Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 198–391 of 391. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
However, it is cheap inferior wheat. Now straight-run pollard will again be issued for sale to the people of this country. That is a very welcome change in the policy which has been in operation for the past four or five months. It was an unwelcome policy and I think the Minister is aware of that.
Ground limestone was adverted to in the White Paper. Ground limestone and the setting up of ground limestone plants has made a certain amount of progress in counties where limestone is available. However, in a county such as County Wexford which has little or no limestone except for a small amount on the south coast, the problem is serious for farmers. The Minister is well aware that there is little or no limestone in County Wexford except a small belt very deep down on the south coast which it would be expensive to work. It is not likely, therefore, to be produced in such quantities and at such a price as would be of advantage to the farmers in the area. The tillage lands of Wexford are poor and light. They have been growing corn for centuries, I suppose, and they need a considerable amount of lime. It is estimated that a minimum of from two to four tons per statute acre is required —say, three tons on an average. That ground limestone has to be drawn 40 or 50 miles by road. It can be purchased at the plant——
Comment on this
Yes—and take three tons at 35/- per ton as an average for a statute acre. It has to be drawn at least 40 miles.
Comment on this
Three tons at 35/- per ton is a considerable amount per statute acre. I am afraid that the farmers will not be able to buy the lime which is required so badly for the land because of the price. I asked the Minister recently if he was considering any plan whereby the transport of that lime over a long distance might be assisted. I think it is the only solution. It is well worthy of the earnest consideration of the Minister to assist the transport of ground limestone by State subvention of one kind or another where the draw is very long. If the lime could be delivered in the farmer's yard at £1 a ton——
Comment on this
No, £1 a ton. He should be able to get it for £1 a ton. It is unfair to ask him to pay more than £1 a ton for it.
Comment on this
The Deputy was 16 years on this side of the House and what did he do in that connection?
Comment on this
I have no doubt that the genius of the Minister will solve all the problems which were not solved in those 16 years. I hope that, in addition to having made a serious mess of a great many things, he will do some brilliant things which will prove of advantage to the community. We have not had evidence of one brilliant action that was of advantage to the people of this country by the Minister so far. In no single instance has the Minister's brilliance shone so brightly that it reflected itself to the benefit of the agricultural community of this country. Perhaps, in providing them with ground limestone at a cheap rate, delivered in their haggards or yards or fields, the Minister will be able to earn the esteem of our farming community.
In addition to his other activities— and they are many and varied, we will all agree— the Minister, during the past year, took on a new activity. The Minister has often told us that he was tired, hard-worked and badly paid but, in spite of that, he took on a new activity during the past year. He became a retailer of flour. Flour of 85 per cent. extraction was rationed in this country. The Minister put another type of flour on the market—flour of 75 per cent. extraction. He became a retailer of this flour—in other words, the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Industry and Commerce have entered the retail trade.
Comment on this
The Department of Agriculture has also taken on the sale of unrationed butter— they are selling paper wrappers now with " 3/6" stamped on them, for 10d. each. It is an extraordinary state of affairs. Where rationing was in effect during the war it was applied only where there was a shortage of goods. It would seem that in future this present system will be part of the permanent set-up. We have two types of flour—the rationed flour and the unrationed flour. We have the slightly brown flour of 85 per cent. extraction—a first-class flour.
Comment on this
It is palatable and every human being can eat it and benefit by it. For some reason or other which nobody seems to be able to understand —except possibly that it was for the purpose of making a bit of money for the Exchequer as a tax revenue—the Minister has placed another flour of a different extraction on the market. Take the position as it exists in the poorer parts of the country. Those people who buy the full ration of the 85 per cent. extraction flour and who find that they have not enough must then purchase the dearer flour—and those are the very people who are being forced by economic circumstances to buy this dearer flour. The Minister should have zoned the country and made more of the 85 per cent. extraction flour available along the western seaboard and in the poorer areas so as to help the poorer people there. The two schemes are to be condemned bell, book and candle—the dearer flour scheme and the dearer butter scheme. Neither should be in existence.
Comment on this
The Deputy agrees that the 85 per cent. extraction flour is inferior to the 75 per cent. extraction flour?
Comment on this
I will pass no comment on the 75 per cent. extraction flour. It should not be in existence. All flour should be on the general market. Let everybody buy the one extraction whether it be 75 per cent, 85 per cent. or 95 per cent. We are the only civilised country in the world at present with flour rationing in operation. We have a surplus of butter in this country and yet butter is rationed. If the people want to buy more than the ration of eight ounces they must pay 10d. per lb. above the ration price for it. It would be far better to have a straight price for butter.
I do not see why we cannot get back to normal as regards the sales of butter, flour and sugar, just as we were in pre-war days, and have the one price for the whole of them and not drive people mad having two prices. If you are well off, if you have plenty of money, you can buy all the white flour and sugar and butter you want, but if you have a limited supply of money you must do with your ration. It is an invitation to the people who are better off to spend more money on white flour and butter and sugar.
Comment on this
The fact is that many decent, respectable farmers are constrained, owing to the Minister's action, to sell the produce of their cows, in the form of butter, at 1/9 a lb., representing 7½d. a gallon for the milk.
Comment on this
The Minister should be ashamed of himself for bringing such a situation about, if he has any shame at all in him. The area under oats in 1949 was 193,000 acres, considerably less than in 1948. Is it any wonder the oats yield was less in 1949? The Minister had another Minister acting on his behalf; he ran away from the problem to America towards the end of 1948. Another Minister, acting on his behalf, organised an oats purchase scheme. It was found at that time that there was a very fine supply of oats in the country, as a result of the 1948 harvest. It was found also that because of the Minister's advice many people switched over from the growing of wheat to oats. The result was that oats were dumped on the small market available towards the end of the year and many people found themselves in serious difficulties.
The Minister's colleague, while the Minister was away, when he was forced to do it by the votes of the people in Donegal, organised an oats purchase scheme and 19,000 tons were purchased.
Comment on this
The position was that 19,000 tons of high quality oats were purchased. Inferior oats would not be purchased; if the crop was not good it would not be taken. The merchants who purchased it needed storage and drying facilities. Soon they had the oats dried and it was kept in good condition. The spring and summer of 1948 passed and the Minister had not yet sold the oats. It was known to every farmer in July and June, but very definitely in August, that the oat crop was going to give a very small yield in 1949. Notwithstanding that knowledge that the Minister had and that his Department should have at that stage of the year, he came along in September and sold 19,000 tons.
Comment on this
Within six months he has had to travel over the world looking for oats. He had to beg dollars to buy the oats that he sold to Germany or some other European country. In September, 1949, he had to beg oats from the countries of the world and beg dollars to pay for the crop. That was not sound management and it does not prove that the Minister was doing his duty properly. He talked about oats here and said it was maggoty. If the Minister was engaged selling the product of Irish land, he should not make little of it.
Comment on this
I will find the reference for the Minister, when he said the oats was maggoty. It is just like the butter you sold one time.
Comment on this
You are a great salesman. The two items you succeeded in selling —the farmers' butter and the farmers' oats—the Minister made little of them all he could. There are other products that he failed to sell and that he could find no fault with, and they are Irish bacon, butter and cheese. He cannot sell one ounce outside the Irish market at a remunerative price without a subsidy. This great, brilliant genius of a Minister for Agriculture, this Heaven-sent man who was going to reform agriculture and make everyone engaged in agriculture a millionaire, could not sell those products at a price that would give a return to the producer.
The Minister might tell the House what is the future of dairying, the future for farmers engaged supplying the creameries with milk. What hope have they next year? What price may they expect? Should they go out of dairying or increase production? That is all-important. They cannot go into it overnight, and the Minister knows that; they must plan years ahead. The planning now done by the farmers will have its effect within the next five years on the production of milk, butter, eggs and other commodities. At the moment things are in a very difficult position.
I understand and appreciate that the Minister has no pleasant job, but he undertook to solve the farmers' problems. We do know, because of the large subsidies paid on food across the water, that things are made more difficult to sell our produce there; we know that well. It is just like the flax the Minister also failed to sell. He threw up his hands and washed his hands clean of it because the Northern Ministry thought well of giving a subsidy to their growers and, because they would not give him part of the subsidy, the Minister advised the farmers no longer to grow flax. We hope that the Minister, in 1950, will see fit to cease making some of the outlandish statements which, in many respects, he made in the past year, and that he will not tell the farmers in 1950 that within a couple of years every plough in the country will be in the museum or outside of it.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will not repeat that statement any more in the presence of sane people. We had other foolish statements from him. We have had so many of them from him over the past two and a half years that they are nearly uncountable. These most extraordinary and damaging statements are resented by our people who are engaged in agriculture—those who support the people in office as well as those who support the Deputies on this side of the House. Those engaged in the agricultural industry know the implements which are suitable for their husbandry. Nobody knows better, certainly not the Minister for Agriculture. He is not, never was and never will be a judge of the implements which farmers need for their husbandry, whether it is a plough or a horse. They are entitled to have a plough or a horse, and should not be held up to public odium because they use a plough or a slow horse. They are entitled to use either, and to claim that much freedom for themselves. The sooner the Minister gives up making these foolish and silly statements the better it will be for agriculture.
Comment on this
I think I should begin by saying that I was surprised at the contribution which has been made to this debate by Deputy Allen, who is a practical farmer. I can only assume that, in doing what he did, he was blinded by prejudice and was not allowed to deal with the facts as he should have dealt with them. For that reason, he did not get the opportunity of putting up sound arguments.
The Minister, when introducing his Estimate, said very rightly that the test of a policy is its results, and that the best arguments are facts. If we look at the results of his policy over the last two years we can see that he is well justified in taking a pride in the progress which has been made since he took office. The value of agricultural exports in that period has increased from £24,000,000 to £40,000,000. You have there an increase of £16,000,000 in the matter of agricultural prosperity.
Deputy Allen referred to the position regarding poultry and eggs. Deputies should remember that, as a result of the agreement arrived at by Deputy Smith, the position in regard to both was very unstable in view of the fact that it did not extend over a reasonable period. We find that, probably since the 1st of January last, our farmers would have been getting ? a dozen or less, probably less, for their eggs if production had increased to such an extent as it has increased since the present Minister took office. The Minister is now criticised because he has made an agreement under which our farmers will receive 2/- a dozen for a certain period and 3/6 a dozen for the remaining period. The Minister said that 2d. an egg was something. It was an achievement especially when we consider that so many other countries had again gone into full production very rapidly and were in a position to capture the market for eggs.
With regard to the import of feeding stuffs, one thing that has struck me is that, from the first day the Minister came into office, he advocated that our farmers should grow the foodstuffs required to feed their poultry and live stock. The policy of selling oats and barley off the land was encouraged by the last Government during their period in office so that our farmers did not get out of the habit of doing that. They have continued to do so, instead of converting the produce of the land into something that would be saleable. Take, for instance, egg exports. The figures for 1950 represent an increase over 1947. We find that in 1947 eggs to the value of £750,000 were exported as compared with exports to the value of £2,500,000 up to a recent date—that is since the 1st of January of this year.
These figures speak for themselves as regards the policy that is being pursued in regard to egg and poultry production. The policy that was in operation has been completely altered since the change of Government took place. There is no doubt that, when the British Government agreed to subsidise the poultry industry here by making available, I think, £1,250,000 for its expansion, it was not anticipated at that time that our poultry and egg production would increase so rapidly. All credit is due to the present Minister for Agriculture for the attitude he has adopted in trying to expand the poultry and egg industry for the benefit of our farmers. The present egg agreement shows, if anything, our poultry and egg producers where exactly they stand. If, as has been argued by the Opposition, it is costly to import feeding stuffs for the purpose of producing eggs, that is all the more reason why our poultry keepers should concentrate on the production of their own feeding stuffs.
In 1947 our poultry exports amounted in value to less than £2,500,000, and that figure included pigeons. In 1950 the exports amounted to more than £3,500,000. Deputies have in those figures another example of the progressive attitude which the Minister has adopted towards the development of the poultry industry.
