Committee on Finance. - Vote 65—External Affairs (Resumed).
Contributions 1–182 of 547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The matter before the House is the Estimate for the Department of External Affairs to which a "reference back" motion has been moved. I should, perhaps, make it clear that in asking the Dáil to refer back this Estimate, we are asking it to express general disapproval of the administration of the Department of External Affairs and if we can persuade the Dáil to pass the motion, then, in our view, it should have some greater significance than was attached to a similar motion passed last week relative to the Estimate for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. The outstanding fact about the Estimate for the Department of External Affairs, to which I think Deputies' attention should be drawn, is the unprecedented increase in the cost of that Department which the Minister proposes to effect in this year.
Comment on this
The increase amounts to practically 40 per cent. over the expenditure on the Department in last year, and to almost 60 per cent. over the expenditure on the Department in the previous year. Now, as Deputy de Valera said last night, the various items making up the total bill for the Department, with one exception-the proposal to provide £25,000 for a fake news agency-are not in themselves objectionable, and in fact, in present circumstances, it would be quite reasonable for an increased Estimate for this Department to be presented to the House by a Fianna Fáil Government. I want to submit for the consideration of Deputies opposite, however, that it is very unreasonable to have such an Estimate presented to the House by a Government that proclaimed, when it came into office, that retrenchment was going to be the keyword of its policy. I want to ask Deputies opposite whether they think it desirable that we should provide more than £100,000 for increased staffs in the Department of External Affairs as compared with 1947 when we are asked to do so by a Government which, in the alleged interests of retrenchment and economy, closed down various activities which might reasonably be regarded as of a more useful character.
Last week we were told in the Dáil that a number of miners in the Avoca district had been dismissed from their employment because the plans for mineral exploration had not been proceeded with.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy not aware that mineral exploration was one of the economies that the Government announced its intention of achieving last year? Were we not told last year that the whole programme for mineral exploration had been abandoned in the interests of retrenchment? It is true that the Government has changed its mind and that the programme is to be proceeded with on a limited scale, but because of the delay there are a number of these miners in the Avoca district now idle. I am looking forward to the spectacle of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs explaining to these miners why it is desirable that they should be left unemployed while the Dáil cheerfully votes £100,000 to increase the number of civil servants in the Department of External Affairs and the number of officials serving in that Department in Ministries overseas.
Is it undesirable to remind Deputies of many of the other retrenchments with which the Government inaugurated its career? How are they going to explain to the hundreds of skilled workers, the aircraft mechanics who are scattered around the world because their employment here was ended in the interests of economy, through the decision to abandon the Atlantic air development? Is it necessary to repeat all the measures of economy and retrenchment in which the Government gloried last year, which they spoke about at every public meeting as indicative of the line they were going to follow? Did they tell the people then that they were going to come to the House in 1949 with a proposal to increase by £100,000 the amount to be spent upon officials in the diplomatic service? I am not objecting to the increase, except to the one nonsensical item relating to a news agency, but I want it to be understood that in proposing it to the Dáil the Government has hereby formally abandoned the policy upon which it declared it was elected, the policy which it announced its intention to follow when it was first constituted and when it outlined its aims and objects to the Dáil.
Is it any harm to remind Deputies what the present Minister for Finance would have said about the proposals in the Estimate if it was produced by a Fianna Fáil Minister and if the Minister for Finance were sitting on these benches? It would be described as further evidence of Fianna Fáil megalomania. Does any Deputy think that is unreasonable-that it is unreasonable to suggest that if the Minister for Finance were on these benches he would have said that?
Comment on this
What I am saying now -that many items of increased expenditure are quite reasonable. I am trying to get Deputies opposite into line with their own past. Every proposal with reference to diplomatic representation abroad was always opposed by many of the Deputies who are now going to sit silently and vote silently for the most spectacular increase ever known in that Department.
I want to repeat that I am not asserting, and I do not believe, that it is undesirable that an extension in the Department should take place. I do not know what precise case the Minister for External Affairs produced to the Minister for Finance to get his consent to the establishment of two new sections in the Department and the addition to the staffs of Ministeries overseas of press officers, counsellors and public relations experts, but there must have been arguments that we could not think of during the 16 years when we were trying to build up this service gradually in the teeth of Fine Gael opposition, and particularly opposition from the Minister for Finance who, apparently, raised no question when these proposals came to him from his present Coalition colleague.
Let that stand as a preliminary. Let us take it that the whole retrenchment policy of the Coalition Government was, like everything else about it, a fake, but in this case they could not keep up the pretence of adhering to that policy for long and so they have to admit themselves that it was a fake.
Comment on this
I do not know if I am right in assuming that there has been some redistribution of functions amongst Ministers and that the Minister for External Affairs has now got responsibilities in regard to negotiations of trade agreements which were previously the function of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and also responsibilities for wider aspects of financial policy which were previously regarded as the special concern of the Minister for Finance. Certainly, judging by declarations made by the Minister for External Affairs, as such, it is reasonable to conclude that such a redistribution of functions has taken place.
That may not be correct. It may be that the Minister for External Affairs is still merely the channel by which other Governments are informed of decisions taken by the Government here for which other Ministers are responsible to this House. I think, however, it is desirable that the position should be clarified, and clarified speedily, because it is inevitable there will be confusion in the public mind when the Minister for External Affairs appears to be taking a line upon matters of trade and finance, which are of particular importance and significance at the present time, and which is contrary to the line previously indicated by the Taoiseach and other Ministers as the considered policy of the Government.
If the recent declarations of the Minister for External Affairs are to be taken as indicative of Government policy, then some change has occurred of which the public are unaware. If they are not so indicative, then they suggest there is a divergence between the policy which he is following and that which the public previously understood to be Government policy. I assume, however, this is the correct occasion upon which to discuss actions and statements of the Minister for External Affairs, acting as such, in relation to matters bearing upon trade and finance, which have or may have in the future very serious repercussions on the interests of this country. Recently the Minister attended, as representative of this State, at a conference in Paris held under the auspices of the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation. The matter which arose for consideration at that conference is of only indirect concern here now, but the implications of the attitude adopted by the Minister at the conference in relation to that matter could be very serious indeed and I am referring to it now for the purpose of getting some clarification of the policy which the Minister appears to have followed there and some elucidation of the aims which he hoped to achieve by following that policy.
The conference in Paris was of a technical character. It was apparently necessitated by the termination of an arrangement which operated during the first year of the Marshall Plan for the financing of inter-European trade and was called specially to consider proposals for an alteration in these arrangements during the present year. We are not concerned with the details, and I do not propose to bore the Dáil by any reference to the details. It may be worthy of notice, however, that the arrangements made last year for the financing of inter-European trade amongst Marshall Plan countries was in accordance with British policy and, as Deputies are no doubt aware, British policy in those matters is very largely directed towards the preservation of the gold and dollar reserves, which have been so much in the news lately and which are not merely the gold or dollar reserves of Great Britain, but of the whole of the sterling area, in which this country is included. British policy arising out of the circumstances existing last year has been largely based upon the idea of conducting European trade upon a series of tightly drawn bilateral agreements, all of which were expressly designed to ensure that sterling resulting from British purchases in European countries could be used only to effect purchases in Great Britain or other parts of the sterling area.
I have said that British policy was primarily designed to protect the gold and dollar reserves of the sterling area and, while it is possibly not in order to discuss now all the implications of the position which is developing in relation to these reserves, it is important, to understand the criticism I have to make of the policy of the Minister for External Affairs, that the Dáil should appreciate the importance of the protection of these reserves to the trade of this country and, in fact, how difficult it would be for the sterling area system to function at all if these reserves should be further depleted. At this Paris conference which the Minister for External Affairs attended, called for the purpose of considering the arrangements to be made for the financing of inter-European trade in the coming year, there was a proposal which originated with the American authorities which was formulated through the Economic Co-operative Administration and which was supported at Paris by a number of European countries, a proposal which was expressed as designed to facilitate the development of multilateral trade in contrast with the system of bilateral trading which Britain had been maintaining—to develop multilateral trade and get away from the bilateral basis— a proposal which was strongly and vigorously opposed by the Chancellor of the British Exchequer, who attended the conference as the principal British delegate, on the grounds that the adoption of the proposal would inevitably mean a further depletion of these dwindling reserves.
As a result of the vigorous opposition to the proposal put forward by the British Government through their Chancellor of the Exchequer the proposal was in fact abandoned or, at any rate, a compromise was effected which the British Chancellor described as quite satisfactory from his point of view. In case any Deputy of the Coalition Parties has any doubt as to what heretofore was the policy of the Government in regard to the maintenance of these sterling area gold and dollar reserves, it may be no harm to remind them that just about this time last year they voted enthusiastically to give approval to an agreement made by their Government with the British authorities which dealt, amongst other matters, with the measures we would take here to ensure that we would not be responsible for any net drain upon these reserves, and voted also for the initiation and maintenance of restriction upon our trade for that purpose.
