Committee on Finance. - Vote 27 — Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 176–352 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
If Deputy Keane wants to make a statement he will make it irrespective of what Deputy Blaney thinks.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Keane wish to make a speech? If he does, he may do so.
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not cease interrupting, he may not have the opportunity of making a speech.
Comment on this
We have this statement by the Minister in 1947 about price not really making any great difference to anyone.
Comment on this
We have, at the same time, the Minister saying in Volume 106, column 2048 of the Official Debates:
"This much is plain to see, we sell our agricultural surplus on the British market or we do not sell it at all."
Both these things the Minister has proved to be true since he came into office. We either sell to Britain or we do not sell at all, and, from my experience, it is mainly the latter that affects most of our people—we do not sell at all. We let our potatoes and oats go to loss and we feed rats throughout the country, all descriptions of rats, with this surplus produce of the land, this produce for which, the Minister would tell us, we could have an unlimited market with his good friends in Britain.
If there was ever a Minister who has been made a "cod" of, surely it is our present Minister, in his negotiations with these people. It is really lamentable to see how our Minister bears himself when he goes across to Britain to deal with business people and, as he thinks himself, in a businesslike way. He goes across and utters such statements as the statement about drowning them in eggs. He was almost tempted into telling them recently that we were going to bury them in bacon. Other businesslike statements of his include: "We want to sell to Britain. We are not going to charge them a scarcity price. We would rather sell to them than to anybody else, even though we have less for our produce." That, surely, is the proper lead up to any negotiations with another country when we are endeavouring to sell our produce—telling them that we want to sell to them and do not want to sell to anybody else, and that their money is better to us than anybody else's. Is it any wonder, then, that the markets and prices the Minister talks of are not available? Is it any wonder that we find, as we have found during the past few years, every farmer, and particularly the small farmers, who depend on the cash crops, oats, potatoes and flax, brought to their knees by this Minister's policy? Yet, as I have said, the Minister wants to put the blame on the shoulders of someone else. He describes in very eloquent terms at different times how Deputy Davern and I have sabotaged the agricultural policy of the country, but he forgets his own sabotage during his term of office and during the last war, when he wanted us to go in on the side of Britain.
Comment on this
The Deputy was twice warned that that has nothing to do with this debate. If he repeats it, he will have to desist from speaking.
Comment on this
Is it the question of sabotage or the question of the time it relates to that is out of order?
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is quite clear. It has nothing to do with this Estimate. If the Deputy remembers that he is discussing an Estimate, he will be quite clear about what is in order.
Comment on this
I am quite clear in that regard, but I want to be sure whether it is the use of the term "sabotage" that is out of order or the time it relates to. The word "sabotage" has been used on several occasions in relation to myself and Deputy Davern.
Comment on this
I did not rule it out of order, but the Deputy's references to events of seven years ago are out of order.
Comment on this
I am not going to argue with the Deputy. These references are out of order. If they are repeated, the Deputy will have to resume his seat.
Comment on this
To come back to the question of sabotage in more recent times than seven years ago, we remember that the Minister is the only person responsible for sabotage either at present or during the past few years. It is by his policy, or his lack of policy, his contradictory statements, encouragements and advertisements that he is sabotaging the country. He is sabotaging it to such an extent that we have a reduction in the acreage of tillage all round. We have a reduction in the acreage under oats and under potatoes, and, more important, we have a vast reduction in the acreage under wheat. Flax has gone off the market completely. The sabotage is on the Minister's part and it is surely something in respect of which the Minister, who regards himself a big man, should not stoop to endeavouring to push the blame over for the failure of this crop or the failure of the market for that crop on to somebody else, when he and everybody concerned know that he is the man responsible.
Comment on this
The only reason I refer again to the Minister's sabotage of seven years ago is that he was not here when I referred to it first. I ask the pardon of the Chair for bringing it up again, but I wanted the Minister to hear it personally. He scuttled out of the House as soon as I rose, because I suppose he knew what was coming.
Comment on this
The Minister should have a look at himself in a mirror once in a while and he would not turn his back if he saw me coming along. I would be a relief to him. There is another place in the city where he could see something like himself and I will not tell him where it is.
There was on the Minister's side of the House one Deputy, Deputy P. D. Lehane, who took a stand on behalf of Deputy Davern and myself and I thank him for doing so, when he said: "I do not agree with the Minister in blaming Deputy Davern and Deputy Blaney about the shortage of potatoes and oats. I think the Minister has a certain responsibility in that regard himself."
I thank Deputy Lehane for that and the Minister should take to heart the fact that Deputy Lehane thinks the Minister has some responsibility. All the criticism is not coming from this side of the House. One might excuse the Minister for the wanderings of his mind, but we then had the spectacle of that brainless colossus from West Cork getting up to back up the Minister, as if the Minister was not able to look after himself. At column 2177 of Volume 121 of the Official Debates, we find Deputy Seán Collins saying:—
"We have heard denunciations of certain foreign purchases made during last year, but it is time Fianna Fáil realised that every constructive effort made by the Minister to encourage the growth of cereals was sabotaged by them. My memory is not so short as to forget the East Donegal by-election when the yowl and howl went through the country about oats, and some of the farmers who adhered to the advice of that strutting little Deputy from East Donegal, and listened to the loudvoiced condemnations of Deputy Davern, were very glad to get back their oats at an increased price."
So much for the contribution of our flower exhibitor from West Cork. It is a contribution he should be proud of. In the first instance, he does not know what he is talking about, apparently, but takes his line from the Front Bench Minister. He goes on to talk about oats and the farmers, after selling them, on my advice, buying them back at an enhanced price. He does not know what he is talking about. With that, we will leave him to try to find a way to get around it later on.
I should like to read to the Minister part of an editorial from the Derry Journal. I am sure he will enjoy it. The Derry Journal is a paper that is not concerned primarily with the politics of the Twenty-Six Counties.
Comment on this
We do not want to hear an editorial because the Minister is not responsible for editorials.
Comment on this
I will try to give the substance of it without reading it. This editorial would express the views of people whom we may not regard——
Comment on this
What I was trying to give is something that would be regarded as unbiassed.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, I have to leave that face down. The general summing up of the people in the country, particularly of the farmers in the Twenty-Six Counties, and also in the Six Counties, is that this Minister is a complete catastrophe. These people, who are not really interested from day to day in our politics, but who are interested in the welfare of our country, which is their country also, can see in the Minister's policy something which is leading the country to destruction and, as they suggest, if the Minister is left long enough in office, he will completely destroy the country as a whole. He will destroy anything and everything that is worth having in this country and we will go back to the state, which I have no doubt will be a pleasant state to the Minister, of being the garden for Great Britain and for feeding the people of Great Britain, where we will grow grass, long and short, feed cattle for John Bull, and export the cattle with our young men and women.
During Deputy Davern's speech last week, the Minister had occasion to contradict me as to the number of persons who had left the land.
Comment on this
Thirty thousand in the two years ended December last.
Comment on this
Eighteen thousand people left this country in 1949, according to official statistics, and in the previous year, according to the same statistics, 12,000 people left. That is a total of 30,000 in those two years, and God knows how many have left since last December. The record is that 30,000 have left the country over the past two years. Do not forget to compare that figure with the incoming balance in the last year of Fianna Fáil, 1947, when 11,000 more came in than went out. In the two years up to December last, 30,000 went out. I want to re-educate the Minister on those figures which were issued by a Government Department.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation. I have addressed a letter to the newspapers in regard to the statement I made because I have a reputation in this House for accuracy in statistics. The Minister, I hope, will find pleasure when he reads my letter.
Comment on this
I would sum up by saying that, in present circumstances, it is unfortunate for this country that we should have such an irresponsible man in the office of Minister for Agriculture as Mr. Dillon. We are faced with the possibility of a world war and I think it is true to say that of all people in this country the least suited to the position of Minister for Agriculture at the present time, or at any time, but more especially in time of war, is the present occupant of that position. It is really a catastrophe that we should have the present Minister in the position he now holds but it would be a greater catastrophe should the war develop. It is all very well for the Minister to make all sorts of promises and to break them. That might be got over in peace time and farmers might use their own common sense in substitution for the ill-advice and nonsensical statements made by the Minister in relation to what they should or should not grow but, in time of war or emergency, we should have in the Department of Agriculture, above all other Departments, a responsible, sane, sound and balanced individual as Minister. We have not got that and that is something to be deplored.
