Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach.
Contributions 198–414 of 414. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Every Deputy in this House clearly realises and understands that this question of drainage is one of the most important problems confronting the Government, no matter what Party is in office. Some decent effort must be made to solve that problem if it is ever to be solved. For a long time past questions have been put to me time and again down the country in connection with this matter. Some months ago an announcement was made that the Parliamentary Secretary was to give a broadcast on drainage but at the eleventh hour that broadcast was cancelled. I do not know what was at the back of it.
Comment on this
I hold that this broadcast was cancelled because the Government were not prepared to go ahead with the schemes which we thought were in contemplation. We are entitled to a certain amount of suspicion when something like that happens behind the closed doors of Government offices.
Comment on this
I do not know. Again, we have been listening for the last 12 months to talk about a White Paper on social services. The Minister came along practically a month ago and told us that it was presented to the Government for consideration. Here we are going to pop away on a long holiday and that means that this question will be again held up until the Dáil reassembles. We have had many promises made by the Government since they took office, for instance, in reference to the question of teachers' salaries. That is another problem that has not yet been solved. We had an Old I.R.A. Pensions Bill introduced. but that is all any of us knows about it. However, I suppose it will keep the people quiet for the time being. So long as the Government can keep the people quiet by promises they are quite satisfied to carry on from day to day.
We had a good deal of what I would describe as cheap talk from the Taoiseach to-day in connection with the Government's agricultural policy. A scheme has been introduced which is going to be operated in a few counties only. I notice that the West of Ireland has been completely left out. If there is any part of Ireland in which the land is deteriorating, it certainly must be the West because the vast majority of the farmers there are small farmers and, being small farmers, they are compelled to till the same fields year after year. Speaking for my own county I expected that Galway was one place that might have been considered when the question of priority was being settled. There is one suggestion that I should like to make to the Taoiseach in connection with the scheme for the improvement of farms throughout the country. We are trying to improve land at the present time for the purpose of obtaining a better output but in the West of Ireland there is the peculiar problem that many farmers live a considerable distance from the main roads. They live along old boreens which are a mile, a mile and a half, or in some cases, two miles from the main road. They are good farmers and produce good crops but their difficulty is that they cannot get their produce to the market because of the condition of these boreens.
Comment on this
I think it is a matter that the Taoiseach should take up with some other Department because it is one of the most urgent problems confronting us in the West of Ireland. I am putting the suggestion to the Taoiseach that something might be done to bring about an improvement in the condition of these farmers. We heard of course again this afternoon from the back-benchers of the Government Party allegations as to the influence Fianna Fáil Deputies had in different Departments. It was not exactly put in that way but it was called political corruption while we were in office. I think Deputy Lemass made the position quite clear in his statement from this side of the House in that connection. I think that any Deputy who tries, even in the cute way that Deputy Timoney did, to convey the impression that Fianna Fáil Deputies had an undue influence in the Departments is just casting a reflection on civil servants.
Comment on this
We all recollect the efforts made by Fianna Fáil to cut that out. I remember when the Land Commission policy was to give land to men who had money and to leave the small uneconomic holder without any if he was not in a position to get some capital. We had to get over that by tightening up the Land Commission machinery to see that people with small valuations got land irrespective of their political affiliations.
Comment on this
Deputy Killilea is making one statement that he is prepared to stand over and that is that we were the Party to control the activities of the Land Commission in so far as we made them deal with holdings of £10 or £12 valuation before they dealt with any others. I think that has worked out fairly satisfactorily. The same question arises in connection with old age pensions.
In connection with old age pensions, we left the doors wide open to every Deputy to make representations, because the Fianna Fáil Government always had in mind giving the poor sections of the community every opportunity of having representations made on their behalf by everybody who wished to make them, whether he was a Deputy or not. So far as I know, these representations were always received and dealt with in a satisfactory manner by the Department concerned. The funny thing about it is that we have Deputies trying to use the argument to-day that it was only Fianna Fáil Deputies who could get an old age pensions for anybody at that time. Yet Deputies who are now behind the Government and who were then sitting on the Opposition Benches made statements at that time that if persons wanted to have their old age pensions looked after properly they would have to go to an opposition Deputy who would get a better hearing in the Department. The impression is still being created throughout the country that the only way to get a minor improvement scheme or a bog development scheme carried out quickly is by going to somebody who sits behind the Government. That is entirely untrue and is only trying to create a false impression in order to capture votes. The people fully realise that every Deputy has the same opportunity of making his case in any Department and that these representations always receive due consideration.
A number of Deputies have put up the case from time to time that it is nearly time for the Taoiseach to insist on his Ministers being of one mind in connection with Government policy. Time and again they have cited cases where different Ministers advocated a different policy in connection with some matter. It is nearly time to have a clear understanding from the Government on that matter so that the people will know where they stand. The Taoiseach himself is one who has blundered more than others. Statements made outside this country relating to national policy did not come well from the head of the Government. Statements on national policy should always be made inside this country and, as a matter of fact, inside this House. It would show more respect for this Assembly and for the country as a whole than making statements in Ottawa and other places which to-day are the cause of a lot of controversy throughout the country.
We are adjourning now for a long holiday. It is our hope and wish that some of the promises made will be given effect to before we come back, that is, if some of us come back at all. The suggestions made from this side of the House should be given effect to, instead of the Government coming along in 12 months' time and realising that they should have been carried out, in the same way as the Government have come to realise that a lot of the work done by Fianna Fáil in days gone by was of great benefit to the people. The Government now seem to have recognised, in connection with the short-wave broadcasting station and other schemes, that they were foolish when they made silly statements about these matters and they are now prepared to put these things into operation. We all welcome that and hope that in the future the Government will be a little more reasonable.
Comment on this
Were it not for the line pursued by Deputy Lemass and Deputy Childers in this debate I would not have intervened. Criticism of a most unjust kind was levelled at our Party, especially by Deputy Childers. I think it is only right that, as a representative of a rural area, I should reply to the suggestions contained in the speech of Deputy Childers. We have been attacked left, right and centre by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party for failing to implement the complete policy put up by Clann na Poblachta prior to the election. We have not changed one white of that policy. We are, however, working in conjunction with other Parties in this Government on a ten-point programme. We hope to see that ten-point programme carried out and, at the rate at which it is being tackled, I have no hesitation in saying that not alone will that ten-point programme be achieved, but much more work will be done as well. I should like to compare the achievements of the past 16 months and the policy pursued since this Government came into office with that of its predecessor.
Comment on this
As a comparison. Since the present Government came into office efforts have been made in the field of social welfare. Increases have been given to the needy section of the community, increases that are not as much as we would like them to be, but increases on what was given by Fianna Fáil. A great land rehabilitation scheme has been passed in this House after undergoing severe criticism and definite obstruction from Fianna Fáil. The Local Authorities (Works) Bill was passed in spite of the obstructive tactics adopted by Fianna Fáil. There can be no denying that the tactics of Fianna Fáil in regard to that Bill were nothing else but obstruction.
Comment on this
We had a large number of amendments to the Bill tabled by Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Moran.
Comment on this
They talked for hours on end. At that time the West Cork election was being fought and they knew that the Local Authorities (Works) Bill would be an issue in that election. When word came back to the Fianna Fáil bosses that their obstruction to this Bill was meeting with the disapproval of the farmers in West Cork, they dropped their obstructive tactics like a hot brick and let the Bill go through.
Deputy Childers tried to insinuate that a slur was cast on the officials responsible for determining the rate of old age pensions and widows and orphans pensions. As has already been stated, a breath of fresh air came into Irish political life since Fianna Fáil went out of office. Prior to the present Government achieving office, it was a wellknown fact in every rural constituency that the local tin goods of the Fianna Fáil clubs whispered throughout the areas "If you do not vote for Deputy So-and-So, your father and mother will not get the old age pension. If you do not vote for Deputy Killilea or Deputy Boland, your son will not get work on the roads. If you do not vote for Deputy So-and-So, when that farm of land is being divided your father or your mother will not get a holding of land." Those were the tactics pursued by Fianna Fáil in order to stifle political opinion in rural Ireland.
Comment on this
The aim of Fianna Fáil was to insert the tentacles of its octopus organisation into every section of the community and every sphere of national life, to bind the country people to their organisation either by intimidation or cajolery. The last general election proved that they can never again hope to cod the people as they did for 16 years.
Criticism has been levelled at the attempts of the present Government to solve the problem of unemployment. The solution Fianna Fáil had for the problem of unemployment was the emigrant ship. All through the war we had the spectacle of people with labels around their necks, emigrating from this country and Fianna Fáil thanked God that they had that solution to the problem. I am not throwing bouquets, or anything like it, at the present Government for their efforts to end emigration or unemployment but there can be no doubt whatever that they are making a genuine attempt, first, with the Local Authorities (Works) Bill, to provide work of a productive nature in rural Ireland, not to give three weeks or six weeks work on a petty minor relief scheme. The only thing Fianna Fáil could promise rural workers was six or seven weeks work in winter on a bog road and keep them on the dole for the rest of the period.
The question of turf was referred to. I do not want to go into that in detail. I do not want to open up a discussion as to who is responsible for the cessation of the hand-won turf scheme. We know perfectly well that the decision to abandon that scheme was taken by the Fianna Fáil Administration prior to this Government coming into office but they insist on saying that they were not responsible for that and they will repeat that ad nauseam in the country in the hope that they will dupe their followers who are dwindling in numbers every day.
I want to see the Government policy in regard to Bord na Móna implemented. There is no doubt whatever that were it not for the war we would still be in as bad a way as every with regard to turf production. It was the lesson of the war years that drove home to Fianna Fáil the vital necessity of developing as far as possible our natural fuel resources. They are to be commended in that respect in spite of the fact that it took a war to teach them the lesson. We must not revert, under any circumstances, to the position that obtained when coal was imported in preference to using native fuel. No coal should be allowed outside the City of Dublin into the rural areas. It is an established fact now that machine-won turf is equal in value and power to the best coal that can be got in England to-day. That is recognised and I see no reason in the world why our industries and business concerns should not use machine-won turf for fuel in preference to coal. I think the Government should give very serious consideration to that aspect. There are numbers of large bogs, especially in the West of Ireland, that can be developed successfully for the production of machine-won turf and that would be one other means of ending the unemployment problem.
