We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1950-51—Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 1–158 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

With your permission, Sir, I should like to make a personal explanation arising out of some figures which I quoted in the debate last night. I was dealing with Vote 27, Agriculture, and with the increase of that Estimate, and I did not at the time advert to the fact that a very great part of the increase was due to the transfer from the Department of Industry and Commerce to the Department of Agriculture of the food subsidies. My attention was drawn to that later and I understand that the matter was subsequently very effectively dealt with by Deputy Briscoe. As the figures I quoted may have misled some people, I should like to avail of the opportunity to assure you, Sir, and the House that my misreading of the figures was not intentional.

Comment on this

I am very pleased at the attitude adopted by Deputy Timoney in intervening to indicate that the way in which he quoted these figures could be misleading but that that was not his intention. Might I suggest that the attitude of Deputy Timoney be adopted by a number of supporters of the present Government because they are to a great extent labouring under similar misapprehensions? Their apprehensions are so varied and so many that it is impossible to correct them unless instances such as we had last night arise. I will give an instance now to demonstrate that.

Various members of the inter-Party Government are extraordinarily vocal about the iniquity of rates of interest charges, particularly where they concern local authorities or the State itself. Are these Deputies aware that under the Fianna Fáil Administration the rate of interest charged to local authorities was reduced from 4¼ per cent. to 2½ per cent.? Since these protestants against high rates of interest came into office they have increased the rates of interest from 2½ per cent. to 3¼ per cent. Surely those who blame us for high rates of interest must be labouring under a misapprehension when we, in fact, reduced them and they themselves are responsible for bringing them back again to a higher level.

Might I point out, too, that when there is a difference of opinion as to the best way to administer the finances of the State, those who hold such opinions should read for themselves often and regularly some of the ministerial statements made by members of the present Government in this House? May I quote in particular the statement of the Minister for Finance when introducing the Budget in 1948? I am somewhat astonished to hear his interpretation of the position we have reached to-day with regard to the attitude of the present Government towards the expenditure of money as between capital expenditure and the ordinary service expenditure treated separately.

I would like to know where we really stand. Are we to take it that, as far as the inter-Party Government and its supporters are concerned, there can be no stable policy, no definite goal towards which they are marching in step, but that, as event succeeds event, and as situation follows situation, policy is changed to meet the particular event or the new situation?

We must remember that when we get a Vote on Account before the House we see for the first time what the housekeeping will cost in the following year. If there is an increase or a decrease in expenditure we do not know how the Minister will meet that because that is something he only discloses in his Budget Statement. But we do know from the Book of Estimates what our commitments will be and we have a fair idea, since each Department is recorded separately, what each Department will do. But then we get this kind of statement. In Volume 110 at column 1039 the Minister for Finance stated in 1948:—

"On 9th March last I informed the Dáil that no Minister of the present Government had had time to examine the details of the printed Estimates for which he had to stand responsible before the House. On that occasion I made it clear that it was the policy of the Government to ensure retrenchment over as wide a field as possible, to limit expenditure to projects and services that were productive or socially desirable and to endeavour to reduce the cost of living in which a very large increase in Government expenditure is a material factor."

Now the Minister there accepts the formula, and one can justifiably describe it as a formula in that particular sense, that the cost of living is affected by Government expenditure and he attributes the then alleged high cost of living, so severely criticised during the election, as being influenced by the fact that Government expenditure was too high. The present Government and its supporters committed themselves in no uncertain terms to reducing the cost of living. I could quote names, dates and places to prove that such statements were made. They promised to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent. as a result of the economies which would automatically take place in State expenditure if they were returned to office.

On the same occasion the Minister for Finance further on in his speech made reference to food subsidies. He pointed out that the system of subsidies carried into effect by Fianna Fáil in order to ensure that essential commodities would be available to all at a reasonable price inflicted a hardship on a great number of people. He intimated that by degrees these subsidies would be altered or removed altogether. How can one keep the cost of living down by removing subsidies on the main essentials? The Minister quite clearly gave an undertaking to the House and to the country that a certain step would be taken in that direction. He kept his word. Very considerable savings have been effected by introducing new methods of dealing with food subsidies.

We all know that sugar was originally rationed in order to ensure that there would be a sufficient quantity available for all during the emergency years, apart from the fact that it was subsidised too in order to keep it at a reasonable price level. We know that the position now is that you can have all the sugar you want, when it is available, at a certain price. It is being kept rationed now solely to ensure that one will get a limited amount at the subsidised price. I appeal to the members of the Government to recognise what is happening. That kind of juggling does bring about a saving to the taxpayer, but it also inflicts severe hardship on those people for whom some members of the Government profess such solicitude. The same is true of tea. The same applies to flour. If one does not like white bread, one can eat grey bread. If one likes white flour, one can have any quantity one likes without any subsidy being paid.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I think somebody said "hear, hear".

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

What is wrong with the grey flour?

Comment on this

I shall answer both Deputies together. The grey flour was introduced during the emergency because we were not in a position to satisfy our own needs from our own production. In order to make bread available the extraction percentage was altered. We were always accustomed to white bread in this country and we all hoped that when normal conditions returned white bread would be available to us again. Some one referred to the standstill wages Order last night. Bread was subsidised in order that wages would not have to follow a rise in commodities. Whether you buy white bread from your baker or buy white flour from your grocer and bring it home to your wife to bake your bread, the position to-day is that unless-you can afford to pay for white flour you cannot have white bread? Who is denied the white bread? "What is the difference?" asks Deputy Donnellan. The difference is that the vast majority of our workers do not get white bread.

Comment on this

They get a better article of food.

Comment on this

I would ask Deputy O'Higgins to leave that matter to the medical profession.

Comment on this

They are all of one mind on that.

Comment on this

I do not know that that is so. The Deputy is a very young man. He has not reached the stage I have reached of having reared seven children. I think I can say that I have some idea of the kind of bread children like and that I know the kind of bread I like. A great number of my constituents would like a piece of white bread if they could afford it.

What happened next? The shops which made buns for the children are now allowed to make certain classes of confectionery only if they use the high-priced flour. Therefore, the poor child, who is now threatened with the imposition of 2d. a lb. on butter, found that he had to pay more for his little piece of confectionery. Subsidy was to be saved in order to bring down expenditure but it was not to be saved and is not now being saved to bring down the cost of living. It is having the different effect of putting up the cost of living.

I noticed when the Minister was speaking on that occasion that he told the House what 6d. in the £ on income-tax meant from the point of view of income to the Exchequer. He assessed 6d. in the £ as bringing in or taking off, whichever way you work it, approximately £670,000 in a year. I want the Deputies to keep that figure in mind. A sum of 6d. in the £ was taken off the income-tax of those who pay income-tax. They were saved that amount of money. The important question is where was it collected? It was not just forgiven to the whole country. It was taken off the people in another way. There was an increase in the price of stamps under national health insurance. There was an increase on the postage rate. Instead of getting back £670,000 the State made a profit because they got back £900,000. Did they reduce taxation? The term taxation is used in this House without proper understanding.

It is true that there is such a thing as direct tax. In this House, however, we are prone to regard direct taxation as the only taxation. We forget that indirect taxation is the only way in which you can get tax from those people who are under the income-tax-paying level. To transfer direct tax from the backs of the higher income classes to the backs of the lower income classes and to say here that it is a reduction of taxation, well, that is something which is beyond my comprehension. I recommend and urge strongly that those Deputies who are supporting present developments should watch their step and consider the matter carefully because a time will come—maybe in the near future or maybe in the distant future—when we shall have to face the electorate again. We shall be answerable for our housekeeping on behalf of those who sent us here.

It is quite true that a lot of people listened to what was said by members on the opposite benches before the last general election and believed that the things they promised were going to happen. They believed these promises because they were made categorically. I have a few references here which I should like to relate to what I am talking about now. Deputy Cosgrave, the present Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking at Dún Laoghaire on 9th January, 1948, made the definite statement that high national expenditure was a direct contributing factor to the high cost of living. The people listening to that statement would assume that he stood for a reduction in the cost of living and consequently a reduction in taxation or Government expenditure. But what is happening? The Government is coming in with a much greater bill of State expenditure. The only conclusion the people who believed these statements then can draw now is that if it is correct to say that high national expenditure puts up the cost of living then higher State expenditure is going to put it up even further.

Deputy Fitzpatrick in his election address said:—

"Clann na Poblachta promises to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent. Defeatists will tell you that this cannot be done. It can and it will be done."

He underlined "it can" and "it will". The people who voted for Deputy Fitzpatrick probably were concerned about their situation in regard to the cost of living. They have now waited two years—it is two years over-due—for a reduction of 30 per cent. in the cost of living.

Comment on this

They have not waited 16 years.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

And it never will be either——

Comment on this

You are right.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

——because they will not be there. It is a safe prophecy.

Comment on this

The present Minister for Social Welfare when speaking at Mullingar on 29th January, 1948, said:—

"We advocate a scheme of subsidisation of essential commodities as a step to ameliorate the burden of the cost of living."

A great number of people believed these promises. We were emerging from very hard times as a result of the war. These people probably voted for those who said that they would do these things. What do we find now? We find a removal by degrees, but very effectively, of the subsidisation of the essential commodities. The price is, therefore, dearer to the people, who were better off during the 16 years that they have just changed from.

The Minister for Finance also in that particular Budget speech referred to the state of the debt of the country. He said that the direct State debt was at £104,000,000 as at 31st March of that year. He said:—

"The service of the debt, together with sinking fund, requires an annual payment now"—that was 1948—"of £4,500,000."

I should like Deputy Hickey to make a note of that. What is it going to be at the end of this financial year? What is it going to be after 1952? I can see us heading for a state of affairs where, if we go on in the manner in which the Minister now suggests, our sinking fund and interest charges will reach £7,000,000 or maybe £8,000,000 a year. That will be quite a considerable amount that you can understand when you talk about it as 6d. in the £ or 1/-in the £. We know that £670,000 is the equivalent of 6d. in the £ on income tax. What then is £8,000,000 going to be?

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy, before he sits down, will suggest the remedy.

Comment on this

I am coming to that. However, I want first to get the Deputies to admit that there is need for a remedy and that what is happening is no remedy.