In the course of the debate upon that agreement, of which the Dáil approved, the Taoiseach stated at column 2165, Volume 112, No. 12 of Dáil debates of 5th August, 1948:—
"The British Government was very gravely concerned at the drain on the sterling area reserve of gold and dollars and this anxiety was shared-naturally shared-by all members of the sterling area."
He explained that the British Chancellor of the Exchequer had informed them that the level of these reserves had fallen this time last year to approximately £500,000,000, that that was regarded as the irreducible minimum, that any further diminution of these reserves would produce something akin to a crisis and that there had been an appeal to the Government here and to all Governments in the sterling area to make whatever sacrifices were necessary in order to prevent any further diminution. Last week the British Chancellor of the Exchequer told the House of Commons that they have since fallen to £400,000,000 and it is obvious that they will be down to about £300,000,000 at the end of the next quarter.
Comment on this
That is an irrelevant observation, as I shall explain later. Later, in the same debate, quoting from the same column, the Taoiseach went on as follows:—
"Sir Stafford Cripps, Chancellor of the Exchequer, informed us that in the view of his Government the level of the reserves should not be further reduced during the period of Marshall Aid"—
the period of Marshall Aid is the four-year period from 1948 to 1952.
"and that the reserves must be maintained at their present level in the interests of the sterling area as a whole so that, at the end of the period of aid, sterling would be sufficiently strong to meet any difficulties and readjustments that may arise."
Then the Taoiseach added the following:—
"Having regard to our interest in the financial strength of the sterling system we cannot quarrel with that policy."
The level of these gold and dollar reserves of the sterling area has, as I have mentioned, fallen considerably below what it was this time last year when the British Chancellor of the Exchequer, Sir Stafford Cripps, was conveying that message to the Taoiseach and when the Taoiseach was declaring to this House that we could not quarrel with the policy which had been proposed.
That diminution in the gold and dollar reserves of the sterling area, the prospect of the still further diminution and the ultimate picture that offers of the breaking up of the whole sterling area system is a very serious one for us; I mean serious for the people of this country, serious in relation to the prospect of keeping our workers in employment and maintaining our present standard of living. We have, therefore, a clear interest in the success of whatever measures may be taken by the British authorities to protect these reserves, to prevent their further diminution and, if possible, to restore them.
The trade of Britain, like the trade of this and every other country in the sterling area, is dependent upon the success of these measures. Even the trade agreement which the Minister for External Affairs signed with France last week is presumably only of interest to France if the sterling surplus which she secures for trade from this country is useful in the financing of purchases elsewhere. It may be that the Government here is entitled to question whether the diminution of these sterling area reserves is due to any defects of British policy. Certainly, the obligation to maintain them does not rest merely upon the junior partners in the sterling area system and, if there is any reason to believe that the British Government have been less careful in their protection than they expected us to be, then presumably representations on these lines will be made by the Government here to the British authorities. That, however, is a matter primarily between the Governments of the countries constituting the sterling area.
We know from the statements made here by the Minister for Finance when introducing his Budget that this country has not been responsible for any net drain upon the sterling area reserves. It is true that there was an overdraft allowed for the purpose of financing dollar trade during the period in which the dollar loans under the Marshall Plan are being negotiated. But, as the Minister for Finance quite definitely pointed out, we are obliged to refund to the sterling area pool the whole of the accommodation allowed out of dollars that we borrow from America under the present arrangement with that country. I do not know if the Government here have been at all concerned about the enormous increase in our dollar imports. There has been an expansion during the first five months of this year compared with the first five months of last year amounting to several million pounds. It is true that we can purchase goods for dollars without encroaching upon the sterling area reserves because we borrow the dollars and we borrow them under an obligation to repay them. We are not, like Britain, receiving Marshall Aid grants and, consequently, the extent to which we import goods from the United States and pay for them in dollars is of concern to us only in so far as we are naturally perturbed by the expansion of any external debt that we may have difficulty in repaying in the future.
Comment on this
I admit that in dealing with these general questions of financial policy I may be going outside the strict limits of the External Affairs Vote. I mention these matters merely for the purpose of giving the House the background in which I shall ask it to consider the line of policy taken by the Minister for External Affairs who has been dealing with these matters at the international conferences this year.
Comment on this
I realise the Deputy made an introductory remark in that respect, but he would now appear to be dealing with matters other than that.
Comment on this
The sole purpose of these remarks is to criticise the line of action taken by the Minister for External Affairs at these various conferences to which I have referred. Let me say that, in criticising that line of policy, there is no question in my mind of either an anti-British or a pro-British bias. We must consider our policy in relation to these matters primarily in regard to our own interests. Whether we like it or whether we do not, we have here a vital interest in the protection of these gold and dollar reserves to which I have referred; we have a vital interest bearing upon the level of economic activity here and the well-being of our own people. I think it is fair to mention that we also have an interest in the efforts of the British Government to maintain the present standard of living of the British people and the development of British trade because the bulk of our exportable surplus goes to Great Britain; and the way of life and the conditions of trade there determine very largely the market that exists for our exportable surplus. If Government Deputies are critical of that situation I can only remind them that under the trade agreement which they themselves made the aim of the Government appears to be to consolidate rather than to alter that position. It is clear, therefore, on the face of it that we have a vital interest and all the facts suggest that we should support the measures which have been taken and are being taken by the British authorities to resist any proposal emerging elsewhere, which, in their view, would have the effect of further depleting these reserves or affecting adversely the efforts of the British Government to preserve them.
I make that statement on the basis of information that is available to me. It may be that there is information available to the Government which members of the Dáil or public have not got, and one of the purposes of these observations of mine is to endeavour to extract that information from the Government if it exists and if they are willing to supply it. I know that in this matter there are other considerations and I am referring now particularly to political considerations. But while I may deal with that matter further, I want to say here and now that, if the line of policy taken by the Minister for External Affairs at the Paris Conference is based on other considerations and particularly based on political considerations——
Comment on this
——it should only be after the fullest possible consideration of all the consequences and the fullest public discussion of the issues here. In so far as the public are aware from the considered statements made last year by the Taoiseach and other Ministers, the line of policy followed by them up to the present has been in accordance with the facts. The Minister has asked me to refer to statements made by him which seem to indicate that he has been following a somewhat different line. I propose to do so. Let me say this, that in connection with that Paris Conference I think it is true to say that the Minister issued a Press interview every day. In fact, he did not even stop after his return.
Comment on this
From recollection, I do not think I gave any Press interviews at all in Paris last time.
Comment on this
A number of statements were published in the Press which purported to be interviews with the Minister and were not repudiated by him.
Comment on this
That is what I am trying to find out now, to what extent they are accurate. I mention that fact to emphasise that we are not complaining that the Minister failed to make known, through the Press, to the public here and to his colleagues in the Government, the line he was proposing to follow and did, in fact, follow at the conference. Therefore, it is on the face of it reasonable to assume that in following that line he was acting in accordance with the general view of the Government as a whole.
On June 29th, which I think was the day the Minister arrived in Paris for the purpose of attending the conference, there was an interview with him published in the Press.
Comment on this
I am quoting this interview from the Irish Press—it was, I think, a news agency circulation—in which he indicated that Ireland would support the United States in urging the development of multilateral trade in Europe instead of the strictly bilateral agreements supported by Britain. “Ireland,” he said, “believes in multilateral trade and we believe trade restrictions should be relaxed.” That was June 29th. There was another interview on June 30th which is not quite relevant to this matter and then on July 2nd in another interview——
Comment on this
Yes, given as interviews. The first report which I read was published as an interview with the Minister in the Irish Press on June 29th. The second interview was a Reuter report of an interview published in the Irish Independent. The third was also published in the Irish Independent. There was, I think, a special representative of the Irish Independent with the Minister in Paris.
Comment on this
Well, the Irish Independent said they had a special representative with the Minister in Paris. On July 2nd, as I said, the Minister was reported as follows:—
"An ambitious investment programme in which the American Government and private American capital would participate is the only way of bridging the dollar gap, in the Irish view.
The British idea that the gap must be closed by expanding exports to the United States and at the same time reducing imports is unrealistic the Irish say."
On July 4th, the Minister is reported as having said the following: He attacked what he termed:—
"the outworn and unrealistic policy adopted by some of the member countries towards the Marshall Plan."
In particular, he instanced the British policy that consisted in recommending to the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation the limiting of certain purchases from the United States and the expansion of exports to the dollar zones.
