Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).
Contributions 1–127 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Deputy de Valera raised in this debate yesterday the grave international situation which has recently developed and the possible consequences to this country if that situation should deteriorate for the purpose of securing, if possible, an indication of the Government's viewpoint as to the preparatory measures which might now be taken in the interest of our security. I do not suppose that the Government have any information concerning the situation and its possible development which is not available to the general public through Press reports. Nobody is deceived, I hope, by the suggestion made yesterday by the Minister for Defence that the Government have available to them secret sources of information which enable them to come to judgments on the position and which are not available to the public. If any Deputy has been misled by that suggestion, I should like that the Taoiseach, in fair ness to the House and to the country, would correct that position. Certainly, no Deputy who had the responsibility of being a member of the Government during the crisis which preceded the second world war and during the course of that war can have any doubts on the matter or any illusions concerning the accuracy or the purpose of the Minister for Defence's statement. The Minister for Defence was, I think, attempting to bluff the House in an attempt to justify what appears to be the policy of inactivity upon which the Government have decided.
There is no likelihood that any deterioration in the international situation which might create a crisis for this country will be so heralded in advance that there will be ample time for the Government here to take preparatory steps of any value. It is very undesirable that in considering this grave matter Deputies should be not misled by childish statements of that kind. Whatever the Government may believe, there is no doubt that the general public believe that this international situation is likely to develop sooner or later into a general war unless something unexpected happens. It is similar in many of its aspects to the situation in 1938. It is, perhaps, even more grave than that which existed in 1938. The preparation of the national economy, the preparation of our defences against the consequences of a deterioration in the position, are such urgent matters that they must be the predominant aim of Government policy in all Departments at present.
I do not want to be taken as suggesting that it is possible for us to do a great deal in a short time by way of preparation. Something can be done in the field of defence and something can be done in other fields, but it is beyond doubt that, if a crisis should develop quickly, it is already too late to do much that, on the conclusion of the last war, we thought should be done against such a situation developing in the future. In the field of defence, something can be done. Again, it is possible to exaggerate what can be done. We here have not attempted to urge upon the Government any course that would appear to be impracticable, or that would be suggestive of undue alarm. We think it is practicable to bring the Defence Forces of this country up to the strength which the Army Command deemed to be the minimum strength which would permit of the creation of an organisation capable of rapid expansion if the need arose. The Army is not at that strength now.
We have been treated by the Government, and particularly by the Minister for Defence, with contempt whenever this question of defence policy has been raised. Figures have been given by Ministers which are known to be inaccurate and contradictory statements have been made, according to the political needs of the moment. There is no Deputy who can feel that he can place any reliance upon a statement made by the Minister for Defence on important aspects of defence policy. The Minister endeavoured to represent the view of this Party as including the mobilisation of reserve and volunteer forces and the placing of these forces on a permanent basis in barracks and camps. We do not think that course is necessary and we have not suggested it. The fact that the Minister for Defence considered it desirable to endeavour to misrepresent the point of view expressed from these benches is itself a factor in the situation which we should take into account, because it justifies the conclusion that no serious consideration has been given to this matter by him or by the Government and that their sole concern, when the matter is raised, is to escape any political difficulty it may cause them. This policy of bluff and pretence is a poor substitute for that for which the situation calls.
The Minister yesterday took a different line from that which he took upon the debate on the Estimate for Defence. On that occasion, he appeared anxious to advertise the weakness of our defence position. He spoke about driblets of armaments procurable from abroad. Subsequently, the Minister for External Affairs spoke abroad about the obsolete and inefficient weapons we were procuring, and generally he and his colleagues have taken a line which appears to suggest that they do not believe the defence of this country by its own citizens to be a practicable proposition. It may be that there are practical difficulties at present in procuring up-to-date armaments in adequate quantities; it may be that there are other problems in extending the size of the military organisations of the State; but more important than these matters is the promotion amongst our people of the will to defend our freedom, of the realisation that the obligation to defend it rests upon them. More important than these matters is the need to make it known abroad that it is national policy here to accept fully ourselves the obligation of our own defence.
The line taken by the Government appears to run counter to that idea and that is the reason why we are so seriously perturbed concerning it. After the speech made yesterday, it is obvious that the Minister for Defence is an unsuitable occupant of that post. If the situation should deteriorate necessitating action by the Government—the expansion of our defence forces and the calling to the defence of the country of its young men—then the enthusiasm that will answer that call will be considerably diminished by the highly partisan line taken yesterday by the Minister for Defence and the obvious incompetence which has characterised his whole administration.
I have said that outside the field of defence there is not much that can be done by way of preparation against an emergency that may come soon. But it may not come soon, and it is obviously desirable that we should begin now in the economic and financial fields, whatever preparations are possible, hoping that either the crisis will not develop at all or that we will be given time to bring these preparations to completion. There are many respects in which our position now is better than it was in 1938. Let me confess that in 1938, the preparations made against the possibility of war proved in the event to be inadequate. We underestimated the magnitude of the conflict that was coming and its duration. We were perhaps unduly influenced by the views then held in many quarters that war, if it came, would be confined to the Continent of Europe and that modern armaments would make it necessarily of short duration. We made preparations, however, which were of value and there is available to the Government now all the experience accumulated by the officers in charge of these preparations. They know to what extent our arrangements proved satisfactory and to what extent they proved unsatisfactory, and that fund of experience available to the Government is of immense importance.
When the previous Government in 1938 was faced with this problem, it was something that was new in this country. It was the first time in our history that an Irish Government was given that task and it had to proceed largely by trial and error. It is not necessary to take that course now because the knowledge then gained is available to our successors.
During the course of the war, the then Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, gave instructions to all Ministers who were charged with responsibility for any of the war-time arrangements to record the measures taken, with a brief account of their development and a note of the improvements that might be tried on another occasion. In preparing that war record for our successors, we hoped that it would not be opened for 20 or 25 years, at the earliest, and we were thinking that far ahead in placing our experience on the files. But, it is time now that it was opened. Perhaps it is being opened. Perhaps arrangements are in train which will ensure that unnecessary delay will be avoided when positive steps have to be taken but, if they are, we want to know it. We think the people of the country would be reassured if they were so informed.
What must be the aim of Government policy in that matter? Clearly, we must try to secure by measures taken now that if an international crisis following a spread of war should develop quickly we will have available here essential supplies in sufficient quantity to maintain reasonable distribution of consumption goods on the one had, for a period, and important industrial activities, on the other hand. The Government has in existence the nucleus of a rationing scheme. I assume that it is not necessary now to go through the preliminary steps which had to be taken in 1940, the preparation of a national register and the compilation of the other particulars which had to be available before ration books could be put in the hands of citizens. Ration books are in the hands of citizens now. Presumably, therefore, the extension of rationing to any goods which should be necessary is practicable without delay.
We know that the area under wheat is larger than it was in 1938, that the knowledge of tillage and the implements necessary for tillage exist, or should exist, in wider areas of the country than was the case in 1938. The only thing that is in doubt is the attitude of the Minister for Agriculture and of the Government generally in relation to the general question of agricultural policy and its direction towards the primary aim of ensuring the food supplies of our own people.
It is desirable that we should have that minimum of essential supplies within the country, supplemented by arrangements, if possible, to procure additional supplies from abroad, not merely for the purpose of protecting the welfare of our own people in time of an emergency, but also to give us the necessary breathing space to consider any political problems that the outbreak of a general war might cause for us.
