Finance Bill, 1950—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 170–351 of 525. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 17 of 1950 ›
That is not the amendment. Where it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the whole of the net proceeds are going to charity, that is all they have to be satisfied about.
Comment on this
I would be satisfied if the Minister would accept my view on the matter and if he would put it in legal form. I have told the Minister that the 50 per cent. gives no protection to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
I have not a legal mind but I have practical knowledge, and people with practical knowledge oftentimes hit on the truth, while the legal mind may float around it. I am recommending to the Minister that the percentage is no guarantee. I want to leave it in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners that, where dances are organised for a genuine charity, there will be no means test.
Comment on this
The difference between us is just what is in the two amendments, and I do not think it is capable of being patched up. I should have mentioned this before. The 30 per cent. and the 50 per cent. are no standards because the people would evade. I want that fact remembered. We are thinking here of charitable, philanthropic and educational societies. Whether it is 30 per cent. or 50 per cent. they will evade it. They will either increase the receipts or lower the expenses. The Deputy says the people would not lend themselves or their names to any evasion. Now, we are both talking about the same people.
Comment on this
We definitely are. The question is as to whether it is an educational, philanthropic or charitable purpose. That is where the case rests. The Deputy's point is evasion. There may have been evasion with regard to the 30 per cent. and the temptation to evasion is less at the 50 per cent. I do not pay much heed to Opposition Deputies speaking about evasion because they allowed that temptation to grow for 14 years and they did not even bother to change it from the 30 per cent. to 50 per cent.
Now, the test with regard to a charitable organisation is that expenses ought to be lower than they are in the case of the commercial enterprise, because, in the former, people give their services free. Therefore, in the old days it was thought that if one could keep one's expenses below the 30 per cent. level, one had a good case for saying that the rest was charity and that the organisation was a charitable one. We quite recognise that the expenses of hiring a band, and everything else, have gone up and we have decided on a figure of 50 per cent. I have taken 50 per cent. as an interpretation of the expression of opinion given to me by quite a number of people who came to see me on deputations. When I told them that it was a question of raising the expenses limit in an upward direction, 50 per cent. was the suggestion I got. We are trying the 50 per cent. for experimental purposes this year. The Deputy must realise that the difference between us is either 50 per cent. or nothing. There is a limit to the expenses that may be charged before one can call it charity. The Deputy's amendment is "nothing" because it lays it down that when the net profits go to a charitable purpose there should be no tax. Then it is open to the managers of every picture house and dance hall to say: "From this time on no entertainment, no greyhound race, no cine-variety show, no dance hall will be run except on condition that the whole of the net profit, after we take our expenses, goes to charity." From that moment, I lose £1,300,000. That will be the effect of this amendment. The Deputy says he will accept any change I may like to make, but it is for him to suggest an alternative. If he thinks 50 per cent. is not enough, does he want 60 per cent.? I think a 20 per cent. advance on 30 per cent. is not a bad advance for an experimental year. Whatever the expenses are, as long as there is 1/- over and above the net profit, and that goes to charity, then there will be no tax coming to the State. I could not possibly accept that. That would not merely wipe out the tax on dances, but on all entertainments, greyhounds, cine-variety shows and the theatre.
Comment on this
One can appreciate the Minister's point. The whole of the net profits, as the Minister has pointed out, would be open to a dangerously wide interpretation if the following words were not there. On the other hand, the Minister has been a little hard on Deputy Fitzpatrick, who has a very good point on the merits. The Minister has asked him if he can make any suggestion. Frankly, it is difficult to see how the section as it stands can be amended.
I suggest again to the Minister that he should consider between this and the Report Stage the introduction of a section to the effect that "where an entertainment is organised by and for the purposes of a recognised charitable organisation". Of course, I recognise then that he will have to define certain well-known charitable organisations, such as the St. Vincent de Paul, certain Church charities, and so on. There would be nothing wrong then in giving the Minister a deciding power as to what does or does not constitute a charitable organisation.
Comment on this
The St. Vincent de Paul Society is a recognised charitable organisation. Under that amendment, if the St. Vincent de Paul Society decided to run every dance, dance proprietors would lend themselves to that in their own interests and there would be no tax.
Comment on this
No. The Minister is going too far with it. Prima facie, there is a strong case for exemption in the case of a dance or fête run by the St. Vincent de Paul Society—I merely take that as an example—for their own purposes.
Comment on this
I said by and on behalf of. "And" is what I said.
Comment on this
It may not. The Minister is a bit hard on Deputy Fitzpatrick. These people will want to make the maximum profit and that will be the Minister's actual safeguard. The evil the Minister fears will not eventuate because these people will want to make all the money they can on these dances and so on. I throw that out as a suggestion of a possible way of resolving the difficulty, a difficulty which undoubtedly exists from Deputy Fitzpatrick's point of view and also from the Minister's point of view.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister to consider the matter. I do not ask him to give actual guarantees now. I do not think there would be evasions, if it had first to be clearly shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the function was for a genuine charitable purpose. I am not thinking in terms of cinema proprietors, the managers of commercial ballrooms or the promoters of commercial dances. I am thinking of committees established for the purpose of implementing the work of a charitable institution. If they clearly demonstrate to the Revenue Commissioners that it is for charitable purposes, then the Revenue Commissioners would be the deciding factor. I regard the Revenue Commissioners as a pretty tough factor.
