We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1949—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–200 of 401. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 14 of 1949 ›

Would the Minister inform the House as to how much he expects to get out of income-tax this year?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Minister for Finance (Mr. McGilligan) Fine Gael

I expect to lose £750,000 this year and £1,000,000 next year.

Comment on this

What is the total?

Comment on this

The figures of income-tax show that there is £725,000 over from last year and that I will lose £750,000 in this part of this year.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know what he is going to get? There was over £13,000,000 anyway collected in the year before. The point is that the Minister used to growl about the unjust burden that taxation imposed upon the people of this country when the Vote for the Central Fund and Supply Services was around £65,000,000. In the last year of the Fianna Fáil Government, the year ending in April, 1948, the expenditure issued from the Exchequer for Central Fund and Supply Services was £65,000,000. This year the Minister has budgeted for the Central Fund and Supply Services for the sum of £72,916,000, which is almost £8,000,000 more than was spent.

Comment on this

On income-tax?

Comment on this

On income-tax, the Minister has admitted that he will get at least over £13,000,000, and if he had lived up to the promise of his leader he would have reduced taxation by £10,000,000. He would have budgeted for £55,000,000 this year instead of £73,000,000.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must keep to income-tax; it is what the section deals with.

Comment on this

Income-tax could have been nil. Instead of having Section 1 of the Bill, the Minister could have had several other sections reducing taxation all round. He could, in fact, have reduced taxation, if he had lived up to his promises by £18,000,000 this year.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is endeavouring to make a Budget speech.

Comment on this

I do not intend to make a Budget speech but I ask the Minister to recognise that at one time he declared that the income-tax was an unjustifiable burden on the people and an extortion. He calmly proposes this year to collect by way of income-tax the sum of £13,000,000, although if he had lived up to his promise, he could have reduced that income-tax to nil and have about £5,000,000 left for the reduction of other taxes. The Taoiseach down in Bantry a fortnight ago said that there had been a reduction in taxation of £7,000,000. If that were true, half the income-tax might have been avoided.

Comment on this

The position is, and it seems that it must be evident even to the Deputy's mind, that before the Budget of 1948 this Government remitted to the people the taxation on beer and tobacco which had been collected by Fianna Fáil and that cost the Exchequer over £6,000,000. This year I am giving back £750,000 and that is £7,000,000 to any simple mind. If the Deputy lives long enough to attain the use of reason, he will recognise that that is an easy calculation. In addition, there were increases in old age pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions and it becomes further evident that while reducing the burden of taxation by £7,000,000 a year, certain further additions were given. I calculate that if they had not been given, the reduction in taxation could have been £11,000,000. It is quite true that if I had not bothered to take the tax off beer and tobacco, there could have been heavy reductions as far as income-tax is concerned, but we decided to do it the other way.

Comment on this

The Minister has not denied the figure he gave in his Budget statement of £72,916,000. That is more than £7,000,000, nearly £8,000,000 more than the sum spent by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1947-48 which was £65,165,000. The Minister's leader in that year went around the country saying that he was going to reduce taxation by £10,000,000. That would have meant that he would have reduced it to £55,000,000 instead of £73,000,000. There is no denying those figures as the Minister has published them in the Financial Statement 1949, which was circulated at the time of the Budget. In view of that fact of the additional £8,000,000 being collected from the people, the taxation has been increased by £8,000,000 instead of being reduced by £10,000,000.

The Taoiseach misinformed the people when he said that they would reduce taxation. The rate of taxation has been reduced with regard to tobacco and certain other things, but the rate of taxation in regard to certain other matters has been increased and the Minister has not only increased the rate of certain existing taxes but has imposed totally new taxes. He has collected money for Central Government expenditure by increasing the national health stamps.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This section deals with income-tax and surtax.

Comment on this

And it is a section for which the Minister does not even tell us what he expects to get. We know that it is more than £13,000,000 which was collected in the year to which I am referring and if the Minister had lived up to his promise he might have reduced taxation to nil.

Comment on this

The situation I have to make clear to the Deputy is that while the gallop of Fianna Fáil was stopped by the people, they left us a Book of Estimates which showed that they were going to budget for £70,500,000, plus Central Fund £7,000,000, that is £77,500,000. I cut that down—it is cut down already. The Deputy has insisted a lot on what Fianna Fáil spent. That was the last time they got a chance to spend. In the Supplementary Budget of 1947, they put on extra taxation because they had additional proposals to spend £10,000,000 or £11,000,000 more in the year. That is a gallop which we stopped, and we made the savings.

If the Deputy says that I have increased taxation, he must face up to this. The beer and tobacco duties were remitted. They were going to bring over £6,000,000. On one single tax, the remission of 6d. in income-tax, there is £1,000,000 in a full year. That is £7,000,000 in total in a full year. That is all taken off. Would the Deputy say what has been put on? There was one major tax last year— on petrol—which was offset by an extra subvention to the people, an increased allowance of tea at the subsidised price, and a variety of other things. If the Deputy says we are spending more than what Fianna Fáil did spend, he is forgetting that Fianna Fáil had contemplated spending £77,500,000 at least in the year 1948-49, only that the people thought better of it and decided they would not stand for that taxation.

Comment on this

The Minister speaks about "the Fianna Fáil gallop" when the actual expenditure in that year was £65,000,000. If it was a gallop to spend that, it is a runaway to spend £73,000,000. It is admitted, of course, that the rates of taxes on beer and tobacco were reduced. They were increased to meet a very special occasion and it was found in the next year, when the budgetary position was being examined, that more money could be got even if the taxes on those particular things were reduced. If the Minister had lived up to his promises to reduce taxation by £10,000,000, he would now be budgeting for £55,000,000. Instead of that, he is budgeting for £73,000,000 for Central Fund and Supply Services. There is no getting around those figures, which have been published by the Minister.

Comment on this

I am budgeting for £7,000,000 less than Fianna Fáil was budgeting for.

Comment on this

The Minister is budgeting for £8,000,000 more than Fianna Fáil spent in the last year.

Comment on this

That is all they were allowed to spend.

Comment on this

Apart altogether from the budgetary figures, the Minister is taking the extraordinary step of taking extra from black market or half-grey market tea and sugar, and getting an additional £500,000 from the ordinary postage stamps.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will have to close down definitely and insist that this section be discussed on the basis of what is in it—incometax and surtax.

Comment on this

I hope to answer the Minister's question, and his challenge across the House as to what he did, if the Chair would bear with me for two seconds. In addition, the Minister took £220,000 from widows and orphans and took the extraordinary step of taking from the Post Office Savings Bank £500,000. All these are additional and queer types of taxation, all to make up the additional £8,000,000 which the Minister proposes to spend this year.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This is totally irrelevant.

Comment on this

On the 1948/49 Estimate, the calculation Fianna Fáil had for their expenditure that year was £70,500,000. If you add £6,500,000 for the Central Fund, there is a bill of £77,000,000. Faced with that, I made certain economies. The first thing we did in relief of the people was the remitting of taxation amounting to £6,000,000 on beer and tobacco, with £1,000,000 this year in income-tax. That is, to the simplest mind, a saving of £7,000,000.

Comment on this

It is not a saving if you spend £8,000,000 more.

Comment on this

It is a saving of £7,000,000.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I take it that this section has one purpose only—to meet the decision in Cafolla's case. I should like to know whether I am right in that premise.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Therefore we have incorporated in this Bill a specific section designed to meet an individual case which was recently decided in the courts.

