Land Reclamation Bill, 1949—Second Stage.
Contributions 1–206 of 415. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1949 ›
I move that the Bill be now read a Second Time. The Bill itself is quite simple and really contains only two effective provisions. One is the necessary statutory authority to the Land Commission to register a charge and, subsequently, to collect the rent arising therefrom, and the other provision is set out in Section 5 which empowers the Minister for Agriculture, where there is a common watercourse serving several holdings and the rehabilitation operations of one holding involve the necessity of clearing the common watercourse and releasing the waters drained off the upper land, to go in upon the watercourse and carry out upon it such works as may be necessary to give the effluent free passage down to the river or other outlet where it would normally go. I think I am right in saying that, in fact, this proviso amounts to no more than short circuiting the procedure whereby any farmer can require his neighbour to remove from a watercourse an obstruction the existence of which damages the first farmer's land, but the common law procedure for bringing the necessary compulsion to bear on the delinquent landholder is long, tortuous and subject to appropriate appeals and simply could not be depended upon exclusively in a project of this magnitude where expedition is needed.
Personally, I do not believe that the powers in Section 5 will fall to be used. If they should fall, I would not hesitate to use them, but the fact that they exist, in my opinion, will be sufficient to ensure that if there are any individuals who maliciously desire to injure their neighbour they must realise that the attempt is foredoomed to failure and, therefore, they will not make it. Deputies will notice that the provision is limited strictly to entering upon a common watercourse to do any works necessary to render it capable of carrying water that should normally pass through it and to dispose of the spoil in such manner as the Minister thinks fit. I direct the attention of the House to that particularly because I desire to emphasise that it is no more than the common law right of any farmer against his neighbour to ensure that there shall be left no obstacle in a watercourse the continued presence of which makes a nuisance on the land of the neighbour.
I take it, Sir, however, that, over and above explaining these two specific provisions in the Bill, this is the appropriate occasion to mention generally the purposes underlying the project. Deputies will have observed that on last Wednesday there appeared in the newspapers an invitation to farmers in eight specified counties who are prepared to undertake the work themselves to make application for the appropriate form on which to apply for a grant. To date we have received about 1,500 applications, and I am glad to think that so far we have been able to maintain our undertaking to reply to them by return of post. Owing, however, to the exigencies of the legislative programme, it was not possible to present this Bill to the House, and so Deputies may have noticed that the invitation which appeared in the newspapers was carefully framed so as to avoid even the appearance of anticipating the decision of the Oireachtas.
The project can be divided into two parts, one where the farmer desires to carry out the agreed works himself in consideration of receiving the grant when the work is completed. That part of the project falls within the general powers of the Minister for Agriculture, and so it was possible for me to put that in operation so soon as we were prepared to undertake the work. That is what was put into operation last Wednesday. The second part of the project relates to those farmers who, because they have not at their disposal the knowledge, the labour or the finance desire to have the work done by the Department of Agriculture. In their case the cost, at the rate of £12 per acre, will be charged upon their land in exactly the same way as a land annuity is now charged. It will be repayable to the Land Commission by way of an annuity in exactly the same way as they pay their annuity at present which is commonly known in the country as the rent.
Under the first part of the scheme, as advertised last Wednesday, the procedure is this. On the receipt of a letter asking for an application form, we forward to the applicant a form of application on which he is requested to state his name, the townland, the parish and the county, and the number of statute acres which he thinks it will be necessary to deal with, and nothing else. On receipt of that form completed, an officer of my Department will call upon him and discuss with him the condition of his land and, if the farmer has the time and the inclination, will walk the land with him, and will arrive at an agreed determination as to what work requires to be done if the full fertility of his soil is to be restored. On that agreement being substantially arrived at, as soon as may be a small outline sketch map of the farmer's holding will be furnished to him, with a description of the works required to be done, and a statement of the amount of the grant to which he will become entitled on completion of the works agreed upon.
The amount of the grant is based on a sum equal to two-thirds of the estimated cost of the work. There is no use my pretending to the House that we are in a position to bind ourselves to a valuer's determination of what the work will cost, nor is there any provision in the scheme which lays down precisely how the grant is to be determined. In fact, the basis of determination in every case will be an estimate by us of what the work should cost and an offer to the farmer, if he chooses to proceed with the work, of two-thirds of that amount on the completion of the job. When the farmer undertakes the task himself, he can carry it out with the assistance of his family or he can hire a neighbour's son or sons or, if there is a private contractor in the parish or in the neighbourhood, he can ask him for an estimate to do part or all of the work and have it done.
That is a matter entirely within his own discretion and into which I do not propose to inquire, my sole concern being, when he declares the work to have been done and seeks a certificate of payment, that on our examination of the holding we are satisfied the work has been done in a way that will give results. When that certificate issues, the farmer will then receive his grant in the shape of fertilisers spread upon the land reclaimed at the rate of six cwts. of ground rock phosphate and two tons of ground limestone, where the land requires that treatment, and in respect of each acre so treated the cash grant will be abated by a sum of £5. Where the land proves to be alkaline in its constitution, and no lime is required, a suitable adjustment is provided. If, in the unlikely event that its phosphatic content is sufficient, and it requires no phosphates, a suitable adjustment can be made and if, in some cases, neither lime nor phosphate is required, then the entire grant is payable in cash.
The point has been raised, where a considerable body of work falls to be done, is it reasonable to ask the farmer to complete the whole of the task before receiving anything on account. I think, on the whole, it would not be reasonable, but this stipulation must be made, and if, in special cases, where it is necessary, a payment on account should be made, it has to be agreed between us that the work will be done in such instalments that, were it to be abandoned after the first payment on account, that part which has been done would function, because unless that agreement were understood between us, the farmer who did a partial job and then abandoned the work might, in fact, do more harm than good; but if he sub-divides the work into units, any one of which, left standing alone, without the remainder of the work having been reached upon, would be a useful improvement of the land for which it was done, I think we can find a way whereby the difficulties of an individual farmer, who finds it hard to finance the whole undertaking before receiving any grant, can be met. I would ask the House to extend this indulgence to us.
The project is on an unprecedented scale. It is designed to meet problems for which we have no precedent and nothing to guide us. We are bound to meet problems as we go for which we cannot make anticipatory provision and, anxious as I am to be as precise and detailed as I can at this stage in informing the House of our intentions, I am bound to say that we are very conscious that individual cases may arise calling for special consideration in one way or another and can only lay down the overriding principle that if any adjustment is made to meet particular circumstances, anyone else whose circumstances are identical will have the advantage of whatever special provision may be made as the project proceeds, on the first occasion when those peculiar circumstances come to light.
It would have been a help if I had felt myself free to circulate a leaflet which is in proof, but I considered it would have been a discourtesy to the House to circulate a leaflet which might appear to anticipate the decision of the House. I will ask leave, however, in the event of the House giving a Second Reading to this Bill, to circulate a leaflet in proof which I aspire to place in the hands of every interested farmer in the country and which, I think, will inform any intending applicant of the procedure and the benefits that are available under the scheme in as clear and precise a manner as I know how to tell him.
Before I go to Part 2 and Part 3 of the general project, I should inform the House of the second part of the actual work programme itself. If the farmer, for any reason, prefers that the Department of Agriculture should do the work, exactly the same preliminary procedure is followed up to the point when the farmer is furnished with a sketch map of his holding with the works requiring to be done outlined upon it. If he then instructs the Department to proceed with the work, the Department will thereupon issue a certificate to the Land Commission on foot of which the Land Commission will charge the farmer's holding with the cost of the work. The Land Commission will then, with suitable machinery and equipment, proceed to carry out the work, including the application of fertilisers, where that is necessary, in accordance with the agreed scheme.
Comment on this
Did the Minister say the Land Commission would charge the holding with the cost of the work?
Comment on this
With £12 per acre. That is the cost to every farmer for reclamation as agreed between him and us and there can be no question of any obligation maturing or of a charge of any kind arising except on the request of the farmer, and on his written certificate, that he desires the charge to be put upon his land in exchange for the work stipulated for in the document signed by him.
Comment on this
No. But it is to be borne in mind that, when speaking of that charge, I speak of land that is being drained. If the Deputy has in mind land where perhaps nothing more than scrub is removed and no drainage is required——
Comment on this
——that will have to be a matter for decision and agreement as the scheme proceeds. When the Deputy reflects upon the wide variety of works we contemplate undertaking, he will realise the virtual impossibility of particularising at this stage as to what the charge may be in respect of any parcel of land until it is ascertained what the nature of the work will be. The figure of £12 per acre relates to where drainage, fertilisation, and any adjustment to fences and so forth fall to be made. It is a guiding line to all of us here in order to understand the maximum charge that can fall upon a farmer who has potentially arable land requiring drainage and every other form of treatment which we are prepared to undertake in the confident belief that by such works we can make the land arable hereafter.
I venture to say to the House at this stage that, no matter how detailed I try to be, I cannot possibly anticipate every inquiry Deputies may have in their minds. I fully appreciate that Deputy Smith and Deputy O'Rourke, when intervening, merely desired to facilitate me in understanding the matter; but I would ask any other Deputy so interested if he would be kind enough to note down any apparent lacuna in what I am saying and be good enough subsequently to afford me an opportunity of dealing with the specific problems raised, after preparation and consideration, when they are speaking on the Second Reading so that I may give them all the information at my disposal.
I had reached the point that the sketch map had been submitted to the farmer. He had approved the proposed works and desired the agreed sum to be charged upon his holding and the Land Commission is then instructed to proceed with the work. I was about to say that at this point I desired to emphasise very expressly and very clearly that this land project has nothing whatever in it of a relief work, nor is it designed to relieve unemployment, nor has it any primary purpose other than to rehabilitate the land. It is a welcome point that in its operation it will provide honourable occupation for hard-working men. I would like to take this first opportunity of saying, in anticipation, to every man who works upon this project that he is under no obligation to the Government who employs him or to the community for whom he works. He will be working on the basis that for every £1 in wages he collects, he is giving to the community that pays him ample value for the £1 it pays; and so I hope to get the best workmen in the country, proud to take a part in what I like to think will be some of the most valuable work that has ever been done in this country. We will employ, where we are called upon to undertake such work, every mechanical device, every instrument that modern science and knowledge can make available to us for the expeditious and efficient performance of our task.
Our aim will be to eliminate in so far as we possibly can low-paid manual labour and to substitute therefor training in the use of the most efficient machinery that our resources will allow, with a corresponding reward for those who operate it. I have always believed that the way to raise wages in rural Ireland is to place within the reach of the workers in rural Ireland equipment that will enable one agricultural worker to do what ten men were required to do 20 years ago. When that one man is so equipped and provides his employer with a return, no greater mistake can be made than to attempt to relate his remuneration to the remuneration appropriate to his grandfather who had no more efficient instrument to hand than a pickaxe or a shovel. I am happy to think, were anyone now to attempt to impose upon those who use the implements of modernity, with the corresponding return therefrom, the wage rates appropriate to the pick and shovel that they will leave and seek service with someone else who will pay them the fair wage for the work they do. I hope and pray our people will always have that opportunity so that those who contemplate their exploitation at home will be faced with notice permanently that, in addition to its being immoral to make the attempt, it is impracticable to hope that such an attempt can ever be brought to realisation. I hope to see employment upon this of country boys who, instead of being directed in the archaic art of the pick and shovel, will be trained to use the best machinery the world can provide. I hope to see these country boys grow into mature operators permanently working for their own neighbours in their own country, not because they are commanded by some patriotic sense of duty to do so, but because their own neighbours will have awakened to the elementary fact that the labourer is worthy of his hire.
Now, I know that it has been a popular catch-cry in this country for many years to say that the agricultural community grudge a fair wage to their workers. I have always proceeded on the basis that that contention is untrue, that the farmers of this country are ready and willing to pay a fair wage if they have the wherewithal to pay it. In the profound conviction that the farmers of this country have never denied, and have never wished to deny, a fair wage to those who work for them, my aim is to see that the operatives on this project, who will be working for the farmers as no one in Ireland has ever worked before, will be paid a wage commensurate with the results of the work they do. The more they get done with the power of modern machines and equipment, the more they will get paid, and perhaps we shall see the time when, with the use of modern methods on the land, there will be a rate of remuneration in rural Ireland commensurate with that of industrial workers who, by the use of modern machinery, can command wages which at present bear so striking a comparison with the normal level of wage rates in the rural parts of this country.
