accepted, it would throw entirely out of gear the right of entry in Section 4. Land is visualised in Section 4 as land in the accepted meaning of the term, and, if you try to read Deputy Lynch's amendment in with the wording of Section 4, it would obviously be ridiculous. I think the Deputy intends it to apply only to questions of compensation and consequently it should be dealt with on Section 5.

Comment on this

There is this difficulty tied up with the amendment introduced by the Minister that, in accepting that amendment, we accept not only his definition of land, but another principle altogether in connection with compensation. There are other amendments to be discussed dealing with the liability for the payment of compensation. The Minister's amendment, in addition to defining land for the purposes of the section, provides that a claimant will be entitled to be paid by the local authority concerned, but there are other amendments designed to provide the very opposite—that local authorities will not be called upon to pay compensation under the section, so that in accepting the Minister's definition of land, if we are prepared to accept it, we are automatically driven to accepting this other matter which we cannot accept.

Comment on this

The whole question of compensation will have been discussed and dealt with before we come to amendment No. 21.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy has missed the point altogether. His anxiety is to have the word "land" defined to include certain things, such as an easement or a profit-a-prendre, with a view to making the position quite clear when it comes to the right of compensation in Section 5. Amendment No. 21 goes much further than defining the word “land”—it gives a specific right to any person who owns a profit-a-prendre or easement to compensation, and, when the Deputy refers to the Minister's definition, he is not quite correct. Amendment No. 21 is not a definition. It gives the owners of certain properties, such as an easement or profit-a-prendre, a right to compensation, and, in these circumstances, it is not necessary to define the word “land” to include an easement or profit-a-prendre, apart from any other consideration whatever.

Comment on this

I would be prepared to accept amendment No. 21 as covering my amendment, with one reservation. Amendment No. 21 proposes to substitute a new sub-section:

(1) Any person who suffers damage by reason of any interference, caused by the execution of works pursuant to this Act or Order made thereunder, with any land owned or occupied by him or any easement, profit-a-prendre or other right belonging to him shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be entitled to be paid by the local authority concerned compensation in respect of such damage.

The reservation I suggest is that the sub-section should end:

... shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be entitled to be paid compensation.

I suggest it should stop there and, later on, the body by whom the compensation is to be paid can be defined. I will not dispute the argument that the Minister's definition may be wider than mine, but I certainly will dispute the insertion of this amendment in toto in substitution for my amendment.

Comment on this

There will be an opportunity on amendments Nos. 7, 8 and 9 to discuss who is to pay the compensation.

Comment on this

Could we leave it over until amendment No. 24?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Does the Deputy propose to withdraw amendment No. 1?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:—

In line 20 after the word "thereof" to add the words "and shall also include any road (whether vested in a local authority for maintenance or not) over which a public right of way exists.

The amendment is designed to widen the definition, such as it is, of roads in the Bill. We can visualise different roads which may not be roads maintained by a local authority, on which there may be serious flooding, or a subsidence, or other matters that may have to be dealt with. There are other amendments suggesting that the definition should include bog roads or cul-de-sac roads, but I think that the definition of roads should be as wide as possible in order to leave a local authority free to deal with this particular type of flooding on roads. I think the Minister should accept the amendment.

Comment on this

If I thought it necessary I would accept the amendment, but I do not think it is at all necessary. The definition of "road" is taken from the Local Government Act, 1925, and it is as set out in the Bill. The Deputy would limit the work which local authorities could undertake in this respect, because his amendment refers to a road over which a public right of way exists. If it is not a road which comes within the jurisdiction of a local authority, or which a local authority has responsibility for maintaining, it can be regarded as land. Any road which is not a public authority road may be regarded as land and it may be relieved of flooding under sub-section (3) of Section 2. In short, a road which is not a road may be considered as land.

Comment on this

I do not accept the Parliamentary Secretary's interpretation. In the first place, in the definition section, the word "road" means a public road and a public road only. You may have just as difficult and just as urgent a problem with a bog road which serves quite a number of people—it may be subject to annual flooding, with the result that people cannot use it— or with a cul-de-sac road or other types of roads which would not be classified as public roads. I am not prepared to accept the argument that, if it does not come in under "public road", it can be regarded as land. I cannot see, in view of the other terms of the Bill, what the objection is to bringing in all roads, because there is still the discretion of the local authority and the discretion of the Minister to deal with the matter, as well as the different checks and safeguards provided further on in the Bill.

Why should we limit ourselves, as I suggest we are limiting ourselves, by tying ourselves to public roads? Why not be able to deal with every one of these problems, which may be just as vital in case of a bog road as in the case of a public road? I do not see how the Parliamentary Secretary can convince me that these roads can be dealt with under the definition of land, and, even if that were so, if the Parliamentary Secretary accepts that position, what then is the objection to the definition of roads which I suggest? If the Parliamentary Secretary is prepared to agree that this kind of work which I have in mind can be done under the definition of land, why then should there be this objection to defining roads to include all types of roads as I suggest?

Comment on this

I am suggesting that the definition would be much wider than the Deputy would have it. His suggestion would confine it to roads over which a public right of way existed. It is not necessary to have grass growing on a road to make it land—it is land, if it is not a public road.

Comment on this

It does not seem to make a lot of difference one way or the other because, as I read the definition of permanent construction in the Bill and the provisions of Section 2, sub-section (3) (b), it appears to me that there is already provision in the Bill to provide for what the Deputy has in mind. In sub-section (3) (b) provision is made whereby these works can be constructed on any permanent construction in the functional area of the local authority which they are not under any liability to maintain if they consider it is in the public interest and "permanent construction" is defined by the Bill as including any public road. A public road is not necessarily a road in respect of which the local authority have any liability to maintain. It is merely a road over which the public have a right of way, whether it is a bog road or a mountain road, as another amendment already suggests. In my view, the matter being dealt with by the Deputy is already provided for in the Bill. I do not exactly follow the reason given by the Parliamentary Secretary but I assume it could also be treated as land. In any event, the road could be dealt with under the provisions in that sub-section.

Comment on this

I agree that the amendment suggested by Deputy Moran is unnecessary, that the very things that he wants done can be done under the Bill as drafted. I am satisfied as to that. If that is so, it is only surplusage to put in unnecessary phrases or sub-sections. That is my view in regard to it.

Comment on this

Surely the definition of "road" narrows the meaning of the word "road" in this Bill to a public road and a public road is a road that is maintained by a local authority.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Not at all.

Comment on this

A public right of way.

Comment on this

If "public road" in this definition means what is normally known as a public road, one maintained by a public authority, Deputy Moran's amendment would at least give the authorities under this Bill the powers to repair non-public roads but roads over which the local authorities or the public have a right to travel. We all know that extraordinary steps had to be taken in order to enable people in backward localities or living at some distance from what was known as a public road on cul-de-sac roads or roads which were not maintained by the public authority to get these roads put into a state of repair and up to now it had to be done out of the unemployment relief scheme. I think the Parliamentary Secretary, unless he can produce for us now what is the definition of "public road," should accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Is not it still covered by the permanent construction definition?

Comment on this

There is a great deal of confusion here and perhaps I might make a suggestion so that the House would appreciate exactly what is referred to as a public road. Deputies may be under the impression that the local authority owns the road in question if it is a public road. The local authority has power to acquire the property in a road but the majority of the roads referred to as public roads are only vested in the local authority for the purpose of maintenance and the ownership of the soil of the road remains in the particular person upon whose land the road was built and, therefore, so far as public roads are concerned, namely, those roads the maintenance of which is a charge on the local authority, they are covered by the particular section in the Bill. So far as any other road is concerned, if it is a road over private land on which there is a public right of way, that is covered by the definition of the word "land." In other words, the fact that there is a public right of way over a person's land does not mean that the ownership of that land is taken away from the person who owns it. Therefore, an entry on the land would be an entry on the public right of way over the land. I do not see any difference whatsoever between that and entry on the land which happens to be the subject matter of a right of way.

