We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote on Account, 1950-51—Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 308–487 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I take it the Deputy is not intentionally addressing the Chair.

Comment on this

I am speaking to the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And supposed to address the Chair.

Comment on this

Through you, Sir.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And supposed to address the Chair.

Comment on this

We seem to have a new Chair here. A leader of one of the Labour groups, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, speaking at Tinahely last month is reported as saying that:

"He was pleased to say that since this Government was elected there had been no increase in the cost of living. The upward trend of the index had been halted and everything possible was being done to reduce it."

I am quoting from a report which appeared in the Irish Times on 7th February, 1950.

Comment on this

It is not the Irish Press.

Comment on this

No, even the Irish Times published it — the Coalition paper.

Comment on this

It must be an intelligent report so.

Comment on this

Who is talking about intelligence?

Comment on this

You should not, anyway.

Comment on this

That was the statement made by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs notwithstanding the fact that the price of flake-meal is now 7/8 per stone, the highest level it has ever reached. Even during the emergency it did not reach anything like that figure. The price of fertilisers has gone up despite the Minister for Agriculture saying it would not. Tyres have gone up in price; cement has gone up in price, and costs generally of other commodities have also gone up.

Comment on this

And you want to bring up the price of milk.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Certainly, in conformity with all the other things that have gone up. That is perfectly legitimate. Why should agriculture not benefit when other sections are benefiting? We are entitled to some remuneration for our work.

Comment on this

The farmers are doing all right.

Comment on this

We were told a few years ago that we would not have any unemployment in this country. I would like to quote a statement in connection with that. It is reported in Volume 105, column 847 of Dáil Debates. It is a statement by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Bryan Myles Brady Mr. B. Brady

Column 847.

Comment on this

I will find it in good time. There is no immediate hurry. We have until midnight.

Comment on this

That is quite evident.

Comment on this

The Minister said — he was then an Opposition Deputy — that:—

"It is an amazing thing that, notwithstanding all the bog developments, the increased tillage, and the increased housing activities, the Minister tells us about, notwithstanding 260,000 emigrants, we still have the hard core of 70,000 unemployed."

Comment on this

Have you got them now?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

As a matter of fact I have the figures here for 11th March, 1950. There were actually 70,772 people unemployed in this country on that date.

Comment on this

I think it represents a reduction of 12,000 on the previous year.

Comment on this

Yet, we are told we are making progress under the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this

Better stick to the porridge, Deputy.

Comment on this

I will try to make porridge of some of the statements which were made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

You are more at home with porridge.

Comment on this

In effect, the statement made by the Minister was that he saw no reason why this country could not find productive work for every able-bodied man in the country. We are to assume from that statement that if he were the Minister in charge and had the responsibility of finding employment for every unemployed person in the country he would have done so. But he has not done so. Peculiarly enough, he is the Minister who is responsible at the present time for finding employment for the people of this country. But it has not been found. Even though we are able to export over 20,000 people in nine months — against the fact that Fianna Fáil brought back 7,000 — we still have 70,000 unemployed. I know that representations have been made to the Minister from many counties to start new industries. For instance, he has been asked to start a cement factory in my constituency in Kilkenny. He has not done it. It would give employment to 150 or 200 people, possibly, of the 70,000 unemployed. I suppose he is waiting for this new council he has set up to examine the details in connection with that factory.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is something of a detail and it might be demanded by other Deputies for other counties. It is not general policy.

Comment on this

The fact remains that it has not been started in Kilkenny nor in any other county as far as I know. We must not forget that it will provide employment for some of the 70,000 who are unemployed.

Another very peculiar feature in the country since this Government came into office is that the number of people now employed on the land has steadily decreased. We find that in the year 1946, which was the last year of the emergency, 519,634 people were employed on the land. In 1947, which was a very bad year — we all remember the bad harvest, and so forth — the number had fallen to 507,568. In 1948, the first year the inter-Party Government were in office, the figure dwindled to 499, 542.

I should like to know and I am sure I will find out later the number of people now employed on the land particularly as a result of the policy laid down by the present Minister for Agriculture, that is, the grass policy. Possibly later on I shall have an opportunity of putting my point before the Minister as to which is the better policy for employment on the land — the production of food or the production of cheap meat for Britain. That seems to be the policy the Minister has in mind now — cheap food. As recently as last week or the week before he suggested that we might export some of our surplus butter. I would impress on the House that the price of butter in England is 1/8 per lb. and the price of butter in this country is 2/8 per lb. It would mean, therefore, that we would have to subsidise the butter we would be sending across to Britain. That also would be in conformity with the policy here since 1948 of giving cheap food to the British. We gave them cheap beef. We could have had a better price from the Belgians or the Germans but we would not give it to them. We had an old and valued customer and we had to supply that customer with cheap food. That, possibly, is still going to be the policy of the present Minister while he is there. Those people who fed the country during the war, when this country was unable to get foodstuffs from outside, are now being denied their inalienable right of getting a market for their produce. I refer now to the people growing barley, oats, flax and potatoes. Only two crops are guaranteed in this country as far as agriculture is concerned and those two crops which are guaranteed were initiated by Fianna Fáil — wheat and beet. Notwithstanding all the Minister for Agriculture had to say regarding wheat and beet in the past, he has to swallow and had to swallow——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is not an Estimate for Agriculture.

