We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 137–266 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Authorities (Works) Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 8 of 1949 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I quite understand that. I said that the principle could be decided on amendment No. 11, but, if Deputies desire it, they can have a decision on any of the others.

Comment on this

We can discuss them all together?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, and, if Deputies desire a decision on any one of them, they may have it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

Before Section 3 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Where a local authority proposes to execute works under Section 2 it shall give to the Commissioners of Public Works notice of its intention to do so. Such notice shall be addressed to the Commissioners so as to be received by them not less than six clear weeks before the date on which it is proposed to execute the works and shall be accompanied by such plans and other documents as will show accurately the nature and extent of the proposed works.

(2) On receipt of the notice prescribed by the foregoing sub-section the Commissioners of Public Works shall inform as soon as may be, but in any case not later than ten clear days after receipt of the prescribed notice, every other local authority, statutory board, authority or undertaking the interests of which in the opinion of the commissioners are likely to be affected by the nature and extent of the proposed works.

(3) Within 21 days after the day on which it receives notice from the Commissioners of Public Works in accordance with the foregoing sub-section any authority which is of opinion that its interests are likely to be adversely affected by the execution of the proposed works may lodge notice of objection with the commissioners. Every notice of objection lodged by a local authority under this sub-section shall state cleraly and precisely the grounds of such objection and shall be accompanied by such data, including maps and documents as are necessary to substantiate it.

(4) On receipt of every such notice of objection as aforesaid the Commissioners of Public Works shall refer such notice of objection and the grounds therefor to their officers, who shall report thereon to the commissioners in due course.

(5) When the Commissioners of Public Works have received the reports of their officers as aforesaid upon all the objections lodged to the execution of the proposed works, they shall consider all such notices of objection in the light of the prescribed reports and if in their opinion there are reasonable grounds for any or all of such objections they shall convene a conference of the representatives of all the local authorities concerned with the objections and of the local authority proposing to execute the works. Such conference shall be presided over by a person appointed by the Commissioners of Public Works to take the chair and conduct proceedings at the conference.

(6) A local authority which participates in a conference, convened by the Commissioners of Public Works under the foregoing sub-section (5) of this section, shall be represented thereat by two elected members, together with the county manager or manager or some person deputed by him, and the principal engineering officer or adviser of the local authority or some person deputed by him.

(7) When a conference which has been convened by the Commissioners of Public Works under the foregoing sub-section assembles, it shall consider the proposed works and shall endeavour to formulate agreed proposals in regard to them.

(8) If and when the chairman appointed under sub-section 5 of this section forms the opinion that it is unlikely that agreed proposals will be formulated by the conference, he shall express such opinion to the conference and shall intimate that if agreement upon proposals be not reached within one hour he proposes to adjourn the conference and to report back to the Commissioners of Public Works. At the conclusion of one hour as aforesaid the chairman, unless he is then of opinion that agreement is likely to be reached, shall adjourn the conference and report back to the commissioners.

(9) On receipt of the report of a chairman of a conference convened under the foregoing sub-section that the conference concerned has failed to reach agreement the Commissioners of Public Works shall consider the works proposed to be executed and the objections which have been lodged thereto and shall make such proposals for changes in the works proposed as in their judgment are reasonable in the light of the aforesaid objections and shall circulate such proposals to all the authorities represented at the conference for their consideration provided always that if the commissioners decide that the objections lodged to the proposed works are insuperable or that it is not in the public interest that the proposed works should be executea they shall not make proposals for the amendment of the works, but instead shall proceed to act as prescribed in sub-section (10).

(10) If the Commissioners of Public Works, having considered the proposed works and the objections lodged thereto in accordance with sub-section (9) of this section, decide that the objections lodged to the proposed works are insuperable or that it is not in the public interest to execute such works, they shall convey such decision to the local authority proposing to execute the works and thereupon the decision of the local authority to execute the proposed works shall be deemed to be rescinded and such works shall not be proceeded with.

(11) If the Commissioners of Public Works acting under sub-section (9) make proposals for changes in the works proposed, the conference prescribed in sub-section (5) shall be reconvened and the proposals of the commissioners shall be submitted for its consideration. The conference shall thereupon consider the proposals of the commissioners and in relation thereto shall decide

(a) to accept the proposals of the commissioners, or

(b) to submit amendments to them for the further consideration of the commissioners.

If the conference decides to submit amendments to the proposals of the commissioners, all such amendments shall be submitted to the conference in the form of a motion which shall be duly proposed and seconded.

(12) All the decisions at an adjourned conference shall be taken on motions duly proposed and seconded and shall be made by majority vote.

(13) If the conference as reconvened under sub-section (11) of this section decide to accept the proposals of the Commissioners of Public Works such proposals shall be deemed to be accepted by the authorities proposing to execute the works and the works in question shall be executed in accordance with them.

(14) If the conference acting under sub-section (11) of this section decide to amend the proposals of the Commissioners of Public Works, the proposals as amended shall be considered by the Commissioners who shall decide whether

(a) to accept all the proposals, or

(b) to accept certain of the proposals, or

(c) to accept none of the proposals.

When the commissioners have thus decided they shall communicate such decision to the local authority proposing to execute the works and if the works in question are proceeded with, they shall be executed in accordance with the decision of the commissioners.

Comment on this

Am I to take it that Deputy Aiken is moving amendment No. 11, in Deputy MacEntee's name?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes. It is the first and the widest

Comment on this

And the most satisfactory from my point of view.

Comment on this

Deputy Aiken is moving Deputy MacEntee's amendment?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy has been so informed.

Comment on this

What does he propose to do about his own amendment, which is different?

Comment on this

I will inform the Deputy, if he allows me to say a few words. Deputy MacEntee's amendment is, in my opinion, a very useful amendment.

Comment on this

That does not clarify the situation. I am asking for information. Is Deputy MacEntee's amendment——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy allow the Chair?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There are several amendments in which the principle is the same. The widest is amendment No. 11. The others are narrow issues on the same principle. The whole matter is being discussed on No. 11, and decisions will be granted on any other of the minor amendments, if Deputies so desire.

Comment on this

If we strangle No. 11, does that execute the others?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy understood me very well.

Comment on this

If the members of the Government Parties succeed in strangling No. 11, they may do a great deal of damage in the country. We hope to get their assistance in preventing this potential damage being done. The Parliamentary Secretary to-day said that all the works proposed by county managers would be vetted in his Department and I take it his engineering staff or his staff, at any rate, will go through these various proposals and say whether or not they should be carried out. We had a Drainage Commission which sat for a long time and went very thoroughly into all this question of drainage. They made certain recommendations. One of their principal recommendations, which was generally accepted by the Dáil, was that there should be a central authority to co-ordinate and supervise all drainage construction operations and that in the opinion of that commission the central drainage authority should be a separate and self-contained branch of the Office of Public Works. That is from the Drainage Report, page 37. That Drainage Commission Report and various other authorities who have considered the question of drainage in all its aspects advise due caution and well-prepared plans before drainage is entered upon. The Department of Local Government is organised to do certain engineering jobs. Their engineers are very efficient in passing judgment on proposals for new roads, new bridges, housing schemes, because in all these works they have had great experience. Up to this date they have had practically no experience of drainage and it is the experience of everybody who has had to deal with the question of drainage that the technical people dealing with it should be not only engineers but drainage engineers. This amendment is suggesting that instead of proposals for drainage being submitted to the engineers non-technically expert in drainage matters, instead of being submitted to the Department of Local Government, they should be submitted to the best technical people we have in the country in drainage, and their address is the Office of Public Works.

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance replied to some local proposals for drainage in one case that we quoted before—they have replied, I am sure, in similar terms to other proposals for drainage over a long number of years—that they would not undertake certain work because they knew the danger involved in it. They made one mistake some years ago, a very big one. They were pressed to do a drainage work which resulted in grave damage and very little benefit and, for a number of years, to my knowledge, they have steadfastly refused to release water upstream unless they know that they would be able to handle it downstream and convey it to the sea without flooding other land and creating greater damage than the damage they were relieving.

This amendment suggests, therefore, seeing that drainage works proposed by local authorities have to be referred to Dublin, that instead of referring them to the non-technically expert Department of Local Government, they should be referred to the Office of Public Works which is our main drainage authority, from whom this Dáil has to seek advice on drainage questions through the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. It proposes, therefore, that the matter should be referred to the Office of Public Works and that the Office of Public Works upon receipt of a proposal should consult all other authorities that in their opinion might be affected as a result of the execution of the work; that if they thought an adjoining local authority would be affected, they should consult it; if they thought a fishery authority or the Electricity Supply Board or any other authority you like to mention might be affected through the carrying out of the drainage, such authority and all the authorities concerned should be taken into consultation. It sets out procedure as to how this consultation should take place.

