Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).
Contributions 128–252 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I shall not allow any Deputy to misrepresent the Chair. As I said, an agreement was reached, conveyed officially to the Chair——
Comment on this
——and the House agreed. The House accepted that agreement. If Deputy Flanagan feels aggrieved, he should have made himself felt when that agreement was being reached by the House. Under that agreement, a certain number of hours is being allocated to the Opposition. The Chair is endeavouring to keep the terms of the agreement.
Comment on this
An Independent Deputy is neither Government nor Opposition and he should not be bound by any such regulation. He should not be bound.
Comment on this
When an Independent Deputy is absent, it is the fault of the Independent Deputy in not being in his place when an agreement is reached.
Comment on this
Will the House realise that the Chair cannot alter a decision of the House? Deputy Burke.
Comment on this
The people of the country, generally, are disappointed that the Government has failed completely to implement the promises they made, individually and collectively. The Government has failed completely to implement their promise that they would find employment for everybody. All they did, in that connection, was to set up a Commission on Emigration —and we hear nothing whatever about it now. Miracles were to be worked overnight but when the present Government came into office they forgot about their promises. Their short-sighted policy in regard to national development has retarded national progress. They have stymied a number of projects which the Fianna Fáil Government were endeavouring to put into operation. Does the present Government intend to carry on with that short-sighted policy in regard to this young nation? Are they going to continue to retard progress as they have been retarding it for the past 2½ years? This is a serious national matter. We are a young country with a young Parliament. Is it merely the policy of this Government, which is composed of so many different groups, to carry on, and no more? Is that just the policy? Of course, I cannot expect a great deal when I hear the members of the Labour Party, the members of the Clann na Poblachta Party, the members of the Fine Gael Party and the Independents tell us about their policy in this House. It is obvious that their policy is short-sighted.
Fianna Fáil, on the other hand, made every effort possible for the good of this country but this present Government is undoing a lot of that effort by Fianna Fáil. Take, for example, the attitude of the present Government to the tourist industry. They told us that Fianna Fáil's methods of dealing with hotels were small parish pump methods. They said the same in respect of a site that was taken over for a hotel. What, therefore, could one expect in the way of national progress from a Government of that type of mentality? The answer, very obviously, is, nothing. The short-sighted policy of the Government of slowing down development and misrepresenting facts is bringing the running of this country to a standstill. Of course, when they go out and talk to the people of the country they are very glib; so glib that they are capable of misrepresenting facts. The Government has now an opportunity of following in the footsteps of Fianna Fáil, if they want to, and carrying on with the work of national development which was started by Fianna Fáil. That work was put on a sound foundation with a good deal of foresight and understanding and, taking the broad national view, in the long run it is the only policy for the development of our country.
Before the present Government came into office circulars were issued in connection with unemployment by the then Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Norton, who is now the Tánaiste and Minister for Social Welfare. He was critical of the number of people who were leaving this country year after year. He was going to stop emigration overnight. He had a plan and everything was ready to put it into operation. What, in fact, happened? All we got was the establishment of the Commission on Emigration. The Government has been in office now for the past two and a half years and we fail to see any national advance in that respect. Our people are still emigrating and, in particular, they are emigrating from rural Ireland. The policy of the present Government has had the effect of expediting their exit from rural Ireland. The policy of the Minister for Agriculture is slowly killing tillage farming in this country and trying to put the tillage farmers out of existence. That policy is being pursued by the Minister for Agriculture in spite of the lip service which was paid over the years to the tillage farmers by people who are now supporting the present Government. Fianna Fáil encouraged the tillage farmers of Ireland in their work and, because our tillage farmers are not now getting the encouragement they deserve, the industry is failing.
There has been a great deal of misrepresentation of the Fianna Fáil Government in respect of air development. We were told that Deputy Lemass, the then Minister for Industry and Commerce, was a spendthrift Minister. My God, are we so blind that we do not realise the importance of progress? Do we want to go back again to the donkey and cart? The Government misrepresented the work of Fianna Fáil in respect of air development in general, in respect of the purchase of Constellation aircraft and in respect of our sound outlook on the development of our airports. When you hear public representatives referring to that, what can you expect in the way of national progress? The roads, from a national and international point of view, are essential, but they are far behind what they should be in repair.
Comment on this
Every industrial project for development that we tried to carry on, taking the long national view of things, was grossly misrepresented by the Parties making up the present Government. If that outlook is persisted in, we will go backwards instead of forwards. It looks like that, considering the statements made by Ministers and their lieutenants. In every line of Government policy, they remind me of the old farmer who had been digging the garden, when his son brought in a tractor. The father said it would destroy the ground and that he would go back to the methods of his grandfather. Deputy Cowan and his colleagues are anxious to carry on in the same old way. They seem to be devoid of an interest in national development and progress and a good strong national view. They are going back to the methods of their grandfathers, but I hope there will be a change to enable the country to carry on with a good national policy.
Comment on this
I intervene for the purpose of——
Comment on this
The Taoiseach put the agreement before the House and the House made the Order. The Chair cannot of itself change an Order of the House.
Comment on this
I submit that no one has authority to enter into an agreement on behalf of Independent Deputies.
Comment on this
I claim that it is not on the Order Paper and that, as I am an Independent Deputy, I have a right to speak.
Comment on this
The House made the Order which the Taoiseach proposed. It is not necessary to put it on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
I wish to bring to the Taoiseach's notice what might be regarded by him as a matter of insignificance but which I regard as very important, from the point of view of the restoration of the language, which was mentioned in this debate by a few speakers yesterday. I have been trying to induce the Minister for Finance to undo his action in following the economic policy with which he started off. The action has had serious repercussions in regard to an undertaking started at the end of 1946, the Place Names Commission. It was suggested —I hope it is true—that we are all here at one regarding the necessity to take steps to ensure the restoration of the Irish language eventually as the spoken tongue of the Irish people.
This Place Names Commission was established, after a good deal of delay, to compile proper lists of place names all over the country, giving them their Irish form, having them on record for all time, and putting them into official use in their proper Irish form. I will read the statement made by Deputy Aiken when Minister for Finance when he introduced the Supplementary Estimate for this purpose, as given at Volume 104, column 1227 of the Official Debates for the 25th February, 1927:—
"This Supplementary Estimate is required to provide for the expenses of the Commission on Place Names for which the amount concerned is £1,072.
The Commission on Place Names consists of a salaried director and 15 unpaid members, of whom one is chairman. Their task is to institute a comprehensive investigation into the original Irish forms of Irish place names and to authenticate and record them for publication and official use. This will involve an examination of all the published work on Irish place names down to and including townland areas, as well as investigations and researches in unpublished manuscripts and elsewhere. I should explain, perhaps, that this matter had been under consideration by the Government for some time before the war but action was suspended at the beginning of the emergency. It is obviously desirable that the work should not be further deferred. The Government are much interested in the work and they are very grateful to the eminent gentlemen who consented to act on the commission. The success of their efforts will be no small contribution to the Gaelicisation of our people and should prove of considerable importance in awakening a fuller appreciation throughout the country of the historical background of the nation. As somebody has said, our place names record not only historical events but the whole social life of our ancestors."
In passing, I might mention that when the Vote was put to the House there was a division. It was opposed by the then Opposition, for reasons stated at the time, not connected with the subject of the Supplementary Estimate.
When Deputy McGilligan became Minister for Finance, he decided as an economy to suspend the work. A great deal of preliminary work had already been done when the suspension was enforced. Work had been done in eight counties of the 32 and the machinery had been prepared to continue it in the other counties. The proposition was that the work would be completed in five years and that all our place names would have been saved from extinction. A good deal of the obscurities that exist with regard to the meaning of certain place names would have been cleared up and the work would have been completed at a cost altogether of between £25,000 and £30,000. That was the amount estimated. It was a tragedy that that work was held up more or less in the middle of it.
