We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Reclamation Bill, 1949—Second Stage.

Contributions 207–415 of 415. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Reclamation Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 15 of 1949 ›

When this scheme develops the present facilities will be incapable of meeting the requirements. I suggest that the Minister should include holdings which show a soil deficiency in this scheme. Many holdings are starved of fertility because of factors outside the control of the farmers. They are starved because of the depression due to the economic war and other factors. If these holdings are included the present facilities will be inadequate. These are matters to which I would like the Minister to direct his attention. I would appeal to him again to interpret land reclamation in the broadest possible way and not narrow it down to drainage or the reclamation of mountainy or hilly grazing.

Comment on this

At a time when there is such an urgent need for an increased food supply, not only for our own people but for the people of Europe, this House should welcome any scheme which is designed to increase the area of food-producing land in the country. The scheme is a broad one. It is a far-reaching one. Let us not swallow the idea which the urban Press has sought to impose upon us that this is a relief scheme and that the farmers are getting something for nothing. Let us not believe that this scheme is something similar to a State scheme to improve a shopkeeper's shop or his fittings. It is nothing of the kind. It is not designed to increase the wealth of the average farmer. It is designed to increase the wealth of the nation as a whole for the ultimate benefit of the nation as a whole. As far as the average farmer who benefits by this scheme is concerned the contribution which he is called upon to make—that is, one-third of the cost — is the approximate value of the scheme to the farmer. For example, if a farmer pays £12 to the State for reclaiming an acre of bog it is not by any means certain that the improvement of that acre of bog will be worth more than £12 to that farmer. Therefore it is not the farmer who is benefiting by this scheme; it is the nation that is benefiting and, of course, it is the nation that should pay for it.

Some Deputies have compared this reclamation scheme with the farm improvements scheme. I do not think the comparison is altogether unfair. The farm improvements scheme when initiated was a bold and useful scheme. Even the Minister on one occasion, indeed on several occasions, paid a glowing tribute to that scheme. The comparison sought to be made between the farm improvements scheme and the present land reclamation project is a comparison between the annual cost of the scheme and a scheme in which £40,000,000 is to be invested. The real comparison is that under the farm improvements scheme the farmer was entitled to receive only 50 per cent. of the labour cost, not 50 per cent. of the total cost, whereas under this scheme the farmer will get two-thirds of the total cost. That is a far-reaching advance and let us recognise it. I do not think that Deputy Smith in his approach to the Bill was unfair to the measure or unduly critical. As an Opposition Deputy, he sought to point out the weaknesses and the flaws in the Bill, as is the duty of an Opposition Deputy, and beyond that he was reasonably fair to the measure. The measure is a good one. It is a far-reaching and beneficial scheme which will confer enormous benefits on the nation, if properly carried out. There are, of course, difficulties which will be certain to arise in its administration. The Bill before the House is a very simple measure but the scheme when implemented will be anything but simple. It is a scheme which will require the utmost care in preparation, in the organisation required and in the general administration of the whole project.

The Minister was right when he said that it is not a relief scheme so far as the workers are concerned. I do not think that any useful work in which men are engaged, and in which they give a useful return for their wages, can be regarded as relief work or should be regarded as relief. If unemployed men are sent to repair a road, to make a footpath, to lay down a sewer or any work of that kind they are doing useful work for the nation. In the same way, if unemployed men are employed on this scheme they need not suffer the humiliation of being described as receiving relief. They can hold their heads high as they are contributing to the benefit of the nation. Similarly, the farmer who cooperates with the Department in carrying out this scheme can also hold up his head and let nobody suggest for one moment that he is a recipient of State aid. Nothing I think could be more harmful to the general morale of our people than to have it broadcast that a large section of the community, the farmers, are receiving State aid.

The scope of this Bill is fairly wide and I am in complete agreement with those Deputies, including the last speaker, Deputy Lehane, who pointed out the necessity for having its scope widened a little further. You can divide the land of this country into three types. You have wet land or hilly land that requires drainage or reclamation, and good land that is producing the average, or over the average production, in the way of crops or pastures. In between these types there is the marginal land that is dry and sound but which is deficient in lime and phosphates and which, because of that very great deficiency, is incapable of producing crops sufficient to make a profit for the farmer or in fact sufficient even to pay the workers engaged in tilling the land and cultivating the crops. I want to ask the Minister is it not possible to extend the scheme to cover such land. Take, for example, a man who has 60 statute acres. Twenty acres of that is bog and he will be induced to spend £12 per acre on these 20 acres— a total of £240. He has also 20 acres of good land and a third 20 acres which is dry and sound but which is producing very little. There is no inducement in this Bill, no encouragement and no assistance to that farmer to do anything in regard to that marginal land which could with a very small expenditure be brought into a high state of production.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy this question? If a farmer has 20 acres of what he describes as marginal land, and he puts upon it fertilisers which will make it highly productive, we may assume that when the harvest comes that highly productive land will be remunerative. He will then have out of the yield of the crops, the price of the fertilisers and a profit for himself. Why, in the name of commonsense, should the State pay to fertilise the soil if what the Deputy says is true, that these 20 acres with the application of fertilisers will give him in the harvest a profit to pay for the fertilisers?

Comment on this

Now we come to the point where the Minister has made a mistake. I think it is a fundamental mistake and I raised this matter on a number of occasions. If land is really impoverished, if it is the type of land which I have described, land which has no real fertility, it will take some years to bring that land back into maximum production. It will require a very considerable expenditure, both in regard to lime and phosphates in order to make it productive and there is no chance whatever that the land would repay the cost of the manures within one year. I know what I am speaking about. I know that type of land which is to be found all over Wicklow and in other parts of Leinster. The farmer who owns that type of land could not think of putting into it the amount of capital which would bring it up to the maximum state of fertility. He would not have the capital in the first place and in the second place he could not hope to get repayment within any reasonable time. I want to know if anything can be done for that type of land. Surely there ought to be some way in this sort of scheme to help that type of farmer. The Minister has said in connection with this scheme that he will help the man who is going to purchase machinery for drainage with a loan of one-third of the cost and a grant of one-third of the cost. Would it be too much to ask the Minister to make the same approach to help the man, such as Deputy Lehane described, whose land is below a certain margin of fertility? Would it not be well to provide him with a loan of one-third of the cost and a grant of one-third of the cost? That, I think, would be a reasonable approach to this very difficult problem. It is a thing that must be faced because there are millions of acres of such land. The Minister can see them when he travels the roads, lands where the pasture is white. It appears all right, perhaps, to a person travelling the roads, but if you go in and examine it in summer when the grass should be green you will find that there is no good grass at all. Yet it is dry and potentially good agricultural land. The time has come to bring that 1,000,000, 2,000,000 acres or whatever amount there is of this land up to the maximum fertility and productivity, for that is the way to get an immediate expansion in agricultural production.

Many bogs if they were properly drained would become very productive.

Comment on this

Who is talking about bogs?

Comment on this

We can refer to wet land as bogs if we like; after all, what is the difference? In the Minister's Connaught English there may be some distinction, but as far as I am concerned wet land is boggy land. I have seen such wet lands drained and made very productive. I have seen land which was formerly regarded as bog producing as much as 20 barrels of wheat to the acre. That is true. It can be done, if not in all cases. There are bogs, as the Minister says, and bogs. There is land which even with the most intensive draining cannot be made very productive and I believe that a certain amount of land will be treated under the scheme which will not give as high production as we hope. Generally, the scheme will be to the benefit of agriculture and of the nation, but you will get a very much greater return and in a much shorter time by bringing up that type of land I have described to maximum productivity, the impoverished but dry land.

There are other aspects of the Bill on which the Minister in replying will perhaps enlighten us. There is a question to which the Minister, I think, referred in an interruption, the time for the repayment of the loans. The period is, I understand, 60 years and I think that is a reasonable period. They will, I think, be availed of to a very considerable extent. There are a large number of farmers in this country who cannot find the necessary capital to undertake work of reclamation themselves and who must depend on the State to provide it. In this connection I want to point out to the Minister that it is rather a strange thing that the State is prepared to provide credit facilities to reclaim wet or mountain land and that it will not provide similar credit facilities to improve, re-equip and re-stock the better land. The Minister has a very able and active mind, but on the question of credit for agriculture he appears to have encased it in a dough of concrete that an atomic bomb could scarcely penetrate. As he has agreed to provide credit on a long term for the one specific purpose of improving agricultural land, I hope he will extend that activity. I can envisage, now that the thin edge of the wedge is inserted, that there will be certain Deputies who will continue to hammer that wedge until adequate capital is provided to bring agriculture to its maximum productivity. There is no reason why the State should provide credit on a long term for the improvement of what I described as bog and what the Minister described as wet land and at the same time refuse credit facilities for more productive and even more useful purposes.

A very useful point was made by Deputy Allen. Although I would like to repeat it, repetition unfortunately is not allowed, but I would like to underline it because I think it is a point which the Minister may have overlooked in drafting the scheme. A farmer can borrow up to £12 per acre for reclamation. He can incur that amount of debt, but it might happen that such a large percentage of his land would require reclamation that he might be tempted to borrow more than his farm could actually carry. I have always advocated credit, but I have never believed it desirable for any man to borrow more than 50 per cent. of the market value of his holding. I think the Minister will agree with me that if 90 per cent. of a man's farm needed reclamation—and there are farms of that type—and if he borrowed £12 on every acre, he might burden that farm beyond what it could reasonably carry. That would be undesirable and it is a point which should be looked into.

Comment on this

Would you leave him on the bog?

Comment on this

It is a problem that will have to be solved. You would have to do one of two things. If you found that the amount of money would be too great a burden to place on the holding you might have to reduce the amount of the contribution per acre in that particular case or else reclaim only a certain portion of the land. Some means can be found out of the difficulty I am sure.

The Minister in introducing the scheme did not refer to the financing of it, but I am to assume, however, that a Supplementary Estimate will be introduced to provide the necessary money to carry it out throughout the coming year. I would not expect it would be possible by any stretch of the imagination or by any stretch of activity on the part of the Minister's Department to spend £4,000,000 in the first year. The House is entitled to know how this money is being raised by the Government, what it is costing and what the terms of repayment are.

I would like the Minister to say, when replying, if adequate equipment is available to carry out the scheme in the most efficient way, not only the mechanical excavators and other equipment but the necessary piping for field drainage. This is important, as there are many areas where field drainage can be carried out with stone, which is plentiful, while there are other areas where no stone of any kind is readily available and where the farmer—or the Department, if carrying out the scheme—will have to depend on pipes. That is really a matter of administration, but nothing would be more undesirable than that the scheme should be launched and a certain number of acres reclaimed by methods which are not of the highest standard of efficiency. We want the scheme carried out not only quickly but in the most efficient way.

I trust the Minister will find a way to deal with the 3,000,000 or 4,000,000 acres of marginal land to which I have referred. There must be some way of dealing with it. The farmer cannot do it himself. The State could assist the farmer, if the Government is willing, and the return is certain to give ample repayment for any effort or expenditure.

Regarding the provision of long-term credit under this scheme, the farmer is to be given a loan of £12 per acre over a period of 60 years. Every time I raised this question of credit here, the Minister always referred to "credit-worthy farmers". I take it that under this scheme there will be no reference to the credit-worthiness or otherwise of the farmer. I take it that the money will be provided on the security and value of the holding, not on the personal merits or demerits of the farmer. If we are to get back to the old groove of the credit-worthiness of the farmer. I am afraid the scheme will be greatly hampered, just as the scheme of the Agricultural Credit Corporation was hampered.

The Minister referred in his opening statement to the great work achieved by Michael Davitt when he succeeded in initiating a movement which led to the purchase of the land from the landlords and the establishment of the farmer as owner. But that scheme was based on credit to the farmer, not on the farmer's personal credit-worthiness. The average farmer at that time, according to ordinary banking standards, would not pass any test of credit-worthiness. That scheme was based on a belief in the farmers as a body and upon the value of the land that was purchased; and it justified itself immeasurably in the years that followed.

Comment on this

That is the very last example I would care to draw down just at present.

Comment on this

Does the Minister claim that the farmers failed in their obligations to the State in regard to the land annuities?

Comment on this

To the tune of 50 per cent., which was remitted under the Land Act of 1933.

Comment on this

That was an international question in which the farmers themselves were not involved.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not arise on this measure.

Comment on this

As far as that is concerned, they fulfilled their obligations and if farmers are treated in the same way again as they were under that scheme and as they should be treated under an extension of this scheme, they will fulfil their obligations as creditably as they did under other schemes for the purchase of the land from the landlords.

