Committee on Finance. - Vote 27 — Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 1–175 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
On the last day when the House met I was dealing with the question of pigs and bacon. I had almost concluded that particular item, but there was a difference of opinion about the words of the Minister in relation to a reduction of the price. I have the reference now which will make it clear. In column 2172 of Volume 121 Deputy McQuillan's speech on the Agriculture Estimate is reported. He asked the Minister to look into the question of reducing the price of bacon. The Minister said:—
"And perfectly right; 260/- is an excessive price and it must come down."
The report proceeds:—
"Mr. McQuillan: I am very glad to hear the Minister say so, and I hope it comes down very soon.
Comment on this
I hope so, too—within 24 or 48 hours."
I do not want to quote too extensively, but in the next column, in reference to the same matter, the Minister said:—
"If that does not succeed the resources of civilisation are not exhausted."
I presume that to mean that if it did not come down in the way the Minister hoped, he would have to deal with the matter further. That indicates the Minister's hope that the price of bacon would be reduced.
Comment on this
On a point of order. There is such a buzz of conversation in the auditorium, particularly coming from the Government Benches, that it is difficult to hear the speaker.
Comment on this
A few days afterwards, and during the same debate, when Deputy Childers was speaking— Volume 122, column 184—he asked the Minister how far he had got with his proposal to have the price of bacon reduced, and the Minister said:—
"10/- a cwt. and another 10/- I hope next Monday.
Mr. Childrens: So far as I know, in one town in Ireland, at any rate, the price of bacon has gone up.
Mr. Dillon: The curers brought it down by 10/- a cwt. and any grocer who has not taken down the price of bacon proportionately is a rogue."
We are, of course, accustomed to the Minister's habit of calling people rogues and racketeers if they do not fall in with him, or if for one reason or another, they make it impossible for him to carry out his wishes, whether they be pious or otherwise. He refers to the grocers in this case as rogues if they did not bring down the price of bacon. All of us have seen a number of communications since then in the daily papers from the organisation which claims to have among its members most of the grocers in this country —R.G.D.A.T.A. They claim that the price of bacon did not come down. In fact, they have said that only one factory reduced the price of bacon, and that the other factories did not, and that it would be impossible, therefore, for the grocers to reduce the price of bacon, at any rate for the reason which the Minister gave. Well, very naturally, they resented the accusation made by the Minister that their members were all rogues. I think it is very unfortunate, indeed, that the Minister should indulge in that type of slander so often in this House by calling members of various organisations who do not seem to fall in with his wishes racketeers and rogues. I think it is only fair that the Minister, when winding up this debate which, I presume, will take place very soon——
Comment on this
As far as I am concerned I will not detain him very long, but, as I say, I hope that, when winding up the debate, he will make amends to those people. There are other organisations which I hope to refer to before I finish, and I hope that, in their case also, he will make amends to them, and to quite a number of groups of people in his winding up speech.
I do not want to go back on what I said last week about pigs and bacon, or on the various pronouncements that have been made by the Minister on this bacon question, to the changes that he had made in these pronouncements, and to his vacillating from one side to the other. In view of all that, it is very difficult for farmers to know how they stand at the moment. There was admittedly a tendency for increased production of pigs for some time, but it looks now as if production is going back again. It is no wonder because farmers do not know where they stand in regard to the price of feeding or as to what will be paid for pigs, and also because the Minister threatens the curers at one time that he will open new factories or export pigs, while at other times he appeals to them to bring down the price of bacon which, of course, means that the curers must being down the price of pigs.
Now, coming to the question of milk and butter, it is rather a strange thing that there has been very little variation in the number of cows in this country over the last 50 years. The percentage change is not very high. The number goes up at certain times and it comes down at certain times, but there is not that very big variation that we have in the case of pigs and of other animals. The yield from cows may vary. It may vary according to the feeding or according to weather conditions. Of course, weather conditions will affect feeding, too. One has a rather complicated calculation to make, and a complicated number of factors to keep in mind every year when discussing the milk yield of cows. Deputies on all sides of the House will admit, I think, that the dairying industry is the basic industry of agriculture, and that if it were to fail not only would we have less milk and butter, but we would have less cattle and less feeding in the way of skim milk for poultry, pigs and other animals. Therefore, it is really a basic industry, and so we should do everything in our power to see that the dairying industry is maintained, and in fact to do everything in our power to increase the number of cows.
The first act of the Minister, when he came into power, was to withdraw the subsidy on farmers' butter. The Minister will give his own reasons for doing that. I think he was wrong in doing it, because up to that time almost half the cows of the country were owned by farmers who made farmers' butter. The other half, or a bit more than half, of the cows were owned by farmers who supplied milk to the creameries. In doing away with the subsidy on farmers' butter, the Minister was dealing a very severe blow to the dairying industry. When I say that half the cows of the country were owned by farmers who did not deal with the creameries, I am not giving, perhaps, a true picture of the real situation if you take into account the fact that a far bigger number than half the farmers of the country are interested in farmers' butter rather than creamery butter because of the big areas where there are no creameries, and where you have small farmers who are interested only in farmers' butter. In that way, a greater number of farmers of the country were affected by the withdrawal of this subsidy. Not every farmer, of course, who makes farmers' butter is interested in the sale of butter because, in many cases, a small farmer has only enough milk and butter for his own family needs, and he has none for sale.
Therefore, he does not mind what the price of farmers' butter is; but, making allowance for all these considerations, there was at that time a large number of farmers interested in the sale of farmers' butter, and the subsidy was withdrawn. Now, up to that time, whether a farmer made farmers' butter or supplied his milk to the creamery, he got roughly the same return for it, and that was the idea behind the subsidy for farmers' butter. That subsidy was withdrawn. In the first place, I think it was unjust to do that, because it was discriminating against a certain class of farmer. These farmers receive no subsidy any longer for their butter because they make farmers' butter, but, like other taxpayers, they have to contribute to taxation, part of which goes in the subsidy to the creameries. The farmers, therefore, who made farmers' butter were put in a very invidious position. They had to pay taxes, part of which went, not exactly to their neighbours, but to another group of farmers who were creamery farmers while they got no advantage themselves.
As I said here before, on more than one occasion, in my opinion the farmers who made farmers' butter were, on the whole, a more industrious class than those who sent their milk to the creameries. After all, I think it is only common-sense to say that the farmer and his wife who not only milk their cows, but also separate the milk and make butter from the separated cream, are more industrious than the farmer and his wife who milk their cows, put the milk in a can, put the can on a cart and send it to the creamery, or, if not, put the can of milk at the gate where it is collected by a lorry which takes it to the creamery. We were, therefore, in withdrawing this subsidy on farmers' butter hitting an industrious class of farmers, and hitting what we admire as a rule in people, the initiative to go out and try to make a living for themselves.
Now, undoubtedly, the tendency of such a step would be to lessen the number of cows. It is all very fine for any Deputy to say to me, "Why does not the farmer bring his milk to the creamery?" Well, there is no creamery available in a lot of these districts. It may be possible to organise creameries in part of an area which, up to this, was producing farmers' butter, but it will never be possible to organise creameries all over. Therefore, there is no redress for the farmer who makes farmers' butter. I would say that, in most cases, there is no redress, and so if he then finds it is not paying him to carry on, he is tempted to get rid of some of his cows.
At the present time these farmers are bringing their butter to market and receiving from 1/6 to 1/9 per lb. At least, that is what they received during the months of May and June. It is possible that, as the year goes on, they will get more, but they will only get more when they have a lesser quantity of butter to sell. Then the butter will have a scarcity value. Now, while butter is in fairly plentiful supply, they are only getting ? to 1/9. That means that they can expect to get only about 7d. per gallon for their milk, while the other group of farmers supplying milk to the creameries are getting ½ per gallon. I do not say that ½ is too much; I shall deal with that figure later on. It is not fair, in my opinion, as between one group of farmers and another, that one should get 7d. per gallon and the other ½ per gallon. The man who gets 7d. is actually contributing in taxation to ensure that ½ to the creamery supplier because part of his milk is subsidised from taxation.
As far as the creamery suppliers are concerned, more than half the farmers are now sending their milk to the creameries. Since early in 1947 they have been getting ½ per gallon during the summer months and ¼ per gallon during the winter months. When that price was fixed by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1947, there were certain Deputies sitting on the Opposition Benches at that time who were dissatisfied with that price and thought it was not enough. They agitated for an increase in that price. The extraordinary thing is that those same Deputies are now sitting on the Government Benches and appear to be perfectly satisfied with ½. Despite the fact that costs have since gone up, particularly in relation to wages, rates and so on, they now appear to be quite content with the price; in fact, they are fighting what one might describe as a rearguard action in an effort to maintain the present price.
