We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 65—External Affairs (Resumed).

Contributions 183–357 of 547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

What about Donegal?

Comment on this

We will keep on asking, all the same. I maintain that issues of fundamental importance to the Irish people should be treated sincerely, should be approached with a sense of responsibility, and if they are not so approached the judgment which is likely to be given in regard to them is not alone going to be defective, but may be disastrous to the hopes of those who cherish the ideal of the reunification of our country. I think it has been trifling with the convictions of citizens that Ministers departed from the pledges they have given. It is necessary in a democracy, above all things, that the people should have confidence in their public representatives. There is only one way in which they can estimate whether or not their representatives are worthy of their confidence, and that is the understandings that are given between the elected representatives and the people who elect them when they seek the suffrages of the people and when they are returned to office. If people feel that the pledged word and public pronouncements of public men are not to be relied on, the serious aspect of the situation is not merely that the credence of these public men is shaken, but that the confidence of the public in the system of Parliament and democratic Government is severely shaken.

In the long run, we have to approach the questions that come up for discussion in our Legislature from the point of view of common honesty and trustfulness, and if there is not honesty and trust, and if the people cannot have that trust in those who for the time being have taken up the responsibilities of office, then all I can say is that it is a very bad advertisement for the democracy which the Government prates so much about. If it could have been shown that the Government approached this issue on legitimate grounds of national well-being and the welfare of the community, and explained their attitude to the public, or their change of attitude, that might have been understandable, but everybody knows, as the favourite organ of the Minister, or that one which described him as a white-headed boy, that it was simply a question——

Comment on this

I have already risen to a point of order. The Deputy is still discussing the merits or demerits of legislation introduced here. I understood the Chair to rule him out of order and he is now continuing his disobedience of the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy was not, in my opinion, discussing the merits of the Act, but the attitude of certain people towards it which, I maintain, has nothing to do with it, because he is discussing what is now the law of the land.

Comment on this

In the history of the English Parliament it happened on a certain famous occasion that the Whigs were out bathing and it was said that the Tories stole their clothes. The Irish Times very aptly referred to this incident in dealing with the Government's treatment of international affairs. They simply put it as an attempt to queer the pitch of a political opponent by stealing his political clothes in order to secure an advantage. I think it will be found that the shortcut in this matter is very often, and in this case will prove to be, the longest home. The Minister has now told us, with reference to the mobilisation of opinion in the United States of America in connection with his visit over there, that he urged that this question of Partition should be discussed between Ireland and the nations participating in the Atlantic Pact. The Government, I presume, felt that if the concept of co-operation and democracy was to be given reality, one of the first essentials was to remove from the midst of Western Europe this dangerous anomaly—dangerous and damaging the Minister described it—to the unity of the democratic world. Then he goes on to tell us that the United States of America has officially proclaimed its attitude which, in the Minister's view, is nothing less than one of indifference, such indifference that it has even been suggested that the United States have, under the Atlantic Pact, undertaken to defend Britain's occupation of Northern Ireland.

We have reached the happy position with reference to dealing with the Partition issue, about which such rosy hopes were raised by the Minister for External Affairs and others, that not alone have we succeeded in securing the united vote of the two Parties in the British Parliament—the Government and the Opposition—in regard to the particular attitude they have taken up on the Ireland Bill, but we have in the United States of America reached the position that the United States is described by the Minister for External Affairs as displaying indifference to this whole question and even, in his view, leaving itself open to the suggestion that, under the Atlantic Pact, they are prepared to undertake to defend Britain's occupation of Northern Ireland. Comments on the results that have been achieved during the past 12 months in Britain and in the United States of America——

Comment on this

Are you blaming the Government for that?

Comment on this

——so far as the Governments of these two countries and public opinion, as expressed by the administration, are concerned, would simply be gilding the lily if I were to attempt to dilate further upon them. It was a famous French commentator who said that lawyers did not make good statesmen. He observed during the course of a long career that they very rarely made good statesmen.

Comment on this

What does he say about teachers?

Comment on this

I think during all our acquaintance with statesmen, there is scarcely any less worthy of the name than the lawyers who compose the present Coalition Government.

Comment on this

Are we now going to have the professions of Deputies discussed?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not individually.

Comment on this

Either individually or collectively, I think that is a most undesirable remark.

Comment on this

The trouble with lawyers is——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is nothing disorderly in the remark. It is not unparliamentary.

Comment on this

The trouble with lawyers is that they think these international questions can be decided on the basis of the written law which they are called upon to interpret and explain, to defend or to attack in the courts of justice. They are not trained in the art of diplomacy. They are not able to look facts in the face. They are not able to face public opinion. They are not able to explain to the public the reasons for unpalatable decisions. They are not able to face a situation that real statesmen may have to face at a particular time.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might remember that he is dealing with one Minister now and not with the whole Cabinet.

Comment on this

I am dealing with one Minister who happens to be a lawyer and I think my remarks are not, therefore, irrelevant.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I was merely going on the assumption that the word "they" meant more than one.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, I shall have to change it then, though I am afraid that it is not the Minister who is entirely responsible, but his colleagues.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The responsibility for this Vote rests on the Minister.

Comment on this

Real statesmen would bear in mind the necessity for acquainting the public with the reason why it might be better to bide one's time, to wait to take advantage of opportunity rather than spoil existing opportunity by taking ill-advised action for the sake of political advantage and thereby perhaps ruining the prospect which might obtain of securing a favourable result by not dealing with the situation as the circumstances of the time demand.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be good enough to specify the action in question so that I may be able to deal with it in replying?

Comment on this

You are interrupting still. It is a habit for Ministers in this Government continually to interrupt.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy be good enough to specify the particular action he is criticising so that I may be able to deal with it when I come to reply?

Comment on this

I am referring in general terms to the mishandling and the gross mismanagement of our affairs so far as dealing with the Partition situation and our relationship with Great Britain are concerned.

Comment on this

Any particular action?

Comment on this

I am asserting my right, and I shall do so even if no other person in this House is of the same opinion. We have heard a great deal about democracy. Do you people who try to shout down those who are expressing their opinions believe in democracy? Why, you do not know what democracy is.

Comment on this

Surely, it would be making a charge of mishandling, to state the particular matters which he democratic for the Deputy if he is accuses me of mishandling?

Comment on this
Deputies

Chair, Chair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am glad to see the desire which is obtaining to obey the Chair. That is not on one side only. This running commentary on a speech must cease.

Comment on this

He will never finish if it does not.

Comment on this

If we take up the attitude that the Taoiseach has taken up in his public pronouncements in regard to our dealings with Great Britain of reducing ourselves to the level of showing our resentment in the way a rejected suitor, who had been turned down by an heiress, would show his resentment, I wonder what the dignity of the country will come to or how we shall handle our public affairs in future.

The Minister informed us during the course of his remarks that we were not faced with any danger in respect of Communism in this country. I hope that is so. I do not know whether the Minister is prepared to assure the House that there is no ground for anxiety in regard to that matter.

Comment on this

I do not think I adverted to that matter at all on this Estimate. I would not have considered it relevant.

Comment on this

I understood the Minister to say—I have not his exact words before me—that we were free from this.

Comment on this

I made no reference whatsoever to the question of Communism in Ireland.

Comment on this

I accept that. When the Minister is providing money for the Council of Europe and when he and his officials are attending there, together with representatives of this House, I would remind him that it is well for us to bear in mind the setting in which that Council of Europe is taking place. In Eastern Europe we have one mighty power with a population of 190,000,000 people. In the remainder of Eastern Europe, under the direct or indirect control of that mighty power, we have a further 90,000,000 people approximately. That is a total of 280,000,000. That is what western civilisation and Christianity in Europe—and Christianity in Europe means Christianity in the world—has to face. It is not so very long ago since the Archbishop of Cashel in an address at the Thurles Sugar Beet Factory stated that it was a well-known fact that there are Communists here in Ireland and that some of them hold prominent positions in the Labour movement.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy relate that to External Affairs?

Comment on this

I relate it to the statement of the Minister that we have no reason to fear. We have not the same reasons to fear the dangers of this disease of Communism spreading in our country as they have in other countries. I maintain that the whole situation should be altered, that there is only one way in which the spread of this menace can be averted and that is the way we would all like to avoid, if it can be avoided. Since this disease thrives on bad social conditions, on depressions, unemployment and all the other social maladies of the present system——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not external affairs, surely. It is internal.

Comment on this

We have a particular point of view in regard to Communism; we have a particular heritage to defend, more than other countries have. I entirely agree that, so far as it is possible in the opportunity of utilising the Council of Europe as a forum for putting forward, in the name of Ireland, the basic principles of Christianity to which it is necessary that the world, even Western Europe, should return if we are to be saved from the danger of the tide of Communism overwhelming the whole of us, undoubtedly we have a part to play there. However, I think we would be fooling ourselves if we did not make it clear in our own minds that, as well as having a forum in which to exercise our opinions by sending the best equipped and the best trained representative that we have at our disposal to see that the traditional principles of Western Christianity that we all believe in are accepted as basic and fundamental, this menace is very much nearer to us than it appears. It is very much nearer than the people of our country, isolated as they have been from European conditions, cut away from the Continent of Europe and having very little intercourse with it, can possibly appreciate. The danger that Europe was faced with a few years ago when some of the nations which were bulwarks of Christianity were almost overwhelmed by this tide, has not been removed and it cannot completely be removed for a very long time. It is only by earnest effort on the part of all of us who believe in these principles and by constant attention to the carrying out of the right principles in our ordinary affairs that a good example will be given and the proper philosophy will be adopted, which will mean the defeat and the destruction of the evil.

Comment on this

There are two matters that I would like to say, particularly with reference to the speech we have just heard. I do not think that for many years in this Parliament——

Comment on this

If I might just interrupt to mention this fact; that after Deputy Lemass had spoken I stood up with Deputy M.J. O'Higgins. Deputy M.J. O'Higgins was called. Now, Deputy T.F. O'Higgins, from the same Party, is called. I am sure that is a misunderstanding.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no misunderstanding. The Deputy is a one-man Party, as far as I know, and the main Parties are entitled to be called before him.

Comment on this

I take it then that I will wait until everybody else has finished?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy knows that is not true, because he has not had to wait until everybody was called on many occasions. He will admit that.

Comment on this

As I was saying, in my view, seldom in any Parliament has political expediency stooped as low as was demonstrated this evening by the speech we have just heard from Deputy Derrig. If he ever had political principles, he has apparently abandoned them in one despairing effort to attack the Minister and the present Government, irrespective of the cost or damage to this country or to the national aspirations. Partition was referred to at length and he has endeavoured to make Partition a peg to which he can attach all sorts of insinuations and allegations against the Minister here.