Comment on this

In his opening statement, the Minister invited Deputies from all parts of the House to join in the debate and put him some questions on any matters which may not appear to be clear. I gladly accept that invitation. There are a couple of matters to which I wish to refer briefly and obtain, if possible, the necessary information from the Minister. I might be pardoned if I take what may be considered a narrow point of view, but I seek information as to the basis on which the order of priority has been chosen. If I remember rightly, the Minister named all the counties one by one along the coast, including Connaught and Munster, with one exception—Clare.

Comment on this

Galway and Clare.

Comment on this

I think it is in operation in Galway since last year, as one of the first counties. However, apart from my natural interest, I would like the Minister to explain how these counties are to fare. In County Clare — and, as the Minister adds, Galway—is the necessary machinery not available there that was available elsewhere, or why was it that this order was selected? In Clare, the Minister will be up against a different problem from that of any other county. He said that under this scheme he hoped to drain and reclaim every acre of land in Ireland — at least, in the Twenty-Six Counties. He did claim that that was what he was going to do. I doubt very much if he will be able to do that in County Clare or in a very large portion of it. If he starts in the town of Ennis moving northwards until he reaches Ballyvaughan, or if he starts at Ceann Bhóirne, in the north-western corner of the constituency, back to Corofin, he will be confronted with a problem that even he will scarcely be able to deal with.

There is one aspect of that territory with which the Minister may not be familiar—you have a huge area of limestone rock and intermingled a considerable area of small valleys, sometimes which could not even be described as valleys but as intervening spaces, of very fertile land, a large portion of which is overgrown with scrub, whitethorn bushes and nut bushes or hazel. I wonder if the Minister's scheme would apply to that and if it would be possible to reclaim that very large area under the scheme.

On the other hand, there is a problem of a different nature. I did not catch the Minister's reference to this, though he did refer to it. It is regarding the estuarine portions adjoining the rivers Shannon and Fergus. I do not know if the Minister intends to deal with that particular problem or whether it is excluded from this scheme altogether. Whatever doubts there may be as to the possibility of reclaiming the craggy lands, there is no doubt whatever about the possibility of reclaiming these very rich lands, amounting in all to approximately 17,000 acres of what would possibly be, if reclaimed, the richest land in this country or any other country. About 100 years ago, portion of this land was reclaimed by the Fergus Reclamation Syndicate and quite recently portion of it was divided and I have been credibly informed that as many as three crops of mangolds have been produced on that land without manure. I mention that merely to prove the rich nature of the soil there.

Comment on this

Not, I hope, to commend the practice.

Comment on this

No—merely to prove what was done there. I doubt if it could be done anywhere else in Europe. It might be done in Java, but I doubt if it could be done elsewhere. This land could be reclaimed at perhaps a lesser cost than the average cost under the Minister's scheme. Twenty-one years ago, the Clare County Committee of Agriculture laid out a small demonstration plot which has been left there since in order to give time to the experiment to mature. Sufficient time has now elapsed to enable the Minister's experts, if the Minister wishes to take an interest in it, to ascertain what has been the success of the scheme. In my opinion, if the plants there were transplanted along the various stretches of mudflats there, within a period of perhaps 20 years, all of that area could be brought into production. It has been done in some portions of East Anglia, as the Minister can easily ascertain if he refers to the authority there, the East Anglia Institute of Agriculture. Large areas along the coast of Holland have also been reclaimed, and, as the Minister did refer to one of the Dutch Departments, I hope he will seek whatever information is there and, if necessary, get some of the Dutch experts over here to advise on the subject. It would be well worth while and I mention the matter in passing in the hope that the Minister will give serious attention to it, with a view to seeing if it is possible for him to bring it in under this scheme and, if not, with a view to having it dealt with in another scheme later on.

This scheme, I take it, is primarily intended to deal, in the first instance, with ordinary field drainage and, for the sake of the general information of the people interested, I should like to know whether, if there is an area of ten acres with a wet corner and the only direction in which the water can be taken from it is down through it, the farmer concerned will have to pay for the drainage of the entire ten acres because one small drain has to be run through it. Another item which I take it will come within the scope of the scheme is the levelling of ditches, the filling up of ditches in uneven land which one often sees in some of the richest parts of the country. Am I correct in thinking that that will come within the scheme?

Another problem which will confront the Minister in certain areas is the scarcity of materials suitable for drainage. In many parts of the country and particularly in the western portion of my constituency, which is in the main of a boggy nature, stones suitable for drainage are extremely difficult to obtain or can be obtained only by going a long distance. Would it be possible for the Minister to have an arrangement whereby cheap pipes could be made available for use in these circumstances? That is an area which could benefit by this scheme, if it were extended to it, and I have been informed by a man whom I would regard as an excellent authority that that land would be capable of doubling its production, if given proper treatment. For that reason, I am sorry that it is not one of the earlier schemes in the Minister's list.

Several speakers have already referred to the utilisation of portion of the large sum which the Minister envisages for expenditure under this scheme to enable farmers to obtain fertilisers at a lesser cost than that obtaining at present. I think the Minister would be well advised to listen to the suggestions made from both sides of the House on that subject. If he wants immediate results, if he wants to get an increase in production, he will be well advised not to turn down the suggestions made to him in all good faith by several speakers from both sides of the House. Everybody agrees that 95 per cent. of the land of the country is in urgent need of phosphates at present, and, for that reason, the Minister should devote portion of this money to the provision of suitable fertilisers.

The Minister also referred to the production of grass seeds, of pedigree seeds. I think that, too, is a move in the right direction, because I have been informed that the percentage of germination in commercial grass seeds has been as low as 26 per cent., which is a very unsatisfactory position indeed. Is it the Minister's intention that these grass seeds will be produced by our own farmers here and there, that a number of farmers will be selected to go in for the production of these seeds and that one group will produce ryegrass of suitable strains, another Cocksfoot and so on, in order that our farmers will be assured of getting suitable strains within a reasonable period? If so, the Minister would be well advised to encourage the production of these seeds at home rather than to import what might perhaps be inferior seeds or seeds which, because of the change of climate and so on, might not be as productive here as elsewhere.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liomsa céad míle fáilte a chur roimh an mBille seo agus focal comhgháirdeachais a rá leis an Aire mar gheall air. Creidim go bhfuighidh an Bille an fháilte chéanna ó na daoine go léir ar fud an tíre. Cuirfidh an obair a deanfar fén scéim seo feabhas thar cuimse ar thalamh na hEireann agus tabharfadh sé caoi mhaireachtála d'fheirmeoirí nach bhfuil an chaoi sin acu inniu. Nuair a chuimhnimid ar an obair a rinne ár sinsear leis an talamh d'fháil do na daoine is brónach an seéal a bhí againn le suim blianta: an talamh san bheith ag dul chun donachta cheal saorthú. Luachair atá ag fás in áit ar chóir barraí bréaghtha a bheith agus tá súil le Dia agam go gcuirfídh an Bille seo deireadh leis an luachair. Má dhéanann an Bille leath an méid atá beartaithe ag an Aire is mór ar fad an maitheas a dhéanfas sé don tír agus tá buíochas na tíre ag dul don Aire ar a shon. Tá cúpla ceist agam le cur ar an Aire.

I see in sub-section (2) of Section 3 a provision with regard to the payment of the reclamation annuity, and I would like to ascertain from the Minister how the period of repayment will be arranged. He mentioned, in reply to a question from Deputy Lehane, that the period for repayment would be 60 years but there is a further provision in the Bill whereby the reclamation annuity will stand consolidated with the purchase annuity so as to form one annuity. I would like to ascertain from the Minister how he intends to make the necessary adjustment in view of the fact that some of the holdings which will benefit under this scheme were purchased under Acts in respect of which the repayment period will soon determine. Some holdings bought under the earlier Land Acts are now free of annuity. There are varying periods for the continuation of the land purchase annuities. Are we to take it that in cases where there is a short period in comparison with other long periods of repayment the ultimate period of repayment will be extended? As a matter of interest, I would like to get that information from the Minister because it is a question which many people will be asking. From the Bill as it stands it would appear that the reclamation annuity will come to an end at the same time as the land purchase annuity now affecting the holding is due to come to an end.

Under sub-section (5) of Section 3 I notice that neither a consolidated annuity nor a reclamation annuity shall be subject to revision under the Land Purchase Acts but, of course, the consolidated annuity will consist of a reclamation annuity added to the revised purchase annuity as it stands at the present time. I do not quite see the necessity for that particular sub-section at all because a future Dáil could change that quite easily if the necessity arose, and I do not see much point in including it in the Bill.

The provision for the charging of the reclamation annuity on the fee simple of the holding may cause some little difficulty because we can easily visualise cases in which the full fee simple interest in the holding may not be vested in the applicant or the occupier of the land. We can visualise cases, let us say, of the widow and children of a deceased owner who died intestate living on there and cases where, for reasons such as the family being young or being in poor circumstances, it may not be possible to get the title put in order. I would like to ascertain from the Minister if he has taken that position into account and if he has worked out a plan for the selection of the applicant.

Comment on this

The occupier.

Comment on this

There may be a number of occupiers.

Comment on this

The rated occupier.

Comment on this

The rated occupier is not mentioned in the Bill, as a matter of fact. Yes, I suppose that would meet the situation. I quite understand how the situation was met under the Land Purchase Acts, by vesting the property in the occupier subject to equities, but I was wondering if that was in contemplation by the Minister and if some principles on a similar line would apply here. I can appreciate that there will be repercussions from this Bill that cannot be avoided with regard to the charging of the ownership. I can visualise, for instance, one case where injustices may be worked to people.

Comment on this

Must not we assume that the work done is worth more than £12?

Comment on this

Oh, yes, I am accepting that. I think that will not be questioned but there is one particular case in point that the Minister might consider. We know that on the death intestate of a married man without children, the property is valued in a certain artificial manner under the Intestate Estates Act. If this artificial value is less than £500 the widow gets everything to the exclusion of the next-of-kin. That artificial value is not related to the market value. We know that in calculating that artificial value, charges on the holding including the redemption value of the land annuities are taken into account. Under this Bill, when this reclamation annuity is charged on the lands the widow will have in fact a more valuable holding but she will be entitled to deduct from the artificial value of it the redemption value of the reclamation annuity and that will in fact work an injustice on the next-of-kin.

Comment on this

God help the widow. Is not it a very good thing that she should be the sole heir to a small estate?

Comment on this

It may be. But there are cases where this Bill will have repercussions on other branches of the law. I suppose it cannot be avoided. I think it is just as well to mention it. The Minister may find a way out of some of these changes which will be effected in other branches of the law. I do not think it is necessary or desirable that the detailed provisions of the Bill should be gone into now.

I consider that this Bill is of such great importance to the farmers of Ireland that it will find a place in the future history of this country and I think the Minister rightly described it as the finishing touch to the work begun by Michael Davitt. I think it is a very great tribute to the Minister and that it is the product of sound intelligence and of a courageous mind. The Dáil ought to be, and the country will be, very grateful to the Minister for Agriculture for having had the courage and the foresight to introduce a Bill of this kind.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

The Bill before us is undoubtedly of great importance to the agricultural community. Whatever snags may arise during its operation there can be no doubt at all but that the Minister responsible, by visualising this problem in a big way, deserves encouragement. I trust that the farmers in general will approve of it and will utilise it to the utmost. I am quite confident that that will be the case. However, I consider that, somehow, the putting forward of this Bill was hurried. For instance, I cannot see how the operation of field drainage can be undertaken without a general survey of the area involved. I am sure that the first operation will have to be the cleaning of the main drains in so far as these affect the drainage in any field if you are to carry out effective drainage there. Who is responsible then for clearing these main drains, small rivers, perhaps, or such watercourses as are of importance to begin with? Since the introduction of this Bill and since the passing of the Drainage Act to be operated by the local bodies there is complete confusion in the minds of the people as to where they should now apply in order to get one of their improvement works carried out. I think I asked a Parliamentary question in that regard. I pointed out that there should be some co-ordination of all the different schemes that are about to operate in respect of land improvement work. We have, for instance, the farm improvements scheme which is operated by the Department of Agriculture, a watertight Department. Its officials—men who have been doing good work over a number of years—are working singly. Then the special employment schemes or minor relief schemes are operated by another set of officials. We have, in addition, forestry work and Land Commission work. Then there is the Drainage Bill under the Department of Local Government and now we have the Land Reclamation Bill under the Minister for Agriculture. All the officials of these Departments are operating in each district. Their contacts are with the same people. Surely the matter could be more efficiently operated and more easily understood by the people concerned if an organisation in each county had control of all these different units and was so organised that the people understood to whom they should apply and which Department was responsible for or would undertake their work. At the moment you have this form of overlapping. Take the case of a drainage operation, affecting a townland, which requires to be carried out. At present we probably could get that job done under the special employment schemes or under the rural improvements scheme. It is also possible that that same job could be carried out by the county council under the new Drainage Bill. There would be overlapping because, as I say, the scheme could be carried out under the rural improvements scheme or under the county council, or the Department of Local Government might be prepared to carry out the same work and be responsible for it.