There was a body of men, very distinguished in the cultural life of the country, who had consented to act. The chairman was Pádraig Ó Siocfhradha. There were also Risteárd Ó Foghludha, stiúrthóir; an tAthair Tomás de Bhall, S.P., Canónach; an tAthair Eric Mac Fhinn, an tAthair Pádraig Mac Giolla Cheara, D.D., S.P., Canónach; an Cornal Niall Mac Néill, an Dochtúir Séamus Ó Ceallaigh, Seorsa Ó Ceallaigh, an tAthair Mícheál Conalláin, S.P.; Séamus Ó Dubhghaill, Mícheál Ó Duigeannain, Séamus Ó Duilearga, an tAthair Pádraig Ó Fearghail, an tAthair Donnchadh Ó Floinn, an tAthair Eoin Ó Riain, C.I., and Seán Ó Súilleabháin. Tomás Ó Muircheartaigh was secretary to the commission. They were as distinguished a body of people as could be got together, distinguished in regard to their work for the restoration of the language. Some of them I know personally have spent their lifetime at it.
In view of the reorientation in regard to the economy proposal which has since taken place, I now appeal to the Taoiseach—it is a matter for the Government, as the commission was established by the previous Government—to have the suspension on that body removed and to get it working again to complete the important national work that it had undertaken. The Taoiseach was approached about this matter before and did not show himself as unsympathetic. In view of the danger of the loss that would be occasioned by further delay, as many who could be helpful in clarifying the meanings and the actual Irish rendering of these place names all over the country are passing away day by day, it is vital that this work should be put in hands again without any further delay.
In the last century, there was an effort of the kind made, but it was an uncompleted one. The great John O'Donovan was employed by the then British Ordnance Survey to do this very work I am talking about now. At that time, it was calculated that there were 144,000 names on the maps. O'Donovan had travelled the country, all over the east, west, north and south, investigating these place names and he had recorded 62,000 townlands names and satisfactorily fixed them, when in the year 1842 the then British Government unexpectedly stopped the grant for the Historic Department of the Ordnance Survey of Ireland and O'Donovan and his fellow labourers, just when they were prepared to arrange to give to the world the mass of materials collected with such study and investigation, were left to seek occupation elsewhere. This is a question of history repeating itself, only this time, unfortunately, it is an Irish Government that has done it. One would expect that from a British Government, but certainly it should not happen under the aegis of an Irish Government.
I appeal to the Taoiseach and urge that the Government reconsiders this matter and have the Place Names Commission called back to do the work for which it had been established. If it had been allowed to continue, it would have finished by next year. The cost would have been infinitesimal, in view of the vital importance of the work.
Comment on this
I listened to Deputy Aiken's speech. I felt it a duty to intervene as representing the fathers and mothers, and I want to assure the Taoiseach that the people, 99 per cent. of them, support him in the policy advocated by the Minister for Defence. The fathers and mothers do not want the young boys brought into the barrack squares to be forming fours as Deputy Aiken wants them. It is better to have them in the shops, on the farms and in the factories, to build up a supply of food and materials to bring us through a crisis. As the Minister for Defence pointed out, there is no need to gather them in for drilling, as we have numbers of young men already trained and they are willing to go back and fight for the country if necessary. We all know that those young boys who were in the barrack squares during the emergency have been destroyed. At the age of 20 they spent four or five years at that and their whole life career was stopped. I know these young lads joined during the emergency and ruined their lives. They were brave and good men to do it, but the Government did not treat them well. When Deputy Aiken was Minister in 1938-39, he gathered those boys in, when it would have been better, as the farmers were broken after the economic war, if he had strengthened the farmers to produce the food we required. If we had had more butter and bacon, there would not have been such a scarcity.
The Taoiseach's policy and the policy of the Minister for Agriculture is to build up the country so that in a crisis we will have fields of plenty, leaving our young people on the farms and in the factories. If the Taoiseach wants to spend money for a crisis, let him get in all the artificial manures he can and get all the raw materials into store. Let him get in fuel, not muck, for future use. That is better than gathering the boys into the barrack square. Let him get in artificial manures and give them to the farmers at low prices, to build up the fertility of the soil. As regards wheat, the better policy is that advocated by the present Minister for Agriculture. We see by the returns last year that we have more wheat out of less land than we had during the emergency. If the Government wants wheat in a crisis, the farmers will grow it without compulsion, if they are given the cost of production and a fair margin of profit. They will also grow any other foodstuff necessary. Compulsion is of no use. The farmer who tills properly is the best person. I am surprised at the Leader of the Opposition falling into the trap about militarism. He ought to have more sense in his older days. I do not mean Deputy Vivion de Valera, as I compare him to a little child playing with soldiers. He seems to have gone military mad. As I say, I do not mind him; but I am very much surprised at the Leader of the Opposition falling into the same trap and going out inveigling our young men into war. We are a Catholic country and it would be much better if we preached peace. The whole world is mad. Why not preach peace instead of putting these ideas into the heads of our young people? God knows, we had enough of it: two generations of our boys reared up to be slaughtered. Why should not we, as a Catholic nation, try to change all that? The Leader of the Opposition should change his tune. Just as I do not pay very much attention to Deputy Major de Valera, neither do I pay much attention to Deputy Aiken. There was another Deputy—I call him the "Deputy of the Voice" since I cannot remember his name. I know he comes from Tipperary.
Comment on this
He made a speech last night and he criticised our Minister for Defence because he went to foreign countries—he mentioned England—for information. Why should the Minister not go to England? Does the "Deputy with the Voice" want him to go to Soviet Russia? Where else would he go but to a neighbouring country?
Comment on this
There are friends of Soviet Russia on your own benches.
Comment on this
He criticised our Minister for Defence because he went to England to get information. If I were the Taoiseach, remembering the speech that Deputy made last night, I would bring in an emergency Order and anyone who made speeches like that I would put behind bars so that they could not lead our people astray.
I congratulate the Taoiseach on his policy. I congratulate the Minister for Defence on the speech he made here yesterday. I can tell the Taoiseach that the views I have expressed are the views of the majority of the fathers and mothers in the country and of the people as a whole.
Deputy MacEntee rose.
Comment on this
Before Deputy MacEntee speaks, might I draw attention to the fact that there was an arrangement made that business would, if possible, be finished this evening, and, if not this evening, on Tuesday. There is a very heavy programme still in front of us and I cannot see how business, which includes the very important Housing Bill, can be finished either to-night or on Tuesday.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan is under a slight misapprehension. The arrangement was that all financial business would be given to-day.
Comment on this
No. Financial business must finish to-day and, as a matter of fact, the Taoiseach said that the Housing Bill might be on Tuesday; but if it is possible to reach it to-day, it can be taken to-day.
Comment on this
Until I listened to Deputy Fagan to-day, it never occurred to me for a moment to think that he might be a member of the Comintern, and I do not think it yet.
Comment on this
I have not said that. I will say that I have no doubts Deputy Fagan is not a communist because, after all, Deputy Fagan is a big landowner and grazier.
Comment on this
Do you begrudge it to me? I have four sons for it and you will not get a perch of it. I worked and paid for it. Deputy Fagan has his land and he earned it and you do not say anything about it now.
Comment on this
Perhaps this matter might cease if Deputy MacEntee would put himself in order and confine his remarks to the Taoiseach's Estimate.
Comment on this
I am replying to the speech which has just been made. I do not believe for a moment that Deputy Fagan is a member of the Comintern, as I have already said and as he himself denies. He is obviously proud of the fact that he is an extensive landowner.
Comment on this
No, Sir, and therefore his being an extensive landowner substantiates the belief which I have that he is not a member of the Comintern.
Comment on this
I am coming to it now. The speech which Deputy Fagan has made is exactly the type of speech which the agents of the Comintern are making in every democratic State in that portion of Western Europe where there is freedom of speech. It is the Kremlin which is preaching peace at any price while it prepares for war. How they managed to get hold of and corrupt Deputy Fagan and seduce him into following the Party line in the manner in which he has done here this morning will, I suppose, remain one of the mysteries of history.
Comment on this
I heard the Deputy a little while ago, I think, complaining that a member of the House was talking too loudly.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I am sorry if I offended. I could not think of the Deputy's name, and I call him "the Deputy of the voice."