"At a time when taxation is of unprecedented severity and economy in State expenditure is imperative it is more than ever necessary to examine critically proposals for capital expenditure which add to the taxpayers' annual burden and thus tend to stifle incentive and to reduce savings. There is general agreement that housing, though not productive of an adequate direct return in the financial sense, is entitled to special consideration on social grounds. But other plans, however desirable in themselves, which entail heavy expenditure uncompensated by an adequate return, must now be reviewed in the light of the community's capacity to undertake them without undue strain on its resources... Capital outlay in excess of current savings is already exerting a strong inflationary pressure on the national economy. Bank advances, largely for business purposes, increased during 1947-48."

As reported in column 1053, he said:—

"We cannot, however, as has been suggested in certain quarters, sustain a continued trade deficit of this order by drawing on our external capital. Owing to the rise in prices abroad, the community's sterling holdings, though greatly increased during the seven years of reduced imports, 1940-46, have not as much purchasing power now over supplies as they had in 1939. This applies also to the income from these investments. The reduction in this, one of the most certain sources of our external purchasing power, the weakness of our export capacity and the uncertainty of the continuance of income from emigrants' remittances, tourists, etc., at their present high level render is impossible to view with equanimity a continued reduction in external assets on last year's scale. These assets can be consumed now only at the expense of a reduced standard of living for the future. Even their use for productive capital purposes is advantageous only if the real benefits are at least sufficient to compensate for the resultant loss of external income and purchasing power."

The Minister there apparently is not quite in accord with the Minister for External Affairs because, if there is any meaning to be attached to the approach of the Minister for External Affairs to the matter, it would indicate that his remedy is to bring home all the external assets within 24 hours and put them at the disposal of the State for all kinds of capital expenditure and so forth. But the Minister for Finance apparently, in that year certainly, was of the opinion, as most prudent people should be, that you can only repatriate your external assets if you have some means of using them without creating a panic, if you can use them judiciously and by a gradual process absorb them in well-planned advances in your economy with the necessary security for the owners of that capital. The Minister pointed out that you cannot use up all your external assets at once and leave yourself to face the future without any external assets.

I could go on and refer to many other aspects of the problem as it was discussed in the House here. What I am concerned with is that the people should get a reasonable picture of what is happening and that they should not be confused. I must say that I welcome very much the attitude adopted by Deputy Timoney to-day, but it is behind the walls of their Party meetings that they should act. I am not sufficiently in the confidence of Deputies on the opposite side to know whether the inter-Party Government supporters meet all together.

Comment on this

I am sure everyone will acknowledge his error when he makes it.

Comment on this

I am suggesting one of the errors that you must acknowledge —the view that was held before the election that Fianna Fáil was overspending foolishly and ridiculously and running the country into disaster. That error should be admitted now and Deputies opposite should admit that they have found that the administration of Fianna Fáil was carefully planned and that it was an approach to the problem from the point of view of ultimate benefits to the public at large. There is an error that perhaps you would be good enough to admit publicly.

Comment on this

The people did not think that.

Comment on this

As against the approach in this year, I want to make a short reference to a statement of a previous Minister for Finance. I am quoting from Volume 105, column 2251, in which Deputy Aiken, when Minister for Finance, is reported as having told the House:—

"We were able also to meet without borrowing the items of expenditure in the Supply Estimates for which I budgeted to borrow last year: £42,000 for Army building, £40,000 for forestry, £400,000 for airports and £200,000 for employment schemes."

That was where provision was made that, in the event of income not being sufficient to meet the expenditure budgeted, one might have to borrow a certain amount of money for items which could easily be regarded as items coming under the heading of capital expenditure. At the end of the year, when there was a surplus, instead of borrowing, the outlay on these items was met out of income from the taxation of that particular year.

We have got to the position where the Minister for Finance, if I have understood him properly, states that the increased expenditure envisaged in this year's Vote on Account of approximately £20,000,000 has to be divided under two headings, one of approximately £8,000,000 and the other £12,000,000 for capital expenditure. If we examine the items one can only conclude that some of them should normally come under the heading of expenditure from ordinary income.

Deputy Aiken as Minister for Finance made this reference also on the same occasion and perhaps Deputy Hickey will be satisfied that it is a matter that was giving concern to the then Cabinet:—

"A matter which has an immediate bearing on the effect on the national economy of any given volume of money is the rate of interest on State debt. It is in the public interest that such debt as the State must incur should be at the lowest possible rate of interest."

Comment on this

What was it?

Comment on this

It was reduced for the local authorities from 4¼ to 2½ per cent. Since then it has been increased from 2½ to 3¼ per cent. Perhaps the Deputy will also remember that after the setting up of the Central Bank there was an idea, a gradual process again, that certain moneys which the bankers deposited and which would be held by the Central Bank would be made available for local authorities for them to borrow from at a cheap rate of interest. One has to admit, whether one likes it or not, that the approach to this matter was considered seriously by the predecessors of the present Government and they were taking the necessary steps to get to a position which would suit all interests concerned.

We have heard a lot about Fianna Fáil in its early days. I want to go back to 1932, because reference was made to the amount of capital debt we found when we took over and the amount we left when the Government changed. I do not think people seem to have sufficiently reasonable memories on matters of urgent importance and of value to the community. When Fianna Fáil took over office there was, according to a statement published at the time, a national debt of some £32,000,000. There was also—and we seem to have forgotten about it now— a debt of £76,000,000 to Britain under what was called land purchase annuities arising from the secret agreement; a local loans annuity of £5,300,000, and a liability under Royal Irish Constabulary pensions of over £11,000,000. In addition to the £32,000,000 we owed over £90,000,000. Fianna Fáil were able to settle that liability—all those three together—for a sum of £10,000,000. Fianna Fáil borrowed £10,000,000 after that settlement and handed it over in full settlement. It was a very considerable reduction of the capital debt.

I would commend this volume to those who want to study these matters —Volume 75 of 1939. There was with the Budget in that year a series of itemised statements showing every item of importance in the State position. You will find all sorts of tables there, including a statement in column 2007 dealing with financial transactions and cash operations of the Exchequer for the period 1st April, 1932, to the 31st March, 1939. In those years the State borrowed, roughly, £41,906,000. That was raised for Exchequer purposes up to that period and the State had paid out some £50,000,000. In other words, in those years the State had reduced the national debt by almost £10,000,000, not increased it. We borrowed £10,000,000—the 3¾ financial agreement loan—and we paid that £10,000,000 to the United Kingdom Government.

Go through the whole lot and you will find that with these payments there was also a list of the liabilities and assets of the State. You will also find an account of investments by the State in State-subsidised or State-helped concerns. I certainly believe all these things. I cannot see how anybody can other than believe a State document of that kind. I often wonder how people, before they come in here, can make certain statements and why, when they have come in here and find that the visa they got on their passport of entry here was a false one, do not say: "Well, we were mistaken about that".

Senator S.T. Ruane, speaking at Kilmaine, said:—

"To-day the national debt of Éire is over £100,000,000; the debts of local bodies total over £37,000,000 and there is an adverse trade balance of £60,000,000. Is it not time there was a change?"

He did not tell the people that what he meant was: Is it not time there was a change for more? That is why we had £24,000,000 last year and we will have £24,000,000 this year and the additional £40,000,000 of the Marshall Aid.

We find people talking about the waste of money it is to import goods from America. We are told that Pierce's will be closed if we do not stop buying machinery from America. Is it not in the Marshall Aid Agreement that we must spend the dollars we get on goods supplied from America, and is it not consequent on the present position that if the Minister has to issue a loan to take up the counterpart of that fund in the Central Bank, if he needs money, it is of interest to him to see that we spend such money as fast as we can in buying goods from America in order that he will have money available for his flotation purposes? Are we not then getting away from the position announced by some of the people over there, that we do not want anything from America?

I could go through a whole list of items I have before me. There was a reference to social services and what was going to be done. I see nothing in the Book of Estimates with regard to this very much publicised scheme of social services which we heard about for the past two years. I do not know whether it is possible to understand what is meant when one hears that it will be introduced very soon. One would expect that if the scheme announced by the Minister for Social Welfare were to be included this year as a State service, it would have been provided for in this year's Estimates. If he is going to bring in a special Bill and if he introduces a Supplementary Estimate during the financial year in connection with it, then I suggest that this Book of Estimates is not a true picture of the situation that will face us, because I understand that scheme will go to £7,000,000 or £8,000,000 a year—that that will be the cost to the State.

Comment on this

Who told you that?

Comment on this

I say I estimate it will cost that. Can the Minister say how much he thinks it will cost?

Comment on this

"If every ducat in 10,000 ducats was in ten parts and every part a ducat..."—does the Deputy remember that?

Comment on this

It was announced that the new social security scheme would be introduced.

Comment on this

At a cost of £7,000,000 to the State?

Comment on this

That was announced, and if it does not cost that, then it was not the scheme that was announced.

Comment on this

It will not cost £7,000,000 to the State; there is no £7,000,000 from the State.

Comment on this

I will correct myself to this extent, that the £7,000,000 will be the total cost, of which £2,500,000 will be borne by the State and the rest by the contributors.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And there is nothing in this Vote on Account about it.

Comment on this

The Deputy has dropped from his original £7,000,000.

Comment on this

The Supplementary Estimates that will be introduced this year will be like what happened last year; they will come singly or in numbers and we will have a considerable increase on this sum of £78,000,000. I want to wind up with one thing. It is quite possible that the present inter-Party Government, including the Minister, may not believe us when we approach this matter as we do, and may think that we are playing politics as they did. Therefore, I will read for the Minister something which he may not have read although I would imagine it has been brought to his notice. I am going to read for him the concluding paragraph in the leading article of his very friendly newspaper, the Irish Independent, in its issue of Saturday, 18th March. It says:—

"We fear that some of Mr. McGilligan's ministerial colleagues, rather than the Minister for Finance himself, must take the blame for the disturbing figures now before us. Mr. McGilligan concluded his Budget speech only ten months ago with these very pregnant words: ‘Agricultural output and exports as a whole are still at dangerously low levels; capital expenditure—some of doubtful productivity—is outstripping current savings; rates and taxes are excessive; dead-weight debt is rapidly expanding; and production costs are unduly high. The primary needs of the moment are increased output at lower unit costs from farm and factory and more saving by the community generally. To this public authorities, central and local, can contribute by reducing their demands on taxpayers and ratepayers.' We find it hard to think that a Minister who so recently endorsed those sound sentiments can be primarily responsible for increasing by £12,750,000 the demands on the taxpayers."

