We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach—(Resumed).

Contributions 156–324 of 324. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

It is unfortunate if Deputy Corry or any other representative of the agricultural community feels that the Taoiseach's Estimate should not afford him a full opportunity of dealing in general terms with what has been universally described as the main industry of the country. We got a great number of statistics from the Taoiseach, but it was impossible to note even the most important ones with the accuracy that would be required, but I think he mentioned that there were 50,000 fewer persons in employment on the land during the past four years than formerly and that a larger number than 50,000 had found employment in industry and other spheres; but it is not merely a question of finding employment assuming—which the emigration figures seem to contradict—that the whole of the 50,000 who left the land found employment at home. From our knowledge of what has been happening in the rural areas and from the exodus that took place after the hand-won turf scheme was closed down, it must be clear that a considerable population has left the country.

The fact that the Taoiseach's statement seemed to regard the national economy more from the industrial and from the Dublin point of view than from the point of view of the man who must view our economy as a whole and place the agriculturist in the premier position is, in itself, a very significant fact. He pointed to the striking improvement in the position of the farmers and it may be true that, as compared with pre-war, the farmers are in receipt of larger incomes, but, as was pointed out recently, if we have regard to the fact that the £ of 1939, in relation to present retail prices, is the equivalent of only 10/9, we have to ask ourselves whether the £100,000,000, which the Taoiseach says the agricultural community is receiving now by way of income, is, in fact, going to purchase for them the same amount of goods which they have to purchase outside their own economy as in 1939.

If there is any truth—and I suppose it is a truth that is generally accepted —in the statement that the land of this country must have suffered severely in the matter of fertility through over-cropping during the war period and that the primary purpose of Government ought to be to restore that fertility, and even to give the land a higher level of fertility than it had previously reached, there is surely a strong case that the opportunities which the Government now has at its disposal of making the moneys available through Marshall Aid available to the farming community generally and not merely to the owners of marginal land, or land which, in a time of scarcity of food and comparatively good prices, it may be profitable to cultivate, but which later on may go back to its original state. It is a matter for the Taoiseach as much as, and more than, it is for the Minister for Agriculture to make at least some reasoned reply to the case frequently made from these benches and from his own benches, and to which no reply has been forthcoming, except the usual scornful epithets from the Minister for Agriculture and that there should be a concerted drive on the Government's part to make fertilisers available to farmers at reasonable rates, since it was due to their efforts that this community was able to carry on without the aid, which, even in the first world war, was available to us from outside and the aid which, in another crisis, if it should occur, may be even more urgently necessary.

The Taoiseach referred to under-production and under-employment on the land. We regard this matter of our agricultural economy as a social question and it does not matter what strides are made in industrial development or technical efficiency, the man on the land has the safeguard in a world crisis that he will always have enough food for himself and his family and will be able to supply his neighbours. The only good book I ever read on unemployment, the only book that made any impression on me, was a book in which the author said that the best form of economy, in the long run, was the economy of the food producer who had some other craft or employment of a part-time character to help him out. There is no use in blinding ourselves to the fact that the economy and mass production methods of the United States of America, which are now being forced upon countries which have an entirely different economy, will not succeed here. We prefer to approach this question from the point of view of having the largest number of families on the land. The provision of whatever is necessary in the way of guaranteed prices or State assistance to enable those food producers to meet costs of production and have a decent margin should be the primary object of Government policy. Any policy of investment, of repatriation of assets, or other, that does not have that in the forefront and that does not regard that as the primary objective in national policy, is not likely to succeed.

We cannot apply the prairie methods of the United States of America to the small farms of this country. We have to accept, as most countries have, the particular characteristics and the particular economy that we have. It would take a very long time for us to adapt ourselves and to inure ourselves to the changes that would be necessary if we were to attempt to move in step with prairie countries.

I suggest that it should be the policy and duty of the Government to have regard to the needs of the small farmer. The surplus from his land when he has maintained his family and himself will be limited assuredly. The Commission of Inquiry into Agriculture that we set up agreed that improved education was the fundamental and most necessary improvement of all in regard to agriculture. They did not say, but I think they might have said, that no other improvement is worth while or that there can, in fact, be no other improvement until education is brought up to date and modern technical methods applied.

The Taoiseach spoke of the country towns. Our opinion is that the country towns are not thriving, are not prospering. Everything is being sucked up into this octopus of 500,000 people. At the rate the population of Dublin is increasing, it may in our time reach 700,000 or 800,000. That is not a very good position. It is a very difficult problem. Surely it would be better for the Government to try to decentralise industry to the maximum extent even if the assistance which has had to be given elsewhere must be given, in the way of providing free sites, certain relief from rates and even grants. Under another Government not very far away, grants are being given to people to establish industries and the Government is actually building the factories.

The terms of trade are undoubtedly favourable to agriculture at the present time. I am in thorough agreement with the advice that farmers are getting to make the very most of the opportunities that present themselves. I should like to see rural electrification and rural water supply schemes carried on with somewhat the same intensity as housing and the provision of other amenities for the City of Dublin and other large centres and with the same desire that apparently exists among the Parties supporting the Government for the provision of these amenities in the City of Dublin and the other large centres.

If other people can organise and secure advantages for themselves, the agricultural interest in this country is not by any means so backward or unintelligent as not to grasp the moral for itself. If the present trend continues, and if we will have the position that the population on the land which we used to hear was roughly 50 per cent. of the total population, decreases to 40 per cent. or even lower, it will mean that the preponderance of influence, which is already too great in the case of this metropolis, in the political, economic and every other sphere, will be so great that, unless the rural community is organised and regimented in a way that has not happened before and that has not been possible, they will not be able to maintain their interests against all the other interests that are organised to get more than their share of the national cake.

According to the Taoiseach, we have an increasing number employed in industry, but that number, of course, is altogether below the number we ought to have if the policy of industrialisation was being carried on in an active and progressive way. According to the Taoiseach, the bulk of those described as being in the industrial category are only distributing goods. Therefore, instead of 20 per cent. in industrial occupations we ought to have a much larger percentage in the actual production of goods which we are at present importing. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has said that there is some £60,000,000 worth on which we could try our hand. We could do so if the Government would only give the necessary direction and set in motion the necessary organisation and direct that industrial effort with the necessary energy and capacity.

I was rather amused when I heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce interrupting Deputy Corry to say that we had more food in this country now than ever we had before. So far as the consumers in the City of Dublin are concerned, it is not very noticeable to them that we have more food if the price of food is any criterion as to the supply. When the Minister for Industry and Commerce told us recently that there was, in fact, an increase in the cost of living, he tried to excuse himself by telling us that, if conditions had remained the same as they were when the promise to reduce the cost of living was made, there would have been a very substantial reduction. Of course, if the conditions of 1947 had obtained in 1948 and 1949, the progress that has been made in industrial production, increased employment and general improvement in many spheres, would not have been possible. When the Government are quoting 1947 as a base figure for comparison to show improvements that have been effected since then, for which they would like to take credit and to attribute to themselves, they fail to make allowance for the particular conditions and circumstances of that year.

If we want to be honest about it and to ask ourselves whether we are making progress nationally or not, and economically or not, in fairness, we ought to compare the figures, as the Taoiseach has done in a few instances, with the position in the pre-war period. Then we shall see, as I have indicated, in respect of agriculture that, even though there is a big improvement in certain respects, particularly if you regard certain figures of output and so forth from the monetary point of view, when you look at them from the point of view of value, the position is entirely different.

It is admitted that in the sphere of agricultural production we have only now reached the pre-war level. It is admitted, also, that instead of a vast increase, having regard to the improvements in equipment and methods to which the Taoiseach referred, we have only an improvement of about 1 per cent. per annum in industrial output, if I got the figure correctly. I think that in a State which was being geared up to a proper level of industrial activity and not still in low gear, so to speak, a greater increase in our output ought to be possible. It is not as if we had reached such heights of industrial production that 1 per cent. more would be regarded as a very big thing. The fact is that we have been starting, of course, from a comparatively low position after the war situation and, therefore, the 1 per cent. per annum is all the more disappointing. If it is to be taken as a pointer that the Taoiseach is indicating signposts of advance, and so forth, I think, as he indicated himself, 1 per cent. can only be regarded as very disappointing.

The Taoiseach also stressed, I think, with regard to the volume of our exports, the increased value of our exports. We know that the terms of trade are in our favour; we know that there is a shortage of food in the world and, no doubt, exports have gone up to a very great extent. Nevertheless, as I understand the Taoiseach, the volume of our total exports is only 90 per cent. of what is was pre-war. If you take these three figures—the 1 per cent. per annum improvement in industrial production, the fact that our total volume of exports is only 90 per cent of pre-war and the fact that we are only now reaching the pre-war level in agricultural output generally—I do not think there is any room for the complacency that the Taoiseach seems to show. I should imagine, if we are serious about this matter, we ought to set before ourselves a target of achievement for the future.

If we want to reach a position that we are going to make our agricultural effort such that we can contemplate the future with equanimity and go out to meet all competitors in the international market; if we are going to face the position that, as far as possible, we will try to provide for ourselves and our own requirements in such a way that many of the things we had to go short of during the last war will now be available; if we are going to tackle agricultural production and industrial development in that spirit, I suggest the Government is failing in its task of leadership and direction in not giving us a more definite target as to what exactly the aim is to be-an aim which ought to be kept before all our producers and all our organisations of both employers and employees so that they may cooperate in the general national effort of turning out the greatest amount possible.

I had intended to refer to the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that one reason why the cost of living had gone up, and which he claimed it was beyond his capacity or power to control, was agricultural produce. "Agricultural produce," he said, in the course of the Estimate on Industry and Commerce, "is about the only article in consumption that I cannot control." That statement was made in respect of this agricultural and food-producing country where rationing is still being maintained and where it looks as if we shall be the last civilised State in the food-producing category applying rationing to fats. The Minister went on, on that occasion, and said, as an additional reason for the increase in the cost of living, that protection leads to an increase in the cost of the protected article in most, though not in all, cases. That certainly, if it is true, is a strange commentary on the Industrial Development Authority, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, on the Minister's prices control organisation. The third point, of course, was one to which the Taoiseach referred and that was that the full effect of devaluation has not yet been felt. As the Taoiseach's statement pointed out, while it had shown itself clearly in the prices of raw materials, it is only now that the increased prices are working themselves out towards the consumer in the way of increased prices to wholesalers and retailers and, finally, to the public generally.

