Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1949—Committee Stage.
Contributions 201–401 of 401. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 1949 ›
It is undesirable in general terms. Simplicity in revenue law was as desirable as in anything else. The tax provision of this section which takes up so much space is an indication that it is not as desirable a type of provision as others. I put it that it is not the best type of revenue legislation that the Minister could adopt to get the money which, for the purpose of this argument, I admit he requires and for that reason, in addition to the cogent reasons submitted by other Deputies, I think that this section should not be accepted by the House.
Comment on this
I certainly do not intend to follow the lines of Deputy Aiken in this debate. I think it is only fair that if the Minister is to be criticised in relation to this section that Deputies opposing him must at least put up some constructive suggestions to him. It was very noticeable in the course of this discussion so far that anything in the nature of constructive suggestion came from this side of the House and not from the Opposition. I listened to the criticisms of Deputy Aiken and Deputy Alderman McCann and it was only after Deputy Fitzpatrick spoke that other Deputies on that side of the House decided that perhaps there was some argument which could be put up to the Minister other than abuse and what can only be described as utter nonsense.
Comment on this
The Chair ruled earlier that anybody who interrupts should be given a short reply and I propose to reply to the interruption of Deputy Butler by ignoring it.
I think several Deputies have already pointed out that this tax was in existence for 14 years when the Deputies opposite were on this side of the House. It took them 14 years to decide the tax was not worth collecting. Deputy Aiken had said that the tax was difficult and dangerous to collect. People resented it and it would have to go. Deputy Aiken at that time during that discussion said that he had not got an accurate estimate of the cost of collection. I wonder if Deputy Alderman McCann was as concerned then as he seemed to be now about the question of unemployment that would result and the hardships that would ensue to proprietors of ballrooms because of the reimposition of this tax. One thing that should interest him would be the views expressed by Deputy Aiken regarding ballroom proprietors during the discussion of the section in the 1946 Bill which removed the tax. I think Deputy Fitzpatrick would also be interested in Volume 101, column 1690, Deputy Aiken who was then Minister for Finance and had undoubtedly been advised by Deputy McCann with regard to the position is reported as saying:—
"As far as the commercial dance halls are concerned, I hope they will not benefit a single penny. I hope, as a result of the taking off the expense of managing their halls in such a way as to comply with the Revenue requirements, that, when they are free, they may not only reduce the price of admission by the appropriate amount of tax taken off but by something over and above that which represents their cost in collecting for the Revenue Commissioners these particular duties. If the people of the country who attend ordinary commercial dance halls have any wit they are not going to give, when the remission of this tax comes into operation, the price they have been giving heretofore. I think it would be most unfair if these commercial dance halls were to charge such prices. But let that be between the patrons of the commercial dance halls and the proprietors. The owners of commercial dance halls should reduce the price of admission by about 20 per cent in the lower ranges."
Deputy Aiken made it quite clear when he was removing the tax in 1946 that he had no interest at all in the proprietors of the commercial dance halls, that he was not giving any consideration at all to any extra employment that might be given by this step. He went even further than that and said that, as far as he was concerned, he did not want to see an extra penny piece going into the pockets of any dance hall proprietor, that he wanted all of the amount remitted in taxation to be passed on to the patrons.
I would recommend to Deputy Alderman McCann that he might study that speech of his leader in finance before he talks about resulting unemployment. I would like if some of the Deputies who know more about this than I do, or if the Minister, when replying, would state whether or not the advice given by Deputy Aiken on that occasion was taken. I would be very interested to know, and I think the House is entitled to know, if in fact the remission of the tax on commercial dance halls was passed on to the patrons of those halls. I would like to know if any Deputy can name four establishments in this city or elsewhere in the country that reduced their prices of admission when the tax was taken off.
Comment on this
I do not care on whom it is hard. At any rate, people on this side of the House are lucky enough to be free to talk their minds out openly and honestly. We are not, as Deputy McCann complained, trooping in a regiment behind anyone when we are speaking on this matter. Deputy Fitzpatrick is entitled to express his views just as I am entitled to express mine. But it would be of some interest to me and to other Deputies here to know what views Deputy Butler was expressing from 1932 to 1946 when this tax was in operation. I am willing to place a wager, big or small, with any Deputy, that the brave Deputy Butler bravely kept his mouth very tightly closed.
Comment on this
Well, do not. There is no obligation. I do not know whether it would be in order or not, but it would be a matter of some interest to know what the Deputies opposite would recommend to replace this tax. At any rate, Deputies on this side of the House have made concrete suggestions. They have put alternative proposals. No doubt the Minister, when he is replying, will let us know whether the proposals which were put up as alternatives would in fact bring in an equivalent to what he hopes to get under this tax.
Comment on this
You would lose more money, as the Deputy would know if he followed the proceedings in this House.
Comment on this
By reducing the tax he got £250,000 extra. That is the answer I am trying to give the Deputy.
Comment on this
I think the two minds are probably running on lines closely allied to what in fact is the Fianna Fáil policy. It would not be the wines or the cocktails that would be taxed; not, at any rate, if they had the experience which was met by this Minister, but I think they are still hankering after an increase in the price of beer and tobacco and cinema seats.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan advocated support for Deputy Fitzpatrick's proposition but, as I say, before a Deputy can make up his mind as to whether or not that suggestion would be adequate to replace the funds which the Minister hopes to get out of the present tax, it would be necessary to get some kind of concrete estimate as to what that particular type of tax —the tax on the licence or the tax on the ballroom — would bring in. It would also be necessary to take into consideration the equitable distribution of that tax. Might we not have an outcry from the people who would have to pay a far greater share in proportion to the number of dances they run than the people in the bigger ballrooms who run dances nightly during the season?
Deputy Cowan also suggested that at the moment dance halls were doing badly, that there was some kind of depression in dancing. I do not know. Deputies more closely connected with the dance hall business may be able to say whether or not that is so but, if that is so, it would seem to me that it is an argument against the suggestion put forward by Deputy Fitzpatrick and supported by Deputy Cowan.
Finally, I would sincerely ask the Deputies opposite to remember — I know this may seem to be impertinence coming from a young and newly-elected Deputy——
Comment on this
I would sincerely appeal to them to remember that this House has a job to do, that their job is not to hurl personal abuse across the floor or personal slighting abuse at people who are dead and gone but it is to give the Government of the day suggestions and assistance as to how the county should properly be run. I say again that the only suggestions that have been put forward have been put forward by Deputy Fitzpatrick, Deputy Cowan and Deputy Davin. Unfortunately, I was not here to follow the entire of Deputy Vivion de Valera's speech, but he seemed to me to be at least making some effort to be helpful and to assist the Minister. I would appeal to the Deputies on the other side who intend participating in this debate to try to follow the lead of Deputy Vivion de Valera rather than allow themselves to be misled by Deputy Aiken.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation, would the Deputy who has just sat down say whether or not it is throwing abuse upon the dead to quote from an authoritative biography published with the approval of his relatives?
