Land Bill, 1949—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 143–282 of 282. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 35 of 1949 ›
It is long over-due. That system has been responsible for a good deal of trouble in families and between neighbours. I hope that the Minister, under this Act will divide land and, further, I should like to see a section in this Bill to the effect that roads would be provided in such a way that the Land Commission could hand them over to the various county councils. I should like to see a section in this Act dealing with that problem because the position all over the country, even under the last Land Act, is that the roads that were made through holdings or through estates, either for sub-division or for ordinary holdings or for farms, were not what they should have been. I hold that any Department of State responsible for land division should see that they make a perfect road through the land and that, in conjunction with the Minister for Local Government, the Minister for Lands should have a provision in this Bill which would ensure that that road would be taken over by the various county councils. That is a point that has been neglected, notwithstanding the fact that the roads were made. They were reasonably good roads too —at least, they looked all right for a while. I became a member of this House in 1944 and, since then, I have made more representations about bad roads through holdings of land than, possibly, any other Deputy in that period.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy want me to compel the Minister for Local Government to take them over?
Comment on this
The Minister must agree with me that there is definitely a problem there. If he states that there is not a problem there, all that I can say is that he has changed very much since he was sitting on this side of the House. I heard him, when he was a member of the Opposition, making several representations in this House regarding the problems of bad roads, Land Commission roads and so forth.
The land of this country should be divided, as a matter of national policy, amongst the very best applicants. Another matter which has often been discussed in this House is the question of the size of holdings. I realise that in the Minister's county and in other western counties the problem of small uneconomic holdings is ever present and has been in existence for hundreds of years. The same can be said in regard to other parts of Ireland also. My sizing up of the whole matter is this: is it not better to give a man an economic holding than to try and give him nine or ten acres of land and leave him hanging in mid-air, as it were, so that he is neither a farmer nor a labourer?
Comment on this
The problem is not so bad in County Dublin because, with a few acres, a man could develop a market garden and, possibly, make some kind of a living for himself. But down the country, and even in parts of my own constituency in County Dublin, the position is quite different, because these people will have to try to make out a living for themselves, to keep a horse or two horses, or maybe a tractor, and a few cows on, say, only 22 statute acres of land. I do not think, taking the long view, that the State is any better for that condition of affairs. I have come across a number of such cases in my constituency. These men are out looking for work on the roads and, if they have a family, they are up against it. If you are giving a holding at all the very least should be one of approximately 35 acres.
Comment on this
I am taking into consideration the number of uneconomic holdings I know in that part of the country where I was born and, again, that I have come to know since I came to Dublin. I realise that the problem is there. I do not want to suggest any more at the moment but I feel that if you give a man a nice holding of land he has a chance of making a living on it. In that way you are keeping him off the labour market —and that is an important point. If he is industrious and goes in, say, for dairying or for market gardening, or such like, he will employ a man. On the other hand, if you give him 15 or 16 acres he will employ nobody and, in addition, he himself will try to get a job that some other labouring man should get. If I were to make the same statement among the congests of Mayo they would say I was their enemy but, truly, that is the position as I see it in County Dublin.
Another problem which has often been brought to my attention in County Dublin and especially in respect of areas where there are a lot of council cottages and where the people there find it rather difficult to get milk sometimes—take, for instance, the north-west part of County Dublin— is the problem of cow parks. I should be glad if the Minister would consider feasible applicants and, if there should be any land adjoining council cottages, I think he should seriously consider giving these people a park for milch cows. It has been the practice in certain parts of the country long before the Land Commission came into being.
Comment on this
Of course that is true. The Minister should consider that when he is dividing land. I am going to deal with a rather ticklish question, that of migrants.
Comment on this
Before migrants come into a parish the land in it should be divided among the uneconomic holders of the parish. I must speak for my own people in County Dublin where there are a large number of small uneconomic holdings, 750 holdings of under 10 acres and over 500 of under five acres. We escaped the migrants over the years of Fianna Fáil and during the period of the previous Government. I think there were only 11 in all those years.
Comment on this
I am hardly able to look after County Dublin without going there. You had more land in Meath than we have in County Dublin. Only that these people are so industrious and carry on market gardening they would not have a living, although their proximity to the city has helped them. I would ask the Minister to deal justly with such people and not to be influenced in a national question of this kind by political motives. The Minister knows of the problem as he was born in an area where it existed. Before migrants are put into an area I should like to see the uneconomic holders with four or five acres looked after. People in County Dublin who have small uneconomic holdings look forward to the acquisition by the Land Commission of certain lands that have not been worked satisfactorily
There is another point about which I see nothing in the Bill and for which the Minister and the Land Commission should be responsible, the problem of water on land. I hold that in law the Land Commission is the landlord of all the land in this country.
Comment on this
I am not talking about drainage. I am talking about bringing water into land where no drainage is needed at all. We have that problem in North County Dublin where farmers had to draw water three and four miles last year and it was not the first year they had to do it. The Land Commission should sink a pump when giving land if there is no water on it. The most essential thing for cattle is pure clear water. I have already approached the Minister on this subject and asked him in a question here if he would consider introducing some scheme, as he is in charge of that Department for the time being, to encourage farmers to sink pumps. Many small farmers cannot afford to spend £300 or £400. They can go to another Department and get a loan but few farmers like to put a millstone round their necks by getting a loan of £400 or £500. In certain areas which I can point out to the Minister there is no water.
Comment on this
Did the Minister not tell the Deputy last summer that that is a problem for the local authorities, not for the Land Commission?
Comment on this
When I went to the local authorities they said they were only concerned with human beings.
Comment on this
I am not saying that the problem has not been there for some time, but when we are introducing new legislation we should do this in ordinary justice, because what is the use of dividing land unless you see there is water on it if the tenant has to draw water two, three or four miles when a dry season comes? Shortage of water and bad water is responsible for cattle dying of disease. The time has come to handle that problem which is getting more acute as time goes on. The Minister and the Land Commission are in charge of the lands of this country. They are collecting annuities and they should see that the land is in perfect order as far as water is concerned.
Comment on this
An annuity is only the repayment of money loaned to a farmer to purchase his holding.
Comment on this
The local authorities have to provide water for human beings and they have to repay money.
Comment on this
I wonder, if Deputy Burke got his way, what the Land Commission would become? It would become an unmanageable body to do all and everything. It would have to provide water, build roads, divide land and do 40,000 other things.
Comment on this
I wonder does the Minister seriously contend that the Land Commission should continue to dish out holdings without water.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister seriously if he thinks he should give a holding with no road there? It is his duty to see that there is a road. An unfortunate man or woman will go into a holding and will have no road there and there is no obligation on the Minister or on the Land Commission to see that there is water there either. I wonder what is the Minister's function or if he is going to say what the Land Commission is going to be. I am very sorry that the Minister cannot see the light of day through the very practical suggestion I am making to him.
Comment on this
I did not say any such thing. I will tell the Deputy all about pumps and other things.
Comment on this
I will put down an amendment about roads and about watering land where there is no water. Indeed, if the Land Commission did all the things I would like to see them do as owners of the land of this country the Department would be doing a bit of work I assure you.
The drainage of land is another problem with which I will not deal now as it has nothing to do with this particular Minister. He has been relieved of that.