In the agricultural field, and particularly in the industrial field, any extension of activity which would increase our security in time of war will take a long time. It is necessary that members of the Government and Deputies should face up to that fact.
I have already recounted here on another occasion the serious gaps in our industrial organisation which our war-time experience showed to exist and urged upon the Government that it should so direct its industrial policy as to close these gaps as quickly as possible. Unfortunately, the Government have taken the course of farming out its responsibility for industrial policy to an outside authority, the socalled Industrial Development Authority. I warned the Government when they took that course that they were depriving themselves of the power to take speedy and effective action and experience during the past two years has shown that warning to be justified.
If there is to be a positive direction of Government activity in the industrial field, with a view to making our industrial organisation more secure in time of war, then the Industrial Development Authority will have to be put in cold storage until that emergency is over and the Minister for Industry and Commerce and his Department will have to take responsibility for direct action in that matter.
All the indication so far has been that, instead of directing industrial policy with the ultimate aim of creating a viable industrial policy that can operate in any international circumstances, the Government is doing the reverse. The specific instances in which Government policy has moved contrary to the national interests have been frequently mentioned here. The particular projects that were in train for the establishment under Córas Iompair Éireann auspices at Inchicore of a factory for the manufacture of motor vehicles, the proposed factory for the manufacture of aeroplane parts and for aeroplane construction, the proposed factory at Limerick for the manufacture of railway wagons, and numerous other projects, less important perhaps, but all necessary to the completion of industrial organisation, have been dropped by the Government for no good reason except that hasty decisions were taken during the first months of the Government's office and they have not now the moral courage to admit that these decisions were wrong and to reverse them.
Deputy Corry raised here yesterday the practicability of extending the steel works at Cobh. Nothing is necescessary to effect that extension to include the manufacture of steel sheets which are necessary for a number of industrial purposes, except three things —the technical knowledge, which can be procured if it is not available—it is perhaps already available—the necessary finance and the decision of the Government. In that particular case, the co-operation of outsiders is not necessary. The industry is controlled by the Government under a board composed of civil servants. Why there has been the long delay in extending activities at Haulbowline, I am unable to understand.
In the textile field we know that the whole industry of weaving woollen goods and the spinning of woollen yarn was incomplete without the wool combing plant which had not yet been established before the last war and which is not established yet. In the other branches of the textile industry, cotton spinning, although a beginning was made in 1947 at Athlone, is still completely inadequate to maintain activity in the weaving mills.
In almost every industrial field there is some critical gap which must be filled before the industries in that field can continue to operate in circumstances in which supplies from abroad may be cut off or curtailed. The most important gap of all is in the chemical industry. We had, in recognition of the importance of the industrial chemical industry, enacted the legislation here in 1947 to establish, under Government auspices, a company, Céimicí Teoranta, specifically charged to facilitate the establishment of that industry and particularly to undertake the commercial researches necessary to enable decisions to be made as to the most practicable methods. I have mentioned here in the course of the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce that the total expenditure shown in the accounts of that company during the past financial year on that important aspect of its responsibilities was £600. That, however, is not the only field in which preparations are possible.
We entered the last war period with no shipping organisation capable of carrying on a regular service for ships over deep waters. We built up that organisation during the war and it was invaluable to the people of this country. For a period of three years no foreign ship entered our ports from across the Atlantic or from other distant countries. Before the end of the war, or shortly after it, the Government then in office took a decision that the fleet of Irish Shipping, Limited, should be extended to the size regarded as the minimum necessary to carry the essential imports of this country in circumstances in which other ships would not be procurable. That policy has also been reversed. The ships which were ordered in pursuance of it have been delivered. No new ships have been ordered since. During the last war our experience was that the only limiting factor in procuring essential food supplies was our ability to carry them in our own ships. Up to the end of hostilities, while a large part of the world was shut off from its normal sources of supply by military action, the supplies were procurable easily enough. The only restriction upon their delivery here was our capacity to provide shipping.
After the end of the war, that situation changed. With the opening up of Europe and the revelation of the appalling conditions that existed in many European countries, the demands upon the available supplies increased and, naturally, the proportion available to us was curtailed. Shipping became available but the supplies were not there and it was in that period after the war that we encountered our most acute difficulties. It seems to me to be wise policy at the present time to take that decision made in 1945 or 1946 to build up the Irish deep sea fleet to the size then decided to be the minimum size which would protect our interest and secure our minimum requirements in time of war, and to get on with it. We cannot purchase ships as one can purchase a pair of boots simply by going into a store and selecting them. Ships cannot be built in any short period in the present state of the market. If there is to be a recognition of the need for the expansion of our deep sea fleet then action to order the construction of ships must be taken at once. Also, I think we should take more positive steps to develop ship building here. Now, that is going to involve Government assistance in some form. Ship building was undertaken here in the past and undertaken successfully. There is a book available by a former chief engineer of the Dublin Dockyard Company, a gentleman named Smellie, which is well worth reading. The directors of the shipyard companies have repeatedly assured me that they are fully equipped to undertake the building of ships of up to a certain size and that the only things they require are orders for the ships and Government assistance in procuring certain scarce materials.
Comment on this
Up to the time I ceased to have responsibility in connection with these matters, these dockyard companies were fully employed upon ship repairs and overhauls. It would have been a waste of resources to have diverted their activities to ship building when they could make a larger tonnage available to us by continuing and extending their repair work. I did, however, intimate on behalf of the Government of which I was a member, at a function under the auspices of the Port and Docks Board in 1947, that we were most anxixous that the ship-building end of dockyard work should be developed and undertook, on behalf of the Government, to provide, if necessary, a tonnage subsidy on the lines of that operated in Australia, if it was required in order to get that development under way.
The extension of the activities of Bord na Móna is another advantage which we have now and which we had not in 1938. But it is necessary to recognise that the total output of Bord na Móna would be inadequate to maintain essential transport and industrial activities in circumstances in which no other fuels were available and that there are still a number of problems—mainly administrative problems but some technical ones—to be solved before the Bord na Móna product can be economically utilised for transport purposes and for some industrial purposes. We never, in the last war, got to the stage where we had an output of turf adequate to enable it to be used for the production of town gas, and the maintenance of gas output was continued with considerable difficulty by diverting to that purpose a high proportion of the very limited coal supplies which were procurable. It is desirable, however, that the work of Bord na Móna should be speeded up and that, particularly, it should be encouraged to expend the funds made available to it for research purposes in the specific direction that will find solutions for these outstanding remaining problems.
Comment on this
Any assurance of that kind which I can get from the Minister or the Taoiseach to-day will be very welcome.
Comment on this
I do not want the Minister to misunderstand me. There are technical problems associated with the mechanical production of turf and also with the utilisation of turf for industrial purposes on which Bord na Móna is working. Over and above these problems there are others, which I describe as mainly of an administrative character, if that is the right word, associated with the use of turf for transport purposes and for certain industrial purposes. I do not think it was stated that these particular problems were having the urgent attention of Bord na Móna.