I want to point out to the Minister that there is undoubtedly a considerable amount of confusion created by the fact that all these schemes are operated seperately. The result is that the ordinary person, for whose benefit they are in operation, is unable to put his finger on the particular Department or the particular group of people who may be responsible for his particular job. I urge that there should be some form of co-operation in controlling these schemes. I am quite satisfied that it can be done with considerable economy to the State. I cannot see why the man who is operating the farm improvements scheme could not also operate the Department of Agriculture's scheme in a large way so far as this drainage is concerned, and similarly up and down through the various Departments I have mentioned.

The cost under this Bill is, I take it, fixed at a maximum of £36 an acre for the carrying out of improvements. I wonder why that figure of £36 an acre was fixed. If the improvement of an acre of land costs over £36, will £36 be spent and then will it be allowed to remain as an unfinished job?

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

£36 is the maximum and if it costs £36 more to improve the land will nothing be done?

Comment on this

It is an estimate of what we believe to be the average. One-third of that is the liability of the farmer. The Department takes the risk of having to spend more if an acre of land, potentially arable, requires more to be spent in order to make it arable in fact.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

So the sum is not rigidly confined to the £36? There is now a balance of £12 an acre. For instance, if the job is to cost £36 the owner is liable to a charge of £12 an acre which is provided by way of a loan, repayable, I understand, at 4 per cent.

Comment on this

At 3½ per cent.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

Take the case of a farmer with 30 or 40 acres who requires improvements on 20 acres. He will, at that rate, have a charge made on his land of approximately £8 or £9 a year. I put it to the Minister that that is not a fair way at all of fixing costs. In many instances that sum will represent a larger amount per annum charged against the holding than was originally charged in the case of the land annuities.

Prior to the Purchase Acts, which fixed the sum on which the farmer paid his annuity, the farmers had the right to go into court in order to get a fair rent fixed according to the value of the land. Therefore, there was a fairly equitable arrangement by which the land was charged with a sum equivalent to what the land was capable of bearing. Under this system there is no means at all of determining what the land is capable of bearing. It is very probable that in the case of poor land as, for instance, small congested areas in the West of Ireland, the land will cost more per acre to improve by drainage and otherwise than good land would cost. Therefore you will put a heavier charge on the poorer quality of land comparatively than on the good land. It is absurd to think that small farmers, even if the land is improved, can carry such a burden which is altogether out of proportion with what the good quality land will have to bear.

I urge on the Minister that if this scheme is to operate successfully the charge should not be fixed upon the cost, but that there should be taken into consideration the improvement made to the land, what the land is capable of carrying when it is so improved and the number of people per acre who are resident in that area. The number of people resident on and depending on the land should be taken into consideration as well as the improvement made to the land and what the land is capable of bearing when it is so improved.

Comment on this

Has not the farmer the alternative of doing it himself and getting the grant?

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

I am bearing that in mind. The farmer with good land which is easily drained and which will cost much less and the return from which will be much greater is afforded the same facility for doing the work himself as the people in the west. The Minister will find that many of those farmers in the west whose farms are so improved will have to bear a heavier burden in the form of a new charge than they were asked to bear under the Land Purchase Acts. Under the Land Purchase Acts the purchase price was fixed with a degree of equity owing to the courts having fixed a fair rent previously. There is no such provision here. They will be charged with the cost of the work. I can assure the Minister that it will have a serious and damaging effect on the whole operation of the scheme because a small farmer, if he is industrious as most of them are, will be very slow to burden his farm with anything like such a sum as may be charged.

Comment on this

They would ordinarily do it themselves and collect the grant.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

A good many of them will. Practically all I know will, but if they have no help available and are not, therefore, able to do it they will have to bear this charge. That will be inequitable, especially if they are in poor circumstances. There may be arrears of land annuities on the holding and to these will be added the additional burden.

I, therefore, say the problem in the west should be considered separately. There should not be any such thing as one uniform scheme dealing with the poor quality land and the good quality land on which drainage and reclamation work will be comparatively inexpensive and the benefits from which will be very much greater. I urge that there should be a total survey of each area before any field drainage is put into operation. That is essential and can be carried out by an amalgamation of the existing officers operating under the Department, most of whom have experience extending over the last 15 or 20 years.

It has been suggested that this is a sort of gratuitous grant to the farmer. It is nothing of the sort. What this proposes to do is restore what farmers were forced to take out of their soil during the emergency in the interests of the nation. Compulsory tillage was in operation—a very necessary thing. That, however, was responsible for extracting the fertility from the soil of farms all over the country. As there were no artificial manures available, the soil became poorer. Compulsory tillage was not generally beneficial to the farmer. He had to carry it out whether it meant a loss or a gain, but the nation gained by it. Therefore, the fertility, which is the great asset on any farm, was by order of the Government drawn from the soil and used for providing the necessary food for our people. If a Government tells a factory which is manufacturing cigarettes that they must manufacture some other commodity which is essential for the time being, at the end of the period of emergency it is always recognised that the owner of the factory is entitled to compensation for having to make the change-over in the interests of the nation. Therefore, this Bill, although magnanimous and magnificent in its outline, by no means makes a gift from the State to the farmer. It is merely giving back what is due to the farmer.

Comment on this

It all depends on the profits the farmer made. If a factory made a profit, the owner would not receive compensation.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

The Deputy misunderstands the situation. He does not understand agriculture. Farmers did not make any great profit during these years. As you know, prices were fixed to a large extent. In some cases, farmers made a reasonable profit, but in many cases there was no such thing as a profit which would allow the farmer to recondition his land and restore the fertility extracted from it during the period of compulsory tillage. The nation, therefore, is morally bound to restore to the farmer what was taken from him.

The Bill is a magnificent one in many ways and I hope it will have the effect that I anticipate. There must, however, be certain adjustments made on the lines I have suggested if it is to be generally useful and made applicable to the areas where it is needed most, namely, the congested areas.

I wonder how far this additional burden when it becomes a mortgage on the lands will affect loans which hitherto have been available to some extent, but always to a very limited extent, from the banks. I wonder will the banks in future limit the loans granted on the security of land owing to the increased burden which will be put on the land by this scheme. If they do, it may have serious effects. It is a matter which will have to be considered. Everyone knows how careful banks are in advancing loans against any property. The charges on land in the form of land annuities or other things very largely determine the amount of credit which banks will make available. This will mean an additional burden on the land and if it has the effect of reducing the financial facilities available hitherto it will have an un-favourable reaction. On the other hand, this scheme when put into operation may have the effect of making credit facilities more readily available to the farmer because of the increased fertility and productivity of the soil. I think the scheme is a good one. I am quite sure that its operation will reveal many snags that will require care and patience in order to make a job of it, but the skeleton and the idea are good and accordingly it is entitled to be persevered with. I am satisfied that the final results will be practical and good.

Comment on this

My excuse for rising to speak for a few moments on this Bill is that I happen to be chairman of a county committee of agriculture. I agree with the other Deputies in welcoming this measure as one likely to benefit a very large number of farmers and, I hope, in particular the smaller farmers of the congested areas. There are undoubtedly great possibilities in this measure but there are, I would suggest, also great possibilities for wasting a lot of money unless great care is used in the selection of the land which will be drained or reclaimed. I have seen land reclamation schemes going on since I was very young. If you examine those lands at the present time there is not very much sign of improvement, quite the contrary. Most of them have gone back to their original wild state. I understand that the £40,000,000 are to be used for increasing food production. I do not think you are going to get the best out of this money if it is to be spent almost entirely on what you might call at the present time waste land.

This matter was under consideration by my committee of agriculture and it was decided to ask the Minister to extend this scheme to include the better type of land mentioned by Deputy Cogan some time ago, land that has become impoverished and needs special attention. I agree with that view. In fact, almost all the Deputies who spoke on the Government side stressed this point. I quite agree with them that it would be nationally foolish to spend all the money on reclaiming lands that just at the moment happen to be in a very bad condition and would not benefit the country very much. That is the first point I wish to make.

I hope the Minister was not very serious in decrying manual labour in this matter of reclamation. I was rather astonished to find the Minister telling us that elaborate machinery is to be used, apparently, in all cases in this scheme of reclamation. First of all, I do not think that this elaborate machinery is going to be a success in many of the places that have to be drained or reclaimed. Notwithstanding what has been said about it not being a scheme to provide labour, it would be very wrong to minimise the amount of labour to be given to people in the poorer areas. It may be all right in some of the richer lands to use this elaborate machinery but it would not be wise in the poorer areas, especially in the west of Ireland.

Comment on this

First of all, do you think you are going to take elaborate machinery into bogs which, I presume, you are going to reclaim? I do not think you will. Besides a large amount of this work can and will only be done by manual labour. You will find that is so yourself. I am rather surprised and I do not know on what the Minister based his selection of certain counties for the benefits of this reclamation scheme. The people in my county, Roscommon, cannot understand it either. We cannot see why counties in the various provinces have been selected and why a county like Roscommon has been omitted. I hope it is not because the Minister comes from Roscommon.

Comment on this

If I did the other thing that would be mentioned pretty quickly too.

Comment on this

I think we stand in need of this scheme as much as any other county. However, there is something reassuring in the statement that within a year he hopes to have the scheme in operation in every county. I should like to know from the Minister when he is replying whether the present farm improvements scheme is going to be continued as it is at the moment. There are certain very great advantages in the present farm improvements scheme. I think the greatest advantage is that when the scheme is carried out it leaves no liability. Perhaps I am an alarmist in this matter but I do not agree with the principle, generally, of imposing big financial burdens and leaving big debts on land.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not realise that I spent half-an-hour explaining that there are two alternatives. The farmer may get a grant——

Comment on this

I understand that. You need not explain any further to me. Notwithstanding anything the Minister has said, there are many people who would make application for grants and loans who do not always know to what it leads. I believe that at the present time the cost of labour is very high and undoubtedly agricultural prices are good, but a day may come when the prices will not be so good and then many of the tenants may find themselves in the position that they will not be able to repay those loans. I know, of course, there are cases where the loans are necessary but I am afraid that in such cases many thinking farmers will not avail themselves of loans in that way.

Comment on this

Four shillings and sevenpence per acre.

Comment on this

That may be, but if you go to some districts in Roscommon you will find that 4/7 will be a deterrent and do not make any mistake about it.

Comment on this

I wish I had some of the banking accounts in the west. I should be a rich man.

Comment on this

Of the small farmers? Surely you are not serious in that.

Comment on this

Is £3 a week for farm labourers too high? Do you agree it is too high?

Comment on this

I am not discussing that question at the moment. I understand from the Minister that the rate of interest is 4 per cent.

Comment on this

Three and a half per cent.

Comment on this

What is mentioned in the Bill?

Comment on this

Four per cent. including the redemption of the loan.

Comment on this

Anyway, three and a half and a half are four. I think it is rather high. One or two things were mentioned in the debate by some Deputies which rather surprised me. One Deputy mentioned that the manufacturers of artificial manures at home should, to some extent, be boycotted and that manures should be imported. I think that is a very bad outlook. Instead of that we should in every way try to encourage the manufacture of these manures at home. If the manufacturers are overcharging, as Deputy Allen stated, there are means of dealing with them. Certainly it would be wrong to try and import manures when these things could be produced at home.

Finally, I want to stress particularly and to ask the Minister specially to consider the question of extending the scope of the Bill—this can be done on an amendment — to include a better type of land than appears to be envisaged in the Bill. It would be a great mistake from the point of view of full production and of the future to confine the Bill almost entirely to those lands that are at present more or less derelict. Perhaps the Minister has that in view.

Comment on this

I never said that.

Comment on this

It appears to be there in the enumeration of the things that are to be done. It does not appear to include the better type of land. I would be glad if the Minister had in view the provision of help for farmers who have the better type of land, but which is now reduced in fertility. It would not be a very costly thing if, by providing cheap artificial manures, you could improve that land. The land is reasonably good and is capable of improvement. The Minister, I am afraid, has a kind of fixed idea against these subsidies. I do not think he is right in that. In my opinion, the best thing to do would be to provide, by means of subsidy or otherwise, cheap artificial manures, such as phosphates and ground limestone for the improvement of the better type of land. It would be of great benefit to the country if we had more of these artificial manures available for that purpose. They are so dear at the moment that farmers do not use them to the extent that they should.

Comment on this

They are cheaper in Ireland than in any other known civilised country in the world.

