Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach.
Contributions 1–197 of 414. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That a sum not exceeding £14,450 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending the 31st day of March, 1950, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Department of the Taoiseach (No. 16 of 1924; No. 40 of 1937; No. 38 of 1938; and No. 24 of 1947).
For some months now we have been discussing in great detail, but not at unreasonable length, the various workings of Government policy in connection with finance, social services and general economic matters. This Estimates traditionally provides an opportunity for discussing general Government policy. Each year there has been a difficulty in ascertaining the precise scope of a debate on that particular topic. If I might put it this way: we have been discussing the details of the picture and this Estimate now gives us an opportunity to stand back, look at the picture as a whole and see the underlying structure and the principles underlining the details which comprise the entire picture. Perhaps I might help Deputies this year by departing from the usual procedure. It has been the general practice of the Taoiseach, so to speak, merely to throw in the ball and let the various Deputies worry the ball and throw it back and forward and, finally, the Taoiseach wound up on the various matters mentioned.
I propose to give some general indication of the principles underlying Government policy which may possibly give a line to those Deputies who are, perhaps, a little bit doubtful as to the kind of matters which may be discussed on this Estimate. At the very outset I want to refer to a change of a rather significant character which has been made in the course of the year in my Department, because it is something of significance in the direction of general Government policy and the outlook of the Government on policy as a whole. There has been created, by administrative Order of the Government, a new office attached to the office of the Taoiseach, a new central statistics office, which forms part now of the Department of the Taoiseach. That decision was come to because of the fact that the Government in framing, designing and endeavouring to carry out their policy, found that, by reason of the greatly extended scope of the responsibility of Government under modern conditions, it was difficult, if not impossible, properly to frame general policy and carry it out without up-to-date statistical data and information. By reason of the complex nature of the compilation of statistics, by reason of the fact that we have not had any up-to-date estimate of national income, we were quite unable to follow the general trend of policy in its working out, and, in order properly to chart the course of Government policy, it was necessary that there should be an office charged with the responsibility for producing an up-to-date, timely, full range of official statistics.
It has been stated that the best indicator of the economic health of the country is the level of its national income. There has been no really official compilation of estimates of national income since the year 1946. To use a phrase employed recently by a distinguished Irish economist, those people who are considering economic policy and the trends of trade, investment and national income are really working, as he put it, in the shadow of a somewhat considerable statistical darkness which has rested on our affairs since the White Paper on National Income and Expenditure for the years 1938 to 1944 was made available in 1946. We desire to dispel that darkness. We wish to have a modern, scientific compilation of the national income so that we could have from time to time the best possible information as to the trend of our economic life, the nature of our economic health. We felt that, although it was natural that the Statistical Office as it has existed up to this should have emanated originally from or found its birth in the Department of Industry and Commerce, yet that up-to-date, timely statistics were of such vital importance in modern conditions and the subject matters to be handled by such a Department were so complex that it required a separate office with considerable independence of every Department, which would be an organ of the Government as a whole, to deal with the compilation of official statistics and particularly estimates and statistics relating to the national income.
Accordingly, we have set up this new office attached to my Department, to underline its independence, to emphasise the importance which we attach to this work and to give the office real freedom and scope for the compilation of those statistics which are of such vital importance to those people who are charged with the conception, design and carrying out of Government policy.
The first time and, indeed, the only time when any really authoritative estimates of national income were published was the occasion of the publication of the White Paper which was published in the year 1946. The preparation of such a document as that involved a high degree of competence on the part of the compilers. Prior to that we had unofficial estimates of the national income. Professor Dunean had prepared for the Banking Commission an estimate of the national income for the year 1929 and Dr. Kieran, in the Economic Journal of March, 1933, had prepared an estimate of the national income for the year 1926. Various people interested in and qualified to write upon such matters contributed papers to the Statistical Society of Ireland, which has done so much useful work, and that work really provided the background and the groundwork of the work that was done officially by the publication of this White Paper in 1946. There has been no White Paper on the national income since that time. We felt that it was vitally important that there should be, at the earliest possible moment, such a White Paper produced.
We have given this new office a status and an independence of other Departments or of any particular Department which, we believe, will give them freedom to do the work that is required to be done and which requires to be done urgently and in a very timely manner.
Since the Statistical Branch of the Irish Government Service was set up, the reputation of Irish statistics has stood high nationally and internationally. We are fortunate in having had as directors of that office men of ability who have won fame for themselves and for their country in their particular scientific calling. We are fortunate in having a director at present who himself is outstanding in his profession. We were fortunate also in securing the services of a professor of University College, Cork, who gave up his Chair to become Deputy Director of the Statistical Office. In addition, through the medium of the Civil Service Commission, we have secured four young people, three men and a lady, who are highly qualified in statistics and the science of statistics, mathematics and economics, who have joined the Government service in this new office and we are again indebted to the generosity of the United States through the funds that they have placed at the disposal of nations wishing to avail themselves of their service. At least two of these four new statisticians who have joined the Irish service will be given the benefit of training at the expense of the United States Treasury in the United States of America.
The office will be charged with compiling every type of statistical information, while, of course, its primary and possibly its most important function and its most urgent task will be the compilation of figures of national income and expenditure. The office will have the surveillance of any statistics that may be left with particular Departments to prepare themselves, but generally it will be the duty of this office to compile all Government statistics and where the office does not undertake that duty the director and the staff will have the right to direct and survey all statistics that are prepared by any particular Department.
An inter-departmental committee will be appointed to co-ordinate the statistical work of administrative Departments and it is intended that for the purpose of giving advice on statistical matters a statistical council will be set up under the Statistics Act of 1926.
I mention these matters although the Minister for Finance gave an outline of the reasons for this new Department when he introduced the Estimate for the office some few weeks ago. We hope that with the foundation of this branch of my Department we will have available to all Departments and to all Deputies and to all economists really up-to-date information on the statistical developments of this country. I have emphasised the desirability of getting an up-to-date survey and estimate of national income and expenditure, because I think it will be agreed that the aim of all Government financial and economic policy must be to increase the national wealth. How far the efforts of a Government are succeeding in doing that, to what extent it can be seen whether or not a Government is in its policy travelling along the right lines, can only be determined by reference to official statistics of national income prepared in a scientific, up-to-date manner. We have, therefore, set out, as the fundamental basis of our Government policy, to increase the national wealth. All our financial policy, all our economic policy is directed to that end.
Every Deputy knows the demands that are being made, and that are increasingly being made upon the Government for bounties and for services of one sort or another. Everybody knows, or should realise that these demands of necessity result in increased expenditure by the State. Everybody must realise the necessity for keeping down taxation and the burden of taxation on the people. In existing circumstances, that burden is far too great.
If we are to do what is required to be done, and even the minimum of these requirements, we must increase the national wealth of the country if we are to avoid a crippling burden of taxation on the people. By increasing the national wealth, increased revenue can be secured without increased taxation. I should interpolate here for the benefit of Deputies who, perhaps, do not realise it, that the burden of taxation, of high taxation, enters very largely into the cost of living. Deputy Cowan has referred to the fact that he intends to raise the cost of living on this Estimate. I would direct his attention, when considering that aspect of Government policy, to ponder upon that aspect, which is very often forgotten, that high taxation enters very largely into the cost of living. If we can increase the national wealth, we can get more revenue without extra taxation; we can get more productive work and thereby save the State from the claims which are being made for unemployment insurance benefit and for all the social services that, of necessity, a modern State must maintain.
So far as our financial policy is concerned, it has been stated and restated. It is not necessary for me to underline it again. We wish to keep down high taxation; we wish to curtail, so far as is reasonably possible, Governmental expenditure. Our general policy on that has been stated—to save public moneys that might be spent better and more productively. A little over 12 months ago, on the 26th May of last year, I addressed the Dublin Chamber of Commerce on certain aspects of the problems that appeared to us at that time to be awaiting solution by the Government. I stated, in the course of that speech to the chamber of commerce, as follows:—
"The two main long term economic problems confronting this country are the necessity for greatly increased agricultural and industrial output, and the rectification of the unhealthy condition of our balance of international payments. The first of these problems is the more important. If we can solve it, we will have gone a long way towards improving the balance of payments position as well."
In other words, it appeared to us at that time that we were not producing enough or selling enough, and that we were buying too much, and that Government policy had to be directed in order to increase the national wealth of the country, to secure conditions within it to increase agricultural and industrial production so that greater productive employment would be obtained, the adverse balance of trade rectified, improved social conditions obtained, and the highest possible level of prosperity for all sections of our people.
I can assure the House that that was the headline we set ourselves 12 months ago. I think we can claim that, with that headline before us, we have made, at least, some substantial progress towards solving those two problems to which I adverted over 12 months ago. We set ourselves out to increase agricultural and industrial output. We had not at that time, nor have we even yet, recovered in this country from the impact of the war upon us. We are still depending, to a very considerable extent, on the success of the efforts that are being made in Europe and elsewhere throughout the world, to restore the disequilibrium of international trade and give some sort of stability in particular to European economic conditions. We can only do a certain amount towards helping the recovery of European economy, and because we cannot escape in this country the effects of the disruption that came upon European economy as the result of the war and in consequence of the peace following the war, we have given throughout the last 12 or 16 months that we have been in office, every possible assistance that we could towards the amelioration of European economic conditions and to the success of the United States European Recovery Programme.
We cannot, even though we are isolated to a certain extent from Europe, hope to escape the effects of the economic disturbances in Europe or even further afield, but there are certain things that we have within our own power, and with our own materials we set ourselves out to increase the capital value of our own economy and to create conditions within which industrial and agricultural production could be achieved and our balance of payments position ameliorated.
Over the last 50 years there has been practically no opportunity for determining a long-term policy for the economic recovery of this country. Other countries have suffered from certain economic ills which have passed us by. There have been, perhaps, in England and other places, industrial fluctuations and normal unemployment: industrial fluctuations due to a falling off in the demands for particular commodities or unemployment because of a falling off in the demand for a variety of products. That is not our problem here. Our economy has been relatively unproductive and relatively under-invested. We have to face the fact that we have an economy which has a great potential source of wealth for the people and which has not yet really been developed in the way that it should have been. Our economy has suffered from what has been described as chronic under-investment. We have had the position here in years gone by where we have had resources available to us for the development of our own economy, and those resources in land, in labour and in capital have been left idle here at home or else have been exported abroad: a position where Irish labour and Irish capital have been used for the development of countries other than our own. Our policy generally in that respect has been a policy of constructive development of our own economy. People have invested their moneys abroad and men have gone to work for other peoples abroad. In connection with our land, which is the real source of the wealth of this country, and in connection with our agricultural industry, it is in those respects that our most valuable resources have remained completely idle and unemployed.
We have been suffering from a condition which has been described by economists as under-employment, a condition in which labour, capital and land have been either not used at all, or not used in such a way or in such a combination as will increase the national wealth. We have set ourselves out to see that all our resources, so far as possible, are invested in this country, both labour and capital, and that the land, which is the greatest source of our potential wealth, will get a chance it has never got before. We believe that large-scale investments of our own moneys will produce better dividends for the Irish people, if invested in the land of Ireland, than if invested anywhere else. Even before the war years, even before the impact of the war on our agricultural economy, agricultural output was stationary and it is merely a truism of Irish economics to say that everybody in this country, directly or indirectly, relies for his prosperity upon a prosperous agricultural industry.
Accordingly, to deal with the situation of under-investment that is such an outstanding feature of our economy in connection with our land and our agricultural industry, we have decided to invest the greatest amount of money available to us in increasing the fertility of the land and developing the land as our best source of potential wealth. In doing so, we were not concerned at all with increasing the wealth or the prosperity of any individual farmer. The whole purpose was to develop the agricultural industry by means of the investment of Irish capital to increase the fertility of the land, so that our national income might be increased and general prosperity produced throughout the country, productive employment given to our people and this greatest national asset of ours, the land of Ireland, developed to the fullest possible extent.
We have debated here on a number of occasions the policy underlying the land reclamation scheme of the Minister for Agriculture. I do not intend to develop that any further than has already been done. I mention it for the purpose of showing that that scheme is perhaps the outstanding example of the Government policy of constructive investment in our own economy, an investment designed to increase the national wealth, to increase agricultural products for export, to increase the productivity of the land and to give genuine productive employment to our people on the land and, through prosperous conditions on the land, to our industrial workers.
Through the operation of the trade agreement which was negotiated and signed last year between this country and Great Britain, we have brought stable conditions to the agricultural industry, and in the course of the various debates on different agricultural topics that have taken place here within the last few months, it has been demonstrated that our agricultural production has increased to a satisfactory extent.
We rely upon an increase in our agricultural production, upon the export of our surplus agricultural products, to a very large extent to meet the second problem to which I referred and which I quoted to the Chamber of Commerce last year, namely, the rectification of our balance of payments. I hope in a few moments to refer to what has been achieved in that respect. So far as that very serious position has been tackled and, to some extent, if not solved, at least put into the course of solution, it has been due to the improvement in our agricultural industry and to the increase in our agricultural exports. While that is the general policy for agriculture, and while we assert it as our fundamental policy, because more than half of our people are employed on the land, and because nearly everybody in Ireland depends directly or indirectly for his well-being on a prosperous agriculture, we have directed all our efforts primarily to creating the conditions whereby a prosperous agricultural industry can be achieved and a greatly increased productivity in agricultural products secured.
We recognise that there must be a balanced economy in our country, and I think we are entitled to claim that we have, in the course of the last 12 months, achieved something towards the development of industrial employment and our manufacturing industries as a whole. We have, as Deputies are aware, given an indication of general Government policy in reference to our secondary industries by the setting up of the Industrial Development Authority. That authority is at present functioning and it will be given statutory form and effect if and when the Bill which has been introduced into this House is passed into law. The main purpose of that is to see that we have our manufacturing industries built up in a coherent, co-ordinated fashion; that that is not done merely in a patchwork way; that new industries will be fostered and given every possible encouragement, and that the development of Irish industry will be upon a coherent, welldirected, well-ordered line; that if one industry is protected or given certain advantages, that those advantages or that protection will not be given at the expense of other industries, and that the impact of all manufacturing industries on our agricultural industry, when they are producing the goods we expect them to produce, will also be carefully watched and the inter-action of Irish industry and our agricultural industry will be watched and safe-guarded.