I appeal to the Minister not to reduce the number of lay commissioners. That is the only assurance we have that every case will be considered on its merits and that no political influence will be responsible for a Minister wavering from one particular man to another, or buying land from a particular man because he did not like him, and giving it to another, saying: "Take this fellow's holding." Under the old system, there was a greater chance of ordinary common law and justice existing all round.
Comment on this
Coming from the country, I am naturally interested in any proposals regarding the acquisition or division of land. It is a national problem that affects the lives of our people more intimately than any other subject. Our people have a tradition in land and associations so deep and so general with it that there is hardly a person—no matter what occupation he may have in the course of his life—who has not close contact with land, either directly or through his father or grandfather. Proposals to deal with land arouse feelings that no other subject could arouse in the minds of our people in general.
In my opinion, the present Bill is a much needed one. It introduces the possibility of the Government acquiring land for sub-division or the creation of new holdings. It gives them a power that had faded out and become obsolete over a number of years, due to the emergency period and the economic conditions prevailing since then. The Land Commission, having acquired all the estates which the landlords owned and sold them to the existing tenants, gradually moved on towards acquiring large properties of several hundred acres, which were apportioned out into new holdings —or sometimes used for the enlargement of uneconomic holdings—and after a time, when those estates of comparatively vast areas were exhausted, we came to the point where in order to acquire land, they had to use their powers of compulsory acquisition and pay a price as award to such owners. Our original plans were to acquire big estates from owners who had no popular claim to the ownership and, accordingly, prices were regulated for the award. At the time prices were thus fixed, conditions were different in many ways from what they are to-day. We had reached the stage when the Land Commission, carrying out a useful national work of providing land for the landless and adding to the uneconomic holdings so as to make them economic, have been forced to pay a price to the owners that was out of touch with modern prices and with justice. Therefore, a Bill of this nature became essential, as it empowers the Minister, through the Land Commission, to pay a reasonable price according to prevailing prices.
There arises one danger, which seems to be very serious, in this proposal. It is proposed to go into the competitive market in the purchase of land. If, as a State entity, the Land Commission become competitors for the purchase of land, then if they desire to acquire a particular farm no private owner may venture to buy against them. Under such conditions, I can see a person willing to sell his farm, offering it through the good agency of his friends as competitors, asking the Land Commission, with the State funds behind them, to pay a price far beyond the economic value. They would thus acquire a heavy liability and future rents, demanded necessarily from the tenants who are allotted a portion of that estate, will be proportionately high and uneconomic in the various changes and exigencies of farm economy.
On the other hand, I notice that the Bill says that the Land Commission shall determine the market value. Let us say they determine that it should be something below what, in the ordinary way, a farm would make in fair, open competition where there are fair, open buyers. There is no such thing as a fair value for land. Within a mile of the City of Dublin, an acre may make a few hundred pounds. Even that applies to lands adjoining remote towns in the country, where it may be useful for grazing or building. Within a quarter of a mile from that, there may be a fine farm of many acres, which would realise only £20 per acre, though equal quality land and agriculturally as good as that which fetched the £200 an acre because of its proximity and because of the competition. Therefore, there is no such thing as a fair price for land. It varies according to location and competition. The man—whether it be the Minister or members of the Land Commission— who could determine a fair price for land is not to be found. Prices so vary that, if the Land Commission are going into competition, there is the danger that those who are selling may find advocates who realise that the value of the farm is a very high price, more than normally would be received in the market, and the Land Commission may pay far too much. Bordering tenants may see that land offered as part allotment to their holdings or as new holdings.
Again, if the Land Commission determine the price, should any farm be offered, medium or large, the competition is destroyed, as there are always in a district people who will say: "The Land Commission are buyers, and if they buy, I will get portion of it." In their own way, these men can destroy the possibility of any outside competition and ensure that only the Land Commission shall be the buyer. In that respect, I see in this Bill a danger that that big charter of liberty which was secured during the days of land agitation—free sale—may be destroyed. It can happen.
Unless the operation of this Bill is very carefuly watched and very carefully handled by the Minister and the Land Commission, the right of free sale may easily be destroyed. In that way, the small farmer and the farmer with the medium-sized farm may find, if he wants to put it on the market, that he is restricted to the price that the Land Commission in their wisdom may determine is the fair price. Do not destroy the right of free sale or you will destroy a very important asset to the farmers of this country. As this Bill stands it has within it that danger. I would like to see greater security than is provided in this Bill that the right of the farmer to sell in a competitive market to the best buyer he may find will be retained.
I have already said that I approve of the Bill in so far as it is necessary to bring up the price of land in view of the reduced value of money since ten or 15 years ago and thus make it possible, in a legitimate and a just way, for the Land Commission to acquire lands, where they may be acquired, at a fair price and thus improve the conditions of that needy section of the community, the men who have no land and men who have uneconomic holdings. There is a danger that in doing that we may go too far. We are giving powers in this Bill which, I am sure, will be very discreetly exercised by the Land Commission or by the present Minister or his successors but it still destroys that right, which is a vital thing to the farming community, that, if they have land to sell, they can freely offer it and secure the benefit of free competition in a price that is not measured by some valuation of what is a fair price. The competitive price is the price that every person wants to get when he goes on the market whether he is selling a hen, a pig, a cow or anything else. Competition should rule the price. If the price is fixed, there is no such thing as competition. What business man will venture to put money in a business if there is no speculation that it may improve in price and that he will get a better price for it when he wants to sell it than he paid for it? What man will put a pound on a horse if he does not feel that he may get £2 in return? What man will speculate on the stock exchange without the incentive of potential return? This Bill is destroying that incentive as far as land is concerned and the position must be clarified in the interest of every small, medium and large farmer who holds land.
As regards the purpose of the Bill, the Minister is asking for powers to acquire land. His own intimate knowledge must have convinced him long ago that those best fitted to use the land to the best advantage are those who have traditional knowledge of land, namely, the men in the congested areas. These men have struggled against adverse conditions and have laboured in good periods and bad periods. They have reared large families on what are regarded as uneconomic holdings.
Since the time when Cromwell drove our people from the rich lands and scattered them around the coast, south and west, they have continued to eke out an existence in conditions that could hardly be credited. They have acquired keen knowledge of the land and they have worked out an economy in using the land that can now be useful to the nation. Under the most trying conditions they have persevered. They have endured adverse weather. They have worked land that is not productive at all without artificial means. That work entailed manual labour on the part of the man and his family. They reared large families. They always observed what was natural and right and, guided and supported by Providence, survived. These are the people to whom the Land Commission and the State should turn their attention.
I have listened to appeals that land should be found for landless men. By all means, if land is available. But, the first consideration is to provide land for those whose holdings are uneconomic. If it is intended under this Bill to purchase land at the expense of the State and to pay a fair price for it, I would strongly urge on the present Minister to use the nation's wealth to undo the slums which exist, which were the creation of Cromwell in the past and which are a national disgrace. I would ask him to undo the neglect of his predecessors and give these people a fair share of the soil which is theirs and which they are capable of working to the best advantage. It is an economic thing. It is a national thing. It is a just thing. I recommend it to the Minister as a first claim in this proposal to acquire land. I recommend that he should give the land to those who are first entitled to it, who owned it in the centuries gone by but who were banished from their land by force. They have succeeded in surviving and in rearing large families under conditions in which only supermen could have succeeded.
In that connection the Minister should have a survey made of the congested areas. There is some useful land there but there are also so-called farms in these areas that could not be regarded as agricultural farms. There are vast areas which would be useful for afforestation. Let a survey be made of these areas with a view to discovering what land is useful for agricultural purposes and development. Let these areas be used for whatever number of families they can maintain and let the rest of the land be used for forestry.
