Finance Bill, 1950—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–169 of 525. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 17 of 1950 ›
As both sides of the House seem to be very anxious to speed up the business of the Dáil, I think if the Minister were disposed to accept this amendment, it would speed up matters so far as this Bill is concerned. I think, however, it would be too much to hope that he would accede to that request. I must say that I am somewhat disappointed at, or that I regret, the absence of Deputy Aiken because I should like him to have placed before the House the information he must have in his possession as to why, during the boom period, he caused this entertainments tax on dancing to be withdrawn. He must have had a very good reason for it because at the same period he, as Minister for Finance, put a tax on the workmen's pint and on cigarettes. There must have been some very cogent reason that prompted him to suspend or withdraw the dance tax at that particular period. If we had that information, then we could ask the present Minister to give the House an explanation as to why, during a period of depression, he has reimposed the tax.
From the information which was placed before the House yesterday at Question Time and the discussions last night, it has been disclosed that the Minister not alone got what he looked for from this tax but practically twice that amount. It seems to me that the Minister has found the hen that lays the golden egg. I am inclined to suggest to him, from my personal knowledge of this business, that the golden-egg hen may be like those hens who, when placed under a battery, lay five or six eggs a day for a week and then give up the nest altogether. I suggest that the effect of this tax upon dancing may be that the golden-egg hen will, like some others, turn into a pullet. Last night from the opposite benches there was a suggestion—possibly anyone did not take it too seriously—that this amendment was introduced because the Minister represents a constituency in which there are more ballrooms situated than any constituency in the city. As a matter of fact, I think there are about 20 licensed ballrooms in the constituency which he represents. There are none at all in the constituency which I represent. As a matter of fact, he has three times the number of ballrooms in his constituency than there are in any other constituency in the city. In view of that fact, I must admire his courage in continuing to impose this tax, believing, as he does, that it is necessary to enable him to balance his budget and for the upkeep of revenue. I am sure he is convinced that the money is there and that they are in a position to continue, but I hold quite a different view.
While there are a lot of ballrooms and dance halls and hotels licensed for dancing in the Dublin North Central constituency, there are, at the same time, a lot of people living there who object to dance halls and dances, and who object to music and musicians. They would like to see this particular form of amusement wiped out altogether. I am afraid that the reimposition of this dance tax is going to go a long way to do that. I appeal to the Minister to give the matter more consideration, because I believe it deserves a lot more consideration. It has a lot more far-reaching effects than actually appear on the surface. The fact that the Minister may collect the amount of revenue he has budgeted for in respect of this tax this year, or possibly a little more, does not prove that the people engaged in the business, whether they be the proprietors or the promoters, are making any money at all.
Is it in order, a Chinn Chomhairle, for me to continue, and to refer to the second amendment which stands in my name?
Comment on this
Very well. I again appeal to the Minister to give further consideration to the matter.
Comment on this
Will the Minister not consider the abolition of the entertainment tax where charitable organisations are concerned?
Comment on this
The Deputy may not repeat what he has already said. That matter is relevant to amendment No. 4.
Comment on this
Since I spoke here last night in connection with this matter, I have met some people who are concerned with the organisation of dances. Their opinion is, as a result of their experience, that no ordinary club will be able to carry on.
Comment on this
I was listening to the Deputy last night and I say that he is repeating what he said then.
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister to consider the request I made last night regarding the position of charitable organisations—organisations which are well known and which are doing good work which the State should be doing.
Comment on this
This House ought to consider whether or not the dance hall form of entertainment has not, in fact, now become a business which one can regard to-day as an industry from the point of view of the employment it gives. Whether the Minister agrees or not, I have been informed from most reliable sources that some of these dance halls are put into the position now of giving only part-time employment to a number of their workers, including the musicians. Surely, if the Minister and the Government thought it wise to reduce the tax on spirits that had been imposed by the previous Government—thus giving an additional lease of life or a new and additional form of business in the shape of lounge bars—it would appear to be unreasonable that young people, apart from the industry involved in it, who can only find a reasonably cheap form of entertainment in these dance halls should have imposed on them this tax which is a sort of method of getting back some of the tax which had been remitted in respect of beer and spirits.
Deputy Fitzpatrick mentioned that some people object to dancing and to music. I would say that some people object to a particular type of dancing and to a particular type of music, but it is not fair to say that we in this country object to dancing as such or that we are lacking in an appreciation of music. I feel the Minister ought to have regard to the situation. In the City of Dublin, in particular, we have a great number of dance halls. They give considerable employment particularly to those who are in the musical profession and who, we know, find it very difficult to obtain a sufficient amount of work in this country to keep them constantly employed. We all heard the discussion on the Estimate for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, and we know that in a great many cases our musicians are very underpaid as compared with the payment which they might get if they were carrying on their profession outside Ireland. I hope the Minister will recognise that whatever the amount that comes into the Exchequer from the tax which this amendment seeks to have remitted, while in a sense it is not so very heavy, it bears unreasonably heavily on the people affected by it. I would ask the Minister to meet the situation and to see if, by remitting this tax, the prosperity he spoke about yesterday will not find its way also into that line of business and those who depend upon it for their livelihood.
Deputy Fitzpatrick pointed out that in the Minister's constituency there are quite a number of dance halls. As a matter of fact, they are very widespread all over the city. As I said before, whether we are concerned about the dancing aspect of the matter or not, the fact is that these businesses are there. Over a long number of years they have given definite employment to the ordinary attendants in these halls and to the musicians who, at the moment, are certainly working only part-time or half-time. I should like to repeat that it is unfair to impose on the backs of the young people, in the shape of this tax, the payment of a tax to make up portion of the tax remitted in respect of beer and spirits.
Comment on this
I support this amendment, and I should like to draw the attention of the Minister to the state of affairs which exists in Cork in connection with this tax. Practically every hurling, football and rowing club —and also organisations that are carrying out very useful social work—runs dances or Céilís in the City Hall, Cork, principally on Sunday nights. They depend largely on the profits they make out of running these functions to carry on their organisation for the rest of the year. The renewal of this tax last year had the effect of increasing the price of admission to the City Hall from 6d. per head to 1/6 and 2/-. The Minister should consider it from the point of view that it is hardly fair to the people attending the dances. It has not been increased in all cases to that exent, but most of the people running dance halls have increased it from 1/6 to 2/-. I do not think it is worth the bother and trouble and expense that this tax causes. Charitable organisations and social workers are depending to a large extent on the profits made at dances to carry on their organisations. The Catholic committee and other organisations hold dances every year, and the Minister would be doing good work if he agreed to the amendment.
Comment on this
I would like to point out to the Minister and the House that this problem varies as between the cities and the ordinary country towns. In country towns usually there is one hall which is generally the parochial hall, in which all functions for that particular unit of the community are held. That hall caters for all the local clubs, football clubs, fishing clubs and clubs of all kinds. All these organisations depend on that particular hall. During the last four or five years in virtually every country town modern halls have been erected, and large sums of money have been subscribed towards their erection. Many of these halls are very much in debt. I have been reliably informed that, due to this tax, clubs are not now using the hall in the local country town, but where possible, hold their functions in a country hall which is outside the three-mile limit. That is a very undesirable practice. It would be far better that the Minister should at least exempt from tax dances that are held for the support of any particular club in country towns. I do not know what effect it would have on the revenue, but I know that it is impossible for a country club in a country town to run a dance in the local hall and make a profit on it now. The hiring of the hall, insurance and light will cost from £12 to £20 for the night. The band, which possibly has to come a considerable distance, costs £20 to £25. With the tax on top of all that expense, the club finds itself running its dances at a loss.
The result has been, to my own knowledge, in a number of western towns at all events that where a club can find a hall outside the three-mile limit, they take over that hall and you have the town coming to the country for the functions, to a country dance hall that has not the same amenities or facilities that are available in the town. That is an undesirable practice. The Minister should reconsider this whole question. Whatever case may be made for taxing commercial dance halls or for taxing dances run solely for profit, the Minister should amend the position so that these clubs and charitable organisations can hold their functions and get some special permit whereby they will be exempt from tax.
Comment on this
It seems to me that there is a devastating air of unreality with regard to our discussions here. We have Deputy after Deputy from the Opposition condemning the Minister with regard to this entertainment tax. If their remarks were to be taken seriously, one would imagine that dance halls in the city and throughout the country were deserted, that musicians were unemployed and that some desperate calamity had befallen those who desire to attend dances. I was astonished to hear Deputy McGrath referring to the City Hall in Cork. My only experience of the City Hall in Cork in the matter of dances is of attending a very crowded one. I would agree that it was a very fine dance.
