Committee on Finance. - Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 1–136 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 1949 ›
Yesterday the Parliamentary Secretary stated that there were £2,000,000 worth of schemes which would be carried out under this Bill when it becomes an Act. We could not discover from him if any great care had been taken to find out how much benefit would be done by these schemes and how much damage. We have not yet succeeded in getting any indication from him that the State is prepared to foot the bill for the damage, although in certain instances the Minister may, through his nominee, carry out works which will result in a large bill for compensation being presented to the local authority. When the Bill was first introduced here the then Minister stated, as reported in column 2144, Volume 114:—
"The finance necessary to operate the Bill is being made available by the Government. The grants to local authorities will be 100 per cent. and local authorities need have no reservations whatever on that point."
The interpretation that was placed on that by most people in the country was that it was a 100 per cent. Government grant and a number of members of local authorities gaily started out to collect works on the assumption that 100 per cent. of all costs in connection with the carrying out of these works would be borne by the State. They thought this scheme was a compensation for the loss of £2,000,000 in road grants and that, as the Government were anxious to do something to balance the cutting down of these grants, the cutting down of road work, and the unemployment caused thereby, they could assume that there would be no cost at all on the local authorities. I wish the Parliamentary Secretary would give an indication, even if the Government are not prepared to bear 100 per cent. of the damage in all cases, that at least wherever the work is carried out by the Minister's nominee in spite of the local council, the State would bear the bill for compensation for any damage caused by the Minister's nominee in carrying out the work.
We have to realise that works under this Bill will be decided upon, as the Parliamentary Secretary stated, by the county manager or by the nominee of the Minister. I think it is only fair, particularly in a case where the work is carried out by the Minister's nominee, if instead of doing something to benefit the local authority, he imposes a great charge upon them, that the Government should be responsible for the bill. The Parliamentary Secretary quite glibly assumes that there will be no damage whatsoever under this Bill. I stated in my speech on Second Reading—I do not want to go into the details again—that I knew of one case where a few thousand pounds were spent on cleaning up a stream, and that work caused many thousands of pounds' damage downstream. There was great local agitation as a result and it was only after a number of years that a settlement was made whereby the Government gave the county council a grant and they in turn relieved the farmers whose lands were flooded. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is engaged in pushing forward drainage in that area, and one of the reasons why the area was selected for the second of the great arterial drainage schemes was to undo some of the damage that has been done by the spending of that money.
Comment on this
I am interested to know what the reason was.
Comment on this
That was one of the reasons and the Parliamentary Secretary, in that case, as in many others, has adopted the policy of his predecessors. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is here and he can bear me out in the assertion that, in some cases, grave damage will be done. I do not mind a county situated in such a way that all the watershed is within its own territory. Take County Kerry and, to some extent, County Wexford. Kerry is protected from incoming floods from other counties and the county manager can see exactly what damage might be created. If he creates some damage in his own county with the approval of his council it is their fault. Some seaboard counties, however, are subject to floods from inland counties and would be subject to grave damage if waters were released suddenly, so some protection should be given. We will come to other types of protection in other amendments, but with regard to this amendment I think that where work is carried on by the Minister's nominee, and causes damage in the area concerned or in adjoining areas, the State should bear the burden.
Comment on this
The Monaghan-Louth case. If the Deputy wants to see the details he can look up my Second Reading speech. Once upon a time, not so long ago, the Parliamentary Secretary refused to carry out a scheme of drainage and I quoted the letter which he sent to the local authority concerned. The letter, if Deputy Davin wants to look at it, is on column 2396, Volume 114, of the 6th May. The Parliamentary Secretary sensibly took up the stand that he could not release the waters from a tributary into a main basin before that main basin was prepared to receive the extra waters. He pointed out that it was attempted to do this thing under the minor relief works, and he pointed out that they had no means of reconciling the interests of landowners whose lands adjoined a main drainage channel with those whose lands were bordering on tributaries. He pointed out that such problems occur in many parts of the country and that they could only be dealt with by means of the machinery of the Arterial Drainage Act, 1945. If we had the machinery of the Arterial Drainage Act, 1945, with all the care that is taken before a job is started there would be no talk here at all about compensation. If the local authority had to go through the same procedure as under the 1945 Act, if they made a mistake clearly it would be their own fault. However, they have not got it. They have only got the machinery we are supplying in this Bill and very limited precautions will be taken even if the amendments suggested by the Opposition are accepted. I would be glad if the Parliamentary Secretary would consider the matter between now and the Report Stage. If he is not prepared to accept all the amendments in toto so as to relieve the local authorities of any liability for damage, he should at least consider relieving them of liability for damage caused by the Minister's nominee. Later, perhaps, we might get him to accept other amendments which, with that particular amendment, would leave the Bill less dangerous and confine it to doing good.
Comment on this
I would be grateful to the Parliamentary Secretary if he would let me know whether, if a county council carries out any of these works under this section, it will be allowed for maintenance. In Kerry we had a meeting with our county engineer and, supposing we made a drain in a man's land, he was not at all sure whether we would have to maintain that drain or anything else under this section. If so, it will be a serious charge on the local authority when we have the liability for damage as well.
Comment on this
I first want to deny the assertion of Deputy Davin in this House last night that our local authority was consulted in connection with this Bill. Our local authority certainly was not consulted nor did it have the opportunity of discussing the Bill or its implications.
Comment on this
No circular was sent out and the matter did not come before our local authority at all. In fact, due to statements that appeared in the Press as a result of speeches in this House that all the money would be provided by the State for these works, a number of works were submitted to our county surveyor. Some of us got replies from the county surveyor intimating that the only works contemplated, so far as he was aware, were works in connection with property of the county council under Section 1 of this Bill and that the question of general drainage was not going to be contemplated at all and that the works submitted to him were ordinary minor drainage works which normally would be done by the Board of Works. One of the things about which I am still confused, particularly in view of the Parliamentary Secretary's statement last night, is what the Government's intention is with regard to the works which are to be undertaken under this Bill. The Parliamentary Secretary read a list here last night intimating for the first time what was going to be done.
Comment on this
I thought I made it quite clear that that was merely a sample list, submitted by a particular engineer.
Comment on this
I do not want to misrepresent the position in any way, but the list he read out certainly did not mention the question of what I would call public drainage except in so far as county council property was affected. I was listening to him and the list was entirely in connection with works contemplated in the first part of this measure. The first part of this measure is quite clear to everybody and reasonable. It is the part of the measure which deals with the general drainage which is to be undertaken for the first time by local authorities. The fact that the works all came under the first part is what gives rise to doubts as to the implications, particularly in regard to the liabilities of local authorities.
