Finance Bill, 1950—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 352–525 of 525. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 17 of 1950 ›
I submit that it is not. Here is a section dealing with an evasion. Last year also we had a section dealing with an evasion. I can anticipate that there will be more. We know of further evasions going on. The root cause of these evasions is that the rates of duty are so high as to be seriously affecting the conveyance of property and that there is a temptation to evade. The net kernel of the point on this section is that, the reasons for the higher taxes for Irish citizens having passed, the real solution would be not the continuing of an Act, section after section, each year to deal with the matter but to reduce the tax payable in regard to Irish conveyancing. You would thus solve the problem automatically and leave it in the state in which it was before. That is the net point in regard to these stamp duties.
Comment on this
It is not an amendment. We are on the section. The marginal note reads: "Stamp duties on certain instruments in cases of reduction of rent."
Comment on this
Surely we are not bound to interpret a section by a marginal note? It is a principle of legal interpretation that the marginal note is given as a guide——
Comment on this
——to the section but it does not describe the section as a whole. If you refer to lines 15 to 21 you will find that an important principle is raised immediately: that where any money, stock or security is to be treated for the purpose of this Act as a lease of lands, tenements or hereditaments——
Comment on this
We are entitled to raise the whole question of the justice and equity of the proposals contained in paragraphs (a) and (b) and the foundation in the principal Act on which they rest. We can deal with this proposal in two parts. The first proposal amounts to this: to assume that any money, stock or security moving in respect of certain transactions is to be treated as if it were a lease of lands, tenements, or hereditaments——
Comment on this
—— is to be stamped as if the money, stock or security transferred were a lease of lands, tenements or hereditaments. I have stated the intention of the section and accordingly, since it is the intention of the section to apply a certain code of duties to a transaction of this sort, we are entitled to discuss on the section the justice and the merits of that particular code.
Comment on this
"...of lands, tenements or hereditaments which had been made in consideration of the rent reduced..." It deals with rent reduced, not the purchase of Irish houses or estates by non-nationals.
Comment on this
The point there is that one can make an actual purchase by way of securing an apparent reduction in rent. I gather from the section that if I enjoy a lease of lands or rent a property for the sum of, say, £300 per year, and wish to buy out my landlord's interest in that property, I can do it apparently not by purchasing the rent outright but by giving him such consideration in the form of money, stock or security as will induce him to reduce the rent from its original figure of, say, £300 per annum to £5. Proceeding from that what we propose to say is that this is an evasion of certain stamp duties. It is proposed to treat this money, stock or security as if it were actually money passing not in respect of a reduction of rent but in respect of an actual purchase of property. On that, the whole question rises. Since we propose to apply the code of stamp duties which are payable on the transfer of property from one owner to another to this transaction, I think we are entitled on this section to discuss the whole merits or demerits of the stamp duties. That is what Deputy de Valera has been asking.
Comment on this
As Deputy MacEntee states, here is a case where a way had been found for avoiding the payment of the stamp duties imposed by Section 13 of the 1947 Act and by Section 24 of the 1949 Act, as the Minister himself stated. Here is, therefore, a positive move by the present Minister for Finance who, I remember, opposed the imposition of these duties initially in 1947 when he was on the Opposition Benches. He is now actually seeking to extend them and to apply them to cases to which they were not previously applicable. There are two points of view on that. The first is the point of view of evasion. If the code is to be there at all you have to block the loopholes or the thing becomes a farce. I will remind the Minister that for once he and I joined forces in regard to these sections in 1947 and, when I made the prophecy that these evasions would occur and that I could think of tricks, I can remember the Minister who was then on the Opposition Benches saying: "Do not give them away." Now things have changed. The Minister was then an Opposition Deputy and he could see quite clearly what would result and for that reason he opposed all these duties. Now, ironically enough, it is the Deputy who opposed the Bill at that time who is now the Minister who is trying to close the loopholes and make this work. At that time, in answer to the Minister's criticisms and the criticisms of his colleagues about this code, a case was made that there was speculation in house property, that the price of houses was going up through the buying and selling of houses, and that this would be a check on it. That case has largely gone now. I think it would be better to abolish the stamp duties on conveyances at home, that is, for Irish citizens.
The Minister, apparently, is of the view now that the 25 per cent. on foreigners should be kept. We would concede that you could keep that. Even though the Minister says that there is not such serious buying of property by foreigners as some people complain, still, it would be as well to keep that provision.
In regard to the buying and selling of houses at the rate of 5 per cent. duty, the case for having that duty as high as that is gone, other than the revenue case, and the proper thing to do would be to reduce the tax to the value at which it was before.
In other words, the only case that the Minister can make for keeping the stamp duty tax at its present value is revenue. That means that the people who are buying houses not in the built category or other exempted categories are saddled with this penal 5 per cent. and that heavy cost is on them. The case which was initially made for that cannot very easily be made now.
Taking these facts in conjunction with what is obviously the fulfilment of a prophecy which the Minister and myself made jointly, that these evasions would occur, and that the Minister now is chasing from year to year these evasions, the better proposal would be to reduce the rate, remove the temptation and then these evasions will not arise. This is one evasion. Last year was another. The Minister probably knows very well of many other evasions that are going on at the moment, evasions, technically honest and right in law, but evasions in the spirit.
Comment on this
That will possibly have to be the subject of further amendments. What is the attitude to be to this section? If you are going to deal with evasions at all, the fair thing is to try to keep the thing level. There is that case to be made for the Minister's section. On the other hand, it is very hard to see why, at the present juncture, the Minister should increase taxation in regard to conveyances. In other words, it means that where heretofore there was a way of mitigating that burden in particular cases, which could be invoked, that way is blocked and extra taxation is being put on. That is another way of looking at it.
Everybody will take his own point of view as to which is the better way of doing it. The net suggestion, the best one, would be as was intended in these amendments that were out of order, to abolish the existing rate and to go back to the old 1 per cent.
Comment on this
This is just one example of the kind of legislation which will have to arise from the principle. Every year, the Minister will have to bring in an unending series of amendments to the original section because evasions are certain to take place. In the debate last year the Minister, when I asked him about one particular point, where the Constitution had been raised by Deputy O'Higgins, said: "More luck to them if they succeed in beating the Department of Finance through the courts." That attitude, I suggest, is all wrong. If a law is so onerous that professional solicitors, in their conception of their duty to their clients, feel bound to try to evade the law, obviously, the law is contrary to public principle and public interest.
At present solicitors will tell one, from many experiences of the present onerous task, that it is stopping the sale of properties, especially in the case of people of moderate means. Nobody of modest means can get a house now at less than £2,000, and the duty on that of £100 is very severe. They just cannot find it. Anybody with any experience of that knows how difficult it is for people of those means to get the money to bridge the difference between what they have to pay for a house and what is due to be paid for the transfer of the property.
I know that the Minister has two views on this subject. He believes that he has to get the revenue from this tax at the moment but he has expressed his own view that he does not like the tax and he admitted in the discussion last year that the longer it goes on the more harm it is doing, especially in reference to closing one gap with regard to companies.
