We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Vote 38—Local Government.

Contributions 1–139 of 274. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Michael J. Keyes Minister for Local Government (Mr. Keyes) Labour Party

I move:—

That a sum not exceeding £2,747,160 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending the 31st day of March, 1951, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Local Government.

Deputies will observe from the published Book of Estimates that the total net amount required in the Vote for my Department for the current financial year is £4,382,160. The total net amount, including Supplementary Estimates, provided for the last financial year was £3,223,100. There is thus a net increase of £1,159,060 on last year's Vote. The increase is easily explained. There are only two main items accounting for it: (a) an increase of £585,000 in the amount being made available for grants to private persons, local authorities and public utility societies for the erection or reconstruction of houses; and (b) £500,000 additional for the financing of schemes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, 1949, this being the first full year in which the provisions of the Act will operate. There is also an increase of £51,655 in the growing amount required to make provision for contributions towards the annual loan charges of local authorities in respect of housing schemes and an increase from £20,000 to £50,000 in the provision being made for grants for reserved houses for newly married couples.

As regards local authority housing, I have to report another year of progress. During the past financial year 5,299 houses and flats were completed by local authorities as compared with 1,871 in the previous year and 729 in the year before that. The record of housing works in progress by local authorities is equally satisfactory. At the end of March last 10,527 houses were in course of erection as compared with 8,193 in March, 1949, and 3,816 in March, 1948. All the indications are that local authorities will achieve a figure of not less than 7,000 completed dwellings in the present financial year.

The number of dwellings completed in Dublin City during the year was 1,574, which is more than double the output of the previous year. Houses under construction for the corporation in March, 1950, numbered 3,591 as compared with 2,759 in March, 1949.

When introducing the Estimate for my Department last year I referred to the serious obstacle in the way of a greater rate of production of houses which was presented by the inadequate supply of skilled craftsmen, such as carpenters, plasterers and others associated with the finishing of houses. I am happy to say that a considerable improvement has been effected in the course of the year under review. The number of skilled operatives engaged on local authority housing in March, 1950, was 5,915 as compared with 3,664 in March, 1949. This represents an increase of 61 per cent. in the number of skilled workers and has been brought about largely by the efforts of local authorities in expanding activities by direct labour and in the creation of a general atmosphere calculated to attract workers to their areas by publicising the extent of the programmes which are on hands and which are contemplated. I have consistently supported these local efforts and given the widest possible publicity to the importance of the national housing programme and the large measure of continuity of employment which the various planned programmes will afford to workers. I do not maintain, however, that the shortage of skilled workers of all types has been completely met everywhere. Local authorities in some areas still experience some shortages in the finishing trades. I have, however, every confidence that the remaining difficulties in these respects will be overcome by careful planning of pending programmes. Unskilled building workers whose contribution to the housing drive is so valuable, and, at the same time, so unostentatious, were employed in increasing numbers also during the year. The number engaged in March was 7,040 as compared with 4,689 in the corresponding month last year.

As regards the financing of local authority housing schemes, in addition to the provision of subsidy towards loan charges which amounts this year to £757,800 and grants for reserved houses and for extra accommodation where a member of a household is suffering from pulmonary tuberculosis, it is proposed to provide a sum of £3,200,000 in the Transition Development Fund for the purpose of making capital grants in reduction of the capital amount which the local authorities have to borrow for their own housing programmes during the year. Thus, the system of contributions towards loan charges and the provision, at the same time, of capital grants is being continued in the present year. A general review is, however, being made of the working of this system with a view to the unification, if possible, of the two forms of financial assistance. For this purpose, statistical information is being compiled on the various systems of housing finance in operation before 1932, from 1932 to 1945 and since the creation of the Transition Development Fund.

I indicated last year that the question of standardising subsidies is closely allied with that of housing costs and that it would be difficult to formulate a new system of housing subsidy until a much greater degree of normality was achieved in the matter of costs. I am glad to say that there is now greater evidence of a tendency towards stability as regards the upper limits of cost and, indeed, a tendency for contract prices to drop. The improvement in the supply of skilled labour and of materials; keener competition by contractors and the influence of direct labour building have all contributed to these developments. Current costs are, however, still very high. Contract prices for unserviced labourers' cottages, including site works, range from about £725 to £1,000 a cottage, while for serviced urban houses, including development cost, the price per house is between £1,100 and £1,400. A severely critical attitude is being maintained towards tenders submitted to local authorities and every effort is being made to ensure that good value is got for the expenditure involved. In the course of the year local authorities were urged to take every possible step towards reducing prices and it has been intimated that tenders in excess of a reasonable maximum should be rejected.

There have been significant developments during the year in the more general acceptance by local bodies of the principle that rents should bear some relation to the ability of tenants to pay. Such a system has been in operation for many years in Cork County Borough and it has now been adopted in the County Boroughs of Dublin and Limerick and in 14 other areas. I have been at pains to impress on local authorities that there is a statutory obligation on them to select tenants on the basis of need for accommodation rather than with regard to their ability to pay rent. This duty cannot be avoided, in view of the clear provisions of the Acts in regard to the classes of applicants who should receive priority in the allocation of houses.

Once this principle is accepted, the question arises of the better-off families who, because of their qualifications and need for accommodation, are given new houses, being required to pay a rent according to their ability to pay, within the upper limits of a pre-determined economic rent. The general adoption of this system would ensure that in applying the State grants and subsidies and the local authorities' contributions from rates, a periodical review would be made of the means and needs of each family. The circumstances of a household will naturally alter from time to time. Tenants with large families of young children have many demands on their resources and often cannot be expected to expend more than a certain recognised proportion of their earnings on rent. When the children grow up and begin to earn, the financial position of that same family can alter very much for the better within a few years.

The capacity to pay varies, therefore, not only as between one tenant and another but also according to the circumstances of a particular household, from time to time. In the larger urban areas, particularly, the diversities in family income offer a wide scope for the adoption of this renting system.

A sum of £1,635,000 is included in the Estimates for grants to persons and public utility societies in respect of the erection and reconstruction of houses. This is the largest amount which has ever been provided in one year for this purpose. It is provided to keep pace with the very marked expansion of grant-aided private building which has occurred during the last financial year. On 1st April, 1949, 7,864 allocations had been made, of which 4,692 represented grants for new houses and 3,172 for reconstructions. Of these allocations, 746 had been fully paid during the year and 1,179 partly paid. On 1st April last the allocations had increased to 16,362. Of these, 10,282 were for new houses. Grants had been fully paid in 4,159 cases and partly paid in 4,175 cases. A total amount of £1,049,882 was paid out in respect of private building or reconstruction grants during the financial year 1949-50 and the provision now being made in the current Estimates represents an estimated 60 per cent. increase over last year's expenditure. It will be observed from a footnote to the subhead I (3) containing this provision, that issues in excess of £414,000 will be conditional on the enactment of amending legislation. This refers to the statutory aggregate provided for under the 1948 Act, as extended, which will require amendment by law before grants in excess of the balance remaining within the statutory limit can be exceeded. A Bill to give effect to this provision has been introduced.

This review of the position and prospects of the housing drive will, I hope, convince Deputies that the present financial year is likely to produce results in the output of completed houses by local authorities and private enterprise which will reach, if they do not surpass, the highest figures ever previously attained. The latest figures show every sign that this very favourable record will be achieved. In the three months ended 31st March last, over 1,900 houses were completed by local authorities and progress at this rate would achieve an annual output considerably in excess of the pre-war record. Between 3,000 and 4,000 new houses are expected to be completed by private enterprise. This brings the total target which we have now in mind for the year to about 11,000 houses, both local authority and private, for the whole country. The total output achieved in the last three years by local authorities and private enterprise shows the enormously accelerated rate at which the drive has gone forward. For 1947-48, the total was 1,502; for 1948-49, it was 3,296; and for 1949-50, it was 7,966.

I have nothing but praise for the activity of the interests, both public and private, which have contributed to this great recovery in building output within such a short period of time. Local authorities and local officers throughout the country have, with very few exceptions, responded wholeheartedly to the drive for solution of the housing problem, so that in some areas the main requirements have already been, or will shortly be, met. In the larger urban areas, the programme will take a longer period to implement, but in all these areas it is well on its way. As Dublin represents the hard core of the national housing problem, I should like to commend in particular the spectacular energies and notable success of the housing authorities in Dublin City and County, including the borough of Dún Laoghaire, and the help and encouragement which is given to these authorities by the Dublin Housing Consultative Council.

The administration of the Town Planning Acts was continued during the year as in previous years, that is to say, the main attention was concentrated on interim control and the deciding of appeals made by interested parties. The number of appeals submitted to the Minister in 1949/50 was 226 as compared with 228 in the previous year.

There has been a growing interest manifested in the problems presented by the steady increase in building in Dublin City and the surrounding areas. Officers of my Department have had consultations with the city manager and his staff on these problems. A consistently rigid attitude is being maintained in opposition to any large scale building developments in the green belt area and effective efforts are being made for the co-ordination locally of all forms of specialist advice as regards building both by the housing authorities and private persons in the areas scheduled for residential purposes. The organisation being aimed at is intended to achieve a complete co-ordination of policy under the Town and Regional Planning Acts, under the administration of the building bye-laws and under the Housing and Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts. Activities under the latter Acts are also closely associated with the administration by the Department of Local Government of the schemes of grants to subsidise the erection of houses by public utility societies and private persons.

Deputies will recall that for the year 1949-50 a substantial portion of the Road Fund was made available for the first time by way of special improvement grants for county roads. The amount allocated was £1,200,000 out of a total of £2,343,518 for county council road works as a whole. The reports available on the operation of the new system indicate that substantial improvements were effected on various county roads by the aid of the grant and that a continuance of the same system for the current year is warranted. County councils have, accordingly, been advised that the grants for main road improvement, county road improvement and the percentage grants for ordinary works on main roads would be continued in 1950-51 on the same basis as had obtained in 1949-50. The estimated income of the Fund for the year is £2,600,000 and the allocations, including a provisional allocation for county boroughs, amount to £2,550,000. In addition, outstanding commitments from previous years to be met in 1950-51 amount to £750,000. To meet total charges on the Fund, further borrowing will, therefore, be necessary, within the margin of the total additional borrowing powers conferred by statute in 1948.

