We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 1–197 of 391. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Looking through the report of my statement on Thursday last in the Official Report, at column 2322, I find that the word "tons" has been used instead of "barrels", and I should like to make the necessary correction. The phrase "carry-over of 180,000 tons of barley" should read "carry-over of 180,000 barrels of barley" and the same applies in all cases where the word appears.

While speaking about the price of wheat, I made the statement that the price of 62/6 a barrel was fixed in October, 1947. The Minister, as I believe, purposely and deliberately, tried to mislead the people by saying that I was "daft" to say such a thing and it has been spread through the country that it was the Minister who was responsible for fixing that price. I now say again that he did not fix the price, and, in proof of that, I will read the official announcement which appeared in the daily papers of October 11th, 1947, as follows:—

"The Minister for Agriculture announces that it is the intention of the Government to make a Tillage Order for 1948, at an early date, under which occupiers of five or more statute acres of arable land will be required to cultivate in 1948 three-fifths of the area of such land and to sow with wheat a specified minimum area equal to one-tenth, one-sixteenth or one twenty-fifth of the arable area, according to the district in which the holding is situate. Land laid down to first year's grass will be allowed to count as cultivation to the extent of not more than one-quarter of the tillage quota. The tillage quota and the wheat quota will, therefore, be the same in 1948 as in 1947.

The Government have furthermore decided in the case of growers of wheat of the 1948 crop to guarantee a price of 62/6 per barrel of 20 stones for wheat of the first grade and in the case of growers of barley of the 1948 crop to fix a minimum price of 45/- per barrel of 16 stones."

The Minister must have been aware that that price had been fixed, and why did he come in here and deliberately try to mislead the House?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister may not be accused of deliberately misleading the House.

Comment on this

The Minister must have known——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister may not be accused of deliberately misleading the House.

Comment on this

He must have known that he was not responsible

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy understands me.

Comment on this

If the Ceann Comhairle will give me a better word meaning the same thing, I shall be satisfied to use it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have no intention of attempting to do so. The Deputy may not continue on that line. The Minister may be mistaken, but he cannot be accused of deliberately misleading the House.

Comment on this

I withdraw the word "deliberately," if that is the case, but to me it means the same thing.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A withdrawal is unconditional.

Comment on this

Was it in order for the Minister to accuse the Deputy——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Nobody raised any point at the time and I was not here.

Comment on this

The Deputy has stated that he was accused of being "daft" because he suggested that this Order had been made in 1947. Was the Minister in order in that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not ruling on what happened last week or last year; I am ruling on what is said now.

Comment on this

I should like the House to know that he was not responsible for the fixing of the price, and I would suggest that Deputies who support the Minister should not try to mislead the people when speaking down the country. They have preached off platforms that it was this Government which gave 62/6 per barrel for wheat. Why has this been so? Simply because the Minister on every occasion has made the statement that he was responsible. We want to kill that lie here and now. He did not have hand, act or part in fixing that price any more than I had.

Comment on this

The Minister was responsible for fixing it for five years.

Comment on this

He was. Why not claim credit for that for which he is entitled to credit and not deny to others the credit to which they are entitled?

Comment on this

I said, when he challenged me on the last occasion, that I gave him credit for continuing that price for five years, but he denied that Fianna Fáil fixed the price and that Deputy Smith was responsible. When he said I was "daft" to say such a thing, what else did it imply but that he was responsible for it? I am sorry the Minister is not here because he might be able to tell us what he meant on that occasion. It is the studied policy of the Minister to take credit for everything that is good. If it is bad, he denies he has any responsibility for it.

There are many things for which we could criticise him, but I think I covered most of what I have to say when I was speaking on Thursday. I want to have this matter that I have referred to corrected and to try to drive home to the Minister his responsibility in the way in which he misled the people.

Another matter that I wish to bring to the Minister's attention is the question of an apple-packing station in South Kilkenny. There are about 300 acres of apples grown in Piltown. Some time ago arrangements were being made for the erection of a packing station in that area. Now the Minister has decided, for what reason I do not know, to build a packing station at Dungarvan, which is 30 miles from Piltown. Only about 30 acres of apples are grown in Dungarvan. Why is it that the Minister must ask the farmers of Kilkenny to transport apples 30 miles to a packing station at Dungarvan? There seems to be no justification whatever for erecting it in Dungarvan, where they have not the apples. I suggest that the purpose is to give the people of Dungarvan a factory because the crumb factory that was to be erected at Dungarvan is being erected in Clonmel. I suggest that it is in order to satisfy the people of Dungarvan that the Minister will place the people of Kilkenny in the position that they must transport apples from Piltown to Dungarvan.

The Minister is making a very grave mistake. It would be very expensive on farmers and they would require a higher price for their apples in order to get the same profit from the crop in view of the cost of transport from Piltown to Dungarvan.

There is one matter that I wish to urge on the Minister. It may not have any direct bearing on this Estimate but it affects it indirectly. It is the question of tourism. When the Minister is issuing advertisements with regard to agricultural produce, he should advise the people as to the value of tourism to agriculture. It would be much better for this country if the beef that we send to England were eaten at home. If most of our beef were eaten here by tourists it would mean additional employment on the land and in the hotels and, generally speaking, would help every branch of the agricultural industry. We would be able to retain by-products such as hooves, horns and all the rest and thereby be in a position to have a variety of factories.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

I was very glad Deputy Walsh, in his opening remarks, congratulated the Minister on the way in which he presented the Estimate to the House. I want to join with that Deputy in congratulating the Minister on that matter. The Minister has reviewed the position over a period of years. It is not very difficult to understand his introductory statement and he has given details in the White Paper. When I listened to Deputy Walsh criticising the work carried out by the Minister during his period of office, I wondered if he had read the particulars furnished by the Minister and if he had examined this White Paper in which the Minister, in five or six lines, has given the net result of his work.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

I wonder if Deputy Walsh has made his own calculation of the increase in the value of our exports over the period of years that the present Minister has been responsible for the Department. It comes as a surprise to me and, I am sure, to many Deputies to find from the documents that have been supplied by the Minister the increase in the export value of surplus stock and food of every description in the last three years as compared with the year before the Minister took office.

In 1947 the value of cattle exported from this country was £12,847,228. That went up in 1948 and in 1949 and in 1950 it has increased to £20,488,800. That is, roughly, an increase of £8,000,000 in the value of cattle exported from this country in 1950 as compared with the year 1947. There has been an increase, also, in the number of cattle exported, but that increase in 1950 is small compared with the increase in value. In other words, the export value of cattle has increased because of the price arranged with the British in the agreement of 1948. The same thing applies to horses, dead poultry and eggs.

As I have mentioned eggs, I may say that the Deputies on the other side of the House have complained about the price of eggs and about the price which the Minister has got for the year 1951-52. Prior to this recent agreement on the price of eggs, the Minister, in 1948, reached agreement in regard to the price of eggs sold to the British for a period of two years. That price has actually operated a year longer, thus giving us for three years the price that was agreed on in 1948. The price which our present Minister got in 1948 was, I would point out, in excess of the price which the previous Minister was able to obtain in any of the years he was in office. Under the present Minister, the producer has been able to obtain 2/6 a dozen for the surplus eggs he has for sale and in some instances a price even higher than that has been obtained. I remember the conditions which prevailed between 1943 and 1947 when the British were crying out for eggs and when they would possibly have given any price for eggs if they could have got them. For the greater part of that period the export price of eggs from this country was under 2/6 a dozen to the producer. Only for very short periods, indeed, was the price over 2/6 a dozen. During the spring and summer seasons the price hardly ever reached 2/6 a dozen. There was a period in the winter when the price did exceed 2/6, but what happened? There were practically no eggs for sale in the shops in Dublin and there was a black market, as far as eggs were concerned, all over the country.

The winter price was controlled during a number of those years, and the result was that vans were sent from the city all over the country to buy and collect eggs. I do not know what prices were paid, but I know the prices they were able to get for them and the prices which were charged in the city. I know that the producer did not get the advantage of the price which the eggs were fetching in those years. That is not the position now. The present Minister did not control the prices: he left the market open. If the people wanted to buy eggs they were free to pay any price they liked for them. The result is that the producer is getting fairer treatment than formerly.

Another important matter which has been raised in this debate is the question of pigs and bacon. During the years I have already referred to, no bacon was to be seen in any shop. The factories were practically on the eve of closing down, and there was also the difficulty of unemployment to be faced. Bacon was then a novelty to everybody. It is my opinion that in those years, and even now, the big increases we hear of in the number of pigs being sent to the factories may not be quite as large as we may, perhaps, think. It is possible that in those years there was a fair production of pigs, but that they were not reaching the factories and the consumer in the ordinary way, and that every section of the people did not get a reasonable opportunity of obtaining a reasonable share of all the bacon that was available. The Minister has changed that state of affairs. He has asked the people to produce more pigs, and certainly pig production has increased, and is still increasing. In 1939 the number of breeding sows in this country was 95,317. Ten years later — 1949 — that number was 67,832. In other words, the number of breeding sows in this country in 1949 was practically two-thirds of what it was in 1939. That shows that farmers are going back again to pig-raising — not that I can see that there is a fortune to be made by any farmer as far as the production of pigs is concerned. I believe that, as in the past, it will continue to be the same old story. However, the pig was always regarded as a sort of savings bank for the farmer. It was felt that the farmer who kept a sow and reared pigs was never short of the price of his rent and rates. I believe that that is true and will continue to be the case. That is one of the main reasons why people have gone back to pig production.

Some speakers in this debate have complained of the high price being charged for rashers and they have said that rashers have been sold in some retail shops for as high as 4/6 a lb. If 4/6 a lb. has been charged for rashers I must say that I agree that that price is far in excess of what it should be. I am aware that that price may have been charged for a special cut — back rashers or some other such cut — but, considering the price at which bacon can be bought from the factory, I am afraid that 4/6 a lb., retail, exceeds a reasonable profit. In fairness to the factories and the prices which they charge, I must say that I think 4/6 a lb. is not a fair retail price to charge for any selected cut. I have made inquiries and from these inquiries it would seem that the price of from 4/6 to 4/8 a lb. for rashers is not general. I understand that the usual price for back rashers is roughly 3/6 a lb. Streaky rashers are being sold at 3/2 and 3/3 and the shoulder at 3/-; some of it is being sold under that. Even though those prices are got for rashers, there is a good percentage of the side of bacon that can be sold at a very low price. There is a portion of the side of bacon that certain sections of the community cannot afford. They cannot pay the dearer prices, but they have the advantage of being able to buy portions of the side at a lower price.

So far as the factories are concerned, they constitute useful industries and they are of great benefit to the farming community. They are helpful to the farmer in many ways and they always try to take his stuff. There is no waiting for the sale of the pig.

Speaking of the price of bacon, I would like to repeat what I said last year, and that is that there should be a two-price period for the pig. Any Deputy who comes from a rural area is well aware that pigs can be reared and fed more cheaply in the winter months as compared with the summer months. Pig prices should be at least £1 to 30/- a cwt. higher in April, May, June and July than in the remaining eight months of the year. In the month of April the farmer is somewhat short of waste food, such as he had in abundance during the winter. In April he has little to feed the pig upon unless valuable food. Sometimes he has to give the pig ordinary eating potatoes. In those months he can turn those potatoes to more valuable uses.

If the farmer is asked to produce pigs in April, May, June and July the public should be notified that they will have to pay a higher price in those months. The Minister would be well advised to introduce an increased price for those four months of the year. The public should be made aware that in that four months' period pigs will be dearer and consumers will have to pay more for their rashers and boiling bacon. If the farmers knew they would get a better price, and the consumers agree to pay more, there would be no hesitation in developing pig production.

