Land Bill, 1949—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 165–325 of 325. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 35 of 1949 ›
In the case of a holding offered for sale, seeing that the market value is now guaranteed under Section 5, would the Minister say what the seller of the land gains by going to the trouble of having an auction? On the other hand, if the Land Commission takes the land compulsorily and gives the owner the market value, what does the owner lose in the transaction? Would it not be as well to go to the logical limit in this matter and, where land is offered for sale, the Land Commission take that land when it is obviously needed for the relief of congestion? Under Section 5, no loss will accrue to the owner of the land.
There is a type of problem with which the Minister must be well acquainted and I am doubtful as to whether it can be solved under this section or not. If I thought that it could, it would make me look a little more kindly on it. I have in mind an exchange that is desired between two neighbours. A neighbour would sell the land if he were guaranteed two conditions—(1) market value, which he is now guaranteed and (2) that a particular neighbour living on land adjoining the farm to be sold would get it. The Land Commission will not give any such promise to any man who sells such land.
Comment on this
Could the Minister utilise this section to cover a type of case which is common, namely, a farm which was originally part of other lands—where it is, say, just a half of what was originally one holding with adjoining land—and where the owner now wishes to sell it and to have it incorporated in what was the original holding so that his neighbour can get it? The Land Commission in such a case will not give the seller a guarantee that they will resell the land to the neighbour who wants to reincorporate it in the original holding. It seems to me that the Land Commission could go a bit further, seeing that they are taking certain new powers under this section, to sanction a private arrangement between two neighbours in a situation of that kind—in other words, to guarantee the loan of the money to the buyer for the purchase of the land from the neighbour. That would bring about work which the Land Commission wishes to do and it would be done in a great many cases far more quickly and effectively than is now the case and also more speedily than will be the case under this section.
Comment on this
But in that case seller would act as the commissioners. He would be allotting the land.
Comment on this
——if a good job of work is done. I am not putting up a case that the Land Commission would not come in first and get the proposition and approve or disapprove, as the case may be, but if they approve I think it would be well if they would then sanction the loan of the money required by a nominated buyer.
Comment on this
That type of problem arises very much in Connemara. I have often been asked if the Land Commission would make a loan to a prospective buyer and I have always had to say that the Land Commission never does that. What happens in this case is that when the land is put up for auction somebody else steps in and spoils the type of settlement which the Land Commission is engaged on.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Minister should still further examine this proposal under Section 23 and see if he could not fit in under it some type of a solution to the problem.
Comment on this
If the market value is now genuinely being incorporated in this Bill and if a seller gets the market value for land which he puts up for auction, what is the point in having an auction and why does the Land Commission step in and take the land and apply it for the purposes of the relief of congestion?
Comment on this
Tá mé i gcoinne an ailt seo mar tá mé den tuairim go ndéanfaidh sé dochar mór. Tá an fhios sin ag gach aoinne san tír.
When the 1936 Land Act was going through this House I heard the people who are now sitting on the Government side of the House talking about fixity of tenure, free sale, and so forth. This will upset everything and it will not settle anything. Rural Deputies will agree with me when I say that in all probability they have never gone into a locality since they became Deputies but representations were made to them about land division to the extent that, where there was a farm of four, five or six acres and the valuation might be only £15, it was put up to them that the land should be taken over and divided and handed over to somebody else. You are going to open this flood-gate. You are not going to solve the land problem in Meath or in the Midlands or anywhere else. It is a very dangerous section in this Bill.
I suggest, as has already been suggested from this side of the House, that the experiment be tried for not more than one year. There are big estates which can be divided and settled in a proper way. I heard the late Mr. Patrick Hogan, who was Minister for Agriculture, state in this House: "Beware of the day you do away with or try to do away with the middle-class farmer. He is the support and the prop of society." You are now opening a flood-gate and you will need to be very careful where you tread.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to give me information on the following matter. I have in mind a problem that arises in every constituency and that arises very often in my constituency of County Wicklow. There is a type of farm which may be 50 per cent. suitable for agriculture, 25 per cent. or even the other 50 per cent. suitable for forestry and which the Forestry Department require. Can the Minister under this section acquire that particular farm? It would be desirable if he could, because I know that both the Land Commission and the forestry section have fallen down in the matter of the purchase of farms under existing legislation. If this section would enable the Minister to purchase farms of that kind and if he could use portion for the relief of congestion and hand over the other portion to the Forestry Department, it would be a great help.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 62:—
In sub-section (2), pages 12 and 13, to delete paragraphs (b) and (c) and substitute the following paragraph:—
(b) the Order shall be expressed and shall operate to vest the land in the Land Commission for an estate in fee simple in possession subject—
(i) in case the land is subject to a State annuity, to that State annuity, and
(ii) in case provision is made in the Order in pursuance of subsection (4) of this section for the continuance or creation of an easement, to that easement, but save as aforesaid free from all public rights (if any) and from the claims of all persons who are interested in the land, whether in respect of incumbrances or interests therein or otherwise howsoever,.
This amendment is a tidying up of two paragraphs in the Bill as introduced. It is deleting these and substituting one to bring about the same effect.
Comment on this
This a very long and involved section and it is difficult to understand. There are 14 sub-sections and these are again divided into paragraphs and there are so many that they absorb the alphabet several times. Anything I do not understand I am inclined to distrust.
This section purports to do away with certain rights of way and certain easements and we would want to be very careful as to the destruction of any particular rights that people have. There are certain rights the preservation of which is wholly desirable and necessary. I have seen rights extinguished by allottees, even though the Land Commission took certain precautions to preserve them, and I would like to be assured that where the Land Commission does recognise these rights they will make the allottees who benefit from land division also recognise them.
There may be certain rights of way along a river bank, ancient rights which are of benefit to anglers and others. The Aga Khan, Deputy Hickey's friend, and other people who are not truly Gaelic, have certain river banks, and no further rights of that nature should be wiped out by any action taken by the Land Commission.
Then again, I want to know if this section applies, not to future transactions, but where injustices were done in the past. There are many public paths which it is right to preserve. There are certain rights of way which no longer should exist as rights of way. They existed before proper roadways were provided in the country, and now, when those roadways have been made through districts where rights of way existed over land before, many people insist on using the ancient right of way, even though they have got a new road. That is the cause of a good deal of trouble and a good deal of litigation. Every farmer objects to trespass—and rightly so.