I would urge the Parliamentary Secretary very strongly to accept this amendment. If he does not accept it, I think we will find that in certain instances at any rate a great deal of damage will be done by engineers inexperienced in this business for which the local ratepayers will have to pay according to the Bill as it now stands, and that portion of the Bill which has already been passed by this Dáil. It is not fair to local ratepayers to burden them with bills for damage without at least having given them the most expert advice that we can give them. The most expert advice this State can give on drainage matters is to be obtained in the Office of Public Works from engineers specially selected for that purpose, engineers who have had long experience not only in the successful execution of works but sometimes in the unsuccessful execution of works. It is by mistakes sometimes that people become really expert. Are we to start this year by having to change our drainage authority to the Department of Local Government? Will the ratepayers of this country have to educate the engineers in that Department and will they be mulcted for large damages and then come to the doorstep of the Custom House and, knocking very loudly, demand from the Minister that as they went ahead with his O.K. he should now come to their assistance and bear the cost of the damage involved. It is thought by some people who have no knowledge of drainage matters that the only damage you can do by releasing water upstream is to flood somebody downstream. But other grave damage can be inflicted. You can lower the whole water-table in a certain region so that farmers will have no water for their cattle and that the wells will dry up. That has been the experience of many authorities that have carried out drainage works.

It has been the experience not only here but in other countries too. If inexpert drainage is to take place—particularly under sub-section (3) of Section 2—on property not belonging to the local authority, grave damage may be done to the level of the water-table in certain regions and you may have a shortage of water for cattle and for human beings. To the city person that does not seem very much. They see some swamp drained and they think that some great good has been accomplished. But to the farmers in a district who are depending for water for the cattle on keeping the watertable at a certain level—which will result at certain times of the year in flooding in a certain marsh—the disappearance of that water might mean that they might have to go four or five miles for water for their cattle and not only for water for their cattle but for water for their household. There are other amendments here, dealing with the lowering of the water-table to that extent, which we shall come to deal with afterwards. However, in view of the expertness of the decision that has to be taken before anybody can proceed with the drainage work in the reasonable expectation that less damage will be done than has been cured by it, it is reasonable, I think, to ask the Parliamentary Secretary to accept this amendment of Deputy MacEntee's and I hope he will see his way to do it. After all, as I said, these schemes have to be submitted to Dublin. What I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to do is to see that the schemes are submitted to drainage experts rather than to engineers or civil servants who are not expert in drainage problems.

Comment on this

If I thought that there was the merest possibility of the Parliamentary Secretary entertaining seriously any thought of accepting this amendment I should never find myself able to have the slightest confidence in him again. It is perfectly clear what is intended by this amendment. What is intended by it is to strangle this Bill in red tape. I do not want to weary the House by analysing it, but the whole tenor of it is delay and red tape —a notice is to be addressed to the commissioners so as to be received by them not less than six clear weeks before the date on which it is proposed to execute the works...; then a further possible delay of a period of ten days; a further possible delay, under sub-section (3) of three weeks, within which period objection may be lodged; then the objections are to be referred to the officers of the Board of Works; the officers are to have them for some unspecified period and they are to report to the commissioners——

Comment on this

"In due course."

Comment on this

——in due course. Then, if we are to accept the amendment, there is to be a conference, with an elaborate procedure for convening it. The findings of that conference can be again referred back to the commissioners and the commissioners can sit on the findings of the conference to decide whether they will amend them or refuse to entertain them altogether. I think it is an insult to this House to seriously put that amendment forward. Deputy Aiken knows perfectly well, with the wide experience he has had of these matters, that this Bill is not a Bill to carry out arterial drainage. I would refer him to Clause 3 of the explanatory memorandum which reads as follows:—

"The works which the local authority may carry out include the making of drains, the clearing of obstructions in and the widening and deepening of watercourses and the making or repairing of walls or embankments."

Comment on this

What does "the widening and deepening of watercourses" mean?

Comment on this

It was made perfectly clear by the Minister in introducing the Bill——

Comment on this

And the diversion of water?

Comment on this

——that what were intended to be dealt with under this Bill were minor watercourses. This Bill was not intended to be portion of an arterial drainage scheme. Deputy Aiken's gloomy prophesies—which would lead one to believe that he had already started to build his Ark in order to prepare for the flooding he said he expected—would certainly, I suggest, leave most Deputies cold. If the Dáil were to accept this amendment, I submit in all seriousness that it would take as long as 12 months for the local authority to remove the dead carcass of a dog from a stream. Deputy Aiken made these gloomy prophesies. He talked about the farmers' knowledge of these problems and of the fact that expert advice should be secured on them. With that, of course, every Deputy on this side of the House is in complete agreement. However, there seems to exist in the minds of the Deputies on the benches opposite the idea that we have no competent engineers in the employ of the local authorities. I do not believe that that is so. I may be speaking in abysmal ignorance but I believe there are competent engineers working for the local authorities throughout the country. I certainly do not conceive for a minute that there is a possibility that the Minister is going to entertain this amendment seriously, but, if he was, I would certainly urge upon him that he should get any idea like that out of his head. From my week-end contacts with the country and with the farming community—I will be told they are not as close as those which Deputy Smith and Deputy Aiken have—I have formed the opinion that the farmers want this Bill and want it in its present form.

Comment on this

I am somewhat surprised that Deputy Lehane, who is a lawyer, should invite us to take the statements made here on the Second Reading by the Minister who introduced the measure or the Parliamentary Secretary or any other speaker rather than what is provided for in the Bill. The amendments which we seek to induce the House to accept and which are said to be deliberately obstructive and creating red tape have been placed on the Order Paper because of the confusion which seems to exist as to what this Bill really intends to achieve. Deputy Lehane has assured us that it is not a drainage Bill.

Comment on this

It is not an arterial drainage Bill.

Comment on this

He then proceeds to refer to the Long Title, in which mention is made of the fact that streams, rivers and watercourses can be altered and changed. On the other hand, last night we had from the Parliamentary Secretary an assurance that of the £2,000,000 worth of schemes already submitted some 70 or 80 per cent. dealt largely with protective works designed to raise the level of roads and protect county council property and so on. I am at a loss to know if I am to have any regard for the statements made as to what is meant by the Bill. I do not know where I stand.

When I turn to sub-section (3) of Section 2 I see there that the local authority is being given power to deal with drainage problems. Whether they decide to do so or not, the power is being conferred upon them to deal with these problems. It is all very well for Deputies to say that we are endeavouring to put around this Bill all sorts of red tape in order to cause delay. I do not say that my knowledge of rural conditions is greater than Deputy Lehane's. What I am concerned about is some machinery, some safeguards which are necessary because of the provisions of Section 2 (3).

Comment on this

Need the machinery have been so cumbersome?

Comment on this

I am not going to analyse the amendment to see if it could not be watered down. As a layman, I know that this amendment aims at placing on the local authority some responsibility to see that people whose lands might be affected adversely as a result of certain works that might be carried out will have some breathing space in which to look around and see what is likely to occur. Because of the situation of the land I own, I happen to be in a position to demonstrate to Deputies who may be in doubt the ill-effects that certain ill-conceived small works might have upon my own interests.

It is not correct to say as Deputy Lehane said that the powers which are being given to local authorities only give them the right to deal with small streams. A stream, no matter how small it is, after passing over three or four or five miles of country must ultimately get to some drainage catchment. Even the simplest sort of drainage work must lead to some little stream. That stream will lead to a larger river and the larger river will lead to a main artery. Mr. Holmes in his report some months ago advised the Government that they should be careful to proceed with drainage problems from the right end.