The Taoiseach referred to the national income and pointed to an increase. He said that there has been an increase in the national income from £338,000,000 in 1948 to £352,000,000 in 1949. I was rather anxious to hear from the Minister for Finance, and perhaps the Taoiseach will tell us when he is concluding this debate whether the principle that the Minister for Finance laid down in his Budget statement last year that we had reached the absolute limit of taxation and that the people could not be taxed further still holds. "Taxation," he said, "was £27 per head of the population and that was roughly, if we include both the national taxation, local taxation and insurance contributions, about 25 per cent. of the total national income." It is quite true that there has been no increase this year in the rates of taxation, but it will be seen that the sum of money which the Exchequer is expected to collect in one way or another of £75,000,000 to £76,000,000 is a very substantial proportion of the total national income. That is only a result of the failure of the Government, as has been pointed out in other directions, to make good the promises which were perhaps not very sincere but which were made, at any rate, that they would, as well as reducing the cost of living, reduce the cost of Government. The Taoiseach told us, when the Government came into office, that the country was overtaxed. The fact is that the cost of Government, which was about £65,000,000 in the last year of the previous Administration, has gone up to about £87,000,000 in the present year—and, of course, the retrenchment over a wide field was only applied to certain schemes which the present Administration regarded as grandiose schemes but which seem very much on the small side in comparison with the huge expenditure and huge schemes we now hear of.

Perhaps the Taoiseach will give us some information as to whether the Government is now definitely abandoning the mandate the Minister for Finance claimed he had in 1948 to carry into effect a policy of retrenchment over a wide field, or whether, on the other hand, the idea of keeping the cost of government as low as possible is to be put on one side and the new policy of meeting expenditure hitherto met out of revenue is going to be the main feature of Government administration. When the Minister for Finance asks us what item of the £12,000,000 we would cut out, we say that is the job of the Minister for Finance. I suggest it is the task either of the Minister or the Taoiseach to explain to the country why, when the Minister borrowed a mere £600,000 in his Budget in respect of these items in the preceding year, he can now turn round and pretend it is the same policy that is in operation when he is borrowing £12,000,000, 24 or 25 times as much as during the previous year.

It would be unfair of me to go through the items, but I think I may, to this extent at any rate, repeat what I said already, that when we are borrowing this £12,000,000 a year which, apparently, we are going to borrow permanently, we will have to pay for it, and the fact that we have to pay £665,000 a year for the next 30 years is sufficient proof of the heavy nature of the charge that has to be met. It is no wonder that the Taoiseach, in his statement, which was interlarded, like the Budget statement of the Minister, with qualifications and suggestions and advice as to the danger of pursuing this policy to an unnecessary degree, or to an alarming extent, said:—

"Let us have regard to the earning capacity; let us put the money, if we are going to repatriate it, into enterprises that will pay."

This £400,000,000, as he said, is only one year's income, and, viewed from the 1938 point of view, or the present value of money, it is not anything like £400,000,000. If you compare it with the pre-war figure of our sterling assets, and ask yourselves how much more we would get if we go outside the country to purchase our requirements as compared with what we would get at that period, then I do not think we would get very much more.

The Taoiseach now tells us we should be careful about this. Are we to agree with the Taoiseach in regard to this money, the yield from which the country is going to lose, and the whole capital of which it could also lose in a very short period under an improvident policy? Are we going to follow the Taoiseach's advice about putting that money into productive enterprises which, as well as giving employment, will add to the national wealth and will help to pay for themselves, or will we take the other line of spending the money on socially profitable schemes, as suggested by the Minister for Finance? If the criterion is to be whether the scheme is socially profitable or not, where will we stop? If we are to borrow for school buildings and housing grants, why not borrow for other services? Socially or otherwise, they are closely allied.

I cannot see where you will draw the distinction. The moment you pass away from the fundamental idea that, if you represent the people's interests truly and want the best return for the community, the investment should be one that will have a reasonable prospect of paying for itself—if you depart from that to any great degree— then we know what will happen. We know that, after a short time, such an improvident policy will have to come to an end.

I have, I fear, taken up more time than I had intended to take. With reference to the spending of $129,000,000 to which the Minister for Justice referred recently down the country, our information is, so far as I have been able to gather from Deputies in this House, that they are not prejudiced against the land rehabilitation scheme. They would like to see that, and other schemes calculated to benefit the country, prospering. We should like to see in operation schemes of such a character that all the farmers will benefit by them, particularly those whose lands are in need of rehabilitation because of necessary over-cropping during a period of emergency.

To that extent Deputy Cogan put the position pretty clearly in so far as it affects the ordinary farmer and, whether we agree politically with Deputy Cogan or not, we must admit that in this matter he has put up the attitude and the feelings of the great majority of the agricultural community. His suggestion was the suggestion of anybody who would have the temerity to make a suggestion to the present Minister for Agriculture, and that is that the whole of the agricultural community are entitled to consideration under this scheme and are certainly entitled to a more courteous, a more reasoned and a more worthy reply than the Minister gave.

There is another point about it. That scheme applies to all the rural areas, even though it is only to a limited extent, and when the Minister for Finance is sneering, backed by his satellites in the Labour Party, reunited now, at the Fianna Fáil scheme for Government buildings, I would remind him that that scheme, reference to which he has made, and the extracts he has purported to quote about it, go as far back as 1935. That is a very long way back. That scheme had not even reached the stage that it was brought before this House or before the Government for any decisions which would bring it into effect or which would even bring the preliminary plans into operation.

What I said before I will now repeat. If you want to provide an unemployment scheme for the large mass of unskilled labour in the City of Dublin or anywhere else, when your ordinary housing programme has reached a point of saturation, you will have to fall back on some large constructional scheme of that character. It is a serious defect in the Government's policy that, although they have received this huge amount of money which, apparently, according to the Minister for Justice, they do not ever expect to be asked to repay, they are not making proper provision for it. It is a serious defect in their handling of that if they have made no provision for increasing productivity in non-agricultural enterprises with the aid of that money. If they are doing it, members of this House have not heard what they are doing about it. We have not heard it from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. We are told the Industrial Development Authority is sitting, but we do not know what they are doing. There is no report from that body and, in fact, it has not yet received the sanction of this House by legislation.

Comment on this

I should like to support the Taoiseach in the compliments which he paid to the Statistical Section of his Department for the good work they are doing. That section of the Taoiseach's Department have collected and are collecting and collating information which is of use to this Government and will be of use to every future Government in preparing policy and coping with national economic problems. I should also like to support the views of those who have pointed out how grave is the present economic situation of the country, having regard to world affairs. Unless some miracle occurs, a war involving the entire human race will take place in a very short time. Faced with such a prospect, there is a terrible obligation upon any Government to make provision for that situation, for the feeding of our people, for carrying our people through that emergency with the least possible loss. I know that any Government which undertakes the unpopular task in peacetime of stock-piling for war is taking a very grave risk of being laughed at, scorned and ridiculed in time to come if a war does not occur. But that is a risk which must be taken and every possible effort should be made to ensure that the raw materials for our vital and essential industries are procured so far as it is possible to procure them.

So far as agriculture is concerned, that industry, if placed on a sound basis, can support our present population without any outside aid. But during whatever period of peace is left to us we must set ourselves to provide additional raw materials for that industry to strengthen it so that it will carry us through that emergency period, if it should occur. The first thing necessary is to speed up and accelerate the pumping into our soil of the necessary lime, phosphates, potassic and other manures that are essential to make the land produce its maximum.

In words dripping with venom I have been assailed for urging the Minister for Agriculture to undertake a policy of speeding up the restoration or the fertility of our poorer soils. I admire the work that has been done in regard to the reclamation of bogs and mountains, but there is another form of reclamation and rehabilitation which must be pushed forward with the utmost speed, and that is the restoration of the fertility of land which is potentially sound but which has been drained of its fertility in one way or another. I hope that no effort will be spared to get from every part of the world where they can be got the raw phosphates which are so essential for this nation. I hope that no effort will be spared to help our farmers to put into their land all the necessary manures that can be put into it during the time that may be left to us. I hope also that whatever can be done to produce additional nitrogenous manures in this country will be done, and that all essential fertilisers will be procured. These are essential and urgent tasks that cannot be left in abeyance. They must be pushed forward with the utmost speed.

I do not feel complacent about our industrial and agricultural output. So far as agriculture is concerned, we have succeeded in getting back to our pre-war output, but that is not enough. We must push forward very much further. All experts are agreed, and amongst experts I include practical farmers, that our land is capable, with proper treatment, of producing possibly 50 per cent more than it is producing to-day. I know thousands of farmers who realise that they are not putting into the soil all the manure that it requires. They would like to be able to do so, but the majority of the farmers are limited so far as capital is concerned. We have heard a good deal from the Taoiseach about chronic under-investment in regard to home development. There is no industry in which there is such under-investment as in agriculture. During whatever time is left to us, I hope the Minister will bear in mind the necessity for strengthening our agricultural industry.

The statistical survey issued last year by the Taoiseach's Department revealed one interesting fact. The figure for net volume of agricultural output for 1939 was given as 100. In 1942 it was given as 112. In 1945 it also reached the same figure. In 1947 it was back to 97 and in 1948 it was 98. It has now reached 102. But the important point to remember is that we are still 10 per cent. below the figure of output for 1942 and 1945. We are also below the average figure for the whole emergency period. I want to know why that should be. It may be suggested that it is due to the inclusion of turf with agricultural products. I have not been made aware by any Minister that there has been such a substantial decline in turf production. I had the feeling that with intensive mechanisation we are keeping up the volume of turf production. If we are not, I think we should be. Modern machinery for producing turf ought to be capable of bringing the turf output up to the highest level ever reached during the emergency. It is desirable from a national point of view that that should be done, thus saving us from sending money out of the country for essential fuel.