I have stated that we have succeeded in increasing greatly our agricultural production, thereby helping towards the rectification of our balance of payments. We have also been able to show during the past year a steady improvement in industrial activity, industrial productivity and industrial employment. May I give a few figures to emphasise and underline these matters? As regards industrial employment, in the year 1938 there were 166,000 people employed in Irish industry; in the year 1947 there were 177,000 people employed; in 1948 there were 184,000 people employed, so that within the last year 7,000 additional people were employed compared with the year before. That is the position as regards people put into employment in Irish industry. There was a 4 per cent. increase on 1947 and an 11 per cent. increase over the year 1938. The year that has just ended was a year in which the highest level of industrial employment in the history of this State was achieved.
So far as industrial protection is concerned, the figures are equally revealing and satisfactory. In 1948 the volume of production for all industries was 16 per cent. above the 1947 volume. It was 28 per cent., above the 1938 volume. Since February of last year the Minister for Industry and Commerce has approved 104 new industrial projects, in 24 of which production has already begun. There are 77 proposals for new industries in process of advancement towards completion.
The year 1948, in addition to being a year where the highest level of industrial employment in the history of the State was achieved, was also the year in which the highest level of industrial production was achieved. That year was remarkable, too, for the increase in our export trade. Deputies are aware of the difficulties that had arisen in connection with the interpretation of one of the clauses in the trade agreement entered into between Great Britain and this country in the year 1938. In the year 1938 our industrial exports were of the value or order of 2.1 millions. In 1947 they were of the order of 6.2 millions. In 1948—that is last year—they were 8.2 millions. During last year, in addition to achieving a record in industrial employment and industrial production, our exports of Irish manufacturing products increased by £2,000,000 on the figures for 1947, a 32 per cent. increase on those figures, and increased by 6.1 million, or 290 per cent., on 1938 figures. I think, therefore, that we are entitled to claim credit that we have gone at least a considerable way towards the solution of the first of those two problems to which I adverted in May of last year when I addressed the Dublin Chamber of Commerce.
We have greatly increased agricultural and industrial output. When I said that we were able to solve the first of those problems, the second of our problems—the rectification of our balance of payments—will follow as a matter of course. I think we are entitled to say that in the 12 months following on that speech we have made considerable progress in solving those problems. While I say that we have made considerable progress in solving those problems, I do not wish it to be stated that we are merely asserting these matters in a mood of smug complacency. We are fully alive to the difficulties that still confront this country. We are quite keenly appreciative of the problems we still have to tackle and to solve. But we are, at least, entitled to say that at the end of this 12 months progress has been made and we appear to be on the right lines so far as our agricultural, industrial and financial policy is concerned.
The balance of payments position, which was the second problem to which I adverted last year, shows a trend that, while we cannot again regard it with smug complacency, is at least satisfactory in its general direction. We had last year when we came into office a condition in which the unfavourable balance of trade had reached rather extraordinary heights. It is, perhaps, right that it should be mentioned and appreciated that the high excess of our imports over our exports in the year 1947 was probably due to the necessity for stocking-up following upon the decline in imports during the war years.
The figures which I would like the House to consider in connection with our balance of payments and our balance of trade are as follows: For the year 1947 our exports were £39,500,000; our imports were £131,300,000; for that year on the balance of imports and exports there was a deficit of £91,800,000. As against that, crediting ourselves with invisible items, the balance of invisible items amounted to a figure of £62,000,000 approximately; so that, taking our exports, our imports and our invisible items into account for the year 1947, the unfavourable balance against us was a sum of £29,800,000. In the year 1948 our exports were £47,500,000, an increase of £8,000,000. Our imports were £136,700,000, an increase of something over £5,000,000. Now, our adverse balance of trade on these two figures of exports and imports amounted to £89,200,000. As against that we had to take credit for the invisible items of a figure of £74,000,000, leaving our unfavourable balance last year at £15,200,000. Therefore, during last year we had reduced our unfavourable balance of payments from a figure of £29,800,000 to £15,200,000, leaving a reduction of £14,600,000.
We endeavoured to check the trend as revealed by those figures by reference to the figures available during the first five months of this year as compared with the first five months of the year 1947. For the first five months of the year 1947, from January to May, the export figure was £13,000,000 and the import £40.82 million, leaving an unfavourable balance for those five months of £27.82 millions. For the first five months of 1948 our exports were £17.05 million and our imports were £63.91 million, leaving an adverse balance for those five months of 1948 of £46.86 million. For the year 1949 the exports for the first five months were £22.70 million; in 1947 the figure was £13,000,000; in 1948 £17.05 million and for the first five months of this year our exports were, as I have said, £22.70 million, an increase of £5,000,000 over the first five months of last year. Our imports during the corresponding period were: in 1947, £40.82 million, leaving for the first five months of that year an unfavourable balance of £27.82 million; for the year 1948 the imports were £63.91 million, leaving an unfavourable balance of £46.86 million; for the first five months of this year our imports were £53.81 million, leaving an unfavourable balance of £31.11 million. For the first five months of this year the unfavourable balance of trade has been reduced by £15.75 million as compared with the first five months of last year. In the first five months of this year the total exports were increased by £5.65 million and the total imports were reduced by £10.10 million as compared with the first five months of 1948. I do not want Deputies to think that we place any more reliance on those figures than we ought to place on them. We are entitled to say this, that if the trend indicated by those figures continues, as we hope it will continue, during the next few months and the next few years, then we will have gone very far to lessen the gap between our imports and exports and our payments out and our payments in.
Deputies will have noticed that in those figures there is one item of very considerable importance. Hidden away in the item that is referred to as "invisible items" there is, of course, the amount of money that comes into this country through the tourist industry. We hope that American visitors will come here in increasing numbers. Our American tourist trade is one of the ways in which we can earn dollars which are so necessary for us to earn, by reason of the necessity for importing goods from hard currency areas. Many of our kith and kin are coming from America this year and we hope they will come in increasing numbers. Some of the American visitors merely regard the Shannon airport as the French call it, pied-á-terre—a spot where they can rest and refresh themselves before they pass on to the Continent or elsewhere. However, even those visitors can be made the source of the earning of much needed dollars for us. We have also had an influx of visitors from Scotland, England and Wales and we hope that that trend will continue this year.
Comment on this
The tourist trade from Great Britain, from America and other countries is one of the utmost importance to us. Our policy generally will be to foster and maintain that industry. Whatever our political differences may be with the Government in Great Britain, English people may be assured, as they have always been, of a good welcome in this country.
I have spoken on the general aspects of Government policy in connection with industrial productivity, increased agricultural productivity and the rectification of our balance of payments. I mentioned that underlying all that is a policy of constructive investment in our own economy, the realisation that the greatest asset we have in this country, the source of our potential wealth, the asset that is really relatively underdeveloped, is the land of Ireland. Our policy is directed towards increasing productivity and that work which will increase the well-being of all sections of our community, if the agricultural community increases in prosperity as it has done in the last 12 months.
After the land of Ireland, our Irish workers are the next most fruitful source of our wealth. We realise that and our policy, so far as increasing the national wealth is concerned, has been directed towards ensuring, so far as Government action can ensure it, that where work is provided for our workers it shall be of a character which is productive and which is not merely casual. The work that we shall give to our workers, who are one of the greatest sources of our wealth in this country, will be work which is productive in character and which adds to the wealth of the country. We have had frequent attacks and many complaints against the policy of the Department of Finance and the Minister for Finance for his parsimony in refusing money and the efforts of the Department to curb expenditure. So far as the present Minister for Finance is concerned, within reason, he has not refused and will not refuse money for productive work. We have had in this country for a long time the attitude that work or the provision of work for our people is an end in itself. That is not the policy that we have adopted or that we hope to bring to fruition. So far as Government policy can assure it, we are endeavouring to secure that Irish men and women will get, in their own country, decent work at decent wages and under good conditions and that the work that will be provided for them will not be merely casual but work of a productive character which will add to the dignity of the worker and the wealth of the nation. That is the general policy, so far as we are concerned, from the point of view of the provision of work for the unemployed here. Anything that can bring work to our unemployed people we will assist in every way, and endeavour to secure, so far as it lies within us, that that work will not be merely casual work, that it will not be a patchwork of emergency operations directed or carried on merely for the sake of giving work and palliating the emergency and not remedying it.
That policy of providing productive work and thereby increasing the wealth of the nation is the underlying principle of all Government policy. That policy is indicated by the high level of the capital expenditure which is provided in the Budget of this year. Most people regard the annual Budget which is introduced into this House as something which either imposes taxation or which they hope will decrease taxation. That portion of the Budget which deals with taxation, with the house-keeping element in our country's affairs, in fact, only brings within its scope something like one-fourth of the country's economic activity. That portion of the Budget is important in itself. You might refer to that portion as the Budget of expenses, the house-keeping portion. However, to get a comprehensive over-all picture of our national economy and activities you must look at the really important portion of the Budget which deals with the employment of public moneys, the capital schemes and capital expenditure. In this year's Budget the high level of capital issues indicates the extent to which our policy is being put into force, in the matter of providing work for the unemployed and those people who want work which will be of a productive character and which will add to the wealth of the country.
By means of the investment of this very large amount of money there can be no doubt that the national income of the country and the real wealth of the people will be increased. These figures have been given by the Minister for Finance on several occasions both in this House, in the Seanad and elsewhere. They have not yet, I think, been fully appreciated. For that reason I ask the leave of the House to refer to them very shortly so that the full amount of public moneys provided by the Government in pursuance of the Government policy to which I have adverted will be fully realised and appreciated. In the year 1946-47 about £2,000,000 was provided by the State for capital works. In 1947-48 that figure was raised to £5,000,000. In the year 1948-49, last year, the figure was something over £9,000,000. In the current year the State will, through the operation of the capital part of the Budget, if I may refer to it in that way, expend over £16,000,000 of public moneys, not including the moneys that will be spent on the land reclamation project. These moneys will be spent for the development of the telephone system, improved housing through the Local Loans Fund, for turf development, contributions to the Road Fund, for the development of electricity works, particularly rural electrification, and other works of that kind.
The expenditure of that large amount of money, over £16,000,000, not taking into account the moneys that will be spent either through the land reclamation scheme of the Minister for Agriculture or the Local Authorities (Works) Bill, must create work of a productive character. It will create assets for the community and will employ many of those persons at present unemployed. We have, as I have said, set out on a policy of productive employment, through the operation of the capital part of the Budget, through the capital moneys put at the disposal of these people for capital expenditure and the creation of new assets for the community. That money must be spent, as it is intended to be spent, on providing really productive work for our people. The scheme initiated and being put into operation by the Minister for Agriculture in connection with his land reclamation policy must give a very large amount of employment to the people. The Local Authorities (Works) Bill, which is now an Act, must also give employment to the people. I have already adverted to the increased figure of 7,000 people put into employment in this country in the last 12 months owing to increased industrial activity during that period. All this must indicate that the problem of unemployment is at least being tackled in a serious way and, if it is not in process of solution, at least serious efforts are being made to solve it in a serious way that will not be merely part of an unco-ordinated scheme of patchwork emergency works and funds.
I have given some sort of indication to the House of general Government policy, in so far as it concerns industry, agriculture and employment. So far as our political policy, our housing policy and our social policy are concerned, these have been dealt with in the course of the debates and discussions on the various Departmental topics relevant to these matters. But I should just like to mention one matter while we are speaking on the subject of unemployment. All these moneys will be spent throughout the country and must produce their effect on the unemployment problem. While we are providing these moneys for these various schemes in the hope that they will provide productive employment, create new assets for the community and increase national wealth, there is one matter that we must keep in mind. Again I insist that at the basis of Government policy is the development of agriculture. We must keep our agricultural workers producing and working on the land. While we are providing for rural unemployment schemes and while we are trying to get work in the cities through our manufacturing industries and other productive works financed through public moneys, we must always ensure that those who have been trained on the land, who have the tradition of the land, the agricultural workers who are really specialised workers, must not be invited or drawn away from the agricultural industry or from the necessity for producing more agricultural products which are so vitally necessary for the economy of this State.
I referred to a variety of these matters merely in passing. I have dealt with agriculture, industry and unemployment. These in a sense are material considerations, very vital and very important, but there is one other matter to which I wish to refer in conclusion. While we are concentrating on our material advancement, we should not, I think, neglect matters of the spirit. We should not neglect the effort to foster, and if necessary to create or recreate, a proper national tradition in art, and the necessity that there really is and the scope there is, for the application of art to industry, the revival of handcrafts and the old arts and crafts for which the Irish were so famous in years gone by. There is no money in this Estimate for the topic to which I am referring but as it is a matter of Government policy I think it is proper that I should refer to it here.
We have in this country great treasures of art. They are not sufficiently recognised or appreciated by our own people. We have in our own people here a people with an artistic tradition and artistic instincts. We have buildings which are architectural gems; we have architects who are trained here in this country and who can hold a place amongst any of the best architects in the world. We have lost, or nearly lost, the old crafts for which our people were famous in years gone by. We wish to revive these crafts and arts if we can. At all events we wish to encourage art and the application of art to industry. Accordingly, the Government has been fortunate in being able to secure the services of an outstanding personality to advise us and the people in these matters to which I have referred. We have engaged the services of an Irish-man who has won fame and distinction for himself and brought credit to his country, by his work in England as Professor of Fine Art in the Barber Institute in Birmingham—Professor Thomas Bodkin. We have through the courtesy of the Barber Institute been able to secure the services of Dr. Bodkin to advise us on certain aspects of our art, the application of art to industry and the development of the crafts generally, in connection with art development in Ireland. He has come here and I would ask any people who have any contribution to make towards a solution of his problems and the advancement of his labours to co-operate with him and assist him in every way they can. We have given him terms of reference to inquire into the condition of art in Ireland and have asked him to examine and report on the following matters:
1. Upon the constitution and working of institutions concerned with the arts in Ireland, in particular the National Museum and the National Gallery.
2. Upon the facilities available in Ireland for education in the arts both from the historical and from the practical aspects, at elementary to professional levels, with particular reference to the teaching of art and art history in the schools, the universities, the National College of Art and the provincial art schools.
3. Upon the existing relations between the arts and industry in Ireland, including such activities as technical training in craftsmanship, the provision of industrial designs and of appropriate advertisements for tourist development, and upon the steps that might be taken to arouse the public interest and the interest of manufacturing industries in the importance of design in industry.
4. Upon the advisability of establishing an organisation or organisations for the purpose of encouraging and spreading a knowledge of the arts in Ireland and of Irish culture in foreign countries.
5. Upon the advisability of establishing an organisation or organisations concerned with the preservation and acquisition by the State of sites and buildings of national importance and with the maintenance of aesthetic amenities in future building projects.
6. Upon the advisability or otherwise of extending such services as those referred to above and of co-ordinating their administration.