Comment on this
And not only that, if the Deputy will allow me, but the special engineers of Córas Iompair Éireann have made considerable progress towards the design of a locomotive which will burn turf. Córas Iompair Éireann are also, so I am informed, concentrating to see if they can find a solution for the difficulties of transport.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear it. Without encroaching too much upon the time available to me I want to refer briefly to one other problem which is bound to become acute if the international situation should deteriorate. It is a problem which was not as serious in the last war as it is likely to be in another. I refer to the methods by which such supplies as may be available abroad can be financed. The House is aware that by arrangement made with the British Exchequer in 1938 we were able to procure during the whole period of the war foreign currencies, particularly dollars, to sufficient extent to finance the purchase of all the goods we were able to get. That arrangement worked from our point of view very satisfactorily. The position of the British Exchequer is different now from what it was then. Our own position is different. It is possible that unless some special arrangements are made we might find ourselves in circumstances in which, even with supplies available and ships to carry them, we would have a financial problem in obtaining them and I think it is unlikely that a solution of that difficulty can be found easily or found quickly in the event of the emergency developing rapidly. In these circumstances we would like to be assured that the Government have that aspect of the matter also under consideration.
In the course of a speech recently the Taoiseach said that the Government were realistic enough to understand that if an emergency was likely to develop the country should be prepared for it. We want evidence of that. We got no evidence of it in the speech yesterday of the Minister for Defence. I am sure even the Taoiseach will realise that a realistic approach to our defence problem cannot be made on the basis of bluff and false figures, and that if there is to be in the field of defence, in the field of finance or in the political field a realistic approach to the preparations required, it must be based upon accurately ascertained facts.
This Government have got an advantage which their predecessors had not got in similar circumstances. There is no political problem facing them in making preparations against a possible emergency, no problem in the spending of money upon these preparations because they are being urged to do it by the Opposition. When we were taking steps of a preparatory kind in a similar situation in 1938 there were many Deputies then in opposition who were urging that those steps were unnecessary, that they were a waste of money, even a political stunt. The record shows that the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce was opposed in 1939 on a motion to refer back, on the specific ground of objection to a decision taken to store wheat against a possible emergency.
We had to carry through such preparations as we considered necessary against that political opposition and it must be confessed that to some extent the adequacy of these preparations was curtailed by our knowledge of the political hostility which they might incur.
This Government have not any such handicap. We assure them that any practicable and sensible measures which they take in that direction will have our approval and support. We promise them that if it fortunately proves in the event that these preparations were unnecessary, that the money was spent as an insurance premium is often spent without any ultimate need for it, we will not criticise them on that account. If they find themselves with a stock of coal in the Park or a stock of turf somewhere else over and above the immediate requirements of the situation when the crisis has passed, we will be glad of it because it will show that the preparations they made were at least adequate. They can, therefore, approach this problem—and it is a grave problem—in the knowledge that it involves no political risks or difficulties.
I cannot understand why we have this indecisive, dilatory attitude; why, instead of announcements on policy, we get the rather fatuous statement we had by the Taoiseach at Mullingar and the extraordinarily dishonest statement made yesterday by the Minister for Defence. I hope the position of the Government will be made clear and that the national interests will be served by the statement the Taoiseach will make when he is concluding this debate.
Comment on this
The thing that is worrying people at the moment more than anything else is this tendency to drift, drift, drift. In so far as there are favourable circumstances at the moment, of course you get some benefit from the drift, but the trouble about all drift is that it is uncontrolled and that it can bring you into circumstances from which you will find it difficult to extricate yourself. It is true at the moment that economically, in regard to cattle prices, the general trend of circumstances is such that our drift does not hurt us. These circumstances are such that benefits accrue.
But, what about the other side of the picture? Even on the agricultural side of the picture, to a Deputy like me, listening to what is said on all sides of the House, listening to the criticisms of Deputies who support the Government, it is patently clear, even from the narrow economic point of view, that things are not as well in regard to the over-all picture as they might be.
From the consumers' point of view in the towns, what is the position? A Government which would even sacrifice preparation for a possible emergency to work on the hypothesis of peace, which alleges it is working on the basis of peaceful economics to cut the cost of living and make life easier, a Government like that, drifting without a positive policy, what has it to say?
The latest returns are illuminating. Even the organ which supports the Government so strongly, in June of this year—3rd June, to be accurate— has an editorial on the cost of living. Here is what it said:—
"The point is of major consequence, because the present Government will be judged mainly by its success or otherwise in bringing down the cost of living."
What has happened in regard to the cost of living? About the same time the Government Information Bureau produced its statistics, the situation was such that apparently an explanatory note was necessary in regard to the cost of living. The cost-of-living figure was up in spite of promises. Why was it up? It was up simply because the drift was allowed to go on and nothing was done. They were hoping for the best and drifted. What is the result? The result simply is this:—
"The increase of two points between mid-February and mid-May, 1950, is accounted for by
(a) Changes in the prices of potatoes and eggs which, when corrected for seasonality, account for a rise of almost one point and of three-fifths of a point respectively;
(b) increases in the prices of cooking apples, bacon and coffee, which are responsible for approximately one-seventh, one-twelfth and one-sixteenth of a point respectively;
(c) increases in clothing prices, which account for a rise of just over one-fourth of a point.
Normally, there is a seasonal increase of about 8 per cent. in the price of potatoes between February and May, but on this occasion there has been an increase of 34 per cent., while in the case of the price of eggs the decrease in the interval in question has been 6 per cent. as compared with the normal seasonal drop of 16 per cent."
This then goes on to say:—
"The increases were offset to some extent by a decline in the prices of milk which, when corrected for seasonality, account for a fall of approximately one-sixth of a point, and of biscuits of approximately one-seventh of a point."
It then goes on to point to increases in the prices of clothing. What I have quoted is a statement by the Government Information Bureau and it appeared in the newspapers of 3rd June last. I think it will also be found in the Trade Journal.
Now, there is the situation and not-withstanding a long answer to a question which the Taoiseach gave here some time previously and in which he purported to show that the cost of living had gone down, it is clear on these figures that it had gone up. But you do not need figures to show that. You have only to ask the ordinary housewife about the position, about the price of bacon, and eggs around Christmas time, and most prices to-day. At any time you can pick a particular commodity. Take oatmeal, or take any commodity which is causing difficulty now and the net result is an over-all rise in the real cost of living.
It is particularly interesting from the point of view of milk. There was a decrease so far as milk is concerned, but even that was not an unqualified benefit to the community, because you have only to hear what the farmers are saying about milk to realise where you are in regard to that.
It is a peculiar coincidence that precisely on the day that the statement was reported in the newspapers there appeared in the same newspapers the report of a meeting of the Housewives' Association where the Minister for External Affairs, with his usual differing views when he speaks apart from the Government, made an apology and suggested action. The general tone of his statement was that nothing was being done, but on this particular occasion, since he had responsibility of Government, he said to the housewives: "Go and do it yourselves." A report was produced by that organisation where it was stated that "the hope that the cost of living would show a downward trend this year had been shattered in recent months." The report further stated that "small reductions on such items as subsidised flour, sugar, biscuits, margarine and soap did not compensate for the 10 per cent. to 33 per cent. rise in prices of oatmeal, bacon, eggs, potatoes, as well as gas, turf, and many items of clothing and footwear."
