Vote 38—Local Government.
Contributions 140–274 of 274. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Deputy Briscoe has made some interesting observations in regard to this family moved from an overcrowded slum area into a corporation house; after a number of years he says that the family becomes just as overcrowded in their new circumstances. I do not think that is so. If it does happen, it can last for only a very limited period because, as a general rule, the boys marry after a few years and leave the house; likewise, the girls marry and leave the house. In the end, we have the father and the mother left alone. We have just got to face realities in regard to this and the suggestion of making provision for the building of an extra room is not practical or practicable at all
Comment on this
Some of them may. It is the experience of all of us that for a particular period all the family are at home. Then they start to drift away and the family gradually gets smaller. I would not think that there is any point really in this idea of building extra rooms. Anyway, there would be a tremendous lot of trouble in regard to it in the city. I think the Minister should be congratulated on the work done during the past 12 months. The very fact that he has introduced this new Housing Bill which meets points of view that were expressed by a number of us over the past two years is an indication that the Minister has listened to reasonable proposals put up to him in this House. I felt very happy when I saw the provisions of this new Housing Bill, which will be before the House probably to-morrow and which, I hope, the House will pass with very little discussion, because it is such an important measure that it is vital it should be on the Statute Book before the Dáil goes on holiday, whenever that will be. The Minister has also introduced the County Management Bill, which gives the House an opportunity of discussing that very difficult and intricate problem. Not only does it give us an opportunity of discussing the position of county managers but it opens the way to a consideration of the problem of city managers and that is a problem with which Dublin Deputies are particularly concerned.
Comment on this
I was just waiting for the Deputy to develop his point. I understood the Deputy was making these observations to show that it was not necessary to discuss administration in regard to these particular points.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy made any observations on the measures. I think he merely said that it was not necessary to discuss administration in regard to these particular points because these measures were on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
That comes exceptionally well from the Deputies who have spoken, particularly on the debate which concluded last night.
Comment on this
Let us get on to the Local Government Estimate.
Comment on this
These two measures which have been introduced by the Minister for Local Government show the progress that has been made by the Department during the past 12 months. If I keep to the administration of the past 12 months, I shall be perfectly in order. It is, I think, one of the very good signs that democracy is really in operation in this country, that the desires of Deputies should be translated into Bills which are brought within a reasonable period before the Dáil for consideration. The main item on which I want to address my few remarks to the House is building, particularly in the City of Dublin. No doubt there has been substantial progress over the past couple of years. The pace is being accelerated, not to the extent that one would like to have it accelerated, but nevertheless there has been an increasing tempo in the production of houses. Deputies who have to meet night after night their constituents who are anxious to get houses can now see day after day particular individuals who are bad cases being housed by the Dublin Corporation. I think that is something that every Dublin Deputy particularly is glad to see. There is nothing so welcome in the morning as a letter from the Dublin Corporation to say that Mr. So-and-So is about to be provided with a house in one of the new building schemes.
Comment on this
All the Dublin Deputies do and I can assure the House that they are very welcome letters indeed. I should like to see more of them. I should like to see the tempo increased. I was disturbed recently by a report in the Irish Press that there had been some reduction in the number of persons employed in the building of houses by the Dublin Corporation. I hope that the Minister will deal with that matter when concluding. It is clear, it appeared to me at any rate, that that is just a temporary phase while work is about to be commenced on another scheme. During the debates last year and the year before on this Estimate and in questions I addressed to the Minister and his predecessor, I asked the Minister to ensure that adequate lands and building sites would be available so that as high a production of houses as was humanly possible would be achieved. I should like to see on hands sites that are being built on, sites that are being developed, sites being prepared for development and sites in course of acquisition. That will be necessary if the full scale housing programme is to be carried out.
In that connection I mentioned last year and the year before the position in regard to the St. Anne's estate where sites are available for thousands of houses, but those sites cannot be built on because there is no sewerage scheme. I recommended to the Minister and to his predecessor that that sewerage scheme should have been tackled as a matter of grave emergency and that, if necessary, men should be employed on that scheme for 24 hours a day working in three eight-hour shifts with electric light at night in the way the Shannon scheme was developed. If we are to make substantial progress with housing in Dublin, it is essential that the facilities available on the St. Anne's estate should be utilised and they can only be utilised if the sewerage work is completed and that should be done as soon as possible. I repeat my request to the Minister that he should discuss with the Dublin Corporation the undertaking and the completion of that sewerage scheme by the employment of all the unemployed people in the City of Dublin working on shifts of eight hours per day.
In the City of Dublin we have quite a number of suitable sites for the building of flats. Those sites are derelict all over this city. You find them in my constituency and in other constituencies. There is a general desire on the part of a number of people in Dublin who need houses that they should be housed in flats convenient to the locality in which they reside, in which they were born and reared and in which their fathers and mothers before them were born and reared. That is a reasonable desire on the part of those persons and I think the Minister should discuss with the housing director and with the Dublin Corporation the development of all these available sites so that flats would be built upon them as soon as possible. On the North Strand, where houses were blown down by a bomb or a land mine which was dropped there during the war, there are sites for quite a number of flats which would house a very large number of families in the vicinity who are living in overcrowded and insanitary tenements at present. The building of those flats could go on hand in hand with the building of houses in the outlying area.
In that regard, I have felt that there should be some improvement in the machinery dealing with the allocation of houses. The people are anxious to be housed as far as possible in their own areas. Under the system of priorities that exists people living and working on the North side find themselves housed on the South side and people who are living on the South side find themselves housed on the North side a considerable distance away from their places of employment.
Comment on this
I realise that. There are difficulties, however, in connection with the matter because the priorities have to be followed. There are difficulties also in the matter of the transfer, because very frequently one recommends two families for transfer and it is not always possible to obtain sanction to the transfer however strong the ground for the recommendation may be. However, that is only a detail in comparison with the more important matter of providing houses for the people who need them and probably by a system of transfer, which may be made more easy after the City Management Act is amended, all those difficulties can be ironed out.
Comment on this
The vanguard. Recommendations have been made in previous years to the Minister to ensure that local halls, recreation grounds, gymnasiums and public parks are developed and constructed in connection with all the new housing schemes. While that is primarily a matter for the Dublin Corporation——
Comment on this
——I think it is something on which the Minister should take a pretty firm stand with the Dublin Corporation and all local authorities. If new housing schemes are developed, if thousands of houses are being built in a particular area which has been open country, those citizens who are being brought out there should be provided with all those facilities and amenities and, side by side with the building of houses, quite a good lot of work can be done with regard to the provision of recreation grounds and the building of halls and gymnasiums. The citizens of Dublin and the citizens of any other city or town are entitled in this century to have those amenities. I do not think that the provision of those amenities is going to affect the rates very seriously.
Comment on this
We have given that great study in the corporation and also the provision of playgrounds.
Comment on this
I should like to see those provided all over the city. Some of those parks in my opinion would be ideal.
Comment on this
If those amenities and facilities are necessary—and I think everybody agrees that they are necessary—then we should not be stopped simply by the possibility that the provision of those things will lead to some slight increase in the rates. Naturally I am not going to develop that matter now——
Comment on this
——but it is the general opinion of the citizens that with the reorganisation of Dublin Corporation and Dublin Corporation services there could be quite a big reduction in the rates in Dublin City. However, there will be a new corporation in a very short time and I think that the new corporation will have the responsibility of probing into that matter.
Comment on this
The Department after all is subject to some extent in this democratic age to the views of local councils and public representatives, but——
Comment on this
—— that is a development which Deputy McGrath would not understand. It is coming along so easily that unless you look out for it you will not see it.
I am glad that the Minister for Justice is here because there is one aspect of this matter that touches to some extent on his responsibilities although strictly it is a matter for the Minister for Local Government. Deputy Briscoe has mentioned the point about evictions, notices to quit and proceedings to eject corporation tenants. It is quite a common thing every week in the City of Dublin to see hundreds of persons, occupants of corporation houses, summoned to attend before the District Court in proceedings for ejectment. The strange thing about it is that Dublin Corporation as a corporation have no responsibility whatever with regard to that nor are they consulted. The notice to quit is issued allegedly on the authority of the city manager; it is signed by an official of the corporation and served on the particular individual who is brought to court. The citizen, the tenant of the corporation house, has no defence whatsoever to the proceedings which are brought by the corporation as the district justice, however sympathetic he may be—the very same thing applies to county council houses and houses owned by local authorities all over the country——
Comment on this
No, Sir; I am trying to relate it to the responsibilities of the corporation.
Deputy Briscoe rose.
Comment on this
It is a point of information to the Chair. Any local authority is bound by the Minister for Local Government to take these steps where tenants get into arrears. Otherwise the Minister for Local Government through his auditors comes down on them. I want to point out that Deputy Captain Cowan is following a point I raised. I thought I was in order.
Comment on this
Where they are in arrears for a couple of weeks proceedings are taken. As a matter of fact they are not based on any law but on Orders issued by the Department of Local Government and in so far as that is the case I am absolutely in order. The difficulty I am up against is that under the County Management Act the authority is taken from the corporation in these matters and given to the city manager.
Comment on this
I will not mention what is in the new Bill but I hope there will be some provision in it before we finish with it to deal with that. While there may be some instructions regarding rent there are quite a number of matters which have nothing whatsoever to do with rent, in which a neighbour may send in a complaint about an individual, in which an anonymous communication may be received, in which there may be some little trouble between a caretaker and a particular tenant.
Comment on this
In all those cases notices to quit are served and proceedings are brought. In fact, it seems to be nonsense to bring them before a district justice because he has no authority except to give a decree.
Comment on this
The Deputy must realise that once a notice to quit is issued by the local authority and court proceedings are taken thereafter it is justice that deals with the matter and not local government, which we are discussing or should be discussing.
Comment on this
Walking on the tight rope I am on at the moment, the position arises, anyway in the City of Dublin, that hundreds of tenants of corporation houses are mulcted in 10/- or 15/- costs every week. I would ask the Department of Local Government to look into this matter. I have not the statistics with me at the moment and I cannot say how many houses in Ireland——
Comment on this
On a point of order. I submit that the Deputy is discussing the administration of the City of Dublin under the County Management Act. It is strictly in accordance with the provisions of that Act and the Minister for Local Government has no responsibility for legislation which this House has passed. He has only to administer it.
Comment on this
It was alleged just now that the Minister for Local Government had issued Orders in that respect. If Orders were issued they are administration.