I should like to ask all Deputies this question. Do they follow the lines uttered and spoken to here by Deputy Derrig? Do they suggest that the deterioration of the relations between this country and England that has taken place in the last 12 months is in any way due to mishandling by the present Minister or by the present Government? If they do, let them specify in what way those relations have been mishandled. Let them have the common courage that is expected of any Party to put their views clearly before the Irish people and say that they think that these relations have been mishandled because of A, B and C. Why are they so careful to hide their particular charges behind a web of words and say nothing that can be clearly recognised? Why are they so willing to wound and yet afraid to strike by stating in what way these relations have deteriorated and what caused them to deteriorate? They know very well that they could not, with any prospect of a political future in this country, specify with any clarity the charges they have made. They want the people, particularly the minority that Deputy Childers spoke to last night, to think that our relations have become less friendly because of the repeal of the External Relations Act. They want to tie on to the repeal of the Act the unilateral action of the British Government some weeks after the declaration of our Republic. They want the people to believe that, but they do not want to say it because they know very well that if they say it, or if any Deputy of their Party is forced to say it, they would be asked here in this House and before the bar of the Irish people why they voted for that measure and why, before that measure was introduced, they promised to the Government full and unequivocal support in the measure. I am willing and every other Deputy in this House is willing to discuss things in a decent honourable manner.

I have the greatest respect for Deputy Derrig or any other member of the Fianna Fáil Party if they hold that view, but state it like courageous men here in this House. If they do not hold that view, let them at least have the decency to be silent. I can only refer Deputies opposite to the very honourable views expressed, before this measure was taken by the Oireachtas, by a front-bench member of the Opposition, Deputy Dr. Ryan, who spoke in the town of Enniscorthy on the 31st July, 1948. In relation to that particular measure he said:—

"If the Government should now desire to dispense with the King of England they can do so, because the Constitution makes that possible. If the Government take action now they will have our full support against any diehard opposition here or abroad."

Noble sentiments expressed by Deputy Dr. Ryan, sentiments which, I have no doubt, won acclamation and applause for him in his constituency. How changed the times are now, some 12 months later, when Deputy Derrig, Deputy Lemass and the rest of them, are like a pack of wolves in full cry uttering howls of joy because the English have passed an Act in their Parliament and they think they can gather some kudos from it.

Comment on this

That is ridiculous.

Comment on this

I am prepared to discuss these particular matters with any Deputy but I shall not hear any interjections from Fianna Fáil Deputies who have not the courage to state what they think. The Irish people, mind you, are watching the conduct of the Opposition with considerable interest. They have been watching the change that has taken place in many of their political views and in many of the principles for which they were supposed to stand, both before they became a Government and while they were a Government. It is a regrettable thing to note that in the ranks of Fianna Fáil there are the only representatives in this State of the friends of the Brooke clique in the North and the new Churchill clique in England.

Comment on this

That is very good for a Commonwealther.

Comment on this

I have said that the people can watch the change that has taken place. I have no intention to chase with Deputy Derrig through the speeches even of the last 18 months. It would be an interesting search but I have merely to mention the name of Deputy MacEntee to recall to Deputies the type of speeches I have in mind. I have merely to remind the House that at a critical stage in our relations with England in the last 12 months, at a critical stage in reference to the problem of Partition, when the Government in the North found or felt that they were isolated and perhaps would have to depend upon their own resources if they were to maintain their position there, they found that down here in the South Deputy MacEntee was one who exulted in the sentiments expressed by Sir Basil Brooke and Mr. Warnock. I would refer Deputies to a report of a speech by Deputy MacEntee in the Irish Times of the 19th November, 1948, at that particularly critical period, in which he said that the objective and the purpose behind the Government's measure to define our international relations was to placate the Communist elements in the Coalition. He followed that by lauding the references made by Mr. Warnock in relation to the proposal of the Government.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy quoting from a newspaper report?

Comment on this

I have referred Deputy Briscoe to the particular newspaper in which that speech was reported, the Irish Times of the 19th November, 1948, and if he wishes he can look it up.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is there not a practice in this House that if a Deputy is quoted his exact words should be quoted?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If a Deputy purports to quote he must do so accurately.

Comment on this

That is what I am questioning.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy did not say he was quoting.

Comment on this

He said he was quoting from a newspaper.

Comment on this

I have referred to the newspaper in which the report of that speech is contained. If the Deputy has any doubt as to the accuracy of my quotation, and if he is anxious to do some private research, he will find that my statement is correct. The fact remains that by reason of the speeches made by Deputy MacEntee and by other Fianna Fáil leaders at that particular time, it must have been gratifying to the Northern Government to know that they had still friends south of the Border. My complaint in reference to this particular matter, if Deputy Derrig's speech is to be taken as representing the view of the Opposition, is this: A Bill was introduced into this Parliament and was discussed here. It was welcomed by the Leader of the Opposition and was spoken to by some six members of the Front Bench of the Opposition. They joined with the Government in ensuring that that Bill was passed through this House and subsequently through the Seanad without a dissentient voice. They made the case—it was open to them to make it—that there was no necessity for the Bill but that, if it was going to clarify our international position, by all means that it should be passed. That was some time in December of last year and silent they remained as to any consequences that might ensue through that Act until, by unilateral action, the British Parliament passed the Ireland Act. Now we have them suggesting, but afraid to say it, that the repeal of the External Relations Act was a blunder, a mistake.

I challenge them, or any individual Deputy of the Party opposite, to go before the people of this country and to state in so many words that it is the view of the Opposition, the Fianna Fáil Party, that the repeal of the External Relations Act was a blunder. If they do that, I am willing to make the prophecy that when they next return to this House they will return with something less than half their number. I know I am safe in making that prophecy because I know well that even Deputy MacEntee—I do not know about Deputy Childers who has constituents of his own—or any Deputy of the Party opposite will not take up that challenge. They have not the courage to do it.

In opening the debate on the motion to refer back, we had a speech by the Leader of the Opposition last night. It was an unctuous speech. It was a speech made by a man who was anxious to put himself on a pinnacle, to be quite away from the difficulties of any situation but reserving full liberty to criticise. Deputy de Valera deprecated the fact that the relations between the two countries, England and Ireland, were not harmonious. He referred to other matters and he specifically dealt with the suggestion, apparently made, that while he occupied the post of the present Minister, sufficient attention had not been given to the problem of Partition. I do not think it is helpful either for Deputy de Valera or speakers from this side of the House to compare records of achievements in relation to Partition but apparently it is being done. I should have hoped that in relation to this matter the unity established by the Taoiseach in the last 12 months would have been acted upon and honoured by the Opposition, but apparently, again, that is not to be so.

I would like to say for the record of this Assembly that we are discussing the Estimate for the Department of External Affairs in July, 1949. The last Estimate for the same Department introduced by the Leader of the Opposition was introduced here in the month of June, 1947. I was interested in reading his speech in introducing that Estimate, which is reported in Volume 105, column 2289. He ends up his speech, two years ago, by these words:—

"I think I have covered at this stage most of the points on the Estimate calling for attention."

I read that speech from beginning to end. At no stage in that speech did he refer in any way to the problem of Partition. That was the last Estimate introduced by the Fianna Fáil Minister for External Affairs, introduced two years ago. The position was that at the end of Fianna Fáil's term of office Partition was not a subject that need be even mentioned by the Minister introducing his Estimate in Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

He had referred to it in 70 speeches before.

Comment on this

Of course, we all know, particularly Deputies like myself who were not in the House at that particular time and other Deputies who at that time were ordinary members of the public, that at the end of the period of office of the last Government Partition was something away back in the background——

Comment on this

Not a bit of it.

Comment on this

——one of the insoluble problems that had better not be mentioned when it could not be dealt with.

Comment on this

Not a bit of it.

Comment on this

If it was something that was in the forefront of the last Government's programme, something demanding all their attention, something to which their efforts were being turned, one would expect that it would at least be referred to by the Minister in charge of this Department introducing his Estimate to the House.

It is extraordinary that even in replying to the debate on that particular Estimate in the month of June, 1947, although Deputy McGilligan, as he then was, dealt with Partition at length, the Minister had nothing to say about that particular matter. I think that the ordinary people, that Fianna Fáil may think they are fooling, also recognised that the very moment Deputy de Valera ceased to be Minister for External Affairs, the very moment his Government left office, they started an anti-Partition campaign throughout the world. The enthusiasm which they showed when they were no longer in a position to implement or assist in the aim they were driving at was commendable, if somewhat late.

Comment on this

It is a long time since 1923.

Comment on this

But the ordinary man outside, the ordinary citizen, including the citizens of the Six Counties, could not help wondering what was the reason for the new enthusiasm by Fianna Fáil in relation to Partition, could not help wondering why it was so necessary the moment Fianna Fáil left office to carry Partition from Dublin to New Delhi, and right around the world to Australia, New Zealand and then to the cities of England, why, in the words of Deputy de Valera last night, Partition had suddenly become ripe. I want to suggest this as an explanation and I have suggested it outside this House on many occasions. The reason for that campaign, the reason Partition had become ripe, was merely that it was going to be used by the Opposition as a platform to crawl back into power.

Comment on this

That is fantastic.

Comment on this

"Fantastic" I heard Deputy Killilea say.

Comment on this

I said it.

Comment on this

Deputy Killilea is only wondering at your new enthusiasm about it.

Comment on this

If what I have suggested is fanastic, can Deputy Little or any other member of the Party opposite explain why Partition was shoved into the background in the last years of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Will you explain who was responsible for it the first time?

Comment on this

Or why it was not referred to in an Estimate and why a campaign was started within a few weeks of Fianna Fáil leaving office, why the peregrinations of Deputy de Valera and Deputy Aiken carrying the message in relation to Partition throughout the cities of England?

Comment on this

Do you object to propaganda being made?

Comment on this

He will not answer that.

Comment on this

I cannot help wondering whether there was malice behind the remarks of Deputy de Valera, Leader of the Opposition, here last night when he pondered as to why relations between England and Ireland should have been worsened. I do not know what views other Deputies on this side of the House may have as to the advisability of a displaced politican in this country causing disturbances in certain cities in England but I know what my views are, that it is discreditable and likely to harm the particular aim that it is supposed to serve.

If there is anything responsible for stampeding labour branches and portions of the trade union movement in England into the pro-Partition camp, it is the peregrinations of those two gentlemen I have mentioned. I should make it quite clear that that particular campaign stampeded the trade union movement in England into the pro-Partition camp and made them suddenly realise that they were the new exponents of the same aims as the Unionist clique in the North stand for. When Deputy de Valera or any other Deputy in this House wonders about matters like these, let him at least examine his own conscience. I do not blame Deputy de Valera or Deputy Aiken for being, if a little late, enthusiastic about ending Partition. But, when the British show fight, let them at least stand shoulder to shoulder with the Government and stop exulting out in the wilderness as they are exulting now.

Comment on this

Is not that what your people did in connection with the land annuities?