Comment on this

It does not touch that case.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I want to get at that now. It may touch the people for the future?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

A certain decision was arrived at in the Supreme Court adverse to the Revenue Commissioners. Substantially, the matter is a question, where a parent and his children are in a partnership, of collecting tax. Whatever about arguing the principle of that in general terms, the Minister does not say this does not affect the case. Clearly it does not affect the case up to the moment, but if—and probably it will happen—the particular set of circumstances which gave rise to this particular case continue as from the date of the passing of the Act, it seems to me that those particular persons will be subject to assessment under the terms of this section. In other words, there is a peculiar retrospective effect here. An arrangement was come to, in the particular circumstances of that case, before the passing of this Bill, and the rights under that arrangement, already subsisting at the passing of the Bill, have been determined and adjudicated on by the Supreme Court. The effect of the Supreme Court decision was merely to determine the actual legal relationship of the Revenue Commissioners on the one hand and these persons on the other, in relation to a certain set of circumstances which existed before the Act. This set of circumstances will continue for the future. It seems to me that, on the application of this section, whereas assessments for the past are not interfered with, on exactly the same set of circumstances these people are going to be assessed for the future.

Now, I wonder if that is a fair thing. I hasten to tell the Minister that I know nothing of the particular circumstances of this case beyond what would be available in official reports. I have had no personal dealings with the case, nor do I know anything about facts that have not come out in court. It would seem that the Minister is creating under this section a precedent. In 1937 and onwards, the law was in a particular form, and, if these people wanted to come to some arrangement at that time, we can credit them with having come to their arrangement in their knowledge of the law as it was at the time. For purposes of argument, we will assume that these people decided to do this in the light of legal advice. Now we are changing this, having allowed the matter to be adjudicated on in court and having allowed it to run for some time. The result is to deprive these people of the certainty of a particular statutory condition as existing at that time. I wonder is that desirable. It takes away all certainty in the matter of people's rights in such contractual or quasi-contractual matters. Is it desirable from the point of view of certainty of rights?

It simply means that you are establishing the precedent here that, no matter what a person does in the light of the law existing at a particular moment, and despite the fact that a decision upholding the rights of these people has been given, notwithstanding the fact that their rights are upheld on that basis, a Department of State for one reason or another comes along and, finding itself defeated in the court, is able to go to the Minister responsible and get a section like this passed. It seems to me to be a type of legislation the principle of which, if admitted, would ultimately deprive the private citizen of almost all rights. Having regard to the danger of that precedent and to the fact that, I should imagine, the revenue yield from such a provision would be relatively small, will the Minister not agree that the section had better be omitted?

Comment on this

I must confess that I do not understand what the Deputy is driving at, except that he is trying to make the point that what the law is at one time it should remain for ever. Take income-tax—I could not therefore reduce the income-tax rate by 6d. People would have made arrangements on the basis of a 7/- income-tax rate, and it would be quite wrong for me to put them in the new position in which they would have to pay 6d. less. The Deputy forgets that the Act of 1922 was brought in for the purpose of defeating attempts made successfully to evade payment of income-tax. That law was passed in 1922, but later, further loopholes were discovered through which people were able to make their escape, and, in 1937, the Party to which the Deputy belongs stopped some of these loopholes. A new loophole has been found, which I am stopping. I am not interfering with the rights of people who have contested a case in court— they are left alone. I am dealing with the future as from the date to which the Budget relates.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I appreciate that point on the Minister's part, but the point I am making is that you are affecting a decision of the court. I would agree with the Minister if he were to say: "I will stop this loophole from a future date" and that all such arrangements entered into as from the date of this enactment would be affected in the way the Minister wants. The point I am making, however, is that an arrangement was come to, perfectly legally—whether it was evasion from the Minister's point of view or not—and was come to anterior to this Act, under which certain rights accrued to these people.

Comment on this

That happened in 1937 and the then Government blocked it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That does not make the slightest difference to my argument. I am trying to deal objectively with this point, that, under an arrangement made anterior to this Act, certain people had certain rights. These rights were determined by the court and these rights were attached to an arrangement made before this section can come into operation. I think this amendment is the type of amendment which goes very far in an undesirable direction. I would have no objection if the Minister were to say that it would apply to all such arrangements which have not been come to as from a certain date—let him go back to the 4th May or whatever reasonable date he wishes. What I am objecting to is this ad hoc legislation which specifically defeats for the future the rights of these people and people in similar circumstances whose rights have accrued and are actually vested by reason of an executed transaction prior to the passing of the section. There is a distinction between that situation where rights are vested and the point the Minister has made about amending the income-tax rate. It might be desirable to limit this section to prospective operation. The amount that will be involved for the Exchequer will be negligible and, as I say, there is a fairly substantial principle involved.

Comment on this

The principle was broken in 1937. We are not doing anything more than that.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to give us the rates of taxation on the various weapons as they stood, in order to compare them with the rates in Schedule 10.

Comment on this

The present rates are: Rifle, 5/-; pistol or revolver, 5/-; shotgun for limited use, 5/-; shotgun, general use, first certificate, £2; and shotgun, general use, second or subsequent certificate, 5/-.

Comment on this

We have the rather extraordinary situation arising whereby the Minister for Justice allows people belonging to an illegal organisation to carry arms openly, while the Minister for Finance proposes to quadruple the tax payable by a person who has a .22 rifle. That is going a little too far. The farmer who has a shotgun for killing vermin, for killing crows and foxes which are running away with his fowl, will have to pay double what he paid last year. I know that I cannot convince the Minister that the Fianna Fáil Government was not a rapacious Government which robbed the poor taxpayers, but we did not go to the length of doubling the tax on the farmer's shotgun or quadrupling the tax on a .22 rifle, while leaving people illegally to carry arms openly without any tax. They can have machine guns, but the person who paid 5/- on a .22 rifle is to be charged four times that amount hereafter, according to the Minister's proposal. I cannot see that the Minister is so short of funds that he must behave in this fashion towards people who have admitted that they have arms and are prepared to pay a State tax for the right to hold them.

In the matter of the details, the Minister is behaving in a rather extraordinary way. He proposes to raise the £2 for a game licence by 5/-, that is, increasing it by one-eighth, while he proposes to double the farmer's licence—the farmer who pays 5/- for the right to carry a shotgun on his lands for the destruction of vermin.

Comment on this

A shotgun!

Comment on this

A firearm. Number three in the schedule describes a firearm limited to the use of killing animals and birds or game on the lands of every person to whom a certificate has been granted.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy is reading it correctly.

Comment on this

It is in fact a shotgun for the killing of vermin on farmers' land. If the Minister thinks my interpretation of number three in the schedule is not right then he should seek advice. All these words boil down to this: that the farmer who confines himself to killing vermin has to buy a shotgun certificate for 5/- and the Minister now proposes to double that, making it 10/-. That is a 100 per cent. increase and at the same time he is only putting one-eighth increase on the others who want to kill game and who have hitherto paid £2 for the licence. Why should there be that big difference? The Minister talked about the difference in the value of money from the time this tax was first imposed but the shillings in the £2 licence have depreciated to the same extent as the shillings in the 5/-licence for the farmer's gun. Why should the farmer's licence for a shotgun be doubled when the Minister is only increasing by 12 per cent. the £2 game licence?

The other thing I want to say in regard to this is that it is completely wrong to quadruple the licence for a .22 rifle. The Minister for Defence and others would like to see the young people who joined the defence services trained to be good marksmen. The young man who gets a licence and has someone around to teach him can go into the Army as a marksman and save the State that amount in training. He can also join the Local Defence Services and when he does he enters as a marksman.

I think we should encourage miniature rifle clubs and the young men of the country to shoot straight provided that they do it in a legal way. It is all wrong that we should discourage people from carrying arms in a legal way and encourage them to carry arms illegally and free. The Minister made a very bad shot at increasing taxation when he increased one tax by 100 per cent. and only increased another by one-eighth.

Comment on this

You want the one-eighth increased four fold.

Comment on this

I object very strongly to this increased taxation. Indeed if the Minister had reduced taxation by £10,000,000 instead of increasing it by £8,000,000 he could not only have reduced these licences but could have given a machine-gun to every person in the country. I hope Deputy O'Higgins is not going to support this particular distribution of taxation because he is one of those who went around the country complaining about the rapacious, grasping Fianna Fáil Government that had increased taxation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought to deal with the section.

