We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Bill, 1949—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–164 of 325. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 35 of 1949 ›

In his statement on this section the Minister has made it perfectly clear—he has spoken in no ambiguous way—what the policy of the present Government, the State policy, is in relation to land purchased under this section and under other sections under which land is acquired by the Land Commission. He has stated that land so purchased shall be used almost exclusively for the relief of congestion.

Comment on this

Under this section?

Comment on this

Under this section, Section 10 and every other section under which land is acquired.

Comment on this

This section is tied down to migrants.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Minister has made it abundantly clear that persons who have not already land in their possession will have very little hope and that there will be very little use in their applying to the Land Commission for holdings. So far as the members of this Party are concerned, it seems that we stand here in this House to be lectured by Deputies on the other side as to our interest and actions in those matters. I want to point out that so far as some of the Deputies on the Opposition side are concerned, they are not too happy about this section and as to how it is going to operate in the provision of lands for migrants. Deputy Dunne speaking in Meath last week, is reported as having told his audience that in the past the claims of local people had been unreasonably ignored and that in Dáil Éireann he had questioned the Minister for Lands as to his policy. The report goes on to state: "It is in the records of Dáil Éireann that the Minister had stated that it was not his policy to bring migrants to Meath."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does this arise under Section 23?

Comment on this

This section I hold gives the Land Commission power to purchase land for migrants and to bring them to Meath.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

To purchase land offered for sale.

Comment on this

For migrants. The report goes on: "Local claims would be satisfied whenever sufficient land existed." That would, of course, be never. "He hoped to see evidence that such a policy was adopted. There could, however, be no guarantee that the Government was, of its own accord, going to carry out such a policy. They should maintain sufficient pressure to convince the Government that any other policy would be unwise and unpopular." That was the statement made by Deputy Dunne. He also told his audience that his trade union organisation of 3,000 members would be used to see that the policy now advocated by the Minister would not be carried out. The Minister himself has been in the habit of receiving deputations in this matter over the past two years from organisations in Meath.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This section does not deal with the policy of migration but gives the Land Commission the right to purchase land offered for sale.

Comment on this

I bow to your ruling. I suppose the Chair is always right. When the Land Commission proceeds to purchase land under this section it lays down three principles under which the land can be purchased—where (a) any interest in land is offered for sale and (b) the interest carries the right to vacant possession of the land and (c) the Land Commission require the land for granting new holdings to migrants. I want to make the third condition perfectly clear to the people I represent in Meath. I should also like to have an interpretation of the "the interest carries the right to vacant possession of the land". I am not a lawyer and I want to know what is meant by this term "vacant possession". Say that an owner of a farm writes to the Land Commission or communicates to them in some other way, that he wishes to sell his land under Section 23, that he has a house on the land and that the farm contains a certain number of acres. It is immaterial what the acreage is but if he has on the land, say, a house, a gate house, and another house in which workmen live, and he says that he is prepared to give the Land Commission vacant possession of the land and the house he lives in himself, does it follow that he must, if he wishes to proceed with the sale, evict the other families who live in the other houses on the land or will the Land Commission purchase a farm offered for sale in such circumstances? I am only asking for information. I am not suggesting for one moment that that is intended.

Another aspect of this section which agitates my mind is that when a farm such as in County Meath or the Midlands generally is put up for sale and some other farmer purchases that farm, he usually re-employs the men, if any, who were working on that farm previously. Under this section if the Land Commission purchases the farm to secure the holding for migrants the people formerly employed there will naturally lose their employment. In an area which is so denuded of its population as some of the rural portions of County Meath have been, it is almost an impossibility for those who lose their employment in such circumstances to obtain other employment. I wonder will the Land Commission take such questions into consideration before deciding to purchase land offered for sale in these circumstances. On the Second Reading of the Bill, I raised the question generally as to the compensation people would get under this and other sections. The Minister seemed to think that that question did not count for so much but the fact is that it counts a good deal. We are now faced with the position that in counties such as Meath, if local people wish to purchase a holding, they have the Land Commission as a competitor. I do not think it fair to people in the Midlands generally if this section will deprive them of their right to secure portion of the land offered for sale in these counties. It is all very well for Deputies who live in areas in which congestion exists to press for a solution of that problem.

The Minister told us in 1948 that the Land Commission was forging ahead. It has been two years forging ahead and now he is asking for additional power here to take the strings off the athletes' legs, as he said himself, so as to speed up land acquisition and division. This is the section under which he hopes to get an extra amount of land that would not otherwise come into the possession of the Land Commission for the purpose of giving it to migrants so that their holdings can be used in the areas from which they come to relieve congestion there. The Minister said he hoped to secure by this method at least 50 farms a year of a certain size. He has not told us what size of holding he intends to buy, but if we assume that the 50 farms will be occupied after they are purchased, in whatever manner they will be purchased, by 50 families, and if we assume that each family had before they came to the new holding about 20 acres each, then this section will place in the hands of the Land Commission about 1,200 acres a year and in 12 years it will give them 12 times that amount of land for this purpose. The Minister, Deputy Commons and other Deputies seem to think that this section will work wonders——

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

——and that it will give to the Land Commission a special method whereby they can speed up the solution of this problem of relieving congestion.

Comment on this

Will it not be quicker than the compulsory method in certain cases?

Comment on this

I am not here to be questioned by the Minister; it is my business to question him.

Comment on this

I will take you at your word. If you want to stick out your nose, I can, too. I never knew a game yet at which two could not play.