Just to take the view of the solicitors' profession on the matter, this tax involves what the Revenue Commissioners regarded as a necessity, that is, the removal of the determining authority of the adjudication stamp. So that it makes it extremely difficult and dangerous for a solicitor now to take part in the transfer of property because that adjudication stamp does not carry with it a final decision that the proper duty has been paid and, in connection with queries that might take place 20 years hence, a question might arise which would involve a large sum of money.
Then, again, especially with regard to companies, where a company is an owner of property or portion of a property, the solicitor has to go into the question very carefully, to make a research first of all into the files of a private company and, if there is a trustee of properties, he has to follow that up to find out whether certain people were aliens or Irish citizens. If he fails to arrive at the full information on the subject and makes a mistake, he is involved in very heavy penalties indeed.
The thing is as wrong as it could be in its present form. It was originally passed as an emergency measure to deal with a difficult situation that arose from inflation. It was not intended to be carried on for a long time. The Minister himself has admitted that it is a thing which should be got rid of. Yet, because he cannot find other resources from which to get the necessary finance, he is continuing what is really a persisting evil.
This stamp duty was denounced in tremendous terms by Deputy Dillon originally. It is worth repeating the phrases he used in particular. At column 1174, Volume 108, of the Official Reports, Deputy Dillon said:
"This is a dirty, contemptible, vicious and disedifying proposal, well worthy of the mind of the Minister for Finance who conceived it, and to my way of thinking a disgrace on the House that adopts it."
He did not say anything about the disgrace to the Government that continues it.
"It is a confession before the world that there can survive here a meanness of spirit that was unknown in this country in the darkest days through which our people had to live."
That was very colourful, but——
Comment on this
The Taoiseach, whose language was rather more restrained, said:
"I believe this additional taxation will result merely in making house property dearer and the provision of houses for the people who have only limited means impossible."
The Taoiseach, whatever we may say about him politically, has had very considerable experience as a lawyer and has a keen sense of protecting his clients and, when he said that, he said a very sensible thing. I think the Government would be very well advised to try, as quickly as possible, to get rid of this tax. I think that the Minister, as a lawyer, largely agrees with us, but, as Minister for Finance, he feels that he is obliged to impose this taxation. I know that it means about £600,000, but I think he ought to use his resources. The resources of civilisation are not exhausted and he should find some other way, more healthy from the point of view of the public spirit of the community, from the point of view of public interest and public law, than insisting on a law which it is the duty of lawyers to try to evade, so far as they can.
Mr. MacEntee rose.
Comment on this
It is extraordinary how great is the lack of concern which some fortunate members opposite show for their less fortunate brethren.
Comment on this
I feel that there is not really any justification for this section. If this tax is being evaded, it is being evaded mainly because it is an unjust tax. According to a very eminent authority, now a member of the Government, when the tax was first introduced, it was a tax which would hit hardest the person who was looking to buy the cheapest house on the market to-day, and there was such a tremendous demand for the cheaper type of house, he went on, that undoubtedly the tax would not be effective in stopping the appreciation in property values, but would merely increase the hardship which that inflation was already imposing upon less fortunate elements in the community. The person who made that statement was a person who is very conversant with the property market and the general situation therein. He was no less a person than the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, then Deputy Morrissey. I agree with him. This tax was introduced as an emergency measure to deal with an emergency situation. The position now, according to the Government, has been reached where the emergency has passed and, therefore, the original justification for imposing the tax has passed also. Accordingly, any person who can evade this tax by any exercise of ingenuity is properly entitled to evade it.
I submit that the House should not co-operate with the Minister in trying to victimise people who, because their means are limited, are compelled, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce said, to buy the cheapest house in the market to-day. That is what the house is being asked to do. By a simple device, this 5 per cent. property tax can be avoided, and the question, therefore, arises whether we are entitled to deprive the thrifty, provident and hard-driven sections of the community who wish to house themselves of the remedy which their own wisdom and ingenuity have been able to devise for the situation with which they have been faced.
Take the position as it exists in Dublin to-day. So far as I can see, the normal run of small houses such as would be occupied by a young married couple sells around £2,250. If we deduct the first £500 of that price which is not subject to tax, we are left with a sum of £1,750 which is subject to tax, and at the rate of 5 per cent., under Section 13 of the 1947 Act, it amounts to £87 10s. 0d. Despite the appearance of things here, if you vote to deprive the people of the natural way of escape which they have devised for themselves from this iniquitous and now burdensome tax, you are voting, if you vote for this section, to ensure that every person who buys a house at £2,200 or thereabouts will be saddled with stamp duty to the amount of not less than £87 10s. 0d. That is the simple situation, and I do not think that, in present circumstances, we are justified in doing it.
The amount of money which the tax brings in, I am told, is comparatively little, and certainly in a Budget of £107,000,000 it does not constitute 1 per cent.; but it is a tax which falls most heavily upon the young people and the middle-class people who are trying to provide houses for themselves. The Government does not cater for these people, except in the limited way in which it was done under the Fianna Fáil Housing Act, 1948, when a substantial grant was made towards the cost of a house which a man erects or purchases for his own occupation. Beyond that, no subsidy is given to the middle-class person with an income of £500 or £600 a year who hopes to marry, settle down and found a family. It is therefore upon that particular element in the community that this tax presses most heavily. I do not think we are justified, from the social point of view, in maintaining it, having regard to the circumstances which I have outlined. If we did feel that it was necessary to pass some sort of sumptuary law to prevent people in present circumstances providing themselves with more housing accommodation than the public interest seemed to demand, we could do so, if we thought that wise. I am not saying that I think it wise; in fact, I would protest against it, as it would only put another limitation on the incentives which are so necessary to enable a man to give his best to the community. However, to meet that point of view, which I think might appeal to some members of the Government Party, if we did feel it necessary in some way to prevent people from providing themselves with more housing accommodation than seemed in present circumstances justifiable in the public interest, we could, of course, provide for the imposition of a tax of this sort.
If we did, I think the tax should be levied upon a value very much higher than the value which is under the present code exempt from taxation. There might be something to be said for imposing the taxation — I say there might be, I am not saying there is — upon a house costing £4,000 or £5,000. Again, one would have to take the circumstances into consideration. If the family were large and consisted of a number of persons engaged in productive employment, there would be justification for providing them with a larger house, costing a greater amount of money. If it were felt that something should be done to limit the demand upon existing building facilities. I suggest that a figure of £3,000, £4,000 or £5,000 might be taken as the limit below which the tax would not be levied. Certainly, there is no justification in present circumstances, with the demand for housing accommodation being as intense as it is, for imposing this duty upon the smaller type of house, the house consisting of two reception rooms, three bedrooms and a kitchenette, the type of house which young married people look for in order to start off their own independent household.