Deputy Killilea, to give him his due, stressed the need for more work and more productive work in the West of Ireland. It is an awful pity something was not done about it in the last 16 years. He had to wait to ask the present Taoiseach to do the work his ex-Taoiseach did not do for 16 years.
Deputy Lemass referred to the team, as he described it. He described the present group of Ministers as a mediocre team. He said they were not pulling together. I would like to point out that even a mediocre team is far better at any time than a one-man team.
I want to refer to one other remark made by Deputy Lemass in connection with remarks that were made both by Deputy Norton and the Taoiseach with regard to certain industrialists in the country. It is a well known fact that certain of these gentlemen were not all they should be and Deputy Norton, in my opinion, was quite right in stating that publicly. Now we have the Fianna Fáil Party coming in here whinging on behalf of the so-called gentlemen that were insulted, mar dh'eadh, by Deputy Norton. It is a big change in the Party that went down the country 12 or 18 months ago and described themselves as the poor man's Government, that they should now cry out on behalf of the big industrialists who put the large sums of money into what Deputy Childers described as the Fianna Fáil war chest. These are the people who are anxious to see Fianna Fáil going back into power. Yet the Fianna Fáil Party went down to rural Ireland and described themselves as the poor man's Government.
Deputy Killilea referred to the question of national arterial drainage. I think I may say a few words on that on the Taoiseach's Estimate. Deputy Killilea said that the first scheme, which was the present scheme, was prepared under the Fianna Fáil Administration. We know that there was an Arterial Drainage Act of 1945. Between 1945 and April or May, 1948, not one single effort was made to get that scheme into operation. There was no machinery on the market in this country and no attempt was made to buy it, except in Britain. No attempt was made to get from foreign countries suitable machinery for dredging.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach would not have been in a position to blow that whistle for another 18 months if the present Government were not in power. I want to see further drainage schemes put into operation as soon as possible. The fact that the Brosna scheme has proved such a tremendous success and has reclaimed so much land has made the whole country conscious of the vital need for drainage. Every effort should be made abroad to purchase machinery. Get the machinery at any cost, because if the land is reclaimed and drained, it will repay the cost of the machinery one hundred fold. We will have the land rehabilitation scheme going full steam shortly. But there are several areas in the country where it cannot be put into operation until the national arterial drainage work is done first. I suggest to the Taoiseach that he should do everything possible, by going into every country where machinery is available, to try and purchase the latest dredging equipment.
Comment on this
I suppose it is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I think that national arterial drainage is a problem of national importance.
Comment on this
Quite. I did not stop the Deputy from referring to that, but when he goes on to deal with the purchase of machinery, that, surely, is a matter for the Minister concerned.
Comment on this
As I have said, a lot of useful work in connection with the land rehabilitation scheme will have to be postponed until the national arterial drainage work is got under way. I am definitely criticising the attempts that have been made so far to get it under way. I have heard the forecast made here that it will take from 15 to 20 years to reach certain parts of the country so far as that scheme is concerned. I am not prepared to accept that estimate from anybody. On previous occasions, I have heard the opinion of experts quoted in this House. On one occasion I proved that the experts' opinion in the matter of drainage was wrong. Therefore, I am not prepared to accept the estimate given here that it will take 20 years for the national arterial drainage scheme to reach certain parts of the country. That is the type of excuse that would be made in order to keep this work going on forever. It reminds one of the policy pursued in the Land Commission, that it is a body that is not there to finish a job but to stay there for all time. I do not propose to make any criticism of the Land Commission except to say that there are quite a lot of big farms and estates yet to be divided.
Comment on this
——to give all possible help to his colleague, the Minister for Lands, in this work of national importance? The land question did not start to-day or yesterday. It has been going on now for quite a considerable period. At the rate at which it is being pursued at present, I can see it going on into the next century. However, if the Chair rules that it is a matter for the Minister for Lands alone, I do not propose to take up the time of the House any longer.
Comment on this
Is that a ruling? Surely, that is a very wide question, the question of land policy. If, for instance, I were talking I certainly would be inclined to talk about it.
Comment on this
The question of dividing large farms in the West of Ireland was discussed on the Estimate for the Land Commission.
Comment on this
One of the fundamental parts of our programme was to try and put as many families as possible on the land, to make as many farms as possible economic and to put as many families as we could in security on the land. That is one of the widest questions of policy that could be discussed.
Comment on this
May I say that, if the debate broadens out on that line, I would like to reply to it?
Comment on this
A question was put to me about land division by the Land Commission. As I have said, the Deputy was not prevented from saying that land could be divided, but that he could not discuss the division of large farms in the West of Ireland.
Comment on this
I do not mind argument. The statement I made to-day was that all the Estimates cannot be reviewed now and every Minister and every Department dragged in again, a Minister to answer criticisms which he has already answered on his own Estimate. That, obviously, is not a matter for which the Taoiseach is responsible.
Comment on this
The whole question of Government policy is under review.
Comment on this
The question is, what is Government policy with regard to land division? I think that any Deputy should be able to put forward a view in the debate and say: "I know that there are a large number of farms, very large farms, in the West of Ireland, which are not distributed but which ought to be."
Comment on this
The Estimate for the Department of Lands was referred back, for what purpose? To discuss policy. If it is discussed again on this Estimate and the same Minister gives the same answer, that is the difficulty.
Comment on this
I see the difficulty, but I want to argue this: what is the meaning of discussing Government policy, which is carried out through a variety of Departments, unless you can do it on this Vote? When the Taoiseach himself was speaking to-day he spent a great part of his time dealing with matters which, naturally, come under the Department of Industry and Commerce and others under the Department of Finance. It is inevitable, of course, on the Taoiseach's Vote, that Departmental policy, which is carried out by the Departments, would come into the discussion here. I cannot see how it could be otherwise.
Comment on this
Deputy T. Walsh was not allowed to discuss certain matters. He did not get half a chance.
Comment on this
Listening to Deputy McQuillan—I am sorry he has left the House—during the earlier part of his references in this debate, made me take a note of what one of my colleagues said: "A new generation has arisen that knew not Joseph." Deputy McQuillan told us, first of all in defence of Clann na Poblachta, that the policy of Clann na Poblachta has not changed one whit and then he told us that Clann na Poblachta is in association with the Coalition Government on the ten points. Surely to goodness, the Deputies who now have some experience of what the nation can or cannot do, and who had, before they came in here, announced a policy which they now know it is not possible to fulfil, should at least be reasonable with themselves. Instead of attacking us for having done nothing in this, that or the other direction, they might, at least, admit that the dreams they had about what could be accomplished were only dreams. Let me refer to a few items to which Deputy McQuillan did not refer, but which are referred to in the policy of Clann na Poblachta. The Taoiseach told us to-day that this nation valued the tourist trade and that he hoped that millions of people from America and cross-Channel would continue to come here; that, as far as he was concerned, they would be welcome; and that they would be attracted here, as far as we could attract them, to the greatest possible extent. Compare that statement with the policy announced by Deputy McQuillan's Party, that the tourist trade was to be abolished and that tourists were "spivs" eating the bread and the butter of the poor of this country who had nothing.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot have his cake and eat it. Either that is the policy of Clann na Poblachta or it is not. The leader of the Clann na Poblachta Party, on his Estimate, indicated that he valued the millions of dollars that would accrue to this country from tourists who came here from the States. It was the policy of the Clann na Poblachta Party tightly to close down the tourist trade.
Comment on this
I say it is. There was a further item of Clann na Poblachta policy. Clann na Poblachta actually gave figures as to the extent to which they could bring about extended reafforestation. That also has to be abandoned because it is now found not to be possible and the policy of the Government, as evidenced by the Minister for Lands to-day, is to carry out reafforestation as speedily as possible, but there are certain limits within which one has to act, as to the number of acres that can be acquired and planted within a year. The Minister has not stated that it is Government policy that reafforestation shall be on the basis of unlimited acquisition of land and unlimited planting of trees, finally adopting the Clann na Poblachta policy of making our own petrol out of the surplus timber that will be available.
Comment on this
Does the Minister seriously suggest, that it is the Government's belief that, at the rate at which we will be able to plant trees on the acreage available we can look forward to the time when we will have our own petrol from our own native timber to the exclusion of petrol from America or anywhere else? Surely the Minister does not believe that?
Comment on this
The Minister stated it. That was the policy of Clann na Poblachta, and surely they should now realise that is not possible. Deputy McQuillan stated that the Fianna Fáil Government started turf development only at the outbreak of the war. There are Deputies in the House, not all on this side, who know that is absolutely incorrect. The development of turf started as far back as 1933, under the administration of the late Deputy Hugo Flinn, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. I remember the jeers and jibes from the Opposition at the time at what they considered the preposterous idea of attempting at the any time to bring about the winning of turf in any form so that it could be used as a native fuel.
Deputy McQuillan ought to be instructed to make more correct statements. If he likes, he can criticise this Party as an Opposition, or when they were in Government, but at least he should confine himself to statements that are correct. Many Deputies will remember that, in order to get the people turf-minded, members of the House travelled all over the country getting the people to understand the value of the turf scheme. When war broke out very considerable progress had been made. Deputy McQuillan now says he does not care what any experts say about drainage. If the experts say it will take 20 years to complete the drainage, the Deputy says they are wrong. Even the limited drainage that had to be undertaken for the purpose of turf development took years, and it will be a long time yet before the bogs can be properly drained to be suitable for working, particularly with machinery. Yet the Deputy could say that nothing was done by Fianna Fáil in the direction of turf development until war broke out.
Comment on this
Of course they were converted. Deputy Davin got up long before the war and questioned the amount of profit to be allowed to the coal merchants in order that they would be induced to handle turf as soon as it could be made available. Deputy Davin knows that that was long before the war. I will not deal any more with Deputy McQuillan's remarks.
I will now refer to certain matters mentioned by the Taoiseach. He gave us figures for certain years, primarily to indicate the position with regard to the balance of payments. He said that for the year 1947-48 we imported goods to the value of £131,000,000, and as regards physical exports, goods exported by us, we exported to the value of £39,000,000, approximately. There was a deficiency, so far as visible exports and imports were concerned, of £92,000,000. The Taoiseach also indicated that we had a very valuable invisible export, and here I would like to indicate to the members of Clann na Poblachta that of the £62,000,000 invisible exports in 1947, £36,000,000 were attributable to the tourist trade, but there was a net deficiency of £30,000,000 in the balance of trade that year. In 1948 our imports rose from £131,000,000 to £136,000,000. Our exports rose from £39,000,000 to £47,000,000, but our net adverse balance, without taking into account the invisible exports, had now been reduced by £3,000,000 from £92,000,000 to £89,000,000. But the invisible exports in 1948 increased from £62,000,000 to £72,000,000, reducing the net gap from £30,000,000 to £15,000,000.