What is the situation? I wonder does Deputy McGrath or Deputy Briscoe or Deputy Moran, or any of the other Deputies who have taken part in this discussion, appreciate that they are discussing and criticising the very same tax that was imposed by them and maintained by them from 1932 to 1946.
Comment on this
For 14 years that tax was there and was clamped down by Deputy Burke and all the rest of them.
Comment on this
It was maintained by them while they were in power, with one exception. In the case of the ordinary charitable organisations, for whom Deputy Moran pleaded and to whom Deputy McGrath referred, there was a particular provision that, if the expenses exceeded 30 per cent., no remission would apply. There was no effort made under the Fianna Fáil dance tax to deal with the rural ballroom or with rural areas.
Comment on this
The position now, with regard to the tax that is being criticised by the gentlemen who are shedding crocodile tears, is that the Minister has made an effort to have regard to the charitable clubs and charitable organisations on the one hand and the country areas on the other.
Comment on this
Before I became a member of this House I was in the emergency services. I had occasion from time to time to organise dances in this city for the purpose of raising funds to provide necessary equipment and other amenities for members of the emergency services. Time after time, under the Fianna Fáil tax and under the Fianna Fáil law, I was compelled to pay tax with regard to those dances. I do not know if that experience has been shared by other Deputies but I know it was shared by members of the F.C.A. at that time. I am glad to say that this Minister who has been— I will not say pilloried because I would not regard the puny efforts of the Party opposite as carrying any weight—but who has been criticised, certainly has shown a regard for that particular situation and he has ensured that these organisations will get exemption on very fair ground, provided their expenses do not exceed 50 per cent. I should have thought that the changes he has made would have received commendation and praise from the Opposition. I can well understand Deputy Fitzpatrick making his complaint here. He at least comes with clean hands.
Comment on this
The implication is that Deputies have been told not to interrupt. They will know the implications if they continue to do so.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzpatrick, when he comes in here to complain about this tax, can at least say: "I never imposed such a tax and I was always against it." I can certainly praise Deputy Fitzpatrick in that respect, and I think he is the only Deputy who has opposed this tax who is entitled to say what he did say. It takes considerable audacity for Deputy Burke, however, who did his best to close every dance hall in County Dublin——
Comment on this
——and Deputy Briscoe who chased through the City of Dublin in his endeavour to close all the dance halls for a period of 14 years up to 1946, to make the references they made here to-day.
Comment on this
I ask Deputy Burke to withdraw from the House. He has no regard for the advice of the Chair that he should not interrupt.
Deputy P.J. Burke withdrew from the House.
Comment on this
Now that we have got rid of the snow, we can continue. Deputy Briscoe has attempted to make a case on behalf of the young people, on behalf of those who desire to have decent legitimate entertainment. Let Deputy Briscoe have no doubts about the young people—they are well able to look after themselves— and so far as dances are concerned, whether it is 1/6 or 2/- will not make the slightest difference.
Comment on this
And I hope Deputy McGrath will remember that. It will not make the slightest difference to the ordinary young people. If they want to have a night's dancing, they are not going to be stopped because of 6d.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been warned about interrupting. That is all I have to say for the present.
Comment on this
Might I remind Deputy McGrath that, when he talks about young people of Cork City or anywhere else, he is talking about young people who, if they go out to buy a seat in a picture-house, pay less now than they did when his Government was in power? That is something the young people remember. If they go to a dance once a week or once a fortnight, their feet will not be stopped from dancing merely because there is a difference of 6d. in the ticket. The proof of it is that these young people are dancing more now than they were 12 or 18 months ago. The figures given by the Minister in reply to a parliamentary question yesterday show that this tax has yielded a greater revenue than was thought feasible at the time, the reason being that more people are dancing. In view of all that, what, in the same of common sense, is the reason for all this wailing we have heard from Deputy McCann and others about the dance halls?
Comment on this
Ask Deputy Fitzpatrick, who owns a ballroom. You could not have been listening to him.
Comment on this
I am asking Deputies to tell me the reason for all this wailing, including the wailing we have heard from Deputy McGrath.
Comment on this
The Deputy obviously did not listen to the discussion at all. He knows nothing about it.
Comment on this
I know that it took me only one minute to realise that a lot of nonsense was being talked by the Opposition.
Comment on this
It seems to me that we have heard a very barren discussion in so far as opposition to the tax has made itself manifest. We have had different Deputies making speeches in which, I feel, they did not believe at all. Each of the Deputies who spoke against it, including Deputy McGrath, were parties to the imposition of a far more serious tax. Each one of them, with the possible exception of Deputy McGrath, who has not been as long in the House as Deputy McCann or Deputy Briscoe, not only was a party to the imposition of a more serious tax, but maintained it for almost the entire period of office of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Reviewing the opposition expressed, it seems to me that we are listening to a discussion of a wrong, if it be a wrong, which is far less damaging to the people than the tax which was maintained by the Opposition.
Comment on this
I was merely repeating the sentence I was saying when interrupted by Deputy McCann and Deputy McGrath. I do not think that any excuse can be put forward by the Opposition by saying that the tax was removed by them in 1946, because it is well known that the Minister who removed the tax in 1946 said he was removing it because he found difficulty in collecting it, and not because he thought the tax was wrong or a hardship in any way on the musicians for whom Deputy McCann has been singing his song. The people we represent here have witnessed, in relation to this small measure, the greatest display of political hypocrisy that this House has seen for some months.
Comment on this
In spite of the valuable advice given by Deputy O'Higgins, I do not think this Dáil or any other assembly can accept the principle that, because a tax has been enforced for a number of years—even if it were enforced for 20 years or 200 years—we are not fully entitled to discuss the reasons for the tax and to question the Minister as to the reasons for its continuance. If the Dáil is not to be allowed to express its opinion on the annual financial proposals of the Minister as to why taxation is necessary, as to why taxes should be remitted, imposed or continued, then the Dáil has no function whatever, and the sooner we close down and go home, the better for us all. An extraordinary thing in modern Parliament is that, while a vast amount of time is devoted to discussing ways in which money can be spent, not nearly enough time is devoted to considerations of how the money is being collected and, perhaps, also, more time might be given to discussing the manner in which it is expended, when collected, and to discussing whether it is being expended to the best advantage of the community. The charge against this Party was that we were a Party of squandermaniacs who had imposed heavy taxation upon the people unnecessarily. I would remind Deputy O'Higgins and anyone else who thinks with him that during an emergency period such as during the war a Government is fully justified in maintaining taxation at a fairly high level.
Comment on this
I am surely entitled to reply to Deputy O'Higgins's point that the tax was maintained by us during the emergency.
Comment on this
When the Government was confronted with the war situation from 1939 onwards, which Deputies now conveniently forget, not knowing what the future may hold, they were not going, unless there were very strong reasons indeed, to remit taxation. They had special services, which I need not go into, to maintain during the period. At the first opportunity, the tax was remitted. The present Minister and Government, which has boasted so much and so loudly of having remitted taxation, came along at the same time that they reduced taxation on alcoholic liquor, thereby encouraging the consumption of drink throughout the country, as the figures have shown——
Comment on this
To discuss the effect of a tax or remission of a tax on alcohol is not relevant to entertainment tax.
Comment on this
I think I might even argue, but I have no wish to question your ruling, that there is some comparison between the different ways in which people spend whatever money is available to them to spend on entertainment. In matters of this kind, there must be some regard to the social effects of remissions or impositions of certain classes of taxation.
Comment on this
On that contention, every Deputy would be entitled to argue on every item of the Budget the social effects—which is a ridiculous idea.
Comment on this
Leaving these considerations aside, the case I made in introducing this amendment is the inequality between the treatment of dance halls or ballrooms in rural areas and in cities and towns. Either the Minister believes this form of entertainment should be taxed or he does not. If he believes it should not, why is there a discrimination between halls in rural areas and halls in cities and towns which, as has been shown during the course of the discussion, have higher overheads and higher expenses?
Comment on this
I can congratulate Deputy O'Higgins on achieving at least one object by his inciting speech, that is, in getting a Deputy put out of the House. Beyond that, it had no effect whatever. He stands up there and blatantly accuses this side of being guilty of hypocrisy.
Comment on this
Is it in order for Deputy Lynch to state that I put a person out of this House? The Deputy has made a statement that I had a Deputy removed.
Comment on this
It is a point of order, to this effect, that the Deputy has no power to have another removed.
Comment on this
I said he was a party to having him removed. If that is not what I said, that is what I meant to say.
Comment on this
He did that by inciting repeatedly the Deputy interrupting him. If there is anything wrong in that, I withdraw, but I do not think there is.