In the summer months the farmer goes into his fields and looks after his tillage. The potato crop comes in during the months of August, September and October. There are plenty of waste potatoes and the farmer also has waste corn, barley, wheat, a surplus of milk, and cabbage and other vegetables. All this cheap food helps during this period to raise pigs, and they can be sold at a much lower price. I feel sure farmers would be satisfied with a lower price at this period of the year. If they are called upon to take the same price from April to July the general feeling is that farmers will not be prepared to continue in pig production. They will not do so during the summer months unless they get sufficient to meet the increased cost of feeding.

There is one grievance I would like to mention and I trust the Minister will keep it in mind. I refer to the scheme of subsidising day-old chicks. This scheme was in operation in Galway last year, but Mayo was not included. I must say that the people in my constituency were very disappointed that they were not included in the subsidised day-old chicks scheme. The Minister is well aware — he will have no trouble in verifying it from the records if he wishes — that Mayo is a very good egg-producing county. There are many small farmers largely dependent on the price they get for their eggs every week. It helps a lot when they have to buy the ordinary necessaries for the house. I appeal to the Minister to include Mayo in the scheme this year.

The Mayo County Committee of Agriculture, of which I am a member, has done everything possible for the people along the seaboard, the people in the Gaeltacht areas. They have been encouraged to go in for egg production and, with the sanction of the Department, we have a special instructor to go into those areas to stimulate the interest in egg production and other matters. I trust the Minister will pay special attention to the Gaeltacht part of County Mayo in any schemes he may contemplate putting into operation. If he omits Mayo on this occasion, the people there will be most disappointed, particularly as regards subsidising day-old chicks, and they will have good reason to be disappointed if they see County Galway included and Mayo ignored.

So far as agriculture and employment on the land are concerned, I cannot see how anybody should be idle on the land. There is plenty of work to be done. The farmer is getting a reasonably good price for his cattle, sheep, eggs, wool and lambs. There is plenty of money at his disposal to have his land reclaimed. He can do that work during part of the year. There is plenty of money provided for work of every description on the land. There is money for houses, repairs to houses, the erection of poultry-houses and buildings of other types. Some Deputies say that employment on the land is beginning to fall off, but I cannot see any falling off. Work should be on the increase and, as a matter of fact, employment is increasing and very few people are idle.

Many people are taking advantage of the various schemes initiated by the Government. There may be some areas where for short periods there is a certain amount of unemployment, but many opportunities are open to the people if only they will take advantage of the Government's schemes and the money that the Government are prepared to provide. If there is anybody unemployed I am afraid it is more or less the fault of the people themselves.

Comment on this

The example of the late Deputy O'Donnell, God rest his soul, encourages me to appeal once more to the Minister to take some action in connection with the reclamation of a large area of my constituency. I do hope that it will not be left as long as the proposal of the late lamented Deputy O'Donnell was left waiting. His spirit, however, seems to have animated the Minister to take action for the provision of water supplies on the farm. Deputy O'Donnell had often pleaded for that; he had preached it almost alone.

The work to which I would direct the Minister's attention is perhaps unique in this country. I refer to the possibility of the reclamation of the vast areas in the estuaries of both the Fergus and the Shannon, amounting in all to 17,000 acres. Some of this land was reclaimed at considerable expense upwards of 100 years ago and is to-day among the richest land in this country. I would suggest to the Minister that for a very small expenditure, even as small as £100 per annum, nature, if only it got a little assistance from the Minister, will reclaim this land. In 1928 the Clare County Committee of Agriculture invested the small sum of £12 for the purchase of rice grass plants. These were sown in various parts of the estuaries referred to, but unfortunately, owing to inexperience — I think it was the first experiment of its kind ever carried out in this country —the plants were not all sown on the most advantageous sites. Those responsible were afraid to go out into these mud flats to a greater depth than perhaps two or three feet. It has now been shown, as a result of the experiments carried out, that by going out three or four feet into the mud flats these rice grass plants take root and so can filter the incoming tide. It takes up to some 20 years for these plants to capture the deposits of mud which each tide brings in and so raise these mud flats to the level of the highest tide. As I say, nature, even without any aid from man, will in the course of time reclaim every acre without another farthing of expenditure from anybody, but I suggest that the work should not be left entirely to nature. These plants will seed naturally. The seed is carried by the tide, and in that way is spread over a vast area. Had this experiment got a little help—if only the sum of £100 that I have mentioned was spent on it year by year — it would hasten the process I speak of and would reclaim at a trifling cost that vast area.

In addition, it would be useful from another angle, and that is the protection of the embankments. Every Deputy who lives on, or has any responsibility for these estuarial embankments, knows what a source of trouble they are. This grass is so prolific that, actually, it has already been responsible for the protection of a pier near Labasheeda in the County Clare. In my opinion, if the grasses were developed, spread and transplanted in the various districts, in the course of time they would create a barrier to prevent the breaking down of these banks. I do hope that the Minister, or whoever will succeed him, will not leave this matter, as happened in the case of the late Deputy O'Donnell, to be a sort of posthumous tribute to his memory.

Now that the cold war which we have witnessed for a number of years has developed into a shooting war in the Far East, I sincerely hope that it will have an effect on the Minister's attitude towards the growing of wheat in this country. The Minister, as we all know, is a man of very strong prejudice, but perhaps the threat with which the world is menaced to-day will help, if nothing else can, to bring him to realise how important it is, in a situation such as we find ourselves in now, to give special attention to this question of the growing of wheat. If this war, which God forbid, should spread throughout the world, what would our position be with regard to food supplies for man and beast? Away back in 1939, the Minister — he was then Deputy Dillon and he was speaking in the Dáil on the 7th July of that year, columns 2241 and 2242 — said:—

"We speak of wheat. The Taoiseach seemed to justify the expenditure of £2,500,000 on the production of wheat on the ground that it provided a guarantee for us against starvation in time of war. Our problem in time of war will be to get food out of the country. Does not the Taoiseach realise that 5,000,000 acres of arable land will feed all the people of the country, even if you ram food down their stomachs with a ramrod? We shall be smothered, stifled and buried in a rotting heap of foodstuffs in the event of war. That is the deadly blow that the enemies of Ireland can deliver against us—to suspend our outgoing traffic. We shall be buying shovels and shovelling food into the sea. With that vast, immense, unconsumable accumulation of food, we are to pay £2,500,000 to protect ourselves against a scarcity of wheat. I lived on oaten bread in my school days. I never got wheaten bread from one end of the year to another, and I weigh 14 stone to-day. We are paying £2,500,000 per annum for the growing of wheat. We have 220,000 acres under this crazy, futile crop, every acre of which could be growing a profitable crop which would provide for our people a higher standard of living. That is Fianna Fáil economy."

I wonder is the Minister still of the same opinion, or is it a case of that "there are none so blind as those who will not see"? Although the Minister has developed 14 stone avoirdupois on an oatmeal diet, I do not think he would get, even amongst those who support him on the opposite benches, very many to agree with him that we should all go back to oatmeal, and neglect to produce wheat. Instead, the Minister has to go to Australia to pay £28 10s. 0d. per ton — that is 71/3 per barrel — for wheat. The Minister claims that he has fixed the price of wheat at 62/6 per barrel, although Deputy Tomás Breathnach, when speaking here last week, pointed out that that price was fixed by the Minister's predecessor. We give him credit for what he did, that, while he did not fix the price, he has guaranteed it for the next five years. We give him all credit for that. The point at which I quarrel with him is this: Why should he pay 71/3 a barrel for Australian wheat that we can produce at home if any encouragement is given to our farmers to produce it? I believe that if our farmers got that price all the wheat we require, and of excellent quality, could be produced here.

Last year, the Minister was proud to announce that the yield from wheat had improved on the previous year. The year was dry and it suited the growing of wheat. I believe that he will be able to make the same boast in respect of the wheat crop this year. Where I find him unfair is that, while he claims credit for the increase in the yield of wheat, on the other hand, when the year proves unfavourable for the growing of oats or potatoes, he will not accept the blame when the yield from these crops is small. I do not want to blame him for that. He cannot blame nature, but I think that, in fairness, he ought to take the blame for whatever diminution there was in the oats and potato crops as well as claiming credit for the increased yield from wheat. I believe that if the Minister were to give the farmers 71/3 a barrel for the wheat they produced — I presume we must take that price to be the market price for wheat this year because otherwise the Minister would not have to pay it — he would get all the wheat we required. I believe, furthermore, that if the Minister were to do that, it would be a very wise policy. Would it not be a safeguard for us at the present time to know that we had, at least in the ground and with a fair prospect of harvesting, a sufficient supply of wheat to carry us over the coming 12 months in the event of another disastrous conflict spreading throughout the world?

In addition he has gone to the Pacific to purchase low-grade wheat. For that he has paid 57/- per barrel, a total of £23 per ton. That wheat is to provide feeding stuffs for animals. With a little encouragement to the farmers they would provide the necessary feeding stuffs themselves. Last year we imported cereals to a value of upwards of £10,000,000; that £10,000,000, spread over the farming community, would have been a considerable benefit to them. It would have helped to keep more people in employment on the land, a policy we are all anxious to see implemented. Worse still, for most of those cereals we had to pay in dollars at a time when it was very difficult to obtain dollars and when the only source through which we could obtain our requirements in that respect was through tourism, an industry that was derided by the spokesmen of the present Government some few years ago.

Eggs are a very important item from the point of view particularly of the farmer's wife. The price of eggs is a very important item. In May, 1948, the Minister told the poultry-keepers, through the medium of a little publication called Pip, that the more eggs they produced and the more they could sell to Britain the more they would get in return. I would like some explanation from the Minister as to what exactly he meant by that. Up to the change of Government, at all events, the position was that the more eggs we exported to Britain the higher the price per dozen or per great hundred, as the case may be. What exactly did the Minister mean by that statement? Does he mean that if we send over a couple of hundred thousand extra great hundreds we will get paid for them also? I think the Minister should clarify the situation with regard to that statement because it might look as if he was deceiving the people in telling them that the more they send the more money they will get in return while, at the same time, not pointing out what has actually happened.

A short time after the Minister taking office the price of eggs fell by 6d per dozen after his first visit to London, in consequence of his desire to obtain parity for our produce on the British market, a position which he had frequently stated could obtain if our Ministers would only cross over the water and meet their opposite numbers. He crossed over on at least two occasions. Each time he returned and announced not parity with Britain but a reduction of 6d per dozen. It is true that during five months, including the winter period, the price will be 3/6 per dozen; during the peak period the price will be down next year to 2/- per dozen. During the five months in which the high price will be payable, our egg exports will be of very little consequence, because during that period there will not be very many eggs to export. Furthermore, the Minister stated that during the months of December and January the birds will be moulting and, as everybody knows, a moulting hen does not lay. That knocks two months out of the five months' high-price period and leaves the producer to carry on during the remaining seven months at 2/- per dozen. I doubt if there will be very much enthusiasm generally for that price. I doubt if there will be any increase in production. Last year there was a slight diminution in production. That was due, in my opinion, to the fall in price which occurred as a result of the Minister's first visit to London.

The Minister gave us the figures of the total volume of milk delivered to the creameries. I think that figure could be misleading unless a comparison is made with the total butter production for the years 1946, 1947 and 1948. Unfortunately, I have not got the figure for 1949. In 1946 the figure was 1,232,601 cwts.; in 1947 the figure was 939,116 cwts.; in 1948 it was 987,723 cwts. There has been very little variation. Production was highest in 1946 and production has been floating around the million mark during those three years. What has increased the volume of milk into the creameries is the abolition of the bounty formerly payable on farmers' butter. Because of that, everybody, who could, had of necessity to go to the creameries. To give Caesar his due, I give the Minister full credit for the steps he has taken in my constituency to provide travelling creameries, without which the people would have been very hard hit. It is only fair that, if we criticise, we should also give the Minister credit for any commendable step he may take. But it gives a misleading impression to give the total volume of milk to the creameries and say that it has increased to a certain extent without, at the same time, pointing out the diminution in the production of farmers' butter.