The second division of this project envisages the emergence throughout the country of a number of enterprising young men who will desire to set up as drainage contractors, holding themselves forth as prepared to equip themselves with machinery and to work on contract, either for the Department or directly for their neighbours. According to the kinds of work that they desire to equip themselves to be able to do, we shall inform them of the varieties of machinery which, in our experience, have proved satisfactory and the user of which, on work with which we are concerned, we are prepared to approve. If from the list of a number of implements they choose equipment for certain classes of work, in suitable cases where they are prepared from their own resources to provide one-third of the cost of that machinery, a loan of one-third will be arranged and a grant of one-third will also be given. The loan will be repayable in instalments over a period of five years—in ten half-yearly payments of between £11 and £12 per £100 borrowed. I do not exclude from that facility any person whose employment, in all the circumstances, would be advantageous to the community in which they live. What is present to my mind is this: normally when we think of a person we think of an individual citizen. I want the House to take the word "person" as meaning more than that; I do not exclude a parish council as a person. I do not exclude a co-operative society as a person. Nor would I wish the House rigidly to limit my discretion in altering the basis on which a loan will be made available where circumstances demand and expediency suggests that course.
I think we must ordain that the amount of the grant will be the same for all comers if they are approved, but I can conceive a situation arising in which one knew some chap who was really a first-class fellow, whom a number of neighbours indicated their readiness to employ and who; if he had some capital and if he had access to a loan for a larger percentage of the capital cost of the machinery, would embark on its repayment without delay. I think it would be a hardship and wrong if, in these circumstances, we found ourselves utterly unable to surmount the difficulty and were obliged to refuse him the opportunity of being able to give valuable assistance in the performance of our task, simply because we debarred ourselves from making the necessary credit available.
Ordinarily—I would say more than generally and only subject to rare exceptions — the intending purchaser would be expected to put up one-third of the cost in addition to the loan of one-third and the grant of one-third because, in the vast generality of cases, men must have a substantial part of their own money invested in the machinery if they are going to take that care of it and use it with that prudent circumspection that the owners of valuable machinery normally observe, but there could be such cases, and I do not think that any undue apprehension about letting some fellow get away with something should deter us calmly facing our responsibility and answering for what we do when we envisage the possibility of exceptional individuals deserving a more liberal class of treatment in so far as the credit element of the facilities outlined is concerned.
I come now to the last part of this project. I want to emphasise very clearly to the House that this is a matter of time. It cannot be done overnight; all that can be done is being done to expedite the full realisation of it. Grass is one of the most valuable crops grown in this country. In a country such as ours, with our climate and our annual rainfall, no one but a lunatic would fail to appreciate that the circumstances obtaining here properly availed of afford an unexampled opportunity for growing grass as a crop better than in any country in the world. If we are to grow grass as a crop, however, we must be as circumspect and as careful in the choice of our seed as we are in the choice of seed for any cereal or root crop such as is traditionally sown. Largely as a result of the obscurantist brayings of political agriculturists for some time in this country, people have failed to appreciate fully that grass is a crop and not just a terrestrial accident. It must be sown in its appropriate place in rotation; it must be sown with discrimination in the right variety and it must receive the appropriate manurial treatment just as any other crop.
I am not going to dwell on the benefits conferred upon us by the wise decisions of the recent past, but the hay seed that was sold in this country during the last quinquennium would make a cat laugh and we have got to try and repair that. To that end we are now propagating Timothy and Cocksfoot of indigenous strain, the seed of which has been saved by some of the distinguished agronomists of our own institutions and we are in the process of selecting and initiating the propagation of an acceptable strain of indigenous perennial rye grass. But we are at once confronted with the problem of propagating such a crop. The desirable feature of an indigenous rye grass is that it runs more to leaf than to seed. That makes it eminently desirable from the point of view of the man who grows the crop for conversion into ensilage, hay or pasture, but from the point of view of the farmer who grows grass seed for sale it is little consolation to him that the quality of hay seed is superb if the yield of the crop is only 5 cwt. instead of 12 cwt. so that the very quality of the grass which commends itself to the farmer makes it a most unwelcome crop to the farmer who habitually grows it for the commercial grass seed market. It is not appropriate that at this stage I should trouble the House with the devices we propose to employ to overcome that problem, but our aim is to eliminate over a period of years from the grass seed market here of all of what are now known as commercial strains. We want to ensure that nothing will be sold on the domestic grass seed market but the produce of pedigree strain, such as rye grass seed perennially renewed and reselected by competent agronomists. Their primary function it will be to maintain a basic stock from which those who grow stocks for the ordinary channels of commerce will be perennially supplied and facilitated in the disposal of it to the seed merchants at a price which will make it possible for those seed merchants to sell it in the ordinary course of trade on the domestic market at a price not in excess of that normally chargeable for the strains normally bought by the farmer who buys it for the purpose of selling his crop.
With regard to wild white clover, which is an essential constituent, we have been advised that there is no advantage in propagating it here, as strains can be procured from abroad which will be quite as good and as valuable as anything indigenous to our own soil. If hereafter further research makes it clear that any advantage is to be had from the selection of the indigenous strain, an exactly similar procedure will be followed. The ultimate aim is to make available to the farmers of this country appropriate seeds and strains at a price not in excess of the commercial varieties available. Let me repeat, however, that any development of that kind cannot be brought about in a short time and that the very earliest time at which I could hope to encourage the House to expect that commercial varieties of seed will have disappeared off the market in this country is at the end of a period of ten years. In the interval we hope to make steadily increasing quantities available with the passing of each year, but the earliest possible time at which they will be available to everybody at the commercial rates is at the end of ten years and it might take longer.
I think I should inform the House lastly as to the organisation and I earnestly press on the House to believe that if in these introductory remarks I have overlooked some facet of the plan with which it seems to them I should have dealt, they should excuse this on the grounds that I am so immersed in it that I find it hard to remember that there are things which I know clearly and certainly which, of course, members of the House could not know inasmuch as they have not heard of them and I will gladly answer any queries which are put to me when I am winding up the discussion. Perhaps I should recapitulate the present envisaged purposes. They are: field drainage, one; land reclamation in general—and that is a deliberately designed anomalous kind of term which would permit the officers of my Department to adapt their procedure to any unforeseen problem which comes within the generic term of land reclamation. Construction and improvement of watercourses; the removal of unnecessary fences causing waste or impeding cultivation. I know how attractive many of our whitethorn and blackthorn hedges are, and I want to make it as clear as crystal to the House that there is no nihilist intention in the Department of Agriculture to sweep through the country like an avenging deity, wiping away every fence, every hedge and every bush in Ireland. It would be an outrage on the amenities of the countryside, and it would be agricultural folly to boot. Many of these hedges are of value as protection and shelter for live stock and it would be reckless folly to sweep them away without discrimination. No such intention is present to the mind of the director of this project, but it is equally manifest that, with the passage of time, many of the double ditches which are supposed to act as fences in fact spread themselves out over the surface of the land and where crops of one kind or another should be growing there is an herbarium of nettles, weeds and herbs, not to speak of the multifarious pests which habitually abide in the bosom of such botanical collections. It is desired in many such cases, of the shough and the attendant sprawling bank, to lay in the shough a pipe drain, then to go behind the bank with a bulldozer and push the bank down on top of the shough and then put the roller over the whole shebang.
Comment on this
I will consult the Deputy —what else? Perhaps that was a sharp retort. I can assure the Deputy that I hope, when we embark on this project—quite seriously, I reasonably hope —it will be undertaken by us all, and that the special knowledge each of us has in our own particular districts will be at the disposal of those charged with the responsibility of making this a success. May I take the occasion to say to Deputies on both sides of the House that we enter upon it with no sense of omniscience and would very greatly value any helpful advice or suggestions that might be offered in respect of any local project of which people may have peculiar knowledge. Whether they are adopted or not, the fact that they are offered will be gratefully acknowledged and they are assured of respectful and careful examination. Nor would I wish that any Deputy on any side of the House should feel any reluctance whatever in approaching either myself or any of the officers of my Department concerned with this project for any information or assistance or any other purpose which they believe would serve the common good.
In that connection of removing useless and old fences, we have power to substitute for such fences proper ones and these, as we are at present advised, would best be constructed with concrete posts and wire suitable to the particular holding we are called upon to treat. It is exceedingly difficult to secure any degree of survival for timber posts, no matter how carefully creosoted or treated, and once one rots away the whole fence tends to collapse. Concrete posts suitably set are enduring and if the wire from time to time requires replacement it presents no serious difficulty. There, again, our intention in that regard is quite susceptible to alteration if experience in the work suggests some other medium of fencing as being more generally suitable.
The improvement of hill grazing— that is quite unbroken territory in this country, as it has never been done before. The classic experiment on that work has been done at the Cahn Hill farm in Wales, while a good deal of work of that kind has been done in the Scottish highlands. We may well find, in the peculiar conditions obtaining here, a variant of the work they have done, which is peculiar to our conditions. Nor am I unaware that, when I come to define hill grazing, I will find the vigilant eye of the Minister for Lands following me with severe, if fraternal, solicitude wherever I go. However, I have no doubt that, with the co-operative spirit which informs an inter-Party Government, the Minister and I will be able to delineate our respective spheres of influence and on his trees will emerge, while mine will accommodate quadrupeds and men. I shall not say anything more provocative about forestry than that at the moment.
The reclamation of estuarine marshlands and callows covers two projects. In many areas where arterial drainage is done, about to be done, or is in the process of doing, there emerge considerable stretches of land which has been subject to periodic inundation which is now very valuable alluvial land, but because its area is so considerable on what is otherwise a small and poor holding the farmer who owns it has never been able to put the capital into it to remove the silts and generally to reclaim it and make it arable again. Were he in a position to do so, much of that callow land would be the most valuable arable land of this country. We propose to do it for him.
When you come to the reclamation of estuarine marsh-land, I do not want to secure the cordial approval of Deputy O'Grady on any false pretence. We are firmly resolved to deal with that problem, but those Deputies who are familiar with the nature of reclamation of estuarine marsh will realise that it belongs to a category of work quite distinct from the general type of agricultural land reclamation. It would be my intention to invite the advice of the leading firms of Dutch engineers in any project which we embark upon in this matter. I am informed that in Great Britain when this type of work was undertaken it was ultimately found desirable to seek the advice, and in some cases the assistance, of the experienced Dutch engineering firms who have a well-established tradition of dealing with the problems arising from inundation by the sea. I do not necessarily say that will have to depend exclusively on their co-operation, but I think it would be reckless to embark on this type of work without at least having the benefit of the advice of such experienced persons and probably the services of individuals trained under their engineers, or at least apprenticed to them for some time, either in Holland or on some particular project which we contemplate here.
The last matter on which I wish to inform the House is one on which I crave a certain indulgence. Eight counties are already under way. I suppose I need make no protracted apology for associating all this work in some measure with the work which was done to make this land our own.
I do not deny that it gives me some certain satisfaction to have been appointed by my own people to repair the land in 1949 which the Land League recovered for our people in 1879. I propose, unless most sternly reprehended, to afford myself the indulgence of extending this project to the County Mayo on 16th August, which is the 70th anniversary of the day on which Michael Davitt founded the Land League in Castlebar. I suppose the most pedestrian amongst us will not resent the manifest irregularity of striking west into Mayo all on its own. I do not deny that we are striking west into Mayo all on its own, for no other reason than that it was to be included some day, and I could think of no more appropriate date than that anniversary, when, by launching the project in Mayo, we could recall to all our people that we would not have land on which to work that project if Michael Davitt had not done what he did in very much more difficult circumstances 70 years ago in Castlebar.
After that slight excursion into pardonable sentiment about the 16th August, I am happy to inform the House that we hope to be able, on a later and suitable date before the end of October, to encompass Tipperary, Waterford, Cork, Limerick and Kerry in the sphere of our activities. Not a sod will be turned or a drain dug in Cork, unlike the flax mill, during the election. Deputy Allen need not worry about that. We are building no flax mills and we are not raising the price of milk by 6d. a gallon. We are not going to weave linen——
Comment on this
——and we are not going to make hens hatch in a fortnight— pure, simple, pedestrian, everyday jobs until after the by-election. If it will relieve Deputy Smith, Deputy Allen and Deputy McGrath, if they think the inclusion of Cork will have the slightest effect on the by-election, I will cut out Cork. Is that agreed?
Comment on this
I hope you, Sir, will acquit me of having brought it in. If, however, Deputy Smith or Deputy Allen or Deputy McGrath will certify to me that they think that this is calculated to have the slightest improper effect upon the minds of the electors of West Cork, I will cut out Cork.
