We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1950-51—Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 159–307 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I had to work and I was not paid for being a trade unionist.

Comment on this

Neither was I.

Comment on this

You cannot take it when you are getting it.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Deputy McGrath.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil brought in plenty of social welfare schemes. There is no provision whatsoever in this Estimate for the much-talked-of social welfare scheme. I suppose the only conclusion we can come to in regard to it is that it is being shelved. I suppose that the only thing that will happen is that they will be able to confiscate the national health funds and buy Store Street.

The Minister for Health will not deny that he has got all the help possible from the people of Cork City and County. The position, however, is that the people on the joint bodies attached to Cork—the board of assistance in particular—do not know where they are. We asked the Minister six months ago, on a deputation, about setting up an orthopædic unit in the county home. He was all for it. He said his intention was to make Cork an orthopædic centre. We said that we would get our engineer to draw up plans for the reconstruction of a portion of the hospital that we could vacate at the time, and the Minister said: "All right". Our engineers sent up the plans, but the Minister's technical advisers told him that we had better get an architect. We advertised for an architect and secured the services of a famous man. He gave us an approximate estimate of £34,000. I attended the meeting of the board of assistance on a Monday. I had just read my agenda for the Cork Corporation, which was to meet on the following night. I saw that the Minister was asking the Cork Corporation to hand over the new fever hospital in Cork to be used as an orthopædic-adjunct to the regional sanatorium at Sarsfield's Court. I suggested to the board of assistance that it would be better to find out if the £34,000 job was required at all. I said that I was sure that the corporation would go out of their way to facilitate the Minister as they had promised to give him this fever hospital as a sanatorium until the one at Sarsfield's Court was finished. We, therefore, came up on a deputation a fortnight ago. We asked the Minister, if the corporation was giving the fever hospital as an orthopædic unit, whether he would still require the one in the district hospital. The answer was that he would not. We have now spent, I am sure, £300 or £400 on architects' fees for work done, and then we are coolly and politely told that the Minister will not want it at all when he gets the other place. I suggest to the Minister that he ought to try and come to some firm plan, as far as Cork City and County is concerned, in regard to what he really wants. I am very much afraid that there is a great deal of waste in officials' time and in architects' time in going into those plans, costing money, and then finding that we do not want that one at all but the other. I appreciate that the Minister is doing good work and he is, undoubtedly, getting a lot of help. However, I am sure he realises now that he is not able to go ahead at the speed at which he thought he would be able to go ahead before he came into office.

I should like to refer to tourism, as far as Cork is concerned. All the Deputies of Cork City and East Cork, members of the harbour board, the tourist association and the tourist board, met the Minister for Industry and Commerce well over a year ago in connection with landing facilities at Cobh. We would not be listened to. We were told that no money would be spent on it. We were told that it was the duty of the harbour board or of somebody else. Notwithstanding the very good case put up to him—the Minister for Defence was one of the deputation—that it should be a national cost, we would not be listened to. Well, some months after that, the famous Colonel Pozzi came along and said that there were not proper facilities in Cobh for tourists. Adopting the attitude of the man who has an overdraft taking off his hat to the bank manager, they then bowed down and decided that something would have to be done about Cobh. A departmental inquiry was held. I understand that negotiations are in progress at the moment which may turn out to be successful. I want to point out to the House, however, that because of that attitude, another season was wasted as far as tourism was concerned. They would not do anything until they were in the position of the man with the overdraft.

Comment on this

You know all that for a fact?

Comment on this

I know that, in reply to a question put down by Deputy Sheehan as to complaints which were made by Colonel Pozzi, a departmental inquiry was set up. I know they met in Cobh. I know the results. I know they have asked the Cork Harbour Board to contribute towards the cost and that the Cork Harbour Board have agreed to contribute 10 per cent. of the cost.

Comment on this

As a result of that man's interview?

Comment on this

Yes. We got a reply previous to that saying that nothing would be done. The Minister knows that quite well.

Comment on this

It was not as a result of any effect anyone in Cork had on him, anyway. If Deputy Keane were here, I would ask him to restore the amount of the home assistance money in the form of subsidies that he withdrew from them.

I am sure there is no necessity for any Deputy to tell the Minister for Finance anything about this Vote on Account because I know that there is nobody in the country more "fed up" than he is for having to bring in a demand like this. Deputy Briscoe read out for him the leader in last Saturday's Independent in which it was stated that they could not understand a man like him, holding the views he had expressed before, doing the things he is doing now. We all know that that is the result of agitation by different bodies in the inter-Party Government. They want this and they want that and in order to keep them together he must try to satisfy everybody. I am sure, as the Independent stated last Saturday, that it came as a big shock to everybody to see him bringing in a demand for £78,000,000.

Comment on this

Everyone agrees that it is a serious matter to consider that, in the Book of Estimates before us, we have figures for the past ten years which reveal the rather astonishing fact that in those ten years the cost of the State services has risen from £35,000,000 to £78,000,000. Every year we have had an upward tendency in expenditure. Starting with £35,000,000 in 1941, the total rose by £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 each year, until we have now reached the present high level of £78,000,000. I do not think the Minister regards that situation lightly. I do not think any Deputy regards it lightly, realising that £78,000,000 is required for Supply Services and, in addition, £8,000,000 for the Central Fund Services. In addition we have a sum of approximately £10,000,000 raised by rates, making a total collected from taxpayers and ratepayers generally of close on £100,000,000. That is equal to the total income of the agricultural industry and to one-third of the total national income. Realising this, I think every Deputy will support any measures which the Minister for Finance may take to introduce into Government Departments a greater amount of efficiency and economy. I think that it would be desirable to have a public investigation into administration generally. I was one of those who, some years ago, asked that a commission be set up to inquire into expenditure. I think that the motion was supported by all the then Opposition Parties. I think that it is important that that should be taken up again. It is disconcerting to find that expenditure is mounting year by year and, so far as we can see, there is no indication of any limit being fixed to expenditure. During the past three or four years, there was a similar tendency in regard to local rates, but in the present year public opinion was aroused to such an extent that there has been a check in the upward tendency of expenditure, for the present year at all events. I think it is time there was a similar check in regard to the upward tendency of Government expenditure.

I have no serious objection to the division of the Estimates under two headings—capital services and other services. Farmers in this House, including Deputy Corry and Deputies of other Parties, have all talked a good deal about the dual purpose cow and the dual purpose bull. I think it is only natural that the Minister for Finance should decide to bring in a dual purpose Estimate. What is the purpose of dividing the Estimates into two categories? I think the Minister is quite legitimately making an effort to distinguish between services which are of a recurrent nature and services which are of an investment nature and which might be hoped to recoup the taxpayer in the years to come. I am not sure, however, that it is sound financial policy to borrow all the money that might come under the heading of capital services. I think the whole question of drawing a dividing line between the amount of money that has to be raised by taxation and the amount that has to be found by borrowing depends not so much on what the nature of the services is as upon the monetary position in the country generally. If there is a tendency to inflation it is desirable to raise all the revenue required by taxation. If there is the opposite tendency, a tendency towards deflation, then it is sound policy to borrow. That I think should be the guiding principle more than the question of whether the services may be regarded as capital services or otherwise. Of course, it has always been the policy of successive Governments to borrow for certain items. I think Ministers for Finance have in the main been guided by the general financial position in the country rather than by the nature of the services.

Some Deputies pointed out that during the emergency the then Government sought to raise practically all the money required by taxation rather than by borrowing. I think that was a sound and reasonable policy, because it was very undesirable to have any inflationary tendency at a time when goods were generally in short supply. I think at this particular time the Minister will have to be guided by somewhat similar principles. If there is, in the Minister's opinion, too much money in circulation, if prices are showing a tendency to rise, it would be unwise to borrow to too great an extent, and thus add to that inflationary tendency. I am sure the Minister will take all those facts into consideration.

When we decide that a certain amount of money required for our State services is to be raised by borrowing, the next question that naturally arises is whether we are to borrow by orthodox methods such as the flotation of loans at a fairly stiff rate of interest, or whether we are to adopt the suggestion that was made by Deputy Sir John Esmonde, namely, that we should use the State's own credit to finance works of development. I think that is a matter that requires serious consideration.

I was glad to see Deputy Esmonde approaching this matter in a calm, non-Party and serious way. The case that he made was a strong one and a very logical one. It is a case that has never yet been answered. There is no use in anybody saying that the raising of money for development work by utilising our own national credit would cause inflation. You can cause inflation to the same extent by borrowing money at a high rate of interest. In the same way, inflation can be caused by people with money, people with sterling, coming into this country and adding to the issue of currency here by demanding our national currency in exchange for their sterling.

I think it is desirable that the State here should control our national credit, that it is necessary and desirable that the State should control the amount of credit available in the country and the cost or the interest charged on that credit. I think the problems that face this country are very much different from those that face Great Britain, or perhaps that face other industrial countries. We are an undeveloped country, to a great extent still an undeveloped nation. What is more, the development work which is urgently desirable in this country is work which requires the outlay of a very large amount of money. It is work which will bring a small return.

What are the works of development that are urgently needed? We have the extension of turf development, the extension of the production of electricity, the reclamation and improvement of land, and afforestation. These are all long term development works involving a very high capital expenditure and giving a comparatively low annual return. They are not the types of work that can be financed by loans raised at the ordinary commercial rates of interest. They are the types of work which ought to be financed by the cheapest credit that can be obtained. That is why I think the Government should go all out to investigate this financial and credit problem and endeavour to meet the demands which have been made in this House by a number of Deputies over a good number of years—demands which were expressed very clearly and lucidly by Deputy Esmonde to-day. In addition to the works which I have mentioned we have also housing, the development of the fishing industry and mineral development.

Housing finance is at a comparatively high rate of interest. For purposes such as housing anything over 3 per cent. is a high rate of interest because, in the course of the years which are required to repay a loan on housing development, the amount of capital involved doubles itself. The ordinary life of the loan would be 35 or 40 years. That is a matter that ought to be attended to immediately, because I believe that the whole development of housing is being slowed down by the high cost of money required as a result of the rates of interest charged. That is a burden both on the taxpayer and on the people who require the houses, and it is a matter that should be faced at once. I do not know what we are waiting for.

Quite a number of Deputies on this side have put this proposal to the Minister in various ways, but so far, we have got neither a reply nor any indication that any action will be taken. By the proper utilisation of the credit of the country we could expand and develop our resources sufficiently, not only to maintain our present population at a decent standard, but also to provide for the increasing population which has had to be exported up to the present.

Afforestation is one of those particular branches of development which offer a return over a considerable number of years. It is not only an industry in itself, but it could be the foundation of a number of other productive industries. I do not think this problem ought to be approached from any Party angle. I was glad that Deputy Sir John Esmonde did not approach this from a Party angle, because no matter what Government is in power the people of this nation will have to depend entirely upon the output of their industry and on the output of agriculture. I think it is gratifying to see that there has been some expansion in the output of our secondary industries. There is no doubt but that production has been stepped up somewhat, but there is a wide field for further development. For example, there is no reason why there should be a shortage of cement for building in this country or why that industry should not be expanded to meet our full requirements in housing and other development work.

With regard to agriculture, I am not satisfied that there has been the expansion in output that is urgently necessary. There is no industry so capable of providing an expansion in production as agriculture, or one as capable of adding to the wealth of this country as the land. I think it is regrettable that we have not had a much greater expansion. I do not think that the figures of agricultural output for 1949 have yet been published. I asked for them, by way of question in the Dáil some weeks ago, and I was told that they were not yet available. We know that in the statistical survey for 1948-49 figures are given of net agricultural output for ten years from 1938. Those figures show that during a couple of the war years net output went fairly high, as high as 112, compared to 100 in 1938. That, in my opinion, is not good enough. We ought to be able to expand production in the agricultural industry high above the 1938 figure.

It is true that a good deal of capital expenditure is being put into the work of land reclamation and drainage. Most of this money, however, is being spent upon the water-logged land of the country. It will give a return, but I think we would get a more rapid return if something worth while were done for the high land and the sound land which at the moment is deficient in manures and fertilisers. If something were done to raise the fertility of that land, I think we would have, in a shorter time at any rate, a real expansion in our net agricultural output. It is saddening to see millions of acres of poor pasture land growing nothing but moss, bent grass and herbage that is unfit for food for any animal. I think that land could be quickly restored if capital were made available.