I heard Deputy Allen criticise the Minister with regard to his policy on bacon. He said the we had no market for bacon, but is it not a fact that we are exporting bacon at the present time which is fetching, I think, 125/- per cwt. from the British Government? Deputies should remember that bacon exports were not resumed until the change of Government took place, notwithstanding the fact that the war, to which so much reference is made by the Opposition when they try to justify their own arguments or to make excuses, ended in 1945. There was then no sign of an improvement in the pig population. In fact, in 1948 when this Government took office, the number of pigs in the country was less than in 1947. The production of pigs was on the decline all that time. In my opinion, that was due mainly to the fact that we had at that time the illegal slaughter of breeding sows. That was permitted to continue by the last Government. We all remember that when the present Minister for Agriculture took over one of the first things he did was to take the bacon position in hands. He had to follow the bacon up the chimneys and into the cellars in order to catch the culprits who were breaking the law, thus destroying the possibility of bringing pig production, as well as the quantity of bacon available, up to the pre-war level. Up to recently, our producers were enjoying the price of 190/- per cwt. for certain prime grade pigs compared to the 135/- per cwt. which was available to the same producers in 1947. The chief and most important difference is that in 1947 the bacon allowance was very small. One had to be a very special customer, indeed, before one could get any kind of weekly bacon ration. At the present time one can go into any shop and buy as much as a stone of bacon if one wishes. In 1947 pigs were only 135/- per cwt.
Deputy Allen invited the Minister to refer to the margin in the matter of profits being made by the bacon curers. At the present time the price received by the producer is very much above the 190/- per cwt. which was the average price received up to this year. Probably the increased price is due in some measure to the cost of imported feeding stuffs; for that reason I think the Minister would be well advised to encourage the production of feeding stuffs at home. I have no doubt that feeding stuffs suitable for pigs could be produced at home at less than the cost of importing them, having regard to the level that now obtains as a result of devaluation.
In 1947, prior to the change of Government, all cuts of bacon were selling at the one price. I think the figure at that time was very nearly 3/- per lb. Now the cuts are graded. The better class cuts are certainly very dear, but there are other parts for which I doubt very much that the price at the present time is anything like the 3/- level of 1947. The bacon factories appear to be snatching up all the pigs they can get. It is difficult to understand why some of the bacon factories should be going out of business. Considering there is such a demand for pigs certain factories must be making a profit. It is possible that the increase is due in some measure to the fact that we have started exporting pigs. Our farmers will not object to the export of pigs if it means they are provided with a new market. There is no doubt that the price would fall and our farmers would be forced out of pig production were it not for the fact that the Minister has succeeded in coming to an arrangement with the British Government under which pigs can now be exported at approximately 225/- per cwt.
Comment on this
Only 8/- out of that 225/- represents subsidy. The fact remains that our producers are oper- ating on the basis of 218/- per cwt. That is not a bad price when compared with 135/- per cwt. this time three years. The Minister quite rightly stepped in to prevent the curers exploiting the producers during the past 12 months. It will be remembered that an effort was made to exploit the farmers because of the fact that pig production had trebled since 1947. The Minister stepped in to ensure that, if anybody would get a price, it would be the producer, having regard to the retail price of bacon. If the consumer was expected to pay a certain price it was only reasonable that the Minister should ensure that the producers would get the benefit of the increased price.
On the information contained in the White Paper issued for our guidance by the Minister it is apparent that our cattle population has come back to the 1934 level. That was the level that obtained before the slaughter of the cattle policy was adopted by the previous Government. It is gratifying to see that the cattle population has again reached the 1934 level, particularly when we realise that cattle at the moment are commanding a good market in Great Britain. We have heard the Opposition speak about alternative markets. We have had experience of these markets. We have had the continental markets— Holland, Belgium, Switzerland, France and even Western Germany. In the long run it has been found that the most suitable market for our surplus cattle is the British market. We have not so far found a better market anywhere. At the time of the change of Government we found that the policy of slaughtering our calves was being continued. In 1947 68,000 calves had been returned as slaughtered. The figure was actually beginning to go up in relation to an increase in the cattle population. That was due mainly to the fact that the price which a calf would fetch at that time was not equal to the wholesale value of the milk required for feeding during the first weeks of the calf's life. The result was that calves were selling at less than 20/- apiece. Because of the change in policy now our farmers have found that it is better to sell the calf rather than have it slaughtered. Calves are fetching very handsome prices now. In fact the price might be regarded as somewhat high for the man who must feed the calf and rear it, but that is merely proof of the demand that exists. It is to be hoped that in the years ahead calves will be available at a more reasonable price to those who wish to rear them for milk or beef production.
Whether we like it or not, we must remember that live stock and poultry are the mainstay of our national economy. We are not industrialised and it looks as if we shall never be an industrial nation. I think our bias will always be in the direction of agriculture. The value of cattle exported in 1947 amounted to £13,000,000; the value of cattle exported in 1950 from 1st January to the present time amounted to £20,000,000, an increase of £7,500,000. That change has occurred since the change of Government.
A similar story can be told with regard to our other agricultural exports: eggs in shell £1,750,000 in 1947 as compared with £4,750,000 in 1950; condensed milk, less than £500,000 exported in 1947 compared with almost £1,500,000 in 1950; wool exports, £750,000 in 1947 and £1,750,000 in 1950. In bacon, the 1947 and 1948 exports were nil; during the past 12 months, that is, 1949, the value of bacon exported was £1,052,000. Those figures go to show that prosperity in agriculture is on the upward trend. The remarkable fact is that the great proportion of those exports was to the British market, the one despised for such a long time but appreciated by those who valued a market for our agricultural surplus.
Regarding our general economy in agriculture, I feel that our foodstuffs ought to be purchased as far as possible in the sterling area rather than in hard currency areas. I am glad to know from the Minister that imports of wheat in the recent past and probably in the future are not from hard currency areas. That is a welcome change in our general economy. On the policy of growing feeding stuffs, if we could discourage our farmers from the inclination to call every crop a cash crop, it would be a valuable move. I hope the Minister will devise a scheme whereby cereals and roots suitable for conversion into foodstuffs will be processed in this country, thus avoiding the necessity to imports certain foodstuffs. The pollard and bran is not at all sufficient to meet our requirements and that is a good argument why some of our foodstuffs should be manufactured in this country.
The 1948 Trade Agreement, under which the farmers are prospering at present, brought new hope to agriculture and we are seeing the results now.
We can measure in terms of money the prosperity that exists to-day in comparison with the measure of prosperity existing before that agreement was concluded. The 1938 Agreement was the first admission on the part of Fianna Fáil that our economy depended on good trading relations with Great Britain, so that we would be able to export our surplus produce to the very large industrial population there where there was not sufficient land for them to produce food for themselves. The first two years of this Government compared with the two years of Fianna Fáil provide a remarkable contrast in the attitude to agriculture. From the first day that the present Minister came into office, he stretched out the hand of friendship to the farmers. He was ready to cooperate with them and to help them, and he asked the farmers for the same co-operation and guidance. Compared with the first two years of the Fianna Fáil Government, it is lucky that we had a Minister to take that attitude towards our farming community.
If we examine the figures, we will see that for the first six years of Fianna Fáil Government the nation went backwards instead of forwards, so far as our economy was concerned. At the same time, other nations were progressing towards a level of prosperity and wealth which enabled them to engage in a major world war. All nations suffered during the world financial depression, but once that period was over—it ended about 1931 or 1932—the other nations began to prosper and their economy improved to such an extent that they were in a position to defy the world and to finance a major war. Instead of that, we find that in 1938 we were obliged to conclude what was called the Coal-Cattle Pact, which was the first move towards the 1938 Trade Agreement. That agreement between this country and Great Britain provided that we could export our agricultural produce, but we would not be allowed to export manufactured goods. It was a welcome change when, in 1948, our Ministers went to Great Britain and adjusted the position, which now enables us to export manufactured goods in competition with Great Britain.
Last year we found the farmers being exploited once more by Fianna Fáil. We found them playing on the nerves of the farmers again. They found there was a good barley crop—if it were a bad crop there would not be a word—and it provided an opportunity for Fianna Fáil to exploit the farmers as far as they could, to create panic amongst them and cause them to suffer, so that some of them might be foolish enough to place the blame at the door of the present Government. In 1948, there was a reasonably good crop of barley, very much better than in 1947—100,000 tons—but in 1949 it was 159,000 tons. That extra tonnage made all the difference when it came to selling the barley. A great number of our farmers sowed feeding barley, intending to sell it as malting barley. Some farmers made contracts with maltsters before they put the crop of barley in and as a result they received 57/6, while farmers who also grew malting barley, not under contract, could not find a remunerative market for it. It appears from the facts now that only a very small percentage of barley was sold at less than £2 a barrel, that 98 per cent. of the crop was sold at more than £2. The maximum of 57/6 was 22/6 better than the 35/- which Fianna Fáil fixed on the farmers—and they made it illegal for the maltsters to pay more. Instead of that, we find the maltsters now offering a price for barley exceeding the world market price. It is a very different position to-day the farmers are in, compared with the 35/-. When Guinness was finished at that price, he went to Australia and elsewhere to pay 89/- a barrel to meet his full requirements. It is a pity it was not left to the farmers themselves to sell their own barley, instead of having the price fixed and having it made illegal for farmers to sell or maltsters to buy at a price exceeding 35/- when the world market price was very much above that level and also when Messrs. Guinness were unable to obtain their full requirements in this country. The position last year was quite different. They paid 57/6 for the malting barley for which they contracted and they imported barley to meet their full requirements at a price below 57/6.
I saw another statement issued about the wheat acreage. The 1949 wheat acreage was 150,000 acres below the 1948 figure. Let us remember that in 1948 there was compulsory tillage. The farmers were bound to till a certain amount of land and the result was that before the change of Government—— and even after the change of Government—in many cases they had made their plans. They had to put in wheat, whether they liked it or not and they had to face the possibility that they might get only four barrels per acre from that large acreage. In 1949 compulsory tillage was not in existence and the result was that the farmers decided to use those 150,000 acres in some other way, to their own advantage. Certainly I do not think any Deputy will say that the farmers decided to use their land to their own disadvantage or that of the nation. Much of those 150,000 acres was probably tired land and needed a rest. The farmers gave that acreage a rest while at the same time fertilisers became available. Free to use their own discretion, the farmers chose what in their opinion was the most suitable land for wheat growing and although we had 150,000 fewer acres under wheat, the yield was equal to that of 1948 and was possibly greater because we have not yet got the full returns for the wheat crop of 1949. Wheat is still coming into the mills and the position is that although the area under wheat fell by 150,000 acres, we had the same amount of wheat apart from the quantity which has been imported in the interests of the nation.
We hear a lot about war at the present time and this Government is doing its part to ensure that our people will have their full requirements of bread, in the event of any crisis developing. We shall have good land available should it become necessary to cultivate it. Remember that the Minister pointed out in 1948 that if it becomes necessary for the Government to adopt a policy, whether it be compulsory tillage or some other policy, to increase production to the fullest extent, he will take any action that may be required. I think that is a very reasonable attitude. Let us remember that compulsory tillage was introduced only as a war-time measure. Even Fianna Fáil did not enforce compulsory tillage when there was no necessity for it.
In regard to sheep production, I should like to say that the sheep population has increased at a remarkable rate and the price of sheep is keeping up pretty well. We find now that the price obtainable for a good sheep's fleece is equal to the price obtainable for a whole sheep before the change of Government.
Comment on this
Yes, you have a short memory if you do not remember the price paid for sheep when Fianna Fáil were in office. The point I want to make to the Minister is that, owing to the rapid increase in the sheep population, a very large number of lambs are offered for sale at the present time. I know for a fact that lambs are coming into the Dublin market for which there is no demand. I am not sure whether we have made any arrangements for the export of lambs but I am aware that in the last week or two, when there was a large number of lambs for sale in the Dublin market, nobody even bid for the lambs.