During the year I had a circular letter addressed to road authorities arising out of various questions raised from time to time regarding the production of road materials by way of contract and the methods by which road authorities should themselves produce such material. I pointed out that it was essential that the best possible value should be obtained for the money spent on roads and that each road authority responsible for a substantial annual programme should provide an engineering organisation, equipment and personnel sufficient to enable them to carry it out effectively. This policy does not exclude the purchase of material or the hire of machinery in exceptional circumstances, nor the carrying out by contract of certain road works, particularly those of a specialised or abnormal nature.

I drew attention to the fact that where costs of direct labour work, either in the production of materials or in actual work on the roads, were higher than in the case of similar contract work, the excess must be due to inefficient machinery and methods. I accordingly recommended the production by up-to-date machinery of materials at central quarries and sandpits and the use of lorries where other forms of transport would be uneconomic or impracticable.

I am glad to be able to report that the first programme of works undertaken under the Local Authorities (Works) Act between the autumn of 1949 and March, 1950, has proved a very great success. A sum of £1,250,000 was voted by the Dáil for the purpose of making grants to local authorities for the carrying out of works under the Act. The local authorities selected schedules of works and their proposals were then considered by the Department. The grants were confined generally to works capable of being completed by the end of the financial year. Practically the full amount of the voted provision was expended in the year. The number of men employed rose from 6,000 in September, 1949, to 13,850 in March, 1950. In the latter month over 26,000 men were employed by county councils on road works and Works Act schemes as compared with about 19,000 men engaged on road works in the same month in 1949.

A further programme of schemes under the Act is being provided for in this year's Vote where, as I have said, an increased provision of £1,750,000 has been made for the purpose. After making provision for the payment of the balance of last year's grants and for grants for urban authorities, I have been able to notify county councils generally of their grants for the present financial year. They total in all approximately £1,600,000. In apportioning this sum all the relevant factors were taken into account, such as the availability of labour, last year's performance and this year's programmes.

In connection with the preliminary compilation of schemes for execution in the current year local authorities were advised that, in selecting works and in determining the time for their execution, regard should be had to the labour position in the locality, the demands of other services such as road works, agriculture, etc., the need for avoiding, as far as possible, sharp fluctuations in employment, and the weather conditions necessary for good results.

The number of vehicles of all classes under current licence in August, 1949, was 122,536, as compared with 108,002 such vehicles in August, 1948.

The Department of Local Government, in conjunction with the National Film Institute and the Garda Síochána, has continued to arrange for the production of various forms of road safety propaganda, including the display of road safety films. Similar activities are projected for the current financial year.

I referred last year to the very large programme of waterworks and sewerage schemes which is pending in most counties and in some of the urban districts. So far as the county programmes are concerned, I indicated the need for adhering to a procedure whereby works should be undertaken in accordance with a planned programme over successive years according to the order of their relevant urgency. The extent of the activities of local authorities in resuming the implementation of their programmes has shown a strong upward trend during the year. A larger proportion of the schemes are being gradually brought to final planning stage. The number of schemes authorised during the year included 70 major waterworks and sewerage schemes, involving a total expenditure in excess of £1,000,000. Of this sum, over £400,000 was met by way of grants from the Emergency and Employment Schemes Vote and the Transition Development Fund.

The programme of 70 schemes so undertaken was a big advance on the previous financial year when 33 such schemes were initiated. The programme for the current year will be approximately of the same dimensions as that undertaken in 1949-50. If progress is maintained at this rate in subsequent years the larger portion of the accumulated sanitary services programme should be undertaken within the three subsequent financial years with the usual time lag of one or two additional years to complete the contracts entered into. This would represent a very satisfactory position as regards the most urgent schemes but it would by no means exhaust the demands from many further areas which will be taking their place in due course in the programmes of subsequent years.

Since the 1st April, 1948, a comprehensive series of inspections of all fire-fighting services throughout the State has been made by the Department's fire adviser. Recommendations for the improvement of the fire-fighting services have been conveyed to a number of local authorities. The recommendations are generally based on a minimum outline fire-fighting service organised on a county basis. The office of chief fire officer of a county or county borough has been approved as a whole-time permanent and pensionable post. In some counties there has been a reluctance to appoint a chief fire officer. I would like now to reiterate what has been pointed out in correspondence with the authorities concerned that no appreciable measure of success can be achieved in the matter of securing even a minimum fire-fighting organisation in the absence of the continuous control, planning and supervision which a chief officer is intended to exercise. Draft fire standards were issued to local authorities last year and have now been published in book form. I hope that perusal of the standards will bring home to all concerned the very considerable tasks which lie ahead with a view to making places of public resort and institutions more secure against fire risk.

Official contractors have been appointed for the supply of approximately 3,000 commodities during the current contract year. Many commodities which were off the official list for some ten years are again being made available at competitive prices. There is also evidence of increases in the number of commodities of Irish manufacture for which it is now possible to obtain satisfactory tenders. There was a further marked increase in the number of applications for appointment as official contractors from provincial merchants.

The prices quoted by contractors are not yet showing any general tendency to fall. Reductions have taken place in the prices of a number of essential commodities but these are offset by increases in others.

Last year many Deputies commented on the upward trend of rates and there were some forecasts as to further increases in the burden on ratepayers. I am glad to say that these forecasts have proved to be largely fanciful. The simple average of rates struck by county councils for the year 1950-51 is just a fraction of a penny less than that for the previous year. In round figures it may be said that the average rates for the two years are the same, viz., 23/2 in the £.

The county rate collection for the past year was very satisfactory, 97.5 per cent. of the total warrant for the year having been collected at the 31st March, 1950, as against 97.2 per cent. on the corresponding date last year. I trust that the public-spirited reaction of ratepayers generally as shown in the fine record of rate collection for the past year will continue to manifest itself. The increases which have taken place in the rates in recent years are, in my view, not symptomatic of extravagance or of ill-considered expenditure but rather a reflection of the great increase in essential local activities which has taken place, combined with the general post-war increases in costs generally.

I have had occasion frequently to point out, both in this House and elsewhere, that the factors to which I have referred have led to substantially greater increases in the expenditure from the Exchequer on grants made available to local authorities in relief of rates on land and towards the cost of other services. This tendency was referred to by the Minister for Finance in his Financial Statement for the current year, where he pointed out that since 1938/39 Government grants to local authorities have increased by over £10,000,000, whereas rates have risen by £4.6 million.

The total loans sanctioned for purposes other than housing for the year amounted to £1,184,782 as compared with £871,601 in the previous year. The increase reflects increased activities of local authorities in respect of sewerage schemes, vocational education, construction of hospitals, county homes and dispensaries, etc. Housing loans sanctioned in 1949-50 amounted to £11,833,234 as compared with £8,361,258 in the previous financial year.

In the course of the year under review, the general administration of local authorities was, on the whole, very satisfactory. I have visited a large number of local administrative units, mainly in connection with the opening of new housing schemes, but I invariably take the opportunity of inquiring into the general conditions and hearing the views of local representatives and others regarding the needs of the several districts. I have experienced everywhere a very full degree of evidence of the willingness of local representatives and local officers to co-operate in the major schemes being promoted under my supervision.

Needless to say, I am frequently confronted with demands which, in my position as mediator between the central authorities and the local authorities, I am often unable to concede fully and sometimes I have to reject them completely or suggest that the projects be deferred. Nevertheless, there is, I believe, a continued increase in that close and realistic understanding which I mentioned last year was growing up between my Department and the spokesmen of local administration. I wish to assure the House, and particularly those Deputies who are themselves local representatives, and through them local elected bodies generally, that so far as I am concerned my efforts will be constantly directed towards a development of this friendly understanding and co-operation with local bodies.

Comment on this

I move that the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration. In doing so, I understand that the Government business has got itself into such a muddle that it is necessary for us to be as brief and as cogent as we can in the criticisms which we have to make of the present general administration of the public services. Therefore, I do not intend to detain the House at any great length. Perhaps, accordingly, I should begin my speech by commending the Minister in the few instances in which I can commend him for some of the things which he has done. I am glad to see that, despite the reluctance with which it was received when it was first put before the House in the Housing Act of 1948, the Minister has realised that, if our housing problem is to be tackled without crippling the State and the local authorities, it is essential that the rents of houses built by public authorities, with Government subsidies and with subventions from the rates, should be related to the capacity of the tenants to pay. I think there will be general agreement that this is a just and equitable principle and I am glad to see that the Minister for Local Government, representing as he does the Labour Party in the Cabinet, has at last accepted it. I congratulate him upon his courage and I am sure that the acceptance of that principle will be of very great assistance to him indeed in tackling the very difficult problem of providing houses for those of our people who require them.

The other matter upon which I should like to congratulate him is the earnest attempt which he is now making to give effect to the policy which had been adopted by the Fianna Fáil Administration of ensuring that every centre of population would be provided with fire fighting services to the best of its ability to maintain them. We know that the need for utilising these services does not often arise. It is only when a holocaust occurs, such as the lamentable tragedy in Cavan some years ago, a tragedy of such a shocking and heart-rending description, that the public conscience is sufficiently stirred and a general appreciation is formed of the need for systematic and careful organisation and maintenance of these services. I know from experience that the Minister is not going to find it easy to persuade shortsighted people, who sometimes do occupy positions of public responsibility, to recognise that need; but I am glad to see that he is addressing himself to the task of persuading them, and I can only say that, as far as I am concerned, I will heartily support his efforts in that regard.

Now let me come to some of the other aspects of the statement which the Minister has presented to the House, to which, as a matter of public duty speaking here for the Opposition, I must direct attention. What I propose to say immediately does not apply, so far as I know, personally to the Minister for Local Government. I have found him courteous and prepared to accept criticism. It is a well-known fact, however, that there are colleagues of his in the Government, who think that the public have become so habituated to their extravagance that they no longer have any regard for questions of pounds, shillings and pence in relation to public services, while these Ministers themselves have now reached such a state of prodigal exaltation that it is regarded by them as something treasonable even to suggest that the burdens upon our people as ratepayers and as taxpayers might not already have become excessive.