Comment on this

I would like Deputy O'Higgins to explain to the farmers in Leix-Offaly why it is that this great Government in existence are so short of money that they have to double the gun licence of farmers for killing vermin.

Comment on this

You can get that in West Cork.

Comment on this

You can give a preliminary canter of the arguments for a cross-roads by getting up to explain the Minister's action

Comment on this

It is to bring in £30,000. If this Government had not decided to reduce by £7,000,000 the tax on tobacco, beer and income-tax we might have been able to go and erect a giant edifice in the Phoenix Park.

Comment on this

The Minister is again repeating a statement which is completely false. He has not reduced taxation by £7,000,000. He reduced the rate in the Emergency Budget on beer and tobacco. He was complaining when taxation was only £65,000,000. It is now £73,000,000 and it is of course this £73,000,000 that the Minister is scrounging around to find, and it is to do this that he has to increase the tax on the .22 rifle and double the tax on the farmer's shotgun. There is no other reason for this increase. Would the Minister explain why he came to the decision to double the tax on the farmer's shotgun and only increase the game licence by one-eighth? I object to it being increased at all.

Comment on this

Why did you not say that?

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 58
·
Níl 45
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Has the Minister any reason for proposing to pass this section?

Comment on this

The allowance was originally given as a compensation for the increased cost of manufacture due to certain excise restrictions. The operations of this company over the years have resulted in the excise restrictions being modified to a very extreme degree. Therefore there was not the same case at all for the allowance. The necessity for the compensation is not there. This company is a monopoly company enjoying certain privileges.

Comment on this

Does the Minister hold, in respect of the original 5d. per gallon which was meant as compensation for the additional cost put on the Industrial Alcohol Company, that the costs have been reduced?

Comment on this

Yes, to an extreme degree.

Comment on this

Does the Minister now reckon what the cost is beyond the norm for complying with the Revenue Commissioners' regulations?

Comment on this

I could not answer that precisely, but there is no reason for this 5d. Then there is the monopoly situation as well.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 3 is out of order and, therefore, may not be moved or discussed.

Comment on this

I do not understand actually why it was ruled out of order. It was far from my intention to do anything that was wrong.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is nothing wrong in putting down an amendment. It is for the Chair to decide whether it is in order or not. Shall we put amendment No. 4 first? Then we can have a discussion.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:—

In sub-section (2), page 6, to add at the end of the sub-section the following:—

and shall be charged, levied and paid as aforesaid at the following rates:—

Where the payment for admission, excluding duty, | Rate of Duty

s. | d.

exceeds | 4d. | and does not exceeds | 6½d. | 1½

,, | 6½d. | ,, ,, | 8d. | 2

,, | 8d. | ,, ,, | 1s. 0d. | 3

,, | 1s. 0d. | ,, ,, | 1s. 8d. | 4

,, | 1s. 8d. | ,, ,, | 2s. 0d. | 6

,, | 2s. 0d. | ,, ,, | 3s. 0d. | 9

,, | 3s. 0d. | ,, ,, | 4s. 0d. | 1 | 0

,, | 4s. 0d. | 1s. for the first 4s. and 1s. for every additional 4s. or part of 4s.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The section has been changed.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 4 is for the purpose of substituting a new series of rates of duty for those previously announced. This means, in fact, that I am reducing the imposition to what it was in 1946. It costs me in revenue about £35,000 or £40,000 in the year.

Comment on this

What will the net be this year?

Comment on this

The original estimate of revenue is £110,000—say £35,000 less than that.

Comment on this

That means that the Minister is proposing to impose £75,000 additional taxation this year and to collect it in the form of a duty on dances.

Comment on this

The people will dance with annoyance.

Comment on this

That was not the plea of a lot of the Deputies now forming the Coalition Government in the days when the dance duty was being collected and when Fianna Fáil was in office. The particular Minister who is now proposing to collect this £75,000 on dances and céilidhes was the gentleman who not only objected to the extortionate bill, as he called it, which the Irish people had to pay to Fianna Fáil but who proposed to reduce it by £10,000,000. Instead of that, he has increased it by £8,000,000 —and portion of that £18,000,000, which he was out, is this tax on dancing. He knows very well that this particular tax is going to hit a number of voluntary organisations in the country which depend for their revenue on the subscriptions of their members or on the profits, if any, of the social functions—céilidhes or dances—which they run from time to time.

We all know that if there is to be any life, particularly in the country districts or small towns, a means must be provided whereby the young people can come together and enjoy themselves and, at the same time, raise some funds for their football club, Gaelic League, Red Cross branch or what not. I think it is ridiculous that we should pay lip service to the idea of making rural life more enjoyable while at the same time we impose taxes that make it more difficult for the young people to enjoy themselves and make it very difficult for voluntary organisations of a cultural nature or sports clubs to collect the necessary funds or make profits.

When I was Minister for Finance I proposed to the Government that we should abolish this tax. I pointed out in this House, when justifying my decision, that it was a rather expensive tax to collect. There are certain existing taxes from which we could get additional yield without a penny extra expense, but there is no doubt about it that if the Revenue Commissioners' officials have to attend all dances or have to inspect all dances within three miles of every centre of 500 population in the country they will be inspecting practically the whole of the country except the tops of mountains. If anybody likes to draw circles of three miles round every centre of 500 population I think he will find that he brings in practically the whole of the country Charitable organisations under this particular tax arrangement have to prove that their expenses are less than 50 per cent. in order to get exemption. We have all had the experience of charitable organisations running a dance or a céilidhe. If they do well, their expenses are less than 50 per cent. If they do badly and lose money, they have in addition to pay a 50 per cent. tax on their intake. I do not see how the Minister can justify this particular tax. At one time he said that, if there was any good reason for spending money, we could print it. He denied that in the general debate on the Budget and challenged me for the quotation. I gave him the quotation. I should like to know from him now, seeing that he did not reply to that particular point in the general Budget debate, why, if he is short of money at present——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Monetary reform does not come into this. That is obvious to everyone.

Comment on this

There certainly can be a substitute for the £75,000 he proposes to collect in this way.

Comment on this

That is absolutely dishonest.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not repeat that statement on every section.

Comment on this

If Deputy Cowan thinks it is dishonest, I have no objection.

Comment on this

You can create money for a constructive purpose.

Comment on this

For a good purpose. Is not all this money for a good purpose?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy please come back to the amendment before the House.

Comment on this

This £75,000 which the Minister is proposing to collect by this tax on dancing forms portion of the £73,000,000 total. We take it that this £75,000 will be spent for some good purpose. I want to know why the Minister proposes to collect it by a tax on dances. He used to speak of the crushing burden of taxation when it was £8,000,000 less. Now he is imposing this £75,000 extra on dancing, although the Fianna Fáil Government, even in the emergency Budget, when they wanted to collect money refused to collect it in this particular way. We all know the temptation for charitable organisations when they have done badly in running a dance or a céilidhe to write down their expenses to a figure below their real expenses. If they are subject to a tax when their expenses are over 50 per cent., there is a temptation to make a return of expenses below 50 per cent.

Comment on this

That is a nice slander.

Comment on this

I said the temptation is such——

Comment on this

Why do they not resist it?

Comment on this

I hope people will resist it in the same way as we resisted the temptation to take over the King and put him in the Park. That would have cost a pretty penny on dances and other things. The Crown ceremonial here would have cost quite a pretty penny.

Comment on this

Not as much as the new Parliament building.

Comment on this

The new Parliament building——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Does not arise on this.

Comment on this

It does not. I would, however, rather build a new Parliament building than bring the British monarch over here. These red republicans of the present moment——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not know how the Deputy can make this relevant to the amendment.