I feel that the inquiry is an essential one which will, when we have the report and are able to put the recommendations into practice, bring spiritual good and material advancement to this country. It will be inferred from the terms of reference that, not merely is there emphasis upon the cultural aspect of art and architecture, but that there are references to very essential and very important aspects of art in industry and the development of craftsmanship. If we can get proper designs for our industrial products, we can develop a tradition of art and a practice of craft amongst our people. It may be that along those lines we may find employment of a useful character for the people upon the western seaboard and in districts in the country where our people are living upon a bare subsistence level. Therefore this inquiry has both a spiritual and material aspect and is one which the Government were well advised to embark upon. I would ask the co-operation of all interested in it to assist Dr. Bodkin in his inquiry and in his work.
Comment on this
I move that the Estimate be referred back for re-consideration. The Taoiseach would probably regard it as discourteous if I were to suggest that his knowledge of the elementary principles of national economic policy was acquired within the past year or year and a half. If, however, we have, in courtesy, to assume that it is of longer standing than that, I can only say that we would never have suspected it. The philosopher Carlyle stated that it is one of the greatest tragedies of life when a man who is capable of knowledge dies in ignorance. I am glad that the Taoiseach has been spared that fate. If we can associate with his present knowledge of the principles of sound economic policy an enthusiasm for their practical application, then I think we will be able to feel that the long weary hours which we spent in the past trying to lead his Party along that road will have been rewarded. When, however, he was recounting the improvements which have taken place in the productivity of agriculture and industry and in the volume of our exports, I think he might in fairness have added that between 1947 and 1949 the world passed from the scarcities and difficulties of war time to the plenitude of peace.
In examining these figures one is far less impressed by the expansion that has occurred than appalled by its smallness. During the years of the war, during the period of difficulty, when a contraction of all economic activities was made inevitable by international conditions, we looked forward to the post-war years, to 1948 and 1949, when supplies difficulties, fuel difficulties and transport difficulties would all have passed, and planned and hoped to secure in those years an enormous expansion in the level of productivity maintained with difficulty during the war, an enormous expansion in the economic activity of our people and in the employment available here for them. If we have not got, and the figures show that we have not got, in those years results commensurate with the alteration in conditions, can we suggest that it may be due to the fact that many of the Taoiseach's colleagues have not yet acquired a sound knowledge of the elementary principles of economic policy which he has just enunciated?
I am proposing to the Dáil that they refer back the Taoiseach's Estimate for reconsideration and I am asking the Dáil to do that as an indication of disapproval of the manner in which the Taoiseach has discharged his functions during the past year. I do not propose to discuss the Taoiseach's functions as head of a small Department, even though it has been extended to include the Statistics Office, but rather his functions as head of the Government, as captain of the Ministerial team. If we have evidence of bad team work, then the Taoiseach cannot complain if we hold him responsible for that, and evidence of bad team work there has been in plenty, irrespective of what particular object the team has been trying to achieve or what particular game it has played, about which we have not got very reliable knowledge.
I have the utmost sympathy with the efforts of the Taoiseach to produce a good team out of the material provided to him. It is very hard to win a match with a team all the members of which want to play full-back and some of whom are not very familiar with the rules. Even assuming that he has been doing his best I want to point to the fact that effective action by the Government on any policy is impossible unless all the members of the Government understand what that policy is, approve of it, and support it in public. They must be all pulling in the same direction to get anywhere, and I assert that all the public indications suggest that that team work has been absent. The primary function of the Taoiseach as head of the Government is to keep his team together, to keep them pulling in the same direction, to ensure that, whatever their internal differences, they say the same things in public and endeavour to provide the public with a clear indication of Government policy and the Government viewpoint on important matters.
The Taoiseach, of course, claims that he has discharged that particular function properly. He said at a public meeting on Saturday last at Galway— and in this he was supported by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs— that there were no divisions within the Government. "Even our opponents," he said, "will not now dare to suggest that there are divisions amongst them." I am going to dare to suggest it. Not that I pretend to have any inside information of the working of the Cabinet. I am going to suggest it because of the public declarations of Ministers and the consequences of these declarations on the Government's work as we know it. It may be that Ministers speak with different voices in public because they are agreed. I must admit that possibility. It may be that the conflicting statements which have appeared in the Press have come from men who are agreed in secret but who are speaking in different voices in public for purposes of deception. Certainly, if that is not the explanation then it is impossible to reconcile Ministerial assertions that there are no divisions amongst them with the vacillating course of their policy.
Dare I refer to the White Paper on social services? Venturing greatly, I will remind the Taoiseach that the Dáil was promised that declaration of Government policy 12 months ago. We have been assured that the delays in producing it are due to practical difficulties, that the Minister for Social Welfare is not at fault in that regard and that the Government have agreed upon the desirability of proceeding upon some lines towards the establishment of a comprehensive social welfare scheme. But Ministers have not been saying that with a unanimous voice and within the space of a few weeks, early this year, we had two Ministers speaking on the same subject almost simultaneously and expressing widely divergent views.
On 19th March the Minister for Finance addressed a meeting at Jury's Hotel, at which he said that social services are not good in themselves, and added that he wished he could get the opinion expressed at meetings where social services were claimed as being something good that they are not anything of the sort. That was the 19th March. The Minister for Social Welfare, reading that declaration of his Ministerial colleague in the Sunday Independent, rushed off to a meeting at Drogheda and, according to a report subsequently published, announced there, on 20th March, that it was part of the Government's policy to introduce a comprehensive social insurance scheme which would enable workers to provide, through the medium of a State insurance scheme, against risks which they were unable to provide against from their own resources. The Minister for Finance, who may have hoped by his earlier declarations to dissuade his colleagues from that course, then accepted the fait accompli and on 11th May again referred to the subject, this time in the Dáil. “When that measure,” he said—that is to say, the measure to which the Minister for Social Welfare referred—“is brought before the House it will be a matter demanding very serious consideration. I wonder whether in the end the exaction of very heavy contributions from the community for social services will be an advantage to them. I think they will probably find in the end that they are not getting as much in services.”
I do not know if Deputies will agree that these Ministerial declarations are to be taken as evidence of a conflict of view between the Minister for Social Welfare and the Minister for Finance. What we do know is that, whether there is evidence of a conflict or not, there is no evidence of action. Now, it may be that the absence of action is due to the practical difficulties to which the Minister for Social Welfare referred. It may be due to his desire to have such a perfect scheme that he delayed it in his Department until he was satisfied of its perfection or it may be because the conflict of viewpoint expressed in these public speeches by these two Ministers has reappeared in the Cabinet and that the scheme is begged down there.
I am sure that members of the Labour Party have noted, as we have noted, that the comprehensive social welfare scheme of the days of the Party's independence has shrunk to a State insurance scheme confined to persons engaged in employment under a contract of service. The exact significance of the changed designation may not be known until the long delayed White Paper has emerged but that a change has occurred has been evidenced by the emphasis which the Minister for Social Welfare is now putting upon the word "insurance" in the new title and his references to contracts of service.
I want, however, in this connection to ask the Taoiseach if there has been no division amongest them, if during the whole 18 months in which the Government has existed there has not been a single difference of opinion, as stated by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, what is delaying the publication of the White Paper. I have asked that question before.
Again I want to remind the Dáil that I am not asking for the production of a Bill; I am not asking for the production of detailed proposals. What we have been promised and what we are asking for is a short, simple statement in plain language of what the Government has decided on. That is what the Minister for Social Welfare anticipated he could give to the Dáil 12 months ago. That is what we have not seen yet.
Comment on this
I will not commit myself on that. Unlike the Deputy, I prefer to see it before making up my mind. Last February, the Minister for Industry and Commerce announced that the Government was going immediately to acquire all public transport systems other than those of the Great Northern Railway. That announcement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce followed the now famous leakage of information as to the Government's decision to the Irish Independent. The announcement was made and nothing has happened since. It is true that the Dáil was asked to give a First Reading yesterday to a Bill which it may or may not see before October, but immediately following the announcement of the Government's decision, the Minister for Finance thought it was again desirable that he should make his position clear and explain in public his attitude to nationalisation. He said he had “an objection to nationalisation of services, for as long as people knew the public purse was behind them there was a tendency to extravagance, and there was no test of insolvency in the background.” Again, I suggest there is evidence of conflict or, at least, of a desire of Ministers to speak with different voices in public, perhaps hoping to hold, in support of the Government, people who do not agree upon aspects of policy upon which the Government has got to take decisions. If there is no conflict in this matter, if there is, as we have been assured, agreement amongst all members of the Government, agreement so complete that never once in 18 years was there a single difference of opinion amongst them——
Comment on this
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs referred to the 18 months which have passed—then I think it is rather extraordinary that the announcement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to acquire immediately the shares of these undertakings—the announcement had such an effect upon stock exchange transactions that dealings in these shares had to be temporarily suspended—the announcement that he thought it necessary to make in February last has not been followed by action until July and is apparently not going to be followed by further action earlier than October. I suggest that the announcement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce was made prior to his efforts to convince all his colleagues of the desirability of that course as one would naturally infer from the subsequent declaration of the Minister for Finance, and that the absence of division in the Government was due to the fact that the Government never got an opportunity to divide on this issue.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach has spoken about industrial recovery. I am sure that the appreciates as well as I do that any significant development of industry here will arise, not so much as a direct consequence of steps taken by the Government, but from a general policy which creates conditions of confidence amongst those who will have the task of formulating and directing industrial enterprises. If there is one thing which will destroy confidence, stifle enterprise and create a climate hostile to progress it is evidence of Ministerial hostility to industrial development in general or industrial development through private enterprise in particular.
I say that the Taoiseach will agree with me in that because he has already made known his views in public and he made them known because his deputy, the Minister for Social Welfare, was indiscreet enough to go to a labour meeting in County Kildare and there attack, in a rather unfair way, those who are engaged in industrial enterprises here, describing them "as a small group of unscrupulous people lining their pockets thicker and thicker with money raked out of the pockets of the consuming public". That was on the 21st January, and so the Taoiseach, realising probably or being advised of the damage which was being done by this reckless declaration by a presumably responsible Minister, thought it necessary to repair it if he could, and so he made a speech describing the same group of citizens whom the Tánaiste had referred to as "a small group of unscrupulous people" in the following terms. This was on the 18th February. "This is an age in which the businessman has become a popular target for frequent criticism and, not seldom, uninformed chastisement". That was telling the Tánaiste where he got off. "Too often he is depicted not as an amiable and human personality, as they know him generally to be, but as a predatory hard-faced self-seeker differing little, save in dress, from the anti-social spectres alleged to have haunted Manchester before the first Reform Act" I wonder could we find an explanation of the difference between these declarations from the head of the Government and the deputyhead of the Government in the fact that the Tánaiste was addressing a Labour meeting in Kildare, while the Taoiseach was speaking after a dinner given to him by the Federation of Manufacturers in Dublin?
We have had the spectacle of Government policy changing in relation to aviation, the development of broadcasting services, mineral development and a multitude of other matters. The Taoiseach spoke here about the Government's appreciation of the need for economy and of their approach to the economic problems of this country on the lines of saving money for the purpose of spending it. I suggest that he knows quite well that when his Government came into office last year they went around looking for every project, every scheme, and for everything which Fianna Fáil had devised and for which Fianna Fáil might get the credit with the intention to tear it down if they could, and it was only after they had done the damage, and evidence of the reality of the damage was brought home to them by deputations of unemployed workers and public representatives, that they began to regret their hastiness, and then decided to reverse decisions and tried to repair again the damage they had needlessly caused. I mentioned here last week that miners in the County Wicklow were unemployed for no other reason except that the Government took a decision to suspend all work on mineral development and when they found they were wrong reversed their decision and decided to start it again but because of the delay the equipment which was required was not available and the men who are now drawing unemployment assistance at the local labour exchanges are paying the penalty for the Government's blunder in that regard.
We had the Minister for Finance coming to the House talking about the short-wave broadcasting station and expressing his regret that he did not get into office soon enough to stop the expense of erecting that station earlier. We had the Minister for Agriculture who, to pay him a deserved tribute, was always consistent in his opposition to these developments emphasising again the Government's delight that they were able to get into office in time to stop that development. Then the Government began to think twice, but apparently the need for avoiding divisions in the Government makes it impossible for Ministers to inform their colleagues of changes in plans of that kind, and so we find that, apparently, after the Government had decided to reverse its decision of scrapping the short-wave station and, instead, to proceed with it, the Minister for Lands, addressed a public meeting in Ballina boasting of the fact that the Government had saved the squandering of public money on the erection of a short-wave station, and within a few days of the Minister having made that speech in Ballina, the Government Information Bureau issues a formal announcement that the whole matter had been reconsidered and that the short-wave broadcasting was going to proceed.
I do not know what Deputies opposite feel concerning the decision to suspend the development of air services across the Atlantic. Probably they have not yet come round to the realisation that that was the greatest blunder of all made in the first rush of their decision last year to destroy Fianna Fáil projects. I know that decision was forced upon the Government by the Minister for Finance. He has, in fact, taken public credit for it. But I hope that I am rightly interpreting more recent declarations of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who has direct responsibility in matters of air development, as meaning that he at least is coming to realise the magnitude of their blunder and is trying to lead his colleagues back into a position in which that blunder can be remedied.
I do not know what the attitude of the Government as a whole is in relation to the provision of capital for industrial development and general economic expansion here. As I understood the Taoiseach's declaration here this afternoon, he does not anticipate that any scarcity of capital will limit our progress. A declaration made by the Minister for External Affairs in March, when an agreement relating to the exchange of workers was signed with Switzerland, would seem to imply that he shares that point of view. He declared then that we have all the money we require and need only men with the "know-how". But the Minister for Industry and Commerce does not know that, and one would think that, as the man charged in a special way with industrial development, he should be given the benefit of the advice of the Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs, because he has been speaking on the subject of industrial development in a manner that suggests that he contemplates proceeding here mainly with the aid of American and other foreign capital.
In New York, in January, he undertook that we would give all facilities possible within the scope of the Control of Manufactures Act to any manufacturer—that is, any American manufacturer—who wanted to retain control of his investment in Ireland. Later, speaking to the Galway Chamber of Commerce, he said that if the enterprise needed—that is to say, for establishing industries—was not forthcoming from our own nationals, the Government would not look with disfavour on the introduction of external capital and technique. I have no particular objection to the introduction of external capital into Irish industry, provided it brings with it no political complications. The Control of Manufactures Act was designed primarily to prevent industrial development here taking the form of the establishment of branch companies by English concerns, following the imposition of tariffs or other trade restrictions.