I think that, as we are making provision in this Estimate for capital development on a large scale, it would be no harm to consider the question of capitalising the agricultural industry. There is no industry which is so sadly under-capitalised as agriculture. One has only to go to the country and see the little farmsteads, the out-offices out of date and the inadequate use that is being made of land that should be producing the maximum. One has only to see these things in order to realise the mistake that has been made by successive Governments over a number of years, and the mistake that is still being made by our Government, in not restoring that land, and the agricultural industry generally, to full production. Unfortunately, the majority of our farmers have not the capital to put into the industry, and no industry can develop without capital. So far, no real attempt has been made to face this problem. I think it was the Minister for Finance who, in reply to a question some time ago, referred to the fact that, of the applications received by the Agricultural Credit Corporation for loans, over 50 per cent. of them had been turned down. He made that statement in reply to a question by Deputy O'Higgins. It shows how inadequate is the provision of capital for our agriculture.

I do not know why the Ministers concerned have set their faces so sternly against promoting the development of the agricultural industry by refusing to increase the capital necessary for it. Deputy Sir John Esmonde, in referring to this matter, pointed out how unwilling our ordinary commercial banks are to provide the type of credit that we require for agriculture, and indeed the type of credit that we require for all our big development works. He said he had discovered that the banks derive far more profit from short-term investments and short-term loans in the City of London. I think that is a terrible state of affairs. It is an unfortunate thing that some of our Ministers are so blind to the real interests of the nation, and I think it is time that they should wake up. This country cannot go on spending one-third of the national income mainly on unproductive work. Neither can we go on piling up a burden of debt. We must get down to increased production, and in this regard the first step is the capitalisation of the agricultural industry.

I think, also, that if we are to get an all-out effort in agriculture there must be some appreciation of the hard and difficult struggle which farmers are making. I can quite understand how necessary the Minister for Agriculture may think it is to proclaim that agriculture was never so prosperous, and that farmers are more prosperous, in fact, than any other section of the community. I pointed out to him last week that the average income of each person working in agriculture is, approximately, £3 4s. per week. The Minister stated that he would completely indicate, when replying to that debate, the falsity and inaccuracy of my statement. However, when he was replying to the debate he did not refer to the matter further. Therefore, I am taking it that the figure which I gave was quite accurate, and that it could not be controverted. Therefore, we have a position in which the largest section of our producers, those engaged in agriculture, have an average income for each worker of approximately £3 4s. 0d. per week. That is not a high income. It is not an income upon which you can base very extensive increases in taxation. Neither is it an income upon which you can base very extensive borrowing. I think, therefore, that the suggestion which I have made, that we should have a thorough investigation into departmental expenditure at the earliest date with a view to effecting economies in every Government Department should be adopted. It is not a question of reducing the salaries of officials or of dismissing established officials. It is a question of ensuring that all the Departments are run with the maximum amount of efficiency.

It is also desirable that we should get down in a business-like way to the investigation of money in our real, internal national assets. I quite agree with those who say that it is desirable to repatriate our external assets, to bring back the money invested abroad. But I quite agree, at the same time while it is desirable, it is not so very easy. The simple way and the only way to bring back the money invested abroad is by importing goods. We all know that if we were to increase our imports of consumer goods in order to secure the return of this money we would be only dissipating our external assets without adding anything to the wealth of the country. Therefore, if we are to get this money invested at home we have to import plant for our industry, fertilisers for our land and commodities of that kind which will add to the wealth of our nation and to the productivity of our land and of our industries. That, I think, will be accepted as absolutely sound national policy. So far we have not been doing very much in that direction, but I can see no reason why we should not strain every nerve to bring back the money invested abroad in the shape of capital goods which will add to our wealth.

I cannot see very much wisdom in borrowing extensively from the United States. While borrowing may be justifiable internally, that is Government borrowing from our own people either by way of flotation of loans or by the utilisation of our national credit, there are very many objections to our nation going deeply into debt to another nation, particularly to a nation to which we cannot export very much of our own produce. The sound policy would be to cut down as far as possible our imports from the United States. We should go all out to produce practically all our own wheat in the coming couple of years. We should go all out to produce as much as possible, if not all, of our own animal feeding stuffs. That would be sound national policy in the present circumstances and I do not see any reason why we should not aim at achieving it at any rate.

Nothing is calculated to lower the output of this country more than adding to the embarrassments and the difficulties of those engaged in the farming industry. I was shocked to find our Minister for Agriculture advocating a reduction in the price of milk. I was equally shocked last year when there were reductions in other prices for farm produce, such as oats, farmers' butter and other commodities of that kind. Having regard to present agricultural costs, the increase which has taken place in local rates and in wages, I think that agricultural prices, if not increased, should be at least stabilised. They certainly should not be reduced. No amount of argument from any Minister or from any particularly well-equipped people who may put up various types of argument on this question, will convince farmers that they ought to accept reductions in the prices of farm produce at the present time. I do not object to agricultural prices being reduced provided costs are brought down first. But we have not that position. We have the position that the farmer is expected to accept reductions in the hope that costs will come down. I do not think that the farmer would be so foolish as to accept that plea. I think that those who are administering the affairs of our country will find that the farmer, whatever may be said about him, has a good deal of common-sense and that he is no fool.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid that the Deputy is discussing farming rather than the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I have dwelt unduly on the farming side of our national economy. I think you will excuse me, Sir, when I point out that it is by far the most important side of our national economy. I have referred briefly to the other side of our national economy, namely, industry generally and pointed out that there has been some expansion but not by any means sufficient expansion. The years facing us are difficult years and we want an all-out effort both in regard to agriculture and to industry. I think that the few words that I have said in regard to agriculture will at least indicate to Ministers that they ought not to be trying to bring down farmers' prices. On this particular debate last year I made an appeal which seems to have fallen on the deafest of deaf ears as far as the Government Front Bench and the Opposition Front Bench are concerned. I pointed out that the economic position of the country was grave and that we were facing problems of great complexity. We are a small nation and our resources are limited. Their development will be expensive and difficult. It will require an all-out effort on the part of all sections of the community to put the country on its feet. I suggested last year, therefore, that all Parties should take part in the government of the country. I make the same appeal this year and I hope that it will not continue to be ignored. I think an all-Party Government would enable the nation to face up to its problems.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not expenditure surely.

Comment on this

It is very important that we should get away from narrow Party argument and conflict in regard to this matter of national expenditure. The burden has increased each year, and the time is now opportune to bring about some reduction. I am satisfied that there can be no serious objection to the classification made in the coming financial year. I think, however, that the cost of the services generally must be reduced, particularly those services which are unproductive. I think Government Departments must be reorganised. There is too much centralisation of government in the City of Dublin. Dublin is the most expensive place in which to live or to do business at the present time. It is not unusual for a business man in some remote part of the country to be visited by two or three different departmental officials on the same day. They travel from Dublin to the country and back again. Added to that, we have this perpetual passing of files and documents from the country to the city, and back again. That was brought forcibly to our notice recently in connection with the Department of Lands. What is true of the Department of Lands is equally true of other Departments. I think State Departments should be reorganised and that certain officials should be appointed in certain areas, officials who would know the people in those areas and who would be competent to deal not only with one particular Department but with a group of Departments if necessary. That is one way in which expenditure could be reduced. There is too much duplication and overlapping. I think if there was a proper investigation into the way in which Departments are run considerable waste and overlapping could be avoided. I am sorry the Minister for Finance turned down my request for an inquiry into local government. I hope he will not reject my request for an inquiry now into all Government Departments.

Comment on this

A considerable amount of ground has already been covered in this debate, so much so that I feel there is only one aspect to which I would like now to devote myself. It is a very important aspect. It is a very urgent one, and to a great extent it has been ignored. I refer to the tourist traffic. That is now the biggest industry we have in the country. Yet, the Government is doing little or nothing to help it. This year the estimate for the tourist board is actually decreased. So far as one can judge from ministerial statements, the Government is anxious to encourage tourism, but is leaving it entirely to private enterprise. Other countries give a great deal more governmental attention to building up their tourist industry, and subsequently maintaining it. In our case the time factor is very important. We have already lost two of the best years because of the attitude of the present Government. They started in office by referring to tourists as "spivs." More than one Minister suggested that tourists should be taxed. Tourism was described as having an inflationary effect on the whole. Then Mr. McMullan, who is, I think, President of Irish Transport Workers' Union, made a statement pointing out how important tourism was and how damaging these cheap gibes were. Subsequent to that the Tánaiste was invited to open Mosney camp, and he paid lip service there to the value of our tourist trade. From that time on ministerial statements were encouraging, but quite in contrast to the complete neglect of what is now our biggest industry. One of the experts of the Marshall Aid Plan pointed out that it was very important that this country should develop its tourist traffic. I think he said in 1948 that we had up to 1952 to equalise our exports in the dollar market because Marshall Aid would then end.

Despite that warning nothing has been done. Mr. Taft, another official of Marshall Aid, said that.

"a forthright and determined policy is needed and that is what Ireland does not have."

That statement was made some time ago, but the Government has not yet adverted to the tremendous importance of this industry. They have continued their policy of closing down the channels of tourism. Recently the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach said that our development of an air service with America was squandermania and they had closed it down, showing thereby that the mind of the Government still persists in believing that would have been a source of loss rather than a most valuable dollar-earning agency.

We do not yet know the policy of the Government with regard to the shortwave station, which can be used for very valuable purposes in relation to tourism. They were determined to shut it down at first. The only indication we can now get is that it is in an experimental stage. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has suggested that owing to modern developments it might not prove to be of very much value. The answer to that is that no other country is shutting down its shortwave station, but that, in fact, other countries are actually increasing their power for future use.

The Government sold the five hotels which had been under the control of the Tourist Board and they are now controlled by private enterprise. Cobh and Cork are the bottle-neck of the American trade. The larger part of American tourism comes through Cork. We have heard what Deputy McGrath had to say on that matter. If one looks back on the newspapers of the time one will see how completely discouraged a most representative deputation was by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

With regard to the development of Cobh and accommodation in Cobh, no serious effort has been made to increase hotel accommodation, guest-house accommodation or the taking over of other houses or anything of that sort for the purpose of accommodating the tourists during the next few years—although the chairman of the Tourist Board himself pointed out what a shortage of beds there was and that this year in particular, being Holy Year, with a number of Americans passing through, it would probably give us a chance of having a boom year. One of the American experts already pointed out that a number of Americans had to leave this country because of lack of accommodation and could not take a holiday here. It was also pointed out that for the first time in history a country was actually giving Government assistance to its own nationals to travel and that it was a thing that had never occurred before until the United States Government adopted that policy. Therefore, every factor of advantage is there if we were only in a position to avail of it. There is the whole question of the increased transport facilities which would have arisen out of the use of Store Street for its original purpose——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is wandering from the point.

Comment on this

I am giving a list of these things—I am not elaborating on them—to show that they all come under public Departments and that they all indicate a general attitude of policy. Again, the cutting down on the money provided for the maintenance of the roads throughout the country will not help to attract tourists to come back again for a further holiday. Another item is the shutting down of the building of the concert hall at Rotunda which would have served for international conferences, for public functions, for the orchestra and for other cultural developments— art exhibitions and so on. The Academy of Art has no really satisfactory place at all. These are cultural things to which other European countries give immense attention as a means of attracting tourists. It has the further advantage that you get quality as well as quantity of people. The people who frequent these cultural places are people who come back again and again and they are the type of tourists who have a far better effect on a country than any other type. One often hears the criticism that tourists are undesirable because they have a cheapening effect upon the standard of general public opinion of a country. The best answer to that is to try to get the type of tourists to come to this country who will place us high in world estimation from a cultural point of view. There was also a question of the building of our theatres——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid the Deputy is not keeping to the point.

Comment on this

Am I not entitled to give what one might call a washing list of what ought to be done and has not been done, indicating that the Government is dominated by a certain policy and showing what should be done in order to attract tourists? These are some of the shortcomings of the Government in reference to the tourist trade which indicate an entirely wrong attitude in the matter. The trade itself is of enormous importance. It supplies a near market for the farmers to sell their agricultural produce. It is infinitely preferable to sending cattle out on hoof, where you lose the hoof, the horns and the hide, and it is a market which, over a period of years, is subject to greater fluctuations than any other market because we have only one market.

The Minister for External Affairs seems to be gradually realising that he cannot carry out the magnificent promise he made to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent. It was one of those gestures upon which he rode into power. He is beginning to realise that inflationary tendencies are not under our control. It was interesting to get that admission from him because it shows that the policy on which he set out was entirely fantastic. Whether he believed in it originally or not it is difficult to say. Now that he has come up against the fact, he has, at least, publicly been able to state—by implication in any case—that it is not possible entirely to control the cost of living in this country. He pointed out that, owing to the prices of goods which were imported into this country, and through other factors, the question of inflation is one that could not be controlled. The fact of the matter is that quite a number of different factors make it impossible to see any future for the hope that the cost of living will be reduced.