Comment on this

I would like to know by what method the Land Commission propose to purchase holdings. The Land Commission have a reserved function to decide what price they will pay for each holding. Will they send an inspector down to a public auction, or do they intend to notify the auctioneer who has charge of the sale what amount they are prepared to pay for the land, or will some particular auctioneer be told off to purchase the land, such as happened when the Minister for Agriculture purchased a farm in County Meath? Will the same firm of auctioneers be sent on this job of purchasing farms up and down the country?

The Minister seems to think that because of the fact that we have no knowledge of rearrangement schemes, people like myself, who come from an area like County Meath, should not speak on this Bill. The problem was solved for the people in Meath between 1841 and 1891 when the population of the county fell from 183,828 persons to 76,987 persons and it continued to fall until 1926, when it stood at 62,969. There is no necessity to point out why the population fell during those years. The repeal of the Corn Laws and that type of business——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is very far away from this stage.

Comment on this

Those are the things that helped to leave these farms available to be purchased in County Meath. That was the type of tyranny forced on us and our people.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might easily go back to the Conquest.

Comment on this

It left the people of County Meath without their land, and that land is available now for the relief of congestion, where it can be purchased in the open market for migrants. I want it to be made perfectly clear that, if the Minister proposes to purchase 50 farms a year, he will be a long time solving the question which is uppermost in the minds of most Deputies—that is, the relief of congestion.

Comment on this

It is rather difficult for one to make up one's mind as to what the Fianna Fáil Party really want. I think most Deputies will agree that it is desirable to secure land to relieve congestion—that is, to provide an additional parcel for uneconomic holders, or alternatively, a transfer of an uneconomic holding from one person to another, and provide a new holding for the person so deprived. That is the main object of the Land Commission, and the question arises as to what way they should acquire the land for this purpose. There are two ways open.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The one in question here is land offered for sale.

Comment on this

That is what I am coming to. We have two alternatives, to acquire land compulsorily or to acquire it by agreement in the open market from people anxious to sell. It seems to me that of the two alternatives, the one provided in the section is the more desirable. It is not any pleasure to the Land Commission or anybody else to go down the country, take people by the back of the neck, throw them out of their holdings and acquire their land compulsorily. It is much better to meet people, who offer their land for sale, in a fair and open way and purchase that land from them by agreement.

I would be absolutely false to everything I have advocated in this House if I were to oppose the principle of this section because on every occasion when the Estimate for the Department came before the House I have advocated that the Land Commission should purchase land in the same way that any purchaser does, that is by agreement, or in the open market for cash and so eliminate as far as possible all unnecessary delays. I think everyone will agree that anyone who offers land for sale wants to realise his property as quickly as possible, and to get his money. As far as this section meets that necessary requirement I think it is serving a very useful purpose.

I do not disguise the fact that this laudable purpose provided for in this section may carry with it certain dangers, but it is absolutely impossible to carry into effect any legislative reform without running some risks. The risks involved in this section are that the Land Commission, if uncontrolled in their operations in regard to the price which they pay, may unduly inflate the price of land in a particular area. That is a danger to be guarded against. The main safeguard in that connection lies in the definite statement of the Minister that the land will be valued in advance, and that the price will be determined before the actual purchase is carried into effect. I think it is important that some experienced valuer should estimate the value of the land to be acquired. His estimate should be a written one, and should be recorded for scrutiny by the Department of Finance or by whoever may find it necessary to investigate the matter afterwards. I think that such a provision would guard against any unnecessary inflation in the price of land through the activities of the Land Commission.

I mention this because I think some Deputies in their zeal for the acquisition of land, and for the prevention of its acquisition by aliens, have stressed the fact that this section might tend to keep out aliens. I do not think the Land Commission should enter into competition with people who, perhaps, have unlimited money and do not know the value of land. If the Land Commission were to act on the principle of out-bidding any particular type of bidder, they would certainly run up the price of land and incur unnecessary expense, and would perhaps be doing a very grave injustice to ordinary people in the district who might require land at a reasonable price.

I think, therefore, that if the Minister, in considering this section at a later stage, would ensure that the price would be determined before the purchase is made, there would be no reason to fear the evils which the Opposition Party seem to anticipate. What I expect will happen is that the Land Commission will send a purchaser to many sales and will enter into negotiations for the purchase of many farms which ultimately they may find themselves unable to purchase because somebody else has outbid them. I think there is no harm in that. They will, on the other hand, acquire quite a number of farms which will be very useful to them in carrying out their lawful purpose of relieving congestion and in providing additional parcels of land for uneconomic holders.

I think it would be desirable that the fact that the Land Commission were interested in a particular holding was not generally known because there might be the danger that their intervention might frighten off other would-be purchasers in the district. I think that danger, if it existed could be avoided if it was made perfectly clear that the Land Commission, when they failed to purchase a farm because they had been outbid by somebody who placed a higher value on it, would not resort to their compulsory powers later to acquire that same farm. There is that danger in regard to the Land Commission that they have a double-edged weapon: that is to say, that if they fail in their attempt to purchase a farm by agreement they could acquire it afterwards under their compulsory powers.

Comment on this

If they had been outbid for the farm it would be a very cowardly proceeding on their part to come in afterwards.

Comment on this

But that will be the law under this section.

Comment on this

There are many things that can be done that we do not do.

Comment on this

There is one point in the section which I think requires explanation and perhaps some amendment— that is, the provision of new holdings for migrants or to facilitate the rearrangement of land held under rundale or intermixed plots. Now I do not think that should be the only purpose for which land acquired under this section should be used. I think the Land Commission should be free to use land acquired under this section for the relief of congestion in the district where the land has been acquired. The Land Commission may acquire a holding on which there is no residence. There are many such through our country. If the Land Commission acquire such a holding, I do not see why they should not have power to sub-divide it amongst uneconomic holders in the vicinity of that holding.