Such a survey should be made quickly and before we proceed in a big way to operate this Bill. It is probably the last opportunity any Minister will have of dealing finally with the awful problem of the slums in congested areas. If this opportunity is used merely for the purpose of gaining political advantage, of providing a farm allegedly for some landless men, then you will have used up all the available land and will still have left behind the dreadful blot of these slums around our coast. We are asked from time to time to vote money for the clearance of slums and the provision of houses. We strike our breasts and feel that we are noble creatures because we engage in that work of providing clean houses, but we have yet to have a Minister who will tackle this problem. This Minister is probably the last Minister in whose hands a solution of the problem will rest. He is dividing practically the remnant of the land of the country. Are we to leave behind for all time this black mark on our national standard?
Let me suggest again to the Minister that a survey be made of the congested areas around our coast and find out what area of suitable agricultural land is available. Let us work out how many families that land will maintain in decent comfort and let the balance of the land be used for forestry, and let us then migrate, in so far as land is acquired elsewhere, the remnant of that struggling population who have survived in spite of every hardship and inconvenience. These are the people who will revivify agriculture, if you give them suitable farms. You will never have to be ashamed of what you have done and they will repay you and the nation whatever money is spent on such development. I appeal to the Minister with his knowledge of conditions in the west to do what is fair in this matter, in the light of his knowledge, a knowledge which is superior to that possessed by any of his predecessors.
The size of farms is a debatable question and I do not know that it is possible to define an economic holding. It varies in different districts and according to the quality and ability of the person working it. I hope the Minister will give full consideration to these points, because this is, as I say, the last opportunity we have to solve to any extent the problem of the uneconomic holder. I hope that he will utilise to the utmost all the land available in order to reach a final solution of the problem.
Comment on this
I am very glad to see such enthusiasm again for land division. During the war, it was quite natural that no land could be divided, and I am glad that the Minister has now introduced a measure which will give a great number of people throughout the country hopes of getting a home on the land. We heard here on many occasions that the misfortune in this country was that the people were inclined to leave the land. I do not think that any Deputy has had that experience. The people were quite anxious to remain on the land, if they got the opportunity, and anybody who reads the history of the land movement will come to the conclusion that, so far as the various Governments in power were concerned, they passed sufficient Land Acts. I remember going to the trouble of reading over all these Land Acts and reading about the introduction of the earlier Acts in the British House of Commons. On every occasion, the Minister introducing the measure said that it was the ultimate and final Act, that it was going to solve everything. The Minister has admitted already that this Bill is not going to solve all our troubles and difficulties.
We here have had a very peculiar problem to solve. On the Continent, the people took the land by illegal means from the feudal landlords, but we are not in exactly that position. Our land was entirely conquered and and the conquerers exploited it to the full, which in itself has tended to make the Land Acts fairly involved. In that connection, I agree with many of the speakers that one of the things that would be very advantageous and that would give rise to more appreciation of the Minister's work is an effort on his part to consolidate the Land Acts. Any of us who made a serious endeavour to interpret this measure will know the difficulties and labour attaching to it. We have even heard some of the lawyers here expressing doubt as to the meaning of several phrases, so that it is no wonder that the ordinary people and Deputies will find it very difficult to understand even this measure.
Notwithstanding that, great interest is taken in the country in land division, and, so far as the statement made here about a flight from the land is concerned, I say that there is no flight from the land. Conditions on the land, however—let us realise it—day by day are becoming more uneconomic. That position has existed here possibly from the time of the first world war when certain financial conditions brought about a collapse and complete chaos. I do not think this country ever properly recovered from it. However, the Minister is determined to make a new effort. That effort has been made in many countries and in this instance it represents an attempt on the part of the Government to buy land. The proposal may be surrounded by more choice words than I can use but the real truth is that the Minister, representing the Government, is going to buy land.
Quite recently I heard some discussions in regard to Government purchases and I think it was admitted that, in almost every single case in which Governments engaged in the purchase of houses, produce, or commodities of any description, their efforts met with complete failure. I hope that the Minister will not meet with similar misfortune in this instance. At the same time the purchase of land is a matter that is very involved. I do not believe for one moment that the Minister would ever allow himself to be led into any wrong actions but we do know that there are people in this country who gamble in land, who are adepts in selling land, and that they will not be one bit shy or afraid to lead the Minister into difficulties. I take it the Minister proposes to buy land at public auctions, and public auctions are occasions on which the art of "puffing" has reached a very high degree of efficiency. If a man gets to know that the Minister is interested in the purchase of certain land, I think there is hardly a Deputy in this Dáil who cannot visualise what is going to occur. The Minister is going to be an extra buyer, with a good deal of money behind him—in fact, with the State behind him. To my mind, that will be a very dangerous position. Things, of course, may work out all right but it is not my experience, and I think it is not the experience of other Deputies, that when a Government embarks on the purchase of land or of any commodity, its efforts are ever attended by success. It is admitted, I think, that the Minister is going to pay more for land; if not, there is no virtue in this proposal. I think he mentioned the fact that he was going to be merciful to owners of land, that he is going to give them every chance, insinuating that we gave them no chance, that we bought land at the lowest possible price.
Comment on this
What is going to happen to the tenants? We know who regulates the price of land at the present time and I think that in future the same people are going to regulate the price. The price of land is regulated here by the British Government at the moment. Later on, if control is removed from the price of cattle, the price of land here will be regulated by what the public in Great Britain will pay for our cattle. The value of land will fluctuate according to that. When land was producing food here during the war, and in fact before it, I think the Minister will admit that, down in Mayo, land for conacre was fetching from £8 to £10 an acre whereas the best land around Tara was not making more than £5 an acre at the same time. The Minister will not deny that nor will he deny that that may be the case again. At the moment there is something of a boom in the cattle trade. I think that the Minister for Agriculture definitely intends to develop that trade and has taken elaborate steps towards that end. I imagine that some difficulty will arise between himself and the Minister for Lands because if a high price prevails for cattle—and it is not so much a question of high prices as the profit that can be made out of the trade—land for grazing and fattening cattle will go up in value. The value of land is determined by what it can be let or set at. There will be many fluctuations in that respect. How is the Minister going to manage his tenants if the tenants on any one estate have to purchase at a very high price, because it is the tenant who is going to purchase? The Minister does all the writing, but it is the tenant who is going to pay.
Comment on this
Would the Minister let the Deputy make his own speech and and stop his cross-examination?
Comment on this
The Minister should not accuse the Deputy of telling deliberate falsehoods because he does not agree with this statement.
Comment on this
Should not the statement that Deputy O'Reilly was telling deliberate falsehoods be withdrawn?
Comment on this
The Minister should not try to be Ceann Comhairle as well as Minister.
Comment on this
Not a bit. We are not displeased at all.
Comment on this
The Minister states there is no relation at all between the price paid for land by the Land Commission and the annuity the tenant will have to pay. I cannot follow that. If that is the case it makes matters much worse, because every man who has land for sale will say: "It is not going to hurt my neighbours in any way because they are not going to pay in proportion to the price I will get. We will make the Minister pay all he can." That is going to inflate the price. That is one of the dangers attached to the action of the Government in entering into a business of this kind. All I can do is to wish the Minister the best of luck. The principal object of the Land Commission always was to relieve congestion. I hope that when the Minister does start to operate all these Land Acts, he will adhere to that principle and relieve all uneconomic holders. It is very objectionable to a Deputy from Meath, when there are uneconomic holders in Meath, to see migrants coming in there. I am sure that the Minister when he starts to divide the land will adhere to the principle of satisfying all the local uneconomic applicants before he starts to bring in any migrants.