Comment on this
I think I am entitled, in all fairness, to point out that it surely is wrong to say that I incited any breach of the rules of procedure of this House or was party to the expulsion of any Deputy.
Comment on this
He unashamedly accuses this Party of being guilty of hypocrisy in advocating the removal of this tax on dance halls. He asserts that he and his Party are the only people who can stand up here and speak with conviction on any point. I deny that entirely on behalf of each one of my colleagues on this side who spoke for the removal of this tax. The mere fact that the tax was enforced for a period of administration of government by this Party is no argument against its maintenance by the present Minister for Finance. In fact, Deputy O'Higgins's argument completely fails, inasmuch as the tax was removed in 1946. If a Government had a tax and found that it was wrong even after five, ten or 15 years, they were perfectly right in coming before the House and the public and honestly admitting that it should not be there. They are more than right when they come into this House on this occasion and argue in favour of its removal, argue in favour of their own decision in removing it.
Deputy O'Higgins said that the difference between 2/- and 1/6 was infinitesimal in so far as it affected the ordinary young person. Deputy O'Higgins possibly came of parents better off than the average person to whom Deputy McGrath referred a while ago as attending the City Hall in Cork every Sunday night. These people are working boys and girls in Cork, and the advance of the tariff from 1/6 to 2/- is an appreciable amount as far as their weekly incomes are concerned. I myself came of a big family, and our resources were not very great. I can assure the House that I would attend 100 dances at 1/6 if I could find them as against a dozen at 2/-. Deputy O'Higgins referred to that City Hall on his only visit, and misinterpreted or misconstrued what Deputy McGrath had to say. No one denies that the attendances at the City Hall in Cork for the city dances are substantial. It is nothing to see 1,000 or 1,200 there. Deputy O'Higgins says he saw the number at a Fine Gael dance in Cork. From my knowledge of the young people of Fine Gael in Cork, I can only say that there were a lot of young people there besides Fine Gael. Even if every young supporter of Fine Gael between 21 and 35 were attending that dance that night, they would hardly fill the cloakroom.
I have experience of running dances, as well as Deputy O'Higgins. I ran dances, not individually but as a member of a committee of a club during the period when the dance tax was enforced, and can give concrete figures. I can remember very well at least one occasion when out of over £100 collected the club that I represented was able to get only between £35 and £40 in gross revenue from that function. One hundred pounds represented an attendance at that dance of about 800 people at 2/6. The tax was 6d. and the dance-hall proprietor took 1/- of the remaining 2/-, leaving the club to pay the band, all the necessary advertising and all the other incidental expenses, leaving a net profit of £20 or £25—and that out of a gross take of over £100. The appeals to the Minister from this side of the House are largely devoted to trying to ensure that the tax on dances, at least in so far as it affects bona fide clubs and charitable organisations, should be withdrawn or that there should be some exemption in their favour.
I have no sympathy—or rather very little—with professional dance-hall owners. I am not saying that with reference to Deputy Fitzpatrick. I have friends who own dance halls in many parts of the country and they tell me quite straightforwardly that it is a profitable undertaking, in fact that it is one of the few undertakings at present which, once the initial cost of erecting and equipping a dance hall has been met, just cannot lose. However, these dance-hall proprietors run the vast majority of the functions on their premises on their own behalf. With the exception of parochial halls a very small percentage of the gates is given to the clubs, Muintir na Tíre or so on.
The Minister might well say in reply to the point I made that it would be impossible for him or for his inspectors to judge which is a bona fide organisation, hurling or soccer club and so on, but I say to him that that could very easily be overcome. Almost every bona fide club, hurling, soccer or rugby, is affiliated to some association or union or branch of some association or union. It would be quite easy for the inspectors or officials of the Revenue Commissioners to check up. They can get authentic information at the headquarters of the associations as to which is a bona fide club and which is not. That would prevent an unscrupulous dance-hall proprietor from advertising a dance on behalf of Red Rovers or Black Wanderers, saying that it is run on behalf of a club, when that dance is being run purely on behalf of himself by which means he would hope to evade paying the tax. I would appeal to the Minister in all sincerity to consider the suggestions which have been made from this side of the House that these bona fide organisations and clubs should receive some remission.
Comment on this
What I am suggesting to the Minister is bound up with the amendment and as we know that the Minister is obviously not prepared to accept the amendment in its entirety I might offer him some little amelioration—what we would be prepared to accept.
Returning to the position I know best, the running of dances in Cork, I would like to say that every Sunday night is taken up by some club. The city hall officials are very careful in selecting the applicants for the hall on each occasion on which it is let. I have no doubt in my mind that every time the city hall is made available to these clubs it is doing some useful work in some direction, social, cultural or athletic. It is a great hardship on clubs and organisations which have few, if any other, means of gathering funds if they must increase the cost of admission and so severely restrict the attendance. That 6d. extra or 1/- in some cases is a serious thing for the ordinary working boy or girl. If Deputy O'Higgins wishes to maintain this tax he should come out openly and not do it in an underhand or halfhearted manner. He should tell the people that he is in favour of putting an extra 6d. on their entertainment.
Comment on this
He had nothing to do with taking it off pictures and that tax would probably have come off in any case. If the Minister for Finance ever moves on to further fields Deputy O'Higgins will make just as efficient a Minister for Finance as the present Minister in the matter of imposing extra taxes on the people if this is his attitude to-day.
Comment on this
On the amendment, Deputy Derrig complains of an implication which he reads into Deputy O'Higgins's speech, that is, that the Dáil has no right to discuss this tax. Deputy O'Higgins never said that. He did say that it required a good deal of brazenness on the part of Deputies opposite to discuss this tax when for 14 years they had maintained it. Deputy Derrig's second effort was the war. War was not on or about or threatening in 1932.
Comment on this
The economic war, I see. As long as the Deputies could keep up any type of war, the tax was necessary. From 1932 to 1939 the tax was kept on whether there was a war on or not. In 1939 it was not a question of putting it on in order to restrict people from spending money in a particular way. It was just maintained and it was kept on for the whole 14 years. I want Deputy Lynch to understand the argument of this side of the House, that is, that it does require a considerable amount of impudence for Deputies who, for 14 years, supported this tax now to amass all the arguments of this despairing type which they have thrown around the House. I am told that this tax is likely to cause and has caused unemployment; did it do it for 14 years? I am told that it is destructive of the amenities of life; was it destructive for 14 years? I am told that it represents a kill-joy attitude; is that the way Deputies label themselves for 14 years?
Comment on this
You were better off; do you think so? We invite evasions by keeping the tax on; we are creating immorality in the country by inviting people to evade legitimate taxes; is that the way in which Deputies realised they were acting for 14 years? Finally, we are not favouring charities; we are not favouring culture or athletics and other sorts of social gatherings; again, do Deputies remember that that charge lies against them over the whole period from 1932 to 1946? If these arguments are real, certainly they were not discovered last year or cannot have been going on all the time. That is why I say, when I hear all the mournful nonsense which is put about the House this year, last year and the year before, that it does argue a fair amount of hypocrisy, real hypocrisy, of people who do not believe in what they are saying because if they did believe in what they are saying, they should all be here in white sheets, with ashes on their heads, on account of their shocking conduct for almost a decade and a half.
Comment on this
I am particularly annoyed to hear Deputy McGrath and Deputy Lynch speaking on this matter because Deputy Lynch, in any event, certainly countered some of the arguments regarding the lack of facilities for amusement.
With regard to the wane of dancing which has been spoken of by other Deputies, he stated that it is no uncommon matter to see 1,000 to 1,200 boys and girls at the ballroom referred to by Deputy McGrath. He told us that the Cork people found it necessary to increase the cost of the dance hall in order to restrict the attendance. You cannot have it both ways. Dancing, we are told, is going down, is on the wane. It is very odd that in Cork you can have 1,000 to 1,200 young people gathered together on a Saturday night. When Deputy McGrath was questioned by Deputy Davin as regards the charge for the dance hall, he said that the charge was £20 a time. Then, when Deputy Davin multiplied £20 by 52 weeks, Deputy McGrath replied that it is a big hall, and that its upkeep is an expensive thing. Then Deputy Con Lehane asked if the Cork Corporation had considered increasing the charges when the tax was taken off, and the Deputy replied that the charges had been increased, but that was not because the tax was done away with. The increased charge did happen to coincide with the year in which the tax was done away with. Deputy McGrath pointed out that everything was going up, and then he mentioned that the city manager said it was desirable that a better class of person should be encouraged to patronise the dances in that hall—that it was desirable to have respectable young people, and not to have the ordinary knock-abouts.