Comment on this

I am bringing in an amendment to that effect.

Comment on this

The inclusion of this section appears very desirable as far as the congested areas are concerned, but everything that is desirable is not sound or good. This section represents a very big departure from custom. Deputy Cogan said that he does not know what the Opposition wants. I think that we understand what we want as well as he, seemingly, does himself.

He was always a great advocate of free sale. I hold that this section is a departure from free sale no matter what the Minister may say about giving market value, when he qualifies that by stating that when he says "market value" he does not mean market price.

As was pointed out, land resettlement is one of the many problems left to us as a legacy. I do not think that even the most advanced advocates of land resettlement, even Fianna Fáil, ever envisaged that it should go on indefinitely; that State intervention for the transfer of land from one individual to another should go on indefinitely, and that is what this section means. Under this section, the acquisition and resales branch of the Land Commission will never end. That is one very big objection, as well as the fact that this is interfering with free sale. I think the intention of all previous Land Acts and those who sponsored them was to take over the estates of this country; in other words, the land which was confiscated from the forebears of the people whom it was proposed to resettle on them. But I think they certainly envisaged that when a certain stage was reached, State intervention should no longer obtain. Of course, we have not reached that stage yet. So far as completely relieving congestion by land division is concerned, I think it is not ever likely to be completed.

Under this section, a holding of land, either medium-sized or large, can be purchased in the open market for a migrant or for the purpose of rearrangement. In the congested areas, it might be a laudable thing to purchase it for rearrangement; but, when that applies to the whole country, I do not think that it is a proper method. The Minister has not explained that when a vested holding is purchased there is not going to be any reduction in respect of the unrepaid portion of the purchase money.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

The point I was making is that, when the Land Commission purchase a holding in the open market for a migrant and it is made over to him, that migrant has a right to get priority in becoming a vested tenant of the Land Commission at a very early stage. In that event, in three, four or five years after he has been allotted the holding, is it not possible for him to offer that holding for sale and, under this section, is it not also possible for the Land Commission again to step in and acquire it for another migrant and pay the tenant the full value without any deduction, using State funds to finance the transaction? Cannot that be carried on indefinitely?

Deputy Commons said on more than one occasion in this House that if the Land Commission did their work as he expected them to do it there would be no need for a section of this kind. I agree with that up to the point that it is conditional on their confining their activities to holdings of a certain size.

The Minister in this Bill has not been very helpful to the Land Commission in carrying out that work in the ordinary way when he has inserted a section reducing the number of commissioners. I just compare the practice that, in my opinion, should be followed with this new departure. I think the Minister should have made it nine and let them work as three elements.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That was debated on Section 15. The number is fixed.

Comment on this

I am in agreement with Deputy Commons on this matter in regard to the proper carrying out of the work by the Land Commission and the speed necessary in order to relieve congestion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely the whole problem of congestion does not arise on this section which deals with purchase at auctions.

Comment on this

In my opinion a great deal hangs on it and it can be fairly well related to it. However, if you say that is the position ——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am merely saying that the whole principle of land division and the settlement of congestion does not arise under it.

Comment on this

I shall not pursue the matter. I believe the ordinary methods used for the acquisition of land, provided the staff was increased, would eliminate altogether the necessity for this particular section. It would be very hard for either the present Minister or any past Minister to convince me at this stage that land acquisition could not have been completed within a three-year period.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I think that would be most desirable, even if we had to hold up land division altogether merely in order to acquire land. I think if that were done a better scheme of migration could be prepared. That may appear ludicrous to a number of Deputies but I think it would be better to do it in the fashion to which we are accustomed and not to do it in this fashion. I hold it is unfair to the owners of land. They are served with a provisional notice in the year 1940.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not under this section, surely?

Comment on this

And in 1952 a decision will be given perhaps. I do not think that is fair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not done under this section.

Comment on this

The section is remedying that.

Comment on this

It may not be on the section, but it was mentioned by other speakers and I am merely expressing my concern. The Minister said that if Fianna Fáil had used all the land they acquired for the sole purpose of relieving congestion the problem would now be a very small one.

Comment on this

So it would.

Comment on this

I do not agree with that at all. Of the 647,000 acres acquired during their period in office a very small proportion of it was given to people other than uneconomic holders and Fianna Fáil should not be blamed for that. That has gone on from the very first occasion on which a Land Act was introduced for the relief of congestion. If the British Government was sincere in relieving congestion they would never have set up a double institution, the Congested Districts Board and the Estates Commission.

Comment on this

And the Land Commission.

Comment on this

The Congested Districts Board dealt with the problem of congestion and the Estates Commission dealt with the problem of local congestion adjoining estates. We know that in nearly every instance the major portion of the estate was given to landless men both in Mayo and Galway by the Estates Commission. That continued under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government and, if Fianna Fáil digressed, they are not to blame for that condition of affairs.

Comment on this

No one is blaming anyone.

Comment on this

It has never been made clear yet whether land purchase by the Land Commission and land division are to be confined solely to the relief of congestion, either by migration or by relief in the immediate neighbourhood. The carrot is still being dangled before the eyes of the landless men. I am very interested in the relief of congestion, and I honestly believe that that could be achieved without the introduction of this particular section in this particular Bill. I hold that, if the Land Commission acted as we would expect them to act, with the ordinary powers they now have, they would be quite capable of achieving the objective it is claimed this section will achieve. I think this departure constitutes a very bad principle since it is a departure from the fundamentals of land tenure and economics as we know them.