Will the Taoiseach give us any further elucidation of those figures, because they are of interest and of value to enable us to understand certain trends and to make up our minds in relation to certain things. The Taoiseach may not be in a position to do so to-day, but perhaps he will some other day. Was there any change in the quantity of goods to account for these figures? In other words, did prices fall or did more goods have to be imported or exported in order to reach these figures? Did the situation occur where, in a number of cases, the same amount of goods may have been exported but at a higher price? It is important to know if that is to any extent related to these changes in prices.
I would also like to know whether, included in these figures of imports, there are any calculations for goods coming to this country under the Marshall Aid scheme. Are there imports of American goods? I know that in 1948 there could not have been much, but there might have been in the first five months of this year. The Taoiseach gave figures for the first five months of 1947, 1948 and 1949, but he did not give us, in connection with these figures, any information with regard to the invisible exports in those periods. He told us that in 1947 for the five months' period our exports were to the value of £13,000,000 and our imports £40,000,000, and there was a net deficiency in the balance of trade of £28,000,000. For the purpose of making it easier to refer to them, I have rounded these figures to full millions. In 1948 our exports for the first five months increased from £13,000,000 to £17,000,000, and in 1949 to £22,000,000. Our imports increased from £40,000,000 in 1947 to £63,000,000 in 1948 and had fallen to £48,000,000 in 1949. Is it still possible for the Taoiseach to make available to the House — I would be grateful if he could give it to us—the invisible increase for those five months in each of those years, and, further, whether or not in this period any goods under the Marshall Aid scheme are calculated and, if not, to what extent, therefore, they can be added to these figures?
From that point of view I wonder if the Taoiseach relates these statistics to the House purely for the purpose of showing achievement or improvement and is that the beginning and the end of the reference to these figures? I wonder whether there are not some members of this House who might subscribe to the idea that when the war was over and we found ourselves with a very substantial sterling credit balance, viewing the question of sterling as some of us have viewed it in the light of whether it will be loosened up or taken out of its frozen situation when some people might consider that its purchasing power might be less, it might have been a wise thing to try to transfer as much as possible of that credit balance into goods of all kinds, including consumer goods. That is a point of view to which certain people subscribe. It is a point of view against which certain other people argue. I merely refer to it from the point of view that it may not be wise just to advert to a reduction in an adverse balance in present circumstances as if it were an achievement as distinct from what may happen possibly in a year or two.
In this morning's paper—I am sure the Taoiseach saw it too—there was a suggestion made in England that the whole of the debt due to India should be cancelled. That is seriously suggested in this morning's paper. As far as we are concerned we must consider what the position is likely to be. It is uncertain. Nobody can give a complete answer. It is a matter of opinion. The other day Deputy Lemass indicated that it might be dangerous for us to detach ourselves from sterling. He pointed out that more obligations were involved in doing that than just getting away from it. To a great extent our standard of living depends upon our continued trade with our next-door neighbour.
If we break away from sterling and continue to trade with our next-door-neighbour, subsequently we may find ourselves back in the position of having re-created the same situation. I am not arguing as to whether that might or might not be good. I merely relate this to the figures the Taoiseach gave the House in order to show that there was achievement because of the reduction in the adverse trade balance. I do not say that is wrong but, at the same time I am not prepared to subscribe in toto to that view. I believe that in the circumstances of the present time where all the sterling we own is spent in England and controlled by the Board of Trade, which regulates to what extent we can spend our money even in England, it might be a good thing to transfer some of our assets into certain commodities. It is true that it would be a very wise thing to convert some of our sterling assets into steel which is so badly required for building purposes here. But it is also true that at the present time delivery of that steel might take two or three years. Therefore, we cannot convert sterling into steel even though we need the steel so very badly. I would be glad if the Taoiseach would give us the invisible figures for the first five months for each of the three years for which he gave the other figures. I would like him to consider, too, whether it would not be wise to give serious consideration to the question of what we ought to do as distinct from carrying on merely bookkeeping transactions in inter-trade in accordance with what is now recognised to be the antiquated Manchester School of Economics.
The Taoiseach gave us another series of items. From time to time appeals are made to us for co-operation. We hear appeals made to us for constructive criticism. When criticism is made, without being constructive, it is described as a waste of time, holding up business and destructive. Some credit ought to be given where credit is due. Some credit should be given to the present Opposition for what they accomplished when they were the Government and for the steps they took which has made it possible for this Government to accomplish certain things.
The Taoiseach read out the amount of capital expenditure on productive schemes for the years 1946, 1947, 1948 and 1949. Does the Taoiseach think that was a fair comparison? Why did he not go back and take the three years immediately prior to the war? After all, when Fianna Fáil came into office they had to put over here certain plans for certain developments. It took time for those developments to come about. This Government will find that a great many of their schemes will take time, too, before they reach the position of being properly implemented in relation to getting things done when the spade-work has been completed and the initial difficulties overcome. Why not give us the credit that is due to us? I think the Taoiseach said that capital expenditure on all the schemes for this year had reached a figure of something like £17,000,000.
Comment on this
Included in that is a very large expenditure on rural electrification. Will the Taoiseach agree that the plans for that rural electrification had been made by the Fianna Fáil Government some years back? Will be agree that it is only now possible to put these plans into effect because of the fact that up to this materials were not available, nor were the technical men necessary available? Both are now more readily to hand.
I do not think it was the fault of anybody in this country that we inherited from the British Government two very serious problems, our slums and a lack of hospitals for our people. Immediately after 1922 a beginning was made in respect of providing hospitals for our people and getting rid of our slums. It had reached a certain point of development; but from the years 1933-1934 onwards a rapid development took place in respect of housing and in respect of hospitalisation. A good deal of abuse has been hurled at us because it is alleged that we did nothing in connection with hospitalisation. I put a question down recently in regard to that and I was surprised to find that Fianna Fáil had built and completed new hospitals to the number of 37 in a period of six years at a cost of £4,000,000. I want to suggest to the Taoiseach and to the Minister for Health through him, that it would be very foolish for them to continue this line because the chicken will come home to roost. The Minister for Health to-day has even a more awkward position to face in that regard than we had. The Minister for Health to-day cannot get building done at the same price as we got it done in our time because materials are dearer and building costs and wages are higher. If he can, in the lifetime of this Government, show that he has built half that number of hospitals at twice the cost of the 37 built by Fianna Fáil, I shall be the first to say he has done a good job. I want to warn him that it is easy to condemn us and to criticise us without making a full disclosure of the things that we have done. But if you overdo the unfair criticism, when it comes home to roost, you will find very little sympathy. We know, on this side of the House, that there are 37 places available from the hospitals' point of view. There are groups of people in each of these areas who know these places were not there three years ago and who see them there before them now. When they hear this talk of nothing done they do not know what to say or what to believe. It is not to the credit of people who are members of this House and who can seriously examine things to, as I say, criticise things that you think we should not have done. At least give credit for things that were done and do not come into this House like baby Deputy McQuillan who does not know anything about yesterday and tell us that we did not do this or that and did not start turf development until immediately after the outbreak of the war.
I can go further. This capital sum that the Taoiseach has also mentioned, of £16,000,000 is a very substantial sum for the development of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. In the Department of Posts and Telegraphs there were plans which could not be proceeded with because there were no materials and no men. Even to-day, with the easing of the situation in the supply of materials I am aware, as every other Deputy is aware, that the Post Office could proceed even faster than it is doing to-day if it could get more skilled electricians, men who understand the technical side that is needed in post office development. We are all anxious to see telephone development going on but we are prepared also, if there is a good reason why rapid progress cannot be made, to admit that and not to find fault with the Government for something which is beyond their control. At least, if we are asked for co-operation let there be some example from that side that you are prepared to admit that certain things which are now becoming possible, would not have been possible at this particular moment if the groundwork had not been done, if the plans had not been laid and if the scheme had not been generally passed by this House in the period of the last Government.
I remember—apparently some people do not remember—that under the Fianna Fáil Government, either when the war was coming to an end or immediately after, this House introduced a Bill to make available to the Electricity Supply Board a sum of £20,000,000 for electrification with particular reference to rural electrification, £10,000,000 of which was to be subsidised by the State. I remember the Fianna Fáil Government, realising the uncertainty which would arise immediately after the war with regard to matters of finance and matters of costs, created a fund of £5,000,000 which was to be used for the purpose of subsidising further the question of building over and above the subsidy which the State gives and which the local authority gives. I suppose it may not be useful to appeal to the members of the House to recognise and to consider things as they actually are in accordance with facts.
Deputy Timoney got up here this evening and made certain suggestions after he had heard Deputy Childers denying absolutely that there was ever any interference in the administration of the old age pensions either by a Minister or a Parliamentary Secretary and saying that there were the same civil servants in charge to-day as there were then. As Deputy Killilea pointed out, we do not believe anybody who would suggest that those Deputies on the Government Benches would be in a position to do to-day what they accused us of having done yesterday. We say we do not believe it because we believe the Civil Service is above that, and it is only an attack on the integrity of the Service to suggest that.
Comment on this
Deputy Tiimoney asked the Taoiseach to clarify the position; he was not satisfied with what Deputy Childers said and possibly the Taoiseach will do so. I am only referring to it in passing. I am indicating to the members that make up the Government Benches, the Coalition group, that those of us on this side who have any experience at all of the administration of Government Departments, are quite satisfied that we will never level across the House at you people charges of corruption in the administration of any Department of State because we are satisfied that members on all sides of the House get equal justice and equal consideration from the Departments of State.
One would imagine from the way debates are conducted in this House that either we are still out on the husting getting ready for the general election which came off some 16 or 17 months ago or that our whole history began in 1945 or 1946. Nobody in this House seems to have heard of the fact that there was a world war which upset everything in the world including conditions here. Nobody gives credit for the fact that it was the Fianna Fáil Government which kept this country out of the war.