Comment on this

Let us get this clear. Where is the definition in this Bill, under which you can bring a road within the definition of land? As Deputy Sir John Esmonde has pointed out, land has not been defined in this Bill but a certain right of compensation has been given in respect of lands owned or occupied by somebody, or any easement, profit-a-prendre or other right belonging to him, who shall, subject to the provisions of the Act, be entitled to be paid compensation. That does not and cannot deal with the matter that we are dealing with in this amendment. That deals with the specific matter of compensation in connection with land. How it can be argued by the Parliamentary Secretary that this definition of land would cover roads outside public roads is beyond me. I cannot see it. I do not understand it. If you limit your definition here to public roads you are limiting it to roads vested in public authorities for the purpose of maintenance. The effect of my amendment is to put a local authority in a position to deal with all roads. I do not see why that should not be accepted because, as I have said, many of these matters possibly would be much more urgent in connection with some of these roads to relieve flooding than some public roads that we will be dealing with.

Comment on this

It appears to me that the main question on this amendment is as to whether there is in existence a well-defined definition of what a public road is, if that definition is clearly understood and expressed in certain terms in a code of law and it is understood that where compensation lies the term "public road" carries a certain connotation, one that can be quoted within the local government code. I suggest that Deputy Moran's amendment would be restrictive in character if, as I say, there is a widely understood and well expressed definition of what a public road is. Is there?

Comment on this

I cannot find a definition of "public road." There does not seem to be such a definition of "public road." There is a definition of "a road," of course, and it is as defined in this Bill. Again I would suggest that, if it cannot be ascertained that a road is a public road or if it is not a road where the local authority have responsibility for its maintenance, it still can be regarded as land because, inasmuch as the local authority does not own it and has no responsibility for it, it must belong to somebody; it could be regarded as a field. In many cases we have roads that are merely tracks across fields. They are in some, cases accommodation roads, in some cases bog roads, and can be treated as land, being part of the field.

Comment on this

What the Parliamentary Secretary does not seem to quite accept is that the first part of this Bill is dealing in the main with local authorities' own property and the relieving of flooding, landslide, subsidence and so forth. If there is this doubt—and the Parliamentary Secretary appears to accept that there is this doubt about the question of defining a road—what is wrong with giving this definition to it for the purpose of this Bill? As the Parliamentary Secretary knows, the definition will be limited to the Long Title of the Bill. It will be for the purpose of doing particular work—affording relief or protection from flooding, landslide, subsidence and so forth. The definition of a "public road" at all events has been accepted by local authorities as a road that is maintained by the local authority. That is the definition that county surveyors throughout this country and local authorities have been going on as a matter of practice. If we are prepared to bring in the bog roads and the accommodation roads and the cul-de-sac roads that are subject to flooding, why not accept this definition which is confined to work to be done in this particular Bill? What is the objection to the inclusion of all these roads where flooding and so forth may occur?

Comment on this

The Deputy is anxious to give us the widest possible scope for operating this very useful measure. I think he should see that if his amendment were accepted it would not be helpful. If it were accepted, roads other than public roads would be defined, whereas in the measure they would be left untouched—perhaps roads that would not be covered by the amendment. Anything that is not a public road will be treated, whereas the Deputy makes a specific definition of roads and rights of way over them. In the measure there is wider scope. I think it is much safer as it is.

Comment on this

I am at a loss to follow the arguments advanced by the Parliamentary Secretary and by the Minister. We are agreed, I think, that the term "public roads" is interpreted everywhere as meaning roads for the maintenance of which local bodies are legally responsible.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

We are not.

Comment on this

That is accepted everywhere.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Not at all.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins would find that out quickly if he were on local bodies.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Stupidity.

Comment on this

It is not stupidity.

Comment on this

Is the point being made by the Parliamentary Secretary and by the Minister—I take it that it is being advanced by Deputies supporting them —that the interpretation of the term "public roads" is not the interpretation I have placed upon it. I maintain that the interpretation of "public roads" means roads for the maintenance of which local bodies are legally responsible. If that is the case, then——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is not the case.

Comment on this

I do not accept Deputy Collins as an authority on the matter. I am asking this question of the Minister or of his Parliamentary Secretary. If that is the case I say that the amendment that is moved from these benches certainly is designed for the purpose stated by the mover of the amendment, namely, to give to the local body a wider power and greater discretion to cover a type of problem that arises in many places and that they would not be free to deal with if we were to take the interpretation I am legitimately entitled to take from the section as it now stands.

Comment on this

A test could be made as to whether there is already power in the Bill to cover roads other than roads maintainable at present— roads to which Deputy Smith has applied the term "public roads". Take Section 2 (3)—having first looked at the definition of "permanent construction"—and taking merely the word "roads" in what is included in "permanent construction" we have the following:—

"3. Where a local authority to whom this section applies are of opinion that—

(b) any public road in their functional area, not being a public road which was constructed by them or which they are required by law to maintain,"

they may then go on to do certain works on that public road. I think Deputy Moran will agree that that shows clearly that public roads not maintainable by the local authority may still become the subject of works under this Bill. That is in accordance with the definitions already contained in the Bill. I appreciate quite clearly what Deputy Moran and Deputy Smith have in their minds. However, it seems to me, from reading the definitions of the Bill, that provision is already there, and I think we are wasting time.

Comment on this

The peculiar thing about it is that although "road" is defined in Section 1 it is not used in the Bill, as far as I can see, in any other section.

Comment on this

It is included in "permanent construction" just before the definition of the word "road" That is the only place it is mentioned.

Comment on this

Line 17 of the Bill.

Comment on this

I know, but that is in the interpretation section.

Comment on this

Well apply that then.

Comment on this

But that means that neither "public road" nor "road" is used anywhere in the Bill, because the definition is unnecessary.

Comment on this

They used the term "permanent construction" then.

Comment on this

I see that it includes roads.

Comment on this

The whole difficulty arises here as to what class of property the local authority is given power to enter on and do certain work, not having that power at the present time. If Deputies will look at Section 2 they will see that the local authority is given power to enter on land, not being land owned by them, or on any permanent construction in their functional area, not being a permanent construction which was constructed by them or which they are required by law to maintain. That means that they are entitled to enter on land which they would not heretofore be entitled to enter on and, secondly, that they are entitled to enter on a permanent construction which they were not entitled to enter on before. In order to find out what they are entitled to do with regard to "permanent construction" you must come to Section 1. You find the expression "permanent construction" defined to include roads. Then you come to the next paragraph to find out what "road" means and you find it means a public road. Accepting the proposition put forward by Deputy Smith and other Deputies that the generally accepted meaning of "public road" is a road for which the local authority is liable for maintenance, you have all those categories covered. Then you want to know what is going to happen and what right you have to enter upon a road which is not a public road in the accepted sense of the term, namely, a road maintained by the local authorities. For that, there is clear and obvious authority given in this Bill under Section 3 (a). And, because there is a public right of way over land, I think Deputies opposite who know something about this will agree with me that that does not cause land to disappear. It still remains land. Therefore, the two classes of cases which are envisaged in this Bill are completely covered.

Comment on this

Having listened to the very interesting observations by Deputy Esmonde, it occurs to me that the lawyers are going to have great fun over this Bill. As mere laymen, we hear that under this Bill a local authority has a right to do something in regard to a permanent construction and that is dealt with in Section 2, sub-section 3 (b). Then we go back to find out what is the meaning of "permanent construction" and in Section 1 we learn that a permanent construction includes many other things than a road. We then go further to the interpretation to find out what "road" means and we find that it means public road and several other things. It appears to me that the draftsman should have gone a little further and given us an interpretation of what a public road means. If he had done that, we would have had no discussion on the matter at all.