Down the country to-day one will find people, even those most bitterly opposed to us, who will agree on one thing, if they will not agree on any other, that the Minister is a calamity and a catastrophe and that the sooner we get rid of him the better for all concerned.
I would apply to this Minister his own words when he was speaking on the Estimate for Agriculture in 1947. They could not be applied more truly than to the Minister who uttered them when he was Deputy Dillon. He said, in concluding his speech: "I congratulate the Minister for Agriculture on nothing. I think he and his Party are a catastrophe. I think that so long as he is there we will get nowhere." These are the Minister's own words in 1947. Never were they more true than they are to-day of himself. He is a catastrophe and so long as he remains there not only will we get nowhere but the chances are that we will go backwards instead of forwards. We have this Minister who, in his young days, lived on oaten bread and never eat wheaten bread. He may have had reason then, as now, for not eating wheaten bread. In 1947—Volume 106, column 2050 of the Dáil Debates—referring to bread and Irish wheat, he said:
"Before you ate it you had to hold it out in your hands, squeeze the water out of it, then tease it out and make up your mind whether it was a handful of boot polish or a handful of bread. If it was boot polish, you put it on your boots or shoes and if it was bread, you tried to masticate it if you were fit."
Such were the rumblings of this irresponsible Minister in 1947. Deputies know the rumblings in 1939, in 1948 and 1949. Unfortunately, we are still listening to them in 1950. Possibly he may have become unsettled with this white flour that he himself imported and, if he has been using this white flour, it might be advisable for him to leave the white flour and the 3/6 butter, popularly known as Dillon's Delight, and go back to the oaten bread of his younger days and the pig's cheek of which he is so fond, the benefits of which are so great, according to good authority.
Comment on this
No. It is really very difficult to dissociate one from the other in particular circumstances.
Comment on this
I would advise the Minister to grow fat on oaten bread and pig's cheek, which is very good for mental cases and it may be good for the country as well.
Comment on this
What is the position with regard to the milk supply in Cork City? I put a question some time ago about it. I am sure the members are tired of hearing about the milk supply in Cork City, but I can assure the Minister that the people in Cork are very tired of what they are getting. Up to the outbreak of war, we had a twice daily supply of milk in Cork, which we are now unable to secure. There was the excuse during the war that they could not do it, that they had not petrol and other things. Since the war ceased, it appears that we will never get again a twice daily delivery. I understand that the Minister is talking about pasteurised milk for Cork and I would like to know what the position is about that. Could he give us any definite date as to when we would be supplied with this pasteurised milk?
Comment on this
The Cork Corporation are supporting it. I have here a circular from the medical officer of health, written. after a conference with the Minister's Department. It says:
"We were informed that the Minister for Agriculture is convinced that pasteurisation must come into effect in the interests of public health. He has been so advised by the Minister for Health. He considers that the formation of a local producers' association to carry out the necessary process would be a very good way of putting it into effect. If this plan fails to materialise, the Minister may consider the advisability of transferring the project to some other public body.
Under the projected scheme producers of highest grade milk will not be required to pasteurise. In this connection we suggested to the departmental representatives that producers of standard milk be given a period of grace in order to qualify for highest grade certificates."
What is the result of this talk?
Comment on this
If the corporation will pass the resolution to-morrow, I will pasteurise on the 1st of January.
Comment on this
The corporation have passed it. I think the Minister is mixing it up with the county council?
Comment on this
Deputy P.D. Lehane knows something about it and the people of Cork want to know about it. Two years ago the Minister was going to drown us with milk. We do not want to be drowned, but want to get good milk to drink.
Comment on this
If Deputy Palmer and others think this is a joke, it is no joke for the people of Cork. If they have not the manners to be orderly, God help the pupils they are teaching.
Comment on this
Maybe. I would certainly learn better manners than the Deputy. Let the Minister tell us when this will come to some finality, when the milk will be pasteurised. As regards the resolution from the corporation, there would be no trouble about that.
Comment on this
They will look into it and if it is only a question of passing a resolution there will be no trouble at all as far as the people in Cork are concerned.
There was another matter brought to my notice by a constituent in Cork, about the new price of eggs. This person informs me that from February 1st, 1951 to September 1st, 1951 when eight out of every ten cases of eggs are exported to Britain the farmer gets only 2/- per dozen, or 6d. per dozen less than in the same months this year. Then in the winter season, from September 1st, 1951 to February 1st, 1952, when eight out of every ten cases are consumed at home, the farmer gets 3/6 per dozen. Therefore, the consumer here will pay from 4/- to 4/6 for his eggs for 21 weeks from September 1st to February 1st, in order to give the farmer what Britain refused to give him. For the past ten years the consumer paid inflated prices for only four or five weeks before Christmas, whereas now he will have to pay inflated prices for 21 weeks. That is a matter which has a bearing on the cost of living, when the public have to pay increased prices for 21 weeks instead of five, the reason being that during that period when eggs are scarce they would be offered 3/6 to send them to England. I do not know if it is because, as the Minister has said, the people in England are the only people in the world acquainted with hunger, that he is so anxious to give them these cheap commodities to-day. In reply to a question some months ago, he said that the curers of bacon here had to pay 40/- a cwt. more for Wiltshire sides than for those sent to England. I probably know as little about agriculture as Deputy Cowan, but I would like the Minister to pay attention to the few points I have made.
Comment on this
Hatred is a very ugly vice. Deputy Blaney is a young man and before he grows much older he ought to awaken to the fact that hatred corrupts the person who hates and not the person hated. It is corrupting him. I suppose as we grow older we lose our capacity to hate. I am not a good hater; it takes too much trouble; but young people would be well advised to avoid the temptation of indulging in the vice. The Fianna Fáil Party—God knows, it is not young, but hoary and experienced as it is in every vice and corruption associated with public life, it should eschew the baseness, the revolting baseness, of personal hatred.
I want to dispose of a couple of trivial matters before turning to the major questions. Out of an estimated crop of 750,000 tons of oats in 1948, 20,000 tons or less were purchased under the oats purchase scheme. A great part of those oats was sold by Deputy Blaney's neighbours at no great price and those same people were short of oats the following autumn. When Deputy Blaney had scraped together the votes to scramble into this House he was willing then to forget what he had indiscreetly revealed. Deputy Blaney forgets that he spoke at Killygordon and he said: "There is also the question of a market for oats"—I am quoting from a report that appeared in that detached and unprejudiced publication, the Derry Journal, 4th March, 1949:—
"There is also the question of a market for oats. We had the promise almost a year ago of members of the Coalition Government of a good market and a good price. That promise was implemented before the by-election began for a short time of buying oats at 2/- a stone. I warned anyone who had oats to sell to sell them before polling day or they would not get them sold at all."
Can you imagine anyone, however degraded, who, in the poorest part of Donegal, would go amongst his own neighbours and exhort them all to rush in with their modest store to Letterkenny, Raphoe, Carndonagh, so that their simultaneous arrival would deliver them into the hands of the oat merchant, that they might get less for their oats than they otherwise would and that, in their resentment for that, or out of it, Deputy Blaney might collect a few paltry votes to scramble into this House where he does not belong?
Comment on this
Let me not forget the contribution, however, that was made by the Demosthenes who has just intervened. Deputy Blaney required an instructor—and he had one. Deputy Davern was a neophyte here then. He did not know the ropes. Up to then he had only been a ward-heeler in the county organisation, but when he graduated in here he was instructed to go out with the rest of them and whisper.
Comment on this
Anyone knowing him could realise that Deputy Davern could not whisper long. He had to open his loud mouth.
Comment on this
"Band yourselves together," said Deputy Davern at Gortnahoe—and Charles Stewart Parnell O'Donnell, who is the honorary corresponding secretary of Gortnahoe, wrote it down for posterity to read—"Band yourselves together. You farmers can save something from the wreck. Demand a proper price for your milk. Carry on your tillage and strive for the Republic."
Comment on this
"That will keep our men at home. That is the type of republic we want. Do not mind promises made by the Minister that end in a bottle of smoke. Sell your oats now. Sell your potatoes now." With Boanerges at one end of the country and Deputy Blaney at the other——
Comment on this
Is it any wonder that the small farmers of this country were crushed between the upper and the nether millstone and suffered a loss? It was a low, mean thing to do. It was a low, mean thing to purchase votes with the hard-earned property of your poor neighbours.
