We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949—Committee.

Contributions 200–405 of 405. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 8 of 1949 ›

In any case, I am not prepared to accept the amendment inasmuch as it involves the big problem of coast erosion which would require a rather lengthy Bill. Works to prevent coast erosion and other matters mentioned in the amendment could not be dealt with effectively under the provisions of this Bill.

Comment on this

Might I again urge on the Parliamentary Secretary to consider these amendments? We had it on the last section that a local authority in its discretion can proceed through the county manager, or however it may work out, to pick and choose works in one form and another. The mere fact of accepting the amendments does not mean that every single piece of coast erosion will be dealt with. Can the Parliamentary Secretary not see that we are making provision in this Bill for the repairing of walls and embankments, that there are many roads on the sea coast which badly need walls and embankments and that there are many houses on the sea coast that badly need protection. I know of some houses that have had to be abandoned owing to the action of the sea. We will be coming up against these difficulties on the sea coast more than inland. For instance, if a house in any town or its foundations are threatened by flooding, we are making provision to deal with that. Are not ratepayers in a coastal area entitled to as much attention as people in the towns?

Comment on this

As it is, that type of person and that type of construction are covered.

Comment on this

I cannot see how they are covered. If they were covered, I would not be moving this amendment. The Parliamentary Secretary says it is possible to deal with erosion. If he can satisfy me that matters of the kind I have mentioned can be dealt with under the Bill without this amendment I am quite satisfied, but I cannot see that from the Bill. I suggest that, as the Bill stands, marine works or anything of that nature are not covered. I am giving the Parliamentary Secretary an instance of a house built beside the sea which is threatened by coast erosion. Will the Parliamentary Secretary assure me that under the Bill we are entitled to build an embankment against the ravages of the sea in order to protect that house?

Comment on this

I have no idea of the place the Deputy has in mind, but I can conjure up a picture of the sea eating into the foundations of a house. The provision of an embankment in my opinion, and I expect in the opinion of a local authority, would not be sufficient to ensure that the same thing would not happen again. Dealing with the flooding of roads or the flooding of lands is entirely different from dealing with the force of sea water and consequent flooding. If a local authority considered it was feasible and that the work undertaken would be permanent, I would imagine they would carry it out. If a local authority feel that a pier or embankment is in danger from sea flooding, they can undertake works under this Bill to prevent that. It would, however, be hard to include other things which the Deputy has in his amendment, such as passageways between the mainland and any island or islands adjacent thereto. He will readily appreciate that local authorities will be very reluctant to accept the slightest responsibility for coast erosion. As a matter of fact, I do not think any Department of State at present has any responsibility for coast erosion.

Comment on this

I cannot follow the Parliamentary Secretary, because in one breath he says that we cannot go so wide as to take in coast erosion under this Bill and, in the next breath, he says that protection can be given by means of embankments and so forth against the action of the waves which cause coast erosion. On which leg is he standing? We have just turned down an amendment to Section 3 which gives to the Minister's nominee and to the county council's manager, if the section goes through, the right to carry out works even without receiving a report from an engineer. Damage may be done through such procedure. One thing in regard to which you can safely give a county manager or an non-technical man the assurance that he could not do any damage is protection against the force of the waves. Small coastal works have been carried out in the way of embankments and so forth to protect roads against sea erosion. I know of one case in County Louth where a road was being undermined and certain houses were threatened and under the minor improvements scheme the Office of Public Works carried out protective embankment works.

The difficulty about this Bill so far as I can see is that it is going to replace the minor improvements scheme and the rural improvement scheme and we will not be able to get as much done under it as we were able to do under these schemes. The whole tendency will be to carry out employment and relief works under the provisions of the Bill rather than under the minor employment branch of the Office of Public Works. I think we should make provision, therefore, in this Bill to ensure that the local authorities or the Minister's nominee, if he appoints a substitute for the local authorities, should have the power to do what the Board of Works have done for the relief of employment and for the improvement of drainage and transport facilities for the people and also protective embankments against the encroachment of the sea. The county manager or the Minister's nominee cannot do any harm even if he proceeds without the report of the engineer.

There are several other matters that are mentioned as well as the protection of piers and sea-walls and embankments. There are also causeways between the mainland and islands off the west coast. I think it is important that where the roads were half-built and were held up because some people withdrew their consent to a work which they had originally consented to, we should, when passing a Bill like this, give the local authority power to go ahead and complete the work and put it into such a state of repair as to enable the people to get from the mainland to the islands.

Comment on this

It must be very obvious that this is not a serious contribution to the Bill. One wonders if it is even intended to be a serious contribution. It envisages completely new departures from the work envisaged in the Bill itself. Deputy Moran admitted that he was asking for something outside the scope of what the Bill is intended to do. It is clearly shown that it is:—

"An Act to enable certain local authorities to execute works affording relief or protection from flooding, landslides, subsidence and similar occurrences and to provide for matters connected with the matters aforesaid."

The intention of the amendment is to tag on to that measure appeals for piers, marine works, sea-walls and embankments and so on. It is obviously a matter that would call for completely new legislation outside the scope of this Bill. Some of the piers are State owned, some are privately owned and there is such a welter of possibilities in my mind suggested in this amendment that one might wonder if he wanted this Bill to go through for the purpose intended. I think we should overthrow this attempt to overload the Bill by the introduction of matter which is completely irrelevant to it.

Comment on this

Whether these amendments in connection with this question are proper or not I leave it to any member of this House coming from a maritime county to decide. I suggest to the Minister that subsidence of these piers and marine works due to the action of the sea would possibly occur quicker than it would occur through the action of a river in connection with some inland works. Again, I appeal to the Minister on this question. Does he not realise that under this Bill we propose to take on work that was never done by a local authority before, that was never owned by a local authority and that a local authority had nothing to do with? To anybody who comes from a maritime county these are some of the matters that are just as urgent as the flooding that you have inland. As a matter of fact, in some cases they are much more urgent. I have in mind cases in which houses are gravely threatened on the edge of the coast by the action of the sea. I cannot see the cogency of the argument that that should not be done in that case, whereas a similar subsidence due to the action of fresh water can be done. If they do it in one case they are entitled to it in the other.

As for the other amendment I have down here I can assure the Minister I was not wasting my time drafting amendments without having some idea behind them. I am telling the Minister now that the Parliamentary Secretary in charge of the Board of Works can tell him the truth of what I have stated before in this House in connection with some of the causeways between the islands and the mainland in Clew Bay. I refer specifically to one, and that is the causeway road from Inniskillew Island to the mainland. It is quite obvious to any Deputy in this House that you are liable to have subsidence and erosion much more in the case of a road that is subjected to flooding by sea water than you will have inland. These are matters that we are coming up against down the country. I think this is the proper Bill to provide for these matters. I am not suggesting that under this amendment you should pass outside the scope of the Bill. In other words, relief would be given where you have subsidence or the wiping out of roads or embankments due to sea action. This is due to flooding, too, and is a matter which is being dealt with by this Bill. When we are making these provisions for inland people the same thing should be done for the people on the coast.

I quite agree with the Minister that possibly many local authorities would not take on the responsibilities contained in this Bill at all; that is, as far as all the sections following sub-section 2 are concerned. Local authorities, in the main, if any other Department or the State would carry out drainage, would not be anxious to take on this work. I am sure many members of local authorities listening to me tonight hold that view just as strongly as I do. However, we are assured by the Minister that the funds are going to be provided by the State for works under this Bill. When that is being done, if local authorities are going to carry out some of the jobs of drainage and so forth that have been thrust on them for the first time, there is no reason why they should not take on the responsibility of dealing with these matters that arise along the coast as well.