On the 18th March, 1950, the Minister for Agriculture went down to Dungarvan and addressed the county committee of agriculture there and, through the Waterford county committee, the rest of the farmers throughout the country. He told them in his opinion the price could not be maintained and he advised those farmers supplying milk to the creameries to accept 1/- per gallon. He said that he would give them a guarantee to maintain that price for five years if they would accept it. I must say that at that time I found it very difficult to understand how the Minister could possibly expect the farmers to take a lesser price than they were getting in 1947-48 since costs have increased considerably. I still find it difficult to understand that. The Minister for Agriculture has the direction of policy. Evidently it is his opinion that it would be better to have the price brought down to 1/- per gallon. He must have felt very strongly about the matter when he went to address the county committee of agriculture at Dungarvan. In a well-prepared speech, which he subsequently printed and circulated, he put forward this proposal, not to the county committee but to the farmers of Ireland. I take it that at that time he considered this was the proper policy. I do not suppose any Minister for Agriculture would address a meeting of that kind and make a serious proposal of that nature, which, I am quite sure, he realised would not be very popular, unless he believed that it was the best policy for the farmers. If he did believe that, why did he not go on with it? Presumably the Minister, having learned the reactions to his proposal not alone from the farmers but from the members of the Coalition Parties, felt that he must soft-pedal. I think it is a serious matter that we should have a Minister who is convinced that a certain course of action is right, but because some back benchers whose votes are necessary to the maintenance of the Government object, immediately falls back on the beautiful democratic principle of consulting the farmers themselves. Of course that was really laughable. It was absurd to ask the farmers whether they would prefer to have 1/- or 1/2, but the Minister fell back on that democratic principle because, as we all know, the Government was in danger.
It is hardly necessary to point out again all the instances we have had. It will suffice if I mention one. About the same time the Minister thought he would save the Exchequer a certain amount of subsidy if he cut the ration of creamery butter to which the farmer was entitled. There are Deputies on the Government Benches who do not know a great deal about these matters and it is our duty to ensure that we do not leave them in doubt. Since rationing was introduced the supplier of milk to the creamery was entitled to a much bigger ration than the ordinary householder. The ration worked out at 12 ounces for every member of the farmer's household. The Minister apparently thought that was unfair to the Exchequer and he decided to reduce it to eight ounces, thereby saving the subsidy on the four ounces per week to every member of the farmer's household. The farmers objected. Here, the Minister did not adopt the democratic system of putting the matter to a plebiscite of the farmers; he pursued his policy because the members of the Coalition Parties did not object. That is the important point. They did not say that they would vote against the Government on this particular proposition and the Minister was, therefore, able to pursue his particular policy in that respect. It may be pointed out here that the Minister, apparently, can vary his democratic principles from day to day. Sometimes when he has to fall back on the democratic principle he is democratic; and sometimes he is not.
He dropped his proposition with regard to the price of milk to the creameries although I am quite certain he felt it was the proper line to pursue. He was convinced it was the proper line. We shall never get anywhere so long as we have a vacillating and pusillanimous Minister for Agriculture, such as we have at the moment. It would be better for the country that we should have a man of principle—even if we have to sacrifice the present Minister for Agriculture—who is prepared to put his proposition through even though he falls on it. We may be able to get on without him, but we cannot get on so long as we have Ministers who have no principle and do not know their own minds from day to day.
Another matter arises out of the creamery industry. When I commenced speaking here the other night, I quoted three or four different passages in which the Minister told us in 1948 that, on account of the Agreement made between this Government and the British Government in 1948, we had a remunerative market for four years certain and, he hoped, for longer for everything that the land of Ireland could produce. Butter was mentioned on the Minister's list. If we had a remunerative market for butter in Britain, this proposition made to the county committee of agriculture in Waterford would never have been necessary. The reason why this proposition was made was that the Minister foresaw that we might have a surplus of butter and that, when we would come to sell that surplus, we would get only a certain price on the British market, not a remunerative price, not a price that would enable the creameries to pay ½ a gallon for milk. I am sure — as a matter of fact the Minister's plebiscite proves it — that the farmers of this country do not consider anything less than ½ a gallon a remunerative price. I am not sure if they are contented with even ½, but they were not satisfied to take less than ½. That is just the minimum that might be called a remunerative price. If we have a surplus on home consumption, and if we go to look for a market for that surplus, there is no market to be found that will take butter on that basis, therefore we have not a remunerative market for it. The Minister has again been proved wrong when he said we had a remunerative market for all the produce of the land of this country for four years certain, and for perhaps longer. The British market so far as that is concerned is not remunerative.
We could, perhaps, turn our hands to something else. You can get more from milk than butter. You could, for instance, make cream and send it to England but they will not take it. At least up to this they would not take it at all, so there is no remunerative market for cream in Britain. Therefore, what the Minister said in 1948, that there was a remunerative price for all our surplus produce, is again proved wrong. The Minister again suggests that we might turn to cheese. We shall have to wait and see how it gets on but it is a very bad thing to base your farming on a system of trial and error.
I want to go back to the British market for a moment in regard to the question of farmers' butter. There was a surplus of farmers' butter last year. I do not know yet how we stand this year, but last year there was a surplus. We sold that surplus in Britain and the price obtained for it regulated the price our farmers received here at home. I should like any Deputy opposite to go to any farmer who is making farmer's butter in this country and ask him is he getting a remunerative price for his butter on the market. I think I can guess what the answer will be, that he is not satisfied at all that it is a remunerative price, so the British market failed there again so far as farmers' butter is concerned. At any rate, you would imagine that the Minister would do his best in the British market, but at a time when he was negotiating for its sale or selling this butter on the British market on May 24th, 1949, as reported in column 1839, Volume 115, the Minister told us what the farmers' butter was like that he was going to sell outside:—
"Any scheme which, at the end of 12 months, leaves your successor with 2,000 cwts. of butter surrounded by a cordon sanitaire at the port of Dublin and which requires almost the fire brigade in gas masks to get it on board ship for export to a processing factory is scarcely one which can aptly be described as `perhaps not perfect', and not assumed to have reached the stage where Deputy Smith would describe it as having failed. The butter would blow the roof off the cold store.”
Deputy Cowan then put in:—
"Or would have walked off the quays."
To that the Minister said:—
"It very nearly did, but we headed it off before we shipped it."
The Minister, who is supposed to be a responsible man and supposed to do his best for the farmers of this country, is much more interested in making a joke here in this House than in getting a good price for the farmers' butter. I think it was a scandalous thing for any man, whether a Minister or anybody else, if he wants to sell an article and says in public what he thinks about it, to describe it in that way. That is, as I say, the Minister's humour, but it is not humour that is putting a lot of money into the pockets of farmers who produce farmers' butter.
We shall now see what we have to say about eggs. When the Minister was talking about this agreement in 1948, as reported in column 2245, Volume 112, he said, in regard to the egg agreement, that he would give credit where credit was due, that the egg agreement was negotiated by Deputy Smith: "For its merits thank him." That was a noble tribute. The agreement was made by Deputy Smith when he was Minister for Agriculture, round about October, 1947. As a result of that agreement, the producer in this country was getting 3/- a dozen. We have not yet reached the stage in this country where we can rear, or at least hatch out, pullets only. Half of them when they come out are cocks. In order to help out the producers of poultry, cockerels received a very good price during the early months of the year. On the 19th March, 1948, the Government Information Bureau announced that the Minister for Agriculture had sanctioned the maintenance of the then price of 3/- per dozen for eggs. Deputies will remember that a month or two later the Minister went across to Great Britain to discuss the marketing of agricultural produce with the British Minister of Food and he threatened the British that he would drown them with eggs.
In order to trace the Minister's actions from that time I may say that he wrote a foreword to a publication called P.E.P., which circulates amongst poultry producers in this country, in the May issue of 1948, in which he said:—
"It used to be the rule that when egg supplies increased the price went down. That is no longer true. We have made an agreement with the British Ministry of Food that the more eggs we send to the British market the more they will pay for our eggs. It is as a result of this agreement that shippers can afford to pay 3/- per dozen for eggs to the producer."
For that we carried on at 3/- per dozen. I find, however, that the Minister in addressing the Donegal Committee of Agriculture on 14th March, 1949, announced that as a result of his recent discussions with the British Government the new price would be 2/6 per dozen, not 3/-. He went on to try to persuade the members of the committee that 2/6 would be as good to them as the 3/-. On May 19th, he told Deputy Commons in the Dáil that he tried to persuade the British Minister to accept duck eggs, but failed. Again, I should like to remind Deputies opposite that there again we failed to have a remunerative market in Great Britain for everything that the land of Ireland could produce. Duck eggs were now crossed out. As might be expected, with a vacillating policy of that kind the exports of eggs for the first three or four months of this year have been down compared with last year.