Comment on this
I want to refer to an incident which has since, I understand, become the subject of a letter to the papers. It was rather an alarming incident. The Leader of the Opposition went to Louth some weeks ago and told us that he noted, more in sorrow than in anger, that 55,000 people had left the land. The Leader of the Opposition has a constitutional distaste for making speeches in this House because he does not like being answered. He twice intervened in the debate on this Estimate but on neither occasion in Leinster House—once in Drogheda and once in Cork. When he had wept over the 55,000 who had left the land, the next time he presented himself here I directed his attention to the fact that the 55,000 had left the land in the last six years of his administration. That shook him a bit and the same source that prepared all the little notes for the Fianna Fáil T.D.s in this debate hustled round, and then we began to hear passing references to the 47,000 that had left the land in the last two years. Deputy Childers referred to it last Wednesday in the House and, quite unconscious of any chicanery, I said to Deputy Childers: "Would the Deputy be kind enough to give me the reference?" He said: "I have not got it. It was in answer to a parliamentary question." Shortly afterwards, Deputy Major de Valera came into the House and very politely gave me the reference —and then there did a strange tale unfold. We have figures every year relating to the number of male persons employed upon the land.
Now, when the statistics are in the process of preparation, male persons employed on the land are segregated into two categories, male persons between the ages of 14 and 18 and male persons of 18 and upwards. The figure for the male persons employed on the land which the Leader of the Opposition used in Drogheda or Dundalk related to the total number of male persons employed on the land and were: for 1943, 554,000, for 1944, 526,000, for 1945, 521,000, for 1946, 519,000, for 1947, 507,000 and for 1948, 499,000. It was urgently necessary to rebut the fact that six years of Fianna Fáil had cleared 55,000 off the land. Therefore, the ever-resourceful Deputy Killilea took the field and Deputy Killilea put down a parliamentary question, to ask the Taoiseach if he would state the number of male agricultural workers employed on farms during 1949. However, before the question was put upon the Order Paper for reply, Deputy Killilea got wind of the word that he was not going to get the answer he hoped for. Did this exhaust the resources of Deputy Killilea? It did not. He withdrew the question.
Another very interesting thing happened. Deputy Lynch of Cork sharpened his pencil, but he phrased the question a little differently. He wished to know if the Taoiseach would tell him the number of male agricultural workers over 18 employed on farms during 1949. So, the Taoiseach told him and that figure was 452,500. That was the figure Deputy Childers quoted for me. It was just 30,000 wrong.
Comment on this
That was the figure Deputy Childers's colleagues had been bandying about. That was the figure Deputy Blaney, not realising I had exposed the business in Mullingar last Thursday night, quoted again to-day. You want to get up pretty early in the morning to cross swords with Fianna Fáil because, if they cannot get you fairly, they will get you unfairly, and if they cannot fight you face to face, they will stick you in the back.
Comment on this
The real figure, the comparable figure, for 1949, was 481,824 and the Fianna Fáil figure was 452,500. However, the old dog for the hard road. I will watch them in future and quotations and statistics will always be carefully checked.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Opposition has spent the last three weeks moaning, groaning and caoining about the state of the country. Neither the new Dublin buses nor the banshees could compare with them in their lamentations. I want to ask Deputies, were the farmers ever better off than they are to-day?
Comment on this
Is it not a queer, twisted mind that wants to get up and dree its weird about lamentations, misfortunes and misery and wretcheduess? You can go to any chapel gate in Ireland and ask the question "Were you every better off than you are to-day?" and, thanks be to God, the answer is "Never." But Deputies on that side of the House know that. Do they think our people are fools? Do they imagine our people, knowing their own circumstances, will fail to realise that it is nothing but this bestial hatred of me that makes Fianna Fáil waste three weeks of public time bawling about ghosts and shadows that are not there? They talk about emigration and tell us that the country is bleeding to death, the implication, of course, being that the inter-Party Government opened the arteries.
The Leader of the Opposition had a word to say on this subject in July, 1947. He said:—
"The most important question was that of emigration, but when they had done the best they could the drift from the land to the towns or abroad would continue. There was no other way for it. There has been that steady trend since the famine, and perhaps it was a tendency they could not stop."
That was quoted by the Minister for Finance in the Seanad Official Debates, Volume 38, column 495. What is all this hullabaloo about the population of Ireland melting away? It astonishes me how people can talk themselves into believing almost anything. The population of this country reached its nadir in recent times in 1939, when it was 2,934,000.
That was after the first ten years of Fianna Fáil disaster and, God knows, you would not blame them to go and have one look at Hitler and another look at the then Prime Minister, Mr. de Valera. After some vacillation they chose de Valera in preference to Hitler and they began to come back. In 1940, the figure was 2,958,000; in 1941, 2,961,000. Then the population began to go down. There was emigration to England. In 1944, the figure was 2,444,000. Since 1944 the population has gone steadily up. In 1945, it was 2,954,000; in 1946, 2,963,000; in 1947, 2,972,000; in 1948, 2,978,000, and in 1949, 2,991,000. I will be disappointed if it is not over 3,000,000 for this year. Does any Deputy realise that, instead of the population of Ireland going down, it is going up? I think we have all talked ourselves into the belief that the Irish people were evaporating. They are not. They are going strong, and we are going strong because our people are based on a sound philosophical foundation and, bad and all as this country is, walk the world and see if you will find a better one. I have been all over Europe recently, and I cannot see any better. I have talked to a lot of people who have come to visit this country, and I think they will tell you that there is a great deal worse than Ireland.
Sometimes, when I hear some of my friends and colleagues talk about the wealthy plutocrats who are coming in and buying up the land of Ireland, I say to myself: "People do not make money in the troubled world we are living in, without a good deal of hard, calculated common sense behind them"——
Comment on this
——"and when they have made it—worldly wisdom is certainly one of the necessary prerequisites for making money—they look about the world to find the safest place to store it. It is significant, whether they are welcome or unwelcome, that they want to store it and themselves in Ireland."
Comment on this
We can settle whether we want their permanent residence here or not but, to me, it is a very eloquent comment on the stability and happiness of this country, because it appears to them, after they have surveyed the world, that Ireland is a country where the bulk of the people feel they are equitably dealt with and fairly treated, a country where there are settled stable institutions, because in it there is not fertile soil for the doctrines of disruption and hatred, and because injustice and inequality are not acceptable to any substantial section of the Irish people.
Now, I have considerable sympathy with people who consider that the members of the agricultural industry long for stability and for guaranteed prices, but, before I turn to that, I want to acknowledge, in the presence of Deputy Smith, that he takes valid issue with me when he says that when I had a matter of grave consequence to settle for the farmers of this country, I thought it in no way unbecoming to consult them. Deputy Dr. Ryan, speaking here to-day, said that was a laughable thing—to consult the farmers about the price of milk. I wrote down his words: "That was a laughable thing, to consult the farmers as to whether they preferred 1/- or ½ for milk." What did he expect them to say? Well, I did not think it was laughable, and I do not think it is laughable now. If I had to do it again, I would do exactly what I did. I want to put it in contrast with Deputy Smith's approach to this matter. He also feels that a firm tone is necessary for an honest Minister for Agriculture. When speaking of the farmers, Deputy Smith — speaking at column 2239, Volume 106, of the Official Debates— said:—
"I shall tell you that I had them safely tucked in the back of my mind when I was talking in Navan and if it had not been for the kind of season that Providence decided to send us, I would not have had them tucked in the back of my mind; I would have had inspectors tucked after them, and I would have tucked them out into fresh land, and I would compel them to break fresh land, and if they did not do it I would tuck in the tractors through the ditches and through the gates and tuck out the land for them ... If the Lord Almighty provides us with good weather that will enable us to make a start, and if there should be a necessity next season to be as rigid as heretofore—and there may be—I am going to tell them here and now that I will recruit the full of ten fields of inspectors, and I will spend plenty of money in paying them travelling expenses and everything else, and I will hire all the tractors and machinery I can get and I will go down and pick every one of the `cods' out and I will say: `Take down that piece of wire and put it around the other corner, and just break it up until we see will you get more than four barrels or four and a half barrels' ... When I do that you can call me a thug or a clod or a driver, whatever you like, I do not care. If I am here in the position of Minister, so sure as I have the Almighty to face some day or other, I will end this nonsense. That is my attitude to this question of production. I have heard more of this word `production' since this debate started than I have heard for as long as I can remember. My back is nearly broken listening to it. Maybe I should not say much more. We were talking earlier in the debate about Guinness, but Guinness is never about at the right time."