With regard to the possibility of an emergency, it is also essential to ask if the Government have considered arrangements for carrying on industries and transport. We are turning more and more to the elimination of the horse and the mechanisation of the agricultural industry. That will take a good deal of the drudgery and hard work out of agriculture and it will appeal to the farmers generally. Everyone likes to carry on his work in the most modern and up to date conditions and the farmer is no different from anyone else. The young farmer naturally is attracted by every form of mechanisation of his holding, but it does raise a problem of supplies of tractor fuel which should be considered very carefully.

In the recent war, mechanisation had not reached the pitch to which it has been pushed forward during the past few years. The number of agricultural horses was much greater three or four years ago. If the process of mechanisation continues, the number will be greatly reduced and a serious problem will arise in regard to the maintenance of our food supply in an emergency.

I do not want to enter on the contentious matters that have been raised. I think the Taoiseach would be well advised to discourage the formation of an army by an individual Deputy. I know that it might be a great asset to every Deputy to have an army of his own, particularly at election times.

Comment on this

It would be a shocking liability. How would you pay for it? It is hard enough to pay election expenses, without having to pay for an army.

Comment on this

It is no harm often to treat matters of this kind in a jocose way, but there is often the possibility of something serious developing out of a complete departure from principle. There ought to be an accepted rule that there is to be only one Army, the Army controlled by this House. I can see very grave dangers arising, perhaps not from Deputy Cowan or anything that he may do or say, but from others who may be inclined, having regard to the leniency with which he has been treated, to follow his example.

The Taoiseach is entitled to ask for co-operation from the Opposition and is entitled to expect it, particularly in times as grave as the present. He is entitled to expect co-operation in regard to national problems and serious economic problems. He is also entitled to invite them to come into the Government, so that they might have representation in the Government in proportion to the representation which they have in this House. I have frequently made that appeal, both here and outside. I have no use for an Opposition Party. I believe that every Deputy should be independent to a great extent, in the sense that he should be free to criticise Ministers or Governments. I believe there should be no definite "ins" and "outs" in politics. That is an old British system, which should be dispensed with.

An all-Party Government, representative of every section in this House, would carry the country much more safely through any grave danger that may face us in the future, and if no danger does arise it would carry this country much better to times of peace and provide for our people a much better living than we get by having half of the population set in opposition to the other.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence approached the problems presented to him by the Leader of the Opposition in the wrong spirit, I think. He started out by trying to find out who was wrong and who was right, rather than by trying to find out what was wrong and what was right. He can hardly suggest that there is a lack of sincerity on this side of the House, or of earnestness in facing up to a problem which at the moment is making the whole world anxious. For that reason, it would have been fairer if he had dealt with the suggestions made by Deputy de Valera on their merits, without suggesting wrong motives. He said that Providence was going to look after us, but "God helps those who help themselves." We cannot leave things to be prepared at the last minute. He said that even two years ago the Leader of the Opposition had been suggesting to the Government that they should give very special attention to our defence problems. Well, if they had done that at that time and had laid their plans then, we would be in all the stronger a position to-day and we would be all much easier in our minds and less prone to be carried off by any panic which might occur owing to outside causes over which we have no control.

Comment on this

The Deputy is doing his best to start one.

Comment on this

He said there were a number of men who would be excellent, well-trained soldiers, like the Deputy, but like the Deputy himself, I think they have got pretty fact and could not run as quickly as they used to.

Comment on this

Most of them are in central Europe to-day, after being thrown out of this Army by Deputy Traynor.

Comment on this

If they had been kept in training, as Deputy de Valera suggested they should be kept, they would be in very good condition now. Goodness knows what would happen if we were suddenly plunged into war in our present condition. That would be much more common sense than leaving things to Providence at the last minute and then asking for men during an emergency to go out and run as fast as they would ten years ago.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want to have them running all the time?

Comment on this

The Minister's general approach was one of trying to persuade us to go in for a hush-hush policy. You cannot carry on parliamentary life on those lines. We must have facts before us, or we cannot form the proper judgements. There is no use in trying to bluff on the situation. People outside the country who are interested in the defence position here know that there are no secrets with regard to our defence policy. There is nothing which can be told in this House which is not very well known already to those who are interested. The Taoiseach said that vague criticism is of no value. I want to say that vague statements from Ministers are equally of no value.

The Taoiseach was very interesting in his whole statement and approach to the question of investments. He said that we had not sufficient investments in the country. That is perfectly true. He said that private enterprise cannot deal with the situation entirely. A considerable amount of criticism has come against the independent corporations established in this country. Are we to assume that the Taoiseach will follow the line he has taken with regard to Córas Iompair Éireann and go in for a code of socialistic propositions of industries supported by the State? Or will he pursue the line of having independent corporations to deal with the big sources of production? It would be interesting to have an answer to those questions.

I shall not attempt to interpret the statistics he gave us, as they would require very close study. I think I can say that the trend of the statistics showed a strong advocacy of the policy of developing our exports. The Taoiseach pointed out the incalculable factors in the American market and he led on from that to the tourist traffic. But he did not tell us what plans he had with regard to the tourist traffic. That traffic has become bigger than our actual cattle trade. It requires close attention. Already the Government has been two years in office and should have been trying to consolidate that traffic by proper planning. We are very anxious, indeed, to know what plans they have for developing the tourist traffic.

There is a tremendous potential attraction in the country and I think our soundest line of approach would be, first of all, to develop these attractions for our own people in order to, shall I say, "exploit" our traditions and bring our people to a proper appreciation of them. The American expert on tourism pointed out that one of our unique features was our national monuments. Other nations have scenery and attractions which are more or less common to all. Our national monuments are, as I say, unique. These monuments require great care.

This is a problem that cannot be solved by any one Department. It is natural that it should arise on the Taoiseach's Estimate because there are several Departments involved. The Department of Industry and Commerce, for instance, deals with development. I do not want to go into details, but I can instance Tramore as a typical example of gross neglect. In my constituency the whole coast-line and into Lismore should be developed. However, to come back to our monuments I want to point out that the right kind of plaques are not put up in order to inform visitors about these. We have not the right kind of guides, such as one finds in other countries, to take our tourists round. The Department of External Affairs is also involved because it forms a link with outside. That Department has done something but a great deal still remains to be done in order to develop our natural attractions and our cultural institutions.

Fisheries are involved, too. I was amazed at the number of Deputies on the Government Benches who pointed out recently how impossible it is to get fish in country towns. Whether or not that is due to the irresponsible remark of the Minister for Agriculture that he does not like fish, I do not know. I know plenty of people who would be delighted to get fish in these out-of-the-way villages. I believe that if the supply were there the demand would come and I think that demand would help to create a healthy population in the most depopulated areas.

When we criticise the Government we are immediately told that we are indulging in sabotage. Are we to behave like dumb, driven cattle? Are we to be mute as mice? Are we to do our duty by taking notice of every form of political corruption, deceit and misrepresentation in order to ensure that these things are nipped in the bud? I suggest we do not indulge in sabotage. Our criticism, if severe at times, is always constructive. We believe the life of the nation must go on no matter what Government is in power. In one sense we are in a very awkward position because we are embarrassed to some extent by the success of Fianna Fáil policy. We get Fianna Fáil policy hurled at us now in an attempt to destroy us. From the point of view of the nation, that is a good thing. I could not help feeling, when the Tánaiste was pontificating upon his Department to-day, that, after all, he was just building on the foundations we had laid and that, if we had not built up what he built on, he would not be able to do what he did.

Comment on this

How on earth did you ever get over there and leave us with your policy?

Comment on this

How did the Taoiseach get there?

Comment on this

As the Kerryman said, it was tricks and devilment that did it.

Comment on this

Something must have done it.

Comment on this

It was the extraordinary combination of opposites and the amazing joining up of all sorts of Parties with contradictory policies. However, so long as they carry out Fianna Fáil policy they will do pretty well.

Comment on this

And you will stay over there.

Comment on this

We shall just try to keep you up to scratch and, when the time comes, it will be for the country to decide who were the originators of the policy and who are the best people to carry out the policy.

Comment on this

First of all——

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

On a point of order. There was an agreement to finish all the financial business to-morrow.

Comment on this

This is not to-morrow.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

That cannot be done unless this debate concludes to-night. Is there any agreement that the Taoiseach should get in to-night?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order and the Chair has no control over that. If there is an agreement, it is for the House to carry it out.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Is there any agreement to let the Taoiseach in before 10 o'clock?

Comment on this

There is no such agreement.

Comment on this

First of all, might I have the temerity to ask the Taoiseach to examine a matter brought to his notice by the Leader of the Opposition to-day when he referred to the possibility of making available to the Oireachtas a staff, which would be an addition to the staff of the statistics branch, under the control of the Taoiseach? The staff of the statistics branch has quite deservedly received the highest praise since it has taken up duty in its new Department. The Leader of the Opposition referred to a body of men in the Congress of the United States who are referred to, so far as I understand, as economic analysts. These men make available to the members of both Houses there all information, statistical and otherwise, in such a form as to leave it untinged by a political approach either one way or the other. I would ask the Taoiseach to examine that suggestion.

In approaching this Estimate this year I have a very clear recollection of the statement made by the Taoiseach in introducing his Estimate last year. In that statement he took a certain amount of credit for having brought about what he described as good housekeeping. He indicated that through the good housekeeping of his administration the adverse balance of trade had been considerably reduced. On that occasion I drew his attention to the position which could arise as a result of a misinterpretation of the monetary situation as it might affect us. I indicated that devaluation could come and that, if devaluation were to come, what appeared to be good housekeeping then could, in fact, turn out to be the reverse. To-day, the Taoiseach gave us a new set of analyses and comparisons to some of which I want to refer. He gave us, among other things, a comparison of the liabilities and assets of the State, and gave one very peculiar explanation. He told us that, in the liabilities of the State, of some £150,000,000, there was a liability of £21,000,000, being the receipts from the economic co-operation fund. At the same time he stated that some of that money, while taken as a liability and as an asset had in fact been utilised for certain purposes. I suggest that if a certain amount of this money has been devoted to certain schemes what has been produced by it should be valued as an asset and not reckoned just as if it were taken from one pocket and put into another. It has been put into circulation and will create something. The value of what has been created as an asset can be calculated at some later date.

