We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach—(Resumed).

Contributions 1–155 of 324. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In 1949, the contribution of industry to the national income was about 20 per cent., distribution and transport about 16 per cent. and all other activities (public authorities, professional and personal services, personal rent, net income from abroad, etc.) was about 36 per cent. With regard to the proportions borne by employees remuneration on the one hand and profits, rents, etc., on the other, it will be convenient to consider these items in relation to non-agricultural income produced at home, i.e. excluding net receipts from abroad. On this basis, wages and salaries represented about 67 per cent. of non-agricultural income produced at home in 1949, as compared with 67 per cent. in 1948, 64 per cent. in 1947 and 62 per cent. in 1938. Thus the share of employees remuneration in non-agricultural income has increased since before the war.

The provisional index for the year 1949 of the volume of production, (taking the base 1938 as equivalent to 100), of industries producing transportable goods was 142.9. The annual index for 1948 was 132.0 and 120.5 for 1947. These figures represent an increase in the volume of production of 18.6 per cent. between 1947 and 1949 and an increase of 8.3 per cent. between 1948 and 1949. This remarkable growth has since continued. In fact, the quarterly index for the first three months of 1950, which was 150.4 shows an increase of 14.6 per cent. over the figure of 131.2 for the corresponding period in 1949. It is a tribute to all concerned in industry in this country that, after the difficulties of the war period when there was a decline in volume of output of about 20 per cent. as compared with pre-war, there should have been such an extraordinary recovery.

The increase in the index of the volume of production have, of course, been accompanied by an increase in the total number of persons engaged in industries covered by the Census of Industrial Production from 166,000 in 1938 to an estimated total of 206,000 in 1949. All this growth has, in effect, taken place since 1946, when the total of 167,000 was almost at the pre-war level. In 1947 the volume of output per wage-earner was 7.4 per cent. above the pre-war level in the case of transportable goods industries and 5.7 per cent. up in the case of all industries. The 1948 figures show a further rise, the index for transportable goods industries being 12.6 per cent. and that for all industries and services 11.2 per cent. above pre-war. While great credit is due to Irish industrialists and Irish workers for such a considerable advance in so short a period, it is well to remember that these figures show that, in relation to the whole period since before the war, the increase represents a growth in industrial production of only about 1 per cent. per annum. In an expanding economy this is not, by international standards, an altogether impressive achievement and there should be no complacency among either employers or employees, particularly since an important contributory cause was improved equipment and improved availability of materials of suitable quality after the stringencies of the war years. A further great effort is needed in the industrial field, not only to increase production but to make it more efficient. Big improvements are called for in organisation of industry, in management skill, in improved standards of work by employees, all of which will contribute to improve industrial efficiency. In pursuit of these aims, we hope to secure some particularly useful help and advice from the Industrial Development Authority and from the Economic Co-operation Administration.

It must be emphasised that these figures for productivity which I have given are based on the data provided by the Census of Industrial Production returns and that these are far from ideal for such a purpose. They are useful as a rough measurement but special inquiries in the nature of costings for individual industries would be necessary to produce accurate measurements of this very difficult concept.

It is too often assumed that a growth in the physical output per worker will of necessity produce an equal increase in the amount available for distribution between the factors of production. In fact, however, there has been since pre-war a fairly considerable decrease in the net output of industry when expressed as a percentage of gross output. In 1938 in the industries producing transportable goods net output was 34.1 per cent. of gross output, in 1947 it was 31.1 per cent. and 30.7 per cent. in 1948. For all industries and services between 1938 and 1948, gross output increased in value by 136 per cent. while net output increased by 110 per cent. There is accordingly, as compared with pre-war, relatively less for everybody concerned in the gross output.

Net output represents the value added by processing to the materials of industries and is the sum available for distribution in wages, salaries, profits and other miscellaneous costs. While between 1938 and 1948 the total output increased by 110 per cent., wages and salaries increased by 116 per cent., profits and miscellaneous costs having increased by 102 per cent. The actual increased in wages was 120 per cent. and in salaries 98 per cent. Expressed otherwise, wages and salaries constituted a somewhat larger proportion of the net output in 1948 than in 1938, namely, about 61 per cent. as compared with 60 per cent.

Agriculture too, has shown a striking and encouraging improvement. From its very nature agricultural production is slow both in its rise and fall. Due to the efforts of our farmers, despits all the wartime shortages of fertilisers, equipment and so on, the volume of gross agricultural output never fell more than 7 per cent. below the 1938-39 level during the war years. Last year the gross volume of agricultural output was back to the pre-war level and the net output volume showed a gain of 2.2 per cent. over 1938-39.

While the increase in industrial production has been accompanied by an increase in the numbers engaged, the pre-war level of agricultural production has been attained despite a fairly considerable fall in the numbers of workers in agriculture. Much though this is to be regretted, it must not be forgotten that the implication is that a smaller number engaged in agriculture have had a larger share in the return. In this context it must be emphasised that before the war there was chronic underemployment on Irish farms.

If we are to succeed in stemming the tide of emigration, we must do so by providing work for our people at home. Not only must there be a further considerable increase in industrial employment but the output of agriculture must rise too. Our industries are unfortunately very largely dependent on the import of raw materials and these we must pay for. It is, of course, quite legitimate to use some of our accumulated sterling assets to purchase capital equipment and materials for capital development but it would be questionable policy deliberately to use them for the current purchases of other raw materials. We must, therefore, if our industry is to develop, expand our exports to buy the increased quantities of materials needed. Improved agricultural production and exports are therefore a fundamental need of our economy not only for the expansion of the home market but also to provide the wherewithal to enable our industry to continue to forge ahead as it has been doing in the recent past and continues to do.

The transfer from agriculture to non-agricultural employment within the State is proceeding at a strikingly rapid rate. In this connection I would like to indicate in a very general way the extent of the change in the distribution of the working population between 1936 and 1946 as shown by the Census of Population. Fairly detailed statistics of the distribution of the population at work will be published in the September issue of the Irish Trade Journal and Statistical Bulletin. The Census statistics show that between 1936 and 1946 the whole population at work declined slightly from 1,235,000 to 1,228,000, the number in agriculture falling from 609,000 to 572,000, the number in industry increased from 205,000 to 212,000, and the number in other employments (distribution, transport services, public services, etc.) increased from 421,000 to 444,000. These changes are highly significant but far less so than the changes which have been occurring during the last four years. Since 1946, the Census year, it is roughly estimated that the number at work in agriculture has fallen by a further 50,000 while the number in industry has increased by 40,000 and the number in other employments has increased by 20,000, the overall increase being 10,000. The percentage of the working population in agriculture is now but 42 per cent. of the total as compared with 49 per cent. in 1936, the proportions in industry 20 per cent. as compared with 17 per cent. in 1936 and the proportions in other employments 38 per cent. as compared with 34 per cent. in 1936. Though agricultural output has been increasing during the last four years, the decline in the agricultural population is to be deplored, but there it is. It would be far better if a much greater increase in agricultural output could be obtained, the workers remaining on the land. The endemic underemployment in agriculture before the war in now taking its toll. It is highly significant that between 1936 and 1946 the numbers of “relatives assisting farmers” declined by 41,000 accounting for the total decline in the agricultural section of the national economy. This is the class which was formerly underemployed, and which is now becoming absorbed in productive industrial employment.

A measure of the magnitude of the problem facing the country in trying to lessen, if not to stop, emigration is that, despite the fact that the agricultural population was never so prosperous as it is now and non-agricultural employment and earnings were higher than ever before, emigration continues. In the four years 1946 to 1949 and in the 12 months ended May of this year, the net passenger balances by sea (probably the best indication of the volume of net emigration) were as follows:—

Period | Number

Year 1946 | 3,000

,, 1947 | 10,000

,, 1948 | 27,000

,, 1949 | 17,000

Twelve months ended May, 1950 | 11,000

I do not wish to make political capital from the fact that net emigration has shown some tendency to decrease in 1949-1950. This problem is not only the responsibility of the Government but of the Oireachtas and the country. There is no guarantee that the recent decline will continue. One can only hope that potential emigrants in the future will consider their personal interest and the interest of their country, and that the favourable economic environment will have the desirable psychological effect of keeping them at home in well-paid employment. In this connection, however, I should like to repeat what I have already said, that since 1946 the number of persons engaged in non-agricultural employment has increased by the remarkable figure of 60,000.

A guiding rule in Government policy has been and continues to be the desirability of maintaining a satisfactory equilibrium in the balance of payments. This must not be taken to mean that all other considerations must be sacrificed to achieve a strict balance between the values of exports and imports. It does mean, however, that in formulating economic policy the Government gives careful consideration to the possible effects on that policy of both the balance of trade and the balance of payments. There are times when a temporary disequilibrium in the balance of payments is fully justified. There are times when the implementation of a particular economic policy requires the conscious creation of a deficit in the balance of payments. Such a deficit is inevitable, for instance, if a policy of repatriation of foreign assets is being undertaken. What is necessary, however, is to ensure that fluctuations in the balance of payments are not left to the blind arbitrament of chance.

In 1947 the deficit in the balance of trade was £91.8 millions; in 1948 the deficit in the balance of trade was £87 millions; in 1949 it had fallen to £69.3 millions. The substantial reductions achieved over these years in the unfavourable balance was in the main due to a very substantial increase in exports. The comparatively high level of imports in each of the years 1947-1948, inclusive, as compared with pre-war years, was due mainly to the general increase in prices. It was also partly due to the better availability of supplies which permitted considerable restocking in the home market to meet arrears of demands since the shortages of the war years.

One of the healthiest features of our economy since 1947 has, however, been the striking increase in exports. In 1947, the value of exports and reexports was £39.5 millions; in 1949, the figure had risen to £60.5 millions. The main items responsible for this great increase in the value of exports during 1949 were cattle and beef, eggs, poultry, raw wool, chocolate crumb, ropes, jams, marmalades, beer, whiskey, paper and cardboard.

In 1949, the volume of imports was 27 per cent. over the 1938 volume; the value of these imports was about three times the corresponding figure for 1938. The value of exports in 1949 was two and a half times the pre-war level, but the volume in 1949 was 90 per cent. of the pre-war level. The significance of this encouraging feature in our trade position is underlined by the fact that the volume of exports in 1949 increased by about 20 per cent. over 1948.

In 1948 the import price index was 259 as compared with 100 in 1938. In 1949, despite devaluation, it had fallen to 248. In 1948, the export price index was 273; in 1949, it rose to 279.

For the first five months of 1950 our imports have shown an increase in value of £9.9 millions (or of 18 per cent.) as compared with the corresponding period last year.

The increase in volume has been about 11 per cent. and the remainder of the rise is attributable to price increases. The total value of our exports for January-May, 1950 is £1.6 million greater than for January-May, 1949, an increase of about 7 per cent. In the case of exports the increase in volume was about 6 per cent. and the rise due to prices relatively small.

The question of the composition of our imports is just as important as that of their total value or volume. In 1938, out of a total of £41.4 million, we imported £2.9 million worth of producers' capital goods ready for use or 7.0 per cent. of all imports. In 1949 such capital imports totalled £13.5 million or 10.4 per cent. of all imports. It is very difficult to classify the materials imported for industry as to whether they are required for the production of capital or of consumers' goods. An attempt has, however, been made to do so and, using the same basis in 1938 and in 1949, it is estimated that the total value of the imports of capital goods ready for use and of materials for home produced capital goods was £9.1 million in 1938 and £33.5 million in 1949. Such imports constituted 22.0 per cent. of the total in 1938 and 25.8 per cent. in 1949. The corresponding percentages for imports in the first four months of 1949 and 1950 have been estimated as 25.8 and 25.5 respectively.

It is of the utmost importance to realise that in a year such as 1949 when we drew on our accumulated sterling balances to the extent of somewhat less than £10,000,000, we at the same time imported £13,500,000 worth of capital goods ready for use as well as about another £20,000,000 worth of material for the production of capital goods at home. Thus, by far the greater portion of these capital imports were financed by our earnings on current accounts.

The deficits in the balance of payments in 1947 and 1948 amounted respectively to £30,000,000 and £20,000,000. These were financed by drawing upon external assets and the aggregate drawing represented about one-third of the accumulation of sterling assets during the preceding seven years when current receipts could not be fully spent owing to the acute difficulty in obtaining supplies from abroad. Notwithstanding higher imports in 1948, the over-all deficit on current account declined by £10,000,000 as compared with 1947 as a result of higher invisible earnings as well as increased exports. In 1949 the balance of payments was brought considerably nearer full equilibrium, the provisional Estimate showing a deficit of approximately £10,000, probably less than £10,000 when final figures are available. This position has been achieved mainly through increased exports.

The problem of the deficit in the balance of payments with the dollar countries, which had continued since the war to overshadow all the other economic problems of the sterling area, was greatly aggravated during the early part of 1949 by a temporary falling-off in U.S. purchases of sterling area materials, at the very time that imports from North America by the members of the sterling group were increasing. Throughout the first eight months of 1949 the position of sterling continued to be critical. Certain sterling area countries curtailed imports from dollar sources. But the obvious inadequacy of that step alone, the withholding of foreign orders for British and other sterling goods in the expectation of an alteration in exchange rates, and, to a lesser extent, concern over the volume of indirect transactions financed in open markets through so-called "cheap sterling", all contributed to the announcement by the British Government in September, 1949, of a 30 per cent devaluation of the £ in terms of dollars. Britain's step in devaluing was promptly followed by similar action on the part of all the other countries of the sterling area except Pakistan, and by a 9 per cent. cut in the Canadian dollar. The great importance of this group of countries in world trade soon forced most of the countries of Western Europe and several overseas countries to devalue their currencies as well.