Comment on this

I am making it relevant to interruptions. I want to ask the Minister to forego the collection of this tax. It is a bad tax in every way. It reduces the opportunity for young people throughout the country to enjoy themselves in a legitimate way. They have as much right to dance as to drink beer or cheap wines, but the Minister believes in cheap wines and beer and dear dancing. I hope he will withdraw this particular tax. It is bad for the country; it is a brake on local initiative. Football clubs and charitable organisations of a parochial and other kinds are entitled to have a dance or a céilidhe to collect funds without having the revenue officials on their heels and putting the commissioners to the expense of sending round inspectors to attend those dances. If a revenue official finds that there are 500 present at some céilidhe or dance and only 400 have paid the tax, the committee or the person in charge has to be hauled before the local court and all that requires a lot of money. This is one of the most expensive taxes to collect. It was found to be so in the past and will be found to be so in the future. If the Minister wants to raise money by taxation, surely there are a large number of ways of getting it and more desirable ways than this. A very slight addition to some of the existing taxes would bring in very much more revenue than this £75,000. The Minister has reduced the price of beer.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Substitute taxation cannot be discussed on this amendment.

Comment on this

I say the Minister has many other ways of collecting £75,000 than by imposing this particular tax. It will be very expensive to collect and will have bad social effects anywhere it is successfully collected.

Comment on this

I think it is only right that the Minister should get some advice and, possibly, criticism from this side of the House. I may be occasionally a little irrelevant, but I promise not to bring in the new Houses of Parliament or the King.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not even anticipate irrelevancy.

Comment on this

Deputy Aiken has informed the House that this tax was taken off in 1946 and that it was a very costly tax to collect. It is regrettable that the Minister did not inform the House in reply to a question on the Order Paper of the amount that it cost to collect the tax in 1946. It would possibly help us to come to a decision as to whether or not it was advisable to reimpose it. The £75,000 which he hopes to collect by imposition of the tax will not be any great addition to the revenue. Offset against that £75,000 will be the cost of the expense of collecting. We will have to pay an office staff, the rent of at least two offices in Dublin City and, I understand, a number of other offices throughout the country. We will have to pay the wages and expenses of inspectors going around the country to inspect those places of entertainment. So I honestly believe that when we offset the expenses in collecting this tax the Minister will find, as his predecessors did, that very little revenue will accrue from it.

It is admitted that when the tax was in operation before it was only paid generally by what are known as commercial halls, and then it was only paid fully where the entertainments were held by the proprietors of those commercial halls. The social clubs referred to by Deputy Aiken, the football clubs and the Red Cross functions and even the dances of political Parties, I do not think were an exception. From my own knowledge I know that the branches of all political Parties in this House from time to time have dances. I would not take the liberty to accuse them but I do suspect that the members of those branches could not see why they should pay a revenue which they looked on as a type of income-tax before they were guaranteed their own expenses out of the functions they were running. They did previously—before this tax was taken off—adopt various methods to avoid payment of the tax and protect themselves from losing money instead of making a little money at those functions.

Where the dances were held for charity, first the promoters had to convince the revenue officer that the dance was for charity. I believe they had then to purchase the tickets and after the function was over send a return back to the revenue officer. If their expenses were under 30 per cent. they got a refund of tax. Deputy Aiken told us that some of them adopted the subterfuge of reducing their expenses. For instance, where there were receipts for £30 and the expenses were £10 or £11 they generally made it a little less than £10. That is only one way. A much easier way was to increase the receipts. There was no opportunity for the revenue officers to check the receipts. They might have an opporttunity of checking the expenses but if the promoters were questioned on it they simply had to increase their receipts.

I heard this personally from people who went round the country. The revenue officers found it practically impossible to get the co-operation of the patrons of dances when they went into the ballrooms to inspect the tickets. The people there resented it. They treated them as they would a bailiff. They gave no co-operation and they generally objected and refused to hand up the portion of the ticket to the inspectors. I know that the law provided that if people who went into dances, when challenged by the inspectors, did not hand up their tickets they were liable to a fine.

The poor inspector went into a ballroom and met some jovial fellow who is in the habit of attending dances. He simply said, "You want my tax ticket? Is that it? No?" Then he would have a search through his pockets. He would pull out six or seven tickets and would then say that he could not find his tax ticket. The inspector had to ask for his name and address and he got a name and address. This tax was practically impossible to collect and I definitely suggest to the Minister that it was never collected at all in the rural districts where the members were known to the committee and were told, "It is all right, Paddy. Give him a tax ticket," and it was done. It was then handed back and the one tax ticket was used several times.

It was incidents like these that I believe induced the previous Minister for Finance to abolish this tax altogether. Now the present Minister in his wisdom is reintroducing this tax. He has taken into consideration the areas where it was difficult to collect the tax and he has made it legal for those law breakers to continue running dances as against the people who previously always paid. I believe it is unfair, illegal and unconstitutional to make one person living on one side of the street pay a tax and not somebody else who happens to be a few yards away on the other side of the street and possibly outside the three miles limit of the population of 500. What Deputy Aiken says about this three mile limit is not altogether correct. If you take a range of four miles outside Malahide you will find several ballrooms outside the three mile and inside the four mile range.

Whatever the Minister's intention, he has not treated the people who previously paid tax fairly. He has actually put it up to them to try and find some way in the future of avoiding this tax. I believe the people will adopt every possible legal method to avoid payment. It is an extraordinary state of affairs to see ballrooms in the Malahide district and places like that that have been built up during the past years—a lot of money was expended on them in order to conform with the county council regulations— having to pay tax while a few miles further on you have a great holiday camp at Mosney, the general population of which is not more than 50. Mosney will be free, but the ordinary people who run ballrooms and dances in the cities and towns will have to pay. I think that is completely wrong and that the Minister should take cognisance of it.

I know that clubs which organised dances previously always objected to paying this tax. The people going into ballrooms object to being interfered with during the course of their enjoyment. The reimposition of this tax is going to create a great stir as well as an amount of resentment throughout the country. I fear that people who will be compelled to pay, while they see others getting away with it are going to adopt every possible means that they can, without breaking the law, to protect themselves and their interests. I am not a person possessed of a trained legal mind like some of the Deputies. I sometimes think that it is not the man who has a legally-trained mind that is always correct on matters of law. As I understand it, the entertainment tax in the case of cinemas and theatres has not to be paid if 51 per cent. of the entertainment is a stage show.

Comment on this

That has been changed.

Comment on this

I was interested in organising an entertainment some years ago and, to put it bluntly, we got away without paying the tax by having a few duds on the stage for an hour and five minutes.

Comment on this

There were a few duds in the Government in those days.

Comment on this

History repeating itself.

Comment on this

As regards this tax, what are we imposing it on? I suggest that, when a boy and a girl go into a ballroom, they entertain themselves and are not being entertained at all. They are the actual entertainers themselves and, therefore, why should they have to pay this tax? I think that the only people who should be liable to pay tax are those on the balcony who come there to look on. As I said at the outset, the amount of tax collected is going to be offset in several ways. First of all, there will be the cost of the collection. In addition, we have to face the terrible position that will be created by the great number of people who are going to be thrown out of employment. I can state with very definite knowledge that, if this tax is reimposed, those engaged in the ballroom business—the proprietors, promoters and people who run clubs—feel that in existing circumstances they will not be in a position to pay. Consequently, it has been brought to my notice, in the case of all the ballrooms in the city and of a number in the country where clubs had made reservations to run dances during the summer and winter, that practically all the dances booked have been cancelled. Proprietors who had engaged bands and orchestras to play in their ballrooms have given them notice. If this entertainment tax goes on they will be compelled to close their ballrooms on three or four days a week. That will mean that the members of the bands and numbers of the staff will be out of employment.

It may be generally thought that it is only the bands and staffs who are going to suffer if the ballrooms are closed. That is not correct. The position will be much worse. As well as the members of the orchestra you have the night staffs, and it has to be remembered that taxi-drivers and caterers derive a good part of their livelihood from those who attend dances. Generally, the position will be that people earning their livelihood in ballrooms and dance halls will be knocked out of employment and naturally they will go back on the dole. They will be collecting back some of the revenue that is brought in. It is to be remembered, too, that a number of the men engaged in orchestras on seven days a week pay a big amount in income-tax. If they lose their employment and their income there will be no income-tax to get from them. Instead, they will have to seek unemployment money.