These interviews and others which I will quote suggest that at that Paris Conference the Minister followed a line which the British believed to be detrimental to the interests of the sterling area as a whole and likely, if successful, to make it impossible to protect the gold and dollar reserves of the sterling area. I am not asking the Dáil to consider now—it would not be in order—whether that was a sound line or a wrong line. What I want from the Minister or from some member of the Government is an assurance that the Government considered the matter in advance. I want an assurance that, having considered the matter in advance, the Government authorised the Minister for External Affairs to take that line and that they are satisfied that, as a result of their considerations, that line is in our national interest. If they did consider it, if they are satisfied it is in the national interest, if they authorised the Minister to follow it at Paris, then I think that all the facts and all the considerations which led them to that conclusion should be made known to the Dáil and to the Irish public.
In the course of the interviews issued in connection with that conference, the Minister criticised the representatives of other countries attending the conference on the ground that they were unduly concerned with their own local problems. I think it is reasonable that this Dáil, now that the Minister is standing before it to account for his administration during the year, should ask him in what capacity he thinks he went there. If he regards it as a criticism of the representatives of the countries to say that they were unduly concerned with their own local problems, for what purpose does he consider that the Irish people should send him as their representative and to defray all the expenses in connection with his visit? The general conclusion which one must draw from the Minister's statement is that he did not regard himself as primarily concerned to protect our own local interests. In a statement issued by the Department of External Affairs last week, after the Minister's return to Dublin, he complained about "the tendency displayed at the Paris Conference to rebuild selfish nationalistic economic systems instead of establishing effective international economic co-operation". That particular phrase struck my eye because it reminded me of similar phrases used in the early days of the Fianna Fáil Government when we were embarking on our own industrial development programme by the representatives of highly developed industrial States who were then very anxious to prevent backward nations like ourselves developing our industry through the method of restrictions on imports.
In the early days of Fianna Fáil there was a world-wide slump and every country was trying to maintain whatever residue of industrial activity was left to it by pumping out exports very freely and even subsidising exports to get them out. Naturally, that practice made it much more difficult for new industries to get established here. We tried to remedy that position by imposing trade restrictions of one kind or another and were, with other States pursuing the same policy, not infrequently denounced at international conferences by the representatives of great States who accused us of pursuing selfish nationalistic economic policies instead of collaborating in international economic co-operation. I was quite perturbed to see a similar phrase used by the present Minister for External Affairs because it seems to indicate that he has been caught out and absorbed in the atmosphere of these international conferences and, in that atmosphere, he is beginning to lose sight of the particular interest of the country which he was sent there to represent.
Now all this comes down in a most specific way to the policy of the Government when one considers the speech made by the Taoiseach at the meeting in O'Connell Street which was addressed by representatives of all Parties following the introduction of the Ireland Bill in the British House of Commons. At that meeting, the Taoiseach indicated that in his view it should be the national policy to hit the British in their pocket. It would be a quite understandable line for the Minister for External Affairs to oppose British proposals designed to protect British interests and, incidentally perhaps to protect our own, but primarily to protect British interests at the Paris Conference, if the reason for his opposition were a desire to hit Britain in her pocket irrespective of the consequences to ourselves. That would be understandable but what I do not and cannot understand, what nobody can understand, is why the Minister followed that line, recognising that in following it it might involve hardships for our people, without explaining to the people why he is doing that.
If the reason the Minister took that questionable line at the Paris Conference was for the purpose of hitting Britain, in whatever manner he could, irrespective of any other consideration, we are prepared to discuss that policy but it seems to me a futile policy unless it is widely publicised and particularly publicised at home so that our people may understand the reason why it is followed. What I want to know is whether the reasons he adopted that particular line of policy are to be found in the speech delivered by the Taoiseach at the meeting to which I referred. I do not myself think that action upon that policy will be effective against Partition if it hits us more than it hits the British. If it has the effect of lowering our level of employment or our standard of living more than it can effect the level of employment or the standard of living in Britain, if the effect of any policy adopted here is to produce unemployment, emigration and generally to disimprove economic conditions, we may well be taking a course which would weaken rather than strengthen the campaign against Partition.
The facts of the matter are that we have in this country a very substantial stake in the value of sterling, first of all, because of our sterling assets which are important for the financing of our current trade as well as holding out a prospect of enabling us to build our capital resources and to engage in future economic development. We have a substantial stake in the value of sterling because of our interests in the level of property in Britain itself, which level very largely determines the size of the market which is available for expanding Irish agricultural production. We have also a stake in the value of sterling because, as Deputies know, its acceptability in international trade is the sole assurance that we have, when Marshall Aid is ended, that we shall be able to effect the purchase of commodities which we require and which are not available to us except from outside the sterling area.
As I say, we may not like the fact; we may wish to change the fact; we may feel that Government policy should be directed towards escaping from that position, but it would be the height of folly to ignore the fact or to follow a course of action which would be intelligible only upon the basis of ignoring the facts. If the Government is ignoring them, then we want a reconsideration of its policy. If they have fully considered it and are fully conscious of the effects of it, and still approve of the line taken by the Minister at Paris, a line which, in the view of the British authorities, would have a serious effect upon the future of sterling and upon the level of the assets of the sterling area, then we want to know why. I am not asking the Dáil to consider that policy now; it would be, probably, inappropriate to consider it on the Vote of the Minister for External Affairs, but we are entitled to ask the Minister why he followed that line and if, in following it, he had the concurrence of his colleagues in the Government, particularly the concurrence of the Taoiseach and other Ministers who spoke in a different strain during the past 12 months.
There is perhaps a supicion in some quarters that the Minister for External Affairs acts in these matters independently of his colleagues or even in conflict with them, and if other Ministers are remaining silent on the matter— and, as I have said, the Minister's Press interviews make it impossible for them to say that they did not know the line he was following in Paris— then it must be because Party considerations appear to make it more important to remain silent despite their disagreement than to express that disagreement in public or to check the line taken by the Minister. If any consideration other than Party considerations justifies the silence of the Taoiseach and other Ministers, assuming they disagree with that line—and we must assume that they disagree because of their previous declarations —we want them to state that publicly.
By far the biggest of the economic problems which this Dáil and the country will have to face in the next couple of years was described by the Taoiseach in a recent public speech. This is a quotation from the speech:—
"World economic dislocations which are creating serious problems from the effect of which, if they develop, this country cannot hope to escape."
There is, in our view, no evidence that the Government is attempting realistically to appraise these problems, much less is contemplating taking effective action to protect this State against them should they develop. At best the attitude of the Minister for External Affairs at the Paris Conference suggested that our immediate local and national interests are being sacrificed to some vague international concept which has not been elucidated, or at worst that our national interests have been ignored, either because the Minister has not fully grasped them or has been play-acting or has a dislike, arising out of bias, from appearing to take the British side on any issue at any international conference. I think this is a serious matter to which the House should give its attention and I suggest that it should not be dismissed by the Government with a few wisecracks or quips, that there should be a serious and considered statement of Government policy and an assurance from the Minister, if he makes a statement that he speaks with the authority of his colleagues in the Government.
Comment on this
After listening to Deputy Lemass it is possibly necessary to remind the House that the letters O.E.E.C. stand for Organisation of European Economic Co-operation. I think if Deputy Lemass dwells on the title of the organisation he might possibly find some clue as to what is the work that that organisation is endeavouring to do and if he ponders a little bit more fully on it I think he will find that the attitude which he has ascribed to the Minister for External Affairs certainly calls for no apology from him. In adopting an attitude suggesting general international co-operation on economic lines he was merely doing the work for which the conference was set up and properly representing the people who sent him to that conference.
I think that for many reasons it is a pity that Deputy Lemass did not deal more fully with a certain document which was submitted as Ireland's long-term programme regarding European recovery. I would like to remind the House that on 6th March last Deputy Lemass went down to Fermoy and made a speech there and that in the course of that speech he stated publicly that the document submitted by the Minister for External Affairs to that organisation as Ireland's long-term programme was dishonest and was calculated to mislead. I raised that question by means of Parliamentary Question in this House immediately afterwards and some discussion, not all of which was tame, ensued. Deputy Lemass gave an undertaking on that occasion that he would see to it that he would raise this matter on the Minister's Estimate and that he would prove that he was right and the Minister was wrong. In Volume 114, column 1163, Deputy Lemass put himself on record as saying:
"There was not a statement in that speech which was false or untrue or inaccurate and I shall raise the matter on the Minister's Estimate and prove that."
Comment on this
I have already raised it. I do not want the Deputy to think that I did not raise it to-day because I have any reluetance to do so. I have already dealt with it on the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
Later on in the course of the same day to which I am referring, that is 10th March last, a Supplementary Estimate in respect of this particular organisation was before the House and Deputy Lemass put on a very good performance then and he fenced with the Chair with regard to his rights to raise this matter of the speech at Fermoy on the Supplementary Estimate, knowing, of course, that he was going to be ruled out on that and that he would not get an opportunity of raising it and he decided, to use his own expression, that he would have to bow to the Chair's ruling but he did it with very great regret and again he uttered the threat that he would be able to deal with this on the main Estimate when the Minister came into the House with the Estimate for External Affairs. He did not do it.
