Land Bill, 1949—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–142 of 282. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 35 of 1949 ›
This Bill is one of many provisions with some of which all of us will agree, but there are other provisions which we might reasonably have some doubts about. For that reason it is no harm to get from the Minister some further information other than what he gave yesterday. Land Bills—and this is no exception— are generally involved and intricate pieces of legislation, and I would like, and other Deputies would like, to protest against the bringing before this House of a Bill which, unless they are trained legal experts, very few, if any, Deputies are capable of interpreting.
Comment on this
I think I would be right in saying that one of the principal functions of this House is to frame the laws of the country and to do that Deputies must understand the Bills laid before them. I think it is only fair that the land laws should be codified and laid before the House in such a way that ordinary Deputies can understand their meaning. I think that would be only fair to all Deputies, irrespective of whether they are trained in law or not. The more complicated the laws of the country are, the better for the legal profession, I suppose, as they will be needed to interpret these laws to the ordinary citizen. I am sure the Minister will agree that the laws of this country should be such that the ordinary person, without the help of legal aid, should be able clearly to understand what they are. I am sure the Minister will also agree that, after 60 or 70 years of land Acts, the land laws are so complicated and involved that, without a specialised legal training in them, a person could not understand them. There are many legal people in this country, especially those practising in cities and towns, who know nothing whatever about the land laws and never had to bother about studying and interpreting them. If they come up against the problem of the land laws, they are just as much at sea as ordinary people.
Comment on this
They are complicated for 70 years and they become more and more involved as new Acts are passed. That they are complicated is all for the good of certain professions.
There are a few matters, however, arising out of the Bill as to which I should like to have some more information from the Minister than he gave us in his introductory remarks. He was so brief in introducing this fairly involved Bill, which will create many complications and problems when it becomes law, that we scarcely got as much information from him as he has already given us in the White Paper.
Comment on this
We would like to have more information from the Minister on many aspects of this Bill.
Section 5 is the first important section that I want to deal with. It is under this section that the price of land that may be acquired by the Land Commission will be determined in future. I understand that, at the present time, the formula under which the Land Commission determine the price of land is contained in sub-section (2) of Section 25 of the 1923 Land Act. It says:—
"As regards untenanted land the price shall, in default of agreement, be such an amount as may be fixed by the Land Commission (other than the Judicial Commissioner), or by the Judicial Commissioner on appeal from the Land Commission, and in fixing such sum regard shall be had to the fair value of the land to the Land Commission and the owner respectively."
That is the formula under which land has been acquired in this country since 1923. It will be agreed, I take it, as a result of the Minister's admission that the previous Government introduced no legislation that took away the people's title to their land.
Comment on this
I am speaking of the formula under which the Land Commission have been acquiring land compulsorily or by agreement up to date.
Comment on this
The Minister, in his wisdom and judgment, proposes to alter that formula under Section 5 of this Bill, and so I take it that the section will then read:—
"As regards untenanted land the price shall, in default of agreement, be such an amount as may be fixed by the Land Commission (other than the Judicial Commissioner) or by the Judicial Commissioner on appeal from the Land Commission. The said sub-section shall have effect with the substitution of the words ‘(1) the amount to be so fixed shall be an amount equal to the market value of such land'."
Comment on this
I am not against a fair value being given for land. I think that, when property is taken from an owner under the operation of State laws, he should get a fair, honest price for it, and I am contending that under Section 25 of the 1923 Land Act there was nothing to prevent the Land Commission, or the Judicial Commissioner, from giving a fair price for land.
Comment on this
There was nothing to prevent them from doing so, and there is nothing in Section 5 of this Bill to make them give to the owners of land the price that they would like to get for it. There is nothing mandatory or compulsory in this Bill to make them do that. In fact, the Land Commission or the Judicial Commissioner may determine to give an owner a lesser price for land than they are giving at the moment.
Market value is not defined in this Bill or in any of our written laws. I wonder would I be wrong in suggesting that, in future, true market value will be the value prevailing at the particular time on the open market?
Comment on this
Would I be right in suggesting that the true market value of land may be the price which people who come here from across the water to acquire land may decide to pay for it?
Comment on this
Clann na Poblachta promised that they would pass a law to prevent aliens coming in here, but so far I have not seen that law on the Statute Book.
Comment on this
I want to know from the Minister if the true market value of land is to be the price that people who come in here with bags of money—they may not want it to be further devalued —may decide to pay for land. Is that the price at which the Land Commission must acquire land in the future under Section 5 of this Bill?
Comment on this
If Deputy Collins wants to discuss Locke's Distillery I am quite capable of doing so with him.
Comment on this
I take it that, if the Chair will not give me permission to discuss that, it will not give permission to Deputy Collins either. I wonder would I be wrong in suggesting that the market value of land in future may be the value it will bring when Section 23 of this Bill comes into operation? Would I be wrong in suggesting that the Minister's officers or agents attending public sales may determine the market value of land in the future? I propose to discuss later Section 23, but I do suggest that I may not be far wrong at all in saying that it is the manner in which Section 23 will be operated that may determine the market value of land in the future. We all know that land values go up and down. That has always been so, and this Bill will not prevent that happening. I suggest to the Minister that the market value of land in a time of depression might be a most unjust price to pay to the owner of the land. I also suggest to him that the market value of land in a time of inflation might be a very unjust price to pay either on behalf of the incoming tenant or the State.
Has the Minister thought out all the problems that may arise in relation to market value? Market value changes from day to day. It will change in the way I have already mentioned—the activities of people coming from other countries to buy land here and because of inflationary tendencies that we may have no control over. We may do a very serious injustice to the owners of land under that section. It was said in the past that owing to the price-fixing by the Land Commission or the Judicial Commissioner, injustice was done to certain people. I did not meet any of them. I know of people who sold their interests to the Land Commission but I have yet to meet a person to whom an injustice was done by the Land Commission. We heard here that certain injustices were done under Section 25 of the Land Act of 1923.
Comment on this
Did not abuses occur under the system by which the price of unvested land was fixed?
Comment on this
I will put another question to the Minister on that matter. I had nothing to do with the operation of the Land Acts. What is untenanted land? Untenanted land occurs in this section of the 1923 Land Act. Can anybody tell me the statute in which untenanted land is defined?
Comment on this
If the Deputy can point it out to me, I shall be delighted. I would like to see it plainly defined and easily understandable.
Comment on this
My limited intelligence is my misfortune. I am not responsible for the Minister's lack of intelligence —somebody else may have been, I challenge the Minister to point to the statute where untenanted land is defined.
Comment on this
I read that section and it is not too clear. So much for Section 5. Let me deal now with other interesting sections. Will the Minister inform the House what is the percentage of land that may be acquired and that is not subject to an annuity?