I suggest to Deputy Moran that, in the interest of getting the work started for those who are waiting anxiously to get this work done, instead of adding a few more words to it, even with the best of motives, he should subtract some so that there would be less work for the lawyers and more work for the men who urgently need it. It appears to me that the amendment is a restrictive, as well as, in a sense, a broadening amendment. If it were to say it shall include "any road" and leave it at that, whether vested in a local authority for maintenance or not, it certainly would have a broadening effect to include much more than is intended in the interpretation in the Bill itself.

Bringing in the question of a public right of way restricts it so that public authorities evidently will not be able, even if necessary for the performance of the work, to enter on private roads or roads over which a public right of way does not exist. In some places, in order to carry out the work that is to be done, they may require to go over a road on which no public right of way exists and, therefore, the restriction in the amendment seems to me to defeat the object which Deputy Moran had in mind, namely, to give it a broader definition. We would have to have another amendment to define what a public road is.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary in his definition of road dropped the word "public" and left it to read "the word ‘road' means any road" and includes bridges, etc., that would meet any objections I have to make. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary will find out on inquiry in his Department that public roads have always been regarded by county councils and others as those roads maintained by county councils and not any other road. Members of local authorities have been told that time and time again. If you want to get in these other roads suggested by Deputy Esmonde, you are still driven back to this definition of road in the Bill. It is defined as a public road. The definition of public roads applied by local authorities and county surveyors all over the country is roads that are maintained by the local authority. If the Parliamentary Secretary will give an undertaking to do one thing or the other on the Report Stage in order to remove doubts, I would be prepared to withdraw the amendment; I mean if he is prepared to go into it from the point of view of ensuring that those roads which have been mentioned will qualify under the Bill.

Comment on this

I am not a legal man and I have not a legal mind. I think we are creating a lot of difficulties for ourselves. As far as I can see, every square inch in this country is land. Public roads are roads, in my opinion, which are dedicated to public use. If you want to define a public road as a road over which a local authority has responsibility, I think the definition as expressed by Deputy Smith is correct also. Under one sub-section the local authorities have power to relieve flooding and do other things so far as public roads are concerned. Anyhow, public roads are land and houses are land, according to the interpretation Act of 1937. Therefore, what is left, in my opinion, would also be regarded as land and that would include an accommodation road or any other type of road that you care to mention. But if the Deputies opposite think that it would make it simpler, I am prepared to delete the word "public" before road.

Comment on this

That will get over my difficulty.

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary for simplification say that the word "road" means "any road"?

Comment on this

Yes, substitute "any" instead of "a public".

Comment on this

I should like the Parliamentary Secretary before the next stage to consider making it read "the word ‘road' means any road and includes bridges, houses, buildings, walls, embankments, pipe, arch, gully, footway, pavement, fence, railing or wall forming part thereof", in other words telescoping the two into one.

Comment on this

If we go on to define the word "road" it is entirely unnecessary. Perhaps the House would be prepared to make the suggested amendment now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Better bring it in on the Report Stage.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think amendments Nos. 3 and 4 could be discussed together.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy MacEntee I move amendment No. 3:—

To delete sub-section (2) and substitute therefor:—

( ) Where damage has been sustained, or where a local authority to whom this section applies are satisfied upon a report from their chief engineering officer that damage is likely to be sustained from flooding, landslide, subsidence or other similar occurrence by—

(a) any land owned by them, or

(b) any permanent construction which was constructed by them or which they are required by law to maintain,

the local authority may execute such works as they consider reasonable for the purpose of affording relief or protection from the damage.

The amendment is designed to ensure that before a local authority arrives at a decision they will have a report from the chief engineering officer to show that damage was likely to be sustained from flooding, landslide, subsidence or other similar occurrence. I think it should be provided that the local authority would have this information before them in a formal way from the chief engineering officer before they arrive at a decision that there is likely to be damage. Otherwise it will simply mean that a member will say that it is likely that damage will be caused and other members may not know anything about it. But, if they have a report from the chief engineering officer, there will be no doubt about the matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The general principles of amendments Nos. 3 and 4 are the same and I take it they will be discussed together.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to accept the amendment, as such provisions are not included in other legislation of this kind. I do not think it is necessary for us to embody in legislation the administrative duties of any officer of a local authority, because the duties of a chief engineering officer are defined on his appointment the same as the duties of any other officer. In this particular case I think the duties of a chief engineering officer broadly are to advise the county council on any schemes or works which they propose to undertake. I am prepared to believe, as I have always believed, that the local authority will act, especially in cases like this, in accordance with public interests as they always have done. It is not usual in legislation of this kind to provide for such duties for any officers of local authorities. As a matter of fact in their conditions of appointment, the duties which are given to them by regulations, such matters as these are very well covered.

Comment on this

I should like to say that in my opinion these two amendments contain very dangerous conditions. I do not know what prompted the Deputy to put down these amendments or what his intentions were. First of all, I agree with what the Parliamentary Secretary has said, that it may be assumed before a local authority comes to any decision concerning any works under this Bill that it will get the report or opinion of its proper officers. That seems to be eminently reasonable. What we are asked to do by these amendments is to provide that, if an essential precedent must be taken by an official of the local authority, before the local authority can do anything they must have a report from their chief engineering officer and that if they do not have a report from this officer, then they are absolutely powerless under the Bill. I should like to have the opinion of Deputies who are members of local authorities as to what might be likely to happen if, as happens from time to time, a chief engineering officer has a particular view himself about works which the members of the public want carried out. Remember, that under this amendment the sole power is given to the county surveyor or county engineer to authorise the work to be done. If he disagreed with the work nothing that the local authority could do, if this amendment was passed, could force him to report in favour of the work to be carried out. You would find if that amendment was passed that you might as well tear up this Bill altogether. It completely restricts the powers given under the Bill to local authorities. It is almost a dangerous amendment to the Bill, in my view, and I cannot appreciate the motive which prompted its introduction except that it is an effort to prevent this Bill being of assistance to the people it is designed to help.

Comment on this

I should like to say that I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary is resisting this amendment. As far as the ordinary administration is concerned we give powers to the local authority and we have to accept that the local authority in general acts in a reasonable manner. The local authority acting in a reasonable manner will, on every occasion, before they decide to take any action under this Bill when it becomes law, undoubtedly have the advice of their experts.

Unlike Deputy O'Higgins, I can see what prompted Deputy MacEntee to put down this amendment. I think that Deputy MacEntee was concerned with the public interest. I think he had in mind that if the chief engineering officer—I do not know exactly what a chief engineering officer is; I do not think it is a usual phrase in connection with local authorities and it is not defined in the Bill—reported to the local authority that damage was likely to occur and the local authority then decided that they would take certain steps, that in the event of any court action arising out of that the court would undoubtedly hold that the public authority was acting in the public interest because they took those steps on the recommendation and advice of their chief engineering officer. I take it that that was the motive that prompted Deputy MacEntee to put down that amendment. However, I agree with Deputy O'Higgins. It would be a dangerous precedent to create that in the case of damage likely to occur the local authority could not move unless they were satisfied on a report of the chief engineering officer that damage was likely to be sustained.

It is well that the fullest possible powers should be given to the local authority as such, depending upon them in the ordinary way to do their work and carry it out in the best interests of the public. Of course, there is always this limitation. If the local authority acts improperly, there is always the law court, where they can be brought to book. If they are brought to book and certain of them nominated as special defendants, there will be no danger that they will act improperly. For that reason I think the principle of the amendment is a bad one. While I can see the motives-behind it, I agree with the Parliamentary Secretary that the House should be asked to reject it.

Comment on this

Some of the Deputies opposite have read something into these amendments that is not there at all. They suggested that this would solely depend on the whim of the chief engineering officer or the county surveyor. That is not so. All that each of these amendments provides for is this: that before they go ahead with this work they would have the benefit of the chief engineer's or the county surveyor's report before them. The first amendment, No. 3, is designed to deal with the land or works owned by the local authority. However, when we come to the proposed works dealt with under amendment No. 4, that is:—

"any land in their functional area not being land owned by them, or any permanent construction ... not being a permanent construction which was constructed by them or which they are required by law to maintain,"

we can visualise some of the claims that may arise, that, mark you, under this Bill the local authority will have to pay for. We can very well visualise, when we come to questions of drainage, cases arising where members of a local authority would come to agreements about some local jobs in their areas, saying: "If you let my job through, I will let your job through irrespective of what the resulting damage may be or what it may ultimately cost the ratepayers of any particular county."