Of course, there is this. We will come to these points later on, as to who is going to pay for the future maintenance of these works. This is a question which will agitate the minds of many members of local authorities here and throughout the country. At all events, if we assume that the State wants to have this work done and that the State is now going to push over on local authorities the duty of doing these works that were formerly carried out by the Board of Works or some other Department of State, when they are taking on the responsibility of one type of work I do not see any reason why they should not also be prepared to do the other works of a similar nature that are provided for in my amendment.

Comment on this

There is one point I should like to make. According to the design of this Bill as introduced, where work is carried out by a local authority or the Minister's nominee and causes damage the damage will have to be paid for by the local authority. We are moving later on in this Bill that the damage should be met by the State.

In this particular section moved by Deputy Moran there is going to be no damage. Are the Parliamentary Secretary and the Government relying upon the fact that local authorities will have to pay the damages to influence them not to carry out work? Why is the Parliamentary Secretary in this particular case, not accepting the amendment when the works can be carried out without doing damage to anybody, because nobody can hurt the sea? If we keep it from sweeping away a piece of land it is not going to hurt people over in America. They cannot claim damages for it. I think that, under a Bill of this kind, we should give the people along the seacoast some benefits. They will have to pay when works are carried out for other people in their area. Everyone acquainted with our seacoasts knows that quite an amount of damage is being done by coast erosion. In some cases the expenditure of a few pounds would help to stop that erosion. By the erection of very slight works you can use the power of the sea to sweep in sand and rocks and so help to defend the land against the further encroachment of the waves.

I would appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister to accept this amendment and make it quite clear that this is a type of work that can be proceeded with. It is more urgent to protect good land or a good building from attack by the sea than it is to relieve some classes of land from water. We all know that there is a lot of land that is high and dry above water that is being flooded and cannot be drained. We also know that there is a lot of land under water which, if it were drained, would be as useless as some of the land above water. In this case there is no question of the county engineer or the Minister's nominee going to engage on works to protect land against sea erosion unless it is worth saving. A calculation can be made as to the value of the land and the cost of the works. I think that the Deputy's amendment is a very reasonable one, and that it should be accepted by the Government.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 52
·
Níl 63
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 7, 8 and 9 all deal with the liabilities of local authorities—trying to lessen or abolish them—and I suggest the debate should take place on No. 7, which is the widest amendment, and the decision might also cover amendments Nos. 22 and 35 and the third part of amendment No. 10.

Comment on this
John Flynn Mr. J. Flynn Independent

I am sorry I was not here in time to move amendment No. 6.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is late. The amendment was called but was not moved. However, if the Deputy will see the Minister, he will be satisfied that the point of his amendment is covered.

Comment on this
John Flynn Mr. J. Flynn Independent

I merely want to get that assurance.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are now at amendments Nos. 7, 8 and 9 and the subject-matter of these amendments will be discussed on amendment No. 7. The debate, as I have said, will also cover amendments Nos. 22 and 35 and, if Deputies will look at the third part of amendment No. 10, that is also covered. It refers to liability.

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7, on behalf of Deputy MacEntee:—

Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

( ) Should a local authority execute works under this section no liability of any kind shall attach to the local authority in respect of such works.

This Bill, which was announced to the country as a Bill to do a lot of ameliorative work, drainage and so forth, at the expense of the State, was promised when the Government withdrew a couple of million pounds for the reconstruction of roads. It was the Central Authority that was giving this money to the local authorities to build the roads and our contention is that whatever work is carried out under this Bill, it should be on the responsibility of the central Exchequer.

We have had a couple of amendments turned down already by the Government, amendments which were designed to secure that where damage was done in an attempt to give benefit to certain districts or to certain people, that that damage should be minimised by having proper inquiries made before the work was undertaken. The Government did not agree to our amendments and we hold that if a county manager or a Minister's nominee is to proceed with work which may cause grave damage and be of very little benefit, the Minister and the Government should guarantee the local authority against any action for damage. I know one case where a Government Department urged on by a Minister spent a few thousand pounds in an attempt to drain poor, marshy land. The result was that good land further downstream was flooded. There was agitation in the district adversely affected by those flood waters for a number of years and all sorts of steps had to be taken in order to relieve the local authority so that they, in turn, would relieve the farmers adversely affected by the flood waters let down. The Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary refuse to accept an amendment which will give the local authority, the Minister's nominee, power to carry out works where no damage could be caused. It appears to me that they are insisting upon keeping this penalty upon the local authority by way of compensation for damage done so that there will be a break and an impediment upon such authority in the carrying out of these works.

We have had numerous instances of where the present Government has postponed or put into abeyance schemes which were doing good work and have substituted therefor a nebulous promise that they will do something better in the future. We had that experience in connection with land improvements. It looks to me as if the Government are going to insist that the local authority bear the cost of all the damage that may be done under this Bill in substitution for their promise to do something better in the knowledge that the local authorities will not undertake the risk involved in the carrying out of whatever work might be done. I hope that the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary will agree that when this Bill was introduced it was represented as something which would fulfil a long-felt want and do great good in relieving lands subject to flooding and that the entire cost would be carried out at the expense of the State. It was claimed that this was very much superior to the rural improvements scheme and minor relief schemes and other measures under which improvement works were carried out in the past. This was supposed to be a Bill that would cut out all red tape and white tape and green tape and get on with the work.

It seems to me that, as the Bill stands, with the penalty upon the local authorities in attempting to carry out the work of an unknown amount of damage for which they will be responsible, very little work will be done. Certainly less work will be done under this Bill than would have been done had the Government carried on in a normal fashion with the minor relief schemes and the rural improvement scheme. Under the rural improvement scheme everyone affected knew what they were facing and what they had to pay.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it in order to open up these other systems?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I shall not allow the Deputy to proceed any further on that line. I will remind him to deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

They were limited and the cost was 25 per cent. of the total amount.

Comment on this

Are these amendments in order?

Comment on this

They have been so ruled.

Comment on this

Surely if these amendments are passed they will clearly involve a charge on public funds because the amendments stipulate that the local authorities are not to pay for these works. There is only one other authority which can be mulcted.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

An amendment, in order to be ruled out of order, must specifically set out that the work is to be a charge on public funds. It does not so specifically state here.

Comment on this

But clearly they will be a charge on public funds.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle has ruled the amendments are in order. My point is that under these other schemes the limit of payment on the part of the local beneficiaries was 25 per cent. of the work carried out. In this particular case work may be carried out and money may be spent on work which may cost many times the money spent in compensation. If that is going to be done in order that this Government may show a "new look" I think the Government should pay for their "new look". Under the old schemes the central Government paid.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has said that before and I have warned him. He must not contrast this amendment with any other scheme. He must argue as to whether this amendment should or should not be accepted.