With regard to land rehabilitation, that is a scheme we all welcome. It is a continuation of the farm improvements scheme with some additions. During the few years in which the farm improvements scheme was in operation very valuable work was done and a very good return was given for the amount of money expended. The schemes were carried out in the main by the farmers themselves with whatever help they had available to them. Recently, in reply to a question from Deputy Childers, the Minister stated that under the farm improvements scheme 242,401 sanctions were issued and a total expenditure of £2,183,167 was made in grants. That gives a picture of the widespread nature of these operations and shows what a considerable boon this scheme must have been to the farming community. In connection with that scheme, the Minister led us to believe that crushed limestone would be available in unlimited quantities in addition to fertilisers in order to improve the land when it had been drained and reclaimed. As far as Clare is concerned there was scarcely any ground limestone available there last year. There is no plant in the county. The nearest plant is some 70 miles away. We were told that efforts were being made to establish a limestone crushing plant in the vicinity of Ennis. So far nothing has been done. Worse still, the Minister refuses to sanction the scheme under which a subsidy was provided for lime through the county committee. Last year the Minister eliminated that, with the result that the farmers did not get their usual supply of lime. In the greater part of Clare, particularly in the western portion of it, you can scarcely raise any crop without lime. There is scarcely any other county in which lime is so badly needed, although North Clare has countless millions of tons of limestone and it only needs to be crushed into dust and spread out on the land; but here again the Minister did not fulfil his promise.

Incidentally, the Minister was invited to come to Clare by the Clare County Committee of Agriculture, over 12 months ago, and while he has roamed through the length and breadth of the land and travelled a great part of the world meanwhile, he has not accepted the kind invitation. He may have been influenced in that decision by the sort of reception he got in Limerick, a reception in which I am sorry to see Young Farmers' Clubs were used — and certainly not used by Fianna Fáil but used by a one-time staunch supporter of the present Government — to give a hostile reception to the Minister. I do not approve of that policy at all and denounced it at the time. I think every Minister of State, whether you agree with his views or not, is entitled to a courteous reception and that I am sure he will get in Clare if he accepts the invitation of the committee. I think it was for the purpose of explaining the parish plan which, unfortunately, has not been working as satisfactorily as the Minister and we all would desire. Any plan, no matter by whom it is originated, which would help to improve conditions in rural Ireland will be welcomed by every right-thinking citizen and I personally would be very glad to see this parish plan a success.

The Minister seems to be very keen on mechanisation and believes that as a result of mechanisation even amongst the smallholders the output will be considerably increased. It might be of interest to Deputies to know that in a broadcast from Northern Ireland a gentleman named Mr. F.G. Sturrock, of the School of Agriculture, Cambridge, stated that it was disturbing to find that

"although English farmers are better equipped with implements than ever before the work accomplished per man shows no sign of increasing".

I am quoting from a report in the Farmers' Gazette, June 24th, 1950. I was surprised on reading that statement. Naturally, one would assume that if the farmers are fully equipped with machinery, as is the case in most of the farms, I understand, in England, we would not have a responsible authority from that country broadcasting that it has not increased the output per man. I do not know if the Minister is aware of that or if that information will help to bring him down to earth before we get rid of our horses completely and leave ourselves to the tender mercies of outside powers to provide us with the wherewithal to continue our agriculture.

For instance, what would our position be if every farmer had a tractor and the full equipment, if we could not get supplies of the necessary fuel? Bad and much condemned though the old horse may be, he performed a very useful function during the last war, and were it not for the number of horses we had then and the good use made of them by the farmers our position would have been much worse than it was. We certainly would not have been able to maintain our supplies of food as we were during that war. It was no mean achievement, particularly when we cast back our minds to the situation that obtained in the first world war, 1914-18. Perhaps not all of the Deputies present will remember what obtained then, that we were using black bread, and very black bread at that, made with an admixture of beans. We were also using brown sugar in tea and could not get anything else. Thank God, we escaped these things in the last war, as we were able to produce most of our bread and sugar requirements here in Ireland. I sincerely hope that, with the danger now threatening and which was apparent to most people for the past number of years, even at the eleventh or the twelfth hour the Minister will change his mind, and disabuse himself of many of the prejudices which he carried with him during the last 18 or 20 years. He should take a different view of the farming position and not merely think of plans as ones which were outlined by Fianna Fáil and given effect to by Fianna Fáil. His attitude should be the attitude which we adopt towards anything formulated by him, that which is good for the country that should be the criterion. He should go ahead with it, no matter from whom it emanates and perhaps then the Government would be much better. We would be able to get on much better if the Minister would take into consideration his own interest and the interest of the Government of which he is a member. It would be much better for the country if he would take a saner view on the policy of his predecessors and adopt that portion of it which in the main has shown to be practical.

Comment on this

In the first place, I want to congratulate the Minister and the departmental officials concerned on the preparation and presentation to Deputies of the very valuable documents circulated when this Estimate was introduced. I wish it were possible — I do not know if it is not — that documents of this kind could be printed and made available for circulation and sale throughout the country through the ordinary Government agencies, the Post Office and so on, in the same way as the White Paper on social security was made available and sold through post offices and other Government agencies. If the farmers of the country, regardless of the Minister in office or the Government that is in power, were only made aware of the facilities provided for them by this progressive Department of Agriculture, I am certain there would be much more advantage taken of the loans and other facilities made available now and in the future for the development of agriculture. I seriously suggest that the Minister should consider that the documents, including the particulars of the loans and grants available, should be printed and made available in the same way as the other documents I have referred to.

I have very great respect, and always had, since I heard Deputy Beegan in this House, for his opinion when he speaks here on any matter and especially when he speaks on questions affecting the agricultural industry, about which I am sure he knows much more than I do. Deputy Beegan, in a rather heated assertion at the beginning of his speech, in reply apparently to something said by Deputy Seán Collins from this side of the House, asserted that Fianna Fáil "has never obstructed or sabotaged any effort". I am quoting from column 2183 of the 21st June, Volume 121, of the Official Debates.

It is hardly necessary to remind Deputy Beegan — he might have been in his constituency instead of here, or he might have been somewhere outside the Chamber — that we had Deputy Smith speaking here for five hours and 50 minutes on this Estimate. Is there any sane Deputy on any side of the House or any sane citizen outside who either heard or read that speech and who would not regard it as a deliberate obstruction and to a great extent as containing a considerable amount of repetition? Deputy Martin Corry rose here after Deputy Smith and pleaded to Deputies, with his arms wide open, and particularly to those on this side of the House, and presumably to the Minister in particular, to approach the consideration of this whole question of agriculture from a non-Party point of view. Deputy Corry—I am glad he is here — went on to copy the bad example set by Deputy Smith, but he was not able to stick it. He stuck it for three hours and 20 minutes.

Comment on this

I could stick it for ten.

Comment on this

Can Deputy Corry say that that was not another attempt, an equally successful attempt, to obstruct this whole debate in the way in which Deputy Smith had set the example? I have read portions of the speech made by Deputy Smith in that endurance test — it was an endurance test, not a test of intelligence or an exposition of intelligence—and I am certain that if the present British Minister of Food reads that speech—and I think these speeches are read and interpreted for themselves by British Ministers — and that it is our misfortune at some future time to have to send Deputy Smith over to meet the Minister who will read that speech, the British Minister will consider that it will be fairly easy for him to deal with the person responsible for that kind of tripe in a speech occupying five hours and 50 minutes.

Comment on this

He is not as soft as the "mug" you sent.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry does not like the Minister for Agriculture. That is the trouble with Fianna Fáil. Instead of dealing with Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture and criticising his policy in a constructive way, they make up their minds — they made them up long ago — that the Minister for Agriculture is public enemy No. 1 to them as politicians.

Comment on this

To the nation.

Comment on this

Any proposal he puts forward, no matter how worthy of consideration it is, will not be considered on its merits. I assert that if there was a free vote, a secret ballot vote of the members of this House, as to whether Deputy Smith or Deputy Dillon should be sent abroad to represent us and negotiate on behalf of the farmers of this country, on that secret ballot vote — of course the same thing would not happen on an open vote — Deputy Dillon would be selected by a majority of five to one.

The agricultural and industrial policy of this country is not determined by what was said by the Minister when he was Deputy Dillon or by what Deputy Corry or any other Deputy said in 1932, 1939 or 1947. The policy of this Government was announced to the people of the country on the day the Government was established. A ten-point programme was agreed on, and it is as a result of agreement being secured on the basis of that ten-point programme, in which very few Party groups were able to get their way entirely, that Deputy Dillon sits here now as Minister for Agriculture. So far as I am concerned, if there has been a failure in agricultural policy, it is only on that basis and not on the basis of what he said ten or 15 years ago that I am going to deal with the Minister and criticise him if it is necessary to do so. It is useless for Deputy Corry, Deputy Smith or any other Deputy to get up here and read at length something that was said from a public platform or in this House in 1932, 1939 or 1947. That has no bearing whatsoever on the present situation. Does not every sensible Deputy know that the conditions prevailing to-day at home and abroad are quite different from the conditions that prevailed in 1932, 1947 or even 1948, and that the policy of the Government in regard to agriculture must be decided in the light of the circumstances in which we live to-day, and not in the light of the conditions in which we were living in 1932, or in the other years gone by?

The majority of the farmers of this country living on economic holdings — I am speaking of what I know in my own constituency and I am not interfering with other constituencies — are well off to-day and are prepared to admit it. It used to be said of farmers in the past that they were always grumbling and growling but I have met farmers recently and I asked them were they pleased with the prices they were receiving for their live stock and their agricultural produce. They were quite willing to say right off "certainly." They laughed and were willing to pay for their round and they were pleased to be in a position to do so. Will Deputy Corry or any fair-minded farmer Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches deny that a big share of the bank deposits at the present time is owned by the farmers? Those who read the papers will see that the bank deposits are three times what they were in 1939. Remember that it is not the commercial man or the professional man who puts money on deposit in the banks because they look for more than 1 per cent. They put it into some giltedged security where they will get a higher interest. It is the farmer who thinks that there is no safer place for his money than the banks, even though they pay only 1 per cent. These same banks, with their headquarters outside this country very often, invest that money in foreign securities and they are not too keen to reloan that money to the farmers for the purpose of developing agriculture in this country. Is it not also a fact that the farmers —it is, as far as my area at any rate is concerned — are paying their debts to the banks and to traders? That was not the position in 1932 or 1938. Deputy Corry knows that better than anybody else. Is it not a fact that if you go to Mass or to a church in the rural areas, you will find many more motor cars outside the chapel gate to-day than you would find in 1932, 1938 or even 1947? It must be remembered that the farmer is not in the same position as the commercial traveller or the professional man when he goes to buy a car. He will not get a car, and does not get it, on the hire-purchase system. He gets it for cash and the very fact that you have so many more motor cars in the ownership of farmers is proof that they have the money to pay for them. They would not get them if they had not.

The main item of the ten-point programme upon which this Government came into existence on the 18th February, 1948, was that it was the aim of the Deputies supporting the Government to increase agricultural production by every means at their disposal. That should be the aim, indeed, of Deputies on every side of the House. Every Deputy who has read the statement circulated when this Estimate was introduced, must acknowledge— even Deputy Burke will not deny it— that there is convincing evidence contained in that statement that there has been a considerable increase in agricultural production. If that is so who is responsible for it? The Minister and his colleagues in the Government. The policy, for the framing and operation of which they are responsible, has brought about that increase in production.