Comment on this
I have not the statistics to indicate to the House the number of houses in Ireland that are local authority houses, but I know that there must be some 70,000 cottages, some thousands of houses in Dublin City and some in other cities.
Comment on this
Some of them have I been built for 50 years. These are all local authority houses. The point I am trying to make is that, developing as we are, in a very short time, the local authorities, or the Government through the local authorities, will be the biggest landlord we ever had in this country.
Comment on this
Is already. I would ask the Minister to consider that, where the old landlord system has been replaced by this new system of State or local authority landlords, there ought to be some protection for these thousands of tenants who are occupying local authority houses.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cowan is allowed to proceed without interruption from Deputy Briscoe, we will reach a conclusion more quickly.
Comment on this
I am very grateful to the Chair and to the House for their indulgence in enabling me to get this point over to the Minister.
Comment on this
As I say, I am very grateful, and I hope the Minister will note the point I have been making in this regard. I want to follow the very good example set by Deputy MacEntee in making a brief contribution to the debate and I conclude in the way I started, by saying that the Minister deserves the thanks of the House and the country for the way in which he has approached the serious problems facing his Department within the past 12 months. If he and his Department continue on the same lines during the next 12 months, I think we shall all have cause to congratulate him this time next year.
Comment on this
I want to say a certain amount about the development of roads. Since we have had this very large cut in road grants in the periods 1948-49 and 1949-50, it has obviously become essential to reconsider the whole question of road improvement and road maintenance in the light of modern conditions. The roads of this country have the same importance, from the point of view of the national economy, as Córas Iompair Éireann, the housing of the people or the provision of electric power. They should be considered as a whole and as part of a long-term plan. Quite evidently, there must be some priorities, and it is not for me to say that a mile of road should be built at the expense of one house or group of houses for the people, but, nevertheless, as I have said, the maintenance and improvement of roads. is a question of vital national importance.
Any neglect on the part of the State to preserve existing road surfaces simply has the effect of doubling the burden of expenditure upon ratepayers and taxpayers in the next ten years, and every year that passes in which insufficient money is spent simply adds, by geometrical progression, to the amount of money which has to be spent by the Government that will succeed the present Government, whatever its complexion or political view. I think that we consider far too many problems in the light of an immediate political situation and the Government, having already decided to impose on the next generation a very considerable burden of expenditure through the repayment of debt, might at least consider the opposite and see how far they can save the next generation money by the proper planning of the roads.
The fundamental facts of the situation are well known to those in this House who have studied roads as a problem by themselves. There are 50,000 miles of public roads, of which some 40,000 miles are county roads and 10,000 miles main roads. Nearly all the main roads are surface dressed, with a few exceptions, and some of the county roads are also surface dressed, but very small in proportion. There are also some 20,000 miles of non-public roads. That figure I have always regarded as very large. It was an estimate by an officer of the Minister's Department, and, whether it is 12,000, 15,000 or 20,000, it is a very large mileage of roads which are not administered or repaired by any one public authority. In 1938-39, there were some 73,000 vehicles. In 1949, that number had increased to 122,000, and, of these, 32,000 were public service and commercial vehicles—an increase of 66 per cent. in the total number of vehicles and of 100 per cent. in the number of goods vehicles, which do most of the damage.
We made a calculation at one time that, by the middle of the war, the capital investment in the roads of the country had already reached the huge figure of some £25,000,000 and, allowing for costs of maintenance and improvement, that figure has increased many times since then. Most of the 20,000 miles of non-public roads are in a deplorable condition, arising from heavy turf transport and from the fact that, in the course of the past 16 years, it was not possible to carry out improvements in every direction at the same speed. My own belief is that one of the most prominent causes of emigration is the fact that the young people will no longer tolerate conditions under which they have to go to Mass, to school, to amusements of any kind or to work, along roads which are utterly out-of-date and which would have been continuously improved but for the advent of the world war, for which no one in this House was responsible.
My views about road improvement are partly based on the idea that, if we want to keep the young people here, we must make communications far more satisfactory. We also have to face the fact that, no matter what the Government of the day does in regard to Córas Iompair Éireann, no Government in this country is likely to take any action which will prevent people owning their own vehicles and transporting their goods from one destination to another. As the Minister knows, the whole problem of Córas Iompair Éireann eventually boils down to the fact that the overhead charges involved in handling goods at either end of the journey, when leaving and when arriving, and in using frequently two and three kinds of transport to carry these goods are so high that no public transport system, however perfectly run, is going to be able to compete completely and adequately with those who wish to bring their goods in their own vehicles.
The position is that Córas Iompair Éireann is likely in future to close down a number of branch lines—it is almost inevitable under existing circumstances—and the more branch lines that are closed down, the greater will be the burden upon the roads. At the same time, as the Minister knows, the number of cars is going to increase continually year by year, until the time is reached when any person above the level of the most modest wage will have some sort of motor vehicle. It is becoming a universal thing in this life from which we cannot possibly escape. Along with all this, the cost of road repair and improvement has increased, on the Minister's own admission, by 125 per cent. My own belief is that that is a minimum figure.
I would say that by the time wages have increased again this year, the increase in cost might possibly be 135 per cent. The principal cause has been the increase in wages so desperately needed by road workers and which has taken place under successive Ministers for many, many years. I should like to add at this point that the attempts made by certain Deputies to give the impression that the present Government alone has raised the wages of the workers is, in the circumstances, ridiculous, since, if I remember rightly, road workers' wages were something in the neighbourhood of 25/- to 35/- before the world war and have been rising continually ever since then. They rose, I think, in every year of the last five years of the office of the previous Government. I may add, of course, that a great many other social services were conferred upon road workers at the same time by the last Government, still further improving their position.
I am glad to see, in that connection, while I am speaking on the matter, that the Minister has continued the encouragement of the provision of protective clothing by county councils. We, I remember, issued various notices about that asking county councils to improve their standards in regard to the protective clothing being given to workers and, from an answer to a parliamentary question I got the other day, I can see that very considerable progress is being made.
Comment on this
That is the position. I think it is Just as well to give the figures to the House in regard to where we stand in regard to the amount of money available. In 1938-39, we had for road expenditure from all sources a total of £2,025,000, of which the rates paid about two-thirds. In 1949-50, that amount had gone to £4,640,000, of which the rates provided about half. The Road Fund grants were £700,000. in 1938-39 and £2,346,000 in 1949-50. That sum looks very substantial. It looks, at first sight, as though we ought to be able to do very good work on the roads but, according to the Minister's own admission, £225 in this year will be required to do the work that £100 did in 1938-39. He cannot escape from that one hard fact.
If you apply that simple mathematical sum to the amount of money made available in 1949-50, you find that the real increase on road expenditure, having regard to its value, is only 10 per cent, since 1938-39. You simply take the total of £4,640,000 and say that every £225 of that will only do the work of £100.
There is no cooking of these statistics. It is a simple problem for the Minister to face, which the Minister of State for every other Department has had to face in connection with the task of providing money for services, perhaps not in the same degree but nearly in the same degree. If you apply that principle, you find that the real increase in the amount of money made available for the roads is only 10 per cent. above 1938-39. The traffic density has increased by 66 per cent. and goods vehicle density has increased by 100 per cent. It is quite obvious that the Minister will have to reconsider the whole problem.
I am not suggesting that the Minister could necessarily have done that in his first year of office. I would like to be as generous as I can but one cannot escape from these figures. There is no reinterpretation of them. They are there for everyone to see.
If you apply that same principle to main road grants—again from figures which I secured by answer to a parliamentary question, you find that even the very large grants made available by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1948-49 were not entirely sufficient to account for the increase in the cost of road improvement, although they went a good way towards it—you find that, in relation to 1949-50, there is an actual decrease in the amount available for main roads of 31 per cent. Again applying the same principle of what value can be effected in road improvement or restoration by the money, in comparison with 1938-39, there is a reduction of 31 per cent.—an increase in terms of money but a reduction in terms of value effected. It is quite obvious that the main roads can never stand up to the burden of traffic, can never be made suitable for this country, can never be made to compare with roads in other countries with the same standard of living as we have unless that situation is changed.
I next come to county roads. Here there has been relatively more improvement in the amount of money made available than in the case of the main roads. The total amount made available for county roads in 1938-39 from rates alone was £853,000. In 1948-49, the total amount available from rates and the new Road Fund grants was £2,601,000 and the amount available in 1949-50, was £2,696,000.
I should mention, in passing, that the suggestion that the present Government have given a great deal more money for county roads is not true in the sense of the total amount of money made available as compared with what Fianna Fáil made available in 1948-49. It is true that the total amount of money made available from all sources is greater than it was in our last year of office but the actual sum is very nearly the same, according to the figures given to me in answer to a parliamentary question. The increase there is very considerable but, if you apply the same rule of relating the figure to value performed, you will find that the increase from the point of view of value is only really about 50 per cent. for county roads as compared with 1948-49, and even that increase does not relate to the numerical increase in the actual density of traffic on the roads and, therefore, the amount of damage which will be done. Traffic, as I have already said, has increased by 66 per cent. for all cars and 100 per cent. for public service and goods vehicles. There is the problem that has to be faced.
I next should advert to the fact that the Road Fund Grant, as the Minister knows, was allocated in reference to the local contribution in the three years before he took office and was also related to the number of cars registered in a particular area, the population of the area and the road mileage in the area. These were the factors, when we were in office, and we considered at that time adding a further factor in calculating the Central Fund contribution. We decided that we should have a special factor for tourist roads, where they were of vital interest to the tourist industry, that if there was a road such as the road that takes people around the Ring of Kerry, there should be some special allowance for a road of that description, irrespective of what the unemployment was in the area.
We also decided that we should give special grants to counties where main roads pass through a county which have very little local interest. A good example would be the main road from Dublin to Cork when passing through Tipperary. So far as I know, from talking to people in that area, the road from Cashel North to the Tipperary boundary has very little local interest to people living in the county, whereas the portion of the road from Dublin to Cork going South from Cashel to Cahir and Mitchelstown would have much more local significance. We decided that there should be another factor used mathematically by the Minister's Department when calculating Central Road Fund grants allowing for that question of the local interest attached to a main arterial road going from Dublin to some place in the West or South or going between two towns.
One could give as a further example the Cork-Mallow road. Although it is an arterial road that goes on to Limerick, it will obviously have very considerable local interest to the people of both Cork and Mallow. There are many other examples of the same kind that will occur to Deputies.