Comment on this
Land that may be acquired. Will you tell me what percentage of that land is not subject to an annuity—land in respect of which there was no advance in the past? There is another very interesting proposal by the Minister in Section 10. That sets out a number of excepted matters, with the provise that the Minister can come in for the purpose of determining certain things. Under certain circumstances he may determine the lands to be acquired, the price to be paid for them and the persons to whom they may be given.
Comment on this
The Minister is taking power to do certain things that he had not power to do before.
Comment on this
The Minister is taking power in certain cases to determine the price that may be paid for land acquired.
Comment on this
Not at all. On a point of explanation. Surely, when Deputies are sticking their feet into it and misleading the House it might be better if the Minister were to interject so as to prevent the House being misled? While it may not come within the rules of order, I may say that I interject merely for the purpose of preventing the Deputy misleading the House.
Comment on this
Under Section 10 the Minister has power to determine the persons who will be selected as allottees for any land, other than any determination arising from or being part of a rearrangement scheme. Will the Minister not have power there? I suggest he has. He is taking power that he previously had not; he is taking power to determine the allottees for any particular parcel of land. That power may be useful to the Minister. He may not like to have that power. Personally, I do not know whether or not he would like to have it for a long time. It may be useful and a good power to have, but I am just wondering whether the Minister is wise in his own interests in taking such power.
Comment on this
I have not been long on these benches, anyhow. Under sub-head E it is stated:—
"the determination (other than any determination arising in or being part of a rearrangement scheme)"
—in other words, the Minister is taking power here to determine the price at which land will be sold to an allottee under that sub-head.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to read that again. I am taking no such power under that particular sub-section.
Comment on this
Did you read the definition of "excepted matters"?
Comment on this
There is no point in acting as mentor, monitor, or remembrancer for other Deputies. Each Deputy has to make his own interpretation.
Comment on this
"the determination (other than any determination arising in or being part of a rearrangement scheme) of the price at which land is to be sold to any such allottee".
I am sure the Minister is well aware of the powers he proposes to take under this Bill. I am sure he has made up his mind before this that he had not sufficient powers. He is proposing to give the Minister for Lands now certain powers and certain responsibilities that he had not got in the past. The Minister may say that these powers are being taken only in regard to rundale holdings. As I read this, those powers may operate in respect of any holding that may be acquired by the Land Commission. This may make a big change in the future operation of the land laws. We wonder if the Minister will not need the lay commissioners as he needed them in the past. He is taking unto himself control of work that was formerly done by the lay commissioners. I am sure the Minister fully appreciates the problems that have arisen in respect of the acquisition, division and price paid for land. He may be wise in doing that. He will know whether he is or not in the course of time. It may prove to be a boon to the Minister and to the Land Commission. It may prove otherwise.
There is another interesting section. There are many interesting sections in this Bill. There is the question of the lay commissioners and the Judicial Commissioner. In the early years of the operation of the Land Act of 1923 the Minister will find, if he reads up the records, that there was little satisfaction with just one Judicial Commissioner operating the Land Acts then. Serious complaints were often made here as to the price paid for land and so on. Under Section 5 the Minister is making a radical change in the manner in which the price of land acquired may be determined. He is doing away with the lay commissioners. These lay commissioners acted as a safeguard when sitting with the Judicial Commissioner. The Minister proposes doing away with these because he has no further use for them. I question whether that is or is not wise. The Minister must know quite well that legal minds interpret the law very, very narrowly and they often take quite a different view from the view taken by the ordinary man in the street. They often make a very unwise decision. I suggest that the lay commissioners would be a help and a safeguard to the community at large in that particular respect. They would provide a safeguard to the owner of land, to the proposed allottee and also to the finances of the State, and the finances are, after all, an important matter. The three main factors consisting in the acquisition, division and allocation of land would be better safeguarded under the lay commissioners than they would under the Minister.
I am sure the Minister will agree that Section 23 is a rather revolutionary innovation. It has never appeared in any enactment up to this. Ways and means may be availed of through the operation of the laws to determine the price of land acquired for the Land Commission or for a public authority. There were clauses in some enactments which acted as a guide to safeguard the interests of all the parties concerned.
Comment on this
That is a different matter. I am sure we are within our rights, irrespective of what Deputy McQuillan——
Comment on this
The Minister proposes to acquire an interest in land offered for sale, carrying with it vacant possession. It is the function of the Land Commission to grant new holdings to allottees. The Land Commission may purchase such interest for cash and they may attend a public sale and bid by auction. I wonder if the Minister has fully considered all the matters that may arise out of that? I am sure he has given it some consideration. Has he foreseen or have his advisers foreseen all the problems and abuses that may arise under the provisions of that section? To my mind very serious abuses can arise under it in many directions. I will suggest a few to the Minister that occur to my mind. The Minister's officers visit a particular holding that may be offered for sale. Immediately they do so the vendor, or the agent of the vendor, and everybody else becomes aware that the Land Commission are interested. A number of things may happen as a result of that. The public sale comes along. Nearly all the vendors are honest people. They fix a reserve price in their own minds and they tell the agent the reserve price. There is nothing illegal or immoral if the vendor makes an arrangement with his legal adviser or someone else to have the price of that holding bid up to his reserve. Will that not be bad? Will it not be a danger to have such a scheme operating—to have the Minister's agents buying at public sales?
It is quite possible that the fact that the Minister's agent or officer visits a particular holding and inspects it may damp the sale. Other persons interested in purchasing the particular holding or piece of land will then and there decide that there is no use in bidding. They will think that if the Land Commission do not buy at the time of the sale they will take it compulsorily. In that way damage may be done to the owner. The principle of free sale may be damaged in that respect too—without that being the intention of the Minister. Even with the best intentions in the world the Minister may do damage which I am sure he would not willingly do—he may damage the principle of the free sale of land. When the prospective purchasers hear that the Land Commission are interested they will say that the State has a long purse and that there is no use in bidding against the State for a holding.
Under this section the Minister is cutting out other possible purchasers. If the Land Commission interfere, attend any sale, or inspect land offered for sale at the time, other purchasers have not a hope in the world. They probably will not bid and you may do an injury to the vendor of that land.
Comment on this
Yes, but it is a dangerous power for any Department of State to have. I can see very many of the problems that may arise under the operation of that section. The Minister and, indeed, other Deputies, may say that it is necessary in the West of Ireland where land is offered for sale to have that provision. I think and believe—and I am sure Deputies on all sides of the House will agree with me—that whether it is the West of Ireland or the East of Ireland or the South of Ireland or anywhere else that is involved, the section will not operate.