Comment on this
I hope the manager will be pleased that he has been quoted by Deputy McGrath, and that he has been correctly reported. The tax, anyhow, was not given back to the dancing community, but the charge for using the hall was increased. The Deputy stated that the city manager said it was because he wanted to keep out certain knock-abouts and restrict the dancing to a better type of attendance. Deputy Lynch said that they found it necessary in Cork to increase the charges in order to restrict the attendance. How, in the face of all that, could it be argued that this is a tax that is going to be destructive to the amenities of social life?
Comment on this
The Deputy will have the right to speak afterwards and he can say as much as he likes. So much for Cork. I have an advertisement here with regard to a dance hall which is described as being inside the Dublin area. I am not referring to a dance hall within any reasonable distance of this House. They advertised that 190,000 patrons a year use their dance hall. I was asked last night would there be any unemployment brought about by reason of the dance tax, and I waited for some time to hear some proof brought forward to show that unemployment had been caused. I have taken out a number of those who have been registered as unemployed, as between musicians and vocalists. There were 32 people registered as unemployed, men and women, in 1947; there were 33 registered as unemployed in 1948; in 1949 it rose to the amazing total of 36, and in 1950 it reached the figure of 37. That means that the number went up from 32 in 1947 to 37 in 1950.
I am told that dancing is on the wane and that dance halls are closing down because the managements cannot meet the expenses and the people who want to keep dancing going are being done out of legitimate profits. We are told that individuals and even clubs are taking themselves off to dance halls in the rural areas where dancing is free from tax. I made it free from tax in those areas. The figures for last year were requested. Detailed figures are not available which would indicate what was derived from the tax in the period before 1938. The figures are available for the half-year of 1938, but I omit them. The rate of tax is the same. I made a remission previously with regard to areas, and this year I am making a further remission. In 1938-39 the amount collected was £53,000, and in the years up to 1945-46 the amounts collected were £56,000, £56,000, £68,000, £88,000, £114,000, £132,000 and £148,000. That represents the revenue derived in the years up to 1945-46, and that was the highest year.
Having remitted the tax in regard to the rural areas, I calculated I would get about £150,000, a bigger return than was usually got from the dance tax. For last year, I calculated on £65,000 or £75,000; I got £105,000. The forecast made was not merely realised, but a 20 per cent. addition of revenue accrued to the State. That does not argue that dancing is going down. This year I calculated I would get £150,000. Perhaps I will not get it now because of the reduction in the charges, but £150,000 was looked for. It may go down to £120,000. Working on a nearly comparable basis, I look in the year ahead of us to get more money than we ever got from this tax before.
There is nothing to indicate that dancing is going down or anything like it. Last year the remission was given for the rural areas. It was calculated that that was going to cost £35,000 in an eight-months' period, or £40,000 in a full year. If I did not give any remission, I would be lucky to get £170,000. That is a good deal up. Deputy Fitzpatrick described the years 1946, 1947 and 1948 as boom years. Notwithstanding all the evasion that is going on and notwithstanding all the talk about people running off to the rural areas and all the caoining about dancing being on the wane and declining steadily because of the tax, I believe that we will get our forecasts working out pretty accurately. I believe we will get more money from this tax than we ever got before. With those figures of the amount of money that is to be collected, nobody can say that there is any likelihood of the amazing amount of unemployment that has been paraded so much in the House.
Let me come back to the tax as it now stands. In 1932 the tax was first put on and it remained there, with Fianna Fáil supporting it up to 1946. It was taken off in 1946. Why? Not because it was causing unemployment and not for the various reasons that were given in the House, if we except one, and that is the evasion aspect. The then Minister for Finance, moving the abolition of the duty said:—
"There is one duty which has been operative for some years"—
That was a euphemism—he might have said 14 years.
—"which, as well as being difficult to collect and costly to administer, is a cause of irritation and a source of dishonest practices";
There is not a word about unemployment or devastation in the country or anything like that. All these things were left off the list of the excuses given by the then Minister for Finance.
"the entertainment duty on céilithe and dances."
Then he swings into another point that I assert I have met:—
"Charitable and educational organisations are entitled to a rebate of the duty, provided they keep their expenses within 30 per cent. of their takings, which, judging from the correspondence regarding the matter, they find difficult. The incentive to evasion of this tax by organisations who want to raise funds, often for desirable local objects, causes bad feeling between the revenue officials, who are only carrying out their duty conscientiously, and the public generally, particularly the younger people. I feel that the duty tends to promote dishonest practices and impedes local initiative, and I propose to abolish it as from 1st August."
Then he gave some figures, and went on to say that
"the abolition of the duty should result in a reduction of the admission charges by approximately 20 per cent."
Of course it did not do any such thing.
Comment on this
I have not the exact date, but it was a speech made by the then Minister on the Finance Act, 1946, Section 13. Will Deputies consider that argument—that
"it was difficult to collect and costly to administer."
An analysis showed that the difficulty with regard to collection and the cost, where it was costly to administer, occurred in the rural areas. For that reason, and for another reason as well, the rural areas were exempt last year. An examination did show that, even when it was described as costly, the cost of collection was 2 per cent. It is under 2 per cent. now with the rural areas left out. The remarks of the then Minister for Finance, with regard to the difficulty of collection, were directed entirely to the rural areas, and later when he went on to speak of the bad feeling between revenue officials and the young people, that, too, had reference entirely to the rural areas. Now, we are not getting any tax from the rural areas and, to that extent, we have met the two points that were made. We have taken off the cost of collection and the difficulty in regard to bad feeling.
The other part of the case made by the then Minister for Finance was with regard to charitable and educational organisations. I had quite a volume of correspondence about that. I think I can say that 95 per cent. of the representations made to me personally or by deputations or by letters were in relation to the expense ratio in regard to the exemption from the tax in respect of charitable or other types of organisations. It was represented to me that in these days the expenses had risen, and that the old limit of 30 per cent. had no relationship to modern times. When I tried to discover from the people who came to me what limitation they themselves would consider one within which expenses could reasonably be kept I was told 50 per cent. I am not saying that many of those who told me that had made any real calculation. I think what they really had in mind was the expense ratio in England and in the North, where it is, I think, 50 per cent. They took that, I suppose, as their model. I have taken that figure, and I believe that the 50 per cent. does give a reasonable approach in the matter of dances for charitable or other purposes. I believe that in doing that I have met the points which the last Minister for Finance had urged as the reasons that operated in his mind when taking the tax off. Dancing is on the increase according to the returns. It has been the object of the revenue for all the years since 1932, with the exception of a small period in between, to get revenue in this way. For the reasons that I have given, I think it is a legitimate way to get revenue. It certainly is a more desirable way to get it than some of the ways which have been suggested to me. We will try it out this year on this 50 per cent. for charities
One does get a certain feeling of annoyance when the main attack on this is launched by Deputy Derrig on the grounds of inequality: that, in remitting the tax on the rural areas and in maintaining it in the small provincial towns and in the larger centres, there is something immoral, something unethical—that this division as between town and country is a thing that should not be accepted. When the tax was first mentioned, the clamour that came from all sides of the House was the unfairness of it to the rural areas. It was urged that the people in those areas had not very many ways of amusing themselves—that it was the one way in which people in the local small towns had of amusing themselves. The plea was also made that folk were drifting away from the rural areas to the towns, and even from the towns to the bigger centres. It was put to me, from the other side of the House, that a desirable movement to stop that drift would be to allow this type of entertainment and pictures if they could be had by travelling people—to have the pictures and dances free from tax. I agreed to that and, having agreed to it, it is now being urged that there is something vicious in having this tax.
I have yielded to the other point that was put to me about dances for charitable purposes. The point made was that the 30 per cent. did not meet modern charges. I have improved that by allowing 50 per cent. for the period of a year. That is somewhat experimental, and I can see what will happen to it. If the tax does not yield it, and if I can get any further cases that are well-established in which real charities have been hampered in getting their funds replenished, the matter can be considered.
Deputy Fitzpatrick came back to his old point that it would save costs by having the tax on the ballroom proprietors instead of having it on the individual dancers. We tested that out last year when the Deputy made the suggestion. Deputies would be astonished to find how heavy the tax would be on the proprietor of a dance hall, say, in a provincial town. If I were to look to get the tax in the way in which the Deputy has suggested I cannot see what difference it could make. If a dance hall proprietor is charged a licence duty of £300 or £400 a year he is going to get that back some way or other. Clearly, he is going to get it off the dancers. In that way the dancers will pay the proprietor of the dance hall and he will pay it to the State. As it is at the moment, the dancer pays in a more direct way to the State.