The Minister knows that £300,000 of the Road Fund is now taken for ordinary revenue purposes. That was done by the former Government. If the Minister were to calculate the figure—I may be wrong—he would find that, before the world war, when conditions for improving roads were fairly normal, the amount of money spent out of road rural grants from the Special Employment Schemes Office was greater than the total raid on the Road Fund over a period. I am fairly certain it was greater; I am certain it was as large. There was no great raid on the total moneys available for improving roads.
The Minister has to face the fact that upon the present horse power basis of taxation the increase in taxation that comes from the number of cars on the road has no relation to the increase in the cost of road expenditure. He gets more money because there are more cars on the road; the cars do more damage, so there is no absolute increase in the amount available for repairing and improving roads. The increase in taxation for small vehicles which was imposed in October, 1947, according to a reply to a parliamentary question, I think it was in the year 1948-49, only provided £300,000 out of a total of £2,400,000. In other words, there is a deficiency of money available for road repair and improvement, because motor taxation has remained stable. That is the fact, even although the number of vehicles on the road has trebled since 1938-39. Even though they have trebled, there is still a deficiency of money. The road contribution has not increased in the same proportion and the rates cannot bear any more expenditure on roads, or very little, and as a result there is this very considerable deficiency.
As the Minister knows, the petrol tax yielded a sum of £3,200,000 in 1949-50. One, of course, can argue until the cows come home whether some of that should be made available for roads or not. Once it goes into the general revenue, it is simply a matter of saying that you have an excuse for providing a sum of money from general revenue for roads, as in that huge sum of money there is some which comes from petrol tax. If we estimate that that £3,000,000 is actually revenue from petrol used on the roads, it would amount to about £24 tax per vehicle in the country— which is a considerable amount. I know that that is a very specious argument, as the money is intended for general revenue purposes; and I merely use it as an illustration of the way by which the Minister might secure more money for roads from the Minister for Finance.
What all this really means is that the Minister must have more money, and a very good illustration of his need for more money is a statement that was made by one county engineer to a county councillor in a certain county, who was asked to state what he considered to be the amount required to keep his roads in their present condition without further deterioration. He said he required, for that particular county, £112,000 for main roads and £116,000 for county roads, just to keep them in their present condition. The amount he got was £47,000 for main roads and £53,000 for county roads.
Now, even allowing for the fact that any county engineer might be inclined to exaggerate somewhat enthusiastically the money that he could spend on maintenance or improvement, it is quite obvious that there is a deficiency. County engineers have presented county councils with estimates of that kind all over the country and even if you were to make a large allowance for exaggeration or for their putting up far more than they could possibly get, this is the clearest proof, clearer than all the statistics I have given, that the Minister should do his best to find more money for the roads.
There is another question, the question of Offaly. I do not know whether Deputy Davin is in the House, he would know about this. In some counties turf production continued in great volume to the very end. The Road Fund grants under present circumstances depend upon the county expenditure in the three years preceding the Minister's entry into office. In Offaly, as in other counties, they could not take full advantage of the big grants given by Fianna Fáil. They spent less, as they were still doing turf, and they could not find the workers to do the large amount of work in the summer. Unless the Minister has changed his method of allocation, these counties still continue to suffer relatively to others. The counties best off were those able to take the fullest advantage of the grants made available by the former Government and there were certain counties where the position is worse than in others. If one were to apply in this case the rule as to what money will do in relation to value, I think the Minister will find that in the present year County Offaly is getting less money than it got in 1938-39 actually, because of the two factors— £225 doing the work of £100 and the fact that Offaly went on with its turf work and could not get workers for roads during the period which the Minister uses as his datum period. If the Minister has changed his method of allocating grants, I would be very glad to hear it, but I think that the method is a little unfair in present circumstances.
When I speak of this deficiency of road expenditure, there are a number of other factors to be taken into account. There has been an increasing use of machinery on roads, which should increase output. There is certainly far better work than ever before being done by county engineers in all counties. There is a better class of stone being used in many counties, as a result of the previous Government's work and the policy advocated by the Minister, of preparing central quarries where stone of approved quality, that could be analysed in advance, could be crushed and prepared as chips for the road. Another factor to be taken into account is that modern lorries are much better sprung than the older ones were and do much less damage to the roads than in 1938-39. That does not apply to some of the war surplus lorries running still, which do more damage in five minutes than six others of the more modern type.
On the other hand, against all that, we have not one-tenth enough modern machinery for use on the roads and there is not half enough competition between contractors and direct labour work to keep up the output. Also, the huge programme of post-war dressing of the roads was never intended to be permanent in many cases. In many cases, the heavy traffic is already beginning to destroy the surface. One only has to travel, as I do on occasion, throughout the country to see some of the very well-made roads that have had to experience extremely heavy traffic, beginning to deteriorate. The waterproof surface is slowly beginning to disintegrate; it has not gone very far, but is absolutely bound to continue unless some of these roads are improved in a permanent way, with solid stone foundations and all the other appurtenances of a modern road.
I next come to the non-public roads, the cul-de-sac roads in the country, of which I have said there are 20,000 miles. As the Minister knows, it is not possible under present conditions for local authorities to repair those roads except when, as in many counties, they administer grants made available by the Special Employment Schemes Office, if the unemployment is sufficient.
The position is, from the point of view of the Minister, that those non-public roads are repaved by three different agencies at the moment—by the Land Commission, by the local authority working on behalf of the Special Employment Schemes Office and by the Special Employment Schemes Office direct. Grants are given for those roads not on the basis of functional need, density of traffic or any other technical factor but (a) because of the number of registered unemployed in the electoral division concerned, (b) because they carry a certain amount of turf, (c) as a result of the local contributors having agreed to put up what used to be 25 per cent. and what in future, I understand, will be a percentage varying according to the valuations of the persons concerned, or (d) by the Land Commission for the improvement of newly divided estates. I would point out that the actual value of farm residences in some cases decreases by as much as 50 per cent., if they are situated at the end of a long boreen on which there may be as many as 15 or 16 other residences. The amount of money made available from the Special Employment Schemes Office, based on all types of schemes was £225,000 in 1938-39 while in 1949-50 it was £152,000. There is a real reduction there of some 70 per cent. if you apply the rule that roughly £225 will do the work of £100 pre-war.
That is a very serious matter and it is going to alter not only the whole question of the valuation of farms in the future but the more people become modern-minded in this country the more intolerable they will consider these boreens to be. I suggest to the Minister that he should consider a long-term policy designed to provide some means of repairing those boreens and improving them by reference to the functional need, the density of traffic and their condition. I suggest that he can still go on employing people where they have to be employed; that he can ask the users to make the same contribution if he thinks it necessary but that they should be considered as part of the road system in this country. If the Minister reads my own observations on that matter when I was Parliamentary Secretary in connection with a debate that took place on a private Members' Motion, he will find that I said that the only excuse we had then for not considering that matter was the vast amount of restoration which required to be done after the war and the need to overcome deficiencies created through war conditions. I clearly indicated that I knew the problem would have to be tackled; that you could not go on leaving 20,000 miles of non-public roads as compared with 50,000 miles of public roads subject to the improvement by any kind of method except functional need and density of traffic. He will realise that I am not, therefore, speaking inconsistently or trying to place suddenly on his shoulders a burden which I did not even consider at that time.
So far as the main roads are concerned, they are out of date for huge stretches in respect of their width, their vertical elevation and their foundations. They are particularly out of date over bogs and they constitute a danger to life in many places. They have, in particular, the effect of causing extreme physical fatigue to drivers. Everybody knows that accidents do not necessarily take place at corners. The cumulative effect of physical fatigue on a driver on a bad road or a road that curves the whole time is to increase the possibility of accidents. Wherever main roads are too narrow in a dense traffic area they are an absolute menace to life. The Minister will be aware that it is in the narrow stretches of the Bray road that most of the accidents occur, according to a report prepared by the Garda Síochána. The county roads are far below adequate standards and only the outbreak of the world war prevented far more being done to them before. I asked the Minister a question in regard to the cost of improving county roads per mile. In his reply on Tuesday, 14th March, 1950, he said:—
"The figure of £1,850 per mile may be taken as reasonable for the improvement (including widening) and surface dressing of a typical mile of county road but it would not be possible to give an average figure because condition as to width and other factors vary considerably. £2,850 may be taken as the corresponding figure for such work including strengthening of foundations in a bog area."
If he takes these two figures and applies them to the present county road grants, both from the rates and the Central Fund, the Minister will find that it will take a great many scores of years to bring the county roads up to the kind of condition which the younger generation of this country would desire.
It seems to me that the Minister should reconsider the whole question of road planning in this country. No one could consider carrying out arterial drainage by widening a river one foot one year and one foot the next year. No one would consider deepening it by several feet in one year and several feet the next year. No one would consider it was adequate to provide electricity supply pylons throughout the country which are so light that in four or five years they would have to be entirely renewed because they would not bear the number of cables to be added. No one would consider that he was right to purchase land for housing purposes by buying half an acre at a time until enough had been acquired for one housing scheme of 60 houses. No one would be prepared to sanction tenders for housing where the specification of the materials to be used in the housing was not of standard quality and up to date. It would seem to me that we must get out of the habit of thinking that road planning cannot be done in the same way as planning for arterial drainage, electricity supply power or housing.
The Minister should now reconsider the whole question of roads in the light of the fact that the more you plan for the future the more you provide for the future; that the less continuous alterations you make in the structure of the road the cheaper it will be in the long run and the less it will cost to maintain; that the more work you can do the more money will be left available for improving all the various classes of roads in the country. In other words, if a plan is made for the road from Dublin to Cork, based on what the Minister considers is likely to be the traffic density in the next six years, and if the Minister wants to build only a narrow road to Cork, a road that is not much wider than what it is at present, in which the curves are not much less pronounced than they are at present, we can argue about that later, but there is no question about it but that we should reserve whatever space is required for the Cork road in the future to a reasonable degree. To plan steadily for its improvement over a period of years is going to result in the total cost being very much less, in its being possible to employ far more modern machinery which contractors or county councils could not otherwise afford either to buy or to hire and to do the work over a long period at less cost. At the same time, when the road is being finally improved it will be far less costly to maintain. The result will be that more money should be left available for the improvement of the county roads. One of the worst features in debates in this House on roads is the idea that county roads should be competitors to main roads in regard to the money available. If main roads are not repaired economically there will not be money for county roads and vice versa. Each one bears a relation to the other. To cut money off main roads, to delay their improvement, to allow deterioration to take place is only going to get the Minister into much more trouble, or a Minister who may come after the present Minister, when it comes to trying to effect any kind of reasonable programme of county road improvement so urgently needed. As I have said, to give insufficient money to main roads merely piles up the proportion of money spent on maintenance over 25 years on the main roads and draws away from funds required to improve county roads.