Comment on this
Apparently the Revenue Commissioners have been got over in the past because evasion has taken place.
Comment on this
I have nothing to say against Deputy Fitzpatrick's proposed amendment. I believe Deputy Fitzpatrick to be quite sincere and genuine. I would draw the Minister's attention to the fact that all over the country it is a common practice to issue complimentary tickets. I speak now on behalf of the people who will benefit by this tax. I do not see why they should be either penalised or victimised whilst others can bring grist to their own particular mill and avoid the payment of tax by issuing complimentary tickets. I would like the Minister to take that into consideration in relation to this particular tax.
Comment on this
I am raising it to 50 per cent. There appears to be about 49 per cent. of a difference between the Deputy and myself. I might as well write 99 per cent. in there.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:—
Before Section 8 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) In this section the expression "firearms certificate" means a firearms certificate granted under the Firearms Act, 1925 (No. 17 of 1925).
(2) The excise duty in respect of a firearms certificate imposed by Section 40 of the Finance Act, 1925 (No. 28 of 1925), shall, in the case of any such certificate coming into force on or after the 1st day of August, 1950, be charged, levied and paid at the rates specified in the Second Schedule to the Finance Act, 1925, in lieu of the rates specified in the First Schedule to the Finance Act, 1949.
The situation in regard to this amendment is that under the 1949 Act the Minister has increased the tax payable in respect of firearms. The effect of the amendment is to bring back the rate payable in respect of firearms to what it was previously. The real bone of contention is that utilitarian type of firearm—the shotgun—which is, I understand, a matter of some importance for farmers. The amount payable in respect of that was seriously increased by the Minister last year.
Comment on this
Exactly, doubled. It was doubled last year. The Minister may be quite contemptuous about the doubling of the 5/- fee on firearms but it is one of these very irritating things——
Comment on this
I should not be a bit surprised at that but it has nothing whatever to do with the tax.
Comment on this
That point merely obviates any argument that it has decreased the number of guns. I think the number of guns would have increased in any event but the point is that it is an irritating tax on farmers and it is doubtful whether it is really justified, having regard to the use to which this type of firearms is put. A case might also be made in respect of the .22 rifle but some of the farmer Deputies can give more explicit information on the subject than I can.
The schedule in regard to firearm certicates shows that the rate for rifles, including miniature rifles, was increased from 5/- to £1 and for shotguns from 5/- to 10/- in one case doubling, and in the other case quadrupling the amount payable. It seems to be, as I say, merely an irritation and it is proposed in the amendment that the increase should be nullified.
Comment on this
Originally the proposal for this increase came, not from the revenue side, but from the Department of Justice. They made the case that, as the rates had been unchanged since 1925, in relation to the value of money an increase was overdue. An estimate was taken from various sources to ascertain whether if the rates were increased there would be any falling off in the number of certificates taken out. Last year I estimated that I would get £30,000 in a full year. In fact I got £40,000.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 6: —
Before Section 8 to insert a new section as follows:—
The entertainments duty chargeable on payments for admission to a céilidhe, ball or dance shall be reduced by 50 per cent., where it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that professional Irish dance musicians are engaged.
I am moving this amendment because I am perfectly satisfied that the reimposition of the dance tax caused unemployment, principally among what are known as professional dance musicians. Professional dance musicians serve what might be termed a new form of society that has come into being as a result of the increasing popularity of dancing which started about ten years ago and the erection in the country of a number of larger ballrooms. Ten years ago we had, especially in Dublin, no large ballrooms at all, and as far as I remember we had no people working full-time in ballrooms who could be termed professional musicians. Prior to that, 20 years ago, before the advent of the motion pictures, quite a number of very good professional musicians were employed in the theatres. The majority of them were dismissed and some of them were taken into the picture houses during the time of the silent films. With the introduction of the talkie motion picture, the services of the musicians were dispensed with. Recently, quite a number of people — some of them were people who were originally employed in theatres and picture houses — started again to find reasonable employment in the ballrooms where they were engaged nightly. Three years ago there were eight ballrooms in the city giving full-time employment to dance orchestras every night in the week. During the past couple of years one of them has closed altogether and one ballroom, where there used to be dancing during the summer, has discontinued that practice, while some others have reduced the number of nights when dancing is held from seven to three or four. The result is that great hardship is inflicted on those people who were earning their living as full-time musicians.
In addition, some professional dance musicians went around the country attending dances in the cities and larger towns. Up to recently, they were well paid. They claimed that their livelihood was threatened by the reintroduction of the dance tax. Their organisation, the Federation of Irish Musicians, placed their case before the Minister last year. Due to some misunderstanding, the Minister did not receive it or, certainly, did not receive it in time. This year, they put a statement before the Minister in which they set out in very definite form that their fears of 12 months ago were only too well founded. They take, for example, four ballrooms in this city. They claim in their statement to the Minister that their men employed as professional musicians in these ballrooms; over a seven-months' period, had their hours of employment reduced by 6,222. That represented a total loss in money, at the rate of 7/6 per hour, of approximately £2,400.