Many of the rights of way that are still being used are being used unjustly, causing a good deal of difficulty to the man who owns the farm. I would like to know if this section will operate to relieve farmers of such trespass. Could we eliminate rights of way that were originally justifiable but now, in view of the multiplicity of roads created, are no longer justifiable? Will this section operate to give a farmer a chance of appealing to the Land Commission to destroy such rights?
There is another aspect of easement which it is very difficult to interfere with, and that is the question of water. This purchase of land purports to eliminate certain rights of way and certain easements. One of the most valuable easements people have is the right of water. You may destroy the value of a farm and put the farmer to a tremendous amount of inconvenience, and I do not know of any monetary compensation that will be sufficient for the farmer for the removal of an easement which he has to water.
I would like to be assured by the Minister in specific fashion as to what exactly are the powers taken by the Land Commission in this case and if the section, when passed, will operate to relieve certain farmers of disabilities from which they suffer now, as well as the Land Commission. The Land Commission want to provide for the elimination of disabilities on farms which they will create. If these disabilities existed on existing farms will the farmer have the right to appeal to the Land Commission for authority to destroy an easement which is no longer justified?
Comment on this
This section will deal, first of all, with land purchased under the preceding section—that is, land purchased for cash in the open market or by private treaty. Secondly, in the case of a private purchaser—for instance, if myself or Deputy Moylan goes out to buy a holding—there are certain things attaching to it. We do not mind that, but in the case of the Land Commission they must hand absolutely clean, sound title to the allottee. For that reason power is being taken under the section to get land absolutely clean and free. We are dealing now, I presume, with the amendment. There are ample safeguards in the section giving the Land Commission power to give alternative rights away, to give rights to water and so on. I think that should put Deputy Moylan's mind at rest.
Comment on this
I think this is an extraordinary proposition that is made on behalf of the Land Commission. Here the State are going to purchase land at the public expense. If there are rights or easements attaching to that land, the Land Commission are taking power to wipe them out, while a purchaser in the open market would have to buy that land subject to those rights and easements.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to tell us where the Land Commission have the power to wipe out a public way over land purchased by them.
Comment on this
They have that power since the 1923 Land Act was passed, and I think even before it.
Comment on this
I would like to have chapter and verse for that because I do not accept it. Under this amendment the Land Commission are proposing to take power to wipe out any of the existing easements that may be an appurtenant to a holding which they purchase.
Comment on this
May I read for the Deputy sub-section (1) of Section 41 of the 1939 Land Act:
"Where the Land Commission have, either before or after the passing of this Act, acquired or purchased any untenanted land or acquired any holding by way of exchange or resumed any holding and such land or holding is subject to any easement or to any grazing, turbary, or other right or to a tenancy of such a nature that it does not constitute an interest entitling the occupier to purchase under the Land Purchase Acts, the Land Commission may by order extinguish such easement, right or tenancy subject to payment by the Land Commission of such compensation as shall be fixed by the Land Commission by their said order."
We are merely giving the Land Commission the same power where they purchase under this section and there are similar safeguards as regards compensation.
Comment on this
Where are there similar safeguards under this amendment in the matter of compensation for easements?
Comment on this
Sub-section (9) provides:
"Where a transfer order is made in respect of any land, the Land Commission shall be liable to pay compensation in respect of every interest (other than an easement continued by the order or an easement in lieu whereof a new easement has been created by the order) subsisting therein immediately before the operative date, but no claim for compensation shall be made after the expiration of six years from that date."
If that is not a safeguard enough, I will make an amendment on the subject.
Comment on this
That mentions the word "interest" and, presumably, interest in this section means an interest within the meaning of the Land Acts?
Comment on this
The Minister must know that there are many different rights that would not be termed easements within the meaning of the Land Acts. There are many different rights attaching to farms, rights in regard to Mass paths, rights to water and perhaps to a well on a farm. It may be the only well that people for miles around can get water from. In regard to holdings near the sea, there may be rights in regard to the taking of seaweed. All these rights may be wiped out by the Land Commission under this amendment.
I want to remind the House that all these rights on particular holdings have been jealously guarded and defended by the people concerned, and particularly in the congested areas. The people have jealously guarded and protected their rights in the courts of the country for many years. All these easements and rights of way are of very grave importance to the people concerned. The exercise of them makes all the difference between running small farms economically or otherwise. I want to tell the Minister that unless adequate provision is made to secure every conceivable type of easement which the Land Commission would propose to wipe out under this amendment, the Land Commission may find themselves up against a big constitutional issue. The individual's rights to property are protected under the Constitution and the Land Commission are not entitled to take them away. I can visualise all kinds of hardship arising in the case of individuals who for a long time have enjoyed certain rights over a farm that may be purchased by the Land Commission. The Land Commission may ignore their rights completely. It is a large body and is inclined to terrorise people.
Comment on this
If the Land Commission are going to wipe out rights which people have enjoyed from time immemorial, then they are going to create a very serious difficulty. I have already pointed out that if a private individual went into the open market and purchased a farm over which there were certain rights and easements, he had to do so subject to these rights and easements. But the Land Commission are going to wipe out all such rights and easements where they purchase a holding. I submit that they have no right to do that. The Minister stated, on Section 23, that the Land Commission would go into competition against the ordinary purchaser in the open market where land was offered for sale. We now find that that is not so, and that the Land Commission will have at least a 15 per cent. advantage over the ordinary purchaser.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the power which the Land Commission is proposing to take under the amendment. I do not see any reason for the taking of those powers. If it was a question of the rearrangement of a holding or of dealing with rundale, where you had criss-cross by-paths, I could understand a power like this being taken by the Land Commission. The same powers were taken under the 1939 Act but, if they were taken, there was provision made for compensation. I presume that this provision is confined to purchases under Section 23. I see no reason why the Minister should get those powers and should be given this advantage over and above any other purchaser who may be in competition with his officials in the purchase of such a farm. If this amendment is inserted in its present form and a farm is purchased with certain rights over it, it will come as a shock to the adjoining people to know that the rights which they have been enjoying are wiped out and they have no redress. I ask the Minister to withdraw the amendment or reconsider the matter before the Report Stage.
Comment on this
No, I will not, because the amendment is a definite improvement on the original drafting of the Bill. I asked Deputy Moran if he had read the whole section because it is a very long section. Sub-section (9) states:—
"Where a transfer order is made in respect of any land, the Land Commission shall be liable to pay compensation in respect of every interest (other than an easement continued by the order or an easement in lieu whereof a new easement has been created by the order) subsisting therein immediately before the operative date, but no claim for compensation shall be made after the expiration of six years from that date."