Comment on this
And he never did it because he would then have been in the position, not of addressing a Fianna Fáil meeting in Fermoy, but addressing the Minister who knows something about this matter. I am introducing this question of Deputy Lemass's speech at Fermoy very deliberately because I want it dealt with by the Minister on this Estimate and I want the Minister to get an opportunity of dealing with it in a way which the Deputies opposite might possibly remember in future. I believe that the speech made by Deputy Lemass at Fermoy was a particularly vicious effort to undo some of the work the Minister is trying to do. I believe it was done in order to give the hint to the American authorities that as long as this Government was in office, as long as Fianna Fáil were out of office, Fianna Fáil did not want to see any Marshall Aid coming to this country.
When the Minister replied to the question I raised here on 10th March, which was the first opportunity I got of raising it after the Deputy's speech. I think the House will recollect the very deliberate effort made by Deputies opposite to prevent the Minister from speaking. I think they will remember particularly the scandalous and audacious conduct of Deputy Lemass when he turned to the Ceann Comhairle and told the Ceann Comhairle, when he rang the bell for order, "You need not ring that bell. We are not going to listen," and I think they will remember similar remarks made by Deputy Boland on the same occasion.
I am raising the matter now so that the Minister may get an opportunity of dealing with it and of dealing with it at whatever length he likes. The gist of the complaint made by Deputies opposite at that time was that the Minister's reply was too long and I think I am correct in saying that the Ceann Comhairle ruled that long replies were not in order. Nevertheless, quite apart from that, there was a deliberate attempt made, particularly by Deputy Lemass, supported by Deputy Boland and the lesser lights of Fianna Fáil, to prevent the Minister from speaking, to refuse to listen when the Chair endeavoured to preserve order. However, I hope sincerely that the Minister will take this opportunity of dealing with that speech and also with some other speeches made by Deputy Lemass in the course of the year.
The Department for which the Minister is responsible is in many respects now a very difficult one and it covers a very wide field of operations. By reason of the trend of world affairs, and the particular stage which the world had reached when the Minister took office, this Department was rendered all the more difficult. It is a Department which, in my opinion, deserves not only sympathy but active assistance from all political Parties in this State. I believe that the Department of External Affairs, by reason of the work which it does and which it must do in the name of the people of this country, should have that active assistance from all Parties.
Comment on this
Whatever may have happened in the past, I intend allowing my mind to travel back over a 12 month period. I think if Deputy Allen will stop hopping about like a flea he may be a little bit interested in what I have to say.
Comment on this
Whatever may be said of State Departments which deal mainly or wholly with matters of domestic day to day policy inside the State, a State Department which deals with other countries, which is charged with the responsibility of representing Ireland's attitude abroad and guiding Ireland's relations with foreign States is a Department which should get active support or at least the charity of silence from all Parties in this House on those matters which very often are of vital consequences not only to the present generation but to future generations. I am sorry that Deputy Lemass in the course of the year did not render that assistance to the Department and did not even render the assistance of keeping silent. I referred to one speech made by the Deputy and I shall come back to it later.
I also want to remind the House of the speech made by the same Deputy in September, 1948, in Bray, at a time when Ministers of this Government were about to become engaged in discussions with Great Britain covering, in the main, trade relations, but, for all Deputy Lemass knew, possibly covering also other questions referring to the future status of this country. That was the time chosen by Deputy Lemass to go to Bray and make a speech there which was reported in the Irish Press on Monday, September 20th, 1948. In that speech Deputy Lemass did not give any assistance to the Government. He did not endeavour to uphold the authority of the Government or the team of Ministers who were going to negotiate for this country abroad. Instead of that, he went down to Bray in order to warn the people of Great Britain that this Government had no authority to speak for the people of this country and that the less they had to do with them the better, as Fianna Fáil was the only Party in the State which was entitled to speak for the people. Will Deputy Lemass accept that as a fair summary of his speech?
Comment on this
This is the quotation:
"There were matters on which understanding with Britain was desirable and even necessary. If it was to be achieved it would have to be attempted by a Government which represented the Irish people and had a clear mandate from them for its policy. The present Government represented nobody."
Will Deputy Lemass accept that?
Comment on this
I am reading from "Truth in the News". Prior to that particular passage, Deputy Lemass had conditioned his audience by this particularly enlightening phrase:
"The manoeuvres of Coalition leaders in regard to matters of external affairs, and particularly relations with the British Commonwealth, were not, as some might have thought, a device to distract public attention from their inability to fulfil election promises or the cost of living and unemployment."
Comment on this
I have finished precisely what I want to read. I will give you plenty of it later. I intend giving also—I forewarn you of it— the utterances at Bantry of the keeper of the Russian jewels.
Comment on this
That was the method in which Deputy Lemass chose to deal with the question of external affairs in Bray on September 19th, 1948, at a time when Ministers of this State were going abroad to negotiate on behalf of the people of this country with the British Government. Deputy Lemass did not do it by accident, in my opinion at any rate. I will say this for him, that he did go down the country again within a week of that and he retracted to a very large extent what he said in Bray.
Comment on this
He spent a considerable time in Tullamore endeavouring to convince his audience there that he did not really say in Bray what the Irish Press had reported him as saying. He said that, after all, whether he liked it or not or whether Fianna Fáil liked it or not, this Government was the Government elected by the people.
Comment on this
I certainly never said it in Tullamore or anywhere else and I do not say it now. You represent nothing except a post-election interval.
Comment on this
He said that this Government, whatever he thought about it, whatever his feelings were about it, was entitled to speak for the people and, I think the phrase he used was, "however they got there".
Comment on this
I have not got that particular quotation and I must accept the Deputy's word. Let me warn the Deputy—and I think I will be able to wipe the brassy smile off his face before I have finished—that I will see that quotation is in the House before this debate concludes, if I can put my hand on it.
Comment on this
I certainly never said that this Government has a right to speak for the people. It is a complete repudiation of everything I stand for.
Comment on this
One of the main items which I think we are entitled to discuss on this Vote is the legislation passed in this House and in other Parliaments during the course of the year and the effects of those Acts. As the Minister mentioned when introducing his Estimate, one of the important things that occurred in the field of external relations this year was the repeal of the External Relations Act. In view of some of the speeches Deputies opposite made during the by-election campaign in West Cork, it might possibly be necessary to remind their supporters that the repeal of the External Relations Act had the support of Fianna Fáil; that, irrespective of the speeches made by Deputy MacEntee in this House during the discussion on the repeal, in fact Fianna Fáil did not oppose the repeal of the External Relations Act in this House; and that Deputy Lemass, prior to introduction of the repeal, went on record in a speech in Rathfarnham as stating that he regretted that Fianna Fáil were not in office to repeal the Act themselves and left no doubt at all in the minds of his readers that Fianna Fáil were in fact supporting the repeal of the External Relations Act.
Comment on this
Legislation should not be discussed except from the point of view of administration. I do not think this is the time to answer speeches made at an election in regard to legislation which is now enacted.
Comment on this
It is, of course, no secret that there are certain views regarding the action of the Government in repealing that Act. There were different viewpoints expressed both inside and outside this House and the matter was referred to at some length by the Minister in introducing the Estimate.
Comment on this
It was referred to in a semi-controversial manner by the Leader of the Opposition last night, in so far as the Leader of the Opposition appeared to be somewhat regretful of remarks which have been made by some of his own followers. It occurred to me when listening to Deputy de Valera last night that it was a great pity the public repudiation of Deputy Boland's speech which was made by Deputy de Valera last night was not made when Deputy de Valera was speaking in Dunmanway during the West Cork election. However, as I say there was no doubt to my mind——
Comment on this
There was no doubt, to my mind, that Fianna Fáil supported the repeal of the External Relations Act.
Comment on this
A by-election occurred in West Cork. Deputy Boland went down to open the Fianna Fáil campaign there. Deputy Boland is not a novice at this game. I might be. He is a man who was for a great number of years a Minister in a responsible position. He is a man who has always been used as the spearhead of the Fianna Fáil organisation when crucial elections have cropped up. He was a man who, rightly or wrongly, had a position of authority and responsibility in the last Government. Because of that position of responsibility and authority, he is a man whose views are listened to at times. Deputy Boland went down to Bantry to hoist the Fianna Fáil flag in the West Cork election.
Comment on this
Are we going to have the speeches that were made in the West Cork election all over again?
Comment on this
I asked Deputies to forget that there was an election in West Cork but, for some reason or another, Deputy Boland went down to West Cork and said: "The deterioration in our relations with Great Britain was due either to short-sighted, incompetent leadership or to deliberate mischief-making."