We must recognise that we have a problem which is not without duplication in other parts of the world, a problem which will always confront a small country seeking to develop its industries when it is in close geographical proximity to a great industrial State, in securing that the development which occurs will be of a kind beneficial to ourselves and of a kind that our citizens will always control. If there is to be any relaxation of the barriers which were imposed in 1933, barriers designed to ensure that industrial development here would take place in the main under the guidance of our own citizens, then it should be in consequence of a full examination and discussion of the problem here, and not because of any hasty decision of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, a decision which, I suspect, is induced by his irritation at the fact that progress during his first year of office has been less substantial than he hoped. We could always have got for more substantial industrial development if we had been prepared to proceed through foreign capital and under foreign direction, and we deliberately took the choice that we would prefer to go slowly but along the right lines rather than show immediate results of the wrong kind.
Perhaps, however, the most serious of the divergent viewpoints which have become evident amongst members of the Government was revealed last week by the Minister for External Affairs. I could multiply examples of lesser importance very considerably. I note, for example, that the Minister for Lands last week-end was promising the people of Galway the development of deep-sea fishing fleets. He obviously had not heard the speech the Minister for Agriculture made on the same subject in the Dáil a few weeks previously.
But, to go back to the more serious matter affecting the Minister for External Affairs, I want to direct the Taoiseach's attention to the fact that I endeavoured to find out from the Minister in the debate on his Estimate last week whether the line of policy that he followed at the recent Paris meeting of the Organisation of European Economic Co-operation was known to the Government and was approved in advance by the Government. This is not a matter upon which I want to retrace the ground I covered last week. The public were entitled to think they knew what was the policy of the Government in relation to the efforts of the British authorities to preserve the gold and dollar reserves of the sterling area which are in their custody, and the sterling exchange rates. They were entitled to assume that from the positive declaration made last year by the Taoiseach when proposing to the Dáil the ratification of the trade agreement then made.
I suggested last week that the Minister for External Affairs had taken at Paris a line which the British believed to be detrimental to the success of their efforts to protect these dwindling reserves or to preserve the value of sterling. I asked for an assurance that he was taking a line decided by Government policy and I asked, if that was so, to have some justification for that policy given to the Dáil. I got merely a jeer in reply. I got no information as to whether the Minister was acting with the knowledge and approval of the Government. I got no elucidation of the Government's viewpoint on these matters. The Dáil was told—I am quoting from column 1037 of No. 7 of the Parliamentary Debates, the concluding speech of the Minister for External Affairs—that I to a certain extent was advising them that "we should if necessary tie ourselves around the neck of Britain and the sterling area and sink with it".
I want to direct the Taoiseach's attention to the particular form of words which the Minister for External Affairs used and to ask him to elucidate to the Dáil what exactly the Minister meant by interpreting my remarks as advice to the Dáil that we should tie ourselves around the neck of Britain and the sterling area and sink with it. I do not know if the Taoiseach is satisfied that we should be represented at important international conferences dealing with finance by a Minister who has very little knowledge of the subject and who, when he addresses himself to it, has revealed a point of view which is certainly not in accord with that of the Minister for Finance, whom one would think would normally and properly be the person chosen as the Government delegate to such conferences. I want to know what he thinks of the desirability of having this State represented at international trade conferences by a Minister who knows so little about our external trade that he denied here in a most formal way that there was an extraordinary, almost a spectacular, increase in our imports from the United States of America in the first five months of this year as compared with last year. We know that this year we are financing our dollar imports by borrowings under the Marshall Plan. We know that any unnecessary expansion of our imports is adding to the burden of debt that we shall some time have to repay. I asked for an assurance from the Government that that matter was being considered and that the expansion of imports from the United States was, in their view, necessary and desirable to our economic development or to the maintenance of our standard of living. I want some explanation other than the denial that it took place at all because that, I take it, was the significance of the rather confused figures which the Minister for External Affairs read out when concluding the debate.
I ask the Taoiseach to realise that, as a result of all these conflicting statements and divergent policies of Ministers, there is real confusion in the public mind, a confusion which is holding up our progress and a confusion that will not be removed unless some clear and categorical statement can be given of the Government's policy upon matters on which Ministers at the present time appear to be divided.
That is not the only function of the Taoiseach. He has not merely to keep his team together and pulling in the same direction, and not merely has he to take responsibility when they do not pull in the same direction, but he also has to see that they do their work and that whatever policy the Government is agreed upon is carried out and that whatever impediments to its fulfilment may exist, because of divergent views amongst Ministers or because of red tape or personal laziness, are removed.
The Taoiseach boasted at Galway that the Government had completed its ten-point programme, the programme which constituted the basis upon which it was formed. Now this is a fair occasion upon which to ask the Taoiseach why it is that so many of the ten points in that programme have been forgotten. I am quite sure he will not try to pretend that they have been fulfilled. They were to reduce the cost of living. It has not been reduced. The utmost that the Minister for Finance would undertake in his Budget statement of this year was to express a hope that the cost of living would not increase in the coming 12 months. There was to be—and Labour Deputies will remember this point because they probably were responsible for its insertion—taxation of unreasonable profits. The only alteration which has occurred in the tax law since this Government came into office is a reduction in income-tax. Did they intend that heading in the 10-point programme to convey a reduction in income-tax? Did their supporters and followers throughout the country read it to mean that? Do they accept that that particular point in the programme has been fulfilled?
I have already referred to the fact that the comprehensive social welfare scheme has not emerged and, judging by the declarations of the Minister for Social Welfare, has shrunk from a comprehensive social welfare scheme to a State insurance scheme. The council of education was another one of the ten points. Does it exist? Will any Minister attempt to suggest that it has been formed in secret and is meeting in secret and that only the Dáil does not know about it? The national drainage plan was another point. Has anything been done in fulfilment of the national drainage plan except to carry out the one scheme that was ready to begin when the change of Government took place?
The Taoiseach said that the Government is spending a great deal of money upon capital projects and that, of course, the expenditure of that money must have some results. Of course, it must. But let us tabulate the results to date for the purpose of asking ourselves the question whether we are entitled to be satisfied with the results? I put in the background of the figure I shall give the Dáil now the fact that there were employed on turf production alone in the year 1917 no less than 15,000 workers on the 1st July of that year. The total number of people employed on 1st July, 1949, under all the heads under which capital is being expended was 13,100. In the Land Commission—where the number employed on 1st July this year was 600 below the number employed on 1st July last year —in afforestation activities, in construction and maintainance of the telephone system, in the building of the power stations of the Electricity Supply Board, in the completion of the rural electrification scheme and by Bord na Móna the total number employed on 1st July this year by all these organisations and under all these heads was 13,100.
The capital expenditure to which the Taoiseach referred is undoubtedly having some results and we can attribute to it the fact that there are 13,000 employed in these activities. Far be it from me to suggest that any one should discourage the Government from proceeding further along these lines. What I want the Government to know is that their achievement to the 1st July in promoting activities of that kind has still left in rural Ireland a debit in employment which will have to be wiped out before even the level of 1947 is achieved.
We know that 40,000 emigrated last year. We know that emigration has not stopped. There was no single subject upon which the Parties now comprising the Government Coalition waxed more eloquent when they were seeking support from the people than the subject of emigration; and, rightly so, because any Government, any administration, any political Party must have its approach to the basic economic problems of this country judged by the effectiveness and genuineness of its plans for curtailing emigration. But what do we get from these parties when they find themselves in a position to form a Government? We get a Commission on Emigration, and that is all. Will the Taoiseach attempt to say, or any Minister, that there has been behind any act of any Department which they control the sole purpose of contracting the outflow of emigrants or are we to understand that all effective action to that end stands suspended until this commission has reported? We know that the Minister for Social Welfare, in his earlier optimism, anticipated that the commission might report in three months. To-day, he informs the Dáil that he does not know when they will report.
I do not think that many Deputies opposite can be satisfied with that position and they will join with me in saying to the Government that rather than spend our time doing nothing in relation to this acute problem of emigration until this commission chooses to report, we would sooner scrap the commission altogether and get down to practical action, even though the ideas that would occur to individuals might not necessarily be related one to another. We could at least get something moving in the rural areas from which the outflow of emigration is strongest.
I must confess that I have been disappointed with the extraordinary and unexplained delay of the Government in producing its proposals in relation to transport. I criticised the Minister for Industry and Commerce for his inactivity last year. I went so far as to allege that that inactivity was predesigned to produce a financial crisis in our main transport organisation which would enable him, for political purposes, to represent it as bankrupt. When he appointed an expert to advise him, I felt at least that he would take action at once when the report of that expert was submitted to him. He did not. Months after the expert's report had been published there was still no knowledge of what the Government intended and there was a great deal of "marking time" in transport developments. Subsequently the Minister issued a brief statement which indicated that, in regard to the most important question of all, he was not accepting the expert's recommendation. However, that brief indication of the intention to introduce legislation here was not followed by any action until yesterday. Yesterday, we got to know the title of the Bill which has not yet been drafted and which the Dáil may not see for months yet.
I do not know whether members of the Government think that we in this country have got time to waste in facing up to these urgent economic and administrative problems of ours. We have only now emerged from a war situation. Most of our problems were accentuated or created by that war situation but the time is running on and we cannot afford to proceed in this leisurely manner in producing proposals for dealing with them that the Dáil could consider. Every time that I have ventured to refer to transport matters here, the only retort from the Government Benches was some abusive personal reference, generally to the former chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann who is not here to defend himself. I think the time has come when the Government should understand that they will not be taken seriously in their assertions that they have a transport policy, unless they can produce something more solid than this tendency towards personal abuse.
In so far, therefore, as the Taoiseach has a second function of keeping his Ministers active in producing the results which they themselves thought to be practical in their ten-point programme upon which they stated their Government was formed, I say that he must be censured by the Dáil because there is no evidence that he has succeeded.
He has also a third function, I submit, and that is as head of the Government to protect democratic institutions and their reputation from unfair attack, particularly the function of ensuring that his Ministers do not, by their conduct, seek to bring these institutions or the normal democratic practices under our Constitution into contempt. I feel sure that the Taoiseach is himself disgusted by the tactics which some of his Ministers and supporters in this House resort to in political controversy. I feel sure that he realises that there is no useful national purpose served in implying that the members of any Administration elected by the Irish people are likely to be, in any circumstances, personally corrupt or to allow their Departments to be administered in a corrupt manner. Is it not about time that the tactics which may have won a few votes for individual Government Deputies before the election when their sole concern was to get votes irrespective of the damage they might do to the national dignity or prestige of our political procedures, should be dropped?
There was, of course, in the first days after the Government came into office, a number of suggestions, particularly by the Minister for Agriculture and I think also by the Minister for Social Welfare, that an examination of Government files had revealed that allegations of corruption were justified and they promised that there would be revelations. There have been no revelations and there can be no revelations. Nobody knows better than the Ministers in charge of individual Departments, who have now been there for 18 months, that all that rotten suggestion that there was some maladministration under their predecessors will not bear investigation. Therefore, I ask them, because of the desirability of promoting amongst our people respect for political institutions, for the establishment of proper practices in the day-to-day politics of the country, to drop these tactics. I was disgusted to see them reappear after they had 12 months in which they had to carry the heavy and important responsibilities of members of the Government. I was disgusted to see them resorting to the same tactics again, the same mean suggestions.
The Minister for Agriculture spoke at Cavan and endeavoured to imply that when the Fianna Fáil Government was in office nobody could get an old age pension except they were a member of a Fianna Fáil club or could get the influence of a club working on their behalf. Do the members of the Government or their supporters think it is desirable that the public of this country should be led to believe that, under any circumstances, political influences can determine the award or the withholding of an old age pension? Ministers know, and most Deputies know, that the old age pension code was framed so as to exclude completely the possibility of Ministerial influence being used in the determination of old age pension cases. If there is a suggestion of maladministration under that code it is a suggestion against the honour of the public officials who are entrusted with that task and not against the individuals who from time to time have held the position of Minister in that Department. Do the Deputies opposite not realise that, in order to eliminate a possibility of there being any suspicious created by their remarks in that regard, the Minister for Local Government endeavoured to ensure that Deputies would not even make representations to his Department except in a formal way and in writing?
Comment on this
That, of course, is a repetition of the suggestion which I have just said is contemptible. Apparently, I have touched a sore spot there. There are some Deputies opposite who are not going to give up that weapon. The Minister for Education, who spoke recently at Ennis, suggested that in the administration of the Military Pensions Act there was a political preference for the supporters of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
If that is so, is it not the Government's responsibility to expose it? My challenge to the Government is that if they are not content to rely on insinuations, they have the power to expose the truth of these allegations if they are true. Why do they not do that? I challenge them now to set up a formal investigation into the allegations made by the Minister for Agriculture about old age pensions, by the Minister for Education about Army pensions, or by any other Minister in relation to any matter. We welcome the fullest investigation. I say that if you continue these allegations while denying those against whom they are directed an opportunity of having them investigated, it is the meanest thing you have ever done. Is that clear enough?
Let me say this. The Minister for External Affairs and his colleague, the Minister for Health, are probably the worst offenders in this regard. Does the Taoiseach think it is good national policy or that it served any useful purpose for the Minister for Health to allege against a very honourable member of this Party that he was a Quisling and a traitor? Does he know that the Minister for External Affairs in the by-election campaign in West Cork spoke about steps taken by the previous Government to suppress crime as if the Government themselves were the criminals? We can rake over old fires as well as anybody else but I suggest that we should try to establish here some higher standard of decency and keep to it. If the Taoiseach will make an effort in that direction, an effort to get his own colleagues to conform to some elementary standards of decency in political controversy, we shall gladly co-operate with him.
Comment on this
Including everything. I know that, in raising some of these matters, I am merely exposing myself to a tirade somewhat similar to that which was delivered here last week by the Minister for External Affairs but I have hopes that the Taoiseach does not suffer from the paranoic tendency to regard all criticism of himself as evidence of personal animosity. I have hopes that he will take criticism in a somewhat saner fashion. I know that he has in public represented all criticism of his Government as a form of obstruction. I deny emphatically that Government business has been obstructed here on any occasion since this Government came into office. I say that, time and again, when the Government Whips came to us and pleaded consideration of urgency or any other good reason why the passage of Bills should be facilitated, they were facilitated. Nobody knows that better than the Taoiseach and it is most unfair of him, in a week in which special facilities had been given to the Government to clear up business towards the end of the session, to allege that Government business was being obstructed.