Comment on this

The Deputy will have an opportunity of speaking. I suggest that he should look after his sugar in the West. It is extremely regrettable that this debate, from the moment the Minister sat down, should have become a controversial debate. Speaking on this Estimate last year, I and other Deputies advocated a common programme amongst all Parties in this House, a common committee to deal with the question of Partition. I did so, not because I believed that any super-Government committee should be established, but because I thought that the lip-service paid to Partition by certain sections in this country could be co-operated into a united drive towards the ending of that problem. I certainly hoped, if that drive were to come up against temporary difficulties such as we met with when the British introduced their Ireland Bill, that by reason of the unity here, there would not be one section or one political Party exulting in the difficulties of the Government and trying to get kudos from them.

Because I held these views on this Estimate last year, I welcomed the step taken by the Taoiseach in inviting the Leader of the Opposition and the Leaders of the other Parties on this side of the House to join with him in a conference, since known as the Mansion House Conference. I know, because I was in the North for a considerable time then, how the action taken by the Government at that time brought joy and confidence to many of the people in the North who had come to regard themselves as the forgotten portions of the Irish race. They felt renewed strength in the fight because they saw Deputy de Valera and the Taoiseach joining together to do something for them. I also know that the confidence which our Six-County brethren felt was shared by the rest of our people in the Twenty-Six Counties and abroad. I expected that the unity and co-operation which that Mansion House Conference symbolised would be carried on throughout all the activities of the political life of our country and that we would never have two voices in relation to Partition—one man doing the work and the other sitting on the fence and criticising.

If Deputy Derrig's speech to-day means anything, I think that that unity and co-operation are now a thing of the past and that that conference is smashed to smithereens. I sincerely hope that I am wrong about that because, if that is so, it will not be for us to apportion the blame, it will not be for us to prophesy the result. The political fortunes of any Deputy or any Party in this Parliament count for nothing. It does not matter in the long run who was to blame or who was right some 20 or 30 years ago. What does matter is the consequences to the movement and to the Irish people of the failure perhaps of our national aspirations.

There is a motion to refer this Estimate back. Might I suggest that Deputy Derrig's speech should be referred back to the Fianna Fáil Party and that they should consider it very carefully? If that speech is to represent their official attitude, then, irrespective of their own fortunes which do not count, the Irish people are going to suffer considerably. I think that this is a serious matter and one which should get serious consideration by all political Parties. It is very easy for any of us to score political points just because a country like England, over which we have no control, may adopt a particular course, but, in doing so, we are not honest and we are not honourable. That is the criticism I have to make in relation to Deputy Derrig.

Having said that, may I just refer to one or two matters in relation to the Estimate? As I understood Deputy Lemass to-day, he disagreed slightly with, or rather varied—I suppose he dare not disagree with the views expressed by Deputy de Valera. Deputy de Valera congratulated the Minister on the fact that his Estimate showed an increase. He went on to say that the room for further expansion in relation to the moneys which should be spent on External Affairs was considerable. But Deputy Lemass criticised the Minister very much for that. Deputy Lemass is entitled to his own views, but he actually posed the question as to what the present Minister for Finance would have said about this Estimate if he were still Deputy McGilligan and was dealing with an Estimate which provided for this substantial increase in the salaries of civil servants in the Department of External Affairs. I took care to find out, not any imaginary speech that might be made by the Minister for Finance or anybody else, but what the Minister for Finance did say on the last Estimate introduced by the Party opposite in relation to External Affairs when dealing with the question of what money should be provided for that service. I find that, in Volume 106, column 2301, of the Official Reports, Deputy McGilligan is reported as follows:—

"In looking through the Estimate I glanced at one thing at which I always glance in these days. The Taoiseach told us that the greater part of the increase in the External Affairs Vote this year is under the heading of salaries, wages, and allowances. It is a remarkable thing that the increase in the salaries for the home staff amounts to £4,000. The old salaries used to be on the basis of £27,000 and we are adding £4,000, bringing it up to £31,000. The ordinary calculation we accept here is that the old £27,000 has now a purchasing power of less than £16,000 as far as the home people are concerned. We are giving them £4 to every £27 and that is supposed to be our best effort in regard to this important Department to equate the present-day value of money with present cost-of-living conditions."

I do suggest that, if Deputy Lemass is wondering what the present Minister for Finance might have said when he was in opposition, he might well consider what the present Minister for Finance did say when in opposition.

Comment on this

Has he carried out that principle since he went into office?

Comment on this

I cannot say. This seems to have been a day of challenges. I am glad that the challenges did not lead to fisticuffs. Deputy Lemass issued a challenge here in reference to a speech that he was alleged to have made in the town of Tullamore in which it was suggested by a Deputy that it contained a retraction of a previous speech made by him. Deputy Michael O'Higgins has referred me to a copy of the Irish Press for Saturday, 2nd of October, 1948, which contains a report of the speech in question. Before reading the extract, I should remind the House that the matter refers to a speech made by Deputy Lemass in Bray at the time negotiations were going on between this Government and the Government of England in the course of which he suggested to the British people that this Government was in no way representative of the Irish people, and that in fact it had no right to rule. The speech delivered in Tullamore by Deputy Lemass was printed in the Irish Press in black type so as to make sure that the retraction would be read by everyone. He said:—

"They were the legitimate Government of this country, however they got there. The laws which they made would be respected, and all their legitimate orders would be obeyed. The British, or other foreign Government, would have to deal with them because they were for a limited time the Irish Government, and it was their responsibility to see that no one would seek to challenge its legitimate authority as the Government."

That seems to corroborate what Deputy Lemass challenged here. I only hope that the Government will adopt the last sentence in Deputy Lemass's speech, and that they will ensure—it is their responsibility to see to it—that nobody inside or outside this Dáil will challenge the right of this Government to govern.

Comment on this

Apparently this is a debate of challenges. There is one challenge which I accept because I can speak on the matter from personal experience. I would wish that Deputies on the Government Benches would stop making false statements about what Deputy de Valera and Fianna Fáil did during the years previous to the change of Government. In 1938, the whole programme of Fianna Fáil had been clearly set out. Before that we had been dealing with the Constitution and after with the economic war, its settlement and with getting back the ports. The next matter to be settled in 1938 was that of Partition. Some of us were sent to different parts of Britain to help in that work. I happen to have been sent to London. We had a fine organisation going there, on good constitutional lines. I came back before Christmas. Early in 1939, at a time when Mr. Chamberlain was anxious to get the Irish question settled and to get the whole thing swept out of the way because everybody knew that war was coming—the cloud of war was over London at that time—the bomb-throwing started, and the whole thing was blown sky high for the period of the war. That was the position in 1939, so that nothing could be done.

There is no getting away from that fact. Members of this Government had friends over there who took part in that sort of thing, and it is nothing to their credit. Therefore, the sooner they drop saying that nothing had been done previously about Partition the better. Apart from that, I have references to Partition which were made in between 70 or 80 speeches by Deputy de Valera. Whenever he or any of his colleagues were in London they missed no occasion of dealing with that question. In fact, British Ministers were almost sick of having the anti-Partition case put before them by Deputy de Valera. He did it time after time. He never missed an opportunity of doing so. Therefore, I suggest to those on the Government Benches that they should drop that line. It does no good to anybody. It is not true.

Comment on this

Will you drop it over there?

Comment on this

Drop what?

Comment on this

Your particular line.

Comment on this

Efforts were made immediately after the war to recommence the holding of meetings everywhere. I cannot understand why any member of the Government should object to the propaganda which has been carried on all over the world, whether they agree with Deputy de Valera or not. They must know that he carries certain weight, respect and effectiveness all over the world. As a matter of fact, they ought to be ready to take the fullest advantage of his efforts all over the world by means of propaganda to get rid of Partition. I do not see for a moment how they can blame him for doing what he did. Their attitude seems to me to be quite anti-national.

Deputy O'Higgins has suggested that the propaganda carried on in Britain in the last 12 or 15 months has had a bad effect. Members of the Party opposite have been very active in carrying on propaganda over there Therefore, their attitude on this seems to be very inconsistent. It is clear that Parties must keep their independence. There must be an understanding to disagree on each side of the House. Each Party must be able to do its own work on its own legs. There is no use trying to pretend that there is unity on these matters. There is unity, if you like, in objective, but apart from that it only tends to create an entirely false position if one side tries to use unity as a means of beating down the other side. There is unity in objective, but we differ as regards method. There is a fundamental difference there.

Comment on this

The Leader of the Deputy's Party said last night that there had been no fundamental departure in the policy that is being pursued by the Department, to-day, and the policy that had been pursued by him.

Comment on this

When I was speaking last night——

Comment on this

I am not referring to what the Deputy himself said, but to what his Leader said last night.

Comment on this

I agree that there is no difference on the objective, which is to get rid of Partition. At any rate, I would have to read over carefully what Deputy de Valera said. I am perfectly certain that he would agree with me in this, that the Government's methods have, unfortunately, led to a position which makes it much more difficult to get rid of Partition now than it was before. That is an objective fact that we cannot get away from.

Comment on this

We know now where we are.

Comment on this

There is a difference of approach but a similarity as regards the objective.

Comment on this

We never have the same approach.

Comment on this

It is a new approach for you.

Comment on this

I had not intended to intervene in this debate and I do not propose to hold up the House any longer. All I wanted to do was to contradict one thing, and that was as to what was done or what was not done to get rid of Partition before we went out of office.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I do not propose to obtrude on the debate for very long. I think we could serve a useful purpose if we started here and now to give credit to anybody who is entitled to it for efforts that have been made in the drive to end Partition, and to coalesce in order to make a more determined and a more united effort to reach the ultimate solution of the Partition problem. I do not think it is worthy of any of us with any kind of national outlook and any belief in the unity and ultimate destiny of this nation, to be bickering as to who did what or when it was done. All I want the Dáil to endeavour to do—and so far as I can get it to endeavour to do so I will raise my voice—is to get on to a common platform on this question of Partition.

If there is one major political problem awaiting a solution, it is the problem of the reunification of the country. That problem should be faced by Irishmen who must realise that the country is bigger than any individual or any Party. To introduce personalities into a debate centring mainly around the problem of getting rid of Partition is a discredit to us all. I can be as bitter and as partisan as anybody and I can thrust and parry in debate, but, if that is going to affect the onward march of this nation to ultimate unity, then it is time for it to stop.

We are sent here to do a job. Deputies should not come here to criticise an Estimate merely because a certain individual who is Minister must, in their minds, merit criticism. I say without fear, favour or affection that a worthy job has been done by the Minister for External Affairs. I will not detract from what Deputy de Valera may have done when he was Minister. As I said last night on the News Agency Bill, I believe he did his best and that he took every opportunity to present Partition to the world. But I do not believe that it got across as well as it might have. I think we have reached a more favourable era. We must all get together and approach this problem, leaving personal and Party bickerings aside.

I am merely intervening in this debate for the purpose of trying to make the Dáil realise that the people are looking to us in a natural way to direct their upsurging impetus to get rid of disunity. Any debate that permits personalities and expressions of personal bias is no encouragement to people looking for leadership. There is a revived impetus in order to make sure that the wrong perpetrated on this country will be removed as quickly as possible. I honestly believe that personalities and Party differences must fade into absolute insignificance if we are to get to grips with this problem.