Comment on this

But the Minister for Agriculture is looming very large in it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Evidently, but it is not the Vote. He is looming very much in the Deputy's speech.

Comment on this

He has a very big sum here — £15,000,000 of the taxpayers' money — to expend for agriculture in the coming year, and subsidies.

Comment on this

He is a good Minister for Agriculture, more so than any Minister for Agriculture who ever came before him in this country

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is in possession.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture has £15,000,000 under his command in the coming year. I do not know why, but apparently it was good policy on the part of the Government to transfer the food subsidies from the Department of Industry and Commerce. No man, I am sure, can deal with them better than the Minister for Agriculture. If he deals with them in the same way as he has dealt with the butter question he will certainly be able to relieve the taxpayer of a lot of the money now going in subsidy.

Comment on this

Will you give him credit for anything?

Comment on this

£10 for a calf.

Comment on this

Oats from the Argentine and spuds from Amsterdam.

Comment on this

He is not killing calves.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Ó Briain understand what I said? He is not killing calves any longer.

Comment on this

There is no necessity. Has he not found a good market for them? If Deputy Fagan were in the House now he would tell us about the good price that obtains for calves. He is very fond of the high price paid for calves now — very fond of it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is in possession and he should be given a hearing.

Comment on this

The principal increases, so far as I can see, in the Estimates are for salaries and administrative purposes. The Minister for Education, speaking at Callan, County Kilkenny, on 30th January, 1948, stated that one of the first things Fine Gael would do if they were returned to office — of course he did not think at the time that they would be returned to office——

Comment on this

Neither did you.

Comment on this

And they were not.

Comment on this

Oh!

Comment on this

The Minister for Education said at Callan in January, 1948, that Fine Gael proposed as a first step that the expenditure of every Government Department should be rationed. Has that been done?

Comment on this

The ration was increased.

Comment on this

The expenditure in every Department was increased and it has continued to increase. The Department of Agriculture is up by £27,000 plus the travelling expenses, which are up by £9,000. If we went to the Book of Estimates we would find, I am sure, for the Department of External Affairs that the wine bill has gone up by about £60,000 or £70,000. I do not know what the increase is in travelling expenses.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell me where the wine bill is referred to? The Deputy had better get back to porridge. He is more at home on that.

Comment on this

The Minister for External Affairs, speaking at Portlaoighise on the 24th January, 1948, said that another source of danger or corruption was the practice of erecting vast Government monopolies and State corporations. He evidently went and set up one himself in the news agency. He has followed the good example set by Fianna Fáil. That has been the policy of the Government — to carry out the Fianna Fáil policy. They have no policy. They are bereft of policy.

Comment on this

If it was Fianna Fáil policy, why all the attacks on it?

Comment on this

On which?

Comment on this

And why did a Fianna Fáil man join the board?

Comment on this

Join which board?

Comment on this

The News Agency Board.

Comment on this

What Fianna Fáil man joined it?

Comment on this

Robert Brennan.

Comment on this

An ex-civil servant.

Comment on this

And an ex-director of the Irish Press.

Comment on this

He was never a director of the Irish Press.

Comment on this

He was managing director.

Comment on this

The Minister for External Affairs has fallen in with the Fianna Fáil policy. He now has a monopoly and he can deal with corruption.

Comment on this

Robert Brennan will see to that.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Who invited him to join the board?

Comment on this

Are you annoyed because he accepted it?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

You should not cast it up in this House then.

Comment on this

No, no. I did not think a man of that type would join a vicious monopoly.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Walsh.

Comment on this

When I am permitted to speak by the Minister, I shall continue. The Minister for External Affairs at that time seemed to be very concerned as I have already pointed out, about the cost of living and about food subsidies. I cannot for the life of me understand why he, as a member of the Government at present, has permitted other Ministers to withdraw subsidies from the people who are least able to bear the burden of the high cost of living, the poorer sections of the people. Subsidies on food have been reduced this year by £3,370,000. The fuel subsidy has been cut away. The only people who were gaining any benefit from the fuel subsidy were people who are now relying on home assistance and on the St. Vincent de Paul Society to get cheap fuel. That is what has been done by the inter-Party Government for these people. Yet we have people from the Labour Benches and they will tell you what they have been doing for the poorer sections of the community.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Are they not getting 17/6 a week now as an old age pension?

Comment on this

And you promised them 26/-.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Is that not a good start?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Walsh would address the Chair he would have fewer interruptions.

Comment on this

It is a fact that in 1948 when these people were looking for votes they deceived the old age pensioners to the extent of promising them 26/- a week. They have not even carried out that promise.

Comment on this

And at 65.