Comment on this
Under the Fianna Fáil Administration this country was kept out of the war and in addition to that this country was kept fed.
Comment on this
Charges were made here that when this Government took over they found the goods lying around which had been purchased at exorbitantly high prices and for which there was nothing but the scrap heap to-day, and that Fianna Fáil had by that method earned a reputation of squandermania to which there was no explanation.
Comment on this
A very good explanation of the Argentine wheat has been given time after time.
Comment on this
Time after time certain people on that side of the House are given explanations as to why certain things happened and why certain things arose and they will not believe them. I do not know what Deputy Rooney's question was, before. Every time I look at Deputy Rooney and I hear him interjecting I find it difficult to continue listening to him because I do not expect an intelligent question or an intelligent interruption.
Comment on this
What I want to say is that arising out of that situation certain precautions had to be taken. There was a time when certain supplies were not available at all to this country. Is it to be expected that the Government was not allowed in emergency conditions to take emergency measures and, having done so, and having brought the people safely through a period that people outside this country never believed we would get through, that they are to be judged by their actions, as if they were normal conditions and normal circumstances comparable with what we want to do as we hope to get nearer to normal conditions?
The Works Bill was cited as evidence of our holding up the work of the Government. Deputy Collins said that if there was any waiting time, from the period when the road grant money would be expended until schemes under the Works Bill could be undertaken, we were to take the blame. There is a simple way out. First of all the Works Bill was criticised from this side of the House. A number of amendments were suggested and a number were accepted. That could not be called destructive opposition. If an amendment is accepted, it is accepted because it is believed to be an improvement on the Bill and therefore it is constructive opposition. There is, however, as I say, a way out. If Deputy Collins feels that the putting into operation of the Works Bill and the employment that will arise from it are going to be delayed, why not give an additional road grant to enable the workers to carry on road work for the period of three or six months that may elapse until schemes under the Works Bill are ready for operation? You will not be spending both sums of money at the one time so that that can be easily got over. Surely we are not going to examine legislation passing through this House merely from the point of view of getting it through quickly in order that employment will flow from it without any regard whatever to the rights of individuals affected by it or the rights of communities under the Constitution?
I am glad, in any event, to have heard certain statements from the Taoiseach. I am glad he has made it quite clear that the policy of the Government is to do everything possible even further to increase the tourist traffic. That is one item in respect to which we shall not hear any criticism when the next election comes around, because we are now all united on it.
Comment on this
So long as the Minister does not consider it a discourtesy. I shall not answer them. I am glad to see certain changes taking place. We are apparently unanimous in this House now on a number of things— on the national issue and on the tourist issue. I hope when other Deputies intervene in the debate they will take the line of examining the Taoiseach's introductory speech and see can they suggest improvements in any of the matters that Deputies have in mind instead of taking this opportunity to attack Fianna Fáil. I hope they will get down to business and try to improve matters generally for the people and the country.
Comment on this
There are a few matters to which I should like to refer on this Estimate. First of all, I should like to express my own appreciation of the work which the Taoiseach, as Leader of this Government, has done for the country in the last few months. I think that there are few Deputies in this House who can, with any feeling of conviction, find fault in any way with the administration of the Taoiseach and the manner in which he has led not merely the Government Party but this country. There are many people outside this House and outside this country who, in the last three months, felt a thrill of pride when they heard the clear definition of Ireland's position in relation to outside countries, given by the Taoiseach in the words he uttered in O'Connell Street. I think the Taoiseach deserves the confidence of Deputies as representatives of the people for the manner in which he carried out his duties during the last 12 months.
We have had during this debate one semi-serious speech from the Front Opposition Bench, from Deputy Lemass, and a number of very silly speeches from back-benchers on the Opposition side. Of course we have come to expect from the Opposition in these days that blend of foolishness and ripe old age which shows a diversity of views in the Opposition. I was interested to hear Deputy Lemass refer, with a certain amount of mock gravity, to this country's position vis-a-vis the sterling area and asking for a definition and clarification of the Government's policy in relation to sterling. I do not think there is anybody, either in this House or outside it, who does not appreciate the gravity of that entire question of our sterling position and the policy that will have to be worked out in relation to it. At the same time, many of us realise that the working out of that policy may be something beyond our own ability to achieve. I was interested particularly in hearing Deputy Lemass, presumably speaking on behalf of the Opposition, voicing his doubts and expressing his own and his Party's defence of the sterling position. I know that, while in opposition, at times the memories of Fianna Fáil Deputies may be short but I remember in this House no later than last Thursday night two Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party suggesting that they were against the link with sterling and apparently that it should be broken. I remember Deputy Dr. Maguire having the audacity to challenge the Minister for External Affairs, when he was replying to the Vote on his Department and saying to him: “Do not imagine that I agree with the link with sterling.”
There you had a Fianna Fáil Deputy giving his views in relation to sterling, and, mind you, he was not alone, because from the great protester and the great protector of sterling, Deputy Lemass himself, we learned on last Thursday night that a break in the link with sterling would have been carried out by Fianna Fáil long before if it could have been done. What is the use of Fianna Fáil pretending to fulfil the responsible position of an Opposition Party in this country if they express diverse and different views from day to day? What is their purpose in having two or three different voices and different minds on any particular item of policy unless it be their considered view that if you say one thing to one section of the people and something else to another section, you are going to get votes from all sections? Deputy de Valera laughs. I know he is a sufficiently long time in politics to realise that that sort of game just does not work. I am sure he appreciates after many years of political life that if his Party is to remain a political force they must, even as an opposition Party, have a definite policy. I used to hear years ago Fianna Fáil Ministers, as they then were, suggesting that different Parties opposed to them had no policy and, because they had no policy, they had no political future. I trust now that Fianna Fáil will bring those words home to their own minds, because it is perfectly clear so far as the country is concerned that in many things even the most loyal of Fianna Fáil supporters and followers are beginning to wonder whether they have any policy. Listening to debates here or at crossroads to Fianna Fáil speakers, they find that Fianna Fáil speakers trim their sails with each veering wind that blows and a new subject and a new policy spring up each year.
Comment on this
I am referring to the statement made by the opening spokesman on behalf of the Opposition in relation to our sterling position and commenting on the fact that from what that spokesman said there does not appear to be any policy in relation to the matter. From other speakers besides Deputy Lemass we have heard criticism, very trivial criticism, of the Taoiseach's administration during the last 12 months. From Deputy Briscoe we have had the picture of the penitent Fianna Fáil Deputy who is very worried about the position of his Party and very indignant that Ministers did not mete out sufficient praise for whatever was done by Fianna Fáil.
I do not intend to pursue Deputy Briscoe's line of argument in that connection, but I was interested to hear him say that the capital expenditure in relation to rural electrification was as a result of a plan in detail drawn up by the last Administration. I am quite certain that that is so. I have no doubt that such expenditure as may now be carried out is directly or indirectly as a result of plans laid down during the Fianna Fáil Administration. I would have thought, however, that when Deputy Briscoe raised that matter he would go a little further, that he might, perhaps, throw his mind back to the fact that the necessity for rural electrification arises from the commencement of the Shannon scheme, that rural electrification was part and parcel of the original scheme. Of course, it was opposed in those days by Deputies opposite on the grounds that it was some sort of a white elephant and could never fulfil a function here.
There is one matter I should like to refer to which has been referred to by Deputy Childers, Deputy McQuillan and some other Deputies, and that is the question of turf. I do not intend to reopen any of the discussions we have had in the past concerning turf, but I want to say to the Taoiseach that the question of hand-won turf is a matter of considerable importance to the country and of considerable concern to many Deputies representing turf areas. Any Deputy who knows anything about turf-producing areas appreciates that proper hand-won turf production is a sure means of maintaining a proper rural population in turf areas and that, consequently, attention to hand-won turf production must be part and parcel of the policy of any Government aiming at ending emigration and providing a better life in rural Ireland. That, I think, cannot be gainsaid by any Deputy. I am not blaming the last Administration in particular or any particular body or authority for it, but the unfortunate fact remains that a possible and potential market for hand-won turf produced in the bogs of Ireland was destroyed through faulty administration of the fuel industry during the emergency years. That has caused considerable damage and it is only now we are beginning to recover from the damage caused during those years, damage, let it be said, caused by people and by concerns that never were in any way engaged directly in the production of turf, but who saw in the production of turf a way of making easy money.
Comment on this
I am only referring to it as it has been raised by three or four Deputies. I would suggest to the Taoiseach that Bord na Móna, which was established under statute as an authority, not for the development of any species of turf, but for the development of turf as a national fuel, should define its policy in relation to turf production. We all appreciate the excellent fuel machine-won turf is and the excellent means of employment given by the production of machine-won turf. We all appreciate the great programme which has been announced by the Government and which is being followed by Bord na Móna in relation to the production of machine-won turf. I do hope, however, that from the Taoiseach will come this definition of Bord na Móna's aims—that machine-won turf as a fuel is going to be produced and sold to compete with and to drive coal from this country. It is as good a fuel as coal. It is a more economic fuel for the consumer, and I trust that that will be the object and the purpose of Bord na Móna's machine-won turf production programme. At the same time, I hope that, while doing that, Bord na Móna will help to develop and assist the cooperative turf societies and bodies of that nature which at present are engaged in hand-won turf production. As I understand it, that is part of Bord na Móna's activity. It should be part of their activity from week to week. At present, I regret to say, there seems to be on the part of Bord na Móna an antipathy against these cooperative societies engaged in the production of turf.
Comment on this
I just wanted to refer to these matters. I have dealt with them not as fully as I would like but as fully as I would be let and I can leave them now. One other matter has been referred to by one of the Deputies opposite. He chided the Government for what he alleged was their failure to reduce the cost of living. I do not think any of us here is in any way satisfied with the progress that has been made in reducing the cost of living. We realise that it is still a problem of very considerable concern to the people but we are proud to state that the vast majority of our people are in a far better position than they were before this Government took office and that many of the things which cost the ordinary citizen exorbitant prices during the last Administration are now at considerably reduced prices and within the means of ordinary people.