This section takes away the right of free sale from the small farmer and proposes to carry on indefinitely State intervention in the transfer of parcels of land from one individual to another. I think that is a wrong principle. I think it is a bad principle. I think it is a most undesirable principle. While I believe that we should aim at taking over, either compulsorily or by agreement, large tracts of land, at the same time we should preserve the element of free sale or the transfer of holdings through the ordinary channels.

Comment on this

I did not intend to intervene in this debate until I heard Deputy Beegan speak. I rise now to express the hope that Deputy Moran, Deputy Aiken, or some front-bench member of the Opposition will utterly repudiate the nonsense to which we have just listened from Deputy Beegan. I do not represent a rural constituency and I have not the same direct personal interest in this problem as other Deputies have. Deputy Beegan spent a considerable length of time in apportioning blame for the delays of the Land Commission, in suggesting that Fianna Fáil, perhaps, had not gone far enough to eliminate that delay but that, at any rate, they may have done something and we should not blame them. Someone else was to blame. In the next breath he tells us that he deplores this departure and that the Land Commission would have got on quite all right if we had left the matter as it was before.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

In the next breath he tells us that we are taking away the right of free sale.

Comment on this

The Deputy is twisting what I said.

Comment on this

What he said in the first breath, in the second breath and in the third breath were all equally nonsensical. If there was delay, surely this is one method of getting rid of or round some of the delay. How is their right of free sale interfered with? Was is not the position up to this that if the Land Commission wanted land, there was nothing to prevent them from acquiring it and acquiring it at what were described here last night as confiscation prices. This puts them into the position of being able to go into the open market and to make their bid there and to pay their price just as anyone else can do so. Surely this is giving some protection to the owners of land, to which Deputy Cogan referred a few minutes ago. I hope that Deputy Moran, when he speaks again, will repudiate utterly the sentiments expressed by Deputy Beegan.

Comment on this

The Minister describes this particular section as an experiment. I think it is a very dangerous experiment. If the Government insist on going ahead with it, I should certainly like to see it limited in legislation to operation for as short a time as possible. A number of Acts of Parliament have been passed here since 1923 and previous to that in the British Parliament, all designed for the purpose of making farmers secure in the land which they work and all endeavouring to relieve, as far as the pool of land would go, congestion and to bring uneconomic farms as far as possible to an economic standard. Up to 1923 there was no safeguard for certain sections of farmers. There was no protection against the operations of the Land Commission if they wanted to take the land compulsorily for the relief of congestion. After a long debate in this House, the 1933 Act gave all farmers who work their land the right to hold on to it, with certain limitations, if they were working it properly and producing a sufficient amount of food and giving a certain amount of employment, having regard to the necessities of the situation. While giving protection to farmers who work their land properly in their own and in the national interest, it took from farmers, whatever their tenure, an unwarranted protection to do what they liked with their own, as it was called.

We are setting out in this particular Bill on a new experiment. We know, from a social point of view, how the operations of the Land Acts since 1923 and 1933 worked. The Land Commission was able to get out after the person who did not work his land and give it to those whom the Land Commission thought were in a position to work it and who were willing to work it. We start off on this new experiment and we do not know what its results will be. The Minister gave no indication to the Dáil as to how he thought it would work out. He indicated that there are about 250,000 acres of land changing hands every year. That land, heretofore, has been bought as small farms by other farmers in the locality to relieve what Deputy Allen called their own congestion on the farm. It was the most desirable type of farmer who was able to purchase another small farm for some of the sons he reared who were prepared to stay on the land and work the land. We know from statistics that the vast majority, nearly all, of the land of this country is divided into 30- to 40-acre farms or under. The small 30-acre farmer who had worked hard and saved was able to purchase another farm for one of his sons when it was offered in the locality. The competition he had to meet was the competition of a similar type of farmer. From a social point of view, it did not matter whether one hard-working farmer or his neighbour got the land. They were both prepared to work it equally well for themselves and their family and the natural consequence was that national production on the land could be kept up. Here we have the Minister going to put an end to all that. He says he is not doing so. However, we know perfectly well that up to the present time, whenever a large farm was advertised for sale in the papers, the local congests got in touch with the local Deputy and asked him to approach the Land Commission to take over that land. That was natural. The Land Commission sometimes went in and said that even though this large tract of land changed hands it was not going in any way to derogate from their right to take it over and to use it for the relief of congestion. But the situation we are going to have after this is that, through time, a small farm of ten or 20 acres in any part of the country will no sooner be offered for sale than, on the appearance of notice to that effect in the papers, it will be followed by questions in this House to the Minister as to whether he is going to make a bid.

Comment on this

There were a good few questions on the Order Paper to-day.

Comment on this

There were 29 questions addressed to the Minister for Lands on the Order Paper to-day as to why the Land Commission did not take land compulsorily. A lot of the Minister's answers, if they had been fuller, particularly when he said that the Land Commission had decided not to acquire the land, would have shown that in the opinion of the Land Commissioners the land was being properly worked. But what is going to happen? It will not be 29 questions from one Deputy that will be put to the Minister for Lands hereafter. It will be 29 questions from every Deputy relating to a couple of thousand acres.

Comment on this

You know something about them yourself. You were a Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have an opportunity of speaking later. It is not 29 questions that are going to be asked of the Minister by one Deputy but 29 questions every day by every Deputy if we are going to cover the 250,000 acres offered for sale.

Comment on this

You have an elastic imagination.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin can make his own speech and say whether it is imagination or not. As the Minister says, we are starting off on an experiment. I think it is a very dangerous social experiment. I would be prepared to support the Minister if he found that there were any flaws in the compulsory acquisition of lands which are badly worked and which should be transferred for the relief of congestion. I am certainly not going to support or to acquiesce blindly in this particular social experiment. If Deputy Davin wants to do it, he can. We know that one result after the Bill has been in operation for some time will be that Deputy Commons will be asking his 39 or 40 questions a day.