We had a plan of that kind, and that plan was in operation when the Minister's predecessor came into office. That plan was criticised by Deputies who had not bothered to listen to the speech made by the Minister for Local Government of the day on the ground that we were trying to construct vast autobahns all over the country. Nothing was further from the truth. The object of the plan was not that you ought to construct vast autobahns, but that you might build a road from Dublin to Cork of whatever type you might think would be required ten or 15 years from now, and that you would do it scientifically and methodically.
If the Minister wishes to have a different type of road to that planned by the previous Government there is nothing to prevent him. The whole idea is to save the State money by doing it in a planned way. We left the Minister that plan. As he knows, it was based on the idea that traffic density would increase at the same rate, from 1945 or 1946, since traffic became normal after the war, for the next 20 years, as it increased from 1928 to 1939. It was a very reasonable gamble. The Minister, I think, will find that the increase has already considerably surpassed that rate.
Bearing in mind that general increase, we planned to improve the roads on a basis that was scientific. We arranged surveys and we asked local authorities to consider taking enough land to enable the roads to be widened progressively and scientifically over a period. We also planned to have standard specifications or road widths, road curvature, road elevation and so forth. The effect of doing that would be just as great as planning properly for, say, rural electrification, telephone extensions or arterial drainage.
Getting back to the question of the Bray road, because there is no general plan in operation for main roads around Dublin, you get the kind of parish pump talk that took place over the Bray road. There is not an engineer in the whole of Europe who would not tell the people of Bray that that road will have to be doubled within the next ten years and the sooner it is doubled, progressively and as inexpensively as possible, the better.
The Minister gave me the average density of traffic on that road. Taking into consideration the increase in the number of vehicles on the road, it reached 300 vehicles per hour at a point south of Donnybrook and 260 vehicles per hour at a point north of Donnybrook. That was the result of taking the figure of the number of vehicles circulating in 1928 and adding a percentage representing the increase in the number of vehicles circulating in the Dublin area, since 1928. The peak densities in the morning, in the middle of the day and in the evening would be greater. There is no modern road authority that would not prescribe a double track road where the density of vehicles exceeds 400 per hour. There is nothing immodest or extravagant in that proposal. The difficulty is that there is no general plan.
People may say that an improved road to Bray is going to cost too much in comparison with other roads around Dublin and they ask why should it cost so much. There is no plan by which the proposal can be given the same amount of attention as that devoted to other roads around Dublin that will also have to be doubled within the next ten years. There are 12½ miles of roads requiring doubling in the Dublin area, planning in respect of which should begin now. That is absolutely inevitable, judging by ordinary modern traffic conditions.
There will never be extensive double carriage way required in this country, because the population is not large enough. The main consideration from the Minister's point of view is to carry out improvements on 1,000 miles of the 10,000 miles of main roads through the country where improvement is very drastically required. He can make whatever provision he likes with regard to the standard width. We decided that the road from Dublin to Cork, the road from Dublin to Galway and the road from Dublin to Limerick should be 24 feet wide with single carriageways. It is not an excessive width and there is no autobahn about that. When you consider that these roads will have to carry increasing traffic for the next 20 years, nobody could say that it is an extravagant proposal. There was a suggestion that the main road from Dublin to Cork should be doubled as far as Naas and then made 24 feet wide the remainder of the distance to Cork.
If county councils knew that that would be the general standard it would be far easier for them to plan and far better work would be done on the roads. It would be far easier to find contractors, to arrange for the use of the largest type of machinery and to increase output. Gradually, if it becomes the general practice, the cost of road improvement will go down. At the moment the cost of main roads, using modern machinery, is enormous. The machinery has to be specially hired and nobody is accustomed to the standards adopted. The road near Monasterevan is more like a scientific experiment than an illustration of the general practice of what could be done in the making of a main road.
Comment on this
That is what I say— they cannot find the money. Another method of improving road construction is the concreting of main roads over bogs—not minor but main roads over bogs. The Minister, if he desired, could save the next generation a great deal of money and would enable the remainder of the county road improvement work to be carried out more quickly. He can be told by his officers that, in the case of a concrete road, when it is considered over a 25-year period, the cost of maintenance is less. You have to wait 16 years before you begin to get back your money but, after 16 years, you recover more than your money from the point of view of lower maintenance cost, particularly over a bog area and in connection with double carriage-ways and all roads bearing heavy traffic. It takes a long time, no doubt, but, if the Minister wishes to have regard for the people 16 years from now, I suggest it is a principle worth applying to the greatest extent that money will allow.
Comment on this
Yes, that is the difficulty. Again, it is good up to a reasonable degree for contractors to compete with county councils in regard to certain types of road work. Contractors should be given their chance to work on the roads and at the same time the county councils could do a substantial amount of direct labour work. I can see nothing wrong in the application of the dual principle. The amount to be done should be a matter of general ministerial policy. I am not suggesting that all the work should be done by contract, nor am I suggesting that all the work should be done by direct labour. A good blend of both would be excellent from the point of view of increasing output and encouraging the carrying out of good, skilled work.
I have dealt sufficiently with the public roads and I have mentioned also the question of dealing more successfully with county road improvement so as to carry out work on the main roads more cheaply. In regard to employment, there is no need for the Minister to worry about employment on the roads. Taken as a whole, he knows that he can have the very largest machines available in this world for improving the main arterial roads of this country. The result will be that, in the long run, he will need more money to employ exactly the same number of men, or more men, on the improvement of boreens and county roads. Because sometimes people suggest that any interference with the general principle by means of which roads are made now may cause unemployment, I would remind the Minister that, in the course of the last ten years, as many as 35,000 people and as few as 7,000 people have been employed all over the country on minor relief schemes of every kind, and that as many as 4,600 and as few as 710 have been employed on Land Commission improvement work. In connection with rural improvement schemes, at one time there have been 591 schemes under consideration by the Government which resulted in a certain amount of employment.
In other words, it is possible for the Minister to devise a modern system of road improvement in which the following would be the results, so far as human beings are concerned. The results are very important and are of paramount interest to the whole community. The more the Minister uses machinery on main roads, a higher proportion of men will be paid fitters' and drivers' wages, and the more scope there will be for promotions so that a man can go gradually up the scale when he joins a county council staff. When he joins a contractor's group, there will be varying wages and varying types of work. The more machinery is used, the more machinery there will be that will require repair, and so more people will be employed in effecting repairs to it and ancillary services. The more machinery that is used, the more money will be available in the long run for employing people on other kinds of road work. There is no need to presuppose that there will be any reduction of employment for any one single man by the adoption of modern principles in road engineering in this country. In fact, if anything, the result should be that more men will be employed as a whole on roads and lands in the winter months, and a higher proportion of them at higher wages.
One of the factors in connection with modern road development is that it is possible to spread the work far more evenly as between the winter and the summer months through using modern machinery. There can be the crushing of stone by high-class machinery in central quarries going on continuously in the winter months. During our term, modern road machinery was not available to enable us to begin to put a proper modern road plan into operation—I may add that everything I have said on this can be found on the files in the Minister's office—but, even despite that, we were able to level out employment on the roads to a very considerable degree. If I remember rightly, in our last year of office the greatest number of people employed on the roads in 1947-48 was in the neighbourhood of 24,000 in the month of June, while the least number employed was something in the neighbourhood of 19,000 to 20,000 in the worst winter months.
As the Minister knows, satisfactory employment in the winter months is a vital thing in a rural district, and that employment can be given on roads, no matter what machinery is used, for the reasons which I have already stated. I do not think I need say anything more about road work. I would ask the Minister to let us know how soon he can continue with the road plan which we left him. It is possible for him to modify it any way that he likes, if he thinks it is too extravagant, but as long as it is a proper road plan and as long as he considers the building of roads in the same way as the Electricity Supply Board considers the erection of pylons through the country and the Board of Works considers the carrying out of arterial drainage, he can proceed to apply whatever principles he wishes.
The next question is that of library development. A Bill was passed through the House shortly before the last Government was defeated. It was praised and approved of by everybody. I think it was almost the most unanimously praised Bill that I have ever heard discussed during the whole of my time as member of the House. It was designed to assist in the improvement of the library service and to take over the central library from the Carnegie Trust. I have read the first report of the Library Council which was established under that Act. It is quite obvious that they have not been able to go ahead with the work which they set out to do. I would ask the Minister whether he cannot do something to help. The position is that, if the Minister wants to, he can encourage adult and juvenile education which can never be given in the schools throughout the country, and which is a thing that is desperately required in the rural districts. It is a thing which is needed as the result of our history. Its vital importance is realised in the case of every other modern State in Europe. In the whole of Scandinavia library development is associated with adult education. It is associated with modern educational conceptions and is subscribed to by the central government on a considerable basis.
In this country, the libraries vary enormously according to the amount of money which can be raised locally and the character of the librarian. The librarian who has a capacity for the work and has the peculiar gifts of imagination required, can enormously increase the number of books read— the number of good books on Irish history, books about Irish life, about science, agriculture and everything of that kind. A good example is that of a library area where all but 10 per cent. of the books will be the very lightest form of novel, and of another library area—in districts away from towns because, apparently, country people always read the more serious books—where the percentage of nonfiction read is 33 per cent. of all the books issued. This is the result of having sufficient money for the service and of having a brilliant librarian who knows how to interest the public in books which may not have always been available to them.