Comment on this
These lambs had to be brought home by the farmers just as they brought them in. It was not a case of being bid a bad price; there was no offer for the lambs. I hope some arrangement will be made shortly whereby it will be possible to dispose of lambs. The market for local needs is over-supplied and the butchers cannot dispose of the number of lambs offered at the present time. I bring that matter to the notice of the Minister in the hope that he may be able to devise some scheme or give some direction to the farmers as to what would be the best policy to adopt in the circumstances. If the British Government do not wish to pay more than a certain figure, it will not be easy for us to force them to do so. There is no reason why anybody should be critical if we cannot succeed in inducing the British Government to pay a price which they do not wish to give, but I hope the Minister will have something to say on the matter when he is replying.
I should like to point out to those Deputies who have been agitating for compulsory tillage that, apart from the fact that the farmers do not get the return per acre from the land that they would if they were allowed to use their own discretion, if we just examine the figures we shall see that compulsory tillage does not necessarily mean more employment on the land. Taking each year in which the policy of compulsory tillage was operated, we find that the number of persons employed on the land decreased. In other words, those who come into this House and advocate compulsory tillage in order to maintain the level of employment on the land are not advancing an argument that can be supported by the facts. Here are the facts. In 1941, when the quota of compulsory tillage was only 20 per cent., the number of men employed on the land was 555,000, in round figures. In 1948, when the quota was 37½ per cent., there were only 499,000 employed, so that we find that although the tillage quota was increased by 17½ per cent. the number of people employed fell by practically 60,000. The figures for each year show that there was a progressive decline in the numbers employed. In 1941, when the quota was 20 per cent., the number employed was 555,000; in 1942, 541,000; in 1943, 536,000; in 1944, 526,000; in 1945, 521,000; in 1946, 519,000; in 1947, 507,000, and in 1948, 499,000.
Comment on this
I did not bring in all the figures because I wanted to put forward an argument and I submit I have put forward that argument. I have given you the figures from 1941 when compulsory tillage was first introduced and each year following that fewer and fewer people were employed on the land. In fact you were driving people off the land by compulsory tillage. Whatever about leaving it to the farmers themselves to adopt a good and proper balanced economy, I think the system of compulsion as introduced by Fianna Fáil cannot maintain the level of employment on the land, if that is their object. The best thing for the Government to do, I think, is to leave it to the farmer's own discretion and I believe that the policy pursued by the Government will encourage our farmers in a balanced policy of agriculture. We know that the live-stock industry cannot progress without a good policy of roots and cereals and similarly roots and cereals depend on the existence of live stock and fertilisers, so that for that reason I am quite sure that the better policy is to leave it to the farmers themselves and encourage them in certain directions to ensure that we will get the necessary results.
Take butter production for instance. At one stage, about the time of the change of Government, the butter ration was two ounces a week. We found that the quantity of butter produced in 1947 was 36,000 cwts. compared with 89,000 cwts. in 1949. I have no doubt that if it did not pay the farmers to produce butter or increase milk production we would not have figures like this which can be verified from the official records.
I am sure that some of the Opposition Deputies might be happy to hear me mention tomatoes and protection for the tomato industry. I would like the Minister to adopt a system of regulating imports to ensure that when our people want tomatoes, if they cannot get Irish tomatoes they can get an alternative. I am not in favour of a policy of allowing a large quantity of tomatoes in because when the wholesalers find that it is necessary to sell that quantity within a few days fearing that they will go bad they thus force down the price of home-grown tomatoes. Irish tomatoes can command in this country a higher price than imported tomatoes but we should be prepared to allow the poor people to purchase tomatoes at reasonable prices. Certainly when there is a scarcity of home-grown tomatoes prices will be high because the maximum price is not fixed and therefore the law of supply and demand will operate. The law of supply and demand being such, when the price of our tomatoes comes below the price fixed in respect of imported tomatoes a regulation should be applied to ensure that we will not import more than is required to supplement the quantity of tomatoes our own growers are capable of producing.
We find that the growers in north County Dublin are trying to sell tomatoes, not alone in competition with imported tomatoes, but also with tomatoes from glasshouses in Connemara and Donegal erected at the expense of the taxpayers and subsidised. Growers there are competing with people who borrowed money to erect their own glasshouses or invested their savings in them and I feel that these growers in north County Dublin are placed at a disadvantage when they must compete with growers in Connemara or Donegal whose glasshouses were provided under a Government scheme at the expense of the taxpayers.
I hope that when the land project is proceeded with some consideration will be given to making a greater area of land available. It is calculated that 1/10th of a locality is taken up by ditches and hedges and I hope that it may be possible to eliminate them in order to make a greater acreage of fertile land available for the production of foodstuffs, etc.
I am quite satisfied with the policy which is being pursued by the Minister for Agriculture. I know that he is faced with certain problems of sudden —I will not say surpluses because I do not like the word—rises in the level of production, but I think that all credit goes to him for the fact that this change has taken place so rapidly. I think that under his guidance the farmers will continue to prosper and consequently the nation. Go into any town in Ireland and you will find that that town is prospering because the farmers of Ireland are prospering.
Comment on this
They can go into a town and spend what they like, to put it mildly. All credit goes to the Minister for Agriculture for that change because if we look at the years from 1945 to 1948 we find that the trend was downward rather than upward so far as most of the agricultural community was concerned.
It was very noticeable during the debate on industry and commerce that some Fianna Fáil Deputies were complaining that agriculture was prospering at the expense of industry. I am not prepared to subscribe to that view but I believe that the Opposition should be consistent, and if they feel that they should show why they have come to that conclusion. One Deputy in opposition suggested that the cost of living was being kept up on account of agricultural prices. Let me deal with the cost of living very briefly. Take it that it has gone up three points since the change of Government. That would represent about 1 per cent. Wages have gone up between 10 per cent. and 25 per cent. and possibly more. Consequently the purchasing capacity of the wage earner is very much higher. We can take it that the two-once butter ration was available at one time. The housewife was then forced to go into the black market and seek butter at 7/6 or 6/- a lb. I am quite sure that Deputy Aiken knows the great trade that went on in Dundalk at 6/- a lb.
Comment on this
—— Cavan butter at 10/- a lb. Take the tea ration. The housewife, in order to supplement her tea ration, was forced to go out and pay 20/- a lb. for tea. Some paid more and some paid less, but there is a very big difference between 20/- per lb. and the present price which is called the economic price. I have mentioned the "3/6 per lb." marked on the packet of butter which annoyed Deputy Allen so much. It is the most the housewife pays and she does not have to supplement a butter ration of four or six ounces——
Comment on this
She has very little to supplement and has only to pay 3/6 per lb. as compared with 6/- or, as Deputy Coburn says, 10/-. Sugar is in exactly the same position. The sugar ration was four ounces and the housewife had to purchase the balance of her requirements at anything from ? to 2/6 per lb. We hear Deputy Walsh screaming now about the housewife paying 7d. per lb. to supplement a higher ration than she was getting when the change of Government took place. These figures ought to show very clearly what the position, so far as the cost of living is concerned, is.
People are inclined to confuse the high cost of living with the high standard of living. The standard of living has certainly gone up, as was proved by the Minister for Finance, who produced figures to show that it has gone up by 33? per cent. When the standard of living has gone up, it means that, when the essential commodities have been purchased, the wage-earner then starts to live up to this increased standard of living by using the balance of his earnings for the purchase of semi-essential and non-essential commodities, so that, if a man to-day says: "I used to be happy with £5 a week; I now have £6 a week and I am not happy", the position is that the cost of living as calculated at the time of the change of Government, has increased by only 1 per cent., but the variety of goods he purchases and the standard up to which he lives differs greatly. That is why there is so much confusion between the cost of living and the standard of living.
Comment on this
To me, it is a matter of extreme regret that the discussion of this Estimate has been carried on in what I might describe as a Party, political spirit. One would think that the debate on this industry which we hear talked about so much as the most important in the country and the foundation on which our whole structure depends, would be carried on in-cool terms and on the basis of examining the position dispassionately in an effort to find out exactly what the situation is and to suggest remedies. The House need go no further back than the last two speakers to see the spirit in which the debate has been carried on—on the one side, everything happening is all wrong, and, on the other side, everything happening is all right. I propose to try to steer a middle course.
To begin with, the size of the Estimate for this Department, £15,097,040, is staggering, and, looking at it, one must immediately come to the conclusion that agriculture must be a terribly spoon-fed industry when so much of the State finances are being made available for its maintenance and development. But let us look at it in reality to see if that is so, to see if the farming community are so useless as to require so much State aid to maintain them even as a vanishing quantity. Of that total, a sum of over £15,000,000, I notice that £7,200,000 is in respect of food subsidies, flour and wheatenmeal subsidies, and £2,639,000 in respect of subsidies, allowances and so on for dairy produce.
I understand that it was a year ago that these food subsidies were transferred to this Department. Illness at the time prevented me from being present to protest against the transfer, because I saw even then that it would be used as a lever to misrepresent the farming community in regard to the amount of State aid they were getting. It is probably too late now to protest, but the fact that it has been included for the second year in the Estimate means that, so long as stabilisation of food prices continues, these items will likely continue. The point I want to make is that this sum of £9,839,000 is not a subsidy to the agricultural industry. It is a subsidy to the consumers of agricultural produce and, therefore, the £15,000,000 comes down to a little over £5,000,000, which is a very different figure.
In the Estimate, there are some very helpful proposals which are to be carried out with moneys from State funds. There are the land rehabilitation and water schemes costing this year £3,100,000; there is the farm buildings scheme amounting to over £400,000 and there is the provision for poultry development schemes of £350,000. These sums amount to £3,800,000. There are other sums which are of direct benefit and which will improve the condition of the agricultural community. There is a sum of £8,000 for the prevention of contagious abortion in cattle; a sum of £45,971 for the improvement of milk production, and £12,925 for the improvement of live stock—a total of a little less than £67,000.
I do not propose to go into the details of these sums but in view of the claims made that agriculture is not a self-supporting industry and the figures introduced now and then in an effort to prove that, I should like to refer to another item to which I referred in speaking on this Estimate in 1948, the cost-of-living index and agricultural price index. By parliamentary question to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, I had previously drawn attention to the fact that the basic year for both these indices had been changed from the original basis of pre-1914 to the year 1938-39, and I was told by the Minister that the question of a suitable basis for these indices was under consideration. I mentioned it on the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture and suggested that the Minister should get in touch with the Minister for Industry and Commerce and see that a base more equitable to agriculture was taken, so that agriculture could not be misrepresented to the same extent as it had been. Nothing has happened since, but we got some information from the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the Estimate for his Department this year, when he said that not even by suggestion or implication had he influenced the people who were responsible for producing those statistics, so that no one can say that, with the change of Government, a change in the basis of the agricultural prices index and the cost-of-living index would make any difference, that conditions were exactly the same as they had been. The fact remains that those figures still misrepresent the agricultural community. Taking the cost-of-living index and the agricultural prices index on the original base pre-1914, in the year 1938-39, when the base was changed, the agricultural prices index had reached 111.9, say 112, leaving out the decimal; the cost-of-living index had increased to 173 and the cost of clothing had increased to 225.
The point I come to is that, on the changed basis, that is, the 1938-39 basis, agricultural prices have increased to 252, I think, for the year 1949; the cost of living has increased to only 100 of the 1938-39 base. That would appear to show that agriculture has a great advantage. The cost of clothing has increased only to 105. Nevertheless, if we get back to the 1914 base, we find that, on that basis, agricultural prices in 1949 had only increased from the 100 of 1914 to 280 in 1949, while the cost of living had increased to 346 and the cost of clothing had increased to 450. The point I want to make is that statistics can absolutely misrepresent the actual position. I hope that will be borne in mind in future and also that £15,000,000 for agriculture absolutely misrepresents the aid to the agricultural community.