One of the Deputies of this House has a motion down asking for an inquiry into the increase in rates. This the Minister referred to in his speech as spending by public bodies as well as State spending, but a lot of the taxation, direct or indirect, hitherto gathered by the State and handed over to local bodies is now on the backs of the local bodies in the form of excess demands which they have to make on the public. That is why the rates are increasing. I shall welcome that motion when it is brought before the House.

The rates the Minister referred to are brought about by savings by the State in regard to certain matters which hitherto went to subsidise certain parts of the local administration, and, secondly, the withdrawal of what previously had been recognised as State liabilities but which are now part of the expenditure that local authorities have to meet. One must have regard to the requirements of local authorities together with those of the national Exchequer. I hope it will be recognised that if these two things are taken together and if the promises and prophecies that were made to get Fianna Fáil out are ever fulfilled we will get back again to a budget of £36,000,000 a year. If we do get back to that position, then the taxes on the backs of the people will be relieved and we can have a healthy, normal development of our people.

I see the Minister for Health here. I wonder what has he to say to the agreement that there shall be an additional 2d. per lb. put on the butter which the people eat. Is that increased charge going to be conducive to the health of the people for whom he has responsibility? These are some of the points I hope the Deputies opposite will examine. I hope they will soon awaken to the fact that without any great blowing of horns they have taken over gradually a great deal of the policy of Fianna Fáil, and that they will soon come to recognise that it was the only sound policy for the welfare of the country.

Comment on this

I think that members of all Parties in this House, no matter what their views may be on other aspects, will agree that after a generation of self-government our industrial and agricultural advance has not reached that stage which the energies and capabilities of our people deserve. In taking a careful view of the picture, as it presents itself to us, we must, I think, feel that there is something in our system which is operating against a proper advance, no matter what direction that may be. I have given very careful study to the matter of finding out exactly what it is that is clogging us here in our efforts. I have come to the conclusion that, apart from certain other causes which I consider minor to the one I am about to refer to, the question of the control of credit in this State is one that requires very careful examination by this Assembly as representing the people.

Now, since I have in other discussions and on other occasions referred to the question of the control of credit, I would like to make quite clear what I mean by that. Control of credit, in the way in which I introduce the subject to Deputies, consists both, in my submission, in the creating of credit and also in the ebb and flow of credit or the opening and the shutting of the sluice gates of credit. I want to make it quite clear that, in dealing with the control of credit, I am endeavouring to deal with something that is entirely different from and divorced from banking and the banking system. It does impinge upon it here and there and relate to it here and there. In so far as I am trying, or endeavouring, to make my point, I want to make it quite clear that I am dealing with what is distinct from banking, that is the buying and selling of money itself.

Now, when we started our own Government in this country we took over from the British system a large number of their institutions and conventions which had grown up over the centuries. Perhaps they were, and perhaps they were not, particularly suited to the British set up as it affected them in their country, but my submission is that the system of control of credit which exists in this State, and which owed its birth and its graduation to the British system, is not suitable to our democratic system at the moment. I want to make this point, that there are only two systems that exist in the world that are of any account or of any matter, and those two systems are diametrically opposed to each other in fundamentals: a system of dictatorship and a system of democracy. Away back in the past the system of dictatorship was represented by an absolute monarchy; to-day it is represented by a form of government. We exist under the system of democracy. We here as representing the people—I as representing my constituency and those who sent me here to speak on their behalf—have, first of all, the control of legislation; and, secondly, we have control of the Executive in the control that we exercise over the Government by our presence here in the Dáil and by the part we take in debates and otherwise. Now, under a dictatorship such as exists in parts of the world to-day the control of legislation is in the head of the State, the control of administration is in the head of the State and the control of credit is in the head of the State. If we want to carry to their proper conclusion the real tenets of a democratic system, the control of credit should equally reside in this Assembly. We make the laws, we control the Government, but we do not control credit.

I should like to explain exactly what I mean by the control of credit. I do not mean that it is a question of dealing in money. I should like to divorce for a moment the control of credit from dealing in money. What I mean is placing at the disposal of an individual or a group of individuals certain resources and backing as against brains and brawn, and not as against stocks and shares and security. To give an example, if you go to a bank and ask for a loan of £70, you will certainly get it if you produce Guinness' stock with a face value of £100 or something with a good margin over and above the £70. I do not refer to that as credit. That is a commercial transaction akin to pawnbroking, in which security is marketed by way of bargain and sale as against money handed over the counter. The sort of control of credit which I refer to is the right to credit—I shall refer later to the Article in the Constitution on which I rely—and the control of credit that resides in the people of this country and which should find its voice through this Assembly. It is similar to the control of credit which was part of the prerogative and dispensing power of the monarch in the Middle Ages and the control of credit exercised by a dictatorship.

America would not have been discovered at the time it was by Christopher Columbus unless he had been given credit, and America would not have been developed if credit had not been allowed to flow in full measure.

I am not an economist and I know nothing whatever about political economy. I can appreciate that there is in existence the Central Bank with the functions which it has to perform in this State. I do not think, however, that the Central Bank or its functions meet the situation which I envisage. So far as I am concerned, I have no personal quarrel with the banks, and I should like to say that I have received from a particular bank from the time I opened an account there, the utmost consideration. Therefore, so far as I am personally concerned, I have no quarrel as regards the control of credit. But, speaking on behalf of the people I represent, I consider that there is a very serious grievance.

That brings me to the point that the control of credit, instead of residing in us here as the successors in title of the prerogative of the early ages, resides in the banks. I am not for a moment blaming the banks for that. That is the position they found themselves in and that is the position, perhaps, in which they would like to remain. I do say, however, that, unknowingly or unwittingly, the position of credit and its control at present in this country means that there is a State within a State. I shall give you two examples of how that control of credit operates. Those of us who remember the years after the first world war will recall that the value of land soared to an enormous height and that bank managers fought with each other at auctions and in the fields for the right and the privilege to advance money for the purchase of farms. That was something that was done within this State by institutions over which neither the Government nor the Legislature had any control. Now we come to the other extreme. When the recent war was over, whatever the reason was, we know that within a matter of days credit was restricted in this State. I do not wish to impute any evil motives to any one, but we might have the feeling that the bankers did not regard with favour the line-up of the inter-Party Government. I do not want to bring that into it. But, whatever the reason was, credit was restricted, with very serious results to trade and industry in this country.

The control of credit should be exercised through the views of the people as expressed by us here. I want to give this example. Suppose we could possibly reach such a high state of perfection that the Government and the Opposition and all other Deputies agreed that it was necessary that a certain law should be passed and administered in a certain way. One would imagine, if this were a perfectly democratic State, as there was 100 per cent. unanimity, that there would be no body or group in this country with a legal right to interfere with the fulfilment of the desire of all the members of this House. I am not saying it would be done, but it would be within the power of the Standing Committee of the Joint Stock Banks to make or to mar such legislation. I say they have done it for various reasons; I do not suggest malicious reasons. I am not referring to this Government or to any particular Government, but they have made or marred plans either through negligence or inadvertence on their part, not realising what the people desired, or to protect their own interests. They are entitled to protect their own interests so long as they are in a position to do so. It is their duty to do so. Protecting their own interests means that there are two things they must do; firstly, they must protect the shareholders and, secondly, they must protect what is referred to as the money at call.

As I understand it, money at call is money that must be available to meet the demands of any customer who has money on deposit or in current account should he wish to withdraw it. Perhaps in those circumstances the banks feel it is better on certain occasions not to give credit over and above the security available. I have already given an illustration on that point. Be that as it may, and advancing that as a defence of the banks, the fact that they have the power to do that places our democratic system in a very shaky position.

Here another consideration enters into the matter. One of the ways, and this is particularly true of our own country, in which the banks earn their dividends is by lending money for short periods on the available markets. The only big one now, of course, is London. I have come across concrete cases of that. It is much more advantageous for the banks to lend a couple of hundred thousand pounds in London for a fortnight, a month or five weeks rather than to lend £10,000 to Irish industry or Irish agriculture over a long term. A particular case of that came to my notice recently. A man had risen in the world. He acquired a farm and, by his industry and diligence, he was subsequently able to acquire a larger farm. He required a sum of £6,000. He would be secured in that amount by one of the safest guarantors in his district, a man of financial stability. The solicitor who was in charge of the matter found that he was getting nowhere. Eventually he made inquiries and the reply he received was: "We do not like longterm loans. The way we like to use our money is to have it available on short notice in London for short-term loans because in that way we get a bigger turnover." That is the position in banking in this country at the moment. I do not want to be regarded as an enemy of the banks. Far from it. I merely point out certain facts. I do say that the sooner the banks realise that their duty is to this country first, consistent with their duty to their shareholders and their customers, the better it will be for them.

I want now to deal with another aspect. At the moment there is a forward movement in housing, but my remarks in this respect apply to practically everything. In that forward movement unlimited credit should be extended to those engaged in the building industry. It should pass from the suppliers to the builders' providers and to the builder. Suppose to-morrow the joint stock banks decided that, in the interests of their money at call apart altogether from any profit they might make in the money market elsewhere, credit would be restricted by 10 per cent. The banks have power to do that. Visualise what happens when steam is suddenly shut off in a goods train as it passes along the main line. Every wagon bangs, one against the other, until eventually the guard's van at the end is hit. If you restrict credit at the source the same effect will be produced in industry and elsewhere. There will be dislocation right through the whole economic fabric.

Now the banks are quite right to do that so long as we allow them to do it. In no sense do I want to be taken as desirous of putting them out of business. They perform a most useful function. Article 45, sub-article 2, subparagraph 4 of the Constitution says:—

"The State shall in particular direct its banks towards securing that in what pertains to the control of credit the constant and predominant aim shall be the welfare of the people as a whole."

Comment on this

A pious aspiration!

Comment on this

Everything I have said is borne out by that rule which governs us here as legislators in this Assembly. If it means what it says, then we are lacking in our interpretation of our duty under the Constitution. We are lacking in our duty if we allow this residue of the prerogative of the people to remain vested in a body running alongside us.

Comment on this

That is logic.