In that connection, it might be no harm to remind the House at this stage that when the Government first became responsible for sponsoring Estimates in this House in March, 1948, they presented a volume of Estimates the total sum of which amounted to £70,520,000 and they were careful to append to that volume a disclaimer stating that it was the Fianna Fáil Administration and not they, not these prudent, provident, stewards who were now going to take charge of the public finances, who were responsible for the fact that they had to present to Dáil Eireann for acceptance Estimates which totalled the staggering sum of £70,520,000.

This year however, they are no longer imbued with this desire to disclaim responsibility for extravagance. On the contrary, they come to the Dáil glorying in it and there is presented to us Estimates for the Public Services which total £78,127,000. It is a colossal and staggering sum, which has already been commented on in this House. I do not want to deal with the aggregate figure but I wish to call public attention to the fact that in the year in which Fianna Fáil left office, February, 1948, in the Estimates which they had provided for the incoming year, for the year which ended on the 31st March, 1949, the total sum asked for the service of the Department of Local Government was £1,172,000. This year, the figure has jumped to no less than £4,382,000—an increase of almost 300 per cent. Is it not staggering to think of it? Here, while the cost of living is mounting, while the people are groaning under taxation, while they are flying from the lands of Ireland, while emigration has become almost uncontrollable, the Government proposes to take from the service by the people of their individual needs, whether they are employers or employees, whether they are manufacturers or farmers, a sum which is almost four times as great as that which was denounced in unbridled language as extravagant when the Fianna Fáil Estimates were submitted to this House in March, 1948. An increase of £3,210,000 represents the fulfilment of the Government's pledges to reduce extravagance and to curb expenditure.

There is something more even than that in this matter. In 1948-49, what we proposed to take would have been raised out of taxation. The money that we were to spend in any one year we proposed to collect in that year. We proposed to treat our people honestly. We proposed to have some regard for interests other than our own and our own narrow political interest. We proposed in the year 1949 to pay our way as we went. In this year in which they propose to spend £4,382,000, they propose to borrow £3,435,000 and, of the huge sum of £4,382,000, they propose to pay now something just a fraction over 20 per cent.—the remaining 80 per cent. of the indebtedness which the Government propose to incur for the public services they are leaving to be paid by their successors, whomsoever they may be. Here, when the world is shaping up to war, when all the resources of the country in the future may be taxed in order to preserve the independence of this people, this Government is already trenching upon those resources, already depleting them and spending them in ways which even the Minister for Finance himself finds it difficult to justify.

One may, of course, endeavour to discount what a member of the Opposition will say in relation to expenditure on the part of the Government, but we have the spectacle of the Minister for Finance coming in and, with special reference to some of the items in this Vote and other Votes, pleading to the House to try to save him from his colleagues—he could scarcely regard them as his friends when they compel him by their exigent demands upon him to make the kind of ad misericordiam appeal which I am going to recall to the recollection of Deputies. The Minister for Finance, speaking in this House on the Vote on Account, said, as he is reported in Volume 119, column 2070:

"I would ask that there be the most careful scrutiny of the separate items under these headings."

The Minister for Finance has to come to this House and make that sort of appeal—saying to the Opposition, in fact: "Boys, it is up to you. I have done my best to curb this extravagant programme. I have tried to keep the State expenditure within bounds. I have not been able to succeed and I cannot succeed short of resigning my portfolio and breaking up the Coalition. Therefore, I throw myself on your mercy and I ask you in regard to housing, land rehabilitation, drainage and other works to subject all these proposals of my colleagues to the most careful scrutiny." Is it not clear then that not only are we convinced, but that the Minister for Finance himself is also convinced, that it is time somebody tried to call a halt to this extravagant administration? If I may reinforce the quotation which I have just given in relation to the Vote on Account by what the Minister said in the Seanad on the Second Reading of the Finance Bill, when he admitted in reply to the criticisms of the Budget which he had to meet in the Seanad that taxation had already reached fantastic heights, is it not doubly clear that what the Minister for Finance asked for is justified, and that we are justified ourselves in approaching the demand of the Minister for £4,382,000 with a sceptical mind as to whether, indeed, expenditure of that huge sum is justified?

Let us consider some of the items under it. Sub-head K (5) provides the sum of £1,750,000 for grants to local authorities for the execution of works under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, 1949. The Minister, in the course of his speech, told us the number of schemes that had been embarked upon and the number of people that had been employed, and no doubt these are statistics which are worthy of consideration. But there is something more than spending money merely in order to get thousands of schemes under way and tens of thousands of men employed.

One is justified in asking, is the expenditure of that huge sum of money, £1,750,000, justified in regard to every penny? I know, of course, there will be different approaches to this question. I know that some people will say that in their area some good schemes have been carried out. On the other hand, in other areas we hear that some schemes which could not be held by any means to be reproductive or remunerative or value for the money have been carried out. There is no justification in spending public money on a scheme merely to inflate the Minister's statistics, merely to be able to state that at a given date in any particular year so many men were employed. Public money should only be spent if the results of that expenditure, in terms of the executed works, justify it. Therefore, we are justified in asking whether the schemes which have been carried out are value for the money.

There again, it would seem as if others than members of the Opposition are somewhat sceptical about the utility of these schemes and as to what has been the net benefit that has accrued from their execution. No less a person that the Minister for Finance has betrayed an attitude in regard to them that might well justify him placing himself upon these benches. When speaking on the Vote on Account he said it was found that more money would be required for the immediate purpose of drainage. It will be noted that one of the things that is to be done under this subhead is the execution of works affording relief or protection from flooding—that is, drainage.

This is what the Minister for Finance had to say in regard to that particular aspect of the problem—but before I quote the Minister I should remind the House that when the Local Authorities (Works) Act was going through the Dáil last year or in 1948, there was an intense drive made by the Minister for Local Government to secure that the county engineers of the local authorities would submit to the Department the greatest possible number of schemes that they could conceivably think of to be carried out in their administrative areas, so that as soon as the Bill went through, the purse strings were unloosed, public money was scattered, broadcast over the country and the engineers were told to go ahead and make a show of doing some useful work. It is necessary to remind the House that it was in that position of chaos, disorganisation and hasty improvisation that these public works schemes were launched. That is what gives the point to the quotation I am going to give from the Minister for Finance—in which we have his disclosure of the way in which this problem of local authorities' works was tackled by the Department. In column 2072, Volume 119, he said:—

"We discovered here and there that land rehabilitation was held up by the fact that, where the waters had been channelled in various ways, they could not be run off properly because the outfall had not been prepared properly under the land drainage scheme."

That is precisely what the Opposition warned the Minister would occur if effect were to be given to the provisions of the Local Authorities (Works) Act in the manner in which we apprehended they would be given, by reason of the general approach of the Minister for Local Government and the Government as a whole to this problem.

Here we may ask ourselves, since so much of the £1,225,000 which was provided in the year 1949 for these works has been mis-spent in the manner in which the Minister for Finance has disclosed to the House, how much of the £1,725,000, which we are going to provide for that same purpose this year, is going to be mis-spent in a similar way, making a splash of doing something for the sake of securing political kudos from it at the public expense?

It would seem to me that the whole of this question of public works has been carried out in the spirit in which I think the Minister for Agriculture was speaking of his attack upon the problem of inland fisheries, that is in "pragmatical sphere". The whole approach has been one of trial and error. "Clear this drain and we will see what happens in the next farmer's field; clear this river and we will see what happens at the main outfall, let us get ahead and proceed on the principle of trial and error and spend as much public money as we can get the Dáil to vote for us and the shortness of our period of office permits us."

That system worked reasonably well last year and this year, thanks to no foresight, thanks to no planning on the part of those responsible for the manner in which this problem has been attacked, but thanks to a beneficent Providence who blessed this country last year with the finest summer we had for many a long generation and, up to now, as good a summer as we have ever enjoyed.

The weather has been dry, the effects of this premature clearing of the water courses which feed our main arterial system have not been manifested during periods of wet weather, during such a winter, say, as we had in the year 1947; but if the coming winter or the winter following proves to be such another disastrous winter as that was, I wonder what the effect of all this unco-ordinated, ill-conceived, unplanned attack upon a very difficult problem is going to be on the property of those who live in our towns and cities that border the banks of our main rivers, or those who live along our main water courses. That is when this policy, which the present Government has embarked upon, will be tested: that is when we will know what fraction of that £3,000,000 which represents the aggregate of the actual expenditure last year and that which is proposed for this year has been, shall we say, not manifestly ill spent but has been justified. There is a balance, I think a very large balance, that must be written off as being ill spent.

Now, I do not want to overlook the good resolution with which I opened, that is to say, that I intended to be as brief as I could. There are one or two other matters, however, that I ought to touch on. There is housing. The Minister talks about the intensified housing drive. The Minister wishes, and the Government as a whole wishes, the country to believe that the problem of housing was neglected until they took office, when the fact is, as the Minister and the country know, the present Coalition Administration got off to a flying start. The 1948 Housing Act had been passed; the sites for the housing schemes had been procured; the plans for the houses had been prepared; contracts, in many cases, had been placed and any houses that were built in 1948, 1949 or in 1950 derive entirely from the efforts of the Minister's predecessors over the years from 1945 to 1948.

Comment on this

And the 1934 schemes.

Comment on this

I do not wish to be censorious of the Minister for being a Party man, or that as a member of the Government, he tries to claim the greatest amount of credit he possibly can for the fact that the Fianna Fáil housing schemes are now coming to fruition under him. That is natural and he is quite entitled to do it. I am only pointing out not the propaganda in the matter but the truth in the matter. I am only pointing out that there is not a house that is being built in the City of Dublin to-day that would be now in process of erection if it had not been for the work that had been done by the Fianna Fáil Administration in securing the sites and preparing the plans. Mind you the securing of the sites is the most tedious and difficult portion of it. In many cases, the sites had not only been secured but developed, in many cases the foundations had been laid, and in every case the plans had been prepared.