All that is outside the Government's device of an off-the-ration rise in the cost of living. Certain commodities, such as tea and even flour, can be had beyond a certain quantity if you pay luxury prices for them. Now, in all this we realise—any sensible man realises—that there are difficult problems for any Government. There are difficult problems of balance. Anybody coming into this House and listening to the debate on the Department for Agriculture and on the Taoiseach's Estimate or on the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce can easily see that there are difficult problems of balance to be met. One can honestly and freely admit that a Government cannot work miracles; one can honestly and freely say that whatever solution is found it will be possible to criticise it. But the serious thing is that the Government—with apparently the elements within it neutralising each other—are simply drifting, letting the economics of the community be dictated by the over-all trend of events, by the currents in which the economics of this country are floating. That is a serious thing; it is a dangerous thing. Even though the cattle prices trend is favourable and we are getting the benefit, the serious consequences of the unfavourable aspects of the drift are another matter and nothing is being done to correct that.
That leads one very logically to consider where all this drift is bringing us and it is from that point of view, the point of view of prudent fore-thought, with the lessons of the last emergency before us, that some of us have found it necessary to point out the dangers of the present situation. It has not been a pleasant task for anyone to see the gloomy side, but with a Coalition Government, with its inherent weaknesses and its Ministers talking with divers voices on fundamental matters, with such differing views in the past as those held by the Minister for External Affairs, the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Defence, with all these combined in a Government at a period when we are facing conditions that may very well lead to another emergency, it is necessary for somebody to point the moral.
The Minister for Defence came in here yesterday and tried to pretend that we were raising this matter as a scare, that we were trying to panic the country. The truth is that for two years many of us have been quietly trying to bring this aspect to the Government's notice without either alarming people or stressing the matter unduly. I ask any dispassionate Deputy to take up the records of the debates on the Estimates for 1948 and 1949 and see if my statement is not correct. But such representations, such suggestions, went completely unheeded and the drift was allowed to continue, while in the mean-time the world situation continued to deteriorate.
It was necessary to draw attention to these facts and now it might be opportune to deal with some points in regard to the Minister for Defence on this Estimate. The Minister for Defence, so far as I can see, was imported into this debate for two purposes. One was to attract the question of debate on defensive measures into a narrow discussion of Army strengths and the other was apparently to make the accusations and the irresponsible statements that only the Minister for Defence can make.
Let me deal with the first. Fundamentally, as was pointed out on other Estimates, in facing a possible defence crisis there arises the question of feeding our people, making sure that the supply aspect is catered for. This has been already referred to on the relevant Estimates. There is largely in that a question of co-ordination and so far as one can see no positive action has been taken by the Government.
The next aspect has been adverted to by Deputy Lemass, the industrial and supply aspect, and the problem of communications. Yesterday was the very first time any indication was given —and it was given by the Minister for Defence—that any of these problems was considered at all. He said that sub-committees were set up and that legislation was prepared. You want more than preparatory legislation. All the lawyers' clauses in Bills, all the paper that can be accumulated in Departments will not feed one single individual if you do not take concrete and practical steps in conjunction with your legalistic planning——
Comment on this
Or all the talk, either, I agree. What we want is some guide to definite action towards the end desired. Now that is what the Minister for Defence told us in regard to that matter.
Another matter that has been adverted to is the protection of the civilian population in a city such as Dublin and in the densely populated areas in this city. Out here on the lawn a deep shelter was demolished, and other shelters were recently demolished too. Shelters are only a minor part of the scheme but some organisation is necessary to ensure that in densely populated areas problems of hospitalisation, the care of the sick, the evacuation of children, the adequate feeding of infants and kindred problems are dealt with. We found out in the last war that these things have to be adequately planned and catered for in advance. That is a problem of co-ordination. These problems are not the sole responsibility of any one particular Department. There is a dovetailing between all the Departments very often involved in this and, as far as one can see, there is nothing being done. There was a token Vote for A.R.P., or something like that, and anybody who knows the value of money will see how far that will go to do anything. Now there is some suggestion about being ready with all our emergency services. What attention have our Red Cross got? What is the position of the Red Cross at the moment? They will tell you that they are rather perturbed about the situation and they are neither getting a hearing nor facilities to fit them for the job for which they would be needed in such circumstances.
Now these are the generalities of the Minister for Defence. I think it is time, with your permission, to inform the Minister specifically of some of his misrepresentations. I want to ask the Taoiseach why is there a consistent exaggeration and misrepresentation that the Defence Forces which we have available are greater than they are? I know the Taoiseach made a mistake in Mullingar and I can understand the nature of the mistake in citing the establishment, as he did, instead of actual strength. I am not for the moment putting him in the same category as the Minister for Defence. But why does the Minister for Defence consistently and erroneously exaggerate and misrepresent the figures relating to his own Department where it is his responsibility to be correctly informed? Even if it was merely a mistake, then one would expect the error to be now one way, now the other; but the error is always in the direction of tending to exaggerate and represent to the people that all is lovely in the garden when it is not.
I take up this morning's papers and I find in the Irish Times,—and notice it is the Irish Times; the Taoiseach has good reason for remembering the Irish Times on the particular issue of the Republic of Ireland Bill and so forth —this headline: “Dáil told there is no shortage of trained men.” It is the Independent, of course, which has the statement that there are 40,000 men and 2,000 trained officers, and if anything can be taken from these figures it is simply that there are 42,000 troops available. The regular Army on his own figures is less than 8,000. His First Line Reserve less than 6,000. The last figure he gave on his Estimate for the F.C.A. is 21,500. It adds up to less than 35,500, and that includes the officers. That is very substantially less than 42,000. One would imagine that that type of error would not go on.
There is another matter in that regard where the Minister for Defence has been exaggerating and misrepresenting his figures. He talks about the men who were available during the emergency. There were a number of men who were demobilised after the emergency but many of them have gone out of the country and, in any event, the men who were of the optimum age in 1940 are older now and, in particular, the officer class of those days is ten years older now. It is not a pleasant thing to have to advert to these things. The trouble is that the Minister for Defence comes in here to make these representations and ensures that in the Press sympathetic to the Government these representations are publicised to all and it is, therefore, necessary to correct them. Another favourite little misrepresentation of the Minister's is that he was budgeting for the same Army as we were budgeting for. You have only to take up the debates where on his own admission he budgeted for 1,000 less and in any event, as was pointed out before, this Party when it was in office, had planned to build up to the establishment. His first act was to cut it and to budget for something lower.
Now the Minister for Defence came in yesterday with something that was rather different from his usual tone. Heretofore he had constantly invited us to look for information. He would hide nothing. Deputies had only to ask the question and any information that was there would be at our disposal. Yesterday he starts complaining that we should not be asking for information of this sort at all. Where are we with the Minister for Defence? Where is the Taoiseach with the Minister for Defence?
Comment on this
I wish the country were as happy because here is the difficulty. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Defence have pronounced a policy of neutrality for this country. To quote the Minister for Defence himself on it, in which he links himself with the Taoiseach, he said—I think it was on the debate on the Defence Forces (No. 2) Bill this year: "Those who have brains to understand words can read into that sentence what our policy and outlook is; that is, as things are, we have to rely on our own strength to hold this island against anyone who may be an aggressor," and he expanded on that on another occasion. Very well. In all the circumstances of the particular case, the Taoiseach can make a case for his policy. But it is all right to pronounce a policy. What are you doing to make it a reality? It is all right to say that you stand for a policy of neutrality and, again, to quote the Minister for Defence, to rely on your own strength to hold this island against anyone who may be an aggressor. But what are you going to do about it? You cannot do it overnight. What are we doing, for instance, to deal with the question of feeding our people and ensuring that our people are fed if such a crisis should arise so that we can produce the necessary foodstuffs at home and obviate any shortages arising from restrictions on the importation of foreign food? What are we doing about fertilisers, what are we doing about industries, what are we doing about power and the protection of power, and about civil defence?