I think, therefore, that before the House decides to vote for Section 17, the House should hear from the Minister some justification for this section. May I here, on behalf not merely of the members of this House, not merely on behalf of the Opposition but on behalf of the people outside whom we represent, protest against the rather contemptuous way in which the several provisions of the Finance Bill have been thrown at this House by the Minister? There was a previous section, a very complicated one dealing with stamp duty, Section 16, where some explanation of the provisions was asked for by a Deputy on this side of the House and the only reply he got was the rather discourteous one from the Minister, to read the section. I challenge anyone to read that section, containing as it does references to previous Finance Acts, and be able to gather for himself from a simple reading what the meaning of the section is. What I have said in relation to Section 16 applies to an even more marked degree to Section 17.
As to the content of this section and the purpose of it, all the guidance and assistance that the House has been given by the Minister is to refer the House to the marginal note. The marginal note consists of 12 words, but the section itself consists of 75 lines of close print. That proposal expressed in 75 lines is supposed to be apprehended by the representatives of the people from a glance at one sentence of 12 words. That is the guidance which the Minister has given to the House, that is the assistance which he has given to Deputies of Dáil Éireann to consider this proposal. Without any guidance from the Minister, without any attempt to enlighten us as to the provisions, we have had on behalf of the people to try and disentangle what the real purpose proposed to be secured is.
As I have said, despite the marginal note — which I am not saying is designedly misleading but does mislead to the extent that it makes one regard this section as being just a mere proposal to stop up a little loophole — the section does make it impossible for the class of person to whom I refer, the person who wants to buy a small house, to avail of the natural escape from this unjust and oppressive tax which his own ingenuity and his own skill and the skill of his lawyers have opened up to him.
In conclusion, I want to express the hope that the Minister will not say that it was his predecessor in office who introduced this tax. When these stamp duties were first brought in, it was made clear that they were brought in as a temporary expedient for a temporary purpose, to check the inflationary trend in property values at that time, and in the state of emergency then to enable the Minister to make provision for the increased subsidies which were being provided on essential foodstuffs. That is all past. There has been no increase in subsidies on essential foodstuffs — that is being evaded, because we are now buying butter at 3/6, we are entitled to buy it, and in the same way we have bread, sugar and tea at two prices.
Comment on this
It has, because the circumstances which called these stamp duties into existence have entirely disappeared. The Government having abandoned the policy of food subsidies, is not justified in keeping on this tax, which was imposed for the purpose of raising the money to provide these subsidies. That is the position and I suggest, therefore, that before the House accepts this section we will demand some justification for it from the Minister and if that justification is not convincing, we will vote against this section.
Comment on this
This tax has been described as harsh and oppressive. The date of its imposition was 1947. It was done by Fianna Fáil. It was harsh and oppressive—it was put on at that date. It was not put on to cheapen houses but was put on as a revenue tax. That was the purpose of it. On the 29th October, 1947, the then Minister for Finance, speaking in Dáil Éireann, as reported in column 1070 of Volume 108 of the Official Report said:—
"I think 5 per cent. is enough at the moment."
I interrupted him, saying:
"To cheapen houses?"
He said:
"Not to cheapen houses—to get money from the vendors of houses. It will not cheapen houses."
If you are looking for money from the vendors of houses, I reckon it should be described as a revenue tax. It was not to cheapen houses. In case there might be any doubt in the then Minister's mind, he returned to the point, as given on the 13th November, 1947, in column 1916 and said:
"It is the vendor whose price is going to be reduced by the 5 per cent. The 5 per cent., instead of going into the vendor's pocket, is going to go into the pocket of the Treasury."
I stand in his shoes receiving those 5 per cents. at the moment and the "harsh and oppressive tax" is described as such by people who are terribly anxious about the sellers of property, the people who have built houses and made any amount of money in recent years.
Comment on this
Its purpose was not to cheapen houses but to get money from the vendors. Deputy Little would have to roll into this with the usual exaggerated statement common to the debate on this tax. He said that it had almost brought to a standstill transfers of property. Deputy Little can do the sum for himself. £600,000 is got per year from the 5 per cent. tax and that means that property to the value of £12,000,000 changes hands in the year. If that is described as "bringing to a standstill transfers of property" language has no meaning.
I met a deputation from the legal side in 1949. About the middle of 1949 we discussed the reductions in the cost of houses and it was then agreed that the £5,000 house of a couple of years before was in June, 1949, selling at £2,500. If Deputies are afraid that the people who want to get these houses cannot get them because of the tax all they have to do is to wander through Dublin. There are numbers of the type of house from £2,500 to a figure about double that with boards up on the windows offering them for sale and there is quite a considerable amount of certain types of property surplus to the demand. In the circumstances I think it is wise to keep this tax.
A certain amount of evasion was practised last year but I do not regard it as anything immoral. I do not know how Deputy Little's indignation arises in connection with this tax. People are entitled to get legal ways out that will stand up in the courts and it is quite proper. It sharpens the ingenuity of the people and leads to good legal practice and leads to the creation of good lawyers.
Comment on this
If you pass legislation and people find a legal way out of it that is not disrespect for the law.
Comment on this
That was an attempted evasion by the Government of the Constitution and of course it brought them to heel.
Comment on this
I do not see any disrespect in operations like this. People should be remunerated for ingenuity. After giving notice—and we gave notice —we stopped that. If this is got round in other ways we will see what they are and if we can we will stop them later on. When the tax was in operation as might be expected it blundered here and there, but we made it something that would hold water and it did hold water to the extent of £600,000.
Mr. Derrig rose.
Comment on this
It is Committee but I looked around the House for a Deputy to offer himself and gave plenty of opportunity but no Deputy offered. I called on the Minister to conclude and no Deputy offered himself.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Collins will give me an opportunity of speaking? No Deputy offered to the knowledge of the Chair or made his intention evident. If Deputy Moran wanted to speak he could do so. I called on the Minister to conclude.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 17 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 10:—
In sub-section (2), line 30, to delete "Account" and substitute "Fund".
This is a verbal amendment. The name of the fund is the Transition Development Fund. In sub-section (2) it is referred to as the Transition Development Account and the word "Account" should be "Fund".
Comment on this
On the section, I wonder whether the Minister could not amplify the information he gave in his Budget statement regarding the operation of this fund? In the first place, I should like to ask whether the facilities are confined entirely to assisting house-building, and, secondly, whether the hopes that the Minister held out in his Budget statement of 1949, when he had then the intention of winding up the fund, as he still has, at a later stage, that building costs would have settled down sufficiently to obviate the need for such large supplements to the annually voted subventions for housing and public health services, are likely to be realised.
This year, this provision is being continued. We are now asked to loan a sum not exceeding £2,000,000 to enable the fund to be continued. It seems to me that no steps have been taken by the Government to effect a reduction in building costs. I think we are entitled to ask if money is being borrowed for the purpose of enabling the ordinary provisions under the housing grants to be supplemented by special loans covering the transition period, and to inquire what steps the Government are taking to reduce the necessity for such a call. If we were to accept the position that has been laid down by the Government in another connection, it might be suggested that there was a case for continuing this Transition Development Fund assistance perhaps for a very considerable period. The Minister, in the extract which I have read for the House, has suggested that he foresees the time when building costs may be reduced, thus rendering this particular assistance unnecessary. I should like to ask whether it is the intention to bring the operations of this fund to a conclusion, whether such reductions in building costs are effected or not. If it is the intention to continue the fund until such time as a reduction in building costs should occur, what steps are the Government taking to have these costs reduced? As the Minister has pointed out, substantial State aid is being given towards housing. The suggestion made by him in the Budget statement, that the differential renting system which the Government are encouraging in order to distribute more equitably the heavy burden of housing costs might not be necessary, if the Government were able to take other steps, of which the country has no information at present, so as to enable housing costs to be reduced.