That is a rather serious matter for professional musicians in Ireland. They are a type that are not being encouraged. I had to complain in this House before that they were not getting the encouragement they should get from Radio Éireann. I now have to complain that another Minister is depriving them through the reimposition of this dance tax of the opportunity they had of earning a very profitable living.
There is another form of invasion into their territory in respect of which they have a grievance. It is the position whereby English dance orchestras are allowed to come over here. Some Irish promoters, but principally English promoters, book ten or 12 ballrooms and bring over English bands and, because they are advertised as broadcasting orchestras from the B.B.C. and have been heard over the radio, the people in this country, foolishly enough, go to hear them. They do not realise that, in going to hear English orchestras, they are depriving Irish musicians of an opportunity to earn a livelihood. The Minister should give some guarantee or protection to Irish musicians.
I suggest that where professional musicians are employed the tax would be reduced by 50 per cent. I know there are certain difficulties in this because, while a number of larger ballrooms in the cities employ full-time professional musicians, there is another section of ballroom proprietors who employ part-time musicians, men who follow some other avocation during the day and take up a job in a dance band at night. That is the difficulty I see in the Minister accepting this amendment without giving it very serious consideration but, on the other hand, I can point out to him that these men have a federation of their own and that, to my personal knowledge, at least four ballrooms in this city employ full-time professional men who do not work during the day and who have no other means of livelihood. Their means of livelihood has been taken from them.
They claim, through the federation, in a memorandum submitted to the Minister, that the reimposition of the dance tax has interfered with them to a great extent. They have also complained, if not to the Minister, to me and to Deputies who represent the City of Dublin, that the position whereby foreign dance orchestras are allowed to come in here is detrimental to them.
I would ask the Minister to give this matter very serious consideration. I hope, although it may be too much to hope, that he will accept this amendment. I had great hope that he would have accepted my previous amendment but he found a lot of legal difficulties to it. I hope that, if there are any difficulties in regard to this amendment, they will not be legal difficulties and that I will be able to argue with him on man-to-man terms.
The position of those men who are employed as professional dance musicians — and there is a great number of them — deserves some consideration. They deserve some protection. They have made their case to the Minister. There is no need for me to delay the House in reviewing it. I have quoted the figures. They have given the Minister the names of the ballrooms in which they have been engaged. They claim that they have lost £2,400 in wages in four ballrooms over a period of seven months. That is a very serious state of affairs that well merits the serious consideration of the Minister.
Comment on this
It would be interesting and very important to get the Minister's mind on this amendment and the succeeding amendment. The whole question of a profession which has the least means of defending itself is involved. It is a profession which is extremely useful to the community in general, not merely in Dublin but in other big centres of population and wherever they go all over the country for the purpose of carrying on their profession. It is rather an anomaly that we should have penalised their work to such an extent that it is easier for an English band with a name or reputation to come over here and play than it is for these people to reach that height of proficiency that they would have equal claim on the popularity of the people.
As to the details of the amendment or the way in which the Minister may deal with it, it is a matter really for himself, his draftsmen and the Revenue Commissioners. But, having regard to it in the context of the present situation in Ireland, where we want to make life as attractive as possible for visitors, it is not merely a matter of amusement but is a matter of serious business.
Comment on this
Here is a tie-up that makes it more difficult than if they were to get the concession.
Comment on this
The concession would have this effect, that it would favour very much the development of interest in this country by visitors. I would like to know what the Minister's attitude towards this is.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not here when this matter was discussed earlier. If I kept the tax on dances in the way in which Fianna Fáil had it, my estimated revenue next year would be £175,000. I have made certain remissions. I lost £35,000 or £45,000 through exempting the rural areas. If Deputy Little had been here earlier, he would have been disgusted, he having been one of the promoters of this scheme of brightening life in the countryside, to hear Deputy Derrig all out against it, saying that it was unfair and iniquitous discrimination as between town and country. However, the Deputies are taking the first step towards a coalition. Having a little freedom of mind and differences of opinion, they will, after a year or two, coalesce.
Here is the comparison I want to make. On the comparable basis, £175,000 would be the revenue gathered in this year from the tax. In 1945-46, the highest year under Fianna Fáil, it was £148,000; in 1944-45 it was £132,000; and in the year before that, £114,000, after which it tapers away to the £50,000 level. The tax being the same, if the revenue is greater, I argue that it means there is more dancing.
Comment on this
More dancing. This is a tax on dancing and therefore it is more dancing. If I had not made these remissions with regard to the 50 per cent. expense ratio, costing about £30,000 and the other remission costing £45,000, I would be getting far more than ever was got in any period under Fianna Fáil. I think that argues that there is more dancing, and, if there is more dancing, I cannot understand how it is that there is any unemployment amongst dance bands or people who officiate at these functions.
Comment on this
Who says there is? There have been statements made by the Federation of Irish Musicians about their loss of £2,600 between so many people.