We never regarded criticism of any kind as obstruction. If the allegation is that business could have been disposed of here with greater expedition, I ask Deputies who were in the Dáil on Friday last to recall what happened when the Minister for Local Government was dealing with the Housing Bill. He rose six times to wind up the debate and on each occasion he was prevented from speaking by the fact that Deputies sitting behind him rose to take part in the debate. Were those Deputies causing obstruction? Most of them added very little to the debate. In any event anything they said was probably going to be said by the Minister for Local Government. As a result of their intervention, an unnecessary intervention, the debate was protracted for a much longer period than the Whips on either side had anticipated. If there has been obstruction of the discussion on any Estimate, it is not attributable to the Deputies on this side. I challenge the Minister to get his Central Statistics Office to calculate the number of Deputies who spoke in these debates and the length of time they occupied and to see whether there were more speakers occupying a longer time from behind Ministers than in front of them. It was most unfair of the Taoiseach to allege that there was obstruction from this side of the House because, if he did not know it himself, a casual inquiry to his Parliamentary Secretary would have informed him how often and how generously the Government was facilitated this year and last year in the discharge of the business of the House.
I do not wish to protract this discussion any longer now. I do not believe that what the Taoiseach and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said last week, that there never has been disagreement in the Government, is true. I think if it is true, it must be an appalling Government. Certainly I can say of the Fianna Fáil Government that we had many disagreements, and even protracted and heated discussions, before we emerged at the ultimate decision which we announced to be our policy. Any body of men who hold views strongly will, of course, argue their point of view and only gradually relinquish it as the weight of argument from some other quarter convinces them that they are incorrect. We are not children to believe fairy stories of that kind. Even the Taoiseach reinforced that by telling us that if the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs left the Government he would have to resign. I hope the audience at the meeting fully understood the reason for that announcement.
Comment on this
If there is no evidence of division in the Government, there is certainly no evidence of division in the Dáil. The Taoiseach was inclined to disparage the Party Whips for one failure. I want to congratulate them. There never has been since the Dáil was established such a perfectly-machined majority as we have in this Dáil. Most of them dare not open their mouths. Those who do dare to express any criticism of the Government have reason to repent of that very quickly, and to prove their repentance in the Division Lobby.
The only member of a Government Party who ever dared to take an independent attitude was shot out of his Party so quickly that nobody even saw him go. At the end of the session, I want to pay that tribute to the Party machine of the Coalition groups and their Whips. They have certainly flogged their Deputies into obedience and I am quite certain their flogging will produce the defeat of this motion. It will be defeated because of the rigid iron-bound discipline they have established, and not because many Deputies opposite do not believe the criticism I have expressed here is well-founded.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass has covered a considerable amount of ground. I have no intention of going over that ground nor have I any intention of approaching this Estimate in the way he has approached it. I was influenced to a large extent by the speech of the Taoiseach. The speech which he made this evening was the speech of a statesman. It was delivered in balanced and even tones. Many of us who had the honour of knowing him before he became Taoiseach were aware of his abilities, but I think we all have seen a very substantial increase in the stature of the Taoiseach during the past 16 or 17 months. I was very pleased that he should introduce his Estimate to-day with the facts and figures which he gave us. Those facts and those figures indicate that there has been an improvement in the national situation over the past 16 months and the Taoiseach justifiably referred to statistics to establish that improvement.
I have, however, as a representative of a city constituency, a particular responsibility for and a particular interest in three matters which, I indicated to-day, I would raise on this Estimate. I am concerned with the matter of housing, and housing has loomed large in our discussions over the past 18 months. From figures given by the Minister for Local Government recently, it appears that the number of houses built in the Dublin City area during the past six months was 600, and we need approximately 25,000 houses to solve the very serious housing situation in Dublin City. I want to say to the Taoiseach that this Government will be judged very largely in the City of Dublin by the efforts it makes to solve the housing problem. We have the Department of Local Government dealing with it, we have the Dublin Corporation dealing with it, and I want to suggest to the Taoiseach that one of the matters that he must immediately consider with his Cabinet as a whole is whether or not the very serious housing problem in Dublin City can be solved by a continuation of the machinery now available. I suggest to him that it is a matter of the highest policy on which the Government may stand or fall in Dublin City at the next election and that it must receive the full consideration of the Government as a whole.
People in my own constituency and in every constituency in Dublin City are living in horrible conditions; and they have been living in those dreadful conditions for many years. We promised them that we would direct all our efforts to the abolition of that slum problem and to the building of decent houses for them, and I almost feel ashamed, after being 18 months in this House, to go back and make excuses to these people for not doing the things we promised we would do. Just as the late Minister for Local Government was personally concerned about this problem, the present Minister has every sympathy with the unfortunate people who have to live in those conditions. But, as I have said before in this House, sympathy is not sufficient. We want more than sympathy.
I want the Taoiseach to declare the housing situation in Dublin City an emergency situation to be dealt with by emergency measures under the direct control of the Government so that the houses we need for our people may be made available at the earliest possible opportunity. The Taoiseach will understand that every Deputy representing the City of Dublin, including himself, has those conditions brought to his notice day after day by unfortunate people whom it should be our duty to assist. I want the Taoiseach to give to that problem all the energies that he personally can make available and that his Government can make available to solve it. If we can make decent progress with it within the next two years, and certainly before the period of the next election, none of us will have any hesitation in going before the electorate for election to this House again.
The Taoiseach has pointed out that there has been an increase in industrial employment and that there must be an increase in employment in the rural areas because of the fact that £16,000,000 has been made available by the Government for capital expenditure in the country. I agree that there must be an increase in employment provided in that way. But the difficulty in regard to employment is that there are growing up in every house in this city young boys of 16, 17, 18 and 19 years of age and their parents are anxious to get them some employment. There is no employment available and those fine types of young Irish manhood have no alternative but to take the emigrant ship or to take a Great Northern Railway train and cross the border and join up in the British armed forces or endeavour to find employment in Great Britain, America, or elsewhere. It is a serious situation that those fine young energetic people should have to leave the country because employment is not available for them. They can only be employed in industry of one kind or another. The employment that is and that will be available in rural areas is of no use to them. Industrial employment must be provided.
I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce has approved 104 new industries and that 24 new industries have started. That progress does not appear to have affected the unemployment situation very much. The Government, with this new industrial development authority will have to consider whether industries directly run by the State and directly under State control cannot be established for the purpose of giving employment to the types of people I have mentioned. There is a responsibility on each of us and a very serious responsibility on the Taoiseach and the Government.
I agree with what the Taoiseach has said with regard to the cost of living, that to a large extent it is affected by the burden of taxation and that unless we increase the national wealth we will not be able to reduce that burden. I agree with that principle but a considerable number of items that enter into the cost of living are items which from the time of production to the time of sale to the consumer increase in price beyond all bounds. The suggestion I have to make to the Taoiseach, and which appears to be the only sensible solution, is that the whole question of profits in distribution must be considered and that where those profits are excessive they must be controlled and reduced and where there is unnecessary handling and unnecessary people or agents brought into distribution they must be eliminated. In that way a substantial reduction can be effected in the cost of living.
I said that I would speak on this Estimate for the purpose of drawing attention to those three items. As I know there will be many items discussed on this Estimate, I feel I should not delay the House or endeavour to lessen the time that may be available for other Deputies to speak. I would, however, say, in conclusion, that if the Taoiseach and the Government can get down to a serious consideration of these problems and if they will avail of all the help they can get in this House from Deputies who support them and from Deputies who oppose them, I am quite sure they will be enabled to make appreciable improvement as far as these matters are concerned.
As I said at the beginning, I was very pleased with the restrained and statesmanlike way in which the Taoiseach introduced this Estimate and I hope that the latter part of Deputy Lemass's speech will not induce the Taoiseach to hit back in the way that type of speech could be attacked.
There has been reference to the way in which the recent debate on a Bill introduced by the Minister for Local Government was conducted. Every Deputy who took part in that debate put forward his suggestions constructively. I hope that on this debate Deputies will put forward constructive suggestions and that their criticisms and suggestions will be accepted by the Government in the spirit in which they are offered. However, I am very pleased that we have seen the second Estimate introduced by the Taoiseach and that we have been able to see from the figures he has given the substantial improvements that have been effected during the 18 months the Government of which he is the head has been in office.
Comment on this
I listened with the greatest interest to the Taoiseach trying to disentangle his original policy and indicate some clear road for the people to follow, and I notice that his policy as now developed is to a very large extent a compliment to the policy pursued by Fianna Fáil. In almost every single respect he has gone back and adopted the policy practised by Fianna Fáil, especially the industrial policy. Unfortunately, during the period in which that policy was not acceptable to the Government, which was the first year of the Coalition Government, quite an amount of harm was done in this country which will take a considerable time to repair. As far as I see one of the greatest injuries done to this country was the loss of confidence created by the original policy that was pursued by the Government. Young people began at once to think of taking ship in the belief that the future here was hopeless. It was largely due to that fact that emigration is so abnormally high. One would think that in a county like Meath, which is sparsely populated, emigration in the ordinary course of events or in normal times would hardly be noticeable. Unfortunately, that is not the case. In every town or village, with the one exception of Navan, it is quite noticeable that emigration is taking place. That was one of the greatest mistakes made by this Government. I know that it is due to certain, perhaps, peculiar circumstances, certain intentions that did not materialise. That might explain a good deal of the difficulties in which the country now finds itself.
It is not possible to please two peoples. In the early stages here every effort was made to please the British Government. We had continual visits to the British Government, many unnecessary, and quite a number of visits from them. We had the Minister for Agriculture expressing the greatest sympathy for their misery and hunger and telling them that he would choke them with eggs.
Comment on this
For some reason or another that has all disappeared. He even went so far as to say—and it was definitely stated—that industrial development would not proceed at the pace or on the basis that Fianna Fáil had proceeded with it. Everything was done at that period to try and satisfy the British people, or perhaps I should say the British Government. Then suddenly there was a complete change. In fact, everything has now changed. We are now going to develop the peat industry. We have had a good deal of talk here in this House about turf. A new Bill has been introduced which I have not read yet, but the development of turf is to be revived.
Comment on this
As long as we produce turf here we will get cheap coal from the British, but once we begin to talk about it as filth and as being a useless fuel—we are doing away with it now at £1 a ton—the British will increase coal prices. They are good business people. The boot is now on the other foot, and so we are going to develop the peat industry and supply very excellent fuel to the people. In my opinion the turf that is lying in the Phoenix Park is the very best of turf. I went to the trouble of looking at it. I hope that, in the next six months, the people in the City of Dublin will not be in the position that they will want it badly. There is nothing wrong whatever with the turf that I saw in the park. I notice that it is now going down the country. The type of policy that was pursued by the Government about turf must have given a headache to the Taoiseach. I had to admire the way that he wriggled out of it, but being the good lawyer that he is he was able to wriggle out of it. He must be convinced now that the policy the Government are pursuing with regard to turf is largely the policy of Fianna Fáil, and that it is the right one to pursue for this country.
Comment on this
I am sorry for the public. Perhaps the reason is that they have too much coal. If coal gets any dearer, people may be very glad to buy the turf.
Comment on this
Following on what Deputy Cowan said I rose mainly for the purpose of discussing housing. On that question I am sure that the Taoiseach is doing his best but at the same time I think a good deal more could be done. I really thought when the late Minister for Local Government —God be good to him—went over to England and spent a week there learning how to build houses, or, perhaps I should say studying the organisation of building houses, that when he came back houses would go up like mushrooms. But really they did not. In my opinion the position in regard to housing is worse than it was. Everything possible should be done to provide houses for the people.
I think I mentioned before that I have noticed quite an abnormal amount of private building going on. Private houses seem to be going up rapidly. When the Estimate for the Department of Local Government was before the House, I mentioned that on a 40-mile journey from Clonee, which is on the borders of the County Meath, to Dublin, I noticed that there had been only one labourer's cottage completed, and that that was under an old scheme. I may tell the House that the area I refer to is a very thinkly populated one. On the same journey I noticed that four or five new private houses had been almost completed. The walls for three houses for workers were up in the town of Trim, but I could see only one labourer's cottage that had been completed. The delay in providing houses is one of the causes of emigration. I know five, six or seven young people who emigrated because they could not get houses and because the conditions under which they were living were impossible. We have as many as nine and sometimes 14 people living in the one house. I think it is essential that every step possible should be taken to see that that position is corrected.
I listened to the Taoiseach give some figures relating to the deficit in the balance of trade payments for the years 1947 and 1948. He indicated how high the deficit was and how much we were purchasing from outside. I think he wanted to indicate that ours was a spendthrift policy. I think that is not right or fair. In our time there was a world war that went on for six years. Goods simply could not be procured during that period. As soon as the position became easier, householders and others made every effort to replace articles which had become worn out during the war. I wonder whether the Taoiseach is right in the way that the looks at this problem. When goods are purchased they must be paid for in some way or other. If we had not made big purchases of raw materials from outside it would mean that our factories would not be working. The bulk of our payments went for raw materials. It was better that we should purchase those raw materials than have our factories idle. As far as I could gather, the Taoiseach seemed to want to indicate that the position which was created was a sign, perhaps, of a want of economy, or perhaps a sign of bankruptey. I do not think that is the way to look at the matter at all. The Taoiseach told us of all the new factories that had been erected. I do not remember the number he mentioned. I still doubt if it is a healthy sign to see the figures relating to the deficit in trade going down. I think that if these deficits were higher it would be an indication that our factories were functioning properly unless, of course, they were able to carry on with supplies of native material.
I think that the Party opposite did a good deal of damage in their time to the tourist traffic, and that, if it had been developed as it should have been last year and the year before, the deficit in the balance of payments would be a small one. I think we are entirely wrong in not trying to cater better for tourist traffic. We have not ourselves any great supplies of raw materials, and, therefore, we are going to find it difficult to develop our industries. I do not know that tariffs are going to be of much use to our industries. When Britain gets stronger some day she will be in a position to control supplies of raw materials to this country. She generally sells these to other countries at about 20 per cent. above the price at which she sells them to her own nationals. I think tariffs are often deceptive in their effects, and that if we had some system whereby there was a prohibition on the quantities of foreign goods that could come in here it would be better than tariffs.