Comment on this
I only want to have that confirmed. It is not that the people in Meath have any objection to migrants. The only objection they have is when they are left without land and migrants are brought in. As I said, the success of land division depends entirely on the Minister for Agriculture. If the Minister for Agriculture decides, as he may do, to purchase abroad all the feeding-stuffs needed here—and that happened before—it is quite obvious that the value of land is going to drop. I hope that the Minister for Lands will keep in close touch with the Minister for Agriculture and try to relate the price that he pays for land to the policy which is going to be pursued by the Minister for Agriculture.
Before 1850 we supported a big population on the land. The population rapidly decreased, and it decreased for no other reason than that the land was limited to the production of cattle. There was no employment for the people. If he cannot grow his own foodstuffs, if it is not economic for him to do so, there will be no occupation for the small farmer. Our principal aim should be, if we settle the people on the land, to have economic conditions such as will allow them to get a reasonable living on the small farms. That, of course, is going to be a big problem in the near future. At the moment, as a result of the war, Great Britain is unable to purchase abroad. Owing to monetary regulations, we are not able to purchase quite an amount of foreign foodstuffs. That does act as some protection for the small farmer and other farmers. But, to my mind, the day that we cease to produce food here for the people the value of land will fall. I hope that in the near future the Minister for Agriculture will be compelled to see that that valuable food is grown here. If it is, the value of land will be kept up. If it is not, the value of land and the value of stock will fall. The production of food for the people takes up a certain amount of land which tends to make land scarcer and more valuable.
I hope that the Minister will have good luck in this effort. As I said, it is the first time in any Land Act that the Government has had the courage to take power to buy land and I hope that nothing will happen to upset that. I hope that the land that the Minister will be able to give the tenants will not be too dear, that the price will not be so high that they will be inclined to leave it on his hands.
Comment on this
I welcome this Bill. I suppose it is not the last Bill we shall have so far as land division is concerned. If this House is noted for anything, it is for the number of Acts it passes, each one of which is supposed to be final. I do not know, however, that there is any such thing as perfection in this world. However, the Minister has faced up to his responsibility. I am satisfied that he is the right man in the right place, because he has a gigantic task in front of him. I am glad that under this Bill there is going to be justice for the land owner whose land will be taken and justice for incoming tenants. What more do we want under any Act than justice? I am satisfied that under this Bill many landholders who were in fear and trembling that their land would be acquired will have their fears allayed, and that quite a number of fairly large farmers who are not financially strong will offer part of their holdings to the Land Commission for which they can get a fair market value and thus be able to restock the rest of their holdings. That, in itself, will be an immense improvement so far as my county is concerned.
In my county and in the Midlands generally there is a fear of invasion from the West which up to the present had been on a fairly big scale. Knowing that the Minister comes from a congested area, I say God help us in the Midlands if he gets his way. The purchase of land at the market value is a good thing, but I would ask the Minister to be cautious about it. I would not like him to go wholesale into the purchase of land at market value. I believe he has power to purchase large holdings openly and above board, to tell the people that the land is needed, pay them the market value and take over the holdings. There will, however, be such things as a backhand pull, puffers, etc. However, I know the Minister is a man who will be able to handle the situation properly.
When big holdings are on the market I ask him to step in in time and acquire them and not allow them to go, as they have in the last four or five years, into the hands of foreigners. Large holdings of 600, 700 and 800 acres have gone into the hands of foreigners who, I admit, have spent a large amount of money and give a fair amount of employment. At the same time, that is not quite sound economically. Middle class peasants are the people whom we want on the land here, because they will give a fair amount of employment and do a fair amount of tillage. The whole idea of the large landholders who come into this country is to turn the farms into grass or establish stud farms. That has gone too far. We should have a full investigation into what these people who have come in here in the last few years are doing with the land. Some of these men purchase 1,500 acres of land and say they are running a stud farm or going in for blood-stock and that the land should not be acquired. I do not say that men who have lived in County Meath all their lives should be touched, but these big landholders who come in here get away scot-free. I ask the Land Commission to have a full inquiry with regard to these people who came into the country during a number of years past and see if they have acquired too much property in this State. As I said, they give plenty of employment, but nationally it is unsound and will react against this country.
I am glad that under this Bill there will be a remodelling of the Land Commission which is long overdue, because it is a cumbersome body. For over 25 years we have been dividing land and turning it into economic holdings. Unfortunately, we are only half through the work yet. I am satisfied that there was something wrong at the top in connection with the Land Commission. We got our freedom through revolution and that revolution should be carried through in many directions. We should have a more revolutionary approach to the question of land acquisition and division. I believe there was far too much of a conservative outlook at the top in the division of land in the past. I hope that we are getting away from that. In connection with land division, we want a new national approach, and men of national vigour to take over the work and bring it to a speedy conclusion. During the last 25 or 30 years land division, which has not yet been completed, has caused a good deal of wrangling, anger, cattle driving and misery. All that was because the Land Commission did not take effective steps to complete the job in five or six years. I know it is a huge job, but it is one that should be approached in a big way. We were told two, three, or four years ago that vesting would be almost completed within three or four years. These years have now passed, and yet the work is not done. I am afraid three or four more years will have passed before many of the new tenants who have had holdings for the past 25 years will have their land vested in them. There are many in my county who have been in the occupation of land for 20 and 25 years, and it is still not vested. That is a shame and a disgrace. It is unfair to those people that they should be left in that position. They have no title to their land to enable them to go into a bank as independent men and raise some money to stock the land. Most of them require capital to stock their land and so make it of some use to them. As long, however, as their land is not vested by the Land Commission they cannot raise the capital they require for the successful working of their holdings. Many of those tenants are in dire need for want of capital. They cannot set their land on the 11 months' system because they are not allowed to do so. If the land was vested in them, these men would prove to be good tenants. The result of all this is that we have a list of evictions ready in my county. Many of them are justified but many of them are unjustified. I say that it is disgraceful to see people being evicted.
Comment on this
If they get title by having the land vested in them they will be able to get the capital to work it. I am not blaming the Minister. I believe that he has the right outlook, but the fact is that many men in the midlands and in County Meath got land —I do not care how they acquired it— but they had not a "bob" in their pockets. The Land Commission, with their eyes open, gave them these holdings. Is it fair now that those people should be evicted after being in possession for ten or 15 years? The Land Commission was responsible for most of those wasters who got land. They slipped it across the Land Commission, and the latter knew well what they were doing. There were three or four people on home relief who got land. They said they would not be able to work it, but the Land Commission said to them to take it, that they would be able to get on all right. Some of these men are now being evicted. The Land Commission almost stuck it down their necks. I think that these evictions should be cut out.
The division of land should be considered more from the national point of view. What we want in this country is a middle-class peasantry. The position in my county is that when a war is over every man who can possibly do so gets out of tillage and puts his land back into grass. Who can blame him when grass pays him better? If you had a good middle-class peasantry, people with holdings of from 30 to 50 acres of land, they would have to till a fair proportion of it whether they liked it or not. It is that type of farming that would give the country a properly balanced national economy. It is bad from the economic point of view, to see vast tracts of land going back into grass. The small man must feel dissatisfied when he sees the big fellow, with all his land in grass, getting the big cheques for the cattle that go off that land to the market.