Comment on this
The Transition Development Fund is being used for the payment of certain grants for housing. There have been certain grants made in connection with sanitary services also in connection with housing. At the time the fund was established, it was intimated to Deputies that they should submit various schemes for which the money under the Transition Development Fund might be used. There was not much in the way of suggestions made.
In the end, a vast amount of money was being spent on housing and on sanitary services. A small amount went towards Ceimicí Teoranta in connection with one experiment and some also went to the Sea Fisheries Association. These sums were infinitesimal in comparison with the amount that went on housing and sanitary services. The fund is being wound up. For the future, moneys for the objects for which these moneys were provided out of the fund, will be met out of voted moneys. It is expected—I have no information about it—that the Department of Local Government will make somewhat better schemes with regard to houses which are being built and the financing of them. The old system was complicated and there would appear to have been a certain amount of overlapping. Subsidies are being given under three headings: an annual contribution towards loan charges, capital sums which used to come out of the fund will now come out of moneys that will appear on the Estimates and the special interest rate which I promised to have made in order to reduce the 3¼ per cent. to an effective rate of 2½ per cent. The Department of Local Government, I understand, is thinking out some new scheme to replace the present complicated system of subventions. Deputies will be informed of that in due time. The differential rental will be pursued at the same time.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (3), line 49, after the word "Fund", to insert the words "or the growing produce thereof."
This phrase was omitted by a mistake, and I am asking the leave of the House to insert it.
Comment on this
On the section, I take it that the amount specified here— £655,432 per annum for the next 30 years commencing this year—is to make provision for the amount of money borrowed in the preceding year, and that this does not cover the capital redemption and interest payment requirements, or the further sums which the Minister indicated in his Budget speech he was going to borrow.
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with previous borrowing. This sum of £655,432 is related to the £12,113,680 which is to be found on the face of the Book of Estimates.
Comment on this
For borrowings contemplated this year? I do not recollect that a similar section was provided in last year's Finance Act to cover the borrowings of the previous year.
Comment on this
Borrowings were made. The Minister raised a couple of loans since the change of Government.
Comment on this
I take it that this procedure is normal in the sense that we are now providing a capital repayment provision and an interest charges provision for a sum of money to be borrowed to the extent of £12,000,000 odd in this year. I take it that, if in the same financial year the Minister has to have recourse to another borrowing, there will have to be an amendment brought in to this Act?
Comment on this
We have this novel situation, for the first time in a Finance Bill, that, under a special heading, we are borrowing capital sums for specific purposes and that we are specifically providing for this £12,000,000 odd loan as distinct from any other Government borrowings. Now, frankly, I cannot see the sense of that because whatever money the State borrows, every Government borrowing will have the same security and the provision in this manner for a specific item of borrowing brings about, in my opinion, a segregation as between one type of borrowing and another. First of all, it is clear to the House that this particular transaction is putting on to the Exchequer a cost of over £650,000 per annum. On the Budget debate I estimated that £750,000 would be equivalent to approximately 6d. in the £ on income-tax. I think the Minister agreed with that figure himself. Here, we have 6d. in the £ added in this particular way and it is bound to be repeated in this way as distinct from other borrowings. In the ordinary way, in the case of a Government loan, if the Government issue a loan the stock is redeemable within a certain period of years and the State is in the position at all time, through the assistance of the Government stockbrokers, to buy in stock if the price at which it can be bought happens to be favourable. In other words, if the price of Government stock issued at par and repayable in 15 to 25 years comes on the market at a time when that stock has fallen in value, because of certain circumstances, to 90 or 89, the Government is in a position to redeem as much of that stock as is available at the reduced price through funds available to the Exchequer because of Departments having balances. On occasions, local authorities and the State can create substantial savings in their commitments arising from Government loans.
In this case we are borrowing £12,000,000 and we are giving a guarantee that it will not be redeemed except in the manner suggested here by these agreed annual payments, at the same time covering the rate of interest which will be involved in it, irrespective of what the money market situation will be at any particular time within that 30 years. I would like to know from the Minister why he is adopting that particular method. It is quite novel in State finance. It is definitely making a commitment for the repayment of capital and the rate of interest, which, in the beginning, will be mainly interest charges because, I take it, that the calculation appertaining to the repayment of this £12,000,000 is similar to the calculations made with regard to other State or local authority borrowings; in the beginning of the repayment period interest charges are high and one is setting aside a very small amount of money for the purpose of redeeming the capital sum; gradually, towards the other end of the loan period, the amount set aside per annum for redemption increases. Why is the Minister taking this special step? Is it because this may be taken from the Counterpart Fund? If it is taken from the Counterpart Fund, it is again brought in in a manner which is, to say the least of it, unusual, and without a proper explanation to the House. I understand that the arrangement with regard to the Counterpart Fund is that when the Minister takes from the Central Bank the equivalent in sterling for moneys borrowed under Marshall Aid, side by side with that an undertaking is entered into whereby the State signs a series of promissory notes over the whole of the redemption period of that particular loan. In my opinion, if I am interpreting it correctly, that is equivalent to legislating here for a transaction done in that way. As I said before, I think the Minister should have given us a little more information than he did. We are not now dealing with an ordinary State loan which we can redeem at any time we like. We are dealing with a commitment under Marshall Aid and we are binding ourselves to the repayment of that commitment over a period of years at a stipulated rate of interest. There is no way out. There is no way of benefiting as we would in ordinary financial State transactions. In fairness to the House and to the country I think the Minister should give a little more detailed information of the commitments into which we are entering under Marshall Aid.
I specifically raised the point as to whether this was last year's borrowing or this year's borrowing for the purpose of eliciting from the Minister which it really was. It was as a result of his answer on that point—an interjection which was very helpful—that I came to the conclusion that this was, in fact, a Marshall Aid repayment becoming liable——
Comment on this
The Minister said this was a provision for a borrowing of £12,000,000 which he intends to conclude in this financial year.
Comment on this
From where is the Minister getting the money? Will it be raised in the ordinary way? I would like the Minister to answer that question. Normally, the State issues a loan, whether it wants the money for capital requirements or to meet a deficit in the returns of the State as between income and expenditure, and it borrows money on short-term loans, under ways and means. If it wants to put a loan on the long finger, it borrows on the basis of issuing scrip to the public. In the issuing of scrip to the public there are likely to be, during the repayment period, opportunities where a certain amount of that money can be redeemed, thereby effecting a considerable saving in redemption subsequently.