It is not fair for Deputies simply to make the allegation that in drafting an amendment like this the one thought we had in mind was to fight a sort of delaying action. I invite the Minister, the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Lehane and others who may address themselves to this matter to read Section 50 of the Drainage Act of 1945. They will find that section compels local authorities to notify the drainage authority of their intention to build a bridge over a river or to reconstruct a bridge over a river. It places not only upon local bodies but other authorities the legal obligation of giving notice of their intention to engage in any work in or adjacent to any river or stream in any catchment area. Speaking as a layman, I think when you read this section you will see that even so far as sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 2 of this Bill are concerned in which we are giving power to local authorities to carry out protective work on bridges and to prevent flooding on roads we are not relieving them of the obligation to notify the drainage authority which is mentioned in the amendment we are now moving as the authority to which all problems should first of all be submitted before carrying out any work. Section 50 of the Drainage Act, 1945, is entitled "Restrictions on the construction or alteration of bridges" and reads as follows:—

"(1) No local authority, no railway company, canal company, or other similar body, and no industrial concern shall construct any new bridge or alter, reconstruct, or restore any existing bridge over any watercourse without the consent of the commissioners or otherwise than in accordance with plans previously approved of by the commissioners.

(2) If any person shall construct or begin to construct or partially construct a new bridge in contravention of this section, the comissioners may serve by post on such person a notice requiring him——

(a) if such bridge has not been completely constructed, to desist forthwith from the construction thereof,

(b) in any case, to remove, within a time specified in that behalf in such notice, such bridge or so much thereof as shall have been constructed.

(3) If any person shall alter, reconstruct, or restore an existing bridge in contravention of this section or shall begin so to do or shall partially so do, the commissioners may serve by post on such person a notice requiring him—

(a) if such alteration, reconstruction, or restoration has not been completed, to desist forthwith therefrom, or

(b) in any case, to remove, within a time specified in that behalf in such notice, all work done on such bridge, or

(c) in any case, within a time specified in that behalf in such notice, to restore such bridge to its original condition.

(4) If any person on whom a notice has been served by the commissioners under the foregoing provisions of this section fails to comply with such notice, the following provisions shall apply and have effect, that is to say:—

(a) such person shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable, on summary conviction thereof, to a fine not exceeding fifty pounds together with a further fine not exceeding five pounds for every day during which such failure is continued;"

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What Act and section is the Deputy reading?

Comment on this

Section 50 of the Arterial Drainage Act, 1945.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

And the page?

Comment on this

The page is 119.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the volume?

Comment on this

The Statutes of 1945.

Comment on this

The point I want to make is that in so far as sub-section (1) and sub-section (2) of Section 2 of this Bill are concerned, which propose to give power to local authorities to carry out certain works on property, the maintenance and so on for which they have responsibility, they are obliged by Section 50 of the Arterial Drainage Act to give notice of their intention, to supply the drainage authority with their plans and other documents in connection with these proposals. That section definitely obliges them to submit that evidence to the drainage authority. I would like some such safeguard to be inserted in this measure to ensure that, in regard to sub-section (3) of Section 2, local authorities would be obliged to notify the drainage authority of their intention to carry out any work under that sub-section and to have their approval as it will be necessary in other cases to have that approval before the work can proceed.

There has undoubtedly been an enormous amount of loose talk as to what could be done under this Bill, in the course of the Second Reading. I actually heard one Deputy on the Government side complimenting those who had framed those proposals on the ground that they created 26, I think, different drainage authorities. It is all very well to make a boast of that kind, but from the point of view of the practical working of a Bill of this kind when it becomes an Act, that could only result in confusion; that is, if work is to be undertaken under sub-section (3) of Section 2. Certainly the power is being given under that sub-section to local bodies to engage in it whether they do or not and we must assume that it must be the intention of somebody that they will take advantage of that power. It is only reasonable that those of us who see in that provision an enormous amount of danger for many landholders in this country should desire that they will be given the same protection other bodies are provided with under the section of the Arterial Drainage Act to which I have just referred.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy suggest protracting the procedure set out there?

Comment on this

I do not want any procedure to be protracted. I have no love of defending protracted procedure so far as any Minister or Parliamentary Secretary wanting to engage in work, having work done and giving employment and so on, is concerned. However, there is no use in our proceeding on the basis that just for the sake of speed alone other very important matters will not be considered. Whatever time is necessary to give normal consideration to the interests I have in mind, then that provision should be made. I give this assurance. I do not know whether we could simplify that amendment while at the same time inserting in this measure the idea that I have endeavoured to express here.

I had at my finger-tips some years ago a clearer knowledge of the dangers that would result from indiscriminate and careless carrying out of work of this fashion. There is no use in trying to represent me as saying that men are incompetent and so on. With regard to engineers and people who have spent a life-time in studying these problems, as Deputy Aiken has said, the best of them will make mistakes and many of them will become knowledgeable as a result of having made mistakes in the past. You can misrepresent my words if you like, but what I am really saying is that in tampering with the course of water you are dealing with something that is far more dangerous and difficult than constructing roads and building houses. I happen to live in a district in which the damage that small drainage schemes can do has been demonstrated to me more than once. As I have contended and as it can be proved, whether you start at the top or not and no matter how simple the scheme, it must ultimately go into the heart of some catchment area. If that catchment area is not in a proper condition to receive it those whose lands are situated there will undoubtedly suffer. I have had that demonstrated to me and I am pleading with the Government, the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary to give us some assurance that they will accept this amendment No. 11 or any of the other amendments that are being covered in the course of this discussion. If they will not do that will they give some assurance that they will afford to those who may be affected the same protection, consideration and examination that is provided for in the section of the Arterial Drainage Act of 1945 to which I have referred and which, in my view, will compel the local body to whom we are giving these powers in relation to their own property to inform the drainage authority of what they intend to do. If they are obliged to do that in regard to the property of the county council, the local authority and corporation then I ask to do the same in relation to my property.

Comment on this

Deputy Lehane went to the trouble of analysing the amendment. I think the most effective reply to the amendment would be to read it in its entirety. Deputy Smith has made a rather unfortunate selection. He selected the Arterial Drainage Act of 1945. That Act did not come into operation until 1948. I should hope that this Bill we are now producing will not have that period of waiting when we go to operate it.

The scope of the measure has been fairly clearly indicated. I do not think there is any substance in the fears that have been expressed by Deputy Smith. Like him, I come from a county where we have a considerable number of small rivers and small streams. I am hoping that there will be some improvement effected in these under the terms of this Bill. I am perfectly certain that if we were to adopt the amendment, or even the principle of it, we would be spiking the operation of this measure. As Deputy Lehane pointed out, there would have to be long waiting periods and conferences and a going back for the holding of further conferences, so that really nothing could be done. There has been a good deal of talk about the public interest. We had discussions earlier as to who had the right to determine the public interest. The acceptance of this amendment would certainly deprive the local authorities, or even the Dáil, of the right to determine that question and would vest it in the Commissioners of Public Works.

What amazes me are the protestations that we have been hearing from the benches opposite that they are not obstructing this measure, and that they are perfectly honest in their handling of it. How anybody can still protest to be helping in regard to this Bill and at the same time stand over an amendment such as this is quite beyond me. The acceptance of the amendment would completely negative the intention of the Bill. We would have all the red tape that has been described by Deputy Lehane. If a local authority wanted to do one of the minor things set out in the Bill, then under this amendment any crank could come along and make an objection and there would follow from that all the rigmarole that is set out in the amendment. The fact is that the local authority would be prevented from doing the simplest piece of work.

It is not fair to compare this Bill with the Arterial Drainage Act. There is another measure that I would like to refer to, because I had experience of it as a member of a local authority. I refer to the Arterial Drainage Minor Schemes Act of 1928 under which work up to the value of £1,000 could be done. It was not a continuing measure. I was assured by county engineers, when I was a member of a local authority, that work of a most beneficial nature in the way of relieving flooding was done under that Act.

Comment on this

The only place in which there was work done under that Act was in the County Clare.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon. There was work done on the Awbeg and on portion of the Morning Star. I was approached by county surveyors at the time to try and get the Government to sanction schemes up to the value of £2,000 under that Act. As I have said, under it work up to the value of £1,000 could be done. It was a most beneficial Act. There was no question under that Act of reporting back to the Commissioners of Public Works. The only thing to be regretted about that Act was that it was not continued in operation.

In connection with this Bill it has to be remembered that if any awkward case arises there will be consultation between my Department and the Commissioners of Public Works. There is no question of friction or of one working against the other. This matter has been discussed with the Commissioners of Public Works. They are perfectly agreeable to the proposals set down under the Bill. They know what is contemplated and, as I say, if an awkward case arises there will be consultation between the two bodies. The one object that this amendment could achieve, if it were accepted, would be completely to negative the possibility of any useful work being done. In fact, if the amendment were accepted, we could drop the Bill.