Comment on this

We have five amendments being discussed at the one time and all of them are designed to limit the liability on the local authorities and on the farmers concerned and to get the State to carry out the promise which it made, through the mouths of its Ministers, when this Bill was first mooted. This Bill was supposed to be some compensation to those people unemployed because of the cut in the road grants. It was to do great work for the farmers. If the farmers whose lands may be flooded owing to lack of proper precautions—even the lack of a report from the county engineer before the scheme is decided upon—have to pay portion of their own compensation I do not think this is a proposition which would have the consent of the House or those people in particular who are frightened about all the improvements that are going to be done on the land and all that is going to be done for the relief of unemployment. It is of little good to a farmer to have Ministers making fine speeches about the improvement of his land if, instead of improving that land, they flood good land and compel the farmer to pay for it. If they call the tune they must pay the piper. Our suggestion is that the State should ensure the local authority will not be mulcted with heavy costs and compensation on foot of this Bill

Comment on this

Again, it is hard to understand the approach of the Opposition to this Bill. I have a very distinct recollection of Deputy MacEntee saying on the Second Reading of this particular Bill that it would not give 1,000 men work for one week and now we have Deputy Aiken afraid we are going to do too much work under this Bill. So far as compensation is concerned, the local authorities were aware three months ago that they would be liable for compensation. Despite the fact that every single local authority knew that they would be liable for compensation they have submitted to the Department for approval by the Minister schemes amounting to £2,000,000. No matter what Deputy Aiken may think of local authorities, they are not such fools as he would have us believe they are.

Comment on this

That is the county managers.

Comment on this

Whatever you like to call them.

Comment on this

The county managers.

Comment on this

I can say "local authorities", because it was Deputy Aiken and the present critics of this Bill who introduced the County Management Act under which the county manager was to be regarded as the local authority.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary accept an amendment to give these powers to elected representatives on the local authorities?

Comment on this

No, but the County Management Act will be repealed in due course and I do not know whether Deputy Aiken will support that.

Comment on this

When the cows come home.

Comment on this

They will come home very quickly so far as Deputy Aiken is concerned. The local authorities have submited schemes amounting to £2,000,000 and they are fully aware of the fact that they will be liable for compensation. So far as the Bill generally is concerned, it is an enabling Bill and there is no obligation on any local authority to engage in any works provided for under the Bill but, in conjunction with the introduction of the Bill, an announcement was made by the late Minister that 100 per cent. grants would be given for these works. I do not think that that is unreasonable and I do not think that any member of a local authority who is a member of this House objected very strongly on the Second Reading to the fact that local authorities would be liable for compensation. In any case, if Deputy Aiken wants to take it that way, it is a safeguard. If a local authority or as he likes to call it, the county manager, knows that it will be liable for compensation, that is an adequate safeguard.

Comment on this

The county manager does not pay rates.

Comment on this

You should have told that to Deputy MacEntee when he was introducing his County Management Act. They are fully aware that they have to pay compensation. The very fact that compensation has to be paid by the local authority is a safeguard. No local authority is going to engage in any scheme which will involve it in any colossal expenditure. Deputy Aiken also suggested that works under this Bill were being substituted for rural improvement schemes and minor relief schemes. Of course he knows that provision has been made in the Estimates for rural improvement schemes and minor relief schemes and that these schemes will be carried out as usual. He mentioned that this was another attempt to bind local authorities with red tape legislation, but I suggest that all these amendments are so much red tape and white tape—the Deputy mentioned every single colour in the rainbow—the only intention of which is to make it impossible for local authorities to carry out any works under this Bill. There is a complete change of front so far as this Bill is concerned on the Opposition Benches. There is no similar provision, as the Deputy suggests should be inserted by this amendment, in the Local Government Act of 1925 which places the responsibility for the construction and maintenance of roads on the local authority. In that particular Act, responsibility is imposed on local authorities to maintain and construct roads and there is no question of the money involved at all. The grants are announced from year to year. In conjunction with the introduction of this Bill, it was announced that 100 per cent. grants would be given and from the returns we have received from local authorities we believe that they are well satisfied with the Bill.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Parliamentary Secretary is hedging to an enormous extent on these amendments. He said that the local authorities were consulted.

Comment on this

I did not say that the local authorities were consulted.

Comment on this

He said that the local authorities were consulted and when Deputy Aiken mentioned that it was the county managers who were consulted, he said that that was the local authority.

Comment on this

I said that they were well aware of the fact that they were liable for compensation.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied that the local authorities were not consulted, and if the local authorities were not consulted I do not know how they submitted schemes and I do not know how the Parliamentary Secretary got all the schemes which he says he received from them. The Parliamentary Secretary may tell us that the local authorities need not undertake any work in which they will be involved in considerable expense. The local authority may not undertake the work but the Minister can then nominate an individual to carry out the work.

Comment on this

In certain circumstances.

Comment on this

Having regard to the fact that these certain circumstances may arise, I think we should have the safeguards that are suggested in these amendments.

Comment on this

What safeguards does the Deputy want in these amendments?

Comment on this

I want the safeguard that the local authorities will not be saddled with the heavy expenditure that may be incurred by the individual the Minister may nominate to do the work.

Comment on this

The Deputy may have misunderstood me. What I said was that local authorities were aware of the fact that they would be liable for compensation but, even knowing that, they sent on schemes for approval involving an expenditure of £2,000,000.

Comment on this

Did the local authorities send them up or did the county managers plus the engineers send them up? That is what I am anxious to know. When we are talking about local authorities I take it that we are talking about members of the county councils.

Comment on this

These schemes were submitted to the elected members of the county councils in most cases.

Comment on this

So far as the elected representatives of one county council is concerned, they were not submitted.

Comment on this
Michael Donnellan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Donnellan) Clann na Talmhan

That is most surprising considering that Deputy Killilea is a member of the General Council of County Councils. Surely he is aware of the fact that they appointed a deputation to point out the great necessity for this type of Bill——

Comment on this

That is not relevant to the amendment.

Comment on this

When that deputation came to the Board of Works they did not even ask for the 100 per cent. provision. They were willing to accept the clause as it is, that if they did any damage they would accept responsibility, that it was their own look-out.

Comment on this

If we are to discuss the General Council of County Councils——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The General Council of County Councils does not arise.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary could raise the matter——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary said that the General Council of County Councils would accept liability.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary was in order——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary was in order in the view of the Chair.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary raised the question that the General Council of County Councils did certain things. I have been discussing with the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government the question of local authorities, meaning county councils. I do not at this stage believe that this Bill is a matter for the Board of Works. I think it is a matter for the Local Government Department. The Board of Works have a lot to do if they would only go and do it.

Comment on this

They are doing more than ever you did.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Galway Deputies would fight it out in Galway and let us get on——

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary in order in interrupting?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We have one on each side and they are both from Galway.

Comment on this

These amendments get down to the whole kernel of this Bill and the Parliamentary Secretary let the cat out of the bag when he suggested that the fact that local authorities would be saddled with the payment of compensation would discourage them from going ahead with the schemes permitted under this Bill. The Parliamentary Secretary said something to the effect that the Opposition were changing front in connection with this matter. If he was listening to the Second Reading of this Bill he will remember quite well—and the House will remember quite well—how strenuously we opposed the suggestion that local authorities and the ratepayers throughout the country should become liable for some of the charges which will arise under this Bill. This Bill at that time was held up as the be-all and end-all of the Coalition Government's policy to provide employment. It was announced here from Ministerial level that all the people who had become disemployed on the roads would find work under this. We now find that the Parliamentary Secretary has announced this evening that it is only intended to do very small jobs. But let the jobs be small or large, I think that what members of local authorities who are members of this House are interested in is this: if there is going to be no damage or if the damage is going to be negligible, why not provide for the payment for that damage? Why put it on the local authorities? Who is going to pay the necessary officials who will be required by the local authority for the administration of works under the Bill if any work is going to be done? Every member of a local authority knows that officials' time, particularly engineers' time, is already fully occupied and is it not obvious that if any work is going to be done it will involve the employment of quite a number of engineers? With the salaries these gentlemen receive at the present time that will be no joke for the local authorities. In addition to that—again if any work is going to be done—a considerable amount of clerical staff will be needed to work with the professional gentlemen to supervise and prepare these schemes for the local authority.