Comment on this

That may be so. I am living amongst farmers and I know that they are not using them. In other countries, where you have big centres of population, the farmers who happen to be living adjacent to big cities have good markets for their produce. I know that the Irish farmer is conservative as a rule, but the point is that many of them are not using artificial manures to the extent they should because they have not the money and cannot afford to buy them. I suggest to the Minister that he should do something to make it possible for them to get cheap artificial manures. We are all agreed that quite a lot of deterioration in land set in during the last nine or 12 years owing to increased crop production. That was inevitable. I suggest that it would not take a lot of money to restore such land to a reasonable condition of fertility. That is a point that has been put by my county committee of agriculture. I am now putting it to the Minister that he should, over the period that he will have the handling of this £40,000,000 or £50,000,000, carry out that suggestion.

Comment on this

There is no need for me to say that I welcome this scheme. I think any honest man should do so, irrespective of whether he is a farmer or otherwise. Of course, we had the usual "Doleful Jimmies" on the other side of the House. I was glad to see, however, that we had not very many long-winded speeches from them. This is a national scheme that we are embarking on. There is no touch of the dole or of relief about it, and there is no doubt but that the farmers will do their share with a good heart and without any dole.

This is a scheme that should have been introduced 20 years ago. There is altogether too much of the land of this nation water-logged. It badly needs reclamation of a high order, and that work of reclamation will have to go on for a long number of years. I am glad that the Minister has made his scheme as elastic as possible so that if he finds any snags in it while the work is going ahead he will have the opportunity of putting them right. The Minister is not the type of man who will allow himself to be tied up in red tape. I hope that, as time goes on, this scheme will lead to much better things so far as the improvement of the land of the country is concerned, and that the farm improvements scheme, the minor relief schemes and other schemes will all be embraced in this great national scheme for the rehabilitation of our land.

I ask the Minister to encourage cooperative effort in all the areas possible so far as this scheme is concerned. This is a scheme that will encourage farmers to get into the right frame of mind as far as the improvement of their land is concerned. I am living on a farm that at one time was part of a 1,500 acre estate. About 40 years ago a vast scheme of drainage was carried out on that estate. A piping system was laid down but, unfortunately, from the time the land was divided, about 20 years ago, the drainage was neglected, with the result that the old dykes got closed up and the piping system was thereby put out of action. One evidence of that is that sometimes you see fountains springing up in some of the fields on that estate. Co-operative effort is needed to get that drainage system into effective working order again. If four or five farmers got together, these pipes could be cleared and so the drainage on these lands could be brought up to an efficient standard. It is only through co-operative effort that work of that kind could be done. It would involve a good deal of expense, but if four or five farmers undertook to do the work the proportion that would fall on each man would not be very great. It would be absolutely useless to attempt to improve the piping system on one farm and do nothing with regard to it on the adjoining farms.

Some of the Deputies opposite have urged that this scheme should be altered to include much of the better class land in the country. I would not stand for that. Our first consideration should be for the small farmers who have been living on scrubby land all their lives. They have had a hard struggle over a long period of years. The farmers who have land that does not need drainage or rehabilitation should be well able to look after their own land. Fertilisers and limestone are now available, and those farmers by using them, and by a little effort on their own part, should well be able to increase the fertility of their land. A vast amount of the money that is provided under this scheme will be needed to give the small-holders a chance. If there is any money left over after adequate provision has been made to meet their needs, then the position of the farmers with the better class land can be considered. Our first consideration must be for those who are living on tiny farms. They have had to try and exist on the dregs of bad land and what I may call the tail-end of estates. They are the men for whom Michael Davitt fought. I am satisfied that the Minister is the right man to be in charge of this scheme. He does not forget what happened 50 and more years ago when his father, Michael Davitt and Parnell were urging the small farmers to secure a firm grip on their homesteads. I am sure that he will bring to a successful conclusion the work that those great men did in their day.

I am sorry to have to say that every speech Deputy O'Reilly has made here lately has been a pessimistic one. I can see why he is so pessimistic. The success of this scheme will mean the political extinction for many of them over there. I think that is why he is down in the dumps, but I would ask him to have a little more courage and to be more optimistic. He said that we are in for a period of depression, such as we had after the first world war and later when the farmers were down and out. Why not keep up our chins while we are able to do it? What is the use of meeting trouble half way? We should stand up with our coats off and our chins up and be ready to weather any storm that comes along. I want to say to Deputy O'Reilly "Hold your heart up; there is no reason to be down in your boots." The farmers at the present time are in good trim and in good heart. All they want is a little assistance. They do not want either doles or sops. They have guaranteed markets for their produce, and I can tell Deputy O'Reilly that they will weather any storm that comes. They are quite satisfied that the present Minister is going on the right lines and is giving them a lead which they never got before.

Deputy O'Reilly talked about the vast lakes that may be created by this scheme in County Meath. Three or four weeks ago we had the Deputy and other Deputies opposite trying to hold back a Bill that would help to relieve flooding in the country. He talked about the Tolka. I know all the damage that the flooding on it causes. I know a woman who lives near Dunboyne whose kitchen and sitting-room have been flooded to a depth of nine feet. When the Works Bill was before the House in the last couple of weeks, the purpose of which is to relieve flooding such as we have had on the Tolka, Deputy O'Reilly did not give very much help when we were trying to get it through. That Bill will afford relief to people in the same position as this woman at Dunboyne. This scheme is going to be carried out in conjunction with other schemes. The local government drainage scheme will go hand in hand with this. As Deputy O'Reilly knows, Meath is included in the first batch of schemes and it will be only a year or two before Meath comes into its own. In the meantime, we have enough minor and other drainage schemes to be put into operation. The River Tolka and other little rivers which did so much damage in the past will be in fair trim to allow the new scheme to be fully availed of when the time comes.

I am satisfied that the scheme is good and I am sure it will be approved by the people. I feel satisfied that the farmers will do their share. I expect the majority of the farmers will carry out the scheme on their own lands, and that will be only right. There are some people who will have the scheme carried out for them, but I should like to see most of the farmers embarking on this scheme in their own way, supervised by officials. In the course of time a proper spirit will be generated throughout the country and the farmers will realise that they are somebody and the nation will get a good return. There is no need for pessimism. We never expected this money and we should endeavour to avail of it in a good spirit. Let every penny be wisely spent. Some of it may be badly spent, but in a scheme of such magnitude as this one must expect snags. I believe most of the difficulties that will present themselves will be overcome if a proper spirit is observed in putting the scheme into operation.

I ask the Minister to make some effort to see that small schemes, such as road improvement schemes, farm improvement schemes and farm building schemes, where there are vast numbers of officials engaged, will be dovetailed into one national scheme. The Minister has the brains to evolve that type of dovetailing. In that way we will have no overlapping. I welcome this scheme and I am glad that I have lived to see the day when it will be put into operation. We will be helping to achieve what the great men of the past, men like Parnell and Davitt and others who devoted their lives to the interests of the small farmers, hoped to see accomplished in their day.

Comment on this

The Deputy who has just sat down has illustrated the confusion that exists in a lot of people's minds about drainage. He assured the House that the River Tolka would be drained, not under this scheme, but under the Works Bill which is at present being considered by the House and which was presented by the Department of Local Government. But the Parliamentary Secretary in charge of that Bill denied that any such rivers would be drained under the Works Bill.

Comment on this

These are streams rather than rivers.

Comment on this

But the Tolka is a river.

Comment on this

A very small one.

Comment on this

When it floods its banks a few miles outside Dublin, as I saw it on one occasion in summer time, it could not be described as a very small river. Under the Works Bill the Tolka cannot be drained, but under the Works Bill the water that overflows the banks of the Tolka may be capable of creating worse floods and, again, these can be added to by schemes carried out under this Bill. We had here a Drainage Commission and many experts gave evidence before it. We had the best people we could get, men with great experience, sitting on that Commission and they solemnly reported that drainage should commence at the mouth of the river and work up.

The Minister for Agriculture recently employed an expert from New Zealand to examine the problem of land reclamation here, and that expert solemnly reported that a lot of land required to be drained in this country, which was no news to anybody, but he emphasised that the proper way to tackle drainage was to start at the mouth of the river. When I saw that, I remarked that surely he did not come all the way from New Zealand to tell us that. We know that if you do not start at the river mouth you will make things all the more difficult; if you start on the upper reaches the water will flood all the adjoining lands downstream. However, Mr. Holmes in his wisdom thought it necessary to put that in his report. I can see from a lot of the optimism that accompanied the Works Bill here and that is evident in connection with this Bill, that it was a very necessary warning that Mr. Holmes gave us—that the proper way to do the drainage is to start at the river mouth.

We will have at least three authorities dealing with drainage and no one knows whether there will be any co-ordination. Under the Works Bill, the Parliamentary Secretary assured us that they would consult the Office of Public Works in any case where there was a doubt whether the draining of a certain watercourse would not do more harm than good. I would like the Minister for Agriculture to give us a similar assurance. He may be in the same frame of mind as the Parliamentary Secretary who would not accept an amendment from the Opposition on that subject. I would like him to assure the House that in cases where the activities under this Bill lead the Department and its agents to a watercourse or a number of watercourses in order that they may be drained into a river basin already subject to flooding, before they proceed to do that work on any wholesale scale they will consult the only expert authority we have on drainage problems, and that is the Office of Public Works. The country has paid dearly for the experience of the Office of Public Works. They have made mistakes, huge mistakes in the past, in draining the upper reaches of rivers without first cleaning the mouth and the main basins. Surely we should take advantage of that experience and not have to teach two other Departments, at the expense of the farmers, that one has to be careful when one is going to do drainage on any wholesale scale.

Comment on this

"Careful" is good—16 years' meditation.

Comment on this

I would be delighted to go to Mayo on the 15th August. I did not see the Minister for Agriculture celebrating the Republic in Paris, but I certainly would like to see him celebrating his conversion to land reclamation in Mayo. Since Fianna Fáil came into office in 1932, drainage and reclamation schemes of all sorts have been carried out. We had the land reclamation scheme upon which we had an expenditure by the Government alone of up to £500,000 per year, or thereabouts. It took us a long time to do that because the farmers had to be educated into accepting the 50 per cent. grant in order to carry out their improvements.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You spent more than that on Constellations.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I fail to see the relevance of the interruption, apart from anything else.

Comment on this

I want to draw your attention to the fact that I cannot get on my feet without one particular Deputy making interruptions completely irrelevant to the debate. We spent on land reclamation up to £500,000 a year. Under the rural improvements scheme and under the minor relief works we were spending about £1,250,000 on various drainage and small road schemes. The Minister when he came into office saved money in his first year for the Minister for Finance by putting the land improvements scheme into abeyance.

Comment on this

That is crazy nonsense.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

On a point of order. No matter how irrelevant my interruption was, what relevancy has this to the present Bill?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy is relevant.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

To the present land reclamation scheme?

Comment on this

But not truthful.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy is relevant and, if irrelevancies are provoked by interruptions, my sympathies are with the man who is interrupted.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

To continue my point of order. In what way can expenditure of money on rural improvements——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have ruled that the Deputy is in order and there is no question arising.

Comment on this

The Minister, having put land drainage and land improvement into abeyance for the purpose of saving money collected by taxation, has now in portion of this Bill reintroduced land drainage but the cost is going to be met out of borrowed money and not out of taxation. That is the difference. The story is that we will drain 4,000,000 acres of land at a cost of £40,000,000 which we will get from Marshall Aid and that we will not have to repay it. We are under contract to repay whatever we have got so far. If this country succeeds in spending £40,000,000 worth of dollars and is liable for a repayment charge with 4 per cent. for interest and sinking fund for the next 60 years the State will have to lay aside every year about £1,600,000 to do the job. The question is will the country get value for that? There is no doubt that there are certain lands which would be worth £20 or £30 in reclamation. There are other lands that would not be worth £1 because they are nothing more than blue clay bottoms and, even when drained, are non-arable. I would like to know from the Minister where he will draw the line. Will every acre of land for which a man applies be drained?

Comment on this

Arable, or potentially arable.

Comment on this

All sorts of land is being cultivated at the present time. There are some lands into which crops have been put which do not give very much in return.

Comment on this

Tá an ceart agat ansin.

Comment on this

Tá, agus is maith liom go bhfuil an tuairim sin ag an Aire. The country will have to pay for this one way or the other. If we put ourselves into debt to the tune of £40,000,000 I want to be sure that the result of that expenditure will leave us with more productive land. The capital charges that the land will have to bear in one form or another, whether it is by means of taxation or by means of annuity on the land, will be heavy. I would be glad to learn that the land that costs this money will yield some national wealth. There is a good deal to be said for giving the farmer help to drain his land even from the point of view of giving him a social service in backward districts where the land is poor.