Another thing is that immediately a place is put up for sale, say, in a congested area and, indeed, it need not be a congested area at all, a local agitation starts—local interests, land hunger and landless men. It is quite natural for any human being to acquire property if he can do so, and especially if he knows that he can get it for nothing through the operation of the Land Act. It will compel the Minister for Lands, through agitation, to buy that farm at the auction. He will have no option, none in the world. That is one of the numerous dangers I foresee in this section. Then, when the Minister has acquired the farm they will further agitate as to who should get it. That will create other problems that will not solve congestion in the West. I suggest that the Minister has very elaborate powers already for acquiring every acre of land in this country that he may need. Remember that he is not amending, in this Bill, any of the powers of acquisition which he has; neither is he giving himself lesser powers. He must have felt that he had sufficient powers, elaborate enough, to acquire land. Otherwise he would have been advised that the machinery that was at the disposal of the Land Commission was too cumbersome and too slow, and that it did not enable the Minister nor the Land Commission to acquire the land needed for the easing of congestion fast enough. But Section 23 of this Bill will certainly not solve the problem.
Under Section 23, the Land Commission will acquire a holding without payment of stamp duty. Take, for instance, the case of an ordinary farmer's son who desires to purchase a holding. He has a few pounds which he gathered together over a long period of time, because he got no wages. The father has a few pounds and the son is of a certain age and wants a holding. The father decides to buy a farm if he can. If that farmer buys a farm he will have to pay 5 per cent. stamp duty on the full purchase price of the holding. The Land Commission, when they buy, will pay no stamp duty. I do not know whether they even pay fees to ordinary agents. I do not know whether they pay solicitors. However, under sub-section (4) of this section no stamp duty is payable. The State agent has a 5 per cent. advantage straight away. That is another disadvantage which the ordinary citizen suffers when buying in competition with the State. No citizen can buy against the State if the State is so minded to purchase a particular holding.
Other provisions arise out of that. Rights of way are dealt with but they are not dealt with in a manner that the ordinary citizen of the country might like. There is special provision here to deal with the question of paths to wells and different matters of rights of way across holdings.
I should like to have information from the Minister in regard to charges and equities in the case of, say, a holding acquired in this way. Will the rights of people be safeguarded or not?
Comment on this
They often, through the operations of the Land Commission, eliminate the rights of people who hold equities and charges.
Comment on this
I thought you said at the start of your speech that the Land Commission never did an injustice.
Comment on this
I say that to my knowledge. That is not the point. I am not charging the Land Commission with anything illegal, but suppose the Land Commission, for the purpose of collecting annuities due to them, put up a holding for sale, the incoming tenant has none of the charges with which that holding was burdened. Am I right or wrong?
Comment on this
Discharge in equity means that the person who owns the mortgages is paid off, but the equities and mortgages are not paid off when the holding is sold.
Comment on this
You should bring some that is a case in point. There may not of these cases to my notice.
be anything wrong and I am not suggesting it. If a holding is sold under Section 23 of the Bill, will the holders of equities or mortgages against that holding be paid?
Comment on this
Another matter may arise under Section 23. The Land Commission purchase a holding at a sale, by private or public treaty, it does not matter which. They divide it among migrants and on the acquisition of that holding the existing annuities—assuming that they were subject to annuities as most of these small holdings are— are wiped out there and then at the State expense. A new annuity is fixed which is half. That holding becomes vested in a year or two in the tenant to whom it is given and the new tenant has all the rights of fixity of tenure and free sale. He puts up that holding for public sale and the Land Commission may be forced by local agitation or otherwise again to acquire it. Again the annuity is wiped out and a new one, half that, is fixed. That could go on as a round robin and they could acquire the same holding 20 times in a century. I put it to the Minister that that is another problem that may arise under Section 23 as there is no provision in the Bill to prevent the free sale of the piece of land that may be given to a migrant or to prevent the Land Commission from acquiring it a second or even a third time. However, these are all matters of which I am sure the Minister is fully aware.
In introducing this Bill the Minister felt that the machinery at his disposal was not sufficiently loose and free to enable him to operate as fast as would be desirable. I have no doubt that he believes that this machinery should be given to him. There are many provisions in the Bill which we all agree the Land Commission should have to make for better working but there are some with which we may not altogether agree and which we may think dangerous. These have been pointed out time after time to the Minister and the matter will come up again on the Committee Stage. I believe that this is a Bill which should be amended drastically by this House and that the powers which the Minister proposes to take for himself should not be given to him. The Minister or his agent may, under this Bill, attend a public sale and buy a farm on behalf of the Land Commission. That is most undesirable and if it were passed, he would have to answer 20 or 40 questions here. He would be all day answering questions about to whom he gave land and what hope Johnnie So-and-So has. It would create a difficult problem for the Minister and the Dáil.
The Minister for Lands lectured the previous Government for many years on the problems of land acquisition and division, but he has found now, since he has the responsibility, that the difficulties are much greater than he ever contemplated when he sat on this side of the House. He has found that there is no royal road to provide land for all the congests of this country. It just is not there. A certain pool of land is available, but it is limited in extent. By disturbing persons who have land which they are using to the best advantage of the community he may damage the structure of the State. I am sure that the Minister appreciates that for the first time. The problem of congestion, which it is agreed on all sides exists very considerably in certain areas, notably in the West and North and in the South to a smaller extent, will not be entirely relieved by giving new land in the East or Midlands to the congests. I am sure that the Minister, who is charged with the full and big responsibility of relieving congestion, appreciates that the organisation of industries in the congested areas would be a great help, side by side with the utilisation of the small pool of land which is available for congests. At the same time as land division is going on and migrants are being put into rearranged holdings, the Minister should build up small cottage industries to give these people a better livelihood in their own districts. The Gaeltacht industries are a part of the Minister's function and come under his jurisdiction.
Comment on this
The organisation of those industries will do more in our time to help migrants and uneconomic holders than the division of the remainder of the pool of land that is available. They must keep in mind that land division has gone on for many years and that the big end of land available for division has been divided.
There is another matter about which, however, there is nothing in the Bill. I would ask the Minister to bring in some provision to cover it. It relates to this question of persons living on holdings of land whose dwelling houses are in bad condition and who, for some reason or another, have not proper title to their land and cannot get a loan from any loan department, either under the Small Dwellings Act or the Agricultural Credit Corporation, for the purpose of erecting a dwelling house they need to live in on that particular holding. I suggest that the Minister should make some provision in this particular Land Bill to enable the Land Commission to make advances and charge those advances on that holding in the same way as the previous advances were charged.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy serious in that—that the Land Commission should build a house at the request of one person on another man's land?
Comment on this
I am suggesting that, where a particular owner is living in a bad or tumbledown dwelling house and has not funds available to erect a new dwelling house—his title may be faulty in some way, as his grandfather may have made a will which was never discharged——
Comment on this
——he cannot get an advance from the Agricultural Credit Corporation or under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act or from any other fund, to erect a dwelling house for himself. He might need it badly for his family.