Comment on this
Deputy McCann I do not regard as an authority. He was one of the great "keeners" in 1948 and last year. "Dancing was going to `pot' and they would all be killed by this"— but the duty brought in more money even though the rural areas were exempted, and that argues more dancing. I have the returns here with regard to unemployment. The number of musicians and vocalists registered as unemployed in 1947 was 32. It went up to 33 the next year, to 36 the next year and to 37 in the following year.
Comment on this
That is the return of the people who register and we have the dance returns. In addition, we have this enormous development with regard to people who say they had 190,000 patrons last year and advertising that as being the biggest they ever had. That is the situation with regard to dancing generally.
I do not know exactly what the special problem is that Deputy Fitzpatrick has in mind. The phrase on which his amendment pivots is "if professional Irish dance musicians are engaged", and in that case he wants the duty remitted. From my information, there are very few cases in which there are non-national musicians employed. If the advent of English dance bands became in any way serious, we could have another look at this matter, but I have not got any information that it is. I cannot parade myself as being a special authority in this matter, but I go occasionally to these functions, and, in the past 12 months, I do not think I have ever been to a function at which an English dance band was advertised.
Comment on this
I do, and I see an odd one advertised, but, in comparison with the number of dances run, they are very small. If there is a suggestion that we adopt a new form of protection and tax the foreign dance musician or musicians coming in from outside, we can consider it, if it becomes an evil. The point of the Deputy's amendment is the word "professional" and he wants the tax remitted where the band is composed not of amateurs but of professionals. That is going to put him and the officials of the Revenue Department to considerable trouble. I shall have to get from him a definition of "professional", but perhaps that is not the Deputy's point at all.
Comment on this
Professional dance musicians are men who earn their living by playing in a dance orchestra and who have no other job.
Comment on this
They are people who have other occupations. Remember that Deputy Fitzpatrick puts it very far — they are not to be occupied at anything else except their dance band work. Again, I should have to get figures in that regard. For the moment, I could not think of accepting this because it would mean, on the information I have, which is to the effect that in the main Irish nationals are employed at these dances, and as there is no definition of "professional", that I would be remitting the tax, as to half, in respect of pretty nearly the whole of the dances held in the country, and no case has been made for that yet. However, if the Deputy will leave it over, I can look into it, particularly if I get figures showing that there is any evil in respect of foreign dance band musicians coming in here or anything really evil in having people who are otherwise occupied at certain times playing as dance musicians. I am not sure that it would be desirable to drive the whole thing into the hands of what the Deputy now calls the professional dance musician. It used to be the situation in the old days that by far the great majority of those who played in dance bands were people with other occupations during the day who came into the dance band in the evening. Those were the days when dances on the whole ran to a much later hour in the morning than the average dance now does.
Comment on this
The Minister has given the list of figures of the registered unemployed, but he was not here when the point was made in answer to that. In so far as these figures show anything, they show that the number of unemployed in that profession increased and that the percentage increase was considerable.
Comment on this
The Minister can wave that aside or be contemptuous, if he likes, but, in so far as these figures show a trend, they show an increase in unemployment in that category and a relatively large percentage increase; but the real point about these figures is that the repercussions on that type of people, as Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy McCann pointed out, is to deprive them of a certain amount of their work and a certain amount of their remuneration, but still to leave them employed within the meaning of the Unemployment Assistance Acts and they either cannot or do not register. In other words, the registered unemployed in that regard are no indication whatever of the hardship that group of people are suffering. So much in answer to the figures adduced by the Minister.
Comment on this
That is another point. The Minister says there is much more dancing. That does not necessarily prove anything either, because one can immediately think of reactions to such a thing as a tax like this which will not be such as to show in either the number of people attending a dance or the number of dances held, but may very well show themselves in a counterbalancing reduction of the expenses incurred in the running of these dances. I quoted, when the Minister was out, what he said in 1932 about this tax and a lot of his own arguments could be turned against him but that is neither here nor there. The point is that it may be that these people are being victimised through being the point at which the tax is recouped to the sponsors of dances. I do not know. I merely got up to make the point in reply to the Minister's figures, since he was not here when it was made previously.
Comment on this
Might I support the plea made by Deputy Fitzpatrick and ask the Minister to give the matter consideration and to agree that, where there is a full band of 12 or 14, getting good wages, a full concession be given? Where there is a reduced number in the band, he could have a grading and allow a percentage according to the number of people employed. In many halls where dances are run for charity or by sports organisation trying to raise the wind, you find a band of six people. We might not ask the Minister to give full remission where there is a small band, but only 50 per cent. If he could work out a scale, so that a hall engaging a full band of 12 — the most I have seen—would get full remission and where there is only seven or eight a reduced remission; and if it goes down to a lesser number than six, then 50 per cent. I think it could be done. It was suggested to the Minister once before and favourably commented upon. If he would meet Deputy Fitzpatrick in that way and meet those anxious to see that the musicians get employment and more working hours, I think he would be doing good work.
Recently in Dublin one of our leading bands, an excellent band, has broken up and those able to earn a good living in entertaining our people handsomely with good music are seeking employment in other directions. If this remission were given, that band might be able to get together again. If the Minister cannot accept the amendment, he should give Deputy Fitzpatrick and those supporting him and the musicians and the union a little encouragement that the matter will be considered.