Now the Minister has announced that for 1951 the price of eggs will be 2/- per dozen and 3/6 from 1st September, 1951, to 31st January, 1952. The uninitiated might be inclined to say that the mean price between 2/6 and 3/- would appear to be 2/9, but it depends on quantity. As a matter of fact, I looked up the exports for the last 12 months, and I find that during the period when the high price will be payable, namely, from September to January, we export 7 per cent. of our eggs during those five months, and 93 per cent. during the period when we will get 2/- per dozen. That would appear to me to work out on an average at 2/1 per dozen. Just as we thought that it was not the time to reduce the price of milk to the creameries, neither can anybody argue that this is the time to reduce the price of eggs, because the price of feeding stuffs has gone up in the meantime, and that is the big factor in both cases. If the price of feeding stuffs goes up, there should be a corresponding increase in the price of eggs and not a decrease such as we have got.
When Deputy Smith, as Minister for Agriculture, made this agreement with the British Minister of Food and, as a result, was able to offer 3/- per dozen to the producers of eggs all the year round, that is, for the 93 per cent. as well as the 7 per cent., he was also able to announce a very attractive price for cockerels when they would be available for the market. But cockerels are not getting anything like the same price now. In fact, I heard complaints down the country that for three or four weeks up to the beginning of this week it was impossible to sell chickens or fowl at all. Therefore, the promise of the Minister to the producers of eggs which he gave in that foreword to P.E.P. in May, 1948, that "the more you produce the more you will get" does not appear to have materialised. The opposite appears to be the case. The promise that he gave in the Dáil, when he came back in 1948 after the agreement was made with Great Britain, as to a remunerative market for everything the land of Ireland would produce also appears to have miscarried.
At the beginning of my speech the Minister asked me to deal in detail with the various things mentioned. I think I have dealt with everything on the live-stock side. I want to deal now with the tillage side. When we speak about tillage, we usually begin by talking about the fertility of the soil. The Minister is keen on making a witty statement whether it is true or not. As reported in Volume 111, column 2589, of the Official Reports, the Minister on 9th July, 1948, said in the Dáil:—
"... the fertility of the land in this country has reached a degree of degradation lower than has been known for 100 years past and we have endemic in many parts of the country a condition known as aphosphorosis in which live stock consume the herbage of the soil and yet die of starvation because the soil contains no phosphates..."
The Minister evidently thought that he had hit on a fairly good thing there because he enlarged on it later and told his audiences in some parts of the country that he had seen cattle lying down and dying. I suppose that was a rather frightening thing for the farmers who were afraid that they might see their cattle just lie down and die although they were getting plenty to eat. Naturally we expected the Minister to make everything right. He said he would and, I think, as a matter of fact, that he has claimed that he has made everything right. "The fertility of the soil is all right now." We have heard nothing this year about aphosphorosis because the soil is all right owing to the beneficent smile of the Minister for Agriculture. It was the Fianna Fáil régime that brought it and it was the Coalition régime that did away with it by Couéism and nothing else. The cure for aphosphorosis is phosphate and I looked up the consumption of phosphate. It comes into the country as raw phosphate or manufactured phosphate. I found that in 1947 when Fianna Fáil were in power the imports of rock phosphate were 73,000 tons; of basic slag, 12,000 tons, and of superphosphate, 3,000 tons. There was a considerable increase in 1948-49. The further we get away from the war the easier it should be to get phosphates. The imports of rock phosphate were 113,000 tons in 1948 and 128,000 tons in 1949; the imports of basic slag went up to 22,000 tons in 1948 and 27,000 tons in 1949; the imports of superphosphates were 20,000 tons in 1948 and 34,000 tons in 1949.
I do not expect Deputies opposite to have jotted down the figures and made calculations for themselves, but when I sat down to look at those figures I had the time to do so. What interested me was whether the present Minister had conquered aphosphorosis or not. No Deputy will deny that land suffering from aphosphorosis would take at least 4 cwt. to the acre, in fact more. That is a small dressing of phosphate for land suffering from aphosphorosis. You will get pasture which is slightly deficient in phosphate and they tell you to put on 4 cwt. to the acre, but land where the Minister saw cows lying down to die should get more. Even on the basis of 4 cwt., what quantity of land has the Minister succeeded in curing? 270,000 acres in 1948 and 400,000 acres in 1949, that is 670,000 in two years. It will take the Minister, if he lives long enough and if he is Minister long enough, 50 years to do the job, and in the meantime the cows will be lying down to die — and the Minister will be looking at them — although they are getting enough to eat as they did under Fianna Fáil when he saw them lying down to die. He has not done much in two years, but he has gone on to talk about something else. He has forgotten about aphosphorosis and maybe it is just as well, because there was not a lot in it.
Comment on this
We will be looking forward to that. The Minister has been, on the whole, opposed to wheat growing.
Comment on this
I am putting everything mildly. When the Minister took over the Department of Agriculture he issued advertisements in the spring of 1948 and appealed to farmers to produce more, but he never even mentioned wheat. He said that oats, potatoes and barley should be grown and as far as the ordinary person in the country reading the advertisements was concerned, there was never a mention of wheat as if wheat could not be grown in this country. He said nothing about it then but, according to column 2593, Volume 111, of the Dáil debates, he told us:—
"I hold precisely the same views now as I have always held about growing wheat on Irish land in times of peace when supplies are available from other sources. In my judgment it is a `cod' and a waste of land."
He coined a phrase many years ago when he said that wheat growing was a "cod," and he has stuck to it fairly consistently; I would say more consistently than he has been about anything else, although he has not been altogether consistent.
On the 5th May, 1948, he was talking at the Irish Ploughing Association dinner at Clery's. They were all tillage farmers interested in tillage, and the Minister said "wheat growing in peace time is all a `cod."' He sticks to that. The Minister got a bad time, however, in the autumn of 1948. After his advocacy of more potatoes and oats the farmers said to him "what are we going to do with them?" and they got cash for their wheat. So the Minister learned something—it was an expensive education — during 1948, and issued an advertisement on the 19th March, 1949, to the farmers of Ireland, and said "farmers who want a cash crop should grow wheat or malting barley." There was no such thing as wheat in the Minister's imagination in 1948, but he learned a lesson at the expense of the farmers of the country. On August 22nd, 1949, he was veering that way when he went down to speak to Muintir na Tíre at Limerick. He appealed to the parish councils to encourage farmers to grow more wheat next year. He had become almost a wheat convert during 1949, but something happened to the Minister. I suppose he was not altogether convinced that he was on the right road. It was a new departure for the Irish farmer to grow wheat. On February 8th, 1950, he told the Cooley farmers "every barrel of wheat that is grown represents a heavy burden on the Exchequer. I would prefer to see barley and oats."
I wonder would any Deputy opposite be able to tell me from these quotations how the Minister stands with regard to wheat. He says that wheat is all a "cod," and at the same time he says that the farmers should grow wheat. He tells the parish councils of Muintir na Tíre to get all the farmers to grow wheat next year. He wants to make them all "cods." Then he goes to Cooley and tells the farmers that he would rather barley and oats. It is very hard to know how the Minister stands and I suppose that we will not get a clear cut pronouncement on policy when he is winding up. He will probably indulge in one of his wild statements.
Comment on this
The Deputy behind him says that he will give us the works. We know that, of course. It was said by some Deputy the other day that he would not be there if he did not give us the "works," because that is the only quality he has. He must give us the "works" or he will lose his job.
There was evidently a little dispute during the debate as to who it was fixed the present price of 62/6 per barrel for wheat. If any Deputy is industrious enough and anxious enough to find out the truth, although I do not accuse Deputies opposite of that, to look up any of the morning papers of Saturday, 11th October, 1947—I do not see any Deputy opposite taking out his pencil to make a note of it — he will find that an official statement was issued by the Government Information Bureau — Fianna Fáil were the Government at the time and Deputy Smith was Minister for Agriculture — which set out the intentions of the Government for the following year with regard to tillage. It stated that the Government would make a tillage Order and set out the percentages and then went on, under the heading "Price of Wheat":—
"The Government have furthermore decided, in the case of growers of wheat of the 1948 crop, to guarantee a price of 62/6 a barrel of 20 stones for wheat of the first grade."