Comment on this
It would be a good thing to build them and to fill them. But what are we doing about all these things? These are all positive necessary and concrete steps which must be taken to make any policy of neutrality a reality, to make it mean something more than words. The Government has not stated what it is doing in regard to them. It has a sacred duty to make sure that it will be in a position to implement what it says. There could be no greater betrayal of a people than to make protestations and leave them to feel that things were all right, and then fail in preparation, leaving them naked and open should an emergency come upon them. There could be no greater betrayal, I say, than to lull them with such promises and leave them open to dictation and want in circumstances when the need for implementing the promises arose.
Comment on this
They need to be given a chance to do what they did before in circumstances such as we are talking about. One has cause to be anxious. Up to recently one simply felt that the Government was drifting, and just did not want to face up to this problem. We had great hopes when they started the recruiting drive last Christmas to build up the Regular Army. They did get 1,000 men or more. We did think that we had seen signs at last, and we were prepared to applaud them for that.
The Regular Army takes a very big place in this picture, because we are a small country, in training defence personnel and because everything has to be built up on it. The nucleus there must be sufficient to do that. We thought we saw signs, but, after the Minister's Estimate was passed, the recruiting stopped. The later figures that we have got reveal that, while the recruiting drive got us 1,000 men or more, the Minister, as soon as his Estimate was passed, stopped the recruiting drive, and relied merely on the dribble that was coming in so that the strength remains static, and indeed is still well below establishment.
It is a disheartening situation, and one wonders. Now, coming to the question of the figures, the Minister for Defence suggests that he cannot get the men, that it would mean taking men out of employment. I answered the Minister for Defence on that before. Nobody suggests that you should mobilise your reserves at the moment. All we ask is that the reserve should be there and trained, the First Line Reserves and the F.C.A. and, if necessary, to build up the First Line Reserve as we did before the last war. Remember that, as regards the Regular Army and the Reserves, we are in a much worse position than we were in 1939. In 1939 we had approximately 20,000 First Line, that is between the Regular Army and the First Line Reserve, available for mobilisation, and 19,000 mobilised. According to the Minister's figures, we have now only about 14,000 between the Regular Army and the First Line Reserve. Even though we got through on the last occasion providentially, many of us thought that the number we had was insufficient.
There is also the F.C.A. numbering about 21,000. They are wanted for their own jobs and will not be available for mobilisation. In any event, they are not trained, a large number of them, in the first line sense, so that the Minister's representations in that regard are completely misleading. The Minister for Defence, as I have said, talks about 42,000 being available, but that number would include the F.C.A. and would not be sufficient. The question one has to ask is, what does it all mean and why was the Minister for Defence brought in here, as he was yesterday? Why, as Deputy Lemass asked, is the Government so hesitant in this regard? Is it that the Minister does not believe in this policy? We cannot but reckon with the fact that here we have a Minister who said before the last war, in March, 1939:—
"As I said, I subscribe to the view that neutrality, no matter how desirable, is not to be expected in the next world war, except on the basis of our givinig up selling a pig or a sheep or a bullock or an egg to any outside country. We cannot afford to do that. We have got to face up to the fact that we are going to sell more of our agricultural produce during a war than ever we would sell during peace times; that we are going to get bigger prices and sell more. I agree with the Taoiseach that that—even if there were no other reason—is going to involve us in the war."
That is what the Minister for Defence said in March, 1939, as reported at column 2227, Volume 74. Again, he said after the last war had started that he was never a firm believer in the feasibility or benefits of neutrality, and went on to say:—
"I was prepared to adopt it and to support it, however, as the policy that appealed to the vast majority and that at all events it was worth trying, but if the first result of it is to pile up costs, to panic the people, to interfere with the lives of the people in every second home and to mobilise an unlimited man-power against unknown and invisible dangers, then I think that we require to know a lot more about neutrality, its implications and its responsibilities, than we have been told so far in this Assembly."
These statements were made by the Minister for Defence before the last war and almost immediately after the last war had started—in September, 1939. In addition to that, when one reads what the Minister for Defence said on his own Estimate with regard to his difficulties and the feasibility of neutrality, one wonders exactly what the Minister for Defence is thinking. Why is the Government so slow to take prudent precautions here? No one is asking them to panic, but we are asking them to take certain prudent precautions that will not upset the economics of the community. They could, as Deputy Lemass has said, do that without any political repercussions. For two years we kept relatively quiet on the matter to give the Government every chance of facing up to the position. In every debate and on the Minister's Estimate, there was a constructive and a reasonable approach to it. I make that remark and ask to be judged by the records on this, in my own regard anyhow, and in regard to the people on this side of the House.
What then is the hesitancy, what is the delay and what is the explanation for such delay within a Government composed of people who, in the past, have expressed views such as Deputy MacBride, the Minister for External Affairs, and Deputy Dillon who was expelled from the Fine Gael Party during the war for his views on defence, because they could not face up to it politically, and in view of the statements of the Minister for Defence that I have given.
That is the situation which we have to face in an unpleasant position at the present day. We hope and pray that what is feared may not come. One can ever find a few hopeful signs at the present moment, but still prudence demands that we should look to the situation as we see it. We have focussed much attention on the Regular Army in this regard because, as I have already said, it is the nucleus upon which all our defence must be organised; it is the brain and the centre from which our preparations for such an emergency must be directed.
The Minister for Defence pretends that strengthening the Army would involve taking men away from their employment. There are two answers to that and I gave them before. In the first place, we are looking only for a few thousand men. He said he could not get them. His own recruiting drive, while it was on, succeeded in getting 1,000 and you require only a few thousand more to get the Army up to establishment. If you allow things to drift, as they are drifting, you will not get even sufficient recruits to obviate wastage. Go out to the people, make your drive and you will get all you want. You already got 1,000 in a few months. Then as regards the pool of employment, your own unemployment and the figures in regard to emigration are an answer to that. The few thousand that would go into the Defence Forces would make no difference to the pool available. Is it not foolish to suggest that getting a few thousand young men into the forces is going to restrict the number available for employment elsewhere? Why, then, is some attempt not made to strengthen the Defence Forces? The sad part of the situation is that so much could be done while time is left to us. Some Deputies, for instance, Deputy Collins on the Estimate for the Minister for Defence, raised other questions but our happy position is that it is not necessary to resolve the problems posed by Deputy Collins to make certain important preparations to meet the crisis if it should come. No matter on what hypothesis you face the crisis, our people will have to be fed and arrangements will have to be made for that purpose.
Comment on this
Do you not think, apropos of what I said on the Estimate for Defence, that it is a matter we should not discuss in this Assembly?
Comment on this
Deputy Collins can make his own speech. The point I want to make, and it is an important point in all seriousness, is that it is not necessary to be distracted or to face up to certain other problems that are there in order to tackle the question of defence. Important and urgent as the problem of Partition is, or as the problem which the Deputy has raised is, under any conceivable circumstances under which we have a face a crisis, our people have to be fed and we have to organise industry up to a relatively self-sufficient standard. We have all the lessons of the emergency behind us to tell us what to do in that regard. The chemical industry and other matters were mentioned. All these things could be considered and action taken. In regard to the more narrow aspect of defence, civil defence, catering for evacuation, medical services and emergency services—all these could be adequately organised and prudent, though not extravagant, preparations made in their regard in advance without being stultified by the necessity for making a decision on the lines indicated by Deputy Collins.