Comment on this
For example, the simple luxuries of the working man and many things like that which, during the last Administration, were becoming a special tax on the ordinary people. While there is that type of reduction in prices—I do not regard it as satisfactory but, nevertheless, it is there—there is this very important thing to be said on the credit side in relation to the Government's achievements, that those who have to pay for commodities like that have in the last 18 months received increases in their earnings and, to a certain extent, have been put in a better position to meet the legacy of high prices left by the last Administration. In the last 18 months, apart from such increases as the Government were able to give agricultural labourers, rural workers and those legions of citizens who, by reason of rising prices and fixed wages had been living on the very brink of starvation, there have been considerable wage increases for all sections of our people and despite those increases the Government have actually reduced the cost of living. I do not think there is any necessity for the Taoiseach or any member of the Government to be in any way ashamed about the progress that has been made in relation to that particular problem and I know that the Government's work in that connection is appreciated by the wage earners. That is as much as I want to say in relation to the debate so far.
I noticed that some Fianna Fáil Deputies were very indignant at suggestions made here that during the last 12 months they had obstructed in this House the work of Government. I am not sufficiently long in this House to judge whether, in fact, their tactics in opposition were obstruction or not, but I do remember in relation to the Local Authorities (Works) Bill that the spokesman who opened the debate on Second Reading on behalf of the Opposition, Deputy MacEntee, delivered a virulent attack on the proposals contained in that Bill and expressed considerable objection.
Comment on this
It was strong criticism, not a virulent attack.
Comment on this
Whether it was sound or not, it constituted to my ears a virulent attack on the proposals contained in that Bill, so much so that Deputy Corry got on his feet and told Deputy MacEntee where he got off. It was perfectly obvious that Deputy MacEntee jumped to his feet in a fit of impetuosity because this was a Government proposal——
Comment on this
Because it was full of flaws which had to be amended.
Comment on this
——to express his opposition to the measure. He obviously did not consult Deputy Corry or other members of the Fianna Fáil Party who are closer to their constituents, perhaps, than Deputy MacEntee is to his, and Deputy Corry, of course, realised that the Fianna Fáil Party could not afford to oppose the Bill and told Deputy MacEntee that. Deputy MacEntee then, in my recollection, disappeared from the Dáil for a period of six or seven weeks.
Comment on this
Amendments that he had put down were moved in absentia. It does appear to me that in relation to that particular matter Fianna Fáil undoubtedly, either intentionally or not, delayed the passage of that measure.
Comment on this
I do know that that particular Bill was introduced at a time when certain Deputies were shedding crocodile tears about the unemployment situation, at a time when Fianna Fáil Deputies were pointing to hungry crowds of unemployed down the country. When the Bill was introduced Deputy Moran from Mayo made academic speeches here about the difference between "roadway" and "public road". I do not know whether it is correct to say that that type of opposition to that measure was obstruction or not but it is regarded as such by the unemployed outside who wanted a job.
Comment on this
That is what the Deputy would like, is it not?
Comment on this
Deputy de Valera is very talkative to-night. The passage of that Bill was delayed nearly two or three months. It is now becoming law and I hope it will be availed of to solve the problem that it is intended to solve. In any event, on the question of these charges of obstruction, I hope the indignant denials made by Fianna Fáil Deputies to-night are suggestive of greater co-operation in the future because that co-operation is needed to solve the problems facing the country. If Fianna Fáil have constructive opposition to express, they have a clear duty to do so, but I appeal to them to do it with one voice and one mind.
Comment on this
The last speaker was very careful indeed not to commit himself to a very definite statement as to whether it was obstruction on our part or not.
Comment on this
What about Deputy Little's four and a half hours' speech last year? I am sorry, Deputy Smith's.
Comment on this
I did not understand the interruption, but the Deputy who spoke, being a lawyer, must have known——
Comment on this
——that that Bill required to be examined with a microscope. These measures were very crude but the intention was good, and, in principle, Fianna Fáil was never against them. We were prepared to give every opportunity to enable them to work out properly, but the rights of the individual had to be protected, and as the Deputy knows perfectly well, when lawyers get down to the job, they have to do it with a microscope. The Deputy, I think, had his tongue in his cheek when he talked about it at all. It was some other Deputy who had less knowledge of law than the Deputy who made the charge, but it is not a charge which can be maintained at all. We can pride ourselves on having improved these measures immensely by our criticism and by the amendments which were accepted by the Government.
My own feelings about the speech of the Taoiseach to-day might be expressed in different ways. When the Government started out, it started out as a sort of experiment in the combining of incompatibles, a kind of conspiracy of minorities—minority Government instead of majority Government—and at the time it reminded me very much of the kind of experiments that are tried in other intellectual spheres, in art, for example, where you get pictures which are all crisscross lines and strokes, with all kinds of queer colours and circles, which people are supposed to admire. You get the same thing in music when a whole lot of discordant noises are introduced and people are supposed to admire it. Apparently the experimental period is over, and, having gone through the sensation of looping the loop in Government policy—a complete swing round—we find ourselves upon the solid ground of Fianna Fáil policy. I must say that it is with a sense of great satisfaction that I look back on the faith we had in Fianna Fáil and its policy. It reminds me of what was said of the ideas of Swift when it was said that he was not in office but was in power. That is exactly what is operating at the moment. Fianna Fáil is not in office, but certainly Fianna Fáil policy is in power.
Comment on this
I am very uneasy, because I do not know what sort of aberrations may be indulged in. It is one thing to carry out your own policy and another thing to see somebody else carrying it out. However, we have to do the best we can. When the Government came into office, we said we would criticise them very severely for anything wrong they did, but that, in so far as they carried out Fianna Fáil policy, we would support them, and it is with a real sense of satisfaction that we look back on the faith we had in our own policy. It must be remembered that the Fianna Fáil Government was the first Government which really exercised fiscal freedom in this country, and, if some of the younger Deputies could have seen the Opposition we had to face, they would know what opposition really is. For my sins, I was Chief Whip in 1933 and 1934 and we used to have to bring in guillotine motions in order to impose a policy, a fiscal policy of putting on tariffs to protect our industries. It was only through those tariffs that we were able to build up industry, and, when the Taoiseach speaks of following a policy of building up industry, I hope he will do it on the same lines as those on which we did it, with protective tariffs and with all the machinery we used.
Later, we pursued a particular policy which is now being followed to a certain extent and to those who would say that we did nothing about Partition, I say that we had first to clear the way. We had to get the Constitution established and there again we had to do it in spite of something which was real obstruction. Let Deputies look back over the records if they want to know what obstruction really was. I do not want to dwell too much on the past except to point out that we did clear the ground and when the time came in 1938 to deal with the question of Partition the whole thing was blown sky high by the bombs which exploded in London.
Comment on this
Certainly not. We have the satisfaction now of seeing that the Government realise the value of our tourist trade, which was so much abused. It puzzles me beyond measure why the Government should have cast aside the methods which were adopted by the tourist board, by which a company was to be established to purchase hotels and to carry on the business of hotels. Why that should be called a luxury I do not know, and now these hotels are being sold to people at prices which are really below their proper value. That is one aspect of what was for the time being the wrecking policy of this Government, which shut down on the short-wave station and announced their intention to sell it. The reason given the other day for the decision to sell the short-wave station was the most fantastic excuse I have heard. They said that the very fact that they wanted to sell it had the effect, through some queer international complication, of ensuring that they got a short-wave allocation. It reminded me of the story of Charles Lamb, who tells how the Chinese discovered a way to roast a pig by burning down the house. We had to attempt to wreck the short-wave station before we could get a wavelength allocation. However, we have that now, too.
Then again, in regard to other developments in the matter of tourist trade, the Government is changing its attitude. It is changing its attitude with regard to cultural matters and I would urge on the Government, as they are changing their attitude, that they should see the enormous advantage, from the financial point of view—and the Taoiseach emphasised that cultural developments have a financial aspect, from the point of view of tourist trade —in the scheme of building a proper concert hall in Dublin which could be used, as we intended the Rotunda to be used, for conferences and exhibitions and as a proper concert hall, such as is to be found in every decent capital in Europe. In that connection again, the excuse given the other day was that the contract was not signed. It was all but signed and it could have been only a matter of days before it was signed. The first sketch plans are in the Board of Works for the Government to follow up, if they want to.
Another scheme which was set aside was the building of a sports stadium which is also used in many countries as a centre of attraction for the tourist trade. In regard to all these matters, we should first look to our own people, to getting the Irish race here, and, after them, to other people. The first people, of course, are our own people here who should be given an opportunity of having holidays at home, and then the Irish race from America, and the development of such cultural activities as archæology, art, music, folklore and all these things in our traditions which are such an attraction. In fact, you very often find that the Irish people abroad appreciate these things far more than we do ourselves.
If it was only for the purpose of teaching our own people to appreciate these things it would be a good thing to bring these people in from other countries. I believe that until you have given the younger generation a love for these things—and I think the cinema should be exploited for that purpose because it has tremendous possibilities in relation to the education of our younger people—until you give them a love for these Irish traditions through the things I have mentioned, you will not really get them back to speak the Irish language out of a real devotion to it. I do not think mere coercion is going to work now, but if we develop that cultural side, if we can get people to think in Irish we will get them to talk Irish in a generation or so.
I should like to criticise the policy of the Department of Health. There has been such a concentration in dealing with the evil of tuberculosis—which concentration is good in itself—that I would suggest that, in so doing, other things should not be neglected. In my constituency we are suffering very severely from that, because a general hospital which was to have contained 100 beds has been completely put aside although about £9,000 or £10,000, I think, was actually spent on plans for that hospital. The whole project has been put aside in the interests of dealing with tuberculosis. I hope the Minister for Health will change his mind about that and give us a general hospital that deals with all kinds of sickness, in Waterford City—it is for the city and county.
Comment on this
The Deputy is rather going outside the scope of the debate. The Deputy is going into details.
Comment on this
I was dealing with the idea that there was too much concentration on one aspect of health. You can see that with the best intentions in the world it is very difficult not occasionally by way of example to descend to detail.