I do not want any Deputy to make one of these debating points that it was only an announcement and was not an Order. The announcements with regard to tillage and prices were made every year in September or October. I am glad I have made the Minister laugh, because I nearly made him cry last week. They were always announced in September or October and the Orders were then prepared and issued, so that there is not much to be made out of that.
Comment on this
The Minister came in here and fixed a five years' guarantee and we were all very glad he did so, although a few days after he described it as all "cod".
The Minister talks about getting in more wheat from a lesser acreage. Quite possibly, that was so in 1949, but any farmer will tell you that that year was the most favourable year for wheat since 1933. I hope it will continue, but factors like these must be taken into consideration before we come to conclusions. For instance, last year the yield of oats was lower than in 1948, but we are still not going to say that on account of aphosphorosis we will never get oats grown again. It was due to the fact that the weather did not suit the oats crop, and in all probability the yield will be up again this year, or if not, next year. We are not going to lose heart and say: "You must not sow any more oats because the yield was down last year."
As we are on the subject of oats I want to say that on February 28th, 1948, the Minister issued an advertisement:—
"Grow more oats. Every farmer should increase his acreage of oats this year. Oats not required on the farm commands a remunerative price."
Has any Deputy opposite any doubt about what that means, because the Minister will try to create a doubt as to what it means? When the Minister said in that advertisement: "Any oats not required on the farm will command a remunerative price," would any farmer not read into that that if it is not required on the farm he could sell it and get a remunerative price? The Minister will try to bamboozle Deputies about that and to say that he meant them to walk it off the farm, but I think it was plain enough. On 20th March he said:—
"Sow from one to five extra acres of oats or barley,"
and he issued the famous advertisement to which I have often referred— a most offensive advertisement, a most political and partisan advertisement issued by the Minister and paid for by the taxpayers—in which he said:—
"Let's show them. Let us show them; let us, the Minister and his friends, show what we are going to do"
— and we had to pay for it. He did not do that since. I suppose he was sorry for it, and we will leave it at that.
The year went on and the farmers sowed their oats on the guarantee that they would get a remunerative market, if they did not require the oats for poultry, cattle and so on. The oats was an excellent crop and farmers had oats to spare. They thought they would have no trouble whatever — there was a remunerative market in Great Britain for everything they could produce — but they found to their great consternation that nobody would buy oats and naturally they began suggesting things to the Minister, suggesting that he should take the oats off their hands and should make some provision for this surplus oats. On 17th September the Minister, at Waterford Agricultural Show, said he would not advise the Government to fix a minimum price for oats. Why? Because the remunerative market was not there. On 15th October, he told a deputation of the grain growers' committee of the beet growers' association that he would not have a price fixed for oats. He was very determined that he would do nothing about fixing the price of oats, but something occurred which the Minister did not expect — a by-election in East Donegal. Oats is a very important consideration in East Donegal.
The Minister went to America and the Minister for Defence was acting for him, and on 11th November the Minister for Defence said here that, though reluctant, he hoped to arrange "that oats will be bought in quantity at a reasonable price". On 26th November he told the Dáil that oats would be purchased through Messrs. Grain Importers, Limited, at 28/- per barrel in good sound condition, bushelling 40.
The farmers got their market, but I wonder did any of them call it a remunerative market. I wonder did any farmer then recollect what the Minister said when he came back from England, that we had a remunerative market in England for everything the land of Ireland could produce for four years certainly and maybe for more. As I said, when the Minister came to issue his advertisement in the spring of 1949, he said: "If you want a cash crop, grow wheat or malting barley". He no longer said that there would be a remunerative price for oats if it was not wanted on the farm. He had learned his lesson and he had learned it at the expense of the farmers. He said in that advertisement that there would be no control whatever on the prices of oats or barley of the 1949 crop. He made it very clear in 1949 that he was not going to be responsible for the price of oats. There was no "let's show them" that time. There was no talk of a remunerative market for any oats that would be to spare.
On 26th March, in Scotstown, the Minister made this very wise statement to farmers, that there was no Government in the world that could guarantee its farmers an immediate cash market for their entire crop. He was coming to learn things. The result was, of course, that the acreage of oats went down by 200,000 acres in 1949, due entirely to the optimistic promises of the Minister, optimistic promises that were made in a political way, in the spirit of "Let's show them", "Let's show them that the farmers of this country would prefer to grow barley or oats than to grow wheat". Then, when he did show them, the farmers could not sell the oats and the acreage of oats went down. What was the result? With the acreage down, the yield was also down. It was a bad year for oats. The result was that, during this last winter, the Minister had to search the world and had to go as far as the Argentine to get oats. It was an extraordinary thing that a Minister for Agriculture in this country should have to look around the world for oats. That was the result of his policy.
In the advertisement which I have mentioned, in 1948, the Minister appealed to farmers to grow more potatoes. When he came back from England, having signed an agreement with the British Government, I think the only criticism he offered of the agreement was that it did not give us a very attractive price for potatoes. When he mentioned the price for potatoes, he said, "None of us would grow rich on that". Even though it was not attractive, he said there was an unlimited market at a remunerative price. In any event, it had the same history, practically, as oats. Farmers did grow more potatoes in 1948. It was a very favourable year. We had an extraordinarily good crop of potatoes and then the farmers found that they could not sell them. They could not see how the Minister could justify his promise to them that there would be a remunerative price for anything they did not use on the farm. The Minister, when he came back from England in 1948, was exuberant about the great agreement he had made and the big money we would get for all our produce and said that £10 13s. 6d. a ton was nothing to boast about for potatoes but, when the potatoes could not be sold, during the winter of 1948-49, on the 23rd February, 1949, he spoke about the price of potatoes being satisfactory. Deputy Aiken asked, "What is the satisfactory price which the Minister has now promised to the farmers if they hold on to their potatoes?" He was advising them to hold on to them a little longer. The Minister replied that farmers had been getting 6/- to 8/- a cwt. for them. It was a boast that they were getting 6/-to 8/- a cwt., although, in his exuberant mood on his return from England having signed the agreement with the British Government, he said that £10 13s. 6d. was not going to make anybody rich.
Comment on this
It is something that the Minister wants to fob off the farmers with in regard to the promises he made.
Comment on this
I defy the Minister to go through his statements in 1948 and show me where "f.o.b." is.
Comment on this
It was held out to the farmers in 1948 as a price for potatoes. There was nothing about f.o.b. Now it is f.o.b. In 1949 the acreage of potatoes, just like the acreage of oats, went down. What else could the farmers do? Again, just as in the case of oats, the Minister had to search around the world for potatoes. He had to search for 50,000 tons for Great Britain. The result, of course, was a scarcity of potatoes at home. The Minister had undertaken to give 50,000 tons of potatoes to Great Britain. We are told now that it was f.o.b. He had considerable difficulty in getting them.
The first reference that I see to the filling of this contract was in the Dáil at Question Time on 25th April, 1950. The Minister was absent for some reason, and the Parliamentary Secretary, Mr. Corish, answered the question. After a long answer, Deputy Aiken asked a supplementary question:—
"Will the Parliamentary Secretary say on what date must the contract be completed?
Mr. Corish: The 15th May.
Mr. Aiken: Will he also answer the point in the question about what steps have been taken to secure supplies from outside sources?
Mr. Corish: I think the Minister on another occassion some two or three weeks ago indicated that efforts had been made to get potatoes from other countries to fulfil this contract.
Mr. Aiken: Where will they get them?
Mr. Corish: On the Continent.
Mr. Aiken: Anywhere else besides the Continent?
Mr. Corish: Not that I am aware of."
Comment on this
I want to be just to the Parliamentary Secretary and to say that he did ring up Deputy Aiken after this answer was given to say that he was not altogether correct. He said that there were potatoes got besides those got on the Continent, but that they were searching for them at that moment.
We went on filling this contract with the British. On 2nd May, 1950, the Minister for Agriculture was answering a question put down by Deputy McGrath.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith asked as follows:—
"Mr. Smith: When is it hoped to complete the contract?
Mr. Dillon: The final date prescribed in the contract is 15th May.
Mr. Smith: What are the prospects of completion before that date?
Mr. Dillon: The contract must be completed before that date.
Mr. Smith: What are the prospects?
Mr. Dillon: There is no prospect. There is a certainty.
Mr. Smith: From what sources will the contract be completed?"
The Minister said he would prefer if the Deputy would not bring forward that question.
Comment on this
The Minister pointed out that he could not say at that stage, before he fixed the price. What I want to stress is that when he was asked about the prospects of completion he said: "There is a certainty". It is one of the Minister's certainties.