Comment on this
It might cost him more to establish title than what the land is worth. It is something that needs more than a mere dismissal of it by saying that it cannot be done. Quite recently, the Minister for Agriculture introduced and had passed through the House a Bill enabling his Department, with the aid of the Land Commission, to charge particular lands for the purpose of rehabilitation, draining and improvement, with a new annuity. I am asking the Minister to make provision in this Bill to enable him to charge a new annuity and to make an advance, in cash or otherwise, to enable a particular person to erect a dwelling house for himself. The Minister will agree that the tendency—which I have observed for many years—is for the existing holdings to get larger and for the number of holdings to become less and less. I have suggested here before that, in spite of everything the Land Commission may do in creating new holdings, side by side with that each year many more holdings with homes are going out of operation and going into the ownership of larger farmers. If a farmer requires an extra 50 or 100 acres and that is offered near him for sale, he will buy it and let the dwelling house fall. There are less and less holdings in the country than there were ten or 20 years ago. No matter how many the Land Commission may create, more are going out of existence. There are many people whose dwelling house will go into serious disrepair, who have no means of erecting a new dwelling house, who cannot borrow money from any source in this State. I would suggest to the Minister that he should seriously consider taking power—if the Land Commission has not got it already —to make an advance, where it is considered desirable, to any person in occupation of a holding, for the purpose of erecting a dwelling house or carrying out very substantial repairs to a particular dwelling house.
Comment on this
When this country was ruled by British Ministers from the House of Commons in London, and when they passed certain land legislation in response to agitation from the people, they set up machinery here to suit their own requirements and to give effect, as far as that machinery could at the time, to the express wishes of the people responsible for the passing of that land legislation. In setting up the machinery here, they took very good care to select as their servants here in Ireland commissioners or officials who would administer the policy that was very close to their own hearts. That machinery for many years after we got our own Government was biased, in my opinion, in favour of the landowner.
There is no doubt that the Land Act passed by the British, and even some of our own land legislation since I became a member of this House, was definitely biased in favour of the landowner and compelled the Minister of the day, and Deputies of this House anxious to force the hand of the Minister, to go through every iota of that machinery so that a hole would be found in it to circumvent the landlord who was anxious to prevent the acquisition and division of that land to relieve congestion.
I do not blame the civil servants or the commissioners who were put in positions by the British when they passed our first Land Acts. Civil servants—whether senior, or getting the glorified title, which carries a good salary, of commissioners—are very jealous about surrendering their power. Land commissioners under the British, and under our own Government even up to to-day, were generally selected from the ranks of the senior Civil Service or from members of the legal profession, brought in because the Government liked them personally or thought they had the necessary qualifications to administer the laws, passed here and previously, in connection with the relief of congestion.
I deny the right—and I will make this challenge in the future, as I have done in the past—of any civil servant, under any title he may get from this or previous Governments, to lay down public policy. It is the duty of the Minister in charge of the Department of State to lay down public policy and it is equally the duty of the civil servant selected by the Minister, to administer the policy laid down by his Minister and the people responsible for the selection of that Minister in this House of Parliament. We all know that the late Minister, Mr. Paddy Hogan—peace be to him—believed when bringing in the first Land Act that it would speed up the question of acquisition and division and solve, in his own time, I am sure, the problem of congestion. Yet I am here to-day inquiring from the Minister to what extent the British in their day, and ourselves in our own time up to the present, have solved that problem.
If you believe the agricultural expert of the Fianna Fáil Party, Deputy Corry, there is no more land left in this country for acquisition except the land that can be taken from small farmers. That is not my opinion. In my own constituency—and I have enough to do to mind my own constituency, without bothering about his, although he bothers about mine very often—that is not so. I would ask the Minister, when replying to this discussion, if he can put his hand on the figures without any great trouble, to tell us what portion of the untenanted land of Ireland was divided during the period of British control, or up to the time of the passing of the 1923 Act; what portion of land has been divided since the 1923 Act and up to date; what portion of the untenanted land of Ireland still remains to be divided; and in what period he hopes to have that land divided and the problem finally solved. These would be interesting figures, if he can put his finger on them. We would be able to make up our own minds then as to the real cause of the long period of delay in solving a problem which should have been solved within the lifetime of a normal man.
To the extent—and I congratulate the Minister on this—to which the Minister in this measure proposes to take power out of the hands of administrative officers—civil servants or lay commissioners, or whatever you like— and put that power into his own hands, I will shake hands with him. This Bill in that respect is nearer to reality than any Bill that has been introduced in my time here. I am not trying to pull his leg because the Minister has a big leg—he is a big man with a big mind—when I say that this Land Bill has all the appearance of a Bill that has been drafted by a man who is close to the minds of the people, much closer than the draftsmen who were responsible for drafting previous Land Acts. The only thing that requires to be done if the intentions of the Minister are to be put into effect is to ensure that the reorganisation of the Land Commission which is provided for by the Bill is as democratic as possible and that the Minister will have power to decide that the lay commissioners must do certain things.
Will any Deputy say that a senior civil servant or a commissioner should be the person to decide whether 1,000 acres of land shall be set aside for breeding and training horses instead of being divided amongst congests? That is interpreting the public interest and the only person properly entitled to interpret public interest or to lay down policy is the Minister selected by this House in the knowledge that those who select him are the representatives of the people. We should know more than a senior civil servant or a commissioner what the public interest means or how public policy should be laid down. I do congratulate the Minister on that. I do not blame the civil servant of to-day or the commissioners of to-day or the commissioners of yesterday for what has not been done by the Land Commission. I blame the Minister of to-day and his predecessors. The civil servants are very jealous of their authority and very careful about the way in which they discharge their responsibilities. The only complaint I have against them is that they do it in red tape fashion and pay attention to the tradition of the Land Commission even as laid down by the British in their day.
I can quote cases and give the names of estates in connection with which preliminary steps for acquisition were taken immediately after the 1923 Act was passed. Several Acts have been passed since 1923 and these steps were renewed under different Acts and under different Ministers and even under different lay commissioners and officials. Yet, the position in some cases in my constituency is the same to-day as it was 25 years ago. Does that not prove that the land commissioners and those who work under them bear in mind what their predecessors did? Although policy was supposed to have been changed, the administration is the same. The untenanted land is still undivided.
If the Minister wants one glaring case of that kind, let him look up the Alley estate, Knockaroo, County Laoighis. I was informed after every Land Act was passed that steps would be taken to have that large acreage of untenanted land divided amongst the local people. In that case there was an agitation in the days of the late Michael Davitt, and my own father told me last week-end that he remembers attending a meeting in the area with the late Michael Davitt in connection with the land war that was going on at that time in that particular area. That land is still undivided. I hope that will not be the position after this Bill comes into operation and when the Land Commission has been reorganised for the purpose of carrying out the express wishes of the people in a democratic way.