Comment on this
Certainly not, and I am not suggesting that; but I should hate if my words only registered themselves in Deputy Fagan's recollection as "a voice". I would prefer that the thoughts which I am endeavouring to express would make some impression upon his brain or upon his intelligence.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy make some impression now on this Vote? As he knows, time is pressing.
Comment on this
The matter to which I want to devote some further attention—other speakers have referred to it in the course of the debate—is the policy which the Government have pursued in relation to a projected national memorial. That policy was finally determined at a meeting of the Government held on 29th July, 1949. I do not want to be rude, but I do hope that I shall be permitted to make my speech with some consideration for the fact that it is not easy for a speaker to maintain his trend of thought and that he should not, therefore, be subjected to distractions. I was saying that the question to which I wish to refer is a matter of Government policy which was finally brought to fruition at a meeting which the Government held on 29th July, 1949, when it was decided to hand over the site which had been secured for the projected memorial to the officers and men of the Dublin Brigade to the Governors of the Rotunda Hospital. That, I think, puts the matter in order, and I trust I shall not be interrupted on points of order while saying what I propose to say now.
Yesterday, the Taoiseach made a long statement regarding a cognate project—the project for the erection of a cenotaph to honour the memories of the late Michael Collins, the late Arthur Griffith and the late Kevin O'Higgins, men distinguished in Irish history and men who had played a particularly prominent part in the events which followed the signing of the Treaty. I do not wish in any way to disparage their memory. I do not want to be taken as denying them the honour of the remembrance which is due to them for the services which they rendered to the Irish nation. I was bitterly opposed to the later development of their policies. I thought they were likely to be disastrous to the Irish people, but I knew that everything they did, they did in good faith, and, as we are all fallible men in these matters, I think that the good they did to this country entitles their memory to our honour and respect. And, therefore, it is not out of bitterness towards them, it is not because I in any way wish to condemn them, that I feel called upon to speak in this debate and refer to the statement which was made by the Taoiseach yesterday.
I would have wished that that statement had been somewhat different. I would wish that it had been a statement designed to give credit to the magnanimity and to the sense of decency of the Taoiseach's predecessors in office. Unfortunately, I think it was not designed for that purpose. It was designed to transfer to his predecessors the major share of the responsibility for a decision that was taken by the Government on the 7th May, 1948. That decision was to proceed with the erection of the cenotaph. I do not question that decision. Had I been in their place and in the Government, I should have agreed with that decision as I did when, with my colleagues, we did decide that the intentions of our predecessors in office should be honoured and that there would be erected here, on the site which had been originally chosen by our predecessors, the type of memorial which they wished to have. If we did that, some of us, for reasons which appeared good to me and all of us— knowing that there was a substantial section of our people, perhaps almost half of our people and a majority on some occasions, who would have liked to see that memorial there—we did it because, despite Party differences, we recognised that the Irish people and the Irish nation is one, and that there has to be an element of give and take in these matters; so that what is dear to one heart, not so dear to another, nevertheless might be realised in order to preserve the essential unity of our nation.
It was in that spirit that men whose brothers who had been done to death, that men who had been deprived of the right to earn a livelihood because they would not take the test under the old Free State Constitution, decided to give effect, as I have said, to the decision of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government which they had displaced in 1932. It is regrettable, and that is the reason I am raising it now, that our successors were not inspired with the same feelings, because on the 14th May, 1948, the Government decided, as has been pointed out to the House by Deputy Colley, on grounds of economy to abandon the memorial to the officers and men of the Dublin Brigade who died to maintain the Republic which had long been projected.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it in order for Deputy MacEntee to state that the Government decided to abandon a project in respect of which the Taoiseach gave an unequivocal assurance that it had not been abandoned?
Comment on this
Unfortunately, the Deputy is one of the people who make me most easily forget myself.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it in order for Deputy MacEntee to make a statement like that, which imputes to the Taoiseach making a false statement here in the House?
Comment on this
I did not conclude from the Deputy's remarks that he accused the Taoiseach of making a false statement.
Comment on this
It does not matter.
I was saying that, on the 14th May, 1948, the Government, according to a written reply which I have here, decided on grounds of economy—not because they wanted the site for any social purpose, not because there was any question of providing a clinic for children, not for any charitable or worthy object—to abandon this project. That is the conclusion to which I have been driven.
People may say that the Taoiseach has promised, at Tib's Eve, that the Garden of Remembrance will be made, but can anybody tell me in this House, in this the legislature of the Republic of Ireland, why a memorial to the men who signed the Treaty should take precedence over a memorial to the men who died faithful to the Republic?
Comment on this
We gave it no precedence; we took the matter as we found it, and when, having beaten the Blueshirts in 1935, some of us had time to devote attention to other matters, one of the first projects that we discussed was the creation here in the centre of the City of Dublin of a memorial so that every man who came to the city as a visitor or as a tourist or from the country districts, might see that Dublin had not forgotten its republican dead.
The negotiations in that matter were formally opened by me in September, 1935. They were finally closed by the acquisition of the site in October, 1939. They were four long years of difficult negotiations when, it is not unfair to say, every obstacle that could be raised in the ceding of the site was raised. It took less than four months to give that site back. We bought it and we had to pay every penny of what it was worth, and it was given back for an indefinite term at a rent of 1d. a year. In October, 1939, the war had broken out, but, despite the fact that we were then in a parlous position because we had not had time to build up our Defence Forces, we did not abandon that project. We decided in March, 1940, that we would hold a competition for the design because we thought that the subject would be an inspiration to our young artists, our architects and our young sculptors, to produce a memorial that would be worthy of the tradition and culture of Ireland. Matters got worse and we were placed in the same position in regard to the Garden of Remembrance, as that in which, as the Taoiseach has told the House, we stood in relation to the cenotaph. But, as soon as hostilities ceased in Europe, our proposals to hold a competition, in order to secure the worthiest design, were proceeded with. The competition was advertised in January, 1946. Those who have been suggesting that we did nothing during that period, mark that date.
Comment on this
Mark that date. Immediately the war was over, immediately it was possible for the artists and creators to devote themselves to the work we held the competition. The closing date of the competition was the 31st July, and so anxious were we to get ahead with the project that the result was announced on the 20th August, 1946. Those who remember the description of the memorial that was given in the House here by Deputy Colley, and which is printed in the Official Reports, will remember that it was to be a sunken garden with a pool in the form of a cross—a garden with a cross where weary feet might rest and little children play, where the youth of our city might realise at what cost their freedom had been bought and learn to honour the memory of the republican dead.
Comment on this
I do not think I ever listened to anything so nauseatingly dishonest in all my life. I shall not listen to any more.
Comment on this
Thank goodness that I have at least endeavoured to preserve the level of debate on this subject, no matter how my speech may develop later. That is the sort of memorial that we had envisaged. That is what we hoped to see in the Rotunda Gardens, which have great historical associations with the Irish nation. It was to front Charlemont House, the home of the founder of the volunteers—perhaps not a wholly worthy figure in Irish political history but still a figure of some significance. It was in the Rotunda Gardens that the Irish Volunteer Movement of 1913 had been launched. It was in the Rotunda Gardens the men of 1916 had been confined following the surrender of Easter Saturday. It had other associations as well.
It was, as I have said, in the centre of our city fronting the Art Gallery which attracts so many visitors. It was not as extensive a sight as we had wished, but it was not an unworthy site. We had hopes that there would be in that garden a worthy memorial, and that on that memorial there would have appeared some names dear to us. There would have appeared the names of the signatories to the 1916 Proclamation because they, too, were associated with the Dublin Brigade. There would have appeared the name of Cathal Brugha. There would have appeared the name of Harry Boland. There would have appeared the name of Rory O'Connor.
Comment on this
There would have appeared the name of Liam Mellowes, the name of Joe McKelvey, a townsman of my own, of Dick Barrett, and other names of men less known but their equal in courage and devotion to the republican cause. That is the sort of memorial we had hoped to erect there.
Comment on this
There are a few other names to go on that, and we shall see that they will go on it.
Comment on this
If they are worthy to take their place. I do not know who they are. If they are worthy to take their place with the names of those to whom I have referred, I hope they will go on it, but they must be in the eyes of the people of Ireland worthy to be put there.