Comment on this
I am entirely in the hands of the House in this matter. When we have brought that traditional area into the ambit of our activities, I think we may then hope that, after a shorter period than has elapsed between the initiation and the addition of these counties, to add the next group.
Comment on this
We have Monaghan under way and Louth, and, in our extension to the next group, I promise the House that I shall ask no further indulgence for such sentimental journeys as I have envisaged in Mayo. Nothing but the exigencies of expeditious and efficient expansion will influence my judgment.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is looking for sharp answers, he will get them, but let us forbear from acrimonious wit on this occasion. I think I ask too much of the officers of my Department who are responsible for the prosecution of these works, though I sometimes wonder if it is possible to ask too much of the public servants of this State, considering the astonishing measure of their achievement; but trusting in their power to perform quasi-miracles when the national interest demands it, I venture to prognosticate to the House that, before 12 months have elapsed from the date on which this project was initiated, last Wednesday, to wit, it will be in progress in every one of the 26 counties of this part of Ireland. That will demand a degree of effort on the part of those responsible for it which it is not really just to demand. Nevertheless, as has been so often done before, I am going to make that request of them. I know that, if it is humanly possible to perform it, it will be done, and, if it is not done, the only reason will be that the physical limitations which restrict men's efforts will be such as to make it quite impossible.
I renew my invitation to every Deputy who has not had every query answered in these opening words to ask me whatever he desires to know and I shall do my best to answer him. I commend this modest Bill to the House not for its contents which are not significant but for its poetic significance, in that we start, as I see it to-day, on the completion of a work that was started 70 years ago — the reclamation of the land of this country not only from dereliction and poverty, but the completion of the task of the reclamation of the land of this country from the landlords for our own people, but they may use it for ever more for the betterment of those to whom it belongs.
Comment on this
The Minister has attempted to explain his failure to follow the practice which has grown up in this House over a long number of years of issuing with a Bill presented here on Second Reading an explanatory memorandum. He has, it appears to me, been over-sensitive in this matter, inasmuch as his explanation of his failure is that he was not anxious to anticipate any decision that might be arrived at by the House on the measure itself. I am not contending that, in so far as the short Bill before us is concerned, it is a measure which might call for an explanatory memorandum, but it will at least be admitted that it is the machinery whereby a very elaborate scheme will be implemented. When he invites Deputies, as he has just done in concluding, to make to him suggestions as to the shortcomings of the scheme he has outlined, he will, I think, admit that Deputies not only on this side but on every side of the House would have been in a much better position to analyse and examine the scheme, with a view to making such suggestions as he has asked for, designed to strengthen where necessary, any weaknesses which may exist, weaknesses which will surely be found to exist in a scheme of the kind which he has outlined if such an explanatory memorandum had been made available.
Let me examine the Bill as I see it. As the Minister has stated, there are only two sections that call for much comment — Sections 2 and 5.
Comment on this
It is all right. It is not of much value to me now. It is understandable, of course, that the Land Commission will require statutory powers to enable them, where the farmer so requests, to deal with the contribution which he is called upon to make under this scheme and to have the charge registered against his holding. There is one point in Section 2 on which I would like information. Where a farmer indicates his willingness to pay the contribution in cash, and where under sub-section (4) of Section 2 he defaults, the Land Commission is notified of such default and I take it, although the farmer has stated originally that he would pay the contribution in cash, is then empowered to charge and register the sum against the holding.
Comment on this
Under Section 3, yes. I am a layman and I have not had an opportunity of discussing with others what they think of that provision but, at first sight, while it may not be desperately objectionable, there is something about it that does not appeal to me. I will only go so far as to register my suspicion or to express my doubt as to the justice of that course. From the point of view of the State it may be all right.
I am amazed at the ease and freedom and the manner in which this particular Minister disposed of Section 5. I just cannot find words to express my feelings about it. When I say this particular Minister I mean it in the sense that a Minister for Agriculture who has made known his own feelings so often on the rights of private property should be the person responsible for introducing a measure which contains a section of that sort without any qualification whatever as to the rights that are ordinarily recognised as rights to which private owners are entitled.
Comment on this
Never mind what I think. Deputy Hickey is a city man, a Labour man, and I understand his point of view in regard to this matter and the country understands it. When I have concluded my analysis of this particular section, Deputy Hickey and the other Labour members who will be enthusiastic in their support of a provision of this kind will be free to speak for whatever length they decide. While that Section 5 would carry considerable objection to me no matter who might happen to find himself in the position of Minister for Agriculture, it baffles me beyond description that such a section should be inserted without qualification or limitation by a Minister who has expressed himself so often on this particular matter. Let me say at once that I am not objecting to the powers that are sought in Section 5, but I am objecting to the fact that they should stand out there naked in this short measure and that they should be inserted by a Minister for Agriculture who, even in this very Bill, acknowledges that he will not undertake any work whatever unless on request of the landowner concerned. Remember, the whole basis of these proposals is that the initiative must come from the landowner, that not fourpence worth of work will be done unless and until the landowner applies and the application is vetted and an estimate is prepared and the applicant says he is satisfied with the estimate and will go ahead or authorise the Department to go ahead with the work.
The Bill sets out machinery of that kind for the purpose of enabling a desirable sort of useful work to be undertaken either by the owner of the land or by the State, but, under Section 5, if my neighbour applies to the Department and the application is vetted and an estimate is prepared and submitted to the applicant and the applicant informs the Minister that he is not prepared to undertake the work and asks the Department to do so, the Minister for Agriculture or his agents or servants, without notice, without even informing me, can walk in themselves and take with them whatever machinery they may think fit or proper to use.
I want the House and the Minister to realise that, personally, I am not in the least concerned as to what the Minister or other members of the House may say in reply to the criticism that I am offering against this section. I can only tell the Minister and the House what my own feelings as a landowner would be if I were treated in that fashion. If, under this Bill, and without amendment, the procedure I have described can be resorted to by the Minister or by his agents and servants, all I can say — and I am not, as a landowner, an unreasonable person in so far as the rights of my neighbour are concerned— is that if he were to attempt to behave in the fashion I have described, then I certainly, as a landowner, would endeavour, even at the risk of breaking the law, to prevent such a happening.
Comment on this
Prevent the Minister, his agent or servant, from moving along the banks of what the Minister— although it is not mentioned in the Bill itself—has seen fit to describe it as a "common watercourse", without even telling those into whose lands he is moving that he is actually opening the gap, that he is making a breach in the mearing fence.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy has grasped the section—"So as to render it capable of carrying waters that should normally pass through it..."
Comment on this
I do not mind whether it is water that should normally pass through it or not. That is a very delicate technical question into which I am not going to go. What I am saying is this and I challenge the Minister to deny it, having regard to the picture that he has given to us and to the country of himself and of his attitude towards the rights of individuals in regard to their property and the respect we are all to have for that property. What I am saying is that when that application is approved and when I, as a farmer, apply under this scheme—when I have the estimate from the Minister's Department and say it is satisfactory; when I say that I am not prepared to carry out that work myself and write back to the Department and say, "I am prepared to allow you to go ahead with this work; I will pay you in cash or allow you to have a charge registered against my holding"—the Minister, his servants or agents can move down to the scene without even telling my nearest neighbour, whether the field adjoining this common watercourse is in oats, wheat, potatoes or hay, that they are going to go in. In the course of the last couple of weeks we have been discussing another Bill in this House on which a great deal has been said with regard to the whole principle of notice and of the rights of the private owner and so forth. I do not want to cover that subject at all. However, I think that, bad and all as the Works Bill was in that regard, prior to its amendment as a result of the criticism levelled against it by the Opposition, this Bill, short as it is, is a most lamentable performance. It is all the more a lamentable performance by reason of the fact that it has been sponsored in this House and has been explained to this House —to the extent that he has actually explained it at all—by a Minister who has expressed the views with which we are all familiar and on which I have already made sufficient comment.
Personally, then, I do not mind whether the Minister is going to be influenced by my objections to this section. As the saying is, you can stick your head in the air and go off and insist upon this Bill in the form in which it has been presented here, without amendment. You can, and I shall not be concerned. But I say that if you do, you are doing something you should not do. I admit that if I occupied the post the Minister occupies, I would be as fond as any man of being armed with the necessary powers to undertake a useful and necessary public work. At the same time, I think I would be the first to admit that the private person has the right to be told what is happening. Not only that, but I would be the first to admit that the private owner has the right to have some means by which, if an injury or an injustice is about to be inflicted, he will have some sort of tribunal, whatever it may be, before which he would be heard in order to get——
Comment on this
There is no need at all to get cross about it. If the Deputy wishes to submit any amendment along those lines, I shall be prepared to consider it favourably.
Comment on this
That is very nice. An invitation like that is all very good but, after all, the insertion of some protective provision in the Bill was such an obvious requirement that I cannot understand why the Minister should have allowed it to come in here without having made an attempt to meet something that was glaringly called for. Now, after we have listened to an hour's speech, the invitation is thrown across at me. I have not the Attorney-General nor the legal officers of the Government to advise me. As I say, I am a layman. Yet, on the very first shot from the Opposition against this provision, the Minister invites me to submit an amendment.
Comment on this
I think it is unnecessary, but I want to meet the Deputy, if he feels any undue unhappiness about it, if I possibly can. I do not want to thrust it on the House at all. I think any amendment is unnecessary, but if I can be of any assistance to any Deputy to meet his legitimate anxieties, I am most anxious to help. Can I be more reasonable than that?
Comment on this
That was a provision that was so obvious in this measure that I cannot take the invitation as a legitimate excuse for its not being here. As far as this Bill is concerned, I would say that these are the two matters that call for comment. Now, let us come to the scheme. It is because of the elaborateness of the scheme—not because of what is actually in the Bill, but because of the intricacies of the scheme outlined by the Minister—that I think, in fairness to the House and to the Deputies, we should have got, not yesterday nor the day before, but a week ago, a detailed memorandum setting out in paragraphs (1), (2), (3), (4) what the scheme aims at, as the Minister has attempted to explain it to the House. The Minister himself should be the first to realise, in order that the discussion on the provisions of this scheme should be an intelligent discussion, that that was necessary.
The scheme is in two parts. The first part is where an applicant intends to carry out the work of reclamation himself. I am not clear from what the Minister said that I have got all the details. From previous reports which appeared, in the main in the Sunday Independent, we were given to understand that, in the event of the applicant's undertaking the reclamation work himself, a maximum grant per acre would be payable to him of, I think, £18. According to the statement we have heard from the Minister, the applicant is likely to receive two-thirds of the estimated cost of the work. I am not sure which of these I am to regard as representing what is in the mind of the Minister and his Department.
There is one thing that does puzzle me. At the conclusion of his speech the Minister explained that this scheme had in fact been introduced already in eight counties, and he then proceeded to describe the process by which it would apply all over the country. I can see the impossibility of building up a staff which would be able to apply this scheme in its entirety to the Twenty-Six Counties; that is, if parts one and two were to be operated at the same time. My own view is in conflict with that of the Minister's. Why apply the scheme in its entirety as a first step? If you apply the scheme in such a way that an applicant can undertake the work himself or, if he does not wish to undertake the work himself, some State Department will do so, you will require very elaborate machinery and it will be very hard to perfect it so as to be able to deal with the Twenty-Six Counties at the one time.
Here is how I would approach the problem. I would say the first part of the scheme refers to landowners who apply on the understanding that they will supervise and carry out the work themselves. There has been in existence over a period of years, perhaps not a sufficient staff, but at least a fairly decent skeleton staff trained for work in connection with the farm improvements scheme. By adding to that staff three or four or perhaps half a dozen in any particular county you would have a sufficient staff with experience to operate the first part of the scheme and you would not be letting the Department in for undertaking something in a short period which would be a physical impossibility. I am not making this point because I am in any way jealous of any particular county which may have been selected for prior treatment. I am suggesting that it would be a better approach if the second part of the scheme were brought in gradually. In bringing in the second part of the scheme you could limit it if you felt it was desirable. You could apply the first part to the whole country, because you have the skeleton staff of inspectors under the farm improvements scheme. You could then, in a gradual way, bring in the second part of the scheme in order to get on with the work quickly as to give farmers who applied some evidence that you were going to get on with the work in a reasonable time.