One of the Deputies asked the Parliamentary Secretary a question in connection with maintenance. There is not one word in the Bill on the question of maintenance.
Comment on this
With due respect, the question of maintenance is in this amendment and it is one of the things I want to save the local authorities from having to pay for. If they had to pay for them it might constitute a very heavy liability on the ratepayers and this amendment of mine is designed to prevent local authorities from being liable for any such expenditure.
Comment on this
——I am certainly not going to start at this stage to tell him what I visualise as works under the Bill.
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle ruled that these amendments would be taken together, including No. 35.
Comment on this
Very well, No. 35 is included in the group that is being discussed and the same principle runs through all. Nos. 7, 8, 9, 10, 22, 25 and 35 are being discussed together and a decision can be taken on any or all of them.
Comment on this
Is it not reasonable to ask the Deputy what he visualises as proper maintenance charges?
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan listened to the Parliamentary Secretary give a brief outline of that last night.
Comment on this
If we are to accept the statements made, this Bill will provide for the carrying out by local authorities of very substantial drainage works and one of the big questions will be maintenance. There is not one word dealing with maintenance in this Bill. It is clear that, if a farmer's cow falls into a drain, or there is some other injury through a drain not being fenced, and if this happens in a couple of years' time, it is what the lawyers call a misfeasance and the local authority will be responsible. By the Parliamentary Secretary and the Government keeping silent on this Bill, the local authority will come in for any damage caused. In addition to that, by their silence they are shoving over on the local authority the liability for maintenance in law of these drainage or other works.
It is most desirable, when the money is being provided for the main expenditure, that the Minister should not stop local authorities from making use of this Bill. If he does not give the guarantees asked for under these amendments, the Bill will be illusory. With a very high level of rates at present, the local authorities will not be prepared to face the further increase in rates envisaged as a result of these works. It will be pointed out to them by the officials that the works may cause damage as a result of flooding, that a number of officials will have to be appointed and salaries provided for them, and when they do the works they will be responsible for the maintenance. When they are warned that they will have to foot the bill, the Parliamentary Secretary will find that the local authorities will be curtailing the work and not making use of the drainage sections.
I cannot understand why, having said he would provide the money for the execution of the works, the Parliamentary Secretary is not prepared to go the rest of the way to ensure that local authorities will go full steam ahead. Let no one mistake this proposition, that a vote against these amendments, if they are put to a vote, is a vote for the increasing of the rates throughout the country. If the Parliamentary Secretary is wise, he will not spoil the ship for a ha'porth of tar but will provide for these officials, for any damage that may result, and for maintenance also. If he does that, he will find the Bill will work; if he does not, he will find the Bill will not work. I ask him to reconsider the position.
Comment on this
I think this will be my last contribution on the amendments, as I can see clearly that the attitude taken up is one of obstruction. I understood from the ex-Minister that local authorities over a number of years were clamouring for power to do the works envisaged in this Bill and as they could not get that power they dare not do the works necessary to protect the property of local authorities. Deputy Corry, who is a very sound representative of local authorities and knows what is in their interests, admitted on the Second Reading that local authorities were pressing for this and, in fact, that he was pressing for it.
The Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary say they are not only going to give local authorities that power to do the things they want to do to protect their own property but they are going to pay 100 per cent. of the cost of doing the work. Can anyone say that is not a generous contribution by a central authority? Not only are they getting the power they want but this Parliament is paying 100 per cent. of the cost of the work. If the Minister had said he would give them the power and authority, that would have been welcomed by the majority of Deputies as it is something local authorities were crying out for for many years. If some Deputy said it would be a strain on local authorities and asked for 50, 70 or 90 per cent. grants, and the Minister acceded, it would have been considered a generous action on the part of the central authority. But the Minister comes in and says: "Not only will I give you the power but also every ½d. it costs to carry out the work." Then Deputy Moran says: "That is not enough; there may be claims for compensation—will you also take on the responsibility for that?" Deputy Allen said last night—and I accept Deputy Allen on this as a representative of the local authority—that in actual fact the claims that may be made for compensation, if this measure is put properly into operation after due consideration by the local authority will be very small.
Comment on this
——and says that, from his knowledge of County Wexford, the responsible people down there will not act the fool. I can say that a member of any other local authority is as justified in saying that his local authority will not act the fool. Not only are we to give them the 100 per cent. grant and the power they want, but, Deputy Moran says: "Pay all these possible claims in the meantime." I ask Deputy Moran what does he visualise these works to be and he gives me the smart answer that I have not read the Bill. He knows I have read the Bill and that I have read every amendment, and he knows that not only have I read them, but that I understand what is in the Bill and in the amendments. I do not want to say anything more than that, but it was a reasonable question to put to him—what did he visualise as being included in the works for the maintenance of which local authorities would have to be responsible? This Bill is a measure which authorises local authorities to do certain works for the particular principles, points and reasons set out in the Bill, and, whether these works are to be done in 1949, 1950, 1951 or 1952, the principle is the same. Any works which are lawful under the Bill and which can be done under the Bill can be done under the guarantee of the Minister that there will be a 100 per cent. grant from the central authority for doing them. Where is the point then in regard to maintenance? I suggest to Deputy Moran that he stop this playacting and let us get on with the work of the House.
Comment on this
I want to repudiate the statement of Deputy Cowan that we are discussing this Bill for the sake of obstruction. My attitude to the Bill is this: I want to save the local authorities from being saddled with expenditure with which I do not think they should be saddled. Every Drainage Bill ever introduced recognised, as does every Party, that drainage should be a national charge.
Comment on this
It is partly a Drainage Bill and it is the drainage portion we are dealing with now.
Comment on this
It strikes me as very peculiar that the Deputies who represent country constituencies and who are members of local bodies are very silent on these clauses and that it is left to Deputy Cowan, who is mainly concerned with a city constituency, to be vocal with regard to them. If the Minister wants this Bill to be a success, I appeal to him to accept these amendments. I know the attitude of local authorities and I know that they are not prepared, with the present level of rates, to accept any further responsibility. Drainage should be a national charge and I appeal to him, for that reason, to accept the amendment and not saddle local authorities with this heavy burden.
Comment on this
I am quite clear in my own mind with regard to this matter, because I listened to the majority of the speeches on the Second Reading, in which Deputy Moran took part. I am not quite sure if Deputy Moran was here when the late Minister wound up the debate on the Second Reading and made the position as clear as it could be made to any intelligent Deputy regarding the contents of the Bill, dealing particularly with the question of compensation in case of damage. Deputy Moran is, I understand, a distinguished member of the county council in his own constituency.