Following devaluation, the value of exports to countries that did not devalue required to be increased by 44 per cent. in terms of Irish currency, in order to earn the same amount of foreign exchange as before. The same was true, in a modified degree, in the case of exports to those countries which devalued only partially with reference to sterling. As Irish exports go mainly to Britain and other countries which also devalued their currencies, the effect on our export trade of the alteration in the exchange rate of the £ could not be appreciable. In the case of Britain, devaluation of the £ was calculated to stimulate larger sales to the Western Hemisphere through a reduction in the dollar prices of British goods. In Ireland's case, the prospect of developing exports to the United States is not likely to be influenced immediately to any substantial extent by devaluation because the types of products which Ireland has available for export are not, in general, such as to command a sizeable market in the United States. Similar considerations apply in the case of Canada, to which exports at present are small.

Belgium and Switzerland are such highly competitive markets by reason of their liberal import régimes, that they are unlikely to provide scope for any large expansion in our exports of manufactured goods, as we have to compete in these and other markets with the many countries which have devalued their currencies to the same extent as ourselves.

In view of the many unpredictable factors involved, it is extremely difficult to give a considered opinion on the probable long-term effects of devaluation on trade and prices. One of the immediate and automatic effects was, of course, that imports from dollar sources were rendered 44 per cent. dearer in terms of Irish currency than previously. However, apart from the mechanical adjustments in the relationship between the two price series, the ultimate effect of devaluation must inevitably be an increase in sterling prices and a decrease in dollar prices. Prices of various commodities in the U.S.A. have already shown reductions, by reason of a certain fall in demand and for other causes. The import prices of raw materials and food stuffs originating in the dollar area have risen by widely varying margins, ranging up to the full extent of 44 per cent.

Irish import prices have risen on average by 2 per cent and wholesale prices by 1 per cent. between January and May, 1950. The index number of retail prices at mid-May, 1950 (Base: mid-August, 1947 = 100) was 102. Agricultural prices dropped seasonally by 1 per cent. during that period. The terms of trade, that is, the ratio of the export price index to the import price index remains favourable to this country, on the 1938 basis of exchange.

The comparative stability of Irish prices since devaluation is probably due to the fact that supplies of many commodities have been obtained at pre-devaluation rates from producers' stocks, and, in particular, from forward purchases in Britain. The comparative steadiness of British export prices, which increased by about 5 per cent. between April, 1949, and April, 1950, is reflected in the relatively small increase in Irish import prices.

The increases in the British index numbers for import, wholesale and retail prices between April, 1949, and April, 1950, have been relatively much greater than in the corresponding Irish price index numbers. During this period, British import prices rose by 13 per cent., wholesale prices by 10 per cent. and retail prices by 4.6 per cent. Significantly, the rise in British import and wholesale prices represents mainly increases in costs of raw materials and of goods in which the passage of raw materials to the finished article is rapid. A second phase is now in process of completion, in which the substantial increase in the cost of raw materials since devaluation (prices of imports have risen on average by over 25 per cent.) is spreading its effect throughout the whole structure of industrial costs and prices. The effects of this second phase, in so far as this country is concerned, are likely to be reflected in an advance in Irish import prices in future months. Owing to the relatively high ratio which imports bear to the total supply of goods and services, an increase in import prices would undoubtedly be reflected in both wholesale and retail prices generally.

Heretofore Ireland's traditional products have not been such as to command a significant market in North America and even yet the contribution which commodity exports can make to increasing our dollar earnings is of very limited dimensions. The most valuable part which Ireland can play, and is playing towards closing the European dollar gap consists in exporting to the other member countries of the O.E.E.C. the commodities, mainly animal products, food and drink, which these countries would otherwise have to obtain from dollar sources. Energetic efforts are nevertheless being made to increase Ireland's direct exports of commodities and services to North America. The most anxious attention is being given to the tourist industry, our most important potential source of dollar income, and the recent establishment of the Dollar Exports Advisory Committee is evidence that the Government will spare no effort to devise the most effective means of expanding the volume of our commodity exports to dollar countries. During the past twelve months steps have been taken to exhibit samples of Irish goods in North America. There was an exhibition of Irish products in a large store in Boston in the early part of 1949, and a similar exhibition in New York towards the end of last year. The Government have decided to participate in an international trade fair to be held in Chicago in next month and are providing financial assistance to enable Irish firms to take part.

The Government have been giving very active attention to the development of an export trade generally in Irish manufactured goods. In negotiations which have led to the conclusion of trade agreements, not merely with Great Britain, but with France, Western Germany, the Netherlands and Sweden, the greatest importance has been attached to the necessity for securing entry to the markets of these countries for the products of Irish industry. These trade agreements, by securing the right of entry for Irish goods, enable our industrialists to plan ahead with confidence in the knowledge that for a wide range of goods a market is available.

The 1948 Trade Agreement with France was renewed last year. So too was the agreement with Sweden. A very satisfactory trade agreement with Western Germany has been signed this week, which guarantees a considerable increase in the volume of trade between Ireland and Germany for the next 12 months. Preliminary arrangements are at present being made for the extension of other trade agreements or for the negotiation of new ones.

During the past 12 months unemployment has continued to decline. The percentage of persons insured under the Employment Insurance Acts who were registered as unemployed averaged 9.0 in the year 1949 as compared with 9.4 in 1948, 9.3 in 1947 and 15.0 in 1938. In the first six months of 1950 the figure averaged 8.7 per cent., substantially below the 10.3 per cent. in the corresponding period last year. Actually the 6.6 per cent. for June, 1950, is by far the lowest on record. These percentages cover the whole State. In cities and towns, where unemployment is usually more severe in its incidence than in rural districts, where it is sometimes mitigated by earnings in kind, the number in the period January to May averaged 28,000 in 1950, 32,000 in 1949 and 43,000 in 1938. The decline in actual numbers must be considered against the background of a substantial increase in the working population to which reference has already been made. The difference in trend as between skilled and unskilled reflects, of course, the present great demand for skilled industrial workers.

While, in general, this country cannot be regarded yet as enjoying a condition of full employment, there are serious shortages of skilled labour and, for this reason, the Government has been campaigning to induce skilled workers to return from Great Britain to assist in the industrial expansion of their homeland. On this point Deputies will be interested to know that between January, 1939, and January, 1950, while the number of unskilled industrial workers unemployed declined by 24 per cent., the number of skilled workers unemployed declined by much more, namely 52 per cent. Between January, 1949, and January, 1950, the percentage declines in unemployment were respectively seven and 19 for the unskilled and skilled unemployed.

Having presented the House with a brief and necessarily sketchy survey of the various sections of the country's economic activities, I should now like to refer in a general way to the economic policy of the Government. There has been an attempt in some quarters to suggest that the form of this year's Budget and the financial policy underlying it represented a radical departure from the financial policy enunciated by members of the Government during the first year of its existence. I think it is not merely my right but my responsibility to express a comment on these suggestions.

In my first public statement as Taoiseach in a broadcast on the 24th February, 1948, I summarised as follows the economic policy which the Government would pursue:—

"In existing circumstances efforts must be concentrated on measures to increase the national income so as to provide within the limits of our resources for adequate health and social services; so as, within the shortest possible time, to increase agricultural and industrial production and thereby provide some hope of easing the pressing burden of the high cost of living. Our export trade must be increased so as to lessen the serious gap between the volume of exports and imports which is causing disorder in our balance of payments. The real wealth of the nation must be increased."

It will, I think, be admitted from the statistical evidence I have given the House that many of these aims have been achieved.

Speaking in Dublin on the 26th May, 1948, in an address to the Dublin Chamber of Commerce, I said:—

"I have stressed the necessity for saving. But having done so it is necessary to give equal emphasis to the necessity for productive investment of savings. It will be generally agreed that this country has for many decades been suffering from chronic under-investment. . . . It can scarcely be questioned that our national income per head is far too low for a country so rich as ours which has the potential to be very much richer. Unless national capital is increased, there is no hope for any real increase in the national income. . . . There is no reason why this country, which is comparatively under-developed, should be satisfied with a normal rate of increase in national income. We should aim at a rate of increase much above the normal, and the Government is determined to use every effort to secure the acceptance of that which must be regarded as a fundamental truth of Irish economics."

These observations were made, I repeat over two years ago.

The Government have been using every effort during the past two and a half years to secure the acceptance of the truth contained in these observations by encouraging productive investment and by creating conditions favourable to productive investment.

Speaking in this House last July, in the course of introducing the Estimate for my Department—Dáil Debates. Vol. 117, No. 16, col. 1368—I repeated that the policy of providing productive work and thereby increasing the wealth of the nation was the underlying principle of all Government policy. I said:—

"That policy is indicated by the high level of capital expenditure which is provided in the Budget this year. Most people regard the annual Budget which is introduced to this House as something which either imposes taxation or which they hope will decrease taxation. That portion of the Budget which deals with taxation, with the housekeeping element in our country's affairs, in fact, only brings within its scope something like one-fourth of the country's economic activities. That portion of the Budget is important in itself. You might refer to it as the budget of expenses, the housekeeping portion. However, to get a comprehensive over-all picture of our national economy and activities, you must look at the really important portion of the Budget which deals with the employment of public moneys, the capital schemes and capital expenditure."

I think it will be agreed from these extracts and from other statements I have made on the Government's economic policy since I assumed office, that the principle of large-scale capital investment has been, from the beginning, a most important feature of Government policy. The recent Budget did not introduce that principle for the first time. The form of the recent Budget and the form of the Estimates for the current financial year merely presented that principle in a manner which made it perfectly clear to every member of the public that, in practice as well as in theory, the Government's economic policy was founded on the principle that, in a modern State which aims at providing productive employment for its citizens and for its national resources, budgetary policy must be based on the national income as a whole and not on the limited sector of that national income which enters into what might be called the ordinary current or housekeeping Budget.

The size of the national income is the only real indicator of economic development. Increases in productivity and increments in national income combine to provide a dividend of progress in an expanding economy. Only through an expanding economy can we provide the better living standards for our people which must be the ultimate aim of all Government policy. It will be generally agreed by people who accept this principle that the dual Budget system which we have now adopted is the best way of indicating clearly to our people the measures which are being devised to reap, through increases in national income, the dividend of progress to which I have referred. In this way alone can policy be framed so to achieve such a level of productive national activity that full employment may become a reality and avoidable emigration unnecessary. Emigration and under-employment have been endemic in this country for so long that the disease cannot be extirpated overnight. Laissez-faire methods will not provide a cure; only the deliberate creation of satisfactory social and economic conditions will eliminate it. Much has been achieved to reduce unemployment and the work is going on. Throughout the world, chronic unemployment has become in this century the greatest threat to free institutions. We are convinced that only by vigorously pursuing the policy of capital investment upon which we have embarked can Irish democracy survive the requirements of this century and serve the greatest good of a people whose traditional way of life has been built on thrifty enterprise and personal effort.

We want to encourage enterprise from employers and from workers, from local bodies, chambers of commerce, vocational groups and trade unions. We want to stimulate a spirit of local initiative and inculcate a greater sense of responsibility in our people. Our economic policy has been aimed at creating conditions in which this progress by the community may be possible. To maintain a high level of employment of men and national resources is more than a mere political expedient. It is an essential condition of democratic survival. Since introducing the Budgetary policy about which I have been speaking, members of the Government have invited constructive criticism from all sections of the people and from all sides of this House. We welcome constructive criticism which may have the effect of improving the plans we are putting into operation. I regret that very little constructive criticism has been offered by members of the Opposition, but such as has been offered suggests that, instead of pursuing an expansionist policy at present, the Government should restrain its borrowing for capital investment to the minimum, so that resources might be available to meet a cyclic depression which pessimistic prophets foresee. This attitude was summed up by the statement that we were "using resources that might be needed for use when depression and deflation came". The reference is to the Leader of the Opposition, Volume 121, No. 3, column 391, of the Official Reports. This attitude displays a misunderstanding of the economic policy which we are pursuing and ignores the economic realities of the external world. This country has not been affected to any extent by cyclic depressions. Our problem is one of continued under-unemployment of natural resources. We do not have to wait for a world depression before having to mobilise our resources by borrowing for the purpose of maintaining a high level of employment. Private investment alone is not sufficient to maintain in Ireland a high level of employment.

Ever since the formation of the State, throughout the terms of office of successive Governments there has been a high level of unemployment, a high volume of unemployment, a high volume of emigration and a great part of our land inadequately developed or left unfertile. In circumstances such as these, it is the sheerest mockery of economic theory to suggest that no drastic action should be taken to improve the conditions of our economy until such time as a chronic depression descends upon Europe. In circumstances such as exist in Ireland, with men and natural resources unemployed, the employment of these idle resources must be secured through investment which, if it cannot come from private effort, must be supplied by the State. This country is not materially affected by cyclic depressions after the manner of complex industrial societies where there are great fluctuations in demand. Our problem is not an acute depression but a constant, long-sustained level of undeveloped and unemployed resources. We do not have to import a chronic depression before taking action. The level of our unemployment and emigration during the past quarter of a century is ample testimony that in a very real sense some pernicious economic illness has in the past held the Irish economy in its paralysing grip.