Comment on this

I have been prompted to speak by the remarks made by Deputy Aiken. During the last two days I have been listening to the Jeremiahs opposite weeping over the ratepayers and the public bodies. What was the purpose and tenor of Deputy Aiken's speech on this amendment? It was this, that all such works should be referred to Dublin so that expert advice would be secured in contradiction of the county engineer and the assistant county engineers. Are those who have been on a public board in a county for 20 or 25 years not supposed to have sufficient experience to enable them to make representations with regard to the carrying out of works under this Bill? I do not like to talk in a derogatory manner about any Department, but Deputy Aiken appears to make the suggestion seriously that expert advice should first be got from Dublin. Even though Deputy Smith sheds tears to-night for the ratepayers, his memory cannot be so short as to forget something that was carried out under his administration in my county. When he was Parliamentary Secretary he thought very little of the ratepayers and of the riparian owners in our county. He wants to repeat the same thing under this amendment. Deputy Smith, when he was Parliamentary Secretary of a Department, made a contractual obligation——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Smith's administration of his Department does not arise on this amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy Aiken asks that schemes under this Bill should not be done without first soliciting expert advice from a Department here in Dublin. That is the advice that is now given to me as a member of a public body, at a time when I have before me the recent history of work that was carried out in my county on the advice of the body referred to by the Deputy. The ratepayers in my county, because of the inefficient work that was done on the advice of that body, were mulcted to the tune of £40,000. That happened within my county within a fairly recent period. Now we are being asked to do the very same thing under this amendment. Will that experience of ours impress Deputy Aiken's sense of justice? I believe that this is an insincere amendment that was spoken to by the Deputy. When Deputy Smith was Parliamentary Secretary we made a contract with him——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow the administration of any Department to be discussed on this amendment.

Comment on this

You made no contract with me.

Comment on this

We have been told that the public bodies have not given their imprimatur to this measure. Within the last month the various political Parties gave it their unanimous support and considered it a measure that was fully deserving of the praise that was expressed at the meeting. It was accepted in my county with general applause. Not alone was it received with gratifying feelings, but at our meeting last Saturday it was the unanimous decision of the council to ask the county surveyor and ten of his assistants immediately to make a survey of the east and west of the county so as to have everything in order when this Bill becomes law. It should have been law for the past month. Our people down there are anxious that when the Bill becomes law it will come into operation as soon as possible.

What do we find? In the western portion of my constituency the flooding conditions have developed with a dangerous continuity, if you like, and 1,000 farmers last summer, through purely voluntary effort, with their own shovels and spades, cleared ten miles of river. They had the help of some engineers. Having done that ten miles at a cost of a £5 note——

Comment on this

To which amendment is the Deputy now addressing his remarks?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it the Deputy is making the point that the farmers did this without the help of the Board of Works.

Comment on this

We invited the Minister to see the work that was done and what he saw was an inspiration to him. We were invited to a public meeting —Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Deputies —and it was pointed out there that it would take 20 years before the Arterial Drainage Act would reach that area.

Comment on this

I suggest the Deputy is not addressing himself to any of the amendments and that his remarks can be regarded as obstructive.

Comment on this

I am trying to develop this point—the urgency of this most essential and most attractive measure. I am stressing the manner in which it was received in my county and by the public body of which I am a member. There were statements made on the opposite benches last night by certain Jeremiahs who said that public bodies were not instructed and did not take cognisance of that particular Act.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The amendment suggests that certain formalities and preliaminaries should be gone through before any work is undertaken, which is in effect a reference of proposed schemes to the Board of Works. I take it the Deputy's point is that all these works he is referring to were carried out without such reference and, therefore, he is making a case against the amendment. That is the ruling.

Comment on this

I must say he is going about it in a very indirect fashion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not responsible for the Deputy's outlook, but that is how it seems to me.

Comment on this

A thousand farmers. seeing the destruction that was done over a number of years through the silting up of the river bed, and knowing that the Arterial Drainage Act would not reach them for 20 years, decided to act for themselves. This inspired the Minister and the Government that something else was needed to treat this situation in a tentative kind of way in order to relieve the obvious obstructions caused by rock and bushes across the river. These were the things the farmers in this locality had not machinery to remove, but they set about it in their own way.

The same applies to the Maigue. The previous Minister went down there and realised that something should be done in the interim before the Act would reach that area. It was Deputy Moylan who promised them that if his Government were returned to power one of the first things to be done would be to attend to the Maigue area in the interim before the Act would reach that quarter. If he did not do something there would be no Adare there now—at least the part contiguous to the river—and there would be no Croom there either. The statistical returns submitted by one of the most capable and brilliant engineers in the south showed that 20,000 acres were rendered unproductive.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Having travelled over Limerick and along the banks of various rivers, perhaps the Deputy will now come back to the amendment?

Comment on this

What I have been pointing out is very analogous to the situation in other counties.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not saying it is not, but it is not quite relevant to the amendment.

Comment on this

According to Deputy Aiken, all these schemes will have to be submitted to Dublin. I am in total disagreement with that view. An action started in my county cost the ratepayers £40,000. The whole thing was brought up in the High Court. Now we are told by Deputy Aiken that we will have to go up to Dublin through the same medium asking them to do a similar kind of work and it might inflict on the ratepayers and the riparian owners very serious charges by way of taxation and rates. I think the Deputy ought to have the decency to withdraw that.

I do not know of any measure that came before my council for the past 24 years that was received with such welcome. There was not one word of contention. It was accepted unanimously. That is so all over the country, too, and why then should we have the Fianna Fáil Party adopting the attitude of delaying such a great measure instead of helping it so as to bring the farmers some measure of happiness and large areas of land into greater fertility? I ask Deputy Aiken to be honest.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Madden will have to withdraw his support from this Bill because the Parliamentary Secretary has explained with great care—if Deputy Madden was listening carefully he would realise what was said—that all these schemes will have to come to Dublin. They will all have to be submitted to the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this

The boys in blue.

Comment on this

The engineer in Limerick will not be able to take his levels and go ahead with the work and send the bill here. He will first have to send the scheme here. My objection is that it will go to a Department that is not expected and that could not be expected to have the same knowledge of solving these problems as the Department that has had all the successes and all the failures—the Office of Public Works. The Minister has flatly turned down Deputy MacEntee's amendment. He will not have this procedure. He is very careful to explain at the same time that this is not an arterial drainage scheme. He did not give any definition of what an arterial drainage scheme is as opposed to a minor drainage scheme. But I have a couple of amendments here which are designed to ensure that when anything other than a minor drainage scheme is embarked upon it will be referred to the Office of Public Works which is the drainage authority set up by this Dáil.

In amendment No. 12 I propose that no scheme will be undertaken where the cost is more than £500 without submission to the drainage authority of the State—the Office of Public Works. In amendment No. 13 I propose that no scheme will go ahead where the damage likely to be sustained in the functional area of the local authority is more than £5,000 or, elsewhere, £2,500. If the Parliamentary Secretary will not accept Deputy MacEntee's amendment, then those two amendments that I propose give him an opportunity of assuring the ratepayers that they will not be mulcted with heavy costs through ill-judged drainage schemes. If the Parliamentary Secretary accepts these amendments the ratepayers will have that assurance. The county council will then notify if there is likely to be more than £5,000 worth of damage done by any particular scheme within their own functional area or £2,500 worth of damage elsewhere. It is only right that a county council should do less damage in a neighbouring county than it does in its own. That is the reason why I propose that if a scheme will result in £2,500 worth of damage to a neighbouring county the county council must seek permission for the scheme from the drainage authority.

In recent winters we heard much about the damage done by floods. We all know that Kilkenny was under a couple of feet of water for a few days. We all know that there were letters to the Press and telegrams to Ministers and T.D's. We know that deputations came up to Dublin. All that activity arose because of the damage done by a couple of feet of water in County Kilkenny for a couple of days. No doubt there was a certain amount of damage done, but what will happen if we embark upon schemes, without opening our eyes to the actual position and without opening our ears to the expert advice, under which we may have not a couple of feet of water for a couple of days but ten feet of water for ten weeks. That could happen. I propose, therefore, some limitation to the damage that may be done by local engineers with the approval of the Department of Local Government. I propose that where they undertake works of £500 that they must be submitted to the proper drainage authority and if there is a possibility of damage of more than £5,000 in their own area, or £2,500 elsewhere, the simpler procedure be followed.