Comment on this
Tugann an Meastachán sea caoi do gach taobh a dtuairimí ar pholosaí an Rialtais a nochtú agus obair an Rialtais i rith na treímhse atá thart a mheá. Ar na Meastacháin eile, do dhein an Dáil mion-scrúdú ar obair gach Roinne den Stát agus mion-phointí a bhain le gach Roinn a chur fé ghéar-iniúchadh. Fé mar a dúirt an Taoiseach i dtosach na díospóireachta seo, go dtí seo bhí mionphointí sa phictiúir á scrúdú ach, ar an Meastachán seo, táimid ag féachaint, mar a déarfá, ar an bpictiúir ina iomlán. Cad í ár dtuairim den phictiúir sin? Maidir linn-ne anseo i gClann na Poblachta, níl sé ró-dheacair an cheist sin d'fhreagairt. Tá mion-rudaí sa phictiúir a dhein an Taoiseach a lua, tá mion-rudaí ann nach bhfuilmidne sásta leo, rudai na taitníonn linn, ach maidir leis an bpictiúir ina iomlán, sé ár dtuairim gur fearr agus gur taitneamhaí é mar phictiúir ná an ceann a bhí ós ár gcóir anoiridh nó an bhliain roimhe sin. Tá rudaí anseo agus ansiúd a dhein an Rialtas nach ndéanfaimis-ne dá mba rud é gur Rialtas Chlann na Poblachta a bheadh anseo. Tá rudaí eile fágtha ar lár agus gan a bheith déanta ná fágfaimis-ne gan déanamh, ach táimid cinnte de rud amháin—tá an "job" atá déanta ag an Rialtas atá ann fé lathair déanta níos fearr ná mar a dhein aon Rialtas é le blianta fada, abair ó 1936-37.
I think that the Taoiseach chose a happy metaphor in opening this debate when he likened the discussion on his Estimate, in comparison with the discussion on other Estimates, to a person looking at a picture, having previously examined the details of the picture. We have examined the details of the Government picture in the consideration given by the Dáil to the various Estimates for Departments of State, and now when we come to the Taoiseach's Estimate we are looking at the picture as a whole. There are details in that picture which do not please us in Clann na Poblachta as fully, perhaps, as they might. There are details omitted from the picture that we should like to be able to say we saw in it, but, taking it by and large, we find it a good picture to look at.
The Taoiseach—and, surprisingly enough, I am supported even by Deputy Lemass in this—showed himself to be on sound ground economically when he declared that it was the Government's policy to increase the national wealth, and when he expanded that statement by an expression of his realisation and the Government's realisation that the main sources of national wealth are our land and the labour of our people. Perhaps, if at this stage I might interject a minor note of criticism, I might remark the Taoiseach's failure, as far as I could understand it, to refer to the importance of the manner in which that national wealth is to be distributed and shared.
The Taoiseach again struck a note to which we in Clann na Poblachta must make a sympathetic response when he expressed his belief that the greatest economic evils under which we labour nationally are those of under-investment and under-employment. If the Government realises that one of the things that must be stopped in our economic system is the export of money and credits, which are followed as naturally as night follows day, by an export of our labour; if credit and capital can be repatriated so that that credit which is being utilised in the interest of foreigners may be utilised at home, there will be no necessity for us to export our men and women after it and we will have commenced on a real solution of our economic ills.
The Taoiseach advocated, and quite rightly advocated, and expressed it to be the policy of the Government to procure constructive investment in our own economy. In that connection, I would again put to the Taoiseach and to the Dáil the necessity once more of considering whether it is wise to maintain our present link with sterling. We in these benches subscribe to the view that it is unwise. Many of us believe that, in the very near future, ample justification for that viewpoint may be forthcoming.
The Taoiseach dealt with industrial development. I would merely like to say that, in addition to what we did hear from him, we would have liked to have heard a statement of Government policy, that what we can produce in this country should not be imported. Pursuit of that policy, coupled with a plan for the decentralisation of industry, so that new hope and new life would be given to our smaller towns and so that the alarming growth of this capital City of Dublin would be stemmed, will carry us along the road on which, in my submission, lies our economic salvation.
There is another matter to which the Taoiseach referred and I hope he will forgive me if I underline it. I notice that, in his discussion of the Budget that was presented to the House this year, he made in his own mind a clear and definite distinction between that portion of the Budget which was devoted to what the Taoiseach termed our national housekeeping expenses and the portion dealing with our expenditure on capital investment. Some of us have held the view—I think I have expressed it in this House before and I know it has been expressed by members of the Government Party—that the time has come when, as a matter of policy, the Government should consider the introduction of a system wherin there would be not one Budget, but two —one dealing with what the Taoiseach himself described as our expenditure on national housekeeping and the other dealing purely with capital investment and the expansion of our productive capacity.
Another matter on which I would like to hear from the Taoiseach when he is concluding is a clear statement of the principle that this Government accepts the responsibility of ensuring that any citizen able and willing to work will have an opportunity of so working without being forced to emigrate.
I am sorry, also, that we did not hear from the Taoiseach some definite reference to a matter which has agitated the minds of some of us for some time past, namely, the question of granting a right of audience in this Parliament to the elected representatives of the people of the Six Counties. Perhaps, in conclusion, the Taoiseach may find time to refer to that. Charges have been made against Clann na Poblachta as a Party that we went before the people at the last general election with that as one of the main planks in our programme. Let me take this opportunity of assuring Deputies opposite that the according of that right of audience to the elected representatives of the people of the Six Counties still forms a main plank in the programme of Clann na Poblachta. If we have not been able, as yet, to get the Government as a whole to see eye to eye with us on that matter, it does not give any occasion or reason for Deputies opposite to taunt us with having dropped it. The whole tragedy of the situation, to my mind, is that the other Parties, on both sides of the House, cannot, apparently, be convinced of the reasonableness of this approach to reuniting our country cannot be convinced that our attitude before the nations of the world must be capable of misrepresentation when we in this House effectively stifle and gag the elected representatives of our people in occupied Ireland from expressing their opinions in this House and giving us the benefit of their views.
I know that the Leader of the Opposition suggested—it was the only answer he was able to make—when that case was put to him that it might lead to disunity amongst the Anti-Partitionists in the Six Counties who are at present united. I would suggest to him as sincerely as I can—I do not do this in any effort to make Party propaganda out of it—to reconsider his attitude on that matter and to give credit to those who at the moment hold the leadership of the Nationalist population in the Six Counties for a little more commonsense and a little more sincerity in their approach to the problem of ending the occupation of our country.
I hope I will not be accused, as my Leader was accused, of being a poseur, of being insincere, if I say to the House that the speech made by the former Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, showed a complete lack of appreciation of what his duty was to the people who sent him here. I do not believe that any Deputy was sent here in order to allow himself the luxury of indulging in venting his own personal or Party spleens or prejudices. We were not sent here for that purpose. Deputy Briscoe, in one of the ablest speeches I have heard and one of the most sincere speeches, if I might say so, that I have heard from the Opposition Benches in a long time, made that very point, that we were sent here to do the people's work, and I do not see how Deputy Lemass can reconcile his conception of his duty to the people with utilising this Estimate for venting his spleen against his political opponents.
Comment on this
For criticising the faults of the Government, is it?
Comment on this
For constructive criticism I have nothing but respect, but I am able to differentiate between what is constructive criticism and what is the utilisation of an opportunity for venting personal spites. It is particularly regrettable that we should have such an exhibition from Deputy Lemass. No man on those benches opposite is in a better position or has more ability to give the Dáil the benefit of constructive criticism than the Deputy to whom I refer. Those of us who disagree politically with him concede him ability far and away above the average, but when he utilises that ability not in doing the people's work. not in doing the job he was sent here for, but when he prostitutes it in order to make attacks on his political opponents, I say he is failing in his duty to the people.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass was doing his duty to the people for 20 or 30 years.
Comment on this
It is regrettable then that Deputy Lemass should have departed in this debate and in the debate on External Affairs from what Deputy de Valera says has been his practice. Any of us could vent personal bitternesses, did we conceive it as being consistent with our duty. As far as many of us in Clann na Poblachta are concerned, we started off nurtured—let us be frank about it —in personal bitterness against some of the people who sit on the same benches with us to-day. Many of us had bitternesses against the Party opposite—that is a matter for ourselves —but the people did not send us here to make this a sounding board for our personal bitternesses or to vent our personal feelings. It is a luxury that neither we nor the country can allow ourselves.
Deputy Childers, I understand, took Clann na Poblachta to task for the promises they had failed to keep. Of course between Deputy Lemass and Deputy Childers it is very difficult to present a consistent defence which will answer both of them because on the one hand the attack on myself and my colleagues and the Clann na Poblachta Party has been "Oh, you have been swallowed up by Fine Gael. You are more Fine Gael than Fine Gael themselves". And then if that record does not suit the other record is played and we are anything from anarchists to crypto-communists. Deputy Lemass finds fault with us on the matter that the Government is ineffective and inefficient because it is disunited. Five minutes afterwards in the same speech this evening he delivered a criticism of the Government and of Clann na Poblachta as part of that Government because they were too united. They could not possibly be a good Government because the Taoiseach said that there were no serious disagreements between them.
Deputy Childers took us to task about our failure to implement the policy upon which we went before the electorate at the last general election. Let me make Deputy Childers and every Deputy opposite a present of this: We have not been able to implement the policy we put before the electorate at the last general election. Of course we have not, but we have succeeded in putting important and substantial protions of that policy into effect. One of the promises that we made to the people was that we would assist in reducing taxation. That was a promise which was fulfilled when the luxuries of the worker were removed from underneath the heavy impost put upon them in October, 1947.
Another promise, one we were taunted about a lot, one in respect of which the famous "in abeyance" phrase was coined, was our promise to repeal the External Relations Act. When the Leader of Clann na Poblachta, the present Minister for External Affairs, stated on the 18th February of last year that that portion of our policy would have to be put temporarily in abeyance he was greeted with taunts, jibes and jeers from the whole of the Fianna Fáil propaganda machine, but we do not hear many of these taunts, jibes and jeers now, nor do we hear much about "in abeyance" because in that respect, too, Clann na Poblachta delivers the goods. It did not remain long in abeyance.
There are Deputies on the benches opposite and in the House at the moment who challenged me personally as to their belief in our sincerity that we would succeed in getting the External Relations Act repealed. We did succeed in getting it repealed. We promised the people internal peace. The people know now that there is internal peace. We promised the sick, the widow, the aged and the orphan increased social services, and, if we have not been able to implement that promise in full, we have gone a long way towards it. The increases that have been paid to the old age pensioners are in excess of those which two former Cabinet Ministers told this House and Seanad Eireann were increases which were beyond the capacity of the Irish people to pay.