Comment on this
The point I made in the Minister's absence this afternoon was that the figures the Minister quoted meant nothing in relation to the argument put before the House. The question of 32 or 33 musicians registering as unemployed has no relation whatever to the question. Prior to the reimposition of the duty, there was full-time employment for practically every member of the Irish Musicians' Federation — which, I would remind the Minister, is a registered trade union with a negotiating licence and which caters for full-time musicians. The musicians of whom I am speaking are the dance band musicians on practically full-time employment. I said I did not want to make any exaggerated statement. The case we made here was that these men were losing a certain number of hours per week. Where they were employed for six nights in the week, now they are being employed only for three nights and in some cases for two. They work for, say, four hours in the night and are paid at the rate of 7/6 an hour, which is 30/- per night or, say, £9 per week. If you cut their hours in half, you have that man's week's earnings. That is the point I made. That is why I reminded the Minister that the statement submitted by the Federation of Irish Musicians related to man hours and did not relate to the number of individuals who had been disemployed. They do not sign at the labour exchange. The majority of these men will look for work and travel to any part of the country where they will get an engagement. There is a register kept at the offices, which the Minister may inspect or see a copy of. It contains the names of all the musicians. It must be kept, and when an engagement comes in one of the men on the easy list will be sent out. It is not a question of going to Gardiner Street and signing. They do not do that, since if a man works for a night he will earn 30/- and quite obviously if he is earning £3 or £4 a week it is useless for him to go to the labour exchange, as he will not get any supplemental allowance. It is quite useless for him to sign as a dance musician when the work is not there. The submission I made was that there was full-time employment for these men. The Minister doubted the submission that unemployment has come about by the reimposition of the duty. He doubts me. I asked him did he doubt Deputy Fitzpatrick. I do not know whether he does or not. I am speaking, as I said earlier, as one who has been briefed by the Irish Federation of Musicians and if he doubts me he doubts the representatives of the organisation which represents some hundreds of musicians in this city. Last year he refused to see these people and discuss the matter with them. If he could get closer to them and were prepared to meet them and listen to them, he might turn a more sympathetic ear.
It is easy for people sitting in snug comfort, with two or three positions and incomes, to say that it is nothing to have men's livelihoods cut in half. I am not speaking here in the sense of caoining or wailing; I am representing here, as I am entitled to do, the views of my constituents, and I will continue to do that. If the Minister took a trip through his own constituency more often and could get nearer to the people whom he is supposed to represent here, he would have a different viewpoint on this question, as he has on a great many more.
Comment on this
As a representative of rural Ireland, I believe there was never such a boom in dancing as there is at present. In the small town from which I come, with a population of 2,000, we have two dance bands and they are not idle, as there is scarcely a night when they have not an engagement. If there is a small bit of hardship caused in Dublin, after all, Dublin is quite able to bear it. If they are professional musicians, as Deputy McCann says, surely they could relate themselves to some other class of gainful work during the couple of days in the week they would not be engaged, just as the bands do in rural Ireland; except in the case of the extreme professional bands such as Mick Delahunty's and Pat Crowley's, which are absolutely professional? I think it is a nonsensical argument pure and simple. There may be some musicians idle in Dublin but in the rest of Ireland, as far as I can see, and I see the provincial and weekly papers, it is nothing but dances, dances, dances.
Comment on this
I submit to the Minister that the increased revenue which he contends he is getting, and will get, is due to the more strict enforcement of the stamp duty on admission. It is not indicative of increased dancing.
Comment on this
That is a grand theory, but it does not bear any examination. Deputy McCann is terribly worried about unemployment, particularly amongst dance people. In 1938-39, Deputy McCann had the tax kept on, at a time when it was bringing in less than £53,000. Next year, on the comparable basis, it will bring in three times that. Does Deputy Kennedy think that three times the amount brought in in 1938-39 is due to that enforcement? I think it is ridiculous. If there is unemployment being caused, when there is so much dancing that a tax of a particular type will bring in £175,000, what must the unemployment have been when dancing was reduced to such a point that the revenue was only £53,000 and Deputy McCann's heart did not bleed?
Comment on this
Over a period of years it has become more popular. It goes in cycles in the dance business.
Comment on this
It is certainly going in a great cycle at the moment. £175,000 would come in in comparison with £53,000 in 1938-39; yet people are talking about unemployment.
Comment on this
The Minister's view is that nobody is suffering?
Comment on this
The Deputy can take it that I do not believe these "keeners" who talk about vast unemployment in dance bands.
Comment on this
They are up against those figures and I have the number of people registered and they are all pointers. On the 7th June, 1947, when there was no tax 32 people registered as musicians and vocalists unemployed. The number in that particular section has risen to 37.
Comment on this
I do not care what percentage it is. That is the figure of unemployed musicians. There is such an amount of dancing that the same tax brings in three times what it brought in 1938-39.
Comment on this
The Deputy is saying that the people went into the business, and also that more people are unemployed. Why does he not take the jump with me to last year when the tax went up from £108,000 — £140,000 would be the comparable figure — up to £175,000. "More unemployed." The point is that as the tax went up there were more employed and there is more dancing still this year; we forecast it.