In the land improvements scheme I think we had arrived at machinery which cost the State a good deal less but got the maximum possible benefit for the expenditure of State money. The farmer was given 50 per cent. of the cost and he was the judge as to whether he would proceed and as to whether the result of the expenditure of his labour would be worth while. If he did not think there would be any reasonable result he did not proceed and the State did not have to pay. The financing of this particular scheme is still in doubt. The Minister's explanation to-day, though it may have seemed clear to him, was neither full nor clear. At one time he said that the State would pay two-thirds of the cost. Later in the debate we discovered that the State payment of two-thirds was based on a calculation that the average acre would cost £30. Suppose that it cost £12 to reclaim an acre, the farmer still has to pay £10. He is, therefore, paying five-sixths of the cost.

Comment on this

If it cost what?

Comment on this

Suppose it cost £12 per acre to reclaim an acre the farmer would still have to pay £10. Is that correct?

Comment on this

I do not know where the Deputy gets that.

Comment on this

I understood that from the Minister in his opening remarks. It goes to show the difficulty of debating this without having some clear facts on paper.

Comment on this

That is one explanation. There is another.

Comment on this

Would the Minister answer a simple question at this stage?

Comment on this

With pleasure.

Comment on this

If the drainage costs £30, the farmer's contribution is £10. If the drainage costs £20 the farmer's contribution is £10.

Comment on this

No. If our estimate of the cost of rehabilitating the land specified is £30 and the farmer undertakes to do it himself, he will receive from the State a grant of £20 when the work is completed—two-thirds of the cost.

Comment on this

Suppose that the farmer asks the State to do the job and that it costs £30, how much will the farmer have to pay?

Comment on this

If it costs £20, he will still have to pay £12. If it costs £14, he will still have to pay £12 so that the farmer is paying a very variable percentage of the total cost. In the case of a work costing £14, he is paying six-sevenths, that is well over 60 per cent. or rather 70 per cent. Under the old reclamation scheme, the most he had to pay was 50 per cent.

Comment on this

If the Deputy stands on O'Connell Bridge offering to give away £12 for £12, nobody is going to find fault with him if he also offers to give £15 for £12.

Comment on this

I am only asking the Minister is that true? Before this Bill was brought in, this enabling legislation, we should have in black and white in a White Paper the amount that it is proposed to contribute under the scheme.

Comment on this

I offered to send the pamphlet to the Deputy at 3 o'clock to-day and his colleague told me to keep it.

Comment on this

You asked Deputy Smith whether it was any good to him when he was on his feet speaking.

Comment on this

He could have lent it to you.

Comment on this

I would be delighted to get it from the Minister but it is not very much use to offer it to me in the course of my speech because I cannot read it and speak at the same time. So far as I can see, under this scheme there are certain farmers who will get less than they would have got under the land improvements scheme that has been operated to date

Comment on this

How did he get round to that?

Comment on this

I observe from some hints that the land improvements scheme is going to be dropped, that the work is going to be taken over and all land reclamation done under this in future. Apart from that particular aspect of it, the farmers' aspect, there is the general economic and financial aspect, that we are proposing to carry out this work with borrowed money. If the State collects £4,000,000 this year, and £4,000,000 goes into the Central Bank, when the Minister for Finance takes this out for investment purposes, he has the option of making the investment in something like the Electricity Supply Board or some other type of investment and of getting a fairly reasonable interest on it. If we put it into this work, the farmer is going to pay in some cases six-sevenths of the whole expenditure back. In other cases he will only pay one-third, so that whatever balance is spent over and above what the farmer gives is going to remain a charge on the State Exchequer. That is a debt which will have to be met some time. This £30,000,000 or £40,000,000 of an additional burden on the State may look very simple to the Minister for Agriculture at the moment but at one time he had great complaints as to the burden of debt on the State. He did not know how long the State could survive under the huge burden of debt but he calmly proposes, for one particular scheme alone, inside a few years to add 50 per cent. to the total dead weight debt of the State.

Comment on this

So that the asset of the land is nil?

Comment on this

Land is a very good asset, an excellent asset and we believed that it was an asset that was worth taking care of and that it was worth asking the community to take care of. The Minister is going to put the repayment of the cost of this scheme on the long finger so that the people will not have to pay for it at the present time but will be paying for generations for it. My only criticism is that if it is worth while to improve all our assets, including the asset of the land, it is worth while for people to pay through taxation to the extent that is necessary, and we should not gaily embark upon a deficit expenditure for land reclamation or any other type of improvement of the assets unless the general economic and financial condition of the State indicates that that is the proper way to tackle the problem. If the situation is as inflationary as the Minister for Finance said it was last year, and as he has indicated it is by certain of his Budgetary proposals, the proper way to meet expenditure for land reclamation this year is not by borrowing but by meeting the cost through taxation. The Minister is very good at imposing future burdens upon the Irish people but he ran away last year from imposing any burden for the land improvements scheme and the farm buildings scheme.

Comment on this

Why is the Deputy repeating that falsehood?

Comment on this

Because it is right.

Comment on this

It is not true.

Comment on this

It is absolutely true and it has been proved here several times.

Comment on this

The thing is wholly untrue. There is not a vestige of truth in it.

Comment on this

If he repeats it often enough he will come to believe it.

Comment on this

Some of the poor lads behind him will.

Comment on this

When Deputy Cogan was speaking, the Minister interrupted him with an interruption of the type we used to be accustomed to hear from him. Deputy Cogan stated that there was marginal lands that were dry and that could be greatly improved by the application of lime, phosphates or other artificial manures and that it would be paid back in the increased value of the crop. The Minister got up and asked him was he mad to ask the State to give any subsidy or assistance to a farmer to pay him to put in artificial manure the cost of which he could get back on his crop.

Comment on this

Plus a substantial profit.

Comment on this

Plus a substantial profit. It is not that I am objecting to the spending of money on land reclamation, but the whole land reclamation scheme is open very much more to objections than Deputy Cogan's proposals, because, as we all know and as the Minister admits, by asking not more than £12 back from a farmer, even though the State pays £100, you are not going to get back interest on the money you put in or any profit and in order to encourage farmers to do it you will have to subsidise them very heavily. The Minister stood on two legs with regard to this.

Comment on this

I hope I did. It would be very queer if I stood on three or on one.

Comment on this

I do not wish to suggest that the Minister stood on four, but the Minister put forward this proposal as a good scheme whereby the productivity of our soil would be increased and which would increase exports so that we can balance our international trade. If that is the problem with which the Minister intended to deal, there is no doubt but that the expenditure of the same amount of money, or even a half or a third of the money, which is to be spent to drain bad land would give a greater increase in output in the next 12 months or two years if it were spent on lime and phosphates. I think everybody who knows anything about land would agree that nine-tenths of the land would give a very much greater output if it got additional lime.

The Fianna Fáil Government had a scheme for lime subsidies and proposals for a greatly increased output of lime dust. The Minister changed that round so as to rely upon a few small concerns throughout the country to produce it and sell it to the farmers without any State subsidy at all. We had the idea of subsidising it so as to encourage farmers to put it on their land. My idea is that the expenditure of a couple of million pounds annually for a couple of years on the erection of plant and the production of lime dust would give a very much greater increase in production from the land than if we spent £10,000,000 for the next two years on drainage.

There was one thing we missed about this Bill. It would have delighted my heart to have heard the gentleman we once knew in this Assembly as Deputy Dillon attacking a Minister for Agriculture who introduced clause 5 in this particular Bill. This clause enables the Minister for Agriculture, his servants or agents, to go wherever the Minister wishes, open any gates, break down any fences, dispose of any spoil——

Comment on this

I cannot help it if the Deputy cannot read.

Comment on this

Well, I will try and read it and the Minister can correct me if I misplace any words.

Comment on this

I spelt them for you the last time.

Comment on this

You can spell them or smell them or anything you like, but this particular section certainly would have smelt badly if Deputy Dillon could have got at it with some other Deputy as Minister for Agriculture. The clearing of watercourses. Clause 5:—

"The Minister where it appears to be necessary——

Comment on this

Read it aright. M-A-Y spells "may".

Comment on this

——for the adequate reclamation of any land under any works being carried out by him, clear or repair a watercourse, and, for this purpose, shall, by his servants and agents, have access to the watercourse and may proceed along its banks with or without machinery in so far as appears to him to be necessary so as to render it capable of carrying waters that should normally pass through it, and may dispose of the spoil in such manner as he thinks fit."

Comment on this

That is smashing gates, wrecking property and carousing about the farm.

Comment on this

The Minister and his servants and agents may have access to the watercourse and proceed along its banks with or without machinery, with or without anybody's leave, with or without giving any notification, with or without compensation for any damage done on that land or any other land on to which he releases water and with or without compensation for any person whose wells are affected by the lowering of the water-table. The Minister for Local Government introduced a very similar clause and finally, after a lot of persuasion, we got him to introduce amendments into his Works Bill which gave the farmer a little bit of notice that the agents of the local authority or the Minister for Local Government were coming along. Surely it would not be too much to ask this Minister, who objected to any agent of the Government opening a farmer's gate without invitation, to send a little note to the farmer when he is going to go in on his land with agents and machinery.

Comment on this

Six hours ago I offered to put that in if you wanted it.

Comment on this

Good. I would like the Minister to add that where he goes in with his servants and agents, in the words of the section, and machinery and tramples down land he will compensate the farmer for the damage that is done and also compensate farmers whose lands are flooded by a too sudden release of water upstream or whose wells are dried up by ill-designed drainage.

If we pass this Bill in the form in which it stands now, there is nothing to prevent the Minister for Agriculture from tackling any drainage of any size. He uses the term "watercourse"; the same term is in the Works Bill; the same term is in all the old Drainage Acts. The Liffey is a watercourse, the Shannon is a watercourse, and under this Bill, from the purely legal point of view, if the Minister wanted to do it he could go in and remove the Electricity Supply Board dam on the Shannon, or blow it up, because it is an obstruction to the normal flow of water.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy talking as a K.C. now?

Comment on this

That is a lawyer interrupting.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is tossing in his sleep for fear I am going to blow up Ardnacrusha——

Comment on this

I am not afraid of the Minister blowing up Ardnacrusha. The Electricity Supply Board is a large organisation well capable of looking after itself. If it goes down, the State has to back it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is not a word about it in the Bill.

Comment on this

No. What I am concerned about is that some small or reasonably sized farm may lose a crop through the action of the Minister's agents, servants and machinery. The farmer may lose the crop not only for one year but for several years, through flooding. I want to guarantee, if I can—under amendments which will be proposed during the Committee Stage —that that man will have a right of action, that he cannot be deprived of his land and crops by the Minister's order, by the action of his servants, and have no right to appeal to a court for some damage. I am also concerned that if the Minister dries wells or drinking places which a farmer has been accustomed to use for a long number of years, the farmer will have some right to compensation.

I would like the Minister to say, when replying, whether he will introduce amendments such as I have suggested to Section 5, to give a farmer some notice that the Minister's agents and machinery are going in on his land —it is a matter of courtesy, if nothing else—and will also give the farmer a right to claim compensation for damage that has been done to him. The Minister for Local Government agreed to embody amendments along the same lines as various amendments we are proposing to this Bill, and I think the Minister for Agriculture might have as much sympathy for the farmers whose lands might be adversely affected by his operations as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government had.

Comment on this
Gerald Bartley Gearóid Mac Parthaláin Fianna Fáil

Is fada mé a tóiríocht focal maith Gaeilge ar "land reclamation" agus tá ceann maith faighte agam as an mBille seo—"Míntirú Talún." Tá an méid sin buntáiste agam, ar chuma ar bith, as an mBille. Ní doigh liomsa go bhfuil morán buntáiste le baint as an mBille ag na feirmeoiri i mo cheanntar-so.

Sa bhfreagra a thug an tAire dhom inné ar cheist a chur mé air i dtaobh "field drainage" i gConamara, dúirt sé gur chosain sé £45 an t-acra agus nach raibh le n-íoc faoin scéim ag an iarratasóir ach £4 an t-acra agus nár ghlac leis ach 23 duine. Bhí brabach le fáil as an scéim sin agus thuig na daoine é sin ar an bpointe. Na daoine a raibh an t-airgead acu le n-íoc, d'íoc siad as, agus tá sé le rá acu ó shoin go bhfuaradar luach a gcuid airgid.