If I were to accept a lot of the argument that has been put forward in the House I would be led, I think, to believe that it was founded on some misconception or misrepresentation of what the last Minister for Finance said. I was told last year that he said it cost £85,000 to collect £80,000. He never said that, and he was never advised that that was the case. The records have been searched and no such figure can be found. The only thing that I can find in condemnation of the tax is the phrase that "it was difficult to collect and costly to administer". The cost is 2 per cent. It is a very fair ratio between costs in respect of all taxes collected by the State. If it were more costly, I could see some case for what Deputy Fitzpatrick has said. If he wants to pursue the matter I can leave it to him to work it out. I do not think his suggestion would ease the situation for small halls.
This tax has been sanctioned by practice over the last 14 years. It is not having any damaging effect so far as entertainment is concerned because people are enjoying entertainment more and more. The State is getting a trifle more as a result of this extra amusement. So far as I can see, it is not causing unemployment from any side. In these circumstances, I cannot see that any case whatever has been made against the tax.
Comment on this
I am glad that for the greater part of his last contribution to this debate the Minister dealt objectively with this matter. I can see that there are points for and against the imposition of this particular duty in this particular case in present circumstances. I think this is a matter with which one should deal objectively. I am sorry that the Minister has fallen into the same error as some other Deputies of arguing this on what somebody said about a particular tax in the past. I do not want to follow into that line of country. It is notable that people, against whom there is a large volume of evidence upon which the charges the Minister made can be based, are the first to make these charges themselves. If, on a change of view, a change of face and a change of language, hypocrisy can be argued, then the Minister on his own record is in a very weak position. I am sorry he is going out. I have his record here on this point. He has run.
Comment on this
In 1932 this tax was first imposed. I am sorry the Minister has run out, but he heard me as he was going out. It is a pity he would not stay and take his medicine. In 1932——
Comment on this
In Volume 43 of the Official Report of 5th July, 1932, here is what the Minister, then Deputy McGilligan, said when making the case against the imposition of this tax:—
"If they do not get money from the dances at the end of the year, they will have to raise money in other ways and they will probably have to increase their charges of admission to the games. That is not the biggest argument that can be used for excluding dances and balls from the scope of the entertainment duty."
He goes on then to talk about the actual position, and at column 157 here is the case he made then in regard to employment:—
"The dances give a very big amount of employment. I should say that, of casual waiters alone, from 200 to 250 will be definitely laid off work if this dance tax is persisted in."
Let me pause here to deal with the figures he has given now. He says that there is now no problem in that regard. Let me take him objectively on this point. Deputy Fitzpatrick, supporting the Minister and his Government and the possessor of very special knowledge in this particular respect, has made his case on that point. I think it should at least be considered. Deputy McCann this year and, more particularly, last year proved the case he made in that regard by quoting facts and figures. The case made by both these Deputies has not been specifically answered. Apparently their facts are not contradicted, though an attempt has been made to sidetrack them.
I said at the outset that this is admittedly a debatable point and one that must be considered objectively. The case made by these two Deputies should at least be answered and the reasons given for not acceding to their request. What answer has the Minister given? He gave certain figures. He said there were less than 40 in each case. The significant thing is that, as far as trend is concerned, the allegations made by the two Deputies I have mentioned are substantiated. The second significant point is that, in actual numbers, the figures are small, but the percentage increase is large. That is a further indication in support of these Deputies.
There is a question, then, that I would like to ask the Minister, or the Parliamentary Secretary who is deputising for him at the moment. These figures relate to the unemployment register; is that not true? Is it not true that if these musicians only lose one night in the week they do not sign and they are, therefore, ineligible? The case made is not that these lose full employment as artistes; it is that they lose a certain amount of that employment with a consequent reduction in remuneration and in their standard of living. I take it Deputy Fitzpatrick will agree with that. Therefore, the figures the Minister has quoted do not adequately answer the case made by either of these Deputies. In so far as they show a large percentage increase, they fully substantiate what these two Deputies have said; and the Minister has not answered them.
Again at column 157 of Volume 43 the Minister, then Deputy McGilligan, made the following statement:—
"There is an economic problem attached to this and it is, again, I think, part of the light-headedness of the whole arrangement that when a number of young men and women are seen tastefully, or perhaps, fancifully attired, in a ballroom, it should be immediately assumed that that represents luxury and should be taxed. There seems to have been no appreciation that these dances give employment through the catering and restaurant trades and that, by this tax, employment is going to be considerably decreased, because, undoubtedly, dances cannot survive on the same rate of admission if the tax goes on and the dancers are going to refuse to come if the price of the admission ticket is raised. That is the first point."
He goes on then to develop that. In quoting that against him now, I think there is something in the figures he has given in regard to return, and I think there is a point in his favour in regard to the buoyancy of the tax, a fact which would nullify the suggestion that dances would not be patronised. On the other hand, having regard to the case made by both Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy McCann, there is an important point which has not been met.
As a Deputy representing a city constituency, and, more particularly, as a Deputy realising that one must look at the good of the country as a whole, why should there be discrimination in regard to the city or town dweller as against the country dweller? We may not have adverted to that point when the remission was given last year in regard to the rural areas. There is a case to be made for entertainment in the rural areas, but why should the city and town dweller be in a worse position in regard to entertainment than the country dweller? The opportunities for relaxation for many city dwellers are very few and less comfortable, shall I say, than for the rural dweller. In the winter months, certainly places of entertainment in Dublin actually fulfil something more than merely supplying entertainment. They are often a refuge, particularly for the people living in our overcrowded tenements. I can, of course, hear Deputies say that there is a flight from the land and that we must do everything we can to encourage our people to stay in the country. All right, give that point its weight, too. The two points should be considered.
The next point to my mind is more serious. It is one I can remember as having been raised before I came into the House at all, and it has often been referred to as a moral problem, in relation to the motor car. Dances organised in purely rural areas, such as those held in what would be called "out in the country," in an isolated spot or a relatively isolated spot, are associated with difficulties of supervision, with lack of amenities, and with certain temptations to certain types of person who, having got away from their own environment, are relatively unknown. That gives rise to a problem which I need not expand, but it has been discussed here at various times. Because of the very fact that in towns and cities the halls are situated in crowded localities, that there are many people around, that there are facilities and amenities, that by reason of their very location they are much nearer to the supervision of the Gardaí, these problems do not arise. There is not the same temptation for a person to go from one dance to another as out in the country. Generally speaking, there is that particular problem in regard to rural dances. It is undoubtedly a fact that if you give preferential treatment in regard to the tax on dances that are held out in the heart of the country as against dances in the towns, you will tend to stimulate the holding of dances in such locations for the purpose of evading the tax and consequently that problem, if that problem exists, as we have been assured by many responsible citizens that it does exist—as I say it arose in regard to the motor car—it should be adverted to in relation to this tax, and the Minister should give an answer to it.
This amendment has been put down to bring about a discussion on that problem. The facts of the situation are that undoubtedly the tax was there for 14 years. Our experience while it was there is a useful one to advert to. Equally it was removed in 1946, and our experience in that regard is worth adverting to also. Again the reasons given by the Minister for its removal in 1946 are worth adverting to. A further qualification of that is that when the Minister gave his reasons for its removal in 1946, he said the difficulty about its collection was due to the fact that many of these dances were held in the rural areas. The Minister met that by the adjustment he made last year in regard to rural areas. Our answer to that is that so long as you are up against this further difficulty, it is questionable whether your solution is the best or most desirable one or the best approach to getting revenue. I think that is the way the case lies. Although some of us dislike trying to base an argument merely on what somebody else said, we have to deal with the question on the facts of the situation and objectively in present-day circumstances. I might again legitimately remark that it is a funny thing—I am sorry that neither Deputy O'Higgins nor the Minister is here—that if you look back on the records of the people who were quickest to make allegations about dishonesty, twisting or improper motives, very often you will find in the records of these same people the largest amount of evidence for basing such allegations.
Comment on this
Listening to Deputy de Valera, one can only come to the conclusion that he has no idea of the conditions under which amusements are carried on in rural Ireland when he compares conditions in the rural areas with the conditions in the City of Dublin. Dances in the country are held only occasionally. To my knowledge, many of the musicians who run dances in the country are people who are employed at other occupations during the week and who run a dance band as a side line. They go to these country halls only a very odd time. On the other hand, look at the dances held in Dublin City. You see crowds going to the halls of the city. You see motor cars parked outside the Gresham Hotel bringing crowds to dances where the admission prices range as high as 30/- to 50/-. We hear Deputies complaining bitterly of this tax now but when the tax was first introduced they were in power and they never said a word. It did affect the poor people just as much then as it does now. Deputy Briscoe mentioned that the Minister removed the tax from drink. We all know that you cannot do without a drink but you can do without dancing.