Another matter that is really as important as the damage that might be done is the maintenance of these works. We all know that it is a waste of time to spend money on compensation for damage unless money is provided for maintenance. Who will bear the cost if, as the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister have said, a considerable amount of work will be done under the Bill with relief to farmers all over the country as a result? Those of us who are members of local authorities know already that the rates have reached a very high level. On local authorities we deal with matters of urgent importance and we know that we have to put off many schemes because we feel that the ratepayers would not be able to provide the additional rates necessary to carry them out. In addition to paying for the damage and for the necessary officials, it is proposed to provide in the Bill that the local authorities, or the ratepayers through their local authorities, will have to pay for the future maintenance of these works.

Many of us who are members of local authorities know that a number of works done under the 1935 drainage code had to be taken over by local authorities under the 1945 Drainage Act. They had to take over the upkeep of them and, although provision was very limited, we had to keep them at the same level as that at which we took them over, but even that—I know in my own county—involved a very, very heavy burden indeed on the ratepayers to meet that annually recurring expenditure. If, as the Minister would have us believe, a lot of drainage will be done under this Bill and if the local authorities have to accept responsibility for its maintenance, it will be a crushing burden on them. When the Parliamentary Secretary made that statement he let the cat out of the bag because he knows that when local authorities know that they are going to be responsible for the raising of these moneys they will say: "We cannot bite off more than we can chew. We will not do the works we could do under this Bill because it is beyond our capacity to pay for them." The Minister is taking power, under Section 3 in connection with any works which he considers should be done by local authorities if the local authorities even on grounds of expense turn it down having examined the question on its merits, to send John Brown down from the Department——

Comment on this

Do not mind John Brown.

Comment on this

Call him Pat Jones if you like. He can carry out the works and the local authority will be liable for the expense of any damage caused by them and for future maintenance.

Comment on this

John Brown is on pension.

Comment on this

These are matters of vital importance as far as local authorities are concerned. We can visualise the type of work that will be carried on, say, drainage. If, as was pointed out on the Second Reading, fishery rights are interfered with you could run into very heavy damages. You could have serious flooding, as was pointed out by, I think, Deputy Aiken, between one county and another. If more water is released than the main waterway can take you may have serious consequences. Before a local authority could embark on schemes of that kind they would have to see where those schemes would lead them and I want to know where the Minister's proposal comes in that all the unemployed are going to find employment on them. The rights of mill owners on rivers are also concerned if they are interfered with, because, you must remember, under this Bill we take the power of diversion of water. It would mean that very heavy damages would be incurred and the ratepayers, under this Bill, are left with the responsibility to pay for all that.

If these amendments, or at least some of them, are not accepted—the first amendment is rather a general one, the second provides for the work plus the damage, and the third for the works if the Minister is not prepared to pay for the damage—this Bill will be completely illusory. Local authorities will have no scope to do the work they want to do, as they will be scalded with the charges that will arise. Members of local authorities know that every year different councillors put in a number of works which are dealt with at the annual meeting—the taking over of roads, and so on—but these are always put on the long finger and put off to the following year, when it is pointed out that they would cost thousands of pounds, as the local authorities are not prepared to undertake such cost. In the same way, if the local authorities are to be responsible for damage caused in doing these works, for the payment of the officials, administrators and clerical staffs, and above all for the maintenance, they will not be prepared to face the ratepayers with those high demands and the Bill will be illusory and futile.

If the Minister is sincere in trying to get local authorities to go ahead with the drainage we all want done and if there is not going to be much danger of great damage, why spoil the ship for a ha'port of tar? If he is providing money for the actual works and there will be little or no resultant damage, why not throw in the cost of the damage? Why not accept responsibility for that very small minor issue —which he suggests it is—when he is accepting responsibility for the major issue?

There is no word in the Bill to support the Minister's statement that the full amount of money necessary will be provided. The Minister undertook that, but that may be for this year only. Next year we may find a local authority asked to put up 10 or 15 per cent. locally, as in the case of road grants. Other Acts state that the money will be provided by the Oireachtas. This Bill contains no suggestion as to who will provide the money or what amount will be given. We have nothing but the Minister's statement when introducing it. He said he would give the full amount for the actual execution of the works, but there is no provision there for the future. This Minister may not be there next year and his successor may ask the local authority to provide 40 or 50 per cent. locally. Local authorities should be assured of full protection against claims for damage and should be assured about future maintenance, if they are to use this Bill fully. It is incorrect for the Parliamentary Secretary to suggest that the members of local authorities, as we know them, realise that they will have to pay for the maintenance, the officials and the damage. The members know no such thing and will not know it, probably, until after this discussion here to-day.

This Bill was held up as one under which the Government would provide everything and there would be no charge on local authorities. The members of the council to which I belong— and the same applies to other Deputies I know of on this side of the House—were never consulted, this Bill was not discussed with them and they do not know its implications regarding these payments. I would impress particularly on Deputies who are members of local authorities that to get the best out of this Bill the Minister should accept these amendments.

Comment on this

If Deputy Moran's latter prophecy comes true and local authorities fail to avail of this Bill to its fullest extent unless compensation claims are withdrawn, he should withdraw the amendment. It is particularly clear that no one would be more disappointed than Deputy Moran if any full employment is given. Deputies Aiken and Moran indicated very clearly their minds on the matter—this was going to be the cure-all for all unemployment—and their determination is that there will be no such cure-all and that this scheme will not see the light of day.

Comment on this

Why not give the road grants?

Comment on this

They say this Bill should never have been introduced, that other Bills were the proper ones. It is perfectly clear that they have no intention of helping the Bill, but desire by opposition to kill it before it sees the light of day. When Deputy Moran talks of protecting the interests of local authorities from compensation claims, he admits the 100 per cent. grant to be given and asks the House that, in an enabling Bill of this kind— local authorities are not compelled and do this of their own iniative and there is a 100 per cent. grant—the local council still must be asked to pay no compensation for any damage ensuing from entering on any works or land. No such provision was introduced before. The county council which we were told before was irresponsible, is, for any further irresponsibility in doing unnecessary damage, to be exempt from liability to pay compensation.

Deputies moving the amendments do not seem to believe a word they are saying. They are not sincere. The steps being taken under this measure have been conveyed generally throughout the country by publication. It was made abundantly clear that compensation would have to be paid by the local authorities. They submitted their schemes in the light of that information. I do not know where Deputy Moran got his statement. Explanations of the Bill have been published in the Press and local authorities could make any inquiries about it. They submitted works up to £2,000,000 in the full knowledge that they would be asked to bear any compensation. There is too much stress being laid on compensation. The Opposition seems to indicate that the Bill is one to do damage rather than to help the farmers, that the destruction will outweigh any benefit that may accrue.

Comment on this

How much is calculated for damage under the £2,000,000?

Comment on this

A lot of damage to Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say if, in submitting the £2,000,000, the engineers responsible gave any assurance that these works would not cause damage to neighbouring districts?