I am not going to stand between the Minister and his reply for many minutes but I want to express my disappointment, on behalf of the congested districts, with the Bill. I think the Minister himself will recognise—I am sure he has recognised already— that this is not a Bill which will confer benefits on the poorer areas. As I said in Irish in reply to a question yesterday the Minister informed me that under his field drainage scheme, in the two rural districts of Oughterard and Clifden 23 schemes were put into operation and the number of acres dealt with in those 23 schemes was 69. The average cost per acre was £45— £41 in one district and £49 in the other, averaging £45 for the whole area. The contribution of the applicant was £4 per acre and for the £4 the applicant got £45 worth of work, which was a very good bargain for him. Those who had the money to pay the deposit jumped at the scheme but, as I pointed out, there were only 23 of them. The rest of the people were unable to avail themselves of what they recognised was a very fine scheme for those who could put up the contribution. I put it to the Minister that, if a scheme in which the deposit was £4 per acre was beyond the reach of the people in the poorer districts, surely he will agree that where the deposit is three times as much—£12, I understand, is the amount to be put down per acre under this scheme—it will not affect these people in any way, as none of them will be able to take advantage of it.

There is another point of view I would like to put to the Minister—that this scheme of his may militate against the work of relieving congestion. For instance, if the large parcels of land which are a potential solution for some of the congest problem are going to be treated under this scheme and if, for instance, work such as is mentioned in this Bill is carried out on those large parcels of land, including field drainage and the removal of unnecessary fences or the construction of new fences, and if those lands are involved in a great deal of expenditure, surely the Land Commission will not come in on those lands again and take them over for the relief of congestion?

Comment on this

Might I point out to the Deputy that the Land Commission does not buy bad land for the relief of congestion but buys the best.

Comment on this
Gerald Bartley Gearóid Mac Parthaláin Fianna Fáil

The land will be bad land when it is chosen for treatment under this scheme, I hope, but I understand from the Minister that this scheme will apply to all land, that cannot be classified as bad land— land that requires treatment and improvement. It may not essentially be bad land. I would draw the Minister's attention to the fact that we had two schemes which dealt with land, which were really reclamation schemes in the proper sense of the word as I understand it. We had schemes where people, like those in the Aran Islands and in a great many parts of Connemara, actually made soil where there was only rock. The Minister can scarcely convince me that a man in the Aran Islands, even if he could put up the £12 per acre, would come under this scheme. However, whether he can be fitted in or not, I want to tell the Minister that that type of person will not be able to find the £12.

In so far as the Bill will achieve the Minister's purpose of improving the fertility and productivity of the land, everybody welcomes it, but I want to impress upon the Minister—I do not know whether any other voice has been raised in the same way during the debate—that this Bill will not do a pennyworth of good in these areas, and, that being my belief, I want to appeal to him to reimplement the schemes which were in operation and which he must know from the files in his office have done an enormous amount of good. When the Minister gets time, I may possibly put down a question to get the information from him, but I should like to find out, in a few of these selected areas, how many acres were reclaimed which were in a bad state and which were brought into cultivation under the original land reclamation scheme and the subsequent farm improvements scheme which absorbed it. Will the Minister say now whether that farm improvements scheme has been scrapped and is being replaced by this measure?

Comment on this

I have given the answer to that 15 times to-day. Under the farm improvements scheme, people got 50 per cent. Under this, they will get 66? per cent. Fianna Fáil have argued all day that we should go back to the 50 per cent.

Comment on this

Under the farm improvements scheme, the Government gave 50 per cent. but the other 50 per cent. was given in labour. Under this scheme, they have to put down £12 in cash per acre.

Comment on this

Not at all. They get a grant of two-thirds instead of 50 per cent. That is the only difference.

Comment on this

Under which scheme?

Comment on this

This scheme.

Comment on this

Yes, but I want to point out that the class of people for whom I speak are unable to put down a cash deposit.

Comment on this

They need not put down a red halfpenny.

Comment on this

How, then, is his part of the burden financed? Is it proposed, if he cannot put down the money, to increase his land annuity?

Comment on this

No. There are two methods of getting the work done: (1) whereunder the farmer does it himself and gets a grant; and (2) if he does not choose to avail of that proposal, the method whereunder he asks the Department to do it for him.

Comment on this

That meets my point. What grant would he get?

Comment on this

A sum calculated to correspond to two-thirds of the estimated cost of the work. That is the 27th time I have given that piece of information to-day.

Comment on this

I was not in for the early part of the Minister's statement, and, if I have unduly delayed him by my ignorance of the matter, I apologise.

Comment on this

Not at all, Deputy.

Comment on this
John Flynn Mr. J. Flynn Independent

On behalf of the people I represent, I welcome this measure, which, I believe, is one of the best ever introduced in the history of this country. I am naturally inclined to ask the Minister—and possibly I may table a question on the matter—why our county was not included in the list.

Comment on this

It is in the next detachment.

Comment on this
John Flynn Mr. J. Flynn Independent

I disagree entirely with Deputy Bartley with regard to the congested areas. I also represent a congested area and the people there are so anxious about this scheme that they have asked me to suggest that a certain type of equipment be made available to the farmers in those areas. I was glad to hear the Minister mention here this evening the provision of modern equipment for carrying out this scheme and the people in my area suggest that compressors be provided for them in mountainous districts to enable them to clear the land of small rocks on the surface, these compressors to be hired out or made available through groups of people who would contract with the Department. That is a practical suggestion from the smallholders in these areas who would be enabled to do tremendous work in record time in clearing up large areas of land. That is the outlook of these people in regard to this matter and further in connection with this matter of equipment I make the suggestion that the type of equipment to be operated in these areas would be slightly different from the equipment to be operated on the flat lands of other counties. I take it that can be adjusted as the scheme operates. I congratulate the Minister on bringing forward this measure and on having the foresight and courage to launch this important scheme for the benefit of the farmers.

Comment on this

I am glad to tell Deputy Flynn that provision is made in the scheme for the providing of machinery suitable for whatever district it is to be used in and available to individuals or groups of individuals on the basis that, if they will put up one-third of the cost of the machinery, they will get a grant of one-third and a loan of the remaining one-third of the cost price. That does not exclude the possibility that, where men or a group of men are peculiarly suitable and are short of capital and circumstances make it peculiarly desirable to equip them, the percentage of the loan may even be made larger in order to enable them to take part.

I cannot feel that this Bill or project has been approached by the Fianna Fáil Party with the slightest desire to help anybody. Every kind of captious folly has been trotted out here to-day by Deputy Aiken, Deputy Allen and even Deputy Smith, and not infrequently, when their apparent misunderstandings were cleared up, they wandered off into incoherency, manifesting that their sole desire was to block and obstruct in every possible way they could. I do not know why. I do not think I said one word in introducing this measure calculated to disgruntle anybody. I very specially asked for the help of anybody who thought he could be of assistance. At a very early stage, Deputy Smith appeared to me to express an apprehension in regard to a matter about which I thought there was no need for apprehension and I was glad to say at once that, even if it did not so seem to me, if it so seemed to him and he wanted to submit an amendment calculated to relieve his mind, whether I thought it necessary or not, I would do my very best to put it into the Bill. The answer to that approach is impudence for the past seven hours.

It irritates me, I confess, when Deputy Bartley gets up at 10 o'clock at night and proceeds to deliver a long speech on the ground that the people in Connemara cannot afford to put up £12 to have their land reclaimed, and that we are remiss in having jettisoned the farm improvements scheme in favour of this much inferior proposal. Twenty-six times before Deputy Bartley spoke to-day I had informed the House that the fundamental difference between this proposal and the farm improvements scheme is that under the farm improvements scheme the person who did the drainage got 50 per cent. of the estimated cost and that under this scheme he got 66? per cent.

There was a great hullabaloo made here to-day about the provisions of Section 5, which was poetically described by Deputy Aiken as the smashing of the gates, the levelling of fences, the devastation of crops, the ruin of farmers. Then he proceeded to spell the section out and found it did not mean that at all, but it was quite good enough to say that if he was let get away with it. What is Section 5? —precisely what I asked the House to believe it was when I was opening. It is settled law for many, many years in Embrey v. Owen and in many cases analogous to that which one could quote ad nauseam, that the right to have the stream to flow in its natural state without diminution or alteration is an incident to the property in the land through which it passes. It is amply established in the common law that if any person whose land adjoins a waterway which serves the waterway of his neighbour obstructs that waterway the neighbour has a common law right to appeal to the courts and to get from the courts power to go in and carry out such works as may be necessary to abate the neighbour's attempt to deprive the litigant of his rights.

All of us know perfectly well that while in theory when you are engaged on a large project of this kind it is practical to proceed by the established procedure of the common law, in practice it would take longer to proceed by that method than the Board of Works takes about carrying through arterial drainage. Can I say more? It is just because we are not prepared to accept as the rational tempo of works of this kind that which was provided by our predecessors in the Arterial Drainage Act of 1945 that it has become necessary to deal with this whole drainage code. The contribution made by our predecessors to the solution of this problem was to pass the Arterial Drainage Act of 1945 which envisages the completion of this work in about 2010. We would all be dead and well buried before the work stipulated for under that Act would be carried into effect. If Deputy Aiken's thesis be correct, that we must do no drainage on the land of this country until arterial drainage is completed in accordance with the Schedule he approved, we will not turn a sod until 2010. Well may Deputies laugh for that is the proposal as made by Deputy Aiken.

Comment on this

It is not mine.

Comment on this

I wonder did the House hear Deputy Aiken rambling about the employment of the Marshall funds? Deputy Aiken says the Marshall funds accumulate in the Central Bank and there then devolves upon the Minister for Finance a duty to take them out and invest them. The Minister for Finance, Mr. McGilligan, recognising his duty to invest those funds safely, instead of choosing British Consols, chooses the land of Ireland and says that looking around the world at the present time, if you want to invest savings, about the safest place you could put them is to invest them in the land of Ireland and the people who live on it. He is reprehended by Deputy Aiken that he did not buy 2½ per cent. Consols or some British security which would be negotiable and handy when it was wanted. Perhaps we take what to Deputy Aiken is an unorthodox view in that matter but, contemplating the world around us and the stability of things, we venture to believe that the safest place in the world to-day in which the savings of this nation or any other nation could be invested is the land of Ireland and the people who live on it and that is where we are going to put the money. Are we mistaken? If we are, we are blameworthy. If we are not, Deputy Aiken should give up talking tosh in order to confuse the mind of the people because, if he wants to create the idea that improvident care is being taken of these funds, if he wants to create the idea in the country and abroad that that which we have undertaken to repay is being so used as to make repayment impossible, what he is in fact saying is that any money invested in the land of this country and the people who live on it is money lost. We do not share that view.

Comment on this

You did not spend any of it last year. We did before that.

Comment on this

Now he is going to make the case that he wants to do what we are doing more exhaustively than we ever contemplated doing. Ten minutes ago he was telling me that it was improvident spending of borrowed money and that the investment of the Marshall funds in this purpose was a very questionable operation.

That is what makes me perhaps a little short in temper when I listen to these men. I do not believe that they believe what they are saying but, anything they can say in malice to disturb the public mind, that they say. Anything they can do to frustrate the purpose of a project of this kind, that they do and they do it in the hope of reviving their battered political fortunes —a hopeless crusade but one does not blame them for playing, albeit vainly, for a return to the flesh-pots. But, I wish they would not allow their lust for lost glories to make mischief all the time.

The second horse they rode to-day was that it was a cruel shame that we did not supply everybody with free fertilisers—why should not we? Why is it that Fianna Fáil instinctively long to pauperise their neighbours? Free beef, free this, free that. Is there any public money we can shovel out? Have they lost all sense of dignity or pride? Have they forgotten what our people are like? Our people are not sycophant paupers who can be bought by shovelling public money into their hands. That is what has left Fianna Fáil where it is. You cannot intimidate our people or buy them in the long run, and the effort to do one and the other has relegated the powerful Fianna Fáil Party of yesteryear into eternal oblivion. It cuts no ice to start that hobbyhorse now. Nobody will fall for it any more. There is a perfectly clear principle here involved. Where there exists a situation of water-logging. collapse of fences, invasion by brushwood or other bracken or the like, the ubiquity of rock, or some characteristic of the land—the capital equipment to correct, which is utterly beyond the reach of any small farmer in this country—it is the purpose of this project to make available the means of doing that which the owner of the land has never been able to do since his father bought it from the landlord, and which he never would be able to do if the community as a whole are not prepared to make provision for doing it.