By means of book lists he can encourage the public to read the right kind of books and can do much to encourage the use of the library service. There are some libraries where the juvenile books that are made available are woefully inadequate. There are others where they have an excellent juvenile library. There are almost no juvenile reading rooms available, rooms to which children could go to read books perhaps after Mass on Sundays or when their parents go to the market on fair days. There are practically no places in this country where children can read books. Such places are practically nonexistent here, although they are to be found in many other countries with much the same standard of living as we have. There are very few children in this country who know anything about the history of their parishes, or about the famous people who have lived in them. They know nothing about the character of birds or flowers or beasts or of growing things. They know nothing about the science of growth, and so there is a terrific deficiency of general knowledge of that kind, all of which, of course, if properly developed, could give so much pleasure to people living in the country. One of the ways of meeting that deficiency would be by an extension of the library service which is going on in other countries and which, I suggest, should be built up here. We hoped that the new library council would appoint surveyors who would go around the country and, in a very friendly way, find out what was required in each area and present a joint report and plan so that the county councils could know what standard they could reach and the way in which they could reach it. We hoped that the Government would then be able to make grants to the local authorities as a result of the work carried out by these surveyors. In many areas plenty of work has already been done but there are other areas where they are definitely lagging behind. The idea was to establish some kind of level standard. I hope the Minister will give more encouragement to the library council because the members have a long way to go before they reach their objective.
Every single Party in this House expressed the highest praise of the idea of providing some better form of adult education. We all realise that no one can learn very much in school. The best way in which one can learn afterwards is through the medium of these library services. They can be of tremendous value in maintaining a Christian civilisation and in maintaining the people's interests in remaining on the land. I ask the Minister to consider what more he can do to encourage the library council in its work.
Does the Minister consider whether something should be done in connection with the cleaning up of derelict sites? The Minister will recollect that we passed an Act in 1940 to secure immediate title to these sites with a view to their subsequent removal. Possibly there is more important work to be done in the provision of actual houses for the people but there are areas where there should be sufficient labour to clear away these derelict sites without in any way interfering with the housing programme. In a space of 60 miles between Dublin and a provincial town I counted no less than 125 such sites. It may be that the Act we passed needs amendment. I think it was one of the criticisms of the Labour Party when we were in office that there were certain features of the Act which were too cumbersome and needed amendment if the work was to be done quickly. Has the Minister given any consideration to that matter?
I want to say a few words about the traffic problem in general. When does the Minister propose to bring in the Traffic (Amendment) Act that was partly ready for him when he came into office to enable the Gardaí to carry out their work more efficiently? Has he been able to confer with the Gardaí and local authorities in regard to standardising the use of danger signs on the roads. In several areas local authorities have put up danger signs which are not in accordance with international practice. That may be all right. One can always argue that there is no need to follow slavishly a certain accepted group of international signs. We did conform to general practice a number of years ago with a view to having as few types of sign as possible and have them easily seen by road users. We did it with a view to not confusing drivers and road users with a multiplicity of signs. If there are to be special danger signs, I think they should be in universal use in the country and placed where they can be easily seen. Some can be seen at night because they have reflectors; others cannot because they have no reflectors. The same applies to cats' eyes. It is perhaps a small matter, but it is one of vital importance to orderly traffic to have the use of cats' eyes standardised on all the main roads. In some areas they can be seen on the entire length of road either by night or by day. On others they begin at a certain distance before the curve; on others they may begin at a lesser or a greater distance. We have no standardisation in regard to that.
What are the present regulations for encouraging the provision of turf ranges in turf areas or in areas fairly close to bogs, though not immediately surrounded by them, in local authority housing? How far has the Minister gone at the present time to conform to the general wish of the people to encourage the use of turf wherever it can be conveniently and economically used?
Has the Minister considered the terms of the Sanitary Services Act, 1948. Has he considered the problem of getting sewerage and water from individual houses attached to main drainage and water schemes? So far as I know in a considerable number of towns nothing has been done to join houses to existing water and sewerage schemes. Under the Sanitary Services Act local authorities were given power to do that. They have to pay for any length of sewer or water pipe over and above a certain minimum distance, and they can collect the cost for the remaining distance through a special rate levied on the occupier over a 30-year period at some very low rate of interest. It seems a very reasonable proposition. If there is anything faulty in the Act, the Minister should consider the position now. I think it was the last Act we passed and it was passed in a great hurry. Possibly there are certain deficiencies in it which will require amendment. I remember being amazed to learn that senior counsel in times past have made thousands of pounds in fees on the question of deciding the joint responsibility as between local authorities and individuals for the maintenance and making of sewerage and water schemes. I was hoping that might be avoided in the future.
Lastly, what is the Minister doing about the scheme for an architectural competition? I think it is just as well we should realise that there have been very few good architects since the dawn of time. An architect is a kind of artist. There have been very few good artists since the dawn of time. There are only about 30 artists among practically all the great Renaissance painters portraying the Christian scene for us. Good artists set the examples for less good artists and good architects do likewise. There is no doubt that the standard of architecture for local authority housing is very low as compared with other countries. One has only to wander through Spain, Holland and the other European countries to realise how true that is. It almost looks as if we built houses merely because we wanted to build them quickly without paying any regard to appearance. There is something very much akin to economic liberalism in the idea of building houses recklessly as human containers without having any regard to the effect they may have on the lives and spirit of those who occupy them.
I would appeal to the Minister to go ahead with the architectural competition. It is better to have a few good designs copied and adapted rather than to have 20 or 30 bad designs. Some of the new houses are delightful; others have no imagination either in construction or design. I think much remains to be done from that point of view. Better designing is needed from the point of view of the built-in cupboard space made available and apart from furniture installed.
I think more remains to be done in standardising the size of cisterns and pipes in order to reduce costs. All these things call for the attention of the Minister. If remedied, they will result in better housing for the people. As I have said, it is impossible to find more than one really good architect out of 50 or 100 from the point of view of artistic design. The majority of them have the sense merely to copy the work of others. That is why I say we need to have a good example set. It should be no more expensive to build a beautiful house well designed than to build an ugly one. It should not cost any more over a period of ten or 15 years. Housing design calls for imagination and inspiration on the part of those in charge of housing.
Before I sit down I would like to refer to an observation made by a Deputy. The suggestion was that in his area people had to belong to a certain Party before they would get a new house. I do not understand what he meant by that. As far as I know, the medical officers of health and the local authorities are incorruptible men. I think the idea that a person would have to belong to a certain political Party in either Longford or Westmeath in order to get a new house is a revolting one. It is contrary to the entire spirit and tradition of medical officers of health. No doubt they are not perfect human beings; no doubt on occasion they may be influenced in one way or another but the suggestion that one has to be a member of a political Party to get a new house is entirely wrong and unfair to the officials concerned.
Comment on this
My contribution to this debate will be a limited one. From my short experience as a member of the House, I have come to appreciate the importance of good local government administration throughout the country. It is not hard to realise the effect that local administration has on central government. It is, therefore, all the more necessary to ensure that the machinery of local administration is maintained at a high level of efficiency. The significance of local government administration cannot be overstressed. I am pleased to learn from the Minister's introductory statement that, generally, over the past year reasonably satisfactory progress has been made by local authorities in their main activities, such as the provision of houses, sewerage, water schemes and the maintenance and improvement of roads. Apart from the general situation, there are some particular points affecting my own constituency which I should like to bring to the Minister's notice for his earnest consideration.
So far as housing is concerned, I think greater stress should be laid on the desirability of building houses, particularly in the rural areas, by direct labour. From my short experience and knowledge of the direct labour system, as against the contract system, I am satisfied that direct labour not only produces a cheaper house but a better house from the point of view of construction and craftsmanship. For instance, in one small scheme carried out by direct labour in Rosscarbery, a considerable saving was effected, and work is in progress on a limited number of houses by direct labour in Drimoleague. On the other hand, in my own native town, Dunmanway, a group of houses are being built by contract. I think this scheme should be sufficient as a test of the merits of the two methods of construction. Therefore I can see no reason why a further group of houses to be erected in my own town could not be built by direct labour, particularly in view of the availability both of skilled and unskilled labour. My dissatisfaction arises from the fact that contract prices in the town are far too high, ranging from £1,100 to £1,300 per house. Therefore I cannot understand why the local authority do not extend their very limited direct labour activities. The local authority's attitude in this matter is all the more difficult to understand in view of the Minister's repeated pronouncements in favour of direct labour.
Apart from this, I should like to direct the Minister's special attention to the urgency of the housing needs of all the towns and villages in West Cork, especially in the towns of Bantry and Skibbereen and in the villages of Leap, Ballingeary and Glengarriff. In order to ensure that the situation is kept under constant review I would suggest to the Minister that he would obtain a quarterly report from the local authorities in these particular areas as regards progress.
Another aspect of housing which merits serious consideration is the necessity for a number of single cottages to be built in rural areas throughout the county. It is within my knowledge that on several occasions tenders were invited but no contractors applied. Many of the cottages were re-advertised but the local authority again failed to get contractors. Such cottages are required for people living in condemned houses and yet the local authority refused to build by direct labour. The poor people who are living under those conditions, which make for the development of tuberculosis, are allowed to suffer on. This position has existed for many years. The number of people who require such cottages to my knowledge in West Cork is about 30.
Coming now to the question of repairs of cottages, the general experience is that when a person reports that repairs are necessary it is often two or three years before anything is done. I hope there will be an improvement in this direction when the engineering services are amalgamated. Furthermore, as part of the housing drive and in order to ensure that proper services are available when the houses come to be built, steps should be taken to instal water supplies and sewerage schemes in all towns and villages well in advance of building.
I come now to the question of road workers. Their present remuneration is fairly reasonable but I think it could be further improved without casting any appreciable burden on the local authorities concerned. There is also the question of protective clothing. I understand that at present road workers receive only one issue every three years. This is ridiculous because, owing to the very nature of the work in which these men are engaged, the clothing, which is of very poor quality, could not be expected to last for a longer period than 12 months. I suggest that, in common decency the road workers should receive an issue every 12 months and furthermore that the issue should be made during the month of September each year.
It has come to my knowledge that road workers living in a particular area in my constituency are employed in another area despite the fact that there is work available and men employed in the particular area in which these men live. I suggest that, if at all possible, county council employees should be given work as near as possible to their own homes. Where it is not possible to give them employment near their own homes and where they are employed more than three miles away, they should be given a bicycle allowance because such an allowance was granted to bog workers during the emergency.
So far as road works themselves are concerned I would suggest for the Minister's consideration one particular stretch of road in my area, namely that from Dunmanway to Macroom, on which some money has already been spent on surveying. This is an important road and it is the most convenient means of communication between Dunmanway and Macroom and it is now in a very dangerous and deplorable condition. In addition, other county roads such as the Drimoleague-Skibbereen and the Durrus-Kilcrohane roads are in urgent need of attention and I trust that the local authority will include them in their programme for immediate execution.