Comment on this

I have dealt with the control of credit outside the country. It is perfectly obvious that it operates to the detriment of the country. I now wish to deal with the ordinary operations of the banks in certain respects. If there is a choice between an Irish customer and an English customer, the English customer will always win. As I said before, every activity here and every industry here is the potential foe of industry and activity on the other side of the Irish sea. We are not a sovereign State. We cannot be a sovereign State unless our sovereignty extends over the whole field of our control and leaves us in the position to say to the banks: "You are quite free to operate here but, remember, if you put Irish signs and Irish names over your banks, you must operate them in this country and, through this country, for the benefit of the country." In the interests of the banks the sooner they realise that the better it will be for themselves and the country. I think the time is arriving when the people will no longer tolerate the present state of affairs. I must apologise to the House for dealing with this matter at some length.

Comment on this

We have listened to something new at any rate.

Comment on this

I have tried on previous occasions within the four walls of other discussions to make the points I consider it necessary to make in the national interest. It is for that reason I have trespassed on the time of the House to-day.

With regard to the Vote on Account itself, I extend my warmest congratulations to the Minister upon the innovation he has made in segregating capital and income items. I know there is a warm and bitter contest on that point. I anticipate that we are going to hear some very trenchant arguments on that point and against the particular framework of this particular Book of Estimates. I can see myself nothing different whatsoever between the way a family should conduct its business and the way the State as a group of families should conduct its business. I think that the wisest family of the lot is the one with a small reasonable income who sets out on the adventure of life—a newly-married couple who expect to rear a family and live in peace, happiness and moderate prosperity. They set up their home, furniture and so forth. In doing so, they look to the system which spreads their capital expenditure over a period of years to such an extent that at the end of that period, with no very great loss to themselves, they have wiped out the original cost of the house and furniture and become the owners of it themselves. In connection with these items of capital expenditure, at the end of the period of 20 years, the group of families which this State represents will be in the same happy position as any thrifty householder who starts his married life under the circumstances I have envisaged.

There is another reason why I congratulate the Minister on the segregation of these items. I believe that by doing so, we will not only be steering in the general direction which I have in view, namely, the control of our own finances and credit to the fullest extent here, but, in addition, we will be paying the way which everybody here has in view, namely, the repatriation of our external assets. I heard the Leader of the Opposition yesterday agreeing that the repatriation of the external assets is desirable if it can be effected. We are all agreed that it is necessary but we do not know how it is going to be done. I believe that the first step in doing it is the particular way in which the housekeeping for the coming year in this country has been approached. I believe it is a step in the right direction. I do not believe that it is a step that alone can accomplish what is desired, but it is moving in the right direction and with its back to the opposite state of affairs. One thing which it may sound rather strange for me to say is that I am sorry that the amount we have down for capital expenditure this year, and under the circumstances in which we have it down, is limited to the amount that appears on the face of the Book of Estimates.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

We are presented this year with a bill which has to be met for the services anticipated in the coming year. I am afraid the criticism should come rather from the benches opposite than from us. We have not the store of adjectives at our disposal that those who sit on the opposite benches had when a much smaller Estimate was brought into this House. "Staggering, prodigal, complacent"—all these were the types of adjectives that were used by the present Minister for Finance when he was speaking about the Supplementary Budget of 1947. That Budget was brought in at a very critical time to meet a situation that had to be met if the whole community were not to suffer. That period was a period of an extraordinary rise in prices and of consequent demands for higher wages. The cost of living was going up at a rate which caused everybody anxiety, and the Government of the day, in order to meet that situation, proposed that the necessities of life should be subsidised in order to bring the cost of living down, and to prevent, as a temporary measure, because we felt that it was going to be temporary, hardships on the section of the people who could least bear these hardships. Of that £70,000,000 over a year, some £15,000,000 would go back directly to the people, in relieving them of the extra cost of tea, sugar, bread, butter and so forth. We felt that we were justified in the public interest in meeting the situation, to the extent to which the extra cost was necessary, by imposing taxation on things that were not as essential as bread, butter, tea and sugar. We were denounced from one end of the country to the other as being an extravagant Administration, and as having no concern whatever for the public welfare. Our opponents went to the country and said that £10,000,000 at least would have to come off that expenditure. The moment they came into office, to pretend to the people that they were serious, they cut off the taxes on what were relative luxuries compared with bread, butter, tea and sugar, and they denounced the previous Administration as being extravagant and as having no concern whatever for the public interest.

In the Vote on Account, which was brought in by the present Minister some two years ago, all these adjectives to which I have referred were used by him. In his Budget he continued on the same line and gave hope to those who gave their votes for Fine Gael that now the things which they stood for were going to be accomplished—that there was going to be a revolution in this matter of State expenditure and that the millions were really going to come off. Last year, though to a lesser extent, we had the same attempt by the Minister for Finance to pretend to the people who voted for him and his Party that they were going to keep the promises which they made to the electorate. But what do we find? This book which has been given to us this year has a long sheet in it which shows the audited expenditure on the Supply Services for the last year of Fianna Fáil—the year which included the special Supplementary Budget—and the total audited account for the expenditure on the supply services for that year was £58.9 million, that is less than £59,000,000. For the first year of Fine Gael—the Administration which was going to cut down expenditure and which was telling us that the cake was being eaten too rapidly—the audited accounts for the supply services is £64.7 million, an increase, as you can see, of some £5.8 million so that instead of the £10 million that was going to come off under the Fine Gael Administration, we have an increase of close on £6,000,000.

We shall soon have the White Paper of the Exchequer Issues and Revenue for the present year. These will give figures reasonably comparable with the audited figures; we have not got them, but if we take the column of the total provision that has been made, we find an expenditure of £74.6 million for this year, very nearly again another £10,000,000 added on. I do not say that the issues will actually be equal to that but certainly the direction in which the Government are going is not the direction in which they said to the public they would go. Of course it would be too much to have £78,000,000 as the total on the front of the Book of Estimates for the coming year as was customary. That would be too much of a shock, but we find the total given properly on the inside in this long sheet of which I have spoken. We have then got this device of separating the total in order that there should not appear on the face of the book a figure which could compare with the figure that was denounced in the past. We have two separate figures. But even if you take the smaller of these figures, the one that does not contain any element of this capital expenditure, you have an increase and not a diminution on the bill in our time.

I have said that it is not from this side of the House that criticism ought to come of this Vote on Account but from the other side of the House, from Fine Gael. It is they who told the people that they were going to reduce taxation and public expenditure. I do not mind Clann na Poblachta voting for this; I do not mind Labour voting for it, but I do mind a Minister who spoke as the present Minister spoke about our Administration. I do mind very much for public decency in this State to see him coming along and standing over this. Our position in the past has been well known. It was not when the Minister for External Affairs began to talk that this whole question was considered by us. There has been an attempt here to tie up the Fine Gael Administration with our Administration, to lump both together as if there was one common policy adopted here for the past 20 or 25 years. Everybody who was alive and thinking in the country in that time knows that that is not true. We came into this House for the purpose of putting into operation what we stood for as the Sinn Féin policy—the policy of developing the resources of the country, the policy of trying to keep in this country as many people as the country could maintain, to keep at least the natural surplus of our population here until the population came to such a size that it would be apparent that the area of land we had was quite insufficient to support it. That could not be done without building up industries side by side with agriculture.

We had the present Minister for Industry and Commerce speaking a few days ago, telling us of the wonderful advance in industrial development made in this country during the whole period, including the period of the Fine Gael Administration. How much of it was done when Fianna Fáil was in office? I am sure, if you examine the figures, you will find that some 90 per cent. of it was done during that period. They boast of what has been done in the last year or two. What has occurred in the last year or two, so far as it has been an advance, has been simply an implementation of the plans made by their predecessors. To try to put us in the position that Fine Gael was in, is something that we certainly resent, and I think we have a right to resent it. Fine Gael to-day is in the mud. I had some respect at least for the people who were in it. I felt they stood for something from which I differed, but they stood for it and they represented it in our national life. To-day, I have the same sort of picture of them as I think I would have of a tug-o'-war team who had lost their anchorage and who were being pulled along in the mud. I repeat that it is not from these benches that criticism of this Vote on Account should come but from the Fine Gael benches and from those in this House and in the country who supported them.

We have stood always for the development of this country. We did not have to wait for the birth of Clann na Poblachta to talk about the development of its resources. We have been working for that in Fianna Fáil. We have been working for it for many years. Our policy was based on the conviction, on the belief, that we could, by the use of the resources and the materials of this country, make it a country which would be able, for a considerable period, to supply the greater-part of its own needs by the labour of its own people and, therefore, keep our population to a large extent here. We had no ideas such as the Minister for External Affairs tries to attribute to us in regard to these matters.

The Banking Commission report has been referred to as having been accepted by us. The Banking Commission report was used by Fine Gael when they were here on these benches as a source of ammunition. It was a constant source of attack on the Administration of that time. One of the attacks was that there was a diminution in our external assets. The value of these external assets was shown and I would say this about the Banking Commission report. I did not accept some of the final conclusions of that commission as determining how our national policy should go, but I would recommend it to some of the people who are talking nonsense about financial matters. They might study it for a bit and it will do them a world of good; it will bring them down to some sense of the realities of the situation. We cannot have our loaf and eat it. We can make up our minds if we want to eat the loaf to eat it and be content. but we cannot, if we are going to be honest, go around the country and tell one set of people that we can eat the loaf and tell another set of people that we can have it at the same time. The amount we are to eat and the amount we are to have can, to a certain extent, be regulated. It is for such regulation that we should be meeting here and discussing with great care these proposals that are brought before us.

Keeping for a moment to these external assets, how were they produced? One would imagine, listening to some of the speakers, who can talk so glibly and use such parrot phrases about Financial and monetary matters, that we just sent those assets over and that we placed them there as one would place an account in a bank and it was all a matter of which bank one went to. That is not what happened and everybody knows it. We were sending goods out of this country, agricultural produce, to Britain. We were not able during two great wars— the first world war and the recent world war—to get anything back like the quantity of goods we wanted. Were our farmers not to send their goods then? If we had somewhere else to send them where we could get returning goods for the goods we were sending out, it would have been our duty to do that, whether in the first world war or the recent war. But where was the place to send them? So far as the things we exported are concerned, we exported only that which was surplus to our own needs.

Comment on this

What you were unable to consume?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Surplus to what was required for consumption. The point is that we sent that surplus out and we were not able to get back equivalent merchandise. Our merchandise account, therefore, was unbalanced to the extent that it was building up on the other side, whilst we were not getting any equivalent. Therefore, our assets increased and, as a result of these two situations, we accumulated assets which make us one of the few creditor nations of the world. Is that a bad position to be in? During the period we would not have denied ourselves these goods but, owing to the situation, there was a compulsory saving, so to speak, in the way of consumption of these goods which otherwise we would have got.