Deputy Byrne's point about full bands is not the amendment. I do not know how it works out. The Deputy probably did not mean it but he suggested that with a full band of 12 there should be full remission of tax. Every dance hall would have 12 people as it would be worth their while in order to get the remission. To have a variety of people in groups of 12 in employment would not, I think, be worth while.
There is more dancing. Deputy Keane was right when he said that dancing had gone up and up.
Comment on this
Of course there are; there must be. Deputy McCann said in 1948 without any tax being put on that dancing was on the wane. I was told last year when the revenue did not show any slackening: "Ah, that is because before the tax went on people made contracts but they will never make them again."
Comment on this
I know the Dublin situation too and there is no falling off in dancing in Dublin. The amazing thing to me is: if dancing is falling off and the tax is the same how do I get more revenue? That is the poser I put.
Deputy Fitzpatrick made a case regarding imported musicians if I might call them that. I do not believe that there are many. He also made a case for professional musicians versus semiprofessionals or complete amateurs. I would like to look into the matter but I am not accepting the view that a professional is at all times to be preferred to a semi-professional. A person who is able to eat under two headings might be quite a desirable person. However, I will get the figures.
Comment on this
I did not suggest that he is to be preferred but I did suggest that a professional musician, a man with no other form of employment should get priority treatment. I am anxious that those people should not be put on the unemployment line.
I would like to help the Minister to clear his mind about the number of people who have registered as unemployed. The information I have presented to him was handed to me by the Federation of Dance Musicians and it sets out the number of man hours lost by four dance bands employed in four ballrooms in the city of Dublin and the amount of money they lost. I do not suggest that one or two men were knocked off but I suggest that where they played four hours a night they were reduced to three hours and where they played seven nights a week they were reduced to six. It worked out that the four dance bands lost 6,222 man hours and £2,400. That is information given to you and the Federation of Dance Musicians does not just make the case; they give you the names of the ballrooms where the people were employed. If necessary it would be quite an easy matter to check up and find out if these particulars are correct or not. You can accept from me however that I happen to know that the figures are correct. In order to give professional musicians a chance I will bring to your notice——
Comment on this
I suppose the Deputy understands that he is supposed to be addressing the Chair. I have nothing to do with dance bands.
Comment on this
Through you, Sir, I bring this position to the notice of the Minister. There was also something of which he is apparently not aware: there are a number of English dance bands coming into this country, getting well paid for playing in the country, and going away. I do not know, but I suggest that the Minister is not able to secure from them the income-tax he is losing where Irish professional dance musicians are knocked off. I am satisfied with the assurance the Minister has given that he is prepared to look into the matter of the invasion of English dance musicians and into the question of professionals versus semiprofessionals.
Comment on this
Question put: "That leave be given to withdraw amendment No. 6."
Do you agree with this result?
Are we to understand that the Minister's reply to a question put to him by a member of the House is that he is not capable of explaining the section, and that he cannot assist the House any further than by merely reading it?
Comment on this
I think the Minister might have the courtesy to explain the concession which he is making in this particular section. We have this legislation by reference. He might tell us the significance of paragraphs (a) to (f) of sub-section (4) of Section 24 of the Finance Act, 1949. I think it would be rather an advantage if the Minister explained that. However, I am not pressing this.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Minister cannot give any information to the House, have we to take his word for it that he knows what the section means?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:—
Before Section 17 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) The stamp duties chargeable on conveyances or transfers of lands, tenements and hereditaments under the heading "Conveyance or transfer on sale of any property" in the First Schedule to the Stamp Act, 1891, as amended by subsequent enactments, shall, on and after the 1st day of December, 1950, be at the rate of 10/- for every £50 or fractional part of £50 of the amount or value of the consideration in lieu of the rates immediately theretofore chargeable.
(2) Sub-section (1) of Section 13 of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 1947, is hereby repealed.
I think it would be convenient if amendments Nos. 8 and 9 were discussed together. The point involved is the same in both. The essential point to be remembered, in regard to these rates of stamp duties, is that in a particular situation resulting from speculation in house property at the end of, and towards the end of the war there was a strong case to be made for the duties which were imposed at that time by the Finance (No. 2) Act of 1947. There was a certain amount of speculation in and transference of property at that time which was having an inflationary effect on the value of property. It was putting up the price of houses. Superimposed on that, there was a complaint at that time, a complaint incidentally which was very strongly voiced by some members who are supporting the Government now, that there was a flood of non-citizens, of people from across the water, coming in here and buying property.
Comment on this
On a point of order. As I read the two amendments, the first proposes to insert a new section. Then there is a repeal provision. Part of the legislation which was repealed is the part which makes special provision for a case where the consideration does not exceed £500. That is not attended to in these amendments. The result of it is that, if the consideration were £300, the duty under the existing law would be 30/-. Under these amendments the duty would be £3. I suggest that is imposing a charge and that the Deputy is not entitled to move the amendment.
Comment on this
I was going to deal with that matter on this amendment. I think I can show that it is not increasing a charge. Anyway, if such would follow and if the Minister were to accept the principle of the amendment a supplementary amendment could very easily meet that.
Comment on this
I am not familiar with all the clauses in the Finance Bill, but, on the Minister's showing, there would be a charge.