In respect to the Defence Forces, whether we are involved or not, this country will have to be garrisoned. Whether we are neutral or not, local protection will have to be supplied. Even if you were involved, it would still be desirable that our own troops should discharge that essential duty of garrisoning our own country. That entails the organisation and development of a Defence Force to meet any situation that we can conceivably contemplate. For that reason I would press the Taoiseach to take this problem of co-ordination in hand. One has a good deal of sympathy with the Taoiseach facing such a problem. It is an extremely difficult problem for any Taoiseach, particularly the Taoiseach of a Coalition Government and, unfortunately, even in the last year the situation into which we are drifting has not improved. The warnings are there for us. We can do a great deal to prepare ourselves to survive. If we do not prepare ourselves to survive, we run a serious risk.
I could conclude with this but I know we are again going to be accused of scaremongering. Prudent preparations, not extravagant preparations, are possible. At the end of the period of office of the last Government, so far as the Department of Defence was concerned, I can with personal knowledge tell the House, as ex-Ministers have already told the House, that a basis was laid which needed only to be implemented that would go a long way towards solving part of the problem.
Deputy Lemass has dealt with the problems such as they were from the point of view of supplies and much could be done in that regard too. The ground was laid in advance. In regard to agriculture, our experience was that a balanced tillage policy such as was put into force in 1937, 1938 and 1939 was likely to be the best for us in peace and war. That too is a fortunate factor for us in an unfortunate situation. It is fortunate that in the last analysis, the type of policy that in its fundamental principles is best for a small country in time of peace also happens to be the best which we can operate in time of a threatened emergency.
All things considered, there is little excuse now for allowing things to continue to drift, especially as that drift is not giving us the benefits which we were promised or the benefits which we might hope to get. As I have already pointed out in connection with the cost of living and its trends, that drift can continue to bring us to a position where the Government would virtually deprive itself of all power of making an independent decision in the interests of the people and could do no more than bow to the inevitable in any difficulty which might arise at a later stage. These are considerations which are agitating the country and all the talk about scares, and the continued misrepresentations of the Minister for Defence, cannot alter the facts. As I have said, although I have a lot of sympathy with the Taoiseach in his difficult task, he must know that the situation now being such as it is; in this matter at least he should step out, take the lead and set a headline for us in this country to move positively somewhere and not just go drifting along in Old-Man-River fashion as we have been drifting heretofore.
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene in this debate but I must say that I was very impressed by the speech delivered by the Taoiseach yesterday.
Comment on this
May I call the attention of the Chair to the fact that time has been allocated in a certain way in this debate?
Comment on this
The Chair is aware of that and it is endeavouring to see that the agreement will be kept.
Comment on this
As I have stated, I was much impressed by the speech of the Taoiseach yesterday and by the very fine picture which he was able to present to the House of the progress of the country industrially and otherwise during the past year. When I turn to the other side of the House, I find a very different picture presented to us. We heard nothing from that side except rumours of war, war and more war. I think Deputies who indulge in talk of that kind are merely trying to terrify the people of the country. Personally I see no signs of any great emergency such as these Deputies portrayed for us. In my opinion it would be fitter for them to pray for peace and harmony amongst ourselves. That, I think, would be our best line of defence. They never seem to think of that; instead we have this continual bitterness and hatred. I think that the people of this country can confidently rely on men of the type of Seán MacEoin, Dan Morrissey and Dick Mulcahy to do all that is necessary to meet any emergency and that they should get the backing of the State in any steps they think necessary for that purpose.
Men like Seán MacEoin and the Minister for Industry and Commerce are all Irishmen, every one of them, and you can be quite sure that if the call is necessary they will make it. To listen to some of those speakers you would imagine they wanted every man in the country to join the Defence Forces to-morrow. Would it not be better to leave the men at work building houses for the country? You have people in Cork who have been living in back lanes all their lives and yet you hear all this talk about defence. It is time enough to bid the devil good morrow when you meet him.
There has been a lot of criticism of the Minister for Agriculture but I think the Minister for Agriculture is on the right lines. I heard him say in this House the other night that if the farmers of this country want to get out of the rut they are in they should get milking machines and tractors. The farmers of this country have not been treated properly in the past. They have been kept down all the time, but now they are getting a better education and are being instructed by agricultural inspectors and are doing things on modern lines.
I did not intend to enter this debate and I do not intend to delay the House but I want to compliment the Taoiseach and all the Ministers. They are all working hard, doing their job and trying to make this country a country worth living in.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach intervened on the Estimate for Public Works on Wednesday to correct "misstatements"—he said—in connection with the cenotaph and he then proceeded to quote Deputy Colley and, presumably, Deputy Colley was the only person responsible for the "misstatements".
Comment on this
No, the administration of the Board of Works arises on the Estimate for the Board of Works and this cannot be made an opportunity——
Comment on this
He has not responsibility for every Estimate. He has responsibility for over-all policy.
Comment on this
Am I not entitled to raise the question which the Taoiseach himself says is very important and of interest to the public mind, that of the cenotaph and the Garden of Remembrance?
Comment on this
He would not be allowed to answer it because the Taoiseach got up and rushed out. He had to be called back, as a matter of fact, by Deputy Smith.
Comment on this
It is obvious that we cannot allow the administration of every Department to be dragged into this Estimate. Otherwise we would have the administration of every Department discussed on this. That cannot be allowed and Deputy Colley knows that. We could not have a discussion on the Board of Works, agriculture or local government. It is overriding policy for which the Taoiseach is responsible.
Comment on this
I cannot allow Deputy Traynor to say that. The debate is not being stifled by the Chair.
Comment on this
He is not allowed to make a statement in answer to a statement made by the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Am I not entitled to raise the question of the cenotaph and of the Garden of Remembrance and Government policy? The Taoiseach on Wednesday though it so important that he actually intervened.
Comment on this
Deputy Traynor made an allegation that the debate was being stifled. Is it in order?
Comment on this
Deputy Traynor did not say that it was being stifled by the Chair. He means, I presume, that it was being stifled irregularly. I want to ask Deputy Traynor if he means that?
Comment on this
Is Deputy Colley not entitled to make a case against the case he made? In that I say it is stifling of the debate and stifling of the debate by the Leader of the Government.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach did what every Deputy is entitled to do: raise a point of order with the Chair as to whether Deputy Colley was travelling on the right lines in respect of this Estimate. The Chair ruled that Deputy Colley was not entitled to raise the administration of the Board of Public Works. Deputy Traynor said after that, that the discussion is being stifled. That surely applies to the action of the Chair.
Comment on this
On a point of order, am I not entitled to raise on this Estimate any question of public importance?
Comment on this
I am not raising the administration of the Board of Public Works; I am raising the statement of the Taoiseach's on the whole general policy of the Government in connection with it.
Comment on this
I am prepared to hear Deputy Colley on general policy but I cannot allow him to discuss the administration of another Department.
Comment on this
Deputy MacEntee cannot come into the House —because he was not present during the discussion—and ask if the Chair is going to allow the House to develop into a beargarden. The Chair has no intention of allowing the House to develop into a beargarden and such an allegation should not be made by the Deputy.