We have the results of that abroad to the extent to which they are available and to which they are stable in value. It is, of course, a matter of tremendous concern and must always be to a country situated as we are, as to whether these assets abroad will have a stable value and whether they can be realised as we want them. That is, of course, a matter of fundamental importance and a matter which we must always have in mind. In a time of danger or if they are losing their values we would naturally try to get them back quickly or put them into a place of greater safety if we could. Can we bring these back? Those who talk glibly about these things give the impression that all you have to do is to put in a demand to a bank or otherwise and get them all back. That is not the way in which it can be done.

Comment on this

I do not think anybody would take it so lightly as that.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Some people take it so lightly that I have great difficulty in thinking they regard it in any other way. I have been a long time listening to the Deputy, and in my opinion he is one who would get a great deal of benefit from reading the Banking Commission report. You cannot get these assets back in that way. You will get these assets back by getting the products which these assets will enable you to purchase in the country where the value is current. If we were able to do it, at what speed should we get them back? Assuming they were of stable value and that there was no danger of rapid depreciation or anything of that kind, at what speed should we get them? That is a special feature that has to be considered. Should we not be rather anxious that if they were to be brought back they would be brought back for purposes that would be really productive? I hope to have a few words to say later as to what productive should really mean.

Is it any loss to this country that it should be in a position in which it could bring in some millions of pounds' worth of steel as it wanted it, and that it could come in every year, because it was the produce of these external assets? Suppose, as a result of these external assets, you were able to get imports of steel—say some £5,000,000 worth per year. Suppose you brought the assets over here instead and used them in such a way that you were able with its produce to get only half of the £5,000,000 would that be good business? We heard from Deputy Esmonde that we ought to regard these things in a simple way and perhaps we could give some homely examples from ordinary housekeeping. Let us say a farmer has some source of income other than from his farm and that income can be used by him to send his children to school. Do you not think that farmer would consider very carefully before he would take that money away and use it for other purposes which would deprive him of the income coming from it? He would naturally balance matters up and, if he found that he could get more from it in another way, he would do that. But, if he found that by realising that source of income he was going to have less available for his children to go to school, he would think twice about it. Surely, we ought to take up a similar attitude in regard to these assets?

If there is development here which these assets will enable us to bring about and these are productive either in a narrow economic sense or in the broader social sense, then when you have balanced up and seen that they balanced properly, if your judgment is that you are going to benefit you will bring them here, but if you think you are not, you will not.

We appreciated the criticism of the Banking Commission that to the extent to which these were being realised in our time the income we would ultimately derive from them would be lessened— that there was an important source of income being diminished. We answered that for ourselves, at any rate. We did not enter into a public controversy to any extent with those who had made the Banking Commission report, but we satisfied ourselves that the work we were doing with the money which we were bringing over was being used to good effect and to the national advantage.

We take the same attitude with regard to this Vote. It is only the amount here and the people who bring it in that are a matter for criticism and comment here; but the principle of using Irish capital, external or internal, for the development of Irish resources has been from the beginning one of the fundamental principles on which we have acted. We on this side of the House cannot, therefore, find fault with that principle as a principle. What we do want to have made clear to us is this, is the manner in which that capital is being expended going to increase the national wealth or improve the national well-being? That has to be proved. There are some of us who are very doubtful, and more than doubtful, that that is going to be the result.

There is nothing easier than deficit financing. Had we chosen deficit financing in the critical year, 1947-48, we would at least have deprived our political opponents of one of their principal cries. And that deficit financing, on account of certain overestimations, could probably have been justified in our time as it could not have been justified at any time since. Deficit financing is very facile. One of the checks there are on public expenditure and unwise expenditure in a democratic State is that the Government have to face the bill or, at any rate, have to face the responsibility and the odium for placing the burden on the people. That is always healthy and helpful to any Government that takes its responsibility seriously. It is always helpful, in advance of Budget time when the Ministers in the various Departments are demanding various services which they think are going to be of value to the country to say: "Very good, but remember when Budget time comes we will have to face the bill and the collective responsibility." If the Government decide that they can stand over it and that it is in the national interest then the project can go ahead. Naturally a good deal of discussion does take place on these matters.

Is there any one of us who if our incomes were not limited would not multiply our wants? Is there anybody sitting on these benches who, if to-morrow he found that there was no limit to the money on which he could call for the things he wanted to do, would not multiply his desires? Every one of us is kept to the particular standard that we maintain. We are kept to that standard by the test which each one has to put to himself—can we afford it? If we want some particular thing that is not an absolute necessity, and we find that we can afford it, that our income will meet it, that we can balance at the end, that out of the £20 income our expenditure will be £19 19s. 6d., then we may say to ourselves: "All right, we will have that; we will have the satisfaction of that desire; we can meet the cost." But if we are sensible and find that if we give ourselves this thing the expenditure will be £20 0s. 6d., we will halt and deny it to ourselves.

We have that type of reasonable check on our personal expenditure and on our family's expenditure. It is there as a guide for us. But when you come to State expenditure you are not in the same position. I am not going to say that those who are in charge of the public purse will not exercise over it the same care that they would over their own money. I am not going to make that suggestion though the fact that you have to put your hand in your own pocket is also a sobering consideration, a consideration which is not exactly there in the case of Governments who are handling other people's money. Nevertheless, there is this big difference between the two, even if we do not take such a suggestion into account. The difference is that there is a definite bottom to your own pocket. When you are dealing with State expenditure there is no such definite bottom.

Taxation can be oppressive. Over-taxation of the people can do more damage than all the work that a Government thinks it can do by the proceeds of it. The question for us to determine here is whether the taxation which we put on will be justified—and whether the national position will be bettered or made worse. You have a definite estimate as to what you can put on yourself. You can calculate your £20 0s. 6d. or your £19 19s. 6d. to a nicety, but you cannot do that in the case of the State.

I have more than once spoken about the conservative finance that has been practised here in the past, and there is this to be said about it anyway that as far as the financial situation in this country is concerned it is as sound as any in the world. That is true. Perhaps—and this was our view—the best use of our resources for our own people had not been met by following the rigid policy pursued, but that policy had this element of safety in it.

We here are political groups and political Parties. At election times we go to the people who elect us or support us with some policy which we are anxious that they should accept. No Party wants to tell the people that burdens are going to be placed upon them. Every Party will shirk that to the utmost. It requires a great effort to act up to the best public interest in matters of that kind, to face the unpopularity of extra taxation. We did it and we are here in Opposition. Other Governments and other Parties know full well that that may be their fate. Every instinct of Party is urging and driving them not to put on the taxation that is necessary to meet the services.

It is a splendid thing to tell the people what wonderful services you are going to give them—better health services, better this and better that. We see that here in this House. We used to see it when we were on the other benches. Every single proposal which came in was approved if it meant some service, and the general line of opposition to the Government was that they did not provide services enough. Then, of course, having no responsibility, when it came to Budget time and the charges had to be met, the Government was abused.

Private Deputies will try to have it both ways, but a Government cannot. If the services are provided, the Government of the day must see that the necessary money is found for them. If we are not prepared to face the cost we must deny ourselves the services. The question always arises: how is the money to be found? If there is a way out the Government will avoid putting on the taxation that is necessary. They will go into debt; they will try to work by deficit financing. The danger in the proposals before us is not the question of using money or the national resources for national development. The danger is that the easy way is being provided for any Government that wants to shirk its duty. Whenever there is any difficulty about putting on taxation to meet these needs, all they have to do is to put it into the capital side of their Estimate, and then set out to defend it. Excuses will be easy. If it cannot be defended on the ground of being productive financially or economically it can always be defended on the ground of general welfare. You can always say that the people are better off, that they are enjoying life better, that they can go to the theatres oftener, that they can smoke more tobacco and drink beer at a cheaper price. You can always excuse yourself and say that some good has come from your deficit financing and nobody can prove definitely that you were wrong. There is no definite measure or standard by which it can be judged.

My objection, therefore, to this sort of proposal is that it is highly dangerous in a democratic State. If, for instance, the bodies who form this Government at the present time had to meet their responsibilities to the full, out of current savings or taxation, a very interesting situation could develop, a situation which, in fact, appeared to be developing if we judge by the bleatings of the Minister for Finance and the bellowings of the Minister for Social Welfare which we heard recently. We had, of course, no doubt in our minds as to whether the bleatings and the bellowings were going to triumph. We believe that a situation like that existed and we now know that the easy line was taken, the line of giving in, the line of putting the debt on to-morrow, the line of mortgaging the future. It is because we believe that that has been the line which has been pursued that we look with anxiety upon this Vote on Account.

So far as the policy of developing our resources and the policy of using money for productive purposes are concerned, there will be no difficulty. But the country at the moment is being badly served, because those who should criticise it from the point of view of conviction as regards principles are silent. We on this side are not the body to criticise that. It is known in advance that we could not criticise that as severely as it could be criticised by those who have different convictions. But there are people in the country who have those convictions and they are the people who elected Fine Gael to represent them. They are the people who think that money left in the pockets of the community is going to be better used than if it were forcibly taken from them and applied to some general purpose. There are some who believe that. We have never held that belief as applying in all cases. It may be true or it may be false in a particular case. If you do take the responsibility of taking money out of people's pockets and putting it to some other use, you have to be fully satisfied that the use to which you are putting it is in the general interest and better than the use which the various individuals who contribute to taxation would make of it.

There are no rigid lines by which you can say: "To the right is right and to the left is wrong." It is for that reason that it is very desirable that there should be vocal in this House people who will be able to show the other side of the case. We cannot be vocal in regard to that because of the fact that we did in the past take it into account and decided in many cases in a direction different from those who held these other views. For instance, I have no doubt that the members of the Banking Commission, had they been members of the Government, would in many cases have differed from our view about a certain expansion. We took the step and we believed we were right. We never pretended that there was not another view which had to be very carefully taken into account. The trouble is that that particular aspect of the matter is not going to be put forward in this House with the force and sincerity with which it could be put forward by those who believe fundamentally in it, and they are sitting on the benches opposite. If we are to judge by the past, they were either blatantly dishonest about those things or they are now sitting as meek as mice. In the present situation everything is reversed.