Comment on this
Very well. I accept the differentiation between Deputy Smith's approach and mine. I think that my approach is the better one. I think my approach produces better results, and I intend to adhere to it.
I have often spoken in this House, in comment, on the desire of Deputies to have guaranteed prices for all the produce produced in Ireland. I pointed out, again and again, that to give such guarantees is possible for a wealthy industrial State in which agricultural production represents a relatively minor part of their national income. Even there it creates a great difficulty. But in a country, 90 per cent. of whose wealth is derived from agriculture, it is just not physically possible. Deputies will ask me why? I will give them the picture of what has transpired in the United States of America consequent on the attempt of the Secretary of Agriculture of the United States Government, Mr. Brannan, to provide guaranteed prices for his own domestic producers. To keep the Commodity Credit Corporation going, the United States Congress last week agreed to add another two million dollars to the 4,700 million dollars it already has. Already the Commodity Credit Corporation has stored up enough wheat and corn to fill a freight train stretching 11,679 miles, half-way around the world at the Equator. It has stored enough cotton to make 90,000,000 bed sheets. It has 880,000,000 eggs in store. It has 99,000,000 lbs. of butter in store and it has enough powdered milk, 316,000,000 lbs., to irrigate the wheaties of all New York City schoolchildren for several years to come. There are also mountains of cheese, soya beans, tobacco, dried fruit and peas, rosin, cotton seeds, meal and other products which no one would buy and which the Government could hardly give away.
Comment on this
The United States of America can afford to find 6,000 million dollars to carry those stocks.
Comment on this
The magazine Time, of June 19th, 1950. Two questions present themselves. What will ultimately become of these stocks of food? And, secondly, supposing Ireland guarantees her farmers, as America has guarantteed her farmers, a remunerative price for any given commodity such as butter, whether or not it can be sold abroad, and she is subsequently unable to sell, what will she do if her store of butter collides with the 99,000,000 lbs. of butter that America has stored in the Caves of Acheson? It is not such a bad thing to have a buyer bespoken, albeit not always at the price that one would like to get, at whatever price one can afford to take when one knows that there are 99,000,000 lbs. of butter, 880,000,000 lbs. of dried eggs and 516,242,531 bushels of wheat and corn in the Caves of Acheson, which may be sold to-morrow morning.
Only six weeks ago the Government of the United States of America was offering potatoes at one cent per bushel in a bag that cost the United States Government 15 cents. Deputy Blaney is displeased with 8/- per cwt. for the modest product of County Donegal. I wonder how he would have felt if the cold blast of competition of the one cent per bushel potatoes in bags that cost 15 cents had been felt in Donegal? Let this House reflect with some satisfaction on the fact that till the 1st of February, 1952, every egg produced here will be sold, and is sold now, for 2d. or 3½d. despite the fact that there are 880,000,000 of them awaiting consumption in the Caves of Acheson.
I want to emphasise again that this House has suffered itself to be sold by Fianna Fáil the fraudulent proposition that the cost of food has raised the cost of living in this country. That is not true. The facts are that the cost of food in this country has absorbed the increase in the cost of living occasioned by the rise in the price of clothing, boots, rent and rates. It is only in the immediately recent past that the reduction in the cost of food has failed completely to cover up the impact of these other charges. So long as I am Minister for Agriculture there will be no successful conspiracy to beat down the prices of our people's products on the ground that they are an occasion of a rise in the cost of living towards which, in fact, they have substantially contributed in order to bring about a reduction.
I am struck by the campaign of Fianna Fáil to frighten our people into a belief that we are on the verge of war and unprepared. Fianna Fáil are willing to would but afraid to strike. They want to make a case that the present Government, because it refuses to subscribe to every panic-mongering carouse that Fianna Fáil encourages, is indifferent to the dangers that exist. This Government has never been under any illusion about the dangers that exist or the precautions requisite to provide against them. If anyone in this country is so foolish as to imagine that the situation in the Korea brings war a day nearer or puts it a day further away, they had better think again. The Cominform will go to war without any Christian excuses, out of no loyalty to friends or satellites, when it is good and ready to go to war. It might go to war to-morrow, it might go to war this day 12 months or this day three years but no fortuitous event, no coincidental occurrence is going to shake its decision as to the time it wants to go to war.
Living in the world we live in, so as long as there are mad beasts of that kind on the prowl, every prudent Government has that present to its mind and acts accordingly but it does not cripple the economy of its own country in terror-stricken panic every time anyone fires a shot. It carries on calmly with its job. What is its job? To insulate our people as fully as possible against any shortage or deprivation that might otherwise come suddenly upon them, in so far as the Department of Agriculture is concerned. What is the first requisite effectively to provide for that? Storage. And what was the position when this Government came into office? Not one square foot of storage for grain had been constructed in this country for 15 years but since this Government came into office, there is increased storage in Limerick, there is 20,000 tons of increased storage building in Cork, there is 16,000 extra tons building in Dublin and 60,000 tons of extra storage is being planned. It cannot be built overnight, but it will all be built and it will be built, not where the grain merchants or millers require; it will be built where our people require.
There is another good place to store food, a good place to store fertilisers and that is the land. There have been more fertilisers and more food in potentia stored in the land of Ireland in the last two years than was stored in the whole 16 disastrous years of Fianna Fáil. Now, the poor creatures, in their desire to find fault, contradict themselves. At one moment the Minister for Agriculture has obliterated wheat and at the next moment the Minister for Agriculture has changed his policy and he loves wheat. I have not changed my mind of one hair's breadth but when we came into office— I have told this to the House before and I make no apology for telling Deputies again—I took counsel with my colleagues and we were all agreed that the true test of democracy is not the size of the Government's majority but the measure of its solicitude for the legitimate desires of the Opposition. I knew that it had become something of a mystique with Fianna Fáil to grow wheat and that judging me by themselves, they expected that when I got into office I would enjoy insulting and affronting them. I said to the Taoiseach that I invited his approval and that of my colleagues for taking a measure right from the beginning to carry conviction to their minds that we had no desire to affront them and that we wanted all of them to know that this Government was their servant, as it was the servant of every citizen of the State, solemnly charged with the responsibility for protecting their legitimate desires as it was to protect the legitimate desires of any other section of the community.
We, therefore, guaranteed a price of 62/6 for wheat for the next five years with this remarkable result. I have read out to the House Deputy Smith's method of persuading the farmers of Ireland to grow wheat and Deputies know the result but last year, on 150,000 acres less land, we got very nearly as much wheat as was threshed after the 1948 harvest. There are not 100,000 barrels between the 350,000 acres sown in wheat last year and the 500,000 acres that were sown in the last year of compulsory tillage. Fianna Fáil's Complaint is that the acreage has shrunk. Is it undesirable to get more wheat out of less land? If it is Fianna Fáil's policy to get less wheat out of more land, I set against that policy our policy to get more wheat out of less land.
I have this strange tale to tell the House. No farmer in Ireland to-day experiences the slightest sense of coercion, yet there will be very nearly 400,000 acres of wheat and there will be very nearly 3,000,000 barrels of wheat. For the first time in recorded history, our people will have grown nearly their total requirements of wheat. Fifteen years of Deputy Smith's inspectors and privateers produced less wheat from more land. Two years of the revolutionary method of treating Irish farmers as though they were intelligent human beings has produced more of that unfortunate cereal than the whole 15 of Deputy Smith's Government.
What gratifies me is this, that not only will there be that remarkable result, which must distress the anxious soul who foresaw our people starving for want of bread, but there will be more cereals grown in this country I hope this year than we have had for many a long day, and I am in a position to face with relative equanimity the prospect, if it must be faced, that we will have no maize at all next year. If we have not, we can get along without it. We will have oats, we will have barley and we will have potatoes I think in sufficient quantity. Should circumstances allow, my aim will be to convert all that into exportable merchandise and then bring in as much more and convert that also. If it is legitimate to import raw materials for any factory in a town or city from the other end of the earth, process them and glory in their export, is it not legitimate for the 500,000 factories represented by the small farmers of Ireland to bring in maize from the Argentine or the United State, process it in the Irish factories and send it out as bacon or pigs or live stock or milk or butter or cheese or chocolate crumb? Need we hang our heads in shame if we exhaust the capacity of our own soil to produce raw materials and multiply our wealth by bringing more to hand, the better to let our people live? I do not believe that our people on the land were destined by God for ever to be poor. They will never be rich, but they have as much right to the amenities of life as any other section of our community, and, if I am to remain Minister for Agriculture, I will see that they will get it.