Let us see how, even with that flying start, the record of the Minister for the year 1949-50 compares with the record of one of the Minister's predecessors, the then Minister for Local Government, for the year 1938-39. I do not want to weary the House, but I shall give just one example, that of the number of houses completed for the Dublin Corporation. In the year 1938-39 the total number of houses completed for the Dublin Corporation was 2,335. I have that figure on the authority of the Minister himself who gave it in reply to a parliamentary question which was put down by my colleague and friend, Deputy Childers. For the year 1949-50, under this Ministry of push and go, the number of houses completed in the City of Dublin was 1,576.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

There are 3,000 at the moment.

Comment on this

Completed?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Under construction.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like to live habitually in a house without a roof? I am talking of houses in which people can live. In 1938-39, the number of such houses completed and ready for occupation in the City of Dublin was 2,335, and for the year 1949-50, the number was 1,576, a deficiency of 759. In the light of those figures I might say that the progress which is being made is somewhat disappointing. I do not want to disguise the difficulties which the Minister has encountered. I know that materials in the year 1949-50 were not in as free supply as they were in 1938-39. I know that, perhaps, we had not as many available workers, though I am not so certain about that, because, according to the same parliamentary question, the number of people employed in 1938-39 varied—let me remind the House again that the number of houses completed in the City of Dublin in that year was 2,335— between 2,320 and 4,243.

On the other hand, in the year 1949-50, when only 1,576 houses were constructed, the number of men employed varied between 2,663 and 3,342. One would perhaps be justified in making a rough calculation and saying that the position was that under the sort of lackadaisical administration which we were alleged to have when Fianna Fáil was in office, the labour involved over that period in constructing a house amounted to 1.67 men, but that in the year 1949-50, under the administration which is making an intensive housing drive, the output is such that it requires 2.5 men to produce a house in a year. That is a rough and ready way of putting it. I do not suggest that the figures have very much value as statistics, but that is a way of looking at it. It does indicate that the Fianna Fáil Administration was getting better results out of the housing industry in the City of Dublin than the Coalition Administration is getting now.

The Minister referred to the rates. He will forgive me if I say that I detected a certain tone of complacency in his reference to the rates. He referred to the fact that people had been grumbling about the burden which the rates represent and that they had been seriously apprehensive, as indeed they might have been, as to what the level of the rates would be for the coming year. He said that he was glad to say that all those dismal Jimmies who had been talking about the prospect of increased rates had been stultified because the rates, in fact, were a fraction of a penny less than they had been for the financial year which ended on the 31st March last.

Of course, there are a number of factors to be taken into consideration in assessing the merits of the fact that the apprehensions as to the possibility of an increase in the rates were not realised. But there is one fact that we should not leave out of consideration. That is the fact that the local elections are looming in the offing and experienced politicians, like my friends, Deputy Byrne, Deputy Dunne and a few other gentlemen, have felt, perhaps, that it might not be such a bad idea to inflate the rates for the year 1949-50, in order that they might be able to reduce the rates a little for the year 1950-51; and that, therefore, as a consequence of that, because there was an unnecessary inflation of the rates in the year 1949-50, there has been an actual increase in the real demand to be made upon the ratepayers for the year 1950-51. However, that is perhaps a surmise as to what is a possible explanation of the fact that the rates in the year 1950-51 are just a fraction of a penny less than they were in the year 1949-50.

Will the House consider what these rates might have been were it not for an Act passed by the Fianna Fáil Administration in the year 1947; it is No. 48 of 1947 and it is entitled the Health Services (Financial Provisions) Act? I wonder what the rates of the local authorities would have been were it not for the fact that the Fianna Fáil Administration, which was alleged to be extravagant and to have no regard to the position of the local ratepayers or the local authorities, had passed that Act. Could the Minister for Local Government, when he is replying, tell the House the total sum which has been paid under that Act to the local authorities over and above what was paid out of the Central Fund to those authorities before the passage of that Act? Then we shall see what the position of these local authorities might have been had not Fianna Fáil been in office in 1947 and had the Government of the day not passed that Act.

I do not wish to say too much about roads. I understand that some Deputies propose to move a motion which will be discussed concurrently with the Estimate. They may wish to speak at greater length upon this matter. Everybody who has had occasion to travel the main roads throughout the country will concede that their condition is deteriorating and that they are not nearly so good now as they were in 1948. Let us not forget that in the year 1948 we were repairing and making good the deficiencies that had occurred in road maintenance over the period of the war years. I ascribe this deterioration, not perhaps very pronounced at the moment, but still noticeable, to the fact that the central authority is failing to give sufficient assistance to the local authorities to maintain the roads in proper condition.

It is true that in 1948 the Government had to implement the promise which the Fianna Fáil Administration had given that an additional sum of £2,000,000, over and above what the Road Fund could supply, would be made available to the local authorities to carry out the further reconstruction necessary and the essential replacement works on roads. But that £2,000,000, which we had intended to provide out of the Central Fund as a free grant, was provided by the Minister's predecessor by borrowing on the security of the Road Fund. The Minister has told us to-day that, because further expenditure upon the roads is required, further borrowings on the fund must be made. I think we can describe this Government as the most "borrowingest" Government in existence. If they can borrow, they will not raise the money in any other way; they have an entirely spendthrift, prodigal and improvident policy in regard to the defrayment of the cost of public services.

The position in regard to that matter is, of course, similar to the position in regard to the housing grants for which they propose to borrow and in regard to local authority works for which they also propose to borrow. Every borrowing which they make on the security of the Road Fund reduces the future capacity of that fund to meet the future demands which will inevitably be made upon it and, therefore, we are merely putting off the evil day when further expenditure will have to be incurred upon our roads and there will be no free revenue in the Road Fund to borrow against. We should face the fact that if the Road Fund is not able out of its own resources to meet the cost, then that expenditure should be met by the central authority out of the Central Fund by way of grant; or, if the central authority is not prepared to do that, then the motor vehicle duties and the other duties which feed the Road Fund should be increased in order that the roads, which are such an important item in the economic life of the country, may be maintained on a proper standard.

In that connection it might not be out of place to lament the vacillating and pusillanimous attitude which the Minister displayed in relation to an urgent scheme of road improvement in the neighbourhood of this city. I refer to his abandonment of the Bray Road improvement project. There is no doubt whatever that that abandonment was a grave error of policy on his part. Everybody knows that that road is one of the main arteries from the city to Wexford and, ultimately, to Waterford, through the important towns along our eastern coast south of Dublin. It is a road that is a veritable death trap. It is a road where accidents are of daily occurrence. It is a road the improvement of which is urgently demanded and the improvement of which was being carried out gradually year by year under the Fianna Fáil Administration. That the improvement was not complete before 1948 was due entirely to the intervention of war and to no other reason. This is a public work that must ultimately and inevitably be carried out.

I do not suggest the work should be carried out all at once. It was a work designed to be carried out in stages spread over a number of years. It would have cost in the long run something in the region of £233,000. It has now been deferred and the ultimate consequence of that will be that, when it is carried out, it will in all probability cost twice as much. In the meantime the life of every user of that road, whether he be a pedestrian, a motorist, the driver of a horse-drawn vehicle or a cyclist, will at certain sections of that road be in inevitable jeopardy every time he passes over them. The Minister was stampeded into abandoning this project by a campaign conducted in a newspaper in the interests of a few individuals who resented the fact that the amenities of their properties might be interfered with. I hope that the Minister—the Minister is a man of courage and I have no reason to deny that—will regard the shelving of that scheme as only temporary, that he will take it up again as soon as the local elections are over, and he will ensure that it is proceeded with and given effect to. I am glad to see that the Minister recognises the need for completing this scheme in the form in which it was originally planned.

There are one or two other matters which I shall just briefly mention in the hope that the Minister may give us some information in regard to them when he is replying. For many years, there has appeared in the Estimates a sub-head providing for competitions for designs for housing schemes. The purpose of the competitions was to secure some variation in the more or less standardised type of house which is built under the various Housing Acts. We were anxious if we could to secure model plans and model lay-outs, which would inspire architects and engineers, who are responsible for the execution of these schemes, to combine aesthetic considerations with mere utility. As I have said, I had hoped that we had got to the stage after the change of Government took place that we would have that competition held in the year 1948-49. For some reason or other, it has not taken place. I am glad to see that the Minister has not abandoned the idea and that the provision continues to appear in the Estimates for his Department. I should like if he could give us an assurance that the competitions will actually take place this year and that the community as a whole will have the benefit of them.

There is another matter upon which I should like the Minister to give us some information. In the year 1947 I thought we had reached a virtual conclusion as to the lines upon which the North County Dublin regional water supply would be carried out. That was a very important work. I thought that we had reached a solution as between the Dublin Corporation on the one hand, as the main water suppliers, and the Dublin County Council on the other, as representing the main consumers. I do not know what progress has been made in giving effect to the scheme but I should be glad if the Minister would give me some information in regard to it. I should like also if he would let me know the position in relation to the Howth main drainage which has again an important place in the general development plans for Dublin and the metropolitan district. I have nothing more to say on the subject. I shall leave a more detailed criticism of the administration of the Department to other Deputies who may wish to participate in the debate.

Comment on this

I understand that the motion handed in by Deputy O'Rourke and myself is to be taken in conjunction with this Vote. The motion reads:—

" That in view of the deplorable state of the roads, mainly caused by the heavy motor traffic which they were not constructed to take, and of the intolerable burden which their maintenance would impose on the ratepayers, Dáil Eireann is of opinion that for the next three years an amount equal to the revenue derived from motor taxation, petrol tax and import duties on imported motor vehicles and parts, should be allocated to local authorities to enable them to bring main and county roads up to the standard required for modern road transport."

Comment on this

I got no notice that this motion would be taken in connection with the Estimate.

Comment on this

If that is so, blame your Whips. It was arranged by the Whips.

Comment on this

May I put it to the Minister that I understand also that the Whips had indicated that there would be no objection to the motion being discussed? It is connected with general administration and the only advantage of moving it now is that there may be a separate vote on the motion.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government (Mr. Corish) Labour Party

We have not even got a copy of the motion before us.

Comment on this

I do not think that there is any occasion for me to point out to any Deputy the present condition of our roads.