I heard Deputy McQuillan making a very interesting, and what I would say was a very sound and common-sense speech, but one point of view was expressed by him that I could not share. He talked about an increase in our exports of surplus agricultural produce and he seemed to indicate and to be himself satisfied that there is a real surplus of agricultural produce here in this country. I would not agree with that and I want to make that quite clear. Even if the Minister shares that view I do not share that view with him or with anyone else.

Comment on this

You do not know anything about it.

Comment on this

Many people appear to think that there is a surplus but the real meaning of the word "surplus" is anything over and above that which can be bought.

Comment on this

The meaning of the word "surplus" in connection with food is that which is over and above that which can be consumed by every citizen in the State. We have 400,000 or 500,000 citizens in this State unfortunately out of our small and decreasing population who have not the purchasing power to buy butter on or off the ration, farmers' butter or creamery butter, and certainly that section of 400,000 or 500,000 who are obliged to live on low allowances cannot buy eggs or bacon as well as farmers' or creamery butter and other essential commodities.

Comment on this

Can they buy enough milk?

Comment on this

That is a most essential food, especially for children. Can anybody get up here and assert that the head of a housesold which is living on the miserable maximum for national health, unemployment insurance benefit or unemployment assistance can afford to buy the milk required by the younger members of his family or any of the other commodities I have mentioned? I would tell Deputy McQuillan that there is only that point of difference between us with regard to the otherwise good common-sense speech he delivered on the Estimate, but he should make up his mind in the future when he talks about a surplus that that word should be used only when there is food in the country in excess of the requirements of the people, both young and old.

If agricultural production is to be increased—and we all agree that it should be increased—for home requirements or for export, I agree with Deputy Walsh or anybody else on the other side or on this side of the House who holds that not alone must we have guaranteed markets—and we must— but that we must have guaranteed profitable prices and that these prices should be announced a reasonable time in advance.

There is no cuter citizen in this State than the big farmer, and there is a high percentage of big farmers in this country who even during the emergency refused to comply with the compulsory tillage regulations, and had to be prosecuted and heavily fined in the courts. If it would have paid them to comply with the compulsory tillage regulations nobody would have done so sooner than these gentlemen. If you want to increase agricultural produce, you must look after the big farmers, who will only till when it suits them to do so. I wonder if the Minister for Agriculture has at his disposal or in his Department the names and full particulars of those citizens— I do not say they were patriotic citizens—who refused to comply with the compulsory tillage regulations during the emergency. If he has those particulars I would advise him, if he has not done so already, to send them to the Minister for Lands, so that the Minister for Lands may use the Land Acts to acquire these lands from these gentlemen, who even during the emergency refused to use them and hand them over to the thousands of cottage tenants who are taking these lands, in the Midlands at any rate, at anything from £14 to £16 per acre at the risk, the grave risk in some cases, of making a loss in the working of these lands which should be worked by the people who own them. If you want to increase agricultural production you have to deal with that type of individual, whether he is a small farmer or a big farmer. You can only get them to till or work the land in accordance with the national interest when you guarantee markets for whatever the farmer is prepared to put into the land and guarantee profitable prices as well. It is only natural to expect that any type of citizen, whether he is a wage earner, a farmer, a professional man, or a commercial man, will give proper service in whatever sphere of activity he is engaged in when he gets an inducement to do so. If he does not get an inducement he should be compelled if it is the national interest during an emergency period or during any other period. It is a scandalous thing that we have had to import over the past few years millions of pounds' worth of agricultural produce that should have been grown on the land.

Comment on this

So you do agree with me?

Comment on this

I do not disagree with Deputy Burke or with any other Deputy just for the sake of disagreeing with him, just as you do with the people on this side of the House. That is a stupid line of action to take for those who profess to be here representing in a sensible way the people who sent them here.

I have been furnished—and I am very grateful to the Minister—with particulars of the conditions under which loans are made available to farmers who need them. I have the idea, however, that the Minister is not convinced that any good, hardworking farmer in the country is really in need of a loan or financial assistance and I am surprised that, after his year or two in office, he should have any doubt on that particular matter. If the minority of farmers in this country—and they are a minority—who are in need of capital or credit facilities are expected to help to increase agricultural produce they must get those credit facilities and capital which will enable them to do so. Without that capital or those credit facilities it must be clear to most Deputies that they cannot make their contribution to an increase in agricultural produce which is so urgently needed.

I will give one clear case to prove that there are people in the country who have failed—and the evidence is there to prove it—because they had not the necessary capital and credit facilities to work the land which was given to them by the Land Commission over the past 20 years. When Deputy Moylan, who made one of the best speeches, if not the best speech so far in the whole debate on the Agricultural Estimate, was Minister for Lands he was forced, as a result of his knowledge as head of the Land Commission, to bring a Bill into this House in 1946 for the purpose of putting 1,500 odd people out of the holdings which had been given to them by the Land Commission during the period of office of Fianna Fáil and of their predecessors as well. Does everybody not know— and nobody better than Deputy Moylan and some of the Deputies sitting on this side of the House—that these 1,500 odd people, previous to getting these holdings, were, in the main, herds, labourers or ploughmen for the land-owners and landlords whose lands had been acquired and divided? They got holdings, but they got no chance of working them, because they had not got a brass farthing of their own and were not given any credit facilities by way of State assistance when these holdings were given to them.

If the Minister will accept that as, evidence that there is a small section, a minority, of the farmers who failed because they were unable to get capital to give them a good start when they got holdings, surely it is, to some extent, a justification for increased credit facilities for that small section of the farming community. Even now, under our Government, if the Minister for Lands proceeds, as he possibly will, when dividing land to give land as it was given in the past to the best agricultural labourers, ploughmen and herds, who worked well and loyally for their employers before the land was taken over, if he proceeds to follow the same policy, these men will fail, unless they get credit facilities and capital to give them a good start on the day they walk into these small farms. These 1,500 odd cases which came under the Act brought in by Deputy Moylan are evidence of a need on the part of a minority of farmers for better credit facilities and if, as the Minister will, I am sure, admit, increased credit facilities are essential for these farmers, I hope he will at the earliest possible date review the existing arrangements for the provision of loans to farmers who need them in order to help the Minister and the country to increase agricultural production.

A rate of 4½ per cent. for a State-established money-lending institution is certainly excessive. Why should a State-established money-lending institution be set up for profit and carried on for profit-making purposes? I assume that money has been borrowed by the Agricultural Credit Corporation at 2½ per cent. and not more than 3 per cent. at different periods during the past 20 years, and if as is the case at the moment the farmers put their huge savings into the ordinary banks at 1 per cent. and, in some cases, at ¾ per cent., surely they should be able and willing to lend it to the State at 2½ per cent. or 2 per cent. in order that the Agricultural Credit Corporation could in turn lend it to farmers at a much cheaper rate than 4½ per cent. I do not understand why a money-lending institution set up and carried on by the State should be carried on for profit-making purposes.

I said that I agreed in the main with the sensible, common-sense speech made by Deputy McQuillan. I am afraid that the Minister—I am not sure if it is his real desire—is in too much of a hurry, in this old country of ours, to mechanise farming, and I agree with Deputy O'Grady that we should not be in a hurry in that connection, because when we wipe out, as we would partly wipe out, the horse-breeding industry by such a policy, there are large numbers of citizens who—and nobody knows it better than the Minister—will go down with it. We have to look forward to the time when, as during the recent emergency, we will have to rely on our own resources to feed and cater for our people. If we had been unfortunate enough to have wiped out the railways during the 1939-45 emergency, what kind of position would we be in now? The same position, to a lesser extent, I admit, would exist, if we went on to mechanise farming in its entirety.

Deputy McQuillan made a very sensible suggestion to which I hope the Minister will give early and careful consideration, that he should consider the establishment of demonstration farms where they are not now available, and that refers to the majority of counties. Such demonstration farms would be an easy way of providing for the neighbouring small farmers tractors and threshing machines for hire in the same way as has been done in my part of the country for years past.

There is one other matter which has not got a direct bearing on the administration of the Minister's Department but which, in my opinion, has an unfortunate effect upon agricultural production. If the Minister would try to convince his colleagues who are responsible of the need to provide money for the repair of a number of cul-de-sac and accommodation roads, it would be a great help to thousands of farmers. If this money could be provided either through Marshall Aid or through the Local Authorities (Works) Act, it would help farmers who are living far away from civilisation to increase their production. There are many farmers I know in my constituency who cannot get a threshing machine into their premises and many more who cannot get motor lorries into their premises for the purpose of taking out beet during the beet season. I could quote exceptional cases in that connection—one of them the case of a very decent farmer living a long distance up a bad accommodation road, one of whose family died. The hearse could not go in to bring out the remains and they had to be carried across a field, instead of along a road in passable condition.

I want to draw attention also to the need for improved transport facilities for live stock, fish, eggs and other exportable commodities of the kind. I have made a careful study of transport conditions not alone in this country but in Great Britain and in many countries on the Continent, and my opinion is that the rolling stock provided for the transport of live stock for export, and particularly fish and eggs, could certainly be improved considerably. That applies to both road and rail transport, and I urge the Minister to use his influence with the new nationalised transport concern with a view to securing improved facilities for the transport of live stock from Irish fairs to the ports through which they are sent to Great Britain.

I have also been asked to seek his assistance in trying to stop the diversion of live stock from fairs in this country from their natural route through Twenty-Six County ports and their shipment through Six-County ports. The very fact that live stock are diverted over the Border and shipped through Six-County ports to Great Britain means a big loss in dues to many Irish ports, as well as considerable loss of employment to dockers in these ports, and also to cattle agents. I understand that even the Minister's predecessor some few years ago was asked to look into this matter as one requiring urgent attention. I would be glad if the Minister would say something as to what has been done or can be done in that direction when he is replying to this discussion.

It is many years since I and other Deputies referred to the necessity there is, for the sake of the farming community, of providing better fair greens and market places in towns where fairs are held and of improving transport facilities. I have been told by cattle dealers that there is a genuine depreciation, that there is a loss in some cases of £3 per head, on the cattle bought in an Irish fair between the time they are bought and the time they reach the British market. That is due to bad transport facilities and the way in which cattle are treated on the fair greens and market places. It is a good many years since a Minister for Agriculture—I forget who the particular Minister was at the time—set up an advisory committee in connection with that matter. I do not know that anything at all has been done to provide improved facilities in so-called fair greens and market places.

I do not know whether I would be entitled on this Estimate to raise the present position of the flour milling industry. I do so, subject to your ruling, Sir, and to the Minister's willingness to deal with the matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think the Minister has anything to do with it.

Comment on this

I believe he has a fair share to do with it. He may not admit it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The flour milling industry is a matter for Industry and Commerce, I think.

Comment on this
James Matthew Dillon Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Dillon) Independent

It depends on what aspect the Deputy wishes to raise.