Comment on this

They have not carried out their promise there either. They do not deny that they misled the people then. The Estimates with which we are now presented are also misleading the people. We have a bill there which on the surface sets out £66,000,000 plus £12,000,000, that is £78,000,000, but in reality that bill is going to creep up until it is £100,000,000 as happened last year when £99,677,000 was collected by the Exchequer. It is time anyway that the inter-Party Government should get away from the position that they created for themselves in 1948, be honest with the people and tell them that what they see in the papers is not correct, that that is not the bill that the taxpayers of this country will have to contribute and that in fact it is a misleading description of the amount to be collected in the coming year.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

In relating these Estimates to the progress of the Minister since he assumed office, it is just as well at the start to go back to the first Estimate the Minister brought in because I presume it is legitimate to ask ourselves on this Vote whether the Minister has been pursuing a consistent line of policy or whether we have something radically different at the moment from the viewpoint with which he approached the matter initially. We cannot doubt that he started off on what one might call an economy campaign. The Minister and his Party paid great attention to a programme which implied three things — a reduction in State expenditure, a reduction in taxation and economies, particularly in administration. How far has he succeeded in this? How far does the policy which apparently activates his approach to his problems this year, conform to that initial approach and if it does not conform, what are the reasons or the explanation for the change? In any event what is the effect of the Minister's consistency or lack of consistency on the affairs of the country? When the Minister came into office he found prepared before him a Book of Estimates showing on its face a total of £70,520,477. The Minister straightway cut that in a number of places by approximately £6,000,000. I have tried to ascertain it accurately from the figures furnished from time to time but, so far as I can find out, it works out at about £6,000,000, leaving the Minister starting office with an Estimate of somewhere in the region of £64,000,000. That Estimate was an omnibus Estimate, so to speak, for the servicing of the State. For that year, to make up his total Estimates, his Supplementary Estimate must be added to that, and that can be taken from the Estimates for the following year.

Incidentally, there is quite a misleading thing in the Book of Estimates before us, and in making this comparision there is no harm in getting the figure straight. In the Estimates presented by the Minister last year, in the long table, there are in the second last column figures given for the 1948-49 Estimates, including supplementaries. The total for the Estimates for that year is given in that column as £71,801,298. If I read that aright, it seems to me that that is, in effect, the original printed Estimates, plus the Supplementary Estimates. I think that is misleading straightway. Supposing we concede to the Minister that he commenced business, so to speak, as Minister, with an Estimate in the region of £64,000,000, he himself brought in the Supplementary Estimates during the rest of the year. Surely the proper comparative figure to be shown there in that column is the total of his own Estimates, not the Estimates of his predecessor, plus the Supplementary Estimates passed by him?

Let me, then, take, and I think I can fairly take, the figure which the Minister at that time wished us to take as being the figure representing his Estimates for his first year of office. I think we will find that his Estimates were in the region of £65,000,000 or £66,000,000, that they are, in fact, the total Estimates upon which the Minister based his calculations and policy for that year. Going to the Book of Estimates for this year, he estimated on the Book of Estimates for last year £65,406,570. As was pointed out in the debate last year, the Minister, in effect, after all the talk which his Party and he himself had on this matter, could do no better than bring in the same Estimates as he had, in fact, worked upon in the previous year.

We asked at that time where were the economies, where were the reductions in taxation. You can shift the burden of taxation, certainly you can shift its incidence, but ultimately the money has to be found. We asked where was the economy in administration, pointing out, in the case of the Department of External Affairs, for one example, that the cost of administration had radically increased. There were some speakers, if my memory serves me aright, if not in the House, out of it, supporting the Minister and the Government, who said: "Give us time. After all, we have been only a year in office and we had to adjust your figures and work from the baseline you gave us. Give us time and we will show results for our policy."

For the second time the Minister comes before us to-day, and what is the position? I am going to take the figures on the Book of Estimates as now produced, but let us note two things. Let us note that, on the best showing the Minister wanted to make, the Estimates for the first year in which he came into office were in the neighbourhood of £65,000,000. Let us also recollect that, having a year to work out his economy programme and keep all the promises he and his Party made on so many occasions, with a year to go he could come in and do, as many of us said last year, no better than he did the year before. He came in with £65,000,000 as his Estimate, and some of us said on these benches last year: "We will give the Minister as much latitude as we can; we will leave it in the position that you merely had an as-you-were Budget." We conceded that for the purpose of argument.

Notwithstanding the favourable trends that were anticipated, such as relief in regard to subsidies and all the other matters discussed in last year's debate, what do we find when we open the present Book of Estimates? When we go to the summary table, we find that the Estimates for the 1949-50 period, including supplementaries, represent a figure of £74,607,444. It will be noted that in the previous year the audited expenditure approximated closer to what the Minister had disclosed, or, rather, was disclosed in the Estimates, as being the figure upon which he was working. But during last year, having come here with a figure of £65,406,570, we, nevertheless, found that at the end of the year, by means of Supplementary Estimates, the Minister, in fact, budgeted for something over £74,500,000. In other words, there were Supplementary Estimates brought in in the course of the year in excess of what has been, I think, normal.