The Minister will need to handle the position carefully. If our national economy is properly handled it can do an immense amount of good, but if not it can do an immense amount of harm. There are parts of Dublin, Meath and Westmeath which are naturally suited for the development of the live-stock industry. Is it not a pity to see that land hacked up to relieve congestion? In my county there is a fair amount of land that could be acquired for the relief of uneconomic holders and suitable landless men. I do not want, however, to see that land torn up into small patches. If that is done it will react not only on County Meath but on the West of Ireland, where the Minister comes from and where the people of Meath go to make their purchases of young stock. If that land is broken up, how are you going to carry on your national economy and what about your fairs and markets?
The Minister should go down into Kildare and Meath and view the position for himself. He should visit the colonies that have been created there. Some of them are doing fairly well. Many of these people can well say that if they have been brought out of congested areas that they are now very much in the position of congests. They can say that they are not able to make a living out of the 22 acres of land they have. They had large families when they came to the Midlands. Now some of their children are married and are living in the house with them. In the houses on some of these holdings you have three and four families living, with up to 14 people in some of them. That kind of intensified migration is not a good thing. It would be far better if men were given a holding of 35 or 40 acres on which they could make a living for themselves and their families. Many of those people got virgin grass land, but at the moment a lot of it is only third and fourth rate land. That is not due to any fault on the part of the migrants. Their holdings are so small that they have to graze them day in and day out. I ask the Minister to consider that position because it is a very grave one. I know that he is very anxious to solve this problem, but I think we can never solve congestion because we have not enough land to do so. We can give a fair amount of relief.
On the borders of Cavan, in North Meath, we have a vast amount of congestion. You have men living there on five and ten acres of poor land. Surely they are entitled to some consideration as well as the migrants. I have no objection to the bringing up of those smaller tenants to County Meath, but I think it would be a much sounder national economy to buy out some of the large landholders in the West, give them a fair portion of land elsewhere and divide their holdings amongst the local people.
Comment on this
I do not believe that this is going to be the last Land Bill. I think this Bill is 25 years too late. I believe that there are many people with a fair amount of land in my county who would be prepared to hand over a portion of it. You have people there with 400 acres of land. If 200 acres of such holdings were acquired at a fair market price and a man was left with 200 acres, he would be able to work it better than the 400 acres. I believe that a good deal of the compulsion there should be cut out.
There was too much compulsion in the past. In Meath there was great fear and trembling on the part of the people. Every landowner for the last 20 years never felt secure. There was agitation at his hall-door and at his back-door and he heard the cry: "We want your land; we must take your land." The Minister has done a bold thing. He has offered fair market value for land, and he could not do more to allay the fears of any of these people. I hope this measure will speedily be put into operation. So far as my county is concerned, he has a vast amount of acreage under his control. I ask him to give fair and simple justice to the local people first and then, if there is land available, to migrants of the type who are most suitable from the point of view of national economy. I wish the Minister every success with this new Bill and I hope it will be many years before he will have to bring in another one. All the same, I am afraid this is not the final measure. I think he will have to remodel the Land Commission.
Comment on this
The main features of the Bill have been well and truly discussed and I do not propose to say anything on that aspect. I rise to mention one point which I think the Minister knows something about. That is, the necessity for a short clause—I am disappointed that it is not already in the Bill—amending the pension provisions of previous Bills so as to provide that an officer of the Land Commission who has retired shall have whatever service he may have given to the Congested Districts Board and the Land Settlement Commission prior to 1923 recognised for the purpose of a pension. I would like the Minister seriously to consider that matter before the Committee Stage.
Comment on this
I think the Minister is to be congratulated on the introduction of a measure that will give such relief when it is put into operation. It will, for one thing, remove a very serious feature which was a legacy of the foreigner here. I believe it is principally in my county that it exists. I refer to dual ownership. I am very glad the Minister has included a rectification of that injustice which, as I have said, was a legacy of an ancient despotism that existed here for 750 years.
I was rather amazed at Deputy O'Reilly when he said there is no flight from the land. I do not know from what source he got his statistics, but there is definite and conclusive evidence every day in the week of such a flight. I am sure every Deputy here has had evidence every day over a number of years of the flight of the rural community. Why is that so? Whatever the cause, there has been a feeling of instability, of insecurity among the farming community. The old Irish Parliamentary Party, in a long and enduring struggle, won for the farmers the three Fs. —fixity of tenure, free sale and fair rent. How about fixity of tenure? Is there in the minds of farmers to-day the conviction that they have fixity of tenure? I say "No." I do not want to suggest that the last Government was responsible. It may be that the Land Commission, with the powers vested in them, overrode the authority of the Minister. There has been for a number of years an atmosphere of insecurity, instability and, I would say, unhappiness. Who is responsible, I do not know. I will not fix the responsibility on any Government or Minister.
Quite recently in my constituency farmers have been visited by Land Commission inspectors who required them to show reasons why some or all of the land in their occupation should not be acquired for sub-division. I have drawn the attention of the Department quite recently to the prevailing conditions. It may be necessary to ascertain why some farmers are not properly utilising their land. No doubt there are lethargic, lazy, indolent persons not utilising their land for the benefit of their families, for the food production of the nation or for the benefit of the general community. I do not suggest that such people should continue in that indifferent, lackadaisical way, acting as a dead weight on the nation, but I would like the Land Commission or the Minister to tell me how anyone can justify visits to progressive, hard-working farmers, industrious men working their land to a high standard of husbandry, meeting their commitments, not to the minimum degree under the Tillage Orders, but exceeding the minimum requirements, men rearing fine families.
Numbers of such farmers have recently been visited by Land Commission inspectors who informed them that on a certain day they proposed to make an examination of the conditions under which they worked their land. Now there must be a definite segregation between (a) the lazy, indolent fellow and (b) the industrious, progressive, hard-working farmer. Where is the fixity of tenure there? That is the atmosphere that has been created in my constituency.
I have submitted the facts to the Minister and to the Land Commission officials. I pointed out to them that in farms adjacent to these there were farmers setting hundreds of acres of grass —even grass for horses—and that to my own knowledge for the last quarter of a century. These people are not working the land for the benefit of the State, the good of community, or the advancement of the nation. It is inexplicable to me how an inspector from the Land Commission can pass by such farms as these and half a mile further on go in to inspect a holding held by a farmer, whose ancestors were in occupation of the land in some cases for as long as 215 years. Does not that attitude seem almost indefensible on the part of the Land Commission? It is to me the antithesis of all that our people fought for in order to get fixity of tenure in its real and true sense.
I am glad that the Minister at last realises the iniquities done by the Land Commission in the past. At least they have been examining their conscience. They are going to make good the harm and the injustices done by them in the past. When I was in the other House I drew a particular case to the attention of the Minister. A farmer in my constituency offered the Land Commission 153 acres of land. The land was inspected by the Land Commission and they decided, after a careful examination I suppose, that the land was not suitable for sub-division but that it would be excellent land for afforestation purposes. The owner was prepared to sell. There was no house on the land and he found it inconvenient to work it. I am speaking now subject to correction since I have not got all the data in front of me. The Land Commission offered him £380 for his 153 acres. The seller would be required to pay the cost of redemption and other legal expenses. Out of the £380 offered he would eventually find himself with £134 net. I pointed out how unjust the offer was to the Land Commission and the hardship it would impose upon this small farmer with a family of seven or eight young children. The Land Commission move very slowly. After another 12 months had elapsed they decided to give him £680, from which had to be deducted £160. That brought the figure down to £520. From that had to be deducted another £40 for legal expenses. In the end there was about £250 left for this 153 acres of reasonably good land, and the owner had no option but to cross the Irish Sea to find work in a more congenial atmosphere to support himself and his children.