Comment on this
May I say that it depends entirely on the manner and the tone in which the remarks were made. I do not know whether Deputy Aiken has a perpetual sneer on his face, but he certainly had one on his face when he was talking this evening.
Comment on this
It is clearly obvious from the speeches that have been made by those on the Government Benches that the only reason why rural areas are exempt from this tax is because it is impossible to collect it and not, as some people suggested, to meet the social conditions in the rural areas.
Comment on this
The argument put forward by both Deputies O'Higgins's was that Fianna Fáil kept this tax on for 14 years and that Deputy Aiken was Minister for Finance for eight of those years. The fact that Deputy Aiken, after eight years' experience as Minister for Finance, found that it was a good thing to do away with the tax is an argument for the abolition of the tax. He must have had tremendous experience as to the difficulty in collecting it. I know, from a small bit of experience, that there is a temptation to deceive in relation to this tax.
If a body runs a dance for charitable or benevolent purposes and applies for exemption they must first of all lodge a deposit with the Revenue Commissioners. They will get a notice to hang up in the hall in which the dance will be held. There will be no visit by any inspector except that one may come to see that the notice is hung up. There will be no check on the takings but the people who run that dance for charitable or benevolent purposes will have to fill in a form giving particulars of their expenses and their receipts. If they are unable to prove that their expenses are less than 30 per cent. Of the takings they will not be granted exemption. All that involves a good deal of trouble on the part of those running the dance and on the part of the Revenue Commissioners. The applicants must give details of their expenses — band, advertisements, and so forth — in their statement and the accounts must be examined carefully As Deputy Fitzpatrick has said, if people who run these charitable dances —and you meet a lot of people who do not think it is any crime—think they will not be granted exemption the obvious and the simplest thing to do is to increase in the statement the amount of the receipts so as to show that their expenses were less than 30 per cent. of the receipts. I think that is, as Deputy Aiken pointed out, a temptation to deceive.
I have been requested by numerous organisations in the City of Cork to protest strongly against this tax. We have two principal dance halls in the City of Cork—one the property of the Cork Corporation and the other the property of a private individual. In the City Hall in Cork we have one of the finest ballrooms in the country. Every Sunday night of the year that hall is used by one or other of the different charitable organisations, but no organisation, as far as I know, will get the hall from the city manager for two Sunday nights because, after all, it is only fair that everyone should get his turn. Every hurling club and football club and coursing club—and political organisations as well—looks upon that hall as a source of revenue to enable them to balance their budgets for the year. They can sometimes make up to £50 at a Sunday night céilidhe. Religious bodies use the hall too. The Legion of Mary and so forth, run céilidhes there on Sunday nights. All these different people feel indignant about this tax and—I am not making any bones about it—they were indignant too when Fianna Fáil imposed it. The hall run by the commercial individual is let also, to organisations who run dances. By the way, the dances in the city hall generally last from 8 p.m. to 11 p.m. while the private individual lets his hall for later hours.
I was asked last night by a committee in charge of the Cork City regatta to bring this matter to the attention of the Minister. They look upon it as one of their strongest ways of getting funds to meet the expenses of the regatta, which are very heavy.
Comment on this
We must remember that it is a big hall and that its upkeep is expensive. We must remember too, that there must be caretakers who have to be paid overtime on Sunday nights.
Comment on this
The Deputy is quite mistaken. They increased their charges when everything went up on them, and not because the tax was done away with. The City Manager gave as a reason for increasing the price the fact that it was desirable that a better class of person should be encouraged to patronise the dances— respectable young people and not to have the ordinary knock abouts.
Comment on this
It was class distinction in that we wanted respectable people to come instead of people from other districts who were not in a proper condition to go in. However, I do not see what that interruption has to do with the case. I am pointing out that those bodies—and I am sure Deputy P.D. Lehane knows some of them—feel that this tax would mean a terrible loss to them. I would appeal to the Minister to reconsider this matter. I do not think he will gain as much as he thinks he will. He certainly will lose a lot of favour— whether that would be to our advantage or not is another matter.
Comment on this
I wish to emphasise a few of the points made by Deputy Fitzpatrick and to ask the Minister to give favourable consideration to some of the suggestions he has made. I, too, have been on committees which ran dances. It is a terrible worry to some of the young people on committees that they may lose on the dance. Naturally they hope to be able to make a success of it and thereby earn £20 or £25 for whatever charitable institution they are running it. The first question a dancer will ask is about the size of the hall and the number of people in the band. If the band is a small band and the hall is fairly large the dancer will not patronise the dance. Dancers want a band sufficiently good for the music to be heard from one end of the hall to the other. It has been suggested that some of the dance hall proprietors will start to curtail their expenses and that some of them have done so already.
There has been a lot of exaggeration in this House about the size of bands. I was rather amazed when one Deputy spoke about 20 men in a band. I do not know of any hall in Ireland that has a dance band of 20 members playing at any ordinary dance. The average-sized band in Dublin City in the biggest and best halls we have comprises 12 or 14 members. If that 12 or 14 is reduced by two or three it means that two or three young men or women will lose the fee which they get for attendance. I implore the Minister to have regard to that possibility. The proprietors of halls do not always run the band. The band is engaged. One of the members of the band does the organising, and the first thing he will consider is whether he should have a band of six or eight or ten. If you want to make a success of a dance and hope to get £25 out of it for any particular organisation, a band of less than eight or ten is really not worth while because the people will not go to the dance. The first thing a person has to ask himself is how much he will have to take in to clear expenses. Before the hall is opened a calculation is made, and an organiser will tell you that he must have an attendance of at least 200 to pay expenses. If they get an attendance of 220 they know that they will cover their expenses. If they can get an attendance of 320, the extra 100 will mean a profit. The expenses of the band, however, are always there. If they reduce the number in the band for the purpose of bringing down the expenses, the dance will not be a success. They are generally at their wits' end to know what to do. A good organiser or speculator will have a full band of ten. Dancers know which are the good bands. No matter what happens, I ask the Minister to see that the money earned by the individuals in these dance bands will not be reduced.
I wonder would it be possible not to impose any tax on the first 200 of the attendance at any dance. In that way organisers would at least be guaranteed their expenses. Some means could then be devised by which a reasonable tax would be paid on the remainder. That would satisfy organisers that they will not lose money. I assure the House that 50 per cent. of the dances in the City of Dublin are run for charity purposes and a profit of £20 per night is calculated on. They must have at least 200 people at an admission fee of 3/- or 3/6 before they can make one penny profit. I put it to the Minister that he ought to consider Deputy Fitzpatrick's point and devise some means by which no tax will have to be paid on the first 200 and after that impose a tax which will bring in the revenue required.
Comment on this
Could the Minister indicate at this stage his attitude towards the proposal with regard to dances for charitable purposes?
Comment on this
There are about 700 dance halls in the country, all told, and possibly 250 of these are in the areas which will be free.
Comment on this
If you do not know, I do not see how you can arrive at the figure of £25,000. I thought it would be twice that.