I, unfortunately, have not had the time to tot up all the Supplementary Estimates introduced, but it does appear from those figures that the net amount of the supplementaries for last year was rather in excess of what should be the margin for such purposes. It seems to indicate that the Minister, in bringing in his Estimates last year, under-estimated. Perhaps it was in an effort to show that at least he was not increasing the Estimates over what he alleged his Estimates for the previous year were, but whatever the reason is, the fact remains that it is patent he under-estimated the figure last year, at this time necessitating his bringing in further Supplementary Estimates, so that, in fact, last year, on Estimates only — and I am dealing with Estimates, and this is the proper time — according to his own Book of Estimates he estimated for more than £74,500,000 for the services of the State.

Even when he adopted the device in the previous Book of Estimates of adding Supplementary Estimates brought in by himself to the Estimates on the Book of Estimates introduced by his predecessor, which he rejected with great noise and with great publicity, the total of the figure which he estimated, even if you add his predecessor's Estimates to his Supplementary Estimates, will give you something less than £72,000,000 — that is, £71.8 million. That is an interesting comment. It means that with all the talk about economy in the services, cutting costs and squandermania, even when he takes his predecessor's Estimate with his own Supplementary Estimate and puts it in the trying to have it both ways, even with that device, when you take the total Estimates last year they are in excess. Finally, this year we are asked to pass an Estimate which in the total is in the region of £78,000,000, the greatest, I think, that has been introduced.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy objecting to the increase?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am merely trying to get the Minister's background with a view to trying to find out where he is going. By their fruits you shall know them. £78,000,000 is estimated as the expenditure for the coming year. Even taking these columns of tables as they stand in the book and which are very favourable indeed to the Minister for comparison purposes, they show a progressive increase since the Minister came into office. Even on the Minister's phoney figures for the year he came into office there has been an increase from £71.6 million to £78.1 million. That is what we have to face. Even the fact that this year's Estimate purports to segregate the same into capital services and other services does that affect that comparison. All of us concede and it is only fair to concede to the Minister — his course might have been very much easier had he in criticising such trends been equally fair and objective — that with modern post-war trends, devaluation and so forth, some increases were likely to occur in the period. I am not raising this matter from the point of view of throwing back in the Minister's face his own special pleadings of the past, but what I am concerned with is what we are to expect for the future. Rumours have been going around — they are only rumours ——

Comment on this

The Irish Press offices.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

No, I could give the Deputy the source if the Deputy wants it. These rumours suggest that we may have to face further Supplementary Estimates this year of a substantial amount. There is ground for apprehension when one sees that an Estimate of £65,000,000 for last year becomes in the total £74.6 millions at the end of the year. It seems to me that Supplementary Estimates of that order are a pernicious and a dangerous thing. It seems to me that it should be possible for the Minister and his Department in present circumstances to estimate the sum more closely rather than that it should be necessary in normal or fairly normal times to have excess Estimates of that amount. There are always explanations for these things, but the question I should like to ask the Minister — and I ask it objectively — is whether he can give us any definite limit to the value of the Supplementary Estimates that may be introduced during the year or whether we are to expect that they will approximate to the same figure as last year in spite of the increase we are at present facing. At any rate, will the Minister say that they will not be any greater than they were last year?

One simply making a case would be tempted to pursue the Minister a little further on questions of promise and performance, but the real net question for us now is how far we can rely on the Minister in this regard, how far, in fact, we can rely on what the Minister tells us regarding these Estimates, how they will work out in the end and whether they are a fair picture for the year. That, to some extent, is our problem. Numerous things have been broached, notably a social services scheme and apparently there is no adequate provision in the Estimates for it. What conclusion are we to draw from that? It seems as if we have the choice of one or two guesses. Does it mean in fact that no expenditure under these heads will be incurred or does it mean that we have to face a supplementary Estimate? If we have, by what method will the money be raised? That might be a question to which we could have an answer before this debate closes.

We are faced this year with expenditure of £66,000,000 on services other than capital services. Let us relate that to the Minister's own Estimates. Taking the view most favourable to the Minister, the view which he adumbrated himself when he came into office, the Estimate for that year was £65,000,000; last year it was £65,000,000 and this year it is £66,000,000. Therefore the cost of administration, of ordinary services, has certainly not been reduced. In so far as any suggestion is made that the increases are capital increases which will be met in a particular way, a way different from the rest of the Estimate, it is hard to see that any economy is being effected. Therefore, I take it that the Minister now finds himself in the position that all this talk about economy and saving on the public services must be adjusted in the light of present conditions. We now have these capital services. These have been dealt with pretty thoroughly by a number of other people and the remarks I would have to offer on them are merely a gloss. We are all at one now apparently in our desire to see investment here with a view to production, to see development here and we are ready to spend money on developing this country.

Comment on this

There is a change of policy.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It certainly is a change of policy for Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy ever hear of the Shannon scheme?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

During the whole long period, the Deputy and his Party voted against all the developments that took place here.