The Land Commission has a duty to treat the community fairly. The Minister says—all credit to him—that he will in future pay the market value of land. I agree with Deputy O'Reilly that it will not be an easy matter to determine what the market value is, since supply and demand and other factors enter into it. Any auctioneer can readily point out the difficulties in determining the market value of land. I have sold a number of farms in the past. Farms sold by private treaty never realise the same price as they would if they were sold in the open market. One may ask why farms are sold by private treaty when they could be sold to better advantage in the open market. The reason is that, if the Land Commission knew that the farms were on the market, they would immediately step in and take them. They would pay not the market value price, but what they considered to be a fair price. This is a Government Department which, if one approaches it to have something done, sends out two or three letters stuck together. When one opens the envelope one discovers that half of them are torn. They begin with "A Chara", nine or ten lines in Irish, and they end with "Mise, le meas". You get no more than that and you throw them away.
The price that may be determined for these lands is about £3 6s. 8d. an acre. Is it any wonder that this big and benevolent Minister who has come from the land and who is working on behalf of those on the land realises the injustices of the Irish Land Commission and has introduced a Bill in this House to try to remedy the matter? Instead of offering him silly, cynical criticism, as some of those on the opposite benches have done — not all, I will admit — Deputies ought to co-operate with the Minister. They should laud him for introducing a section to remedy dual ownership, which is a legacy of past tyranny and injustice by the British, and, secondly, to give to the farmer the market value of his land and withdraw the locusts of inspectors who are creating to-day a feeling of insecurity and instability, as I have already said. They go around visiting men who are a credit to the country— farmers who work their land with industry and in a progressive manner and who conform to all the statutes in regard to extra tillage. They visit these men who work so industriously and who rear good, decent families. How can these farmers have any feeling of peace or security? By whom is this authority given? Is it the order of the Government? Has the Minister given that order? If not since their advent to power, were these orders issued by the previous Government and, if so, why? I should like to know why certain men, one after another, were selected—men against whom no charge of inefficiency or negligence could be made. These are just a few points that strike me.
I went to the Minister before, and he cannot say that I have, as it were, come here behind his back. I went to the Land Commission and pointed out these happenings. I hope the Minister will remedy them and that the Bill, when it becomes law, will vest in him and in his successors in office power to keep under control the mercenary methods adopted by some officials in his Department.
Comment on this
I have listened very attentively to the speeches of the different Deputies. Some Deputies seem to be very keen on land division. It is a very drastic act to go in on a farmer's land, to take it from him and to divide it out. A farmer has, say, 300 acres of land. He is raising food on that land and he is giving employment. That type of man is an asset to the State. If you take 100 acres of his land from him and give 20 or 30 acres to his workman what will the position then be? The workman will require money to buy stock and machinery for the farm. I believe that we have too many small farms in this country—too many farms of 10, 20 or 30 acres. Usually the farmers on such farms just barely exist. The Minister should be very careful before he starts land division. I know farmers who have, say, 50 acres of land. These men run their farms efficiently and they give employment. If the Minister for Lands is entitled to take this action I think some other Minister is equally entitled, say, to go down O'Connell Street and take over half the business of a big store or to take over part of some industry. Very careful consideration should be given to that matter. Probably other Deputies who have spoken to-night are aware of that.
If the Minister is contemplating dividing the land I think he should not give men ten acres or 20 acres. He should give them 60 acres or 70 acres. Further, along with giving them the land, it would be necessary to give them some money to run the farm. There is no use in giving a man land unless he has the money to stock it and to work it. Therefore, I say that there are lots of problems in regard to the question of land division and careful consideration should be given to the matter by the Minister before he takes action.
Comment on this
I have listened to this debate to-night and to similar debates in years gone by, but I must say that I never thought land was as cheap as a Deputy said it was to-night. I heard Deputy Madden from Limerick say that it could be had for £3 6s. 8d. an acre. If you look for a bit of ground for the purpose of building a house on it you will pay £1 a foot for it. If you build a house in the country for the agricultural worker you must pay at least £25 an acre.
Comment on this
We get it for £25 in Wexford. We are building houses for the working classes at the moment and we had to pay £135 an acre. Who wants the land in the country? Passing through my constituency and through County Wicklow every week, I notice that the unfortunate agricultural labourer has a half acre in some places and one acre under the new scheme. If he is lucky enough to have a cow he will have to find grazing for it on the banks by the roadside or he may have a goat grazing on the side of a ditch. We hear them talking about taking the land for the farmers. In my constituency there are plenty of good, genuine agricultural labourers and small farmers who are trying to exist. Some of the best farmers in Ireland are to be found in County Wexford, where we till more than in any other county. Some people there are trying to rear families on 10 or even on eight acres. If they go next door, so to speak, their neighbour has a big ranch. They have to pay a high price for conacre, while the owner of that land goes around the country, does not bother about tillage, does not stay on the land at all but draws his conacre money from the small farmer, and so forth. The Minister would do right to divide up the land. The reason some of the small farmers' sons have to fly from the land is because they have not enough to rear families and keep them there. That is why they have to go away. They are not able to get a living. At the same time you have big estates all over the country lying there and set only for grazing purposes.
It is only right that the Minister should come along now and take courage. Many Bills have been brought in and we thought that the land divided for 16 years under the last Government would have almost satisfied the people who want land, but we find no, there are still thousands of people who have not half an acre. Something should be done to give land to the people of rural Ireland and give them a chance of living. That is why there is a flight from the land, and many small farmers and labourers, too, would be glad to get a few acres, till them, and make use of them to produce food. You see in the papers that people in the city have to pay 1/1 for a head of cabbage. They have not a back yard, not to mind a garden, while there are thousands of acres of land around County Dublin, as in other counties, where these people could get some to satisfy them.
There has been great talk about market value, but no farmer to-day sells his land cheaply. Go to an auction where you will see farmers bidding for land and you will see what land will go to. They will not throw it away. We want the Land Commission to give them a fair price and not do as the last people did, take the people's cattle and send around John Browne to give them whatever price he likes. We do not want the Minister to take land without giving a fair price. Give the people who have land to sell a fair price and you will get the land. Divide that land among the working classes and the poor farmers and you need never be afraid that you will leave this side of the House.
Comment on this
I have been in this House for 22 years and during that time I have seen and welcomed many efforts to solve this problem of congestion. I am willing and anxious to help the Minister in any way I possibly can to try to solve this problem, but I would like him to put his cards on the table and give us a much broader outline of what his proposals are. I would like to ask him why, if he is serious in this matter, he did not give us more particulars of his policy. I think we should hear, for instance, the area of land he proposes to acquire or resume under this particular Bill. He should also tell us where this land is situated and where exactly he intends to acquire enough land to form a pool that will help to solve the congestion problem in the West of Ireland. I think that the Minister to-night realises more than ever the problems that confronted the Fianna Fáil Government in their effort to solve this problem. Most of the Deputies I have heard speaking from across the House do not seem to have any knowledge or idea of the problem which confronts the Minister. They seemingly do not understand what exactly congestion means. When I hear a man advocating that the smallest holding given to any particular individual should be at least 60 or 80 acres, I say that it is a pity that that Deputy would not take a tour through the West of Ireland and try to picture for himself how it is that people living on ten or 12 acres of land all their lives have accomplished the feat of eking out an existence and rearing a family.