It has been observed that the policy which we are pursuing involves a danger of inflation. The Minister for Finance has gone to great care to point out the risks of inflation which exist in the present situation. The fact, however, that the danger or the risk of inflation exists is quite a different thing from the actuality of inflation. As mortals, we all face the risk or danger of sudden death, but we do not have to act as if sudden death were already upon us and the risk and fear were actualities. To refuse to take a risk in a good cause is a sorry admission of feeble timidity, particularly when, as in the present context, there is so much more to justify the effort than the comforting thought that in the long run we will all be dead.

Nor is there any truth or any substance in the suggestion that the capital investment programme involves the use for the benefit of the community of more resources than it can afford. It is perfectly evident that there are resources of men and material available for productive use and I am sure most members of the House will agree that what is physically possible is financially possible. I do not say it is always desirable. The danger of inflation becomes imminent only when an attempt is made by financial means to achieve that which is physically impossible. We are a long way from that point in this country and I can assure you that that is an experiment which this Government will never undertake —in times of peace, at any rate.

It has become the fashion in some quarters to criticise in a sweeping way the general policy of the capital investment programme and to criticise vaguely the schemes covered by that policy. Such criticism is valueless. If critics can point to the undesirability of executing any specific scheme as a capital investment project they are being helpful. But if they condemn in mere general terms, without indicating which scheme they would reject, their criticism becomes merely irresponsible. In this House, this afternoon, the Minister for Finance repeated the challenge to the Opposition to give him details of any of the £12,000,000, of the projects for capital expenditure, which are specifically stated in the Book of Estimates, to which they object, and he will deal with their objections. As a feature of this irresponsible criticism I would refer to a statement made on one or two occasions to the effect that the national debt of this country has increased by 50 per cent. in the past few years. The real position is quite otherwise. In March, 1950, the gross liabilities of the State amounted to £157.3 millions of which over £21,000,000 represents the liquid proceeds of the Marshall Aid Fund, which are available for use and which are being used for the benefit of the community. The gross national assets of the State amounted to £43.9 millions in 1947. On the 31st March of this year they had increased by £45,000,000 to a figure of £88,000,000. In speaking of the national debt it is necessary to consider both sides of the national balance sheet; to take both national liabilities and national assets in conjunction to get a clear picture of the true national debt position. When this is done it is easy to appreciate the nonsense of the suggestion that the national debt of the State has increased by 50 per cent. in the past few years.

Speaking to Clonmel Chamber of Commerce on the 24th April of last year I made a reference to public debt which I think I should repeat here. It is as follows:—

"There is a close analogy between the national debt and the debt of a private corporation. A private corporation, like the nation, does not expect to die. A corporation debt is treated in the balance sheet as the counterpart to the plant and equipment and other assets that the debt represents. An increase in outstanding debt is regarded by the directors as the counterpart of expenses of equipment and plant undertaken to deal with an increased volume of business. That firm, therefore, is debt-free only when it is bankrupt. No accountant would be so absurd as to report to his directors a deficit of £9,000 in a year in which his business earned a profit of £1,000 and in which the firm was able to spend £10,000 on building a new factory. Yet that is precisely the mistake made when speaking of a national deficit resulting from capital investment by the State."

The aim of the Government's economic policy is to secure a more buoyant and expanding national income, which will, in real terms, increase substantially the standard of living of our people and solve the problems of emigration and unemployment. The up-to-date statistics which I have quoted indicate the progress which has been made and which is being made to that end. The Government will spare no effort to accelerate that progress. For far too long Ireland has been a country of unrealised social and economic potentialities.

Dealing with this Estimate last year, I stated that it gave an opportunity to Deputies to look at the over-all picture. In the course of the discussion on Estimates for individual Ministers, Deputies had an opportunity of dealing with the details of Government expenditure and Government policy. This Estimate gives an opportunity for dealing with over-all Government policy and of having a look at the over-all picture.

Although, this year, the picture must be looked at in the rather more sombre background of the present international scene, nevertheless, some of the tints in the picture to which I referred last year as being bright are brighter still this year. Some of the tints which were grey last year are brighter this year. There are still some dark spots but, looking at the picture as a whole, I think we have solid grounds for a reasonable satisfaction as to what has been achieved and have considerable justification for prudent confidence in the future.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I move that the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration. When I was listening to the first portion of the Taoiseach's statement I made up my mind that I would begin by complimenting him on the refreshing change from the flamboyant statements to which we have become accustomed from the opposite benches to a sober statement of fact. We could not possibly digest all the figures and see the implications of the figures which he gave in the rather long statistical survey of the economic position of the country. I was about to suggest that on occasions like this it would be desirable, if he wished any properly informed discussion upon the figures, that he would supply them to us in bulletin form so that, before the debate, we could study them, see their implications and ask ourselves what is their real significance. I do not think anybody who listened to the reading of these figures could have grasped them so completely or even written them down, so as to use them properly in the debate. There was not, however, anything astonishing in the picture that was revealed by the figures in so far as we could grasp them from the mere listening to them. Most of us have been informed already in regard to the figure of the national income and the figure representing our external assets. We have learned from statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce of the progress in industrial production and in employment in industry, and so forth. Therefore, in so far as one can comprehend the statement in general, it did not reveal anything which, I think, was not already known to the members of this House. At the same time I do not say that a close study of the figures, which will be possible when we see them in printed form, will not reveal aspects which do not appear at first sight. Before I leave the question of statistics I should like to say that I am very glad that we got a survey of this sort from the Department and glad to note that that Department is acting independently. I presume that any time members of the Opposition want fundamental facts the information will be made available to them just as it would be made available to the Government Deputies. Perhaps the method would have to be by way of parliamentary question.

Comment on this

I desire to say that all the information in my Department will be available to Deputies any time they want it.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

That will be a great advantage. I do not know whether I could go a step further in suggesting a scheme such as that which they have developed in the Congress of the United States of America whereby there is a Department to facilitate private Congressmen and private Senators who may want to make investigations. I mention that matter so that it will be looked into in an effort to see whether any help can be made available to the Opposition on such lines. If our discussions here are to be of real value the information which is necessary to enable us to form proper judgments should be available to us. A great deal of our time here is very often wasted in arguing at cross-purposes.

I should like also to say, in connection with the Statistics Department, that if it is to be of real value two things are essential. The first of these is that we should have a sufficiently adequate staff to ensure that these statistics are available quickly. I would point out that statistics lose their value to the public and become useless from the point of view of trying to regulate Government or national policy if they come late. They become what almost could be described as of historical interest only. If they are to be of real present-day value it is necessary that they should come quickly. I hope that the Government, and the Taoiseach in particular, will see to it that a sufficient number of persons will compose the staff so that may be done.

One of the most valuable of our statistical publications is the Statistical Abstract. It is the book to which anybody will go in the first instance to get general information. Unfortunately, it has been late in its publication up to the present. I hope that that book will be produced every year immediately the statistical bases for it become available. It deals both with the calendar and with the financial year.

That brings me to another point which I should like to have considered by members of the Government, namely, the question of making the financial year coincide with the calendar year. From the point of view of the work that would be done in the House, and from the point of view of the staffs and the members of the House, it would be very much better if the summer season were largely free. In that way a great deal of the discussion could take place here on matters that only begin seriously to be considered after March. Though I ask that that should be considered I realise that there are some difficulties in the way. However, I was never completely satisfied that these difficulties were sufficiently great to prevent the idea of the two years corresponding from being adopted.

In addition, having a sufficiently numerous staff, it is necessary that they be of first-class quality. You will not get a staff of first-class quality unless you pay salaries which will attract men of the highest ability. It was a complaint of mine, when we were in charge of the Government of this country, that the technicians in every Department were not paid sufficiently well in comparison with the administrative staffs. I realise the importance of the work being done by the administrative staffs but, as a rule, when civil servants enter an administrative Department they have chances of promotion. The trouble is that when you get into a specialised or technical section, such as a statistics section, it is composed, as a rule, of only a small group of persons and the possibilities of promotion are not great. That helps also to deter people of the quality that should be available for services of this kind from pursuing their studies to enable them to qualify, and they go on to other lines of activity.

It is customary in the debate on the Taoiseach's Estimate to deal with some of the major points of policy to which the Opposition want to direct attention. The increase in Government expenditure is obviously one, particularly having regard to the statements made by the members of the various Parties who support the Government. If democracy is to be a reality, if there is to be real confidence in it, the statements made at election time ought to be of such a kind that the public can put some confidence in them. If people are elected to office, and if when they get to office, the policies which they pursue are directly at variance with the policies which they professed when they were looking for election, it is quite clear that that strikes at the root of any confidence in democratic Government. I think it is right, therefore, in the interests of democracy generally, that when statements are made at election times, those who make those statements should constantly be reminded of what they have promised.

It is in that context that one naturally approaches the consideration of Government expenditure at the present time. The next question that one would naturally think of is the question of the cost of living. There, too, the facts and the promises are vividly in contrast, and those who expose that are doing a right and proper thing in the public interest.

There is, too, the fundamental question of emigration. The Taoiseach, in part of his statement, has referred to it. I, as Taoiseach, made a fairly long speech on that matter. It is a speech that I think I could repeat to-day, and anybody else interested in the question who wanted to tell the truth could repeat it to-day without very much change. It is very easy to take a sentence and twist it and put one phrase in one part with another phrase and give a completely wrong impression as to what was said. The Minister for Finance was guilty of that, and the Taoiseach, by singling out a phrase which I used here—it was on the occasion on which the use of external assets was in question—took it out of a long speech in such a manner as would not indicate the argument to which it was a reply.

Comment on this

It was not from a long speech. It was a summing up of what someone else said, the summing up of an argument.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It had reference to some particular statement made from the Government side of the House, where the suggestion was that you could regard these moneys as a hindrance instead of being of value, as if external assets were things to be dissipated just for the sake of dissipating them. Now, with regard to the Taoiseach's statement that we have no cyclic depressions here, of course we have not cyclic depressions here of the type that you have in industrial countries, but we do have depressions here. We had, for instance, an agricultural depression from 1929 onwards, and that was due to outside causes. By 1932, before we got into office, you had got into a very deep agricultural depression, and everyone knows that.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

We know who brought it about, too.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

How could we have brought it about from 1929 to 1932? How does the doctrine expressed by the Taoiseach compare with the Fine Gael doctrine of those days?

Comment on this

Did your Party not get in on that agricultural depression?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Most of the policy the Taoiseach has been talking about is the policy that was brought in by us, despite all your efforts to prevent it. It is a policy that was based upon decent social ideals. It is the policy for which we stand to-day, just as strongly as we stood then, and our whole history, the history of our Government during the period, was a history of trying to get out of the laissez faire position which Fine Gael wanted to preserve. I well remember the speeches that used to be made from that side of the House when I was in opposition and before our Party got to be the Government. I was delighted to hear the expressions of Republicanism from that side, when they were brought to make them, and so was I delighted when I heard the Taoiseach giving expression to ideals which were always our ideals but which he now wants to pretend are his and his Party's and that they are ideals to which we were opposed.

Comment on this

Will the Leader of the Opposition refer to the precise matter that he has in mind?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I am referring to the taking out by the Taoiseach of a sentence from a statement of mine with regard to the possibility of depression and suggesting all round that our attitude towards national development was of the type that he characterised. The position is this, that the greater part of the aims that have been set down in the Taoiseach's statement as his aims have always been our aims and we are not converts. We have criticised statements with regard to what is called capital development and, when we did so, we were criticising statements made on the other side of the House with regard to the use that should be made of, and the manner in which you could bring back, our external assets.

We always wanted to see that these assets should be used productively but we felt there was an obligation to prove that they would be really productive, that if you put £100 in you are going to get £100 out or, if you did not, that you should ascertain what fraction you would get and judge if it was adequate. The duty of showing that would be the duty of the Government, but they have not done it. They have said: "We will do this and we will get certain results," but they have never attempted to estimate the percentage of the results or the extent to which capital assets would bring in something in the new circumstances which they would not have brought in in the old. We were always for the use of the capital resources of this country for the development of the country, and any suggestion by the Taoiseach that we had a different point of view is quite incorrect.

Comment on this

Surely the Leader of the Opposition and his Party have opposed certain proposals in regard to capital development?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

We have opposed two things, first, the use of borrowing where it was quite clear that borrowing should not be used, and secondly, we have questioned in many cases whether the use of our resources would be productive to an extent which would warrant the use of the assets in that direction.

Comment on this

In what cases should borrowing not have been used?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I ask to be allowed to develop my points. Anyone who wants to speak later will have plenty of room and ample opportunity to do so. As I pointed out on the Vote on Account, we have not been against the use of national resources for national development and the use of national capital that is employed elsewhere being employed here, provided we are satisfied that it will be productive. If you have capital producing an income of £100 at the present time and you employ the capital in such a way that you will only get back half of that, it might happen that the half will be more satisfactory for certain reasons. Surely it is the duty of people to examine and satisfy themselves that the investment will be profitable? We say to the Government that they have not been doing that; that they have not been applying any test. They simply say: "We will be able possibly to get more out of the land," but they have not estimated how much more.

If we are to deal with these economic and financial questions, we ought to deal with them on some basis of that sort. What is the use of the figures the Taoiseach is presenting if, when we begin to apply them, we throw them completely aside. That has not been our attitude; our whole history when we were the Government proves the contrary. Before we left office we had a large scheme of development. Part of the attack upon us was that it was an extravagant scheme. It was a scheme for construction of various kinds in which the building of houses played a most important part, because it was and still remains the most important and urgent public need. I have said these things because I think that, when we are dealing seriously with matters of this kind, it is not right to try to make petty debating points by picking out a sentence out of a long speech divorced from its context and using it to build up a picture of an attitude of mind which is not ours at all.