I shall not detain the House any longer. The subject I was mainly interested in was the question of the tourist traffic which bears very much upon the whole policy of the Government.

Comment on this
Liam Cosgrave Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. Cosgrave) Fine Gael

I should like to give the House some indication of some improvements that have taken place and some attractions that probably influence tourists in coming here. Since this Government took up office it has improved the supply of a number of commodities which attract tourists —notably the supply of butter, bacon and eggs. It has provided these foodstuffs at the same prices and in some cases cheaper than they were available when Deputy Little's Party was in power. There are now adequate supplies of butter, bacon and eggs, and in the case of bacon, the price is much lower than it was in recent years. The turnover of the bacon factories has increased and the supply of food available to tourists is not merely adequate for their needs but ample supplies are available for home needs as well. I think it is no harm to realise that, when we consider what is essential to attract toursits and whether it is more beneficial to provide good fare, attractive food and conditions under which tourists will come here, as a policy likely to achieve results, rather than the policy that was in operation, one which had as a feature of its programme the running of State hotels under the Tourist Board. That policy succeeded in demonstrating at a time when hoteliers throughout the country were all making money, at a time when every guest house of every sort and description entitled to claim that title was overcrowded with guests, that the State hotels were the only hotels in the country that lost money.

Comment on this

They did not.

Comment on this

Of course they did.

Comment on this

They did not.

Comment on this

As the Deputy knows under any normal system of accountancy, in which account is taken of depreciation and interest on loans, they did not pay. If these items were left out it might be possible to show that they made a small profit. Under normal accountancy practice, it was clear that the State hotels failed to make a profit. That was a remarkable fact at a time when every hotel was not only making a profit but was able to book ahead in the knowledge that when the guests there had already departed, there were others willing to come to take their place.

The Deputy went on to criticise the decision to abandon the transatlantic air service as one example of a line of policy that is not designed to promote tourism. I have yet to learn that tourists wishing to come to this country, if they could get cheap accommodation would have been more likely to come if the transatlantic service were available. All the services operating the transatlantic route at the moment have failed to operate at a profit. I do not know whether it is sound policy to bring people here on a subsidised air service and to meet whatever deficit arises on the operation of that service out of the taxpayer's pocket, without some information in the background that when they come here they will be a dollar asset other than from the narrow point of view of the people in whose hotels they stay. I think that from the national point of view on any system of accountancy that is not a policy that would yield a dividend or that would find any support in the country.

I should like to tell the House that the Government is alive to the necessity for providing facilities for tourists and is taking certain steps in that regard. Some Deputies referred to Cobh. A scheme has been sanctioned which will involve an expenditure of £75,000 in providing better landing facilities at Cobh. A contract has already been entered into for the trial borings necessary before the general development takes place there. At the same time, a delegation has returned to this country after a tour in America, which was made possible under Economic Co-operation Administration facilities and through Economic Co-operation Administration finances, which delegation has studied American methods, American technique, American training and, generally, the outlook which Americans have on tourism and on the facilities and standards which they expect to find when they visit this country. I believe that the results which will flow from the visit of that delegation to America are likely to be more beneficial to tourism than any operation of State hotels or any possible gain which a transatlantic air service as tourist attractor might provide. In addition, I am glad to say that a proposal is in train for the dispatch of a number of hoteliers to America on a course provided for by Economic Co-operation Administration facilities so that we can get for our hoteliers practical experience in tourist facilities, general training and technique in the United States.

I think that these definite lines of policy are likely to be more beneficial than the mere spending of money by a State company competing with private enterprise in a sphere in which it should not be the responsibility or the duty of the State to enter. It has never been part of our policy that the State should enter into spheres in which private enterprise is already engaged and in which private enterprise is, as far as it is possible to see, meeting the requirements. It is true to say that at peak periods of the year there is a shortage of accommodation in certain parts of the country but the mere fact that there is a shortage at periods does not justify the expenditure of public money on the provision of accommodation for a limited number of people and for a very limited period. With the general improvements in the tourist trade, as well as the facilities which are now available for hoteliers who want to reconstruct or rebuild their hotels, any lack there is in existing facilities for the accommodation of tourists should be made good, and I believe will be made good, by private enterprise. I have taken the view and have given expression to it on a number of occasions that, as far as tourism is concerned, hoteliers should not regard the present boom as one that will continue indefinitely unless they themselves make available to tourists the facilities which tourists expect. Unless we are prepared to provide standards of cleanliness, cooking and other amenities, which particularly American tourists expect, we cannot hope indefinitely, particularly with the opening of continental resorts, to attract tourists from America.

In view of the successful years which the hoteliers have had since the end of the war, they have made profits which, I believe, many of them are prepared to plough back, and are in process of ploughing back into providing more up-to-date amenities and more attractive accommodation than was provided in the past. It is generally understood in the country that if we are to attract tourists we must provide them with facilities which they expect and which they will get elsewhere if they do not get them here.

I listened to-day to the criticism voiced against the Fine Gael Party, particularly by the Leader of the Opposition, and the objections which he had to the capital Budget as well as to the form in which it was presented, mainly, I suppose, because it was presented, as he described it, by a Fine Gael Minister. Normally he would have expected that if a Budget of this sort was presented by anybody else, the first persons to attack it would be the Fine Gael Party. He went on to assert that the Fine Gael Party was in the mud, that its name was in low water. All I have to say to that is that if we can continue to win, in association with the other Parties represented in the inter-Party Government, by-elections such as the recent one in Donegal, then it is a pleasant place to be in the mud.

I believe that the country is satisfied with the present Government; that it is satisfied with the development that has taken place and it will in time realise that the present form of the Estimates is one which should have been adopted before and which will be looked on as the proper system of accounting and the proper system under which capital development in the country should take place. I believe that it will be appreciated that the form in which the Estimates are presented is more appropriate, particularly when the gigantic nature of the capital investment at present being undertaken is recognised.

In the course of the Deputy's observations, he said that Fianna Fáil always favoured development. He instanced a number of projects which they favoured and which they continue to regard as desirable. In the course of his remarks he criticised Clann na Poblachta and other Parties, saying they thought it was possible to go more quickly, but that Fianna Fáil knew from experience that you could only do certain things. He omitted to inform the House that two of the most successful enterprises in the country, two of the projects which are good examples of State enterprise or of schemes promoted by the State, were started by the present Minister for Finance when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce.

It is no harm to recall just a phrase or two which Deputy MacEntee used before Fianna Fáil assumed responsibility for these two schemes. He spoke in Tallaght, and was reported in the Irish Independent of 14th December, 1931. He said that the Government had squandered £14,000,000 on the Army, £10,000,000 on the Shannon scheme, and £2,000,000 on sugar and beet. One of the criticisms which the Opposition has voiced against this Government is that the Defence Estimates are not big enough, but we will leave that aside for the moment. Two of the schemes which Deputy MacEntee criticised at that time are schemes which, I believe, everyone in the country realises have proved of immense benefit; in fact, from the point of view of the nation it is difficult to assess the value of the Shannon scheme or the sugar beet scheme. The only criticism which Deputy Lemass has offered about the Shannon scheme or about other Electricity Supply Board schemes is that they are not going fast enough.

I believe anyone who has examined the position, and who appreciates the situation both during and since the war, must realise that the sugar beet scheme is of immense benefit. It was essential to have it started, and it is to the credit of the Fianna Fáil Party that they extended it. These are two schemes which, in earlier years, the Fianna Fáil Party, when in opposition, criticised. I believe the only drawback with regard to the electricity supply scheme is that it has not been as rapid as all Parties would like. Everyone who has had experience of the benefits which flow from electrification from the point of view of industry, and possibly more so from the point of view of agriculture, will realise that a rapid extension of rural electrification is desirable.

When we come to consider the nature of this capital and supply Budget, I think it is worth while examining what projects are under consideration and what projects money is being spent upon. This year it is proposed to spend £3,100,000 on the land rehabilitation scheme. I listened a short time ago to Deputy Cogan speaking on the need for capitalising agriculture, developing land that is not up to optimum production. I believe that everyone agrees with the view that we should develop our land to the utmost by providing drainage, fertilisers, seeding and all the advantages which scientific knowledge now makes available to the agricultural community.

I am sure nobody will criticise the proposal to spend £3,100,000 on land rehabilitation. I understand it is part of the land rehabilitation scheme that what Deputy Cogan referred to as marginal land will be attended to. It is not entirely confined to drainage. If any farmer wants to avail of the scheme for dealing with that type of land there is nothing to prevent him availing of the facilities under the scheme. If a farmer does not avail of it he can apply to the Department and they will carry out the work for him.

There is a big sum devoted to housing under the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act. It represents an increase of almost £600,000 over last year. I think all Parties are satisfied that in this sphere of activity the only regret is that it has not been possible to proceed with the housing of our people more rapidly. It is only right to point out that the housing programme is much more rapid now than it was this time two years. There are now in course of construction by local authorities over 10,500 houses. Last year the local authorities completed 4,200 houses. At present there are over 11,000 persons employed on that work. At the moment, by virtue of local authority houses being built by persons availing of subsidies and State grants, or persons availing of reconstruction grants under the Housing Acts, there are in course of construction, aided directly or indirectly by the State, a total of 22,000 houses. They include new houses being built and houses being reconstructed. The rate of construction is satisfactory. It may be that with greater numbers of skilled men and increased supplies of essential materials it will be possible to improve this position, but at least it means three houses now for every one in course of construction this time two years ago.

Another capital item which the country generally is satisfied represents desirable expenditure is the money that is being provided for harbours. Deputies of all Parties appreciate that not only are some of the major harbours in need of repair and construction but that many of the smaller harbours which serve the smaller towns and provide facilities for people in remote rural areas are badly in need of repair and construction. There is the sum of £340,000 for harbour development work. Two hundred and fifty thousand pounds of that sum are for capital work. Incidentally, there is an increase in the sum devoted to harbours of over £100,000. I do not think anybody in the country will object to the provision which is being made in regard to these items of capital expenditure, or that anybody will find fault with these schemes of development. Similarly, under the Drainage Acts and the schemes operated by the Board of Works, there is over £300,000 available for drainage and the ancillary works connected with it.

Now, the chief criticism which Deputy Aiken made yesterday was that this Government had no plan for increasing production and said the object of the Fianna Fáil Party was to increase production, both agricultural and industrial and to provide increased employment. I do not want to weary the House with extensive quotations from statistics to show what has been accomplished over the last 12 months, some of it over the last two years. In 1949 our agricultural exports were over £11,000,000 above those for 1948. Our industrial exports were over £1,500,000 above 1948, the figures for which showed a rise of £2,000,000 over 1947. Deputies who are familiar with the returns for those employed in insurable occupations realise that there are now over 200,000 persons in insurable occupations. The figure for December, 1947, was 183,000. I am sure all Parties are glad to know that right from the start of protection, away back in 1926, that the first census of those employed in insurable occupations in 1926 showed that there were 102,000 persons employed. I believe that the figures for last year will show that there are approximately double that number in insurable employment at the moment.

I believe that the policy of protection carried on by three Governments, irrespective of whether the Governments agreed or disagreed with each other on the form or type of protection — that the national policy to protect secondary industries here is one which has been more than justified by results. It was decided on a long time ago. I think one of the first Ministers responsible for it was the present Minister for Finance. The decision taken at that time to provide protection was continued by the first Government. It was followed by Fianna Fáil with, perhaps, a different form of protection, and it has been continued by the present Government. Anybody who examines the figures will, I believe, accept the view that it is good national policy. No one questions the wisdom of the policy of providing protection for industry. It is, I think, significant that the substantial rise in the numbers of persons employed in the last two years has continued. When we hear, as we did hear, criticism that this Government had not a policy for industry, or that it had substituted talk for a policy, one can say that the results are the best test of any policy. These figures have not yet been finally checked. They are only tentative, but when they are checked I believe it will be found that they represent an intake in employment over the last two years, which has been higher than in any similar period since the State was established.

In that connection, I think it is no harm to say that we have heard from Fianna Fáil that they had plans, and that they had programmes. One of the plans which Deputy de Valera mentioned, and which has an attractive cover, was a health scheme. Again, I do not know whether any plan is a substitute for a policy or whether it is a good thing to have plans if they are not put into operation. The plans that have been implemented over the last two years have borne results. There is now available, in hospital accommodation, over 1,800 additional beds. At the same time, the social services have been increased to the tune of over £2,500,000 for old age pensions, widows' pensions and blind pensions. The pensions for old age pensioners, for widows and blind persons have been raised, and at the same time the penal taxes on beer, tobacco and cigarettes have been lifted to the tune of over £6,000,000. Additional salaries and wages have been granted to civil servants, the Gardaí and the Army and to a variety of other workers throughout the country and directly from the State there has been an increase, by means of a reduction in the penal taxes imposed by the Supplementary Budget, as well as increases in the form of increased pay and allowances to the more lowly paid workers of £4,500,000. That is approximately £11,000,000 in the last two years. I think that however the Opposition may criticise or may find fault with the alleged inconsistencies in policy, the fact is that these taxes have been taken off, that social services have been improved, that employment in the country has increased, that housing has increased, that there are more beds available in hospitals and that health schemes have been increased and extended. I think all these are objects which the country realise are essential. I think, too, that the country favours them in so far as it has had an opportunity of expressing an opinion.