He issued a White Paper to give us information before this debate started and he told us that 24,000 tons had gone to Great Britain, not 50,000 tons. Perhaps the Minister will reconcile that when he is concluding and say what he meant by a certainty, as it does not appear to me to fit in with the facts given. In this searching around for potatoes to fill the contract to Great Britain, as might be expected, there was a scarcity created here at home and the price of potatoes for some time went up very high on the consumer, higher than has been known here for many a long day. When the Minister was asked about this, what he was doing about the consumer, he gave a typical Coalition Government reply:—
"Mr. Dillon: My information is that consumers can secure supplies of potatoes at 2/6 pretty generally."
Not every Deputy in the House can agree with that.
"Mr. Dillon: It is not my duty to command housewives in this city where they are to buy their potatoes... My duty was to see that there would be at least one centre where potatoes would be available at a price which was reasonable and which was within the housewives' capacity to pay. I think that has been achieved."
That is given in column 7, Volume 121, No. 1, of the Official Debates. I think that is a typical Coalition reply. It is the type of reply which says: "Well, if you have not got bacon, eat pig's cheek, which is cheap"— as if we were going to breed pigs with all heads and nothing else. He means: "If you want cheap potatoes, go to one certain market in the City of Dublin and you will get them". That is just the greatest camouflage. It is nonsense to think that the people of this city can go to one market and that because the Minister was able to get the potatoes supplied to a certain group of people and they were able to sell a certain quantity at a certain price he had done his job. I can leave it at that by saying that it is a typical Coalition Government way of doing things.
The Minister said, in his talk of this agreement, that in the first year the British were to take 50,000 tons. I am stating what happended in the second year, 1949, when they took 24,000 tons out of 50,000 tons. He said that after the first year they would take as much potatos as we liked to contract for. How much have we contracted for and is it intended that we should try to increase our acreage in order to supply more potatoes to Great Britain? We would also need to search this f.o.b. business. The unlimited market at unlimited prices has so far failed that one is inclined to ask whether it still holds. We may come to that when we go through all the items.
When dealing with the question of root seeds, the Minister said it was in the hands of racketeers. What he meant to convey, as far as I can see, was that the merchants who were getting the farmers to grow these seeds were racketeers. As I said at the beginning, when the Minister was not here—I would like to say it to him openly, as I do not like to say things behind his back that I would not say to his face—he should be more careful about calling people racketeers and rogues, unless he is more sure of his facts, as he is sure to be found out in the end. Regarding these root seeds grown in Ireland, it would appear—and the Minister has never attempted to contradict these figure as, of course, he could not—that the merchants who organised these things were not racketeers, by any means. Take 1948 and 1949. I dealt before in this House at the end of the last session, last summer, with the position up to that time and do not want to repeat it. The position is much the same. The English grower was getting 120/- a cwt. for turnip seeds and Swede seeds. The Irish grower was getting 150/- in 1948 and 160/- in 1949, but as far as the retail prices are concerned in this country they were both sold for the same price, both Irish seed and English seed.
Comment on this
3/3. Here you have a position where seed was sold for 3/3 by the retailer, the man who sells the seed in the country shop to the farmer The English grower only got 1/1, the Irish grower got 1/4 or 1/5—it depends on the year—so that, at any rate, the racketeers, the people between the grower and sower, got less out of Irish seed than out of English seed. I am inclined to think that the racketeers, that is, the importers of seeds, the wholeselers and retailers, who are racketeers, would more naturally try to get English seed than Irish seed. The Minister should not come here and talk about racketeers unless he knows the facts—or if he does know the facts he should stick to them and not talk about racketeers to get out of it in that way. That was a nice little bit of business for the grower of seed.
Comment on this
It has been practically killed by the Minister and I suppose he is proud of his job. In may, 1949, he notified the companies who were operating this home-grown seed that he was opening the ports from December, 1949. The redult is that the Irish growers this year are offered 120/- and 116/- per cwt. The only result of what the Minister has done is that for the future the Irish grower will get 4d. a lb. less for his seed than he got last year.
Comment on this
The farmer will be paying the same, but the retailer who his selling over the counter to the farmer will get the difference of 4d. and the sower of the seed will get the same. Therefore, the Minister's action amounts to this: he his going to take 4d. a lb. off every lb. grawn by a farmer in this country and put it into the pocket of a wholesaler or a retailer.
Comment on this
Yes, and on a farm at Johnstown Castle, County Wexford, run by the Department of Agriculture, experiments which were made in 1949 with English seed, Danish seed, Irish seed and so forth proved that the Irish seed was by far the best. Therefore, there is nothing but absolute prejudice behind this thing. The Minister promised, the last time we were talking about this matter, a scheme for the growing of pedigree Swede seed. He has forgotten his promise in connection with aphosphorosis.
Comment on this
I want to know when it is going to take place. There is no point in talking about it unless the Minister is going to take some action. Another crop which is not very well liked by the Minister is the tomato crop.
Comment on this
He regards tomatoes as an exotic crop. Tomatoes are a fairly important industry in this country. One thousand persons are employed in connection with it—more than in very many of our big industries in this country.
Comment on this
I do not know. The Miniter says sometimes—in his saner moments—that there should be no sudden or violent change in agricultural policy. He is right. Sudden or violent changes in agricultural policy have very disturbing effects on people whho engage in a certain line of agriculture and who have put their money into it. Further, they have very discouring effects on any group of farmers who might be inclined to try a new line of agriculture in order to make money. However, although the Minister sometimes lays down these very good principles that there should be no sudden or violent changes in agricultural policy he does not always abide by them. If I am not mistaken, he said on practically the first day he became the Minister for Agriculture that he was going to do away with the Gaeltacht glsshouse scheme. Than the trouble started. Some of the Deputies setting behind him did not like the idea so he changed his mind. He yielded, as he usually does, to pressure of that kind and the Gaeltacht glasshouse scheme was allowed to proceed. The Minister, in connection with the tomato industry, talked about racketeers in this country. The tomato growers say that find it very difficult to understand why it is that Dutch tomatoes can be landed in this country at about 1/2½ per lb. and be sold at 1/4 per lb. while Irish tomatoes which are sold on the market—as they were sold in the early part of last week —at 1/6 to 1/9 a lb. are retailed in the shops at 2/6 a lb. The Dutch tomatoes were 1/2½ a lb. at the port and the Irish tomatoes were 1/6 to 1/9 a lb. on the market. It does not appear to me to be an unfair difference considering the quality of Irish tomatoes compared with that of imported tomatoes. It would appear, however, that the selling margin, and so forth, is very much higher in respect of Irish tomatoes compared with that of tomatoes imported from the continent. Would it not be well for for the Minister to bring his attention to bear on that aspect of the matter and find out who the racketeers are?
Comment on this
Wobble, wobble, wobble. Wobble to and fro. Stop wobbling now and come down on one side or the other.
Comment on this
Will the Minister please listen to me? The tomato growers are not racketeers. Let the Minister find out, after that, whether there are any racketeers.
Comment on this
The Minister must let off steam now and again. I come now to the subject of maize. At Portumna in September, 1949, and at Mountbellew a week later, the Minnister said that there would be no increase in the price of maize. I ask the members of this House to keep that statement by the Minister in mind. He said: "I am the Minister in charge of maize. I can tell you that the price of maize will not advance by one farthing in foreseeable time." The Minister has a language of his own. I do not know what he meant by "foreseeable time". If the Minister was not able to foresee the few months that elapsed between the time he made that statement and the time of the increase in the price of maize then he is not a man of great foresight and he is hardly a suitable man to be in charge of the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
That is what is worrying you—you are not Minister. You were a failure when you were Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary is wrong about that. He is all right now—he is behind the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
Not many months after the Minister made that announcement, the price of maize was increased by £4 per ton—and the Minister said that it would not go up in "foreseeable time".
I think that I have accepted the Minister's invitation and answered practically every point. He asked me, in the begining, to deal with the points seriatim. I think I have done that. If I have omitted any point I should be glad if the Minister would remind me.
Comment on this
I come now to the summing up. I am sure that the Deputies opposite will agree, although they will not be allowed to say so, that it is as clear as crystal that the Minister has failed to find a remunerative market for surplus produce.
Comment on this
I want to take it quite clear to Deputy Cowan that I said, when speaking, that it was a very difficult matter and that my criticism of the Minister was that he said he had found it. I know that it is a difficult matter. At column 2607 of the Official Report, 9th July, 1948, the Minister is reported as follows:
"I am in a position to say to the farmers of this country that there is an unlimited market at remunerative prices for cattle, sheep, pigs, butter, cream, cheese, bacon potatoes, bareley and oats, and that the more of them they produce the better we hope prices to be. There is no reservation and no qualification about that. I do not think any Minister for Agriculture in this country has ever been in a position to say that before, or to say to the farmers of this country that will be irrevocably true for at least four years and we hope it may be for a much longer term to come."