Another matter that naturally comes up for consideration is the question of the cost of living. People on the opposite benches went before the country with all sorts of ideas and promises as to how they were going to reduce the cost of living and blamed us for being chiefly responsible for it. The cost of living was going to be reduced at any cost, huge subsidies were to be given in order to diminish it. We know now that the cost of living has gone up, again exposing the fact that those who are in office at present went to the electorate and were elected on a programme which they have failed to carry out.

Comment on this

What did you tell them?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I did not get elected on that basis.

Comment on this

On a point of order. When the Taoiseach was speaking, there was not a single interruption from this side of the House. If they want to turn it into an uproar, two can play at that.

Comment on this

Is that a point of order?

Comment on this

Is the Leader of the Opposition not entitled to make his speech without interruption from the members of the Government? We have listened attentively to the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Speak to your own Deputies.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

The next matter of importance which you will naturally like to consider at considerable length is the question of emigration. When I was listening to the Taoiseach's statement on the question of employment, I was wondering how his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, was taking it. When they were on these benches the attitude of the present Ministers on this question was that it was only necessary to have the will to do these things and they could be done overnight. Deputy Morrissey, as he then was, said that anybody who wanted work in this country could have been provided with work within 24 hours. We are now informed by the Taoiseach that the matter has not been solved yet.

Comment on this

What matter?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

The question of full employment. You mentioned full employment, at least I think so.

Comment on this

I will deal with it.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

When the present Ministers were on this side of the House they spoke as if the questions of full employment and emigration were things that could be dealt with if the Government had the will to do it. There is very little difference between members of this House with regard to general aims. Every one of us would like to see a number of things done in this country if there were means available by which they could be done. There is nothing for the Taoiseach to boast about in saying "we want to do these things and we want to increase production". Of course, we want to increase production. We know that the more production there is the more will be available in one way or another for our people. It is not a question of wishing to do these things; it is the method we ought to be dealing with.

Everybody would wish to increase production. Everybody would wish that our people would be able to find a livelihood at home instead of having to leave the country. Perhaps it would not be right to say that everybody would wish that more of our rural population would be able to remain on the land, because some people might not. I have met some people who think that the ideal society would be to have the people congregated in the cities where all sorts of amenities could be easily provided, and then have a rural blank space worked with tractors and all the rest of it—huge ranches with very few individuals on them. It certainly would not be my idea for a social system in this country. We might not then, perhaps, agree as to how exactly the people should be distributed.

I should like to see the greatest possible part of our population remaining on the land. I discussed that on previous occasions from the opposite benches. It was from a speech in which I was discussing that particular problem that the Minister for Finance chose to take out certain sentences and string them together irrespective of what the whole argument was about.

So far as the position on the land is concerned, I pointed out that the first thing was to divide it as quickly as we could into as large a number of economic holdings as would be reasonably possible. There were certain limits to the extent to which that could be done. The next thing I pointed out was that, when you had people placed on the land, having formed a rough estimate of what would be an economic holding, you would find that the present number on the land would not be greatly increased. At any rate, when you had it done, you then had the problem that out of a family of four or five people only two on an average could remain on the land. Therefore, if you want to keep them in the country, you have to find occupations for them in pursuits other than farming. Let us take a family of five. Three of these will have to get an occupation away from the land. They would naturally go into commerce or industry or into the professions.

We have always held that the real way to set about solving that problem is to build up our industries as quickly as possible. If there is a big increase to-day in industrial production, it is an increase that naturally arises from the foundations laid before this Government came into office. I remember the then Minister for Industry and Commerce, Mr. Lemass, pointing out in the early part of the year that in the year 1947 all the industries were hopeful. From the point of view of industrial development, everything pointed to rapid recovery and rapid extension, the moment the raw materials and capital equipment became available. What has happened is what was anticipated by Deputy Lemass at that time. The development is due to the fact that the foundations were properly laid. It is not surprising or astonishing to us that there should be this industrial advance, as we expected it. Whether it has been more than we expected or not in certain details, I am not able to judge, or whether some of the increase was due to special activities of the Government at the present time. The real truth is that, in so far as there have been successes in several lines of development, those successes are mainly due to the fact that you are building on foundations and plans which were already made. When we were originally in opposition, we believed that our policy, this policy, was a lasting policy, not a policy for a day but one which would continue because, seeing the advantages which were accuring from it, the people would insist upon it, just as in the political sphere, we knew that the changes we were trying to establish would last because of their soundness and the same insistence. We knew that these changes corresponded with the natural aims and ideals of the Irish people. We knew that any Government coming after us, whatever they might do about going ahead from that base, could not reverse from that advance. We are happy to see that that is so.

The only thing that we resent is that the suggestion should be made that these policies are now the exclusive property of the Government and that we should be put in the position as if we were opponents of the policies for which we have been standing all our lives.

Emigration is a problem which we all recognise as serious and dangerous. It has to be solved by definite steps. The keeping of people on the land must be solved by providing some of the amenities for country people which the city people have and which make city life attractive. The distribution of electric light and power in our rural areas is one of those amenities. Another inducement is good country roads, which would enable a man and his family going to Mass on Sunday to avoid having to plough through mud. The supply of running water is another thing. These would help to make country life more attractive for some of those people who are at present disposed to leave it. If you wish to keep people in the rural areas, you must develop the industries in those areas also. When we were in office, we tried to bring about decentralisation of industry, to bring it into the smaller towns. Under voluntary systems we found it very hard to induce some of the manufacturers to do that, but we did our best. When leaving office, some of us had come to the conclusion that one of the most effective ways to begin that process would be to try to develop the smaller cities. This city is growing in many ways—much will always have more. For the manufacturer there is an attraction in the large centre of population. One must try to combat that by building up some of the secondary cities in size. There is Cork, Limerick, Galway, Sligo, Kilkenny and Waterford. I have named them without any special care in selecting size and may have omitted some I would ordinarily mention, but I am giving these only as examples. It should be our object to send industries as far as we can to those areas. As a first step, that is the nearest we can get in regard to any large industry. If we can get smaller industries to go into the smaller areas, all the better. Methods like that, pursued steadily, will achieve certain results.

These are the type of remarks which were distorted by the Minister for Finance. Noting the general tendency of people in every part of the world to go away from the land, you cannot be sure at the start whether these things will or will not be successful. I never suggested, however, that it was a thing we should throw up our hands at in surrender, saying that we could do nothing about it. We ought to try to do these things and try to get over the difficulties that present themselves. I do not think many in this House would disagree with that as an objective, but there is no use in having statements and aims of that sort alone. It is the method by which we achieve the aims that is the important thing for us to discuss.

The next question naturally coming up here is one which we have discussed already on the Vote for the Department of External Affairs, the question of Partition and the methods we should use. Everyone is agreed that we want to bring about an end to Partition as quickly as we can. What I have objected to always is statements such as those made frequently by members of the Government as to its nature and the ease with which it can be dealt with. It is doing infinite harm to the morale of our people generally to state that it is a problem which could be solved overnight and that if Fianna Fáil had the will to solve it it could have been done. The truth is that it is an extremely difficult problem. One of the main aims of our general strategy, as far as Fianna Fáil was concerned, was to clear the ground in order that we might achieve a certain unity in other things which were disturbing our national economy so that it would be possible ultimately to tackle this most difficult of all our problems as a united people. We wanted to achieve a situation in which these lesser problems could be put aside, as it were, so that we might all combine to bring about a solution to this problem by whatever means seemed to us to be the best means of achieving our objective. Now, in order to solve this problem, the most obvious step is to inform right-minded opinion, first of all. Naturally that is a matter that we would have to discuss here under other circumstances. As I have already said, I do not propose to discuss it now nor do I want to add anything to what I said yesterday in the debate on the Estimate for the Department of External Affairs.

There is another fundamental problem in which there would probably be agreement, too, as to aim; at least, I hope there would be agreement on it, though I have never had evidence of any real test of opinion on it. I know that an odd Deputy here and there might not agree, but I believe that the vast majority of the members on both sides would agree that every effort should be made to restore the native language in order to make it once more the spoken language of our people. Just as in the case of Partition, it is no use shouting at the Government, whether it be the present Government, our Government or any other Government; it is no use shouting at the Government and expecting that the Government can itself restore the language. Naturally, the Government can do a great deal to help in moulding public opinion in coping with difficultes that may arise and, above all, by leadership. I can assure the Government that in anything they will do towards the restoration of the language as the spoken language of our people we, on this side of the House, will do everything in our power to help. I understand that the Government had a deputation recently from Comdháil Naisiúnta na Gaedhilge. I was approached. I understand that certain proposals were made to the Government by that body. In the discussions with me certain suggestions were made. I hope the Government will examine very carefully the suggestions that were made. One of the suggestions made was that a special board should be set up to deal with the Irish-speaking areas in particular and that a certain sum of money should be made available to that board for that purpose. The primary aim of that board would be to assist in keeping the language alive as a spoken language in those areas. In order to achieve that, it would, of course, be essential to provide employment for the people in those Irish-speaking districts, so that they might be able to make their living there and thereby ensure that neither the language nor the Gaeltacht would be endangered. In order to restore our language as the spoken language of our people it is essential that that area in which it is the traditional language should be preserved.

If the Government comes forward with any policy designed to achieve that object they can be assured of the support of this side of the House. I think that here, again, our aims would be the same. I do not believe the Government would be niggardly in providing money for this purpose any more than our Government would have been niggardly in that regard. Naturally, that money would have to be spent in such a way as to bear fruit satisfactorily.

There was a further suggestion made with regard to An Gúm. That might have been more appropriately discussed, perhaps, on another occasion, but, as I am speaking in particular now to the head of the Government, it is not out of place to suggest certain steps to him. One proposal put forward is that An Gúm should be organised outside Civil Service control altogether. I think that would be desirable. I think very valuable service can be given towards the restoration of the language by An Gúm through the encouragement they give to authors by the publication of their books. I think a good deal could be done if An Gúm were given more freedom than they have at the moment as civil servants.

I merely put forward these suggestions so that the Government may know that there are a number of matters in which we have a common aim and, in so far as the Government tries to solve any of these fundamental national problems, they can be assured of our support provided always, of course, that we are satisfied with the methods adopted and that we think the methods will be effective. There was also the question of the use of the cinema.

But it was not, however, upon these matters that I mainly intended to address the House. I am drawn to speak principally because of the nature of the concluding portions of the Taoiseach's address.

I want to deal primarily with the problem of our national defence. We have been urging the Government to appreciate that there is a dangerous situation ahead. That danger has been threatening for a considerable time. I do not know whether the Taoiseach has changed the complacent attitude he adopted in this matter in the past or whether he still thinks that the situation is not a serious one. I do not know whether he still regards us as being unduly alarmist. I do not know whether he does not consider the matter a serious and an urgent one and whether he still believes that he can go on legislating for peace just as if there were no dangers threatening. Most householders hope that their premises will not be burned down and, in case their efforts to safeguard their premises should not be successful, they insure in some measure against complete loss. Since U.N.O. started and since the attitude of some of the Great Powers in it has been revealed, it is quite obvious that we are not approaching real peace. We are in a completely different situation now from that which obtained after hostilities ceased at the end of the first world war. The moment it became obvious that these two groups of States were splitting apart and that one group deliberately, as it seemed, was setting itself out not to co-operate and to frustrate all the efforts of the other group at co-operation, it became equally obvious that we were, unless some miracle took place, moving from bad to worse. What will be our position then in circumstances that one does not find it very difficult to envisage as ultimately likely to arise. The fact that one looks at these dangers realistically does not mean that one is unduly alarmed. If one does everything in one's power, one can then face a crisis just as bravely as the person who pretends that the situation is one to which attention need not be paid. I do not know whether the Government has been shaken out of its complacency as a result of what has taken place in recent times in the Far East.

One has only to look at the map to see what possibilities can lie within it. You can see there the Western States —I am speaking of one group—engaged now in a conflict some thousands of miles away from their natural bases. You see in the rear of the United Nations forces, mainly the United States forces, some 70,000,000 to 100,000,000 Japanese people who have been recently defeated and people that one would naturally expect to be resentful. You see in front, not merely the Northern Koreans, but you see behind them a country that has become Communist with some hundreds of millions of a population. Behind them again you see Russia with its manpower and industrial power to provide equipment for all. One can easily see that this is not a war—unless by some miracle or for the reason that one side might feel that they were not quite ready for the conflict—that is likely to end quickly. If this conflict should go on for a certain period of time it is quite obvious that one side or the other will lose patience about it and will say: "It is much better for us to try and bring it to a speedy end by using every method and every weapon we have got."

You have, therefore, facing you the prospect of a conflict far more terrible than the conflict through which we have recently passed. Are we just to sit down and depend absolutely on God's providence and do nothing more about it? We know that we cannot stop the conflict. The only question that can concern us is to try and see what measures we can take ourselves, so that we can survive as a nation through it. I do not think the Government is taking any steps at all. The first step that would naturally be taken is to see that the standing Army, which was necessary to develop and to be the core of the manpower of this nation, was brought up to the limit that was thought to be essential. I have many times repeated that, having gone into it with great care, a force of, I think, 12,500 was regarded as the minimum standing Army which could expand, take control, train and organise and take charge generally of what might be regarded as the available manpower. From the figures that we have got I do not think there has been any effort to bring the Army up to that strength.