Comment on this
I do not wish to create any bitterness, but there have been in this House suggestions that we are endeavouring to make political propaganda out of this. Would people who have been so intimately associated with this proposal as the members of this Party have been, be human if they did not resent what is done to their comrades, to their dead? The Taoiseach has told the House how his predecessors had respected the desires and wishes of those who had supported him and his colleagues. He has told you how we had been meticulously careful to consult them as to the type of design they wished. He told you that no consideration of economy, even during the period when they were telling us that the people were groaning under taxation, even when we were fighting the economic war, even when we had to deal with the menace to the peace and security of this country, prevented us from doing what we thought a large section of the Irish people wanted. Why could not our successors have honoured the memory of Cathal Brugha, of Patrick Pearse and his comrades, of Rory, Liam, Dick and Joe, in the same spirit as we were prepared to deal with their dead? That is the question that has to be answered.
If we do feel strongly on this, we feel strongly, not because we are politicians, but because we are Irishmen. These were our friends; these were our comrades; these were men with whom we had chatted and joked, with whom we had stood side by side on other occasions. It is not because we want to make petty Party political capital out of this; no, it is because we feel that it is due to the stand they took, due to the sacrifices they made, we stand here to-day, in the Twenty-Six Counties, a free and independent State, as we have stood since 1937. That is why I raise this matter and, surely to God, if bitterness has crept again into the hearts of Irishmen, if there is any attempt to recreate the old feelings of the civil war, it is being done by those who have pursued the republican dead with malevolent hatred even beyond the grave. We do not want to deny any honour to the men to whom the cenotaph is erected but, in the words of another Irishman, who died in a cause in which we did not believe but in which he thought he was fighting Ireland's battle, we, in relation to these men, "keep the past for pride". We do not keep it because we want to condemn or in any way dishonour the memory of other men. It does not matter how humble the men were whose names should be inscribed on that memorial; we will stand for their memory and venerate it and we expect any Government that purports to speak for the Irish people to give them the veneration that is their due.
I want to come to another aspect of this matter. I say that there was no occasion why that particular site should have been handed over to the Rotunda Hospital even if the establishment of a clinic of the type which has been mentioned was as urgent as has been suggested. The total area of the site now being used is, according to figures given to me, 86,800 square feet; the total floor area of the buildings is 10,431 square feet. I know that within the grounds of the Rotunda Hospital space enough was found adjacent to one side of Parnell Square to afford a site for a concert hall of very much larger dimensions. I know that the preliminary negotiations with regard to the acquisition of that site from the Rotunda authorities had reached the stage at which it, with other buildings and appurtenances, was going to be conveyed to the Government for a rent of £6,000 a year. If the Rotunda Hospital authorities have in their grounds, in their possession and under their control sufficient space to afford the erection of a concert hall, sufficient property to bring in a rental of £6,000 a year, can anyone tell me what justification they had for approaching the Department of Health and securing this site for the Garden of Remembrance in the circumstances in which they did? I cannot suggest that I can give any answer to that question, but when we remember that the Government took its first decision not to proceed with the Garden of Remembrance in May of 1948 and that the acquisition of the site for the authorities of the Rotunda Hospital was not broached, I think, until some time in February in 1949, perhaps even later, and that the Government took its decision in relation to the matter on the 29th July of 1949, it seems to me that there is a very awkward question there that the Government must answer. I say that this clinic could have been built inside the grounds of the Rotunda Hospital without taking one square foot of the site acquired for the Garden of Remembrance. With Deputy Colley, I think that even if there were not that alternative site for it inside the Rotunda, at least the Garden of Remembrance should have been regarded as sacred. Even if it would occasion the authorities of the Rotunda some little inconvenience, just as suitable a site from the point of view of the public—the people who were going to have resort to the clinic—could have been obtained somewhere else within the neighbourhood.
The Taoiseach has given us a sort of indefinite promise that we will get the site back when the hospital indicates to the Minister for Health that it has no further use for it. I would like the Taoiseach now, having had the case put before him as I have endeavoured to put it before him, not perhaps objectively but subjectively as expressing the feelings of a very great number of our people, to realise that a complete mistake has been made. Even if it does cost £40,000, £117,000,000 is being spent this year, while it is proposed to spend some £40,000 on the memorial outside and I do not know what we spent on the platform which—I cannot say "graces"—but which occupies the space in front of Leinster House. We are spending money in other ways, so surely even if that £40,000 has been earmarked for this clinic, the Taoiseach now, realising that even the members of the Opposition, even almost half the people of the Twenty-Six Counties who voted for Fianna Fáil, have a right to have their views, their feelings, considered in a matter of this kind, will decide that before this year is out alternative accommodation will be provided for this clinic and that these temporary buildings which now deface it will be removed.
The Taoiseach yesterday said something else and it is apparently going to be—I hope it is not but on reading the text of his statement one would conclude that it is intended to be—a sop to the feelings outraged by what has been done in connection with the Garden of Remembrance. He said that they were going to undertake, in addition to the Garden of Remembrance, the erection of a proper memorial adequately to commemorate the long struggle of the Irish nation for its existence and freedom. That is published to the people as if it were something that had been initiated by the present Government and as a substitute for, and in order perhaps to allay the anger and ill-feeling which has been caused by what has happened to the memorial to the Dublin Brigade. I want to say that the proposal for a national memorial was discussed by the Fianna Fáil Cabinet following the centenary commemoration of Thomas Davis and that sketch plans had been prepared for it and submitted to the Cabinet. If they had not got to this stage at which a definite decision could be taken as to the nature of the memorial, we had the project in mind and it would have been realised as soon as we had a staff available.
In connection with memorials of that type it must be remembered that not every architect has the capacity to design one. We were fortunate in having in the Board of Works one or two architects who, because of their artistic talents, their creative talents, could have provided us in the course of years, if God had spared them, with a series of memorials that would have been worthy of the Irish nation. But we can only take these things one at a time. We cannot carry on a great number of projects simultaneously. We had hoped, as soon as the Garden of Remembrance was completed and the cenotaph was completed, that we would be able to provide in some of our public places a memorial of the nature which the Taoiseach outlined in his statement yesterday.
I had some other criticisms to make on the Vote, but I prefer to confine myself to the one which I have submitted to the House. It would be wrong for me to say that I do not feel very deeply about this matter. I feel hurt; everybody on this side of the House feels hurt; but we do not wish to make it a political matter and we hope, as it has now been ventilated, the Government will see their way to meet our views in opposition as we endeavoured to meet theirs when we were the Government.
Comment on this
I should like at the outset to thank those who, in the course of their observations on this Estimate, paid tribute to the officers of the Central Statistics Office. As I have stated, that office is one that is independent in the exercise of its functions; one that is available from the point of view of the results obtained by its work for all who wish to make use of its efforts. Last night, Deputy Killilea asked me to give him some assurance as to the rights of private Deputies in reference to going to Departments. Just as every Deputy is entitled to get, and will get, from the officers of that office all the information and every facility they want, so, in reference to every other Department of State, every Deputy will get the same facilities, irrespective of the Party to which he belongs or does not belong.
In opening the Estimate, I gave what was hoped to be a reasonably objective outline of the economic and financial policy of the Government. The best tribute to the policy that the Government have been pursuing during the last year has been the speeches that have been made in this House yesterday and to-day. There was practically no criticism of any of the various items of policy referred to in that speech. There was no discussion of the various aspects of the financial and economic policy. But matters such as the Garden of Remembrance, the Army and the letting of land on the 11 months system were brought into or endeavoured to be brought into a discussion of this kind. The fact that there was no criticism offered or constructive suggestions made in the course of the discussion of this Estimate from Deputies opposite, from the Leader down, is the best tribute, as I say, to that statement which was made objectively, and the conclusion clearly emerged that the results of our policy were beneficial to the people in bringing about a condition of peace in the country and a condition of comparative prosperity.