Comment on this
I have considerable experience of clubs and charitable organisations of all kinds. I am very sorry that the Minister reimposed this tax, because Deputy Aiken was only a short time Minister for Finance when, in his wisdom, he decided to abolish the tax on local entertainments. We have very little in the line of entertainment in rural Ireland. Speaking as a representative of local clubs and charitable organisations, I feel that the Minister is striking them a very hard blow by the reimposition of the tax. There was an air of freedom after Deputy Aiken removed the tax.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that the tax will only have to be paid in areas where there is a population of over 500. There is hardly any area in my constituency which will be exempt under that condition.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, Deputy Norton spoke very highly of that "charitable organisation" when he was down there some time ago.
Comment on this
I have been associated with charitable organisations for over 30 years. The charitable organisations will be very hard hit by this tax. Of course the Minister does not mind hitting these people hard and even under the belt. When dances are being held for charitable organisations money will have to be lodged with the Revenue Commissioners or a certain number of tickets purchased. If the dance is a failure, further representations have to be made to the commissioners. Then on the night of the dance an inspector is sent out. The committee running the dance are not running it for themselves, but for the benefit of people who are not in a position to help themselves. When they put a person on the door to collect the money, they will be afraid that he will fail to issue a ticket to some person entering the hall. I have had experience of people, through some oversight, failing to do something like that. The result is that the inspector questions people in the hall.
The Minister is anxious to persecute the people of rural Ireland and the clubs I am speaking of. Football clubs, tennis clubs, dramatic societies, welfare societies, Red Cross branches and the St. Vincent de Paul Society which organise functions of this kind will have this persecution reimposed on them which Deputy Aiken, in his wisdom, removed from them when he realised what he was doing. He gave an air of freedom to all the clubs in the country. That air of freedom is to be taken away from them again. There is also another section dealing with another rural sport—the increased charge for a gun licence.
All these things, as far as I can see, only reimpose persecution on the various clubs' committees that are running functions in this country. The Minister, in stating that certain areas where the population is only 500 will not have to pay tax, is trying to hoodwink the people. I am telling the Minister that in County Dublin I do not know of an area that will not come within that three mile limit. Everybody associated with any club has a great regard for the previous Minister for Finance for a very sensible act. I want to know what is prompting the present Minister to reimpose a tax that is going to persecute every club in the country.
At the moment I can definitely tell the Minister that dances are not paying. The dance-hall proprietors have made their own case in their own way. As members of clubs, we have to pay our fee for the hiring of halls, pay high expenses for a band, pay performing rights and so on. The result is that clubs to-day are working for a band and a hall and now, on top of that, the Minister says that you are not going to have any fun in rural Ireland except you pay through the nose for it.
Comment on this
I have never said a word but the honourable Deputy Davin must burst in. I want to point out again to the Minister that charitable organisations will be in a very bad way. A number of welfare societies that I have been associated with and am associated with in County Dublin have existed on the promotion of dances. They have been well conducted and well run. Now they are going to be back in the position where, if their expenses are over 30 per cent. of their takings on the door, they are going to have to surrender the whole thing; not to speak of carnivals being run for parochial purposes, to help the building of schools, the reconditioning of churches and the building of parish halls. Every football club, debating society and so forth, that was responsible for brightening the life of rural Ireland is going to be persecuted. I look upon it as sheer persecution. If a person pays his fee into a dance hall he is persecuted by the inspector saying: "Can you show me your ticket?" Many a patron, a boy or girl, may possibly have dropped their ticket. Their name is taken and they are asked: "Why did you not get the ticket at the door?" We have been told many times in this House how anxious the Government are to brighten the lives of the people of rural Ireland and here is an example of it. When Deputy Aiken, as Minister for Finance, in his wisdom tried to give them an air of freedom and encourage them to brighten their lives in the country and——
Comment on this
I know. Another point that Deputy McCann has made here and which I definitely support, is that the reimposition of this tax is going to cause unemployment. I have no doubt it will, judging by the statement made by Deputy Fitzpatrick. That is another point that the Minister should consider. If, as a result of the reimposition of this tax, dance musicians, people who are associated with the running of dance halls and employed by dance hall proprietors, are going to lose their employment and if the Minister is concerned about them he should seriously consider doing something to alleviate any further distress because we have enough unemployed already.
Parochial halls have cost a lot of money and have possibly been built by clubs. Perhaps the clubs have overdrawn at the bank in order to carry on. The same applies to individuals who have put up a dance hall and as Deputy McCann says, there has been a good deal of building of dance halls since the tax was taken off by Deputy Aiken as Minister for Finance. Now we are going to have the position again where that very much needed enjoyment in the urban towns and in rural Ireland is going to be killed. People are not going to build these halls because they will find after paying for everything that the clubs are not going to hire the halls. If the clubs are not going to hire the halls, there is going to be unemployment. The Minister will go down in history as the Minister for Finance, better known as the kill-joy Minister.
Comment on this
I realise, as everyone here does, that a tax is never a popular thing, no matter what it is or how necessary it is. We all understand that something must be done in order to run the country. We are all anxious to get everything as cheaply as we can; at the same time, I must say that I regret the Minister has found it necessary to think of this increase in taxation so far as dancing is concerned. I realise, as many others do, that it is the one thing which is a very popular and good pastime within reason, in the country. It is all very well to talk about what is happening in bigger places. In the country it is just the one thing that most people look forward to on Sunday nights, say. In my opinion, it would be a splendid thing if the Minister could find some other method to collect this required amount of money. I believe that there is consternation amongst the various proprietors of the various dance halls throughout the country. No doubt, these people have to live just as any other person in business. I had conversations with several of them during the week.
As a matter of fact I do not find myself quite in agreement with the Minister on this particular matter. I am more in favour of the proposal that was made by Deputy Fitzpatrick that, instead of having a ticket tax the capacity of the dance halls should be taxed. If that were done a certain amount of money would be collected, perhaps not as much as by the ticket tax. It might, say, come within £20,000 of the required amount. Deputy Fitzpatrick, I understand, has gone into this matter very carefully. Several other proprietors of dance halls have come to me and have explained to me that that would be a far better method than the ticket tax, apart altogether from the fact that it would cause less worry to the proprietors and to the general public. The capacity of the halls could be easily ascertained and so it is urged that that would be an easy method of collecting the money required.
There is another point which is a serious one. The amount that it will cost to collect the ticket tax if the scheme which the Minister has in mind is gone on with. There has been so much said on that that there is no need for me to stress it further. There will be quite a lot of money spent on the inspectors. I, for one, do not like the idea of inspectors interrupting people when they have paid to engage in a legitimate pastime. I think that the Minister's scheme could be got over by the method suggested by Deputy Fitzpatrick. The Minister, I know, is very considerate. He does not want to stand between people enjoying themselves. On the contrary, since he became Minister he has given back quite a lot of things to the people. He was faced with a terrible outlook at that time. There was a tax on almost everything, yet he was able to give back many things to the people which were regarded as luxuries by the last Government. The Minister is anxious that people should have things at a reasonable price, but, having given back so much, it is easy to understand how it is that he must find some way to make up for the reductions he has made. In all sincerity I would ask him to consider some of the suggestions that have been made. Perhaps he might consider setting up a body in this House composed of people intermil ested in this particular tax to find other ways and means of collecting the same amount of money without putting into effect this ticket tax.