That ought to be one of the first steps that should be taken. The Minister for Finance, or somebody else, will say "look at the expense." But when you insure yourself you naturally ask yourself the question, "Well, what is the premium, what is the expense?" when there is a serious danger, and you have something that you regard as of great value. What could be regarded as of greater value than the maintenance and integrity of this State, the maintaining of our independence here and our way of life, what could be more important than that? If we really believe that that is important, nobody should say that the one, two or three million pounds which might be involved was too big a price to pay for security. It will be argued, of course, that the expenditure of that sum of money would not guarantee security. I agree that it would not guarantee security. Neither in the last war, nor any other period of time anywhere, can a small nation be sure that by the expenditure of its own resources, it will itself be able to ensure absolutely its continued existence. I never felt, for instance, in the last war that if certain forces were brought against us that they could not defeat us militarily. What I believed was, that if defeated militarily and having done our best to preserve our independence, that that would not be the end of it. We had existed for seven centuries with the sovereignty of the people taken from them. While we should do everything in our power to see that similar conditions would not exist again, I felt that even these would not mean the end of our nation. But we must face the necessary expense.

The first thing which, in my opinion, the Government should do to meet the present situation is to bring up recruitment as quickly as they can, and to bring up the standing Army, in the first instance, to the number which we would regard as the minimum which could handle the manpower of the country.

Comment on this

Was that a peace minimum?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It was the minimum that was required to organise and to officer an army that could be made available on the occasion of dangers such as the present.

We urge on the Government, in the first place, to deal with that and to set that right. I speak with some knowledge about this because, at the beginning of the last war, I found that we had not at all anticipated the tremendous difficulties that were going to be involved in building up an effective force rapidly.

The next thing is to see what is the extent of our reserves, to what extent we have reserves that are to a certain degree trained, and then behind them we ought to build up our F.C.A. forces so that they will be available for further training in case of necessity. We should give them the best training we can so that they will be available as they were in the last emergency for defence. The defence problem now is not of facing one line of troops with another. At any time now you can have troops landed from the air, and part of the general policy of defence ought to be to provide for a situation of that sort.

Next there is the organisation of civilian defence. A good deal of work is being done elsewhere in making provision for a possible new war. We have something that we can learn from that. What is the type of defence that is regarded as being most effective? I do not think that anything is being done. We have no indication, anyhow, that anything is being done, and I do not see that the existing forces are sufficient to enable any work of that sort to be undertaken. We do not know that there is anything being done in that regard, or that organisations are being set up which would be able to instruct the civilian population in the methods of defence and the methods of security which would be the best to take in case of attack.

Over and above these military measures, we have the question of the provision of supplies of various kinds. I know there is an argument that can be used, particularly by the Minister for Defence, against the suggestions I have made as being altogether ineffective to meet the danger. I shall deal with that before I conclude, but for the moment let me pass to the other question of seeing that we have food. In the last war we were very fortunate. Our people were on the up-grade so far as increasing cultivation and growing the cereals we required were concerned. We want to get back that mentality and the people will not get it overnight, particularly if we have suggestions from the Government that this is unnecessary. Even those who think that the next war will necessarily involve co-operation with other people, should remember that even though we should be co-operating with other people, these other people will not be as interested in seeing after our people as we ourselves would be. If we want ships, for example, for some reason or other they may not make them available. The important thing for this country is to see after our food supplies, particularly bread. I saw a stupid leading article in a newspaper some time ago, with regard to this matter, suggesting that we had plenty of cattle and plenty of potatoes. You know perfectly well that bread forms a very important part of the ordinary diet of our people and while we possibly could exist on potatoes and meat, it would so upset our whole economy and mean such sweeping changes in various ways that it is a thing that should be only thought of as a last resort. If by some chance we were deprived of bread, we would revert to a very primitive existence. So long as we can provide bread ourselves we ought to see to it that it is provided. I do not see that the Government are giving any leadership in informing the people as to the policy of this country with regard to the growing of certain cereals but now, at any rate, so long as this serious danger is there, we ought to see to it that we maintain supplies such as were maintained during the last war and we should try to work up again to the 600,000 acres of wheat we had before.

Next to food, there is the question of fuel. We had to improvise in the last war. The late Mr. Hugo Flinn—go ndeana Dia trocaire ar a anam—who was then in charge of that Department, tried to organise supplies of fuel for the city.

Why cannot we now think of that possibility and see to the arrangement we should make—how we can improve methods and equipment, in other words, have some plan for providing fuel in the case of necessity? Talking about plans, I do not know whether the Taoiseach is aware that during the last war one of the most valuable sources of information for us was a book indicating what another country, which had experience of war, would do at the outbreak of an emergency. There were certain indications of certain steps of every type that had to be taken. That was studied by our officers during the emergency. When the war was coming to an end, one of the things that I urged should be done—I do not know whether it has been done because we are inclined to go on to the work of the next year rather than look back upon the work that was done a few years ago—was that our experience during the time of the emergency should be crystallised in the form of a book which would be ready should ever the occasion arise again as a source of instruction in the vital steps that should be taken for the safeguarding of our people. I do not know whether that work has proceeded to any great extent, but that was the direction I gave. If it has not been completed, I would urge upon the Government very strongly that one or two of the officers of the Government Departments in charge of that should bring it up to date, so that the various steps that will have to be taken in case of the recurrence of an emergency will be taken and in the order in which they should be taken. I say that that is a work which would be of lasting value because I suppose we have not come to the age of universal peace yet and, so long as we have emergencies of this sort, there are certain steps that will require to be taken to meet such emergencies. Returning from the digression, food and fuel are the two most essential things to have.

There is also the question of shipping. We did develop our shipping reserves to some extent during the emergency. We were looking abroad for ships from various places. I do not know that I could say exactly that we found stony hearts, but we found people, anyway, who were preoccupied with other problems which were more important in their view than any question of what would happen to us. I should like to urge strongly that measures should be taken to bring necessary supplies from outside—not food, because I think we could make ourselves relatively safe as regards food—but I think we should have the necessary shipping to bring us other essential supplies.

These are the sort of steps which I should like to think were having the attention of the Government, but I see no indication of that. In fact, it seems to me that the Government are more or less gambling as to whether their view is right or ours is right. It would be some satisfaction—I assure him he would be welcome to it—if there was no war for the Taoiseach to say: "Well, these are the people opposite who were telling us there would be war and see now, there is none." That would be a splendid position if there is no war; but if there is a war, the Taoiseach and his colleagues will be held responsible by the Irish people for failure to take the reasonable steps which should be taken and which we at any rate are urging them to take. If it does involve expense or extreme measures, we shall back them. There is no fear that they will find an Opposition which will oppose them in these things. We know only too well the need there will be for them if a crisis should come upon us.

I have said that I know there would be some arguments that would be used against the suggestions I have been making about building up, first of all, the central core of the Regular Army and then seeing that our reserves are made as efficient as possible. We shall be told that we have very few arms. That is too true but, even to-day, the rifle, if all comes to all, is a useful weapon. We ought to see that every rifle and every round of ammunition that is in this country is capable of being used in case of necessity and if we have to defend ourselves.

When I am urging that, the Minister will say: "Do you not see the immense powers that are arrayed against you and what chance have you, a small Power, against these?" I say that if either of them were concentrated to attack us that would be true, but that is not exactly going to be the position. There will be two mightly Powers fighting each other. The side that matters to us will be very glad to see that there will be no gap in the defence in this country. People will say: "We have no chance of defending ourselves." I remember how Bernard Shaw mocked at our idea of trying to be neutral in the last war. There will be people who will say that we are attempting an impossible task. One of the things that made it possible was that during the earlier parts of the last war Britain was afraid of attack upon herself. This country could have been attacked at that time and they were very glad that we were prepared to defend ourselves. They would have given us arms at that time very gladly, I think, if they had arms to spare.

Another occasion may come when a similar set of circumstances may arise and when the fact that we are prepared to defend ourselves and to prevent this island from being used as a basis of attack against other countries will make these other countries glad to give us arms for that defence. But there is no use in putting arms in men's hands if they have no training and experience. If we can get even samples of these weapons we should do so, so that our people could be trained to use them and continue their training and so that, in case of necessity, if arms did come our way, we would be able to use them properly in defending ourselves.

The Minister for Defence pointed out very rightly here on some previous occasion that if we here were not distracted with the problem of Partition it might be very easy for a Government to prepare a line of national defence policy. Even though it might not get agreement from everybody, they would be able to put forward a definite line of national policy which they, as representing the majority here, would put through. I can understand that. He is quite right in saying that if we had not this problem of Partition, which is a paralysing problem under present circumstances, paralysing practically for everybody who is thinking in terms of national defence, then it is quite possible that, although there might be a division of opinion in this House, a policy could be put forward by which this country would take the line of action which is taken by other small countries of combining with other people for defence. But that is out of the question for us now. Still, there is no use in throwing up our hands completely at the situation or in saying that we can do nothing. I think we can.

If common sense should prevail, if some of these people who are talking as if our problem were a petty problem were really to regard it as a petty problem for themselves—it is not so for us—then the paralysing situation would end as far as we are concerned. If we had a united Ireland, obviously the Parliament of a united Ireland would have to decide how the people of this united island could best be defended in the circumstances, and if there was a question of choice what course our people should take; but that cannot arise under present circumstances. What I am complaining of is that the situation being what is is, we appear to be completely giving up and making no attempt at all. I think that is bad national policy and I would urge with any powers of persuasion I have to bring to bear that the Government should go all out in preparation. If it does mean expenditure of certain money you will have to regard that money simply as you would regard an insurance premium. I have explained my point of view sufficiently to make it possible for me to pass on to another point, but I am dissatisfied with the Government because it is not dealing with that situation as I think it should be dealt with and as I think the national interest demands that it should be dealt with.

There is another matter which I raised by way of question with the Taoiseach a short while ago and I regard it in principle as being of fundamental importance. There are people in this country who are misreading Irish history. It is true that when we had an English Government here it was possible to pursue at the same time two lines of policy. You had one line in which parliamentary representatives were trying to fight, as Parnell said, "within the Constitution". It was the only thing they had. You had, side by side with that, a number of people who were using other methods. That was fundamentally possible as long as you had no native Government here, as long as you had a Government which was a foreign Government against which all action was being directed. They were all being directed in the same way against it, but even at the time there were complaints by those who were called constitutionalists that those who were adopting physical force methods were interfering with their progress and that they were frequently embarrassing them when success seemed in sight, when it was very awkward for them to be embarrassed. You had, on the other hand, those who stood for physical force saying: "What is the use of all this talk? There has been talk and talk and talk in this country for so long and we are getting nowhere with it."

Comment on this

It is the greatest industry in this country.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

There is a lot of truth in that, but if you accept it as an industry it does not yield very much by way of profit.

Comment on this

Faith, it does.

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

If the Taoiseach is pointing at me——

Comment on this

I am talking about my own profession. I made quite a lot of money out of talking at one time.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I am sorry; I did not see that aspect of it. Those who stood for physical force had no use for the people who were talking. The fact was, they both worked in together in the long run. One did one piece of work and the other did the other piece, but that was possible because there was an external Government in this country that was ruling this country.

Comment on this

It is ruling part of it still.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

There is no use in blinking it. If you say that, you must say that this is not a sovereign Parliament and that it has no rights. You cannot have it both ways. You must say either that this is the legitimate Government of this part of Ireland based on the Constitution that was passed by the Irish people or that it is not. You cannot deal with this Government and with this Parliament in the same way as you would deal with a Westminster Parliament. You cannot have it both ways, and with our history it is a dangerous doctrine to preach. One of the things we, in Fianna Fáil, set before ourselves was to clear the ground here by having a Constitution derived from the people of this part of Ireland as representing the Irish nation and the leadership of the Irish nation here or elsewhere was to remain in this House. This House will have to be jealous of its leadership and should not permit anybody else to usurp it.

I think that the Government, in not calling attention in specific terms to this business, is pursuing a dangerous line. I know that the excuse is that the danger has not yet come, but there is a question of principle in it. A very good rule is: resist the beginnings and, if you do not resist these beginnings, you will find that a situation will develop in which many lives will be lost, because the Government will have to assert its authority ultimately and cannot allow the Irish people to be dragged into escapades against their will. I am not saying anything with which anybody on the opposite Bench will, I think, disagree. The only point is that they imagine, for some reason or other, that this had best be handled by ignoring it. I do not think it can be ignored. Under cover of that sort, you can get people organising and getting ready, and, when the time comes, when they are led to believe that they are sufficiently strong to defy you, they will do it.

Do we want a recurrence of that sort of thing? I do not think we do, and the Government, therefore, ought definitely to state, for the information of everybody concerned, that any attempt to organise young people here into a military force to take action which would be a usurpation of the authority of this Dáil will not be allowed. If, as Deputy Boland said, it should happen that the law is not sufficient to enable that to be done. they should see to it that the law is made strong enough to enable it to be done. I believe it is strong enough and that no special powers of any kind are necessary, that the legal powers are already there to implement the Article of the Constitution to which I referred in my question to the Taoiseach. If they are not, I think it desirable that the powers should be taken.