Comment on this
I think he was present at the meeting of the council at which the whole matter came up for consideration.
Comment on this
If he was present at the meeting of his own county council when this matter came up for consideration and decision and when the proposals of the county engineer for the county were under consideration, surely he is the one man who should have made the whole question of compensation clear to his colleagues.
Comment on this
I should like the Parliamentary Secretary to tell us whether any proposals under the terms of this Bill have been received by the Department from the Mayo County Council and, if so, whether these proposals were submitted to the Department on condition that compensation would be borne by the central authority for any damage that might occur as a result of the carrying out of these schemes.
Comment on this
Surely a decision on this amendment does not hinge on what the Mayo County Council did or did not hear?
Comment on this
I could appreciate the position of a county engineer who submitted proposals at the request of the county council, if these proposals were submitted for a 100 per cent. grant, on condition that compensation would be borne by the Central Fund and not by the local authority. I ask Deputy Moran if he thinks it wise to waste any more time discussing the merits of these amendments and I should like him to say whether he knows of any measure passed by this House since the House was established which provided that maintenance should be borne by the Central Fund in respect of any works carried out at the expense of the Central Fund. Money is provided for farm improvement schemes, for reconstruction of farmers' dwellings and of other houses, and for road construction. Is there any measure of any kind introduced since the State was established which provides that maintenance work should be carried out after grants had been made available, with the exception of the Barrow Drainage Act? In that case, portion of the maintenance charges has still to be borne by the ratepayers. The discussion on these amendments is merely a waste of time, and I say it deliberately, in order to delay the coming into operation of a valuable measure which is bound to provide useful work for the unemployed in rural areas.
Comment on this
If Deputies on the Government side, such as Deputies Cowan and Davin, are to charge Deputies on this side with speaking for the purpose of obstruction, this Bill will have a tortuous passage through the House. I do not mind Deputy Cowan, because he is irresponsible in all circumstances, but Deputy Davin is an old stager who should give as much credit to others as he takes himself when he gets up to speak and has something to say. One thing, however, has been borne in on me after listing to him, that is, that he has not studied the Bill and does not understand what is in it.
Comment on this
The Deputy's intelligence, for which I am not responsible, is so low that it could not be improved.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Parliamentary Secretary have they considered this and have they given the final word on it? We are not pressing this matter without being absolutely serious about it. In connection with sub-section (2) I say in all seriousness that the local authorities do not want from the State one penny either to carry out the works that they should carry out under sub-section (2) or to maintain them.
Comment on this
The Deputy said it last night and I am not going to allow repetition on these amendments.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that the local authorities did not want any further power than they had in respect of that section.
Comment on this
What I am saying now is that they want no funds. I did not say that before. They want no funds for the carrying out of the work that it may be necessary to carry out under sub-section (2) of this Bill either for the capital costs, maintenance costs or the legal costs that may be incurred afterwards.
Comment on this
Sub-section (3) is the important one. If the Minister will meet us on sub-section (3) we on this side of the House will be satisfied, I am sure. At least, I will be.
Comment on this
I am discussing sub-section (3) of Section 2. Sub-section (3) is the important section in this Bill.
Comment on this
I can discuss the sub-section that is proposed to be amended on the amendment, surely?
Comment on this
It could not be amended if attention were not drawn to the part of the section which needs amendment. I suggest to the Minister that under sub-section (3) of Section 2 works of far-reaching importance will fall to be executed—whether they are done this year or next year. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is aware of that. Very large sub-major drainage areas will need to be drained under sub-section (3) of Section 2, if the Bill is to operate. There is no doubt about that. It is not denied that large catchment areas will fall to be drained under this sub-section. As I said last night, this is the portion of the section that local authorities dread and will fear in future. It is the portion of the section, as has been said a moment ago, in respect of which their advisers will so advise councils that I am afraid little or no work will be done under it. For that reason, I would ask the Minister to give an undertaking to reconsider this matter between now and the Report Stage, to reconsider the whole question as to whether the State will reimburse local authorities for the legal charges that may fall on them arising out of sub-section (3). They are not claiming anything for ordinary maintenance. There should be some provision in this Bill for the maintenance of certain types of work. There is no such provision in the Bill. There should be a provision whereby the local authorities, from their own funds or otherwise, would maintain works but that is beside the point. Some further consideration should be given to that aspect of the matter. I say that with a full sense of responsibility.
Comment on this
I think it is the attitude of people like Deputy Peadar Cowan that is responsible for the obstruction and prolonging of the debate on this Bill.
Comment on this
I want to make a point, if Deputy Davin does not mind, and I hope he will listen to it. I am amazed that, as yet, I have not seen one member of a local county council sitting behind the Government saying anything against the amendments proposed from this side of the House. All the Deputies that have spoken on that side are not members of a local authority.
Comment on this
They have not had experience of what happened in days gone by in connection with maintenance costs of other drainage schemes that were carried out prior to the passing of the 1945 Drainage Act. Enormous burdens were placed on the ratepayers and the ratepayers have to bear that responsibility yet. If we are trying in this particular Bill to avoid placing similar burdens on local authorities in future, it is absolutely wrong and unfair for Deputy Davin or Deputy Cowan or anybody else to say that because our efforts are focussed in that direction it is obstructive tactics. Every Deputy must be well aware that the responsibility for collecting rates is a heavy responsibility and must recognise that the rates are already a very heavy burden on the unfortunate ratepayers. If we are trying to avoid further burdens on the ratepayers, we are doing a very useful work.
There is no use in saying that we are obstructing this Bill. We all welcome the Bill and we are trying to get the Parliamentary Secretary to see things in the light in which we as members of local authorities see them. Deputy Moran has been criticised by everybody. He was criticised particularly by Deputy Davin, very wrongfully, in so far as he asked what happened in Mayo County Council, having had Deputy Moran's word that this matter never came before the Mayo County Council. Neither did it come up before my county council. We are trying to get the Parliamentary Secretary to see the difficulties that will be facing local authorities in putting into operation any particular scheme under this Bill and we are endeavouring to relieve the local authorities of heavy responsibility that may be placed upon them through expense incurred in carrying out any particular scheme and in maintaining it. I do not know, of course, if there will be any maintenance but if we were to have drainage without maintenance it would be better not to have it at all. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance will clearly understand that if you are not going to have maintenance afterwards, it is quite useless.
Comment on this
Do not say a word about the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, whatever you do.
Comment on this
I like to say a word in his favour and try to get the people to understand that he is a little more intelligent than they think he is.
Comment on this
I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government to consider carefully the amendments that have been suggested from this side of the House and to take them in the spirit in which they are presented, that is, of trying to make the Bill workable.