That happens, too, in the case of local authorities. They have power to borrow money. It happens in the Department of Finance. There are officers there who have specific instructions to watch the stock returns from day to day and, if they have in hands a certain amount of cash not likely to be needed in the immediate future, they can opt to buy a certain amount of the State liability before the redemption date at a reduced price. In this particular section we are committing ourselves to a liability which is specified as to time and as to interest with no option whatsoever in the event of money markets so affecting the value of State loans as might make them an advantage to the Exchequer. The Minister says this has nothing to do with Marshall Aid. I do not know whether provision has been made for Marshall Aid interests. Perhaps the Minister would guide me as to that. We have begun—I do not know whether it is under this section of the Bill—substantial borrowings for Marshall Aid. Provision will have to be made for its repayment and for interest.
Comment on this
In 1952, but we know that it is a liability from the moment the Minister enters into it.
Comment on this
I am looking for information. I think this is a section which requires a great deal of clarification by the Minister. I am saying that this method of provision for the repayment of State loans is a novel one and I should like the Minister to give us some information about it. We do not know where we are heading for. We do know that we have this liability to a specific amount written into the Finance Bill. There will be other borrowings and we shall have added to the liability of the State considerably increasing annual payments and interest charges which very easily could go up, to an amount which would necessitate 1/-, 2/- or 3/- of an increase in the rate of income-tax. I ask the Minister—perhaps he can help me and if he does not want to help me, perhaps he will help the House—for this information. I am certainly not quite clear as to what is the meaning of this section.
Comment on this
I should like to support Deputy Briscoe's demand for further information in regard to this very important section. As Deputy Briscoe states, we have an entirely new conception with regard to the repayment of borrowings in this section. I think we are entitled to get some more information from the Minister as to what exactly he has in mind. Normally, as Deputy Briscoe has pointed out, when the Government is borrowing money, it is dealt with in the ordinary way through redemption from time to time by means of the funds provided for that purpose, but on this occasion a specific sum of money of very large dimensions, £655,000, is being set aside. Although in the Finance Act and the financial proposals of the Minister for a particular year, we deal only with the expenditure and revenue for that year, in this case we are placing a burden on the taxpayer, not alone for this year but for the next 30 years. That is a very unusual proceeding; in fact it might be described as revolutionary, and if the section were allowed to pass without comment it might very well be that Deputies, let alone ordinary taxpayers in the country, might not realise that they are not likely to hear any more about this £650,000, except that it is to appear in the account which is to be published annually and that it will also appear in the Central Fund. By appearing in the Central Fund it is established in a special position as having a special priority charge on the revenues of the State and upon our future production and taxable capacity.
Why is it that this particular borrowing transaction cannot be carried out in the ordinary way? Why is it necessary, before the Minister has gone to the lenders to look for the money, that he should come to the House now and ask us to pass into law a provision which will place this mortgage on the taxpayer for the next 30 years? We are told that borrowing is a very cheap policy. It is a very popular policy. It is very generous, indeed, to pay out large sums of money and have grand schemes but the settling up of the debts can be rather vexatious. This system brings to mind the words of the American humorist, Artemus Ward, who said: "Let us live within our means even if we have to borrow to do it."
The Minister has found it necessary to come forward with this proposal to establish this capital services redemption account, into which £655,000 will have to be paid for the next 30 years, to redeem the sum of £12,000,000 provided for in this year's Estimate and which will be spent this year. Up to the present such borrowing has been paid out of revenue. Last year, out of an expenditure of some £74,000,000, the Minister following on the practice of his predecessor in office, set aside the comparatively small sum of £600,000 to be borrowed but, during the year, some extraordinary change occurred in the Minister's mind and in his attitude towards borrowing and the principle by which a comparatively small sum of money, amounting only to a small percentage of the total budget requirements, was set aside for borrowing has been entirely departed from. Instead of borrowing a sum of £600,000 for the Supply Services this year, the Minister is borrowing over £12,000,000. Why is that necessary? Because the Government is unable to pay its way.
Comment on this
May I draw the attention of the Chair to the fact that the expression "capital services" means voted services which are to be met out of borrowings.
Comment on this
May I call your attention to the expression "capital services" in line 43? It is there stated that capital services means voted services which are to be met out of borrowings.
Comment on this
The Deputy is quite right but the section deals with the Redemption Account for the services.
Comment on this
It is proposed under sub-section (3) to set aside a sum of £655,000 to redeem borrowings which, I understand from the Minister, are to be made to meet the cost of certain services referred to in the annual Estimates and according to the Book of Estimates the cost of these services amounts to £12,000,000. I think I am justified in making the point that the Minister has found himself in the position that he has been unable to pay for these services out of revenue and therefore has had to make this arrangement in order to enable him to borrow. The fact that he has had to make this special arrangement and now proposes to get statutory authority to pay into the Central Fund, not for this year but for 30 successive financial years, this sum of money indicates that the borrowing is not on all fours with previous operations.
There may have been in previous Finance Acts provision for Capital Services Redemption Account, but I have never heard of one having this particular provision in sub-section (3). I take it that the reason this account is being established is to give additional security for borrowings which would be unnecessary if the money was being applied for productive purposes. I should like to ask the Minister to let us know when he is replying what proportion of this annuity of £655,000 is attributable to interest and also how the figure of £423,000 in subsection (5) is arrived at. The position seems to be that the £655,000 may be invested in redemption towards defraying the interest on the public debt as to one portion and as to another portion of it towards investment in certain funds or perhaps in redemption of the public debt generally. I think the House is entitled to have a fairly full statement from the Minister and I hope it will not be considered an act of sabotage if we suggest that the Minister has been very improvident indeed when he has found it necessary to place this millstone around the necks of future taxpayers as well as over the present generation in order to cover the cost of services which could, in great part at any rate, be met from the revenues which come in in the ordinary way.
I stated in the debate on the Budget that there is a distinction in my view between borrowing for productive services likely to increase the wealth of the country and borrowing for other purposes. That was fully set out by the Minister in his Budget statement. In fact, if one were to go through the Budget statement one could make an admirable case against borrowing for other purposes. To give an example of the Minister's attitude, I quoted from a statement which the Minister made in the Seanad not very long ago—on the 26th October, 1949; column 142—when there was a discussion on the monetary policy of this State. Referring to the question of capital development the Minister said: "from one angle, it is very good to enthuse about capital development here at home..."
Comment on this
When the light goes out there is darkness. If Deputy Corry were to go out there would be silence. The Ceann Comhairle said that this section dealt with the setting up of the Redemption Account and that the question of capital development was out of order.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that the Ceann Comhairle dealt with the matter that arose in a proper fashion. If I deem that the Deputy is out of order I shall deal with it as I think necessary. I do not think that he is out of order so far.
Comment on this
In this statement in the Seanad, referring to the large sums of money being put into circulation, the Minister went on to say: "Unless it were to lead to an immediate production of goods—and very little of this money as expended in this way is to lead to an immediate production of goods—there is bound to be inflation. So at once while I am pursuing this desirable course of making a tremendous increase in capital development, do not forget the other side, that I may be weakening the value of the Irish £ and, with the high rate at which Government expenditure is running, our capital account and current account and with our situation in respect of balance of payments, I am not too sure." The whole quotation is very interesting for those who wish to go back on it. But this is not capital development proper. This money is being borrowed in respect of services such as the provision of buildings— Iveagh House; office accomodation and staff restaurant: £27,000.