Comment on this

I would not be surprised to learn that the Minister has a finger in this pie, and quite rightly so, and that he could say more in regard to the present position in the flour milling industry and its future than any other Minister, even though a considerable amount of money has been provided by way of subsidies for the few people engaged in this industry in another Vote. A commission was set up, with the knowledge and approval of the Minister for Agriculture, known as the Lavery Commission. I am one of the Deputies who have been waiting for a long time to read the report and recommendations of that commission. I understand that the report and recommendations were furnished a long time ago to the Minister for Agriculture and to his colleagues in the Government. I raise this matter because I know it is the desire of the Minister, as it is my personal desire, to cut down the huge amount provided by the taxpayers by way of subsidies to the lowest possible minimum figure. I have a shrewd suspicion, in fact I am convinced, and want to be converted if I am wrong, that there are a few people engaged in the flour milling industry who are getting too much by way of subsidy, at the expense of the farming community, the people who provide them with the raw material. I will not say any more on that, but I would invite the Minister, if permitted by the Chair, when he is concluding this debate, to give us a little more information than we have been given so far on this matter

I said in the beginning, and I want to repeat in the presence of the Minister, that I am very grateful and I believe every Deputy should be grateful to the Minister and his departmental officials for the very valuable and informative statements which were circulated to Deputies when the Estimate was introduced by the Minister. I make the suggestion—it is not the first time it was made in this House —that the farmers would have their eyes opened wide if the Minister could persuade his colleagues and the Department of Finance to print and circulate through the ordinary Government agencies, the Post Office and so on, all the valuable information that is contained in the documents that were circulated to Deputies in connection with this Estimate.

Comment on this

As I do not know a whole lot about agriculture, I shall be very brief. Like Deputy O'Grady, I should like to express concern at the trend in agricultural policy under the Coalition. There seems to be a return to the pre-1932 policy of raising live stock for export and cutting down cereal production. Such a policy, in my view, in face of a threatening world situation, when the mind of man is dominated by fear of a recurrence of a world war, apart from being economically unsound, is disastrous for this country.

Reviewing the war years, we can recall the great effort on the part of our farmers to raise the acreage under wheat from 258,000 acres in 1939 to the record figure of 662,000 acres in 1945.

Comment on this

Would it relieve Deputy Ormonde to know that there was never more wheat in this country than there is at this moment?

Comment on this

I will come to that point if the Minister will permit me to make my speech in my own way. We must remember that the wheat policy of Fianna Fáil during the emergency years was responsible for ensuring our basic bread ration. In 1949 the acreage under crops had declined considerably, particularly in wheat and oats. The acreage under wheat, I believe, represents a reduction of 160,000 acres on 1948. The yields in some cases were on the increase, undoubtedly, but production generally was low. In the case of oats, there was a reduction of nearly 200,000 acres, and production was only 559,000 tons as compared with 792,000 tons in 1948.

The position is that we are reducing our cereal production and resorting to imports of grain bought with dollars at a time when we should be husbanding our dollar resources and expanding output. If the decline in wheat acreage is maintained over the next couple of years, our imports of wheat in 1952 will be alarmingly great. One wonders where the Government hope to get dollars to pay for wheat imports when the Marshall Plan comes to an end. It will be interesting to learn from the Minister why he persists in a policy of incurring dollar debts for a commodity which could be very easily produced at home.

The Minister may claim that he has made repeated appeals for an increase in the acreage under wheat. He has certainly made appeals for an increase in the acreage under wheat, but he has made them in such a fashion as to create the impression that he did not give a straw if there was another acre under wheat or not, provided his policy of exporting live stock went on apace.

Above all, the Minister should remember that if war should come, we will be faced again with a return of emergency conditions. Shipping difficulties alone could easily cut us off from our present suppliers of wheat. If war comes, we must depend entirely on what we produce ourselves and any year's bread ration might easily depend on the acreage under wheat in the previous year. In view of that, I would urge the Minister to reconsider his tillage policy with a view to making us completely independent of outside sources for our food supply.

The cause of the reduction in the acreage under oats is not far to seek. It must be directly attributable to the Minister's handling of the oat crop in the first two seasons of his term of office when, having induced farmers to increase the acreage under oats by an assurance of a ready market and an economic price, he left them without price or market. The crop was left on their hands or, rather, had to be disposed of at a price that was not economic.

Last year, in the absence of any assurance from the Minister of a market or price, and having the experience of the two previous seasons, farmers were very reluctant to grow oats, with the result that there was a drop in the acreage under the crop. The Minister must take steps to relieve the uncertainty in regard to this crop and, by guaranteeing a price and a market, secure a big increase in the acreage under the crop. Statistics show that the greatest exodus of people from this country is from the land. Judging by the Minister's public statements he does not seem to be greatly concerned about emigration. He publicly stated that his ideal position would be a family of 21 of which he would be glad to see 20 emigrate. He also stated he would like to see a position brought about here where one man on the land would be doing the work of six men—I presume the remaining five would have to emigrate. Perhaps the Minister, in making these statements, may have been speaking in his usual irresponsible manner.

Comment on this

Flamboyant.

Comment on this

The word I used was "irresponsible". There is no doubt that the pursuance of the Minister's agricultural policy is steadily bringing about his ideal position in the country and, if it is not altered, it will constitute a serious menace to the welfare of the nation. This policy of leaving us completely dependent on outside sources for our food supplies, coupled with the policy of the Minister for Defence of leaving us defenceless, might lead us into the next war.

Comment on this

Were we not supporting Britain in the last war? What is the use of denying it? Why are you trying to fool the people?

Comment on this

We were not. It was entirely as a result of the agricultural policy which was pursued by Fianna Fáil that we were not in that war. We were able to feed ourselves.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

The Minister has a flair for boasting and one of his recent boasts is that there has been a marked increase in the number of our live stock. In making that boast, he carefully refrained from making any reference to the reduction in our tillage acreage. There is one aspect of the increase in our live stock to which I should like to refer briefly. The increase in the number of sheep has led to an increase in the export of sheep. The arrangement with Great Britain in regard to that export has been very unfavourably received by representatives of the tanning industries, of which there are two in my constituency, and other industries which are affected. Just as the export of live cattle has brought about a shortage of hides for the tanneries, so the export of sheep and lambs will create a very acute shortage of pelts for soft leather and shoe linings. This shortage is also reflected in the increase in the price of leather and footwear generally—and in a periodic lack of employment in the tanning industries. The Minister is not entirely free from blame in that connection. His advice to the people supplying hides to the tanneries to keep them until the price offered was raised had dire repercussions. The Minister might now endeavour to eliminate this shortage of hides by coming to some agreement with the British Government whereby a certain percentage of the hides which we export on the hoof would be returned at an economic price.

Comment on this

Would the tanners think of paying as much for an Irish hide as for an Argentine one?

Comment on this

It does not seem to be sensible to be exporting hides on the hoof to Britain and then buying the hides back.

Comment on this

Would the tanners think of paying as much to the Irish farmer for a hide as to the Argentinian farmer?

Comment on this

They can buy these hides at a much cheaper rate at home.

Comment on this

True for you.

Comment on this

Could it not be arranged that a percentage would be returned by Britain? If the Minister could ease this shortage he would be doing a good day's work for the tanning industry.

Comment on this

Why would they not pay the Irish farmer as much as they are willing to pay the Argentinian farmer?

Comment on this

Possibly they would be prepared to pay an increase on what they are paying now, but we are paying far in excess of what we could pay at home by importing these hides.

Comment on this

Why not pay the Irish farmer as much as you pay the foreigner?

Comment on this

I come now to the subject of eggs. The Minister's announcement in regard to the price of eggs in 1951 must have come as a rude shock to the egg producers. He seems to be quite pleased with a bargain under which the producer of eggs will have to suffer a loss of 6d per dozen over a period of seven months for an increase of 1/- per dozen over four months.

Comment on this

Seven months plus four month make 11 months. Where is the twelfth month?

Comment on this

The scheme will begin in February, 1951. That leaves 11 months. I am dealing with the year 1951.

Comment on this

It is a queer year that has only 11 months.

Comment on this

I am dealing with 1951.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Ormonde maintain that there are only 11 months in the calendar year?

Comment on this

I am beginning from February, 1951, and I am dealing with that year.

Comment on this

The Minister seems to be quite satisfied with this agreement but if he thinks that the egg producers are going to be fooled into thinking that an increase of 1/- per dozen for eggs over a period of four months when production is at its lowest will offset the loss of 6d. per dozen over a period of seven months when production is at its highest, he is mistaken.

Comment on this

What is to become of the twelfth month?

Comment on this

The Minister must have a very poor idea of the intelligence of the people if he thinks that he can fool them into thinking that that is a good bargain. The Minister said that 2d. an egg is not a bad price provided we produce the feeding stuffs at home. He said that there is no reason why fowl should be fed with anything which is not produced at home and, to a certain extent, I agree with him. I would point out, however, that not all those who are engaged in egg production are in a position to grow the feeding stuffs. Quite a large number of these people do not possess a rood of ground outside that which they use for their fowl. Consequently, those people have to feed their fowl on oats purchased at 50/- a barrel and on balanced mash at 26/-.

Comment on this

You told me a minute ago that the oats had to be thrown away.

Comment on this

I do not know why the Minister was not able to reach as good an agreement with the British as the Australians were. The Australians got an increase in the price of eggs. I do not know why he should have allowed his hands to be tied so that he could not accept an offer from America to buy our eggs for much-needed dollars.

Comment on this

America?

Comment on this

Yes. This egg agreement is going to have a very detrimental effect on the industry and it is a very poor substitute for the agreement made by Fianna Fáil under which the British were providing a subsidy of £1,750,000 in order to pay 3/- a dozen for our eggs.

Comment on this

That has gone long ago.

Comment on this

It has not. I do not know whether the Minister referred in his introductory speech to flax. No flax is grown in my constituency but while travelling in West Cork and in Donegal I was impressed by the great areas of land there unfit for the growing of other crops. No effort should be spared to put the growing of this crop on an economic basis for those people. We would welcome a statement from the Minister as to whether he made any representation to the northern buyers with a view to securing an economic price for our flax. Is he prepared to subsidise the growing of flax——

Comment on this

In order to sell it to the Belfast spinners?

Comment on this

No. The Minister might establish a mill here and thus make the southern growers completely independent of the northern buyers. I should be glad if the Minister, when he is replying, would tell the House the position in regard to the flax crop this year in this country. As I have said, it is not grown in my constituency but I was greatly impressed when I was in West Cork, in particular, and in Donegal. I saw that the flax crop was a particular asset to those people down there. Quite a large number of them are not engaged in the growing of any other crop except flax and, therefore, no effort should be spared to put it on a sound economic basis for those people.

I appeal to the Minister to do something to improve the lot of the cowtesting supervisors. As he is no doubt aware, nothing has been done for those people since 1945 when they received, I think, a small increase in their pay. Their work is only part-time but I would point out that they work as many as 60 hours a week. They start very early in the morning—as early as 6 o'clock—and often they are not finished until 9 o'clock at night. Their pay is miserable. I understand that their weekly average is £2 5s. 0d. I am told that they went on strike recently for an increase in pay and improved conditions. On the Minister undertaking to submit a scheme to the creamery societies, the strike was called off.

I do not know why the Minister should not introduce a scheme himself, apart altogether from the creamery societies. The fact remains that these people are worthy of an increase of pay, improved conditions and some security, in view of the very important work they are doing. That is shown by the increased yield of milk in the areas covered by the various cow-testing associations. I hope the Minister will do something to improve conditions. I know I have made very little of an impression on the Minister——

Comment on this

Deputy, you fascinated me.

Comment on this

——but I hope the matters I have brought to his notice will in due course receive his serious consideration.

Comment on this

I can see that the Minister is anxious to get in, but I assure him I will not take five hours and 50 minutes—not more than a fraction of the 50 minutes—to say what I have to say.

I listened carefully to Deputy Smith and Deputy Cogan and I also read through their contributions to the debate, and there was one point that struck me very forcibly. I was wondering if Deputy Smith had some sort of secret way of getting to the Minister's office, or if he was using the truth drug on the Minister, because of the line he took in saying that he knew so much. The line adopted by Deputy Smith was terribly different from the line adopted by other members of the Fianna Fáil Party, members representing city constituencies and constituencies embracing large towns.