I represent a county council that has always been most helpful in putting into operation any schemes that were ever submitted by a Government to them. When this Bill is through and when we are called upon to do certain works, I want local authorities to be able to go ahead with the work without any interference or stumbling blocks. I do not want to have the impression among local authorities and throughout the country that the Government are bringing in this measure to make it unworkable and to put the local authorities in the position of being able to say to them: "Well we have given you an Act and you are doing nothing about it." If, as was pointed out in this House before, the cost of administration is going to be as light as the Parliamentary Secretary has conveyed to us, then why not stand up to the original words of the Minister who introduced the Bill—that it is not going to cost the local authorities anything whatsoever, the whole hog or not at all? All the recommendations made from this side of the House are reasonable and well worthy of consideration. I have yet to see any member of a local authority standing up behind the Government and saying that the case we are making is not reasonable and right.
Comment on this
I have not intervened in this debate up to the present but I have listened very attentively to the arguments both for and against the amendments. I must say that I have not been very much impressed by the arguments from either side of the House either last night or this afternoon. I believe that a very good case could be made for these amendments —a better case than has been made for them. On the other hand I believe that a very strong case can be made against them.
Speaking for the amendments, the case would appear to be that the compensation clause of this Bill would in the first place impose an exceptionally heavy burden upon the local rates and, in the second place, might have the effect of deterring a local body from undertaking work by reason of the risk of having to pay heavy compensation.
Against these two arguments I should like to submit, as a member of a local authority for a great number of years, that I do not believe that the liability incurred by this clause will be heavy. I think it will be a reasonable contribution, having regard to the amount of money that is being provided. I should like to ask how many times in the past 25 years a local authority has been offered a 100 per cent. grant for any type of work. The hospitalisation grants were very generous but they were not 100 per cent. The lime subsidy grants were generous but even they were not 100 per cent. I do not think that any of the emergency grants for road reconstruction during the past few years—and these also were very generous grants—ever exceeded 90 per cent. I think that the liability which a county council will undertake by reason of carrying out this work, if they carry it out properly, will be a very modest portion of the total expenditure. As far as the argument that the compensation clause will deter county councils from undertaking useful work is concerned. I do not think there is anything to fear in that direction. The scope of the Bill is very wide. The number of schemes that a county council can undertake is very large. It will be open to a county council to select the very best of these schemes and to eliminate those which have an undue measure of risk. I believe the number of works that can be carried out under the Bill is so great that it will tax all the resources of the local authority to carry them out. It will provide employment for all the men that the county council may have available. The number of works that can be carried out is very large and they can be very widely distributed over each county. Therefore, I think that in reason and justice the Bill as it stands is quite a reasonable one. Some Deputies suggest that county councils were not aware, when they were submitting their schemes, of the compensation clause. The county council of which I am a member was aware of the compensation clause from the very outset.
Comment on this
Since the Bill was drafted. That clause was referred to at the county council meeting. Some members suggested that it should be deleted and other suggested that it should remain as a kind of a safeguard so that work that would involve claims for compensation would not be undertaken. It would be quite wrong for a county council to undertake work which, while it might be useful, might also do a considerable amount of damage to land, industry or something else. I think that, in the implementation of this Act, the county council should concentrate upon work that is simple and straightforward and that will not hold up or damage existing industries or injure land. I think that that is quite an understandable proposition and I think that was the aim which the late Minister had in mind when he was introducing the Bill.
On the other hand, I have heard various statements from this side of the House to the effect that this amendment was put down merely for the sake of obstruction. I would appeal to Deputies not to pursue that line in this House. The Opposition Party, if it is to be of any use at all, must approach legislation in a critical fashion. These amendments deserve reasonable consideration on their merits but I think that, on their merits, the House should reject them.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Cogan when he says that a local body should be very careful before undertaking work that might result in doing damage in some other way or in some place outside the immediate district in which the work was situated. In fact, it is to the damage that could result if the local bodies took advantage of sub-section (3) of Section 2 that Deputy Allen has referred. I agree also in the main with Deputy Cogan that, in so far as a local body takes advantage of sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 2 for the carrying out of work for the protection of its own property, an excellent case can be made to show that such a local authority, after getting the 100 per cent. grant, should be called upon to maintain that work and to keep it in proper condition. But if Deputies will read sub-section (3) they will see that the local authority, whether or not they exercise the type of discretion that Deputy Cogan has advised they should exercise, are given under that sub-section very wide power indeed. I am not suggesting that they will just run off and behave in all cases in an extravagant and dangerous fashion. I have before me the Parliamentary Secretary who is now in charge of the Office of Public Works. He has some knowledge of the administration of even small drainage schemes out of the Employment Schemes Vote and out of the Rural Improvement Schemes Vote. I had that responsibility for a number of years. I can say, as I think I may have stated on a number of occasions in this House, that we found in the execution of even small works costing only a few hundred pounds that damage did arise so far as adjoining districts are concerned. Deputies who are on local authorities seem to think that the problem is similar in every county. It is not. Every county presents peculiar problems of its own. What I am afraid of is that, while local authorities will take the advice and follow the course perhaps that Deputy Cogan has mentioned, there may be in certain cases pressure brought to bear upon members of a local authority and they may be induced to carry out a scheme of drainage or improvement of some river that might result in continuous damage arising at certain seasons of the year which the local authority would be liable for as long as that state of affairs existed.
I have not had any consultation with my colleagues on the point of view I am going to express now, but if I were to get an assurance from the Parliamentary Secretary that he would consider introducing an amendment on the Report Stage protecting local authorities in regard to the compensation that might arise under Section 2 (3), I would be reasonably satisfied with a gesture of that sort. As Deputy Cogan stated, it is nonsense to suggest that this discussion is intended to be obstructive. It is not. As the Deputy said, we have a duty to perform here. Quite apart from that, some of us who are not experts have at least some considerable experience from an administrative point of view of the problems which can arise from the carrying out of what might appear at the time a useful work if it is not planned in a very careful way by men who are qualified and who know the dangers, the implications and the harm which could result. That is our function as an Opposition and that is the purpose of these amendments. I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary at least to endeavour to meet us by saying that between now and the Report Stage he will consider the question of introducing an amendment on the lines of even the most moderate of these amendments, not in relation to the whole section, but in relation to sub-section (3) which gives to local authorities power to go outside their area and do work which has no connection with any of their own property.