Comment on this
May I respectfully put it to you, Sir: did you hear the noise made when I rose to a point of order?
Comment on this
You did not, Sir. I am sure if you had that you would have dealt with it. It was a most unseemly noise but one which one might associate with the persons who made it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, you said that the administration of a Department cannot be dealt with on this Vote but only general policy. May I call to your attention a question which I put down on the 9th May when I received a reply from the Minister for Finance in the course of which he said:—
"At a meeting of the Government held on the 14th May, 1948, when the question of effecting economies in the Vote for Public Works and Buildings was under consideration, it was decided to defer this scheme with a number of other projects."
This matter therefore has become one of general policy on the part of the Government, I submit, and therefore it may be discussed in this debate.
Comment on this
I have ruled that the administration of every Department cannot be discussed on the Taoiseach's Estimate. The matter of general overriding policy may be discussed. Deputy Colley proceeded to deal with what is purely a matter of administration by the Department of Public Works. Deputy MacEntee rose in the House when Deputy Colley proceeded to do that—
Comment on this
May I say that Deputy Colley proceeded to deal with the statement made by the Taoiseach, not with the Estimate of the Department of Public Works?
Comment on this
That is my difficulty. He proceeded to deal with a matter which is outside the province of the Taoiseach as Taoiseach.
Comment on this
As one who was present during the debate on the Board of Works, I can say that when the Taoiseach made a certain statement and quoted from the Official Report, Deputy Colley was present and answered the statement. If he was not competent to give a proper answer, he has no right to introduce the subject now. I would have sympathy for Deputy Colley if he was not present.
Comment on this
I will hear the statement so far as I think it is relevant. Deputy Colley on the Taoiseach's Estimate.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach quoted statements of mine. The first one was:—
"The erection of the cenotaph is going ahead. Immediately the Government took office they saw to that. In fact, it looks like a deliberate attempt to try to create the whole civil war spirit."
What the Taoiseach did not do was to quote the very next sentence. He deliberately left it out. It was:—
"At the same time they abandoned the Garden of Remembrance."
Comment on this
On a point of order. Yesterday another Deputy tried to speak on a subject of great importance, namely, the subletting of land by the Land Commission. He asked to be allowed to inquire what was the Government policy on that and was ruled out of order. I cannot understand why Deputy Colley can get away with another matter when another Deputy was stopped from speaking on one of equal or greater importance.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not want to hear anything about the Garden of Remembrance or the Black and Tan war.
Comment on this
There are a few men who took an active part on the Black and Tan side sitting beside you.
Comment on this
Is it in order for Deputy McQuillan, Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Aiken to be throwing threats at each other across the House?
Comment on this
I said that if Deputy McQuillan wanted to make threats, we were not going to be threatened by him.
Comment on this
I am going to hear Deputy Colley on the motion to refer back the Estimate for the Taoiseach's Department.
Comment on this
Do Deputies McQuillan, Aiken and MacEntee intend to obey the direction of the Chair? If not, they will have to leave the House.
Comment on this
I think the R.I.C. had not very much to do with their soup when they gave it to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I will give no more directions. If the Deputies do not desist, they will have to leave the House.
Comment on this
My attitude in this matter was to criticise the action of the Government on the line they took about the cenotaph and, on the other hand, the line they took about the Garden of Remembrance. I think I made that perfectly clear, but the Taoiseach seemed to think that I misrepresented altogether the Government's attitude about the cenotaph. He went on to quote the statement I made in which I said:—
"So far as I am aware, all that the Fianna Fáil Government undertook to do was to replace the previous temporary memorial which had to be taken down as dangerous and which was put up by the former Government. They did not undertake to build an elaborate monument such as that which is being put up at the moment. I want to correct the belief which, apparently, Deputy Cowan holds about the matter."
I should like to point out, as I think was pointed out by Deputy Traynor at the time, that the key word in that statement is "elaborate". I did not object to the building of the cenotaph. I was only answering the statement made by Deputy Cowan—I forget the exact words—but it was to the effect that it was the result of the previous Government's decision.
The Taoiseach set out to give a history of the whole matter and somewhere in his statement said that Deputy Cowan was quite right and Deputy Colley was wrong. He said in that statement that on the 15th August, 1939, the former Taoiseach announced that the temporary cenotaph would be taken down as it was in imment danger of collapse and would be replaced by a more permanent memorial. After reciting certain things which happened over the following few years about designs, he told us that on the 16th September, 1947, it was decided that a new sketch design in the form of a column or obelisk should be submitted. I had better read the Taoiseach's own words so that there will be no misunderstanding:—
"Subsequently, as I have stated, on the 16th September (that is 1947) the Government decided not to go on with these plans but to have a new sketch design of a monument in the form of a column or obelisk including provision for a cross and for portrait plaques. These were then to be submitted to General Mulcahy and to my colleagues and, in fact, were also submitted. That having been done, the architects of the Board of Works were directed to proceed with the making of designs for a column or obelisk. The preparation of the new design was delayed in the Office of Public Works owing to the pressure of work on the architectural staff of the office. Mr. Raymond McGrath, the principal architect, then submitted plans and in the meantime a change of Government had taken place. Mr. McGrath submitted plans to me and to my colleagues following this decision for the erection of a column or obelisk. We approved of the present column or obelisk with some changes and additions. It will, therefore, be seen that Deputy Colley has done something which might be a great public disservice and which could have caused very great bitterness had I not taken the opportunity here to-day to correct it."
I submit that that shows plainly that the previous Government ordered the execution of a design, but that that design had never been submitted to them before they left office and that the whole responsibility for the approval of that design and the carrying out of the work is the responsibility of the present Government and not of the former Government. I cannot see, therefore, how the Taoiseach claims that Deputy Cowan was right and Deputy Colley all wrong in his statement. It was quite possible for the former Government to have changed their mind, as apparently had been done a few times earlier, with regard to the plans and designs for this memorial. I think it is very unfair that the Taoiseach should, by the whole tone of his statement and the line he took about the statement I made, try to put the responsibility on the former Government. His own words show that it was the present Government approved of the plans and carried out the work. The farthest the former Government got was the ordering of the designs.
With regard to the Garden of Remembrance, the Taoiseach said:—
"Much propaganda has been made in regard to the project for the Garden of Remembrance. Deputy Colley, in a most unworthy speech, said that we were reviving the civil war spirit because we did not proceed with that project and because we were proceeding with the memorial on Leinster Lawn. I hope we have convinced him that that is not so and that, in fact, it was his statement that was a deliberate attempt to revive the old civil war spirit."
Further on, he said:—
"This Government had never any intention to abandon the Garden of Remembrance. So far as they are concerned, that project is going ahead."—
I want the House to note those words: "is going ahead"—
"and will go ahead as soon as the Minister for Health says that he does not require these grounds any longer for the use to which they are at present being put."