That depends on what the interest covers. If you turn to sub-section (14), paragraph (d), you will find that the word "interest" there in relation to land is defined as "an easement or an annual payment". In between lines 5 and 10 you have this: "The word ‘easement' includes any profit-a-prendre or other right (including all sporting rights, within the meaning of the Land Purchase Acts) in or over land, and also any fisheries appurtenant to land within the meaning of the Land Purchase Acts.” In other words, it includes practically every conceivable kind of right for which the Land Commission must pay compensation to the owner. What greater safeguard can you have than that?
Comment on this
The point is that a water right is invaluable and no amount of compensation is adequate for it. Is it proposed under this section to destroy water rights which are the cause of constant litigation throughout the country?
Comment on this
Not at all. A good deal of the Land Commission time is taken up acquiring rights of way in the case of vested land. In the course of their ordinary land resettlement, it is the duty of the Land Commission to provide rights of way to water if none exist or if there is trouble in connection with them. I have known cases where there was litigation because rights of way were not clearly defined and the Land Commission had to get the necessary land for the rights of way. It is inconceivable that they would do what is suggested. On the other hand, as in the case of forestry, it is necessary for them in case they would meet a person——
Comment on this
It is not. The Land Commission must give clear title to the allottee. It is not in their own interests they are working. When they go to purchase land it is not for themselves they are purchasing it, but for some future allottee. They want to give that allottee a clear title. If no right of way exists, they will not hesitate to strike out a new right of way.
Comment on this
Definitely. If there is not an easement of water, it would be their duty to provide it.
Comment on this
Will the Minister provide for an amendment to settle the question of easement so far as water is concerned?
Comment on this
It is provided for. We have taken great pains to see that it is. As a matter of fact, I set more store on a right of way for foot passengers. It is the biggest bone of contention in my part of the country.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:—
In sub-section (5), page 13, line 42, to delete "in".
That is merely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:—
Before sub-section (10), page 14, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(10) Where a transfer order is made in respect of any land and the interest therein purchased by the Land Commission was, immediately before the operative date, subject to a mortgage—
(a) the reference in sub-section (9) of this section to every interest subsisting in the land immediately before the operative date shall include a reference to the interest purchased by the Land Commission, and
(b) the fixing of compensation in respect of the interest purchased by the Land Commission, and the allocation of such compensation as between the Land Commission and the mortgagee, shall be carried out in accordance with the rules made for the purposes of this section.
This amendment is being moved to meet the wishes of the Incorporated Law Society. It seeks to clarify the position in relation to the payment of compensation to mortgagees whose interests may be extinguished under a Transfer Order. As a general rule, mortgages against a vendor's interest will be discharged in the process of completing the purchase under Section 23 of the Bill. It is only in a very rare case that such a mortgage will be affected by and compensatable under the Transfer Order procedure.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Aiken I move amendment No. 66:—
To delete sub-section (11).
I do not like this sub-section for the reason that it seems to me that, in going out to purchase farms as going concerns, the Land Commission and the Minister should be very careful and should not purchase them speculatively; I mean in the sense that they have not a settled plan of use immediately. It would seem to me that that plan is not clear in the Minister's mind. If the Minister is purchasing a farm, it ought to be purchased with a specific purpose and design and not with a speculation as to what might happen later. The verbiage of this is peculiar, "becomes not required by the Land Commission." If there is any likelihood that the Land Commission will not require it, they should not purchase it. There ought to be some specific plan in their minds for dealing with the going-concern farm immediately and not having it on their hands and having Deputy Commons asking why it has been in the hands of the Land Commission for the last 20 years, as he might conceivably ask.
Then, if the Minister will look at Section 25 of the Bill and at Section 31 of the Land Act, 1923, if we have to have this Bill, I have no objection to a person who is the tenant of a holding which, in the opinion of the Land Commission is not an economic holding, getting one of these farms. I have no objection to a person who has entered into an agreement with the Land Commission for the exchange of his holding getting one of these farms.
Comment on this
Section 31, which is quoted in the section the Minister is defending. You may take my word for it anyhow.
Comment on this
Romance came up on the 9.15. I wonder if the Minister got his 9.10.
"(3) A person who within 25 years before the passing of the Irish Land Act, 1903, was the tenant of a holding to which the Land Purchase Acts apply and who was evicted from that holding in consequence of proceedings taken by or on behalf of his landlord or, in case such person is dead, a person nominated by the Land Commission as his personal representative."
I have no objection to that person, but Section 25 of the Minister's own Bill says:—
"Where a person is displaced from employment on land by reason of the acquisition, resumption or purchase of that land by the Land Commission, the Land Commission may, if in their discretion they so think proper, pay to him such gratuity as they consider reasonable in respect of his displacement from employment."
That is a section of which I approve. But then sub-paragraph (d) of Section 31 of the Land Act, 1923, says:—
"A person being a labourer who by reason of the sale of any lands under the provisions of the Land Purchase Acts has been deprived of his employment on the said lands."
If you intend to purchase a going-concern farm for a man who is displaced from his employment because of the acquisition of an estate, I think that is wrong and I think that section needs amendment. I do not know if I have any objection to trustees for the purposes mentioned in Section 4 of the Irish Land Act, 1903, as extended by this Act. We got our education in various ways. Portion of mine came from the present chairman in regard to legislation by reference. It had escaped my notice up to then but, since then, I have become very keen on it. Anyone can dig up all the Land Acts which affect this particular Bill. They go back as far as the Deasy Act and at least to 1883. It is important for me to know whether or not I object to these trustees. I think I have an objection to the people under (f). The Minister includes all these people mentioned in the section of the Act of 1923:—
"(f) Any person or body to whom in the opinion of the Land Commission an advance ought to be made.
In selecting persons under this paragraph the Land Commission may have regard to the cases of persons who, or whose predecessors have been evicted from their holdings in consequence of proceedings taken by or on behalf of the landlord, and who are not included in paragraph (c) above."
If you include all these I shall be accepting at least four farms because there are a number of farms in which my forebears lived and from which they were evicted. Another peculiar thing is "any other person or body to whom in the opinion of the Land Commission an advance ought to be made." If you go back to Section 10, sub-section (1) (d) and (e) the opinion of the Land Commission gives way to the opinion of the Minister because we have in brackets:—
"(other than any determination arising in or being part of a rearrangement scheme.)"