We all admire the work done and the effort made by the late Mr. Hogan. When he introduced the Land Bill of 1923 the position regarding the amount of land available for acquisition was entirely different from what it was when the Land Bill of 1933 was introduced. At that time there were ranches all over the country in the hands of landlords, and the problem facing that Minister was fairly easy. He could walk in and acquire a farm of 1,000 acres and still leave 5,000 acres to one individual. The only flaw we found in that Bill was that areas up to 5,000, 6,000 or 7,000 acres were vested in those landlords, and we had to face the problem of getting after them again, and the Land Act of 1933, introduced by Fianna Fáil, had that aim before it. I can assure the Minister that he will not meet the same type of criticism from this side of the House on this Bill as Fianna Fáil had to contend with when that one was introduced and passed through this House. He is not going to be told that this Bill means the confiscation of private property, as we were told by the people who now occupy the Government Benches. He is going to receive from us every co-operation and assistance to make this Bill workable and to put him in the position, if possible, of solving this problem as soon as possible. It is because of the knowledge we have of the things that happened in those days and because the Minister has had experience of the working of the different Land Acts from the 1923 Act to the present day, that we believe that he should now be in a position to put his finger on the problem and say: "Here is my plan to solve the problem of land division." I am in entire agreement with the purchase of certain types of holdings by the Minister or the Irish Land Commission and I sincerely hope that by this Bill the Minister will solve the problem.
We have experience of people with a number of holdings, one or two of them non-residential, 20 or 30 miles from the parent holding on which the individual resides. As soon as there is any local push to have those lands acquired, that man puts a holding up for auction. The Land Commission says that it does not matter whether it is (a) or (b) holding they purchase. They say: "We will let the man sell his holding and purchase from the new owner at a later stage." But as soon as that land is sold, a high market value is put on it straightaway and the Land Commission find that they cannot look at it. I believe that the Land Commission had the power to take over any land they were anxious to take over for the relief of congestion in any area if they only took the necessary steps to go ahead and do it. In so far as fixing of price was concerned, I have yet to see the first case in the Land Commission courts where an appeal was brought against price and that the appellant did not get an increased price. I think it has always been given in the courts. I think an increased reasonable price was given always.
Comment on this
But the increased price was thrashed out between people who could do justice between one man and another. I do not think the lay commmissioners or the judicial courts are out to rob any individual.
Comment on this
They were not. They could pay £7 or £10 or £30 an acre. If they were tied by the Act, surely the price they offered would be the same price all the time and one could never get an increase on appeal. The Minister knows they were not tied. The Minister cannot quote from any section of any Act to show where the Land Commission were tied down to £10, £20 or £40 an acre. No matter what he tries to do in this section, he cannot tie himself down to fixing a price, nor can he tell this House that he will pay £40 or £60 an acre. Coming from a congested district, and from that portion of the country, he knows that, in any two townlands, where the land is equal and the valuation is not one shilling greater in one district than in the other, a 50-acre holding in one place may go £500 or more than in another, although there is no difference in the size of the holding or in the valuation.
When he is talking about fixing a market price, I do not know where he is going to get that price, or how he is going to fix it. He cannot put it down in black and white in a Bill, any more than Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Cumann na nGaedheal could not put it in their Land Acts. I must say I would like to see power in the hands of the Land Commission, but I am not prepared to give too many powers to any particular Minister. I have good reasons for that.
When we came into office, I had the unhappy experience of seeing the Land Commission work under an Act whereby the Minister had certain powers. He had the power to give a holding of land, as he actually did, to any particular individual he liked. That individual would not necessarily be a man hostile to the Minister or his policy. Unfortunately, to-day we are going to have a Minister putting himself in the very same position. If we give those powers to this particular Minister confronting us and in charge of this particular Department, I have no doubt in my mind that the people who are politically opposed to him will not be the people coming out best in his division of land. For that reason, I am not prepared to give it to him or to give it to a Minister from these benches, either.
Comment on this
I certainly was. I should be much more wise now, when I see what is happening everywhere with the Government in power at the moment, in so far as their powers go to giving anything to anybody supporting them. Because of the things to which I have referred, and because of the danger of any particular Minister getting too many powers and doing too many things from his particular eye, I do not like to give to any Minister very drastic powers in this direction.
I believe that the Minister should produce a policy, should draft his Bill according to that policy and compel the Land Commission then to carry it out. I do not think there would be much need to change any commissioner who is working in the Land Commission, unless you pension them off altogether and clear the whole lot out and put in some more revolutionary crowd-but that would not fit in with the terms of this Bill. If the Minister put his policy into this Bill, he could take power to compel the Land Commission to carry that out. He should keep out of the division of land, the acquisition and resumption of holdings, and so on.
There are three dangerous sections in the Bill—Sections 5, 10 and 23— sections that I would like changed, and which I hope I will see changed by the Minister, for his own benefit as well as for the benefit of all the Deputies in the House who will be voting for anything he puts into a piece of paper, as well as for the benefit of the people of the country in general whom it is intended to benefit by this legislation. We would like to know from the Minister how he intends to fix market value.
Comment on this
For the information of the Deputy, I say that Fianna Fáil never fixed it but left it to the Land Commission.
Comment on this
I challenge the Minister now, and the Deputy who passed the remark, to name one individual, in all the working of the Land Commission, where the Minister took sides.
Comment on this
I am not referring to the Deputy at all. I am speaking on behalf of congests and not of ranchers.
Comment on this
I want to challenge the Minister to give us a case now, where Fianna Fáil or any Fianna Fáil Minister gave a holding of land to landless men. The business was left to the Land Commission to decide and they were responsible for putting the man into the holding. If he had not sufficient cash, I do not hold that the Land Commission should finance a person who has not sufficient cash.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy say, so, what was the need for the 1946 act? If none of these things occurred, why did you bring in that Act?
Comment on this
The Minister is a bit quick, but he is not smart. I said I challenged the Minister to give us the name of a Fianna Fáil Minister who gave a holding of land. I said the Land Commission dealt with it and they alone determined who would get the holding. Does the Minister say that is wrong?
Comment on this
We determined definitely, and the present Minister will have to determine the same thing.
Comment on this
The Minister will have to determine it and determine how he is going to compensate the individuals who earn their livelihood on it. The Minister is faced with the very same problem. We made provision for compensating the herds and other people who earned their livelihood on the land. We made provision for compensating Old I.R.A. men who had given service to the country. Does the Minister say that we should not have made provision for these people? Experience has shown that there are other ways and means that can be adopted to provide for those people. We simply made provision for them in the best way we thought fit and left it to the Land Commission to work out the problem and to do the best they could. We did not dictate to the Land Commission that Tom, Dick or Harry should be given a holding. That is the implication the Minister is putting on the whole thing. That is where he is entirely wrong. The sooner he educates some of the Deputies from his own constituency who have been throwing sneers and jeers about landless men across the House the better for themselves and the more helpful for the Minister,
There are two pages of this Bill in Section 10 setting out the powers we are giving to the Minister. As I have said, I am not one of those who are prepared to give any power to any Minister to do any particular thing.