Comment on this

The Deputy should have been speaking yesterday at Finaghy.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

These taunts do not affect me, I assure you. The Deputy is not more interested in solving Partition than I am, but I do not intend to try to induce people to go into something in which I know they are going to suffer and the people of this island are going to suffer as a result. There is nobody in this Assembly who is not just as interested as the Deputy in solving Partition, but the Deputy ought not to be allowed to mislead people, to bring them on to a wrong track, and the Government, from the very first day, should tell him so and should warn parents and the young people of the country not to be led by any talk they may hear on the hustings into an organisation of that sort. If there is at any time any force to be used on behalf of the Irish people, that force must be the Constitutional force under the authority of the legitimate Government and Parliament of this part of Ireland. That must be clear to everybody, and the slightest departure from that principle is going to involve us in troubles which will be many indeed—Deputy Cowan can organise a force for one purpose; Deputy Somebody else can organise a force for some other purpose.

Comment on this

Daniel O'Connell said that down on Burgh Quay.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Do not try to misrepresent and misread history.

Comment on this

He said it where the Irish Press is now.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

If we have selfrespect as a Parliament, we will see to it that our authority is not interfered with. If Deputy Cowan can organise one type of force, Deputy Somebody else, as I say, can organise another type of force. We had our difficulties here—let us not repeat them. I had to speak from those Benches opposite with feelings which I thought I would never have to experience, feelings of sadness.

Comment on this

That is the explanation.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It is an effort to see that no other people are going to lose their lives, if I can help it, in conflict with the State.

Comment on this

You were responsible for enough of them already.

Comment on this

The Deputy is justifying his own past.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I am justifying the fact that we have here a sovereign Parliament in this part of the country, and under its authority must remain the forces of this country. Otherwise, we are going to have chaos here, because, if Deputy Cowan can organise a military organisation for one purpose, I do not see why half-a-dozen other Deputies could not organise half-a-dozen military organisations for other purposes. My point is that the Government ought to make it quite clear that there will be no organisation for a military purpose and no military force in this country, except the organisation which is under the direct control of the Government.

Comment on this

That was always our policy.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Your position was a very different one and do not bring us back to it. The position to-day is that you have a Constitution framed by the Irish people and you have that Constitution accepted.

Comment on this

By less than half the people.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

By practically the whole of the people in this part of the country and, if the Deputy wants to deal with that elsewhere, he can do so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cowan must cease interrupting.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It is in times of crisis that we have these difficulties, and the fact that such appeals can be made to our people is one of the serious dangers of the whole position. Appeals can be made on account of this wrong of Partition persisting, appeals which will lead young people, who can be induced by various devices, and led into organisations of that sort. It is at times of crisis that these activities naturally show themselves, so I ask the Government to make it clear that it is a matter of principle and that it is something which could not possibly be tolerated by this State.

I have dealt with the two matters with which I intended to deal: the question of defence and the question of the authority of this Assembly. Other matters may be dealt with by other speakers, but, in view of the fact that the Government does not seem to be alive to these two very important responsibilities, I am moving that the Vote be referred back.

Comment on this
Michael Joseph O'Higgins Minister for Defence (Dr. O'Higgins) Fine Gael

I am sometimes puzzled by the statements of the Leader of the Opposition. From his speeches sometimes we appear to be going the same road and sometimes we appear to be going completely different roads. When it comes to a question of national security, even though we might be very incompatible companions and very unhappy comrades, so long as we are going the same road in a common interest, that interest being the safety of the country and the security of its people, I will put up with that incompatibility and try to iron out the unhappiness and go as a good comrade along the same road. But the Deputy at the present moment happens to be in a position of comparative political irresponsibility and we over here happen to be in a position of grave responsibility. From that position of grave responsibility, we have, of necessity, to balance up in an unsettled and turbulent world the advisability of keeping our country and the minds of our people calm and concentrated on their job of work, on production of food, production of goods.

Even facing the possibility that the time may come when goods will be in short supply and when man-power will be demanded not in hundreds but in thousands, for the Defence Forces of the country, we have got to balance up in that way and time our stroke as to when it is advisable to lock up the man-power of the country, not to occupy them in knocking sparks out of a barrack square, and to the greatest length of time that is possible, to occupy them in the field and in the factory, producing the goods to which the Deputy refers that may at any moment be in short supply. That is a matter of balancing and that is a matter of acting according to the advices and the information you can get.

No Government in the whole world to-day, not to speak of any individual Deputy or member of Parliament, can claim to be able to look into the future. That is reserved for the Almighty. It may be said that one man's guess is as good as the next, but the opinion of a Government that has representatives scattered throughout the globe is at least of as much value and as much weight as the opinion of an individual Deputy or an individual member of any Parliament in the world.

We know there are dangers. We know we are living in an unsettled world. We know that the future is doubtful. But we were not brought up in the breed of pessimists. We still believe there is a Providence up above, and we still believe that the best injection to instil into our people is the injection of hope and confidence and of looking to Providence. At the same time, when Providence is looking down upon the whole lot of us, we are quite aware of the fact that Providence expects each one of us to do his job and to face up to his responsibility.

The Leader of the Opposition was only two months out of Government when he started preaching war at home here and from far-away America. For two months before that he had been blasting down air raid shelters and disbanding the Army and cutting down his Army Estimate and providing for the same Army as I have to-day. He probably sent those messages from America and made those speeches at home in good faith and in honest conviction but, thanks be to God, so far, he has been wrong, and, with the help of God, he will be wrong for the next few years, at least as wrong or as right as he has been for the last few years.

He and his lieutenants frequently compare and attempt to contrast the position of the Defence Forces to-day with the position of the Defence Forces at the outbreak of war in 1939. Even within the last 20 minutes, he referred to the use of the rifle and to the fact that the rifle is still a valuable weapon. So it is, and even if there were no heavier arms than a rifle, it is a defence weapon and a formidable weapon in the way of protection.

The position in this country is very, very dissimilar to-day from what it was in 1939. In 1939 you had a tiny Army and you had a fairly adequate First Line Defence Force, and you had nothing else. Your manpower capacity for putting arms into the hands of people trained in arms was confined within those two bodies—the Army and the First Line Defence Force. What happened since? It is a thing that Deputies opposite ignore. We mobilised during the emergency an Army that swung between 35,000 and 50,000 men. We were never engaged in war. We never had a casualty in war. We never fired a bullet in anger. They were all demobilised and we have at the present moment up to 40,000 of the best young men that this country ever produced, soldiers by inclination, soldiers by their very blood and upbringing, who sprang into the Defence Forces during the emergency years, who served for those five years, who are completely accomplished and trained soldiers. We have every one of these in the country still. We have 2,000 odd officers of the same calibre, completely trained. There is no necessity to pull these men back into barracks, as was the case in 1939. They are in the field; they are in the factory; they are in their offices; they are in their shops, they are in their professions; but they are all standing by as trained men. It would be nearly bankrupting the manpower of the country in the days in advance of war if we were to be piling training on training on top of those men, teaching them what they learned years ago, how to form fours, to brighten their buttons and to salute an officer. Every one of these is a trained soldier. Every one of these ex-soldiers is a trained and potential officer.

We have that immense army of men out there as reserves, not paper reserves but human reserves. On top of that again, we have the vast numbers of young men in this country who, during the war, were trained, trained not only in the theory of war but in the practice of war, in other armies during the late war. They have come back to their motherland and every one of them is as Irish as any of us. If war crashed on us to-morrow we have that immense reserve of our own, trained by ourselves, and we have the big reserve that were trained elsewhere.

There is no fear on our minds, none whatever, that we will be short of trained manpower if a war crashed on us to-morrow. Those are the things that we as Government and myself as Minister for Defence, reckon up when we are looking at the defence, security and safety position of this country. Am I not entitled to reckon up all those good Irish lads as people who are game enough to fight for their country if and when the time comes that it is necessary to fight?

Do you think I would be doing any national service, any good to the country or making for the greater security of the country if I banded and corralled all those trained men into barracks and taught them how to use an army cup and to form fours? I want to know, in connection with this type of criticism that has been lately launched by the Opposition, supported by their powerful Press—I want to know and I am entitled to ask—to what extent it is necessary, to what extent it is honest and to what extent it is stimulated by patriotic motives. I put that question with a note of interrogation in my mind. The alternative question is to what extent is it stimulated by purely sordid political motives merely because the Government is doing well, the country is going ahead—let us panic the people, let us capitalise on fear. I ask that question for the reason that, 11 years ago, when a war was coming, when a war was imminent, the very first proposal that the Leader of the Opposition, who was then the Taoiseach, brought in here was a complete shut-down, a complete censorship, a complete black-out on any information with regard to Army strength, Army equipment, arms or armaments. That was considered wise in the interest of the security of this little country.

To-day, he says war is around the corner; war is imminent. He himself, his satellites and his Press are attempting, by question, by speech, by newspaper articles to extract every bit of information down to the last bullet in the armoury. Every line of the Deputy's speech in Cork, in Ennis, in Dáil Éireann, every third column that appears in his Press, is trying to expose to the world the weakness of this country in the field of defence.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Surely the Minister who spoke on defence in the terms in which he spoke is not going to accuse me of that?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

The Minister who spoke as he himself spoke about the position of the Army here is not, surely, going to accuse me of that?

Comment on this

The two-faced Minister speaking to the multi-faced Leader of the Opposition.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

We can exchange compliments, but that does not get down to realities.

Comment on this

We can. It is about time we did. I want to know this: if it was best in the national interest, when war was imminent 11 years ago, to close down absolutely and completely with regard to any information regarding our Defence Force, its strength, its equipment, its arms or supplies——

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Because you can remedy it now if you want to.

Comment on this

——why, if the Deputy believes war is imminent, does he now want all that publicised to the whole world? After all, we are at the other end of the telephone; we are across a strip of carpet. After all, the Deputy has his office upstairs and mine is downstairs. Could none of these things be done in confidence and in private rather than on the hustings?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

If the Minister had not himself, in his statement in this House, gone out of his way to minimise whatever strength we had, there would be a lot to be said for that.

Comment on this

Let us not quibble. I was not brought up in that school of training. I can talk straight out.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

So can others talk straight out.

Comment on this

I will always give the figures. I have always attempted to give the figures as accurately as my recollection will serve me and as correctly as I can read figures. I have been giving our potential man-power and, in my opinion, it would be unwise and not in the best interests of the nation, its security or supplies, to corral that man-power at the present moment for defence.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

That was not the suggestion.

Comment on this

That has been the suggestion for three years.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It has not.

Comment on this

Now we come to the question of equipment. I inherited an Army and I inherited a supply of armaments from a Government that had been in office for 16 years.

Comment on this

And that dismissed some of the finest officers just before they went out of office.

Comment on this

I shall not go into that. They had been in office for 16 years. During eight of these 16 years arms and armaments were in ready supply. Half the countries of the world were selling and it was a case of looking for buyers. There was an unlimited world market there in the way of arms and armaments. That Government was in a position to buy them. They bought a certain quantity year after year. A very great quantity of the supplies coming in from year to year were still there and are still there. To the maximum extent that the supply was available—not to the maximum extent that money was available but to the maximum extent procurable—since I took responsibility for the Minister for Defence, I have increased the supplies there. Has the Deputy any fault to find with that policy? We have never been at war. We are not bragging or blowing as to what equipment we have, but we have a considerable amount accumulated through the years, expanded in the last three years, and none of it wasted in war. The equipment is there; the man-power I have dealt with.

The Deputy comes on, then, to refer to the whole question of civil defence and the inadequacy of our efforts in that direction. There again much, very much, has been done. It has been done, however, without disturbing the mental ease of the population, without agitating them, without making them nervous. We were only two months in office when a sub-committee of Ministers was appointed to view all this situation of the possibility of war. The compilation of books from the different Departments, based on their experiences during the last war, the compilation of legislation in the event of its being required—all that is being done and has been done. But it is being done unostentatiously, quietly and without disturbing the mind of the woman of the house, of the man in the field or of the man in the factory. Is that not much better than being noisy about it and turning our people into a population of jittery persons—not knowing whether to lay down the foundations or to postpone the whole building because war might come? We believe that, if war is to come, the maximum amount of building we get done before war comes the better for our people.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

That is so in every country. Everybody believes that.

Comment on this

That is the line we are taking and which we have taken not recently but since 1948. We have not been blowing bugles or parading or strutting the stage but the work has been going on quietly and steadily. It is with reluctance that we state these facts even now and we do so only because of the provocation from the other side and because of the deliberate campaign of the past three months to try and put this country weak in the knees through fright.

You have a Government at the moment, a people's Government, a broad representative cross-section of the people. Does the Deputy think that Government is in any way either unnational or anti-national? Does not the Deputy know that, in the complements that go to make up this Government, you have as broad and complete a cross-section of the Irish people as it would be possible to get, a Government conscious of its responsibility, a Government careful of the people, a Government fearless with regard to an outsider and a Government determined to leave behind it a better State than it took over, if it is possible to do it? That is our attitude.

We do not work all the time in the limelight. Most of the hard work is done in the dark. Most of the real work is done behind doors, but the hard work and the real work has been going on all the time. It is nonsense to be showing men into uniform before they are required.

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera is clutching at this straw.

Comment on this

The Deputy referred to auxiliary services. I have a point of view with regard to auxiliary services. A skeleton of those auxiliary services has been kept there all the time. We know we are a little island here, that we are remote from the great world and, thanks be to God, to an extent removed from the warring world; but we have got continuously, over the past three years, all the information, all the instruction, all the intelligence and all the guidance that we can get from that greater world across the sea. We have all the time been sending people for courses of instruction, for informative courses across the sea.