That gives the Minister full control in the case of price and allotting. If we include (f) of sub-section (1) of Section 31 of the Land Act, 1933, as mentioned in the Bill at Section 24, I am afraid that I would not like to confer all that authority on the Minister. I think he ought to make some change in sub-section (11) in order to narrow the number of types to whom this land will be given.
First of all, these going-concern farms should be bought for a specific purpose, the purpose being the relief of congestion. I have no objection to a true representative of an evicted tenant, even at this late hour, getting land. But the problem of the existing congestion is much more important and its solution should override all other problems.
Comment on this
I am afraid that on four counts I get a farm, and there are a lot of people like me.
Comment on this
I never knew the Land Commissioners to be so liberal as to give four farms to one person. It is possible that from time to time a holding or farm may be purchased for a particular migrant. The standard holding at the present time is about 33 statute acres and it is possible that the holdings purchased may comprise 50 acres. A standard holding would, therefore, leave a balance on hands and that balance might be added to an adjoining small-holding in order to make it economic. That would be allotted by the commissioners and not by the Minister since it would have to form part of a rearrangement scheme before the Minister would come into it.
Comment on this
The whole purpose of buying these going-concern farms on the Minister's own case and on our understanding of it is to have a farm in one's hands as quickly as possible in order to relieve congestion by migration. If the Minister intends to cut up what is really an economic holding for the purpose of giving portion of it to a migrant and the remainder to someone else, the whole thing is ridiculous.
Comment on this
It is done every day by the Land Commission. They may take over 400 acres and allot 180 acres to a big migrant and turn the rest into standard holdings. What is wrong with that?
Comment on this
If we take over a 400-acre farm we should take it over under the ordinary process of the Land Commission. I think the Minister is becoming involved.
Comment on this
I think it is the Deputy who is becoming involved. I do not like the idea of the utilisation of this method. I think the ordinary method of the Land Commission should be utilised in that matter. The Minister was quite clear all the time that what he wanted was a small farm of medium size to put a migrant into.
Comment on this
If he starts chopping and changing these little farms he will ruin them. In order to have the fullest benefit we can get from this proposal, let us confine it to a very few types of grades of people. With (a), (b) and (c) of Section 31 of the Land Act of 1923 I would agree. In regard to the other three categories (f) widens the whole thing completely and will defeat the Minister's purpose. The Minister must not shake his head. Apparently he has not got the point. I think he ought to go back and take time and look over it during the Recess and come back with a proper explanation or a changed idea. Certainly, Section 25 of the present Bill cuts out (d) of Section 31 of the Land Act of 1923. It should cut out (f) as well. Will the Minister look into it?
Comment on this
I shall. However, I want to say that that has been fully examined from every angle. I shall certainly look into it again.
Comment on this
As I have not Section 31 of the Land Act of 1923 before me, would the Minister tell me if this particular section covers the case I mention?
Comment on this
Does this particular sub-section cover the point which I raised—the case of a farm of which portion may be suitable for forestry? I think it would be very desirable that this particular sub-section should enable the Minister to transfer portion of that holding to the Forestry Department.
Comment on this
I take it that Section 31 of the Land Act of 1933 covers it. If that is so, I am satisfied.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 67:—
In sub-section (11), page 14, line 24, to delete "granting new holdings to migrants" and substitute "(as the case may be) the provision of new holdings for migrants or to facilitate rearrangement of lands held in rundale or intermixed plots".
This amendment is similar to and consequential on amendment No. 56.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 68:—
In sub-section (11), page 14, line 27, to insert "sub-section (6) of Section 26 of" before "this Act".
It is just a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:—
In sub-section (12), page 14, to add at the end of the sub-section the following words: "and any such rules may be expressed to confer any powers appropriate to the purposes for which the rules are made and shall have effect accordingly."
I am informed that this amendment is necessary to forestall legal objections under the rules to be made under Section 4.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:—
In sub-section (14), page 15, to delete paragraph (4) in the definition of "State annuity" and substitute the following paragraph:—
(a) any land purchase annuity, funding annuity or annual sum, within the meaning of the Land Purchase Acts, payable to the Land Commission.
This amendment is to add to a funding annuity which was omitted by an oversight on the original drafting.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:—
To add a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) Where any such person is employed on agricultural work for wage or payment in kind on the estate, he shall be entitled to a holding on satisfactory proof that he has sufficient stock, equipment or capital to enable him to undertake the successful working of the holding.
I think this amendment is very desirable. It is true that, in the past, first preference was given to employees. That did not work out satisfactorily. Of course, I can see that the Minister can defend his section on the grounds that a number of those who were given holdings of land did not prove capable of working them. It also affords protection to other employees. Despite the fact that the regulations, I believe, stated that employees did get first preference, that was not always put into practice. In very recent years an estate in my constituency was divided. There was a large number of employees and there were two or three what you might call old retainers who were physically unfit for land and the Land Commission passed them over and they got no compensation at all. Some of those men are as a charge on the rates at the moment as a result of this provision not being there. A number of others got holdings and within the past year they have been given permission by the Land Commission to sell them. Consequently, on that score, I do not find any fault with the section. At the same time, it is very sweeping. It leaves full discretionary powers with the Land Commission to deny anybody or any employee a holding of land and give them, in lieu, cash compensation. That is why I would wish that there would be a safeguard as far as persons who worked on estates and who were, perhaps, living on them are concerned. I know that the Minister will say he has already given an assurance on the Second Reading that such types of persons are going to be treated fairly. The Minister's assurance is all right but what is in the Bill is different.
No assurance of that kind is given to anybody. It refers to employees, all and sundry, and the Land Commission can, in their absolute discretion, take exception in any particular case. If a Land Commission inspector prepares a scheme, the Land Commission, on his recommendation or report, allocates a holding to some particular individual who, in the opinion of the inspector who prepared the scheme, was a suitable person. If, after a while, it becomes apparent that the allottee did not use that land and made application for permission to sell, naturally enough, the inspector would become very irritated. If he came along and found a person on an estate, such as, say, the head of a household who, although perhaps a good and a satisfactory employee so far as his employer was concerned, was not a very thrifty person as far as his family was concerned, the Land Commission inspector might very probably take the line of action of saying: "Well, it is better to compensate this man than to give him a holding." In that case, it is not the individual concerned who would really be penalised but his family. After all, if some brake is put on the discretionary powers of the Land Commission in that way to ensure that a holding would come to the family—and it need not be vested for quite a long number of years—it would be a very great safeguard. Despite the fact that that individual, who, as I said, may have been a very satisfactory employee in carrying out another person's business but not very careful or thrifty as far as his own family was concerned, would receive monetary compensation, I am afraid that if it was handed over to him it would pass away very quickly. There would be a definite form of security if the amendment that was tabled here were inserted, and still it need not deny the Land Commission inspectors their discretionary powers in numerous cases. At the same time it would safeguard the others. Of course, the condition is here in this amendment that where any such person is employed on agricultural work for wage or payment in kind on the estate, he shall be entitled to a holding on satisfactory proof that he has sufficient stock, equipment or capital to enable him to undertake the successful working of the holding.