When speaking on the Republic of Ireland Bill I said there were many past bitternesses that reflect credit on none of us, and they should be left behind. I pointed out that this year we arrived at a certain stage in having an independent Republic for 26 counties, and from that united common plane we were in a position, irrespective of Party affiliations, to make a definite forward move to reunite the country.

I think the Minister for External Affairs is making an honest contribution to try to get that united effort going and it ill becomes anybody to offer petty criticism. If we were men enough and honest enough we would be aware of the really national, self-sacrificing effort that is being made by the Minister for External Affairs. We all have our personal feelings at various stages of our lives, but here in the Dáil on an issue so vital and so mighty compared with our smallness as individuals, we should adopt a more manly course. We should be able to coalesce and find agreement, not alone in an objective way, as suggested by Deputy Little, but in a solid, united forward plan to achieve something which will redound, not to the credit of one Party, but to the credit of the Dáil as a whole doing the nation's work.

The people of the country are earnestly watching this debate. They are interested in the efforts the Minister is making to put Partition before the world, to put the case for Ireland fairly, squarely and manfully before the nations. They will not think anything the better of us for cheap sneers or gibes. This is an Estimate in connection with which there may be petty differences or bitternesses in regard to administration, but in the consideration of it, all of us should make ourselves worthy of the trust reposed in us by the people. They look to us to give them a lead that will give them hope for the future and not bring back the sourness of the past. They look for a lead that will give this nation some prospect of realising its full and free nationhood. We should be big enough and fair enough to give credit to everybody who does his best in a national way to get a national job done. It does not matter whose son he is, whose nephew he is, or what his relations are, if he does his little for the good of Ireland.

Comment on this

An intriguing plank in the platform of Clann na Poblachta at the last election was concerned with the solution of Partition. The introduction of the Six-County members of Parliament into Dáil Éireann was contemplated. The people were led to believe that, once this was accomplished, the solution of the remaining difficulties in relation to Partition was only a matter of time. I believe there were some people in the country who thought that Deputy de Valera, Taoiseach though he was in the past, had never even thought of this. I might remind the House that this plank, like so many other of the election planks, has been cast aside and I rather think it has been ridiculed by the master Party with which Clann na Poblachta, despite their one-time lofty ideals, have mis-allied themselves.

During the elections in Northern Ireland great hopes were raised amongst the people that out of the concerted effort of all the Parties here one clear and definite policy would emerge to guide the people towards the achievement of our prime national objective. We are still waiting for that policy to show itself. As far as the people in Northern Ireland are concerned, they are sick and tired waiting for a lead from here, just as their elected representatives are sick and tired waiting for a lead from here. We all know that they are dependent upon us for such a lead.

I appeal to the Minister to state clearly and unequivocally what he proposes to do. In what way will he direct the national effort towards the achievement of a united Ireland in view of the fact that the one solution which he hitherto proffered, prior to his coming into office, has now been cast aside? We wonder if he has any alternatives. I think of the promises we made to these people during the northern elections; we were in; we were going to stay in; our motto was "No surrender". I think the people there must now believe that all our effort was just a fraud and a delusion. We are still doing a good deal of talking about Partition, conjuring up visions of the strength of the Irish vote in America and what it would do for us in Canada and New Zealand and Australia. We know now the great help America will be to us if ever the fight for complete freedom becomes a fight indeed. We know now that they are committed to fight against us. I was not disappointed when I saw that announcement because I never expected anything else.

The Minister has stated that our relations with England have deteriorated in the past year. That does not surprise me. If that deterioration is not due to the repeal of the External Relations Act, to what is it due? I shall not indulge in recrimination. I voted for it.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

I shall come to that later. I hoped at the time that my fears regarding possible repercussions were groundless and that that aspect had been probed up to the hilt. I feel now that the probing was not very skilfully carried out and that the difficulties which have since arisen were not then visualised by those who decided to repeal the Act.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be specific? Would he state the particular things which he thinks were mishandled?

Comment on this

It must have been realised that the repeal of this Act could not possibly be unattended by certain dangers. I think the Minister will agree with that. No one can deny that the deterioration in our relations with England is due to that. Let us face up to that fact and try to find a solution for it.

Comment on this

What about the threat of invasion in the North? Had that anything to do with it? I think you advocated it, did you not?

Comment on this

I shall come to that in time. It was regarded as a precipitous step by some. It was regarded as a retrograde step by others.

Comment on this

And as a progressive step by many.

Comment on this

A progressive step by some. Only time will show which exactly it was. At the time of the passage of the Republic Bill I expressed fears as to what history would record of us if, by repealing the Act, we retarded the ultimate realisation of the unity of our country. I hoped I was wrong in those fears. Somebody asked why did I support its repeal. I asked myself the same question on, I think it was, the 4th of May when the first news of the Ireland Act appeared in the public Press. I asked myself why I did support it. Then it occured to me that, if I did not support it and if we in the Opposition did not support it, the Government would take the first opportunity of allocating the major portion, if not all the blame, for the Ireland Act to the Fianna Fáil Party. The passing of this Ireland Act has created a serious position for us; we cannot get away from that. It is an attempt to perpetuate Partition. It should have been regarded as a hostile act to the Irish Republic.

Comment on this

So it is.

Comment on this

If it is, are we prepared to meet this addition to our struggle for freedom by the action it deserves?

Comment on this

Did the Deputy not hear his colleagues and the Leader of his Party advocate that we should get closer to the Empire and help to support the Empire?

Comment on this

Who suggested that?

Comment on this

The least I expected as a result of this hostile act by England was the breaking of diplomatic relations and the rescinding of all trade agreements until such time as England withdrew her entire military personnel from the Six Counties and ceased all financial obligations towards the Six Counties. I admit we made a protest. The time has arrived when words should be translated into action; yes, irrespective of what happens to our eggs or cattle. This Bill is Britain's answer to the declaration of the Republic. There is no doubt about that and it is up to the new republicans to answer in kind.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to the Minister?

Comment on this

I say it is up to the new republicans to answer England in kind. What was won by blood, sweat and tears had to be completed by an economic war which, together with the Treaty, is the foundation on which this 26-county Republic is based. I ask you, is a 32-county Republic not deserving of equal, if not greater, sacrifices?

The Minister referred to the deterioration of our relations with England. I cannot recall his referring to or commenting on our relations with the Dominions; he may have done so. I would be more anxious about them than about our relations with England because I recall that the Taoiseach, in introducing the Republic Bill, paid tribute to the friendly attitude shown towards us by the various Dominion Premiers with whom he had contacts. I have always hoped that the friendly attitude shown by these reasonable men and the people whom they represent, towards this country would eventually force England to do justice to us as she has had to do to other countries of late, and in the words of Prime Minister Attlee to one of those countries, permit her or compel her to abandon the sovereignty she has exercised over our country. I believe that they eventually would, for their own and for England's sake, endeavour to solve this problem. I submit that were they so inclined they would have been glad to avail of this slender External Relations Act—slender and all as it was—as a lever in any negotiations with England on the subject of Partition. Although I do not imagine for a moment that that friendship towards us is in any way lessened, the wind has been taken out of their sails by the declaration of a Republic of 26 counties and the passage of the Ireland Act.

I gather from statements made by the Taoiseach and, I think, the Minister, that despite many conversations, aides-memoire, consultations and communications between our representatives and the British representatives extending over a long period, the introduction of the Ireland Act came as a complete surprise. During the Northern Ireland election campaign towards the end of January and early February, I was informed that legislation on the lines of the Ireland Act would be introduced into the British House of Commons very shortly after. This did not surprise me, in view of the statement made by the Prime Minister of Northern Ireland a short time previously on his return from an interview with Mr. Attlee—I think the interview was on the 6th January—when Sir Basil Brooke jubilantly announced Mr. Attlee's assurance to him that the constitutional position of the Six Counties would be reaffirmed. I thereupon put down the following question to the Taoiseach on the 16th February, Volume 114, column 2:—

"Dr. Maguire asked the Taoiseach what action the Government proposes to take in view of the declaration by the British Prime Minister in regard to the reaffirming of the Partition of our country.

The Taoiseach: I am not sure to what particular declaration of the British Prime Minister the Deputy is referring, but I can tell the Deputy that the most effective action we can take in view of any effort to reaffirm or continue Partition is to redouble our efforts to mobilise all the moral energies of the Irish people, at home and abroad, towards bringing Partition to an end. That is precisely what the Government are doing.

Dr. Maguire: Is the Taoiseach aware that legislation will be before the House of Commons early in March in connection with the reaffirming of Partition?

The Taoiseach: I am not aware of any such thing."

Comment on this

What is the date of the question?

Comment on this

16th of February. I admit that my information was a few months out in the suggested date of the passing of that Bill in the House of Commons but I think the delay was due to the Easter recess. I accept the Taoiseach's statement that he was not aware of such contemplated legislation on the 16th February but, as he now admits that he was still uninformed of it until the 3rd May when the Ireland Bill was introduced, all I can say is that the Government has been out-generalled in this whole matter.

The Minister has referred to our application for membership of the United Nations Organisation and stated that he was glad that we had so far failed, owing to the difficulties which would attend the staffing of such a project. I am glad that we failed for another reason. I fail to see what useful purpose can be served by acquiring membership of such an organisation, the outstanding characteristic of which, since its inception and indeed its only achievement, has been a complete absence of unanimity at the meetings.

Comment on this

It was the Deputy's Leader who applied for membership.

Comment on this

I will not deny that.

Comment on this

It is true.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy approve of the action of his Leader?

Comment on this

A lot of water has gone under the bridge since then. The world did not stop still when Fianna Fáil left office.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Dr. Maguire, on the Estimate.

Comment on this

I would rather we did not succeed in obtaining membership. International conferences have not played a great part in the evolution of the freedom of this country in so far as it has been achieved. I have little hopes of Ireland's claim receiving justice before such conferences composed of people who, though fully cognisant of our centuries-old struggle, are nevertheless mute observers of England's latest act of tyranny towards this country—not that it matters whether we are elected there or not. The views of small nations, if they are consulted at all, on matters of peace or war, continue to fall on the deaf ears of the world's bullies. As far as this little country of ours is concerned, we can never hope to gain anything from the crumbs that fall from the tables of international conferences presided over, as they invariably are, by one or other of the high priests of hypocrisy.

I trust my remarks will not be misconstrued into hostility towards the English people. Indeed, I have always contended that geographically, and because of common view on various matters, there are no two countries in the world so suited to the dovetailing of their resources in agriculture and industry and, if necessary, in man power. I have lived with them, and worked with them, and, as is generally well known now, I have served with them. I maintain that there are no two peoples so compatible, one with the other, so that none of my statements can be misconstrued into hostility towards England. Even the most stupid of English politicians must realise that the dovetailing of our resources, should the necessity ever arise, must be on a basis of absolute equality as between the two nations and the prerequisite of the complete unity of the country.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister said.