Comment on this

The works intended by the operation of this Bill are well known. There is not a county where, without consultation with the chief engineers, the damage cannot be seen year after year in the flooding of roads, houses and land.

Comment on this

I know of schemes submitted by county surveyors and if those surveyors were asked to stand over them as schemes that would do no damage to neighbouring districts, they would not take that responsibility.

Comment on this

Under this measure?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has claimed that £2,000,000 of works have been submitted by county surveyors and that that was indicative of the way in which local bodies have received these proposals. I want to know if, in submitting this £2,000,000, the engineers have sent an accompanying assurance to each local body to the effect that, in the execution of these works, no damage would result for which the local authority would be responsible later.

Comment on this

What about the Mulcaire drainage which you carried out— £40,000 on the ratepayers.

Comment on this

Never mind the Mulcaire. I am asking a question.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that the provisions in this Bill were conveyed to the county surveyors at a conference held by the Minister's predecessor?

Comment on this

Let the Minister answer the question put to him and do not be trying to draw in red herrings.

Comment on this

I am not in a position to give any guarantee to Deputy Smith. I am not an engineer who is conversant with all these works, but I suggest there is nothing in the Bill which is not capable of being dealt with competently by the local authorities with their advisory experts in regard to carrying out these works with the minimum damage and compensation. In regard to such damage as is essential and incidental, ample provision for compensation is being made, and we suggest that the reasonable people to pay this compensation are the local authorities, having regard to the munificence of the grant being given for the relief of unemployment, the improvement of the conditions of farmers, and the relief of flooding by dealing with roads which are perennially flooded, so that children cannot get to school, as I know is the position in places within my own knowledge. The local authority is not entitled to go in to repair the eye of a bridge and prevent that flooding. These are the things which this Bill attempts to deal with it and it is utterly unreasonable on the part of the Opposition to say that the local authority should bear no responsibility whatever, that they should do the work at their own discretion, get a 100 per cent. grant and have no responsibility, and that the State should pay whatever compensation has to be paid.

Comment on this

If I had an open mind about these amendments when coming in here, it certainly would be open no longer, because the arguments advanced by the Opposition members who spoke so far, by their insincerity and weakness, have convinced me of one thing, that these amendments were put down purely from the point of view of obstructing the passage of what the Opposition know is going to be a highly popular measure. That is the reason for these cunctatorial tactics, if I may so describe them. I should like to ask Deputy Moran, in the light of the speech he made, if it is his opinion and the opinion of Deputies opposite that we have not got in this country any competent engineers, because that is really the effect of the arguments put forward. The answer to the objections made that local authorities will not engage in these works is what has already been stated by the Parliamentary Secretary, that £2,000,000 worth of schemes have already been submitted. I think the Opposition are engaging in purely delaying tactics.

Comment on this

One cannot prevent Deputies who support the Government from attributing to those of us who are discussing these amendments whatever motives they wish, but I want to say that, if I were assured that, in the preparation of schemes to be approved, a proper engineering report were obtained and all the technical steps necessary to safeguard the local bodies and ratepayers from the payment of damages were taken I certainly would hesitate very much to ask the State to accept responsibility, for example, for compensation for consequential damage. I asked, in the course of the Minister's statement, for an assurance as to whether or not, in submitting £2,000,000 worth of works in a couple of weeks——

Comment on this

A couple of months.

Comment on this

Let it be a couple of months. I asked for an assurance that, in submitting £2,000,000 worth of works from different parts of the country, the engineers who submitted these proposals sent with them to their county councils or to the Local Government Department reasonable assurances that every engineering precaution had been taken—you cannot have everything perfect and some damage may arise—and that every step which engineers could reasonably take had been taken to ensure that they were not walking local bodies into a responsibility for the payment of damages which might far exceed the value of the work undertaken. I am satisfied, from my contacts with county surveyors who acted on the request which was sent out by the Department of Local Government for the submission of schemes, that, if we were in a position to bring these gentlemen before us and to ask them a few questions as to what they thought of some of the schemes submitted, on the basis of the amount of damage that would arise if the work proposed were carried out, they would, in the case of almost 90 per cent. of the submissions made through local authorities to the Department, refuse to take responsibility for them.

Comment on this

Their own schemes?

Comment on this

Their own schemes. I am perfectly satisfied from what I know of the proposals which must have gone in that they have been sent in, not because of any irresponsibility on the part of these gentlemen and not because of any irresponsibility on the part of the local bodies, but because they knew that these schemes were being "vetted" by the Department. As a matter of fact, the Parliamentary Secretary has admitted here, as proof of my contention and their belief, that a letter went out yesterday to local bodies asking them to re-sort the schemes, which conveys definitely and clearly to the local bodies that they have not got the final say in the schemes to be selected, and that therefore they have a fairly loose and free hand to submit any scheme, in the knowledge that it is Local Government which will decide ultimately the amount of money to be provided for these works and therefore that the money must fit into a certain type of proposal.

I cannot speak for what is in the minds of members, even of my own Party. I can to a certain extent, but I cannot speak with the same confidence as that with which I can speak in regard to what is in my own mind, and, to the extent to which I am supporting these amendments, to the extent to which I am advocating some safeguard for a local authority in regard to the payment of compensation, it is because I know that, in sending forward the schemes which have been submitted, it could not be expected that engineers would have been able to "vet" in a proper way £2,000,000 worth of works in the course of a couple of months, when work which is now being carried out under the other drainage code has taken years. Although £1,000,000 are invested in that work, it has taken years to satisfy these engineering people as to what will result, what benefits will accrue and what damage may follow from the execution of the works. Yet we are told here that under a Bill which has not yet become an Act, county engineers have been able, in the course of a few weeks, to fire up £2,000,000 worth of schemes and we are asked to regard that as an indication that the local bodies are prepared to go ahead with this work and that the works have been "vetted" in such a way as to enable county councils, county managers or county engineers in the knowledge that they would have to be responsible for the compensation, to know what these schemes involve. To ask us to accept that as a serious proposition is carrying things a little too far.

Comment on this

The Deputy's proposition is, then, that unless liability——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is in possession.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want us to scrap it?

Comment on this

I am asking him to clarify the position.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

To make the mud muddier.

Comment on this

I say, as I think the attempt is being made, that it is not fair to place local bodies in the position that people whose lands are affected by flooding and who will not be interested in what the result of the immediate relief given to them may be on their neighbours can be told: "We are giving the local body 100 per cent. grant if they carry out that work but the giving of that grant is conditioned by the provision that the local authority is responsible for the payment of compensation." After the passage of this Bill, if these amendments are not inserted, we will be transferring the baby to the local body in the knowledge that most of us have that many of these problems cannot be approached or tackled in this piecemeal fashion.

Speaking for myself, and I believe I can speak for other members of the Party, I want to say that in asking the Parliamentary Secretary to accept this amendment, or some amendment that would cover the point, we are doing so because we know that schemes that have already been submitted are not in the main schemes that could be carried out without exposing the local authority to the payment of unreasonable compensation later. We feel that the State and the Government is trying to shirk its responsibility, trying to transfer its responsibility, trying to put itself in the position that it can in future say: "We will give you full cost State grant although we know that, by making the local body responsible for payment of compensation, we are giving you something that we know in our hearts you cannot use."