There is another matter that will enable us to assess the farmer's income. Of the total national income in 1949, those engaged in agriculture got only 30 per cent. That is, probably, 60 per cent. of the population got 30 per cent. of the national income. The statistics will not bear me out in saying 60 per cent. but the amount of female labour coupled with the figure for the number of males of 14 years and upwards engaged in agriculture would show that at least 60 per cent. and probably nearly 70 per cent. of the population are directly dependent for income on the land. The point is that they only get 30 per cent. of the national income although they are at least 60 per cent. of the population.
Furthermore, that state of affairs exists in spite of the fact that cattle and sheep prices were never so high in the memory of any living man. What must be the return from other products of the farm if, with these very high prices for cattle and sheep, the income of the agriculturist is only 30 per cent. of the national income?
We were told by the Minister for Finance when he was concluding the debate on the Estimate for his Department, and pointing out the progress that has been made, that agricultural production had come near to pre-war level while industrial production had increased by 43 per cent. Why is that? Why has industry prospered and expanded by 43 per cent. since the end of the war while agriculture has barely reached pre-war production? Is not the acid test of any expansion, expansion in the matter of providing a living for human beings? There must be some serious cause of agriculture lagging behind while industry marches forward to such an extent.
Perhaps the statement made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce on 7th June—Volume 121, No. 10, columns 1450 to 1451 of the Official Report—may throw some light on the cause. This is what the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Mr. Morrissey, said:—
"This country is to-day enjoying the greatest and widest measure of protection for its industries than was ever afforded to them in the past. I have given protection in greater measure to some industries that already had it. I have given new protection to other industries. I have reduced quotas. In some cases I have guaranteed almost the entire market to some of our principal industries, for example, the footwear industry. I reduced that quota from 1,250,000 pairs to 40,000 pairs.
I want to assert here—and again it will be accepted by Deputies if they are going to be honest, and there is no use in beating about the bush and in trying to deceive ourselves, much less the people—that in most cases, I do not say all cases, the increasing of protection leads to some extent, to a great extent or to a small extent, to an increase in the cost of the protected article. There is no question about it. I am making no apology for it."
That, to my mind, explains in simple, short phrases, the reason why industry has advanced while at the same time agriculture lags behind. In spite of the great advance in science and mechanical production, and all the rest of it, during the last couple of decades, agriculture lags behind and fails to maintain its population for the simple reason that, in the first instance, the increased prices of the products of industry in so far as they constitute the raw material of the agricultural industry and the household requirements of the farming community are an additional charge on agriculture. At the same time, increased production of agricultural produce, by whatever means it is achieved, has to compete on the export market with foreign produce and, in many cases, with an unsympathetic Government. Therefore the farming community suffers in two ways. The costs of agricultural and household requirements have increased by the policy of protection, for which the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us he makes no apology— and to which we all subscribe in so far as it employs the population rather than that they should emigrate—and weigh heavily on the agricultural community seeing that the policy of national protection is not applied to agriculture as well as to industry.
I have mentioned that the expansion in any industry should be measured rather in its results on human beings than on any other consideration. In so far as the decline in the numbers employed in the agricultural industry is concerned, there appears to be a dispute between the Minister for Agriculture and the ex-Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, as to what period the decrease of 50,000 in the number of those enaged in agriculture relates. The Minister for Agriculture, and other Deputies behind him, pointed to the fact that that decrease took place over the years 1941-48, and the official statistics bear that out. But we can go further. We can go from the period 1948 to 1949. The official figure of employment on the land in 1948 was 499,542, whilst in 1949 it was down to 452,500—a drop in one year of 47,042.
Comment on this
We must make allowance for what was the decline in the years previous to that. However, such a serious drop in one year must give cause for serious thought as to the reason. If agriculture is so prosperous as we are led to believe it is, why is it that so many of the farmer's family are deserting? Why is it that the number of hired labourers is getting smaller? If it paid the farmer to employ more labour, does anybody think that he would not make every effort to employ more labour, produce more goods on his land and sell those goods, if he could do so, at a profit?
In introducing his Estimate the Minister said that the best test of policy is results and that the best arguments are facts. If the disappearance of the human element from agriculture is the test, I think we must admit that there is something seriously wrong and that serious consideration should be given to the matter. The causes which might influence the position should be seriously considered, and if it is found that we are on the wrong track it is time to put a stop to it and change the course before the position becomes worse.
Comment on this
The vast increase in butter production has been referred to but I do not think the increase has yet reached the 1939 production level and certainly not the 1936 production level. The House has been told of the great increase in the poultry industry: that is a fact. Furthermore, we have been told of the great increase in the pig industry which also is a fact in so far as numbers are concerned. I understand that the target set by the Minister in 1948 for the poultry industry was that in the year 1950-51 at least 8,000,000 day-old chicks would be supplied to the poultry-keepers throughout the country. We had been getting on towards that figure over the years. I shall refer to the figures in this connection later. The figure for the export of eggs over the period 1st January to 30th April, 1947, was 614,699 hundred; from the 1st January to the 30th, April, 1948—1,144,052 hundred; from the 1st January to 30th April, 1949—1,848,747 hundred. From the 1st January to 30th April, 1950, the figure was down to 1,683,877 hundred. That was a drop from April, 1949, to April, 1950, of 164,870 hundred. Therefore, we appear to be going back rather than to be continuing in the direction in which we had been going.
I have picked up some figures with regard to day-old chicks. In the 194849 hatching season there were 3,830,000 day-old chicks hatched; in the hatching season just completed, 1949-50, that figure went down to 3,590,000, a drop of 240,000, so that, before we reached the half-way mark, 4,000,000 day-old chicks, half the target set in 1948, we began to go back. We should endeavour to find out dispassionately why that is the case. There was a great rush in production in 1948. Even in 1947 an effort was made to turn out from the hatcheries a considerable number of day-old chicks. That was even before the Department intervened. That encouragement was brought about, I understand—I am now speaking from memory—by a bargain made by the ex-Minister for Agriculture with the British Minister of Food.
A sum of £1,350,000 was made available by the British Ministry of Food to subsidise the price of Irish eggs in an effort to encourage Irish people to go in more for the production of eggs in order to supply the British market. I understand our own Government put up a similar sum, but the money put up by our Government was to be used for development work, such as the provision of new houses and other buildings for poultry on the farm, for the subsidisation of the price of day-old chicks and for other purposes, all in the effort to encourage our people to go into greater production. Out of that sum of £1,350,000, provided by the British Government, a subsidy of 6d. per dozen was paid and that put the price of eggs in the 1948 season up to 3/- a dozen. That was encouragement to the farmer's wife to develop the poultry industry, and she did.
There was every evidence of a great increase in production, but still it did not appear to be sufficient. We were assured at the time that the more eggs we produced, the more we would get for them, by arrangement with the British Ministry of Food. The sum of £1,350,000 was likely to be used up before the period it was intended to cover expired, because the farmers' wives, being anxious to avail of anything that would yield a reasonable profit, increased production considerably in order to gain as much as possible of that money while the going was good.
I foresaw some danger at the time, and I put down a question to the present Minister for Agriculture asking him for how long the 3/- a dozen was guaranteed, and his reply was "until further notice". I pressed him for a definite period, but I failed to get it. Later on I mentioned that it might become dangerous, when production would increase to a point where there would be a rather big exportable surplus, and the price might not be maintained. Within a year that took place. The sum provided by the British to subsidise eggs was likely to run short of the period it was intended from to cover, and the price was reduced from 3/- to 2/6. Now it appears that the period of the original bargain is running out and a new price has to be arranged, and that is 2/- a dozen for seven months and 3/6 for the remaining five months.
Before I go any farther, I want to point to the fact that, when the price was reduced from 3/- to 2/6, the demand for the day-old chicks slackened off, the number of hens decreased, and the export of eggs went down considerably. What will be the prospect when the price goes down to 2/-? In comparison with the present guaranteed price of 2/6 over the year, the price of 2/- for seven months and 3/6 for five months will hardly average more than 2/2 over the year. That is a considerable drop from the price the farming community has been getting in the present year.
Where is the encouragement to the farming community to develop production in any way? Has it not been their experience all their lives that the more they produce, the less they get for it? We were assured in 1948 that the more eggs we produced, the more we would get for them, but it had exactly the opposite effect. Therefore, if we go on producing in increasing quantities, producing to a point where there will be a rather big exportable surplus, where obviously we will have no bargaining power and where our prices will be influenced by the prices at which Britain can buy produce from other countries, what encouragement will there be for the farmers to increase production or even maintain the present low level of production?
It is the same way with pigs. I heard Deputy Rooney say that in 1947 the price of bacon pigs was 135/- a cwt. I wonder is that a mistake? I think there was no difficulty in the midwinter and the early spring of 1947 in getting 220/- a cwt. The fact is that pigs increased until we had an exportable surplus, and then prices went down to £9 10/- a cwt.—for heavier pigs the price was as low as £7 10/-. The inevitable consequence of increased production of agricultural produce is lower prices.
So far as the agricultural producer is concerned, what is there to justify lower prices for his produce? Has the cost of labour gone down? Has the cost of raw materials gone down? Has the standard of his requirements in any way gone down? Agricultural machinery has increased in price in the past couple of months by 10 per cent. In spite of what Deputy Allen said, the cost of fertilisers came down last year. The main types of fertilisers, including nitrogenous manures and phosphates, have come down by 10 per cent. Apart from that, can anyone point to any decrease in the cost of production? Therefore, what is to justify lower prices for farms produce?
Is it not obviously exploitation to encourage people to increase production and then, when they have the stuff ready to market, they have to face the position when they must accept lower prices? Is it any wonder the members of the farmer's family leave the farm? In many cases, the heir apparent to the farm will go off to find other employment, will go into one of the sheltered industries, the industries where the incomes of those working there, the dividends secured by the investors, are guaranteed and protected by embargoes and tariffs against imports, so that the produce of those industries can be sold at an artificial level.
If that is so in relation to other sections of the community, why should it not apply to the agricultural section? The fact is that the farmers' agricultural and household requirements have increased to a great extent and the ironic part of it is that he gets little or no benefit from the national policy of protection; he gets a good deal of the disadvantages.
I assert that the prices of agricultural and household requirements are at an artificially high level. If the farmer has to sell his produce in competition on a foreign market and to sell his produce on the home market at the same price—Deputy Rooney mentioned to-day that at the moment lambs are unsaleable—then it follows inevitably that these prices must come down if there is not some method by which prices can be maintained.
Until there is some standard of justice introduced whereby the same yardstick will be used as a measure of protection for both the agricultural producer and the industrial producer, what prospect is there for even the present small population that is engaged in farming? Is it not obvious that in such a situation industry must have a great advantage over agriculture? Since the end of the war the numbers engaged in industry have increased by 43 per cent., while the numbers engaged in agriculture have been dwindling year by year.
I come now to discuss the land rehabilitation and water scheme. To my mind, this is a wise scheme that will benefit the nation as a whole. The money invested in it is in safe keeping. I say that because any improvements that we make on the land will remain, at least, for a considerable period. This is interesting, in view of the fact that the £3,100,000 to be invested in this scheme is money which, I understand, is being borrowed from the American Counterpart Fund. I think the Government were wise in putting such an amount of that money into the agricultural industry. If they were to put a big sum like that into the erection of buildings, no matter how laudable the purposes for which the buildings were erected, well in these dangerous days in which we are living, with the atomic bomb or even bombs of lesser power, one of them could wreck and do inestimable damage to these buildings, whereas if a bomb of any description is dropped on the land it will only cause a crater which will not extend over a very wide area. That crater can be filled in and use can be made of that land again. Not so, however, if buildings were hit because they would be wiped out altogether.