Comment on this

The Minister has again mentioned the question of our preparedness to give guarantees to the Six-County people should they decide to join up with us. He made that suggestion before and I resented it, for the same reason I shall give now. I think it was a mistake. The offer of guarantees, political and religious guarantees, implies that there is a possibility at least, that they may be required but there is nobody knows better than the Protestant people of the Six Counties that no such guarantees are necessary. The religious aspect of Partition, as everybody knows, is only a red herring drawn across the question. The only people who have fear in their hearts are the despicable junta who rule in the north and who fear the loss of power and office.

Quite a lot has been said, and rightly so, in connection with Partition, regarding the majority in certain areas of the Six Counties who favour union with the rest of the country, but in my opinion that is beside the point. Quite recently I noticed that the Taoiseach appealed—to whom I forget; I presume it was to England—for the return of Tyrone and Fermanagh. I consider that is a dangerous line to take, one that may quickly be seized upon by the enemies of our country as an indication of a lack of confidence on our part in the achievement, in the near future, of the unity of the country. I say "the near future" because if there are any Deputies here who are marking time in connection with Partition they have no right to be here.

Comment on this

You have been.

Comment on this

Unless we make up our minds to achieve the unity of the country in our time, by every means at our disposal, then we are merely wasting our time and fooling the unfortunate Nationalists of the Six Counties who rely so much on our efforts down here. Irrespective of whether they are inhabited by Protestants or Catholics or by neither, it is the territory, the soil and the territorial waters of the Six Counties which we are after and which we mean to get. The Six Counties have ever been an integral part of this country. We can, and we must, with the determination that has characterised our struggle in the past, restore them to the parent body and with that determination to have them by every means at our disposal, we should make an unequivocal demand on the British Government to clear the Six Counties of their occupation forces by a certain date.

An incident which, I consider, created a misconception in the minds of other peoples regarding our declaration of a Republic here was the holding of celebrations in connection with the day on which it came into force. When the suggestion of celebrations was first mooted, I protested for the reason that I think any celebrations held in connection with that——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not want to limit the Deputy. I know his views are absolutely sincere and I do not want to limit the discussion more than is necessary but I suggest that that hardly comes within the scope of this Estimate.

Comment on this

All right, but I shall say this before I conclude. We are sick of anniversaries, celebrations, commemorations and centenaries.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Let us for Heaven's sake stop them until we have achieved the object for which the people for whom we are holding these anniversaries and celebrations, sacrificed their lives. Then when we have achieved it, let us have one celebration. I would suggest that we then close down for 25 or 50 years on all such functions so that by that time another generation will have arisen whose refreshing ignorance of political and religious bigotry will enable this country to progress and achieve the prosperity which at present it so sorely needs.

Comment on this

Last month I asked the Minister to state his policy in regard to the request which has been made for the protection of our holy places in Palestine. The Minister informed the House that everything possible was being done. I think he convinced me at any rate, and convinced the House, that everything possible is being done by our Government to ensure that places that are sacred to the Christian population of the world will be protected and made accessible to people of all countries. I think that this attitude and this action is only what one would expect from a Minister representing our country. I think his approach to the question has been wise and prudent and I trust that in conjunction with other nations his effort will be successful and that those small, struggling and somewhat aggressive nations that control these Holy Places will at least have respect for the things that are sacred to the whole Christian population. I do not think that the small nations concerned can afford to trample upon the sentiments of Christianity throughout the world and I hope they will not attempt to do so. I am sure that the pressure of public opinion, in which the Irish nation will co-operate, will succeed in achieving its laudable purpose.

It may be a matter of interest to the House to know that since I asked that question I received a packet of propaganda from one of the States concerned. I mention this because I intend to pass the leaflets on to the Minister as an example to him of how inept, incompetent and stupid some nationalist propaganda can be. The people who wrote to me call themselves the World Truth League and they omitted to state to what race or nation they belong, what they were striving for, what they wanted or what purpose they hope to achieve. They content themselves with reams of abuse of practically every nation and every race on the earth.

One of the great functions of the Department will be publicity and propaganda on behalf of our country addressed to people who do not, perhaps, understand our rights and our national position. I sincerely trust that the propaganda that will be issued by the Department will differ fundamentally from the propaganda of this Palestine organisation.

As the Minister's Department is concerned with external affairs, it is right to say that fair-minded people generally must admire the tremendous ability and energy which the Minister has put into his work during the short period in which he has been Minister. There is no doubt that the duties of his Department have been very strenuous. The work that he has been called upon to do has been enough to wear out any man. He has had to travel to all parts of the earth attending conferences and meetings of all kinds and getting the Irish viewpoint on a very large variety of questions prominent before all sections of people in the world. That has been a tremendous task and I think it has been carried out by the Minister with great ability.

Fundamentally, the two big problems that face our nation in regard to world affairs are, first, the menace of international Communism, and secondly, the achievement of national unity. The Minister will be surprised, perhaps, or alarmed that I have put the menace of world Communism first but I feel that there is in this country a tendency, because we are concerned mainly with our own national problems, to overlook the tremendous menace to western civilisation, to the free nations of Western Europe, which is constituted by the growing strength and ever-increasing stretch of the Communist controlled bloc of nations. It may be that we in this country and perhaps the people in other western countries have been since the end of the European war living in a fool's paradise. We may have been enjoying a certain measure of peace and prosperity that is only a prelude to a more terrible conflict that will envelop and involve all the nations of the earth. There is no reason why we should ignore that menace. There is no reason why we should ignore the very solemn warnings which have been issued by His Holiness the Pope, by those who direct the affairs of the Catholic Church on earth. There is no reason why we should ignore the ruthless persecution of the Catholic Church in those nations which have fallen under the control of the Communist monster and there is no reason why we should not in every possible way co-operate with other free nations in seeking to preserve the world, first, from a third world war and, secondly, from complete overthrow and control by these Communist forces.

The Minister and Deputies may ask, what can small nations such as ours do in present circumstances to try to preserve the peace of Western Europe, what can we do to strengthen the forces that are resisting Communism? There would seem on the face of it two lines which a nation such as ours can adopt. First, there is the economic line of defence. There is the building up, in co-operation with all the western nations, of a certain measure of economic strength that will sustain the peoples not only of this country but of the other European countries. As far as that is concerned, the Minister has, I think, worked strenuously and I think worked well. He has co-operated in the organisation of European co-operation. He has co-operated very ably with the formation of the Council of Europe. Behind those efforts we must depend upon the ordinary plain people, in co-operation with their Government, to build up the prosperity of our country, and then to co-operate in restoring the prosperity of those other nations whose economy was so badly damaged by the war. As far as that is concerned, I think no Deputy can criticise the Minister.

It must, however, be remembered that the forces of Communism will not rely entirely or alone upon the breaking down of civilisation in the peace-loving countries through the failure of their economic system. They will, if it suits them, also resort to force. Most realistic people are prepared to acknowledge that a resort to force by Communistcontrolled nations is something which may happen within the next few years and something which will happen unless the people who control those countries are satisfied that the organised forces against them are too strong to be tackled. There is nothing which can stop the Red Army except a stronger army.

The question arises then: What can a small nation do in such an eventuality? What can a small nation do at present to present to any aggressors the organised strength that will stop them from initiating a third world war? The only thing a small nation can do is to co-operate with other nations in some type of defensive organisation. The Minister announced in this House, and I think also in the other House, that this Government had definitely decided not to have anything to do with the Atlantic Pact or the Atlantic alliance. I am one of those who hold the view that, when the Government state their policy clearly and definitely upon a really important national issue, it is undesirable that there should be any division of opinion presented in the country in regard to that issue. Once we have declared that our policy is not to join the Atlantic Pact, I do not think that we should alter our policy with regard to that. But, if this small country wants to co-operate in the defence of Western Europe, and if we are not prepared to enter into a defensive agreement with Great Britain in present circumstances, there is nothing to prevent us from entering into a defensive agreement with the United States.

We have repeatedly called upon the United States to help our country in achieving national unity. If the United States should call upon us to help them in defending their continent from attack through the defence of Western Europe, I do not think there is any reason why we should turn down that appeal. I do not think there is any reason why we should not at least enter into discussions with them as to what would be the nature of that agreement and what they would be prepared to do for us in return. It may be that such a suggestion might not be very welcome to the British or to other signatories to the Atlantic Pact, but we are not so much concerned about that. As a small nation, we are concerned to co-operate to the fullest extent in preventing, if possible, a third world war, and the only way that is possible is by the unification, as far as possible, of the nations that stand for peace. It has been said so often that it has become a hackneyed phrase, that Nero fiddled while Rome burned. Let us hope and pray that it will not be said that Eire fiddled not only while Rome but all Christianity trembled on the brink of a Red inferno; that at least our small nation showed a willingness to co-operate with the bigger and stronger nations in the defence of Christianity and in the preservation of the freedom of the world.

I also asked a question about our attitude towards the United Nations Organisation. This House unanimously agreed to make application for membership of that organisation a couple of years ago and our application was turned down by the veto of Russia. I think that the wise course to have adopted would have been to withdraw our application. I may be wrong, but I think it would be a more dignified course. I do not think we gained anything by having our application waiting pending some change of view on the part of the Russian dictator, because any change of attitude towards us might be interpreted by freedom-loving nations as a change of our policy towards Russia, which is a thing we would not like to have happen. On the other hand, I do not think we would like to have our admission ticket into the United Nations Organisation peddled about in exchange for the admission of some countries under Communist rule. I think the more dignified course would be to withdraw our application and wait until either the United Nations Organisation disappears, as it is likely to do, or until it is reformed.

The other big issue which has been debated fairly fully but perhaps not fully enough during this discussion is the question of national unity. I prefer to use the words "national unity" rather than the word "Partition". I think our whole psychological approach to this question should be changed. Our policy should be, not so much war upon Partition, but a great effort to restore national unity. If we bring the matter down to a homely analogy, a partition may exist in a very small but very compact detached house, but there is still a sense of unity there. There could also be some sort of a State boundary within a very united nation without impairing the unity of that nation. Switzerland, a small country, is divided into a number of States. America, which is a large country, is also divided into a large number of States. We ought to make it clear at this stage that we are not so much against this country being divided into one or two States, but that we are seeking to have this country unified, so that whether it is one State or two or three States, they would all recognise the essential unity of the nation as a whole under one central Government. If that were made clear, it might be helpful to our efforts for the unification of our country.

On the broad issue of national unity, we have to make up our minds quickly as to how we are going to achieve that objective. We have had 25 years or more of independence here in the Twenty-Six Counties, but there has not been so far a successful effort made to achieve national unity. I do not think that the whole nation has ever definitely decided what line to adopt upon this question. I do not think that we have ever been able to convince those nationalists who are in the North of Ireland that we have a policy on the question, that we know what it is, and that we can see our way clear to the realisation of that policy.