That would be a fairer way because, as I understand it, in introducing the scheme envisaged as a result of the passage of this Bill and actually putting it into operation prior to the passage of the Bill, inasmuch as the Minister has power to allow the first part of the scheme to go on even without the powers he is seeking here in relation to eight counties, you are cutting out previous activities which were carried on all over the country under the farm improvements scheme. In that way you are doing an injustice. If it were something that could not be overcome, I could see the reason for it. As I see things, the proper approach to the implementation of the scheme would be that the first part of the scheme should be applied in a general way all over the Twenty-Six Counties on the understanding that we had already the technical staff and the people with sufficient knowledge and training to carry it out. Then the second part of the scheme, which provides that the Department would take responsibility for the execution of the work, could be introduced if necessary in a piecemeal fashion. If it were not necessary, of course it could be applied to the whole country.
The Minister is quite right in saying there will be snags in abundance arising out of the operation of a scheme like this, as in some respects at least it may be somewhat different from what has been already in operation for some years. I am sure that I cannot foresee all these snags but I can foresee some of them. I should like to get some indication as to how these could be overcome. It is not unusual to find in low-lying districts portion of the holdings of a considerable number of farmers affected by flooding. That would be the sort of case in which there would be what the Minister referred to as a common drain or watercourse.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy referring to what is called callow land — land subject to periodic flooding?
Comment on this
I am referring to the sort of drainage problem which exists in practically every parish over 70 per cent. of the area of the country. You have small pockets of land affected by periodic flooding.
Comment on this
This scheme would not cover that. That would come more under the scheme outlined by the Minister for Local Government, under which minor rivers will be widened and deepened to prevent periodic overflow.
Comment on this
That makes the matter even more obscure than ever, because I can visualise many of the applications under this scheme arising from the sort of situation I have described where you would have, say, a pocket of land that would be subject to periodic flooding.
Comment on this
I am talking about a common watercourse. The Minister in his Second Reading speech referred to what he called a common watercourse although it is not mentioned in the Bill. I take that to mean a watercourse that would facilitate the passage of water from the holdings of, say, two, three, four, five or six people. Is that not right?
Comment on this
You are looking for powers in Section 5 to enable the Minister, his agents or servants to deal with a common watercourse?
Comment on this
I will put myself in the position of a landowner who is in some way anxious to benefit by this particular scheme. I apply to have certain improvement works carried out which will relieve some portion of my holding from surplus water and enable the drains on the farm to function properly, not only the existing drains, but any new drains. On the Minister's servant coming to inspect the application he finds that it will be necessary to deal with this common watercourse described by the Minister. The estimate is approved by the Department and it is sent down to me, the applicant. I am agreeable to what is proposed.
Comment on this
If you just let me develop this case I believe that I could make this clear. I would, as I say, indicate my willingness to have my holding charged with the sum of £12 per acre in order to effect the proposed improvement to my land. The Minister's servants would then proceed to execute the work. In doing so, by opening the common drain, they might do a considerable amount of damage further down the stream by allowing the water to move more freely into an area that was not drained, so as to admit of its passing to the main artery as it would be required. In one case the work might result in doing considerable injury and in another case the work might result in conferring a benefit on my neighbour's holding, although my neighbour's holding would not be charged in any way with part of the cost of the scheme.
Comment on this
Never mind. I am not any more decent than anybody else. I am approaching this as a problem that I can see arising as a result of this scheme as it has so far been explained to us. I have no doubt whatever that a problem such as this would arise.
Comment on this
You never know. I have not, of course, dealt at all with the arguments that can be used against the announced intention of the Minister in regard to the Holmes Report. It is all very well to say that it is not intended under this scheme to deal with periodic flooding. However, when we come into close contact with that we find that the Minister is only anxious to engage in work of a kind that will enable a farmer to have his field drains cleaned and to have an outlet that will permit of the water being taken out of the field drains—those that are in existence and those that may be created. You must remember that in dealing with the common watercourse to which the Minister has referred and in making it possible that that common watercourse will take the water from the field drains, the water from the field drains gets into the common watercourse; the common watercourse flows into the little stream to the minor river.
Comment on this
The minor river flows into some tributary in some other catchment. No matter how you attempt to look at this you can see at once that activities of this character, however small they may be at the source, must have the effect ultimately of bringing about the situation that has been referred to in our discussions on a previous measure. It was also referred to by an expert brought over here from New Zealand by the Minister himself and who was paid a small sum for his report. In that report he stated quite clearly that this was not the way in which this particular work should be done.
Comment on this
The Deputy is suggesting this and no more than this, because there are very few things—in fact, I suppose there is nothing—in which I am expert; but I know a little about this. I am suggesting nothing more than that we have got to be tremendously careful in our approach to this matter. However much Deputy Cowan and some others may wish to present themselves to the public as Deputies who are progressively-minded, who want to make us believe that they are thinking in terms of things that are big and expansive, that they have large minds, that there is no petty approach to a solution of these problems and so on, that is all right. It is all right to try to make the public believe that that is your understanding and that is the way you would tackle these problems. I know that certain results must accrue from the implementation of this scheme that we must watch and try to envisage in advance, so that while conferring benefit in one case we do not do some injury.
Comment on this
Is that not a matter of collaboration? Where a number of farms have a watercourse in common there should be a co-operative effort to see that the water released above does not cause undue suffering to the people below, the people below acting in co-operation with the people upstream. I have land myself in which there has to be co-operation from time to time.
Comment on this
You are even better than I am, Sir. I have not grasped fully the reference which we have heard from Deputy Madden about co-operation. I happened to be in charge of the Office of Public Works during some of the war years when a good deal of public money was spent on the drainage of areas in which farmers had a right of turbary. During my years in that office it was the policy that had the support of every public man and thinking person in the country to create, for all those who had the type of rights to which I have referred, all possible opportunities to get on with the work because of the national necessity to engage in that work. There was no question of shortage of money for such provisions. The only occasion on which the work that I have described was impeded was, perhaps, when a letter was received in the Department concerned pointing out the harm that would be inflicted on some other important business or on some important piece of private property as a result of the work that might take place upstream. I cannot see, as Deputy Madden seems to be able to see, how farmers downstream would be able to grasp the significance of what would happen maybe two or three miles away from them or the damage that might result from the activities that I have been endeavouring to describe. If the amount of work that is undertaken is small, then, of course, the volume of water and its rate of progress in its course to the main artery will not be so great, but if the volume of work undertaken is large, then the evidence as to the damage that may result to other people will become more clear.
I should like the Minister to justify the course that he is pursuing in this regard, and to explain why he has abandoned what is really the equivalent of the first part of this scheme, seeing that he had a trained staff of officials who had been engaged on work not very far different from the work he is undertaking in this part of the scheme. The first part of the scheme which he has outlined to us is really the equivalent of the farm improvements scheme except that there is a contribution of two-thirds being made to the cost of the work. Will he explain why he has not gone on with that part of the scheme in regard to the whole country and why he did not wait until such time as he had his own organisation built up for the application of the second part of the scheme? I would say that, while the latter may be a desirable part of the scheme, it is not as desirable as the other part which entitles an owner himself, who might have help of his own, to engage on the work. When the second part of the scheme is put into operation a good deal of public criticism is bound to be levelled at it.
Some questions were asked as to the difficulty and maybe the unfairness of charging against a particular holding a standard sum. I can see an objection to that at once, as I am sure most Deputies can, because the work that individual landholders may apply to have carried out will vary. Take it that I have to agree to have my holding charged with £12 per statute acre for the reclamation of two, three or four acres of land on which the State may have to expend twice the sum that will be necessary in the case of my neighbour who will have his three or five acres charged with the same amount. That will raise objections that will not be easy to provide against. I, of course, see the difficulty of having other than a standard charge because if you had not a standard charge there would be all kinds of dangers in that, too.
Comment on this
Is it not so that you will scarcely find two acres that will require for their rehabilitation the same expenditure? If the four or five acres for which I have applied require the maximum, then the charge registered against my holding will be at the rate of £12 an acre. If the same area of my neighbour's land is reclaimed, and if the cost is considerably less, the charge that will be registered against his holding, even though less work has been carried out on it than on mine, will be the same.
Comment on this
But surely men are not so jealous that, if one gets £15 for £12 and the neighbour gets £16 for £12, they will grudge it to one another.
Comment on this
There is a good deal more in it than that, and I think that will prove to be so in the course of the operation of the scheme itself. It may be that means may be found to overcome it, but I think that when you come to carry out the work you will find that objections will be raised on that head.
The Minister has explained that some criticism has been levelled against the scheme on the ground that a farmer who proposes to reclaim an acre of land must complete the job before any money is paid to him. That was an objection which, I think, most people saw. The Minister's explanation, of course, was an attempt to meet that objection. In my opinion, the effort made to meet the objection will not prove to be entirely satisfactory, inasmuch as it has been explained to us that a case such as this may happen. I am taking the case of a farmer who proposes to reclaim land himself. Let us suppose that the work can be undertaken in sections and that there are so many perches of field drainage to be improved. If we suppose that the field drainage can be done efficiently without carrying out some other part of the work, can he be paid for the field drainage work that he has done, irrespective of whether he has touched on the other part of the estimate or not? That is all right, but it will not be so easy.
Comment on this
It will not be so easy to get the workable section in a reclamation scheme on any particular acre. I imagine you will find considerable pressure for the payment of the instalment on the ground that some particular section of the estimate has been completed, and a good deal of time will be expended on the inspection of work of that kind where the Department will be notified that a section of work has been completed that has only been touched upon.
Comment on this
If a man ran out of money you would not leave him with no grant at all; you would give him an instalment enabling him to finish it.
Comment on this
Let us come to the whole purpose that underlies the introduction of this scheme. The whole purpose is to reclaim and rehabilitate semi-derelict land. Enormous sums are spoken of as being available for that work. The one thing that puzzles me and most other people is this, that much as that work is desirable for the purpose of enabling landowners to rehabilitate and reclaim any semi-derelict land they have, when we are dealing with such enormous sums as those mentioned by the Minister, not only here and now, but over the last 12 months, why should we not be free to devote some portion of these moneys to other purposes?
Comment on this
The subsidisation of artificial manures, the subsidisation of ground limestone, the encouragement of farmers to use much-needed phosphates and ground limestone upon land that is not derelict.
Comment on this
It provides for that on land reclaimed under this scheme and for which the owner of the land will pay. This scheme is being introduced for the purpose of enabling landowners to engage in a wholesale policy of land reclamation and drainage, with the avowed intention of increasing the productivity of the land, giving the farmers a higher income, giving the workers higher wages and creating desirable improvements in the standard of living of those who work on the land. That is all very desirable and any person must support a policy that is aimed at achieving that end. But I ask the Minister to consider this, that £40,000,000 is a lot of money. I have my opinion as to when and where and how that £40,000,000 will be spent.
Comment on this
Do not mind what I believe. Suppose you said we have £20,000,000 or £25,000,000 to be devoted to land reclamation and the balance of £10,000,000 or £15,000,000 should be devoted to creating inducements and encouragement to our farmers to apply the artificial manures, phosphates and lime that are so glaringly required on most of our land, we are not likely to get any immediate results. The farmer who reclaims five or six acres will undertake a long-distance investment. Neither he nor the community will be likely to reap a benefit from that investment for a considerable period, but in setting out to encourage a farmer to apply artificial manures, lime and phosphates to his land you are doing something that will give results almost immediately. I am not using that as an argument against land reclamation. My point is: why should not the two objectives be aimed at at the same time?
Comment on this
I am suggesting that side by side with a scheme of this kind, especially in an atmosphere of £40,000,000 or £50,000,000 and where £5,000,000 or £10,000,000 does not appear to matter, desirable as a scheme of this nature undoubtedly is, if these sums are available for the implementation of such a scheme, portion of such sums should be devoted to a purpose just as glaringly necessary as field drainage or land reclamation. My suggestion is to encourage farmers to apply limestone and phosphates on land that does not need drainage at all but on which production could be increased in a very short space of time if that policy were resorted to.
Comment on this
The Deputy has his own ideas as to the manner in which these things would be produced and distributed if he had the responsibility in that connection.
Comment on this
We are talking here in terms of £40,000,000 to be spent over ten years. That money will be borrowed and it will have to be repaid with interest. It will be used in furtherance of a policy of land reclamation and the farmers will have to contribute a somewhat similar or perhaps a larger sum. We are proposing to do that in a year when the Government saw fit to remove whatever subsidy existed on the amount of artificial fertilisers available to the farmers.