I think it is no harm in that connection to consider what has been accomplished and to put what has been accomplished against criticism on the other hand. I know that the last Government had a number of plans. One of the plans which the Opposition did not tell us about to-day was the spend ing of, I think, £11,000,000 on new Parliament buildings. The Minister for Finance gave a vivid description here before of that particular scheme — that if they could not get sites in the city they were going to the Phoenix Park; that if the people were not satisfied with having no Phoenix Park they were going to extend the park to Lucan, and if that was not far enough they were going to Leixlip. I do not at all know whether these were some of the plans which the Opposition did not get the opportunity of implementing. I believe that if the £11,000,000 was spent on that sort of work instead of increasing the salaries of lowly-paid workers or of providing increased hospital accommodation, and if the public had the opportunity of assessing and deciding which of these policies would be the more beneficial for the community, there can be no doubt but that the policy implemented over the last two years is the one which would find support and favour from the vast majority of the people.

I think that the form in which the Estimate has been presented this year is one which will enable the people to realise much more clearly the extent to which capital expenditure and capital development is being undertaken in the country, the extent to which we are proceeding with work which will not merely provide benefits for the present generation but which will provide lasting benefits for the community as a whole, benefits which it is difficult to measure in terms of money. Many of these undertakings will ultimately increase the level of production and increase the national income.

I believe that the form of presentation is one which will bring home in a clear manner, in a manner which the former presentation failed to bring home unless a person was prepared to examine closely and carefully the Estimates, the extent of the expenditure on capital development. I believe that the present presentation not only finds favour with the Parties supporting the Government but that, in fact, the Opposition favour it as well. It is quite true that if this form of presentation was not carefully scrutinised, if the various items grouped under the capital expenditure were not carefully examined to see whether they were proper to be met under that heading and proper to finance from borrowing, it could lead to dangers and that there are objections inherent in it. But the same objections could have been made at any time during the last 28 years. The same objections could be made to the items included in the capital end of the Budget at any time, with this difference — that it will now be possible for those interested and for the people generally to get an accurate picture of the total expenditure on capital development segregated from the ordinary Supply Services.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has given us a list of the services upon which the Government are going to spend more money this year. That is not denied. Nobody has, in fact, objected to the provision of additional money for any of these services. We do not even object to the proposal to spend in this year £1,166,000 on new Government buildings or £659,000 on repairs and decorations to Government buildings. We are raising as the first issue here a question of morality and, secondly, a question of policy. What the Government do now must somehow be related to what they undertook to do. That applies to every aspect of Government policy.

The Parliamentary Secretary opened his remarks by describing in detail projects for the development of the tourist trade. We welcome these projects. We shall have another opportunity of discussing whether they are adequate or not. But is it unfair to remind the Parliamentary Secretary and the members of his Party that their Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, as a candidate in the recent general election in the constituency of Dublin South East, declared as part of his policy that he intended to put a tax upon tourists? That was a nonsensical suggestion in our view. The Government were wise in abandoning the idea and, in fact, executing a complete reversal of viewpoint as indicated in the Parliamentary Secretary's speech this evening. But somewhere in South East Dublin there is a number of citizens who agreed with that suggestion, and who wanted to send into this Dáil a Deputy who would advocate it here, and these people have been deprived of the service which they thought they were going to get from the representative they elected.

Comment on this

I never knew that was part of Fine Gael policy.

Comment on this

The suggestion is therefore that it was the personal policy of the Taoiseach. It was not merely his policy, it was the policy also of many of the constituent groups of the Coalition. However, let us get down to a specific matter, the matter of Government expenditure. Nobody is denying that the Government are proposing to spend more. The fact is that they got elected because they undertook to spend less. Is not that so?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Less foolishly.

Comment on this

Less money. There was a specific assurance given by the present Minister for Finance that the cost of Government services in the year 1947, amounting then to £58,000,000, could be reduced by £10,000,000. When he became Minister for Finance in the Coalition Government he came here with his first Budget in 1948 and he informed the Dáil that the Estimates, which were the basis of that Budget, were not of his making and that he intended to go through them with a fine comb for the purpose of eliminating from them every item which could, in his view, be dropped. He told the Dáil then that if he did not succeed in reducing the cost of Government services by £6,000,000 he would not object if the Opposition described him as a failure. These were his words.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Quote.

Comment on this

The Deputy can find the precise words to which I have referred in the speech of the Minister for Finance replying to the Budget debate in 1948. That is on the record. Can we forget about the record? I shall undertake to quote no speech by any member of the Government made before the most recent general election if the Parliamentary Secretary will agree to ignore speeches made 20 years ago.

Comment on this

It is no harm to refresh our memory.

Comment on this

If memory refreshing is necessary I will undertake to do my share of it. We have a bill here for Government services amounting to £78,000,000. Can we start off this discussion by assuming that it is agreed that all the talk we used to hear about the cost of Government under Fianna Fáil, about Fianna Fáil squandermania. was so much eyewash?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Certainly you cannot.

Comment on this

That is going to make it rather difficult to reconcile the present attitude of the Government with declarations of that kind which they made previously. They argued strongly that under Fianna Fáil, when the cost of the Supply Services amounted to £58,000,000, the country was being taxed beyond its capacity to pay. They described the policy of their predecessors in regard to finance as prodigal and thriftless—in relation to a figure of £58,000,000. If Deputy Collins tells me that he is not prepared to agree that that was all eyewash, the figures speak for themselves. The audited cost of the Supply Services of this State in the year 1947-48, the last year in which the Fianna Fáil Government were in office, was just under £59,000,000. Then Deputy McGilligan became Minister for Finance and the policy of economy and retrenchment, as he described it, came into operation, and, under the Coalition type of economy and retrenchment, in the following year the cost of these services rose from £59,000,000, in Fianna Fáil's last year, to £65,000,000 in the Coalition's first year. But they were only getting into their stride then. In the following year, the year which is just now drawing to its ignominious close, the cost of these services was estimated to reach a figure of £75,000,000. That is not an end of their Rake's Progress, because they tell us in this booklet that in the coming year, the year commencing 1st April next, the cost of these same services will reach a minimum of £78,000,000. Is it agreed that all the talk we had about the cost of Government under Fianna Fáil, involving taxation beyond the country's capacity to bear, was so much eyewash?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Not at all. You are not even codding yourself.

Comment on this

Will Deputies at least agree that all the promises that were made of economy and retrenchment— the pre-election promise to reduce the cost of Government as established under Fianna Fáil by £10,000,000, the post-election promise to reduce the cost of Government as it appeared in the Estimates for 1948 by £6,000,000 — were all phoney? Will it be agreed, at least, that the promises have not been kept? If we could get agreement on these things, if we could have it established as common ground here that when the Parties opposite were fighting the election on the issue of reducing the cost of Government, they were hoodwinking the electors and that they did it successfully; if we could get it agreed here that the promises they made then cannot be kept, we might be able to discuss the particular matters that arise out of this Book of Estimates and the totals on the cover of it in a more realistic way. We can proceed then to discuss the expenditure that is needed in order to effect a desirable extension in the activities of the Government. We can under certain obvious handicaps discuss the question of the country's taxable capacity and discuss also, as I think we must at some stage, whether now or on the Budget, the question of the practicability and the consequences of borrowing for Government services which were previously financed out of tax revenue. That latter is, I think, the main issue that arises.

In order to make my point of view quite clear, I want to say that I personally have gone through this Book of Estimates for the purpose of noting any possible sub-heads in any Vote which I could urge represented an unnecessary expenditure or offered scope for economy. If I were Minister for Finance, facing the task of delimiting the scope of Government expenditure in this year, I would cut out some minor items like the unnecessary News Agency. I would avoid certain costs which are consequential upon the desire of Ministers to farm out their responsibilities to commissions. But, with the exception of one or two items of that kind, there is nothing in this Book which I would urge should be changed solely in the interests of economy. I think that economies may be possible, but I have not available to me the information which would enable me to pinpoint them.

We note the fact that the actual cost of administration has increased in every Department of the Government in the last two years. As we cannot see any evidence of increased activity in these Departments we may reasonably conclude that an efficient Minister for Finance would find some scope for economy. But on the most optimistic assumption as to the possibilities of economy in all the Departments of Government and cutting out the few items of expenditure which I would regard as unnecessary or undesirable, the maximum saving I could hope to effect upon the services indicated in this Book would not reach anything like £1,000,000. I want to put that point of view before the House because I do not want to be taken as arguing in favour of a reduction of Government expenditure merely to keep down the total cost and without regard to other consequences.

On the contrary, it is obvious that this Book of Estimates is in fact not an honest presentation of the probable cost of the Supply Services of the Government in this year. We know, unless the Government has changed its policy in many matters, that later in the year there must be produced to us a whole series of Supplementary Estimates which will represent a considerable inflation of the total bill. We know that last year, having been presented with a Book of Estimates which indicated on the cover that the Supply Services would amount to £65,000,000, we were subsequently given Supplementary Estimates amounting in total to over £9,000,000, which indicates presumably that last year's Budget, if the Minister for Finance's revenue estimates were accurate, must have closed with a very substantial deficit.

If the Government has not changed its policy in relation to transport, the policy of subsidising Córas Iompair Éireann, to make good losses incurred in the operation of its services, there will presumably be a Supplementary Estimate for that purpose.

I do not know what the significance of the sub-head of the Department of Industry and Commerce Estimate relating to rural electrification may be. If it has its obvious meaning, rural electrification has been brought to a standstill. I do not believe that. I do not believe that even the Deputies who sit behind the Government will agree to that. Yet, we see that there is provided for capital subsidy for this scheme a meagre £25,000 in this Book, whereas last year it was £325,000, and it should be £1,000,000 if the scheme was proceeding at the rate planned. We know, however, that that figure of £25,000 could have been £5,000, for what has taken place has been merely an arbitrary writing-down of the figure in order to reduce the total on the face of the Book and with the intention of producing a Supplementary Estimate later. We know that there is nothing in this Book which would indicate any intention on the part of the Government to proceed this year with an expansion of social welfare services. It is clear, therefore, that we have here before us a figure which represents the very minimum cost of Government services in this year, and the only observation I want to make in that regard is that I am more perturbed by the absence of certain provisions in the Book than by the magnitude of the sum.

In addition to the cost of Supply Services, the Exchequer will also have to meet the cost of Central Fund Services which will exceed £8,000,000 in the coming year and it will also have to find some further sum, probably in excess of £12,000,000, to meet the capital needs of the Electricity Supply Board, of the Turf Development Board, of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs for telephone development and of other capital services which have always been defrayed out of borrowed moneys. It is clear, therefore, that the total amount which the Exchequer will have to find in this year will be approximately £100,000,000. The issue I am putting before the Dáil now is not whether it is good politics and likely to win by-elections to make increased provision for various Government services but what the economic and social consequences to this country will be if the Exchequer draws unto itself from its citizens, whether through taxation or borrowing, in this year approximately one-third of the total national income. We have been informed that the total national income is now estimated at about £320,000,000. All the work done by all our people in farms and in factories—the total value of all the products resulting from their labours is £320,000,000. Out of that £320,000,000 the Exchequer is proposing to take £100,000,000, which is one-third of the total, for the financing of Government services in this year.

Let me digress for a moment to refer to that estimate of the national income and to protest most emphatically against the extraordinary delays in the publication of official statistics since the Statistics Office was transferred to the Department of the Taoiseach. The most recent figures we have here relating to national income and expenditure are for the year 1944. They are now six years old. Perhaps it will help the Dáil to understand my protest if I read one paragraph from the introductory chapter of that publication:—

"For the proper consideration of public policy during the post-war period, more detailed and coordinated knowledge of the monetary value and the real value of the national output of goods and services has become essential. These statistics are indispensable for the study of such questions as taxable capacity, social insurance, savings and investment policies."

We, however, are being forced by the Government to take major decisions bearing upon taxable capacity and investment policy without a shred of the information which we would need to assure ourselves that our decisions are sound. I think it is preposterous that the statistics relating to the population of this country, secured by a census taken in 1946, are not yet published. I should like to get some excuse or explanation, if one is possible, for the delay. It is, I think, futile for us to be discussing these vital matters of public policy here without having available to us the essential details to enable us to do the job properly.