It has been said, too, that a lot of people will try to evade this tax. It is a bad thing to have that sort of idea abroad, even before the scheme is put into operation. I have been told that in the past that the payment of the tax was evaded. One may be surprised to hear many people say now that they did evade the payment of the tax when it was in force. For that reason I think it would be far better if, somehow, Deputy Fitzpatrick's suggestion could be considered. It would be a far better method of collecting almost the same amount of money. I ask the Minister to consider that point. I think it would be a far better and a wiser scheme for the collection of the same amount of money.
Comment on this
Could the Minister enlighten us at this stage, arising out of Deputy Burke's remarks, as to the effect of this on dances for charitable purposes? It appears that all dances and entertainments are to be affected. I should like to know if I am right or wrong in that. Is there to be any loophole or any exemption for such things as dances for charitable purposes?
Comment on this
I merely want to know what the factual position is. The Minister must find revenue. I, for one, think that if it were a question of finding revenue I would go for the non-essentials before going for the essentials. I would tax the non-essentials first. We said that before and I am prepared to say it again. We are prepared to concede that we would rather go for those in the category of non-essentials than for essentials. I still think that the arguments that have been made against this section——
Comment on this
On a point of order. I understood that the Deputy got up to ask a question. He is speaking now to the exclusion of Deputy Butler and others who want to speak. The Deputy spoke before.
Comment on this
I am not going to take up the time of the House except to say that the real question seems to have shifted. Is the incidence of the tax going to be changed, even when the tax has to come from this source? Some Deputies will still object to the tax coming from this source for other reasons. A number of Deputies have been arguing about the particular method of getting the tax from this source. The Minister has indicated that he is not prepared to accept proposals made by other Deputies here. I am just wondering, just as Deputy Mrs. Redmond has been wondering whether there is not another way of getting around it to get the £65,000, even from the same source, without the objections which have been already fully pleaded.
Comment on this
I quite realise that taxes must be imposed so that the services of the country may be carried on. I have not risen to criticise this particular tax in any hostile spirit at all I am sorry that it will hit parochial committees, charitable organisations and athletic associations of various kinds. There is good authority for saying that it will cause a great deal of unemployment. That is a very regrettable thing. I object to the tax on a number of grounds. One is that it will not make the country attractive. The imposition of this tax will make the country less attractive than it has been up to date.
Some Deputies on the other side of the House tried to give the impression that this tax would not hit the country, that it would not hit rural areas. I think it would be more true to say that it will hit very considerable expanses of the country outside the large towns and cities and anything that is possible to brighten up rural life should be done. There is nothing that so brightens the life for young people in country areas as dancing. I do not think any other form of recreation you could offer them would have the same attraction. From that point of view, I am sorry this tax is being reimposed.
There is this point also, that this tax may drive a large number of recognised dance halls out of existence. It will certainly discourage the erection of additional ones and young people will find this form of recreation for themselves and the result will be that they will probably go into small and stuffy private houses, sometimes in great numbers, and they will find themselves in rooms where the air is vitiated and very unhealthy. I think in that way we will not do much to help the anti-tuberculosis campaign. I think it would be a serious thing to drive the young people in the rural areas from recognised dancing places, possibly into holes and corners. In the recognised halls the parents know where the young people are and with whom they are associated. If they are scattered here and there in order to find this form of recreation which they cannot get in the normal way, it will not be a good thing for them. It is comparable to the closing of licensed premises where beer and spirits are sold and encouraging the spread of shebeens. There is something comparable between these two things.
The more serious objection in my mind is the discouragement to training in music, vocal and instrumental, that will result from the imposition of this tax. There is no doubt that training in music, vocal and instrumental, is nothing like as widespead or as good as it was when I was a boy.
Comment on this
That was not yesterday— that is true. I was reared in a country town and we had there a very fine choral union where we did the works of the very best composers, from the Elizabethan period down to the present time.
Comment on this
I am saying that the training in music, vocal and instrumental, has deteriorated very much from what it was 30 or 40 years ago and, with the imposition of this tax, if it reduces the number of musicians or the possibility of employment for them, it will tend to discourage people from training in music. I think that would be a very undesirable thing. In that small county town — this is my own experience—we had a very fine choral union and, in addition, we had a very good orchestra in which we, at least, attempted the works of the very best composers. I had the pleasure of being the pianist to that orchestra for a number of years. In the orchestra we had all classes of people, from the poorest upwards. I might mention, incidentally, that the oboe player was a clergyman, the rector of a neighbouring parish.
I am pointing out these things in order to show that a great deal can be done for the uplift, the amusement and the enjoyment of people in country places, given proper encouragement. I am not blaming the present Government in any way for the state of affairs that exists now and that has existed for a long time. The gramophone was very damaging, in the first instance, and then we had wireless later on.
Comment on this
I do. I maintain that if this tax is imposed it will still further damage the cause of musical training. I am saying that already it has been damaged very much by the gramophone, the wireless and the tinned music that we have in the cinema. I think it is a very great pity that the training of young people in music should be discouraged, as it certainly is discouraged by the imposition of this tax. One Minister had a praiseworthy objective before him of keeping Government inspectors outside the gates. Here we have a Minister apparently determined to bring them back inside the doors of the halls in which people enjoy themselves dancing.
Another serious objection to this tax is that any legislation that, as it were, encourages circumvention of the existing law is bad. We have it on the authority of Deputy Fitzpatrick and other Deputies here to-night that people will go to extraordinary lengths to circumvent this law. For that reason I think the Minister should try to think of some other means of bringing in revenue. I do not altogether agree with Deputy Fitzpatrick's alternative of putting the tax on the proprietors of the dance halls. If you take small villages and towns, you will find that one of the most desirable things is to have a local hall.
If dance halls are liable to be heavily taxed there is very little likelihood of their being built at all. Where dancing is promoted under proper supervision it encourages the building of halls more than does anything else in small towns and villages where such halls are so very desirable. These halls can be used for other purposes apart from dancing. What are described here as dance halls are very often not strictly dance halls as such. They are used for various purposes. They are used for concerts and lectures and so on. They help to maintain interest, particularly in the rural areas. The suggestion offered by Deputy Fitzpatrick plays into the hands of the big man. That suggestion would tend to discourage the erection of small halls in country villages and towns. I consider a town with a population of 500 people very small. I trust that the Minister will accept the general wish of the House that, if possible, this tax should be remitted.