I should like to hear from the Minister what prompted him to reimpose this tax. I feel that he did not do so merely for the purpose of balancing the Budget. One might assume that he felt that he was going to be short the sum of £110,000 and decided to get it by putting a tax on dances and by increasing the price of the pint. I do not believe the Minister approached the matter in that way. I should like to hear from him how he arrived originally at the figure of £110,000, or how, by going back to the old fees charged in 1946 he arrived at the figure of £75,000.

It has been suggested in some of the morning papers that the Minister has surrendered to the opposition offered on this dance tax. I would like to say, as one of those who led a deputation to the Minister in connection with it, that I do not accept that. I feel that those who approached the Minister do not think that they gained any victory at all. While we gave the Minister permission on the Second Reading of the Bill to reimpose the tax that was knocked off in 1946, my view is that we did not give him permission to increase it by one-third, which is the figure that he put before us to-day. Consequently, there can be no foundation for the suggestion that he has surrendered at all. I regret exceedingly that the Chair found it necessary to rule out my amendment because I had gone into this matter carefully and, as a supporter of the inter-Party Government, I did not want to be in the position of opposing the Government. I believe that the tax will not be collected and consequently I wanted to suggest a way out to the Minister by which he could collect the tax easily without any expense to the revenue. I suggested to him that instead of making the boy and girl who go to a ballroom pay this tax at the door that the ballroom proprietors should pay. If that had been done there would not be the general resentment that there is to this tax as far as ballroom proprietors are concerned. What they would have to pay proportionately would not be very much. The proprietor of a small ballroom would pay a small licence, but as the ballroom grew the price of admission would also go up and they agree that the annual licence would be greater.

I regret that you did not find it possible to allow that amendment to stand and I am terribly disappointed that the Minister did not give it more careful consideration. I state with all the knowledge that I have—not legal but practical knowledge—that the Minister would gain more money if he adopted the method I have suggested. I would like to know how the Minister arrives at the figure of £75,000, which he said he expected to receive from this tax. I do not believe he will get that amount. I am not going to guess how he figured it out.

He is re-enforcing a tax that will be resented. He will be held responsible, whether correctly or not, for closing down ballrooms all over the country two or three days a week and throwing out of employment numbers of men and women who are engaged in orchestras or on the staffs. He will also put out of employment people in the catering business, taxi owners and others. I appeal to the Minister, even at the eleventh hour, to reconsider his decision and withdraw this tax.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

For the information of the House, I will explain why this amendment was ruled out. The amendment should be based on a financial resolution which would have to be introduced in Committee on Finance by the Minister. No Deputy could introduce such an amendment. That is the reason why it was ruled out.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister has received all sorts of representations in this matter. The fact that he is making a certain concession indicates that. The pity is that he did not withdraw the tax and adopt some alternative. I am sure many Deputies on the Government Benches have also received very strong representations. I have received them myself from various clubs and organisations which will be hit very severely by this tax, especially in big centres where you have well-equipped ballrooms and where people have gone to considerable expense setting up their establishments and have developed a kind of goodwill with people from all sorts of scattered areas belonging to rural clubs, beagle and sporting clubs of various kinds, as well as cultural clubs—clubs with a public interest, but which could hardly be regarded as charitable institutions, although they, too, will be hit.

These clubs will be driven to hold their dances in small halls where they cannot possibly afford to have the bands they like. There are certain bands which are very popular and which charge high fees. It will be impossible in these circumstances for these organisations to employ them. The tax will definitely hit the particular halls which have been catering for these institutions. The blow will be very severe and, as Deputy Fitzpatrick said, it will throw a great many people out of employment.

It will not be easy to mend your hand in another Finance Bill, because once you do this you will possibly bankrupt some of these proprietors. You will certainly scatter the staffs and it will take some years again to build up that particular type of business once you allow it to be destroyed by this tax. I ask the Minister to reconsider the matter very carefully. In order to indicate our attitude, we ought to vote against the principle of the tax. It has been pointed out that it is an expensive and onerous tax.

Comment on this

It is not expensive.

Comment on this

To collect?

Comment on this

No, 2 per cent. is the estimate, and that was in the time when it was all over the country.

Comment on this

It will lend itself to very considerable abuse.

Comment on this

On the point of expense, it is not expensive.

Comment on this

It is anybody's guess.

Comment on this

No, it is the estimate of people who collected the tax for 14 years under the Deputy's Party's administration.

Comment on this

Why could you not tell me that in reply to my question yesterday?

Comment on this

I told you it was not possible to state it definitely. The information would have been given yesterday if it was asked for.

Comment on this

This tax will hit all sorts of halls all over the country.

Comment on this

It did that for 14 years.

Comment on this

The readjusted situation made it possible for a goodwill to be built up, but that will now be scattered. I urge the Minister to withdraw this section and find some substitute.

Comment on this

I was interested to hear the views of Deputy Fitzpatrick in relation to this tax. It was welcome to hear from Deputy Fitzpatrick some knowledgeable comment on a tax such as this; it was a welcome change from the speech which preceded it, the speech from Deputy Aiken. Of course, no tax imposed by this or any other Government will find a ready welcome everywhere in the country. No tax is popular and all a Minister can do is to try to balance things with remissions on the one hand and perhaps new taxes on the other, in the interests of the community. In this particular instance, under the Budget statement which preceded this Bill the people did get important remissions in taxation, including a remission in income-tax, and that is one of the things which will add weight to the balance.

One would imagine from what Deputy Aiken said to-night that some type of catastrophe had overtaken this country because the Minister for Finance proposes to tax dances. I do not know whether Deputy Aiken dances outside this House, but he frequently dances very queer jigs inside the House. It will be of interest to the country to know that Deputy Aiken is now a reformed character and that the Minister for Finance of an Administration which for 14 years maintained the tax on dances throughout the country now realises that not only was he wrong but that that particular tax is unjustified.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

He remitted it.

Comment on this

I can only say that the entertainment tax such as is contained in this measure was discovered by the Fianna Fáil Administration in 1932 and imposed by them as a new tax. At that time Deputy Aiken was a member of that Government, but he had very little to say against the tax. For 14 years his Government maintained that tax. For some eight years, I think, Deputy Aiken had the honour to be Minister for Finance. He came into the Dáil each year making provision for this particular tax, not allowing his mind to dwell upon the injustice it might be doing to the dancers and the people generally in the country. Ultimately, he removed the tax. He did not remove it because he suddenly discovered after 14 years that it was an unjust tax. He removed it because he came to the conclusion that it was difficult to collect. In my recollection, he himself stated that it was difficult to collect because, in the particular instances mentioned by Deputy Fitzpatrick, dances held in rural areas could not be properly supervised and the trouble of collecting the tax made it quite impracticable. That particular difficulty is recognised by the present Minister and, therefore, the particular areas affected by it are excluded from the scope of this Bill.

I agree with Deputy Fitzpatrick that from the theoretical point of view there does appear to be an apparent argument against that exemption because those who did not pay this tax in the past are now excluded from liability under the law. That may be because the Minister merely recognises facts, but I prefer to think that it is done in pursuance of the policy of this Administration to improve conditions for people in the rural areas and to attract them into remaining in the rural areas. I am sure most Deputies here appreciate that Deputy Aiken's opposition to this particular tax is merely just another exhibition of Fianna Fáil's determination to play any little game that may find any little support for them anywhere in the country. I am quite certain that the people recognise that this is a fair tax balanced against the good that has been done by the remission of income-tax where the smaller income groups are concerned and by the provision of increased social services for the people generally.