Comment on this
From the speeches of Deputies opposite one would imagine that the purpose of the Bill was to place a very large burden on the ratepayers of the different counties. As against that, I would point out that local authorities and Deputies were well aware of the fact on the Second Stage of the Bill that compensation would not be paid out of State funds. Deputy Killilea and Deputy Aiken tried to tell the House that the late Minister for Local Government gave an indication that all expenditure on schemes under this Bill would be met by a 100 per cent. grant. I should like to refer those two Deputies to the late Minister's reply on the Second Stage of the Bill in which he said, as reported in Volume 114, cols. 2461-2 of the Official Reports:—
"The question of compensation has been raised on this Bill. I have already indicated that the Government will make available to the local authorities 100 per cent. of the cost of these schemes. It is not intended to exceed that amount by any sums to cover the cost of compensation. I am quite satisfied with regard to the cost of compensation, because I feel and I know that this Bill will be sensibly operated and that the cost of compensation will be very small."
I rather imagine that if the late Minister had announced when introducing the Bill that 75 per cent. of the cost of the actual execution of the works would be given Deputies opposite would have been rather satisfied and might only have asked that the 75 per cent. should be increased. Here there was an announcement that 100 per cent. grant would be given and Deputies opposite are not satisfied and ask that the Minister for Local Government should go further. If he did go further and say that he would pay the full compensation as well, they would probably ask for a bonus on it. I do not think it is an unreasonable gesture by the Minister for Local Government to say that, in respect of works to be carried out under this Bill, local authorities will get 100 per cent. grant.
Some local authorities have considered this Bill and in most counties they have formulated schemes which have been submitted to the Department and there has been no protest from the local authorities against the provisions of the Bill or the announcement that 100 per cent. grant would be given for the actual execution of the works.
Comment on this
It is no harm to remind the House that I am informed by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance that some months ago a deputation from the General Council of County Councils approached him and asked that local authorities should be given the facilities that they are being given in this Bill to enable them to carry out certain works to prevent flooding and to provide against other things which are mentioned in the Long Title. They asked that power be given to them and that power is being given in this Bill. I assume they are representative of the county councils of the Twenty-Six Counties. They asked merely for an 80 per cent. grant to help them to carry out these works. I am sure the General Council of County Councils and the 27 county councils in the country must consider it extremely generous when they get 100 per cent. grant towards the execution of the works.
Deputy Mrs. Crowley raised the question of maintenance. There is no obligation on the local authorities to maintain any work which they have undertaken. I should like to stress also that under this Bill local authorities are not being in any way saddled with any burden nor are the ratepayers. This is merely an enabling Bill which says that a county council may do certain things such as enter on land to carry out certain works. The county councils can consider and decide upon schemes. If they think there may be severe claims for compensation, they are entitled to say, and if, as I believe, they are responsible men, they will say: "We will not engage in any such scheme because it will result in too heavy a burden on the ratepayers."
Comment on this
What about Section 3 which gives the Minister power to do them whether the local authorities are willing or not?
Comment on this
I would refer Deputy Aiken to the Relief Works Act, 1940, by which the Minister is given power to compel a local authority to execute certain works for the relief of unemployment. There is no question there of compensation. There is no question of any contribution to the local authority for the cost of the works. Here there is an announcement that they will get 100 per cent. grant. In the Relief Works Act of 1940 introduced by a Fianna Fáil Minister there was no such figure, while in connection with this Bill there is the announcement of a grant of 100 per cent. for the actual execution of the work.
Deputy Moran raised the question of consultation with members of the local authority in connection with these schemes. I have a letter here from the county engineer of the Mayo County Council and he encloses with the letter a list of schemes which it is proposed to carry out in Mayo. In his letter he says:
"All the works included in this schedule are works which have been considered or mentioned at county council meetings."
Deputy Moran and Deputy Allen said that they had not seen the circular of 10th March. If these two Deputies have not seen that particular circular of the 10th March they are entitled to ask the county manager why he did not bring it before the meeting.
Comment on this
Is there anything in the circular to the effect that the local authorities are liable for compensation?
Comment on this
No, but there is nothing in the circular which says that the local authorities will not be liable for compensation.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary last night wanted to convey the impression to the House, I think, that local authorities had been informed that they would get a 100 per cent. grant and that they would be legally responsible for any damage that might arise afterwards. In any circular issued by the Department to the local authorities was that so stated?
Comment on this
In saying in this circular that 100 per cent. grant would be given for the actual execution of the works, I think it is reasonable to assume that any body or local authority would take it that they would be liable for compensation.
Comment on this
That is another way of putting it. That particular circular referred to by the Parliamentary Secretary was read by the secretary of the county council or manager at a county council meeting in Wexford. I raised the question because no circular was brought to the notice of the county council at Wexford setting out that the local authority would be liable for compensation. I want to make that clear. The Parliamentary Secretary has now admitted that no such circular was ever issued from the Department of Local Government.
Comment on this
I would still point out to the Deputy, who was present when the Minister made his Second Reading speech, that in no uncertain terms he said that compensation was to be paid.
Comment on this
That was not the Minister's Second Reading Speech. In the Minister's opening speech he did not mention compensation, good, bad or indifferent. That was a phrase in the closing speech.
Comment on this
Yes. I move amendment No. 10, Parts I and II:—
To add two new sub-sections as follows:—
( ) The powers conferred by sub-sections (2) and (3) of this section shall be exercised directly by the local authority acting by resolution whereof 14 days' notice shall be given.
( ) The resolution prescribed by the foregoing sub-section shall not take effect unless approved of by a majority of the full membership of the local authority.
The first part of this amendment is designed to ensure that the members of a local authority will directly exercise control under this Bill and will, by resolution, decide what works shall be undertaken. The second part of it proposes that a majority of the members of the local authority must pass a particular work before it is carried out. The reason for that is quite obvious, and I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that he should keep it in mind. Some of our county council areas are very large, and, naturally, councillors coming from one end of the area would not be familiar with the conditions in another part of the area. Some members might live 60 or 70 miles from one part of the county council area. Two members of a council might decide to try to get a particular work through for their own area, and in doing so would seek the support of members from other areas on the plea that when the latter wanted to get a work through in their area these two councillors would support them.
This amendment is designed to meet a situation of that sort, because it provides that a majority of the council must decide the matter before any works are executed. That means that every work coming before the council will be fully discussed by it, and that before any particular scheme is embarked upon a majority of the members would have to decide that the work is of a beneficial nature, that its execution will not do undue damage, and that in all the circumstances, it is a work that should be undertaken. That will ensure that a majority of the members will have to be fully satisfied that all due precautions have been taken, that no work will be carried out unless it is one of urgent importance, and that it is a work that had the support of the majority of the council. It will also ensure that the most urgent work to be done under the Bill will be carried out first by the council.