Comment on this
On the Minister's showing it would, as it stands, in regard to between £500 and £1,000.
Comment on this
The intention here is to propose that the tax go back to the previous rate.
Comment on this
The Chair cannot deal with intentions. That is the unfortunate portion of it. If the amendment proposes a charge it may not be moved.
Comment on this
Would the Minister allow me to parse the section?
Comment on this
There is no provision where it is under £500. "In any other case where the amount or value of the consideration does not exceed £500"— that is what the Minister is referring to.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy is reading from. I am reading his amendment, and that phrase is not there.
Comment on this
The amendment is simply to replace sub-section (1) of Section 13 by a sub-section in identical terms. It is the sub-section that is repealed.
Comment on this
Before Section 17 of the present Act to insert a new section. The effect of the insertion of that new section is to substitute for sub-section (1) of Section 13 of the Act a sub-section in exactly the same terms but with a reduced rate. I say that the Minister is not accurate in what he says. I shall explain the reason for the way in which the section is proposed at the moment. The net effect is to change the words "rate of £2 10s. 0d." occurring in Section 13 to "a rate of 10/-". That is really what the effect is, and no other.
Comment on this
There is nothing in either amendment to say that they are in substitution for something else. Their purpose is to insert a new section. If the effect would be to impose a charge, then they cannot be moved.
Comment on this
I submit that is not so because the only effect of this section is to delete sub-section (1) of Section 13 — in other words to repeal it — and to substitute instead this new section. The effect, though it is not done in that particular way, is to substitute instead a sub-section which is identical in terms and merely has the figure "10/-" instead of £2 10s. 0d. I submit the Minister is mistaken in what he has said in that regard. The net effect is that it simply deletes sub-section (1) of Section 13 and substitutes another provision. Now that can be done in either of two ways. One can do it simply by deleting the words "£2 10s. 0d. for every £50" and substitute therefor the figure "10/-", or one can do it in the way in which it has been done here. It amounts to exactly the same thing in either case because it only repeals that particular sub-section and the remainder of Section 13 stands fast. This new sub-section takes the place of sub-section (1) and the net legal effect is the same.
Comment on this
I submit that, in fact, it does. I submit that if we adopt it the position will be precisely the same. As a matter of amendment, I submit it is immaterial whether you amend it in one way or the other. For a reason, which I shall deal with later, I think this method of doing it is probably preferable to the alternative method.
Comment on this
Let me answer the Minister's £500 case. Sub-section (1) of this section shall not apply. I agree one would probably want thereafter consequential amendments.
Comment on this
For instance, it would be desirable in consequential amendments to go on and deal with the scale in particular that is already there.
Comment on this
That is the trouble. There is a lacuna. It does not affect what the Deputy says. I take it that the Minister would oppose a charge. I think the Deputy himself has admitted that other consequential amendments would be required.
Comment on this
Admittedly they would be required. I was going to suggest that. In brief, the intention was——
Comment on this
The Chair is not concerned with intentions. The Chair can only deal with what is there.
Comment on this
What I am asking the Minister to do in this connection is to bring these duties — that is, in regard to the stamp duty in the case of Irish citizens — back to their old level; we would be content then to leave the 25 per cent. there. That was the difficulty.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact there is a flaw in the second amendment, since it sweeps the 25 per cent. away altogether. If you read the amendments together, they certainly seem to me to imply that the 25 per cent. is put out of legislation altogether.
Comment on this
I see the way it is. I agree with the Minister that sub-section (1) of this section would have to be amended to apply where this new section would not apply. Is not that the position?
Comment on this
On a point of order. Perhaps the Ceann Comhairle would be able to enlighten us as to how exactly we can express our opinions now in view of this technical difficulty which has arisen on this very technical Act?
Comment on this
That is not my business. It is the business of those who wish to discuss the matter to put in an amendment which is in order. I thought this amendment was in order until the Minister pointed out certain facts to me. Now, it is out of order.
Comment on this
Usually when amendments are submitted to the office it is pointed out to Deputies, who have not got the expert assistance of the officials of the Department of Finance when dealing with this very elaborate and complicated code, that a particular amendment is out of order. I think it is bordering on sharp practice on the part of the Government to prevent us from expressing our views. There is a volume of very serious opinion on this question of the 25 per cent. stamp duty. If it is intended to shut us out from discussing that simply because of a technicality, it makes debate very difficult for us.
Comment on this
Nobody is doing that. Until the Minister pointed it out to me here quite recently, I did not know that there would be a charge. I am convinced now that there is.