At the same time, I want to say that the scheme falls very far short even of justice. It is, to a large extent, a premium on laziness. My use of that word may cause resentment to some, but the point is that over the past half century since landlordism disappeared, there has been a steady effort by the farmer, with the aid of his unpaid family labour, to improve his land, to drain it, to ditch it and to fence it. The injustice to the farmer who did that —and this is the point which I want to make—is that his farm is now held not to need any of the expenditure of this £40,000,000 of borrowed money that is to be spent in the next ten years, whereas his less industrious neighbour who did nothing to improve his farm can now avail of a grant up to £20 an acre for the reclamation, improvement and fertilisation of his land. To my mind, at least, that is not justice. It is no encouragement to the thrifty or industrious farmer. Further, it is unjust, because of the fact that the land which that farmer and his family of unpaid labour drained and cultivated during the early years of this century —up to the period of the war when that land produced food to maintain our people during the years of emergency and when very little could be got from outside—was depleted seriously in its fertility by the production of the crops which we needed at that time. During that emergency period we had less than half a sufficiency of farm-yard manure and for a considerable period no fertilisers at all.
In view of that I hold that this State is under an obligation to take considerable steps to restore the fertility of that land. That could have been done through this land reclamation scheme. Rather than spend all the £40,000,000 on land that needs reclamation, I suggest to the Minister that a considerable portion of that money should be used in refertilising land which had been put in a proper condition by the industry of the farmer and his unpaid family labour in the years gone by. I suggest that, even now, the Minister should give serious consideration to that suggestion which I make— that he should make available a considerable amount of that £40,000,000 in the provision of fertilisers and lime for land that does not require drainage. I do not say that it is necessary to put out fertilisers on, say, the lands of Meath or in the Golden Vale of Limerick. But, there is a considerable amount of mediocre land that has always been, particularly since the emergency period, very much in need of both fertilisers and lime.
I suggest, as a measure of justice to begin with and in an effort towards a measure of self sufficiency, that a very considerable amount of this £40,000,000 should be utilised for the provision of fertilisers and lime for such land. There is no reason why a proportion of that money should not be a free grant or, at least, a big proportion of it. I suggest further, in view of the necessity for becoming as nearly as possible self-sufficient in regard to the production of foodstuffs, that it would be a sound policy to encourage that, so that the land may be made more fertile and that there would be an encouragement for the farmer to produce crops on his land. By reason of the low return which the farmer gets for the stuff which he turns of his farm, apart altogether from the crops which he grows for sale as cash crops, I think it would be wise to encourage him either by the provision of fertilisers or by price subsidisation for the finished article, especially in view of the serious situation that is confronting the world at the moment. I think it would be a very wise policy to do that.
There is next the question of farm buildings. I think it is a good sound investment to borrow money for this purpose. I understand that £350,000 from the American Counterpart Fund is to be devoted to this purpose in the present year. Anything that will improve farm buildings will certainly lead to a healthier and a more reproductive stock.
There again I think it is a good investment to spend money on farm buildings. En passant, I would like to mention the fact that the supervisors of this new scheme were the supervisors who administered the farm improvements scheme in the years gone by. Some of them have now gone over to the land reclamation project. The remainder were given bigger areas over which to operate. In some cases one man is now expected to do twice the area he previously covered and many of them have had to provide themselves with cars in order to carry out their duties. In all probability they have a mileage allowance for those cars but that allowance will not be sufficient to meet the cost of the running of the car over the year. Some of these men have as much as 11 years' service. They are unestablished. They have no rights. They can be dismissed on a week's notice. Many of them have families to support. Yet, they are paid a lower salary than a builder's labourer in the City of Dublin. It is remarkable that in practically every sphere of agriculture incomes generally are on a much lower level than they are in any other sphere of activity. These men have accumulated a considerable amount of technical knowledge through the operation of these schemes, some of which included the erection of farm buildings. It simply does not seem right that men of their intelligence, ability and experience should be paid a lower rate of wages than an unskilled builder's labourer in the City of Dublin.
During last February and March I dealt in extenso with milk prices and pig prices when speaking on the motions I had tabled at that time. I do not propose now to weary the House in recapitulating all the arguments I then advanced. May I remind the House, however, that when speaking in connection with pig production at that time I said that at the prices bacon pigs were making then, which was about £9 4s. od. or£9 5s. 0d. a cwt., I held the view that it was not possible to produce on the farm feeding stuffs to feed a pig to sell at that price. I said at the same time that I was well aware that one could use a ration composed largely of imported feeding stuffs and on that ration produce pigs to sell at £9 10s. per cwt. I held that view then. I hold that view to-day. Is it any wonder that the production of food on the farm for pig and poultry feeding has dwindled? The farmer who was employing labour and who had either credit or capital available could increase his pig population considerably, buy these imported feeding stuffs and neglect cultivating his farm. In that way he could do with less hired labour. That is exactly what the farmer did and no one can blame him. In the circumstances what else could he do?
Seemingly, it was necessary to impose a high tariff and quota restrictions against foreign boots, shoes and clothing in order to maintain the native industries. Why on earth should it not be necessary to give some protection to the agricultural producer? Why should it be made well-nigh impossible for the farmer to produce food on his farm because of the low prices he will get for that food when he feeds it to his pigs and walks it off his land? The same yardstick should be used to measure protection in the agricultural industry as is used to measure protection in other industries.
I pointed out in February and March the increase in the cost of milk production. I drew attention to the increased production that had taken place as a result of more favourable weather conditions. The cows were yielding more. The price was inadequate. I gave figures to show that in the creamery area close to where I live the total income from the milk of the average cow, even allowing that 25 per cent. of her milk was retained for use at home, was only £20 per annum. To that must be added on the value of the calf and of the skimmed milk returned. That would probably bring the income from the cow up about £27 per annum. Owing to more favourable weather conditions the milk supply has been steadily increasing. But the turning-point may come in that even as it has come in poultry production. It may come in pig production, too. The farmer cannot change his economy overnight. He cannot even change it successfully in a year. Because a good crop in one year leaves him carrying on successfully in the following year, the farmer does not see results immediately. The prospects at the, moment are not bright. We are facing a reduced price for eggs, a reduced price for milk supplied to the creameries, and our bacon cannot be exported without a subsidy of 8/- per cwt. Is there any prospect, then, of employing more people on the land? It is possible that because of the increased imports of fertilisers a fillip may be given to home production. When we reach a stage where imported feeding stuffs are not so cheap the farmer may then be compelled to use the feeding stuffs he grows on his own land. He may get a higher price for his animals and his agricultural produce and that will be some encouragement to him to increase his production of cereals and root crops. So far as one can see at the moment there is no stability. The more industrious the farmer is and the more he produces the less of a future there is for him. He has no protection. The smaller farmers in the community, are in a state of unrest. They are labouring under a heavy sense of frustration. They do not know what to turn to next.
The industrial population is protected to such a degree that—apart altogether from the numbers available for employment, that is the numbers on the unemployment register—the wages of the workers are kept up and, through protection, the price of the finished article is such as to maintain the dividends paid to investors at a high level.
The Minister should make an effort to fix prices for the main items of agricultural produce for a period of years, to give the farmers some stability and encouragement. I know it would not be possible to fix the price of store cattle, as we produce so much that our own people do not require and which must be exported. No one will say that those prices are not very satisfactory at the moment, due not to our own efforts but largely to the fact that Britain cannot get from the Argentine the supplies she would like to purchase—she is able to buy at the moment there only a quarter of what she wants—with the result that she is driven to rely on the Irish supply, the price of which is very high. That is a great help to the farming community in Ireland and it is being availed of. It has led to the point where calves which used to be slaughtered as uneconomic are being reared, thus increasing the cattle population and giving a good return to anyone who has not to employ much labour. That does not operate with the small farmer, who cannot go in for extensive stock raising. He is confined, at least in my area, largely to the pig, the cow and the hen and if the income from these is small he is in a very low position.
I have come across some suggestions in the White Paper of an attempt to improve the dairy herds and I am glad to see that. The Minister suggests providing artificial insemination centres in the areas where there is a considerable number of dairy cows, as in the creamery districts, and to provide proven dairy bulls so as to give good milk and dairy stock. Good luck to his efforts. I am glad that it is being done. I made a request two years ago to him to provide these proven dairy bulls for the creamery area of Killeshandra in my own county and after two years' waiting I am glad to see that notification has come to that creamery committee that they will be provided with an insemination centre and with proven dairy bulls and the services of a veterinary surgeon to conduct it. We may hope that an improvement will take place, but not much earlier than in ten years. How is the farming community to exist for those ten years?
I have given the average milk yields for that creamery in 1949, which provided an income of only £20 per cow for the milk supplied to the creamery and used on the farm. That state of affairs, as I pointed out on the Milk Prices Motion on the 3rd March, has been brought about through the Live Stock Breeding Act of 1925. There has been a steady decline in milk yields year by year since that Act was brought into force, by reason of the fact that the official policy of the Department seems to have been during all the years from 1925 to 1948 to encourage the beef bull. If it has taken 25 years to bring down the yields of the cows to such an extent, what hope may we have for an increase in two, five or ten years? Would it not be a long time before we get back to the point we left at that time?
I hope these proven dairy bulls will be really proven dairy bulls and not the type we were accustomed to under the schemes of the Department in the past. My own experience during the late 20's was that from a 630 gallon cow, and a dual-purpose bull sent out by the Department of Agriculture, I got a 212 gallon heifer. That was no encouragement and I hope it will not take place again. I hope these bulls will be really reliable and will produce the milking stock that we so much desire and which it is difficult to get at the moment. It was right to provide this scheme to cow-keepers through cow-testing associations. Cow testing is the only means by which we can ascertain whether a cow is worth her keep or worth breeding from; and it would be only a waste of time if these bulls are not of the best type, as the progeny would show no improvement. The Minister's proposal to have cow-testing associations in connection with the scheme is a good one. Although the scheme is good on paper, when it comes down to practical application it will provide many serious problems for the Department.
The suggestions for milk recording were sent out from the Department to the creamery committees with a covering letter of the 24th February, 1950, as follows:—
"Sir,
I am directed by the Minister for Agriculture to state that, with a view to improving the general level of the milk yield of dairy cows and the elimination of those which are uneconomic, he has under consideration the introduction of a milk recording scheme on new lines which would replace the existing cow testing scheme. The broad outlines of the proposed new scheme are indicated in the enclosed memorandum.
The Minister will be glad if, when this matter has been considered by your society, you will indicate whether the society is prepared to cooperate with him in putting the new scheme into operation as early as may be found practicable. If your society has any suggestions to offer in connection with the proposals, the Minister will be glad to consider them.
I am, sir,
Your obedient servant,
M.H.HEELAN,
Assistant Secretary."
The summary of the proposed conditions is as follows:—
1. All milk suppliers to creameries to become members of local milk recording associations.
2. Weighing and recording of the milk to be carried out by a supervisor employed on a part-time basis. Milk yields to be estimated as a result of weighings made not less frequently than once every four weeks.
3. Supervisors to visit two herds per day, to take samples of the milk and to send these samples to the local creamery for calculation of butter-fat content.
4. Certificates of the milk yield of each cow in a supplier's herd to be furnished monthly to the local creamery by the supervisor.
5. Suppliers whose herds give a yield exceeding 400 gallons per cow to receive the standard guaranteed price for their milk, those whose herds include cows giving a yield of less than 400 gallons to receive 2d. per gallon less than the standard price, if, without any attempt on a supplier's part to improve his herd, such cows are retained in the next lactation period. The lower price to be paid also to suppliers who do not participate in the scheme.
6. Remuneration of supervisors to be at the rate of £3 10s. a week, rising by annual increments of 5/- to a maximum of £5 per week.
7. Suppliers participating in the scheme to make a contribution towards the cost at the rate of7/6 per cow per year. Payment to be made by deduction from suppliers' monthly cheques. A contribution of an equivalent amount to be made from State funds.