On the question of the operation of the Local Authorities (Works) Act, 1949, I suggest that all schemes submitted under that Act should be carried out during the summer months. The work will then prove most beneficial to the landowners, to the workers and to the State and the bulk of the road maintenance work should be deferred until later in the year. Also every effort should be made by the Minister and his Department to see that the schemes submitted under the Local Authorities (Works) Act are carried out as expeditiously as possible with particular reference to the Beara peninsula in my constituency because chronic unemployment exists there.
There are many deficiencies in the Managerial Acts and I am sure that none of our public representatives will be satisfied until the assurance to repeal these Acts is implemented. Personally I am glad that the Minister has already introduced a Bill to remove these deficiencies so as to ensure that those who offer themselves for election to the local councils will do so in the knowledge that if the people give them their confidence they will have available a democratic form of machinery under which they can give effect to the people's wishes in local government affairs.
Comment on this
I am going to be very brief for once. I look upon the Local Government Vote as one of the most important Votes of the Government because a number of vital matters affecting the people in every area is controlled by the Department of Local Government. I wish to deal with that very hackneyed subject, housing, that has been already spoken of by a number of speakers to-night. In County Dublin the housing position has advanced considerably and it was due in no small way to the activities of the previous Minister for Local Government, Deputy MacEntee, in the acquisition of sites.
Comment on this
And Deputy Burke. Now we have the position in County Dublin where a number of people still require houses and the work is slowed up completely. It is not the fault of the present Minister but the acquisition of sites seems to be a burning question. I have spoken on this very urgent matter before, and as far as I can see, in a number of areas in County Dublin housing is at a standstill due to the slow acquisition of sites by the Dublin County Council. I look upon houses as being more important than hospitals because if we have not good houses there is very little use in bringing people to hospital and giving them first-class treatment and then sending them back to the same old hovel, 6 by 4, 6 by 6 or 6 by 7 as the case may be. It is very nice to see that members of the Government Parties can take this serious position so lightly that they can laugh at it.
Comment on this
I am talking about small houses and indeed the Minister for Lands is not very helpful; he does not give much land for houses.
Comment on this
This is a very urgent matter and I can assure the House that if the Minister can do anything about speeding up the acquisition of sites he will have the full support of every public man in this House because there is a big delay which is retarding progress.
Comment on this
Due to the work we had already done before you people came into office.
I have raised the question of the building of extra rooms to cottages before, especially the case of people who are suffering from tuberculosis and who applied to get an extra room as was arranged for under an Act passed by this House in 1945. I must say that while the Minister is not directly responsible, the local authorities could expedite the granting of such applications and assist people of that kind.
The repair of cottages is hopelessly slow. I have referred to it umpteen times and I am not going further into it to-night.
While I want to keep my promise not to speak too long, I want to refer to the short-sighted policy of road making and road repairs in County Dublin. I have made representations on a number of occasions about dangerous corners on second and third-class roads and when you make representations you are told that there is no money to meet it and you are dealing with roads that are no more than prairie tracks. I wonder will the Minister consider taking the matter in his own hands and requesting local authorities to take the long view on the remaking and widening of roads and the elimination of dangerous corners. We have had the experience of kicking up a row when somebody was killed, of votes of censure passed by juries saying that it was a pity that the road was not repaired or the dangerous corner taken off. My county is a tourist centre, so far as Dublin City people and people from other areas are concerned, and the roads to the seaside in the area leave much to be desired, and I suggest that a policy of spending a reasonable amount of money each year, until such time as we reach some state of perfection in our roads, should be embarked upon. That can be said of the main road from Swords to Dublin. I am merely running over these points and do not propose to elaborate them.
Comment on this
I understood that there was a desire to get business done. Interruptions will not facilitate that.
Comment on this
It is a very important matter, especially in an area to which we hope to encourage tourists to come, that our roads should be perfect, and the Minister and his Department should take an active part in seeing that a policy is adopted under which this work will be carried out and will not have to wait for a year, two years or 20 years. That is retarding progress and not tackling things as they should be tackled.
With regard to sewerage and water schemes, I had a number of questions down with regard to the provision of these amenities in various areas and I hold that anything the Minister and his Department can do in this very vital matter deserves the support of the country. I am sorry to say that there are areas within a mile or two of Dublin which have still no sewerage or water schemes. In a number of cases, they have succeeded in the past few years in having them provided, but there are towns like Blanchardstown, Castleknock, Donabate, Lusk and similar areas along the coast, to which thousands of people go, which have not got such facilities. I have raised the matter on numerous occasions by parliamentary question and I merely refer to it now to ask the Minister to see what he can do to expedite this urgent matter.
Seaside amenities come within the purview of the Department and I must say that the amenities available for citizens who come out from the city leave very much to be desired. In certain areas, on the recent few fine Sundays, any man fortunate enough to have a car could scarcely find parking space within a mile of the coast, and it is a matter to which I should like the Government, now that those making up the Government have stated definitely that the tourist industry is worth something to this country, to give serious attention. The only way to encourage people to go to those seaside resorts is by providing the necessary facilities—by providing parking space for cars, facilities for the people who have no cars and all the smaller amenities that add greatly to the attraction of any district.
In view of the introduction of the new Local Government Bill, I will reserve any further remarks I have to make on local government for a later occasion, but I should like the Minister to tell me what has happened to the old North County Dublin regional water scheme. Is it still under consideration or has it been scrapped? That was a very important scheme which would definitely have facilitated a number of areas, if it had been possible to put it into operation some few years ago.
Comment on this
I should like to say a good deal about the Department of Local Government, but, in view of the desire to curtail the debate, I shall limit myself entirely to what I consider to be necessary, with the object of trying to bring before Deputies certain matters which I think are worthy of their consideration. First, I think this Department is the greatest burden with which this country has ever been saddled. It would be impossible to imagine any Department so inept, so far away from the minds of the people and so careless of its obligations, and, unless I receive some satisfaction in the Minister's reply with regard to some of the points I intend to make, I shall seriously consider whether I can support this Vote. I go further and say that, if in his reply I find no hope of improvement, I shall certainly vote against it. The present condition of the Department is possibly not the fault of the Minister. It is a heritage which has come down to him from an alien Government and it has never ceased to follow on the lines on which it was founded by that foreign Government. Since the Minister took office a little over a year ago, he has, I am sure, done all that one man could do against a Department which is definitely hostile to the will of the people.
Particularly am I concerned in my constituency, which consists of something like 100,000 people, with the matter of housing. During last year, on various occasions, in an effort to get solved the problems from which the people are suffering, I raised certain questions with regard to housing in the House. The matter was also raised by my colleague, Deputy Brady, who put a question to the Minister on 23rd May last asking, in reference to the Dún Laoghaire Borough Corporation area and the Rathdown area of the Dublin County Council, the total number of houses built or reconstructed each year from 1934 to 1949 and the average number of manual workers employed during these years. I am only concerned with housing. The answer we got from the Minister was that in 1933-34 164 houses were completed; in 1949-50, 145 houses were completed and in regard to the Rathdown area, in 1934-35, 133 houses were constructed, and from 1939 no houses were completed during the subsequent years until 1949-50, when 29 houses were built.
I wonder if any statement could be a greater reflection on the ineptitude of the Department which is responsible for maintaining in comfort the families who, in that large area, for which I happen to be one of the representatives, are crying for shelter. There were 145 houses completed in 1949-50 in Dún Laoghaire and 29 houses in Rathdown.
I know that the Minister and those associated with him can give figures showing how many houses are under construction but is he so unaware of the conditions that exist that he will not take further steps, as he should take, to supply the needs of those who require houses?
On 23rd March, 1950, I asked him some questions about houses. I asked him what was the reason for the delay in the provision of houses by the county council and the Dún Laoghaire Borough Corporation for families living in deplorable conditions. I asked him whether, in order to safeguard the Christian fundamentals on which family life is based and to terminate the many cases of separation of fathers from their wives and children, he will take adequate remedial steps at once in respect of the areas concerned. The Minister did reply but he did not answer the last part of the question and that is the kernel of the reason why I take such an antagonistic view of his Department. Instead of relying on the fundamentals on which family life is based and encouraging our young people to get married and to live in decent homes, he and his Department are so negligent that they forget these very fundamentals. When I asked the Minister, in a supplementary question, would he answer that part of the question, he said, "I think I have answered the question as fully as I can answer it." Surely no rationalist could do better.
I wonder if there is a single case in the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown area where newly-weds have been provided with houses. I want to know from the Minister is he going to allow families to grow up where children are separated from their parents and husbands from their wives, without taking serious notice of the situation.
Comment on this
Hostile Department is correct. It is because that Department is hostile and because it is too much of a luxury for this nation to carry it and other Departments of State that I say that until every document which is in these Departments is taken out into the middle of Dublin Bay and dumped there and a new system is organised, a system more consistent with the ideals of our people, we cannot hope for the solution of our social problems.
Comment on this
I agree entirely with Deputy Burke. I think this is a very, very serious problem. The allocation of houses, such as they are, is another matter to which I shall refer later. It is to the discredit of the Department of Local Government that, instead of having solved the housing problem now, after 2½ years of office, we are worse off than we were in 1934.
Surely the Minister must realise his responsibility. If he does not do so, he should come to this House and tell us and he should go down to the people and talk to them and give his excuses and utter his platitudes and wishful thinking. What the people want at the present moment, is not oratory, but houses. People living under conditions which are truly deplorable receive very short shrift from the administration which is responsible for the allocation of houses in the county and in the Borough of Dún Laoghaire. I have no hesitation whatever in stating here and now that I believe that some influence, and some underhand influence, is at work to prevent a just distribution of houses. I believe that the Minister should hold an inquiry into the method by which this is done. Had I known that this debate would be on to-day, I could have brought into this House a load of letters received from the county council and from the Borough of Dún Laoghaire, stating that other and more urgent cases are to be given houses.
I remember a case of a family of eight—which is now a family of nine —living in two rat-infested rooms, who were visited by the acting medical officer of health. They were promised a house. The reply I received from the borough corporation in regard to them was a machine-made reply; it did not even bear the signature of the responsible officer; it was simply rolled out. It said that that person did not deserve a house—that there were more urgent cases—I think these were the words. At the same time I know in the Borough of Dún Laoghaire where families of two, three and four have got houses and I know of others living in squalor and in filth and under conditions which are a disgrace to any civilised community, who are not deemed to be worthy of consideration for a house.