There are two ways of achieving national unity, either by converting the majority in the Six County area to our way of thinking or to get them in by force. I have great respect for the views expressed by Deputy Dr. Maguire, views which are expressed with absolute sincerity, but yet I think that not only the Government but the Leader of the Opposition would have to consider those views very earnestly and very long before they would adopt them. The policy which he suggested was one of war in the very near future. The Government and the leaders of our Parties here would have to be satisfied that that policy was the only one that could achieve this desired object, and they would also have to be satisfied that it had a reasonable prospect of success. No Christain nation is justified in going to war unless, first of all, the conflict cannot be avoided, and, secondly, that it offers a reasonable prospect of success. I believe that resort to force, in order to re-unify our country, would not be justified.

I believe there is an alternative, and that if we pursue it with steadiness, patience and perseverence, it will eventually succeed. The alternative which I suggest to every member of the House, and to every person in the State, is the policy of friendship, in spite of everything that has been done by the people who control the Six County area as well as those who support them on the other side of the water. I believe that, by establishing closer contact with those people and maintaining such contacts with them, in spite of everything they may say or do, we will eventually break down their prejudice against this nation to which they belong. Deputy Dr. Maguire suggested that there was very little use in being reasonable with the people who control the Six Counties. That may be true, but those people would have no power whatever unless they had behind them the very substantial number of ordinary citizens who, by their votes, elect them to office and have done so again and again consistently over the last 25 years.

Another suggestion which I put forward with absolute sincerity—it has been made in the last six months and may seem somewhat rather novel—is that an effort should be made to set up an all-Ireland council, representative of the Six-County Government and of the Irish Republic, a council or conference which would meet regularly to discuss matters of common concern to both areas. There are quite a number of such questions which require consideration and which are capable of being discussed in a friendly way by the Governments of the two areas, questions relating to trade and finance, and particularly, questions relating to transport, drainage, electrical development, agriculture and the fight against disease not only amongst live stock but also of those diseases which afflict the human population. These are questions on which there could be a certain amount of co-operation, no matter how fundamentally we may differ on political issues. Both Governments could come together in a friendly way and discuss these matters. I believe that, if we were to do so, eventually we would break down the prejudice that is seperating those people from the rest of the nation at the moment.

In addition, we would need to have, and always must have, a steady campaign not so much of propaganda but of the truth. There is always the tendency to regard propaganda as being something apart from the truth. I think that by telling the whole truth about our position, and to keep that objectively before the people of other nations, to tell it in a moderate and a restrained way to the people of the United States, of Canada and of other free nations, we would achieve the object we have in mind. That, I believe, would be the result if we were to continue that policy consistently and steadily. On the question of national unity there is no division whatever amongst the people of the Twenty-Six Counties. We are all anxious to have that ideal achieved—the ideal of Ireland as one nation. While we are all agreed on that, I think nobody would seriously disagree with the proposition that any area that is around Belfast, or any portion of the Six Counties which desires a separate Parliament, should be allowed to have it, but beyond that we are all in complete agreement that the whole nation should be unified.

Reference was made to the question of an instalment plan. I have very grave doubts on that. I do not know what the attitude of Deputies generally is towards it. I have very grave doubts as to whether it would be helpful; whether, if we were demanding the restoration to the nation of portion of the Six Counties, the result of such an attempt would be beneficial or otherwise. I have the feeling that it might not, and that it might only aggravate the problem. I think that if we were to consider an instalment plan at all we should consider another type of instalment plan for the Six Counties, that is if we are to reconcile ourselves to the making of a demand for less than the complete restoration of the Six Counties to the Irish nation. We might perhaps demand some change in the attitude of the majority in the Six Counties to the minority, some reform in their electoral system that would make the way easier for the restoration of this area. If we are going to ask for an instalment, let us consider that also, because it is possible that, if strong pressure were brought to bear, with the co-operation perhaps of the United States or other friendly Powers, we might be able to secure that instalment of justice. It was suggested that a fairer electoral system should be introduced there, and perhaps also we might be able to secure that the British would not be permitted to subsidise or otherwise offer inducements to the Six Counties to remain with the United Kingdom. They would be instalments of justice, but not complete justice, which might be demanded. However, I will not express any dogmatic opinion on that.

I think the Minister has carried out the tasks allotted to him with great ability and I do not think there is any justification for asking the House to refer this Estimate back for reconsideration.

Comment on this

In this debate a great deal has been said from the Government Benches to Deputies on this side of the House. Listening to the speeches made by Government Deputies, and particularly Deputy O'Higgins, one would imagine that we were introducing the Estimate and the Government spokesmen were opposing it and wanting to have it referred back. Deputy O'Higgins, when he was speaking to-day, started to abuse Deputies on this side of the House on the grounds that our attitude towards Partition was something new and he wanted to know to what he could ascribe this new attitude on our part.

I do not know whether Deputy O'Higgins has followed the history of this country for the past 30 years. I do not know that he ever heard of Fianna Fáil in opposition from 1927 to 1932. I do not know if he ever took the trouble to see the posters issued by Fianna Fáil, even in non-election times, or whether he took the trouble to find out what this Party stands for. If he did, he would discover that this Party is definitely committed to using any and every method possible to end Partition.

He also suggested that the Leader of this Party never spoke about Partition. I think if he took the trouble to look up the records of this House he would find that on every occasion possible Partition was obviously very close to the mind of the Leader of this Party. I do not know whether Deputy O'Higgins ever took the trouble to study the debate on the introduction of the Constitution or if he even read the Constitution, because it is quite clear that in that Constitution, which was put before the people by Fianna Fáil and which was opposed by all the other Parties in the House, provision is made for the time when Partition will be ended.

Comment on this

When will that be?

Comment on this

Does Deputy O'Higgins not realise that there were many other constitutional issues and that the Fianna Fáil Government, as such, inherited a legacy which had to be dealt with? It was not Fianna Fáil who endorsed Partition. Fianna Fáil had to remove the Governor-General, the Oath of Allegiance, which was imposed on the members of this House, and appeals to the Privy Council.

Comment on this

They swallowed the Oath.

Comment on this

The Oath was removed by the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with this Estimate and the Deputy should not answer these irrelevant, disorderly interruptions.

Comment on this

The attitude of this Party in relation to the position which has now developed as a result of the removal of the External Relations Act has been questioned from the point of view of a patriotic approach. I recommend Deputies to read the speeches made here during the years when Fianna Fáil were involved in an economic war with England for the removal of the land annuities.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the Estimate.

Comment on this

Our patriotism has been challenged.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And I challenge anything not related to the Vote before the House.

Comment on this

References to the by-election in West Cork were not considered irrelevant. A lot of references were made to speeches during that election and also in Bray, and there were quotations from papers which were not produced, although the dates of issue were stated.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy is finished in his criticism of the Chair, he may proceed with his statement on the Estimate.

Comment on this

A great deal of latitude was allowed by the Chair. I am merely asking for a direction from the Chair. Am I entitled to reply to criticism of the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party in journeying to foreign countries, including England, and trying to educate people about Partition? It was suggested that he has no right to go to England and that he was driving friendly members of the trade union movement against us by raising the question of Partition there. It was mentioned that it is only now, since we went into opposition after our period of office as a Government, that we suddenly realise the importance of Partition.

Do Deputies not realise that there has been a conversion brought about in regard to Partition? There has been a conversion in the minds of Deputies on the far side of the House. It is not so long ago since we were surprised to find those who had advocated closer ties with the Commonwealth suddenly emerging as even more extreme Republicans than the Clann na Poblachta Party. Every Party in the House has a certain history and has emerged as a result of certain developments in their own associations and in relation to the country as a whole. There have been criticisms of the manner in which the Government handled this matter. It is quite true that when the Bill was presented this side of the House indicated that if the Government believed it would do some good they were not going to be prevented from doing that good.

Comment on this

Pull down the sails instead of only trimming them.

Comment on this

It has been suggested that because we did not oppose it we have no right to criticise now what has resulted from that particular line of approach. Some people have said to me—and I have heard criticisms in the House—that the Government's approach in this matter was undiplomatic and opportunist. It was undiplomatic because it was done in such a way that it led to statesmen in Britain making the charge that no proper official and diplomatic approach was made to them. I am not saying whether there is or is not any truth in those charges. I am merely saying that those charges have been made——

Comment on this

Really, the Deputy should tie himself to some charge.

Comment on this

——that opportunists, it is stated, who stood for the Commonwealth relations suddenly reversed their policy. Now that has been widely canvassed outside this House. Every citizen of voting age who is asked to read election literature and vote for a Party standing for a particular policy tries to understand the particular policy of the Party for which he or she casts a vote. These are the things that should either be clarified or left alone. If they are left alone, I think the spokesmen of the Government ought not to endeavour to blame this side of the House for what has happened.

There was no opposition to the Bill when it was introduced. The Opposition were not consulted about its introduction. The announcement was made abroad. Even Government supporters were not consulted and were just as surprised as we were. When the interests of the country were paramount there was wholehearted and unanimous support. When a certain reaction took place——

Comment on this

You trimmed your sails.

Comment on this

When the interests of the country are challenged, or when the legitimate authority is challenged, it is the duty of every citizen to stand for his country irrespective of whether the position has been brought about as a result of a good manoeuvre or as a result of a bad manoeuvre. To the extent that it was necessary and for as long as it was necessary, this Party played its part. Since then everybody has been disappointed. Even the spokesmen of the Coalition Government spoke with different voices on this matter. I remember hearing the Taoiseach indicate more or less that because he was a lawyer and because the Prime Minister of England was a lawyer they would be able to settle this matter more easily; I think he said in the course of 24 hours. On the platform in O'Connell Street at a meeting of all Parties combined I heard the Minister for External Affairs say he did not know how long it would be before Partition was ended; it could be a long time or a short time, but it would have to end some time. Everybody had a different view. Then we had a statement that it would end in a matter of months.

The Opposition had a realistic approach to this matter. We want to see Partition ended. We have on the Opposition Benches men who have given evidence of good service as far as their country is concerned. They are not prepared to take second place. On the Government side of the House there are men who have taken risks in the past in order to bring about the freedom of this country. A situation arose in which there was a cleavage because some people felt that commitments were being entered into which could never be honoured. The rope that hung around the neck of the nation has at last been cut away, except for this one outstanding problem of Partition. As Deputy Little said, while we can agree in absolute unity as to the objective, there is room for disagreement as to the best method of approach to bring about the end of Partition in the shortest possible time.

The two Deputies to whom I have already referred brought in all manner of suggestions, raised all kinds of matters and made all kinds of unfair and unreasonable attacks. Dealing with the news agency service, I want to ask the Minister has he ever examined in detail the possibility of having Press attachés—properly trained experts——

Comment on this

Has the Deputy not read the Supplementary Estimate?

Comment on this

I am speaking of Press attachés as distinct from a news agency service in order to obviate the necessity of having this news agency service.