I want to suggest to the Taoiseach that we should examine the capital liabilities of the State to-day. We should have some regard, in assessing the value of these items, not to what they cost in the past, but to their real value to-day in relation to the value of money. If we took out a balance sheet we might find that some of the assets, included in that list of assets, would bring our assets to-day, with regard to the value of money, almost to, if not over, the value of our total liabilities. I mention that for the purpose of pointing out to the Taoiseach that we must not lose sight of the fact that, when we are given figures in relation to assets and liabilities, whether they are composed of money on the one hand or of institutions, they do not portray a proper picture. In the same way, when we are dealing to-day with money, from the point of view of its world value, we should remember that we are dealing with something that is fluctuating in value.

I said last year that I had grave apprehensions as to the stability of the nation. Again, I say there is every evidence that we can be faced with a further devaluation of the £, not in the distant future. One may ask what has led me to that conclusion. In the free markets of money, not the control exchanges, the £ to-day can be bought cheaper than at its controlled rate. The £ sterling, instead of being sold at the equivalent of two dollars 80 cents is being sold at two dollars 40 cents, which is a drop, in world opinion, of the value of the £ note of another 14 per cent. I suggest that, when we come to consider the position of the affairs of the State we must bear in mind that the £ note, or the coinage we use, is no longer static. It is a fluctuating commodity.

On a previous occasion I attempted to make a reference to the Coinage Act. I was ruled out of order then because the Coinage Bill was not before this House. It has since been passed by the Seanad and is now on our Order Paper. With the permission of the Chair, I would like to make a short reference to it and a suggestion to the Taoiseach. When that measure is passed by the Dáil, it will become the Coinage Act. According to the Minister for Finance, the purpose of it will be to call in silver coinage and substitute for it what is called cupro nickel. The Minister for Finance indicated in the Seanad that, as a result of doing that, the State Exchequer would benefit to the extent of £1,000,000 by selling the silver bullion and by using the new form of cupro nickel. I want to suggest to the Taoiseach that we should keep that silver in our Central Bank as a commodity which will have an international value. It will not fluctuate downwards if our coinage falls. If we sell it for 1,000,000 £ notes we may find, in time, that these will have only one-third or half the value of their present rate. I suggest that it would be a good thing to start keeping that silver within the control of the nation as a backing for the paper money issued. It is a commodity which will have a value. In time to come it will be a form of guarantee for our paper money if, at any time in the wisdom of those who are in control, it is decided that we should break the link with sterling and have our own independent currency.

I make that suggestion to the Taoiseach and would ask him to pass it on for examination. We hear a lot of talk about the repatriation of money from abroad. If that is ever accomplished, I believe we will have reached the position when we can afford to anchor our own currency to whatever sort of backing we decide on whether it is with regard to our earning capacity as a nation, to our trade, or to whatever we have in the shape of commodities.

From time to time we hear a great deal of talk about the repatriation of capital from abroad. It was discussed to-day. It is a question that is greatly confused by some people with what they call breaking the link with sterling —in other words having our own currency. As regards the arguments in favour of the repatriation of capital, a question arises as to how it will be employed. What the Leader of the Opposition said to-day is quite obvious, that you just cannot take it back and leave it no longer a dividend earning investment. You cannot just dissipate it, and have it disappear. It is obvious that it has to be done on the basis of where and how it can be employed for the benefit of the nation, for the development of industry and so on, but without the destruction of it, from the point of view of its existence, because it belongs to the great number of people who have credit balances. In that connection, I have come to the conclusion that where the State to-day seeks to get large sums of money made available to it for State purposes, it finds itself in competition with private enterprise which is also seeking to attract capital for the development of larger industrial enterprises.

In the manner in which we are going on to-day, a position has been reached in my opinion where money, when it is available for investment, is attracted either to the Government for Government schemes or to private enterprise for other schemes, to the extent to which either the State or private enterprise is prepared to pay in the shape of interest, which some people call a tribute, for making that money available. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has made it clear, without any reservation whatever, that he is anxious to see industrial development in this country continued at as rapid a pace as possible with all the benefits that will accrue to the nation from it— the reduction of the adverse trade balance, the production in this country of all the goods this country needs and so forth. We have reached a stage where apparently there is a unanimous acceptance that that is a desirable development.

I should like to hear the Taoiseach say in connection with that matter and in connection with the blessing, if you like, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has given to the development of industry, that what has been said in the past will no longer be repeated, that those who start these industries will not be described, if they become successful in industry, as racketeers, buccaneers and all the rest of it. The industrial development of this country is of great importance from every point of view. I think the time has come when an indication should be given that it is no longer considered an evil thing and that those who were prepared to establish industries and conduct them properly, under whatever controls are thought necessary, are entitled to have the benefits of the profits which accrue to them as a result of their ability to make such profits.

Some cross-talk was indulged in here to-day about what had been promised in pre-election times and what had been accomplished. I think all of us on this side of the House would join with Deputy Little in congratulating the Government and the Parties that make it up, in having adopted to a great extent what we regard as the Fianna Fáil policy. I think the time has come when we should cease from this side of the House producing all the pre-election promises of the different Parties, pointing out all the different promises that were made by these Parties which they said would be put into effect if any one of them became the Government, and we should concentrate on considering, not the pre-election promises but the post-election promises made by the combination of Parties. In that connection I should like to refer to the ten points on which they came together and I think it would be fair to launch a criticism with regard to the extent to which these ten points have been achieved. I can remember only a few of them. Certainly, one of them was a reduction in the cost of living. Well, that has not been achieved and I do not think it can be achieved. I am prepared to admit that since the devaluation of the £ we all have to agree that No.1 can be crossed off and the inter-Party Government is then left with nine points.

We have a variety of items in these nine points. As I say, I can remember only a few of them and I do not want to deal with them in the same manner as I have dealt with No.1. We were to have increased production in everything. In that connection, the Taoiseach gave us some very interesting figures. It is quite true that none of us could write down these figures quickly enough. I was in for only part of them and we probably will not be able to examine the figures until we get them eventually in the Official Report. In connection with production, does the Taoiseach not agree that whenever a statement is made as to so many million pounds' worth of goods produced or sold that we should get side by side with that the quantities?

Comment on this

The information I gave referred both to price and volume.

Comment on this

I was not here all the time, as I said, and I did not hear that.

Comment on this

I gave price and volume.

Comment on this

I am very grateful. That is something new.

Comment on this

Price and volume were given.

Comment on this

I am very glad to hear that. It will be very interesting to read because it is something of which I wanted to make a study. Furthermore, in connection with production, I should like to make this suggestion to the Taoiseach and to the Government as a whole. I thought that the Minister for Health had gone a good distance towards being reasonable in introducing his Estimate and in replying to the debate this year, as compared with previous years, because he did say that were it not for the plans which he had found in his office which were left there by his predecessors, a great deal of the work which he had accomplished would not be accomplished at this moment. Would it not be possible for the Government now, after two and a half years in office, to say: "We have also reached a stage where we agree that while we claim we have brought about increased production, that increased production has been brought about in a great many of the industries started by our predecessors." It is all very well for Deputies opposite to say that there was a danger of closing down our boot factories because a big quota had been given for the importation of British manufactured boots some few years ago but when we took office in 1932 we were not self-sufficient, so far as the manufacture of boots and shoes was concerned. We are to-day.

Comment on this

Over-sufficient.

Comment on this

Very well. The fact is that that over-sufficiency will bring greater competition amongst manufacturers and the most efficient will survive. The country will get the benefit of that competition. In a great many other industries, increased production would have been possible if there had been a similar approach to this problem. A great deal of the arguments in this House could be avoided if there was a greater degree of concession from one side of the House to the other on what could be regarded as just simple plain facts.

I would also say in that connection that there is at this moment the danger of a world conflict, the danger of another emergency, and requests were made for co-operation. I think everybody in this House, irrespective of Party, will agree that where the interests of this country are affected from outside, the Government, whatever Government it is, can always rely on the fullest and absolute co-operation not only from every member of this House but from every section of the community. In time of emergency, in time of war, the fact remains that it is the country that is involved and that political differences must take second or third place.

I have a comment to make on that matter. I have heard that when certain of the elected representatives have been outside this country, they have discussed matters concerning the welfare of the nation and on occasion personalities were indulged in. I am glad that the Minister for External Affairs is here because he probably will be the first to appreciate what I say. I have heard from America, for instance, that on occasions when certain representatives of this country were over there a debunking almost of the Leader of the Opposition was attempted.

I was at a function in Paris some years ago and I met the leader of the opposition of a certain little country where there was great bitterness between the opposition and the Prime Minister's Party. In the course of a toast to him I heard him asked to give the assembly some indication of his opinion of his Prime Minister and his answer was: "Any differences between the Prime Minister and myself are differences which exist in my country when I am at home. When I am abroad, he is the Prime Minister of my country. He is the elected representative of the people and he is the Prime Minister to whom I give my respect when I am abroad."

Can we not talk in the same way of either the present holder of that office or the Leader of the Opposition? Can we not keep our political differences here among ourselves and when we go abroad add to the dignity which this country deserves by not discussing our domestic affairs but rather our national affairs? Abroad, wherever we may be, we are all agreed that one of the things that concerns us and that we must do is to push the question of the abolition of Partition. On that we are all in full agreement and that is the question that should concern us when we meet people outside.

Comment on this
Seán MacBride Minister for External Affairs (Mr. MacBride) Clann na Poblachta

The Deputy has made suggestions. Could he specify them more concretely?

Comment on this

I could but not in this House. I will tell the Minister privately what I have in mind. I mention it because I have heard that in America, Particularly at what are called drawing-room meetings of certain people, certain references have been made which, I think, were out of place.

Comment on this

Surely that is not Government policy.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Then why has the Deputy brought it up on this debate?

Comment on this

I am just giving a hint.

Comment on this

He is just wasting time.

Comment on this

This is Government policy however. We had a discussion last year in this House on the publicity indulged in to bring back our skilled workers from England. Is that not in order? I wanted to ask the Taoiseach if it is still Government policy to advertise abroad for the purpose of bringing back skilled workers?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That was discussed on Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

I think it was discussed on the Taoiseach's Vote, but I cannot say. If I am out of order I will leave it, but I was anxious to know whether, from the statistics point of view, the Taoiseach had any information of what numbers had come back; whether there was still a trend back or whether we had reached saturation in our requirements of skilled workers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have a recollection of the figures being actually given on one of the Estimates this year, I think Local Government.