Comment on this

I want to make it clear that I am not agreeable to taking this motion on the Estimate. The motion is not one connected with my Department. It is one that is connected with the Department of Finance.

Comment on this

Has the Acting-Chairman seen this?

Comment on this

Some of the Whips must have blundered.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the Chair, really.

Comment on this

I thought the Ceann Comhairle was well aware of it.

Comment on this
Matthew O'Reilly Acting-Chairman (Mr. M. O'Reilly) Fianna Fáil

The Minister objects to its being taken on the grounds that it is connected with Finance?

Comment on this

Yes, Sir.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I think that objection holds good. It is a question for Finance.

Comment on this

Is it not connected with this whole Estimate?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It is a question for the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

The allocation of certain moneys raised in that way is not a matter for the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

I do not think the proposal to discuss it in this way emanated from this side.

Comment on this

Who else would it be a matter for except the Minister for Local Government who is in charge of the roads of the country, for good or evil? Who else would be responsible in this House for the condition of the roads, only the Minister for Local Government? I suggest that the Minister will have to stand up to his responsibility.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy can discuss the matter as far as improving the condition of the roads is concerned.

Comment on this

I want to go a step further. I want very definitely to have a separate Vote on this.

Comment on this

On this Estimate the Deputy introduces a new technique. He brings forward this motion. I suggest that that is not a motion connected with the Local Government Estimate.

Comment on this

On account of the time provided for the termination of the session, I would have no objection to postponing this motion, but it has been on the Order Paper for a long time. It was handed in a long time ago. I understand that, in order to facilitate the Government, it was to be taken in conjunction with the Estimate for Local Government, but not at our request.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister for Local Government has no responsibility for the collection of any moneys by way of taxation on petrol and has no responsibility in the matter of the import duties on motor vehicle parts.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Dáil Éireann has a responsibility.

Comment on this

Dáil Eireann has a responsibility for everything, but the responsibility is divided between different Ministers.

Comment on this

I do not see where the division of responsibility occurs. I am endeavouring to help out the Minister, who, quite frankly, does not seem to be strong enough for the Minister for Finance in this matter.

Comment on this

I want to get a ruling on this matter. I am protesting against the debating of this motion. The Budget has been dealt with and passed, including the allocation of the taxes on petrol. Deputy Corry introduces a motion which I say is not in order and I want a ruling on it.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Would it not be the Minister for Local Government who would act on behalf of the Government if this motion were taken in Private Deputies' time?

Comment on this

No, the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government is responsible for the administration of the Road Fund and the allocation of it. I take it that he would answer on behalf of the Government if the motion were moved in Private Deputies' time. I suggest to the Chair that he is the Minister who would deal with it. It will not prolong the debate in any way if the motion is discussed now. Definitely it is a matter which is applicable to the Minister for Local Government's Department.

Comment on this

It was dealt with by the Minister for Finance in the Finance Bill. I am not responsible. I suggest that the matter is not in order.

Comment on this

This is not a Finance Bill. This is an endeavour on my part and on the part of my colleagues to get for the Minister for Local Government the finances necessary to put the roads for which he is responsible in a proper condition. I would expect to see the Minister voting in the lobby with me as well as my colleagues of all Parties who are members of the Cork County Council.

Comment on this

Would not any change in the matter of the distribution of such taxation as is mentioned here in this motion involve a change in legislation?

Comment on this

Apparently there has been some misunderstanding about this motion. I understand that it had been conveyed to us that the Government would permit the merits of the motion more or less to be discussed and that a vote would be taken on it afterwards. I do not know whether that was, in fact, a definite agreement. What I suggest to Deputy Corry is that if he would devote that part of his speech which he intended to make to the general demands which the maintenance of the roads in proper condition would make upon the finances of the State in one form or another and leave to one side the question of how the money would be provided we might conduct the debate on these lines and we might, if the Chair permitted, put the motion afterwards as a separate motion to be decided without discussion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is the first I heard of it. I have not seen or heard of this motion until I came in here. I do not think the Minister has either.

Comment on this

I never heard of it until it was introduced by the Deputy when making his speech.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When was the motion sent in?

Comment on this

The motion is on the Order Paper.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is taken from the Order Paper?

Comment on this

I understood it was to be taken in conjunction with the Estimate for Local Government. I understand that that was conveyed to the Whips. If there is any mistake about it, I want to have a day for the discussion of this away from any sidelines. I will have to get a free day for it. If I have not permission to move this motion now and have a separate vote of the House on it, then I would prefer to get time for it later on in the session. It is too important to be left over.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter could be discussed on the Estimate but a vote on it is quite a different proposition.

Comment on this

A discussion on the motion is not much good.

Comment on this

All this has been discussed on the Budget.

Comment on this

There were some discussions about trying to arrange the parliamentary programme and, in the course of these discussions amongst some Parties, the question of this motion arose and it was then suggested that perhaps a way out of the difficulty might be found if the merits of the motion, which relates to the amount of money which ought to be provided for the proper upkeep and maintenance of roads, could be discussed during the course of the debate on the Estimate for Local Government and that afterwards, as a separate and distinct motion, a vote might be taken on the motion without any further debate. I think that was the suggestion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Any objection?

Comment on this

I do not mind a discussion on the amount of money that ought to be spent but I am not going to be responsible for the collection of it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Then the amount of money can be discussed and there is no objection to a separate vote being taken without further discussion?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Very good. It was news to me.

Comment on this

As I said, in moving the motion, I have no doubt that I will have the support of every Deputy no matter what Party he belongs to, because we are in the position that the roads of this country were, in the first instance, built out of the ratepayers' money in the old Grand Jury days and that was carried on by the rates collected by the county councils when they came into being. These roads were built up by the ordinary country people paying each year their assessment on roads. Now of late years, and when I say of late years I do not mean the lifetime of this Government or the lifetime of any other Government, this thing of collecting money which is other people's property and devoting it to uses other than the use to which it should be put, namely, the improvement of our roads, has been carried on here. It is on account of that that we are anxious that the Government should step in and refund in the only way possible for them by handing over the money derived from the roads by motor taxation, petrol taxation and by the import duty on motor vehicles and devoting it to the roads for the next three years so as at least to bring them up to a condition in which they will be able to bear modern traffic.

The Minister might state that he was not the first bandit, but the facts remain that motor taxation went up during the past two years by over £750,000, and that petrol taxation went up by close on £2,000,000.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Was this Minister responsible in that matter?

Comment on this

I am speaking to the motion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I said that the Minister is not responsible for the collection of petrol taxes or the other taxes to which you referred. The Deputy should refer to the amount that should be spent on the roads and not ask this Minister to devote that money to specific purposes.

Comment on this

I am in the position that I had to pass my copy of the motion to the Minister. If anyone will supply me with the motion, I would know whether I was caught out or caught in.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will get a copy.

Comment on this

This amounts to £6,900,000 against which is set an amount of £2,300,000. That would give us £4,600,000 extra for the roads of the country.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You have a hope.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins seems anxious to interrupt. He is anxious, I am sure, to speak for his constituents in West Cork who came in a body and voted for this motion a fortnight ago in the county council. I am sure that Deputy Collins would like to carry out the wishes of the representatives of his own Party in the county council.

Let us have a look at the condition of those roads for which we want this money. The report of the deputy county engineer of Cork County stated on the 17th January, 1950:—

"We present our estimates for the year 1950-51 and this year we are making a radical change as we have made it out in two parts: (1) the minimum required for pure maintenance, and (2) a list of works of rolling, etc., on important non-rolled roads.

Our maintenance figures are the lowest at which we consider our roads can be maintained at their existing standard. The comparative figures of our estimate and the amount available in 1939/40 show an increase of 126 per cent. This at first glance seems large but is, in fact, on the small side as wages have increased from 35/- a week to 66/- a week, an increase of almost 90 per cent., and the price of cut back bitumen has increased from £4 1s. 0d. per ton to £15 12s. 4d. per ton, an increase of 385 per cent. This means that our surface dressing costs have gone up practically three times the pre-war price. Having regard, therefore, to the value of money, we are asking for less than was allowed pre-war.

The biggest factor of all we have left to last, namely, the intensity of traffic and the change that has taken place both in the location and weights of such traffic. Roads that only occasionally saw a lorry pre-war are now expected to take very heavy traffic and these roads have deteriorated sadly. In August, 1939, the number of vehicles taxed in County Cork was 5,571; in August, 1948, it was 8,997; in August, 1949, it was 10,791; and the estimate for 1950 is 12,300. In other words, our motor traffic has doubled in numbers and is getting on towards trebling, and the weights of the individual vehicles have also increased in nearly the same proportion, so that it would be fair to say that the total weight of motor traffic using the roads to-day is not less than four times that of pre-war.

Last year the amount of money available for county roads permitted only a negligible amount of surface dressing on existing surface-dressed roads and no money was available for this purpose from central funds, with the sole exception of a few miles of suburban roads carrying city bus services. In the South Cork district, for instance, there were 162 miles of surface-dressed roads at March 31st, 1949, and over 150 miles could not be done. This is a very serious situation as a few years of this would mean the breaking up of these roads and the loss of the capital expenditure involved in their making. The same applies, in a lesser degree, to the north and west areas, but the total money involved is not far short of £750,000.

In view of the above, we consider that we are justified in not accepting responsibility for the maintenance of the roads unless the sum asked for the purpose is made available.

In the course of the year, and in fact any year, representations are made in various ways to the council to have certain roads rolled, etc., and a common method of dealing with such applications is to refer them to the estimates meeting. We are now submitting a list of roads which, in our opinion, should be improved, and we give in each case an approximate estimate for the council to implement resolutions, or take such steps as it thinks fit. In considering this list, it can be borne in mind that a grant for the improvement of roads will, in all probability, be made available in the coming year much on the lines as in the current year."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy give the reference?

Comment on this

Column 1880 of the Official Debates of Thursday, June 15th.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We want it for reference.