Comment on this
Yes. I am suggesting that in conjunction with the reclamation of land, as proposed under this measure, for the purpose of improving the general standards of our people, the incomes of individuals, the income of the nation, improving the conditions of those who work on the land and increasing the wages of land workers, there should be a provision whereby portion of these moneys could be devoted to obtaining artificial fertilisers and lime for application to land not needing drainage or reclamation so as to increase productivity immediately.
In the view of most people such a policy would result in an almost immediate improvement in productivity, far in excess of anything which could result from the reclamation of land at such a cost as has been mentioned here. In some cases that land, even when reclaimed at the cost mentioned here, will not prove to be more productive without much further expenditure on the part of the farmer along the lines indicated by the Minister, and the farmer and the community cannot hope to reap the benefits that would result from a much smaller investment if directed along the lines I have indicated.
Comment on this
Does the Minister admit the desirability of the principle? If he does, then we can agree as to the rate of subsidy. What I want is an admission from the Minister that the principle of subsidisation of artificial fertilisers and ground limestone is a sound one in view of what we are doing in regard to land reclamation. If I get that admission from the Minister and from the Government we can then decide at what particular level it should be. I say that that would be good policy. If I had responsibility myself as a member of the Government for the borrowing of a sum of money of that size for the purpose of engaging in a policy which would increase the productivity of our land I would insist upon diverting a considerable portion of that sum for the purpose I have indicated. In taking that course and in insisting upon that policy, I believe I would have the support of the large majority of the land owners.
Comment on this
Never mind the manure ring. The Minister is more conversant with the standards and activities of business men than I am. He is very prosperous business man himself and he should not be jealous of others who have achieved success in other lines. I do not know what methods have been employed to bring success either in his case or theirs. I am talking now of the desirability of pursuing a certain course of action and I am sure that the recommendation I have made would meet with the approval of those people who live upon the land and work on it.
Comment on this
I am trying to help the Minister. I think I have done fairly well. Even yet, though I cannot see any reason why the Minister should be so hostile to the suggestion, I would appeal to him and to the Government, not only to continue along the lines that are envisaged in the Bill, but to consider seriously the desirability of applying to some extent subsidies to both artificial fertilisers and ground limestone, both of which are very essential commodities as far as the farmer is concerned. It is difficult to plead unceasingly for assistance and help for those who are engaged on the land, but the Minister himself strove to convey to the House, when introducing this scheme, that this was no relief work. He said that there was no question of giving the farmer relief. This is regarded as a good investment and as one that will pay considerable dividends. In the full knowledge that I am saying something which will meet with the approval of every farming Deputy and every farmer, I say that you will get dividends three times as large as those that will result from anything that could happen in the next ten years as a result of the passage of this measure if portion of this money is applied to the other purposes I have mentioned.
Comment on this
I think the best way in which to describe Deputy Smith's attitude towards this measure is to remember that he had to say something and that something had to be in opposition to the Bill. He certainly did not contribute any useful criticism. I sometimes wonder why the Opposition would not follow the lead we set when we first came in in 1943. I say that without any bitterness. When we came into the Dáil our object was to give assistance where a measure was a good one and to criticise it if it had any flaws either in drafting or in the general working of it.
To describe this measure as a glorified extension of the farm improvement scheme is carrying the joke a bit too far. It is said by the Opposition that there is not much difference between the two schemes. There may not be if you look at it from one particular viewpoint. But there is a tremendous difference when one observes that the Minister has added three noughts to the sum of money required for this scheme. We have provision now for £40,000,000 as against £40,000.
I have no hesitation in saying that this is the most revolutionary measure introduced in this House since the establishment of our own Government. I go further back and I say that it is the greatest revolution in land since the Land League was formed. The Minister adverted to the formation of the Land League in the course of his address. The aim and object of that Land League was to make the farmers the owners of their own land. All efforts down through the years were directed to making the farmers the owners of their lands, to buy out the landlords and to establish a system whereby a farmer would eventually hold his land freehold. During all those years there was a good deal of talk too about land reclamation, the improvement of the land and the production of more crops in greater quantity off the land. But no real practical step was ever taken towards that end until to-day we have this measure introduced. The work of the Land League was important in giving the farmers ownership of their lands. This measure is no less important and it is as revolutionary to-day as was the Land League in its time. I think the Minister and his officials who worked with him to produce this measure in such a very short time deserve a great share of praise.
Since the establishment of our own Government the problem of land reclamation has only been nibbled at; small grants were given to the farmers to help them to reclaim land, but the grants were so small that they held out no inducement. There was a certain amount of land reclamation done —perhaps an acre or two, or even half an acre. That work was excellent in its way but it was on such a small scale that no lasting impression could be made. This measure aims at giving assistance on a huge scale. If a farmer wants to reclaim useless land, and if he has sufficient help in his own house, he can do the work himself if he has enough labour available to him and be paid for his work. If he does not do the work himself, he will be subject to a very small charge spread over a number of years. That has the effect of reducing the yearly liability for reclamation to little or nothing. I do not think the Opposition should follow Deputy Smith's lead in attempting to block this work.
The acreage of unreclaimed land in this country, without taking into account the type of land which the Minister for Agriculture refers to as being suitable for forestry, must be in the neighbourhood of 4,000,000 acres. If we could, under this measure, in ten years reclaim even half of that land which at the present time is useless and which represents a heavy liability on farmers who have to pay annuities to the Land Commission and rates to the local authority, I think it would be an excellent job. It would be equivalent to placing an additional 2,000,000 acres at the disposal of farmers all over the country. If, in the same period, the Land Commission could afford to relieve congests to the extent of 2,000,000 acres, the Minister for Lands, whoever he might be, and the Land Commission would feel very proud of that achievement. One thing I like about this scheme is that it is definitely labelled a reclamation scheme and not a relief scheme, because while it may give more employment than any of us can visualise at the moment, I think that if it were called a relief scheme it would be hampered very much in execution.
Section 5 appears to have caused a lot of trouble to Deputy Smith. It is undoubtedly a section which gives fairly wide powers to the Minister for Agriculture and the Deputy envisages all kinds of disasters happening unless it is amended in some way. The Minister has agreed to consider any amendment that the Opposition may put forward, but speaking as a farmer, and from my knowledge of agricultural conditions, I feel that I should oppose any amendment of the section as it stands. Deputy Smith must remember how, when he was Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance in charge of the Office of Public Works, he was pressed on many occasions, particularly by farmer Deputies, to take powers in the carrying out of relief works such as are proposed here to-day. There is no doubt that while this measure does give the Minister for Agriculture and his servants power to go in and clear up watercourses without asking the leave of certain farmers, such a measure is absolutely necessary because I think there is not a single rural Deputy who is in any way familiar with this problem who cannot recall certain cases in which five or six, or perhaps ten or 20, farmers have been held up when their lands were flooded and when an application was made to the special employments office to have a main drain opened up. The whole scheme was held up because some crank further down the stream, whose own land happened to be high and dry, refused to allow the scheme to go through. I would ask Deputy Smith to visualise his position if he were Minister for Agriculture and had a request coming in from five, ten or 20 farmers whose farms were situate in a particular pocket of a low-lying valley to have their lands drained and reclaimed. What would happen then if this section were not allowed to stand in its present form? If some farmer further downstream sent in a written objection to the work going through simply from a spirit of churlishness the Minister would have to write back to say that he had no power to authorise the scheme going through. I therefore think that this section is absolutely necessary.
I would be the last Deputy in this House to favour any section which might undermine the rights of the farming community, but we must consider the position that would arise where one crank, simply because he wishes to be awkward, holds up a scheme that would be of immense benefit to ten or 20 of his neighbours whose lands are flooded and who can make no use of that land although they are paying rent and rates for it. I hold that Section 5 does not take away any legitimate rights which a farmer may have. It has been suggested that the Minister may proceed along a big expanse of land with or without machinery. Even if the Minister does want to open up a drain bordering a field in which a crop has been sown, that does not mean that the crop is going to be destroyed. There is always a margin left along such drains which has been used to dump the stuff taken up out of the drain and which is useless for any other purpose. Alternatively, the Minister may decide to wait until the crop is saved and in that way no damage will be done to the crop. Apart from that, the Minister is always in control and I have no doubt that if the section is passed as it stands, and if the Minister or his officials hear of any ganger or foreman who is deliberately damaging crops through wantonness or carelessness, such a ganger would be severely reprimanded and perhaps dismissed and some other man put on the job who will have more consideration for the farmers through whose land the drain runs.
The objections to this section in my opinion are purely frivolous. There is no use in passing a measure of this character and at the same time tying it up in red tape. There is no use in giving a man authority to go ahead with a scheme of this kind if at the same time he is so bound up in red tape that he cannot exercise the powers which you give him. Many measures which the last Government passed in their time were found to be absolutely inoperative because of some foolish clauses of that kind. If we had the reputation of being reckless and of having tried to sweep away all the rights of landowners in the past, I would not blame the Opposition for trying to prevent us getting any extreme power into our hands now and for seeing that we did not simply run amok in operating these clauses, but we are not that kind of Government. If a flaw does appear in the Bill when it comes into operation I am sure that if the Minister brings forward amending legislation, or even if the Opposition sponsors such legislation, it will be considered very favourably.
At one time we were blamed by Deputies on the opposite benches for being too conservative. Now we find we are accused of being reckless and we are told that it is absolutely necessary to enmesh us in bundles of red tape. I think it is very foolish to introduce a Bill, the general principle of which is agreed to be sound, and then so clutter up its provisions with red tape, as to prevent it from being effectively operated. The Government just cannot operate it or let it go into action; it is just like a person in a coffin. I do not see what Deputy Allen has to laugh or sneer about. If he proposes to speak we will hear what he has to say. Deputy Allen's constituents will benefit more from the measure than any other people in Ireland. It is not a measure to laugh at. I say, and repeat it for his benefit, that it is the most revolutionary step that has been taken in this country since the foundation of the Land League. Next to giving farmers the right to own their own land, this is most important as it proposes to reclaim from the water almost half as much as the arable land of this country is reputed to be. It is equally as revolutionary as the Land League's coming forward with its famous three F.s—Fixity of Tenure, Free Sale and Fair Rent. The principal one of those was to make each farmer in this country the owner of his own land. It was looked on as being foolish and wild and it was said that is should never have been attempted, but the bulk of the plain people stood behind it. This measure proposes to steal from the water 4,000,000 acres—4,000,000 of the most productive acres of this country will be taken from the water and given to the farmers. Do not forget that every perch of that land, or practically every perch, will carry an annuity and rates.
I must say that in my part of the country we would welcome the removal of many of the fences which exist. There are many old sodden fences which have become flattened out with time and are now neither a fence nor anything else. They are too low to be a fence and they are taking up good useful room. I hope that as many farmers as possible will take advantage of this scheme to level out those fences which are six, seven or eight feet wide in some cases covering perfectly good land. A simple narrow fence of concrete and wire such as the Minister has described is a perfectly good fence. We are moving towards the day when small gardens and fields will be considered wasteful from the point of view of headlands and fences and while they may have been useful in days gone by, the movement at the present time among farmers is—and the Minister for Agriculture is perfectly safe in this— for larger fields where there is more room to work.
Although the charge is put on the farmer's land there is a safeguard in the fact that the farmer must give his consent. In other words, he must ask for the reclamation scheme to be put into operation on his land. If he cannot carry out the work himself or pay cash down the charge must be put on his land. The amount will be extremely small and, as I said, the farmer is safeguarded.