Deputy Aiken, when he was Minister for Lands, told me that a certain section of the 1936 Act—an amending Act—was brought in for the express purpose of making certain that that estate would be acquired and divided. Deputy Aiken was not the boss, although he was Minister at the time. There were other people. That is why I hope Deputies on every side of the House will regard this measure in a non-Party fashion and give the Minister, who should decide matters of public policy, all the power he requires to carry out his own wishes.
I know of individual applications of a minor character, involving small expenditure of public money, that have been made year after year as one Minister succeeded another. Some of these cases are in the same state of suspended animation to-day as they were many years ago. I brought a case to the notice of the Minister quite recently of a decent man in my constituency who got an uneconomic holding but who could not get a house on the holding which would have enabled him to get married and to go in and work the place. He has to work it from his sister's place, which is four miles away, and he has had to drive cows to and from that place every day for the last 15 or 16 years. Although there has been a change in the officials since the time this man got that holding, the present officials are not prepared to change the decision made by their predecessors. The policy is to stick to the old tradition and not to let down your predecessor. We have to get away from that, regardless of individuals. I hope that in this Bill the Minister has power to direct the lay commissioners to do certain things that are in the public interest and the interest of smallholders; and, if he has not, I hope he will take it on the Committee Stage.
I do agree, of course, that we must have a judicial commission. I would not dream of suggesting that anybody except a well-trained person, a High Court judge or Supreme Court judge, would be a proper person to decide questions of law, particularly questions of dispute over price.
I do not want to put the Minister to too much trouble because I am a wholehearted supporter of this Bill. I shall not assist Deputy Allen to butcher it and to butcher the most important parts of it. But, I would like to hear from the Minister whether many cases have come under his notice since he came into office where the landowner has been agreeable to sell to the Land Commission and did not take the attitude adopted by the majority of landowners of putting the Land Commission to every trouble and expense he could think of. How long, on the average, should it take the Land Commission to acquire and divide an estate where the landowner has expressed his willingness to sell? On the other hand, how long, on the average, should it take the Land Commission to acquire and divide an estate where the landowner objects and makes use of every section of the Land Acts to pursue his objection?
I know of a case where a landowner in my constituency—the Minister for Defence and my colleague, Deputy Flanagan, can confirm this—agreed about three years ago to sell his land to the Land Commission. Last week, Deputy Flanagan put down a question asking if and when that estate was going to be divided, with the knowledge that the landowner had agreed so long ago to sell to the Land Commission. Here are we, the Deputies for the constituency, being badgered by our constituents, and properly so, in regard to the delay on the part of the Land Commission in connection with that estate and the Minister in that case was unable to say when that estate would be divided. I think there has been something radically wrong with the machinery of the Land Commission in that case, and that is why I ask the Minister to tell me what is the average period it should take the Land Commission, if it is a properly organised Department, to deal with cases where the landlord is willing to sell and where the landlord is unwilling to sell.
The Land Commission, apart from the heads, requires to be reorganised from top to bottom, or from bottom to top, whichever way you wish to take it. It is the only Department of State I know of from which you get this buff-coloured acknowledgement of your communication—and you are a lucky man if you get a reply in six months. I understood that, when the Minister for Finance took over control of that responsible Department, when this Government was established, he issued an instruction or advice to the heads of all Government Departments that members of the public and Deputies, anybody who thought fit to write in to or to telephone a Government Department should be treated courteously and should get an answer one way or the other within a reasonable time. We get acknowledgements from the Land Commission, but it takes a hell of a long time to get a reply, and in some cases we never get a reply. One is told that one's application is being dealt with in a sympathetic way.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy not have an opportunity of discussing all that on the administration of the Land Commission?
Comment on this
I thought I was entitled to refer to it because there is a section in the Bill, a most important section, giving the Minister power to reorganise the Land Commission, and I suggest that if the Land Commission is properly reorganised, citizens who write direct to the Department, who telephone or call to the Department, and particularly Deputies who represent these citizens, will get what they are entitled to, that is, an answer to their communications within a reasonable time.
Comment on this
I further suggest that, if the answer is in the negative, a good and valid reason should be given for the commissioners' refusal to accede to a reasonable request. I understand that the Minister for Finance issued that instruction when this Government took office, and I urge the Minister, before sanctioning the scheme of reorganisation, to make certain that it will be done in future. There are enough officials in the Land Commission to deal with the business of that very important State Department in the same way as I see it being dealt with in other State Departments. If the commissioners or chief officers have not got sufficient staff to enable them to do the work in a proper businesslike way, the businesslike way in which work is done in any well-run commercial concern, I urge the Minister to provide the necessary staff so that the work under this new scheme of reorganisation will be done better in future than it has been done up to the present.
With regard to Deputy Corry's statements, the Minister can deal more effectively with Deputy Corry and Deputy Allen than I can. It is not my job, but I thought it a very serious statement for Deputy Corry to make when he said that the only land remaining to be acquired is that owned by the ordinary farmer. If that is so, we are wasting our time here.
Comment on this
An estate of 1,500 acres, 1,300 acres, 1,000 acres, 600 acres or 500 acres in the possession of a citizen is not in the possession of what is commonly known as an ordinary farmer in my part of the country.
Comment on this
"Landlord" is a word which is more understandable by those of us who are anxious to have the untenanted land which we see all around our constituencies acquired and divided in a reasonable time.
I note that it is the intention of the Minister to secure power to pay gratuities to disemployed labourers. I personally regret that the necessity for such a provision should arise and I have grave doubts whether it should arise in the same way in the future as it has arisen apparently in the past, because there was another way of settling the question. During Deputy Moylan's term of office as Minister a Bill was brought into this House and passed to give power to the Minister —I voted for it and I regret to say that I knew that there were good reasons why I should do so—to dispossess people to whom land had been given and who never took possession of that land or made any attempt to work it. In particular areas in my constituency there were decent young men, the sons of small farmers and labourers, who were quite willing to work the land if the commissioners had used more wisdom in the selection of the allottees.
I spoke to the Minister quite recently, with others, about one estate divided 15 years ago, on which three allottees had houses built at the expense of the taxpayers and economic holdings provided for them, and who up to this day have not walked into the houses built for them or made any attempt to work these holdings. We passed a measure empowering the Minister to dispossess about 1,500 such persons. If 1,500 persons of that type get houses built and holdings given to them at the expense of the taxpayers, it is a very serious reflection on the judgment of the Land Commission inspectors responsible for recommend ing these people. It is in the public interest that they should be dispossessed and the holdings given to good Irishmen who will try to make a living out of them.