Comment on this

I repudiate the suggestion by Deputy Smith that the county engineers in this country are not competent men. There is not the slightest doubt but that a substantial amount of money will be paid on works as envisaged under this Bill and as prepared by the county engineers. I do not know whether Deputy Smith knows it or not, but it was mentioned here that on the 25th February every county engineer in the whole country attended a conference at which were also present the chief engineering officers of the Department. This Bill was discussed in full and the works which they could undertake or which they might undertake were also discussed in full. The county engineers are aware of the type of schemes which they could well engage in without causing serious damage or without causing damage which would mean substantial amounts in compensation. At a recent conference of the county engineers they reported that there would be some claims for compensation but that the compensation would not be heavy and that the works engaged in, when completed, would be fully justified even in view of the small amount of compensation which would result. My information from the county engineers is that approximately 80 per cent. of the work proposed to be done under the provisions of this Bill and with the aid of the 100 per cent. grant will relate to roads, that is, the protection of roads from flooding; another percentage within the remaining 20 will go for the protection of houses and there are other schemes, a very small percentage, which will be rejected. These schemes will be sent up from the county councils after being thoroughly examined by the county engineers and they will also be examined by the engineering officers of the Department.

I would like to give an example of the type of schemes that one particular county proposes to engage in and this, incidentally, is a county which has submitted schemes to an amount of £75,000: the improvement of drains, streams, etc., which cause flooding of roads; the raising of the road surfaces at the points where they are liable to flooding; the alleviation of hardship to landowners whose lands have to take considerable quantities of road surface water by improving existing watercourses through their land or by the provision of adequate soakers or new watercourses in their lands; the provision of side sub-drains to roads where these are incut or where, for other causes, the water table is too near the surface of the road; to pipe and close in existing road side drains where these are in the nature of dykes which, by virtue of their size and proximity to the road margin, constitute a hazard to road users; to improve and enlarge road gullets and culverts which at present impede in any way the free flow of water in minor streams and drains. Also, to eliminate any road hog-backs caused by such gullets and culverts; to provide suitable impervious side channels to roads, particularly on embankments and on slopes, where the ordinary road run-off is liable to cause surface scour or sub-surface damage by seepage under the sides. Also to provide adequate and suitable collecting points for the draw-off of such water from the side channels.

That is just an example of the type of schemes which the different county councils propose to engage in and I think the Deputy ought to be assured that these county engineers know their job and have not selected schemes indiscriminately. Also, I would like to remind him that the circular which asked that such schemes be prepared was sent to the secretary of each county council and to the town clerk of the urban councils and corporations.

Comment on this

What date?

Comment on this

10th March. The county engineers, of course, were aware of this and were asked to prepare schemes on the 25th February, but this circular setting out the type of schemes that may be engaged in was brought before the members of the local authorities and the circular to which I referred previously, which was sent out yesterday, asked that first preference be given to simple schemes, not requiring elaborate surveys or preparation, which can be undertaken without delay, within an appropriate period of the present financial year. As a matter of fact, members of local authorities and, for that matter, Dáil representatives, have themselves submitted schemes to the local authorities. I was reminded that in some counties—I think Mayo happens to be one of them—the nature of the schemes to be engaged in or, at least, this particular circular was not discussed by the local authority. That may have happened only in a few counties but, generally speaking, the terms of this circular were very well known to the members of the local authorities themselves and they were fully aware of the fact that the local authority would be liable for compensation. Again I repeat, despite that fact, they know they could submit certain schemes for this 100 per cent. grant, bearing in mind that they would be liable for compensation but knowing also that they could have a substantial amount of work done which would not result in compensation.

Comment on this

May I ask were the local authorities informed by circular that they would be liable for compensation?

Comment on this

Yes, they got a copy of the Bill.

Comment on this

Wait now. The other way is the better way. There is nothing in the Bill that says one way or the other whether they would be liable or not. Were they informed by circular?

Comment on this

Not specifically.

Comment on this

Deputy Moran deliberately suggested that the schemes already submitted to the Department of Local Government by the various county councils were submitted under the wrong impression that not alone the full costs of carrying out the schemes but the cost of administering these schemes would be included in the 100 per cent. grant. I am not a member of a local authority but I have some knowledge of what is going on in my area since the circular of the 10th March last was sent out to the local authorities. I have personal knowledge, from conversations I have had with the county engineers concerned and with several members of the two county councils in my area—and I am not confining my conversations to the Labour members of these authorities — that when these schemes were being prepared by the county surveyors and by their assistants in the two counties they knew perfectly well that the cost of any compensation that might be involved would not be included in the 100 per cent. grant. If Deputy Moran and his colleagues on the Mayo County Council did not understand that, well, Deputy Moran has a big responsibility for it, because he was here in this House listening to the discussion on the Second Reading of this Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation——

Comment on this

Do not interrupt.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy does not give way——

Comment on this

I do not give way.

Comment on this

I am being misrepresented.

Comment on this

The Deputy is an old hand at that.

Comment on this

I would not have taken part in this discussion were it not for the speech made by Deputy Moran. If he did not listen to the speeches in this House on the Second Reading of the Bill—and I listened to most of them — and, in particular, if he did not hear the speech which was made by his colleague, Deputy Corry, I would advise him to study the Offical Report carefully. Deputy Corry welcomed this. Bill with enthusiasm and said that immediately he read it he proceeded to his own constituency in Cork and got the county surveyor on the job. He indicated that before the proposals were completed, in so far as his constituency was concerned, the cost of the schemes involved would be somewhere in the vicinity of £250,000. When Deputy Corry went to Cork—before the Second Reading of this Bill was passed—he knew perfectly well that the cost of compensation would not be included in the 100 per cent. grant. The circular that was sent out on the 10th March, nearly three months ago, made quite clear to the county managers and to the members of the county councils concerned the types of schemes that would be provided for under the terms of this Bill. I feel very proud to be able to say that, so far as my constituency is concerned—and my colleague, Deputy T.F. O'Higgins, will confirm my statement—Fine Gael, Labour and Independent members, and so forth, drafted the best schemes that could be drafted and sent them along to the Department of Local Government, where they are now awaiting sanction. I warn Deputy Moran and his colleagues that his attitude of obstruction is holding up the day when these schemes can be put into operation.

Comment on this

Codology.

Comment on this

If we are wrong and if the county councils have been misled by anything said up to now, I would say to the Deputies opposite to withdraw the obstructionist amendments and that we on this side will answer to the people when the time comes. You are here to-night engaged in a policy of delaying action. We know that that policy is bound to prevent men who are waiting for work from getting the most valuable work in the country. Withdraw your amendments. Take responsibility and thereby withdraw your obstructionist attitude. You will find that the county councils and the county engineers and all the county councillors of the different counties who are sensible and reasonable people know what they are doing and what they have done when they submitted schemes amounting to £2,000,000 to the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this

I thought the inter-Party Government would take advice from anybody.

Comment on this

It is refreshing at all times to hear out colleague, Deputy Davin. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

Thanks very much.

Comment on this

When anyone is required to apologise for the people beyond, Deputy Davin is always available. He comes up smiling every time. He tells us that because of the obstruction by the Deputies on this side of the House, this Bill is not in operation.

Comment on this

Delaying action.

Comment on this

I would repudiate that.

Comment on this

It could have been in operation a month ago.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You should have said "delaying tackling".