I think that is a very big safeguard so far as the Land Commission is concerned. If the Land Commission are to be provided with protection and given these discretionary powers to ensure that no unsuitable person will be allocated a holding, I think that on the other hand an employee of the type we have mentioned here should also be entitled to greater security. If the Minister is not accepting the amendment in this form, I expect that on the Report Stage he will be able to bring in some form of amendment to provide that security.
Comment on this
In paragraph (a), sub-section (1), of Section 31, of the Land Act of 1923, the Land Commission were empowered to give, if they saw fit, to an employee a holding of land on the estate taken over by them because, by the acquisition of that estate, the employee had lost his employment. I thought I was doing very well when I was providing for the type of employee who might have been a very short period working on an estate, who lost his employment and who, perhaps, would not be in a position to get similar employment elsewhere. That was one type of employee. Then there was the type of employee who lost his employment on an estate but to whom a holding did not offer a suitable type of alternative livelihood. It did not happen very often but it did occur on some occasions that disturbance, inconvenience and perhaps actual loss were caused to such employees when an estate was taken over. That is the reason Section 25 was introduced and I think the Deputy will agree that it is an improvement on Section 31 of the 1923 Act. It has been left to the discretion of the commissioners but I have never heard a case in which it was seriously charged against them that they treated some person who lost his employment in circumstances of this character in any harsh manner. I could not accept the amendment in the terms in which the Deputy put it forward.
Comment on this
We all welcome the amendment of the section. Deputy Beegan is quite right in saying that there has been a certain inequity in the way of compensation. I should like to ensure that everybody who worked for a reasonable time on an estate should get adequate compensation and I should like that in assessing compensation, payment in kind might also be regarded as an emolument to be compensated for. It was the practice of the Land Commission to compensate employees on an estate by giving land to them.
Comment on this
There had to be some system of selectivity. Many people who might have been a long time on an estate were found unsuitable to get land and therefore got no compensation whereas people who were only a short time on the estate and who were regarded by an inspector as suitable, got compensation away beyond their deserts. One evil was created by that. Many of those people had not the farming mentality. They had not the capital or equipment and in dealing with them the Land Commission recreated a condition which they set out to ameliorate. After a few years they gave those people, most of whom fell down on the job, permission to sell their lands. That was a most unwise proceeding and I am glad the Minister has changed it but I should like nevertheless that where possible, some provision might be made to give to a man who has real farming experience even though he may be only a part-time employee on the estate, who has equipment and who has stock, some consideration and not completely close the door on him because he may be a very valuable tenant of the Land Commission. Otherwise I welcome the section. I want to point out again that Section 25 as it stands amends Section 31 of the Land Act of 1923 which operates in regard to the former section and makes it necessary to recast the Minister's proposals in the previous section. Perhaps, the Minister would look into that.
Comment on this
I just want to point out that the land problem and the congestion problem vary from county to county and from place to place. One thing that strikes me in connection with this amendment is the position of men such as those working in the Lagan Valley in Donegal. They have been taking conacre for the last 200 years and they are real farmers. From time immemorial they have been taking plots of two and four acres and intensively cultivating them. If land is to be acquired there under Section 23, I think that some amendment of this kind should be provided because, owing to the way in which this section stands these people would of course be excluded. You are cutting out any temporary convenience lettings and presumbably that particular type of letting would be a temporary convenience letting. I do not regard the type of individual who worked these lettings as a landless man. We were talking about landless men to-day and in particular it was suggested that you could give a holding of land to some man who had no connection with a particular estate or farm at all, that you could make a present of it to somebody who was not connected with the land in that way. I invite the Minister to state now if he is prepared to take the line that we are to make up our minds once and for all to acquire land for the relief of congestion only. Are we going to say that for all time the landless man is cut out?
The Minister to-night gave two answers to that question. He stated that it was the intention to finish for all time this question of landless men, and he came along a few moments afterwards and said, not for all time, that they might come in at some later stage. The sooner the Minister, the Land Commission and the House make up their minds on this matter, the better. It is most unfair to these men who, in many instances, have been coming along to Deputies and pressing them in connection with division of estates.
It is not correct to state that harshness by the Land Commission does not occur sometimes when dividing estates, in not taking into account people working on the estates, who would have claims. We had a case of that type on the Dignam estate at Shrule, between Galway and Mayo. A man who worked there for years—the Minister, I am sure, is aware of the case—got no compensation when the estate was divided; he was not provided for. In cases like that some provision should be made. I do not include that type in the definition of landless men, as I would mean it in the ordinary sense. The Minister, before the Report Stage, should consider this matter and leave the door open to provide for special cases of that sort.
Comment on this
I think I know the case to which the Deputy refers. I made a very strong plea to the commissioners to consider his case, but because he had been six years out of employment before the Land Commission took over the estate, they refused to consider his claim.
Comment on this
The Minister can now delegate his powers to the commissioners and tell the commissioners what to do.
Comment on this
Under Section 10 of this Bill, which is now becoming law, the Minister takes unto himself very special and wide powers, and I think that is one of the matters that the Minister could deal with.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:—
In sub-section (7), page 16, line 24, to insert "as for the time being in force" before "all."
This is merely a drafting amendment. When the Bill becomes law the word "scheme" might be construed as having a very restricted meaning, which would be undesirable. Do Deputies understand what amendment No. 72 really means?
Comment on this
All the amendments to this section are my own. This is a section which is really retrospective, but it will operate for the future as well. In pre-1922 days the Lord Lieutenant had certain powers in cases where the Congested Districts Board or the Land Commission allotted fields and parks for certain purposes. He had certain powers to prescribe the type of scheme, and when I use the word "scheme" it is not to be confused with a Land Commission scheme for the allotment of land.. A scheme in this case was a document signed by the Lord Lieutenant and it set out the use to which the field could be put. The same document governed the conduct of the trustees. The Lord Lieutenant had power to appoint new trustees in certain cases, or authorise the trustees to dispose of the field if its normal use ceased.
