Committee on Finance. - Vote 65—External Affairs (Resumed).
Contributions 358–547 of 547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I know, but these things, taking them by and large, may have the effect of browning people off, if I may use the expression, in regard to this Partition problem. Then, on top of that, when I read in some newspapers—I have not the reference with me and I am at the mercy of the Minister—the statement made in the United States by the Minister suggesting that this problem of Partition might be solved on a federal basis, I felt that we have no fixed policy at all in regard to this. The Minister for External Affairs says "deal with it on a federal basis"; the Taoiseach says "let us look for instalments". That is the problem, and I do not want Deputy McGrath to be amused at this, because the unfortunate thing is that these very same points of view were put forward by his own leaders. The federal idea and the instalment idea were put forward by them.
Now, this is one problem on which there should be a substantial unity of view. Our Ministers and our former Ministers, our Government and our former Government should be able to sit down and work out what are the practical steps that we can take to end the Border and to end Partition. I was asked by the Minister for some reason as to what my methods were. I explained what they were. If I had the responsibility of putting these methods into operation I have no doubt whatever that I would make a success of the job, but, unfortunately, I have not that responsibility, and all that I can do in a debate on this Estimate is to draw attention to this. But, in the meantime, while the Government are making up their minds, while the Minister for External Affairs is making up his mind as to whether we are going to have the federal idea or whether we are going to have the instalment idea, whether we are going to try and solve it by force or whether we are going to do anything at all, whether we are going just to use the news agency service when the Bill becomes law to talk about this, whether we may get this £54,000 that is available and use it for propaganda purposes; while minds are being made up in regard to those matters, I would suggest to the Minister that there is one step that he can take, and that is to create conditions down here that will at least be equal to, and in my view, ought to be better than the conditions that exist in the Six Counties. I do not think it would be relevant if I were to develop that point.
Comment on this
However, I can only put it in its broad setting, and having campaigned with the Minister over a period, he will understand and appreciate what I mean. I think that the criticism levelled at the Minister in regard to our relations with Britain was unfair—a lot of it—and for this reason, that what did happen in Britain and what was responsible for the introduction of the Ireland Bill was something that is very difficult to understand. I am satisfied that what really happened over there was that this Ireland Bill was to be introduced for the purpose of clearing up certain matters that arose from our declaration, or rather from the Act we passed, which declared the name of this country to be the Republic of Ireland. I am satisfied that when that Bill was drafted there were introduced into it the clauses to which we took exception. I am satisfied that those clauses were in the Bill when the British Minister received it and that the British Minister had to stand over a Bill which he did not understand, which he did not read in advance, and which was prepared by people much cleverer than he was.
I am prepared to go that far in extenuation of the action of the British Minister concerned, and to that extent I think that some of the criticism directed at the Minister was unfair. But I will add this little bit of criticism myself, that the Minister went on a visit to the United States of America. I asked him a Parliamentary Question as to the period of time he spent with the Secretary of State, and the answer was that he spent a quarter of an hour —that was in the period of some weeks when he was over there. I should have imagined that the main value of the visit to the United States would have been to get the ear of the American Secretary of State in regard to these problems of ours. A discussion between two Ministers lasting for a quarter of an hour can permit of nothing beyond an exchange of courtesies.
Comment on this
I think, speaking from memory, I spent some 40 minutes with the Secretary of State—that is purely from recollection.
Comment on this
I accept that and I will make it threequarters of an hour. We will not quarrel on that point and still we will endeavour to keep on the line. I felt that the Minister made certain statements in America which, if the British Ministers were bothering about them, would have been somewhat provocative. The impression I gathered was this: "Here are we in Ireland, a small country divided by an artificial border. Ireland is vital to the defence of Western Europe. We want to come in with you to defend Western Europe, but we cannot do it while Britain keeps us divided." In other words, there was the suggestion to Uncle Sam that he should pull John Bull's tail. "Britain is treating us unfairly. We want to go in with you, so put the pressure on Great Britain." My views in regard to Great Britain are pretty well known, but at least there is this to be said, that Britain is a proud country, they have weathered many storms, they have fought many wars and, being a proud country——
Comment on this
An unjust one, if the Deputy wants it that way. But they are a proud people, and if they paid any attention to what the Minister said the effect could well be: "Well, we will show these people where they get off." I am not saying that that was the attitude of the British Government at all, but it could have had that effect.
Comment on this
We will let the Minister deal with it first hand, if he should wish. Now, I would talk to Britain, and I am quite sure a lot of other people would talk to them, directly rather than try to put the screw on them through a third power, and particularly when that third power was and is as unreliable as the United States was and is. President Truman has told us his interest in the ending of Partition. Of course, it is easy to be wise after the event——
Comment on this
The State Department said it could not advise President Truman to take any action regarding Partition.
Comment on this
I do not want to deal with the political organisation in America or the responsibilities of the President or who advises him or who does not, but so far as President Truman is concerned, he has not done anything towards the ending of Partition. What I am endeavouring to suggest is this, that if, during that period when the Minister was in America, he had been across in London, and if he had been speaking to each of the Ministers, explaining to them the problems, and if he had been able to secure from them that they would let him see a preliminary draft of the Ireland Bill before it was introduced in the House of Commons, it is quite possible that the very objectionable sections of that measure which have caused controversy between the British Government and ourselves might never have appeared in the draft as finally presented.
As I have said, it is easy to be wise after the event, and it is easy to criticise the Minister when the thing is done. I do not want that to be used in the form of criticism that has been directed against the Minister from the other side of the House to-night. I say that, in accordance with the measure of freedom we have here on this side of the House, for a Deputy like myself, who has not seen the Minister's speech before he made it and who is not consulted about the things the Minister does, it is a good thing if I can put forward constructive criticism of the Minister, as I am endeavouring to do.
I shall conclude on this note. I agree with those Deputies who say that the Minister has applied himself to the work of his Department during the past year, that he has worked very hard, and that he has spared no effort in carrying out the responsibilities of his office. I may disagree, as I say, with some of the things he has done, but I do agree with the observations that have been made by Deputies.
May I conclude by saying that criticism is a good thing; that we must all take criticism now and again and that when a Deputy criticises a Minister, as I did last night, it would be much better if the Minister did not impute unworthy motives to that Deputy?
Comment on this
In the course of this debate Deputy Tom O'Higgins had occasion to challenge the members of Fianna Fáil who seemed to him to take the attitude that they were not in favour of the repeal of the External Relations Act. He suggested that for us to criticise the handling of the Department of External Affairs, or to bewail or regret the events that have taken place was pure hypocrisy. I think Deputy O'Higgins's challenge should be taken up. We did have to face a new situation. We can be thankful that at the present time, and for the first time since 1921, all Parties have agreed here on one issue; we wished to defend our Constitution and we wish that Constitution to apply to the whole of Ireland. We are all agreed upon that.