It never was possible to shake ourselves free of dependence on Indian meal in the past and the reason is simple. We had no cereal to put in its place. You cannot use oats as you use maize and the barley we grew in Ireland, bushel for bushel, was so much dearer than imported maize that our farmers could not have lived if they had access to nothing but Spratt Archer barley and then had to complete in foreign markets where their competitors have access to maize. But we have got new varieties of barley now in Ymer, in Kenya and in Freja. Cautious scientists will forbear from optimistic predicition. I am neither cautions nor a scientist—God forbid I should be either. Therefore, I suggest that we have in these—and I speak from experience, which is very often the master of caution and science—varieties of barley which, on our own land, can produce 50 cwts. to the statute acre and which have produced 62 cwts. Do not take me to say that I anticipate there will be an average all over Ireland of the order of 62 cwts., but I say that there will be an average yield from Ymer and other foods, where land is well cultivated, of between 40 and 50 cwts., and it used to be, with Spratt Archer, 15 to 18 cwts. That is why I say now that we stand on the threshold of a day when, if we have no maize at all, we can contemplate the future with equanimity. But, when we have used all the cereals and all the feeding stuffs we are capable of growing here, I make no apology for saying that I glory in the opportunity of bringing in as much more as money can buy and our people can handle, so that by steadily increasing production we can contribute to the food supply of the world and to the wealth of our own people.
I want to comment in passing on Deputy Boland. I quote from the Roscommon Herald of Saturday, June 17th, which reports Deputy Boland as speaking at Strokestown and, becomingly enough, he founded his oration on the Irish Times. He said:
"During the war we were at least in a position to ensure a fair sized ration of bread from our own wheat and also sugar, and, as a result of the Fianna Fáil Government, we were able to overcome most of our fuel difficulties."
Shades of the Phoenix Park.
"Now, however, thanks to the activities of Mr. James Dillon, we are almost totally dependent on outside sources for our bread and our animal feeding stuffs."
If you are going to tell one there is nothing like telling a whopper, because at no previous stage in the history of Ireland was there ever more wheat in store and growing than there is on this particular day.
Comment on this
I was saying that in Mullingar—that, since I came into office, if any crop grew, it grew by the providence of God in spite of the Minister for Agriculture, but, if any crop failed, well, what could you expect from the Minister for Agriculture? When Deputy Smith was in office, if 1947 came a wet year, everybody said: "We must accept the Will of God." That is the providence of God, of course, but if there was a pet year everybody said: "My God, look at Dr. Ryan; isn't he a wonderful man."
Deputy Dr. Maguire has not yet, surely, got corrupted with the hate of Fianna Fáil?
Comment on this
The Deputy should be incompatible with hate that twists a man's mind, that makes a man say white is black and black is white, and that straight is crooked and crooked straight.
Comment on this
I have spoken of the position relating to the employment of men on the land and Deputy Killilea's intervention helped me to make the story interesting.
I want to say a word about milk. It is wonderful what reference to yesteryear will do. I have been sitting here now for close on 48 hours and short of reading the Koran they have read almost everything else. I am going to read a piece, quite an interesting piece, too. I wonder was Deputy Smith Minister for Agriculture then, in 1946?
Comment on this
It was Deputy Dr. Ryan. He was being very philosophical here to-day. Deputy Dr. Ryan spoke on milk. I am quoting the official minute of the County Committees of Agriculture meeting for Minister Counties, held in Limerick on the 16th January, 1946:
"Dr. Ryan in dealing with points raised in relation to the dairying industry said that prices would be revised for a period of 12 months as from 1st April each year and on the basis of prices of feeding stuffs in the previous calendar year. He had no doubt that a cow would have to be fed better than was indicated in the White Paper but most of our milk is produced off grass and we could not fix prices on the basis that all cows are winter producers. Only 7 per cent. of our milk is produced in winter. Farmers have been content with prices for some time past and their big fear is that there may be a slump. The Department has tried to guarantee them against this. The prices in the White Paper were those submitted to the Government and they had been agreed to without alteration. He added that up to 15 years ago dairy farmers here could compete against the world but then butter prices slumped so low that something had to be done but it was never intended that the subsidy should be a permanent feature. With regard to the present proposals, however, he would like to point out that we may have butter for export later and, if so, and if the export price is lower than the home price, the cost will fall on the State. Continuing, the Minister said that if farmers had now to compete against other countries the price of milk might be as low as 6d."
Comment on this
The report goes on:
"If we were to import butter we might have it at ? per lb. The milk prices suggested by some of the delegates would correspond to a price of 3/- per lb. for butter. He thought that if the facts were placed before the consumers there might be many who would prefer to let the dairying industry go and have butter at ?. Briefly, the position was that the Department was telling farmers that they were not in such a bad position at present and that they were going to try to keep them there."
Comment on this
I understand that the file on which that is recorded took fire in the Registry and burnt—spontaneous combustion.
I went, as Deputies know, to Dungarvan, and greatly shocked Deputy Smith by telling the farmers the situation as I saw it. In discussing milk prices to date I have always laboured under a certain difficulty, because I was sharply challenged on more than one occasion, and from more parts of the House than one, to produce costings. I knew the costings had been prepared and I had seen them but I had never had leave to quote them. Deputy Corry, however, a fortnight ago, produced them. He showed them to the House and said: "These are Professor Murphy's costings and I am going to quote them." And he did. He did not know that I had them on the desk in front of me, too. I said to the Deputy: "When you quote them you accord me leave to quote them, too.""Yes." I thanked him and now I am going to quote them.
The House will remember that Deputy Ryan wisely said that creamery milk, if it is to compete on the markets of the world, must be produced from grass. Quite different is the case of people supplying liquid milk to the city or town where people drink the same quantity of milk every morning with their tea, and you must have a stable supply in December, January, April, May and June. It is quite practicable so to arrange your operations that the bulk of your cattle calve in spring. The bulk of your milk goes to the creamery while the grass is growing and is converted into butter, the cold storage of which presents no formidable problem. Now, with the development of silage, cattle can be carried through the winter without the provision of any purchased feeding stuffs at all for well-made silage now is superior in many cases to oil cake or concentrated compounds. It is certainly true that if Irish dairying is to be a competitor with the rest of the world it must be based on growing grass and silage, for that is what its competitors use. Therefore, it is summer milk that goes to make creamery butter, and when Professor Murphy fell to make his calculations on the cost of producing milk he established that the cost of producing milk in the summer months was 8.82 pence per gallon, if you allow £1 as the value of the calf. If the average yield is 500 gallons and you get £10 for a calf, you get £9 more than Professor Murphy foresaw. Nine times 240 is 2,100 pennies. Five hundred divided into 2,100 is 4d. per gallon.
Allowing an increase in the costs of production of 2d. per gallon—it is excessive but let us allow it—since Dr. Murphy made these costings, and apply the extra 4d., it only costs 6½d. per gallon to produce milk from grass to-day. But let us concede that to strike an average for the whole dairy area of the country of £10 per calf is unduly liberal, and this, I think, can be claimed beyond a shadow of doubt, that the surplus over 8d. in the cost of producing a gallon of milk is so small as to be negligible. It was possible to say to the dairy industry four months ago that, if they would take a minimum price of 290/- for butter, the saving to their own Treasury would in this year be such that, according to every criterion of prudence, it would have been possible to guarantee that that price would be maintained for five years, whatever surplus accrued, because there was no possibility of an annual surplus arising in the course of those five years which could involve an outlay on export subsidy which would charge the Treasury with a sum greater than the subsidy due to be paid this year.