If we are to approach this problem that every acre of land is to be left forever abandoned unless, in terms of pounds, shillings and pence at 5 per cent., the expenditure can be justified on strict economic grounds, more than half this island would be evacuated and left to the Guano birds. If that is to be the test you can make an unanswerable case for evacuating a very considerable part of the island but that is not the test for me. I look rather at this from the other point of view— that our people love their land and want to keep it. I want to see them able to keep it and to live upon it in decent comfort. Two proposals are offered. Where, with the assistance of the local drainage contractor—provided for under Part II of the scheme —you can do the job yourselves, we will give you a grant corresponding to two-thirds of what we estimate the cost will be. The alternative is that by charging £12 per acre we will do the job for you. I am told by people like Deputy O'Rourke that this would constitute an unbearable burden on those improvident enough to avail of it—small farmers. The small farmer at this time has to pay £7 or £8 an acre for conacre and this scheme will provide him with an acre of land for 9/8 a year. A sum of 4/10 every six months will discharge his entire liability if he charges £12 an acre on his land; the annuity stretched over 60 years. Just imagine Deputy O'Rourke coming from North Roscommon, as I come myself, and telling me that where a farmer in that area charges his land which is restored from virtual dereliction to arability with 9/8 a year he is imperilling the fortunes of himself and his family for countless generations to come. That kind of mischievous, vicious misrepresentation is not the error of an ignorant man. Deputy O'Rourke is a well-known principal teacher in the West of Ireland. He must understand perfectly the nature of his own misrepresentation. All his neighbours are paying land annuities. Nobody knows better than he what 4/10 every six months means, every gale day. Nobody knows better than he what conacre costs. Nobody knows better than he the kind of land that is likely to be brought into a scheme of this kind in the area in which he lives. But it is good enough to come in here with that rather revolting, avuncular sincerity to express his apprehension and his concern.

Of course he does not want to discourage anybody or to cause unnecessary alarm but then he would not like to see small farmers dragged to the county home or to see their homesteads snatched from them or their families burdened down with debt as he has seen happen to improvident people in the past. I know every word of that to be a malicious, vicious effort to raise unnecessary apprehension in the minds of people foolish enough to have a misguided respect for that man's opinion. It does not distress him a bit that he is injuring his own neighbours if, thereby, he can do a bit of damage. That kind of malignant irresponsibility I confess revolts me. I am not at all averse to exchanging the ordinary thrust and parry of debate in political life. But where I see men like Deputy Blaney and Deputy O'Rourke cheerfully injuring their own neighbours in order to run some political scare for a purely political end I am revolted that they have the barefaced indecency to disgrace the public life of this country as they do.

Now we come to Deputy Allen. His heart was bleeding all over the House to-night. He did not want to provide cheap fertilisers; he wanted to provide a subsidy for fertilisers "like we used to do." Deputy Allen was distressed when he thought of the grand days when he was supporting the Fianna Fáil Government and the offhand way they used to subsidise fertilisers and he wept to think that those good old days were gone. The poor—I shall leave the adjective standing alone.

Comment on this

You got stuck.

Comment on this

The rules of order prescribe certain limitations. I should like to set the Deputy a good example. In 1945-46—those were the halcyon years—£120,000 was provided to subsidise fertilisers. Do you know, when the Appropriation Accounts came to be examined, how much exactly was spent subsidising fertilisers?—£1,463.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the Minister quoting from?

Comment on this

I had the figures before me in the terms which had been prepared. I am now quoting from column 1710 of the Official Reports from my speech winding up the Estimate with the prepared returns of my Department before me when I was speaking.

Comment on this

The figures related to a year in which you could not get manures.

Comment on this

That is as good an alibi as any other. We shall give you 1945-46. You got away with it in any case. We will not make you blush about that. But the next year there was a very dramatic gesture. The barrel bottom was scraped and the best they could do was £77,400. The last penny they could scrape up they were going to use it. They were sorry they could not do as well as the previous year, but needs must when the devil drives. Wait a moment and observe the drama associated with those years of lavish subsidies. They licked their thumb and pulled off £18,395 and, just as they were getting ready to bestow this on the deserving fertiliser manufacturers, someone came trotting in from next door and said: “Whoa, boys, those people got away with £39,512 the year before last; they overcharged the people that much; take it back from them,” which they promptly proceeded to do. So that in the second year all that happened was that they put £59,000 back in their hip pocket and collected £39,512 from the fertiliser manufacturers who had not taken it from the Government, but taken it from the farmers about whom poor Deputy Allen's heart was bleeding all over the place to-day. Having taken it from the farmers, there was no talk of giving it back to them. It was slipped in through the night safe in the Treasury and no one heard anything about it. There was not a rough word spoken about the noble Irish industrialists whom Deputy Allen hears referred to disrespectfully with such pain and distress. This was all kept as dark as night. Next year they said: “We are really going to do it. We are going to beg, borrow and steal and make a bit of a splash. We cannot quite do the £200,000, but we will just squeeze out £198,750.” They spent £19,058 out of £198,000 and the rest went back.

Deputy Allen got up here to-day and revelled for a quarter of an hour over the fact that the liberal, far-sighted, generous, flaitheamhlach gesture of the Administration he supported was being sadly departed from by the niggards now in charge. Why had we not come along and given free fertilisers to everybody? Why not? But, if we were going to give a good substantial subsidy, let no one speak a disrespectful word of the disinterested fertiliser manufacturers in this country. Are they not doing the best they can to serve Cathleen Ni Houlihan faithfully, economically, disinterestedly? Why not give them a decent subsidy, the hardworking men? Deputy Allen was not aware of the £39,000 which somehow lost its way in the counting house of the manufacturers until a bloodhound was sent in to get it. If the bloodhound was not as good a bloodhound as we hope he was, God knows what he left after him that we never heard about.

I shall venture to tell the House an interesting story. I do not believe in providing cheap fertilisers for our people by doling out hundreds of thousands of pounds to the sulphuric acid cartel, the phosphate cartel, the potash cartel, or the nitrogen combine. I had an interesting experience quite recently. We learned from the French Comptoir which controls phosphates that the price of French phosphate rock f.o.b. Algiers was 32/6 per ton, or we thought we learned that. Our informant spent a pleasant couple of days in Dublin enjoying the hospitality of our city and doubtless meeting his friends. Before leaving, he thought it right to take his leave of us. He took the precaution on the occasion of his second visit to mention that he seemed to charge himself, if his memory served him well, with a slip of the tongue; that he should not have said 32/6, but that he should have said 47/6—a significant and interesting change. I subsequently heard from a competent critic the comment in the course of conversation that it was in no way surprising that a Government-controlled or directed enterprise should be asked to pay about 15/- per ton more than Deputy Allen's little darlings, who of course had to have their profit. The distributing agents had to live and 15/- was not an unreasonable margin. I should imagine that 15/- was 9d. a cwt. and if six cwts. were to be employed on every arable acre of land in Ireland that represents 4/6 per acre. No exploiter in the history of this country ever claimed that a vested interest, great or small, could assert a right to levy 4/6 per acre on the land of Ireland and no vested interest ever will. If Deputy Allen thinks that I would ask the Government of this country to provide subsidies from the public purse to ensure that those disinterested patriots never know poverty or distress he has another think coming. This Government will get cheap fertiliser for our people with or without the help of cartels of that kind. Legitimate business is praiseworthy in this community. Anyone who wants to carry on a legitimate business in this country is welcome to do so, but domestic and foreign cartels had better make up their minds once and for all that there is no cartel in this world, foreign or domestic, strong enough successfully to challenge a sovereign democratic Government. Any cartel that has got it into their head, foreign or domestic, that it can levy with impunity on the people of this country in their Government's despite, will never know what hit them because, remember, the most effective weapon against it is the light of day, and it will be let in upon them from a variety of angles if they try those tricks again. Perhaps Deputy Allen understands why I do not propose to ask the Government to open the Treasury to these harmless little creatures; why I would not ask the Government to pay these gentle, patriotic souls for permitting our people to have access to their wares. No, I will not ask this Government to subsidise any cartel anywhere. But we charge ourselves with the responsibility of getting fertilisers for our people at a price they can afford to pay and at a price which will leave them a fair profit after they have used them in accordance with rational husbandry.

Deputy Allen allowed his generous heart to bleed again because we would not subsidise lime. He just loves to subsidise things for the fun of it. Ground limestone is available in this country at 16/- per ton at any pit where it is ground. That is cheaper than it is available in any country in the world. We plan to make it available, spread on the land, anywhere in Ireland at 30/-, far or near. Now, I know that according to Fianna Fáil mentality that hope will be frustrated because the farmer who lives near the lime grinding plant will grudge the fact that he has to pay the same price as the man who lives a great distance away. If you explain that, in order to get the flat price for all, the man living close at hand may have to pay a little more, whereas the man living at a distance pays a little less, I believe our people are not so mean and grasping and grudging that if they feel they are getting good value themselves they will snarl with discontent because their neighbour is able to get the same. I do not believe Deputy Aiken is right in reading the character of our people that because one man is paying £12 for £16 worth the whole character will be distorted because somebody else got £20 worth for £12. How does the fact that somebody else gets £18 worth for £12 affront him if he knows that in both cases the net result is that land which was derelict is arable now, no more nor less than that?

I listened closely to-day to the Fianna Fáil hobby-horse and watched them ride it to the very brink and, realising the logic of their case, gallop off into irrelevance when they saw the chasm open under their feet. Their proposal is that where a man has a good farm, plenty of land, fences, drains and everything in first-class order with the land wanting fertilisers, there is a duty on this Government to go into him and spread on his land for nothing, or for a tithe of cost, fertilisers guaranteed to enable him to get from his land a crop which will not only produce in autumn sufficient to pay for the fertilisers but leave him an ample profit as well. Unless we have all gone mad we will not disgrace our people by making such a proposal. Have we reached the stage where farmers of this country want their Government to come in, plough their land, harrow their land, fertilise their land, sow seed on it and leave them sitting on their sashes till the crop is matured, save the crop and put the proceeds in their pockets? Where are we to stop? Bear in mind if you once make the case that the Government must do for a farmer upon his land that which it is well within his own capacity to do and to earn a profit, you cannot draw the line. If you admit the obligation to fertilise soil which is well able to provide an abundant and profitable crop given the suitable fertilisers, the next problem is that if you have land which has matted grass upon it—scutch and moss—a sod must be broken, and that if a man has not got the means to purchase the right variety of seed that you have to provide him with grass seed, and that we are reaching the stage when we have got to plough the land, and to harrow it, that we have got to fertilise it and to sow it, and then, I suppose, for tidiness sake we will roll it before we go. What has become of the farmers of Ireland into whose care we have committed our land?

If I believed that I would not want to see an acre of land of this country in the keeping of such people; if I believed that of the farmers of this country I would be ashamed to say that I came of their stock; if I believed that the farmers in this country who, by their own exertions, could earn an honest living on their own holdings, preferred to charge themselves upon the public purse I would abandon hope of Ireland. Then Deputy Aiken would be a thousand times right if those facts were true, and it would be madness to invest our savings in the land of this country and in the people who live and get their living on it; but it is because we believe those things are not true, it is because we believe that the farmers on the land of this country, given the opportunity to get a fair return for hard work honestly done and who will do hard work on any land that they can call their own and that is so conditioned as to give them a reasonable return, that we do not hesitate to invest the money for which we stand trustee for the Irish people in them and their land, confident that there is no safer place that we could put it.

I have another word to say. We will import phosphates in any form that we can get them. We will grind phosphates and take any other measures that it may be necessary to take to protect our people from exploitation as they require fertilisers without which our people cannot live.

I want to answer some specific points which Deputies raised. I used to feel with Deputy Giles when Deputy O'Reilly began to moan and groan, but I got rather to like it. He moans and groans in an agreeable way; he is always gracious; he always foresees disaster around the corner, and gloom and catastrophe, and he is as genial and as happy as a sand boy when his hideous anticipations do not materialise. I often think of the pessimists of this world, like Deputy O'Reilly, that their whole life must be one series of glorious surprises.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Which Deputy O'Reilly?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Reilly of Meath. I do not know that Deputy Patrick O'Reilly is a little ray of sunshine, but he is not quite so gloomy as the Deputy from Meath. I am happy to think that from time to time they experience some little surprises to light up the gloom which they gather about themselves. Deputy Collins pointed out, very correctly, that any farmer who does not want to avail himself of the scheme is free not to do so. It is only those who ask us who can conceivably contract any obligation under the plan at all.

I have dealt with most of the dreary rubbish that Deputy Allen contributed to the debate. I have dealt with the apprehensions alleged to exist in regard to Section 5. I have no apprehensions at all and I offer no amendment, but if an amendment is offered in good faith by the Opposition to meet some apprehension of theirs, they are quite entitled to have it carefully and sympathetically considered, and it certainly will. I need hardly assure the House that we would never contemplate entering any man's land to get access to a common drain without notifying and consulting his convenience in every possible way we could.

I have not the faintest doubt that the compulsory powers envisaged by Section 5 will never be used, because the only circumstances in which powers of that kind would fall to be used is where you get a cranky person, and usually once such people are convinced of the uselessness of being cranky they will give up being cranky and get sense. I do not think that I can make the proposal to pay something on account when work is part done any clearer than I have already made it. Our aim is not to embarrass people who are short of money, in so far as it is practicable to meet their requirements, without running the risk of wasting public money or leaving a job half done and in such a way that it will not function at all. I have already told the House that we have received about 2,000 applications in response to the advertisement.