We were not agreed upon it in 1921. We were not agreed upon it during the whole period of the economic war in which we faced every sort of obstruction and criticism from the then Opposition. At least to-day we have that very great measure of unity that we want the Constitution to apply to the 32 counties and, in so far as the British Government take any action to delay the day when it will apply to the 32 counties, we object to that action and we support the Government in their stand against it. In any action which the Government may take to make the Constitution apply to the 32 counties, which we are agreed is a good action, we shall give our approval to it and we shall give our consent and all our support to the Minister and the members of the Government.
Having said that, there is no point in our being hypocritical in the sense that we refuse to talk about things in connection with external policy which are known to the whole world, which are known to the British, to the Northern Irish and to ourselves. If, by talking about them, we can get back to fundamentals and start again, take a new view, recollect all we have done since February, 1948; and, if by so doing, we can advance in a better way and take wider steps, it will be to the advantage of the country as a whole. I think it is up to any member of Fianna Fáil, who desires to do so, to state why we did back the Government in their policy of repealing the External Relations Act and the assumption we made when the Government took that action.
I daresay a number of us had different views about it. As I have said, the only real common factor between the Parties in this House is a belief in the Constitution. That is a fundamental belief with all of us, together with its application ultimately to the 32 counties. Some members of the Fianna Fáil Party, just as some members of the other Parties, may have slightly different reasons amongst themselves individually as to why they approved or did not oppose the repeal of the External Relations Act. I think it is just as well for some Deputies, who feel inclined to do so, to accept Deputy Tom O'Higgins's challenge and give those reasons in the light of the present situation.
I propose to give mine. They may not be those that other members of the Opposition hold. But I think that many members of Fianna Fáil would agree with my views. I did not oppose the repeal of the External Relations Act for varying reasons. I did so assuming certain things would happen. I assumed, in the first instance, that the Minister would ensure that the repeal of the External Relations Act would not considerably worsen our relations with Northern Ireland immediately and in a very definite way. That is a perfectly reasonable assumption. One is not being a traitor to one's country or impeding the cause of unity in saying that. I cannot be challenged on the ground of not backing the Government in their present campaign by saying that.
Secondly, I assumed that every step had been taken in advance to ensure that Partition would in no way be further sanctified or embuttressed by the British Government as a result of the repeal of the Act. When I speak of the repeal of the Act, that could take place at any time now or in the next ten years. There are a great many Deputies in Fianna Fáil and in other Parties who were quite prepared to have an open mind on the date on which that Act should be repealed, if repealed at all. Therefore, my second assumption was that it would not sanctify Partition in the eyes of the British and that they would take no step to make the situation even one degree worse so far as getting rid of Partition was concerned.
My third assumption was that it might be something to satisfy the feelings of those people who call themselves extreme republicans to remove the doubts that had been cast upon our independent status here. I might say in that connection what is purely a personal observation, that with the actual status of our country under the Constitution and with the External Relations Act in operation, I did not wish to define it particularly as a Republic. I was quite content with the fact that we had our Constitution, that we had two Houses and a President. I was quite prepared to wait for a number of years after the war had ended without wishing to further define it, any more than the American Government or the American character of democracy is defined.
My next assumption was that what happened to us after the Act was repealed was a matter that had received the attention of the Minister for External Affairs and that he was taking into account the reactions of the other members of the British Commonwealth. In particular, I had assumed he had consulted with the Government of India, or would consult them, and that he would have regard to the whole question of the future character of the Commonwealth and any change in status that might take place in the Commonwealth; and that he would do all of these things before he would finally take the decision to repeal the Act.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not overlook the fact that there were several conferences with Commonwealth Prime Ministers before any measure was introduced here.
Comment on this
I am not overlooking anything. If the Minister would kindly let me make my speech, he will have all the opportunity he wants for replying. I also assumed that the way of concession lying open to the North, as long as the External Relations Act remained in operation, would not be rejected unless the Minister was aware of some way whereby we would not be placed in a less favourable position in regard to any concession we might make to the North; that we would not be on a less favourable basis and our bargaining power would not be less satisfactory after the repeal of the Act than it was before; and that he himself had taken the necessary steps to deal with that matter. That was also quite a reasonable assumption to make.
Then, at the time of the repeal of the Act, a great many of us began to feel that the Minister and the Government had something very special in mind in connection with Partition. The Taoiseach, no doubt, under the guidance of the Minister for External Affairs, spoke six times before he came back from America and in each of the six speeches he quite clearly seemed to indicate that the situation was now much more hopeful than when he landed in the United States. In each of the speeches he quite clearly seemed to indicate that the situation was much more hopeful. When he landed in Cobh he gave an interview to the Press in which he said: "I believe that this additional independence"—and he was not referring to the repeal of the Act, he was referring to the ending of Partition—"might come to the Irish people within a very few months". A great many of us began to feel at that time that we should be very careful because something might have been brewing. The Minister might have had consultations with representatives of the Dominions and maybe there was some justification for the Taoiseach speaking in that optimistic way. He was in contact with the American Government and with the Canadian Government and presumably he had been in contact with the Minister for External Affairs. Maybe there was some justification for his extreme optimism and, therefore, this new approach to the solution of Partition might be a good thing. At least, it would be very unwise of us to turn it down.
Of course, I also assumed that the Minister would see to it in advance that those people in the British Dominions, the Governments, the individual Leaders of Governments, the non-Irish and the Irish there, when we had taken this action, would continue to be at least as friendly to us as they were before and that our kith and kin would be in a position to give us the same assistance and moral support. I assumed that if the Prime Ministers of New Zealand, Australia and India had ever thought at all of assisting us in solving this problem, the fact of our repealing the Act would not in any way induce them to forget us and that they would, perhaps, take advantage of the occasion to say to the British Government: "Now, a very serious action has been taken by the Twenty-Six County Government of Ireland, which is fraught with importance for the whole of the British-speaking world", and that they would at that time come forward with some proposals to bring pressure to bear on the British Government. Perhaps the Minister for External Affairs was against all these things.
Comment on this
The facts of the situation we know well. They are that it has been made more difficult for a small group of people both in England and Northern Ireland who were anxious to help us. I agree that that help had not been very evident. That may pass away in time and people may once more be willing to help us. Another result has been the fact that people who did not know much about Ireland before, now knew a great deal about the declaration of the Republic but unfortunately too little about the problem of Partition. It will be a man-sized task for the Minister, using any kind of Government Press agency or any kind of wireless installation he has in mind to tell all the people, who up to now have taken very little interest in Ireland, all about the problem that still remains unsolved. So far as we know, the British Dominions have not shown any special sign of being more friendly to us than before and the groups I have mentioned have not demonstrated their willingness to help us. We have to rely, so far as I can gather from the Taoiseach and the Minister, on the moral pressure made by ourselves and our friends largely in the English-speaking world, to persuade the British Government to undertake a settlement of Partition. I do not see any evidence that they are going to take any greater interest in us now than they took before.