At the same time I think that the tourist industry should be developed. We have huge numbers of our people in other countries. In our time, we did our best to set up an air service that would bring them here on holidays. I think it was very foolish on the part of the Taoiseach to have sold the aeroplanes that we had purchased. People have to travel by ship now. I think that if the air services had been kept on and developed they would be the means of earning a lot of dollars for us now. They would also be the means of keeping us in more intimate touch with our people abroad. It is my opinion that we should try to cultivate the greatest possible intimacy with our empire abroad, because we have a fairly strong empire abroad. It has not any ships or guns, but it is a powerful empire, and if we could induce more communication with those people we would be a lot stronger and we would not have to be scratching our heads to know what to do next. If we had these people behind our backs we could have more courage and face things with more determination. Obstacles would not be surrounded with so many entanglements.
We have what is possibly the last big question between Great Britain and this country to deal with, and that will not be solved easily.
Comment on this
I just wanted to mention it. From the point of view of industry, apart altogether from politics, if we had more communication with our people abroad, if we had more of them moving backwards and forwards, we would be a good deal better off. Many of those people are industrialists in other countries and they could give us a great deal of useful knowledge. It is a pity that we are not able to keep in touch with them. Of course, we have repentance at the last moment; we have the short-wave wireless station being set up. That in itself will help to keep us in touch with our friends and relations abroad and in that way I believe we can do a great deal for this country.
I am a bit puzzled over statements made about the cost of living. Quite a number of people speak to me about it. Any person who has a family will realise that all this talk about the cost of living is very deceptive. We have sugar on the ration and yet you can buy sugar at 7½d. on the black market. I do not think that that should be allowed. I think the rationing system was a great system and was very economic. Now that the 7½d. black market sugar can be got there will be a lot of blackberry jam and stuff like that to be made. Really the cost of living has gone up although it is not indicated in the cost-of-living index figure.
Many people who depend on the cost-of-living figure for bonuses are deceived. You pay 7½d. for your sugar and you can also buy tea—it is, there to be bought. If somebody eats up the ration the householder has to get more. That is a wrong system and any normal Government would not agree to it. Whether or not this is a source of revenue, I cannot say, but the Government should do something about it. It is unfair to the community that any shopkeeper can sell sugar out of a sack at 4½d. and later dip the shovel into the same sack and sell it at 7½d. There is something really wrong about that and it should be stopped.
Comment on this
To my amazement, listening to the Taoiseach, I discovered he did not avail of this opportunity to express any opinion as to the possibility of a near solution to Partition.
Comment on this
The other night, when speaking here, I was upbraided by the Minister for External Affairs because the former Taoiseach, when introducing his Estimate, did not utter a single word about Partition.
Comment on this
I think I am entitled to make some comment on the lack of policy on the one national objective remaining. Having listened to the Minister for External Affairs and the Taoiseach, it really looks to me as if there has been no policy formulated by this Government regarding this problem.
Comment on this
We had a full debate on that matter on the Vote for the Department of External Affairs.
Comment on this
It is the Taoiseach's responsibility, as captain of the ship. It would be much easier for us in the North, on each side of the Border, to fight this evil if we were encouraged by the formulation of some definite policy which would guide us.
Comment on this
Perhaps it is easier to play politics, inter-Party politics, without a policy than with one. I would like to assure the Taoiseach that so far as the conditions of the people in the North are concerned, political and religious discrimination are becoming intensified.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy heard me say that it is a duplication of the debate to discuss Partition on this Vote. There was a lengthy debate quite recently in which the Deputy participated.
Comment on this
I think the sooner that we down here realise that the political vitality of our people in the North is being slowly but surely sapped, the better.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy should realise what the Chair implied—that this matter is not in order.
Comment on this
All right. I merely say that as regards Partition, the sooner we realise that time is not on our side, the better.
Comment on this
I listened carefully to the Taoiseach and was very pleased with his remarks. I listened later to Deputy Lemass when he slandered Deputies on this side of the House. We voted for the Government and the Taoiseach 18 months ago because the last Government failed to do what we wanted them to do. How many times did we put down motions looking for increases for our old people? How many times did we ask for some relief for the distress that existed then in our country? The Fianna Fáil Party, led by one man, for 16 years ignored all our requests. This is a Government of a better type. It is a democratic Government. We can criticise freely and express our views. For 16 years we had one Party in office, led and said by the one individual. To-day there is freedom for all Parties who comprise the Government and all Parties in the Government work as one. Improvements have been made in the last 18 months. Increases have been given to the old age pensioners and to the widows and the orphans. Those increases have come about as a result of the change of Government. I am proud to belong to that Government.
Some part of the ten-point programme has been carried out despite what the Opposition says. Deputy O'Reilly talked about the cost of living and said that it had not gone down. If this Government had not removed the taxes imposed under the Supplementary Budget introduced by Fianna Fáil on beer, tobacco and the cinemas what would the cost of living be now? The Standstill Orders were removed. They might not have been removed had Fianna Fáil remained in office. We are carrying out the promises we made to the people who elected us. Fianna Fáil slandered us during that election. When the general election was over but the election had still to take place in Kilkenny they indulged in low, mean tactics against us. The people whom I represent in Wexford are quite satisfied with the progress we are making.
Mention was made of turf. Had Fianna Fáil remained in office only machine-won turf would have been available to-day. Deputy O'Reilly said the price of coal was due to the fact that we are not producing turf. Why did Fianna Fáil import coal from South Africa and other countries? It has been deteriorating in the dumps in the Phoenix Park all the time. That was wilful waste. Our Government had to sell the timber at half its value rather than let it rot.
Workmen's compensation has been increased. There will be more increases in social services generally when the White Paper is introduced. Deputy Lemass is worried about the comprehensive social welfare scheme. We are not worried about it. We know that it will come. It was Deputy Lemass's Government that turned down the bishop's proposal. His Party did not want social services. Deputy Dr. Ryan said the Government then could not afford more in old age pensions. Has the present Opposition forgotten all that? If we were as long in office as they were and had done so little during our 16 years as they did I would be ashamed to get up and talk as they do. They had a majority for 16 years. Why did they not do in their 16 years all that they want us to do in our 16 months?
Who is worrying about the short-wave station? Certainly the workingclass people are not worrying about it. Deputy O'Reilly talked about black marketing. The bacon is back in the shop windows now for sale to the people. Where was it when Fianna Fáil were in office? It was under the counter. They allowed that black market to go on.
I think that the Opposition could give us more co-operation. The Opposition Deputies seem to have been told to prolong the debate here. They even prolonged the debate on the Works Bill. Deputy Lemass spoke for two hours here to-day. He said the Government Deputies were holding up the business. It is not a crime for any man to express his view. That is democracy. There can be no democracy under a dictatorship. The County Management Act will go and local government will be given back into the hands of the people. That will do away with the increase that had to be made in the rates to pay the salaries of county managers. That was a burden upon the ratepayers. Fianna Fáil never adverted to that. I am a member of a local authority and I know what is happening. Deputy Lemass says there was no corruption, but I know that there was.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass wanted facts. He said there was no corruption. I know where two people were given old age pensions and the claim of another person 100 yards down the road was disallowed. I made investigations and I discovered that the pensions were granted to the first two because Fianna Fáil held meetings in their house.
Comment on this
That is proof all right. During the last election I.R.A. pensions were given to Fianna Fáil followers.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass wanted proof. I am proving now that there was corruption right through all the Fianna Fáil clubs all over the country.
Comment on this
I would not in the ordinary way reply to some of the statements made by Deputy O'Leary but I think, in fairness to the decent, honest officials in the Department of Local Government, who were in charge of the old age pensions appeal section, it is just as well that I should reply to his allegation of corruption. I happened to be in charge of old age pension appeals for two years until the Department of Social Welfare was created and I can only say that neither the Minister over me nor I myself ever, in the course of our administration, ordered any single person to be given a pension or to have a pension withheld from him. I would also say that if we had, the group of officials, including the two chief deciding officers of the Old Age Pensions Appeals Department, were men of such calibre that they would have come and said that on the facts stated this individual should be granted a pension or should not be granted a pension. They would have had no fear in coming forward and speaking to me or to the Minister for Local Government on that matter.
Comment on this
I would further say that the custom was that the deciding officers in connection with old age pension appeals had what might be described as a non-legal judicial authority; in other words, there was nothing in the Act which said that they were dependent on the Minister. They had, in fact, been placed independent of the Minister. Appeals received from Deputies of all Parties were treated with the utmost consideration by the officials concerned, and the proof that they acted leniently towards the community in general may be found if Deputy O'Leary will look at the percentage of appeals allowed from every constituency, those where the Government had a big majority and those where we were in a large minority. He will find that, as compared with 1932, the percentage of cases in which questions raised by applicants were listened to, were given a fair hearing and were granted an increased pension was very much larger. That process went on continuously through the whole 16 years of the Fianna Fáil administration.
Comment on this
Can we take it now that the debate on the Taoiseach's Estimate has opened on this plane?
Comment on this
I have allowed Deputy Childers to speak because he said he was replying to a statement made by Deputy O'Leary about unfair decisions.
Comment on this
I think I have said sufficient to protect the reputation of honourable men in regard to this matter. On this Estimate I would like to refer once again to the failure of the Government to reduce the cost of living. They have failed to slash the cost of living, to bring it down to a point where the workers could feel that they had a greatly increased purchasing power. The promises made as far back as February, 1947, were not that if workers' wages went up by 10 per cent. and the cost of living did not rise, that was sufficient. The promises made were related to statements that the cost of living was grossly inflated, that an enormous number of rich business men who were bribing the Government with contributions to the Fianna Fáil war chest were charging prices, not 10 per cent. too high but 20, 30, 40 and 50 per cent. too high; that the whole economic life of the State was in a state of inflation and that it was due to the failure of the then Government to protect the interests of the worker. The position as a result of Government action is well known to people in this House. The only noticeable decrease in the cost of living took place three months before the Fianna Fáil Government left office when, with the aid of supplementary subsidies to certain important foods, the cost of living was reduced by 3 per cent. and the tide of inflation was stemmed. A great deal of what was then hot money was syphoned away by processes known to economists in half a dozen European countries. From then onwards no noticeable reduction took place. The cost of living in December, in fact, rose to 99 points, where it has remained ever since, from 97 points at the lowest period, November, 1947.
The excuse that certain wages have been increased without a corresponding increase in the cost of living is not a valid one, for two reasons. First of all, there have been cuts in the prices of certain imported raw materials but not of others and, secondly, so far as I know, whole groups of workers have either made demands for further increases of wages on the grounds that they are not able to bear the cost of living or else they have been restrained by private negotiations from so doing. The facts pointed out to them are similar to those pointed out to workers in Great Britain by Sir Stafford Cripps, Chancellor of the Exchequer, the usual facts obtaining in a condition of inflation whereby, under certain circumstances, if wages go up, prices automatically go up. As I have said, the Government has failed to carry out their promise in regard to the cost of living. It may be that in the course of the next few months certain prices may come down due to the fact that conditions are getting more normal. It will not be the result of Government action. It will be the result of world conditions over which the Government has no control. I might add that as a member of Fianna Fáil I am proud of the fact that, regardless of the peculiar circumstances we had to face, out of 73 countries, according to statistics, the cost of living went up here during the war less than in all of them save about ten. In those ten there were several factors to account in a large degree for the fact that they succeeded in maintaining the cost of living at a slightly lower figure than ourselves, such as the granting of lower subsidies, with a consequent imposition of a higher taxation than we ever had to face in this country. I am proud of that record and I am willing to face the electors over and over again on our success in that matter.
In regard to social services the Government's achievement in increasing old age pensions has been adverted to. It is just as well to remind the House that Fianna Fáil gave free, at no cost to the contributor, an increase of 50 per cent. in national health insurance, widows' and orphans' pensions, and unemployment assurance at the end of the war. Increased contributions are now being asked for from employers and employees and the cost of those increased contributions would largely meet the increase in the old age pension grant made available by the present Government. If certain other savings under the head of social services are taken into account, such as the abolition of the contribution to local authorities for certain allowances, it will be found that the actual net increase while it may exist, is nothing about which the Government should boast.
I would next refer to the question of full employment. The Labour Party and the Clann na Poblachta Party got into office largely on the promise that there would be full employment. They did not make any reservations about it. There was no suggestion that it was going to take ten years to bring about. There was no suggestion that it was have to wait until the effect of injecting large State capital into various national schemes would produce more employment. They got into office on those grounds and the only other ground was simply dislike of Fianna Fáil and a desire to change the Government. The most specific promises were made in that regard. The promises made were that the entire financial system must be changed, that the State must be prepared at any time to inject such financial assistance into the life of the community that, no matter what conditions existed, there would be no dole paid to any able-bodied man able to work. They promised that emigration would be cured by the immediate application of large-scale reconstruction schemes all over the country. There was to be no delay for any reason. The promise was made, definitely and beyond all doubt. We now know the results of the Government's action. They have had a year since July last to pursue their policy and the increase in employment in connection with the Department of Lands, the Department of Forestry, the Telephone service, rural electrification work, hydro-electric stations and Bord na Móna is precisely 781 persons in 12 months. I wonder what sort of reception Clann na Poblachta Party would have received throughout the country, if they had said to the people that the application of large scale capital schemes to secure employment, to end unemployment and the payment of dole would result in the year 1949, after a period of 12 months, in the employment of only 781 persons? That would be a magnificent achievement, an increase of 781 persons employed out of a total of 12,354 who were in employment on 1st July, 1948. I wonder by what remote principle Clann na Poblachta can justify the non-fulfilment of their promise to the electors having regard to that figure? You can add if you like 2,000 or 3,000 more people employed on houses. You can add a couple of hundred on national drainage and the question still is not answered and the promises still have not been fulfilled.
Comment on this
You can even treble that figure of 781 and the promises still have not been fulfilled. They are never likely to be fulfilled so long as the orthodox system of finance pursued by the present Government is maintained.
Comment on this
These were the promises made. We know that the Fianna Fáil Party during the 16 years they were in power, did their utmost to solve the problem of unemployment by the injection of State money into certain enterprises. We tried to create employment in industry by protection and in agriculture by encouraging tillage. We gave employment to upwards of 15,000 to 20,000 persons a year outside the activities which I have indicated, by special employment schemes. We knew the problem was so very difficult that it would take a very long time to solve, that the solution of the problem is a long-term matter. Now all these promises of the Clann na Poblachta Party have been ruthlessly broken. I wonder how the Clann na Poblachta Party account to their craobha when they speak to their members for the speech made in January by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to the effect that if people were willing to work as hard at home as they are abroad, fewer would have to emigrate? I wonder if Clann na Poblachta have investigated the statement made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the registers in the unemployment exchanges had been swollen by political agitation? I have searched County Longford and County Westmeath and I could find no evidence that a Fianna Fáil club in any part of the area had induced additional persons to register. Indeed to me it is a most shallow excuse, but then again the tune has been changed since the Government came into office.