Comment on this

That was signed by Mr. Coffey, Mr. O'Donnell, and Mr. P.J. Malone, the three deputy county engineers for the county. The report continues:—

"What is the result of that appeal? They say, in the first place, that the minimum required for road maintenance was: main roads, £160,000; county roads, £253,000. All they got from the county council was £136,000 for main roads and £206,000 for county roads, leaving a deficit of £71,000 for road maintenance on main roads alone."

The reason for that was that despite the fact that the cost of bitumen had gone up and wages had gone up, the Minister only made the same allowance in grant as was made in the previous year. The elected representatives on the Cork County Council could not see their way to place any further burden on already overburdened ratepayers.

Comment on this

Not the whole lot.

Comment on this

Deputy Desmond will have an opportunity of speaking on this Estimate. I advise him to take a look at the back numbers of the Cork Examiner and see what he did at the meeting of the Cork County Council. The position is that the roads in Cork County this year are being run, in respect of maintenance alone, on a sum which is £71,000 short of the lowest estimate the county surveyors could give, and I want the Minister to realise that.

With regard to the improvement looked for by the three county surveyors, the total estimate for the improvement, not of all the roads but of some of the roads in Cork County alone amounts to £1,000,000 or one quarter of what we are looking for in this motion, so that, at best, if this motion is carried, we could only do half the job of improvements which the surveyors say is necessary in Cork County this year.

These roads are the property of the local authority, the county council, and not the property of the State, and, if the State collects an income from these roads by way of motor taxation, petrol taxation or otherwise, every £ they collect means an extra deterioration in the condition of these roads and extra wear and tear on these roads. I am sure the Minister knows and appreciates that fact and he will appreciate my anxiety that these roads should not get into any worse condition than they are in now. They are the property of the local authority, as I say, and it is a new form—or, if you like, an old form —of highway robbery for the State to step in and give an individual a licence to travel over these roads, while drawing a tax from his petrol, when the roads which are worn by that individual are not the property of the State.

I am sure that the House will agree that transport has been completely revolutionised during the past ten years. One sees very few horses and carts or horses and butts going the roads nowadays. The bulk of the transport is motor-lorry transport. The bulk of the passengers travelling travel by car. We hear a lot about the dollars which the tourists bring in. They come in here and travel on one of these roads which the county surveyors have said will be unfit for traffic, if some radical change in the system of financing them is not made, and, if they break a couple of springs, they will not come again, and we will lose that asset.

I should like this matter to be taken seriously into consideration not alone by the Minister and the Government but by all the Deputies, each of whom in his own county is faced with the same condition of affairs as that with which we are faced in Cork. There is no justification for that condition of affairs being carried on week after week and month after month.

The Minister during the past fortnight has received from the Cork County Council an appeal which was passed unanimously by the council on exactly these lines, so that, in speaking here, I speak with the unanimous voice of the elected representatives of the Cork County Council. We all see what the position is and we see the condition into which these roads are falling day after day and week after week. In the case of a number of these roads, as I pointed out during previous discussions on roads, the water-table, instead of being in the dyke at the side of the road, as it used to be, is now in the centre of the road, and, despite the soft and cooing voice with which the Parliamentary Secretary told me some time ago that I could get such matters dealt with under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, I notice that, when these matters are sent in, they are turned down.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee said it is waste.

Comment on this

Every Deputy can answer for himself. I am putting my case and I can assure the Minister and his Parliamentary Secretary that, if the position were reversed in the morning and it was Deputy MacEntee who was sitting there, I would make the same case and put forward the same arguments. This is not a political matter with me. It is a matter of seeing that the property entrusted to us as representatives of the ratepayers, the property of which we are the custodians, will not be allowed to deteriorate, while money is taken out of it for purposes other than those to which that money should go, that is, the upkeep of the roads of the county. That is my attitude in this regard. Out of the county roads, the State has drawn an income which amounts to, roughly, £2,300,000 more than Deputy MacEntee drew when he was Minister in his last year of office. Surely we could expect that that £2,300,000 would go back into the roads and that the attitude of the Minister for Local Government would be that he would insist that at least he would hand back the roads to his successor in as good a condition as he got them. That would not be asking for too much. If these roads have deteriorated to the extent that there is £2,300,000 worth of traffic more on them, that £2,300,000 should go into the roads. There is no justification whatever for the attitude that has been adopted in this matter.

I am glad that we have not alone the opportunity before the recess of puting this case but that we also have the opportunity before the recess of having a separate vote on it and of enabling Deputies to come together on this and to insist, by passing this motion, that the local authorities will get what they are entitled to. That is all we are asking for. I consider that a three-years' programme on the lines I have suggested will undoubtedly bring the roads up to a standard that will bear the modern traffic that is imposed on them. It will relieve the Minister of nightmares. It will relieve him of a load on his mind every day, thinking of the condition of the roads, thinking of the deterioration of the roads and afraid of his life even to take his car into one of these by-roads for fear he would never come out of it again. The Minister knows the position that exists. The Minister knows that these roads are not fit for traffic. When the Minister is opening housing schemes some day, he may get into one of the bad roads and I would not like to meet the Minister when he would be stuck in one of them.

The condition of the roads is to my mind complete justification of the case we are putting up. I do not wish to delay the House on the Estimate in general. I could, perhaps, say a lot praising the Minister. I could perhaps refer to other things in which he is to my mind blamable. I consider that this matter transcends in importance any proposition that could be put up. I have great pleasure in moving the motion and recommending it to the House.

Comment on this

It is rarely I find myself in complete agreement with Deputy Corry but on this occasion I have pleasure in seconding this proposition.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not formally before the House. The Deputy appreciates that he is allowed to discuss it. It is not formally before the House. It is open for discussion only.

Comment on this

Is it not to be voted on?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

That is all we require. I will be as brief as possible. When I decided to attach my signature to this motion, it was not just through any caprice or for publicity of any sort. It was because I saw that it is a matter of dire necessity that something should be done to change the condition of our roads. Deputy Corry has given an account of conditions in Cork. Any Deputy or member of a local body who is sincere and honest in expressing his views can say the same of practically every county. It is true that, during the emergency, owing to turf production, in the West of Ireland, work on roads was very much neglected. Most of the men who had been engaged on the roads were engaged in the production of hand-won turf, with the result that the roads deteriorated greatly. Added to that, there was very heavy traffic. Lorries carrying many tons were travelling, not only over the main roads, but over the secondary roads, county roads and by-roads. The result is that there is great deterioration in the condition of the roads.

During the three years before Fianna Fáil left office, liberal grants were given for the restoration of the roads but that work was not completed. Last year we were notified by the then Minister for Local Government that our grants were to be cut down. We were also notified that a certain amount was to be allocated for the improvement of county roads. That was a good thing all right but I am afraid the Minister is very optimistic if he thinks that the amount allocated for the improvement of main roads will do anything appreciable in any reasonable time. At the rate we got grants, it would be about 70 years before we would have improved all our county roads and long before that time had expired there would be a great need for renewal. The amount granted for improvement of county roads is altogether insufficient.

Apart from the condition of county roads, main roads in many cases are very badly in need of re-surfacing and in fact many main roads in the West of Ireland should be rebuilt because they are not able to carry the traffic that they are carrying at the present time. In County Roscommon in only about two cases are the streets of our towns in a reasonable condition. The streets of all the other towns would need to be rebuilt. That would be a very big task and would require a great deal of money.

When Bord na Móna ceased production of hand-won turf, they left us a legacy of roads that were in a deplorable condition. Hardly a week passes that representations are not made to me by people who live along the roads asking that something should be done about them. Only a few days ago I was told of a bridge that was broken on a by-road. Bord na Móna left it there and it is now impassable.

Taking all things into account, I would say that the roads are in a very bad condition. I am not blaming the present Minister for Local Government. It was not he who first intimated that the road grants would be reduced, but I think he would understand that it was a very grave thing to do. Even allowing for the fact that in the last year we got something like £42,000 improvement grant for county roads, the net reduction, as we had estimated, was £78,000 for a mediumsize county. That was a very serious matter and has been a very serious matter since.

This year, in preparing his estimate, the county engineer estimated for over 50 per cent. more than we were prepared to give him. Unlike other counties, we did not continue the rate that had been struck in previous years. The roads had deteriorated so much that we decided—this applied to people of all Parties on the county council—to increase the rate for county roads alone by 1/8 in the £. Last year, when we were notified of the cut in road grants, we only raised the rate by 5d. in the £. Deputies can see that the raising of the rate by 1/8 in the £ is a very big step and represents very heavy expenditure on that particular item alone. If we increased the rate to the extent that the county surveyor would require, it would be increased by 5/- Even then, he would not be satisfied that we could put the roads into proper condition.

It may not be the best procedure to say: "Allocate to the local bodies an amount equivalent to what is raised in taxation on the various forms of motor vehicles." It does not matter what way it is obtained, the money is required. The total amount involved would be about £7,000,000, if all the money derived in one way or another from motor traffic were applied to the roads. If all that cannot be allocated, a very big proportion of it would be required for the next three years.

We brought in this motion in order to draw attention, in the first place, to the great necessity to do something. To do something small is not very much good: a large sum of money must be allocated if the roads are to be put into a reasonable condition. I would appeal to the Minister to accept this motion in principle. I am not asking him to accept the motion in its entirety, but I would ask him to accept it in principle. I know he is not the final authority in this. I know that the reduction of the road grant by £2,000,000 obviously is a Cabinet decision, that no Minister, not even the Minister for Finance, would attempt to make such a reduction, that he would have to get the sanction of his colleagues and if anything like this is to be put into operation it will have to get the sanction of the Cabinet. However, it is the responsibility of the Minister to try to get proper roads in the country.

The Minister, as Deputy MacEntee said, seemed to be rather complacent about the condition of the roads. I can assure him it is not a matter for complacency. It is a very serious matter. In our particular case—and we are not paying anything for health services at the moment; later it will come to the time when we will have to pay—we have already a rate of 24/2 in the £. No one used to a rate of 10/-, 12/-, or 14/- at the most, can look at the present position with any degree of satisfaction. It is a very serious state of affairs. While it is true that prices are pretty good for those who have land, this is becoming a very heavy burden.