I need hardly say anything about our relations with Northern Ireland. Deputy Cowan has dealt fully with the unfortunate results of the Mansion House committee which was started too late. I can only say what everybody knows, that the result, so far, has been the hardening of the attitude towards us and that was already hard enough. Another result has been a certain muddling in people's minds about the kind of propaganda we should use. I referred to that in connection with the Government's Press agency. I do not see that there is very much use in saying that you are going to rob the English people of their pride, prestige and their pockets unless you know very clearly what you are about. I gather that the present Government have eschewed the idea of any physical force or any economic retaliation. It leaves, therefore, the weapon of propaganda. If the weapon of propaganda is going to be employed, it is no use gratuitously insulting the Unionists of Northern Ireland. I am not saying it is going to be confined to any one Party. I merely mention that we have got to have 800,000 dyed-in-the-wool Unionists amongst us. It is no use being gratuitously insulting if our only means is the moral influence and moral support of other people. It is not going to be a solution to the problem.
I would like to repeat what Deputy Cowan said and to ask the Minister, so to speak, to start again so long as he controls the destiny of the Department of External Affairs. Blunders have been made before in our external relations. We shall not know in 50 years' time whether even the former Government made blunders. Blunders have definitely been made in the past and the thing to do is to try and repair those that have been made in the conduct of our external affairs. I think that one of the difficulties we have to face is that far too few leaders of the people remember that there are three groups of people in the 32 Counties to consider; three groups of people who will always be amongst us.
There are the Unionists and the strong supporters of the Commonwealth, the people who believe in the Commonwealth and some relationship to the King. They number a very considerable proportion of the total. They are a minority of the whole 32 Counties but they are a part of our people. Then there is the group of republicans who are perfectly willing to have some association with the Commonwealth provided unity is assured and provided that there are no humiliating conditions attaching to that association. There are other republicans who are willing to have that association grudgingly, not accepting it fully but believing that perhaps it is an inevitable conclusion. There are republicans who want no kind of association whatever but an absolutely pure republic, a politically, isolated republic.
As I have said, the thing that counts is our belief in the Constitution. If a policy is to be devised, it must be one that satisfies the interests of the majority of the whole of Ireland, who do believe in the Constitution and secondly, one that will do something to recognise the feelings of the minorities. That is the thing we have always worked for. We have had bitter conflicts on what the reconciliation should be. But there has always been at least a suggestion that there must be some positive reconciliation. We have the Constitution on which we all agree. Within that Constitution there can be formed a reconciliation, as the Minister well knows. I hope that he will start thinking more about a definite attitude and approach towards the North and the British Government. We have heard a great deal of suggestions for a federal basis of settlement. We have heard suggestions of having our unity in instalments. We have heard suggestions made by persons from all Parties in this House, more of one Party than of another, that we should attack the North in spite of the Taoiseach's declaration that that is not to be the policy. I think that the Minister should start to consider what the policy is to be in the future, what the Northern Government is to expect might be our future relationship with them.
The position now is that the ground work is prepared. We have now the great advantage that the second world war is over and we have a common interest in maintaining a Christian civilisation. The Minister starts with certain advantages. He is not going to be accused of stabbing England in the back if he asks for a measure of unity for the whole of Ireland on a Christian basis. He has the possibility of installing a great short-wave wireless station. He has himself declared that by means of the news agency we could do much more propaganda, although he should see that such propaganda will not consist of the repetition of unwise speeches made in heat. As I say, he has opportunities for reviewing the whole position. I want to make it quite clear that it is possible to be a republican, to advocate the application of the Constitution to the 32 Counties, to support the repeal of the External Relations Act and at the same time to disagree vehemently with the manner in which it was done because of the lack of forethought which was evidenced. Having said that, we can still say that we support the Minister in his stand against Partition and that we support him in any constructive act he undertakes about the unity of the country, that these things are not inconsistent and that there are moments when it is wise to be prudent in regard to constitutional relations. It interested me to hear Deputy O'Higgins talking about our attitude in this matter, remembering that if there had been silence, even for six short months in 1933, the economic war would have been settled in about two years and the Partition campaign would have begun in 1936 instead of in 1939.
Comment on this
A great many Deputies on the opposite side of the House have spoken in the course of this debate. That is good and as it should be. I am glad that Deputies have been taking a more active interest in the work of the Department of External Affairs. From another point of view, I have seldom listened to a debate that made me feel more despondent about this Parliament than the debate to which I have listened for the last two days.
Very few of the Deputies who have spoken from the Opposition Benches have spoken either with sincerity or honesty. Possibly Deputy Childers was one of the few who did speak with honesty and sincerity. Possibly, too, Deputy Mrs. Rice and Deputy Dr. Maguire also spoke with sincerity and honesty, but it was quite obvious that if they were sincere, there is not room for them in the same Party. Most of the other Deputies who spoke on the Opposition Benches—and I think also Deputy Cowan—were not interested in the external affairs of this country, were not interested in making any constructive suggestion for improving our foreign policy or for the abolition of Partition. Their one and only interest was to try to damage either the Government on the one hand or myself personally on the other.
It is perfectly obvious that either the Fianna Fáil Party is split, irretrievably split, on a fundamental issue or that it is a two-faced Party. On the one hand you have some of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party advocating in this House, and putting it forward presumably in the name of their Party, that armed force is the only solution, that we should break off diplomatic relations with Britain and repudiate all existing trade agreements. On the one hand that is the advice from one wing of the Fianna Fáil Party. The advice from another wing of the Fianna Fáil Party, represented in this debate by Deputy Derrig and probably Deputy Lemass to a certain extent, is that we should, if necessary, tie ourselves around the neck of Britain and the sterling area and sink with it. I have really felt, in listening to the criticism that we received from the Opposition Benches, that the administration of my Department under my direction must have been perfect. I was criticised from two completely opposite directions. Having regard to the very wide and deep split which obviously exists in the ranks of the Fianna Fáil Party, I can begin to appreciate the attitude adopted by the Leader of the Party both in this House and elsewhere. I can begin to understand why, repeatedly, after having voted for the repeal of the External Relations Act he made speeches, repeating several times in the course of the same speech: "I won't say whether it was a good thing or a bad thing to repeal the External Relations Act." Of course he could not because he had a split Party behind him.
Now, I do not think it is a bad thing that there should be a divergence of views in the ranks of the Fianna Fáil Party or in the ranks of any other Party in this House. I have often said that we had had no normal political development. That was largely due, first of all, to the fact that we had not control of our own affairs until about a quarter of a century ago. Secondly, we had the civil war and its aftermath, which has persisted right up to now. But from now on it should be possible to get away from the civil war, to get away from the bitterness and hatred which occasionally shows itself on the Opposition Benches.