Amendment No. 14 is another amendment which I think the Minister could accept because it gives some little guarantee to the ratepayers in the various districts. The amendment states:—

"A local authority shall not without the prior sanction of the Commissioners of Public Works execute under this Act a drainage scheme where the cost of such scheme exceeds £250 if the effect of such scheme shall be to increase substantially the flow of water into the functional area of another local authority."

In regard to this matter, I shall deal now with amendment No. 42, which is slightly different from the others. I shall deal with it now and we will get the whole thing over as soon as we can. The purpose of this amendment is to empower the Commissioners of Public Works, who have knowledge of drainage problems generally, where they are satisfied upon the report of their chief engineering officer that serious flooding is likely to occur if additional waters are drained into a river basin, by order under this section, to schedule such river basin as a prohibitive river basin. Then there is power to alter that scheduling as conditions change. That is a very necessary authority to give to the Office of Public Works. Take the Owenmore river into which the Board of Works refused to let the Kilshanny river be drained until the Owenmore was first improved. This amendment would give to the Office of Public Works the right to schedule the Owenmore basin and to say that until such time as that basin is improved they will not permit more waters to flow into it and cause damage, as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance pointed out in the letter we quoted, to be done by such excess waters. Surely it is not obstructive to ask the Parliamentary Secretary to give the people who reside in dangerous river basins some assurance that there is not going to be a flood of water pouring in upon them because of several little schemes costing a few hundred or a couple of thousand pounds. Kilkenny was subjected to a couple of feet of water for a few days. With several little schemes costing a few hundred or a couple of thousand pounds there would be danger of a sudden inrush of water into the Nore thereby increasing the flood level considerably and protracting the duration of such flood over a very much longer period. There should be some assurance that that will not happen. It is no use the Parliamentary Secretary telling me that all that will be done in the ordinary way by Departmental consultation. We want a little better assurance than that.

If it is going to be done by ordinary inter-Departmental consultation, why not give the people an assurance that it is going to be done? The Minister's and the Parliamentary Secretary's statement that that will be done gives no assurance to those people who might be adversely affected in the future and it gives them no right to compensation. If we put this amendment into the Bill then the individuals adversely affected will have some right to claim compensation for the damage inflicted upon them. If the Parliamentary Secretary will not go through the procedure outlined in Deputy MacEntee's amendment No. 11 which is not by any stretch of imagination as frivolous as Deputy Lehane tries to make out— after all the Government cannot be in such a hurry about this Bill as they pretend; it was the 23rd February when they introduced it and we are not responsible for the fact that the Committee Stage has only been reached in the first week in June—will the Parliamentary Secretary not undertake to give the smaller assurances to the people that are involved in my amendment? I hope the Government will accept either one or the other.

Comment on this

There is another angle to this that I should like to suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary particulary in dealing with some of Deputy Aiken's amendments. In the main, what is in our minds in connection with these amendments is that the larger type of drainage work is the type that will create the most damage. Anyone who has any experience of these schemes must realise the dangerous amount of water that is released. There is no provision in this Bill about notifying fishery authorities, mill-owners, the Electricity Supply Board or other statutory bodies such as there is in the 1945 Drainage Act. If there is danger of damage to the interests of people such as I have mentioned, there is just as much reason, if not more reason, that the same statutory protection should be enshrined in this Bill as was provided in the 1945 Drainage Act. The smaller drainage schemes may not give rise to so much damage but it is not a very large scheme that will be carried out for £250. Where, however, two or three of these schemes enter into the one river it does not take any great stretch of the imagination to visualise the amount of damage that may be done. Releasing water in an unscientific way is much the same as releasing fire. It is just as liable to do as much damage and the local authority will have the privilege of paying for any damage done under this Bill.

If parties, such as are described in Deputy MacEntee's amendment, parties with vested interests, like fisheries, millowners, or the Electricity Supply Board, suffer damage as a result of any of these schemes the ratepayers may be liable for very heavy compensation. The combined effect of four or five of these £250 schemes may be the cause of serious damage to these parties. We must take into account the fact that this Bill provides for the deepening of drains, the removal of obstructions and even the diversion of watercourses. If that type of work is going to be done and if there is no consultation with the drainage authority, we can well visualise that the claims which may arise on the ratepayers of various counties may reach a very high figure.

There also arises the question of drainage as between one county and another. It may be all right so far as maritime counties are concerned. If they create damage, it will arise within the limits of their own counties but where you have a river flowing from one county into another, it will be necessary for these counties to observe the greatest scruples in releasing water. If due precautions are not taken, and due consultations carried out by the experts, you may have the position arising that water may be released into an already flooded river to such an extent that it will create a terrific amount of damage in other counties. These are matters that it is better to put right when we have an opportunity of doing so rather than wait until we come up against these difficulties in the operation of the Bill. I would suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that the guarantees asked for taking all these amendments, might possibly be secured in another way, possibly we might achieve the same object by a redrafting of the amendments and if the Parliamentary Secretary is prepared to consider this matter before the Report Stage so as to obviate the dangers which we point out, well and good. I would suggest that there is a duty on the Government to endeavour to foresee the difficulties that may arise under this Bill and I would point out that in every legislation dealing with drainage all these precautions were provided for.

For instance, in Section 47 of the 1945 Act, which deals with the question of weirs, if there is any interference with a weir by the alteration, removal or enlargement of any watercourse. there is a definite liability for damages and certain precautions have to be taken. One of the matters causing obstruction in watercourses are some of these very weirs and we take power under this Bill to remove these obstructions. I wonder has the Parliamentary Secretary foreseen what that may give rise to? Again, by the execution of a very small drainage work, damage may be caused to hatcheries such as you have in some areas. In particular in one amendment of Deputy Aiken—what I call the £250 amendment—I think there is a very reasonable safeguard. I think he is only endeavouring to make the Parliamentary Secretary consider certain matters that may arise as a result of indiscriminate damage in the country if due precautions are not taken. If he guaranteed to accept any of these amendments or favourably consider what is in our minds before the Report Stage, he would meet our objects in the matter. I would impress upon the Parliamentary Secretary that it is only by the experience of carrying out drainage that he will see the very grave questions of damages and infringements of the rights of private individuals that may arise.

Amendments Nos. 11 and 12 put and negatived.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment No. 13 put.

Tá 48
·
Níl 61
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

With regard to amendment No. 15, the Parliamentary Secretary has, I think, tabled an amendment providing that certain notice should be given.

Comment on this

Fourteen days' notice.

Comment on this

This amendment was tabled after the Second Reading, because the Bill as it then stood did not provide for any notice by anybody going in on anybody else's land and trespassing there to do some work. I am glad to see that the Minister has thought fit to mend his hand in that matter and has provided some notice, although it is not as good as we would expect to be provided. In view of his having recognised now, after consideration, our opposition on that question during the Second Reading, I do not propose to move amendment No. 15.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 16 is out of order, as it runs directly counter to the principle of the Bill. If the Deputy reads the Long Title, he will see that.

Comment on this

I am opposing this section, which reads:—

"Where the Minister is satisfied—

(a) that particular works should be executed pursuant to this Act by a local authority, and

(b) that the local authority are unable or unwilling to execute the works,

the Minister may by Order nominate a person to execute the works and thereupon that person may execute the works in accordance with the directions of the Minister, and in relation to the execution thereof, shall be deemed to be acting on behalf of the local authority and shall have all the powers conferred on them by this Act."

It is an extraordinary section for inclusion in this measure by the present Minister or any member of the Labour Party. We have been hearing for quite a long time the awful thing the County Management Act was in taking powers away from local authorities. Here we have a power being enshrined in this Bill, under which the Minister, over the heads of the local authority, can send down his nominee to carry out any particular work and the local authority will have the pleasure of paying for any damages done. That is an extraordinary power for a Minister to take who professes to be so worried about democratic rights and the rights of local representatives. It has been held up to the House and to the country that the County Management Act deprived the local authorities of such powers. Speaking on the County Management Bill on the 14th March, 1940, as given in column 929 of the Official Debates, Volume 79, the recent Minister for Local Government, the late Deputy Murphy, on a section giving power to remove a manager by sealed order, for unfitness, said:—

"My only comment is that this power renders even more farcical the position local representatives would be asked to share when this Bill becomes an Act. I would go even farther than what has been said already and say that this section tends to make the county manager the creature of the Minister for Local Government, and I am not prepared to vote that that power should be put into the hands of the Minister or of any future Minister for Local Government."