Comment on this
Deputy Boland, when making that remark, was referring to the repeal of the External Relations Act.
Comment on this
There is no doubt at all that his reason for referring to the repeal of the External Relations Act was that he wanted to make a pawn and a plaything out of the minority vote in West Cork. That is the reason why, instead of repudiating the speech of Deputy Boland when he later went down to speak there, Deputy de Valera could not make up his mind, and said to the people of West Cork: "I cannot say whether it is a good thing or whether it is a bad thing."
Comment on this
I will let the Minister know who is making the mischief, I hope, before I have finished.
Comment on this
Last night Deputy de Valera opened the discussion for the Opposition on this Estimate. He adopted what I thought was a very reasonable attitude throughout. It is a pity that he was not here to-day to conclude rather than allow Deputy Lemass to nip in. In the course of his statement last night, Deputy de Valera did say that the Minister was not to blame for the deterioration in our relations with Great Britain. He did not quite put it like that. I think his exact words were: "The Minister is not at fault although he regretted that relations with Britain had not improved but the reverse in the last year or so."
Comment on this
What I think the Leader of the Opposition said was: "I am not saying whether it is his fault or not."
Comment on this
Deputy de Valera was quoting the Minister who last year boasted about the fact that he had improved our relations with Great Britain.
Comment on this
We can clear it up through Deputy Lemass's mouth, because Deputy Lemass was not content with making speeches at Bray, Rathfarnham and Fermoy, but he also visited the unfortunate people of Rathluire, and there he said: "It was ridiculous to suggest that the revival of British interest in maintaining Partition was due solely to the repeal of the External Relations Act."
Comment on this
The Deputy must be very fond of hearing himself. There is nothing of very great interest in the rest of it. I am prepared to accept the words of the Leader of the Opposition and of the deputy-leader of the Opposition that, whatever may be said about the question of our relations with Great Britain having improved or deteriorated, the Minister is not at fault, and that that is not due to the repeal of the External Relations Act.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe will have some other point of view on this later. I want to assure him that I am just as interested in his view as I am in the views of Deputy Boland, Deputy de Valera or Deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
Whenever Deputy Killilea contributes to discussions here I can see why it was necessary that a very eminent counsel in this State should go on record, briefed on behalf of a very eminent newspaper in this State as saying that most people view the proceedings in Dáil Éireann with a kind of cynical amusement. "This kind of thing is small when compared with the kind of abuse they have, say, in Dáil Éireann. Most people have come to regard Deputies in Dáil Éireann as drones in our particular hive and a very expensive luxury boxed within the four walls of that Assembly."
Comment on this
I was merely giving Deputy Lemass's opinion of Deputy Killilea, and I hope that Deputy Killilea has read that with as much interest as I did. I do think, quite seriously, that the conduct of proceedings in this House, and the esteem or otherwise in which Deputies are held by the ordinary people, may have a very great effect on our external relations as a method of measuring up what people think of another country: whether they are worth dealing with and whether they are serious, or otherwise, in propositions they put forward in the Parliament of the country in question. I think it is quite safe to say that what we think of ourselves here, what we think of our own conduct in this House, may have a very great bearing on what others think of us. There is no doubt that one of the responsibilities the Minister for External Affairs is charged with is to see that others think of us in the light in which we want to have ourselves shown. It is rather disgusting when you have the Leader of the Opposition and the deputy-leader of the Opposition paying a legal mouthpiece to say that kind of nonsense about Deputies in this House.
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Deputy to say that the Leader of the Opposition and the deputy-leader paid counsel to make statements in court when it is not a fact at all?
Comment on this
I should like to make it clear that any statements made by counsel on behalf of the Irish Press do not necessarily represent my views. If it is going to be argued that they do, then I suppose we can quote the statement made by counsel appearing on behalf of the present Minister for Finance in a recent case relating to Article X of the Treaty.
Comment on this
In the views he was expressing he was speaking on his own behalf and on behalf of nobody else.
Comment on this
I think the Minister deserves to be congratulated for the energy and drive which he has put into the Department of External Affairs since his election and appointment to that office. No matter how bitterly opposed politically individuals may be to the Minister, to this Government or to the Party which the Minister represents, I think it will be agreed that he has put the necessary drive and force into his Department to ensure that the views of this country and the grievances of this nation are heard outside the confines of this island. I think that the Minister is worthy of the congratulation and commendation of the House for the work he has been doing. I am sorry that Deputy Lemass did not feel himself able to say that from the Opposition Benches, because I have heard expressions of opinion, similar to those which I have expressed, by very many supporters of Fianna Fáil. They have not all put it in the same way. Some of them were very surprised that the Minister had made such a good job of his Department; a number of them said they never thought he could do it; but there is no doubt, at any rate, that he has done it and I believe we should be generous enough to say that to him and, in particular, that Deputies opposite should be generous enough to say it.
The work which the Minister has done has been difficult work. It was work that was complicated for various reasons. Some of the circumstances were such that he could not control, and that the Minister before him could not control, but, taken by and large, the work of the Department of External Affairs last year was difficult and it was well done. I think it is true to say that never since the early days of this State has such intensive work been done in this Department as was done by the Minister last year.
I think, in respect of the Department—I wanted to say this earlier, but I was interrupted—it is work which should not be hampered by Party political considerations. It is work that requires the assistance of all Parties in the House and all Parties outside the House. It would be very dangerous if Deputies opposite were to continue to travel on the lines which Deputy Boland wanted to lay down for them in Bantry and Deputy Vivion de Valera wanted to lay down for them in Dublin. I think the whole explanation of that outrageous utterance by Deputy Boland was the particular political circumstance in which it was made and I believe the Deputy probably now regrets——
Comment on this
However whether I am being too charitable to the Deputy or not, I appeal to him that if he feels the urge to make this type of speech again he will control himself and that he will first ask the advice of someone who is able to keep him in his place.
Comment on this
I think when the Deputy who has just spoken spends a little more time in the House and gets more accustomed to political warfare, he will not feel so disposed to take upon himself the task of acting as political mentor to Deputies who have served a very much longer apprenticeship than he has done at this particular type of strife.
We are providing in the Estimate a sum for the Irish news agency which the Minister spoke of yesterday. In my view, the Minister made no case to the House to justify this expenditure. No explanation was given as to whether consultations had been held with representatives of the Press, or whether the object which the Minister has in mind could be accomplished by a body which would not be subject to State or Departmental control. I do not think an effective answer was made to the suggestions put forward from this side of the House that, with agencies like the Government Information Bureau and the Irish missions abroad at the Department's disposal, as well as the Press generally in the ordinary way in which the Press is utilised by the existing agencies, the paraphernalia of this costly new organisation seems to be entirely unjustified.
In the long run what we have to offer the world as a small nation is more in the spiritual and cultural sphere. We cannot hope to compete with large industrial nations in the matter of news or in the struggle to secure publicity for ourselves any more than we can in the normal industrial or economic sphere. I think that if money is to be spent in trying to secure for our nation a certain position in the world, it might be spent—more usefully spent—in some such directions as the Minister himself had indicated in connection with his committee for cultural affairs. Although we may not all agree with the particular line upon which money is being spent even in that connection, nevertheless I think it is by paying attention to such matters as our spiritual heritage and the particular gospel and tradition for which we stand in the world and the circulation of that outside wherever we have influence, that we shall achieve the best results. In the long run these are, perhaps, more potent in dealing with fellow-human beings than is this mass publicity or this attempt to enter into competition with highly technical organisations already carrying out work of a very complex character.
I think it is quite evident to anybody who gives the least attention to this matter that on readers, even in those countries which do not claim the same standard of education as we claim to have reached in Western Europe or to have the same standards and values that we have, news of this particular character will not have much effect, I think news that is anonymous in its character and is issued from a Government agency, however it may be described, cannot have the same effect or the same influence and cannot achieve its purpose in the same way as does the signed article containing the opinion of the responsible journalist giving his views for what they may be worth. We may agree with him or we may disagree with him. It is quite clear that in the United States of America, for example, it is the publicity of the expert journalist and the man of affairs which is so important in the moulding of public opinion. These expert journalists are almost as well informed in the diplomatic world as are the representatives of the different States. I was reading recently that, while the British Foreign Office in the early years of the present century was unaware of the policy that Germany was pursuing in foreign affairs, it was the representative of the English Times who conveyed to the British Government what exactly Germany's aims were and what she was seeking to achieve. It has been through responsible newspaper men from the time of de Blowitz down to our own time that quite valuable work has been accomplished in the international sphere.