The amendment will also put the local authority in a position to decide the priority in which works in a county council area will be undertaken. I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that the members of a county council acting by a majority vote, are the best authority to decide this order of priority. They, of course, will know from their officials the jobs that are most essential from the urgency point of view. The local authority under this amendment will have the power to decide that issue. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will see his way to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept the amendment. This particular question was referred to, though not specifically, on other amendments. The effect of this would be to make the powers given by sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 2 reserved functions. I am wholly in sympathy with the Deputy when he says that the members of local authorities should be acquainted with the different schemes which it is proposed to engage in, but, as I said last night on another amendment, the County Management Act will be repealed and I do not think it would be wise to amend or change that Act in piecemeal fashion, as would be done if this amendment were accepted.
The Minister has endeavoured, as far as he can and with the powers he has, to ensure that the members of local authorities will be fully conversant with the schemes proposed to be carried out. Again I will refer to the circular which he issued to local authorities on the 10th March and the one issued no later than the 31st May. For the benefit of the House, I think it will be no harm for me to read that circular again. It was addressed in the following terms:—
"With reference to previous correspondence, I am directed by the Minister for Local Government to inform you that as soon as the Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949, becomes law decisions will be issued on the various schedules of schemes submitted to the Department for the purposes of the Bill. First preference will be given to simple schemes not requiring elaborate surveys or preparation, which may be undertaken without delay in an appropriate period of the present financial year. It is, therefore, recommended that a selection on these lines be made from the schemes submitted and that particulars thereof be placed before the elected body concerned for their preliminary approval."
I am aware that members of different local authorities are taking an active part in the submission and consideration of these schemes. As a matter of fact, even Deputies of this House are taking an active interest inasmuch as they are sending communications to local authorities and suggesting certain types of work which may be carried out.
I do not propose to accept this amendment, because it would mean amending the County Management Act in a piecemeal fashion. It is hoped in the near future to repeal the Act altogether.
Comment on this
I cannot accept the Parliamentary Secretary's reasoning on this matter of the County Management Act. We have had many sermons on that Act from the Parliamentary Secretary and his colleagues, but still there has not been any legislation tabled for the purpose of amending it. If the Act is bad, as the Parliamentary Secretary and his colleagues appear to believe, why not accept an amendment of this kind, which is designed to place the power in the hands of local authorities? We are told the County Management Act will be repealed. From reading the papers there would appear to be a divergence of view among the Parliamentary Secretary's colleagues. Here he has an opportunity of practising what he preaches; he has an opportunity under this amendment to place the power of deciding questions of priority of works and the types of works to be done in the hands of the local authorities. That being so. I cannot understand why the Parliamentary Secretary is so shy in accepting this amendment, which professes to do what he suggests should be done, and that is to give more and more power to local authorities.
Outside any question of the manager's functions under the County Management Act, the Parliamentary Secretary is aware that local authorities have various other functions, and one of the matters that could best be carried out by a local authority would be something of this kind, of deciding priority of the works and the type of works which should be done. I do not know why, in this Bill, schemes submitted by county managers are evidently being accepted, in some cases at all events, by the Parliamentary Secretary, without consultation with the local authority. It is true that county managers and county surveyors will have knowledge of many schemes, particularly in the line of drainage, that may have come from time to time under notice by these officials.
It is, as the Parliamentary Secretary is aware, a regular practice in the country up to this that even where you were submitting a scheme to the Board of Works, which was the authority that used to carry out these drainage schemes, you also endeavoured to enlist the aid of the county surveyor and the county manager—you submitted the scheme to them to get their approval. I understand that the Parliamentary Secretary has received a number of schemes from these officials. In one or two cases that we are aware of there was not consultation with the members of the local authority.
Comment on this
Oh, yes, they would be re-submitted to the local authority and considered by them. What I intended to convey was that certain schemes were submitted to me and I would send them back to the local authority for their consideration.
Comment on this
Suppose these schemes were not ones in which the local authority would be interested. There are schemes in which they would be interested, but these will not be considered at all. We have to select from the ones submitted to you.
Comment on this
I would let the local authority decide—I would send them down to the local authority.
Comment on this
It is quite easy for the Parliamentary Secretary to say he will let the local authority decide, having already said that the functions are the functions of the county manager.
Comment on this
We did not make the local authority such an incongruous body; the County Management Act did that. We are not going to amend that Act in a piecemeal fashion.
Comment on this
There are certain matters in connection with the County Management Act that possibly we will be dealing with on another occasion, but if that Act is not right, why then, when he gets an opportunity to carry out a particular function under this Bill, does the Parliamentary Secretary not accept the amendment which seeks to give the power to the different county councils to carry out these functions? It will not blow the bottom out of the County Management Act if you do that. You still have the Act and can amend it if the House so decides.
This is a new function for a local authority. Local authorities heretofore did not have the function of carrying out this system of drainage here, there and everywhere. It is a new duty that is being put upon the local authorities. When you are giving them this new job, why not make this particular rule suggested in the amendment for the local authorities to act upon? There is nothing unreasonable about that. If the Parliamentary Secretary is sincere in his criticism of the County Management Act, there is no reason why he should not accept the principles contained in these amendments. It will be the most practicable way of dealing with any problems that will arise. I urge him to reconsider the matter.
Comment on this
I should like to support Deputy Moran's points. It is quite clear to those of us who are members of local authorities that in this matter we are dealing with something that county councils heretofore have not had to deal with. We are on new ground and I am surprised at the Parliamentary Secretary refusing to accept this amendment. It has been pointed out by Deputy Moran that we have heard a lot of talk about the giving back to members of local authorities of the powers of which they were alleged to be deprived under the County Management Act. By accepting this amendment we have an opportunity now of giving to local authorities power to carry out certain works under this particular Bill. I do not see why we should not avail of that. I do not see why we should not trust the members of local authorities to carry out the schemes envisaged in this Bill. The Parliamentary Secretary has pointed out that since the Second Reading members of local authorities have taken an interest in submitting schemes and some of those schemes have been submitted to the county engineer. It is quite safe to assume that at least a percentage of these schemes will not be carried out. If this amendment is not accepted and if it is left to the judgment of the county manager or the county engineer, despite the representations that may be made by local authorities as to the schemes which they in their wisdom think should be carried out under this Bill, the schemes decided upon may not be the ones they want to have at all. We are thus depriving the local authorities of their power to carry out the schemes which they consider are in the best interests of their particular county. I take it no scheme will be carried out without the approval of the county engineer.