Deputy de Valera, in opening the debate on behalf of the Opposition, rather set the kind of headline which appears to be the guiding line for Opposition tactics at present. Many of them in the course of the debate have reiterated claims that we should be doing something which they during 16 years failed to do. They asked: Why do you not do this and why do you not do that?—things which they had the opportunity to do during their 16 years of office, and which they failed to do. Typical of that attitude was the query put by the Leader of the Opposition in the very forefront of his remarks. It is a small minor detail, but it does typify the outlook and tactics of the Opposition in carrying out the duty which they have to perform in this House. Deputy de Valera asked us to consider whether we would not make the financial year coincide with the calendar year. That matter was raised and considered by the last Government, of which he was the head, and on the 23rd January, 1947, just a year before the general election which brought about the downfall of that Government, as reported in the Official Reports, Volume 104, column 199, Deputy Davin asked the Minister for Finance:—
"If he will consider the desirability of making the financial year coincide with the calendar year; and whether he is prepared to have the matter examined by a committee representative of the various interests concerned."
The then Minister for Finance replied:—
"The question of changing the financial year to coincide with the calendar year was examined within recent years in conformity with an undertaking given in my predecessor's reply to a parliamentary question by Deputy Mulcahy on the 16th July, 1942. Departments, local authorities and commercial, insurance, accounting and banking interests were consulted as to whether the change would be desirable. The inquiries showed that the weight of opinion, private as well as official, is, for substantial reasons, against a change and in favour of retaining the present financial year. The reply to the second part of the Deputy's question is, therefore, in the negative."
That is a mere detail, as I say, but that is the sort of criticism to which we were subjected; why do you not do this, that or the other things which they themselves failed to do when they had an opportunity of doing them.
Another remarkable claim was put forward as a headline to this debate by quite a number of speakers. While they could not disagree with the results we had achieved, while they could not point to anything wrong with our policy or the results of it, they said: "You are carrying out the Fianna Fáil policy." That is a most remarkable phenomenon in political history, for here is a Government which replaced another Government two and a half years ago and which succeeds in carrying out, as was practically admitted in speech after speech, certainly many aspects of the former Government's policy, because they said: "That is the Fianna Fáil policy." That is a most remarkable phenomenon in political history, that a Government which replaced another Government carries on its policy successfully and more successfully than the previous Government carried it on. That is the only criticism, apart from the question of the Army and Deputy Cowan's volunteers, that has emerged in the course of the discussion.
We listened to long speeches on the subject of national defence and the national emergency. Word was passed round last night that the Minister for Defence (Dr. O'Higgins) was to be made the principal subject-matter of this debate. Epithets were hurled at that Minister. Statements were made about the viciousness and the bitterness of his speech and other comments of that kind were made. Phrases such as "bluff" and "false figures" came trippingly off the tongue of Deputy Lemass. That is the way he spoke of the Minister for Defence's speech. These words "bluff", "false pretence" and "false figures" come very trippingly off the tongue of Deputy Lemass.
"Viciousness", "false pretence" and other epithets and phrases of the kind which I cannot recall at the moment were words applied to the remarks of the Minister. I listened to the Minister's speech and when I heard Deputy Lemass this morning, after having given a number of reasons, or alleged reasons, drawing the conclusion that the Minister was unworthy of his position for the reasons he had stated—"bluff", "false pretence" and "false figures"—I sent for a copy of the speech the Minister made yesterday. I had listened to these words and epithets being hurled around here last night and early this morning and I wondered had I taken a different impression from the speech, because when I heard him making that speech —and the Minister intervened on his own in the debate for the purpose of making clear our policy on defence—I felt that there was nothing I could add, or ought to add, to it when I was winding up the debate; that, on matters of national defence, he had covered the ground adequately and had covered it well.
Then, of course, a scapegoat had to be got and the Minister for Defence was deliberately made the scapegoat. Whispers were sent round the galleries and corridors: "Attack Dr. O'Higgins. Make him the target", and that of course was the real keynote of this debate—"defence", "lack of preparedness", "Dr. O'Higgins' bluff", and "false figures". That is an old dodge. It is centuries old among politicians and political tacticians—keep the people's minds distracted and disturbed; get them off the figures produced here yesterday, coldly and calmly and accurately; keep their minds away from the results achieved during the past 12 months by the economic, financial and agricultural policy of this Government. Let them think there is going to be a war. Insidiously, under the guise of national defence, prey upon the people's fears so that they may forget the achievements of the Government and may think that the Government is unprepared for this war which Fianna Fáil alone have discovered. That is a political dodge and the Minister for Defence characterised it as such yesterday.
I heard that Minister's speech and I read his speech this morning. I agree with every word he said, and, were it not for the concentrated effort which has been made on the Minister, I would not have thought it right to add anything at all on the subject of preparedness for national defence. But the whole keynote of the debate from the Opposition Benches was national defence—"You are unprepared. What are you going to do?"
Deputy M. O'Higgins, speaking on behalf of the people with whom he is in contact, the ordinary plain people of the country, and Deputy Fagan, speaking as an agriculturist knowing the country people, gave a clear, simple and definite answer to all the stuff we have been listening to on the subject of preparedness, defence and the attitude of the people towards it.
We are not going to be dragged by political tactics of that kind from the work we have set ourselves to do, nor are we going to allow the minds of the people to be clouded or their vision to be obscured from what has been done, by the efforts of the Fianna Fáil Party to turn the minds of the people on to war, to prey upon their fears and to create a condition bordering upon mild panic in the country. It is a wellknown trick to try to divert the attention of the people from financial, economic and agricultural matters on to something else when it does not suit a political Party that the people should concentrate their minds on these financial, economic and agricultural matters.
If the Party opposite was able to discuss our economic policy, our financial policy, our agricultural policy or general Government policy, item by item and line by line, comparing achievement with achievement and objective with objective, and to criticise what we have done and are doing in the way in which an Opposition with the interests of the country at heart would be expected to do it, we would have had a far different debate. I recognise that it is the right, and, I would even say, the duty of the Opposition in present circumstances prudently and calmly to call attention to any matters they think should be attended to in connection with defence or national policy in connection with the defence of the country or preparedness for any emergency. I think the matter has gone too far, however. It has been dragged across this debate, as it has been dragged across speeches in the country for some months past, for the purpose of trying to distract public attention from the achievements of this Government and from the beneficial results of Government policy over the past two and a half years.
It is not by reason of the Korean incident that this matter of national defence has been brought up. Before the Korean incident occurred at all, before many people in this country ever heard of Korea, the Leader of the Opposition and members of his Party were going around the country preaching about the necessity for having a big standing Army, the necessity for preparation against an international emergency and telling us that we were not spending enough money upon national defence, upon armaments and upon bringing our young people into the barrack squares, as the Minister for Defence said, to knock sparks out of the cobblestones of those squares, instead of doing what they have been doing, bringing back the soil of the country to fertility, producing the crops our people want, building the houses our people so urgently need, building the hospitals which our tubercular patients want and building up the moral, spiritual and physical strength of this nation against the possibility of another emergency. Deputy de Valera, junior, this morning repeated that they had been doing this for two years, so that it is not the present situation in Korea that has made the Fianna Fáil Party interested in getting us to spend the taxpayers' money on armaments and on bringing our young people up for military service.
What they want to do, and what they have been endeavouring to do for years past, is to get us to spend on an unproductive Army and on taking our men away from the factories and the fields and putting them into barracks, the money we are spending productively, so that they may thereafter say: "This is an extravagant Government. While they were right to spend a certain amount of money on the Army, they spent too much." If we did tax the people for a higher standing Army and for the purchase of more and more costly equipment, we would not have the same amount of money to spend on productive enterprises and on the forward economic, financial and agricultural policies on which we have been spending money and we would not have the story we have to tell, a story of which we are proud and which we are happy to be able to tell.
That is what is at the back of all this. I will give the Leader of the Opposition and some of his Party credit for the fact that they do not want to make political capital, but there is a very large element of endeavour to make political capital out of this. We are accused of being unprepared. I suppose that, if we indulged in histrionics, in dramatics, we could pretend that we were prepared, as a small nation, to beat the world.