I desperately want to secure for the dairy farmer that degree of insurance. I know of the millions of pounds of butter stored in the United States of America. I know that Germany is exporting butter at certain periods of the year. I know that Holland and Denmark are returning to the export market, and that Switzerland will, as well as New Zealand and Australia, and, as that growing ocean of butter comes upon the markets of the world, the security of our dairy farmers will become more doubtful every day, and the only way we can prevent a situation arising in this country such as I have described as having arisen in the United States of America, is to eliminate the problem of surplus or else limit production. I said in Dungarvan: "If you do not take a long view, all experience teaches that no enterprise ever stands still. It goes forward or it goes back," and I say now that the day our Government fixes a rigid limit of production beyond which the dairy industry may not go, we take our first step on the road that leads to the ultimate ruin of the whole dairy industry. Either the dairy industry goes forward to increased prosperity and productions, expanding production and expanding sale, or it goes back—it cannot stand still.
Will any Deputy say to me that I would be equal to my responsibilities if, faced with the fact that this year's output of the dairy industry will cost the Treasury £3,000,000, and, if it expands as I want to see it expand next year, it will cost £4,000,000 or £5,000,000, I deluded the dairy farmers into believing that a Government can be found who will find £5,000,000 to subsidise them? I know they will not and I tell them now that they will not. The only difference between me and the frauds who tried to avail of their dilemma is that, just as Deputy Blaney was willing to purchase the votes of the people in East Donegal with the property of his own neighbours, so they would hope to clamber back into office by pledging their souls to maintain a price for milk out of the public revenue which they knew in their hearts neither they nor anybody else could do.
We heard Deputy Smith in his opening speech saying: "I will not complain about promises. We all make them and none of us keeps them."
Comment on this
It is very melodious. At column 1960 of Volume 121, No. 14, of the Official Debates, Deputy Smith said:—
"There were some Deputies opposite who had a special interest in milk producers and who had made promises to make not a reduction but an increase in the price of milk. I do not want to talk about promises, as they do not mean anything anyhow."
Comment on this
The Deputy passed on, in the spirit of Burke and Sheridan, and said: "I never make promises myself; I am a performer," to which another Deputy interpolated, "So is a monkey," to which Deputy Smith replied: "The Deputy should go home and feed the cat," and on that note the controversy ended. I do not propose to make any promises and I can perform nothing without the help of the farmers themselves.
Comment on this
The farmers now know what the position is. Neither this Government nor any other Government can find £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 to subsidise butter at the present rates next year.
Comment on this
In my opinion we can secure still five years' stability in the dairy industry on a basis of continued expansion with a market for unlimited quantities in which we shall be able remuneratively to sell the entire output. No other market is of any value to the dairy industry of this country. We have that for the taking if we take it. If the dairy farmers of this country can be misled by those who seek to exploit them, I can do nothing without the dairy farmers. If they run their own industry to destruction, in my despite, I cannot stop them.
Comment on this
They employ me. I work for them. I am not ashamed of that. I think they have a right to dispose of their own industry. Is it not theirs to make or mar and is it not the duty of a Minister for Agriculture to tell them frankly what he can do to help them to make it and how little he can do to prevent them marring it if they want to mar it themselves? I see no indignity. I see no shame in telling the owners of that industry that quite plainly. I disclaim the duty to be their slave-driver. I disclaim the duty to command them. I think it is unbecomeing in a servant to command his master. Deputy Smith might remember that simple precept and his appearance would be more attractive. I believe that with the market, which is expanding, for cheese, chocolate crumb, dried milk, there is a great future for the dairy industry of this country.
Deputy Allen and Deputy Ryan made great play to-day about farmers' butter. Of course, it is a subject about which many Deputies are not much concerned and into which they have not inquired. I wish Deputies knew the facts. There are certain areas in Ireland, notably Wexford, North Clare, South Galway, in which the mixed farming traditionally practised there left a surplus of milk but never sufficient to maintain a creamery industry. That has been the case certainly for the last 20 years. The best contribution Fianna Fáil could make to its solution was to propound a subsidiary scheme, the net result of which was that the dealers in butter made more than they ever made before and Deputy Smith's successor had left to him a cargo of rubbish on the North Wall and, as I told the House before, it took a fire brigade to get next or near it. If Deputy Smith thinks that by putting on a gas mask and travelling to London sitting on top of that butter, he could fool the British butter buyer into believing that that was the evening breeze that was coming up the Thames, he is a greater fool than I think he is. The only hope was to put on Dutch raiment and wooden shoes and pretend it was Lieder Krentz cheese.
Comment on this
Of that junk? I would not export that as butter to Liberia or to my worst enemy. It would poison a dog. We have no reason to apologise for Irish butter. It is the best butter in the world. Let me tell you its history. Why should we disgrace the name of the Irish industry by sending out foul smelling rubbish of that kind and claiming for it the treatment and respect due to good Irish butter? I would not feed that stuff to a dog.
Comment on this
I sent it out under protest to a factory. It was used for lubrication or conversion into a jawbreaker toffee. You can put this stuff through a process of treatment which removes the foul smell. That was not farmers' butter as Deputies know it. The farmers' butter that we know of is the farmers' butter made by 95 per cent. of the women who make farmers' butter and who have a queue of customers from their own neighbourhood standing at their door waiting for the butter to come off the churn. But there is in every community a couple of women who think they can make butter. I know them well. They are decent respectable women but, whenever I see a bit of butter-muslin trailing out of their basket, I fly like the wind because if I will not buy the butter from them I will insult them and if I do buy the butter I will not be able to live in the house with it. They are decent women but they do not know how to make butter and everyone they go to runs out because they see the butter muslin before they see the women. The woman eventually goes to a grocer's shop in the town and gives her order for tea, sugar, meat and whatever else she wants. The grocer makes up his bill. Up comes the butter and he either buys it from her or she leaves him with the parcel of goods and, of course, he buys the butter. Then the firkin is produced and the butter is buried as near the bottom of the firkin as he can put it in the optimistic hope that he will buy some good butter later in the day.
Long experience has taught us that, as the market for farm butter has tended to dwindle, local demand consumes almost all the well-made farm butter. The only farm butter that gets into the Cork butter trade now is second rate stuff.
Comment on this
A good deal of that can be used for confectionery purposes but when you come to the tail end of the second-grade farmers' butter the only thing it can be used for is to provide Deputy Patrick Smith with something to put into cold storage and, unfortunately, me with something to take out of cold store. What is the use of working oneself into a passion, trying to persuade oneself that that product is a desirable product, and economic or a creditable product? It is neither one nor the other, and it is no discredit to anybody, it is simply that the people making it do not know how.
Comment on this
Instead of blabbing and barging at one another across the House as to why, all I know is that the stuff has a smell that is as foul as the devil. I am not interested in wrangling or blathering with Deputy Cogan as to how and why and when. My concern is to provide these women with a profitable place to sell their butter. I am told by Deputy Allen, Deputy Smith and Deputy Cogan that all they can get for the butter is ? a lb. Very well, I am going to provide them with the means to get 2/6 and if the product produces more they will get it and they will have no need to make any more home butter except that which they want in their own house and which their neighbours ask them to make for them. So far as Wexford is concerned, we will try it out, buying that milk from them, not in the regular quantity that would justify a butter creamery but for the manufacture of cheese. In North Clare and South Galway, I am glad to be able to tell the House that we can resolve the problem in another way. By doing a little campaigning and organisation, we have increased the milk supply from North Clare and South Galway to a point which justifies establishing creameries there, and that we are at present in process of doing.
Now, a matter that has been touched upon here—Deputy Davin and Deputy Cogan touched upon it—was credit for farmers. I have tried to inform Deputies very fully of the facilities available to farmers for credit. I am a great believer, however, that if you can meet the wishes of Oireachtas Éireann in consonance with the fundamental policy of the Government, the wishes of Oireachtas Éireann should be met. The view does seem to be held that our farmers live on land which is relatively good but which lacks fertility and that nothing stands between those farmers and the recurrent cycle of prosperous performance but the means to prime the pump. Very well; I am prepared to test that out and under the land project if any farmer in Ireland believes that his land lacks nothing but fertilisers to make it fructify and if he will apply to the Department of Agriculture— the scheme will have to be prepared in detail, but I offer the Dáil the outline of it now—enclosing a fee of 1/- per acre—if he is a ten-acre man, 10/-; if he is a 1,000-acre man, £50—we will test the soil of every field upon his holding and we will undertake to provide, deliver and spread the lime, the phosphates and the potash the land may require. He will be informed of the total cost and, subject to his paying any fraction of that cost, the balance can be funded as an annuity to be consolidated with his land annuity—subject to the provision that second recourse may not be had to that scheme unless and until the annuity in respect of its first application has been redeemed.