Comment on this
If I may say a word of reprimand, of condemnation, now to Deputy Briscoe, who is not by any means one of the most bitter Deputies on the other side, I think he should stop criticising and talking in sneering tones about Deputy Tom O'Higgins Junior and Deputy Michael O'Higgins. I am glad that we have young men in this House. I am glad that we have young men who are able to examine issues and decide issues on their own merits irrespective of the past, irrespective of past affiliations. I should also like to say a word of condemnation of those Deputies on the other side of the House who frequently make references to the fathers or the families of T.D.s on this side of the House. We could all do that. We could ask many questions about the relatives, the antecedents, of Deputies on the other side of the House, too. Would that serve any useful purpose for the conduct of the affairs of the nation? Is it on that basis that we are to run our Parliament —on bitterness, on hatred, on personal prejudices? Are we going to continue that for ever? Or, are we going to begin to have a normal political development? Are we going to begin to behave normally and to consider issues on their merits?
That is why I said that I was glad, quite apart from any question of Party advantage, to see that there was such wide and fundamental divergence of views in the Fianna Fáil Party. I think it was inevitable. I think that we have not had normal political alignment because of all the past differences and that the time has come when Deputies of all Parties should consider issues on their own merits and decide accordingly.
The whole purport of the speeches made by the Opposition Deputies and by Deputy Cowan who, of course, can never resist the temptation to have a side kick at me, if he can, was to suggest and to say—some said it directly; others who were more clever, said it indirectly and inferentially—that the Government, or myself in particular, had committed a blunder. Most of them refused, even when asked by me, to specify the blunder that was committed. Some have suggested that the repeal of the External Relations Act was the blunder. Deputy Childers, if I may take him first as he was the last speaker and his remarks are fresh in my mind still, gave a number of reasons as to why he voted for the repeal of the External Relations Act. He voted for it, he said, because he assumed that I had certain particular precautions taken that would ensure (1) that our relations with the Six Counties had not worsened. I addressed the House when the repeal of the External Relations Act came before it. I do not remember Deputy Childers asking for any such assurance. I do not remember my adverting to that.
The next reason he gave was that we would have no difficulties with Britain. Is, then, the right of the Irish people, of the Irish nation, to determine its own form of government and its own status to be governed by the wishes of the British Government or are we an independent nation? He then said— and this illustrates, if you like the type of irresponsible statements that are made just for the sake of opposing, just for the sake of throwing some form of criticism at these benches—that he assumed—and he gave that as one of his most cogent reasons—that the Minister had had discussions with the Commonwealth Ministers before the Act was repealed.
I just want the House to bear with me a few minutes on this because it is a good illustration of the irresponsible nature of charges that are made. The House will remember that before the Bill was introduced, long before it was discussed in this House, there had been numerous conferences in relation to the Bill, in relation to the repeal of the External Relations Act, with representatives of the British Government, of the Australian Government, of the New Zealand Government and of the Canadian Government and that the House was given a full account of these discussions when the Bill was introduced in this House and that while the Bill was in process of discussion in this House, while I was actually addressing the House, messages came from the Governments of Australia, New Zealand, Canada, India, South Africa, sending their best wishes and setting forth the future relationship which they hoped would subsist between this country and their country. What assumption then was Deputy Childers voting on? All that information was before him at the time but, of course, Deputy Childers, had forgotten his text, he had not prepared his proofs in detail or thought out his justifications now for voting for the Act. I notice also that apparently Deputy Childers does not approve of the all-Party committee which is known as the Mansion House Committee because I noticed that he referred to the unfortunate result—"unfortunate result" are his words— of the Mansion House Committee. But, as I have said, I believe that Deputy Childers is absolutely sincere in the attitude he has put forward to the House and that it does represent a viewpoint, but that it represents a viewpoint which is miles apart from the viewpoint held by most of the members of his Party. There is far more in common, might I say, between a Communist and a Conservative than there can be between the viewpoint held by Deputy Childers, and the viewpoint held by Deputy Dr. Maguire and some other members of the Fianna Fáil Party. I am quite certain that Deputy Childers would have the honesty to get up and say publicly that he disowns, disapproves of and condemns any suggestion that we should repudiate all our trade agreements with Great Britain, that we should break off diplomatic relations with Great Britain, or that we should march on the North immediately.
The Leader of the Opposition spoke last night in this House and I thought we might have the benefit of his views to-day again, because I am afraid that I failed in the course of his remarks to get any indication of his views. He just barely avoided saying: "I do not know whether you have done a good job or a bad job", but, short of saying that, that is the effect of his remarks. He agreed with me that it was extremely unwise economy to maintain a Department without providing it with adequate staff and funds to do its work, but he said it was essential that the Minister should be satisfied that the expenditure proposed was necessary. Surely Deputy de Valera did not believe that I introduced an Estimate to this House not having satisfied myself and, what is far more difficult, the watchdogs of the public purse, the Department of Finance, that the expenditure involved was necessary.
From beginning to end of this debate, there has not been one single, solitary word uttered from the Opposition Benches in criticism of any of the items in this Estimate—not one word. It has not been suggested that the additions to the staff in Washington were unnecessary or should not be made. It has not been suggested that the Press officer in New York was not necessary. It has not been suggested that there should not be an additional Vice-Consul in Chicago. It has not been suggested that there should not be a Vice-Consul in Boston. It has not been suggested that there should not be a Vice-Consul in San Francisco. It has not been suggested that there should not be a Press officer in London. Not one item has been questioned from beginning to end of this debate on the Estimate.
Comment on this
We asked what happened the policy of retrenchment. We did not believe in it; you did.
Comment on this
I will tell you what happened the policy of retrenchment. The policy of retrenchment was used for the purpose of providing money for services that were likely to benefit the nation, for the purpose of giving old age pensioners a pension on which they could live, for the purpose of building hospitals and providing a proper hospitalisation system.
Comment on this
And for the purpose of enabling me in this Department to do more than to avail of Partition as a war-cry when I felt it was necessary to have a war-cry during an election campaign here. There was no retrenchment on the part of this Government for the sake of retrenchment. Any retrenchment was to put an end to the squandermania of Deputy Lemass principally, to put an end to the spending of millions on Constellation aeroplanes, to the building of things like the new bus depot, to the building of a Parliament House that was to cost £11,500,000, to the paying of vast salaries and allowances to certain persons, to the building of luxury hotels that could not pay, to the buying of Argentine wheat at an excessive price the day before the change of Government.