Comment on this
I am prepared to give him power to put his policy into effect and to leave it to the Land Commission then to carry out that policy and to the Minister to force the Land Commission to do it. It is unwise, it is very foolish, for the Minister himself to do it. I wonder what the reaction will be in Mayo if he ever attempts some of the things envisaged here. Two heads are wiser than one. The commissioners are intelligent people who know exactly what they are doing when they are exercising the powers that the Minister is now taking from them. They have had long experience and, if the Minister tells them exactly what he wants done, in as strong language as he likes, and that he wants a particular job done within a certain length of time, he will get results. Experience has been gained from the various Acts that were passed. We brought in the 1933 Act. We found at a later stage that it was not entirely satisfactory. When that Act was introduced it was met with unscrupulous opposition. The Opposition did not want us to take over one acre or to divide one acre and definitely and deliberately set out to ensure, if they could, that we would not take over one acre just as they tried to prevent us doing many other things. It was in spite of them and it was by the loyalty of the Irish people to our policy and to ourselves and by our determination to do this job as speedily as possible that the issue was decided. The people who were talking about confiscation of private property had that driven home to them pretty forcibly, not by mere talk, but by a general election. It took a general election to drive that home and it was driven home. At the same time, that opposition hampered us from going as far as we might have gone with the land division. The Minister may rest assured that he will not meet that type of criticism or opposition from these benches.
As I have said, I am not prepared to give the Minister the power he seeks in Section 10.
Comment on this
Because, first, there is the danger that a particular man who has a holding that he wants to dispose of can easily make arrangements with the Minister to purchase it. He can easily get some agitation started by two or three people when the Minister comes along.
Comment on this
I think it is unfair that Deputy Killilea should be prevented from making his own speech.
Comment on this
I only want to get the right reference. That is all. I thought you had the Bill in front of you.
Comment on this
I suppose I may correct the mistake I made in saying Section 10 instead of Section 5. In Section 5 power is given to the Minister to fix price, and so on.
Comment on this
I wonder has the Deputy the same Bill as Deputy Sweetman has or is he dealing with the last Government's Bill?
Comment on this
The things that may be done under Section 5 are by the powers given to the Minister under Section 10. Is not that correct?
Comment on this
Will Deputies address the Chair? It would make for much better debate than answering each other across the House.
Comment on this
I am not prepared to give the Minister the powers that are being sought in this particular Bill for either acquisition or division, particularly as regards division. In regard to the question of price, if the question of price is to be left to the Minister and to any individual that he decides should fix the price on market value basis, it will lead to all sorts of corruption.
I think it was the Minister who made a suggestion about people being robbers. I do not think this country is completely free of people who would be prepared to go that far and who, if they got an opportunity of robbing the Land Commission, would say: "I am only getting some of my own back." I believe that this question of price is too big a problem to leave to any one individual and the commissioners who were dealing with it before are still quite capable of carrying out that duty.
Comment on this
Surely we are getting "shut" of the lay commissioners here, clearing them out altogether, and, that being so, how is the work to be done?
Comment on this
I regret that the Minister has not made a decent effort to solve the problem, and, further, has not made any real effort to give the House a clear idea of what his intentions are. I hope that in his reply he will give us much more information than he gave us in his opening remarks. Even the White Paper circulated with the Bill does not give a whole lot of information and it is not at all in keeping with the statement made by the Minister, but perhaps he will clarify the position when replying to the criticism put forward. I advise him to be careful in this matter of market value and to try to ensure that "puffing" will not be allowed to interfere. I do not think it at all fair that the Minister should come into open competition in the market with any individual who wants to purchase a holding and some other method must be devised for getting over this particular difficulty.
Comment on this
There are only two excuses that can be given for the speech we have just heard from Deputy Killilea. Either he was deliberately trying to distort what is in the Bill, or, by reason of his rather futile endeavours in another place, he did not read the Bill. I am being charitable and accepting the second as the reason for his failure to understand what he was discussing. The Deputy was at great pains to prove that the Bill gives to the Minister powers which it does not give at all. It is an old Fianna Fáil trick—to put up ninepins for the sake of knocking them down and take attention from the real issue; but the unfortunate thing, so far as the Deputy was concerned, is that he did not read the Bill sufficiently well to know enough about it to be able to draw the red herring across the trail.
This Bill—let us be quite clear about it—does not give the Minister any power to fix the price of land. The Bill in Section 5 changes the legal basis upon which the commissioners and the Judicial Commissioner must fix the price and it leaves to the Land Commission, and to the Land Commission alone, the power of determination of the price at which any man's holding will be acquired. I will say at least this for Deputy Killilea, that he was not the first speaker from the Fianna Fáil benches to make that case. He was not the first who tried to draw the House, and I have a slight suspicion— I am perhaps a little cynical—the country, astray on that issue.
The issue could not be more clear and the Bill could not be more clear. Under the Act of 1923, a different legal basis was established for the price at which resumed land would be paid for by the Land Commission relative to the price at which acquired land would be paid for. The price at which resumed land would be paid for —and it is, of course, land which has not been vested—was set out in the Act of 1923 and restated finally in the Act of 1939. The then Minister in charge of the Bill made it quite clear when discussing the 1939 measure in the Seanad when he said that all that was being done by that Bill in respect of the price of resumed land was restating the existing law. The law always has been so in respect of resumed land. I am sorry the Deputy is not prepared to learn and perhaps I was too charitable in thinking that it was merely that he did not understand the situation; he was perhaps deliberately misrepresenting it.
In the 1939 Act, the Fianna Fáil Minister in charge of the Bill made it quite clear that the insertion of the particular section dealing with the price of resumed land was only a restatement of the existing law and that the law then was that the Land Commission must, as it did, pay, in respect of any resumed land, the market value of the holding to the person from whom the land was resumed and, in addition, were bound to pay, in certain circumstances, compensation for disturbance. That has always been the case and any one who has any experience of the work of the Land Commission in regard to resumed holdings knows that it is and always has been the case, and that there has never been any difficulty about the Land Commission assessing the market value of these holdings.
That market value was paid in respect of holdings that were not vested and surely there should be a very much stronger case for the payment of the market value in respect of vested holdings—the payment of a higher price for vested holdings as compared with that paid for unvested holdings. In spite of the fact that on many occasions it was put up to Fianna Fáil that they should grant that measure of social justice, where it was necessary in the social interests of the community to acquire and distribute land, they always steadfastly refused to do so. This Dáil is not the first Dáil which has had to consider the question. It was put up on two occasions in my recollection in the Seanad when Fianna Fáil were in power, and on each occasion, although the issue was exactly the issue which is now in Section 5, they deliberately opposed it because they were afraid to face the issue.
I am glad to have this opportunity of congratulating the Minister on having faced the issue, and having faced it courageously, and on having determined that there should be at least a measure of justice, because it is only justice, for these people from whom land is to be acquired in the interests of the community as a whole and these people who have to give up their land in the interests of a social policy. I am extremely glad that this section has been introduced. It has been introduced, not for the reason which Deputy Killilea has given, because the Minister under Section 5 has no more power than has Deputy Killilea to fix the price of any land that may be acquired by the Land Commission in the future, once this Bill has become law, as unquestionably it will become law, with, I hope, Section 5 unchanged.