Comment on this
I should like to see ceilidhe dancing free of tax, and also to see outdoor dancing exempted. When I passed through Kerry some months ago I was surprised and delighted to discover a crossroads dance in progress when I stopped at a certain crossroads—a fine healthy thing out in God's pure air.
Comment on this
I am a bit too heavy for that, but you could do it. I suggest that it is a waste of time for Fianna Fáil Deputies to put up an argument against this tax when they did not do so for the 14 years it was in operation while they were in office.
Comment on this
You kept it on when times were worse than they are now and when the workers' wages were pegged down. I think the dance halls in the City of Dublin have become a bit of a racket and people are making big profits out of them. The prices of admission to dances throughout the country range from 2/6 to 5/-, from 5/- to 7/6 and even from 10/- to £1. What do these dances mean to the poor people about whom we hear so much talk? You know yourselves what they mean for any man who has a big family. If he has boys and girls, one of the greatest worries he has is these dance halls. I think that you should try to control the prices of admission to these dance halls instead of asking about the tax which is put on them. Take the case of a man who has four boys who attend a dance once a month to which the admission price is 5/-. That means that he has to pay £1 out of his pocket every month. There is no control over prices of admission. Tell me of one dance manager in the country who reduced his prices of admission when the tax was reduced. The price remained and that was that. When the tax was increased in respect of, among other things, amusements in the Supplementary Budget which was introduced by Fianna Fáil we did not hear much protest from Deputy Major de Valera or from any of those Deputies who were then sitting on this side of the House. Not one of them said one word against these increases. The pictures are more important to the working man than dancing.
Comment on this
They are more damaging, too.
Comment on this
The working man likes to go into the picture house and rest himself after his hard day's work. He pays his 4d. and goes in. The majority of the people do not worry about dances at all. I would point out that in the case of a person who knows how to dance, no price will stop him from going to dances. He will go because there are other attractions—not the dance alone. Is that not true? That alone is not bringing them to the dance. If I were the Minister I would stop jitterbugging, jazz and foreign dances in this country because they are ruining our young boys and girls. The sooner Deputies cease to refer to debates which were held in this House in the past, the better.
Comment on this
Who opened them? I was never in a lounge bar in my life. There are very few of them in rural Ireland. They are almost all in the city.
Comment on this
They do not affect us at all. I believe that the less talk there is on that, the better for the Deputies on the Opposition side of the House. There seems to be a craze for dancing. We are constantly hearing about dances being run for this, that and the other. That shows that there is money in it. Fianna Fáil go around the country organising Fianna Fáil dances. Fine Gael does likewise.
Comment on this
So does Labour. Why? Because they are making a profit. Therefore, it is not affecting the people at all. I feel that it is wrong to delay the time of the House in discussing this matter—especially Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party whose Government a few years ago imposed extra taxation in their Supplementary Budget. These Deputies had nothing to say then.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy O'Leary is right when he says that there is no point in prolonging this argument, because it would appear that the Minister's mind is definitely made up. The Minister has failed to answer the arguments advanced by myself, by Deputy Fitzpatrick and by other speakers on this side of the House. He says that our arguments are based on a misconception, but his reply is based on a complete misconception. He fails completely to understand the position.
I made a simple statement that unemployment had increased since the reimposition of this tax. Deputy Fitzpatrick, speaking later, substantiated my statement by saying that the musicians, who formerly had been employed six nights a week, and other personnel of ballrooms, are now being employed only three nights a week. The Minister quotes unemployment figures. With his long experience he must know that the figures which he quoted mean nothing in regard to this case. Musicians, as Deputy Fitzpatrick said, are paid at the rate of 7/6 per hour. For working four hours a night that would amount to 30/-. They earn, say, £9 a week if they are working full time. However, if as is happening now and has been happening for some time, the number of hours they work per week are cut in half, their income is reduced from £8 or £9 a week to about £4 10s. a week. That is the position. No person who is working for one night as a dance musician and earning 30/- will bother to go to the labour exchange and sign on there. He does not do it. He goes to the Federation of Irish Musicians. There is a register there and I understand that, in the ordinary way, those who sign it are sent out as jobs or engagements come in. I made that submission on the basis of a brief which was given to me by the Federation of Irish Musicians. The Minister says he doubts my statement. If the Minister doubts my statement then he is doubting the word of the representatives of some hundreds of musicians in this city.
There is another aspect to the matter. Since the tax was taken off there is no doubt at all about it but that, in the City of Dublin—I am speaking of the City of Dublin only because that is all I am intimately acquainted with—numbers of ballrooms and dance halls have come into being and are giving employment to musicians and others. We have very talented musicians in this city. I know two people who won senior awards for violin playing at the Feis Ceoil and who are now earning fairly substantial salaries as dance-band leaders in this city. We get numbers of musicians from our schools and particularly from the Municipal School of Music, of the committee of which I happen to be chairman. I know the potentialities and I know what has happened. I know that numbers of people have got employment. There are numbers of good musicians who would never have got employment if the dance-hall business had not come on in the way in which it did after the tax was remitted. I repeat the statement that unemployment has been caused on a fairly wide scale and that the majority of the musicians are working on very short time. Some of them are working only two nights a week and others three nights a week. If the Minister thinks it is worth while to collect £100,000 a year and to cut people's wages in half, then I can only say that the sooner the Minister and the Government of which he is a member go to the public and test public opinion the better.
Comment on this
I opposed this unpopular and irritating type of tax when it was originally imposed by Deputy MacEntee when he was Minister for Finance in the Fianna Fáil Government. I argued in favour of its abolition last year because it was, like every new tax which is imposed, unpopular and because I thought it was a very irritating type of tax in the way I know it to be administered in some parts of the country. I also opposed it because I thought that the amount to be collected was costing too much. I must admit that, from the figures given by the Minister for Finance to-day—and previously given, I think, too—there is very little ground left for further argument on that. If it is costing only less than 2 per cent. to collect £150,000 in this financial year, then the cost of collection is not worthy of so much time being wasted on it. Every Government, no matter what kind of a Government it may be, that claims to be a democratic Government, when it wants to look for more money to carry on essential services or to develop the resources of the country, is bound to look to the people with the money, the people who can afford the money, to find the increased taxation that must be found from time to time. When a democratic Government goes to look for more money for the purposes I have mentioned, it has to get the people who have the money and impose a tax where the cost of collecting that tax is going to cause the least possible confusion and where the cost of collection is kept down to a minimum. It is only natural to assume that, before people go to a dance, to a race meeting, to the cinema or to some other form of amusement, they will, if they are sensible and ordinary citizens, make proper provision for their food, clothes and the payment of other essentials such as rent. If they have money left for amusement, there is nothing wrong, from a democratic point of view, in looking to such people for whatever increased taxation may be necessary in order to provide for the needs of the poorer section of the population.
What I want to know from Deputy Derrig, Deputy Major de Valera and my old friend, Deputy McGrath, from Cork City, is why this tax was originally imposed in 1932. What was the main purpose of going to the people who patronise dance halls to collect another £100,000 or £150,000 from them? Why was it imposed at that particular period? Deputy Derrig, Deputy Major de Valera and Deputy Lynch and every other Deputy sitting on the Fianna Fáil Benches who has spoken to-day have evaded that very important point. I must confess, as one of those who have been described as the seven sinners at the time, that although I was opposed to the tax, which was introduced by Deputy MacEntee in his first Fianna Fáil Budget, I had to swallow the pill and walk into the Division Lobby, very reluctantly, and vote for the imposition of the tax. But I opposed it.
Comment on this
Then you will have to swallow the pill again.
Comment on this
I would like to hear from Deputy Major de Valera, if he speaks again on this matter, as I am sure he will, what was the main purpose of imposing the tax originally in 1932. Whoever suggests that dancing is becoming unpopular must surely be convinced, on the figures given by the Minister for Finance this evening, that that is not so. Quite accidentally, I visited a modern dance hall, situated in a rural area on the boundary of two or three constituencies, last week. I was informed that as many as 920 young men and women attended a dance recently in that up-to-date hall which my colleague on the opposite side, Deputy Beegan, knows better than I do. I am not sure whether or not the registered capacity of the hall was exceeded by the attendance of 920 persons. In this particular case the young men and women left the provincial towns and went out into a rural area to enjoy themselves, as they are entitled to do, to the extent of 920. That does not show that in the area that Deputy Beegan comes from dancing is becoming unpopular.