I was accused yesterday in the course of the debate of having been weak in introducing the Bill for the Irish news agency, of having to introduce it weakly. It seems an extraordinary and regrettable thing that in this House, unless you hit out and attack your opponents, they think you are weak. If you make a reasoned statement, as I tried to make in introducing this Estimate, immediately you are attacked right, left and centre. This debate has hinged largely on the question of Partition. That is as it should be, because that is the main national objective that remains to be achieved by this nation. I wish it had been discussed in a more constructive way than it has been. I wish, too, that the Deputies on the opposite side of the House, no matter what the temptation may be from the Party point of view, and no matter how resentful they may be or how they may dislike me personally, had not availed of a discussion on Partition to try and make political capital out of it. Deputy de Valera, and a number of other Deputies, criticised me for saying that Partition was going to end very soon. I have no recollection of making that statement, and I ask the Deputy to produce it.
Comment on this
I did not make that statement in O'Connell Street. I can produce the typescript of the statement which I made in O'Connell Street.
Comment on this
All I did say was broadcast on a record. Of course, Deputy Lemass's tactics are these— and there is a good deal in them—if you are sufficiently unscrupulous say that a thing is black if it is white: it does not matter but keep on saying that it is black, then publish it in headlines the following day and in the following week he writes some article himself saying it is black.
Comment on this
On a point of information, the Minister says there is a record of that speech. Deputy Lemass's recollection and the Minister's recollection can be put to the test. Let the record be produced.
Comment on this
It is a point of information when there is so much bandying around that it is on record.
Comment on this
The Minister is entitled to proceed without interruption and every Deputy should know that.
Comment on this
I might have said that, given the necessary unity in support of the Irish people, it would be possible to end Partition much sooner than might be thought. Let me say this, that I would much prefer to see members of the Government or Deputies in this House say that Partition was going to be ended next week than remain silent as the Party opposite have remained silent about Partition for the last ten years or more.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the last Government. I say this that there was not one single officer in the Department of External Affairs whose sole responsibility it was to deal with Partition until I came into it.
Comment on this
I would like Deputies to throw their minds back to what the position was 18 months ago or more. How often did they hear any references to Partition from any members of the Government? Go to the files in the National Library or go to the files of the Irish Press and count the number of references to Partition made by Deputy de Valera in the previous 12 months, and compare them with those that have been made since they went out of office. The best proof of all is that Deputy de Valera was Minister for External Affairs and, until I took over, he had to do what I had to do this year and to do last year. He had to introduce his Estimates in this House. In the course of the introduction of his Estimates, he had to deal with the foreign policy of the State and with the various matters that have to be attended to by this Department. Let Deputies read the speeches made by Deputy de Valera in introducing his Estimate to this House, in 1947, the year before I took over, and they will find that the word “Partition” is not mentioned from beginning to end of that speech. Get the Dáil debates for 1947 and read them for yourselves.
Comment on this
Deputies on any side of the House should not interrupt while the Minister is making his statement. They had time enough to make their speeches and, surely, the Minister is entitled to conclude.
Comment on this
The references to facts that were made in the course of their speeches by the Leader of the Opposition and by his deputy, Deputy Lemass, were not even accurate. References were made to the expenditure of the Department. Deputy de Valera, as a former Minister for External Affairs, is quite familiar with the working of the Department. He knows perfectly well that the Department earns fairly considerable sums of money which should be set off against expenditure. That was not done. Deputy Lemass to-day suggested that expenditure on dollar imports in the first five months of the year had mounted up by several million pounds. The average dollar expenditure in the first five months of 1947 was £1,688,736 per month. The average dollar expenditure on imports in the first five months of 1948 was £1,047,542. In the first five months of this year the average monthly expenditure on dollar imports was £1,624,927 —less than in 1947. Again you see facts do not matter.
Comment on this
Cute—we will make it cute, if you like. Deputy Lemass to-day constituted himself the champion of the sterling areas, with a certain amount of reservation so as to be able to back out, if necessary. It is all right to be the champion of the sterling area so long as sterling remains all right, but in case sterling does not remain all right he wants to leave himself a way out, and he adopted his leader's phrase: "I am not saying whether it is a good thing or a bad thing."
Comment on this
I think the difficult position in which we find ourselves is due largely to the disastrous policy pursued by the last Government.
Comment on this
We have some £400,000,000 invested in Britain to-day. In terms of 1938 figures, each one of those £400,000,000 is worth only 11/5 to-day. If you take the purchasing power of £1 in 1914 and compare it with the purchasing power of £1 to-day, it is worth only 36 per cent. of its 1914 value.
Comment on this
I am glad Deputy Maguire finds another point on which there is a divergence of views in the Opposition.
Comment on this
I am glad to find that Deputy Maguire has an independent viewpoint on these matters. I think Deputy Maguire should come over to this side of the House.
Comment on this
If the Deputy likes to come over to this side of the House, I will welcome him with open arms. We will even take him into the Clann, if necessary. I do not think you should air your internal differences more than necessary. What you should do is to examine your internal differences and either form two different Parties or else have a general re-shuffle of cards in political life.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil started off in its young days calling itself Fianna Fáil. Then it was Fianna Fáil, the Republican Party, and that was written underneath it without brackets. Then again it was the Fianna Fáil Party with "Republican Party" in brackets. Where are we now? Has it the brackets or has it not? Is it still the Republican Party or is it not?
Comment on this
I would like to know whether there is any possibility that the Fianna Fáil Party, the Opposition, could reach an agreed policy on the question of Partition. I think they should discuss it seriously amongst themselves so that there could be some form of constructive policy put forward from the Opposition side.
Deputy Mrs. Rice, in the course of her remarks, asked me whether I had any guarantee, or whether there was even any likelihood, that any news sent out by the Irish news agency would be published by American papers. When I was in the United States last I met a great many newspaper proprietors and editors. In particular, I was invited to attend a conference of newspaper editors and proprietors in Massachusetts, representing the whole newspaper world of the area. I discussed this proposal with them. They suggested and emphasised the urgent necessity of having such a news agency. I likewise discussed this very question with newspaper proprietors in Chicago, San Francisco and New York. I had this in mind at the time and I discussed it very fully with people in the newspaper world throughout the United States and also with the Irish-American societies that have been doing so much work unselfishly and untiringly on behalf of Ireland, and it is largely as a result of these discussions that this proposal comes before the House.
References have been made to the possibility that the coming into operation of the Republic of Ireland Act should have deluded the people of different countries into the belief that Ireland was now united and had achieved her national objective. There was that possibility and I took measures to anticipate that possibility and I think those measures were effective. I think, on the contrary, instead of that being the case, that we received far more publicity on the coming into operation of the Republic of Ireland Act——
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I remind you that when Deputies from this side of the House were referring to this very matter, the Minister protested and got a ruling from the Chair that it was out of order in this debate?
Comment on this
There was a point raised by Deputy Mrs. Rice on that which I took down at the time and I am merely giving a reply. The fact that Ireland was partitioned and still had to bring about unity was one of the points emphasised in most of the American Press. On the 18th April I happened to be in Chicago and all the Chicago newspapers published maps illustrating the partition of our country.