Comment on this

The Shannon scheme was the greatest capital investment this country ever saw. There was no greater capital investment.

Comment on this

A sum of £60,000 for yellow phosphorus was a capital development.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Deputy and the Minister will find some sorry reading from their own point of view from 1932 to the present. However, now that they have changed, we are concerned with the present, and, as I have said, we are agreed on the desirability of developing the country, but as to the nature of what is capital and what is not some questions may arise. From one point of view, for instance, the development of housing, hospitals and so forth is admittedly capital development and capital expenditure, but it has another slightly different attribute from that which will result in reproductive activity, whether agricultural or industrial. The trouble about such capital expenditure (which is socially desirable and socially good) in respect of such matters as housing or the building of hospitals is that, instead of, so to speak, producing as time goes on, they are from another point of view, a continuing liability. Take, for instance, the case of a hospital. There is the capital expenditure involved in building the hospital — very good and very desirable socially — but thereafter the maintenance and running of that institution will continue to be a charge on the community. It is certainly an investment from the health point of view and you will probably get benefits in that way, but financially you will constantly find it a charge. In the case of such an institution is it desirable to saddle the burden of the capital development of that institution on the the future? Would it not be better in that case, since there will always be continuing expenditure associated with it, to try to find the capital for its development more immediately in the present——

Comment on this

That is the trouble — like Santry Court.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

——and then deal with its maintenance in the years that follow? A somewhat similar consideration can apply in the case of housing because expenditure will be anticipated to occur for a number of years in succession. Is it desirable to develop in this respect by way of loans? I may have taken the Minister up wrongly, but I understood him to say that he is proposing to raise the £12,000,000 for capital services largely by way of loan. What capital services are involved? One can certainly say that in relation to some a strong case can be made for financing them by that method, but is that case to be made in regard to such things as housing? Having regard to the considerations which have been mentioned, it simply means that the future has to carry the burden.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government (Mr. Corish) Labour Party

Is that not right in respect of hospitals and houses? Would you not agree?

Comment on this

Apart from whether it is right or not, has it not been done in that way?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister is making a certain proposal at the moment and I am attempting to see where we are going in its regard.

Comment on this

And I am trying to see where we have gone.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The more you raise by loan and the more you proceed in that way, if there is no limit to it, the greater the danger ultimately of clogging up the possibilities for development in the future, or, at least, the greater that risk. Is the Minister not at the moment seeking to raise too much by that method? As I see it, it is borrowing from the future. I do not know if economists will agree, but one can draw a rough and ready analogy between the individual and the State, as I think another Minister did here. If an individual finds himself in difficulties, if he wants to do something, there is a limit to the extent to which he can borrow on his future prospects, as everybody knows. Take the case of a man who wants to get married. It is very desirable for him to raise a loan for the capital investment of getting married, with all its attendant housing difficulties and so on.

Comment on this

Such as building a house.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Exactly. Do we not all know that, in actual practice, that problem is limited for such a man by what he can bear, by what he can repay in the future or is likely to be able to bear?

Comment on this

And on what his security is.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If he exceeds that, the liability will pile up against him and break him. Worse still, if he incurs an over-heavy debt in the beginning, finds that he cannot meet it and tries to meet that later situation by incurring a further debt, he is simply going to run himself into an inextricable mess. It is a very naive thing to ask, I know, but cannot something the same happen with the State?

Comment on this

He would be a big fool to go into debt to get married.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The point I am making is: may not the State, if it pursues that policy, be a big fool, too, in the long run? That is more or less the point we are trying to make. Within the last year or so, we had two loans and now we are to look for more. Are we going to look for more in the next year and go on increasing our liabilities in interest and sinking fund?

Comment on this

If war breaks out?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I grant you that one may bank on getting out of difficulties in that way, but that is another story. Taking a reasonable view of events, if you go along like that, where is this going to end? I have here a statement by the Minister, which many people thought was reasonable enough, made in the Seanad on the 12th March, 1948. He was dealing with general finance and his approach to it, and he said:

"I think it would not be a bad thing to have the five Budgets considered as a series, not entirely disconnected as to speak of the one year as being divorced from another, but having the finances considered over a limited period of five years. That is a point of view which I shall try to make more clear in debates later in this House. I shall try to make some progress along those lines.

I should like to make that point of view even clearer at this point. I do think that the State is landed into unnecessary difficulties because it is tied to making ends meet inside 12 months. I do not see why it should not be allowed to go outside that period and, say, iron out the finances for two, three, four or five years following. If I see myself in these five years ahead facing two years of difficulty and depression and three years in which things might be easier, I think I might arrive more speedily at the three easy years if I eased things in the two difficult years by relying on the future to ease the situation. That is the mood that is on me and it is one which I shall try to work out."

It would be interesting to know if that is still the Minister's point of view. It would be interesting to know whether this year is to be the critical year and whether thereafter this process will stop, without increasing the load. The Minister's approach depends very much on easier years ahead. Is he going to get them? That is something we would like to know. Will the Minister say this is just a difficult period, a single separate thing for this year, or are we going to face the same type of thing next year, and so on?