Comment on this
To my mind the proposal to reimpose this entertainment tax is very wrong particularly when one considers the rural areas and the lack of entertainment facilities and the paucity of attractions in these places. From the Minister's introductory speech it would appear as if he were actuated by a desire to assist rural entertainment and encourage facilities in rural districts. His proposal, however, will have the effect, in my opinion, of retarding such a development. Cinemas and dance halls are the major attractions available in the majority of country districts. They are really the only form of entertainment the people have. Any Government action which might impede their development must further unpopularise rural life. Any movement in that direction is ultimately bad policy and the Government should be very slow to adopt such a line of action. The present proposal will have an injurious effect on small towns. I take it the Minister had before him the experience of the previous Government when he eliminated areas three miles distant from a town with a population of over 500 people. A population of 500 does not really constitute a town. At most it is a village.
Since the introduction of this proposal a number of potential itinerant cinema producers have sought to book up all the towns and villages with a population of 500 or less. They have travelled as far as County Leitrim. These shows will have the effect of making the position of the permanently established cinemas in towns with a population of 1,000 untenable. That would be the maximum population of any town in my county. Under this proposal every person in such a town will be subject to an entertainment tax. I do not know what form of taxation could apply to these intinerant cinemas. They are already in existence. These people book halls within three miles of a large town and naturally the townspeople will travel three miles to see these shows. If that happens no business will be left for the permanently established cinemas in the town. It may have the effect, if it is imposed as a permanent tax, that some enterprising people will build reasonably substantial dance halls——
Comment on this
Is the Deputy dealing with Section 12 or with Section 13? He seems to be discussing Section 13.
Comment on this
This will have the effect of bringing into existence conditions the Minister never intended when he introduced it. I strongly urge upon him that he should consider the appeals made here. He must know that this is a highly unpopular proposal. I have no objection to dancing or any entertainment of that kind and I hold that entertainment generally should make a contribution to the State in the same way as do commodities like tobacco and whiskey. From the experience of the previous Government I am satisfied that this tax is not worth the candle. It will be injurious in so far as social life in rural areas is concerned. Conditions must be made attractive in the rural areas if we wish to keep our people there. I suggest the Minister should pay heed to the considered arguments advanced against the application of this tax in its present form.
Comment on this
The Minister has listened to a great deal of argument against this tax and he must now have reached the conclusion that it is difficult to impose a tax on anything that is popular. I suggest that that is one of the reasons why he and his colleagues succumbed to the temptation last year to reduce taxation on a number of popular commodities. We are all agreed that the Minister has a perfect right to come forward with proposals for the imposition of taxation in any direction his Government thinks fit. If it is absolutely necessary that this £65,000 should be obtained, and if there is no other means of obtaining it except on entertainments there can be no great objection to getting this money from entertainments in preference to imposing it on some of the necessaries of life. I am sure that all Deputies agree that if dances could be made completely free of restriction and free of taxation that would be very desirable. The major objection advanced against this tax on dances is the fact that there are so many problems to solve in the way of getting stamps and so on.
The Minister and his advisers are aware of the efforts to evade this tax. Everybody who has had anything to do with the organising of dances knows quite well of the efforts that were made all over the country, demoralising the whole community, to evade the tax and the fraud that was carried on against the laws of the country. Suggestions have now been made that the Minister might raise the money by means of licensing dance halls, by imposing stamp duties on licences or otherwise. That would cut out all the need for inspection, all the red tape, and it would give the Minister this £65,000. I believe he could raise more money by means of a licence duty than under this proposed arrangement. He told us that it would cost something about 2½ per cent. for administration. That is roughly, I suppose, about £2,000 out of £65,000.
Comment on this
I said 2 per cent. That was the estimate when it had to be collected all over the country.
Comment on this
You are going to get £65,000 by this tax. I make that out to be .00013 of your total revenue.
Comment on this
We are not concerned about getting popularity. I was one of those who brought to the notice of the Minister and his Department, the fraud that was going on when the tax was in operation and the nuisance the collection of the tax was to all organisations in this country. I am sure the dance promoters in this country are well able to stand this £65,000. The people attending dances pay far more for motor cars and in the consumption of drink at these dances than £65,000. I do not think that £65,000 is going to break dancing organisations in this country but there is the nuisance that the collection means for organisations who organise dances for charitable purposes and indeed for every possible purpose. That is what they object to. They would willingly pay £3 or £5 on a straight licence duty to carry on the dance rather than be compelled to stamp the tickets and to make returns for the Revenue Commissioners. That is the nuisance objected to by organisers of dances. I would suggest to the Minister that he should reconsider this whole matter and see if he could get his revenue in some other way rather than by the system that was in operation and that was found to be such a nuisance over many years.
Comment on this
I had hoped that I would get from the Minister the grounds on which he bases the estimate of £65,000 that he hopes to collect by means of this tax. Would it be correct to assume that the Minister is basing that estimate on the amount collected in 1946?
Comment on this
I am referring to the estimate of £65,000 as the receipts from this tax. I take it that you are basing that on the amount collected in 1946.
Comment on this
I would not say for 1946 but for the later years of the tax, with a deduction of course for the smaller area.
Comment on this
I should like to point out that 1946 and 1947 were boom years, and when it was not found a reasonable tax to collect in the boom years, now that the boom is over I do not see how the Minister can possibly hope to get anything like the amount that he is budgeting for. Speaking from practical knowledge, I can tell the Minister and the House that the boom in dancing at the end of the war and in the years immediately following the war, was caused by the number of American soldiers that came here on leave from Europe. Every American soldier who came here wanted to go to a dance hall to enjoy himself. They were followed in the summer time by visitors from England who came across here in search of enjoyment and good food. Dancing is more popular in England than it is in Ireland. The young people especially flocked to the ballrooms and dance halls of the city here. That is now all practically over. We have no American soldiers coming from Europe. Many people may be greatly pleased, but I would not say that anyone here is pleased that the English visitors, especially young people, have ceased to come to this country. They were welcome here, and while they felt that sometimes they were fairly well fleeced, they were allowed to enjoy themselves and they went away with pleasant recollections of the city here. That influx was responsible for the boom in dancing during the years on which the Minister has based his estimate.
I suggest to him, and I defy contradiction by his officials, that the attendance in the ballrooms in Dublin has fallen by two-thirds and that where he hopes to get £65,000, he will not get more than £22,000 because if the people are not attending dances they will not be paying taxes on the price of admission. It was with that knowledge that I considered it my duty to my constituents to advise the Minister and the Government as to the true facts of the situation when I spoke against this tax and when I endeavoured to submit an amendment. I feel now, in view of the statements made here, that the Minister might even still consider the suggestions I made in my amendment and to use them as a basis for the collection of this tax, so as not to interfere with people who go into the dance hall to enjoy themselves. The fact of being followed into the ballroom and of being interfered with perhaps in the middle of a dance is something they always resented and always will resent. I feel I am not letting myself down or that I can be accused of putting my personal interests before the interests of the community in general or of failing in my duty as a Deputy of this House when I suggest that it is not the people who go in that should be taxed but the people who own the ballroom. They pay a nominal fee for a licence at the present time and I think it would be a much better system for the Minister to adopt than the one in force at the present time. I think none of us objects to his getting the money, but we suggested to him how he would get it cheaper and easier and in a way which would not cause resentful sentiments outside. I would ask him even at this eleventh hour to reconsider the matter. He said that he would only get £25,000, but I thought it would go to between £40,000 and £50,000 or even higher. If the scale which I set up was not enough and the Minister adopted the manner in which I suggested the tax could be collected without any resentment, he is at liberty to take the figure I put before him and increase it by a third or a half or double it. He can do that without interfering with the people who have the right to enjoy themselves and I respectfully submit that even now he should consider it.