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I ask the Minister how he reconciles this statement with the message sent by the Taoiseach to Canada on the occasion of the repeal of the External Relations Act?
Comment on this
On a point of order. When a Deputy raises something he calls a point of order which is not a point of order, surely it should be regarded as obstruction.
Comment on this
Many of the Deputies, some generally and others with their tongues in their cheeks, sought to suggest that the repeal of the External Relations Act was directly responsible for the deterioration in trade and in our relationship with Great Britain. That, of course, is not in accordance with the facts as we know them. Firstly, there has been no deterioration in trade. On the contrary, our trade has been improving. Dr. Maguire wanted us to repudiate the trade agreements we have and to stop selling anything to Britain.
Comment on this
You proposed the repudiation of trade agreements with Britain. It was suggested by some Deputies directly, and by others inferentially, that we should not have repealed the External Relations Act because of these possible consequences. Certainly, I think that was the general purpose of Deputy Derrig's remarks. Yet, in the Irish Press on the 21st October, 1948, Deputy Lemass said that the consequences of the repeal of the External Relations Act on British-Irish relations, whether in regard to trade or other matters, were of less importance than would be the consequences of a reversal or of a postponement of a decision to repeal the Act because of British pressure.
Is it suggested then that we should have yielded to British pressure of any kind? If Deputies will throw their minds back to that period they will remember that the next line was to suggest that the repeal of the External Relations Act was a blind to cover a new treaty, to cover a new attempt to sell out the country, and that the country should be watchful of the dangerous things that were being pleaded in order to tie this country more firmly into the Commonwealth than it has ever been before.
Comment on this
Deputy Childers, and most of the other Deputies who spoke, dealt with what they referred to as the blunder that was made and the deterioration in our relationship with Britain; and they ascribed that to the repeal of the External Relations Act. We were told by Deputy Major de Valera in the Irish Press of the 25th October last, in referring to the External Relations Act: “It is now going to go and would probably have gone in any event.” But then, of course, a note of warning had to be sounded. We are told: “The appearance of a Fine Gael Minister alongside the Minister for External Affairs at a crucial stage is somewhat disturbing.”
Then Deputy Boland comes along in the Irish Press of the 28th October, 1948, under the heading as to what would take place if the Act were repealed and says: “They should tell what was to take the place of the External Relations Act which would bind us more closely to the Commonwealth. That question was causing great concern and it should be answered clearly and at once.” Deputy Boland said that. But in this House, when the External Relations Act was going, he was the Deputy who shed crocodile tears about our being a member of the Commonwealth. Then Deputy Derrig, who to-day spent so much of his time and eloquence in suggesting that something had gone wrong in our relationship with Britain, said in Castlecomer as reported in the Irish Press on 1st November, 1948: “Apparently the severance of the last link, as Mr. Churchill had expressed it, was to be regarded as merely the prelude to some form of treaty or alliance between this country and the other states.”
We had a completely different line from Deputy MacEntee because he went off on his own. The first objective according to him, was to play into the hands of the communistic elements in the Coalition. Unfortunately that particular speech was reprinted on the American Continent and it was suggested that the repeal of the External Relations Act and the enactment of the Ireland Bill was a Communist measure.
Comment on this
They do not know Deputy MacEntee on the other side of the world. He may be famous in Dublin.
Comment on this
I am only dealing in general with the attitude of the Opposition to the whole question, which has been the main topic of the debate. The next thing we were told by Deputy MacEntee on the 20th November, 1948, was:
"This Bill will not repeal the External Relations Act because it contains a very peculiar clause, that it will not come into operation until the Government by Order so decrees. When Fianna Fáil put such a provision in a Bill it was clearly stated that the Order would be laid before both Houses of the Oireachtas."
However, time went on and on the 22nd November, the Leader of the Opposition in Manchester, as reported in the Irish Press, said that it appeared now that the majority of the people did not want that Act—the External Relations Act. I would ask the House to listen to the next words carefully:
"The Unionists in the Six Counties now said the repeal of the Act would destroy all hopes of unity, but though the same Act had existed for a long number of years it had made no difference to these people.
They had refused Dominion status when offered it, and what was the use now in pretending that the repeal of the Act made any difference?"
Is that not destructive of the argument in the speech made by the Deputy?
Comment on this
Oh, that was before the by-elections. Then in the Dáil, of course, Deputy de Valera told us that he had come to the conclusion some time ago that the External Relations Act should be repealed. In the Donegal by-election at Lifford on the 29th November Deputy de Valera said:—
"Do you not think it was a great joy to us to see some of those who opposed us coming out for a republic? Thank God, it is established as far as the Twenty-Six Counties are concerned."
Of course, we must not forget the West Cork by-election a little later on: "I did not know whether it was a good thing or a bad one." But in Donegal it was: "Thank God we have a Twenty-Six County Republic at last." I think it is unfortunate——
Comment on this
——that responsible members of the Opposition should not make an attempt to be more honest and sincere with the House and with themselves than they are.
Comment on this
The Minister fully appreciates, I hope, the consequences of the line he is now taking.
Comment on this
I take it, it is meant to be some form of intimidation. Questions have been asked by Deputy Lemass and by Deputy Cowan in relation to the meetings of the Ministerial Council of the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation. Deputy Cowan quite rightly said that it was good for Ministers to be criticised. I accept that and Deputy Cowan, therefore, will not mind if I criticise him a little bit now.
Comment on this
You had better clean up your own Party and settle your own little troubles. Some of them might do worse than join Deputy Cowan. I always supect a Deputy, or anybody indeed, who starts off his remarks by saying: "Well now, I do not want this to be interpreted as a personal attack." The minute I hear that I know it is going to be a personal attack.
Comment on this
All right, a personal attack. Before I make a personal attack or criticise the Deputy let me explain a little. The Deputy asked, and I think Deputy Lemass took the same line, why I attended the meetings of the Council of Organisation for European Economic Co-operation in Paris. They took the opportunity at the same time to say that I had no knowledge of economics or finance at all. I have no doubt that Deputy Cowan is an expert in the matter.
Comment on this
May I draw the Deputy's attention to the fact that I think, with the exception of two of the 19 Ministers present, they were all Ministers for Foreign Affairs and not Ministers for Finance? That had been the practice, as a matter of fact, until the second last meeting. Each country was represented by its Minister for Foreign Affairs and not by its Chancellor of the Exchequer or Minister for Finance. We, little Ireland, followed suit with the other countries.
Comment on this
You cannot have it both ways. You questioned my being there and now you say the Minister for Finance does not know everything about finance.
Comment on this
Very good. The position of Parliament generally in relation to the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation and to economic co-operation is this. The work involved brings in four Departments. It brings in the Department of Agriculture primarily, because they are very directly concerned in every respect. It brings in the Department of Industry and Commerce whose concern is on the industrial side and in commerce generally. It brings in the Department of Finance only so far as currency matters are involved. The work is done in Paris and in Washington through our missions there. All the work is centralised and co-ordinated in the Department of External Affairs by Government decision and it is carried out in that way. The Deputy next accused me of being a salesman.