If the members of the local authorities have no power except merely to submit schemes to the county manager and county engineer it is these officials who will have the last word as to what schemes are to be carried out. In that way I think we are merely perpetuating what the Labour Party, of which both the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary are members, decried and criticised in the County Management Act. This amendment only seeks to make it a reserved function of the local authority to advise the schemes and put them in their proper order when the county engineer has sanctioned them, provided they are schemes that come within the scope of the Bill and can be reasonably carried out to serve the functions which this Bill is intended to serve. Having fulfilled all those conditions, the members of the local authorities should have the last word as to the schemes that are to be carried out and it should not be left to the county manager. If the Parliamentary Secretary is sincere in his protestations I cannot see how he, or the Minister, or any member of the Labour Party can resist this amendment.
Comment on this
I wonder what has suddenly imbued the members of the Opposition with this potent desire for vesting in the members of local authorities new-found powers. Nobody on this side of the House and no member of the Labour Party ever accepted—
Comment on this
I wonder if a complete change of front has taken place, because I have a very distinct recollection of who was supposed to be the best judge of the public interest when the County Management Bill was going through the House. It certainly was not the elected representatives then. That Act was not passed by anyone who now sits on the Government side of the House. Now Deputy Brady wants to say that the best judge of the public interest is so-and-so. The position is that the present Opposition passed the County Management Act. That is an Act with which the members of this Government now and when they were in opposition fundamentally disagree. We are going to introduce legislation very quickly to amend that Act and we will not be forced by the Opposition under cover of this Bill to do anything else.
This is a Bill that is much more urgent than is the alteration in the County Management Act. Earlier on the Opposition wanted to truncate and tie down local authorities and county councils by having them under the control of the engineer. They did not trust either the county manager or the elected representatives. They said it must be done under the report of the engineer; otherwise the schemes could not take place at all. The difficulty is that under existing legislation passed by the Fianna Fáil Government they cannot be trusted until such time as we amend the County Management Act.
As the Parliamentary Secretary has said, there are two distinct functions. We want to get on with this Bill and we want to get on with the work. In due course the functions will revert to the proper authorities and powers will be restored to the elected representatives. That will be done very shortly. Meantime the Opposition need not fear that anything will go wrong. We could not accept any piecemeal division of what we propose to do in a general Bill for the amendment of the County Management Act. I do not know that the Opposition are quite so worried as they profess to be. They need not worry because in a very short time the County Management Act will be amended. Until that time the Opposition should accept the Bill as it is. There is no danger that the works will not be properly carried out.
Comment on this
In thinking of terms of this amendment I did not ask myself as to whether or not it would have the effect that I now see it can have; that is, the effect of amending the County Management Act. My approach to this amendment was that, in considering the proposed scheme under this Bill when it becomes law, I thought the widest possible source of knowledge, after the technical people employed had made their observations, would come from the practical men who were members of the county council. I did not advert to the fact that it might have the effect of amending the County Management Act. Since this matter has been raised by both the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary I would like to ask them if, in the course of a month or two, we have an amendment introduced here transferring back to the local authorities powers which are now vested in the county manager why, when we are in possession of that knowledge, should we now proceed to introduce a Bill giving local authorities a power which they never had before. Why should we, in the knowledge that we are going to strip the manager of all powers which he has at present, come along and in this new matter put responsibility upon him? It is all very well for the Minister to make play with this idea that we are now very keen on giving to local bodies this and that power.
I must confess, although I was a member of a local body and have some experience of the working of local bodies, that I have no strong views, or never had, one way or other as to the County Management Act. I certainly even yet can see no very strong objection that can be made to it. Why should we have this attempt from the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister to play around the powers given under the County Management Act? After all, we were not the architects of the managerial system. The managerial system was instituted before our time and there are members over there who were responsible for the Government of the country when the managerial system was first introduced. I was a member of the Opposition then. I admit that we adopted it and extended it to the country but we were not the only people responsible for it. I am not trying to shed myself of responsibility for the County Management Act but it is only right that the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary should remember, in talking about the County Management Act, that they have in their own ranks the people who are the architects of that whole system.
I would invite the Minister to be serious on this matter. I say, as one with a little experience of local bodies, that if there ever was a function that could be suitably carried out by a local body, it is the function that local bodies will be called upon to carry out under this Bill. There is no other matter on which a local body is so well equipped to express an opinion as on the order of priority or on the question of what works should be carried out. They have the county surveyor there to advise them as to the utility of the work and as to the damage that might arise. If there is any duty which a local authority is properly designed to perform it is to express an opinion on these matters and this whole bogey of amending the County Management Act does not arise at all. This is a new power we are giving to local bodies and we should leave the County Management Act out of it. We are simply suggesting, without reference to the County Management Act, that the majority of the county council will have the right to say which work will be carried out and the order in which works will be carried out. If there is a really tangible argument to be advanced, apart from this flippant type of stuff to which we have been treated, I invite the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary to come down to earth and to be serious about it.
Comment on this
The arguments advanced in support of this amendment are more reasonable, or perhaps I should say more plausible, than those to which we were treated on the previous amendments put forward. I think the answer to the point made by Deputy Smith is that, as instanced by the Parliamentary Secretary, there will be consultations with the county council. In the second place, were this amendment to be accepted, it would be possible—I am not saying it would be done—to render some of the effects which it is intended to achieve by this Bill completely nugatory. Generally speaking, in considering any piece of legislation, I think it is wise for a Government not to attempt to deal in a piecemeal fashion with the question but to deal with it in one particular piece of legislation.
I am glad to hear that the County Management Act will be amended and that in the near future. One thing that does strike me—and I wonder it does not strike Deputies opposite—is the complete incongruity of their position in seeking to give additional powers to the local authority or in having any concern over the withholding of power from the local authority because, when in office, the policy they pursued was completely the reverse.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary and to the Minister that the County Management Act was dragged in here as a red herring. It did not arise at all in this Bill.
Comment on this
It does not arise on this amendment. If this amendment were passed it would not alter the County Management Act by one comma. I further ask the Parliamentary Secretary to tell the House what executive function, assuming this amendment were not here, the manager will perform under this Bill as it is? Will he perform any executive function? Will he operate as a county manager at all in any single respect? It might be interesting to know that. Can he inform the House?