That was in the Dáil on July 9th, 1948, column 2607. That is the thing I am finding fault with.
Comment on this
I have accused the Minister of making jokes, but that is the biggest joke of all—he says it is true.
Comment on this
There is not a farmer who will not say the Minister has failed in that—to get a remunerative market for surplus produce. The Minister says it is true. What about duck eggs, oats, farmers' butter, creamery butter, bacon, live pigs—what about everything? Is it not true about everything except cattle, sheep and eggs? There is a market there all right, but is it remunerative?
Comment on this
When we were the Government we were fighting an economic war and the men over there now were fighting with Britain against us and some of them put on blue shirts. We had to resort to desperate measures, but we did win in spite of it all.
Comment on this
There was never a day's peace since the time you first appeared; there was always some kind of a war.
Comment on this
I will sum up by saying that, first of all, the Minister did not find a remunerative market and, secondly, the Minister does not know his own mind. He is always changing his mind. At one moment he will say oats is a cash crop and the next moment he will tell you there is no one in the world who could fix a price for oats. One day wheat is a cod and the next day he tells the farmers to grow it. How are the unfortunate farmers to know what they are to do? They do not know what the programme is; so far as they can ascertain there is no programme.
He mentioned ten items—cattle, sheep, pigs, butter, cream, cheese, bacon, potatoes, barley and oats. These are the ten items the Minister told us in 1948 we had a remunerative and an unlimited market for. He may be right in three out of the ten, but he is wrong in seven. That represents a 70 per cent. error, and it is not too bad. Looking at the Minister's achievements, I wonder if there was ever a public pronouncement made by any Minister in any Parliment that has proved in two years to be so utterly falsified?
Comment on this
I think that since Joan of Arc was put on trial and condemned to be burned at the stake there was never such a ghoulish exhibition as we witnessed here this evening in this particular debate. I wonder what is our concern here? Are we concerned with driving Deputy Dillon out of public life, or are we concerned with the Department of Agriculture? Listening to Deputy Ryan, who has repeated what was said by Deputy Smith, Deputy Corry and quite a number of other Deputies, the concern seems to be, not for the farmers or agriculture, but to score some type of petty political victory over Deputy Dillon.
This debate, because of the way in which it has been conducted over the past four weeks, is not of much value to the nation. In a period of difficulty such has this, and with world affairs in the way they are, we should be concerned with the future of our agriculture, with agricultural prices, agricultural production and agricultural surpluses. We ought to be concerned with the relationship that exists between the prices our farmers are getting for their produce and what consumers of agricultural produce have to pay for it. But all that is forgotten we have, instead, a rehash of everything that Deputy Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture, has said over a period of two years.
If one reads the statements of statesmen anywhere in the world over the past couple of years, one finds very significant changes in what they say. The world is moving rapidly and things which may appear right to-day may be entirely wrong to-morrow. If one had time to go back 22 years—and quote the to go back 22 years—and quote the thing said by Deputy Ryan, Deputy Smith and other Deputies in those periods, one would find tremendous contradictions.
I would like to see a realistic approach to this very serious problem. If a miracle occurred to-morrow, and if Fianna Fáil were to come back here as the Government——
Comment on this
——and if Deputy Smith were to replace Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture, what would happen? He would be imprisoned and strangled in his own oratory in this debate.
Comment on this
The farmers of the country are responsible people but they are held up here in this debate as being entirely irresponsible, as people who must be led by the nose in regard to everything, who have no minds of their own and who cannot think for themselves. That is how the farmers are being held up to us in this debate. I think the farmer is the shrewdest, the most sensible and the most solid person in the whole comnnity. What we ought to be doing here is to concern ourselves with the future that is facing the farmer. It sounds ludicrous and ridiculous to have Deputy Dr. Ryan talking about potato surpluses, and asking why we were not able to fulfil a contract when it is well known that America had such a surplus of potatoes last year and this year that she was giving them away free. The Candian Government had to step in and prevent free potatoes being sent into Canada by the United States of America.
The general opinion all over the world seems to be that we are facing a time of serious agricultural surpluses in many commodities, particularly in butter and in cheese. If we are going to have surpluses in these commodities, what is the position of our farmers going to be? Are they still going to get their high prices abroad, or are they to face the crash in a world crisis? I think that is a serious aspect of this problem that might get the consideration of this House for a little time. That is far more inpertant than what the Minister said two years ago, what he said a year ago, or what he has said recently. The Fianna Fáil Party have always been considered to be a Party of astute politicians. Perhaps they are playing a good political card in this, but is it fair to our farmers to play that type of political card while the farmers are facing this very serions situation? Fianna Fáil speakers have been peddling petty Party politics all over this House. In the concluding stages of this debate, I would ask Deputies to get back to the realities and to the dangers that face us, and to face up to those problem. Let each and every one of us do his best to deal with the serions crisis that may be upon us in the very near future.
That is all I have to say. I am thoroughly ashamed of the way in which pubilc time has been wasted during four weeks on this particular Estaimate, bringing us right into the month of July while there is still months of work waiting to be done. Everything that has been stated on the far side, or that could have been said by way of criticism of the Minister's Estimate, was said in six hours by Deputy Smith. I suggest, in the intersts of the nation, that criticism of the Minister might have been left to that speech.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan has talked of the way in which speakers on this side of the House have spoken. He said they had indieated that they regarded farmers as irresponsible people. I think that, if all the speeches made from this side of the House and quite a number of those made from the other side of the House are analysed, it will be found that the irresponsible talk was not attributed to the farmers but to the man who now occupies the position of Minister for Agriculture. It is due to the good sense of the farming communnity that we are in the position in which we find ourselves at the moment. If the farmers had taken the statements of the Minister, since he came into office, at their face value, where would we find ourselves to-day? If they had taken his statements down through the difficult years of the war, and the statements he has made since attaining office in regard, say, to the growing of wheat, at their face value, would we have any wheat grown in the country at this moment?
It is true that the acreage under wheat has decreased to a very great extent during his time in office. In 1948, there were 518,383 acres of wheat grown in the country; in 1949, that acreage had decreased to 362,805, a decrease of 155,578 acres. If we take the latest available figure, namely that for 1949, we find that the acreage in that year is a litle over half the acreage grown in 1945. Surely, it is evident to everybody, and should be very evident to the Minister, that the international situation at the moment is such—it has been so for the past few years—that, instead of having a decreased acreage under wheat, we should be going all out, while there is time, to increase the acreage, and so leave ourselves in the best possible position in the event of war.
The Minister, in 1939, in circumstances somewhat similar to those in which we find ourselves to-day, had this to say in relation to wheat:
"We speak of wheat. The Taoiseach seemed to justify the expenditure of £2,500,000 on the production of wheat on the ground that it provided a guarantee for us against starvation in time of war. Our problem in time of war will be to get food out of the country, even if you ram food down their stomachs with a ramrod? We shall be smothered, stifled and buried in a rotting heap of foodstuffs in the event of war. That is the deadly blow that the enemies of Ireland can deliver against us—to suspend our outgoing traffic. We shall be buying shovels and shovelling food into the sea. With that vast, immense, unconsumable accumulation of food, we are to pay £2,500,000 to protect ourselves against a scarcity of wheat."
He goes on to say: "I lived on oaten bread in my schooldays. I never got wheaten bread from one end of the year to the other and I weigh 14 stone to-day." That was in 1939; possibly he has gone up in weight since then. At any rate, with the oaten bread and his fondness for pig's cheek——
Comment on this
It is from Volume 76, columns 2241 and 2242 of the Official Report. In relation to his living on oaten bread, it would be interesting to know whether or not he still eats only oaten bread. Does his menu consist solely of oaten bread and pig's cheek which he tells us he likes so much? There may be a very good reason for his lauding the qualities of pig's cheek in the light of something that occurred a few months ago. The urban council in Youghal complained that too many pig's cheeks were being included in the diet of the patients in the mental hospital. That was on the 20th March, 1950. In relation to the complaint made at that meeting of the urban council, we had subsequently a statement from Dr. Honan, the resident medical superintendent of Cork Mental Hospital; he stated that pig's cheeks had a peculiarly sooting and curative effect on mental patients. If that is true, then the more pig's cheek the Minister eats the better it will be. To come back to wheat and the policy adopted by the Minister, as far back as 1939, when the war clouds were looming on the horizon, the present Minister did everything he could do discourage wheat growing. Even then he despised wheat growing and thought it was foolish it spend money on the production of that crop. To-day we are faced with a position somewhat similar to that which obtained in 1939. Instead of the Minister encouraging the growing of wheat, we have his contradictory statements, some of which were quoted here this afternoon by a Deputy Dr. Ryan. We have his statement that wheat growing is all cod. We have his statement, when he is anxious to get himself out of a perticular dilemma, that if the farmers want a cash crop they should grow more wheat. In what position will the farmers find themselves with all these contradictory statements? What will the position of the country be if the war develops as it may develop? We will find ourselves in the position in which the present Minister would have liked us to be during the last war, when he advocated that we should join in the war on the side of Britain. If the war spreads, we will join it, not voluntarily but because we shall be forced to join in order to procure enough food to keep ourselves alive.