That was the comment by the recent Minister for Local Government on a section in the Managerial Act simply taking power to remove a manager for unfitness—it would make the manager the creature of the Minister. But what does this section do? It makes every member of every local authority a creature of the Minister, because when a local authority in its wisdom decides that some work would not be in the public interest and should not be done, due to the potential damage that would accrue to the ratepayers, and decide to turn it down, someone can come to the Minister and the Minister can send his nominee and carry out the work in spite of the local authority. That is going a long way towards restoring power to the local authorities, that the Minister and some of his colleagues have been so loquacious about. It seems extraordinary also to be taking power when the local authority will have to pay for the results of the acts of the Minister's nominee. Someone has said that the man who pays the piper calls the tune, but in this particular section the local authority, the ratepayers, may have to pay the piper —in paying for the damage that might be done in the maintenance of the work—and the Minister, notwithstanding the fact that the local authority has turned the work down, can go ahead in the face of the opposition.

In another way this creates an undesirable position. While it may not happen with the present Minister, some future Minister may have a friend who is interested in getting some particular work done. If the local authority turns it down, he can get the Minister to do it, in spite of the opposition. I would ask the Minister to withdraw this section and avoid such an undesirable position.

I suggest, particularly in view of the expressed attitude towards the County Management Act, in saying that the local authorities have not sufficient power, that there was not enshrined in any Act a more strongly-worded or dictatorial section than this, as between the Minister and a local authority. If it is the intention to amend or repeal the County Management Act, why enshrine this section in the Bill and why give power to any future Minister for Local Government to take such action as is provided for in the section? If it is the intention at an early date to repeal that Act and give more powers to local authorities, why should this principle be enshrined in a Bill introduced by a Labour Minister?

I suggest that the Minister should withdraw this section and that it is a section that will be resented by members of local authorities. As surely as he exercises the power in this section to put through some work in spite of the majority of a local authority, so surely will he be working against the bringing about of good relations between local authorities and the Department. The Minister should realise that this section will be repugnant to every local authority. If he realises that, he will realise that it is an unwise principle to have enshrined in the Bill. It is a section which will serve no useful purpose and I appeal to him to withdraw it.

Comment on this

I am surprised at Deputy Moran's attitude and I am more surprised still that Deputy Harris, who is here, did not get up and contradict him, because Deputy Harris knows as well as I do that, in parts of Kildare, there are joint committees looking after the Boyne and the Blackwater, and, but for this section, it would not be possible to include them in this Bill. This section will enable the Minister to designate one local authority to do the job, where several local authorities are involved. If it were not for that section, obstructions in the Blackwater River could not be removed because more than one local authority is involved. For that reason, if for no other—and there are others—I think this is a good section, a section which I would strongly urge the Parliamentary Secretary to retain in the Bill and a section which I know people in parts of North-West Kildare will be glad to see passed.

Comment on this

It was a happy thought on Deputy Sweetman's part to bring in this matter of joint drainage boards to cover up the real danger in the section. I suggest that a safer clause could be inserted in the Bill to meet that position. I believe the section is dangerous, because it gives the Minister a power he should not have, a power by which he could do much that would be detrimental to a local authority. If a local authority feels that it is wrong to carry out a particular work and if they oppose the carrying out of that work, certain influential sections in the particular county who have access to whatever Minister is in office could go to the Minister and snap their fingers at the local authority. The section undermines all ideas of democracy.

Comment on this

That was the Fianna Fáil way.

Comment on this

I support the representations made for the deletion of the section. I think it is a very dangerous section. It is a pity that Deputy Sweetman did not point out to us where provision is made in the section for local authorities to carry out the work at present being carried out by drainage boards. There is nothing in the section in connection with that. It merely states that, where a local authority is unable or unwilling to execute a particular work, the Minister may, by Order, nominate a person to execute it. Some Deputy on the opposite side talked about our being in an anomalous position. I wonder what position is the Minister for Local Government and the Parliamentary Secretary in to-night? We had them earlier refusing to trust local bodies in the matter of carrying out these works and now we have the Minister taking the big stick. If a local authority or county manager refuses to carry out certain works, the Minister will nominate somebody to carry them out.

Comment on this

The Minister "may".

Comment on this

When Deputy Cowan has finished with his game of matches, he can give us a legal interpretation of it. I am dealing with the section from the point of view of a member of a local authority. I believe that, when new works such as have not hitherto been included in their functions are to be carried out by local authorities, the members should have the right to state the priority of the works in consultation with and with the approval of the county engineer and should have the power to carry out these works. I cannot visualise the circumstances which the Minister appears to visualise which make it necessary to insert this section.

I do not know any local authority that is going to endeavour to prevent work being carried out under the Bill, but evidently that is the mentality behind the insertion of the section. I do not think the House should agree to it. The House could very well leave the carrying out of these works in the hands of local authorities. I cannot visualise any situation in which local authorities might refuse to carry out certain works, but if a local authority, with its knowledge of local conditions and circumstances, decided not to carry out particular works, I do not see why the Minister should have power to compel them to carry them out.

Comment on this

No; the Minister "may."

Comment on this

Consequently, I think the section should be deleted and the House, by its vote, should delete it.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Will the Minister say what will happen if a local authority wants to do a job one way and the Government Department wants it done another way? Who will arbitrate? I have in mind the position with regard to Charleston Road in Dublin, where the corporation wanted to improve and re-asphalt the roadway. The previous Government had the benefit of an inquiry into the widening of the road and apparently some influential friends waited upon the Minister of the previous Government and stopped the corporation from carrying out the much-needed improvements on that road. It is now a danger to the public and there is a clashing of interests between the engineer of his Department and the Dublin Corporation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This applies where the local authority is unable or unwilling to carry out work.

Comment on this

I do not know why it immediately springs to the mind of the Opposition that there is some sinister motive in embodying a section of this kind in the Bill or that a section like this immediately suggests to them that some friend of the Minister might benefit. It is not the intention at all under this Bill to inflict any punishment on a local authority or to get them to do something which is unreasonable. Before I go any further I should like to ask if any of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party thought there was anything peculiar or anything sinister in the inclusion in the Relief Works Act of 1940 of a section which gives the Minister power to compel a local authority to execute certain works and which also requires that they should bear the full cost of the works, the full cost of damage and the full cost of compensation?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil Deputies are not permitted to think. They have to do what they are told.

Comment on this

As far as this particular section is concerned, it is intended for the benefit of local authorities. If, for instance, an urban council or corporation could not or had not the means to carry out certain works under the provisions of this Bill it would be possible for the Minister for Local Government to nominate, say, the county council to do that work for them. If, for instance, a river flowing through a county area also passed through an urban area, and the county council were anxious to carry out certain works but if the urban council did not do a certain job within their functional area the county council's work would be ineffective, it would be reasonable then, I think, for the Minister to nominate the county council to carry out the necessary work to make the job effective within the functional area of the local authority. Again I would like to stress that there is no sinister motive in this. I think Deputy Moran paid the Minister for Local Government a compliment by saying he thought he would not act in a manner as suggested by some of the other Opposition Deputies. But, if Opposition Deputies think there is any sinister motive in this, if they think it means giving to the Minister a power which he should not have or which in their opinion he might abuse, I think that we might be prepared to reconsider it on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

That will tie them up.

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary think of adopting and including the amendment that has been turned down?

Comment on this

No, no. Keep it out. It is turned down.

Comment on this

There is power in this section that we are discussing at the present time for a nominee of the Minister to be appointed to do a job of work that will leave the county council to be mulcted for more than £5,000 worth of damage as the Bill now stands and I think he should put some limit on the amount of damage that his nominee can cause in the area of a local authority.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:—

In sub-section (1), line 36, immediately after the word "may" to insert the words "subject to the provisions of this section".

This is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert the following new sub-sections:—

(2) Before entering on land under this section for a purpose other than the execution of urgent works, a local authority or person executing works pursuant to this Act or an Order made thereunder, shall either obtain the consent (in the case of occupied land) of the occupier, or (in the case of unoccupied land) of the owner or shall give not less than 14 days' notice in writing of the intention to make such entry.

(3) The notice referred to in sub-section (2) of this section may be given to a person in any of the following ways:—

(a) by delivering it to such person,

(b) by leaving it at the address where such person ordinarily resides,

(c) by sending it by post in a prepaid registered letter addressed to such person at the address where he ordinarily resides, or

(d) by posting it at or near the land concerned.