Reference has been made to our past and our programme. We have been asked questions about development. I think I have answered them. We need only point to the development that took place during the period in which we were in office. As I have said before, we had here the other day a picture of the increased output in industry, the number of extra people employed, and so on, presented to us by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The period chosen was carefully selected so as to cover a period longer than the period in which we were in office. But when one segregates the work that was done and the advances that were made in that period and the work that has naturally continued after it, one sees to whom the credit in the main is due for our present state of development. There is housing. Go around this city and see the new city, so to speak, that has grown up in the suburbs. We have 140,000 houses to show. Our period in office embraced the period of the world war during which there was a shortage of material and during which the progress that had been made could not be continued at the same rate. I happen to have here some notes I had as head of the Government, at a time we were considering post-war problems. We were being constantly and persistently asked what our plans were. I did intend to read them to the House in detail. They are a summary of the various projects which were in hand at the time.

Comment on this

Would you circulate copies of them?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I did intend to put them on the record so that they might be there for all to see, but I do not think the Chair would permit me to do that. Neither would I be able to read them with that ease which would enable me to hold the attention of the House. For the Deputy's information, I refer here to the White Papers. Here is the White Paper on our housing plans. It contains a review of past operations and immediate requirements, indicating what our policy was. Here is a White Paper on agriculture. We had set up a commission to examine that principal industry very closely. The policy in relation to our programme was published. The reports are there for anybody who wishes to see them. If he studies them he will get, just as he will get from studying the report of the Banking Commission, information that will enable him to do his duty as a Deputy here more effectively than he might otherwise do it. They are valuable reports.

In connection with agriculture, there were to be guaranteed markets and satisfactory guaranteed prices for various products. Indeed, looking at this summary, one can realise what a lively topic it would be at the present moment. Here is another one dealing with pasture, fertilisers and feeding stuffs. Here is one dealing with industry. Before the war had ended the then Minister for Industry and Commerce had got in touch with all the industrial concerns in which there was hope of expansion. He had also got in touch with those people who might be interested in establishing new industries. The plans were made. Is it any wonder the present Minister can point to the advances made in the past two years? All the plans were laid. The ground was prepared. I give this information to show that as far as our Party was concerned our policy was quite clear.

I have here the post-war building programme. A sum of £70,000,000 odd was involved in capital expenditure over a period of years. I remember how those who support the Coalition Government to-day dealt with that particular project in relation to building construction.

Here is a White Paper on tourist development. Need I remind the present occupants of the Government Benches of their attitude towards tourism. Need I remind them of what they said about the "spivs" coming in here to eat our food and their suggestion that a tax should be put upon them. Very soon after they took office we were told that the tourist industry was worth something in the region of £33,000,000 a year, as far as my recollection goes. That is more than all our exports in our two principal categories bring us in in any year. Yet, because an effort was made at the right time to get in on the ground floor and make use of the particularly good situation in which we found ourselves in order to develop that industry, we were classified as a spendthrift Government, concerned only with the foreigner, the outsider and the wealthy visitor, and with no concern for our own people. Here is another White Paper indicating the plans that were made and the programme laid down for the development of our bogs, for the erecting on them of power plants in order to ensure that we would be to as great an extent as possible in future independent of foreign fuel.

Comment on this

Have you the secret plan on social security?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Now that the Deputy reminds me of it, here is one on health services.

Comment on this

We have not seen yours yet.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Indeed, I have not got the half of them. I remember one excellent paper dealing with tuberculosis, indicating the attitude to be taken in that matter. The other day I saw where the present Minister for Health opened a new sanatorium. I happen to know something about that, because I finally came into it in a dispute about the site while we were in office. It is like the houses where the foundations were laid by us, but the superstructure has been added since.

Comment on this

It was not Santry Court by any chance?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

In Santry Court we had to keep away from the airport. You are keeping away from the airport too.

Comment on this

I am not keeping away from the airport at all.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

The other day we had a statement from one Minister to the effect that they have to restrict building there. I think it is necessary to have licences or permits of one kind or another.

Comment on this

We did not throw away £40,000 beforehand.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

The point is that one swallow will not make a summer. One fault will not prove that there was not definite planning.

Comment on this

You learned all this from the cover.

Comment on this

You never learned it anyhow.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I did more. I helped to establish a Department of Research.

Comment on this

But you only saw the cover.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

That Department did and is doing good work.

Comment on this

But you only saw the cover of the tuberculosis report.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It is coloured differently from the other ones. The others were White Papers. This happens to have an orange cover. I suppose there is some special reason for that. All those papers and reports indicate that this Party stands, as it has always stood, for development; but we have to ask ourselves at every step what the cost will be, whether we can afford it, and whether in the long run the benefits that accrue will outweigh the initial disadvantage of cost. If it can be shown that expenditure will produce worthy, desirable results, we are prepared to face that expenditure. We do believe, however, that the temptation towards deficit financing, the mortgaging of the future instead of facing up to present-day responsibility, is a danger we shall have to watch. I hope the people will watch it.

Comment on this

Why did the people not swallow all these reports?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

At the election we got more first preference votes than Fine Gael, Labour and Clann na Poblachta all put together—than the whole lot of you put together. We got more elected representatives here than all your separate organised Parties together.

Comment on this

That is why you are there.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It is easy to gang up.

Comment on this

We had 16 years of it.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Yes. Undoubtedly, 16 years in office is a very heavy load for any Party to carry in an election. We never had any doubts about that. Other Governments that have been a long time in office—irrespective of what good they have done—have gone out of office precisely because people like a change. But the big thing in our case was that we came back after seven general elections with as great a strength in 1948 as we did in 1932. The difference is——

Comment on this

The Labour Party sold out.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

——that the Labour Party, which then supported our Party ——

Comment on this

Who was the buyer?

Comment on this

You all got your share.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I remember the Leader of the Labour Party over there looking at Fine Gael here and he pointed at them contemptuously and said: "What! To join up with you who were the rejects of the country!"

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is travelling a small bit away from the Vote.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

What put me on that line, I am afraid, was that I wanted to point out the temptation there is for Parties that have to face the electorate to take the easy way and to avoid the hard way. The hard way is the way of taxation, even when it is within reasonable limits; even when it is, in the view of the Government, justifiable, because nobody—whether he is the income-tax payer or the smoker of tobacco or the consumer of beer—wants to pay more of his income to the State than he possibly can. He certainly does not want to pay anything he can avoid. Therefore, to live up to your responsibilities as a Government in getting the taxation that ought to be imposed to meet your current needs, requires strength and character. It is not a strength that I can see in the Parties that compose the present Government. They have completely different views. As I look across the floor of the House I see the whole spectrum, from infra-red to ultra-violet——

Comment on this

Pale pink.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

——and I naturally ask myself what cohesion there is among them and if it is not obvious that to keep together they must take the easy way. I believe that this Vote on Account is an indication of it. It is unfortunate for the country that they can play this trick constantly. Those who want to pull Fine Gael further along can always say: "You can do it with safety because the policy of the Opposition has been a policy of the kind which makes it difficult for them to criticise you as you should be criticised." That is the position in which the country finds itself. I have not the slightest doubt that if things were changed and we were in the benches opposite and brought in a Book of Estimates and proposals of this kind, there would be no words in the English language sufficiently strong to denounce us. I know full well that every one of the papers which are supporting this action now would be very loud in their denunciation of us if we were doing it. I hope that we will be able to do our duty as an Opposition and that we will be able to examine these particular items in close detail. At any rate we will strive to make sure that wherever public money is involved some good justification for the expenses will be given and that it will be proved to us and to the country that it is worth while.

Comment on this

Since this Government came into power we have been listening to the cry that they succeeded in reducing taxation. Naturally, being good showmen, they followed the old example of all good advertisers in the belief that if you tell the people something and tell it to them often they will come to believe it in the end. It is rather surprising that, in the face of this huge bill which is presented to the country, the Minister for Finance even now points out that this Administration has saved the country £7,250,000 in taxation.

As another speaker has pointed out to-day, taxation does not necessarily mean the amount paid by the people in income-tax. Taxation must relate generally to revenue received by the State and the expenditure from that revenue by the State. This year the proposed expenditure amounts to £78,000,000, that is £66,000,000 for Supply Services and £12,000,000 for capital services. When Fianna Fáil left office the entire bill for Supply Services and the Central Fund amounted to £65,000,000. That was described, before these Estimates appeared, as an exorbitant sum. It was said that the country was being run extravagantly. We heard a lot of adjectives such as "megalomania" being used to describe the administration under Fianna Fáil. We were told then that the people could get the same services as were being provided under Fianna Fáil for far less money. We were told, in fact, that, having regard to the services people were getting at that particular time, taxation should be £10,000,000 less.

Comment on this
Michael Donnellan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Donnellan) Clann na Talmhan

Do you remember the time you were going to rule the country on £11,000,000?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary himself does not know what he is spending his money on. If that is an example of the type of administration we are getting, it is no wonder that the bill has gone up so high.

Comment on this

It is difficult to explain things to people who cannot understand.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Donnellan make a speech himself?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Lynch must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Not only has the present Administration failed to reduce taxation by £10,000,000, but we are now faced with a bill of £78,000,000. Then we must have regard to the fact that during the course of last year Supplementary Estimates were introduced to the extent of something like £8,500,000, and, even at that, we are not finished with Supplementary Estimates because some remain to be passed, amounting to almost £750,000, with the result that before the present financial year concludes, added to the £73,000,000 bill we had last year, we shall have an additional £9,000,000, making a total of £82,000,000. Even, therefore, in that year for which the inter-Party Government must be held completely responsible, they advanced by £17,000,000 over and above the £65,000,000 which was the bill when Fianna Fáil left office. How then can the Minister for Finance even at this stage claim that he has succeeded in reducing taxation by £7,500,000?

Comment on this

Do you believe that? Do you agree that the extra taxes were taken off been and tobacco at a cost of £6,000,000, and do you believe that income-tax was reduced at a cost of £1,000,000?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

That is £7,000,000.

Comment on this

I also believe in the figures placed before me in the Estimates. The money for the Supply Services is got out of revenue and revenue can only be got out of taxation. In the year 1948-49 there was a total of £72,000,000 in revenue receipts. That represents, in the first year in office of the Coalition Government, £6,500,000 over the revenue receipts of the Fianna Fáil Administration. Surely if that £6,500,000 of revenue comes out of taxation that represents an increase in taxation.