The Taoiseach did not give us any further details about the Garden of Remembrance. I propose to give more details about it, as he did about the cenotaph, and I want to quote from Volume 120, column 1917 and 1918 of the Official Debates of 9th May, 1950, where, in reply to a series of questions by Deputy MacEntee about the Garden of Remembrance, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance said:—
"The proposal was initiated in September, 1935. The site is the northern part of the Rotunda Gardens and is, approximately, one and a half acres in area. The site was acquired in fee simple from the governors of the Rotunda Hospital on the 20th October, 1939, in consideration of a sum of £2,000. The decision to hold a competition for a design was taken on the 15th March, 1940. The first advertisement appeared on the 26th January, 1946, and the 31st July, 1946, was fixed as the closing date. The result of the competition was announced on the 20th August, 1946. In accordance with the published conditions of the competition, Mr. John J. Robinson, M.Arch., F.R.I.A.I., F.R.I.B.A., acted as assessor, and selected the design submitted by Mr. Daithi P. Hanly, B.Arch., M.R.I.A.I., A.R.I.B.A., A.M.T.P.I. The design comprises a sunken garden with a pool in the form of a cross, the main axis running east to west, the principal entrance laying at the east of the site and a large sculptured monument at the western end. The cost of the scheme was estimated at £23,000, but this did not include the cost of the sculpture, of which no estimate was made, pending a decision as to the actual design of this feature. The following provisions for the scheme were made in the Vote for Public Works and Buildings:—
£
1946-47 | 3,000
1947-48 | 10,000
1948-49 | 5,000
1949-50 | 10 (token)
1950-51 | Nil.
At a meeting of the Government, held on the 14th May, 1948, when the question of effecting economies in the Vote for Public Works and Buildings was under consideration, it was decided to defer this scheme with a number of other projects. There has been no decision not to proceed with the execution of the winning design. As the Deputy has already been informed, the scheme has been deferred and the temporary use of the site has been granted to the Rotunda Hospital authorities, who made urgent representations for it for infant welfare purposes."
I want to draw attention to the fact that this project had proceeded to the stage at which the whole plans had been prepared and approved, a design had been selected after public competition and, I understand, a money prize given for the best design. Provision had been made in the Estimates. The site was acquired in fee simple and was available at the time, but, on the ground of economy, according to the Parliamentary Secretary, on 14th May, 1948, a couple of months after the Government had assumed office, the work was not proceeded with. Subsequently, apparently, it was handed over to the Rotunda Hospital for children's clinics. In or about the same time, the question of the cenotaph, for which, according to the Taoiseach's own statement, a design had not yet been approved and for which £2,500 had been included in that year's Estimate, was apparently pushed forward judging by the stage it has reached, but the Garden of Remembrance, the memorial to the real founders of the State, the men of 1916, was postponed on the grounds of economy, although £5,000 had been provided in the Estimates by the former Government. Let us hear no more about the baby clinics. It was postponed on the ground of economy two months after the Government went into office. That is the statement of the Parliamentary Secretary. Subsequently, apparently to make sure that it would not proceed in any reasonable time, it was handed over, temporarily, moryah, for clinics.
Yesterday, I asked a question as follows:—
"To ask the Minister for Health if he will state the total estimated cost of the buildings now being erected on the site of the Garden of Remembrance at the Rotunda Hospital; and if he will indicate the period for which it is intended to use this site for a children's clinic."
The answer to that question was:—
"I am informed that the estimated cost of the buildings as requested by the Deputy is £39,734. It is intended to use the site for an infants' unit until the accommodation has been provided elsewhere in permanent form. Proposals, and details of preliminary planning for the erection of such buildings, on an alternative site, received from the Board of the Rotunda Hospital are under consideration in my Department."
The Taoiseach said—I drew attention to it when reading—that the project is going ahead. A site, the fee simple of which had been obtained, and which was vacant at the time; the plans, and a £5,000 provision in the Estimates, were handed over to the present Government. They decided to defer it and, to make sure that it would be deferred, they handed over the site for children's clinics that will cost practically £40,000 for temporary buildings. If the plan is going ahead and will be pushed ahead, as the Taoiseach said, is that £40,000 to be thrown to the wind? £40,000 is to be spent on temporary buildings to be pulled down in a few years. That, from the Government of retrenchment and economy. Is there anybody in this House who does not know that, even with the present high cost of building in Dublin, permanent accommodation, quite adjacent to the site, could have been secured if the Government were prepared to spend £40,000, or even a much lesser sum, for its acquisition, and the Garden of Remembrance could have been proceeded with?
Comment on this
I am going to make my own speech. Deputy Flanagan can make his, when he likes. I am not answering any interruptions from him.
Comment on this
I only addressed a question to him. Is that the same sum as was being spent on Santry Court?
Comment on this
If the Government had been prepared to spend £40,000—it is only for the cost of building, according to this reply—there is nobody but knows that much more commodious property in a permanent form quite adjacent to it and quite as convenient as these huts that are now being built, could have been secured. The Government's official attitude in statements here is their own greatest condemnation. It is quite evident. It is because it is so obvious that the people are saying and that I said that this Government looks like trying to recreate the civil war spirit. Where plans are not ready, they set out to push the memorial to the founders of a partitionist State. They had everything ready for the memorial to the men of 1916. Everything there was ready for them and they postponed it and they then took steps to see that it cannot be done, without a huge loss, in any reasonable time.
The Taoiseach in his statement here disclaimed any such intention on the part of the Government and said that was far from their minds. These may not be his exact words but that is the meaning of them. If that is so, if that aspect has never occurred to his mind before, I suggest that he has that excuse no longer, that everybody, around Dublin at any rate, has been able to see it. I suggest to him that if he is in earnest that he does not want to create that bitterness and antagonism again, he will take steps immediately to proceed with the Garden of Remembrance. Deeds will speak louder than words. We have had a lot of words from the Taoiseach, for instance, his election promises, the value of which we know. Let us have deeds, if he wants us to believe, in view of what has happened up to this, Any difficulties that there are in the way now are of the Government's own making. Let them unmake them. Then we will believe them.
Mr. Flanagan rose.
Comment on this
I am wondering how the time is going. Would it be in order to ask the Chair to give some indication to the House as to how the balance of time now remaining is to be divided as between the Government and the Opposition?
Comment on this
The Chair is endeavouring to adjust the time so that the agreement arrived at will be kept. That is the reason the Chair looks constantly almost at the Opposition side of the House. I think that is a clear indication to Deputy MacEntee of how the time is running.
Comment on this
——they are at liberty to speak, as long as they wish, whilst they comply with Standing Orders. Is not that so?
Comment on this
——that a certain number of hours was to be allocated to the Opposition. That agreement was communicated, I understand, officially to the Chair and the Chair has since been endeavouring to adjust the hours so that that would be kept. The Chair will, therefore, call on a member of the Opposition if a member of the Opposition offers himself.
Mr. P.J. Burke rose.
Comment on this
——that Independent Deputies are being debarred and prohibited, without being acquainted. I was not acquainted. We are prevented from making speeches.
Comment on this
I think there would be no trouble at all if the lame, the halt and the blind were not being put up here.
Comment on this
The Chair has no option but to call Opposition Deputies as they offer, within the terms of the agreement. If Deputies wish to repudiate the agreement, that is no concern of the Chair.
Comment on this
As a matter of principle affecting the right of an Independent Deputy to speak in Parliament, I think it is wrong and unfair.
Comment on this
May I say that I think the Chair is merely carrying out the agreement which was made and which was confirmed in the House?
Comment on this
Quite. That is so. There was agreement reached by the House and I am calling on Deputy Burke.
Comment on this
On a point of order. There was a remark made by Deputy Cowan that the lame, the halt and the blind were being put up. Are any Deputies in that category, to your knowledge?