Comment on this

It is unworthy of Deputy Davin. There are three amendments here that propose, in effect, that the local authority shall have no responsibility for compensation that may arise out of damage that may occur as a result of the passing and putting into operation of this Bill. If the county councils are only to be allowed or asked to carry out the schemes just mentioned a while ago by the Parliamentary Secretary, no Bill at all was needed. He mentioned the type of roadwork — nothing but roadwork, completely on roads—and it is work for which the county councils already have full authority to carry out. They are already fully covered by law in every possible respect. No Bill whatsoever was needed and no compensation was payable either if they were going to be kept to the roads. Further, it is significant that the schemes which the local authorities have prepared amount to a sum of £2,000,000. It is a very significant amount. A figure of £2,225,000 was mentioned very often in this House early this year. It represented the amount by which the road grants this year were reduced. I hope, for the sake of the lot of us and for the sake of a lot of people outside this House, that it will be possible to spend that £2,000,000 in the present financial year.

Comment on this

It will not, if you do not hurry up.

Comment on this

I hope it will. I hope that every possible effort will be made by the Minister and by his Parliamentary Secretary and by everybody concerned to make it possible to spend that sum of £2,000,000 in the present financial year.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Give us the Bill.

Comment on this

I am afraid that that sum of money will not be spent within this financial year if only the minor schemes that have been submitted to the Department are carried out. In such circumstances only a very small amount of the money will fall due to be spent.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This amendment has reference to liability under the local authority—not to the amount of money to be spent.

Comment on this

This amendment will safeguard the local authorities so that they will not have to provide, at the expense of the ratepayers in their particular counties, any funds to compensate a person who may be aggrieved under this scheme. There was much talk here since this amendment came under discussion on the question of whether engineers are a responsible body of people or otherwise. I do not think anyone will suggest or has suggested or will attempt to suggest that any engineers in this country are irresponsible. I do not believe they are.

Comment on this

That is what Deputy Smith suggested.

Comment on this

He did not suggest any such thing. He pointed out——

Comment on this

He said that they were dishonest.

Comment on this

He pointed out—it is a well-known fact to everybody down the country and it was broadcast generally — that engineers, in preparing those schemes, were told by their county managers that every possible scheme that might fall to be done, whether on the roads or on the land, that would serve the interests of the community at large, should be put on the list—every possible scheme that would serve the interests of the community. These were the instructions that they got.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

Nothing whatever. When Deputy Smith points out here——

Comment on this

He said 90 per cent. would do damage.

Comment on this

—— that it was possible and almost certain that a large number of those schemes were prepared hastily by the county engineers. There is not any doubt about it.

Comment on this

Does that apply to Deputy Corry?

Comment on this

Deputy Davin is well able to speak for himself. I am surprised that he has to fall back on Deputy Corry for his defence because he is usually able to defend himself. Assuming this £2,000,000 will be spent before 31st March next year, could the Parliamentary Secretary give an indication to the House as to what proportion of that £2,000,000 will be spent on labour and what proportion on capital expenditure, administrative expenses, etc.?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is wondering how this is relevant to the amendment.

Comment on this

I am proposing to show the approximate amount of the cost which may fall on local authorities in administrative expenses without considering compensation at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This has reference to liability.

Comment on this

Yes. The liability will fall under two headings. There will be the liability on the local authorities for providing engineering and clerical staff. Secondly, there will be the liability for damage that may be done and awards made against the council as a result of activities under the Bill. I think I am entitled to refer to the approximate cost for engineering and clerical services as distinct from labour on the particular works. I suggest that it will be approximately 30 per cent.

Comment on this

For clerical work?

Comment on this

For expenditure outside that on labour. It will cost between 20 and 30 per cent. probably nearer to 30 per cent. I am speaking from previous experience of local authorities doing such works.

Comment on this

What did the administration of the special employment schemes cost?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary in charge of employment schemes is in the House and can tell you if he wishes.

Comment on this
Michael Donnellan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Donnellan) Clann na Talmhan

Four per cent. in the majority of cases.

Comment on this

I know that in connection with roads the cost is roughly 70 per cent. for labour and 30 per cent. for other costs. I see no reason why the Government should resist these reasoned amendments which will enable more work to be done. There are several ways of damaging schemes that might otherwise do a lot of good. Much more work will be done under the Bill if such a provision as is mentioned in these amendments is inserted. The engineers and the manager of local authorities will be very careful to safeguard the council and the ratepayers. They will be most cautions in advising their councils to undertake any scheme. That is the danger I see in the Bill. The greatest danger under the Bill, from the point of view of getting work done, is that the advisers of local authorities may be too cautious and too careful. They will act as prudent men.

Comment on this

Deputy Smith said three or four times that they did not act as prudent men. You cannot deny that.

Comment on this

You will not put me off that way. There is no responsibility put on any one for any action they may take. If the advisers of local authorities see a danger to their local authorities or the ratepayers in giving certain advice, I am sure they will be very slow to give it. It is quite possible that many otherwise sound schemes may be left out because of the over-caution that may arise on the part of advisers to local authorities under the Bill. The safeguard suggested here will improve the Bill and enable it to work much more smoothly in any local authority area. Personally, I am not afraid that a big amount of compensation will fall to be paid in the area I am acquainted with because of the coming into operation of the Bill. It is quite possible that a big lot of compensation may not have to be paid for all the works that are being recommended, but it might happen that a very considerable amount of unforeseen compensation may have to be paid on one scheme.

Comment on this

You knew the council was liable for compensation?

Comment on this

I want to be clear about that. Until the announcement was made on the winding up of the Second Stage of this Bill the public at large were not aware of that and no indication had been given of it. No member of any local authority was ever informed by circular from the Minister or his Department that the council would be liable for compensation for damage done under the Bill. I challenge anyone to show that any circular was sent down to local authorities to the effect that they would be liable for compensation under the Bill or even for the cost of the engineering and clerical assistance necessary to carry out the work. I do not know whether the fact was conveyed to their officers. I know that the officers of the local authority of which I am a member did not convey it to the local authority.

Comment on this

They knew it.

Comment on this

They may have been told it.

Comment on this

They had got the Bill.

Comment on this

There was nothing in the original Bill to show that. I defy you to find it in it.

Comment on this

You knew it.

Comment on this

I knew it because it was announced in this House.

Comment on this

What does Section 5 (4) say?

Comment on this

The Official Reports will show that I was the person who asked the question on the Second Reading when the information was given. The information was conveyed to the public for the first time before the Second Reading was passed. Possibly the papers published it and a great many people became aware of it then. Officially the local authorities were never made aware of it.

Comment on this

The Deputy saw the circular dated 10th March?

Comment on this

That is beside the point.

Comment on this

That is not beside the point, surely?

Comment on this

I do not know what I saw. The local authorities were not informed. Local authorities were not informed that they were liable for compensation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has said that at least five times.

Comment on this

Some people seem to doubt it still.

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

However, I would appeal to the Government to reconsider this matter. If, as they claim, little or no compensation will fall to be paid, there is no reason why they should not propose putting in some safeguard that will satisfy the minds of local authorities and that will leave them more inclined to undertake certain types of schemes. It is all according whether this Bill, when it comes into operation, will do the work it is supposed to do, enable the local authorities to spend the money provided for them by the State. It is all-important that the works needing to be carried out should be carried out. There is no need for this Bill to carry out the works indicated by the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is repeating himself constantly.

Comment on this

Delaying action purposely.

Comment on this

You can get up and talk if you wish. It is better to say nothing when you cannot talk sense.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Then why do you not sit down?