Let us bear in mind that many of the ratepayers are paying for these roads for the use of motorists, people who have not even a donkey and cart themselves. It is not fair that poor ratepayers should be paying for those who are using motor vehicles. I understand that the number of heavy vehicles in recent years is about 100 per cent. more than it was formerly. Much of the work that was formerly done by Córas Iompair Éireann or its predecessors, the railway companies—in fact; the great bulk of that work—is being done by lorries which are carrying heavy loads. They do not go merely on the main roads which may be calculated to carry them safely, they go also on county roads and by-roads and even into culs-de-sac.

Here again we have a serious position with regard to these same culs-de-sac and I hope that in any extension of the grants to local bodies the Department of Local Government will consider some scheme by which they may be repaired and maintained. We have applications again and again before the county councils, but owing to legal difficulties we cannot do anything. It is not fair that the people who live in these culs-de-sac, in many cases a large number of families, should be condemned to slavery like that, as they have not the financial means to repair the roads.

I did not intend to speak at length, as I understand there is a question of trying to get Government business done and I do not want to impede it in any way. However, I do ask that when a vote is taken on this—as I hope it will be—the Deputies of all Parties will consider their responsibility to their constituencies and to the country in general. I do not think it is unreasonable to ask that substantial grants, such as we have asked for, should be made available for three years. After all, grants are being made available for many purposes, but anyone must admit that the roads are absolutely necessary arteries in the life of the country and must be maintained. Everyone realises that the longer you leave these roads in a bad condition the more costly it will be to maintain them. I travel over roads right beside me, up against my door; the paving stones were put there maybe 100 years ago. They are exposed and the whole surface is worn off, perhaps by motor traffic. I do not know how the vehicles travel on them at all. Consider what it will cost in a few years' time, if nothing is done.

I do not attribute any ill motives to the Minister or anyone connected with him, but I hope he will have something done in a big way to increase the grants. I suppose there cannot be any change in the present Estimate, but I ask that the grant be increased when the time comes. Deputy Corry mentioned a fairly definite sum and I think nothing less would be of much use. If we come back to normal in three years, we can consider the position that will then exist.

Comment on this

May I ask your advice, Sir, on this—are we discussing the Estimate in general?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, and the motion only incidentally.

Comment on this

It is satisfactory to see progress being made in housing. We have come to the time when it has been proved that the policy commenced so thoroughly by the late Minister, God rest his soul, is now bearing fruit. We have the satisfaction of seeing housing going on on a very satisfactory basis. I wish the present Minister luck in that and I hope that, through the co-operation of the various local authorities, housing progress, under the Minister responsible will, within a few years more, please God, ease the terrible burden and worry which is unfortunately the lot of many people. I am glad that in South Cork —where Deputy Corry, although he represents East Cork, is chairman of the board of health—we have made arrangements whereby the people entitled to houses are getting them. Even there—I do not say that Deputy Corry is in any way mixed up with this—we had outside influences and propaganda telling people they would not get the houses unless they joined certain political Parties. To be fair and honest, I am not coupling Deputy Corry's name with that, but I am speaking from experience and from what I know. I am glad that that has been eliminated and that we are now in a position to say to those people: "You are a worthy applicant for a house and the position is coming about whereby you will get it."

I am glad to see that, during the term of the present Minister and his predecessor, the road workers in the country as a whole have been made a little better off than they were. I hope that they will be in somewhat better circumstances financially and that the co-operation which is expected from them under ordinary circumstances will be forthcoming, through fair conditions being given. As we have seen, the introduction of the "Wet Time Act" was helpful to those people. I am not speaking in any sort of a biased way but we cannot forget, from our experiences in the past, that a change has come about in the conditions under which these road workers work down the country. Things are a little different now from the anxiety displayed by the wee Deputy from the north, Deputy MacEntee, who was so generous to our people down south that it nearly broke his heart to give them 2d. a day. I hope these times will never return and that whatever Government may be in power in this country and whatever Minister for Local Government may be responsible, and however, members of local authorities may differ politically, the workers will never be a pawn in the hands of either the Minister or the Government.

I want to refer very briefly to Deputy Corry's motion. It seems to be rather complicated and it is difficult to know the bounds within which we can discuss it. Deputy Corry mentioned that roads are the property of the local authorities. Let me say that I agree whole-heartedly with him there and that I have done so on many occasions in discussions in the Cork County Council. However, after that we differ. Deputy Corry says that they are the property of the local authority but that the central authority must repair them.

Comment on this

I say that they are the property of the local authority and that, while the local authority is entitled to assistance from the central authority, the local authority is bound to ensure that money will be secured locally as well as centrally for the upkeep and improvement of these roads. Public representatives, if they are honest and sincere enough to face their responsibilities, will realise that that is so. It is possible that Deputy Corry's colleague, who more or less seconded the motion, was not aware of all the circumstances. Will Deputy Corry deny that, when dealing recently with the roads estimates so ably covered by him by extracts from the Dáil debates, our surveyors told us they wanted a certain amount of money sufficient to keep the roads in their present condition and that the majority of the Cork County Council voted for a reduction on the surveyors' figures? Does he deny that?

Comment on this

Certainly. Will the Deputy allow me to explain?

Comment on this

I will give way to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I consider that where roads deteriorate as a result of action by an outside body, even if it be the State, and where they draw an increased income out of the deterioration of these roads, the State should pay the piper and not the other man.

Comment on this

I am glad that Deputy Corry said that, but he does not deny that the majority—it was not unanimous—of the Cork County Council decided, in respect of the figures submitted by their surveyors and engineers, that though these engineers were asking for a definite amount to keep the roads in their present condition that figure would have to be reduced by about 1/6 in the £. Considering that 1d. in the £ in Cork brings in £4,800, it is obvious that the majority of the members in the Cork County Council were so determined to see good roads in County Cork that they went so far as to reduce that figure by 1/6: that represents £4,800 multiplied by 18. I must say that I cannot see the sense of a motion being brought before this House by any member of a county council who will have to admit that what happens locally does not always tally with what happens here.

Has it not been made clear by Deputy O'Rourke that they do not care what happens in respect of a discussion here? They do not care if they have no discussion so long as there is a vote. Are we to forget that Deputy O'Rourke and Deputy Corry are preparing their guns for a local election and yet, despite all that political playacting, we have the sorry sight of a reduction of £4,800, multiplied by 18, in respect of the roads?

Comment on this

The grant.

Comment on this

Is it not fair to say that we should not act as hypocrites, saying here that we want more money while at our own county council meeting we say that we will not give up our share? The Waterford County Council, in their wisdom, decided that they would spend the money on their roads and put them in good repair. It is admitted that they have good decent roads now. However, through sheer neglect and sheer fright at the thought of spending one penny, they have squandered pounds in Cork by not keeping the roads in good repair. I put down a parliamentary question for answer yesterday and I would say, in connection with it, that at times in this House comparisons are made between the amounts given this year, last year, the year before that and the year before that again, and so on.

If we are to be fair and honest and desire to make a true comparison on the figures, surely we must, as I have asked in that question, make a comparison between the period 1941 to 1945 and 1946? Deputy Corry is as cute and as wise as any man in this House and I give him full credit for that. He knows full well that, in respect of the amounts allocated for each county and for Cork, in which both he and I are interested, while there are certain increases throughout these years, there was a balance accruing from the amount which was not given out in these years. In 1947—the time of the increased grant—even the increased grant itself did not make up for the amount not given out between 1941 and 1945-46.

I am at all times anxious to see the central authority put every penny they can into the Road Fund and through that into the roads themselves. But we in Cork must not forget that if we are paying increased motor taxation because of a large increase in the number of vehicles taxed and increased petrol duty, we have the right to travel the roads of every one of the Twenty-Six Counties. We are not paying that money simply for the right to travel the roads of Cork County alone. If we can travel over the roads of every one of the Twenty-Six Counties, surely it is only fair to admit that there is a certain amount of wear and tear on the roads of other counties caused by Cork men? I suppose that even here in Dublin we are responsible for a certain amount of wear and tear and that, even here, we are probably responsible for much wear and tear on the patience of our opponents at times.

As Deputy Corry is fully aware—but he escaped discussing it—the one line taken in the past was just the question of trying to get extra money some way or another—we had not the foggiest idea of what way we could get it. I believe the only sensible approach— other than by the local authorities facing their responsibilities—the only genuine approach would be, instead of the Minister allocating a certain amount out of the Road Fund each year and each county putting up its own amount, accepting the recommendation made by some of us on the deputation that saw the Minister. Deputy Corry was present, but I do not think he agreed too wholeheartedly with it. The recommendation was that, instead of raising a few hundred thousand each year, we should go somewhat further and raise up to £500,000 if necessary. In the meantime, we would be assured of a continuation of our slice out of the Road Fund each year to make up for what we would be getting in the ordinary sense.

I believe that is the only approach we can see—that we raise £500,000 and that we get a guarantee for a continuance of the money for Cork County out of the Road Fund. I ask the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary to bear that solidly in mind. Then if the local authorities do not face their responsibilities Deputy Corry will have full satisfaction in finding me voting against him.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy vote for that motion last Monday week at the Cork County Council meeting?

Comment on this

I made it perfectly plain that I did not agree with what was expressed when the chairman tried to bring in outside circumstances and when Deputy Corry admitted openly that it was playing into his hands becauses he had a motion down. If the records of the Cork County Council are checked it will be proved that while the chairman, who was at one time a member of this House——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think these Cork compliments should be exchanged in Cork.

Comment on this

That suits me.

Comment on this

I would like to see the Deputy voting the same way now as he voted last week.

Comment on this

I will always vote against you when I believe it is correct to do so.

Comment on this

I want to make a few suggestions to the Minister whose Department is now under review. The suggestions I propose to make are not in the form of criticisms. I think the time has come for us to reflect on what has been accomplished in the effort to bring about some system of relief for our people in the matter of housing. When we took over control of this country we inherited an amount of slumdom and, as time went on, under our own administration, there was created a situation in which we began to realise that not only should something be done rapidly, but that it should be done extensively.