Comment on this
The last point which Deputy Smith made was that all of the £40,000,000, the sum which the Minister mentioned in public some time ago, should not be spent on the reclamation scheme but that some of it should be spent as a subsidy on fertilisers. There is no scheme which has been brought into this House on which it was not the popular thing to say: "Do not spend all the money on that but spend some of it on something else" and, in my opinion, that is the cheapest form of politics. When something is offered for nothing there are always people anxious to get it and make the best use of it. It is a petty, cheap thing to say for no other reason than to appeal to the very odd farmer —for it is the very odd farmer, in my opinion, who will not benefit by this scheme—who happens to have land perfectly free from scrub and rock with no water-logged fields or any need of field drainage and who happens to want cheap fertilisers. All farmers are getting two tons of ground limestone per acre spread and six cwts. of potassic manure spread on the land which will be reclaimed. There is a side to this measure which was not adverted to either by the Minister or by Deputy Smith, that is that every farmer—and I am speaking particularly for the medium and small farmer —who has waste land on his holding to be reclaimed will have a very big increase in his income when it is done. I know my neighbours in County Mayo and I know that there are very few farmers there, in Galway, in Leitrim or in Roscommon—and they are in Munster and they are in Leinster—and in every county in Ireland who have not six, eight or ten acres which would benefit under the Bill. They have fields which are next to useless to them at the moment. They can use them, perhaps, during the dry months of the summer, but even then they produce only very coarse grass. In most cases these will be the very best land, alluvial soil, and will form probably the richest part of the holding when they are reclaimed, when there is freedom from water and when the owner can go into them at all times of the year. The profit from that reclaimed land should give the farmer more fertilisers and more ground limestone if the land is deficient in lime. The profit the farmer is going to reap off the reclaimed portion of his land will go a long way in a year or two towards putting him on his feet. The first thing the farmer wants is land on which to work and the second thing is that the Government must see that he gets a fair price for his produce. They are the two big things. The present Minister for Agriculture has already seen to it that the farmer is getting a better price than ever before, and the next thing is to help him to clear up, drain and put into production any waste land on his farm.
I would appeal to the other members of the Opposition not to follow the lead set for them by their first spokesman. He made a very poor attempt, and it was not even good criticism. Deputy Smith had to admit that this was a good Bill, but he had to say something against it and I think that is a very poor, shabby, shoddy attitude. I think he would get far more credit, even from his own supporters, if he stood up and said that this is a good measure and, if there were flaws in the drafting, to point them out, but he did not point them out. He hammered at Section 5; he hammered at Section 3 until he found he was wrong. I am an ordinary farmer and I am as anxious to safeguard the rights of farmers as ever Deputy Smith was, but I would oppose any attempt to tie up Section 5 in any red tape. That would be the one thing to block the whole measure. There is no use in bringing in a good Bill and tying it up so that it cannot operate. That has happened too often in the past. I do not want to see this Government, or any Government after us any more than any Government before us, taking away the rights of farmers, but we must consider the odd crank. Thank God he is extremely scarce, but occasionally one meets one crank who, for the sake of awkwardness or through extreme carelessness towards his neighbours, holds them up and causes intense suffering and hardship to perhaps ten or 20 people. The Minister must make up his mind whether he is going to consider that one man's rights or the hardship quite a number of that man's neighbours might suffer as a result of his awkwardness. The objector would suffer nothing or lose nothing by allowing the drain to be done or, in the case of a byroad, by allowing the byroad to be repaired, but he just does not want to see his neighbours getting on. This occurs very seldom and there is often a whole parish without any crank, but where there is a crank we must have a weapon to deal with him. It is unfair that one man should cause serious loss and hardship to a big number of his neighbours as well as a dropping of production over the country.
This is a good measure and I have not the slightest hesitation in recommending it to the House. There cannot be an improvement of it just as it stands and any attempt to amend it will injure it and prevent it from coming to the rescue of the vast number of farmers whom we intend to rescue. There is no danger of this Bill coming into conflict with the forestry programme, and I warn Deputies, as the Minister for Agriculture warned them, that there is no conflict between the two. It would be extremely foolish to try to reclaim the particular type of land that should be devoted to afforestation. In that case, you have nature always there to bring that land back to the heather and to erosion. It is generally in rough mountain-side, country bog and wild land in the valleys between the mountains, and, in my opinion, reclamation would not be the proper way to approach it. My idea would be to use one of the forces of nature, afforestation, to undo the damage that nature has done by heather and erosion in those areas.
As the Minister for Agriculture said when introducing the Bill, the reclamation scheme is intended to start where the land for forestry leaves off. Where the rough land suitable for forestry ends, this reclamation scheme will take up. The two go hand-in-hand and work perfectly together, and one is intended to benefit the other. The present forestry scheme, the proposals in this Bill and the proposals in the Local Authorities (Works) Bill, at present going through the Oireachtas under the Minister for Local Government, are all three working hand-in-hand to bring the extremely waste land under forestry and the semiarable land, at present water-logged, into full production; while the Works Bill, to complete the job, is a good forerunner to the Arterial Drainage Act.
Comment on this
This measure is designed to spend a very considerable sum of money, some £40,000,000, and where it is to come from I do not know. There appears to be a good deal of nervousness about this scheme and Deputy Blowick seemed to resent any criticism of it.
Comment on this
The first business of the Opposition is to know how to criticise and, secondly, it is our duty to do so.
Comment on this
Constructively or otherwise. I am not saying that this is not a reasonably good measure. I believe it is but I think it is an extremely difficult one to work and that it is highly speculative. On the debate dealing with the Estimate for Agriculture, I said that such schemes as this were tried many years ago and for some reason or other they all failed. Some people may say that the failure was due to the economic position of the time, while others may say the schemes were badly constructed, meaning by that that there was no exit for the water.
In County Meath I can visualise some of the schemes the Minister may have to tackle. I suppose the best known river we have in County Meath is the Tolka. It finishes up here in the City of Dublin. It runs through the County Dublin and into the County Meath and drains Tara, Culmullin and that whole district. I suppose it would be 40 or 50 miles long. I do not know how many hundred farmers would have to be dealt with on the way. There are other such rivers there and the same applies to every county. It would be difficult to carry out such a scheme as that with compulsory powers for every farmer, some farmers having 20, 30 or 40 per cent. of their land to be drained and others having none at all. Along the courses of most of these rivers, there are farms that need no draining, while others need quite an amount. I would like to know from the Minister if each statute acre that is drained is liable for this £12, which will be the contribution by the farmer for drainage. If a farmer has 25 acres and there are 12 acres to be drained, the contribution will be fairly heavy.
No doubt we made the way easy for this scheme, first by other such schemes that we had introduced and, secondly, by the halving of the land annuities. For the last year or two, however, the rates have gone up so high that the halving of the land annuities does not mean so much. No matter what we may manage to do, with the high rates and the very considerable increase in annuities in certain cases, we are well back to where we were in the early stages. At the same time, I think this is a good effort; but to say that we should not consider and think out other schemes, that might be more suitable at the moment, is entirely wrong.
There is a good deal in what Deputy Smith says and when the Minister for Agriculture started first here he was very favourable to the scheme that Deputy Smith spoke of. The only difficulty he had in that was the question of getting the money. He confessed quite clearly that it was a question of getting money. The war is over and the fever of high prices is dying down and we are beginning to come back to normal life. Before very long, prices will be at a normal level. We have heard of schemes having become useless because they were not maintained and kept in order, due to economic conditions during the war. If that happens again—as it may happen—this £40,000,000 will be a burden the farmers will find it very hard to bear. They use artificial manure at the moment, as the prices might not evaporate rapidly and they might get some benefit from them. It is quite right that the prices we enjoy at the moment are not going to stick there. Everyone knows that. By the time this scheme is in order, we may have to meet a considerable amount of depression. There is no use in my saying that it will not come: it will come and is coming. Even if it does not come, the keen competition that arises in the British market, and that is rising every day there, will bring prices down to a very low level. Some Deputies may smile, but they do not know what they are smiling about. If they look back to other periods, they will see a period after the first world war when for three or four years everything was booming.
Suddenly, overnight, down came the cloud and everything was darkness, misery, poverty, bankruptcy and so on. Deputy Smith is perfectly right in suggesting other schemes and there is no reason why these other schemes should not be considered. If we are to carry out this scheme merely to get this American loan—and, for all I know, we may be compelled to carry it out—we might be as well off without that loan and working the scheme in other ways. We have been progressing very reasonably with these drainage schemes—small reclamation and rural improvement schemes—and it was from these the Minister got the idea for this scheme. This is a copy of them —it was there he got the inspiration. The Government are rapidly adopting the principles and systems which we had—the only point is that they may be going a little too quickly.
I did not understand exactly from the Minister where this drainage is to start from. I take it that Mr. Holmes and all other authorities on drainage believe in starting at the beginning, and, in the case of the Tolka, I take it that it will have to start in the City of Dublin. That would be only reasonable. It will go from there into the Dublin County Council area and then into the County Meath area. I wonder what difficulties will arise?
Comment on this
I take it they will have to start draining the river in the City of Dublin. What difficulties there are with regard to the contribution of business people who are not paying land annuities I do not know, but it is a river that is doing very considerable damage and has been doing it for years. Because I mention that, I am not to be taken as being crotchety or trying to find snags. I am merely pointing out one of the difficulties which struck me straight away.
Comment on this
Then the Tolka will not be done under this? If it is not, what are we to do? Deputy Giles knows that district well and he will tell us what drainage we can do there. It is hard to see what drainage could be done in all that large area under this scheme. We might make an odd inland lake, but then what would the tenant farmer have to say about it? To be candid, I do not think this is just as simple as the Minister thought. I think there are very considerable snags and that is why I say to the Minister for Lands and Government Deputies that they should not resent criticism. We will all have to carry this baby. Both sides will have responsibility and each side should give the matter full consideration, because it is not just as easy or simple as the Minister tried to persuade us it is.
Comment on this
I welcome this Bill and the ambitious scheme it envisages, but there are a few matters on which I wish to question the Minister. It is easy to understand this scheme in so far as it applies to work to be done by the farmer himself. It is laid down that he will get a contribution of two-thirds of the estimated cost. I must confess, however, that I find myself in difficulties, which I hope the Minister will clear up, as to the position with regard to the man who, possibly through circumstances over which he has no control, may be forced to accept the scheme on the basis of a charge by way of annuity on his land. What contribution does he get by way of a free grant from the State in these circumstances, and to what extent is the amount chargeable as annuity the cost of the actual work? I see a difficulty there which possibly the Minister may clear up for me.
The position may quite reasonably obtain of two holdings adjoining each other, both of which are being operated on by the Department at the request of the farmer and both being chargeable by way of annuity. In one case the work may cost as much as £20 per acre and, in the other, only £14 or £15 per acre. In that case, it seems to me, in so far as the Minister has explained the scheme, the charge by way of annuity on both farms would be £12 per acre and that strikes me, in its first analysis, as rather unreasonable. I should like the Minister to explain to the House in more detail what exactly is the nature or extent of the contribution to be made by way of annuity. Is it a flat rate which all farmers will have to pay, irrespective of what the cost per acre of the reclamation may be? I understand that two-thirds contribution is payable to the man who does the work himself, but that provision does not hold in the case of the man who does not do the work himself.
I urge on the Minister that, whatever about the Bill itself, in the operation of the scheme, he will have to take into account the fact that there may be certain types of work and certain economic circumstances over which particular individuals have no control which may compel them to call in the Department to do the work for them. I do not think that they should suffer any penalty because of that, and in the scheme as outlined by the Minister there seems to be an implied penalty that he will not get by way of State contribution the same consideration as the man who does the work himself. I know perfectly well that it will be argued that this may be an added inducement to get the maximum number of farmers to do the work themselves, but I urge upon the Minister the consideration of people who, for circumstances over which they have no control, may be either not naturally adept enough to do the particular work or so economically situated that, with all the willingness in the world on their part, they will not be able to undertake it.
The Minister will have to consider, possibly not in the manner that Deputy Smith proposed, a principle that I believe in. It may possibly be a fallacy but I have not heard anybody yet who was able to convince me that it is a fallacy. If one of the primary objects of this Bill is reclamation and increase of production, he will have to consider the old maxim that you increase productivity more rapidly by treating good land than you do by endeavouring to bring back into heart waste land that has been waterlogged. There is a good deal of consideration necessary. The suggestions made in a rather crude way by Deputy Smith do merit a certain amount of consideration, that you have the position obtaining under this Bill that it is quite possible that a man by his own industry and earnestness over the last period of years has excluded himself from benefits that might have accrued to him normally under the scheme. By his own efforts he may have brought his land out of the particular type of scrub growth or may have cleared watercourses in such a way as to make land dry that would normally be wet. That man, by his own earnestness, may have excluded himself completely from the benefits of this scheme.
I do think that in a national scheme of this magnitude that drives towards the general betterment of the agricultural community from top to bottom, the Minister will have to consider the case of farmers whose land, even though not wet or in need of clearing of scrub or anything like that, may be in need of very large artificial rehabilitation by way of limestone or phosphates or superphosphates, or anything else that may be necessary for the soil content. He will have to consider the possibility of having a third leg to his general scheme that will enable a grant to be made to them. I do not suggest that the grant should be by way of subsidy. I am a person who shies away from subsidy of artificial manures because I always feel that there may be a certain type of people other than the agricultural community who may gain under such a scheme. His grant should be by way of actual grant of the manures in kind rather than by way of subsidy, and if any subsidy was to be paid for manure it should be paid by way of rebate for actual manure delivered than any other way. I urge the Minister to consider the possibility of devoting certain of this money to help land that is describable as reasonably good to become better because, if the production uptrend is to take place, the most rapid way it can take place is by the consolidation and betterment of what one normally describes as good land.