The purpose of these amendments is to ensure that, before a local authority will go ahead with a work, it will have a full report from its engineer giving an estimate of any damage that may be done. If the local authority goes ahead with the work it will, in that event, do so with its eyes open. If these amendments are accepted it will prevent the members of a local authority undertaking some job in their own area irrespective of the damage that might be caused by carrying it out. Before a council decides to go ahead with a work, it should know from the report of its chief engineer the possible damage that is likely to be done. The amendment does not limit in any way the right of a local authority to go ahead with any particular job. All it provides for is that the local authority will know where it stands before it starts the work. I think that, in the public interest, this is a very necessary safeguard, one for which provision should be made under this Bill. I think the Parliamentary Secretary should reconsider the matter from that point of view so as to ensure that local authorities, before they commit themselves, will know where they stand. I think he would be wise to accept these amendments.

Comment on this

I think we ought to give the local authorities credit for having some sense of responsibility. No local authority would engage on a housing scheme, for example, or on the making or repair of a road without first consulting its county engineer. The people who elect the members of local authorities are the very same people who elect us to represent them in Dáil Éireann. Surely no Deputy assumes for a moment that a local authority, before engaging on a major work of any kind or even before effecting any changes, does not avail of the expert advice of its principal officials. It is reasonable to assume that a local authority, before engaging on any of the types of works covered by this Bill, will seek the advice of its chief engineering officer and of any other official who can give advice.

I should like to point out to Deputy Moran that the amendment speaks of "a report from their chief engineering officer". Does that mean that if the amendment were accepted and that if, say, the chief engineering officer were ill for three months, no work under this Bill could be done during that period? I do not think the Deputy is serious in suggesting that we should embody an amendment such as that in legislation. The duties of a chief engineer are defined and are made known to him before he takes up office. They are defined to be "to give to the county council such engineering service of an advisory, supervisory or executive nature as is required by the council in the exercise of its powers, including the duties of a county surveyor". I do not think any local authority would be so foolish as to start the building of houses, the making or the maintenance of roads or the execution of drainage works without first consulting its county engineer.

Comment on this

It seems to me that Deputy Moran, when arguing this amendment, did not quite appreciate the effect of it. As has now been pointed out by the Parliamentary Secretary, its acceptance would have this further effect that, assuming the chief engineering officer were ill and that the local authority on the report of his deputy went ahead with some work, the local authority in that case would be doing something that was ultra vires, something that it would have no power to do.

It is quite clear from the amendment that, in a case which is foreseen, "where the local authority are satisfied upon a report from their chief engineering officer that damages are likely to be sustained", they cannot take action unless they are satisfied, and they cannot be satisfied unless they get a report from their chief engineering officer. Deputies can visualise the case put by the Parliamentary Secretary where the chief engineering officer is ill. A report from his deputy would be of no avail under the amendment as it stands. If a local authority were to act upon his report, they certainly would leave themselves open to an action for damages. The amendment creates restrictive conditions which, I think, would cause very considerable difficulty for local authorities.

There is the further objection that I have to the acceptance of the amendment, that it would put too much power in the hands of the chief engineering officer. It would put the public in the position that there would not be very much use in their making their representations to the local authority, assuming that a member of the public foresaw damage in a particular case and reported it to the county council. The whole thing would have to be done through the chief engineering officer and through him alone. I would not be satisfied at all if these amendments were accepted.

Comment on this

If we assume, as I think we are entitled to, that local authorities will, in the main, behave as the Parliamentary Secretary has described, why should we see any danger in inserting this provision in the Bill? We are entitled to assume that the local authority will seek a report from its engineering advisers. If we regard that as a natural, reasonable approach, why should we object to this amendment? Suppose we do not, and that, in spite of its non-insertion the majority of local authorities will behave as the Parliamentary Secretary has described but that one local authority may act as Deputy Moran has said and that, as a result, demands come before the court that is to determine questions of compensation, and suppose further that these questions of compensation arise as a result of work on which that local authority had engaged without getting the prior report and advice referred to in these amendments, I wonder what would be said of that local authority by the court that is to determine questions of compensation?

There has been a lot of argument advanced about the title of the chief engineering officer referred to in the amendment. In some places he is called the county surveyor. I think that, in the Department of Local Government he is usually referred to as the county engineer. Whether he is called the county engineer or the county surveyor the term, in my view, does not mean what it is alleged to convey by Deputy Timoney. It does not follow that because this official is described as the chief engineering officer that he will report in all cases on the works which are carried in the county. He is, of course, the person who is responsible for all engineering works, but he may delegate his duties. He is authorised under the terms of his appointment, as far as I know, to delegate part of his duties to other officials. Naturally, if he is ill a substitute is immediately appointed. The principal assistant or some other person is authorised to undertake his work.

There is nothing in that argument at all, good or bad. There is no question of works being held up because he might be ill or absent. There are two points to meet the arguments advanced by the Parliamentary Secretary. Local bodies will behave in a sensible fashion and, in doing so, naturally they would get a report from the chief engineer or the county surveyor before they engage in any work. If that is the natural thing to do, what is the objection to having it put in this Bill? If you do not put it into the Bill there is the possibility that one local authority might happen to do as Deputy Moran described. It is then you will see the mess in which that body might find itself.

Comment on this

There is no point in this amendment and there is no safeguard for even one local authority. The amendment sets out that where damage has been sustained, or where the local authority are satisfied, upon a report from their chief engineering officer, that damage is likely to be sustained, they may execute such works as they consider reasonable. They need not accept the advice of the chief engineering officer. Deputy Smith talks about safeguards, even in respect of one local authority. It means nothing —there is no safeguard. And why are we so careful about the local authorities now? There have not been similar provisions in the Housing Acts or in other Acts where it is definitely stated that the local authority is required to consult any officer.

Comment on this

It is not correct to suggest that this would not provide a safeguard. There is a very obvious safeguard. If the engineer to a local authority says to them: "You will be lunatics to go ahead with this scheme; it will run you into thousands of pounds by way of damage through flooding and it is a dangerous thing," the local Press will publish that and the ratepayers will know about it and it will act as a good check on the local authority. If we are to assume that the local authorities are not going to go wrong, why is there a section in the Bill which sets out that where the Minister is satisfied that the local authorities are unable or unwilling to execute works, he may nominate a person to execute them? You are taking power there to send people down over the heads of the local authorities. Does not that section presuppose that he will have to exercise some power over the local authority? Is it not abvious that the Minister is making provision for a situation where a local authority will act unreasonably?

We can safely assume that local authorities will act in the way I suggest. I am sure everybody will agree that a prudent local authority will consult its officials and find out what will be the effect before they embark on any scheme. What is the objection to making provision so that a prudent local authority can be advised through its engineer before proceeding with any undertaking?

Comment on this

The suggestion in this discussion is that the chief engineering officer will report to his county council or other local authority that damage amounting to thousands of pounds will be done if a certain scheme is embarked upon. Deputies should realise that this Bill seeks not to do damage, but to carry out improvements. But the attitude of the Opposition seems to be that the damage will outweigh whatever benefits may accrue through these schemes. Is the position to be that we cannot trust the local authorities unless they go through the conduit pipe of a chief engineering officer? The fact is that the people, through their county council representatives, have been clamouring about the damage that has been taking place for years, and they are still restricted from carrying out the improvements which this measure will authorise them to carry out. Surely we will act in consultation with the chief engineering officers, but why should we restrict the power of the local authorities themselves, who are the people who will eventually make the decision?