We are only guessing at facts and, unfortunately, experience has taught us that we cannot rely with any confidence on many of the statements relating to economic and social conditions which are occasionally made by Ministers. If the Government have come here with proposals to change the method of financing the cost of Government services — to meet, in future, by borrowing the cost of various services which in the past was defrayed out of tax revenue — have they done so in consequence of any examination of the people's taxable capacity, of the annual accrual of savings available for investment, of any of the essential facts which they should have examined before recommending a major change like that? Have they any views to express upon these matters or are they, like ourselves, groping around in the dark, trying to make deductions on the basis of obsolete statistics or, as was stated here, going ahead any old how regardless of possible economic or social consequence of their actions? This we are told is a change of policy. It is devised to disguise the enormous increase that has taken place in the cost of Government services, under a Government that promised to reduce that cost and that it represents an innovation. The only innovation is that Deputies have been put to the trouble of adding up two figures in order to get the total whereas previously the addition was done for them by officials in the Department of Finance.

Comment on this

Is that the only difference?

Comment on this

It is the only difference so far as the Book of Estimates is concerned but, of course, it is a fundamental change if, as was indicated, that method of presentation represents an intention on the part of the Minister for Finance to base his Budget upon the idea of defraying the cost of a substantial proportion of these services out of borrowing instead of out of taxation. Let us be quite clear that that is what is happening. In so far as this discussion has revealed any clear intention on the part of the Government, it is that they are now going to propose to the Dáil that the cost of various Government services, previously defrayed out of taxation, will in future be met by borrowing, not merely this year, but in every year.

Comment on this

Capital services.

Comment on this

All the talk we have heard here in this debate about capital investment, about Ireland's need for increased capital investment, all the talk that has been going for some weeks past, in and outside the Dáil, about the repatriation of external assets is all fraudulent. It is all part of the camouflage which is being built up to disguise the fact that the Government is going to meet the cost of services by borrowing instead of by taxation. We all know what that means. They are playing for popularity. The speech we have just heard from the Parliamentary Secretary indicated clearly the manner in which this financial problem facing us is going to be presented to the public. The public are going to be told about the benefits they will get from the increased provision made for various services. They will be relieved to know that they are not to be asked to pay for them — that the obligation of pay for the benefits we enjoy in 1950 is being passed on to posterity. Why is it being passed on to posterity? For one reason and one reason only — posterity will have no votes in the next election. The Minister for Finance asked Deputies to scrutinise carefully the items set out on page 3 of this book, in respect of which the Government proposes to borrow, and to satisfy ourselves that these items are really capital ones properly met by borrowing.

The Minister for Finance did not give us a definition of "capital items properly met by borrowing". I wonder could we get agreement as to what constitutes a capital item for which it is legitimate for the Exchequer to borrow? I think we will all agree that it is proper for the Exchequer to borrow money when its expenditure is reasonably certain to create an Exchequer asset, that is to say, when in consequence of the expenditure there will come back into the Exchequer over future years an amount of money which will enable the Exchequer to meet the capital charges involved in that borrowing, the interest and the sinking fund charges which otherwise would have to be defrayed out of taxation. I think it is legitimate for the Exchequer to borrow to meet abnormal and non-recurrent expenditure where it would be deemed undesirable or impracticable to require the taxpayer to meet the whole of the cost in a single year. I do not think that it is legitimate for the Government to borrow for any other purpose.

Comment on this

What about increased production?

Comment on this

I am prepared to agree that in times of depression or to check a serious deflationary trend, the Government can deliberately leave the Budget unbalanced, fail to meet the whole cost of Government out of revenue and borrow to meet a deficiency in order to ease the burden of taxation and to stimulate trade. I take it that it is not being seriously contended by any Government spokesman that the device of borrowing for the Supply Services in this year is being adopted for that purpose, because they spend most of their time telling us how well off the country is under their beneficent rule. May I say to the Parliamentary Secretary that I concede at once that the output of bacon and of eggs is higher now than we found it possible to maintain during the war.

Comment on this

Or even before it.

Comment on this

Can the Parliamentary Secretary imagine himself coming in here and speaking on behalf of a Government in office five years after the war is over and saying that they were not better off than they had been during the war?

Comment on this

You were two years after the war and you could not produce bacon.

Comment on this

O.K. We admit the difficulties have passed and, of course, production has increased.

Comment on this

Two years after the war we were still on two ounces of butter.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary can take to himself all the credit he likes but he had as much to do with it as Chiang Kai Shek on the Island of Formosa.

Comment on this

You need not tell us that you had anything to do with it.

Comment on this

However, I have given a definition of the purposes for which the Government can borrow. It can borrow where expenditure will create an Exchequer asset which will enable the Exchequer to meet future charges arising out of that borrowing. It can borrow for non-recurrent abnormal expenditure. How many of these sub-heads, for which the present Minister for Finance proposes to borrow, conform to that definition? Borrowing for other purposes, borrowing in normal times to meet the recurring cost of Government services is not merely bad finance, not merely a thriftless policy but is evidence of moral cowardice on the part of the Government concerned. I think the real explanation of the proposal which we have before us is to be found in that term. However, the Government is going to borrow £12,000,000 for these purposes.

Let us take the case of building grants. The Minister for Finance said, in justification of his proposal to borrow for building grants, that, of course, we are all in favour of getting on with the housing programme — which has nothing to do with the point. Of course, we are all in favour of getting on with the housing programme but that has nothing to do with the specific issue of whether the cost of building grants should be met out of taxation or be met out of borrowing. We had the Minister for External Affairs giving us the false analogy of the individual who bought his house and arranged to pay for the house over a number of years. That is not the position of the State. The State is not like an individual who is buying one house intending to defray the cost of it over ten or 15 years. The State is in the position of a building contractor who is building houses every year and selling them at a loss and who is now going to borrow to meet the loss. There was never any question of borrowing against the sale value of the house. Whether the money was raised out of the Local Loans Fund or raised by the local authorities directly, the actual capital value of the house as represented by the rent charged for it, was defrayed out of borrowed moneys but in so far as the house was sold at a loss, the loss was made good by a grant from the Exchequer. This was a grant which in the past was defrayed out of taxation and should in future be defrayed out of taxation. There is no Exchequer asset; this is not a non-recurrent type of expenditure unless we are to assume that the building programme will stop after this year. Year after year the Government will have to continue to meet the cost of these grants. It will, presumably, have to increase its borrowing every year because these grants must increase as the building programme advances. There is no Exchequer asset being created.

Comment on this

The house is an asset.

Comment on this

There is no cash return coming into the Exchequer.

Comment on this

It is something of an asset.

Comment on this

Of course it is something of an asset.

Comment on this

They are getting the benefit.

Comment on this

The Deputy is missing the point. I want the amount provided for housing grants to be increased. The more that figure expands the better I shall be pleased.

Comment on this

The house will be there for years.

Comment on this

Of course it will, and the cost of the loan will be there. Under this policy of borrowing you are not avoiding the loss; you are merely passing it on from year to year. Do you not understand that it is merely a political stunt to decrease the apparent cost of Government in this year, to avoid increasing taxation until such time as some other Government will have to come in to clean up the mess you have left behind you?

Comment on this

Do not get excited.

Comment on this

Keep cool.

Comment on this

The same applies to all these grants. The harbour grants were met out of tax revenue before. Every time the Government make a free gift of money their duty is to meet the cost of that gift out of tax revenue. Why is it not being done now? It is not because there is any idea that it is better policy to borrow; it is because the Minister has not the moral courage to tax for it.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is a good judge of nonsense — I will give him first-class honours. To meet this policy, this policy begot of moral cowardice, of borrowing for services for which previous Governments imposed taxation, the Minister has to raise £12,000,000 and, in addition to that, a further sum of not less than £12,000,000 to meet the normal demands on the Exchequer for capital, for Electricity Supply Board and other development purposes. That means £24,000,000. Where is he going to get it? Has there been any examination by the Minister which suggested to him that it is possible for him to go to the Irish public this year and raise £24,000,000 on Exchequer bonds, and has he assured himself there will be no economic or social consequences arising from it?

Comment on this

He did not say he would raise it this year.

Comment on this

He said he was going to get it from the counterpart fund. How much will accure to the counterpart fund this year? Is there any reason why that information should be kept secret? Deputies know what the counterpart fund is. It represents the counterpart of the money we are borrowing from America, borrowing in dollars, and which we will have to repay in dollars, beginning repayment in 1956. If that money is going to be drawn on now to meet housing grants or land rehabilitation grants or other similar purposes there will be nothing going back to the fund to meet the obligation for repayment when it arises. When the repayment obligation develops taxation will have to provide the money, and it cannot be dodged then. You can dodge it this year or next year, but the Government in office after that will not be able to dodge it as successfully.

Some of it will be raised from other funds under Government control. The Government control various funds entrusted to it through the Post Office Savings Bank and under the Unemployment Insurance Acts and the National Health Insurance Acts. There are certain funds held at the present time in the main in British Government securities. I am sure the Minister for Finance has a keen appreciation of the consequences of transferring the assets of these funds from the securities in which they are now invested into Irish Government stocks. I am not going to elaborate on that point. It is for the Minister for Finance to decide whether that course is wise.

There are some Deputies who have an idea of the loss which might accrue to the State if circumstances developed in which the capital assets of any of these funds had to be quickly realised in order to meet claims. There are some Deputies who will appreciate the difficulty which anybody would have in selling quickly upon the Dublin Stock Exchange any substantial block of Government stock without depreciating its market value. There are Deputies who will understand the consequences of a serious depression of market values of Government stocks upon the State's credit, upon the assets of the funds themselves and upon trade and industry in the country which is, to a large extent, financed by bank overdrafts granted on the security of that kind of stock the value of which determines the amount of the accommodation given.

I feel sure that not even the present Minister for Finance would be reckless enough so to alter the investment of these funds as to make it impossible for them to meet sudden or large demands upon them without incurring serious loss through the causes to which I have referred. The balance, we are told, is to be raised from the public when the market settles down. What does that mean? What has unsettled the market?

Comment on this

This kind of speech of yours.

Comment on this

I wonder? There have been speeches other than mine in recent weeks which may have unsettled the market. Is that what the Minister referred to? I am only asking a question — what has unsettled the market? It is quite easy for the Minister for Finance and other members of the Government and Deputies behind them to decide to solve their political problems by borrowing to meet the cost of Government services instead of increasing taxation. It was the easiest decision to make, but it is not going to be quite so easy to accomplish it, and I think we are entitled to get some information from the Minister which would indicate that the difficulties of accomplishing it without adverse economic consequences have been considered by him.

We know that in 1949 an issue of £12,000,000 3 per cent. Exchequer Bonds attracted public subscriptions only to the extent of £7.7 million. We know that in 1948, according to the report of the Central Bank, new capital known to the bank to have been raised from the public in that year for all purposes — for Government purposes, by local authorities, by other public authorities and by all private business firms — amounted to a total cash value of about £16.4 million. The Government are going to the market this year to raise some proportion of the £24,000,000 which they will require if the Minister adheres to his decision to borrow the cost of these Supply Services.

If the State is going to borrow from the public anything approaching the amount which would appear to be needed to supplement what can be drawn from the counterpart fund or transferred from other funds under Government control — and we know that it can get enough provided it is prepared to make the terms of the issue attractive enough — then it is going to absorb the whole of the money available for investment and it is going to create a situation in which it will be impossible for any local authority, any other public authority or any private firm embarking on a new enterprise or an extension of its existing enterprise to raise new capital, or else it is going to create a situation in which these other authorities and private firms will be forced to offer such terms for the new capital they desire that will attract it against the Government effort to bring it into the Government funds.

Comment on this

More power to the financiers.

Comment on this

The Deputy can ignore these difficulties if he likes, but I do not think the Dáil should.

Comment on this

That is the profit motive again.

Comment on this

And well they can realise their power.

Comment on this

I wish Deputy Davin, if he has not spoken, would elaborate that remark. It is, of course, possible for a Government to confiscate anybody's property.

Comment on this

You coined the phrase yourself.

Comment on this

Who told you?

Comment on this

I am telling you that, according to the statistical information available to me, according to the report of the Central Bank, according to the Estimates of national income and expenditure published by the Department of Statistics, according to the Irish Statistical Survey, published last year by the Central Statistics Office, the amount of new money that will become available for investment in 1950 will be substantially below the amount which the Government proposes to borrow.