Comment on this
A super-salesman for the United States of America. I was almost forgetting the accusation of being photographed with Mrs. Attlee's dog, but let us deal with this debate seriously. On the question of the foreign policy of this country, there is no country with which we have closer affiliations, either historically or by population relationship, than the United States of America, and in so far as I can influence the foreign policy of this State, it will be one of the utmost friendliness to the United States of America. I make no apology for that to Deputy Cowan or to Deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
The Deputy has frequently criticised America here and criticised my policy in relation to America. We owe a tremendous debt of gratitude to the American people for the help they have given us in the past. We owe a tremendous debt of gratitude to the American people for the financial and material assistance they are making available to us every day. I do not think it wise of Deputies to indulge in indiscriminate criticisms of Parliaments or of heads of States of other countries, as was done by one or two Deputies in the course of this debate. I think it would be better if criticism of that kind could be avoided.
Deputy Cowan told us that, instead of having visited America the last time, I should have gone over to London, have a talk with British Ministers and spend my time there talking with British Ministers instead of visiting our own American societies throughout the United States. I wonder how many questions I would have got from Deputy Cowan afterwards if I had done that? We got questions yesterday about my being photographed with Mrs. Attlee and her dog. If I had spent a fortnight talking to British Ministers, as he suggested, I should like to hear the comments which would be made by Deputy Cowan in the course of the debate to-night. I think that Deputy Cowan, who is really quite intelligent, should have a little more sense of proportion in dealing with me. He should remember that he has actually a bit of a prejudice against me and he should make allowance for that.
Coming back to deal with the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation, Deputy Lemass criticised a number of Press reports which he described as interviews. In point of fact, I have no recollection at the moment of any interviews save, possibly, one given to a French newspaper. I am not suggesting that somebody's reports did not represent the viewpoint held by me or expressed by me at the conference. Some of them, not all of them, definitely did not represent the viewpoint expressed by me, but I think Deputy Lemass is entitled to know the position in relation to the Ministerial Council Meeting in Paris that was held a few weeks ago. The only concrete proposal made there was made by your humble servant. The proposal made was that Monsieur Spaak, who was President of the Council, should nominate himself a very small committee, adjourn, try to settle the differences that existed between Belgium and Britain and report back to the council meeting. That proposal, strangely enough, was supported both by Belgium and by Britain. That is the only proposal that was actually made there.
I did express a criticism, not exactly a criticism but a viewpoint, when the conference was over. The House may recollect that the issues were connected with the intra-European payments scheme. Certain differences of views existed between Britain and Belgium and also to a lesser degree with the Economic Co-operation Administration representatives. I did express the viewpoint that that crisis was merely one of the symptoms of a much wider problem which should be examined and I circulated a summary of the points that I considered should be examined. I do not know if the House would like to have these now. There is nothing particularly secret about them and possibly it would be as well if I made them available to the House. The summary was as follows:—
The subject matters of the crisis on intra-European payments and on liberalisation of trade, were in my submission but symptoms of a far greater problem which should now be considered before another crisis arises.
The features of the situation which created the problem with which we had to deal, can be summarised as follows:
(a) Increased production in Europe without increased multilateral trading—or proper distribution.
(b) The tendency to rebuild autarchic economic systems, rather than the making of a determined effort to put into effective practice the concept of economic co-operation.
(c) Failure to examine our economic problems jointly with those of America.
It would be highly dangerous in this situation not to face these facts frankly. Unless we do, the whole concept, on which the Organisation of European Economic Co-operation is based, will be endangered. This would be disastrous and would weaken confidence in the ability of the democracies to achieve economic stability. Realities must be faced and a definite attempt made to secure a far closer degree of economic co-operation than we have yet achieved, not merely between the nations of Europe but also with the Western Hemisphere.
Paradoxically enough, it is the success of European recovery in the field of production which is now beginning to cause us difficulties. This merely emphasises a factor which was obvious at the beginning, namely, that increased production by itself, unless accompanied by an integration of the European economy, proper distribution and the creation of fresh trade outlets, would lead to the likelihood of renewed economic conflicts within Europe itself as well as with the U.S.A.
It was this danger that made some of us here so repeatedly urge on the council the need for closer planning and co-operation. We felt that this was urgent and should be done while the economy of Europe was rebuilding rather than await a situation when an internally conflicting economy had been rebuilt. Likewise, we were anxious that there should be a greater measure of co-operation between Europe and the big producing nations—the United States, Canada and Australia. The tendency instead was to concentrate on the division of the aid generously provided by the United States rather than to face the broader problems. I mention these matters, not by way of complaint, but rather in the hope that from now on, we may adopt a new approach.
In examining the present situation we must not minimise its seriousness. The factors which have caused the present crisis are not extraordinary. The rebuilding of German production, which is both desirable and inevitable, can only intensify the problem. The threatened depression in the United States cannot be ignored. It may reduce the earning capacity of European exports to the United States and increase the existing dollar deficit.
In a situation where the United States are themselves entering into a difficult period of economic adjustment it is questionable whether the pursuit of a policy which advocates that Europe should restrict her purchases from America still further or that the United States should continue—in effect—to subsidise the export of European goods to America is wise or practicable. The British proposition that "a solution to the problem can only be found in an expansion of earnings in the dollar area and in a reduction of imports from the dollar area" in the light of existing circumstances would appear to need review.
To pursue a policy of reduced consumption in the present situation would be merely to adopt the out-dated philosophy of a slump. With increasing production and falling prices in both Europe and America, the aim should be to expand consumption. The only alternative would be to reduce production, which would result in unemployment, higher prices and a fall in the standard of living.
Surplus production should never be considered a problem as long as people in any part of the world are underfed and living in subnormal conditions. Instead of advocating a policy of tightening of belts when surpluses are being produced, we should plan for the utilisation of the surplus production, for full employment and a higher standard of living.
We have succeeded in stepping up production. That is a good thing and an achievement in itself, for which we can congratulate the Economic Co-operation Administration and the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation. The problem now is to distribute the goods produced. The only obstacle is the mechanism of exchange and distribution. Is it not time that we adopted a wider approach to this problem? Unless we do so, we will again reach a stage where essential goods will be destroyed, instead of being made available to those who need them and to areas of want.
In the final analysis, the purpose of money is merely to facilitate the production and distribution of goods. Money in itself has no intrinsic value, save as a medium of exchange. One of our present problems is that money is failing in its purpose as an international medium of exchange.
In the light of rapidly changing circumstances, it is essential that we should review our policy and place more emphasis on the creation of a mechanism for the utilisation and distribution of "surplus" production.