I cannot see the purpose of these amendments. I do not know what is in Deputy MacEntee's mind. Deputy Cowan endeavoured to interpret him, but I cannot do so. On the Second Reading—Volume 114, col. 2157, 31st March, 1949, he said:—

"We are now at the stage, therefore, at which it will be possible for a local authority to benefit a friend of a friend of an officer of that authority, or the friend of a friend of a member of the local authority, with sufficient influence to persuade whoever is going to be the responsible executive officer under this Bill, by making it possible for that authority under this Bill to remove, say, a weir in order to improve the drainage of a certain stretch of land along a river and, at the same time, do a great deal of damage to the private property of some other man."

He would not be a very responsible officer who would allow himself to be pulled to do some work for a friend and in so doing destroy the property of somebody else.

I think this approach on the part of Deputies opposite is wrong. This measure seeks to do a reasonable job of improvement and any compensation that may be awarded will be infinitesimal in comparison with the improvements it will make. Why should we have to intimidate county councils or other local authorities and put them in such a position that they can do nothing unless through the conduit pipe of their engineering officers? I say that if we were to adopt these amendments we would hamper and clog the operation of this measure and prevent these schemes being undertaken speedily.

Comment on this

The Minister says that this Bill is designed to give benefits and not create damage. What we want to ensure is that if it gives benefits, those benefits will not be outweighed by the damage that will be caused in certain cases. On the Second Reading I instanced a case which came within my own knowledge where £5,000 was spent and damage to many times that amount was caused down the river. If water is doing damage to some person upstream it may do a lot more damage to valuable land downstream if it is let down before the river bed is cleaned out and prepared to take the extra water that will be let down upon it. Every individual would like to see the water taken off his land and brought somewhere else, but all the individual is concerned with is: "Get it off my land no matter whether or not it causes damage downstream."

County councillors have the same idea. Some ratepayer will approach them and say: "My land is being flooded and I wish the county council would get the water taken off." What we are concerned with is that the county council will take a decision after considering a report from their engineers rather than have the council merely acting upon the motion of some member. Some counties you will find 50, 60, 100 miles in length or breadth. How can county councillors go around to see whether some man's land is relieved of excess water and that it will not do greater damage downstream. Surely, in such a case it is absolutely essential that county councillors, for their own protection and for the protection of the ratepayers, should, before undertaking a certain job, find out if any damage is likely to be caused. We urge the Minister to accept these amendments because they are a safeguard and the procedure is very normal. There is no reason why the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary should not accept the amendments.

Comment on this

Why is this necessary.

Comment on this

Because in Drainage Acts there is a long procedure to be followed which gives everybody a chance to make an objection. There are surveys made which show the state of the land before drainage is undertaken and these surveys help to reinforce a claimant for any damages that may be caused through a scheme. There is no such provision in this Bill; and the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary can see from the amendments that they were forced to introduce that this was a very hastily drafted measure and did not take cognisance at all of the damage that might be done beyond even the £10 that would be upheld in the District Court. The Government have had to mend their hand in this regard in several amendments but we are not satisfied, even though they have put in amendments which are longer in sum total than the original Bill, that they have yet introduced the safeguards necessary if damage is to be prevented.

Comment on this

Deputy Moran seems to have no faith whatever in public authorities. He seems to think that a member of a public authority will come into a county council meeting and suggest that certain things, of which no county council could approve, should be done for his area. That is exactly what the amendments say. They lay it down that any county councillor can come and suggest the carrying out of improvements which would land the county council in the law courts with heavy damages awarded against it. Has anybody with any experience of local authorities or of county councils ever found those bodies doing anything like that in respect of their districts. I have been in public life for 20 years. I know county councillors of all Parties and I know county councillors who belong to no Party. I never knew a county councillor to come into a county council meeting and suggest against better judgment or advice that work should be carried out which would land the county council in a court of law and involve it in the payment of heavy damages.

What happens in respect of works that county councils have to do? Let us take sudden damage. What does a county council do in respect of that? Does a man to whom sudden damage occurs outside his gate and who is thereby caused considerable inconvenience say that the work of repairing that damage must be done in a certain way and that it must be done at once? No. The chief engineering officer reports upon the damage done and the county engineers carry out the necessary repairs. In the case of new works, who examines new works for the county council? Is it not the chief engineering officer who examines them and reports thereon? Is it not he who recommends as to whether or not these new works should be carried out?

Why is it suggested by Deputy Moran and Deputy Aiken that county councils would act otherwise in respect of the particular works now under discussion? Is it not the chief engineering officer who will survey, report and supervise any such works? Does anybody suggest anything else? Surely, one has there the very safeguard that Deputy Moran wishes to put into this Bill. Safeguards are already there. No county council has ever acted or will ever act in a different manner. They will send out their chief engineering officer to examine the works and, if those works are approved of, they will be carried out under his supervision.

Comment on this

Why not accept the amendment then?

Comment on this

The amendment gives no safeguard. Why not say that the work should be done with a certain kind of pick or shovel or a certain type of dredger? What safeguard is there in that?

Comment on this

What harm will it do?

Comment on this

What good?

Comment on this

It will satisfy us.

Comment on this

I would go quite a long way to satisfy Deputy Smith, but I could never go as far as putting a special clause in an Act of Parliament to satisfy him.

Comment on this

If it does you no harm and if it satisfies me, why not agree to it?

Comment on this

I have said that I would do a lot to satisfy Deputy Smith but I would not go so far as to put a section into an Act of Parliament for that purpose. Will Deputy Smith not agree that there are shoals of schemes prepared by county councils at the present moment? Who prepared them? The chief engineering officers. Who supervises them? The chief engineering officers. Who will carry them out? The chief engineering officers. Deputy Smith knows that as well as I do. It is nonsense to call this a safeguard because county councils have all the safeguards necessary all the time in relation to the works they carry out.

Comment on this

I think the nett point is as to who should be the judges in the work to be done. Is it one individual or the county council. Deputies opposite would prefer that a single individual should have the right of veto with regard to the works to be carried out under the Bill. The Minister would prefer that the county council should have that responsibility. I take it I am right in that, in so far as the Deputies opposite consider that there is no safeguard in this Bill. The only safeguard that there can be if the wording of the amendment is correct is that the county council cannot move without the sanction of a particular individual.

Comment on this

Without a report.

Comment on this

They can ignore it if they wish.

Comment on this

And without a report of a particular kind. I do not think there is any doubt that what it means in effect is that the decision is left entirely to the chief engineering officer.

Comment on this

The amendment does not state that. It is where the county council are satisfied, but they have to get a report. Who are they going to get that report from?

Comment on this

I think Deputy Aiken moved the amendment but he did not draft it. I doubt if he read it.

Comment on this

I did read it.

Comment on this

The amendment says:—

"Where damage has been sustained, or where a local authority to whom this section applies are satisfied upon a report from their chief engineering officer."

Now, there is no direction in that; the chief engineering officer is to report. It is within his discretion in so far as that amendment is concerned whether he will or will not report "that damage is likely to be sustained by flooding", and so on. The local authority, having got that report, may proceed. The section enables local authorities at their own discretion, if they are satisfied that the work is required, to do the work.

Comment on this

How will they become satisfied?

Comment on this

In the perfectly obvious way, as stated by the Parliamentary Secretary, of doing the work as they have done all work heretofore. A number of us have been trying to search the mind of the drafter of this amendment, to see what he had in mind when he put it down.

Comment on this

A lot of searching can be done if the Deputy starts.

Comment on this

Deputy Aiken did not even bother to do that. I at least can say that I have read Deputy MacEntee's speech on the Second Reading of this Bill. I also read Deputy Moran's, Deputy Aiken's and Deputy Smith's speeches. In all charity I do not think it would be fair to read out any extracts from Deputy Aiken's speech, but Deputy MacEntee dealt with the section on the Second Reading in order to show that this House was in some way abrogating its constitutional authority and its duties. According to Deputy MacEntee, the reason why the House was doing that was in order to give county councils the right to decide what was in the public interest. According to Deputy MacEntee the Dáil is the only body in the country which is entitled to so decide and for that reason the Dail has no right to say to county councils:

"We will pass this authority on to you so far as these works are concerned and you can make up your minds about them because you are the people with the local knowledge."