That particular power was never transferred. It was an oversight that occurred in the change-over of Government from the British to our own people in 1921 or 1922. That oversight was not discovered until a court action brought it to light in 1939. This whole section legalises things done in the past by the Minister for Agriculture for a period, and various Ministers for Land since that time. It legalises these things and sets the matter right for the future. It is a long section and I must admit I do not understand the finer details of it—nobody but a solicitor would.
Comment on this
Are there any actions pending, or likelihood of actions at the present time, before the passing of this Bill?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:—
In sub-section (9), page 16, line 59, to insert "the scheme or by" before "or under" and to delete "both or either of".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:—
In sub-section (11), page 17, line 21, to insert " , funding annuity or annual sum" before "thereon".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:—
To add the following sub-section at the end of the section:—
(16) In this section, any reference to disposal for public purposes includes disposal for purposes related to the education, entertainment or recreation of any group, association or class of persons.
Comment on this
I am advised that it is desirable to add this definition of the expression "public purposes". Without it the words "public purposes" might be very narrowly construed and the section might not be regarded as allowing the Minister to authorise trustees to dispose of land except where it was required for State purposes or, at best, for, say, parks open to the public at large. It is obvious that the section will benefit the community very little unless it is wide enough to enable trustees to come to the rescue where land is needed for desirable purposes; for example, to provide education, entertainment or recreation facilities. Used in this way, the section could be a valuable contribution to the betterment of rural conditions. I am asking for the amendment on these grounds.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:—
To add at the end of the section the following new sub-section:—
(16) Sub-section (2) and sub-section (3) of Section 32 of the Land Act, 1933, and paragraph (a) of sub-section (6) of Section 39 of the Land Act, 1939, are hereby amended by the deletion of the words "for the inhabitants of villages, towns, or cities or for schools".
The deletion of these words will allow the Land Commission to allot sports fields to people in rural districts where they could not do so before. They were confined to what was set out in the words which I propose now to delete. The Land Commission being a Department of State dealing principally with rural Ireland, it was doubtful if the giving of sports fields in certain cases would be valid for want of such an amendment as this.
Comment on this
I do not quite understand what the Minister has said, because I find that paragraph (a) of sub section (6) of the Land Act of 1939 provides:
"Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing provisions of this section, the Land Commission shall not resume such holding or any part thereof for any purpose other than the relief of congestion in the locality in which such holding is situate, or the provision of sports fields, parks, pleasure grounds or playgrounds for the inhabitants of villages, towns or cities or for schools or the provision of gardens for schools."
Why is the Minister proposing to cut out the inhabitants of villages, towns and cities?
Comment on this
We have been informed by counsel that it was very doubtful whether a sports field could be allotted to a rural area. I do not want the Deputy to understand that we are depriving towns, cities or villages of any benefit that they enjoy at present. By the deletion of the words in the amendment they will still have the benefits which they have at present. The trouble is that the Land Commission could grant a sports field to a city like Dublin, but not to a rural district. The whole thing hinges on the definition of the word "village". By the deletion of the words proposed, the Land Commission will have the power to allot a sports field to any city, town or village or even to put it on the top of a mountain.
Comment on this
Does the Minister mean that, by the deletion of the words in the 1939 Act, he is enlarging the scope of this section? Is that the advice he has received?
Comment on this
Yes. The granting of a sports field to a rural district under the section as it stood was of doubtful validity. Perhaps the matter would never be questioned, but there was the odd chance that it might.
Comment on this
But surely, the Land Commission have been allotting land for parks in certain parts of the country.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 78:—
To add at the end of the section the following new sub-section:—
(16) To avoid doubts and without prejudice to the Interpretation Act, 1937 (No. 38 of 1937), it is hereby enacted as follows:—
(a) any reference (whether specific or otherwise) in any provision made by or under any Act other than this Act to an amendment or extension by virtue of Section 33 of the Land Act, 1933, shall be construed as a reference to an amendment or extension by virtue of this section, and
(b) nothing in this section shall prejudice or affect any matter or proceeding related to any enactment mentioned in sub-section (1) of this section and pending at the passing of this Act or any certificate given in relation to the matter or proceeding before such passing.
The purpose of the amendment is to safeguard the Land Commission from legal difficulties in proceedings for the acquisition or resumption of land.
Comment on this
As far as I can see, this amendment proposes to confer further power on the Land Commission which they may wield against anybody. I do not think that I have ever seen a Bill go through this House with so many provisions as this one contains intended to ensure that no matter what the Land Commission may do, let it be right or wrong, nobody is going to have any redress against them. This Bill is remarkable for that. The Minister, in this Bill, is providing the finest type of insurance for the Land Commission that I have ever seen in a Bill. That is the position so far as this amendment and other sections in the Bill are concerned. No matter what goes wrong, no one will have any redress against the Land Commission. If poor Pat Murphy is adversely affected in any way by anything done by the Land Commission he is not going to have any redress against them.
Comment on this
This amendment is really aimed at a tightening up arising out of flaws discovered in previous legislation. Counsel have discovered flaws in previous legislation, and, after all we cannot be blamed for putting things right. We must act legally.
Comment on this
I assure the Minister that thousands of flaws will be discovered in this Bill after it is passed.
Comment on this
I have never seen this House in the case of any other Bill, go to such lengths to ensure that nobody will have any right of redress against the Land Commission. Under one section it is provided that, whether the Land Commission are right or wrong, no action will lie against them. This amendment would seem to me to be a continuance of what I may call the building up of an iron curtain around the Land Commission. Surely, the Land Commission will make mistakes from time to time as everybody makes them. Therefore, they should be liable like other people for them, and should be prepared to take the consequences. On that general principle, I am against the amendment as I was against another section which provided buffers and safeguards for every single thing done by those inside the doors of the Land Commission from the office-boy up to the Minister himself.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy has exaggerated the effect of this amendment. When one bears in mind the history of land tenure in this country and the scope of the land code, one must admit, I think, that it would be impossible to visualise the framing of a perfect Land Act. There have been many Land Acts passed since the Deasy Act of 1860. The Deputy is right, I suppose, in thinking that counsel and solicitors will discover flaws in this Bill as they have discovered them in others. It would be foolish on my part to claim that this is a perfect measure. At the same time, I must point out that it is a very unpleasant thing for a Department of State to find, while they had been taking a certain line of action in perfect good faith over a long period in the belief that they had adequate powers under a statue to do so, that in fact, when a test case was brought to court, what they had been doing was illegal, although the illegality might not matter a row of pins. What we have been trying to do is to plug holes that have appeared in previous Acts passed in 1933, 1936 and 1939. I want to tell the House that there will be another Land Bill following on this. It will be made up practically of amendments to previous legislation.