The problem is one that cannot be dealt with on a purely regional basis. It is one that affects both America and Europe. If we try to deal with it on a purely regional basis (the European area, or the dollar area, or the sterling area), we will merely run the risk of economic conflict, and ultimately of failure.
In addition to an examination of these questions by the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation, therefore, I would suggest that there should be a joint conference between the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation and America on the widest policy basis possible. Such a conference might be able to give birth to an "American-European New Deal" and could examine the following questions:—
(a) The utilisation of "surplus" European and American production.
(b) The development of the underdeveloped areas of the world by means of these surpluses.
(c) The creation of an investment mechanism for the foregoing purposes which will assure the expansion of trade on a multilateral basis.
Indeed, I think that, in addition, the possibility of providing an international exchange medium aimed at assisting distribution should at least be considered.
Such a conference might enable the development of underdeveloped areas in accordance with President Truman's "Fourth Point" by availing of European productive capacity. In this manner an outlet could be found for increased production without contracting American-European trade.
If such a proposal finds favour with the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation and with the American authorities I would suggest that a conference be summoned as soon as possible. It should be fully representative of the different points of view of the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation. The possibility of including at such a conference representatives of great producing nations such as Australia, New Zealand, South Africa and Canada should also be envisaged.
Recent events have fundamentally altered the assumptions on which we have been working. We must, therefore, be prepared to devise measures to cope with the new situation in conjunction with the United States. For this purpose some such conference appears to be essential.
That is a copy of the actual proposals which we circulated and I think that on reflection Deputies on the opposite side of the House will appreciate the seriousness of the problem that confronts not merely us, not merely the sterling area, but the world and Europe in particular. Basically the difficulty is that Europe has never balanced her trade with the United States. She was in a position before the war to pay the deficit by various means such as investments, shipping, insurance and so on. She is no longer in possession of this income wherewith to pay the deficit. American production has increased considerably; European production is now reaching or surpassing even its pre-war level; the problem now is the question of devising a means of exchange and distribution of goods which are produced both in America and Europe. Otherwise, unless this is done and unless this is faced up to, you are going to have a slump both in the United States and in Europe and we will suffer because we cannot hope to avoid the effect of any major world depression. We may be possibly better insulated against it than highly industrialised countries, but we are bound to suffer and suffer fairly acutely. Of course we are interested in sterling; of course it is our interest to maintain sterling and maintain it in sound condition. We have some £400,000,000 invested there. It may be said that the investing of £400,000,000 in the one bank was an unwise and disastrous policy pursued by the last Government.
Comment on this
Was there any alternative? Do you know anything at all about it? What else could have been done?
Comment on this
I know considerably more than the Deputy who signed an agreement the day before the change of Government to buy Argentine wheat at a time when everybody knew the price of wheat was going to go down.
Comment on this
And fed our people, when you wanted to cut the ration. I am glad I did it and I did not do it before the change of Government. I was perfectly justified.
Comment on this
The night before the change of Government, he did it, but again he says it is black in spite of the fact that it is proved to be white.
Comment on this
Why did the Minister for Finance invest another £4,000,000 in sterling since he came in?
Comment on this
It would have been done long ago, if it could have been done. Can I take that as an authoritative statement of Fianna Fáil policy on the matter—that it is their policy to cut the link with sterling?
Comment on this
After Deputy Kennedy, there was never a greater expert on finance that Deputy Killilea.
Comment on this
Deputies should learn something about order. There will possibly, I understand, be a vote.
Comment on this
Deputy Derrig quoted at some length extracts from a letter published in the Press on 27th January, 1948, and written by me. He quoted various pieces of it. I should like to read the whole letter, but I am afraid it might be tedious for the House at this hour, so I will limit myself to reading one or two portions which the Deputy omitted to read and which I think have some relevance. The Deputy said that in that letter there was no reference to Partition. The second paragraph of the letter states:
"The ultimate aim of Clann na Poblachta is to reintegrate the 32 Counties as one national entity. Everyone, I think, agrees that this is desirable. The only problem is how it is to be achieved.
In passing, however, I should like to take this opportunity of dealing with whispered suggestions that Clann na Poblachta contemplates ‘marching on the Border' or pursuing some such means in an attempt to end Partition."
Comment on this
That letter continues:—
"Such suggestions are completely devoid of any foundation; on the contrary, we look upon Partition as being now largely an economic problem. One of the realities we have to face is that, unless and until we establish economic conditions and social services here that will be at least as attractive as those that prevail in the Six Counties, we cannot hope to arouse real enthusiasm for the ending of Partition, even amongst the Nationalist population of the Six Counties. We have no intention of utilising Partition as a catch-cry—we must face the hard facts."
That is a letter written before the general election. Deputy Cowan, I think, suggested that I and some other Deputies has been elected on a policy of marching on the Border. We were elected on the policy set out in that letter, or at least there was no concealing what our policy was, and I merely quote that to repudiate the suggestion by Deputy Derrig that there was no mention then of Partition, or of what our policy was. I think I have dealt with most of the questions raised in the course of the debate. I would again like to make an appeal——
Comment on this
——to the Opposition Deputies. I know that it is quite useless to appeal to Deputy Lemass because I am afraid he is too hardened and too unscrupulous in his methods to be capable of reform at this stage.
Comment on this
I know, however, that there are other Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party who are honest and sincere. We may disagree with their views and we may disagree on various matters of detail and of application, but at least I would appeal to them to realise that the strength of this nation can only lie in unity, that the policy of Britain, of those who have conquered this nation, of those who have divided this nation in two, has always been to divide and conquer. On that, as relating to Partition, on that, as relating to external policy, where there is no difference between the Parties, we should work together and co-operate.
Comment on this
I know that the Deputy wants to inject the greatest amount of bitterness he can into public life——
Comment on this
——and he has given ample evidence of wanting to do that. I know that it is useless to appeal to him, but I am entitled to appeal to the other members of his Party who are not as maliciously minded as he is, and, if I cannot appeal to the members of his Party, I can at least appeal to the people who have hitherto genuinely supported them in the belief that they were a national Party.
Comment on this
I know that the Deputy does not like to hear that. I know that he realises that the Party he is in is split and that he considers that his only chance is to launch personal attacks on me and that he intends to pursue that policy.
Comment on this
Nevertheless, I will continue to appeal to the more honest and sincere members of Fianna Fáil to try sometimes to place the country and national unity above their own Party interests, their own personal interests or their own personal hatreds or dislikes.
Comment on this
Might I ask a question with the Minister's permission? As one of those on whom the Minister commented as referring possibly in disparaging terms to United States assistance to this country, may I ask if he considers I was justified in my remarks, in view of the statement recently issued by the State Department of a country which is the supposed champion of freedom and democracy?
Comment on this
Question—"That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration"— put.
Do you agree with this result?