(4) In this section the expression "urgent works" means works the immediate execution of which is, in the opinion of the local authority, necessary to prevent serious injury to any person, land or permanent construction.

This amendment provides for 14 days' notice in writing to be given of intention to enter on a man's land. Notice is not necessary where urgent works have to be done, and I think the House will agree that that is reasonable in view of the fact that there may be immediate flooding due to excessive rain. If there had to be a delay of 14 days it would be absolutely ridiculous to try to alleviate such a condition. There is also provided in this amendment the method by which this notice should be given and I think that meets some of the subsequent amendments of the Opposition as to the giving of notice and the actual method.

Comment on this

I did not move a previous amendment that we had tabled as a result of the discussion on the Second Reading. I do agree that in the case, say, of sudden flooding of roads, which would in the main, I think, arise under the first part of the Bill, or a landslide, or a breach in a road it is right that the authority should proceed immediately to do that work but as far as entering on the lands of a private individual for a scheme is concerned, I would again suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary, notwithstanding this amendment of his, that if it is any kind of major scheme, there should be publication of notice. Publication of notice was provided for under other Statutes and I would suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that when he considers the matter before Report Stage he might think fit to provide for publication of notice outside the notice he proposes to give under this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not think this is unreasonable. It is included in the Water Supplies Act, 1942, for similar work.

Comment on this

I am accepting the amendment as covering many of our objections on Second Reading but I have in mind that a scheme may start in one end of a county—this applies to drainage schemes in particular—and any consequential damage may arise in the other end of it. If the Parliamentary Secretary thinks that over he will see my point and I think there should be notice outside the notice in the amendment that you are going to start the work, particularly having regard to any damage that may be done. There should be publication of some kind and I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to think the matter over between this and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary says he will consider it.

Comment on this

I will consider it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 20 is governed by No. 19. It is the same principle.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

May I ask the Parliamentary Secretary if under this section he has any power to deal with the dangerous bridges all over the country, for instance, a bridge in New Ross, that is dangerous to the people generally?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Byrne knows what this section refers to. It relates to power of entry on land and the preliminaries to be taken before the local authority enters on the land.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

The White Paper that was circulated referred to bridges.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not arise on this particular section. We are on Committee Stage and Section 4 is before the House.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

I do not see any section dealing with bridges as such.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That should be raised on the Second Stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

I can give the Deputy much more information if he discusses it with me outside the Chamber.

Question agreed to.

SECTION 5.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:—

To delete sub-section (1) and substitute the following new sub-section:—

(1) Any person who suffers damage by reason of any interference, caused by the execution of works pursuant to this Act or Order made thereunder, with any land owned or occupied by him or any easement, profit-a-prendre or other right belonging to him shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be entitled to be paid by the local authority concerned compensation in respect of such damage.

This amendment is wider than the original sub-section. Deputies opposite were worried about the definition of land, especially with regard to the question of compensation for damage caused to land. This amendment gives a fuller definition of "land", especially as far as compensation is concerned. I think it was agreed on one of the earlier sections that this would meet the requirements.

Comment on this

All I would say to the Parliamentary Secretary is that I have looked into this so far as I could in the time at my disposal. In so far as the compensation section is concerned I would agree that every adequate safeguard is included. But the Parliamentary Secretary may come up against the difficulty that while the Act gives him power to interfere or to enter on land it may not give him power to interfere with certain rights—as I put it to Deputy Lynch, when he mentioned the definition of "land," that "land" did include the matters which he said were included in "land." I have not been able to look into the matter fully but I do think, in the definitions I have looked up, that the definition of "land" for the purpose of particular statutes is something that should be set out in the statutes. I do not want to go further than ask the Parliamentary Secretary that, between this and the Report Stage, he might look into the matter to see if the expression "land" gives all the rights that the Parliamentary Secretary wants and that we all want to be exercised in regard to this Bill. It is a technical matter on which the Parliamentary Secretary may require the advice of the Attorney-General. I would ask him to look into this matter between now and the Fifth Stage.

Comment on this

Sub-section (4) of Section 2 sets out what may be done——

Comment on this

But I am concerned with what may be entered upon. Land may be entered upon——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us not go back to the definition section now.

Comment on this

At that particular stage it was agreed that when we came to this stage we would look back to that definition section. I am asking the Parliamentary Secretary, between this and the Report Stage, to consider the matter. We may have the right to enter upon land but we may not have the right to enter on particular rights. I want the Parliamentary Secretary to ensure that within the definition of "land" we have the power to enter upon the particular rights that we are all agreed should be affected by this particular section.

Comment on this

I think it is fairly well covered but I will look into it.

Comment on this

I am just asking the Parliamentary Secretary to consider it.

Comment on this

Before the Parliamentary Secretary moves amendment No. 23 I would point out that there are a couple of amendments of ours dealing with the same question. I was going to suggest it might be taken with them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Nos. 23a and 36.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert the following new sub-section:—

(2) Every claim for compensation under this section shall be made in writing to the local authority concerned within 18 months after the commencement of the works which caused the interference to which the claim relates.

I think that a period of 18 months, within which a person may make a claim, is reasonable. I do not think any less or any more would be good. It is considered that a period of 18 months is a period which will cover a full year adequately, that is providing for a late or early winter. I do not think that, as is suggested in some of the other amendments, a period of say, six years, might be given because the local authorities would be, as it were, waiting in suspense to see whether or not a claim for damage was coming forward. In any case, an unusual happening such as cloudburst or any similar occurrence might induce a person to make a claim for damage which was not done by the execution of works under this particular Bill.

On the question of damage and compensation, let me say that I do not visualise that there will be many claims for compensation and, in any case, where they are on account of the nature of the schemes, I think that the compensation will be very low.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 23a reads:—

"Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

( ) Every claim for compensation under this section shall be made in writing to the local authority concerned not later than three months after the damage has been ascertained, but in any case, not later than six years after the completion of the works which it is alleged have occasioned the damage to which the claim relates."

This amendment and amendment No. 36 go together. I think, in particular, that amendment No. 36 is possibly wider. It is as follows:

Notwithstanding the provisions of the Public Authorities Protection Act, 1893, or of any other statute of limitation, a claimant may institute proceedings for compensation under Section 5 of this Act at any time within a period of six years from the date of the conclusion of the work by reason of which the claimant's land has sustained damage."

This is a matter for which, when the Bill was previously going through the House, no provision was made. The Parliamentary Secretary has gone a certain distance with us, under amendment No. 23, when he says that every claim for compensation under this section shall be made in writing to the local authority concerned within 18 months after the commencement of the works which caused the interference to which the claim relates. I would point out that 18 months after the commencement of the works is much too short a time. The works actually may take 18 months to complete, if it is a substantial work, and, possibly in accordance with the time of year the work is undertaken, the work may have to be suspended on a particular drainage scheme and actually the scheme itself may not be completed within 18 months from the date at which it started. I would further point out that work undertaken under this Act in one part of a county may not, in itself, cause damage. The draining done under that particular work—say, for the sake of argument— flows into river X. Another work done in the same catchment area also flows into river X. It may be the third work under this Act, flowing into river X, that may cause the flooding and damage. You may have the combined effect of two or three works causing the damage under which claims arise under this Act. I think, in particular, that 18 months from the commencement of the work is much too short a period.

The Parliamentary Secretary mentioned cloudbursts. He should know quite well that the question of cloudbursts will not arise because there would be no claim for damage done as a result of any cloudburst. The cloudburst I am afraid of would be the burst due to the combined results of two or three works—possibly small in themselves—under this Act. I think the position would be most unfair for an unfortunate claimant whose rights may be interfered with and who may have suffered damage. He did not know when the first work started. He would be in the position that he would be out of court when he had not brought his claim within 18 months of its first starting. I think there should certainly be a longer period. The Parliamentary Secretary must be of the same mind that these questions of damage under this Act will have to be proved (1) before the District Court, in small cases and (2)—which we shall come to later—before an arbitrator or a court under the Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act, 1919. The claimants will have to satisfy these courts that they did in fact (1) suffer damage and (2) that it was as a result of works done under this Bill. I do not see why the Parliamentary Secretary would not reconsider this question of limitation of the period. Six years is the usual limitation. We have a number of statutes limiting the period.

Comment on this

The Deputy will see that it is six months under the Public Authorities (Protection) Act.