Comment on this
Deputy Keane cannot allow anybody to make any statement that happens to hit the Coalition Government and its policy.
Comment on this
There is one border I would like the Deputy to cross and it is not the Border he is talking about.
Comment on this
If the Deputy, or any other Deputy, thinks that by interruptions he will——
Comment on this
I will name one thing the Deputy should do, and that is maintain order and not interrupt.
Comment on this
As a result of the present wheat policy, we may find ourselves, should the present war develop in the position of the having to procure food from somewhere. If we are to get that food we know very well the price we shall have to pay for it: the price will be that we shall enter the war on the side of those who will provide that food and we shall pay for it in the blood of our young people. That is the position we are facing. That is the position in which the present Minister would have liked us to be in the last war. Fortunately, because of the foresight of the Government at that time, we did not have to go begging for food and pay for that food with our manhood. It is only because of the common sense of the farming community that we have to-day even the amount of wheat that is grown. If we were to take the Minister's statements at their face value we would go out of wheat and every other tillage crop.
We all remember the Minister's statements in 1948 with regard to oats and potatoes. We all remember the advertisements ending with the phrase "Let us show them." We all remember the promise made that if more oats and potatoes were grown there would be both a market and a good price from them. We all remember the result when the harvest had been gathered. We had a high yield of oats and potatoes and we had a surplus for sale. When it come to selling that surplus there was no market. The Minister scuttled off to America to tell the world and all concerned how they should run their affairs leaving the farming community to get itself out of the muddle in which he had left it. In regard to oats we had eventually a Government purchase scheme. That scheme was a last resort in order to try to stem the tide in regard to votes at the then forthcoming East Donegal by-election. That scheme failed both in regard to the purchase of oats and in regard to the stemming of the tide in that perticular election. The Minister himself gave us the figure of the total tonnage bought under that scheme. Of approximately 794,000 tons of oats in that 1948 crop only about 19,000 tons were purchased under this scheme.
During that election campaign I and a few others advised the farmers to sell as soon as they possibly could because we saw that scheme merely as an election stunt and nothing more. Those who were lucky enough to take our advice sold. Those who did not take our advice were unable to sell after the election. Following on that, the Minister came along and accused Deputy Davern and myself of sabotage. If anyone is guilty of sabotage, it is the Minister for Agriculture. We can remember this strutting Minister's praposals; we can remember the behaviour of this purse-proud saboteur during the war years when he tried to act the quisling and involve us in that war.
Comment on this
I will grow old, as you have done, in time. I am sorry the Minister has seen fit to scuttle out of the House so soon as I commenced to speak. On serveal occasions during the past 18 months the Minister has gone out of his way to accuse me of sabotaging the agricultural policy of his Government. In dealing with that I have refrained during the past six months from referring to these accusations of the Minister in the hope that, if I said nothing, it would follow as night the day that his agricultural policy would progress. I have waited for this opportunity to see of this policy would progress as a result of my keeping quiet. It has not progressed, as we all know, and I take this opportunity of refuting his allegation and of proving that these allegations are untrue. In regard to sabotage, if the use of that world by the Minister is to be allowed in this House, then I accuse the Minister of sabotage and if everything had been, as it should have been, and if the Finna Fáil Government had not been so soft-hearted in regard to then Deputy Dillion's statements during the war, they would have put him behind bars——
Comment on this
I am sorry. I did not regard it as repetition. I was merely finishing what I had begun.
Comment on this
As the result of the Minister's endeavour, as I say, out of 794,000 tons of oats grown in 1948, only 19,000 tons were bought under the Government purchasing scheme. With the exeption of these 19,000 tons, no market was available here or elsewere; right through 1948 and as late as September, 1949, some of the oats were still in storage in this country. As a result of that flop in the oat maket of 1948, it was natural that a decrease should take place in the acreage in 1949. In 1949, there was a reduction of 45,000 acres in the area under oats. Allied to that, we had conditions that were not favourable for that crop and the result was that it became apparent, as the harvest approached, that we would have a very great scarcity of oats during the following season. That was evident to anybody and everybody who wanted to see those thing as early as August, 1949, but the very person who should have seen that situation did not see it and the surplus oats of 1948, which were still in storage in September, 1949, instead of being kept in the country were then shipped out at a loss, to some foreign country. These same oats in storage were bought at approximately £16 per ton and the last lot of them, that I know which left this country, were exported at a price of £15 1s. 6d. f.o.b. They were exported as a late as September, 1949, when it was evident to everybody concerned that there was going to be a scarcity of oats during the following winter of 1949-50. Of course, the Minister carried on in his usual irresponsible manner; he left us with a great shortage of oats after selling the balance of the crop of the previous year when it should have been apparent to him that he should have kept them at home. Then he came along and told us that he was not responsible for the shortage of oats, that Deputy Davern and myself were responsible.
In the case of potatoes, just as in the case of oats, in 1948 we were encouraged to grow all the potatoes we possibly could but, at the end of 1948, when we should have been getting rid of these potatoes, we found that the market promised was not available nor was the price promised available either. Again, we get the Minister coming along telling us later that somebody else was to blame for that situation. After he encouraged the farmers to grow potatoes in the spring of 1948, promising them a market at a remunerative price, we found, when the time for marketing them came around, that the price or the market was not available and the Minister blames somebody else. Can anybody say that that is the record of responsible man? Can we take it as the record of a man with a properly balanced mind or are these statements issued periodically by the Minister to be regarded as the eruptions of an unbalanced mind? That is what I think the farmers generally down the country take the Minister's statements to be. It is in that light they regard these statements and it is just as well for the people of the country that the farmers themselves have that sense which the Minister lacks.
We had, as I say, a decrease in the acreage under potatoes due to the slump in the market, the mismanagement by the Minister and the wrong advice he gave erlier on. In 1949 there was a decrease in the area under potatoes of approximately 35,644 acres with the result that in the winter of 1949, and up to the late spring of 1950, there was a very great scarcity of potatoes in the home market. That home market scarcity was not entirely due to the decrease in acreage. It was due to the decrease in acreage primarily but, allied to that, was the fact that the Minister had contracted to sell 50,000 tons of potatoes to Britain, which quantity according to the latest information I have been able to secure, was never sent. The latest figures I have got show that 24,000 tons out of that 50,000 were shipped to Britain. Those 24,000 tons were being sent out of this country up to the 15th May. Long before the 15th May it should have been evident that there was going to be a scarcity of potatoes, having regard to the decrease in acreage I have mentioned but the Minister took no congnisance of that fact. He wanted to fill that contract with Britain and any means which he could take to fill it were, he felt, justified. Whether or not we were faced with a scarcity or famine for potatoes in the early spring, apparently that was no concern of the Minister. He wanted to send them to Britain, to send them to his old friend John Bull, the only market and the only people to whom he want to sell any Irish produce. If we had a scarcity as we had here in this country, if the people of the cities had to pay famine prices for potatoes a few months ago, you can lay the blame for that state of affairs on the Minister. He is to blame directly for his action in exporting potatoes to Britain when he knew that these same potatoes would be required at home. In the light of that and of his recored all along the line, can we wonder if tillage as a whole is decreasing year by years since he came into office? It is hard to expect the farmers to till the land and to put in certain specific crops when they have no idea in the world, and no guidance upon which they can rely, as to what they are to do with these crops when they are harvested. Taking these things as they are the position would be bad enough, but the Minister is not satisfied with letting the farmers down in regard to prices and in regard to his promises.
He goes further and actually adds insult to injury when he states publicly that the farmers—the small farmers really are the people to whom he referred—who grow crops for cash are people who should not be farmers at all. It is the small farmers as a whole who are the backbone of the agricultural industry and the Minister knows that. Despite all that, he has no regrets, apparently, for anything he may have done to these people. He has no regrets that they may have been at very great loss, due to his ill-advice in 1948 in regard to oats and potatoes. Neither has he any regrets for or apologies to make in regard to his policy in relation to wheat.