Comment on this
Is it not? Then the Minister will have an opportunity of explaining it to us. I understood that the redemption account which is now being set up and which provides for the payment of £655,000 into the Central Fund is to amortise the loans which have to be raised to cover that expenditure. Is that correct?
Comment on this
The Minister is going to borrow money to pay for these services. They are described as capital services. If the Minister means that the moneys are going to be provided out of funds at his disposal, well and good. The Minister had been so strong in his Budget statement on borrowing from current savings for this capital investment policy that it seems to run counter to the purpose which he had in view of avoiding inflation by getting the necessary moneys from savings.
Comment on this
If we were dreaming about inflation in 1947 how many times has the Minister for Finance referred to the dangers of inflation? How many times has the Central Bank referred to the inflationary factors which exist? Why has the Minister in this statement in the Seanad and in the Budget statement which he made quite recently referred to the dangers of inflation in this large-scale borrowing programme which he has put before the country? I want to suggest to the Deputy and others who think like him that, just as we have reached, in the Minister's view, the limit in regard to taxation and nothing more can be got from the taxpayer and we are driven to borrowing, there will be a limit in due course to the amount that can be borrowed. The Minister has suggested —even more than suggested—that the whole of this capital programme may not be physically possible to undertake during the present year. Nevertheless, provision is being made for it. Deputy Davin says we are bothered about inflation.
Comment on this
What about your own Taoiseach on 15th October, 1947? He nearly cried about it that day.
Comment on this
I referred to the position, which the Minister promised to look into and in regard to which he gave me no definite answer, of the Transitional Development Fund. Take the question of housing, for example. He admits in his Budget statement that there is an inflationary situation already. I think the Minister has admitted that in his public statements. If the Deputy will bear with me, I will read him a paragraph—column 1634 —from the Budget statement:—
"The employment afforded by the housing activities of local authorities and private builders is in itself a great social advantage which has indirect benefits in many directions. On the other hand, the magnitude of the programme inevitably involves certain risks. The resources of the building industry are at full stretch. Skilled labour is still short, and our cement industry is unable to meet the unprecedented demand, with the result that large quantities of much dearer cement have to be imported. In view of the intensive building activity which is being generated by State assistance, building costs require special attention so as to ensure that no section of the community profits unduly from the urgent necessity, on social and health grounds, of improving the housing of the population."
Comment on this
It is evidence of inflationary conditions if you have shortage of men and materials in regard to housing——
Comment on this
——and you try to carry through a programme that is impossible to carry through. It is a legitimate deduction that you will have a certain amount of inflation.
Comment on this
The Minister is a very skilful tight-rope walker. He is very careful. He wants, if he wishes to do so, to be able to say that he has not proceeded with certain plans or schemes by reason of the danger of inflation but is not prepared to say definitely, in advance, that there is inflation.
Comment on this
There is danger of inflation. There are inflationary factors. If we are not careful in regard to the steps we take and the way we proceed, we are going to have inflation. Is that correct?
Comment on this
At column 1642 the Minister said:—
"It is necessary, however, to bear in mind that the realisation of sterling assets and the use of counterpart moneys are methods of finance unrelated to current savings and, as such, may have inflationary tendencies. Recourse to such sources must in present conditions, be cautious, and the greatest care will be taken by the Government in choosing the methods of financing its capital programme, to ensure that there will be no adverse consequences for the economy."
Comment on this
At column 1645 he has a further development of that thesis. The point, in any case, is that we are borrowing this year. Borrowing has become necessary because services which had been normally met out of revenue are now being transferred to the sphere of capital. As I was saying to Deputy Davin, just as there is a limit to the amount of work that can be physically accomplished and to the number of schemes that can be put in hand, there is obviously a limit to the amount of money that can be borrowed. If there is a certain limit to the amount of money that can be borrowed, I think the Deputy will agree that it would be more beneficial that moneys that have to be borrowed and which are described as in the nature of capital services should be allocated to purposes that will increase the national wealth, that will give employment and develop our resources and industries.
Comment on this
I went into some detail on the Financial Statement and I think the Minister has agreed to a certain extent with the thesis that if you are borrowing for unproductive works, as I suggest he he doing in this case, you have to make special provision. The fact that the provision is being made in this particular way and that it is so onerous in character is proof that the Minister is not satisfied that the purposes for which the borrowings are to be made are generally productive, and that they will ultimately contribute, either directly or indirectly, to the cost which is incurred in regard to them.
The Minister gave the Seanad a good deal more information with regard to the change that had taken place in his mind about this whole question of capital development and that enables him now to espouse with enthusiasm these grandiose schemes which, as I said yesterday, he was so ready to condemn only a few years ago. One of the reasons why he attacked these schemes was that they did not contribute to the supply of goods.
Comment on this
It is a very important machinery section, one of the most important that has ever come before this House, a section which, in three or four lines, will place a burden on the Irish taxpayer to the extent of £655,000 a year for the next 30 years, and I suggest that we are entitled to examine, in detail, if necessary, the policy which has given rise to that. I suggested on the Budget statement that the opinion of economists elsewhere was that, if moneys were being borrowed for public works, it was assumed that abnormal works which would be met by provision from borrowing would only be required, in times of depression and when they were so required, in order to increase purchasing power in the country, they should be paid off within a comparatively short term of years; but in this case, in order to meet the expenditure on capital services, as the Minister terms them, amounting to £12,000,000 we are being asked to pay a very much larger sum.
If Deputies calculate what £655,000 for 30 years comes to, they will see that borrowing can be rather expensive. If we borrow £12,000,000 we pay back £19,663,000 and, therefore, for the original loan of £12,000,000 we have to pay back roughly £7? millions additional. That is in addition to whatever other charges we have to meet on normal capital services. The point I was making is that if we have to provide this huge sum to meet the cost of services which should be met to a much greater degree from revenue, if not altogether, there must be less money available when the Government goes into the market to look for money for the Electricity Supply Board or any of the other big capital development schemes which we believe will repay the country by adding to our productive powers and by adding to our wealth in the future.
It was suggested by the Minister for Defence when he attacked our Party recently for a campaign of sabotage, as he called it, worthy of the worst days of our extremely bad past, that we did not give the Government warning of what we intended to do or say in criticism of this policy but it is quite impossible to know what the Minister for Finance is going to do. In 1948, he has a mandate for retrenchment; in 1950, he forgets that mandate but discovers, with the Taoiseach, a new mandate, that is, a mandate to increase the national debt. The Government has discovered this wonderful secret of the national debt. You do not have to impose taxes; you do not have to retrench; you just borrow. So long as lenders are available, you pile up the national debt, which has increased by 50 per cent. in the past few years.
If that were being done on the basis of policies which genuinely gave employment in the really productive sense leading to permanent employment later on and to an increase in the wealth-giving resources of the country, there might be something to be said for it, but it has the disadvantage that a large proportion of our resources are being locked up in schemes which are not going to add to our productive wealth and that is going to reduce the amount available for the schemes which should be borrowed for and to which the Government should give a high priority in order to develop our national resources.