Comment on this

I am not concerned in this connection as to whether or not it is feasible or impracticable to collect this tax. I am not concerned with Deputy O'Higgins' remarks as to whether or not we are playing a game. I am concerned with the fact that since this tax was remitted in 1946 quite a number of ballrooms and dance halls have started in this city. The proprietors of them have put money into the business and ploughed the profits back into it. Deputy Fitzpatrick, who is a ballroom proprietor himself, has made a very sensible and sound case in my opinion; I hope that the Minister, as Deputy Fitzpatrick said, will realise even at the last moment that he has done so. Chiefly I am concerned with the fact that, though the Minister has met the dance hall proprietors, I do not think he has met the Irish Federation of Musicians. That body asked the Minister to meet them.

Comment on this

I do not think they did.

Comment on this

I have a copy here of a letter which was sent to you.

Comment on this

What is the date?

Comment on this

Asking you to see them and you have not seen them to date.

Comment on this

What is the date of that letter?

Comment on this

The 31st May, 1949.

Comment on this

Personally, I got no such letter.

Comment on this

It is addressed to "Mr. McGilligan, Minister for Finance"—that is you.

Comment on this

I go no such letter.

Comment on this

The Minister says he has not seen the letter and, therefore, he does not know the facts. Attached to that letter was a letter from the dance hall proprietors informing the federation that they would have, as Deputy Fitzpatrick said, to close their establishments on certain days during the week. I met a deputation from the Irish Federation of Musicians and, therefore, I am speaking of facts. They informed me that this will mean the disemployment of some hundreds of musicians and other personnel. The Minister has remitted another tax. He has reduced the tax on wine. He will create more lounge bars. His reason for remitting that tax was that the imposition of the tax created unemployment. He will now, under this Bill, impose a new tax to collect a miserable £75,000. That will not be the nett collection despite what he says about 2 per cent. He is putting on this tax on dancing with the certainty of creating unemployment.

Comment on this

Do you remember the Deputy said last year it was a certainty too because of what somebody else described as "dud shows".

Comment on this

But I was perfectly right last year. I rub shoulders with actors and with others who make their living on the stage. The Minister knows nothing about it. I was perfectly right last year. Since the tax was imposed last year many variety artistes have been idle more than half the year.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick described them as "dud shows".

Comment on this

People can be as "smart Alec" as they like.

Comment on this

But that is from a man in the business.

Comment on this

I am seriously concerned about the people who will be disemployed.

Comment on this

Nonsense!

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman says "nonsense". To my mind every interjection of Deputy Sweetman's is either irrelevant or nonsensical. Deputy Fitzpatrick has told us that it is not nonsense and he is qualified to know whether it is or not. Last night I met three of the largest ballroom proprietors. One assured me that out of a staff of 20, he would have to let ten go; another said that he would have to let 12 go; and the third said that he would have to let 14 go. The Irish Federation of Musicians assure me that the tax will affect some hundreds of their members, either full-time or part-time. I appeal to the Minister to listen to reason. In my opinion, the only thing Deputy Fitzpatrick did not say about this tax was that it is an iniquitous tax. I think it is a miserable tax. The Minister would serve a better purpose if he reimposed the duty on wine and remitted the tax on dances. It is all very well for his supporters who troop in here behind him and who shout "nonsense"——

Comment on this

That comes well from a Deputy who for 14 years levied the iniquitous tax.

Comment on this

The tax was remitted by the then Minister for Finance when he realised that it was impracticable to collect and iniquitous in itself.

Comment on this

In the rural areas.

Comment on this

The then Minister did not give that reason.

Comment on this

Perhaps when these men lose their employment the Minister for Industry and Commerce will offer them employment on the bogs. We shall have the spectacle then of violinists and pianists at the labour exchange being offered work at Clonsast. When they refuse to do that work, we shall have the spectacle of them looking for unemployment assistance.

Comment on this

I do not know what actuated the Minister into reimposing this tax. Some years ago there was quite a lot of propaganda about dancing in the country and about the danger of the commercial dance hall. We had a considerable amount of propaganda of that kind which resulted in the passing of legislation requiring the licensing of dance halls. I am just wondering if there is any similar purpose behind the reimposition of the duty. The suggestion has been made—I have heard it myself—that dancing is evil, that it should be condemned, that it is bad for the community. I have heard that said but in the part of the country from which I come, there was always dancing, and 35 years ago there was more dancing than there is now. It did not seem to do the people any harm then and I do not subscribe to the views of those who say that there is any evil whatsoever in dancing.

As I have already stated on the Budget debate, I am worried about the possibility of this tax resulting in unemployment. If the tax will result in musicians and staffs becoming disemployed, and in unemployment for other people connected with the dancing business, I think the collection of £75,000—even if that amount is collected—would not be justified at all. I think that the proprietors of ballrooms have put a very reasonable proposition to the Minister as an alternative, that is, that he should tax ballrooms rather than the dancers who go there to dance. Probably if the Minister were to give some consideration to that proposal, he would find that he would get the same amount of money as he proposes now to collect and he would collect it in a much easier way. If he were to impose a tax, say, on the basis of the legal capacity of the hall, a hall with a legal capacity of 500 would pay £500 a year—that is, a £1 per person. It would bring in a considerable revenue. From a dance hall in Dublin with the capacity of 500, it would mean £500 a year or, roughly, £10 a week. That is a burden that can be carried, apparently, by these dance halls, but if the proposed tax is imposed it will be a more severe burden on the business. If the Minister wants to consider that proposition, he might be able to make it very convenient for the proprietors of these halls to pay their tax by monthly instalments in advance. There is a serious objection from many parts of the House to taxation on the prices of admission per head, and the other proposal seems the more reasonable one.

Whatever the result of this discussion may be, and whether there is a vote on the matter or not, I should like strongly to support Deputy Fitzpatrick in recommending to the Minister that he might reconsider this matter in connection with the alternative proposals that have been put before him. Dancing in the cities and towns has become a business, just like any commercial venture, and on that business quite a considerable number of people depend for a livelihood. I think this is not the time for doing anything that may disturb people in their employment. It is certainly not a time for creating conditions that may lead to unemployment. I like to see young people dancing and enjoying themselves. I think they are much better occupied in dancing than in spending their spare time in some other ways.

I cannot do very much more than to renew the appeal I made to the Minister when the Budget was under discussion to reconsider this whole matter. If his idea is to get £75,000 this year, I think he can get it in a very much easier and cheaper way than by the imposition of this tax. The Minister has said that the cost of the collection of the dance tax is 2 per cent. Two per cent. would mean that the cost of collecting £75,000 would be £1,500.

Comment on this

I should have corrected that statement long ago. It will bring in £65,000 only and there is a collection cost of £1,300 on that.

Comment on this

I do not know. There are some of these calculations——

Comment on this

That is an estimate.

Comment on this

It is one of these estimates that it is very hard to stand over because it means a couple of minutes of somebody's time and a couple of hours of somebody else's time. Certain people will be occupied even in writing up the data for answering Parliamentary Questions arising out of the tax. It is very hard to know what it will cost. I do think myself it would cost more than 2 per cent. because, obviously, there must be inspectors if the tax is to be enforced. Those inspectors must go round. They have got to pay for their admission to dance halls and to pay for a car to take them there. They will have certain incidental expenses with regard to the journey and, if all the items were totalled up, it would be surprising if the sum total of the cost of collection were not more than £100 a month. However, that is not the most important part of it. If it is a good tax and if it costs only 2 per cent. to collect it, that is not bad but the most objectionable feature of the tax is that it will result, and apparently has resulted, in threats to cancel bookings. For some reason or other I understand that the dancing business is not prospering at the moment. I understand that dance halls, which used to have an average of 350 or 400 dancers are lucky now to have an average of 100, so that the business is not hitting the high spots at the moment. If that is so, and if all the interests concerned believe that the imposition of this tax will further depress the business and will lead to unemployment, I think there is a strong case to be made to the Minister for reconsideration of the tax.