In regard to flax, if that crop could be killed, if anybody could kill it or try to kill it, it is the present Minister for Agriculture. On the one hand, we find him going to Britain, where, no doubt, he is a source of great amusement to the people. He is taken as a very good joke there, but, unfortunately, his antics, his actions, and his irresponsible statementes over there, while they may amuse the people in England and abroad and be a good joke for them, are unfortunately a very bad joke for us. In regared to tillage produce, we find that the farmers have been badly let down by the Minister. As to potatoes, so far as the Minister could go, he has given them the hammer. He has also given the growing of oats as a cash crop the hammer. In regard to flax, he told the only buyers we had available to go to blazes. That is the type of Minister one would expect not to get on with very well. The Department of such a Minister could not be expected to progress.
If there is a suggestion made by some people, who like to here themselves talking, that Fianna Fáil is obstructing the work of this House by spending time uselessly talking so long on this Estimate, I would say that, even if that were true, which it is not, it might be no harm if we spent the next six month talking on the Estimate as we know we would not be retarding the progress of the Department of Agriculture or the progress of the Government as a whole, because there is no progress. It would be a good thing if we could retard what we might call the retrogression in the Department of Agriculture and in the policy of the Government generally. As I say, if we were trying to waste time, I think it would be a good job if we kept them here for another six months. But that is not our purpose in talking and repeating the arguments put forward by Deputies on this side of the House. We must of necessity repeat these things, and we repeat them in the hope that, having been repeated often enough, the Minister may take cognisance of the complaients which we have put before him during the past few weeks.
There is one perticular item which I want to touchh upon in more detail and that is the question of potatoes. We have dealt with the 1948 crop and the crash in the marcket after a time. Then we had the decrease in 1949 and the scarcity in the Dublin markets as the result of over-selling to Britain. That is in relation to ware potatoes only For some years past we have had also a very lucrative market in the export of certified seed potatoes. Some few months ago I asked the Minister for Agriculture what quantity of certified seed potatoes was exported as ware potatoes this year. Whether he quibbled at the words I used in the question I am not in a position to say, but "none" was the answer given to the question: in order words, no seed potatoes were exported as ware. As I say, the Minister may have been quibbling with the words when he stated that no certified seed potatoes were exported as were potatoes. If we take that statement on its face value, that no potatoes certified as pure seed potatoes were sold as ware potatoes, then I tell him that that is nature and I am prepared to stand over that.
The seed potato market in my county has been stifled by the Minister. If the industry of exporting certified seed potatoes is done away with and killed completely, than we can lay the blame justy at the door of the Minister. This year we had the rare experience of having a shortage of potatoes in the country. We have seen these potatoes being shipped to Britain, and among the potatoes shipped to Britain were the best of certified varieties going as ware and being paid for at ware prices; while, at the same time, as I pointed out on 16th December last, there was a market available for certain varieties and for a certain specified quantity last November. The reason why that quantity was not sold was because the Minister, his Department, and this newly established marketing board, as it is now kown, refused an export licence for the potatoes when requested by the intending exporter. I brought that matter to the notice of the House on the 16th December but no notice was taken of it. There was, however, no denial of the fact that I gave. I had proof in this House at that time in the shape of correspondence between the potato exporter, the Department and the Potato Marketing Association and it was clearly evident that 2,500 tons of seed potatoes would have been bought in the Donegal area at a very good price, a price that we regarded as very lucrative.
I brought to the notice of the Minister that that request for an export licence for 2,500 tons was refused. I did not then get any reason why it was refused. All we found was that the first attempt to export these potatoes was made by way of a letter to the Department. The Department passed the baby along and referred the intending exporter to the Potato Marketing Association. They did not reply for many weeks and then the reply was that the licence would not be granted.
The potatoes for which this export licence was requested included 1,000 tons of Home Guard certified seed potatoes and the price indicated in the correspondence to the Minister's Department was £12 3s. 4d. per ton. That licence was not granted nor did we ever hear again during the past season, any question of anybody giving £12 3s. 4d. for certified Home Guard seed.
Comment on this
I personally had seed to sell when that licence was requested.
Comment on this
You will find all the particulars of that in the Official Debates for the 16th December, 1949. You, I understand, only arrived back that same day and did not find it convenient to come into the House. I got no information then or since as to why the licence was not granted. The potatoes which could have been sold for £12 3s. 4d. were later exported as ware potatoes at £8 per ton.
We had a statement from the Minister in 1947. I think he was talking about bacon but it does not matter what he was talking about. What matters is the statement he made when he said: "Do not become obsessed with price. Price does not matter a row of pins."
Comment on this
You left off at "it does not matter a row of pins" when your colleague, Deputy Donnellan, said that that was the greatest misstatement you had ever made in your life.
Comment on this
Your colleague finished it for you when he said that it was the greatest misstatement of your career.
Comment on this
"Price does not matter a row of pins". In 1947 price did not matter and since then we have discovered that in relation to most of our exports and most of the produce of our land price does not matter as far as the Minister is concerned.
Comment on this
It did not matter then and it does not matter now.
Comment on this
The Minister says that it is profit and yet he committed himself very definitely that price did not matter one row of pins.
Comment on this
Let us take a statement in the light of all the happenings of the day and even if we take into consideration that it is profit that matters and not price how can the Minister justify his present policy which has resulted in a decrease in the price of eggs while at the same time the price of feeding stuffs has increased rapidly? Where can we find the profit of which the Minister talks? Is it not obvious again that the price did not matter then and does not matter now as far as the Minister is concerned?
Comment on this
The price of eggs has been reduced from 3/- when the Minister took office by 6d. and according to a recent announcement as and from 1951 it will be still further reduced to 2/-.
Comment on this
Do not worry. I am going to continue. I will not leave out the 3/6 part. Later on, in September, we find that we will get 3/6. The Minister suggests that if we are to take the best advantage of the higher price in those months of the winter of next year we must change the laying season of the hens. The Minister has produced some rare birds in his time and I have no doubt that if we gave him time he would produce one that would lay at a completely different season from the others, but until then I cannot see much point in his trotting out the 3/6 price during a period when we will have little or no eggs to export. We have had a reduction in the price of eggs and they will be further reduced to 2/in the very near future.
Comment on this
At that time you will have, as we know to our cost, maize at a very much higher price than when the Minister came in.
Comment on this
The Minister described himself some time ago as "the Miniter for Maize". I would say that he is the amazing Minister for Maize.
Comment on this
I do not mind if it was said 27 times. It is very charitable to use that word to the Minister rather than some of the words that come to our minds very frequently. When we remember the Minister's promise that all the maize we wanted would be available at 20/- a cwt. how can we reconcile that with the present position where the price is 30/-?
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot buy maize at that and the Minister knows it. The Minister always tells us that if you cannot get it at the right price in one place you can go to another place.
Comment on this
If the Deputy puts the money on the table I will be glad to send it to him in the morning.
Comment on this
Still in the business. The amazing Minister for Maize is able to offer to the House maize at £26 a ton.
Comment on this
Grain Importers will sell maize at £26 a ton to any honest citizen in this State at any time.
Comment on this
Apparently there are not any honest citizens in this State.
Comment on this
There are not. They are all out of step with our Jimmy. We have a reduction in the price of eggs and poultry and an increase in the price of the commodities on which we feed those birds, and yet we are supposed to be satisfied and feel that we are doing very well. The price still, in the Minister's estimation, does not matter. It does matter of course to those poultry keepers who are producing these birds and who, on the Minister's advice, got into that business in the first instance.
Comment on this
Would the Minister be referring to the promises he made with regard to the rehabilitation scheme in Donegal when he said that he was going to make plains out of the mountains of that country?
Comment on this
That is something of the substance of what the Minister said. We were going to have green grass all over the county. "As level as the plains of Meath" were the Minister's words at that time.
Comment on this
The rocks, the hills and the mountains are still there and they will be there after the Minister has gone.
Comment on this
According to the Minister those mountains were going to be shifted. They were going to be pushed into the Atlantic.
Comment on this
Like many statements of the Minister we cannot take them seriously, but it is a pity if we are held up to ridicule on account of them. If you have no sense of responsibility towards yourself you should have some sense of responsibility to the people of the country.
Comment on this
The Deputy would be better off to go to Killybegs rather than sniffing around Carrigart.
Comment on this
If the Minister wants to refer to that I will stand over it. I am not ashamed of anything I do like you are.