As I said, the desirability of milk recording in connection with an attempt to prove the milking properties of cows, is very desirable but to my mind the implementation of that scheme will be much more difficult than the Minister thinks. Take the question of supervisors alone. Number 3 says: "Supervisors to visit two herds per day, to take samples of the milk and to send these samples to the local creamery for calculation of butter fat content." I have been making some rough and ready calculations as to what that would cost in a creamery area and I confine myself to the creamery in regard to which I have an opportunity of knowing the facts. The supervisor is to get £3 10s. a week and he can visit only two herds per day. I do not believe that he will be able to do more than five days a week, that is starting off on Monday evening, because the difficulty is that if he wants to test two herds a day, he will require to make arrangements the previous day as to what herds are to be delayed in the milking period so as to give him an opportunity of being present at the milking of each herd. He can only make these arrangements on Monday morning, get to work on Monday evening and finish on Saturday morning. He has, therefore, only five days in the week. That means that he can only do ten herds in the week and in the particular instance that I am aware of —the Killeshandra creamery area—the average number of cows to each supplier, although they have something more than 15,000 cows altogether, is about four cows per herd. There are some big herds but not many, and there is a very considerable number of small herds. A big number of suppliers would have only three cows per herd and that would reduce the average down to four cows per herd. Even making some allowance for the bigger herds, you would require a very large number of supervisors. Say that we take the total number of cows as 14,000 —that will leave a floating number of 1,000—you would require 88 supervisors at £3 10s. per week or £182 per annum for each supervisor. That means that with 88 supervisors, the annual charge on the creamery would be £16,016.
Comment on this
The Deputy can consider the figures when they appear in the Official Report and he can decide whether I am right or wrong. At the same time, the amount paid in salaries and wages to the management and staff of the same creamery would only be something like £9,000 per annum for the running of the creamery. I would suggest to the Minister that he will find problems like these confronting him even in this most desirable scheme. Whilst that scheme might work out beautifully in Limerick and in portions of Cork or in any place where the herds are big, it will impose an intolerable burden on the creamery industry where the herds are small. I would suggest a simpler scheme that might achieve quite as good results but one that would be more practicable, where the farms and the herds are small. Whilst I am not an advocate of low wages for anyone, I think the cow testing supervisors could do the work of sampling in, say, three or four hours, or five hours a day, working morning and evening. If they were local people they could do it very much cheaper, make the returns to the creamery and let the calculations be made by a few competent people at the central creamery. Furthermore, I would suggest that the element in cow testing in the past that led to what I consider is its considerable failure—that was the building up of records so that the progeny of the cows which are tested could be sold on the record of the dams and the sires— should be eliminated, although the registered record of each cow would be available only for the information of the man who owns that cow, and that anything in the nature of registered herds be discontinued. If cow testing had been any advantage in the past, it would have spread to a greater extent than it has done. The result that I mentioned, that I got a 212-gallon heifer from a 630-gallon cow with a dual-purpose bull, showed that the old records were not reliable.
I think to have any chance of success for cow testing on an extended basis under this scheme, we must eliminate that record-building. Mind you, these records can be built up quite honestly. By getting the dam into very good condition before calving and feeding her well during her milking period you might increase the yield of that cow by 150 gallons, but I would suggest that the keeping of records for the purpose of selling the progeny of that cow will not have very good results and should be eliminated. There is no need to build up herd records over a wide area for every herd. We can just simply provide that information for the owner of the cow so that he may know what his cow is capable of, the amount of milk and butter fat that it produced in the year and whether she is giving a reasonable return for the amount of food consumed.
Having dealt with that matter in detail, I turn to the suggestion I have already made that the general bulk of the small farmers are in a state of uncertainty. There is no security or no guarantee of what prices will be in future or whether they are going to get anything to enable them to retain the members of their own family on their farms or to employ hired labour.
By direction of the organisation that put me where I am now I am going to ask that a guaranteed price for the produce of the pig, the cow and the hen be established based on the cost of production and a reasonable profit and on what it would take to employ labour if necessary and that the produce of that labour on the farm be paid for from the price received for that produce. That it has not been doing so is evident from the fact that the numbers are dwindling. If that is to be stopped, guaranteed prices must be assured to agricultural producers just as well as the workers in the factory.
I mentioned the produce of the pig, the cow and the hen because unfortunately the farmers in my area have never benefited very much from the wheat or beet schemes. It is regrettable, and as a result they were driven to those three things I have mentioned. I have been directed to demand that those prices be guaranteed. That was the purpose of my motions on pig prices and milk prices but, unfortunately, they were not implemented. By a majority of the House my milk prices motion was defeated, but singularly enough my pig prices motion asking an increase in prices which would enable farmers to produce pigs on the produce of the farm was unanimously accepted by the Dáil. No attempt, however, was made to implement it and no attempt was made or is being made to find out what price it would be necessary to give for bacon pigs so as to give farmers the cost of production. Any figures I put up were ridiculed but when I challenged that no one could put up figures to refute them. Obviously ridicule takes the place of logic. The fact remains that there is no security and that is an injustice to this section of the community.
I would suggest to the Minister that he should take this Estimate back to his colleagues in the Cabinet and put the points he has heard in this debate during the past five or six days before them. Let him say candidly to them that the farming community are not getting justice or a reasonable share of the wealth they produce. In view of the fact that when no other food was to be got they impoverished their farms in the effort to produce food and worked very hard, late and early, it is not right that they should be continually kept as underdogs. I suggest that he put these points to his colleagues in the Cabinet and say to them that the farmers cannot be fooled any longer and that we will have to concede justice or at least a measure of it to them. If his colleagues do not agree to that, do not agree to set about finding the costing of agricultural production so that the prices at which farmers must sell will be guaranteed, my instructions are that I am to vote for the motion to refer this Estimate back for reconsideration. I will be sorry to have to do so, but whether or no the position is more serious than it would seem to those who look lightly at this thing because they are getting more pigs, eggs and so on at cheaper prices, while at the same time the agricultural population is dwindling at a greater rate even than during the years 1941 to 1947.
The people are in a state of discontent and unless they get some assurance of a guaranteed price for their produce based on the cost of production so as to give unpaid farmers and their families at least a labourer's wage—it is not too much to ask—there will be no question of generosity to the agricultural community. Again I would suggest to the Minister to take his Estimate back and put the position clearly before his colleagues and say that the farming community must get justice.
Comment on this
I have listened carefully to Deputy O'Reilly's speech and I must say that there is a good deal that is absolutely true and sincere in it. I would say that every farmer Deputy in this House must agree with a lot of it and I would suggest to the so-called farmer Deputies on the Government Benches that they should seriously consider it. He has sounded a warning and has stated that the farmers have been deceived and fooled, in short, that the farmers do not know exactly where they stand. I agree absolutely with Deputy O'Reilly on this.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Reilly quoted some figures to show that the Minister, in spite of all the eloquence of which he is capable, has not proved to the small working farmer, the farmer who matters in this country, that he is in any state of security whatever. From the very beginning the Minister's attitude has been a changing one towards farming and I would quote one or two examples, first as to what might be regarded as the main produce of agricultural land, the main hope that in the event of peace or war the ordinary citizen is entitled to and will get a loaf of bread. I refer to wheat. I will take the House back to the debate on agriculture in 1947 on the 18th June, Volume 106, column 2042 where the Minister stated:—
"Some day I am convinced that beet will go up the spout after beet and wheat. God speed that day."
We will come along to the agriculture debate in 1948 on the 9th July, Volume 111, column 2593, where the Minister still persisted in his attitude towards wheat when he said:—
"I hold precisely the same views now as I have always held about growing wheat on Irish land in times of peace when supplies are available from other sources. In my judgment it is a `cod' and a waste of land."
The Times Pictorial on the 19th March, 1949, quotes the Minister:
"Farmers who want a cash crop should sow wheat or malting barley."
I come now to 22nd August, 1949, and the report of the Minister's address at the Muintir na Tíre Rural Week in Limerick. He appealed to parish councils to encourage farmers to grow more wheat next year "and we will come still further". On 17th February, 1950, the Minister was addressing farmers in Cooley, County Louth, and he said:
"The plain truth about wheat growing is that, while it is true you are guaranteed a price of 62/6 per barrel for all the millable wheat grown upon the land of Ireland until 1953, every barrel of wheat that is grown represents a heavy burden on the Exchequer which must be met by corresponding taxes payable by our people. I would prefer to see barley and oats grown on our land which we will dispose of at a profit on our export market in the shape of live stock and live-stock products rather than wheat, which can only be disposed of by compelling the domestic milling industry to buy it and paying them a heavy subsidy on every barrel they buy. Don't believe all the nonsense about wheat saving dollars. Under the International Wheat Agreement, there is plenty of wheat to be had from dollar and non-dollar sources, just as good as any we can produce in Ireland, but I know of nowhere in the world where we can buy, for dollars or sterling, oats and barley which can compare in quality with what the land of Ireland can produce."
That is the Minister's attitude to wheat. What is the Government's policy on wheat? Shifting from one day to another, so that the farmer who can grow wheat, and has done so, is now in a dilemma and does not know exactly what he is to do.
Comment on this
I would not be a bit surprised by what the Deputy would swear. The Minister, in his opening remarks, admitted quite frankly that he cannot find a market for Irish butter. I wonder why? In 1949, at column 1839, Volume 115 of the Official Debates we find the Minister, speaking of farmers' butter, saying:—
"Any scheme which, at the end of 12 months, leaves your successor with 2,000 cwts. of butter surrounded by a cordon sanitaire at the port of Dublin, and which requires almost the fire brigade in gas masks to get it on board ship for export to a processing factory, is scarcely one which can aptly be described as `perhaps not perfect,' and not assumed to have reached the stage where Deputy Smith would describe it as having failed. The butter would blow the roof off the cold store.”
Here the Minister, faced with a situation in which farmers have butter to sell, starts off by shouting from the rooftops a warning to any prospective customer not to come in and buy that butter. Is that a proper method to adopt, even though the situation was becoming not so rosy?
Comment on this
Can you imagine the Minister, being what is called a successful merchant himself, shouting off the housetops to his customers not to approach him to buy his produce?
Comment on this
The Minister will have the retort that he has set up creameries. In so far as the setting up of creameries has affected my constituency, I must give him credit for doing it—to the extent to which it affects those people who can conveniently get to the creamery. I assure the Minister that, where I can give him credit, I will do so, and, where he needs the whip, I will whip him also.
Comment on this
I come now to another crop, oats. On 28th February, 1948, there appeared in the daily newspapers an advertisement from the Department of Agriculture:
"Next to wheat and potatoes, oats is the most important crop in our farming economy. It is a valuable human food. Oats not required on the farm commands a remunerative price."
In that same year, at column 2956, Volume 111 of the Official Debates, the Minister said:
"Oats I need not speak of because their value is too well known. `Grow,' I say to the farmers, `all the oats your land will produce and you will sell them profitably either in bag or on hoof during the winter and the spring of next year."'
"In bag", mark you. Acting on the Minister's advice and the Department's advertisements, the farmers sowed plenty of oats, as the House is aware. That harvest, the country was flooded with oats for which there was no market. Deputation after deputation called on the Minister and the Department but nothing was done about oats until the Minister left the country. The farmer who grew oats in 1948 was faced with no profit although promised a remunerative price—in the bag, mark you.
Comment on this
I admit, on the hoof. He was told, during the 1948 harvest, that he must feed it to live stock. Is that farmer encouraged to sow oats again? The result is that, this year, there is a scarcity of oats. The Minister changed his tactics again in 1949, and at column 1081, Volume 115 of the Official Debates of 12th May, he said:
"Oats should be grown on an ever-increasing acreage by those farmers who understand what farming means and who realise that the bulk of the oats grown upon our lands must be consumed on the holding if they are to yield a profit in all circumstances. The farmer who grows them exclusively as a cash crop will confer a blessing on the community at large if he puts himself as an apprentice to a tailor or a cobbler."
Grow oats in 1948, but apprentice yourself to a tailor or cobbler in 1949. What encouragement has a farmer to grow oats?