We know what others are doing. We are getting weekly the material, the instruction, the advice of people who are closer to war than we are. We have been saying nothing about it, and it would not be in the national interest if we had been bleating all that kind of stuff for the past few years when we wanted people to get back to work and to work all the harder. Does it serve any national purpose to have the kind of speech that we heard to-day, to have people mentally disturbed, agitated, uneasy and perhaps fearsome with regard to the future?

Do you think that kind of speech brings solace to any woman in her home? Do you think that kind of speech is likely to make any man bend his back harder to the task he is supposed to be doing? It is unsettling everybody, male and female. It is bad for the adult and unhealthy for the child and the responsibility that is on the Government is to stand as a shield and a barrier not only between the people and danger, but between the people and anybody who wants to upset or unsettle them.

We are doing our duty and we have been doing it in the past. If war comes we will do our duty even better in war than ever we did it in peace. The fact that we have left the people alone in their occupations, peacefully employed, will ensure that if war comes, please God the response of the nation will be a response of gratitude that we have left them undisturbed so long that when we want soldiers we will get them in greater numbers than ever they were got before.

Comment on this

I have no intention of following some of the hares that were introduced into this debate by Deputy de Valera. I want to deal, as I intended to deal, with the Estimate presented by the Taoiseach. I want to compliment him on his excellent review of our economic position, as contained in the very informative statement he made to the House.

This Estimate each year gives us an opportunity of taking a broad view of our national affairs and of seeing where there should be acceleration, where there should be a marking of time and where, if necessary, there should or ought to be a change of direction. The Taoiseach has asked us to look at the over-all picture. I think every Deputy who is honest must admit that the overall picture is a satisfactory one.

This Government has been in office for a period of two and a half years.

That is a very short period, and we must realise that those Ministers who form the Government had, first of all, to familiarise themselves with their Departments, with their responsibilities, statutory duties and ordinary everyday administration, and they had to get to know their higher officers, the civil servants on whom so much of the successful running of a Department and of the country depends.

Notwithstanding those difficulties, which are considerable difficulties and which take some time to overcome, if we look at the volume of legislation that has been passed and the work that has been done in those two and a half years, I think it will be agreed that we have reason and grounds for congratulating ourselves.

We have a Housing Bill before the Dáil which fills a very necessary need and which has been welcomed by every Party in the House and by the leaders of public opinion outside. The Local Authorities (Works) Act is operating in every county in the State, giving, as it was intended to give, necessary employment and doing very valuable work for the people generally. Our arterial drainage programme is being pressed on with vigour. To-day, in reply to a parliamentary question, we have been told the amount of work that has been done and the numbers employed on the biggest of these schemes at present in operation. The land reclamation scheme has been launched, again giving valuable employment and, what is more important, giving heart to the land and rehabilitating the land so that it will be able to provide the food we would need in an emergency. Deputy de Valera talked about providing food in an emergency and taking steps to ensure that it would be available. What better preparation could have been made than by the land reclamation scheme?

Through the Department of Social Welfare we have made it possible for the old age pensioners, for the blind, for widows, for that very large section of the people, to improve their conditions of existence. Salaries have been increased for all State servants and pensions have been provided. In the Department of Education, a matter which has been before this country for a considerable time and which helped in a way to bring down the last Government, namely, the grievances of the teachers, has been faced and very substantial increases in pay have been given, and very important improvements in conditions of service have been made. The health of our people has not been neglected. A magnificent hospitals programme has been carried out with energy, enthusiasm and efficiency.

That is the picture which I want this House to see, a picture of work which has been done in the short period of two and a half years by a Government composed, in the main, of Ministers who had no previous experience of departmental or ministerial responsibility. If we look at that picture, I think we are entitled to congratulate ourselves and are bound to congratulate the Taoiseach on the magnificent work done by the Administration of which he is the Head during that period. A Social Welfare Bill has been introduced which will revolutionise the social services in this State and, before this Vote comes up for discussion again in less than a year's time, that Social Welfare Bill will be in operation.

Notwithstanding what Deputy de Valera may say, we have a condition of internal peace which we have not known in this country for many years, due to the wise and judicious way in which the Department of Justice has been administered by the Minister for Justice (General MacEoin). In the sphere of industry, the Minister for Industry and Commerce stated recently that 60 new industries have been established. I asked the Minister to give me particulars of these industries, the number of people employed, and where they are located and, in a reply a couple of days ago, the minister stated that that information would be furnished to me within a very short period as soon as it is available.

Another matter of considerable importance in connection with which due credit must be given to the Government, and one which is vital if our industrial programme is to be carried out, is that there should be unity in what is known as the Labour movement. The first steps to bring about that unity have been taken by Ministers of the Government. I think every patriotic citizen was delighted that these steps were being taken. All of us would, I think, regret the statement we read in to-day's newspapers in which a Fianna Fáil Senator sets out to sabotage the efforts which are being made to bring about that unity. Those are the things that are important. Yet we have had from the other side of the House sabotage by individuals, sabotage by the Party as a whole, obstruction, delaying tactics, filibustering, a six-hours' speech on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture which leaves us in the position now that we have to hurry very vital business in order to get it done in a couple of days at the end of the session. We had a Land Bill introduced which does the Minister for Lands great credit and which is very important from the point of view of the division of land and the abolition of slum tenements of land in the seaboard areas of this country. That Bill was held up as long as it possibly could be held up by an obstructive and malicious opposition.

Comment on this

Nearly seven months.

Comment on this

Those are the things which ought to be dwelt upon in this House, but we have Deputy de Valera in this House and in the country talking about the Defence Forces, their state of preparedness and everything else. That comes very well from the Head of a former Administration which, the moment the emergency was over, dismissed out of the Army some of the finest officers that ever served this State. Men who had given their services for many years, who were competent and efficient, were forced to go out under an artificial age limit and were deprived of the opportunity of further serving this State. Why did he do that? While he was Taoiseach and Head of the Administration, why did he allow conditions in the Army to be such that every soldier was anxious to get out of it? Why would he not listen to the rumours that must have reached into the fastnesses of his mind about the conditions in the Army, that there was a state of dissatisfaction and discontent right through the Defence Forces during that period?

The Minister for Defence has not refused any recruit. Recruiting for the Army is open and has been open all the time. Every person who presents himself for enlistment and is within the age limits and complies with the requirements as to physical standards is recruited. But our Defence Forces are not up to the strength because those soldiers who served during the emergency were treated very badly by the Administration in which Deputy de Valera was the Taoiseach. These are important matters which must be considered by this House. During this year, 1,250 small holdings have been raised to economic level by the Land Commission. Is not that something of which the Government must be proud? Seven tons of seeds have been sown in the State nurseries for our forestry programme. Let the tally of constructive work done be put against the obstruction and the people of the country will have regard and appreciation for those who are endeavouring to work.

Let me say this about the team of Ministers as a whole. No one will suggest that any one Minister in the Cabinet is neglecting his work, that he is not devoting every minute of his time, day and night, to the work of his own Department. Any Deputy can walk down the corridor and go in and see any Minister and discuss any problem that he thinks he ought to discuss in the interests of his constituents. Not only is that permitted, but it is encouraged. That is a very big change from the days of a couple of years ago, when the Fianna Fáil Administration was here and when a private Deputy dare not go down to see a Minister unless he had an appointment made a fortnight in advance.

Comment on this

That is not so, but the Deputy did not know anything about it, as he was not here. He had not made up his mind to come in at that time.

Comment on this

We meet our Ministers as man to man, but even yet, in regard to the people on the Fianna Fáil Benches, they shrink and slink away when they see their Leader come along the corridor. They are afraid to talk, even to some of their own ex-Ministers. There has been a change brought about in this country that Deputy de Valera and the Fianna Fáil Party do not yet understand. There is real democracy in action now.

Comment on this

If that is the imagination that will build up the Deputy's army, it will go a long way.

Comment on this

There is real democracy, where the people, acting through their representatives, can influence and control the Government and can ensure that the things they want done by the Government will be done. That is democracy in action.

Deputy de Valera, or rather the Party that he leads, faces political extinction, political oblivion for a long period. He clutches at these straws, the straws about war and about defence, and he issues a warning here as to what will happen any individual who may attempt to do anything constructive in regard to the abolition of Partition. Deputy de Valera was 16 years in charge of the Government and during that time he did nothing in regard to Partition. When he attacks me in this House, he attacks me because he sees certain ghosts rising up before him, ghosts of individuals that he sent to their death, and he is trying to justify that action by his declarations against me and against the volunteer movement that I am very proud and happy to be organising.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Illegally.

Comment on this

Within the law, within the Constitution, it can be done; and within the law and within the Constitution it is being done.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

You will have a nice country soon, then.

Comment on this

Let me say this to Deputy de Valera. Twenty-eight years ago I was defending the Constitution of this country. I defended it as an officer of this Army from 1922 to 1946. I held a commission granted to me by the first Government of this country; I held a commission granted to me by Deputy de Valera as head of the Fianna Fáil Government; I held a commission granted to me by Dr. Douglas Hyde when he became President. I understand the responsibility of a citizen and Deputy de Valera will not teach me that responsibility now. I hope that Deputy de Valera will compare, in that period I have mentioned, his actions and his record with mine.

Comment on this

He could not hope to compare with yours.

Comment on this

I am simply asking him to compare that record of constitutional behaviour and constitutional responsibility with mine.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

The people of the country have done that. They have passed their judgment on any action of mine. The Constitution you have to-day is due to our action.

Comment on this

The Constitution we have to-day is a Constitution enacted as a face saver. The Minister for External Affairs has written a pamphlet on liberties, in which he has shown that, in the old Constitution, which was overthrown by the new, there were greater safeguards for individual liberties than there are in this Constitution. It is because there are not adequate safeguards for personal liberties, in this Constitution that Deputy de Valera talks about, that these ghosts stand up in front of him in this House.

I hope that Deputy de Valera will give an opportunity to young, energetic people to do the things he did not do during the long period he was a Minister of State and Taoiseach. Instead of the speech he made here this evening, he should have stood up in that seat and congratulated Deputy Costello, the present Taoiseach, on the marvellous work that has been done during the past two and a half years, by an untried Government but by a Government that set out to honour their promises and do their best for the Irish people.

Comment on this

I would like to get back to the temper of the debate and to the frame of mind that was in the House when the Taoiseach introduced this Estimate, and I would like to make particular reference to the remarks of the Taoiseach. He gave a very detailed and valuable analysis of present economic trends and of the future developments that we might expect in those trends. My only purpose in rising is to address to the Taoiseach a few questions and to make a few references to matters which the Taoiseach did not cover in his opening statement. I would have been glad to have had from the Taoiseach some indication that consideration was being given to remedying the position which exists at the moment whereunder our currency is tied to and must fluctuate with the £ sterling. On the 18th September last when Britain decided to devalue, as I understand the existing state of the law, we had no option other than to follow suit. If I am wrong in that, perhaps the Taoiseach will deal with it when replying. But that is the position, as I see it. I would suggest that that is an undesirable position for this State. It is undesirable that we, having the means to achieve complete economic freedom, are not availing of those means.

The Taoiseach made reference to the export position and to the necessity for stepping up production and exports to Britain and the United States of America. I would be glad if the Taoiseach could—perhaps it is unfair to put it to him, but it was not dealt with specifically on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce—deal with the question of the setting up of an export authority charged with the responsibility of underwriting normal export risks and with the responsibility of making available to our manufactures information as to market trends and the data necessary to them if they are to compete effectively with the manufacturers and industrialists of other countries.

The Taoiseach referred to the fact that 38 per cent. of those in employment are engaged neither in industry nor agriculture. In other words, there are 38 per cent of our people engaged in distribution, administration, transport and the professions. I would suggest that is a figure which should give the Government some food for thought. In my opinion, that percentage of people employed, engaged in what one might describe as non-productive work, is an unduly high percentage.

The Taoiseach did not make any reference to afforestation. I would be glad if, when he is concluding, he would give some indication of the Government's attitude. I hope I am not doing an injustice to the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Not at all, but I am just looking at our very competent and comfortable Minister for Forestry sitting beneath you, whose job it is to look after forestry.

Comment on this

I suppose I will not be believed if I say I did not see him. I would be glad if the Taoiseach, when concluding, would underline the fact that this Government is determined to pursue a vigorous policy of afforestation.

Deputy Cowan, in the course of his speech, touched on the question of trade union unity. It is with a good deal of apprehension and a certain timorousness that I make the suggestion to the Government that consideration should be given to the establishment of a fund which would make it possible to assure to those who were formely members of non-Irish controlled unions that they would suffer no loss by reason of their adhesion to completely Irish controlled unions; in other words, that they would not be at the loss of such services and benefits as they had expected to secure unto themselves by contributions made to the funds of foreign unions. As far as I can recollect, this matter was examined by the previous Administration, and I understand that a tentative figure as to the probable cost was arrived at. If we could achieve unity in the trade union movement and if we could get rid of the foreign control in the trade union movement by such a step, then I think the money would be money well spent.

Finally, I would endorse what Deputy de Valera said with regard to the Irish language. I believe there should be the same approach to the question of the language as there is to the question of Partition. I believe that one of the most effective steps that could be taken would be to give a lead from this House and, as in the case of Partition, to set up an all-Party committee charged with the responsibility of seeing that the drive to restore Irish as the vernacular of our people is not allowed to slow up, charged with the responsibility of ensuring that the Gaeltacht areas are served and charged with the responsibility of ensuring that we will build a nation which will not be free, merely, but Gaelic as well.