Comment on this

3,500.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That was within the last fortnight.

Comment on this

I can put down a question about it when we reassemble.

Comment on this

If you remember it.

Comment on this

I can hand it in to-night. Sometimes, I think, members of this House underestimate the intelligence of the people outside.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

And the Minister for Industry and Commerce is one of those who has not seemingly a sufficient appreciation of the intelligence of those outside.

Comment on this

If I had not, I would not be sitting here.

Comment on this

I do not think it was the intelligence of the people outside that put the Minister there. I have heard reference to the wonderful prosperity we have due to many items, one of which was the increased value of lambs and sheep. The man who is selling the wool off the sheep's back knows that wool has gone up so high——

Comment on this

What has this to do with the Vote?

Comment on this

It has to do with the figures of the Taoiseach's expenditure. If the Taoiseach wants to say that the export of wool was not included, I am out of order.

Comment on this

I included wool.

Comment on this

And I am coming to wool prices. They have gone up because of the excessive demand in the world to-day in relation to the supply and it could, at any time, fall back to normal. If people are encouraged to get into the production of items that have taken a sudden steep rise there can be the danger of the opposite happening when a reverse takes place. To take credit as if these benefits had accrued to the people as a result of Government policy instead of as a result of circumstances entirely beyond our control is to use an expression that the people know how to assess.

Comment on this

The farmers do not care what way it comes so long as they get the price.

Comment on this

I am afraid that the Deputy does not appreciate what I am trying to suggest.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce is here. I do not think he is responsible for it although he had to execute it and I wonder does he realise what a tragic disaster it was to abandon air development in this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Estimate.

Comment on this

Government policy is——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The test for anything on this Vote is: was it discussed on or appropriate to an Estimate? If it was, it should not arise.

Comment on this

If you say to leave it out I will leave it out.

The final thing I come to is the discussion we have had on taxation. I think it was one of the ten points that taxation should be reduced. In this country we have a direct form of taxation in the shape of income-tax, surtax and excess corporation profits tax, but we also have a form of indirect taxation such as the excise on cigarettes, tobacco and drink. It is true that income-tax was reduced by 6d. in the £ but when it is stated that taxation has been reduced, I think we must bulk the lot together and recognise that since greater revenue has accrued to the Exchequer we must find some cause for it. Is it not a fact—and I am sure this must interest Labour Deputies— that one of the causes is that, due to increases in wages and salaries, a greater number of people have reached the income-tax paying level? Whether the over-all rate of 7/- has been reduced to 6/6, or to whatever figure it stands at, the fact remains that there are many thousands paying income-tax now who never paid it before, so that taxation has not been reduced. It has been spread over a wider number of persons. Taxation is whatever the Exchequer receives, whether by direct or indirect taxation, and, in addition, we have to remember that there is such a thing as local taxation. If we are to have discarded by the Government its responsibility for certain payments from the Exchequer, or if there are to be reductions in these contributions by the Exchequer, and if these responsibilities are to be imposed on the ratepayers, it is again not a reduction of taxation but a change in the incidence of taxation from one shoulder to another or a change from one method of payment to another. I do not understand how people outside are expected to believe it when they see a great increase in the income of the State being expressed as lower taxation. In some cases there seems to be such an opinion of the public intelligence as to amount almost to contempt, but I think the people are able to size the situation up and I think they will in time come to indicate what they regard as right.

I say to the Taoiseach that we have reached the time from the point of view of a possible national emergency at which we shall have to conduct our housekeeping for the next few years not on the lines we thought of a few years ago, when we seemed to be heading for permanent peace, but on the lines of looking forward to a situation in which we could easily have to undergo great hardship and suffering as a result of what would then be regarded as bad housekeeping for the nation. In addition, the question of our financial arrangements with the outside world is also involved.

Some Deputies referred to the need for examining whether our defensive measures are up to requirements, or whether a greater effort should be made in that regard. I think the people as a whole would be pleased to see the most extraordinary provision made in order to enable us to defend ourselves, both from the point of view of nourishing ourselves and defending ourselves physically if attacked. If the danger passes and all these measures prove to be what might be called wasteful, we on this side will be the last to point the finger at the Government and to say: "Your insurance expenditure was unwise." The Taoiseach need not worry about political capital being sought to be made on this side because there may be a residue of unused arms, ammunition, fuel or any commodity the State may have thought it necessary to provide for its people. The nation will back the Government in taking every measure possible to make the people feel that security measures have been provided, and if, in time to come, they are found to have been only an insurance premium, from what I know of the members on this side and of the people who support this Party, they will applaud rather than abuse.

Comment on this

Am I in order in raising on this Vote the letting of land on the 11 months' system?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is scarcely a question for the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

In view of the statement made by the Minister for Agriculture on this matter——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy can discuss it with the Minister, by question or otherwise.

Comment on this

I was ruled out by the Chair when I sought to raise it on the Vote for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy agree that it should be allowed to go on?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is a matter which could have been raised on the Vote for Lands.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture made a statement about the letting of land on the 11 months' system in relation to Government policy.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The letting of land on the 11 months' system does not arise on the Taoiseach's Vote.

Comment on this

Government policy arises on the Taoiseach's Vote and I wanted, for the constituency I represent, an expression of Government policy which I think was not given by the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

It will not be expressed by me, if the Deputy were to stay there for the rest of the night.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been informed that it is not a matter for the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

If that is so, I do not propose to proceed any further.

Comment on this

I would not have intervened in this debate were it not for the speech delivered by the Minister for Defence. I have been a member of this House for 20 years and I have listened to many heated debates, but of all the exhibitions of vindictiveness, of spite and of viciousness I ever listened to, the speech of the Minister for Defence was the worst. It seemed to be deliberately intended to prevent anything like co-operation in the matter of the defence of this country and it seemed to be intended to kill any inclination towards co-operation or unity.

The Minister, by innuendo, accused the Opposition, and particularly the Leader of the Opposition, of disclosing the strength of our defences, and then, in direct contradiction of that idea, went on to explain in minute detail the resources we had in the shape of what might be called trained men. He talked about all the supplies he had and sought to create the impression that huge quantities of military supplies were coming into the country without the knowledge of the people. We are living under a constitutional Government and I always thought that, under the Constitution, money could not be spent by any Department of State, unless this House voted it.

Comment on this

Quite right.

Comment on this

I should certainly like to know where the money for these huge quantities of war munitions came from.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy talking about? There are no such huge quantities of war munitions coming in without being paid for.

Comment on this

Any money expended by this Government has to be voted by this House.

Comment on this

Of course, it has.

Comment on this

Therefore, what I say is right.

Comment on this

Except that there are no such munitions coming in.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence talked about mysterious quantities of military supplies he was getting.

Comment on this

The Deputy is suffering from a delusion. There are no quantities, mysterious or otherwise, coming in.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Taoiseach will allow me to make my speech. I do not usually interrupt him or any other speaker. My contention is that, having gone to all that trouble, after a vicious harangue and making every spiteful statement he could make, he proceeded, as I said, to disclose, if it could be called a disclosure, the military strength of this country. After all that, he proceeded to disclose, if it could be called a disclosure, the military strength of this country, while his major accusation against the Opposition was that we were doing so.

The Minister then referred to the numerous trained men that there are in the country and told us that they would spring to arms. I have no doubt at all that the men who entered the Defence Forces, either the Regular Army or the auxiliary force, will answer the call if necessity arises. By the way the Minister spoke, it looked as if he had a secret understanding with Joe Stalin or some other body that when an emergency would come Joe would kindly send him word to the effect: "We are going over Dublin to-morrow night with our planes. Tell the people to go to the Phoenix Park so as to be out of the way." He ridiculed the idea of mobilisation—no matter how critical the situation became, it would not be right to mobilise these men; it would be a waste of labour. He forgot that thousands of men are leaving this country every year. The Government has not taken any steps to stop them. If an emergency arises, those men will be sorely missed. Now we are told that it would be bad policy, bad tactics, to mobilise the Defence Forces.

Then, as I have said, we were told a fairy story about fabulous shiploads of munitions that are coming into this country, pouring up secretly to somewhere in this city. It brings the minds of some of us back to days gone by when we smuggled a revolver or something of that description. I repeat that of all the viciousness and spitefulness and vindictiveness I have ever heard, I heard the worst exhibition of it that could be given in this House to-night by the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

I would like if the Taoiseach would tell us which of his sMinisters we are to believe in respect to policy, especially in regard to the policy spoken of by Deputy Walsh. After the passing of the Ireland Bill the Taoiseach said in O'Connell Street that they would hurt these people in their pride and in their pocket. On 3rd March, in Cork, the Minister for Defence said that they would appeal to that "lion-hearted statesman, Winston Churchill." As far as I can gather from replies to questions in this House about the defence of this country, I am coming to believe that it is on some people like him that the Government intend to rely. Of course, it would not be the first time that some of the members of that Government relied on the same gentleman. I quote from the Cork Examiner of 4th March:-

"Dr. O'Higgins, who concluded with an appeal to Mr. Churchill to use his ‘immense influence and unquestioned prestige' towards a settlement of a question of ‘farreaching importance to the democratic world in its stand against the Communist menace,' pointed out that in a great defence line from Iceland to the American continent, there was a vacuum in the centre, a vacuum represented on the map of Ireland."

I wonder what does the Minister for External Affairs think of that policy. Is that the policy that he would adopt, of appealing to the man who helped to create Partition to do away with it now, or, does the Minister for Defence realise that he is making a laughing stock of himself in the Six Counties and in England by appealing to a man who did everything in his power to injure this country? Is that the attitude we are going to take up to defend this country against any foreign invader or anything else?

Then we had two other Deputies, Deputy Giles and Deputy Collins, whose attitude was that, it did not matter what happened the Six Counties, we were going to join the Atlantic Pact. That happens to be the attitude, as far as I can see, of the Fine Gael Party in this Government and I want to know does the Taoiseach stand over the attitude that we should be appealing, at this stage, after all our talks of republics and everything else, to Winston Churchill to finish the Border. I think it is a very sad reflection on all the boastings and fireworks we had in the Phoenix Park.