As a supporter of the Government, if there is a division, I am not going to vote against the Government. My amendment is there and I could oppose the Government and vote for it but on the other hand I am not going to vote against the Government for the purpose of advertising myself. But as every second speaker who has spoken on this controversial matter against the system by which this tax is collected was a Government supporter, if a free vote were taken that system would be turned down. I put that before the Minister and appeal to him to consider it.
Comment on this
I hope you will not mind, Sir, if I refer to a few facts to which I should have referred before. It was pointed out to me the number of clubs that would be affected. Hurling clubs, football clubs, tennis clubs, beagling clubs, hunting clubs, political clubs, benefits for printers' organisations, etc., and agricultural societies and farmers' societies would be very gravely hit by this tax and, in fact, quite a number of them my correspondent anticipates, will cancel their bookings and some have already cancelled them. That is not imagination, because one association gave figures showing that by the time they paid the tax it just would not be worth their while to run the dance. These are concrete facts, and I am glad that Deputy Mrs. Redmond supported that claim. She must have received the same letters as I did.
Comment on this
The City and County of Waterford has two or three big centres of population available to the surrounding rural dwellers.
Comment on this
Most of that correspondence is in answer to a whip round of the proprietors of dance halls. Do not the letters show that that is so?
Comment on this
Only the letters I got myself. It is pointed out that in the case of the short dances on Sunday night where the patrons pay 2/- and they are all working boys and girls who seek recreation and good music and are willing to create their own amusement—the price would now be raised. I do not know what the new price would be.
Comment on this
Céili dances will be affected. I could understand the Minister having regard to certain social benefits which he would like to see accruing and if he excepted céilis and dances where no drinks were sold, but he is not making an attempt to do anything like that. He is slapping on an inconsiderate tax which will mean the closing down of halls so that the result will be that he will not get the tax he anticipates. It is a pathetic commentary on the promises of the Government that there would be freedom for the various sections in the Government and that they would not be asked to vote against their settled definite opinions and convictions. We have an example where rigidity of discipline is even greater than it was in my experience as Chief Whip of a Party in which the discipline was pretty severe.
Comment on this
I would like to say a few words on the section as amended by the Minister. It struck me very forcibly that not since the days of the Charge of the Light Brigade at Balaclava have I seen so many Deputies eager to speak on such a trivial detail in a budget of £70,000,000.
Comment on this
To be candid and honest about the whole thing, I would much prefer if the Minister did not impose this tax, but while saying that, I do not subscribe to the gloomy forebodings that a terrible catastrophe is going to happen to this country as a result of this tax. I have experience of halls built by my associates out of their own little savings. They run dances now and then and are going to be affected. But the only thing I hope is that when the tax is in operation there will be no such thing as the evasion which was practised at the time it was in operation before and of which I could give examples if I wished to cause a little trouble in the House but I am not going to do that now. Do not the Deputies know very well, and Deputy Aiken when he was Minister for Finance stressed the point, that when the tax was in operation the price of admission was fixed in view of the tax and when the tax was taken off the price of admission was not reduced pro rata? Is not that a fact? Yet no one Deputy on the far side adverted to that very pertinent fact which is the foundation of the whole argument as far as the imposition of this tax is concerned. We were very glad at home when the tax was taken off but when it was in operation we paid the tax and when it is in operation now we will pay the tax and we will not increase the prices but will do with less. There again, is it not a well known fact that young people get into a motor car and go to a dance 50 miles away? Yet we are told that, if they have to pay 3d. and 4d. more, the county is doomed. We have had it advocated here that it will do away even with our culture and drive out the love of music from our people. We used to be very renowned for that, but surely no one on the opposite side will attempt to argue that there is music in dance bands. The more canned music they get in a dance band, the more they like it nowadays.
Comment on this
I happen to know a wee bit of music and have a good ear, and I know good music when I hear it. As regards this question of destroying the joy and pleasure, as suggested by Deputy Burke, in the rural population, I do not think his statement is correct at all. The vast majority of the rural people will have that three-mile limit, which will mean that they will not have to pay any tax on the hall which they use for recreation, dancing, cinema or otherwise. I believe that exemption is a very good one. I make these remarks, although personally I would prefer that the Minister did not reimpose the tax. At the same time, I do not subscribe to the views put forward by many Deputies on all sides of the House that, if this tax is imposed, the sky will fall and something awful will happen. Some Deputies seem to think that dancing is the be-all and end-all of the prosperity of this country. That is a view to which I do not subscribe. So far as the physical and cultural welfare of the people is concerned, it would be bad that they should have that opinion. I believe that the sensible Deputies—and I refer particularly to the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy de Valera—will find it very difficult to go in and vote against the Minister's imposition of this tax.
Comment on this
Will the Minister deal with céilidhe dancing? I am not a follower of these modern dances or jazz music and never found interest in them. My interest is in céilidhe dancing and whether it will be exempt.
Comment on this
Céilidhe dancing is dancing and is not exempt. Deputy Little, on his second intervention, spoke of the correspondence he had from his own area. I received, I think, the same correspondence. The letters, in the main, were protests against the increase in the tax not the reimposition. One letter sent to me personally said that:—
"Press reports following the Budget speech lead me to believe that the Budget tax was merely a reimposition of the old tax."
That note runs through all the letters —100 per cent. increase on the tax in 1946. It is clear from these letters that the proprietor of one of the halls naturally set about canvassing all his patrons and wrote to them urging them to write to him protesting against the tax, so that he could pass on the letters to Deputy Little. That is quite clear. One says:—
"I am in receipt of your letter and am amazed to learn that the tax would be 100 per cent. above the tax applied some years ago."
That was the protest I got, in the main. That was also the greater part of the burthen or song of complaints which two or three deputations I took on this matter had. I understood I had met by far the greater amount of the complaint about this tax by the reduction I brought in, at a cost of £45,000 to the revenue.
However, in the background of all this tax, there is one mistaken point of view which I do not suppose I will succeed in having removed—that this is a costly tax to collect. That is not so. There is no good in people working into a frenzy of calculation, in an amateurish way like Deputy de Valera, as to what might happen. The people on whom the State relies for the estimate of revenue to be got from all the various methods must be regarded as having some talent in estimation, in knowing what taxes would be fruitful and what the yield is likely to be and in associating, at least by way of estimate, the cost against that. Their view as expressed to me was that, in the days in which this tax had to be collected in a difficult way over remote rural areas, the cost of collection was 2 per cent. of what we got. I do not suppose that, if I say that a dozen times, I will get any credence from the Deputies opposite. They have taken a certain view, and will try to make the same calculations as Deputy de Valera indulged in, to prove that it must be costing more. There is the situation presented to me by people of experience, as against this amateurish action.