If the Minister were making some arrangements to employ journalists or experts in public affairs for campaigns of publicity, lecture work or propaganda dealing with different aspects of our policy in order to make it more widely known and appreciated elsewhere, I think it would be preferable to this system of adding yet another organisation to the numerous organisations we already have and about which the Minister himself was so vocal only a short time ago. Personally, I am strongly opposed to the idea of a Government company having to do with what may be described as the "control and dissemination of news". I think the Opposition are bound to try to safeguard the position in order to ensure that Government interference in matters connected with the dissemination and propagation of news will be kept to a minimum. Unless there is definite agreement on both sides of the House that such a step is necessary, I think the correct attitude for the Minister would be to withdraw the present proposals until he has examined them further and has secured more general support than he would seem to have at present. The whole problem bristles with difficulties. The Minister, for example, says that this news agency will not be the mouthpiece of the Government. What will it be? The Minister must take responsibility.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy. I know that the Supplementary Estimate includes a Vote for the news agency. But there is a Bill going through the House at the present time dealing with the news agency. It has not yet passed through the House. Without wishing to unduly curtail references to the news agency, might I suggest that possibly a detailed discussion on the news agency would be better reserved for the Bill itself? Otherwise, we shall have two debates.
Comment on this
I see the Minister's point. It is quite reasonable but there is money in the Estimate for the news agency.
Comment on this
I take it to be the duty of the Opposition to safeguard the rights of the people in relation to the free circulation of news without any purported Government tutelage or supervision of any kind. But we are also interested in the question of expenditure. I think we could, if we wished, make a case for a second debate. I am merely making a few preliminary comments now since I did not wish to hold the Minister up yesterday on the Second Reading of the Bill.
I was about to deal with the point that the Minister will either be responsible for the statements issued by this agency or he will not be responsible. If he is not responsible and if he wishes to divest himself of all semblance of responsibility, then the agency will be entirely independent. It should not, therefore, be set up directly by the Government. It should not be controlled by the Government. Assuming that some such organisation is necessary, there may be some liaison between it and the Government.
Reference has been made to the amount of the expenditure upon this Vote. Like other speakers on this side of the House, I appreciate that this small nation is very much dependent upon showing to the world that we have something to offer of a special character in the spiritual sphere. In so far as our political connections with other countries are concerned through the Department of External Affairs, my knowledge of the Department is that excellent work has been done there. The officials are a highly expert body and a hard-working body. I think we should bear in mind, however, as Deputy de Valera pointed out, that expenditure on this service could go on until it reached an extent where we might be compelled to ask ourselves: "Is there any limit"? Obviously in the new situation in which we find ourselves now, there is no reason why we could not start missions in a great many new countries, with consequent additions to staffs. It is quite clear that the operation of the European co-operation plan has cast an immense burden upon the Department of External Affairs and I think everybody must be grateful to that Department for the splendid work that has been done. As the Minister has said, we have got a picture which we might not otherwise have got. We have got some information as to how we stand in regard to our economic connection with other countries and as to how other countries impinge on us and what the reactions of international changes are likely to be here.
I would like to emphasise again that in 1945/46 this Vote only passed the £100,000 figure.
In 1947-49 it increased to £154,000; in 1948-49 to £188,000 and this year, between the Supplementary Estimate and the additions in the ordinary Estimate which have been presented to us, there is an increase of over £74,000 over last year, or £261,000 in all. It is no doubt legitimate for the Minister to argue that we are getting value for this money, that it is necessary and he has given us examples from China to Peru of where the Department is called in to exercise certain functions and to look after the interests of our people abroad.
In his statement he referred to the necessity for making political headway abroad and told us flatly that no apology was necessary for the additional expenditure. I should have thought that even with the short experience the Minister has, he would realise that, since this is likely to be a very big spending Department, reasons must be given and some account must be given of the value of the work that has been achieved and the results that have been secured. If that could have been done in the form of an annual report, all the better. But I do not think it is sufficient that the Minister should tell us that he has no apology to offer. I think the Dáil, which has control of expenditure, is entitled to have reasons given for the additions. What has to be borne in mind in this connection is that——
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy a qestion. I thought I had made a fuller statement of the work of the Department than had ever been made before to the House, but if there is any additional information the Deputy wants I am only too willing to supply it now or later. I thought I had made a statement which covered every sphere of the activity of the Department. I quite agree with the Deputy it might be a good plan to provide for an annual report to be made to the House but, unfortunately, that practice has not been pursued hitherto and I do not know whether we will be entitled to do it. I think it would be a useful thing to make an annual report from the Department to the House. I certainly thought that in the Estimate I covered, more fully than ever before, every sphere of activity of the Department.
Comment on this
The Minister did give us an ample statement and furnished the House with a good deal of information, information which I, like other Deputies, was very glad to have; but the assurance to which Deputy de Valera referred in his address, the assurance of the Minister's own satisfaction that the particular projects which he has in mind are worth the cost and an indication from him as to the result which he expects to achieve or has secured would, I think, have been a valuable addition. However, as far as the statement went, it was quite all right. It did not, in my opinion, deal sufficiently with matters of general interest such as that to which, by the way, Deputy Lemass referred.
The Minister is representing us at international conferences and an international conference is now to be called —apparently he has had something to do with the suggestion that there should be such a conference—and the House has no information, so far —perhaps on the Vote for European Economic Co-operation it will get that information—as to what is the line of policy which the Minister proposes to put forward then. If it is merely that he is acting as the honest broker in trying to bring conflicting opinions and interests together and to evolve a settlement between them, that is one thing. If, on the other hand, there is any question of our seeming to take sides publicly in issues that are of the greatest and most serious importance to our neighbours, that must be a matter, I think, for serious consideration by the House. I do not want to delay the House on this matter at the moment but it may be no harm to support Deputy Lemass's remarks to the extent of quoting an extract from the Irish Independent, page 5, of June 30th:—
"STERLING POSITION NOT DISCUSSED.
(Irish Independent Special Correspondent.)
According to a Reuter message from Paris, Mr. Seán MacBride, in an interview, said: ‘The fact that America is facing a depression calls for a very prudent policy on our part. We must not be killing the goose that lays the golden egg.'"
I do not quite follow that. I must say.
"Of the problems facing the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation on the eve of its second year, he declared: ‘The difficulties arising over the intra-European payments scheme for the coming 12 months are highly symbolic of a much larger problem. The real problem is to find outlets for Europe's increased production. Another vital problem is to co-ordinate European and American trade.
The difficulties with which we are faced to-day should have been foreseen a year ago, not kept to the last minute.'"
Whose difficulties? According to the Irish Independent of July 4th:
"USE FOR AMERICAN SURPLUS.
Mr. MacBride attacked what he termed the ‘outworn and unrealist policy' adopted by some of the member countries towards the Marshall Plan, in the course of an interview which he gave to the Paris Le Monde.
In particular, he instanced the British policy that consisted in recommending before the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation the limiting of certain purchases from the United States and the expansion of exports towards the dollar zones. ‘America,' he said, ‘has a surplus of merchandise on hand that rises daily. This is a great fact we must face up to if we wish to avoid the depression that threatens us. We must make use of this surplus or else perish by it.'"
That may be one side of the question, whereas Deputy Lemass pointed out there is another very important and very grave side of the question also and that is the position of sterling. It is quite true that the British Government has accepted, as on a previous occasion, the general principle of multi-lateral trade but they have not stated that the principles which they adhere to can be put into operation. There is always the question between what is undesirable, what is desirable and what is practical in existing circumstances. Whether we agree with the British Chancellor or not I think we must all admire the gallant effort and the splendid fight he is making to save the position. Apart from our personal feelings, as Deputy Lemass said, we have a keen interest in this matter. The Minister's past references to the question of currency and the link with sterling are not sufficiently reassuring that even now he is going to approach these questions in a realistic and responsible manner. Having in mind that it is the interests of the community he represents in this country, that should be the first claim upon him rather than the adherence to some general principles which, however excellent they might be, may only be theoretic. Whether we like it or not, out interests are bound to a very great extent economically with those of our neighbour. That is a position that has arisen for historical reasons. I think we must be very careful not to give rise to any suspicion—I hope it is not the position and I am sure it is only necessary to mention it to have the Minister disclaim the idea—that we have any feelings or any antagonisms in this matter apart from the interests of our own people.
The Minister referred to certain trade agreements which we made during this year. He referred to the fact that there was an expansion in industrial and agricultural exports. I think he stated that the value of our exports had gone up to certain countries, which he enumerated, to the extent of £1,000,000, which was good news. On the other hand, when he says that the expansion is on a mutually satisfactory basis, I think it is necessary to look at the other side of the balance sheet. In this troubled era, when the balance of payments is of such tremendous importance, when, if countries do not pay special attention to this aspect of their affairs they might find themselves in Queer Street, we have to try to approach parity as far as possible in our trade relations. Allowing for the fact that we are at the present time securing imports from the United States on very favourable terms, it is not very satisfactory to find that as against £7,000,000 worth of goods which we imported from that country during the first five months of the present year, we exported only £112,000 worth. According to that, for every £1 worth of goods we export to the United States we buy from them £62 10s. Od. worth. In the case of Canada, I calculate that for every £1 worth we sell her, we buy £67 worth. In the case of Sweden, the position is not quite so lopsided, but nevertheless the position is that for every £1 worth we are selling to the Swedes we are buying £14 worth from them.