Comment on this

This evening, when the Taoiseach was introducing his Estimate, he reminded me of the many occasions that he was in court with a client who had a bad case. By the time he was finished appealing for the client, the jury were practically convinced that the case was a sound one. Certainly, this evening, he tried to make a very good case out of what is a very bad one.

Comment on this

I hope I convinced the Deputy as I convinced the jury he refers to.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach did not always convince the jury. The Taoiseach tried to do with figures what the Minister for Agriculture tried to do for the English with eggs. He tried to drown us in figures without anyone having time to examine them and to know exactly how they worked out. The difficulty that is facing the Taoiseach is that the team he is relying on are not a reliable team. If the Taoiseach is to carry out any programme for the betterment of the country he must have beside him Ministers upon whom the country and the Taoiseach himself can place reliance, whatever about the propaganda they might be prepared to make in order to have themselves returned to this House at any future date. They should put the interests of the country first and Party politics after. Unfortunately I am afraid that is not being done. I have listened to most of this debate. The only Deputy who made a very serious effort to come to the Taoiseach's rescue was Deputy Cowan.

Deputy Cowan complimented the Ministers and pointed out the numerous difficulties they encountered as new Ministers who took office without having had any departmental or administrative experience. It is because of that and because of the way they have tried to bluff in their offices and here day after day that the policy which the Taoiseach so often announced could be, but is not being, put into effect. I listened to Deputy Cowan tell us that the health of the people had improved and tell us of all the things which this Government had done. Of course, he did not omit to tell us that the Fianna Fáil Party, despite all their years of office, did nothing and that now they are making every effort to sabotage this country and adopt a policy of obstruction. He said that we obstructed when the Local Authorities (Works) Act was being put through this House. Every Deputy in this House will remember that before that Bill was introduced we were informed that it would be a four line Bill: actually, it turned out to be a Bill of, I think, four sections. We offered amendments and we criticised the Bill in an endeavour to make it a Bill that would be workable. There is not a Deputy sitting on the Government Benches who can deny that by the time the Bill passed through this House in all its stages the Minister had not alone added a number of sections but there was very little comparison to be found between it and the Bill as it was originally introduced.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy realises, of course, that legislation should not be discussed on the Estimate.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan was allowed to discuss all this.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cowan did not discuss legislation.

Comment on this

Deputy Killilea is not discussing legislation. He is referring to a charge which was made by Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have been told that Deputy Killilea is not discussing legislation. If discussing the merits of a Bill on its different stages is not discussing legislation——

Comment on this

If the Ceann Comhairle will pardon me, I should like to point out that we have been charged with obstructing. Our criticism of the Local Authorities (Works) Act on its different stages is referred to as an example of obstruction by us. I contend that any time we criticised either that Bill or the Land Bill or any Bill it was for the purpose of improving the Bill in question. I may say that the Land Bill was improved time and time again and it was a better Bill when it was passed by this House than it was when it was introduced. If we criticised any piece of legislation it was for the purpose of ensuring that it would be useful to the people of this country and I think the facts prove conclusively that our criticism was fruitful.

Deputy Cowan told us that he joined the Army in 1922 and he then proceeded to challenge the Leader of the Opposition regarding his activities since then. He joined the Army in 1922 for the purpose of establishing a Treaty which recognised the unnatural Partition of this country and to-day he is trying to establish an army to try to remove that boundary. If that is not jumping, I should like to know what is.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is that Government policy? The Deputy is supposed to be discussing Government policy.

Comment on this

It is Government policy when no effort is being made to stop this tomfoolery that Deputy Cowan is going on with in making fools of the young men of the City of Dublin. Deputy Cowan went further than that. I suppose he sort of let the cat out of the bag. Whenever any of the members on the Government Benches get up on any platform in the country they always talk about our Constitution and say what a great Constitution it is They impress upon the people that it is their duty to obey the Constitution and to stand by it. This evening Deputy Cowan described our Constitution as a "face saver". I wonder if the Taoiseach agrees with him in that statement. If the Taoiseach agrees with him in that statement he must agree also that the Bill which was brought in here to establish the Republic was also a face saver.

Comment on this

It did not save your face.

Comment on this

It did not—and our faces do not have to be saved the same as the O'Higgins' faces.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You should have a look at your own some time.

Comment on this

Nor the empty barrel faces, either.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It was not raised on scrub.

Comment on this

I am not one of the people in this House who are here on the record of another person. I am here on my own record. If Deputy Collins wants to speak on this Estimate he is entitled to do so but certainly he should not interrupt. He is constantly interrupting, morning, noon and night.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I am not here on false pretences. Ramble on.

Comment on this

I do not think that statements like that are any credit to any Party or to any individual. I consider that credit should be given in this House for work well done no matter which Government may have done it and credit should be given to the Fianna Fáil Party for all it did while it was the Government of this country. No matter what this present combination of Parties who constitute the Government have in mind, the speople of this country are quite satisfied that, despite the statements which are made in this House day after day by Deputies on the Government Benches to the effect that nothing was done by Fianna Fáil during the 16 years it was in office, Fianna Fáil was a good Government for this country. I think the people are well aware that even now the present Government are working on a Housing Bill that was produced by Fianna Fáil. I would point out, too, that despite the boasts of the Minister for Lands, legislation regarding the division of land was produced by Fianna Fáil. Even the boasts made by the Minister for Agriculture regarding his work for land reclamation ring some what hollow when we remember that the headline was set in that respect by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Has the Deputy anything to say on the Vote for the Taoiseach's Department?

Comment on this

I have this to say, that all these items I have mentioned and numerous other items which I could mention are all part of a policy that is being carried out by this Government under false pretences because it is really and truly the policy of Fianna Fáil that is being carried out. I should like to remind the Taoiseach that every Deputy in this House is of equal value.

Comment on this
Deputies

Oh!

Comment on this

That is the highest compliment ever paid to you.

Comment on this

I will give them full credit. I think that the Taoiseach must realise that if Ministers and Deputies who sit on the Government Benches make statements throughout the country to the effect that representations made to Government Departments on behalf of individuals throughout the country are useless unless they are made by individuals on the Government Benches, they are doing a grave wrong and that such statements should not be made. In any event, when a Deputy approaches a Department to make representations on behalf of a constituent the Department gives the same attention to every Deputy no matter to what political Party he may belong. I think I am quite right in saying that, and I believe the Taoiseach will agree with me. Therefore, it is very wrong of Government Deputies and Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries to try to create any other impression. The behaviour of Deputies opposite, with their grunting and snorting, reminds me very much of the family to which I would suggest they belong—but I will leave the rest unsaid.

The last item that I have mentioned is one, I think, that the Taoiseach should make a statement on when he is concluding the debate. I have never met with discourtesy myself in the various Departments. In every Department I have gone to I got the greatest courtesy from the officials, whether on matters relating to old age pensions, the Board of Works or any other Department. I do not want the impression to be created outside that if a Fianna Fáil Deputy goes in person to make a representation, it might be much better for any other person to do it. That impression has been created and I would like the Taoiseach to indicate whether it is right or wrong.

Comment on this

I intervene in this debate for the purpose of registering an emphatic protest against the treatment meted out by this Administration to the people in the congested districts, and particularly the people in Connemara. It is true that at the best of times the people in that area have a rather precarious existence. It is equally true that under the Fianna Fáil régime, with the development of turf schemes, with bog development and road development and with extensive grants under the minor employment schemes, there was work available to the people. The Fianna Fáil Government provided South Connemara, anyway, with a glasshouse scheme which, if allowed to develop, would be of tremendous economic advantage to the people in that area.

The present position there is very bad. There is wholesale unemployment and one consequence of that is wholesale emigration. Any Deputy can go down to meet the western trains at any time and he will find plenty of people on their way to England. The Commission on Emigration cannot settle that problem. What the people require is work. I should like the Taoiseach to tell us what he intends to do for that particular area. Is it the policy of the Government to get out of its difficulty simply by letting the people emigrate? If that is the policy, then it is succeeding. It would be a very grave indictment of an Irish Government if it were to allow conditions like that to continue. I make the appeal now that some attention should be given to the problems in that particular area, and that the Government should proceed with schemes there, particularly in relation to turf and bog development and the improvement of roads, so as to give much needed employment.

There is another matter which affects the people of that area, just as it affects the people of Dublin City, and that is the operation of the dual price system. It always seemed to me to be a terrible thing, in a Catholic country like this, that you should have two prices, one for the man who is well off and another for the man with only a small amount of money. It is also a terrible indictment of the Labour representatives here that they ever stood for that. The people most affected by it are the poor, the working man with a large family who has to depend on bread, butter and tea. It is very easy to understand in a place like Connemara where they have not much of the world's goods and where they are happy in having large families that they have to buy food outside their rations. It is all right for the Minister to say that the rationed goods are sufficient. That may be all right for people in the cities who can afford a better table, who can have varied commodities on the table, including plenty of fresh meat and vegetables. In Connemara the people have to depend mainly on flour, butter, tea and sugar. To me it is a scandalous business that you should have this dual price system in operation. At least it can be said of Fianna Fáil that during the war years they maintained an equal price for all the citizens.

Comment on this

Black market prices.

Comment on this

Your Government was the first to let the offenders out—we all know that. Another matter to which I would like to direct attention is housing, and particularly the financing of housing schemes. The position is very disturbing to people who examine what is happening in relation to housing. The Minister for Finance, in his Budget statement, said it was the purpose of the Government partly to relieve the Exchequer of the charge in respect of housing by the introduction of the differential rents system, but that tends to make the worker pay a higher rent; that is really what is happening. By a very devious method, the Minister for Local Government has sent a circular to local authorities advising them to adopt the differential rent system, and the whole purpose behind it is that if such a scheme is economic—that is, if the rents accruing do not warrant a contribution from the rates—then the Central Fund is relieved of its contribution and also of its contribution to the Transition Development Fund. The result is that the rents on the working classes will go up. There are schemes with rents ranging from 31/4 for a working-class house to a minimum figure of 11/4. Under the Fianna Fáil régime the Central Fund paid 60 per cent. of the cost of houses. Those figures can be vouched for.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil introduced the differential rent system.