There is now within the reach of every farmer in this country the means to rehabilitate his land, the means to fertilise it on credit, paying every penny back that is lent to him, the means to buy stock, to buy implements, the means to erect new buildings, the means to have everything requisite for useful users of the land—except hard work. There is no one who could provide that but the farmer himself. Every farmer who is prepared to provide that has the road open to him. I want to make that demonstrably clear.
Deputy Smith found fault with me for saying that the 1948 Agreement made available to our people a remunerative market for everything produced upon the land of Ireland. I want most deliberately to reiterate that statement now. I want to call in evidence that in 1949 the agricultural exports of this country earned a greater money income for our people than on any previous occasion in recorded time. I say that there is available to our people to-day a profitable market for cattle, sheep, milk products and eggs, for all the live stock and live-stock products our land is capable of producing, and for every cwt. of cereals our land is capable of growing. But I want to say again and with emphasis that there is no Minister for Agriculture who can ever take his stand here and honestly say to our people that there shall be a cash market for every crop he grows upon his land. If he makes the attempt so to guarantee, he embarks upon the road taken by Mr. Brennan, the American Secretary for Agriculture. The industrial wealth of the United States of America may permit of that in America, but in Ireland everybody lives out of the land and if they do not live out of the land they do not live at all. The land cannot support the land: the land in this country has to support everything else. And the land does it, not out of price primarily, but out of profit, the difference between the cost of production and the price for which you sell.
As I told the British Minister of Food, our people want no excess profit, but they will not work for a loss and there is no use suggesting that you can buy Irish produce at an uneconomic price, for the only result of fixing such a price is that you will get no produce at all. I have no doubt I will be told hereafter that that was arrogant and flamboyant, but I glory in the fact of our people's capacity, should circumstances require it, to go back, as they have gone back before, to subsistence level and to resolve that the day will never dawn when they will work for anybody for nothing. God keep them so for ever. On that basis I want to sell, and I believe we are going to sell, increasing quantities of foodstuffs to the British people, and I am glad to sell them to them at a fair price, fixed by consent between a willing buyer and a willing seller. I know what can be done will be done by my friends on the Opposition Benches to prevent that coming to pass, but despite their best endeavour I think it will.
Deputy Smith or Deputy Blaney wanted to know if there was a sale for potatoes this year. Yes—50,000 tons. I believe there will be sale for all the pigs and bacon we can produce—but I cannot prove that——
Comment on this
——where they make a fair profit. I know the Deputy does not like that prospect: it distresses him. That fact notwithstanding, I think it will come to pass. It will not be for the want of trying on my part if it does not. I shall not be in the least ashamed to fail if I know I have done my best. I can do no more.
Comment on this
Oh now, that was a piece of mischief-making I want to refer to. Let me tell that story—and I will tell it all. Two years ago, when I came into office, there was a contract for 50,000 tons of potatoes—and it was a year of great abundance. It became early obvious that the British themselves had far more potatoes than they themselves could dispose of. I would not have thought it was in any degree unreasonable for the British to say: "We are smothered out in potatoes and can ye dispose of them anywhere else without compelling us to take them?" Nothing could exceed the scrupulous rectitude with which the British Ministry of Food proceeded—and it is right that I should say that. They are tough, hard, ruthless bargainers—and they are right to make the best bargain they can for their own people—but once they put their hand to a bargain they keep it. They insisted on taking delivery of every stone they purchased and they paid us £10 and more for it, according to the season. They had to deliver them to factories for processing and they took the loss without a word and, in respect of one consignment which I knew had been turned to industrial purposes, they returned to say that they paid for this consignment as were but it was delivered on foot of a contract for seed and they accordingly enclosed a cheque for the difference. Very well. This year, a similar contract for 50,000 tons had been made— and then Deputy Davern and Deputy Blaney came on the rampage. Early in the year the Department accumulates a reserve of potatoes for the protection of the Dublin City market. In addition to that, this year we had bought potatoes for delivery under the contract to Great Britain. When we proceeded to test the Dublin City reserve, the classic symptom emerged that farmers had in many cases sold the potatoes which they had already sold to us to somebody else who came along with a lorry and bid them a higher price. That is so typical a symptom that we knew at once that we were going to be faced with a shortage. Our first duty was to make safe the domestic consumer from scarcity. When we had done that it was clear that our total delivery on foot of the contract for 50,000 tons of potatoes could be no more than 24,000 tons from domestic sources. I looked for potatoes on the Continent but I failed to get them.
It is not every type of potato that can be delivered under a ware potato contract to Great Britain. They specify certain types of potatoes they are prepared to accept. Those varities are not easily come by in the United States —in fact, they are not available at all. But there is an area of Prince Edward Island in Canada where types of potatoes acceptable to the British market are available. We located there 26,000 tons of potatoes or the option of them. I sought authority from our Government to spend dollars belonging to our earnings——
Comment on this
I am going to tell that story but I did not use the word "lying". I used the term "prevarication of mischievous kind". We were very careful that they should be our dollars. We were very careful that they should constitute no charge whatever on the sterling pool. A high officer of my Department went specially to London to see the head of the Potato Division of the Ministry of Food and to explain that there was no need to have any delicacy on the subject of dollars because we had the dollars; that there was no question of impinging on the resources of the dollar pool because these were dollars which we had available outside the dollar pool, and that they must dismiss from their mind any question of the expense to which we might be put because we acknowledged that in the previous year they had cheerfully met heavy expense and we would not wish to see them short of a hundred-weight of potatoes on account of our failure to perform our contract as they had performed theirs. The reply of the British Ministry of Food was: "We think we can get through. Do not spend your good dollars if it is not necessary. We will let you know if we are caught short and we will reckon on that 26,000 tons as being available if we want them." When the last day of the contract time came, they notified us that they just squeezed through and that they were obliged to us for our solicitude to offer them performance in circumstances such as that. Every blooming mischief that Deputy Smith could make he made in this House because, of course, the responsible Minister in London had to take the risk of being sharply chastened in his own Parliament if, in his desire to act equitably, he should have run into— and he very nearly did—a shortage.
They had a large reserve of potatoes in Northern Ireland which they foresaw would be surplus to their entire requirements and suddenly the whole thing was swept into the market and they just squeezed through. But my helpful colleague was here baa-ing every week to give them all the details of this story. I knew perfectly well that if I got up to tell that story ex parte while the contract was still current there would be plenty of his prototypes in the British House of Commons to say baa to the Minister of Food.
Comment on this
The Deputy said we drew dollars from the sterling area pool to purchase potatoes in Prince Edward Island for the British Ministry of Food.
Comment on this
I deny that as a true interpretation of what I said. I want the Minister to quote me correctly.
Comment on this
On a point of order. If a statement I am alleged to have made is to appear on the records, I ask the Minister to quote me correctly.
Comment on this
If this is to go on the records of the House, the Minister should get the quotation.
Comment on this
Are we to suspend proceedings while I go rooting round for the Deputy's reference to the dollar pool?
Comment on this
——that there was a charge on the sterling pool for these potatoes. The whole point of our approach to the British Ministry of Food was to show that we had the means of fulfilling our contracts in Canada without making any demand on them. It would have been a very poor gesture to go to London and say: "We will get you potatoes if you pay for them". The whole object was that we put ourselves in a position without imposing any charge on the British to fulfil what we had undertaken to fulfil, and they very decently said: "If we cannot get on without them, we will ask you to do it, but otherwise we will not." I will try to get the Deputy the column in which he made that statement. Does he know the column in which that statement appeared?
Comment on this
I will get the column for you later on. I have tried to cover most of the matters that were raised here, but one could talk for ever if one were to try to deal with everything. There are, however, one or two things I want to conclude with. One is the land project. The land project was designed for farmers in every category, but it was primarily designed for small farmers. I am sometimes a little troubled that small farmers seem to think that it is so vast that it must be intended only for the big farmers and that these great machines have no place on a small holding.