Comment on this
I do not know. If there is any good the Deputy thinks may be got from the information, I will get it for him. That was the estimate which he would have been given yesterday, if he requested it, on the question he put to the Parliamentary Secretary, but as the answer was circulated with the Official Report there was no chance of having any supplementary question. I know that every Deputy says that Deputy Aiken, when he took the tax off, said it took £80,000 to collect £85,000. He never said anything of the sort. He was not advised to say anything like that and, even on his own, he never said anything remotely like that. But that error persists and everybody talking on this uses that mistaken information, that this is a costly thing. I know that is the background of the Deputy's amendment.
He suggests, as an amendment, putting the tax on licences, calculating on so much money being received. Deputy Fitzpatrick, I think, was not attempting to collect in his tax the whole thing, but some portion of the tax and he was trying to give me the sum which he said represented the sum, less the expense, he thought, of collecting it. Deputies who have been talking about following me into the Division Lobby tramped resolutely through the Lobbies for 14 years to keep this tax on. All this imagination that was displayed in the Dáil to-night, that apparently was breaking their hearts, did not break out into speech for 14 years in the Deputies opposite. Apparently this tax was always a killjoy, always likely to cause unemployment, to lead to disposals of dance halls and prevention of others being built. According to Deputy Butler, it is even a help towards tuberculosis in the country. That is the way the tax is characterised. Deputy Butler gave me an impression of himself 40 years ago, if he was asked out to a social evening, bringing his violin — and he is lamenting that the dance hall tax has killed that sort of stuff. That was the position for 14 years. Deputies opposite walked the gangways every time.
Comment on this
Worst of all, it was apparently recognised for many years —I am not now referring to Deputy McCann's own particular and special piece of nonsense but to the general nonsense talked—that evasion was being practised all over the country.
Comment on this
You did not think it worth while to read the letter from the Irish Federation of Musicians.
Comment on this
Evasion was being practised all over the country and Deputies were cognisant of that, but they are afraid now of the demoralisathey are afraid now of the demoralisation that will be caused in the country through the evasion of this tax. While that evasion was being practised, they were either dumb about it or followed blindly the man who brought about that situation.
Comment on this
Some Deputies spoke of this as the real brightener of country life, and, for 14 years, the Deputies opposite dimmed the brightness of country life. I am the only person who has tried to remove these and other taxes from the rural areas. When the dancing tax was in operation, it was in operation in the rural areas, and, when entertainment tax of another type was in operation, it was in operation in the rural areas.
Comment on this
The Deputy is one of the people who complained about the rural areas of County Dublin. The rural areas of County Dublin have no bright rural life, but he did not do much to assist them to get any brightness in their drab lives for 14 years.
Comment on this
When it came to a question of taxing these people who were not able to go to picture-houses or dance halls in their tobacco and their beer, the Deputy taxed them, no matter what discomfort it was going to bring in those areas. Through the years, a big sum of money was collected. If there was evasion — and I am told there was, all over the place— the tax was apparently worth it. It crossed the £100,000 mark in 1943; it was £132,000 and a bit in 1944-45; and was just short of the £150,000 mark in 1945-46. If the promise of the first four months had been borne out, it would have gone fairly close to £250,000 in 1946-47. That was a good deal to extract from the bright countryside. I am looking for only £65,000, but I am looking for that sum in new circumstances.
Comment on this
In connection with an entertainment tax last year, Deputy McCann told a story, which I later characterised as a complete falsehood, about a Ringsend picture house.
Comment on this
The Deputy was one of the men who did and I challenged him and Deputy MacEntee later. We awaited a denial and got none, because in the meantime I had made contact with the proprietor. That is why I discount——
Comment on this
The Deputy pretended to be. I was in touch with the man spoken of and the Deputy was not briefed by him.
Comment on this
There is a difference between a false statement and a damned lie. A Deputy can make a false statement quite sincerely without knowing that it is false. Deputy McCann will withdraw that expression he has used towards the Minister.
Comment on this
Is the Minister entitled to persist in his statement when the Deputy has denied making the statement? The Deputy has denied it at least four times, and the Minister persists in repeating it.
Comment on this
The situation, as I see it, is entirely different under which I am looking for this amount of £65,000. Last year, as a result of the remission of the taxation given and by reason of people having more money to spend on themselves, certain of the taxes which were retained showed an increase in revenue yield beyond any expectation. They were mainly what I would call types of entertainment tax, though I do not mean the types which come strictly under the heading of entertainments tax. It was picture-houses last year, and the revenue derived from racing and betting and the yield from taxes on whiskey and tobacco — all these, taking them all together, went far beyond the estimates made. All the taxes which go to indicate that people had money to spend on themselves and on their amusements—and were spending it that way—yielded very well. I cannot understand why dancing is to be segregated and how people can come to the conclusion that all other forms of entertainment on which money is being spent, and spent partly for the good of the State, are going to continue to yield revenue, but that dancing is going to fall off. That is why I discount to a great extent all these lamentations about loss of employment. If there was to be loss of employment, it should have been seen over a 14 years' test, but Deputies opposite ran the tax for all that period, and if there was any evidence to be derived from the past, Deputies could have brought that evidence here and could have said: "Look at the results of this tax over 14 years. Look at the unemployment caused and look at all the dance halls lying derelict"; but not one particle of evidence of that sort can be brought forward.
When Deputy Aiken withdrew the tax some years ago, he did not do it on the ground that it was defeating itself, or on the ground that it was causing unemployment, or on the ground that it was hurting the rural areas, because the rural areas were not particularly in his viewpoint at the time. His attitude was: "We have recognised the truth of part of this statement that it is a dangerous tax to collect." That had application to the remote areas of the country and it was difficult—the word was used in the same context—from the angle of inspection. We are cutting out the dangerous and difficult areas, and, even then, in the easier areas, I will still abide by the estimate of 2 per cent. expense ratio in relation to the revenue to be derived. It cannot be called a costly tax.
Deputy Burke has put himself on record as saying that dancing is on the wane and, in fact, he says that dances now, before the tax is put on, are not paying. I am glad to have that recorded, and, when we come to have an inquest on this tax next year, we will see whether the situation is as bad as the Deputy believes.
Comment on this
He did not. He said that there were not as many dances as there were in what he called the peak years. Members of the House have spoken about this tax for the best part of three and a half hours—I want only ten or 15 minutes.
Comment on this
That was one of the suggestions made, I think, by Deputy Butler, but I did not think that Deputy McGrath associated himself with that particular piece of folly. Last year we got more revenue by reducing the tax on wine, and it seems to me the height of folly to increase a tax when the increase will result in a lesser yield.
Comment on this
I hope that there will be more wine drunk because there will be a greater yield, but the greater yield comes from the reduction in tax. I cannot get any more money out of an increase in the tax on wine.