Comment on this

They did not.

Comment on this

Yes, they did; they passed the legislation.

Comment on this

They did not say they would refuse a grant under the Transition Development Fund, which your own Minister said. At the present rate, even taking in the Transition Development grant and the two-thirds subsidy, it is less than 50 per cent. as against Fianna Fáil's 60 per cent. With the introduction of the differential rent system the effect will be that workers will have to pay higher rents and every increase the worker will get one-sixth of it will be represented in his rent. I do not know what the workers' representatives are doing if they allow such a position to develop. If they come to Galway soon they will be told what is what. It is a terrible thing that they continue to support a Government which does that to the workers.

Comment on this

There are bad employers in Galway. What about the four months' strike?

Comment on this

Grow up and be your age. I advise the Deputy not to say too much about that or he might get a reply he would not like. The Government should face its responsibilities and in the matter of housing fix a definite contribution from the Central Fund that will enable the local authority to let houses at a rent which the workers can pay. The Minister for Finance has said that the Transition Development Fund will be wound up this year and merged in the Local Government Vote. He also qualified it by saying that the subsidy for workers' rents would be reduced— which means that those rents will be higher.

I would also like to protest against the action of the Government in raising the rate of interest to local authorities. It is true that that has not been done purely for the superstructure of housing, but the rate of interest is increased for the acquisition of land, for development, sewerage work, and so on. We heard a lot about cheap money, but it is extraordinary that it was the Fianna Fáil Minister who in 1944 brought in the policy of giving loans to local authorities at 2½ per cent. while one of the first actions of the present Government was to raise it to 3¼ per cent.

I would make a slight reference to rural electrification. While very good work has been done in our constituency, it would appear from the Vote that there has been a falling off in the moneys voted for that.

Comment on this

There is no falling off.

Comment on this

There was an indication of that on the Finance Vote.

Comment on this

There will be no slowing up in rural electrification.

Comment on this

If that is so, I hope there will be no falling off in the development of electricity in the Connemara area. Since you have taken everything else away, you might as well give them a bit of light.

Comment on this
Michael J. Kennedy Micheál Ó Cinnéide Fianna Fáil

Tá cúpla ceist agam don Taoiseach. Bhíos ag éisteacht leis an cheist a chur an Teachta de Valera air, ar cheist na mbóthar fan dtuaith agus ar cheist an airgid, agus chuir sé in iúil dhom an Meastachán a scrúdú. Dúirt an Teachta de Valera go mba cheart go ndéanfaí iarracht i dtaobh na daoine fán dtuaith a bhí in a gcomhnuidhe ann agus a bhí ag imeacht agus ar siubhal as na feirmeacha. Dúirt sé go mbeadh siad ar siubhal chomh fada is nach mbeadh slí beatha maith acu.

I want to reiterate what Deputy de Valera said about conditions in the rural parts, that if the people are to be kept on the land they must have the same amenities as the people in the towns and cities. They must have good roads and good boreens into their residences. They cannot be asked any longer to go through muck and slush on those boreens on their various occupations. The maintenance of the country roads has been evaded by this Government. They or their successors will have to face the responsibility.

The Taoiseach was speaking about the financial position of the State and it reminded me of the note that the Minister for Finance has in the Book of Estimates for the current financial year. In the latter portion he is dealing with the segregation of capital services and current expenditure and he states:-

"For a full account of capital outlay financed by borrowing, regard must, of course, be had not only to the capital services included in this volume but also to the direct issues from the Central Fund for advances to the Electricity Supply Board, the Local Loans Fund, etc., estimates of which appear in the White Paper of receipts and expenditure published prior to the annual Budget."

There has been an attempt all along by the Government to mix up current expenditure with capital expenditure. In this segregation the Government takes, for instance, the question of grants to local authorities for the execution of works under the Local Authorities (Works) Act of 1949, £1,750,000. Since I have become a member of this House, there has been current expenditure, under the heading of minor relief schemes, for this work. That will occur every year. How that can be put under capital expenditure confuses me altogether. It is current expenditure and it is falsity to put it under another head. Not only will these works have to continue but, as I have advocated here on the Estimate for the Office of Public Works, there will have to be a State scheme for their maintenance when they are done. Consequently, it is wrong for the Government to put that particular item down as capital expenditure. It is an annual expenditure and should be treated as current expenditure.

In the same way, housing grants were always made out of current expenditure. Any person examining the rural needs for housing knows that the back of the problem will not be broken for the next ten years, even at a conservative estimate. In my own county, which is a go-ahead one and which the Minister for Local Government will admit is a go-ahead country, I have seen elaborate schemes formulated and drafted for solving the rural housing problem; but no matter what we do, the progress is not all we desire. The same applies to a greater extent to other southern counties about which I have read, where they have not gone on with housing at the rate we have done. In my county, I estimate about 800 rural houses will be needed. We are building only about 80, notwithstanding the introduction of direct labour methods. I cannot see how this money for housing can be treated as capital expenditure. It is a current expenditure and the problem of the housing of the farmers will become more and more pressing and will have to be faced up to by this Government or the Government that succeeds it.

The same applies to the Gaeltacht. Anyone conversant with the Gaeltacht and the congestion there knows the number of houses on uneconomic holdings there that need to be pulled down and replaced. The back of the housing problem in the Gaeltacht, with the best intentions, will not be broken for at least ten years. How you can treat that as capital expenditure is beyond me.

From my knowledge of history, it strikes me that any country which keeps on borrowing, instead of taking its courage in its hands and taxing the people to their bearable capacity to meet current expenditure, cannot advance in the national interest. They are only biting off their noses to spite their faces. We have to-day the example of France where one Government after another collapses and where the value of the franc depreciates every six months. The Minister for Finance has stated that excessive borrowing leads to inflation. If there is inflation, then the cost of living—which this Government promised to bring down—goes up. In two years the interest and sinking fund of the national liabilities has gone up from £3,250,000 to £6,500,000. I have read out a number of items which I said should not be treated as capital expenditure. These items will recur next year and the year after and the increase in the redemption of capital will go on at such a rate that deflation must follow, the cost of living will go up and the Government that succeeds the Coalition Government will find itself faced with no enviable task. It is time the Taoiseach and those responsible examined the state of the Exchequer. The Minister for Finance made reference in his statement to the fact that in one year there has been an appreciable rise in the national debt. At column 1638 of Volume 120 of the Official Report the Minister said:—

"The gross State debt on 31st March, 1950, stood at £151,000,000 as compared with £116,000,000 on 31st March, 1949."

Is it not time that those responsible should take cognisance of this matter? Scoring political points is all right, but we should have a national outlook on these matters. That outlook does not appear to exist on the Government Benches at the moment.

Comment on this

I had no intention of entering into this debate——

Comment on this

You are under orders.

Comment on this

——until I heard the speech of the Minister for Defence. I think it is the duty of every republican Deputy to condemn that speech. I never thought I should have to listen to such a bitter speech as that delivered by the Minister for Defence to-night. It was brimful of hatred. We care very little about that. We care very little about the man who on one occasion referred to the immense influence and unquestioned prestige of Winston Churchill. We care very little how he denounces Fianna Fáil or shows his hatred for the greatest leader Europe has produced, Eamon de Valera. Were it not that the times are so dangerous, we would let these speeches pass just as we have let many speeches of that kind pass before this. This is not the time for preaching hatred. This is not the time for dividing the national forces. Possibly in weeks or months this same Minister for Defence may be appealing to the people to defend our independence.

Comment on this

It is a pity Deputy MacEntee is not here to listen to that homily.

Comment on this

The defence of this country will be primarily one for the Minister for Defence. Nothing short of a revolution in Russia will stay the tide of world war so that democracy may be saved for another 100 years. Is it by preaching hatred that the Minister will find his volunteer Army? On the last occasion when this country was threatened we had many men with military experience, members of the Old I.R.A., who were anxious and willing to defend our independence. They may not be available to help in organising another defence force. The Minister will have to retrace his steps and cease this policy of bitterness if he hopes to meet any threat to our security, with a united front. Let nobody be foolish enough to think that other nations will not demand our ports or air bases. We must be in a position to answer that demand, we must take every step to ensure that this country will not be brought at a low price, or even at a high price.

I would like to see the F.C.A. reorganised on a war basis. I think it should be possible to do that. We have patriotic young men who, if they were given facilities for training, would from the nucleus of a very effective army. The Minister for Defence has failed to carry out the promises he made with regard to establishing halls throughout the country for the use of the F.C.A. so that they could be trained in military strategy and the art of war for the defence of the country's independence. Our agricultural position should be strengthened so that, in the event of war, we would not have to cave in because of the want of the necessaries of life, particularly of wheat. If the Minister for Agriculture pursues his present policy of grass we will soon be back again to ranching, pandering to the ranchers who farm from their hall-door steps. We do not want that position. We must remember that it was the working farmers of the country who kept us in food during the last emergency, and they are the people who will again come to the rescue of the nation if the necessity should arise. I want to refer briefly to the dilatory methods of the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise on the Taoiseach's Estimate.

Comment on this

I hope that the Minister will carry out some of the promises he made and undo landlordism and plant on the land of this country people who will work it for the advantage of the nation. We hear quite a lot about the rehabilitation of the land. In my opinion, if the rivers are not drained first then we are simply putting the car before the horse. I would make an earnest appeal to the Minister for Defence that one of the first things he must do is to apologise to the House and to the country for resurrecting the bitterness that he was responsible for in this House a few hours ago.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Taoiseach to conclude.

Comment on this

A Leas-Chinn Comhairle——

Deputy Aiken rose.

Comment on this

Is the Taoiseach concluding? There are other Deputies to speak.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No Deputy offered himself, and the Chair called on the Taoiseach to conclude. Deputy Aiken.