Comment on this

Please God.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The Deputy has suggested already that there will be 5,200 questions a day asked.

Comment on this

Did I say that?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You said that there would be 39 questions by every Deputy in the House.

Comment on this

There is no reason why there should not be.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is opposed to the Deputy's arguments.

Comment on this

There is no reason that I can see from the point of view of order why Deputy Commons cannot ask a question about the same farm at least once a week.

Comment on this

All I do is to ask one once a year.

Comment on this

Deputy Commons does a little better than that. We have often heard the Minister tell him that he has nothing to add to what he said last month about a particular farm. Deputy Commons' questions hereafter will take the form of embarrassing the Minister as much as he can. Between the Minister and himself they did for poor ex-Deputy Cafferky and Deputy Commons is quite determined that he is going to be the surviving member, if there is a survivor of any kind in Clann na Talmhan after the election.

Comment on this

We also did for you.

Comment on this

Deputy Commons' question is going to take this form: To ask the Minister whether he is aware that there is a certain farm for sale and whether he is going to make an offer. The Minister may answer "yes" or "no". Next week the Deputy's question will be to the effect that the farm has been sold to some private individual and he will ask what did the Minister offer. The Minister will name a figure and Deputy Commons will then come back and ask: "Why did the Minister not offer a bit more and get the land for the relief of congestion?" The result will be that the Minister will be urged to bid higher and higher for these farms that are for sale, and the tendency will be to crowd out the private person, the farmer who is offering to pay his own money for the farm on offer. If a small farmer buys a farm at present he pays for it with his own money.

In future if this section goes through and the farmers follow the advice given them by Deputy Corish, the Parliamentary Secretary, they will wait for the Land Commission. The Parliamentary Secretary said it would be a good thing if private individuals did not buy land but waited for the Land Commission to do it for them. He also said that the Land Commission should have an advantage over the private individual. What is the result of that? The private individual, the Minister having an advantage of 50 per cent. on him, will fail to get the land in many cases. Instead of congestion being relieved by the operation of the private individual and his own money, the land will be purchased by the Land Commission at the public expense. That is at the expense of the general taxpayer. Then the Minister will cut the land annuity in half after having declared a loss on the resale. We may have a situation arising where there will be very little difference between individuals who would normally buy land under the present conditions and those who would get it through the operations of the Land Commission under this section. The result will be that the State will have to bear this burden.

I know that Government Deputies in recent times have become great spenders. They have all since they topped the £100,000,000 mark and cheered the Minister for Finance on having reached the £100,000,000 mark, got the 100 millionaire mentality. However as the Minister for Agriculture warned us to-day agricultural prices may not always be so high and it might be slightly more difficult for the ordinary farmer and taxpayer to pay this £100,000,000. So that if the Minister declared a loss of a million or two on resale the halving of the land annuities to the new allottees might mean a considerable burden on the community.

Comment on this

Especially if they had to pay for your white elephant.

Comment on this

The Coalition Government since they came into office have created white elephants in what would normally be productive unit. I can congratulate them on the result of their efforts to do that from the point of view of the old Fine Gael mentality. They have all been converted to that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

White elephants are not in order on this section.

Comment on this

Deputy Cogan said that the operations under this section should be extended to cover the purchase of land in the open market for all the purposes of the Land Commission, including the relief of congestion in the locality, and the Minister promised that he would introduce an amendment to that effect. Actually this Bill contains these powers. You have them in Section 24, sub-section (11).

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We have not come to that yet, unfortunately.

Comment on this

In Section 23 we are setting out to purchase land offered for sale. I want to inform Deputy Cogan that under Section 24 the Minister has power to do what the Deputy suggested he should do.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Could we not wait until we come to that section?

Comment on this

We could, but it is no harm for a moment to advert to the fact that it is not only for the purposes set out in this particular section, as amended by the Minister's amendment, that land is being purchased, but also for the purposes set out in Section 24, sub-section (11), which says: "Where any land becomes not required by the Land Commission for granting new holdings to migrants, such land may be disposed of by the Land Commission to any of the persons or bodies mentioned in sub-section (1) of Section 31 of the Land Act, 1923, as extended by this Act." That is, where land becomes not required by the Land Commission under Section 23 for the granting of new holdings to migrants, so that we have the situation that the Minister, having sold this particular section to the country, for the purpose of providing land for migrants, can, if he wishes, use it for the purpose of acquiring land for all other types of persons to whom land may be given under the Land Acts. I take it Deputy Cogan has thought a little bit about this particular section; I can take it from his speech also that he wants to do a little bit more thinking about it, if he wants to get some idea of its full consequences.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Why does the Deputy not take a headline from him?

Comment on this

We would like to see the Minister, if he proposes to continue with this—and I certainly would like to see him—limiting this legislation to one year because, if this system gets going, it will be very hard to stop it. If the powers fell automatically at the end of a year the Dáil would have a new look-out; it could look at this matter again and see if it was in the interests of our people that it should be renewed for a longer period. It is a very dangerous social experiment, in my opinion.

Deputy McQuillan said it was going to provide a pool of land. I remarked on that that it was going to create a whirlpool of land. There is nothing in the section which would limit the operations of the Land Commission. They can go into the open market, outbid local people and give land to migrants from Mayo or some other place or, under Section 24, give it to somebody for the relief of local congestion. If the land comes into the market again in a short time they can rebuy and resell it. If Deputies are pressed by their constituents and, in turn, bring pressure to bear on the Minister and the Land Commission, they can go along gaily spending public money purchasing the 250,000 acres that normally are for sale within the year. At that rate it will not be many years before we have bought and resold a quantity of land equal to the total amount of land in the Twenty-Six Counties.