Let me say in all earnestness that I think all sides of the House welcome the principle and the ambition that are enshrined in this Bill. It shows a good deal of progressive thinking. It aims at something that fundamentally and outside politics we all aim at—making the land of this country better for the people. The Minister has had courage, and possibly he is right, in allowing his sentimental extravagance to bring him back to Mayo on the commemorative date of the founding of the Land League to initiate this scheme there. The gradual development of the Land League led to the ultimate success of the Irish people over the landlord ascendancy and if that spirit were to be inculcated in the effort to be made under the 1949 Land Reclamation Bill, many of our pessimistic outlooks and many of the airy and rather embryonic dangers envisaged by us could be overcome by that spirit that at one time overcame something that nobody conceived could be overcome so quickly. We in our day and in our generation, by taking this Bill in a spirit of earnest endeavour to move forward for the rapid aggrandisement and betterment of our own people on their own land, could make a contribution in a large way comparable with the contribution made by Michael Davitt and his followers. If we do it in that spirit, and not in a spirit of acrimonious politics, ultimate success will be assured and we may claim in our day to have made a real and lasting contribution to the settlement of the land problem.
Comment on this
I, like Deputy Collins, would like to welcome the introduction of this Bill. Possibly the constituency which I represent will benefit very considerably by what is envisaged in the Minister's scheme and in this Bill. It comes very well from a Minister who, I think everyone will agree, no matter what attitude he takes towards problems, certainly always presents things in a big way. This is a big scheme. If we take the trouble to review what writers of history have to tell us of the condition of these lands about 200 years ago and what their research has set out for the information of later generations, we envisage a country which presented an entirely different appearance from the appearance this country presents at the present moment. During the course of those eight or nine generations, owing to the hard work, industry and skill of the tenant farmers, vast areas of unproductive land were won into production for the first time.
You can take, I think, an example from the geographical layout of the City of Dublin at the present moment. When we realise that at one time the waters of the sea lapped Merrion Square, that Beggar's Bush was at one time an island, and that Trinity College was more or less situated on an island, we can then understand what human energy, properly directed and properly subsidised, can accomplish. Taking a long-term view of this scheme, I believe it is one of the greatest factors for the prosperity of this country that any Government or any Minister has yet envisaged. We, I think, would do well in the infancy of our State to study the doings of those countries in the economic sphere who, for century after century, have had their own individuals in control of their own destinies. We can look, I think, with admiration on the doings of the inhabitants of the Low Countries who not only brought infertile lands into fertility but even won land back from the bosom of the sea. Acres upon acres in the Low Countries were won back by human endeavour under the wise leadership and guidance of home Governments. One of the recognised decisive sea battles of the world which was fought several centuries ago—the battle of the sluys— was fought at a place which is now 12 miles inland on the boundary between Belgium and Holland. What those people could do, with the disadvantages under which they were suffering, we, I think, would be able to do in this country. I welcome this scheme because it recognises that in our Irish land we have the real prosperity at the hands of our people. I welcome this scheme because it is a form of giving to the community who own the land the resources of credit which should be at their hand. Roughly speaking, I see the scheme as this. If I, as an industrious farmer, have a corner of my farm which requires reclamation, fencing or draining, or something of that kind, and am prepared to put down £1, the paternal Government is prepared to put down £2 to match it. That seems to me to be the scheme in a nutshell.
We have in the layout of our farms in this country what we refer to as "headlands" around the fields. I think that is a general expression throughout Ireland. I wonder, if a census were taken of the total amount of land in this country which is included in what we describe as "headland", how much that acreage would be. When I see the mechanics of this scheme—where hedging and ditching is considered—I believe we will not only win back whole infertile fields but also a large proportion of the headlands which are now a breeding ground for every kind of weed and pest that agriculture has from year to year to fight against.
Reference was made here by the Minister that he thought that possibly there would be a contest between himself as Minister for Agriculture representing the farm lands on the one hand and the Minister for Lands representing the forestry lands on the other hand. It has always been recognised that the highest form of agriculture has these two types of land side by side. According to climate or local conditions, it is necessary to have well-planted timber lands beside ordinary arable farming lands. Again, anyone who has had the experience of going through the great Northern Plain of Europe and of looking out through the windows of a train will have seen first of all a neatly drilled—almost, you would think, dusted with dusters— wood and then immediately after that a patch of arable land, and so forth. I hope that when these two schemes— the scheme of the Minister for Agriculture and the scheme of the Minister for Lands—are brought to their final conclusion we shall see in or around our countryside these neatly growing groves of timber and these well-regulated farmlands. This is a scheme which recognises the absolute necessity for increasing the productivity in general of this country. It is a scheme that should commend itself to every Irishman who believes in the economic future of this country.
Deputy O'Reilly, I do not know whether it was intended to be by way of criticism or for some other purpose, mentioned the American European Recovery Plan and the loan which it was intended we should get under that plan. I cannot see that it matters very much where this money is going to come from. I believe that if this money is produced it is going into good hands. It is going into the hands of those who can boast—when we get into conversation with them—"My family has been on this little farm for seven or eight or nine generations" or on "this big farm" as the case may be. Its primary object is to spend money on increasing the productivity of this State. In the course of doing so, it does no person harm and it does an immense amount of good. It raises productivity, it increases fertility and it creates employment. It gives us a proper appreciation of the resources of our State and of the neglect of those resources. I believe it will bring us together, working in a happy combination of co-operation. It will bring us together in the full realisation that what really matters in this country, the extra bit of wealth, we can with our own energy, our intelligence and resources win from our native soil.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture and his spokesman, the Minister for Lands, told us at great length about this revolutionary measure and about all they hope it will achieve for the country. We can join with them in the hope that it will achieve all that they visualise it may achieve. I think everyone, without exception, in the whole of rural Ireland will have the same hopes for it. This Bill is by no means a revolutionary Bill. There is nothing revolutionary in it so far as I can see. It proposes to give authority to the Minister for Agriculture to do certain things—(1) to carry out certain work on agricultural holdings, (2) to charge that farmer's land with certain burdens for the future and (3) under Section 5, which has been subject to adverse criticism from this side of the House, to go in on any farmer's land he wishes, without the farmer's authority and without serving any notice on that farmer.
Comment on this
The Deputy, when he is speaking, can tell us otherwise. Section 5, as I read it, is as follows:—
"The Minister may, where it appears to him to be necessary for the adequate reclamation of any land under any works being carried out by him, clear or repair a watercourse, and, for this purpose, shall, by his servants and agents, have access to the watercourse and may proceed along its banks with or without machinery in so far as appears to him to be necessary so as to render it capable of carrying waters that should normally pass through it, and may dispose of the spoil in such manner as he thinks fit."
That section to my mind is a revolutionary one in view of the pronouncements made by the Minister for Agriculture in this House and in the country that never in future will any servant or agent of the Minister attempt to cross a farmer's fence without the invitation of the farmer. I hope he will amend this section to require at least that notice will be served on the farmer that it is necessary to trespass on his land and make some provision, if crops are damaged or fences knocked down, for compensating the farmer. No one on this side of the House has any objection to the Minister's being given power to enter on any land to clean up watercourses or rivers, but the owner of the land is at least entitled to the courtesy of a notice being served upon him or his being told that his land is about to be trespassed on, even if it is for essential and necessary work.
With regard to Section 3—payment of occupier's contribution by means of annuity—the principle of charging lands for work done is a new principle and, if you like, a revolutionary principle.
Comment on this
It is a revolutionary principle from the point of view of putting an extra burden on a holding for all time.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the Bill to say that even the Land Commission are to be satisfied that the land on which it is proposed to put this extra burden is capable of bearing the extra burden.
Comment on this
Under that sub-section nothing can be done except at the request of the occupier of the land.
Comment on this
The occupier of the land is oftentimes not the best judge of the burden his land is capable of bearing.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture is not the person to judge that. The Land Commission who are responsible for the charges on the land in the way of land annuities are the responsible people in that respect. I think it is a great weakness in the Bill that the Land Commission are not to be consulted as to the charges which may be put on the land in future. It is all very well for Deputies to say that it is with the consent and on the application of the particular farmer. That is so, but that does not mean that it is always desirable to put heavy extra charges on an agricultural holding. It must be remembered that these charges which it is proposed to put upon it will have priority over all other charges.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy will be able to tell us about what everything means. He is an encyclopedia full of knowledge on all matters.
Comment on this
Your store is overflowing. The principle of adding to the existing annuity on land is one which should be seriously considered. There may be a holding the greater portion of which may need reclamation. The charge of £12 per acre for reclamation may be greater than the actual market value of the holding. Instead of being an advantage to the farmer, it may prove to be a blister upon him. I, therefore, think the section needs amendment so that a certificate from the Land Commission will have to be produced before the Minister can proceed to spend money on a particular holding. There may be many charges against a holding which the farmer has not been able to discharge, charges by the Agricultural Credit Corporation or other charges. That is an aspect which should be taken into consideration in respect of a particular holding. I consider that it is a serious matter.
There are many holdings also which may require a new dwelling-house or to have the dwelling-house and out-offices reconditioned. The farmer may have to go to some bank or credit corporation to obtain money for that purpose or he may have to charge his holding with other burdens. Because the land annuities were halved some years ago, it is a temptation to the Minister for Agriculture to increase an annuity to what it was originally. Spending £20, £30 or £60 upon a particular holding may not be economic. Every rural Deputy is aware that there are many holdings which need rehabilitation and drainage but which, after a big amount of money has been spent upon them, will go back in a year or two to their former state. A big lot of this £40,000,000 which there is so much talk about may be spent unwisely. If you spend £40,000,000 on the boglands and the mountains, I am afraid it will pay a very poor dividend.
Comment on this
I will not suggest anything. I wonder if the Minister has given this matter full consideration? I admit that there are areas and holdings that would benefit to a great extent from drainage but not all the land that needs drainage would prove to be economical. You could spend far more money on draining an acre of land than the acre would be worth for the following 30 years. I hope that full and deliberate consideration from all aspects has been given to this by the Government before it was fully embarked on. If £40,000,000 is available it must be the primary intention in spending that money to improve the agricultural income of the whole community. I am very much afraid that if all that money is spent in the direction indicated the resulting increase in income will be very small. We all want to see an increased income coming from the land but it is very doubtful that this scheme will do that. I cannot see how it could if it is only going to be started in eight counties this year.
Many people wonder why the Minister for Agriculture could not have started without any legislation in the whole Twenty-Six Counties. There was nothing to prevent him. He told us today that he had started in eight counties on the scheme that the farmers will carry out themselves. He has the machinery of the farm improvements scheme which is about ten years in operation now. He has many officers in his service who are capable of carrying that scheme into operation in the whole of the Twenty-Six Counties at the same time, with voluntary grants on the same basis as the farm improvements scheme was carried out over the last ten years. If he wanted to double the grants or increase them in any way and if he wanted to extend the scheme to provide for manuring or anything else, he needs no legislation whatever. He has power under the existing law to do all that. If, by degrees, it was found that there were many holdings where farmers could not carry out the work themselves this Bill could have been brought gradually into operation as the demand came from the people.
The farm improvements scheme was popular. An effort was made by the Minister for Agriculture, owing to the lateness of inviting applications, to have no work done at all last year. Sometime about Christmas I remember I asked the Minister a Parliamentary Question. I was told that in County Wexford out of about 400 or 500 applications only about 40 had been dealt with by that time. It was quite obvious to everyone that the Minister's intention was to kill that scheme.
Comment on this
It was his intention to kill that scheme. It must be remembered that he is not replacing it in the present year by any other scheme in other than eight counties. I want to appeal to the Minister to reconsider that matter. He should extend the scheme whereby the farmers are going to carry out the work themselves automatically through the whole Twenty-Six Counties. He can increase the grants and widen the scope of the scheme in any direction he likes. He has the skilled personnel for the carrying out of that scheme and there should be no cause for delay.