Deputy Lemass sneered at me this morning, in his characteristic way. He spoke about the "fatuous" speech I made in Mullingar and he referred in that sneering tone to the statement I had made in Mullingar about our being realistic in regard to this matter. We have been realistic but we have not been indulging in histrionics and dramatics. We have taken the view that we are a small nation. We do not want to indulge in the ridiculous posturing that the people opposite, in Fianna Fáil, would have us indulge in, a small nation talking like a big nation and pretending that we were able to beat the whole world and the biggest nations in the world. We realise our own limitations and we have a very real appreciation of the difficulties in which we would stand if there was an emergency in the future.
We also have, what Deputies opposite have not got, a genuine appreciation of the fact that if there be a war —and God forbid that there should again, in our time, be a war—but, if there be a war, that war will be fought in a different way and the pattern of that war, the methods that would be employed in that war, will be of an entirely different character from what they were during the last war.
If I may make a criticism of all the speeches that have been made on the subject matter of defence in this House yesterday and to-day, from the Leader of the Opposition, through Deputy Lemass, down to some of the back-benchers, they are all asking us to prepare for the next war as if we were going to have conditions precisely similar to what we had in the last war. Deputy Lemass and the other people who spoke on this matter overlooked the conditions created by the A-bomb, the H-bomb—the hydrogen bomb. Are we going to get our scientists to waste their time trying to do better than the hydrogen bomb? Are we going to get a loan of an A-bomb from the Americans in order that we may, if the Americans invade us, drop that bomb on them; or get a loan of a hydrogen bomb from the Russians in order that, if the Russians invade us, we will drop that bomb upon them; or will we get a loan of an A-bomb from the Russians and of a Hydrogen bomb from the Americans in order that we may drop them on both of them or on the British in the unlikely event of the British invading us?
What is the use of talking nonsense? They say that we ought to have 12,000 men filling this vacuum, as Deputy Aiken said last night, and, having filled this vacuum, we can stand with our rifles facing hydrogen bombs, A-bombs, jet-propelled aeroplanes and all the rest of the terrible paraphernalia of war and pretend that we are going to get away with that. We have to be realistic.
Comment on this
We are being realistic and we know that, while we have taken steps, as the Minister for Defence said yesterday, within the limits of our capacities and our powers, there are other things that have to be done besides collecting arms. There are other influences that we can bring to bear, and which we hope to bring to bear in order to save this country from the terrible consequences of any future war.
We are told by Deputy Lemass that we should be prepared in this, that and the other, that we should be getting ships and, by Deputy de Valera, that we should be preparing to have food, fuel and all the rest of it. I may have some apprehensions as to whether or not we would be able to defend ourselves against attack. I may have some apprehensions about our lack of modern equipment. I may have considerable apprehensions about our manpower but, whatever apprehensions I have or that my colleagues have about the difficulties facing us, we have no apprehensions about our food situation and the situation of the farmers, our land and our supplies position in general. We are better off that ever we were under Fianna Fáil at the present moment.
We are told by the people who always talk about tillage as if tillage was the one thing that was necessary to heal all our economic ills in this country, that we ought to have more tillage, that we ought to revert to the position of compulsory tillage, which was, apparently, the panacea for all ills of the Fianna Fáil Government, when they were in office. This is the recent, up-to-date position of the food supply in this country now; we have here in store or growing, wheat, an estimated amount of 512,000 tons. I am told that the total consumption of wheat in this country is 3,000,000 barrels. There are eight barrels to a ton. Therefore, 3,000,000 barrels are equivalent to about 400,000 tons. We have, according to these figures, 100,000 more tons of wheat than a year's supply. As the Minister for Agriculture pointed out when winding up the debate on his Estimate, more wheat has been got out of less land in this year, and better wheat, without any compulsion.
Comment on this
We have in store in farmers' premises, or coming up this year in the ground, 750,000 tons of oats. We have, similarly, in store, in the hands of brewers, distillers, maltsters or farmers, or growing, 210,000 tons of barley, and we have 3,150,000 tons of potatoes either growing or available. That is the contribution of the Minister for Agriculture to a possible emergency here.
Is there any justification whatever, therefore, for the effort to put into the minds of the people panic that we are not prepared or that, because we have not been indulging in ridiculous and futile histrionics, of which we were given an exhibition here by Deputy MacEntee a short time ago, that we have been neglecting the nation's interest or doing nothing? Because we are not shouting from the house-tops is not to say that we are doing nothing. The less noise there is about a person, the more work he is going to do, and the more flap and flapdoodle that you get and the more people like Deputy Lemass, spinning their words around about people like the Minister for Defence, about bases, of bluff and false pretence and all the rest, the less work and the less sincerity there is behind it.
We have, as Dr. O'Higgins said, appreciated the position from the very moment we came into office. Deputy Lemass spoke sneeringly about this "fatuous" speech that I made in MuHingar last week, and I will have occasion to refer to some of the matters that I have said there in order that Deputies may have the opportunity of judging whether that speech was fatuous or whether it was sound common sense where it epitomised the policy which has been in active operation for the past two and a half years and which has brought great and lasting good and prosperity to the people of this country and which has given us a buttress against any possible difficulties that we may experience in the event of an emergency.
I spoke in Skibbereen on 24th July, 1948, nearly two years ago. I had not to wait for Deputy de Valera, Deputy Lemass or anybody else to tell me, or for my colleagues to be told, that there was an international situation which might at any moment develop into difficulty. One of the first decisions we had to make in the Government was how were we to direct our policy, on what basis were we to build. Were we to stultify our efforts by keeping our eyes on the ends of the earth, fearful lest at any moment, at the ends of the earth, something might blow up that would cause a war and bring us into the whirlpool: Deputy de Valera, yesterday, in his opening remarks on this topic, spoke about the ordinary prudent person who insures his house against conflagration. The ordinary prudent person insures his house, but he takes very good care that he gets the maximum cover for the minimum premium. That is prudence. That is what we did, and I believe we can say now, at the end of two and a half years, that we have got the maximum cover for the minimum cost to the community. Deputy de Valera and Deputy Lemass would have the fire brigade sitting in the house of this prudent man all the time. That is the policy they are advocating here. Spend the money to have the fire brigade and the Army sitting on your doorstep all the time. Spend the taxpayers' money instead of taking out a proper insurance policy adequately to cover yourself with the minimum premium. In 1948 I announced at Skibbereen that the Government had taken that decision. I said:—
"Peace and order have since the change of Government reigned over the land, and we earnestly hope that they will continue to do so. Abroad the war clouds are lowering over the world. Nevertheless, the Government has decided that it must face its plans on the hypothesis of peace. Otherwise, we would be stultifying our efforts and putting a brake on the economic progress that the country so much desires, and which the Government is confident of achieving. In addition we are keeping a watchful eye on developments abroad, and we intend to ensure that whatever developments occur our national and economic security will be maintained."
That was two years ago. We have achieved the economic progress the country desires inside that two years. We have, as far as it can possibly be done, also kept a wary and a watchful eye on the situation abroad, and kept our country ready, so far as it can be ready, for anything that may happen in the international field.
As I have said, Deputy Lemass referred in a sneering way to what he described as my "flamboyant" speech. This is the "flamboyant" speech:—
"While hoping for peace, we are at the same time sufficiently realistic to know that the affairs of our own country must be so conducted that if war were to come we should be reasonably prepared for it."
There is the word "realistic" that Deputy Lemass this morning sneeringly referred to.
"We are sufficiently realistic to know that we should be reasonably prepared if war comes."
We had, in October, 1948, established a Cabinet committee to watch the matter all the time and steps have been taken all the time to do what I had said should be done. Let me now continue the "fatuous" speech in Mullingar:—
"When the Government assumed office two years ago it decided the best way of safeguarding the liberties and welfare of our people against the contingency of war was not by merely adopting the wholly negative and unproductive method of building up a large standing Army and equipping it with costly armaments which would absorb so much of the country's resources. We decided that Ireland's cause could best be served by developing our land and restoring to the soil the fertility it had lost during the period of the last war; by improving and enriching the productive capacity of our economy by investing the largescale capital that was so long overdue; by improving the health, strength, and resistance of our people by undertaking an energetic campaign to provide them with the houses and hospitals they so urgently require; by pushing ahead schemes for electrical development from water and turf and so making the country more independent of imported fuel. The result of that policy is that with the productive capacity of our people and our land much greater than it was three years ago, we are all the better equipped to meet any dire contingencies that might arise. It would have been mere futile stultification to have diverted from productive purposes the money and the resources which have been used and are now being used to build up the strength and resistance of the country.