Comment on this
I have not got the Act here. I would want to look at the Finance Act. I think the difficulty might arise, as far as the Minister is concerned, rather in respect of sub-section (3). If my recollection is right the status quo ante in regard to the 1891 Act was that if there was a certificate under £500 there was an exemption comparable to the present case. I wonder is the Minister completely accurate? I am speaking from recollection now since I did not anticipate the Minister's objection. If my recollection is right the position under the 1891 Act was that there was a specific provision there which covered a case not exceeding £500. Would that not still operate in the position which the Minister is contemplating? In regard to the scale under sub-section (3) that would work out at less than 1 per cent. We suggest therefore that the exclusion of that scale would not operate to increase the tax. I should like, before completely accepting what the Minister says, that he should demonstrate that this is so. Let me make the point again. Under the 1891 Act is was customary, before 1947 so far as I can recollect, to include in conveyances a certificate to the effect that if the consideration was under £500 there would be exemption and that operated to take away the force of the stamp duty. That was equivalent to sub-section (2) (b) 1 in the present case. I would suggest that the Minister's technical point that this would increase taxation is not well founded in that case. In regard to sub-section (3), which is a completely new departure, is it not patent on its face that the reduction of 1 per cent. brings the reduction below the scale given in sub-section (3) and, therefore, there is no increase either?
I submit that before this is ruled out of order, it should be demonstrated that what the Minister says is correct. In answer to the Minister, I say that it is probable that the position under the 1891 Act and the other Acts dealing with it will still apply in the £500 case and, therefore, the Minister's objection is not valid. I am putting that in the form of a question and I am quite prepared to submit to the Minister's point if it can be demonstrated that he is right in his contention.
Comment on this
The effect of the second part of the amendment is to repeal sub-section (1) of the Act of 1947. That goes. The Act of 1947 then as far as sub-section (2) is concerned reads: "Sub-section (1) shall not apply —" but there is no sub-section. It is gone. Then we go back to the original section to see what is going to happen and the first part of the amendment says: "The stamp duty shall be at the rate of 10/-," but there is no provision for the transfer where the consideration is under £500.
Comment on this
That is already the law under the 1891 Act.
Comment on this
The section does not make provision for that. This is a new section which followed the old legislation and makes provision for all cases and it does not make them subject to any exception. It simply says that the stamp duty chargeable shall be 10/-.
Comment on this
I submit on the face of the amendment that all it does is to alter the rate, that there is no express repeal and there is no repeal by implication. Is there any way by which this matter could be referred by the Chair for a legal opinion — this ruling out of discussion?
Comment on this
If it does impose a charge — and I believe it does — it may not be moved except by the Minister.
Comment on this
Could it be ruled that sub-section (1) is in order and that sub-section (2) is not in order?
Comment on this
There is no sub-section (1) and the new amendment makes a new charge applicable in all cases.
Comment on this
Under sub-section (2) it makes a new charge: "The stamp duties chargeable on conveyances or transfers —" that refers to all cases.
Comment on this
I am submitting with respect that in a case like this if a Deputy submits that a particular submission is correct and the Minister submits another contention, that the case should be proved. However, this is a purely technical point and we shall be able to discuss the merits on the section itself in regard to stamp duties. I take it that the Minister would not be willing to allow another amendment in this regard on report and I ask the Chair to rule on that matter formally.
Comment on this
That being done, I wish to give notice that we intend to put down on the Report Stage an amendment which will have the effect of these amendments and which we hope will be properly drafted.
Comment on this
Section 17 deals with stamp duties on certain instruments in cases of reduction of rent. This is just another section from which it is apparent that all these sections are developing into a very complicated code of stamp duties. I think it is highly desirable that we should look back and see what the origin of these stamp duties was to ascertain, whether in the present set of circumstances, it is desirable to continue them then or whether it is better to get back to the relatively simple provisions ruling beforehand. These stamp duties were put on initially in very peculiar circumstances. As I was pointing out when the Minister made his point on the amendment which I was purporting to move, we had a very inflationary situation where houses were subject to speculation and where prices were rising because of the speculation in house property. These stamp duties were introduced as a curb. One of the reasons for introducing them, as was pointed out at the time, was to put a curb on that speculation and to try to prevent what was then a strong tendency towards an artificial rise in the price of property, particularly in the case of smaller houses. The second point, as I pointed out, was that there was at that time considerable complaints about people coming from England to buy up property and it was thought desirable to discourage them by a tax.
Comment on this
Section 17 deals with stamp duties on certain instruments in cases of reduction of rent. What has that to do with the point the Deputy is raising?
Comment on this
As I was pointing out, if the Chair will bear with me, this point is coupled——
Comment on this
The Deputy might bear with the Chair when it is endeavouring to get in. I ask the Deputy to read the marginal note on the section which says "Stamp duties on certain instruments in cases of reduction of rent". Would the Deputy explain the connection of that with the sale of houses to foreigners?
Comment on this
I will explain later. I was merely pointing out that this code is becoming——
Comment on this
The section dealing with stamp duties is becoming complex and here is another one of these sections dealing with that. It is a question of stamp evasion in this case, evasion under Section 17. We already had a clause under the 1949 Act to deal with evasion last year. Here is another one. As far as the section is concerned it seems as if the Minister has no choice but to pursue this course as long as the stamp duties situation is left in the particular way in which it is. In other words, the rates are so high as to be a stimulus to evasion. I can foresee further evasions in the future. It would seem that, instead of enacting complicated sections like this, the simpler and more direct and more beneficial procedure for the community would be — instead of enacting sections like Section 17, Section 24 of the Act of last year, and so forth — to reduce the rate payable in respect of conveyances at home here to Irish citizens to the rate at which it was before and which apparently was working satisfactorily — 1 per cent. — without these complications of evasion.