The Minister may say—and I am sure he can say—that this is done by statute. That is the refuge which is taken for every lapse and every departmental inefficiency. Statute, statutory powers, statutory procedure —we are sick of that. That is why the Department of Local Government should be dumped into the middle of Dublin Bay. What we want is an approach to the real problems, the real social problems, from which the people are suffering. We want an equitable distribution of such favours as can be given by the responsible administration. When I say that I believe that the distribution of houses depends on inequity, I know of a case where a councillor is able to come to certain people and say: "You are getting a house." Now, whether that is guesswork or not I do not know, but it is happening and I do not make a statement like that lightly. If I did, I should not be worthy to stand on the floor of this House.
I suggest that the administration both of the Dublin County Council and of the Borough of Dún Laoghaire should be entirely abolished and that every document in the departments controlled by these administrations should receive the same treatment as that which I suggested for the Depart ment itself. It seems to me that these two administrations, as well as the Department, believe that the objective of the people is to provide a luxurious environment for the sole purpose of keeping in employment and providing for the future of the supernumerary officials in whose custody is placed the unfortunate fate of long-suffering people. I sincerely hope that the Minister, in his reply, will give some hope to the people whom I represent that at any rate family life can be restored, that husbands separated from their wives and children can be provided with a house, that young people entering into the marriage state can secure a home. There is no use in telling me that it is going to be done. I want it done—and it should have been done in the last two years, and it would have been done had ordinary decent business people taken the job and had red tape been eliminated from the procedure which has kept from the people whom I represent, and who are suffering as I have suggested, the comforts which they have been denied.
I do not intend to say more than I should, but there is one thing I must say in dealing with the administration, especially of Dún Laoghaire Borough. The ratepayers of that borough contribute largely and painfully to the luxury of keeping in employment the corporation which controls the borough, and the condition of the streets each morning is perfectly disgraceful.
Comment on this
Is not that a matter for the corporation? The Minister is not responsible for the streets of Dún Laoghaire.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Minister is responsible for the administration of Dún Laoghaire in so far as it is carried out.
Comment on this
I thought the borough was the responsible authority for looking after its own affairs.
Comment on this
I still maintain that the sweeping of the streets of Dún Laoghaire it not a matter for the Minister, directly or indirectly.
Comment on this
It is the Borough of Dún Laoghaire that is subject to the Minister and I suggest that the Minister should inquire carefully and in detail as to whether the officials there do their work in the manner expected of them and for which I think the Minister is responsible. I can only say that I hope I have not said too much. I have not said half what I would like to say, but I am quite serious in this, that unless the Minister is going to give some hope that the housing problem will be solved for the people whom I represent, I will not support him, I will vote against him, and as far as I can I shall do everything to see that the administration for which he is responsible will realise its duty and do for the people what one would expect the administration to do.
Comment on this
I will not take much of the time of the House this evening, but before coming to the Estimates proper I would like to say a few words in connection with Deputy Corry's motion regarding the road grants. There are 50,000 miles of roads in the country and out of those we have 10,000 of main roads.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I understand that Deputy Walsh is speaking on Deputy Corry's motion. I would like to know if Deputy Corry's motion is before the House and, if it is, why a motion of mine, No. 9 on the List of Motions, has been passed over and a motion which was tabled last year and a motion tabled by Deputy Corry on somewhat similar lines on the 4th May is being taken.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry's motion is not being taken officially. It was understood, without my knowledge or the Minister's knowledge apparently, that the motion would be discussed along with this Estimate. It was allowed to be referred to in the debate on the Estimate but the motion itself is not directly before the House and I understand now will not be put to a Vote. If the Government gives way to one motion, that is their business not mine.
Comment on this
If this motion, which was tabled on the 4th May, is taken, my motion, which was tabled early last year, should also be taken.
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with this. It is for the Government to decide. I have nothing to do with it. As a matter of fact, no Vote is being taken on Deputy Corry's motion.
Comment on this
Parts of it, that is, the amount of money devoted to roads—not petrol tax, or motor tax, which are not under the jurisdiction of this Minister.
Comment on this
My objection was that I could not take responsibility for taxation and I could not, therefore, take that motion on my Estimate.
Comment on this
You can discuss the money required for roads. If the Deputy thinks it desirable that more money should be granted, he may say so.
Comment on this
It was in that connection that I intended to speak. We felt that money could be found in a certain direction and therefore we put down the motion. We also understood that we could take that motion in conjunction with the Estimate for the Department of Local Government. That was the understanding which I thought was come to this morning.
Comment on this
I think I have explained the position to the Deputy. I think he understands it now. No vote is being taken on Deputy Corry's motion. Neither the Minister nor I knew anything about it.
Comment on this
We have 50,000 miles of public roads in this country and, of these, 10,000 miles are main roads. Some 13,000 miles of the 50,000 miles are resurfaced but 37,000 are not. In addition to those 37,000 miles we have 20,000 miles of what might be described as cul-de-sac roads. The amount of money spent on those roads at present is not sufficient to keep them properly maintained. The ratepayers are going to be faced with a problem in a few years' time because the same amount of money is not being spent on them as was spent in the past. They will have to go and remake those roads— and the ratepayers will be called upon to foot the bill. Heretofore, a certain amount of money was paid out through the Department of Local Government by way of grants. Those grants were substantially reduced two years ago, I think, to the extent of about £2,000,000. Our submission is that those grants should now be restored. Those of us who are members of county councils have had experience, from time to time, of deputations composed particularly of farmers living on county roads which are in a shocking condition and in respect of which no moneys or only very small amounts were spent during the war period. Even if we had had the money available during that time—and there was money available in many instances—it happened that the county councils were not able to use all the money allocated for county roads because we had not the men. They were in the Army and they were cutting turf in the bogs in order to provide fuel for the people in the cities.
When the war ended, a survey of our roads was taken by the county engineers. I understand from my county surveyor that it was the general opinion of the county surveyors of the country that it would take at least two years to restore the roads to their pre-war condition. What happened? The grants were cut in 1949. The result was that if those roads were to be put into the same condition as they were in pre-war, it would mean an additional burden on the ratepayers of the country. That is very unfair. During wartime, we had turf lorries and beet lorries travelling on the county roads, and even on the bog roads which were never built for the purpose of carrying heavy traffic, and the result was that they were cut to pieces. The withdrawal of the grants meant that the ratepayers would be responsible for putting them into a proper state of repair. They could not afford to do that. Therefore, those roads have not yet been restored to their pre-war condition. As I have said, those of us who are members of a county council have, on many occasions, met deputations from farmers about the condition of county roads. These roads had bad bends, hills and so forth, and the farmers were hoping that something might be done by the county council. The county council was unable to do anything because it had not the money. The only way in which many of these works could be carried out was by getting grants from the Government. As a result of the withdrawal of the grants, we were unable, in my county, to go ahead with necessary and important works, and works that would be of benefit to the people. In connection with the 20,000 miles of cul-de-sac roads, we have boreens, laneways and so forth leading into farm houses. Under the Fianna Fáil régime there was a scheme whereby many of those laneways could be done under the minor relief schemes. That has been discontinued. No grants are made available as they were during that period.
Comment on this
That is not so.
Comment on this
It could be done under the rural improvements scheme or the special employment schemes but it is not the same because the people living in those boreens, laneways and cul-de-sac entrances have to pay a contribution.
Comment on this
I do not know what happens west of the Shannon. Many things happen there that we do not know of east of the Shannon. My concern is that, generally speaking, grants are not made available for the repair of those laneways and boreens——
Comment on this
——except by payment by the people living along these lanes——
Comment on this
If I call to the Parliamentary Secretary's office to-morrow, I hope that he will give grants.
Comment on this
I will test that very quickly. I would be very glad indeed if the Parliamentary Secretary would give grants for the repair of these boreens, and it will be my fault, I suppose, if I do not get them. Already we have had the experience of having the road grants cut to a very substantial extent, over £2,000,000. I submit that the amount of traffic through the country compared with the volume of traffic some years ago justifies the increased grants we are asking for. We hope that the Minister will use his influence with the Minister for Finance to extract more money out of the motor taxation fund.
As Deputy Childers pointed out, the Minister has stated that it takes £225 now to do the amount of work £100 would do in 1938-39. Let us take that as being correct and let us take the amount of money that we spent, including grants from the Road Fund and the contributions from the rates. In the year 1938-39 we spent £2,025,000 and in 1949-50 the amount spent on the roads was £4,640,000. That seems a very substantial increase, but if you compare the two figures, and if you assume the Minister is correct in stating that the cost of the upkeep of the roads, maintenance and improvement, has gone up by 125 per cent., then that sum represents an increase of 10 per cent. over and above what was spent in 1938-39.
We all know that there are far more motor vehicles on the roads to-day than there were in 1938-39. The number of motor cars, private and otherwise, has increased by 66 per cent. The number of heavy motor vehicles, such as lorries and trailers, has increased by 100 per cent. If you look at it from the point of view of the amount of damage done now by these vehicles, as against the amount of damage done in pre-war days, I think everybody will agree that it is far greater now.
We have more heavily-laden vehicles travelling the roads. Going through the country, you will meet a lorry and trailer coming along and they are like a small train. I have seen a lorry and trailer conveying 29 tons of beet. There are not many county roads capable of carrying vehicles with loads of that sort. They were never built to carry such heavy loads. If they continue to carry loads of beet and turf and merchandise of every description the roads will soon wear out if some effort is not made to reconstruct or improve them.
There are cattle being conveyed to the Dublin market in these lorries and trailers from all over the country. If this is to continue, what will be the condition of the roads within a few years? We are not spending the money necessary in order to keep them in proper repair. The only way we can look after those roads is by getting grants. The cost of the upkeep of the roads has gone up during the past two years as a result of the reduction in the road grants, yet we are not spending and cannot spend the same amount of money as we did spend three or four years ago. Even at that time we should have been spending more. We could not do any more then, mainly because men were not available and we had not the machinery. We hear a lot of talk about unemployment now. So far as the roads are concerned we have the men ready to work and we have the machinery and the materials but we have not the money.
Deputations came before our council and we informed them that we were anxious to go ahead with the work but we were in the position that we could not afford the money. If grants were made available in the same generous way as they were in 1947, we would be able to carry out some of these works and we would be able to make some improvement in the roads. I want the Minister to use his influence with the Department of Finance and try to get more money for us.