Again we had Deputy Norton, speaking in this House in 1947, saying:—
"We are settling down to a policy of exporting them (the Irish people) to Britain at a rate greater than in the war years. I do not blame these unfortunate people for seeking employment in Britain; it is the only alternative to the workhouse or a beggarly pittance."
Yet, so far as I can recall the rate of emigration in 1948 was up to the highest level ever recorded in the war years. We have had complaints that workers cannot be found to work on Bord na Móna schemes. Everybody knows that during the 12 months which the Government took to make up its mind to increase development grants, a huge number of turf workers migrated to Great Britain and the pool of workers, available for Bord na Móna has largely decreased because the Government failed to put into operation the plan left ready for them by the previous Government to offset the unemployment occasioned by the ending of the production of hand-won turf. I believe that more should be done to encourage the turf industry. I think that the Government have had sufficient experience now to know that the depression that has taken place in the retail business in the turf areas, which is well known to everybody, is due to the fact that the hand-won turf industry brought money and cash to people who needed it and that that source of income is no longer in existence. I say that no matter what reclamation scheme is carried out, no matter at what expense you increase agricultural production, these schemes will not replace the cash that was made available to small farmers and workers throughout the turf area during the war years.
I myself believe that with coal at its present price the Government should re-examine the whole question of turf production and see what can be done to increase the production of turf. I know that in Dublin at present machine-pressed turf can be bought, although the quantity is insufficient, at something like £3 11s. Od. per ton. Hand-won turf can be brought also from the bogs in Westmeath to Dublin and a mixture of machine-won turf and hand-won turf in the less cold months is a most adequate form of an inexpensive fuel and bears favourable comparison with coal except in one matter—that it leaves a lot of dust for the unfortunate housewife to clean up. I realise also that mixtures of any type of turf for use in tenement houses is not a very suitable type of fuel. Where, however, you have room to store it, a totally different situation emerges, but in the tenements storage is difficult and any type of turf must crumble and lose its calorific value.
This is certainly an apportunity for the Government to think over its attitude to turf production, now that they have had experience of the decline in purchasing power of the community in the turf-producing areas. I do not believe that the land reclamation scheme, while I welcome it, is going to make that essential difference. It may be helpful to the people but it will not restore the prosperity to the turf-producing areas that was brought there during the war years when turf production was at its highest. The present situation is a challenge to the Government to use its initiative and its inventive powers. During the 16 years we were in office we used our inventive powers and our initiative for the benefit of the public. It is up to the present Government to do the same thing. We all of us know that the injection of capital by the State into enterprise may or may not increase unemployment to any degree that would be noticeable. In many cases, the expenditure involves the importation of expensive raw materials and equipment and the actual proportion of money spent on labour may be very small. In other cases, the results may be successful from the point of view of the employment given in the right place at the right time.
I mention again the fact that unemployment is a particularly serious problem in this country because it is both local in character and seasonable. I suppose that labour is less mobile here than in a great many other countries with a similar national income to ours. We have to recognise that fact. It is all very well to say that workers cannot be got to work on Bord na Móna schemes or on hydro-electric schemes. We had a rule that unemployment assistance could be paid to men if the work offered to them was more than a certain number of miles away—I think four miles. We had that rule because we were faced with the general problem of immobility of labour, due partly to traditional reasons and partly to lack of houses. It is a problem for the Government to face. There are places, I am quite sure, in this country at the present time where, even with reduced tillage, with reduced agricultural employment, work could be found for workers who migrate from the West to England and Scotland if they had houses. It is a permanent problem because the local county councils are not supposed to build more houses than are required for the local inhabitants and the problem still remains of providing housing accommodation for migratory workers. It is a serious problem. It should be dealt with on its merits. It is existing in the central areas where tillage is a tradition.
I should mention the fact in relation to the 781 persons more employed on these services than on July 1st, 1948, that there were, if I remember rightly, from 11,000 to 15,000 persons employed on turf in 1947, and there is a tremendous amount of employment to be given if that figure is to be achieved. As I said, the figure of 781 does not seem to relate to anything that Clann na Poblachta promised. I want to make quite clear the difference between the present Government's policy and the Clann na Poblachta policy and to point out how far their policy is in abeyance.
The Government have some plans for investing capital in various enterprises. A great many of these plans were in operation before the Government came in. Many of them have been slowed down for want of raw materials and equipment. Some of them may be new, may be novel in character. That was not the Clann na Poblachta policy. Their policy was that at all costs, a sufficient amount of money must at all times be injected into the life of the community on national schemes and that the effect of it would be definitely to employ all the unemployed and to relieve the problem of emigration. There was to be no limit. If, for example, Fianna Fáil were to have an annual budget of £1,500,000 for special employment schemes, that was insufficient. The budget must be unlimited. The money must be borrowed on the credit of the nation. There was even a suggestion that the character of sterling should be altered and, if it were altered, it would be possible to borrow this money without increasing taxation, without making the rest of the people already employed pay any tax for paying these workers who were engaged on these special schemes. That was the point. It was so far removed from the present Government's programme that there is no comparison. To that degree, Clann na Poblachta has broken one of the principal pledges which they made to the electors and the people are well aware of it.
I notice that there are some 658 fewer persons employed by the Land Commission at the moment as compared with 12 months ago. If I remember rightly, both Clann na Poblachta and the Labour Party indulged in agitation of a most serious kind throughout Westmeath during the election with regard to the failure of the Government to divide land, calling on the Government to abolish the Land Commission, to alter all the old alleged out-of-date rules in connection with Land Commission administration and to divide immediately large numbers of estates, including estates where there was an adequate number of persons employed to put the estates fully out of the running so far as the Land Commission was concerned. But they were all included by Clann na Poblachta. Practically all estates of 300 acres or over were to be divided immediately. All you required to do was to abolish the Land Commission or to remove the officials who were there, to alter the regulations, and then the work could go ahead. Now we have, after 12 months, 685 fewer people employed by the Land Commission on works of land improvement.
We had also the promise made to cover tens of thousands of acres of land with forests. The principle was not that of acquiring forest land wherever it could be acquired in the ordinary way. It was even giving more for forest land than Fianna Fáil gave. It was not growing seedling at a greater rate than they were grown by Fianna Fáil. The principle suggested was that whole areas should be acquired for afforestation with ancillary industries attached and that the land must be acquired compulsorily, because it could never be acquired otherwise. If there were farms in the areas to be acquired, the people must be transferred and new land found for them. In these great forest belts of thousands and thousands of acres new wood industries would arise. That would certainly employ a lot of people if the policy were carried out. But we now see that during the year the number of people employed in forestry has only gone up from 1,904 to 2,094.
Of course those who talk glibly about afforestation employment have always to bear in mind that, like so many other kinds of State enterprises, the employment, unfortunately, is given largely in the summer when the problem is not at its greatest. If you take any unit of afforestation, for every 30 workers employed in the summer the number will be reduced to 10 in the winter when you want it exactly the other way around. That is not to say that we should not do afforestation. But afforestation is not a major method of employing men in the winter months when they need it. Although it would largely leave a residue of people employed, the main employment is in the summer in the relation of 30 to 10.
There are certainly no more persons employed on the roads at present. There are certainly no more persons employed in agriculture at present. If there should be any slight variation in the figures, it is not very much one way or the other. We have to wait until the winter comes to see the effect of the deeline of tillage on agricultural employment generally. We have to wait also to see what the effect of the reduced road grants will be on road workers employment, to see the final result. The local authorities' works scheme is, I understand, coming into operation. We have to wait to see whether as many persons will be employed on roads and on the local authorities' works scheme taken together as were employed previously on roads. It would be very hard for the Government to find the necessary £2,000,000 to bring that state of things about—that the number of persons employed would be the same as a result of this new form of local government activity. So far as the land reclamation scheme is concerned, it is not yet in operation and we are unable to judge the effect on the level of employment.
As I have said, my main contention is that the promises of the two small Parties aiding Fine Gael have been broken and the fundamental basis of their policy is not being adopted. What is being adopted is a policy which has no relation to what they suggested. I shall leave to other speakers the question of agricultural policy, but I want to make that point. People in my constituency know well that there is no hope of bringing into operation the Clann na Poblachta or Labour Party policies as they were understood by the electors. They know that they have gone beyond recall and that they are never likely to see the Government measure the unemployed, measure the rate of emigration and then proceed to borrow enough money or to get enough money to carry out such employment schemes as will absorb all the people who are unemployed, in the areas where they are unemployed, at the time they are unemployed, and in the occupation which they wish to follow, which is the problem of unemployment in this country.
Comment on this
It is rather pathetic to find somebody like Deputy Childers, who purports to have a reasonable degree of economic knowledge, meandering into a sea of pre-election promises to try to make a case for himself. Pathetic might be the proper way to describe the situation in which he and his Party now find themselves. After 16 years of stewardship of this nation's affairs this Government was forced into a situation where it had to stop wild extravagances, stupendous expenditure on wild-cat schemes and at the same time orient the country towards an economic era of balance where capital investment would be made in schemes and in land that would ultimately show a recoupment to the nation.
It is interesting to watch the divergence of views expressed on the Fianna Fáil Front Bench now. Deputy Lemass, in typical Deputy Lemass truculence, was trying to make divisions where he had hoped they might be found. The real gall and the real bitterness that poor Deputy Lemass is suffering from is that the divisions that he and his colleagues, secreted so often in their chamber at the other end of the House, hoped for and wished for, have not come to pass. He is gradually realising that the hope that he was able to give in a desperate kind of way to Fianna Fáil supporters throughout the country that the Government would split has gone and that he now must face the isolation that he and his Party have earned by 16 years of gross, stupid misgovernment.
I am saying this not to give the Taoiseach a slap in the back but because I feel my constituency wants me to say it to him that we are proud of his captaincy of this ship of State and proud of the achievements of his Government in the last 12 months.
Fianna Fáil come in here and bleat about unemployment. Two schemes of major national importance came into this Dáil within the last couple of months and, thanks to Fianna Fáil rambling stupidity, neither of them has become effective law yet to enable employment to be given to people whom they say need employment. No amount of speech-making in Dáil Éireann will change the country's honest belief that both the Local Government (Works) Bill and the Land Reclamation Bill could be in full steam but for Fianna Fáil's stupidity and but for the fact, in particular, that they were directing personal spleen and invective against a man who has proved to be the success he is in the Department of Agriculture. No amount of talking is going to get you out of it. You were never able to do anything constructive and I suppose we can expect nothing but destruction from you. It is ingrained in your very foundation and in your very development.
Comment on this
Deputy Little will have to bear a bit more before I am finished, because he is not a monument of intelligence to the last Administration. I want to say that, looking at the picture after 18 months, looking at it with the eyes of a young man, in common with people of my age, I can now see a genuine hope for a future in this country for ourselves because we are getting down to the problem of increasing basically the national wealth. As I have often said, it does not matter what avocation one follows, we are ultimately and in the final analysis dependent on the one real wealth, the actual land and the produce therefrom. The sanity and wisdom of investing our own money to improve our own property, our own land, cannot be questioned by any economist. It is rational, it is reasonable, to put money into something which gives complete security and in which you have the nation's resource and the nation's labour effort to ensure reasonable return for the investment, not to any particular section of the community, not to any particular type of parasite, but to the nation as a whole and in general.
It is rather interesting to listen to economic theories such as are sometimes advanced by Deputy Childers, but there is one thing that the Taoiseach can rest assured of, that is, that those who are the mainstay of this country, the farmer and his labourer, are satisfied now that they have a Government that is putting them in the forefront of the picture, treating them, not as menials or mendicants but as the keystone and the centre-piece in the rehabilitation and redevelopment of the national economy. I say "treat him as he should be treated, as the person who is, always has been and always will be, with God's help, the keystone of all Irish development, economic or national". I can say to the Taoiseach without hesitation that the people are feeling already, in every farmyard throughout the length and breadth of Ireland, the benefits that have accrued to them through the wisdom of his Government's attitude in the conclusion of the trade agreement with Britain.
Comment on this
You stick your cart in the gap where you could not put a gate and you let your wife do the farming.
Comment on this
The position is this: that poor Deputy Walsh can cackle all he likes about the chickens, but the women in the farmyards of Ireland know that, if Providence had not taken the hand of Deputy Smith off the Department of Agriculture, they would be lucky if they could get 1/6 a dozen for their eggs next month. That will never sink into the cranium of poor Deputy Walsh, but it has already been acknowledged and acepted by the Irish farmer's wife as something sound and sensible which Fianna Fáil would never have been capable of. I was surprised that when Deputy Walsh interjected "chickens" that he did not interject "bacon", because we now see bacon in the country for the first time for a long time, and we have not to ask a Fianna Fáil T.D. "could you get a bit of it for us?"
Let me come back to major Government policy and say this in no spirit of criticism. I would like the Taoiseach to know that in my constituency we are anxious that his schemes should be pressed forward as rapidly as possible so that sneers or jeers at a hiatus between the Local Works Bill and the cut in the road grant can never be made. I want to warn the Taoiseach that Fianna Fáil have done their best to obstruct the Works Bill. I am only urging him now, as a supporter of his Government, that he should use his good offices to see that that Bill is put into top gear as quickly as possible because, as I said on the Second Reading of it: "As soon as it gets working it is going to give Fianna Fáil the works."
In conclusion, I should like the Taoiseach to know that throughout the length and breadth of the country there is a gathering force behind his Government. The people know and appreciate not only his own individual sacrifices but the sacrifices made by many of his colleagues in their efforts to govern this country wisely and well for the benefit of the people as a whole. There is a welcome warmth there to let us know that this nation realises now that there are men running it big enough and able enough to put the country before any other consideration. I want to say to him in all earnestness: Steer your ship as well in the future as you have in the past; we are behind you, we are proud of you and our nation is only waiting to acclaim you.
Comment on this
I take it this is the only opportunity we have of examining what the Taoiseach has been doing during the preceding 12 months. As Taoiseach or captain of the team, he has responsibility for every member of the team. Those of us who have any connection with teams know that, unless you have all the team pulling together, you are not going to have a successful team. As regards the team we have here under the leadership of the Taoiseach, I think it will be agreed that all of them do not pull in the same direction. In addition we have as members of that team men who are misfits in their jobs. Last year, when speaking on the trade agreement with Britain, I think I told the Taoiseach that, unless he made a change in the Department of Agriculture, he would ruin agriculture in this country. Now, to a great extent my words have come true as far as tillage is concerned. As many Deputies know, there is a feeling of unrest and uncertainty amongst tillage farmers. We have people who, when the emergency had ended, and who had made money——
Comment on this
The Deputy should differentiate between Government policy and the policy of a Government Department.