I mentioned last year, and I will repeat it now, that in one Party alone there seems to be two different approaches to this subject. One is the viewpoint of the rural Deputies. They are clamouring for increases, as Deputy Corry points out. He gave certain costings with regard to milk. He gave the figure of 13.35 as the cost per gallon for milk and he went further by adding 3½d. or 4d. It is interesting to note that in the 3½d. or 4d. he included an item for which no payment is made, that is, agricultural holidays. As against that we have Deputies from the cities complaining— and, I believe, at times rightly— about the cost of milk. There is a difference and we will have to bear that difference in mind. We must consider agriculture as a whole. We have to take into consideration the producer, and in this respect I have in mind the smaller farmer who may be in a harder position at times to make ends meet.

It is essential for us, when we consider agriculture, to have in mind the Twenty-Six Counties as one unit. We have to differentiate vastly between the costings and the ultimate returns for the producers in areas adjacent to cities and towns and the producers in the outlying districts. When we consider the costs in the cities and towns and large villages, there are certain facts that must not be forgotten. I do not quite agree with certain passages in the Minister's opening statement. For instance, he said that the agricultural community are carrying the rest of the people on their shoulders. I can assure the Minister that the working people in the villages, towns and cities are a long way from being carried on the shoulders of the agricultural community. The price paid by them for various commodities bears a very high relation to the price paid for any other commodity they have to buy. In South Cork there are instances of people paying 4d. for a turnip and they are paying the top price for milk. As the Minister pointed out, the cost for milk is a little over 8d. per gallon for the summer months. I do not agree with the cost given by Deputy Corry when he indicated 13.35 as the average for the whole year.

Comment on this

That is creamery milk.

Comment on this

Even in the creamery areas we can differ with the figure given by Deputy Corry. I think it is only fair we should congratulate the Minister on certain aspects of his work. There is one matter that Deputy Cogan and Deputy Smith seem inclined to pooh-pooh, and that is the problem of trying to prevent the spread of tuberculosis in so far as it might be conveyed through milk. There is a very big danger there as regards the supply not being up to a proper standard. I am not saying that it is deliberate on the part of the producers when they are sending out the milk, but it is a point on which we should concentrate.

As regards the line of approach by Opposition Deputies and by Deputy Cogan, one thing that did strike me was that their criticism could really hold no weight. Their approach to this matter was something like the approach of a legal gentleman in a court trying to make a case when he really had no case at all.

One point which seems to have escaped the notice of most Deputies is the wage paid to the agricultural worker. Notwithstanding the length of the debate, there was very little said about that. Deputy Cogan gave certain figures and mentioned the total agricultural income. He based his case on 11,500,000 acres of arable land and he brought it down to the point that if there are 600,000 on the land, that represents roughly £9 per acre. We will have to be quite candid. All over the country we can see farms totally neglected. I have no sympathy with the people who own those farms, farms that are neglected when they should not be. If we are basing a return on neglected land, and if we take the average at £9, I do not think that is a fair approach.

Deputy Cogan mentioned one very illuminating point. Taking 100 as the index for 1939—that is, dealing with agricultural output—he mentioned that in 1941-42 the index rose to 112, an increase of 12 points over 1939, and in 1944-45 it was also 112.

What struck me very forcibly was this: If the figures were 112 in 1941-42 and in 1944-45, and if the return from agriculture amounted to that figure during the war period, why was it that Deputy Smith, when he came into office, did not do something for the agricultural worker? He was then in a position to do it, but he refused point blank to interfere when the workers asked for an increase in wages. This was the Deputy who, in the course of a six hours' speech on this Estimate, said that Deputies should listen to and give grave consideration to his words. These figures are now admitted to be correct, and they are being recorded as such. I think this is the first time that that has happened. In view of these figures, it is time that the position of the agricultural worker was considered. What I have to say on this may apply more to the southern counties and to the province of Leinster as against, perhaps, West Cork and Kerry and along the western coast where the holdings are very small. In considering the position of the agricultural worker, we must also consider the Agricultural Wages Board. I want to say openly that its attitude towards the agricultural workers is possibly one-sided. I have proof of that here. I do not want to go into the setting up of the board too deeply in view of the fact that if I were to do so I might not be in order. I do want to say to the Minister that I have information which shows that while the Agricultural Wages Board was willing to meet the Cork workers, on a regional wages board, that just because the farmers refused to do so, the board sent a belated letter saying that their hands were tied because the other parties would not attend. Is that a fair attitude for the board to take up? I suggested here before the desirability of having these meetings of the board open to the Press. The Minister, unfortunately, was not present on that occasion. There was another Minister acting for him.

I give the Minister full credit for admitting, in the figures which he gave last week, that there has been an increase in agricultural output. Deputy Smith and Deputy Cogan may say otherwise, but the returns show that whether you take the figures for gross output or net output the increase has been far greater in the last few years than what it had been previously. The point I want to make to the Minister is that the return the farm worker is getting is not what it should be. I do say, in all sincerity, that the Minister has done a good day's work for the farming community. I believe he also realises that he has an obligation to the agricultural workers who cannot be left in the position in which they were in the past. I give him credit for the increase in wages which they have got from the Agricultural Wages Board, through him, since he became Minister. We, on the Labour benches, can never forget what the attitude of Deputy Smith was when he was Minister. He and his henchmen denied the agricultural workers one penny. Therefore, the present Minister cannot be placed in the same category as his predecessor. That was the position in which the agricultural workers were left, notwithstanding that their importance during the war was such that they would not be allowed to leave the country, even though they could better themselves by going elsewhere.

This year, thank God, the road workers throughout the country have got another increase. The Minister for Agriculture should realise that. There was in the past very little difference in the wages paid to these two classes of workers, but the late Minister for Local Government—God rest his soul—when he came into office broke the rule that was there against the road workers which had been held so steadily and so fastly by little Deputy MacEntee and his class. I do put it to the Minister for Agriculture that, if it has been seen fit to bring the road workers' wages up to a standard that has some reality to the presentday cost of living, he will see to it that the agricultural worker is entitled to a fair return for his day's work.

With regard to the land rehabilitation project, which has been avoided in their speeches by so many of the Deputies, I think great credit is due to the Minister. As regards the grants under it, there is one point that I would like to bring to the Minister's attention. It is this, that I believe the larger the landholder the more benefit he can get out of this scheme. It can be of more benefit to him than to the small man with ten, 15 or 30 acres of land, even with the grants. The large farmer may get a grant to put up a few extra gates on his holding, a barn or water troughs. The small man will not need extra gates for his few fields. Neither will he want an extra barn because he has only a small number of cattle. I know that, in relation to other matters, we have condemned the means test, but in connection with this scheme, unless it is to be one-sided, greater benefits should go to the small holder rather than to the large one. No matter how hard the small farmer may work his return from his small acreage of land is bound to be small. In conclusion, I would ask the Minister to give close consideration to the working of the Agricultural Wages Board, and to the crying need of the agricultural worker getting a decent return for a good day's work.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Allen.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen, Deputy Gilbride and Deputy Childers. Deputy O'Grady said over half an hour ago that he was the last speaker.

Comment on this

I said no such thing. The Minister was not here and does not know what I said.

Comment on this

I think this is the largest of all the Estimates which are to come before the House. It represents a total of almost £16,000,000. Even though the Minister issued a White Paper, I think he might have given the House more information than he did. Will he tell us what proportion of that £16,000,000 is to be borrowed money? It would be of interest to Deputies to know what proportion of it is to be borrowed this year. He might also tell us, apart from what will be borrowed, how much of what he is asking is to be raised by taxation, to be paid for this year, for the services set out under the different headings in the Estimate. Many matters arising under this Estimate have been referred to and I am sure the Minister will deal with them when he is concluding. For the past year the Minister has been trying to find solutions to some of the problems facing the agricultural community and he has failed to find them. After making an agreement with the British Government in 1948 the Minister informed the House and the country that for all time henceforth there would be an unlimited market for all the agricultural commodities we could produce here at remunerative prices and prices which would leave the agricultural community a fair profit for their labours. Two years after the making of that agreement the Minister finds himself with a surplus of butter for which he is unable to find a market. He has no hope of selling any surplus bacon or butter to Great Britain unless he is prepared to pay a very substantial subsidy on them. He gave very scant information to the House as to what he proposes to do with surplus creamery butter this year. We were led to believe that the more milk we had the more butter we could produce and the more butter there was available for export the better it would be for the country. The dairy farmers at the moment are on the horns of a dilemma. The Minister has told them he has no hope of selling their surplus butter in Great Britain. He has more or less told the farmers that they would be foolish to try to produce more milk or more butter. That is a very serious matter. Thousands of farmers depend for their livelihood on their dairy produce. The Minister should give them some clear statement as to what the position actually is.

The Minister went down to Waterford this year and told the farmers that unless they were prepared to accept a lower price for their milk and the community in general was prepared to pay more for their butter he saw no future for dairying here. He told them that unless they accepted a lower price the industry would find itself in a state of chaos. That was six months ago. The Minister has not done anything about it since. He alone has the responsibility of increasing the price of butter and reducing the price of milk. He has the responsibility of ensuring that the livelihood of those who depend on milk production will not be impaired or injured. A large quantity of farmers' butter is produced here. The position with regard to that butter has been discussed here on many occasions. Each time the matter is raised the Minister runs away. He will not face his responsibility in that respect. Almost 50 per cent. of the butter produced is produced on the farm. A large proportion of that is surplus to the requirements of the people during six or seven months of the year. In order to solve the problem the Minister's predecessor in his time provided a subsidy from State funds to enable a fair price to be paid to the producer. The present Minister saw fit to withdraw that subsidy thereby throwing those who produce that butter to the wolves. He is well aware that the producers are getting a totally uneconomic price for it. On their returns it works out at less than 8d. per gallon for their milk. The creamery supplier is guaranteed 1/2 in the summer, 1/4 in the winter. A subsidy of over £2,000,000 is provided to enable the consumers of creamery butter to purchase their butter at 2/8 per lb. That is not a subsidy to the farmers. It is a subsidy to the consumers. The economic price for butter, as the Minister has told us, is 3/6 per lb.; the consumers receive their butter at 10d. less than that. There is no good reason why a subsidy of 10d. per lb. should not be paid on farmers' butter. The Minister is sadly lacking in his duty when he refuses to take steps to ensure that that section of the community gets fair play. They pay rates and taxes. They are good citizens. The payment of a subsidy on creamery butter has helped to put the producers of farmers' butter in the position in which they find themselves to-day. If that subsidy were not in existence the problem would not be as serious as it is. The Minister has an important responsibility in this matter.

When introducing his Estimate the Minister said that he proposed to establish cheese factories in County Wexford to replace some creameries which had closed down there; he said they were closed down by me. Irrespective of whoever closed them down, four creameries have closed in Wexford, a central and three auxiliaries operated by a co-operative society. They closed down because they had not a sufficient milk supply. Any steps taken to remedy the position are welcome, but I do not believe that the reopening of these four creameries for the manufacture of cheese will provide any solution to the problem. This problem is not confined to any particular area or county. It extends throughout the whole of Leinster during six or seven months of the year. The reopening of a few creameries for the manufacture of cheese will not solve the problem. If it is proposed to purchase the milk from the farmers, a better solution would be to open a large central creamery with a number of travelling creameries, for County Wexford. The Minister's proposal is to open cheese factories. He will not get the milk at the 1/- a gallon he mentioned, as it would be thoroughly uneconomic for the farmers to bring milk to the creamery at that price and get back no skim or anything else. That is the proposal, to sell the whole new milk at 1/- a gallon. Even at the present time with farmers' butter, it is returning about 7½d. a gallon for milk and the skim milk is worth at least 3d. per gallon and it would cost at least another 1d. to bring it to the creameries. There would be little or no difference between the getting 1/- a gallon and getting 1/9 a lb. for butter. The economy of the farmer is based on using the skim milk at home for feeding pigs and raising calves. The scheme is doomed to failure from the start and I see no hope of any solution along these lines.