Comment on this

At the same time the Deputy agrees that £7,500,000 was thrown overboard in the remission of taxation? That is a bit of a miracle.

Comment on this

If you take a shilling out of a man's pocket and give him back sixpence——

Comment on this

How did I do that?

Comment on this

He gave sixpence and took back a shilling.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy should be allowed to make his own speech.

Comment on this

The Minister can reduce income-tax and increase taxation in other directions.

Comment on this

What did I increase?

Comment on this

Under the 1948 Social Welfare Act, which extended the upper limit of wages of those who might become insurable, in a period of ten months owing to the increased cost of sixpence in insurance stamps and the increase in the upper limit of wages, the Minister was enabled to collect £780,000.

Comment on this

Can you point to the Vote under which that was done?

Comment on this

I want to object to the Minister for Finance, who is an old hand, interrupting a comparatively new Deputy, particularly when he kept his mouth shut while members of the Front Bench here were speaking.

Comment on this

If Deputy Lynch thinks I am embarrassing him I apologise.

Comment on this

I am not a bit embarrassed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputies on both sides do not uphold the ruling of the Chair it will be impossible to keep order in the debate. Every Deputy is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I am apologising to Deputy Lynch. I did not know that I was embarrassing him.

Comment on this

The Minister is not embarrassing Deputy Lynch and I shall continue answering Deputies when I am interrupted. I said that under the 1948 Social Welfare Act there was an increase of 6d. per head in the insurance contributions paid under the national health insurance scheme. That increase brought in in ten months an increased revenue of £780,000 and in a single year it is only reasonable to assume that the increase would represent a sum of £1,000,000. That £1,000,000 is collected by way of taxation in the same manner as taxation is paid by a consumer of tobacco or beer. Therefore, if the Minister relieves taxation in one respect and puts it on in another respect, he cannot in the last analysis, say honestly to the country that he has succeeded in reducing taxation. I seek to prove through the Estimates that not only has he failed to reduce taxation, but he has increased taxation considerably.

We have been listening for the past day and a half to eulogies of the wonderful wizardry of the Minister in introducing this new system of presenting estimates to the people, segregating capital services from other services. It may be an innovation to set it forth on the cover of the Book of Estimates, but certainly the Minister himself will admit that it is not a new procedure in any way to show the difference between capital expenditure and the expenditure on ordinary services. The fact is that, in order to justify capital services at all, there must be reasonable expectation of revenue-earning capacity in such capital undertakings. That may be true of many of the items the Minister has set out in the first couple of pages of his Book of Estimates as capital services, but, at the rate he is going, the Minister will have succeeded in about two years in imposing a capital debt on the country as great as Fianna Fáil did in the entire term of their 16 years of office. I have no quarrel with that in so far as capital expenditure now will bring benefits to the people of this generation or another generation but, so far as I understand, the test that should be applied to capital expenditure is, first of all, that it must be abnormal, secondly, that it must be non-recurrent and, thirdly, that it must have a revenue-earning capacity. In the capital service I see before me, there is an item of £1,635,000 for housing. In the first place, the housing situation is anything but abnormal. I admit it is serious, but it is recurrent and it will always recur. Therefore, it fails under the first two tests. I think it fails utterly in the final test inasmuch as capital expended on housing is non-productive. The Minister admitted that in his own Budget statement last year.

If we are going to have loans raised for the purpose of housing, I say by all means let us have them but the Government should not shirk its responsibility to provide for housing out of taxation. Housing, heretofore, has been provided for out of taxation and nobody will deny that there was a tremendous housing drive in the years from 1932 to 1938. So far as I know no big loan was raised to defray the cost of housing during those years. It was faced honestly by the Administration in office and met out of taxation. I say "honestly" because housing on the Minister's own word is not productive and, therefore, it cannot be treated justly as capital expenditure. If the Minister in those days wanted to raise a loan for the purpose of housing he could have done so. By all means let such housing finances as have been provided heretofore out of revenue be provided along with whatever capital he is going to raise by way of loan. If possible let the housing drive go ahead at a double pace.

We have been listening for some time to Clann na Poblachta telling us that there is no necessity for floating housing loans at all so long as we have £400,000,000 in external assets. We were told to bring our assets home as if all that is required is to send somebody over to walk up and down Threadneedle Street singing "Come Back to Erin" or else to write to the secretary of the Bank of England saying: "Please let me have a cheque for £400,000,000."

Comment on this

That is very childish from the Deputy.

Comment on this

It is not childish. So far as I can understand, the Clann na Poblachta policy was this, that all we had to do was to restore our external assets and we could have capital expenditure on productive schemes all over the country—forestry and God knows what else. Fianna Fáil knew very well that repatriation of assets was desirable as far as it could be achieved, and they set about that in the only manner in which it could be set about. They established industries; they tried to get agriculture on such a solid footing as to make the country as self-sufficient as possible. By doing all that they put our economy in such a position that it would encourage people who, up to this, had been sending their surplus money abroad, to lodge their money in Irish undertakings. By making our own country financially and economically sound was the best method any country could adopt to encourage the repatriation of assets. That was what was being done and, please God, it will be done without bleating emptily of calling back and restoring our external assets. It is a thing that can only be done by organised planning.

Many people examining the Estimates must be perturbed at the alarming increase in the cost of various Departments. It is rather significant that one Department has advanced by something like 133? per cent. When Fianna Fáil left office the Department of External Affairs bill amounted to £153,000. In the current year the Estimate is £359,000. That represents an increase of almost 133? per cent. Everybody realises that some of that increase must be put down to the devaluation of the £ and the advance in the value of the dollar but, nevertheless, it by no means represents the full amount of the increase. If the thing were properly analysed, it could be proved that there is still about 100 per cent. of an advance in the sum to be provided this year over the sum provided in the final year of the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

The Deputy must admit that a lot of very useful work has been and is being done abroad.

Comment on this

A lot of work has been done, but it does not account for such an enormous increase. A lot of the extra work that is being done could, with a bit of judicious pruning, be done more effectively. I had occasion to refer to this before, that Ministers are going abroad at the slightest provocation and that has been receiving a considerable amount of comment.

Comment on this

Some ex-Ministers went out without any provocation.

Comment on this

But they went at their own expense, whereas the Ministers go at the State's expense, and that is the difference there. Some people are travelling all over the world, Ministers and other members of the present Government, at the State's expense.

Comment on this

On State work.

Comment on this

People are commenting adversely on it. It is little wonder if people nowadays change the old saying "Join the navy and see the world" to "Join the Coalition and see the world". That is what is happening. That represents the minds of the present Government. When Fianna Fáil were in office any increased expenditure was described as extravagance and megalomania. Fianna Fáil as the responsible Opposition realises that some increases may be necessary in the moneys provided to run the country but, having regard to their promises before they came into office and their performances since, the bill that is now presented to the country and which will be subject to the Budget statement when the Minister is imposing new taxes, is out of all proportion to those promises and to the Government's achievements. The Government will have to answer for that, if not in the immediate future, certainly when some of those capital charges will have to be repaid—capital charges which do not deserve the title of capital expenditure.

Referring to capital expenditure, I might be permitted to deal with one particular item and that is the £3,000,000 for land rehabilitation and the £1,750,000 for the Local Authority (Works) Act. Everybody realises that many parts of this country are in a rather backward state from the point of view of irrigation and drainage. That is not due so much to neglect as to the particular shape of the country, which is saucer-like. It is very difficult to drain one area without making another area suffer. What has not been provided in any Estimate I ever examined is a reasonable degree of compensation for people who have been affected by flooding, apart from flooding as the result of drainage. For some years there were occasions when serious flooding took place. I remember one occasion, after a heavy fall of snow during the term of office of the last Government, when a lot of farmers' property was destroyed. They got special treatment in order to restore whatever crops or live stock they lost.

Since this Government came into power I had occasion to refer to particular flooding in the winter of 1948. The flooding, again, was in no way due to any organised scheme of drainage. It was due to an act of God, if you like, inasmuch as there was a particularly heavy fall of rain. Certain people suffer as a result of flooding, be it through organised drainage schemes or an act of God. If they are farmers they can successfully come to a Government and ask for special terms, for a loan or a grant to restore their property. But if it is the case of city dwellers, as I have occasion to remember, they have no redress for flooding.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy caught himself out by saying there is no redress. He means there is no legislation and he must not advocate legislation.

Comment on this

Can I not deplore the fact that there is no legislation?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not suggest legislation.

Comment on this

I can deplore the fact that a grant cannot be made out of some fund to provide compensation for people who suffer or whose property suffers as a result of flooding. When flooding takes place in rural areas compensation can be provided by way of loan or grant. If it is by way of loan, it is at a reasonable rate of interest. When flooding takes place in city areas there is no means of providing compensation. I suggest that a grant should be made available out of some fund to assist people in city areas who have suffered from flooding. Some help should be given to enable them to restore bedding and furniture destroyed by the flooding. I do not, however, anticipate any particular success on that point.

I want to refer again to the capital debt that is now being imposed on the State by borrowing for purposes which, as I have already alleged, are not proper capital purposes at all. It is a method of providing for essential services other than through taxation. Taxation, naturally, would be unpopular with the people. The raising of capital for unproductive schemes is only postponing the evil day when some generation will have to foot the Bill. It will be taxation, directly, if not in the present day at least in the case of the generation that is now growing up. I think the Minister should, if possible, avoid going too far in that direction. He should have some regard for those who are now growing up and who, in their day, will have to provide for the repayment of unproductive loans out of taxation.

There are many aspects of this Vote on Account that one could explore. It is almost impossible to resist the temptation to speak on each one of them. I shall finish on the note on which I started. It is that the Minister and his colleagues in the Government have been making the claim that over a period of two years they have succeeded in reducing taxation. I want to say that that claim is as false as the Estimate and the burden which he proposes to place on the people are high.

Comment on this

It was pitiable to have to listen to the efforts made by the Opposition in finding fault with the manner in which this Vote on Account was presented to the House. I thought we would have had some constructive suggestions on policy from the Opposition, but, apparently, their whole grievance is that the Vote on Account is being presented in a way that they cannot agree with. They find fault with the segregation of capital expenditure. I think that if Deputy Lynch had any experience as member of a local council, he would know that capital works are not immediately financed out of the rates. They are usually carried out by means of loans. The same principle is being followed here. Surely, posterity should make some contribution for the benefits it will enjoy from the execution of the capital works which are now contemplated.