In column 2153 of Volume 114, Deputy MacEntee says:—

"Do Deputies not think that the House in this section is being asked to abrogate one of its major functions? We are here, in general, supposed to be the ultimate judges of the public interest. That is why we have the law-making prerogative. When we pass legislation to limit the rights of property in certain ways, or do other similar things, we do it as judges of the public interest. We are, under the Constitution, the judges of the public interest; and one of the points that may arise in the courts—if people can ever get to the courts under this Bill—for the consideration of the judges, is as to whether we have any right to constitute the local authority as the unrestricted and unqualified judges of the public interest."

Now Deputy MacEntee, in face of that speech which he made on the Second Reading of the Bill, wants to go even further than the Minister was going and wants to give to one individual in the employment of the local authority the sole right to judge what is or what is not in the public interest—that, despite the fact that also on the Second Reading of the Bill, as the Minister has said, Deputy MacEntee felt that under this section an officer or a member of a local body was going to be activated in carrying out these works because of pressure or influence brought to bear on him by a friend or a friend of a friend.

Deputy Cowan showed a very charitable disposition in his interpretation of what Deputy MacEntee intended by these amendments. I confess that in face of the spoken word of Deputy MacEntee on the Second Reading I entirely fail to understand these amendments. They are entirely against what Deputy MacEntee was pleading then. Deputy Moran thinks that there is a safeguard and that is Press publicity. I had the interesting experience of reading some of Deputy Moran's recent speeches at the Mayo County Council. I think Press publicity did not deter him, but I shall have an opportunity of dealing with him later and in another manner.

Comment on this

Any time you wish.

Comment on this

How is a local body to make up its mind as to the feasibility of proceeding with a scheme unless it has before it a report from a person such as in this case the engineer, to guide them?

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

If, as Deputy Hogan has stated, it is the practice of every local authority to follow the normal procedure of obtaining such a report, what is the objection to inserting this in the Bill? Deputy Hogan says that it is unnecessary, that it will, in his opinion, do neither good nor harm. We say it will do good and since his views and the views of those for whom he speaks are that it will neither do good nor harm, why not let us put it in the Bill? Can the Parliamentary Secretary cite any case where a drainage authority, whether it be a local authority or a State Department, will proceed with work, even work involving only an expenditure of £100, without first obtaining a report from some person whom it regards as qualified to give a report, setting out what improvements are likely or what damage is likely to accrue, from the carrying out of the work. The suggestion put forward by Deputy O'Higgins that we, in asking the Government to accept the amendment, are transferring from the local body to one individual the right to make a decision, of course, does not stand a moment's examination. The fact that Deputies are afraid to have that stipulation contained in the measure conveys to my mind that what they are afraid of is that the local body might be hampered by the report and that if the report containing something that some members of the body did not desire, it would be better not to have it there at all. There is no suggestion in the amendment that we are transferring the decision from the local body to the individual who is the chief engineer. What we are leaving to the local authority is complete power to decide for themselves but only after they have before them a report which this Bill, after it becomes an Act will oblige them to have, rather than leave it in the loose open fashion suggested by Deputy O'Higgins:—"Well that is what they will do anyhow." If that is what they will do anyhow there can be no possible objection to our saying "Let it be clearly and definitely inserted in the measure."

Comment on this

I am surprised that so much time has been spent on this matter. I tried to defend Deputy MacEntee's motive in putting down this amendment because I could see what he had in mind, interpreting it from the printed words on the Order Paper. Any interference with the rights of an individual is a serious matter and under the law, as I understand it, such interference can only be justified in the public interest. Consequently I am satisfied that before a local authority can decide to enter upon a man's land for the purpose of doing certain works, they must be satisfied that it is in the public interest and they must so declare it in their resolution deciding to do the work. That being so before a local authority is going to take the risk of interfering with the rights of an individual, they will take all the steps necessary to see that their interference is in accordance with law and in accordance with the public interest. For that purpose they will in the ordinary way consult their county surveyor and other officers. They will be advised by their law adviser, as he is bound to advise them, as to the possible legal effect of the decisions they will take. Consequently I am satisfied that under the particular section as here drafted the local authority will in the ordinary way go through all the procedure that is necessary to ensure that the decision which they take is a proper decision which cannot be interfered with by any person who may go to the courts for the purpose of upsetting it. As the Parliamentary Secretary has said the people who elect the local authorities are the very same people who elect us and send us here to make laws, and they are not going to stand over local authorities involving them in very heavy damages and very heavy costs. I am perfectly satisfied that local authorities will, as always, act with the greatest sense of responsibility and the greatest discretion. I think it is an insult to local authorities to say "you cannot do such-and-such unless your paid official, your county surveyor, advises you to do it."

Comment on this

The amendment does not say that.

Comment on this

If it does not say that it says nothing at all. Here is what it does say: "where local authorities are satisfied upon a report from the chief engineering officer that damage is likely to be sustained from flooding." There is no doubt about it; that is the whole purport of the amendment. Where damage has occurred they can, by resolution and without a report, decide to go in and do the work, but where damage is likely they can only do it on the report of their chief engineering officer. In this Dáil for a period of 25 years responsibility has been given from time to time to Ministers. To the Minister for Local Government responsibility is given by law and I think it would be an extraordinary thing if we were to write into an Act of Parliament that the Minister for Local Government may, if he is advised by a chief engineering officer, his Secretary or his Parliamentary Secretary, do certain things. That would be an insult to the Minister and no Minister would accept a position in which his rights or his responsibilities would be limited by the advice he was to get from his paid officials. I am quite sure, if it was written into an Act of Parliament that Deputy Smith, when he was Minister, could only do certain things if certain officials in his Department advised him to do them, he would say: "You can get somebody else to act as Minister under those conditions. I would not do it." And if an individual, a Minister, would not tolerate that sort of restriction, I think it is an insult that we in this House should say to local authorities who were elected by adult suffrage, by the very same people who elected us: "You must have a report from one of your paid officials, your chief engineering officer, before you do this." I think there is no necessity for us to insult local authorities in that way. The whole history of local government for the past 25 years indicates in the main that local authorities have acted with responsibility and due regard to the public interest. I am perfectly certain if we give them this authority, having behind it, as there is, the full power and authority of the courts of justice if they do not do what is right, the local authorities and every member of the local authorities will act very responsibly and sensibly in every decision taken regarding the powers and responsibilities vested in them by this section as drafted.

Comment on this

I do not know why Deputy Cowan says that there are no cases in which Ministers have not to get a report from certain named officials before they can make up their mind. It has been held in the courts that where a Minister signs some document without having had recourse to officers referred to in a statute his decision is null and void and that, in fact, he did not take the proper care, care imposed upon him by law, before he arrives at his decision.

Comment on this

He did not act in the public interest.

Comment on this

All we are concerned with is that before a local authority can decide to do something which may do damage they must have before them a report from their chief engineering officer. We know perfectly well that county councillors are not paid public men and cannot spend their time going around the 101 schemes proposed at the county council. The local man alone will know the circumstances, that flooding affects certain lands or buildings. If the rest of the people from other parts of the county have not a report from the engineer they will have to make up their minds upon the speech of somebody who is interested and who knows nothing about engineering. We want the local authority to take their decision after having received, and addressed themselves to the terms of, a report of a man qualified to give advice, a man who will have a certain permanent interest in the thing because his reputation will be based upon his report. No engineer will report that 200 or 300 acres of land can be drained by spending a couple of thousand pounds if damage of tens of thousands of pounds is going to be done without at least calling the attention of the county council to the fact that damage of tens of thousands of pounds might be done.