There is the other side that ought to be considered in the context of this tax. People who go to dances do not merely dance. There is a good deal of smoking that goes on at dances and there is some drink actually consumed at dances. Both tobacco and drink are cheaper since February, 1948. There is about £6,000,000 that was being extracted from the people of the country in connection with these two taxes and that £6,000,000 is in the hands of those people to spend. I am asking here for £65,000. It is about £1,300,000 shillings. Deputies may come to their own conclusion. What proportion of the community dances? Do £500,000 of the £3,000,000 population dance?
Comment on this
And what dances do they attend? What can I get off them? If I get 2/3 from £500,000 people divided out of whatever number of dances they go to, the tax is saved. Mind you, this is in circumstances in which people are not made to dance the tune that Deputy O'Rourke's Leader made them dance for 14 whole years.
Comment on this
This is Section 12 of the Finance Bill of this year. In the first seven sections I have lost £886,000 by way of remitted tax in this year— £1,220,000 for a full year. In Section 12 I am asking for £65,000 in return. Surely it is a fair bargain the people are getting when I remit £886,000 in seven sections of the piece of legislation and ask for £65,000 back. I suggest it is a good tax and that I will get the money and will get it at less cost than is imagined.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider on Report Stage making exemption in the case of ceilidhes?
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Minister if ceilidhe dancing carried on for educational purposes will be exempt? We have had, I am sorry to say, several instances of the present Government hitting Gaelic in various ways.
Comment on this
The Minister says he has given back something to the people and that he is now asking only for £65,000 in this particular section. Actually, that £65,000 is portion of a bill which amounts to £24 7s. 0d. per head on the people. They have to pay that to the Minister for Central Fund and Supplies Services in one form or another, entirely apart from any capital that is raised for capital purposes, Electricity Supply Board and so on. He is taking £24 7s. 0d. per head off whatever he is giving back and that stands as against the £21 14s. 0d. per head that Fianna Fáil took off them. The £21 14s. 0d. has gone up to £24 7s. 0d. per head. The Minister can calculate that whatever way he likes, in the number of smokes or the number of dances.
The Minister did not deal at all in his reply to this long debate with the real, serious aspect of this tax on dancing. He made no effort at all to deal with the appalling case that was made by Deputy Fitzpatrick here as to the evasion that was going on to Deputy Fitzpatrick's knowledge, and he is in a position to know.
Comment on this
I was not eight years in Finance. I was two and a half years, and I abolished the tax because I got some little inkling of the facts that were announced here in this House by Deputy Fitzpatrick to-night. It is no secret. I mean, Deputy Fitzpatrick did not make any secret of it and he himself is a dance hall proprietor. I want to know what good is it to this community to have that sort of game going on for the sake of collecting £65,000? There are other taxes in connection with which you cannot have this evasion—and we will not put it any stronger than that.
I had hoped that the Minister would remit the tax when he heard Deputy Fitzpatrick and a number of other people say here in this House what I have heard myself—I could not speak from my own personal knowledge—that charitable organisations, having to keep their expenses within 50 per cent. of the total takings, are tempted and, according to some of the Deputies here who have spoken to-night, fall for the temptation of keeping their expenses very much lower than they actually are. Surely, a number of people in this country, whether they are in a political club or a football club or the Gaelic League or some other organisation that is doing something to give the people in the various localities a little bit of amusement and at the same time make a bit of profit for local organisations, are entitled to carry on without all these pip-squeak inspectors. That is not my phrase. It is the Minister for Finance's phrase and the Minister for Industry and Commerce's phrase. Are we going to have, unnecessarily, not only the pip-squeak inspectors into farmers' land and so on, but into the dance halls and into the dances and ceilidhes run for charitable organisations or for the local football club? Surely we are not that badly stuck. There was experience of this thing in the past and, even though we had postwar experience to meet and sudden emergencies, the cost of food and so on, even in view of that, the Fianna Fáil Government took the decision that they would abolish this particular tax and I believe still we were right in doing it and I believe the Minister is very wrong, from a social point of view, in reimposing it. There is not much in it. According to Deputy Fitzpatrick and others, he will not even collect half of what he should collect.
It is a very bad thing for the country that tax evasion on that scale should take place. I want the Minister to remember that after to-night's performance in this House the people of the county are not going to have to rely on my word as to whether a tax is a bad tax, leaving itself open to evasion and all sorts of flaws. They have the evidence of members of this Dáil, who spoke from personal knowledge, that it did lead to evasion and to fraud. I do not know how the Minister, or anybody, could calculate, to the fine point of 2 per cent., what this tax is going to cost to collect. I am sure that the Minister's official advisers did their best in making a rough shot at what they think it will cost. I do not know whether, in that particular item of cost, they took into consideration the travelling expenses, attendance at court and all the other incidental expenses that attach to the collection of this tax. I am certain that whether it is an easy and a cheap tax to collect from the official point of view of merely pounds, shillings and pence, it is a very dear tax to collect from a social point of view. I think, myself, that we should leave some part of the local pleasures alone, without having inspectors going in upon them, and that people should be able to come together and have a céilidhe or a dance and make a few pounds for the organisation in which they are interested without being subject to all this inspection. The matter of inspection has one other aspect. I do not know whether the Minister adverted to it or whether his officials brought it to his attention—as, indeed, they brought it to mine—that this particular type of collection makes the Revenue Commissioners' officials unpopular in the district.
If we are going to have the goodwill of the people behind the Government— behind all Governments, because no matter what Government is in power it has to collect a lot of money—in regard to the collection of revenue for the State we should do our utmost not to impose on the Revenue Commissioners' officials more unpopular jobs than we can avoid. Their job is unpopular no matter how we do it, but why on earth give them a job for a petty sum like this which is going to antagonise a very much bigger section of our people than would come into contact with them in the ordinary way? I feel that the Minister was very ill-advised. I could almost name the member in the present Cabinet who suggested this tax at the Cabinet table when the Minister wanted £100,000 to round off. All anybody has to do is to go back and read——
Comment on this
I am not mentioning his name at all. The Minister quoted statements I made when this tax was being abolished. All I suggested was that the Deputies should examine that debate and they will see who made the suggestion. I think it is a crazy suggestion. It is very bad socially and, from the point of view of the people of the country, the Minister should, even at this late hour, change his mind.
Comment on this
It is very evident that the Minister is not going to give way on this point because he prefers to have the inspector following all the people associated with sports clubs and charitable organisations around the country, spying on them here and there. Will the Minister consider giving a total exemption even to charitable societies? I have spoken on this before, and I am not going to delay the House any longer.
Comment on this
I would ask that total exemption be given to the charitable societies that you want to spike——
Comment on this
It was given by Deputy Aiken as Minister for Finance —to charitable societies, clubs, and so forth.
Comment on this
I should hate to think of the evasion that would be practised by people representing their activities as charitable. The demoralisation would be terrible.
Comment on this
By the spies — to look after the clubs all over the country. They can go into every dance hall now. The people cannot enjoy themselves without being interfered with. I should like the Minister to answer me on that point.
Comment on this
Question—"That Section 12, as amended, stand part of the Bill"—put.
Do you agree with this result?