If this tax is to be continued and if there is any justification for its continuance, from my point of view, it should not be applied to the organisers of dances which are for the purpose of getting funds for either political, social or charitable organisations. The majority of dances held outside the four principal cities, are, to my limited knowledge—I may be corrected on this —held for the purpose, not of putting more money into the pockets of the organisers or promoters, but for the purpose of finding money that is essential for the maintenance of political clubs, social clubs and charitable bodies.
Comment on this
I had my eye wiped. It is not unusual for a Deputy, even Deputy Donnellan, to have his eye wiped on an odd occasion. I was staying in an hotel in a provincial town in my constituency. I had intended retiring at the ordinary time when a gentleman asked me if I would go to a dance which was being held in a particular hall. It is a very decent hall, which is run by professional ballroom owners. I asked what the dance was for. I was told: "It is the poor man's dance." I was given the impression, by the words used, that the dance was for the purpose of raising money for the St. Vincent de Paul Society. I could have got free admission to the hall but I insisted on paying for myself and my friends, being under the impression that the profits would go to the St. Vincent de Paul Society. I discovered, before the dance was half way through, that it was for the purpose of putting more money into the pockets of the poor people who own that fine ballroom. They made a good thing on it for the night. I would have liked to have been able to get in touch with the Minister for Finance and to say to him: "In view of the attendance here to-night, there is a good deal of money to be scooped up here, and get at that type of person."
Having listened to this debate for a considerable time, having very definite views on this particular tax, having opposed it in 1932 when it was originally introduced, having argued in favour of its total abolition last year, I would like to hear from Deputy Derrig, Deputy Major de Valera or anybody else on the Fianna Fáil Benches what was the real reason for its imposition in 1932 and what are the reasons for its abolition to-day if its introduction was justifiable in 1932.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin has invited a rejoinder. I happen to have the volume in regard to 1932 here, but, looking objectively at this problem, the situation is that it was imposed in 1932; there have been 14 years' experience of its working. There was sufficient experience of its working to have it abolished in 1946, for reasons then given, some of which have been quoted by the Minister. The Minister tacitly admitted the force of some of these arguments for its abolition in 1946, but he says that he met those by the arrangement which he has made for exempting rural areas and his proposal in regard to charities. Now, admittedly, that is a case. As I have said, I see in this definitely a debatable problem, but, again, the point remains that the steps that the Minister took are not a completely unobjectionable approach or obviation of the reason why that tax was abolished after 14 years' experience of it.
Secondly, a strong case has been made by both Deputy McCann and Deputy Fitzpatrick which has not been answered. It is not enough to try to sidetrack the argument by saying that that is a dishonest approach. I have quoted the Minister in 1932 in that regard. The net position is whether it is better for the House to adopt this amendment now, putting the position back to the 1946 position, or to find the money as the Minister proposes to find it. The Party in opposition here have moved this amendment and have advocated the case on that. We say that that case has not been completely answered.
One can add very little to the debate beyond that because, after all, it is the factual position at the present moment that we are concerned with, not an analysis as to anybody's motives in the past.
Comment on this
There are many approaches to this particular problem. I think the most reasonable one has been taken by Deputy Fitzpatrick in the suggestions he has made to the Minister. These suggestions clearly are suggestions that are put forward by the persons who organise dances in the way in which they ought properly to be organised, by the provision of first-class halls, with first-class amenities. The provision of these halls, which are necessary from the point of view of the social life of the people, is a very expensive business. There are different types of dances, but, so far as ballroom dancing, properly organised, in Dublin and other cities is concerned, dancing is, as it were, just part of the particular business. There is the employment of the musicians, very excellent employment; there is the employment of other staff such as waiters, waitresses and attendants of one kind or another. These dances give considerable and valuable employment almost all the year round. The imposition of the tax has undoubtedly led to the closing down of some of the first-class ballrooms in Dublin City and it has undoubtedly led to the disemployment of musicians and of other persons generally employed in connection with dances.
These ballroom proprietors do not say to the Minister: "Abolish the tax entirely." What they say is: "Instead of charging it on the admission charges per head, put a specific tax of whatever amount you will on the dance halls." There is a lot to be said for that. By the imposition of such a tax, the ballroom proprietors will know where they stand and the organising committees of different functions will be called on to contribute a particular proportion of the impost, but, nevertheless, the business of dancing will go on, and, while it goes on, the employment that goes with it will continue. I would very strongly support that recommendation to the Minister. It would save a lot of checking, of testing and of holding people up now and again to find out whether they had paid the tax or not. It would obviate and avoid that type of inconvenience to the ordinary people attending dances.
It may be that the Minister will not get the same revenue as he gets at the moment, but he will get a very substantial part of it and it is a matter for him to consider, from many points of view, whether it would not be better to lose a portion of the revenue he is getting, if, by doing so, he ensures that there will be no disemployment of musicians, waiters, waitresses, stewards and other people generally employed in connection with dancing.
I agree with what Deputy Davin has said. Most of the dances in rural areas are organised not just for the sake of dancing alone, but for the purpose of financing political organisations, social organisations, athletic clubs, football or hurling clubs or swimming clubs. The main source of revenue of these organisations has been the dance. I had some practical experience recently in connection with the organisation of such functions for the purpose of obtaining funds and the fact is that the net result to the promoting club is very small. The natural result of that will be some form of tax evasion, and there is tax evasion everywhere. From a general social point of view, it is demoralising to the community if groups here and there through the country organising dances for very good social purposes, such as the maintenance of a football team or an athletic club, are drawn into illegalities or drawn into adopting some method of avoiding the tax. That is bad from the general point of view, and I would ask the Minister to reconsider the whole matter in the light of the contributions made by the different Deputies. If the Minister does that, he will probably come to the conclusion that it would be worth giving a trial to the suggestion put forward on behalf of the ballroom proprietors by Deputy Fitzpatrick. It would be well worth a trial and it may bring him in an amount very close to the amount he is getting from the tax imposed and collected in the way in which it is imposed and collected at present.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 4:—
In line 31 to delete all words after "1950" to the end of the section and substitute "by the deletion of the words `and that the expenses in respect of the entertainment did not exceed 30 per cent. of the takings in respect thereof.' "
I hope that the Minister will see his way to accept this amendment, even if he accepts it only on an experimental basis for the next 12 months. I cannot see any justification—and I never did— for what I term the means test on charities. When the Revenue Commissioners are perfectly satisfied that an entertainment is run for a charitable institution there should be no means test as to the amount of the expenses. I have got many explanations for this 30 per cent. being introduced originally. It was suggested to me that the reason for introducing that clause that the expenses of an entertainment run for charity should be kept under 30 per cent. was to prevent individuals, either the promoters or ballroom proprietors, from organising dances themselves for a genuine charitable institution and arranging with that institution that they should hand over a percentage of the profits.
I would point out to the Minister that if that is the main reason for maintaining this percentage clause, whether it be 30 per cent. or 50 per cent., the individual it aims at eliminating will still be there, and that there is a great reason why genuine charitable organisations should take individual promoters or proprietors into their confidence and association for the purpose of protecting themselves, because the individual promoter can at any time make out a balance sheet or report in such a way that the Revenue Commissioners cannot find any flaw. If the incentive is there to evade the tax and if the promoters are running the dance for a charitable organisation there is nothing to prevent them if they have an attendance of 400 from making out their returns showing that the attendance was 200. That reason has not been given to me officially but it has from time to time been submitted to me outside this House.
I would point out to the Minister that by maintaining this clause not alone is he putting the promoters of genuine charitable functions to great inconvenience and annoyance but he is also imposing great inconvenience on the revenue officials. The procedure that has been adopted and that will continue to be adopted under this clause is that any committee organising a dance to raise funds for a charitable institution must first go to the nearest revenue office and apply for exemption. They fill in a form giving the approximate number of people they expect will attend and the price of admission. If the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that it is a genuine charitable function they will give the exemption but they will take from the promoters a deposit. Where the price of admission is 3/- and the number of people expected 400, the Revenue Commissioners take from the committee a deposit of at least £15. When the returns are sent in if they are not under the stipulated percentage the Revenue Commissioners will have sufficient from the deposit for the tax.