Deputy O'Higgins said that we should probe into motives. I do not want to probe into motives very deeply, but to whom is the Minister proposing to give the power to decide to drain land without even the report of a county council engineer? It is not the members elected by the voters of the county council area, but it may be under Section 3 a nominee of the Minister's. Under Section 3 where the Minister is satisfied, perhaps by the report of a deputy or by a letter from somebody down the country, that certain work should be done and if the local authority are unable or unwilling to execute the works he may nominate a person to carry them out and give to that person in relation to these works all the powers local authorities have. If we pass this particular clause without the amendment suggested by Deputy MacEntee, that individual will have power to execute works of all kinds which come under this Bill without even getting a report from a county council engineer.

Comment on this

The amendment does not cure that.

Comment on this

Yes, it does.

Comment on this

Read the amendment.

Comment on this

The authority under Section 3 may be the nominee of the Minister. We might read Deputy MacEntee's amendment that the local authority or the nominee of the Minister shall not proceed except upon the report of an engineer. There is no other interpretation.

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this

There is none and if the Deputy thinks he can make it I would ask him to tell me whether Section 3 does not substitute for the elected representatives of the people, the county council, the nominee of the Minister as the authority to decide whether one of these works is to be carried out or not.

Comment on this

It does, but it is not the same thing. There are two different problems.

Comment on this

The Deputy admits that it does substitute for the elected representatives of the people the Minister's nominee.

Comment on this

There is not much respect there for the elected representatives of the people.

Comment on this

What Coalition Deputies are afraid of is that we should write into the Bill that either the nominee of the Minister or the elected local authority should not decide to proceed with works which might cause more damage then they would cure without having received a report from the chief engineering officer of the people. We are not even asking that they shall not go ahead with the work, even if the engineer indicates that damage is to be done, but that at least before they decide to do it, and to do the damage, they will have before them and address themselves to the terms of an engineer's report.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

Yes.

Mr. Allen rose.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest that repetition is out of order.

Comment on this

I have not spoken on this.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not referring to the Deputy, but to the House in general. Some Deputies have made the same comments three times. If there is anything new it is all right.

Comment on this

I will say something new now. The most important thing to keep in mind in discussing this amendment is that, in sub-section (3) of this section, local authorities are being asked to take over and perform a new function not hitherto performed by them. That must be kept in mind, as it is fundamental to the whole argument. Under Section 2 of the Bill, you can have any machinery you like. The machinery is there to do it. It can be done in the future as in the past, under sub-section (2) of Section 2. There is no necessity to have this amendment at all in respect of that sub-section, but in sub-section (3) of Section 2 a very important matter comes to be considered.

We all know in our own areas the work that will fall to be done under that sub-section. We realise quite well the work that local authorities will be called upon to perform under it. All possible safeguards are necessary to safeguard the ratepayers of a particular area, to safeguard the people in general and to safeguard also the people on whose lands the local authority must enter. There are many people to be safeguarded under that sub-section. A huge amount of work will fall to be done in every county in Ireland under that sub-section. The whole function this Bill is meant to serve is all in that sub-section. That must be remembered. There was no necessity whatever—I said that on the Second Reading—for any legislation to give local authorities power to safeguard their own property. I never saw the necessity. They could carry out any work on any property or buildings they had, without legislation. Under this sub-section, there will devolve on local authorities matters and work which the Board of Works, in the ordinary course, if they had time to reach it, would be doing. They were organised to do it and have machinery and power under the 1945 Drainage Act to do it. They might not reach it for the next ten or 25 years.

Comment on this

That would be too long to wait.

Comment on this

It may be five—I will put it at five. Local authorities are being asked under sub-section (3) to perform that work of the Office of Public Works. Every possible safeguard is necessary. I want to put this to the Parliamentary Secretary and to the Minister for Local Government: is it the local authority in council, the elected members of the local authority, that will determine any particular matter in connection with this Bill, or is it their executive officer? There is nothing in this Bill and nothing in any Ministerial amendment to show that. Is all the work under this Bill not an executive function?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

Why look for safeguards, then?

Comment on this

All the more reason for having them.

Comment on this

If it is an executive function of the manager?

Comment on this

Let the Parliamentary Secretary not walk into it for a moment. It is clearly admitted now that it is an executive function, that the elected members of the local authority, the democratically elected members, have no say, good, bad or indifferent, in this Bill except with the goodwill or otherwise of the manager. Is not that so? Let us be honest and frank about it. Let us realise what we are doing and understand that, in asking that, before the county manager undertakes to carry out the drainage work in any county, he must have the report of the chief engineer before him. Will the Minister say who will determine the order of priority in which any of the works, listed and already in the Minister's Department from all over the Twenty-six Counties, are to be carried out? Who will select the works in the particular areas and who will determine the amount of money to be spent on each work? That is a most important matter and we would like to have these questions answered. Is there anything unreasonable in suggesting—even if the county councils, that is the members of the county councils, had the determination of this matter, as to whether work is to be carried out or not—that before determining it, they should have the report of the chief engineer before them? Is there anything unreasonable in asking a sensible body of men to have the report of their chief engineer before they decide whether it is feasible, sensible and justifiable to carry out a particular work? I cannot see in what way bringing in the engineer into these two sub-sections is going to hold up the work. It will not hold it up in the slightest. Every local authority in Ireland wants to go on with the work that has to be done. We object in principle to more work being thrown over on local authorities and their staffs. I said on the Second Stage that they were ill-equipped to carry out the work they were going to be called upon to carry out under sub-section (3) of Section 2. However, they will take on this work willingly and members of local authorities will put their full weight and influence behind it to get as much as possible done. They may have to neglect other work.

Comment on this

So well they ought.

Comment on this

They may have to employ a great many engineers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does that arise on the amendment?

Comment on this

It arises under this amendment because the amendment says the report must be made to the council by the chief engineer before a work is undertaken and in order to get that report he will need assistance— and very substantial assistance—that he may not have available at the moment. I hope the Minister will see the wisdom of accepting this, or even agreeing to consider the matter for the Report Stage. I do not know whether that will be satisfactory or not. He might give it further consideration and tell us now whether it is the members of the local authority, by a majority or unanimously, in a functional area, that will have the determination of these matters or whether it is their chief executive officer. It does not make any difference, on this point. I have every confidence that the county managers all over Ireland will do the work honestly and well. I have no objection to their doing it, but there need not be so much talk here about local authorities, in some instances, hindering this work. So far as I know local authorities, the members are the same as ourselves—no better and no worse—and they will do any job they are asked to do as honestly as any of us on any side of the House would do it. I suggest that the Parliamentary Secretary should accept the amendment in principle.

Comment on this

It is hard to understand the contradictory lines of argument put forward by the Opposition. Deputy Smith and Deputy Moran were very fearful about the actions of certain local authorities—or of one local authority, as one of the Deputies said—in the matter of carrying out works which would cause a great deal of damage. It is hard to reconcile these statements with the generally accepted principle by the Fianna Fáil Party of county management. It is not news for members on this side of the House to say what their general attitude towards the members of local authorities is and always has been. Shortly after the new Government was formed, we announced that it was intended to amend substantially the County Management Act. We are not going to be forced, on this amendment, into a position in which we will change it in any piecemeal fashion. The county manager, as the law stands, is responsible for the control and direction of staff, and surely, therefore, no member of the Fianna Fáil Party, which has always been such a champion of the County Management Act, and county managers in general, will think other than that the manager, in respect of such works as these, will advise the local authority and direct that the county engineer will give the benefit of his advice before schemes like these are carried out. Deputy Smith started off by asking how could a local authority make up its mind to carry out a certain scheme without having the chief engineering officer's report before it. How can a local authority engage in any housing scheme without having the report of the chief engineering officer or town surveyor before it?

Comment on this

Do they?

Comment on this

They do, of course. The members of local authorities do not decide themselves on the design of houses and the different methods of construction.

Comment on this

There is no comparison.