I want to put it to the Minister that the real cause of the failure of men who were herds or ploughmen employed by landowners in the old days to work land was the fact that they were not provided with sufficient working capital when given these holdings. If in cases I know of good ploughmen, herds and agricultural labourers had been given sufficient capital to make a start at the proper time, there would be no necessity for the inclusion of this provision in the Bill authorising the Minister to pay gratuities to disemployed labourers. I wonder is it too late for the Minister and his colleagues to do what has been so well done in other countries where activity of the same kind has been carried on, that is, to provide the labourers who lost their employment on the land acquired and divided with a minimum amount to enable them to purchase machinery and buy stock and make a decent start rather than to pay them compensation and to tell them to look for a job elsewhere, to look for their cards at the employment exchange and for a passport from the Department of External Affairs to enable them to go to work possibly for a farmer in Great Britain. I should prefer to see these people who have been working on the land given some chance of working land for themselves and providing a decent livelihood for themselves and their dependents. If that had been done after the first Land Act was passed by this House there would not be the same kind of story to tell about the failure of that class of people in the matter of the working of land as is to be told to-day.
I am not going to take up the time of the House any longer because I am fully satisfied with the contents of this Bill and with the assurance given by the Minister that further legislation will follow. I am very keen that the Minister should avail of his great knowledge of the people of the country and of his limited experience in the Land Commission to see that when this Bill becomes law, the Land Commission will not be worked under the type of machinery that was considered suitable for the working of that Department when the British Parliament passed the first Land Bill in the House of Commons.
Comment on this
I do not think that the Minister, in making his opening statement, told us very much more than was already in the White Paper. For instance, when he was dealing with the question of market value, I think he might have given us an idea of how market value is to be arrived at.
Comment on this
In the same way as market value is arrived at at the present time and for a number of years past for unvested land.
Comment on this
I assume that was done under the old definition, namely, a fair price from the point of view of the Land Commission and the point of view of the purchaser.
Comment on this
No. That is what has caused the trouble in regard to vested land and that is what is being repealed now in this Bill. Market value was paid for unvested land since the 1923 Act but it was not paid for vested land and that is what gave rise to all the trouble.
Comment on this
In administration, I assume that the inspectors had always in mind the principle that in fixing a price for the purchaser, the price must be such that the farmer would not be plunged into debt and such as would enable him to bring up his family in frugal comfort and with reasonable profits. Under the former Administration that was one of the main objects and every inspector or valuer had to take that very carefully into consideration. If they are to arrive at the market value now, it must be according to the fluctuations which take place from time to time. Looking back over the history of the value of land, we know that these fluctuations swung from very high to very low. The Minister can recall a period, during and after the first war, when the price of land was very much inflated. That was the market value then. Afterwards there came a period when farmers were coming to all of us who represented rural areas, telling us that they had suffered very severely. Some of them were "broke" because they had bought at a time when prices were very high. Later the price of cattle and other produce fell to such an extent that they were not able to make ends meet. I suggest that the standard "market value" by itself is swinging too much in one direction and that it would be fair that "market value" should be checked by some other considerations such as the old definition which protected both the State and the individual purchaser as well.
Further, I would suggest that if there is a gap between what you might call the economic price to the purchaser of the farm and the amount that would be fair in cases of hardship to the vendor, the difference should be made up not by the imposition of a high rent or price which would be too difficult for the farmer to meet, but that the State should intervene and give compensation. There is reference to compensation for disturbance, and I think the Minister might have told us that he was taking that type of case into consideration. He did mention that there was a small number of cases where there was real hardship to the vendor, but hard cases make bad law. I do not think the overriding definition should be determined by such hard cases, but that the State should allow for such elasticity as would enable it to deal with hard cases as they arise. A danger also arises once the State goes into the open market, as the State will have to now. I gathered that it was implied by the Minister that the operations of the Land Commission will be largely concentrated on getting rid of rundale holdings and placing migrants on other holdings. If that is done on a wholesale scale, it means that the Land Commission will have to go into the open market to a very considerable extent and that in itself will enhance the value of land.
Then again on the question of market value, rich people come along here from other countries and buy farms. I know one county where about 34 such farms were bought. They do not regard these purchases from the economic point of view. They regard these lands rather as residential farms and they give fancy prices for them. That can influence the whole standard of prices and the market value. We ourselves, in regard to house property, had to put on a high tax in order to stop inflation of the price of property of that type and it had the desired effect. Do I gather from the Minister that he would not like farms to be sold from the Land Commission to foreigners, that he would confine it to nationals? In answer to Deputy Lehane, I gather that he said something of that sort, that the Land Commission would not allow farms to be sold to outsiders?
Comment on this
That is a matter that will have to be taken into account. To quote a speech of Lord Rugby on one occasion, he said that these fellow-countrymen of his were coming over to this country and buying property here and that some people regarded it as the retreat from Moscow. If you do get a number of rich people buying land in that way, it is going to inflate the price. I, therefore, suggest that there should be some controlling phrase governing the definition of "market value" which will protect the purchasing farmer.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not think that there is a difference between market price and market value, which latter is specified in the Bill?
Comment on this
The old definition by which the land inspectors were guided did not increase the price of land. They would not take the day-to-day market value. I think it is not definite enough.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy not agree that it is not the ordinary layman in the main who will determine what the market value is?
Comment on this
If farmers are buying land that is going to affect prices and the value of land will go up as a result of the general lay opinion in the matter. Then, again, I think it is a weakness in the Bill that you should be reducing the number of commissioners on the Appeal Board. However clever the Judicial Commissioner may be—like the professor of classics on a famous occasion who, when he made a mistake when writing on a blackboard, said he was ex-officio ignorant in mathematics—if a man has concentrated on being an expert in law, he is not necessarily a good valuer of land. It is much more likely that your lay commissioners will be experts from the point of view of fixing the value of land. For that reason, I think it is throwing a tremendous responsibility on the Judicial Commissioner to ask him to decide questions as to the value of land.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not think that Section 5 would reduce considerably the number of appeals that might arise on the question of price?
Comment on this
I do not think so. I think the very vagueness of the phrase "market value" is going to increase enormously the number of cases that will come before the Judicial Commissioner.
Comment on this
Unless you are able to elaborate this definition so that it will be very much clearer to people what market value means, I think you will find that the number of cases that will come before the Judicial Commissioner in future will be much greater than in the past. I think the Minister might have been a little more frank with the House in pointing out the extra power which he himself is taking with regard to rearrangement schemes. He is taking very large powers with regard to rearrangement schemes. In that case he can himself appoint a senior inspector to fix the price and to decide who are to be the allottees. In that case, also, he need only get the consent of one commissioner and not two, as in excepted cases, so that he is taking very great power for himself. He may claim that he is going to expedite the work, but I think that in these two matters he is taking very dangerous power unto himself. He will be responsible not merely for the price fixed, but also for the allottees who are to receive the land.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister admits, with regard to rearrangement schemes, that he is taking much bigger power. It is not an excepted matter. Elsewhere he has power to appoint one inspector not lower than a senior inspector.