Deputy Lynch would hardly disagree that the land rehabilitation project is going to be of future benefit and a source of income to the country. Some of us may not be here when the full benefits of it and of other schemes will be accruing to the country. Anybody with any knowledge of land must know that this reclamation scheme is undoubtedly going to put quite a big area of land into production in the future. A lot of that land is, at the moment, unproductive.

As regards housing, Deputy Lynch rightly said that there was a housing drive between 1932 and 1938. Quite a number of houses were built during that period. I want to point out to him that the public body of which I am a member is now making provision to build between 1,400 and 1,500 houses. In that particular area, the number of labourers' cottages built from the passing of the first Labourers Act up to recently was 3,300. Therefore we are building practically 50 per cent. as many houses at the present time as had previously been built over, one might say, a period of 60 years.

Comment on this

You say you are going to build them?

Comment on this

We have decided to build them. I am sure Deputy Lynch will agree that the building of schools is being stepped up at the present time. School building is going on much more quickly than it did in the time of Fianna Fáil. They had plans in 1932, but they never materialised. I think I remember a Parliamentary Secretary to their Minister for Finance saying at one time that they could run the country on £11,000,000 a year and would bring people back from Tanganyika and Australia. I thought that, when Deputy Aiken went out to Australia, he would bring back some with him.

Comment on this

We brought back nearly 13,000 of the number that you sent out.

Comment on this

As I say, these new schools are going to be of great benefit to our children and grandchildren. It is only fair that posterity should pay its fair share of what it is going to cost to provide these new schools. The children of the country are entitled to get their education under the best possible conditions and to enjoy all the amenities which the State can afford to provide for them.

There has been a good deal of talk about road improvement. At a time when such things as tar and bitumen and other things were in very short supply, the Fianna Fáil Government decided to dissipate the Road Fund. They threw out certain sprats to the various councils in Éire. I think it started from 1946. If the council did the same amount of work as was done the year before, they got 90 per cent. of a grant. That was continued. How were the roads improved? The three deputy engineers in Cork reported after an inspection that at least 60 per cent. of the roads were not yet properly finished and would not be for a number of years to come. Yet the Road Fund was dissipated.

In February, 1948, two days before the change of Government, it was indicated by wire to the Cork County Council that the Government were prepared to carry on under the same conditions. That wire was sent after a member of the Government Party stated at an election in Kilkenny that rather than drive the country into another election he was going to join up with any Party that would form a stable Government. The writing was on the wall, hence the wires. I should like to know what amount of money was in the Road Fund at that time. I know that it cost this Government about £2,500,000 to make up the loss and to stand by the promises made by a Party that knew when they made these promises that there was no money in the Road Fund.

We hear a lot of talk about trips round the world. The Department of External Affairs has focussed international attention on the position that exists in Ireland and on the cancer of Partition. Deputy Lynch is a very young member of this House and a member whom I hold in very high regard. Does he realise that, through the External Affairs Department, we are getting world-wide prominence? Deputy McGrath may object to suppers and other things like that. I remember when Fianna Fáil Ministers would not wear a top hat or get into "boiled shirts" when in this country. But, amazingly enough, when they went to Ottawa they wore them there. Of course it was all right in Ottawa, but it would not do here, because if you tell some people here a certain thing they will believe it. The position now is that, with all their concentrated efforts and their vocal ability, the country has realised that these people were not as sincere as they pretended to be.

Comment on this

That is the reason why they are by far the biggest Party in the House.

Comment on this

Some time Deputy Ó Briain will get into hysterics and, in addition to the Deputies who are doctors, we will have to call in a few more doctors to get him out of them.

Comment on this
Matthew O'Reilly Acting-Chairman (Mr. M. O'Reilly) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should keep to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Lynch talk about the increased cost of the Departments. I should like to remind him that there is such a thing as esprit de corps. I think he was at one time a departmental official himself, and I am sure he was not satisfied with his salary. This Government went a long way towards satisfying the claims of civil servants for increased salaries. They may not have gone all the way. They secured a rate of wages for the workers of this country which would never have been secured if Fianna Fáil remained in office. Fianna Fáil were more concerned with the racketeers and the exploiters of the people whose charter of freedom appeared in the Irish Press some time before the election, than they were with being the poor man's Government, the guise under which they went into power. I am sure Deputy Lynch did not mean to cavil at the increase of salaries given to civil servants, which no doubt is responsible for much of the increase in the cost of the various Departments. When the Minister is concluding the debate he may be able to give us an idea of the percentage increase in the salaries of civil servants.

I now come to the forestry workers. Their wages have been stepped up, but not, perhaps, as much as we would like them to be. They have been increased by 16/- by this Government since they came into office. These workers have also had certain amenities provided for them so that they can carry on their work under better conditions. Reafforestation will be of great monetary benefit to this country. It will also benefit the low lands convenient to forestry belts by the drainage which will take place. This generation, perhaps, will not benefit by the trees that are planted, except from the drainage provided.

I am sure Deputy Lynch did not mean to criticise the farming community when he spoke about the services being provided for them under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. I quite agree that city men will not reap any advantages from this particular work, but surely Deputy Lynch will not cavil because we give those people who have laboured for years under the most primitive conditions an opportunity now of carrying on their work under better conditions. In the past 12 months a certain amount of drainage has been done. That is beneficial to the farmers living in proximity to it. I remember Deputy Moylan saying in Fermoy that arterial drainage would take at least 20 years. I am inclined to agree with him. The project is an immense one and will take a long time to reach completion.

I have been disappointed at the Opposition's approach to this Vote on Account. They had an opportunity of putting forward constructive proposals, but they did not take that opportunity. They dealt with petty matters like functions, teas and suppers. During the emergency Deputy Aiken made a trip to America to purchase rifles for the Defence Forces. The fruits of his labour were Springfield rifles that had been left in England by the American troops in 1917. They were Springfield rifles, but they came from England. They were quite safe for the man in front but not so safe for the man pulling the trigger. Perhaps even at this late hour we may have some contribution from the Opposition of a constructive nature, a contribution which we can assimilate and digest and perhaps ultimately draw benefit from. I appeal to them to drop this silly attitude of everybody being out of step but themselves.

Comment on this

I suggest to Deputy Keane that he should ask the Government to reduce the rate of interest charged to local authorities to the 2½ per cent. to which Fianna Fáil reduced it while they were in office. Before I had any intention of becoming a member of this House, I remember Deputy Hickey explaining to me the effect of these interest charges on the rents of houses. He calculated that the effect put about 10/- a week on a corporation house at that time. According to him then these charges were scandalous ones. Fianna Fáil reduced the rate of interest to 2½ per cent. They gave a grant of £400 from the Transition Fund to local authorities. They made a grant of £275 available to those who wished to build houses under the Small Dwellings Act. Yet, there are some people who now have the impudence to tell us what Fianna Fáil did not do for housing. There is no necessity to dwell on what they did do. Everybody knows it.

Comment on this

I did not say anything about their housing programme.

Comment on this

You did not, but it was said by other speakers yesterday. We built 140,000 houses in seven years. We built them during an economic war when even the people at home stabbed us in the back and threatened to march in here.

Comment on this

You are including the reconstructed houses, of course.

Comment on this

I suggest that Deputy Keane, too, should ask the Government to give back the road grants. We got nothing for road improvement in Cork City this year. We had a deputation to the Minister recently and he told us that he was considering giving us a grant in the coming year, but I take it he will have to deal with the man introducing this Vote on Account first.

Deputy Keane referred to Deputy Lynch's remarks about the Department of External Affairs and the expenditure incurred by that Department. In 1947 Fianna Fáil introduced an Estimate for £52,000,000. At that time the present Minister for Defence described that Estimate as "a crazy demand and unjust extortion." He said at column 1986, Volume 104 of Dáil Debates, 12th March, 1947:—

"We have far more expense, pomp and ceremony attaching to every Minister, every one of whom travels in a car de luxe irrespective of price. This is the result of 16 years of insane extravagant administration.”

Deputy Keane says that we have got far more prominence in the world to-day through the medium of the Department of External Affairs than we had hitherto. I was rather disgusted a couple of weeks ago when I saw in a paper that the only solution we have now towards the ending of Partition is to appeal to that lionhearted man, Winston Churchill, to do it. If that is the only solution this Government can offer after all their promises, I say "May God help us."

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would quote.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny the statement?

Comment on this

The Minister is asking the Deputy to quote the statement.

Comment on this

It appeared in every daily paper in the country.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy quote one of them?

Comment on this

To appeal to that lionhearted man, Winston Churchill.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy quote?

Comment on this

Is the Minister denying it?

Comment on this

I am denying the interpretation the Deputy is putting on my words.

Comment on this

You said:—

"I think we should appeal to that lionhearted statesman, Winston Churchill."

Comment on this

On a point of order. I think that if a Deputy presumes to quote either another Deputy or a Minister, he is entitled to be asked through the Chair to produce the quotation.

Comment on this
Matthew O'Reilly Acting-Chairman (Mr. M. O'Reilly) Fianna Fáil

Did the Deputy intend to quote?

Comment on this

On a point of order. Surely it is not fair to interrupt a Deputy when he is speaking, especially when the Minister will have a full opportunity of explaining exactly what he said in his own time.

Comment on this

I made a point of order.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy did not purport to quote exactly what was said.

Comment on this

I said that the Minister for Defence suggested appealing to Winston Churchill to end Partition. The Minister has any amount of opportunity to deny that.

Comment on this

Is it not the rule that if a person purports to quote he produces the quotation or withdraws it?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy did not purport to quote.

Comment on this

That is not a quotation.

Comment on this

It is a distortion.

Comment on this

It is his dense misunderstanding.

Comment on this

I would not be so dense as to appeal to Churchill to end the partition of this country. There was a lot of talk about all that Fianna Fáil did and did not do and about workers' wages. Surely Deputy Keane knows very well that Fianna Fáil brought in the Conditions of Employment Act? Surely he knows that we were the first people to consider giving holidays with pay to workers?

Comment on this

What about the Wages (Standstill) Order?

Comment on this

It was the saving of this country. I have no doubt about that. I was a trade unionist before you were.

Comment on this

And an Irish one too.

Comment on this