This farmers' butter is produced over a very wide area, over three-fourths of the County Wexford, a good portion of Carlow and portions of Wicklow and other counties in Deputy Davin's area. You have many creameries there closed down, that were opened about the same time as the Shelbourne creameries. There were four or five known as the Slaney Valley Creameries, in Deputy Davin's constituency. There is a prolem there at this time of the year. The Minister should reconsider the matter and Deputies sitting behind him should press him to provide a ready solution. There is no other way except to subsidise the export of this farmers' butter. It is a simple and readymade solution, which will cost the taxpayer far less than cheese factories or even a central creamery, as you would need so many of them over such a wide area that the capital cost would be huge.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The Deputy wants us to pay so that others can get the butter cheaply.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins has just blown in and if he wants to start interrupting we will have to deal with that. The farmer Deputies sitting behind the Minister were elected to look after the farmers' interests. What have they been doing about this? Have they brought any pressure to bear on the Minister to give fair play to every section of the farming community? Are they satisfied with the policy being operated by the Minister? They are not. I am sure that when they go down the country those Deputies will tell their constituents that they have been working hard in their interests and in the interests of agriculture. The proof of the pudding is in the policy being carried out by the Department at present and that policy is detrimental and damaging and can lead only to bankruptcy. It is the action of this House in providing that £2,000,000 to reduce the price of butter to the consumer that has brought about the whole situation and made it as bad as it is. For that reason, I cannot see that another £100,000 or less, which would solve the whole problem, would make much difference. It would give many farmers engaged in that system of farming an economic price for their produce.

In regard to the bacon and pigs muddle, the Minister in the years while he was sitting over here, told us month after month and year in and year out that if he had anything to do with the Government or was a member of it, he would provide an immediate solution for the bacon and pigs problem. We find that he has muddled the whole thing.

Comment on this

He took the bacon from under the counter.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Davin had a rasher every morning all the years of his life, and a good back rasher, too. Anyone looking at him would know he was well fed and well minded and never lacked anything. We found some time ago that there was a surplus of bacon. This Minister was always opposed to paying subsidies on the export of agricultural produce. He is paying substantial subsidies now in order to sell our surplus bacon. He refused up to now to pay a subsidy on the export of butter—creamery butter or farmers' butter. He found a surplus of bacon and had to pay a subsidy to export it. If there is a surplus of bacon in the future, he will also have to pay a subsidy. The great British he was so fond of were to get food irrespective of the price, as he loved them as old and valued customers and was prepared to sell to them at a lesser price than that which people in other countries were offering for our produce at one time. He soon found that that old and valued customer was a hard nut to crack, that the British would pay as little as they could, as they always did with this country in regard to anything we had to sell to them.

That was well known to almost everyone in this country except Deputy Dillon, the Minister for Agriculture, but he has discovered it now. He has discovered it in respect of butter and bacon. He has also discovered it, to the grief of many people here in this country, in respect of eggs. When he took office, the export price of eggs was 3/- a dozen, on an agreement negotiated by his predecessor. He was not very long in office when he came to make the next agreement. It was at a price reduced by 6d. a dozen. The Minister's diplomacy was not as powerful as he thought or as his colleagues on the Front Bench or those sitting behind him thought it was. When he went over, he found out very quickly that his opposite number in England was not falling for his blarney and that all his soft soap was of no avail. When he came back, he announced that the poultry keepers, if they had eggs to export, would have to take less money. He was over again recently—he went twice, or three times for all we know, inside the last six months—and came back with a further reduction in the price of eggs. We are told now that from the 1st February next the price will be 2/- a dozen until 1st September, when it will be 3/6 for the five winter months. Everyone knows that 9/10 ths of our egg production is between the 1st February and 1st September and we allowed 1/10th production for the other five months. Even if he had brought back a price of 4/6 a dozen, he would not get a supply of eggs in the winter time in anything like the same volume as in spring and the early summer months. The Minister very often tells the House that we should produce milk from summer grass at a time when the cows will give the most milk. He is reversing that policy in the matter of egg production and he wants the poultry keepers not to produce eggs in the spring and early summer but to produce them in the winter. That just will not happen and nobody knows it better than the Minister. If he does not, he has officers enough to tell him that. The net result will be that the poultry keepers will unfortunately be forced to take a considerably reduced price for their eggs in future at the same time that the price of feeding stuffs and of all cereals is jumping sky high.

When eggs were 3/- a dozen, maize meal was about 20/- or 25/- a cwt. It is now 30/- to 35/- a cwt. The retail price of maize meal in my constituency ranges from 31/- for straight run to 35/6 for flake maize. The average price for maize meal is 32/-. If the Minister tells the country to produce pigs and poultry with maize meal at that price, I am just wondering what margin of profit would be left to the producers. If we are to have a surplus of exports and are prepared to produce eggs with mill-stuffs at the present price I am afraid the profit left to poultry keepers will be on the negative side.

We can truthfully say that our Minister for Agriculture has failed the poultry keepers, the butter producers and the bacon producers—failed miserably. He has failed to find a market at a remunerative price for any commodity outside dry cattle that is available over and above our own requirements. He is the greatest failure in so far as the sale of Irish agricultural produce on the foreign market is concerned that ever existed or that I hope will ever exist in this country.

We had quite a lot of discussion here about wheat production and wheat imports. In the White Paper, the Minister informs us that he is paying £28 10s. per ton at the present time for wheat in America but he is not prepared to pay £28 10s. to Irish farmers to grow wheat at home—for what reason we do not know. We had a lot of boasting from the Government Benches about the 62/6 per barrel that was being paid for wheat by the Minister. The Minister for Agriculture who occupied that post before the present Minister, in October of 1947 announced that price as the price that was to be paid for wheat the following season. What the present Minister did was to confirm that price for five years. I think, having regard to the increasing costs of production here at home, that it is about time the Minister increased that price of 62/6. If he is prepared to pay £28 10s. per ton for foreign wheat, he should pay £28 10s. for Irish wheat. He is paying only £25 per ton for the home-grown produce and if he were to increase that price to the price he is paying for the imported wheat, it would be an incentive to the Irish farmer to grow more wheat and we would not have to borrow dollars to pay for foreign wheat.

I think every possible incentive should be given to the Irish farmers to grow wheat. They should be paid at least the same price that we are prepared to pay the farmers of Canada or U.S.A. It costs our farmers as much, or even more, than it costs the farmers in America or Canada to grow wheat, as they produce it on a different system altogether. The production of wheat here at home would obviate the necessity of borrowing dollars to purchase wheat abroad. I think it is a sad commentary on our whole system of agriculture that we cannot grow all the food we need in this country. We are told that we have 12,000,000 acres of arable land but I think there is not much more than 2,000,000 acres under crops. We had 10,000,000 acres for other purposes, for growing a crop that the Minister speaks very highly of. Grass is a good crop but we have far too many million acres devoted to it in this country. If we had a further 1,000,000 acres under tillage it would be better for the whole community. It would serve the farmers, the traders and the workers; it would give more employment than any other system of farming. The sooner we realise that and the sooner we plan our economy to put another 1,000,000 acres under the plough the better it will be for the country. The only hope for agriculture and for the national economy is to produce here at home all we need to feed ourselves and our animals instead of borrowing dollars to buy wheat from America at higher prices than we are prepared to pay our own farmers for it. I think that is not sound agricultural economy and the sooner the Minister thinks over it and announces an increase in the price of wheat for our own farmers the better.

Comment on this

There is more wheat in this country at the present moment than there ever has been in its history before.

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

You may be sure of it.

Comment on this

There should be more grown than ever was grown.

Comment on this

There is more of it growing than ever before.

Comment on this

I hope it will be a good harvest.

Comment on this

With the help of God.

Comment on this

And that we shall have a good yield.

Comment on this

The Deputy will pray for me, I know.

Comment on this

Definitely we imported last year a considerable amount of wheat with borrowed money which the taxpayers of this country must repay at some time.

Comment on this

We are well able, thanks be to God.

Comment on this

We are borrowing dollars to buy foreign wheat at £28 10s. per ton and all we are prepared to pay our own farmers is £25 per ton.

Comment on this

£28 10s.

Comment on this

We are borrowing dollars to buy considerable quantities of maize which is being retailed here at 30/- or 35/- a cwt., as I said before.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Why does the Deputy say it again?

Comment on this

I want to emphasise it for the Minister's information——

Comment on this

It has no relation to the truth so he wants to repeat it continually to get someone to believe it.

Comment on this

——in the hopes that by emphasising it, if the Ceann Comhairle gives me the privilege of doing so——

Comment on this

Some poor fool will be found to believe it.

Comment on this

——I will succeed in changing the Minister's point of view on many matters upon which he has a very unsound agricultural view at the present time. I remember the Minister for Agriculture announcing on one occasion in this House that if the price of a dozen eggs were the same as a stone of Indian meal, things were right.

Comment on this

A cwt. of meal to a hundred of eggs.

Comment on this

I thought it was a cwt. of meal to a dozen eggs. Meal costs over 4/- a stone, from 4/- to 4/6.

Comment on this

Make it 5/- while you are at it.

Comment on this

Eggs fetch only 2/6 and they will only be 2/- up to next January and I do not know how the Minister can reconcile his formula with that. He will have to change it and get a new formula for a dozen eggs. That formula was a complete failure.

Comment on this

The Deputy can get all the eggs he wants.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister will have the opportunity of speaking.

Comment on this

Anybody who can only afford to buy a cwt. of meal must pay 32/- or 32/6. If the Minister can buy it per cwt. at less, many small poultry keepers, agricultural workers and small farmers will be glad to know where.

Comment on this

The Shelbourne Co-op.

Comment on this

You will want to put up co-ops in every village and town. The Minister was not very fond of co-ops at one time in his career. I heard him almost cursing them out of existence more than once but he has become quite reconciled to co-ops and for the future they are the only salvation while he is Minister for Agriculture that I can see.

There are a number of agricultural crops of which the Minister is not too fond and to which, in my opinion and in the opinion of a great number of producers, he has not given fair play. I refer to root seed growing and root seed growers. Some time during the emergency when it was found that root seeds, turnip seeds principally, were no longer available from the source that formerly supplied the farmers and merchants of this country, the English root seed growers, and when the British Ministry of Agriculture or some other Department notified the Minister for Agriculture of this State that they were not prepared to supply them, an organisation was set up to grow turnip and mangold seed in this country. They did it very successfully. Some years previous to that the Irish Sugar Company successfully grew all the beet seed required in the country. The organisation that was brought into being during the war years succeeded admirably in getting Irish farmers on Irish land to grow all the turnip and mangold seed required for their use, but when this great Minister for Agriculture took office he decided that that no longer would be allowed to go on. At the first opportunity he announced here that he would have the ports opened and that seed would be imported from anywhere the merchants of this country liked to buy them—not the farmers. It was not where the farmers would like but where the merchants would like to buy them or where the travellers from abroad would like to sell them—that was the consideration.

There were in this House a number of discussions on root seed growing and the Minister could not think of things bad enough to say about the people who were engaged at the request of the then Minister for Agriculture in the organisation of root seed growing in this country. They were called rogues, robbers and highwaymen and every name that could be thought of by the present Minister. We were told that they were robbing the farmers openly and brazenly. We would like the Minister to tell the House the truth about that matter. We would like him to tell the House that in 1947, when the root seed growers of Great Britain were getting 120/- per cwt. for the turnip seed they produced, the farmers of this country were getting 160/-. He did not tell the House that. He did not tell the House that in 1948 similar prices were being paid. He came along here and announced openly that he proposed to open the ports for the import of all the seeds and allow the merchants to buy their seeds any place they liked. We should produce any crop that can be produced in this country and produced well—and it has been proved that root seeds grown in this country are equal to, if not better than, the best that were ever imported.