Comment on this

That is why I asked the Deputy if he has not read the Estimate. Part of the Supplementary Estimate which the Deputy is now discussing is for the provision of Press attachés in Washington, New York and London and an information section here.

Comment on this

I know that this news agency service has already been discussed on the Second Stage of the Bill, but I think it is legitimate to make a short reference to it here. Has the Minister given detailed thought to the possibility of having Press attachés? Could not these experts do what the Minister has in mind? I cannot see what useful purpose this agency will serve which could not be served equally well by a Press attaché. If he is an expert and knows his job and the people in whose country he is working, he will know the type of bulletins to issue and the kind of information to give. I would ask the Minister to reconsider this news agency proposal in view of the criticism expressed by the Opposition.

The countries in which we have Ministers or consuls are limited in number. The business of a Press agency will also be limited because of the fact that we have not representatives in certain countries. I would ask the Minister to postpone this proposal until such time as he has received reports as to what his Press attaché in each country thinks will result from the setting up of this news agency. In my travels abroad I have gathered that our representatives stand very high in the opinion of the other diplomatic services and in the opinion of the citizens of the country in which they serve. As far as Ireland is concerned, we can be very proud of the reputation we have gained because of the services rendered by our representatives abroad. I have never heard a complaint of lack of courtesy or lack of consideration. We have a very large number of our people leaving for abroad, say, America. Every one of us probably knows some recent emigrant and probably occasionally gets back a letter. I want to put this on record and I think the Minister ought to commend his staff for it.

Whenever any of our people abroad happen to run into a jam or are in trouble they can always find a human reaction, they can always feel they are almost at home, the moment they put their feet inside the Irish office wherever it may be. I want to say that, because of the high reputation which our consular service and our Ministerial service abroad enjoys, I think that if the dissemination of news such as the Minister has in mind were to emanate from these offices it would be accepted with a much higher standing than if it were just rolled out, as will be the case, by what one calls an ordinary news agency. I would appeal to the Minister to take the opportunity of reconsidering it, to compare the standing of the consular service and our legations abroad with any other country and he will find there may be something in what has been said from this side of the House.

I do not want to delay the House any longer except to say again that as far as the Department is concerned I certainly feel a little bit of a grievance, as many of us do, when I find people grumbling about the recent increase that was put on the passports. Outside of that I do not think there is any complaint with regard to the Department of External Affairs.

Comment on this

I rise on this Vote to say a word or two and to express my appreciation of the manner in which the Minister and the officers of his Department have discharged their duties during the past year. In approaching an Estimate of this kind I think it would be well for Deputies to realise the fact that, whoever may happen to occupy the position of Minister for External Affairs, he is not the Minister of the Government or of a Party but that he is really a Minister who is representing the Irish people at home and abroad. Listening to this debate and hearing the mean, low criticisms that have been passed on the Minister, I think that the Deputies opposite have done a great disservice in so far as the interests of this country are concerned. Deputies must recognise the fact that when our Minister for External Affairs attends a conference outside the shores of this country the success which will attend his efforts depends to a very large extent on the unanimity and co-operation that he receives in the Parliament of which he is a member. Do not forget that.

Comment on this

When did you discover that?

Comment on this

I have always said that and I am 22 years a member of this House. I always gave credit to whatever Government was in power. Coming of an old constitutional and nationalist family who were Irish before Deputy Lemass was ever heard of in this country, I can realise what my responsibilities should be to the people who sent me here. Understanding the very high position which the Minister occupies, I think we should show that, if not to the Minister in person, at least to the position which he occupies.

Coming to the many activities with which the Minister has to deal, I think that Deputies should be glad of the work that he has accomplished. He has told us here that he has made agreements with Great Britain, France, Belgium, Spain and many other countries which have reacted very favourably in so far as the trade and economic interests of this country are concerned. I think in 1939 our exports to some of those countries were only in the region of £10,000. To-day, in 1949, they are somewhere in the region of £50,000. In particular, our exports —I think it is to the Netherlands—are almost £300,000 as compared with £60,000 or £70,000 a few years ago. That is a direct result of the activities of the Minister and his officials during the past 12 months.

He has also taken a very live interest in seeing to it that, as far as it is humanly possible and with the resources at his disposal, our Irish missionaries in the Far East, whose very lives are threatened by the forces of atheism whose one object is to sabotage and undermine the very foundations upon which Christianity itself rests, are given all the help possible wherever they may be. No mention has been made of that part of his activities from any member opposite.

Again, in the matter of passports or in the matter of facilitating our Irish citizens here in recovering property, the services of the officials are ever ready to be placed at the disposal of any of our people, however humble they may be, who may have occasion to call at the office in Stephen's Green or at the office of the representative in the various countries to which they are attached. I join with Deputy Briscoe in paying a tribute to the officials of the Department of External Affairs in the way in which they have carried out their work in regard to the issue of these passports and visas.

The question of Partition has been discussed here and I am not going to say very much about it except to quote the words of the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party when he himself was Taoiseach. He said that the only people who can deal with that problem of Partition are the Government for the time being, whatever Government is in Power. I would say to all and sundry, even to our fellow countrymen in the Six Counties, leave this question of the solution of Partition in the hands of the present Government. That is why I was so silent in the past on this question of Partition. I never mentioned it here during the 16 years when Fianna Fáil was the Government of this country because I think their Leader, the then Taoiseach, was right when he said that if any suggestions from the opposite benches—which were the benches of Cumann na nGaedheal and Labour at that time—were sent over he would give them all the attention they deserved. I say the same to-day. There is no use in saying that this question can be easily solved. There is no use in men like Deputy Maguire getting up here and stating that we should break diplomatic relations with England because of the passing of the Ireland Bill. There is no reason for that.

I have been as long as anybody in this House and longer, fighting the question of Partition so far as the national unity of this country is concerned and that goes back well over 50 years. No one in this House can tell me anything in so far as this question of Partition is concerned. Although I am one of those who are quite prepared to fight for the national unity of this country I am going to take good care, although I do not mind what happens to myself, that I do not put anybody else in danger.

We have a lot of loose talk about taking certain action because the British have passed the Ireland Bill, and it is suggested that the Government is not doing its duty. All this talk about bad relations with the British Government is not true. The relations between this Government and that of Great Britain never were better than they are to-day. It is true that a certain amount of distrust was created when the Ireland Bill was introduced. It is only natural that, following an event of that kind, there should be a certain amount of coldness between the two countries, but the greatest friends, even in the same household, often have differences of that kind. So far, however, as trade relations are concerned, they are the very same as they were before the introduction of the Ireland Bill or before our own Government repealed the External Relations Act. The proofs are there. Never in the history of the country for the past 15 or 20 years have our exports to Britain been greater than in the last year or two. That is the country with which Deputies on the opposite side have said our relations have deteriorated. What is the use of trying to establish that a state of affairs exists here which in reality does not exist?

I say, no matter what may be said to the contrary—I may be up in the Six Counties shortly and I shall make the same statement there—that the question of the solution of Partition is a matter for the Government of this State at the moment. We do not want 101 Taoiseachs all over the Twenty-Six Counties telling us what we should do. The Government is not going to be stampeded into taking any action that would be inimical to the best interests of the country. The Government must be guided by prudence and must feel assured that any action taken is one that is likely to produce the best results. This Government, rightly or wrongly, has been elected by the majority vote of the Irish people. The Opposition are here as representatives of a very strong and powerful section and it is their duty to work in harmony and co-operation with the Government, so that by their united action the unity of the country may be restored.

Comment on this

I should like to address a few questions to the Minister in regard to the news agency which he intends to establish. In what way is that going to assist in the solution of the Partition problem? He made the statement that there are 700 newspapers in the United States. Can the Minister tell us at this stage how many of these newspapers will be willing to carry any news of this country to the people whom they serve? At the present time it is not possible to get even one line in the English papers in regard to anything that would be likely to favour this country. They are ready enough to publish news that is likely to be detrimental to this country but there is never mention of anything that is likely to further the campaign against Partition, for instance. When the proposed news agency is established will these papers publish anything concerning this country, anything that is likely to assist in the solution of Partition?

From what Deputy Coburn has just said, one would think that our relations with Britain were never so rosy. I wonder has he read the speeches made at Orange celebrations in Northern Ireland on the 12th of July and the reaction which the passage of the Ireland Bill has had in relation to the Six Counties? I am one of those who was deported from Northern Ireland 25 years ago and I have a personal interest in seeing that that part of the country is restored to the nation. I had the privilege and honour of being deported because my late husband would not take the Oath of Allegiance. After being interned for three years in a prison ship, he was deported and for that reason I have a personal interest in seeing that this problem of Partition is solved. I was there when the Stormont Parliament was inaugurated and when the King of England came over to open that Parliament. We looked in vain at that time to the people of the South for some protest against the injustice that had been perpetrated on our country. We got no protest. That is all past history now but so far as I can see the situation is more serious now than ever it was before. What has brought about that deterioration in the situation I am not going to suggest, but I will say that there was a little too much pretence about the establishment of the Republic of Ireland. People of other countries were misled. They were told that we had got a Republic and that the aspirations of Irishmen all down the years were now satisfied and their hopes fulfilled. It was left to these people themselves to find out that we had a Republic only for 26 counties.

Of course, when the Constitution was passed in 1937 it embraced the whole 32 counties. I think the present Minister acknowledged that, that a 32-county Republic was established by the Constitution of 1938. Now we find ourselves in the position that Partition has become stereotyped and the introduction of the Ireland Bill has made the situation far more difficult from our point of view. That is shown by the speeches made at the Orange celebrations in the North on the 12th July, one of which I shall quote briefly. Speaking at the Ballymoney demonstration, Mr. W. McCleery, Minister of Labour, said that—

"with the new Ireland Act which had just been passed at Westminster, they had reason to hope and expect and earnestly pray that the Partition question had been so manifestly settled as to leave no doubt in the mind of anyone."

It is clear that they are perfectly satisfied but we down here are further away from the solution of the problem than ever.

It is a pity that people are misled by Ministerial pronouncements in regard to this matter. I read in the newspapers a short time ago a statement by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in Geneva in which he assured the members of an assembly there that when next he visited that assembly he would be speaking as Minister of a 32-county Republic. I noticed also that the Minister for Lands, speaking in Ballina some time ago, assured his audience that when he would be back within two years he would be speaking as Minister of a 32-county republic. Do these Ministers really believe that? Have they any plans to show that Partition will be solved in one year, two years, or 20 years? If they have, they should tell the people about them. It is not fair to say that Partition can be solved in two years if no such plans are in existence. I think it is ridiculous to be trying to mislead the people in that way. We are only making a laughing stock of ourselves here for the people of the Six Counties. They know that as long as they have Britain to back them and America to back Britain, Partition will remain. The Minister has said that the efforts of our AntiPartition friends in New York have not been helped in any way by America; that, as a matter of fact, their representations are treated with indifference and that they are not going to help us in any way; that, as far as they are concerned, they will back Britain in any effort she makes to maintain Partition. Where are we to look for help? If America does not back us up or use her influence with Britain, where are we going to seek help? Our own people all over the world are helpless. Their sentiments are with us and they hope that they will see a united Ireland, but if the American Parliament, which is mainly a Freemason Parliament, backs up a Freemason Parliament in Britain, there is no hope that Partition will be solved in our time.