That matters from the point of view of the credit-worthiness of the State. I may be wrong. I do not profess to have any deep knowledge of these matters, but the analogy with an individual does suggest something to you. If one goes on borrowing and borrowing without apparently being able to meet one's debts out of one's current earnings, or failing to balance one's yearly budget, does one not become uncredit-worthy? If I get a loan from anyone, be it bank or fellow citizen and I so adjust my ordinary day to day working that I can repay it in a limited space of time and in a definite way, I am likely to get another loan if I require it. But if, having got a loan — or, worse still, having got more than one loan — I fail to balance my own personal economies or only barely balance them and get for myself the reputation of a man who is already in debt, does not my personal credit contract and will I not find it much more difficult in future to secure money on loan?

Comment on this

Are you suggesting that your country is not credit-worthy?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am not suggesting anything at the moment. I am wondering will it be so if this situation goes on. If one gambles with the country and raises loan after loan, will we be credit-worthy in the end and will money be available when it might be wanted? Will we be in a position, without altogether overloading the generation that will be called upon to pay, to meet our debts if we go on as we are going? The Minister, as he has said himself, obtained one loan without difficulty. His next loan was not completely subscribed. That might have been due to competition and a lot of other things but nevertheless that fact exists. The fact that that loan was not subscribed was the cause of comments, to say the least, that would tend to damage confidence.

Comment on this

Which the Deputy is helping to restore, of course?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am doing no more than the Minister and I think I am perfectly entitled, as a Deputy, to look forward to see what the effect would be. If the Minister is talking about confidence, I have at least the right to quote, in this regard, what the Minister said about the Dublin Corporation. There was a body which, for the most laudable purpose, for a most urgent necessity, was seeking a loan and could not get it. What did the Minister say about it? I will read it now. This is from the Seanad Official Report for Wednesday, 26th October, 1949, column 131:—

"But when he comes to the attitude of the banks to the Corporation of Dublin, in its recent effort to float a loan, he gets into financial considerations of the private type. The view has been expressed recently that the Corporation of Dublin could stand as the most credit-worthy corporation in the world. Without at all wanting to depreciate the standing of the corporation, I doubt if that phrase is a good phrase—I doubt if they are that. At all events, they approached the private banks for a loan of £5,000,000 and, for reasons best known to the banks, but about which we can speculate, the banks informed them that they had decided they would not advance them the amount of money they required, £5,000,000 at that particular time, but they did say they would advance half of it at a particular rate. The rate has been questioned. It bears a good comparison with the rate prevailing for sterling investments. No doubt, the banks had in mind the question of the price stability of corporation stocks and how freely they are marketable at any given time and also how freely they are marketable if thrown on the market in any big quantities, and, having taken a view of that the banks made up their minds that in regard to the corporation they had alternative investments of a better type. One cannot blame the commercial banks for taking that financial consideration into account. There is a good deal of clamour that the banks should think more about the provision of amenities like housing. But the banks probably say that it is for some authority other than banks to deal with that. They would probably pass the matter on to the Government and say: ‘If you can improve the situation by some other method, maybe we could lend you the money, because the investment might become a more profitable one.' However, I do not think, at any rate, that Senator O'Farrell said anything against the banks of the type that used to be said about them — that the commercial banks were against housing. They are not. They have their own standards and we cannot object to their having them in regard to the particular proposals which come before them from time to time."

If I am damaging confidence, what was the Minister doing?

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am not saying there was anything wrong with it. I am quoting it back to him. If the Minister can comment like that, surely I can comment here as to the possibilities of the future.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that statement?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I have quoted that for the purpose of saying to the Minister that, if my comments here are damaging to confidence, the Minister has made statements equally damaging to confidence.

Comment on this

I do not see the point. There is nothing wrong with that statement.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am not dealing with the Minister's statement. The point is — if the Minister will allow me to make it — that, for whatever reason, the corporation were not able to raise that amount of money; that one of the considerations in that regard was the matter which the Minister mentioned; and another was, undoubtedly, the commitments of that body, and high rates.

Comment on this

That is not in my statement.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is not in your statement. I know that.

Comment on this

Do not add anything to it. That is a good statement.

Comment on this

There is quite enough in it.

Comment on this

It is not to be distorted.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

In any event, the position is this — and I think it is perfectly legitimate for me to draw attention to it — if we go on borrowing and saddling the future, where are we going to end? I am not an economist and do not pretend to be.

Comment on this

That is obvious.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

But a little common-sense often helps one in these things. If the Minister will tell us how one gets out of these difficulties, well and good.

Comment on this

I do not know what the difficulty is.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I forget the figure the Minister has already borrowed. He has already saddled the State with that expenditure, to be repaid in future. He is proposing to borrow more, increasing the total liability which must be paid some time. Am I right in that?

Comment on this

For what purpose is he borrowing it?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Leave out the purpose.

Comment on this

Cash down for hospitals?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Will that not have to be repaid? Coming back to what the Minister said, the mood that was on him was, he was easing it out over years to come. I grant you, this year is within the two years the Minister mentioned. Is the burden going to stop next year?