The Minister told the House some time early this year that his Department proposed to grow pedigree seeds for distribution amongst the growers of the country. We and the root seed growers would like a little more information on that. We would like to know where the mother seed from which these pedigree root seeds are being produced was found or produced. Is it a fact that the mother seed is being produced in Glasnevin or Johnstown from roots selected from Irishgrown seed? Is that a fact or not? The root seed growers would also like to know from the Minister if his threat to open the ports freely from January next will be carried out or not. That is all important and the Deputies sitting behind the Minister should busy themselves and find out definitely what the Minister's policy for the future is on root seed growing.

Comment on this

To expand it and export it when it cannot be sold on the domestic market.

Comment on this

Root seeds have been grown successfully——

Comment on this

Yes, and will be.

Comment on this

——and the market needs protection.

Comment on this

Just the same as other things.

Comment on this

We know, and the Minister is aware, that in the past season a country in Europe offered to sell root seeds here at 80/- a cwt. He knows that quite well.

Comment on this

We can grow them better and cheaper in Ireland than anywhere in the world.

Comment on this

He knows that, if these root seeds are allowed into this country, they may be inferior seeds, which can easily be mixed with the home-grown seeds. They were offered at 80/- a cwt. to this country by a European country during the past year. They were not allowed in, but they were offered at that price, and the farmers were paid 120/- last year per cwt. in their yards for seeds they grew.

Comment on this

What did they have to pay for seed per lb?

Comment on this

If you tell me what the profits of the retailers and of the wholesalers per lb. were, I would be able to tell you that.

Comment on this

They were paying 4/- per lb. at one time.

Comment on this

The growers were paid 120/- per cwt. The seeds had to be processed, dried, cleaned and put in sealed bags and the wholesaler had to get a profit and the retailer had to get a profit. I am sure the Minister knows more about these profits than I do.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with the profits of any merchant in the country.

Comment on this

I know you are. You are personally concerned and should be concerned otherwise. I am concerned, and very many farmers are concerned, that the ports of this country will not be thrown open next January and seed imported from any country in Europe at any price—inferior seeds which are likely to be mixed amongst the home-grown seeds. They are very concerned to see that no foreign seeds whatever come into the country, because their acreage must be reduced by every pound or cwt. of foreign seeds that comes in.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

Their acreage must be reduced. There is no way out of it.

Comment on this

Can we not sell them abroad?

Comment on this

You will sell them abroad the way you sold the butter, eggs and bacon abroad. You are the greatest salesman that ever existed in this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister.

Comment on this

That is the way the Minister will sell the root seeds abroad— the same way as he sold the other agricultural produce, when he failed to sell any of them. Any line of agricultural produce of which there was a surplus, with the exception of dry cattle, the Minister failed to sell it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is repeating himself.

Comment on this

The Minister interrupted me.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am drawing the attention of the Deputy to the fact that there is a Standing Order against repetition.

Comment on this

The Minister interrupted me and told me he would sell them abroad. I wanted to show him that he was incapable of selling anything abroad and has proved that up to now. I hope the Minister will give this matter further consideration. There may be only a small number of farmers, out of the total, who are engaged in root seed growing, but nevertheless it will be admitted that if they are capable of producing as good root seeds at as low a price as the best root seeds produced in any country, they are entitled to be allowed to stay in the production of these seeds.

Comment on this

And to double their production.

Comment on this

No action of the Minister should prevent them from remaining in it, on the basis of a fair return to them. So long as that aspect is safeguarded, I am satisfied, and that is the most important aspect to have safeguarded. There is no good in the Minister making all sorts of threats. The farmer has suffered as a result of these threats already. When he started threatening first, they were getting 160/- per cwt. for growing root seeds and they are now getting 116/-. The Minister has succeeded in doing that and the farmers will not thank him in the least for bringing their return down from 160/- to 116/-.

The Minister, before making these wild pronouncements, should consider the matter and should take the interests of the growers into consideration. They may be few and they may not have much influence, but they are Irish farmers farming Irish land and employing Irish labour, and they are entitled to sell the results of their labour in this country, provided they are producing a good article in sufficient quantity. I hope that, before next January, they will have more information than they have at present. At the moment, they are like Mahomet's coffin, suspended in mid-air. The Minister may not know that a little over 12 months ago provisional contracts were made at 160/- for 1949——

Comment on this

That is the ninth time the Deputy has said that.

Comment on this

——and that, as a result of the announcement he made in May, 1949, the price was reduced to 120/-, but quite a number of farmers who are engaged in this root seed growing are fully aware of it

Comment on this

I never heard of it.

Comment on this

That is absolutely true. There is another crop, a small crop also, in which a number of farmers and other people owning glasshouses were interested. I refer to the tomato growers. The Minister did not treat these people justly. Many small people borrowed money to erect glasshouses, and, as a result of the Minister's policy, find themselves in the bankruptcy courts or thereabouts. They are not getting a fair crack of the whip.

Comment on this

What is the price of Irish tomatoes to-day?

Comment on this

The Minister allowed the market at the peak period, when Irish tomatoes were sufficient to supply the whole market, to be flooded with foreign tomatoes. I do not mind if the Minister fixes a maximum price for Irish tomatoes. It would probably be the proper thing to do, but there is definitely a certain period of the year when no foreign tomatoes should be allowed into the country.

Comment on this

What price would the Deputy fix?

Comment on this

The producers of tomatoes should get a fair and honest price, a price which will pay them for their trouble and give them a reasonable margin of profit.

Comment on this

What price does the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

I am not a tomato grower and could not answer that, but the Minister will have no difficulty in getting proper information on the matter. During the peak period of production, there should be a total prohibition on the import of foreign tomatoes.

Comment on this

And price fixation.

Comment on this

That is the Minister's job. That is his responsibility and nobody else's. We on the back benches here are not allowed to fix the price of anything. We have no say whatever in it and the Minister must take his responsibilities in his hands and do what he should do to protect the growers of Irish tomatoes by protecting the market——

Comment on this

And fixing a price.

Comment on this

—— and by giving a total prohibition against foreign tomatoes during the peak period of production, when there are sufficient Irish tomatoes to supply all the needs of the community. I hope that, in the present tomato growing season, the growers will not have the same reason for complaining as they had last year, when they complained very bitterly, and with just reason, that, as a result of the Minister's action in the past two years——

Comment on this

It must have been music to your ears.

Comment on this

I would value the Deputy's advice as to the price which should be fixed for Irish tomatoes.

Comment on this

A profession of ignorance on the part of the Minister again.

Comment on this

I have dealt with many of the matters I wanted to deal with——

Comment on this

But not with the price of tomatoes.

Comment on this

A neighbour of mine has a parrot, and, if I can get it, I will bring it up to the Minister.

Comment on this

It will be a welcome change.

Comment on this

The land rehabilitation scheme is another matter that I wish to mention. The provision for this scheme in the present year is over £3,100,000. This scheme, when in operation, will serve a useful purpose as far as the individual farmer is concerned. It has not been very long in operation and it is difficult at this stage to know whether it will be a success or not. It would require a year or two of experience of its operation before results can be fairly judged. There is one thing that may damage it seriously, namely, that the whole thing is being regimented too much by officialdom and that the administrative costs may be too high. That is an important matter which the Minister must keep under close observation. It is impossible until the scheme is fully in operation in all counties to estimate the cost per acre of land improved. It will not be possible to get that costing until the scheme has been in operation in every county for at least one year. From what we can see, the costs will work out very high. We hope that as the scheme progresses there will be an improvement in that direction and that administrative costs will not be anything like what they have been up to the present time.

This money is all borrowed money. The nation is responsible for it. The people are interested to see that the best possible results are obtained from the expenditure of that money and that the farming community will get the lion's share of that money and that the greater part of it will not be spent on machinery and administrative costs of one kind or another. Judging by the staff we see already employed in the Minister's office, we have very grave doubts on that matter.

In the White Paper, the Minister adverts to the fact that a certain amount of fertilisers was produced in this country in the past year and that a considerable amount was imported. The Minister was very vocal in the House for quite a long time about the Irish fertiliser manufacturers. He told us on more than one occasion that farmers were being robbed, that the fertiliser manufacturers were crooks and I know not what else. We would like to know, now that he has them under his control, what he has done about that. Has he made any investigation into the matter of the price being charged by the Irish manufacturers of fertilisers; was it an unfair price; has he taken any steps to have that price reduced?

Comment on this

Competition.

Comment on this

We would like to hear all that.

Comment on this

Competition.

Comment on this

Even with the competition, the price of artificial manures is going up. Even with the competition, artificial manures went up in price in the present year.

Comment on this

The price of certain artificial manures increased this year. There is no doubt about that. The Minister cannot deny it.

Comment on this

What manures?

Comment on this

If the Minister will check up on it, he will find that is so.

Comment on this

What manures went up?

Comment on this

We hope that the Minister will tell us whether these "enemies" of the Irish people and the Irish farmers have been dealt with and in what way the Minister has dealt with them.

Comment on this

Competition.

Comment on this

The House would be glad to know that.

Comment on this

Competition.

Comment on this

Has the margin of profit been reduced or not or has the Minister done anything about it or was it all baloney as far as he was concerned?

The Minister is also providing a subsidy of over £7,000,000 for the millers. The millers were not friends of the Minister either. He referred to them in very scathing terms on many occasions. It is some two years since a commission was set up under the chairmanship of the present Supreme Court Judge Lavery. The country has been anxiously awaiting the report of that commission. Is the Minister prepared to give it to the House or the country?

Comment on this

Shortly, I hope.

Comment on this

It has not been published, as far as we know.

Comment on this

It will be.

Comment on this

It has not been published. We would like some information as to what progress the Minister has made in reducing the profits that he said the millers were making and what steps he has taken. Is the same formula as was adopted some years ago still in operation in respect of the millers? We would like to know that. They are the second large body of manufacturers in this country that the Minister has now under his control. The country and the House would be very interested to know what he has done about them.

A great number of people in this country did not believe the Minister that either the manure manufacturers, the flour millers or the bacon factories were making such great profits as he would have us believe. The Minister even told us that there were two bacon factories ready to go bankrupt and that there were others on the verge of bankruptcy. Has that been as a result of the Minister's policy? We would like interested to know if action taken by the present Minister for Agriculture has bankrupted two native Irish industries and if he proposes to put the employees on the unemployed list? Is that so or not? Are there many other bacon factories in danger of bankruptcy in the near future as a result of the Minister's policy or are these people making fabulous fortunes, as the Minister often told the House?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think they are charging too little for bacon?

Comment on this

In the past——

Comment on this

No. Does the Deputy think they are charging too little at present?

Comment on this

The Minister has the bacon factories, the millers and the manure manufacturers all under his control now and we would be most interested to learn what steps he has taken to reduce the so-called and the supposed excessive profits that these groups of manufacturers were making. We have not heard even one word from the Minister on this matter. He did not mention it. It is an extraordinary thing, seeing that he is paying over £7,000,000 subsidy on wheat, that he did not mention the matter.

The Minister did mention one matter which many people were interested to hear. He confessed that since January or 1st February last, as a result of departmental action, straight-run pollard was no longer for sale in this country, and that he took from the market something like 5,000 tons of straight-run pollard. He informed us that he had received this cheap wheat which he bought in Russia.

Comment on this

The Pacific.

Comment on this

What is the country of origin?

Comment on this

The Pacific is the ocean which rolls on the western shores of the U.S.A.

Comment on this