I noticed that great portions of the speeches from the benches opposite were directed to taunts and criticism of our Party. I would just ask the Deputies opposite to consider this: are there any nine Deputies in Fianna Fáil —and, remember, there are only nine of us—who, if agreed on a policy, would be able to get the Fianna Fáil Party to adopt such a considerable part of it as has been adopted by the present Government, not grudgingly, but gladly and co-operatively? I would like to take this occasion to pay tribute to the manner and spirit in which the present Leader of the Government has not alone treated the Clann na Poblachta Party but all the Parties comprising the inter-Party Government.
References were made here to our failure to implement our afforestation policy. We have not been successful in putting into effect the policy of afforestation that we would have liked, but we have been successful in doing this: that, henceforth, the annual planting will be four times greater than that achieved in any year by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I do not know if it is particularly hard on the Deputies opposite to have to listen to this, but I would merely like to make this point, that they should examine the facts before they taunt us about our failure to put into operation our complete policy on afforestation. Let them deny that there has been a substantial advance made. They cannot deny it.
Comment on this
There has been more planting this year than ever before in the history of this country.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, the position is that facts and figures are something which Deputies opposite are, I am afraid, prepared to ignore when it suits their book to do so.
In so far as turf is concerned, our policy for the development and utilisation of turf as a national fuel remains the same. In so far as we can urge it upon the Government we will urge on the Government that coal should be excluded from all turf areas. I am satisfied that the development of machine-won turf will receive at the hands of the inter-Party Government the treatment that it merits. We may have divergences of opinion as to the tempo at which this development should take place, but I am satisfied from the Taoiseach's statement to-day that we are at one in our policy in that respect.
I would ask the House, and particularly the Deputies opposite, to let us have the greatest possible degree of unity on major national issues. For a period it seemed as if it were possible to get that. It appeared to be possible to get it when Deputy Lemass, speaking at Rathfarnham in August, 1948, said that his only regret about the decision to repeal the External Relations Act was that by the result of the general election in February of that year Fianna Fáil had been robbed of the chance of doing it, because it had been their intention to do so in the coming session. I thought that when that statement was made by Deputy Lemass that we had unity on these matters. Unfortunately, Deputies on the opposite benches, former Ministers and those whom the people are entitled to regard as the spokesmen of the Fianna Fáil Party, have drifted very, very far away from the attitude expressed by Deputy Lemass in August, 1948. I thought that on Partition we would get unity. I think there is still a great degree of unity on it, and I would urge Deputies on this side of the House as well as those on the opposite side that on no occasion should an attempt be made to utilise Partition as a Party plaything. It is using it as a Party plaything—it is using it to extract mean Party advantage—by making accusations against others of doing so. I do not want to put it any further than that.
Deputy Briscoe complained, in the course of his speech, of the failure of Deputies on this side of the House to give credit to the Fianna Fáil Party for what, he alleged, they had achieved. That is a charge which Deputy Briscoe cannot make against some of us. I would be as critical of Fianna Fáil for many things they have done—and I make no apology for it—as any Deputy in the House, but I have never failed to give credit to Fianna Fáil for the advances that were made in the removal of the Oath, the retention of the land annuities, the abolition of the Governor-Generalship and the restoration of the ports. We have never been niggardly or mean in our approach to these matters. We criticised where we felt the criticism was due, but we never failed to give credit where we thought credit was due.
Deputy Briscoe appealed to Deputies to work in the interests of the country. I will endorse that appeal. That is what we were sent here for. I would ask Fianna Fáil to look at the picture— to return again to the Taoiseach's metaphor—but I would ask them before doing so to take off their Fianna Fáil spectacles which are aggravating their political astigmatism. If they do that, they will get a proper look at the picture.
Comment on this
It is rather amusing, after the speech made by Deputy O'Higgins about the diverse views of the Opposition, to hear Deputy Lehane tell us about "we of Clann na Poblachta" Party. Judging by Deputy Lehane's statement to-night, those who accused Fine Gael of having swallowed Clann na Poblachta and all the other Parties were wrong. I think it is Clann na Poblachta that must have swallowed the whole lot, if the Deputy's statements are correct.
We were also accused of obstruction. I heard that charge from a young Deputy like Deputy O'Higgins here, but I remember that for at least 12 or 15 years, when Fianna Fáil were in office, the Opposition at that period were so negligent of their duties that I had to act practically as official Opposition. They would not even bother to read a Bill, not to mind to criticise it, and they knew very little of what was happening in this House. They bothered very little about what was happening in this House.
There was also a sneer at the different attitudes adopted by Deputy MacEntee and myself towards the Works Bill. I gave the viewpoint of the ordinary countryman on the Works Bill. It is only natural that a Deputy who was a Minister in the same Department for a number of years, and who had been accustomed to dealing with these matters, would see the weaknesses and would endeavour to correct them here rather than have them coming back from the Seanad to be corrected. That is only quite natural.
Comment on this
I do not want any interruptions from any lawyers. We have enough of them. I believe you could earn more in an hour in the courts than you would earn here in a day. I believe you charge them £5 5s. 0d. an hour.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I noticed recently in the House that it has become the practice of some Deputies to talk in a disparaging manner of other Deputies, but more especially of those in the legal profession. Deputy Corry has made some references, not alone to the profession followed by Deputy O'Higgins, but to his charges. I think he ought to be made withdraw those references.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture in the course of his speech talked enough about the lawyers.
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Deputy to refer to the private profession of another member of the House?
Comment on this
I was answering a point of order when the Deputy interrupted me. I am not here to defend any class if a charge is made against them, but if a charge is made against an individual, yes. The Deputy was wrong and disorderly in referring to the fees paid to an individual lawyer.
Comment on this
In case it relieves Deputy Corry's mind, I may say that I take no exception to his remark. I certainly would not act for Deputy Corry for the sum of £5 5s.
Comment on this
What I object to is that this Party that made so much noise about the power taken from representatives of the people down the country, the local authorities, the power taken from them in the managerial line and all that kind of stuff, should form themselves into an absolutely autocratic body with a set policy and should endeavour to remove from the local authorities the loyalty and honest service that they would expect from their employees. That has been done repeatedly by each Minister here who has any connection with the local authorities.
It is customary, for example, that when an official is dissatisfied with his lot, if he considers that he is entitled to an increase of salary, that he is entitled to shorter working hours or anything of that description, that that official would make an application to the local authority concerned. Instead of that—and I am not alone in my protest against this—what you have happening is that there are letters sent down to-day from the Minister for Social Service, to-morrow from the Minister for Health and the day after from the Minister for Local Government, each one of them couched in these terms, that the Minister considers that an increase of so-and-so should be given to a certain set of officials; the Minister considers that the hours should be shorter for another set of officials; and the Minister considers that so much bonus should be payable to a third set of officials. As a matter of fact, they tripped over themselves so far that we had a little bit of delay at a health meeting, because we had three letters together from the one Minister, each one suggesting a different set of salaries for the officials under his control.
I have no objection whatever to the officials of local authorities getting a fair do, but I certainly object to this set Government policy of removing from the local authorities the little right they had, and removing from them the loyalty that I expect they are entitled to get from their officials. That is happening constantly. One letter from the Minister for Local Government last week put an extra £11,000 on the ratepayers in County Cork. It was considered a reduction in the cost of living by removing it from one portion and putting it on to another.
I am sorry Deputy Con Lehane has gone away. I remember those loud speeches we heard, about people increasing their own salaries and the enormous salaries of Ministers, from the Clann na Poblachta people at the last election. We hear little about that now. In other days we would fix a salary for an official and send it to the Local Appointments Commissioners to have it advertised, and we would be told: "You cannot get the right kind of man for that money; you should give him a few hundred more." Above anything else I do not believe that you can possess a worse servant than one who thinks he is underpaid and who is dissatisfied with his lot. He becomes, in the words of some of my colleagues in Cork, when they are looking for an increase for some fellow, "a slovenly individual in his work, a man who will leave half his work undone and who has no interest in his work." I appeal to the Minister on these lines.
I have been surprised here during the past 12 months at the manner in which the Minister for Agriculture is carrying out his functions. We had trouble about the oats. We did not think much of the way in which he handled the flax problem. We are short 33,000 acres of beet this year. We are worried about the price of milk and home-made butter. We wonder what is happening. But all these things can be traced back to a statement he made here on one occasion. He repeated the statement very emphatically last night. He referred to his mangy, inadequate salary of £2,000 odd per year. I do not think the Taoiseach should leave it until the third time of asking. When the Minister for Agriculture alludes to his position as a Minister and describes the salary he is paid as a mangy, inadequate one I wonder what the members of the Clann na Poblachta Party think about it? I would like to hear their views on the matter. I am sure they would be enlightening, particularly for those who elected them to this House. They promised to reduce salaries when they were coming in.
Comment on this
I am dealing with Government policy as a whole. That comes under this Vote. I am dealing with the manner in which business in general is being done. After all, there may be something in the statement of the Minister for Agriculture, taken in conjunction with the letters we get down the country saying that one cannot get the right kind of man unless one pays a particular kind of salary. Perhaps that does account for all the blunders that have occurred in the past 16 months.
I suggest to Deputy Lehane that the time for statements with regard to principles is now ended. What we want now is a little action. He alluded to the statement of principle by the Taoiseach that what we can produce in this country must not be imported into the country. I wonder was the Taoiseach thinking of that when the Minister for Industry and Commerce raided the funds of the sugar company. I suppose the Taoiseach must have authorised that. That raid resulted in a reduction in productivity this year to the extent of 33,000 acres of beet. It will result in unemployment on the land and at the four factories concerned. It will result in a loss of income to Córas Iompair Eireann, freightage charges on 300,000 tons of beet. I wonder did that enter into the Taoiseach's mind when he said that what we can produce in this country should not be imported. I take it we shall have to import sugar to make up for the loss.
That policy seems to run right through. There is a reduction in the acreage under wheat and we shall have to call upon our very scarce dollars to pay for it abroad. One can travel right through the whole range of agricultural produce, from Deputy Rooney's tomatoes up to the glass houses, and one will find that production is rapidly declining under the methods adopted by the present Government. In that way one gets what Deputy Lehane described a short time ago as "a fair picture".