Every single item in the Board of Works Estimate that could be regarded as coming under the heading of building works has been taken as an item for which the Minister proposes to borrow. Even national schools and Garda stations, the cost of which should be met in the ordinary way annually from revenue and which in the past were always so met, are now to be put into the capital services category and borrowed moneys are to be spent in making substantial provision for them. That may look very well. It may be said: "Are you not relieving the present even at the expense of the future," but the point is that we are avoiding or evading our obligations if we are not able to meet in the normal way the services which we have met in the past, and, when the Minister talks of the fact that his professional friends have changed their minds with regard to what are the services which can be borrowed for, I would remind him that they condemned very strongly in the past the idea of allowing the deadweight debt of the country to be piled up, that is to say, the debt which is not giving a return reproductively, or which, as the Minister has said so often, relates to schemes which are not helping to pay for their cost.
The Minister was very critical of State boards and Government enterprises in the past and the basis of his complaint was that they were not paying their way. In his latest Budget statement, he has somewhat altered his position in that regard and he thinks he foresees a somewhat brighter prospect in regard to them——
Comment on this
The Minister ought to give the House the information to which it is entitled and state specifically what are the schemes which he feels are likely to pay for themselves, either now or within a reasonable period of years, and what are the schemes which are not likely to do so. But, in this matter of capital development, in the same way as the Minister has changed his attitude with regard to his mandate for retrenchment, he has also changed his attitude as to what the basis of the capital programme should be. Originally, the idea was that they should be remunerative, in the sense that they should, to a large extent, pay their way. Now the Minister has completely changed his attitude and is prepared to put projects, which he admits can only go into the sphere of capital services under the very vague and wide title of being socially desirable or socially profitable, in the category that the money can be borrowed for them. Sometimes the Minister condemns social services very vigorously and describes them as being concomitants of the servile State.
If you are going to borrow for the types of services that are included in this £12,000,000, I fail to see why you should stop there. Why not go further and borrow for health services or social services generally? The only thing necessary, apparently, under this new policy, is to select some arbitrary figure, say £66,000,000. Having regard to the fact that the Minister last year said that taxation was at its higest peak, that the community was paying 25 per cent. in one way or another to the national income for taxes and rates and contributions, apparently even the Minister cannot be driven any further in that respect. So he takes arbitrarily a certain figure, £66,000,000, which represents more or less what he is getting on the ordinary rates of taxation and says that everything over that will be described as capital expenditure. Perhaps it is not quite as simple as that and we may be unduly suspicious of the Minister, but it looks extraordinarily like it.
The most serious aspect of this particular section is that, except for the publication of an annual statement, we may never hear of this section again. Unless some Deputy wishes to query the annual account which is to be published in regard to it, he will not have an opportunity in the Finance Bill of raising the matter. In that way, it will not come under the review of the Dáil and its operation will not come under the observation of the public. I suggest that, because of the special way in which this clause has been introduced, because of the special provision that the payments should be made into the Central Fund, it is necessary that those who are interested in this matter should call attention now to what is being done. I stated that it was the general opinion of economists that if money was being borrowed in a period even of grave depression for public works, that money ought to be repaid as soon as possible during a period of recovery. The idea of borrowing money in times when there is a very high level of money in circulation and when, according to the Minister, the indices of prosperity are all in his favour and show that everybody is having a jolly good time, seems to be an extraordinary one, especially to incur borrowing on this very large scale for this particular type of service. There is no reason for that, that I can see. I am entirely against the principle of borrowing for these services in present circumstances, but if the circumstances were even other than they are and we were dealing with a situation with a depression facing us and we had then to go forward with some large scheme such as the provision of new Government buildings, may I remind Deputy Davin in that connection that while a great many of the Government schemes will give employment in rural areas it is not easy to devise schemes which will give employment to large numbers of unskilled labourers in the City of Dublin? It is only by large constructional works——
Comment on this
——that they can be catered for. Deputy Davin may laugh. I am not including the re-equipment of Córas Iompair Eireann in that category.
Comment on this
There was no destruction of churches. Deputy Davin will not get me off on that red herring.
Comment on this
Has a Deputy of this House who ran away from his post in the pre-Truce period a right to make observations such as that?
Comment on this
So far as Deputy Cowan is concerned, that is worthy of him. I never ran away from anything.
Comment on this
The Minister states that this is to provide for the borrowing of £12,000,000 in the coming year. Is the interest to be calculated at the rate of 2 per cent. per annum?
Comment on this
The sum that someone referred to, £423,000, is the interest at 3½ per cent. The rest is sinking fund.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance is a very peculiar gentleman. When he is here playing to the gallery and to the Party which, according to Deputy Davin, has been responsible for designating him as the holder of his portfolio, he is very chirrupy; but when he is in the Seanad he is singing quite a different story. For instance, when he was dealing with this question of capital expenditure on the 26th October last and pointing out that in one financial year the sum had risen from £700,000 to £7,500,000, he said:—
"But sending that money into circulation through the hands of the community, into which the money must get when expended, has, of course, a very definite inflationary effect."
When Deputy Derrig was speaking, Deputy Davin seemed to feel that any reference on his part to this danger of inflation was rather ridiculous.
Comment on this
Nonsensical, a dream. Now, I suppose one may deal with matters in an imaginative and figurative way when in opposition. That is how Deputy Davin used to deal with this question when he was in opposition, but when one becomes Minister for Finance he ought to cease to dream. According to Deputy Davin, when the Minister for Finance was speaking in the Seanad on this important question of the monetary policy of the State, he appeared to be dreaming — as he did point out that the effect of this heavy capital expenditure, mainly of borrowed moneys, had a very definite inflationary effect. Was the Minister for Finance dreaming when he said that?
Comment on this
Was the Minister for Finance dreaming when he said that? That is the question that has to be answered by Deputy Davin. If the Minister for Finance was dreaming when he pointed to the fact that there was a very definite inflationary risk is Deputy Davin going to continue voting so that the finances of this State may be handled by a dreamer? But let me go on with the quotation:—
"Unless it were to lead to an immediate production of goods— and very little of this money as expended in this way"——
He was speaking of the money to be spent last year and I will come to the money to be spent this year in respect of which £655,000 is going to be charged on the Central Fund each year for 30 years.
"—— there is bound to be inflation."
Do the words of the Minister for Finance spoken on that occasion carry any weight with Deputy Davin? They do carry weight with me because it is quite clear to any person who has been watching the trend of prices particularly in recent months—the prices of bacon and meat are spiralling as are those of other foodstuffs and clothing is going up that we are at the beginning of a definite inflationary spiral such as the Minister for Finance anticipated when he spoke in the Seanad on 26th October last. In this inflationary situation are we justified in flooding the market with more money because that in fact is what we propose to do when we propose to spend £12,000,000 upon works—whether they are meritorious or otherwise is a secondary matter—which we do not propose to procure out of the available purchasing power of the community? The Minister was almost beating his breast on that occasion as he appeared in sackcloth and ashes before the Seanad; for he went on to say:—
"So at once while I am pursuing this desirable course of making a tremendous increase in capital development, do not forget the other side, that I may be weakening the value of the Irish £ and, with the high rate at which Government expenditure is running, our capital account and current account and with our situation in respect of balance of payments, I am not too sure."