The Minister has been talking for the last three months about the £40,000,000 that he is going to spend on the bog lands, the lands that need drainage and on land rehabilitation. I think that is an unfair scheme in this way. All the farmers of the country— and they are the big majority—whose lands need no drainage whatever will have to contribute to the repayment of that loan. They are getting nothing towards increasing their income in any way. I want to suggest to the Minister, side by side with what Deputy Smith suggested, that there is no reason why half that money should not be spent each year in making artificial manures and ground limestone half the price they are at the present. Every farmer would benefit in that way.
The income of agriculture and the output from each farm in the country is bound to increase immediately. There is no guarantee under the scheme proposed by the Minister that there will be any immediate increase whatever. I certainly do not believe there will, but I am hoping for the best. I cannot see, and no practical person from a rural area with a practical knowledge of agriculture can see, that there is going to be an immediate benefit. It may benefit individuals to a small extent. A great number of farmers are in occupation of lands that need no drainage but they need artificial manure and limestone and they have not the capital for that. The cost of that would be, as the Minister has estimated, a minimum of £5 per acre. Every farmer in the country will have to contribute to the repayment of this £40,000,000 when the Minister has spent it. Each farmer is entitled to a share of that £40,000,000 as I have suggested.
Comment on this
You can get the manure where you like. You can set up the Minister as a manufacturer of manure in this country if you like. You can compensate those manure owners——
Comment on this
——and make them a State-owned concern in the morning. The Government can deal with them as they think fit. The manure ring will then be cut out from any question of profits. I think it is unjust of the Minister for Agriculture or any other Minister to hold up to public odium in this country any group of people engaged in industry or otherwise when the Minister for Industry and Commerce has absolute power by law to limit the profits in any industry in this country. He can impose profit restrictions on any group in existence in the country. I think it is time, in the interests of ordinary decency, that any group engaged in industry or any group of farmers or business people and so forth was let alone and not held up to public odium. The Minister has made a fad of it all, over the years. He had the bacon curers and the millers and now he has the manure ring as he calls them. God knows whom he will have to-morrow morning. These are all decent citizens of the country who have set up in industries and put their energy, brains and everything else into it.
Comment on this
That type of loose talk in this country has done more damage in the last 12 months than anything the Coalition did.
Comment on this
Let State enterprise manufacture artificial manures and quarry limestone and leave out the manure ring. We will not object to that. I want again to stress the importance of this, that the Minister should see that, from this fund of £40,000,000, at least 50 per cent. of it would be used each year to subsidise both ground limestone and artificial manures.
Comment on this
No matter the price at which these manures are available, or how much we bring down their price?
Comment on this
The Minister must know that the price of artificial manures went up last year and that it has gone up again in the last month.
Comment on this
I am not concerned about that but I am concerned with the price the farmer has to pay for them. The price of artificial manures was increased on two occasions within the last year.
Comment on this
I am sure you are not very much concerned, one way or the other. Artificial manures are so dear at the moment that they are beyond the reach of many farmers, and so they are not using them in the quantities that their land requires.
Comment on this
I want to have them made available at a cheaper price per ton than they are at the present time.
Comment on this
By subsidising them and by making them cheaper by any subvention that you like. I do not mind so long as they are made cheaper for the farmer who has to buy them. I do not mind what machinery the Minister uses so long as he does that. The same applies to ground limestone. The Minister knows the price at which ground limestone is available when spread on a farmer's farm at the moment. He knows that it needs from two to three tons of ground limestone per statute acre, and that 95 per cent. of the land that needs ground limestone needs superphosphates as well. The price is £5, £6 or £7 per statute acre. It is not possible for farmers, out of their resources at the present time, to provide sufficient quantities of ground limestone and artificial manures, at their present prices, for use on their land. I hope the Minister will give serious consideration to that aspect of the matter.
It is estimated that 4,000,000 acres of land are in need of drainage and rehabilitation. Are we to take that to mean 4,000,000 acres out of the 12,000,000 arable acres, or 4,000,000 acres out of the 17,000,000 acres in the whole country? If we are to take it that it means four out of 12, that will leave us with 8,000,000 acres that need no drainage or rehabilitation. Unless the Minister is prepared to subsidise and cheapen the price of artificial manures, that means that the occupiers of these 8,000,000 acres are going to get no benefit from the expenditure of this £40,000,000, while as taxpayers they are going to be called upon to contribute towards the repayment of that loan.
Comment on this
The occupiers of the 8,000,000 acres, whose land needs no rehabilitation, are entitled to some portion of this money. If they can get artificial manures at a cheaper price, their land will give a greater response and there will be an immediate increase in the total output for the agricultural pool. It is very doubtful if there will be any increase in the agricultural pool from the type of land that the Minister proposes to drain, bogland or mountain land. There is nothing wrong in draining that land, but I do not think it is desirable to spend the whole of the £40,000,000 a year on it. Portion of that money should be spent on the better-class land that needs no other capital outlay except manures.
With regard to sub-section (4) (a) of Section 2 I suggest to the Minister that the section should be worded in the opposite way from the way in which it is worded. I do not think there is any need for the use of the word "default".
Comment on this
It says that "Unless the occupier, in accepting the Minister's proposal, informs the Minister that he wishes to pay his contribution by means of an annuity" and so on. It could easily happen that a farmer did not inform the Minister at the time he made the application that he wished to pay it by means of an annuity.
Comment on this
I do not think there should be any question of a default in payment at that stage. While the Minister was out, I stressed the point that provision should be made in the Bill to enable the Land Commissioners to decide whether the amount that the Minister proposed to charge in respect of a particular holding was economic or not.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not be using the second person so often and should address the Chair.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it not contrary to the rules of order to repeat what one has said three or four times in the same hour? I submit that Deputy Allen is now repeating what he said half an hour ago, and that it is being done for the purpose of obstructing the business of the House.
Comment on this
I object to that. Every Deputy has a right to speak here, and the Chair is the judge of whether I am obstructing or not, and not the Minister. If the Minister wants to start the same tactics as he adopted last week——
Comment on this
If the Minister wants to start the tactics that he indulged in last week, when he interrupted almost 200 times inside an hour, he can do so.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not repeat what he said when the Minister was out. It is not necessary for the Minister to be here to listen to what the Deputy has to say.
Comment on this
I hope he will listen to what I have to say. As regards Section 2, I suggest that when the Minister is informing an occupier of land what his contribution is, he should also inform him, if he proposes to accept the loan from the Land Commission, what the annual charge will be. I think that section should be amended. The occupier is entitled to know what the extra charge in his annuity will be. It is important for the farmers, in addition to knowing the bulk charge, to know what will be the charge if this is added to the annuity.
The Bill provides two outstanding things: it enables the Minister to place extra burdens on a farmer's land and it enables him to go in on a farmer's land. There is no reasonable objection to either of those things. An amount of useful work can be done. An amount of useful work could be done in the Twenty-Six Counties without this Bill. It could be done under the farm improvements scheme if the Minister will allow the machinery connected with that scheme to operate in the coming year as it operated in the past year.
Comment on this
I want to support this Bill because I think it is a good Bill, a courageous Bill and a farsighted Bill. It is something that will probably be referred to in the country as another subsidy for the farmers, but I must take this opportunity of saying that it is nothing of the kind. It is an effort to increase the national wealth through the principal source of national wealth that we have, and that is the land. In every effort to do that the farmers are paying their share. They will reap a certain amount of benefit, but the nation as a whole will reap the major benefit. I hope we will not have this scheme referred to throughout the country as another subsidy for the farmers. I deny emphatically that it is anything of the kind.
There are a number of matters in the Bill on which I am not quite clear and I would like the Minister to give us some information with regard to them. So far as I can see from the descriptions given in Section 1, emphasis is laid on drainage and the improvement of hill and mountain grazing. There is mention of land reclamation and the Minister has told us that that is capable of very wide interpretation. I hope it is, and I hope the Minister will give it the interpretation that I and a number of other Deputies who know rural Ireland would like to give it.
We know that all over the country for a number of years, due to certain things that happened—the agricultural depression that started at the end of 1920 and carried on to the 30's, and also the economic war — farmers generally were impoverished. They were unable to keep their land in a proper state of fertility. There were numbers of farmers who had no money for fertilisers and they were not able to do their farming operations properly. We know they were selling milk for 3d. a gallon and killing calves for their skins. They were absolutely unable to carry on farming in the way they would like to. They had to do a certain amount of soil mining in order to eke out any sort of existence. Then, when they were just about recovering, the world war came and there was a shortage of fertilisers.
But, even though these farmers had no money, they had ability and energy and plenty of muscle and a willingness to work and during that period they cleared the drains on their farms and the furze out of the hillside fields. They had not anything to put fertility back into the land. It might appear from the emphasis on drainage in this Bill that these people are to be sacrificed in favour of people who sat down and did nothing, who did not exert themselves or utilise their energies during all that time.
The Minister has suggested that one-third of the cost will be paid by the owner of the land and two-thirds will be paid by the Department. He also said that the payment on the part of the landowner would be £12 per acre. If my mathematics are correct, the cost of reclaiming an acre will be £36. If the farmer pays £12 per acre and the State pays two-thirds, then one-third of the cost represents £12 and the cost of draining the acre would be £36.
Comment on this
The two-thirds calculation applies to the other leg of the scheme where the farmer does it himself.
Comment on this
In that case the cost of draining an acre would be £30. I think a good deal of the land, and probably the land that will prove most expensive to drain, will not be worth £30 an acre. The Minister for Lands, in answer to a question here, said he was paying at the rate of £3 8s. per acre for land for forestry. I do not think the Land Commission paid anything like £30 or £36 for the land they bought in the past ten years. The point I am trying to make is that there are people who cleaned the drains and kept the furze out of their land because they were energetic and not afraid to work and these people will be ruled out of this scheme while those who did nothing will avail of it—people who, after having their fields drained for them and the furze rooted out of their land, will allow the drains again to become clogged and the furze to grow once more. I want the Minister to take my interpretation of land reclamation and not his interpretation in applying it merely to drainage and the reclamation and improvement of mountainy or hilly land. When the Minister was speaking to this Bill he referred to the Land Commission and he said that the Land Commission would be asked to add the charge on to the annuity and carry out the work. I was rather confused there because shortly afterwards——
Comment on this
The Deputy misheard. I said the Land Commission would collect the annuity, not that it would carry out the work.
Comment on this
I am clear on that point now. I would like to know what the rate of interest charged by the Land Commission will be.
Comment on this
The Minister said a good deal about conditions of work and agricultural employment. He said that he would turn the farms into factories. He was not too happy about the man who uses a pick and shovel, but the Minister should realise that in this country where the majority of the farms are small the shovel and the pick and the grafán are essential implements and the man who wields the shovel and the pick and the grafán is entitled to as much respect as the man who drives the bulldozer. I think that on the smaller farms, and even on the bigger farms where one wants to fix the drills at the end of the headlands in order to fight the nettles to which the Minister referred, we must also have the shovel and the pick.
I think the Minister did intend to say something about the organisation of the scheme. He did touch upon it but he did not develop it at any great length. I think that in a big scheme where one intends to expend the colossal sum of £40,000,000 one must set up some definite organisation to deal with such a scheme. The Minister gave us no indication and no inkling good, bad or indifferent as to what type of organisation it would be. He did not tell us whether there would be any liaison between the Board of Works and the Land Commission. He did not tell us whether any steps would be taken to prevent overlapping. I am interested to discover what type of organisation this will be. I would suggest that some kind of board, such as the Electricity Supply Board, should be responsible for this scheme.
The Minister referred also to grass seeds and the different strains of grass seeds which are being evolved in the seed-producing stations. That is a very desirable activity and I think it is something which should be incorporated as part of this scheme. Seeds should be made available at a reasonable price for the reseeding of land that is reclaimed. I think the Minister knows that I have as little love for the sulphuric acid cartel or any other combine as he has himself. I think it should be possible, however, either through some new organisation or through the organisation which is at the moment importing phosphates very successfully, despite a good deal of opposition——
Comment on this
It should be possible to import sufficient quantities of these phosphates, outside the control of the cartels or the rings. The Minister should then arrange with Córas Iompair Éireann to carry these at a flat rate of 5/- per ton for delivery to any part of the country from the port of entry. I suggest the soil survey should be developed still further and where a survey or a soil analysis shows there is a definite deficiency of some important mineral element that land should also be brought within the scope of this scheme. I do not suggest that the farmers who own these lands should get their lime or phosphate free, but they should get them supplied as cheaply as possible and be given every encouragement plus any technical advice they may require to discover what is absent from the land. I know the Minister has done a great deal in providing these soil facilities over the past year, but they are still quite inadequate.