I agree that the Department should spend more money on county roads for the reasons I have given. I know many farmers are depending to a far greater extent, in fact to almost 100 per cent., on having their produce carried by road. Very little agricultural produce is now going by rail. Every year we see lorries going to farms for corn and beet and other farm produce. I understand in many parts of the country, but particularly in the West—and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance can bear me out in this— that farmers have to haul their beet a long distance to a pickup point, because of the fact that the roads leading to their homes, or even to within two or three miles of their homes, are not built to carry the heavy lorries. That happens in my own county, and I can speak with greater knowledge of my own county than of County Galway. I know there are places where heavy lorries cannot be brought.
If we are to have an expansion of production in the agricultural areas, greater facilities must be given to the farmers, and they must be provided with better roads. One of the ways in which you will induce them to produce more is by providing good roads to their homesteads, giving them greater facilities by having roads capable of carrying lorries to where their agricultural produce is ready for removal. I can see no great difficulty in the Minister going to the Minister for Finance and making a reasonable case for increased grants. The roads originally were not built for motor traffic, and neither have they been improved to the extent that they are now suitable for that traffic.
Motor traffic in this country means £7,000,000 for the Exchequer, and out of that money £2,000,000 is given for the maintenance of roads. What justification can any Minister put up to hold the £5,000,000 that is paid by the direct users of the roads? What excuse can he make for not giving it to the people who are maintaining those roads? If the grants are not made available the ratepayers must do the job, and if they are unable, then the roads will deteriorate to such an extent that the State one day or another must come to the rescue and we will have nationalisation of roads. You can have partial nationalisation now or you must have it in the future, one or the other. If you want to escape that at the present time, the only way you can do it is by making a substantial increase in the grants to the county councils. So much for roads.
I want to say a few words in connection with local government, with particular reference to the appointment of tenants to cottages. Under a regulation recently made by the Minister, a preference must be given to agricultural labourers. I should like to have a definition from the Minister of what is an agricultural labourer. I had a case like this recently. It was that of a married man, the father of five or six children who worked all his life on the land. Some time recently he got a job with the Electricity Supply Board as a tractor driver on the rural electrification scheme. He has made within recent times three applications for a cottage. He has been turned down on each occasion on the grounds that he is not an agricultural labourer. As a matter of fact he should have been number one choice for a cottage. He would have been had he come within the category of an agricultural labourer. I should like to know from the Minister if the same thing is to happen to road workers in the rural areas. They are in much the same position as the man I have mentioned. If he cannot be defined as an agricultural labourer, then neither can a road worker. The same, I suppose, would apply to a handyman in the country who does a good deal of work for farmers and is sometimes employed in the towns or villages. Strictly speaking, I suppose those men are not agricultural workers because they do not use a sprong or a fork. At the same time they are living in rural areas.
According to the regulation, as it has been interpreted in my county, the man who drives an Electricity Supply Board tractor is not regarded as an agricultural labourer. But, if for any reason, he were to lose his present job or were to become redundant, he has no option but to go back and work on the land. Suppose he did go back to work on the land then, naturally, he would become an agricultural labourer. Apart from his present job, the only other work he can get is with farmers.
There was another regulation made some time ago by the Minister in connection with the tenancies of cottages. It has been my experience that on no occasion has the original applicant for a cottage got it when it was built. Away back in 1938 and 1939 in my constituency we had advertisements in the newspapers asking people in the rural areas who required cottages to make application for them. Agricultural labourers and others did so. In many instances, men were given plots by farmers voluntarily. In other cases, the plots had to be compulsorily acquired. But when the houses were built, in practically all cases they were given to people other than the original applicants. The latter did not qualify simply because they had their families reared. That was the principal reason why they did not get a house. As I have said, I have known original applicants who were given sites for cottages voluntarily in 1938 and 1939. The houses have now been built. Those original applicants were at the time living in mud cabins or in hovels. I know one particular man who reared a family of six children. The house he lived in was so small that if he wanted to enjoy a smoke he had to go outside the door. Now his family are scattered and there is no one remaining behind but his wife and himself. Due to that fact he is not entitled to a cottage. Is it right for the Minister, or for a local authority, to deny people like him the right of having a decent house in his old age? That ought not be the policy of the Department.
The regulation in regard to that should, I think, be considered by the Minister and be amended. The unfairness of it was brought forcibly to my notice about 12 months ago. I went into a house where there was an old man. He told me that about ten or 12 years earlier he had applied for and got possession of a plot on which a house was to be built for him. When it was, his application for it was turned down. I made a suggestion at a meeting of the county council in connection with cases of that sort. I do not know whether it was ever submitted to the Department or not. It was that these houses be let in groups of five, and that one of the five be reserved for original applicants. If that had been adopted it would help some way to solve this problem. Later I suggested that two out of the five be given to men with families, that two others be reserved for newly-weds and the remaining one for original applicants. That scheme was turned down. I am chiefly concerned with the cases of original applicants who were given plots ten or 12 years ago on the understanding that houses would be built for them. When the houses are built they find they are debarred, because in most cases there is no one left behind but the man and his wife. It looks as if they are never going to be able to enjoy the comfort of a decent home.
There is another matter I want to refer to. It is a suggestion that was put before the late Minister for Local Government on the occasion of his first visit as Minister to Kilkenny. It was in reference to houses that, from the structural point of view, are well built, which we have in many parts of County Kilkenny. I suggested to the Minister that these houses be taken over by the county council. Many of them are well built with granite stone.
The suggestion was that two of them be converted into one house, or, on the other hand, that an additional storey be added to each. I think if that suggestion had been carried out it would mean the saving of a lot of money both for the State and the ratepayers in County Kilkenny. These houses are let at a very low rent. If they are left as they are it is likely they will be condemned by the doctors as not being suitable dwellings. I think that if two were converted into one you would get a very good house. You would certainly have a far drier house than some of the newer ones that are being built. I think the Department should give careful consideration to that suggestion.
In my constituency of Kilkenny-Carlow we have houses of this description in many of the villages and towns. In County Kilkenny you have them in Goresbridge, Graiguenamanagh and Gowran, and in Fenagh and Borris in County Carlow. I believe that very suitable houses can be built or reconstructed there. The rent on the tenants would be much smaller if the houses were reconstructed. In addition to that, many of these sites are situated in towns and villages. The usual procedure nowadays is that, if there is a new building scheme, the houses are built outside the existing village or town. The authorities have an eye on sewerage, water and so on. That is quite right, of course, but the villages are beginning to lose their identity under these schemes and what was once a village is now perhaps a derelict site. Approaching these towns and villages nowadays one meets a nice patch of houses on the outskirts and inside the village there are only derelict sites. The village of 25 or 30 years ago has disappeared to all intents and purposes. All that is left are the shops. The ordinary people have been transferred out to new building sites and the old village is rapidly losing its identity.
With regard to the Local Authorities (Works) Act, representations were made on numerous occasions by the county council with reference to the drainage of Lough Cullen. That is situated in South Kilkenny. If the bed of the river was lowered, it would drain the lake and keep the roads in that area from being flooded. Many of the roads there are flooded after heavy rain. Good grazing land is being damaged. I understand that application was made to the Department of Agriculture under the land rehabilitation scheme to have some work done in that area, but, in the opinion of the Department of Agriculture, the work comes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, and they refuse to do anything about it.
I think myself it should be done under the land rehabilitation project. I think the Minister for Local Government should at least send down an inspector to find out definitely into which category the particular work comes. Irrespective of whatever Department undertakes the work, it would be of great benefit to the people in the district. I understand that the works undertaken under both these provisions are being financed out of Marshall Aid and there would, therefore, be no question of extra taxation imposed on the people. The money spent would be spent to good advantage.
I understand other works have also been submitted but have not been passed so far. The scheme in connection with the Powerstown river was sent up last year and, so far as I am aware, that scheme has been turned down. That river causes considerable damage by flooding on at least three roads. Any time there is abnormal rain the river floods. In addition to the roads being flooded, the lands are flooded too. I think it would be well worth while carrying out that scheme. Because it causes damage to roads, I imagine it should come within the scope of the Local Authorities (Works) Act.
With regard to some of the works, I believe the council will have trouble because claims can be made. Some works have been carried out and one does not need to be an expert to know that, if flooding follows upon abnormal rain, the lands around will be inundated. In some cases the level of the road has been raised and there will be no place for the water to go except on to the adjoining lands. If that happens, the council will be faced with the responsibility of making good the damage done. I think I am right in stating that there is a provision in the Act to cover that matter.
Another objection is that the council has to pay the engineers. I think that is very unfair. After all it is the Department which suggests the scheme in the first instance. We have to employ the engineers. It may happen that our engineers will be compelled to do work which will ultimately prove detrimental to the council. We may be paying men to do harm to ourselves.
Comment on this
The council is doing it on the recommendation of the county surveyor. He submits the plans.
Comment on this
We do not, but the fact of the matter is we have had no experience of it yet. If we had a repetition of the abnormal weather of 1947, then we might be able to see what the results are and we might be in a position to say: "We were wrong in our forecast with reference to this work. We said it would do damage, but we have not had that experience." Since these works commenced we have had two of the best years we have ever experienced in living memory. We have had no abnormal rains. There has been no test. During 1947 we had water 18 and 20 feet deep in North Kilkenny. It is the general opinion of the engineers and of those who live in those areas and have seen the floods in the past that there will be worse floods in Kilkenny, Thomastown and Inistiog in future. The river has silted up at Thomastown Bridge. We made arrangements two years ago to have the silt removed, but the Department refused to sanction the scheme on the ground that the river would come under the arterial drainage scheme. There are portions of the River Nore across which one could walk at the present time because of silt and tree trunks. If extensive work is done north of Kilkenny and the waters flow down after heavy rain irreparable damage will be done in Kilkenny, Thomastown and Inistiog. These towns have all suffered from flooding in the past. The position in the future may be much worse. I understand from other Deputies to whom I have spoken that the same is true of other areas where there are large rivers.
I am not saying we should not have the scheme, but I do think the arterial drainage should be put into operation before these smaller schemes are carried out. I agree that excellent work is being done in some areas. I might mention here that we carried out a scheme in Kilkenny under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, and the Minister for Agriculture subsequently claimed the credit for it. I understand he sent down a special representative to report on it. It was really one of the Department of Local Government's schemes. However, it was not our business to interfere. It was a matter for the Department of Local Government. The scheme was a good one, and the Minister for Agriculture took advantage of that fact.