Comment on this

There is, of course. Local authorities do not engage in any work whatever—and the Deputy knows it—without first having the report of the town surveyor or county engineer. I do not think there need be the slightest fear that local authorities will not, as they have always done, and as we expect they will do in the future, take the advice and guidance of their expert advisers. As Deputy Cowan said, and as I repeat, it is reasonable to assume that the Minister, before he proposes to effect a change or to carry out any scheme of works, will take the advice of his Departmental secretary, of his legal advisers and of his technical advisers; but there is no provision to that effect in any Act which went through this House. I do not think there is the slightest necessity at all to have such a provision in the section and I do not see why we are arguing about it, because, under the County Management Act, which we propose to change substantially, this power is vested at present in the county manager. We do not, however, propose to amend it in any piecemeal fashion.

Comment on this

Our view is that, whether it be the manager or the council has the responsibility, the amendment should be accepted.

Comment on this

If the county manager's authority becomes vested in the Minister's nominee, will he act without a report from the county engineer?

Comment on this

No; naturally, he will get expert advice as well.

Comment on this

Why not oblige him to do it?

Comment on this

There is no necessity for it. There is no similar provision in other Bills of this kind, as the Deputy knows.

Comment on this

Of course, there is.

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary answer the questions I asked? Who is to determine the order of priority and who will select the work that is to be done? Is it the Minister or the local authority, acting through the manager? Suppose there are 700 different works already lodged in the Department. Who will determine the priority?

Comment on this

I do not think it arises on this amendment but, for the benefit of the Deputy, I will read for him a circular sent to each county manager on this Bill.

Comment on this

What date?

Comment on this

31st May. It reads:

"With reference to previous correspondence, I am directed by the Minister for Local Government to inform you that, as soon as the Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949, becomes law, decisions will be issued on the various schedules of schemes submitted to the Department for the purposes of the Bill. First preference will be given to simple schemes not requiring elaborate surveys or preparation, which may be undertaken without delay in an appropriate period in the present financial year. It is therefore recommended that a selection on these lines be made from the schemes submitted and that particulars thereof be placed before the elected body concerned for their preliminary approval."

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 64
·
Níl 54
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The decision, I assume, governs the cognate amendment No. 4, which was discussed with amendment No. 3.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:—

Before sub-section (4) to insert two new sub-sections as follows:—

( ) The expression "permanent construction" in the foregoing sub-section shall include piers, marine works, sea walls and embankments and any roads, causeways, road foundations or passageways between the mainland and any island or islands adjacent thereto.

( ) Subject to the provisions of this Act a local authority may proceed to repair, reconstruct, enlarge or raise any permanent construction described in the foreging sub-section of this section irrespective of any sailing or navigation rights or any profits-a-prendre or easement alleged to be in existence over any channel or passageway between the mainland and adjacent islands.

The definition of "permanent construction", as contained in this Bill, is limited to roads, bridges, houses, buildings, walls and embankments. To my mind, that definition would not cover marine works, piers or embankments in maritime counties where the danger of subsidence, flooding and so forth is much more serious in some of these cases than it actually is inland. There is another matter which I should like to point out to the House, namely, that a work under the Bill may mean the building of a house that is, for instance, undermined, in a town. If through undermining, due to flooding or subsidence, a house inland is or may be injured there is provision in the Bill to deal with that matter and to provide for it. If there is provision to deal with matters of that kind which occur inland, there is all the more reason why similar provision should be made with reference to inundation by the sea.

Those of us who come from maritime counties know that we have several instances of houses being undermined due to erosion and flooding by the sea where proper embankments are not provided. So, when we are making this provision for the people who live inland, there is the very same reason, if not a much stronger reason, I submit to the House, for making similar provision for the people who are living around the coast. In addition, you have a peculiar position arising with reference to roads or the making of roads and passageways between some islands in maritime counties and the mainland. There is one particular place which I have in mind in my own county in which a sum of money was expended by the Board of Works on the construction of a road between an island known as Inishnakillew in Clew Bay and the mainland. All the people in this island gave their consent for the work to be done but the Board of Works did not finish the work that particular year. Then an agitation was started by a gentleman on the mainland. He got some of the people to go back on the consent they had previously given. The result now is that that work is there and it is half submerged. It is all right when the tide is out but when it is in some of the people claim navigation rights. One solitary individual has been responsible for all that and his sole purpose was obstruction. I think that that is a matter that should be covered. I have tried to provide for it in this particular sub-section so as to enable the local authorities to go ahead with works of this kind—and not be held up by the frivolous objection of one particular individual—where it is a matter of public policy in the interests of the people concerned.

These are the main purposes of the introduction of these two amendments. First, to provide through "permanent construction" that we will be able to deal with serious questions of flooding and inundation and in some cases to build embankments to stop encroachment by the sea, particularly where houses are endangered. As I have said, we are making provision for that in regard to houses inland and there is no reason why the people on the coast should not be entitled to those same facilities we are providing in principle under this Bill. Secondly, to deal with the question of works which are quite important to the islands adjoining the mainland. We have a number of these small islands in coastal counties that have to be provided for and whose roads may be flooded or wiped out or interfered with as a result of inundation by the sea.

Comment on this

On a point of order. May I ask if this amendment is in order, having regard to the fact that we have already passed Section 1 in which the term "permanent construction" had been defined and that term is used only, as far as I can see, in Section 2? If we have already defined it in Section 1, are we entitled to put in a second definition after Section 2?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It should more properly go with the interpretation section. Whether it would be in order, therefore, is another question. It would, in the interpretation section. Does the Deputy mean the second portion of this amendment?

Comment on this

Well, the first portion——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It more properly belongs to the interpretation section.

Comment on this

In Section 1 we have already defined "permanent construction".

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This amendment should have been there.

Comment on this

We use the expression "permanent construction" in Section 2 only and this is another definition which will create trouble. I submit, with respect, that it is not in order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It should have been earlier in the Bill. I am allowing it and, if it is passed, it will have to go in earlier in the Bill. It is not necessarily out of order by not being tabled in the right place.

Comment on this

I accept what the Ceann Comhairle says.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have doubts myself on it. In fact, I have just asked the question.

Comment on this

On that point. Since the amendment says that "The expression ‘permanent construction' in the foregoing sub-section..." is it not quite proper that such a special definition may appear elsewhere than in the interpretation section of the Bill?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The same applies to the next one. It might be where it is, but I think it would be more proper in the interpretation section. I see the Deputy's point, too.

Comment on this

We may take it that, as the Ceann Comhairle has ruled, we cannot raise the matter again with the Leas-Cheann Comhairle? I do not want to do that——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

On the other hand I think that the second sub-section is out of order. I submit that the amendment is completely outside the scope of the Bill. If one refers to the Long Title it will be seen that this is an Act to enable certain local authorities to execute works affording relief or protection from flooding, landslide, subsidence and similar occurrences and to provide for matters connected with the matters aforesaid. There is no reference at all to that in the amendment. It would appear to me that the object is to enable local authorities to construct, enlarge, repair or raise causeways and piers, namely, causeways leading to the sea. It was not intended that such matters be dealt with in this Bill. I think it must be agreed that such works would be more appropriate to a Coast Erosion or a Marine Works Bill.

Comment on this

I submit that this amendment is quite in order. I respectfully point out to the House that the amendment starts: "Subject to the provisions of this Act..." That means that the work that would be done under this section is subject to the provision, including the Long Title. What I have in mind would be damage as a result of inundation by the sea, subsidence due to the sea or erosion due to the sea. It is flooding, at all events, and it is subject to the provisions of this Bill. I am suggesting to the House that it is very important that, when we are providing this relief for houses collapsing in inland areas, for instance, it is just as important that damage by the sea should be dealt with too.

Comment on this

I submit that the words "Subject to the provisions of this Act" refer to the actual carrying out of the scheme rather than to the method of entering on land, claims for compensation and things like that which are mentioned specifically in the Bill.

Comment on this

Subject to the whole of the provisions of the Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

"Subject to the provisions of this Act" seems to make the amendment in order. It provides a saving for the work which the amendment proposes to carry out. I am ruling that the amendment is in order.

Comment on this