Comment on this
Good enough. The Parliamentary Secretary talked about this amendment amending the County Management Act. I want to challenge that. It amends it in no possible way. The Parliamentary Secretary is further aware that in both the County Management Act itself and in subsequent enactments by this House, many reserved functions were mentioned. That occurred even in legislation that became the law of this country years after the passing of the Management Act. I can see that under this Bill the executive authority will rest with the Department of Local Government, the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary and with nobody else. They will have the final say as to whether a particular job—it does not matter whether it is to cost £5 or £5,000—will be carried out. The works will have to be sanctioned by the Minister. The Minister for Local Government will be the executive authority under this Bill and nobody else. The machinery which the local authorities will operate under this Act is the ordinary machinery they operate in regard to minor relief schemes, rural improvement schemes and a number of other schemes at the present time. There is no doubt about that. There has been a lot of hullabaloo beyond about all the powers which are given to local authorities under this Bill and a lot of nonsense because under sub-section (3) new work is to be performed that never was the function of local authorities before. The passing of this amendment will give local authorities——
Comment on this
——no power whatever. It gives them the power of putting on a list which will be sent to the Minister for Local Government the schemes in the order they think they should be done, and it gives them the power to leave off that list schemes which they think should not be done. The Minister will write then to the secretary of the county council or the county manager to say that he has approved of schemes Nos. 7, 8 and 10 perhaps.
Comment on this
He will give authority to the engineer to carry out schemes and no other person gives that authority. There is no amendment of the County Management Act in this amendment. It just enables local authorities to put schemes in the order of priority they think right and if their name was not in it the Bill would enable the county manager to put them in the order of priority he thinks right. Is that not so? I contend that in accepting this amendment the Government are affecting in no way whatever the County Management Act. It is there for all the good that is in it and for all the bad that is in it. I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that local authorities are just as quick as county managers to get work done and I would appeal to the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary at least to reconsider this matter—that is all I am asking them to do—between this and the Report Stage. No principle is involved as far as local authorities are concerned. With or without the amendment they will get support and help to get work done. I want to stress that the authority lies in the Minister for Local Government and that is quite right when, as the Parliamentary Secretary has said, he is providing the money. I want to kill the contention that I am amending the County Management Act.
Comment on this
This mass repudiation of the County Management Act by the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party comes as a welcome surprise to us. I have often wondered to myself what section of the Fianna Fáil Party prevailed on the Minister for Local Government in 1940 to introduce the County Management Act at all.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary is not careful we will have a debate on the County Management Act.
Comment on this
I would like to remind the House that Deputy MacEntee's name is after this amendment. In effect, it means that members of local authorities shall exercise the powers conferred by sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 2. It would be interesting to know if Deputy MacEntee still has the same ideas about the County Management Act as he had and I refer Deputies on the opposite side of the House to some remarks he made on the 31st March. I quote Volume 114, column 2154. Bearing in mind what Opposition Deputies have said they should consider these remarks of Deputy MacEntee.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen was quibbling for quite a long time.
"At the moment I am dealing with one particular point: for the first time in its history Dáil Eireann is being asked, I believe, to allow small bodies of local men—however estimable they may be in other respects— to become the judges of the general public interest. However estimable they may be in other respects, they cannot have the necessary vision or the necessary experience to constitute themselves reliable judges in such a cause."
Comment on this
All I want to say is that the County Management Act has nothing whatsoever to do with this amendment. If the Minister is anxious that the works under this Bill will be carried out quickly he should seriously consider this amendment. Local authorities exercise many useful functions notwithstanding the County Management Act and very many people have not changed their minds in connection with that Act. This particular function of deciding on these works is a function designed for a local authority. Members of local authorities coming from the areas concerned will be in a much better position to judge whether one work is more important than another than the Minister or some of his officials in the Department. They will know which work should get priority. If it is estimated that some work may cause damage or that it is too large to be undertaken in one year they, knowing local conditions, are in a much better position to decide according to those conditions which work should be undertaken in this year and which should be left over. We know that all the works which come under this Bill cannot be done in one year, particularly the works under the second part of the Bill which, to my mind, from the local authorities point of view is by far the most important part. Under the second part local authorities will deal with works on property not their own. Although the Parliamentary Secretary may, as he says, give the full grant for the actual execution of the works in one particular year, the local authority might not be in a position to carry out all those works. As far as I can see, local authorities are now going to take over the function of the Board of Works in connection with drainage and that being so, we know that a considerable amount of survey work and spade work will be involved before schemes can be done.
I want the Parliamentary Secretary to realise that if that work is left to the local authority it will be far better for the Minister and his Department in the long run. If the local authority in its wisdom decides to go ahead with certain works this year and leave others to next year the door will not be left open to the suggestion regarding the Parliamentary Secretary or the Minister that somebody came to the Department behind the back of the local authority and succeeded in getting a certain work done while another urgent work was left undone. That will be the position if the amendment is accepted and it has nothing to do with the County Management Act at all. This Bill gives new functions to local authorities and new work will be done and in handing over these new works I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to authorise the local authorities to say that the most urgent works should be done first.
Comment on this
A further point that has not been made yet in support of this amendment is that, even under the County Management Act, with all its defects, the initiation of public works must come from the local authority. If they decide to carry out a certain scheme, it is obligatory on the county manager to make the necessary arrangements to have the scheme carried out. Therefore, it is not asking too much that the initiation of schemes under this Bill should be in the hands of the local authority.
We had a revelation here from Deputy Lehane—I am sorry he has gone out—who, so far as I know, has no knowledge of local authorities. He is not a member of one. He says that, if the powers we seek in this amendment were given to local authorities, it is possible to render some of the effects of this Bill nugatory. I would like to have a repudiation from the Minister that he is afraid that if he gave these powers to local authorities they would render the effects of some parts of this Bill nugatory. I believe that is a reflection on the local authorities. In any legislation passed through this House that affected them—no matter what Government was in office —the experience has been that the members of local authorities have cooperated and given all the assistance they could in putting the legislation into effect, whenever they thought it would help some of the ills affecting their district or county. For a man with no experience of a local authority, not even a member of one, to make that charge against the members of local authorities on the whole, is not a very creditable performance.
It seems to be useless to appeal to the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary to reconsider their attitude on this particular matter. Deputy Allen asked a very important question and the Parliamentary Secretary promised to answer it but, whether he overlooked it or not, he did not answer it when he was replying—that is, what executive function would the county manager exercise in connection with these schemes. It is obvious that he has very little power or function so far as this Bill is concerned. It is a question as to whether the Minister could transfer some of the powers he has under the County Management Act to him to exercise under this.
I hope that the reason for not giving the local authorities power to promulgate schemes and have the say in the priority and as to how they are to be carried out, is not the reason given by Deputy Lehane. I think the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary are making a mistake in not giving to the members of the local authorities the power that we ask them to give in this particular amendment.
Comment on this
There are several amendments which are allied. They provide that proposed works be executed in accordance with the decision of the Board of Works. All the amendments referred to are not to the same section, but they are amendments Nos. 11, 12, 13, 14 and 42. The principle, at least, I suggest, would be decided on amendment No. 11.