Comment on this

I simply want to ask the Taoiseach to tell the House and the country as to whether Government policy for the next year is going to be based, as he explained it was in his Estimate for the last two years, on a policy of continuing world peace. We would all be delighted, and we all hope in God, that the world will settle down and that some arrangement will be come to between nations whereby disputes will be settled by the application of law rather than by the rule of force. But does the Taoiseach think that is the sort of world we are living in, and can he give any assurance to the country that peace will continue for another few years? The Minister for Defence laid down, as his rule for governing the Department of Defence——

Comment on this

Out of deference to Deputy Aiken, I think a Deputy sitting behind him should not be reading an evening paper.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I was not reading an evening paper. I was merely taking information from it for the purpose of the debate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

A Deputy is entitled to do that.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Higgins and the particular group of Deputies around him who do nothing but grunt and snort would cease from that, this would be a more orderly House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will deal with interruptions.

Comment on this

I will deal with interruptions, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, if you do not deal with them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That contains an insinuation—I do not know whether the Deputy intends to make it or not—that the Chair is not going to deal with interruptions.

Comment on this

It is a purely hypothetical answer.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Does the Deputy mean that the Chair is not going to deal with interruptions from any side of the House?

Comment on this

I hope the Chair will.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I want a straight answer to the insinuation that the Chair is not going to deal with interruptions.

Comment on this

I said that if the Leas-Cheann Comhairle did not deal with them I would. I take it the Leas-Cheann Comhairle will. That is his duty. The Taoiseach, and the Minister for Defence, should have dealt, I think, in a better and in a clearer manner than they did with Government policy in view of the present world situation. The Minister for Defence laid down, as Government policy in relation to defence, that he was going to sharpen the sword when the drums beat for battle, but not before that.

Comment on this

The Americans seem to be doing that now.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan does not like America.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence was going to leave every man at the plough or to look after bullocks if the Minister for Agriculture has his way; he was going to leave every man in the factory until war broke out. That would be all fine and dandy, as the Americans say, if the other fellow would do the same, but we know that the situation in one part of the world in recent weeks was that, while one Government was acting on the thesis of the Minister for Defence——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Conversations should be held somewhere else than in this Chamber.

Comment on this

—— the other Government was acting on a completely different one, and that five years' training told inside a couple of weeks. We know of course that one of the reasons why Deputy Cowan praised the Taoiseach so much and praised the Minister for Defence, was that he would like us to continue to act on the principle that we sharpen the sword when the drums beat for battle, but he does not act in that particular way himself. Why does he not apply that in his own case? He wants the rest of us to be disarmed, and he will sharpen the sword and tell us where to get off.

Comment on this

Is not that what the Minister is preaching?

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan wants the present Government for his own particular purposes, which I do not think he has disclosed very frankly either to the House or to the country, to continue in that fashion.

While the Government have been carrying on as they have in regard to the Army for the past couple of years, other countries of Western Europe have been devoting 25 per cent to 30 per cent. of their national energy to defensive purposes. The Minister for Defence recently complained that, owing to a certain situation, this country would be a vacuum in case of war. We all know that war, as well as nature, abhors a vacuum and if we do not fill the vacuum, if there is a vacuum in the Western World, it will be filled by somebody else.

Comment on this

I hope that is not an invitation.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan would like it to be filled by a certain section and the Minister for Agriculture by another section but I do not want it to be filled by either of their friends. I want to see it filled by Irishmen. Before the last war, we had to consider the question as to whether it was right and proper that we should expend a fair proportion of our national energy in trying to organise to keep all sides out. In spite of great opposition at that time, we did succeed in so developing our resources, in so training our young men and inspiring them with a correct sense of duty, that we were able to keep all sides out—both the gentlemen whom the Minister for Defence and the Minister for Agriculture would praise and the people whom, perhaps, Deputy Cowan would praise.

Comment on this

Were they not both members of the Defence Council?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cowan was permitted to make a speech of his own and I should like him to permit Deputy Aiken to do the same.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan pretends that he wants to make a speech but, when he gets up, all he can do is to flatter the Taoiseach owing to what he has done for Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

That is a crime.

Comment on this

It is not a crime. It was not even a crime to leave Deputy Davin here instead of putting him on the board of Córas Iompair Éireann, as he wanted.

Comment on this

That is a good joke.

Comment on this

We want to put it to the Taoiseach that it is his duty, in the present world situation, to base Government policy, not on any likelihood of a continuing world peace, but on the assumption that we may be launched into a world war before we wake up some morning, whether it is to-morrow morning, in two years' time or five years' time. If we spend a reasonable amount of our national energy in taking ordinary precautions, in the training of our Army and the procurement of stores, we can make good use of the money earmarked for that purpose, but if we let the Army drift, if the Taoiseach continues to allow the Minister for Defence to sneer at everybody who goes into the Army as a person who is shirking an honest day's work, as one who is going to kick his heels and knock sparks out of the barrack square, we are not going to make a reasonable use of the Army. If it were true that the right policy for defence is that outlined by the Minister for Defence, that we should not take any more men into the Army and that we should keep all our young men at work until the drum beats for battle, why do we not dispense with the 7,000 or 8,000 men we have already in the Army and put them to work until the drum beats for battle?

For these last few years the Fianna Fáil Party has had to do the work that the Government should have been doing in relation to national defence. It is the Government's duty to face unpopularity, if there is unpopularity involved, in asking the people to support a reasonable defence policy under all circumstances. Other Governments do it and the Fianna Fáil Government were forced to do it. We were forced to do it in 1938 and 1939 and we were denounced here as spendthrifts, as people who were draining the life blood of the nation when we were making a very modest preparation for the war which then seemed to most people inevitable but which the Minister for Agriculture told us was never going to come. It is the Government's duty at the present time to ask the people to support a reasonable defence policy. It was their duty for the last couple of years if they had fulfilled it, but, to avoid the unpopularity of collecting money to pay the soldiers and to pay for arms, they neglected to carry out their duty in that regard.

When the atomic bomb exploded in Hiroshima, the next war was dated. Everybody who realised the consequences of that explosion, knew that it was dated unless the Russians were prepared to open up and allow other countries to inspect their munition factories and assure themselves that the atomic bomb was not being made. We know that if war comes, it is going to be a pretty savage affair. The one hope our people have to keep out of it is to make certain that no outsiders will come in here unless the Dáil has decided that they should do so. If we are going to create a vacuum here, that vacuum will be filled by somebody. Troops nowadays do not have to cross water on the surface, or under the surface, in order to get to an island. One of our fears in the last war—one of the danger points in my opinion always— was at the beginning that the Power which seized the Continent might easily come in here by air when the tide of war was flowing with them and the second danger was that they might have attempted it as a last throw.

It is our duty to do what we can to make certain that this defence vacuum, as the Minister for Defence called it, is filled by Irish troops. We would not have to mobilise the whole of our population in order to do that, but we have to make the reasonably modest demand of our people that they support as a maximum another few thousand men in the regular forces so that we can add to our regular Defence Reserve and also provide cadre and a stiffening for the Volunteer Forces and our Local Defence Force. We would not have to draw into the Army or attempt to draw into the Army the people that were outlined by the Minister for Defence, all who were trained here during our own previous wars or in foreign wars. It is useful that our people have such experience but that experience will be of no value militarily unless the people who have that experience are armed and trained to work together before the drum beats for battle.

Our F.C.A. should be getting very much more attention than it is getting at the present time. If airborne forces were to come on this country they would have to be hit quickly, and we must ensure that every weapon we have at the present time is in the hands of a trained man. One trained man is worth 20 half trained men when it comes to repelling an attack. Without any warmongering, and praying to the Almighty God that war may never come upon the world and that this thing that has started in the East will not lead to war upon an unprepared Europe, we should at least take steps and the Taoiseach should at least take the very small preliminary step of saying that his policy, the policy of a Government in a world in which every country is increasing its armament as quickly as it can, is no longer based upon the assumption that world peace will continue. His instructions to his Ministers should be that they should make reasonable efforts to organise the Departments of State and bring to bear on the people the influence of those Departments so as to secure reasonable defence precautions.

Without very much expenditure we can produce an A.R.P. service, the ordinary ambulance service of the Red Cross and other such organisations. That will not cost us a lot of money; all it will cost is that the Government should say that it is our duty to prepare to defend ourselves and to prepare to succour anybody who may be hurt or wounded in such an eventuality.

With regard to agriculture we could without any expenditure—indeed with the saving of dollars—set ourselves to grow the minimum of our cereal requirements particularly of wheat. If we are going to do that next year we cannot leave it until the Dáil comes back. If our farmers are to go in for a programme of increased tillage next year sufficient to meet our reasonable requirements for man and beast, they will have to know that now so that in a month's time when they start to cut their oats they will be able to get ahead and prepare for the following year's tillage. It will take a couple of months to get our farmers around to that point of view. Surely from any point of view our farmers owe it as a duty to their own people, a duty which they will fulfil if they are asked by the Government, to till as much of their land as will secure our people from starvation or from the threat of anybody pushing us around because of the fear of starvation. We all know from recent disclosures that that game was tried on us in the last war but we were not vulnerable to such an attempt. If tillage continues to fall as it has been falling during the last few years, however, we will be vulnerable. There are a number of Deputies, I am perfectly certain, on the Government Benches who are as little anxious as I am that we should be vulnerable in that regard. To produce merely what is necessary to protect our supply of bread will actually save us dollars and it will give farmers who are facing a price of a couple of shillings for eggs instead of 3/- a dozen something to compensate them. The change from our present policy with regard to wheat growing is a change that will be welcomed by our people next year. I think that the Government would gain in kudos, would gain somewhat in popularity if even at this late stage they were to say: "It would have been foolish to follow Fianna Fáil policy for this last couple of years but now under present circumstances it is our national duty to go out and get all the wheat we can."

Apart altogether from owing it as a duty to our own people to prepare ourselves in a reasonable fashion to fill that vacuum about which the Minister for Defence spoke, I think we owe it as a duty to civilisation. The one thing that will stop aggression in the world is that free peoples should be prepared to defend their freedom to the last breath. One of the things at which I am disgusted at the present time is that certain of the Powers who prate about the coming fight for freedom and democracy are not prepared to carry out in their own regard the rules of conduct they have laid down for other Powers. I would be prepared and I hope our people will be prepared to make them do it in our regard before they ask us to go gunning for those principles elsewhere. I think it would be a good contribution to the cause of Christianity and western civilisation if we were prepared to fill our vacuum and see that nobody will get in here except with the concurrence of our people. I move to report progress.

Comment on this