Comment on this
Except in the case of rearrangement schemes, which are not excepted matters. They bear on rundale and, obviously, on migrants. The only other point I should like to make is to emphasise a point made by Deputy Moylan. I do think that, even if you have commissioners who are only used for the purpose of appeals, some of them who have experience could be employed very well in helping to consolidate the Acts which have gone before, because consolidation is really needed. I am perfectly sure that the officials of the Land Commission would be delighted to see that that work had been done. It would simplify the work of everybody very considerably and save headaches all round if the Minister would direct that a consolidation Bill should be given very special attention and introduced in due time.
Comment on this
I subscribe thoroughly to the last suggestion made by Deputy Little. I think a consolidation Act is long overdue. Like many other Deputies. I welcome the Bill with this reservation—I should like the Minister to realise that to me at any rate it is a positive reservation—that I look upon this Bill as a step in the right direction. I am not going to weary the House by airing many of the views I have already aired on other occasions as to the administration of the land law. Part of it is a bad legacy and, in the main, efforts at amendment of the land law have only added confusion to something already confused. I feel that the Minister in this Bill may be possibly making more difficult the ultimate codification in a reasonable way of our land law. I must confess, as a practitioner of a number of years' standing, that I find each new amendment or each new regulation under the Land Acts only more confusing. Beyond two specific powers given in this Bill, I do not feel that there is any radical change being made, except possibly a question of interpretation which is dealt with.
I am not going to be tempted, as at one stage I was, to follow the rather tragic, pathetic, calamitous, stupid argument of Deputy Allen to its logical conclusion. Whether he was deliberately mischievous or just plain dumb, he started off by telling the Minister that he is taking certain powers under Section 10 and quoted paragraphs (b), (c) and (d). The actual opening words of Section 10 designate these clearly as excepted matters with which the Minister cannot deal. Yet Deputy Allen has the audacity, the crass impudence, to suggest that the Minister is acquiring this power under the Bill when the actual opening words of the section designate these specifically as matters excepted from the purview of the Minister. That is sufficient for Deputy Allen's rambling, wandering statement which was purely obstructive rather than constructive.
He asked me specifically if I could give him some definition of "untenanted land." If he reads Section 73 (2) of the 1923 Land Act he will get, basically, a definition of "untenanted land" and it still stands with the exception of tenancies which may have been in being at the passing of the 1923 Act which a decision of the Supreme Court held to be such. Untenanted land, as it implies, is land in regard to which there is no contract of tenancy and of which the owner in occupation is owner in fee simple, or under a fee farm grant, or any lease for lives or for a term of years of which 60 years is unexpired.
Deputy Allen has practical experience as an auctioneer in his own constituency and, therefore, the definition of untenanted land should not present to him any of the difficulties which he has been airing in the House. I do want to say at the outset that we are all a little bit dishonest and inclined to be political on a land matter. The land problem is of vital importance to the economic structure of our country, and so it should be moved, if possible, from a Party political level. From my limited experience, I want to point out to the Minister some of the difficulties that can and must inevitably arise under the land system as it is, and will be when this Bill is passed. The only real difference which the passing of this Bill is going to make is contained in Sections 5 and 23. Section 5 will compel the Land Commission to pay the market value for land. I can, to some extent, appreciate certain of the difficulties which are presenting themselves in a genuine way to the mind of Deputy Little as to how market value is to be determined. I think that, when the section comes to be operated, that difficulty will simplify itself.
We have to draw a distinction between market price and market value. I want seriously to sound this note of warning for the Minister, that he will have to consider what has been urged upon him from all sides of the House, namely, the detrimental effect, from an inflationary point of view, which the arbitrary buying of holdings by wealthy foreigners could have. That may not have reached very alarming proportions so far, but it is something which the Minister will have to watch because of its possible reaction in inflating prices.
I think that Deputy Little was honest in the submission that he made on that point. If anything of that kind were to occur it might result in very grave hardship to the person who, ultimately, was put in possession of a farm that had been purchased by the Land Commission. I wonder if it would not be more reasonable to assume that, under the operation of this section, there may be infinitely more goodwill found than heretofore as between the Land Commission and the person selling the land. I say that because the person whose land is going to be acquired will not be subjected to an arbitrary price different from that for unvested land. That person will be met on the basis that, no matter what the technicalities behind the scenes are, the value of land itself, whether it is vested or unvested, is going to be the same.
Fundamentally, there was at one time, possibly, a reason for a difference in price as between vested and unvested land. That was a difference that could be legitimately argued and was properly argued. It was that, in the main, the people in this State were reentering their own, that tenants were being replaced on land which was formerly theirs but which had been acquired, through confiscation or plantation, by the foreigner. I think that in the main that stage has passed. If it has not passed, I would urge on the Minister that, on the Committee Stage, he should make a reservation to himself that he could still pay not anything like the real value for a holding that could be acquired by the Land Commission, where it is still in the possession of the seed or generation of planters, to meet the claims of evicted tenants in the locality. I think that the acquisition of the type of land that Section 23 contemplates for the benefit of migrants will be from decent Irish men who are properly in possession of it but may want to sell it. It may be necessary, in the national interest, for the Land Commission to acquire some of that land in order to give decent people a chance of living on the soil of Ireland.
This Bill is revolutionary in the steps it takes under Section 5. I think that, possibly, our doubts and our fears in regard to the section may be allayed when the Bill has been in operation for some time. I think the Minister will have to be very careful to see that some basis is found on which to determine the real value of land. That should not be left completely to be settled in a situation in which you had either inflation or deflation. A situation of that kind should not influence the Land Commission in the price they would pay. I wish the section good luck. I think that Deputy Little was honest in his submissions in trying to point out the dangers which he could conceive in regard to this section. I, too, can see dangers in it, but possibly youth makes me optimistic. I am of opinion that, if the section is given a chance, the difficulties that genuinely seem to arise at this stage will resolve themselves in practice.
The section of the Bill which merits the serious consideration of the House is Section 23. Deputy Allen excelled himself on it. He was lachrymose as to what was going to happen under it. He did not know whether he was going to stand on his left foot or his right foot when speaking on it; he did not know whether the poor person whose land was being sold was going to be mulcted because the Land Commission was going to bid for it. People, he said, would not dream of bidding against the State, and he did not know whether the Minister, on behalf of the State, would not be mulcted by people running up the price on him so that he would have to pay an exorbitant price for the land. I think that Deputy Allen, possibly, and to some extent Deputy Little have missed the real essential. Deputy Little's submission was, possibly, due to an oversight, but Deputy Allen's was mischievous. The section puts no compulsion on the Land Commission to bid. If it finds that the price is too high it can withdraw from the contest.