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is this distinguished ex-Minister for Finance entitled for the third time— on the Budget, the Finance Bill and now—to repeat himself in the way he is doing?
Comment on this
I am not repeating my words but the words of a member of this House which carry more weight and greater conviction apparently to Deputy Davin than mine do; I am repeating the statement of the Minister for Finance himself. If I can I will get back to commenting upon the passage I have just quoted. He said:
"Do not forget the other side, that I may be weakening the value of the Irish £."
What happens when the value of a currency is weakened? At once prices begin to rise. Nobody I think to-day, despite the cost of living index figure as it is called, is prepared to get up here and deny that the cost of living has considerably increased over the past six months. There is no person who notes the trend of prices who does not anticipate that it is going to increase at a considerably accelerated rate in the very near future. That, I take it, is the justification for the demands which the workers whom Deputy Larkin and others represent in this House are about to make. We have, therefore, evidence that the fears which the Minister for Finance expressed when he spoke in the Seanad last October were justified and that in fact they are already beginning to materialise in a concrete form, in a form which affects every one of us and affects particularly the people whom we represent in this House. The Minister then went on to say:
"We are not too strong, possibly, to present ourselves to the outside world and claim that our £ is better than the English £. People here are accustomed to look across the Channel and see all the defects in the situation in England and complain of all the money that they are circulating, causing inflation and weakening the purchasing value, internally, of their own currency; but we are following very much the same programme at home."
Now it is not Deputy MacEntee, a member of the Opposition, who is expressing himself in these terms, but the present minister for Finance, who is responsible for putting the proposals contained in Section 22 of the Finance Bill before the House. Having mentioned that a member of the Seanad said that he agreed that one may take the risk, and even though in the short run what you do may have an inflationary effect, it may be necessary to take the risk in order to get certain desirable objectives achieved, the Minister went on to express himself on the point:—
"We have weighed that risk and have taken the risk, but it is not a very happy side of our situation and it may be—"
and I hope that those who have been accusing us of damaging by our criticisms the public credit will weigh and ponder very carefully what the Minister for Finance himself had to say concerning the effect which the Government's present policy was likely to have on the investing public, when he continued in these terms:—
"—it may be that the investing public has surveyed the position and come to its own conclusion, and maybe that was why subscriptions did not roll in for the last loan in such volume as they might have."
What was true or what the Minister surmised might have been true in relation to the reactions of the investing public towards the last loan is likely to be made more true and much more pronounced when the investing public see that the Minister proposes to do what Section 22 provides.
Comment on this
That poster would not have been issued and could not have been issued except for the policy which Deputy Davin and his colleagues are pursuing in relation to the management of public finance. You have been playing ducks and drakes with the public moneys since you came into office and now of course the chickens are coming home to roost. However, I do not want to be sidetracked on that issue. I want to get back to the point I was making. The effect of the provisions of Section 22 of the Bill will be to weaken public confidence in the credit of the State. I believe that these provisions will deter investors from investing in our future loans. It is bound to do that, because they see here a proposal to saddle the State with an annual burden of £655,000, with a total payment over 30 years, making almost £20,000,000 in respect of a sum of £12,000,000 that is going to be spent this year. Those who have money to invest, those who have lived prudently and providently all their lives and have earned their money hard and saved thriftily, are going to look askance at the prodigality with which the public finances are now being handled.
This £12,000,000 is going to be spent this year and, ultimately, the taxpayers will have to find almost £20,000,000 to repay that debt with interest. What is it going to be spent on? We have that set out here in the section. Sub-section (1) provides that the expression "capital services" means voted services which are to be met out of borrowing, and in sub-section (3) of the section we find that a sum of £655,000 is to be provided to redeem borrowings and interest thereon in respect of capital services and it shall be charged annually on the Central Fund.
We have, as an indication of what these capital services are, a note supplied with the Estimates for Public Services. It is headed: "Note regarding Capital Services", and it points out that the total of these services, which are voted services and which are to be defrayed out of borrowed moneys, is £12,113,000. It goes on to issue a warning that this does not represent the full expenditure of the State, through one agency and another, which has to be met out of borrowed moneys. I am merely saying that by way of footnote to the fact that, included in the volume of Estimates for the Public Services, there are services amounting to a total value of £12,113,000, the cost of which is to be defrayed out of borrowings, and these borrowings are to be met by a charge on the Central Fund to be paid every year of £655,452.
Let us see what that means. The first thing that means is this, that next year the taxable capacity of the community to defray the cost of corresponding services is going to be reduced by that amount. The £655,000 may be taken, roughly, as equivalent to 6d. in the £ on the income-tax. If, therefore, the expenditure, not upon these services for which we are borrowing this year, but the expenditure upon the services for which we are taxing this year, is to be maintained at its present level, if we are to continue old age pensions at their present level, and if we are to continue widows' and orphans' pensions and the normal expenditure upon education and all the other services at their present level, we shall have to find, in order to do that, an additional sum over and above what we are raising in taxation this year, an additional sum of £655,000.
That is a considerable sum. It represents nearly a quarter of the tax upon petrol and upon hydrocarbon oils, light and heavy, which we were discussing yesterday evening; it represents virtually 6d. in the £ on the income-tax. I cannot say what it means in relation to the tax on tobacco or beer or spirits, a proposal to increase which would make the Government Party stand aghast. But the Government Party had better face up to this fact, that when the section goes through, next year, if they are going to maintain public services at their present level, they will have to find out of taxation an additional sum of £655,000, over and above what they are proposing to find this year.
Let us consider to what extent we are justified in imposing this charge on the Central Fund in respect of these services. In order to do that it is necessary for us to consider the services in some part. The first of these is Public Works and Buildings, and we see there, under the heading "New buildings and works of reconstruction", that a sum of £800,000 has to be borrowed. There, so far as the capacity of this Dáil to appraise the wisdom of borrowing for that purpose is concerned, we are brought to a standstill, because when we turn to page 9 and look at sub-head B, New Works, Alterations and Buildings, we find the sum total of the New Works, Alterations and Additions to be provided in the year 1950-51 is estimated at £1,166,000. All we know is that out of all the building that is to be done for the President's establishment, the Houses of the Oireachtas, the Departments of Finance, Justice and Education, as well as every other Government Department, amounting in all to £1,166,000, we are going to borrow £800,000.
We do not get any further information on that from the Minister, and the public, therefore, are not in a position to judge whether it is wise or unwise to borrow that £800,000. I think it is unwise to borrow it, for the reasons I suggested. The State ought not to do any more in one year than it can afford to pay for in that year. The State is not in the position of a man who buys a house, as was at one time suggested. The State is a continuing organisation which must, in each year, make provision to maintain itself out of the resources available to it in that year. It is a living organism.