In the case of Belgium and the Netherlands the position is somewhat more satisfactory. I think that that is possibly due to a considerable extent to the fact that we happen to be one of the few food-producing countries and that at the present time and for some years to come, there will be an intense demand for food and for such things as cattle. I have no doubt that the exports of cattle and foodstuffs, which have gone from this country to Belgium and the Netherlands are largely responsible for the more satisfactory state of the figures in regard to these countries than to the other countries to which I have referred but in the case of Belgium we seem to be buying a great deal more from her than we are selling to her. In the case of the Netherlands, in spite of the considerable expansion in exports to which the Minister has referred, I make out the figures to show a very heavy balance in favour of the Netherlands. In the case of France, the balance is very much more favourable to the French. We imported £733,000 worth of goods and we sold only £85,000 to her.
When we consider that our adverse balance of trade runs into over £70,000,000, it is obviously a matter of the most pressing importance that we should try to bridge the gap in the case of these countries and other countries with which we have trade dealings. In the case of the British, although our purchases from them were over £6,000,000 worth, we sold them only £3.8 million worth, so that the pattern in respect of our trade with our nearest neighbour is that we are paying to the extent of two-thirds only of what we buy from her whereas we are very much below that ratio with the other countries I mentioned.
Last year, as has been stated, the Minister informed the House that he had to report an improvement in the mutual feelings between Great Britain and this country. If I say that I wonder whether we are getting value for the money that is being spent under the heading of External Affairs, it is not that I have to find fault with the many admirable activities of the Department, the good work of the officials or even the efforts of the Minister himself in a great many respects. It is in regard, not to issues ranging from China to Peru but issues bearing on the relationship between our immediate neighbours and ourselves, that I think external policy must be very largely judged and the value of the Minister's work during the year assessed. He told us last year that the feeling of traditional ill-will towards Britain and the British people, which certain persons believed to be a dominant factor in the relationship between the two countries, did not exist, that it was even the reverse of the truth. He went on to tell us that there was a great fund of potential good-will towards Britain.
Comment on this
Let us see. "We want to be friendly," he said, "with our big neighbour.""Furthermore," he went on to say, "I believe that the British Government and people are approaching a realisation that a statesmanlike policy lies in the direction of securing the complete friendship and co-operation of this island, a realisation that a ‘united and free Ireland is as essential to Britain's welfare as it is to Irelands.'" These were the sentiments expressed by the Minister last year. There is a noticeable absence from the Minister's statement on this Vote of any reference worth speaking of to the potential fund of good-will or the statesmanlike policy which the Minister believes the British Government and people were approaching last year. I think that it is the duty of all of us not to do anything in connection with the issues arising between this country and Great Britain or this part of the country and the portion that is cut off temporarily from the rest of it, which would add fresh enmities to the situation. I think that it is our duty not to say or do anything that we can avoid which would make the situation worse. But I am afraid that the Minister has not been quite so meticulous in this matter in the past and I am afraid I cannot avoid referring to certain statements he made when he announced his policy to the Irish people in what might be described as a political testament in the form of a letter to the Irish Times. On that occasion he informed us that the British people were logicians.
Comment on this
The whole letter is very long. I am proposing to read the portions that in my opinion throw light on the Minister's attitude to this problem of Partition and our relations with Great Britain immediately before he became Minister:—
"The present hybrid form of ‘dictionary republic' commends itself to no one. To our brothers and sisters in the North it appears but as a subterfuge; to the British people, who are logicians, it is an aggravating anomaly; it in no way satisfies the traditional aspiration of the republican section of our own people. It has the further drawback of preventing our Government from entering into close co-operation with Britain, lest they be accused of reinforcing the existing connection with Britain."
Comment on this
So what? Well, I often heard of cases, even in the famous Reno, Nevada, where people rushed so quickly to get a divorce and then to reunite themselves in even closer bonds within a short time afterwards, as the Minister apparently prognosticates in this letter he will do with the country with whom a short while ago they had severed the last link.
Comment on this
It seems to me that you severed the last link with a mighty fanfare of trumpets and booming of guns only to come into closer relationship and, in fact, if necessary, to enter into treaty commitments and into a regular alliance with those with whom you considered it necessary to break the slender legal relationship which already existed between themselves and you.
Comment on this
I think you should tell the Dáil whether you approve of the repeal of the External Relations Act or not.
Comment on this
I am not being cross-examined at the moment by the Minister. The Minister at the present moment is standing his trial.
Comment on this
I am taking this opportunity to remind the Dáil and the country of some of the things that have not been brought as much under their notice as I think they should have been.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, at this time the Minister was the white-headed boy of the Irish Times and if anything made me feel sad it was the fact that the Irish Times was so badly let down because, when they had got the Minister to announce that in respect of the breaking of the link with sterling, he really did not mean it, they assumed that in regard to the other question of the repeal of the External Relations Act it was quite safe.
Comment on this
Surely, in fairness to me, the Deputy will quote what I did say to the Irish Times about sterling, now.
Comment on this
I am replying to an interruption. If I had not to reply to an interruption I could have pursued my speech.
Comment on this
"It has the further drawback"
—that was the External Relations Act—
"of preventing our Government from entering into close co-operation with Britain, lest they be accused of reinforcing the existing connection with Britain."
Therefore one of the primary, perhaps, if not the primary purpose, of the repeal of that Act was to enable the Minister and the Government—the Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs in particular—to bring about closer relations with Britain.
"The world has moved rapidly in the last quarter of a century—and with it the British people. In this post-war world the cutting of the slender link now existing between the British Crown and ourselves would create no difficulty, I think, with Britain. On the contrary, the British people would understand and respect us more for doing so than for maintaining the present anomalous position. Having once cut the painter, we could then get down in earnest to the job of arranging the maximum co-operation possible on all matters of mutual interest. Because of the present position any close co-operation is always looked upon with suspicion. Having got this ‘out of our system,' we could then freely enter by treaty into much closer and more genuine co-operation on matters of mutual interest."
We severed the slender link in order that we can enter into closer and more genuine co-operation on matters of mutual interest.
"Cultural and economic bonds, coupled with mutual interests, would inevitably drive a free, united Ireland into a close alliance with Britain."
In these prognostications of the Minister, that we could enter freely into treaty arrangements with Britain once the External Relations Act was repealed and even go to the extent of having a close alliance with that country, there is no reference to the question of Partition, as the House will notice, as qualifying in any way the sentiments the Minister expressed about his desire to have freer treaty arrangements and close alliance with our neighbours. Why did the Minister omit the question of Partition when he looked forward to the position that once the External Relations Act was repealed the way then lay open, the road lay straight before him, to enter into proper and free treaty relationships and, if necessary, into this close alliance?
There is no reference to the question of a treaty with regard to Partition or with regard to a close alliance in the making of which our attitude and our demand in regard to the Six Counties should first be met. On the contrary, the Minister's attitude in regard to Partition at that time was very revealing indeed. I do not know whether he has forgotten it. Events seem to have moved very quickly indeed in regard to the Minister's point of view—
"We look upon Partition as being now largely an economic problem."
That was the attitude of the Minister speaking as leader of his Party:
"One of the realities we have to face is that, unless and until we establish economic conditions and social services here that will be at least as attractive as those that prevail in the Six Counties, we cannot hope to arouse real enthusiasm for the ending of Partition even among the nationalist population of the Six Counties. We have no intention of utilising Partition as a catch-cry. We must face up to hard facts."
Comment on this
From a letter to the Editor of the Irish Times published on January 27th, 1948. It is a letter from the Minister as Leader of Clann na Poblachta, and was written by him on 24th January, 1948. We have not seen the White Paper yet. I do not know whether the Minister is one of those who are endeavouring to see that, when the comprehensive social security plan is produced, it will at least be equal to that in operation in the Six Counties and in Great Britain, if not overtopping it, because money, as we know, has never been the slightest obstacle in the programmes of some of the Parties which now form the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
The Minister disclaims any intention of using Partition as a catch-cry or the idea of using the circumstances which the Partition question has given rise to since he took up his present office for political stunting. Perhaps he will explain what exactly is the position in regard to the following prognostication:—
"Apart from our proposals in relation to nominating representatives from the Six Counties to the Seanad and of giving right of audience in the Dáil to the Six County M.Ps., we believe that considerable progress can be made by developing a close cultural and economic relationship between the Six Counties and the rest of the country. This aspect so far has been completely neglected."