Comment on this

In the Taoiseach's Estimate we have, more or less, a survey of different matters that have occurred during the past 12 months.

Comment on this

With great respect, you have not. You have general Government policy.

Comment on this

I take, first of all, Government policy in regard to industry. Like Deputy Cowan, I am wondering where these factories are that have been established during the past two and a half years. I am sure that my constituents down in the towns of Fermoy, Youghal, Midleton and Cobh are also anxious to know where the new factories established by this Government are situated and why a single one of these factories did not come down to the towns I have mentioned. I have been urging in this House on the Minister for Industry and Commerce during the past one and a half years to finish, or at least to go another step in regard to that splendid industry in Cobh which was set up by his predecessor, Deputy Seán Lemass. I allude to Irish Steel, a factory which was only barely pulled out of the fire——

Comment on this

I submit that questions of detail cannot be raised on the Taoiseach's Estimate, the debate on which is confined to general Government policy.

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

The Deputy is entitled to discuss general industrial policy on the Estimate, but not details such as the situation of a factory.

Comment on this

My question is not in relation to the situation of the factory, but to the policy of a Government which talks about starting industries and the giving of more employment in this State. While it talks like that, it leaves threequarters of the machinery in that factory at Cobh idle, machinery that was brought in in 1939.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy is now dealing with details of administration, which should be discussed on the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

I raised it on the Vote on Account, on the Budget, on the Vote for Industry and Commerce, and I think I had about 15 different questions down asking why 300 of our people in Cobh have to leave this country while that factory is waiting to be opened. That is one very definite charge that I am making against this Government. Our principal industry, agriculture, has been turned into a position of absolute uncertainty and chaos by this Government so that the producers of wealth, who were referred to a moment ago by Deputy Lehane, find themselves the worst paid people in this State to-day.

Comment on this

They are better paid to-day than ever they were before.

Comment on this

They are the worst paid people in the State to-day. The agricultural industry is in such a position of uncertainty that no man producing a crop knows whether or not he is going to find a market for it, or if he will get a price for his produce which will cover his costs of production. This Government has a series of fixed prices which bear no relation to the costs of production which have gone up by some 25 per cent since 1947. The position of the producers of the wealth of the nation is that they are receiving for their produce to-day the same as the figure that was there in 1947.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Was not all this discussed by the Deputy on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture, and is there not a Standing Order to the effect that a subject cannot be rediscussed within a period of six months?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy is entitled to make general observations on agriculture so long as he does not go into details.

Comment on this

That is just what I am doing. The policy of the Government, so far as agriculture is concerned, is to send out dollars, which have been borrowed or got otherwise, to foreign countries to bring in what our own agricultural community should be producing. The refusal of the Government to give a guaranteed price to the agricultural community for their produce or for what they were producing, has put the Government in this position that it is in the hands of every foreign extortionist that can sell it muck. I have seen what this Government was compelled to bring into this country. I have seen the dockers in Cork refuse to go into the ships and unload that muck for which £500,000 of our money was paid to the foreigner.

Comment on this

Is that the Canadian oatmeal that was bought by Deputy Lemass?

Comment on this

It is the Iraq barley that was purchased by Deputy James Dillon, our Minister for Agriculture, for which we paid £320,000. I saw it in Cork and 50 per cent. of it was sand, and the other 50 per cent. muck.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy is now going into details, and he has been warned that he cannot do that.

Comment on this

I was answering the Taoiseach. Does he consider it wise policy for this country to send £1,250,000, in dollars, to Formosa or to Cuba for sugar at £12 a ton more than the Irish people are growing and manufacturing it here for.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I told the Deputy before that he must not go into details, and he must abide by the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this

He said all that on the Estimate for my Department.

Comment on this

And on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. I know it is very unpleasant for the Minister. We had a lot of talk here on various Government policies and on various Government changes, and the good they were going to do. I wonder is the producer to be still held against the unmovable wall. If the Taoiseach seeks information he can get it from a semi-State concern known as the Irish Sugar Company.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Not on this Estimate.

Comment on this

I am suggesting where the Government will find information as to the results of their work.

Comment on this

They will be found in the Deputy's bigger bank balance. He is much better off to-day than he was three years ago.

Comment on this

I know how my bank balance stands. I know very well that for the past two and a half years I have been producing at less than the costs of production.

Comment on this

You are getting more than ever you got.

Comment on this

I am getting the Fianna Fáil Government's 1947 price for what has cost 25 per cent. more to produce. The Minister has free access apparently to the semi-State bodies I mentioned a few moments ago, judging by the attitude of the Chair, but he will find that, with rising costs of production——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I have warned the Deputy several times. I hope the Deputy will not put me in the position of having to warn him for the final time.

Comment on this

The Deputy is dealing with the extra cost of production.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy is dealing with matters that are not in order on this Estimate, and if the Deputy will not refrain from doing so, I shall have to ask the House to deal with him.

Comment on this

If a Deputy in this House a few moments ago dealt with the benefits that this Social Security Bill was going to confer on the people is another Deputy not in order in reciting some of the disadvantages that this Social Security Bill will entail? That is exactly what I am doing. I am informing the House that the Social Security Bill will increase the cost of production of beet by 2/5 a ton, and that the other little things to which Deputy Cowan referred to as advantages, according to the costings of the eminent professor who acted as chairman of the board, will add another 4/6 per ton to beet. These two facts I want to put before you as the disadvantages of Government policy in regard to agriculture in this country. They have got to be put side by side with the other disadvantages.

Comment on this

Cheer up.

Comment on this

I am quite cheerful, because, thank God, before I am finished with the job I shall secure that the costs of production will have to be paid in that particular sphere anyway.

Comment on this

You are looking for more?

Comment on this

No. We made our bargain and we are sticking by it, and we shall see that we will get it. My pity is for other sections. I am thinking of the unfortunate position of the man who is producing milk per day at 3½d. a gallon less than the price he was getting from Fianna Fáil because his cost of production has gone up 25 per cent.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy will refrain from following that line or I shall have to take other action.

Comment on this

I have frequently found over a long period of time that the principal industry of this country cannot be discussed in this House. You can talk about ragtime armies or about anything you wish——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

You cannot talk about them on this Estimate.

Comment on this

——but you cannot talk about agriculture. I can quite understand that it is a ghost that Governments—I say Governments—in power do not like to have to face.

Comment on this

It is a very vigorous ghost to-day.

Comment on this

A very vigorous ghost all right, a ghost supplied by the nigger, supplied by the Formosans, by the Argentine, by the Cubans and the Department of Agriculture in this State remains inactive. If that is the lifeline on which we are to depend for our food supplies in a period of crisis, I can well understand the attitude and the mentality of the people who were sitting on these benches in 1939 who said: "Why produce wheat when we can get plenty of it in the American market to feed our people during the war?" I can quite understand that attitude and the frame of mind here to-day as one who had to sit over there and listen to them in former days. I can quite understand the reason why one of those who advocated that policy loudly during those days is put in charge of agriculture to-day. I can quite understand that, but where is it going to lead us? Where are we going to find food for our people facing that condition of affairs to-day?

Some time ago, I had to issue a warning that you cannot turn on a tap and get a crop put into the ground and produced in a day, that there would be very little use trying to set a few thousand acres of wheat in the months of June and July, that you were not going to get 12 months' notice of the next war. Apparently that fell on deaf ears. The Minister never concealed what his intention was, namely, that the people of this nation in any emergency of that description would pay for their food by the life blood of our young men fighting for the foreign grabber. That was the attitude then and that is the attitude to-day. Does the Taoiseach consider that that is a right policy? I take it that he must consider it is a right policy when he is allowing that Minister to continue in charge of the Department. For the life of me, I cannot put any other complexion on it. If that is the mentality with which we are facing another emergency, the mentality that we are to get all the food we require brought in in American or British bottoms, I think the fallacy of that argument was more than proved from 1939 to 1947. I have endeavoured to the best of my ability, by example and otherwise, to induce the people, my fellow farmers— I considered it a patriotic duty—to produce in this country all the food required for the Irish people. I did my utmost in that line, but we are up against a condition of affairs to-day where it is hard to believe that the Government want home production of that kind.

I should like at this stage to issue a fair warning and it is a warning that should be considered when we talk here of a flight from the land and things of that description. The worker on the land to-day has only his four bones to sell, the same as every other man in the country. He is going to sell them to the man who will pay him most for them. If you find, as I find and as my neighbours find, that in any other industry that man's labour is calculated at double the value it is in agriculture, then you cannot, on that basis, build a prosperous State. You cannot, on that basis, increase production. There is no use in pretending that we can. On the Agriculture Vote I appealed to the Government of the day to take what by rights should be the first step in this matter, namely, to get to work to fix the minimum wage in agriculture at least as high as that of the unskilled labourer employed in any other industry. All over the country, in the different counties, the Government have at their fingers' end the means by which they can ascertain what the costs of production would be on those figures. Professor Murphy of Cork could give them on any day. Let us have fixed prices on them and then let the Taoiseach stand up and say: "I not alone ask for, but demand increased production. I demand that this nation will produce here at home all the food it requires for its people" and let us, in God's name, be independent, in the food line anyway, of any foreign nation. Let us do that in a courageous way and approach it on that line and not in this cheese-paring fashion of putting one section of the community up against a target, putting them up against the wall, putting them up against increased salaries for civil servants, increased pensions for some other tribe, increased something else for another tribe and increased social services for all. One section of the population is set up against the wall to be scourged and robbed in this present condition of affairs.

That is my objection to the way in which this present Government is working and this present Government have got the results of it; they have got a proof of it and they can see it for themselves. It is not with any pleasure that this State has to go away to the foreigner and pay out the dollars that are needed for other things for food and for stuff that could be produced here of far better quality than is produced by the foreigners.

Comment on this

Is more food not being produced in this country to-day than has been produced for years?

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

It is true.

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

It is absolutely true.

Comment on this

It is nonsense and nobody knows that better than the Minister. I can tell the Minister that I have the utmost sympathy for him. It is not with any pleasure that the Minister has to pay £1,200,000 for foreign sugar, £12 a ton more than the Irish farmer was paid for his produce.

Comment on this

Why does the Irish farmer not produce it at home?

Comment on this

Pay him.

Comment on this

He is being paid.

Comment on this

According to the Minister for Agriculture costs are increased by 25 per cent. Pay him the 25 per cent extra. It would pay you better to pay him than to pay the nigger in Formosa and that is the buck you are paying one and a quarter millions of money. Does the Minister consider it better than in the autumn of 1948 when we were begging that Government to find some market for the oats they had induced farmers to grow——

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

The Deputy will not forget what I said to him a moment ago.

Comment on this

No. I might draw another one before I am done.

Comment on this

It is the Canadian oats you are thinking about.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Minister will also allow the Deputy to speak.

Comment on this

It came from the Argentine, and it was only chaff at 46/- a barrel. The Minister, of course, is aware of the manner in which that is reflected in the cost of living, the manner in which that muck has driven up oatenmeal to over 10/- a stone.

Comment on this

Do not be too hard on Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this

I tried to get meal, but there was none in it, and I defy the Minister to get much meal.

Comment on this

Were there weevils in it?

Comment on this

There was nothing. 46/- a barrel was paid for it and the poor unfortunate old farmer was begging the Minister to get him 20/- a barrel in 1948. As a result, the agricultural community is no longer foolish enough to go on producing stuff when they have no guarantee as to what they are going to do with it. That is why I am here making what I consider to be a last appeal to this Government, and if there is an emergency within the next 12 months or two years in this country, Deputies will have reason to remember that appeal of mine, and sore and bitter reason, because when the condition of affairs which has brought about that position is made known to the people of this country it will take more than Deputy Cowan's army to save the boys. That is a fair warning.

I do not wish to delay the House. I have been prevented from dealing with the subjects that, in my opinion, should be the first and most important subjects to be discussed by a House of Representatives in this country who, after all, must consider the main industry of the country, agriculture. I am sorry that I could not enlarge on that matter, but I must obey the ruling of the Chair on that. You can talk about armies and you can talk about defence, but there is an old saying of Napoleon's that an army marches on its stomach and if you have hungry bellies among the army of the future you will have very little use in asking that army to fight. They will have very little humour when their backbones are tied to their bellies and they get a feed of Iraq barley instead of decent Irish wheat. I am telling you that it is not fighting they will be thinking of.

That is the position that is being created, and I regret that we have not got an opportunity of discussing the matter more fully. I wonder if the Minister for Industry and Commerce could tell us the amount of oatenmeal got by the ordinary process from a ton of Irish oats and the amount got from a ton of imported foreign produce of the Argentine brand. These would be rather interesting figures for the Irish people. I have got samples of both and have sent them to the millers for test in that respect. I hope that, when we reassemble in October, I will be able to give the House the results of my explorations in that line. I am sure they will interest the Minister as well. It is time some effort was made —and I have offered the Government full co-operation, as, I am sure, they will have the full co-operation of every Deputy, regardless of Party—to get produced in this country the food that the Irish nation will require and not have this drain on our people in peace-time involved in our having to rush abroad for foreign produce, and being in the position, in time of emergency, that there is no food to feed the people, unless it is paid for, as the Minister for Agriculture hoped it would be paid for from 1939 to 1946, with the lives and blood of our young people.

Comment on this