Before the function is held the committee are faced with the deposit of, say, £15 to the Revenue Commissioners; they must pay a deposit of £5 or £7 on the ballroom they are engaging, and they must pay for the printing of dance tickets, so that before they get one penny they must have at least £25 in hand. Where are they going to get that? If the function is for a genuine charity the practice has been to go to various people and secure from them a subscription. Some years ago when the committee running a dance for a charity solicited and secured subscriptions from supporters the subscriptions were taken into account as portion of their income and the tickets they sold to people who were not going to the dance but who bought one to support the charity were also taken into account. I am not quite sure but I understand that the present system is that when the Revenue Commissioners are tallying the percentage the only money they take into account as receipts is the money paid into the cash box for tickets on the night of the dance. They may have very good reasons for that. They may feel that if the committee wanted to evade the tax or get back their deposit they could claim that a number of tickets were sold to people who did not turn up and they could put down the names of individuals who gave them subscriptions of £1, £3 or £5 towards the initial expenses. One might be inclined to feel that those subscriptions were never handed in. If they were never handed in, I would like to ask the Minister how does he think that any committee that got together for the purpose of holding a function for charity can get the initial expenses? They have to deposit with the Revenue Commissioners a sum equivalent to £15 where they expect about 400 people to attend. They have to pay the deposit on the ballroom and they have to pay for the printing of the dance tickets and a certain amount of advertising. Consequently, they must get subscriptions and they must raise money somewhere.
In view of all these obligations, and all the trouble that is given to the committee and to the Revenue Commissioners, I think that this means test —and I cannot call it anything else— is not justified and I ask the Minister to accept this amendment, at least for the period of one year, and where the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied— and they must be satisfied—to give them power to give exemption to committees running charitable dances. I am perfectly satisfied from what I know of charitable institutions that they will not lend their names in such a way that anybody can make money out of them. This matter warrants a certain amount of consideration. It is the cause of great annoyance.
The Minister made a passing reference to charitable dances and said he was losing a lot by increasing the percentage from 30 to 50 per cent. I do not agree with him. He may undoubtedly be making it more convenient and comfortable for committees that set out to raise funds because they will know at least if they take £20 on the door they can spend £9 19s. without losing the deposit and if they take £40 they can spend £20. Anyone with knowledge of organising these functions will know that you cannot book a ballroom, open it up that night and people will be found outside waiting to get in, waiting for the place to open so that they can go in and dance. Like every other business, it has to be well organised. Where charitable functions are well organised, they give a good return to the promoters, but where the promoters are hampered—and I claim that they are by this means test—it will be practically impossible for them to run a dance and run it straight.
Even charitable organisations have had to adopt the method I suggested for the purpose of getting back the deposit. Take any group of people, select representatives from each Party in this House, for example, and form them into a committee to run a dance, say, for some member of the House or a charitable institution outside. If they have to deposit £15 or £25, when they come to make up that deposit a certain human feeling will enter into the matter. They do not consider they are doing anything wrong. They set out to raise money for a charitable institution; they do not set out to raise money for the revenue, and when it comes to making a return they may feel inclined to increase the receipts by increasing the number who attended or reduce the expenditure by arranging with the band leader or someone else to say that he got only £5 where you paid £10 or £15.
I think the Minister should accept this amendment and carry out an experiment, say, for 12 months. I know the ability and the power and the influence of the Revenue Commissioners to find out whether people are attempting to use charitable organisations for the purpose of making money for themselves. The Revenue Commissioners are quite capable of dealing with them. I trust he will accept the amendment and try it out for experimental purposes for one year.
Comment on this
It appears that Deputy Fitzpatrick has made a strong case for the amendment. I do not propose to repeat what he has said. I commend it to the Minister. It strikes me that essentially what is involved here is that when giving this exemption to charity there is a consciousness either that certain evasion could or would take place or that the function, nominally charitable, could in effect work out as lucrative for a particular business interest. The provision that is complained of is one that naturally suggests itself to somebody dealing with it on paper. We all know that that type of thing does not work out in practice. It seems from what Deputy Fitzpatrick said as if it is so in the present case. The revenue officials, who have to determine whether a thing is bona fide charitable or not, will in the last analysis be put to a certain general investigation and on top of that they must consider the bona fides of the promoters.
Comment on this
From what Deputy Fitzpatrick says, they do.
Comment on this
I think I do. The bona fides enter to this extent. As Deputy Fitzpatrick suggested, there may be a temptation to pay a certain amount to a band and on the basis of that hand over a certain figure to the Revenue Commissioners. If such matters arise, perhaps it would be better for the Minister to take the risk that is involved and avoid complications of the sort that the Deputy mentioned.
Comment on this
I may have misunderstood Deputy Fitzpatrick.
Comment on this
I have. The Minister's amendment is by way of relief, raising it from 30 per cent. to 50 per cent. Deputy Fitzpatrick's amendment is simply the deletion of any percentage.
Comment on this
If every dance in Dublin were run for St. Vincent de Paul, there would be no dance tax— that is what it comes to. If every dance in Dublin gave St. Vincent de Paul only one pound at the end of the night, it would be exempt.
Comment on this
I quite appreciate that, but is there not a case even in that regard to be made for Deputy Fitzpatrick's amendment? Is there not a case, even supposing that only a small sum were to be given to charity?
Comment on this
Even if there was only that, it would mean a very substantial amount. What is going to happen in a case like this is that people will not promote these things or permit them to be promoted for a valid charitable purpose.
Comment on this
There is no question of permission. When the net proceeds are devoted to a charitable purpose, then there is no tax. If the managers of picture houses agree that for the future they will give a half per cent., or .05 is taken for charity—that is the position.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzpatrick has made his case for this amendment. The second point is that the Minister is making a case which can be equally met by another procedure. The submission of an amendment of this nature does not purport to be an exhaustive suggestion to the Minister. We are always satisfied if the Minister will say that he will take the spirit of it and will meet the case as best as he can. The Minister, for instance, could do that by dealing with the people who actually promote the dance and seeing that a certain percentage goes to charitable purposes. Deputy Fitzpatrick has made his case in regard to the particular form of this. I quite admit that the Minister may have to make some other arrangement to avoid the pitfalls which he sees. If he will not accept the amendment, and if the section is allowed to stand as it is, he could bring in an additional protective section saying that where the dance is bona fide promoted by and for a charitable purpose—if he wants to define a charitable purpose to suit himself he can do it—that then this limit in regard to expenses would not be there.
The Minister has raised some pertinent points in regard to the amendment. Taking what both the Minister and Deputy Fitzpatrick have said I am wondering if the case could not be met by a further section to be introduced by the Minister on the Report Stage on the lines I have suggested.
Comment on this
The section in the Finance Act of 1943 which is being amended by my own amendment in the Finance Bill is this:—
"Whenever it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the whole of the net proceeds of an entertainment held on or after the 1st day of August, 1943, are devoted and will be applied to educational, philanthropic or charitable purposes and that the expenses in respect of the entertainment did not exceed 30 per cent. of the takings in respect thereof, the Revenue Commissioners shall remit..."
I propose to amend that by having it read in this way:—
"Whenever it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the whole of the net proceeds of an entertainment held on or after the 1st day of August, 1950, are devoted and will be applied to educational, philanthropic or charitable purposes and that the expenses in respect of the entertainment did not exceed 50 per cent. of the takings in respect thereof, the Revenue Commissioners shall remit...."
That is my amendment. To that Deputy Fitzpatrick moves that the section shall read this way:—
"Whenever it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the whole of the net proceeds of an entertainment held on or after the 1st day of August, 1943, are devoted and will be applied to educational, philanthropic or charitable purposes the Revenue Commissioners shall remit...."
That means without any evasion and without anything in the way of bad conduct on the part of any charitable organisation. That is, to ask that cinemas, dancing, greyhound racing, cine-variety shows can be run on the basis that the whole of the net proceeds, after the proprietors have subtracted what they think are their expenses, will go to charity, and that then there is no tax. What is in question here is £1,300,000. I need not get one penny of that tax if the amendment were passed. Suppose every dance in the Gresham were run on that basis, and that the whole of the net proceeds were to go to a charitable organisation. If £5 were the whole of the net proceeds, it would go to charity, and then there is no tax to be paid. The same thing would apply to cinematograph shows and other classes of entertainment for charitable purposes. What the amendment means is that if the whole of the net proceeds are to go to the Vincent de Paul Society, then there is no tax paid. That is what is being discussed, but I do not think that is what is meant.
Comment on this
It is not. I do not know how the Minister can adopt that attitude towards the amendment. I am sure he understands that is not what is meant. It was not contained in any suggestion that was made in support of the amendment.
Comment on this
What I am suggesting is that by trying to keep the expenses under 30 per cent. or 50 per cent. is no guarantee that people will not evade the tax if they can. What I am suggesting as a remedy is that the means test should be abolished. It is a question of where the Revenue Commissioners must be satisfied.