Comment on this

We are going into it with a great swing!

Comment on this

There is nothing to stop it, because the Minister is taking power to do it.

Comment on this

Last night I drew the Deputy's attention to Section 4, but he does not seem to know that it exists.

Comment on this

I have seen Sections 4 and 10 and I know what the Minister has in view under Section 10.

Comment on this

Is there any chance of buying up the Six Counties under this section?

Comment on this

If we could operate in the Six Counties no doubt it would be all right, but I would like to operate it in some country other than the Six Counties because this sort of social experiment is something you would like to try out on your enemies, not on your friends.

Comment on this

The Minister said last night that it was intended under this section to tap an untapped stream of land for the purpose of relieving congestion. I certainly would not quarrel with that, but if we are going to tap some untapped stream, let us tap it in the right way. The provisions in this section are unworkable. The section pretends to set out to do something that cannot possibly be done for the purpose of relieving congestion. The powers conferred under it will be useless from the point of view of making headway with the problem of relieving congestion.

I was interested to hear Deputy Cogan to-night advocating that the House should accept this section. The mere fact of Deputy Cogan asking that should be sufficient warning to everybody interested in the relief of congestion to vote against it, because Deputy Cogan regards himself here, and has always done so, as the ranchers' advocate. If Deputy Cogan thought for a moment that under this section there was a possibility of acquiring land in Wicklow or Limerick or where large tracts are, he would be up in arms against it. He is supporting the section because he knows it is a fraud from the point of view of acquiring land to relieve congestion.

It has been suggested that we on this side of the House have different views on the section. It was amusing to hear the Minister asking Deputy Moylan last night if he was reflecting the opinions of the Fianna Fáil Party. Of course the acquisition of land differs in every county, as the Minister is well aware, and the problem of congestion differs in every county where it exists. It differs just as much as the price of land differs from county to county. The Minister was very careful to avoid giving a definition on that aspect. The Minister and, I think, Deputy Cogan, suggested that on this side of the House we have different views on this matter. That type of suggestion comes very well from a member of a Government no two members of which express the same view whenever they open their mouths, and they are contradicting each other from week to week—every single member of the Cabinet.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

That is not so, but probably that is the way you would like to see it.

Comment on this

We have only to listen to the Minister for External Affairs and the Minister for Finance on the question of finance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise.

Comment on this

I want to show how this section is unworkable. It is unworkable, firstly, from the point of view of getting land.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is a bit of wishful thinking.

Comment on this

The Minister told us that the price to be paid for land will be fixed by the commissioners. A holding that would be suitable for the Minister's purpose is advertised, let it be in Limerick or Clare or Mayo. It is land suitable for the purpose of this section. The advertisement usually appears two weeks before the sale. Does the Minister suggest that a Land Commission inspector must go down to that area, make a report on the holding, send that report to the Department in Dublin, let the matter come before the commission and then let them decide? If that has to be done, does the Minister really think that the holding will still be on the market after all that time has elapsed?

Comment on this

That was the system, but that is not going to be the system.

Comment on this

The Minister informed us that the price was going to be predetermined by the lay commissioners who operate in Merrion Street. Suppose a holding is advertised for sale in two weeks' time in Mayo, Cork or Limerick, will the lay commissioners be able to have one of these holdings inspected and valued and the predetermined price decided on within a period of two weeks?

Comment on this

We could farm out commissioners through the country.

Comment on this

If the number of lay commissioners is going to be four, and that no less than three must be present at a court sitting, and if, in addition, they have to determine the question of price for any land that may be available in the Twenty-Six Counties, we can see how much land is going to be acquired under this section.

Comment on this

There will be no harm done.

Comment on this

The harm that is being done is that it is being pretended that a big attack is to be made on the problem of congestion, and that a big pool of land is going to be acquired under this section. I am pointing out that that cannot be so. In spite of all the powers vested in the Land Commission for the compulsory acquisition of any type of land, and with their full staff back in the offices, the total amount of land that the Land Commission succeeded in acquiring in the year ended 31st March, 1949, was 8,196 acres. That is the information that is given in the Report of the Land Commission.

Comment on this

I will have a word to say on that when the Estimate for the Department comes before the Dáil.

Comment on this

That is the position, that the Land Commission with their full powers and with their full staff operating under normal conditions only succeeded in acquiring 8,196 acres in the last year for which figures are available. I suppose it would be correct to say that, when allowance is made for water, scrub, bog and so forth, not more than 5,000 acres of that total of 8,000 acres odd would be available for the relief of congestion. If that is all the Land Commission was able to do in one year, I wonder what can they do under this section in the way of creating a pool of land for the relief of congestion?

The Minister refused to accept an amendment which was moved from this side with regard to sales of land by private treaty. Evidently he takes the line that under this section he is going to send a representative to sales for the purpose of acquiring land. So far, the Minister has not informed the House as to what type of land he intends to get. He did not say whether he was going to get after the large ranches or after small farms or what particular type of land he has in mind.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is a lie. The Minister said that he was going to try and buy holdings suitable for migrants.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Collins will have to withdraw the word "lie."

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I withdraw.

Comment on this

The Minister did say that he was taking power to purchase land for the relief of congestion, but he was careful not to state what type of land. In connection with the migrants, it was pointed out by some Deputies that, in some cases, they evidently are not very welcome in some areas to which they have been sent. I thought it was a fundamental practice with the Land Commission, when carrying out a migration scheme, to send five, six, eight or ten migrants to the same area because it was found in practice that where they acquired land in an outside county for their accommodation, a local agitation was carried on principally by landless men. Speaking of landless men, I would like if the Minister or somebody would at some time tell those people who have been looking forward for years to getting land what their position is going to be. They have been expecting for years to get land.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see how that arises under this section.