Comment on this
Can I not discuss the policy of the Government with particular reference to agriculture?
Comment on this
That is what I am doing. There is this uncertainty that has been created by the Minister for Agriculture. It is one of the matters which I want to deal with.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not go into details of the policy of the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
I will brush them aside so. The Taoiseach does not like to be reminded of all the things that the Minister for Agriculture has done during the past 12 months, and does not want to take responsibility for them.
Comment on this
I glory in what the Minister for Agriculture has done, but I am not here to answer in this debate for the Minister.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is answerable to this House for every act of every Minister sitting on the Government Front Bench.
Comment on this
The Deputy is making a mistake. The Taoiseach is responsible for general Government policy, but not for the policy of a particular Department, whether it be the Department of Agriculture, the Department of Industry and Commerce, the Department of External Affairs or any other. There is a particular policy in respect of each Department, but it is general Government policy that the Taoiseach is responsible for.
Comment on this
No. The Ceann Comhairle pointed out, when this debate opened, that that could not be done.
Comment on this
I think I have a responsibility to remind the Taoiseach of some of the things which the Minister for Agriculture did during the past 12 months, and of some of the speeches that he made during that period. Take the question of tillage. Take Government policy at the present time as it has been enunciated by the Minister for Agriculture. The farmers who produced wheat and beet to feed the people during the emergency and made money, and who, notwithstanding the gibes and the sneers during the emergency and prior to it from the people now sitting on the opposite benches, were in a position to buy machinery. What are these people to do now with the machinery which they have?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy address one question to himself. What is he going to do about conforming to the rules of the Chair and not be asking questions?
Comment on this
The Chair cannot make it clearer to the Deputy that he must only discuss general Government policy. The matter he is endeavouring to discuss arose on the Vote for the Department of Agriculture. That was discussed in detail when the Minister's Estimate was under consideration. If we are to go over all the Departments on the Taoiseach's Vote, clearly we will have all the Estimates discussed again. That is what has to be avoided, and the Ceann Comhairle made that clear this afternoon.
Comment on this
I am sorry, I did not mean it in that way. The Taoiseach had some documents in his hand and he gave us figures relating to various aspects of production, agricultural and industrial.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach referred to trade pacts, which have a specific relationship to agriculture. Surely, Deputy Walsh is entitled to refer to the advantages or disadvantages, as he sees them, arising out of the trade pact to which the Taoiseach referred?
Comment on this
I did not interrupt Deputy Walsh on that. He talked about machinery that was purchased and, clearly, that was discussed on the Vote for the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
I will mention more about machinery, and that is in connection with the amount to be spent in rural areas under the two measures that were introduced here, the Local Authorities (Works) Bill and the Land Reclamation Bill. The Taoiseach referred to the amount that would be spent in rural areas as a result of these measures, but he forgot to mention the amount withheld by the Government from the rural workers when the grant of £2,500,000 was taken from the roads. In the coming 12 months the only provision made under the Land Reclamation Bill is for £1,000,000, thereby indicating that the people in the rural areas will lose £1,500,000. If I cannot discuss agriculture, I do not see any purpose in standing up here to talk. Agriculture is the one thing I want to refer to. Other Deputies dealt with the industrial situation, but nobody yet has had a chance of discussing the agricultural policy of the Government.
Comment on this
Is not the Taoiseach responsible for the Government—has he not collective responsibility?
Comment on this
It is no use finding questions like that at me. I endeavoured to tell the Deputy what the Taoiseach is responsible for—for general Government policy. But that does not mean that a Deputy can traverse the field already covered in respect of every Government Department.
Comment on this
When the Taoiseach was introducing his Estimate, did he not link it up with the question of agriculture—that we were preparing vast schemes for the improvement of agriculture? He was nearly a quarter of an hour on agriculture.
Comment on this
I did not stop Deputy Walsh from talking about agriculture in general way. It was only when he came to the details and connected them with the Department that I intervened.
Comment on this
I take it I cannot discuss agriculture in detail, but what is the agricultural policy of the Government? Is there any special policy for the tillage farmer? This Government, through the Minister for Agriculture, have fixed a price for wheat for five years. All they have done in that case is that they have extended the period over which that price will be paid. There is no price guaranteed for barley, oats or potatoes and there was no increase granted in the price of milk. The present price of milk was fixed in 1947 by the then Minister at 1/2 and 1/4 a gallon. Since then there have been increases in labour costs and the cost of production generally. Do the Government intend to do anything to compensate milk producers for these increases? We have been told that agriculture is in a more flourishing condition than under Fianna Fáil. I deny that. The only thing that has improved is the price of beef and store cattle.
Comment on this
Who was responsible for that? Not the Government. Do not take any credit for it. The people know very well who is responsible for the increase in the price of barley. The Beet Growers' Association are, and not the Government. You would like to chime in on it, but I know you cannot. You will not get away with that. There is no guarantee for these commodities. We have had experience of the Government policy also in taking away the subsidy from farmers' butter.
Comment on this
I will not discuss it; I mention it in passing as part of the policy of the Government. There is no use in the Taoiseach telling us there has been an improvement from the agriculturist's point of view. There is no improvement. He has no stability or security, such as he had under the Fianna Fáil Government. If he is a tillage farmer he does not know whether he will have a market for his crops. We had experience in relation to potatoes and oats last year. There was an advertisement issued last spring showing how the farmers could help.
Comment on this
It is Departmental policy. The Taoiseach is not responsible for leaflets issued by the Department; he is not responsible for administration. The Deputy should differentiate between administration and policy. The issue of leaflets is surely an administrative act.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach and many of his supporters said that because of Fianna Fáil those two new schemes could not be put into operation until now. In what way did Fianna Fáil obstruct the Government in putting these Bills through the House? They actually helped to have them put right. The Minister responsible for them accepted amendments from this side without discussion. Did that prove there was obstruction? Did it not prove there was help given in putting them through? I heard Deputy Collins talking about obstruction from this side. There has been no obstruction, and if there has been criticism it was constructive criticism.
We heard many wild statements made here and through the country by Deputies opposite. We know the hypocrites who went through the country shedding crocodile tears and we know the trickery and deception that have been put across the people.
Comment on this
I will give you plenty of them. For one thing we have the cost of living. Prior to the election we were told that it would be reduced by 30 per cent. What is the result? Has the cost of living gone down?
Comment on this
How much has the cost of living gone down? It is three points lower than it was in 1947 and the only reductions made since 1947 were those made by the Fianna Fáil Government when they reduced the price of tea by 2/2 per lb., sugar by 2d. per lb., bread by ½d. per lb. and flour by 1/- per stone. What has this Government done? It has placed unsubsidised flour and sugar on the market—flour at 7/- per stone and sugar at 7½d. per lb. You cannot hoodwink the people. That is mere trickery and deception. It will not work. The people are not such great fools as the Deputies on the Government Benches think they are.
Comment on this
If the Deputies on those benches are any indication of the happiness that exists in the country it shows the happiness there must be when you have to cling together in order to remain over there. It does not show a terrible lot of happiness.
Comment on this
I take it the Taoiseach will accept responsibility for his Ministers and the members of the various Parties constituting the Goveernment when they go around the country telling the people what they are going to do. For example, down in West Cork the Minister for Lands stated that if Bill Murphy was elected he, the Minister, promised the full support of the Land Commission to the people of West Cork.
Comment on this
Is it not Government policy? Surely, it was Government policy there because they all came together in order to elect Deputy Murphy.
Comment on this
Is it a fact then that the Taoiseach has no longer any responsibility or control over his Ministers once he leaves the precincts of this House?
Comment on this
The Chair is endeavouring to explain to the Deputy what the responsibility of the Taoiseach is.
Comment on this
I warned the Deputy before that he will not imply that the Chair has said things which the Chair has not said. The Chair neither implied nor said that the Taoiseach does not accept responsibility for his Ministers.
Comment on this
It was also said from Government platforms in West Cork that the Land Commission was empty of land and that there were no farms to be divided when this Government took over. During the past 12 months I have sent in a list of farms in my own constituency and in every case the reply has come back that these lands are not required.
Comment on this
That is Land Commission administration and not the policy of the Taoiseach's Department. If the Deputy continues on these lines I shall have to ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
This debate is becoming very restricted. Am I allowed to discuss the wheat and beet policy? We have the Minister for Agriculture talking about wheat and beet. We know what he said about them in the past. I would like to know if the Taoiseach stands over the following statement taken from Volume 106, column 2042 of Dáil Debates of 18th June, 1947.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Surely it is not fair to barrack a Deputy like that. Surely he can say who made the statement afterwards just as easily as before.
Comment on this
Certainly I will give you the name. The statement was made here on the 18th June, 1947. It is reported at column 2042 of Volume 106 of Dáil Debates.
Comment on this
It seems to me that this is something somebody said before the Taoiseach became Taoiseach. I submit the Deputy should give the name of the person he is quoting.
Comment on this
The Deputy has given the reference and any Deputy who wishes can check the reference and see who made the statement. The Deputy has also promised the Chair that he will give the name of the person who made the statement.
Comment on this
"Some day I am convinced that beet will go up the spout after peat and wheat." There is hardly any necessity for me to tell Deputy Timoney or anybody else, who made that statement. Does the Taoiseach stand over that statement? Does he stand over this statement: "I want to say again with emphasis that when one ton of wheat from abroad is available to this country again I would not be seen dead in a field of wheat on my land in this country because I know that that whole rotten fraud in fact was invoked to permit the Rank interests and the other milling interests in this country to charge our people 30/- a cwt. for flour when they were selling it in Liverpool for 19/-. I will not have to worry because the wheat scheme is as dead as a door nail."
Comment on this
Therefore, the Taoiseach cannot be responsible for that statement and the Deputy should not have read that statement.
Comment on this
I want to know if that Minister has changed his mind and if he has given any indication to the Taoiseach——
Comment on this
On a point of order. It is hardly fair to a Deputy who is not familiar with the work of the House over the year to make fine distinctions between policy and details of policy.
Comment on this
With regard to what the policy was as expressed before the election and what it is after the election.
Comment on this
Deputy Little must realise that the Chair gave Deputy Walsh every opportunity. I did not close him down until I was compelled to do so. He is clearly endeavouring to get past the Chair in some of these matters.
Comment on this
I quite appreciate that it would not be reasonable to expect the Taoiseach to deal point by point with the various matters raised in this debate. I feel, however, that there is one matter with which he must deal when he comes to reply. He will not mind my asking him to do so because it is a matter of very great importance. It was dealt with specifically by Deputy Lemass when he complained about charges of corruption made prior to the general election. One of the examples which Deputy Lemass gave was the allegation that people who were not affiliated to Fianna Fáil and who did not make their applications through the Fianna Fáil Cumainn had very little chance of being granted old age pensions. Deputy Lemass, as is to be expected, denies that the affiliations of any particular applicant had any effect whatever on his prospects. Accepting unreservedly Deputy Lemass's denial, I have to say that it was the custom to cash in upon the influence which it was believed Government Deputies then had. Supporters of the then Government did not deny that Government Deputies had more influence than Opposition Deputies in their dealings with the Departments. I am merely giving that as an example and I think it is necessary to go into that detail to try to make my point.
The declaration which I want to suggest is that representations from any Deputy, irrespective of Party, will receive the same consideration from the various Departments. It is important that there should be that confidence in the impartiality of the Government and it is important that the people, the majority of whom are behind the Government and have put their confidence in it, should have it made clear to them that it does not matter what Deputy makes representations, those representations will receive identical consideration. I think it would be a very healthy thing for the present Government to have such a declaration made. It would dispel that atmosphere of suspicion and would make every public representative feel that he had the same weight as other representatives behind representations which he made. I think it would be a very bad thing, from this Government's point of view, if it were believed or said throughout the country that more heed will be paid to the representations of a Deputy on the Government side than will be paid to the representations of a Deputy on the Opposition Benches. I should like it to be known that any of the Deputies opposite could go on the same assurance that their representations would be attended to.
That is the only point with which I want to deal save to compliment with genuine sincerity the Taoiseach on the manner in which he has managed the Government of this country for the past 18 months. As one of the other Deputies said, from the political point of view he has certainly grown in stature. Great tribute was paid to him 18 months ago and after a year and a half we can still state that he has proved himself fully worthy of the confidence and trust placed in him by the people's representatives here. The peope themselves have endorsed that confidence and trust placed in him.
Comment on this
I was glad to hear from the Taoiseach this afternoon a statement to the effect that they had woken up at last, that a number of the foolish statements they had made in days gone by and up to very recently were now changed and that the Government were prepared to adopt some better type of tactics than they have in days gone by. I think that now the Dáil is finishing up this particular session and going away on a long holiday they are entitled to have from the Taoiseach some reasonable explanation that perhaps he should have given to-day but which he may give when he is replying to this particular Vote, as to what immediate steps are going to be taken by the Government by way of relieving the unemployment position that exists throughout the country and by way of solving the emigration problem.
In so far as even this new departure from the old policy of the Government regarding peat production is concerned, that in spite of all the statements they made regarding the damage that was done to the Phoenix Park, they are now prepared to go ahead even on a much larger scale than Fianna Fáil with peat production, in my particular county this year there will be much less employment given on peat schemes than there has been for a long time past. I have also noticed that in spite of the statements made by the Minister for Lands regarding the speeding up of land division throughout the country, to-day there are 700 people less employed by the Land Commission than there were a year ago. To my mind that is not an indication that the Government are making any reasonably decent effort to speed up land division. We have, for a long time past, been listening to various statements made regarding the putting into operation of the arterial drainage scheme. No matter how the present Government try to boost up their particular work in that direction, I am afraid that anybody in this country who is looking forward to work in the near future on drainage or to any effort being made by this Government to give effect to the Arterial Drainage Act, is not alone misled up to the present, but there does not seem to be much hope of any work being done in the future. The only thing that has been done is that the Taoiseach, having been presented with some sort of a whistle, blew it down at the Brosna scheme which was, of course, prepared and ready to be put into operation when we were going out of office.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins is always very sincere in what he is talking about. I think the facts in connection with the Brosna scheme have been made pretty well known to everybody throughout the country. Even the Parliamentary Secretary has clearly admitted that the scheme was prepared, so he must know something more.
Comment on this
I should like to hear the Deputy without interruption. There are no appointed censors of Deputies' speeches here, except the Chair.