Comment on this

Yes, but that is much too short. That Act is not of such universal application as some people seem to think. I am suggesting that there is nothing unreasonable in making the limitation period six years, because claimants will have to prove their case in any event. If you put a limitation of 18 months on a claimant, as suggested in the Parliamentary Secretary's amendment, it means that if some farmer in a backward area is not quick enough to put in a claim in time, you simply put him out of court on what merely amounts to a technicality in a case where genuine damage may have been done. I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to bear in mind that when work is done under the Bill there may be an unusually dry winter when you would not have the normal rainfall, whereas in a winter with normal rainfall you may have flooding which would not be apparent the previous winter. It is only after a couple of years that the full results of the work would be seen, taking one winter after another.

These are matters which would affect the period of time within which a man might claim, because the damage may not arise during the year the work is carried out and may not arise until the following winter, which may be a more severe winter than usual. He may find then as a result of the work done that his lands are being flooded and damage done. On the other hand, the public authority is protected because, let it be one, two or five years after the work is done, a man has to satisfy the court that he has suffered damage as a result of work or combined works done under the Bill. I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to reconsider his attitude and accept the principle either of the amendment tabled by myself or the one tabled by Deputy MacEntee.

Comment on this

I do not endorse Deputy Moran's plea for the extension of the period to six years, but I do think he made certain criticisms of the Parliamentary Secretary's amendment which should be considered. To my mind, what goes a long way towards vitiating that amendment as it stands is the period from which the calculation is to be made, "after the commencement of the works". As I said, I would not endorse the plea to extend the period to six years.

To my mind, what is important is not the period allowed, but the date from which that limitation would commence to run. The amendment would be completely unobjectionable if it were to read something like this: Every claim for compensation under this section shall be made in writing to the local authority concerned within 18 months after the date upon which the damage or interference caused became apparent. The important thing is the date from which the period of limitation will commence to run. I cannot compliment the Parliamentary Secretary on the drafting of the amendment. I appeal to him to consider an alteration in the time from which the period of limitation will run. After that, if he wants to make the period within which a claim can be brought as short as six months, I would agree.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with either of my professional brethren. I think Deputy Moran's plea for six years is altogether out of the question. I think Deputy Lehane's date for the commencement would be far too indeterminate. It would be quite impossible to prove at what date the damage became apparent. I urge the Parliamentary Secretary very strongly that, whatever period he inserts, and I do not quarrel with his period of 18 months, it should date from the completion of the work, because until the work is completed it will be impossible to tell for certain whether it will cause damage or not. I would rather have a much shorter period starting from the completion of the work than a longer period starting from the commencement because, unless one is an engineer, one is not in a position to judge when the work is started what the exact effect will be. When the work is completed, one is in a better position to judge.

Comment on this

In this matter my view lies between what Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Lehane said. I agree that the period from which the limitation is to run in the proposed amendment is not a satisfactory one, because I can imagine nothing more difficult to ascertain than the commencement of any particular works. A considerable amount of administrative work must be done before the apparent evidence of the work on any river or road may be seen by people. The commencement of work under this Bill covers just as much administrative or preparatory work as it does the more obvious kind of work which people might see. I think the word "commencement" in the Minister's amendment does not indicate a satisfactory or clear period from which the limitation should run. Deputy Lehane suggested that the limitation should run from the date on which the damage was caused.

Comment on this

From the date it became apparent.

Comment on this

From the date it became apparent. Under Section 3 of the Public Authorities (Protection) Act, 1893, which at present protects local authorities, the period of limitation runs from the causing of the damage or injury. There is at least that precedent for dating the limitation from that period. It has not been difficult to ascertain in practice and I do not think it would cause much difficulty if something along these lines was provided for. I urge on the Parliamentary Secretary, from an ordinary drafting point of view, that something clearer should be decided upon than the word "commencement" in the amendment. Perhaps the most satisfactory compromise would be that suggested by Deputy Sweetman, namely, the completion of the work. There again I leave open the question when such work is completed. I do think that some attention should be paid to this on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I take a rather different view from everybody else.

Comment on this

Now we have the legal opinions.

Comment on this

I would rather have attention given to the wording of the Parliamentary Secretary's amendment which is to the effect that a claim to be made be brought in 18 months after the commencement of the work. As far as I can see, that does not interfere at all with the time that is laid down under the Public Authorities Protection Act. I should say that as the amendment stands at present it prescribes that if a claim is to be made notice in writing must be served in 18 months. Having regard to what the various Deputies have put forward in this particular amendment I think it should be reconsidered between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I want very briefly to add my voice to the pleading with the Parliamentary Secretary to reconsider this matter. Quite frankly I would like Deputy MacEntee's amendment No. 23 (a) if it were tidied up a bit. I think the period of six years is far too long. Something in the neighbourhood of 18 months or two years would improve it. Secondly, some of the speakers have pointed out the difficulty of ascertaining when the work commences. I think there would be far more difficulty in ascertaining when the work is completed. If the Parliamentary Secretary thinks well of the idea of allowing the claims to date from the completion of work it would be necessary to add some further provision stipulating the definition of when the work is completed. I suggest we might consider making it a duty of the engineer and county surveyor to certify and, if necessary, certify by public advertisement, the date of the completion of work. If something of that sort were done, at least it would remove one of the difficulties which might arise in courts on that question. I should like to recommend to the Parliamentary Secretary that he reconsider this amendment with a view to dating the time for the claim from the completion of the work and further define when the work should be deemed to be completed.

Comment on this

Such a certificate of completion as mentioned by Deputy O'Higgins might be all right except if it were found after the certificate of completion had been issued by the county surveyor or engineer that damages had resulted from the work and that these damages were likely to be recurring. It might then be necessary for the local authority to undertake further works. The issue of a certificate of completion is provided for in the Act of 1945 but that would be in a case where the most elaborate survey would have taken place in connection with any drainage work carried out. I would plead with the Parliamentary Secretary to listen to and take heed of the point made by Deputy Moran when he mentioned the fact that even if you make it 18 months from the date of completion and even if you were able to decide exactly when the work is completed, you would still have the difficulty of a dry winter. We do not get very many dry winters in this country, we must admit.

Comment on this

We had a wet summer.

Comment on this

We have had cases of dry winters in our time. I remember inside the last 25 years two dry winters following each other. If works are carried out in a period like that, it would be impossible for a person whose property might have been injured to come before a court inside the time specified and prove, as it would be necessary to prove, that damage had resulted to him as a result of carrying out these works. I think it is not unreasonable to ask the Parliamentary Secretary to insert a period that would at least give the individual who might be affected an opportunity of going to a stronger body and seeking there redress for any damage that might result from the work carried out.

Comment on this

Most Deputies are agreed that the period of 18 months is more reasonable than six years, but some of them seem to differ as to from what particular time that period should date. I would be more favourable towards relating it to the commencement of the work, because it can readily be seen that in a lot of cases it will be very difficult to determine when work has actually been completed. To all intents and purposes, a particular scheme might be completed, but it might be necessary for an engineer to go back and make adjustments or to effect some minor changes. From that point of view the actual execution of a small scheme might take a period of, say, six to nine months. That is to say, the work might be actually completed in three months, but it might be discovered after another three months that some minor repairs or adjustment or minor digging work might have to be carried out. From that point of view I think it would be very difficult in a lot of cases to prove when the work was actually completed.

As far as Deputy Lehane's suggestion is concerned, that is, that it should date from the time when the damage became apparent, it could not be easily determined because any claimant is entitled to protest, and he may very well protest, that he did not know of this damage until such and such a time. In effect, the damage might have been there for six months but he was too lazy or did not bother his head to make any claim at the time the damage actually occurred. Therefore, I would be inclined to reconsider this amendment on the Report Stage but I would like to tell the House that I will stick to the dating of the period from the commencement of the work and consider a smaller extension of the period.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary not consider the point that I have made that, for instance, because of a dry winter, or for a similar reason, a man would not realise that he was going to suffer damage, he will not be debarred from making a claim? I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to consider this question of protecting the small man as against the large local authority with all its power behind it. If he is genuinely going to suffer damage I do not think there is any good reason why a technical clause of this kind should cut him out. After all we are providing that if damage is done the local authority is going to pay for it. If there is a genuine case, and even if a man does not bring his claim within, say, 18 months of the commencement of the work, provided he can prove damage, surely he should not be penalised by a section such as this. I would again urge the Parliamentary Secretary to bear this in mind.

Comment on this