Comment on this

With respect, I think it does, because the Minister is taking power under the section to acquire land for the granting of new holdings to migrants. I have been pointing out that very often local agitations are carried on by landless men in the areas to which migrants are taken. Can we take it from the Minister that there is no intention of ever providing land for landless men in the future, and that the intention of this Bill is to concentrate on the relief of congestion—to get migrants out of congested areas and so get those areas resettled?

Comment on this

That does not exclude the landless men for all time.

Comment on this

I should like to get a definite answer from the Minister so far as these landless men are concerned. Am I to understand from him now that he contemplates considering the position of landless men? At any rate, those unfortunate people who seem to have been forgotton should not be misled. Evidently, the Minister wants to ride both horses crossing the stream.

There is another matter that the Minister has not adverted to under this section. There are a number of cases pending before the Land Commission courts in regard to acquisition. There is a suggestion that the Land Commission can purchase these lands for cash. I should like to know what will be the position of these people now. I understand this Bill is to be retrospective to cover cases where the Land Commission did not get possession before the beginning of this year.

Comment on this

That is the market value.

Comment on this

There are a number of cases before the court and, under this section, the Minister is taking power to take land that is offered for sale. Certain prices are in the course of being fixed before the court in these pending cases.

Comment on this

Not under this section.

Comment on this

This is the particular section under which the Minister takes power to pay cash for land. The cash which the Minister proposes to pay for land is fixed under the market value section which we passed earlier.

Comment on this

And which was amended to include land, the possession of which was taken on or after 1st December last; in other words, in connection with land which was in the Land Commission machine but which was taken possession of after 1st December last, if the price has been fixed, the owners can apply within six months after the passage of this Bill to have the price redetermined so as to get the benefit of this Bill.

Comment on this

I accept the assurance of the Minister. In this section the Land Commission take power to pay cash for land and I am wondering what is the position of these cases. The question of the acquisition of land varies from county to county. Deputies from different parts of the country have pointed out that under this section large farms might be acquired or bought. In the West of Ireland I think that the contrary will be the case. Instead of enhancing the prices paid for the land, the mere fact of a Land Commission official appearing at the sale will finish the sale so far as the vendor is concerned. In connection with every farm purchased in the West of Ireland one of the first requisitions of title is, "have the lands been inspected by the Land Commission?" and where a Land Commission inspector has appeared on the holding no purchaser will touch that land. Under this section, if the Minister's representative goes to a public auction and makes a bid that will finish the sale and will finish the vendor so far as the sale of the land is concerned, because the Minister, under sub-section (5) of this section, preserves the power that, if he does not get the land one way, he will get it the other way.

Comment on this

That is not correct.

Comment on this

Then I do not know the meaning of plain English. Sub-section (5) reads:—

"The powers conferred by this section are in addition to, and not in derogation of, any other powers which the Land Commission may have by law for the acquisition or purchase of land or resumption of holdings."

Comment on this

That is purely a safeguard against any legal argument later on that the Land Commission were committed to purchase land only for cash in the open market or by private treaty. That is merely a legal safeguard for their existing powers.

Comment on this

There was an amendment to this section to try to get the land by private treaty and the Minister refused to accept it.

Comment on this

This allows us to buy by private treaty.

Comment on this

This sub-section preserves all the compulsory acquisition powers of the Land Commission in any case covered by the section. Therefore the Minister or his officials cannot deny that, if the Land Commission bid for any holding and they do not get it, there is nothing to stop them from putting a notice in Iris Oifigiúil the following week and acquiring the holding compulsorily. Is that the law or is it not?

Comment on this

If the Land Commission did such a thing, I should like to hear what the Deputy would say in this House the following week.

Comment on this

The Deputy would have no business opening his mouth in the House the following week, because we are putting in a section giving the Land Commission this power. In the West of Ireland at present, if there is a rumour that the Land Commission are going to touch a holding, you cannot sell it in the open market. It has been decided by the Judicial Commissioner that anybody purchasing land in Mayo should be aware that congestion exists and therefore should know that he is running the risk of the land being taken from him.

Comment on this

That was the Judicial Commissioner, not this House.

Comment on this

It happens to be the law of the land. The matter has not been appealed to the Supreme Court, so far as I know. This may not apply in other areas, but the fact of a Minister's representative going to a sale in the West of Ireland will prevent the vendor from getting the market value of his land.

Comment on this

Would it surprise the Deputy to know that several owners have already offered us land believing that the Bill had been passed?

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister that I have about 40 "white elephants" which I can offer to him. The Minister will get any amount of "snipe" land and places that nobody will buy. I am sure he has been offered those already. That is the danger of the powers conferred on the Minister by this section. Political pressure can be brought to bear on anyone holding the Minister's office or even the Minister for the purpose of getting some farm acquired by the State that could not be sold on the open market.

Comment on this

The commissioners, not the Minister.