It should be remembered that it is just as difficult to shift a double ditch topped with hawthorn that has been growing there for years on a ten-acre holding as it would be to shift a similar obstacle on a 1,000-acre holding. I know of nothing better than a bulldozer to do that shifting, unless you are to put a gang of men on the work for a month. It is on the eight, the ten, and the 12-acre holding that we want to see this machinery doing the work that otherwise could never be done and it was for the owners of such holdings primarily that this project was put in hands. I hope Deputies will help me to persuade the small farmers to avail of it. I will now quote from column 1946:—
"The fact that it was a prince's island did not seem to make any difference, republicans and all that we were. Finally, we entered into a contract to buy potatoes in Prince Edward Island. Then, of course, they would only take hard currency and that hard currency could only be obtained from the dollar pool."
That statement was false.
Comment on this
I take it the Deputy is not denying that he said that these dollars were to be sought from the dollar pool. The Deputy is now wagging his head up and down.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that all our dollar earnings had to go into the dollar pool and, therefore, if we want the dollars we must apply to the pool for them?
Comment on this
Deputy Aiken has strolled in within the past few minutes and apparently he is bucked with himself. If he will subside we will be finished in a moment. I want to call attention to one phenomenon and that is the Fianna Fáil ramp about unemployment. To me, if there is one man in this country who wants an opportunity to earn his bread and has the strength wherewith to do it, and he is unable to find a job, every hour of his existence is a standing rebuke to the Government of the day. But that Government's task is a thousand times complicated if there is a fictitious claim made that a vast number of people are unemployed who are no more unemployed than I am. It is the Fianna Fáil purpose to affirm that there are hundreds of hungry, unemployed men walking the roads of rural Ireland unable to find work wherewith to maintain their families. Now, that pretence is creating a situation in rural Ireland where the genuine seekers for work are getting smothered up by the individuals who are not looking for work and who will not take work if it is offered to them.
There are as many drawing the dole in rural Sligo as there are in any other county in Ireland. There is a report of the Sligo County Council where the county engineer said that they cannot put the Local Authorities (Works) Act grants into use because there is no man available to accept employment. Where there is delay in connection with the land project, in 50 per cent. of the cases, whether the work is done by the farmer himself or whether we are charged to do it, the delay is due to the fact that we cannot get men. There are not any men available for employment. That is something about which we should rejoice instead of flapping around the country moaning and groaning about the millions of unemployed.
I got a letter recently from a man in Gibraltar. He said he gets the Weekly Independent and they are perplexed to see on one page Mr. Dillon saying there was work for any man in rural Ireland who wanted it and on another page a record of 62,000 on unemployment assistance going to the labour exchange. He asks: “How do you reconcile these things?” I want to face this problem, and I think there is an explanation of it. I think, when you get to the stage of dealing with farmers in this country whose valuation is below £2, you are not dealing with the problem of unemployment at all. You are dealing with the problem of inadequate means of subsistence; you are dealing with men whose homesteads are not capable of yielding a reasonable living to the men of the house and who, therefore, have to have accessible to them in the immediate vicinity of their own homes some supplementary source of income. But they are not unemployed in the sense that they are available for work, because they cannot leave their homes and take a job away. If they were to do so, their seven or eight acres of land would go wild, and they would lose more, due to the want of supervision at home, than they would earn in employment away. That is a problem which my colleague, the Minister for Lands, is doing his part to solve, and which I, in the Department of Fisheries, am doing my part to solve. Each of us is lending a hand to solve it, but it is not the problem of unemployment. The great danger is that, misled by that description, we will go on applying remedies appropriate to unemployment and will fail to get results because we are losing sight of the wood for the trees.
The tragedy is that there may be quite a considerable number of perfectly genuine working men mixed up in a miscellaneous bag of small farmers and the like, some of whom are genuinely unemployed and some of whom are not, but they are all called unemployed. The man who has not got a little farm of seven or eight acres may be denied the chance of getting a job because, while he may go down to a labour exchange where there are ten or 20 men looking for a job, when you go there and find 3,090 looking for jobs, you throw up your hat in despair. Nothing that I can do is going promptly to mop them up. There are too many whose circumstances are manifestly such that we cannot force them into the area where they live, and get sufficient work to occupy them all.
You cannot tackle a problem like that with the same resolve to clean it up that you would do if it were a real problem of working men looking for work in circumstances in which it would be worth their while to take it.
I see at the present time—I foresaw it some time ago—that one of the great difficulties that is going to confront us at a very early date is the scarcity of genuinely available labour. Unless we are very careful to marshal our resources, urgent and important work may be held up because we will not have the hands to employ to get it done. I would ask Deputies to lend me their aid in persuading our people in rural Ireland to avail promptly of the water supply scheme, and, in dairying areas especially, of the credit scheme for the supplying of milking machines. There is no dairy farmer who should contemplate continuing in the dairying industry unless he installs a milking machine. It is imposing on his family a degree of drudgery which should not constitute an essential part of the dairy farmer's life. Means are available to him now to install a milking machine to-morrow morning and to pay for it out of his creamery cheque month by month, as the manager draws it. If he has not got the heart to do that, he ought to get out of the business altogether because it is not fair or right to expect young people to go on striving with equipment and under conditions that would be more suitable to their grandfather's time than they are to the present day. It is all very well to be sentimental about marching along a grand headland with a lovely Dobbin, but if you have to tramp behind Dobbin with a stone of clay on each boot and then, when you bring him in, you have to take the harness off and feed him before you wash your own hands, it is not quite so romantic, whereas if a young fellow can sit up on a tractor, drive into a field and realise that he is not killing the horse in the work he is doing, and if he can drive home in the evening with the plough cocked up behind him, and put his tractor into a garage the same as the dispensary doctor or the curate can do, then I can tell you farming takes on a very different appearance.
In saying that, I am following the good example which our President's distinguished lady set when she said that the time had passed when we should look down on agriculture as an occupation in this country. She went a little further than I do, and described the rest of the population as parasites on the farmer. I say that agriculture supports the rest of the country. They are a welcome charge, always provided that farmers are given the means effectively to support it.
There is one problem that I cannot solve and that the manure manufacturers and the importers cannot solve. Only one person can solve it and that is the farmer. There is not storage in this country for all the phosphates that we should put out on the land. You cannot build up greater stocks than your storage will allow. If everyone is going to put out phosphates between February and June, the total output of our manufacturers, together with our capacity to import supplies and with the limited storage at our disposal, will not be sufficient to meet the demand. On grass land, it is even better to put out phosphates between September and January than it is to put them out in spring. The farmers could help by putting phosphates and potash on grass land in such quantities as circumstances will permit between September and January. If they would do that we could double the possibility of the user of fertilisers in this country.
Deputy Dr. Ryan derided me this evening about aphosphorosis and said that it must now have disappeared. Little he knows. There is a big advertisement going to appear in the Press next month giving the name for aphosphorosis as it is known in the Institute of Folklore in every county in Ireland. It has a different name in nearly every county, such names as "Boglame", "Bockamona", "Luanagh" and others. They have six or eight local names in some places. I have to advise the people to realise that unless this disease is blotted out of the people's memory there is going to be a loss of from 20 to 30 per cent. profit so far as the live-stock industry is concerned. One of the most effective means of wiping that condition out in Ireland would be to persuade the farmers to put out phosphates between October and January. I do not think I am making an excessive demand on my colleagues in this House if I bespeak their influence to that end.
With regard to the land project, we shall shortly be producing, I hope, all the pipes we require here But I want to sound this note of warning: in respect of concrete drainage pipes, I do not think that in their own interest there ought to be many more entrants to that trade. I think the manufacturing capacity for concrete pipes is now nearly commensurate with our requirements, which may be from 10,000,000 to 20,000,000 a year. In respect of earthenware pipes, production is still far short of our requirements. I am prepared to buy the entire output of any unit—and I asked Deputy J.J. Collins, I think, to think over this—established anywhere in Ireland for the length of the life of the kiln which is manufacturing from clay in a kiln fired by turf. There is ample scope for further enterprises in that connection.
That is the story. God knows, it has been a long one. But in the light of the many chapters that were contributed by my disinterested, open-minded and benevolent critics on the far side of the House, I do not think I have unduly trespassed on their patience in finishing the last chapter. I want to end as I began. I want to exhort Fianna Fáil to exorcise in themselves and their Party the disgusting vice of hate. It is twisting their minds. It is disgracing the proceedings of this Parliament and, valuable as I may be, I am not worth hating all that much. Do not damn your souls and the country's institutions just hating me.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?