Had national revenues been so diverted, we should still be with exhausted and undeveloped land, grossly inadequate housing, rapidly increasing death rate from tuberculosis and insufficient social services."
For not one word of that do I apologise. I put that in this House, with emphasis, as a proper premium to pay for what we have got in the past two years. We are as well prepared to-day as ever we could be for any emergency that may arise from war or rumours of war. Deputy de Valera and Deputy Lemass would have us pay, from the taxpayers' pockets, money for armaments and armies that we have put into houses and into the land. We have a productive soil here now. We have our agricultural industry on a proper basis and we have it on a firm basis, on which it did not stand in the 16 years of the Fianna Fáil régime.
Let me state briefly some more of what I said in this "flamboyant" speech. I repeat it with confidence and pride as an expression of what was done and what I believe was right to have done and submitted to this House as a proper policy to meet the situation we had to meet at home and abroad in the past two and a half years.
"The resources of this country are limited. So much constructive work
requires to be done and has been done in the interests of economic and social betterment in recent years that events have proved that it would have been irresponsible folly to have diverted to unproductive purposes the limited money and resources available. A large Army is of little use if there is insufficient economic strength to nourish it."
Is there anything "fatuous" about these statements? Does Deputy Lemass, now that he has heard this, still persist in saying that it is a "fatuous" speech and a "fatuous" policy? If he does I say to him that I am proud of that policy and confident that I and my colleagues adopted a proper policy when we set out on the task two and a half years ago of bringing this country to a better economy and saving it from the agricultural ruin in which we had found it when we took office in February, 1948. We had not our eyes to the ends of the earth to the exclusion of our own people. We kept our eyes on the ends of the earth to ascertain if there was likely to be danger and, if so, when it was likely to occur, but then we kept our energies directed to building up the health and strength of our own people, to restoring the fertility of the land, to making this country strong and capable of meeting any emergency that Providence, in His will, might send upon the world and this country to afflict it, if such should occur. A large Army is of little use if there is insufficient strength to nourish it. We now have sufficient strength to nourish whatever size of Army we may have to maintain in this country. If there is an emergency arising out of this Korean situation, we have our country now far better able to meet that emergency than if we had exhausted our resources and wasted the time of our men in armies and in buying equipment and costly material that would have been out of date a few months after it had been purchased, if we were able to purchase it. We glory in that policy. It may have been a "flamboyant" speech, but it is one for which I have no apology to offer. I say—and I use, perhaps, a flamboyant word—that I glory in it because it shows that we took the proper course two and a half years ago. We did not stultify our efforts thinking about war and rumours of war. We set ourselves to get houses for our people and hospitals for our sick. We set ourselves to give our farmers the right to live and to earn a decent living.
I was able to announce yesterday that, as a result of our agricultural policy—as a result of what the present Minister for Agriculture has done— the one section in this country that really has definitely and decidedly benefited from the increase in the national income is the farming community. That would not have happened if our farmers' sons and labourers were standing around the barracks to keep up the strength of the Army—"filling the vacuum", as Deputy Aiken referred to it last night.
Another person, this morning I think it was, sneered at the talk of peace. We are a small nation and we must remember that; we must keep that in the forefront of our minds all the time and in the forefront of our policy. We must talk of peace. The strongest hope we have is not in our 12,500 men and our rifles to defend ourselves against attack from the air or anywhere else; the strongest hope we have, or any small nation has, is in peace and in continued peace, and our greatest security is to give whatever contribution we can give in the international field to secure that there will be peace, peace at all costs. That is the only way that a small nation can serve itself or can maintain its integrity and sovereignty. We must preach peace, we must give a spiritual contribution towards peace. That is what our nation can give and that is what our people are in a position to give, and that our kith and kin abroad in practically every country in the world can give in the cause of peace.
We are not to talk about peace. I suppose to talk about peace would be flatulent and fatuous, if I were to use Deputy Lemass's verbiage. May I refer to what the Pope said in the course of his Christmas message in 1948?
"Nations should be careful of the use of threats by armies in support of claims, even if legitimate, in view of the risk of starting a conflagration, with all its tremendous consequences, spiritual as well as material."
We have some little influence in the world. Our policy, as carried out by our Minister for External Affairs, has given us some little standing, even as a small nation, in the councils of the nations. He has played a good part, an honest part and an influential part in many of the councils and in many activities in international affairs. Through our influence, and through his activities, we may give our contribution towards endeavouring to secure peace. We must talk about peace, although certain Fianna Fáil spokesmen think it would be fatuous and flatulent to talk about it. We must try to get our point of view known to the nations and now, as a result of what has been done in the past two and a half years, we have greater influence. Our case is known, our difficulties more appreciated than ever before—that is one of our contributions towards the defence of this country in the event of an emergency.
We escaped invasion during the last emergency, and I am in no way detracting from the work done or the sacrifices that were ready to be made by the people in the Defence Forces at that time when I say that we were saved from that invasion, not by the force of our armies but by the forbearance of the warring nations during that time. It may have been expediency, it may have been decency, it may have been some little respect for international morality that prevented the invasion of this country; it was their forbearance, and what we have to see is that we make friends amongst the powerful nations and the small nations who will help us if we are faced with any trials in another emergency.
These are the ways in which we can help to defend this country and build up its resources and its defence, and it is not by bringing young people into barracks, organising an army of 12,500 soldiers with so much arms and equipment and spending millions of the taxpayers' money. There are other ways, tangible and intangible, in which you can defend this country. I will repeat what the Minister for Defence said: such steps as we are able to take have been and are being taken—they have been taken during the past two and a half years—to meet any emergency which may result from the international situation. I think it is deluding the people and misleading the people to tell them otherwise and, if there is any false pretence lying around this debate, it lies on the side of those people who are trying to get it into the heads of our unfortunate countrymen that we are in a position, from our own resources and by our own strength and with our own men and materials, to defy the world and to meet all-comers. We are not, and the sooner that is realised the better.
That is why I am realistic; that is why the Government are using their best endeavours in various ways to secure that there shall be peace, amongst other things, by taking steps to ensure that the economic and financial structure of this country is strengthened and by ensuring that we have food supplies adequate to meet all emergencies and that we will have such other supplies as we may be enabled to obtain to meet any situation that may arise.
I have spoken at far greater length on defence that I intended. I believe it is largely, I do not say entirely, a political trick to get us talking around the country about defence, to get our people to follow on the tail of Fianna Fáil speakers, to swing after them and talk on defence questions. Apparently, members of the Fianna Fáil Party have come to the conclusion that if they talk about defence and create a panic by saying that the Government are unprepared to meet an emergency, it will divert attention from such important questions as economics and finance and making known the wonderful results that we have achieved during the past two and a half years and what we hope to achieve in the next two and a half years.
I do not propose to deal at any great length with the various points that were raised in the course of the debate. I want to end the question of defence by saying this, that I drew the conclusion from Deputy de Valera's speech last night that the idea was that we will have X-thousand men and so many guns, with whatever equipment that we may have, and we will fight anyone who comes and, having been wiped out, we will settle down for another 750 years of war. I do not want the country to fight another 750 years war, nor do my colleagues. We want to give the ordinary people a chance to continue doing what has been done, and to try to do even better in the future, utilising our unutilised resources, employing the people of the country, getting more wealth out of our land, and giving our people an opportunity to enjoy the rights they have and realising the genuine prospect they have of achieving within our lifetime real peace and prosperity.