I do not wish to unduly delay the House, but these are matters of primary importance when one considers employment on the land and increased production. Is it for that purpose that the dice is being loaded? Is that the reason why the burden is increasing on the backs of the farming community month after month? Is that the definite, set policy of the Government? The increases, as a result of the letters to which I have already referred, reach something in the region of £34,000 in so far as South Cork Board of Assistance is concerned, in salaries alone over the past 12 months. There has been an increase of £35,000 odd in salaries under the mental hospital committee in Cork. There is a pro rata increase right along in every section. The increased burden on the ratepayers in County Cork amounts to 5/- in the £, roughly, this year. These ratepayers have no increased incomes to meet those extra burdens. Perhaps the Government thought that was a step towards bringing about increased production on the land. The burdens are daily piling on and we are faced now with the deliberate manoeuvre to prevent discussions on such matters in this House. Deputy Cogan's motion has been on the agenda for practically 14 months.
These are the matters on which I would like to hear something from the Taoiseach. If fair criticism is wanted, I am giving it now. Instead of this rush to adjourn to-morrow night, I think the Taoiseach should give two days next week for the discussion of Deputy Cogan's motion so that the agricultural community may know exactly where it stands and what the burden is likely to be in the next 12 months. I think that would be more important with relation to getting more production from the land than a protracted holiday for the poor gentleman who has to work on a mangy, inadequate salary of £2,000 a year.
Comment on this
I always like sitting-in when Deputy Corry is speaking, because I find it a great mental exercise trying to ascertain exactly what he is speaking about at any given moment. In the round-about to-night I was completely lost. Like Deputy Corry, I, too, would like to extend my sympathy to the Taoiseach, but for a different reason. The Taoiseach, being a man with a deep sense of duty and a deep sense of responsibility, may feel that he is under an obligation to make some effort to deal with the various points raised by Deputy Corry. I certainly would not like to have that task imposed upon me at any time.
A number of Deputies in the course of this debate adopted the Taoiseach's metaphor in opening the discussion of painting the entire picture of the Government structure and Government policy in dealing with this Estimate. I think it is true to say, as was remarked by Deputy Little, that one has in this Government—at any rate, one had when it was first set up—an experiment which is completely novel to the minds of all political thinkers in this country. It was a new idea and a new method being tried out. As the Taoiseach himself said some months ago, it has gone beyond the experimental stage now and it has become an institution.
I think we can claim, either those of us in the Fine Gael Party who were associated with an earlier Government or those who accepted the traditions of that Government, that the inter-Party Government, by reason of the very fact that it is broadly based and truly representative of all sections of the people, is probably about the best type of Government that this country has witnessed so far. It is certainly a very great improvement on the last Government which was representative of one section of the people only and which worked unashamedly in the interests of that section and who had Ministers going on record that they conceived it to be their duty in so far as the allocation of jobs was concerned to see to it that the jobs went to supporters of Fianna Fáil.
Deputy Lemass to-day complained about suggestions of corruption made against the Fianna Fáil regime. Deputy Timoney, in his speech on this Estimate, said that he accepted 100 per cent. the statement made by Deputy Lemass that there was never anything in the nature of corruption connected with Fianna Fáil. I do not accept that but I want to make it clear that I am not talking about personal corruption or anything of that sort. I believe that in the political sense Fianna Fáil werecorrupt and they did not know it themselves because they were so corrupt that they took it as the ordinary routine of Government and of political administration that a Government should be corrupt in that sense. I think Fianna Fáil Deputies would be surprised at some of the statements made by their own Ministers when they were members of the Government. They would be surprised at the indifferent and nonchalant approach made by Fianna Fáil Ministers, notably Deputy Boland and Deputy Moylan, in relation to this question. As I say, I am not in any sense talking about what might be described as moral or personal corruption in that sense, but I am talking about the Fianna Fáil political outlook in so far as the division of labour in the country is concerned.
I want to join with Deputy Timoney in suggesting to the Taoiseach that it would be a very great mistake if this Government allowed any backsliding in the principles which were enunciated by the Taoiseach himself when he took office first, when he said that one of the main principles of this Government would be to see to it that all sections of the people were dealt with equally by the Government, that in the giving of work, in promotion in services and that kind of thing, a man's political affiliations would have nothing whatever to do with it. I believe that the Government have worked on that principle so far, and, as I say, I join with Deputy Timoney in expressing the hope that they will continue to do so.
I have suggested that the Fianna Fáil Government unashamedly exercised political patronage and were so accustomed to it that it was nothing unusual to them.
Comment on this
All that is as untrue as the charges of personal corruption.
Comment on this
There were charges of personal corruption made in the past, and that is as untrue as these others were.
Comment on this
We merely give the facts. I will give Deputy de Valera an opportunity of refuting them if he can. In Volume 96 of the Official Debates, column 2143, Deputy de Valera, if he goes to the trouble of looking it up, will find there a discussion on the Estimate for the Department of Justice in the year 1945, when that Department was presided over by his colleague, Deputy Boland.
Comment on this
I am talking about the general question of the approach of this Government, as distinct from the approach of the previous Government.
Comment on this
You have been doing exactly the same. The present Government is doing exactly the same.
Comment on this
Now Deputy O'Higgins is reading and Deputy de Valera is interrupting. I want to know what has the Official Report of 1945 to do with the Taoiseach's Estimate of 1949.
Comment on this
The Chair cannot see how there can be any connection between the two. Surely it is going back too far altogether.
Comment on this
With respect, before you took the Chair, I was dealing with a speech made by Deputy Lemass in the course of this debate and that brought me on to this subject. Deputy de Valera has challenged the truth and accuracy of my statements. I am inviting him to consult that debate. During that debate, the present Taoiseach, then Deputy Costello, made some suggestions to Deputy Boland in reply.
Comment on this
I cannot see how this can have any reference whatsoever to what is before the House at the moment.
Comment on this
If I am going to allow this to proceed, where are we going to get with everyone else doing the same?
Comment on this
On a point of order, this matter was raised specifically by Deputy Lemass on this Estimate in the course of his speech to-day and Deputy O'Higgins is dealing with matters that were raised by Deputy Lemass specifically by way of accusations.
Comment on this
The Deputy must show how the present Administration is concerned with it, otherwise he must pass from it.
Comment on this
Very well. I take it I am permitted to say that when the present Taoiseach took up office he announced quite clearly that one of the main tasks facing this Government and one of the matters which he and the Government would address their mind to was the wiping out of political patronage which has existed in this country under the Fianna Fáil régime.
Comment on this
I regret that I must pass from that. I always bow to the ruling of the Chair; but I take it that I shall be allowed to suggest to Deputy de Valera that before he finally convicts me as a liar he will take the trouble to read the reference which I have given to him.
Comment on this
The debate so far has covered a wide range of subjects from the matters which Deputy Little raised and to which I regret I cannot reply, to the speech made by Deputy Corry a few moments ago. One speaker on the Fianna Fáil Benches, Deputy Little, surprisingly enough, said that this Government in all its actions to date was merely——
Comment on this
I think actually what Deputy Little did was to describe the Government as a conspiracy of minorities which started off making discordant noises and that it had now climbed back to the solid ground of the Fianna Fáil policy. I think I am correct in that. Having claimed that this Government had climbed back to the solid ground of Fianna Fáil policy, Deputy Little would probably be surprised at the criticism which was directed against this solid ground of Fianna Fáil policy by subsequent and earlier speakers on the Fianna Fáil Benches. Deputy Little should at least remember that he cannot have it both ways. Either the policy of this Government is different from that which was pursued by Fianna Fáil for 16 years or it is not. If it is different, surely Deputy Little, as a person who was very closely connected with the Fianna Fáil Government for a long number of years, will be able to appreciate the difference.
Comment on this
That is a tribute from Deputy Little, even though a left-handed one. I think Deputy Little has possibly pointed out one of the differences which existed between this Government and the Government with which he was associated. He says that this Government is capable of anything. I was going to submit that the last Government was capable of nothing by the time it reached the end of its term of office. At any rate, if their policy is similar, if they are now back on the solid rock of the Fianna Fáil policy, I want to know why are all the Deputies opposite so very determined to criticise everything this Government does?
Comment on this
I know that certain Deputies—the Leader of the Opposition for one and Deputy Briscoe for another—generally take the line of argument, in dealing with matters which this Government has done, of saying that they do not know whether it is a good thing or a bad thing. Deputy Briscoe spoke in that fashion at great length to-day. Deputy de Valera did that in West Cork in relation to the repeal of the External Relations Act.
Comment on this
Deputy Little should be careful in what he says about the Chair. I have not heard Deputy O'Higgins deal with it.
Comment on this
Let us be quite clear. I am referring now to the repeal of the External Relations Act, which was referred to by a number of speakers. I am saying that Fianna Fáil, having supported the repeal of the External Relations Act, and Deputy Lemass having gone on record as stating in Rathfarnham before the repeal was introduced that the only regret Fianna Fáil had was that they were not left in office to introduce that Bill——
Comment on this
On a point of order, will it be in order for us to go over all the statements that have been referred to by Deputy O'Higgins?
Comment on this
The Chair cannot give a decision on a matter that is not before it. The Chair will give its decision on these matters when they arise.
Comment on this
I do not know why Deputy de Valera should be so anxious to prevent me from touching on these matters. Remember that, without any objection from the Taoiseach or from anyone on this side of the House, the matters that I want to refer to were referred to at length and ad nauseam by Deputies opposite in the course of this discussion. I think we are entitled at least to deal with these matters such as they are. Deputy Briscoe will, of course, back up his leader when I say that Deputy Lemass did make that speech in Rathfarnham. I read out portion of that speech in the debate on the Vote for the Department of External Affairs. Deputy Boland later made another speech in which he described the repeal of the External Relations Act and the deterioration of our relations with Great Britain, as either the result of deliberate mischief-making or shortsighted, incompetent leadership on the part of the Government.
Comment on this
Keep quiet. Deputy de Valera having supported the repeal of the External Relations Act in this House and Deputy Lemass having made that speech in Rathfarnham, Deputy de Valera went on record as saying eight or 12 months after the event, that he did not know whether it was a good thing or a bad thing.
Comment on this
I am going to ask a plain question of Deputy de Valera. Will he say before this debate ends whether it was a good thing or a bad thing?
Comment on this
I am satisfied to take an answer to that simple question in the course of the debate. After all, it is a very simple question. We were told in the course of the debate by Deputy Little that all this great movement had started away back in 1932 and that it continued up to the introduction of the Constitution in 1937. I move to report progress.