I would like to say this in conclusion: we are endeavouring and I am endeavouring to put forward to the Minister reasonable suggestions with regard to this tax and I think we would be helped by contributions from all sides of the House that would have that for their objective. I think that the contribution by Deputy Aiken here this evening did not help in any way and particularly when Deputy Aiken, as he has done on other occasions in this House, went back to the dead to make references to people who are dead in a slighting way to their relatives here in this House. I think that does not help the case here at all. I think it is a low form of political propaganda and I think Deputy Aiken should be ashamed of himself. The references which Deputy Aiken made to the late Kevin O'Higgins were references he has no right to make.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. The two Deputies O'Higgins are constantly interrupting me in this House. I simply referred to a paragraph, a chapter, in a book, the biography of the late Kevin O'Higgins which was issued with the sanction of his relatives, and I pointed out that he wanted to take the British King over here, crown him and keep him in the park.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the debate.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan may think that is a slight on the late Kevin O'Higgins but his own family did not think so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing whatever to do with this tax.

Comment on this

We are anxious to put forward to the Minister a strong case based on reason. If Deputy Aiken did that there might be to a large extent an identity of interests with regard to this thing, but when he uses the occasion to make remarks such as I have objected to——

Comment on this

I was interrupted.

Comment on this

You certainly did use the occasion.

Comment on this

And I will use the occasion when Deputies interrupt me.

Comment on this

This happened repeatedly during the last few months in this House.

Comment on this

You are not bad at it yourself.

Comment on this

When any observations are made by either of the Deputies O'Higgins we have this type of observation from Deputy Aiken.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When people interrupt they may get sharp answers.

Comment on this

Low answers.

Comment on this

The Minister is a judge of low answers.

Comment on this

There should be some respect for the dead.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should come to the matter which is before the House and not initiate a debate on this subject.

Comment on this

I am not initiating a debate but protesting against this blackguardly insult to a man who was once a Minister of this House.

Comment on this

I want to protest against the expression Deputy Cowan used. I merely referred to what was in the biography of the gentleman in question which was published by his relatives and that cannot be held to be a black-guardly attack.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The word "blackguardly" is to be withdrawn, as used by the Deputy.

Comment on this

If the Ceann Comhairle orders that it should be withdrawn I certainly withdraw it in the interests of order in this House, but I say that the observations which were made this evening should not have been made.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has said that four times and might now get on with the business.

Comment on this

I want to maintain my right to characterise the observations made in this debate by another Deputy in this House as a foul slander on the memory of a man who was respected in this House and in this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy maintains his right to repeat a thing four times despite the Chair's request not to do so.

Comment on this

On a point of order. It is quite obvious that the Deputy has broken your ruling. He has withdrawn the word "blackguardly" and substituted "characterise as a foul slander" a reference to a historical fact published with the authority of the late Kevin O'Higgins' family in his biography.

Comment on this

If Deputy Aiken has finished I will finish. I hope it will not be necessary for me on any future occasion——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will please drop that matter.

Comment on this

I am simply saying that I hope it will not be necessary for any Deputy in this House to make a protest such as I have just made.

Comment on this

You cannot rewrite history. "The moving finger..."

Comment on this

I am sure that the Minister as well as every other member of this House who is anxious to discuss this matter on its merits will agree that Deputy Fitzpatrick presented his alternative proposal in a very fair and convincing manner. I am not saying that he has done that because he has a knowledge of those associated with the ownership of ballrooms. I think from my knowledge of the views of my constituents that Deputy Fitzpatrick has presented the viewpoint of the man in the street on this matter, and I hope for that reason that his alternative proposal will receive the careful consideration of the Minister which it deserves. Dancing is a popular pastime in my constituency and the overwhelming majority of dancehalls or ballrooms are in the possession of commercial dancehall or ballroom owners. Some of the best of them are owned by local authorities and others are under the control of the parish priest or the Catholic Young Men's Society and bodies of that kind. In every one of these cases, no matter how small the area may be whether it is a rural area parish hall or a commercial ballroom in an urban area or even a county courthouse or town hall owned by a local authority, the Minister will on inquiry be able to satisfy himself that a very high charge is always made to the promoters of dances.

I know of no dance hall in my constituency where the charge is lower than £3 3s. It may be £5 5s. for a parish hall in a rural area and it goes as high as £10, £15 and in some cases £20 for a commercial ballroom in an urban area. These people should be liable in the ordinary course of events to a higher rate of taxation than the nominal stamp duty which they have to pay whether the hall is situated in a rural or an urban area. Deputy Fitzpatrick suggested as an alternative that a higher stamp duty tax—if that is the correct way to put it—should be imposed on the owner with a lower cost of collection and that would bring in the revenue the Minister and his advisers are looking for. I doubt if the Minister personally is responsible for the introduction of this tax, but I have no doubt whatever—and I had better be quite frank about it, though if there is a division on this, I feel in honour bound to vote with the Government side—that this will be an extremely unpopular, irritating and annoying kind of tax. It is going to be annoying, not to the ballroom owner, whether he be commercial or local authority, but to the dancers. That was the real reason, I believe, why the Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance, under the strong representations of every Fianna Fáil Cumann in the country, removed that tax in 1946. They knew it was a popular thing to do and I suppose they were responding in the ordinary democratic way to the almost unanimous demand of their own members throughout the country. This reimposition will cause irritation and annoyance, not to the ballroom owners but to the dancers.

Deputy Fitzpatrick has a very intimate knowledge of the conditions prevailing in the ballrooms in the cities and towns, and I have a little knowledge of what goes on in the country. The Minister surprised me when he stated the cost of collection does not amount to more than 2 per cent. of the total tax revenue. It is a fact that the supervision of the dances carried out in rural and urban areas is done by the local customs and excise officer, who has other duties to perform, and I doubt if any part of his salary is taken into the 2 per cent. cost which is being given by the Minister as approximately the cost of collection. Is it not a fact that the majority of dances held in rural or urban areas are held on Sundays and, if that is so, is it not a fact that the customs officer must get extra pay for the Sunday duty, over and above the ordinary salary? If he has to travel, as he must in every case, to dances held in his area, he has to hire—and I know he does—a local taxi. He has other expenses to incur. The amount he pays for admission to the dance hall is trivial, but I suspect he goes in and has a "quick one", if it is inside the licensing hours, with friends of his before the dance. There is a certain amount of that going on.

Apart from that, the average dances are not confined to the boys and girls of the rising generation. The middle-aged people go to the dances held in parish halls, and particularly to those organised by political clubs and other bodies for charitable purposes. For instance, the trader in the town, whether he is a good dancer or not, feels himself under a moral obligation to go to the dance held for a political or charitable purpose. He advertises his existence and his business when he goes there, and if one trader goes his next-door neighbour is expected to go. If there are two publicans in the village and one goes and the other does not, the person who does not go is better known to the people who organise the dance than the one who does. I know, from my limited experience, that the visit of the customs officer to a dance hall when a dance is on, and his usual inquiries, which he is bound to make amongst the dancers, for the production of tax tickets, cause irritation and annoyance which has a reaction.

I admit that my knowledge is very limited compared to that of Deputy Fitzpatrick, but I assure the Minister that the organisers or promoters of dances for every and any purpose, in cities and in urban and rural areas, would far prefer to pay a higher fee to the owner of the dance hall than go to the trouble, annoyance and expense caused by the reimposition of this tax. Is it fair, I ask the Minister, that the owners of these dance halls, whether they be in city, in town or in village, should get away with this nominal stamp duty fee of £1 or thereabouts? Is it fair that Butlin's, who have distinguished directors, some of them including members of this Oireachtas, should get away with the same licensing fee as is paid by the owner of a parish hall in my constituency, when the people who go into Butlin's Camp must pay a minimum of £9 9s. 0d. a week for their maintenance there?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What has that to do with this?