Comment on this

By accepting these amendments and by providing a sum to cover this compensation we will be making this Bill more acceptable to local authorities and to the country in general.

Comment on this

I think it is one of these regrettable things when you see the deterioration and disintegration of a wax-work Party.

Comment on this

Clann na Poblachta.

Comment on this

Surely, the Party on the other side have listened to a great deal when they are left here with their Three Musketeers to fight this delaying action. The Three Musketeers—Deputy Aiken, Deputy Moran and Deputy Smith.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What has that to do with the amendment?

Comment on this

I am coming to that. I think it is regrettable, but it is more regrettable when we see a Party, the majority of whose members know this is a good Bill and are anxious to see it put through, held up by the Three Musketeers that I mentioned. It is a sad thing when——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is a sad thing that the Deputy does not come to the amendment.

Comment on this

I listened here to Deputy Corry who spoke on the Second Reading of this Bill. I listened to other Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party who spoke on the Second Reading of this Bill when it was clearly explained by the then Minister that this compensation clause would be in the Bill and, in fact, it was in the Bill — Section 5. That Bill was welcomed by all those Deputies containing as it did that particular section to which these amendments have now been put down. We saw that after certain attacks had been made on the Bill Fianna Fáil Deputies had gone to the country and found out that their action was not approved. We then saw the change of front there was. However, these amendments in the name of Deputy MacEntee who is not here, and in the name of Deputy Moran were put down deliberately for no other purpose than to obstruct the passage of the Bill through this House. That is the purpose of the speech that was delivered on this Bill by Deputy Moran this evening. A more disgraceful speech I never heard.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

On this amendment?

Comment on this

Delivered by Deputy Moran on this amendment. I say, a more disgraceful speech I never heard from anybody than I heard from Deputy Moran. We had two points of view expressed. Deputy Smith expressed one of them when he said that engineers and local authorities are so irresponsible that the bill for compensation is going to run into an enormous sum. Then Deputy Allen said, and I think he is very near the truth, that the amount of damage that will be done by carrying out the works envisaged in this Bill will be almost negligible. Now I want to know which side is being put forward here. Is it the point of view that, because the irresponsible engineers and irresponsible county councillors are going to do an enormous amount of damage, this House is going to provide the compensation involved; or are we to take the other that there is going to be so little damage that, having provided 100 per cent. grant for carrying out the work, we should go the whole hog and provide the very small amount that is needed in compensation?

I think Deputy Davin was perfectly right in his approach to the measure. This Bill is needed, containing as it does the section dealing with compensation. The amendments that are now under discussion are not genuinely put forward at all. They are put forward, as I have said, for no other purpose than to obstruct the passage of the Bill. I would ask Deputy Moran, Deputy Aiken and Deputy Smith who are leading the Opposition now, to withdraw those amendments and let the Bill pass through the House so that the people who are unemployed or who will be unemployed very soon will get a chance.

Comment on this

Why were they not kept on the roads?

Comment on this

Deputy Aiken knows very well that, when that matter was going through the Dáil, I opposed the reduction in the road grants and voted against the Government on that particular issue.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This amendment has reference to the liability on councils.

Comment on this

I understand that, but I want to remind Deputy Aiken that I did take action on that particular measure. I want to say to Deputy Aiken and Deputy Moran that, in the ten minutes before the House adjourns, they should withdraw these obstructive amendments and let the Bill pass through this stage.

Comment on this

As a member of a local authority, I want to say that I believe that if the Bill is passed as it stands very little useful work will be done under it. As Deputy Allen has pointed out, the works outlined by the Parliamentary Secretary could be done without the Bill. When speaking on the Second Reading of the Bill I asked for certain information. I gave the example of a minor river being drained into a major river, and asked the Minister if work such as that was going to be done under the Bill and, if it was, who was going to pay the consequential damages. I got no reply to my question, and so I do not know if work of that kind can be done under the Bill. I did say that when that scheme was sent to the Board of Works they would not pass it without a recommendation from a county surveyor. He would not give the recommendation until he was satisfied as to who was going to pay for the damages that would occur on the main river.

That position still obtains. That is a class of work the people are anxious to see done under this so-called Drainage Bill. That position is not being remedied under this Bill. I maintain that there is too much of a burden being thrown on the local authorities. In the case of almost every Bill passed here, extra burdens have been thrown on the local authorities, so that the rates have gone up to such an extent that the local authorities are beginning to wonder where all these extra demands are going to stop. There is also the question of minor rivers draining into other counties. In Sligo we have the position that there is a minor river draining into the River Moy, which is in the County Mayo. Suppose that work is undertaken under this Bill, who is going to pay the consequential damages that will arise in the case of the River Moy? What I see is going to happen under this Bill is this: that if, in the case of any of these works the county surveyor is not prepared to make a recommendation to undertake the work, some man who is in favour of the Government or the Minister can come up here and get an order from the Minister to proceed with the work. If the Bill is passed without these amendments, the result will be that the local authorities will be saddled with additional burdens. They will be obliged to undertake works that they are not prepared to undertake. No local authority will be prepared to embark on any scheme that would be worth twopence without these amendments.

Comment on this

These amendments could not be accepted by any Government with any sense of responsibility at all. I am perfectly sure that if Deputy Aiken, Deputy Moran and Deputy Smith were on this side and were in charge of this Bill they would not accept one of these amendments. The effect of their acceptance, particularly in cases where a majority on a local body was opposed to the Government in power for the time being, would be to put into the hands of such a local authority a dangerous and a fatal weapon.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

If the local authority had no responsibility whatever, then one can be sure that the most fantastic scheme that the most harebrained member of a local authority could think of would be brought forward and passed, thereby putting into the hands of anti-Government local authority a highly dangerous weapon. For that reason I am altogether opposed to these amendments.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy please develop that point?

Comment on this

It could be easily developed in this way. There is the saying that the man who pays the piper calls the tune, but in this case, I suggest, that the man who calls the tune ought to pay the piper.

Comment on this

Since the Government started this whole thing, is it not fair to ask that they should bear the responsibility for payment?

Comment on this

The Government introduced this measure with a perfectly good intention. The execution of important and useful work is contemplated by the Bill, yet Deputy Gilbride tells us that the Bill is going to serve no purpose at all.

Comment on this

Under certain conditions.

Comment on this

The statement made by the Deputy was a perfectly ridiculous one. It was not relevant to the amendments before the House, and, therefore, I do not propose to deal with it further.

Comment on this

I have been listening to Deputies on the Government side——

Comment on this

You have just come in.

Comment on this

I have been in the House all the night. We have been trying to make a good job of this Bill by bringing forward these amendments. The position is going to be a rather serious one. The Parliamentary Secretary told us that one of the objects of the Bill is to save the roads from flooding. Deputy Moran made a very useful contribution when he asked the Parliamentary Secretary if he did not consider that it was equally important to save land from being flooded by the sea.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What is before the House deals with the liability on local authorities.

Comment on this

I know the Chair allowed others——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will allow the Deputy to speak on that.

Comment on this

No liability of any kind should attach to a local authority in respect of these works. That is the object of amendment No. 7. Amendment No. 8 provides——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not going to allow the Deputy to play that silly game with the House by reading out amendments. The Deputy will address himself to what is before the House.

Comment on this

I have considerable knowledge of drainage work and I support Deputy Gilbride in his point of view. I move to report progress.

Comment on this