When I assert that the State can get it at the same terms, I am brought up against this issue of external assets about which we have been hearing a good deal lately. Let me express right away my view that a great deal of what we have been hearing from the Minister for External Affairs and other Ministers about our external assets is just ballyhoo. I think it was intended as a prelude to the announcement that the Government were going to shirk their responsibilities and borrow instead of tax to meet the cost of Government services. It may be that the Minister for External Affairs has merely failed to check his theories against any facts. Let us get the facts right. All this talk of external assets, and their repatriation, has been initiated in order to suggest that this Government is doing something that was not done before. I think the Minister for External Affairs has the political idea of grouping, in the public mind, Fianna Fáil with Fine Gael, two Governments with a dark past which neglected the national interest, or were unaware of where the national interest lay, until the bright light of Mr. MacBride's genius was thrown upon these matters.

If any Deputy is under the illusion that there has been any repatriation of our external assets let us get him disillusioned straightway. We know that the value of sterling assets in Government funds has increased. The figure of £4,000,000 has been mentioned. The only precise figure I have is from the Central Bank report, which indicates that so far as the Post Office Savings Bank is concerned they have increased by £2,500,000. I want to read this from the Irish Statistical Survey published by the Stationary Office in 1949:—

"In this connection it may be observed that between the third quarter of 1948 and the second quarter of 1949 the external assets of the commercial banks increased by 5.2 million as compared with a decrease of 16.1 million in the corresponding nine-months' period of 1947-48."

In case any Deputy thinks that that process has stopped, I will quote from the quarterly statistical bulletin of the Central Bank of Ireland for January, 1950, where the value of the external assets of the banks is shown at the end of last year at £266,000,000 as against £260,000,000 on the same date in 1948 and £261,000,000 on the same date in 1947.

There was, of course, some repatriation of external assets, but it was effected almost entirely upon the initiative of private citizens who were realising their sterling holdings in order to pay the cost of goods imported in excess of exports, to meet through their efforts, the deficit in our balance of trade in each of the past two years. It is a fact worth noting that of the total accretion of sterling assets during the whole of the war years amounting to £162,000,000, already one-third has been expended in meeting trade deficits in 1948 and 1949. Let it be quite clear that these external assets were used for purposes which created no corresponding asset here. We were just unable to pay our way during these two years and had to draw upon capital resources to enable us to do it

However, the facts which I want to get over are slightly different. The first fact which I do not think will be denied is that the yield of these external assets, amounting roughly to the gross figures of about £18,000,000 per year, is part of the national income, part of the resources available to us to pay our way abroad, and that if these assets are utilised in any way which does not create a corresponding asset here, and which does not enable us to reduce our imports or to increase our exports in a corresponding degree, then the only consequence of their repatriation will be a reduction in our capacity to pay our way, and by that I mean a lowering of the standard of living of our people and a lessening of our capacity to maintain them in employment.

Now, the Taoiseach pointed out, in reply to a parliamentary question recently, that the only way in which these sterling assets can be repatriated is in the form of goods or services. That may not be wholly true, but it is true enough for the purposes of this discussion. When Deputies talk, therefore, about the repatriation of external assets, I want them to visualise it in the shape of ships at the North Wall unloading goods for this country. That is the only way in which we can bring them back. When Deputies talk about bringing them back, that is what they mean.

Comment on this

Even consumer goods?

Comment on this

Any class of goods. I do not know if we can get agreement upon certain things. We do not want to use them in order to buy goods when we can make them ourselves. We do not want to use them to go on a spending spree to buy any other class of goods in excess of our immediate needs. Are we to proceed on the assumption that there is something undesirable about having assets abroad and that we should get rid of them as quickly as possible, even if we are to do it wastefully? If we are to utilise them for the national benefit we must do so only for the purchase of plant and equipment which will increase our productivity.

Now, I want to assert that all the proposals of the Minister for Finance in relation to borrowing to meet the cost of the Supplies Services, and of utilising for this purpose funds under Government control now invested in British Government stocks, will not repatriate one penny of our external assets and is far more likely to add to them.

Let us consider what happens when the Government sell some British Government stock in which some of its funds are now invested and transfer the proceeds of the sale into a loan to the Government. Money becomes available to the Government because these sterling assets are sold and that money is paid out through the Government Supply Services, to officials and workers throughout the country and, inevitably, it comes back into the banking system and must reappear in the form of an increase in the sterling assets of the banking system. It cannot appear in any other way. The only way to repatriate them is in the form of goods. If the effect of Government borrowing upon the scale now contemplated is to dry up ordinary commercial enterprise, to make it impossible for business firms or other borrowers to raise money in the Irish market, money that might be utilised in the purchase of capital equipment abroad, then the net result of the whole transaction may well be an increase in our sterling assets and not a decrease. That increase took place last year. It will take place on an expanding scale this year if this nonsensical policy of the Government is pursued.

I submit these observations as indicating some of the possible economic consequences of the policy the Government are proposing to follow. Have the Government considered these matters? Do Deputies not think it reasonable to expect that a Minister for Finance coming with this extraordinary innovation in Government finance to the House would have elaborated the views of the Government concerning it and its consequences? Did we get from the Minister the slightest suggestion that the Government had considered all the ramifications of the course they are now proposing to adopt?

The importation of production goods in 1949 represented about £14,500,000 of the total imports in that year and probably the whole of that volume of production goods could have been financed out of savings arising in the normal course in that period. Again, that reinforces my argument that borrowing for Government purposes, even though the borrowing does appear to involve the sale of sterling assts from Government funds, cannot in itself alter the total of our external assets in the least and can indirectly, as I said, have the consequence of expanding it.

There is one further point which I want to make in this regard. The Minister for External Affairs and some other Ministers have been making speeches which appear to suggest that the Government contemplates doing something in relation either to the currency laws or to the reorganisation of the banking system. Do they intena to do anything about it? Even the Minister for Finance must surely realise the adverse consequences to the nation and the problems created by himself, in a year in which he has to undertake substantial borrowing, of leaving statements of that kind in the air without following them up by a precise indication of what the Government are going to do, if anything. We may regard, and I personally do regard, the observations of the Minister for External Affairs as indicative of a very shallow view of our financial problems.

Comment on this

You cannot do everything at once.

Comment on this

I agree. What I want to know is, what is going to be done? I think that it is undesirable from every point of view, from the public point of view or the Government point of view, to have statements of that kind made by a Minister unless they are a prelude to action by the Government. It is inevitable that anxieties will be caused, that people will be speculating on the possible course the Government may follow, that people may hesitate to invest in Government funds except on attractive terms when there is uncertainty as to the possible action the Government may take in relation to the currency or to the banking system.

If the Minister does in fact intend to go to the public for a loan this year, then before he does it he must say precisely what the Government intend to do or, if the Government intend to do nothing, he must say that also. It is playing with the serious problems confronting the people to have speeches made, perhaps for political purposes, perhaps as an indication of some intended action, and to leave them unsupported by an authoritative statement from the member of the Government on whom the responsibility for enunciating Government policy in that field primarily rests—the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I am sure you agree it is time to start.

Comment on this

I also agree that this is about the worst possible time to start.

Comment on this

When was there a good time?

Comment on this

The Deputy has me there. I know that some Deputies have criticised the previous Government for not having effected certain changes before the war. They have chosen to ignore the circumstances that existed before the war. Deputy Hickey, I think, will recollect the internal conditions that prevailed during the days of the so-called economic war and the difficulties the Government would have had then in effecting changes of that character. He will also, perhaps, remember because this discussion has followed upon the devaluation of the £, which in turn enhanced the stability of the dollar, that in the middle of our pre-war term of office, in 1936, it was the dollar which was devalued, devalued 50 per cent. in one stroke, and that at that time the only stable currency in the world appeared to be sterling.

There is one other thing I should like to say and it is no harm that it should be on record, that just before the outbreak of the war I was given by the Government responsibility for making preparations against possible shortages. One of the matters that naturally rose for consideration was the means by which we could finance imports from the dollar area while the war was in progress, and it naturally occurred to us to transfer a substantial part of the funds of the Central Bank into dollars or into gold, a course which would have had serious consequences at that time upon the international value of sterling, and it would have been, in any event, a rather difficult operation to conclude. However, the British authorities, being anxious to prevent any developments that might appear to suggest a run on sterling, discussed our needs with us and they entered into an arrangement with us, in consideration of our not taking the course we were contemplating, agreeing to maintain here the same type of exchange control that they considered necessary during the war. They undertook to provide during the whole of the period of the war all the dollars we required to meet essential imports from the dollar area.

Comment on this

By their consent.

Comment on this

And they fulfilled that undertaking faithfully.

Comment on this

Of course, they did.

Comment on this

In consequence of that undertaking we had made available to us dollar exchange far in excess of anything we could have accumulated for ourselves in the pre-war years and the arrangement lasted until the convertibility of sterling was restored for a brief period in 1947.

Comment on this

In other words, the Bank of England was our boss during that time.

Comment on this

It was also our friend. I am quite prepared to discuss these matters fully with the Deputy, but I think this is hardly the appropriate occasion for such a discussion. It is obvious to everybody that our position is onerous at the present time. We would much prefer to have a means of escape from the present situation. It is unrealistic, however, to suggest that there is an easy means of escape.

There is not. It will be some considerable time before we can effect any fundamental reorganisation; but let me say that the last stage in the transformation that the Deputy desires will be the amendment of our currency Acts. Long before that stage is reached we shall have to deal with the situation that five of our commercial banks have their head offices outside the country, that there is no active capital market, and no money market worth talking about. These are the deficiencies which truly represent the weakness of our position and the remedying of these deficiencies will be a far more difficult operation than will any verbal changes in our currency laws.

Comment on this

You dodged it for 16 years.

Comment on this

No. At no time during the period we were in office did we consider it to be in the national interest to effect a change. But circumstances have changed since then.

Comment on this

They have changed.

Comment on this

Exactly. There is now upon the Opposition Benches a Party which will not criticise any proposition the Government has to make from any other viewpoint except that of pushing them further upon the road of national development. Deputy Davin was in this House during the economic war when some of the Deputies now sitting on the Government Benches were wearing blue shirts, and he must know that it was quite likely then they would not refuse to avail of any situation arising from a proposal on our part to change the currency laws to enable them to bring down the Government at that time. Of course, in a subsequent period, when war did come it could not just be done, any more than it can be done now, and it is a futile pretence to suggest that it is possible to do anything.

Comment on this

There were not half enough wars for Fianna Fáil. You got out of them well.

Comment on this

You ran away from the war.

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

Deputy Lemass must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I shall sum up to this extent. We do not object to the expansion in the cost of Government services. We always believed it both necessary and desirable. It was the men who thought it unnecessary and undesirable who are now sitting on the Government Benches. We think, however, that the expansion in the Government services must be related to the country's taxable capacity. We want information, which we have not got, concerning the country's taxable capacity. We object to this proposal, because we regard it as a demonstration of moral cowardice, to meet out of borrowed money the cost of services that should be a legitimate charge upon tax revenue. We think that will create in the immediate future economic and social problems of major import. We think it will prove disasterous in the long run. If the Minister for Finance persists in this course, I am quite certain he will go down in history as the greatest disaster that ever befell this country. There must be some Deputies on the Government Benches who realise that as well as I do and who can pull him back a bit now so that he will face up to his responsibilities. Be assured that—and I speak now as a politician with some experience—if he does stand up to his responsibilities and carries them courageously he will get more votes than he will if he runs away from them as he proposes to do here.

Comment on this

This Vote on Account is a matter which should compel the interest of all Deputies. By means of this the Minister will be provided with the money to carry on the essential services in the coming financial year. It is to be regretted and deplored that a discussion of such importance to the country should take the line it has taken during the last two days. Most of us on the Government Benches are always ready and willing to co-operate in so far as that co-operation is consistent with the views we hold and in so far as a particular Government is doing something it believes to be in the national interest. I regretted the tone of the speeches delivered by the Leader of the Opposition and by Deputy Lemass to-day. The burden of Deputy de Valera's speech was that, in so far as it lay within his power, he would see to it that the Government got as little support and co-operation as possible from the people. Instead of discussing the Book of Estimates he devoted most of his time to dealing with the policy of his Government during the period in which they were in office.

It looks to me as if the Opposition does not yet realise that there has been a change of Government. Whether that is good or bad for the country is a moot point. Judging by the success that has attended the efforts of the Government in the last two years one must conclude that the present holders of ministerial posts have some little brains and some little practical commonsense. No matter how one may agree or disagree with the Minister for Finance, one has to recognised his ability as an economist and as an expert on finance. I am sure he has nothing to learn from the Opposition, even from Deputy de Valera or Deputy Lemass. One is at a loss, therefore, to understand the tone of the speeches here to-day.