Although oats generally were scarce last season, the Minister, in order to encourage growers to grow oats again, went to the Argentine and bought 8,000 tons of Argentine oats at 46/- a barrel, yet he could not fix a price of even 30/- a barrel the year before. What encouragement is there for the farmer who can grow oats to do so? I certainly admit that oats is an excellent food for live stock but there are farmers who cannot put in the extra live stock to consume all their produce. Such farmers will have a moderate amount of oats left and will naturally be anxious to have a price for them. Is it too much to ask the Minister to ensure that farmers who have a surplus will be able to sell it at harvest time rather than have it wasting in their barns? The Minister knows very well that many of these farmers have not the up-to-date equipment and accommodation for preserving all these cereals that perhaps bigger farmers may have. On every occasion that a Deputy on this side of the House mentions the matter of surplus corn, he is met with a series of jeers, gibes, and so on, but the poor farmer has still to hold his produce.
I want to refer to another very important branch of agriculture, namely, eggs and poultry generally. In May, 1948, there appeared in the organ P.E.P. a signed statement by the Minister as follows:—
"It used to be the rule that when egg supplies increased the price went down. That is no longer true. We have made an agreement with the British Ministry of Food that the more eggs we send to the British market the more they will pay for our eggs. It is as a result of this agreement that shippers can afford to pay 3/- per dozen for eggs to the producer."
I wonder what happened to that agreement. Perhaps the Minister will tell us. He will, of course, try to convince this House and the farmers that they are better off now with 2/- a dozen than they were when they were getting 3/-.
Comment on this
Are you going to choke your own hens? Divil a choke. He has a nostalgic smile on his countenance.
Comment on this
The Minister is an expert on dragging red herrings across trails. It does not affect me. Perhaps the reduction in the price of eggs may be said to be due to the Minister's blowing. There appeared in the Irish Press of 6th May, 1950, a report which states:—
"We do not take Mr. Dillon's way of talking very seriously, said Mr. C. F. Whittal, chairman of the Morton-hampstead branch of the N.F.U., Devonshire, 32 members of which were entertained at Ashford by the County Wicklow branch of the I.F.F.
Mr. Dillon had told the British people he would drown them in eggs and bury them in bacon. Drowning and burying denoted a disorderly market, declared Mr. Whittal, but they would have to secure an orderly market to get anywhere."
Comment on this
The Minister knows that the reduction in the price of eggs from 3/- to 2/6 does not meet with approval of the egg producers down the country. Large producers of day-old chicks from the hatcheries will say that the reduction in the purchase of day-old chicks last season was due to the reduction in the price of eggs as well as the scarcity in the supply of bran and pollard. Many of these farmers have a considerable quantity of their own cereals but cannot get sufficient bran, pollard, meat meal or fish meal to make a balanced ration. In latter months they cannot even get a complete balanced ration from their merchant. I think it was by way of interjection when my colleague, Deputy Beegan, was speaking on this Estimate the other day, that the Minister said he was about to establish a meat meal industry in Ballinasloe.
Comment on this
I am very glad to hear it. Perhaps the Minister would follow that up and establish a fish meal industry. It would be very useful for poultry and pigs.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister may not know that there is complete dissatisfaction among the people who run poultry hatchery supply farms. Last season a number of farms did not even sell one egg to the hatchery.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would be kind enough to give me the names as he did so in connection with the barley?
Comment on this
Last season there was a falling off in the demand for day-old chicks. Naturally enough, there must be a falling off in the demand for hatching eggs. I know some supply farms that did not supply any eggs. The hatcheries were closed to them in the middle of March. That is not very satisfactory because, as the Minister and the House know, these farmers went to considerable expense to build up stocks only to find that they have no market for their produce or an unsatisfactory market. These people are not satisfied and will not give the attention to this matter that they might give to it if they could get rid of all their supplies.
I am glad to note that there is considerable improvement in blood testing and that the first this year has already been taken. I note also that there is a very satisfactory result in regard to having disease free stocks.
There is another matter to which the Minister might give his attention and it is a matter which only came to my notice a few evenings ago when I was rambling in my constituency. There is, all over the country, I expect, as there is in my constituency, a mobile blood-testing unit. When I came upon this unit the other day it was stranded on the road. The blood-testing technician told me that one of the tubes had burst a fortnight before and that, although the matter had been reported to the Department and a request made for a spare tube, the tube had not arrived and now the second tube had burst. She was, therefore, stranded. She had to take out that tube on the road, bring it to a garage and try to have it patched up. The cost of petrol was about 12/6 and the cost of a new tube 14/-. Perhaps the Minister might give his attention to the matter and ensure that there will be no undue delay in matters of this kind.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy misunderstood the officer of my Department. It is not customary for civil servants to make complaints of that kind. They never do.
Comment on this
The next time the Minister gets a complaint that the unit is stranded miles out the country will the Minister investigate any such complaint?
Comment on this
It might be like the barley.
Comment on this
Or will he investigate it in a slipshod manner—like the barley? Now we come to the barley.
Comment on this
About the 1st May last I was informed that the Minister was about to import something like 16,000 tons of feeding barley. A certain number of merchants asked me about it. I knew nothing. Nevertheless, these merchants asked me to look into the matter. Knowing the position as regards barley in my constituency especially, last season, I considered that it was my duty to do so. I know merchants who turned away last harvest, and up to very recently, several of their best customers with lorries of barley. Admittedly, some of that was malting barley but nevertheless the merchants had to turn them away because they could not get a market for it. Will any Deputy in this House suggest that any merchant will turn away a good customer with his produce if he can resell that produce at any price? The merchant will purchase it, even knowing that he will have to sustain a loss, in order to retain that customer. We have the spectacle of lorries of barley coming into my own town and being turned away again—and yet we find the Minister importing feeding barley from far off Iraq.
In reply to my question on the 10th May last the Minister asked me to send him the names of people who had some of this barley. I got some names from the merchants concerned and some people approached me themselves. I sent the Minister a list. Good enough of the Minister, he sent down his inspectors. However, the Minister's report does not tally with mine, somehow or other. The Minister said: "I first went to Mr. J.H. His barns were said to be bursting. He told us he had not any barley at all, but that he had sold 73 barrels some time ago for 42/-.""Some time ago!" He did not say at what time. Will the Minister now state, or when he is replying to the debate, if this man actually had his barley when the Minister went sweeping up the barns of Iraq barley? If the Minister says he had sold it at that time I will accept his word—I will leave it to the owner of the barley to accept it or reject it.
Comment on this
"Deeming Deputy Lahiffe's information to be an invitation to enter on the premises of Mr. T.K., I knocked at his door. He said he had three barrels, but that he would not take a penny less than 50/- for it because he wanted to feed it to his stock." He had half a ton and the highest price we get is 30/-.
Comment on this
We will divide it. I have the man's word that he had half a ton. He is only a small farmer. I resent any jibes from the Government Benches that this man is not entitled to sell his barley because he is a small farmer.
Comment on this
"I then went to Mr. S.S. He said he had not a barrel of barley in the barn for some time, that he had sold the last of it for 44/- some weeks ago.""Some weeks ago"— some weeks from the week after the 10th May, when the question was down. I would say that the inspector called the week after the 10th May. The man had sold his barley "some weeks ago". Does the Minister now suggest that the man who grew his barley and still had it "some weeks ago" in the middle of May will be encouraged to grow it again?
Comment on this
The Minister has probably heard that this man is not a supporter of Fianna Fáil. He is, in fact, a great admirer of the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Donnellan, who is now sitting beside the Minister.
Comment on this
He is a good small farmer. I wonder if the Parliamentary Secretary was informed that this man had a lorry to take his barley to my town last harvest and had to take it back again only "some weeks ago." Was that man encouraged to grow barley again? "I repaired to Mr. P. H. He said he had not a grain in the place, and had not had for some considerable time." This man had got rid of his barley. Nevertheless, he had it, and yet the Minister went out to Iraq. "I went to Mr. M.C. His larder was also bare." Perhaps that is admitted. He then called to Mr. M. M. and Mr. O'B. "both of whom received him with genial but ribald laughter." They said "they had no barley at all, but that Mr. O'B had had three barrels which he had sold six weeks ago for 42/-." That is false absolutely. This man's name I got from the merchant. He could not sell the barley. Nevertheless, we see Mr. O'B. arriving at the merchant's premises with his barley—and not three barrels, but 39 cwt. 1 qr. and 7 lbs.
Comment on this
As a result of my question. It was on the 14th June, and my question was on the 10th May, and the Minister could find only three barrels. He was bursting with ribald laughter, but he could not find the barley. There was more ribald laughter. There was Mr. M.G., whose name I did not give to the Minister.
Comment on this
I gave the Minister the name of a merchant who would not purchase this barley. He did not send the inspector there.
Comment on this
I did not give his name to the Minister, but I gave the Minister the name of the merchant who would not purchase it.
Comment on this
The Minister is trying to put another red herring across the path. I gave the name of the merchant who would not purchase it, because he could not get a market. Nevertheless, we have Mr. M.G. arriving at the merchant's premises on 1st June with 31 cwts. of barley.
Comment on this
Then there was Mr. J.L.—I did not give his name to the Minister. The merchant concerned gave me his name. He arrived on 5th June with 44 cwts. of barley.
Comment on this
He got 50/- He held over his barley from the harvest of 1949 until 1950. In spite of the Minister's Iraq barley——
Comment on this
That there was barley in South Galway. The Minister said the inspector called there. The barley was there, but they could not sell before that.
Comment on this
The farmers should see the lovely stuff the Minister brought in from Iraq. I gave another name to the Minister that he cloaked; I gave him the name of Mr. T.C. There was no reference to it in the Dáil debates.
Comment on this
I did not give his name at the time I gave the bunch, but this man wrote to me a separate letter. Now maybe the Minister can catch on.
Comment on this
Mr. T.C. wrote to me after the question appeared in the Press. He had 35 barrels and he could not sell it. He asked me where he would get a market. I reported it to the Minister and it was not until then that this man got a market, but I will not tell the Minister the price.
Comment on this
Before I leave the Chair, may I say that I do not think this type of running commentary helps the debate?
Comment on this
May I submit that the Deputy is now harping back on what I said in the House and he seems to challenge the accuracy of my report to the House?
Comment on this
The Minister will have his opportunity when he is concluding the debate—and not even a Minister has the right to interrupt a Deputy unless the Deputy gives way.
Comment on this
I was saying that I reported to the Minister that Mr. T.C. had barley he could not sell. It was about the middle of May last. The Minister's inspector did not call on that man. If he did he would be sent to three other neighbours who had barley—and not three barrels either. Mr. S. had six barrels, Mr. F. had ten barrels, and Mr. H. had ten barrels. Now, we will come to where the Minister was notified after my question appeared in the Press. The Minister received a letter from a merchant who had large stocks of barley, and more barley booked in the country. He asked the Minister if he could find a market for it. An inspector called to see the barley, but nothing happened. This merchant wrote to one miller. The miller is Robert Perry & Co., Belmont, Offaly. He replied on the 30th May, 1950, as follows:—
"We thank you for sample of barley and oats. At the moment we are not buying oats owing to the slow demand for oatmeal, but can offer you 40/- per barrel in our sacks ex your store or 42/- per barrel delivered at Belmont for the barley. We understand you have approximaately 200 barrels of same."
Yet the Minister could find no barley in South Galway. Perhaps the Minister and perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary will now admit that there was barley at that time in South Galway.
Comment on this
The Minister will now have to admit that it was my duty to raise the matter in the Dáil when, as I understood at the time, he was about to import about 16,000 tons of feeding barley. In raising the matter on the Adjournment I stated definitely that I was concerned chiefly with those farmers who were asked by the people opposite to sow Ymer barley, which is a feeding barley, and who may be confronted with the same conditions next harvest. Will the position be that these people, if they have this barley for sale, will be left with it until June, 1951, before they can get a market for it, or until a humble Deputy like myself has to make a protest on their behalf? Will the Minister not consider it his duty to take up the barley from those people before he goes sweeping in the barns in other countries for foreign stuff which must be described as inferior feeding barley? Will the Minister, when concluding, state what guarantee he can give to those barley producers for the future, or what guarantee he can give to the producer of any crop in the future?