Deputy Lemass said we were farming out our industry. He spoke about the Industrial Development Authority and said we had allowed that particular authority to usurp our functions in the matter of industrial policy. The best answer and the most succinct answer I can give is to refer him to the results achieved since that body was set up. I want to pay them this tribute to-day, that since they have been set up they have been a conspicuous success and a complete justification of the policy of the Government. I was able to announce it in cold figures yesterday when I was opening this discussion on this Estimate. There has been the highest volume of industrial employment on record. We have less unemployed in this country now than ever there were before, and at the same time we have the highest volume of industrial production on record. In the year 1949 we had 60 new factories. That is a fair piece of achievement for that body, which was set up only a short time ago. That is the body whose activities Deputy Lemass here did his best to torpedo and cripple in the speech he made when the Industrial Development Authority was set up.
Deputy Lemass also asked what provision we were making in face of our financial commitments in the event of an emergency. I gathered he appeared to suggest that his Government had made some wonderful arrangement in 1939 about dollars. This country was a member of the sterling group in 1939, as it is a member of the sterling group at the moment. We have the same right as the last Government had in 1939, the right to draw on the sterling pool for our dollar requirements. We do not require to take any steps against this mythical war that Deputy Lemass thinks is coming. Our position in that respect is amply safeguarded. For some years past we have not, in fact, effectively drawn on the dollar pool at all, but we have the right to draw on it as soon as Marshall Aid is over, if we want it. We have been endeavouring to increase our own dollar earnings without drawing on the pool, but we have the right to draw on it if the occasion requires. That right will not be denied to us if emergency conditions descend on us and require us to exercise it in order to provide us with dollars.
I was interested in Deputy Derrig's speech. At least he was honest, as he disclosed quite clearly that he was against the provision of houses and schools by means of capital expenditure.
Comment on this
I listened to it quite clearly, as he was the only one who appeared to me to make that admission. He stated that money should be expended on schemes such as we contemplated only in the event of there being a return——
Comment on this
I think I am entitled to ask the Taoiseach, if he professes to give an account of what I said, to quote what I said.
Comment on this
What I can do is to quote from my own notes. The money you expend— I do not give this with complete accuracy and if I am wrong the Deputy can correct me—the fundamental principle for the spending of money—and I put this in inverted commas—is a reasonable prospect of paying for its use. I take it that if my recollection is wrong the Deputy will correct me. He mentioned houses and schools and mentioned schemes which produced an annual return for the expenditure and he said you could spend the money on them.
Comment on this
I referred to the £12,000,000 which is being borrowed this year and which hitherto was provided out of revenue. I pointed out that in previous years housing grants and provision for schools had been met out of revenue.
Comment on this
I do not know that the Deputy has answered the point I had made. I still repeat, and can be corrected if I am wrong, that he said the fundamental principle—those were the words used by the Deputy—was that there must be a reasonable prospect of paying for its use.
Comment on this
You can only pay for housing and schools by the social result you get. You cannot get money's worth out of housing and schools.
Comment on this
I am dealing with Deputy Derrig. I will reserve my comment on Deputy de Valera on this aspect for the moment. Deputy Derrig drew the distinction between houses and schools——
Comment on this
——between expenditure, capital expenditure on houses and schools and capital expenditure on other purposes that produced revenue, the fundamental principle being, as I took it down, "a reasonable prospect of being paid for its use".
Comment on this
Does the House object to a Deputy correcting a misrepresentation of what he said? The criticisms of the borrowing policy of the Government from this side of the House have always made a clear distinction between the ordinary provision for borrowing by local authorities and the housing grants, which up to the present had been paid from revenue. It is now proposed to borrow for housing grants.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce had better read the Taoiseach's speech about the cost of living. He denied yesterday that it had gone up.
Comment on this
The time available to me to reply is so short that I will not waste it on Deputy Derrig.
Comment on this
I have informed the Deputy that I did not purport to quote —I could not—but I quoted from my notes, the sentence being in inverted commas in the notes. If I am wrong, it can be corrected. As the Deputy has said that my interpretation of his speech is incorrect, I will pass from it. It can be dealt with at another time.
A large portion of my opening address yesterday on this Estimate dealt with capital expenditure. In the entire debate, taking everyone from the Leader of the Opposition down to the last speaker, adding all the time they spent in their speeches, I do not suppose there was a quarter of an hour spent on this capital expenditure of £12,000,000. I think it was Deputy de Valera who said they were not supposed to pick out of the £12,000,000 the items of capital expenditure that they objected to, that the onus was upon us. We have taken that onus. In every single instance, in matters on which we intend to spend our capital, we have given details of expenditure and the objects on which we are going to spend the money. We have not got one single constructive criticism upon any single item of all those proposals for the spending of the £12,000,000— and that in itself is a complete justification of the programme which we have set out to carry into effect.
We are told we are carrying out Fianna Fáil policy. Deputy de Valera started that yesterday and Deputy Little continued it yesterday, but even Deputy Little had to sit down smiling and laughing at the ludicrous situation into which he had landed himself by saying that the present Government was carrying out Fianna Fáil policy. Was land rehabilitation Fianna Fáil policy? Was the Local Authorities (Works) Act Fianna Fáil policy? Was the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, which has been so severely criticised, Fianna Fáil policy? Was the Industrial Development Authority, which has been criticised to-day by Deputy Lemass, Fianna Fáil policy? Is there any single item of our policy that was Fianna Fáil policy? If there were, I would not have been able to get up here yesterday and point to the wonderful results and achievements of this Government in the last two and a half years.
Deputy Derrig will not let me give my interpretation of what he said yesterday in case it might be incorrect. I think I am correct in saying this, that my interpretation of the general policy of Fianna Fáil is that we ought to go on with the new Government buildings, in respect of which they made a provision of £200,000 in the Estimates which we found when we came into office. They have criticised the land rehabilitation policy of the Minister for Agriculture. They have criticised our capital expenditure. They want us to go on with the £2,000,000 for Government offices in Dublin Castle. The only comment I make is: if the ancient Egyptians had gone in for a Dillon scheme of land rehabilitation and drainage, instead of building the Pyramids, their civilisation would probably be alive to-day.
Deputy C. Lehane asked me for certain assurances on forestry. I think I can readily give those assurances. The gentleman to whom I referred yesterday, perhaps somewhat facetiously, as our very competent and comfortable Minister for Lands and Forestry is as big an enthusiast about forestry as the whole of the Clann na Poblachta Party put together; and I am content to say that he has a far more practical outlook and knows more about forestry than the whole of that party put together. I think, therefore, that we will leave forestry in the very competent hands of my colleague, Deputy Blowick, Minister for Lands.
Comment on this
There was imported into this House this morning a subject which, I think, might very well have been left undealt with. The day before yesterday I gave to the House specific assurances on the subject of the Garden of Remembrance and of the Government's intention in that respect. This morning we listened to the histrionic and hysterical speech of Deputy MacEntee with fictitious sobs in his voice. I explained the day before yesterday the Government's intention. I do not intend to revive any more bitterness or controversy. I have given the most specific assurances and I have explained the Government's intention in regard to the general memorial.
Finally, I want to say—and I think this must be said and can be said— that at the end of nearly two and a half years of government, at the end of a period during which every possible obstacle was placed in the way of this Government achieving the purposes which it set out to achieve by the operations and speeches of the Fianna Fáil Party, by lying and insidious propaganda, and by a whispering campaign throughout the country in an attempt to torpedo the efforts and the solidarity of this Government, to-day, after two and a half years, we are able to say that this Government, which was sneered at and about which it was said that it would not last six months, is solid, lasting and united, and is able to put before the country in the calm and cold objective statement that I read yesterday a history of achievement in the agricultural, financial and economic spheres of Government activity, such a history as no other Government was ever able to put before the people after such a short lapse of time.
We have every confidence that, given the opportunity and given peace, when we come to submit our record and our story at the next general election, it will be a record of achievement that will commend itself to our people, not because of anything we may say, but because we will have, in every aspect of financial, economic and agricultural life and in every section of the community, brought hope and happiness and some degree of prosperity.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach mentioned a Cabinet sub-committee. Has he any objection to telling the House who the members are?
Comment on this
I am speaking now from recollection: the Tánaiste, the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Defence, the Minister for External Affairs, the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I am speaking from recollection.
Comment on this
Question—"That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration"— put.
Do you agree with this result?