Comment on this

I hope not.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Therefore, we have a general policy of deferring these burdens into the future and letting them pile up.

Comment on this

Of investing in the country, yes.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Is not that what it means?

Comment on this

Of investing in the country.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is letting the debts pile up.

Comment on this

That is what investment means.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

How is it going to be paid back?

Comment on this

By increased production.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

We will deal with that now. Some of the matters that you are going to apply your capital expenditure for are such things as hospitals, housing and so forth.

Comment on this

Healthier people.

Comment on this

Let him alone. They do not count.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

They will not increase production in the sense of giving you a return.

Comment on this

A healthy man would not be better at work than a tuberculosis patient?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is not the point. The point I am dealing with at the moment — and if we could deal with it without side-tracking all to the good—is the purely monetary question that there is a burden, no matter what laudable purpose it is for. We all agree that it is a very laudable purpose and we agree that this should be done. The only question I am dealing with is the method of raising the money for doing it. In this particular case it is the repayment of these moneys afterwards that is the question-mark. If we go on borrowing and borrowing, what effect will it have on the State and what effect will it have on the possibility of getting loans? I think it was Deputy O'Leary who said: "Wait for another war" or "What if another war comes?" Perhaps that is a point of view. Surely what that would mean, if it means anything, would be simply this, bank on an emergency, let us pile up the debt, then, when a crisis comes, we can wipe out the debt, and the people who are owed the money in this regard can go hang for it.

Comment on this

He means, if war comes, money could be raised then. That is his point.

Comment on this

How do you know what he means?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If war came, money could be raised then! That brings us to this matter that we have been discussing in the past, called inflation.

Comment on this

You raised £7,000,000 in the emergency.

Comment on this

And paid it back.

Comment on this

You did not.

Comment on this

Out of taxation.

Comment on this

Not at all. A good deal of debt piled up.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Could we hear Deputy de Valera, without interruption?

Comment on this

Paid out of Sinn Fein funds.

Comment on this

He is beating the clock.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If we had a load of debt already, I doubt if we would be in any better position than if we came into it clear. I do not want to complicate the argument by that. The essential point is that here, on top of a loan, and a loan that was not completely subscribed, the Minister is apparently going to seek further loans. It raises the two practical questions as to repayment and financing of these and the burden that future generations, if it goes that far, have to bear. It also raises the practical question for the Minister that this kind of thing cannot go on. A limit will automatically be called to it. Calling on your own credit, so to speak, floating loans ad lib., will ultimately bring its own risk in that the money will probably not be made available.

Getting back to the Minister's two years, even if there is a case for doing what the Minister has done up to this, the Minister is not prepared to say, obviously, that he will not go beyond this year and he is looking forward to easier years. This time in 1948, apparently, the Minister was looking forward to easier years. In March, 1948, the mood that was on him then was that he was looking forward to two difficult years and three easier years. Are the years in front of the Minister likely to be any easier is a question we could all ask and, if we do ask that question, quite apart from the amount of money that is in this Estimate, quite apart from the financing of it, are we doing the proper thing generally to meet that? A number of things will occur in detail on the Estimates but, generally, can the Minister bank on easier years?

Generally, can the Minister bank on easier years? What position is the Minister likely to be in in regard to his currency as a whole? We have had protestations about what is going to happen to money, about monetary policy and the desirability of doing this, that and the other, but the Minister has conformed to a very definite pattern which has been merely a general currency trend in the State since the time when he was Minister before. Are we going to face any further monetary difficulties such as further devaluation or anything of that nature, and if so has such a factor been taken into account in embarking on a system of financing by this series of loans projected into the future? I am simply asking that question because I have no means of being able to guess whether there are any changes. The Minister will have information if such factors have been taken into consideration in regard to the policy he is now embarking on in raising loans. In other words, there are questions of monetary stability. Have, for instance, the commitments that we may have to meet in regard to other State liabilities in the years 1952 and 1953 been taken into account? It would be interesting to have an answer to these questions.

Finally, have we taken into account in our estimate and in our allocation of expenditure the possible situation that may confront us in the five years that may lie ahead? There are two possible views in regard to that. A number of people are very apprehensive that the war which Deputy O'Leary spoke about may come. If their view is right, what preparation are we making in that regard? We talk about increasing production, but our essential production, from the point of view of enabling us to live under emergency conditions, has deteriorated since the Minister came into office: the production of food of a certain nature, particularly of grain, and I understand there is the question of sugar requirements. I understand that production of that nature has been on the down grade.

Comment on this

They are both up.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The trend in regard to that is not one that would fit us for an emergency.

Comment on this

It is up.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Take, for instance, the acreage under wheat.

Comment on this

The yield is far bigger than it was.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is a harvest matter.

Comment on this

We are getting more.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I will get the figures by to-morrow. Another aspect of that is, what about the laying in of reserve stocks?