It is useless for the Minister to stand up here and say grow this, that, and the other crop and then quote a lot of figures. The farmers know the figures, no matter how eloquent the Minister, or any other speaker, may be, and no matter how they may tell the farmer how well off he is. The farmer himself knows exactly how he stands. Is it a sound proposition in peace time, or in war time, or in a time of threatened war, to go trotting over the whole world for food stuffs for animals or for humans, that we have in this country? We have the land and we have the farmers who are prepared to grow the food stuffs if they are assured of a market for what they produce. It is only reasonable, I think, to ask the Minister to ensure that, for the future, these farmers will not be left stranded again. I would ask the Minister to reconsider his whole attitude on this matter.
I am only voicing the opinions of every practical farmer in the country on this matter. Farmers on the Government side of the House have criticised the Minister's attitude on this. Deputy O'Reilly to-day, in a good, sound reasoned speech, showed that the farmers are not satisfied, and that they do not know exactly where they stand. Perhaps it is too much for me to ask the Minister to throw off this cloak of deception and tomfoolery, to get down to groundwork and to let the people know if he is going to condemn entirely the tillage policy; to tell the farmers openly that they will not be allowed a market for their stuff before they go to the trouble of sowing it. Let the people know that the country must depend on outside sources for the commodities we require. If that is the attitude of the Government, well and good. At least the people will not be deceived again.
There is another matter I want to refer to. It is one that I would like to compliment the Minister on. I am ready to give credit where credit is due. During the last two years on this Estimate I made an appeal to the Minister to consider some form of veterinary aid for the farmers. He has initiated a scheme against contagious abortion in heifers. That scheme has been a success to a reasonable extent. In my area the Minister probably will have observed that the response to it has been slow, the reason being there is not a great number of reasonably good heifers in that area. The Minister and his Department will also probably have observed that the people there have gone over to a Hereford crossbreed of cattle. That would be a reason for the slowness of the people to avail of this scheme. Nevertheless, the scheme represented a start and so I want to give the Minister credit for that.
With regard to the land project, I cannot say much about it because I have not seen anything done about it. I know of one farm that has been inspected, and of an estimate that was given to the owner as to what he would need by way of a grant. The amount of money to be spent on ground limestone on that land was, in my opinion, excessive. I should like to know from the Minister whether his Department, before deciding to spend money on ground limestone, subjects the land to be treated to a lime test before the application of the limestone?
Comment on this
Thank you. I will conclude with the note of warning that was sounded by Deputy O'Reilly, namely, that the farmers are not satisfied, and that the Minister must mend his ways if he expects the co-operation of the farming community.
Comment on this
I suppose, in this imperfect world, it would be very difficult to find a perfect Minister for Agriculture. I think, however, there is general agreement throughout the country that the present Minister has carried out his duties efficiently and well during the last few years. As Minister in charge of the agricultural economy, he has put forward a policy. Now it is not the Minister's duty personally to put that policy into operation. It must be implemented by those on whose behalf the policy is propounded. Listening to this debate, one would be led to conclude that it is the function of the Minister to spend all his time travelling around the country personally supervising every individual farmer in his daily work. I believe the Minister has sufficient confidence in the common-sense of our farmers to appreciate that once they are given a lead they will do their work well. As to whether the farmers are in the parlous state some Deputies say they are the only guide which we have on that is the material results of the policy propounded and pursued by the Minister during the past two years and the position of the farmers generally, more especially the position in the income which has come their way during that period.
Leaving out all personal prejudice and spleen—and spleen has been shown here in no unmistakable fashion against the Minister for Agriculture— I think most Deputies realise that so far as the farming community is concerned more money has poured into the pockets of the farmers during the past 12 months than poured into them during the previous ten or 15 years. That is a fact of which we should be proud. That is a fact we should frankly admit. Is it not a fact? Is it not the experience of every Deputy who has the well-being and the success of the farmers at heart, irrespective of political views or affiliations, that the position of the farming community at the moment is good? It is well for the country that that should be so because, when all is said and done, the interests of those who dwell in our cities and towns are dependent in large measure upon the success and the prosperity of the farmers. One cannot live without the other. For that reason I deprecate the line taken by certain Deputies who tried to put the farmers in a different class from those who live in our cities and towns. We must all pull together. We must all sink or swim together.
I shall not go into detail in relation to agricultural policy generally as outlined in the White Paper. Every Deputy has had a copy of that White Paper. I do not believe that document has been read by even one member of the Opposition because not one of the Opposition speakers has given the Minister any credit. They have tried to damn with faint praise. Any little credit that has been given has been the niggard credit of a mean mind. I shall not go into all the details of policy. Suffice it is to say that, if the present policy is pursued to its logical conclusion by the farming community, it will result in bringing increased wealth and prosperity to the country as a whole.
The Minister has been attacked by the Opposition in relation to his attitude on wheat growing. Most of the speakers spent their time quoting from speeches delivered by the Minister when he was a Deputy on the benches they now occupy. Time marches on. It is not with the waters that have passed under the bridge we are now concerned. It is the on-coming waters that claim our attention. We must accept the position as we find it. The Minister has been twitted because, it is alleged, he is against a tillage policy. To my knowledge and to the knowledge of every Deputy the Minister has, not once but on many occasions, implored the farmers to increase the acreage under oats, barley and potatoes. If the farmers failed to take his advice last year, especially in relation to the growing of oats and potatoes, the responsibility for that rests entirely on those members of the Opposition who carried out an insidious propaganda against the publicly announced policy of the Minister. In that connection I would refer in particular to Deputy Davern and Deputy Blaney.
Comment on this
That is not correct. I emphatically deny that. You know very well it was the muddle the Minister made when he scuttled off to America and left the farmers in a mess.
Comment on this
With regard to oats and potatoes, I have had personal experience of that insidious propaganda. Because of that propaganda every farmer throughout the length and breadth of the country wanted to sell his oats and his potatoes on the same day. They were all going to the workhouse. If a farmer with 1,000 barrels of oats could not sell that 1,000 barrels on a particular day, he was ruined. He could not afford to wait for even one day. That was the type of propaganda. The same situation existed in relation to potatoes. I took upon myself the responsibility of advising farmers in my constituency to have patience and keep their oats and their potatoes. Those who took that advice were wise men because they subsequently sold these oats for 35/-, 40/- and 45/- a barrel.
Comment on this
It took Deputy Lahiffe an hour to say what could have been said in a few minutes about barley in Galway. I am not surprised that he tried the patience of the Minister. He referred to the Minister having gone to Cooley and talked there about wheat and potatoes and oats. The Minister did go to Cooley. He was the first Minister to visit that area since 1923 and he was received there with open arms. He made an impression on the farmers of that area, who for husbandry are unequalled in any part of this country. They are men who work and they have told me since that the present Minister was the finest man who ever addressed a meeting in that area for the last 50 years. Eighty per cent. of those men supported Deputy Aiken on the last occasion.
What is the position there in regard to this question of potatoes and as to whether the farmers are in a prosperous condition at the present time? I am not going to say they are millionaires. There was a year in which I myself, some 15 or 16 years ago, rode down on the wettest day we ever saw in this country, on a Sunday, to plead for 5/- on the top of £3 for their potatoes, which they could not sell. I remember making a prophecy on that day that possibly the day might come when the people of this country would be glad to buy these potatoes, not at £3 5s. 0d. and £3 10s. 0d. but at £7 and £8—and I am glad to say that, due to the foresight of the present Minister, who made an agreement with the British Government, the British market is again available. That was the market about which Fianna Fáil said: "Thank God, it is gone, and gone for ever." It is there still and I say thank God it is. It is the only market in which the farmers can dispose of their agricultural produce. The Minister arranged for the sale of 50,000 tons of potatoes and the farmers of Cooley got from £8 to £8 10s. 0d. per ton for every stone of potatoes they grew in that area. They had the satisfaction of disposing of between 7,000 and 8,000 tons at £8 a ton, which is in the region of £56,000 to £60,000—as against £20,000 which was received during the régime of Fianna Fáil.
I would not say this at all were it not for the statements that have emanated from the far side of the House. I believe that we should all work in the interest of the farming community in general. We should not talk about what appertains to our own constituencies only but talk of the policy as it affects this country as a whole. Look at the income that has been derived from agriculture in the last few years— the cattle industry especially. There again, Fianna Fáil tries to make out that the Minister is out for grass, for the graziers, for more cattle and less tillage. I always think about the old story, the more cattle you have the more tillage you must have, as they go hand in hand. Cattle are necessary for farming.
I am going by what I hear throughout the length and breadth of the county which I represent. It is one of the best farming counties in Ireland where they go in for mixed tillage. Although it is the smallest, I would put them against any farmers anywhere. I mix as much with the farmers as any one else. I say here, honestly and above board, that I have not heard any great complaints on the part of the majority of farmers in County Louth. We all know that, human nature being what it is, people will complain. Taking the matter in general, I am proud to say that the farmers seem to be in as good a position to-day as ever they were, though they are not millionaires. There is no use in talking about the poor farmer being pauperised, being a slave and so forth. There has been no slavery in this country for the last 25 or 30 years.
A good deal has been said about eggs. I never heard a more doleful speech than that of Deputy O'Reilly. According to Deputies opposite, the farmers are not to raise an extra hen for fear they could not sell the extra eggs. They are not to grow any extra oats or potatoes. As regards the price, I think the Minister made a good bargain regarding eggs—2/-, 2/6, 3/6. There is more money coming into the pockets of the farmers as a result of that increased trade with Great Britain. The Minister is right when he says that the more eggs we export the more money we will have in our pockets. That has been proved. There is more than £3,000,000 income being derived from the sale of eggs.
Again, we have heard from many of the Opposition in regard to barley and oats. In the same way, they are putting their hands up and asking what will happen in the event of any little extra crop. If we all went on that line, that the sky might fall, we would do nothing. In the same way, some members are trying to scare the people about a war period and our people caught napping. As far as I am concerned, the wars come and will come. We have had two great wars and we are here still. The Irish people will live and will not starve. As far as the growing of wheat is concerned, the farmer will not have to serve five years to grow wheat. He simply rotates his crop.
Comment on this
The farmers do not need to serve their time for five years to learn how to grow wheat. They are not going to be forced into the war as Fianna Fáil tries to make out, in trying to convince the people down the country—in fact, they are at it already —that the Minister for Agriculture wants to get the people of this country into the war.
Comment on this
There is no truth in that whatsoever. I think the Deputy should withdraw that statement.
Comment on this
These are political statements and Deputy Davern will have an opportunity of repudiating them, if he so desires.
Comment on this
It has been said by the Deputies opposite and it has been implied in no uncertain way that one of the reasons why the Minister is against growing wheat is that we would then not have food in stock and in the event of war we would have to go into the war.
Comment on this
I want to answer that by stating that it will not take the farmers six or 12 months to learn how to change over from oats to wheat or vice versa, or to potatoes. They are doing it every year since the world began. Of course, Fianna Fáil would like to be talking of war. In so far as going into the war is concerned now, we would be just as good as Fianna Fáil were during the last war. They were not such bad friends of the British, though they pretended to be the other way about.
Comment on this
They were always good friends on the other side of the water and we are not going to starve. Those opposite need not be trying to frighten the people about the threat of war. Wars come and wars go, and we still get through.
The land rehabilitation scheme has been referred to. After all, it is a new scheme and the child must creep before it walks and the Minister must serve his time. If it is a bit strange, even a man going to a strange job feels out of place for a few days. This scheme is novel and new and will require time and, above all, the sympathy and co-operation of all concerned. It has been introduced for the benefit of the farming community and I thought that one of the men who would be the first to praise the scheme would be Deputy Smith, the ex-Minister for Agriculture; but it seems that he spent most of his time in spying upon the officials of the Department who were engaged in that scheme. He said they were doing nothing but spending time in the offices, drawing maps, when they should be out in the country. It seems that he has his Quislings going around watching the officials. Again, their hatred of the Minister is such that they even attack the officials in order to get at him. I move to report progress.