Comment on this

I am pointing the different dangers arising from this section and that the section will be unworkable from a practical point of view. If there was any hope offered in this section of relieving congestion, certainly all the western Deputies would be more than interested in accepting it. There was a suggestion made that the Minister should concentrate one section of the Department, if he is getting land under this Bill, on acquiring lands in the Midlands, in County Limerick and other such counties, and another section of the Land Commission on the congested areas, getting suitable migrants and creating a pool of land and having it ready instead of trying to do it in bits and pieces. I think the Minister would be well advised to listen to that suggestion. From the point of view of relieving congestion and from the point of view of this section stopping people like the Aga Khan or the Aly Khan acquiring land here, this section is so much eyewash. The Minister knows that quite well. If the Minister wants to take land off any Aga Khan or Aly Khan or any other Khan in order to relieve congestion he can do that under the compulsory powers vested in him at the moment. But he will not do it under this particular section. There is a law operating against these people to the extent of a 25 per cent. stamp duty. If the Minister is anxious to get shut of the Aly Khans and the Aga Khans and all the other Khans coming into the country he has power to do that and to take their lands from them in order to relieve congestion. It is no answer to the Opposition to say that this section will stop the Agas or the Alys or the Begums coming into this country and buying land.

I have tried to show that this section will not relieve congestion. It is open to every type of abuse. From the taxpayer's point of view it will create the extraordinary situation where the Land Commission will buy a holding for Pat Murphy; Pat Murphy wants to better himself so he buys a better holding and he sells his old holding back to the Land Commission and they give it to another Pat Murphy at State expense. In addition to that, it will interfere with the most sacred right of the Irish tenant farmer, the right of free sale. I see no good reason why this section should be passed in its present form and I ask the House to reject it.

Comment on this

This is a new departure. I take it the Minister thinks that this will be a short cut in the acquisition of land. If the Minister improved the present machinery for acquiring land by appointing more commissioners he would get all the land he wants much quicker and more easily. Short cuts are very often the longest roads in the end. I can see this system laid open to the gravest abuses. I can see people organising to ensure that they will get enough money or enough land. The Land Commission never had the name of paying too much for land. I do not believe that the price will be forced down under this. I think it will have the opposite effect. I think every effort will be made to see that the Minister's representatives or the Land Commission pay enough for land. Land will continue at its present high rate for some time to come because there are many competitors. We have complaints here of people coming in with money and buying land without let or hindrance. It is said that there is a handicap, but the handicap does not stop them from purchasing land. I think any sensible person whose lands comply with the regulations will do his utmost to get all the money he can for it. I think the Minister would have been wiser if he had left the situation as it was and increased the staff, particularly that section of the staff that deals with legal points which arise. As soon as the Minister decides to purchase there will be a shoal of letters and applications forcing his hand.

Comment on this

The Minister will not purchase any land.

Comment on this

His representatives will.

Comment on this

His representatives will not.

Comment on this

Is it not the Land Commission that will purchase the land?

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It is the lay comsioners.

Comment on this

It is the same thing.

Comment on this

It is not. What is Section 10 there for?

Comment on this

The Minister will be forced to compel the commissioners to take action.

Comment on this

The commissioners cannot be forced to take action.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The Deputy is obstructing now. He does not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Reilly must be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

I think the Minister does not know where he is going. I do not think the State should purchase land in that way. There is machinery for the purchase of land and that machinery should be maintained. I do not think it is wise to make changes merely for the sake of change.

Comment on this

I had no intention of intervening in this debate but, like all western Deputies, I am anxious about the problem of congestion. I do not wish to say anything which might be construed as hampering either the Minister or the Land Commission in solving the problem.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Then why say anything?

Comment on this

In the early stages of this Bill I hoped some good might come of it. Having listened to the Minister yesterday evening, my hopes are dashed. He stated that all the forces of the Land Commission would be diverted into one channel. Does that mean that all the other work will cease and the forces of the Land Commission will be thrown into the congested areas to start the congests fighting amongst themselves?

Comment on this

But why should they do that?

Comment on this

I wondered why those behind the Minister on the Government Benches remained so silent. Now I understand. The ranchers will get a breathing space while all the forces of the Land Commission will tinker with the problem of congestion amongst the congests themselves.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The people in the West will not be very flattered.

Comment on this

Do not publish that in the local papers when you go home.

Comment on this

I believe I am right in saying that. I have here a letter I received to-day.

Comment on this

Does it refer to the section?

Comment on this

It is about a farm that is being offered for sale. Portion of the farm is evicted land. It is on the verge of a congested area. It is being sold privately. What steps can the Minister take when that farm is sold? Once it is sold, he can do nothing about it.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

If you let this Bill through he may be able to buy it before it is sold.

Comment on this

He will not be able to buy it because it is being sold privately. When he was speaking on his own amendment last night, Deputy Commons said:—

"Over the last ten or 12 years, when the Land Commission wished to acquire land the owner immediately put it up for sale. While the Land Commission had power to follow up the new owner they only succeeded in one out of 50 cases."

Comment on this

That is why I wanted the Minister to get it.

Comment on this

It has gone off the market. No man would put it on the market. He would sell it privately— maybe to the Aga Khan or to the Aly Khan, as Deputy Moran has pointed out.

Comment on this

Let the Bill through and give the Minister a chance.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Deputy is entitled to fair play. He is not in the habit of interrupting and he should be allowed to make his speech without interruptions.

Comment on this

I only gave an explanation.

Comment on this

I do not mind interruptions at all. In my opinion neither this section nor this Bill will solve congestion. At the present time the Land Commission and other people are tinkering with small places in the West of Ireland. We have the position there that people on small farms of eight and ten acres had to go to America or to England in order to earn a living and hoping, at the same time, that they would be able to return and settle down on these farms. Their neighbours are now writing to the Land Commission asking it to acquire these farms and the ranchers are laughing at the whole thing. That is what this Bill will do. The only way to get land is to acquire it compulsorily. I heard it shouted by Deputies on the Government Benches that that was confiscation. Even if it should be confiscation, I ask you how was it got in the first place. It was got through confiscation. I do not stand for confiscation. I stand for fair play. I am very much afraid that this Bill will do great harm and that it will give the ranchers a new lease of life.

Comment on this