This Book of Estimates merely asks for a certain amount of money, about one-third of the total revenue that will be required if and when the Budget is introduced. It is divided into two parts, one part dealing with supply services and the other with expenditure of a capital nature. There is no reason why we should spend any considerable time talking about the Supply Services because a large portion of the money applied to them will go in old age pensions, widows' pensions, children's allowances and so on. These items recur every year. Due to certain circumstances over which the Minister has no control, there is an increase this year in the cost of the Supply Services. In so far as the introduction of this Vote on Account is concerned, the Opposition choose to regard it as an "innovation", because it segregates for the first time the cost of the Supply Services from expenditure of a capital nature.

I have been a member of this House for many years. I always understood —and I have heard this view expressed on both sides of the House—that it was good policy to invest all the money we could within the country for the purpose of developing new industries or expanding those already in existence, and for the purpose of extending and increasing our productivity, especially in regard to agriculture. Nobody can deny that during the last two years the income derived from both agriculture and industrial production has increased very considerably compared with the year 1947-48. The members of the Opposition must admit that after two years of government by those who comprise the inter-Party Government, the results speak for themselves and that the revenue derived from our exports has never been greater. I think that that in itself is a fitting answer to the doleful prophecies that were made especially, I regret to say, by the Leader of the Opposition when he stated very early on that if he and his Party were not returned to power the country was doomed. Thank God, it is not doomed yet. It is very much alive.

Instead of endeavouring to thwart in every way the bona fide efforts of the Government, the Opposition should co-operate, not so much in the interests of the inter-Party Government as simply and solely in the interests of the people of this country as a whole, a very large section of which they themselves represent and whose interests they are bound to protect even though they are in opposition. They owe a duty to that section of the people they represent to give of their best in this House and, instead of indulging in the destructive criticism to which we have been listening for the past day or two, they should turn over a new leaf and give the Government a chance.

Everybody realises that things cannot be done overnight. Everybody realises that in so far as the expenditure of money is concerned care must be taken that it will yield satisfactory results. I think that the immediate needs of this country are: (1) increased production, and (2) production at a lesser cost than what it is at the moment. If this country is to get back to anything like a balance of trade, if it is ever going to set things right, the first essential is to increase our exports and to reduce our imports. I think it will be generally agreed that anybody who has given any thought to the situation as it has been developing during the last year must realise that our exports have been increasing and that there has been a reduction in our imports, thus putting this country in a better financial position than it was in prior to the advent of this Government.

In saying that I am not reflecting in any way on the state of affairs that existed prior to the advent of this Government. Several of our Ministers have already paid tribute to the work of the recent Government and the only thanks they got to-day from the Leader of the Opposition was destructive criticism. The Minister for Industry and Commerce referred to the progress that had been made in industrial production in this country from 1926 until 1948 or 1949 — a period of almost 24 years, during 16 of which the Fianna Fáil Government was in power. If that is not paying a tribute to the Fianna Fáil Government—when the Minister referred to the progress that had been made during those 24 years — I do not know what is. Therefore, I say that if the Opposition would seriously consider their position and do what is possible by way of co-operation with the honest efforts that are being made by the present Government to increase the prosperity of this country they will be representing more fully and more realistically the views of their opponents than they have been doing during the past year or two. I think that, taking everything into consideration, the Government has done very well during the past two years. If they are going to invest large sums here by way of development they are only going to do that after giving everything in connection with those investments very careful consideration.

I was amused with the tone of Deputy Lemass's remarks when he was dealing with our sterling assets. One would imagine that this Government was going to transfer the £400,000,000 of our sterling assets overnight. It was never the intention of the Government to do that. What they said was that they thought it would be a patriotic thing if we could invest some of our sterling assets here in the manner in which they intend to invest them. Everybody knows, as well as Deputy Lemass, that our increased exports have increased our sterling assets during the last year or two. During Deputy Lemass's régime they decreased for many years. It shows in a way that the capacity of this country to earn sterling assets has never been as good as it is at the present time. We on this side of the House have no doubt at all that the Minister for Finance has given very serious consideration to the proposals which he has in regard to this Book of Estimates and which, during the coming year, he intends to put into operation. Very few Deputies in this House like to spend money just for the sake of spending it. However, we believe—and the Opposition believed it many years ago — that it does not matter how much money is raised by way of taxation so long as that money is well and wisely spent. We believe it will be well and wisely spent if and when these projects which the present Government have in view are put into operation.

I want to issue this warning to the members of the Opposition and they may take it for what it is worth. The success of the efforts of the Government on behalf of the people of this country will depend to a very large extent on the co-operation you are prepared to give here along with the co-operation which you are bound to ask for in the interests of the people all over the country whom you represent. A nation divided against itself cannot succeed. It is all right to come in here and criticise but remember you have a duty to the country. This is the Government which is in power. It can only be put out of power by the votes of the people. You can have your remedy if and when a general election comes. Until that event, it is the duty I respectfully submit of the Opposition, if they cannot give active co-operation, at least to give co-operation of a tentative nature. Let us have less of this destructive criticism to which we have been listening for the last year or two.

Comment on this

The Vote on Account every year produces a very interesting debate. Looking back over the last few years and comparing the speeches of various Deputies on this Vote on Account with the speeches which they made in similar debates in former years, one can notice a remarkable change in the views expressed, particularly from the far side of the House. In fact the speeches of Opposition Deputies are very amusing for, where formerly they were very wild, they are now restrained and conservative. Personally I am satisfied that there is altogether too much make-believe in public life in this country and there is altogether too much tommy-rot spoken here and all over the country. The ordinary general public have the wool pulled over their eyes by a lot of tongue-twisting politicians who carry on this high-falutin nonsense. The ordinary people want nothing better than an opportunity to earn their bread in peace and honour and to see national progress maintained.

Since the change of Government there is a revolutionary outlook in this country. The old order of things has been left behind for ever and Fianna Fáil must face up to that. For over 25 years, we have had control of our own affairs and during that time we had two Governments, both of whom have now lost power. During that time we saw national energies being wasted in futile quarrels, emigration increasing, the work of national construction left in abeyance and the country generally marking time. We had the political Parties carrying on that tomfoolery and tommy-rot while the main national issues were neglected. Thanks to the formation of the Coalition Government there is now a new approach to things. We have Labour, Conservatives, Radicals and Republicans all joined together in an united effort to bring peace and order to the country. It has brought into existence the things we have been waiting for for 25 years and I would ask Fianna Fáil to try to grow up and to become politically mature. For the past 20 years they acted as if they had a monopoly of patriotism in this country. They were intolerant, cantankerous and contemptuous of all others. Do they realise what they cost this country in lives, in money and in many other things? They speak about Fine Gael and Cumann na nGaedheal. Do they realise that Cumann na nGaedheal had to lay the foundations of this State? Do they realise that that Party had to fight with one hand and build up with the other. Do they realise that certain members of that Party were shot down doing their duty and that immediately new members stepped into their place to carry on the good work? They forget all this now but we who went through all that do not forget.

I am glad to say that at the present moment the country is peaceful, happy and progressive. At the present moment there are gigantic schemes in operation which should have been initiated 15 or 20 years ago. We have schemes of land reclamation, drainage, afforestation and housing. We have a hospitalisation programme and a national drive to stop emigration and one of the main efforts of the present inter-Party Government is to bring about national reunion. I would ask Fianna Fáil to fall into line in all this great work, to stop the bickering and to realise that the country is sick and tired of it. The country as I say at present is in a happy mood. The people see our problems being tackled in a national way and in a big way. Agricultural production is going up and prices are steady. Why should the country be unhappy? Why should Fianna Fáil be so down in the mouth? I know — because things are good for the country. When things are good for the country they are bad for Fianna Fáil.

Social services have improved enormously. Old age pensions have been increased and the sick and infirm are looked after adequately. Wages have increased and housing and hospitalisation are being pushed forward. What more can a Government do? If this Government remains in office for a further three years, then we shall reach the position in which this country should have been 15 or 20 years ago. I say to the Fianna Fáil Party: "You have not learned one thing after all your years in office and you will be where you are for the next 15 or 20 years if you do not mend your hand."

I listened to the Leader of the Opposition this evening in a speech which was mostly a whine. He is now a great conservative but I saw the time when he was not a conservative. Deputy Lemass was just the same. We had a tirade of abuse, until he almost frothed at the mouth, directed against the Minister for External Affairs. I saw the time when the Minister for External Affairs was regarded as a loyal colleague by members of Fianna Fáil. They were glad enough then to clap him on the back but he has since seen the light of day. He saw that our national forces were being wasted away and he was man enough to change the order and to unite with other Parties in an effort finally to right the wrongs of this country. Now he is all wrong with the Fianna Fáil Party because he came over here. As I say that Party should remember that they have no monopoly of brains or of national outlook. At present they are narrow, sour and vindictive. I do hope they will examine their consciences and try to get a normal outlook on things, try to realise that in all Parties in the country there are some very good men and also some damned bad ones. I would ask them to clean up their Party before starting to make little of other Parties. Until they clean up their Party and get shut of the racketeers and hucksters, they will remain where they are at present.

Since the change of Government, the racketeers have taken a back seat, the smugglers along the Border are fewer in number. Honesty, straightforwardness and fair dealings are now taking the place of all the trickery that we experienced in past years. I am glad that I have lived to see the day when we can forget our differences and when men of different political outlook can come together for the good of our native country. This old country of ours awaits the best efforts of all its citizens; it needs only to be given a chance to raise itself up and to take its proper place among the nations of the world. Soon it will take its place at the head of all civilised Christian communities and will give of its best to see that the sick and infirm and the aged are properly looked after and that every man will be given a chance of working in his own interest and in the interests of his country towards an era of peace, freedom and happiness. That is the aim of this Government and I feel sure that every decent-minded, solid man with a sound national outlook will be behind them. I say to Fianna Fáil: "Examine your consciences."

Comment on this

It was very amusing to listen to Deputy Giles, particularly when he was attacking Fianna Fáil. It was remarkable, and it was very conspicuous by its absence, that he did not offer any constructive criticism. So far as I am aware, he did not say anything of a constructive character. He has not told the people why it was necessary for the Government to present the Estimates now before us or who are the people, who will benefit under those Estimates.

Going through the Estimates, one finds many disturbing features. Generally speaking, increases are shown in every Department, largely due to increases in salaries and administrative costs. So far as the chief industry of this country is concerned — agriculture — many of the things which the Minister in charge of that Department proposes to do are not, in my opinion, in the best interests of the people. For instance, we have a land project which will cost £3,100,000 in the coming year. I wonder if the Minister and those who support him will argue that that is the best way in which that money could be spent — the reclamation of bogs?

Have the Government given serious consideration to that aspect? Have they not considered another and, in my opinion, a better way of helping our people to be more productive? Would it not be better if we were to make the marginal land more productive? Is there any farmer in this House who will argue that it is a wise policy for any Department to spend £18 per acre on land when possibly the Department of Lands will come along in a few years' time and offer, as the Minister said some days ago, a sum of £4 an acre for that land?

Comment on this

What Minister said that?

Comment on this

I think it was the Minister for Lands who said that the average price paid for land during the past 12 months was £4 per acre.

Comment on this

For what purpose?

Comment on this

For afforestation — that is the purpose. Many of the lands now being improved under this rehabilitation scheme at a cost of £3,100,000 in the coming year may in the future, if the Minister for Lands is going to carry out his programme of afforestation, be taken by him at £4 per acre. That is the type of land that the Government propose, on borrowed money, to reclaim at a cost of £18 per acre. Will the Minister say that it will be done at less? I know of cases where applications have been made for grants for the reclamation of land and when the inspectors called those people were told that the cost of the reclamation would be £18 per acre.

There is another way in which much of that money can be spent to better advantage than by the reclamation of bogs and it is by supplying fertilisers at reduced cost to those people who grew large quantities of wheat during the emergency period. We know that from 1940 to 1945 and 1946, when fertilizers were almost unobtainable in this country, the people set out to produce wheat on land that possibly was not in a proper condition to produce it. That land was starved in order to produce bread for the people. In the years that followed these lands were robbed of their fertility. If fertilisers were made available at a low price it would be a much better policy for the Government to adopt. In the later years of the Fianna Fáil Government there was a subsidy of £198,000 made available to reduce the price of fertilisers.

Comment on this

How much of it was spent?

Comment on this

That money is not there now; there is no subsidy on fertilisers. That is one of the things the Minister for Agriculture has done—he has taken away that subsidy. Would it not be a better policy if some of the £3,100,000 was devoted to putting fertilisers into the land? Why is some of that money not used to provide markets for barley and oats? In my own constituency in Kilkenny there is a big proportion of land where barley was grown extensively but there was no market. The people are told this year that if they grow barley they will not find a market for it. We had similar conditions two years ago when there was no market for oats. The same conditions applied in 1948 and 1949 when there was no market for potatoes. Why has not the Department formulated some scheme whereby the people prepared to produce commodities will find a market for them, and stability and security?