Many things have been said about the Leader of the Opposition, that he never did anything to remove Partition. When he came into office he removed a lot of obstacles that made it very easy for others to follow without any trouble whatever. The last and remaining obstacle was the External Relations Act. There is one thing: Whatever he did—to use a slang phrase—the British never put anything across on Deputy de Valera. Anything he did, he knew what the consequences were going to be and there were never any repercussions for any association he had with them. He got back the ports and they could then have tried something on him but they did not do it. He put a Constitution before the people. That was a time there could have been repercussions, had the British so desired. Whether it was as a result of the removal of the External Relations Act or the passing of the Northern Ireland Act, the position as regards Partition is more difficult now, to my mind, than ever it was.

The people who talk here so glibly about the removal of Partition do not seem to realise the mentality of the people of the North. I wonder if they have ever lived amongst them? I lived in Northern Ireland for 10 years, amongst a Protestant people, and although they were the nicest people in the world, on the 12th July they could not say a civil word to you or pass the time of day. They are first and last anti-Catholic, I am sorry to say. Their loyalty to the Crown is really overrated. It is a matter of religion, pure and simple. How we are to break down that bigotry I do not know. In one of the speeches reported in The Telegraph on the 12th July it was said that the greatest menace in this world was the Catholic religion and Communism. That is an extraordinary statement to have made in a Christian country. We never tried to convert them to our way of thinking.

Everybody here is free to practise his religion no matter what it is. If they think we want to coerce them to become Catholics, they are wrong. They can never have that to say of us. As a matter of fact, the boot is on the other foot. We have only to remember history. They were the people who tried to proselytise our people, when they were dying of starvation. We never tried any such measures on them. They should remember what they are talking about. We have no bitterness towards them. As regards religion, they can practise any religion they like. As proof of that, the Protestants in this part of the country cannot say to any Government in this State that they have ever been coerced in any way. Why should they hold such bitterness to the Catholic religion as displayed in the burning of effigies of the Pope or crying "To Hell with the Pope" and all the rest of it? That is old fashined now. Until that old mentality and that old Freemasonry dies a natural death, I am afraid this trouble will exist.

I am afraid the Minister's news agency, no matter how he tries to put the case of Ireland across, will not help in any way. I cannot conceive how any papers in America will give prominence to the cause of Ireland if it does not please Britain. They certainly will not do it. I wish the Minister every success in any effort to end this problem but he certainly has a pretty hard task. It is only those who have lived amongst these people, who know the mentality of them, their bitterness and their bigotry, can understand the situation as I know it.

Comment on this

The speech which has just been made by Deputy Mrs. Rice conflicts to a very large extent with some of the speeches that have been made from the Fianna Fáil Benches this evening and that have been made from Fianna Fáil platforms since the External Relations Act was removed from the Statute Book. Clearly, Fianna Fáil policy would appear to be directed towards gaining the votes of what I might call the Protestant minority in this part of the country. Deputy Mrs. Rice has indicated a different point of view and I am perfectly certain that that point of view will not be welcomed by the Leaders of her Party. I feel that this attempt to play up to the Protestant minority here as if they were imperialists is wrong. It is quite true that their grandfathers, or maybe the fathers of some of them, may have been British imperialists, but in the last 25 years there have grown up the sons and daughters of that Protestant minority and they are as good and as sincere Irish men and women as there are to be found in the country. This effort to single them out as British imperialists whose votes can be got by suggesting that Fianna Fáil are better imperialists than the present Government is, I think, a very distasteful and obnoxious piece of propaganda.

Comment on this

If we were trying to get their votes, we failed signally. You got them all.

Comment on this

Deputy Childers made a good attempt.

Comment on this

The Irish Times leader made an attempt in the Cork election.

Comment on this

So long as we are clear that the effort was made by Fianna Fáil to get the votes and that they failed to get them, well and good, but I am quite sure it must have nauseated Deputy Boland when he was preparing his speech for Bantry and it must have nauseated his Leader when he was preparing the speeches that he delivered in a somewhat similar vein in the West Cork constituency. I feel that this debate on External Affairs should be lifted very high above some of the petty considerations that have influenced Deputies on all sides of this House this evening.

Comment on this

I listened last night to Deputy de Valera. I listened to-day to Deputy Lemass. I must say that I thought both of these Deputies put forward in a critical way a point of view that ought to be expressed in this debate. I do not or could not support some of the criticism that was directed against Deputy Lemass for his contribution. I thought it was a sound contribution from his point of view. I thought it was constructive. I thought that he had held up the mirror to the Department, that he had examined it very carefully and with quite a number of the points that he made I personally was in agreement. But the debate has deteriorated considerably since then.

We had, or at least we thought we had, an extraordinary set up in this House when we had a Government formed from a number of Parties and a number of Independents and an Opposition consisting of a single Party. I felt when we had reached that position in the House that probably the more critical side of the House in regard to Estimates and Government policy generally, the more critical from a constructive point of view, would be the inter-Party side. I am disappointed in this way, that immediately an Estimate such as this is introduced it is criticised from the Fianna Fáil side and then every Deputy and Party on the Government side spring up immediately to the defence of the Minister concerned. I think that that is wrong; it is regrettable that that should be so. I think that we can discuss, that we can examine, that we can criticise in a constructive way and still, when all that is done, we can say: "We have criticised, but we are quite prepared to give the Minister his Vote." That is what I am going to do this evening.

Up to recently the Department of External Affairs was a Department which dealt with diplomatic relations, in the main. But, in recent years, and certainly since the formation of the inter-Party Government, the Department of External Affairs seems to include more than the ordinary diplomatic matters that we considered part of the Department of External Affairs. Economics and financial matters seem to play a greater part than diplomatic matters in the working of the Department. I wonder if our Department is properly built for the consideration of these matters. Deputy Lemass mentioned matters of trade. I was surprised when I saw that the Minister for External Affairs was representing this country at conferences in Europe on matters that were purely trade matters which hitherto had been dealt with by the Department of Industry and Commerce. Only recently, the Minister was at a conference in Paris at which Great Britain was represented by the Chancellor of the Exchequer. We were represented by our Minister for External Affairs and not by our Minister for Finance. Is our Department constructed and are our officials in the Department trained to deal with economic matters and financial matters? I do not think that the Department has been constructed for that purpose.

Comment on this

Maybe our Minister is competent to deal with them.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will not consider that it is criticism if I say that it is well known that the Minister for External Affairs has a very slight knowledge of economics and a slighter knowledge of finance. Nobody can expect him to be an authority on economics, because to be an authority on economics requires study over a long period. Obviously, the Minister had no opportunity of becoming a specialist in economics. To be an authority on finance requires study over a long period, and it would be very unfair for any person to expect the Minister for External Affairs to be an authority on finance. The peculiar way in which the machine is running now, however, means that these matters of finance and economics seem to be the main concern of the Department of External Affairs, and in my view, the Department is not constructed for the carrying out of that function.

I read a statement in the Irish Times of the 29th June last in which it was stated:—

"Mr. MacBride, who is in Paris to attend to-day's meeting of the 19 Marshall Plan nations—called to try to break an Anglo-American deadlock on trade and monetary policy— criticised the policy of Marshall Plan countries of cutting down imports from the United States. This, he said, merely makes the slump worse."

That was the statement of the Minister for External Affairs in Paris. He criticised the Marshall Plan countries. We are one of these countries, and I presume that the criticism was directed against this country as well as the others. The criticism was that we were cutting down imports from the United States. I suggest that no economist with a knowledge of what has been attempted to be done in this country over a quarter of a century would have made such a statement in Paris or any place else. I do not think that the Minister for External Affairs ought to set himself up as a sort of super-salesman for the United States of America. I do not think that that is his function. I think the Government are wrong in placing on the shoulders of the Minister matters which are proper to the Department of Industry and Commerce or to the Department of Finance. I do not want these observations of mine to be taken as a criticism of the Minister, because it would be unfair to criticise him if the Government gave him responsibilities that ought not to be thrown on his shoulders.

Partition has been mentioned in this debate. I agree with Deputy Mrs. Rice that the problem of Partition is probably more serious now than it has been for a long period. If the efforts to end Partition are to be constitutional methods, then I say it is almost impossible to remove the obstacles that have been placed there over a period; not only the obstacle of the latest British Act, but the other obstacles that are created by virtue of the fact that we have become members of certain international organisations. I am afraid that there has been no proper or realistic approach to this problem of Partition.

Not many months ago, they had an election in Northern Ireland and we here decided to participate in that election. We took the decision to participate too late. The actions we took were ill-considered, and I think everybody would agree that the results were bad. We set up a Mansion House Conference, or rather a Mansion House Conference established itself. There was a collection and there was a magnificent response to the collection; approximately £54,000 was collected. What was that £54,000 collected for? The people wanted enthusiasm and they wanted leadership.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I am quite prepared to take on the burden, if the Chair so rules, of accounting for the funds held in trust by the Mansion House committee. I would like the Chair to rule whether I am supposed to account for these funds or not.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister certainly is not. I understood the Deputy to claim that the methods taken to end Partition were wrong and quoted that as an instance without there being any responsibility on the part of the Minister for the expenditure of these funds. The Minister has no control over them.

Comment on this

That is correct. It is just exactly what I was doing, and I think the Minister knew very well what I was doing.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is entitled to raise a point of order.

Comment on this

He is, and he knows when to raise it if he can throw a speaker off.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows something about that, too.

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

Aithníonn ciaróg ciaróg eile.

Comment on this

I may be put off if this continues. However, the people wanted leadership. That was clear. They showed their enthusiasm in collecting this £54,000. It is perfectly safe, I hope. I sincerely trust that it never will be the subject of an action in the High Court. I cannot grumble on that score, but I doubt if I would be available when the legal issue in regard to that came to be tried. The response showed the enthusiasm of the people for leadership in regard to that. The enormous demonstrations that we had in Dublin and elsewhere again showed the enthusiasm of the people.

The Minister and myself came into this House on a programme of endeavouring to bring about an end to Partition by making the necessary changes in the law that would enable representatives from the Six Counties to take their seats in this House. Now, that was an important aspect of our policy at the time, but the Taoiseach has stated that the Government do not propose to follow that up. They do not propose to suggest any constitutional changes that might make it possible for representatives of the Six Counties to take their places here. As I said last night, I am afraid that this News Agency Bill will have the effect of damping down enthusiasm on our failure to do the right thing in regard to the Northern Ireland elections and our collection of the £54,000: that we do not seem to have made any use of these things.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister has no responsibility for that.

Comment on this