In the period of the Cumann na nGaedheal régime, when housing was started on a comparatively large scale, some of us thought that it might be questionable to go on with the schemes then envisaged because we might only create new slums in the elimination of the ones then existing. In the City of Dublin, at any rate, where we had such a scarcity of accommodation and where we were forced over a number of years, particularly in the years prior to the outbreak of the war, to give priority to certain classes, the position became very acute. We had to give priority to families living in basements, families living in single rooms, families consisting of parents and maybe seven or eight children. We had to give preference to families where certificates of ill-health had been issued by the dispensary doctor.

In the case of families consisting of eight persons or over, we put them into ordinary small houses which were built in accordance with the regulations as they then stood. What was the result? Where we put a father and mother and, say, eight children into a small house, we found in the course of a few years that instead of there being a father and mother and eight children we had really ten adults in this small house. As children, the boys and girls shared the same bedroom, but to-day we have grown-up people, mixed sexes, sharing the same rooms and accommodation.

I suggest that in future schemes of housing on a large scale, consideration should be given to leaving some space to add on a room or two to houses which were built even in accordance with the present space standards. I also suggest that there should be a grant made available for local authorities so as to enable them to provide that extra accommodation. If officials of the Department will go round to Cabra or Crumlin or any other part of Dublin where these large housing schemes are in progress, and examine the houses and the occupants, I believe they will come back with the feeling that many of the houses are overpopulated. Some arrangement should be made whereby the tenants of local authority houses will derive some benefit in the shape of an additional room or two. In the case of future housing schemes that aspect should be kept in mind.

It is all very well to suggest that as time goes on and these young children grow up you can shift them from one place to another, but that cannot easily be done, because these houses are mainly built to the same standard. That applies to the types of houses made available to those who purchased under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. I would like the Minister to have this matter examined and he should endeavour to have consultations with local authorities, particularly in the City of Dublin, with a view to seeing how this position can be relieved. I have personal experience of this problem and I am aware that where we made available a good type of house, suitable for a young married couple with a certain number of children, in time the family increased, the children grew up and then you had in that type of small house a degree of overcrowding which made the position almost as bad as when those people were first taken out of their hovels or tenements.

There is another matter I would like the Minister to consider. We are now applying what are called differential rents. The idea behind that is that local authorities will be able to grade up or grade down the rents of their tenants in accordance with a tenant's income. I understand that has been tried out to a certain extent in Cork. It is being applied at present in Dublin. What I suggest is, that there should be some formula or machinery whereby this up or down arrangement in rents could be carried out more rapidly than at present. In answer to a question that was asked in this House recently we were given an astounding figure as to the number of applications made by the Dublin Corporation to secure possession of rented houses from tenants who had got into arrears in their rent payments. In a great many cases, a man in constant employment finds he has no money left out of his weekly earnings when he has met his liabilities. If he has the misfortune to lose. This employment he gets into arrears with his rent. The local authority can then start proceedings to secure possession of the house within a couple of weeks. My suggestion is that, where people's earnings change rapidly through loss of employment or some other unforeseen cause, there should be some formula or machinery by means of which there could be a lowering in the amount of rent and the application of the differential rent principle without hardship to the occupying tenant and without imposing unpleasant duties on the local authority officials. In these cases, too, the local authority representatives are often held responsible for what occurs. All that would be obviated if what I suggest were done.

I do not know how this differential rent principle is going to be applied finally. There seems to be, even in this House, a very great difference of opinion on the subject. Recently in a discussion in this House the Minister for Finance was obviously referring to economic rents in the sense that they must be economic to the local authority and to the State. Another member of the House, dealing with the same subject in almost the same words as the Minister, referred to economic rents as they affect the tenants. I am afraid that in the City of Dublin we are reaching the stage where we are being forced by circumstances to erect houses at rents which may ultimately prove to be too high for the tenants Therefore, I think we will have the same old problem all over again unless there is some formula or machinery whereby, on examination, rents can be fixed up and down in accordance with circumstances which arise suddenly in the case of the tenants.

I should like to have a statement from the Minister to clarify something which is not quite clear to me. The Minister for Local Government, and his predecessor in office, as well as the Taoiseach have, on a number of occasions, indicated that a shortage of money will not hamper the building of houses. We in the Dublin Corporation are not quite clear as to how these statements affect us. The City of Dublin raises its own loans for housing. Recently, there was a short hold up because of the difficulty of obtaining the full amount of money estimated to be required within a certain period by the corporation. It is true that we got the money at a later period. I should like, as I say, to have a statement from the Minister which would clarify the position where the Dublin Corporation or any other local authority finds it necessary to continue the building of houses on a large scale. I should like to have an indication from the Minister that, in these circumstances, there will be no hold up of schemes due to any shortage of money and that if the Dublin Corporation finds any difficulty in obtaining money from its bankers, the State will at any rate make it available to them.

We have now had some 30 years' experience in the provision of houses to meet what we think are our own needs. We may have made some mistakes. At the same time, I feel that the Minister and his Department cannot help but have sympathy with a point of view that I have expressed before. Take the case of a family which is taken out of a slum tenement and put into a new house. In time, the new house does not provide adequate accommodation for that family. In a case such as that, I think there should be not only permission to make an addition to the house to meet the needs of that family, but that there should be State assistance to enable it to be done. I think that would be preferable to having to build a new and larger house for that family which would involve the payment of State and local authority grants, the acquiring of land as well as the cost of building the house. I think that in the future where we are considering housing schemes on a large scale, that inherent in those schemes should be a provision for making additions to the houses at a future date when such additions became necessary. I think it would be far better do that than spend additional capital at a later date to meet the need which would then have arisen. I think that my suggestion, if adopted, would give real satisfaction to the people for whom we are providing houses at present. Certainly, under it they would have better living conditions than they have had in the past.

I do not know if what I am about to refer to will be ruled out by the Chair. In the City of Dublin—I take it this right also applies in the case of local authorities all over the country —if an application say for the erection of a cinema in a certain district is turned down, the applicant has the right of appeal to the Minister. The people of the district also have the right of appeal to the Minister. I think that is admitted. I wonder, in view of that, whether the Minister would listen to an appeal from a number of Dublin citizens and, possibly, from the corporation against the decision of another Department to take the Store Street premises for a purpose other than that for which that building was originally intended?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on this Estimate.

Comment on this

It arises in this way, that if I apply for a licence to build, say, a cinema in a certain area of the city, and if the corporation turn down my application, I have by law the right of appeal to the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no right of appeal from one Minister as against another.

Comment on this

I thought, perhaps, we might be able to appeal to him.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy thought he might be able to introduce a subject which was debated twice recently.

Comment on this

And probably will be debated a good many times more.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It may be, but not now.

Comment on this

We may try outside the House then by way of petition.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have no objection.

Comment on this

We are not discussing the proposed new Housing Bill, but I would like to draw the Minister's attention to a particular matter in connection with housing. Possibly, Deputy Captain Cowan will be angry with me for raising this. Where a person applies for a loan from a local authority, whether it is to buy a house built by a local authority or by private enterprise, under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act some limit should be fixed by the Department to the legal charges the proposed purchaser is asked to shoulder. On one occasion I pointed out that where the corporation bought a property and built identical houses on it, selling a number of them subsequently under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, the prospective purchaser was asked to pay legal charges almost equivalent to his buying the whole site, although it was a case of repetition as far as each house was concerned.

Comment on this

Surely they would not do that.

Comment on this

It was done to a great extent. It has now been changed somewhat by ourselves.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is that not a matter for the corporation?

Comment on this

No. It is a matter that——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Has the corporation nothing to do with it?

Comment on this

Yes, but the Department of Local Government has to do with it, too.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I want to know to what extent.

Comment on this

The Department of Local Government gives grants towards the erection of houses to be sold under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. In connection with the giving of the grant the houses must comply with certain regulations before they can benefit, but the Minister for Local Government exercises control.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Personally, I have no objection to this being developed but, clearly, it is a matter for the Minister for Justice and not for the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I just wanted to hear the Deputy on it. I have asked him to prove if it has anything to do with this Estimate.

Comment on this

The Minister for Justice is in the House now.

Comment on this

I feel there should be control over the costings by the Department of Local Government. The Department does consider the costings in connection with the acquisition of the site. It considers the tenders.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand the contracts are given by the corporation.

Comment on this

Subject to the control of the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Am I right in saying that the contracts are given by the corporation? If so, they have to deal with the legal aspect of the matter and not the Minister.

Comment on this

I am talking of the contract between the purchaser of the house, whether he buys it through a local authority loan or through some outside body.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Local Government has nothing to do with that.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The question of cost is one between solicitor and client.

Comment on this

I suggest that, since, the time has come when the ordinary working class people are being enabled to buy their own little bit of property, the Minister for Local Government should specify the maximum legal costs falling on the shoulders of such prospective purchasers.

Comment on this

He cannot do that

Comment on this

I am not interested in the question of costs as between solicitor and client. I am not dealing here with an ordinary business transaction. Obviously, every penny these people have to find by way of deposit is a hardship; otherwise, we would not have this proposed new legislation. If, on top of that deposit, they have to find £100 or so by way of legal expenses ——

Comment on this

That does not arise. It is nonsense.

Comment on this

I have known many cases where, in my opinion, the charges were certainly on the high side. Where the ordinary workingclass person is acquiring a house there should be specially fixed rates of legal charges.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Surely the Deputy is advocating new legislation.

Comment on this

I am not advocating new legislation. I am making a particular suggestion to the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Local Government has nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy was told that already.

Comment on this

I do not know who will deal with it. I shall have to find out. Perhaps the present occupant of the Chair could advise me which Minister is responsible.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

I do not offer any criticism of the Estimate. I merely make certain suggestions. I think those in charge of our housing schemes should now pause and reflect on what has been accomplished. They should consider in how far it has benefited the recipients of new houses. They should ask themselves whether the houses provided are now adequate for a completely adult family or whether it is desirable that some additions should be made to them. In particular, they should consider the possibility in the future of designing houses to which it will be possible to add one or two rooms should it be found necessary to make such additions in order to accommodate a completely adult family. I think we should now have some better idea of housing in general and perhaps the Minister can improve on the suggestions I have made to improve a situation which is gradually. becoming objectionable.

Comment on this