There is nothing in these Estimates to indicate that the Government are concerned for those people who are prepared to produce crops from their land. There was a scheme initiated by Fianna Fáil under which a sum of £50,000 was allocated each year for the purpose of marketing potatoes. That £50,000 does not appear in the Estimates this year. That scheme has been forgotten. We also had an experimental scheme in Donegal for the production of tomatoes, and £100,000 was allocated for that purpose. Why was not that scheme continued? Was it because it was a Fianna Fáil scheme? Does the inter-Party Government believe that it was not a success? Any people who have been through Donegal and who have met those who worked that scheme are aware that it was perfectly satisfactory, but in order to give the Dublin people — as the Minister for Agriculture said, the people of Dominick Street — a cheap tomato the people of Donegal were denied the right to produce tomatoes at an economic price. They could not be produced at an economic price when the Minister would not find a market for them.

In that Department travelling expenses have gone up. I know the Minister for Agriculture has travelled all over the Continent and he has also gone to America. Was it for the purpose of helping our farmers that he went to those countries? He has been travelling through our country making wild statements. He has reduced his Estimate by £160, which was to be devoted to a consultative council. It would have been well if he retained that consultative council because then he might not make so many wild statements as he has made during the past 12 months. The administrative costs and salaries have increased, but the benefits that accrue to the agricultural community have not increased.

Let me take one item, and that is the price of milk. We heard during the past month or so of the Minister's determination to reduce the price of milk. What authority had the Minister to go through the country and tell the farmers that he was going to reduce the price of milk in view of the fact that, since 1947, the dairy people had a guarantee of a long term policy? At that time the price of milk was fixed at 1/2d. per gallon during the summer months and at 1/4d. for the winter months. The Minister for Agriculture, in order that the Minister for Finance could produce a good Budget this year, thought he would go down the country and deceive the people as he has done on many occasions during the past few years by telling them that he would give them a long term policy and would fix the price of milk at 1/-per gallon for the next five years, and that in order to further reduce the subsidy which the Government must find for butter production he would increase the price of butter by 2d. per lb.

Of course, in doing that he was carrying out the policy in operation in other Departments with regard to the cost of living. He was placing butter in the same category as other Departments have put tea, sugar, coffee and many other things. The December issue of the Trade Journal gives a number of items which prove that the cost of living has gone up. A table shows that the cost of beef, mutton, bacon, pork, eggs, butter, cheese, margarine, flour, tea, sugar, jams and other things has gone up. Members of the inter-Party Government contend that, in many cases, the cost of living has come down. Their speakers all over the country have to put up a case like that because it was by promising a reduction in taxation and in the cost of living that they got into the seats which they now occupy. It is by reason of the deception which they practised on the people at the end of 1947 and the beginning of 1948 that they are now enjoying the fruits of office. How long more are they going to continue deceiving the people? They did so deliberately in 1948. Is it not time that they went back and told the people that they did deceive them? How long more shall we have to wait until they present to the people a true indication of what the taxation of the country is?

Last year the actual amount collected in revenue from all sources was £99,467,000. In 1946 the collection of all moneys by the State amounted to £62,626,000. The expenditure in that year was £62,000,000, less £542,000 which remained in the Exchequer on the 31st March. In 1947-48 the figure was increased by £14,000,000, bringing the total £76,648,000. In 1948-49 the grand total collected by way of revenue, other receipts and other issues amounted to £99,467,000, and in the coming year, basing one's figure on the Estimates which have been placed before us, the people of this country are going to contribute to the Exchequer well over £100,000,000. The people of the country have not been told these things. They believe that what appears on the Estimates is the true figure, but it is not. It is financial juggling that the people are getting.

We have been told about borrowing for capital works and capital expenditure. Deputy Lemass pointed out that house building should not be regarded as capital expenditure. House building is one of the great industries in the country, particularly in Dublin. It is going to continue so, not for two, three or four years, but as long as Dublin continues to extend itself. We have people coming up from the country to build houses for those now resident in Dublin. The same thing will be happening in five years' time. People will be required to come here to build houses for those who left the country five years before. I believe that will go on for the next 15 or 20 years.

Dublin City has now extended down to the sea. Therefore, I say, borrowing for the purpose of building houses is wrong. House building should come out of current expenditure. It would be far better if there were no grants for the building of houses. The grant that is available for those living on small farms is not sufficient to enable them to build a house for themselves, but of course the white-collared worker in Dublin must be provided with a grant in order that he may provide himself with a house.

During their last year in office Fianna Fáil provided well over £12,000,000 by way of food subsidies. In the year 1950-51 these subsidies have been reduced by £3,370,000. The fuel subsidy which was in operation under Fianna Fáil has been completely cut away. That means that practically £5,000,000, which was being expended in the way of subsidies, has now been taken from those who can least afford to bear the loss — the poor sections of the community. Turf production has ceased and the subsidy on fuel has been denied to those people.

We all know that we have untold wealth in our bogs. Yet, in spite of that, the inter-Party Government last year permitted the importation of English coal to the extent of 1,250,000 tons. At the same time they stopped work on our bogs and so hindered the production of fuel that would be equally as good as coal. The people who had been employed in the bogs lost their employment. That is the policy that has obtained during the last two years under the inter-Party Government. The members of it were not hot in their seats on the benches opposite when they decided to stop turf production. Why? Not because they did not think it a good scheme, but because it was Fianna Fáil who had initiated it.

Comment on this

And who stopped it? You stopped it.

Comment on this

Your Government stopped it and you did not restore it. You stopped it and thereby caused unemployment. Unemployment increased in the areas where turf had been produced.

Comment on this

That is not so. It was stopped before we came into office.

Comment on this

We were also told during that period when you were out on the hustings that the cost of living was going to be reduced. It is because of the deception practised on the people that you are on those benches now. Let me quote some of the statements made by Ministers. Deputy MacBride, Minister for External Affairs, speaking at Carlow on the 6/9/'47, stated:

"It was his intention to provide subsidies on all food produced on a sufficient scale to enable the producer to provide for himself and the agricultural worker whom he employs an adequate family wage, having regard to the present cost of living and modern requirements."

Notwithstanding that statement, the food subsidies were reduced by £3,700,000. Has he carried out his promise to the people who sent him here? He also said:

"The subsidies provided should be sufficient to bring about a reduction of at least 30 per cent. on the existing cost of all food produced and consumed here and should be accompanied by a strict control of prices."

He also said:

"Supply all agricultural producers with fertilisers free of charge to increase the production of the land."

Notwithstanding the fact that that Minister is a member of the Government, one of the things that this Government have done is to take away the subsidy of £198,000 on fertilisers which was provided by Fianna Fáil. He also said:—

"Cease wasting shipping space and credits on imported luxury articles such as motor cars, wines, brandy, canned fruits, etc., and utilise that shipping space and those credits to obtain fertilisers and agricultural machinery."

What a change of front in two years! He was not, of course, in office then. He was looking for the fruits of office. Now that he has found them, he has forgotten the people whom he deceived and misled at Carlow. He also stated:—

"Food subsidies would enable the farmer to pay wages which would stem emigration. They would also bring about a reduction in the cost of living. Reduction in the cost of living is far sounder policy than an increase of salaries which must inevitably result in a further increase in the cost of living and an economic spiral."

Let us see what has happened since in regard to all these things. There has been a rise of approximately 10 per cent. in the cost of cement. Does that affect the cost of living? Of course it does. We have our housing programme to provide houses, particularly in the rural area, and I am sure that that has the support of every Party in the House. If the price of cement goes up, it must automatically follow that the rent of the houses will go up. If the people who get these houses are unable to pay an economic rent, it will mean that the ratepayers are going to be burdened. No matter what way you look at it, you will find that either the ratepayers' cost of living or the workers' cost of living must go up as a result of the increase in the price of cement.

The price of tyres has gone up as is shown by this extract:—

"It was announced yesterday (that is the 14th January, 1950), that as a result of increases in the cost of imported materials the Minister for Industry and Commerce has made an Order with effect as from Monday fixing revised maximum prices for tyres and tubes. The increase is equivalent to 10 per cent. in the case of motor and bicycle tyres."

Everyone must agree that cycle or motor car tyres are essential for the people no matter what their station in life is and, consequently, their costs have gone up.

We had an increase in the price of fertilisers. The farmer, of course, had to pay the increase, notwithstanding the statement made by the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister has given us a lot of gems, but that statement was certainly a gem. This is an announcement made on the 3rd October, 1949:

"Beet growers have been notified by the Irish Sugar Company that the compound beet fertiliser, which has been selling at £22 a ton, will cost £24 a ton as from Saturday last."

Speaking at Portumna Show on September 20th, the Minister for Agriculture said:

"Some people have expressed apprehension that the price of artificial fertilisers will go up. I am your Minister for fertilisers, and I want to tell you that the price of fertilisers will not be increased in Ireland by one penny piece in foreseeable time and that supplies will be equal to any demand you make upon them."

The fact remains that the price of fertilisers has been increased and any increase in the cost of fertilisers must react on the farmer who is purchasing them.

Then we have the question of porridge. Two or three years ago we had a surplus of oats in the country for which there was no market. A remedy had been found by Fianna Fáil when there was a surplus of oats before and there was a price fixed for it. But the inter-Party Government were unable to find a market for the surplus oats and did not fix a price. A couple of weeks ago when the question of an increased price for milk came up we saw how the farmers' representatives supporting the inter-Party Government voted against the interests of the people who sent them here. I hope that when the opportunity occurs the people would take full notice of what happened then. That was more deception and trickery. But trickery and deception cannot always continue and one day or other there will be a reckoning and those who deceive will have to answer to the people. I hope that day is not far off.

Comment on this

If it is 16 years off it will be long enough.

Comment on this

Too long!

Comment on this

Sixteen years was your period.

Comment on this

If we have to suffer as we have suffered in the last two years there will be no people left in the country. They are running out of it in shoals. Mr. Norton told us in April, 1947, that emigration would stop.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Tánaiste.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste. What is the position?

Comment on this

You are sitting over there.

Comment on this

The last year in which Fianna Fáil was in office we had a net gain to the country of 7,000 people. In the last nine months, according to statistics, 21,000 people have left the country. A commission was set up to inquire into emigration, moryah, on the 1st April, 1948.

Comment on this

It is your own commission.

Comment on this

But it has not reported yet. I take it it will report a week or two before this Government goes out of office. That was merely a continuation of the fooling that has been going on since November, 1947.

Comment on this

November, 1947, is a good date.

Comment on this

That was when the County Dublin by-election took place and the people were first fooled.

Comment on this

And when the commission was first announced.

Comment on this

Yes, and the people were first fooled.

Comment on this

Who was in power then?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil were in power, but the by-election in County Dublin started the fooling. That started the racket.

Comment on this

Not the racket, the rout.

Comment on this

That started the racket. I was referring some time ago to the market for oats. There is at the moment no flake-meal in the country and the people have no porridge. The farmers were always anxious to produce oats but they are no longer producing them because there is no market. If there was a market they would produce them. This year the price of oats has jumped from 30/- to close on 46/- because of lack of stability. One thing the inter-Party Government has given to the farmers is insecurity and instability.

Comment on this

That is why the pigs are running to the factories.

Comment on this

Quite so, and they will continue to run out of them.

Comment on this

They are running out as bacon.

Comment on this

Why are you not reducing the price of bacon then to the consumer?

Comment on this

It is being reduced.

Comment on this

Why has it gone up 2d. a lb.?

Comment on this

That was only for a week or two, and it was done by the curers.

Comment on this

The price went up.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Walsh is in possession.

Comment on this

I thought for a moment the pigs were in possession.

Comment on this

Is it not the first time, and I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance will bear me out in this, in the history of this country that bacon was dearer than butter? Is it not the first time that has happened?

Comment on this

It is only lately that we have had either and it is hard to tell.

Comment on this

Is it not the first time? You know it is. You know the reason why.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not invite interruption.

Comment on this

We have the best cattle market Ireland ever had to-day.

Comment on this

Who is responsible for that?

Comment on this

We are because the calves are coming up.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

The people have no porridge. Flake-meal, the basic ingredient of porridge, jumped to a new high record this week of 7/8 per stone. Even during the war period flake-meal was not as high in price as it is at the present time. These are the things in which the people are interested. These are the things from which the Government cannot hide. These are the things for which the Government will be answerable when they go to the people. The trickery and the deception will no longer help you when you go to the people. You are quite smug sitting here in Dublin, but go down to the people——

Comment on this