Some people seem to think that the only agency through which the Land Commission can act under this section is going to be composed of either rogues or fools. I am content to believe that they will be neither. I am satisfied that the agent buying on behalf of the Land Commission, or the person designated to do so by the Minister, will be a rational being, and that normally he will be authorised by the Land Commission to give for the land what is considered to be a reasonable price. If he is outbid at the auction he can withdraw and let the land go to the highest bidder. I cannot see, under this section, any reason for alarm. I think it is a very good idea, and a bold experiment if it comes off, for the Land Commission to buy land in the open market, It will make for infinitely more content among the people whose land is taken in that way, because they will then feel no grievance as to price.
I do not believe there is any danger of Deputy Allen's left-legged idea of land being deflated to little or no value. His fears that the Land Commission will frighten other bidders are airy, fairy fears. This is a section that has to be put into effect cautiously, I will admit, but in my optimism I am prepared to think it is a section that will work extremely well. It will relieve the heartache and burnings that we Deputies have to face over people who are quite anxious to get rid of big holdings but are afraid the Land Commission will not give them value.
Taking Deputy Little to be a reasonable person making reasonable submissions, I question him as to why he is apprehensive that the Judicial Commissioner might have an increasing number of determinations of price to deal with. He made no solid case. Surely, if the situation arises that a person will get a more equitable price for his land, as Section 5 will ensure, and if the Land Commission in the future, with regard to migrants, can go into the open market and buy their holdings, those two things must logically and rationally lead to a better degree of satisfaction as to price and, therefore, inevitably the appeals that will go to the Judicial Commissioner for determination must decline. The appeal in the main will be because the price is too low. What appeal will any person have if the Land Commission buy in the open market? It will wipe out that type of appeal and I think the Judicial Commissioner can look forward to many happy years of lean work.
I do not like being facetious, but I have often felt that the best description one may give of the "lay commissioners" in the Land Commission is the "delay commissioners". I am glad the Minister is improving this cumbersome procedure and we will not have that anomaly any more where you have lay commissioners excluded from acting as lay commissioners because as lay commissioners they are members of an appeal tribunal. It is an amazing situation. It must have been a tortuous brain that conceived it. Fortunately, we have a fairly active brain operating to remove it.
People seem to be anxious to see difficulties and dangers in this Bill. I have one great hope for it and that is, that the clarity of some of its sections will remove some of the difficulties and dangers and some of the extraordinary juxtapositions that exist. It will ensure that there will be no more general outcry, no more wails of widows or anybody else that the Land Commission have practically robbed them of their heritage, because this Bill will enshrine one principle, that there will be no more virtual confiscation price for land when it is resumed or ac-acquired, as there was in the old days, in so far as this Bill tends to establish the principle that a man selling his land, whether to the Land Commission or to anybody else, can go into the open market and get the best price. As long as it ensures that principle, you are making a realistic advance in settling land problems.
In my own constituency I know people anxious to vacate fairly substantial farms, people who, when this Bill becomes law, will without hesitation offer them to the Land Commission. These people may, through economic circumstances, old age, lack of a young family coming up, or possibly lack of younger people in farming as a livelihood, find themselves in the position where it would be infinitely better if they could get rid of the land. They will be happier and they will have a real appreciation of the Minister because he is now assuring them that they need not be afraid there will be any arbitrary price imposed on them or that the Land Commission will pay only what they feel like paying for the holding.
I do not think this Bill goes half far enough. It is only still scratching at the problem. There is a wealth of confusion in our land code. There is every necessity, not only for codifying land legislation, such as Deputy Little pleads for, but also for reasoned minds to address themselves to the problem of clarifying as well as codifying the law. I suggest that the Minister, before he takes his next step in relation to the land code, should deal with everything in a careful way and not content himself with one small sphere, such as he does in this Bill. I trust he will deal with the whole matter on the basis of simplifying the method of making good your title and, above all, he should bring about a more speedy method of vesting. I regret that this Bill does not deal with that problem. I think perhaps some of the worst delays in vesting may be offset when Section 5 becomes operative because then the people controlling credit will know that unvested land and vested land rank pari passu so far as price is concerned.
I wholeheartedly support this Bill because it is a step in the right direction. I think the Minister is working along the right lines. I think he should ensure that economic holdings, upon which the State has spent money, will never under any circumstances, if offered for sale, be allowed to pass into the hands of an alien who might thereby benefit but that those who suffered under the old order of "to hell or to Connaught", will be given an opportunity of coming back into the enjoyment of the land of Ireland.
Comment on this
This problem of land and the various Land Acts governing it has been one of the most debated problems throughout the country. People will naturally look at this Act to see if there is in it any improvement on previous Acts. From a cursory glance at the Bill it appears to me that the Minister is anxious to take more control himself. That is my personal view.
Comment on this
That may be a good thing and it may be a bad thing. I dare say every man ought to be boss in his own house. As a nation we are susceptible to likes and dislikes. Governments can change overnight. Taking the long view, I feel that the lay commissioners acted impartially in the acquisition and distribution of land. Admittedly the machine may have been slow. No matter how fast the machine may go, the fact remains that we have not sufficient land for everybody. No matter how willing and anxious the Minister is, he will not be able to please everybody. Under this Act the Minister is doing away with the lay commissioners. I think the lay commissioners were very sound because they did not act from political motives. They decided each case on its merits.
I come now to deal with the market value of land. I think that if a man decides to sell his land, because of economic circumstances or for any other reason, and the Land Commission decides to acquire that land he should be given the value of the land on the open market. The only difficulty is as to how the Minister will determine the market value. Land normally goes to the highest bidder. The possibility is that, if it is known generally that the Land Commission intends to buy, the seller may have other bidders there for the purpose of running up the price. That is only human nature.
Comment on this
One must face the position as one finds it. That, as I say, is only human nature. I believe that a seller should be paid a proper price for his land. On the other hand, a greatly enhanced price may have repercussions on the subsequent allottee because it may place on him a liability he cannot afford to carry.
Comment on this
I have studied it. I come now to deal with the question as to whether or not the Minister is taking too great powers under Sections 5 and 10 of this measure. Every native Government has done its utmost to deal with the land problem. The difficulty is to decide whether to rush matters or to let events shape their own course. Possibly the Fianna Fáil Government made some mistakes in allotting land to people who did not deserve it or who did not make good tenants. No matter how careful the inspectors may be, that can occur. Naturally if that does occur steps must be taken to remove such people. So far as I can see the Minister is abrogating more power to himself under this Act to settle any friends he likes on land than any of the powers taken by the Fianna Fáil Government under the 1933 Land Act.
It was often stated to the Fianna Fáil Minister, in relation to the 1933 Act, by Deputies who were then on the Opposition side of the House that the Fianna Fáil clubs did this, that and the other but, under that Act, the Minister was actually a Minister and the Commissioners were there to carry out the Act as laid down to them. I see that under this Act the Minister can settle up a few friends and that he will have more power to do so or, if any other Deputy should go to him, that he will have more power than the Fianna Fáil Minister had or than he himself has had hitherto.