Comment on this

I do suggest seriously to the Minister that it has a very definite bearing on the case. The people who own Butlin's Holiday Village—I am sorry I called it a camp; I was pulled up last week, not inside the House but outside, for calling it that—are a commercial concern and should be in a better position, by way of their huge income, to pay a higher licensing fee than the owner of a village hall which is used for dancing purposes. I appeal to the Minister to reconsider, if possible, this whole business, for the very good and convincing reasons given by Deputy Fitzpatrick. If he does so, he will meet the reasonable wishes of the dancers and of the ordinary people of the country.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

One must be struck by the argument put forward by Deputies Fitzpatrick and McCann in this instance, as both of them have got more than hearsay or secondhand knowledge of what they are talking about. Arising out of this, there is a counter suggestion, which has been supported by other Deputies, of a pro rata fee on the dance hall proprietor. That would be preferable in many ways to the type of tax proposed here. The only question I can see arising from that suggestion is that it would cover only established routine dance halls. I am still somewhat in the dark as to how logically to follow such a proposal in respect of casual functions. Some club or body whose activities do not normally include dances may want an occasional licence for an occasional dance during the year. That would be a specific problem to be dealt with in this counter-proposal by the Deputies in question.

Moving aside from that, on the whole question of this section, I think we had better get it into perspective in regard to the whole Bill. We are on the section specifically, but it can be looked at only in relation to the whole Bill, which is a Bill to implement the Budget. On the Financial Statement for 1949 and the explanatory tables connected with it, both officially published documents, the first thing is that the Minister budgeted for a surplus of £35,000.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy cannot deal with the whole Budget.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am not. This £35,000 is immediately related in this way. On this section, the Minister has brought in an amendment which absorbs practically £35,000, if the calculation which he gave is correct; so that the effect of the amendment, plus the section before us now, is to absorb that surplus from the Budget. That leaves the position that the Minister cannot forego this section and maintain his Budget figure, without making some other adjustment. That should be kept in mind when discussing the section. He has to face a certain expenditure and he has to provide the revenue for it. He has already foregone now, on the amendment to this, a sum equivalent to his nominal surplus. I recognise that it is a nominal surplus and I realise the elasticity of that in the Statement, but nevertheless, formally it is gone. He is in the position now that he cannot reject this section without making some complementary adjustment.

From a purely financial point of view, what is the case for the section? The necessity for it is brought about by the fact that the Minister has undoubtedly given releases in certain respects in regard to taxation—a matter of about £7,000,000, he claims, in reliefs in certain directions. But it is also indisputably true on these figures that he must seek to collect in the coming year nearly £8,000,000 more than any Minister for Finance who went before him.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has gone wide of the amendment.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If the Chair will bear with me, it will see that my remarks are very definitely related to the section. If I am trying to put a case logically, I must be allowed to put my premises before I put my conclusion. We are dealing with a shifting of the incidence of taxation, coupled with an all-round increase in taxation, and the question is fundamentally whether, in view of the fact that the Minister must find more than any of his predecessors had to find and in view of the fact that he has shifted the incidence of taxation otherwise, this particular shifting of the incidence is a good thing.

The first objection is, as has been stated, that this is not an economic tax to collect. The Minister has given a figure of 2 per cent. Like other Deputies, without having any specific information, I should be inclined to question that. Supposing the tax had to stand on its own, it would be a conservative estimate to say that ten revenue officers at least would be required and these ten officers would be paid at least £500 per year.

Comment on this

Full time.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That would represent £5,000 — well over the 2 per cent. The Minister is quite correct in saying full time, but, as against the hypothetical ten I suggest, on the part-time basis, there would be very much more and an estimation of the time that a part-time officer devotes to any particular matter is largely a question of the manner in which you care to apportion it, and, as Deputy Davin pointed out, there are factors which would lead one to expect that this would be a fairly expensive tax for the State to collect and one which the Minister's predecessors thought was relatively expensive to collect.

Comment on this

They did not think so. It was never so said.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am not in a position to say whether it was so said previously, but I understood Deputy Aiken, who is one of the Minister's predecessors, to say so, and I gathered that that was his opinion.

Comment on this

He did not.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If he did not, it is my mistake.

Comment on this

Why, then, go on with the mistake? Originally what was said was that it was a dangerous and difficult tax to collect.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

A difficult tax.

Comment on this

The emphasis was on the danger in the country areas and we are cutting that out.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It was a difficult tax to collect and off-hand I should imagine it was relatively, compared with certain others, an expensive tax to collect. I will give the Minister his 2 per cent., however, and simply make this comment, that, when the costs of administration are going up — and these costs are going up under the Minister's administration — there will be an extra 2 per cent. in respect of this tax on that cost. This tax represents now a further increase in the cost of administration, whereas I think that, in the case of other taxes, it would be possible to achieve the revenue without a corresponding increase in that cost. Therefore, the objection straightway is: is this a good tax to collect, admitting that the Minister would have to do it to maintain his Budget figures? It is going to involve some administrative costs. It is not a sufficiently general picture of the situation merely to relate that to a percentage of the tax collected — over all, it is an actual increase in the cost of administration.

We could discuss this matter a little more tightly if the Minister could give us some figures with regard to other taxes and their collection, but if we take that and couple it with the argument of Deputy Fitzpatrick, namely, that it is a difficult tax to collect, a tax which, in its nature, lends itself to evasion, a tax which is a temptation to evasion, the Minister has either to organise a relatively tight system which will mean expense or take the risk of foregoing revenue by being content with a more or less average collection of the tax, with the abuses which will follow. The worst feature of these matters is that some people get away with something and others do not, and any tax which brings about a situation like that is fundamentally objectionable.

That is the second argument and it is advanced by Deputy Fitzpatrick, who is in a position to know. The other argument is the argument mentioned by Deputy Davin and Deputy Fitzpatrick and particularly by Deputy McCann — its possible impact on employment. All these things considered, it seems to me that this is a tax which is really not worth the imposing from the State point of view, having regard to the drawbacks involved. I am not quite sure that the counter-proposal put forward by other Deputies meets the situation. It may, provided the trimmings, and one in particular which I have mentioned, are captured within the scheme. The same money could be obtained otherwise.

I take it that the figure which the Minister has finally decided on as his estimate of the yield is £65,000. The original figure was £110,000.

Comment on this

In the current year, £110,000. I now have a new estimate of £65,000, as a result of my own amendment.

Comment on this

Did the Minister not say a reduction of £35,000?

Comment on this

I was wrong— £65,000 and £110,000 are the two figures in the current year.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That does a little more than absorb the Minister's surplus on his Budget statement. However, a surplus estimate is somewhat elastic and that would merely be a point on figures, without much substance. He estimates for £65,000. Perhaps the Minister could tell us how that estimate is arrived at. Is provision made in it for the possible consequences of evasion and so forth or is it based purely on the assumption that the returns will be the same as in the past two years? I think it was Deputy Fitzpatrick who suggested that the Minister would not collect what he says he will collect from this tax. Personally, I do not propose to express an opinion, because much would depend on the basis upon which the Minister made his estimate as to the sum that would come in, but perhaps he could tell us whether his estimate makes allowance for such unavoidable losses or extra expenses in ensuring that there is no evasion, or whether it is merely a figure based on the returns of the past two years, which must be adjusted in the way Deputy Fitzpatrick suggests. By and large the section simply comes into the picture as one of the numerous ways that the Minister seeks to make up what he has given away in other directions.

Fundamentally my objection to it is that it is a bad way to get the money which, for the purpose of this argument anyway. I will admit the Minister requires. I am not quite clear as to how one is going to be affected in regard to location. The Minister undoubtedly anticipated that there would be a great clamour in regard to the little dance halls and that he would hear again the arguments pressed on him with regard to the depopulation of the countryside. I take it this three-mile limit which is apparently to be introduced now is the Minister's effort to meet this case, but the 500-centre of population is not a big one and the point is how is that 500 defined.

I do not know if I am entitled to raise Section 13 and take it with this section.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a separate section.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Since this tax is going to now involve yourself in refinements of the other section — 13 — it further opens the administrative complexity.

Comment on this

What is the refinement?

Comment on this