Comment on this
I hope it will be drafted in a different manner from the way in which this has been drafted.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79:—
In sub-section (2), page 18, line 59, to delete "in".
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 80:—
In sub-section (2), page 19, line 3, to delete "intended" and substitute "proposed".
Comment on this
One might say that Section 27 is complementary to the foregoing section. It relates to 30 plots which were given out in pre-1922 days. These plots were sold to trustees of former landlords on the advice and suggestion of the then Land Commission. These trustees have never come under the benefit of the Land Purchase Acts and this section is intended to give them the benefit and not to leave them outside the pale.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 81:—
In sub-section (1), page 19, line 31, to insert "the Minister or" before "the Land Commission".
This amendment is necessary because trust instruments of this kind will in future provide for the appointment of trustees by the Minister. Unless the words "or the Minister" are inserted, as proposed in the amendment, the procedural facilities in Section 28 would not be available for use in the case of future trustees.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 82:—
After Section 28 to insert the following new section:—
Where a scheme of rearrangement or resettlement has been prepared and submitted by a Land Commission official such scheme shall be put into operation if a three-fourths majority of the people interested sign an agreement to accept such scheme.
The idea I have in my mind is to help to speed up rearrangement and avoid the usual trouble which arises in the congested areas. We know that when a scheme of rearrangement is prepared by a Land Commission inspector and submitted it is very hard to get the agreement of the parties concerned. As Deputy Moylan has often told us, it is very hard to satisfy all the people, particularly those who have been in such dire circumstances and so hard pressed for such a long time. When a reasonable rearrangement scheme has been submitted to tenants by a Land Commission official, it is wrong that any single individual should have the power unjustly to hold up such a scheme. I know of two or three areas in my constituency where there was sufficient land to bring practically all the congested holdings up to an economic size and practically all the tenants were in agreement with the scheme submitted by the Land Commission official, but, because some crank in the locality, because of jealousy that his neighbours were put on equal terms with him, refused to sign, the agreement fell through. When the best job possible has been done by a Land Commission inspector, if a majority of three-fourths of the people interested sign the agreement the scheme should be put through because, no matter what any Land Commission official or any Minister or Government will do, it will be impossible to satisfy everybody in connection with a rearrangement scheme. There will be people dissatisfied despite the best efforts of the inspector.
In order that resettlement may go ahead with a fair amount of progress, I suggest that this amendment should be accepted.
Comment on this
We have threshed out the whole question of rearrangement thoroughly on Section 10. This amendment raises it all over again. I was thinking along the same lines as those suggested by the Deputy in his amendment, but the truth of the matter is that there is no means, short of bringing out guns and bayonets, to compel a tenant to take a rearranged holding if he does not want to take it. Even if the amendment were inserted, it would never be of any use. Suggestions were made that the majority of the tenants should have power to bring objecting tenants into court to show cause why a good sound scheme should not be put into operation.
I have had the advice of the commissioners, the legal men and inspectors with excellent records and the general consensus of opinion was that any attempt at force in a matter of this kind is worse than useless. It would only cause embitterment amongst the tenants which would put off rearrangement for 20 years. The scheme must be left more or less to the tenants themselves. Even if the commissioners and the Minister and the whole of the Dáil went into a townland where 20 tenants were to be rearranged, until each of these 20 tenants is satisfied that he is getting a fair deal they will not agree. In other words, when an inspector proposes such a scheme, instead of having six commissioners, every one of the tenants will be a commissioner and much more severe and critical than any Land Commissioner. That is why we introduced a new departure by bringing in Section 10, because a rearrangement scheme is the tenants' own scheme. The whole secret of an inspector being able to put a scheme into effect is to give as even a division of the good land and bad land available as possible. When a man knows that his neighbour is not getting any more or any less than he is, then the scheme will go through. The amendment would not serve any useful purpose; neither would any other method that we can devise or think of. The whole thing depends on the goodwill of the people whose holdings are being rearranged. As a matter of fact, the less interference there is with them the better chance there is of success. No amount of pressure is any use. For that reason, I ask the Deputy not to press the amendment.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister knows that this principle has already been accepted in connection with other legislation, for instance, in the Local Authorities (Works) Act and I think in connection with rural improvement schemes. I would not put the number as low as Deputy Commons puts it, but if 90 per cent, of the people involved in a rundale area agree there should be some procedure whereby the scheme could go through at the instance of the Land Commission, subject to a simple appeal to the District Court by the 10 per cent. dissatisfied. Some rearrangement schemes which would have gone through were upset for other reasons. The Minister, when he was a Deputy, upset one down at Kiltarsaghaun by simply going out on the land and stopping the people signing. People will always be exploited in some direction. At the same time there should be some way of getting over the difficulty where in a particular rundale area nine out of ten tenants are agreeable to the rearrangement scheme and one black sheep holds out against it. In many cases the particular individual may not be responsible for his actions. I have known cases where that occurred and the whole scheme was held up for years. That has been one of the Land Commission headaches in dealing with rundale areas. Now that the Minister is putting this Bill through, I do not think he should confine himself to the 75 per cent. suggested in the amendment. Would the Minister consider a figure of 90 per cent?
Comment on this
He should take the power to deal with the crank who holds up the scheme and keeps the other unfortunate people from benefiting under it. It is unfair to the majority. I think this is a matter the Minister would be well advised to consider between this and the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy Moran will sprout wings when he hears that Kiltarsaghaun has been rearranged to the complete satisfaction of the tenants.
Comment on this
Joking apart, let me say that was achieved by one man and one man only. The tenants and the inspector in charge got instruction that they were to deal with one another and that the matter lay entirely between themselves and the inspector. He drew up a very fair scheme and achieved success where all the others had failed for the past 21 years.