There is such a great hullabaloo made sometimes that I feel inclined to ignore it all. This Parliament and our liberties depend on the deference that I am bound to, and I hope I do, show to the Opposition, and in deference to their constitutional right I reply to their complaint that the farm improvements staff should do the work of this project. I think that proposal was made for the purpose of suggesting that the real distinction between this project and the farm improvement scheme was so trivial that the sensible thing would be to throw away pretence and let the whole thing go on together. Of course, the fact is that the farm improvements scheme—and I have no desire, whatever, to asperse it—bears no relation whatever to this project in magnitude or in scope. It may console the Deputies in opposition to know that we have so far expanded and expedited the farm building scheme that the entire staffs appropriate to both the building and improvement schemes are now fully engaged on farm building alone. The Deputies opposite will find it difficult to accustom themselves to the dispatch with which public business is now attended to. I know the stuffy incompetence and dreary nonchalance that descended on them in their 16 disastrous years, but they will learn, as we go along, that that basis is no longer sufficient and is no longer tolerated.

I agree with the Deputy who found some difficulty in foreseeing how the annuity would work—I think it was Deputy Timoney. I confess it took the burning of some midnight oil on my part to fathom the labyrinthine mysteries of the Land Commission and how they do these things, but they have some elaborate procedure whereby they notionally ascertain the existing land annuity and they notionally ascertain the reclamation annuity; they combine the two together and then the whole is repayable on the basis of £4 per cent. per annum. If the Deputy is much wiser now than he was before, I will be very much surprised, but this is one of these concepts which I grasp, like the Marquis of Salisbury when he was discussing the Ireland Bill, for ten minutes and it then eludes me. If the Deputy is concerned with this matter, I think he need not be in the least ashamed in joining me in momentary confusion, as the Lord President of the Council in Great Britain was obliged to join the Marquis of Salisbury in the confusion which overcame them.

I have no doubt that when Deputy Timoney and I retire in conference on this matter, as I shall hope to do, our passing confusion will be more readily elucidated than the Lord President of the Council or the Marquis of Salisbury can hope to have theirs. I ask the Deputy, who is familiar with the ways of the law, to understand that the procedure of the Land Commission in consolidating and fixing land annuities is not easy to expound extempore, but the net result is that the land annuity is augmented by a sum either rather less or rather more than you would expect it to be.

Comment on this

Is the sum repayable irrespective of the date of the expiration of the land annuity?

Comment on this

I think whatever balance of annuity in respect of the purchase agreement is outstanding, the term over which the reclamation annuity will be repayable is the full 60 years. Whether they take the balance of the purchase annuity and spread that over the same period, I am not quite sure, but in so far as the reclamation annuity is concerned it extends to the full period of 60 years, repayable at the rate of £4 per cent. per annum. It could happen that by the addition of the land annuity and its extension over the whole period you might have a reduction in the customary gale period of the land annuity, but a payment of rather more than the 4 per cent. you would have expected to pay if the two annuities were kept segregated.

Comment on this

Is there a danger that anybody who avails of this new loan will have this annuity extended for another 60 years?

Comment on this

You mean his land annuity? I understood one of the triumphs I have achieved was to be able to report to the House yet again the unfailing readiness of the Minister for Finance of this Government to provide money on advantageous terms for anything that will benefit agriculture and that he had readily made available money and found a way to do it on which repayment would not be required for a term shorter than 60 years, at 3½ per cent. interest. If we shorten the term we raise the annual burden. I would have thought we would all agree that the desire was to get a long term with a low rate of interest and sinking fund. That is what I got. If I have been mistaken and if Deputies think it would be better to have charged £8 per annum for a shorter period, I would be glad to discuss that with them, but I would be hard to convince.

Comment on this

The point I am confused on is that you have people who have purchased land under various Acts. For those who have purchased under the Ashbourne Act the period of redemption is nearly finished and if they get a loan for the purpose of the reclamation scheme for 60 years does it mean that this is a separate annuity that will carry on after the land annuity has been finished?

Comment on this

If they have only four years of their land purchase annuity to go and they propose to repay their land reclamation loan through a period of 60 years, it must be manifest that if they ask to have a charge put upon their land which may be discharged over 60 years, in theory that can and will be done, but suppose two years later a wealthy American aunt dies intestate and they inherit £1,000,000, they can direct the Land Commission to compute for them the redemption value of the annuity, pay it on the nail and the whole horror goes.

I beg Deputies on all sides of the House to believe that there is not a nigger in the wood pile, that there is no awful plot to make land annuities permanent, that there is no hideous scheme in the mind of the Minister to grab from the farmers something they are not entitled to pay. There is nothing at all except what money they borrow for the purpose. They may undertake repayments on whatever terms suit them best. They may accept a grant or they may declare the prerogative of a lady and choose to have it charged on Monday and redeem it on the following Wednesday. I think the versatility of these proposals is unprecedented. The Bill is drafted to meet the wishes of the farmer and not of the Minister for Agriculture, which, I agree with Deputy Lehane, is quite a surprising departure from recent legislation.

Comment on this

I want it made clear for the information of people in the country as to what exactly are the implications of this Bill. I think that there is a certain amount of confusion in my mind and in the minds of the people in the country.

Comment on this

Will the Minister indicate what the legal position is? Is it that the new charge will be charged on the fee simple and can be redeemed in the same manner as the land annuity?

Comment on this

I am obliged to Deputies for attracting my attention to the possibility of misunderstanding, which I very fully appreciate, because most country people are a little allergic in the matter of land annuities. I agree with Deputy Lehane and Deputy McMenamin that it is necessary not only to expound the matter but to expound it in a form that will be clear and that will carry conviction. I think the simplest way we can do it is this. The land annuity is not affected, good or bad. We simply elect to use that machinery for an entirely different purpose and to establish quite a different annuity, the reclamation annuity, the payment of which and the duration of which has no connection with the land annuity at all. Some people have felt a certain qualm of conscience in relation to this scheme.

The House should know quite explicitly that that matter was considered and quite deliberately overridden because it was determined that, as the Department of Agriculture was the authority charged with the work, it was not to be assumed that they would undertake to do under the project the rehabilitation of land which should not have been done; and that, unless the landholder was to get in the work done more than the value of the money charged on the land we would not do the work. Does the Deputy follow me?

Comment on this

I do not follow that at all.

Comment on this

The Department of Agriculture anticipated that it would, in fact, do work to the value of £30 on an acre of land for which it would charge the farmer only £12. The Department of Agriculture would reject any proposal where circumstances only permitted of the doing of work which would not enhance the value of the land at least by £12, if not by more. Therefore, we feel that putting the charge on the land and allowing the charge to go with the land, on which every improvement ultimately will be doubly repaid, is no injustice because, if the land carries the charge with it, it also carries the extra value which we put into it. If we do not do that—and this is something I think the Deputy will readily understand—the whole project would become impossible because we would find ourselves tied up in the investigation of titles in the Land Commission and it would be Tibb's Eve before anything at all could be done. Many of the most deserving cases—small farmers who have not taken out administration for two or three generations—could not be touched unless the occupiers of the lands were prepared to incur expenses far greater than they could readily contemplate.

Now, having exchanged the first round of this debate—the tone of which I think I may legitimately say I did not set—I would very much prefer if we could recover the spirit of co-operation so that all would join with me in making the very best we can of this project. I cannot impose goodwill on the Fianna Fáil Party; but, unlike Deputy O'Reilly, I am an optimist and I still go on hoping for it and am disappointed. I am still prepared to hope. If I can depend upon that goodwill it will be of very material assistance. I can do the job without it if it is withheld albeit the difficulties will be greater. I earnestly urge upon the Fianna Fáil Party that they now have an opportunity of contributing something useful and that, for once, they might take that opportunity. I want to reassure them that if they want to block, if they want to obstruct and if they want to hold this project up, as they have held up the local authorities' scheme and as they have tried to hold up most other things, their constitutional rights will be strictly respected. A minority is perfectly safe in the hands of this Government. They need not, however, hope thereby to exhaust our patience so far as to suffer the loss of their rights. We stand trustees for all their liberties and we will preserve them safely.

Comment on this

Nobody is holding it up now except yourself.

Comment on this

I had hoped that the switch which has recently taken place in the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party would accrue to my benefit. Apparently it has not been as complete as that yet. Nine months ago the sewer-pipe of Fianna Fáil policy was directed exclusively upon me. For the last week I observe my colleague, the Minister for External Affairs, is the target. I feel quite lonesome. I wonder could any of my comments be used by the ability of the correspondent of the "kept newspaper" to justify a Parthian shot.

Comment on this

Your vanity is offended when nobody talks about you.

Comment on this

I would be grateful for the delivery if thereby we could speed up our proceedings in this House. Apart from that, I am not distressed. I do not suppose that the Minister for External Affairs is losing any sleep from apprehension. It is always a pleasure to provide material to help along a poor old thing like the "‘kept' newspaper."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not seem to be relevant to this Bill.

Comment on this

All I suggest is that they keep on burning their fuel. That I do not mind. But if they would be so good as not to wreak their vengeance by wasting the public time of this House, of which we have so little that, if they continue, we shall be here until August——

Comment on this

What are you doing now? You are wasting time now. Would the Minister get on with the Bill?

Comment on this

I suppose I am. I suppose any suggestion to Fianna Fáil to mend its ways is a waste of time. I will waste no more.

Comment on this

I wonder would the Minister allow me to put one further question to him on this system of repayment of the annuity. I am raising this question because frankly I do not understand the position. I think Deputy Lehane does not understand it either and I feel there are others in the House who labour under the same difficulty. I shall put it by way of a concrete example. Let us take the case of a farmer whose annuity is £10. Let us assume that the balance still outstanding will be redeemed or paid off finally in five years' time. Under this Act that farmer becomes liable for the payment of a reclamation annuity. Let us say that the amount for which he becomes liable is £5 per annum. Now, that £5 will be payable over a period of 60 years, as I understand the Minister. It will be added on to the outstanding part of the land purchase annuity. Are we to take it that for the next five years the farmer will pay a consolidated annuity of £15 and that at the end of that five years the £10 land annuity comes off, because he no longer owes it under the land purchase scheme, and he then continues to pay £5 a year for the remaining 55 years under this project. It that correct?

Comment on this

Yes, that is substantially the case. The all-important point to make is that the land annuity is not affected, altered, or changed in any particular. Any farmer may avail of two separate annuities. He may avail of a land annuity terminating on the date on which he expected it to terminate, unchanged and unaltered in any particular. He will have an entirely different receivable order in respect of the money involved under this scheme, so that he is paying on one receivable order the balance of his land annuity. Perhaps he has only four years to go and at the end of that four years his land annuity is for ever discharged. Is that clear?

Comment on this

That is clear.

Comment on this

There remains the liability for the money which he borrows under the land rehabilitation scheme. Is that clear?

Comment on this

That is clear, but I understood that the land reclamation annuity and the land purchase annuity would be consolidated.

Comment on this

That is what is in the Bill. The Minister has not read it.

Comment on this

Unlike the Deputy, who wants to make mischief, Deputy Timoney and I want to avoid the possibility of any doubt creeping into the people's minds that a charge under this Bill would in some mysterious way extend the period over which their land annuities would become due and payable.

Comment on this

That will be said on every platform in West Cork before the end of the week.

Comment on this

It will, and you can see that the two distinguished occupants of the front bench opposite have already begun to say it. That is not true and they well believe that it is not true, but all the buttons and the bows well calculated to mislead the people about whom they know little else——

Comment on this

Are we starting the debate over again?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy might be answered without reopening the debate.

Comment on this

I want to make a statement in reply to the question of the Deputy and while I was making that statement, clearly and explicitly, an interjection was made by a Deputy in opposition that has no other purpose except to create in the minds of the people the impression that there is some ambiguity. There is no ambiguity whatsoever about the statement that not one farthing or one week will be added to the period for which the land annuity is payable.

Comment on this

That is clear.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister another question? The Taoiseach, in referring to this Bill some time ago, announced that no increased valuations would be put on land that was reclaimed under the scheme. The Minister has not referred to that matter. I should like if the Minister would reiterate what the Taoiseach said outside the House in that respect.

Comment on this

The question was asked of me at Mullingar and my reply was: "Over my dead body". I have nothing to add to that.

Comment on this

He cannot live a lie.

Comment on this

I think the Minister had better consider sub-section (3) to make it conform with his speech.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When is it proposed to take the Committee Stage?

Comment on this

Would the House consider it unreasonable if I were to ask for all the remaining stages now?

Comment on this

Yes, utterly unreasonable.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not consider some amendments to the Bill?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wishes to submit amendments, we can take them this day week.

Comment on this