Comment on this

Of?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Essential commodities. I shall deal with these matters on the particular Estimates. For example, during the last emergency storage for a number of items was a problem. Are we making any provision in regard to certain essential industries? These matters will come for discussion on the appropriate Estimates. They have already been referred to in other debates but we know from past experience that it is absolutely necessary that they should be attended to.

Comment on this

I have the feeling that the Deputy wants to get back to munitions.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

No. I am talking about food.

Comment on this

Phosphorus.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I will answer that.

Comment on this

Is it in order for members on the Government Benches to be keeping up a running commentary during a Deputy's speech?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No. Interruptions except on a point of order, are disorderly. The Chair has re peatedly said so.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

If the Minister wants an answer in regard to the phosphorus it is this: that little effort supplied the match industry here with material during the emergency period. It was originally projected as a defence expenditure.

Comment on this

Rubbish, it had to be destroyed.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It actually per formed that duty.

Comment on this

What did it cost?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

We have here the Minister's mentality — let a thing drift and have no preparation. At the moment he can scoff and be cynical about it, but when the crisis comes what will happen? If a crisis is coming what preparations are we making for it? The Minister apparently is budgeting on easier years. Is he, in fact, going to get these easier years? If a crisis does not come are the three years ahead going to be easier years? The indications are that they will not be.

There are certain lessons that can be learned with regard to expenditure that can be usefully provided for. I do not propose to go into details because these would be more referable to the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce. But one matter is the production of fertilisers here, the organisation of what one may call a chemical industry that would be directly related to agriculture both from a peace time and an emergency point of view. Such a project would be productive and would be useful. So far, we have nothing of that sort being provided for. Therefore, it seems to me that the Minister, in this regard, is merely providing for increased administrative expenditure and for capital expenditure of the nature of housing and hospitals and similar matters, but that he is not prepared to carry the burden himself and is passing it on to the future. I have questioned the wisdom of doing that.

On top of that, one has another matter to consider if the Minister is dealing with the Estimates. There have been complaints since the Minister came into office about the incidence of rates and, to some extent, the increase in rates has been attributable to the Minister's policy. In regard to housing particularly, that is a serious matter, because it means that the cost of living of the citizens in regard to accommodation is going up on account of this increase. Therefore, in that particular matter there does not seem to be any change in the Minister's outlook.

Deputy Lemass to-night dealt with the question of our external assets. It would be interesting to hear from the Minister how, in effect, the floating of this loan and the raising of the moneys as the Minister has proposed for the present year will affect the position of our external assets. I think Deputy Lemass quoted the figures. There is in the region of £260,000,000 outside this State. I can hardly blame the Minister for this, but the Minister's colleague has been suggesting, if not saying, that this particular policy of the Minister will directly repatriate those sterling assets which he so much decries. I do not know if that is the Minister's view. But there are viewpoints in regard to these assets that might be considered. In view of the questions put to me and the cross-examination I have been subjected to, I should like to say that I am putting these points largely in the nature of questions for answer.

We are agreed that the development of the country is desirable and, in so far as it is necessary to develop and invest at home, bringing back our assets for that purpose can be a very desirable thing. In making these comments, there is no suggestion that that should not be done. Nevertheless, there is no harm in looking at the facts as they stand. Much as they have been decried, these assets have a certain amount of value, particularly so long as the trade balance remains adverse. These assets do, in fact, earn interest and dividends which go to close the adverse gap in the trade balance. To that extent they have a value and, in approaching this problem, one cannot simply say that they are completely undesirable. If one transfers them or alters them, it is only proper that that fact should be remembered.

The second point is this. Supposing a loan is raised out of current savings purely and that you apply it directly to the purchasing of goods or services abroad, say in England. You get the money here; it represents your current savings. The claim attaching to that you transfer to the Government and you get goods which you import. In other words you pay for these goods with current earnings. That transaction, if completed by itself, does not affect your external assets. But it can affect them in this way. Supposing you get the loan from a bank which draws on its investments in England, then it would affect them. But is that likely to occur? The point is that if you raise it out of current earnings at home and use it simply to bring in goods from abroad, you are not repatriating any assets from abroad, subject of course to qualifications of the nature I have mentioned.

Therefore, if a loan such as the Minister purports to raise is to be used to repatriate our assets abroad, it must draw upon them in such a way as to purchase the capital goods that you are going to bring into this country, thus decreasing the assets by that amount and getting here at home the value of the assets which you have used for purchasing machinery or goods which will be used for productive purposes. That would be desirable, I take it, if it could be done. But what is the Minister up against in that regard? It would, first of all, result in increased production, if properly directed, to decrease our dependence on outside and so decrease imports, which would tend to close the gap in the adverse trade balance and would offset the decrease in these assets and their earning power. But it can go further. If that increased production goes to the point where you are actually facilitating increased exports, it further reduces the adverse trade balance and, if it succeeds in completely closing the gap and bringing about a favourable balance, it will start to build up external assets again. That is all very well if you can do it, but the question is, can you? In floating a loan, how is the Minister going to get the money? How is he going to get his hands on the external assets? I move to report progress.

Comment on this