Ireland, apparently, did not appear on the map of the world until the Minister in 1949 proceeded to put it there; neither had there been cultural connections with the Six Counties. The Minister forgets that important Gaelic, social and religious organisations, as well as sporting organisations, have maintained relationship between the people down here and the people in the Six Counties. This perspicacity of the Minister in announcing his policy that he would utilise the opportunity, should it be given to him, to develop a close cultural and economic relationship between the Six Counties and the rest of the country is coupled with a rather inconsistent statement, in my view, if the Minister was sincere in that desire.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy has been quoting for some 20 minutes from a certain letter written by the Minister before the change of Government. Is it in order to read such quotations in dealing with a matter of this kind? We are supposed to be discussing the Estimate of the Department of External Affairs.
Comment on this
The Chair is of opinion that there should be a curtailment of many things in this Chamber, but unfortunately he cannot enforce it.
Comment on this
"As to our brothers and sisters in the Six Counties, their attachment to the Crown is more apparent, I think, than real. It is but the outward expression of the prejudice of some, coupled with the very real fear by others that we would not respect their civil liberties."
If the Northern nationalists, some of whom may have espoused the Minister's policy, some of whom may have followed him, had been expecting that that policy and those pronouncements which I have referred to were likely to lead them into the promised land, they must feel greatly disappointed. It would be an extraordinary thing if they did not feel more than disappointed, if they did not feel humiliated. If they banked their hopes on the Minister for External Affairs and on the possibility that this Party, which proclaimed that it had a solution for Partition and could bring about a united Ireland, presumably in a very short time once Deputy de Valera's Administration was got out of the way, they must find that these visions that the Minister held out before them were as illusory as the mirages that meet the traveller in the desert. As has been well said, the hopes that were cherished, if they were cherished, may well have proved, unfortunately for those who held them, as hollow as the booming of the guns that ushered in the inauguration of the Irish Republic last Easter Monday.
Perhaps, however, when the replies have come in from the 50 States, with which we are on terms of friendship or in diplomatic connection, to whom the Ceann Comhairle forwarded copies of the resolution of protest passed by this House on May 10th in connection with the Ireland Bill passed by the British Parliament, the Minister will send them at an early date, through the news agency, the copies of the official replies, which will I have no doubt be received from some or all of these States, and those perhaps will provide these unfortunate people who believe in the Minister and his promises with some small shred of consolation that, whatever else may happen, the present holder of the office of Minister for External Affairs is seeing to it that, however the people of the Six Counties may be situated, national publicity and, incidentally, publicity for his administration of his Department, will certainly not be neglected, whether they are or not. That is the position that has been reached by these wonderful warriors who came along with their two-handed swords to break this slender link which the Taoiseach told us was of no importance: that it did not make the slightest difference whether it was there or not.
Comment on this
Do you believe that it should not be broken?
Comment on this
As a result of their handling of that situation and of their blundering they have now landed us in a position in which even those who never believed they were competent to deal with such a situation could scarcely conceive that their incompetence would reach to. It is only geniuses in political incapacity that could have reached the stage that the Minister and his colleagues have brought us to in regard to this most serious national issue which still confronts us.
The Taoiseach, speaking in O'Connell Street on the inauguration of the Twenty-Six Counties Irish Republic, said: "We believe that what has been done to-day will ensure more cordial and closer co-operation between Ireland and Great Britain and the other members of the Commonwealth of Nations that would ever have existed under any conditions before." What are we to think of the Leader of the Government who would voice these sentiments in public to the citizens of the capital of the country, and who, a few weeks afterwards, told us that the whole resources and influence of our people in North America must be marshalled, and that their energies must be marshalled? Why must they be marshalled? "So that the British may be hit in their pride, their prestige and their pocket."
The Minister talks of the necessity of moving with the times in regard to diplomacy. He tells us that a Press agency is now necessary. Apparently, the old methods of diplomatic intercourse are not sufficient. We have to move with the times. It is not sufficient that we should move with the times in regard to the setting up of a large new organisation to disseminate information to the Press of the United States and every other country, but it is also necessary that, in the field of diplomatic relationship, with our nearest neighbour, we should eschew completely the ordinary procedure of the council chamber, and try to secure our ends by means of loudspeakers in O'Connell Street; we should try to secure our objectives, not by give and take, or by friendly intercourse, or by drawing on that fund of goodwill that the Minister spoke of last year in our relationship with Great Britain, but that we should accept the position apparently that ranting of this type from public platforms, on an important and serious occasion, is to be taken as a genuine contribution to national progress, that it is a sign of national leadership, and is likely to get us somewhere, that it is likely to get us further on the road than the older methods would have done.
The Minister, last year, asked that we should recognise the necessity for continuity in foreign policy and he emphasised that, if possible, we should approach this problem with a certain unity of feeling, and with support for whoever was, for the time being charged with the conduct of our foreign affairs. He said that we ought to have unanimity if possible. I thoroughly agree with him, but how are we to have unanimity, or even substantial unity; how are we going to have any measure of progress in this very serious matter if we are going to be treated to the kind of thing that the Taoiseach treated the Irish people to in O'Connell Street; if we are going to be treated to a slipping back and a reneging of election promises and election pronouncements such as the Minister and his colleagues have been guilty of?
The Minister complains of the epithet—"stunts"—which has been applied to some of his activities. Probably like the kangaroo we have to proceed by fits and starts and not according to any reasonable plan, not in regard to conception that is worked out in advance, but by some personal feeling, some personal urge of vanity, disappointment or something of that kind. If we are going to proceed on that line in regard to very important issues, such as the reunification of this country, we will find ourselves in the position of the character immortalised by Jimmy O'Dea who, when he took one step forward on the way to school, found that he had taken two steps backward and never succeeded in arriving there.
Is it any wonder that the people do not know where they stand in regard to the conduct of our external affairs so far as it applies to our relationship with the neighbouring country? Does the Minister deny that if there is to be a semblance of unity in this matter of our external relations and if he is to have any justification for asking for the support and co-operation of the Opposition in this House in his efforts, that he must give us some guarantee that he is sincere in his approach and that his conduct of our affairs is worthy of securing our confidence?
It is not merely the Minister's past that is in question in this matter. There is the past record and declarations of those prominently associated with him in the Government. When one looks back over the history of the past 18 months——
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I ask the Chair whether it is in order to discuss on this Estimate the past utterances and actions of every member of this House?
Comment on this
It is not. Ministers are responsible to this House only from the time they take up office as Ministers. Apart from that, this is an Estimate for the Department of External Affairs.
Comment on this
The Minister, perhaps, would not like me to remind the House that, in the general election campaign, the leader of another Party, now a Minister in the Government, told us that there were more pressing issues than the republic, the same gentleman who told the Irish people, as leader of his Party, that he stood unequivocally for membership of the British Commonwealth.
Comment on this
Surely the Government at least give lip service to the principle of collective responsibility. Am I not entitled to ask them upon which leg they are standing, or upon which horse they are riding at the present time, or if they have completely given up the imperial steed, and what particular mount have they at the present time? Another Minister told us that if we were to attempt to declare an isolated republic we would, within five years of having done so, find ourselves under the heel of a foreign tyrant—slaves of foreign domination. His attitude on that occasion was that he wanted to see this country working its way in the Commonwealth with the help of the United States of America.
Comment on this
The Chair has already ruled that it is not proper to discuss the merits of legislation. The Deputy is now discussing the merits of legislation—the Republic of Ireland Act, which came into operation on Easter Monday of this year.
Comment on this
I am not discussing the merits of the Republic of Ireland Act. I am trying to point out to the Dáil inconsistencies in the attitude of Ministers of a Government which is supposed to bear a collective responsibility in regard to this matter, and I want the Minister, if he is able, or his colleagues, if they will be good enough to assist him, to explain the attitude in regard to these issues upon which they pronounced as I have indicated. I propose now to pass away from that.
Comment on this
The Deputy and other Deputies must acknowledge all the legislation passed by the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
Am I not entitled to discuss the attitude of Ministers as indicated by their statements?
Comment on this
The Deputy apparently wants to discuss the attitude of certain members of the House to certain legislation before that legislation got through the House. It is now the law of the land and a Deputy's attitude towards it has nothing to do with this Estimate.
Comment on this
Is it not a moot point whether these Ministers are men of principle and conviction——
Comment on this
——and whether they are worthy of the confidence of the people after having told them one thing and acted in another way?
Comment on this
It is not a question of whether members of the Government are men of principle, but what relates to the administration of the Minister for External Affairs.
Comment on this
The administration of the Department of External Affairs, or any other Department, must be based upon certain principles. Those principles must be laid down in Government policy. I am trying to find out what exactly is Government policy in regard to this important issue of our relations with Great Britain.