Comment on this
I want to tell Deputy Moran and the other Deputies interested that there is only one secret in inducing agreement in relation to a rearrangement scheme. The first essential is fair play between all interested in the scheme. Secondly, the tenants know that the scheme will be in existence for a long time to come and it will be the last settlement for which they can hope. Very often the Land Commission is cramped for want of land, but where they can make a liberal settlement that is the best means of ensuring success. There is no other way of doing it. In most cases the tenants are reasonable. They recognise that there is not a lot of land at the disposal of the Land Commission and very often they accept settlement at a much lower valuation level than I would like to give them if I had the land at my disposal.
Comment on this
I am in agreement with a good deal of what the Minister has said. I do not know whether the Minister has had as long an interest in this resettlement problem as some of us have. We know that all the tenants in a rearrangement scheme are not brought up to the same level. An effort is made to do that, but it is impossible to make all equal.
Comment on this
That is so. Some scheme should be devised where when nine people agree the tenth will not be allowed to hold up rearrangement. There was a provision in the old days but I do not know whether it was ever enforced. If anyone refused to sign a scheme the valuation of his holding was raised to an economic standard and he had to do without any extra land.
Comment on this
I am not asking the Land Commission to enforce any such provision now. What generally happens is that the Land Commission decides to rearrange and there is not sufficient land available. There is always a delay and during that time certain portions of the available land are let for grazing at a rent to those who will ultimately benefit. When the final settlement is reached these people expect to get the same portions they had for grazing. In that way trouble arises. Some provision is necessary under which the Land Commission could hurry up these rearrangement schemes. Certain powers have been taken in other legislation, such as the Local Authorities (Works) Act, where an obstructor is taken to court if necessary.
Comment on this
But that is affecting a man's land. It is not affecting the hearthstone on which he was reared.
Comment on this
I do not want to press this, but I ask the Minister to examine it between this and the Report Stage and, if 75 per cent. agreement is too little, he can decide what the figure should be.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 84:—
After Section 28 to add a new section as follows:—
"Notwithstanding anything contained in the Land Purchase Acts the Minister is hereby empowered to give directions to the trustees appointed under the said Acts in regard to the construction and repair of river and sea embankments and the trustees concerned shall comply with any such directions."
I put down this amendment in order to get clarification of a certain type of procedure. As far as I am aware the Land Commission has only an indirect control in relation to trustees on certain estates. I would like a statement from the Minister in the matter. This has become a subject of controversy in our area on various occasions where moneys for the repair of embankments are concerned. In one case a particular trustee stood to benefit from the trust moneys and he influenced the other trustees to allocate money for the repair of his own particular embankment. Naturally the tenants objected to the money being used in that way. I raised the matter some time ago with the Land Commission and I was told that it has no direct control over these trustees. If you like, they have control over them in regard to the principal of the money invested, but not altogether, as far as I am aware. I should be glad to hear a statement from the Minister as to whether he can clarify the position. If he could do so, I would be satisfied. I should like him also to go further and to accept this amendment which would meet the point made by me on behalf of the people whom I represent.
Comment on this
I should like the Deputy to understand that the entire question of embankments and trustees is very complicated. I realise that something should be done about the matter but how it will be done or what shape it will take, I do not know. However, I guarantee to the Deputy that between this and the Report Stage I shall give the problem he has in mind full consideration to see if his points can be met. I know a little about that problem although it does not affect my particular province. Therefore, I would ask the Deputy to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I should like to say something about this matter in relation to the county in which the Minister in interested. To our amazement we discovered a fortnight ago from a statement made by the Minister that if there is something in the nature of a sluice gate or an embankment keeping out the sea, and which was erected by the Land Commission, it disclaims liability once the land has been vested.
Comment on this
Do not say "liability." The liability up to the date of vesting is the landlord's liability to his tenant. After vesting, that liability passes to the landlord, who then becomes the tenant. The tenant is no longer the tenant—he is his own landlord.
Comment on this
Some years ago these embankments and causeways and sluice gates were erected by the Land Commission. In the meantime, their holdings happened to be vested under the Land Acts and when these embankments or causeways or sluice gates break down the Land Commission disclaim liability. They say that as the estates are vested they have no further interest in the matter.
If the Minister is going to reconsider this amendment I want him to reconsider this question also. You have in these coastal areas, and particularly along the West coast of Mayo round about Kilmeena Bay, a number of these embankments and so forth which were erected by the Land Commission 20 or 30 years ago. The lands have since been vested. These embankments and so forth have, in a great many cases, broken down. Hundreds of acres round the coast are, therefore, damaged and the sea floods the farmers out. These are big and costly jobs and they are sent from post to pillar. Apparently no Department of State accepts responsibility for them. I was amazed that the Land Commission had taken this line—perhaps it is their line all over the country—in accordance with the law, that once they vest the estates they have not the necessary power to act in the matter. But if they have not the necessary power I would urge the Minister, before the Report Stage, to consider seriously whether he should take the necessary power to deal with these matters. No Department, other than the Land Commission, should be responsible for these matters. It was responsible originally for erecting these piers, barriers, sluice gates and so forth and surely it should be responsible for their maintenance. Why they should get out on a legal quibble when the lands are vested, is beyond my comprehension. If County Kerry is to be considered I would point out to the Minister that charity begins at home and that he should not forget County Mayo.
Comment on this
Originally, the principal purpose of the Land Commission was to buy out the landlords of this country and to make the tenant farmers their own owners. That occurs in the act of vesting. Some of the rights won in the past from the landlords still apply to the Land Commission so long as unvested holdings lie on their hands. The tenants on these unvested holdings enjoy the same rights against the Land Commission today as they did against the landlord in the past. The act of vesting transfers the ownership that the Land Commission bought from the landlord and hands it over to the tenants.
While I should like to see these points met I should not, at the same time, like to see the Land Commission becoming a wagon with every kind of label and tag tacked on to it and that they would do a bit of work for the Department of Industry and Commerce, for the Department of Finance, for the Department of Defence, for the Department of Justice, for the Board of Works and so on. Their sole object was to purchase the land of Ireland from the landlords and to make the tenants the owners. The relief of congestion and land resettlement have been grafted on as part of their duties. I understand that the Board of Works is there for the type of work which Deputy Flynn and Deputy Moran have in mind. We assume responsibility from time to time. We have to get the sanction of the Department of Finance for the repair of embankments and the installation of sluices and so forth, in the case of vested lands. I would point out, however, that we do that because our engineers are more familiar with the problems than the engineers of any other Government Department—not because we have a responsibility or a liability in the matter. However, I shall look into the two points.